TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2018

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board

· recording 3 hr 19 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

426 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

9:03 I'd like to acknowledge, first and foremost, Whitney's eight years of commitment as the marketing director for MLT. She will be leaving September. She just got disconnected. She just got disconnected. Timing. Whitney's last day is September 21st. Is that correct? John? Yes. Might be worth getting her back on the phone before we acknowledge her time. Please enter your six-digit conference code. Welcome to conference calling. If you are the host, please enter your four-digit host code.

9:49 If you are not the host, we will now connect you to your call. There are three attendees in this conference. The host has joined the conference. Whitney, are you there? We are here. Okay, perfect. Amanda Clinton, myself. Okay, great, thanks. Hello. So, Whitney, it seems like the timing, we were just talking about point three on the agenda at acknowledging the eight years that you've spent committed to the organization and wanted to thank you for your service. I know that John had some things, but that was our first order of business.

10:21 Sorry to see you go, but obviously wishing you a good life in Arizona and wherever that takes you. John, if you have... Yeah, I just want to thank Whitney for her years of service with us. When I came to the organization in July of 2010, she came on board very, very shortly thereafter, and really that's when we started building the team, and she's been a huge, huge piece of our successes over the years, working with the agencies and really getting us to this level, and she will definitely be missed, but...

10:49 Whitney, I just want to say thank you for all the years. You've been part of our team. Thank you. I appreciate that. And then we also have a new employee coming on board October 15th. As most of you know, we've been working on getting a director of special events in this town for a couple of years. And fortunately, we are to add Caroline Casey to us. And I'd love to have Caroline if you want to just come up and give us a little bit of an intro. Hello, everyone. Thank you guys for...

11:25 I'm very, very excited to be in this position, and it's something that I've been hoping was going to happen for many, many years. I think it's a crucial position for kind of aligning the town and for getting everybody together, and we can really grow events pretty quickly here. I'm definitely excited to hit the ground October 15th and have a lot of ideas are churning quickly, so both from small things, big things. I hope to tack off a few things immediately and then start to work on some bigger things.

11:54 Definitely looking for it. We just had a great Mammoth Gran Fondo, and Eric will expand too, but 1,700 riders, it's the biggest, I think it's the biggest event in the county, certainly the biggest one-day event, and I need some better numbers, but it certainly brought in over a million dollars of revenue into the town, and actually I think it's more, it's quite more than that, but we'll get some good stats on that, but huge, huge increase in that ride, and I think

12:23 Sets us forward for some good stuff in the future. Thank you guys very much. Welcome aboard. Do you have any board member comments or external committee comments at this time or any agenda additions? I think we can talk about it as we get down to that point. Scott, I had a comment on item 8, new business.

12:56 I just wanted to say that I was a little taken off guard by surprising the community and a little disappointed, I guess, or concerned or confused. I don't know what the emotion is, but that all of that came about and the knowledge that I have on this issue comes from two articles in the sheet in consecutive weeks versus anything from the board, board chair, anything. And I see here that there's even going to be a discussion on a vote. You're talking about 8-1?

13:26 8-1. Yeah. Thank you. And I just am wondering if there was another way that that could have been handled, that the board could have had more vision. I mean, I was really caught flat-footed in the community by that. And I didn't have any information, any guidance, any anything to address these questions when they were put forth to me. Other than, like I said, I'll have to read the sheet and see what that's all about and then get back to you. Right.

13:56 I would say that going through, especially with the Brown Act training most recently, is that the executive committee members that were in that initial session don't have the right or the privilege to be able to communicate outside of that session to the general board with any comment or feedback on that, which is why that doesn't get communicated out from the board chair or from any of the executive committee members. If the executive committee was to communicate to the general board in private in an email or an update, that'd be a violation of the Brown Act. Even of the notice of such meeting?

14:25 Just the fact that there's going to be a meeting? I'm not sure how the hosting of the meeting, if that was there, was not shared out to the rest of the board when that was presented. John or Emily, we have to speak to that, but it was a publicly posted meeting and meeting notifications would come from the executive director as board chair. I can't send out a notice that says you should come to this meeting or not. Okay, fair enough. It just seemed like some of the issues that were in the second, the follow-up article in the sheet,

14:55 reference things that happen up to six months or more previous, and I just felt like, how did that get to here without any kind of a heads up or understanding of what was going on in that process? That's all. I think that's the appropriate time as we get to 8-1 is we can address those questions at that time, if that's okay. Okay, fair enough. Be more specific in that period, if that works. Okay. Any other board comments or agenda additions? Okay.

15:25 Public comment? I believe we have several people like to make public comment. When you come up to public comment, please state your name and the nature of your affiliation or organization and what you're representing. I think I know most of you. My name is Ward Jones, Canadian interoper, actually, but I'm well invested here in the motel business, holiday house, hostel, tree house, and Idleweiss Lodge. So these are observations. I'm not pointing fingers at anybody. I just think like maybe

15:57 They might plant a seed with you guys to proceed on some of it. I am a business guy. I've been doing a lot of stuff. So my first one was, can I get a loan? I want to buy back my corners like Whiskey Creek and stuff. I was wondering if you guys are giving out loans like Dark Winter's Loan. That's humor, by the way. You'd like me back as a landlord, wouldn't you, Sean? No comment. No comment. Okay. So first off, I'd like to...

16:23 Thank you for public service because people come in here and they throw darts at you all the time and they don't do anything for it so I'm not sitting in your chair. I don't know what you know and it's way easier to be the editor than the author so where we are. A lot of discussions for two years now on MLT's budget and it goes right through town council I know.

16:47 A comment for us at Mooring Coffee, quite often and stuff, I know it's expanded to around $10 million now. I don't think it was ever supposed to get that big. I think it was probably supposed to end up around $5. Somehow the money's managing to be spent. Yes, we have success. I'm not sure if we had $2 million more on last year's budget and TOT was slightly down. So I don't think any of us here, including you guys, know exactly where the results of that $10 million are coming back in.

17:18 As a former retailer, I used to own an ad agency in a former life as well, so I'm not telling you I know anything about it, but just enough to be dangerous. F.W. Wellworth, who was the largest retailer in the world at one time, said he knew that 50 cents out of every dollar that he spent on advertising was wasted. He didn't know which 50 cents it was, so there we are. I think it's a little bit better than now. So back when I was doing a lot of advertising,

17:47 We used to do advertising audits. And I think Deloitte's was doing them for us. And what this is, is this is a hands-off, third party who's not looking for a contract for the next year or whatever, performs a success level on the money you're spending. So if you're spending a million dollars over here, they're going to have a look, is this the target market? Are we reaching them? And more importantly, are they actually coming to Mammoth? So I know you have that data yourselves. This is somebody independent who, that's all they do.

18:18 It also takes the performance of your director, see if that works, if they're duly qualified, et cetera. So I like them. I think it's a good thing to do with $10 million. I think you guys would probably all like the results. Like, how are we really doing from an independent audit from outside this thing? Are we getting the right numbers back? These are just comments. So that's one comment. Another one is,

18:45 I and the smaller businesses in town don't feel we have a voice at MLT. Your vote is controlled by much larger entities. I know we have representatives from lodging and stuff here, but on a smaller basis, when I was sold on TBID, it was, hey, there's going to be some direct advertising for lodging. I don't really see that there. I don't see the in-town stuff that I thought was coming along.

19:14 Can we have kind of more of a vote on major issues than having Rusty and some other large entities control the whole vote? It kind of leaves the rest of us out of it. Leaves the Chevron out, leaves me out, leaves Kirk out, all of us are out. So just food for thought. The airport, I think you ought to get out of the airplane business. You're not good at it. Gone from 50,000 passengers down to 23.

19:39 I think during MLT's tenure, you spent like $5 million in guarantees, and I don't think you're very good at it, and get someone else in there. I think as a board, great, you guys are all there, but it's not working. You've got to figure it out. At $23,000, it's not working. The TOT customer is gone, totally, from the airport. $23,000 is us going in and out. There is no TOT stuff left on this thing, so I think you can revamp this whole thing. For years, I've been wondering about Las Vegas.

20:09 Ski Week material to come into Las Vegas for your first night and spend your last night in Las Vegas and come skiing in Mammoth. One of the things I hate doing is flying over where I'm going and then waiting for a plane and flying back. So Las Vegas has more direct flights than anywhere else in North America, so I think it's something that could be looked at and could be something that you might want to invest money in. It's not going to make money for the first two years, but I think with some investment it would come along. During this audit, I think the...

20:38 Constant conversation is the commingling of assets with Mammoth Mountain. Are they getting more than they should? All the rest of the stuff. So should that be split up? I don't know, but it should be looked at, I think. And, you know, I know from my business and other people's restaurant business and stuff is that spring, summer, and fall now is 65% of the business and winter is 35%. So does that equate to the amount of money that we're spending on things? So I don't know that either. So that's my comments.

21:09 Thank you for listening, and that's all they are is comments. Thank you. Thank you. Any additional comments? Thank you. Sean Turner, Mammoth Marine Company, Bluza Palooza. And I want to make this comment as public, not as board member. I just want to report out that Bluza Palooza has secured a verbal commitment.

21:39 from Dirk Winters to hold the 24th annual event on his property the weekend of August 1 through 4, 2019. Just so everyone knows, I'll be recusing myself from all future discussion and votes between MLT, Dirk Winters, and the Woodside. Just want to be clear on that.

21:55 Again, with regard to Bluesapalooza 2019, I've reached out to the owners of the Otaker property for 2019, but have not yet heard back. As you know, the Otakers did allow Bluesapalooza to lease their property for 2018 and previous years, but did not allow Sierra Classic Theater nor Labor Day Arts Festival to utilize their side of the property in 2018.

22:20 The third property owner that provides a temporary use agreement to Beliza Beliza is I-Star, which owns Uller, Whitestag, and a church property. They have been very generous in previous years and usually give their okay in the spring. As we get closer to the event, this is very important to the behind-the-scene support of the event. I'll provide a three-minute verbal update to town council during public comments.

22:45 on the performance of 2018 Bluesapalooza event in early October, along with the written evaluation report to the town of Mammoth Lakes before then. Thank you very much. Thank you. Any other public comments? Feedback? Sean, thank you for the update on where you're at and for recusing yourself from any of those positions. Obviously, there's a conflict there. Ward, I'd have the pleasure of sitting down with you and going through numbers if you'd ever like. I think that if you get a chance to look at some of the independent

23:20 Some of the things that you've stated of where numbers are, how they're measured or not measured, there may be some lapses in knowledge that you're not aware of that are done in the background. I think saying that no one on this board really knows where the dollars have been spent is untrue. I think most of us spent many, many, many, many hours coming through fine details of this budget and know where it was spent last year and where it's going in the future. So if there's lack of clarification there,

23:47 I'd love to be able to sit with you and go through that. And if you don't feel like you have a seat here, I would connect with the Lodging Association, given the fact that there's, you know, we have a, well, just to be clear, we have a member from Mammoth Mountain Ski Area that votes on this board, and we have the rest of this group that represents the rest of the community in various areas. So to make a statement that there's no one representing the rest of the community here seems a little bit short-sighted.

24:22 And the reason why I stand corrected is there are two people that are appointed here by the lodging association who have a vote quite specifically. I wasn't talking about lodging, I was talking about it. Pertaining to budgets and stuff, I did an actual audit of Mammoth Lakes Tourism last year, so I'm aware of where the money's being spent and some of the reactions that are coming back to you. Bank accounts, I get $5 million in the bank last year at this time and stuff.

24:51 I am aware, but yeah, let's sit down and get to a higher level than I'd love to. Okay, great. Screen freezes. Minutes. Anyone have any questions from the minutes from last month that were in the board packet? Any changes or revisions to the minutes from the meeting of July 11th? No. I'll make a motion that we accept the minutes. We're just going to accept the minutes for both June and...

25:34 So I'm talking specifically the minutes for July 11th.

25:38 Okay.

25:43 So we'll do general board minutes first.

25:49 I move that we accept the minutes from August 1st.

25:53 Second?

25:54 Okay.

25:56 All in favor?

25:57 Aye.

25:57 Aye.

25:58 In the eight centers, abstain.

26:01 Okay, so pass.

26:02 minutes from June 25th

26:04 the executive committee session

26:06 any uh

26:08 Any questions regarding that session? I think that the approval of those minutes can only come from the parties that were present. I will move that we accept the minutes from June 20th. Is that me? No, so the June 25th executive session is Mr. Truax, Mr. Morris, Mr. Schaubmeyer, and Mr. Ledesma. I'll make a motion to accept the minutes. Full second. And any questions?

26:38 All in favor from the group? All right. All right. So accepted. Okay. Moving on to new business, the executive committee member evaluation. Ten minutes. Michael, you had some questions going back to that. You can pick up that conversation now if you'd like. No, it was just a comment, just a board member comment that I was caught flat foot in the community and was...

27:05 Wish that I had had more information on that, especially for the stuff that went back to February and May prior to learning of it in the paper. And I, you know, personally, I apologize for that. I don't know legally if there's any way or possibility for me to have communicated to you without it being a violation of the Brown Act. Even as an update, my understanding of talking to Andy that any communication from my seat of information going out, even dissemination of information, we've had times where

27:35 A member of the board has sent out a, hey, here's something to know about to the entire group, and my understanding is that is not Brown Act compliant, so it's not possible to send general group communications out that way. Staff is allowed to do so, but board members are not. So if you have an article you think we should all read and that gets shared from you to the rest of the board, technically that's a violation. I think we need to be really clear on what that is. I apologize that that's...

28:05 How that comes about. I think maybe in the future the best way to do that is I believe and I know you're a stickler for Brown Act. I believe that if we have a meeting scheduled that staff can notify the rest of the board of a meeting and its agenda if it's of a committee without it being a violation. Is that what you happen to know? That staff is allowed to communicate to the general board but the board members are not to each other. Is it a public meeting? It's a public meeting, yes. Or is it just posted and has to stay publicly posted? I would consult with

28:42 Morris on that one, Andy Morris on that one. You do have to be very careful with, I didn't get a notification of that executive meeting. I think you do run into trouble if you have a certain amount of board members who are there to hear what is going on in the executive committee. That's something that we don't have to deal with on town government, having an executive committee.

29:12 So I'm not the best person to speak on a nine-member board. Got it. Did everyone get a chance to read the questions in the tax response? Does anyone have any questions regarding the questions or response as a discussion? No, but I would like to make a statement, Scott. Sure. So I'm here sitting today wondering why. I'm wondering why did a town council member send me a letter asking me to resign on town letterhead and applying a certain authority? Would I have the audacity?

29:46 to write to a town council member on MLT stationary implying I have some board authority and say that he has overstepped his council role in demanding that he come to the MLT board meeting and resign in front of us. Ted would have a field day with us. Why is town council member trying to dictate who sits on a board and I'd ask who is next? I asked myself why did the board chair approach me and ask me to resign or else?

30:11 Why did he tell me he had the authority of the executive committee to do so, but upon asking other board members, I found there has been no meaning and no formal decision? So why did the chairman tell me this? Does he not like me? Does he not like my employer? It does not matter. There are processes and rules to follow, and we have not done that. I don't know, but I know this. The definition of bullying is to use superior strength or influence to intimidate someone, typically to force him or her to do what he wants, he or she wants. I tell my daughter,

30:44 That if someone approaches you at school and says, use these drugs or else, that's bullying. I will not stand for bullying here at school or anywhere else. I represent the Chamber of Commerce on the MLT Board. I was elected to the Chamber Board and in turn elected to the MLT Board. Everyone on the Chamber Board is fully aware of my role in the community and who I work for. In fact, it was part of a discussion as working for the Sierra Nevada Resort was part of the reason I'm on the board.

31:13 Each board member here wears different hats. You have a town council representative supposedly to keep us aligned and connected with the town government. A Mammoth Mountain representative who is the voice for the mountain. The mountain signs the air service agreement and makes all the necessary guarantees to make air service happen. Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce representative representing the other business interests in the community. Two lodging representatives are a primary source of revenue for this community. 70% of our income comes from lodging.

31:47 One representing retail, one representing restaurants, and two at large, specifically chosen because they have an interest in tourism, because we are a tourism economy. Each of us here is to represent significant stakeholders in the community. I faithfully represent the chamber and serve on the board for the benefit of our community. When the board member stands up and asks questions or gives their thoughts, I do not see the difference as to me why someone who gets a loan from a town.

32:15 represents a developer with a major developer agreement and 1,200 rooms development, or even someone representing the biggest voice in the community. I believe everyone's voice is important, and that's a reason they're here, and they should be heard. I was handed a list of questions by the chair initially said I had 48 hours to respond. I then consulted legal and asked, I believe, fair questions in response. And there's some very heavy legal ramifications to some questions.

32:47 Because, for instance, I was asked about grand jury. But I've checked with a grand jury. I've checked with the courts recently. And upon further investigation, I find that not only does those questions potentially violate certain rules, but it's also against federal law to retaliate against a grand jury witness.

33:10 I put this as not to put out against the board, but I kind of went back and say, why don't we go back and legal and ask which questions should be really asked, and if there's something I need to talk to, great, but certain things should not be part of these questions, and I caution this board carefully on certain questions. You know me. You know who I am, how I conduct myself, how I serve our community in a variety of organizations. I have volunteered over 4,000 hours in almost a decade here in this town, all in the pursuit of making this town a better place to raise my family,

33:42 and for people to visit and enjoy. I hope you also respect my strong sense of integrity. I'm honestly at a loss to understand the chairman's move to remove you as a vice chair and potentially as a board member. We've never pursued removing a board member or officer in the past. So I ask, why now? What is really going on here and who's driving the bus? That's in my comment. Thank you. Thank you. So I'll respond so that we have some questions and a couple clarifying points. One, there's no intent of removing.

34:11 Mr. Tourax from the board. That's not our right. His position is appointed by the chamber board, is entirely at the discretion of the chamber who serves in their seat. So very clearly it is not a conversation. We as a board member, as a board, do not have the right to make that decision. So can I ask clarification on that? Because that's first I'm hearing this as a response as a follow-up. Is that different than what you asked me for previously when you and I sat down and asked me to resign?

34:46 Would you like to go back to that conversation, the details of our private conversation? I'm just trying to make sure I understand where the board's coming from. If you would like to reveal the details of our private conversation, I'm comfortable doing so in public. I'm stating facts. That's what I would prefer. I think it's in all of our best interest. So to clarify our point, the process of how things happen, was that there have been several questions, and I believe actually Kirk and...

35:11 Michael, you were present at the Executive Committee session back in February where some of these questions originally came up. Is that correct? About response to allegations in the community and there was some process that was requested. Yes. And there have been questions since then about where that process has gone and why that has not taken place. And I know that both myself and Mr. Turner have asked, where is this process going? That is part of question one.

35:35 Well, I don't want to speak for Kirk, but I'll say if it was an executive session in February, I was secretary and I was a part of that meeting. I'd have to look back at notes and make sure I understand what we talked about. That's where some of those initial questions came from, as for myself being present. Secondarily, going through the grand jury review, and I understand there's legal questions around what can or cannot be done, and we have consulted with our legal counsel and understand from our legal counsel under their advice that there's no problem with the questions as they were asked.

36:05 We have a grand jury that has said that they had to subpoena our organization for paperwork, and we understand from our email records that that paperwork was provided to the chair in time. Why did we have to get subpoenaed? Because as an MLT organization, that doesn't look great on us if it looks like the grand jury had to subpoena to get information from us that we actually freely provided within hours of the request. Why did that happen? That also seems like, to me, a somewhat reasonable inquiry as to

36:32 process, and especially the perception that creates the organization in public. Going back to a request to ask you to resign, the comment that was made specifically was, as you have noted, you were going to be asked to resign by a member of council, and what I said to you was, there are questions around how this has happened, and there are two choices, which is in good faith, in recognition of your 4,000 hours of community service, that

37:00 I'm giving you a heads up that if you want to address this, there are a couple of ways. One of which is to resign and then it doesn't happen. Two, if it does proceed, it happens in public because all of us as executive members do not have the privilege of an employee having private conversations around performance or ethics.

37:20 Those questions have to come up in public. So the or else is a simple legal ruling which says you either address things in private on your own or if they affect the organization they have to be addressed in public. That is the or else model. That is not my choice. That is the way public boards work. That is how the Brown Act works. None of us can go in that back room and have a conversation around whether I'm the person fit to be here or if you're the person fit to be here or if there's a question around those ethics.

37:49 Have to happen in a public session. Do I believe that in the past those conversations have happened in a much more private environment? Absolutely. And I believe this organization, MLT, has been highly criticized by some members of the community because they believe all the conversations happen in the back hallway and don't happen in public. And the intent is, let's have this in public. Let's be civil with each other. Let's be open and honest with each other in a public setting. This is why it has to happen in the executive committee. That is due process.

38:19 In an executive committee session, those questions were asked. They have to be written. You received them in writing. It was not demanded of 48 hours. I asked if 48 hours was reasonable. You said it was not. We extended that period of time. Fine. We have the response. End of story. But I believe we have to be an open and transparent organization. And when we have questions that come up, if something happens like, is Mr. Turner voting on something because it's Belooza-Palooza related or not?

38:49 We have the right to ask him that question. If we think that there's something there that Eric is voting on, is this the voice of Mammoth Mountain Skiria as an appointee? Is this a vote from the chamber as an appointee? Is this from the lodging association? Specifically, there are certain people on this board that are here specifically for bias. I expect when I ask Leland comments that she's going to come with the view of town council because she's the town council representative. If there are positions that happen outside of that, I think it's right to say, where does that come from?

39:19 That's it. We don't need to rehash this. I believe the questions are there. I believe the answers are there personally as the chair. I think that asking questions of each other and making sure that people are operating the best way is right. If people think I'm misbehaving, if people think that I have an alternative agenda, ask me and they'll answer the question. Scott, I just would have appreciated when we had our executive committee meeting if you had expressed in that way.

39:45 My view on that might be different in terms of your approach, but that was my initial takeaway, but I appreciate your clarification now. Okay. So the question comes up and the question still remains. More dialogue. Anyone have any more questions or clarifying points? John? No, it's done. No? Okay. I do have a question. A letter was mailed out on town letterhead from a town council member to... It was after the executive committee session.

40:22 That was sent out, correct, on Monday? Is it Monday? I don't know about the letter, I received an email. Oh, you received an email? Yes. I believe there was a physical letter that I believe went out as well. Okay. I find that fairly interesting. I'm not sure where it fits in the conversation, but I find that pretty interesting. Me personally, I'd like to address that back with the town council because I don't believe it's...

40:54 as relevant to here, but I just, I'm disturbed by that communication as a general communication for town council. Um, I am, uh, I think the language, uh, with the grand jury, that is supposed to be very, very quiet, uh, proceedings, so I'm kind of surprised, I mean, I know the final report is out and the responses are out there, but, um, uh,

41:22 I'm not really sure for in the future where grand jury, that would depend on, and you can't tell me, but who was interviewed and it's supposed to be. So we weren't, to be clear, the question has nothing to do with the grand jury. It has to do with MLT's process of providing information. So it's why was there a subpoena? The question being, if information was provided, one, was information provided in a timely manner?

41:53 Not asking content of information, not asking who provided it. Clarifying point. Yes, information was provided at a timely manner, and the subpoena you'll have to ask the grand jury. That's an answer. It is a process question. It is not to do with any of the findings. It's not to do with who reported it. It's very specifically, as an organization, we've been informed that we were subpoenaed. Why was a subpoena required?

42:18 And I do think that there are two aspects to the Brown Act to keep in mind. One is an actual conflict. The other one is a perceived conflict. And that is a very razor-sharp line to stand on.

42:39 I would almost say that I could probably find conflict with most people on most projects. So I just want to make sure that everybody's aware of that, that there are two different types of conflict that you have. And one thing that came out of the Brown Act training that I think is very something that every board should take note of is that even if somebody abstains from, say, an issue,

43:09 But it turns out later on that, and I don't know what your holdings are in this town, but even if a person abstains from a subject, but they have some kind of holding, some kind of interest in it, then that can put the whole board in jeopardy and will make it null and void. So I wanted to add that also, just since we're talking about the Brown Act here.

43:38 So just I want everybody to kind of know since I'm new on this board where I'm coming from on this. Thanks. I mean, hopefully everyone has filled their Form 700 out and been really clear on exactly what their holdings are and where those conflicts may exist. And so, you know, that's why we provide those to Jamie every year and trust that they're accurate. Any other conversation?

44:10 You know, I'll go ahead and speak just because, you know, I feel like I really want to kind of try and clear some air, you know, I feel like we can cut this air with a knife here. You know, I just want to say a couple things, and since we are not supposed to be talking about this outside, this is the place to be saying it. You know, Brent, I do have some frustrations with specifically, not necessarily the grand jury review or even the...

44:33 Air service, you know, conflicts of interest. I think we've all talked about in such a small town, we all only have one degree of separation, it seems like. I gotta say, I did raise my eyebrow when Jim Demetriotis sent, I sent Brent. I thought that was kind of unfair on Jim Demetriotis' part when he made it clear that he sent you to the...

44:54 The air discussion specifically, and I didn't attend that, so I'm not familiar with what happened there. You know, I will say that I am, I was a little frustrated with the town contract, just because I did want to see some further discussions on that. You know, you did say you were going to be bringing that forward. Likewise, with regard to an HR policy and procedures, would love to have seen that happen in a timely manner. I sent you a couple of emails saying, hey, where are we with this? Didn't get any responses on that.

45:22 Do these things rise to the level of removing somebody from an executive, from the executive committee? I don't know. I'm a little frustrated that we can't talk in a more private conversation way, but that is the Brown Act, and that if we are going to sit on this board, we do need to be able to ask these questions in a public forum. So, you know, the response from the lawyer, I get it.

45:47 Geez, I got all kinds of lawyers that tell me, don't say that, don't say that. But it's sometimes, you know, I would like to get some answers to the questions, specifically that are raised around the HR policy and the town contracts, and probably the air service as well. I would like to know those answers. And so I'll just say that, you know, just in...

46:08 hopefully moving this conversation along. I don't know if this rises to the level of removal from an executive, from the executive committee. Michael, I'll just say that, you know, because you actually have good comments that I think a lot of people have said, whoa, whoa, whoa, where did all this come from? You know, it has been coming up in conversations, and maybe I've not been saying loud enough during board meetings that

46:37 Dammit, I want an answer on the HR policy, or I want, where's the town contract? You said that you were going to be providing this at the June 6th, you know, where are we with it? So I will speak up more specifically during board meetings so that this doesn't...

46:54 And that's truly, I don't want the perception of any kind of railroading going on. I don't want the perception of anybody feeling like they're out to get one person or the other. That maybe we are discussing these things in a more transparent way, which is definitely criticism we've heard from the community, and that we're really talking about these things in board meetings. And I'm just going to do a brief reply of that. I'm looking forward to it.

47:20 Doing answers, but at the same time, remind us that all board members are allowed to bring something back up to, if you want back on the agenda. If Scott's chair, our job is to remind Scott we want it on the agenda. If it hasn't been there, we have a right and a privilege to seek that. Secondarily, though, just remind us all, we kind of, in that early April time frame, had a whole air service issue going on with Alaska playing out, and the board prioritization was rebooking new air service and moving forward.

47:45 So there's other things that come up that all distract us from certain things, and we all have to make sure we remain diligent and back to answering all the board's questions. And I would agree that we're a volunteer organization, and being busy and not being able to get to things as a volunteer organization is a completely reasonable response to doing things. Where I take umbrage is when

48:09 What I would consider are, at best, misleading statements, and perhaps are factually untrue to misleading organizations, specifically around the nature of where a town contract exists, or when there are people that are visiting this town who are here under contract between MLT and MMSA, are pulled into private meetings to work for a private individual to review paperwork, and that question comes up about those things. Those are not, we got busy, we got distracted, we're a public entity.

48:36 Those are things to me that become egregious, and those need to be asked. And I think it's always... So for me, the question is, the challenge that I face, and this is, I know this obviously comes out of, you know, perceived in the public and probably with the board as a personal battle between the two of us, but asking a question about someone like Tomsich having a private meeting with you, I think the right to ask you, was that person compensated, giving you the benefit of the doubt? Were you clear? Did you tell somebody?

49:04 Hey, by the way, it's great that Mammoth Mountain and MLT paid you to come here, but I'd like for you to look at my private documents. This is a side thing. I'd appreciate the favor. Being honest and transparent about it, that is an answer. Effectively telling us to go to hell and you will hear from my lawyer's response is not the type of communication that I think an executive member of this organization can convey and build trust with the rest of the group. I think the way the whole conversation started prompted that.

49:31 As a reply, I think it could have probably been approached differently, but we are today, and I'm not. Those questions were asked in a private meeting, and you had the opportunity to answer to them then, and you walked out. And so they got asked in a public session in an executive committee, and you told us we'd hear from your lawyer. And we've now heard hear from your lawyer who's told us that we don't even have the right or questioning the right to even ask those questions. To me, you've had three opportunities to say, let's clear the air, and at each point, you've opted to either not answer the question or to defer some other reason.

49:59 No, I'm just asking. That to me is an eyeball raising response. Okay. I disagree. I think I'm trying to get clarity in terms of the board and why they're asking questions because do we go back five years and ask why John Morris made a decision or somebody else made a decision five years ago? You know, we are all an active board. If there's something that comes up that makes us all feel uncomfortable, that should be a current discussion discussed at that point in time. Going back six months and saying I don't like something that the chair did or somebody else did, I question that. Well, it doesn't mean I'm not going to respond back to it. I just question the procedure.

50:29 If I can go back to the portion of the second part of what's going as a question today, because I want to make sure with regards to any response, if I need to leave the room or there's something I want to make sure from that standpoint to those questions, I'm here, but I also, if there's some conflict in terms of me sitting here with that board discussing response, I don't want to conflict that. Secondarily, just I question the vice chair only from the standpoint of I personally believe this

50:54 The Board is fully empowered to modify who's on the Board anytime. The rules state that. I question the fact that just the process, and I believe what the process should be is if you want to make revisions to the Board is you do it as call up a new vote. Calling today to retroactively respond back to a vote that was done previously I don't think is appropriate. I think the Board is fully empowered to make their decision and say, you know what, we want a difference and, you know, this is...

51:21 We're going. The board should say we should have a vote next board meeting. Here's the candidates. May look at the whole slate again and say that's the candidates recommended and move forward. I think the board's fully empowered to do that. But I just question because if you go back overall, California law is very specific in protecting. Let's just say, let's just say, sorry, I'm going to pick on you, Cleland. Let's just say we've elected Cleland to be chair of the organization and we decide we don't want Cleland to be chair. You can't go back and redo to vote. You've got to go forward. Everything affects.

51:49 The future, not past. So I just caution us on that in terms of how we respond back to that. I don't intend to be part of that conversation, and I will leave the room if you want as part of that conversation. You feel well versed in our bylaws, correct, in understanding those? I mean, you seem really well adept at those. I try to be. I don't know if I'm an expert, but I try to understand. So if you want to go back to that original conversation, we were having a dialogue around who was going to be in the executive sessions. There was a joke about other people showing up.

52:16 and we were, I believe Mr. Clark was actually considered for vice chair and you stepped up in that meeting and informed Mr. Clark that he couldn't be viable in that seat because the requirement is for two years of someone to be sitting on the board before they can be a vice chair position. I don't recall directly but I believe there was a requirement in those laws but I haven't looked at that. What interesting is that you have an impeccable memory of some of our bylaws but our bylaws actually state that someone can be a board member after one year.

52:45 So Mr. Clark was actually, would have been a fair consideration, but we didn't actually have that consideration of the dialogue because as the chair at the time, you shut down Mr. Clark saying that there was a two-year requirement for that position. I don't recall that. In that state alone, you ended up with the vice chair position again through. I'm not trying to, the board, if you're telling me the board had no right to vote me in the vice chair, I completely disagree.

53:12 Right, I think the board made a decision off of misinformation. We've, in the past, have had, from the standpoint of just operational disorganization, have, whether or not informally or formally, always said that the MLT board should be careful about who's on the executive committee, particularly from Mammoth Mountain and what they represent in the community. I've no ways tried to misstate or underestimate. If you recall, we sat there for 20 minutes and no one put their name forward for a while. It was...

53:37 Kind of sitting around, everybody's looking at each other. I think there was a full opportunity for somebody saying, hey, I want to serve. This is what it is. Let's check. So from that standpoint, my comment today is I just believe from a procedural standpoint, retroactively doing a vote is not the way to approach that. It's to say, let's put on the agenda, let's do a new vote. I believe the board's fully empowered to do that. It's on the agenda and we have the ability to. Is there any further conversation?

54:10 Then I would like to move that we open the discussion and take a vote and make a motion to remove Mr. Truax as vice chair. Can I make a suggestion? And I actually really want answers to the questions before I make a vote like this. And I guess what I'm asking is, I don't know, I'd like to make a motion. I've looked at this from the standpoint of being an MLT board member.

54:40 Lawyer for quite a few years. The board has the right to ask questions of a board member, whatever questions it wants. The board member has the right to refuse to answer those questions. Mr. Runner, we can't hear you. Oh, I'm sorry. Thank you. Someone once said, speak softly and carry a big stick or something. Anyway, I'll just repeat myself for the benefit of the attendees here.

55:15 The board has a right to ask any questions it wants of a board member. That's perfectly legitimate. The board member has a right to refuse to answer those questions. That's also legitimate. However, the board may take the refusal to answer questions in any way it wants. It may see that as a negative thing and that the board member therefore should not have an executive position or it may see it as, well, that's their right not to answer, so what?

55:43 It's a personal, individual decision to each board member. So I think the questions have been asked, Sean, but I don't think as a board we have an absolute right to demand that Brent answer them. He has a right to refuse, which he's done. Okay, thanks for that clarification. I don't know, that's my biggest concern, is that I think that these are valid questions, at least the way that I'm reading them.

56:13 I'd like to get an answer. I mean, are you, so my question to you, Brent, is are you saying that you're not going to be responding to these questions? No, I actually believe the question that was asked the board is just clarify why you're asking these questions under which auspices so that I can tailor my response and those ones I can back based on what that question is. Is it, are you asking me a question on conflict of interest because you want to remove me from the board? Are you asking me conflict of interest because it affects something else? I'm just trying to make sure I can respond. It was very

56:42 Some of those questions were listed as an overall standpoint. And from my understanding, for instance, on the grand jury, I'm just trying to make sure I'm following it correctly and hope that on that one, I'd love to be able to hand over the emails that I've already prepared to hand over to the chair and to the executive committee, but I just need some clarification that that's okay and not just one, but I'd like to make sure that we're okay with doing that and I'm not violating the ethics laws or any other rules. I believe at the executive committee session, you said that you were going to reach out to the grand jury and...

57:09 Ask what you were able to share or not. Is that correct? That's correct. I did. Okay. And they told me I can't share anything other than say, here's the final report. You're not authorized even to even talk about it. Okay. So, but if there's a portion of that, I have no problem like in that area. I would love to be able to share that to clear up the air in terms of what exactly was going on there because I think it's a very simple answer, but I just want to make sure I follow the rules. If I can just comment further.

57:35 I don't want to be railroaded into having to make a decision right here, right now without these questions being answered. You know, I don't mean to use that term lightly, excuse me, but I guess what I'm saying is that, you know, I'm being asked to vote you on or off the, we are being asked to vote you on or off the, stay on or off the executive committee.

57:57 Based on questions that you're saying that you're not going to answer or you will answer, and maybe what I'm hearing you say is, why are you asking me these questions? The answer to that, if I can just speak for myself, is that this board has been accused of not having clear enough transparency in the past. I hope that we can...

58:19 Be much more transparent going forward, that we are following proper procedures, Brown Act, all of those kind of things, and that we have a great reputation in this community for doing things that we're, say we're doing, that we're acting in the best interest of tourism, of the MLT board itself, and I don't want to make a vote right now if these questions, if you're saying that you are going to be answering these questions.

58:49 Did I make sense in saying that? Yeah, and I guess all I can say is never was my intent at this point in time not to answer a question unless there was some weird portion. I always planned to come back with answers, just trying to get clarity so I could come back with the right answers. Again, the biggest thing that happened to me during the presentation by Jim Demetriatus was when he made that statement, and I think that...

59:12 If you were here, I don't know. It was just one of those things that perhaps you should not have phrased it that way. These other questions are things that I've had questions for for a while with regard to the HR policy and the town contract. I'd love to get these answered.

59:31 Because we're trying to railroad anyone, but just because, yeah, they have been on my mind for a couple of months now. Why did it take so long? So, Sean, just overall from the standpoint, just on one of the questions. One of the questions in terms of HR policy, that was from an executive session of this board. I'm just trying to make sure I can respond to that because it's supposed to be an executive session and not brought into the public, but now we're talking to the public, so I'm trying to make sure I'm not violating any ethics as well. So I'm just trying to be clean on this.

59:57 Okay. So one of the questions in there is from a public meeting on June 6th where you presented an HR policy, an employee handbook, and a conflict of interest policy for the board. And one of the questions was, why was that presented? Why was no vote requested? And why was there no follow-up request for the rest of the board to?

1:00:14 either vote or approve. And I don't have a problem answering that question. Well, you have a problem answering that question. That question was asked in writing and he responded by a lawyer saying by what legal authority do you have to even ask these questions. So you've been asked questions that you're now willing to answer, but you weren't willing to answer either in the private session or through the lawyer. When I left that meeting for the executive committee, I was under the impression that the executive committee was asking these questions because they wanted to remove me from this board.

1:00:38 So that was the impetus and no clarification document to give me other than that. There was no preamble statement saying we're asking these questions because we want clarity based on what I believed at that point in time was you're doing that to remove me from the board. I want a clarification why you're asking a question because there's a difference as to why those questions are being asked. You could have asked a clarifying question then. Your response in that executive committee session, which I believe the other members here saw, was that you questioned whether there was even a legal right for anyone to ask you an ethical question.

1:01:08 That there was no right, I believe the word you said was that you have no right to even ask me a question under whose authority, under what legal authority do you have to even ask a question? That to me is a shocking question. Actually, I really had a written statement and I have contract to that and I can provide that as documentation as my follow-up. We need to wrap this up. How do we move this along? Because I will just state for myself and I don't mean to be speaking as much as I am, but I'm really just wanting to answer to the questions if you're comfortable with that, not with any.

1:01:38 Malice or any intent. Brent, you know, I know you as a friend, as a community, and I got to say, you know, we all put immense hours into this without pay. And so I think that we've all got the community's best interests at heart. I know we do. But at the same time, this is an uncomfortable...

1:01:57 Situation is an uncomfortable vote, but at the same time, I feel like there's valid questions here. Is there any way that we can postpone this vote until after we get these questions answered, which would be before the next board meeting? Do I have any comment on that? I would appreciate that because, again, I feel the same way in that, you know, I have not had a problem with any of Brent's service. I do would like to have answers to these questions.

1:02:30 The answer of the questions in my mind raises a red flag that, okay, that's maybe that wasn't truthful at that time. And should we consider, you know, a change? I'd like to, I can't formulate that answer until I know what the answer is to the question. And so I personally, in thinking about this, and maybe I'm misspeaking here, but I don't see a quote.

1:02:52 Danger in keeping Brent on the Executive Committee until we get those answers. I just don't see anything that is going to explode in our face in the next month, and maybe I'm wrong, but I just don't see anything that rises to such a level that warrants taking Brent off the Executive Committee at this point until we get those answers. I personally just, I don't, I have a problem with the questions not being answered.

1:03:18 But I can't formulate an answer in my head until I know the answers to the questions. I just feel like we're chasing the dog here. Sounds fair. That's just the way I feel about it. Yeah, I'll weigh in on that as well. I think that, you know, this came to me a little bit late as well. Yes, I have been part of the processes in the past here as part of the executive committee. I can't help but think there's, you know, a couple things happening here.

1:03:49 We're questioning the process, number one, as to how we go about this and conduct it. And at the same time, I too feel like I don't have all the information. I'm intently listening. You're clarifying your position well. Brent, you are as well. The cards are on the table. I think that it's...

1:04:15 In my opinion, I don't have that answer right now. And so that's me being honest saying, you know, I would almost have to recuse myself from a vote because I feel that I have not vetted this as much as I would like to. And I think it's a service to Brent and to you and to all of us on the board to go through a little more process. I'm not into...

1:04:42 Analysis through paralysis through analysis type thing, but hey, you know what? It's not the first time we've discussed a situation to the nth degree. So there's a proposal. I believe the grand jury gives 10 days to respond to questions. I think that's the standard policy. If we said, here's the questions as the board.

1:05:05 And Brent has said he's willing to listen to those questions and to respond to those questions and that I hear a majority of this board saying that they'd like answers to those questions. Can we say 10 days to respond to the questions? I mean, he's had them now for two weeks, so this would be an additional 10 days to be able to answer those questions to the board. Would that seem like a reasonable period of time to say, you know, even if it's to the point of saying I can't answer the grand jury, I checked the grand jury and the grand jury says I can't say anything? Like, to me, that's an answer.

1:05:35 So, Scott, could I just ask, I have no problem with that, my only suggestion is next Friday. Next Friday instead of 10 days, that's, I don't have anything to do with that. Is that 10? 10 and a half. Does that seem suitable? Does anyone have any disagreement with that as a process to make sure that? Yeah, I don't know, I think that's probably fine. I mean, I think it's an important enough issue to go through.

1:06:05 Yeah, I think we owe it to the process. And I have two kind of issues, Scott. One is the process itself. I understand your points of clarification and also appreciate that. I also understand if I put myself in the shoes of another board member who's getting a public flogging, you know, it just feels like the process, if I put myself in those shoes where I have a meeting with the chair board, the next

1:06:31 Then there's an executive session on that issue. And then I get a letter apparently demanding resignation from a council member. I think anybody in this room, anybody in this board can understand how one can feel the victim or being picked on in that situation. And I wonder if that process, if the process to evaluate, you know, board behavior or board

1:06:59 Projects and so forth is due process or it's just some other process. The second thing I have is I want to make everybody at this table aware of what is amounting to a major shift in the culture of this board. And for me, I don't see it. Look, accountability is everything and I live with that every day in my life, in my business life, in my personal life. However, I know that I have missed meetings. I know that I have

1:07:24 not performed on time and done things as well as I would have liked to in a volunteer board. However, if we're going to make a cultural shift to this level of accountability where it's a public, as I said, flogging and either demands or suggestions of resignation from either committees, chair positions, or board level positions.

1:07:52 I think we all need to recognize and be held accountable to that same level without any bias ever because we all coach teams. I got to leave here early to coach a soccer team. I know we all coach. I know we all have businesses, and I know we all work hard. We all fundraise. We've all given a lot to this community, and I just feel really uncomfortable with them.

1:08:22 with this level of scrutiny, you know, in this public forum. And I just want to make it clear to all of us that if this is the direction that we're going to go, we need to all be held to 100% account 100% of the time because that's kind of what we're saying. And the message there isn't, hey, the MLT board should be inaccountable or unaccountable. It's just, I think we're all, you know, men and women that work hard and give to our community and this may be,

1:08:51 You know, in my opinion, just a little much. Can I ask you a question? How do you feel when people in the community say that we're a boys club that does nothing but protect ourselves and look after our own interests and don't do anything to help the community? Or when people stand up here in public comment and give out misstatements about this board not doing its due diligence? The second part of the question again? You've been privy to cartoons that have been drawn or other things that have been shared that basically has accused this board of being ineffective at best?

1:09:21 Does that perturb you as much as the pressure of being fully accountable? Or is that something you'd think is just noise from the community and you're comfortable with just letting that slide off the pack? I can only answer that like this, Scott, that HR policy number one that starts with rumors, accusations against staff circulating in the community, again, is something I'm really uncomfortable with. I don't live my life in a world of...

1:09:49 of addressing rumors and accusations, okay? I'm not talking about the rumors. It's facts and it's due process. Anything outside of that is unacceptable and irresponsible. I'm good with that. My question is that there are several members of this community who have expressed to me and in public lack of faith in this board being transparent and covering each other's backs. Now, does that bother? That bothers me.

1:10:17 I know that that's not how this board operates. I know that's not how this group operates. But there has been, I believe, enough lack of transparency over the years where the perception is reality. And the only way I know to combat that is to be as transparent as possible. Fair enough. If that transparency becomes too much of a burden, I also understand the weight of that. But we do, as a board, we actually have oversight of one of the largest budgets in town.

1:10:46 for taxpayer dollars. We do have a fiduciary responsibility to lodging and to restaurants and to the members of the community to say, what are we doing with that? So when someone like Ward stands up and says, you guys have a $10 million budget, I don't think you know where it's going, we can say, well, it's just, you know, we're a volunteer board and we've done the best we can or we have to be really dug in. And I think it's a good question, like, what should the board do? You and I have had this conversation when you started, it was an advisory board. It was very...

1:11:15 Passive. It was very much in the back shadows. I think staff has taken some beating sometimes in that because decisions have been made by an advisory board and staff goes and acts on that and then the community goes after staff and the advisory mindset's like, well, it's what the team did. So I feel like we are at a crossroads as an organization. The board is either going to have to be active and be very much a part of it or it should go back to being an advisory board and staff is on their own.

1:11:43 That's an interesting, you know, that's a perspective on where we should go. I want to be clear that I'm not discussing whether or not we're transparent or shouldn't be transparent. I'm saying there's a level of accountability for every task and committee tasks that we get, what our responsibilities are, and if that shift is going to be this, if you don't, you know, execute something properly, okay, we should just all be on notice for that, and it should be 100% to each individual at this table.

1:12:10 And then the second thing is when that comes up, there's a process for it and is that process being followed properly? I can tell an employee that, hey, you know, you didn't really do a great job last night or you were late yesterday. Unless I notify them, write them up, put that in their file, I haven't papered and documented that properly. The process isn't being taken care of properly. Some of these items go back to six months.

1:12:35 Prior. Do we have that file? Do we have that documentation? Do we talk to our legal counsel prior to the personal meeting or the executive session? Do we get an opinion from our legal counsel on what we were doing? That's the process part. The other part is the culture of what we're doing. We are not a working board. And if we are, that's something that should be made very clear.

1:13:01 to every single board member. And then the employee handbook should be handed out with the expectations. And every single person at this table should be held accountable to those expectations, be it job performance or conflict of interest. That's all I'm saying. And if that's the shift we're making, I don't think we've made that abundantly clear over the last six months that that's the shift that we're making. Transparency.

1:13:29 Completely different issue. 100% we should be transparent. 100%. I think when we start talking about the scope of this specific situation, you have questions around performance, which is, you're saying like an employee showing up and being late, and you have a question around, did an employee specifically use your funds to go do something for themselves? Right. So that you have a scope of what we're talking about here. One is, and this goes back to my really clarifying point,

1:13:59 You have the, I'm busy, I can't get to it, it's a volunteer organization, and you have one that is potentially outright deception. What does potentially mean? That's what I'm trying to understand. That's the question, so by not answering the question, it is only potentially. We have a consultant that was hired to come present to this organization that then met privately to advise a private business entity of this board. Why? We have a contract negotiation with the town.

1:14:33 The town specifically provided guidance prior to our budget dialogue as a group to the chair. The chair opted not to share that specific guidance from town that would potentially have changed all of our votes on our budget with the organization and denied receiving it from this dais. That's fact. That's on dais. You can look that up on Granicus. Mr. Truax received information from the town prior to this board voting on its budget.

1:15:03 and refer to it as being immaterial to our budget conversations. So when we sat and looked at our budget, we did not have the specific direction from town saying, here's what the next five years looks like. So we voted on a budget without having all the information. And it wasn't missed, it wasn't forgotten, it was decided that it was immaterial information for the rest of us to have. Why? There's a big difference between me saying,

1:15:33 Hey, I'm going to be a little late. I screwed up. And me intentionally setting you to go to some place and not be there. I know we've got to move on. I would love to take you 100% at your word for everything you're just saying. All I'm saying is that if anybody has violated anything, whether it's a code of conduct or it's something other, there needs to be accountability and transparency. However, the process is not you being the judge, the jury, and the executioner. We all need to have all that information in front of us.

1:16:02 Prior to a 72-hour notice to make a decision on whether to remove somebody from their position. So that's what I'm saying. That's due process, not your process. Due process was I consulted with the rest of the executive committee before I approached Brent in private and said, here's the issues that are coming up. I want to present these to Brent. So I checked with the executive committee and made sure that if I went to them, it was an executive committee consideration. That's the process. I met with Brent. We talked about it.

1:16:32 When Brent didn't want to respond, we called an executive committee session. The executive committee sat in that session, presented him questions. He asked for them in writing. He asked for more than 48 hours. He got them in writing. He had them for more than 48 hours. He responded by legal. Then those things were presented here to have an open discussion. That's process. I'm not judge, jury, or executioner. I ask the questions as chair. They're presented to all of us. We all have the right to make the decision.

1:17:00 I'm not calling for his head. I'm saying there's information that's there now. Do with it what you want. If we want to say we're going to wait until next Friday, then we wait until next Friday. I've just been trying to champion the questions to make sure it comes to light. If I could just add on that. I tell you, that's why I really don't want to make a decision right now. Why? Because if I had to make a decision right now, you know, without the questions, I don't even want to say.

1:17:26 So, if, I think what I'd like to do, or if I could make this suggestion, is can I make a motion that we table this conversation until after we receive the, just to move on, that we table this conversation until after we receive the responses from Brent Truex, and that may not happen until the next board meeting. He said next Friday. So, to be clear in Brown Act, the responses would come next Friday.

1:17:53 Staff would have the ability to disseminate those if the responses are sent to Mr. Urdi, but this board cannot have a discussion around those responses at all without having a meeting. And there's three processes of that meeting, which is you could schedule an emergency meeting, which I don't believe this qualifies as, which would give you 24 hours. You could schedule a special meeting, which you'd have to have posted, I believe it's either 48 or 72 hours ahead of time, or you wait until the next board meeting. It's one of those three. I don't believe this, you know, there's no,

1:18:22 To your point, there's nothing, you know, hair on fire, nothing's going to happen to the organization if we don't make a decision. So it's either we're going to wait until the next reporting meeting or if there are answers in there that people feel it's necessary, any board member could raise their hand and say, I believe this is important enough that I'd like to request a special meeting. We'd have to notify it within 72 hours, post the agenda and have it. Otherwise, this will wait until the October 3rd board meeting. So just to clarify my motion, I'm asking that we table this conversation until the October 3rd board meeting. Have a second?

1:18:53 Excuse me, I do have a question. Since I am new to this board, I just, do you have to ask for public comment before a vote, or is that something that's just done in a different format? I don't believe we have to ask for public comment. Okay, so public comment's not part of that. I could be wrong on that, so I'm not sure on process. Then I'll second Sean's motion to...

1:19:19 You're saying for the next meeting. Table the vote until table or yeah. How am I phrasing this? Can I clarify? I understand that your motion is receive answers by next Friday, end of day next Friday. Staff would share those with the board. So staff would receive them and staff would share those with the board. And then the board would review and have a discussion on October 3rd.

1:19:45 Is that how I understand your motion? Yes. Which is receive questions, distribute questions, discussion October 3rd. Thank you for clarifying. That is my motion. Scott, one quick question. I just want to make sure since we're going by the book here. Since 8B says discussion and vote of appointment of vice chair position and it is part of the agenda, are we, we're within our... You can table now. Okay. The motion is to table the vote. Yep.

1:20:12 I'm going to retract my second just because I don't believe with the Brown Act that we can actually as a board receive all that information separately. That's almost like a serial meeting or something like that. So we'd be able to receive it as part of the agenda then and that's the only way that we'd be able to be distributed for conversation. Yes. Cleveland, we can receive it, we just can't discuss it.

1:20:44 Like I said, I'm new to this board, and I'm just learning how you guys operate. Well, it isn't a question of operation. It's a question of obeying the Brown Act. We can receive materials, but we can't discuss them with each other. Can't do that. We have to wait until we're at an agendized meeting, and then we can discuss those things. We're on the agenda for the next meeting. Yeah, no reply all.

1:21:17 I'm just retracting my second on that because I do have a little bit of a lower comfort level on that move. I'll second it. Okay. And let me make this comment. This is a difficult issue. Michael, there are no set in stone procedures or processes.

1:21:45 around this sort of thing, because it doesn't happen often, and the obligation is to follow the Brown Act and try to do something fair by the board and the individual board members. It's fairness, as you said, transparency and so forth. I think you create a little bit of a straw man when you talk about are all the board members going to be held to this standard?

1:22:15 We are already held to a standard of being truthful at all times. There's no argument about that. That's just how it is. That's not a particular burden on us as board members. It's just, you know, you want to serve in any public capacity, that's your obligation. If that comes into issue for some reason or question, you have to respond to it. But there are overarching requirements for us serving on this board.

1:22:44 We are funded by the Town Council. We have to maintain the confidence of the Town Council. If we lose the confidence of the Town Council for any reason, our funding will go away, and that's the end of the organization. What I would suggest is that maintaining the confidence of the Town Council is an item of great importance to this board and has to be a factor that we look at when we're dealing with

1:23:15 Any kind of personnel problem, whether it be a board member or an employee or what have you. That's not to say that we should allow a town council member acting individually to be unfair to a board member. That's inappropriate. If a council member says something and there are no facts behind it and it's just some sort of personal attack,

1:23:37 We as a board member should close ranks and do right by our individual board member. On the other hand, if a council member complains about something, we have an obligation as a board to look into it, to investigate it, to see if there are any facts, and then draw our own conclusions. I think that's the process that we're going through now. It's uncomfortable, very uncomfortable. I think every one of us given a choice would much rather handle this thing in closed session, but the law does not allow us to do so. So we're doing the best we can.

1:24:06 Under present circumstances. No, I appreciate your comments. Wait, one more thing. The Brown Act, I think Councilwoman Cleland described it very well. It's tremendously difficult. We all went through that three-hour presentation, which convinced me that if you say anything at all, you're in violation of the Brown Act.

1:24:29 And the issue as to conflict of interest under the Brown Act is extremely difficult. It says you're in conflict if you are involved in a board action, if you sit on a board, as Cleland pointed out, even if you abstain, if you sit on a board that is considering something where you would have a benefit or your employer would have a benefit greater than any member of the general public, theoretically that's a conflict of interest.

1:24:59 Conversely, the people who serve on this board all serve because we have an interest in the economy. Every one of us here is working for a living and is dependent on our tourist economy in Mammoth. So you could argue everything we do is a conflict of interest. Obviously, that doesn't make any sense either. But we walk a knife edge. So on one hand, we have to maintain not only the confidence of the town council,

1:25:28 But we have to maintain the confidence of the community, as Scott was saying. We are obliged to maintain that confidence of the community in what we do that it is the right thing to do and is not a product of conflict of interest. That's a sacred obligation for this board. If we, in the eyes of the community or the council, violate it, we won't exist anymore.

1:25:54 The members of this board and the members previously and John Urdi have labored for thousands of hours. The employees of this organization have put a good part of their lives into creating something of value. We have an obligation to protect that. At the same time, we have an obligation to be fair to each one of our individual board members. It's a tough challenge. Let me clarify. I mentioned in board members' comments that

1:26:22 I was caught flat-footed by this. The only knowledge I had of it was in two consecutive articles in the sheet. It's odd to me that it requires a full board member vote to make a decision to remove somebody. However, we don't get that information until 72 hours before the meeting, and most of that isn't even the depth of what you're discussing, which is relevant. That's odd to me. It's like telling a jury you need to decide on this case, but you don't get the information. You don't get to hear from either side.

1:26:51 But we're going to take a vote. You're going to remove this guy? No, and that's why this was a discussion. It's not. It doesn't have nearly the amount of depth that you know and that is being put into the process. We can't share that in private. I understand. The oddness isn't, I'm not saying that it's anybody's fault. I'm saying it's just odd to me that we're required to make a vote like this without having all the information in front of us. And I think it's in some ways irresponsible, regardless of how it comes forth, Brown Act or otherwise.

1:27:20 And to be perfectly clear, Paul, it would be disingenuous to suggest that I'm saying that we shouldn't be held to an account for truthfulness. My comments earlier on everybody at the board's accountability is specifically and 100% related to performance, okay? I'm sorry? Performance, right? You didn't get that task done.

1:27:42 Fast enough or appropriately or done right or whatever it is. That's 100%. I want to make that crystal clear. No part of what I said earlier is relative to, oh, we shouldn't be held at the standard of truthfulness is what you said. Michael, my point was that I don't think that we're dealing with an issue of a board member not performing up to an adequate standard. But that's four or five of the things that are listed here. I think we're dealing with a different issue here.

1:28:11 I'll let the questions speak for themselves, but I don't think we're saying, gee, you didn't, you know, do this well enough or, you know, so forth. So therefore, we're calling you to account. I think you're right about that. So we have a lot of discussion, Paul, but you've made a second, right? So I want to make sure that you made a second, and this is the commentary of the second, and I believe that second is to hold off until Dr. Whitman. So we have a first, we have a second. You do. All in favor?

1:28:41 Hi. Any opposed? Any abstaining? Apparently abstaining doesn't matter from a standpoint, but abstaining. Can I just ask a point of clarification? I represent the Chamber of Commerce, and maybe we can check with our council, because I don't want to violate any distribution, but I want to be able to share that information with my board as well for the Chamber of Commerce. Which information? My response is back. So am I...

1:29:08 Do I need to respond to this board first or is it okay for me to share that with the chair board at the same time or before you get answers? I just want to make sure process-wise I'm not violating any distribution. Your answer is your answer. You distribute them however you want. They're your communication. I mean, you can tweet them out 240 characters at a time if you want. I don't think it really matters where they go. I don't think there's any issue there whatsoever. No, I'm just trying to make sure I'm following the Brown Act.

1:29:39 So much of that, 10 minutes. So moving on quickly, grand jury response. I don't know if you guys got a chance to see. There's a response from town in response that John has drafted, just going back to the grand jury response. I think the only thing in there that I wanted to bring up as pertinent was that the grand jury had asked for contracts to be reviewed down to, I think it was $5,000 or $10,000.

1:30:06 We as a Board have voted to have contracts reviewed down to 25,000. Given the number of contracts that are coming in, given the policies that we have in place for budget and making sure how budget looks and works and any variance in the budget, that seems like a reasonable, you know, we didn't take the recommendation 100%, but we moved quite a bit towards that from where we were in the past. Does anyone have any issue with this response? I'm fine with that. I'm fine with that. Any discussion? Okay.

1:30:37 Air service update? All right, JetSuiteX, we can hopefully roll through this fairly quickly here. So we've been talking for a few months now on air service and we have settled out on where we are with United. We're still trying to finalize all of our direction with JetSuiteX. So what I've done here is I've given you guys the proposal and the recommendations and also some review of other markets that we had discussed in the past. So at this point, proposing and recommending that we go into

1:31:05 Both Orange County and Burbank four days a week, Thursday, Friday, Sunday, Monday. We had talked about going into Carlsbad. We have a proposal from JetSuiteX. At this point, since we are looking at being responsible for the entire JetSuiteX contract, I am making a recommendation that due to budget constraints that would be outside of the current cap 1.51 million in winter that we hold off on Carlsbad at this point. I think looking at the

1:31:33 Looking at the load factors and looking at the rates of the flights, I think that our subsidy in Carlsbad itself could be upwards of a quarter million dollars. So right now, with all of the other pieces that we've kind of taken out of reserve, I'm not comfortable adding that quarter million dollars if the board decides that Carlsbad is that market that we should have a 30-passenger plane out of. I think my other concern with that is it's not united that we're flying, so we would have to basically educate people in the San Diego and Carlsbad area as to JetSuite X.

1:32:02 And I'm just not comfortable that we can get to the capacity that we're not going to be less than a quarter million dollars on top of the money that we've already reinvested into the budget, the money that we're asking for today for supporting the Denver flight, et cetera, as well as some of the other pieces that we've put into the budget. So my recommendation is that we hold on Carlsbad. We can talk about that. And then we had talked about Oakland in the past, and I think for the same reason, even more so in Oakland, we don't have a lot of marketing. At least if we go down to Carlsbad, we market quite a bit to Southern California.

1:32:31 If we go into Oakland, we don't have that ground cover. All of our marketing in the Bay Area is specific to the San Francisco flight, so we would either need to add marketing dollars to that market as well as the subsidy, or we would have to take it from the San Francisco marketing, and I don't think we want to do that as well. So those are the four markets that we're talking about, so the recommendation is to go Orange County and Burbank.

1:32:54 And if I can go through just the contracting, we had talked in the past about Mammoth Lakes Tourism taking on the entire contract with Jet Suite X. Eric and I have been working closely on MMSA and MLT's cost sharing agreement. That still is in works, so I think that'll be approval for the 10-3 board meeting. I think that would be best.

1:33:15 proposed at that point. But at this point, I'm saying that we would want to put forth MLT sign-in agreement with JetSuiteX. There may be an option for us to do a multi-year deal with them, but I'm not sure that it's got enough benefit to do that.

1:33:28 We have worked with Pat Foster down at Huck Creek Aviation on the timing of flights, and I think right now if we can have Burbank and Orange County, I don't recall which one, but we have one coming in at 4, one coming in at 4.40, he can add staff, he can accommodate that. If we have one coming in at 9 o'clock and we have one coming in at 4.40, it may be more difficult for him. He was more comfortable having three flights a day because of the cost that he's looking to put in, but at this point I'm not comfortable with the third flight.

1:33:55 So we would be responsible for all JetSuiteX subsidies. We do have upfront payments. That's another piece when we talk about cash flow. So with two markets, I'm assuming that we'll have $100,000 a piece up front. Obviously, we had Carlsbad. That takes us from $200,000 to $300,000 up front. Cash flow is tough until we get TOT receipts from December, which we get in February. So that's another concern that we'd have to dig into reserves.

1:34:19 We did talk about the insurance piece. We did figure that the insurance requirements for MLT would be none. The insurance that was in the contract, $10 million, $15 million? I think it was $15 million in insurance, is based on the diversions to Bishop and the transportation up the hill. So it doesn't have to do with the flight itself. It has to do with us taking their customers from Bishop to MMH.

1:34:44 And if MLT owns that contract, who still owns that transportation? Is that still part of the cautionary agreement that Mountain would cover that? We would look to bifurcate that from that agreement so that with our commitment to the transportation, we would own that. They would have either an addendum or separate contract. So you'd own the transportation, MLT would own the flights. Yep. Correct. Correct. Just because we've committed to, you know, purchase the bus and so forth to help that air service program.

1:35:12 John, how many people are going to be on a bus at conceivably a week? 30 people. It's 30 passenger planes. So if there's a plane that gets diverted, it's 30 people max. So when you're talking about 15 million in insurance, is there any additional insurance owned by the bus company, owned by MLT, I mean by MMSA, that would cover it? 15 is a little light for 30 people. Well, and that's what they had in the contract, so I don't know. I'm sure the mountain is more highly...

1:35:41 Insured. Insured. You're right. I just wanted to confront. That's what I thought. That was the minimum that they had. It was the requirement from JetSuiteX, and we fulfilled that requirement. Yeah. Okay. So, a couple questions. I know we had some members from the public come and speak about San Diego pretty passionately. Mm-hmm. My personal take on this is that, and this sounds somewhat unfair to people of San Diego, but my guess is that most people from San Diego that want to come to Mammoth are probably still going to come.

1:36:10 Highway Vehicle, because there aren't other options, where being able to take those dollars and invest in either long-haul flights, Denver International, or getting people from San Francisco to fly over here that maybe in the past have been going to a squaw, seems like dollars better spent. And San Diego going to Orange County would save time, so if people are in San Diego and want to go to Orange County and fly, there's potential there. I think we've been doing Burbank for a while, the third year.

1:36:38 Personally, I don't think Burry Burry is the strongest new market development for us, but because it's been there third year and from the load factors, it's probably one that being able to go into that fourth year and really look at and building on it. Does anyone have any major issue? If we want to do San Diego, we're either doing it at the cost of Orange County or taking those dollars from other places. Does anyone have any issue with the recommendation from John? Let me add one note, too. I think that Burbank will also see a spike this year because instead of the two Alaska Airlines flights that we had daily last year, we only have one.

1:37:08 So I think we will see some carryover. Actually, I think we'll also see carryover back to Orange County as well. So I think with only one flight out of Los Angeles, I think we might see the overflow going either way. Quick question. I'm sorry, just geographically because I don't, I'm not from San Diego. How long does it take to get generally from San Diego to John Rain? I think it was an hour. I looked at it the other day. You had an hour?

1:37:29 Yeah, maybe two, depending on where you're at. Depending on traffic. Right, right. If you're going northbound at 5 o'clock on the 805. But what you're talking about is, again, let's think about it, it's a non-TSA flight. So the hour drive, if you have to drive from San Diego to Orange County to take a flight, which is non-TSA, the amount of time you have to go to Orange County Airport and go through TSA and go through all that.

1:37:52 We're talking about maybe the same amount of time. So what I'm hearing is I think that it is kind of a trade that you're going to be spending time in an airport either getting to it or at it. So if they have the option of flying out of John Wayne instead of San Diego from a time standpoint, it's... So it's an hour and a half. It's 89 miles, 86 miles. Does that make sense? I mean, am I kind of close on that time within 20 minutes? 86 miles? 86 miles. Yeah, that's got to be an hour and a half drive. It is an hour and a half. A longer drive, right?

1:38:22 But it's not, but again. But it's an hour and a half to get through TSA. Easy, exactly. I mean, the amount of time you have to plan to be at a bigger airport longer and so forth. So it's probably a push as far as time commitment, which time is everything to all of us, right? And the people with road rage are more pleasant than TSA. So we're talking three considerations, which is the for direction of staff is the conversation around not pursuing Oakland, not pursuing San Diego, and

1:38:49 the organization taking on the direct contract with Jet Speed X, absent of transit. And within the existing budget or not? Well, I know you guys did the research, so what was the logic behind losing San Diego?

1:39:03 And not replacing it, but adding Orange County instead of Carlsbad. Because that would seem like the obvious solution would be to not do Orange County because you have a flight from LAX and a flight from Burbank. We overlaid season pass holders and second homeowners to which had the majority or which had the bigger pool. Got it. To reach. Figured there was some. And we also looked at the reason that Oakland went out, like I mentioned before, Orange County is within our marketing area. Yeah.

1:39:27 Oakland would be a new marketing area which would require more funds, which we... Plus, you have SFO, so it's not... Yeah. No, that makes perfect sense to me. It was just Carlsbad, Orange County that I was questioning. And there's nothing that says that we can't revisit it next year. It's, you know, it's an option for us. Subsidy is about the same with those two markets. Well, so...

1:39:46 Burbank is, last year was 150, 160. I think that Orange County, because it's a little bit further, the rates will be higher. Hopefully we can get that load factor up there to keep it right in the same range. My concern with, when we started looking at Carlsbad, we started looking at the average rates at somewhat like a 60% load factor, and a 60% load factor at $420 round trip was $273,000. And I think that that's a pretty hefty price tag.

1:40:13 to the point of people being able to drive here for 420 round trip. Maybe I'm wrong with Rancho Santa Fe and some of those other neighborhoods right down by Carlsbad. But I think I'm just I'm a little risk averse right now because we've already invested a lot of extra reserve dollars this year. I would add one more comment as we looked at it that we were looking at other options of

1:40:34 Going through a commercial provider as well. And they weren't quite there yet. They could be there next year. So there's opportunity to continue to look at that and see how to fulfill it. But at this point in time, I think it's too much risk with, you know, looking at that segment alone was, we were thinking it was around $250,000. And with three markets, it was really interesting. It was going to be one plane. So go Burbank, Mammoth, Mammothson.

1:40:58 Santa Ana, so John Wayne, John Wayne Mammoth, Mammoth San Diego, or Mammoth Carlsbad, Carlsbad Mammoth, Mammoth. Oh, that's not good. No, no, yeah, well, it was something that potentially could have worked out, but at this point, again, the risk is just not, I'm not comfortable with the risk if the board decides a different direction. Fair enough. Scott, are you looking for a motion at this point? Looking for a motion to support. I'd like to make a motion that we pursue JetSuiteX out of Burbank and Orange County as stated in.

1:41:29 Second. Any discussion on that? Second. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? I'm going to recuse because I think I should, but I don't know if I should. Thank you. Better safe than sorry. But even if you were here, you could vote and it wouldn't make any difference. Yeah, right.

1:41:54 Okay, on the contracts, some of these are just updates. So we've got the LA Kings renewal for this year. This is the second year of six years, and this has all been part of the joint funds that we have set aside. My goal is to have not only our board chair sign the agreement with the Kings, but also to have the town manager sign the agreement with the Kings, recognizing that they are joint funds and that they are committed and that we are set to go for the next...

1:42:22 Excellent reviewer. So my memory on this one is, and overall, is that you're going to give us back an analysis of what the return on investment for Kelly King's money was. So my question here is, what is our return from overall, because we're asked to shift money later on from subsidies, et cetera, and my question is if this is the best use of our dollars as an overall, because as we remember, there was going to be an agreement with LA Kings, the Town and the Mountain parties.

1:42:45 Pulled back from that. There's no more subsidy back to the town. So one of the impetuses was for us to move forward because the Kings were going to reinvest in the community almost a million dollars. That has not happened. So if it stands forward as a separate marketing promotion, what's our return on investment? And I believe we had asked Marion Carson to give us an estimate of what that response was going to be. And we did run through that with Marion Carson. I don't recall seeing any information that's presented here. Okay.

1:43:11 We'll get those numbers back to you. I'm with Brent on that one. There was a request on making sure that the ROI on that was cost per impression was comparable or better than other marketing in that same region. It may be a great deal, but I just want to make sure we're... Well, they were going to contribute a million dollars to the construction of the ice rink, correct? We made the decision for some marketing opportunity.

1:43:29 Notwithstanding that they won't be able to make the contribution unless we actually build a nice one. No, no, no, they withdrew from that discussion, so there's no contract there, so this is just a marketing opportunity only for us. That was the conversation then was knowing that there could be something that could have happened, which did happen. We as a board said, we're doing this because this is actually the best dollar investment in cost per impression in our target market for what we're doing. It might even be better than some others. I don't know if I just want to make sure we're...

1:43:59 But to Brent's point, it would be good to be able to see that as a CPI compared to other. And there are still discussions with the Kings on having some sort of presence with us, whether it's programming, whether we're working on them. Redirect a million dollars to maintaining restrooms in the likes basis. I second that motion. So question, this is for $100,000? $100,000 annually. For three years? This is a two-year agreement with a third-year option.

1:44:27 And I believe, Mr. Chair, our rules say that anything over a certain dollar amount has to come back. I would make sure we're authorizing the Chair to sign this because the information comes back and it doesn't get executed before we have this information. Correct. Okay. Mammoth Half Marathon, you also have in your packet this is a report. Oh, sorry, go ahead. Before we move on on this, sorry, was there, this is an update or are we being asked to vote on this? This is an update. We have an agreement moving forward, but I understand. I'm asking.

1:44:54 That it be authorized, because that's, I believe, what our motion on the board was, is that anything over a certain amount has to be authorized, regardless of its joint funding. I'm just asking if we would please make sure we make a motion. We have a multi-year agreement with the town for the funds. Yep. I believe our obligation is to respond and have a motion. To this organization. So what we're saying is that without having the ROI, if I understand your question, without having the ROI present,

1:45:22 that as chair I would not be permitted to sign the contract without being able to share the ROI beforehand. This is the question coming up. This means that that contract could potentially not be signed until October 3rd or following because of the absence of the information. Is that correct?

1:45:39 And just when we go to the next one, is this a motion or a non-motion? Because I'm going to remove myself from the room on this one as we're being very sensitive because they buy rooms at my hotel, so therefore I must be of conflict. I would say it's a request. It's a motion. So I would say it's a request. I'm going to excuse myself from the conversation about that. So as a matter of process, there's several of us that they buy rooms from. So is that, do we all believe in that? I think it's hard to.

1:46:09 Have a board without that? Yeah. I do too. If he feels he has a specific contract that would create bias, then I think it's good that he feels he needs to recuse himself. I'm sure they buy rooms from you. I wonder if it even shows up on your balance sheet. It's something that reaches your level. No, it does. I mean, it's the right time of year. It's a great event. It's on brand. And this is where I think we need to be really clear as an organization is that specifically, like, I would really look towards

1:46:40 To Kirk and John in this, like if there's a lodging question, like even though there may be bias because they're booking rooms in there, we're specifically looking to people from lodging to be able to say, yes, this is why we support this because it's good for that. Knowing that it may actually benefit your individual property, you're specifically here for the purpose of lodging. So I think there's... To that point, I'll tell you from my last five years of experience, when we did not have the marathon, we wouldn't sell out that weekend.

1:47:09 We sell out on that weekend in our MMSA properties now ever since we added the marathon. So I feel like it's a great contribution. Kirk and John, how do you guys, do you guys see similar lift from the marathon? To be honest, I don't think we at Snow Creeks, I mean, in an individual business, but I would say as a town and as lodging, certainly an event on a not-so-busy weekend is good.

1:47:39 And that's a minimal amount of money to invest in something that I believe probably brings way more than $15,000 back into the community. So I would say that it was well worth money well spent. We have a couple of things going on our advantage this year that we've got. It's not on Father's Day. And I think having Caroline on board to start working with the events to maximize opportunities for all events, I think that it stands to do well this year. Yeah, I don't think it's something, you know, perhaps in our lodging meetings going forward.

1:48:08 I think it's something we need to focus on a little bit more. I think some of those events in off weekends are things that what I think happens is that the lodging community gets a little blase about it and is like, oh, great, there's an event going on, rather than really reaching out to the folks that are promoting those events and saying, give me all the information you possibly can on that event because I want to promote it and I want to get people here. So I think there needs to be some more proactivity by the lodging community too.

1:48:33 Help push those events in their on their websites and in their literature and so forth, not just let them happen because letting things happen is not a good marketing scheme. So yes, sorry, in summary, yes, I believe the $15,000 is well spent. Hope is not a strategy. Hope is not a strategy. So I had a question around it as well in the sense that the $15,000, I have not read through the agreement.

1:49:00 But to my understanding, so I apologize because I didn't get to that part, but was that we would only provide $15,000 if they didn't hit a certain level. Correct. Last year was $13,000. That was last year's. And so did we pay out the $13,000 for this year? For spring 2018, yes. Yes. So they did not get the... It was guaranteed up to $15,000. It was $13,000. So it was not the full amount.

1:49:30 Oh, okay, got it. It's 13th. I've got some questions around this because I truly do not remember this discussion last year. Are we doing this for any other events at all? We don't right now. This was originally set up as part of the events discussion moving forward with the idea that we would have...

1:49:50 An additional funding source that we didn't have. But it was one of these things where we were at risk of losing this event. And during the need time that we had last year, we stepped up for it. I want to go back and understand what I missed last year. Do you know what board meeting this was discussed at last year? I can look it up. I would assume that it was probably comparable time frame. Okay. Yeah, I'd be curious to know, you know, and this is just another question as well. I just want to understand this just, you know, when it comes to all events.

1:50:19 Yeah, all events. And I'm going to tell you that one of the reasons why I requested kind of what our policy is around social media

1:50:29 promotion of various events that I have to admit I have not had time to fully dive in yet. I feel like I'm just now getting my head back above water. But I want to spend some time with that document that I thank you very much, John, for forwarding to me. You know, I'm just saying anecdotally, I remember that it felt like there was a lot more support, social media support for this event than others. Is that the case? That is not the case. Okay.

1:50:58 All right. No, we sent you the, what we did was we sent you the written policy that Josh put together and Megan put together and we sent it to you with the results for what we did for Bluespalooza. We didn't give a comparison to the half marathon, but basically what we did was here's the baseline and here's what we did and it was in excess of the baseline. Okay. All right. So getting back to just, you know, how this affects other events, have you had any other events ask for this kind of support? Other than yours, no.

1:51:27 Are we setting up for, well, no, mine didn't ask for this kind of support. A few years ago you did. Well, I'll have to go back and actually review exactly what we asked for on that. Okay, John? My question here, though, is have there been any others then? Actually, I shouldn't say that. The Mountain has requested specific sponsorship for their events in the past. Okay. I think this is something now with Caroline coming forward to where we would need to have a set policy specifically around what constitutes

1:51:58 number of either protecting events or new events and where MLT would have kind of at least some thresholds of does this at least go to the board for a vote or not on that so that there's kind of a at least what's the threshold to get to that point you know is there a certain number of people or a certain number of dollars or a certain number of guarantee that then becomes a threshold like above that is the board can discuss it as an investment and below that it doesn't even reach that threshold yeah so we're spending our dollars at that that highest level okay

1:52:28 And that's exactly how the policy works on social media, too. If it's events driving TOT, if it's community events, if it's there's three different tiers. Maybe dollars in the same three different tiers. Could be. Because this may actually. Well, and if you look at it moving forward, we'll be, you know, for the next year at least, we'll have the town funding for the $100,000 that gets granted out to events. If we decide to, if we opt to put more money into that pot, we will be putting together the committees to work on that as well.

1:52:54 Okay, and I'd like to follow up with you on what you're saying Bluza Palooza asked for that manages this side. I'll go back and take a look at my notes here. Thanks, John. John, how has the participation in the half marathon been? Has it been growing over the several years? Well, the last two years it's fallen on Father's Day, and I think those are the two years that have suffered. And so prior to that, we were upwards of, I think, 1,400 runners, and I think the break-even is really right around that 1,250 mark.

1:53:23 And so I'm cautiously optimistic that the fact that it's not falling on Father's Day this year, again, that we've got some additional backup to support all events is hopefully going to help us. Carolyn, sorry, she was behind you. I was going to save this for one of the Mammoth updates, but I think it's appropriate, given your question now.

1:53:46 And that is that with Caroline coming on, she's been doing a wonderful job at Grand Fondo for the Mammoth Community Foundation. And so the last three years or four years of the Mammoth Grand Fondo participation was 1250, 1400, 1530, and this year, 1700. So a lot of participation in that event.

1:54:14 Growing in a nice clip. It seems like to me two of the biggest communities in Southern California are the running community and the bicycling community. And we ought to see annual growth in events that we're financially supporting. And hopefully with Carolyn on board we will see that. But it just seems like there's this great big well of potential participants who...

1:54:38 You know, would come up here and that we ought to be moving forward to justify our investment. I think John said it on the head about Father's Day. When that first came up, we actually approached the vendor and asked him to move it, you know, earlier in June because we saw that conflict and it's kind of proven out. But still a good amount of participation this year, but it has been declining. I think as we start working on our five-year strategic plan as required and start thinking about that contract for the town around

1:55:07 What constitutes experience is being able to carve out a budget allocation of what supports, similar to what we're trying to do with air service, the same thing with events, where you go through and say, here's a pool of dollars, they go to events, the intent is to grow them to a certain point so that, you know, if the running event, this is my personal view on it, if you have a three-year investment in the running event to guarantee things, after those three years, like, hey, we've gotten to this point now, you know, you're fledgling from the nest.

1:55:35 You're good. We've helped you get to that next point and then take those dollars and invest in the next series of events. And I think we have a potential to be able to keep building off that if we have a strategic plan around that. Well, hopefully with Carolyn on board, we will develop expertise in marketing these things that then Carolyn can share with like events to say, gee, you're, you know.

1:55:59 You're not meeting your goals or you could increase your goals by doing the following things that you haven't been doing, that sort of thing. Hopefully she'll become a knowledge base for new events. I'd like to see that too. And I'm actually even, you know, questioning. So we're not doing any additional marketing for this event above and beyond others. Nope. I almost want to ask why not. And maybe that's a discussion. Because it's policy that we don't want to be preferential to any individual event.

1:56:27 Yeah, and that's why I say almost want to ask that question because I know that there's an entire conversation that, frankly, maybe it's time to start having it. You'd all have to leave room for it. But I tell you what, you know, maybe what needs to happen, though, is that as we get into our strategic discussions, that maybe this is an area that we explore a little bit further. And I think there will be because part of the event group that you were part of to build this position and kind of set the groundwork, we did talk about...

1:56:54 The support of events outside of that kind of October 1 through the winter up till, you know, 4th of July during the need period. And it may be that we decide that during, if somebody wants to bring a bluesapalooza in October, end of September or June or something where it is a need time, that there is a policy that says, okay, we're either going to afford them more dollars or we're going to afford them more marketing support or whatever it is because those are the need times. And I think that's definitely something that we should look at.

1:57:23 Whether it's from a funding standpoint or from a marketing standpoint, I think if June's hovering around a million dollars, if we could pump some money in there from a TOT standpoint and get it up to another $2 million a month or a million five or a million seven, that'd be great. Let me ask just one more question just so that I can ask this in a public forum. And this may be more of a question for Josh. Do we delete any of our posts that we do on Instagram after the event has passed?

1:57:52 Thank you. They live on there. Any other conversations around Mammoth Half Marathon? Yeah, you asked if I had any input on... Lodging? Yeah, on lodging. I'm typically on a vacation at that time, so I have to report back. My premonition is that since it's on my birth date, it's going to be a rousing success. Perhaps more so than ever success than...

1:58:19 on any Father's Day before. Because the inherent problem, the dad wants to drink beer and the rest of the family wants to rally around dad, so therefore, not a lot of running. But yeah, I'd have to get back to you. But I think in concept, it's a solid one. It fits. It's in our wheelhouse, to use a borrowed phrase, for sure. I mean, this is something that...

1:58:47 Yeah, rain or shine, it kind of happens, and people respond well to it, so. But yeah, I'd have to get back to you with some figures, maybe. Before we go to the airplane's contract, Emily, can you grab Brent and just let him know we're done talking about Mammoth Half Marathon? So is there a direction to move forward with a request? Is there a motion on that contract? Oh, move forward with a request for support?

1:59:10 Sorry, Brent, just a second. I'll make a motion to move forward on the $15,000. Second? I'll second. All in favor? Aye. I'm going to recuse myself again because it does, the contract as I reviewed it here has a specific mention to Mammoth Mountain for staff lodging. Okay, so you'll be recused. Any opposed? So carries unanimous, minus one recuse and one absent. Okay, now we're good.

1:59:41 Yeah. So air planners contract with Kent Myers? Yeah, this is really a continuation of what we've been doing with Kent over the years. We've been contracted with Kent since we really, at least Mammoth Lakes Tourism has been contracted with Kent since 2012. The Mountain has worked with him prior to that, I believe back to 2009 at least, well before Eric and I were both here. But this is really just a continuation of our existing agreement with Kent.

2:00:17 And it's within the budget. My personal vote on this is that Kent's support in getting us both Denver with the change in the ICON pass and quickly helping us secure United out of LA after what happened with Alaska has shown his worth to the organization just in that alone. That's my take on it. For transparency, as John alluded to, we have a contract with Kent.

2:00:46 And it's identical to the one that is proposed here. And we have signed it and have executed on that contract. Do you have any concerns that the contract is being proposed by? Just a question overall, did we have legal review of this to make sure, you know, the amount standoff, did we have our legal blesses as well? We had them reviewed a number of years ago, and I'm not sure that has principally changed, but. I just suggest we, a quick, a fair move forward, but I just.

2:01:14 It may want to be one brush through with something changing the law or something we need to modify. Is that note on the side of that? That deletion? Is that just on my copy or is this? No, it's in here. Okay. So that means that I think it's removed? It was just a red line copy, so I'm not sure what. So you deleted a space. Yeah, it looks like it. Period. Yeah, I deleted a double period. Okay, that's okay. Yeah. Okay, so.

2:01:54 Brent, was that a motion to? Scott, I'll make a motion to approve the contract. Would you, pending legal review, do you want to add Brent's concern, or is that just an advisory that we should have contracts reviewed? If we approve the contract, John, and then you communicate with legal and there needs to be a change in a comma or two, that's not really an issue, is it? I don't think so. You can just say approve.

2:02:25 Pending legal review, and if there's something huge that comes up, I'll get back to you with it. Okay. I'll make the motion to approve a pending legal review and conclusions by John and legal staff. I'll second. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Yes, you're going to recuse yourself. I've got to recuse. We have our own agreement. Unanimous minus one. The last one here is just the addendum to our ongoing contract with

2:02:55 Marion Carson, we just received that back late yesterday, and what they've done instead of the addendum, and I sent this to Scott this morning, is they've actually redone the contract itself, so it's not just an update to the addendum, they've actually updated the contract, which was done in 2016, so I need to review that, but the goal is to, it's within our marketing budget at this point, and to give approval to have Scott sign off on that once we get it done.

2:03:19 So specifically the question came up in the contract with Marian Carson, the way that it was written and with the addendum. There were some questions there around who owned assets, the terms of the contract, the ability to determine it, the exclusivity. There was a language there that said that we would use Marian Carson and Marian Carson alone. So I wanted to be able to say, just from a clarification standpoint, the way it was worded is if Josh used somebody to do marketing support or promotion or buy advertising through social media.

2:03:47 That could technically have been in violation of the contract because the contract said, no, we're only going to buy advertising through Marian Carson. So we removed that. We've asked for a change on some of the language around who owns the assets and how those assets remain within the organization here. There was some language in there about how Marian Carson was going to not retain the assets, but they had forever rights to be able to continue to use them moving forward, even though they're things that we paid for. And we want to clarify some of that.

2:04:13 You know, if we separate with Mary and Carson, we own it. If they want to use something to say, here's the good work we did, that's one thing, but they didn't have a permanent license to use that stuff forever on their own, right? Like video content they couldn't take from us and use for some other client. So you want to add some clarifying language there to make sure there wasn't dual purpose. Yep. So we will be able to review that contract then? You can. The option is there. The question I think that John was proposing is a request of.

2:04:41 You're okay with me reviewing the contract with Tim based off the initial request. Nothing's changing on the material budget amount. It's just the initial contract and that addendum if you want that to go back to the whole board to review and approve. My challenge is just there's a lot of money. It's a lot of what we look at for scope. I'd be uncomfortable voting on this without seeing that in hand to make sure that we are all comfortable moving forward whatever those addendments are.

2:05:05 And to be clear, we have a contract that exists, and what we've done is instead of changing just the addendum for 17-18 or for 18-19, they have provided us a new contract. Correct, but this could be built in. Just as a significant part, we've had many conversations about this contract, and I'd be uncomfortable moving ahead without seeing that contract. Move ahead to get ready, but I'd like to vote on that as a board, in my personal opinion, before we finalize.

2:05:31 Given that we have several contracts and questions and stuff that are coming up, I'm going to propose that we're going to need to have a special session of the board between now and October 3rd. Like this contract in particular has been outstanding since July 1. I don't believe that being able to wait until October 3rd for some of these contracts and some of the things we're talking about for the October 3rd meeting is going to be, we're talking about holding off on a lot of stuff until October 3rd to review. Anyone have any issue with trying to put together a special session for contracts?

2:05:59 Offward, I think that this is timely and important, but at the same time, in light of the fact that we're reviewing our contract with the town and our overall strategy, I think that it is important that we review this contract. Okay, so then John and I can work together to find a special session time outside of our regular, but then, as I understand it, then that the, we'll finish this contract, the contract will get shared, I believe, going back to Brown Act questions, and just timing-wise so everyone's clear.

2:06:27 We have a number of contracts and a number of other documents that we're going to send out on an agenda. We can't, I don't believe, we have to question how much of that we can send out prior to for everyone to review, but there'll be a fair amount of reading for people prior to being able to go back and look at those contracts. So heads up in advance. Hopefully we'll be able to just

2:06:48 Highlight the differences, obviously, because it's a big contract. What's the difference between what we had and what's the difference between what we're proposing? Well, like I said, with the Marian Carson contract, well, we asked them to update the addendum. They got rid of the addendum and added into a new version of the contract. Just wherever the new language is. Yeah, it's all highlighted. Redline is very helpful. That should be easy. I mean, I'll go on record just saying that the initial contract, in general, is something that I think

2:07:16 does raise questions. We're somewhat bound by that contract. We have an addendum whether we go through this new one. And I think as we start talking about our relationship with Mary and Carson long term down the road, we should probably really look at these contracts and whether that should follow our strategies, not retroactive. Okay. Closed session. We talked about having a closed session regarding Dirk Winters. I know that this is a place we were going to leave the room. Just kind of a, I can give the update if you want. So generally what we understand right now is that

2:07:46 If everyone's not aware, the property's been listed. You're right, everyone's aware of that. The property's been listed. We've been in conversation with legal counsel. Paul has taken some lead there with some conversations with our legal counsel, also going back and reviewing some of the terms of the agreement. The question comes up now as far as path forward. I think questions that are there that are unanswered, and these are things that the reason why we're not going to go into closed session is because we don't actually know if there's litigation at this point in time.

2:08:16 And we're not entirely sure. We're waiting on some feedback from town plus some of the responses from Dirk. What we do know is that Dirk has sent a letter to town asking that he no longer has to pull his permit requests. That means that he is not going to go forward with any of the improvements. Our understanding looking at it is that that means that if he's not going forward with those improvements, that that is a default on the $300,000 agreement with MLT.

2:08:44 Whether that gets paid back to the organization or not, I think, is still TBD. So that's, we don't know yet. We don't know if that's going to be requiring litigation or not. So it's open session until we know for sure what that situation's like. Does that sound fair to your understanding? Yes. But basically, we're not going forward with the discussion today because the language that we used to notice the discussion did not pass a muster with Andrew Morris, who wanted more specific language to be an absolute

2:09:14 compliance with the Brown Act. So we thought it best not to go forward until we did that. I think probably for the advice of the board is just to be aware that there are litigations not out of the question. We don't yet know what's happening and there's still some vague questions as to whether or not the property could even be sold with its current constraints or not. And so there's enough questions now that

2:09:40 Without answers, there's really no action for the board to be able to take. There's still a lot of questions to go forward, and I think the next time the board meets, it'll likely require a closed session because there are conversations that may come up specifically around litigation, acquisition, whatever those things are, so that we can actually publish those very accurately to be able to justify that conversation. Scott, really there are a number of issues at stake.

2:10:10 And since you've already indicated that we're going to need a special session before October 3rd, it really would be beneficial to have our closed session at that time because, as I understand it, the property has been listed for sale so that there is some jeopardy for us in regards to this matter. And it would be strategically best to have that closed session meeting

2:10:40 If we're going to have a special session anyway, we might as well do it at the same time. And then we can notice it. So it's a request to add this as an agenda item to a special session. I'm sorry? That's a request to add this topic as a special session agenda item. And John will run it past Andrew and get his approval that it meets the requirements of the Brown Act in terms of the exact wording of the notice. Okay. Moving on. Patiently waiting for your presentation.

2:11:16 So I'm going to turn this over. I'm going to go run the slideshow, but I'm going to turn this over to Amanda from Marion Carson. We've got Amanda on the phone, we've got Whitney on the phone, and we've got Clint Osler from Embark on the phone. And Amanda's going to run the presentation. They should be on the speaker. Good day. Yeah, let's just make sure that goes close. Good day, everyone. Hopefully you can hear me clearly. Yes? Yeah, I can hear you. Perfect. Well, thank you, Executive Director, Chairman, and Board members for having us here today.

2:11:48 And again, I know there were some questions earlier on the Marianne Carson contract. I wish so much I could be with you all in person to hear you clearly, but I'm more than happy to address any questions, and we'll circle back with the chairman and John Urdi to get those answered for you. That being said, I know there's been a lot on this agenda, so my plan today is to walk through the presentation that was shared earlier. John will work with me. We'll move through all the slides together, if you don't mind, and then keep quiet.

2:12:18 So that being said, we'll open into the presentation itself and I'm on slide two. Just quickly for our agenda today, we're going to walk through the situational analysis, our media strategies and objectives and planning parameters. We've also prepared for you today the sample media partners that we work with and messaging considerations that have also been

2:12:47 working quite wonderfully for us this past year. We've taken learnings and continue to develop our air service programs to do even better for the destination. I'm going to provide an overview of the media sliding and budget, and then we can go in and talk about it. But if we move over to slide three, where we currently sit with the air service program is growing. And up until now, we have always looked at

2:13:15 We have the budget year over year and season by season to be able to determine how much of that budget we can support with air service messaging. Now, with the additional air service that has been added for fiscal year 18 and 19, it's time for us to reevaluate, per se, how we put dollars toward these flights. We have the Denver route. We have the Orange County route coming into play.

2:13:43 And we also have, you know, the heavy-up service in winter. And so with the additional service that's been secured and the board's request to set its air service program up for success, for continual success, we are making that recommendation, as we've always had an always-on air service program, to look at it even more holistically as a year-round paid media program so that we can explore ways to partner with our air service partners,

2:14:12 in-destination partners, as well as working with ourselves and our own seasonal campaigns to ensure that we are maximizing dollars to support air service. So in order to implement this new path for air service, we do need some additional funds since there are those additional routes, and which I will walk through now the media plan and framework for the year so that it is understood.

2:14:38 where those dollars will be going, and then how we plan on looking at air service moving forward again to continue to set the destination up for success. So as we move on to slide four, this is really outlining our framework for planning this media. Our overarching goal, as always, is to make Mammoth Lakes a strong year-round destination, and one way to achieve this is to increase our visitation through our air service while maintaining those costs.

2:15:08 Been working very hard with our seasonal campaign to ensure everywhere we can possibly insert our air message that makes sense, we are doing so. That being said, we can put additional media strategies in play to help the performance of our plan. This includes maximizing our reach of flight messaging by making sure we're always targeting a qualified non-stop flight accessible designated marketing area.

2:15:35 It's better for us to focus on the people that we know that we can convert to flights versus more of a broader buy. So that way we are converting as many people as we can to flights. We can partner even stronger with our air service providers as well to make sure that we are retargeting people with the offers to come to Mammoth as well as the flight offers that are worked on to promote people to fly instead of drive.

2:16:02 And then we even want to expand our ability to work cooperatively with our stakeholders in destination so that there is added value to participate and to support air service. And it's not just benefiting the destination as a whole, but it's letting people know, you know, you can fly and stay with us, you can fly and experience the destination in many ways. So our immediate objective overall is to increase that awareness.

2:16:27 We want to increase that consideration through working with our air service partners specifically, which up until now, our current marketing plan does not have the incremental budget to support, as well as increase our intent to use that air service by working with our service providers and our in-destination partners. This is Brent Truex. I've got a quick question for you on that. So when I look at this holistically, it looks very similar to what we're doing now. I'm not seeing how we're changing.

2:16:56 For the incremental, particularly, I'm already jumping ahead a little bit, and I excuse myself, we look at Denver. I really see this broad marketing as something we've been doing, and we've seen that our results have not been dramatic. How is this different than anything we're doing right now? We're doing more of it, but how is this different? So, and I can get through the whole plan and talk about it holistically for you. However, our air service plan is doing very well for us. We continue to increase our time on site and engagement.

2:17:27 in which we can drive people to consider flights. This is completely different from what we were doing in the past because we have not had the opportunity to co-op directly with our air service partners. Up until now, we are sending all of our visitors to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism destination site and we cannot track people who are converting to flights.

2:17:47 So by co-opting with our air service partners, we can now track that and ensure we're giving people better opportunity to show that our marketing is working. No, I'll hold the end, but I believe our employments and our load factors have not dramatically increased. So unless I'm wrong, which I don't believe I am, we have nominally increased air service. I'm not trying to be bad on that because I'm very, very excited about the potential. Just as we go through this, I'm looking at we're spending additional dollars. I'm not broad-based marketing.

2:18:16 to me is, I question that, and I get a little detailed, but I'll stop there. I'll go through the rest of the pieces so you can see how they all work together, and in comparison to the efforts that we've been doing up until now, really we've been trying to get the awareness out there for air service. A big portion of the marketing dollars that we are spending is saying, hey, this airline exists. Now we need to get people further into that booking pass to say,

2:18:46 Here's the deals. Here's how you convert them. And at the end of the day, we need to be working with our air service partners who can actually send out those deals and convert those flights so that our dollars are working harder for us. So as we move through the mentality of looking at planning from a seasonal standpoint, I am on slide five right now. We are still going against the same targeting practices that we use for our fall, winter, and summer seasonal campaigns. Again, focusing on the target market.

2:19:17 specifically where air service is available. This is also a differentiation from what we have done in the past in which we are making sure we are looking at these incremental dollars and allotting them by the number of routes that exist. So as I had stated previously, what we do is we look at the budget as a whole based on the support that we've been provided and been able to figure out where that air service messaging can come into play. By pooling in these incremental dollars, these are ensuring we're matching

2:19:46 our division of these dollars in the lower funnel of purchasing to the number of flights that exist that season. Again, so there's one flight in the fall, one flight in the summer, so smaller portions of the budget are going to support that, whereas it's more heavy up in winter when there's more flight service available to us. And then as we move to slide six and to slide seven, I'm going to start breaking down into the specific

2:20:14 partner placements, the media partner placements, and suggested creative. And again, so we are all on the same page. Since the budget has not been completely secured, this is not a finalized media plan. We would need the budget secured by the board today in order for us to move forward with those final buys and to be able to coordinate with our partners and ensure that we can get the most maximum added value out of our dollars. So on slide seven,

2:20:43 We're looking at our first objective. So this is increasing that awareness of Mammoth Lakes Air Service through seasonal brand campaign messaging integration and or rotation. This section right here is the core piece of how we currently get our air service messaging across since we are funded to first and foremost, you know, support the air service as well as support the seasons in which people travel to Mammoth Lakes. So as we head to slide eight.

2:21:12 Social media is a big partner for us in this space. This is an exploratory space where people are not only garnering awareness of the destination as a whole, but of the availability of that air service as well. So I won't go through word for word here, as I know the board has access to this full report, but we've made sure on every page we've been very clear with the units that we're purchasing, how they're being targeted, the key performance indicators or case guides as you read, and how we measure success.

2:21:42 the creative that we'll be utilizing as well as where they're driving. And so as I had stated earlier specifically for this section, these are the assets again that we've currently used year over year and they drive to the seasonal landing page for air service on the MLT site. So we would continue to keep this layer in noting that it helps let people know who are interested in coming to the destination that there is that ability to fly there.

2:22:08 And then moving forward to slide nine, additionally, we work with some other partners that also achieve this awareness. We have responsive ads through Google. These are more direct when it comes to exploring and wanting to research how getting to Mammoth Lakes is easy. And so this is also woven into our brand creative rotation, and it also leads to that landing page featuring air service.

2:22:35 And then on slide 10 as well, we are considering adding in what we in the industry call an end card or a donut to talk about air service for our video. So this would ensure that people that we are reaching on an awareness layer and a broad stream, that we are hitting them with not only what the destination has to offer year-round, but the knowledge that they can fly there and achieve an easy and convenient flight.

2:23:00 So again, this section really focuses on the core pieces of the advertising that we continue to maintain year over year. As we move into the next two sections, you'll see a little bit of where we're starting to inject some new thoughts along with some tried and true practices for us. On page 11, we have our second objective, which is to increase consideration to use air service through Mammoth Lakes Tourism site traffic. So this is, again, further education down in the consumer journey about

2:23:30 how it is to get there and encouraging people to book flights. So as we move to page 12, two of our key partners in this space, this would be our banner unit. So this is where we start to get, we start to include the price points that work very well in converting people. Again, as we look to the pieces I've laid out here, the targeting, we're starting to really focus on people that are showing the search, the search.

2:23:58 packages for looking to book a trip to Mammoth Lakes, and we're measuring this still against the time that is spent on site, as well as the people that are clicking through on these ads. We have our preliminary results for fall, and we are seeing increased time on site of people who are interested in flying to Mammoth Lakes. But again, I believe to answer your question a little bit earlier, Brent, one of the things in this space, because we do not have direct access to say

2:24:26 This ad led to this flight. We're still increasing our awareness of the flights that are available, but because we are the tourism board, we do not have access to the proprietary data that is owned by the airlines. By partnering with them in this space, we're taking people further down the funnel and being able to say, okay, I'm going to retarget them with an airline unit and be able to determine and make some optimizations against what our ad money is lending to people booking those final flights.

2:24:54 And then same thing on slide 13, our search engine marketing efforts. Again, this is still more of a mid-funnel effort. We are targeting users that are still showing signs of considering their travel to Mammoth Lakes. We are still measuring in this space on click-through rate and time on site. And the message you're seeing here is still that general slide to Mammoth messaging. People are still in that educational phase. They're still working through, you know, how they're going to get to the destination.

2:25:22 And it's flying to the flight page. Sorry to interrupt. I believe the chair has a question. Can you hear me? This is Scott McGuire. Can you hear me okay? It's a little muffled. If you could ask the question and John could repeat, that would be helpful. It's also really tough hearing her. I don't know if we can move that. Can you hear me better now? I'm trying to get the microphone as close as you can. Yes, I can hear it very much better. Thank you. Quick question. You were talking about the air service partnerships and going through and looking at your KPIs. I know that they have proprietary information, but...

2:25:52 If we're going to have more of a partnership with them, is there anything we can get past post-CTR to be able to tell us any kind of conversion and why and how we compare to other markets? So, I mean, it's great to know that we're getting improved CTR and improved time on site, but is there anything that says, hey, compared to other destinations, your actual transactions that are committed are at or below or in the norm for other markets we're in? I'd be curious if, you know, if United be willing to share that with us, like, hey, you know, compared to...

2:26:21 Jackson Hole, when people come through your tourism site, you guys are better, worse, or why? Can they share any of that with us, even if it's not the actual transaction itself, as far as how we perform in their markers? To my experience with past destinations, as some of you may or may not know, I did work with the Las Vegas Tourism Board and on their air service program, and even then, some of the biggest airlines were tight to hold their information and telling us.

2:26:50 You know, who was converting and how much was converting. What does help, again, is when you're partnering with them, those dollars to dollars, which you're about to see in our objective number three, where we are very helpful because we are showing our monetary contribution to them and supporting their flight directly, that they will partner with us. And even if it's them, I guess, to say...

2:27:12 spending our money, but then reporting back on the data, we're more likely to get some of those results that we need to continue to be better and make our plan work harder. I may defer if Clint is on the phone at the moment, if he has any other additional information coming from a more winter-focused destination that he's worked with on the past in these sorts of situations. Yeah, I would just add, you know, speaking towards United, they are...

2:27:40 They're pretty guarded with their information, just as I've been working with them and the rest of us have been trying to kind of build a cooperative partnership with them. But I think things are kind of turning, at least with United this year, because they've expanded the footprint quite a bit and we are, as Amanda's kind of leading to, we're planning to share more information in terms of budget and strategy. I think they're going to open up a little bit more and try to help us out where we can on optimizing

2:28:11 The performance. But aside from adding tracking pixels and things that are necessary on their site to track actual conversions, it's going to be very difficult for them to tell us how much traffic is coming from our source and of that what is converting and vice versa with other destinations. So I think that would be a challenge, but I think the plus side this year is we're kind of setting the groundwork for hopefully a better relationship.

2:28:43 cooperatively with them on different media programs. Yes, and as we lead into this objective number three, this is the piece where really the majority, if not all, of that incremental budget is going. So I apologize if I wasn't more clear with that sooner, but we did want you to see the holistic existence of air service presence within the overarching marketing plan.

2:29:09 So when you think of objectives number one and two, and to your point again, Brent, these are the pieces of the puzzle that we have been implementing on a regular basis. But this objective number three is really our core opportunity to try to increase our presence and work with our air service partners. So as we move to slide number 15, and I'm pretty excited to share this with you guys, but Maren Parson also happens to be the media and creative agency of record for JetSuiteX.

2:29:36 Coincidentally, and I don't know how this happened, I also am the group account director overseeing that piece of business as well. So we are hoping through our partnership with both brands that we can find congruencies and help work together on making some media plans where to the board's concern we can look at some of that data, be able to learn from it and grow from it and be able to target people that are looking to fly from markets that JetSuiteX service does exist within.

2:30:03 So these display banners are where we're using the airline partners' creative instead of our own. People have affinity for these brands. They're looking for deals with these brands. We're working with them specifically to retarget. If somebody has engaged with, I believe, we want to just quickly hop to slide 12 just for the visualization, John. If someone has worked and clicked on one of our brand banners, and I'm excited to announce it seems the airplane visual is working very well.

2:30:33 for us this fall, as we drop down to slide 15, we'll be able to retarget them directly with an ad per se if they're flying from a United Market or a Jet Suite Market and be able to drive them specifically to the United site or the Jet Suite site and help them convert the trip further. And to the point Clint had mentioned earlier and just on our side, we cannot guarantee the data that these airline providers will share with us, but we are hopeful that

2:31:00 This will help us convert more flights because we're working off of their brand affinity and they can give us at least enough information or we can let them control a little bit more of the media story so the ads are getting more targeted and we're really getting in front of people that are showing interest in flying to the destination. As we fly, as we fly, oh, I'm so funny, aren't I? As we move on to slide 16, we're also looking at social media as well.

2:31:30 A lot of interest in Facebook with our JetSuiteX partner. So we are feeling it is a good opportunity to weave in Mammoth messaging as well and to be able to drive people directly to the JetSuiteX site to book their flights. And again, this partner, specifically JetSuiteX, we believe will have a little bit more freedom to get creative and message and work with their target audiences and be able to capitalize on those that we see have interest in flying to a winter destination.

2:32:00 And then finally, on slide 17, we're also looking to utilize search engine marketing as well. So these three tactics right here are really the crux of why we would like to request these incremental dollars. This process has not before been completed or part of the marketing plan for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And by adding this additional layer and working very closely with JetSuiteX and again doing...

2:32:28 Everything in our power we can to try to get United to share information with us or at least, you know, expand the horizon of why they're offering to partner with us. This is, again, really where we think we can move the needle for the destination. So, just quickly going over flighting, and I'm going to jump quickly to slide 19. This shows where the media would be in market and when. So, our target audience, as I had mentioned before, are specific and we will match.

2:32:58 them to the audience we tend to target by season for fall, winter, and summer. But we want to make sure, unlike past years, there's a more continuous support for our air service. So we know that flights are being loaded a little bit earlier than the season itself actually starts. That way, we're smoothly transitioning from fall to winter to summer and ensuring that people know the flight service exists and we're sending them to a place they can book even before the day the flight becomes available.

2:33:27 So this year we want to be more conscious of that as well. And then slide 20, the budget recommendation just so everybody can visually see the overarching support that would happen in addition to the incremental funds being requested.

2:33:51 Again, for fiscal year 1890, we're looking to pull funding from two places. We'll continue to pull funding from the brand advertising budget to support the awareness pieces. And then our dedicated air service budget, this incremental request, is to beef up our consideration support, which we'll already have some of. And then, again, as I have mentioned, mainly focus on that intent layer to travel.

2:34:16 So we believe an additional $400,000 is the right amount for the board to approve to invest to ensure that we are hitting all of the people in the consumer journey that are looking to purchase a flight. And then additionally, we would look to include air service as its own line in the paid media budget. So knowing that before, again, we've integrated it by season.

2:34:39 And it's always been there, and we've always looked at it as its own program. We want to even pull it out even more visually, and we'll begin to plan it as its own separate line item so everybody feels confident up front. So our eight-hour board meeting to review the annual plan will become nine hours, but you know what? It's going to be worth it for everybody. And then beginning of 19-20, our request for the board is to include that additional $250,000 year over year.

2:35:07 So that's just ensuring, you know, we're keeping up maintenance of the intent to travel in the air service line and that, again, budgets will be planned with a separate air service line in mind so it's understood the funds that are going to support the seasons throughout the year. Again, everything you see below is detailing out the ad budget and the incremental budget and the total. And so even with a lower budget than we've had in the past 17-18 fiscal year,

2:35:35 We are still keeping the same level of support with the additional incremental budget included to support air service. And then finally I'll round this up with slide 21 that just goes over our timing. Since we are in the middle of fall, it is important and we ask for the board's approval today on this incremental fund. That way we can move forward in talking to our air service partners to secure co-ops as well as finalize our media planning.

2:36:03 Get the plan completed and roll it in, roll the media in without faith. So I appreciate it and thank you for your time today and I'm open to any questions at this time. Okay. So we're being asked to approve this budget change today? An additional $400,000. Correct. Which is...

2:36:28 Stan, if I'm not mistaken, we went back and we reduced our air service budget originally by $500,000 and we approved our budget back in June and now we're being asked to add that $400,000 back in. Right, because at the time when we approved the budget we didn't have the additional flights that we needed to support. No, just to put a clarification, we reduced it $500,000 because we had additional funds from the year before we invested in flight service. That came out and so we're down $500,000 what we spent before. So we're still spending the same money on?

2:36:57 Right. The reason the marketing went down this year was based on the TBID contributions on season pass. Okay, because where I'm going to go a little bit is I'm a little concerned about what's air marketing, what's general brand marketing is worth my challenge in all this. That's probably where I'm going to go. That's where I'm trying to sort this out in my head of saying, well, I recognize we need a certain amount of input and expense to make sure we have this successful. If I was to read this the other way, I'd say...

2:37:22 The original budget that was submitted was at least $60,000 short of where we should have been probably to do air service. I'm just trying to make sure I understand the parameters here. And I guess part of my question here is, and this was not part of our packet, so I'm just. This was additional, it was an additional attachment as a PDF. Yeah, it was. I missed it then. Oh, it was the, yeah, it was a separate package because it was too big. Third attachment. Okay.

2:37:55 Just to quickly address the previous question in terms of understanding where the budget is going, as previously mentioned, the money that is going towards brand advertising and awareness is coming from the initial already approved budget. This, again, comes from those objectives, number one and number two, where we have continuously supported and driving people to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism website to learn and discover more about flights where they can click through and

2:38:24 Book a flight with our partner. That being said, the additional incremental funds is that opportunity to work with our partners like never before and invest more money in the opportunity to drive people to where they can directly book a flight where we see less drop-off and more value for our money as well as work with them in other area opportunities. Again,

2:38:46 noting, you know, our earned media teams and owned media teams are also always working to support it as well, but it's those paid media dollars that get in front of the people who are directly looking to buck slice with their preferred air carrier. And I would also just throw out, too, that we're working pretty closely with United, and they're interested in helping us out with the Denver launch, and so their request has been to see, you know, a media plan on how we plan to support

2:39:15 The Denver flights, given the fact that it's brand new service and it's going to take a little bit of an investment to ramp up and get more awareness built around those, they've expressed interest in augmenting that in some way, whether it be through their own channels. One of the things that's thrown out is including Mammoth Lakes on all of their information displays that are throughout the Denver terminal, as well as email inclusion and other

2:39:45 elements or assets they own in the Denver region. And so us showing our commitment on what we're going to be doing on the marketing side or advertising side, I should say, is going to help try to seal the deal with United in terms of getting more assets and elements that they don't normally provide or do for other resort destinations. And so that's kind of where the number is relatively large, but it's kind of a necessity just given the fact that

2:40:14 Zero Awareness of Mammoth Lakes in Denver today. And we're trying to build that awareness and get partnership from United. And I would echo that sentiment on the JetSuiteX side as well, although we are flying from markets that aren't supported with brand awareness dollars for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Once JetSuiteX sees our commitment in terms of budget to support these initiatives, they are open to including Mammoth Lakes.

2:40:39 Not only in their digital advertising, I've showed you examples of here today on page 15, but they do run television, they are looking into running a television campaign in November, where with the secured partnership with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, they will be open to including Mammoth Lakes as a destination that is listed as a place where people can fly from.

2:41:03 They do not normally feature seasonal destinations, but the commitment on that side would open them up to revising their creative to include our destination. And even to further speak to that as well, again, the continued partnership with Mary and Carson on the media side of both would allow us to really pay attention to the data, but the way ads are currently purchased with Mammoth Lakes.

2:41:28 Tourism, and we look to drive people directly to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism website. The capability to really build and be a valuable partnership for both Mammoth Lakes Tourism and JetSuiteX would require that additional investment. One more thing that's pretty exciting. I've been talking with JetSuiteX off and on the last couple weeks, and they're also very interested in supporting lots of local cooperative opportunities on the advertising side. So as we build out even the local component,

2:42:02 We're going to be working with them pretty closely on trip giveaways and promotions of that nature. And they've even expressed interest in working with individuals outside of the Mammoth Resort properties, which was kind of a commitment they've already agreed to, but even working with some of the other independent hotels and lodging partners in town, providing flights for different opportunities for inclusion in the marketing materials and promotions that local independent

2:42:33 Lodging partners are providing as well. So I think it's going to be really exciting to work with JetSuiteX coming up to the local level as well as on the external paid advertising side. So I have a couple questions more for the board, not for the presentation here. Okay, we're just going to have a couple board questions right now within the board. So a couple things for me that I think about on this is that, you know, when we, when I look at this breakdown,

2:43:05 I support the idea of going and supporting the JetSuite X side of things, the 337 for winter. I feel like we took a reduction in our budget with the loss of the season pass contributions from Mammoth. The resort owns those contracts and those agreements. The mountain expressed a desire to be able to invest those funds. I think that with MLT owning the agreement with JetSuite X and particularly the fall and the summer where we're trying to grow our shoulders quite a bit, I think are...

2:43:31 This is just my opinion on this, is that those are places where I feel comfortable with us investing in incremental, but knowing that we took a budget shortfall earlier this year, and specifically around air marketing, specifically around a decision by the mountain, and knowing that the mountain is invested heavily in Denver, I feel like that obligation to drive winter traffic out of Denver is that of the mountains, and that this organization shouldn't take on those additional dollars and should focus on JetSuiteX and the shoulder seasons if we're going to take on additional marketing spend. That's my

2:44:01 So you're looking at the 110 that's in the 337 for Denver? You're saying reduce that by the 110 that's in there for Denver? That 337 has, I think, 110 in it. And I'd like to see a breakdown of what winter is entirely, but without having more clarity on what winter is, I support the 31-250 for fall and the 31-250 for summer. I have questions around winter in general, in addition to the 110 for Denver. Okay. Well, let's ask the questions so we can get the answers. Yeah, fair question.

2:44:33 What are your questions around what you're specific? We took $500,000 out of our air marketing budget this year specifically with the loss of the season pass dollars and my understanding was the Mountain was going to be using those dollars to market air and now we're being asked to come back and spend $400,000 in marketing air. That seems like we took those dollars, we did that to be able to get TBID back in place and now we're being asked to come back and refund those dollars again.

2:45:03 90 days later, it's hard for me not to feel like that was a little bit of a, you know, follow the shell. So, Scott, from a mountain perspective, it won't directly answer your question immediately, but I think that it will provide some information as it goes in that direction. So, going back to the TBID and where we clearly stated our perspective of what we feel the TBID is important for, and that is to provide air service for our community.

2:45:33 And during those discussions, we didn't bifurcate how much was this marketing dollars, how much was this that. We were saying this is what can be generated through a TBID, through our customers, and we feel it's important that this type of funds go towards air service because we think that that's the most important thing in our community, whether it be marketing, whether it be subsidy. What's that total number?

2:45:59 And so let me get to your questions in a second, because I want to make a point in the sense that when we look at how we then went down to Bishop and said, you know, part of us continuing on with TBID is to be ensured that we're looking at the right regional air service solution. And during the due diligence of that,

2:46:27 We had discovered that there was no way that we could spend MLT funds on infrastructure down at Bishop. So without being able to spend MLT funds on Bishop, we look at the reduction of what we've estimated. Could be less, could be more.

2:46:49 Just to be clear, of $500,000 reduction from essentially our contribution to TBID would be around $2.5 million versus a $3 million that we contribute to TBID. So knowing that we have that $500,000 reduction, we had committed that we're going to continue to use this money to help regional air service. And although we can't charge our guests,

2:47:17 and pass it on directly. We were actually saying that we're going to make commitments within our organization to contribute that amount of money, even though we're not getting it directly from the gas. So it comes from our bottom line. So when we looked at it, we said, okay, if we're not able to use MLT funds for a terminal.

2:47:42 or other parking infrastructure down at Bishop, but that's the right area to go, then we would look at that. So that's how we bifurcated the $500,000. You're talking about it being marketing, and I know we've had several conversations. You talk about it coming out of our budget, specifically. It comes out of marketing. It's coming out of marketing. So when we talked about, back in our budget conversation, we talked about having a budget shortfall. John left, but I remember talking about this million-dollar budget shortfall, of which $500,000 was that.

2:48:12 Just a clarifying point. So you came back and you said the intent with TBID was the $2.5 million that the mountain contributes to be going towards general regional air service. If I look at our current financial contributions between all subsidies, all in, that number for 2018, if we take on the... From TBID specifically, it's 2.15. Okay. And then we have currently $250,000 in air marketing. We're at 2.35.

2:48:41 That tells me that there's $150,000 of air marketing intent from the mountain, a contribution to TBID that hasn't been spent, not $400,000. So the question is, really, does the board feel comfortable taking another $250,000 to $300,000 from the general budget? Do you guys follow how I did that math? I think so, yes. So in general, if we said, look, we agree that all of the mountain's dollars are going to pass through the organization to support air marketing, and it's 2.5.

2:49:09 2.15 is in all the subsidies. That leaves $350,000, right? We have $250,000 currently targeting air budget. We now have that broken out where we didn't have that before. That leaves a difference of $100,000.

2:49:26 I followed that math too, but from a Mountain perspective, I think transparently we're all trying to work towards air service and not trying to do the math on a daily basis as to how much is getting spent there. The reason why I'm bringing it up is because I do think that if, in good faith, if we made the agreement with the Mountain saying, yes, we understand that all that 2.5 is going to pass through the organization to BTB, which is what I just heard. That was the way we were looking at it.

2:49:56 Roughly $100,000 still left of that that the organization was somewhat obligated to commit to air marketing based off of the agreement with the mountain. Fair enough. Which leaves us really asking about $300,000. But not $400,000, $300,000. We still had more. And that means that the organization itself hasn't invested in air marketing at all outside of the contribution for the mountain. Does that make sense?

2:50:19 Well, we have with Measure A. That's the caveat, is that on the subsidy side, we've got $150,000 set aside in Measure A. So the total air subsidy commitment is $2.3 million, but the TBID specifically for summer and winter is $2.15. So we have another $150 from there? From where? From Measure A? From Measure A. Yes. We have it already budgeted as another $150 to cover summer. So, with that accounting,

2:50:49 And looking at the philosophy aspect and whether we think that this is the right investment, I also wanted to share that in addition to that, we are, of course, working with the team to provide further marketing efforts as well. And I'll just go through that really quick. Obviously, we're going to be looking at our emails and we're going to have dedicated Mammoth Air Service campaigns, ICOM passholder database.

2:51:18 You know, there's 200,000 plus at this point. We hope to have many more. There's 30K in Northern California, there's 50K in Southern California, and there's 60K in Colorado. We're going to have multiple inclusions in the Altera newsletter. We're going to have non-passholder Mammoth Air Service campaigns as well for SoCal, NorCal, and domestic connectivity versioning.

2:51:45 300K in our active segments, guests who have visited us in the last two seasons, inclusion in all lodging pre-arrival emails, inclusion in all dump alerts, our best performing emails, heavy promotion of any fair sales, lodging, event, powder discounts, flight icon, where in all of our emails there will be a circle like an emoji of flights that you can

2:52:13 look at and will be out there. Organic social with heavy promotion on our Facebook, Instagram, Twitter. Facebook is 345,000 followers. Instagram's 333,000. Twitter's 49,000. Paid media and PR campaign and budget is set out there. I don't have the exact digital spend on that, but there is an amount.

2:52:43 Co-op and market activation expected, placement in Mammoth Magazine and other partner publications. The web, of course, are home pages, dedicated air service and flight deal pages, main deals and package pages, lodging, event discount support on sub-landing pages, promotion on five separate hotel websites, 35 million annual page views through Mammoth.

2:53:08 Mountain.com only. Out of those activities, just curious, since we were talking about the discovery of Denver and these additional flights, for winter specifically, we're talking about increasing, we're talking about being down, the organization's being asked to spend 437% more on winter air marketing than what was originally budgeted. Is Mammoth planning on spending four or five times what its original air marketing was now that these new flights have come available for winter time?

2:53:37 Yeah, man. Without having to reveal the dollars, I'm just curious, like, my concern obviously is that people, you know, if someone's concerned that we're just, that MLT is basically just paying for Mammoth's advertising of air service. Right. Is that in our best interest? And so I'm just trying to clarify, like, is there an equal amount of investment from the mountain to come back and promote to what's being asked of MLT, whether it's pass-through of TBID dollars or not?

2:54:00 Correct. Understood. So I look at that two ways. I look at it from a marketing perspective as well as a risk perspective, which we don't have the exact number of how much the Denver flight is going to cost us, but we believe in the destination air service and we think that the connectivity through Denver is really important for us. And we feel that that's, you know, a significant amount of money that we're going to have to pay that we weren't budgeted for.

2:54:30 So both through marketing and through subsidy, we're planning on having to spend more than the $437,000. That was just the point I wanted to get to, was just find out that MLT is kind of on the hook for fall and summer since those are not related to mountain travel or investment. And if that $337,50 feels right, just knowing that...

2:54:59 The Mountain is a partner they're taking on additional risk. It's not just coming back to this organization to take on that risk. And I'll just say that, you know, I kind of want more to go to fall and summer. You know, I get it with regard to the risk at MMSA and, you know, really glad to have you at the table. I don't mean to be discounting what I'm saying at all, but I guess I'm just, you know, looking at it from the opportunity to grow that if we were going to be...

2:55:26 Spreading some of these dollars that I'd like to see it go towards more fall and summer. That's just my personal opinion. I'm going to vote that way. I'm going to say it. I want to be very clear and appreciative. Keep in mind we have the one flight spring and summer, so we have one flight to feed there. There's even more opportunity to grow. Correct. This budget was allotted based on the flight and even the capacity.

2:55:56 of the people and the frequency of those flights as well, which is why you're seeing more of this budget push towards winter. The overarching investment and incremental of $400,000, I would say to the board if they were looking to disperse a little bit from winter to push into summer, which is more of an opportunity market for us in this current year. So it is, but my concern overall is in a different way coming at it.

2:56:29 MLT's goal is 10 months a year, $1 million TOT. And we're, wants Denver's flight to be successful, but I look at this and say, and I hate, I hate us trying to split out numbers because we've got professionals on the phone who have given us numbers, but at the same time, I'm struggling with a $400,000 number and realizing it's $250,000 additional year over year on top of that. It's not just $400,000. We're really saying, by conceptual, are we okay with going forward?

2:56:58 And the big part is we've got a great opportunity in front of us. Is this the right optimization of this opportunity? And that's where I struggle with a little bit from that standpoint. And I'll take that conversation even a little bit further. You know, we're talking about reviewing our overall strategic strategy that we're trying to go forward with advertising Mammoth Lakes. And we're talking about moving 400 grand. Let me ask this question. And then the 250 year over year.

2:57:25 We are being asked to vote on this today, and how far into the future is this vote going to tie us? Are we talking about an annual contract or are we talking about multiple? Just this winter. Just this winter. Then we'll... I will tell you, that makes me feel a little bit more comfortable. Then we'll budget for next year. That's a good clarifying question in the sense that there was a recommendation for $250,000 year over year from...

2:57:51 our partners, but I don't think that's what we're voting on, right? Correct, just the 400. And I will say, Board, as well, for your consideration, that incremental money for winter, keep in mind, we would be dividing it by those flights and creating specific creative that speaks to those markets. So when you break that money apart, the money that is being put against each individual flight in that market.

2:58:18 It is still a smaller investment on the grand scheme of things. It may feel like a lot for winter, but if you're parceling that out by market, you know, it will only take us so far, and that's why we're requesting the incremental fund so that we can partner with those airlines and really put the money where it's going to help us the most, where in the consideration and awareness layers, we are still leaving that air service messaging as we always have. On the winter...

2:58:46 On the winter subsidy, so we're talking $110,000 for Denver, that leaves $225,000. Do you know roughly how that $225,000 is split up between JetSuiteX, LA, and San Francisco? You're talking about the advertising dollars, not subsidy? The advertising, so the $337,500. I think that's what you're saying. So Amanda, do you, at this point we say $110,000 for Denver, do you have a breakdown of the other markets at this point, or is that still?

2:59:15 to be determined. Like how much of that incremental is going? Yeah, the incremental, there's about $31,000 a flight, but do keep in mind, you know, there's Burbank, Orange County, we're all in the same area. This is a framework for the media plan, so on the board's approval, that's when the real media planning comes and the official allocation by market is. But on our top line analysis, again, with this being

2:59:42 You know, in addition to the scope of work that we do for the MLT organization, we do feel confident with this $400,000 total dollars and that $300,000, which will be broken out by swipe. And I know that's not the most direct answer, but again, this just being that framework and going off of the about $31,000 to support each route is what we're looking at. What's the $655,3696 total as a percentage of total revenue from the three seasons?

3:00:13 The budget. You lost me. What's the total? The marketing budget is X percentage of total top line. What is the percentage about? Oh, it's 50, 40, 48 percent. It's on our budget sheets. I don't know off the top of my head, but the marketing line itself is more than half of the budget. Is that what you're asking? Or how much is the 600,000? The total revenue generation from all the flights projected for...

3:00:37 Fall, Winter, Summer. We're spending $6.50. How much is that getting us? You're asking us what the return is? What is the marketing as a percentage of sales? Well, so when we go back to the overall, the spring, the number was $10 million from people flying in currently at the current employments. So we garnered $10 million of revenue in our budgets. So that's 6%.

3:01:04 Okay, I didn't understand what you're asking. It seems like it's very, very much in line and we're adding Denver and Orange County. Well, I think the goal is to do with Denver is you're getting longer haul stays, you're longer haul markets, so you're going to get longer stays. You're going to actually see the number, the cost, the spend per passenger go up because they're not going to fly here. Well, maybe they will fly here from Denver on a Thursday and fly back on a Monday or a Sunday, but I'm guessing you're going to see them for a little bit longer. So just maybe a suggestion to move forward.

3:01:34 They needed a budget to be able to work on a plan. The idea of approving a budget increase pending and then final confirmation pending a marketing plan. Meaning, yes, we agreed that there's an additional $400,000, but they're going to come back with a media plan and we would approve that plan in September. Meaning, would this board want to be able to see that?

3:02:04 plan before those funds are actually released to provide that detail that you guys are asking for. It's a little bit chicken egg, like they're asking for the, but they need to know that they can get the $400,000 before they can do the plan. We need to see a plan, really, this is what I'm hearing, is we need to see a plan to have a deeper understanding before we can feel comfortable with the dollars. And so, look at that as a question. That was the conversation we had last month. And we said, no, we want to challenge Marion Carson, go give us a plan that is around $400,000.

3:02:34 And I think that even though this isn't the exact detail of the plan, this is the plan, right? Correct. This is a strong framework. Again, I'm only giving this information from a top-line standpoint, but as we've continued to perfect our placements for our air service marketing, we've already had our mid-check-in for our fall report, and we've increased our time on site that people are engaging with our placements, and we've also...

3:03:03 We've also seen more people moving through our program for our banner inventory as well as our search engine marketing. And that being said, again, you know, when we're seeing this time on site and all of that for advertising, that's a major success. So it's the perfect mix of paid media, it's the, you know, how many flights we have, what's the services, all coming together. And by adding this additional incremental budget, that allows us to work with our partners.

3:03:32 We'll hopefully continue to push even closer to the questions the board is looking for us to be able to answer on the paid media side that, unfortunately, due to the limited data that our partners will provide us, we're unable to do. But we can say with confidence that the paid media program is really working. So us all coming together into those spaces to try to do everything we can to help with that load factor, you know, this is one way to move forward and do it from the paid side.

3:03:59 So if I go back, and my memory is a little bit different, because I thought the request was for $500,000. We said, Mary and Carson, go back and say, okay, what does this look like? So this is their fault. We originally talked about $500,000 was the original number. I just, same, it was the process. It was the process, yeah. What we just, my perspective, what we've just been shared, our tactics that we've been doing, reiterated, does not feel to me like we were just presented with a plan, as much as, here's banners.

3:04:29 Here's SEO, here's those things like that. That doesn't seem the same to me of like very targeted, like it feels like something's missing from that as a plan. Like I understand the initial request, but it doesn't seem like it is fleshed out enough to be able to say, here's the specific markets, here's the specific tactics in those specific markets. Like Denver's great at 110, but like where does that go? What's that specifically for? What's considered a success at 110 in that investment? Okay.

3:04:56 So that would be all part of the media planning process in which the key performance indicators are set, and then we would do the deeper dive into where all these placements go. But again, understanding the request for the framework and needing that approved budget to move forward and start those conversations with our media partners, we're confident with the framework and the partners that we've put forth that we'll be able to put together the right mix of media for each individual market. You have a question? Well, I did have a proposal that might...

3:05:27 Okay, just a couple questions. The $400,000, I mean, we're talking about if we pull this from just our general marketing, this is $400,000 that's being... Reserve. It's from the reserve. Being asked from the reserve. I think that's a good point. And how much reserves do we have? I mean, we all have seen it, but... Right, we have $2 million in TBID reserves right now. Right. Next question, I just want to ask this and...

3:05:51 No offense, Amber, but I'm just going to ask this just because I think I heard it from the audience and being in a public forum, we need to ask this in a public way. A comment was made by Ward Jones earlier, I think I heard him say that we need to get out of the air marketing business that we're not doing a good job of it. I think that's what I heard from Ward earlier. Air service business, I heard. Was it air service or air marketing? Yeah. Okay. So just, I want to be clear then that Marion Carson

3:06:19 Again, no offense, Amber. Is the right entity to be doing this? I mean, they're already doing all of our other marketing, so why not step in and make sure that we're pursuing the air marketing? The question there is somewhere along the lines of are we utilizing the right service for our air marketing? Well, and that's why we hired Embark to work with us as well as the experts. Yep.

3:06:42 So Embark is working with Marian Carson on this? Yeah. So they're doing it as a team, and that's the benefit of the organization. I would say, just jumping in, Matt, since Marian Carson is kind of like the agency of record with what you're doing on the advertising side, like, it's a natural extension to also have them do the media buying and media planning and media strategizing for the air side as well. There's just a lot of, like, economies of scale that come with that.

3:07:10 Instead of breaking that out into a separate agency or a separate another entity that would do that type of media planning exercise. Since it's all under one place and it's broken out into different segments, it's far more efficient than if you were to break it out into separate agencies. They're on point on the strategy and what they're doing. So, I mean, from what I've

3:07:39 Witnesses they're doing versus what I've done with many other clients and even at other, you know, the last grounds is like really on point in terms of strategy and where they're investing time and investment in the different media channels. I know you've heard that question before and that's why I wanted to be clear on making sure that we got an answer out of that. Thank you. So just as a, maybe a suggestion, I don't know if you mind going back to the flow schedule.

3:08:08 If you can go back to the budget slide. So if you can go to slide 20. Given the fact that we're barely at a quorum, because I don't believe, Mr. Clark, you can vote on this. You know, I think I can. And I was going to discuss that with the group beforehand. Because I'm so transparent about where our interests are and what that is, I think that we have the right to do that.

3:08:38 Hopefully this isn't too convoluted of a motion and I don't, as board chair I can make a motion, right? Or do I have to have someone that's not working? You can make a motion. So my motion is that we approve the 400 from reserves with the 31250 approved to spend because that's imminent and the 337500 tentatively approved based on a media plan so that we actually have a better understanding of it. So they're good to go start spending the 31250 now.

3:09:08 The budget is there, but before the dollars get committed, we'd like to see a media plan for the 337,500, and we're good to go on the 31,250. And I think that's fair. So basically we'd be all in on fall and summer, and we'd wait to see a media plan on winter, knowing that the intent is that those dollars are there, but we'd like to be able to review that marketing plan and that strategy before committing those dollars.

3:09:35 By a certain time. Well, that gets us to the next board meeting because they've got financial commitments for fall that need to happen between now and then. So if the plan is generally approved, they've got a launch date that's happening in October. They can commit to fall. They can have a plan to us for winter. We can see a media plan available at the next board meeting with the intent of saying, yes, we agree to spend some extra dollars, but just as a stopgap before those things just go clearly out to go spend, we would like to see the media plan.

3:10:02 and just be able to review that prior to those dollars being allocated. I would like to ask, what are we agreeing to with regard to winter of 1920? Nothing. Okay. So just to be clear, you know, the year-over-year is just that, a recommendation. Okay. Then I'm okay with that. So we approve the four. The fall and summer are clear to be moved forward to 100%, and the winter is...

3:10:29 Approved with the caveat of we'd like to see the media plan as a component of that so that there's that deeper level in specifically at 337. I second that. That's a formal motion. That's a formal motion. All in favor? Aye. Aye. I'll recruit. Just because there's five others here. Actually, I disagree on this one because this is about marketing for the whole town and it has nothing to do with our subsidy.

3:11:00 You got a majority there. I'm saying only because I think we need to make a commitment now, and I'm concerned about the time to just do that. I respect where that's going, and I don't disagree, but I'm just concerned about our time to get ahead of this, and I hate to split out the budget, and I don't want to say I'm good at $300,000 because I don't really feel knowledgeable to make that, but I just...

3:11:19 I think we've got to make a concerted effort to move forward, but I also respect that we really need to move forward. You're comfortable moving forward to $400,000 right now and not even having to wait to see any kind of immediate plan? I'm just saying that you made a motion, the motion got the votes. I'm just saying at this point in time, I'm saying no because I feel that we need to make a commitment to make sure Denver is successful. I don't know if I would, if the motion was $400,000, I'm not sure I would have said yes, but I'm just concerned that we're just going to push down to October and some of this stuff should start now.

3:11:48 That's just my only portion, but you've already got...

3:11:51 John, do you have concerns about going this process if we... No, I think the thing that the agency is waiting for is they're waiting for the commitment of dollars to be able to build the plan because if not, we're asking them to do a hell of a lot of work for nothing. No, and I think that's where, as a group, my motion is to commit those dollars to build a plan and just before that plan gets executed, we'd get to look at the winner plan because it's such an incredible increase. And I think that 928 is a good date. I think they put it in there with the idea that... So the vote is to move forward. You've got the consensus of the board to move forward.

3:12:21 Did Eric, did you recuse? Well, I really, I wanted to talk through the board because I don't know what I'm supposed to do at this point in time. And I feel like we all have these moments where, you know, obviously it's sensitive right now. But I think we are trying to set a new culture of transparency. And I can't imagine looking back how I...

3:12:48 We could be more transparent about what our desires were or what we support and how we want to see money spent. So I think that I have the right, as being appointed by MMSA, to vote in these issues. I would agree with that because you've been clear in what the investment is from MMSA and as the MMSA vote here, we expect you to come with that bias.

3:13:15 Well, but I disagree on it to the standpoint of, I would say, absolutely for this, I would say on air subsidy, you have to be careful with the standpoint of how much is, you have a direct financial interest with how much air subsidy, but this is marketing for the whole community as well as the airport as a bait or draw. I would, and I'm the one who's most sensitive right now, I would not have any objections to you voting on this because I don't think it's, I don't think there is any reason not to. I'd like to go ahead and vote then because I think it's a good principle for us to have on record. Okay.

3:13:44 So we have a 5 and a 1. So you got your budget approved? Thank you. We're good to move forward? Motion passes. Passes. Financial reports? Yeah, I can go through these really quickly here. I think if you look at where we were, initially I was concerned about July because of the smoke at the end of June. And July came in just 0.58 of a percent behind last year or so. July came in very strong.

3:14:14 TBID also came in well over expectation at $348,000. As I mentioned before, CDARS, we have $1.15 million in the Measure A and $2 million in the TBID. We did take out $500,000 with the idea that we needed from a cash flow standpoint to pay the Alaska Airlines invoicing, which we're still working on.

3:14:38 And then we took $350,000 out and set it aside for the wayfinding signage program with the town that we had approved last meeting. So I think it's been removed from the CDARS, so it's sitting in our account now with the idea that we can sign that over to the town once we do an MOVU. I need to get together with Hayes again just to make sure that that's all set. That being said, the checking account balances are there.

3:15:01 Savings counts as well. The joint balance, the joint bucket balance as of July, because July was so strong, we have $102,000 in there for this fiscal year, and then the carryover from last year puts us at $473,000 of uncommitted funds in that bucket. That takes into account the $600,000 that's been committed to the Kings, so it's well, it's over a million bucks in there right now with the idea that there's a substantial portion of that's committed for the next five years with the Kings.

3:15:26 P&L reports, I sent those out. We have reclassified a few things. Thank you to board members who commented on that. We just had a couple things in the wrong direction. So that's the financial report. Quick question, Keith. Year-to-date compared to last year, year-to-date, such a record year. How are we looking overall? Not just month of July. Well, I do still think that we're going to look at August being probably 10 to 15 percent behind is my anticipation. From last year.

3:15:55 From last year. For budget, we're well over budget. I mean, budget, again, is very conservative. If you look at July, it was budgeted at 1.175. Last year was 1.7, and we did 1.75, so. So just, I'm curious, last year was an absolute banner year. Our total year to date at this time last year was roughly. We're $10,000 behind last year right now, because we're only, we start the year in July. And that's a. .58%.

3:16:26 Not even half, it's a half a percent. It's awesome. It's amazing. It's like this. It's pretty amazing, and I think that really the only true blip that I see right now is potentially August. I think September is going to rebound with fall. I think the efforts that we have for fall marketing, I think September, October are going to rebound. The Gran Fondo last week, 25th anniversary, they had 1,700 riders, which was well up over last year. I think we've got a lot of good things going on for the smoke rolling out in August.

3:16:53 Letting people rebook for the fall. So I think September, October. And then after that, it's all dependent on Mother Nature and when she decides to snow down. Just looking at how seasons are rounding out and how summers are shaping up and growing, it's kudos to the team. I think you guys have done an awesome job at, you know, without having additional head count, really being able to go out and grow consistently, like being able to hit numbers the way you guys have been hitting is pretty awesome to see. Thank you.

3:17:21 In the interest of time, I'd be happy to answer any questions. I did have a few items I was going to update you, but I would like to answer your questions first. When's the zip line open? When's the zip line open? That's going to be the first item. Good question. Right now it's looking like we'll have

3:17:45 The authorities to inspect it out at October 8th, inspecting a, expecting a opening of around October 13th. We do intend to continue to operate that this season, so it's being pushed back and, well, we're actually talking about, there's two sections, right? The lower section, I think we're going to operate on opening day.

3:18:10 is kind of the idea right now. Not the upper section, though, because that just provides different challenges for us. But as we look at it, we really want to get it up and running and see how it is operating before next year. So we're still committed to doing that. Had a lot of challenges with the

3:18:32 LIDAR, you know, surveying through the snow, getting everything ready, figured out we made some mistakes there. I have extra dynamiting to get the stuff through. The dynamiting has been canceled so many times because of the lightning, but a lot of explosions still to come. You've got to hang off a drill off the cliffs up there and get in there. So it just took a little longer than we thought and dealt with some adversity, but we're still going to get there.

3:19:00 And Canyon, we think, will be done December 13th. And Night of Lights is December 15th. So just, you know, perfect. Love it. Anything else? So we'll adjourn. Next meeting is October 3rd. And, John, can you send out a request for me to discuss dates for a special session? Yeah. Between now and October 3rd? Yeah. Do you want to do it sooner than later? We can talk about that offline and we can come up with some ideas. Okay, move. We adjourn. Do we need to do that?

3:19:30 Thank you for doing that. Second. Aye. Done. Thanks. Thanks, guys.