Town Council
· recording 4 hr 25 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
598 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:54 No, they gotta go. Meeting, Town Council meeting for August 1st. Here we go, folks. I'm quick on the gavel, so, okay, roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Yes. Yes. And I would like Amy Creston, Executive Director of Eastern Sierra Symphony, to please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance.
2:31 So we are now to public comments. Anyone? Oh, I already got a hand up. Madam Mayor, thank you. John Eastman, member of the community of Mammoth Lakes. I wanted to thank the, there were three members of the Town Council who attended last night's Forest Service update on the Lions Fire, as well as the Town Manager. So good stuff for people being involved. Were you there, John? There was four of you. Cognito?
3:01 I was in the back standing up. Excuse me. Good meeting. We learned a couple things. That was the second meeting that the Forest Service has held on the update. We've learned a couple things. A couple things that we learned to start out with is that the Forest Service admitted that they screwed up a couple times. Initially on the first fire, they goofed up because they got there a day late.
3:28 10-acre fire turned into 4,000-acre fire just because it was a day late in response. The second fire that ignited has burned 1,500 acres and the goof up on that was igniting, purposely igniting additional vegetation and trees on fire that caused a health index.
3:54 Registering at 7.05, 705, 300 is extreme health with damaging to adults and children. So it was over twice that helped the index. Make no mistake, the Lions Fire is and was a let burn fire. They've changed the name, but it's basically a let burn fire. That fire's burned for two months already.
4:27 And last night we heard that now they're going to go to full suppression on that fire and that it will be an additional four to five weeks that we'll have on and off smoke in the community. In my mind, that's unacceptable. I'm here this evening to ask the town council to direct staff to organize a meeting, a public meeting with local forest service, possibly the board of supervisors, and have a discussion on the continuing allowance.
4:56 Of the Forest Service having to let burn fire. If it's four or five more weeks of smoke, that means that we will have had a full three months of our summer in Mammoth Lakes wasted. Not only are there health consequences, severe health consequences, as we noticed two mornings ago, there's also economic consequences. And as best I can tell, the Forest Service locally and nationally could care less about those consequences to our community.
5:27 I think it's time that we stood up and did what we possibly could. If you want to argue a let burn fire, that's fine. But you saw the response to the fires that we had yesterday. And within a period of one day, both those fires are 80% or more contained in a day. When we want to put a fire out, we can put them out. And those fires were 200, 300, 500 acres.
5:59 This fire back here was a 10-acre fire started by a lightning strike. So anyway, I've said enough. I think it's really, really important for the Council to start a process where we can have communication with local elected officials, local Forest Service, and hopefully our local congressional representatives for Mammoth Lakes. Thank you. Thank you for your comments.
6:26 And public comment? Yes, please. You get five minutes to talk about whatever you would like to. Got it. I'm Amy Creston. I'm Executive Director of the Eastern Sierra Symphony. My husband and son and I are second homeowners up here in Mammoth. We live in Pasadena. We have a condo at Bigwood. We don't go to it anymore because we got a postcard from the town a few years ago.
6:51 Talking about how difficult housing is here, so we decided to put it up for a 12-month lease, which we just renewed for the third year, but we stay here and there when we come up, and we still feel like we're part of the community. I'd just like to invite everybody to our two free symphony concerts. They are this coming Friday and Saturday, August 10th and 11th at St. Joe's. We decided this year for the first year to make both of them free to the community.
7:17 We really feel that there are just generous, wonderful people up here from the individuals that adopt a musician for a week to people that give us their whole condo, restaurants that feed us, hotels that give us great rates, and not to mention, of course, Measure U and the town. So this is really a thank you back to all of you guys.
7:42 And we would love for each one of you to come with 20 of your closest friends to our concerts. Somebody told me recently, if you want to know the values of an organization, you look at their budget. We have an entirely volunteer staff. Well, it's not entirely true. My salary is $83 a month.
8:07 And my general manager, her salary is $50 a month. But other than that, everybody else is volunteers, many of you up here in Mammoth. Our budget goes to the highest quality musicians that we can bring to Mammoth Lakes. We have people from the Los Angeles Philharmonic, the San Francisco Symphony, the Minnesota Orchestra, the Chicago Symphony. We have, I shouldn't tell you this, but somebody flying in with his Stradivarius to play. So we're really pouring everything into...
8:35 Giving you guys the best we can. And so I wanted you to know that. In addition, we're very, very committed to education. We started a pilot program last year with Mike Hammers at the high school to send up wind teachers, oboe and bassoon clarinet, those instruments, because we identified with him that that's where he could use a little bit of help. And that was very, very successful. So we're expanding that.
9:04 To once a month we'll be sending up teachers that will assist Mike and give free really high quality lessons to the kids at the schools. We also keep our eyes open and scrounge around for any instruments that we're not using anymore, you know, our old student instruments that are sitting under the piano to give to the school district. I personally believe that music education is so important to children's development.
9:33 And I'd just like to tell you guys that there are literally millions of people living in Los Angeles that would give their eye teeth to send their kids to a school like you guys have here in Mammoth Lakes or this kind of music department. It's very rare to have public school with music anymore at all. So what with the Felicis and Mike, and we're trying to do our part, all you guys who have kids in the schools, you might be luckier than you know.
9:59 So again, our concerts are the 10th and the 11th. I spent the afternoon trying to figure out how to do a live Facebook feed. I think somebody here knows how to do that. I talked to three or four people, but I'm hoping to be able to put at least the concerto of our 17-year-old soloist on a live Facebook feed. And I've already spoken to the Colburn School in Los Angeles, which is the preeminent.
10:24 Music Conservatory on the West Coast, and they would also put it on their feed, so it would have quite a wide visibility for everyone. This young man is a clarinet player. He was picked as one of four clarinet players in the United States to be in the National Youth Orchestra and to tour the world as emissaries of the United States, and he's presently in Seoul, Korea. We're picking him up at LAX on Monday at 11 and driving him straight up here to play for you folks.
10:53 So, and he's a great example. He's, you know, a young kid and he's just, just phenomenal. So he's playing on Friday night. So that's about all I have to say. Please come to our concerts. Friday, Saturday, St. Joe's. We have a little fundraiser on Thursday that's the foundation. That's $50 and there's...
11:11 Appetizers and things like that. And that's featuring a few more of our younger players that don't get to stand front and center with the orchestra like our main soloist does. We're going to play summer and winter from the four seasons. And then we're going to have a cello ensemble, which is just, if you can imagine, six or seven cello players with that deep, beautiful, warm sound of cello without any violin players like me messing it up with a high screechy sound.
11:41 Thanks. That was a good time. Thank you. Okay. Anybody else for a public comment? Hi there. Pam Bold from the High Sierra Energy Foundation. And the last time I saw many of you, not all of you, since you have some new ones, we were with the sixth graders doing our outreach on public, or on...
12:06 Single-serve bottled water, and I have to call a few of you out here, I don't know, but I did just want to tell you that they won second prize and that the Shane McConkie Foundation Eco Challenge and $4,000 of which the school district is going to be putting in water filling stations this summer with that money, so we were proud of the work that the kids did on that.
12:30 Just a brief update from the High Sierra Energy Foundation. We're working with the town of Mammoth Lakes currently through Southern California Edison's Eastern Sierra Energy Initiative on our energy benchmarking program in which we will be taking data and putting it into the Energy Star Portfolio Manager.
12:52 There's, you know, the saying, you can't measure what you don't know. And so this will compare our buildings to like buildings as well as, you know, hopefully identify some energy efficiency projects that we may be able to do in municipal facilities. And so that's underway. And thank you for the support from different town personnel for that. And then I wanted to introduce Leah Webb. We were proud to receive a
13:21 Grant from the Cal EPA through the California Green Business Network, and we will be, we are starting and we're ready to get rolling on a green business program, Eastern Sierra, and this is where we will go in and help identify energy, water, toxics, pollutions, different measures, I'm sorry.
13:45 That a business has. And we'll recognize those business owners who are making a commitment to environmentally friendly practices. And we'll be working with the town of Mammoth Lakes, the community water district, Southern California Edison, Sierra Conservation Project, and the Mammoth Lakes Chamber.
14:03 On that program. And we're excited to get it kicked off. And we finally feel with Leah's help that we're ready to get started. So if you know of a business, they can go to greenbusinessca.org and start the process. We will also be presenting at the Mammoth Lakes Chamber on August 21st. So if anyone would like to know more information about the program, we'll be presenting more there. So if you have any questions, if not, thank you. Thank you.
14:39 Good evening, Mayor Hoff, Councilmembers, Stacey Corliss, Mono County Board of Supervisors. I want to make Council and the public aware of a very important item we have coming before us on the Board of Supervisors meeting on August 7th. As you may be aware, the City of Los Angeles Department of Water and Power is moving forward with a plan to dry up over 6,000 acres of irrigated lands it owns around Crowley Lake.
15:08 Currently these lands are leased by local ranchers and the DWP's plan will be devastating to our local environment and economy. So the Board of Supervisors will be considering actions to take to stop this destruction. This agenda item will be heard at 10 a.m. at our regular meeting Tuesday, August 7th up in Bridgeport.
15:33 And also via teleconference, we're changing the teleconference location here in Mammoth to the Town County Conference Room, which is just down the hall here above Giovanni's. There's lots of information on this issue at mono.ca.gov, but I would invite and encourage council, town staff, and the public to attend this meeting and speak up. Thank you. Thank you.
16:01 Good evening, Councilmembers. My name is Jason Kander. I'm just following up on Supervisor Corliss's introduction of that particular item regarding the county's concern with LADWP's proposal to dewater a significant portion of Southern Mono County. I just wanted to provide a couple facts and some background on the proposal by DWP as well as some of the county's actions to date, and I'll try and keep them short so it'll allow you to ask some questions at the end.
16:30 These particular lands amount to about 64,000 acres in and around Crowley Lake, particularly on the drainage of the Upper Owens, Hot Creek, Convict, McGee Creek, as well as Hilton Creek. And DWP is proposing to essentially eliminate irrigation and water to these lands.
16:50 Back in April of this year, LEDWP approached the ranchers with new leases that provided no irrigation water. Historically, for the past 70 to 80 years, these lands have received somewhere between or up to about 5 acre feet per acre. That amounts to about 32,000 acre feet on all these particular pieces of property. According to DWP, approximately, on average, over the last 25 years, we're looking at a total of about 25,000 acre feet.
17:20 The complete elimination of these waters or of water to these lands will result in devastating impacts not only to the ranching and agricultural economy of southern Mono County, but have disastrous impacts on the environment, both in terms of aesthetics as well as environmental and habitat resources, specifically wetland and wet meadow habitats that support sage grouse and provide fire buffers for the communities in and around Crowley Lake.
17:48 The county's efforts to date have been to engage DWP on this particular issue. At this particular time, after speaking with the mayor, DWP has committed to providing only 0.71 acre feet per acre, where, as I explained earlier, they were up to about 5 acre feet under their current leases.
18:09 That amounts to more than an 80% reduction based on historical or at least average water use for these lands. And so again, we're looking at the loss of a significant amount of habitat, a change, a total change in what the aesthetics of this landscape will look like, as well as impacts to sensitive species such as the sage grouse, which may or may not be listed under the Dayner Species Act in the near future and cause
18:35 Additional restrictions on the economic use as well as the water use on these particular properties by DWP. Unfortunately, the county's engagement with DWP has been to no avail. They have dug their heels in and refused to budge, so we're looking at this year no more than 25% of average and a very nominal amount of water provided for the sage-grouse just to more or less
19:05 More or less substantiate DWP's claim that they will do anything for the environment. So at this particular point, the county is pursuing a number of different options, or is considering a number of different options that include both education and awareness of both elected officials as well as residents in Southern California, the preparation of a water management plan, engagement with federal and state wildlife agencies, as well as considering the
19:32 The drafting of new legislation to protect these lands and the possibility of initiating litigation. More importantly, the county has been the spearhead at least to date on an advocacy and education plan or education and awareness to get out interested stakeholders and
19:51 Interested and concerned public to voice their concern, and as Stacey Corliss just mentioned, the Board of Supervisors is holding a meeting at its, has an agenda at its regularly scheduled meeting on August 7th to receive public comment and hear the public's concern and interest on this particular topic. So I'm going to turn it over to Matt McLean real quick to further explain some of the efforts that we've taken to date.
20:21 Thank you, Jason. Matt McLean, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Good evening, Mayor and Councilmembers. In addition to the cultural impacts, the environmental impacts, the economic impacts, one of the things that wasn't entered into the conversation early on were the recreational impacts. Long Valley hosts a thriving fishery.
20:48 This fishing area has several major fisheries on it, certainly Hot Creek and Upper Owens are world-renowned fisheries. Crowley Lake, obviously very popular. These are going to be impacted by this action. To what extent, we do not know, and so we need some time to study that. We have written off a letter to both Mayor Garcetti.
21:11 And Department of Fish and Wildlife, or not Department of Fish and Wildlife, but Department of Water and Power, asking them to reinstate the water enlockments until we can conduct full environmental studies to discern that impact. In the meantime, we are conducting outreach to the community. Again, this action is going to have impacts, not just on the fishing community, but it's going to impact.
21:31 The hunting community, there's some waterfowl hunting that takes place down there. Certainly a lot of camping, some hiking, people go down and enjoy the tubs, all kinds of activities. So this is an area that is an incredible resource, not just for the folks in the Mammoth Lakes, but to visitors who are coming up through the eastern Sierra. We are conducting quite a bit of outreach. I'm sure everybody's seen a lot of these posters already popping up.
21:52 Thank you.
22:21 impacts, recreational impacts from this action. There's a host of indirect recreational impacts. Wetland habitats are probably one of the most efficient habitats for conducting CO2 exchange. So if you take that out, the ability to fight climate change is increased. And so obviously climate change impacts probably everybody in this community, whether it's the likelihood of, you know, bark beetles propagating fires like we're seeing to, you know,
22:50 Variabilities in snow and rainfall, all those things, you know, are things that impact our community and everybody here directly down the road in some capacity. So if that's something that you're concerned with, you should definitely be following this situation. We want you to turn down and voice your concerns and opinions. Thank you. Thank you. If I could ask a question of the last two gentlemen that were speaking for my own edification.
23:18 The way the watering of those lands has gone since the 20s is flood irrigation. A good deal of that five acre feet, it seems to me, from sitting on my tail end of my boat in the lake and watching it happen, is that a good deal of that ends up back in the lake. Has a study been done on how much of the water that is used for irrigation actually ends up back in the lakes with the actual usages?
23:46 A hard figure on the usage? Yeah, there's been different studies conducted. If you talk to DWP, their conservative estimates are anywhere between 40, perhaps up to 50 percent. If you talk to some of the ranch operators, it's been as high as 80, 85 percent. So even if you take kind of the mean of that between 50 or 60 percent, that's quite a bit of water that's going back into the system. That's not even being factored in into the DWP's assessment of this.
24:14 Right. It makes no sense to me, but it's important for people to understand. Most of that water we're talking about, because five acre feet sounds like a lot, but three acre feet of that ends up right back in the lake in terms of water runoff. It's not really lost. It's recaptured. And another interesting point that DWV fails to mention is that they're required through their obligations for maintenance for the bi-state sage grass.
24:41 To maintain a certain amount of water back into that landscape. That's being done right now by the ranchers. If these leases get taken away, DWP is going to have to do that on its own. They're going to have to bring people up there and take care. That's an additional cost. That's not getting talked about. That's not getting factored in. There's all kinds of levels of this and falsehoods that are being spread about by DWP. So if you want to go by the county, they have a lot of information on the website. I'm sure Jason might want to add to that.
25:11 Thank you.
25:14 Just to Matt's point, I would just like to point out that right on the county's homepage there is a link for recent news and this is kind of situated and kept at the top of it. So if anyone of you or anyone in the audience would like more information about this particular subject, the county does have an item dedicated to it that includes its fact sheet as well as the number of different letters and correspondence that the county has had with the mayor's office as well as with DWP as well as with state and federal elected officials that represent this particular region.
25:44 Okay. Thank you very much, gentlemen. Questions? Well, I think that's good for now, and hopefully we'll see you on the 7th. Thank you very much. Thank you. Good evening, Mayor, Council Jennifer Halfordy, Mammoth Lakes Housing. So, tonight is my last night at a Town Council meeting as the Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing.
26:10 So I just wanted to give a little recap and say farewell. So I've not always agreed with Town Council on the allocation of funding for workforce housing, the need for workforce housing, though I do believe that now there is a consensus that there's a need and that it is critically low, the supply of housing for our locals, and that it's impacting our workforce and the local economy's ability to see its full potential.
26:40 So I also think that we agree that the community housing action plan needs to be put into play and not put on the shelf. To that point, I look forward to the town council working through updating the town's housing mitigation ordinance and adopting a fee increase schedule to allow the mitigation fees.
27:00 To address 100% of the gap created by new development as prescribed in the plan's near-term strategies. Similarly, in my new capacity with the county as a supervisor, Mono County is reviewing their housing mitigation ordinance and their fees. And while we don't need identical policies, I think we can also all agree that it's good to have some consistency in the region on...
27:27 All hands on deck on how we're addressing our lack of local housing. So I want to reflect back. So I took over as the Executive Director in 2013, April 2013. And since then, I've overseen the closing of 27 homebuyer loans. That's $2,244,420 in loans to our local workforce.
27:56 Four deed restriction ownership transfers, and that's included recording new deed restrictions, which dedicate with stewardship, secure those homes for 60 years for locals so that they'll be affordable to them and available to them. I've worked with Mono County to create and establish the preservation and stewardship of those homes through a revolving loan fund of $300,000.
28:21 And oversaw $4.9 million in federal and state grant funding throughout the eastern Sierra. So going forward, I know Mammoth Lakes Housing is in exceptional hands of Patricia Robertson. She will be taking over on Monday as the acting executive director. She has the capacity to serve the community and a great depth of knowledge and professionalism. And we also have a very diverse and committed board of directors. So with that, thank you.
28:51 Thank you. Hello, Council. First of all, I just want to say thank you guys for allowing me the opportunity to come up and introduce myself. My name is Tanner Beard. Okay. This is my partner, Tomek. Hello. Mansuri. We're actually with a 501c3 organization called the Mammoth Media Institute, and we put on our first inaugural Mammoth Film Festival this year in February. And again, we just...
29:24 Kind of wanted to come up here and say hello to you guys, take this time and opportunity to, you know, be a little bit more part of the community, hopefully be able to introduce ourselves and we can chat a little bit more when it's not a town council meeting. But we like to think, you know, the community as well, everybody in town was just unbelievably receptive. The businesses, the restaurants, the people, the organizations, we had over a thousand attendees in our first year, which is kind of unheard of.
29:52 But with that, we're looking to gear up for year two and Mammoth being so incredible in what they do for the arts and the community and that kind of welcome and kind of what they're kind of getting known for is their, I guess, commitment to the arts and community. That's something that we wanted to kind of make sure that we kind of, you know, we're not, even though we don't live here, not here day to day, we just wanted to be here more often. Tom and myself have been coming up here just about.
30:21 Every month to, you know, showcase our dedication of what we're trying to do here in town. And moving forward with that, we just wanted to kind of connect with you guys and also everybody else in town, letting them know that we're so reachable and so ecstatic about making year two even bigger. We had a tremendous amount of press, international press. I don't know if we shot ourselves in the foot or not, but they called us the biggest first year festival ever designed.
30:49 I never organized, excuse me. So with that, it's good and bad because now we have to live up to that every single year. But with that, that's exactly what we set out to do. And we were very happy that we not only accomplished that, but with the community and everybody else, we could accomplish so much more as we already have. So we just, again, wanted to come up and introduce ourselves, say, you know, extend our gratitude for the way that we were received in town and hopefully.
31:14 We'll continue to grow with the community and get, you know, even more events, excuse me, more events and everything else that's involved with putting on a festival of that size and that nature and stuff in town. So that's really, ours is really simple. It's more or less just wanted to come and...
31:31 You know, introduce ourselves and we appreciate the time that you guys have allowed us to do that. So do you have anything? Yeah, I think you covered it all. Like you said, we may not be residents here, but we're going to be here for a long time and we look forward to building a relationship with each and every one of you and kind of building an arts and entertainment culture here with you guys. You know, anything we can do for you, please reach out and we'll do the same. Thank you. Sure. Thanks, guys. Thank you. Anybody else want their five minutes? Maybe two. Maybe two. Okay.
32:01 E.L. Smugin, long time, fairly long time Mammoth resident. I'd like to commend the town on the job we've done with our paved trails from Shady Rest to Horseshoe Lake. You can ride, cycle, walk almost without interference with automobiles. I ride quite a bit with, cycle quite a bit with people with spinal cord injuries. And there are gaps in our path system.
32:31 It caused people with no feeling to go, ouch. And there's been numerous attempts to just patch the cracks, which turns a lump into a bump, lump, bump, and they don't last the season. So I'd like to encourage the town to put the time and effort and money into repairing rather than patching the past system. That's it. Thank you, folks. Okay. Thank you, EO.
33:02 Well, and you should know that that, of course, is item two on the agenda tonight. It is, man. Public comments? Oh, boy. Okay. No takers, so I'll go ahead and see if, Dan, do we have any additions to the agenda? Yeah, it's not an addition, but we've had a request if we could have item 10. It's a policy item.
33:34 Heard prior to the staff presentation items. There's a number of people here to speak on that item, some of them with younger children for the, just the timing of the evening. So that request was made and it's up to you, council, if you wish to change that order to hear that item prior to the staff presentation items. But right now we're keeping it at 10? It's item number 10, but if you wanted to hear it before item number 2 would be the request. Oh, okay. Do I move it up on the agenda to accommodate some schedules? Okay.
34:05 Thank you. Madam Mayor, I would have no problem moving it up and hearing it first. I would want us to do the introduction number one first and then go to the other. Yeah, we're going to do the introduction. Yeah. Okay. Then I don't need to do anything on that. I can just say okay to you on that one. Does anybody from, I'm sorry, what? You may want to ask the rest of council how they feel.
34:36 No, first it would be fine. I figured they would jump in if they had a problem with it. John, are you cool with it too? Sure. Okay, very good. Then we're going to go with that. Okay, so reports from commissions and or departments as needed. Good evening, Councilmembers, Ms. Mayor. My name is Joel Rathje, the Mammoth Lakes Trails Coordinator. Just wanted to extend an invitation.
35:15 To anyone who's interested to join us on August 11th at Convict Lake, we have our third in a series of four trail day events for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, our 10th anniversary season. We begin at 8.30 in the morning and we'll work until about 1 or 1.30. I want to extend our gratitude to Volunteer Eastern Sierra for providing us with lunch from Blue Handcrafted Foods.
35:42 And also New York Deli and Bakery for providing a bagel breakfast. And Convict Lake Resort and Friends of Yenio are our sponsors for this event. So we're grateful for them as well. If you have any questions about the event, I'd be happy to answer them. I'm sorry, you said that started at what time? 8.30 a.m. Okay, 8.30. And is there any particular place you want people to meet up in Convict? Is it at the little fishing shack or is it?
36:10 Around the lake. So we're going to ask folks to park in the actual official trailhead parking instead of at the boat ramp and maintain those parking spots for people that are launching boats and things like that. Okay. And then we'll begin not too far in from that parking. It'll be a short walk to join us. And we'll have signs directing people to where our tents are set up.
36:31 Okay. And I should add this point. It's actually in the context of an agreement that just has taken shape between Mono County, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Humboldt-Toyabe National Forest, and Inyo National Forest for us to be able to work outside the municipal boundary. We're taking this opportunity to really manifest this partnership on that day. Okay. Thank you very much, Joel. Thank you.
37:02 Good evening, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers, Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission Chair. Thank you for reappointing me to the Commission. We're very excited to welcome our new Commissioner at our meeting on August 7th. I just wanted to take a moment to really commend the Parks and Recreation staff for an amazing...
37:20 Park and Recreation Month in July, hashtag Discover July. They did everything from softball tournaments to the second annual beach volleyball tournament to free swim day in addition to their regular parks maintenance program and camp program which has been a little bit interesting obviously with the weather and they've just done a fantastic job so hats off to them. At our commission meeting,
37:42 We will have a presentation on walk, bike, ride. We will also do some housekeeping things like appointing our chair and vice chair, looking over our calendar for the upcoming year and our work plan, as well as having an update on the playground and a discussion of the multi-use facilities based on council direction this evening. So thanks very much. Thank you.
38:09 Grady Dutton, Public Works Director. I have a quick comment on item number eight on the engine. There's no reason to pull it from your consent agenda. It is to award to the lowest responsibility of the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure Project. I just want to let you know that when you take that action, you'll be awarding a contract in the amount of $377,777 to speech construction. It came in about 15% below our estimate, so that was great news from a budget standpoint.
38:37 We'll also be taking action to request that some of those ATP grant funds be moved from construction back to right-of-way. Those of you on the council for the last few months, we went through quite a struggle, if you will, to get the right-of-way with that, finally got all the support from the community and made that happen. So it was great news to get that bid. We'll be moving forward with that project later in the summer. Just want to let you know. Thank you. Okay. Great. What is the timeline on this again?
39:07 Beginning? On the project itself, about three weeks from now, Hayes? Okay. We want to start it by the end of August. Okay, so quick, great. And it'll be done this summer, definitely. Thanks. All right, Grady, real quick, the Edison trenching on Lake Murray Road and the Lakes Basin, last time I think you said they would be up here in July to fix that. Do you have any update on when they're going to be here to fix that? They have delayed it a couple of times, and we have the contractor working directly with the Forest Service on the final details of that.
39:34 But it still looks like they're working on it. They're done by now? There we go. They weren't done yesterday. They were? They're up there today. We'll take a look. That's pretty fresh. We'll take a look. Thank you very much. One real quick thing on the Mammoth Creek gap closure as well, speaking of the Forest Service, I actually got an email this afternoon from Janelle Walker with some information and a final sign-off on that. So we were able to work with them to resolve the minor issues we had on the east end of that path successfully. Good. Thank you.
40:03 Thank you very much. Okay. There are no more reports. We are going to go ahead and move to agenda item number one, introducing Grady. I think this is you, but I'll let you. Where's Stuart making? Where's Hayes going to? Don't mind me. Don't mind you? Okay. Lawn, if you would go ahead and come on forward with Rigo. Thank you. Yes. Thank you. Thanks. I was going to pass it to Grady to pass it to Lawn.
40:37 I'm just going to introduce again Lon Adams, our fleet manager, and to introduce the new employee. Thank you. Okay, thank you. I'd like to take this time to introduce our new fleet mechanic, Regal Lemus. He's no stranger to our area. He's been here 15 years, so he knows snow, and we're going to teach him how to move it and how to fix our big equipment. So he'll give me a great asset to our team, and I'd like to welcome aboard.
41:06 Okay. And I would love for him to say his full name because I was too scared to try that one. Okay. First, I just want to thank you. Thank you for letting me this opportunity to work for, you know, for the town of Mammoth. And my complete name is Rigoberto Lemus-Priviesca. You say that much better than I do. So thank you. I don't even try anymore. Well, welcome very much. We look forward to seeing you around. Thank you.
41:38 Welcome. Very good. Welcome, Rego. Thank you. Welcome. There you go. Rego works. Sue, are you just, you're getting ready for this one? Oh, okay. So now we will go ahead and go to item number 10, which is policy matter, community multi-use facility project update and recommendation for project.
42:15 Sequencing. Thank you, Mayor, Councilmembers. Thank you for taking this item out of order. We've got, I think, one or two people in the audience that are interested in this item. So this evening, we're going to go over the Council direction for the last few meetings. We're going to talk about project alternatives. We're going to discuss the Recreation Commission input, talk a bit about budget, schedule, and we'll end with the staff recommendation.
42:47 We were at Council on May 6th. Direction from Council at the time was just a commitment from our design team to deliver a project that meets expectation and is also financially viable with the goal to maintain all the features of the project that support programming and to maintain all the design aesthetics and also to share with our partners. On June 6th, we received a specific direction.
43:13 To come back with options for a project totaling no more than $13 million incorporating comments given by council and staff that evening. At that time there was consensus to move forward with the RFQ for CM services, construction manager services, directions to move forward with a specific alternative and to return to council with a schedule, input from rec commission, a funding strategy, and a public process for a selected alternative.
43:43 So looking at alternatives, where we landed when we went through the process to look at all the alternatives of reducing the cost of the project, working backwards from our low bid, adjustments for reduction in webbing and steel, reductions in electrical interior components and so forth, we were only able to get the project as designed and proposed down to $17,700,000.
44:10 And we were assuming some CM work would be neutral and we wouldn't really, it would pretty much balance out. So we looked at some other alternatives and this site map, just to kind of preface the two alternatives, working with HMC, we really distilled it down to two viable options. Every other alternative was really a derivative of these two options.
44:35 Both of the options provide no additional parking, so as it shows on the site plan, the existing parking lot, and it more or less lands in the footprint of the existing building. Existing infrastructure on site, the playground, the bathrooms all retain, and there will be minimal improvements to the site. So alternative one, which we're just calling the rink and the roof, because that's historically what we've called it,
45:02 Which is kind of a misnomer because it does provide a significant amount of summer programming and opportunity. Again, there is no community center or additional parking with this option. We would replace what was the viewing platform on the north with a solid wall. There is no change to the floor plan internally. Locker rooms, showers, storage are all retained. We would modify some of the storage rooms on a temporary basis for rental space and concessions.
45:30 There would be minor changes to the aesthetics, obviously, because we're not including the community center component, so there would be a temporary impact to the aesthetics. And we would also winterize the existing park restrooms to provide additional bathroom facilities because the lobby space would be compromised. What that looks like, the blue area at the top is eliminated. That's the community center and lobby spaces. Entrance to the facility would move to the east.
46:00 Kind of where the playground is, we would utilize the existing multi-use path and just add on to that. You can see a lot of the spaces, the floor plan looks exactly the same, same size Olympic rink. And then the two orange areas on the far right-hand corner would be concession space and rental. And then on the other side of what's being called the open public space would be
46:23 What does that mean for programming?
46:53 In the winter, all the programming is more or less retained. All the sports that were originally included in the playbooks are retained, hockey, skating, most importantly, curling. In the summertime, we retain, you know, all the summer sports that were envisioned for the area with the sport court, soccer, volleyball, basketball, providing space for our camps and so forth.
47:18 We would be losing the programming for the community center, all that space that was going to be for, you know, what was programmed originally in the playbooks, and the lobby and gathering spaces, which we are going to create temporary facilities for within the existing footprint of the covered area for the ice rink. Alternative two would be a community center with what we're calling a modified rink.
47:43 There would be, again, no additional parking, and we would eliminate the roof over the ice rink. There would be minimal support structures for the ice rink because it was designed that the superstructure would house all of the facilities, and so they weren't designed for snow load, so we would have to come up with some temporary facilities to meet, you know, storage of the Zamboni and the chiller room, and then we'd have to create some new spaces for restrooms. But we believe that all can be done within the budget.
48:10 The foundations for the future ice rink roof would be installed with this alternative. So what this looks like as a floor plan, again, winterizing the restrooms, everything south of the gray line, that's where the superstructure for the ice rink would be eliminated. The lobby spaces, community center spaces would all be retained as originally planned. At this time I invite Betsy up to talk about the project goals and the recreation commission input. Thank you, Hayes.
48:43 So just to remind everyone, the commission actually began planning for this project back in 2015. And our mission, which remains, is to provide multi-generational, multi-purpose, year-round, indoor and outdoor recreational opportunities accessible to all residents and visitors. And so these were the original goals of the project, which are still goals today and still very much needs in the community. And that's to enhance the quality of life for our residents, to create a venue that encourages social interaction, to provide a recreation destination.
49:12 Thank you so much.
49:41 So the commission really expressed at our last meeting at the end of June unanimous support for the rink and roof alternative. And Hayes, if you want to go to the next slide, it talks about that. So the commission strongly supports alternative one.
50:00 And one of the commission's concerns is that public opinion and the overall comprehension of the project in the community could really be greatly improved. You know, we hear a lot of talk about the hockey community and an ice rink, and we don't believe that the project is well understood as a year-round recreation center designed to meet the growing needs of the community and the winter and summer visitors. Particularly, we have such a growing demand for our summer camps that we cannot meet in addition to, you know, program community events.
50:29 So still for the commission, the deciding factor for the design alternative is really based on the programming identified in the community developed playbooks that you've heard so much about.
50:41 Thanks, Betsy.
51:13 Project budget. I'm going to turn it over to Dan to discuss the budget as a whole as it stands right now. Thank you. As it kind of is outlined in the staff report and above there,
51:25 We have currently identified $9.1 million for the total project cost. I think we presented this before to Council. Very little general fund dollars at this point, about $120,000. The rest of it has come from a variety of restricted sources, Measure U, a debt issuance, Melrose funding, and park development impact fees. To get to the initial $9.1 million,
51:48 We've looked at that, and there's a portion of it that has been expended and committed. So $1.8 million has been committed for contracts. The largest one that is unexpended at this point is for a grading contract with speech construction, and he has agreed to honor that contract, although it's about a year old now. And still, if the project goes forward, that would be an existing contract. We'd not have to rebid that.
52:11 And then also we've had some architectural funding still held for the project. The current work by HMC is being done at no charge, but those funds would go forward if they managed the project forward. We set a budget target of $13 million, and if you look at the alternative one in the high end of 10.9,
52:32 And the existing $1.8 million that's committed would be about $12.7 million. So we're into that ballpark. And so that's kind of the high-end side of the budgets projected to date. And so we would still be looking at that as the top-end dollar. And so we need to look at another $4 million in total costs for that. We've identified a number of different sources for that. Depending on the alternative that comes out tonight, we can come back with additional detail on that. But that would include, you know, looking at
52:58 Similar funding sources. It looks at some either, you know, one-time funding out of measures R&U again. It would look at some one-time funding potentially out of the general fund. We have some other, you know, non-restricted reserves from other areas that potentially could be shifted into this project. Continue to look at some fundraising opportunities. We believe there's anywhere from a half a million to 750,000 of fundraising dollars that are still a potential for this type of project.
53:24 And so as we walk through those and look at those, pending again the option or direction from Town Council, we would come back with a detailed outline of where we believe that funding can work to where you can be at that $13 or $13 plus million and then be able to adjust accordingly. And again, if we end up with bids closer to the bottom end of this, then you would have some additional savings there.
53:46 Not be spent on the project or go into an additional piece of the project that's currently not being proposed in the alternatives as currently presented. So I think we're still pretty comfortable with the $13 million number, again, based on the bids we got, the work that was done, the review of those, and the estimates as laid out in the staff report at this point. So that would be the current funding structure of that. The final allocation of those dollars, we need to come back to Town Council once we get
54:16 Kind of a final direction on the project that is potentially to be funded. Thanks, Dan. So a revised schedule. What we'd be proposing if council direction was clear this evening would to start moving forward with HMC on a preferred alternative. We're currently working to onboard a construction manager.
54:39 Once we onboard that team, we would marry the two to finalize the plans. It's imperative that you have the construction manager be a part of the final construction drawings to ensure that the project is feasible, we have constructability, we can actually get the resources to avoid some of the issues we had in the prior bid.
54:58 We would work through that through the winter. Our hope would be towards the end of winter we'd be able to enter into a contract with the construction manager to deliver the project for a not-to-exceed or a guaranteed maximum price contract. That would allow them to start bidding the process, excuse me, bidding the project for the various components, holding the construction contract with SPECE, allowing them to start work early in the spring, weather permitting.
55:28 Construction duration would really be a function of the construction manager. They would determine how long it's going to take, so I really can't comment on how long it's going to take for them to pull the various pieces together. Best guess would be 18 months, but ultimately they're going to drive that process. So the staff recommendation at this time is to proceed with the development and the construction of the multi-use facility, implementing a phased approach, beginning with the rink and a roof alternative.
55:58 For a not to exceed cost of $13 million all in. That concludes my presentation and I'm happy to field any questions at this time. Okay, do we have any questions from the council? Okay, John, we'll go ahead and dig in. Sure. The new park that's been installed, you guys can do all this without, and you'll be able to speak to whatever disturbances would.
56:24 Would affect the new park? Yeah, obviously we would have to close down the new park while we're doing major construction, but we did design the infrastructure to marry with the plans that we have for this project. So ultimately everything will blend seamlessly together. Okay. And HMC, they're the folks who are working for free? Currently, yes. And how long, how, get that kid some water. How, how, how much?
56:53 What effort do you anticipate getting out of that under that arrangement? They've agreed to get us to where we need to be to get the project moving forward. So under this proposal, they would work with the CM to deliver a brand new set of plans and specifications to move the first phase of the project forward. Okay. And the CM, we talked, I mean, I think a lot of us thought it was a pretty interesting idea to have that capacity for a variety of different capital efforts. Do we need to have other capital projects to make this CM?
57:22 I think the effort that we're moving forward with the county, the foundation, and the school district is to really create a bench of opportunity using construction management services and that could be used not only for infrastructure projects like this but could be used for
57:52 Road rehabilitation, sidewalk projects, and obviously all the great things the school and the foundation and the county are working on. Yeah, okay. And the schedule laid out here, it sounds like it's, you know, we have this meeting tonight if we had to do a little bit of a tweak or something like that. It's not like we have to, you don't have a date that's coming up that we have to. No. Okay. And the speeds, was that for the grading?
58:14 Contract or the construction? That was for mass grading alone. Just the grading. The idea at that time was to pull the mass grading to get in front of construction to prepare the site for another contractor to work to put in the roof and the community centers. Okay. Final question. You mentioned phased. The final slide says something about phased. Can you elaborate on that a little bit?
58:39 A phased approach. I mean, if we say if we go with number one or something, is there some phasing within that or what do you mean by phased? Let me address that one. We really, after all the community input we did have in the last council's action, it was clear that there was a vision for the project in the long term and we didn't want to lose that.
58:59 Okay. Thank you.
59:29 Kirk, did you have a question? Yes, I did. The original plans in the alternative one, it states that the ice rink is, that one of the walls is replaced with a solid wall. That means we're going to replace the glass with a concrete wall. That wall will be replaced with a concrete wall?
59:55 The material has not been determined yet, but it would be consistent with the design elements of the structure, which were a split-face CMU, core 10 steel, corrugated metal, or hardy plank. So one of those materials. So we would use something that looked appropriate and not, you know. So if we...
1:00:20 If we go to the original design and everything, the $20 million project, we're going to have to tear that wall out to meet this kind of a visual from the upper deck? Correct. So let's say hypothetically we were to move forward with phase one rink and a roof, and a year later you came in with the funding for the community center.
1:00:45 We would pull out that temporary wall. It would be non-structural, not load-bearing, wouldn't have utilities in it. It's a temporary wall, so we can replace it. Absolutely. The other question I had is on the operations and maintenance on this and the idea that we've identified 1,193 students. So what is it? I mean, if we're going to...
1:01:11 Subsidize these students and not do a full cost recovery. What's the operations and maintenance costs on this new facility? Yeah, and I'll let Stu field operations and long-term maintenance of the facility. And this will include staff, new staffing? Yeah, so we're being, working with our team over here to kind of, you know, discuss all those projects as well. I don't have definitive numbers for you.
1:01:41 Councilmember, I mean at this time to give you an X number to provide operations and maintenance. We have numbers based on the existing entire facility which we would go in and start pulling out if the alternative that you selected, I would then pull out like alternative two, pull out the community centre and start running those numbers. If you selected alternative one, I can start running those numbers based on the footprint and the amenities that I have. I've probably updated that operation and maintenance
1:02:10 You know, P&L about six times in the last three years. So I'm just seeking input, direction, and then I can provide that kind of information back when we kind of provide the funding package for the complete operations and maintenance. And if I could add to that, Stu, one of the concepts of having this kind of population is...
1:02:29 Not all things that will happen there are a charge. The programs are certainly a charge. You know, the summer programming, the camps and everything are a charge. But we expect this to be a place where kids after school or late, they can come and hang out and take care of it. But, I mean, the point is they can come and have a place to go after school. It's not going to be a charge at the door just to come in and stand and watch hockey as an example or do something. So I think that's part of that question that needs to be answered too.
1:02:56 1,193 students, 60%. They'll have someplace to go that they don't necessarily have to pay for. I understand Parks and Rec is a community benefit, and the idea is that it's not to break even. What I wanted to know is what impact it's going to have on our general fund in the future. That's my question so that we can begin to budget it in the future because I strongly support Parks and Rec and those types of programs. Yeah, I mean, a lot of the programming through the playbooks, you know,
1:03:27 Itemized programs, expenses. I mean, we've got all that kind of P&L laid out. I mean, some of the plan with this facility is when we talked about in summertime, you know, doing the adult leagues at night, you know, doing the drop-in play, you know, free 4 to 6 p.m. for our community members, and then during the day it has a drop-in capability for summer camps, programs, and, you know, scheduled activities. So, I mean, summer is pretty built out, and I think the goal that we've kind of...
1:03:53 Move forward with certainly council and the commission is really making sure that the visitation is the primary metric, not kind of the dollar is the primary metric of performance. You know what I mean? So we really want to make sure we're programming and building a facility that the community can use and afford to take advantage of. And that's really been kind of our primary goal through this process. We have some pretty specific numbers that we can share with you, but I don't want to get ahead of it right now because I...
1:04:19 I want to make sure we're clear with the alternative, and then I can start running those numbers again. I'm well aware of the numbers. Thank you. But the public needs to also know what some of the numbers are. Okay. Thank you, Kirk. Lynda, did you have some questions? I do. I have a number of questions. So just to start with a phasing question. So we're proposing this plan.
1:04:52 That would have some sort of a vague, in the future, we'll try to do a community room, but we really don't have a cost set for that, or what kind of timeline for that, so it's sort of this nebulous in the future phasing. Is that accurate, do you think? We have an idea of the cost. We have an idea of what it would take to get it done. We do not have a budget. Yeah, and funds would also go along with timeline. So when I look at the alternative one,
1:05:22 And then I look at alternative two. Alternative two is sort of like not, you know, an open rink again. We have an open kind of space, so that doesn't really seem to get us much of anywhere. When I look at alternate number one, I think about being a parent, bringing my child to this facility to skate, play hockey. Maybe I'm a visiting parent from down south and we're here. And I walk in.
1:05:53 And there's no space to sit down and have a cup of coffee while my child goes out into the rink and does things. We're winterizing the bathrooms, which implies to me what we would expect people to schlep from here out into what is not always welcoming weather and maybe with a couple of smaller children in tow to the winterized restroom.
1:06:23 I can't watch them easily because now we've made what was going to be a window a wall. I'm not sure that this is doing what we had talked about this doing. So I'm a little I have a lot of questions about that. So if I can address a couple of those. So the gray area above the rink, that was the old viewing platform.
1:06:53 So that was a couple of ramps, that was the bleachers. The idea is we would not install the platform and the ramps and create a space for tables, chairs, bleachers, and other facilities for people to watch. How big is that space? Yeah, to have a cup of coffee. What you were explaining is exactly what we were envisioning using that space for. The idea behind winterizing the restroom.
1:07:22 Was to just create additional capacity. The restrooms we have for the locker rooms and there's an additional public restroom, we would move a couple doors around so that we could have two locked off restrooms when we didn't have tournaments in play. And we would have, that would give us a total of three restrooms inside the facility. The idea of winterizing it is just to build some additional capacity because we lost a few restrooms from the lobby space.
1:07:49 How many people would come and view and be in attendance at a tournament? I'll jump in. I can see where you're going with this question. So that size is roughly, if you look at the open public space size, it's about 15 feet by about 100 feet. That kind of gray rectangle, I think is kind of what the estimate is. So that gives you space. So potentially in a tournament, what we could do during, you know, weekend tournaments with a cold a classic, we could actually just bring in our bleacher sets, you know, place them in that space.
1:08:20 And then as we, you know, finish the tournaments. Tournaments we see people cycling in and out. You've probably, you know, been called a classic and having a look at that. So you'd have probably, you know, 50 to 100 people coming in for each game, switch out, new set of parents come in, you know. So the space is around 50 to 100 people for a tournament set. What we're really looking into, which is the larger challenge, is winter.
1:08:44 You know, when we're looking at peak times during the holidays, we could have 200 to 300 skaters, you know, getting in and out of that facility. So we'd take the bleachers out, or we can tilt and roll them, move them to the other side of the rink, and then open that space up for benches, you know, little market tables, those type of things. So we can be pretty flexible with that kind of programmable space. And in the summertime, we'd probably clear the whole...
1:09:06 You know, the majority of that out because, you know, we're turning in a lot of our kind of hub for our summer camps and programs. Our kids would migrate to the locker spaces and so forth and then we'd have that kind of public space as well. So we're kind of playing, you know, as best we can with the space that we, you know, have available. And that doesn't include the spaces on the side of that facility and potentially on the outside in summer as well. No concessions, right? We do have a concession building. So if you look at the orange.
1:09:30 When you come in on the facility entrance, that large space that you see on the right there when you come in is actually the storage for the original community centre. So that would be retrofitted for the skate rental area that we currently have. So that's where all the skates would be. We have skates for probably about 400 plus users. And the other orange little space at the end of the open public space would be the concessions.
1:09:53 That's where the water is. So we'd kind of retrofit that to our hot chocolate, you know, coffees, drinks, you know, those type of things, refrigerated merchandise. And the rest of the room spaces remain the same. So they haven't been changed from the original design. So you still have our four locker rooms. We still have the adjoining kind of locker spaces slash restrooms. We still have the snow pit. We still have the kind of the...
1:10:16 The snow grooming, Zamboni pit, and we have that larger space for the chiller package that we've talked about, which is so important as well. I wish that we had a rendition of what that really looks and feels like. I have a vision of winter clothes, boots, people everywhere, smooshed in, people going out and sitting in their car because they can't breathe inside. I mean, I just, it does not seem to be we're building something that would
1:10:45 Be welcoming and enjoyable and some of the core values as Betsy talked about, that we're actually meeting those core values that we had for so long drove this process. And yeah, that's my question. Thank you and I appreciate that. And I get the public open space that social interaction was a real goal. You know, we'll do the very best we can.
1:11:13 I know we'll have a lot of people here speak to, you know, what experiences they have in different rinks, you know, around the countryside and how they manage. But again, the original designer's facility was an indoor-outdoor experience. You know, we chose not to pursue a fully indoor, you know, conditioned space. You know, the desire through all the planning process was to try and combine this indoor-outdoor. So we have that experience. So that's kind of where we're at with the design right now. And you mentioned that during the winter this might be a...
1:11:41 A drop-in place for kids after school, and I know Bill has spoke about that in the past. How many drop-in kids could you accommodate? So a big part of our program, as you know, is our school district students. You know, currently we only charge them $2 to skate with their rentals. We receive, I mean, last year was our biggest, you know, year for about 10 years, and that was 1,500 of those kids dropping in in a kind of a two-month period.
1:12:10 So if you look at this facility that is planned to operate for six months, that provides a lot of opportunities for those kids after school. You know, if you run that math, that's, you know, 6,000 plus kids that we can kind of get in out of the facility for our local community. Okay, probably more later. Yeah, appreciate the questions. Thank you. Guys, if we chose to run the roof,
1:12:38 Without actual building any of the building of the community center, what does that add? Kick them. So the community center component, we were estimating to be about $4 to $4.5 million standalone as an addition to the rink and the roof. The sunk costs are really in the utilities, the HVAC system, air conditioning. If you're building conditioned space, no matter what the size, we're going to be sizing it for the entire facility.
1:13:10 If we'd say hypothetically just built the lobby, you know, we're not, it's only going to be maybe a million, a million and a quarter less than building out the whole facility because we're going to have to build for the whole, all the infrastructure will have to be included for the entire facility at that time. And Hayes was talking about the entire blue section. Right. Not just community centers, when you're talking about that. The whole blue thing, yeah, we were looking at that as a whole and then.
1:13:36 What it would take to break that down in components. And we keep, as I was saying, everything was a derivative of an alternative we kept on coming back to. Well, we're going to have to put in all of the utilities and all of the systems to be in place for the whole building. And so the structure is really nominal compared to that. So if we exclude that piece completely and don't build the roof out, how difficult is it going to be to tie it together and reproduce our original vision?
1:14:07 I know that the walls we were talking about earlier are not load-bearing, so they can come out. You can still do the raised thing, but is it possible to join the two buildings in that way without doing the full roof today? Yes, it was designed that way. Right. And as I'm looking at this, we've got this lovely color-coded and lettering so small, and all the presentations I've seen, I can't read them even with my readers. But for public space, where you could potentially, on a non-hockey game night,
1:14:37 Put up some tables and chairs for the hot chocolate and the spectators. You do have three of the corners available and the open space down the other side where we have no color coding in here. So other than the 1,500 square feet of open public space you've identified, we do have concessions. We do have an area for skate rental. I don't like the fact that they're so far apart it makes it tough to run them with one person.
1:15:04 If we can find a way to fix that somehow, I would appreciate it. I don't know about Betsy and Stu, but from a council standpoint and a funding standpoint, it makes it easier on slow days if one person can handle the whole load. But there is, in doing the math, plenty of room for some tables and chairs in those corners and in that open space for spectators and for all the necessary good.
1:15:34 The roof height doesn't change from the original concept, so it's still going to be like 35 feet over the top of the rink, so it's going to be a very wide open space, seemingly very open and comfortable, if I get that right. Correct. And that's really it. Are we going to do on the one side of the rink where we have no color now, are there going to be doors there for
1:16:07 The player areas, what do we call it, guys? The boxes. The box. Yeah, all the backer boards, all the spaces for players and penalty boxes, and all that is retained. Nothing on the south end of the building has changed. All the structure is exactly the same, the concrete, patio, whatever you want to call it, walkway area, fencing, none of that has been changed.
1:16:36 And it still gives us areas to walk behind those boxes that the public can mill through. So besides the open, what I'm getting at is besides the open public space, there's an almost identical open public space on the other side, only it's even bigger. Yeah, and that would hold benches or other tables and chairs if necessary. What's unique about the design is actually it's tempered glass around the entire circumference of the rinks itself, right?
1:17:06 At our rank right now, we clearly don't have that. And we actually have, in the scope right now, have the tempered glass behind the player boxes. So those player boxes are actually shielded, so separate. So if you've got people moving back and forth, they're in their space, they're separate, protected, so forth. So anyway, that's that kind of design. And then what's also unique that we've really kind of programmed for summer, we're looking at the Olympic ice sheet.
1:17:33 Why we've kind of gone that way, as you know, is because it's 15 feet wider. It's 100 by 200. It's 20,000 square feet. And divide that into three spaces. You have three individual spaces we can program during summertime. We can do one court. It could be volleyball. One could be basketball. One court could be fuzzball, table tennis, you know, whatever activity you want to do. And each of those spaces have individual entrances, right? So we've actually programmed doors for each of those spaces so you don't have people mingling around. So within that space, we're able to compartmentalize.
1:18:02 That larger space into kind of more programmable spaces, right? So we're really maximizing, you know, that 20,000 square feet as best we can, right? And in wintertime, you know, the opportunities for cross-ice hockey is significant, right? Because with Olympic ice sheet, for mite squirts, you know, you can center off the middle of the rink and have two different program activities going on at the same time. Thank you. That's it for me for that. Thank you.
1:18:28 Any more questions from the Council? Okay, now we will go to public comment. If I could please ask that you keep it under five minutes as well. If you could, just don't repeat what the person in front of you said. Go along the same lines. But please, if you're in agreement, just please say I agree with the statements ahead. And Mr. Posey? Madam Mayor, Jeff Posey, Councilmembers. I just got here.
1:18:58 I was watching on TV waiting for a customer to come by, but one thing that sticks out the most is the restrooms and the summer use, winter use. I don't want to derail the project whatsoever, but this whole thing started out as an ice rink. So I know you want an Olympic rink, the sizing, you can fit more bodies on it, you can have three pickleball courts on it instead of two. I think the safety of the children.
1:19:28 It's more important than an Olympic-sized rink versus an NHL-sized rink where you can take the money saved and build a lobby, build bathrooms. You cannot have this dude walking in while my kid's getting changed in the restroom. That's absolutely 100% unacceptable. It's against every single safe sport rule put out there. You can't even go in the locker room unless you're safe sport certified. You have to have a background check. You have to take the safe sport course. This is serious shit. You can't.
1:19:58 You can't have, it just blows you away. I mean, you're sacrificing summer versus winter, and you have to have facilities for these people to come in. They're spending a lot of money to get here. Hockey is not cheap. Okay, I can, I'm telling you, and I've been to all these rinks, you know, I've been to a ton of hockey rinks. And if there's not a place for you to sit and watch your kid, I mean, go to San Jose, go to, go look at the facilities these people build. Don't half-ass anything else.
1:20:28 Everything we build in this town is half-assed, and we pay for it in the end. So build the right goddamn facility. Thank you. Okay, would someone like to follow that? Howdy, Council. I can't really follow that. But I do appreciate Jeff's passion and his commitment to this. We've been involved in this for more than three years.
1:20:59 Actually, kicking the can down the road, so to speak. Yeah, just a business owner, volunteer. I don't have any kids yet. I would like to, but same thing. Speaking of that, do you have a name? Excuse me, yes. Jill Hannigan. Okay, thank you. So just support of the rink. Get it done, as Jeff said. Excuse me. And, yeah, there's a lot of people passionate about it. So we're here to support, and business opportunities are great.
1:21:29 Community opportunities are great. It's a can't lose deal. The only problem is we keep kicking it down the road and it's going to cost more and more money. Taxes, tariffs, you name it. Inflation, this $4 million addition is going to be $10 million this time next year. So just think about it. I know it's tough finding the money, but we can do it. So that's all I can say. Thank you. Thank you. Hello, my name is Michael Draper. I'm a Mammoth resident.
1:22:00 Thank you. Mayor Hoff, Patrick Bernard, Mammoth Youth Hockey resident.
1:22:33 Kirk, Linda, congratulations. This is our first chance to meet. I've been here with Posey six years working with Mammoth Youth Hockey. Cleland's had the opportunity to come out as well as the other council members to see some of our tournaments. I'd be happy to answer a few of the questions. I think I can clarify some of the things you guys had before to go along with what Jeff had. Jeff's frustrated because Jeff's been in this for 20 years. We have pictures of his daughter here.
1:23:03 He's about to be a senior in high school, and his oldest son, Ben, has graduated. And he's been working on this project for 20 years. You know, whether you've been on council before, this is your first tying up, how long you've been here, but there's a 20-year history of this town needing an ice rink and a facility. What we need is a successful facility. And the bathroom, we can figure that out, I think. Mammoth Youth Hockey, what we've strived for is to create an affordable product, which we've had.
1:23:33 We've brought 50-plus youth hockey teams here, millions of dollars in economic impact, LA Kings, Golden Knights, Anaheim Ducks, San Francisco, Reno, Vegas, everybody. Everybody wants to come here, just like you heard from the guys that run Mammoth Film Festival. People like us, right? You know, they love us. This is Mammoth. But what we really need is a roof. And so we...
1:23:56 Run hockey tournaments at a facility very similar to this, but it has no roof. The public space currently is smaller than what we have now. That rink is not only shut down half the time, but when we do have tournaments and snow comes, we're constantly trying to move. So a rink with a roof, it will already be improved upon of what we have. Roof is the huge component here. Not only is it going to help ice hockey, but it's going to help the summer programming.
1:24:22 20,000 square foot of a roof is a lot more easy to program or more space than 2,500 square feet of a blank room. We have a community center that my daughter is 12 and a half. We haven't been there in three years because now she practices plays at the old Supreme Court house, which is across the way here. And, you know, we haven't utilized that. So we've spent million plus dollars many, many years. This is an improvement. We need the roof.
1:24:52 The bathroom can be worked out. We obviously know people shouldn't go into a bathroom, into a locker room. That's the small stuff. But alternative one is something we need to get done. And this has been 20 years and we cannot wait any longer. The longer we wait, these kids are going to graduate. I've got sixth graders that are now graduating that spoke to you guys five, six, seven years ago. And obviously kids that are, you know, did it 15 years ago. So this is your opportunity to be a part of this.
1:25:21 It's not just about subsidizing us. There's thousands of people to go to that rink. Everybody from the public and all of our visitors deserve a successful place that runs. And for programming and staff reasons, you're going to have more staff selling skates at 18 bucks a person than shoveling snow. And instead of turning 27 people away every hour that want to give us 500 bucks an hour to skate,
1:25:47 Your staff's going to be collecting money. So we are going to be successful. This rink is going to be good. We need that roof. That roof's going to be good in the winter and the summer. So please, alternative one, get this thing started. If you're creative enough to do it all at 19 million bucks, we're pretty smart. We're paying a $40 million debt. I think we can handle six or seven million. I don't know who will float us alone.
1:26:11 But let's do it. If you guys can do that, let's great. If not, start with one. We'll finish the rest later. And let's get it done. Alternative one has most of the things we need. If you have any questions, I'm here. Thank you. Thank you very much. Good evening, Mayor and Council. Matt McLean, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Recreation. I'd like to read a prepared statement approved by our staff and board. Mammoth Lakes Recreation has supported the concept of the park since its inception.
1:26:50 Option 1. Option 1.
1:27:16 Live up to the town's original commitment to provide a covered rink, allowing us to facilitate a full menu of winter and summer programming with greater protection and more efficiency. However, this option does not include a lobby area or the community space, elements that would have made this facility a true and robust hub for community activity and civic events. Option two, foregoing the roof and building the community center prioritizes the need for a broader audience.
1:27:46 Providing us resources that would benefit dozens of community groups, families, and visiting guests. This option also comes at a cost. Our failure to fulfill an obligation made to the many individuals, families, and visiting hockey enthusiasts who have been stalwart in their patience and support of a decade-long effort to secure a roof for their rink.
1:28:08 After much consideration and in the absence of a real, considered alternative that might allow for a fully functional but scaled back version of a covered area at the Mammoth Creek Park, Mammoth Lakes Recreation has chosen to support option one, the immediate construction of a roofed ice rink and rec zone facility. For the record, Mammoth Lakes Recreation believes that this option limits our ability to secure outside funding for this project, shifting the burden of the cost back to the residents of Mammoth Lakes.
1:28:36 We also believe that this option will result in the long-term delay in replacing the town's aging community center. By committing to option one, however, our hope is that it demonstrates to the town of Mammoth Lakes our ability to fulfill on promises and may help build trust and ultimately pave the way for future projects such as the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center, childcare facility, and potentially a community aquatic center. Thank you.
1:29:17 Sandy Hogan, a long-term resident, 23 years, and a lifelong supporter of all recreation. And that's one reason why I live here, that's why I didn't move back to South Lake Tahoe, because I don't care they have that beautiful rec center, this is my home. Anyway, I want to remark that, you know, the intents and goals of the staff, all the work that you've done, the rec commission, all, it's really admirable.
1:29:45 But now we're down to reality. And as Stu has said a couple times, as best we can. I heard the Recreation Commission for a long, long time always repeat, we want it done right or not at all. I heard that up until basically the last few months. And in response to Christy, who said, why don't people come to our meetings? There are those that watch your meetings. We're out there.
1:30:13 But you don't go to meetings when you know everything's a done deal and you've just got people cheerleading and hoping it'll happen. And so a lot of us just watch on TV rather than coming and commenting. I'm commenting tonight because it is a decision point. You've got two new council members, the second meeting, and you're asking them to make a $13 million decision. And a number of years ago we had new council members and I believe they made the decision to move it.
1:30:42 But it started off with the hockey folks, we support you. I mean, all of us. We support our kids, all of the students. I, too, grew up in a town where the town offered wonderful recreation and kept me on a straight path. But the town and the school district worked together and didn't try to outlast each other or whatever. So anyway, I have to commend the staff. They've always done a good job of soliciting ideas for activities. But, you know, it just grew.
1:31:13 Like Topsy. It kept growing. And a lot of us said it's not when we were asked for some input. Actually, we said it's not feasible. And I mean, Matt's comments were excellent ones. Jeff's were right on. And the one thing I want to say is somebody who used to make decisions with the Forest Service and who reviewed alternatives, these alternatives are bad and worse.
1:31:38 Number two is what we used to call a straw man. You put that in there so you drive everybody to number one. Let's consider some other alternatives like an NHL size and solving the restroom problems. I mean, the things that, you know, parents are going to look for. They're not going to drop their kids off in some place where they don't feel safe. We need to resolve it. There's no urgency tonight to commit to a 13,000.
1:32:05 Very blank page, frankly, where we'll handle the restrooms as that comes up. We're sending them outside to the winterized ones. A two-holer? I don't think so. So I guess what I'm saying is I do agree we need to do whatever we're going to do, do it right. But there's no urgency tonight. The new rec commission meets next Tuesday and two of the members, there are only three members in the June meeting. And I think the new people
1:32:34 Such as Dan O'Connor, who actually built Rock and Bowl and knows the right questions to ask, he should be able to ask the same type of questions that our newer council members have been asking. So I was just saying, what's the urgency? Put it off. You've got strategies and priorities coming up in three weeks. And, you know, maybe then you want to look at a bigger picture than just this facility that really doesn't sound very good. Alternative 1 or 2.
1:33:02 Create number three, I think I heard that when I listened and watched Mammoth Lakes Recreation, I heard people making that comment. Alternative three, where is it? Four? So, take a little more time. That schedule doesn't call for groundbreaking this fall. And we don't want to tear up a park if we don't even know what we're going to do. So I'm just hoping that the town council, I'm asking, will postpone this decision. Look at the plans.
1:33:29 Ask the hard questions about the budget and this and that and who's going to sit where and this and that and develop a couple more alternatives that you can actually see, not just things that we can't read. As Bill said, I have trouble too. So thank you for the opportunity to comment and thanks to the staff for constant efforts. I mean, I don't think anybody knows for the last couple of years they have just labored under this as if this were our first priority in the world. It's not.
1:33:57 And later August, our council will talk about that. So let's put it off and do it right when we do it. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. I'm Sharon Clark, and I'm a Mammoth Lakes resident. Please excuse my reading of my testimony. It's much more efficient. The irony of calling this building a rink with a roof is that all we wanted four years ago was a rink.
1:34:39 With a roof. A roof on Mammoth Ice Rink. Turning it into a year-round recreational facility costing, I think, two to three million dollars. Leasing the rink from our school district is a top-notch amenity that benefits us all. Our taxes pay both our town government and our school district. It's like the right hand giving to the left hand. It's a win-win.
1:35:10 More depressing than spending four times the money and wasting four years is what has happened to the trust in our government. What a lesson our youth have learned. They, like the rest of us, expected Mammoth Ice Rink roof to be built. Their fund drive raised thousands of dollars to pay for that roof. Instead, the multi-use facility grew and grew.
1:35:37 Until an Olympic-sized ice rink was presented, perhaps ready by 2017. Hopes and trust were high. 2017 came and went. The muff ballooned to $19 million. Consolation, a community center, two alternatives have been presented.
1:36:05 A changed rink with a roof that I don't think our community really understands are, second alternative, a community center with a rink without a roof. These are not real choices. It's almost like we've come full cycle back to where we started. We have a community center. We have an ice rink.
1:36:36 Both need improvements. Please send this mistake back to staff with instructions to bring real alternatives to all of us, not just the commissions. We, the entire community need to participate in how to spend this $13 million. Whatever you do, do it right or don't do it at all. Thank you.
1:37:12 Public comments at this time? Then we will go ahead and staff, were there any things that came up that you'd like to answer? Okay. Then I'll go ahead and ask for council deliberation. So I'd like to start by saying that I appreciate the, I went to the Mammoth Lakes Recreation meeting and I've heard the expression of kind of the
1:37:44 A certain lack of satisfaction of the alternatives, and I understand that. But I think Alternative 1 gives us a good place to start. And I think that I'm hearing, Lynda, your concerns about the entranceway in the lobby. And I would like to, because we do not have a hammer, we don't have a season coming down on us, so we have to make a decision to move something forward right away. I would like to explore looking at Alternative 1 with the entranceway.
1:38:12 And I'm willing to potentially sacrifice the community center going there. So to see an alternative that has the utilities and all that kind of stuff that would serve us just that entrance way to make that work and to see if that's something we could bring back for $13 million. If I can speak to that a second. I think that there is an opportunity to put forward an alternative that gets us in a better place. And for that, I would concur that I think that the community center is perhaps the linchpin
1:38:42 Doesn't need to be there right now. And when I think about that, I think about we have the parcel development looming before us. Citing a community center with perhaps even a child care center, sort of on the model, I don't know if all of you may or not be familiar with the Levining Community Center. It's a very nice community center, but it also includes a daycare portion. So you have a daycare and a community center.
1:39:12 And the parcel, having been developed for workforce housing, to me that seems like a really good location for that. It's, you know, downtown, sort of in the downtown revitalization plan. We want to kind of, you know, bring activity and animation to that area. I think that that might be something worth really looking at and thinking about. Maybe there's some grant opportunities that would then like that, sort of this, you know, combination. So if we were to
1:39:40 Sort of let go of having to build the infrastructure that would eventually support community center. You then could maybe go back and take a look at, you know, adding back some of those, you know, some might say amenities. I call them sort of a crucial, you know, piece of making this facility really great, welcoming facility.
1:40:01 And I don't think of it as an ice rink. I think it as sort of a multi-use sports center. I think, you know, it has winter program, it has summer, and I think that's something that we should really recognize as being so important to our community, that the value of providing a place for our families and our youth and our children year-round is really what I see as the overriding. And, you know, lots of people here to talk about the skating rink, and I respect that, and I think that that's...
1:40:29 You know, a great winter use, but I'd like to think that maybe we go back and look at that other alternative. And in the meantime, maybe we take a look at our community center and make that look, you know, a little more usable than it is now. I was over there actually this afternoon at a meeting, and I'm going around and poking on things and wiggling things and thinking, you know, that could actually be a pretty darn good community center in the interim while we're kind of working through the process of seeing how that goes, you know.
1:40:57 I think there are some opportunities. I think there's an alternative that wasn't necessarily going to take a really long time to do. Because I understand we've waited a long time. We're trying to get this going. So those are just some thoughts that I think maybe staff could maybe continue the process of what has already been super hard work. But just to follow up on that, I think we need to make a decision.
1:41:20 And I'm hoping that we can come to a consensus around whatever staff would bring back. I'm hoping we can, obviously, Council's going to weigh in on this, but if we looked at the facility with what it would cost to do the entrance area with utilities just for that, potentially if we needed to remove that a little bit to ensure that we've got the max amount of real estate for another recreation-type facility on that lot, that's something that I'd be interested in looking at and maybe bringing that back at the next meeting in August.
1:41:50 And again, you've got $13 million to work with and see if that can happen, but that's kind of where I'm at. Okay. Do you have anything else that you would like to add? I, too, have been with this program for well over 20 years. I was on the rec commission as a newbie when this came up. First, I want to say to those who are saying we only want a roof and a rink, that this was never intended to be a rink.
1:42:17 25 years ago, this was a multi-use facility. It has always been intended to be a multi-use facility, and that's what the community needs. In terms of waiting, putting it off, if we're talking another two weeks, I'm good with that. I don't know if they can bring plans together that quick. But the fact is, we've got a contract with SPIECE that's already a year old, and they're willing to extend that for another year, but that price is going to change, and it's going to go up.
1:42:46 The price of steel is going up exponentially as we speak. So the need to get this off the ground and get it going is great. We do not have time to sit around and rethink this. It's not there. Time is up. When the idea first came forward to include the community center in this, I was opposed to that before it went to public meetings and everything else because I said I didn't think we could afford it.
1:43:16 Well, lo and behold, we can't afford it. However, the reason it was added was because it went through an extensive public process, and the public told us this is what they wanted. This is what they wanted at the site. This is what we need. This is where we wanted to go, so it was added in there. I would be, while the idea of the extra space is very, very attractive to me, believe me, I would be reticent to put anything in there that would preclude us.
1:43:44 From being able to eventually do that, unless we can very quickly come up with another funding source and how we're going to raise it and everything else. We have MLR on board. I've been told that that community center may be easier to raise funds for than the rink was. So I believe that while option one is not a great option, I believe it is doable. To call this the same as what we have,
1:44:15 This is all under roof. How many total bathrooms are in it? There are three bathrooms. Right. So it's not, there are two locker rooms and one additional that are in the footprint. Yeah. So it's not like we're asking people to go to that fourth bathroom. That's an alternative. It's not like we can, we will have the locker rooms that public can be kept out of and still have.
1:44:41 A restroom for people to use in there. And then if they have a big emergency, they can go out in the snow. It gives us the reason for the Olympic rink isn't just to have an Olympic rink. It gives us great opportunities for summer programming that I really believe is what this thing is for that I wouldn't want to lose. As a drop-in for the kids, even the kids that can't afford the two bucks, to have an area under roof that has park and rec employees there anytime it's open,
1:45:11 So kids can just drop in and hang out is huge. I grew up in this town. It was never available. We got in a lot of trouble. I'd rather see our kids not getting that same trouble. So to compare this with what we currently have or just a roof, I am very upset with staff that we're calling this a roof and a rink because that is not what it is. This is a building. It's a beautiful building with beautiful programmable space in it.
1:45:40 Even eventually, if somehow, as some people in the room think, that hockey isn't going to survive there, this is completely reprogrammable. It's 20,000 plus square feet of programmable space. So I would love to see a commitment from this council to move forward with option one and for alternatives to that option to be brought to us that we could change if it didn't bust the budget.
1:46:09 And go forward. That's where I'm at. This is a beautiful facility, and I think it will get a lot of use. I'll spit on you, John. No, no, no. I'll spit on myself. Okay. With that said, if there's... Ms. Stett, what would you like to say? I have a lot of things to say.
1:46:38 First of all, the first ice rink was out at the equestrian center. Paul Rudder put down plastic and then filled it with water and tried to create an ice rink out there. That was 34 years ago, by the way. So it's not the 20-year. We've been working on this for 34 years. Kirk, if we're going to talk history... Let me finish. Let me finish, okay? No, no, I'm not contradicting you. I'm saying the first rink was actually up behind the yodeler. Okay.
1:47:06 The other thing is that it's very difficult to talk about the ice rink in isolation. So let me go through some budget issues that are confronting us. First of all, in the report, the budget projection, the unallocated capital fund, there is no money in that fund.
1:47:27 Also, the shady rest, we borrowed $3.3 million out of our reserves, and that has to be paid back. We've underfunded road maintenance about $400,000 to $500,000 a year. The last three years, we took excess TOT to make sure that the roads are being maintained. We do not have a set-aside EL.
1:47:56 We do not have a set aside for maintaining our bike trails. So that's done on an ad hoc basis. The debt service is about $2.3 million a year. We are repaying the...
1:48:13 Vehicle Replacement Fund, $340,000 a year, which we borrowed against for some purchases. The MUF and the theater, the O&M, from what I understand, would be about $500,000 a year.
1:48:33 Proposition 6 passes, so I'm going to encourage everybody to vote no on Proposition 6 on the state ballot that's coming up. We will lose about $400,000 a year in grant money that will come into the town. Our and you commitments are pretty extended.
1:48:53 Stu was in the paper for $4.9 million worth of park maintenance. Right now we're going to be utilizing general fund money for part of the $9.1 million plus general fund dollars to make up to the $13 million. The future budget to complete the project, it seems to be up in the air. We don't know what that's going to cost.
1:49:22 And again, they're the O&M. So that said, you know, this community has always stepped up to get bike trails, to get a whole bunch of things. So I look at the Ike Rink people and I say do a 1% TOT for 10 years. That's $15 million and therefore the...
1:49:45 Project would be completely funded and be done. So if that comes forward, I think the council would support it. It means that the supporters of the ice rink would have to get out there, talk to your lodging communities and everybody else to get a two-thirds vote. It would lock in about a million for a year.
1:50:10 And therefore the entire project could be done. So I'm not opposed to the project right now. I think the town is upside down in some of its budget commitments. And I am not completely up to speed on all of the budget issues. But if the vote goes to option one, I will probably abstain.
1:50:35 Because I just can't, at this point, see how the budget manages that, and I don't think the option one meets what we're looking for as a community in the future. I believe that with a good political campaign, that 1% of TOT that generates about $1.4 million a year for 10 years,
1:50:59 Will get us a quality project out there. Otherwise, and it gives the community a chance to weigh in on what this actually is. So that's my suggestion. And as I said, right now, because of all the other budgetary pressures, and I'm not totally up to speed on the budget, I'm working hard trying to figure it out.
1:51:25 But I would support a 1% TOT and I will abstain on issue or option one because I don't know how we're going to fund it in the future. I'd rather get it done and have the project there and a quality project that I don't have to worry about next year trying to figure out how
1:51:51 To add to it or bathrooms or all the other things that need to be done. So let's get it done. Let's get it done right. You got a political action committee standing right there to try to go out and convince the community to do this. Okay. Well, thank you so much. I think everybody's answered a lot of my questions and my thoughts. So at this point, would anybody like to make a motion? I would make a motion.
1:52:25 To proceed with the development and construction of the multi-use facility, implementing a phased approach beginning with phase one, I'm not going to call it a roof and rink, alternative for not to exceed price of $13 million. I would, I support that, but I would like to staff, not asking to do anything absurd, but to come back.
1:52:56 And to let us know.
1:53:16 If that could be done within the $13 million. At this point, I think when I go back to the commitment to start this project off, my fundamental concern was that we were going to be investing money to build a facility and a piece of land that we did not own. I think that that's fundamentally problematic. I think that the schools, Linda, you ran in the campaign talking a lot about child care. Whatever happens with that facility, I think the town should not be occupying in some way
1:53:45 Land that has other purposes associated with it. So I would like to see what that alternative looks like. If that's not going to work, then I'm going to be okay with going with alternative one. I would amend my motion to speak to that. Okay. Thank you. So I have a second. You have a second on that motion as amended. We have a first and a second. So comment. Okay.
1:54:09 I would just like to, Councilman, that'll be, it'll take, it's probably the second month of September to get something back to you of detail. I mean, we would continue to work forward based on what you're saying, but it'll take a little bit of time to walk through what you're asking. So we don't mind doing it, but it'll just, it'll take. Okay, but in terms of the next meeting, but we can continue to move forward with the base motion, but we will be coming back with something. But in terms of the schedule that was laid out, that's, even if you bring it back in September, that's not going to affect anything. And you can do a good job, good thorough job, and tell us what that looks like. Is that okay?
1:54:38 I'd love to hear that motion in a shorter sentence. In a shorter sentence. Well, here, we'll try again. We'll try again with the motion. Try again. So I would move to the council approve. You need to withdraw your first and second and then make your new motion. Okay, so I will withdraw the motion. I'll withdraw my second. Okay. And I will attempt to make another motion here. So I would move to the council approve alternative one.
1:55:05 and that staff be further directed to bring back an alternative that includes construction costs for the entranceway as proposed with utilities to serve just the entranceway and not be anticipating putting in utilities and stuff for the community center and to also consider if moving that entranceway
1:55:27 If that makes sense, to allow for sufficient real estate for an aquatic facility or something like that, we've got real estate there to make sure we can maximize the value of the site. So I would second that with, as you said, the addition of asking staff to come back, and I would not necessarily limit that to one alternative, but the alternative that would say, get us the restrooms lobby space office without the community center.
1:55:57 As a potential phase in at a later date. Is that consistent with your motion? That's fine. That's consistent. Okay. I would second that then. Kirk, did you have something that you wanted?
1:56:12 Well, it's been moved in first. There's a second. So my comments are that I'll put on the agenda a discussion of a 1% increase in TOT at the next council meeting to be considered. If there's no community support, then I will obviously drop that. However, I will abstain on this because I think that we need to do the complete project.
1:56:40 Okay. Well, with the first and second, I will go ahead and ask for roll call, please. Council Member Salcido? Yes. Council Member Salcido? Abstain. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Rosen? Yes. Mayor Faulkner? No. With that, that's three in favor, one no, and one abstention. And thank you for all your time to everyone who came out and spoke tonight and put in your input for this.
1:57:10 And at this point, we are going to go ahead and, yeah, give yourself a second. And we are going to take a break and we will be back in 10 minutes. Thank you very much. This wonderful town council meeting.
1:57:58 That's okay. Can you tell me? Audience instruction. Closer and speak louder.
1:58:09 Oh, I could hear her just fine. Oh, you know what? I'm sorry. I should have been her eyes and I didn't look out. Oh, for the king. Huh? Yeah. I like these. I'm going to have a short bottom for myself. Was that a Gatorade? Strawberry lemonade. Nice.
1:58:35 Okay, we are all back. We're going to go back into the meeting, and we are going to go ahead and if we could take the ESTA update at this time.
1:59:02 In your packet, if you're following online, it's item four. So we'll take that right now. And, Madam Mayor, if I could do a real quick intro to this. This was brought forward following the last ESTA board meeting where some action was taken there regarding some routes and impacts in Mammoth Lakes. We were able to understand what was happening there. We had a good discussion at that board meeting. Member Stapp was there.
1:59:31 I can speak to some of the comments from the board there as need be. So we wanted to be able to come back and provide the community update and the council update of the actions taken at that meeting and also some of the other challenges we've seen this summer with ESTA just in terms of staff capacity and being able to really provide the full level of service that we all would love to provide. So there's a little short, just an action sheet, there's a little bit of information in that background. I won't go through all of that.
2:00:00 I think the key issues there, we believe the service up to Old Mammoth Road through the limited has been discontinued until school starts again. I forget the date, but that information, letting that get out there. The other side of that is just ongoing. Some of our special event services and stuff are able to fully staff Blueza Palooza, for example, but it is with some help from Mammoth Mountain Ski Area as well as ESTA. And so just some of the challenges they're having there.
2:00:27 And as you all know, with the departure of Mr. Helm, the previous Executive Director, there's been an ongoing recruitment. We do have an interim director that's been brought on board. You'll meet Joe here in just a moment. But with that, I'm going to turn it over to Katie, who's been the acting interim or whatever that title might be. Just multiple hat wear might be a better idea. But doing a great job in juggling a lot of items and keeping things afloat.
2:00:55 And then also the Mammoth area. John Robertson's here as well. Can speak to some of the service levels here in the town. But with that, I'll turn over to Carrie. She can give a little bit of an update and then answer any questions from town council and or the community regarding some of the service impacts and the challenges that they faced. Thanks. My name's Carrie Bentley, Eastern Sierra Transit. I was, until just last Friday, acting executive director. I was appointed by the board after two unsuccessful recruitments when John Helm retired.
2:01:25 Did have a couple of other key administrative people turn over at the same time. I just want to take a minute to introduce Joe Rye. He's our new interim executive director. He has ample transit experience and I'm really happy to have his support. He's going to be coming a couple of times a month and he'll also work remotely. So because I prepared the staff report, we decided that I'd go ahead and update town council.
2:01:53 So at the end of June, I was contacted by the Mammoth Operations Supervisor who provided a summer driver staffing spreadsheet indicating that Mammoth Lakes was short between five to eight full-time drivers and showed a weekly shortfall of over 200 hours. And if you assumed one shift per day per person, there was a shortage of 137 weekly shifts.
2:02:18 Now some of those shifts like lunches and covering can be grouped together, but not all of them. And so this was a really a critical situation that we found ourselves in. The analysis reflected the number of regular hours drivers were generally willing to work and had no buffer for time off requests. The shortfall did not take into account any special event demands, only regular summer service in the town of Mammoth Lakes and in June Lake. There are many, many issues.
2:02:48 Came together to result in this driver shortage. Poor spring recruitment, poor retention of new recruits. Some winter drivers that we were hoping would come back for the summer didn't. We had some positions open up in Bishop and drivers that...
2:03:04 You know, had mammoth-based jobs transferred down there. And there were some other reasons, too. The cost of living and housing issues in Mammoth Lakes are likely impactful, along with DOT testing requirements in a state where recreational marijuana is now legal. So we have to test for marijuana. And this creates an additional...
2:03:24 Challenge for us, being that it's now legalized here in the state. Additionally, unemployment is very low, and increasingly, there is an industry-wide driver shortage. So this isn't just something that's happening in transit for ESTA. This is something that's happening. It's happening everywhere.
2:03:41 So we took a number of actions to try to provide as much manpower for actually driving the buses as possible. We took the administrative work from the Mammoth office, and we just bus it down to Bishop every day, and we've been covering for that down there.
2:03:59 The task that the operations supervisor or dispatch generally did was man the line at Red's Meadow, you know, do the crowd control, help load the buses, okay, the bus is full, who wants to sand, that sort of thing.
2:04:12 Contracted. We called the Mammoth Mountain. They do ticket sales for us, and they were able to provide some hosts, and so that freed up the supervisors and dispatch to supervise and dispatch, and also to cover lunches and do tripper shifts, so we did that. You know, we've been calling people. There's a lot of things we did. I'm not going to bore you with reading the whole list, but we've been working hard to bolster
2:04:36 The availability of summer drivers. And I want to thank the town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce, and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area for their help. They've placed ads on their websites and really reached out for us to try to find people that are already licensed Class B drivers. We do train Class B drivers, but it takes approximately six weeks. So by the time we were at this critical spot and we lost some people, it was kind of too late for that. So I want to thank you for your help.
2:05:04 These efforts did yield approximately one and a half full-time equivalents. And so that helped some. And just to kind of illustrate, you know, what's going on is we've had three pay periods, two-week pay periods.
2:05:21 Since I was notified of this issue, and there's been 644 hours of overtime out of Mammoth Lakes, and that's been spread over between 22 or 23 people, and so we were seeing timesheets where someone had, it's a two-week pay period, but 30 hours or more of overtime in a two-week pay period. Now, some people like overtime, some people don't, you know, and we don't want to lose staff or burn out people. If we do that, we find ourselves in an even worse situation, you know, than we were in.
2:05:50 So part-time staff were working the balance of the hours that ESTA is short. While some people are willing to pitch in and work more than they signed up for, the scheduling person reports that many people are eager to get back to a lesser amount of hours. An accommodating request for time off has been a particular challenge, especially since historically we've been able to grant those, and so it's difficult when drivers, you know, that are committed to two days a week and are...
2:06:18 Working three or four come to us and ask for a day off. You know, we kind of expect it. We want to do it for them. We realize that a long-term solution must be found. Achieving a stable and growing workforce will require shifts in company culture at all locations. And we've been compiling myself, the new interim director, John Robertson, the Mammoth Operations Supervisor, Chris Paul Escher, the bishop.
2:06:45 Operations Supervisor. We've been compiling observations. We've been talking to drivers. We've been trying to figure out how to keep the good people we have and how to get more good people in. So we have been discussing a number of creative ideas pertaining to recruiting and staff incentives.
2:07:07 But as all this is happening, we still have a shortage. We felt it was important to determine the best use of Esther driver resources to reduce burnout and to increase job satisfaction. We don't want to lose anyone because we're working them too much. Currently there, so I brought this update to the board, the staffing level.
2:07:27 And we talked about two routes that had the lowest ridership. We were thinking if we could do something to relieve the burden on our drivers and to show them even if we can't get everyone to the amount of shifts and hours that they want, what can we do that would have the least amount of impact that would show them that we're making an effort and we see what they're doing? And so we discussed with the board the limited route and the June Lake Summer Shuttle. The June Lake Summer Shuttle
2:07:57 Had a change of service this year. We don't have a lot of numbers on how that's going yet. However, the limited has historically, you know, very poor ridership. And when I looked back through the service review plans that our board approves,
2:08:17 You know, twice a year. I saw that the ESTA Board at the March 16, 2018 meeting as part of our six-month service review approved the limited route with a note that said it expected it to be replaced on July 1, by July 1, 2018, and it was anticipated that a suitable turnaround would be in place at that time and service could be provided by the Red Line and Town Trolley buses.
2:08:44 You know, as we know, we don't have that turnaround yet. So the board decided to go ahead and discontinue the limited service. You know, we do have, Town Manager Holler talked about bringing it back for school, and that's certainly something that we're going to talk about at the next board meeting, but, you know, my note was that we were going to talk about that, but hopefully we can do that. But ESTA has...
2:09:10 We're in a driver shortage, so it's not that we don't have buses. It's not that, you know, I mean, overtime is expensive, but I'm not here saying we need more money to run the service. I'm saying that we don't have enough drivers. And, you know, we need to look at how we can get the most people moved and provide the most transit with the resources we have. And the resource that we're short on right now is people.
2:09:38 And one way to keep people is to be, you know, to be kind and to not ask more of them than they should be asked to give. And so I just, I want Town Council to know that ESTA wants to provide all the service we can in Mammoth. It's important to us. We're really trying to think of creative ways to provide service out there without additional drivers. I'm not...
2:10:05 100% certain, you know, what's going on with the turnaround, if that's totally dead or if that could be put into place. If we could get that turnaround put into place over at Woodman, what would happen is we would take the town trolley in the summer or we would take the red line in the winter and just the same driver would just drive up there and do that bit and come back down. And so it would take no additional staff. It would just put just a couple extra miles on the bus.
2:10:32 Just a tiny bit more fuel. And so that is the thing that made sense that was passed on from John Helm. We've been talking a lot about it, and we're really hoping that that can happen so we can just smoothly provide that service without impacting the resource that we're short on, which is people. And so that's kind of...
2:10:58 Where we're at. And if you have questions, I can try to answer them. John Robertson's here is to help answer questions. And Joe has a lot of transit experience and has been driving around looking for alternatives and looking for creative solutions. And whoever's most appropriate would be happy to address any questions you have. So, Linda, you have a question? I do. When you are...
2:11:23 When drivers are working this much over time, are you running into safety standards or safety regulations that prohibit them to work, like, so many hours without a break? I mean, where are you then working within that? We are complying with regulations. So there's regulations about how long a driver can drive in a day, and then there's a certain amount of days. Is it six or seven that they can't work? Yeah, there's a, they can only do. Yeah, John, if you want to come up to the mic and speak, please. Thank you.
2:11:52 I'll let John speak to that, but we are complying with that. So the state has it that you can only work so many hours in a day before you get a rest period, like your night off. It also has how many days you can work and how many hours during the week before you have to take a day off. And we're complying fully with the hours of service rules that the state supplies us.
2:12:20 But a lot of our drivers are getting close to those stuff, so we monitor it accordingly. And did you mention, are we looking at any way to sort of increase the pay grade, increase the base salary, or to try to get more applicants? That would be something that needs to be discussed in closed session with our board. I mean, it's...
2:12:45 It's an obvious thing to look at when you're having a recruiting situation. We have quite a list of other things, too, that I think are going to be helpful, but that is on the list, but it would be a closed session item that needs to be discussed with the board and commented on at the appropriate time. Okay, thanks. Carrie, if I can answer that question. It's on a closed session.
2:13:11 At the next estimating. So it will be discussed in closed session. Go ahead, John, please. I have a favor to ask. The town and the county and some of our regional partners are working on a variety of efforts that are potentially interested in the state of California around the workforce in rural areas such as ours. It would be very helpful as you guys explore
2:13:41 What you think it would take to solve your workforce shortage. If you could report out on some pretty, what the specific things are that are the challenges of getting drivers. For example, is it housing? Is it compensation and pay? Is it some other intangible thing that we don't know about? To the degree to which you can be specific is the degree to which the county and the town and other partners can go to the state.
2:14:08 And advise them. Because the state, I think, potentially has an interest in the workforce in rural parts of the state. And the particular and specific challenges that we have is something that we can potentially be taking to the state to say, we need help here with these things. And then maybe we can get some resources to help out with that. Absolutely. Who should we speak with about that? You can just get in touch with me or Supervisor Corliss. Okay. One thing that I also want to thank the town for is
2:14:38 I'm not, I really, I feel it's important that we have meetings with staff and find out, you know, what it is that we can do to, you know, what could make you like your job? What could make, you know, what's going to help you stick around? And what, and just thinking about experience that, you know, that I've had in my life when I was looking for work or, you know, I've hired a lot of people over the years and what they were looking for. And some of that is, you know,
2:15:06 Historically speaking with people I've known to myself is I like to have a full-time benefited job. And so I'm curious to like reach out to people and find out, you know, if there's some way that we can shift things to provide, you know, more stable hours and better benefits. And the town has, you know, made public comment saying that, you know, they would work with us with that if that was something that was deemed an appropriate thing to do in recruiting.
2:15:34 One challenge that we are facing at ESTA is because John Helm retired, I've been acting, and now we have an interim, we do have a recruitment going, but I think there's also this kind of feeling, it's like, you know, something needs to be done, but when you don't have, like, a permanent director in place, it's, sometimes it's, makes it a little bit, even a little bit more challenging, and so I'm really glad that Joe's been really easy to work with, we're getting along good, and, and, and hopefully,
2:16:04 You know, we can help the board for when we get a permanent director in place, get something going. But there is that challenge as well that I think is noteworthy. And one other thing, you'll be bringing this to the LTC, I'm assuming, right? We will be at, I will be at the, we'll both be at the Mono LTC meeting. So we can do a report on this and we have another agenda item for the Mono LTC as well. Good, okay.
2:16:32 Are there any questions from the public? I guess it could be questions and or comments. Comment, that works. My name is T.J. Chase and I'm a parent of two students, formerly three students that go to the school system here in Mammoth. And since the limited was instituted that one time, I think twice a day actually, my students have written it almost every day.
2:17:04 And just to let you know, taking that away would be, you know, for not just my kids, but if you're ever on the bus at 7.45, 7.47 in the morning, it's almost packed with kids. And it's a great way for them to get into school. It's a great way, it's been a great alternative from the school bus, which they would otherwise have to be down at Snow Creek.
2:17:31 I think seven o'clock or a little bit after seven and then they'd have to drive all throughout town and then they'd eventually get to school and dropped off. So it, you know, it takes off. It also takes that part of the day of just sitting down, which our kids do so much of out of the equation. But it's super important. It's super important to the community members out in Old Mammoth. And so if you're thinking about that, that might be something that you cut.
2:17:57 I would just ask you to think twice. It's been extremely important to me and my family. Both me and my wife work from home, but we, you know, work out in the community and around the area, and sometimes we have to be in other communities, you know, an hour and a half away. And knowing that our kids can safely get on a bus with a safe driver, not sit on the bus for five, you know.
2:18:22 We've been going through transportation issues in Old Mammoth for some time.
2:18:59 There's ridership issues. There's the driver issues. And I don't envy what you guys are challenged and plagued with. I mean, that is an extremely tough situation to have to deal with. I'll echo what TJ said was every day this last school year, there were probably about nine kids on that bus to get to school. I live on red fur.
2:19:24 We have three families alone that we would all walk right down to the bus turnaround where the limited was and hop on that bus and it took them right to school. Invaluable service for us. My wife works full time. I work full time. We don't have the flexibilities of being able to battle traffic and get down to there. And we're not the only ones that are utilizing it. There are many others.
2:19:54 And then, you know, we're also hosting an intern from Columbia for the Mammoth Unified School District this next year, and she's going to need to get to school too, and so we're really hoping that that service continues. To piggyback on the red line extension, which we think that's an extremely valuable idea, I know, John, you and I have had great conversations about
2:20:23 The town really following the vision of what was set forth in the SHARP document for what they have already identified as a public transit hub out in Old Mammoth area to be at Mill City to be able to provide through and through red line service from the mountain all the way to
2:20:46 to a facility or a bus stop up there. I would love to be able to sit down and discuss those points and really open up that conversation again about the red line because it was slated to be turned around on red fur which got a lot of opposition and it wasn't such a great idea going down essentially a single lane street with families and everything else.
2:21:14 I'd really like to urge the Town Council, if there's anything that you guys can do to help the situation of transit in Old Mammoth to work with ESTA and essentially the community members as well. We'd love to be included in this decision and be able to try to come up with viable options to help have service out there. And then not only that, increase and bolster our already great public transit that we have. Thank you. Thank you.
2:21:47 Stacey Corliss, Mono County Board of Supervisors. As Lyle said, this is an issue we've been working on for almost two years now, and I would just urge the ESTA Board, Town Council, and staffs of both
2:22:03 Thank you.
2:22:28 Do I need to...
2:22:59 Does anybody else have any more comments? I do have a comment. Okay. As one of the representatives on the ESTA board, and I missed the last meeting, sorry, but sometimes these are unavoidable. Carrie here was thrown into the quicksand with the departure of John Helm, and she has stood up to the task incredibly, and I just want to give her a public attaboy. I'm happy to help, and I just, one just final.
2:23:31 Just kind of emphasizing point is that we do want to provide the service. And if there's anything that town council can do to get that turnaround in place, it would be very, very easy for us to do. It would be very easy. We could start the day the turnaround was done. Am I right? We could start the day the turnaround was done. We would just start sending the red line in up there.
2:23:51 Double-check the times, all three of us. It wouldn't even put any kind of a delay in the red line or into the town trolley, depending on the seasonality. So if there's anything that any of you could do to get that turnaround in place, you know, we're ready to provide that service. So if I could ask for a quick staff, do you have an update on that turnaround? Yes, we've gone ahead and done some topographic work out there, and we actually have an engineering drawing now that shows a great amount of detail so that the
2:24:17 The Water Board can take a look at that and make an informed decision. I'm going to send this by email to Pat tomorrow, and their next meeting is August 16th, I think. Okay, so August 16th, that turnaround issue is going to be on the agenda for the Mammoth Community Water District. We will request that. That's our request. Okay, so I want to make sure everybody understands that it's going over there, and we need to go over to the Water Board and say, hi, guys, let's be good neighbors with the community. Let's get this thing figured out.
2:24:42 If that can happen, then we can maybe make some progress getting where you're going to be. And unfortunately, I'm not able to attend that meeting. I had a trip planned. Mr. Rye's also not going to be in town that day. So any support that you could provide on behalf of ESTA would be greatly appreciated. If I didn't already have this on my calendar for six months, I would be at that meeting.
2:25:03 I would just request for the LTC that maybe this is something to put on the agenda for the LTC because maybe the LTC could support that. If you guys aren't going to be there, that's something we could drive over to the water board and get a recommendation from the LTC and from the council to say, dear water board, let's make this work. Thank you. I appreciate your support. I have talked to one of the board members on the water board, and I have talked to the head of the water district. And this position that they're currently taking is sort of a flip-flop from the original. Correct me if I'm wrong, Grady.
2:25:33 And the reasons being given for it to me are a little vague and I'm not understanding. So I will be meeting with them again and going to that meeting. We appreciate your support. I'll also mention that the next ESTA board meeting, if anyone wanted to come and make a public comment, it's in Bishop on August 10th at 11 a.m. at the Council, I don't have all my lingo right, but City Hall, what do you call it?
2:26:05 I'm sorry, I'm embarrassed that I don't have that exact correct phrasing, but it's there at the city on Line Street, and if anyone needs a location, you know, feel free to give me a call or send me a message. I can send you the agenda, send you a link to the location. So I want it to be very clear that the red line extension isn't a viable solution for the coming school year here.
2:26:36 for our kids and everything else. That brings up some safety concerns for my kids and the other three or four families that are on Red Fur, particularly if they were to walk a very treacherous narrow part of Old Mammoth Road to get down to a turnaround where it's proposed at Woodman Street in the middle of winter. Not a safe idea. I don't think that's going to be a
2:27:02 A good alternative for our kids to be able to take a bus to that area. Instead, I would like to revisit a conversation that I know I've presented out there for the town council to follow the vision of what was already set forth by the Sharp document in creating a turnaround at Mill City instead of the Woodman Street. This gives a through and through service.
2:27:31 All the way up to the Sherwin's. And it also provides access to infinite recreational hubs up there, both cross-country, mountain biking, skiing, hiking, you name it. Woodman Street does not. It doesn't make sense. It doesn't give
2:28:01 So I urge the town to look at that document to
2:28:31 Reanalyze the turnaround area because I think, again, it's been obvious here tonight that we have to do these things right, right? So your kids, I mean, there would be a bus stop on Old Mammoth Road somewhere, right? Yeah, there would potentially be a bus stop right there at Redford and Old Mammoth. Is there an existing stop there now? Only with the limited service.
2:29:01 Okay. And, you know, we're looking also, there's even two other families that are on that street that are ski team people as well. And if they had route service straight up to Main Lodge, it'd be used quite a bit. You know, I understand we're dealing with small numbers here. I really do. But I think the overall big picture has to be look at the recreational value of providing red line service to
2:29:29 opportunities, recreational opportunities that make sense, not to just in the middle of Old Mammoth where they can't use that as a departure site to go backcountry skiing, to go cross-country skiing, to go mountain biking, to do all these other things. There's no recreational value to those areas. Okay. So anybody else have anything that they would like to add?
2:29:55 Carrie, I would like to echo what Bill Sauser said, and thank you so much for your tireless work, and with, I'm so tickled to meet Joe, and I look forward to some of these issues being resolved once we, once Este gets back to
2:30:17 Well, I guess, actually, you need people. So that's, unless, you know, hopefully people are putting it out there right now and hearing it and they're going, oh, okay, there's a job available and hopefully that your efforts with that are met. So thank you so much for your time. Thank you very much. Okay. So let's see. We are now going to have
2:30:45 A conversation about, let's see, this is going to be going to Haislips, I believe. Hais? Which item are we going to now? We're going to go to item, oh, excuse me. Item three. Yeah, item three. I think item two. Sorry. Sorry about that. Maintenance multi-use paths. There we go. So, Madam Mayor, I'm here this evening at Council's request to provide a brief informational item on our maintenance of our multi-use paths.
2:31:33 Acronym being a MUP, signage in our sidewalks. So the town has approximately 20 miles of paved MUPs, including the Lakes Basin, that are maintained on a daily basis by the Parks Maintenance Department. In addition, the town has a number of various signs related to wayfinding that we'll talk a little bit later. The MUPs range in age from about 1 to 25 plus years and show a wide range of wear and tear, as E.L. has described.
2:32:00 The parks maintenance budget includes an annual allocation of $30,000 for projects that typically fund our MUT program, tennis courts, as we did last year, and our parks, facilities, and ball field maintenance. So that's kind of our contractual service budget. Over the wintertime, staff considers and prioritises these projects.
2:32:21 Our maintenance projects, I want to specifically speak out, not so much our capital projects, but we prioritise and consider these maintenance projects that take into account our staff assessments that we conduct on an annual basis, along with about a two or three month recreation commission process. This past year, the majority of these funds of the $30,000 were spent to repair the community centre tennis courts. I think as the community has realised, they were very much needed.
2:32:50 Due to kind of that significant cracking and kind of really in a situation that weren't really safe to use anymore. In 2016-2017 we spent $50,000, about $57,000 to slurry seal about 9,000 square yards of the path from Sierra Park towards Trails End Park and then we also fog sealed about 33,000 square yards and re-striped the lake space and path.
2:33:15 In regards to sidewalks, restricted gas tax funds, SB1 and one-time allocations are used to fix damaged curbs and gutters and sidewalks that is part of the capital improvement project which is managed by our public works and engineering team. Engineering staff, Hayes, Ron and his crew are in the process of updating our town's maintenance plan for these assets and they include our MUPS sidewalks and our signage that incorporate
2:33:43 As we all understand, different levels of funding for the different levels of required maintenance. Grady, sorry, Hayes could probably talk a little bit more about that. As part of the year-end budget, process staff will be providing council with a list of recommended one-time funding opportunities, and as with last year's process, the list of projects will likely exceed available funding, and council will need to provide direction as to the priority use of these funds.
2:34:09 This would include enhanced funding for maintenance of MUPS, sidewalks and our wayfinding. Council will also need to consider funding currently planned larger capital projects and priorities that were spoken about tonight a little bit about. Staff anticipates coming forward again in October, probably that third meeting with a more defined asset management list of those MUPS, sidewalks and our wayfinding.
2:34:34 Perhaps Hayes can talk a little bit more about the process, the methodology that engineering would apply to evaluating these capital assets. So I didn't know if you wanted to include anything else to that. So the town utilizes a pavement management system to evaluate all of our asphalt assets, includes roads and mops.
2:34:56 It uses a complex set of algorithms to take the use of the facility versus the cost of improvements to really come up with the best benefit for the community and where to allocate our resources. The program allows us to input a number of variables to get an outcome. So if we say we have a budget of, you know, a million dollars, it will tell us how best to spend those resources.
2:35:24 When we are given funding to work on trails projects, we apply that same methodology. We've inputted all of the multi-use paths into our asset management system, and we look to see what the biggest, called bang for the buck. So this last cycle, we put the money into the lake space and path.
2:35:47 Instead of making major repairs to other paths that may seem like they need more work, but the lakes basin path would be prohibitively expensive to replace. By fog sealing that asset, we were able to extend its useful life a number of years, five to ten years right off the bat. So we look at a benefit-cost kind of analysis when we're looking at spending resources on our paths.
2:36:18 That's our presentation. So we're just here before you, just providing you an informational update, telling you we're going to go through that methodology, go through that process, and be back on October 3rd, unless there's any other direction or information that you'd like staff to take into account as part of that process. Thank you. Hearing from Kirk here. Yes. Since I asked for this to be on the agenda, we have over 100 miles of
2:36:44 of roads. We budget $550,000 annually. The roads actually need a million dollars.
2:36:53 Annually. The last three years we have been able to take excess TOT and spend about $900,000 to a million dollars. So our roads are, for the last three years, are done. But in our budgetary process, we're underfunding that about $400,000. In relationship to our 20 miles of
2:37:17 Bike Trails. Let me first of all compliment the town staff. If we look at Trails End Park, that is flawless. I mean, it is really, I mean, it's as smooth as silk down there. I mean, it's really nice. But when you look at the trails from
2:37:37 Mammoth, Old Mammoth Road and from Sierra Park Road down towards the Water District. Mammoth Creek Park to Commerce Drive has 75 cracks ranging from one half to 12 inches. So that had...
2:37:54 Definitely need some work. From Sierra Park Road parallel to Meridian Boulevard, which was slurry coated, it's in pretty good shape, very small cracks in it, a quarter to one half inch cracks, and so there are 12 of them. If you walk Sierra Park Road parallel to 203, which was slurry coated, it's in pretty good shape, but there are 38 cracks.
2:38:24 One half inch to a quarter inch. And so that's also in pretty good shape. If you walk Shady Reft's path from the tunnel at 203, or from Shady Reft to 203, just in that very short area, there is a quarter inch to eight inch cracks. There are 13 of them.
2:38:53 You know, eight inch. We're talking about, and when you hit it with a bicycle, I mean, your teeth are going to be jarred. And if you're in a wheelchair, which I did meet a couple of people out there and had some discussions with them, it's very difficult. From the campground to Shady Rest Park, this is another really good section of trails. There were ten one-half to one-half inch cracks out there.
2:39:23 My concern is from Old Mammoth, or Meridian, the tunnel there, down towards the water district, there is some substantial cracks there, and at the bottom of that, there's all these little whoop-de-doos. So if you watch somebody riding a bike down there, you'll see that they're bouncing along. That's approximately 800 feet.
2:39:49 I have sat down with staff. They said it's $78 per linear foot to fix that. So if you multiply that out, you'll see that it's about $58,000 that would take to do that particular section. And that's the section that I'm most worried about because that's where people pick up speed as they come down the hill, either direction.
2:40:16 What I'm suggesting is that when we have our budget discussion coming up very soon on this quarterly basis to look at the excess TOT, that that be included in that discussion as to the allocation of those funds. Also, yeah, I can go through the
2:40:41 The cracks down towards the water district, I walked that this morning. There are 39 of them just in that small section I'm describing, and some of them are 14 inches across. So I did go out and measure them all just to make sure that I can...
2:41:00 I have sat down with staff. I have contacted Black Gold Asphalt to find out what their cost is. Staff is projecting $13 a square foot. Black Gold is looking at about $9 a square foot. So, you know, I think it's something, a budget discussion that needs to, or we need to add it to our budget discussion when the fourth quarter
2:41:30 TOT is being discussed. That's all I have. I'm impressed at your tenacity about counting over 200 cracks, so good work on that. Does anybody else have something? Does that make him a crackhead? It makes him very dedicated. So, I mean, thanks for bringing this up. It's something that obviously with the trails program we've been looking at for a long time.
2:41:58 I think there's two things that with this agenda item I think would be helpful. One is, as you mentioned, it sounds like you guys have got a very good scientific, technical way of analyzing asphalt assets. And I would think that we should take the asphalt assets that are referred to in this item. Let's put those on a track that's associated.
2:42:16 Appropriate with asphalt. The signage stuff, I think I would like to be talking about those with the next item as part of the signage assets so we're getting, you know, like things in the right places. And I think that it would be helpful to understand
2:42:33 Staffs, your assessment of those asphalt assets as they relate to all the work that Kirk's done to go out to look at their relative state of disrepair so that we can be looking at these things in the capital investment or the maintenance improvement into that to be able to look at it systemically so we can understand because my understanding is the construction of those
2:42:54 Sections of Path that Kirk's referring to, they may not have gotten the kind of the base and the aggregate work that the Lakes Basin Path did, and we may be bumping up to a situation with the tennis courts where the underlying infrastructure, you know, we could be throwing money at it because it's going to keep coming back and biting us. So I think it would be really helpful to get an understanding of what the state of the capital asset is. So when we start, Kirk, looking at what kind of resources to put into it, we're getting it on a sustainable.
2:43:22 thing, a sustainable program, we know how to invest in it. We absolutely need a
2:43:28 20 miles of trail that we don't have a pavement management program for. So I totally support what you're suggesting. But I do think that for budget discussions coming up with the XSTOT, we need to specifically address that particular issue. Sure. So when we're looking what that investment is, investment's part of a larger thing. We understand we're doing this now, but what it's going to look like down the road. The other thing I would add is the trails program's got, I think, 38 trail counters.
2:43:57 That are out. And I think the first year-over-year data will be available. I know they're making a presentation at the Trails Committee meeting, but that might be something in terms of allocating resources, bang for buck kinds of things. Staff should be able to have a good sense of where the traffic is, where the most use is happening on the multi-use pass system. I really encourage staff to start absorbing that data.
2:44:21 And putting that in, I think it's something I want to, I'd like to be talking with MLT about, talking about to Mammoth Lakes Recreation also. This is the only, you know, physical presence we have on the ground that's telling us what kind of activity is happening out on these assets. And I think it'd be a very good idea to be encouraging staff to, for all of us to be consuming that data to say, this is where everybody's going.
2:44:42 It's going to have a lot of utility for a lot of other policy decisions as well down the road. But I thank you for bringing this up. I think it's going to be a great thing to get into some sort of an asphalt management program for these facilities going forward. But the signage piece, I'm hoping that's kind of a different discussion. We can talk about that in the next item. Okay. Do we do a crack seal program on the mops? When we have funding, we do. Okay. Yeah, when we have the... I mean, outside of the overlay stuff, we...
2:45:10 As we would do with our roads. Yeah, we do crack sealing and you've kind of alluded to a problem that's an older asphalt that continues to shrink. So even when we fill the cracks the next year, they come back. Right. It's the same as airport road. It's a classic example of block cracking.
2:45:31 Okay, so do you need direction from us? If I'm hearing you right, you'd like staff to return with a description of, we do have an asset management program, so we will bring that forward and describe what that looks like. We can provide some alternatives of what a maintenance program would look like as a function of a number of different variables and provide some options to council as to a path forward. Yeah. Stu. Or Hayes.
2:45:57 What do we do? So in this case, we had a council member go out and ride all the trails. What do we do on a regular basis to inspect the trails to see to it? Because outside of John's point, the ones that get the most use need service. We don't want to lose any of the miles of trails. So how are we inspecting them on a regular basis to ensure that doesn't happen, that we're doing at least the minimum necessary to maintain the asset?
2:46:27 Yeah, it's a great question. I do want to say that the new hybrid position that the council funded last year is the majority of that time is dedicated to the trails, to the hard surface trails. So Zeke, who comes out of public works in wintertime, is kind of our trails designated person. So he is, there you go, I mean, from additional funding and, you know, job responsibilities, his oversight is those trails. So he's on those trails pretty much every day.
2:46:50 As far as the second question, I think that's probably Ron and his crew in regards to... And I can speak to that. So we use the exact same methodology we use for our road network. And depending on the severity of the winter, we will review the roads on an annual or biannual basis. We use the exact same methodology for reviewing the roads on a year-after-year basis so we have a consistent set of data that we enter into our program.
2:47:16 Kirk, I commend your work. I know how much work it takes to do this. And if you'd seen me before, I would teach you how to geo-reference your data so I could just not have to spend staff time later to do the same work. But we use a very specific methodology for assessing asphalt. And based on the data input, the output will tell us how best to treat the asphalt. Unfortunately, we have a very similar type of asphalt that fails the exact same way on the older paths.
2:47:45 We struggle trying to find a solution because there frankly isn't a way to fill the cracks without them coming back the next year. The only solution is ultimately to move and replace. And that goes back to the capital inventory thing. I mean, if things are getting to the end of their useful life and we start looking at the maintenance costs to bring them to a certain level of service, at some point we've got to start saying this infrastructure has failed, it's done its useful life, we've got to start replacing the stuff. One other thing I'd add is the
2:48:15 At the Trails Committee, I think next week, they're talking about the Trail Patrol, which is a program in the Trail System Master Plan, which is an effort to get more bodies out on the ground to do this kind of analysis. That might be another useful tool to help you. And they've all got the geo-reference stuff. They could tie it back into your databases. One more quick question on the maintenance. We have several trails that we have removed snow of for years, from the elementary school to the trails residents.
2:48:45 Hold up better, the ones with the snow and ice on them or the ones where it's been removed? Yeah. Because they could help us in determining removal efforts in the future. Right. Yep. We do keep track of that, and different asphalt mixes hold up better than others, and if you use the appropriate type of mix, knowing that it's going to be removed, it may compromise the smoothness of the asphalt, but you'll get better longevity.
2:49:12 So we do take that into account when we're looking at these things. Thank you. The two trails from Sierra Park down to Trails End Park, both of those were slurry coated two years ago, and they've held up really well. Now, you know, because we do plow those, you can see areas where the slurry coat has been, you know.
2:49:36 You know, damaged. But right now, those two particular trails are in really good shape. But some of the other trails need some real work. Any more on that? Then we will go on to Agenda Item 3, Municipal Signage and Wayfinding Project Update and Implementation Strategy.
2:50:22 No, I'll go ahead and kick off. I'm joined with John Urdi. We'll tag team this a bit. So before you do is an update on the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Wayfinding and Community Messaging Program. It's been some time since this item has been before Council, so I'm going to go back through some history here.
2:50:45 This project was identified in the general plan. It's a goal of the plan to develop and implement a town-wide wayfinding system, and an action item was to prepare a town-wide directional signage and wayfinding plan. In 2011, there was a scope of work and RFP approved by the Planning Commission and the Town Council that was ultimately issued.
2:51:08 A consultant was selected and the work was funded through the LTC, a planning grant and Mammoth Mountain ski area. The consultant worked to develop a master plan that was ultimately accepted by the planning commission in October of 2012. About the same time, staff put together an application for Measure U funding to complete the engineering of the master planning.
2:51:36 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:51:46 Through the planning process, Measure U was identified to be the ultimate funding source for the entire project. If you look through the accepted documents, you'll see that there was a program in place for an annual allocation for wayfinding signage going all the way from 2012, which was actually approved in 2013, all the way through the end of 2014.
2:52:09 Staff returned to the Measure U Committee in fall of 2013 with an application to implement the first phase of the pedestrian and vehicular component of the wayfinding program, but was ultimately designed. At that time, MLR was kind of coming forward, and they were reserving funds, ultimately moving it into that pot. Since then, Town has...
2:52:34 Staff have been looking for other alternative ways to fund this program. We've looked at a number of grant programs and really haven't been able to find a pot of money that really met the intent of this program or met the intent of a grant program. John and I have been discussing this project.
2:52:52 Since then. And he's identified some resources through his board to help bring this project back to life. And we've been discussing that over time. However, a long period of time had gone in since the planning exercise had occurred. Staff engaged MLTPA using LTC funds to revisit the planning process and make the necessary updates to the signage program, identifying the things that have changed throughout town.
2:53:20 We also had MLTPA work on a sign clutter program. So once the wayfinding program was implemented, we can go throughout town and pull down all the conflicting messaging, all the cluttering signs, and basically have a clean system that is providing clarity to our visitors as to how to navigate the town. So working from the funding opportunity that John has provided, we started to work on what
2:53:51 So the vehicular signage.
2:54:19 From the master plan, it's consistent with, you know, the look and feel throughout town. It's core 10.
2:54:25 The signs are, you know, MUTCD standards, retro-reflectivity is all met, all the basic requirements for signage to be on the highway system. They kind of match the gateway monument. They look very similar to the trail system. The idea is that this is complementary to existing systems, and a user will identify them as municipal in a wayfinding program, but will also, when transitioning from the trails, will have, you know, a clear understanding of
2:54:54 The differences and will have consistency in navigating the systems. This shows the types of pedestrian signs. Many of them are placed on existing light standards and existing infrastructure to kind of mitigate, minimize the amount of poles and so forth we have to send the ground. This also shows the kiosk on the right-hand side. It's a three-sided piece of infrastructure that has
2:55:21 An opportunity to provide not only wayfinding, but additional community messaging or special events. And there's also an opportunity there for marketing. The district monuments were always envisioned to be...
2:55:35 Driven by the development community as a way of identifying their part of town. Outside of the original downtown monument that was approved with the 2012 Measure U application, the rest of the monuments were always envisioned to be paid for by the development community. And again, these monuments are codified or were accepted by planning commission and any developer moving forward would have to follow these designs.
2:56:05 I mentioned the banner program, and I'll be honest, this is kind of a pet project. On the corner of Old Mammoth Road and 203, I believe we have an opportunity to use the wayfinding program designs to improve this intersection and come up with a consistent banner program so that when our visitors are coming to town, the first thing they see is a high-quality product that presents the information to the community.
2:56:34 We would definitely have to make some infrastructure changes here. This picture doesn't really demonstrate it, but if you're traveling through to the mountain, that street light actually blocks a number of the banners, so you're not even getting clear messaging at this time. This is something I presented to the MLT board as an opportunity that wasn't really envisioned in the program. However, this issue wasn't
2:57:00 Really a problem at the time that this master plan was created. So a preliminary budget, a thorough budget was created when this master plan was put together. We've gone back through that, added some cost escalators for the steel and so forth, and also modified the types of signage that are included. We're looking at a budget for phase one, which would include everything in town, the lakes basin and Inua craters.
2:57:32 For about $430,000, $440,000. We've pulled out Red's Meadow. At this time, we don't have ownership of that road. We need a number of approvals. And frankly, we're going to go through there and rebuild the whole road. So we feel it's better to wait to implement the Red's Meadow signage until after we've gotten through that program. A lot of the messaging takes people to Red's Meadow. It gets them to where they need to be right now.
2:57:57 The Reds Meadow signage is actually down in the valley. So we're still directing people to where they need to be at Mammoth Mountain Ski Area to get their tickets and get on the shuttle. Future phases.
2:58:11 Banner program, banner structure, we're estimating approximately $60,000. Airport signage, about 70,000. District monuments, again, at the cost of development community, about $275,000. And kiosks, while there was a program that was put in place back when this master plan was developed, I don't think that's completely accurate now. I think things have changed. So I just gave...
2:58:36 Per item cost at about $8,000. We would work with, you know, Chamber and MLT and whoever else was interested in installing those to place them where the people are now. So with that, I'm going to turn it over to John and kind of talk about his board's direction and his participation in the program. Thanks. Good evening. John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Just to go back a little bit, back in 2015-16 when we actually had a surplus above and beyond the TOT budget for the year,
2:59:05 MLT started putting money away each year. So that year, you'll remember, I think we had $11.3 million budget. We came in at $15.7. Mammoth Lakes Tourism typically got to eat what we killed, and we were able to keep about $800,000, $900,000 of that overage. So over the years, we built up that reserve. Back in 16, 17, we started to earmark those dollars, and this was one of the projects that we had earmarked.
2:59:29 We set aside $350,000 towards this program. A big piece of it was we really felt that even though we're a small four square mile town, two roads that way, two roads that way, we have a lot of new people coming here that don't recognize where they need to go. And with safety issues like where's the hospital, we felt it was really an important piece for our new visitors. And I think that's even more...
2:59:49 We've maintained that $350,000. We've moved some other things around in the earmarks, but we've maintained that over the last few years. Based on the presentation that Hayes went through this morning or this afternoon with our board, we're completely in
3:00:16 In agreement with where we're going, I think the one thing that we would be really looking to see is that that banner placement on Old Mammoth Road and Main Street goes into phase one. I think if you look at it right now, it looks a little bit of a, it's a little bit disappointing when you drive into town and you've got
3:00:31 Stakes going each way and maybe the banner straight, maybe it's not, maybe it's three by eight, maybe it's four by 20. So I think if we can get a consistent message out there recognizing that there are some other infrastructure things that can change to actually have that be a nice presence when you come into town, I think that was the one thing that my board looked at was we're in agreement with phase one, but we'd like to see that that $60,000 piece put into put into phase one as well. So with that in mind, our board did vote today to
3:00:58 Finalize the commitment of the $350,000. We have that money in CDs right now. In fact, I have two CDs that are renewing August 9th. I've actually put the call in for those to come back into the account, and we're willing to write a check as soon as possible to keep the program going. I think the timeline of trying to get something in for next summer, plan it this winter, get it in the ground for the spring and summer, is really something that we're fully supportive of as well. Thanks, John.
3:01:29 We're looking for town council concurrence, and if we did have concurrence, staff would work with MLT to try to close the funding gap. We believe there's a few partners we can tap on the shoulder to help us out with this program. Assuming we can close that gap, staff would work to finalize the budget and the scope for phase one, including the banners, and any direction we receive from council tonight. We would work to complete a bid package and specifications this winter.
3:01:56 We believe the bulk of the work is really just managing the shop drawings, making sure that all the signage that's being sent out for fabrication is correct and accurate. That's a significant amount of staff time. And given our work program in the summer, we believe that really needs to be a winter work program for our staff. Assuming that we can pull all those pieces into place, we believe we could actually get this project moving in springtime and deliver this project early summer of 2019.
3:02:25 Assuming all the pieces fell into place. My comments are make it happen. Okay. Can we add, do we? I concur. Well, can we do some questions to staff or how would I proceed, Madam Mayor? We can ask questions. Okay. Good. So a couple things. Just some things for council to be aware of that enhance the value of this.
3:03:00 I appreciate the
3:03:29 Red's Meadow piece. However, I think that the mountain is getting close to closing the land exchange. And I'm going to assume that when the NAT piece closes, that this wayfinding program is going to be articulated as part of that project. There's no reason we should assume that that's not going to happen, right? Because that would make sense. I would further add that this is supported by the Walk, Bike, Ride program.
3:03:57 It's the labs project. I had a very good conversation with the forest supervisor last week. I advised her that the Sierra Nevada Conservancy had spent $200,000 on that planning out for the lakes basin and that for some reason that thing sat on the shelves perhaps at the direction of the prior forest district ranger in Mammoth Lakes. She thought that would be perhaps a missed opportunity. She's very much looking forward to bringing that forward. That's an accepted document of the town council. There's a wayfinding component in that executive summary.
3:04:25 That further supports doing this. I just want to make sure that that rationale is covered. The standards, when you get the final shop drawings, you implement this, this will go into the Public Works section? To be numbered. To be numbered, okay. But this will be memorialized in the Public Works Standards Manual, which would be very important going forward. I think it would be helpful for the Council, as you guys do, to see a map of where the proposed...
3:04:51 Where the proposed things are going to go. So we can line that up with the walk-bike-ride scope. So we're looking at the full extent of what we're doing here. We're just consistent with the walk-bike-ride values. That would be helpful. I think I'm going to ask kind of a provocative question. I appreciate the provocative nature of the question. There's a monument on the intersection where this banner thing that your board was looking at that I'm not sure if it was ever permitted.
3:05:16 I think there might be some typos in the plaque that's on that monument, and I'm wondering if you could perhaps advise Council at some point, as you look forward to putting in place an appropriate welcoming signage situation, and I'm assuming that that's not going to be a challenge. I can engage the Ancient Honorable Society of E. Clampus Vitis on that issue. Yes, and I think with all due respect and appreciation for their efforts, but I think at this point that intersection is, I think MLT is properly identifying the
3:05:45 The importance of that intersection in our community, and we all believe in spell checks. That could have been intentional, by the way. No editorial thing for me. I think the final thing I would add is that I went through Banff in March, and that this program, you know, we're right in there with that. And I think that it's very...
3:06:12 And the clutter program is included. I think that was directional from Council previously, so we're not going to proceed with a program like this. We're not going to just put another iteration of signage out there without taking out the garbage. And I think there's a good plan to do that. I'm assuming that would be part of this going forward as well, right? If the money to do this will figure out where to pull all the junk out of the ground. And the maintenance piece, I'll save for deliberation, but I commend. And I think this is exactly the kind of thing when the community wants to see MLT in the town working on these things that...
3:06:40 Really enhance the product that we have here that we're selling, and I just want to commend you guys for bringing this forward. And I will add, John, I have this document available with all the locations and signage and messaging. If anybody wants it, it's, you know, some light reading. I can put this out. It's too big to email, but if you want to swing by, I can give you a flash drive or, you know, we can make arrangements to get you a copy or photocopy it. John, I concur with what you said about Banff. One of the, right before I left Jackson Hole, we had redone all of the
3:07:08 The signage in Jackson Hole and out to Wilson. And it just, it makes a huge difference. I mean, it's so welcoming and it's so user-friendly and it just looks clean and it looks, it just really adds a whole level of professionalism to a resort area like ours that I look forward to. Kirk, are you okay? No, I'm very supportive. You've got everything you need from us. Sounds like I have consensus. Last thing I'll add.
3:07:42 Is that the lesson that we learned, I'm sorry, Madam, how do you want to, I mean, I, okay. If you learned the lesson, I want to hear. Well, the lesson that we learned from the trail system signage program, which came through the American Recovering Reinvestment Act, so it was a very significant federal grant to put the signs on the ground. We still have not addressed the maintenance.
3:08:05 And the updates of that program. And I have to say, I don't know what my fellow council members would say, but I would say we cannot move forward. And you've done a great job. You've identified the clutter. We've got the naming conventions in place. We need to have a program, a fund.
3:08:20 In place so that we can do the maintenance on it. We can update the naming conventions because, John, it's not going to do you any good if we do this beautiful program put on the ground as it ages and things happen and we can't update it. So my only thing before I can fully support this is for staff to come back to council with a recommendation that's going to cover the wayfinding stuff but also the Mammoth Lakes Trail System signage so that we have a way to
3:08:45 Reliably maintain and update these things as things go forward. That's one thing I would request from the Council, that we make sure that that recommendation is in place before we go forward with this. We'll incorporate that into what would come back to Council in the programming. Absolutely, yes, to make sure that it's covered. And maybe, John, you can help me with this, but I do know in today's meeting there was some talk about that there's some...
3:09:10 There's some things that we can't actually, someone used the example that we can't put Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, but we can put Eagle Lodge if you... Yeah, and that's more of Hayes' world, but yeah, it has to do with Caltrans and the commercialization of namings, resort names or company names. It has to be more generic. And the naming conventions that John was speaking to are consistent with the Outdoor Advertising Act, so we took that into account when putting together the program.
3:09:39 Okay, awesome. Thank you. So, with that, you just need consensus, I think. Do you want any public comment or? Oh, yeah. Do we do public? Oh, public comment. I just have a question about the thing at the intersection of Main Street and Old Mammoth. Would it be visible from all angles, not just the angle coming into town? It would really likely be mostly visible from the
3:10:12 The budget I'm proposing includes some engineering time to look at alignments, visibility. We don't have a plan yet, so we're going to have to go through an exercise to see what's the best fit for that intersection in dealing with the constraints that we have with everything there. In that case, are you going to be looking at not just
3:10:42 An on-the-ground potential banner, but an over-the-street type of banner? No. Take any of those on the ground? On the ground, realigning, looking at all the infrastructure in place on the corner, realigning it to get the best views from people coming into town, providing lighting that is not obtrusive, some stuff that doesn't impact, you know, Footloose and their business. There's a lot of things in play in that corner, so we'll have to go through an exercise. Any other questions, comments?
3:11:14 Okay. So you just need consensus? Yeah, consensus is fine on that because this will be coming back to council before we would actually go out and spend any money. So it would be coming back to you in that process, incorporating the comments we've heard regarding maintenance as well as some of the other elements of the program, i.e. I get enough from you. I know we're in consensus here. So moving on to the consent agenda. Yeah, we're only to consent.
3:11:46 Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of July 18, 2018. Number six, adopt the resolution amending the local conflict of interest code. Seven, waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance amending municipal code. Title one, general provisions. Eight is award construction contract that Grady brought up earlier for the Mammoth Creek Gap closure project.
3:12:14 And then number nine, accept payment approval report number 18-63, accept payment approval report number 18-63, accept payment approval report number 18-64, accept payment approval report number 19-02, accept payment approval report number 19-03, and accept payment approval report number 19-04. And Grady, at the beginning of the meeting, you said that
3:12:43 Grady, you said that number eight, we're keeping this on the consent agenda even though? That's correct. There's no reason to pull it off. I just wanted to go ahead and announce the number and frankly celebrate the fact that we got a good number and it's a good project moving forward. Thank you. I'll second the motion. I guess then I should make the motion. Well, you just read it. You're making a motion as read. I wanted to see if anything needed to be removed first.
3:13:13 I'll second. Okay. There still wasn't a motion. No, Kirk made a motion. Oh, okay, you did make a motion. Oh, okay, good. And that's seconded. Okay. Moving on to policy matters. We had to vote on it. Oh, excuse me. I'm sorry. It's only 9.30. Roll call, please. Councilmember Salcido. Yes. Councilmember Staff. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Yes. Yes. With that, we will move on to policy matters number 11.
3:13:44 Which is, ma'am, at the Yosemite Airport Policy Discussion. Do you need to stretch your legs? Okay. Are you kidding? If I stretch my legs and we take a break, we won't get out of here till midnight. Okay. Well, then we'll just go ahead and dive right in. And this is...
3:14:09 Great. Thank you. You Dan or Grady? Yes, I do have a brief PowerPoint. It does not contain any new information that's not already in your packet. It's more of a guideline so that the public can follow along and you can. Brian has a few paper copies that they'll hand out. But again, there's no new information there. It's just really meant as a guide as we do this discussion, if you will. There are a couple of copies up here if anybody wants a printed copy of it, but it is up on the screen.
3:14:40 The first slide is the picture this morning, a little after 9 o'clock. It was not as smoky as it was the last couple of days, but it didn't look too bad. Again, I would just like to remind everybody that there are three cameras at the airport. You can always take a quick look at the weather and see what we have there. The next slide is really the airport layout plan. I just want to focus on this for a second. It was conditionally approved in August of 2014, so it's already four years old.
3:15:12 And we have taken very little action on this plan except for rehabbing the West General Aviation apron and a couple of other minor things, some other projects that are ongoing.
3:15:23 As I talk through these things, you'll see that this is the nature of the airport, is that it will change. Everything's going to change. It's going to change rapidly. It's going to change in directions we have no idea about when we get onto air service, aircraft, pilots, and everything else. But the ALP is as it is. Just to orient yourself to the bottom there, it's not shown, but US 395, of course, is along the bottom. The runway is clearly east-west, runway 927.
3:15:49 The airport layout plan is important as a planning document. It is not a program. It's not a funded program. It's not something we're absolutely going to do. The ALP is meant to be a guideline for the next 10 to 20 years. We put things on there that we think we'd like to do.
3:16:08 By getting them on an approved AOP, that means they're eligible for FAA funding. That's really all it is. As an example, it shows a runway extension. That's great. It may happen someday, may not. The orange areas around the outside, to the left, the top, and to the right, are Forest Service land that we'd like to acquire and make part of the airport.
3:16:26 But that's not necessarily going to happen. It's just a planning document. What doesn't show great really well because it's not colored, but the east end of the runway is actually on a lease from LA Department of Water and Power. So as we address all these things, keep this in mind. If somebody looks at this and says, well, you're going to do that.
3:16:44 That doesn't mean that necessarily. But it's a visioning document. Airports are something you plan for 20, 30, 50 years, not for five years. So the document has to be far-reaching. It has to include things that some people may not like, but that's okay. Again, it's a planning document. It doesn't require even a CEQA or a NEPA review to get an ALP approved. That's the level of documentation. It's a picture. I mean, I've said that enough times. I can't overstate that fact because we get criticized a lot for what we're going to do.
3:17:13 That's certainly not the case with an ALP. In the presentation, the airports and air service, as we all know, have been a point of discussion in the Eastern Sierra for decades, and as our mayor and others know, there are a lot of airlines come and gone, a lot of air services come and gone. The airport started out in the 40s, as most did, as a military airstrip, and then it grows into what it is today.
3:17:40 If you want to read back on the history, it was privately owned. It was purchased by Mono County. We ended up with it. It's gone through many name changes. And again, I'm just trying to emphasize the changing nature of airports and air service. Recently, however, there have been a renewed effort by a number of stakeholders to work together for a regional approach in an effort to identify and implement.
3:18:02 Mid- and long-term strategies with the goal of enhancing air service opportunities. I wanted to read that to get it exactly right. We've been talking to Inyo County, we've been talking to Mammoth Resorts, we've been talking with MLT, and the whole goal and direction from this town council under comments from ESCOG and the MIWOG has been how do we work together to improve regional air service? A couple of actions that have been taken. We actually
3:18:31 Executed an outlying statement of intent. Town Council heard that on January 17th of this year. And all that did, and I described it well back then, is it didn't, it wasn't a commitment to spend any money or do anything. It was a commitment to work together. It was a commitment to have conversations with ESCOG, with our other partners, with Mono County, with Inyo County, and see if there wasn't some way we could move forward.
3:18:54 The second point on here is airport sponsors and air service. I want to draw a very clear distinction between airport issues and air service issues. Airport issues are managed by the Town of Mammoth Lakes. We are the airport sponsor for Mammoth Yosemite Airport.
3:19:10 In the airport sponsor world, that doesn't mean that you own the airport. It doesn't mean that you necessarily operate the airport. It means that you're the sponsor in FAA's eyes. You're the one that's the liaison to FAA. That's how you get funding. That's how you get projects approved. That's how you move things forward. Any other kind of entity can be an airport sponsor.
3:19:30 We could be an airport sponsor of Bishop Airport, as an example. We don't have to own it. We may have an operating agreement, but that's it. But as long as in the eyes of FAA, we're the designated airport sponsor, we're who they talk to.
3:19:42 Air service, on the other hand, is something that MLT and, frankly, Mammoth Resorts helps manage us. It's in MLT's contract to manage air service for the region. I think you've had some good updates recently from MLT about the air service coming this winter. Later on, I'll ask John if he has any updates from that from our last few discussions because, again, there are changes all the time, especially with the scheduled charter service that we have. So that's the air service issues.
3:20:10 For Bishop Airport, just as a note, Inyo County is the airport sponsor for Bishop Airport. So Inyo County is the one that talks to FAA about planning, design, and construction issues. Current airport summary, just very briefly, because we could be on airports for days. We could do a workshop that lasts three days, and we won't cover it all. It's a very complex issue, so I'm going to give a brief overview.
3:20:33 And I invite members of the public, yourselves, everybody, to ask all the questions. Ask them by email, call, do anything, because a clear understanding is really important. Mammoth Yosemite is approximately 246 acres. It is within the town boundary. It is an island out there. LAFCO doesn't usually do islands, but because of its critical nature and the fact that the town owned it, they allowed an island in this case.
3:20:59 It's actually owned, again, by three parties. We own the biggest chunk of it. Forest Service owns some pieces, and especially on the south boundary next to 395. And then LA Department of Water and Power owns the east end of our runway. Just as a footnote on that, we are already engaging with the LAWP to see what it would take to bring that piece under town ownership. I'll address that later.
3:21:22 If you recall, Bishop has a, in your county, has a long-term lease in perpetuity, frankly, it's an easement for operation of Bishop Airport. We'd like to have the same arrangement or even own the eastern end of our runway, which is something that FAA certainly encourages. Bishop Airport, and I did talk to...
3:21:41 Back and forth with Kevin Crunchy a few times. We had a meeting about two weeks ago, and I also had an email with him as late as this morning telling him, I'm not going to talk a lot about the detail of Bishop Airport. I'm going to give some basic data. I'll answer what questions I have. But most of those questions he asked, they may be referred to a future, hopefully, joint meeting at the end of August, which the town manager and Kevin are trying to set up.
3:22:05 Just a footnote, if you haven't heard, his last day is August 10th, and he's already engaging Clint Quilter to take over that role and make sure that we don't lose any speed on this. Bishop Airport is approximately 800 acres, and again, that's an easement on land owned by LA Department of Water and Power. Just to give kind of an idea of relative sizes of airports and whether that's important or not, frankly, we have plenty of room at 246 acres to do most of what we want to do.
3:22:33 We could certainly use some more land, especially to the north. It's my opinion that anything south, frankly, of Airport Road doesn't meet the Forest Service mission. I would have to convince them of that. But with the road there, it doesn't really lend itself to being part of the forest. And we have an idea that someday maybe that could be within our boundaries. Bishop Airport is 800 acres.
3:22:58 It doesn't mean that they can take that much more traffic, however, and my example is Lindbergh Field that I worked in in San Diego. It's the largest single runway, the busiest single runway airport in the country, 663 acres, and they put 20 million passengers through that. So don't let acreages, you know, distract you from the real mission here. It's really not that important. As long as you have the minimum to do what you need to, we're okay. Current air service, again,
3:23:27 We've had recent updates from MLT, and I'll just ask John any updates since the last couple of weeks. John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Nothing really new to update. We did have a joint press release that went out with United Airlines earlier this week. They are working on getting us into their ski program. They're planning on doing quite a bit of a big push behind that, which is going to be fantastic. We are still working on JetSuiteX, which is really our next step. Right now we're looking at Burbank.
3:24:00 We're looking at adding Orange County through John Wayne Airport. There's potential of adding Oakland, and there's potential of adding Carlsbad. We won't be able to really figure out Carlsbad until probably another month, so I'm anticipating that we won't have much news on...
3:24:18 JetSuite X at least for another month. Our plan is to come back at the September 5th MLT board meeting and hopefully have a much better handle on what our options are. I think it would be in a perfect world. We would add Oakland and we would add Carlsbad as well as Orange County, but I think we have to look at the benefits of each one of those as well as the budgets that we have to work with to be able to afford the subsidies. So really nothing else concrete. There is a carrier out of
3:24:44 Carlsbad that has been working for quite a few years to get actually into service called California Pacific Airlines. We have conversations with them as well. They would be running a 44 passenger plane which would go to the commercial terminal. Throughout all of this, Pat Foster and I have talked quite a bit about just the ability to utilize the general aviation because JetSuiteX is great because they go to the general aviation and they can divert to Bishop because they're unscheduled, but there are ramp challenges and
3:25:13 With the increased traffic that Pat's going to see this coming season and beyond, we want to make sure that it works with his schedule. So right now, looking at the tentative times for if we go with Burbank and Orange County, they're at 4 o'clock and 440 in the afternoon, which works for Pat. And I think if we go with Oakland and or Carlsbad, they would have to be really kind of first thing in the morning because of the traffic that comes in throughout the course of the day. So we'll continue to work with him on the timing to make sure that we're not signing up for something that we can't handle.
3:25:42 But at this point, I think we've got some great options. We've got some great connections. The united connections between Los Angeles, Denver, and San Francisco are amazing. And just the fact that we've got 57 perfect connections through Denver alone. I brought it up at the board meeting today. I ran into Kathy Cage at the bank yesterday, and she was saying, this is great. My sister lives in Columbus, Ohio, and there's a direct flight right through Denver.
3:26:09 To come right here. So I think it's really going to make it a lot easier for folks to get here. This is a bucket list resort town, and I think that people, at least on the East Coast, haven't really thought about it until we have some access to it. So we'll have more to report probably in the next month. Thanks, John. Just want to have that opportunity. Thanks. John, I have a couple questions. On the United, we still have the money set aside for the subsidy, the $1.5 million for...
3:26:36 Yeah, the total subsidy that we have set aside is $2.3 million between Measure A and TBID and between winter and summer. So that money is still in place for this year. And if we're successful, because United seems to have so many more connections, if we're successful, then that whole subsidy does not have to be utilized. There's potential for that. I think if you look at...
3:26:58 This past winter, we're pretty much right at the $1.5 million. But the prior year, we were at $1.1 million. The prior year to that, we were at $647,000. So, yeah, the more successful we are with filling the planes, the less we're actually going to pay in subsidy. Yeah. And the Jet Suite X, so we have not created a contract with them yet? We have not. Okay. And would there still be that $400,000 subsidy available or not?
3:27:26 JetSuite X, United, all of that is part of our pot. Okay, part of the pot. Okay, I get it. Part of the pot. And so we still need to work on the cost-sharing agreement with Mammoth Mountain. We may see more funding go towards winter subsidy than summer subsidy this year, but they're always going to be the backup financial to it. So that's why when we look at adding all of these markets, it really comes down to what are they willing to take the risk on as well.
3:27:52 Obviously, Denver's a fairly sizable risk just because of the cost of the flight. You know, I think the cap for that flight is $1.8 million. That means if nobody flies on the plane, then we owe $1.8 million. So it basically starts to work off of that. So I think we have our set amount, and we need to manage the risk on both sides. And United will be working with us on marketing and all of that. Yeah.
3:28:17 Yeah, and we've got a great relationship with United. Sandy Everett, who runs their marketing out of Houston, we've worked very closely with her the last few years. And then personally, we have connections with the managing directors of Australia, Europe, South Korea. They're all, they're actually all personal friends that we can actually get back and do some partnerships with overseas. I think the potential is huge. I agree. I agree. Anything else?
3:28:47 In our regular meetings, and again, ESCOG asked us to get together a group, and the town council supported that. We've been meeting on a regular basis with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Mammoth Resorts, Inyo County, and ourselves on a staff level, just kind of assess where we are. So the next section really deals with what we've been talking about amongst ourselves. I'm going to focus on...
3:29:09 What we have told the group, what our ideas and plans are, and I have some very brief statements that I'll basically read from the others and I'll show you why. Basically on our side of things, we have a relocated windsock and segmented circle. We awarded that project just a couple of weeks ago. Expect to start construction sometime in August possibly, Brian? I would hope so.
3:29:30 Waiting for FAA to finalize that. Okay. And FAA actually helped us a lot on that because they wanted to make sure we spent our entitlement funds, frankly. It's a project that they were arguing about internally about how to, where to move the Windsock and where to move that segmented circle. They resolved that and they have accepted a grant and we expect to work that out very quickly and it should be done later this summer.
3:29:51 To relocate that. The wildlife hazard fence, we also have a grant for that. We have to work out some final details with the Forest Service about the NEPA determination there, but we do expect to be under construction with that next summer.
3:30:05 Additional aircraft apron, four years ago in that ALP that you saw, the aircraft apron was pretty much associated with the new terminal building. Since that time, we've had continued concerns by FAA and not serious safety concerns by many means, more of a standards issue that, you know, you guys would really...
3:30:24 You'd really work a lot better if you had more aircraft apron, period. I mean, it wasn't a matter of, you know, we're in dire need of it in terms of an emergency, but they wanted our planes to be parked farther from the runway, as an example. And, you know, Pat's here as well, and he'd be a great fan of extra aircraft apron. I would say that this weekend will be very interesting, and I'll let...
3:30:46 I'll comment on later if he wants to when we're done, but there's probably a lot of traffic coming in, Palooza Palooza's in town, and there's a lot of helicopters, at least five of them on the ground today, taking up a lot of ramp space, and we'll get to some of those issues later. But FAA is fully supportive of that. They've even noted that for them, that type of an operation is a categorical exemption. It's not a capacity-increasing thing. It's just a ramp space type of issue. So you'll see one of the recommendations.
3:31:15 Recommendations later will be for us to work with FAA to get that done. The last one, and I characterize it as commercial and general aviation facilities. One of the things we've been discussing with the group about is our plan at this time for a new terminal. Our airport layout plan and our terminal area development plan shows a 40,000 square foot terminal to serve strictly commercial aviation. What we're really thinking about for a lot of reasons, one being cost concerns, because costs have gone up
3:31:45 Quite a bit even in the last four years, as you know. But to meet that short-term need and also to play into the long-term vision that at least Inyo County has that this town council can discuss about moving air service to Bishop, if we build, let's say, a 20,000-square-foot building, and don't quote me on the number, it's just, you know, as an example, a 20,000-square-foot building.
3:32:06 In five years or in 10 years, does that transition into more of a general aviation facility? Or does that transition into something that serves those scheduled charter planes? Things like that. So we want to take a look, and again, I'll describe that in more detail later, at that plan and say, look, let's back up for a second. The plan's four years old. Let's see how we can meet today's understanding, today's understanding of regional air service, what that means. Because our whole job...
3:32:33 And if you ask FA, it's the same thing. Our job is to create a facility that is prepared to serve whoever wants to use it, whether that be commercial air service, general aviation, charters, or whoever. That's our job. And to do so in a safe and efficient manner. The details, they're not even that concerned about. They just want to know that we're doing our job to make sure that we're ready for whoever shows up, frankly.
3:32:58 Other projects that I've listed, and I'll go through them in more detail later, these are things that some of them are on the ALP, some of them probably need to be on there, but some of the land acquisition issues, facilities to support other issues, what that means is U.S. Forest Service, what did you call it, Brian, a strike team, or why don't you describe an attack base? Or a firefighter. Yeah, so we have...
3:33:22 We have ample water with Crowley Lake and other facilities. You've seen them out there almost daily for the last few weeks, frankly, and that's something that we'll, frankly, if your direction would love to talk to the District Ranger and to the region about, hey, is this a good place for an attack base? We have plenty of fires in the region, that's for sure, but this is an opportunity, especially at our altitude, that might actually be a great advantage to everybody.
3:33:52 Other comments? Again, I'll just go through these very briefly. I talked to Eric Clark about this earlier, and I said, did you read the staff report? And is it okay for me to read this? And he said, fine. So, Tom, you can read it if you like.
3:34:08 Exactly. Basically, Mammoth Resorts has publicly stated their strong preference that air service to the region be substantially relocated to Bishop Airport as soon as practicable. This means that the primary market driver for air service and financial partner supports this transition.
3:34:24 We have stated they will continue to support and work to retain and enhance air service into Mammoth while in order to transition to Bishop is pursued. That's why they're continuing to support the subsidy. They're continuing to support the program. They got, you know, the letters from the airlines and they're working on those contracts with us.
3:34:42 In an effort to assist Inyo County, Mammoth Resorts has recently obtained a letter from United Airlines that states that United will continue to be interested in providing air service to the area should Bishop become an option. It's also anticipated that Mammoth Resorts will continue to work with airlines in Inyo County to establish commercial service at Bishop Air Force. And again, I can answer some questions about that, but clearly I don't want to put words into our partner's mouth, so that's up to them to get into more detail.
3:35:11 With Inyo County, same thing. I sent this to Inyo. They didn't have any comment about this very brief paragraph, but suffice to say that they're working with FAA to initiate air service to the region at Bishop Airport. They've submitted their Part 139 package. They've gotten preliminary comments back, and they expect to be moving forward. A lot of this discussion, Inyo staff has asked that we do in the joint meeting later in August.
3:35:40 I did commit to our partners that I'd answer technical questions as far as I could, but it's up to them to read their opinions. Mammoth Lakes Tourism, they've been at the table to basically give information on how different funding sources can be used, how it relates to a service, subsidies, marketing, transportation down in Bishop. If you have any questions about that, I'd leave it to John to answer those, but suffice it to say they're at the table because there will also be a strong partner in this.
3:36:09 I want to talk a little bit more about FAA. Their basic statement is this. We'd really like it if you all got together and figured this out. And then we'll support whatever the region wants. And if you can't figure it out, then we'll get involved with making the decision.
3:36:22 They don't see this as a competition between Inyo County and Town of Mammoth Lakes. They don't see it as a competition between Bishop Airport and Mammoth. They see strengths and weaknesses in both locations from a facility standpoint, from a subsidy standpoint, and transportation. What they're saying is try to work it out. But they are being very responsive in terms of meeting with us. They're being very responsive in terms of looking at documentation that Bishop has submitted.
3:36:48 And they're actually helping look for additional funding sources that might be available in the future to help both airports. A key comment I want to make, and then I can get off of FAA's comment, is they've said it many times, that the decision point for where FAA funds go for final design and for construction is not in 2018, and it's probably not in 2019. They've actually encouraged both parties to continue on their current track. They've told Bishop, yes.
3:37:16 Do your Part 139. Identify your needs. See what it's going to cost. And they told the Town of Mammoth Lakes, continue your planning efforts. If you're going to design a terminal, do that conceptual design. Do your environmental documents. And then in a year and a half or two years, we'll see where everybody is. And that's when we hope the region has come to a consensus and that we can, that we, meaning FAA, can give us some advice for where they think the funds should go. And I want to emphasize that because
3:37:43 In our recommendation, it's, no, we need to keep going. Not everybody shares that. That's okay. But it's FAA's stance that, yes, everybody should keep going. They don't consider it a waste of funds if we spend $500,000 or $600,000 doing environmental documentation and planning for a possible terminal or a GA slash commercial terminal. They think that's good money spent because they see the great value in momentum. You know, if we stop and try to figure it out without doing this.
3:38:12 If something happens, we're not continually moving. So they're supporting both efforts, and they agree that that decision point is a year or two away. Okay. Some of the analysis and discussion, actually before I get to the actual recommendations, some of the things we talked about, and it's in the staff report, we think one of our big mandates is to continue operations and maintenance of Mammoth Airports to support existing services. That may sound like a...
3:38:43 You know, an easy button, but we want to make sure that we have a statement that says, no, we need to continue doing what we're doing. We're not going to stop what we're doing and say, well, let's move into Bishop in three years. Let's just end it all. Let's just quit accepting commercial service. You know, we see the value to the region and staff strongly recommends that we continue to do so.
3:39:02 Number two is that we actually continue to develop and enhance our ability to provide that safe, efficient facility. That's why the segmented circle is being relocated. That's why we need the wildlife fence. That's why we need the apron. All those things are important, whether this is a commercial airport or not, or if it's a hybrid, whether it has more flights than it has today or less. Those things are important to the continued operation of any kind of airport, whether it's a GA airport, something that handles a lot of the charters.
3:39:31 The other thing we want to make sure is that we want to continue because we also want to take no action that would preclude our continuing to provide that type of facility. We don't want to stop or take some action that...
3:39:46 Means later we can't suddenly build a terminal if in five years we find that we need to do so or we have to increase an apron. There have been some things in the past that were done that could have been done differently. The hangers could have been 50 feet or 100 feet further from the runway. We're going to make sure we don't do that type of thing. We won't get it all because the airline industry and everything will change. And in 50 years they'll look back and go, what were they thinking back in 2018? We can't guess that far out, but we're going to do the best we can.
3:40:17 Staff really does believe, and I'll get to the specific recommendations, that we do support the concept of enhanced regional air service through infrastructure improvements and initiation of commercial service at Bishop. It can only help, the more the merrier. I mean, if they have commercial service and it's very successful and in five or ten years an airline says this is great, but we also want to fly into Mammoth, that's great too. The market is going to decide air service. All we can do is take care of our facility.
3:40:44 And make sure that it's ready to respond to the need. And we also, as from staff at least, support Zinyo's effort to get funds to do what they need to do, for gosh sakes. A key one at the end of the recommendation you'll see is that doesn't mean town funds, but I'm going to make that clear. The regional discussions, again, we share Council's direction before in ESCOG that yes, we need to continue the regional discussions so that we're all working together on this issue. That's the only way it's going to work.
3:41:12 A quick comment on FAA assistant and oversight. The two airport district offices between San Francisco and Los Angeles are working very good together, very well, excuse me, and we even have the involvement of the Director of Office of Airports for the entire Western Pacific region who attends all the meetings. He is very interested in what happens up here and he's one of the chief proponents for us getting together as a region and making this work, even to the point that since the
3:41:42 Environmental and Planning Section in San Francisco knows this region better than the one in Los Angeles. He's actually assigned the environmental staff in San Francisco to work with Bishop so that it's much more seamless. The two airport district office managers are already working very closely together, both Lori and Dave, but they've actually assigned the environmental work to San Francisco because they know Mammoth Airport and this region better. So we have that cooperation.
3:42:12 I'm going to go ahead and get to the summary recommendations. There's A through G. That's seven, I guess. And these are very specific. I'd like to read through them. And then Council, of course, at your discretion, Mayor, can take them one at a time or all at once or whatever discussion you want to do. But they're kind of linear in nature. I want to make sure we understand them all.
3:42:35 Staff recommends, one, direct staff, or A, direct staff to continue working with the Forest Service and F.A. to complete the final environmental disclosure documentation and keep the wildlife hazard fence moving. Get that done. B, direct staff to work with F.A. to obtain approval of a grant modification or a new grant, as appropriate, for design and construction of additional aircraft apron area. Again, that's something F.A. has suggested to us.
3:43:03 They're very much in support of, and they are already saying, yes, your entitlement funds can go through this and go to this effort. C, work with FAA to obtain approval of grant modifications or a new grant to begin analysis of the possibly new or expanded building to enhance the passenger experience, either commercial or scheduled charter. And my point is, we want to back up. We're not going to design a terminal just for commercial aircraft, okay? We'd like to.
3:43:31 Do more of a planning level, back up a little bit, and say, look, how can we anticipate what's going to happen in the next 20 years? What if Bishop does have mainline service and we have less? What if it's just commuters in the future? Maybe there's a hiatus for five years and then some commercial comes back. We haven't really studied that. We've already done a preliminary selection of a consultant. We're negotiating scope and fee. But we'd like to go to FA and say, hey, can we use some of these grant dollars to study that effort to make sure that you all can make an informed decision?
3:44:00 D is to direct staff to complete an updated assessment of facility needs. I looked at the ALP. There are other things that we need to look at. We need to relook at our vehicle exactly when are we going to need it. 2022, according to Brian. The hangars, one of the comments that made is those hangars on the east end of the runway and on the north side are too close to the runway.
3:44:29 One of the concepts that nobody has really attacked, though, is, okay, what if they're not there? That doesn't mean next year and five years, but what if in ten years they've reached the end of their useful life? Or maybe there's a less expensive way to just move them back. What does that mean to the airport in terms of long-term capacity?
3:44:45 We haven't really studied that, and we'd like to do so. There's a long list there, and I don't need to go through each one of them, but there's A through K this time. One of the ones I think is really important is K, though, because it's pertinent to what we're doing today to support firefighting helicopters, the attack base, other aircraft. There's a lot of people that would love to use a high-altitude airport, and we really haven't studied that or contacted them to the extent we should have or maybe we can, so we'd like to do that.
3:45:14 E, staff recommends that Town Council affirm that Town supports the concept of enhanced regional service through infrastructure improvements and initiating of service at Bishop Airport. F is that Town Council affirms that Town supports Inyo County's effort to acquire funds. And all we're saying with E and F is, great, good idea, go for it. I mean, seriously, to put it in those blunt terms, it's just, use your best efforts, we support you, we know we're behind you 100%.
3:45:45 But I want to tag on G at the very end. With that, we would recommend that Town Council firms that no town funds directly or through MLT are to be utilized for the Inyo County efforts in terms of infrastructure. That's really up to them to do that. We have 800, what's our operating funds to the airport down on annual basis? It's over 800,000. We have our own projects. And we certainly can't afford to spend town funds.
3:46:11 And Bishop. I think they need to prove with FAA and with other of their own partners how they can build infrastructure, how they can plan it, and how they can subsidize any future air service. That was a pretty quick overview. Again, we could be on airports for days. So I'd rather just kind of hit those highlights and then ask for any input. And again, staff has looked at this and does make those A through G, I guess, seven recommendations. And of course, you're welcome to attack them.
3:46:40 One at a time or all at once, however you like. Whatever is faster. But questions, again, it's a huge issue, airports, and it's very complex, but we're trying to adjust it down to a pretty short summary, so thank you. Okay, no, thank you. With that, I'll actually look around. Does anybody have a preference of taking it? I don't have any questions.
3:47:07 I'm looking forward to any questions from Council. I'd love to hear from some of the public folks here, but then I think after that I'm ready to make a recommendation about how to move through it. Okay, good. In that case, okay. Oh, there you go, Jack. Jack Benham, the sheet. You mentioned that the airport, or the town, might be able to acquire land to the north of the runway. Would that be enough land to ever build a crosswind runway? Once upon a time there was a
3:47:39 Sort of a crosswind runway in the planning documents. There was a crosswind runway at this location. When we go back to study the ALP, we will take a quick look at that. I think with today's standards with commercial airlines and the nearness of the mountains to the south, that's likely not possible. I'm not going to say never. I won't do that. But I will say we'll take a quick look at that. We just don't think it's technically feasible for commercial aircraft at this time. I'll say never. Okay.
3:48:10 With that, John? Yeah, I would recommend that we approve all those items with the exception of item C and add some clarifying language to item G. For item C, I
3:48:40 This is how I'd like to approach this. I think that the town of Mammoth Lakes has demonstrated that we're a very good, considerate and hardworking partner with this effort. And I want to make sure that it's very clear on the airport side who are the two principal players in this, which is Inyo County and Eltero Resorts. And I think that we should not be
3:49:09 Providing any opportunity for distraction for the conversations between Altera and Inyo County as they look to figure out what kind of air service that they want to actually do. And I would recommend that we give those folks a year to come up with a project description which will be needed for the NEPA analysis of the air service that they want to do out of Bishop Airport. That project description will tell us
3:49:38 What Altera is willing to invest in, what FAA is willing to provide. And from that document, we will then know what our role may be for our terminal up here. And I would just say that I think it's very important not to interject any kind of level of distraction in those conversations. And I would also say that I, in the interest of having some fiduciary oversight over
3:50:04 Federal public money. But I have no idea what to say, what kind of thing we would be designing down there right now. And until Altera and Nino County go through that process and figure out exactly what it is that they want to do, which is going to, you know, Altera, I'm assuming, there's not enough public money in the eastern Sierra to do what they want to do down there. There's going to need to be a private capital investment in what they're trying to propose. And I think...
3:50:29 Just let these guys get to work and let's see what that's going to look like. And then based on that, then we can say, okay, this is what everybody's willing to do. We could then come back and take a look at what we want to do for this. The other clarifying piece before that is in G is to clarify that no town funds directly or through MLT's Measure A general fund monies.
3:50:55 Can be spent down there. It's up to the MLT board to figure out what they would want to do with TBID money, but I would want to make that distinction. What's that? Majority of infrastructure. Exactly. I would leave the general A money, the measure A money, that's ours. I mean, that's the communities. The TBID has a different set of things, and I would just want to make that distinction. Those are my thoughts. And, John, I would agree with you.
3:51:21 Oh, sure. Well, there will be,
3:51:51 Again, Altera and Inyo County, and Altera as the primary proponent has got to be able to tell everybody in the region this is the kind of air service that we want to have. Yeah, we want planes from Atlanta, from New York, I mean, whatever, who knows what that's going to look like. Once that is described and Altera is willing to say between Inyo County and the FAA, whatever they're going to do, we're going to be able to round up the resources to make that happen, then
3:52:18 Then we've got some information we can figure out what to do. And I think between now and then, let's let them have at it, figure it out, and see what's going to play. If they're playing with their dollars, I absolutely agree with you. Yeah, sure. Yeah, those are my thoughts on that. So back to number C, directing staff to work with FFA. So we're proposing that we would lay back on that until we have a better idea of how the project is going to go within you. So we would not then...
3:52:46 Proceed to obtain approval of grant modifications or a new grant at this time but wait for a year you're proposing? And I would even tie it to the language of that project description. That's a term of art that will have to be in the environmental document that the federal government is going to have to analyze. But in that project description, that's when we'll know what's going on down there. Well, yeah, to some degree. But, yeah, basically you're saying.
3:53:12 We wait until we have the temperature of what's going to happen down in Bishop before we proceed to look at any changes or granting or anything. And I had not realized until recently that what we have there now in that terminal was never considered to be a permanent terminal anyway. No. I had no idea. That was a new thing to me. So we're operating currently on a temporary sort of, okay.
3:53:38 That's correct. I mean, this whole deal with El Torino County might blow up and fall apart. Yeah. I mean, that could happen. I mean, the capital investment may be too much. I mean, who knows what's going to happen. If that were to blow up, well, that's a very different terminal we're looking at. So, Brian, you were starting to say something? Yes, that was a temporary terminal. That was the old maintenance building. It was not designed as a terminal.
3:53:59 It does not meet TSA requirements. It did not meet our requirements, so we had to put a sprung structure down there. Our baggage collection is outside. There's no cover. I could go on forever. It's a temporary. I mean, it looks pretty good for all that, honestly. I think people seem to love it, and I have an excellent staff that takes excellent care of it. It has nothing to do with me. They just do a great job. So people like it, but it is a temporary structure.
3:54:27 At some point in time, it needs to be replaced with something that's fitting for the community, that meets the community values. Yeah. Thanks. Okay. I have a little bit of a problem with John's suggestion here. I would agree that we probably shouldn't spend a lot of money designing a new terminal. However, the enhanced aprons...
3:54:53 And the other modifications that they're asking for are all important today. Absolutely. That's in B. That's in B. Yeah, that's... All that stuff's in here. Okay. Sealy speaks to the... We separated B and C. Okay, got it, got it, got it, got it. My bad. I should wear them more often. John looks better in them than I do. May I provide a qualifying point?
3:55:25 I just want to make sure just there's clarity on the discussion of TBID funds and Measure A funds. At this point, it is very clear to all those parties involved that Measure A and TBID funds cannot be used towards infrastructure in Bishop. Moving forward, if and when commercial service becomes available in Bishop, those funds can be used to market.
3:55:43 Air service and to pay subsidy for the people that are coming to Mammoth Lakes. So we can figure that out how it goes down the road. But that's just to make sure that that's crystal clear that we're everybody's on board with the idea that those can't be used for infrastructure, but they can be used for marketing subsidy. Thank you. Oh, I'm sorry. If I could add one clarifying thing as well. If the council chooses to take out item C and not make progress on that, I completely understand that. But I'd only suggest that in item D
3:56:14 We at least consider the possible location of a future building. We're not designing it. We're not even saying what use is in it necessarily. But if we're going to look at the overall airport, we have to say, okay, if there's a building later, it's probably going to be there. And that's really it. I just want to make sure that if you get a report back later that talks about a building, that's to the extent we'd look at it. Location's important. Thank you. That's fine. And you would have to be looking, well, it might be this, it might be that.
3:56:42 And just as an editorial comment, I think that the pursuit of an attack base, the amount of money in the state of California that's coming to fire, it's just...
3:56:59 Overwhelming. And I think the degree to which we can develop projects that can tap into those funds, I think that that's a very important track to be pursuing. I think we should be able to get money from Cal Fire, from Cal OAS, from a whole bunch of agencies in the state where all the cap-and-trade money is coming through to deal with this fire stuff. I think that that's a very important thing to be pursuing. That's an editorial comment, but that's... So I can make a motion if that would be helpful. You know, I have one comment on the whole Bishop thing.
3:57:30 That I would like to just speak to. Before I would be willing to spend even our marketing dollars on Bishop, I would want to see the logistics plan for how the people are going to get from Bishop to Mammoth, who's going to pay for it, what kind of transportation, how are we going to entice a car rental company to keep enough in Bishop to potentially deal with that. I haven't seen that yet. The other piece is I would really need to see
3:57:59 That Bishop is ready and willing and has the capacity to step up to the plate and pay their share of the subsidy. Because as we do a nexus study, which we're going to have to do, in far more depth than we did, incidentally, to determine the 80-20 split we currently have, because as I understand it, we use credit card receipts, and if your address was not Mammoth, you were a tourist, which isn't true, all of our second homeowners are... That's not how we do it, but that's okay. Yeah.
3:58:26 So when we do that study, there's going to be a certain percentage that can't be identified as Mammoth, that can't be identified as tourists, that are going to have to be subsidized. So Inyo County is going to have to be able to do that. Town of Mammoth General Fund cannot do that. You know, we cannot be the one subsidizing air service for another location. So those are the things that I need to see coming forward. Thirdly,
3:58:54 For Mammoth Airport to lose all commercial service to Bishop makes no sense. I understand the size of the flights that we want to get in from Denver and stuff may require a longer runway. But, you know, nine months out of the year, we don't have airport closures due to weather. And we are the destination. And if we're going to market a flight and get people on it to pay less subsidy, then that flight's going to need to be marketed to Mammoth, not to Bishop, where I think we lose...
3:59:24 In my opinion, which is not completely uneducated on the matter, we lose ridership share. So I never see the need for that building in Mammoth going away because I would hope that we would still subsidize some level of air service to Mammoth in the appropriate months and when they can land here, not move the entire thing to Bishop and abandon this one.
3:59:51 I wanted to address the transportation piece because that is something that when we met with the FAA, they were very clear that that has to be part of the conversation. You know, what does the transportation piece look like? So I think that that's something that will be part of the narrative that we that we have with the FAA. And we've had conversations with a number of different people just as to what logistically works and what doesn't work.
4:00:11 As far as the subsidies and who's paying what, that's all to be figured out because I'm not sure that Inyo is going to have a whole lot of skin in that game. I think it's probably going to be more the company up the hill and whatever portion we can justify for Mammoth Lakes. Moving forward, I think we also have a vision of having the JetSuite Xs of the world still continue to fly into Mammoth Lakes. They're not considered commercial air service so that they're
4:00:40 They're able to fly into the airport. We'd still need to maintain Part 139 because they have to be scheduled into Mammoth. The only reason they can land in Bishop is because they're unscheduled. So we do have all that to take into consideration. There are a lot of moving parts left. You have a lot of questions. We have a lot of questions. Yeah, a lot of people are assuming because the big guy stands up and says, I want to move this to Bishop, that we're going to go there. We're probably two years away from even knowing the answer whether that's going to work or not.
4:01:09 Well, I'm hopeful back to that project description piece. I think a year is a reasonable period of time for Inyo and Altera to get together and hash this stuff out. And if they haven't figured something out in a year, it's, you know, it's, really, you can't figure this out in a year?
4:01:27 Could take longer than a year. But I think at that point we started going, well, look, what's the plan here, guys? Okay, now just to clarify, you're looking for direction, you're not looking for a motion or... Actually, a motion regarding the staff recommendation. Okay, you would like that, okay. Do you have anything that you wanted to add, Kirk, or questions, Linda? No, I'm kidding. Oh, okay. Did you have a motion that you wanted to... Yes, Madam Mayor, I would propose that the Town Council
4:01:58 approve items, all items with the exception of item C and with clarifying language for item G to or through MLT. I don't know. Is that language necessary to clarify TBID versus general fund? At this point in time, maybe not because the TBID and stuff is only going to be for marketing or subsidy. This is really the next year or so. It's really looking at
4:02:31 Infrastructure, investment, or other dollars. Does he need to clarify that language? No. Andy, excuse me, is there any issue with us having not listed as a recommended action a motion as opposed to just receiving or providing direction? No. I mean, you are providing direction. You're just doing it through a motion. It's not. That's not inconsistent. No, it's fine. So my motion would be to approve all identified items with the exception of item C. Item C. Okay. You know what? I will second that.
4:03:01 Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. With that 5-0, we are moving on to item 12, the legislative update and direction regarding town position on
4:03:31 Legislative matters. And, Mayor Hoff, if I might remind the council, because there are two new members who, Councilmember Stapp may or may not remember this, and Councilmember Salcido may not be aware of it, but a long time ago, the council adopted a resolution prohibiting you from introducing any new items after 1030. Correct. There's no real consequence for not complying with that, but that is the council's standing rule. Correct. So just bear that in mind as you consider it. So, you know what, with that said, is this something that I, that item 13,
4:04:00 Should be dealt with before 12. Can we get through this in 15 minutes? I think we should deal with item 13. We can deal with item 13 first if you want. You know what? I would like to do that as well. So let's go ahead and do. Can I try one thing real quick? Sure. If I made a motion for the legislative cashman A to support the items on the November ballot, Prop 1, Prop 2, Prop 3, and Prop 6.
4:04:30 I'll just make a motion to do that. If we can support that, great. If not, then we can plan until later. Which items again? One, two, sorry, to support Prop 1, Prop 2, Prop 3, and Prop, sorry, to not support Prop 6. I'm sorry, John, one, two, three. One, two, three support, Prop 6 opposed. So did you just make a motion? It would be following the recommended.
4:05:02 Positions that the League of California has taken on those propositions. There's other ones that you could talk to, but they have no positions in the league at this point. But I would like to continue that item, too, when we can get to that next time, because I think it's worth a discussion, you know, but for now, I would second that motion. And you'll need to take public comment, of course. Can we act on this motion and come back if there's time to deal with the other issues on this?
4:05:33 Sure, because the motion isn't covering every possible aspect of this item. You have a motion covering some things, and if you want to come back to it, you can. It might honestly be easier to support the slate as presented here as reflection of the League of California Cities position rather than pull some out, because I don't think there's any others that we would, I mean, they have no positions on the other ones, and wouldn't that just be easier? I would amend my motion to be,
4:06:02 Town Council supports items as presented consistent with the recommendations of leaving cities. Yes. Yes, and I will second that. Okay. Okay. Roll call, please, Jamie Gray. Discussion? Oh, I'm sorry. No, we're just getting through this. Any public comments? Any discussion from the Town Council? Yes. On Proposition 4, I just wanted, you know, I...
4:06:27 I support the league position as no position. On Proposition 4, I support that, the $1.5 billion for the University of California as well as the nonprofit hospitals. Also, I support...
4:06:44 The fire department, the fire, let me look at which one that was. I mean, I was going to go through these one at a time. Proposition 8, no position. I support the California firefighters who endorsed this. So I have two, just two different issues. Proposition 8, I support. And I also support the Children's Hospital Bond, which they took no position on. So I have two yeses.
4:07:14 That the rest of them I agree with. So Madam Mayor, I would amend my motion to table to bring back for Council for further review Proposition 4 and Proposition 8 for further discussion. And Linda, if that's okay with you. Yeah, I would approve that. Yeah, do that. Okay. Any public comments on that? Any more discussion? Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes.
4:07:46 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. With that, we will now move to item 13, the Town Council Strategic Priorities Workshop. Yes, Madam Mayor, if I could address this. One is in the last couple of years, we've done some, you know, workshops with the council looking at how do we set priorities, moving through, getting some direction. The original thought process here discussed before was looking at an August time frame where we could set aside.
4:08:17 You know, three days here to come in and really work through this. Based on some input from council members, I'm not sure the three days at this time and frame to work all through boom, boom, boom will be viable just in terms of, I know, from work standpoints and some of those types of issues. Based on the comments and discussions, sorry, it's, you know, in the last week or so and just some of the questions raised, I would propose a modification.
4:08:43 To the program. One would be still to have in that. I'd need to nail down which day works best to 22nd, 23rd, or 24th. But to have a, I'm going to call it a full day, maybe it's a three-quarter day with Town Council. Really looking at the first few items here, but taking out items like three and four on strategic priorities, smart principles, but really looking at the roundtable discussion, presenting information, providing a good framework for the council to work from.
4:09:11 This would include looking at some of the adopted and accepted work programs that are out there, the walk, bike, ride, downtown revitalization, our housing action plan, and spending a lot of time with council working through that so you all truly get on the same page on some of these items of how you would move it forward, taking a gap in that before you get to the next day or two, be able to look at a couple of options. One would be is do you want to do any in-between meetings with our partners, NGOs?
4:09:39 And or to have additional time to really digest that information that comes forward to you. We would work through a calendar of timeframes to put that together. But I think, again, based on some of the discussions and comments, that may be a stronger way really to build that consensus on the Council looking forward. We'd have to work through the calendar and see what the timeline would be there.
4:10:01 As an option to do that. If not, we are set up. We could walk through the three days as presented, but we can make that modification as well as we look to the future here. So I'll put that out as an option for discussion by the council, and we'll take the direction accordingly if you're okay with bifurcating this work a little bit and or plowing through it.
4:10:24 Since I am fine with whatever we do, I'm going to go ahead and let somebody else start with this one. I have a couple of issues. One is that we're planning three days at the end of August, the week before Labor Day, my busiest season already. I am a one-man show.
4:10:47 To take three more days, I mean, I already have to golf two days, for crying out loud. To take three more full days out of that may be problematic. Can this be moved after Labor Day or do we lose any impetus? If we could do one day, it'd be really beneficial, I think. We could move it out the day out, but one day here would be really helpful just in terms of as we plan out. And I have no problem with that. I want to be mindful of your calendar. Yeah, three days in a row makes it...
4:11:15 Right. Tough for me to tell somebody, yes, I can do you tomorrow. Correct. You were going to take out what are strategic priorities in the first day. Yeah, we take out a couple of definitions. Really important for me up front is for the council to have an understanding what the day-to-day workload of staff is. Right. Before we start planning all the extra stuff we can get them to do so that we have an understanding of capacity and we stick to that capacity in setting the priorities for the next.
4:11:44 It's short term. That would be on that item for that work day. Right. So if we were to do the first day, you know, kind of find a date that might work best for Councilman Sauser, and...
4:11:56 I think there's more value to that than just the things that are listed here. I think there's a lot of value in getting us together and beginning a dialogue around what the priorities are, how we're going to work together. So I would, you know, kind of advocate for doing that. And as far as the next day, the two days that are sort of laid out here, I think it's important that when we...
4:12:16 Sort of understand what our strategic goals are, what our priorities are, and then begin the discussion then about what, how we might link those to what our expectations would be of the NGOs, I think sort of follows, but I don't think that that needs to follow, you know, day to day to day, because three days of...
4:12:32 In summer, like that is kind of a big ask. So, you know, push the next one to September, beginning of September, maybe then the last one to sort of the end. Yeah, we'll put a schedule together if that's the direction. And I think taking out this, you know, what our strategic priority is, you know, that we can, you know, sort of touch on that. Smart principles, yeah. But, I mean, you know, and that's asking the facilitator sort of to bring that together, you know.
4:12:57 Kind of suggest an entire day, like to five or three? I'd say a three-quarters day. It's probably like an 8 or 8.30 to 3.30. It depends on the amount of dialogue Council is having. We'll set a start time, and you can end when you can no longer stand it. But we'd look at that for, I'll say, a three-quarter day. So I'm okay with this recommendation. Two things. One is that I think that homework,
4:13:27 I mean, whatever things we need to have so we're prepared, so we arrive, we know what we're all talking about. And the second thing is to make sure that the facilitator and to some degree staff identifies what types of outcomes you need out of this so that we're not leaving this at the end fuzzy. If we have disagreements, fine, but whatever. We come out of this thing with things that you guys can use to provide direction to staff and to our partners. Agreed.
4:13:57 Is that going to be an issue, do you think, to have it spread out with the facilitator? I'll work with Michael Ward, who we're working with. I'll need to check his calendar and time of that, whether it's three separate days or it's one day here, then two days. I'll work with him on that and we'll come back with that as part of this first day workshop. We'll really come back with a schedule at that point. You can look at your calendars and we'll be able to map out the next couple of months of work that way.
4:14:25 Okay. Any questions, comments from the public? Any more? Everybody wants to be there, I know. Everyone's excited about this, too. Yeah, I support the strategic planning, absolutely. The idea of...
4:14:46 The council planning out how we're going to walk through this because we've got so many documents. It's not just the foundation documents. It's also the town's budget and the town's capacity for dealing with all those different things. So even the general plan plays a part in this whole thing.
4:15:10 When I look at that first day, I look at not only the council trying to plan out how we move forward, but in that planning, how we walk through all these different documents, as well as our capacity.
4:15:25 You know, from the budget to staff time and everything else. So I very much support the strategic planning. And this day has got to be crafted in such a way that we're getting up to speed on all, especially, I've been out of the loop for a long time.
4:15:45 So knowing all those different plans, and also I think one of the critical things is to, you know, Mammoth Lake Tourism, what are their, you know, in their silo.
4:15:56 What are, you know, their priorities so that we can hear that also as well as Mammoth Lake Housing as well as ESTA and everything else. So try to get some of that feedback as well as when we meet later that there's a dialogue that goes on with those different things. This is a community planning and so I think that we need that feedback.
4:16:22 As much feedback as we possibly can before we put our feet on the ground with adopting this. Well, I think also we have to recognize that with the NGOs, they are contractors. I mean, we work with them, but I think the work that we do to really establish with staff, with capacity, with resources, what are the priorities we want to do, and to make sure and to have these dialogues.
4:16:48 Our contractors, NGO partners, so that when we come into this session, we're pretty much, we're hopefully on some kind of a sane page with this stuff. But then to get to the things, the priorities, so they get articulated in the contracts, so that the representatives on the boards can say, well, look, I'm here representing the town council in the town. I've got, here's a general idea of what my fellow council members have established as the things we need to be doing.
4:17:12 So that everybody's got a sense of direction where we're going. I think that might also play into Kirk's question you brought up earlier about what is the role of council representation on the boards of the NGOs. And I think that all kind of comes together. And I think that as we set priorities and strategic goals from a council level, sort of the global...
4:17:36 You know, then beginning to decipher that down into how it works on and with the NGOs as reflected in their contract and the expectations, I think that that is how I kind of see it coming together. I agree. What I'm talking about, so I look at Mammoth Lake Tourism and they have begun to shift their, some of their focus. I mean, $350,000 for signees, that would be...
4:18:02 So the dynamics of some of our relationships has changed. And so not only from their point of view, but from our point of view. And that goes back to your contract. So the idea of getting that information as to what are the roles. And I look at Mammoth Lake Housing. I mean, they've kind of stepped back from being involved.
4:18:31 And that's a whole discussion that I think the council needs to be aware of so that when you go into strategic planning we have an idea of what their needs are and what their focus is so that we can incorporate that or
4:19:01 You know, say, no, we don't accept that. We think you need to shift here. And I think the lens, really, that we have to be looking through is accountability. Because the only way the public can hold our contractors accountable is to the contracts that we put in place with those organizations. And so if there's a problem or things are getting off track, you know, the public says, hey, why the hell are you directing people to, why are they going over here? We need to be able to say, we have an agreement with them, we direct them to do it. If you don't like it, you can recall us or reelect somebody else.
4:19:30 But that accountability piece has got to be really in place. But in the contract recently that was agreed upon with MLT, there was language in there that said these will be updated and revised upon the strategic planning priorities set by the council. So they're already anticipating that. So I mean, I think that's useful. We still need their feedback.
4:19:53 That's all I'm saying is I want to hear from their marketing perspective and from the shifts that have taken place. I still want to, if they disagree with, you know, $350,000 for signage, then I would like to hear that. I think they're in agreement and I think it's the right direction to go and I support it. But I do want to hear from their board, you know, what
4:20:20 Within a silo, within their marketing and everything else, that's going to drive the contract and that's going to drive our discussion. So getting that feedback from them, from their perspective, you know, as to what their priorities and then, you know, the idea of incorporating them into the strategic plan is what I'm suggesting. Maybe this is part of that first day discussion.
4:20:46 From Council's level as to how do we want to interact with our NGOs? Well, we want them, you know, as contractors to be fulfilled in the policy direction. It ends up in a contract. Yeah, I agree on the first day. Part of the conversation, whether it's roundtable or afterwards, because it'll be a lively one, is how we are going to deal with NGOs and what we are looking for and what those relationships look like.
4:21:16 Well, it's sort of also within the information review on the first day, number five, where you talk about, you know, the adopted draft NGO agreements when you're talking, you know, and kind of the, I see that kind of as a bit of a history lesson there, too, you know, where we are currently. And so I think maybe that can be incorporated, some of that language into that and some of that dialogue maybe there. So it sounds like we have a consensus that we will meet as a council.
4:21:44 Is there information we need before we meet? I would recommend to staff. We will actually get a lot of information out. Yeah. The sooner the better. From the foundation documents to everything, almost we're going to end up with a giant binder, which is, you know, we're going to have another one. One more? One more binder. Actually, this would be even outside of one binder because there's a lot of stuff. Yeah, some might just be reference to that and stuff. The other question I would look at is,
4:22:13 If you have a preference for the 22nd, 23rd, or 24th, it's at Wednesday, Thursday, Friday. It's a Wednesday, Thursday, or Friday. I don't know if there's a preference. You can let me know that as well. If there's a problem, we'll get it scheduled. Can I ask a clarifying point? Oh, absolutely. Just wondering, so in this first session, are we talking just council, or are we talking the NGOs as well? Because we do have some conflicts with board members. Yeah, it'd be primarily just to council. There'd be some information on the NGOs of what's already in place, but there would be a follow-up.
4:22:44 Much more detail with, if you have a board member to attend to be good, but it'd be much more, the level of detail I think for contracts and if that would come at the secondary. Okay, I'm just looking at it from, are we participating that day or are we gallery? That's fine. First day I would say probably more gallery, but I would have somebody here.
4:23:03 Yeah, yeah, no question. From my standpoint, gallery the first day. Yeah, that's fine. I just want to make sure so I'm not, you know, we did talk about it at our board meeting today. We did talk about carving out the three days. We've got different conflicts with different board members and staff, so I just want to make sure. We will definitely have people here, but I just wanted to make sure that we weren't expected to be bringing everything to the meeting. The first day, the 22nd is the one that would be most preferable to me. Yeah, 24th doesn't work for me. What day is the 22nd? Wednesday is the 22nd, like earlier in the week.
4:23:32 It's Thursday the 23rd. It is. Fall is the 22nd. Yeah. But I can do anything. 22nd. 22nd? Yeah. 22nd. What day of the week is it? Wednesday. Wednesday. It's a Wednesday. It's still Wednesday. Council meeting day. And that's at 830. All right. So it's at 830. But not a council meeting. 830? Yes. Do we get coffee? Yes, we get breaks and all sorts of good stuff.
4:23:59 So I can go ahead and take this off for Thursday and Friday, correct? Okay. One just other note on that. I would like if this could flow that if we can have them done in a timely as best it fits with everybody involved so that we don't kind of lose track of, oh, what was it that we talked about two weeks ago? So as long as that's
4:24:30 So, consensus on that? Okay. So, with that, I guess save your council reports until next meeting. Dan, is there any problem if we put that in the front of the agenda for next time just to catch up? Yeah, if that's the request, we can do that. I'd like to request that if that's okay.
4:25:02 So, okay. With that, this meeting. Do you want to go back to Kirk's? Back to agenda item Proposition 4 and Proposition 8. Oh, okay. Is there anything in here on Proposition 4? No, I think what I can do on the propositions, they're not as critical in the timeline with the legislature. We'll pull information out and bring that back as a separate item for discussion. Okay. That way we can take formal action and have some information in the packet. Because I haven't read up on either of those. No, that's fine.
4:25:30 I'm sorry, I misunderstood. I thought that's what you were saying. So with that, we will adjourn this town council meeting August 1st, 2018. That hurt. What hurt, baby?