Town Council
· recording 4 hr 53 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
633 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
3:32 And I do roll call afterwards, right? Okay. Okay. We'll go ahead and open the Wildfire Prevention Response and Management Workshop. Welcome, everyone. And Dan, I'm going to send it over to you. Yeah, I'll kick this off.
3:55 We've had one of these, I guess it's been a year plus ago or so when we had a discussion related to the rough fire and some of the elements that came into play with that from smoke and other impacts and those types of things and looking at some of the fire management items. This last summer, again, we saw the different wildfires, different areas, and then obviously with the Lions Fire close to town and those things. The side of that and some of the community meetings we had and stuff, I had a brief conversation with Taro, I believe at the time.
4:24 I'll let them go through and introduce all their staff here shortly from the Forest Service. But the offer is, hey, if you really want to talk about some of these issues and where we're at and what we're doing, be glad to come in and have a presentation and discussion. So I appreciate the offer from Forest Service slash BLM to come and do that here for the Town Council and the community and to be able to talk about some of the issues. We wanted to structure this a couple different ways. One is we'll start off with some presentations from our town staff.
4:52 And some of the things that we're doing in terms of fire, bad terminology, but fireproofing the community. What are we doing out there from a planning perspective? What are we looking at? Some grants we've got, some implementation. What are we looking at for fuels reduction within the community, local fire? And the same side of that is to take a look at the forest around us and stuff and what are they doing from that perspective and what's actually going on to try to reduce
5:20 The risk of fire coming into our community. And they can walk through the details of that, but I think we've had about 100 years as if you get a fire, put it out and fuel loading up and longer fire seasons. I'm not sure it ever ends anymore, but longer fire seasons and warmer and hotter fires, et cetera. And we're seeing that throughout the state. The state of California has taken a lot of actions most recently. I think it's SB 901 incorporates a bunch of different changes regarding fire and responses.
5:49 You know, this debate back and forth of how much fire on the ground versus other means of reducing fuel loading. So we want to be able to walk through that and then also have some time to look at, you know, what's that decision matrix when we get a localized or regional fire, whatever we want to call them here in the region. Fires don't like to stay in the boundaries, which are really frustrating. You know, either stay in Sequoia or in the open.
6:13 The element there and just that decision matrix and where do we have input as a local government in that decision making process and then spend some time kind of touching base on the lion's fire and the process with that and some of those pieces of that and the different resource values and management decisions and the elements that we hear a lot about and we've talked through different things of that nature. So hopefully this is designed to be really hopefully
6:40 Well informative on what we're doing and then some of the decision and where we're at looking to the future and the elements that we do need to continue to look at and how do we continue to, one of the major hazards we have facing the town of Mammoth Lakes is wildfire. And so how do we live with that? How do we look to protect ourselves better? How do we integrate with all the various partners and agencies that are engaged in that fire realm?
7:07 With that, I'm going to have Sandra Moberly, our Community Economic Development Director, start. She'll touch on some of the elements that the town's working on, some of the planning work, and some of the grants we've received to do some of this type of work. Thank you, Dan. So I just would like to start out talking a little bit about the Community Planning Assistance for Wildfire Grant. We called it CEPA.
7:31 The town of Mammoth Lakes along with the fire district applied for this grant opportunity last year and we were one of eight communities across the nation that were selected for this grant. It was a pretty, it was a different grant than I think I've been used to where instead of getting funding to hire consultants, we got a consultant team that came out to Mammoth Lakes and we had foresters, fire behavior specialists, planners and it was a really great group of very
7:58 Very knowledgeable people who came out and helped us with this process. So they had several site visits out to Mammoth Lakes. They came out and basically looked at learning about the community and trying to assess our wildfire hazards. And the intent of the program was to put together...
8:20 General plan policies, goals, actions that would help prevent wildfire and help to address the planning challenges that we have around wildfire. So they came, they toured the town, they looked at our wildfire challenges. They also conducted an audit of our existing wildfire land use planning documents, so the safety element of the general plan, to look at how it addressed wildfire, what policies we had in our current general plan, and how that could be improved.
8:49 The team provided us with some draft recommendations, which we presented.
8:54 To the commission a couple months, about a month ago. And those are available on our website as well. And so basically what we're doing is taking those draft recommendations and feeding them into kind of our next process, which is updating our safety element of the general plan. So we are also updating the housing element. When we update the housing element of the general plan, it triggers a safety element update. So this process kind of feeds into this next process that we're doing right now.
9:23 We also received a grant from Caltrans for climate adaptation and resiliency strategies. So that grant is underway. And it's also really kind of similar goals of coming up with resiliency strategies to make this community more resilient to wildfire. And ultimately, those strategies would be converted into goals, policies, actions that would be incorporated into the safety element of the general plan. So we have kind of two similar processes that we've just finished the CEPA process.
9:52 And now kind of kicking off this climate adaptation and resiliency strategies process, both of which will feed into our safety element of our general plan. So we're anticipating that the safety element of the general plan will be updated by
10:11 Mid-next year, by June, I think is the goal. So we'll have these strategies in place. And we also have Frank Freeval from the Fire District here to speak a little bit about some of their strategies. And one of the takeaways out of the CEPAW process was an update of the CWPP, which is the Community Wildfire Protection Plan, right?
10:34 And Frank will speak a little bit about that, but I'm happy to answer any questions you have about CEPA or our Climate Adaptation and Resiliency Strategies grants. Thank you. Good afternoon. Frank Frival, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection Chief. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak with you this afternoon in the workshop. Dan had asked us to just cover a couple of overview items on what we're doing in the community related to protection of the community from wildfire. I've really broken them down into three areas.
11:12 We have direct preventative measures that essentially fall into four categories. One is education. I think our best fire suppression is done with knowledge of the people that live here and understanding really what the true risks are. We can't get out there and rake everybody's yard or clean everything up, but if people understand what the risks are, they'll usually step in and start mitigating those things themselves. We typically do that through inspections or fire safe counsel.
11:42 Recently this year we kind of linked up an open house at the fire station with town cleanup day. That seemed to be a good match. I appreciate staff working with us to coordinate that date. The next one we work on is defensible space, which is the direct output of doing the inspections. We find that if you manage that first 100 to 150 feet around the house for ignitability, especially of natural vegetation and planted vegetation,
12:09 It goes a long way to protecting the structures. The next one is actually the structures themselves. We have a WUI code, a Wildland Urban Interface code, as part of our local ordinance. There are state WUI codes as well, very common to the West. And closely related to that, but I think it's slightly different, while those are building construction codes, you know, right materials, we're finding out through good data with, you know, post-fire analysis,
12:40 Kind of retroactively improved. The term coming out is kind of hardening. If you think years ago when we started seeing our bridges collapse, then we started these projects by, you know, wrapping some of the supportive structures and hardening the bridges and the pillars. It's kind of analogous to that, where we're learning that there's a few really critical things we can do on structures retroactively that support them. I think we're going to see more emphasis on that in the future. It's a pretty big gain for a low level of...
13:09 And then the other one is fuels reduction, not so much at the parcel level, but on the perimeter of town, some of the larger town parcels. I've been working with the town on some of the acquired properties there to just not let some of those areas get fire established in them. Once they're established, they're hard to suppress, as well as working with the Valentine Reserve here in town. Ms. Blanchett's been very helpful. So the second chunk of things I like to call enabling.
13:40 And Sandra just alluded to one of them, the CEPA process, had a lot of direct recommendations that are enabling. In and of themselves directly don't change a lot, but over time make us more resilient to the effects of fire when it comes through. We live in a fire ecology. My Forest Service colleagues can expound on that. But the Forest has been around here a long time. It's behaving in a...
14:07 The other one that's...
14:38 I need to keep a little close to my chest, but I've been meeting with the Insurance Services Organization and some representatives from one of the larger fire networks in the western U.S. And we're trying to connect what we know to be best practices for defensible space to the way insurance carriers underwrite risk in the wildland urban interface. I bet if we canvassed the room here, we'd all know a few people who either had
15:06 Cancellations of insurance or non-renewals. People coming to the area discover that. So we're trying to work with some of our partners to connect what we know to be best practices in the field with whatever methodologies they're using to rate risk. It's going to be a long slug, but it's like investing in your 401k. It takes time. And the last one we don't really want to forget is direct suppression. It really comes in two flavors for us.
15:35 Most commonly when we go out on wildfires with our federal partners, our specialty is structured defense. So we'll directly suppress or protect structures. And then sometimes the fastest way to save threats to a town is just go ahead and put the fire out at a distance. And so we will do that as well within our scope. So that's really kind of the three areas that we break down what we do for that part of the services that the fire district does. And I'll answer any questions that you have or do my best.
16:05 Frank, if you could touch on some of the warning systems. We just saw that today that came out. So just in terms of that prepositioning, planning, and those types of things, when we get that type of information, et cetera, if you can touch on that briefly, that interagency cooperation that comes through that and call-ups or not, or I know we send out or strike teams out, et cetera. So a little of that response capability and the planning side that comes in with that.
16:31 California, by virtue of the frequency and severity of its fires, has developed a pretty extensive mutual aid program within the state where essentially we collect up local government resources, both directly engines that your local government owns and those personnel, and also supplements to that through California Office of Emergency Services equipment. Some communities can acquire equipment that then...
16:58 It goes out and rolls and surges throughout the state as innocents emerge. Nobody can survive the holding costs of having everything you need when you need it. And so we have this system where we can move resources around in the state much like the federal system does around the country. For many years, that system was reactive in that it would...
17:21 It would respond to going fires. As complexity and needs elevated, requests would go out and the resources would surge and go there. After the Tubbs fire specifically and Thomas fire, there was a change in policy to attempt to do what's called pre-positioning. Predictive services have gotten better over the years and so the thought was let's try to look at criteria that would qualify for
17:49 Mobilizing and pre-positioning in a geographic area that's going to hit critical fire weather with engines to cut down the reflex time. Great idea. The bottleneck in it for me is we had over 1,000, so about 1,100, what we call UTF, unable to fill requests for strike teams of engines. That's five pieces of equipment with a liter. We had over 1,100 of those last year for real fires that we couldn't fill because the system was just overtaxed. I'm not sure how much luck we're going to have filling them for
18:20 The other thing is there's recent legislation that passed through Governor Brown's office, 23 plus pieces of legislation that were wildfire related. Some of those had some pretty large impacts related to utilities, ways for the utilities to be exempted or at least have their physical exposure minimized as long as they did some different types of actions.
18:50 Part of that whole mindset was you're now going to see a larger application of what are called public safety power shutoffs, PSPS. And one of the alerts that we received today that I pushed out to Dan and to Leslie and some of our other cooperators was current fire weather, next 24, 48 hours show critical fire weather north of us and south of us. We missed it so far.
19:18 There are a number of those areas. I think there's nine some odd counties that are staring at a wide-scale public safety power shutoff. It's got no small consequences when we start looking at them. So those are then triggered by weather and predictive services as well. Is that what you were looking for? So what you were referring to there is the thing we got from SCE about proactively shutting the
19:51 Thank you.
20:19 Are there checks and balances there that will keep them from abusing it? Or if I'm correct in any of my assumptions. No, no, no, no, you're spot on it. There was a letter written and sent today from Mark Dillarducci, President of the, or Director of the California Office of Emergency Services 2, SCE, PGE, and I think San Diego Gas and Electric, that reinforced his expectation that the protocols
20:48 For these types of shutdowns included, you know, some chronological warning, geographic kind of footprints, GIS polygons, if you will. So I'm going to qualify my answer. Yes, there are theoretical checks and balances. I think the procedure is so new. I'm pretty sure there's going to be unintended consequences that we're going to experiment with, and this is going to teeter-totter back and forth a bit.
21:16 And on that note, during the talk with SCE, they did bring up if somebody has a medical condition that they're going to need electricity, there is a special form that you can go to on their page. It's not the price change version. It is something that, for instance, somebody who is on oxygen, they do have a way, I don't know what that entails, but that is on their SCE website. So you can have oxygen.
21:46 You can't actually, once they shut the loop down, the loop is shut down. I think the idea there was they're supposed to try to do a personal notification. Right, that's the... Yeah, say it's coming, so plan or whatever, so yeah. It's fine. I already get notification of it. I think one of the other things that really jumped out at me was that the systems normally have a multiple trip. Right. In other words, the stuntman shorts out briefly, it'll retest the line a little bit, and if it's okay, it'll re-energize. During these incidents, they shut that off.
22:16 I would anticipate more widespread, longer lasting shutdowns, but once the fire weather or the event subsides, it won't necessarily require ground crews to come out and reactivate it. So I think getting power spun back up should be faster, but it's new for me too. I just got on the notification list today. California PUC. All right. Thank you very much.
23:05 Good evening, and thanks for letting me have a chance to talk to you guys and be part of the conversation. I wanted to introduce to you the folks that came with me. So first, I'm Deb Schweizer. I'm the Public Affairs Officer for the Inyo National Forest. Also with us is John Goss. He is the Fire Management Officer for the Sierra National Forest. We have Gordon Martin, who is our District Ranger for the Mammoth and Mono Lakes Ranger Districts. Taro Pesina.
23:33 The INYO National Forest Fire Management Officer. And Tammy Randall Parker, who is our forest supervisor. And I hope I can make this work. Yay. And what I really want to do is just go through very quickly a little bit that dovetails on some of the stuff that Frank had shared as well. That's not it. There we go.
24:07 Some of the projects that we're working on as well in the Mammoth Lakes area for fuel reduction and community protection I wanted to highlight. The two main projects we're working on right now are up in the Lakes Basin and then in the next year we're looking at the Reds Meadow area where we are looking at doing extensive thinning.
24:28 Followed probably by some fuel wood collection and prescribed fire or pile burning as the finish to those fuel projects. But if you've been to some of those locations, you certainly know the extent of the fuel buildup in those areas and the threats to some of those communities. So that's been a big focus for us. It's always a project for us to do fuel wood as a way to help have folks, A, get fuel wood and B, help.
24:57 Limit some of the fuels that are out on the landscape. So that's another very big tools for us. And I also wanted to put some context into this year's fire season to help frame this conversation. And there's been a lot of attention given to megafires this year in the media. It should be noted that Australia just noted that they had a gigafire that went over 2 million acres. They came up with a new term for that.
25:23 But the biggest fire in California's history was this year in the Mendocino Complex at just over 450,000 acres. And it surpassed the Thomas Fire, which had been the biggest fire in California's history, by only six months. If you start looking at the trends of how fires behaving in California, they're getting bigger and they're getting more destructive and they are a concern. Ten of the 20 largest fires in California's histories have happened in the last ten years. Two of them happened this year.
25:53 That's the Mendocino Complex and the Carr Fire. The Ferguson Fire at 96,000 acres doesn't even make the list. Fifteen of the largest fires in California's history have happened in the last 20 years. And if you want to see my stats, this is the report from Cal Fire that helps summarize where we're at. And what I also wanted to point out about a lot of these fires, but not all of them,
26:19 Is that there are human-caused fires. And understand, any human-caused fire will be suppressed, regardless of location, regardless of agency. Human-caused fires are suppressed. And if I've listed the cause, it's been released. If I haven't listed the cause, it hasn't been released, but has been known to be human-caused. What I would point out is that road corridors and cars are a real problem for us. I actually included one of these fires, the Clamathon fire, which was caused by a personal debris fire.
26:48 Pile burning on July 5th, which seems amazing, because it didn't even make the news, and there was a civilian who died in it, and part of the town of Holbrook burned down from this fire. So the point of these fires is when they start, human-caused fires tend to be next to life and property. They're a serious concern. We had firefighters killed. We had civilians killed. We had homes lost. We had whole communities shut down.
27:17 And we know that historically fire has been a big part of California's landscape, so the natural cause, which is lightning. Scientists tell us that 5 million acres used to burn in California every year. Half a million of that was in the Sierra Nevada. And for us, about 5,000 acres would have burned in our eastern Sierra Jeffrey Pine forests. What would have happened is these fires would have been smaller.
27:42 They would have been less intensive and they would have been less destructive. This is the fires we're seeing are not what our forests are adapted to. All this is to frame there is no fire option for us in California or in Mammoth Lakes. Fires are going to start. In years of fire suppression, more people moving into the wildland urban interface, places like Mammoth Lakes. More recreation is being drawn here to play here. People bring fire with them.
28:13 Warmer temperatures, beetle kill, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. We're seeing these larger fires. And we could wait for that new norm to come to Mammoth Lakes. And it could very well still might. This is one of the communities that I think for the Forest Service we are seriously concerned about fire hazard in. But as much as we can and possible where we can safely do so, we want to put fire on the landscape in a positive manner.
28:43 The tree mortality issue here highlighted on the map, what I really think is interesting for the town of Mammoth Lakes is there's one community where the mortality numbers are showing high that squirts over to the east side and that's at Mammoth Lakes, which makes sense because the moisture that squirts through Mammoth Pass is also what brings that vegetation over here. So we're seeing similar mortality over here, not quite to the scale of the western slopes, but it's starting to come to us and it's a substantial issue.
29:13 So I also want to talk a little bit about what the Lions Fire does for the town of Mammoth Lakes. And what it does is it creates a fuel break. And it's only a piece of the puzzle for this town. But it builds on a mosaic that will help prevent the mega fire from running up the San Joaquin River drainage. I'm not going to say we're out of the woods there yet, but it's an important break for us.
29:36 It reduced the deadened down fuel from the red fir blow down in 2011. And although we did extensive thinning and chipping and everything else after that event, there's still a lot of fuel out there. And it reduced the beetle kill trees. This is lower down in the elevation, getting more into the standard mixed conifer, where we were seeing 50% mortality from the beetle kill.
29:58 It's in a wilderness area where we have very few options for mechanical thinning, so it's really one of the only serious ways we can treat these fuels. And we actually did it with surprisingly good fire effects this year. And I just again want to highlight, this is the red line is the Lions Fire. The little gap in the middle of it was the Butte Fire from last year that it did manage to burn around. And then here's the Town of Mammoth Lakes. It's an important piece of the puzzle, but it's just one piece.
30:29 This is some of the fuels we were talking about out there. Substantial. This is the red fur blowdown. And this is some of the fire effects we saw. Really good fire effects out on the landscape. In both forest types and in the red fur and then in the Jeffrey and Lodge pool. In fact, our fire effects, this is our severity mapping. Red is high severity. This is what we saw this year. So it's really good fire effects. We also want to fully acknowledge that the eastern Sierra and the Town of Mammoth Lakes.
31:01 Had significant smoke this year. And we also want to acknowledge that it's all significant smoke from Lyons because it was so directly close to the town of Mammoth Lakes. Mammoth, June, and Levining also experienced significant smoke from other fires throughout the state of California. California in general had a very smoky year. But most notably for us is the Ferguson Fire.
31:23 And this slide here shows the Lion's Fire when it was amongst its most active. And it also shows exactly what we know, that it comes across the pass and into the eastern Sierra into towns. And depending on which way the wind was blowing, sometimes June Lake saw a little bit more of it than Mammoth Lakes, but always somebody was seeing it for sure. But for context, I wanted to pull back. That little arrow is the Lion's Fire.
31:51 The other arrow is the Ferguson fire. So orders of magnitude and scale here. When Ferguson was growing substantially, it was putting a lot of smoke into our community as well just because of the size and scale. Sometimes when it was really active, it actually tamped down the activity of the Lions fire because the smoke was actually creating enough inversion to slow our fire behavior. But then when it stopped, our fire would pick back up.
32:18 And I also wanted to show this. This is one of the really big fire days for the Ferguson fire and the prevailing winds pushing towards Mammoth. And just to show, you can't even see the lions under there because it's buried under the smoke from Ferguson. So as one of these, you know, just mostly to make the point, we know our fire added smoke here, but some of this bigger regional context is worth noting because Californians saw a lot of fire and smoke this year.
32:46 I also just wanted to point out it's in our new fire management plan that some of what we're doing here is going to keep going. We have in our fire management four zones, the community protection zone, wildfire protection zone, Town Mammoth Lakes.
33:00 Areas where suppression is the tool to protect life and property, where we're going to be looking at thinning and defensible space to help protect the community from an unwanted fire. As we start to move out from those areas, we might start looking at prescribed fire. These are the general protection zones. And these are the areas where we're going to start maybe doing a little bit more proactive use of fire.
33:21 But then we get into wildfire restoration, it's called. We're trying to put fire back on the landscape so that it can function resiliently in a way that's good for our ecosystems. And ideally we get to the place where it's called wildfire maintenance, where those lightning strikes don't go 13,000 acres, they maybe go 100 because the fuels aren't so great. And that's what we're trying to get to. Our plan looks at increasing the pace and scale of...
33:48 Mechanical treatments, prescribed fire, and managing fires for resource objectives. And this is because we recognize that fire is necessary for sustainable and resilient ecosystems, and it seeks to reduce these fuels and restore the ecosystems while protecting life property and watersheds. It emphasizes a landscape approach to fire management and the need to restore fire return intervals on the landscape for resiliency.
34:17 And it tries to mitigate smoke impacts to communities when possible and to tourism. It also aligns with the National Cohesive Wildland Fire Management Strategy, which suggests that we take an all-lands approach to fire management and it requires that we coordinate with state and local governments. And I thought that would be a really good point for us to end because I think that's where we want the conversation to go. And I also just want to show you a pretty picture of snow because, you know, at least we are out of wildfire season.
34:46 So with that, I'll open it up to questions or we can go to discussion and I've got a whole cadre of experts here to help me. Okay, questions? Okay, Kirk? You've mentioned twice, you know, putting fire back on the landscape. I mean, how is that going to be controlled? I mean, if we're going to burn a certain area to create a healthy forest, which I, you know, very much support, but...
35:14 I mean, do you bring all the resources in to make sure it's controlled, or you just kind of let it creep along? What is the procedure? It's a really good question. I think for Lions Fire, it really illustrates, because our focus was always on the eastern flank of that fire, where our communities in Reds Meadow and our developed areas were where we wanted to protect.
35:35 But certainly sometimes where the fuels are not in natural condition, the first thing we do is mechanical thin. So thinning is always sometimes the first thing we need to do just to make something a safe landscape. Prescribed fires are done under a prescription for, you know, winds and temperature and relative humidity to make it as safe as possible. And I can tell that Tara wants to weigh in, so I'm going to stop.
35:59 Hi, Taro Pesina. I'm the fire chief. Thank you for the opportunity to speak and for the invite. And that's a great question. How do we control fire? But the fact of the matter is we don't. But we can choose when and where we choose to take a natural ignition like a lightning fire and not just put it out at a two-by-two or a tenth of an acre.
36:22 And that is a challenge. We try to use the best available science. We try to pick the right time of year when resources, including firefighters, are available, when the fuels aren't at their driest, for example, when we're not going to be taking from other fires in the region and in the nation that may need our firefighters more. But there's never any guarantee of complete control.
36:49 So we have to try to mitigate that as best we can by bringing in firefighters and staff to manage the incident as best we can. So are you talking, and again, I'm just struggling, do you guys identify an area and actually create the burn? When we do prescribe fires, absolutely. We try to mimic that natural process. We can't
37:18 Allow all of those natural ignitions to burn the 500,000 acres that burned historically under a natural fire regime in the state. We suppress probably 95, 90% of all wildfires, regardless of how they're started, human caused or lightning caused. And that's what's got us into the predicament that we're in now. We have far too much vegetation in amongst our communities. But of that 1% that we choose not to go after aggressively.
37:48 I just want to make it clear that our top, top priority as wildland firefighters and responders is to protect those values at risk, those being communities, infrastructure, irreplaceable cultural and natural resources, threatened and endangered plant and animal species, recreation values. We understand the importance of that. So our primary objective is to try to protect those values as best we can.
38:11 But we also are obligated and bound by duty to try to make our forests healthy again. They are out of whack right now. They are not healthy. You need to look no further than your backyard to see all these dead trees. This town will burn again. It's not a question of if. It will. The question is how well prepared are we going to be for it. So we are going to be as absolutely proactive as we can to fireproof the community. I think you used that term. That's great.
38:37 And so how do we do that? We do that through proactive mechanical treatment directly adjacent to your structures in your homes, followed up by prescribed burning of both piles and broadcast burning directly in the backyards of your homes, followed by management of natural ignitions when the time and the place are right. We have the resources when the fuels and weather and topography are conducive.
39:03 I can't guarantee complete control, but when it's conducive to take that lightning strike and safely bring that fire right down to those treatments we had done leading up to that event. And those are the kinds of treatments that sequence and process has proved itself to be successful on fires like the Ferguson, like the Rim, like the Ruff, that essentially allowed firefighters to take a stand against them because of all those proactive treatments. So I kind of got off on a little bit of a tangent there. I apologize.
39:33 Thank you. So while I agree our forests are in terrible condition, it's not all because of fire suppression, but partly because of the way we've managed over the years using it as a resource to create lumber, planting 10 times more per acre than we should, thinning it out as we should have. Then when we stop lumber production, we stop thinning, creating an issue. And if we go back during when all of that was going on, prescribed fire was going to be our salvation.
40:04 I didn't particularly agree with it then because I thought mechanical treatment first made more sense, but that's my personal stance. And we were told that we would be doing the prescribed burns so that fires like this lightning strike haven't happened. But we haven't seen that happen. And it would seem, I have all kinds of questions here, I'll try to get to that, but it seems we've moved away from prescribed burns in this area to just doing pile burns. And is there a reason for that?
40:32 And why aren't we proactively the worst time for a fire because of weather and all sorts of things is from Memorial Day to Labor Day. The way the air travels is different. We end up with it. The heat, the humidity, the dryness of the duff on the ground, the whole nine yards. Better to have these fires in October and November. And we could, especially in wilderness areas, it seems to me, use prescribed burn by setting your backfires in the right.
41:01 You guys know the technology. Everybody up here doesn't have to know it. Why has not that happened? Because certainly the cost of fighting fires, like the Ferguson Fire and others, once they reach a certain size, even though we're trying to let lightning work, we have no choice but to try and cut them off, has got to be much higher than what the cost of prescribed burning would be. So how politically do we get to that point, or am I way off base here, to get back to...
41:27 What 20 years ago was going to be the forest salvation, and that was prescribed burns versus mechanical treatments. I'd like to go all the way back to the start of your question about logging and timber. I'm being told from the highest levels in Washington and locally by a regional forester that the timber and increasing our timber production and our target across the nation is the Forest Service's top priority right now, the number one.
41:57 And this goes right along with our brand new forest plan revision that states we're going to increase the pace and scale of timber production. One of the issues we have here is there's no market for it, at least not right now, at least not in Mammoth. It's cost prohibitive to transport those logs to Terra Bella or to Reno or wherever those mills are, right?
42:19 But we can increase it in other ways. We can increase our mechanical fuel reduction treatments, which we are trying to do. We are doing that. I think the second question is, why aren't we doing as much burning? I've only been here for a little bit over three years, and you're absolutely right. In the short time that I've been here, we've done very, very little burning. We are making a commitment to increase that, but we need your help.
42:44 We need to educate people more about the importance of accepting prescribed burning as a surrogate to those unplanned wildfires that a lot of times we have no control over. We like to think we have a lot more control when we do prescribed burning, when the conditions are conducive for it. But why aren't we doing more burning? I personally feel it's because of risk aversion. It's much easier to respond to a fire that we didn't start.
43:11 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
43:38 And a lot of the regulation that goes along with proactively lighting the match or proactively choosing to manage a natural lightning fire for resource benefit objectives, that triggers Title 17 and the Clean Air Act, which has a lot of regulation behind it, which I understand is being relaxed by our governor to some degree with his mandates, but we're still mandated under those laws to adhere to
44:05 Can I add one thing, on a high point?
44:33 This year in the forest in California, we did put more prescribed fire on the ground than we had in the last 20 years, so close to 70,000 acres, which was huge for the state of California.
44:48 And, you know, we put more fire on the landscape with prescribed fire than we have in quite a few years. We did 2,000 acres, which is a drop in the bucket. But, you know, 5,000 acres, as Deb pointed out, burned naturally under a natural regime before we came and started putting them out. We're getting there. And our forest plan calls for 10 to 15,000 acres within a 5-year period. That's a little bit less than the 5,000 acres that burned naturally, but.
45:14 We don't want to hit it all at once. We want to gradually bring it back. So with the prescribed burns, if they are funded and the aversion to potential issues are waylaid, are the restrictions on you any different in the wilderness than they are in the front country? Because back when prescribed fire was presented as the thing to save our forests,
45:41 We had less than half the wilderness we do today. So how is that by itself affecting our ability to get ahead of this program and to keep these megafires from happening? We can conduct prescribed fire in the wilderness, but we really need to focus from the inside out, from the centers of our communities, from our infrastructure, our homes, our community here. Focus here, and it starts with the homeowner doing their clearance, raking their leaves, using fireproof.
46:11 We can certainly do prescribed fire in the wilderness. It's a lot easier. It's a lot. The funding is much more available to us if we take that natural lightning ignition and use that as the process to reduce fuels and use that.
46:41 Ability to bring in incident management teams, that funding source that comes along with a natural unplanned ignition to achieve our objectives of what we would be trying to do with the prescribed fire, if that makes sense. But the problem with the lightning fire is that most often they happen in the absolute worst time of year because they're created by our thunderstorms, which happen with the unstable weather patterns and the heat.
47:10 And the dry and the moist air coming over the, I probably don't have to tell you how a thunderstorm happens, but it happens in exactly the worst time of year to be allowing these fires to go off to maintain any control at all. That's a good point. They can occur year-round, but they are concentrated for us on the eastern Sierra, typically during the monsoon period, which is right in the middle of summer.
47:34 And, you know, because of the drought, actually, we're seeing areas that historically never would have burned, areas at higher elevations that are actually, that's kind of what we're proposing, is to manage some of these ignitions higher up on the slope where there are far less threat to us. And it's because of the drought, actually, that we're able to do that. Historically, with snowpack, most of the year, a lot of those fires would have never even been detected or never even started.
48:01 And so we're looking very closely at things like elevation, slope, aspect, fuel type, fuel loading, fuel moisture, resource availability. And if it's square on, middle of summer, dry as can be, we're not going to make a decision to manage a lightning fire right outside of the town here. So if there's any perception that that's what we're trying to do with Lions, that wasn't it. Our objective initially was to have it.
48:31 Have it wrapped up before it got to be into those conditions, but it wound up that we were simply trying to keep up with it and get around it the whole time, part one and two of the Lions. I think, Bill, it's going to be a combination of some of these naturally ignited fires and the prescribed. So you're going to have these naturally ignited fires in the summertime.
48:58 During June, July, and August. And you're going to roll right into your prescribed fire season in the October, November, December until we could catch up. So I could foresee this in the beginning here. It's going to be a combination of, you know, six or seven months out of the year. We could potentially have these naturally ignited fires going with some prescribed fire activity in the spring and the fall where we've traditionally done our prescribed fire season. I drove over to Tioga Pass today and Yosemite has the Indian fire going and it was putting up all kinds of good.
49:27 Smoke, Great Fire Effects, and it's November 6th. I don't remember ever driving over Talga Pass this time of year when I've seen that decent amount of smoke in the air there. So we're trying to follow this current weather and pattern here and kind of choose the best time to do the prescribed and the naturally ignited fires there. Yeah, I know we have to catch up. For someone like myself, it's hard to think that all of my summers...
49:56 I've lived here for a long time without smoke every summer, that all of my summers for the rest of my productive life are going to be filled with smoke. That is a hard pill to swallow. That's why I, whether it's mechanical or whether prescribed fires, I would certainly love to see, and I'm not blaming you guys, but I would certainly love to see the government and the Forest Service get off its tail and do the prescribed fires necessary.
50:17 In the proper times of year with the proper controls so that I'm not living the rest of my life with smoke during the high tourist season and during the worst time of year for fires. I'll try to stop bogarting the mic and let someone else. Correct. And one more quick point. Last January and February on the Sierra, we had this really good prescribed window, you know, about two months. So in January and February, when the air is already really bad over on the west side of the Sierra.
50:44 It's in our high pressure. We are doing a lot of prescribed burns in January and February. So I see more of that as well. So again, we're trying to adapt to this new way of our climate here. So to have two months in January and February is unheard of to have a prescribed fire window, at least over on the western slope there. So I'm trying to adjust our tactics as well. Thank you. One last comment while I have the floor. I really wanted to highlight and thank the relationship that we have in your forest with
51:13 I'm Frank Freevault at Town of Mammoth Lakes Fire Department and also the 13 local government fire departments that we partner with, have agreements with to respond to incidents and aggressively suppress those fires that we don't want. Thank you, Frank. Thank you. I'm happy to answer my questions. John, did you have a question? I got some questions, but Linda, you do. Linda, do you have a question? Yeah. Okay. Okay. Okay. Good afternoon.
51:43 Great to see you guys up here. A number of us as elected officials serve on a variety of different boards and organizations in the region. I serve in the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District, sort of the board of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, and fire and these issues is a recurring theme. And what's nice about those boards and those agencies is that we're looking at things at a broader scope. And it occurs to me that the new reality of fire is truly a systemic
52:13 It's a systemic situation. And when we're talking about the west side of the state, the east side, the effects of the smoke coming over here. And so I'm going to torch you guys because you're here just, you know, just because. And ask a couple of questions of a kind of a high level. And I'd just like to get a sense of what you're feeling about that. The first thing is, if you could speak a little bit about the relationship. Oh, I'm sorry.
52:38 I'm sorry. Thank you. If you could speak a little bit about the relationship of federal policy for fire and what you guys are charged to do as federal agencies and how that relates to what's coming out of the state of California. How do these, are they wildly out of sync? Do they complement each other? Is it something that you guys have to wrestle with all the time? How does that, what's the relationship between the state of California's fire policy and the policy of the U.S. federal government?
53:08 You can take your time. You can figure it out amongst yourselves. I'll take a first stab at that because I'm with a group that's called the Fire Management. It's a fire MOU, they call it. It's an agreement between probably 40 different organizations in California who are committed to trying to get fire done right where they can in California. And it's Forest Service, it's Park Service, it's BLM, it's Cal Fire, it's state and local governments, it's air districts.
53:38 And one of the things that I think has been really interesting about watching that group evolve is CAL FIRE.
53:44 In particular, has gotten very, very proactive in saying we need to do more. Chief Pimla has been really integral in going to the governor and saying we need to open up more windows for prescribed fire in a regulatory sense. One of the things that's being done right now is the California Air Resource Board is being told, loosen up your standards to allow more prescribed fires to happen. And that's not for us. That's for CAL FIRE.
54:11 So I definitely think there's a lot of alignment there more than not. I think if you'd asked me that a couple years ago, I may not have answered it the same way, but I think there's been some really good work done by a lot of governments in the recent years to get us on the same page and working together because it's a better way to do it. So is it fair to say that the policy, and Tammy, sure. Yeah, come on up here so we can hear you. If the folks can hear you at home, you've got to talk to the microphone.
54:43 I actually think Taro could speak to it better, but since I've been here and we've talked about what's limiting the Enyo with putting prescribed fire back on the ground has been limitations from the air boards and smoke permits. We had an excellent burn window this fall and Taro was getting phone calls saying you can only put 25 acres.
55:14 Fire out on the ground today when we anticipated putting a few hundred acres of fire on the ground. And I think the hardest part is not understanding where those acreage limitations are coming from. Did I speak to that correctly? So we have a lot of work to do.
55:34 If we're to increase the pace and scale of restoration on the landscape in California, and I'm new to California, and a lot of it has to do with managing the air boards and getting more acceptance of having more smoke in the air. A little smoke now is a lot of times a lot better than that mega smoke you saw coming off the Ferguson, right?
56:01 Oh, sure. And I'm just thinking that that coordination of where we have, I'm looking at the larger issue of education and the larger issue of what we can do for all of our constituents and constituents throughout the region to understand the forces that are at work that are driving what's happening on the ground, what's coming from the policy from the state, what's coming from the policy of the federal government, so that we can articulate to constituents
56:27 This is the world that we're living in so people can start understanding why decisions get made and we're not in that most difficult of all situations. We're all over at the amphitheater on those nice air-conditioned refrigerated chair seats battling it out with an incident commander. I mean, at that point when we're in conflict and we're yakking with each other, we've missed all the opportunities. So I think it would be
56:54 Especially helpful to start focusing on the education from this kind of systemic perspective. I know that the Air District is working on updates to their MOAs. I'm looking at Fred and Stacy back there. And these are the policy prescriptions, if I get this right, that go to the kinds of things that you're talking about. So a second question I'd have for you guys is if we look at the Sierra Nevada of California, say the east side and the west side, and thanks for coming to be part of that.
57:23 What would be the dream team version of DEB's, not a statewide thing, where we've got every acronym on the planet is there, but what is the team that we need to put together for our region to start focusing and optimizing and making most efficient the kinds of understandings, interagency understandings that can develop the outreach materials that go to the public to advise people?
57:49 This is how this is going to work and this is what we got to do. Who would be on that, be part of that group? Who would be on the team? Yeah, who's going to be on the team? So there's some great models that have arisen out of what's called the collaborative forest landscape restoration projects across the country. And those projects that have been really successful in getting restoration implemented out on the ground have included everybody.
58:18 You need scientists at the table. You need the land management agencies. You need your towns. You need your board of supervisors. You need your implementers. You need your recreation groups. Everyone needs to be there because everyone's affected by these activities. And when everyone gets educated about the historical
58:46 And if we look at ecosystems, how they worked, how they functioned, and we all understand it, then we can all agree on some of the solutions to move forward. Because I'm just thinking at this point, we should really start writing that list down. I think I appreciate that level of generality, but I think we should start looking at the counties, Inyo, Mono, Alpine, the Air District. I mean, but let's start getting that group together. Because the Air District Board, they've got some things they're doing over here.
59:13 Federal land managers got some things they're doing over here. The state of California's got some things they're doing over here. And I just don't think from our perspective that we really get the sense there's an opportunity to bring these things together and get them focused so we can start advocating on behalf of getting fire in the landscape with our constituents to Bill's point and say, look, we're supporting policies and we're not caught in positions of put the damn fire out and, well, no, look, it's like this, just start working on that. Another thing is,
59:42 Do we have the technical expertise in this region to access the money coming out of the state through CAL FIRE, through other Cal OES, other resources? Do we have the ability here to write the grants, to monitor the grant, to do all the kinds of reporting to access?
1:00:03 The enormous resources that are available in the state of California. And if we don't, I'm thinking maybe the recreation partnership that's kind of being put together and what's coming out of the Sierra Nevada Conservancy, that might be a way to do that to start really getting some real resources over here. And you and I have talked about that. These are softball questions. No, we need, I mean, we absolutely could use some type of fiscal agent that could help write grants.
1:00:33 Accept the money. Help actually do some of the contract writing. Those contracts don't necessarily have to come to the Forest Service. The town of Mammoth Lakes or a county could hire contractors on our behalf with those grants monies. So that would be an amazing benefit to the NEO to have
1:00:58 A partner to work with to receive grants. And the state monies we know are difficult in terms of their accounting. There's a lot of work involved. So to hire someone to specifically work on that piece would be very beneficial. I guess I'll put a plug in for the Recreation Partnership because that, at the same time, is looking out for the recreation assets, which are our economy and our quality of life and all the rest of it. But I think there's a real opportunity to stand up that capacity.
1:01:23 To start getting significant amounts of resources from the state over here to help to deal with the fire issues. And I think that's an opportunity that we should really try to take advantage of. Yeah, and most recently, the Good Neighbor Authority. Yes, exactly. It's not new, but it's now being used in more states. That tool in itself gives us the ability to not only implement restoration projects, but they're using it now to do sustainable recreation projects as well.
1:01:52 So, you know, we could be on the cutting edge here if we could begin combining sustainable restoration with sustainable recreation in Mammoth Lakes. And if you're familiar, do you know the Good Neighbor Authority was just signed, I think it was between the S&C and Region 5? Correct. Is that correct? Yep. That's a new twist because it's usually been just between the Forest Service and the state, but we have this new with the...
1:02:20 So that could be a real opportunity to get all the resource from the state to start coming over here. And finally, I'll just say, I think that without being pejorative politically, but I think the state of California is coming to realize that it's nice to have 50% of the land mass of the state of California be federal public lands, but when there are divergences of policy at the executive level, certainly around things like climate change, where the state of California is deeply invested in climate change and putting a lot of money into it,
1:02:48 And the executive branch of the federal government doesn't, is not interested in that right now. That the state, I think, is motivated to get resources from its funding streams over to rural communities like ours. And I think it's a key opportunity to be, for all of us to be taking advantage of. So I thank you. Thank you. I don't want to miss this opportunity. I mean, the other thing that's being worked on here with the biomass facility, perhaps.
1:03:16 Tarle said it, but we've had no way to utilize any of the trees other than fuel wood. So a biomass facility here, at least for the waste products, could be really beneficial. So really support that, and thank you. Yeah, thank you. So I have another question. Go ahead, if you're answering John's. Just a couple quick things, John, over on the Sierra. To your first question about what is that list of people to get to get in the right room there.
1:03:44 So there's a somewhat new group. It's called the Southern Sierra Leadership Forum. Familiar with that. And they met last June or July at Montecito at Sequoia Kings National Park. And that was the counties. That was the federal entities. That was the state entities. That was the nonprofits. That was the group that should be in the right place at the right time there. So that's a newly formed group. And I'm guessing the INYA was invited to that meeting as well.
1:04:12 Yeah, and I know the SNC was, Sierra Nevada Conservancy was there. Correct. That's great. But if we could start, the fact that you're here is a testament to the kind of things that we have to do. Because the relationship of what's happening on the west side to what's happening on the east side, it's great that that group is meeting over there. We've got this recreation collaborative things happening over here. We need to kind of realign, maybe. And any suggestions or ideas about specific people or agencies or if there's already a framework existing that we could start pulling that together?
1:04:41 We've got a lot of broadband technology over here so people don't have to drive. We could do things with teleconference and stuff like that. But I think it would be enormously helpful to start setting that up. So when you have this jurisdictional problem of it's in the end, you're now moving on to the Sierra. It's not. It's you. And you're here. And we can say, well, let's figure this out and see what we can do about things. So I appreciate that. That's a great idea. And we can figure out how to tie in with those things.
1:05:03 And then the second thing, the Sierra National Forest is currently chasing a CCI grant with the state. So it's a climate change initiative. And so we're tapping into that state money. We have to have a sponsor. We can't actually apply for the grant. We have to have a sponsor to carry that to be successful in getting that grant. And then up 10% to 50% of the work has to be done on SRA lands and the rest can be done on FRA lands. But again, it's...
1:05:30 It's not forcing us. It's getting us to work together, the state and the Fed side there. So it's a great avenue of money coming in to get that work done. Yeah, and I think to Tammy's point about having the technical expertise locally to be able to write very complex state grants, manage that money, be the fiscal agent. And again, we should be comparing notes with you guys so we're not creating competing kingdoms. We're creating things that are actually going to be at the end of the day when the money comes in, it can really flow and it can really work and get on the ground and do the things that need to be done.
1:06:00 I just wanted to tack on to the CCI grant. The precursor to that greenhouse gas initiative, we did make a run at that, as you're aware.
1:06:10 I think it's worth noting that, you know, John mentioned it, that 50% of it needs to be SRA. Well, the state doesn't have, we do partner with the state here, but they don't have the responsibility for the land around your town, so we're not quite as competitive as those in other areas and those on the west side. But we are going after those money, so that's a great point. I appreciate it, but also the fact that for the state's climate change program to work, I mean, the carbon sequestration here.
1:06:36 The water from the state comes from here. The recreation acts. There's a lot of interest when you start thinking about the state has, even though there may not be state lands to manage. But I think there's a way to start. If we start working this thing a little bit, I think we can bring some real resources to you guys to do the work that you want to do. Good. Oh, yeah. Okay. I'm going to go a little more.
1:07:01 We talk about what we can do here to fireproof the town, as it were, by clearing around the town. But you guys have all seen treetop fires. You've seen massive wildfires. You know how they move. No matter how much we thin, if that type of fire comes through town, we're in big trouble. And my fear is that that starts in the wilderness because there's far less room for us to manage fires and other things in the wilderness or in our forests where we have a lot of standing dead. Do we have any plans for those standing dead?
1:07:30 To me, it certainly seems, and I can only, anecdotally, I've lived in the forest for my whole life, a tree rots and keeps a lot higher moisture content on the ground than it does standing up. For firewood, I'd much rather get standing dead than down dead because it's in much better shape to use for firewood. Would it not help us? I know we don't have the funds to go in and haul those out, but would it not be advantageous to at least go through certain sections?
1:08:00 Put those puppies on the ground so they can start the rot process. That's a good point. I mean, the tree mortality, thankfully, isn't quite as bad on our side as John can attest that it's horrible on the west side. We're seeing entire stands of Ponderosa, hundreds of thousands, if not millions of acres of devastated pines. We're not quite there yet, but it's getting there. And so region-wide, we're prioritizing areas to treat, at least on the Forest Service side.
1:08:29 This forest was probably the top priority for treatment, and in those areas that rise to the top, we have to pick road corridors, those areas where we have the concentrated infrastructure. We started the process on this side of the hill. We started removing the worst offenders, but as we move further out, we simply don't have the resources at this time yet to address it. But what we are doing for your town, for Mammoth,
1:08:57 Is we're revising our NEPA, our compliance documentation to allow us to start treating, as I was mentioning before, from the inside out. That includes dead trees. There's no market for it. And then I'd like to highlight Tammy's kudos to you. I would tag on wholeheartedly that we fully support some kind of biomass generation, whether it's a facility, a plant, a site, a portable unit, a grid tie unit.
1:09:26 That would be awesome. We could commit to a certain amount of biomass to provide to you. We would look to the power companies to committing to a certain amount of dollar per kilowatt hour generated. That's been the hang-up on certain biomass facilities on the west side. But if we're not trying to make any money off of it, if we're going to pay for all of it, then we don't need the power company buy-in. But it would be nice if we could.
1:09:50 And you know, we have this grant, the town has a grant. I know that you guys have been talking about it, and I'm assuming you guys are working on trying to find a site for it. Okay. Those conversations are ongoing. Yeah, but I wasn't referring to necessarily removing them if we take them down. It seems to me it would be advantageous if we could even just get them on the ground. Well, then they become an aerial fuel and transformed to a surface fuel, so it's still fuel that's going to burn in the wildfire, so we still want to get rid of it either.
1:10:18 So optimally, well, burning it or pulling it off site. Chipping it, once again, turns it from a surface fuel to another kind of surface fuel. It's still going to burn. So we really need to get it off site somehow or another. If I may, I'm not sure who to direct this to, but if you could just touch on the decision matrix it goes through, like with the lightning strike, et cetera, and some of the responses to that, and especially when it's, I'll say, multi-jurisdictional across the various forests.
1:10:51 The town or the county wants to be in there at the table on some of that discussion point and some of that decisions, how we're going to manage this, how aggressively or how big a box or whatever else comes into play in all the various terms here is that early engagement, especially in these core months, as Bill referred to in the summertime where, hey, we know this is going to happen. We know there's going to be an impact. How do we get in there and say,
1:11:20 Excuse me for the guessing here, but how do we get a 215 S firm that deals with smoke? Or, you know, how do we get, you know, something in the area there to begin to really highlight that early on so we're not sitting in the amphitheater at the Forest Service office having this debate over that element that, no, it's, hey, we've talked about it, it's here, the Air District is engaged, and we have probably better level of communication going out at different levels, not just from the Forest Service at that point.
1:11:50 That we can articulate those issues and say, no, actually, we're engaged. We're at the table. Those discussions are ongoing or decisions are being made that way. So if you could kind of walk, it kind of brings it back down to on the ground daily here that we deal with. Right. First of all, I want to emphasize, as it was shown in the PowerPoint, if we have a human-caused fire, we put it out. That's the way it works. So when we get a new start,
1:12:19 That's the first question, what caused it? And if it is lightning, then we look at, you know, where is it burning? Is it close to or threatening structures and things like that, in which case we put it out? Or is it someplace where if we were to manage it at a larger level?
1:12:46 Would it provide the benefits that we might be looking for otherwise? But those decisions are made, frankly, at the line level, which is why I'm up answering the question here. And a lot of times the window that we have in order to make that decision is very short. There isn't always time to have a debate.
1:13:14 Which is why we're doing this now and as I think Tammy mentioned or somebody mentioned the chief has required us or to requested that we engage with our partners such as yourself prior to the fire season, prior to having those fires so that we know
1:13:43 What sort of parameters that we're working with so that when it becomes my job to start making that decision, do we manage this fire for multiple resource benefits or do we work as hard as we can put it out? That we know what your thinking is.
1:14:10 So that we don't have to run to you every time we have a fire. Now, once it gets going and running, those decisions are actually remade virtually every day. You know, what do we do? Do we continue with managing this fire for resource benefit or do we work really hard to put it out? I'd also like to point out that even though sometimes we're working as hard as we can to put it out, we still get...
1:14:39 Big, as was shown in the PowerPoint, Ferguson was a human-caused fire. They tried to put that out from the beginning, and it ended up as a very large fire. I wonder if you could just elaborate on that, if you could talk a little bit about the role of the air boards in that decision-making, because I have a civilian's understanding that what the nature of the cause of the starting of the fire affects.
1:15:04 To what degree the air district has a jurisdiction over what you're doing. I'm wondering if you could talk to that a little bit. Yeah, that's correct. If we're managing it, as we say, for multiple resource benefits, and particularly if we are, in order to do that, using techniques where we put fire on the ground. Right. We work very closely with the air board.
1:15:30 During the Lions Fire, we actually had one of our air resource experts come in and was in constant contact with the air board that had special sampling devices that we had put out to sample both the weather and the air quality so that we could stay on top of that.
1:15:53 Because I think that relationship would be very helpful to the public to understand, like, who has jurisdiction, who has authority in these things when people are complaining about smoke to understand the Air Board is doing what they're supposed to do or whatever. And I think also the comments made earlier about from the state's perspective, if they're pushing a very hard policy around active burning on landscapes, and yet their state agencies through the California Air Resources Board and local Air Boards are not supporting that.
1:16:21 That just makes it a ripe opportunity for conflict and finger pointing and that kind of stuff. And then it goes back to getting that little local dream team together to say, what are the things we need to do to get everybody so we can work as efficiently as possible in these kinds of situations? Right. And I've worked around the country with different air boards. And to a certain extent, there's an education process there as well.
1:16:50 That, and we've mentioned it before, this is going to burn. This is all a fire adapted community. And it will burn. It's just a matter of when and how. And we want to cause the least impact as we can to the community, both directly in burning homes and things like that, and indirectly through the smoke.
1:17:21 You're right. If it's a wildfire, the air boards basically have nothing to say about it. But if we are managing it, they do. And there are reports we have to write, and we're turning in things to them on a daily basis. Yeah. Okay. Just to tack on to that, to your question.
1:17:41 For a little bit of clarity, I'd like to hope that any fire, regardless of how it was caused, if it's putting smoke in a smoke-sensitive community such as Mammoth, I feel the public deserves to have the best, most current, most timely information available to them because it adversely impacts all of our health, right?
1:18:02 Technically speaking, and the Air Regulatory Board, the Air Resources Board, Great Basin Unified, is one of your direct conduits to us in certain cases. So you asked the question on a new start, what determines the air regulatory process to kick in? Gordon stated it, and I'll maybe try to state it just maybe a little bit differently. So any fire that the sole objective is suppression, to put it out.
1:18:29 Technically speaking, we don't have to coordinate with the Air Board, but I'm telling you that I will, to the best of my ability, provide information to the Air Board, provide information to your community, and we can do that in a number of ways. We can use the one o'clock smoke call that you may or may not know about, that the Air Boards participate in, to tell you what the smoke is doing, and tell you what we're doing about the smoke, regardless of what kind of fire it is. Now, if we choose to take that natural lightning fire,
1:18:58 And manage it for multiple objectives, including resource benefits. Now, most of the time, we're going to be suppressing every single fire. There may be parts of it we're not aggressively suppressing. There may be parts of it that we're achieving a lot of benefit out on the landscape for. If we claim that outright and up front, that triggers the federal law, the Clean Air Act, and Title 17, the California law.
1:19:23 And it's treated essentially as a prescribed fire, even though we didn't ignite it. And as such, it is subject to regulation by the California Air Resources Board, the state agency, and the local air board and jurisdiction that it falls within. And it's subject to the regulatory process and everything that goes along with it. And once again, you're privy to that information. That's a direct conduit from the fire to the air regulators to you for that kind of information. And that's all happening in the context of the incident?
1:19:53 The incident commander and the incident management of the fire. The team. The team. That's where all that stuff is. Responding to the incident. Right. Right. But I'd like to hope that this day and age, that any fire that we have that's putting, that we're responding to, that's putting smoke in your community, that you have the best information available to you about the smoke, about the...
1:20:13 Level of smoke, the potential impacts, things that you can do to mitigate those health concerns. So thank you for bringing that up, the health and safety concern, because I think that everything you've talked about is very sensible. The way that the decisions are made, there's no issue with that. But I think that when you do have prescribed burns that then bring in the level of smoke of the level 2 or greater air alert, that that impacts those sensitive people.
1:20:40 To the point that, you know, you're, you know, sheltering indoors and there is respiratory and cardiac and all the other kind of issues that go with us, that gets to be a huge concern, especially in those areas where there are prescribed burns. Because, you know, you have an incident that was naturally started, which then progresses into another level, and there's that level that is very concerning to me, but also the level then around, and we haven't really talked about that, and that is the impact tourism.
1:21:09 The fact that that needs to be factored too. And I think establishing a group that can speak as a whole.
1:21:16 And weigh those and understanding how those decisions are made and what comes down from the federal level, the state level, what comes from the local level and what local control and local input we have into those decisions is pretty essential. Because over the years, my background is in public health, you know, we're watching these alerts that come out from the health officer in conjunction with the air boards and understanding there was a time when we actually tried to delay a burn.
1:21:42 Because of weather conditions and there was concerns around what the sensitive populations would do with that. And so it's a bigger question, but I don't want to lose that thought of it either because I think that's pretty essential. I just want to take one thing to that also, Linda, which is as this becomes kind of a new normal, we go into this kind of a situation. And a lot of this, I think you can, it's reasonable to say you can trace it either to management practices or to climate change. To be able to document to the state the mitigation measures.
1:22:10 That we as a community have to take. If we have to get, you know, what are they called safe houses? Oh, they're called clean air. Clean air facilities. We don't have any things like that. And if this is going to be part of what we're dealing with going forward, you know, if we get this group together, we can anticipate what the mitigation measure is going to be. This means something that we can work with the county and others to go to the state to say, look, your policy of prescribed burning and things like that, it's fine, but...
1:22:37 It's coming at a great cost to our community, and we can organize how we go to the state and other resources to get mitigation funding for a lot of that kind of stuff. Yeah, I would. I'd just like to add a piece, because we started talking about safety, and Gordon answered the question really well about the line officer and the decision-making process.
1:23:03 It weighs really heavily on us as agency administrators is the safety of our firefighters. And we're making different decisions today in this agency than we did years ago in that we have to look really hard at the landscape and what we're trying to protect when we go in and put a fire out because we're putting people's lives at risk.
1:23:28 We are losing 13, 14, sometimes more than 20 firefighters a year. And then to look back as a line officer and say, why was that person there? What were the values at risk? What were we trying to save? So just know that that weighs heavily on my mind, on Gordon's mind, when we make those decisions on whether or not we're going to put them out.
1:23:56 Why are we putting people at risk? And we have a lot of wilderness on this fire. So that's your priority? Absolutely. Their safety is our number one priority. The priority is your firefighters. Absolutely. And it should be your responders and your firefighters. That has to be your primary concern. Thank you. And so I didn't want to not bring that piece up because the Año and the Sierras are a hard piece of ground. There's a lot of people that have died in these mountains putting fire out in the past. And we have to rethink that. Is it really worth it?
1:24:25 I think that's also a point of public education. Yes. Is, you know, what the community may clamor for and, you know, really demand, if you will. Being able to talk about that, I think, is vitally important. The meeting we had over at the Forest Service that night, I think that was brought up, but that is an ongoing education piece. We're not going to risk responders, firefighters over this when the result is smoke. Yep. Thank you. Thank you for understanding.
1:24:53 Thank you for that. For right now, I would like to open this up for public comment. If we have a little bit of time, then we'll revisit if we have any more questions from the Town Council. But right now, for public questions or comments, come on up to the podium, please. State your name, rank, and serial number. I'm Bobby Tanner from Reds Meadow, Reds Meadow Resort, Rock Creek Lodge.
1:25:24 I've been out of town for a week or two years, I don't know what's been in the media or what you guys, but I think so far from what I'm hearing, Forest Service, you guys are missing a really good opportunity and you guys are really selling yourself short. Right now you've got a fire going on in Reds Meadow, a prescribed burn, it's really doing a good job, and I haven't heard one single person complain. I was in there yesterday, I came around a turn, big wall of smoke. And where's all the complaints now? Come on, Forest Service, stick up for yourself, say, look, we're actually doing something. On so many levels.
1:25:54 You guys could be saying, look what we are doing. We do have this going. We can do this. We can control these fires. We can do this that it's not affecting the community. And you even had the lost fire that you could say, look, this time of year, here's a perfect example. The fire really didn't do much. It kicked off. I was in the resume the other day. It kicked off. It was a huge cloud of smoke. Nobody complained. Come on, you guys. Stick up for yourselves. You can keep this stuff going and do more what you're doing down there. It looks great what you guys did.
1:26:22 And it's still going. I came out there yesterday, I don't know, about 5 o'clock in the afternoon, well, it's still light. And looking down the San Joaquin River drainage, you can hardly see anything. There's all smoke down there that's still drifting down there. Maybe a man with pools are complaining, but you guys aren't getting the complaints here in town. So put it out there. Hey, we got a fire. We're burning. We're doing stuff. We're trying to protect your community. And we can actually get it right once in a while. So stick up for yourselves.
1:26:51 Harvey, I want to thank you for helping me make my point that there are more appropriate times to burn than the middle of the summer. Any more public comment or questions? It's okay to speak here, but I just want to second the suggestion that a group be formed and that we really emphasize education and communication.
1:27:20 I want to commend the Sierra National Forest for an incredible job on communication and outreach, especially via social media around the Ferguson Fire. It explained fire speak, and I think that's really critical in helping us as elected leaders and our constituents understand fire activity that, you know, we saw this on the Lions Fire, there would be planned activity that...
1:27:43 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:27:59 If you go back and look on the Ferguson fire, it was outstanding. I mean, they were translating the fire speak, putting amazing images out that helped us understand what values were at stake, what lives were at stake there, and how hard those firefighters and fire managers were working to protect people, the communities, and our beloved public lands. So I think that could be a great example and a great place for us to start with, but really helping us.
1:28:28 Know what the planned activities are when you have the luxury of planning them and helping us communicate that out. But I would love to be a part of any of that effort and also just want to thank the town and council for holding this workshop today. It's been great. Thank you. Anyone else from the public liking questions or comments? I do have a question and I'm not sure to whom.
1:28:54 To address this too. But what are the positives that came out of, say, the Lion Fire down in, yeah, the Lion's Fire? Is there any, because I think that did grow to be a lot bigger than you initially expected, correct? I'll start, you know, feel free to jump in. We had about, well, 12,500 acres of treated landscape. You saw the picture that Deb showed of that good little red blob there.
1:29:27 And it's that first big piece of the puzzle we've been actually been able to put down on, at least in the Sierra. And then, you know, it's the largest fire we've managed in a long time. So I'm pretty excited. I went out, I walked out there and looked across the landscape and just the fire effects. You saw that the severity map, the fire effects were great. It was a long duration incident. You know, it went from about June 1st to I think there's probably still smoke coming off the Lions fire.
1:29:55 So I think one of the biggest positive pieces was we got that first piece of the puzzle down there. So it's how can we build off that? How can the annual build off that with maybe some prescribed fire activity, a little more around doubles post pile, which is going to bring the park service into the mix there as well. So I think getting that first big piece of the puzzle, I think, was one of the positive impacts there. How many pieces are on the puzzle? It's a good question. Okay. Wow. Good question. We definitely have a lot more there.
1:30:25 Oh, okay. But as far as the forest is concerned, that did help a certain amount of land return to where it can grow to be a healthy forest? Or are there repercussions that we're not even talking about today? Yeah, no, it definitely went a long way. There was no way we could have...
1:30:45 We treated that with prescribed fire the way that it was treated. I mean, we couldn't, we would have, the cost would have been a lot more. We still spent about $13 million on the Lions fire, which you divide that by 12,500 acres. It was about $1,000 an acre is what it costs. And some of those, that's real heavy on aviation type of equipment because there was places where we couldn't get firefighters into because of the steep terrain.
1:31:07 So my personal thought is I was hoping we'd get those costs down to closer to $500 an acre because it's, I mean, it's expensive, whether it's mechanical, wildfire, or suppression, or managed. The Ferguson was about $1,000 an acre, too. That was $130 million and $100,000 acres. So, yeah, nothing that we saw good positive results as far as the forest health there after the Lion's Fire.
1:31:33 Okay. Thank you for that. Do you know what your tree mortality is going to be of the green standing after every fire because of the heat? We have a certain amount of those that die, and then they become more standing dead for us. Do we know what that's going to be on the lions? That's a good question, percentage-wise, because the trees were already stressed to begin with before the actual fire, and that's the tough part. So the percentage, I'm guessing, are going to be a little higher. In a normal type of a forest, they probably would have been a little bit lower.
1:32:02 That's a good question. Most of our forest over on the Sierra below 7,000 feet, we don't have any more, Ponderosa or Sugar Pine. Pretty much wiped out the bulk of those two species there from about 45 to 6,500 feet elevation there. Good question, though. Not too sure. If you recall Deb's severity map of the lions, I'd say...
1:32:25 90 to 95 percent were squarely low to moderate severity. There are two different kinds of severity we look at. We look at soil severity and we look at vegetation severity. That's the soil severity, so that's going to be a little bit lower than the vegetation severity. But the preliminary indicators are that we had very favorable fire effects. But we will induce overstory mortality from fires like this, absolutely.
1:32:55 The big fire, the ribbon, no, what was the big fire down there? Rainbow. Rainbow, I'm sorry, the rainbow fire, that was probably flip-flopped, where 90% of it was probably high severity, we lost most of the overstory, but a lot of the remnants of that were actually cleaned up during the Lions fire, and one of the huge benefits I see, and John pointed them out, but it's strategically located in the San Joaquin River drainage, which isn't
1:33:23 In alignment with the incoming wind, the same winds and storms that funnel snow to Mammoth Mountain also funnel winds and fire potential into our community. So now we have a foothold that could be viable for at that elevation in that fuel type. I'd say that it'll be viable at reducing future fires for at least five to ten years.
1:33:46 I know that doesn't sound like much, but it's something. And you'll notice that in the middle, that donut that didn't burn, that was the Butte fire from last year, showing the effectiveness of that fire at keeping this fire from burning. So these fires prevent future fires from becoming more catastrophic. Just to think of note, since we got this actual picture up, if you guys see the red portion, the high severity portion, that was about day 10 of the fire. It was about 1,000 acre.
1:34:16 Run that happened overnight with an abnormal wind event coming from the east side there. So that little event really kind of changed kind of the plans and got our buddy's senses and nerves going pretty quick because up until that point, it wasn't gaining too many acres on a daily basis. It was a very, everything was nice and mellow, very good fire effects. But that one evening, it was about a 10-hour stretch. It put on 1,000 acres. That kind of changed our game plan a bit.
1:34:46 The plan for that, the smaller and larger box there pretty much remained the same. It just got us thinking more suppression-wise versus managing strictly for resource benefit. How did that compare on the Ferguson fire, I mean, in terms of the landscape benefit or whatever the benefits there on that side? Yeah, great question. And I haven't seen a severity map for the Ferguson yet, but just visually.
1:35:11 The lower portion of the Merced Canyon there, I mean, it was a stand replacing event. Most of it was brush and oak, so it wasn't up in the timber. But once it got into the mixed conifer 5,000 foot and above elevation, it was a very positive mosaic burn there. So the fire effects higher elevation out of the Merced River Canyon were really, I was really surprised at how good the fire effects were. So again, that's...
1:35:38 Even though it was a suppression fire from the get-go, it was human cause. That's going to provide a benefit for years to come for Yosemite and the visitors and the like there. So we're kind of diving into the science of restoration, which gets me really excited. And I have a lot to learn about the science here. I've spent most of my career in the Southwest.
1:36:06 The INYO very much welcomes this concept of a collaborative that comes together to focus on issues that we have on the forest with our public lands, with the town, whether it be recreation or restoring our forests.
1:36:24 Just food for thought. We did a field trip last week, our forest leadership team, and we went out to the research natural area at the Jeffrey Pine Forest. And scientists have done a lot of exciting work around what the fire intervals were.
1:36:43 You know, how frequently fires burned, what the effects are on tree mortality after prescribed burn and wildfires. And there's just an amazing place that we could go look at and see how fire effects changed.
1:36:58 When prescribed fire had been placed on the landscape prior to a wildfire and the difference in the intensity and the effects of the trees. And that might be a great way to kickstart our working group is a nice visit out to the forest to take a look at some old prescribed burns and some old fires and what the effects of those were and how some prescribed fire helped.
1:37:23 Stop a wildfire. So just a suggestion. But we very much welcome and would love to get started with a collaborative group and solving problems with the town. Yeah. I think we got some volunteers right here to start getting that thing going. So yeah, thank you. Any more questions or comments about fire prevention, fire fun stuff? Frank, you almost look like you wanted to say something.
1:37:53 I want to pick up a couple of questions that I was kind of writing down as we went through. If we're wrapping up, take a couple of minutes to pick those up. First of all, there's even actually a better map of this in some of the future discussions you'll have with the local federal partners. There's good fire history mapping that shows what year, where the fire location was. One of the things that excited me about the Lions incident is it's actually closed a couple of corridors from other.
1:38:23 And so we ask what the benefit is, certainly from the forest side, strategically for Mammoth Lakes, it really does help add into finishing the puzzle, if you will, of that San Joaquin drainage. Not all of our risks are equal on all points of the compass here. That is a real gun barrel for us. We have a couple of others in the region. So picking up a couple of items, you'd asked about collaboration.
1:38:53 You know, with the forest, local partners, SNC. Through the Fire Safe Council, the Forest, the EOS Forest Service had a project up in Lakes Basin. They were waiting on funding. It's a common problem. For the Fire Service, the Fire Safe Council, we actually applied for and received an SNC grant to pay for their project. And that directly benefits us because it thins out.
1:39:23 And the Lakes Basin, both for restoration and recreation, there's some benefits there. So, you know, we're clawing our way at those things. Staff capacity due to grants administration is a real choke point for us. Yeah, I just want to emphasize that point. And that was that the term of art for that, I think we're kicking around as technical, the technical resource, the technical capacity. Those same resources are coming to light with the opportunity zones in Bishop and Southern Nino County, where they're, they've got a...
1:39:53 This has something to do with the federal tax law, but there's an opportunity for lots and lots of capital investment in Bishop and Southern Inyo County. It's that same problem. They don't have the technical resources to be able to get the funding that's out there. I'm glad you brought that point up because I think it goes back to what we may be setting up through the Recreation Partnership in an Office of Outdoor Recreation in the Eastern Sierra to be able to have the technical skills there so when the Fire Safe Council is writing a grant to the S&C and needs someone to write it, administer it, and all the rest of it,
1:40:21 Let's build capacity to be able to do that throughout the region. So I'm sorry to interrupt. As an administrator, I'm just going to beat the drum here. Grants are not free money. Oh, man. They take a tremendous amount of effort. Especially California is free money. They are highly inefficient to manage. Some of the most expensive money you can go after from a staff perspective. Kirk, you had asked a question about, I took it as kind of a quality assurance question about prescribed fire. How do we make sure something bad doesn't happen? And I agree with Taro.
1:40:52 You know, you can't guarantee all of that. What I will say is if you were able to chime in on my radio or walk around with me during some of these days, I have an open invitation from our local federal partners to attend the morning briefings when they set out to put out their game plan for the day to do prescribed fire. They actually make a go, no-go decision the night before usually based on air quality management restrictions, much to their dismay sometimes.
1:41:18 I'll regularly get emails or texts about if there's any changes in there. I'll listen to the radio chatter before I came over here. I was listening to, I can't remember all the different crew leads, but I had people all over the forest going out and checking on status of existing burns down at Reds Meadow, Dead Man Creek, the Lost Fire, just checking out in the morning, checking out in the evening, giving a short little spiel, you know, no immediate threat to the line, we'll be back out tomorrow, etc.
1:41:49 There are times when I raise my hand or come visit directly and say I'm a little nervous. The prescription was for this. It looks like maybe we're flirting with the edge of that. And whenever I've done that, I either get a very detailed personal debrief on what's changed or I'll get a pretty detailed email. There was an excellent one for the Devil's Postpilot Barn recently. Really took the time to, you know, kind of get me out of my mother hen mode and totally supported it. But there's a lot of interaction that goes on that you won't.
1:42:19 And they're outstanding partners that way. I can't thank them enough. Why aren't we doing more controlled burning? Back when I used to work in the federal side on the Bureau of Land Management and tried to wrestle with some of these things, the seasonal workers are hired primarily to fight fire. 180-day appointment, not to exceed. You've got to get them hired, trained, placed, get them just at the right time to catch all the fires, and then we want to get them off the books so we don't have to pay for them at the end. And yet at the very beginning of the year,
1:42:49 It's the best window and sometimes at the very end of the year. But we don't want to lose the fire, which means we have to have enough resources. So we want fiscal responsibility. We want minimal cost, but we also want to be really aggressive on getting these prescribed acres consumed. But we want it done safely. It's a real tough balancing act for the administrators. It's very tough. And if you say mechanical, put equal sign expensive. It is the most expensive.
1:43:18 When I looked at it, some of the most expensive ways to reduce fuels as opposed to natural and prescribed fire. Stuff on the ground will smolder longer. If you're talking about smoke concerns, it may not burn with that crown intensity, but you'll get lingering kind of residual smoke effects for a long time. It burns hot, it burns quick, less efficient like a good campfire, right? It burns down in a hurry. Air quality. I just want to put something in perspective.
1:43:52 Let me just minimize this. Washington Post put out a good, this is a collection of North American daily air modeling from data that are picked up around North America. And it just kind of puts in perspective what things look like. It starts in May and it goes into August. So when we were having our worst times in July and August, just nowhere to really go. A little bit like rearranging chairs on the Titanic.
1:44:33 Sometimes you just, let's just admit it, we can't control everything. The other thing that you won't have access to, and quite honestly, some of the federal partners are too busy to run through the details with you, you have a finite set of resources, and every day there are strategic decisions made on where they're going to put resources around the country, let alone the state, and there's surge to those places that are at the greatest risk. I would hope that the day Mammoth is faced with burning structures, we won't divert,
1:45:03 State and federal resources someplace that's struggling with smoke. So, and that's assuming the life safety risks are all equal. So I just, there's, there used to be this idea that we could just go out and suppress everything. We're running so short and the fires are getting so big and they're running so long. We're down to point protection, that's really what we call it, is we can't necessarily pull the whole, put the whole thing out, but we can steer it around key places. And I think what you're going to see is we're actually starting to do that with the...
1:45:31 The fuels reduction projects. We can't fix everything in the national forest, but we can strategically try to do fuels planning and reduction, which is what our federal partners are doing. I think that's going to be a key going forward. I think that's it, unless for any other, I think those are the questions I heard that were kind of lingering out there.
1:45:51 No matter of fact, unless there is a burning question or comment, I'd go ahead and just like to thank everybody for showing up for this workshop and I appreciate all that you do and giving us the information and answering the questions that we have. We're going to go ahead and adjourn and come back to the regularly scheduled six o'clock town council meeting. So thank you very much.
1:47:09 Thank you.
1:47:35 Okay, we will now go ahead and call to order the Town Council meeting of Wednesday, November 7th to order. And since I didn't pick anybody, I'm going to go ahead and lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance if you could join. Oh, excuse me. Let me do roll call first. Here. Here.
1:48:18 Here. Here. And here. Thank you. Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay.
1:48:45 Thank you. Okay, now we will go ahead and listen to, well, actually, I'm going to make a public comment. If you notice, we have some very nice new table drapes. Do we have one? Oh, and we have one over there, and I think that we also have something that's going to be added to our podium, and I would like to thank Town Clerk Jamie Gray for doing such an excellent job. I just walked in and I went, wow, loving it, so thank you very much for that.
1:49:11 With that, now I'll just turn it over to the public for any public comments at this time. When you come up to the podium, introduce yourself, please, and you have five minutes to speak. Good evening, Town Council of Mammoth Lakes. My name is Mark Davis. I am a 34-year resident of Mammoth Lakes, and we are facing critical challenges at this time. I know we just had a summit to talk about affordable housing.
1:49:44 But I would like to address the Town Council with some thoughts. We need to see this situation as the dichotomy of being a community and a commodity. I have seen several of these boom and bust periods of which we are in one now. Real estate is skyrocketing. The developers are rubbing their hands. They are making plans to make money. That's being a commodity.
1:50:17 Housing is the most critical issue facing the community. I do believe you recognize this. But are we going to behave differently in this gold rush? Are we going to give the developers everything they ask for every time? Are they going to give some long-term commitment to this community? Or are they just going to pocket the gold and leave when they're done? It's happened before, and history tends to repeat itself.
1:50:47 I'm afraid that this boom of real estate and prevailing development is making the housing situation much worse. We've sort of put a certain number of units out there and say, this is our need. But that need is growing very rapidly and our solutions are not moving forward quickly enough. I ask this council to make it your highest priority in every decision you make.
1:51:17 Housing Action Plan? Where's the dollars? I'm not seeing real action money being spent. We don't seem to be moving forward with this. We seem to be pretty hypothetical so far. And will we tax the public to build more housing? Maybe inevitable, but I would like to suggest that we have imposed several taxes.
1:51:41 In the current economic downturn and within this cycle, we've really added a lot of taxes. I don't know if the public will vote for more money. And this is especially because this council has not taken the money promised to be set aside for housing consistently and seriously. We have broken promises with previous taxes. Asking for more may be inappropriate.
1:52:10 Here's my original suggestion for the night, a different way to look at the housing crisis. Perhaps we should say no or slow growth until such a time that housing catches up. As it is, we've always been reactionary with housing and let the booms boom and let people pocket the money. The developers made all the money and left town with it.
1:52:37 Thank you for your consideration in this ultimately important matter. Thank you.
1:53:06 Good evening, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers. My name is Betsy Truax, and I'm actually here for the Mammoth Lakes Foundation on behalf of Shira Dubrovner and the Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater. This Saturday, the public will have the opportunity to see a great production of Huck Finn. There are two shows. One is at 4 o'clock. One is at 7 o'clock. The actors are from Los Angeles, and there are three actors who play 27 parts. As if that wasn't neat enough,
1:53:34 Through a grant from the California Arts Council, we've actually been able to host literally hundreds of school children from grades three through eight throughout the Eastern Sierra. They've been coming in all week to see the show for free. So it's just been a really, really nice time over at the theater. So I invite everyone to come and check it out on Saturday. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, Madam Mayor, Town Council. Brent Truax here on behalf of Disabled Sports Eastern Sierra. In addition to this Sunday's celebration for Veterans Day,
1:54:09 Disabled Sports is hosting a film called Hold at All Cost, and that will be on the 11th from 6 p.m., and that will be at the Edison Theater. The theater will be open at 5.30 p.m. for light refreshments and an opportunity to meet our Korean War veteran special guest, Bob Baker and Roy Crotty. These individuals are both Korean War veterans, and it's going to be an opportunity for featuring stories, interviews.
1:54:35 Footage of both American and Chinese veterans. It highlights the bravery and sacrifice of these men and women in a way that no textbook or film has yet to accomplish. So we encourage everybody coming out. It's free, and we hope people can attend that evening. Thank you. Thank you. Time for public comment. Okay. We shall go ahead and move on to Councilmember, let's see, do we have any agendas, additions to the agenda tonight? We do not, Madam Mayor. Okay.
1:55:08 And we'll go ahead. And John, would you care to kick off the Councilmember reports, please? Thank you very much. This kind bar, almond and coconut, is really good. Oh, okay. Would you like me to start with the... No, you don't mind, do you? October 19th, I attended the meeting of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. We touched on a number of issues of regional concern, including the Inuamono Broadband Consortium.
1:55:38 California Federal Opportunity Zones in Bishop and Inyo County, which we've talked about a little bit. Mammoth Yosemite Airport and Bishop Airport Update. SCOG Administrative Support, which is coming out of the town with that shared position to help NGOs. Talked about the Joint Powers Authority for the SCOG, just checked in and heard what we'd heard from all the four different jurisdictions. And, of course, we talked about Fire and Smoke in the Eastern Sierra.
1:56:05 October 20th, I attended the Parcel Tour. I really want to commend town staff for putting on just a five-star show right up to the hot dogs and the parking maps and the docents and the tour guides who really got us in touch with that piece of land, which is now owned by this community. So that was a lot of fun. Then October 25th, the OHV Grant Workshop in Bishop. It was a very interesting thing to be down there with those folks and to check in with our...
1:56:33 OHV and Green Sticker friends down in the Inyo County. Good time down there. Attended a momentum meeting with town staff and MLR. It's productive getting that thing moving forward, breathing some life into that. Attended the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District meeting on November 1st. Again, the fundamental primary topic we talked about, smoke, air quality, fire.
1:57:01 So it's hitting all these different places all at the same time. On October 22nd, with Supervisors Corliss and Halferty, we put on a community conversation on ballot measures. I haven't had a chance to figure out how we did in terms of the recommendations of the Board of Supervisors and the Town Council. I think we did okay. I know Prop 6 did not go. Jennifer's nodding her head back there, so I guess we did okay. Good. Finally, the Housing Summit.
1:57:29 This last weekend, which will be on the agenda this evening, we'll get a chance to talk about that. Thank you very much. Mr. Salazar, please. Attended the MLR board meeting last night. Not much to report out there. Other than Tom, Jonathan, our chair is not going to re-up, so he's not going to be with us anymore. That's a tremendous loss. Other than that, that's about it. Okay. Thank you very much. Linda?
1:57:59 Okay, after our last council meeting, I attended SCOG on the 19th, and I think he gave a good report on that. Nothing to add to that. Then I was out of town.
1:58:16 And got back just in time for the summit to begin on November the 2nd. Attended the summit on the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th, and I think it was a really great, it was a great weekend, and we're going to be getting a little bit of a report on that, but I think it was well attended, great speakers, learned a lot, and I think it was a great event for our community. So many thanks to everyone that helped organize that. On the 6th.
1:58:40 I attended the Mystery Dinner last night, which was a great event, a community event for the Sierra Classic Theater, and it was really enjoyable. Today, we attended a meeting at the Mammoth Unified School District, then I was down at Bishop for the Pioneer Home Care and Hospice board meeting.
1:59:00 Again, they continue to offer services throughout our county, up through June Lake, and they're doing well, and I think I might have mentioned this, but they recently merged and were acquired, if you will, by Northern Inyo Hospital, so they have a lot more capacity now. And we're here tonight, so that's it. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I attended the Parcel Walk, which was, I think, excellent. Over 200 people attended, so people began to realize
1:59:30 Wonderful asset we have and hopefully moving forward will be expeditious. Attended the ballot measures. I think it's very important to let everybody know that the Proposition 1 and 2 will provide billions of dollars. Proposition 1 is about $4 billion in bonds and $3 billion of that is for
1:59:56 Workforce Housing. It will be a competitive grant and it will take some time for the bureaucratic process to be put together and then it will be a competitive, probably a competitive grant process. But I think we'll be able to be very viable with the particular piece of property we have. I attended the summit and I think there'll be a presentation on that.
2:00:23 And I have nothing but positive things to say about it. A lot of good ideas came out of the summit. Mammoth Lake Housing met last night, our Monday night, and we have the contract on the agenda this evening, so that will be discussed. And finally, I did receive, or the council did receive a letter from our town attorney.
2:00:51 He and I are still debating as to what is and is not a Brown Act. So if anybody needs a copy of my debate with Andy, because I'm still kind of questioning his interpretation of the law with my interpretation of the law. But I am trying to be very careful about how I respond to our town attorney's advice. And that's it. What is the date of this letter?
2:01:20 This date, I think my response is October 29. So we received it prior to that. I did not have a date on this, on the cover letter. If anybody needs a, wants a copy of this, it's available. Jamie, if you can put it on the corner of your desk there. Thank you.
2:01:55 Okay, then I'll just run through on, I also did the walk the parcel on Saturday the 20th. On the 25th there was a CPT or a collaborative planning team meeting. I'd have to say that's a lot of Mono County entities that get together. It's a very good meeting. We didn't have quite the number of people at that meeting that we usually do.
2:02:19 Working, so I think one of the main things that came out, I think everybody realizes that we need to really think about working regionally on a lot of the...
2:02:29 Recreation partnerships that we have going on. And I really liked a term that was used during it called table of trust, where everybody's on the same page. So that was a CPT meeting. On the 26th, I got to judge the Halloween costume for the kids at the fun zone. And then I also attended the housing summit. I'd like to say on the events that I mentioned that were town,
2:02:55 Kudos to everyone who worked on the Walk the Parcel, the Housing Summit, and the Halloween Carnival. I got such a kick out of that carnival. I was two seconds away from grabbing a kid and running away with it. They were so adorable, so thank you for that. And then if anybody's looking for something to do, this is kind of mean because I don't think they have any tickets left, but the murder mystery was an excellent community.
2:03:20 event that was going on and they did a great job with that. With that, we will go ahead and get reports from commissions and or departments, please. Good evening, Town Council. Tom Perry, building official for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. I'd like to take this opportunity to introduce the newest member of the Community and Economic Development Department for the Town. It's our new permatech that we hired and put to work a couple weeks ago who is replacing the outgoing
2:03:59 Permit technician that we've had for a number of years down at Jacobson. Her name is Bailey Thompson. She's here with us tonight. But I'd like to give you just a quick back, a little bit of a background on Bailey. First and foremost, Bailey is a true local. She was born in Mammoth Hospital, raised in Mammoth, went to Mammoth High School, told us that she's lived in various other places and didn't want to do that and wanted to come back to Mammoth because this is home. So she is a true local, which I think is a great asset.
2:04:29 She studied at UC Santa Barbara, got a degree in psychology and a minor in Spanish, got a 3.78, which I think is quite impressive. For the last several years, she has worked in various capacities for and with local contractors, which also is a great asset as she already knew a lot of the contractors before she even started, so that was great.
2:04:55 We had a lot of good applicants that applied for the position, but at the end of the day, it was a fairly easy decision to hire Bailey, as we believed, as a staff, that she had the best combination of experience, education, personality, a good fit, and something, again, in my book that's big is she's a local, so I don't think she's going to be going anywhere anytime soon. So we're very lucky to have her. She's worked out very well in the last couple weeks. And without further ado, I'd like to introduce you to
2:05:24 Bailey Thompson. This is amazing. Wonderful. $10 for every story about Kirk if you had him as a teacher. Okay. Welcome. You realize we just didn't know the truth, right? Yeah, no idea. That was... It's fine. It works. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I thought Bailey was going to say something, but thank you, Bailey. It's a tough act to follow anyway.
2:06:12 I'm still Betsy Truax, but now I'm here as the Chair of the Recreation Commission. Recreation Commission met yesterday, and we had a couple of presentations from staff, the ice rink operating plan, as well as a deferred parks maintenance presentation, a form of which will be presented to Council. It's pretty exciting, all the things that have happened in deferred maintenance in the parks.
2:06:38 Had discussion items including our annual programming menu update. So now that it's fall, it's time to plan for next summer. So very excited about the great work that the Parks and Rec staff continues to do. And last but not least, we discussed our agenda for our joint workshop with you next month, which the commission is very much looking forward to. So that will be really great at your first meeting in December.
2:07:01 Kind of on the Parks and Recreation side, thank you, Madam Mayor, for coming out to the Halloween event. There are some great costumes I got there a little later, but thanks for being a judge. The ice rink weather permitting will open on November 23rd, so hopefully the temperatures will cooperate soon to start making ice.
2:07:21 Just very exciting things happening at the rink this year. You know, we just continue to see demand grow, programming grow. We've got about, I think, 60 kids registered for the youth hockey program, which is fantastic. In addition to that, we've got a really robust lesson schedule that will start shortly after the rink opens. And certainly form your curling team now because we'll have a couple of league nights. So we had so much interest last year. I know there were people who wanted to get into the curling league and couldn't. So staff has added another session.
2:07:51 Any questions? Thank you for all your work. Thank you. Thank you, Grady Dutton, Public Works. Three things on preparation for the winter, which is coming at some point. I know, you know, we know it will. We'll have confidence in that, even though the resort had to delay their...
2:08:14 Opening day on a daily day-to-day basis. A couple things. We did have a Lakes Basin closing prep meeting with the Forest Service and all the users up in the Lakes Basin. So at such time, we're ready and everybody knows what their job is and when that happens. And we actually scheduled the opening meeting for next year on April 1st. So everybody's looking ahead, Forest Service and everyone's on the same team and communicating pretty well. This morning...
2:08:37 Is that this morning or yesterday morning? Caltrans and the Mountain had their winter preparation meeting. That was yesterday, yes. Great turnout. I wasn't able to attend, but we had both our police department and our public works staff well represented. That's an opportunity for Mono County, for CHP, Caltrans, and everybody to get together to talk about the winter, what traffic conditions, and make sure all the resources are ready for that as well. This afternoon, we actually had another meeting related to transit with ESTA and the Mountain as well, because we,
2:09:07 We don't know what's going to happen this winter with Altera and the Icon Pass. We don't know how many people are going to be here. We don't know, and they don't know yet, what Tuesday through Thursday are going to be like. We talked about equipment. We talked about driver burnout. We talked about being flexible. We were introduced to Philip Morris, who is the new ESTAD director, M-O-O-R-E-S.
2:09:28 I don't know if I'm pronouncing that correctly. Moores, I guess. So we got to meet him as well. So we've set up those lines of communication so we're ready for the winter. Earlier today, on an earlier agenda item for the benefit of the public, we did take a tour of three projects that are almost complete. We wanted to do it now because there's no meeting late in November. We wouldn't be able to do it until early in December.
2:09:50 Went to the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure, a $900,000 ATP grant project that is, I'd say, substantially complete, just a few cleanup items. And as you can tell, the public is already enjoying that. Most of the barricades are down, and people are walking and biking that. That came out really well.
2:10:06 We went by Lower Main Street and saw the sidewalk. The sidewalk itself is complete. Still a little bit of cleanup work to do. I think they're going to be striping parking spaces in the very near future. So that piece from the post office down to Forest Trail will be complete before this winter. Again, that's just a first phase of a...
2:10:26 Three-part project, really, that goes into next summer with the part between Mountain and Sierra and everything on the south side of Main Street. We then did a sort of a drive-by up on Minaret. We were able to see the new wall. The curb and gutter is in. They're prepping to get the sidewalk in the next few days. So all those will be complete before the winter hits, and we're really looking forward to that. Thank you. Grady, can you just...
2:10:50 Let the public know that all these sidewalks and everything else, the majority of the cost all came from different kinds of grants. I think they would really like to. Yeah, no, absolutely. I appreciate that because we were talking on the bus that we do our best to spend, as we call them, other people's money. They're not really other people's money. They're our tax dollars, hard at work.
2:11:10 But the ATP grant for Mammoth Creek Gap Closure was very competitive, and we were able to get that. And the rest of it is state transportation improvement program funds that we've acquired and working closely with LTC and our other partners. So, yeah, those are not all town general fund dollars. There's very little of that. In fact, it's mostly state money and other tax money. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for that question. Thank you, Grady.
2:11:37 Okay. Is that it for departments and commissions? Okay. Thank you very much. Now we will go ahead and go to staff presentations. The streets know management policies and procedures. Okay. Thank you. Brady, I'm presuming I send that back over to you. You bet. In your packet and in the packet that's out there for the public, there is what I would consider a very long PowerPoint presentation.
2:12:12 I do have it all here. We're not going to go through every slide on this, otherwise it would extend this meeting another hour. It is basically the same as what we did last year, so three of you have already seen most of that, but just a couple of updates. So what I'd like to do is flip through it and bring out some highlights of things that I know that we...
2:12:30 Do have concerns about or that I, let's just say they're common points of discussion from year to year. So please stop me if you have any questions on any ones I cover quickly and certainly we can answer anybody's question from the audience or yourselves at any time in the future. But again, it's a lot of information so I didn't think that maybe we all needed to see every single slide in great detail. One thing I put up here is Chris Smallcom, excuse me, from National Weather Service Reno was in town a few weeks ago.
2:13:00 And I definitely paraphrase what he said, but the bottom line was, it's going to snow. He doesn't think it's a drought by any means, and it's not going to be a record year. It could be anywhere in between. So what does that mean? You know, 250 to 450 inches, he doesn't have a clue. He went into great detail, though, to talk about how they predicted
2:13:21 Mammoth, frankly, and it was one of the last ones because we are some of the most difficult. He talked about how La Nina and El Nino really don't affect us at all because of our location. So it was a really nice presentation and he ended up doing it again in Bishop the next day, I think. But the bottom line is they don't expect a drought by any means but not a record year either. Somewhere in between once it gets started.
2:13:46 We have a complement of staff here tonight. We have Haislip Hayes from our engineering manager, of course, Todd Murphy and Pat Vargas from our road maintenance crews and Brian Picken from the airport. So if you have any questions about that specifically, I encourage you to ask the experts. Todd's been doing it here for at least...
2:14:05 27 years, maybe longer, and he's the guy I go to, and I don't pretend to understand what they do on a daily basis. But suffice it to say that we do have a snow management program, and we do have a policy, and we do take that very seriously, and we prepare for the whole thing for a couple of months. Lon Adams, our...
2:14:25 Our fleet manager as well is making sure all the equipment is ready to go and we have the right chains and everything else. A great deal of preparation goes into that. It includes polishing on the streets, the sidewalks on the paths, which you heard from Stu just last meeting. He went through in great detail some of the changes there and the additional paths that we're taking on, which include...
2:14:45 The Mammoth Creek Gap Closure Project. I just want to highlight that because for the first time we will be able to clear from up near the athletic club all the way to Mammoth Creek Park West, and that's the goal is to do that the entire winter. Certainly if we have a winter like two years ago, I said it before, all bets are off, we'll see what happens, but that's certainly the intent, and we have the equipment to do that. Again, I'm not going to go through these in great detail. These are pictures from a couple of years ago because they're more fun than last year's.
2:15:13 Frankly, you know, there's more snow. But we do have an accepted and adopted snow management policy. Number one, I just want to put on this slide, is that public safety is always the primary concern. Number one priority is making sure the roads are clear so that first responders get to where they need to go. Everything else comes after that. As a detail, we do have approximately 104 lane miles. It means a two-lane road that's a mile long, that counts as two lane miles, and that's what the guys have to clear.
2:15:43 In terms of the policy, again, support for emergency agency responses are first, main arterials and bus routes, secondary residential streets, and on down the list. We do get to the rest of it. Typically, everything's cleared within a 12-hour period and sometimes twice within a 24-hour period, again, depending on snow. One thing I'll say about the crews is that when they sign on to that group, they understand that they have to explain to their families that
2:16:12 Okay, I might not be around for Thanksgiving or Christmas or New Year's or for two weeks. You never know because a couple of years ago we put them up here in town several times so they didn't have to drive home and get back. So there's a great deal of commitment to that and a great deal of pride in what they do. The operations levels, again, I'm not going to go through this in great detail, but just suffice to say that we do have different levels. Here's a map, however, and I do want to make one comment on this. We had a question earlier about...
2:16:41 These different colors. Well, red is typically the first priority of the first ones plowed. Let's put it that way. As you can see down by the shop in the industrial area.
2:16:51 We do go through the trails early on. That's not because it's that special. It is. It's a great neighborhood, and a number of town staff live there. But frankly, when they leave the shop, it doesn't make any sense to drive right past a mile's worth of residential streets. So they get in there first as they're coming up Meridian to head other directions. And you can see this mainly shows the main alturials, Old Mammoth Road, Meridian.
2:17:17 Lake Mary Road as far as we can go and Minaret. One that isn't in red here but it's treated as red and this is a response to a question I got was the road in front of the school and the hospital. Even though it's blue because the school's not in session.
2:17:31 We're going to clear a route to get to the hospital, certainly. But the way it happens to work is when we come up, in fact, Pat usually blows that one himself. He does that very early on, probably before 7 o'clock. So that's typically open regardless. I just wanted to point that out because it is shown as blue and we could probably go through and update the map. But again, we know that we do it that way. One question on that, Grady, on that slide.
2:17:56 The Sierra Valley sites, if you will, is all third tier. I'm assuming that that's an elevation and flatness thing. Most of the town's snow shovelers live in that neighborhood. So it probably should be important to get out, but I was just...
2:18:10 And this is my opportunity. I really do want you to, you know, to see these guys more up close. So here's Todd to go ahead and respond to that question. Todd even used to live in that neighborhood. Is that why you put it on the last? Yes, I used to bill many years ago. You can stand there or sit here. Take your picture. I can speak to him. You need a mic, though. I need a mic? Yep. We record everything you say. We're very interested. The reason why it's on that tier, Bill, is because it's a lower elevation area.
2:18:39 So the snow isn't quite as heavy as what it is up in the slopes in the higher area. So that's why it's deferred to later in the mornings. Realizing that a lot of the workforce comes through that area, but we have to get the high areas open for the buses and for the tourists who are making their way up to Canyon Lodge and whatnot. Greg, I have a question on Main Street. So it looks like we clear in front of the fire station, but then there's a gap down there.
2:19:11 As you go further? Most of the red, and Todd, correct me if I'm wrong, but most of that red is actually the frontage roads as opposed to 203, correct? Correct. And the gaps there were, the gray areas are actually what Caltrans does, so you can see the upper part of Main Street. Oh, okay, so EMS can get out. And many red are gray, that's correct. So other roads are Caltrans? Yeah, parts of 203 are Caltrans. Why don't you talk about your discussions with Caltrans lately and some of the changes we're doing for this year?
2:19:40 Yeah, I think we're going to have a pretty good discussion next week regarding the new sidewalks on the section of 203 between Forest Trail and Whiskey Creek area up in there just because of our new sidewalks. It's going to change both the town snow removal program and the state's program through there. I'm going to meet with their superintendent there out on Main Street next week.
2:20:06 Basically, it's going to be a trial winner for us for Main Street there. Caltrans still is assuming the snow removal for it. The plowing, they're going to plow it just like they have in the past. We're going to request that they try to keep the snow off of the sidewalk with their plow trucks so it doesn't make it tough on our sidewalk blowers. And then we're going to have to figure out what we're going to do with the snow storage as far as that goes, whether it's going to come down to placing it on the...
2:20:33 Side of the road, in the bike lane, like we currently do on Old Mammoth Road, and when it gets large enough, haul it off, and there's going to be quite a bit of it stored in the parking areas, which will be trucked off to on the parking lot sides of the frontage roads. It'll be interesting to see how that happens. So this year, we're meeting, we're going to go over what we think is going to work for both of us, and we're going to figure out what we're going to do, what's going to be the most efficient way to do it.
2:20:59 But it's going to take us a season to, you know, figure out what works best for both agencies. The nice part is one is Caltrans a couple of years ago did not have the resources. At one point they were short, what, 20 drivers, they said, and equipment. And they've ramped up so they have a lot more resources. In addition, later on the agenda, on the consent agenda, is the snow trucking contract, which will help us get that snow out of those parking spaces down the road. Correct. Thank you.
2:21:31 Okay, the next few slides are talking in detail about some of the equipment, you know, everybody's still pretty happy about our new loader blower that we put into operation last year. It did make a difference. It hasn't been tested, I wouldn't say, right? I mean, we know what happens, but it hasn't been tested in two weeks long of big storms, but we're real confident in that, and we're really happy to have that, of course.
2:21:56 And we are ordering a new plow truck. I think on October 3rd you authorized that. We're actually speccing that thing out right now. Lon and I had a long discussion earlier this week about how we're going to acquire that. That was around $200,000. So we may not have it for much, if any, of this season because it does take quite a while to get that equipment in and upfit it. But it'll be a great benefit hopefully late season and if not, definitely next year.
2:22:23 Yeah. And the ones that aren't here who aren't represented really is our fleet mechanics, and I just want to give them kudos, too. They're a big part of this team, not just in their highest priority, which is keeping the loaders and blowers and everything moving, but in bigger storms, they do fueling, they run the cinder trucks, they do some plowing, and again, they're a big part of this team as well. They don't get to go home for Christmas either if they get stuck. They work the same hours as all of us. That's right.
2:22:50 We already talked about Caltrans. I also already talked about the Lakes Basin opening and closing meetings. We did talk about Reds Meadow as well. And again, it's not something that historically, not in the last few years at least, that we've done a lot in terms of clearing it out. And we certainly experienced last year where the snow was...
2:23:10 Melting, and part of the road was going with it, so we're very careful if we do anything down there, but again, it's a year-to-year basis, and I can report that the project to rebuild Reds Meadow is moving along nicely. It still looks, you know, still four years out or so when the funding gets here, but it's moving nicely through the process, and we are paying attention to that. One comment on that, as we have discussed in the past with some of the
2:23:35 The concessionaires down at the bottom there actually have a set of plans that I asked Mr. Tanner to mark up for me with some of his concerns. And now that we're pretty much through with our construction period, I'll have the chance to get back to him and try to compare what the 30% plans that the Federal Highways is coming up with with his comments. We're not going to satisfy them all. We know that. But at least I want to let him know what the status is and what we're doing down there. Tell us about that picture. Pardon me? The picture.
2:24:04 Oh, that picture? This was after the big storm of two years ago, 16, 17. There was damage all through the lake's basin. This is actually a little shop there, yeah. Again, we already talked about the sidewalks and mops.
2:24:20 Wait, could you just go back for a second? Because this is what I always think of on the cartoon. So I'll tell you what, it actually is in a larger format as the last slide. Oh, it is. Okay, good. I want to make sure everyone gets to see that. I liked it too, so it's in here twice. I'm not going to hit the airport a lot. Brian Picken is here if you want to talk about it, except to say that the standards for snow and ice on the airport are an eighth of an inch.
2:24:47 Okay, so when it snows, they have to be there, or we don't get the runways open. An eighth of an inch is not much snow, so it accumulates pretty quickly, and those guys are on it very quickly, so in order to keep the runways open. Typically after even a decent storm, everything's clear and ready to go by 9.30 or 10 in the morning. We actually had some pictures, I didn't leave them all in here, but from two years ago again, where there was...
2:25:13 Six feet of snow all across the entire airfield after 395 had been closed for three days because they couldn't get out and remove it, so everything was shut down. They removed that in basically one day, and that was quite a job, that's for sure. And again, we list all the equipment, and if you have any questions now or later, just drop me an email if you have any questions, and certainly we invite everybody again to tour the facility, both at the yard and the airport. To support recreation,
2:25:44 It's really Joel Rasty, our trails coordinator, who coordinates this in terms of the winter grooming between the off-road stuff, the snowmobiles and everything else. I don't have a lot of information on that. We can ask Joel for more detail at some point, but it really depends so much on snow. About three years ago, we didn't have any cross-country skiing, any Nordic at Shady West, and two years ago, it was daily for the entire season, just about.
2:26:13 And he works with MLTPA staff and gets the job done. I want to mention the private snow management services for two things. One is I want to recognize them. Last year we actually had a meeting with about 20 participants who showed up to talk about kind of the rules and instituting those.
2:26:31 They were very happy here. We didn't have a lot of rules. We asked them to put their name on their equipment, put a phone number on their equipment, and give us an idea of where they'd be working so if we got calls, we could take care of that. I would say, by and large, everybody behaved really well, so much so that this year we're just going to send out emails and make phone calls. We're not going to have them even come to a meeting. They actually did pretty well. One of the things in the ordinance that we have...
2:26:55 And it's not a matter of not enforcing, it's just how you do that in a way that helps them get their job done. One of the things in there is the idea that they're not supposed to take snow from one property across town streets to another. Well, we don't have any problem with that as long as they have their name on their equipment and their phone number so we know who they are. And also, if asked, or if we ask, they need to show us that they actually have permission to put the snow on that other piece of property because sometimes it just kind of happens.
2:27:22 If they have permission and they're doing it in a safe manner and they're identified, again, we don't have any problem with that. So this year, again, we'll remind them, we'll ask them all to fill out their things, update their information on their equipment so we know who they are. But again, they did a good job last year because snow storage can be a huge issue. This is a picture in my neighborhood where we hauled off the snow out of the front yard three times during that winter. So we realize that they're partners with us. They're not just contractors in town.
2:27:53 I want to get to parking for just a second. Again, this is mostly stuff that's in the presentation. You can ask questions. And I talked to Chief Davis earlier, and he's ready to address briefly how they're preparing for the winter and the kind of enforcement areas that they're going to do this winter. So we have an expectation. You will get phone calls. That's the easy part. We always get phone calls because somebody feels like they've been slighted. But go ahead, Chief.
2:28:20 Essentially, the ordinance says from November 1st through April, there's no parking on town roadways or ride-aways, but we're waiting, and it's going to be based on enforcement, based on snow on the ground.
2:28:32 That kind of level of enforcement. So it's really designed to help out with the plowing and everything. And what is it, 10 feet from the edge of the roadway is actually town property so they can blow snow in there. But Kari and I also have my guys as well as Rick Bellis that will be out looking and trying to, you know, enforce those things as the snow comes. So that's essentially it. 10 feet from the edge of the road in some places. Yeah, we know. 30 feet in some places.
2:29:01 The actual line's from the middle of the road, but that's where the road's supposed to be, not necessarily where the road is. That's right. Just thought I'd lay all that out there. Yeah. Well, it's interesting. Yeah, in some areas, the street pavement is consistent, but one, the right-of-way varies hugely in a couple of Manzanita Road sections, as an example. And also, the pavement isn't necessarily in the middle of the easement, so it gets pretty interesting to try to keep up with that, so.
2:29:29 But the key, again, is teamwork. And this does happen more often than these guys will admit. But it happens, and it happens every year. But we try. I'm hoping that's not the new sidewalk. Exactly. That's Warren and that's Caltrans. Exactly. So with that, we're glad to answer any questions. Again, we have the experts here between Todd and Pat and Brian. Questions?
2:30:02 I'm fine. Todd, Grady, I mean, have you surveyed your own staff as to, you know, what do they need? I mean, this is a great presentation, and I haven't had no complaints about this, no removal or anything else, but reading this, I wondered if sometimes we ask our staff, what do you guys need to be more efficient? I just wondered if we've ever surveyed our staff down there.
2:30:29 I think, personally, I think we're going in the right direction by updating some of our aging equipment and stuff like that. You know, that's a key thing there as far as having good, reliable equipment, stuff that doesn't break down and take our mechanics away from helping us out with the snow removal on the streets, you know, is a great way to go. And other than that, it's just keeping staff staffed.
2:30:52 Yeah, and there was a list of all the equipment there, and so everything looks pretty good for this year? Yeah, we're good. I think we're coming up for another loader replacement here real soon for our replacement schedule and stuff like that, but we'll review everything and see where it stands there just to keep everything up nice and newer anyways. So the blower last year was a huge addition to us. It gave us a really solid backup blower.
2:31:20 For the fleet when something goes down, we don't have to run that old meal blower that we gave to the airport on public roads. It's better suited for parking lots down at the airport than it is town streets. And I think we're doing pretty good in that respect as long as the council keeps allowing us when the time comes to spend the money on newer equipment. Thank you. And I do say you guys do a great job. Thank you.
2:31:51 You do a great job. The only thing I would ever reiterate is always is it is a partnership between the private homeowner and the private snow remover and the town of Mammoth Lakes. One does not hold sway over the other. It has to be done in concert with each other or it just doesn't work. I agree with you, Bill. Are there any questions or comments from the public on this item? We will go ahead and...
2:32:26 That's a good kind of comment. Okay, so now we will go ahead and move to item five on the agenda, update on the parcel public outreach event and review of community housing summit. And I shall turn this one over. Oh, excuse me, did I? That's it. Oh, no, that is it. Okay.
2:32:52 Okay, I was confused. Okay, thank you, Grady. Oh, that's okay. And I'm really just going to introduce Mickey Brown, who needs no introduction to get started on it. And then Sandra and I can add any comments on the end, because we were there for most of the summit as well. So, thank you. And I'll also be bringing up Ken, you know, because we like a lot of company.
2:33:14 First of all, I really thank you for the town support and the community support and for council. I know, Bill, you had some issues that you couldn't come, but I really appreciate everybody on council for showing up to the summit.
2:33:28 It was really an exciting weekend. And as we said at the beginning of the summit, you know, we had three goals. One goal was for housing literacy, and we still have glossaries around. So if anybody in the audience didn't get their glossary, I'm sure Sandra can help you. We have a whole box of glossaries. The second...
2:33:49 Objective was to work on short-term wins and the continuation of our community housing action plan, and Ken's going to be talking about that shortly. And then the last part, objective, was really about the development opportunities for the parcel and about financing. And that's what I'd like to talk about a little bit. This was our sessions that were Friday evening, Saturday evening, and Sunday morning.
2:34:17 And for those of you that weren't there, it was like being on a peer resort tour, but only having all the resorts come to us. It was really an amazing group of speakers. We heard about people, what they did in Boulder with similar-sized parcels, Breckenridge, Tahoe, I mean, that list, and then we saw probably 20 to 30 different pictures of affordable housing work sites for resort areas across the United States.
2:34:45 We felt it was really important to take all this wonderful information and try to come up with three focal points that as a community we wanted to share back to the council. And this is just regarding, as I said, regarding the parcel. And the first point...
2:35:07 That the group felt very strongly about, the community felt really strongly about, after seeing what other communities had done, is that the parcel needs to be master planned. And not only does the parcel need to be master planned, but we really need to tie that master plan down Tavern Road all the way to the McFlex parcel. Because it really does integrate, and it'll be part of our downtown revitalization.
2:35:31 So that was the first point that wanted to be conveyed. The second is we need to create a dedicated stream of income so that we can really start our work on the parcel. When we ultimately get to the parcel, the financing will be very, very complicated. But we have a lot of pre-work to do. And it was pretty amazing to hear that the city of Breckenridge
2:36:01 Which has a little bit bigger budget than we do, but only 5,000 permanent residents. Their dedicated stream for new development is $3 million a year. So I know, I mean, when we talked about this, I jokingly said, wow, the air just went out of the balloon, you know, but we have to really, if we're going to be serious about...
2:36:25 Developing our parcel and really serving our community well, we're going to have to come up with a dedicated stream of income. And then lastly, some of these other projects took really a long time to get off the ground. And what our guest speakers really said is, and some of the people that were present on Sunday morning is what we termed, we need a quarterback.
2:36:52 One person whose full-time job, they don't have to know everything, but they have to really be able to oversee the master plan process, the outreach to the community, how we're going to finance it, and the horizontal build. And so we hope that the council can find financing really in the short term to hire a quarterback.
2:37:16 If we are going to move this parcel forward, we're going to have to really dedicate the resources and the capacity to do it. So those, I mean, I can share lots of things with you, but those were really the three main points that we wanted to share with you. And I don't know if anybody has any questions about those points. And if not, then we'll, and Nicole Godoy here, she's my best supporting person. So, I mean, I do know, I think you all know that.
2:37:47 The spear of Mammoth Voices is, besides myself, is Nicole Godoy and then Kathleen Taylor. And the three of us really worked together on that. And the only other thing I'd like to say before I leave the podium, John Wentworth is a force to be reckoned with when he decides he wants to do something because he worked on this with a...
2:38:07 Unbelievable amount of passion and enthusiasm and is really largely responsible for how well the summit came out. So I'm very grateful to your energy and it was really a pleasure to work with you on that. Thank you. Okay, Ken, you can talk about the future. Thanks, Mickey. Ken Bringle, Executive Director of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. We were involved, of course, with the Saturday session where we had
2:38:39 Employer Housing Solutions this winter was the 930 session talking about a deliverable we hoped to come out of that was how do we come up with 50 units, 50 beds, 50 something this winter to help with employee housing. And the afternoon was implementation looking at the housing action plan and what were the five top priorities.
2:39:05 Let me start with the 930 session. I thought it was very well attended, very good energy. I would say we had a good mix of not only business, but residents coming together. And the thing is, we started talking about what can we do in the next six weeks to kind of look for workforce housing for this winter.
2:39:33 Started off the session with Colin Fernie and talking about the LLC that he and Kathy and Shields Richardson put together for their employee housing and how they went about that. And what was great about that and great about Colin Shields and Kathy were willing to lay out their business plan that could lay out for
2:39:58 If a number of small businesses wanted to get together, it gave them kind of a roadmap of, gee whiz, if we all threw in some money together, could we buy a unit? Because some of the units they had ended up having where they could house eight people and so forth. And it was a way that they had their employees for both side door and black tie be able to live.
2:40:23 First of all, Colin did a great job on that, plus I think there's some commitments there to help us as we move forward on trying to look at how do we come up, the ideas started to come up, but how do we come up with these 50 units? Rich Sanfilippo, who owns Perfect Clean, is also president-elect of the chamber, the cleaning companies, they know within his
2:40:49 How do we provide some management services and property management and some others?
2:41:18 Contact all the lodging establishments. See if there's, you know, if their average occupancy over the winter is 95% or 90% are there two or three rooms that they'd be willing to rent as over the four months of the ski season, five months of the ski season as employee housing.
2:41:41 And we needed to start the discussion on providing a way for small business owners to create that collaborative effort of how do we come together, because they may not have enough money for them, you know, for each business to do something, but as a collaborative it might work. We did pull up the Mammoth Community Foundation, which is the Chambers Foundation, has been kind of idle. We redid the purpose and used it for funding.
2:42:11 The summit will, I think, have some additional dollars left over that could be seed money for some of these projects. But, you know, what we need is, what we're going to need, and it was brought up by Mickey, and that is the funding issue. And we're willing to go out through the foundation and try to raise money, because what we looked at for this short-term trying to find...
2:42:35 The next six weeks, those 50 houses, we're going to have to hire somebody that can make the phone calls, could call all the HOA managers, call all the cleaning companies, make phone calls to the lodging establishments and say, what do you have available? What can we put together? And then we have to come back and figure out how do you do that and how do we provide some assistance to them?
2:43:00 So we're willing to go out and try to maybe find that through our foundation. And I had talked to Patricia at Mammoth Lakes Housing about, you know, working together on some of this stuff. But the reality is both of us don't have the capacity. We don't have the staff that can just go out and make it happen right now. So if we go out and raise money and try to hire this person, one of the things that we're going to ask for is some at least backfill, at least.
2:43:27 A guarantee that if we don't raise enough money that you're not putting the foundation in jeopardy or something that we can move forward and all that's taken care of. The afternoon session, Wendy Sullivan, Steve Fritch, I'm still waiting for them to bring, I think they're going to be getting us some notes and some for both the morning and afternoon session. It was talking about the
2:43:52 The action plan. I had to go take care of some personal stuff, come back an hour later, and it's listed all the things the chamber's going to do. It taught me to don't leave the room. But, you know, we're willing to look at all those things, but the reality is it's going to come back.
2:44:11 Thank you.
2:44:40 The reality is that both MLH and the chamber, we need to work together, but we're going to need some backing to make it happen. We're going to have to figure out how we fund that. But I think overall it was a very successful, I will say the morning session was very high energy, and I think the business community is willing to step up and try to make some things happen. Happy to answer any questions.
2:45:11 Any questions for Ken? And I just had one other comment. Our commitment by your December the 5th meeting, we will deliver to the town five videos we filmed of the sessions and then all the notes from the speakers. So that is our commitment to have all that completed and delivered by your first meeting in December. Thank you very much for that. Mickey, will all of the PowerPoint presentations that were used also be available?
2:45:43 Yes, they're available now, so if you'd like to go through them now. Great, thanks. We can send them to you. Okay, thank you. Okay, do we have any questions or comments from anyone on the Town Council? I would just like to thank the people who worked on this. John, your energy for this and your passion were well noted by Mickey and Kathleen.
2:46:10 Nicole, being there and making this happen, it was so professional. From the time you walked in the door, the little walkway where everyone was sort of exhibiting things, the people who were there presenting, Amaka and Mammoth Lakes Housing, and I'm forgetting a lot of them, but that was great. And the speakers that came in, some of them because of relationships that you had, it was really well done.
2:46:32 And I'm just sorry always that more people didn't avail themselves of it, but hopefully having the availability of it online for people to look at will bring more people in, but good work, good work. Let me try to give some concrete ideas. There's really some good sessions. So I thought the most important thing was a realistic goal of 50 units in the next six months, and I think it is doable.
2:47:03 One of the tasks was, you know, to contact the hotel to see if there are empty rooms available that they might allow for long-term rentals instead of the short-term rentals. Contact the Forest Service.
2:47:19 And what can be done in partnership with them. The down payment assistance, no strings attached. This is something new because we've been kind of limited to cap and trade grants and those are focused on 80% of AMI, average medium income. And the idea of beginning to look at a broader picture is very important.
2:47:43 Central property management of workforce units, the idea of making sure that the private sector, if they want to move their management to a central location, as well as the town's unit, as well as Mammoth Lake Housing. The RV down in Bishop perhaps as a fairground, using that as a working something partnership with Bishop. Reach out to condo owners to consider monthly.
2:48:13 The quarterback job of actually contacting owners out there and finding out if any of them do want to switch from short-term to a long-term rental. Housing authority and Section 8 vouchers. And enhanced infrastructure finance district, which could be a funding source, which needs to be explored. Cap-and-trade grants. Obviously, we're developing some grant applications now.
2:48:42 So is the town going after, and we're doing those jointly. Renter vouchers, and where's the funding that come for that? Construction, shared wall, there was some really good information about.
2:48:55 And again, the partnerships.
2:49:14 The request for funding, I absolutely agree that that's got to be dealt with and finding this person to reach out to the Forest Service, to the campgrounds, to Bishop, I mean that's going to take a lot of legwork and using the phone to find out if there are owners out there that are on short-term rentals that want to switch over. So a lot of good information came out of that and
2:49:39 And it's kind of up there on the wall. And now it's our responsibility to figure out how to begin to explore these and implement them. So I applaud John and Mickey and Nicole. You guys did a great job. I think a lot of good information. And now the burden still is out there is how do we make this work? So again, thank you for all the work you guys did.
2:50:08 So just a couple quick things. So, Dan, can the council and the public anticipate that I think maybe December 5th meeting we're going to have some kind of an item on the agenda? Yeah. If it may, you know, ideally we'll follow that. The next session with the council is on the 19th. It's really your priority setting. 19th of November. Yeah, November. Okay. That's a day-long, that's probably a day-long session? Yeah, it's a longer workshop for the day. Depending the outcome of that, then, yeah, we would prioritize bringing stuff back that December 5th, December 19th related to those priorities. Okay.
2:50:37 I make an assumption that housing is probably a relatively high priority. Perhaps. We'll confirm that on the 19th, for sure. Thank you. Great. So good. So I think that we all are anxious to kind of follow up on things that we could do, and that's good that'll be there. To just follow up on what Mickey said, if you didn't make it to the summit, you'll be able to watch all the presentations, read all the meeting notes, get all the stuff, and I'm anticipating it's going to be a page on the town's website that will have all the stuff on it.
2:51:07 Yeah, we'll look and see what we can post up for a page and stuff like that once we get all the information put together. And that's outreach-wise. So we'll get that for people to know where to find it. The last thing I want to just share is a woman from Breckenridge named Lori Best who spoke a lot about all the amazing things we're doing in Breckenridge. And she shared with me this document called Building Housing, Community Preservation, Economic Health and Sustainability in Summit County, Colorado. And it's such an inspiring little document.
2:51:35 They printed this for conference. They don't have any more copies left, but she sent me PDFs of that, so that would be on the town's webpage as well. But I think from the funding perspective, it's really important to emphasize the way they do it in Summit County. So this is not, while Breckenridge gets $3 million, they're taking it from a county-wide tax. Summit County has two local designated funding sources for employee housing. There's a voter-approved local 5A sales tax of 0.125% that's effective in perpetuity.
2:52:05 On November 6, 2016, voters approved a 0.6% increase for 10 years that will go to construction of affordable housing. With a new rate of 0.725, the countywide collection in 2017 was 9.4 million to be distributed proportionally to each municipality based on revenue generation. So we've talked a lot this evening about all these different regional things we're thinking about. I think as we start getting into this revenue conversation, certainly the Eastern Sierra
2:52:31 It may be worthwhile to be thinking about that from a regional basis. But I want to just, this will be up on that webpage when we get that thing done. So that's it. Thank you. Okay. And finally, real thanks to the staff, Christy Williams, Kirsten Pusam, MLTPA staff, other folks that worked on it. We're all patting ourselves on the back up here, but they actually, they did the hard work and made it happen. There's some very, very talented people in this town that can do things like this. And if you guys ever need an event, we know who to tell you to call. So thank you.
2:53:01 And I would just like to add, thank you so much for everybody involved with that summit. I was so excited about it, three days talking about housing, and I think one of my favorite things that came out of that is actually the glossary. I think that everybody needs to have a copy of that. It's going to keep us on track, and some of the terms that I had a little bit different of a definition, so I was very happy to see that clarified, and I really...
2:53:27 If you don't do anything, oh, okay. You want to say something about the Glocks? Whenever you're done, I just want to make sure we did. No, you can go ahead. I could talk all day about how great it was, so go ahead with the.
2:53:36 Thank you. The update was also mentioned talking about an update on the parcel itself and the work we're doing. And just very briefly, most of it is surrounding with public outreach. Obviously, we already talked about the walk and the summit itself. We are engaging a software or platform called Bang the Table, which we're hoping to launch sometime in December and get that working and updating the town's website. So all this information will be out there. It'll be a great...
2:54:02 Avenue for engagement. On the RFQs that you authorized last time, we do have a contract with Kaiser Marsden. We're reviewing and ready to execute that one. And the two RFQs for both the planning consultant, which is really...
2:54:15 Planning, some engineering and public outreach, and then an affordable housing expert. Those are all also in the works and should be out any moment now. I wanted to circle back to the summit very quickly, and we could thank all the sponsors, and there was a host of them that were advertised the whole week, and it was great to see, but a couple in particular.
2:54:33 Mammoth Resort stepped up in a couple of ways. One is Eagle Lodge turned out, in my opinion, anyway, to be a great venue for this type of thing. It was very comfortable, and everybody felt, I thought, very relaxed the whole time, and the staff there had to be very nimble, and they were. They worked so closely with Christie and everybody else's staff and made it work. And in terms of other staff,
2:54:54 Clearly, Sandra was there for all but one session on Sunday, so all of Friday night and all of Saturday. And it wasn't a matter of town staff or MLH staff with Patricia just attending. They participated. They were engaged. They were a part of it as well. So it wasn't just, see, we'll sit here and take notes as a town. They really got all over it. We had one of our finance department staffs there as well on Sunday.
2:55:15 So that was great to see. My last comment is at the end of Sunday, Mary was talking and she said, you guys must be worn out three days of talking and you just have nothing else to talk about. And our comment, several people's comment was exactly the opposite was true. Everybody was more energized about housing, about what they heard then at the beginning on Friday night. So I just wanted to add that and thank everybody again. So thank you. Okay. So do we have any public comment about the summit or any?
2:55:46 Questions? Okay. Let's go ahead. And we are going to now move on to public presentations, item number six on our agenda. And the Staten, I think I'm saying that correctly, the solar presentation on power purchase agreements. Yes, Madam Mayor, if I can kick this off. Don Condon with the Ready for 100 reached out a while back in terms of
2:56:12 We're presenting some information to the Council. Part of it's the solar side of this, but it's talking about what a purchase power agreement is, a PPA, and how that's worked in some other areas. Obviously, if you're doing a standalone for the town, there's different restrictions and those types of things. But again, just as we talked about with the housing, part of this is to be able to put out information and just what the language is when you talk about a power purchase agreement. What is it? It also ties, we've had some very, very preliminary discussions regarding
2:56:41 You know, community choice aggregation type concepts. I've had that discussion with the water district and with the Mammoth Mountain Ski Resorts and things of that nature. So starting that dialogue and having an understanding about what those elements are I think is important as we look at that in the future and as we look at different opportunities that may come forward to the town. You know, different values there and things of nature. A lot of it gets into some technical details.
2:57:09 Thank you, Dan. Thank you.
2:57:38 Don Condon. I just wanted to mention that I got connected with Staten Solar through South Lake Tahoe who passed a resolution to engage in an active pursuit of renewable energy. And Staten Solar is partnering with them on a project at the South Lake Tahoe airport to deliver a 300 kilowatt array.
2:58:07 And provide power for their operations and their town offices that they have there. We had Staten up here last, I think it was March, and they did a presentation to the library, and I've been talking to them off and on since I initially contacted them at South Lake Tahoe. I think we're embarking on a lot of interesting projects going forward, not only the
2:58:37 The affordable housing, which could be a candidate for renewable energy to keep the utility costs down for the occupants. But also we have the school district, which has a bond project. We have the hospital embarking on a project. There are a number of opportunities for power purchase agreements, and that's why I wanted Staten to come and present on what a power purchase agreement is and how it works.
2:59:05 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Don.
2:59:39 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:00:05 We've done about 1,200 megawatts of projects so far. About 800 of those being power purchase agreements. I'm going to delve into benefits of solar energy. I'm going to go through this. I'm sure most of you have looked at this. Renewable, non-polluting, and available planet-wide. Two words kept coming up.
3:00:35 With the speakers who are here before, that was resources and capacity, right? So the way I see solar is that we are a resource, right? And we will help build that capacity. So in case of looking for resources and capacity, we have it. Let's go with benefits. It creates energy independence.
3:01:05 Obviously reduce or eliminate electric bills, predictable operating costs, give control over rising energy costs. I don't know whether any bills, do you ever see any Southern California Edison bills reducing or do they always go up? I don't know. I think you know the answer to that question. Okay. Yeah, so.
3:01:35 So with the low payback periods, and obviously whenever we have a good federal system, we have tax credits and rebates, and obviously reduced carbon footprint, and it also creates local wealth and jobs. Having said that, I'll move to the power purchase agreement. So what is the power purchase agreement?
3:02:05 Power Purchase Agreement is a financing mechanism that states and local government entities can use to acquire clean, renewable energy. So the main thing with the Power Purchase Agreement, instead of building a system that will go on the county books, this is, you know, we will come in, sit down, negotiate a Power Purchase Agreement.
3:02:35 Which, you know, you can agree to purchase power from whoever you're negotiating with for the next 20 years, whereby, you know, if it's, you can calculate the savings, let's say you're doing at 17 cents per kilowatt hour, or 9 cents per kilowatt hour, we can come in and say, hey, well, we want to go for 5 cents per kilowatt hour. So you negotiate the tariff, after you negotiate the tariff,
3:03:05 We are able to build the system and then look the main areas for the power purchase agreement is really on the tariff, knowing that what kind of tariff you're going to get from the power purchasing agreement, knowing what the termination clauses are, the deemed generation payment terms such that you know whether you have a bankable
3:03:36 Power Purchasing Agreement. So once you have the Power Purchasing Agreement in place, then, you know, we can go ahead and build, we can come in with the finance here and we can go ahead and build the system and, you know, it will, you can look at the rates, the return on investment over 20 years. So if you are paying Southern California Edison,
3:04:05 17 cents per kilowatt hour. And we come in and say, hey, it's going to be 9 cents per kilowatt hour. That's locked in for the next 20 years. So that's one of the advantages of the power purchasing agreement. So benefits of a power purchase agreement. Predictable cost of electricity over 15 to 25 years. Definitely no upfront cost.
3:04:39 Cost of electricity will be lower than the incumbent utility. Obviously, you hedge against rising and volatile energy prices. And the third party will be responsible for O and M of the system. In that case, Staten will be responsible for the O and M for the next 20 years, for the life of the system. If you have any questions, please feel free to go ahead and ask.
3:05:15 Yeah, sure. What happens if the contractor's debt in solar goes bankrupt? Is there a mechanism to deal with that? Yes. We have good insurance. When you're negotiating the power purchase agreement, there's also a big insurance factor you have to put in for the next 20 years. And also,
3:05:46 Not only that will cover the modules. The modules will have their own manufacturer's warranties. The inverters will have their manufacturer warranties. But then also the power purchasing agreement will come in with an insurance wrap for that. Could you explain what you mean by the feed-in tariff and how that affects the contract?
3:06:26 So with power purchasing agreements, once when you're talking to a financier, he or she will want to know what their rates of, you know, their IRR, internal rate of return will be. Basically, will the project be profitable over the next 20 years? And that's why you come in knowing you have to negotiate the tariff.
3:06:56 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:07:24 All right. And then also the financier will know that that's locked in and he can calculate his rate of return and return on interest and the IRR from the tariff. So basically the tariff explains the worth of the system and that's from where everything will be calculated.
3:07:54 Do you guys? Okay. Did you answer your question? Okay. So, advantages of a PPA for government agencies, long-term cost savings, it provides budget stability, meets government mandates on sustainability goals, definitely you guys want to go green, you want to reduce the carbon footprint, that helps in taking it there.
3:08:30 Locking in a predictable electricity rate for years makes financial sense and also helps in playing an active role in the town and community's long-term strategic or climate action plan that incorporates energy reduction targets. So on PPAs, do you guys have any questions on the PPAs? Maybe I might have to elaborate any further.
3:09:14 Would it still be a grid-tied system to Edison power? Yes, because of net metering. So it's still connected to whatever you don't use during the day still flows back into the grid. And in the evening, there's no sun, so there's no solar, so that you can use the Edison power then. So very similar to the net metering on a residence?
3:09:47 If you had a solar system at your house? That's correct. You know what? I'm sorry. If we could just hold questions for a bit, just make some notes, because when you ask some questions, I'd like to have you come up so all the people who are going to be watching this in the future will be able to see you, hear the questions, and know the responses. So thank you. Okay. Because actually I'm very interested in that, but we'll wait. Thanks. So that's with the PPA. Moving on.
3:10:18 I talked to Don quite a little bit before coming to the meeting and he did mention quite a bit of stuff you're trying to do with the school district. I did mention about the hospitals, there's some renovation going on. Everybody who came up here talked about the housing which is about to come up.
3:10:48 I think these are all systems which can use PPAs, power purchase agreements. We can divide this. It doesn't have to be all in one for the school. We just need to find out what is the capacity the school is using, and we can do it right behind the meter using the roof.
3:11:17 And using the carports, let's say it's two megawatts or three megawatts of solar, we can use that, put that on the roofs and put it on the carports with different power purchase agreements between, let's say, the school, between the hospital, between the affordable housing. So that's something which we can do and it can be negotiated and, you know, taken from there.
3:11:50 CCA is Community Choice Aggregation. I understand you guys have had two of my colleagues who are here maybe about six months ago. And, you know, I believe they talked to about two council members in the library. I'm not sure. Oh, you were there. It wasn't me. Okay. Yeah, I was there.
3:12:17 And what we gathered was that you guys have had a chance to look at or consider community choice aggregation programs. I don't know whether that's one way you've tried to solve the energy situation. I don't think we've gotten there. Okay. Okay, so I'll touch a little bit on the CCA.
3:12:46 So the CCA Community Choice Aggregation allows local governments to pool the electricity demand of participating communities, homes, businesses, and municipal facilities to buy or build power facilities on behalf of their residents. So this was established back in 2002 with the California legislature, and usually we find that
3:13:17 In the CCAs, everybody, once you make a decision, you're going with a community choice aggregation, then everybody's opted in, whether they like it or not. But there's a period whereby if they don't feel comfortable, let's say one of some of the residents or some businesses don't feel like they want to participate, they could opt out. There's usually a...
3:13:45 I think a 60-day period, depending on different areas, the residents could opt out of the program. Communities throughout California are exploring CCA, including cities of San Francisco and San Diego, San Mateo County, Monterrey, San Luis Obispo, Santa Cruz, San Benito, Santa Barbara.
3:14:13 Yolo County, and several cities in Silicon Valley. Examples of CCAs in California include marine clean energy, Silicon Valley clean energy, peninsular clean energy, and Sonoma clean power. So some of these are pretty big CCAs. For example, we are working with marine clean energy. We are actually doing a 1.4 megawatt for them.
3:14:43 And they have, I would say they have close to 800 megawatts. And I think they include about up to 30 cities. So it's pretty big. Once you get into a community choice aggregation program, you could scale up depending on how much you want to go. So advantages of community choice aggregation.
3:15:21 Competitive, often significantly lower electricity rates, control over local energy rates and future, transition to a cleaner, more efficient energy supply, local jobs creation and local power resiliency. It depends on how ready, I know it does take some time, you have to involve the whole community to
3:15:50 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:16:19 I think they do have about a megawatt installed. Something to think about in future is they could...
3:16:47 You know, come up with, you know, a 20 megawatt system whereby, you know, the residents could opt in and they could sell power to the, you know, to Mammoth. There could be a full utility with the power and the water. So that's one thing you may want to think about. So that's Mammoth Lakes, small population, big image, environmental treasure, limited resources.
3:17:23 2,000 revenues from tourism, plenty of sunshine. So we have a slide about Staten. I think I'm going to run through this really fast. You know, we are headquartered in Milpeters. We have some subsidiary in India. We do everything in-house, engineering, and we can also finance. We've done about 1,200 megawatts.
3:17:57 We've done international financing to up to $100 million for power purchase agreements. We do have a track record. These are some of the plants we've built in India, 100 megawatts, 50 megawatts. We're making a big push to the agricultural community in San Bernardino. We just did a 10 megawatt.
3:18:29 Totally, it's for pumping, water, irrigation, and it's, you know, to one customer. So that's a big, big push we are doing on the agricultural space in California. I'm leading the push into Africa. We're also doing about 120 megawatts right now to different countries in Africa.
3:18:54 And we are in the process. We have negotiated the power purchase agreements with different countries. And this is about to be, we should start construction maybe in about by end of first quarter next year. This is part what we do, technology, we help select the technology. We help with engineering, help with the procurement, definitely construction.
3:19:34 As I said, this is one of the projects we did back in, I think in 2016. It was a levee mounted system down in San Bernardino also created to save land for production. We're also trying to be innovative. We're talking to Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. They have asked us to look at floating solar for some of the reservoirs
3:20:04 That's some of the things we are also exploring and hopefully maybe in a year or two we'll have something on the ground. So that's, I know I ran through the presentation and it's going to be a long night for you but do you guys have any questions so far? John, do you have any questions? The only question I have is the presentation that you gave us tonight is different than what we have here in our packet so I'm hoping you can give a copy of that to the clerk.
3:20:43 Because it would be good to have that on hand as we go forward. Okay. Okay, good. We can share that with the council. That would be great. Thank you very much for coming up here. I very much appreciate the presentation. I like that picture a lot. Okay. Do you know where that picture was taken? No, I don't know. It's right down the street. Oh, dear. I have a couple of questions. Most solar arrays,
3:21:16 We see her built kind of low to the ground. How does that work with, you know, 300 average inches of snow in the wintertime? 300, yeah, that's a good question. I think our first one, we've just done, we're just about to do a system for South Lake Tahoe, you know, so we will land with that, but we can always.
3:21:45 Do innovative engineering. They could be a little bit higher. And the operation and maintenance, we have to run the operation and maintenance a little bit more often. That way, come out to clean the panels. But as you said, how many inches of snow? Here in the village, I think the average is probably around 300 inches.
3:22:12 Okay, 300 inches. 400 inches at the mountain. Okay. I think we can, we can, it's all a matter of the design and engineering. We do the site surveys. We do a very, we have a team which before they do the designing, they do a site survey, take care of all, you know, all the situations, take into consideration everything before they do the planning. And I think with that we can raise the,
3:22:42 The panel's a little bit higher and go from there. The other question, and I don't know that it really, this is education I need to get for myself. Obviously the solar output is not on the town buildings. Usually it's a solar array somewhere like what the water district has. So the power to get to our infrastructure would come over the current power lines, correct?
3:23:09 Goes into the grid. Goes into the grid, right. Goes into the grid and then you get credit for it. So at some point, and this is, I have to educate myself here. I'm ignorant on this. At some point, SCE starts losing money. They're the ones maintaining the grid. Then whose responsibility does it become to maintain that grid when they decide they're not making their nut here? The other side of that is,
3:23:37 Solar produces in the day, and I'm a huge fan of solar as soon as we come up with some superconductors and can actually have some storage capacity, but because Mammoth's a mountain town and our heating and our lights and everything, probably our greater electric needs, other than the mountains, the ski area for their lifts, happen at night, that still has to come off the grid from otherwise produced electricity. So the capacity to produce that still has to stay in effect.
3:24:06 So how does this really cut down on the greenhouse gas emission from electric production that has to still be there to back it up until we can come up with a storage system? I do have solar on my motorhome. I absolutely love it. But I have these massive golf cart batteries that are my storage capacity. Yes. Oh, yeah, sure. This is a subject that the CPUC deals with extensively.
3:24:36 The IOUs, the investor-owned utilities, obviously are concerned with the cost of distribution when there are other sources of generation, and it's a very complex topic. They're looking at, you know, they've had to offload money to Arizona and pay to get rid of the power.
3:24:59 Because we have so much solar here in California. But there are ways that they're learning to address this. A number of ways. Battery storage, storage of water, hydraulic. You pump the water up and let it drain down at night when you need the power. There's a lot of creative things that they're looking at. Electric vehicles, when you plug your vehicle in, you can let the utility use the battery of your vehicle to provide power to the grid.
3:25:27 So it's all very complicated, and it's going to be a subject we're going to be living with for a long time. But in general, the movement towards renewable energy is inevitable, in California at least, where we have some decrees now that require it. And the utilities have to adjust. And when Staten Solar or whatever company provides a solar array,
3:25:55 It has to be accommodated somehow through the grid. And that's something that a lot of great minds are working on very carefully. And I hope they're going to make progress because solar energy, it's going to happen. It's got to happen. So anyway, that's the best answer I can give you right now. Thank you. I'm going to add to that. Most of the time, most of the shows,
3:26:25 Most of the solar shows or conventions which have been existing for the last maybe 10, 15 years, you go in, you see inverters, you see solar modules. You know, that's about it. That's the racking and all that. But the last one or two years, there's been a lot of push on energy storage. Energy storage, and it's getting cheaper. So that is going to be...
3:26:54 You'll see it more and more incorporated into solar systems, which will answer a lot of your questions about how is this stored and then brought up to the grid. So energy storage is a really, really big topic right now, and that's where we are all headed to. Thank you. Did you have a question? No. Oh, okay.
3:27:20 And actually, if you could just stay up there, and then if there's any questions from the public that you'd like to get up and just ask, if you could kind of share the podium there so we can both hear and see you. That would be wonderful. Thank you. Hi, I'm Robert Creasy. I'm with the Water District Board of Directors. Just to clarify a couple of things, for example, Bill, your question about a ground-mounted system.
3:27:53 The one megawater rate at the water district is a ground mountain system. Two years ago, we did have some trouble with that. But otherwise, for the last, I guess it's been six years, it's been fine. It's a matter of designing it to suit the circumstance. And out there, we don't have as much snow as we do, say, at the mountain.
3:28:21 Power at nighttime. The peak power periods, we're moving to time of use rates throughout the electric system. And currently, I have a solar system on my house. The peak rates are from 2 in the afternoon to 8 in the evening. And so if you're producing power during at least some of that peak, you're getting credit at those peak rates. And then if you're using power at night, that's some of the lowest super off peak rates.
3:28:50 So a kilowatt produced at 2 o'clock in the afternoon is worth a couple kilowatts in the middle of the night. Now, more to your point and your question, and which is a question I have for you that I'm getting to, is as the utilities adjust to more and more solar, those time of use rates are going to switch into the off-peak. And what we're finding at the water district is we're getting demand charges. So even though we don't have a lot of kilowatt-hour consumption,
3:29:20 Because we're working all of our pumps to run during the hours the solar system is providing power, we are getting demand charges, which is kind of your peak power demand from the district when certain pumps kick on, and they are ratcheting up those demand charges versus the actual energy charges. And so as you set up an agreement for PPA and look at the costs,
3:29:50 Does that analysis take into account where the utilities are going with changing time of use rates and demand charges? Yes. Time of use, that's a big one. That's being addressed right now in PPAs. And also another way of addressing time of use also is what I talked earlier.
3:30:20 The energy storage, because when you know that you incorporate a certain amount of energy storage into your system, that will greatly help with the demand charges and the time of use. That also has to be factored, the pricing has to be factored into it, but when you look at it, you'll see the
3:30:48 Return on investment is still good enough, especially now that energy storage is getting cheaper and cheaper. So that's one way we, you know, that's going to be addressed in the PPA, and that's the one way that it's not going to be very, very expensive. Great question. Thank you. Oh, Pam. Hello, Pam. So Pample, the High Sierra Energy Foundation Executive Director.
3:31:21 And, you know, obviously this is all complex. And, you know, I might just want to suggest that you consider putting a task force together with other entities in the community that are, you know, interested in addressing this issue and as well to really assess what the will of the council and what the will of the town is to move forward and what path that might be. So I think that that...
3:31:49 You know, there's lots of different entities that are interested in this, and I think coming together and having a cohesive, you know, idea and will and a path forward may be what you want to consider in the future.
3:32:03 Yeah, if I could on that, I think there's been a lot of advocacy around this topic, and I think the council and the town is very keenly aware of it, but it's going to be very helpful if the advocacy community and the aggregation of these opportunities and partners, if that could start to happen, because I don't think there's any doubt that there's buy-in and a desire to the town to do something. We don't know exactly what that is, and so I think we really need the thought leaders in the community to actually start putting some tangible, specific proposals together.
3:32:31 To give the town something to engage with. That would be super helpful. Or even if the task force itself was formed in the community that then the town could be a part of, I think that would be useful also. And I just want to thank you for coming to Mammoth to talk about this because I think our collective knowledge perhaps around things like PPAs and other sort of agreements is not robust.
3:32:58 And so every time we hear it, we'll learn a little more. And then if we can be part of a community advocacy for this, I think that would be a great match of us moving forward for this. Because I agree with your comments, Don, that solar is inevitable. Solar energy is inevitable. And the more we can learn about it and be conversant in it, I think the better we'll be. Thank you.
3:33:27 With that, any more questions or comments? I'll make a few comments. Hold on one second, sir. I'm sorry. I'm going to go ahead and let Mr. Stapp speak here. My comments are, you know, the airport, there's land behind it that was used for grinding stumps and everything. It's about five acres behind it. So we do have a piece of...
3:33:54 Maybe it's the Forest Service. I don't know. I think it is the Forest Service. But the fact that it's been disturbed means that it might be a location for a solar farm back there. The idea of doing research on a specific project, which...
3:34:13 I agree with John on that. Maybe that is the thing. But it's always come down to getting some person on the town side. I hate to pick on poor Brian Pickens because he worked on there 24-7. But, I mean, we might want to ask Brian to really be the person that begins to really look at this and put it in some sort of format.
3:34:37 In conjunction with Don to see if we could do something down there. Yeah, and I would just really, because I know we're going to come up to a priority, our next big meeting is our priority setting session. I know we're all very concerned about overwhelming staff and, you know, we're going to have priorities and things that we got to do. And so I'm going to go, again, back out to the advocacy community. Understand what...
3:34:59 The world is that we need to make decisions on. And so more advocacy is nice, but I think we don't have to worry about that so much. I think we would really like to see the partners that you guys are talking to who want to participate in this thing to have them come in front of us with demonstrations of political will, demonstrations of resources that they're willing to commit to this thing to make it happen, and then we can figure out how to engage. And I think I agree with you completely. I mean, let's get this thing moving.
3:35:26 We're going to be struggling, I'm sure, with our capacity. If we've got some meaningful proposals, some things we can actually act on, I think that's going to be really helpful for us to engage. If I may have a comment. My name is Robert Creasy. Again, I spoke earlier. To John's comment, I do think that at some level the town government is the lead, the political lead in this community.
3:35:56 You know, there's the hospital, the schools, the mountain, the water district. You know, there are different, perhaps more resources, financial resources there, but in terms of providing direction to the community and taking kind of a philosophical lead, I believe that falls upon the council. Well, I just want to speak to that a little bit. I think that I can speak only for myself.
3:36:21 Yeah, and I appreciate that. I don't think...
3:36:50 I'm not asking you to say we are going to do something that we don't have any plan for, but when we're trying to bring all the various entities together in, say, a task force of some sort, it seems to me that that is sort of the role of the town government is to be that unifying force. Well, if I could real quick, if we had an agenda item in front of us that said would you be only part of a task force?
3:37:14 Then we can act on it. Right now we're dealing with a presentation. We're limited what we can engage with here this evening. So if you guys, if some people put together a proposal and a task force and they want the town to be part of it, boy, we'd love to see that. Yeah, no, and I'm not asking for action tonight because I understand how the agendized actions take place.
3:37:33 I just was concerned when you were saying put it on the advocacy community to come up with a plan. I'm not sure that's the appropriate process. Well, look, we just put on a housing summit that the town had nothing to do with, and it's an important issue to the community. Rallied a bunch of people together. We got something happening. I think if we could do something around renewable energy, that would be really helpful. And, again, get an agenda item in front of the council that says so we can take some action on it and find a way to meaningfully engage. Sounds great. Yep. Thanks. Thank you. Just a final comment on that, John.
3:38:03 Yeah, we're going to do what we can to get the school district educated, the hospital educated, and, you know, try to get some of the entities that could participate in meaningful renewable energy adoption to learn how to do this. So we'll be advocating. I'm not sure we're going to come up with a nice little package because it's just, life just doesn't work that way, but we will.
3:38:32 Be making an effort to get everybody, you know, involved in such a way that they understand what the real options are. Because the way I see it, if you look at the school district and they've got a lot of south-facing roof area, it's going to have to be upgraded to accept panels, it's going to have to have the conduit installed. Well, why wouldn't you do a PPA that doesn't cost anything? They can give you a fixed electricity rate. It just...
3:38:59 So I understand, you know, your situation.
3:39:28 I understand the reality of the situation. I also think the community housing is going to be a good, especially since we haven't really done a plan yet that's really a site plan that we've really developed, we can look at that too. So yeah, we'll be looking at all these individual components and trying to put something together on all of them. But yeah, so I take that to heart and we'll be working on it. Thank you. Great, looking forward to that. Thank you.
3:39:56 Okay, so at this time then, thank you very much for that presentation. We are going to go ahead and take a 10-minute break so people can stretch their legs and get the blood flowing, and we will be back 10 after 8. Thank you. Red line of the four, whatever item that was. Okay, let's see. I used those as a coaster earlier.
3:40:55 Okay, and now we are back in session, and we are going to start with item seven on the consent agenda. Well, let me read the items here on the consent agenda. We have approved the meetings of the regular meeting of October 17, 2018, board contract for snow trucking services, adopt the resolution making the required municipal code findings and approving time extension request 18-002.
3:41:22 For a six-year time extension of the Old Mammoth Place project entitlement with conditions as recommended by staff, number 10, accept payment approval report number 19-20 and accept payment approval report 19-21. And continued on the next page. Accept payment approval report number 19-21.
3:41:51 We are now going to move to the public hearing portion and
3:42:31 Let me get past it here. Sorry. We're on item number 11. It is consider approval of zoning code amendment 18-002 to amend the regulations for cannabis retailer businesses within municipal code table 17.24.020, municipal code section 17.52.085.D, including finding the project.
3:42:59 Categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to California Business and Professions Code Section 26055H. Okay. And here, we're opening this up. Here, hold on one second. Sorry about that. Okay. So I want to make sure I've read the title. We're formally opening the public hearing. And if I can hear from staff. Great. Thank you.
3:43:32 Zoning Code Amendment 18-002 is a request to amend the regulations for cannabis retailer businesses. The proposed amendments include removal of the ground floor use restriction for cannabis retailers within Table 17.24.020, removal of the restriction that cannabis goods not be visible from outside the premises,
3:43:55 And clarify that cannabis retailers on the ground floor are required to adhere to the commercial business transparency requirements. The First Amendment removes the ground floor use restriction. The reasoning behind this is that with the use restriction, there is limited retail areas where a cannabis retailer could be located. An analysis of all the existing structures that are on eligible parcels adjacent to active frontages indicated that there are only two structures that meet all of the location requirements.
3:44:26 Without the ground floor use restriction, additional retail space becomes available but still remains relatively low due to the other location constraints including the buffers from sensitive use requirements, separation between cannabis retailers, and existing uses on those parcels that preclude a cannabis retailer from locating there.
3:44:46 Additional reasons include these businesses are now classified as a retail use that is open to all persons 21 years of age and older and are not any longer a service use that is closed to the public and only provides services to those who are members. The second proposed amendment removes the restriction that cannabis goods not be visible from outside the premises. The existing regulations require there be some sort of obstruction to obscure views into the premises. This was previously a state requirement.
3:45:18 The state requirements were amended in June 2018 to no longer require this. Additionally, this is not consistent with the town's transparency requirements for ground floor businesses, which encourage visibility into the business and enhance the pedestrian environment. Additionally, with the state's packaging requirements for cannabis, all cannabis goods are required to come prepackaged, and there's no longer raw cannabis being handled.
3:45:46 Within the shops and the products more closely resemble ordinary retail products. And the third proposed amendment addresses transparency requirements and makes a reference to the town's existing commercial business transparency regulations that specify what types of window coverings are permissible. Additionally, this regulation addresses potential security cages or roll-down cages that might be installed and gives the director the design review authority over the design of any such security cage.
3:46:20 With that, that is a summary of the proposed amendments to the regulations. Staff has determined that the required findings for the zoning code amendment can be made and are recommending approval of this zoning code amendment. Okay, you're done. Thank you very much. I will go ahead and take questions from the council at this time. I have a technical question. I have a question around
3:46:54 Yes, so the
3:47:23 Restriction for ground floor is really something that was unique to Mammoth and that was really a carryover from when it was a medicinal businesses only since they were essentially not open to any walk-in plant. But didn't we have a ground floor dispensary? That came in in 2010, which was prior to the ground floor use restrictions were included in the zoning code update. They weren't specific to cannabis businesses.
3:47:51 That restriction applied to other kind of service type uses, so doctor's offices, physical therapy offices, as well as medical cannabis dispensaries. Okay, so now having it on, allowed to be on ground floor is sort of, it's retail, so it's retail and that's what it is? Correct. Okay, thanks. Mr. Stapp, any questions? So, you want to go ahead and do that now? I have questions for staff. So, this,
3:48:22 We will be consistent with state regulations. Correct. The state in June removed that restriction that cannabis products not be visible from outside the premises. Okay. And the recommendation on the Planning Commission, what was the vote? Any comments on the Planning Commission? The Planning Commission vote was 3-0. Two of the commissioners were absent. Okay. Thank you. Is there some additional language, I'm trying to remember back, on...
3:48:50 And so a lot of that more comes with how the products, the appearance of them, what types of products they are so that they, you know, discourage,
3:49:21 Products to appear like cartoon characters or animals, as well as the packaging requirements that require when it leaves the premises to be in an opaque package that's nondescript, as well as the packaging itself is intended not to be attractive to youth. And is that still in our code? That is still in our code, yes. Okay, so these are just excerpts that we're changing. I can remember the whole thing, but that's all covered still. Okay.
3:49:45 And following up on that, I also had a question about that. You know, I've heard vaping problems. I know that over the years, cigarettes have been moved behind counters. They're not in the eyesight for kids. And this is kind of a two-pronged thing that I'm sure we'll get some answers to as well. But that was my question that it seems to me most packaging that you see in a window.
3:50:14 That type is either going to have cannabis, a marijuana leaf, it's going to have marijuana on it. There's not a lot of items that don't have something that lets you know on there that it's got pot in it. And I do worry about the message that we are sending to the kids. We're hiding some things from them, but all of a sudden this is going to be, and that also goes with, I want to correct,
3:50:44 Find this from one of you fellas. Is it a law that I understand to, and I have two minds of this, the opaque windows. So what you're saying is that people need to be able to see into that business, whether it is open or whether it's closed, they need to be able to see into the shop and what, see what they sell there or
3:51:14 Is there any reason legally that we can't have opaque windows or some type of opaque window, like partially half of it or something like that? So let Andy address the legal standpoint. I mean, there's no legal reason why you couldn't mandate that. I mean, even though the state has kind of tinkered with it, it hasn't taken away the town's ability to decide whether to require or prohibit opaque windows.
3:51:48 Okay. Although in our retail ordinance, we request or require clear windows for the streetwalker, right? That probably was the wrong word. Yeah. Not streetwalkers. Right. I mean, the customer on the street. We might have to do a little tweaking of the code, but there's nothing in state law that prohibits it. Right. So, I mean, you can get to whatever outcome you want about opacity of windows. It's just a question of what we need to do to get there.
3:52:17 And so the commercial business section does have an allowance if it's like a window display area. It has a minimum depth in that has to be open for a display if you are going to have, you know, some businesses want to have shelves all the way along their walls. They have concerns that, you know, if they have to have windows along their whole frontage, how that impacts them. So there is a code section that I believe it's four feet in or six feet in is the depth that that display has to be.
3:52:48 You still get that perception that you're seeing into this active retail use, whether it's cannabis or a liquor store or a supermarket. Oh, okay. You know what? I think we'll just go ahead. Does anybody else have any questions at this time? Because I think we'll just go ahead and move to the portion, the applicant, if you would like to present or comment. Oh, okay. There you are.
3:53:18 Good evening. I'm Robert Calvert. I've been working in the cannabis industry in the town of Mammoth Lakes since 2010. I was awarded the first permit for Mammoth Lakes Wellness. And so just a couple of comments. I mean, my goal here is to really remove a lot of the stigma that cannabis is something that we shouldn't be using for ourselves or for our loved ones or our family or anything like that.
3:53:47 The cannabis industry has changed tremendously in the last eight years since I've been involved in it, and I do have some photos of some other, I should have printed some things up here, but I'm also working with a company down in the industrial park that's doing wholesale. So I'm working on the retail end, I'm working on the wholesale end, I'm knee deep in this industry, and the products that are coming out these days are very professionally packaged.
3:54:15 I don't see marijuana leaves on them. I see very, I mean, it almost looks like a lot of the vape pens and a lot of the edibles. I mean, these companies are putting a lot of thought and a lot of marketing and a lot of design into their packaging products. It's a very professional industry these days. So I disagree with what you're saying, Cleland, about packaging products that have marijuana leaves. I haven't seen any of them that actually have that.
3:54:45 So, and the idea is that we're trying to bring the customers in from the outside. And I can tell you with operating Mammoth Lakes Wellness for eight years, it was very, very, very, very, very hard to get people to come in. There was this perceived curiosity and it's like, oh no, we can't go in there because it's got the fogged out windows. My number one concern with having the fogged out windows is a security concern.
3:55:15 The retail floor on the inside and it's fogged out from the outside and something's going on in the inside. Somebody's hidden. Now they're hidden. Now they can do whatever they want to do on the inside. I'm also concerned about making this a successful business. I had to close MLW because it was losing money. And there's this perception that we're just rolling in the dough. It wasn't happening. I was losing money. And I openly expressed that during public forums here many, many times.
3:55:45 So this is my second chance to try and open a retail store in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I appreciate the opportunity that the town has given me, and I believe that I have proven myself to a very professional level. Everything that I've done has been by the code to the T on a professional level. And what we're trying to do with our new location is create a very comfortable and inviting environment where people can come in and get educated.
3:56:14 On the products because there is a lot of curiosity out there. So we want to have educated staff that can help provide answers to the people, the customers that are interested in now using cannabis products. And there isn't a day that goes by that you're not reading about it in the news. So I would very much support and I am in favor of having our store visible from the customer that's walking by.
3:56:45 When we're closed in the evening, we're still going to have it lit up. We're going to have a security curtain in front of the windows, which I've already talked with the town staff about, and we've gotten their support. I've talked with Chief Al Davis about it, and we're going to have a couple further discussions before we order the final product for the security. It's kind of like a mall. When the mall stores close, they bring down those steel curtains. So we're looking to have something across that in the evening.
3:57:15 So that's really it. I'm working hard at this. I want this to be a success. I want this to be a good thing for our community and the tourists that come here to enjoy themselves. And I'm happy to answer any questions. Any questions for Mr. Calvert? Any comments? Any public comment or question at this point? Okay. Thank you. I guess there's no rebuttal since there's nothing. Thank you, Robert.
3:57:47 Staff, let's see. Now, do you have any questions of staff? Okay. I am going to, I guess, formally close the public hearing, and then now I'm going to ask for deliberation and comments from the Town Council. Kirk, do you have any comments or anything you'd like to say? I support the recommendation. Okay. Okay. Any questions or comments? No, I support the recommendation. I think that
3:58:19 As in the world of the tobacco industry, when, you know, if things rise to a level of concern, the state and or the federal government will likely start doing things like you got to do restrict this, you got to put stuff behind count, you know, you have to do all that kind of stuff. And I, you know, I think we're where we're at with the regulatory environment of the state. This is consistent with that. I think the applicants point about we want, you know, this is a legal activity.
3:58:48 In the state. And I think the community has an interest in getting a competitive cannabis, marijuana industry in this town. So I'm supportive.
3:59:00 Nope. If everyone's ready, I'll make the motion. Nope. Here, I've got some things that I would like to say. There are a couple of things that do worry me about this. Number one, I think, and I'm not speaking for anyone on Town Council, I am the most 420-friendly person up here. I can tell you right now, a store that people could see me going in and out of, you're not going to see me in there because...
3:59:27 It's the same thing, I remember I saw a school teacher on break smoking a cigarette when I was young. I was crushed. I thought teachers were infallible. I didn't know that they could have habits like that. I fully support cannabis. Cannabis business is in town. However, having opaque, having windows that you can see through, I don't see that so much as a safety.
3:59:50 I think that people have their ideas about marijuana and if you can, whether you can see through the window or not, that could actually in a way backfire. I am hearing things different from my cohorts, so that's fine, but I want to put that out there. I do think that we are being a little bit unfair to our kids because
4:00:15 Even though it is legal, so is alcohol, so are cigarettes, and the trend has been throughout the years to make it less of an impact for them. Like I said, I hear that vaping is a problem. I'm not even sure what a vape pen looks like or if I can tell if it's a cigarette vape or another vape. I do think that you'll have some issues with that, but if I'm the only one that that's a concern.
4:00:45 I do think that it should be on the first floor. I think it's ridiculous that that is something that we're even addressing right now, especially since it was medical before. People in wheelchairs have got to have access to cannabis retailers, so I absolutely believe in that.
4:01:08 Another thing I would have to say, you have product in the window, probably not a business I would go to because marijuana should be kept in a nice, dark, safe little place. It doesn't need to be exposed to any kind of sun. I see where you're kind of getting at with the making it, trying to make it just okay for everybody, but at the other...
4:01:35 Adults can make that decision for themselves at 18 if they want to be seen in the store or not. And the other thing that I have to say, looking through these maps, we never as a town council, and I'm not sure if the planning commission came back with this, but when we were deciding how many retailers we were going to have in this town, it was kind of the
4:02:02 The 250, the 500, the 600 feet, those barriers actually were going to limit the amount of pot shops that we can have here in town. I'm a little bit worried with this. Are we creating so that we can now potentially even have four dispensaries in a town of 8,000 people? That was one thing that I was not able to tell.
4:02:33 And can either? Pardon? If you haven't had a question, then no one will address these. Oh, okay. So you can answer? Okay. So that question, yeah, the transparency. And then, so I guess those are the only two that I would be asking for that information. Oh.
4:03:05 The other thing that we have going on, going back to the kids, are we going to protect our kids or are we not? Because some of these areas, including the store that we do have in town right now, does go within the parcel. There has been talk of perhaps child care being on there or a park.
4:03:35 So here on the screen, this is the map that... Yeah.
4:04:05 Shown in the discussions when we were talking about the buffers and the separation requirements. So this one here shows 600 feet from schools, daycare centers, and public parks, and what 500 feet between cannabis retailers look like. So the existing one that's in operation is right here at 94 Laurel Mountain Road. There is an approved use permit that is contingent on the zoning code amendment in the same center where Mammoth Lakes Wellness previously was.
4:04:34 So as discussed back in March, these buffers do create the ability for some additional shops to come into or to find a location. It is up to those businesses to find a suitable location. Thus far, they have had trouble finding leases or property. Realistically, there's probably room for one additional shop based on the areas out there. If you do look at the map, there is potential
4:05:03 Something, you know, in this block here, these areas here on Laurel Mountain on the southern portion are outside of all the buffers and separation requirements. And there is a small area here on Oak Tree Way. However, when you look at what's there, you have a church, you have a design center, and you have a vacant parcel on the very back. And same with on Laurel Mountain Road.
4:05:28 You have all condos or apartments with the exception of the kind of office building here where the body shop gym is. So none of those really change with it being a ground floor or not. They still really have the same limitations to find any suitable space there. And then the second item when you talked about the parcel. So those buffers and distance requirements are
4:05:59 Okay. And then I had another question. I think...
4:06:22 What was my first question about? Okay. You know what? Going back there, and this is, I mean, I'm thinking this through because this could be me going into this store. And if I had a kid that I could see, if you do have where people can see through the window, dimes to donuts, people are going to leave their child in the car because they can't take their child into the store. They're going to say, well, I can see my child. And that's going to give them a false sense of security that
4:06:51 Children will get left in cars. People will go into there because they can't take kids. If you're going to be leaving kids out on the sidewalk, I think that keeping it something that is low key is actually going to make so people will like, well, okay, I'll get a babysitter because I'm going to go to a store where I can't take my kid. Whereas you can take your kid to any kind of liquor store, any kind of other shop other than even though this is a retail shop.
4:07:18 As far as I know, you can't have anyone under 21 in that shop. So when they walk into the shop, do they get carded when they walk into the shop? Can you bring underage kids into it? How does that work? So the design of all the shops that I've seen, you know, it's not like it's a key card at the door. You walk in, there's a reception or waiting area. Within that, that's kind of separate from then the retail premises that have where you're going to.
4:07:46 Verify your age with someone at that county before you can enter the retail area. As far as if parents leave their kids, that's the same as bars, other establishments that are 21 and over that restrict who can enter the premises. I don't think opaque windows, that stuff would really address that, whether parents are going to leave their kids in a car or not. Well, there are time limits for...
4:08:12 And one thing I do want to say is I look forward to this because I do think that we need to have competition in this market. I don't appreciate a monopoly, and I think that this will definitely help that.
4:08:41 Obviously, but I think maybe we're not really taking the long view on this with some of the, and like I said, I'm very supportive of this, but I'm not supportive of kids having a lot of access or even being that savvy about, oh, that's the pot shop. That just, I guess, is just my item. So if there are no other comments or
4:09:08 I'll just go ahead and let Bill go ahead and make a motion. You know, I will say that regardless of what my position is on these shops, we made them legal. And to make them commit to rules that other businesses don't have to, this just levels the playing field. I don't believe that liquor stores that display liquor cause alcoholism. I don't believe that pot shops that show a product in the window are going to create child usage.
4:09:38 That is societal issues, not store issues. So with that, I would like to make the motion to waive the first reading and introduce by title only the ordinance making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving zoning amendment 18-002 as recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission as well. Yeah, that's it. I'm done. I'll second that. Okay.
4:10:05 Wait a minute. I need to make one more question that I had. So I want to make sure that in doing this that we are not making the shop, not making it a rule that it has to be. I think that the owner of the business, if we have another permit coming in, they should have the option of making opaque windows if they want to. So in other words, I couldn't really tell from this on the background information. I want to make sure that that is something that...
4:10:33 They have an option with the opaqueness. So the opaqueness is only applicable to those that are on ground floor. In the active reference to the code, I believe it's only for those on ground floor along active frontages is when that applies to. So if they're not located adjacent to active frontage or if they're on a second floor, then they could have opaque windows. I'm sorry.
4:11:08 So there's a certain streets that are defined as active frontage. That's the whole idea of the active retail. So if that business is on that active frontage, then they would be precluded from having opaque windows. If they're off of that, like I believe part of Laurel Mountain is not an active frontage, there they could have an opaque window. Or if they were in the back of the building and not actively on the street, I believe they could have. So if you walked into a building that had multiple businesses, they could have an opaque window. But if they're on that active frontage, then it would have to be clear.
4:11:38 Okay, and so... That goes with all retail on the active frontage, so it's a... So pretty much this is a no-brainer, then, if you're looking at the map, you have one place already in business, one that's well into the permitting, one will have opaque windows, one doesn't need it. The spaces that you mentioned earlier that do have a little bit of wiggle room, considering if the people would rent them out, lease them out.
4:12:03 on Old Mammoth Road or Oak Tree or any of those locations, will they have the option of doing opaque or non-opaque and will they also have to do the gates? No, so the gates are optional. Okay, gates are optional. If they're located on Old Mammoth Road on the ground floor right adjacent to Old Mammoth Road, the windows cannot be opaque. They can have kind of a window display area that
4:12:32 I looked at it. It has to have a minimum depth of three feet in so they could have essentially a window box that has whatever displays they want. It can't have the words cannabis or marijuana or leaves or anything attractive to youth. That is an option that businesses along the ground floor could do. Okay. Thank you, then. We'll continue. I'll go ahead and take a roll call, please. Council Member Salcido? Yes. Council Member Staff?
4:12:59 Yes. Councilmember Woodward? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Sauser? Yes. Mayor Hoff? Yes. It passes 5-0. Thank you very much. And with that, I will go ahead and you did catch the second on that one. Okay, good. Okay. So the public hearing is over. We are going to go ahead and move on to item 12, contract with Mammoth Lakes Housing.
4:13:32 And we did get an additional handout for Town Council people if you weren't sitting at your, this is where it comes in. Yeah, and just to note that that handout is the red line version that Mammoth Lakes Housing Board.
4:13:51 So there was a handful of red line items in there that the town is agreeable to. And there's also a couple copies in the back for any members of the public who would like to take a look at that.
4:14:06 So just to briefly discuss this item at your joint meeting with the Board of Mammoth Lakes Housing on September 10th, the group discussed the future contract for Mammoth Lakes Housing and during that discussion there was agreement to move forward with a contract that basically captures the things that Mammoth Lakes Housing is currently doing with the addition of monitoring deed restricted units for the town. So right now there's
4:14:35 There's a number of different deed restrictions. Some Mammoth Lakes Housing is a party too. Some Mammoth Lakes Housing is not a party too. And so the town is looking to take those deed restricted units that just the town is a party too and have Mammoth Lakes Housing do that deed restriction monitoring for the town. So that I see is the biggest.
4:14:56 Difference in this contract based on what they're currently doing and what we're looking to ask them to do. There is also a requirement for them to participate in a GIS database. So this is really working with the town to create a GIS database of housing-related items so that we can kind of have more data as we look to future housing programs and projects.
4:15:22 And with that, we provided, like I said, we provided the draft contract to you in your packet, and then these are just the minor red lines that were approved by the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board on Monday night. And I'm happy to answer any questions that you have on this item. Yes. What's the status of the town's deed restriction? I mean, are they up to date, or are we going to have to go back and dig into them to get them in compliance?
4:15:53 So our thought is that we haven't been actively monitoring those deed-restricted units, so there is going to be a transition period. So I don't think that when this contract is executed, we're just going to hand you a box of old deed-restricted units. This is really going to be a transition where town staff is going to go through, take a look at those, and kind of transition those over to Mammoth Lakes Housing. So we're not going to just...
4:16:21 Lump it all on you. I realize that, but somebody that has rented something and the deed restriction has not been enforced is going to be a huge issue. And it'll probably take, I would think, the town attorney and a whole bunch of legal. I'm just saying that this addition to the contract is going to take a long time.
4:16:49 One at a time to get them into compliance. How many units are we talking about? How many units are we talking about? I think it's around 80 units. Oh, wow. Yeah, so the idea on that would be the town obligation to get them in a manner that are cleaned up enough to have MLH manage them going forward. The expectation, I don't believe, is to ask MLH to go spend that legal time and services to...
4:17:16 Clean them up. I think that's on the town. So we actually give a deed restriction that is manageable versus not. And let's be clear, what we're talking about when we say clean them up, and we can't unilaterally change any deed restrictions? No, that's not what I'm talking about. The fact is that some of the developers that was a requirement on them, the fact is that they have rented to
4:17:42 Workers, whoever, and they have ignored the deed restrictions. So, I mean, the deed restrictions are a constant monitoring issue. And if we let it slide, then we've got an issue that we're going to have to work our way through, and that's going to probably take some of your time, too, and knock them off one at a time. And I just wanted to make sure that everybody understands, when we're talking about this contract,
4:18:10 I mean, trying to get these into, by the way, I completely agree we need one organization to be monitoring all these things so we don't lose units. Right now I'm speculating, with a great deal of confidence, by the way, that we've lost a lot of these units because they haven't been monitored. So are these people qualified to be in them at 100% AMI or whatever level it is?
4:18:40 I will pass these out to Council.
4:19:10 These are just... Kirk, I'm sorry to interrupt, but I just want to make sure that we're asking questions of staff because I want to make sure we deliberate at the appropriate time. Yeah, and I'm just giving out a piece of information and I will discuss this too. This is another thing that will impact the work program for this contract. So as these things come forward, this contract is going to be in flux.
4:19:36 It's going to be, as we say, okay, we want them to reach out and work with the chamber on reaching out. This is staff time. And so I support the contract as it is, but I wanted to make sure that people understood with the housing summit, with the housing action plan, with trying to get up to speed on these deed restrictions. These are going to be big workloads.
4:20:06 And I think, but just from, in terms of the question to staff, it's a scalable agreement, meaning that if additional work is needed or additional resources are needed, technically, this agreement can scale to accommodate those needs, provided that there's money and staffing to support it. Well, the contrast- It's a scalable agreement. Again, I- I'd say it's a scalable- Excuse me, just, Madam Mayor, in terms of where we're at, in terms of this item, I mean, I want to have a deliberation, but I think that the way we need to do this is technical questions to staff.
4:20:36 And then public comment or whatever, and then get into deliberation. And I want to deliberate if we need to, but I don't want to be getting into deliberation before we're at that point in terms of the agenda item. So I look to you for some guidance on that. Okay, everybody take a deep breath. And I, yes, if we could just keep to the technical questions right now. We will let people in the public speak on this as well.
4:21:04 And I also have a technical question. I did watch part of the meeting, so I have a technical question as well, and I believe Linda has one too. So before we get two down one road... The question that I have is this document that you just handed me, Kirk. It doesn't have a date. It doesn't say what it is, that it was something... This is generated by you based on... No, this is generated by Jennifer Halfordji about a year and a half ago.
4:21:31 Right after the housing action plan was adopted. She was very interested in
4:21:37 And providing and to doing these things. I'm sorry. I need to go to council here. This is not something that was in the packet. I mean, I don't understand what's going on here. So if we could get some clarification, that would be helpful. Okay. I'm going to clarify things right now. If we are talking about this handout that we got today. No, we're talking about one that I only have here. Okay. This is something. I don't have the paperwork. I prefer not to have something that I don't have the paperwork on. Well, that's what I'm trying to say is that I have this document now that you gave me that doesn't say where it came from.
4:22:06 Other than it was based on, I don't feel comfortable passing this out. That's fine. That's fine. I mean, it's a public document, so I'll give it to Jamie.
4:22:22 Okay, so I just want to state for pretty much for anybody who is ever bringing anything at the last minute for us to be able to read through it in the time that we have, it's not going to happen. So I don't even know what is in here. I'm not sure what they're talking about. So if we could just go to some questions that we do have in the packet, that would be very helpful.
4:22:42 I'm going to start with my question. I did watch the MLH meeting the other night, most of it, and I did notice that when they were talking about the contract, the question came up with MLH, maybe you can answer this, if the contract had not been seen by MLH attorney, and where did you guys end up on that one? Yeah, so the attorney has the draft contract.
4:23:10 And so we're just waiting for his comments to come back. The board agreed that they would approve the contract with the attorney's comments, and town staff has drafted your recommended action item in that way so that we can finalize any small comments from both the attorneys. I will have some suggested edits, too, just meant to clarify things. Nothing that MLH will find objectionable, but there's a little bit of cleanup work to be done, I think.
4:23:38 Okay. Since there is, when you say a little bit of cleanup work, is there any way that the attorney is going to come back for MLH and also have some cleanup language in there? Well, I mean, from what Patricia is saying, I imagine it's going to be technical sort of lawyer stuff that only lawyers care about that we're just trying to get it clean as best we can. I wouldn't think that there's anything substantive enough that it would have to go back to the council or the MLH board, but, I mean,
4:24:06 I look forward to talking to MLH's attorney. So we're being asked to approve a contract that has not yet been approved by your attorney? Well, if I could a little bit. The MLH, there was a good discussion about this on Monday night, and the red line items in here are of not, we're seeing them here.
4:24:28 There's no one's under any obligation to sign anything unless a lawyer looks at it. So I think to Andy's point, the representation from MLH staff and from staff here is there are minor things in here. I think if the council were to, as part of our deliberation, were to say there's something really fundamentally objectionable, that would have to go back for redrafting. But the MLH board was comfortable with this red line document as presented.
4:24:52 So it's up to us right now. If we wanted to change something in this thing that was substantial, then folks would have to go back to the drawing boards. Are we still questioning or are we deliberating? I'm trying to get back to it. I'm confused. I understand. I was just trying to clarify a question. Well, let's keep, yeah, okay. So let's have, I guess, well, you were on, that's kind of hard. That really should come with you. But you were comfortable with that from an MLH.
4:25:19 Point of view that the attorney hasn't technically signed off on this. Okay. Kirk, did you have another question? No, I provided this because the last time I put it in people's boxes, I was accused of doing a Brown Act violation. Oh, okay. That's why I brought it to the council. Bill, do you have any questions? No, I have questions for deliberation, I believe, is where they belong. The only thing that stuck out at me was,
4:25:50 We removed monthly and put it in periodic. What do we mean by periodic? I don't even understand the change. I'm assuming that you'll still have regular meetings, that we're not going to have staff run the thing and then have a bobbing head board. If I can, on that one, the question was, sometimes if you don't have a quorum or you don't have an item, you don't do a monthly meeting. Right. So requiring one that doesn't happen isn't.
4:26:18 Appropriate. The idea was periodic. They'll meet as they need to as a board. It could be multiple times in a month or not. Yeah, as long as it doesn't lead to non-regular. Yeah, they have that set up that way. This is really an important thing on our calendar and important that they meet probably more than monthly. I wouldn't have used monthly either, but I would have put regular or something. Periodic just jumped out at me for some reason. Thank you for that.
4:26:46 So any more questions for staff or for Patricia at this moment? Okay, then I'll go ahead and anybody in the audience wishing to make a comment or have a question on this, please feel free to come forward. My name is Mark Davis and I've lived in this community for three and a half decades. This is a very critical issue. It does seem like it's a bit complicated.
4:27:17 Mammoth Lakes Housing has done a good job when they have been given the tools in the past. They have a good track record. I hope you will renew their contract, and honestly, I don't see why we should base the contract on what's not been happening in the past five or six years, and they need more money. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Anybody else in the public with a comment?
4:27:46 Okay. Seth, did you want to respond to any of the questions that were raised? I just want to address Councilmember Salcido's question. Certainly, if you're not comfortable with leaving a relatively small bit of drafting to MLH's attorney and to me, we could certainly bring this back to Council once it's fully baked, if you like, or you can approve it tonight subject to a little bit of further drafting. Well, I think that's, I mean,
4:28:16 It's a fair question, and I guess the answer is that
4:28:48 I would hope that you would trust that I and the rest of your staff and that the MLH staff wouldn't do that to you. Thank you. Only because I would feel errant if I didn't ask the question. You've answered it. Thank you. No more public comments at this time. We'll go ahead and ask for deliberation. Would anyone like to kick that off? I'd love to pick up where Linda was. While I do trust town staff, is there a downside to
4:29:19 Holding the vote off on this until we have a finished product. And I would just say to that, the MLH board, they had the same document. And after lengthy discussion, public comment, all the rest of it, the board was comfortable with the same document being presented to us. And I don't, I would have looked to MLH if the board had a significant objection, we would not be here this evening. They would have said, we got a problem with this, we're going to pull it.
4:29:48 They're happy with it. I'm a member of the board, so I guess we are happy with it. And I think that I'm satisfied that the types of things that are being talked about don't rise to the level of your concern. I very much appreciate your question. It's a legitimate one and well phrased and well asked. And I think that, from my perspective, the preponderance of the need.
4:30:07 For this community to get MLH under a contract that they can work with, that's scalable, that can, if additional tasks need to be added to it, that can be done in a readily and efficient way. I think that the need of the community to move forward with this outweighs the need to do some cleanup and errata type work with the agreement. So I'm comfortable with it based on what happened at the MLH board meeting, what's happening here, I'm comfortable moving forward with it.
4:30:30 And I would have to say I agree after watching that meeting. I felt that the board was very comfortable with this. And if the roles were reversed, I would probably have an issue with it. But since the board was fine with it, I don't have any problems with that.
4:30:54 So we're still deliberating. Bill, do you have anything to say about this? No, I would ask for it to wait and come back if we were having the meeting on the 21st, but we are not. No reason, I think, to push this off until December. With that being said, would you like to read this or do you want me to? Hold on one second. I just want to make sure that there's no more deliberation from this side of the table.
4:31:16 Yeah, sooner or later there has to be a discussion between Mammoth Lake Housing Board and the Town Council as to Measure 2002A and how that money, I recognize that there's 1% of TOT that is supposed to be dedicated to housing and that was a consensus of the community, you know, it was not a, what I'm trying to get at is I recognize
4:31:45 The parcel and the funding that needs there. But, I mean, there's also this issue of we don't want to lose deed restrictions. We now have the revolving loan fund so we don't lose that. Just to give you guys some information, there's a unit out there that might be coming forward and we're going to have to use both revolving loan funds, not only the county but the towns. So it's a $350,000.
4:32:13 Piece of Property. And so, you know, using the revolving loan fund, which the town has, and then repaying that. So there's a, there's a,
4:32:25 There needs to be a bigger discussion than the contract, and that's all I'm suggesting. I support the contract. I think there's minor tweaks that will come back, and I don't know if we want to agendize it a second time. We can approve it with recognizing that both attorneys will take a look at it, and if necessary, they'll bring it back for another ratification. Yeah, I think it's, again, I think it's in the community's interest.
4:32:50 To get this thing done, and I think we talked earlier this evening that we're going to be talking about this at a priority session on the 19th. Council's going to have, I mean, staff's going to be giving us an agendized opportunity on the 5th, and I think it's just, it's a great opportunity to get this contract in place, get it on the books, everybody knows what we're doing, and then we can move forward and get to those larger discussion, Kirk, that you're talking about on future agenda items, which is needed. We need to have those things, and that's an opportunity for December 5th, even the 19th.
4:33:20 And so I'm personally willing to make a motion right now to move this thing forward and let's get MLH a contract. Well, if everybody's done deliberating and no more information from staff, I will entertain a motion. Okay. So, Bill, go ahead. My motion is that we authorize a professional services agreement with Mammoth Lakes Housing subject to town attorney's approval and pending finalization of the agreement with Mammoth Lakes Housing for housing-related services.
4:33:49 Reflecting the scope of work as shown in Exhibit A of the agreement for any agreement. Any reason to go into the monthly amount? That's it. Period. Just a note that it's Exhibit A as presented this evening or as amended via MLH. Right. Oh, thank you. It's the amended Exhibit A. Oh, okay. Thank you. I'll second. Thank you. A roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes.
4:34:22 Yes. Yes. Passes 5-0. Now we will go ahead and move on to agenda item 13. Madam Mayor, if I could, I'd just like to make a point of order about documents coming into agenda items. If staff, can we have this agendized as a future item? Because it's enormously disruptive. It creates a lot of chaos up here in the dais. And I'm just hoping for all of us, we get some clarity of how that works. And if you've got a dispute with the town attorney, I'd like to know, I think we need to know what that is.
4:34:52 Just so that we cannot have things coming in here that are disruptive and kind of break our flow and our ability to have productive meetings. I applaud you. I mean, I don't know how to get information to you. I can't put it in your box because the last time I put it in the box, I was accused of a brown act. No problem. Let's agendize that for a future thing and have a discussion about it so we can get this figured out. Yeah, I absolutely agree. Okay. Me too. So we'll have a discussion about that. Thank you.
4:35:19 Okay, moving on to agenda item 13, authorization to transfer property from the town of Mammoth Lakes to Mono County within the Civic Center site. Yes, Madam Mayor. Item before you is follow up and working through the potential transfer of property owned by the town to Mammoth to Mono County. The item really looks at a couple of different very specific parcels to be transferred
4:35:49 I won't go through all the detail in the staff report with the legal descriptions, but the one, the exhibit B, which is a map that's in your packet, refers to the Mono County Civic Center parcel. That would be transferred in fee, and there's a process to do that. And then parcel A3 is a transfer property that references areas that would be used for access and parking that would also be transferred.
4:36:15 Along with that, parcel A3 or the parking and access component, there would ultimately be an IOD, that's an irrevocable offer of dedication back to the town for road purposes. So we're recommending that those be approved. In order to finalize the parcel 3, we will ultimately need to have a termination of the easement agreement, and that needs to be signed off by the town and the hospital district. But not until after the bonds are issued. Right.
4:36:45 Yeah, that can follow that process. But that will need to be signed off as well. So we're asking for authority to process those things accordingly to actually effectuate the actual transfer that the proposed deeds that are attached to the staff report allow us to move forward. To add to the last one, we are asking that if we have any final legal or engineering review of this. This actually came together pretty quickly.
4:37:14 Bond Council did a lot of work on it. Andy picked up a couple of typographical errors, if I may, from that process. And so one additional reading probably doesn't hurt us is to make sure we have the right terminology. I think it was a transferee versus an assignee or something simple of that nature that we had to pick up because of the changes that were going through this process. The other items on the agenda will relate to this. We need to actually, the property that is involved,
4:37:42 Was utilized to secure our debt financing for the police station. Separate items will need to actually release that properties that are being transferred from that debt portion where this was used as collateral for our debt. And I'll speak to that more in the next item. But the first step here to be authorized the various deeds to be signed off by staff to effectuate this transfer.
4:38:10 As we move forward in partnership with the county for them to proceed with their construction of the South County offices. I believe the county actually was meeting in San Francisco today, I believe, looking at their bond rating process with S&P and I'm not sure if it's just S&P or Moody's, whoever else, but anyway, they're actively going through that process and this will be necessary to effectuate the transfer of property and for their debt security.
4:38:38 I can answer other technical questions on this. I think it's the map probably is the most to look at that. Those are the two parcels you're authorizing to transfer and then ultimately an offer of dedication for road purposes for the future. At this time, do we have any questions for staff? Just the language in the recommended motion, is that sufficient to cover any legal concerns between both parties prior to anybody signing anything? Yes. Subject to finding legal and sharing your view.
4:39:10 I am nodding my head, sagely. Okay, sagely. Okay, do we have any, well, no, actually, we're not, we're going to go to public comment first. Okay, no public comment. So now you answered the question that was raised. Council deliberation or questions, comments?
4:39:43 Please. I've been reading all night. Sure. Okay. Madam Mayor, I would move that the Town Council authorize the Town Manager to sign required grant deed documents for the transfer of property from the Town of Mammoth Lakes to Mono County and the irrevocable offer of dedication of easement for road purposes subject to final legal and engineering review. Portion of APN number 035-010-064-000. Second. Okay. Roll call, please.
4:40:15 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We will now move on to item 14, resolution of the town of Mammoth Lakes amending certain lease financing documents dated August 1, 2015. Thank you, Madam Mayor. The item here relates to, again, the transfer of property between the town and
4:40:48 The action here takes certain properties that were utilized to collateralize the town's debt, which was referenced in the financing documents that were approved back in August of 2015. The release of the property includes the parcels being transferred to the county and two small remainder parcels referenced as parcel A1 and parcel A2. Together they total about 10,000 square feet.
4:41:17 All of that would come, the two parcels going to the county and those two remainder parcels would come out of the land that collateralized the loan for the police department. This has included a number of amendments to the lease agreements. We have had confirmation from BBVA Compass, a bank that has basically in their credit partners who own the debt, if you will, to release that property for these purposes. The finalized construction of the
4:41:47 Police station itself more than securitizes the loan, so they're comfortable with that. Police station is now collateralized well for that debt, so they're comfortable with that. And again, this allows us to actually move forward with the transfer of property once it's released from our debt collateralization. My question on that, when you say that they are comfortable... Yeah, they've approved it. They've reviewed the documents and...
4:42:14 We have an email confirmation going. We're fine with the release of the property. You do have confirmation that- From the bank. Okay. Thank you. Questions? Just the same question. Number two in the motion, allow for final legal review of the amended lease financing agreements. I'm just turning to Andy Morris so that you're comfortable that you have the latitude to make sure that things are all done and be done properly.
4:42:36 Yes, I do. I mean, we have, I've gone over this with county council who is, as always, has been extraordinarily helpful and bond council for the town, bond council for the county. And so we've got four lawyers or sets of lawyers who've now agreed that these documents will work. That's no guarantee, but I'll take it for what it's worth. And when this was drafting for the agenda item, you know, some of that question with all the reviews still happening, so.
4:42:59 Okay, I will make a motion. Here, hold on one second. I just need to go to the public. Anybody out there like to bring up anything? Okay. If I can add one other item to this. This is an action at this point by the town. You will have a similar action later on the agenda sitting as a municipal service corp, which is the other side of our transaction. The same documents here will be
4:43:28 Attached to the resolution from the Municipal Services Corporation, but the documents are not reprinted in the agenda. They're the exact same documents that get attached. Okay. Do we have any discussion or comments on this from the Council? Okay, I will, oops. Okay. Now I will move that the Council approve the resolution of the Town of Mammoth Lakes amending certain lease financing documents dated August 1, 2015 to provide for the release of a portion of the real
4:43:59 I second the motion. Okay. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yeah. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And now we are going to... If I may, Madam Mayor.
4:44:31 Is there any reason that we can't convene the, what do we call ourselves, the Municipal Service Corporation Board now, so that when we leave, we can just announce what happened and close and go home? What you'll need to do is adjourn as the Town Council formally, convene as the Municipal Services Corp., and then adjourn as the Municipal Services Corp., reconvene as the Town Council.
4:44:58 It's just a process because you're two separate legal bodies to this process. Okay. So you're saying it's probably easier just to go to closed session and come back? For me, yes. The choreography is less complicated. Okay. Again, I have one moment. I've got a quick comment. Oh, okay. Well, can I go ahead and... Okay. We're not adjourning this meeting. We're just going to do closed session. Right. I was going to see if we could...
4:45:28 They could walk and talk while we went. I know it doesn't, does it? It doesn't look like we can. Okay. Before we adjourn to closed session, Mr. Holler has pointed out that it would be helpful to clarify that what we understand to be the case, which is that Councilmember Salcido recused herself from item nine.
4:46:03 On the consent calendar. On the consent calendar. Yes, absolutely. Yeah, as with all consent items, you were not required to leave the dais, which is fine, and we thought that you'd recused yourself, but we just wanted to confirm that. Yes, thank you. Oh, thank you for clarifying that. With that, we will now go into closed session, and we will come back out and report if there's anything to report. Thank you.
4:46:31 You can't take too much longer. I'm running out of cough drops. Oh, no. I'm running out of life. Oh, no. I was going to do a damage, but I forgot what I was supposed to say. They keep saying that, and it doesn't happen. I was waiting for SCE to tell us the wind was coming, and they were going to turn the electricity off. Did they turn any electricity off? No.
4:47:09 They have in California, several places, yeah. Okay. We're back, boys? Yep. Okay. There was no action taken in closed session. And now we will adjourn the regular meeting for November 7, 2018. We're adjourned. And now we are going to open the meeting.
4:47:39 The Town Council will conduct a Municipal Service Corporation Board of Trustees meeting. And you'll need to do a call to order, and Jamie, do you need a roll call again? Oh, okay. Roll call, please, Jamie. Trustee Salcido? Yes. Trustee Stapp? Yes. Trustee Wentworth? Yes. Trustee Souser? Yes. Trustee Paul? Yes.
4:48:09 All accounted for. Do I need to make a motion on the minutes or ask for? You got public comments? Oh, public comments? Okay, hearing none, I will go ahead and, let's see, we have the minutes of the last trustees meeting, which was October 4th of 2017.
4:48:39 I think the agenda is set up so that you're taking your one policy matter first and the consent agenda is second, but you can take them out of order if you want. Look at the agenda that actually is in your package where it walks through. Copy that. I'm sorry. Okay. So now with policy matters.
4:49:01 Item number one, approve the resolution of the Mammoth Lakes Municipal Service Corporation amending certain lease financing documents dated August 1, 2015 to provide for the release of a portion of the real property of the town of Mammoth Lakes specified therein and authorizing and directing certain actions with respect thereto and allow for final legal review of the amended lease financing agreements.
4:49:26 Thank you, Madam Mayor. This here is the second half of the action that allows you to release property that was used as secure debt for the police station. The resolution and the associated amendment to the documents allows that to no longer be encumbered for the collateralization. It allows for the clear transfer of property between the town and the county for their facilities. The detailed information is provided in the town council packet.
4:49:55 The detail there is the item here is the resolution of the service corp to allow for those transactions to move forward. And just by way of background, the municipal service corporation is kind of a captive financing entity. A lot of cities have them. And the reason that they exist is that in order to do a lease-leaseback transaction, which is the kind of financing that we used for the police station, you have to have somebody to do it with. You can't play ball by yourself. So you have the town, then you have the MSC. That's why you're convening as this other body, and that's what that body is.
4:50:28 Any questions on what actually the Municipal Services Corp is? I should explain that maybe in the front end. I don't have any questions on that either. Any questions, Mr. Saab? So I'm just on the recommended motion. This is just to get the police department paid for. We're borrowing that $300. No, this is, this is. This is, as Dan mentioned during the council meeting, we used some of the land, the McFlex parcel, as collateral for the police department financing.
4:50:58 Because we're now trying to convey some of that land to the county, this is partially unwinding the transaction. It's just slicing out that land so it's no longer collateralized. Thank you. So, Madam Mayor, having the council on a regular session, having reviewed and debated these documents, I'm wondering if it's appropriate to make a motion subject to any public comment, but I'm wondering if that's how we can proceed. Read it. Okay, so I would move that.
4:51:24 The corporation approved the resolution of the Mammoth Lakes Municipal Service Corporation amending certain lease financing documents dated August 1, 2015 to provide for the release of a portion of the real property of the town of Mammoth Lakes specified therein and authorizing and directing certain actions with respect thereto. And two, allow for final legal review of the amended lease financing agreements. Second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yep.
4:51:58 Yes. Passes 5-0. And now on the consent agenda. I'd love to make a motion to approve. Item 2, approve the minutes of the meeting of October 4, 2017. I hear a motion from Mr. Sauser. Second. A second. Roll call, please. Just real quick. There are people who were participating in the meeting who are not on this diocese evening. Is that, how do we deal with that?
4:52:26 There's not actually a rule on that. I mean, some bodies out of custom will have people refrain or accuse themselves from voting on the minutes. It's really just a technicality. Okay, fine. Just a question. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Thanks for asking. Yep. Yes. I didn't participate in this. That's fine. No, that's fine. You can do that. That's no problem. As long as we have a majority. Yeah. And you three participated. So, I mean. I'm trying. Yes.
4:53:01 Yes, motion passes 5-0. No, it doesn't pass 5-0. Excuse me, and excuse me, 4-0 and 1 recusal. With that, we will go ahead and adjourn from this meeting. And our next town council meeting is a special meeting held on Monday, November 19th at 8.30 a.m. Thank you very much.