Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2018
Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board Special meeting
· recording 1 hr 42 min
On the Town's site: Video ↗
Transcript
229 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:54 Very similar to American and Delta and Southwest. United's cap number is 27.8% lower than Alaska was with similar service coming out of Delta. Big break for us. Less expensive. Explain the cap number. You have a cap number in which you cannot exceed the payment on a given season or year-round basis. United's cap number.
1:27 is 27% lower than what Alaska's was for the similar service. Different aircraft, similar service. United had service in Mammoth since 2009. That was a big deal because I didn't want to try to go out and find another carrier to create a brand new staff and office, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Big advantage for United to serve it.
1:59 United has LAX. They have a lot of connections between LAX and San Francisco. Fourteen flights going and coming every day. You can say less than 90 minutes lag time between those flights. A lot of connectivity. So if you fly to San Francisco, you can get back to LA and vice versa. That's quick. Less than 90 minutes. Better United LAX operation in one terminal. When you flew,
2:32 Alaska Air, and you want it to connect to American, guess what? You have to go clear around on the other side of the airport. What terminal is United again at LAX? Six. Six or seven. I haven't been to LAX for a while. I only know it's in one terminal. More connecting flights in LA. And United's cost per round trip is less than in Alaska.
3:08 The cost of flying the Alaska plane last year compared to what United quoted us, it's less on a per round trip basis. That's our cost from the subsidy, not the guest's cost. That's correct. The fares are different. That's a totally different other game. So the cost they're charging us for that aircraft on a per round trip basis is less.
3:37 than what we were being charged on Alaska. Is that commensurate with seat count or is that just overall it's a lower cost? Very good question. You have cost per round trip and then you have what you call a chasm, cost per available seat mile because the flight we're flying, the aircraft we're using has less seats, has six less seats on it. It goes from 76 to 70. So that cost is about 6.1% less.
4:07 So both of them are less. Very good. Excellent. Okay. Current plan in place as far as San Francisco is concerned. Daily flight December the 19th to the 30th of March. They fly CRJ-700, 64 seat coach seats and six first class seats. LAX, they fly the same aircraft. They start December 1st. The day
4:39 After Alaska pulls out. I heard yesterday from Eric Clark that people from United are already in conversations with him about lodging and finding lodging for their staff, which has grown by 100%. Went from four to eight. There's some equipment laying around that they need to take care of, that they're taking care of their staff, they're moving forward, they're well aware of it, what they're trying to do at this airport.
5:06 So it'll become a united airport. And I gotta tell you a side story today. I'm over here filling with gas. This guy, contractor guy, I would call him a gentleman contractor. He looks at me and he says, are you visiting here? No, I'm here on business. He said, well, what do you do? I said, well, I help the airport run their, manage their air service. He says, yeah, I heard they had a little problem out there with Alaska Air.
5:35 Yeah, but we got that squared away with United Airlines. He goes, United Airlines? United Airlines is the third largest airline in the country. This is not Alaska Air. They were dramatically larger. And they carry a large brand name. And they have a lot of a much larger network.
6:01 Kent, I just want to comment on regarding the employee housing a little bit in the sense that you just alluded to. Indeed, we've had conversations with United because we provide housing for the team that comes here on a seasonal basis. So over the last couple weeks, we've had multiple conversations with the team in United. So it's coming down into the operations. And that's to help the community so that we can bring those people that are necessary to provide the United service.
6:31 They're engaged is the point about this transition. Okay. This is a spider map. This is the hub and spoke in the connecting nonstop markets on United Airlines out of San Francisco. So you can fly to Boston, fly to San Francisco, and connect. We don't connect to all of these cities because we only have one flight. We'd like another flight, but we didn't quite get the other flight. But that's what the spider map looks like.
7:02 This is what the spider map in LA looks like as far as United is concerned. It's substantially smaller, but when you combine the two because of the connectivity between LAX and San Francisco, that's what it begins to look like. It begins to cover more and more of the country. And that's all about the connectivity. We never had this opportunity with Alaska because they wouldn't connect. They weren't partners with United. They were partners with American. And they were in a different terminal.
7:35 An American doesn't have all those flights back and forth between San Francisco and LA. Okay, so additional options that we consider. A second daily flight, seasonal winter out of San Francisco as well as LAX, same kind of aircraft, it would complement the daily flights. We also looked at a Denver flight, and that's still in play.
8:01 We'll fly a CRJ700 with 70 seats. The Denver nonstop would offer connecting service to numerous Midwest and East Coast cities. It's United's second largest hub, and Denver's the fourth busiest domestic airport in the United States. So that's Denver's spider map. And if you connect it all, that's what it looks like.
8:32 We can begin to see the connectivity that United brings to the table, particularly if we get those three jobs, something that has never been able to really be offered here. I didn't know why that didn't slip. Okay. Business class express jet options. So this is all the point-to-point stuff that we looked at. Jet Suite X, four times weekly, seasonal service, using a CRJ 145 configured to 30 seats. We looked at Burbank.
9:05 Carlsbad, Oakland, Santa Barbara, San Jose, and Orange County. Contour Air, same schedule, same type of aircraft, looked at Oakland and Phoenix. Cal Pacific, four times weekly, seasonal, an RJ configured to 50 seats, which then we have to go through a sterile terminal, you have to go through TSA, and that would fly into the...
9:34 Regular terminal air as opposed to the FBO. And they are still in play in San Diego or Carlsbad. This is what are our recommendations as far as the legacy carriers are concerned. The daily year-round LAX, the seasonal San Francisco, and the daily seasonal coming out of Denver. That's seasonal being winter. As far as the business class jet...
10:09 recommendations. We want to serve Burbank, Orange County, and Oakland. It would all be mid-December to the end of March. We continue to work with Jet Suite X and Cal Pacific on service out of Carlsbad or San Diego. So this is the summary as far as the seat count is concerned. If you look at last year's inbound, and this is on a fiscal year,
10:41 from December 1st to the end of November. The one on the left is we had 46,562 inbound seats. This year, if we get all of those, we have got 44,694 percent lower. But if you really look at what happens in the summer, the summer took a dramatic decrease. It moved from 14,000
11:08 A little under 13,000, so there's 12, there's about 8% decrease in the summer available seats. The point I want to make to you is that we're close, we still don't know about Denver, and we don't know about Carlsbad or San Diego. Kent, one thing to note on summer is that it's seven days a week straight through, so we don't have the four day weeks for the set. Yeah, bring summer, fall, or all daily.
11:36 This is an interesting chart and it really reflects about the previous slide. This is the load factor coming out of LAX by month for the fiscal year 2015-16 and 16-17 because 17-18 is not completed. We never really achieve much higher than a 75% load factor any month in these flights and particularly summer is lower than that.
12:07 So we will have a smaller aircraft fly during the summer which will raise our load factors. There should not be, it may happen where people won't be able to get a seat. Well, that's kind of a nice problem to have because it's full and it begins to turn a profit. That's the way the airlines make money. It's a consolidation of seats. They'll reduce the seat capacity to drive the load factor up to raise,
12:38 revenues, the way they work. Good question. So, Ken, when you go back to the previous slide, I believe this last year's load factor is about 68%. Given that fact, did you look at it in terms of how many times that does create a capacity limit on certain flights? Because there's space there, so even though we're flying with a few less seats, in theory, you're going to... Yes. There will be days, and I can run that analysis from that standpoint about...
13:06 How many days that we ran over, you know, there are days that we run 100% load factor, granted, okay? People will shift, people will move through another day of the week, okay? But I can tell you, it's a nice problem to have when you run higher load factors from a financial standpoint. Yeah, my real question is, even though we're down 4.2% in seats, do we really see a 4%?
13:35 Set reduction in actual seats used because load factor is going to go up. Well, you'll see a reduction in available seats, but you'll see an increase in load factors. That's exactly right. Absolutely. We want that to happen. We want these airlines to be profitable. You know, sometimes when a program is really maturing from a client standpoint, I'll get complaints from the public if the fairs are too high. And I go, you know, I'm really sorry.
14:06 But we want the fares to go up. We want them to be successful to a level. We don't want them gouging people, but we also want to create more competition. Once we meet that level of where we're bumping up against a higher load factor, we'll find other places to fly. There's a lot of opportunities. Yes, sir. Do you have any research that tells you when a fare gets
14:38 so high that it forces the sale of airwine to get down. When does it get counterproductive? We've seen a huge range of fares over the last, some very inexpensive and some very expensive. It's all done via computers anymore as far as the larger carriers are concerned and it's done by forecasts that they generate and
15:08 They'll open buckets of available lower seats and so forth. But yes, I don't have a set formula or any research on it. But generally speaking, the higher the load factor, the higher the fare will be because the last few seats on that aircraft become very expensive. As a subsidizer, we don't actually get to influence the airline of what fares and charges do.
15:39 Very, very little. I was complaining to John not long ago. I was on an Alaska flight. Actually, I ended up not taking the flight, but I registered for it. The plane was completely in. Every seat was available. And the charge was a little shy of $300 each one. This was an Alaska flight. This was an Alaska flight. About two weeks before the flight was going to fly. They hadn't sold any tickets, and they wanted $300 a seat.
16:09 How did you know they didn't sell any tickets? Oh, because I called up a seat map. Well, that seat map is not always true. I will tell you that right now. Well, I assume that it was accurate as to one or two seats. The seat map was completely empty. I could have had a seat anywhere in the airplane except for the pilot flat. Right. I understand. I'm not saying it's perfect. In airline fares, and I'm not going to defend them by any means, but
16:39 When those things happen, you know, send me a note. We'll look at it. And I'm real serious about that because they make a lot of mistakes, believe me. They're not lily white by any means. We have two concerns. One is we're subsidizing this and if they don't sell any tickets, obviously that increases our costs. Two, we're trying to provide a service for both our tourists and locals and the seats are priced through the stratosphere. It's not affordable for you to want.
17:10 Kent, before you answer that, are you done with your presentation? Yes. Okay, so this would be the appropriate time. Yeah, this would be the appropriate time. So let's talk a little bit about pricing and fares. I can't comment and won't necessarily comment about Alaska because I can't do anything about it. I'm looking forward as far as United is concerned. I picked up the phone and we had a conference call. When was the conference call, John? A couple weeks ago. Okay.
17:39 And there was some sensitivity about that. And I called them up and said, hey, guys, this is where the data that I can send you without getting any kind of pushback from Alaska as far as that's concerned, because I know all the information. They took that and they published the fairs. And as far as I can see, United is $100 round trip. OK, that's where they placed it. And we'll see what happens.
18:09 And I will continue to monitor that. They were always competitive coming out of San Francisco. I think Alaska, quite honestly, overall didn't charge enough. I looked back at some of the financials that we had. We had an average fare of $96 and $95 each way back in 2009. And now it's like $105. You can't tell me that.
18:40 The cost of doing business over a 10-year period of time has only gone up 10%. There's something wrong with that. So I don't want them to be astronomical. I want them to be competitive. It's going to be competitive in a range. And that might be $115 one way. Can you go to your slide that's yellow? And I'll try and make us... Which one? The very last slide you had.
19:14 Previous. Previous. There you go. Question for you when you're talking about how you assessed second homeowners and the like. If the airlines make their money off of the incidentals that come in, kind of a two-part question. One, if people have second homes here and they're not taking skis, that reduces the baggage fees that they're paying for that. Is there an economic benefit out of Denver where people are likely going to be bringing their skis and their equipment from a profitability standpoint on the sales? And then secondarily,
19:41 Just my anecdotal experience is that people that fly here tend to, if they're coming out of the LA market, tend to fly on Alaska, we're coming for a couple days. If we're talking about Denver or San Francisco and these hubs, are we looking at, do we have any data that would say these people are more likely to come for three, five, seven days? So thinking both about the sources, is there a more incidental that's going to benefit the airlines profitability-wise, and are we going to get longer stays by which airline we choose, which hub? So,
20:09 Trend, generally, Bill can comment on this as well. The farther you travel to any destination, the longer you will stay. Just kind of common sense. You're just not going to take the time to do that. Anybody coming from Denver, in my view, will be as a minimum a long weekend, and typically they'll be here for five or six days. And anything connecting,
20:40 Just compounds that. Okay? So, I mean, just logically with that. But we've had San Francisco, you know, connectivity in past years. We just haven't had enough of it to really create a bunch of synergy from that. As far as your luggage and baggage and ancillary income or revenues for the airlines, skis are a part of it, but luggage is, you know, a much larger, you know, part of it.
21:11 Second homeowners is kind of a, it's a reason to come. A program years ago was a summer program to a resort. We did some research at the airport. It was the first year we did it. And it turned out that 52% of the people that flew on that aircraft were either second homeowners or friends of second homeowners. And the lodging community in this area, they were the main supporters.
21:44 of the air service. And they said, well, what are we doing here supporting this thing? Just filled with a bunch of second homeowners. And I told them, it's wonderful, because they're paying for the habit out there. They're paying the majority of the fee. And what happens with second homeowners, and it will happen here, classmates, college classmates, friends, they will say, hey, hop on a plane, you can connect through Denver, come and visit Mammoth. They will become your greatest ambassadors.
22:14 For this mountain. I've got a lot of them. I understand. I just, I also know that we have, the question I'd have is if we have such a drive market from LA, and that's what a lot of our second homeowners are, you know, if their clothes are here, their luggage is here, their skis are here, and if there's no flight they're going to drive anyway, should our air initiative be focusing on people that wouldn't come here otherwise without a flight service? I don't think so. I think they're going to drive more business for you because they've got friends and relatives that will say, come on over here.
22:43 Try Mammoth. Give me some questions. Hi, I'm Cindy Appolito. I'm a pleasure to be here for my first meeting. I am a second homeowner, but I live here six months out of the year now. My kids are both on a ski team. And I have to say that I've written several letters to Mr. Ledesma through Michael Wadnerhurst complaining about our service because I have family, friends, back and forth all the time to ski here, my family, and the track record with Alaska has been horrific.
23:12 And I'm happy to see it go. Mechanical problems, as we all know. But I think this is all wonderful in numbers. I think Denver is a great option. We use JetSuite now because we have the option to land in Bishop. So my question is, with United, it sounds wonderful. However, since we can't fly in Bishop with United, what is the landing percentage expected or anticipated of getting here? Because that's the whole problem I see.
23:40 Flying back and forth as disgruntled long-term, short-term visitors, how they never want to come back again. I mean, I'm in the airport and I hear them, I know you hear it too, but I'm like frontline too, hearing all these people when you get turned around or we can't land and it's heart-wrenching when you subsidize so much and I think that anything we can do to increase that percentage. So I just wanted to ask Mr. Mars what
24:05 Is expected. I'm not that old. It's not any better. It's not any better. I thought you were going to say that. It's not that much better. It's about a percentage and a half point worse as far as the completion rate. Okay? It's because of the aircraft and the navigational system. And that's one of the reasons we really like
24:39 Q400 aircraft. It did have better navigational systems. Mammoth is an issue with that. It's been an issue ever since we've been flying in. And it's not necessarily going to go away tomorrow. I wish they had better news for you, but that's the reality of it. I have some relative comments. Just a quick, if you're going to comment, we need you at the podium with the microphone, please. Just to address who you are. Thank you.
25:13 Again, I'm Bill Tomsich from Aspen Snowmass, and I have a lot of related experience with this, and I just kind of reserve some of my comments, you know, as appropriate, depending on how this dialogue goes, but I do have some relevant information about this, and the partner of United, SkyWest Airlines, has been serving the Aspen community with CRJ 700 since 2006.
25:35 And we've seen a huge improvement on their operational reliability in and out of Aspen over those years to the point that mechanical and maintenance disruptions are almost nonexistent during the winter months. So while they may have slightly lower landing minimums than Alaska had, they definitely have a more reliable operation. And then I also have to credit SkyWest. Their mission statement is safety first.
26:03 They're not going to fly when it's not safe to do so, and they're going to have their prescribed landing minimums here at the Mammoth Airport, and when it's clear to fly, they'll land. If not, they're going to safely divert or cancel flights. But I've seen a huge improvement on what's happened in Aspen Snowmass through SkyWest over the last 12 years.
26:23 The other comment I wanted to make, and I've got a couple of others I'll reserve for later, but why United? Kent really focused on that, but one of the points he hadn't made is we've been working with United Airlines as a dominant carrier in Aston Snowmass since I've been affiliated with the program in 1995, and they went through a significant change as Air Wisconsin was then there.
26:42 dominant carrier, and they had to get rid of the BA-146, and like I said, we've been flying CRJ-700s with SkyWest ever since. And United is a very different airline today, this year, than they even were three or four years ago.
26:57 They've gone through a lot of cultural change, senior management changes, and I had the opportunity to sit in on a presentation from their senior vice president of network planning just a few weeks ago at a nurse service development conference, and he focused on some of United's core strategies, and among them was focusing on where they've lost round against some of their competitors in recent years, and to focus on attributes that they call uniquely united. One of those attributes is ski, where they've been losing share since the merger with Continental back in 2011.
27:25 So there's a redoubled effort from United Airlines to focus on ski, and I think the timing of that is very fortuitous with the change that you guys have seen here with Alaska pulling out and the opportunity to bring United in. It's part of their core strategy, and it's in great alignment, and I think you're very fortunate to have this opportunity to have United truly play a dominant role here in this market with not just one hub of San Francisco, but two, potentially three hubs where you're really tapping into the entire network.
27:53 of United Airlines. So I see this as nothing but a golden opportunity. And then the third point I wanted to make, this is related to one of Kent's opening slides when he talked about how quickly the change came from Alaska Airlines. Well, I have to tell you, that story reminds me so much of the story that I had back in 2005, 2006, when we had a March meeting with United. Again, a different United Airlines back then than they are today. But I had asked specifically, how long do you expect the BAA-146 to be flying?
28:23 Because it's an older aircraft, and he's like, oh, you've got years and years before we have to worry about that. Less than 30 days later, we were hosting the Mountain Travel Symposium in Aspen, and I saw our account manager sitting in the lobby of the St. Regis, and I'd just received a press release from Air Wisconsin announcing that they're going to be retiring to BA-146. They're not going to even respond to the RFP United sent out for express service, but they're going to keep four airplanes alive just to service Aspen for one more year.
28:52 So I can relate to how quickly things can change in the airline industry and how quickly we needed to react and adapt and come up with a solution, which we were successful in doing. And this also speaks to how successful Kent and this team here have been at coming up with a solution to the surprise announcement made by Alaska back on May 18th. So I'm sure I'll have more comments to add. Can I just build a question?
29:17 Since, you know, right now, Aspen, what, the 225,000, 250,000 deployments a year, and you're using just a regional jet, do you believe we have enough connectivity with this program? This is going to be far better connectivity than you've ever had before. So it's a step in the right direction. Aspen, we've been very fortunate. You know, we are down to very, very limited service in 1994 after Continental pulled out. Again, after Frontier Airlines was a carrier in our marketplace that pulled out.
29:46 2012. Things change in the airline industry and it takes time to rebuild the flight programs. And now we're in a fortunate situation in Aspen today where we actually have all three major network carriers. In addition to United, we have American and Delta flying nonstop flights from 10 hubs, 10 nonstop hubs during the winter months. And it's actually very successful and we're seeing some reasonable competition.
30:14 This program, as outlined here today, is an excellent step in the right direction. I see, in terms of overall connectivity, it being a huge improvement from what you've had with just United from San Francisco and Alaska from LA. And the reason I ask you the question is, I think Ken was kind of leading towards, I'm kind of inferring a little bit, that another flight to SFO would greatly enhance already what we're doing. We haven't got to that point of conversation, but I may be referring too much there, but you're basically kind of saying another flight would really enhance that. I'm just trying to...
30:41 Think ahead in terms of are we thinking broad enough from an overall standpoint? Because we still have to talk about San Diego. How many is enough seats? The challenge we have, you know, San Francisco has never exceeded a 54% load factor, John, or something? We've got to fill some seats. If you go back and you look at that, we've got to do something here. We've got to create some more demand.
31:12 You know, that takes, it may only take one, I don't know what the icon pass is going to do. I mean, there's, Eric knows how many passovers there are in Denver. There's a large number! As Kent alluded to earlier, that was one of the metrics that we looked at in trying to figure out what would be the best connectivity for us.
31:40 And I want to share some of those metrics in the sense that 72% of our ICOM pass holders live in either Colorado or California. And that breaks down to where 42% of them are in California and 30% of them are in Colorado. Further breaks down to where you have 60% in Northern California, or I'm sorry, 60% in Southern California of the California portion.
32:10 and 40% in Northern California. So when you go back and you look at Kent's spider map of San Francisco, Denver, LAX, and you look at that connectivity, that's 72% of our numbers right there. Why is it San Diego? I mean, that's a portion of longer. That's 80% of California. Why are we not going out of that? Sorry, but you'll need to, if you want to speak publicly, we need you to come up to the podium and address and state your name.
32:42 Thank you. Hi, everybody. I'm Scotty Marzoni with Mammoth Taxi Transportation out here in Mammoth since the inception of our airport. So the Southern California basis of our, you know, basically all the people that come up here, 80%, I've always heard 80, 85% of Southern California. The connectivity issues being fantastic and being great hubs in Denver, San Francisco, and LA, the concern is we had San Diego flights with United before.
33:14 And they were, I mean, good from a ground transportation standpoint. I don't have all the numbers in my head or profitability. But it seems the people I talk to, the ones that are down below and near San Diego, are going to be more apt to take the flights because of the longer drive and...
33:32 I won't go into Vegas because I don't know that option either, but I'd love to know why we're not doing a San Diego into Vegas because of the also international people that come from all over. That's part of our circle, the San Francisco, LA, Las Vegas, Death Valley. I mean, it's all part of that connectivity that what people are coming to our area for. It seems like a good idea. I'd like to know the reasoning why we aren't going after San Diego primarily, but then Las Vegas is a hub why it would or would not work for United.
34:01 Hey, Kent, I know you're going to jump in there, but I'm going to answer the San Diego real quick, and that is, we asked United and they said that they would not do it. And to give you some numbers, the San Diego, Alaska was about 3,600, 3,700 employments this last year.
34:22 So that's how many. We do know that that market is imperative for us. And as a matter of fact, on the sheet, we have an opportunity to go down there. It's not through United because they won't do it, but we are looking to add service there because it's an important aspect to us. And you can go back and show that. As far as Vegas is concerned, Vegas isn't a real hub. There is no...
34:51 It's like for a legacy carrier. Allegiant has kind of a hub there more than anything that they've got going on. But there's a lot of point-to-point service to Vegas that they would have to transfer, and it gets complicated with luggage and tickets and so forth. Ken? Yes, sir.
35:17 Did you have any exposure to how that affected their business from an airline standpoint? I wasn't with the company at the time. I left their resorts as an executive in 99, so I don't know. I can say this. I do work for Crested Butte and Gunnison. They are like jumping off, you know.
35:42 Going, whoa, this is too much. And I can see the impact already for summer flights that they have. And they think it's associated with the Epic Pass. I mean, it's a big deal, these two pass competitors. And the people that are running those are highly intense people. They are competitive to a fault almost. But it's going to make a big deal. The Epic Pass is going to make a big deal.
36:12 And the Icon Pass will make a big difference. Will it affect the Denver flights? Absolutely. The Icon Pass will affect all of these flights. I mean, my kids are a perfect example of it. I mean, they are independent consultants. I mean, they work for consulting firms. They have points that they can fly anywhere they want to, and they'll buy these passes, show up at these resorts.
36:38 Hey, Kent, can we go back to the service that we're evaluating for the San Diego market? We didn't quite cover that for Scotty's question. I just want to finish answering that. Oh, here. You want to go to here? Yeah. Okay. And explain what we're looking at. Okay, so the shaded area of LAX, San Francisco, Burbank, Orange County, and Oakland, we have a verbal or a written commitment. And, Kent, just to clarify.
37:10 We've had LAX and SFO with legacy carriers in the past. That's continuing. Burbank was regional with JetSuite. Is that loaded currently or just... No, it's a verbal commitment. None of the JetSuite stuff is loaded at this point. Okay. So they plan to reinstate Burbank and then they've also given verbal commitment through JetSuite that they would also add Oakland and... Orange County. Orange County. I have written...
37:38 Commitment on that. They're not loaded yet. Sure. None of the JetSuite X. Understood. So they have a commitment that they're willing to continue with Burbank and add those two additional flights. You got it. And then your recommendation would be to add an additional legacy out of Denver and add a potential additional regional carrier out of either San Diego or Carlsbad. That's exactly right. Thanks.
38:06 Hi, good morning. Very exciting series of developments. Great to be having this conversation. My name is John Wentworth. I serve in the Town Council. I also serve as the Chair of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. So I want to ask an air service airport question. As we've been talking through this over the last year or so with the potential to move operations down to Bishop, the ESCOG and our regional partners have been very clear to make a differentiation between the air service conversation, which is what we're having today,
38:36 and the issue of airports. And Scott, if you could designate, whether it's Ken or Eric or someone, to speak specifically to the role that the opportunity to move air service operations to Bishop is playing with these conversations with United Airlines. It's going to be very important and very helpful for all the regional partners working on the airport side of this thing and the infrastructure side of this stuff to understand
39:02 Does United have expectations? I know the TBID's only in place for five years. How does this air service conversation you're having now, what should we know from the regional partners' perspective, from the town's role as an airport in all this, in terms of our expectations, in terms of United's expectations for air service and the moving of service down to Bishop? And very much looking forward to hearing whoever wants to speak to that. I'd like to clarify your question. Basically, you're asking...
39:26 Is United expecting a commitment for a new airport to be able to be part of this, or are they happy to stay at Mammoth if that's not working? I just, if the information that whoever can share in terms of whatever, if they have any expectations, if they do have expectations, to help inform the kinds of conversations going on between Mammoth and Inyo County, to help really understand the role, if any, that an airport and the air service happening at a Bishop plays in all this.
39:52 Is there anything predicated in the agreement with United that requires a new airport in Bishop, or is this specifically they'll fly to what's available in the region?
40:01 Let me answer the basis of the question, not that specific question. And that is that United is very much aware of our desire to, and obviously this is a mountain desire to move to Bishop. I don't want to speak for others, but because we want a regional, consistent, and reliable air service that, as mentioned here today, hasn't been the case at the Mammoth Airport.
40:30 United has written a letter and offered that commitment that we've submitted to the FAA so that they know that as a carrier that they're very committed to going in that direction. And I think it's towards Bishop and it's a really important point that John has made that we're trying to do something separate here. We're talking about air service and then there's the airport. So those are two different issues.
40:59 And today is the air service for this upcoming winter. But as we look at this strategy and as we look at what this service represents, it certainly is a building platform to what it could be in three to five years. And United is saying that they like that. They want to be uniquely united. They want to be ski destination. They want to look at that. However, I will share with you that there are some challenges ahead.
41:26 Even with all the excitement of United and them being a great partner that they are, the CRJ 700 is eventually going to go away just like the Q400. So as we look to how are we going to provide reliable and consistent air service, it's not just a CRJ United answer at Mammoth. You have to look further down the line.
41:50 So it is interplaying, but we're trying to keep the conversation separate. As we go forward, there may be more information to share, but as we have those regional discussions, there's a group of folks from the town, from the mountain, from Altera or Mammoth Resorts or whatever, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, engaged in these conversations. And as we move into the ESCOG, the MIWAG, which is the public convening of these discussions, I'm hoping that there will be a designated representative who can speak.
42:19 from the air surface side of things as we're having discussions on the airport side of things and making sure that we're all in sync and the expectations are properly set.
42:29 so that folks, second homeowners and others can understand how the future of air service and airports is going to work in the region. It's something we're all very excited about, something we're all very interested in giving time and resources to doing, but there are going to be some needs for some institutional capacity. Certainly, I'm not expecting that Mammoth Lakes Tourism is going to be able to deal with all the subsidy issues. You know, people are flying into Bishop. Sure, the Mammoth TBID can cover someone who gets off a plane and Bishop comes to Mammoth. If they get off the plane of Bishop and they go to Death Valley,
42:58 We've got some institutional development work to do here with all our partners in the region. I think it's going to be critically important to make sure that we are continually articulating the expectations and the needs to make this thing successful. So thank you. A more near-term question, if you don't mind. So for the record, I'm excited by this plan that's put forth, and I'm also so forward with the idea of going to Bishop. But the question I want to ask is more specifically to where I think John was leading. We know it takes a long time to build a market.
43:26 So if we support this and United has an expectation that in three to five years we're going to be in Bishop because it's more stable and we can't get an agreement from LADWP to give us enough groundwater for firefighting, which I think is going to be an issue. We do have that agreement in Bishop, by the way. Okay. So let's say we don't have an airport because we know things take off. Let's say we don't have an airport in four years. Is there a risk that we're going to spend three years of subsidy money to develop the Denver market and United's going to say?
43:52 Nope, you guys didn't get the Bishop Airport fast enough. I want to understand what their expectation is. Is it, do they have the patience for five years? Do they have the patience for seven years? Are we going to spend to try and develop a market and there's an expectation that in 24 months we're going to be in Bishop? Has any of that been communicated? There's, as it's related to their commitment is that we support the air service here in the region and wherever it goes, it is, we're with you.
44:18 So they're not saying we're only with you because you're moving to Bishop. They actually said in the letter that they support it as this air service that you're developing. So none of this is predicated on a future. That's what I wanted to clarify. Yes. Can I, because I know we're not here to talk about it, but because Bill is kind of an expert in this area, I do want to make the group aware of the CRJ 700.
44:47 situation. And Bill, if you don't mind commenting on as you look at Aspen's service and where that's going and what you're preparing for as it's related to the CRJ-700? That is a perfect segue because I was actually going to see if I could interject some comments because they're relevant to this discussion right now. As I mentioned, the CRJ-700 has been flying successfully into the Aspen Airport since 2006. The reality is there have been no new CRJ-700s built since 2011.
45:17 And there is a finite lifespan for how long those aircraft will continue to fly. And they're actually somewhat of a shorter lifespan with regional jets because they are cycle limited. And once they hit a certain number of cycles or flight hours, they essentially turn into pumpkins. And it's usually about 20 years of a lifespan that you can reasonably expect out of most regional jet aircraft before the maintenance becomes absolutely prohibitive.
45:42 to continue to breathe life into those aircraft. So we recognize that, you know, the average age of the CRJ-700 is between 10 and 15 years right now. So they're going to start being removed from the fleets, you know, in the early 2020s, and we expect by probably 2031, you know, we'll be seeing the last of the CRJ-700s actually flying.
46:03 So this is something we've been well aware of at the Aspen Airport because it is now the only commercial aircraft that can fly in and out of ASE. And it's something that we've actually just completed an environmental assessment on for some mandatory airport improvements to increase the runway-taxiway separation to allow the whole new generation of regional jet aircraft to be able to potentially operate in and out of the Aspen Airport. That includes like the Bombardier C-Series, which is going to start being flown by Delta as soon as next year, the Embraer E-175.
46:33 and the E-2 series, which are going to have higher performance, less noise and less environmental impact because of a new wing design and new engines. And it also includes the Mitsubishi aircraft, which is another...
46:47 New clean sheet design, which is undergoing tests in North America right now, for which SkyWest has a firm order of 100 of these aircraft. So as I mentioned in my introduction, there are a lot of similarities between the Aspen Airport and what's happening here in Mammoth. And some of our experiences and the research that we've done that I'm already sharing with you all and what we're anticipating for could have great relevance with the...
47:10 conversations that are taking place about preparing Bishop for the future, because you're basically preparing for the same type of aircraft that we are down the road, and it's important to have that long-term view. Bringing it back in a little bit shorter term, I also wanted to comment on the recent fleet shift of the CRJ-700s. SkyWest is really the best CRJ-700 operator in the world. They have 76 of those aircraft.
47:34 Until recently, as recent as two years ago, they had 60 of those CRJ-700s flying for United and the vast majority of the remaining ones flying for Delta.
47:44 What's happened since is because of the pilot scope clause at United Airlines, they wanted to start flying more Embraer 175s across their network, but they were limited to the total number of 70 to 76 passenger aircraft that they could legally operate because of their pilot contracts. So for every new Embraer 175 they brought into their fleet, they had to get rid of a CRJ-700. So the net effect is over two years.
48:10 United's CRJ-700 fleet, operated by SkyWest, has gone from 60 aircraft down to 20. That is why United was not able to offer an option from San Diego. They just don't have the airplanes anymore. And I can tell you, of those 20 aircraft, we've got 18 of them that are touching Aspen one way or another every day during the winter.
48:29 And through another stroke of luck, because of the introduction of the Embraer 175, which was never originally designed as a mountain performance aircraft, but there was a new enhanced performance module that was introduced to those aircraft just over a year ago to make them more viable at Denver, a major hub for United. They've also been able to start introducing those Embraer 175s over a year ago into Sun Valley, which is another airport with similar constraints. And just within the past month, they started introducing the E-175 into both Eagle and Jackson Hole.
48:59 in the hot and high environment in the summer. That has actually freed up some additional CRJ-700s both for Aspen and also for Mammoth and one of the reasons that you are able to enjoy this sort of miracle service with 33 days notice after Alaska told you guys they're pulling out. It's all intertwined here with the aircraft availability. So short-term, long-term, you know, the CRJ-700 is a great mountain aircraft.
49:26 There's been some musical airplanes in terms of who's flying them, and that's also why we've got more flights on Delta and American in recent years, because now they have some of those CRJ-700s that used to be flown for United. And then long term, you know, it's going to be really important that we, both communities in Aspen Snowmass and here, have airport solutions that will accommodate the next generation of aircraft, all of which have wingspans in excess of our wingspan restriction in Aspen. I think it's also important to note that United did have Q400s.
49:56 Yes. And they've retired that fleet? Yeah, they did. Republic flew them, and they actually flew them into Aspen for a period of time. And that was short-lived. Those aircraft, they become very expensive to maintain over time as well as they get older. And that's exactly one of the challenges that Verizon had seen. Let's be clear, the retirement of the CRJ isn't related to a lack of fundamental commitment to regional service. It's just to do with that aircraft? Yep.
50:22 So they're going to replace that aircraft and commit and stay committed to regional service. Absolutely. So to your point, we're vulnerable but not perhaps that vulnerable because they're committed. You have to see what planes are flying exactly. Okay. Exactly what happened with the changes. These aircraft, they transition out and it's kind of like they're gone. You know, they're headed to the chop shop. This Embraer aircraft, you're going to do that. What was that? They improved.
50:51 Will that be able to land a Mammoth or will Mammoth require to submit a Mammoth to have a Mammoth?
50:57 I don't know yet, and I don't even know if that aircraft can fly into Aspen yet, even though it fits within our wingspan restriction. It's very expensive for the airlines to develop procedures and train their pilots and do all the simulator tests that are required to introduce a new aircraft type into our market. And I can tell you what they've quoted me for the Aspen Airport is that we've not yet found a procedure we're comfortable with flying it into Aspen, and they're not willing to make that investment yet in terms of time and energy since they have an aircraft that fits perfectly into Aspen today.
51:27 So if they're not willing to make that investment for Aspen, it's probably unlikely they're going to want to make that investment for Mammoth Lakes anytime soon. John's been waiting. Sorry, guys. John's been waiting. John's been waiting. That's okay. I have a couple of questions. One, first, on the original table, I guess my question is, why Oakland rather than San Jose? Is there a reason for that? Because it's the same, if it's the same carrier? JetSuite? Just curious. JetSuite serves both markets.
51:58 They have a hangar and a head, not a hangar, but a kind of a second headquarter and a hangar at Oakland. We had a lot of conversations about that and a bit of a toss-up, you know, what we're trying to do here and how does it balance with what's going on in San Francisco. So that was certainly under consideration. Just curious, I didn't see it on there. I think San Jose, we had aircraft, they didn't have the aircraft in San Jose. They really didn't have the aircraft availability there.
52:27 My second question has to do with San Francisco, and maybe you can clarify a little bit for me, but I know that San Francisco, at least my understanding has been that San Francisco has been a more challenging airport for flights originating from more clogs in San Francisco, more cancellations originating from San Francisco here. A woman over here talked earlier about reliable service, and mechanical is one thing, but there are issues with weather in San Francisco or other things that cause
52:56 cancellations from San Francisco here. So what, although I personally feel San Francisco is a better option for a lot of things international and some other things and hubs, what are we looking at as far as reliability of flights from San Francisco versus LA because of that? Because the more cancellations we get that originate there have nothing to do with weather and Mammoth causes more problems for us. We went back and looked at the
53:22 On-time performance records out of both San Francisco and LA as a standalone. And to my surprise, they were not that much different. I mean, it was like 2% and 3%, you know, 3% being up in San Francisco. Those are not the exact numbers. 1.6 versus 0.6. Yeah, okay, one percentage point. One percentage point different.
53:47 Okay. And I was kind of stunned because that's the same perception that I had and I would agree with that. Well, in our cancellations last year, we were 10% out of LA, 12% out of San Francisco. So San Francisco, we do have flow problems, air traffic control problems because there's just too many planes moving around. We haven't had the fog issues that we had three years ago as much as our own weather issues on our side. So the air traffic control is a hard part. LA is under construction right now so we've also had some of that with
54:17 with Alaska as well. And one just follow-up question, John, maybe this is more for you on the marketing side. Regarding, and if I'm getting ahead, you can cut me off, but regarding China and the mandate for 100 million skiers by 2024, 200 million? So what, you know, what's the feeling on
54:40 Our ability to reach China, to get people, and now with the ICON Pass, if you have people coming from China skiing, coming here for 10 days, as long as they're going to come, it's going to be a long trip. How does that translate into where we want to put our efforts? Is San Francisco the best place to have that, maybe an extra flight or something, or is Denver? In other words, where are those Chinese skiers going to be coming from? Can we capture a larger market? Is that part of...
55:07 Our strategy going forward, obviously the Icon Pass has a huge amount to do with it, but what about that international travel too? I'd like to speak to that because I used to live in China and I will tell you that when I lived there, the flight from Shanghai and the flight from Hong Kong that fly direct to San Francisco perfectly lines up with that connection to go through San Francisco Airport. When that flight wasn't available, my travel back and forth to Asia was really challenging. For me personally,
55:35 Having been through that experience quite a bit, I was going back and forth as much as 10 times a year, it lined up exceptionally well from those two markets, from Hong Kong and Shanghai, directly in direct flights, Flight 869 comes in, it's like a five-hour layover, four-and-a-half-hour layover, which is what you need to get through San Francisco Customs and international person on the visa. I think it's a really ideal, we talked about this before, it seems like it's a really ideal opportunity. That's Mike. Those schedules will change some, you know, given what we have, but...
56:03 I can pull the similar spider map as well as what you call a bank analysis. It'll give you the list of connecting cities. But again, those change a little bit from year to year. So as it grows, we'll have that connected. I guess the final part of my question is how much of our air marketing strategy is domestic and is now shifting more towards icon pass holders and international versus are we still
56:33 I won't say this delicately, are we that concerned with people in Los Angeles who live there flying to Mammoth or are we going after other people? That's I guess the main thing because I don't feel like just the people from flying from LA to here because of it's only a five hour drive and the cost of bringing toys and all that other stuff has been that effective. So are we going at a much broader market now? It seems like it makes sense to me. I just want to kind of.
57:01 And the goal has been to go after the broader market. I think we've expanded with our marketing in general. I think when we look at the international side, when Michael Vanderhurst is in Australia or Germany or UK or wherever he is, the opportunity with United is much bigger than we've ever had with our current connections. We had Qantas flying into San Francisco that connected with United already. So I think when we start to look at the
57:27 the opportunities internationally. This will make a huge impact. I think we also, and I'm not sure whether Altera still has the connection, but Squaw used to have a connection with Hidden Garden in China, the ski resort, mainly the big Olympic resort. So I think that we've got a lot of those things in place. I think that this is something that Michael's...
57:46 Ready to rock with all of our international agencies. So we've got agencies around the world and everywhere from China to South Korea to UK, Australia, Germany, Italy, France, and just get that message out there. He was in Brazil a few weeks ago, and even just the whispers of United Airlines were great because of the connectivity. So I think that that's another reason why we look at San Francisco. And, you know, in the past, just roughly we have 50% of the people coming from the San Francisco flight come from San Francisco.
58:14 The other 50% are coming from around the world, whether it's Chicago or Singapore. And I think when we look at LA, it is much more of a local flying traffic. And in the grand scheme of things, for the health of the community, the idea is to get the person that's going to stay the whole week, not just Friday through Sunday, and then fly back to their job in LA.
58:31 To your point, I think that this connectivity is going to give us a lot more opportunity for that destination traffic. I think the Icon Pass is going to be a huge piece because even when we talk about Denver, it's great that we have a huge concentration of Icon Pass holders in Denver, but we have the opportunity to connect Newark, you know, Chicago, Houston, everybody else that can come through Denver with one stop to come here. And I think that the...
58:54 Yeah, I mean, Texas, Texas Ski Council, Crescent Ski Council, Chicago Metro Ski Council, Florida Ski Club, you know, huge amounts of people that are going to own this pass. And the easier we can make it for people to fly in with a one stop through Denver or even flying into San Francisco and coming in. You know, you can fly right now the way this, the Denver, the LA flight is set up. You can fly Boston, LA, LA Mammoth and be here by four in the afternoon. So I think the connectivity is going to be huge and there is a major opportunity for us to increase that message out there.
59:24 That answers all my questions. So if I may, my goal here is to kind of drive this conversation forward.
59:28 Our ultimate goal here is we have a recommendation on the table. The board needs to deal with that recommendation. So first of all, I want to say thank you to both of you guys for coming. It's awesome to have experts in the room, and the amount of information provided is really helpful in us making a recommendation. Also, thanks to the group that went down to LA and met with the FAA. I think if we would have lost service this winter to LA, that would have been catastrophic. So thank you for doing that work to backfill that so quickly and put us in a good position.
59:58 You know, I think we're getting maybe caught up a little bit in the weeds here with some of the aircraft type and those type of things. I don't really think that should be a large concern for the board because I think what I'm hearing loud and clear is that the air industry is constantly changing. You're coming from Aspen, which is an airport like a steamboat or a Jackson Hole that has had a tremendous amount of success with those regional type carriers and bringing people to town. So I think that...
1:00:26 While things are constantly changing, we just need to be willing to adapt to that. And the important tenet here is that we want to have a reliable regional air service for our region. And so whether that's a CRJ 700 or a Q400 or whatever it is.
1:00:43 There's going to be aircraft type and carriers that are looking to provide that service. And as long as we're in the conversation and that's important to us, I'm not concerned about changing aircrafts in the industry. You know, and I think the air industry as a whole is going through a lot of changes right now. I mean, talk about an industry that people are fed up with. It's very similar to the taxi industry. That's why Uber was able to come in and completely revolutionize that industry. I think we're seeing some of that change with the jet suites and the like.
1:01:12 So to me, I've been very public in the fact that I think that our regional solution may down the line include two airports and how we figure that out. But if you look at the chart of the recommendation there, you've got a combination of legacy larger carriers and smaller regional carriers. I think that's what's going to...
1:01:31 take us into the future is looking at how that mix works. I'm not, to kind of your point, John, I'm not tremendously convinced that a bunch of people are going to want to jump on a plane in LA and fly to Bishop. That being said, if somebody wants to come from Chicago or Newark or Florida, maybe flying into Bishop is a tremendous option. If you look at ski industry, flying long haul and being 40 minutes away from your destination is tremendously convenient.
1:02:00 Also flying in a short regional capacity and being eight minutes away from your destination is tremendously convenient. So, you know, we have our challenges now, but I think if we can get through some of those hurdles, we have a very convenient option on the table.
1:02:15 You know, if you look at one of Mammoth Achilles heels in the ski industry, it's always been our connectivity and our access to people. So, you know, you can pick up any ski magazine and it says the same thing every single time that, you know, people love the mountain, people love the ski experience. It's difficult to get here. So that's something that we need to address as a community, especially with the Icon Pass. If we want to take advantage of that stuff, we need to provide multiple options for people to get here.
1:02:44 I'm actually tremendously supportive of the recommendation that you provided. I'm really pleased to see that. Would you mind going to that slide for me while I'm walking through this? Okay, hang on. I'm not here. That last one. If you don't mind real quick, if you can clarify, so the recommendation that we're going to discuss today, I'm looking for a motion on if someone desires, is this recommendation as outlined in the slide you were about to show with your subsidy dollars is already approved within TBID.
1:03:13 Correct. Just to make sure. Well, the subsidy dollars, overall subsidy dollars approved. So we're not asking for any change to anything on a budgetary standpoint. We're just asking for support for the recommendation as it exists here. Correct. We currently have $2.3 million approved for subsidy summer winter.
1:03:31 What we're asking for right now is agreement from the board to move in the direction of this. We may not end up, you know, again, we're shooting for Carlsbad. If we don't get Calgary Pacific. Just take the available seats slide. Oh, the available seats slide. Keep going. So if we don't end up with Carlsbad, we still want the board to say, yes, we want to keep moving forward with this. We're in agreement that this is where we think we can go. This is the direction. This is the direction, yes. And I think it's important.
1:04:00 I understand, though, Scott, to your point, it doesn't mean that if we implement this, it doesn't mean that the subsidy risk is only at $2.3 million. It could be significantly over that, especially because the Denver flight is an expensive flight. So we as the Mountain are looking at that additional risk and believe in it and are too.
1:04:27 supportive of what we're looking at, but we're also expecting to pay a lot more than the $2.3 million. And that's the mountain. But the risk to MLT is the $2.3. That's right. It's the cap. That's correct. As originally stated, you said that this was the $2.3 and that's the risk to MLT, but there's further risk. And I think that's an important note that if Altera and Mammoth...
1:04:53 Believe enough that they're going to take on greater risk without a greater risk to MLT. Yes. Likely the marketing and push behind that to help mitigate that risk also benefits MLT on the back end. Yep. And MLT helping with the marketing as well. So thank you for that clarification. I just want the board to have this conversation, so I'm going to start off.
1:05:15 You know, I think I've always been very supportive of us kind of dominating the state of California, and I think that needs to include LAX and San Francisco, of course. So I'm supportive of continuing that, especially with all the connectivity and it being United Hub and all that kind of stuff. To Scotty's point, I would like to see us continue to push for San Diego, because I think that's a big piece of our market, the additional drive time and having to go through.
1:05:39 LA traffic and all that kind of stuff. I think it does make it an attractive flight for people from San Diego and that's a big customer base for us. So I'm supportive of pushing forward with some sort of either San Diego or Carlsbad solution. You know, I love the JetSuite model and adding in some of those smaller regionals with Oakland and Orange County I think is great. So I'm supportive of that in addition to Burbank. Denver specifically, I'm tremendously keen on that.
1:06:07 Denver is the hub of the ski industry. As you articulated already, now we cover 72% of the ICON pass holders. I spend a lot of time in Colorado for work. Denver is exploding, as most of you know. It's a destination. People are moving there in droves.
1:06:28 Component of that is the tech sector that is exploding in Denver. And I think that fits in tremendously well with a lot of the initiatives we're doing at the town, with the fort, with our digital 395 efforts. You know, these are the exact type of people.
1:06:44 That we're trying to get to come to Mammoth. You know, these are the type of people that work remotely. They can come here for three, five, seven, ten days a month if they want to. So, you know, it's a very, very good target market for us. And it also provides a tremendous amount of connectivity to the rest of the country. So, you know, I think Denver is something I'm really, really keen on pushing that forward. And I think...
1:07:09 You know, that's where I'm at. I'd really like to see us push Denver first and foremost. And then secondarily, I'd really like us to see come up with something out of San Diego. So well done on the recommendation for everybody that put effort into this. I was really pleased to see that. One comment about San Diego. The number one O&D market for Aspen or their LAX flights, San Diego. We don't have a non-stop in San Diego ourselves, but it is by far the number one connect point through.
1:07:41 Los Angeles as well as Phoenix. So they will connect. So they originate in San Diego, fly to LAX, go to Phoenix. And they'll fly that. That's not much of a backup. Sure. I'd like to have that too. I mean, it was originally laid out.
1:07:58 LAX and San Diego, and I agree with you. And we see that in the summertime when we have just the LAX flight, and we do see San Diego fly to LAX and then up with us. I think it's funny, so back in my day when I worked with Colorado Ski Country, you know, one of the things that's important is that the top five ski markets for Colorado are Colorado number one, Texas number two, Florida number three, Illinois number four, and then California number five.
1:08:21 Yeah. And in the grand scheme of things, back in one of the peak years while I was there, 41% of the traffic, 41% of all skier visits in Colorado came from Colorado. So the front range of Colorado is huge, but the connectivity through there to Texas, Florida.
1:08:36 Chicago. It's a pretty amazing opportunity, and I think that that's going to be one of the big keys to getting us to being that destination. And it's somewhat anecdotal, but I spent a lot of time in Denver. I was just there with some buddies in the city.
1:08:52 The conversation is like very robust in Denver right now. Epic icon. That's like it comes up in the hot tub at the bar. Everywhere you are, people are talking about ski season and which pass they're going to buy. And most people view them as kind of relatively equivalent passes and they're just kind of choosing one based on which resorts they prefer.
1:09:12 The Epic Pass is getting a lot of pushback right now due to I-70. It is an absolute disaster. And people do not want to jump in the car and drive to Vail and Breckenridge on the weekend. So, you know, they're dealing with that, that people are saying, you know what, I'd rather go to these different resorts because it's become such a headache to get to Breckenridge on a Saturday. So they can honestly fly from Denver to Mammoth much easier than they can drive to Vail on a Saturday morning.
1:09:40 You know, I think people are really starting to think about, you know, moving towards the Icon Pass and what that brings, and Mammoth is one of the key resorts in the Icon Pass, and having that direct connectivity would be huge. You know, and I've always thought, what is our regional? What do we get east of California to start to open us up to the rest of the country? And I never really cared whether it was Salt Lake City or...
1:10:03 Phoenix, or Las Vegas, or Denver, and now I think Denver has really moved to the top because of all the things we've already talked about. And our partner in the airline obviously having the connectivity. Yeah. Ken, a quick question. All of the options other than obviously the legacy, they can all land in Bishop? All of our other options at all JetSuite? Oh yes, they can all land in Bishop. Well, so JetSuite can't, right now JetSuite couldn't schedule service.
1:10:32 Well, they can divert because it's unscheduled. But they currently couldn't schedule service to Bishop because Bishop is in Part 139. Right, no, but I'm saying in weather or whatever, they can't divert there. Except California Pacific. Yeah, if we went to California Pacific. There's a question there because it's a 50-seat aircraft. Gotcha. And that was there just because they were kind of a late comer to the party when they finally found out who to contact. They're TSA, so that's different. Yeah, exactly. Go ahead.
1:11:07 Lucas with Moss Transportation. Question regarding the, I think you mentioned there was about 10% cancellation from United, 12% on Alaska. Alaska. Other way. The other way around? 10% Alaska, 12%. 10% Alaska. Alaska had three flights daily last year. United only had one. If you're going all United this year, and you have a lot of times...
1:11:34 People that cancel in Alaska were able to fly into, sorry, cancel on the United were able to move into Alaska and just get out of here. If you're going to have a lot of cancellations to Alaska, I don't know how Aspen does with basically visitor retention and long term, what do you guys do out there to basically people that have better experience out here and are trying to basically get out of Aspen.
1:12:01 It's been a years-long process to try to improve the guest experience, but it has improved a lot the past couple of years with all three carriers using Grand Junction as the primary alternate. It's about a two-hour drive away, but it's only the long-haul flights that divert there. The Denver flights, because they have such a short return, and to get that aircraft positioned to where it needs to go, if they know that they're not going to be able to land and ask them to just cancel the flight and provide ground transportation from there. So it's been an improvement.
1:12:31 But it takes time, you know, to figure out the operations. I can actually tell you what we've experienced here in just the last six days. I've never seen better coordination between the carriers and ground transportation companies because our airport was greatly impacted by the wildfire when outside the salt. There was a temporary flight restriction that recluded instrument.
1:12:53 Flights from coming through the fire suppression efforts. So we've had well over half of our flights canceled since the 4th of July when that fire broke out and operations are finally returning to normal today. But the coordination between all three airlines and using ground transportation to get to gather people from Grand Junction has never been better, but it's taking time to get there. Thank you. I think that's a great question, but that's always been one of the major Achilles heels for Mammoth is we have no backup option.
1:13:22 You know, to fly somebody that's flying from LA, circle the airport and go back to LA or divert them to San Francisco, that's not a sufficient backup plan. So, you know, I think that's why we continue to work on this regional solution. You know, if at a steamboat, for example, where I used to live, if you can't land in Hayden,
1:13:45 You fly back to Denver, which is a pretty significant diversion. It's three and a half hours, but to your point, they have a very robust ground transportation system that's very seamless.
1:13:54 You land in Denver. Maybe you were supposed to check in at your hotel at 3 p.m. You end up getting into your hotel at 7 p.m., but you still get all your nights. You still get all your days on the hill. Your trip is not ruined. Whereas if you divert over to San Francisco and get stuck in a storm cycle and your flight gets canceled day after day after day until your entire trip is gone, that's a very different experience for the guests. So I think that's an infrastructure question more than a flight question. What we're trying to do is build out the network and have a robust...
1:14:23 Must Flight Program, but that's absolutely something that we need to be focusing on for the future is what is our backup plan. If somebody does fly into Mammoth and they can divert to Bishop like JetSuite does, that's great, you know, but, you know, just turning them back around to LA is problematic. So I think we've got a lot to work out on the infrastructure side in the future, but right now we're just trying to detail the flight side of things. My name is Tom Johnson. I'm the Director of Marketing for The Mountain. I just want, I have a
1:14:56 Comment and a question. The comment is just basically to share, to amplify a little bit of what Eric was talking about, our passholder base, and a little bit of passholder, encouraging passholder tracking that we did. We don't have much experience with ICON passholders. We have about two months' worth from last spring. But we issued a very surprising number of
1:15:22 temporary icon passes in April and May. As you recall, we had a buy now, ride now deal, and we were one of the only mountains left to open. And we didn't know what to expect. If Eric gives me the nod, I'll share the number. But it was a lot of passes we issued. We were not... It was about 10,000. And these are incremental pass holders. These are not people who had California passes.
1:15:49 the year before. These are purely new people to the pass base who came up to ski with us in that two-month window, and we did a heat map that kind of compared California pass holders coming up for spring skiing versus these new Icon pass holders. The California heat map was centered on Mammoth, as you'd expect, all our local skiing, and Southern California. You didn't see a shade of color anywhere else in the heat map.
1:16:17 For these ICON pass holders, we were getting visitation from Northern California, from Seattle, from Salt Lake City, from Denver, from even Dallas. And that's without, you know, this more sophisticated routing for those pass holders. So it's a small sample size, but it's a really encouraging kind of, I guess,
1:16:39 A bit of data that shows the kind of demand profile that we'll be working with coming into next year. And then my question is, when would these load, these new, if these are approved, because I've got, I mean, my first outbound winter campaign, early booking campaign is starting at the end of this month. And I'd love to be able to tell people how to get here and then book lodging. LAX in San Francisco is loaded. Okay. They are available for sale. You can go on united.com, done. And then Denver?
1:17:08 Denver? That's why I keep on looking at that computer. If we get an okay today, it wouldn't shock me if we get it loaded in a couple weeks. But I've got to get this thing squared away. Thanks, Tom. With regards to Denver, I just want to reaffirm the things that Colin has said about Denver because it seems to me that our future
1:17:40 Am I not talking loud enough for you to record? I just want to make sure it gets on the audio. Our future is not adding more skiers from Southern California on weekends. That's cast in stone. The only way we can progress as not only a ski area but a community and an economic community is to increase that midweek use, the Icon Pass, and people from Denver do that more or less by definition.
1:18:07 No one, people in large part based on what Kent was saying, aren't going to fly in here on a Saturday from Denver and fly home on a Sunday. That's not going to happen. They're going to be here for some midweek days. That's where our future is. So I know that we had an experience with Denver which didn't work out in the past, but we need to look past that now with the Icon Pass and do everything we can to get...
1:18:34 to make our future based on the opportunity the Icon Pass is representing. It's a huge opportunity. And this is very different. This is seven days a week. That was one flight a week. We're trying to catch lightning in a bottle. It's like, does it work for you to fly in on a Saturday and then out again on a Saturday? Not necessarily. That wasn't going to work.
1:18:54 But the Icon Pass was a creation involving hundreds of millions of dollars and, you know, of assets coming together to be able to do that. It's all an opportunity for Mammoth. And I think that in terms of Mammoth having a future, it's the only...
1:19:11 real solid opportunity on the horizon right now. So getting set up to take advantage of it is extremely worthwhile and I think that we would be very remiss in our duties to this community not to give Denver another opportunity. That's apparently where those ICON pass holders are and we need to have them come here. Well, you're absolutely right, Paul, but the second part of that is also united.
1:19:36 Because Denver with Alaska is different than Denver with United based on the connectivity. And I appreciate your opening comments on connectivity because for me that's the foundation, one of the foundational pillars of this whole process. Having had a flight booked for me in a consulting thing just three weeks ago to Virginia, hands down the worst flight process I've ever been through. Alaska to Virginia involved co-chair through American, which is the, you know, not only the bus ride.
1:20:06 Right. Around LAX trying to get on that bus at Terminal 6, which is always full by the time it gets there, ended up the long walk back, 50% greater chance of losing your bag because it's going to transfer from one airline to another around the airport. The 10-hour layover, the pleasant experience of a double TSA process. You know, everything that goes with that, it just doesn't say,
1:20:36 I want to come from a long-haul destination and to Collins Point have a great chance of missing my ski experience, my ski trip experience. So the connectivity is huge. It cannot be understated, the multiple, almost every 90 minutes flights available to cities like Houston, Newark, which is New York, of course, Chicago, Denver. So to your point, I agree with you, but...
1:21:02 The United experience and the connectivity is a huge part of, I think, why Denver will work this time in addition to the bonus of the Icon Pass. Well, I really like what Colin had to say about it. It's easier for people to get to fly from Denver to Mammoth than it is for them to drive from Denver to Breckenridge. Right. It's horrendous. And with that in mind, we could put up a billboard on Highway 80 that says, if you were skiing at Mammoth, you'd be skiing now. So a quick question.
1:21:32 From being timely, we've got, for the last 45 minutes, we've had consistent support from everyone that's talked. I'm curious if there's any dissenting comments from the board at all or any dissenting comments that need to be considered from the public. I wanted to bring something up because you're right, this is turning into a love fest and I love it. If it's a love fest, we can vote, but if there's a dissenting comment, I want to bring it up. But I do have some other questions that are regarding air that I would like to ask and then, yeah, I'm going to back you up on let's bring this to a vote.
1:21:57 The questions I wanted to ask is, you know, how do we take advantage of this? How do we make sure that we don't lose United the way that we lost Alaska? And I think, you know, I'm even going to follow up a little bit further on that is, you know, I want to make sure that this is successful. I think this is great. I think we're all in agreement that United is, you know.
1:22:17 Better connectivity, all that kind of thing. But I'm going to ask just how do we make sure that we make the most out of this opportunity that has been given to us? And then I'm also going to ask a little bit about the marketing efforts that is different for summer versus winter. We know why people like to fly here for the winter. I would like to ask how we can increase our visitation via air for the summer. Okay, address that first question. I just think this from a board position, I think it's important vernacular, which is we did not lose Alaska.
1:22:46 Alaska abandoned the airport service that they had with their planes. So I think it's important that we understand that this community did not do something wrong by Alaska and lose service by not doing something. They made a decision based off of old aircraft to no longer service a number of small airports of which we were one. And I think I want to clarify that because I think there is this misunderstanding in the community that is lack of marketing or some other thing drove that decision. And it was a business decision based on planes, not something that was wrong with this community.
1:23:15 Is that clear? Yeah, that's very true. Is that fair? I want to make sure we don't get caught up in that, especially not coming from this part. How do we continue to work and secure a united in the future? We had a conversation, because I have some smaller airports that have two-year contracts that are year-round service. That's one, okay? We can make this flight sustainable from an economic standpoint. Sustainable where we don't have to pay any guarantees.
1:23:45 We need to raise the load factor and make this thing work. And all of a sudden they start flying in. I mean, that's where Vail, when we started Vail, when Bill and I were in Vail, I would never believe that American Airlines now flies Dallas on a year-round basis. And it doesn't cost the community a penny because there's no contract. So the challenge is really let's make this thing successful from an economic standpoint and they'll be here. With that in mind,
1:24:16 We need some other options. We need to have them have competition along with it. You know, there's some other hubs out there that we need to target and keep focused on. I think the point being made as it relates to the point-to-point service, very true. You're a very unusual market where you've got, what is it, 35 million people that are an hour and two hours away? That's kind of like in my back pocket, you know. That's pretty good. But can you grow the market?
1:24:47 Not as much as you can grow points east. Points east are huge. So I think it's a relationship with United Airlines. It's a much better, you know, much different situation. That culture has changed, as Bill alluded to earlier. A year ago, two years ago, rather, United was just okay as far as I was concerned on relationship changes. And each one of them changed. The airlines changed a little bit because of their culture.
1:25:17 I don't know if I answered your question, but... No, I'm sorry. I'm looking for... Well, it's greater relationships and more service with that airline. We would like to have twice a day service. I think the market could survive twice a day service out of LA or San Francisco this year in the winter. We don't have that option. We asked for it, but they just don't have the aircraft. I'm going to jump in and see if I can...
1:25:47 Go ahead. Answer part of Sean's question because as we've gone through this process, the LA flight 365 days a year, we almost lost that because we didn't make the decision appropriately in an expedient time. We got it.
1:26:08 But we need to look at that and see what the process is. Scott alluded to earlier, we've approved a budget of TBID subsidy, $2.3 million for the year. We should be able to move quicker on decisions like that to ensure that we're working with our partner with United. So I would say that's one thing that we need to look at our process because we want to be inclusive and transparent and everything.
1:26:36 Correct me if I'm wrong, Ken, if we didn't almost lose that. It's because of our being able to respond in a timely fashion. When you say we, are you referring to MMSA or specifically this board? Well, that's a unique point of that in the sense that ultimately we sign the contract because we take on the additional risk. So it is us signing the contract, but because the waterfall, the first subsidy,
1:27:03 goes through Mammoth Lake Tourism, the board needs to approve it as well. It's a process where this planning group should meet and understand what they want to try to do in March. In fact, in early March. Right now, if you want to go and book an airline ticket on United Airlines, you can book it 330 days in advance. That's as far out as they go. So they have to make all that happen and put it on at six months in advance.
1:27:33 You know, cruise bid 90 days in advance. That's the window that we had. And so, in February, we'll put together a plan. Say, okay, and we really won't know how we're doing other than in what happened in January. We can look forward, but financially, we really don't know. But we'll have a plan in February or March next year. Sean, I think this is from, oh.
1:28:02 What Kent said, I think I can boil down to three words in terms of airline success, and that's high load factor. I think the high load factor part is, I mean, Kent has done his job of saying you should be here and you should have this flight and so forth. That's the flight structure. But then I think it's MLT's role in conjunction with Mammoth Mountain and Mammoth Mountain's marketing.
1:28:25 To market that flight and to do, we have to do a bang up job of marketing in a market that we're not, you know, we don't presently operate in, but we've got to ramp up fast to hit that market and make this whole thing a success. I mean, if we have a plane that's empty, that doesn't do us any good. And the airline won't stick with us. But if that plane is full, the airline will.
1:28:50 And I think that's the direction I was going. I appreciate very much, you know, your comments just that we need to be moving more nimbly. You know, I know it's 11 o'clock and I do need to take off here shortly thereafter. So those were my questions. We have one from the... Eric? And just to clarify, Kirk, did you have a question earlier? Did you have a comment? No? Okay. Eric. Hi, good morning. I'm Eric Walserman, just representing myself as a businessman today. Number one, great job, guys.
1:29:21 A tough situation. We got new air service quickly. I appreciate that. I just want to talk about some of the things that Sean was alluding to. It's been a love fest. I travel a lot. If you guys were to look up my frequent flyer account, you'd like it. But so some of the weaknesses that I see or some of the things I'd like to see develop is we're focused on the guests and the tourists, and let's face it, all of our businesses depend on that, and that's great. But as a local businessman that has clients in over 30 states that travels to seminars, it does a lot.
1:29:51 Outside of winter, it's really difficult flying in and out of here. One flight a day out of L.A. doesn't cut it. It forces me to have an overnight layover at some part of my trip, no matter what. I'd love to see a morning and a night flight. You know, you're stuck in a red eye. If you take that flight now, you're stuck in a red eye going back east, and then you're a fraud for your meeting. So basically, there's an extra day. Getting out here, you know, you can get here at night. I'd like to see a morning and a night option.
1:30:18 I'd also like to see, I think we're dropping the ball on the tourists in the summertime, kind of what Sean was talking about. I just had some guests come out here from New York and they wanted to see Yosemite. So they flew to San Francisco and drove and then drive back with a family through Yosemite to get all the way back to New York. Kills them. I think having year-round service to San Francisco, personally, I'd like to see it. I do business in San Francisco. It's great to be in the air for 35 minutes and I could...
1:30:45 Leave here and have a dinner meeting, work a full day. So I think we should really look at that as an option going forward. I realize there's finite budgets and I get it. I've served on...
1:30:54 Many committees and boards around town, as a lot of you know. So that's my two cents on that, just more connectivity year-round in summer. I personally had to cancel two conferences. I have conferences a lot of times in the off-season, like October and May, where a conference in St. Louis will start on a Thursday. We don't have service to fly out of here on a Wednesday, so I have to decide if I want to take a week off work to go to a two-day meeting. The answer to that is no, 90% of the time. Also, with the...
1:31:22 You know, cancellations and things like that. It's difficult. I mean, I'll say this. If you look at all the airports around the country, who has weather like we have? I mean, come on. We get four feet of snow in a week. We don't bat an eye. That happens in Newark with six inches. They canceled a thousand flights. So the thing is, I think, and I don't know if this is an airline thing or a Mammoth Airport thing. I don't want to sound ignorant, but.
1:31:44 Whoever has to spend the money to get better equipment on the plane, I think we should look at that and see how it happens because it really makes or breaks a vacation when if you miss skier days because you're going someplace, it's just a sour, sour taste that you leave in somebody's mouth. So that's just my two cents. I'd like to see more year-round.
1:32:05 Flights, more than one a day. I'd like to open up San Francisco in the summer, and particularly Yosemite's our backyard. What do you think's a better experience for a guest? Flying to Fresno, 103 degrees in the heat, drive two hours to get to the park, or land at our airport, look at these beautiful mountains, and just maybe, just maybe, they'll spend a night or two here instead of Yosemite, or they'll come back to Mammoth and spend the dollars in our community. So just some thoughts for everybody. Thanks. You know, I'd like to...
1:32:35 Pardon me, I'd like to make a comment. And also follow up with a short question. You know, in the lodging industry, it's taken years and years to build up our international clientele. I think everybody in the room is probably pretty familiar with the summertime drill and hopefully very thankful for their visitation and the amount of business that it brings to this community.
1:33:04 You know, I grew up in that and 40 years later, it's going pretty good. You know, today we're talking about a new program here, which I'm in favor of and I totally support the direction. I've heard a lot of opinions and I empathize with a lot of the comments that are made because it is about guest service. But I would urge everybody to approach this with
1:33:34 A little bit of patience because it does take a while. The old analogy, you can't catch a fish if you don't cast a line, well, that holds true right here. It's an expensive proposition. It's a difficult one to undertake. It's something that I don't think there's a silver bullet to this equation. There's so many moving parts. It's really difficult to quantify and to that end.
1:34:01 I applaud the direction that we're going and support and applaud the efforts of all the people that have brought it to this point. So now following with a little question for you, how long do you see this kind of taking or what have you, in your experience, have you, let me phrase this better, I think you know where I'm going.
1:34:28 How long does it take to really get to a solvent point where all of a sudden you don't have to subsidize a flight from Dallas to Vail? And, you know, to reach that critical mass, is there a percentage where that kind of turns around? You know, again, I don't think that's going to happen tomorrow, but I do believe that if we start and undertake this process, we will attain that goal eventually.
1:34:55 The general target is 75% load factor. Okay? But you can fly a lot of people at a 75% load factor at cheap fares. So it's a balance there. But that's a general rule. The time, the length of time to get there, I've seen, you know, this program in 2009, we made money all winter, for the winter in LA.
1:35:25 and help pay for the San Jose flight. And I'm going, okay, this is golden. We can make money here because it was one contract. And then all of a sudden, the weather changes. You know, you don't have enough snow or you have four feet of snow, you know, time and time. And that's, I would never thought we would be here at this point in time. But there's no timeline.
1:35:55 But if we can fill flights at 75% load factor, we have a very good chance to get off the juice, so to speak. Well, and I think it does fluctuate with the weather. So two years ago, big snow year, we actually, we didn't pay anything in Los Angeles. We paid very little in San Diego. So Alaska, the bill for Alaska was $200,000, and the bill for San Francisco was slightly higher. But, you know, so we fluctuate where we go from it being...
1:36:24 $1.8 million to $600,000. So really a lot of it does depend on that. But the year that we were, we didn't owe a dime in Los Angeles, we were 78% load factor and we were 74% in San Diego. So, but again, it goes back to the costs, the costs of the fuel and the planes and all the other pieces plus all the revenue on the plane. So if we give away tickets of $29, we're not going to, we're going to owe a subsidy because we're not covering those costs. But I think this board needs to be,
1:36:53 Prepared to commit to these type of ideas for a longer time frame. I mean, something like Denver, if the foundational structure for us going into that market makes sense, it makes sense a year from now and two years from now and five years from now. So, you know, I don't think that we should have an expectation that a Denver flight will be 75% in year one, but I'm totally comfortable with saying five years from now, the foundational structure of why we're exploring that market is not going to change.
1:37:20 And so therefore, you know, I think we need to be prepared to look at the long haul. I think that speaks to our long-term three to five-year strategy about being able to go through and say, you know, moving forward, it's like, you know, if our first priority is to get LAX to a load factor where there's no more subsidy whatsoever, and we're like, okay, when that triggers, now we'll look at Dallas. And when Denver gets to the point where it has no more subsidy because it's gotten to a certain load factor, then we can think about Chicago. I'm just putting those out there. But I think that if, as we talk about this five-year strategic plan, this is an immediate need now.
1:37:48 and have those triggers. It's like, okay, we're going to continue to spend that subsidy, but we're going to wait until that one stabilizes and then move to the next one and continue to invest in that new market, knowing that that could be two, three, five years out. But there's a judicious process by how we go about that. I think that's how we expand our service continually is to stabilize one, move to the next one, stabilize one, move to the next one, know what those priorities are.
1:38:13 The Icon Pass is an exceptional way for us to be able to figure out where that is because we know where that market is. We know where that person's interested in this community. Let me go back to his question really quick for both of you guys. We look at this in terms of almost a vacuum based on the ski industry and the visitation with building air service here. How much of our opportunity to build air service is also...
1:38:38 interdependent on infrastructure within the communities such as convention space or force four and five star properties with day spas and the likes of that which Vail and Aspen both have a ton of and we don't. Actually I'll comment to that because at Aspen that's one of our limiting factors right now is our actual shrinking bed base and one of the reasons we haven't been as aggressive as other communities in actually trying to grow air service. JetSuiteX approached.
1:39:06 Me, you know, about possibly flying into Aspen. And at this point in time, we've got hotel occupancies that are over 90%, you know, pretty much every weekend from...
1:39:15 Mid-December through the end of March. So there's not a whole lot of opportunity for us to grow beyond that until we start getting more infrastructure and we have a couple of new hotels opening both in Snowmass and Aspen the next year, which will actually help us grow our commercial air service. But it is very important. You've got to have the capacity, enough places for the lift tickets to sleep in order for them to fly in on the flights. The other comment I was going to make relevant to your question in terms of how long it takes to rebuild.
1:39:44 Another great analogy of an experience we had in Aspen was when Frontier pulled out in 2012. A lot of locals who loved and adored Frontier Airlines, they had those cute talking animal ads on television. They were just devastated that they were losing their beloved Frontier Airlines. It took us three years before we fully recovered from replacing that loss.
1:40:06 Looks like you've almost recovered fully in less than one year. I'm sure it's going to be fully recovered in under two. The other point I wanted to make relative to an earlier public question here about San Francisco year-round, and to your point, Scott, you've got to fortify your existing service before you start growing it, but I really believe by adding LA with United, that's actually going to help the San Francisco service as well, because you'll have...
1:40:29 More connections flowing over both hubs. And the stronger you make San Francisco, the more likely it'll be positioned for expanded service. Excellent. Given our timing, if there's no more public comment or any questions from the board, I'd like to, while we still have everyone here, before we lose Mr. Turner, to bring this up for a vote. I don't know that we need to have a motion on this, but this is the...
1:40:57 I don't know if we actually need a motion because we were specifically called here for an advisor. How about I try this one? I was thinking about that. I will make a motion that we, MLT, support the recommended 2018-19 air services presented. So we're doing as recommended. Just to be clear, that's the right-hand side. Correct. With inference that.
1:41:18 I think there's conversation that's been here about more connectivity to San Diego or Southern California. If those things become relevant or still come back up, but today is about the air service that's being presented to us and that we support the recommendation. We're not approving it, but we're supporting that recommendation. So I'll make that as a motion. I'll second that. Ready to vote? Yeah. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Any nays? Any dissenters? Anyone abstaining?
1:41:50 Unanimous. Thank you. The next board meeting will be August 1st here in Sweet Z.