TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2019

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 2 hr 10 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

248 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:39 Give us tips. We're also beginning to receive an uptick in complaints of mold. That's also pretty typical with a large winter like this. And, of course, we're dealing with a lot of snow storage issues. I like to call them snow wars.

2:59 And then already looking at planning, little preliminary planning for town cleanup day. I know it's not until May. Hopefully it's in May. We don't push it too much farther with this winter. But doing some ordering and preliminary planning for that. Any questions? Yeah. The middle school is planning on being a part of that again this year. Great, great. We'll touch base later. Yes, definitely. Okay. Thank you. Great.

3:28 Is there any code that says if you're a business you have to have some form of snow removal contract? A couple of people have been bitching at me that people adjacent to them don't even have a contractor so their cars are being parked in their lot and then they can't get a tow truck and yada, yada, yada. They have to provide for adequate snow storage and removal. I'm not sure if they need to have that professionally, I think.

3:54 You can do that on your own. But there is something in the Municipal Code about making sure that you're removing the snow and getting it out of here. You're responsible for that as a business owner. So do you want me to get in contact with you about some particular ones? Okay. I'll reach out for you. Okay. Thanks. Thank you, Shireen. Are there any other public comments?

4:25 All right. Then we'll move on to what I think is the hot topic for the meeting. Our first business matter is a public workshop for the Yotelped project. And Nolan's going to be giving a brief staff report, and then we'll have the applicant give a presentation, and then we'll open it up to questions and comments up here from the commission and from the public. Great. Thank you.

4:53 The proposed Yotel pad project is a new mixed-use condominium hotel development located at the northeast corner of Minaret and Main Street. The project encompasses three parcels at that corner. We're currently in Novato's and the Yotel sales office. Previously, the Snow Creek sales office are located. The project consists of a five-story condominium hotel with 156 units. These will all be studio and one-bedroom units.

5:23 21 three-story townhomes that will be two-bedroom units, approximately 4,700 square feet of restaurant lounge space, and understructured parking for up to 185 vehicles with valet service. There will also be a small surface parking area for guests checking in. The condo units are being branded as micro units and will range in size from 334 square feet to 569 square feet.

5:50 for the one-bedroom units and studio units, and the townhome units will be approximately 1,300 square feet. Site amenities for the site include space for fitness room, kid's zone, indoor and outdoor fireplace areas, lounge areas throughout the site, a pool and hot tub, and a bocce ball court. The purpose and role of today's workshop is to provide an opportunity for the public and the commission to provide input on the project.

6:19 and identify any issues and or concerns that they may have on the project. Specific discussion items for today's workshop include the context and compatibility of the project in relation to the overall North Village, site design including pedestrian movement, vehicle circulation and building orientation, bulk mass and form of the buildings, architectural detail of the buildings, and just overall site functionality with regards to emergency access.

6:47 And then service uses for deliveries and trash services. The project as proposed is in conformance with all areas of the North Village specific plan. The proposed use is consistent with the allowed uses for the resort's general zone since the project is a condominium hotel lodging project that has a restaurant component intended for guests and visitors. Additionally, the density does not exceed the maximum allowable density for that specific site. The lot coverage is less than the maximum lot coverage permitted.

7:19 The building area does not exceed the maximum allowable building area and the heights are equal to or less than the maximum heights permitted. Additionally, the setbacks for the project are all adhered to. The parking meets the parking requirements for the intended use and the housing mitigation requirements are being met through the use of the existing housing mitigation credits that the site is entitled to. This was through a previous agreement with the previous owners.

7:51 For the workshop, I will walk through each discussion item and then the architects will elaborate further on their just architectural vision for the project. After that, the workshop will be open for questions and comments from the commission and the public. As noted, the site is located in the resort general zone of the North Village specific plan area within the pedestrian core area. This zone is intended for visitor-oriented resort services such as hotels, resort condominiums,

8:21 and retail restaurant uses, and the pedestrian core area is intended to be a mixed-use village with commercial uses on the ground floor and accommodation uses on the upper floors and provide a pedestrian path throughout the North Village area. Also, this project site serves as the gateway to the remainder of the North Village specific plan area.

8:44 On the screen here is the southwest corner of the site, which is what you'll see when approaching the North Village area from Main Street and Minaret Road. The corner was designed to provide visual interest at that corner and serve as the gateway to the North Village area. The piece shown kind of in the corner here is just a concept piece for where there'll be kind of a future monument sign gateway area welcoming guests to the North Village area.

9:14 This area is also intended to provide pedestrian connectivity to the site and provide a more natural transition as it steps up to the hotel site through the use of landscaping and terracing. Also with the stairs coming from the sites intended to try and direct the pedestrians to the crosswalk down at the corner. Access to the site will be from a single driveway on Minaret Road in the upper northwest corner of the site.

9:43 This will then direct guests to the surface parking area where there will be room for approximately five vehicles while they await the valets to then take it into the parking structure. Access to the parking structures here on the northeast corner of the site. All of the long-term parking will be under structure. And then just the other overall site design.

10:12 The buildings are oriented in kind of a north to south fashion with nothing on the south side really to limit any shading that's going to occur on the site. As shown on the screen here, there's shade analysis done throughout all the different periods of the year in the morning and in the afternoon. During the summer months, it's really limited shading on the site. What this also shows is that there'll really be limited shading to the adjacent sites to the north and the east from the project.

10:42 This is due to they place the shorter lower buildings on the northern and eastern sides of the property. For building form and mass, as noted, the building mass is stepped down as you go from the west to the east and the shorter three-story buildings are on the eastern and northern sides of the property. This will provide an easier transition for the residential areas to the east as well as the hotel use to the north rather than having a large five-story building right on those property lines.

11:16 Additionally, to reduce some of the mass, the main building has a bend to it. This breaks down some of the massing, and when looked at it on the side, it just provides more visual interest on the site. Also, the site, as noted earlier, will be terraced going up from the corner, again, to provide some visual interest at the corner and reduce some of the visibility of the building. The proposed building materials consist of corrugated metal panels in a charred brown color.

11:48 Fiber cement siding in a cedar wood color, fiber cement siding in a charcoal color with a brick pattern, and natural stone. The materials and colors are varied and used in a vertical and horizontal fashion throughout the project to again break up that massing and provide visual interest on the project. The architects on their presentation will go more into detail on their materials and the use of those materials.

12:19 Again, the entry for the sites, access via the single driveway into the guest drop-off area. This area has a continuous roof along the lower portion of the building to protect guests from the elements. It also has seating areas mixed into that area. And then also on the area where the restaurant will be, there is a...

12:44 Exterior entrance that will provide access into the restaurant area from the outside. Site functionality of the site is really how the site's going to work with snow, trash services, deliveries, etc. Snow will be temporarily stored on the site in the areas shown in red adjacent to the parking area as well as in this area.

13:13 Peer adjacent to the driveway area. Also, all the areas in red hatching, so all the driveway and pedestrian walkway areas will be heated to provide for snow melt. The deliveries and trash services are proposed to be mainly in this pullout here near the entrance. Trucks will drop off here and be brought into the site.

13:37 Good afternoon, Commissioners. Thanks for allowing us to add a little bit of

14:43 Additional detail to what Nolan provided. Nolan, thank you for that presentation. That was fantastic and covered a lot of the detail. And thanks to all of you for joining us today. We're really appreciative of your time and for your interest and consideration of this project. So I thought Nolan did a great job of covering most of the details, but I did want just to add a little bit to the story. So some of the images you see on the screen are from the interiors of the project.

15:14 Micro-unit approach to the project, as Nolan had mentioned. It's kind of a Swiss Army knife. Everything has its place within the footprint. This is a typical unit plan, and everything is operable, and depending on the time of the day, the floor plan changes, the couch becomes a bed, and the desk becomes bunk beds. And sort of one of the mottos is,

15:42 Every inch is used purposefully. There's an important aspect of it that it feels clean and polished with some great millwork that when it's opened up, again, everything has its place within the project and really is designed specifically for a mountain resort type of experience and use. You can see here even down to the helmets and goggles and ski boots has all been thought through on the interiors.

16:22 You can see the couch transforming into a bed here and the bunk bed or the desk transforming into a bunk bed. And really one of the important things when you're working on a micro unit project, since the units have less square footage inside of the unit itself, a lot of the importance is placed on the amenities and social and cultural spaces within the building. So on level one, there's kid zone and

16:55 Lounges and bars to really support and gather the building occupants together in a nice social and fun atmosphere that really helps to engage and enliven the property. These are just a couple of views of the townhomes interiors. Again, here you can just see a nice clean approach to the interior design, really letting the views through the building to be the featured elements.

17:26 from the project. Nolan kind of went through the site details quite a bit, but we really are wanting this to be connected to your community and to your existing infrastructure, really hoping to make this a pedestrian-friendly atmosphere and environment that just adds to what your community already has. Really inspired by the village that's across the street,

17:58 Bringing that same excitement and experience and sort of a car-free atmosphere within and among the buildings was a really important part of the design strategy. As Nolan mentioned, with pools and hot tubs and outdoor exercise and social space with fire pits, etc. And really, cursor, here we go. The north end of the project really opens up.

18:31 and has a response to the village and the space that connects what we like to refer to as the backyard in-house among the design team really connects our backyard to the village in terms of visual connection and then that backyard experience or the outdoor amenity experience wraps all the way around the south end and culminates and or starts at that southwest corner which is the gateway to

19:00 The North Village. And we have put quite a bit of time into developing landscape plans that add quite a bit of texture and variation to these outdoor spaces, including trees that are smart, drought tolerant, water wise trees that are appropriate for the community. Really being inspired by that idea of a village in the trees. And so really taking the design cues from

19:35 The village and surrounding areas of Mammoth, using that stone base and floor-to-ceiling storefront to really enliven the level one sort of amenities, bringing in steel detailing in the fascia and some of the port cocher elements and the railing elements within the units, and using siding similar to you see in the village for the upper level units. So here we

20:03 Have a view. If you were to stand at the village and turn around and look back towards the project site, you can kind of see how this project starts to tuck into the trees from afar. And this image here really highlights that exterior experience, the Yotel village experience. You can see the pools on the south end getting that great solar orientation in the townhomes and how the

20:31 The larger five-story building steps down to the neighborhood to the east as well as to the hotel to the north to those three-story townhomes. And bringing down one-level volumes at the amenity space that really brings down a human scale where the experience both inside and outside really occur. Again, here's just an image of one of the outdoor fireplaces with views into the amenity space.

21:03 This is a view from the backyard area or the pool and amenity space on the outside. This is just a detail of the townhomes. Here you can see those materials, the natural stone veneer, tightly corrugated charcoal siding, wood, real wood soffits where it's protected from the weather.

21:30 Railing and other elements to add detail to openings and doorways and entry components. And this is just a quick view showing how this building we feel really sits in nicely into the tree line. It doesn't have, this is a view from Main Street looking back to the project site towards the north. You can see how the trees, that idea of the village in the trees is really

22:03 Evident in this image here. I'm going to switch over to a different software so bear with me for a second. So this really is the same view that Nolan had included in his presentation and it just shows how the project has a general horizontal feeling to the overall massing but at the same time has a great rhythm of vertical elements very similar to a lot of the elements in architecture in the village itself. Here you can see the balance of that neutral

23:07 Darker gray siding, fiber cementitious siding, with the lighter, warmer, cementitious siding that is recalling cedar wood. And then in the foreground, the boulder and site walls that would be board formed concrete in the foreground. And how the port co-share is really more than just a port co-share, it becomes a porch on the west side of the project that has some really great seating spaces and connects the

23:36 The Port Co-Share, the front entry of the hotel to the restaurant. This is a view looking from the north corner of the project back to the restaurant element there at the far south end and the hotel entrance there in the middle. And here you start to see when you get in and close to that Port Co-Share how that storefront floor to ceiling.

24:20 Starts to come down and really open up the main lobby and lounges and kid zone and gaming space and the restaurant to that experience on Minaret. We really think this will help to enliven that experience on Minaret and be in concert and echo what's going on at the brewing company. So again, this is just a sketch-up model that doesn't have all the details worked out. We're certainly working on those things, but we're

24:59 open to your comments and consideration at that time. Kyle or Ron, is there anything you would want to add to that story or that detail? Thank you. Thank you very much. So I guess we can start with some questions and comments up here, open it up to the public. This doesn't have to be as formal as a public hearing. This is just a workshop, so we can go back and forth as needed.

25:32 Well, I think maybe try to consolidate some comments as much as possible. And if some people who have spoken before you have already voiced your concerns, I'd appreciate it if we can just at least state that we agree and kind of keep the ball rolling a little bit here. Does anyone up here would like to start? I just have a comment. I don't really have any questions because I've already familiarized myself quite a bit with this project.

26:04 But I just want to say that I'm really excited for new development to come to our community. I think this is a great looking project and will bring a nice vibe to the village and it'll really refresh that corner quite a bit. So thank you for investing in this and trying to make a great looking project. Thank you. I have a couple of really quick questions and it's a little bit more of my own personal curiosity.

26:32 What is the projected seating capacity of the restaurant? That's a really great question. The footprint within the building is just slightly larger than the current Nevado site, so it would be very similar to the Nevado site. The thing that has been enhanced is the outdoor seating component, as we showed in some of the images and here on the screen. We've got a little bit of additional terraced seating.

27:00 To the southwest of the Nevada site, and then also wrapping around the south and connecting. So the intent is to be similar to what is currently on the site. Got it. And I'm assuming that your parking strategy also includes parking for patrons that will be patronizing the restaurant but may not be staying at the hotel pad? Yes, sir. So we do have the valet parking in the structure below. That would...

27:28 Yeah, so the parking structure includes parking for

27:58 The requirements for the hotel units themselves and the townhomes and then additional stalls for the restaurant. Got it. As well as the parking aisles in the parking rods, they're 26 foot wide. And so per valet style, there'd be an opportunity to park along the aisles as well and still have plenty of room for... Yeah, the valet is an important component of the success of that.

28:30 Being able to not have any of the general public parking their own cars in there. Right. Being able to get them very tightly packed and efficiently packed in there. So even though we have 180 plus parking stalls, there's, like Kyle said, room for several more cars in there. Got it. I'm assuming you gentlemen are aware that parking is one of, a key issue with the North Village has been in the past and will be in the future. So that's one of the reasons I wanted to bring that up.

28:59 Yes, sir, we understand parking and pedestrian connection are two of the most important aspects of making this project a success and tying into the village. Thank you. The other question I had is, if you notice from the plans and the diagrams, it appears to be a flat roof on the hotel pad and with a winter similar to what we're having now, you could have in the future. I'm wondering if you could just briefly give me your strategy for snow removal from your roof.

29:27 Yes, so we are providing a membrane roof and we'll have a protection board below the membrane and then also we're looking at a protection board above the membrane so it can take additional personnel for snow clearing on the roof when it's necessary. There will be a snow melt system up there and ample roof drainage so that we can get as much snow off as possible. In events like you've experienced, you know, that's not going to work in all situations.

29:57 But one of the interesting things about the flat roof as we've studied is that the wind itself will actually help to clear most of the snow off of the roof and in a lot of ways it'll bring it down into the backyard. So there'll be, you know, intense snow removal from that backyard as well or the courtyard area. And the courtyard will have snow melt as Nolan pointed out throughout all the pedestrian walkways as well.

30:25 And then, of course, our structural engineer has compensated very well for the additional loads of the heavy snow and snow drifting. Thank you. If I might add, we are proposing a low parapet on the roof, and that will also aid in limiting snow drift piling up on the roof on one side or another. And again, the wind would carry it off because of those lower parapets. That's it for me.

30:59 I'd like to follow up on that a little bit. So what you're trying to tell us is that the snow is going to melt off the roof or it's going to get blown off the roof and it's never going to need to be shoveled or removed. No, and that's why I mentioned that we would have a protection board on the roof so that when necessary personnel will be able to get up there. We do have a stairway to the roof that...

31:23 Snow equipment could be brought up to the roof when necessary to shovel off just like we saw today. The nice thing is on the flat roof it will hopefully be a safer situation than standing on a sloped roof and where OSHA requires it we would have tie-offs up there so that snow removal personnel could clip into a cable system and be safely secured up there. And when that snow comes off the roof and it's compacted mud like we have now,

31:53 It's not going to melt out of your snow melt. How is it going to get out of your backyard? It will be shoveled and moved with snow removal equipment similar to the village. And where are you going to park your truck that you can load to haul a snow pit on that map? We have the area here on the south end for trucks, and we have the main turnaround area where we could bring a truck in in that area, as well as snow removal equipment loading up a truck.

32:25 Oh, excuse me, yeah, this right here serves as a fire lane up to this point here with the turnaround area there. We could bring up something up to 75 tons into that area as well. Thanks, Kyle. Okay. Yeah, this is something we take, you know, we're taking very seriously. We see it, we know you guys live it every day. We understand how much of an impact it has on the community and the success of a community. And it's the character, it's what's awesome about Mammoth.

32:58 We want to make sure we get it right. And we think that we've got the right team in place that's thinking through all these elements. But, you know, we're all ears if you have some suggestions. Thank you for the question. Is there a reason why you don't have Snowmel's system at the entryway, according to the drawing that I see here? That maybe is an error. I don't know, Nolan, if we can bring that drawing back up. I don't have it in my presentation. I didn't want to be. Yeah, we've got it around.

33:39 Right in front of the entry is all covered. Do you mean the entrance off of the street? Right here. Yeah, that should be snowmout right in here at the main entry. Yeah. But between there and the street. Yeah, that should be extended, yeah. It's also covered by the portico chair. Yeah, and we saw down just down at the Starbucks that snow gets tracked right in there. Absolutely. I think it's a great point. I think it's something we need to clarify in our illustration, yeah. Okay.

34:14 I think Paul was asking about the really approach to the Port Cashier, the circle from the street. Right. From this entire section. The whole top right corner of the. North corner. Because I see that it's not identified as snow melt patch pattern. Yeah, Kyle, maybe something we can talk about with Triad and the civil injury. The intent would be that this portion would be.

34:45 Cleared with snow removal equipment. And really there's, we're not, we don't want to encourage pedestrians on the driveway right here. We have a sidewalk that would be cleared just like your other sidewalks in the village. But really this is for vehicles right in through this area and we're not necessarily encouraging pedestrian use of that driveway. But where we do have connections to that sidewalk and where we think people will be getting out of their cars, that's either covered by the port co-share or snow melt is provided.

35:14 Of the five valet parking stall, surface parking, are any of them for ADA purpose? Yeah, absolutely. They will have an ADA stall and the slopes through that out that area would be 5% or less maximum slope and 2% or less cross slope. Okay. And they will be available for that exact purpose with ADA ramp up to the pork crochet sidewalk.

35:45 It's hard to see, but that one that's right in front of the building. So there will be one? Right there. Yeah, there's one right in front here. Oh, I see. I'm assuming that given that this is a condo hotel, you're looking for the owner to participate to be on the rental program that the hotel would manage. So that means out of the 277 units,

36:15 You would have probably, what, 150 plus units that are going to be in the program, rental program. If that's the case, during the prime season, I would imagine you need minimum of 150 to 250 parking spaces, right? Yeah, we are providing over 180 parking stalls in the parking structure. You have 185 parking stalls.

36:47 According to the document that I read. Yes. So during the prime season, you know, I would imagine most people would have one or two cars coming up here during Christmas and New Year. So you need more than 185, not to mention the restaurant component that you have talked about. So I'm puzzled as to the

37:16 I'm not clear as to the number of parking spaces that you have to have. Paul, just to clarify, and maybe I misheard you, but I think we have 177 units. Correct. Yeah, so not 277 units. No, no, I understand. But what I'm saying is that if you're going to have, let's say, 80 to 90 percent of units, that's going to be on the rental program, right, that you're going to be managing.

37:44 And whenever a family comes up, potentially they could have one cart or maybe even two carts to stay per unit. Am I correct? Paul is going to weigh in. So the parking requirements are based on the use and what's in the North Village plan. So we can't require them to

38:10 Park and the perception that they may have two or three or four cars, we have to go based on what we have in the plan. That's the requirements for this use, which is... Well, just because the zoning code calls for, doesn't call for certain things, it is a bit of a concern during, as regards to visitation, right? It is a concern as far as... Yeah, as far as design... If your restaurant has... Let's see, if you're going to have...

38:38 100 or 150 occupants in that restaurant on a Friday or Saturday night, I'm confused as to where are you going to park those people? Sure, so part of that will be with the valet service, they're providing a parking study done by a parking consultant that's going to

39:05 A, one of our questions was provide analysis on how the valet parking plan will work for the project. That's one of the items that's still going to be coming from the applicants. That will look at what the kind of maximum capacity of that garage is with valet only. So parking the car is in tighter. As far as what we can require them to provide for parking, again, it's only, we can only require what's in the plan. We can't, you know, we can encourage them to provide more. We can ask for more, but we can't.

39:33 I understand that. I mean, I'm not looking for a solution. This is, to me, that's a concern. We agree. We think that the valet parking does help provide part of the solution, being able to flex above and beyond the actual stalls provided. And I think it will accommodate more than one stall per unit, which is maybe not.

39:59 Every stall for every single person on the heaviest days, but it's getting very close to it. You know, it's trying to address that concern in a smart way. It's a good question. I think the valet parking is the solution. I think one thing to keep in mind is that a majority of your units are the studio style and really are only sleeping two people. Isn't that correct? Yes, two to four.

40:26 A family, a small family. So they could be two to four. But it's unlikely we're talking about fitting four adults in one of those studio spaces. Yeah, the townhomes themselves might have... It's really not designed for four adults. It's designed for two adults and two kids, perhaps. Correct? Four girlfriends or four buddies. Yeah, sure. Okay.

41:08 Everything. So I'd anticipate on a daily usage of employees, you'd probably have at least 30 people fueling it. Robert, would you mind coming up to the microphone for comments? It's an informal workshop type of thing. Well, it is, but Sandra requested that we... My name's Robert Schaubmeyer. My brother and I are from the Alpanoff Lodge, just right next door. Come on, keep walking. Even further. Microphone from the microphone. Right here, like this. Yeah. So,

41:37 My question is, where are all the employees going to park? You know, we can talk about the restaurant, we can talk about occupancy all day long, but unfortunately you're going to have to have employees to fuel the building, to power the building, and run the building, and essentially where are they going to park? Are they going to be allowed usage of the valet system as well? On down the line. Yeah, so this is Chris Heinrich with Replay the Developer. You can add some depth to the answer. I apologize for our retardiness.

42:08 Coming through from Reno today. The plan for employee parking, with the ability of the valet parking system. In valet parking, you're parking one to two deep in the aisles during the height of the parking demands. We will be parking the management of both the restaurant and the hotel within the parking garage, and then we'll have the ability to flex.

42:33 Potentially for employees, and then we're going to be relying on public transportation, et cetera, for the majority of the employees. For the majority of the employees. How many employees do you anticipate? Around 30. And so we'll be parking in the garage 10 some odd from general management to engineering to head of maid service, et cetera.

43:10 And then again, you know, in the times that we need, you know, we'll have the ability to flex and park into that garage with the valet. For the employees. Sorry? For employees. For employees. Okay. This might be drilling a bit too deep down, but I'm assuming that the bar would probably go until 2 a.m., the bar operations at the hotel? We haven't set hours yet. You know, it'll be later. Yeah. Correct. Okay. And just because I'm not familiar with...

43:39 The operating hours of our public transportation system. When does the red line stop running? I don't even know. I don't know. My apologies, Hayes. You would think a tourism guy would know that. Hazel Pays, engineering manager. The red line, the late night line, it varies by season. Right now it goes past midnight.

44:11 In the summer, it varies depending on what's going on in the weekends and so forth. But typically, it does only get to, I think, just past midnight right now, the late night red line. I forget the actual name of it, the owl or night trolley or something of that nature. And what time does it start running, Hayes? Right, I actually don't know. It's early. Okay. It's seasonal.

44:39 Got it. And just so you gentlemen know, public transportation, there is some limitation on its availability in Mammoth Lakes. I just want you gentlemen to be aware of that. Yeah, and we won't be running it until 2 in the morning, so that's, you know, to be determined, but absolutely, I understand. Thank you. Thank you, Hayes. Sorry about that. Paul, did you have any other questions or comments or conversation?

45:10 Sure. Come on up. Yep. Please. Yeah. I'm just sort of saving some of my comments until later. Can you introduce yourself, please? Yeah, I will. Thanks. Okay. It's a nice project. Okay. It's a nice presentation. I'm Dave Nelson, actually manage viewpoint, own property of viewpoint. On one of the site plans, you can actually see the property I manage. It's the two little semi-little boxes that are 20 feet from the back of the building.

45:41 Do you have a view from our property on the back side? Would that be okay? Yeah. It's a sketchy view, but it will help to... Doing this without a mouse is tricky, so bear with me. He's on the east. There we go. That's okay. Yeah, that's all right. Is that... Yeah. No, that's great. Yeah. So just a couple comments, just because it's...

46:40 Open forum. My question, so we take a look at that. Could you step a little closer to the mic just so everyone can hear? Sure. Yeah. Thanks. So the property isn't, you know, it's nice, it kind of gradually shows a little incline there, but the property actually has quite a distance from where they're going to start building onto the far side. So I was wondering with grading,

47:11 We set 10 feet off the property line. You guys are going to send 10 feet off the property line. It's going to have to be graded some or dug or something and to mitigate, you know, for the next year as far as noise goes, dust. The top of where you're digging is rock. It's pumice on the sides and there's a rock hill. I've been there 44 years.

47:41 Doug actually worked even on the property you're on. Bill Souser actually used to live on that property, had a motel. I'm just wondering how, with our buildings and yours 20 feet apart, your buildings are going to be flat. There's a long distance. You're going to cover a good chunk of our property. It drops really steeply in the front and then in the back. And is there going to be a retaining wall?

48:11 Which means landscape or just maintaining the landscape in between. And I'm sorry, I'm just kind of firing some of the thoughts, you know, as you guys are headed into it. I think the building, I love the front side and how you kind of looked around. I am concerned with our view, looking towards it. I'm concerned with how much is going to be graded, what kind of retaining wall or no retaining wall.

48:37 All the trees will be wiped off the property in order to get the level that you need. So it'll be just whatever you put back on. There won't be any trees left. We'll be looking, you know, literally 10 feet from our property line at the stories. And I appreciate the fact you guys didn't put the five story. You put the shorter ones. And we knew something was going to be built. Some trees are going to come out. But I guess a concern with that.

49:07 The snow blowing off the top of the building, the wind blows our direction, because I end up with all Novato's trash. I know it blows our direction. So that means the snow blowing off your roofs will actually not land on the dirt or the ground, but has a really good chance of landing on top of my buildings.

49:36 Because my buildings sit lower than your buildings. And that snow coming off. So I have a concern on the snow removal, snow storage on the backside, accessibility. All the others have buffer zones with street. We have no buffer zone between you and us. And I go, it's just hard. Do you know what I mean? It's so tight in there. To lose the trees, have a large building, not much buffer zone.

50:05 So anyway, I just, I didn't know if there's a way to help that out or mitigate that. During construction, the dust, it's pumice. Pumice, even with pine needles covering it and keeping it down, let alone excavation, that stuff just moves. You know, your property is going to be dusted. I mean, the stuff with closed windows ends up inside the buildings.

50:35 Parking's been addressed, but I will say, just been being here for so long, if someone knows there's a parking lot near and they can't get parking, they use the adjacent properties. It just happens. So anyway, those are just some of the concerns. I like it. I actually would love to have you guys as neighbors. I just wonder if there's any more we could do in between the properties. What was your name again, sir?

51:09 Dave, thanks for your comments. So, you know, I mentioned this is not an engineer drawing. It's really useful for us as a design tool. But our intent from a design perspective, a civil grading perspective, is to wherever possible tie into existing grades. And where that is not possible, we will have some shorter retaining walls.

51:36 So there will be some retaining walls. And we're very aware of drainage requirements. And we'll make sure that our civil engineer is one of the best in Mammoth. And he's going to do a great job in making sure that we're dealing with as much of that on our side as we possibly can. From the trees perspective, let's see if I can pull up. And I guess one more point while I'm on this view here. The edge of the parking structure.

52:04 is along that setback line, which is approximately 10 feet from the property line. But the buildings themselves are set back from that an additional handful of feet to the closest building, and then even more so for the way we undulate that facade. So it's not 10 feet, it's a little bit more than 10 feet, which I think

52:32 Is part of our response to that concern, right? And our intent is to plant with new trees and have a beautiful landscape on that east side of our project as well. So you're absolutely right. During construction, the contractor will be required to

53:15 to meet all codes in terms of, you know, working within noise limitations that Mammoth has set forth and dust limitations as well that are set forth already. Thank you. I'll go ahead and offer a few comments. Thank you. Oh, I mean, I don't have to be the last person, but if you want to come on up. Share it, your honor. No, it's all right. Okay.

53:47 So I've seen this project a couple of times now in design committee meetings and in an ADP advisory design panel meeting. And I know the applicants are aware of my concerns. Overall, I want to say I think you have a great project. I'm excited to see it happen. And I feel like you've responded a bit to some of our concerns from the previous meetings. I really appreciate you reducing the number of

54:17 I appreciate the effort.

54:48 To me, it still falls drastically short of what I really think would create the best product for Mammoth. Just so that all of you know up here, my opinion is that this is probably the most prime piece of property in this entire town from a commercial hotel lodging perspective.

55:16 It feels like we're just putting a parking lot and snow storage on the most visible corner in the village. I know that you, between the last meeting and this presentation, you've addressed that a bit. I see a couple of sidewalks and some stairways getting us closer to a pedestrian connection to the crosswalk at the corner. I appreciate that, but I feel like you're contradicting yourself on the next

55:47 On the next plan where you're showing the snowmelt system and the sidewalk that has the snowmelt on it going directly back to the street, basically inviting everybody to jaywalk right across the street once again. So, I mean, if you're going to go to the effort of creating a sidewalk and the stairway to attempt to connect people to the crosswalk at the corner, I think that

56:17 So that's my main concern.

56:57 And I know we can workshop this a bit more tomorrow. Tomorrow we have an advisory design panel meeting. So maybe we can talk about it in more detail tomorrow. But I think there are still a lot of details yet to be ironed out. We would appreciate the opportunity to continue to workshop with you and the rest of the ADP committee at that meeting, if that's okay. Yeah, of course.

57:34 Throw it back to anyone. Kirk, did you want to come up and say a few things? Amy Wiley's coming up. One quick clarification. I double-checked the ESTA website. I'm incorrect. The wintertime night trolley does run until 2 a.m. It's the line that runs to Juniper that closes at midnight, so I apologize for that. Okay. Thank you for the clarification, Hayes. Yes, thank you. Thanks. Hello, my name is Kirk Schaubmeyer. I'm a member of the family that owns Alpanoff Lodge, your neighbors.

58:07 Nice to see you again. Nice to meet you all. Wonderful presentation. I speak today as a member of that and not of the MLT board, which I also sit on. Kudos to the project. This is not an easy thing to do. I mean, there's a lot of public scrutiny. I'm going to put in my five cents, of course, too.

58:34 I am in favor of this type of thing, and I think it actually looks pretty good, all things considered. But somewhere between what's on paper and what's actually on the ground exists reality. And I'll give you a couple examples of that, and then I will ask you a couple of questions with how you intend to maybe take care of that.

59:03 Yeah, you know, it's easy to say, okay, you know, per the plan, we've met this, and okay, everything looks good, practically speaking. Here's the example, and I don't know if you all remember Ben Onager, and he was always very well spoken, and he said, as far as the delivery schedule for the village, you have all the big box trucks, U.S. Foods, Cisco and such, parking in the middle of the road on

59:31 On Minaret, by the trash entry of the village parking lot. And he said, oh, it's just an issue of compliance. You have to issue fines. The dock is over there by the gondola. And that is where it's supposed to happen. And this is, it's as simple as that. Okay, well, it's not that simple because now years along, years go by and it's just part of the scenery. You know, people get used to having a delivery truck in there.

1:00:01 It's difficult in times like this, and I think I'll preface it a little bit by saying, you know, our family has a Petrus, and in the restaurant business, a common practice is if somebody comes to you at the counter and says, do you have a table? And if I have something, certainly, I'm willing to put people down. I'm going to take a guess as to when that might clear. Now, they might clear.

1:00:31 In five minutes, am I clear in half an hour or something like that? But I might say, I'll have a table ready for you in half an hour. Okay, it's up to that person to sit there and accept that and wait. But I know in the back of my mind, ideally I'd like to deliver a little bit sooner than that. So, you know, their expectation is half an hour. I come through with the table at 15 minutes.

1:01:01 Everybody looks great. It goes the other direction with if I say, oh, I got a table in five minutes. Okay, great. Half an hour goes by. Now the customer is not so happy with me and what it is that I've promised. So what's it have to do with regulations and stuff? I think that to over-deliver, to over-compensate, to add X amount more,

1:01:28 Oh, hey, what about the delivery truck? Where does that go in? That's going to be one of my questions here. The reality is it's going to go in the middle of the road or it's going to be parked in front of our parking lot just so people can go on by. That coupled with employee parking concerns and guest parking concerns and all that together.

1:01:58 If you're just on the button, I know it's gonna happen. It's gonna spill over and it's gonna go somewhere else. And that just negatively impacts the guest experience. Now I gotta be a jerk because now I'm gonna kick out Yotel employees out of our parking lot. I have to kick out Toomey's guys, village people, everybody that comes by. I have to hustle along these big box trucks to try to get them in and out and so forth. So, all right.

1:02:30 I've talked about many different things. Let's try to narrow that focus. Have you really thought about that? I mean, you know, it's not easy. And again, I want you guys to know that I applaud this effort because it's quite a quest that you have to go through to get something on the ground. And again, I'm in favor of this type of thing. But I would love to hear. I have X percent more just for the just in case type thing versus.

1:03:01 I'm just on the button. Probably forgot a couple of thoughts there, but I've rambled on for long enough, so I'll leave it at that, and if that prompts any other questions, then maybe I can contribute to that, or we can talk about it a little bit further from there. So thank you for your time. Thank you. Kirk, we appreciate the question and the concern. And I just wanted to reiterate,

1:03:41 The few points that have been made and if there are any additional operational things you want to speak about, Chris or Gary, you can maybe add to that. But we do have multiple areas for service and delivery vehicles to get out of the way of the entry to our neighbors to the north as well as get out of Minaret.

1:04:08 Whether it's the turnabout at the front entry or this fire lane area here at the north end of the building. We have, you know, double wide drive aisles down into the parking garage. So I think there are several areas that a service vehicle will be able to pull off and get out of the way. And, you know, none of those are...

1:04:36 Easy to maneuver around, but they are ample and sufficient and meet code and other requirements, such as the nature of driving a commercial vehicle, I guess. And then, again, I just wanted to reiterate, the parking structure itself is, it meets the minimum requirement, but with valet service, it will flex well above and beyond 180 plus stalls.

1:05:03 So I really think that does help to go the extra mile in terms of providing extra space for parking in those peak times without building a second parking level, which would be more of a burden on the site than is necessary. I guess with that, Chris or Gary, if there are any other operational ideas. Operationally, everything is designed to come down through the parking garage.

1:05:31 All of our service component to the hotel operation sits within the parking garage. With the maneuvering for the fire trucks within the site, there's ample maneuvering room, and the idea is to get, we're heating that north driveway to get the service vehicles down that north driveway, and we're bringing all of the goods into that garage.

1:05:56 Stored, and then we have a specific service elevator for those goods coming up, and we also have a dumbwaiter for the restaurant coming out of the garage also. So you're not anticipating a, you know, a Cisco truck to pull into the garage, but they'll, like, back in off the street, basically, and, and park along the north side of the building and then unload and hand cart things into the, in through the garage? Everything comes down and through that garage, correct.

1:06:30 And so if you're parking in the lane, our only access point for service is down and through that end point. You're going to want to get your truck down to that point for unloading. Right. How about during your course of construction? You're going to have a big, tremendous crater there. It's going to get covered in concrete. And then it's not going to be one or two Cisco trucks. You're going to be having many semis a day bringing material to get that concrete up to a five-story structure, right? One of our busiest intersections. No.

1:07:03 How are you going to do that? So the project itself, the main parking structure is a concrete parking structure. Everything going vertical is modular. And so the construction methodology is to this summer is to build the parking garage, put a surface or put a waterproof membrane on top and stop for the winter season. And then come May of next year, we will set all of the boxes.

1:07:32 Within 30 to 45 days, everything is vertical on the project. And then we're spending the rest of the next six months, eight months, essentially stitching the building together. That is just putting on the siding, putting on the roofing, attaching all of the internal MEP systems, mechanical electrical plumbing systems. And so that's one of the things from an impact perspective is going to be greatly lessened to the community and the surrounding neighbors also.

1:07:59 So if you can imagine, again, 30 to 45 days, that entire project is sitting there. Including the furniture will be already installed in those units? So we're building these in Boise, Idaho, and to Josh's point, even to all the furniture will be loaded, which is a big part of the project towards the end of any hotel project. That's loaded in the yard of the manufacturer when they show up.

1:08:28 It's literally being locked and we just finish off the corridors and the common areas and finish off the skin and we're done. Does that mean the actual site itself will act as a staging area as well? You don't need a separate staging area other than just the site itself? Yeah, we'll plant a crane out front and then, you know, we're talking to the mountain where we stage the units and then they'll be brought in and we'll be setting, I believe we set five per day.

1:09:02 X number per day. And so they'll, you know, we have to work out a whole plan with the town and how we stage and how we pick and how we set. But again, you know. What does that have to do with the mountain, I'm sorry? Sorry? Mountain parking lots to stage. To bring the modules in and hold them and then bring them down and set them. Will that crane be reaching across Main Street? No, it'll be sitting on our site.

1:09:44 Go ahead, sir. Hi. Good afternoon, Commissioner. Tom Hodges. I'm VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. Yeah, I just wanted to confirm that, you know, we've been in close discussions with Chris and Gary on the project all the way from when Gary came here like a, you know, hadn't seen Gary so excited. He hasn't been here since the Interwest days and when rumor would start circulating about the property being sold.

1:10:15 And I put a text in to Gary. He said, hey, Gary, you guys got something going on in town? He says, yes, I can't wait to tell you about it. I'm going to be there tomorrow. And there he was. So yeah, these guys have been really going very quickly with the design and the development. But I think the plan, I want you guys to know that they've engaged us on their design. And as much as that we operate and manage the village and now the Westin, we've got some

1:10:44 Some operating years under our belts with dealing with this type of site and close quarters and snow removal and so forth. And in working and talking with the design team as well, I mean, I think there's no perfect solution for any site in town with respect to snow. I mean, there's always a tough side of the building, right? Leeward side, north side, perpetual shade and so forth.

1:11:08 When you look at the layout and the massing of the buildings, I mean, I think the architects and the developers were very thoughtful of trying to take the greatest advantage of solar access. I mean, the north-south orientation of the length of the building I think is actually brilliant because you actually do have an opportunity to get sun on the majority of the site year-round, even in the wintertime, which is a huge help when you're dealing with, you know, snow and ice and so forth.

1:11:38 And in the areas where they do, you know, have areas of leeward sides and a little bit there on that driveway entrance, you know, they do have those areas snow melted, so that'll help to mitigate those issues. And they have access into the back of the buildings there, as they pointed out to you with that fire lane, so they can get heavy equipment there to do snow removal. The other thing I would point out, too, you know, in a lot of ways, a flat roof is actually the best roof solution for our snow country.

1:12:05 And as the architect team pointed out, the lower parapet, a lot of times it's going to blow clear. I mean, if you look at roofs around here, and this is a great time to go around and look, where you see flat roofs that have sort of clear exposure to where the winds are predominantly coming from the west, where they're clear and flat across, they're blowing largely clear.

1:12:31 It's really the roofs that have the gables and the leeward side gables that those things load up with snow and cause a lot of trouble and then also potential snowfall cornices and dropping down on pedestrians and so forth. You're not going to have that issue on this site. So anyway, I think there's been a lot of thoughtful design and work put into that and I think it's going to perform as well as it possibly can.

1:12:57 And the other thing I want to point to you guys, you know, I mean, you're the Planning and Economic Development Commission, right? And, you know, I think the one aspect of this project that should not be overlooked is the economic, the positive economic impact it'll have on our community. You know, in comparing the key count here on this site to the village and, you know, what we're seeing in current metrics in the village and ADRs and occupancies,

1:13:26 You know, this property has the potential to generate, you know, a million and a quarter to a million and a half in annual TOT to the community. And when you consider that our annual TOT is $18 million and, you know, this is going to contribute another million and a quarter to our TOT roles, that's significant. So, you know, I think we need to approach this as being partners with a developer.

1:13:55 You know, this is a fantastic project to lead off sort of the renaissance here in Mammoth, you know, with some of the renewed interest in Mammoth as a result of Altera coming in and the Icon Pass. You know, we've got some momentum. And, you know, Gary's team and Replay, these guys know how to, they've built Mammoth, they know what they're doing. So, I mean, this is a real opportunity for us to

1:14:23 You know, really get a start to seeing some new development, incremental development in our community in an area that's, you know, our prime time location, resort corridor of our community. So, so anyway, I just wanted to share those thoughts with you guys and just don't lose sight of, of the big picture. I mean, I think there's, you know, a few little things that you maybe still want to work through, but largely, I think those, this project's fantastic.

1:14:48 And I think it's going to have a huge benefit to our community. It's a product that I think is going to be very successful in terms of the ability to sell it. And I have no doubt in my mind that we have a developer who knows how to deliver it. So those are my feelings and thoughts about the project. Thanks. Thanks, Tom. I haven't heard such a pep talk from you in a long time. No, I really appreciate that. And I agree.

1:15:13 Pretty much 100% with everything that Tom just said. So despite the fact that I had a couple of negative comments earlier, I don't want you to think that I don't like the project. I'd love to get one of the units for my family. So I'd like to see this happen. And I think you guys are getting there. Like I said, a few more details to iron out, a couple of tweaks. Maybe we'll have a meeting with ADP tomorrow. We can talk about some things in more detail.

1:15:45 But for now, I think we've had some good comments and questions up here. Is there anything else up here anyone would like to ask? Anyone else in the audience have comments or questions? I have a quick question I'd like to ask, actually, of Nolan. Hey, Nolan, would you mind, without getting too far off track, just elaborating a little bit on what you mentioned earlier with the housing credits? So this site was subject to

1:16:16 I believe it's called an implementation agreement. It was an agreement between the previous owner, Dempsey's when they owned this, as well as the Snow Creek Athletic Site and Aspen Creek Village Apartments out in Old Mammoth. When they developed that, there was, essentially, they got, the developer got, it was like 140

1:16:43 Housing mitigation credits, full-time employee equivalent credits for that development that they have then since divvied up and transferred to other properties that they then own. So some of that went to Snow Creek 7, some of it's leftover for Snow Creek 8, and 40.41 credits went to this site specifically. And so those credits...

1:17:06 are tied to that parcel, tied to that APN, so when they purchase the property, they purchase those credits with the property. So those, essentially they've already mitigated their affordable housing by building that Aspen Creek apartments, not replay specifically, but they bought those rights with the property. Got it. Does this exhaust that pool of credits that are associated with that property?

1:17:35 We're working to put together, so the credits were accrued in a different calculation method under a previous

1:17:44 Housing ordinance. So we're working on converting that into our current ordinance, which applies fees to determine that. So they definitely will have enough credits to cover the project. We just don't know how much excess they'll have. So that's what we're working on and we're looking to bring that forward to Council in March. Got it. If there are excess credits, can those credits be taken off of that property? Yes, currently they can. Thank you. Well, unless there's anyone else out there who would like to comment.

1:18:18 I guess we can wrap up for today. Thank you very much for coming and braving the snow. I guess it was a long drive. We really appreciate your presentation and I know that Sandra is hoping to bring the project back for design review to commission in April. Thank you, gentlemen. Thank you very much. So our next item is a presentation.

1:19:05 of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System and Associated Tracks by Joel Rathje. Thank you, Nolan. Are you here for the April meeting? Yeah. Are you trying to be here for the April meeting? Maybe not March, but April.

1:20:23 Unflicked it out. She's resigned.

1:20:55 Thank you. My name is Joel Rathje. I'm the Trails Coordinator for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And I just wanted to take a few moments of your time. Thank you very much for your time.

1:21:37 to go over the walk, bike, ride action plan that you were a part of about a year, year and a half ago. Of course. Okay. How's that? Does that sound good? Test? Testing. Thank you. My name is Joel Rathje. I'm the town of Mammoth Lakes Trails Coordinator. I wanted to take some time to go over

1:22:09 Parts of the walk, bike, ride action plan efforts that the Mammoth Lakes Trail System has been involved in as a partner. So on the screen I have a shot of the action plan cover just as a refresh. I'm going to begin a PowerPoint. I'm having trouble seeing the screen. I think I need glasses. Did you take that picture, Joel? I did. I figured you did. It's a great picture.

1:22:46 Thank you very much. I do it frequently. Here is a crop of a table that articulates what the Mammoth Lakes Trail System is involved in as a part of the walk, bike, ride action plan. We're not the lead on any one of these tracks, but we are partnered on seven of them. The first one I wanted to update you on was the e-bike track.

1:23:17 We were struggling because Mammoth Mountain had officially working with the Forest Service as partners allowed Class 1 e-bikes on Mammoth Mountain's trails. And so at the time, the Town of Mammoth Lakes Pathway System did not allow Class 1 e-bikes or any motorized device.

1:23:39 on the pathways, and so we felt like there might be some problems having people allowed in one area and not being able to connect into town as a part of their experience. We were directed to engage with the Indian National Forest to see if we could change that. Now, we vetted the request with the community so that we had clarity. We held public meetings. We had a Mammoth Trails.

1:24:08 meeting at the library where the public was invited to come and show up and express their concerns or ideas about how to incorporate e-bikes into our community. This is the letter that was sent by International Forest back to us upon our request to allow Class I e-bikes to be sort of synchronized with Mammoth Mountain Resort. So check. We got one of those tracks through.

1:24:35 You can ride an e-bike, a class one e-bike all around our town pathway system. There's really one reason in this letter that you'll find why we're able to do this is because none of our multi-use pathways were considered Forest Service system facilities. They're under special use permit with the Forest Service and they're not a part of their inventory of facilities. The same applies to Mammoth Mountain. Their trails were built outside of the

1:25:04 Structure of the Forest Service System. Does that make sense? You're saying that that worked to our advantage in that respect? We would not have e-bikes on our trails today, I don't think, if they were a part of the Forest Service System. Part of the agreement with the Forest Service was they requested that we provide some temporary signage to provide clarity.

1:25:31 to trail system users, so we posted these signs shown on the TV on our multi-use pathway system at entry points. We provided public outreach information material so that people had clarity at the bike shops where they're renting these things. This is an 8 1⁄2 by 11 handout that went along with the change of use. We also posted where they're not supposed to go.

1:26:00 So this was the first thing we did. We mobilized and put signs up all over non-motorized soft surface trails throughout the system. And so up in the Lakes Basin, trails like the Mammoth Pass Trail, where they're not allowed, we had them posted up. Here's another example out in the Sherwins on one of our new connector trails. Another piece of collateral that we provided was a summer recreation handout that incorporated

1:26:28 The e-bike use clarity information. So if you look at this map, it's a front and back. It articulates where you can and can't go with your e-bikes. Okay. I'm going to shift gears to the next track. I wanted to talk a little bit about some of our subregions that we work in. We work in an area called Sherwin's area.

1:27:03 Lakes Basin and Shady Rest Inyo Craters are some areas of focus that we have right now. And a lot of what we're trying to do in these areas fit into the context of the walk, bike, ride action plan. So the Lakes Basin in particular. In 2011, Lakes Basin, sorry, I got a little bit off track here. I'm going to start by explaining

1:27:33 The Sherman's Area sub-region. This you're probably familiar with. If you're not, it's been an area focus for trail development since about 2008 and 2009. And so we have projects in the queue. We did a phase one Sherman's Area project two summers ago, and we have forthcoming phases of that project. One piece of the Sherman's Area project we're working on is a trailhead, which will likely become a transit trail hub

1:28:03 Which fits into the context of walk, bike, ride. Here's just an articulation, a map of future phase of Sherwin concepts. We do expect to be building out and connecting the Sherwin's area with the Lakes Basin. Connectivity is critical, we think. Here is a map that shows concepts that have been derived from the Lakes Basin Special Study.

1:28:33 Similar to the Shermans area, this is a little further behind as far as timeline, but these concepts are in development. A lot of the field work's been done for design, and we will be formulating and putting together a proposal to the Forest Service. So these are trail concepts, but they fit into the context of walk, bike, ride, because right now a lot of the lakes are disconnected by pedestrian facilities.

1:29:03 And there are a lot of user-created trails that are not a part of any system. We can't put signs on them, can't tell people to go. There are some use trails that connect lakes, but we're making the proposal and making the case that people should be able to walk or ride a bike from lake to lake instead of having to drive to each lake. Lakes Basin Special Study was paid for by the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. Just a note there, here's the cover of that study.

1:29:31 It focused primarily in front country facilities and the issues around them with a real focus on water quality. That's where the Sierra Nevada Conservancy was focused at the time with their grant funding. So we had issues with parking, of course, guerrilla parking, we call it, where people are just parking outside of parking areas, out in the woods, a multitude of things. And I encourage you to go over this when you find time.

1:29:59 The point is, is that the Lakes Basin Special Study and the concepts coming out of that, we think fit nicely into walk, bike, ride. On this slide, I wanted to have Haislip Hayes provide a little bit of insight, and this is because Public Works also has concurrent projects that fit into the context of the walk, bike, ride action plan. So if you wouldn't mind, Hayes, just...

1:30:27 Take a minute to talk about your project study reports. Absolutely. Thanks, Joel. Like Joel said, there's a lot of parallel tracks that go along with walk, bike, ride in the town. Public Works Department works on a number of municipal projects. We updated town council at the last meeting with basically a state transportation improvement program update outlining what the

1:30:53 Next year holds for us for programming construction projects and one of the key elements of that process is developing project study reports. These are engineered feasibility studies that take a look at the budget, the scope, the right-of-way and all the various components of a project.

1:31:09 We proposed a number of projects at Town Council, and by no means is this list comprehensive or exclusive. There was a lot of opportunity for the public and the council to weigh in on the potential projects, but the idea is to build a bench, a battery of projects that we could potentially fund using transportation improvement dollars. Fund estimates are not in, but they could vary from anywhere from $6 to $15 million.

1:31:33 Over a five-year cycle. So we want to be prepared to spend that money. And we've been working with Joel on a number of projects that cross over into trails and trailheads and so forth to prepare these reports so that we're ready to go once the funding comes forward. Very good. Thank you, Hayes. The next slide and the next series of slides I just put together to indicate to you we are working on

1:32:08 Some trailhead solutions as well, not just trail concepts, but, you know, how are people going to stage for their adventure? So we've looked at, in the Lakes Basin, each trailhead facility and how can we optimize it was the question as a part of this walk, bike, ride action plan effort. Horseshoe Lake Trailhead was a big focus for obvious reasons. We see the most visitation in the summer months, the trolley.

1:32:37 Goes to Horseshoe Lake. So some basic things, and I'm not going to go across everything, but I just wanted to leave you with the impression that we're thinking about things like e-bike charging stations or whatever gadgets come along in 10 years. We're thinking about what they might need for supportive infrastructure. We want to try to make it an easy choice for people not to drive up to Horseshoe Lake, that it's more fun to take public transit or to ride an e-bike up the hill because it's not such a...

1:33:07 Hard pull anymore with an e-bike. And we have a great pathway system in place. Other trailheads like the Twin Lakes trailhead, looking at that for some improvements. And these are basically what I would call strong concepts. It's a way for us to think as a team. And these concepts will be pushed to engineers to actually engineer the facilities.

1:33:36 Here's one at Lake Mamie Trailhead where you can see trails coming together. This is a very high use area as well. And the trails take out, like I said before, to try to make it so you don't have to drive to the next lake that you want to see. Coldwater trailheads, similar thing. And so I'm going to move on to the next track, which is our loop trails track.

1:34:05 My good friend here, Andrew Mulford, has done extensive work on this, both with GIS and out in the field, and put together a brief presentation for you. Thanks, Joel. So, right here's an overview map of the two loop trail concepts. You can see they're both concentric around Mammoth. The smaller loop is approximately 20 miles, 21 miles, and the outer loop.

1:34:39 Approximately 50 miles. I think it's 54, but that's subject to some slight change based on unbuilt segments and getting those through the environmental review process. But I'm going to drive over to an interactive map. Thanks, Joel. So coming out of the walk-bike-ride tract, we were tasked with developing these loop trail concepts. So we brought together all existing

1:35:09 Data sets of Forest Service roads, Forest Service trails, paved roads, and any planning concept trails that we had in the works and brought those all together in GIS and came up with these concepts as at least a place to start and I think they're pretty well developed as far as possible best options for these two trail experiences.

1:35:43 Bear with me here. So in the dark green is all wilderness. So one of the design considerations here was to keep the trail outside of wilderness so that it could be available for trail marathons or events like that that are only permitted to operate outside of the wilderness area. And then you see in the manila color is the MMSA ski area boundary.

1:36:15 So this outer trail crosses it on an existing trail, the Mammoth Mountain hiking trail. So I'll kind of walk you through it piece by piece without trying to take up too much of your time. There are several access points. We'll start here down at the 203 and just follow it clockwise around. So here you're going to be on a gravel road that

1:36:47 Connects, brings you across and ties into the Sherwin Trail Network, hops onto the Mammoth Rock Trail, and at this point here jumps onto a conceptual trail. So actually that brings up a point, let me just show you another layer here that represents built versus unbuilt segments.

1:37:17 So the lion's share of this outer loop trail is built roughly 90%. So everything in green is already built. This area to the north is primarily Forest Service roads. As Joel mentioned, there's a current planning effort going on out there as Shady Rest Inyo craters to develop more trails out there. And as we get those through the environmental review process and potentially build them.

1:37:44 We would incorporate those into this loop trail experience. But at the moment, that section is primarily dirt roads. And so you come around to here, and this is where it becomes unbuilt. This segment follows up Solitude Canyon and connects the Sherwin Trail system with the Lakes Basin. I think the success of this outer trail kind of hinges on this trail piece.

1:38:14 Getting approved by the Forest Service and getting built in the next few years. So definitely something to keep our eyes on. So that trail segment is about 10 miles long. And Joel mentioned before the sharp Sherman's Area Recreation Plan and labs planning processes. I'll just throw that layer on here so you can get an idea. So the yellow is sharp. So the Solitude Canyon kind of...

1:38:42 Bridges the gap between SHARP and LABS and we're currently in discussions with the Forest Service about getting that in the most fast-tracked planning process so it may become a part of LABS or it may stay as a part of SHARP Phase 3, I think he's fair to say. But they are aware of it and we're optimistic that it won't have too many archaeological holdups and we could possibly see it built.

1:39:14 Sorry. Excellent. Yeah. So yeah, like I was saying, 90% built. So that's the main segment that we're worried about getting built. Over here is another little piece of red, which is a trail that's part of the lab's executive summary and implementation plan. But the success of the overall trail doesn't really rely on that little piece. There's other options to route around that. The trail itself,

1:39:47 is 42% gravel roads, 52% single track dirt trail, and 6% paved road. So highly desirable when you look at other loop trail experiences in other areas. That's a really good metric if you're over 50% trail, then I think user groups are excited. I also mentioned, similar to the Tahoe Rim Trail,

1:40:18 There'll be varying levels of use allowed on different pieces of the trail, so you may not be able to ride a mountain bike on the trail in its entirety, but you'd certainly be able to walk or run on the entire thing, and then segments of it would be open toward equestrian and bicycle use. Let's see. Distance? 50 miles. The reason I brought up distance is because when people are interested in organizing events,

1:40:50 A 50-mile loop is very desirable. Thanks, Joel. Let me pull up. Sure. Yeah, that's why not. Just on the user group side, because part of that is already existing, we're that excluded. No, we would not change the use of a road or the use is allowed on the road. Yeah, so you still handle the true use. Oh, sure. You'd have motorized horse, mountain bike.

1:41:33 On a road, and we already, and we already do. You could already, today, you can go out and ride a horse on a road. Sure, yeah. Right, or a bike, yeah. No, thank you, that helps to make the point of, we're not going to restrict, be more restrictive. Yeah. Yeah. Sorry, I'm having a little bit of trouble with this mouse. Joe, I got a quick question. Part of the 50 mile, earlier you mentioned, or, I forgot the gentleman's name.

1:42:08 Andrew. Andrew. He said that parts of it is for bike, parts of it is for walk, and parts of it is for vehicles. Sure, I can... So does that mean if I'm on e-bike, I need to stop somewhere and get off the trail? Yeah, and we have examples...

1:42:33 All around where it's that way today. And the best example we have is just to our north, the Tahoe Rim Trail. And if you go there today and you're riding a mountain bike, you're going to hit the border of a wilderness area at some point. And you will have to turn back around. You can't do the whole loop. Analogous to this, once you hit the trail on Mammoth Mountain, where today it's a hiking trail, not a mountain bike trail, you would not be allowed to ride your mountain bike on that section.

1:43:00 But you could walk or run on all of it. Just like today, you could go walk or run on any dirt road out on the system. The same applies here. So in a similar way, you mentioned equestrians, Andrew, there's going to be a limitation. So the same trail on Mammoth Mountain that allows hiking does not allow horses today. So you would hit that same boundary and have to turn around.

1:43:30 possible for all use. The loop is not to make it possible for all users. The loop really speaks to runners, and runners in particular are going to be the biggest benefactors to this loop, especially people who want to participate in running events. That will be the, I think,

1:43:53 The target audience of this whole loop, because like you're bringing up, we can't do the whole loop on a mountain bike, so I can't really do a mountain bike event on this loop. I can't do the whole thing on a horse, so I couldn't do the whole loop on a horse, couldn't do the whole thing on a quad or a motorcycle or an e-bike. You could do sections of it. And so the Tahoe Rim Trail, what you find are segments are extremely popular with mountain bikers, and other segments are very popular with equestrians, and then the runners are super happy.

1:44:24 As a common denominator. Yeah. That's a great point. And I think it brings up also a point. So with the majority of this thing already being built, it'll largely be about signage and giving some people an option of a trail experience that they can easily navigate. And that northern side of town is kind of intimidating to some people.

1:44:53 Navigating all those Forest Service roads with the limited signage that exists out there. So that'll be a big positive of this coalescence of trails into a loop experience. Let me pull up the inner loop, just briefly touch on that and let Joel move on. The inner loop is 21 miles and is

1:45:36 About half built and half unbuilt. So this one would require some more work to make it connect, at least in this conceptual state. See here it crosses the Mammoth Mountain permit area. If you're familiar with paper route, it's kind of similar to that alignment. Actually, there's a trail concept in the Trail System Master Plan that makes up part of that alignment.

1:46:05 So that would involve negotiations between the Forest Service, the ski area, and the town. For public access. Exactly. Or if it was going to be some type of pay access, that would just have to be signed and made clear. You can notice here that they share part of the Mammoth Rock Trail and that there's a lot of opportunity to use the inner loop to connect to the outer loop and create.

1:46:39 Other experiences also. Excellent. I think that's about all I have. I was trying to pull up the elevation profile for the outer loop, but I'll just give you the numbers here. Low is 7,250 feet high, 10,930 roughly. So you're getting to the Mammoth Summit and you're also getting to the Sherwin Crest, which is also right at around 11,000 feet. So a couple of great climbs and overall not.

1:47:07 Not a ton of up and down, so. Okay. Good work. Thank you. Thank you. Great question. The inner loop would be open to mountain biking in its entirety. The only question mark would be that access issue across the MMSA permit area. Is the inner loop open for e-bike? Sections of it.

1:48:23 Okay. Some sections are road. Yeah, correct. And, yeah, the current Forest Service regulations are that e-bikes aren't allowed on any soft surface trail. That includes the Mammoth Rock Trail. Exactly. In particular for this loop, right? Mm-hmm. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. This guy. Okay. I have these slides up just to articulate

1:49:16 How our Lakes Basin Special Study Concepts incorporate the outer loop. I'm toggling back and forth, and that's how that outer loop fits in. Nice. Okay. Okay. The next track on deck is Long Distance Hiking Hub. Here we go. To promote Mammoth Lakes as a destination for hikers, the town could create a centralized hub for people.

1:49:56 To store belongings, wash clothes, and access other services supporting the local economy by drawing more visitors to town. So this is basically hospitality for through hikers. How are we going to welcome these people into our community? And the Pacific Crest Trail has been around for a long time. And the John Muir Trail, my grandparents went on their honeymoon on the John Muir Trail. It's been around for a long time. It's getting more and more popular. It goes all the way from Mexico to Canada.

1:50:26 And what we're seeing is a real spike in recent times and we can attribute it to things possibly like social media, word of mouth. There's been a nice book written with an accompanying movie about the PCT. Also technology, there's just information out there about these things and pictures are flying around. It's the most beautiful place in the world, so why wouldn't you want to come hike the PCT? And so we're just seeing these numbers.

1:50:55 Go up and up and up over time of permits issued for the through hikers. And so for this track, we've been investigating, you know, what do they need? What do they need for services? And, you know, what ground can we find to support these sort of facilities? So things like close proximity to the trail, town access, we have that.

1:51:24 Transportation from trail to town. We've got a nice transit system all the way to Horseshoe. You know, a couple things we're missing. We don't really have a good, cheap option for the hikers. And we don't have good, like a centralized hiker spot just to hang out and agglomerate. So, you know, we want to think about what will make Mammoth Lakes the Sierra trail town, you know, and the perfect long-distance hiking hub.

1:51:54 We have a lot going for us already with a lot of different services, but we lack a nice centralized hub. Things like showers, bathrooms, water spigot with a drain, basic stuff, bear boxes, hiker box, charging stations, trash recycling, picnic areas, a shaded environment we think is critical, hiker register, public transit, and then

1:52:22 Early on we were struggling to really think of a location and then serendipity happened just to the east of the Mammoth Lakes District Ranger Station. There is an abandoned ADA accessible campground facility that was built in 1970 by the Lions Club and it's just been abandoned and partly built and there's some concrete and it's odd and it's just kind of going back to nature.

1:52:50 And it's in a really good location near the Welcome Center, near the Ranger Station, where people have to take care of their permit paperwork and things like that. It's also where they can get a wealth of information. They can cross the street and go to Starbucks, connect to the pathway system. Nice location. So we're proposing to put together a package for the Forest Service to say, hey, can we think about using this ground and start developing a project? Tehachapi has an example.

1:53:20 of such a place. It's really inexpensive for people to use, $5, and tends to retain people in the area doing grocery shopping, going to restaurants, things like that. And so here's the bullets, positive economic impact we expect from this sort of thing, affordable place to stay where people can plan to stay for a few days in Mammoth on their through hike.

1:53:48 Place to hang out and get your tasks finished. Easy access to showers, even when camping, and with a low upfront cost, people might stay a little longer in town, spend more, it's a great place. And then here's a note, in July of 2018, Mount Shasta, the town, was named the first trail town of Pacific Crest Trail, and we want to get on this list, since they're starting a list.

1:54:17 The city teamed up with the Pacific Crest Trail Association in an effort to boost the local economy as well as promote trail advocacy. And the neat thing is, we're so much closer to the PCT than they are. It's kind of out of the way to go to Mount Shasta. So we think we fit this bill better. And that's the Hiker Hub. What's the significance of that designation, Trail Town?

1:54:47 Significant, so it's a Pacific Crest Trail Association thing, right, so it's their program, and so whatever channels that they push out and promote things, that's the benefit, so Mount Shasta's benefiting from the marketing compartment of the Pacific Crest Trail Association, essentially, you know, it'll be on their literature, it'll be on their website, hey, go to Mount Shasta, and a lot of the through hikers, you know, get information from the PCTA.

1:55:17 So here's another interesting one to toggle. I'm going to move on to transit trail hubs. I mentioned that earlier a little bit. So think of this as a trailhead that is much bigger and has a transit connection. Here's a photograph of the Horseshoe Lake Trail today and with some recommendations. And this is in your packet. I can't read these words from here.

1:55:46 But hopefully you can see in your packet, okay, here we got it. We've got it. Great. We've got things like benches, nice trash can facility that consolidates recycling and normal waste, interpretive signs, benches, things, a lot of these things you already see out on the system. It's a matter of putting everything together in the proper configuration for function. And you'll notice a nice...

1:56:13 Vault toilet bathroom. That's a vault toilet that we're proposing. That's actually a cutout from the one at June Lake. So we took a photograph of the new bathroom at June Lake that they put in as an example. Things like ADA access off of the asphalt onto the sidewalk. You know, some really rudimentary things, but putting them all together in a nice, clean way efficiently.

1:56:40 Here is out at what we're calling the Sherman's Trailhead where the propane tanks are. Two summers ago we built two new soft surface trails and one of them connects here. A part of the next phase, phase two of Sherman's projects will be this trailhead. And so it's got a transit stop, nice interpretive signage in the background, our nice large type two trail system sign with map.

1:57:09 Our poo ferry station for dog waste, recycling and trash, bike rack, things like that, and a bathroom. So you're anticipating extending the pavement to that point there? Yes. Yeah, you won't see that whole dirt area paved over, not the whole thing. Right. Small. Access to this location? Correct. Okay.

1:57:41 And if you're interested in the next phase of Sherwin's projects, I'd be happy to sit down with you and show you all kinds of good stuff. Thanks. So that's sort of the concept development we've done with the transit trail hubs is really putting ideas together into a visual format for discussion to share. And then this is a supporting graph that shows

1:58:12 We have trail counters. I should start over. We have 38 trail counters installed on our trail system for the summertime, in the summer. And it tells us where the most people are going. The trail counters are often, you know, 10 to 20 feet into the trail, so you don't necessarily see them. And it tells us where we need things like more bathroom service, more trash service.

1:58:40 Also more transit service. So we can tell by looking at this that Horseshoe Lake in a season is seeing just over 50,000 people in 2017. Dropped down in 2018 a bit. We're not sure quite why. It could have something to do with the unbelievable snowpack in 2017 that people were pent up is what we were thinking and that July came and

1:59:11 Everybody wanted out. Or a bad smoke season, that may have had some effect. Right here. I wanted to briefly update on wayfinding signage. As you can probably gather by now, we work a lot with geographic information systems to try to keep things straight. We have a database.

1:59:52 for all signs within the municipal boundary. Each point has information and a georeference photo associated with it, so we can do work in the wintertime on these sort of projects. More recently, I know Hayes is bringing forward a municipal wayfinding program that'll be implemented, and he's working with trail system staff to make sure that all things wayfinding are integrated and that things like naming conventions are all consistent.

2:00:21 across the whole system. And that's probably as much of an update I want to provide on that. You'll be seeing a lot of information coming from Hayes on that. But I just wanted to make the point that the trail system is synchronizing with that effort to make sure that things are consistent. And then update on recreation support facilities. We are working with Stu Brown to come up with a plan.

2:00:59 to do the same sort of GPS, GIS inventory of all park facilities. So everything at Whitmore, everything at Mammoth Creek Park, we're gonna, Stu will have to pay for services, our team, Andrew runs the program for GIS, for MLTPA, and the goal there is something similar to what we've done with the signs, is to support Stu in that way, so that they can make

2:01:27 And then lastly, lastly, I'm already there. Due to weather, our new Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator is not with us today. I was gonna introduce him to the commission, but I wanted to describe the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership. If you hadn't heard of it yet, this is a,

2:02:01 The partnership, it's expressed through a challenge cost share agreement between Humboldt-Toyabe National Forest, Inyo National Forest, Mono County and the town of Mammoth Lakes. Matt Perullo was hired, his name is Matt Perullo, he came from Yakima, Washington most recently, got here a few weeks ago and this is an effort that's very meaningful for the region in how we

2:02:30 really take care of our public lands, how we can provide services to our visitors, important services, and really how we can help our federal partners provide better services. And the best example I have is actually right now between the town and the Mammoth District of Inyo National Forest, an example of what you could see come forward is the STU's program that maintains

2:02:59 And it was three days a week, once a day.

2:03:30 Two times a day. So everything in our municipal boundary will have that kind of level of service for the same amount of money. So through a challenge cost share agreement with the town and the forest, we're able to provide better service. We think that we can manage the human resource part of the equation better. That's what they think. They have a hard time getting seasonal staff nowadays.

2:03:55 And there's high confidence, Stu and Warren, I made sure to ask them, is this good? I mean, is this a bad deal for you? It actually helps Warren's program in the summer because some of the energy, the staff that he's going to have on doing those projects, he'll be able to flex them in to help on other town projects. And so it's a net benefit to the town's recreation staff. Wanted to be sure to share that with you.

2:04:23 And so extrapolate that sort of thing to the county and then to the region. I know Inyo County and Bishop are also interested in this agreement and will likely sign on to it sometime over the next year. So it's pretty interesting, very high level agreement. The Sierra Nevada Conservancy is watching this and potentially helping with this effort. So I wanted you to be aware if you have any questions at all. We now have a coordinator to help answer your questions.

2:04:52 Great. I have a really quick one, Joel. What would be some of the services that this, what would be provided seven days a week, two times a day? They're cleaning bathrooms and emptying waste facilities. Okay. That, that's it. Thank you. And that concludes my presentation. I really appreciate your patience and your time. That's great. Yeah. Thank you, Joel. A lot of great information there. Thanks, Andrew. Appreciate it. Yeah, really exciting stuff, guys. Thank you. Yeah. That's pretty good. Really exciting stuff.

2:05:26 All right. I guess, well, were there any other additional questions before we wrap up? Okay. One quick one, Joel. When do you foresee the timeline when you're going to approach the Forest Service to inquire about the usage of that deserted campground behind the Welcome Center? Right. So the way I explained it to the ranger in our meeting yesterday, great new ranger, though. Gordon Martin, if you hadn't met him, had a great meeting with him yesterday.

2:05:56 I told him that, hey, we kind of have these planes on the runway, on the taxiway. We have a lot of projects stacked up. And as soon as he's ready to absorb, we're ready to launch. And this is one of those proposals that would need to come forward, get it in their queue as a part of their annual work program. That's the key, is to get things in their work program. And we think that this partnership is a great way.

2:06:24 for us to work collectively to, you know, influence their work program. Great. Thank you. Well, thank you very much. Good deal. Thank you. All right, that wraps up our business matters. We do have one item on the consent agenda. It is the minutes from our last meeting on December 12th. Unless there are any comments. Did you have a question for that? I do not. I was about to make a motion. We can just do a

2:07:04 A group vote. All those in favor of approving the minutes from December 12th? Aye. All right. All right. Quick commissioner reports? I think Joel just kind of summarized mobility, some of the stuff we've talked about with in our last meeting. I mean, I don't really have much to add to your summarization. Thank you, Joel.

2:07:40 I don't have any reports, but I would like to thank town staff and all the plows out there, the men operating those plows and women, if there's women, for doing such a great job trying to keep up with everything that's going on because it's been kind of rough for everyone. So thank you, everyone, for your hard work. Absolutely. We had an ADP advisory design panel meeting last month to...

2:08:10 To discuss the, um, the hotel project, so, which I alluded to earlier, uh, and we have another one scheduled for tomorrow, so, um, that will be a little bit more of an in-depth conversation on the hotel project, uh, prior to the project coming through to, um, uh, for design review with the commission. I think that was the only design committee or design ADP issue.

2:08:32 No, tomorrow you're also looking at the 540. Oh, right, tomorrow, the 540, 540 Old Mammoth Road project, which is right next to the Sierra Center Mall, the currently empty lot. So we'll be looking at that tomorrow as well. And then I am sad to say that I've really enjoyed working with all of you for the last four years, but this is unfortunately has to be my last Planning Commission meeting because I have accepted a job as an Associate Engineer with the town.

2:09:04 So I will be around. I will be working with Hayes and Grady in the public works in the engineering department. But I start doing that in March. So this is unfortunately my last meeting with you all. Congratulations. Yeah. And it's been a pleasure, Amy. Thanks. I may see you all from the other side of the table next time around. We'll make sure to grill you. Okay. I'm just kidding. But you have provided fantastic leadership for this organization. Thank you. It's been a lot of fun.

2:09:34 So just kind of following on that item is all schedule. I'll include an item on the agenda for your next meeting to appoint the chair and vice chair, however you end up deciding. So you'll have that opportunity to talk about reorganization of the commission. We will recruit for Chair Callinan's position.

2:10:03 Probably we won't, I don't think we'll have another commissioner by March because it usually takes some time to recruit, but we hope that we'll have someone for April because we do have a pretty full meeting for April. March is a lighter meeting, but on April we should have the Yotel public hearing. We'll likely have the 540 public hearing and some other items as well. But we'll follow up and let you know how the recruitment goes at your next meeting. And I think that's all I have.

2:10:33 Thank you, Sandra. Okay, well, then we can adjourn to the next scheduled meeting, which is at 2 o'clock on March 13th. I'm sad we don't have a gavel for your last gavel. I don't need a gavel, that's all right.