Town Council
· recording 5 hr 0 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 finding- A December 19, 2018 action sheet said the roughly 4-acre Woods site was listed for sale and in litigation with Mammoth Lakes Tourism Woodsite Resort Residential PUD (Minaret Road)
Transcript
504 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
4:55 Okay, we will go ahead and call the meeting to order for tonight's town council meeting. We did have a closed session meeting. There is nothing to report out on that. Now, I would ask
5:25 Linda Salcido, if you would mind leading us in the pledge. Oh, excuse me. Let's do roll call first. Make sure everybody's here to do it. Yeah, sorry. Here. Here. Yep. Here. And now we'll go to the Pledge of Allegiance. Please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God.
5:56 Indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Now we are to the public comment section of this evening. If you have any items of interest that are not on the agenda, right now is your time to speak up. Good evening, Council, members of the public, staff. Betsy Truax from Mammoth Lakes Foundation.
6:28 And on behalf of Shira Dubrovner of Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater and Mammoth Lakes Film Festival, we wanted to share that three of our films from the Film Festival 2018 lineup were shortlisted for Academy Awards nominations. There are 15. They'll be narrowed down to six. And because we have three of them, we think we have a very good chance. They include On Her Shoulders, which was sponsored by the Mammoth Lakes Women's Club.
6:53 Minding the Gap, and Crime and Punishment. And we'll find out in January if any of them make the final cut, so we're very excited. Also, Barefoot in the Park opens tomorrow, and we'll play for the next three weekends. The set looks fantastic. It's going to be a great show, so go to mammothlakesrepertorytheater.org and get your tickets. Thank you. Thank you. Congratulations. Okay, public comment? Good evening, members of the city council and staff.
7:31 I'm Tom Boo. I'm the Mono County Health Officer, and I thought I should introduce myself, but Lynda Salcido asked me, and I asked Dr. Steve Swisher from the hospital to come and update you a little bit about things that Mono County has been doing to address the opioid epidemic. As everybody knows, there is a nationwide
7:54 Epidemic of opioid addiction and attendant opioid overdose deaths. We've been spared the high rates in the eastern Sierra that some areas of California and certainly the United States have experienced. But we do know that there are people here as everywhere who are at risk. And I believe, we believe, the health department and other county agencies believe that
8:20 That certain evidence-based services should be available to people who are at risk. And Mono County identified addiction and opioids as one of its strategic priorities for 2018, and we have been working on that. So the health department, which I'm a part of, has been working collaboratively with behavioral health, and Robin Roberts is sick today, or she would have been here to join us.
8:47 With the Sheriff's Department, with Mammoth Hospital and other county agencies to make services available. And so what are these services? One is there's a drug called naloxone or the common brand name of Narcan, which is being distributed in communities around the country to rapidly reverse opioid overdose with nasal spray.
9:16 Had the opportunity to apply for a grant of naloxone, an in-kind grant from the state health department, and that grant has been approved and we're waiting for delivery probably sometime in January of a few hundred doses of naloxone, which we will work to distribute in the community without prescription. The state of California passed laws, passed a law a couple of years ago making that possible under a local health officer.
9:45 Standing Order, and there's some training involved, and it'll be a process of implementation, but Behavioral Health has hired a consultant to help us, somebody with a lot of experience in opioid harm reduction, to help us implement the Narcan distribution and training. Another key intervention is what's called medication-assisted treatment. It's recognized, the evidence shows that
10:12 And we've been working with behavioral health and with Mammoth Hospital to make MAT
10:42 And then the...
11:10 The county behavioral health and public health, we want to establish a state health department certified syringe exchange program here in Mammoth, probably with sites both at behavioral health and maybe down the road at public health. Syringe exchange programs are not just proven as an intervention to reduce the risk of
11:37 People who use injection drugs contracting hepatitis B, hepatitis C, and HIV, but also it's a way that agencies like ours can interact with people who are at risk and a chance to offer them services like Narcan, like MAT, and other treatment modalities. And so that application has not been submitted.
12:02 And if it's approved by CDPH, there would be, I believe, a 90-day public comment period. And so I just want to make you aware of that. We think it's an important intervention. And that's most of what I have to say. We're working very closely with Sheriff Ingrid Braun to make sure that anybody who has opioid use disorder who's in the county jail has access to these services as well.
12:30 She has applied for and received. Thanks. Okay. Hey, thank you so much. I've got a few copies. I'm sorry, but I have a few copies of a CDC report on evidence-based strategies for preventing opioid overdose. And it kind of, just more information about the things that we're doing here. I just brought a few copies if anybody. I'd love a copy if that's, or Jamie will take it. Thanks. So Dr. Boo, so nice to meet you. Put a name to a face.
13:06 So I'm Steve Swisher. I'm an emergency physician at Mammoth Hospital. I'm also the treasurer of the district board for Southern Mono Healthcare District. And Tom and I are actually the only two people in Mono County who have the ability to prescribe buprenorphine for opiate addiction. It's something that isn't that common and it's becoming more common. I want to talk about first what the hospital is doing.
13:35 The hospital now has kind of looked at this process and we've developed a commitment to try to get some program going. So if you come to the emergency department, you're addicted, you're in withdrawal, we can start you on this medicine and get you into follow-up treatment. The purpose of getting people onto buprenorphine is actually an opiate, but it decreases your ability to take other opiates and have the rush that you get. And it also lasts for a long time. It prevents withdrawal.
14:05 Taking away the problems of the opiates without giving any of the additional benefits of the opiates. You go from being somebody who's addicted and shaky and vomiting and miserable to somebody who can actually go back to your family, hold a job, get out of legal trouble, become a taxpayer, live longer. Because of all these benefits, because the population in America has been so severely impacted and our actual longevity is decreasing related to this particular epidemic,
14:35 Essentially everybody in all political sides is looking at it. They're looking at it as cost savings. There's less jail time. There's less probation. There's less child custody issues. There's better health. There's people who are in your family or somebody close to you doing better.
14:51 California has a much lower burden and Mammoth Lakes probably has a significantly lower burden than other places in California. But what will happen is if you come in and you go to the emergency department, we will be able to start you on this medicine, get you up to speed within about one day, and then you will be able to continue on this medication first with very close visits and then with ongoing, you know, maybe farther spaced out visits to the point where, you know, you're doing well and you can continue on.
15:19 The success rate for this type of program is about 80 to 85 percent. The success rate for abstinence, such as a Narcotics Anonymous, is about 5 percent. So there's a definite increase in your chance of being successful if you're on this, and this is actually long term, sometimes potentially lifelong, because the receptors in your brain have changed. Alcoholism does a lot better at treatment.
15:42 Thank you so much.
16:09 They got together with me. I'm the lead physician. And we submitted a grant that has been received. If we get this grant at its full funding, we'll have $260,000 to work with over 18 months to help this program go. Do you have any questions? No. Thank you so much. And I'm glad that you guys are going to be morphing into the alcohol abuse as well. Hopefully. Hopefully. Well, I...
16:38 Okay, there you go. Yeah, I do have a question. Approximately how many people are we treating on a monthly basis or an annual basis for this? I mean, I see some of it, but I didn't realize how extensive it is. Currently, we're treating zero. We don't know how many people are here in town who have this. Some people are probably already on buprenorphine, and they're getting it from some other provider someplace else. Other people move here, they're on buprenorphine. Other people are...
17:08 Okay, another public comment.
17:37 Good evening, Council. Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain. I don't know if this is appropriate procedurally, but I would like to request that you pull item 7 in the consent agenda for public comment and discussion. Thanks. Okay. If that is it for public comment, we will go ahead and move on to town council reports. And I'm going to start that off really quickly and just let you know.
18:14 At the Mammoth Lakes Tourism meeting earlier this week, I know some people have asked me about this. There was $250,000 that came from the joint bucket that went to address the winter blitz promotion. We actually, or MLT, ended up, the invoice total was $188,000.
18:39 So we have about 60 some thousand dollars that was not spent and remains in that bucket. So that is what I'm reporting out on. John, I'm going to start with you. I know you've had quite a time. Sure. Thank you very much. I'm going to go through some things I've been doing. I've been traveling a fair bit and then I've got a couple ideas or thoughts for us as a council.
19:07 On December 6th, I was in Sacramento, attended the Sierra Nevada Conservancy Board Meeting. This is on behalf of our Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership. There's money coming through Prop 68 that can help fund an Eastern Sierra Office of Sustainable Recreation and Tourism. That's an ongoing discussion with those folks. The board has approved the grant guidelines, and there is a million dollars set aside for vibrant recreation and tourism, and they're looking at the Eastern Sierra as being probably a pilot project for a statewide effort.
19:35 More to come on that. They'll be considering a proposal at their March 6th board meeting. It's back in Sacramento. Actually, that'll be in Placerville. Then on December 7th, I attended the Integrated Climate Adaptation Resiliency Program Technical Advisory Council. I'm a member of the Technical Advisory Council. This is the Governor's Office of Planning and Research. I have another year on my term. The Governor's Office of Planning and Research, these are all political appointees, so that's all a little chaotic over there. This is also useful because, as you know, the town got a grant through SB1.
20:05 To update our safety element, the general plan, and the folks at OPR in Sacramento are interested in hearing about the specific issues that are coming up in rural communities like ours to help to better inform the framework and the climate change adaptation and resiliency policies coming out of Sacramento. And they don't hear from a lot of small communities like ours because it's very expensive to do it. We got a nice grant from SB1 to make that happen, so that was interesting. I was then in Washington, D.C.
20:32 On behalf of the Recreation Partnership, I won't go into too many details in these meetings, but if anybody wants to get together with me later, ask me what I was doing and why I was doing it, I'm more than happy to do that. I met with senior leadership at the Department of Interior. I met with a group called the Outdoor Alliance, which is a non-motorized national advocacy organization, which has announced that they'll be hiring a recreation contract planner organizer here in the state of California.
21:02 The Western United States in the outdoor recreation space. So if we can't figure it out, other people are starting to show up to try to do it for us, which is interesting. I met from staff from Senator Harris's office, staff from Congressman Cook's office, folks in the Wilderness Society, and then finally with the Washington Office of the United States Forest Service. And as you know, the Washington Office of the Forest Service has committed staff time to supporting our recreation partnership here in the Eastern Sierra. A guy named Jonathan Cook Fisher, I think some of us know, has worked for the Washington Office staff out of South Lake Tahoe.
21:32 All very productive, all very interesting. And they're very supportive of the work that we're doing here. And it's great to be back there on behalf of a project of a regional organization that we're all trying to do that people seem interested in. That's nice. I then spent three days at the National Gateway Communities Conference. And I was channeling all of you. I wish all of you guys could have been there. We are a gateway community. It's great to be with a whole bunch of other gateway communities talking about common issues, challenges.
21:59 I made two presentations on behalf of the town of Mammoth Lakes. And again, I don't want to go into all the details here, but it was a very interesting, productive conference. I spent a fair amount of time for the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Rural Development, Western Regional Director. And while I was there, several things of interest to us. There was a $600 million push coming out of the administration for broadband, for rural broadband initiatives that I think we should be looking into. I advised Nate Greenberger that.
22:26 Also, the Farm Bill, which I've been working over with Dan. There's some very interesting things, the Farm Bill that just came out of the Senate, out of the Congress, that have, I think, very specific opportunities for Mammoth Lakes, for Mono County, for the region. And I've got some write-ups on those. I look forward to sharing those with folks. Also, a very interesting effort in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, where the Forest Service has property that's referred to as administrative units. It's not used for recreation or extractive purposes, but it's administrative.
22:53 Stuff like our housing compound right here in the heart of town where USDA, RD, the Forest Service and the local community working on translating that into community housing. It's kind of a cutting edge project they're working on, but I look forward to following up on that, bringing that into our housing conversations with our Forest Service and federal partners. Finally, in South Lake Tahoe on Sunday, I met with a web development team. We've got a housing item on the agenda this evening.
23:20 We're in South Lake Tahoe, North Lake Tahoe. They're working on a program to do matching between existing homeowners and employees and people in the workforce looking for places to live. These folks have a web platform that could probably be very easily repurposed, and they're very excited, enthusiastic about doing that. I think we'll talk about it a little bit later. They're going to be coming down here, I think, in the next first part of the new year to see if there's some opportunities there. We can start getting some units matched up with some people who need a place to live using a web-based platform to do that.
23:48 Finally, just a couple things for Council. I think as I left after our last meeting and drove up to South Lake Tahoe, I was reflecting on
23:55 How we, our workshop with the Recreation Commission, the recommendations coming from our advisory bodies, and I'm not sure if we, if we didn't really miss the kind of appropriate deference and engagement that we need to be giving to our commissions, people like MLR. And I, at some point, I think I'd like to maybe, if we could figure out a way to do it, to have a conversation with council about
24:20 Really understanding what the role of these recommending bodies are and what's the level of deference.
24:27 That we should give to their recommendations to make sure that we're paying a proper level of respect for the kind of work that people are doing. And if we get a recommendation and we choose to go off in a different direction, then we're making sure that we're acknowledging that the work people are doing and providing good rationale for why we're doing the things that we're doing. These people are volunteers. They do a lot of... I don't mean to interrupt you, but it's kind of going into a diatribe now about something. So unless it's a report out, let's just stick to this. Sure. So that's a point that I would like to follow up on with the council at some point.
24:56 I think that's important. And a couple other things. There's something on the agenda this evening. It's called responses to council, response to council requests.
25:08 And we've been sort of saying, hey, we want to get things on the agenda. And it's great that things come forward on the agenda, but I think it's important for the public to understand that maybe doesn't give the staff the time to do the kind of staff work necessary. It's good to have these issues acknowledged, but things start getting a little loose. So I just would want to reflect on that a little later down the line. So that's it. Thank you. Okay, Bill, do you have anything to report out, any meetings you've been to lately? The only meeting I went to where there would be anything to report out would be the ESTA.
25:37 Meeting that Kirk and I attended in Bishop where we voted in a new chair and a vice chair. Jeff from Bishop is the new chair. Bob from Mono County is the new vice chair. And other than that, that's all the reportable info I have. Thank you very much. Ms. Salcido. Okay. On the 6th of December, I attended the CERT.
26:03 I'm sorry, Mammoth Voices meeting, and CERT was there to talk about their role, their work. It's a good meeting. It's always worthwhile. We have good speakers there. On the 10th was the Local Transportation Commission meeting, and there was an item there on the Highway 395 Wildlife Crossing project, which was very interesting. It was a report of...
26:26 The amount of animal strikes, if you will, up and down 395, number of accidents, you know, cost of those accidents, and it was, as we all know who live here, it's a frightening time when we drive up and down 395, and we're always the cars in the far right driving 30 miles an hour, hopefully behind a large truck who will take the hit first. But they talked about the next motions in trying to get...
26:52 Fencing, overcrosses, underpasses, things for animals to be out of the way to try to mitigate these accidents. There's a big push to do this. Funding is being looked at, but this is also not the first time we've talked about this, and it's an ongoing issue, but I think that at the moment it's getting a lot more attention right now, and that was the main ESTA update. I met the new ESTA director. Then on the 11th, I met with...
27:18 The Chamber, I think we call it the Housing Committee, if you will, out of the Chamber of Commerce, looking at some of the things that were directed in the Housing Action Plan and actions that the Chamber can perhaps take to move along housing for workforce. And then just multiple meetings and calls from community members with wide-ranging views and opinions and questions, and that takes a bit of time, too. That's it for me. Thank you.
27:47 Attended the ESTA meeting, met the new executive director. I think he's going to be very successful down there. I've walked the trail site down in the trails to look at the school and how the water runs there. I was lobbied on the ice rink again, and I was lobbied on Sam's wood site.
28:10 And I did attend the movie over in June Lake called Keep Squaw True. I think it's a worthwhile, if you get the opportunity, it's a worthwhile watching the movie. They're looking at a billion dollars worth of development, but it doesn't seem that the community is not dealing with water issues, fire issues, transportation issues, carrying capacity.
28:39 A lot of the different issues that are brought up in that film are also issues that Mammoth Lakes is facing. So it's worthwhile if you get an opportunity to see Keep Squaw True. And obviously I've been lobbying on the cannabis stores. Thank you very much. Do we have any departments that would like to speak up? Oh, looks like we do.
29:17 Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. Just a note that we've received some interest in the upcoming CDBG application period. They released the NOFA last month in November.
29:30 The Notice of Funding Availability. And we have received some interest in that grant application. So we will be looking to ask the council to have a one-item agenda on your January 9th meeting that you're having, the joint meeting with the Planning and Economic Development Commission, to have a public hearing to take input on the applications for that item. And then we would also be looking to schedule likely a special meeting with you later on in the month to actually approve the submittal of the application. So I think I've talked.
29:59 Dan, and we're looking at maybe around January 23rd. So just kind of a heads up that we'll be looking at that. Any questions? Sandra, the CDBG grant, is that targeted for the parcel? No. Okay. Thank you. Thank you so much. Evening. Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation. Just a few quick updates for council and the community. If you're on the nice list, you can join us for Skate with Santa tomorrow, December 20th.
30:38 5 to 8pm. A wonderful kind of annual event. Holiday hours at the ice rink kicks off this Saturday. They'll be from 12 to 10pm. So we have a full calendar and schedule on mammothicerink.com, but we just want to allow the public to come during that time. We can kind of keep the ice up to a good condition for those visitors and holiday experiences.
31:05 In Mammoth. And then finally, the commission will meet on the second Tuesday in January, which is January 8th. So again, we're not going to meet on January 2nd. We'll meet on January 8th. So that's all I had from Parks and Recreation. Any questions? Did you have anything that you wanted to say about anything that's happened out in the rec zone lately? I don't think we've met since the tournament, the hockey tournament. Have we met? Did you give us an update on that?
31:33 We have another tournament coming up, the Calda Classic, which will be December 27th. Okay. It'll be a seven-day event. So that's coming up. So there'll be an invite for you to come back and welcome our next kind of group of players. So that's December 27th. Yeah. I'll put that on my schedule. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Steve. Good. Okay. Is that it for department heads? Excuse me, Matt. I've got a couple of questions for Dan. Sure. Okay. Dan, I'm wondering, or if you and Cassie could advise on when,
32:07 We funded a support position for NGOs in the ESCOG. I'm just wondering what the progress is on that. Yeah, that would be the deputy clerk level position or assistant clerk level position. It's out for recruitment. It closes January 4th. Okay. So we'll go from there. We've actually had a very, very good response to that. So it'll be a little bit of a process to screen through that. And so we'd be looking, hopefully, to have somebody on board end of January, the 1st of February at the latest in that time frame.
32:36 Okay. Depending on the scheduling of interviews. Good. The second question is the recreation coordinator position. I know that that person is getting ready to start. I don't know if we've crossed the T's and N's in the contract. Yeah. The joint position between Town County and Mammoth Lakes Recreation is scheduled to start January 14th. Okay. We do have an agreement between the three of us that needs to get out for a signature. Okay. And finally, our strategic...
33:00 Thank you very much. Thank you. Stuart, did you have something else that you wanted to add?
33:32 Standing by. Oh, you're just standing there. Oh, okay. Okay, next item. Okay, I guess we have a new person in our town family, and so now I'm going to have Marco Macias, Macias, Macias, rhymes with gracias, I think. Am I correct on that? You're laughing. I've just spent the last half an hour trying to work through the right pronunciation. Good evening. So on behalf of Public Works and the Parks and Recreation Department, I'm here before you to
34:02 Introduce Marco Anthony Macias Espaza, who is the new Public Works Parks Maintenance Hybrid employee. Marco joined the Parks Maintenance team in 2015 as a seasonal Parks Maintenance employee and has worked for Warren, who is right here. Warren's joining us, all the way from Bishop, so thank you, for the past three summers. Previously, Marco worked for Eastman Homeowner Services, Phillips Stoltz Construction and Mammoth Lakes Resort Services.
34:32 As you know, Marco oversees, or if you don't know, but Marco oversees Shady Res Park with Juan Prieto, who's a long-time employee. And I know you will all agree that it has never looked as good as it has. Marco has a contagious smile, there you go, that resonates throughout the department. And thanks to his passion and dedication, sometimes seven days a week, and sometimes till midnight, pumping out the softball fields full of water for our tournaments the next day, the town and the community are the fortunate.
35:00 Beneficiaries of Marco's hard work. Please join me in welcoming Marco to the Town of Mammoth Lakes as a full-time employee. Thank you for this opportunity and I work really hard for this job. Thank you. Thank you so much. Thank you. Welcome. Thank you so much. Good to see you. Now on agenda item number four. This is the Deferred Parks Maintenance presentation.
35:51 This is continued. Sorry we ran out of time last meeting to dive into this. So I guess, Stuart, I'm going to let you take it away and appreciate your patience in coming back to another meeting for this. Of course. Thank you. So as the mayor indicated, this is a carry item from December 5. We have some packets in the back if anybody wants to follow along, any media or any interested parties. It's about a 30-minute presentation. I'm going to try and do it in.
36:21 10? You go, boy. 15 minutes. I do the best I can. But thank you for the opportunity. It's certainly a groundbreaking time to be able to run through the many items that we've been able to address in the last 18 months. The opportunity hasn't been before the town for our parks, pools, facilities for quite some time. So it's a real honor being here. And thank you for the council and the commission for their advocacy and support.
36:50 Of our infrastructure. So this is our presentation. I'll kind of run through it as best I can. The program started back in May of 2017, and Council approved the $300,000 for our deferred maintenance program. We went through the process with our Recreation Commission to understand the methodology, the criteria, strategy, and the prioritization for these items. And then on June 6, 2017, Recreation Commission approved the program of work, and off we went.
37:20 The methodology, this is really important to kind of understand how we came about addressing the many deferred maintenance items. So we kind of broke them down into three categories. The first one was really looking at the priority items and they were the ones that were items that were not in a sound, safe or able to condition and operate the facility. So you can look at these items at structural deterioration, failures, tripping, building code violations or ADA non-compliant features.
37:49 Second one was any kind of item or system or component that had exceeded their expected life, useful life, which is quite a few that we'll kind of run through with you tonight. And then any items that provide the greatest benefit for the most users, have little or no increase or impact to the financial maintenance obligations, opportunity to leverage funding, and then assist in the efficient delivery of existing parks maintenance work efforts. So that was kind of our criteria.
38:15 We started with a budget of $300,000. We added $18,000 for the non-compliant bleacher issues that we had. And then we added general fund money from the parks maintenance budget for our tennis court rehab project. So we started with a funding allocation of about $345,000. This just kind of gives you a brief overview of how that money was spent throughout the community. You can see the majority, about two-thirds, was at Shady Rest Park.
38:44 About one-third, a little less than one-third was at Whitmore Pool. Tennis courts were about 7% and the Whitmore Recreation Area made up the rest. So we're just going to kind of run through each of these parks. Each section will start with this kind of master slide which talks about the items per park. Don't need to go into a lot of detail but that kind of gives you the breakdown of the $218,000 spent at Shady Rest Park. Quite a diverse list. We can run through kind of the poly-cap fence guards which is really kind of a safety
39:15 Item for our softball fields. Snack bar siding project. This was kind of the wildlife sanctuary that we had going on at Cheddy Rest Park for quite some time, so it was good to get into that project. And we resided that concession area with a hardy plank material, which will give us far more longevity for that facility. It's actually part of our park's maintenance storage as well, so staff are there all the time, majority through summer, spring and fall.
39:42 And then the concession is operated by our Mammoth Lakes Women's Club. So we also were able to fix, in one of those slides, photos shows you the little building on the bottom left hand there. That was kind of a storage space for our little league. So we were able to do that as well. Restroom rehabilitation, this was kind of a project that Marco completed as well, who's gone. You can see on the left, that was kind of from the damage from the heavy snow. So those screens were beyond repair. So we spent some time fixing those.
40:12 They came out much better than when they were. So happy about that. Pavilion roofing project. We were here on June 20th performing a ribbon cutting ceremony for the Shady Rest Park projects. This included the fascia and the top cap on the roof. Water management system. This is a big focus for us in parks and recreation and water conservation. This is one avenue that we can kind of implement this strategy. And this was kind of a web-based IQ system to manage.
40:40 Our water platforms, both at Shady Res Park and actually at Whitmore. So our entire system there is able to be tracked and managed online through a system, which was great advantageous operations for Warren, who's left again. This category is kind of safety, seating and accessibility. So this talks about the need to provide ADA parts, access and safe seating for our guests and our users of our facilities.
41:06 That included installing new bleachers. We contracted this out. This was six bleachers that we had to build in a period of time, which was overwhelming for our parks maintenance staff. They had jobs to do. So this was a contract effort, again, to bring in a crew to build all the bleachers and site them on the concrete pads. Previously, most of the bleachers were just on the dirt. So here's an opportunity to create the concrete pad, build them, fix them to the surface, and make a safe and compliant area for our guests to watch the activities.
41:35 These were the other bleachers. We had several that were non-compliant. Non-compliant means that if it's a five-row bleacher, they need to have a back mesh screen on it so people don't obviously fall off the back of the bleacher. We also had the opportunity for the first time ever to have ADA bleachers installed in our parks as well. And to make that accessible, we created these asphalt paths that you can see in that main image to allow any wheel devices and any folks.
42:04 Access to those bleachers. So that's a big improvement. So that's Shady Rest Park. Community Centre tennis courts was our kind of rehabilitation project, just over 25,000. I think everybody understands the challenges we have at the asphalt courts that have been there for quite some time. A lot of deterioration. They're very hard to manage. Any fix that we're kind of really investing in those courts is kind of a short-term nature. So we really need to kind of address this on a long-term nature. But this was kind of...
42:31 An item and certainly a priority for the commission to address some of these issues you can see here, the cracks were, as you can see, big as a dollar bill and as deep as a dollar bill. So really those courts were in a state of disrepair and really unplayable and unsafe for the public. So we spent kind of the bare minimum just to kind of bring them up to a condition where they can be used by the public. You can kind of see here the unreal court that was fixed in April and May of this year.
43:00 We saw a lot of increase in use from that project as well. So that was really money well spent. Whitmore Recreation Area, we spent a little bit of money down here on dugouts and then the water management system upgrades. Phase two of the deferred maintenance program sees more investment into Whitmore Recreation Area, but this is the way we prioritise them. This was the state of our dugouts. This was on the main baseball field, which is kind of the high school baseball field.
43:26 You can see the roof was in disrepair and the siding on the dugouts. So you can see it's a substantial increase in not only the longevity with a steel roof that Marco and the team put on, but it was also painted by the high school players as well. So just a good partnership to work with our school students on as well. We also installed ADA bleacher and a regular bleacher down at softball field one.
43:53 And the idea with our kind of next deferred maintenance is to put some concrete pads on these locations as well. Whitmore Pool, this was just under $100,000 of investment. I think the pool was here for quite some time, built in 1939. Not a lot of money has been spent on that pool for quite some time. So what we performed first was, well, parking lot rehab was actually not the first, but it was the second. And this was kind of predicated on,
44:23 A Mammoth Disposal truck that happened to stop in that location that was on fire and through that process were able to recoup some funds from Mammoth Disposal to contribute towards the rehabilitation of the parking lot. So that was a good investment. Okay, thanks. Welcome. So Whitmore Pool Assessment. So our first step here was to really understand what we were dealing with.
44:50 Whitmore Pool, as I said, has been there for a long time. We contracted with Terracon, a group that is kind of world-renowned, sorry, renowned throughout California. So they were coming in, so they came in and conducted an immediate first-year, short-term, and kind of a long-term analysis of our pool. And through that process, they were able to provide us with probable costs and options for replacement, upgrades, and so forth through that, for the pool.
45:17 What we tackled first was the immediate first-year repairs, and these were the ones that needed immediately to bring the facility to a sound, safe, and fully habitable condition, any items which pose a rift to health, safety, or well-being of our visitors, and any deferred maintenance items or any items that kind of exceeded their expected useful life. So that was how we prioritised the $96,000 for the Whitmore Pool. This one here is the replastering of the kiddie pool.
45:45 This was a situation where that plaster was basically cracking, bubbling. It was really to the point of we weren't really able to safely operate that little kiddie pool. So that was a $15,000 investment. What it means now, though, is once you replaster a pool, you have to keep the water in the pool. So what we've done in the meantime is purchase a pool cover, which you'll see coming up in that presentation, to provide a safe...
46:12 The other major change that we made to the pool, which is a big investment, Warren got a kiss there from B, long term.
46:39 Pool Swimmer, very happy about our replacement of our pool heater. You can see on the left-hand slides there, that pool heater's been there for, I think, about 28 years, clearly past its useful life. So we're able to install a new heater, still working through, you know, some challenges with that pool heater, but by and far, it's a great investment. It'll do some, create that pool a bit, make that pool far more sustainable in the future and able to kind of keep that pool at a consistent temperature.
47:07 For our guests, because it has been a challenge. So that's a $12,000 investment. The other items here, which is probably the most common upgrade that aquatic facilities are being made right now to their facilities is automated water chemistry controllers. So this is something that we had on our list as well.
47:27 And then also the crew that came up and did the install for the chemical controllers also upgraded the mechanical room. So they basically pulled every component apart, re-piped it, re-plumbed it, and replaced it in a far more efficient economical manner, which has since improved the efficiency of our pool. So that was a really great investment. The next phase there is to do the same to the kiddie pool. So this is the same upgrade. So you have a chemical controller, a feeder.
47:56 And the other thing we're going to install as well is kind of web-based chemical controllers that through just your computer use or web-based or tablet, you can actually track the pH levels, the water chemistry and so forth and manage those pools far more efficiently than we have done in the past. So that's the investment that's scheduled for the spring. There's the wading pool cover that we talked about. So that was installed about two weeks ago.
48:22 And then we added these lockers. So in our changing rooms, there was really no place to stay, store, or safely lock your personal belongings away, and that included staff. So staff basically used the concession slash office for their kind of personal belongings, and that's where they got changed and so forth. So that's really not acceptable. So we're able to add these lockers to those changing rooms. So that's been the change.
48:48 So that was the $345,000 of deferred maintenance through our parks and facilities. These slides just following kind of notable enhancements additions that I just want to kind of make the council and community aware of what we've also accomplished in the last 18 months. And this is kind of a broad and diverse list of items. You can see here it's anywhere from signage on Whitmore Recreation Area down to kind of our e-bike regulatory signs.
49:14 Nonetheless, they've added a lot of benefit to our parks and facilities. I don't know how long it's taken to get us a sign on Highway 395 identifying Whitmore Recreation Area, but we're able to accomplish that this year. Thanks to Caltrans and that team for working with us. It was about a two-year project to get this up, so very happy about that. That was no cost to the town. This one, this was probably the saddest and probably the most joyous.
49:41 I think upgrade that Warren and his team were able to achieve. On the right there is the mower that basically was in operation for something like 30 years and I think that's just not acceptable. So we were able to source a 2013 mower with only 550 hours, save the town over $15,000 by purchasing a used machine but it's exactly what the parks team wanted and this machine here is, even though it's in front of
50:10 Mammoth Creek Park, its home is at Whitmore Recreation Area. So it lives down at Whitmore Recreation Area, and that's been a great enhancement to our maintenance efforts. As you can see, that was a long time due. We also are able to replace Warren's main truck that we've had in service for about 12 years. And then we also purchased this little used, again, save the town money, used Tacoma for use in our trails and our parks. So again, that was a well-needed enhancement to our parks maintenance efforts.
50:39 This was work completed by a contractor on behalf of the JLA project at Vulcan Brothers Skate Park. This was the additional bowl at the backside of the Vulcan Brothers Skate Park. Again, this was completed just before the Wave Wave Skate Competition in August. So a great enhancement. You can see they really spent a lot of time cleaning up the pathways in and around the back of the skate park as well. So really thankful for the JLA project for their investment in our facilities as well.
51:06 Working on through the Lions Club, we started this program two years ago with Tails and Trails. We host this event at the Mammoth Rec Zone every summer. So through this partnership, we're able to receive donations from the Lions Club to invest in these poo ferry stations throughout town. And these locations will be kind of identified as the main sites in and around our park facilities to encourage our folks to deposit dog waste in these receptacles.
51:36 So it's another good partnership we're working with. Clearly the largest investment that was made in our parks this year was our playground. As you know, we were a recipient of the Statewide Healthy Play Initiative, which kind of really triggered the construction and the implementation of our inclusive playground. It's the only one in eastern California. It's a national demonstration site, and our team did a phenomenal job. I know Lauren's here, and Lauren's here, hopefully somewhere, and our entire team.
52:05 Marco is here. Hector is here. Anyway, our entire team, Public Works, spent a lot of time and effort, as you know, installing this fabulous playground. So very proud of that. And then finally, the most recently, this was the new Holder tractor that arrived just before the first big storm of the season. This is a wonderful addition. Thank you again. So along with this machine, we're able to hire a seasonal parks maintenance worker, which is Hector, who worked with us in the summer.
52:33 He's an existing driver that works with another snow removal firm, so we're able to acquire Hector, who has a lot of years of experience running this machine, adding to the extensive trial network that we have throughout town, including Main Street. So if you've seen that machine around, it's been put to good use. And then the last one here is the, you know, working with Joel, our trials coordinator. This was the investment towards citing regulatory signs with the...
52:59 The change that we made in summer for our e-bikes. So this is something that we're starting. And then I know we have a larger signage and wave finding project coming up in summer. So this is kind of the first phase of this project as well. So all in all, which is a staggering number, I'm so proud that we're able to accomplish this for our community. So thank you again.
53:23 Is just under $1 million of investment in our town parks and facilities in the last 18 months. So again, I'm just a huge, I'm so proud of our department, what we've been able to do, and our council for supporting our community. So thank you for the opportunity to come before you to present this wonderful program of work. Thank you for your presentation. I do have a question when you were talking about the water, the remote water management. I really love that. That's kind of the wave of the future.
53:53 My only question about that, who and are they utilizing the software that is presented here? Is there someone who's actually on their phone and keeping track? And actually, who would that be? So Warren manages that system, our parks manager. Yeah. And the beauty of that system, it's accessible from anywhere. So you can do it on your phone. You can do it from home. The beauty of the system as well, it's all on a main...
54:21 Water main, so if they have an issue with any of these system sprinklers, you can shut that off from that water main and it saves again so much to the conservation. There's also a built-in weather station, so it actually has that smart technology where it'll adapt to the more water, less water and adapt that cycle as needed. So we're kind of mapping out the entire irrigation network of each of these parks to try and create some more efficiency with water conservation. So it is a big step and it's a big step throughout California, yeah, certainly.
54:51 Okay, thank you. Thank you. Yeah. Did anybody else have anything that they would like to say? Yeah, just thank you and congratulations to your staff for this really great season of repair and much appreciated and you guys did a great job. Finally, eh, Stu? Yeah.
55:11 I just want to say it's really encouraging to see the great work that when this department gets the resources and how valuable all these things are. It's also really encouraging to see your department working with Public Works, the Trails Department, I guess we could call it that, everybody working together to provide tangible, visible deliverables for the community. It's great to see that level of cooperation with the town within the staff. It's very encouraging to see.
55:42 I admitted that. And I do want to say that all this work was completed outside of the regular daily duties of our team, by the way, so, you know, it's even more monumental. And this just kind of shows the team, Parks Maintenance Crew, missing kind of Derek, Kyle, and Justin, but small amount of people, but do, you know, large, great, big things for our community, so thank you. Okay. Thank you so much. Wonderful. Thank you to the whole 2018 Parks Maintenance Crew there, too, including the puppy dog.
56:17 Okay. So now on the consent agenda, are there any additions? Actually, I didn't ask earlier. Are there any additions to the agenda tonight? No, Madam Mayor. Okay. So I'm going to go ahead and read the items. Consent agenda. Item 5, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of December 5, 2018.
56:49 Number six, accept and file the SB 165 tax accountability report for CFD 2001-1 North Village, CFD 2004-1 fractional, CFD 2005-1 in lieu, and CFD 2013-3 transit services.
57:09 Seven, waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance updating Municipal Code Chapter 15.16, Article 2, Development Impact Mitigation Fees. Item 8, adopt a resolution adopting Mammoth Yosemite Airport 2018-2019 to 2023-2024 Airport Capital Improvement Plan.
57:31 Yep, and that's it. We do have a request from the public, so I will go ahead and pull Item 7 for a separate conversation. Madam Mayor, I would make a motion to approve consents 5, 6, and 8. Second the motion. Roll call, please. Council Member Saucio? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Council Member Wood? Yes. Mayor Wood? Yes. Mayor Hall? Yes.
58:02 Motion passes 5-0. And now going back to consent agenda item 7, waive the reading and end up by title only, the ordinance updating municipal code chapter 15.16. I'm going to go ahead, Tom. I think we can address his question from Sandra. They've had a chance to discuss it.
58:23 So I spoke with Tom, and I'm happy to hear what he has to say, but he just didn't have an opportunity to review the draft ordinance before the meeting tonight, so he wanted to, we talked a little bit about continuing this item to the January 16th meeting, the second reading, so that Tom has an opportunity to take a look at it, and he and I can meet and talk through the changes. Does that summarize what you want? Yeah, that's correct, and I apologize. Sandra pointed out to me that this was on.
58:51 The last agenda from two weeks ago. It kind of, I don't know, I guess I just was maybe still buzzing from the discussion about the housing mitigation fees. I didn't really focus on it. And as I saw it, I came back for a second reading. I asked for some more clarifications today and got a copy of the redlined ordinance language, which is a lot more than I recognized. And so I just didn't have enough time to get through all of the changes. And there are some material changes.
59:20 I think it's, you know, overall acceptable, at least from our perspective, but I would like an opportunity to have a chance to talk with Sandra, and if you don't mind, if you could continue it to one meeting, that would be fantastic. Okay, thank you. Do you have any issues in doing that? I don't have any issues with that. Okay. Okay, do I need to, can we just do that by consensus that that's going to be, pardon? A motion would be appropriate to carry the item to January 16th. Would anyone care to make that motion? I will make a motion to carry this item to the January 16th.
59:50 16th meeting, and you may want to change the signature page from Mayor Wentworth to Mayor Hoff.
59:56 Thank you.
59:59 Okay.
1:00:01 Roll call, please.
1:00:02 Oh, excuse me, I didn't hear a second.
1:00:04 Second.
1:00:04 Okay, roll call, please.
1:00:06 Councilmember Saucino.
1:00:07 Yes.
1:00:07 Councilmember Saucino.
1:00:08 Yes.
1:00:09 Yes.
1:00:10 Mayor Motton Schoenberg.
1:00:11 Yes.
1:00:11 Mayor Hoff.
1:00:12 Yes, motion passes 5-0.
1:00:15 Okay, now we are going to go into the public hearing portion of our evening. This is public hearing to discuss expenditures and accomplishments of the Community Development Block Grant for homebuyer assistance and electrical rehabilitation of the Glass Mountain Apartments. I'm going to formally open the public hearing.
1:00:39 And if I could have a staff report, please. Thank you. So I'll start off, and then I've got Patricia Robertson here from Mammoth Lakes Housing to provide some information as well. So as the council is aware, in 2014, we were awarded, the town was awarded a million dollars in funding for homebuyer assistance and the rehab of the Glass Mountain Apartment project through the Community Development Block Grant, CDBG.
1:01:04 The town contracted with Mammoth Lakes Housing to administer the Homebuyer Assistance Program with the town, and Planning and Public Works administered the portion of the project for the Glass Mountain Rehab. The Homebuyer Assistance Program was very successful. We facilitated four households purchasing condos in town.
1:01:26 And the Glass Mountain Project was also successful. And the grant paid for the complete electrical rehabilitation of the apartment complex. And that apartment complex provides low and very low income households, rental property. The grant expenditure period ended last winter.
1:01:46 And as part of the closeout process with the state, we're holding this public hearing just to discuss the accomplishments of the grant. I'm available to answer questions. I have Grady as available to answer any technical questions you have about the Glass Mountain Rehab. Patricia Robertson can answer any questions about the homebuyer assistance. And just as a note, the staff report shows that there are funds that are being disencumbered as part of this process, so we didn't spend the entire grant award, but that's not uncommon with these types of grants. And I'm happy to answer any questions that you have.
1:02:16 Thank you. Thank you. Absolutely. Senator, the only question I'm left with is there are so many different types of grants and so many different types of granting agencies. A lot of times when you turn money back and you don't use it all, it is a ding against you in the next process. Is this different from that or did we hurt ourselves by not using it all? I mean, I don't think we hurt ourselves. We completed successful projects. We did what we said we were going to do. We just did it with less money.
1:02:46 I don't think it's going to hurt us in any future applications. I just wanted to speak, good evening, Town Council, a little bit about some more specifics on the households that we assisted with the CDBG funding for homeownership assistance. And I know Larry Emerson from IMACA is here to speak a little bit about the Glass Mountain Rehabilitation Project.
1:03:09 So Mammoth Lakes Housing assisted four low-income households purchase homes within the town of Mammoth Lakes, and that comprised 13 individuals, community members. Those community members are employed in different sectors of our community, including religious services, personal care, retail, and legal services. The average loan amount for these four households was $77,500,
1:03:38 Which seems like a lot and illustrates the gap between what a low income household can afford in a mortgage and our purchase prices in our community. Something interesting is that all four of these households purchase deed restricted homes and so that illustrates the additional subsidy that our community members need to obtain affordable safe places to live. These loans when they're repaid will go into a revolving loan account that
1:04:08 Will be reused to help additional low-income households. And Mammoth Lakes Housing currently manages a loan portfolio of $3.6 million in Mono County and the City of Bishop. That's all I have on the Home Buyer Assistance Program, unless there's questions. Any questions from Council? Larry was going to speak to the Glass Mountain project. Yes, please. Yeah.
1:04:43 Larry Emerson from Amaka. Good evening, Mayor and Councilmembers. Thank you for the opportunity to talk about the Glass Mountains Rehabilitation Project. I worked with your planning and public works staff over the last few years on this project and was finally completed at the end of last year, beginning of this year, and it resulted in the elimination of electrical safety hazards.
1:05:16 At the 26-unit Glass Mountain Apartments over at 25 Mountain Boulevard. We're very pleased that we eliminated those hazards. They weren't identified until we actually, after we submitted the, the town submitted the block grant application. So unfortunately we were...
1:05:37 We had to defer a number of other improvements originally contemplated with that application, including drainage improvements. We wanted to replace some of the plumbing. So we would like to participate with the town in the 2018 block grant program so that we can obtain funding to complete the originally
1:05:59 Sought-after improvements for Glass Mountain. But I'm happy to say that the tenants, we have about 45 tenants there at Glass Mountains. They're very happy with the improvements. And as a result of the electrical improvements, we're able to replace their stovetops with actual ovens. And so that's very beneficial to the tenants as well.
1:06:25 So it was a very successful project and it went pretty smoothly. So thank you for that. Thank you very much. Since this is a, I'm sorry, did you have anything else to add on that? I don't. Oh, okay. Since this is a public hearing and I'm going to go through a certain process here, I just want to make sure that the council, right now is your time to ask any questions that you have. Okay, no questions.
1:06:51 We're going to go ahead and go to public testimony or comment. Please limit it to five minutes if you have anything that you'd like to add from the public, please. Okay, no comments, so I guess I don't need a rebuttal from the applicant. Staff, there's really no questions. Is there anything that you would care to add on that? No. Okay. If everybody's satisfied, we're going to go ahead and close the public hearing.
1:07:24 I will ask for deliberation and comments to see if there's even anything somebody would like to add? No, my mind is saying this is kind of a technical closeout, an opportunity for the public to give an update on what happened, and I'm happy to hear what we heard and more than happy to close this thing out. I do have just one thing to add. Is there anybody here that happens to live in this?
1:07:51 Oh, okay. I'm going to be working over there tomorrow. Does that count? Yeah. It would be nice to hear from people who are actually living in these areas just in the future just to go, yeah, it was awesome or anyway. So with that, I will ask for a motion. There's no motion. It's really just a public hearing. No motion. We're closed. And now we are going to go ahead and move on to item number 10. And this is amended budget for housing position.
1:08:19 Authorization to recruit an allocation of funding for housing-related programs. Again, this is also continued from the last meeting on December 5, 2018. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'll kick this off, and then Sandra and Grady can... Can I ask my questions first about... I was going to suggest that we were looking at somewhat bifurcating a portion of this item, as you know.
1:08:49 Member Sauser has a conflict for anything related to the parcel. It is. There's a number of items in here that both directly related to the parcel, which we would suggest that Mr. Sauser cannot participate in. Part of it is a larger budget question, which may be a little more of a gray area. I'll defer to Andy on in terms of some of the ability to comment. Or if you'd rather comment on the non-
1:09:12 Paul's related items and excuse yourself from the rest of discussion. That would be the other option, I believe, that could work as long as you're not speaking to the items that you have the conflict on. Yeah, I think the cleanest way to do this, Andy, in my opinion here, is for me to make comments right now on the financial piece of it without dealing specifically with anything and then leaving the room until they're done with it. I think your legal analysis is spot on. Thank you.
1:09:41 Remind me to raise my pay later. So my biggest heartache with the whole thing, and you guys have heard me say it before, at the end of the day, with everything we're adding here, virtually all of the funds that we are allocating for housing through, you know, the 0.85% and then some are going to be consumed by staff in one location or another. We will be spending a million dollars a year on staff without producing
1:10:13 One piece of housing. At some point in time, as a government body, I think we need to be responsible enough to step back from how we're doing things and seeing if there is another avenue to go forward maybe without as many management-level personnels or high-level personnels and more Indians in the box. I understand that the Community Housing Action Plan called for us to hire all of these people.
1:10:44 But, you know, those plans don't take into account, as Kirk is harping on all the time, budgetary constraints. Basically, we're going to have a housing manager in the town, a housing manager at Mammoth Lakes Housing, and housing personnel at the chamber when we get done, and some of that isn't even in here. So, as you're looking at this and adding the pieces in, I'm not allowed to talk to.
1:11:11 Thank you so much. Thank you so much.
1:11:41 Runs for it. Forest Creek or wherever. We could be buying a lot of units for what we're spending on management. Then, of course, we'd have to hire somebody to manage them. So before, as Mr. Sauser leaves, will you be coming back to vote on this, or how are we doing this? No, I will not. So this is general observations, comments? I am making comments. These are general observations. If this was budget time, I would be asking for it to be broken out differently so that I could participate.
1:12:11 You guys can do what you will with it. You can, you know, decide that you're going to punt it down the road, and we're going to do it during budget time. At this point, the way it's written, in my opinion, and Andy's backing me up here, I need to go sit in the chairs over here. I'll even close the door. Yes. Thank you, Bill. If I can just note for the record, the conflict is due to his personal residence being within 500 feet of the parcel project area, so that...
1:12:47 Automatic conflict under the rules, so. So don't talk parcel to Bill Sauser ever. We'll keep him in the dark. Okay, so where are we now that we've... Yeah, if we want to, we can kick it off the staff report, walk through what's before you. Excuse me. The item looks at a modification to the currently adopted budget.
1:13:15 I'll walk through some of the details of that. The existing budget authority was structured less than the full, you know, dollars generated by a 0.85% of TOT that's currently committed to the housing program. To the extent that we don't expend dollars there, they are continued to be held in reserve for housing, so it's not like they go somewhere else in the budget, so they do still stay to the housing ultimately for use by town council.
1:13:43 Elements that we started to look at in working through with staff, and I'll defer somewhat to Sandra and Grady in some of the detail. In terms of our current housing work program, we actually do a fair amount internally with staff already. That has grown in terms of consuming approximately a half of a planning position and some other support staff. Obviously, our finance department's engaged in some of this as well. A lot of that, right now we have a one-time project going on updating our housing element of the general plan.
1:14:12 Along with some of the other element updates that were referenced earlier this evening in our safety element. We also still, we are the applicant for the CDBG or the Community Development Block Grant funds and the home funds and so we have a fair amount of monitoring work that we're required to do on those and processing and payment and like for example the public hearing we just heard. We do the vast majority of that in partnership with
1:14:38 Other agencies, Majority, a lot of that with Mammoth Lakes Housing. And then as you noted on the Glass Mountain Apartments, that was the town and Amaka's applications for that. So those grants can go to other partners with the town that we're involved with in terms of utilizing those funding. We also deal with the reuse program of program income where dollars come back in. That is held by the town and then is reallocated back into the housing projects.
1:15:07 Again, as mentioned earlier, there's additional loan money that comes back in through some of the grant funds managed by Mammoth Lakes Housing, so there's this ongoing coordination in those efforts. We have the revolving loan fund, which dollars are held by the town. We go through that process to update those for the administration of that. We also have a fair amount of application of the town and state, I'll say the density bonuses and other planning-related work on housing projects as they come forward.
1:15:36 That we look at in terms of just normal processing and things, but there are elements if there's an affordability component. We also respond to a number of questions related to that. We've had several recently, frankly, on the use of CDBG money, for example, for child care facilities and other grants in those areas, which is something then that we end up spending staff time on it. More importantly here recently, I guess, would be the adoption of the Community Housing Action Plan and the acquisition of the parcel.
1:16:04 Both of those have resulted in additional staff time just in terms of management work, administrative work, in terms of how do we move those forward. The recommendation now of the housing plan was to have a coordinator, if you will, within the town. We had originally hoped to do that via a contract so we could kind of lay out the program and stuff. We did not have a successful recruitment in that area. We'd also looked at some intern support.
1:16:33 Full-time position support for the year under the Civic Spark Program. Fair amount of back and forth on that, but never did end up with a viable candidate to bring on board for that program, leaving both of those elements vacant. In discussing that component with staff and looking at it, the recommendation was to come back and move forward with filling a full-time position to fall into those areas. It continues to work on the programs outlined here.
1:17:01 We believe there's additional elements coming forward from the community housing action plan and related work on housing that which a staff person will need to be dedicated to do that. There's a fair amount of technical work that gets done. There's other outreach in those areas. On top of that is the parcel, and I call it the parcel development team. I want to be cautious. A little discussion the other day that we're actually not the developer from a building and, you know, the full boat.
1:17:31 But we are the landowner. Therefore, we're in charge of the CEQA process, the planning work that needs to be done, the master planning and work. There's been other work done on that site, most recently by Mammoth Lakes Housing. There's been other development proposals. Those need to get brought together and reviewed. And that happens in two different areas. Again, that happens in part to our planning department and our public works department. The public works side of the house.
1:17:57 Has really taken on the lead through Grady Dutton. I gave him a new title in the staff report here, the Director of Parcel Development. But again, not to be the developer, if you will, but he's a chief cook and bottle washer for as far as managing project out and signing staff. And following through the steps, he's probably the most experienced staff person as far as a development project and the steps that have to happen before you actually get to put anything on the ground. Is that fair characterization?
1:18:26 How to be able to do that. The other side of that is there's been a number of other staff people involved in the parcel work that get pulled into the various pieces there. And I'll say, frankly, I don't think they have the time to really focus on that project and the priority of it. We have a certain frustration level. It's been nine months, eight months since we bought the property. And we're not as far down the road as we'd like to be. But part of that is we don't have the staff capacity or the
1:18:55 Subject matter expert capacity really to move some of that forward, getting to that next phase where you can actually put something out to the public. I know there's a desire to say, let's lay out this design concept and let's get some public input through it. You end up really working through a community-based master plan development to look at. You take the other work that's been done. We used to have some up on the board here, the various work that was done, and how do we
1:19:23 Bring those together but have something that our community steps up to and says, yeah, we really like this. How quickly can you get phase one done? How do we get housing on the ground to the comment that Mr. Sauser had made? How do we really begin to move that forward? But that coordination of work, again, the reason we're looking at the full-time positions is so you actually have the capacity to do that. You're not...
1:19:48 Stretching other staff thin in terms of work and assignments and some of the continuity in that area to make that really work through. Both sides from that, from planning and engineering, obviously, you get that type of position. There still may be overlap in work, but a funded position here may be supported by a general fund funded position within the department as well. But to have somebody that we can put on point, hold accountable.
1:20:16 Serving those primary capacities becomes really critical to be able to do that. I think with the right staffing support and other elements, really trying to look at the next 18 months to be really moving these projects forward. I think the amended budget really dedicates staff to manage those types of projects, both the parcel project and to be able to complete what I call a preliminary task. It's really not.
1:20:42 You know, development, development, but we haven't got some of the engineering side of it done, you know, the soil work, the infrastructure layout, the capacity issues, how big do your water and sewer lines need to be, drainage issues, obviously, with the drainage that goes through the site, looking at complete street elements, looking at snow storage, looking at what type of other amenities in there. Again, building off a lot of the work that's already been done there. The other concern is just the ongoing staff resources for
1:21:11 Our current core housing programs that we're doing. Walked through a number of those before. Ruth Traxler will hold her responsible for a lot of things here recently as she has recently left the town, taken a position near her family in Washington. Did a great job, stepped in, learned a lot of elements. We got her trained up and now we're losing her, which is great employee, great for her opportunity. And we couldn't quite relocate her family down to here to keep her here, so one of those options.
1:21:41 Anyway, that core work and services like that, there's other staff that end up helping that, but that really was consuming about half of her time. And as we're looking at some larger development projects potentially coming in or just the ongoing small projects coming through, that senior planning position really does need to be focused on the planning side. And then she wasn't doing elements in the housing side that she would have loved to have been working on. And so there's that tension and frustration.
1:22:07 I want to do a better job here, but I don't have the time to do it. And so as we looked at those elements, bifurcating those positions and having a full-time housing person really seemed to be an element to go forward. That person becomes our primary interface relationship with Mammoth Lakes Housing. We've had Patricia in on a number of the parcel discussions, other elements there to how do we pull that together to really get that focus there.
1:22:33 And also just in terms, and I'll go back to it, is having the right staff in place, knowing the steps to take and working with outside subject matter experts allows us really to focus how do we actually get housing on the ground and both from a new development and parcel focus, but also to the other programs that were identified and been discussed at different levels, whether we know the success of the down payment assistance program.
1:22:58 Between the town and Mammoth Lakes Housing, we've really dialed that program in, and they do a great job on that. Some of the outreach work, some of the other, you know, we have a, from the board, I think there's a 70 plus or minus wait list for housing within MLH, and how do we coordinate and keep that outreach going, those types of things. And so we have a lot of efforts to try to make that come together. And I think it's been a back and forth, and ultimately when we were unable to fill the contract housing,
1:23:27 Coordinator position in the Civic Spark position was to go back, walk through this and look and really say, okay, what do we actually need to really move this forward coming out of the council priorities and even in front of that, just the vital importance housing is in the community in terms of our economic sustainability, in terms of just decent places to live, fill in the blank. And we are seeing that more and more structure, not just.
1:23:55 To our affordable side, but even to the middle side of housing and cost of living issues here in the community. So those were key elements we were looking at. We also have the housing element update that would be ongoing, completed by June, is the target, to have that done. So before I walk through, I want to walk through the budget changes in the kind of the revenue sources and stuff. Before I do that, I do want to give, if I can pause there, questions either from Council or for Grady or Sander that touch base.
1:24:24 On the positions to use and the importance it has in terms of having the capacity to achieve the things we believe are in front of us. So if I could pause there before I get into the detailed budget question. I don't have any questions. Okay. Kirk, do you have any questions? And Linda. No. And no questions at this time. Anything else you want to add? So let me touch base on the budget element. It's on page four of the staff report.
1:24:55 There's two pieces of that showing what the 18-19 adopted budget looked like. We had 40,758 left in reserves. And as I mentioned earlier, as we have excess dollars in the budget from the TOT allocation to housing, we are now earmarking those and holding those in the housing reserve. Coming out of 17-18, we did use some of those dollars to, I think it came out of there as a repayment of the RLF.
1:25:22 Fund to make sure that was fully funded. There were some dollars prior to that utilized in the acquisition of the parcel. The net impact of that is today we have just under $41,000 in that. What would you call, we refer to affectionately joint bucket. I don't like that term so much, but that held reserve for housing and we spend those dollars accordingly for that purpose. The revenues for 1819 projected at 882.6.
1:25:51 92 based on that 0.85% of a percentage point going in from TOT revenue in. The appropriations, the personnel cost that is really tied to current town staff and the allocations that go into work on items, be that some of Sandra's time, Ruth's time, I think Kim may have some time in this one, one of our other planners, looking at that element there. And then our contracted services are listed out there. I'll just note the adopted budget had MLH at the 321-190.
1:26:21 With the updated contract, that would go to $330,000. It's not a big adjustment, but it is an adjustment we'll need to make. That would get made upon getting the final signatures on the contract process. And then, so we would end up with the year, if we did that, with the $345,000 reserves, if we did not amend the budget, didn't touch it, just left it, and that would roll forward. We're actually recommending that the budget be amended, same revenue sources.
1:26:49 But looking at an increase in personnel of about $125,000 that would support the two proposed positions, basically over a five-month period, timing of recruitment, et cetera, may change that a bit, so there may be a little bit of savings still in there, and of course, final hiring amounts. The dollar amounts are predicated on current staff costs that we're looking at, so we have a pretty good handle there to be able to do that. The contract services would shift, really, to only have the three items there, MLH,
1:27:18 Again, that would need to go up a couple hundred, up to the 330 ultimately. A home grant monitoring contract, we actually are required in certain home programs that we have and projects out there that have that reviewed annually, so that's been funded out of here over time. And Sandra could speak to more detail to that as needed. Then the housing element work that we're going through. On an ongoing basis, the home grant monitoring is continuing.
1:27:45 That's something each year. If the housing element would be done this year, those funds would no longer be required for that purpose. The other two elements is there is allocation of the remaining dollars. We're requesting dollars to go into the parcel account so we can actually have dollars to move that project forward. One of the things, and it's kind of a push-me-pull-you element.
1:28:06 Of how much of that each time if we come back to council and say we need an additional $15,000 or $25,000, the question is, well, where is it coming from in the budget? This will at least have the budget there and trying to get that authority to move forward. It actually will help us be more efficient in our processes and getting out in front of the community, working with the public on the project. And then I call the other one housing programs. Those dollars are there. We've had over time, one of the questions has been, we'd like to pursue something in housing, but there's no allocated funding for it.
1:28:36 In this case now, we just recently with programs coming forward, we're going to be underfunded element there. But the housing program idea there is so the money is actually allocated in the budget so you're not doing a budget management down the road. You know what you have to work with. And then, for example, here more recently, both the chamber and MLH has both had discussions at their board levels to bring an item forward for additional funding for housing programs. One would be a missing middle.
1:29:03 Down payment assistance program discussed at the most recent MLH board meeting. The other has been the chamber has been looking at an element and looking at the short-term rental market and long-term conversion potential. Also the matching program, how do we have our employees and employers, you know, the website concept or an app concept that they could actually hopefully facilitate more of that. And then also some discussion at least in looking at least the program inside of it at
1:29:32 How on the employer purchase of units, some of them are doing that on their own. Do we have the role of the play in that? Are they more a facilitator for private investment? But basically you'd have $125,000 allocated to work with that. Both of the programs would exceed that amount at this point in time. We're recognizing that and trying to set those dollars aside and hopefully also we then we look at that in context. Here's three or four programs, which ones have the highest priority for the council use of those funds?
1:30:02 Which ones are the recommendations coming forward from the various bodies, chamber, Mammoth Lakes Housing, others, in terms of their recommendations for use? And yes, you will have to make some difficult decisions in some of that programming work. The parcel dollars are really just an estimate now. We believe at the end of the day, it'll end up being the half a million, 750 plus minus more. Until you get into it, we won't know for sure.
1:30:29 Discussions with Grady and some of the elements on this is if we're really going to do this right, move these projects forward and get some good on the ground information we need and the infrastructure and then some good designs and then how do we phase it? And then what we don't really know on this is the vast majority of the parcel work is going to be grant supported, we're assuming, and or private equity partners as who do affordable housing for a living to come in and do something. Our dollars is more for that front end planning work.
1:30:58 Front end design. What is the community going to accept and really hopefully be very excited about? We know based on some preliminary other work, it's, you know, that first phase four or five acres could easily run in the 40 plus million dollar range. And so that's not going to happen without other funding sources. But we do need to be able to leverage dollars into that. So those elements are there. Again, if you wanted to split that 200 and 125 differently, that
1:31:28 Council policy could do that. And I'll defer to Councilmember Sauser's comment too as well. If there's concerns over the staff time and the amount, you know, do you fund one position or two positions? We can have that discussion as well. We're recommending the two to move that forward to do that. So I'm going to skip over the parcel update for a minute because I'll defer to Grady a little bit to walk through that.
1:31:55 And so, but as we get through that, the back of this, we talk about the housing program implementation is the need to do that. We know there's a growing need in the community. I think Tom's still here from the mountain, but maybe not. They've, you know, they're renting hotels in Bishop. We've had other staff that have challenged finding housing. We've had other, you know, private sector folks buying homes and now for their employees and stuff, you get the anecdotal people living in their cars and in the forest and camping and...
1:32:23 We see the impacts of some of that. We've had a few different vans parked in the parking lot out here by us here. People are spending the night in their vehicles. So we know there's a need out there and stuff, and how do we move this forward? Both looking at that short-term, but ultimately that long-term solution as well to get housing on the ground. I mentioned the two other projects identified in here that we believe will be coming forward.
1:32:47 Really looking at how do we get the right resources. And we did the discussion with the council in the strategic planning process. We spent some time on our whole idea of core services and the capacity that the town has to take on additional work. We are limited with the current staffing structure of what we actually can do. And so by providing additional resources, both in the staff side as well as some potential dollars for outside assistance in these areas.
1:33:13 I think it makes us all more efficient than that. I know it's hard to say let's fund more town staff. But if you really look at that capacity to actually achieve the things I think that are on the to-do list, it's going to be required. Or we can continue to muddle through, but there will be a certain level of frustration as the length of time that some of this process will take. And that's whether, you know, we're maximizing out of MLH and us and others. It's just there is some staff components.
1:33:41 With Mammoth Lakes Housing, they've been a good partner in this stuff, obviously. The contract that we currently have, we tried to structure that to really focus on what has been done and where we're trying to really make sure we don't fall behind in areas. To add additional capacity there down the road or whatever, there'd be an option to look at as well. But at this point, we're really trying to say, how does the town step up and really fulfill its role in these areas? And we do believe that there's additional staff capacity necessary to do that.
1:34:10 Somewhat highlighted in some of the project update on the parcel. I'm going to turn this portion over to Grady to speak to kind of where we're at, some of the elements that indoor, Sandra, whichever want to tackle part of this. But Grady, I'll start with you as the Director of Housing Parcel Development as well as Public Works. I am out of business cards, Dan, but I'm not going to order any with the title on it. I don't think we need to do that, but I appreciate it. A couple things. First, just in terms of status,
1:34:41 And I'll use the word only, which I don't like to use, but the only things we've done so far really is we have a contract with Kaiser Marston, which we have executed for some financial analysis that we're going to get started. We have RFQs out for both the planning consultant and for affordable housing consultant. Those are key members of the team. And again, I've described this to Council before, so I don't want to go through it in too much detail. But the first thing we do in this is really develop that team.
1:35:07 That's essential to getting this done. And when I describe that, it's been very difficult for me, frankly, and I'll admit it, it's been difficult to describe it, if you will, having spent a couple of decades, if you will, in that world, in the development world, both as a vice president of a development company, then as a consultant subject matter expert, if you will, for 15 years, so I am that subject matter expert.
1:35:31 It's still difficult to come before a group like this and say, okay, we're not, we're the owner, we're not the developer, but, and again, I'm going to go into a little bit more detail there, but this is really important. People misuse the word developer as much as they misuse consultant, frankly. You know, I don't like the word consultant that much either because people come in, I'm not sure what they did. Maybe they, no offense to planning documents, maybe they just gave you a book you put on the shelf and you never see it again. Maybe they're an economist, for gosh sakes, you know, those are consultants too.
1:36:00 You know, no thanks. But a subject matter expert really helps you lay out the road and how to get things done. We've had many discussions in my household, frankly, over the years about management and middle management. This speaks a little bit to what Bill said before he left. We're just adding staff, and staff is consuming the money, and I'll say that what he said was bureaucracy without a product. Well, he'll come in and kick me tomorrow in my office, but I'll take exception to that because without people like subject matter experts,
1:36:30 This stuff doesn't happen, okay? And we have not devoted the resources to this, frankly, at all that we need to do. And even at the Housing Summit, I sat there and I actually commented, Tom went through a great exercise talking about Eagle Lodge and saying how much money they spent before they did anything, and they haven't done anything. And it's millions of dollars in consultants, subject matter experts.
1:36:53 But in addition to that, the part that he didn't describe, which I'm going to guess, but I'm guessing I'm pretty close, is it wasn't just Tom sitting in a room talking to architects and engineers. They had the lift people. They had the concessions people. They had all the experts at the mountain who had to come in and give input to all those experts. That's what we're trying to do here. We have to have that team. We do know the road that it's going to take to get this done. We know it very clearly. We can't do it without...
1:37:20 Without any resources, the town's made an investment of $6.5 million in this piece of property right now, and since then we've had a little bit of staff time, and that's really it. I mean, we just haven't done it. And a developer, and I would encourage any developer in town, Mark Carney or anybody else to come in here and say, let me explain how much money we spent at Snow Creek before we created the first anything out there, or how much money we spent to build Sierra Star before we started anything.
1:37:48 It's a lot of money. It does take an investment. And it's not just the, quote, developer that builds the roads and houses and everything else. It's the entitlement process. We were struggling earlier today to try to come up with a name for that. And maybe you just want to talk, it was a bad word back in the 80s, but now it's appropriate for the town. Maybe we're just flippers. A flipper comes in, buys a piece of property, subdivise it.
1:38:15 Puts the bonds in place and then flips the different neighborhoods to everybody else and they make a lot of money doing that. I'm not suggesting the town's going to make a lot of money on that, but we're really flippers. We're the ones that are going to come in, do what Lori Best from Colorado said very clearly. One, decide what you want. Two, somebody has to be in charge of that. I'll be glad to be the one in charge at this point in time because, again, I am your subject matter expert. In addition, decide what we want. We haven't really started that yet.
1:38:44 I've actually been a proponent from the beginning of putting a land use plan on the wall and seeing what sticks. It's a double-edged sword because out in the community they say two things. One, oh, you've already decided what you're doing. And that couldn't be farther from the truth. But on the other hand, if you don't put something on the wall, they don't have any idea what you're talking about and they need something to criticize, critique is a better word, if you will.
1:39:07 So that master planning effort, a developer, if you will, the town can guide the process for the initial street and utilities layouts. We need to talk about product types. We need to talk about absorption. One of our goals, and I've laid this out in some of the earlier PowerPoints, is eliminating unknowns. And I want to emphasize this, and then I'll try to wrap it up and turn it over to Sandra. I'm getting out of the soapbox for a second.
1:39:32 When a developer comes and looks at a project, the one thing they do not like more than anything else is unknowns. Eliminate every unknown you can, and you'll get more interest, you'll get more secure deals, and if you have the expertise to at least know what they're talking about, which Andy assures me he's done a lot of development agreements, and I've written them on both sides, frankly. If you call the city of Escondido, they're still mad at me, but that was a long time ago. But the point is, eliminate unknowns.
1:39:59 Through our due diligence, the first thing we did, we did a title report, we did a phase one, now we're doing topo maps, boundary surveys, engineering stuff with utility, anything that can eliminate unknowns. So when a developer gets here, he goes, okay, what do you want? We want this number of units, plus or minus, times will change as we move through this project. It's not going to be stagnant. If we think we know exactly what the land uses are going to be today, in five years, maybe we're in phase three by then, or phase four, they're going to be different.
1:40:29 It's going to change. So we need to have the vocabulary to do that. But our job is to eliminate unknowns so developers and actual builders would be interested in that. I think I've covered all my scald notes. But the first thing we need is resources to get started. We've talked in our parcel development team about, well, gee, what about this? What about that? We don't even have somebody who can stand up on a whiteboard, make it look right, and then produce a document that we can bring before you like the ones that were on the wall. They aren't there now.
1:40:59 I'd even start talking about it. We need help. We need the resources. I can assure you we have the expertise to manage this process, and I'm not afraid of being called a manager or a bureaucrat or whatever. Without us, stuff doesn't happen. It just doesn't. So I guess I'm giving facts but also imploring you that we need the resources. Otherwise, nine months it's been since we've closed on this thing, two weeks short of nine months anyway.
1:41:27 We don't have a lot of deliverables to show for it, and that very much frustrates your team here in town staff, and we want to get started in earnest, and we think we can get back to you quickly. Once we get started, once we have an agreement with a planning facilitator or a planning consultant, we think we can get back to you quickly with a more solid plan and get this thing, get some momentum. So you didn't kick me at all. You were supposed to...
1:41:51 Go ahead. The only other thing that I have to add is just kind of briefly is that on the public engagement front that we've got a contract with our public engagement firm, or not a firm, but software called Bang the Table. I think we've talked about that before. So we're finalizing all of that this month, and so we anticipate that we'll be able to kick off kind of that component of the public engagement next month. So a dedicated website for this project and then for other projects as we move forward with them. So that's all I had to add.
1:42:22 Okay, thank you. Right now, do we have any questions for staff from Council? Okay. I'm going to go ahead and put it out to the public then. And no surprise. Good evening again, Councils. Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain. Yeah, you know, I think we've had this discussion before that there's a lot to do and there's nobody to do it.
1:42:57 You know, I think it was a great staff presentation, and I definitely support the staff's position that they need resources and help to get this done. As Grady alluded to, you know, we've done some big projects. We just finished a multi-million dollar renovation at Canyon Lodge, and there was a lot of expense with just project management that didn't put any bricks and sticks, build them.
1:43:26 Or pay, you know, for the subcontractors to put them in, but somebody who has to manage the process and make sure that the things get designed the way you want them and they get built and executed the way you've designed them. So, I mean, it takes real time and effort and, you know, those expenses can be 10 to 15 percent of the cost of, overall cost of a project. So, I mean, recognize that you guys are talking about, you know, 300 to 400 units on a 25 acre parcel. You're talking about, you know,
1:43:56 Millions and millions of dollars, I don't know, total numbers on that, but I don't know, 50 million, I don't know, something, it's a huge number, more than that. I haven't read the numbers, but so yeah, I think you definitely, you guys definitely need the horsepower to get going on this, and if we really, you know, that we know that we're already in a deficit of housing units that we need for the community, we need to kick this into high gear and get going. I think the recommendation, you know, I,
1:44:26 The two positions that are being asked for, I think it's going to allow Grady more time to engage on this. And I think you really need the skill set that's really development management set of skills. I was actually asked by somebody else at large about my opinions on what the skills that we need, and I found a senior project management housing development job description that I forwarded on.
1:44:52 You know, it's a development manager, and there's a wide breadth of skill sets that you need to do. I mean, you have somebody who has understandings of construction and development and has the ability to, you know, work with a master planner and retrain consultants to design or, you know, subdivide the property and design the infrastructure that you need to support the development of it and then manage the, if you guys, when I think it's a good path to go, is to break it up into pieces that you can then entice
1:45:20 You know, development interest to come in and build portions of it, and then you manage those contracts and so forth. So I think it's all appropriate. I think you're going to need more money allocated to the actual outside consultants for the parcel eventually. You know, $200,000 for the remainder of this year is going to probably barely be enough. I mean, you probably need a little bit more than that, but I know you guys are limited by your funding. I think that it's prudent to...
1:45:48 I think it's something that the community needs to start recognizing that
1:46:15 We need more money for housing. We have a housing gap. We're in a unique community with a resort-based community where we have people who can buy second homes and drive housing prices up. So we have to be able to subsidize housing to make it affordable for our local workers. And that's going to take money. And hopefully we can leverage that and obtain grants to build the parcel out and get some good funding to help.
1:46:43 Leverage our money by, you know, who knows, maybe we're 10% matching and we get 90% funding on certain projects. You know, those are things we've got to figure out with the help of the professionals. But point being is, you know, our peer resorts are getting more, you know, Breckenridge told us they're $3 million a year from local tax sources that fund housing in their community. I think Aspen has a similar amount of money that they're receiving from different sources of revenues from the community from different sources of taxing.
1:47:13 We need to have that discussion. I have some opinions about that and think that we can probably pull that from excess TOT that we're already collecting. And just recognize that housing for our community, for our workforce is the number one priority of this community. And nothing else is going to happen unless we address this issue as quickly as possible. We need to build our foundation for sustainable economic growth in this community and achieve all the things we want to do.
1:47:39 This is the first, most important step. So I fully support staff's recommendation and recommend that you guys move forward and start putting your money where your mouth is. Thanks. Thank you. Any additional public comments on this? Ken Bringle, Executive Director of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. And we've been coming before you concerning housing for a while now.
1:48:16 We put together a proposal. We were calling it the Mammoth Lakes Housing Action Plan, and people got confused with the Community Action Plan, so we changed it to the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce Workforce Housing Program. I sent the information to Sandra and Dan. I have copies if anybody would like to have it, but it basically has what our proposal is.
1:48:45 A job description for our workforce housing coordinator and a budget, a three-year budget starting in January of this year, basically asking for $28,000 for the rest of this year and then $50,000 for each of the next two fiscal years and then from July of
1:49:14 I'm talking about 2021. I can't believe it. 2021 to December of 2021, $25,000. What the Chamber is putting up is one-third of basically from that. We're putting up $25,000 during the full fiscal years and $12,500 for that six-month period between July and the end of 2021.
1:49:44 Again, I would like for this to be agendized maybe at the next meeting. It's our proposal. Our board has stepped forward and said we're willing to step forward and make some things happen. Yes, it is more of the short term, but it's also some issues that are going to take some time for us to get coming up with the money to...
1:50:09 For the business community coming together to buy properties. They're looking at how do we subsidize property management to encourage short-term rentals to move to long-term. We provide subsidized property management. I know that John has brought some people forward from
1:50:33 South Lake Tahoe and North Lake Tahoe with a program that would hopefully tie in with our website about roommate matching, finding, tying in with rentals and so forth. So we've got to go through all that and ours is we do need a person on staff we feel to do that. And like I said, we're willing to fund one third of it and we'd like to have the town fund the other two thirds.
1:51:00 Again, we'll have the information for you, but if we could agendize it for the, I guess it would be the December 16th, our January 16th council meeting, we would appreciate that and have the debate at that time about what we're willing to offer and what we're willing to hopefully put together a program. Thank you. Thank you. Any more public comment on this subject?
1:51:33 Okay. Now I'll go back to Council and love to hear your comments. I'm happy with this. I'm good with this. I'm hoping that we can deliberate what we have to, but I think it's critically important to move forward with this. I'd like to say that I think Tom said it best that we have to put our money where our mouth is. This breaks my heart because I don't like spending money.
1:52:01 I am one of the people, I do not like the term consultant, I think that that, I believe you came up with the subject expert, and I think that that is what we are lacking. I would consider if this is something that we have to do at the same time, is there somebody that we can have as a senior planner, the housing coordinator, have them start, and then also in a part for
1:52:28 So they would have some part in getting the associate because I think that they would be working very closely. I could be wrong on that. This has been a subject of our priorities, not only for the town council, but the community and housing is our number one priority. And this is the time to put our money where our mouths are. And it's going to...
1:52:55 So those are my comments. See if I can get through this without choking here.
1:53:29 One of the key factors for me is considering the current workloads, the current workloads that were in place when we actually purchased the parcel and understanding that people were at that point working at full capacity. We then added this large purchase and in the meantime, staff in the interim nine months, staff has been trying to accommodate and to work on this and as stated with
1:53:54 Not huge amounts of progress because you don't have the horsepower to do that. The regular work continues. You don't have time to just stop what you're doing over here and suddenly focus on the parcel. I think that's pretty important. And I agree that this is where our strategic priority of expanding availability and affordability of community housing, which consists of projects both large, such as the parcel, and small, such as
1:54:22 The Community Housing Action Plan and some of the smaller, looking at ADUs, looking at short-term to long-term, some of the things. This is expensive. I think we knew when we bought this parcel that that was not going to be the last expenditure we had. And trying to move our money and look at ways in which we can hire these two positions, it's replacing Ruth, which is already in the budget.
1:54:48 It is beginning to, you know, take some things we thought were going to work, some specific sparks, such another, you know, we looked at doing the housing coordinator, that sort of we can take that money and now point it at these two, I think, well, better defined positions that can step in and begin to not only free up current staff to focus more diligently on the parcel, but to move us into the next steps. This was not going to happen.
1:55:16 For free. This is not going to happen without added resources. It worries me, are we going to be able to afford it next year? We can afford it now, but what does next year look like if something happens or there's some sort of financial struggle? There's nothing for sure, but for now, in this day, I think we can move this part forward. I think Tom made some good points. He's been through this and experience and how much it takes to move it.
1:55:44 Our subject matter experts, it's like you wouldn't go to your dentist to have brain surgery. He might be a really good dentist, and he knows a lot about brains, but you really, I think, handicap yourself by not getting the right people at the table to give you the right answers, and then you're trying to learn as you go. I mean, these are philosophical discussions as well as practical. So, for myself, I think that...
1:56:08 For the moment, we could do this in the future and every year at the budget season. Every quarter when we report on budget, we're going to have to take another look at it and make sure that we're still on solid ground and we're not taking unnecessarily risk with our financial stability for the town. So I think those are the comments that I have today. Thank you. Thank you. I disagree with the approach the town is taking.
1:56:36 First, the agenda bill reads as if it's going to be the partial developer. And if you look at that staff report and the hiring of staffing and everything else, then it certainly does demonstrate that. Second is, as good a staff is, and I'm very complimentary of staff, they are not housing developers. Sandra and Grady need to run their departments first. The town also needs additional staffing just in the planning and the community development.
1:57:04 I mean, we need additional staff. And we just lost a crucial person, a critical person in there. Third, the town needs to bifurcate the parcel from the town's service levels. The parcel is an independent project.
1:57:20 Providing service levels is another aspect of what the town does. We need to make sure our two departments are providing the service levels that are currently expected. The parcel, again, is a separate issue. Fourth, the workforce housing, and this is important to understand, the workforce housing state legislation
1:57:44 It's a bureaucratic maze. Governor Brown just signed 15 pieces of housing legislation that were enacted at the beginning of this year. Brett Metcalf, who is the Director of the Community Housing Department of California, is now putting pressure on anybody that changes your...
1:58:05 Housing Element. He can come in and stop the development. So if we put anything else on the shady rest parcel or the parcel, the state can actually bring us to a halt. Let me try to explain. This is my fifth point, and this is an informational. A housing development developer
1:58:27 And I'm talking about a developer, addresses most, if not all the tasks identified in the staff's agenda bill. So if you look at staff's agenda bill, if you bring a housing developer in, a workforce housing developer will incorporate into any proposal
1:58:42 First of all, Prop 1, which just passed, $4 billion, mostly for veterans, but it also has an affordable housing element. Cap and trade, which is a competitive grant. The CDB grants, which are competitive. Home grants, which are competitive. The income housing tax credit, low housing tax credit. There's another whole component of this that we can't go after.
1:59:09 Any kind of units above 120. So there's some real interesting thing. Bonding, measure 2002A. You know, providing this grant writer.
1:59:20 You know, it's not something that we really want to get into doing and adding all these different staff to go on to do these two things. My recommendation to council is, one, direct staff to bifurcate town staff's needs and town staff's levels from the development. So we have two different things that we're actually talking about, development of the parcel and making sure that staff is meeting the community needs as far as
1:59:48 Processing developments and everything else. Number two is the town needs to put an RFP for a workforce housing developer for just four acres. This has already been done by Mammoth Lake Housing. So if you look at this...
2:00:03 If you do it in parcels, here's the first parcel right here. It would be 42 units. And the cost, we've already costed it out with it. This was two years ago, $27,813,000. And the third thing is the town needs to work with the owners of Mammoth Mall as well as Mammoth Lake Housing to get those two. There's 13 units that might be developed at the Mammoth Mall.
2:00:33 For Sierra Manors, there's 11 units. So I think that town staff should not be looking at staffing up. We should be looking at getting a housing developer to come in that addresses all the needs that town staff is doing. I've been doing this for a long time. This is the way Mammoth Lake Housing has done it in the past, and I think that we're going down the wrong road. Thank you. So thank you, Madam Mayor, if I could.
2:01:04 I would like to propose a motion. And if I could, I would like to propose that the Town Council adopt a resolution amending the fiscal year 18-19 budget by increasing the funding for the housing programs and planning department.
2:01:19 100-445 from $577,344 and $922,343 as provided in attachment A and to one, authorize the town manager to hire two additional personnel, one associate engineer, one senior planner housing coordinator, two, approve the use of up to $200,000 for subject matter experts, consultants for work related to the parcel project, and three, dedicate the use of up to $125,000 for housing programs with specific programs subject to council approval.
2:01:48 And I would request that the proposal coming from Mr. Brangle be agendized for January 16th. That's our next meeting, if practicable by all parties. That's my motion. Second. At the front end of that, John, I think you hit it, but you mentioned adopting the resolution, correct? Correct, I did. I believe I did, yeah. If I may on that, just the last item.
2:02:24 If you could take the chamber presentation separately, I think that would help us just in terms of the work program. That would help me as well. Okay, sure. No problem. I will drop the mention of the January 60th amendment of that for staff's request. Okay. Roll call, please. Oh, excuse me. Discussion? Question? I think we can do discussion after roll call. Can we do it beforehand? No, I need to do further discussion before we call the vote. Okay, further discussion.
2:02:54 And I guess, Kirk, do you have anything that you'd like to say about that? I think doing the, I mean, this is what Tahoe does. Tahoe is a purchase, the railroad yard, and they're tearing up the tracks. They do it a piece at a time. And the discussion up there, I did have a half an hour discussion with a housing person up there. The discussion in, they do it in parcels.
2:03:26 The community, when they discussed this, the town staff said,
2:03:30 We're not going to touch this. We need to go to an outside people that specialize, that go after the grants, that go after all the different funding tools that are necessary. And it needs to be a focused effort. We own the property, so we'd be able to lease it to a developer for a dollar a year, and we'd be able to drop the fees that are normally charged, not the water, the school, and that sort of thing.
2:03:58 This is the way to expedite it. If housing is supposed to be a crisis in this, then we need to get the developer on board now, not going through all these, oh, we have to do all these different steps. That is what a developer does. A developer already does these steps, community outreach and everything else. I've been doing this for 15 years, and this is the way we've done it in the past, and I think that we're taking a path that I think is going to
2:04:27 And exacerbate the time that it's going to take to actually get product on the ground. So, Madam Mayor, the only thing I would add is that the staff report, the agenda item, is wholly consistent with the Community Housing Action Plan as accepted by the Town Council. I don't understand why we would go through hundreds of thousands of dollars of investment from outside partners to do something like this, to do through the community engagement process that we've done.
2:04:52 To put on housing summits, to have staff working on things, committed, consistent with a document that we've already adopted, why we would all of a sudden take off and go that way. So my motion stands and I look forward to a vote on it. Thank you. My one comment on that would be, Kirk, I understand what you're talking about and I do think incremental building is the way. However, I do think that it has to be
2:05:19 We can't just have small pockets. It has to be the overall plan, and that's what I'm looking forward to, and then incrementally build from there. I'm worried about some of the infrastructure and the overall look at the end of it, and that is my comment. Madam Mayor, there would have to be a master plan. There is one now. But the way it moves forward is with
2:05:46 You know, in parcels. I mean, there's six parcels there that would be developed. And so, you know, yeah, there is a master plan that has existed for 35, 40 years on it. It has a certain density and everything else. That has been gone to a public vote in the past to reaffirm it because there was a big discussion over that. If I could, Madam Mayor, that's not in our...
2:06:11 That's not in that agenda, this agenda on this evening. No, no, that's fine. And no, I'm glad that we're on the same page with that. So I'm done. Does anybody else have any input for this one? No. Okay. We'll go ahead and the recommended motion is as written in the agenda, correct? Correct. Okay. Roll call, please. Yes. No. Yes.
2:06:35 Yes, motion passes 3-1. Now, if we can please have... If you want to address the question of the chamber item, for any direction to us, that would be... Madam Mayor, it's just a request that the chamber item, which is referred to in the back part of this agenda, be agendized for January 16th, should that be practicable between the chamber and town staff working together. I think it's critically important, and Mr. Sauser's comments...
2:07:01 We've talked a lot about development, building, things that are many years out. This item is an opportunity to start getting things on the ground as quickly as possible. And I think in the interest of the community, I request that we get this agenda for January 16th. Do we also have an agenda item proposed to a discussion with MLH, Mammoth Lakes Housing? They had a discussion at their last board meeting, and I don't know the timing on the planning for bringing that forward, but I'm assuming it was coming relatively quickly. I don't.
2:07:30 So perhaps agendize not at the same meeting as we have the discussion around? Okay. That's up. I'm not sure the timing on that coming forward. I'm assuming it would be from the discussion. These are not competing items. Well, if I could make a motion on that, I would prefer to kind of look at the timing that we have and some of the other things that are moving forward.
2:07:56 I think that may be pushing it just a little bit to meet in January. If I could, Madam Mayor. So up in Lake Tahoe, South Lake Tahoe, North Lake Tahoe, I met with people who used to work at Airbnb. They have a very specific technical skill set around putting together a web-based platform that will specifically address the program Linda and I serve on that steering committee with the chamber.
2:08:22 To start moving this stuff forward. This is a specific thing that was talked about at the Housing Action Summit. And by agendizing, we're not approving it.
2:08:31 I'm just in the interest of getting things on the ground as quickly as possible. I'm hoping we can put that on the agenda for the 16th if Ken and his team and the town staff can work together to get a credible agenda item here so we can start to move forward. I'm hearing Bill's comments here about, well, we're hiring people and doing all this kind of stuff. We need to get things on the ground now. And I would really like to...
2:08:53 Give the opportunity for that project, this proposal to move forward, to come to us so we can start doing some things in a timely fashion. And I would request that of you. We've deferred to other council members to get things on. I'm not asking for a new item. This is something that's in the current agenda. And I would just like to see if we get the agendas for the 16th. Do you need consensus or do you want to... Yeah, it'd be nice if we have at least, you know, we're trying to work as things get requested to come forth. There's, you know, at least...
2:09:24 Majority of the three, four of you sitting there to look at this item then. I think it's, it'll come forward as a request from the chamber ultimately, so getting some direction from the council for the timing for it to hit you. If, I like the idea, if we don't have it ready for the 16th, it won't be on the agenda. It's not ready, it's not ready. We have something, yeah. We can make it happen. That's a month from now, so I think. Yeah, if we can get it together and we can get something in front of us that we can move housing forward and get people into housing units, I think it's probably a good idea.
2:09:52 So I'd appreciate if that's a consensus of the council to do that. Yeah, we'll consider it if there's going to be. If it's ready, it looks like at least three of you are saying okay to bring it back. So we'll take that as direction there. Sure. So to work with that in partnership. So thank you. Okay. Well, then I think that you have a consensus on that. And with that, we are going to take a 10-minute break. We'll be back at 8.20.
2:11:02 I know, and it's all, I'll be submitting, all my invoices, I'll submit to Dan, and it's all. Yeah. It's a pretty good deal, actually. That's me remembering who it was. That's fine. It may not happen. That's fine. It's a pretty good deal. Yeah, no, that's fine. I mean, I represented you well. Well, there's no, I mean, there's no lodging expenses, no travel expenses, other than just, like, one flight from Florida to there.
2:11:29 Some gas. I mean, it's not. Yeah. And we didn't have a reporting out or a counting. Yeah. What's that? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Okay. We are now going to get back to the subject at hand. Bang the gavel.
2:11:57 Okay. I would just like to start this as John pointed out at the beginning of the meeting. These are response to council requests, and so please keep that in mind. When it comes to public comment, please limit your comments to five minutes. If you are just reiterating what the person ahead of you said,
2:12:25 Just say you agree. I'd like to hear different versions of I'd like to let me reword that. I don't need to hear different versions. I would just like to if you're in agreement, you can leave it at that. If you have a spokesperson that's going to be giving the overall information, that is good. Please do not be upset if I end up having to cut you off. I do want to keep this running. So we will now go on to
2:12:55 Agenda Item 11, update on status of the woods at Mammoth Lakes, previously known as Sam's Woods, property located at 5699 Minaret Road, Mammoth Lakes, California, 93546 APM 033-100-039-000, and summer 2019 special events location.
2:13:21 I'm going to go ahead and hand this over to Dan, I believe. Yeah, thank you, Mayor. The item is here. We've had a couple different requests and discussions related to the wood site. I think at the last meeting, if you look back at the minute, I think Member Sauser requested some level of discussion of the item. Mr. Stapp has mentioned it in the past as well as being able to talk to this.
2:13:42 As we bring these forward items and these types of requests, we haven't had a ton of staff analysis in time. That's why you won't have a detailed staff report, but we can address some issues that we're aware of or hopefully assist informing the council. And the worst part is, I mean, this is a forum to do this in. We can't sit down with you all somewhere else or, you know, those types of issues. So that's the other reason for these types of items falling here is just all five of you can hear it at the same time and be able to work through that.
2:14:12 So as you're aware, the woods at Mammoth Lakes is referred to at this point with the current owners. It's been listed for sale. It's our understanding that they do have a couple of very interested buyers in the project and are going through that whole process. Again, we're not privy to that, but that's at least understanding from that. But nothing is done. So it's still being held there. Also, it is in subject...
2:14:40 The agreement for funding for the event site with MLT has gone to court or the suit's been filed, which has also created some challenges in the purchasing of the property, escrow, those types of discussions, which hasn't been resolved, obviously. I think they have a court date in January. So our understanding of some of that, again, we're not a party of litigation and we're not a party of the selling of the property. So some of this is...
2:15:07 Discussions and comments that are coming forward, but to the extent that we can speak to it without overstepping our knowledge or authority here, we want to be able to do that. The selling of the property, again, concerns, et cetera, and MLTs, legal issues. One thing we have requested through the brokers on the selling of the property, we would anticipate that nothing would be done next summer.
2:15:32 If someone's to buy it for development purposes, is there a way to continue to allow for events next summer? I think that is a likely outcome. Again, we're not in the room to guarantee that, but as things to be supported from the broker side of the house, that that would be a continued effort to allow for events next summer as part of whatever sales agreement would go forward. That would be something definitely we request. Again, we have no authority to enforce that.
2:15:59 I'm not sure what will happen to the litigation side. I know that's created some challenges and has to date at least I think one of the reasons why there is not an agreement in place today for the use of that site this next summer. The primary, there's three basically events that get held on that site or between the two parcels there. The largest one being Bluza Palooza. Sean Turner's here and he can speak to the.
2:16:24 Number of attendees and the elements there in the process for that. My understanding, I believe he is going forward with ticket sales. There's a good head nod. He can speak to that as well. Our concern there is I honestly believe that the wood site will likely be the viable site for that. The other two events are the Shakespeare in the Woods and the Labor Day Arts Festival, both kind of staple events for the community.
2:16:51 The other question we had, though, was should something happen either to the litigation process or the purchase of the property, et cetera, that we don't have control over, if that parcel was not available, the other two elements the town could look at would either be doing something on the parcel site, that would be allowed use, looking at the bell-shaped parcel as a potential use there, or really working with private sector side.
2:17:19 Most likely maybe one of the mountain venues. There's some challenges there. So should we need a plan B or plan C for Blueza Palooza, any comments from the council in that area would be beneficial. So we could plan accordingly and deal with the community accordingly in terms if we were to shift it from that other site. Again, we don't have a good feel on the timing that we all know that. Hopefully it's sooner than later. But we did want to be able to give the council an update on that.
2:17:47 There's been discussions back and forth in terms of the town's interest in the property, et cetera. This is a real property negotiation element here on the agenda, so I can't really speak to that in detail, but again, the current owner of the property is in negotiations on the seller site, and we obviously are not a party to that purchase or agreements. So I want to be able to give you the update there, the one question being, and I'll let parties in the audience speak accordingly.
2:18:17 But we did want to bring the council up to date where we're at. The owners of the parcel, in terms of who hold the note, have expressed interest to individual council members that if the property was open and available back to them, if they were to reacquire the property, that they'd be interested in working with the town on it, that would be a future item should that happen. At this point, the note holders do not own the property or control the cell, is my understanding.
2:18:45 But that would be something down the road should that happen. That would come back to Council for discussion should there be an interest in doing so. So that's the update on this that we have tonight that I'm aware of. Again, some of this is kind of a moving target, if you will, in terms of the activity going on around that site. So I can answer questions to the extent I have the information or some other folks in the audience may have more information than we currently have.
2:19:12 Okay, I just want to clarify with Andy. Sorry to put you on the spot here. Since I am on the MLT board, is there any area of this conversation that I will need to recuse myself? No, you don't have to recuse yourself because of the nature of MLT's relationship with the town. Okay. My understanding is you don't receive any compensation for being on the MLT board. Not legally. No, just kidding. No.
2:19:35 That was a joke, people. No. Excuse me, I think I fainted for a second. Because you don't receive any compensation, it's not a political reform act conflict, and because of the nature of MLT's relationship, it's not a conflict under something called Government Code Section 1090. So you're okay. The only tricky juggling act that you have to do, you in particular, is remembering that you can't tell us what happens in their closed sessions, and you can't tell them what happens in our closed sessions, which you've managed to avoid doing so far. So thank you.
2:20:03 I'm doing a great job at that. Thank you very much. Okay. Wonderful. Thank you. Okay. With that, questions for Dan. I really have no questions. I have some comments. Okay. So let me go ahead and let's see. I think I'll go ahead and put it out to... Mayor, I do have one question. Okay. Good. When is this going to court?
2:20:30 You said January? That was my understanding. I don't have the dates in front of me, but last I heard there was a January. I'm not sure. Sorry, I defer to Andy, a legal process, but I think there's two things scheduled. The first one would be either summary judgment type request or whatever the process would be, and then a follow-up. I haven't been following the litigation. I don't know if anyone's made a motion for summary judgment. I don't know if they're having status conferences. I don't know if there's a trial date. I just don't know. Thank you.
2:20:57 Supposed to be the first hearing in January is all I was aware of. Sometime in the middle of the January there's a scheduled meeting for a deposition for the members to be deposed. I don't know what part of the legal process that is. I just know that's happening in the middle of January and the hope is we will have a better sense of what direction it's going to go after that, if it makes any sense. Yeah, if you could do public comment and bring it back to the board for the council for discussion.
2:21:28 Oh, yeah, no, I was mulling over a question if I'm trying to think if I'm sorry, I'm trying to balance two closed sessions. So I will see if there's something in January, there's something in January. So now public comment time for the wood site, please. For the woods at Mammoth Lakes.
2:21:56 Hello, Council. Thank you. I'm Sean Turner, owner of Mammoth Marine Company and Bluza Palooza. I also sit on the MLT board, and Cleland, well played. That was a good line there. However, I recused myself during all of these discussions, so I am very specifically not involved in any of the discussions going on with regard to the lawsuit. The biggest thing that I think I really wanted to say at this time, and then I'll just make myself available for questions.
2:22:25 Is that Bluza Palooza is taking a heck of a risk in the sense that we are putting our tickets on sale tomorrow. And we're very excited about it. We actually have a couple of fantastic music acts actually verbally on hold, nothing committed yet, but very excited about those announcements that I hope we're going to be able to make in January. And we are taking the leap of faith that this will be resolved here within the next couple of months.
2:22:54 By putting our tickets on sale, we're actually doing a fairly steep discount initially just because we're asking the public to take that leap of faith with us. But I do want to say that as a business owner, especially in a very risky business of events, and I can go into all kinds of details about the risks that we face from weather to ticket sales to marketing to our competition out there,
2:23:21 It's a little bit, it's, I gotta tell you, and it came up in the earlier conversation about businesses do not like uncertainty. I am looking for stability. I'd like to know what my line item is going to be for the next several years. And it is preventing us from making true investment in this event to grow it when we don't even know if we have an event site seven and a half months away.
2:23:48 From when we are putting on this huge event. And we really, I would like to be looking at a contract that is two to three to five years in advance so that we can be investing in growing a brand, Bluza Bluza. This is going to be our 24th year anniversary. I'll let Kristen speak to the 20th anniversary of Shakespeare in the Park and the 50th anniversary of Labor Day Arts Festival. And we don't know if we have a site.
2:24:18 And we're putting tickets on sale. Now, I will tell you again, we're very excited about this. We've got some new things that are going to come out for Belooza Belooza. And hope is not a business plan. And yet that's our current business plan. And right now we do not have a plan B. I welcome very much the thought that has been put out there about a possible plan B. Because if we get to late February,
2:24:45 And it is time to start executing on further contracts for that. That's decision making time. That's real decision making time for when we need to start executing on contracts for where we're going to be putting this. So if we get to that stage, I got to tell you, I'm a little bit nervous. So while I do not want to make any kind of comments on the property or the lawsuit, we've enjoyed where we've been at.
2:25:14 For the past 24 years, 23 years, and I hope that there is some kind of resolution, and if there isn't, I am wide open to suggestions for Plan B. Thank you. I'll make myself available for questions unless you have any right now. Okay. Thank you, Sean. Thank you.
2:25:39 Thank you, Council. I am Kristen Reese, and I'm here on behalf of Sierra Classic Theater as a board member and on behalf of Mono Arts Council as the Festival Director for the Labor Day Festival of the Arts. And I just want to say briefly that I agree with Sean in all of his comments. And I would just like to add for both Sierra Classic Theater and the 20th anniversary of Sierra Classic Theater and also Mono Arts Council, we have
2:26:09 Additional complications because we have very limited resources. Our capacity with Mono Arts Council is especially small, so the longer that things are delayed in a decision on a site makes it even more challenging for us to make plans. And the same goes for Sierra Classic Theater. So that's all I would like to add. Thank you for your time. I do have a question about that. When do you start your...
2:26:37 I guess you would call the jury for the people who are applying for the art show. We start the application process for the Labor Day Festival in January. In January. Okay. And then presently at the Wood site, you've been able to accommodate how many artists total? About 120. About 120? Yeah. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Public comment? No. Okay. Crickets. I'm going to...
2:27:12 Boot it back to Town Council, and now is a great time for your comment. You know, I sort of asked for this to come back because we have built our summers, and partially we have built them, and that has become our stability, but we've built them on special events and having things go on in Mammoth that are attractive. Not all of the events draw people here, but they give the people who are here enough to do that they come again. So I view these as hugely important.
2:27:41 And I wanted to just put the word out there because I'm sure after this meeting we will all be hearing from people about the possibility of us using town-owned property at either the bell-shaped or the parcel as an emergency backstop so that we don't lose these events this summer. These are critical to our financial success long term. Ask anybody in the promotion business of events, if you lose one year completely, you're starting all over again.
2:28:11 And chances are you're not going to ever get there. So this to me is just critical. And I wanted to let the people out there in town know that we are going to have to make these considerations because there's only two spots that we have any control over. For service process, if you want to do a special use permit, I mean, for something like this, you're talking 18 month minimum. So I just believe that this was really important. I wanted us to have the discussion some. So at least I would know the temperature of the council.
2:28:42 On the possibility of using some of our own assets to keep these things going. And the other sort of question I had, I had it set up so I could have had a phone conversation with Mr. Winters, you know, through some friends that are involved in the whole process. But then I got concerned about whether I'm overstepping where a council member should go. You know, if this was the past where I was an advocate for the thing, I would have jumped in with both feet.
2:29:13 But back in those days, Rick was sitting up here and I was sitting out there and it was a much easier place to sit. So I'm just unsure about that and wouldn't mind hearing because I have not been appointed as the council's representative to do anything and I'm not asking for that, believe me. The appropriateness of me representing town, if you will, I'm just, it's a slippery slope that I'm looking for input on.
2:29:43 Just as a general observation, you can say whatever you want as long as you make it clear that you're only speaking for yourself. If the council wants to appoint you to carry a message to them, I mean, can, but in general, one council member can't ever bind the town. It takes a majority of you. So it's up to the council about how you want to communicate with the relevant parties if you do at all. Or if we want to communicate at this point.
2:30:10 And bouncing off of that, I'm not really sure, what would you do, beg? Come up with something that is... Because I like having all the facts in my quiver when I pull out the arrow to make my shot. I have not heard from Mr. Winter. I don't know what he is thinking. I don't know what his side of it is. I know the argument from the attorneys at the MLT side. I know where I personally sit on the issue. I don't know.
2:30:40 If Dirk would or would not have considered a different compromise going forward under a different format, I just don't know where he's sitting. Can we make a deal where we get a guarantee for next year regardless? I think it's important that there's two roles we can play that would be helpful. The first, oh, I'm sorry. There are two roles that we could play to be, I think.
2:31:04 I would caution about getting involved too much other than maybe just simple information gathering with
2:31:34 Thank you.
2:31:56 That would be my two cents, and that's, Sean and I have talked, I haven't talked with anybody to figure out how we can find some plan B's and some way to make this stuff work, but I think that's how we can be most productive. Okay. Kirk? I support maintaining the site, and I support Mammoth Lake Tourism, the direction they're taking. I don't know what else to do. Bill, if you have, you know, I support you stepping up, doing whatever you can do to...
2:32:25 To maintain it. And I do think that we do need to look for backstops, you know, what can we do as many options can. Whatever we can do to make these events successful, we've got to step up to the plate, find a location, whatever it happens to be. I don't know what else to say. I mean, we're not in control right now. I'm going to do anything I can do to support the events there.
2:32:55 I would concur that everyone said I have nothing really unique to add, but, you know, certainly we controlled the two pieces of property, looking at both of those to have available and to have thought about that before, you know, a decision needs to be made. You know, Sean, I applaud your moxie and sort of stepping up and, you know, going for it anyway, and whatever, you know, we can do to support that I think is essential.
2:33:22 Good thoughts. I think we're all basically on the same page, so let's just keep watching. I think all of us have been approached. I think we've all talked to different parties about this over the last weeks, and I have no great idea to solve this right now. I think we're just sort of stuck where we are. So it's us to try to provide, like you said, a safety net. Thank you. To your point, Bill, I would have to say
2:33:50 You know, feel free, as Andy said, to reach out as a person as far as Town Council getting involved in this at this point. I do not advocate that with Winter. However, I would like to, and this is going to be tough, and I know that there's going to be neighbors who are not going to be happy about this. I do think that we need to look at either a temporary solution, and that's going to be
2:34:20 The tricky part about that, we do have the parcel, we do have the bell-shaped parcel where this event could be held. However, Sean, when you did bring up, you know, that your goal would be to have a three-year contract, that would be, I believe, a little bit of a hard sell because, so I was just, I want to be very clear because when this goes forward, I don't want it to ever say, well, Cleland said that we're going to use
2:34:48 A site for the next 10 years for this. That's not what I'm saying. So I would really like to hear what my fellow council members and staff, how we can move forward and make a decision and go ahead and get a place. Like it, lump it. It may be noisy for a certain group of people. There may be parking issues. However, I do see
2:35:16 I mean, when you're talking 50 years for the art show and it has moved in the past, that is still very successful. Balooza Palooza, I can't even believe it's 24 years. And then for Shakespeare in the Park, which just gets bigger every year. So with this conversation, I would like to move forward towards finding a temporary home for these.
2:35:45 Even though it seems to me it would be a little bit simpler to have all of these on the same site, that isn't necessarily a given. So they could be, one could be on one site, another one could be on another site. So that's my two cents on that. That being said, it would seem to me that if we're going to move this forward at least on the first
2:36:14 Meeting in February, which I think is what the second, and I don't want to spend a whole lot of staff time on it, but there are some questions I think that, and I rarely do this, so staff I apologize, what it would take legally to use either of those, whether there's a CEQA process that has to be done or whether they can just be used.
2:36:43 And in what context? If I could, I think before we even get even talking about doing that kind of stuff is to sit down with the event promoters and say, look, here's some 25 acres of woods that has no infrastructure. Is this even viable? So before we even start getting into this kind of stuff.
2:37:03 You know, let's talk with these folks and see if there's anything that's even viable. And I don't, I'm a little concerned about the open-ended nature of this agenda item, and I don't want to, I mean, I appreciate the need to have this discussion. The need is obviously there, but I don't know if this is going to be the best forum to kind of figure out where we're going, but that's just my thought. Well, this was just a conversation start. I understand, but I wouldn't want to. Open-ended on purpose. Yeah, but I don't want to go.
2:37:29 Get into things that are silly. If I can just make a comment, and thank you very much, and you're right, the discussion is about the wood site, not necessarily about what a plan B may look like, but I will say that we've had the opportunity, Jim Vanko, Peter Corcoran of Sierra Vet Management, Dion, AG, and myself have had the opportunity to meet with Dan Holler and town staff, and we've made some recommendations that would make it a very easy
2:37:57 Plan B, and I want to be very clear that it would be a Plan B if we're not able to get to a resolution with the wood site for 2019 only. And Cleland, thank you very much for making that clear because likewise we've been talking about the three existing events that are legacy, well established, do bring so much and also give to non-profits that if we weren't able to come to some kind of
2:38:24 Understanding, say, by February, March, something like that, that we could go forward. And by the way, I just want to say that we will make anything work. I'm at this place where, you know, we, Mammoth Brewing Company, Peter Corcoran over there, we've made some incredible improvements, I would say, if I may say so, with regard to the wood site for turning it into the wonderful place that it is for events. And it's a great location.
2:38:54 It does lack some of the back of the house. We have to use the I-Star Church, Uller, and White Stag lot for back of the house, you know, that kind of thing. We've made it work. And I can make just about anything work. And I've made some offers, you know, making sure that we keep the fence line 100 feet away from any kind of residence. We've talked about some of these things that I'd be happy to follow through on to make this.
2:39:23 Truly, if we did have to go to a Plan B location, I promise you we would knock the socks off all the local residents in a very good way, I say that, in that they will be, we will, the town of Mammoth Lakes will be impressed that if we need to go to one of these other sites, I promise you that I'll make it very, we will make it very inviting for Bluza, Labor Day Arts Festival, and the...
2:39:51 Shakespeare in the Woods. And obviously we would need to, for us to take any action on anything, we need to see things. We need to see feasibility analysis and all kinds of stuff. So I would just encourage folks, I don't know what's going on with this litigation, I don't want to know what's going on with the litigation, but if we can start working on teasing things out, seeing what things might look like so that if there does need to be something back in front of us, it's ready, you guys have vetted it out, we can consider it. I think that's probably the most productive thing we could say this evening.
2:40:18 So this is just to provide directions, I think. Direction, but I do have, last year I do believe because of a rain event, the previous year you did get some supplemental money. Was that from a town reserve or was that from MLT or did that come? Yeah, it was not from MLT. We received a $25,000, Dan, let me ask you to help me exactly what it was called, but we got a $25,000 grant.
2:40:47 And this was the first year that Blue Sauser had ever received that money. The $25,000 special event funding. That was out of event funding. That was a separate application and process that went through that. So my only other question to that is how much are you going to hit us up for this year then? I've already submitted our paperwork and we asked for $25,000 again. Oh, okay. Thank you very much. And Cleland, actually, you know, I'm even going to make this offer right here from the podium.
2:41:15 I have to answer to my staff a little bit later on. You know, I would be, the money that we spend in right now, you know, again, I hope that we were able to come to some kind of resolution with the wood site. But if we needed to make an investment, Mammoth, Bluza Palooza, I'll say specifically in Mammoth Brewing Company, if we needed to make an investment in a plan B, as long as that money was going back into improvement of that site, we would do that. Again, this discussion is about the wood site.
2:41:44 Thank you. Thank you.
2:42:15 Thank you for considering bringing that back. Oh, yes, a public comment. I'm sorry. I get into my little thinking space there. Sorry. Hello. Shields Richardson, broker for the wood site and also broker for the Odeker site. So a point of clarification for everybody is there are two sites that are used. Okay. So when everybody is focusing on just the wood site.
2:42:49 There are two sites there that are being used. And, you know, I hope it's all resolved too. But, you know, we're not here to talk about litigation. I really don't know much about that. I just represent a couple of people that are looking at it right now. Thank you for that clarification because it is the two sites. Any other public comment on this subject? Okay. Then I'll go ahead and...
2:43:22 Turn to my council members and see if they have any final comments or if there's any direction that anybody cares to. You know, I think we have effectively educated. This way, I don't hear back anyway from people saying, geez, I never heard anything about this until the last minute. So at this point, I'm more than comfortable moving on to the next agenda item. I would concur. Thank you. My only comment is make sure that
2:43:56 If there's any zone, let's take the bell-shaped parcel, you know, that's zoned open space and everything else. Make sure you've done a little bit of pre-work, you know, Sean, on looking not just at the bell-shaped parcel but also the parcel. But you might also want to make contact with the foundation. Just to, and, you know, if there's going to be any kind of...
2:44:20 Something that has to come before council, a zoning, a permitting, or whatever, you know, sit down with staff and say, okay, let's go through the hypothetical, I don't get it, I want to use the bell shape, what is it going to take? And if I, you know, what is it going to take for the parcel? And I would talk to the foundation to see what options they might have.
2:44:46 So I want this to be successful. I hope the wood site is the number one. That's what I support. But I also get a little nervous. I thoroughly understand. And I just want to say on this real quick, yeah, I agree. Our first choice is the wood site. I hope that everything's able to be resolved. And if we were looking for a plan B, again, it would be for 2019, existing legacy events only, that kind of thing.
2:45:15 What we need to go into is if there's not any resolution, say in February, decision time, March 1st, that we would want to look at a site here in town that truly represents the eastern Sierra and everything that Mammoth Lakes has to offer. Because if you think about it, I don't want to do it in a parking lot. People don't drive up here from Southern California to be standing in a parking lot.
2:45:43 The number one comment we get is under the trees. Every single site here in town and even proposed for the future has some challenges. But those, I believe, are overcomable. And, Kirk, you're absolutely right that we would want to make sure we do all our research and that we do it right because if Blues-a-Palooza specifically and likewise Labor Day Arts Festival and Shakespeare in the Park, if we're going to switch to the risk of moving our event,
2:46:13 It's got to be better than it was before. And I truly say that not just for the brand that we are building that is called Bluza Palooza, Liberty Arts Festival, and Shakespeare in the Park, but it's the brand of Mammoth Lakes. It's got to represent what we are all here about. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Sean. Okay, with that, I think we can just do consensus that...
2:46:37 This is something that we're all going to be keeping in mind and keeping our fingers crossed and hoping for the best that this works out. And thank you for your time on that. With nothing else, I will go ahead and I'm going to move on to agenda item number 12. This is, again, a response to council requests. I see some familiar faces in the parking lot, in the audience. You can tell what's stuck in my brain from Sean's
2:47:07 Here, I'll give people, when you said parking lot, that just stuck in my head, sorry, so here, I'll give some time for people to leave here. Okay, and since we have just a few people in the audience that it looks like maybe you'll be talking on this, just again, don't be offended if I cut it short a little bit, but however, it doesn't, seems like.
2:47:34 I won't have to worry about people repeating themselves. So with that, I'm going to go ahead and turn this over to Grady Dutton, please. Yes, thank you. At the West Town Council meeting, I just asked that we bring back a report on the drainage situation and the trails. I have a brief two-page and a half staff report. I'm not going to read the whole thing. Hopefully, everybody's had an opportunity to do so. I just want to hit a couple of highlights.
2:48:00 First of all, in our number one, as evidenced by the letter from the National Weather Service, we weren't getting 2016-17 was a record in a lot of ways. I've even found some longtime locals that admit that it was a pretty big storm. I'll leave it at that. I also want to point out that regarding the type of weather it was, certainly there have been a lot of big storms and big winters and big snow years since
2:48:25 Town was incorporated since 1997, 0405, 5, 6, 9, 10, 10, 11. I mean, I didn't live here, but I was a visitor to all those. The difference between those years and this one is the type of atmospheric rivers that we did get. It was different. The rain on snow was fairly intense. Even the one in 97, which was a lot of rain on snow, overall, the snow year wasn't that big. It was just the happenstance of when it happened, and there's nothing we can do about this. 16, 17 will happen again.
2:48:55 Hopefully it's not for 30 or 40 years, but it will happen again. I'm hoping that it's not the new norm. And if anything, the things that Chris Swalcombe from National Weather Service said when he was here visiting about Mammoth and weather is that we are unpredictable more so than any place else in the state. Frankly, we are not as affected by El Nino and La Nina as a lot of places. We are also not affected as much by the north. We don't know what we're going to get.
2:49:20 That's different all the time. It makes it very difficult to predict, not just from a meteorologist standpoint, but from an engineering perspective on how do you design for these things. We can't design for 16, 17. It'd be like making 203 an eight-lane freeway for those few days out of the years that we needed it.
2:49:39 Number two, Mammoth Elementary School did complete a project in 2016. The town acted as basically an on-site construction manager for that. We did assist and recommend some change orders to that, which had to do with drainage, but we were not the engine of record and it was not our project, if you will. The school district has limited staff and on a number of occasions we've helped them by stepping in and doing that. They compensate us for some things. We do that for them because they don't have construction management staff on board.
2:50:07 Number three was a letter from Mr. Wood and Wood Law Group. We did receive that in August of 2017. It does mention a flooding event on February 8th. I'm not sure what's special about February 8th versus...
2:50:21 Mid-January and late January and earlier in February because there was rain and snow a lot of those dates, but we were happy to recognize that date is fine. The one thing that was not in that claim, which we thought we might get within a few months afterward, was detailed specifics on any damages that did occur.
2:50:43 I will tell you that I was out there in late January, as was our finance director, Rob Patterson, our engineering manager, our road manager, with shovels out in that area working. And we did see the waters moving through. We did see the, basically it was slush that was the hardest thing to move through there because it slows everything down. I did not witness a lot of damage to homes or anything. You know, everybody was out there working, the neighborhood, everybody. And I think if I recall correctly later in that year, I applauded.
2:51:12 The whole community, not just the Trails neighborhood, but the entire town for how they stepped up and had to deal with that. That was a rough period for everybody. Number four, I have met several times out on site and in the office here with members of the Trails, various people, whether it was at least one of the two homeowners that border on the easement that is directly from the elementary school two-wagon wheel and also in the office. In number five,
2:51:42 Yes, we did observe the storms this last summer. In July, we had, call it a gully wash or whatever. It was a significant storm event. It was a very short duration. And while the water was moving pretty fast, the system did work as designed. Number six, again, I don't want to go through each of the comments from both EL and from Michelle's notes, but I did comment on those. There were some statements, and I'm not...
2:52:08 By any means saying that they were intentional, but I wanted to make sure that it was clear that who did which project and when. Specific due to 6B3, if I could. We are willing to consider any reasonable engineered solution or improvement that either the association or one of the adjacent property owners comes up with.
2:52:31 It's my recommendation, and I close with that, that we don't think we do need to do initial design analysis or construction. Having said that, if the trails HOA or one of the property owners wants to suggest any type of improvement within that easement, we can certainly take a look at that, we can review it, and if it holds up from an engineering perspective, we can issue an encroachment permit. There certainly is a liability to that, and it's really up to the engineer who does that.
2:52:58 I would encourage them to have a civil engineer actually design anything that they do in that area. Having said that, and I'm going to stop my comments after this, having been a civil engineer in practice for many years and an expert witness, I'm not going to state for now that we've done a detailed hydrology study to look at the forensics of before and after these various projects.
2:53:25 That's a concerted effort. That's somebody where, frankly, I would hire somebody outside the town to do to put their license number on that and to do that detailed analysis because that's something you would typically do. We have not done that. What we have done is looked at the before and after, and it's our professional opinion without doing a detailed engineering analysis that the improvements to elementary school did actually improve the situation. It certainly changed it. And, again, unfortunately, it comes back to us to the weather.
2:53:53 And 16, 17, and it will happen again. We just have to be prepared for it as best we can as we are throughout town. With that, I'd be happy to answer any questions anybody has or respond to any other concerns you might have. Do we have any questions from town council? Yes, I have a few questions. It's the town's easement, correct? That's correct. On the map, it was dedicated to the public.
2:54:18 The public, as far as I'm concerned, was the town. There's nobody else that's going to be the public. So have we given written permission for them to work in the easement? Have we? Have we as a town given the trails permission to go in there and modify it or remove snow? Thank you. I think what Grady has said is that if the trails or individual homeowners
2:54:43 I think that there's a way to improve it. We would consider issuing them an encroachment permit, which is the form of permission they would need to go do that. I would like to add, Andy, that it's not an exclusive easement for use. Certainly the property owner has the use of their property, and they can come through, walk on it, do what they need to, mow the grass. In that easement. That's correct. But if they make changes to the drainage system, that they need permission for. Thank you. Okay, so if they're shoveling...
2:55:10 So if Michelle is shoveling snow in there and she injures herself, who's liable? That's a property owner on their own property, but I'll let Andy elaborate on that. That's certainly the position that we would take, is that a property owner engaging in activities on their own property would be liable rather than us. I have no further questions. I have a couple questions. So just to review, this work was initiated by Mammoth Unified School District.
2:55:45 The elementary school project? That's correct. Okay. And who was the engineer on that piece? It's not in front of me. I believe it was Triad Homes, and sorry, Tom, if I'm incorrect, but I believe it was Triad Homes. And the town served as construction management? That's correct. Okay. All right. That's all I have. Thank you. Grady, what I'm hearing a lot is that that project specifically funneled
2:56:19 Drainage water that used to go down Meridian into this drainage which it had not done before. Was there something in the project that did that? Was this done specifically for a reason? Or is that just layman's analysis and likely not correct? The only piece I'm aware of that was even close to Meridian, there was an existing
2:56:51 I'll call it soil swale, drainage swale that goes from up near where the multi-use path crosses over in that area that heads along the sort of on the east boundary of the trails, on the boundary between the trails and the school, the elementary school property. It was unlined, okay? There was erosion in that area and there was erosion through that path and in fact in a way where a lot of that water was actually cresting that and going into
2:57:19 Maybe it never made it to people's backyards because it absorbed so quickly or infiltrated so quickly, but that area was rock-lined. Now, that doesn't by any mean make it impervious. It just keeps it from eroding further. But I wasn't aware of any changes to that. Now, I've heard that there was a previous project that changed some work on Meridian itself, but that was in the years past, and I have not done a detailed analysis of that one. John, any questions? I don't have any questions.
2:57:49 I do have a question. I did see when this was going on, I did go out to that property a couple of times. At the same time, I did go to other properties around town. Depending on where this conversation goes, is this something that...
2:58:09 Other areas are bringing up the other flood areas in the Sierra Valley sites. There was some at some of the other condo complexes. I know even at my place I had flooding that I've never experienced in the 25 years that I've lived in that place. So my question is, maybe it's more towards Andy that with the discussion, it's actually just not, I mean, even though this is coming
2:58:37 Can this be part of a larger conversation about flooding issues when we do have a storm that we're not used to? Sure, you can have a conversation about that anytime you like. What the law considers to create liability is what's called a dangerous condition of public property. And that's been litigated extensively. There are a lot of things that go into it. So it's difficult to say.
2:59:07 So whether a 100-year storm, whether a particular improvement failing or not performing as it should in a 100-year storm, does that create a dangerous condition of public property? I don't know the answer to that as I sit here. If we were going to have some kind of discussion, I would ask that we do that with enough notice that we could sort of figure out what we're talking about. And also, of course, we'd want to bear in mind that this is a delicate thing that litigation
2:59:34 Could potentially be threatened. And so there's maybe a limit to how much we would want to talk about this in open session. Okay. Thank you. If everybody has their questions out there, I'm going to go ahead. I'm going to ask a couple more questions to Grady, if I could, please. Sure. Grady, we have a stormwater drainage system or a flood mitigation plan, if you will. I don't know what we call it, but I know we have one. Because I know the drainage by my house doesn't
3:00:02 We have not been able to upgrade that to what that plan calls for. The trails where we're talking about this swale, is this up to snuff with our plan? And I probably shouldn't have hijacked you without asking you that question first, but I apologize because it just came to me. It's okay. I don't feel hijacked. I try to answer with the information I have. If I don't know, I'll tell you I don't know.
3:00:31 We do have a stormwater master plan. In fact, it was recently updated a couple of years ago, and we're actually one of the leaders in the state on actually having a plan like this, which is making us eligible for some Inyo Mono Regional Water Management Plan funds that we'll be applying for in the future. Having said that, it did not identify anything of this size in the entire town. It didn't look...
3:00:53 Specifically at one, say, 100-foot section or one small section of the storm drain. It looked at the major components throughout town. As an example, it listed the two largest projects all the way up near John Muir and up in that area, which have significant erosion issues and things like that. And as soon as we do find a couple of million dollars, hopefully through those grants, we can start attacking those major issues. We did not identify something like this.
3:01:18 The one thing I do want to add, which is in my notes, forgive me, but in discussing things with the neighbors, we have tried to at least make offers and try to come up with some solutions that we could.
3:01:32 We have instructed our snowblower operators and some times at 3 o'clock in the morning they do miss to try to keep some of the snow out of that easement. I'm not going to say they're perfect. They're going to miss it again sometime this year. It's going to happen. But they are making those efforts and we're getting better every year. We've actually put different colored snow stakes there with blue on them, I think it is, so that they miss that. We've also asked the association, because they don't want the snow in that area, to two things. One is...
3:02:00 Okay, please keep the areas that we would typically use for snow storage clear in the neighborhood. It's very typical in some people's neighborhoods that people park five and six cars. This doesn't happen in the trails, but in other neighborhoods, there are five and six cars where we put our snow storage. So we've just asked the neighbors, hey, be sure you keep the areas where we can put snow clear. Additionally, the trails has one thing that's unusual is they have an actual lot that's set aside for snow storage. On the map, it's an HOA lot. I can't remember.
3:02:29 The number, but it's off on the north end as wagon wheel then turns go back east. It's a panhandle lot and it's available for the HOA, not for us, to use for snow storage. And we've offered, say, hey, look, if you can allow us to do so, we might even be willing to compensate you somewhat for using your property because we do that a couple of other areas in town. We could put some of this snow there instead. The difficulty there, and I've always been very frank with whichever neighbors I'm meeting with, is
3:02:59 Okay, but on a tough year, we might have a 30-foot pile of snow there. I'm not convinced the neighbors on either side are going to be very happy with that, so we'd ask them to, you know, to approach those guys and let them know that's happening. That offer still stands. That's something we'd be happy to do, again, if that works with the neighborhood. In addition, the easement itself, I'd say it's a multi-use easement, even though it's...
3:03:23 A drainage easement to the public. It's on private property. It is commonly used for school children to get to the elementary school. I don't think that's an HOA easement. I think the property owners there are just nice enough to allow that to happen. So I told the HOA, look, if you do suggest improvements in there, keep that in mind because as soon as you change something, you're going to have somebody else mad at you. We're very used to that.
3:03:48 So if we try to make improvements for drainage or if the HOA does, then somebody will say, well, now it's not safe for our kids, which it's not an actual easement for them at all anyway. It's just, again, it's a courtesy that the property owners decided to do and good for them, but that's separate. So thank you. I just wanted to fill in some of those. Yeah, and I do want to clarify on that because that's one thing when Kirk was bringing up that it's the town easement. I want to be very clear on that because I do have an issue with if there's any town liability.
3:04:18 I mean, I don't know that I can say that we would never have any liability under any circumstances. It's more complicated than that. But my understanding is that would be the homeowner's insurance for the way that that easement's being used. Yes, it should be. I mean, if we were to store snow on it, though, then we could,
3:04:51 We could be taking some action that could create liability under some circumstances. But as long as we're not the ones doing anything, then right, there's no liability for us. So if I could, Madam Mayor, I'm anxious to hear the people who waited for many hours. Yeah, I want to hear from the public. But I also want to just advise all of us that this item was brought forward as requested by a council member. I mean, the staff did not have time to do.
3:05:12 A definitive staff report on this. We're engaging. We want to try to find a solution to this. But we don't have, as a council, we don't have a definitive, I wouldn't look at this as being a definitive representation on behalf of staff to get to a solution. It's great to hear ideas and talk these things through, but I don't feel like I've got all the information here to be able to make a decision that's going to, you know.
3:05:33 Find the solution to all this. But I am very anxious to hear from folks who sat here for many hours. And I agree. And I think that this is something that I know that I've been talking with some of the involved parties for the last few years. And so this is something that it's good that we're all in one room and it's going to take a little bit of time, but we're going to talk through this and go from there. So I'm opening it for public comment. And E.L., are you going to be speaking as a homeowner or head of the HOA? Head of the HOA.
3:06:03 Head of the HOA. Okay, thank you. Here's five copies of stuff. Stuff. Okay. Again, Yael Smugin. This has become quite a contentious thing, and I don't know why. It's a problem. It needs to be solved. If you look at the first graph, or the first page, if I can get mine flipped open here, shows that 2016-17,
3:06:39 It was not a record year, so it shows that there were one, two, three years bigger than that year, one year that tied it if it didn't exceed it, three years that had tremendous water content in the snow. 88-89 is when the trail started. So we went through that whole period without any flooding issues whatsoever.
3:07:09 Hey guys, real quickly, so this is snow, not water content, is that correct? This is total snowfall. It's a snowfall, it's not water content. Not water content. Okay, thank you. But what's highlighted here is water content for the big years. So I'm proposing, let's quit talking about 2016-17 and talk about 2017-18, because we had the same problem. So forget the big year, forget the...
3:07:40 The National Weather Guy and what, I mean, I was trying not to be contentious, but the paragraph after what you quoted starts out, unfortunately, and you know where it goes from there, downhill, with reporting on the year, the water that year. So that, to me, is not a good representation. Okay. The town filed for an environmental study exemption.
3:08:17 Saying that they weren't doing much over there. But it does list drainage improvements are to be included. If you look, who's the responsible party? It says the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Department of Public Works. To me, it's clear that when changes were made to the parking lot, problems started. You could draw a line. 2016, they did the parking lot. 2017, we started having problems.
3:08:50 There's two sheets, both sides, that show the extent of the drainage system that was put in there. Before, there weren't curbs and gutters that show all the water just off the blacktop, not even mention Meridian coming down. So my feeling is that whoever put that soil in, either by luck or by good design, hit it right on and it worked fine.
3:09:22 But when a change was made upstream to that and nobody looked downstream, the system collapsed. So I think we need to have a solution to fix this problem for this winter and then next summer you need an engineered solution to take the water and get rid of it wherever you want. I don't think it should be on the trails to engineer a solution to put on property that the town owns.
3:09:53 I babbled enough. I do have a question. Are you currently having issues with it this year? No. We haven't yet, but we had a little dusting of snow Saturday or Sunday. At 9.30 in the morning, the dry well was about half full, and that was just water coming from the traffic, and that might snow, send it down that way. So if we had another few hours of snow, I think the...
3:10:22 The drywall would have filled, and then water would start over the edge. The blowing the snow from the street, the only thing that impacts is it's wet snow, it's hard to dig. But you really need to start at the school, it's almost exactly 250 feet to the culvert that goes under the street, and then it's almost exactly 250 feet to where it goes back under Meridian. If you don't shovel that whole thing,
3:10:55 It just floods. I mean, wherever you stop is where it comes up over the top and starts to run toward houses. You say it just floods. How much damage and how many houses are we talking about last year? Did you say last year was the same as the year before? Well, we shoveled it last year. We kept on top of it. Every time it started coming up, we, the trails homeowners, had paid to have it shoveled. So physically there was no damage.
3:11:24 It's just people can't sleep at night because I'm having, I don't mean to be contentious either, but I'm having some issues with this because of personal knowledge. Maybe I shouldn't have any personal knowledge. I was the snow removal operator at the elementary school for years prior to the fixing. Okay. And the water from Meridian always went down beside the driveway and into the drainage, into the trails. Maybe it wasn't supposed to, but I can tell you that it did. But it wasn't directed.
3:11:55 From Meridian all the way down, it could run every which way. No, there was an actual erosion stream bed that went down beside it until somebody would kick dirt into it later. The parking lot at the elementary school used to almost flood as well. In terms of last year, or 16, 17, not being a record year, I'm here to tell you in the way the snow fell and the rain in between, it was.
3:12:26 There's no evidence to support that. It's just conversation. I actually think that there's plenty of evidence to support that. I don't know where these particular numbers came from, but in terms of how it came, in terms of the rain events in between only the 96, 97 and the 68, 69. But discount that. Discount that. It was going to happen last year if we didn't keep on top of it every storm. Forget the big year.
3:12:54 So then my next question, how much damage was done in the big year? Physical damage, I'm not, it was minor, but we had water in garages, we had water under houses, we had half the mountain ski patrol down there, we had fire department, we had probably six or eight neighbors all out there shoveling, this was in the big year. And it wasn't just once, it was over and over and over. Dan asked,
3:13:25 What we, the trails, would like the town to do. This was at the first door. I said, just keep the water in or on your easement and we're happy. Simple. It's your easement. Fix it. Question? No, no, that's, I just, you know, through personal history of seeing the water flow through there and I, and while sometimes it may overflow the banks of that ditch,
3:14:02 If you will, I don't know that it rises to the level of... In the summer, it can handle a ton of water, put snow in it, and all that snow. I'm sorry, did you want to speak to this, Tom? Yeah, Tom Hodges, private citizen. I'm actually a trails homeowner, member of the association. I actually had some technical questions that, I don't know, maybe will help explain a solution or find a solution, but...
3:14:33 So when the elementary school repaved entirely, their whole parking lot and arrival, they must have had to pull a grading permit with the town, right? I'd have to look at that because the school districts are kind of different on what permitting they get, but we did certainly help construction manage the project. I'm just not going to answer yes because schools are different. All right, so this is a question that needs to be answered. You know, I'm assuming, so the mountain.
3:15:04 The building on federal land was required to pull a grading permit when we redid Canyon Lodge arrival and parking area this summer. And as a result of our repaving project, we had to re-engineer the drainage for the area that we repaved, which was about an acre, which is probably less than what was done at the elementary school. And we had to put in two enormous stormwater retention facilities underground
3:15:34 100,000 bucks probably to retain our on-site drainage that wasn't retained before. It went down Canyon Boulevard, down the storm drain system. But it was a mandate through the town permitting process that we had to retain because we were repaving. We had to retain our storm water on our site per the prescription of the town code, which I believe is you have to retain your 100% of your 25-year event or something like that. I forget the specifics.
3:16:03 I don't think the elementary school did that. I live next door. My kids go to the elementary school. I don't remember them in that summer digging deep trenches and putting in huge retention facilities as part of that project. So I'm just questioning whether the project was properly designed, if it was issued a permit, and if it followed a municipal code for what was required for stormwater retention on site. I have a feeling that if it was done properly,
3:16:30 Then that would mitigate some of the runoff, which then would go to the trails after it leaves the site of the elementary school. And maybe that would resolve the problem. So I don't know the answers. That's why I'm asking the questions. I think it's something that should be confirmed or, you know, we should understand that information. Thanks. I have a question for you really quick, Tom. I do know during this same incident that Meadow Creek, I believe,
3:17:00 In the Sierra Valley sites, that condo complex had a lot of flooding. However, it turns out that that was something that was going on with Sierra Star Golf Course. And it was, I hate to say it, more egregious than what was happening even in the trails. How did the mountain deal with the drainage issues? Was anything done since we haven't had that event and the water is not running into those places?
3:17:31 So, again, you know, all I can say, because I actually didn't build or develop the golf course that was done by Interwest, but... But it's still mountain property. It is now, yeah. Yeah. It is now. You know, my understanding is that if there was drainage that flows through a site, it continues to flow through the site. If you do improvements to the site that create concentrated flow or increased runoff...
3:18:01 Like with impervious surfaces and so forth, then you have to manage that within your site, whether it's some type of retention facility, dry wells and so forth on your site to manage that excess of water that you're creating as a result of your development. So, you know, again, I don't know in the case of Sierra Star because I wasn't engaged in that when it was developed and constructed, but I certainly think in the case of the school parking lot redo.
3:18:28 Based on what we had to go through at the mountain when we did the Canyon Lodge project this last summer, I don't understand why they wouldn't have had to put in pretty huge retention facilities for that repavement project. I think what would be really helpful for me is to start to hone in on what the technical fix is going to be for this problem. That's not here. I mean, we're hearing... Yeah. I mean, I... That's what I'm getting at, is this something that we could look at and say, well, was that considered? Is that a solution?
3:18:55 Yeah, and I think it may take a little bit out of the box thinking, but I think we've got willing parties willing to figure out how to do that. And I would just hope that whatever expertise the town can provide that you guys have got, that we can sit, you guys know what happens there, you know precisely what happens in these events. Let's get people of goodwill together and figure out how we're going to come up with a technical solution to this. Because I don't think, I just don't see that there's a whole lot of...
3:19:21 Value in going back to whatever the schools did and all that kind of stuff. Let's figure out, because again, I'm interested in finding a solution to this. I don't have the information here to try to address that, but I am certainly willing to do whatever I can as a council member to get people together and let's figure out what the technical problem is and try to find a technical solution. But beyond that, I don't know what we can do here tonight. Hold on one second. Let me continue with the public comment.
3:19:51 Thank you. Would you like to respond to the technical question very quickly? Sure, yes. I'll take like 10 seconds. Yeah. Just to answer the further question, it was triad homes. I see it on paper in front. Oh, okay, good. I just want to confirm that. Secondly, what I'm looking at is a couple of change order diagrams because when the school site was permitted by Department of State Architects, that's who does that, they actually did not include that much drainage stuff in that.
3:20:17 By change order at our recommendation, they did add a dry well and added three 36-inch pipes under there for some of that retention. So that was addressed at least partially. Again, I haven't done a detailed engineering analysis, but that was at least discussed in part of it, and it was tried home. Sorry about that. Thank you. Okay. That's okay. So I have something that I would like to read.
3:20:40 Peter Bernasconi had a medical emergency, so I'm hoping that if I by chance run a little bit over that you'd be a little lenient on that, because I'd like to read his statement and mine as well, if that's okay. Yes, no, that's fine. So first of all, Madam Mayor and Town Council, thank you so very much for your willingness to discuss the drainage easement in the trails. We are very appreciative. And based on the discussion tonight, everybody is fully aware of Mr. Dutton's report.
3:21:07 And I would like to respond to some of those concerns that I have in reference to that, your point of view. First of all, we were never told that we could fix issues in the trails until now. Since the easement belongs to the town of Mammoth Lakes, we were told that any improvements made to the easement had potential to become a liability on our part. We have always maintained that we wanted the town to take care of the new problem.
3:21:34 And ensure that water stayed within the easement. At one point, Haislip Hayes threatened to put a large, deep concrete swale in there to solve the drainage issues. And I can't recall that any of us ever said no. Secondly, in reference to the fact that we didn't have any damage is far from the truth. Damage may not come in a receipt or repair. Both my husband and I lost wages, personal time, and plenty of sleep.
3:22:01 This continues to be a significant stress in our lives, especially mine. If it weren't for the fact that we had neighbors who were willing to, on their free time, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, the Mammoth Lakes Fire Department, paid shovelers, friends, paid shovelers from Manny's crew, ski patrollers, we would have sustained significant damage. And I have proof on my computer tonight to show you if you'd like to see what happened that day. I can show you. We prevented all that damage.
3:22:31 I have evidence, so if you'd like to see it, let me know. Next, if the town of Mammoth Lakes isn't responsible for upgrading the easement, my question is, why are Mr. Duttons and Mr. Hayes' names on multiple documents related to the parking lot upgrade? It's just a question. We have always maintained that we want water to stay within the town's easement, and it does not when the snow is in the way. So it's not a question of whether or not the easement is...
3:23:00 What could be maybe an affordable solution could end up being costly in terms of hundreds of thousands of dollars of damage and potential
3:23:30 Home sale loss. If I were to sell my home and I flooded, I'd have to disclose that. Finally, last year was a drought year and we still saw the need to keep snow out of the way. Whenever there's a wet event, the volume of water coming through is like nothing I've ever seen in all the years I've lived there. I moved in in 2001. If snow's in the way, the water finds a new path. It isn't the place of a private homeowner to fix a town's drainage system. We implore you to do the right thing.
3:23:59 Looking on your website, you repeatedly stress community core values. In addition, you desire to have a proud, cohesive, well-planned community where the town has a reputation of proactive leadership and responsive local government. Our town is supposed to protect and serve its residents. I just can't understand why we are meeting such resistance with something that could be a more simple solution. We're asking you to do the right thing and finish upgrading the rest of the easement. And due to the fact that it isn't fixed at this time,
3:24:28 We feel it's a fair request to ask the town to pay for shoveling until the fix is in place. So thank you for that. That's my statement. I don't know where I'm at with my minutes, but I do have... Actually, I'm going to just ask, can we restart her time for Peter's response? Okay, I'm reading his just straight. Okay, so, sorry, it's small.
3:24:51 So this email provides comments regarding the current drainage problem in the trails from drainage flows coming from the elementary school parking lot, which was designed and constructed by the town and its contractor. I had planned on speaking at the council meeting regarding this problem, but I'm unable so due to a family emergency. I would appreciate these comments being read into the record, and I can respond at another time if there are questions. In the past, the town has had many areas with acute drainage problems, even with small rain events.
3:25:21 The winter of 1997 gave the town staff direction to design and develop what is known as the 2000 Drainage Projects. These projects included work on Red Fur, Hidden Valley Road, a portion of Sierra Valley Sites, Center Street, and the Trails Subdivision. The drainage problems in the trails consisted of flooding several homes, garages, and inundating town drainage facilities.
3:25:45 The town hired a consultant to evaluate the drainage issues and design improvements to correct the problems. These designs were based on the upstream conditions that existed at that time. These designs included an evaluation of the 20, 50, and 100-year storm events. These facilities were designed to function year-round regardless of snow conditions. Once the projects were completed, the drainage issues were resolved and complaints and claims cases against the town subsided.
3:26:14 In 2016, the town partnered with the Mammoth School District to improve the elementary school parking lot, circulation on Meridian Boulevard, and pedestrian access. The town may not have included an evaluation of increased flows for the 20, 50, and 100-year storm events in the scope of work for design. During the construction, the town had a change order added to the project, which increased the size of the drainage ditch along the east side of the parking lot.
3:26:41 Directing flow into the trails drainage facilities that were previously improved by the town in the drainage project. After the project, drainage from the elementary school parking lot flows into downstream properties that were not sized to carry increased off-site flow. It doesn't seem reasonable for an upstream property owner, and in this case an upstream property owner, the town managed project to increase drainage that is now causing flooding, even with minor storms.
3:27:08 I know funds are always limited.
3:27:33 But it seems reasonable to have a third-party civil engineering firm review the plans and drainage flows that are now flowing into the downstream properties causing the flooding issues. All of the storms to date have been relatively minor, and in my opinion, a drainage study should be completed and either reduce or attenuate the increased flows that are causing the problem. The study may include 20, 50, and 100-year storm events in summer and restricted capacity conditions that can occur in the winter or during periods when pine needles fall.
3:28:03 On another note, it looks like my name is used as the responsible party contact on the plans, although I never reviewed the RFP, the plans, or the drainage calculations. That's it. Thank you very much. Okay. Any other public comment? Don't be nervous. I know this is your first time speaking here. It's getting late. Yeah. Hi, everybody. I'm Rick Wood, and I'm here actually in three capacities.
3:28:39 First, as a former owner of property in the trails. I lived there from 25 years ago to 17 years ago, or perhaps 26 years ago to 17 years ago when I moved to another area of town. Second, as a former council member, and I'll tell you why in a second. And third, as a council for the Trails Homeowners Association.
3:29:08 John, I think that you made some good comments. But this really is the time for those people who are affected and have been to come before you because the effort to resolve this or even have a good faith dialogue with the town has simply failed.
3:29:35 And so I'm going to say, I'm going to start with this. This may seem provocative. It may, it's not intended to be. I sat in that Senate chair for six years, and I sat on the dais for 12, and I have seen thousands of agenda bills. And not as many as you have, Kirk, but thousands nonetheless.
3:29:58 And I'm pretty disappointed in this agenda bill, and I'll tell you why. It contains misinformation. Sorry, Grady. It's incomplete. It is very defensive. And it is designed to persuade you to do nothing, which is what has happened for two years, because we've been at this just shy now of two years. So the next thing I want to say is the trails.
3:30:30 Could be described as a unique community within this community. It was built 30 years ago. 1988 is when that easement was dedicated. The first houses went in in 1990. I bought a house in 1993. And interestingly enough, my house is next door to Randy Mellinger. That's a name that some of you will remember. Randy Mellinger, our former planning director's house.
3:31:00 Which is where the drainage begins from the school property. It used to rain in the summer in Mammoth. And I've seen a lot of rain in Mammoth. And my house, which is immediately to the south of Randy Mellinger's old house, 10 feet from the start of the drainage, had a little swale, not much wider than this podium. And the swale began at Ed Bowska's house right next door, the concrete swale. And above that,
3:31:29 There was no swale. Now, I understand that there's been comment tonight about the fact that there was an existing swale. No, there wasn't. Here's what happened. This is not complicated. We've made this complicated because nothing's been done. Improvements were made to Meridian. A curb was put in where there had been no curb. The grade at Meridian just...
3:31:57 West of the entrance to the elementary school parking lot is fairly steep. The water comes off. It used to sheet off. The water comes off now, hits that curb, and goes into a grate, into a culvert. And the culvert runs underneath the entrance to the elementary school. I know that.
3:32:20 And where it goes is into this settling pod. And it's been heralded as this place where all this water from Meridian is going to go. Now, I don't know whose responsibility it was to have water coming off of Meridian go somewhere where it's not going to impact an existing easement that the town has admitted and clearly owns. And with that, by the way, is the obligation to maintain it. It's not complicated. The obligation to maintain it.
3:32:49 Haislip said, well, we're not obligated to maintain it to prevent damage from a hundred-year flood. That's a legal question. I can't answer that, but I can tell you this. The settling pond is the size of a large jacuzzi, and then the water flows out of it, and it goes down through this rock area that used to be dirt. But it was exacerbated by the fact that a curb was put...
3:33:16 On the boundary, the east-west boundary of the trails and the elementary school, there's a curb there. The water comes down. The curb funnels it into the swale. The little piece of concrete behind mine and Ed Bowska's house is still there. And it runs down and it goes into there. And then, of course, what happens is it finds its way to where? A settling pond, a very large settling pond out by the industrial park.
3:33:46 Excuse me. Is there any way that I know you have three things to talk about, but I'm a very stern mayor and I want to keep it to, can you wrap it up in about maybe two minutes? Probably not. And I'm going to ask for what I'm going to call, let me suggest something. I feel like I've earned the privilege to stand here for more than five minutes. And when I was the mayor, I'm not telling you what to do. When there was something important to say, I allowed people to say it. And the problem is that this is the only opportunity.
3:34:16 We have to actually address staff and you in the room. The trails is a locals community. Our mission statement was changed some years ago, and there's great debate about what the emphasis should be. Should we be a four-season destination resort, or should we cater to and meet the needs of our residents? And here's what we came up with in 2010, which still exists today.
3:34:44 The Town of Mammoth Lakes is committed to providing quality public services that ensure the highest quality of life for our residents and our businesses. That's first, and an exceptional experience for our visitors. That was second. The Trails is a locals community. Off the top of my head, I can give you 20 names. Rusty Gregory, Dennis Agee, John Eastman, Larry Johnston, Bill Cockroft, Peter Bernasconi, Tom Farnetti, Ed Bowska.
3:35:13 Randy Mellinger, many, many others who have contributed to this community and it's truly a locals and always has been a locals community. So what's going on? And let me tell you why it's so darn simple. One, because when it flooded once before many years ago, you guys don't remember this, but I do because I represented Greg Seamus when his house was flooded because you see there's a culvert that goes under another part of Wagon Wheel Road.
3:35:43 And sure enough, what happened there is that the town, it was improperly engineered. And what did the town do? They came in and they dug up the street. They put in bigger culverts. They paid Greg for the damages that he suffered to his yard and to his house. And they ran, and then they ran underground. They took the drainage, the swale, which is the easement, and they ran it underground.
3:36:08 There is a history of the town fixing this. Why is this so contentious? Why is it that a local's community has to think that they are at odds or on the opposite side or adverse to the very town when we are constituents? This makes no sense to me. The last point that I'm going to make is this. I'm not going to debate today whether or not the town has liability under what circumstances, but I can guarantee you that I know.
3:36:39 That the town has, that any entity that owns an easement has the responsibility to maintain that easement or the structures within it. I represented 20 of the 41 round fire victims who sued Southern California Edison and LADWP. And that case was settled on the eve of trial this past summer for tens of millions of dollars of damage. And you know what the biggest item of damage was for those 41 people?
3:37:09 What they call stigma damage because once your house or your neighborhood floods, you got to tell the realtor who has to tell the buyer. And once the property value is affected, everybody's property value is affected. And if you think that that's not an item of damage, that's truly an item of damage. And these trails homeowners will suffer.
3:37:31 Not just the psychological damage when it rains or when it snows, they're wondering whether they're going to have to get up in the middle of the night and shovel snow, but because they have to reveal that it's in essence in a flood zone as a result of something that they did not do. Last point. It truly is now my last point, Madam Mayor. This is why I think it's uncomplicated. The town puts the snow in the easement.
3:38:00 20 feet. Understand, it's got a snow storage easement. It's got the right of way on every property in the town, allows the town to source snow, to blow snow. And the town blows the snow on either side of the culvert. And a culvert is just a pipe. And there's two of them. And they're about 12 inches like this, and they run under the road. And you put snow in front of them.
3:38:22 And then on the other side, and the water just does not have anywhere to go. This is not a problem of having 600 or 300 inches of snow. By the way, the trails never had 600 inches of snow in its entire existence because it's the trails. The problem is that packed snow, and you guys all know what that's like. Just go out and try to get rid of the berm after the plow comes by. It's the snow that's trapping the water because it's obstructing.
3:38:49 On either side of the culvert. It is so simple. I'm not an engineer. But you can see it. You walk out there and see it. This is not complicated. And so we've proposed a number of very simple solutions that will not cost the town very much money. You don't necessarily have to redesign that, although I think it should be redesigned. We need some help.
3:39:13 Today's the day that we've been able, and thank you for allowing us to tell us what is on our minds. We've got anecdotal experience. We've got personal experience. I have a theory of liability in the event that something goes wrong, meaning in the event that there's damage. I believe that stigma damages exist, and I believe that there's a really easy solution. But most importantly, I'm going to get back to my first point. There is no reason why this
3:39:42 Particular community or any part of our community should feel like it is adverse to the town, adverse to the council that serves its constituents. I'll leave it at that. Thank you. Unless you have any questions. No, Rick, but I'm going to make a comment. You just preached at me.
3:40:00 If you'd like me to pull out of my hat the name of many dignitaries that have lived in my neighborhood, or if you want to suggest somehow that the trails, which started out as something completely different, should be higher in my thinking than my neighborhood or any other in town, I'm more than happy to have that argument with you, buddy. You and I have had these before. We can go there. You know what? I'm stopping it. Right now? No. As a council member, you sat here and you have to make economic decisions on where
3:40:29 To spend the money. Is this, I'm not saying we shouldn't fix this. How many places in town need to be fixed? You know that. I know that. My neighborhood suffers. She's giving me her cold. My neighborhood suffers worse than the trails does with drainage. Right. Do the trails deserve adjudication before the people in the?
3:40:54 Sierra Valley sites? Bill, it's not about comparing the flooding in areas of town. It's about a condition that has been created by a structure inside an easement. It is 20 feet wide that runs through the trails that the town has accepted. Which is right. That's all I'm saying. And that's the distinction between all of these other places that have flooded, in some instances, for decades and decades. And you bring me the facts.
3:41:21 And I listened to them very well, and you and I have had many conversations. You preach at me, and I'm going to get indignant, which is what I just did. Well, thank you. I appreciate that. Thank you, Bill. And thank you, Council. Over. Done. Thank you for everybody's input on this item. However, we're not going to be able to provide any answers tonight. Nope. I think everybody has had a chance to be heard. I would like to boot this back over to staff.
3:41:50 Let's come up. Council need to make comments, Madam Mayor. I will. I'm making my comment right now. I'd like to... All this stuff I'm never going to understand. I would like this to be taken care of in some way, shape, or form.
3:42:09 And the only thing I want to say is everyone is equal in this town. I don't care what you've done. You get your five minutes. I did give you a little bit more time. I want people to be very clear that when I say stop, I would like it to stop. I am the mayor working on a stipend. I deserve that. So if we can proceed and if this can be civil, otherwise I'm just going to clear the room and we'll deal with it later. So comments to staff and let's move on.
3:42:40 The only comment I have is it is the job of this council to set policy. Policy, I would like to think, is that we treat our citizens as suggested. My only comment to staff is to get this resolved. That's, I think, the policy that this council can say. That is our policy. Yeah, obviously there's a problem.
3:43:11 Obviously, the more time goes by, it's not getting better. It's getting worse. I don't have any of the... All I have is my goodwill as your elected representative to get this thing figured out. That's all I got. And I think I'm with Linda here. Let's get this figured out. Okay? And let's do that. We offer a solution for the short term, which is we would pay... Please go. I'm sorry. If staff has the information, great.
3:43:41 We'll go to staff. We're directing our staff to work with you, get these, which I assume you've provided to them, and these guys will figure out what that is and we'll figure it out. We just, I can't talk to you directly. I've got to go through them. Any more comments? Okay. Kirk, your comments? Yes, kind of interesting. First of all, I think we need to, because I did walk the site a couple times, and, you know, it looks like the school district is creating
3:44:14 A lot of the problems. So partly we need to, I think staff needs to talk to the school district as to where they're pushing the snow. If you look at all that edge of the parking lot, there's supposed to be drainage, and they're dumping all the snow into that swale. I mean, I could not find where the drainage ditches were because the snow was piled up, and that's with a minor year.
3:44:42 So that was just one observation. The other thing is that, I hate to bring this up, but we just went through a strategic planning session, and this is on page four. Maintain general infrastructure to high standards. Maintain maintenance of infrastructure to a barely acceptable, and then it says maintain storm drain collection and conveyance system. This is a core service that was identified that we just went through our strategic planning.
3:45:11 I've done a lot of research on this. I don't know if this is a solution or not, but I did look up heat tapes, and I brought up a bunch of different research that's been done back east.
3:45:28 Where they have some severe drainage problems. So I don't know if heat tape is the answer. Snow Creek 4 has heat taped all over the roofs. It's not on full time. One of the comments was that it's very expensive to run. Well, in Snow Creek 4, I mean, we have a switch. We just turn it on and off, and it's also on a timer.
3:45:55 What I'm suggesting, and this is from the article, it says that 100 feet of heat tape operating 24-7 can translate to an additional monthly cost of $41 to $62 to operate heat, $62 an hour to operate heat tape. So I don't know how much it costs, and I don't know the length of heat tape there. But what I would like to suggest is that
3:46:23 I don't know where we're going to direct staff or anything else, but at least get an RFP from an electrician. What is the capital cost? And then obviously, you know, what is the capital cost to put that in there? I mean, if that is a viable solution. So it's not only the capital cost, but the operation of maintenance. But from my point of view, it certainly is cheaper than snow shovelers.
3:46:48 Getting in there. And they seem to be using it back east extensively. You know, I want to find a solution. And as I said, I've gone on Google and looked up all the different solutions that I can find. But I'd certainly like to at least get an electrician out there to look at it and say, OK, is this possible?
3:47:16 And is the town responsible for laying that heat tape? And is it actually going to work? So I think that needs to be explored before, you know, hopefully it doesn't snow heavily. But I think I would like to see, you know, town staff or the trails.
3:47:34 Go out and get an RFP from, or put out an RFP to an electrician to say, what would it cost? And what are the monthly? Is it going to be on a timer? Is it going to be on a switch? I mean, how is this going to work? If it is viable. Is this a motion? Again. No, I'm trying to explain something. Madam Mayor, if we could please bring this back. I know you interrupt constantly. Into the realm of reality. Okay, again. This is way beyond what it is. Okay, stop. Everybody just shut up. Excuse my French.
3:48:02 If I can finish, all I'm trying to say is that the trails, or I'm not trying to give a direction to town staff, but I think that is a solution that needs to be explored. And I think an electrician could, you know, give us some numbers. And it gives the trails the opportunity, the homeowners down there, to actually look and see what's happening back east.
3:48:27 You know, because that seems to be the solution that they're implementing back east. I would just point out that we put this, Council Member requested this be on the agenda. We did it. The staff work probably was not what it should have been. We've had a good conversation, a good dialogue. This will continue. We'll find solutions. I think the consensus I'm having here is staff, work with these folks, figure something out, and we look forward to finding a way to get a solution to all this.
3:48:57 Okay, do I have consensus? Yes. Yes. We're all nodding, so that's over. We're now going into closed session. Madam Mayor, if I might, I know the closed session's on the agenda, but it's not absolutely necessary to do that tonight. We could certainly postpone this closed session until January 2nd, if you'd like, if all of you would like to just go home. You know what, we'll get a consensus, but do you guys really want to put up with me for the next half hour? Sure, let's do it. Let's get her over with. We're going to get her over with. Thank you.
3:49:30 I'm sorry, I'm going to go ahead and get this going now.
3:50:01 Thank you. Thank you.