Town Council Special meeting
· recording 1 hr 59 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
287 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 I'm trying to call me back, but I'm not actually making a damn phone is off.
0:10 How are you doing? How are you? I'm doing good.
0:39 I even used all five fingers. That's okay, the world can hear that. I think that's everyone.
1:05 Right, but that's true. Is this for me prior to or after? No, it doesn't even cross your mind. Now you hardly have a rhythm that I cross my mind so much. Okay, let's see. And we do have... long time no see. Yeah, we'll share there.
1:40 She's not coming? Oh, okay.
1:42 Here, I'm going to give it to you because you're running than me.
1:44 Donna. Donna should tell her.
1:48 She resigned.
1:49 Yeah, but that goes into a second tomorrow.
1:52 This is her last one.
1:52 Oh, right. I'm pretty sure.
1:53 This tomorrow.
1:54 Yeah.
1:55 Okay, so Zariah's not going to be here or?
1:59 Oh, okay.
2:00 But Donna will be at the meeting.
2:03 Oh, okay.
2:04 I don't have my eyes, I can't see them.
2:07 You know, I always hung mine around my neck. Yeah. And I don't have to go back to doing that. It's in our pack. It's in our pack. Too often I don't have them with me, like today when I need them. Right. I might have a pair of you. No, I think I'll be alright. I know. Yeah. Oh, okay.
2:46 Okay, five after three. I think we've got everybody and we'll just wait for Donna. Okay, we will go ahead and call to order the Town Council slash Mammoth Lakes Housing September 10th, 2018. This is a working agenda. The meeting purposes for council priorities and alignment.
3:17 With the partners and contract direction and options for moving forward at this time. Tom, do you mind? I like to do this. It's not necessarily on here, but I like doing the Pledge of Allegiance. Would you mind leading that for me? Which time? Oh, this time. Tom with an H. I pledge allegiance to the United States of America, to the children of all its hands, one nation, under God.
3:50 Indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Tom. And just to remind everybody with the microphones, if you could just speak into the microphone so everybody can hear, as you can tell, we have a new sound system. And we will go ahead and do roll call, please. Council Member Salcido. Council Member Stapp. Here. Council Member Wentworth. Here. Mayor Pro Temps-Houser. Yes. Mayor Hoff. Here. Mammoth Lakes Housing Board Members Corliss.
4:23 Here. Barksdale? Yes. Kinney? Here. Cruz? Mercer? And Hodges? Here. Okay. And for this meeting, this is a really great thing to have both entities here speaking. And at this point, I'll take public comments of anything that is not on the agenda for today. Okay. We do have a...
4:50 Pretty good discussion time. We're going to have a hard stop at 6 o'clock for the Mammoth Lakes Housing Meeting to begin. So I will again take public comment time given at the end of the meeting. So now we will start the workshop portion, which is a joint workshop between the Town Council and the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board regarding the Housing Action Plan and related housing topics. I do hope everybody has read through the package.
5:19 If you have not, this meeting may not make a lot of sense to you. So just to let you know that there was a lot in here. So with that, I shall now turn it over to you, Dan, for a second. Yeah, just for a quick introduction, and we'll turn it back over to Councilmember Stapp. As you mentioned earlier, as part of our Council priority setting initial discussion, there is a request that we take time to meet with each of our NGO partners as we go forward.
5:50 And so this is the first of three workshops in that vein. And so part of that will hopefully help in any type of contract negotiations and other elements as we work together, in this case on housing-related items. Be looking for able to do that. We are not going to spend a lot of time on a staff report, as you mentioned, or trusting you've read through it. We'd like to get into the discussion points. But before we get there, as we do have some new folks in the room and on.
6:15 various boards and stuff here that we would want to give a little background information on MLH and actually asked councilmember Stapp slash MLH board member Stapp to kind of give a brief little history on he's got a lot of background on this but probably brings the most knowledge forward and so on the working agenda we'd ask him to make some comments there and a little overview maybe of the current status and then even other board members if need be or Patricia.
6:43 And then proceed forward. So, Mr. Stapp, thank you. Yes, thank you. Just a brief overview. Back in 2000, and this is kind of people that went in elementary school. Sorry, Giselle, but you're the young one here. But anyway, back in 2002, the community passed.
7:10 Measure 2002A to provide money and 1% of that passage went for establishing or addressing the issue of housing. So that 1%, the council at that time created an NGO, Mammoth Lake Housing, and that was 2003. Between 2003 and 2008,
7:35 The Mammoth Lake Housing developed 131 units, actually it was about 2003 to 2010, actually developed as a developer, and when I say Mammoth Lake Housing as a developer, no, I mean actually it was Neubauer and Jenison that worked with this as well as the town staff at the time, so it was a joint effort, but 130 units were developed.
8:04 The value of the outside grants that came in during that time period was about $44 million that with the cooperation with the town and with Mammoth Lake Housing, we brought in about $44 million. And between 2003 and...
8:24 Currently, our Buyer's Assistance Program has helped 103 different families actually get into different houses throughout the community. 2010, the airport litigation occurred. Between 2010 and 2018, Mammoth Lake Housing...
8:47 You know, has been functioning on a maintenance contract, a contract of about $330,000. We have gone after grants and that sort of thing, the latest grant, but you two are aware of and were provided direction, was for the Sierra Manor helpers property. So hopefully we'll be able to get 11 units out of that.
9:15 Two years ago, we began to consider, it was a long debate at the board level meeting, should we look at becoming a chodo? The board, after months actually of deliberating this, decided to, yes, we should become a chodo, and the major reason is because it just opened the door to another funding source for Mammoth Lake Housing. So the board, after a long discussion, did
9:45 Did decide to become a CHOTO, and that seems to have become a political issue. We've had several Mammoth Housing Directors, Andrea Clark, she was initially our Housing Director, Executive Director, she did a wonderful job, having Hernarty, who's down in Bishop now, as the, as the, I'm not too sure the director for,
10:15 For the county down there, Neal County. And then Jennifer Hauferty and now Patricia has stepped up. Patricia has done an excellent job because she's had to, you know, fill in, didn't know, and she's been going to different conferences and has got her real estate license and she's working on her broker's license. That's kind of the current status as far as Mammoth Lake Housing.
10:46 If you have any questions, I'd gladly answer them. If we could add two items to that. Just recently we did the joint agreement for the home funds for first-time homebuyer assistance that we partner in between the town and MLH. We also received a community development block grant for that, and we're going through the process to set that up again for the first-time homebuyer program. So that's been a really successful program over the years, and we have, you know, those two additional pots of money coming forward to work on that first-time homebuyer program.
11:17 Okay. So any questions for Kirk? Okay. So we shall go ahead and move on to, oh, the wonderful part. We're going to have policy question discussions. Dan, is there anything that you would like to say or Sandra before we dive into? In your packet, you'll see that we have a specific questions that we're looking to talk about today.
11:48 Madam Mayor, I don't understand our Brown Act anymore, so I struggle through this. So I do have a written response to each one of the seven questions that I'd like to pass out. I apologize if they're coming late, but again, I don't get what the procedure is anymore on the Brown Act. So rather than take any kind of chance, I agree.
12:19 Put some time into thinking about responding to these seven questions. Okay, thank you, and we'll look forward to answering those as we go along. I am going to take all seven items. Since we do have a hard stop, we shall go through these one by one. I will reference this as we go along. However,
12:51 I nor anybody else probably at this point has time to read through this. So hopefully they are just in line with the questions that we have. They're in line with the brief comments that I just, as I pondered these questions that came forward.
13:12 I thought about them and I said, okay, what's my initial? This is Kirk's response. This is not the board's response. It's not a councilman's response. This is Kirk who has been involved with housing for quite some time. Okay. Did you have something to say on that? Well, Mayor, I just want to emphasize that I think the point of today's meeting is to...
13:34 Have a discussion between council members and MLH board members. So I hope we'll hear from everyone, not all of us. I came here prepared to have a discussion and look forward to hearing from everyone at the table and in the audience. Okay. Thank you very much. So going ahead with that, shall I just go ahead and dive into the first policy discussion question. Okay.
13:58 Let's see. Which one should I read from? Are they the same one? Do the Council and MLH support proceeding with a basic services maintenance contract within the existing funding parameters at this time? Once MLH is fully staffed, should an expanded contract be considered? And Tom, not to put you on the spot, but I'm going to go ahead and start with you. Yeah, you bet. As a member of the MLH board, I absolutely believe that
14:30 I definitely support that we proceed with the basic services contract. And, you know, clearly there's some limitations right now with the level of staff that MLH has. Patricia is sitting there by herself. So I know that I'm working on the contract committee currently, and we're evaluating all the things that are on the sort of routine list of requirements that are...
15:00 Or in the package here that everybody had a chance to look at. And it clearly requires more or less the full time of two employees to address all items that are being asked in the contract. And at present, we don't have two employees. So I think that the MLH, we have to acknowledge the current state of affairs with our staff.
15:23 We have some decisions to make here, and we'll be discussing that in our board meeting here coming up today, tonight, in regards to next steps with recruitment or not of an executive director and how we want to proceed with that. So, you know, there's realities of where we are today, and it's not to minimize anything that's been done in the past, but, you know, what abilities we have today are much more limited than what we had in the past.
15:53 But I think there's every need and intention that MLH should continue to provide those basic services that they've done historically with town and the prior contract agreement. And moving forward, I have every expectation that MLH will restore staffing levels in conjunction with what's being asked from the town to provide in those services. I guess the next part of that discussion will be
16:23 All the other things that are on the Housing Action Plan, which is a lengthy list of things, and obviously is going to require even more bodies to do. So how that's best accomplished, I think we'll have a robust discussion about that moving forward. Okay. Thank you. Lindsay. I would really like to see the contract move forward as we've been working on it.
16:51 For quite a few months already, I'd love to see a new contract come forward, see some of the priorities from the Community Housing Action Plan come to fruition, just continue to take steps forward. I think that I don't, I'm a bit nervous if we sort of decide right now that a maintenance agreement is the way to go, that we kind of come to a stop on some of the great things that have already been happening.
17:15 With a community action plan. So I kind of think that we're already on a great track. We've had a lot of meetings with the contract committee. We have another one scheduled, and I think we're off to a great start, and hopefully we could get that done pretty soon and start moving forward. I agree with Tom that capacity on our end, MLH end, is tight right now for sure, but I also really feel like we're hopefully tonight going to take some action and move forward on that as well so that then we'll be...
17:43 Really poised and ready for a bunch of new things. When you're speaking of tonight, you're speaking of your meeting tonight. Our board meeting. Oh, okay. I want to make it clear that this is not, no decision, this is a conversation. We're not making decisions. If we come to a consensus, that's great, but okay, thank you for clarifying that. So I would be, I guess, the question, am I in support of proceeding with a basic services maintenance agreement or contract? No. I guess that's the answer to the question.
18:12 Because the alternative then that's maybe not there is I would support a new contract and moving forward with that at this time. Oh, okay. That's sort of how I read that. Thank you. Giselle. Can you hand me the mic? Oh, there you go. We're sharing one mic over here. So I think with any contract, if at any point the town wants to ask for us to expand our services, then
18:40 Funding services, I think, also need to be expanded with it. So I think it depends on, as Lindsay was saying and Tom were saying, since we are in negotiations with the contract, I don't want to say right now, yes, let's stick to the basic, because I am not a part of that committee, so I'm not necessarily sure if there's any differences between what we're discussing now or what's going forward. But if there is going to be expansion of services, then there should be more funding. Okay. Thank you. I hear it. Yeah, you get two in audio.
19:10 Thank you. Based on what I know, like, Giselle, I'm not on the contract committee for MLH, but I support moving ahead as quickly as we can in getting a contract in place, and it should be a contract that aligns with our priorities in implementing the housing action plan. So if we need to do the basic contract now and work out priorities associated with the funding it takes to get those priorities implemented, then
19:41 Let's do it in two phases. But let's get it done. Get her done. Okay, perfect. Here, I'll just let you read from your... Well, I'm not going to read it in there.
19:56 There's two parts to the question. Do the Council and Mammoth Lake support proceeding with the basic service maintenance contract? No, because the fact is that if we look at the housing action plan, there's a lot of actions in there that I think the town and Mammoth Lake Housing should jointly address. I mean, if...
20:18 Housing is a crisis facing this community, and I believe it is, and we need to work together. And once Mammoth Lake Housing is fully staffed, should an expanded contract be considered? Well, absolutely, yes. We need to expand that contract.
20:35 You know, not only to address the housing action plan, but if we're going to maintain what we have. And if some services are shifted over from the town, if you read Sandra's very complete...
20:55 You know, analysis, you'll see that there's the stewardship of maintaining, and I do agree with that, by the way, but it might be a great deal of work to try to get everything under one roof.
21:07 I think there's a lot of discussion that needs to take place, and I do believe that we need to expand the contract and address the housing action plan, the items in them that the Town Council prioritizes, or just simply common sense that needs to be done. Okay. And Mr. Salzer? Well, at this point, I certainly would support going with a basic services plan. I don't see how that would keep...
21:38 Mammoth Lakes Housing from the traditional role they've already always played. So I need some understanding from those who are saying, no, we shouldn't proceed with that because they don't agree with it because that at least maintains the status quo until we can staff back up and then define roles and then move forward as those roles get defined. I will say on a side note that, and Kirk said it just a few minutes ago, this question has almost seemed to be us versus them and it needs to be us.
22:08 I mean, it needs to be us together. It has to be. There are things in the housing action plan that to me don't make a lot of sense, like perhaps the town having its own housing guru. Well, if we're going to have – there's a lot of questions that have to be answered there. The reason to create an NGO in the first place is because it can be more nimble than a government organization. So if we can get back to being more nimble and move everything forward, of course I support –
22:37 Doing the basic services, which, if I understand it, would bring Mammoth Lakes Housing back up to where they were, not where they are. Am I missing something? It would basically take their current workload as presented and then allow for the staffing up to the two full-time, for the two full-time positions. And then if you wanted to go beyond that, then we'd come back and look at the resources necessary to do so. Yeah, so a two-fold question. Yes, we should proceed with the basic services plan.
23:07 And should we look expanding the contract? Anytime we can move housing forward, if it takes expanding the contract, then we look at it. Nothing should ever be written in stone. Thank you. And Mr. Wentworth? Yeah, I think it's important to get an agreement, as described on page 8 of the staff report, to get a contract in place that is not going to preclude the negotiations going on currently. But I think it's been...
23:36 Mammoth Lakes Housing has been engaged and struggling with a variety of different transitional pieces. It's all been good work. We've got a new board. I think it's a great opportunity to be turning a page and be looking at the future. We've got new staff opportunities. We could be turning that page and looking forward. But I think it would be very helpful to get just a minimum basic floor in place that's a contract that the board knows, okay, this amount of money is in place. It's guaranteed.
24:04 As new opportunities come forward, we can add to it, but I think it would be very helpful to have a just get let's get the contract in place. It doesn't preclude anything, but at least we as a board know, okay, we got this much money to work with and then we can start figuring out where we go from there. Thank you, John. I also agree that we just need to get the contract. I do think that Mammoth Lakes Housing, you know, we're not reinventing the wheel here. There are other places that have
24:34 Such contracts and NGOs that are similar to ours. My goal is really to find a consensus about this and to really start working together. We've had great changeover in not only town council but supervisor.
24:55 The Housing Board. I think this is a real time of adjustment. And I'm very excited because we have some really good chances ahead of us. And I would just like to get to a place where we can all work together and make this happen. And so I'm very supportive of a proceeding with the basic services contract. And then once it's fully staffed, should an expanded contract be considered? Heck yeah.
25:25 It's not saying we must. It's like this is should it be considered. Absolutely. We should be considering everything that we can to move forward. So with that, Dan or Sandra or? May I? Oh, excuse me. I don't know the format for this, if we're able just to sort of discuss. You know what? I would like this just to be a really good discussion. So I started it out that way, but feel free to jump in. Yeah, which stems great conversation. Thank you.
25:54 It's taken us a really long time in this contract committee, and I know not everybody's familiar with it, but it has been...
26:00 Since May, maybe, that we've been working on it, since April? I think we even said that we were going to have it done by April for this contract, which then maybe didn't even start until May. So I guess my main concern is if we say that we can come, because I do agree, we need to know where we start from, we need to know where we stand, we need to know where money is going, what jobs need to be taken care of, what programs need to be funded.
26:25 But I'm afraid it's going to take a really long time if we now start again on a basic service agreement, which we haven't even talked about yet. So I guess in my mind, we've been rolling now for three years. And I sort of look to produce it for some of this, but we've been rolling for about three years without a signed contract. And so my concern would be, why stop the progress that we've made now, continue as we are, and let's try to get this contract done as soon as we can. That's kind of where I'm...
26:53 Where I'm coming from and saying, I think we just need something new. We've started on it. We're in progress. I don't want to reverse, go back to a whole other something that could take another two plus months, however long, and then come to something new. So that's kind of where I'm at. If I could add to that. So just in the vein of open discussion real quick. So again, I know that right now MLH has limitations because we only have one employee presently.
27:21 Couldn't accomplish everything that's on the proposed contract presently because of Jennifer's election to the board supervisor and she's no longer there. So with that said, you know, I think if I understand it correctly, I mean, I think we can have a pretty fluid process moving forward to adapt the contract over time. And, you know, I personally don't have an issue with tailoring the current work program that's there to reflect.
27:49 So, um,
28:17 You know, knowing that, I mean, if the, because I think if we were to fund it at the current level, the MLH wouldn't be able to deliver on what's in there because there's not enough staff. So I think it's just a technicality in that respect. I mean, I think we can match up the workload with what we have presently, knowing that we're going to find somebody which, you know, depending on what role that person plays, the MLH board will determine here quickly how we're going to recruit for this person, and then we can decide
28:46 You know, once we get that person on board, we'll be back up to speed and we can fully execute on what, you know, the contract workload is. And then, and by all means, you know, as Bill pointed out, you say,
28:59 Housing is the number one priority for the community. There's more to do than can get done right now. We've got lots to do. And as we divvy up the work and the task and the expertise where it resides and figure out what has to get done, I mean, again, I'm thinking that it's not like this contract, in my view, is signed and that's it for three years. It's like, hey, we can always come back to the table and say, hey, we've got ability to take care of this now. Let's do this. We're going to add another body here. And let's take off and go. I mean, like you said.
29:29 I agree with much of what you've just expressed.
29:54 But we also have to look into the future. I don't know how much of the housing action plan, but if the parcel comes forward, who's going to maintain all those contracts to make sure they stay deed restricted? The town is going to have some huge impacts on its budget.
30:10 By snow removal and all the different things, the maintenance in there, the janitorial if there is a child care put in there. So looking forward, the impacts on Mammoth Lake Housing and the town are going to be huge. And they could come very quickly if we're successful, if the town is successful in getting a grant for the infrastructure, and hopefully Mammoth Lake Housing is involved in that. When we looked...
30:36 A couple years ago, at just the infrastructure, that's $8.3 million for the road, and that's two years old. So getting those roads in there and the infrastructure, undergrounding and all of that, you know, we have a better chance and the town has a better chance if we do this jointly, if we submit grant applications and everything else with support and with the county support. I mean, I think everybody's on board.
31:02 on board on that particular issue. The county's been great with the revolving loan fund. But I'm just looking forward with not only the housing action plan, but all the things that are just coming that have to end as well as the maintenance contract. Well, I think it's clear the town council tried to have a productive agenda item discussion on housing a couple weeks back, and we managed to
31:32 Trip over ourselves about nine different directions. It's going to take a lot of work to get it figured out as to who's doing what. And I appreciate, Kirk, there's going to be a whole host of different tasks for a lot of different partners to be doing. But I think in the spirit of what Tom says, we're looking at an iterative agreement that we can at least get something under our feet for the board to understand we're starting here.
31:56 The town, the council, MLH and partners start figuring out kind of who's going to be doing what. I think if we all approach that contract with that spirit in mind, with the understanding that, okay, MLH, we've got a role for you to play. The council can make a decision that says, okay, let's put some money over there. Let's bring that capacity online. That's the spirit I'm hearing. And I think it's probably a, you know, I don't know what's going to happen in the future. I don't want to start trying to plan for that right now. I mean, they're a thing too, right?
32:25 When the parcel is fully developed and built out, right, we're going to add 300 plus new deed restricted units, something like that. You know, that's going to require management, right? I mean, in my view, at that point, you need another body, right? Just somebody who's going to be full time qualifying people's incomes and making sure they're meeting the deed restrictions on a year to year basis. So, yeah, I mean, you respond to, you know, your growth and you put the right bodies and you figure it out. I mean, it's...
32:54 I just want to get, I don't feel like we don't want to get too hung up on like having the perfect org chart and exactly figuring out how this is all going to play together. I mean, we're all in this together. We just want to, we want to deliver on housing to our community, to our people who live here and want to stay here. That's what I'm focused on.
33:12 I just wanted to interject, and Dan, maybe you can help me on this, is that we do have someone that has a conflict talking about the parcel expressly, so I know it's part of this conversation, but instead of where, let's concentrate on just the overall housing, and then, Dan, you'll just stop the conversation if we... I was going to jump in on that, too. Thank you. Okay. Thank you.
33:37 Council knows Mr. Sauser has a conflict from the parcel-related items, so he can't participate in those dialogues and discussions, so housing in a broad standpoint, absolutely, but in terms of the specific location there, so if we get into that, he would need to excuse himself and leave the room. Housing, please. Broader issues, fine. But the point you make is to John's point.
34:01 We don't know where that's going to occur. We don't know if we're going to trade with the Forest Service. We don't know how any of that plays out or what our capacities are going to need. I'm hoping that we're smart enough when we get there that we can determine which entity can handle which job in the most efficient manner and put them that way rather than continuing to...
34:23 Put our own ivory towers up saying, no, no, I'm housing. I have to have everything. No, I'm the town. I have to have everything. The only place where I feel differently is that when tax dollars are involved, I don't feel that as a town council, we should even have the ability to give the authority over how all of that tax money is spent to a nonprofit. We have to work within the nonprofit and then allocate money to it.
34:48 As the requests come forward, so we're doing our fiduciary responsibility with the tax dollars of the people of Mammoth. And I think you'll see changes with all of our NGO contracts, I hope from my standpoint, that reflects that. So just kind of like, I guess as a clarification for myself, in my understanding of this question,
35:09 As Lindsay mentioned, there's already been contract negotiations. So with this, if we were to go with the intent of just a temporary basic needs services contract, sticking to the one that we have currently that was signed three or so years ago, and then once we get everything else laid out, then start building off of that? Or are we wanting the contract committee to keep going forward and do a new basic needs assessment of what the contract will look like?
35:38 I would suggest that we get this agreement in place, understanding it can be added to, and then we focus our attention between MLH and the town as to divvying up the roles and responsibilities, figuring out, okay, who's best suited to be doing what. That's going to take some work to get that figured out. When we get those roles and responsibilities figured out, then it goes to council to appropriate funds to say, look, MLH is going to have to be doing this. We've got to get them some money to do it.
36:07 And do it that way. Because otherwise I think we're maybe putting the cart a little bit with the cart in front of the horse. But we're kind of doing things a little bit ass backwards. And I think the work we've really got to do is focus on how do we work together, how do we leverage our capacities, all the skills we've got to figure out who's doing the right thing in the right places. And then when we figure that out, then contract to that. So that didn't necessarily answer it. Because my question is, do we want to just stick with the one that we have and then go forward with, like,
36:37 Changing it or change it with right now in the committee as stating it as this is just basic. We're not even trying to add new jobs, but just making sure that it's up to date on what the tasks are just for keeping the foundation steady. Because I feel like those are two totally different things because if it's the first one, then we can just literally sign it today and move on. If it's the other one, then it's still going to take time to kind of figure out. If I may just tell it in the staff report, kind of walk through it, one of the options looking at it is.
37:06 The last couple of meetings with MLH, I think most recently in August, there was a work program put together, I think by Patricia, kind of laying out, here's what we're currently doing and here's how we allocate staff. Ideally, that's pretty simple, you could actually take that and say, so if you had two full-time people working on those projects, this is what that agreement would look like, taking that work program and formalizing it. Here's the base cost structure staying the same. And then either you can have language in there, it would be there probably regardless going, okay,
37:35 As things move forward, things change, and there's additional needs and capacities that's been discussed. Yeah, every year, at minimum, you're going to review the deliverables and look at that contract and say, look, we need to make a change point A to point B. Or the council could come to MLA and say, can you take this on, or vice versa, coming forward and say, hey, here's something we can jump on. Okay, does that mean it's one-time money for a contract? Does that mean it's hiring a full-time staff person? We don't know the answer to those questions either.
38:04 But we'd know what that core work program is. And I think it was actually done pretty well and laid out in terms of the two positions and the types of things. And I'm trying to recall now, most everything in there is attached to the packet, I think, really represented what looked to me like would be an ongoing work program. There may be some of it that would, you know, up and down based on funding, i.e. the grant stuff coming in. But that would give us a solid foundation. We know what the expectations are for what's happening today. And then say, okay,
38:34 What then becomes, you go through the housing action plan, okay, what's the priorities there? There may be something that we looked at throwing in the contract today, but we might not get to it for four years, so I don't want to prejudge those things. But knowing what you can do with the existing staffing, which isn't there yet, and then there's a solid foundation. And we could write this contract, it's a one-year agreement versus a three-year agreement if you want. I mean, two years, whatever, can go into that.
39:03 I think if we have that foundation, it's easy to build off of versus my other fear challenge would be we create a new contract and that in the first six months out, we come back and go, why haven't you done these things? Which we recognize why, but we don't want to set MLH up or vice versa for failure in an area either. And I think the current work program, there's some stuff in there that frankly staff is excellent at doing. And how do we continue to build off of that area and figure out what those strengths are and then go, great, let's move that forward.
39:32 We're being successful. Let's build off of success versus putting a bunch of stuff out there and going, okay, when do you get to that? If I could add, I just want to think. Just cautious. Reading through the staff report, there's a lot of, we're all kind of in a certain level of the weeds. And I think we really need to be thinking about the community. We're doing this for the community. And I think it would be really helpful if we get whatever this first iteration of the contract is to be very clear.
39:59 Okay, MLH at this point is doing this, this, this, this, and this. And so when we're communicating with the public, when we're talking to people, people can, well, what exactly is MLH doing? What is the town doing? MLH right now is doing this, this, this, this, and this. And so we can really, as a board and organization, say, oh, you want to, you need home buyer assistance, you want to do these kinds of things, go over to MLH.
40:22 Town, what's happening with X, Y, and Z? Well, we don't know. We're still trying to figure it out. But it's going to be really important to get that front-facing stuff in front of the public so they can start understanding who's doing what. And I think the sooner we can get to that, the better. And I just would like, I feel sort of maybe I'm starting to beat my dead horse, but the Community Housing Action Plan has short-term priorities that are already
40:47 We're agreed, I don't know, agreed upon, but we're already sort of assigned to MLH. So I would just love to keep that in our conversation to make sure that some of those short-term things are still talked about because I'm a little bit nervous when we talk even about we can shorten the contract to one year. Just seeing how long this has taken already, we're a long way out from getting anything done if we stop talking about those short-term priorities.
41:10 The midterm, the longterm. So I just want, I would love to keep that in the conversation if we're sort of going to go with this basic service maintenance agreement. Let's throw something new and exciting in there that we can get done for the public, that we can try to take some more things off our list. There's public? No, you know, actually, I'm going to deal with all of these questions since we do have a time limit, and then it will be at the end of the meeting that we will take public comment.
41:42 So, depending if there's time. Pardon? Oh, no, write them down. So, no, thank you for everybody's input on that. I'm so happy that everybody is talking about this. And I am saying that it's kind of funny that we're using the word foundation because if you look at this.
42:06 What we're doing today is kind of just like building a house. We've got to set a solid foundation in order to go from here. So I appreciate everybody's comments on that. And so let's go ahead and move on. Sandra, was there something that you or Patricia would like to add on there? I don't have any additional. No, I don't. Oh, okay. Do the council and MLH
42:33 Have timelines for the hiring of vacant staff consultant support for housing work program. So if you let us tackle that first, Cleveland, it would probably be beneficial. Yeah, I can just provide a quick update. So the town, we have a housing coordinator RFP out right now. We only had one proposal for it. So we've extended that deadline to September 24th.
42:58 So we're expecting, we have been talking with other interested parties, so we're expecting to have a couple more proposals for that so we would be able to vet.
43:05 Those proposals and hopefully have somebody on board in October. Also the Civic Spark, the AmeriCorps program for California, we were looking to have a new staff member starting today. However, we have gone through some interviews and the applicants have been placed with other cities. So we're still kind of in that process of trying to find applicants, interview them, and then hopefully hire someone.
43:31 Civic Spark allows their, they call them fellows, the fellow to start up to six weeks after the beginning of their entire program, which is the program starts today. So we're going to be really pushing hard for the next six weeks, trying to find someone and place them here. If we're not able to place someone the next six weeks, then we would...
43:50 Probably have to reapply for next year, so we wouldn't have that capacity, which is something we had been really hoping for, because it would really help us to get some of kind of the low-hanging fruit of the housing action plan accomplished, but we're still trying to be optimistic, working with the local government commission on that. Excuse me, how hard or how difficult is it to get a Civic Spark person here? Is there something about Mammoth that we're not on a higher list, or is it?
44:20 I don't think, no, we have, we're going to use the town condo. We have a, the town owns a condo, so we're going to provide housing for this person at a reasonable rate. It's really, I think, a combination of different things. We have an assigned person from the local government commission who hasn't had enough time, I think, to really market this opportunity so that they've kind of renewed their marketing efforts for us.
44:49 to try to get that out to applicants. So people apply from all over the country to do this. So we have already interviewed one person, and we're hoping to have additional interviews. But I don't think it's really that it's Mammoth. Obviously, we know this is a great place to be. And I think there's a lot of people who have just graduated college or considering a master's program who would want to be here for a year. It's a really great opportunity because I think we
45:16 We give interns and someone of this level, a fellow, we give them a lot of the ability to really kind of take this project and run with it, you know. So I think it's a good opportunity. We're just continuing to work hard to try to find someone, the right person for this opportunity. Okay.
45:37 Within that, are there any timelines that you, Mammoth Lakes Housing, has for any positions? Oh, yeah, Patricia on that one. The board directed staff to search for a temp to fulfill staff responsibilities in the meantime while we have one full-time staff person, and we've been unable to locate a temp.
46:02 With the qualifications to perform the duties in the office. So the board will talk about filling vacant positions at their meeting tonight. Any comments on that from anyone on the town council? On the second one. Yeah, B. Yes, Madam Mayor. Again, you know, we have the housing action plan. We have different
46:34 Timelines and everything else, and I think we've done a good job. I think the community's done a good job. But when you look at these timelines and everything else, one of the big omissions is just simply, okay, do we have the staff to do it, and do we need to budget to be able to get it done? So a lot of it, you can't just keep dumping workload on staff and say, okay, look, we adopted a timeline, now do it.
47:01 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
47:21 And I just think, I think that I feel
47:49 A lot better this evening because I think our conversation this evening, we are finally taking these first steps to do exactly what you're talking about. And I think it's, you know, the council, we've accepted the Community Housing Action Plan. We haven't made any decisions yet about how to prioritize things and how to do stuff. So I think it starts tonight. I think we just, you know, the way you eat elephants, the way you climb peaks is one step at a time. And I think that I'm very encouraged by these initial steps that we're taking. And let's stay focused on, okay.
48:19 One step after the other and how are we going to get to where we're going to get to and I'm quite confident we'll get there. I have just one request. Since we were talking about two different entities, I've already caught myself multiple times when someone says staff. I'm not necessarily sure if they're talking about Mammoth staff or town staff and Mammoth Lakes housing staff, especially coming from Kirk and John since you guys are liaisons between the two agencies. So just for everybody in mind, I think it would be good to...
48:45 Define which agency you're talking about when you say staff. I think it's an excellent point because there's a lot of stuff like in the staff report. I think it's incumbent upon all of us to be very clear with the semantics so that the public knows what we're talking about and so we don't get confused, right, to make sure exactly which things we're talking about. Thank you. Anybody else have any thoughts on this one? I'll go ahead and move on to part three.
49:15 As part of the town's contract with Mammoth Lakes Housing, should Choteau administration be included? And I'm going to go ahead and start. Tom, do you have any thoughts on this one?
49:31 If I could, Madam Mayor, if I can interrupt quickly. You may want to roll up item G, which also talks of Town Council support for maintaining Choteau. If you want to put the two Choteau items together, it may be a little easier to handle the conversation. You know what? Item number seven. I do like that. Would you like me to move that down to the bottom, or shall we tackle both of those right now? That's up to the body here, but I think if you have them together in context. Okay, we'll go ahead and stick them together. So what we're going to do now is we're- Madam Mayor, I would disagree.
50:01 If you look at questions four and five, they have, they're asking the Mammoth Lake Board, Mammoth Lake Housing Board, you know, to choose between two different options, you know, to fund the parcel or to send funding to the parcel to send it to the revolving loan fund. That's a Hobson's choice. And a Hobson's choice is a choice of two bad alternatives. And what I mean by that is
50:30 Mammoth Lake Housing, if we look at its mission, supports both of those. The parcel as well as refunding the revolving loan fund. So four and five are something that the council is going to have to deal with. Mammoth Lake Housing, if you look at our charge, would have to, the board, if they think about it, is going to say do both. And then the
50:59 The council is going to have to make the decision, the budgetary decision as to what to do. I will take your point. I'd like to go ahead and address C and G. Well, I think they're numbered. Three. Well, if you do, I'm number three. I'd like to do three.
51:22 Seven together. And C and G. Yeah, exactly. C and G, depending on what you're looking at. C and G together here. And let's go ahead, since you brought it up, and let's, even though this is something that perhaps the town council, even if they have the last word on this, this is what I'd like to hear from you guys, what you think about this. And so this is something that definitely
51:50 I would like to talk about it. In that, I would like to stay away, like I said, with the parcel, because I would like Bill Sauser. I should go home. Bill wants to go home, and my goal is to keep him here. So let's go ahead and talk about item four or D and E, and let's just kind of get those out and see what everybody has to say about that.
52:18 And just remember that, you know, we're working together for something here, people. I mean, this is, this is, I think, I know it's my top priority. I'm hoping that it's yours as well. Housing, this is not going to be easy. This is going to be very tough, but we have got to come to a working place together. So, you know, let's just go ahead and attack some of these hard questions because this is not something that we need to have just as a love fest.
52:45 And nothing accomplished. This is a time where we need to get down and get to work and honestly just put it out there in the best and nicest way that you can. So with that, I'm going to continue with D or 4, however it's numbered on there. Should housing reserve funds be used to replenish the revolving loan fund or designate these funds for specific projects?
53:12 Whatever that is. If I can, and I'll address that, I think to help the two bodies. Kirk's right, ultimately the council need to make a financial decision, but input from MLH could be beneficial to this. Right now, estimated fund balance of unused uncommitted housing money coming out of last year is $205,000. Let me round that to $200,000.
53:35 One of the questions we want to be able to bring forward to Council for discussion is should that be allocated for specific housing projects or should a portion of that, basically it'd be $114,000, be allocated back into the revolving loan fund to bring it up to $300,000. The revolving loan fund is currently funded out of housing impact fees and there's $186,000 in that account.
53:57 If we were to allocate $114,000 over there, that would bring it back to $300,000. We would bring that forward resolution-wise, setting that aside for the RLF, the revolving loan fund, and be used accordingly. I don't know if there's anything out there pending coming forward quickly or not. The other side of that is you can say no. We will just continue to let that fund grow as fees come in.
54:17 And once it gets back to $300,000, we would set that aside in total, and then other fees could be used for other projects. So the question, I think, and input from MLH is just, it is a tough priority because both of them should be priorities, but one says, let's go ahead and get the RLF back to the full funding as soon as possible. The other says, no, we should take our additional dollars and stick it into housing.
54:42 Projects and Programs now and let the RLF grow more slowly, if you will, back to that. I'm assuming there's consensus to get it back to at least $300,000. So that's the way the two of those kind of came together. So when we come forward, I think it's October 3rd we're planning, we'd come in with a recommendation on allocating $200,000 of housing funds. And if we have some level of discussion here, that's beneficial. If not, we'll make a recommendation regardless of if the council beat that around at that point in time.
55:11 Well, I would love to hear the pros and cons on this, so feel free to speak. I would just like to update the group that I've been in conversations with two deed-restricted homebuyers in the past two weeks, one who has been wanting to sell their unit for a long time, and so I think will move quickly, given the opportunity, and another one who I think may be in an emergency situation and needs to sell quickly as well. So that's two deed-restricted homes that could be coming up in the next week to six weeks. I don't know, but...
55:40 Two homes that we wouldn't want to lose. Okay. Thank you for that. And that's relatively new. Yes, in the last couple of weeks. Oh, okay. Awesome. Okay. Thank you. We do have a partnership with the county as well. It also has the same involving loan fund within the county, up to $300,000. I'm assuming that's currently available as well. Okay. So that's the other nice partnership.
56:02 Okay, so with that said, what you're saying is that increasing the revolving loan fund is actually a plus for the goals that you have. Okay. Sorry, if I may first, Dan, the housing reserve funds that are referenced in number four, was that in our package? It's an attachment that shows the balance ending last year at $200,000.
56:28 Right. And where do those funds come from? That's the TOT dollars that have been allocated to housing, and that's the unspent portion as of the ending of last fiscal year. Perfect. Thank you very much. Sorry about that. And then, do you want to keep going? Oh, no, keep going. I'd like to hear the pros and cons of what you guys think about this. I was going to say the same as Patricia. I believe one of the two people that she's speaking of,
56:55 Current deed restricted homeowner came to me and said they would like to sell their house and I referred them to Patricia. So we may be speaking about even three people or it may just be two. But yeah, so the Revolving Loan Fund helps Mammoth Lakes Housing purchase deed restricted homes that homeowners want to sell. And so if we lose those, they go away. They are no longer deed restricted. They go on to the open market. So I just really wanted to be very clear about that. I think it is pretty important that we have that.
57:25 I live at San Joaquin Villas. My home is deed restricted. There are 40 units in ours. They were all supposed to be deed restricted and they were not able to be sold as deed restricted units. So currently I believe there are only 20 units out of the 40 that are deed restricted. So we lost 20 units there and I'm not sure why or how, but it's...
57:45 It's important. So I do believe that the revolving loan fund is important. One thing as well, I just wasn't going to throw in, I just went to a 401k planning session last week. One of the things, of course, they say is, we were talking about, it came up about 529 plans for funding children in college. The thing that struck me about this is regarding some of our other, and I'll use the right terminology, some of our specific projects, you can get grants for those. I don't know if we can get a lot of grants.
58:15 Quickly enough to buy back some of these homes that the Revolving Loan Fund gives us money for. So that was just one thought that I had was in thinking about what we can fund in different ways. It's nice to have relatively quick money to use that you don't have to apply for a grant, but then there are some others that are really well suited to grant funding that maybe that money might be. So it's just kind of a thought for me. So while I agree with Kirk, we want...
58:41 As much money to go toward housing, I do think that having some of that money in the revolving loan fund is important. Okay. Yeah, I think it's a simple conversation, right? I mean, we're struggling to produce units. Why in the world would we let an existing unit go, right? So to me, it's a slam dunk. You've got to replenish the fund and have the ability to buy back these units as they're imminently coming back to us, right?
59:09 A bird in a hand is worth doing in a bush. I'll just add to, as part of the Community Housing Action Plan, one of the ideas that Tom had was to put together just a very simple chart. We can put it up on the wall in here that says, our current deed restriction housing inventory is this. So that when we start making decisions about this, it's a very simple calculus. If we don't do this, are we going to add?
59:33 Okay, thank you.
59:59 Giselle, did you have a question, a comment? Yeah, I kind of just want to emphasize more on Lindsay's point because deed-restricted housing is the most fundamental way to keep affordable housing because you can't do anything different with it while it's deed-restricted. And even though, yes, the county also has funds allocated for this, I remember I think it was last fiscal year we had like three come all at once and it was
1:00:27 Kind of stressful. There was a point where we were like, do we buy this or do we do something else with this money? And I don't ever want us to be in that position. I think we should always have, whenever a deed restricted home comes up, be able to purchase it immediately and keep it within the community. And with any other special projects or specific projects, I mean, we can always search out for third party grants. You know, we've done it regularly at Mammoth Lakes Housing and we're able to...
1:00:55 Within grants, you know, sometimes you can do different things, so I just think it would be really important to keep the revolving loan fund intact and keep that money there. Stacy, do you have any comments on that? Oh, sorry. Yes, we need to fund, the town needs to fund the revolving loan fund, and it's not my place to really say how you do that. I'd like to point out that
1:01:23 Preserving deed-restricted housing is a priority in the Community Housing Action Plan. We talk about, are we actually doing anything? Yes! We're already doing this, and we're doing it well, so let's keep it funded. And as Dan mentioned, the county's involved and very committed and supportive of the revolving loan fund. So I dare say I speak for the supervisors, would urge the town, but there's one in the audience, and she's nodding, to fund this.
1:01:50 Okay. Bill, can I hear from you? You know, on this one, I am here or there. I'm here to listen to their input. I can't tell you which is going to accomplish the quickest way of have housing on the ground, moving the money towards a specific project that who knows how long the environmental work has got to be done. There's all sorts of things out there.
1:02:20 Or putting it back in this, I am right now confused on this particular issue. Okay. If it's okay for me to admit that I don't know it all. You know what? You were supposed to know everything about everything when you're on town council. And if you'd like me to give you an answer that shows that, I will. No, that's okay. So, Kirk, I know you kind of kicked off this conversation, but would you like to add something to what you've heard?
1:02:46 I mean, if you have to choose, then obviously the revolving loan fund. I mean, don't start, don't be losing units and then try to build new units to replace, I mean, you know, the net results is nothing, you know, and yes, I know that some of the development that might occur are going to add, hopefully, a large number of units, but if out the back door for the next couple of years,
1:03:15 We're losing units, then that's just foolish. You know, I would not make a comment, but ask one further question for my own edification. In the past, we have a project that should have 40 deed-restricted units that only has 20 because we couldn't get them all sold. There's another project, and I don't know the answer to it, but the chutes was supposed to be all deed-restricted as well, and we lost some opportunity there because we didn't have the people available to buy them at the right time.
1:03:43 Don't know if that's true or not, but that's the way it has been put to me. So what is our market for the deed restricted? Is buying them back, keeping them in the stream, do we have a list of customers waiting to move into those units so that, because them moving in over time replaces the fund as well? Yes, and so typically it's one unit at a time, and there's plenty of first-time homebuyers and low-income homebuyers that are in the market to purchase.
1:04:11 These deed-restricted units. We typically hold a unit maybe for three months before it's sold to an eligible household. Right. Kirk, you said no, that that's not how we lost those. So if you can educate me on the shoots. I really don't want to get in. I don't know the answer. If someone has the answer, I would. Well, that was in the past, and we can't correct that.
1:04:36 I think that's going a little bit too far back into the history and a little bit too much of the weeds and we're moving forward. As long as we're not repeating the mistakes and that would be something that I would hope that MLH...
1:04:48 Would keep us abreast of if we're heading down the same path that made us lose it before. But I really, if it's okay. It goes to more than this question. You know what, I realize that, but I'm really looking at the clock. We have 50 minutes left, and we still have a lot of stuff to dig through. So if that's something that you feel the need that, Dan, how could I handle this so he could get that information? We can provide some conversation offline that may provide some additional information. I think it's out there from folks.
1:05:17 Okay. Because it has to do with not just this, but what is the best product to build in the future as well? It answers a lot of questions. Well, as a general point, I appreciate moving on, but the issue of literacy about housing is a very technical realm. There's some discussion about maybe putting together a housing action summit the first weekend of November so that we can all get to a level of literacy so we all understand what these things are.
1:05:46 I'm just going to make a pitch for that. I think we've all got homework to do to figure these things out. And we need to get that out in the community so we're all talking apples to apples and oranges to oranges so we can have a good conversation. And I think that that's going to be very important that we're all on the same page with this. Just since we were on this conversation, John, I know you made a comment earlier, but would you like to kind of continue with the RLF? RLF, thumbs up.
1:06:14 But I definitely want to get that inventory in place of our units. There's something in this agenda item on page four having to do with GIS database program. I think, again, we've got to figure out who's going to do that, but that's incredibly important, especially how that kind of GIS data ties to single-family rentals and transient rentals.
1:06:35 There's a huge opportunity to be leveraging those two data sets against each other that can really help us make really good, important, informed decisions. So I'm just going to make a quick pitch for the GIS thing, and I know we'll get to that. Let's get a thing up on the wall that says, we've got this many units.
1:06:50 And each one of these projects come forward. Is this going to produce units? And how long is it going to take to do it? So that we are focused on producing units for the community. So what I'm hearing from everyone is that there is a consensus that the RLF is a good place to put monies. Am I pretty correct on that? Yes. Yes, we've got a good consensus for that. And that helps us as we frame up items coming back to Town Council for allocation and then ultimately to MLH in terms of what the resources are they have to work with.
1:07:20 Did you have something to say on that? Yeah, just to, Patricia, how many people are on our wait list at this particular moment? Because this might help Bill. On our rental waiting list, there's about 75 households. 75 households. Yeah. But sometimes those rental households purchase. Yeah. So that's people just waiting to get into one of our rental units. How many rental units do we have approximately?
1:07:52 How many rental units do we have approximately? 182. So, I mean, it's really important that not only those people that are waiting to try to get into those units, but to John's point is how many units are out there and to have those statistics is valuable. Okay.
1:08:16 Thank you. Well, I think this segues nicely into the next one, going to Item 5 or E. Should the town continue to allocate the housing mitigation impact fees to replenishing the RLF up to $300,000, or should these fees be committed to a specific project?
1:08:36 That almost seems to me to be about the same question, but I would love, matter of fact, since the town's first in this sentence, I'm going to go ahead and start with the town. If we can jump into that. I mean, the idea there was you have two different funding sources. The priority of the RLF has been discussed before. So one of those questions was, do you take time to fund that and spend dollars on projects or not? I think the consensus would be is to move forward more quickly to reestablish the RLF fund.
1:09:05 Those other housing NLU fees then would be available for other project work accordingly unless you wanted to grow the RLF fund and that could be a discussion down the road. Those funds need to be used for, you know, housing purposes, same as the other dollars we're talking about. The question there was if you want to keep existing dollars going to projects, we still need a way to refund the RLF and so that would be continuing to put the NLU fees there.
1:09:31 If it is reestablished, then it's pretty easy to come back and say, okay, to the extent those fees grow, now they're available for other projects and programs based on the priorities that are set accordingly. John, would you like to kick off this one? Sure. I think that, just getting a little technical and weedy, but I think that the money that comes in as part of number four,
1:09:56 The Housing Reserve Funds to Measure A, right? That's more reliable. We kind of know what that is. And I think we had this immediate need with the RLF. So it makes sense to maybe take that funding source and line up with the RLF. The housing mitigation impact fees, I don't have enough information. My sense is that there's not a lot of money coming from that because we don't have a lot of housing projects going on, but I don't know. And I think that that money is a less reliable source. And so I would like to get some more analysis of, OK, what does that look like? How clumsy is that?
1:10:25 And how quickly, if we can use the Measure A money to get back up to $300,000, okay, then we've kind of secured the deed restrictions, we're not going to lose those, but I need more information about the mitigation impact fees, because I, again, I'm kind of, I don't, development in Mammoth Lakes right now is kind of an odd thing. I don't quite know how to make sense of it. I'd like to do some more analysis, get some more information to figure that out.
1:10:53 Okay, is that something that would come up in our November discussion? It'll be later out. We can give you information. It is predicated on how much building happens. We have $186,000 now. About a year ago, we were a little less than a year. We were at $70,000, so we got a good bump. Will we get another bump in the next three months? We don't know. It is as funds come in, and I think if you track it, it really isn't, it's up and down. So it really is tied to the building cycle.
1:11:21 No, we don't have a good answer for that at this point. Well, I think John's answer was correct. The housing mitigation fees are intended specifically to create housing to meet the needs of what is being built commercially in Mammoth. So it would make sense to use those funds into a pot to solve that need, thereby put it towards specific projects, where the Measure A dollars were just general, so it would make sense to replace the RLF with those funds.
1:11:50 Can I just add one quick comment to it, Bill? Sure. I think that in discussions with the Chamber and businesses and others, I think at this point, having an expectation that somehow the community, through various mechanisms, is going to address the workforce housing issue for people coming in here and wanting to start businesses, I think we have an opportunity to kind of flip that around a little bit, to say, look, you want to come into town, you want to build a hotel, you want to do something, what are you doing to provide for your workforce?
1:12:18 Because if you don't provide a workforce as part of your business plan and what you're doing, you're not going to be successful. And I think that may be a conversation to start having. Certainly if there are projects coming to the town for development agreements or they're coming for variances or any of the rest of it, it's like, well, fine, we can have that conversation. But what, you know, you're not going to succeed if you can have 40 or 50 workers. Where are you going to house those people?
1:12:40 And start putting that onus and that burden on these people who want to do business this year to be proactive about it. It's just a thought. Yeah, but that goes back to the housing mitigation fees that we charge. Are they appropriate? So I believe what you're saying is we need to go back and have that conversation. We could. So we can tell them coming in what they will be expected to pay. Does the fact that your project generates the need for five housing units, does the fee we charge pay for those units? Exactly. And that's a place that we have to go.
1:13:09 And figure that back out again. So I think that's council work that needs to be done. Okay. Kirk, I'm going to skip you because looking at this, I see that you have more comments about this. So Stacey, do you have anything to add? No, because I want to give you time. Don't worry. This is more of a council. We haven't discussed it as a Mammoth Lakes Housing Board. So I, you know.
1:13:37 Oh, okay. We can urge council to figure out a way to fund it. Yeah, I mean, I don't have the knowledge of all of your funding sources and how they can be allocated. So, you know, my one concern would be if you guys were to move the litigation fees to something else, how to replace them so that there's still a funding source. I don't know those things. So, again, I agree with Stacey. It is one of your guys' plate. But I don't think, don't take away the funding and not replace it with something kind of thing. Okay.
1:14:07 Go ahead. Yeah, I feel similar to the last item, funding the RLF is important, and I think to John's point, just looking at some of the money between the housing mitigation fees or the housing reserve funds and what rules are attached to those and then placing them appropriately because how they need to be used to be sure that we're, and kind of to Bill's point as well, that we're using them as they need to be used.
1:14:36 I've got a quick question for maybe Patricia and Dan, being that I'm a rookie to the MLH board, but so the town's funding $300,000 to the revolving loan fund, and you said the county's got an equal amount? $300,000? What's that? Is the county? Yeah, the county has an RLF at $300,000 as well, and then the town has a revolving loan fund that's currently sitting at $186,000. But restored to $300,000. So we have a total of $600,000 to buy back. That would be correct.
1:15:04 Which, what's the average unit price that we're buying back? It depends, maybe around $250. So we've got enough to cover two. Two. Two. Centaneous. Ten to roll. There may be three coming up. Potentially, it could be. So, anyway, it sounds like we've got a bare minimum, I guess is my point. And I think as we get further along and develop more units, we may need to have a bigger reserve for, right? So I just thought it's something we shouldn't lose sight of. So it sounds like we just have enough.
1:15:34 You know, cover, you know, could get a little sketchy. I just hate to see us in a situation where, oh my God, we're short. Maybe then we come back to the town council and say, well, you know what, we need a little bit more. I think we're talking just a little bit of a crisis situation, which is fine. But I think, you know, as we work on our literacy and figure out how we do things, drilling down a little bit deeper in those deed restrictions and really understanding, are they written properly?
1:15:59 Are they coming back on the market too easily? Are there things that we can do to really, you know, ironclad that or bulletproof so they're stronger? Because if not, then we need maybe that RLF, we're going to have to bump that up. Yeah. And, you know, depending on economic cycles and conditions, right? I mean, if you look back to the crash, you know, the last real estate crash, you know, we would never have had enough money to buy a home and back, right? I mean, so just recognize that, I think, as we move forward. And I don't know, you know, I mean.
1:16:28 You know, we'll see where our cycle goes here, but there's always cycles in real estate. And that's the thing, I think, that what killed us the last time is people never anticipated how bad things would go down, and they never went through that scenario of what if the values go below the deed restriction? Oh, my God. So it's just something we always got to keep our eye on as we move forward because there's going to be big, you know, there'll be turns in economic cycles as we move forward. So those are just my thoughts on that. And I think...
1:16:56 As much as the specific on the question about using the mitigation fees, yeah, I mean, once we have the fund replenished, I'm certainly supportive of that. I've got very, very strong opinions about how we fund housing from a developer's perspective. And so I think there should never be an expectation that a developer should come in and fund all the housing that does provide for his workforce. That's absurd.
1:17:25 I think the point is that... It may not be that absurd. Well, nothing will get built is the bottom line. So it's just a question of what the community wants to do, right, in terms of economic growth. And so, you know, the point is I think you've got to recognize where funds come from for housing and they come from other sources as well. And let's say, okay, what percentage of equity do we need and how much can we leverage with grant funds and other sources of funding for housing to get the housing built and not overburden?
1:17:54 Sure. The development so it never gets built. Anyway. And Kirk, I think you may, would you like to speak on this since you've took all this nice time to do this? 600,000. You mentioned the 2008 crash and how many units that we lost, 20 just in that. What happened is that the developers came to us, they had built this product, it was deed restricted, but
1:18:22 They had not been able to sell, and guess what? It couldn't sell, even at deed restricted because of the crash. I think the $600,000 is insufficient. And the reason I say that is because you mentioned the crash, but look at what is going on at the federal level. Mammoth Lakes does not exist in isolation.
1:18:42 I mean, if these trade wars with China keep escalating, and they seem to be as well as the TPP, as well as what's going on in Europe, we could have another downturn. And everybody, you know, is speculating. So, you know, when we say, should a housing reserve fund be used to replenish the RLF?
1:19:03 Yes, and we need to, you know, if it's only $186,000, then the town needs to budget more money, as well as I think that that is just simply not enough money in the RLF. We need to get that up to a million dollars so that if four units come on at one time, that we're able to do it. We can pull that money back if things don't.
1:19:27 Happen. Or if another project comes before the council, they can pull that money out if something needs to happen with another piece of property out there. But I think we need to get it up as high as possible. $600,000 is not enough. Okay. Well, again, I feel as though I'm hearing consensus on this that that is something. And to me, you're making a heck of a lot of sense saying let's keep what we have.
1:19:57 So thank you for your comments. Dan, you look like you wanted to say something. No, I think we have pretty good consensus between these. We'd probably look at coming back, bringing it to the $300,000 out of the Measure A money, leaving the mitigation fees in place. Sound like there may be down the road more information on that. I understand, yeah, you could build that fund up again, but we know we have other projects out there that are going to be competing for housing dollars. So we'll start choosing and saying, okay, which ones have priorities and how do we move dollars around?
1:20:27 I mean, we talk about projects in general. We know we have one for sure, but I think there's other demands within the housing action plan and stuff that comes forward. So I wouldn't say put everything into revolving loan fund at this point or you'll come back and just put it in and pull it right back out again, frankly. But I do agree down the road, if you have additional dollars that could go into there, that's probably not a bad place to put some of that. You could argue if MLH has additional funding left at the end of a year and it's retained there, I could argument the same program.
1:20:56 Can I ask one quick question? Would it be in terms of the town's reserve for economic uncertainty? I mean, is it possible you could tap into that to help cover a shortfall on a mortgage buyback or on a deep restriction buyback? Let me say, is it legal? Yes. Would we recommend doing it? No. I'm just wondering, I mean, you know, just if there's a way to share some of these reserves for economic uncertainty, essentially, it's kind of what we're talking about, right? Something that's driven by...
1:21:25 Economic forces we can't necessarily predict, but just... My fear on that is I don't want to have reserves that are built on IOUs. I think the town did that once before. It didn't work out that well. Okay. Sorry. I'll be very blunt on that one. I know in talking with our bond folks and stuff of that nature, if they see that, that's no longer considered a reserve at that point. IOUs don't count. Put it that way. Sorry.
1:21:49 Appreciate the comment. Yeah, and I think that's something that maybe can come back in the November discussion because I think I view the economic uncertainty maybe a little bit differently.
1:22:04 That's for the really bad things. And I know we've been talking about this as a crisis to me. This is something really tough. It's going to take a lot of work to do, but this is not a crisis. A crisis is if none of us had a home and we were working from the government in a street. So I just want to say we're using the word crisis, but I think that's a little bit of a stretch. It's definitely my main focus, but the crisis.
1:22:33 I've been through a crisis before and this is not it. So now if we pretty much have a mayor. I just wanted to clarify something I said earlier. Mammoth Lakes Housing manages a rental wait list of approximately 75 households and that wait list is for approximately, it's for 82 rental units that Mammoth Lakes Housing manages that wait list for. I said 182, so it's 82.
1:23:01 That was the Kirk's question. Yes. So it's a little crisis to me. Yeah. I just wanted to say that I just wanted to put it out that then everybody says crisis and I think that that puts like a puts your brain into a different panic mode rather than something that we can just
1:23:23 Actually get through this. So I just want to let you know, every time you say a crisis, it makes my brain go into a hyper mode that is not conducive to our goal. So I just wanted to let you guys know that that's just a thing I have.
1:23:39 I have to. There are people, though, living off the government living in the street. No, there are cars in the woods. Okay. You know what? I did not mean to start a discussion on that one. I've been talking to people from other towns, and they have a crisis. And so I just want to put things in perspective that maybe it is for people in Mammoth. Forget I said that. Take that off the agenda, please.
1:24:03 And then going back to we have about a half an hour now. And so now we are going to go back to item three or C. And you know what? Let's go to item six at first. Should town staff formalize a housing working group with the intent that they provide oversight feedback on the implementation of the housing action plan?
1:24:32 And if we may, I'll let Sandra speak to that real quick. Oh, okay. I think that'll help frame up the question.
1:24:39 Right, so the housing action plan, obviously we had a housing working group that helped shepherd the needs assessment in the housing action plan through the process. It was a pretty broad range of people from different agencies, NGOs, and so one of the questions that we had is as we move forward with implementation of the housing action plan, should we reach out kind of beyond kind of town staff, town commissions, and then the MLH board?
1:25:08 To get kind of a broader, some broader input on the implementation of the housing action plan. So that was really the question. I'm just posing that to the group tonight. Would you like to start on this one, Stacey? Sure. If you would be so kind as to hand me a microphone. Sorry. There you go. Thank you. I support this concept. I was a member of the housing working group.
1:25:33 Which was an incredible experience. And as I recall, when it came down, as these complex public processes sometimes go, got down to the wire last December, and we were running out of time on really important issues like the timeline, roles and responsibilities, and how do we move forward from here? We ran out of time.
1:26:00 The consultant put out the question of, you know, how do we track this? How do we maintain accountability? And the question was posed, do we have an oversight committee with this group? At that time, I was supportive of it, but it was put to a vote by a slim majority. For whatever reason, working group members didn't opt to do this.
1:26:29 Now, nine months later, the level of community concern and interest in this, I'd like to see us do this, have some kind of public oversight committee, and I would recommend it. I want to be fully honest about how it went down at the Housing Working Group meeting, but I think there is a need for greater, not that there isn't a level of transparency, but just a greater
1:27:01 Effort to make this available to the public and starting with that housing working group with those engaged committed members would be a good thing to do. Okay, so we'll get some pros and cons on that one. Would anyone care to start? All right. John, go ahead, please. I'll open my mouth. John, please. No, no, you go ahead. You're better at opening your mouth than me. Okay, I'll take that as a compliment. I definitely support this. I think that
1:27:30 As we have struggled in the previous six or nine months to try to find homes of various things. And I think that
1:27:40 The reality of how the town's configured, I think if I'm looking forward to discussion with MLH to reaffirm if that's the way the board wants to go around the CHOTO and their governance restrictions on that, that's fine. But I think it's critically important to have a stakeholder group like this. And I think it's I heard after the last sort of our town council meeting that we didn't.
1:28:02 Went late and it was kind of challenging. I've heard from a number of people who are legitimate stakeholders in this community that want to be part of this. And I think anybody in this community that wants to show up to be part of the solutions of this, we have an obligation to provide that for them. And I would hope that we could use the Housing Summit in November as a formal kickoff for that group. Whoever wants to show up, be part of that. No restrictions on it except to be.
1:28:27 Productive and be civil and to understand what's going on, but I absolutely support this. I think it's critically needed. I think it's something that we absolutely have to convene to make sure we're beating the bushes for every stakeholder's got an interest, housing for their staff, housing for their employees, housing for the community. We've got to make sure we're catching everything. I think this is a critical thing to pursue. Okay, thank you. Bill? So my take on this is a little bit different. I am never in favor of just increasing bureaucracy for the sake of increasing bureaucracy.
1:28:58 There needs to be an oversight committee of some sort. I would like us to look into the possibilities of using MLH staff as it gets re-upped, plus some MLH members, some town staff, and some council members to be that group perhaps, not saying it will or won't work, but then we're not creating another whole different level or layer of housing plan. Who do they report to? Is it Mammoth Lakes Housing? Is it the town of Mammoth Lakes?
1:29:25 So I think this bears some scrutiny to see how we can best fill this. If we have partners in the community that want to step forward and volunteer to serve, I think that's great. But I don't know that we need to create a whole other entity in order to achieve that. But I just want to emphasize, I take a little exception with their bureaucracy. I think I'm looking for...
1:29:51 There are stakeholders in this community who've got something to bring to help us solve this problem. And I don't care who the hell it is. If they're willing to show up and participate and be civil and understand what the role is going to look like, that's what I'm looking for. Right. But then there are staffing considerations which cost more money, which takes money from things. There are all sorts of things. So that's a point of contention for you. Kirk, what do you think about that?
1:30:17 Well, I think it's premature. And one of the reasons that I think it's premature is because we haven't unveiled what's happening on one major project that's coming forward. But the more important thing is we don't have a budget and staff time allocated to the housing action plan. We need to have that information. You need to have factual information for any kind of working group to be effective.
1:30:43 I mean, what are they going to base their recommendations or anything on if they don't have, shall we say, the Housing Action Plan? What does it cost? What is the town's priority? What's the staffing to do the different tasks within there? I mean, there's 25 different tasks in that, and you have these different timelines and everything else. I mean, all this information's there, and we don't have staffing and funding.
1:31:12 To do a lot of this, a lot of this. So, you know, I agree with Bill. I mean, you know, and then we're going to use staff time and everything else. So there might be a time that this comes forward, but I think we need basic information before this group is formulated. Okay. Anybody for a man? Oh, you know what? I would like to welcome Donna Mercer to the meeting. I hope I'm not speaking out of turn. This is going to be Donna's.
1:31:42 Last meeting, she has resigned because of the formation of it. There were some issues. And I just wanted to let you know, I've really never met you, but I've watched many of the meetings, and I've always thought you gave very thoughtful input. So I wanted to thank you publicly for your service on the MLH board. We are talking right now about the Housing Working Group. Tom, did you have anything that you wanted to say, or did you already get a chance to address that?
1:32:11 You know, I hear, I hear, I think, all good comments, and I don't disagree with Kirk and Bill as much as it might be a little premature right now. I mean, I think there's this housing summit we're talking about having in November. I think that's going to be a real fruitful event and help to lay some groundwork and educate the public. And, you know, maybe adapt would be a great opportunity to put a list out, you know, put a volunteer sheet out to say who's interested.
1:32:41 You know, as we start to get our legs under ourselves here, see what happens with the housing coordinator position with the town, MLH getting backfilling the next staff position there. We have some, start to build some ability to get, start taking these things on, as you say, and staff and budget and what have you. I certainly see that it could be a benefit and as much as, you know, anybody wants to.
1:33:04 Participate in the effort of housing in our community. We shouldn't discourage that. So I support it generally. I think the timing is, you know, at the right time and it makes sense and start teeing it up. It makes some sense to me. I have been going back and forth about this question. I feel a bit like Bill does, that if we're adding one town staff member to be a housing coordinator,
1:33:34 Housing Coordinator. Then the civic person, fellow, I believe you call them, who's going to also do housing. And then we have Mammoth Lakes Housing Staff, and then we have a housing board. I do feel like that's a lot of people looking at housing, and I would like to put out there right now to everyone listening or in the crowd, we are accepting new board members. So this is a great opportunity if we do have people who are interested in housing on a full-time
1:34:03 Not full-time, I shouldn't say that, but on a more possibly long-term basis, we can have one member of the community on our board, and then we can also, we need one person who would represent the low-income community. So I'm going to throw that out there. That's a great way to get involved, no matter how this question goes. The part that kind of got me was...
1:34:25 To provide oversight. And I guess, and I know, again, it's semantics, but we wanted to be specific about things. And it's that feeling of we'll create one more group to look at housing and who do they report to? How does that kind of work? If they don't like what's happening that MLH is doing or the town is doing, how does that then information, how does that information get disseminated and how legitimate is that?
1:34:56 Housing Working Group's opinion, maybe, and how does that sort of come down the pipeline? But then it's hard because I do agree with John. The more people, if somebody wants to get involved but maybe can't meet every Monday and be on our board, how do we involve them? So I go back and forth and I have some comments. I feel like in our next item on the CHOTO, maybe this is the perfect solution to have a housing working group, keep CHOTO status. So I'll get into that on the next item. Oh, okay. Yeah.
1:35:27 Thank you. Donna, I won't put you on the spot since you just got here. Giselle? I currently don't feel like I have any comments that are with further conversation, so. Okay, thank you. And Stacy, did I, or did you start that one off? Yeah, I started. Oh, you started that one off. Okay, so I'm kind of getting a consensus that we're not really quite sure. I personally think that it's a good idea, but what Bill and
1:35:56 Kirk did talk about that maybe taking some time on that. I am looking at the names of the people who served and thank you very much. And then maybe in October as well, that's something that these people can come forward that are still interested and see where we are with that. Just since we have 20 minutes left and I know this is going to be kind of a long one, we are now going to move on to the Chodo question. So that will be.
1:36:24 We'll be addressing number three and then number seven or C and G. So I'll go ahead and read both. Number three is part of the town's contract with MLH. Should Choto administration be included? If so, accounting of activity and use of funds need to be specifically accounted for. Let's go ahead and talk about that one for a moment and then we'll go into
1:36:52 Well, you know what? Can I do both at the same time? I'm going to do these both at the same time. And then the follow-up question for that is, does the Town Council support MLH's maintaining its status as a CHOTO? So who would like to kick this one off? Oh, Giselle, there you go. Giselle's kicking it off. So with the aspect of
1:37:23 The Chodo administration being a part of the Mammoth Lakes Housing Contract, I don't think that's necessary when we are doing a grant that under the Chodo status, that grant pays for the administrative work for the Chodo. So I don't necessarily see why the town's money needing to go towards that since we have a funding source that allows for the upkeep.
1:37:52 of those grant funds and the administration that is a part of it. And then with the second part of does the Town Council support Mammoth Lakes Housing maintaining it? I mean, my suggestion would be to say yes, that I would love for the Town Council to be in support of it because all the CHOTO really does, yes, it does open up for
1:38:16 Other funding streams, but it also ensures representation of all different groups, public, low income, and then a third group that's more open that can be anybody from the community. So there's no limitations that really come from the CHOTO because all it does is ensure voices from all communities are present, but it doesn't say you're not allowed or you're not allowed. It just keeps the presence of those. And, Lindsay, it seemed as though you had some things about this.
1:38:44 Yeah, thank you. As far as the funding for administrative fees, I was under the same impression, and again, this just comes back to making sure that we're all in the same knowledge about everything, but that when we apply for money that would come through the CHOTO status, that it comes with some administrative money. So maybe I'd like to have Patricia speak to that first, if we can, to make sure we're understanding. Yeah, sure.
1:39:14 Chodo administration doesn't take any additional staff time or monies to administer Chodo. We're already an established 501c3. We follow the Brown Act in accordance with our contract with the town. Any additional funding that would fund a specific project, we would deal with that funding as needed through grants.
1:39:41 So you don't see that having CHOTO status for the organization, just simply the status adds any expenses. Yes. Special projects, we have, there's one bit, page 10, about some money and there's, we've applied for $100,000 for operating funds, things like that. That's, then we're able to cover it. So that, I'm, that's kind of, was my understanding as well.
1:40:10 My other thought then about the status of the Chodo is it just gives us more buckets of money to choose from. It allows us to apply for more money. And I think that in the initial talks about becoming a Chodo organization was before my time.
1:40:29 I think as far as I can understand and what's in here is that was really important to the board. Just open up more funding sources, which I don't see. I can't see how that can be a bad thing. I think what we've gotten into on our board is it limits the way that we can recruit new board members. And that's been holding us back a little bit is that we can have.
1:40:50 Giselle just mentioned. They're sort of, you split our board into three parts. One third can be open members of the public. One third is elected officials or employees of public organizations. And then one is representatives of the low income community. But then what it says is when we need to find new board members, the members who are elected officials or work for a public organization cannot
1:41:18 Be involved, and I highlighted here, they cannot, may not appoint the remaining two-thirds of the directors. So it makes some of our board members not be, they're not allowed to be part of that process, and I think that's been really hard. So kind of in looking at the housing working group, I thought what happens is I think some of our board members couldn't put their voice out there as much for people that they really wanted to be on the board. This might allow some of those people to be involved.
1:41:46 So maybe that's a great thing. We've talked carts and horses and eating elephants. Maybe we're eating cake and having cake and eating it too here. But I think that at the end of the day, the Chodo status gives us more possible money. And I don't see how that's bad. Going back to the housing working group, I have concerns about adding one more layer of people.
1:42:16 I don't know the right, but just one more layer to the housing process. But I think if it brings in more people to be involved, then maybe that's a great way to do it. Okay. I'm hearing some pros here. Do we have any cons on this item at all? Or any thoughts for the CHOTO from you fellas? I'm very encouraged by the progress.
1:42:44 of the conversation among MLH board members around this topic. And I'm very much looking forward to a very robust discussion among the MLH board members about this question. I am personally agnostic about this. And I really want to have that discussion with the MLH board. And I want to, I would like to use the home application that was recently submitted as a test case.
1:43:13 For the MLH Board to go through that and understand, okay, if there are going to be gaps in funding, what is our exposure, what is our liability, make sure that we're clear about all that. So if we've got to come up with some money to fill it, we understand what that means. I also want to have very specific legal and administrative representation.
1:43:34 From MLH or from whoever, so that we can really understand what the role of MLH as a chodo is going to be vis-a-vis our relationship with the town. My understanding is that if MLH continues as a chodo, there's some things that we have to do.
1:43:51 I'm not well-versed in this, but things like keeping administrative, separate administrative books around administrative monies and things like that. I don't know about this stuff, but I want to make sure that we as a board, it's crystal clear to us, if we're going down that road, we understand what that's all about, the town can understand what that's all about, and the community can understand what that's all about. So it's very clear, MLH is a choto. This is what MLH does.
1:44:17 It's very clear. So the expectations of what the town can or cannot do, it's clear. So we all know what the hell is going on. So I'm very excited to have that conversation. And like I said, I'm going to defer. I would even say as an elected representative on that board, I don't even know if I could vote on that. I don't know if that's appropriate for me to vote on that. That may be something. But again, I don't know. That's something to talk about. But I very much am encouraged by
1:44:43 Lindsay's representation about the role of this stakeholder group. I would be more than happy to consider taking that oversight thing out of there, but just to give a forum so that the folks who are interested in this thing, it's like, man, I don't want to be in a board. I don't want to do this. That's not hard to convene and facilitate a forum to do that kind of stuff.
1:45:03 I mean, that's not a huge staff burden. I don't think they do that. But to make sure that there are people out there who don't fit here, they don't fit there, but they're engaged and they can say, hey, we can bring something either the MLH's efforts or the town's efforts. So I'm very encouraged and I very much appreciate your thoughts. I look forward to having that discussion with the board and make sure if that's what we want to do, we understand what that means and what the implications are, what the exposures are and all the rest of it. And that's going to help really inform the contract with the town a lot.
1:45:28 It's also going to help us inform our staffing because then we're going to know we're doing CHOTO. Okay, that means we're a development organization. We've got a staff to that. It's going to bring a lot of clarity to where we go from here. I think that's going to be a very important step forward. Bill, do you have anything to say on that? Pretty much what John said. I don't know enough about it. Kirk was nice enough to make me up a packet so I could educate myself some, and I have, but there are still questions about how CHOTO.
1:45:53 Works versus a regular non-profit board and the government entities on the board. I do know that there are funding sources that the Chotos can get that Mammoth Lakes Housing and the Town can't get. I know there are funding sources the Town can get that the housing can't get. And I know there are funding sources that you can get that we can't get. So, as you said, the more the merrier. If we can make this thing work, but it takes us all working together to get it done. That's my bottom line is what is best for the community.
1:46:21 And on the CHOTO, whether it should or shouldn't be, I'm never going to be a housing expert. Yes, that's okay, as long as you're a locking-the-house expert. That's what I can do. Kirk, what are your thoughts on this? $1,985,000 is the grant.
1:46:41 And we've submitted that. So it's about this thick. It's competitive. Hopefully we'll have a chance to do it. And that's 11 units. All the different, you know, concerns, I think, can all be addressed. We can develop a working relationship with the town. But I look at $1,900,000 on the table, and I say 11 units. And if the total can support...
1:47:09 Another project in this community, you know, how about $8.3 million worth of infrastructure, roads and underground utilities, you know, so there's a partnership that needs to be better understood and better developed and I think it can be done. So, you know, I just, again, I mean, the money...
1:47:34 You know, you said a housing, you didn't like the years that they were housing crisis, but the hospital called me and asked if I knew somebody that could take care of somebody that they had to release who lived in the woods. And they asked, could I find somebody to go out and check on him? He's living in a tent. So I think in some respects we are facing a housing crisis.
1:48:02 Yeah, I think this is a really great discussion. I want to thank everybody for engaging in it in a really
1:48:33 Thank you.
1:48:54 So what I thought of in terms of answering these questions, does Town Council support MLH maintaining its status as a CHOTO? I'm not on Council, but I would, in order for Council to opine on this or make a decision or recommendation,
1:49:11 I would just ask the question, what does CHOTO status mean for the partnership and potentially the contract between the town and MLH? Does status as a community housing development organization somehow interfere with or impact Mammoth Lakes Housing's ability to deliver on the contract for providing?
1:49:35 Programming and services and potentially project management. Really concretely, is that an issue? There are some barriers maybe that we've identified particularly or challenges around Mammoth Lakes Housing Board development, but there are also some great opportunities in making sure that we're hearing
1:49:56 Thank you so much. Thank you.
1:50:21 And on that, is there a timeline that where this kind of decision and the grant will dovetail with that November meeting? Or is this something, what's the timeline on the? Well, as far as the town's finances coming back, there'll be October versus November. Excuse me, October. No, the CHOTO grant is on. I'm not sure the timeline for that. And then that's a different process at this point. The awards are supposed to be announced in December.
1:50:47 Oh, in December. Oh, okay. And it's already been submitted, so that's something we have a little bit, the October meeting would fit with it. We wouldn't be discussing the CHOTO at that point. Oh, okay. It's not a funding, the funding question comes up to the town, if I may, there's three things that run into that. One being, we have a contract dollar amount of X dollars that goes to Mammoth Lakes Housing, and we end up with the CHOTO admin money. Is there an offset against the town's dollars, or does it just go to the pot and sit there?
1:51:14 For other purposes, assuming the admin money is funding the same staff, so we're funding them twice. That's an issue that our auditor brings up now and again, so we need to look at that. There's also in the law, there's some restrictions of a subrecipient, making sure that we're not subsidizing CHOTO activities with subrecipient money, which basically is to grant funds that we do pay the MLH for the first-time homebuyer program. So that's an accounting exercise to say, make sure that those things are kept clean and separate.
1:51:43 Because there is some federal restrictions in terms of how we do that. So that's the accounting process and then managing the town's funds and how are those accounted for against.
1:51:52 Those other revenues coming in. So, I mean, that's doable, just we have to write it up, but there is some accounting processes that we need to make very clear in that process. Okay, I am going to want to give some people, like, one minute apiece to talk, but could this be within the wrap-up of future items to bring forward to the Town Council on Mammoth Lakes Housing? I'll just say this, as the Council's representative of the MLH Board, the need for coordination and communication with this particular relationship, I think, exceeds that of anything else I can think of.
1:52:21 And I just say that going forward. We have to be communicating effectively and regularly to be on the same page. So I'll leave it at that. You know what? I entirely agree with you. Thank you, everybody, for all your comments. I didn't know what to expect today, but I feel like I've got a better idea where everybody's coming from. I do agree we need to meet on this, make sure we're using the same terminology. And I'm sorry about this, but I will take public comment, but I will keep you to one minute if anybody has something to say.
1:52:50 Tom Heller, I had a whole list of prepared comments, but what I want to hit on and emphasize is from the public's point of view, this is the first time I've seen you guys sit down and actually have a constructive conversation. From my standpoint, what I've seen over the last year or so has been bickering, has been infighting, has been
1:53:20 No conversation between the two entities. And this is kind of enlightening. It actually works when everybody sits down. What I would suggest is you do this more often. Maybe you create subgroups amongst each one of you that get together on a frequent basis from the contract standpoint. Maybe that subgroup then can work on those upcoming issues so that when you actually implement something, you're not starting all over again trying to start.
1:53:49 Afresh with a new contract. And lastly, the working group, the housing working group, being a member of that, had some real validity to it. The suggestion I'd have for Mammoth Lakes Housing is every two months have an open house. Invite whoever shows up. It doesn't matter who it is, but what that does is that gives you a list of people, as Tom said, that gives you that list of people who you can call upon when you have a vacancy. And there'll be a better understanding as to what it is you're doing. Thank you.
1:54:19 No, thank you. Good evening, Jennifer Halfordy. I wanted to clarify a few things and talk about a few things. The RLF is really important, and I'm so glad to hear that consistency across the board, I felt like. But I do agree that more money would be prudent. There's nothing to say that the county wouldn't waiver on theirs. You know, I know they have the $300,000 there now, but...
1:54:49 You know, they're looking at what to do with housing going forward. We're having a meeting next week with the Planning Commission on a housing toolkit. So it's probably a good idea to try to bolster that amount, especially in the light of a potential economic downturn. I mean, that's always an option, right? We always know that's on the horizon. Our real estate market goes in cycles.
1:55:15 And when it is down, that is when people sell, and that's when nobody's buying, and that's when you really need to have money. And you being the community and the housing fund has to have plenty of money, that's one of the things that we learned from the book that we read.
1:55:34 And that Aspen did so well and does so well. They don't stop funding housing and buying housing in a down market. That's actually when they start buying housing. So you actually need tons more money then because that's when you want to be...
1:55:48 Gathering those up and keeping them so when the cycle flips again, which it will, you have housing stock available. You're not trying to recover on a climbing market. I'm sorry to cut you off here, but we are going into the next meeting. It's really unfortunate the public doesn't have more time to talk. Thank you. Well, you know what? We will have future meetings. Thank you very much. Sandy Hogan, temporarily disabled. Oh, no. I need surgery. Temporarily.
1:56:21 Okay, a couple of quick points. One, Mammoth Lakes Housing needs more money. More money needs to be set aside. I don't, let's face it, I see Mammoth Lakes Tourism still floating way up there and things like that need to be leveled or maybe moved over a bit. The program of work is just absolutely massive, diverse, fragmented, and I don't know how.
1:56:49 You keep your head straight, Patricia, because for one person, oh my gosh, one thing in the housing action plan, action plan that are accepted, you know, you can change them, there's no legal requirement or amendment. One thing in there, it says additional staff is needed for both agencies, and at the time it was written, there were two. So that means three, doesn't it? And then, when I look at in lieu fees,
1:57:17 Just like in-lieu parking fees not being even to come up as an urgent policy matter, you're going to be left in the same position we are right now with parking and everything else. There's no money for it. Let's, and I mean, our in-lieu fees right now are really low for housing. We know that, far too low. So I would hope that that could be pushed up on the staffs. Sandra and I have talked about this in a different, but I mean.
1:57:44 It's got to be accounted for, and you've got to think about it up first, and if you don't create those policies, development happens, and you go, oh, I guess we should have done this. It's called lessons learned, just like San Joaquin Villas, lessons learned, the hard way.
1:58:00 Thank you for your comments. And as far as some of the public comments, this was a discussion between two groups that this is a rare treat for us to get together. So I don't want people to feel shorted from the public. You will have so much input on this project moving forward. And I want to thank you. I didn't take the time for all your remarks. I heard some really good remarks and some really honest back and forth that I really want to thank you for your remarks. And I think trust is the word. Trust in others' expertise.
1:58:29 Trust in the other's goodwill and, you know, intent and understand when one party can't deliver for a reason, there's a reason a lot of times. Thanks. Okay. No, thank you so much and thank you to everybody and with that we're going to adjourn and then Mammoth Lakes Housing has their regular board meeting starting as soon as the chair calls it to order. Would you like my candy?
1:58:58 I'm not a Kit Kat eater. Get out of here, mate. You might get real good in the song. I know. No, thank you so much for being my little... You know what? I tell you, I think we're all pretty much on the same page with a lot of things.