Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2019
Mammoth Lakes Recreation Allocations meeting
· recording 1 hr 48 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
227 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
5:13 I hereby start the meeting of today's allocation committee meeting with MLR. I'm Heather Schaubmeyer, and this is my first time, so I apologize if I stumble through this. Roll call, please. Heather Schaubmeyer. I apologize. Sorry. I've heard worse. Don't worry. Here. And Catherine Taft. Here. Thank you.
5:49 Okay, any public comment? Public comment before we move on? Okay, so I think we will, first of all, we need to approval of the meeting minutes from January 10th, 2019. I don't believe we have, Catherine was here, but I don't know.
6:14 Right. You can? Okay. So you just need a motion. I need a motion, please. I'll make a motion to approve the minutes from the allocations committee meeting from Thursday, January 10th. I need a second. And I'll second. Okay. All right. Fantastic. Call for a vote. We can just do all in favor. All in favor? Aye. Aye. If you want to vote, we can definitely vote. I think we're okay. I do appreciate that. Thank you very much.
6:42 Fantastic. And then I think from there we're just going to pop into the review of the applications for 2019-2020. Thank you, Kim, for all of your work on this lovely journal that we all had the pleasure of reading in the last week and getting it to us in a very timely manner. And I think at this point we should just go ahead and start since we have the people here. Thank you very much for being here from Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater. And then start with you all.
7:12 Mr. Rich Baccia. Good morning, Madam Chair, committee, staff, members of the public. Rich Baccia, Mammoth Lakes Foundation. We're honored to be here today to participate in the allocation process. We've been involved in this process historically for a number of years. We're very pleased on the outcome. We're very pleased with the work we do at Mammoth Lakes Foundation supporting higher education and cultural enrichment. I've got Betsy Truax, our Development Director, here today to answer any questions about the application.
7:41 And Shira Dubrovna, our Artistic Director, to talk about programming specific. We're very excited about the Mammoth and Arts and Culture Project. We'd love to have the opportunity to speak with your entire board about where we are in the process, you know, as we kind of move this project along. So with that, good morning. Thank you. We're here to answer any questions you may have for us.
8:01 Just one thing, Madam Chair, I'd like to reiterate for the public is the purpose of the allocations committee is to review the applications. They're very thorough here and gather more information and questions. And then at that point, we make a recommendation to your board. And the board is the one that either that approves that sends it back to us for more information or clarification for the funding along those lines.
8:31 We're asking a lot of information gathering questions today that will just help provide that process because Measure U funds are public funds. And we want to make sure that it's very transparent here and invite those that are thinking about applying for Measure U funds in the future. This is a great way to see how the process works. Absolutely. Thank you. I guess we'll go ahead and just start diving in this. As I was going through
9:02 Y'all's application, the increase of $14,000. I did read through it. As you know, $51,000 is already a large portion of the budget. Could you please explain to me the $14,000 specifically and why now without the actual structure, please? So I'll start and then I'll have Shira speak a little bit specifically to the budget. Okay. One thing that I just want to clarify is that
9:31 Previously, as you know, we had an approved multi-year allocation that was approved by MLR, but our multi-year funding was not approved by town council. So last April, when council voted on multi-year funding, ours was just a one-year fund because obviously with the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center coming online a little bit later, it's just shifting a bit. So the reason that we...
9:56 Applying for more funding is one, because I think when our original application was done, it was anticipated that the MAC would be a little bit further along, if not even open. And then also, we are just really increasing our programming, and I'll let Shira kind of speak to that. To get ready for the new facility, we do need to ramp up the type of programs that we offer and also the amount. So we will be adding programming.
10:23 Also increasing the amount of imported shows, which we have to bring in professional actors, we have to house them, we have to pay for their transportation. Even though I use connections to get the best deal possible, there are expenses that you cannot get around. So I think that that's where the increase is going to be coming in. We've tried to keep it as low as possible, that's realistic, and also that keeps with our trajectory to having
10:52 the programming that is appropriate for when we open the bigger facility. So I think that it is appropriate and also conservative for what we are planning for the future. I'm ignorant right now. When are you all planning to break ground? Okay, next.
11:16 Okay, I got about an hour I can talk. I know, I know, but I've been involved in the process, but where are we at now? Environmental review is going to be approved by mitigated NEDEC by the Planning Commission on April 10th. We've hired Banner Construction Management Firm doing pre-construction services. We're continuing our capital campaign. We believe we're 80% funded at this point in time. We expect to break around in the spring of 20, so about an 18-month build, and open in December of 2021.
11:44 Are they going to do like a prefab? Sorry, because 18 months sounds really fast to me. Are they doing like a prefab? No, not prefab.
11:51 You know, we're looking at, you recollect, you look at the town work plan, there's $2.5 million of one-time capital for Measure U. There's the ongoing of $300,000. We anticipated, as Betsy alluded to, that we'd be here today asking for that, but we're a year behind the scope right now. So we're beginning to expand programming. We'll have a community group coming together to talk about what else goes into the facility. We're pretty jazzed about it, but we're beginning to look 18 to 24 months out, so we feel like we're on target right now.
12:20 I'd like to speak with your board to a bigger presentation on this project. Thank you. I have a question, too, and I don't know who it may have played. There are some things that happened with your programming or your ability to work shows. The government shut down and your facility was used by others, which you didn't anticipate. There's cancellation of shows. How did that affect your revenues and your programming?
12:50 So I've been here for 12 years. Before this February, I've had to cancel three performances in 12 years. In February, I had to cancel three shows, three performances all in one month. So this is not a norm winter. It does affect us financially because we do lose revenue on ticket sales and lost money.
13:18 We anticipate productions that will make a certain amount of money, and given the circumstances of this extreme year, which doesn't happen every year, I mean, like I said, in 12 years I've had to cancel three performances, and I've done at least probably 75 to 100.
13:35 Performances or events. I think that's a really good track record and in one show itself had to cancel three that kind of shows how this year is an extreme year and extenuating circumstances. But I don't foresee that happening every year. So this year was special and we did lose some money because of the weather. Anything from the, I know there was some Forest Service
14:02 Yes, the Forest Service had to use our facility. Did that affect you? Yeah, we had to move some scheduling around to accommodate the rest of the community, and we're more than happy to do that, but it is taxing on our crew and our staff, but we are always willing to work with the community and make it happen because that is our commitment to the community with having performing arts here. Okay. On the budget,
14:34 Oh, my God, please. Take it, honey. Take it over there. We got extras. They must think there's a lot of emotion involved. It is the arts, but we'll make it work. I was reading through the budget, and I see an approximate 30,000 donated of housing needs. We also received a discounted rate from our partner going from
15:02 20 to 30,000, I'm sorry, 20 to 50,000. It's a $30,000 difference. Can you explain what that is, please? Housing of talent. Sure. So we used to own fully the student housing facility. We partnered with the hospital, bought into that, and owns half of the facility. When I used to have access to that entire building, that went away when we sold the building.
15:32 I have within the entire year, we have the film festival, which we house probably about 100. We had 140 filmmakers. We had about 170 to maybe 180 people that we house just for the film festival alone. Then when I do the theater for young audience, we bring in actors for an entire week that we have to house.
16:02 I also do other shows that we bring in people that we have to house. So even though I get a lot of housing for free, I can only ask for free for so many times when you're housing that many people throughout a year. So even though I would say I probably have more than $50,000 in housing and a lot of that is donated, but we do have to pay for some of it. So that is where you see that.
16:28 That line item. So excuse my ignorance, but, and I understand like when we like do special events, you've got to house entertainment, right? So is that what you're, is that why you have to house 140 people is because you're housing the entertainment? So for the film festival alone, we housed 140 filmmakers that attended. We also housed
16:48 Some of the VIPs that came, the people that are on the jury. Sure. And that alone is about 170 people. That's just for the film festival. Then throughout the year, I have, I do two, we just moved up to doing two Theater for Young Audience programs, and those are usually imported. So I have to house those actors. That's not 170, but it is, so we had four to five actors for one. We had
17:17 Two to three for another. Then I had also, I did an imported show for a Christmas show, which was two actors that came for a week. So it adds up. I think the amount, the hip hop workshop, which we're going to be doing. So like I said, it does have, we bring in a lot of events that are not just homegrown.
17:43 Yeah, no, I get, I'm just thinking, 140 people to house, 170 is a lot. It is a lot. Come to the film festival, you'll see how many people are here. Is it because you didn't give them housing, they wouldn't be able to afford to come? I don't understand how film festivals work, so that's why I'm asking. Yeah, yes, that is correct. Filmmakers spend all their money on their films, and because we are a new festival, that is part of the incentive to get, most film festivals don't have that kind of turnout.
18:11 But you have to remember when you get that one person housing, they bring in 10 other people because their friends from LA, their family will come and see their films being screened. So there's a lot of support that comes in from us just offering that housing to them. Now, I get some money to help pay for that and that's the one that we do get a discounted rate for. So when I'm
18:39 I'm housing those 140 filmmakers. I'm paying a discounted rate and the Sierra Nevada Resort is footing the bill for the other half. So that's not the total amount that we're paying for 140 filmmakers. We get a very, very reasonable and inexpensive and very generous donation from the Sierra Nevada Resort to make that happen. And that's why this film festival has the trajectory that it's had is because of what we offer.
19:07 We've had, for five years in a row, we've had one of the top 50 film festivals worth your entry fee from Movie Maker Magazine. We had Variety here last year. We had Vanity Fair last year, Associated Press, Huffington Post. So it's really, because of that offering, it's put us on the map in the film festival world. I think a point that is working, this is part of what I used to do in another life, was
19:37 Not only helping to coordinate things like this, but I think what is not probably represented in your budget is the incremental dollars that are brought to the community for something like this. And so it's a small representation. If you looked at your number of room nights, that might be the better comparison at this rate to show how much it affects it. And as you said before,
20:06 They are eating, drinking, shopping, recreating in the community, and that's really where the community benefit is. And to give that back as the more it grows, yes, the expenses go up, but how many more people it touches in the community, and that is one of the goals that...
20:24 The Measure U funds are things that actually grow things within the community, too. And I think that that's, it's, I think your budget reflects the impact on the community quite conservatively. Oh, okay. Yeah, last year the film festival actually sold out midweek airfare. Wednesday and Thursday were both sold out because of the film festival. In May. In May, yeah. Midweek. When you could fly. Yes. So that was kind of an interesting.
20:55 And if I could just add something, too, I think Shira summed that up nicely, but the other reason for the increase in that part of the budget is also because, as we all know, our shoulder seasons are shrinking, which is great for our community, and we have very generous lodging partners, but we are also, you know, we're also just seeing some rate increases, which I think is, you know, across the board in town, ADR is going up, and so it's not just an increase in housing, for example, the hip-hop workshop, you know, we'll be bringing in actors for two
21:25 One last question about this. And your access to the housing on site, is that affected seasonally? Do you have more availability in the summer for that? Or is it just this is it no matter what? It's more in the change in the management of the student apartments.
21:53 And also I think that's why I picked Memorial Day weekend because historically it wasn't a very busy weekend and so that's why I picked that specific weekend to do the film festival and it's kind of one of, now we're known for Memorial Day weekend, the Mammoth Lakes Film Festival happens. So as things change it'll be interesting to see what happens but that's originally why I picked that weekend. And now that you're skiing it.
22:20 That definitely is going to affect occupancies. And I would suggest locking in your prices right now. Oh, you know, on that note, that is actually a lot of the filmmakers do go skiing when they come up. So they're not only, you know, buying food, they're skiing and they're buying memorabilia and things like that. Do you have any questions for us?
22:53 No, thank you for the clarification on there's a request for an increase and in order for us to fight for additional funds because it has to come from somewhere and looking at, you know, fighting for additional funds that'll be something that we have to have all the ammunition, the board will have all the ammunition it needs to do that because
23:23 You know, there could be somebody else in there asking for the very same thing. And, you know, we need all the, just all the ammunition. Which is why we'd like to have the opportunity to meet with your board to make a formal presentation about the project. You know, there's been some transition with MLR. You guys have been a little challenge at this point. So this is just one little piece of the pie.
23:43 And we want to give you the idea of the holistic picture of where we're going over these next 18, 24, 36 months. You know, we're sitting in the house right now looking five years out and trying to backward map that. What do we need to do is we've ramped this up, what does programming look like, fund development, facilities, you know, the indoor house with 300 seats. How do we use Edison Theater? How do we maximize that? The outdoor amphitheater. You know, there's a lot of moving parts right now. We'd like to have the opportunity to share the entire picture with you, which I think would be probably easier to sell.
24:12 You know, an increase in funding at the same time. So with that, thank you. Isn't that you would like to put on an agenda for another meeting when we have an April in front of the entire board? Whatever works best for you all. Okay. Yeah, I think I mentioned that at your last board meeting that we'd really like to get in front of your full board. Okay.
24:27 Kim, could you make note of that? Thank you. I have one last question that does not have to do with your specific funding, but is one of your partners that I need some clarification with, and I'm hoping that you all can help me so I can see both sides of it. And it's when you look into your profit and loss on your arts program revenue, it says Forest Island $21,750. Could you explain that to me? Because I'm confused on that. Forest Island, we've been working with, this is our third year with them. We are their nonprofit umbrella. It's a pass-through for us.
24:57 Kirsten does a great job with the program, but she needs a home base. Three, four, five years ago, I think, MLR agreed to bring them on to fund them for some of their spring and fall seminars. I meet with Kirsten quarterly to talk about programming and where she is at this point. So right now, we are their pastor. We are their nonprofit. I'd like to see them grow over time. If I stretch this a little bit, I would compare her project, you know, similar to Anderson Ranch in Snowmass, Colorado.
25:26 You know, we have on our 86 acres, we have two acres set aside for some kind of visual arts facility of some sort. And we begin to talk about what does that look like. We've talked with Mono Arts Council, you know, and right now it's kind of sitting in our house. We're not quite sure it's where it's going to live indefinitely, but we want to support the growth and development of the Forest Island Project. We think it's a very positive addition as we really build a balanced community that has, you know, a thriving arts and culture component.
25:52 Okay, so that's how it's just a pass-through aspect. Okay. Okay. And the in-kind donation aspect of it, in-kind, what is it that you are providing, or is that her in-kind donations? It's on page two of Profit and Loss. Sorry, but this is kind of fun stuff we get to go through. Just so I can understand it, it helps me when I'm going to the next person, please.
26:23 Okay, that in-kind donation for Kirsten over the years, she said in-kind support from the Rudder Center, which is no longer the Rudder Center. But it's nothing that's coming from you specifically? No, no. It's just, again, it's part of the budget and your budget? Yes. Okay. Mountain housing, support for the facilities, things like that. I didn't know if it was something that you were providing her, but it's just her budget that happens to be part of your budget because of the housing aspect. Okay. Okay.
26:47 Cool. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
27:19 It's kind of interesting when we look at the budget. So I don't know if this all makes sense to you when you're looking at it. So I just wanted to make sure that you kind of, we started doing multi-year. Last year was the first, well, two years ago was the first year that they, last year was the first year that I was part of the allocation process.
27:39 Two years ago is when they started multi-year. Okay. Okay? So when I was given this, I'm like, okay, so we've got multi-year, three-year, which is great for the application process because these people don't have to do this every single time, right? They get to go off and do the follow-up. However, what it does do is it ties down. We've got $115,000. Right. And it ties it down. Committed. Committed. So if you look at what we have to play with this year, we right now have $32,000, $32,605 to play with. Right. And then when we get into next year,
28:09 We'll have 57,000. But you can see there's a big chunk of change of these people, the Chamber Music Unbound, Eastern Sierra Symphony, Mono Arts Council, and Mammoth Lakes Library will have to all reapply for multi-year again. So this is actually going to, believe it or not, be an easier year than what next year is going to be. So just to put that into perspective.
28:28 of what all we have going on. And then do you understand what special project is versus multi-year funding? Okay, cool. All right. I just wanted to make sure because I remember the first time I was like, say, what? That's very important to recover that for the public because the application is so thorough, the process is very thorough, but it can be very confusing. If it's confusing to us and we're working with it, you can imagine what it is somebody trying to see the difference between different funding.
28:58 Different funding criteria, different funding applications. And so thank you for expressing that for benefit of everyone. It's really important because to me, like when we're sitting here planning out year after year, whatever we say this year goes into multi-year, then ties up this is 57 for next year. Exactly. You know what I mean? So it's...
29:16 We're kind of playing this game, and that's why I think it's going to be important when we meet with Rob Patterson on Tuesday that we have this conversation of, okay, as this is growing and we're seeing where the needs are, are there going to be more funds available? And where does that come from? Is this going to be, I think there's, I was reading an article.
29:38 And the sheet where somebody was saying, you know, growth year over year for event funding, is that something that we're going to embrace as a town? Or is it something that we're going to tick down instead? And the applications are... These are the conversations. Exactly. And we're encouraging programming. We're encouraging for people to do more and more, to make this a more well-rounded, you know, year-round resort. And improve their programming. And we just saw an application that is saying, we want to improve our programming because if we're building a facility, it's going to have to have a level that...
30:08 That may be different to the community, so let's ramp it up, understand that. But is going through, so you have good years to have a static fund there. Is there any way that we can work with this? And the fact that we have to, that our applicants have to have matching funds.
30:24 And it's not, you know, it is a gift with stipulations. And so those funds, they have to go out and find other sources to match those funds. That does show the commitment to it. And though we've made this commitment for multi-years, we go through and scrutinize, is it an effective commitment? Let's go to Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association. So this is not their first year to come with us.
30:56 Let me go through here. They received Measure R in new funding. They received 7,000 last year from us. I believe they originally applied for more than that, but that's what we came to after our whole scoring system. And then this year they're asking for 47,95, which tells me that they've done a little bit of readjusting in their budgets and looking what they truly need.
31:25 I do appreciate their conservativeness on this number because they could have asked for... Yeah, that was my feeling as well. Like that's a nice round number. Okay, so yeah, I think it's a number that they thought about and in the past they've asked for significantly more. So I'm like, okay. When I was reading through here, I want to go over to the facility itself and look at their ADA accessibility. I think it's something that's important when we're dealing with public funds.
31:52 I was actually going to go by there yesterday. I didn't have time to find out. Cool. Thank you. To find out if that's something that's going to be, I can't imagine that the Forest Service isn't going to be getting any money to make that ADA accessible. But it's maybe something we can talk to them about, encourage them to maybe try to get funded for at some point.
32:20 Right? So that we are keeping our public funds. Exactly. And these guys, when the government shutdown did happen, they did go over to the foundation and they get to use their location, but I think it affected their show because of the move of location. And it was also during cruddy weather, let's be honest. Yeah, it was a triple whammy on anything that happened in February. So the fact that they, yes, you didn't have expenses, but you also didn't have your opportunity to support those things too, which I think we're going to,
32:50 I saw throughout everybody's presentation and it's really appreciate the community coming together to support certain things whenever it could and those are things that we always should have a contingency for and along that line so I appreciate that. Does anybody know on here it says Mammoth Lake Tourism on their finances?
33:17 Total contribution, $56,375. Does anybody know where or what that is? I was looking through their tax return event, and I found it interesting that MLT gave them $56,375. I don't quite understand what that is, and it was just one of my questions for them. Is that something, Kim, that we could send them an email in and ask them?
33:47 For clarification of? Process we can write, you know, make note today of specific questions. Okay. You as a committee have. Okay. And we can email them and they can have the opportunity to attend the public hearing.
34:01 To answer that? I would appreciate that because here is a question that I need to find out about. I've seen in a couple different instances, and I'll bring it up again later on, of MLT giving funds. And from what I understand, and I don't know if they justify it as a grant or if it's passed through in another way, but I did notice another one of our applicants that they received grant money from MLT and also from us. And it's my understanding when people get special event funding specifically from the town that they in turn can't get town money, they can't get money from Measure U.
34:30 Right? So they can't double dip. So my question is, is that how do we separate and what is the clarification of something like when I see MLT 56,000, what is that? Right. How does that work and is there any conflict? Exactly. So that would be my question on that one. Yeah. So we need clarification. Correct. That this is not part of the match. Right. This is not a qualifier. I just want to make sure that in no way or form we are
35:00 Funding events with the guise of programming. Funding something who's getting funding from another source of the town money specifically. Right. Right? So like when Jazz by the Creek got money from special events, then that disqualified them for getting money from us from Measure U. So I just want to make sure that that's all going in the same direction. Right. Did anybody have anything else about their application that stood out or any questions that they had about it? No, I mean, personally, I think this one was
35:28 Well within reason. And I think really. Especially with the adjustment of the budget shows that they will really went in and crunched their numbers. Absolutely. And found out for areas that they could, this would help their sustainability as well. Yeah. Do we know, do they have, they have a different contact person, Jeff Gabriel. Okay. So different from last year. Okay. All right. So we'll probably be meeting them whenever we have.
36:01 And I think in my underneath the same understanding as everybody else is, we're just going through the applications, we're going to have discussions if there's any questions, and then we will do our own individual scoring, and then on the next meeting have a discussion about that scoring.
36:15 Yes, that's fine, because in order to do the scoring, we need to have these questions done, make notes there, because it applies to that, makes a scoring process, which for the public is very intense, and it is, you know, it's not a subjective process, it's designed to be objective, and this is the information we need to do that. And I think we can discuss that maybe if we have time after we go through all this, we can kind of talk about how... No, that would be very helpful. Okay, how we kind of applied it, but I think if we are...
36:44 efficient with this, because there's going to be questions, obviously, as we can't make decisions today, and our scoring will be obviously influenced by the questions that we have answered, right? Kim, do you have a copy for the public or something to show that scorecard?
37:06 basically that we could present to them because I think that would be helpful if anybody is looking in wanting to see well really you know how is the scoring because that's great because I encourage anybody that wants to know how you do how we do this it's not a dartboard it is actually you know because it
37:28 It follows the strategy and it meets, everything has to meet the goal and it's given a score, an objective score, is it one to five or one to four? Something along there. Zero to five. Zero to five is that, have you met that? And also an important part is you may get a zero on something because there's no way that you could, on a particular element, but there was nearly a hundred elements that the scoring was.
37:55 One thing doesn't disqualify, but then appealing to having a mediocre score on everything may disqualify you, but it's good for everyone to see. And I think, does everybody have like a full understanding of what their program is about, what is it they're doing? Absolutely. Their budget seemed spot on, no questions there. I don't have any additional questions. Thank you. All right, so we can move on from those guys. And I think that was my only question that I have on there.
38:25 Okay. Forest Island Project. Yeah, so as we get into Forest Island, I just want to bring up, and I've spoken with Matt about this previously, that I have personal ties to many of the members of Forest Island.
38:41 You know, stay with a friend up here who is on their advisory board. So I do feel strongly that I should recuse myself from a formal vote, but if everyone's comfortable, you know, I'm happy to be part of the conversation. I think what's interesting about, and I appreciate the putting out there, in a small town we all have some sorts of connections, right? And so I understand if you'd like to recuse yourself from that, but I think being part of the discussion of your support is important for
39:10 Somebody, like, because Forest Island is so new to our community. That's great. And somebody like myself, I'm still wrapping her head around what it is. Sure. And I get it now. Last year it was a little harder, but I get it now. I think it's important to have your input. Great. And if you want to increase yourself, that's totally fine. We'll just make sure when we do our scoring system that it's off. It will be off of what we score in the recommendation.
39:35 And so I appreciate that because there's a lot of things that we've over the years been trying to figure out. Mainly how Forest Island Project really connects with the community here in Mammoth because
39:51 The community is the constituency that's going to help provide them funds. And so that has been where there were questions and things, and so I appreciate you being available for questions. One thing I did want to mention is I was able to see a presentation for the Forest Island Project at the recent Mountain Ventures Summit, which was...
40:15 It was a wonderful event to have to this community. I was bummed that I missed it. Everybody should be bummed if you weren't there. Because to see just a little plug for this type of activity is to see other communities like communities in the Eastern Sierra, in the Tahoe region, how they're addressing some of it.
40:37 The very same, if not more issues this community has. And we have a tendency to believe that we're unique. We're not. We may have...
40:48 We may have some different situations, but they're all providing the same result. So one of that, which I was very encouraged to see, that it wasn't all economic, tech, housing, although those are very important. There was a segment devoted to art in these communities and how other things were here. And Kristen made a presentation.
41:13 I saw what they were doing, and it still clarified even more that the challenge is to connect this with the community. And there were a lot of things that kind of were glaring in front of us as, why didn't we think of that? And, you know, one of the things is, I'm seeing they have had some struggles with their locations and space there.
41:36 I looked up in the meeting room I was in and realized it didn't look any different from where it did 15 years ago. And every wall was blank. The fact that, you know, there is no gallery space, we are one big gallery. And looking at creative ways to bring art into everything we do because we've looked back at the other communities and realized that
42:01 The art is everywhere for them. And that is something that this community has struggled with. And there's a lot of things. So there's a lot of opportunities, whether it be physical gallery on this wall or a virtual gallery through electronic on that monitor in some places. So I was excited to see that there's ways that we can address this if we just look at it differently.
42:31 It's a very, they have a very large request from us. And we have given them something in the past that was not near their request. It's a large request. But how they're doing it and programming it and want to make sure that we're still fulfilling that and give the community an opportunity to see what they've done.
42:56 Exactly. And I think that that has been the biggest challenge there. So when you do meet with them is how are we going to show the community how their money is being spent? Right. I mean, when you're dealing with public funds, people want something tangible. Absolutely. People want to see the result of what they're giving money to. And I completely understand that. And even having pop-ups.
43:24 You know what I mean? There's a lot of people who don't have bricks and mortar restaurants anymore. Exactly. They don't have pop-up restaurants. But they make sure that they're out there and that it's known. And for me, I know Kirsten's had a lot of issues with location, but I think that we could help with an olive branch, help her out, which you did, so thank you, of having these discussions, helping her find, because some people...
43:50 Are good at creating, but maybe finding a way to put it out there is probably more difficult. Versus me, I'm more about like, I can get it out there, but the creative aspect, it's not my forte. You can see by my drawings. So I guess, I think, what is the new situation with her location? Does anybody know? Is she going to be back in the Sierra Center Mall?
44:17 Is she not? I believe at my last, and I think that this is maybe something that Kim, you might confirm, my last conversation with her last week was they had come up with a compromise and alternative. She did have somebody advocate for her that is a tenant of the mall for this space and how much it is. I believe that they're coming to an agreement, which would really help that.
44:47 Along that line to give them the visibility that they need, which would be one step and give them a home to feature this. And then she was definitely interested in looking at ways to provide this information. I mean, what I'm holding here is the activity report that actually has what they did for the last year. It has the stories why these particular...
45:14 pieces of art were important and how the Eastern Sierra inspired them. Well, this could be put on a USB stick and shown in different areas at different times. So that's what I'm talking about as far as virtual art in a lot of areas that don't have wall space, but they have
45:37 TV space and things there in the Forest Island project. So that is kind of a way to look at how this technology could help us going forward. And I think she was really open to then producing something like that that gets their content out there. Like doing a presentation to the chamber. Absolutely. Like going to a chamber meeting, doing a presentation, being part of the meet and greet with the community. So that way there's exposure to the community, exposure to other business owners, exposure to locations.
46:06 I just think it all needs to become a little bit more whipped into our community. Yeah, and just having known them and watched them from their founding to where they are now, I think it does take at least a three-year cycle to get their program up and running. And because it really is just Kirsten on the ground, one person, it's a tall order. She's heading up all the applications, all the funding, working with the artists, getting them logistically here to make their work.
46:35 I think I expressed this at a board meeting before, but the public perception of Mammoth, or I'm sorry, of Forest Island Project in Los Angeles is quite big. Completely different. You know, like we know in the arts community that this is happening, that this is a possibility for artists from other places to have a chance to work in the Eastern Sierras.
46:56 Which I think is terrific for them, but as you've expressed, it's not really reciprocated the other way around to kind of get the local community more invested. Like I wonder like if, and this is me totally speaking out without having anything to back it, okay, but I'm wondering if like a space like The Village.
47:14 Or one of the, during the summer event series, having a 10 by 10 setup. Absolutely. And just to be able to speak and communicate with the community. I also think another thing that could be a possibility, I don't know, but like the old Polo location next to Black Velvet Coffee, just doing things like that and have like a wine and art night.
47:37 Or a chocolate and art night or something like that. Just something for a presence for the community. And I know it's a lot because it's one person. I get it. I get it. And also the nature of the work that's being produced through these residencies isn't always the kind of thing that you can easily hang on a wall. Exactly. It's ephemeral, it's performative. So I think, yeah, it is a challenge for Kirsten and for, you know, the kind of curatorial goals that they have.
48:04 How they're going to be presenting the results of this. But as we heard from the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, you know, they potentially have the ability to help grow with Forest Island and give them a space on their own. That's fantastic, especially when you're talking about the foyer of somewhere for something like that. That's what used to be housed. Yeah, and really Anderson Ranch is a great model for this in Aspen, which is a world-class residency where artists come from all over the world.
48:33 Yeah, just bring culture and contribute to. Well, I think that by reaching, the first place I would reach to is the chamber because she has something that there's no way for her to know where do I start. Chamber would help her start. And, you know, whether we, whatever level we decide to work with it on there, this would be.
48:58 Key to getting it going and being successful and to doing this here. And I think that that is a great, because after I saw the presentation and realized nobody gets to see this, but then there's no place to see this in the community. Wait, there's a lot of places to see this. We just, you know, can't, the Mountainside Conference Center has completely blank walls. And it's...
49:25 Wait a minute, what if there was a, these were used for other types of things, you know, you have to produce it, you have to bring it up there, but many communities have it in public spaces, they are safe, you know, because it's always a concern, is the project safe there? Go to...
49:46 Go to Park City, go to Deer Valley, go to Breckenridge, go to even Mountain High. It's art is in that, and that's how we integrate in the community, and that's probably what our overarching goal is. So it was good to get it to understand, and how we can assist them is pointing them in this direction. I really love that they also connected with SNARL. Yes. I thought that was a smart decision.
50:16 And I'd actually like to hear a little bit more from Kirsten about it. But that had me intrigued and happy to hear that instead of feeling like it's taking a negative into something positive. Absolutely, yeah. And maybe, Kim, it sounds like we want to reach out to her if she just did the presentation that she did at the Mountain Venture Summit. Mountain Summit, which one?
50:46 That answered a lot of questions, and I think for the board it would probably answer a lot of questions too. Then we go to my favorite part, budget. So when I was looking at the budget, there's some things that I need clarification on, and when you just go to Mammoth Lakes Recreation, proposed budget was presented in her application.
51:16 Do you have a page number? You know what? It's right when you go to... I know it's so hard. When you start the budget instructions and then you start there. And this is like the last couple pages, so it's kind of nice to see that. It says like miscellaneous, $19,500. It's the largest item in the budget, but it's miscellaneous. So I need clarification, being that it's...
51:42 Twice as much of anything else, more than that. It's more than like 110% larger than anything else that's itemized. So that is something that I would ask questions about. Fundraising, who do you have now? So I see fundraising $10,000. My question would be, how do you plan on getting that $10,000? Like what kind of fundraising are you doing?
52:05 Is that an event you plan on putting on? Is that a person that you're talking to? So just a little clarification on that because I know this is the reason why I'm getting kind of nitpicky because it's such a new thing. I know that it's hard to get funds so I just need to kind of feel like we're not the only source of income and I need to have a little bit of a stronger understanding of where additional funds are coming from. And then something that when you go to the next page,
52:35 Volunteer federal rate. Just so she knows on the in-kind contributions, this is something she may not understand. She gave it a value of $65 per hour. Underneath federal volunteer rate, that would be 22 point, I think it's 24.14 is what it is right now. And so that needs to be adjusted on there. And that's going to bring that down to...
52:55 $1,700 versus $5,000, which affects her in-kind contribution aspects. Maybe have her rethink and rework those numbers and really sit down and think about how much volunteer time has really played into it, and she's going to have to adjust that, unfortunately, to the federal rate. And then I guess my other question on there would be housing sessions, two times at $10,000. That sounds like a lot of money for housing.
53:23 So I need clarification on that too. Yeah. And just the same way that we did with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, if you put it in context of room nights at a certain rate, that may help give us more clarification. And also we want to make sure that she is negotiating like everybody else at a certain time. And she may not know.
53:51 Who to talk to or where some sources are about that. But to split that up and how many room nights are you really talking about? And I think that is really a good way to clarify how many artists you really have to bring here with the housing it does. And because this is required in order for their participation. It's part of the part of the deal. Yep. And the same thing with like the studio space. Again, I don't know.
54:18 So that's why I have to ask. It seems like a high number to me, 2,500. I consider like if I like to rent a space for 500 sounds reasonable to me, 2,500 sounds kind of great. It's high, especially when a lot of the artists are working out in the field. Those are kind of like my little red flags. Stipends I get, that's 1,500 per stipend. I understand that part of it. Travel's expensive. But those are just kind of the couple things that stood out on me on the budget that I went, wait a minute.
54:48 That needed a little bit more clarification and a little bit more understood. And that's my finality of tearing that apart. I hope it wasn't too brutal. Scrutinizing. Scrutinizing. I hope people realize that that's all I'm doing. If anything, most of this stuff, this is a lot of numbers to look at for every single person. And I'm not trying to do anything more than ask for clarification on things that stand out.
55:18 Right. Absolutely. Absolutely. Because I do understand that putting things on are extremely expensive. Yeah. Does anybody have any other questions about Forest Island? Any clarifications? No. I think, you know, another, I don't know when the right time to talk to Kirsten would be about this, but I would wonder, you know, what is their kind of even two-year plan, three-year plan in terms of becoming their own nonprofit?
55:45 Not having to use Mammoth Lake. That's a really good question. Thank you for bringing that up. She discussed that she wants to. Great. So she may need guidance in the direction to go. Yeah. And it would be appropriate. Yeah, I think that would help, you know, give us a sense of their kind of financial.
56:06 And also here's the other thing is that when we're doing these multi-year recommendations, they're recommendations. So this is not a guarantee either because it comes back on the performance report. So we could say, okay, we recommend that we give her the three-year allocation. However, based on the performance report, next year, if we're not happy with something, because I know this is all slowly going to be moving forward, but if for any reason it starts moving backwards, we can say, wait a minute. And I do know that setting up a nonprofit, which I'm sure you know, it's a...
56:34 It's expensive. It's time consuming. So I'm hoping that she can partner with somebody that can help her get through that process and get out of the house of another establishment. But that may not be the best use of their funds. You know what? Until you do the exercise, you go, you know, and you want to...
56:54 You don't want to feel like you're trapped and that you're not able to do this, but that may be the best level of support and they can use funds for other things and energies for other things because when you're a one-man show, you know, she's out of hands to hold things up. But she should at least explore. Yeah, and in terms of a multi-year investment from the community to really see that they are serious and here to stay and grow. Yeah, and grow. Absolutely.
57:24 Do we have any other questions or input on that? Forest Island, do you have anything else? No, I don't. Could I propose a potty break in about 10, 15 minutes? Sounds good. Sorry. Friends of the Inyo, they have a phenomenal budget. They do a lot for our community. I'm very thankful for them. You can see that last year,
57:56 They got $6,000. Let me see here. This is from last year's also. I think last year they asked for the same amount, $17,000, and then we gave them $6,000 on that. So I think this is going to be one of those situations where they're asking for the dream number, and then we figure out from within there what we can actually apply and help out with. I had a couple things about them that,
58:28 I will, we need, that we clarified last year, but we need to make sure we state it again and that we can only fund things that are in Mammoth Lakes. Mono, we're not funding for someone to go into another forest. So any of their work that we contribute funding to needs to make sure that it stays within Mammoth Lakes. We're not, and because we have four different,
58:57 Forest Services crossing over and county lines and stuff. We just need to make sure that we keep that very clear. And the only thing on their budget that kind of, on their profit and loss that kind of stood out to me, which is after their tax return that I was like, what is this? Contracts, it says. And I don't know what contracts are. January through December 2018, $68,000. And the budget of that was $147,000. So they were...
59:24 You know, down on their budget $80,000. My question is, what is that? Did they lose a contract with somebody? Did they lose funding in that amount of $80,000 from somewhere? That would be my question to them, because that was a big difference. And I don't know if I have... I'm personally kind of familiar with this program because we went through it last year, so kind of in depth.
59:55 Does anybody have any comments? Recall what we, you know, the questions are and those seem to be the same questions here. I think with the guidelines and making sure that our funds are applied to in Mammoth because Measure U is from Mammoth voters and the clarification of tell us the information regarding the contracts is this, you know, and how do you see that affecting?
1:00:21 And you saw that they, I think, where is it, should be a comment in here, something about, on the performance report, about the trail ambassador, maybe doing more stuff on the weekends, is that what she said in here? From the beginning of the application? Yep. Or the presence during peak time? And, you know, once I think is...
1:00:44 Refresh my memory if I got this wrong, but once again, it was, this is for programming and not labor to do, and we had some issues to make sure that those clarifications were consistent there, so. With the programming, and so it's about having stewardship is the primary funding for behind this. Because our trails program, we do.
1:01:06 Give $300,000 a year to the Trails Program. We want to make sure that we're not crossing over on that. Exactly. And, you know, the Ambassador Program. Excuse me. No worries. Okay. That was the same thing. Yeah. Same questions. And, Kim, I'm just making sure we're putting this all down, right? Cool. Thank you. I know I've probably asked that three times. Do I need to write or not? Yeah. I'm like, do I need to write? Be writing this down.
1:01:41 Thank you. Anything else, ladies? For that one, no. For that one specifically, no? I think that looks good. Should we go into the Mono Historical Society? And this is going to be for the Trolley Program. Historical Trolley Program. So right now the Historical Trolley Program is May 24th through September 8th. So that's Memorial Day through Labor Day.
1:02:07 I think originally they had, last year when they went through this application process, they were saying, you know, pretty much based on how much funds, depending on how much they can put out there, whether it be four days a week, whether it be seven days a week. It sounds like in this new application, they changed it to just Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, from 12 to 6 is what I have highlighted here. So they've kind of narrowed it down to specifically what that is. Which is where, if it's, you know, if you have
1:02:37 A guide on there. That's the time that most of the travelers are the visitors. They've seen that and they've seen that concentrate their efforts on the weekend. They'll probably reach more people. Which is interesting because during the summer, I mean, we're busy seven days a week.
1:02:55 That's the one thing. Well, and it's the tough part. We are busy seven days a week. We have a variety of international visitors. They actually, now it's spread out a lot. But if you're having a real bulk of visitors, they actually are here Tuesdays, Fridays, and Saturdays. Because that's the pattern that their travel programs provide them.
1:03:22 Okay, that's where we have the biggest influx. So that means they could be, but they're here at certain times a day, in the afternoon and after the evening. But also as we see more people, hopefully our visitation, we're seeing more people add extra days to their stay in the summer, more domestic visitors that live here, they are still tied to weekends and things.
1:03:48 The program's got to give somewhere. It needs to have interpreters seven days a week. We know that. But is it, I think your question is, is it feasible to just limit it to the weekends? That would be based on their ridership. And if there are statistics they're saying that ridership, we have the most riders that benefit from this program on the weekends, at least they're making those judgments to put the few dollars they get into.
1:04:18 So this is one. Does anybody have any other questions? Do you have any questions about the programming, about what it is and what it's about? No, I think I got it. And she had mentioned in there that they wanted to move it into the winter, but in this application, she didn't apply for this for the winter. There hasn't been any programming explanations for what the winter is, so therefore I'm going to keep this on that this is Memorial Day to Labor Day. This is where we're at.
1:04:46 Until there's something that's more concrete. So that would turn out to be is when the board, you know, our recommendation is based on the application. If you want something different, change your application and do that along here. But that's what we would be looking forward to do is based on this application. Here is my big red flag. Last year I knew that she was in conversations with MLT.
1:05:15 For the trolley program, I know that there was a conversation. Nothing had been set when we gave allocations out from Measure U. Measure U is specified in their profit and loss as a grant for $7,500. MLT is specified as a grant for $15,500. Now, I get MLT is not considered town money specifically, but I need clarification on that because just like Jazz by the Creek,
1:05:45 Got event money, therefore we could not give them funding. I need to make sure that we are on the up and up on this. Please. For the same program. Is that double dipping? Is that something you're going to talk to, Rob? That's something I can bring up to Rob for sure at the meeting on Tuesday.
1:06:08 Right at the top of the meeting. Let's get this out of the way. We need clarification on funding because I know special events and Measure U are not allowed to. This needs to really be spelled out black and white. And as we know, there's been a lot of confusion on where MLT dollars are versus special event funding is. That was a big conversation that's happened this past week. So we need real black and white understanding for the community to understand how this works because I think there's a lot of confusion. We don't waste anybody's time. Correct.
1:06:37 Trolley Program Payroll, $28,400. Payroll expenses, other. So I don't know. I guess I have it highlighted. I thought that was kind of high, but maybe I just need to...
1:06:54 Because I don't think it crossed over with what her other budget said on what things were being paid. You just might want to ask for some clarification as who's providing these. Are they ESTA drivers that are at a certain level? Are they private drivers or whatever that is? Because that just may be, there's no choice. They're not our own employees. And because of driving that particular type of vehicle regulations, they contract that out. Yes, ma'am. The pay is for drivers?
1:07:23 Or the actors, I believe. That's what I wanted to know. Is it for the actors? Okay, which is the programming aspect. It should be. Okay. But we could clarify with that. Clarify that, yeah. Yeah, just make sure that's what it's for. It is, I want to do that. Yeah, right. And then after that, when you go to her budget for 2019, she then changed over to the grant dollars from us being $12,000 and the grant dollars from MLT being $12,000. So reducing the money from MLT by $2,900. So I guess, or...
1:07:52 $3,000 depending on what it is that she got exactly. So I guess my question would be for a little bit of clarification on that too. Is she downsizing that because she thought she was going to get more money from us? Is she downsizing that because that's what she was told she was going to get? And that just is where I wanted to know on that. In kind. So in part of the...
1:08:30 Proposed project budget instructions is that for the MLR is that you're supposed to, you're 50% of your ask, 25% in-kind, 25% organization cash match. This is the only applicant who has zero in-kind, I mean 1% in-kind. Does that disqualify them because of that? Yeah. The organization needs to show that they're... So they need...
1:09:00 Yeah, so that's way out of balance. There's some things, I mean, not everything's perfect, you know, like I'm not going to sit here and be hardcore on exact numbers on everything, but this one is way out of skew. So at that point, we give them the opportunity to address that line on them, to come back, the one opportunity to do that. Let's clarify that. I think this came up in a previous board meeting, and we said they can do up to 25% in kind, but if they get a matching.
1:09:29 of that portion. They don't need to show in cotton. Up to. So like if they have, okay, so let's clarify this. The way I understand it is it's at least by matching. Oh, at least. So it is a necessary requirement. Okay, got it. And in cotton, again, at least they can have.
1:09:51 Sure. Okay, I see. That's my understanding too. And the reason is, is because, again, we don't want to be bankrolling everything. Yeah, no, of course. And that's where we're kind of coming from on this. Now, I guess my question would be is that if their cash needs match up to, their cash sources match up to half to their needs, then we could probably push the in-kind over a little.
1:10:17 That was my understanding from a previous board meeting that, you know, as long as you're showing at least 50% matching. At least 50% of something matching, whether that be in-kind or cash. Yeah, exactly. That makes sense to me. Yeah. And if we need to clarify, we can, but to me that makes sense. Yeah. My point is that half of your money is going to be coming from somewhere else besides us. Exactly. Whether that be in-kind or cash.
1:10:38 Correct? Yeah. No, that's good because for the record, they probably can't hear you, but that is that they have to match 50%. The guideline is 25-25 there, but if you go 45-5, you're still matching. Is that your interpretation? You're still matching. You're fulfilling the requirement. And she's got partner funds on here, $12,100, MLR fund request $12,100. So she's doing that 50-50.
1:11:08 So I guess she doesn't need to redo it. But do you, Kim, do you feel that we need clarification on that? And the partner funds would be MLT. Do you know what I mean? That's me because that's what she put in her budget for 2019. So do you see that? So then that to me goes, okay, so 100% funded by the town then with MLT and MLR or Measure U, excuse me, not MLR because it's not our money, but Measure U's monies. So to me that's not flying.
1:11:38 And I want to, and I like this program. This is nothing. It's just this is part of our curriculum of what we need to make sure that. Well, that's part of the mandate. Mandate. Yeah. Is that we can't. Not our choice. The community cannot 100% bankroll something. We're not going to make that call. And then anything else. That's it. Yeah, that's it for that one, right? Yeah. Until those questions are answered. Do you all mind if I take a quick break real quick? Totally fine. Okay. I appreciate it. Thank you.
1:12:47 Do we want to go into the approved multi-year funding, folks? Or do we want to save that for another time? Does anybody have any questions about it? Did anything stand out on anybody? I didn't have, I didn't really have any questions because of looking at what we had last year and a lot of those questions about their programs and things were answered and those are continuing. So I really don't at that point, but somebody else may.
1:13:17 Did you have any? Yeah, I guess I trust the recommendations and these are fixed numbers, right? No, nothing's fixed. Oh, there's nothing fixed. Okay. Here's what I would like to be able to say was that are recommendations from last year people can depend on. Okay. Unless something horrendous happened or they didn't do what they said they were going to do.
1:13:37 Other than that, I would like for the point of having multi-year funding is so that people can depend on those funds. And so I would hate to ever take anything away from the recommendation unless there was something that really glaring non-performance. Otherwise, I would like for those to stick that way. Then I completely trust where these numbers are founded. Yeah, and it was, and it's, well, yeah, what do you, questions, please?
1:14:02 Oh, no, I don't think there's anything specific. I was just, yeah, more of the general. Understanding how does it work. Exactly. And some of these recommendations were done before we, so last year was our first year. Okay, good. And then that was their big question when they all came in, because these people that are on their third year right now were all like, are we getting our funds? I'm like, somebody else recommended those, I'm not going to touch them. Okay. You can depend on them. That's great. So next year we will have our first round of kind of really kind of going through and making our decisions based on that. Because they will be approved.
1:14:31 They have to go through all of this again and look at the performance of the past years. Did it meet, you know, did it meet a standard for funding? Is there any recommendation that, oh, this didn't work and, you know, it would be non-performance based on their, in something that they could control.
1:14:52 We're finding all types of maybe it's turning out to be non-performance that was just force majeure. The weather, it couldn't do those type of things and that's the type of stuff that it happens and we all have to find a way to recover from that. Anything forward? I think we can move forward then unless anybody has anything else they'd like to add. Special projects.
1:15:27 Eastern Sierra Conservation Corp. Inyo National Forest to determine best locations for backpacking with an available volunteer trail project. I think this project's pretty awesome. I think it's a phenomenal opportunity. I like its message. I have it highlighted in two different places. Inyo National Forest to be determined.
1:16:00 This goes back to the same thing that we tell the people with trails. Right. It has to be in Mammoth Lakes. Exactly. So I don't know if that's something that could be changed. I don't know if that's something where we should say, if you want to go with Inyo National Forest, let's put you in touch with Friends of the Inyo. No. Okay. So do you think that Inyo National Forest is just something in general?
1:16:32 Can you specify on that? Do you know a little bit about it? Yeah, can you repeat the question? I've got to start. So Inyo National Forest, to be determined for best location for backpacking. Yes. It's an available volunteer trail project. So for us to do funding through Measure U at Hasse Mammoth Lakes, can that be changed in their application? Is that something that they're willing to discuss or specify? Yeah, I think that's something we should reach out to them to reiterate.
1:17:02 That it's not going to be a wilderness project. It will be in your national forest within the town of Mammoth Lakes planning. Exactly. That would be fantastic. So it needs to be updated. Right. And to just, you know, let's see the trails that you want to use. And that would be easy there because of the trail system. Correct.
1:17:25 Will be probably wilderness enough for a lot of people at that point, but then realizing, you know, around the airport lands and things there, along there. I think there's plenty of trails to satisfy their project, just to find it for us. Excellent. And this is multiple series, correct? It's not just one, because I was seeing over 18 weeks. Eight days through 18 week.
1:17:55 Experiences. I guess I'm trying to figure out the math on that. Like, how many different groups are we talking about? Or does it take 18 weeks to start it, do it, and finish it? Or is there multiple groups? Sorry. The way I understood the application was it was each group would be, there would be several different groups doing the same iteration of the program.
1:18:24 And these are going to be primarily folks that are brought from out of town to come experience Mammoth that come from different walks of life. More urban environments and things that don't get the chance to experience this and don't even know if they ever would. And it very well could also be Mammoth Lakes youth that participate in this program. It's not open to solely out of town. And I think that's what they said in the application is they would open it up to the locals first and then bring it in also.
1:18:54 A really awesome program. I totally agree. I think it's really in line with MLR's strategic plans also in terms of development. The allocate strategy, new, yes. I agree. I guess, and this is consistent through their application on the finances, is that their year one is half of what year two and three is. Do we know why that is the case?
1:19:26 On their finances, Kim, do we have any idea? Sorry, I was taping. No, no, I'm sorry. It's okay. So if you look at year one, operation and management, $7,400. You go to year two, it's $14,800. And that's consistent throughout their budget that year one is half of what year two and three are. So I'm just trying to find out why. Could we?
1:20:00 That'd be fantastic. So that we requested that we ask for that clarification. So you don't have to run up there. Just everything that I have answered for, we will clarify. Great. I'm looking at the, for year one input, just right off the top of the hourly pay for the program manager. It's the number of hours doubles. So they may be looking at this being
1:20:29 On their fiscal year, it may, this funding program may be coming in at the middle of their fiscal year. That may be the answer there, and then that would make sense. So even though that, just clarification on what that is, but if that's, if they're doubling the number of hours, we may be coming in the middle of the year if we could have that clarification. So here's a question for us in this. Programming is what we're paying for.
1:20:59 Now this program is people going into the wilderness, which involves equipment and people, but it also includes food and beverage, which is $2,500. Is that something that needs to be for us excluded as a portion of what their cost is, or is that considered part of the programming? I know that sounds silly, but it's a question. It's a good question. Yeah, because if you were presenting this.
1:21:27 If you were marketing this, you would say, this program includes the tour, the guided tour interpretation, beverages, you know, you get a pair of boots. And that would be part of the program and the benefit to the program. But now if your program didn't include those type of things, you know, that's a programming thing. It's not like it's a food party.
1:21:58 No, it is not. I think that's really excellent. Is that what I'm saying? Like, this is part of what their program is. So we can say that that's okay if anybody has any questions about what that is. I would say that's an excellent distinction. Okay. Yeah, it is. We're not having survival pizza. Because we have these similar conversations about programming and what people are versus people's salaries.
1:22:23 Exactly. Right, during that conversation we've had about how does this work to justify. So the survival pizza party after the trip is an event. This is part of the program experience. Right. I think that's a fair distinction. Okay. Yeah. All right. And everybody kind of agrees with that. And you know, the good part is they broke it out exactly that way, was allowing to show that it
1:22:49 It is not just a gathering afterwards. This is actually part of the experience. I think it qualifies. Does anybody need any more clarification on what this program is and what it entails and all that good stuff? Okay. We can go on to the Historical Society, Southern Mono Historical Society for the re-roofing of Hayden Cabin. I do know that this was asked for back in, I think it was October?
1:23:18 When it was first presented to us, I know that there's a sense of urgency. I'm kind of wondering, based on our programming and how checks are written, if they're going to be able, like getting a check from us in July, is that going to be good enough, considering they want to put a roof on as soon as possible, but based on this winter, they may not see a roof until July. So, I mean, this is one of those years, right? So, I mean, that would be something to ask the applicant.
1:23:47 Obviously, making sure, or I guess not asking, but clarifying that they understand that through this process, for this one-time funding, that a check would not be cut until July. And that she understands that when dealing with having to write checks for people's services. And so, also can, if I was a member of the public, I'd be asking this question. Yep. Can you explain to me how a new roof is,
1:24:19 Falls under the criteria of programming? It doesn't fall underneath programming. This isn't going to be any special event. Exactly. So this is going to be any special event. A special project, not an event. Sorry, special project funding, excuse me. Which has more discretion. Which has a definition that can include infrastructure. Thank you. Yes. And I guess as somebody who understands the costs of building in this town,
1:24:47 I would request that she get two more quotes. Another roofing quote and another parts quote. And if she's got high country lumber, I would like that she would get a quote from one other company, maybe even at Home Depot with a delivery cost involved. And Freeman Roofing, who I know, great people. But I think it's always wise for any business to get more than one quote.
1:25:16 And I think that would be a fair, you know, two or three. I just think it'd be fair to make sure that these costs are in alignment because I know, and obviously I'm going to assume, but I did not see in this that permits were already pulled and approved for this because I know that that takes months in this town. So that would be something else I would like to have proof of that permits have been pulled, that they've got the go from the town, that
1:25:42 That they've done their due diligence on making sure that we get more than one quote for the parts and for the labor just to justify the cost. Within those quotes are going to come if they have availability to work and that may need that clarity as well. Am I reading this right that they've received special funding in the past? Yes, they have for different programs but not specifically for the roof. So they have received funds for us but not for this special project.
1:26:18 And let's see here. I'm trying to find the exact wording for special product. I know we have it in here and the multitude of papers here. Measure R, Measure U. Requirements for it, yeah. Yeah, there is Measure U funding, special projects, $25,000. And I know we have wording specific if anybody would like clarification for that, but I know I read it.
1:26:51 Great. To make sure that we are correct. Yes, ma'am. The measure U reads, for the purpose of planning, construction, operation, maintenance, programming, and administration of facilities and projects for mobility, recreation, and arts and culture. Cool. Thank you. Thank you. For the record. Does anybody have any questions or any input on the roof other than that? That was my own question. Thank you for the clarity on that.
1:27:26 And one more thing to add, excuse me. Those two projects we just reviewed are requesting funding for the current fiscal year, 18-19, special projects. So how would we be able to expedite that? Do we need to separate those from this allocation process then and get them in front of the board sooner than later? That could be debated. I think the biggest thing is just separating the actual allotment of what funds are available. So there's $25,000.
1:27:55 Available for fiscal year 18-19, an additional 25,000 for the 19-20 fiscal year. Okay. So that being said, we would need to make a decision on this sooner than the other. Then to me, I think we should separate these special projects. Because special projects, we put them into this allocation process, but they don't need to be in the allocation process. So I think if we could...
1:28:18 Make a separation of those. Okay. Is there any outstanding questions you need to ask of Rob next week? Is it the access to those funds? For that specifically, no. I just need to know, for myself, I would just like to ask, and I know quotes can take a lot of time, so if we could just ask Marianne, I know she's been very patient with us, and we asked her to come into this process, and I appreciate that. So if we could ask her to please just get one more quote, and they may say there's no accessibility to the property.
1:28:47 That might be an answer we get. If that's the answer, then at least she tried. And I know myself, I have done quotes from High Country Lumber. Is it High Country Lumber? No. High, what's it called? Down in Bishop. Just want to make sure I say this properly, where she got her quote from. I've actually spoken to these people also from High Country Lumber. I actually got a quote from them also and compared it to Home Depot, and I think it ended up being a difference of a couple hundred dollars. I've done it myself, but I would still like for her just to...
1:29:17 to make sure if that's okay. And that she could probably do, honestly, in a couple hours. If she does not come back or is not able to come back with another quote for a roof because of the accessibility, are we okay with moving forward based on one quote? Yeah, I mean, I think if there's this urgency, but yeah. You know, because what if it's nobody else quote? Right.
1:29:43 Which is very possible. It's very possible. Sorry that I'm thinking and we're processing this out loud. No, that's actually part of this process. We have to. We're going to have to eventually. Especially if she just gave us that information that they need this done in this fiscal year, that means we have to move a little bit faster on that. Yeah. So with that being said, the Mono County Office of Education on this sheet was kind of separated.
1:30:10 The 1920 versus the 1819. So what you're telling me is that that is why it was separated because the money's got it. Because that was my question when I originally said it. I'm like, why is that separated? I'm going to start off with saying I love the Mona County Office of Education, what it is that they want to do with the Create Eastern Sierra Arts Institute. I had a really hard time finding an alignment with our strategic plan.
1:30:44 And what Measure U is specifically for and this program. Can anybody please give me some insight of how you feel? And it was really a hard pill to swallow to go to bed with last night. It's hard to connect. Because I really want this program to exist. I just don't. And I actually, I know that they applied at the special events process through the town.
1:31:15 And I hate to keep closing doors on people, but at the same time, I don't know if this is where this should be housed. And I would love any input if you guys have any on how this works with our allocation strategy. I'm not making any decisions today on this. I need to sit down and kind of process it and really go through our scoring system. Exactly. And make a decision based off of that. But anybody's input on what they felt and how it could align
1:31:45 With our strategic plan and what the allocation process is meant for for Measure U with this program, I would love to hear it. Well, I think that you came to that conclusion based on the application was not aligned. Correct. So the first place I would start is sending the application back for your one time to please align it with this because
1:32:16 They're, you know, looking at their budget is absolute, their expenditures are absolutely not, they're for the things that it's not to be used for. So show us where you're going to apply these requested funds to your programming. And if it can't... Well, this is for special, it doesn't have programming specifically. But...
1:32:42 It doesn't, from based on her. Okay, that's what you're saying. Based on her description of that, doesn't fall into that either. Right. And maybe they need a little bit more clarity on what special programming funds are to be used for and appreciate that there's more leeway in that. But let's apply them a little closer. Okay. Because if you're not seeing the connection, give them a chance to make the connection. If they can't make the connection,
1:33:11 Your decision is made. Yeah, exactly. And I also think that, and I did have this conversation with her at one point because I was there at the special event funding meeting. It may be premature also, and this might be something that once she kind of gets her hands in it, it could evolve into that aligns more with what we are about. Yeah, exactly. Do you know what I mean? Yeah. Because I think it's really at the beginning.
1:33:41 Right. And what this program is. It's hard to define. Startup. Startup. Sure is hard to define. Exactly. So I would like for her to kind of go back and really read about what Measure U is for. How does it align to what Measure U is for? And if she can't find that connection, she can kind of understand where we're coming from. And I don't want to close the door. I want to say, okay, if she comes back to her own conclusion that
1:34:07 Maybe it's not the right place. Let's try to help her find that connection. But I'm not making a decision on it right now. I'm just asking if she could please reconsider her application to really look into it, to kind of see what Measure U is, to make sure that, and then we'll go through the process with her. That sounds fair. Right. I think that's, and just to get a sense of what these workshops are, you know, I think with the other special project request for the
1:34:35 kind of outdoors program. We had a sample curriculum. We sort of had a daily breakdown of what really the educational value. Right. And that's always the issue. And how it aligns with us.
1:34:48 To your point, that's always the challenge of the first time applying. And we give that opportunity to anyone. And some of them, we had a lot more that are on multi-year funding last year that we did kick it back and say, okay, find this. And they did. So that's why it feels like there's only a couple that fall under that criteria. But that option was open to everyone. We did.
1:35:14 But they did a great job this year of coming back and making sure that that was the goal to align that. So they're not getting a consideration any more than anyone else would. This one needs to have that connection that wasn't done. Are we good on that one? Mm-hmm. Okay. So I think out of this, we'll go now and look at our scoring card to kind of go over that in that discussion. But I think at this point we realize that we need to kind of fast track and we might need to have another session.
1:35:46 For those special projects to fast track them. And we have that understanding. So we might have to schedule a meeting within the next couple of weeks. And I think what we could do for ourselves is to, on those special projects, based on the information that we have, and if we can get additional information on the roof, that would be fantastic. But with the information that we have, to go ahead and move forward with.
1:36:12 A recommendation based on your scoring. We don't have to do it today, but we can then after that have a special meeting specifically about the special projects. Okay, great. And then go from there. No, I'm open to that. Because we have the $25,000. It needs to be fiscal. It is a process. We understand that, right? Mm-hmm. Okay. I think probably the next challenge will be getting this room available and everyone's, you know, participation. And I do know that.
1:36:40 You have the ability to call in, Catherine, if you're not in the area, that still is compliant with the open meeting. There are others that are calling. Would we need to, and we would obviously need to get board approval for those funds, which means we could do it when we maybe do our special session in April, and then we could vote on it specifically for special projects in April?
1:37:12 So they can fast track that. And then does that need to go in front of town council for special projects? So is there a way to fast track it? I don't know. Okay. Okay. That's a question if we can find out. Yeah, that's going to be one of the questions we're looking at. Okay. So last year, it was kind of fun to sit around and go through this.
1:37:40 And I should have brought my book from last year, but it was interesting to kind of make your own little notes up here about, like I put here what they got for 2018, and then I'm going to put on here afterwards with the requesting for 2019, just for my own quick reference. And then from there on the scorecard, you know, I literally sat here where we sat around, both of us did, with our strategy in front of us, our guiding principles.
1:38:10 Our board objective, you know, measure you, what this is, what it's specifically for, and kind of sat around with this and said, okay, and went back and forth. Took the boxes. Yeah, so as you're going through that, like literally read, alignment with MLR strategic, you know, planning guide principles, and yes or no, and then I would go this, look at it, and kind of go back and forth, and then once you kind of got through one.
1:38:31 It became easier. Okay, good. It's not as scary as it looks. It actually kind of went, oh. They did a really good job of preparing and getting this put together. And then from there, what we would do is we'd come up with a number. Okay. So let's say at the end of the day, that number was 75, right? And the next person would have 73 and this and that. Then we'd base that number on a percentage.
1:38:56 And then once that member was taken on percentage, we took that percentage and we applied it towards the request. I see. Okay. Great. So if you're between each one, the average came out to be 75. Exactly. 75% of that. And then, you know, we looked at that and then there was, sometimes there was a few dollars left over and then we'll go back and see, do we think that...
1:39:20 We funded this properly, or is it something else we need to use there? It was a challenging exercise, but it actually was very conclusive. And then we will, at our next time we do this, you may come up with a 55, somebody else comes up with a 95, and we want to know what did we miss, or what are you missing?
1:39:46 And things. And that's kind of where we came back. And you go, okay, well, I scored a zero on this. It's kind of interesting because she might get something a zero and I might get something a two. It doesn't really make a difference. But consecutively is where if someone keeps scoring a two, a two, a two, a zero, then you're like, okay, that's where their percentage number went down. Things didn't waver too far off. But then when some people are asking for something that's way, when they're reaching for the skies, shall we say?
1:40:14 And then you get a percentage of that number. And then you have to go back and kind of skew it. Totally understand. Because somebody who maybe didn't ask for this guy, they had a little bit more reasonable number within their budget. Then we kind of moved it around in that direction. Good. Okay. That's great to know. Does that make sense? Absolutely. That's a really good process. And we tried to make it so that literally if somebody wanted to look at our scorecard.
1:40:37 Mine was a junk show, but you could look at it and actually come to a conclusion of how we came to that same process. Perfect. So I think last year we did that, we did our scoring process and we sat there and we debated and we came back, we had another meeting because maybe something didn't sit well with me or something didn't sit well with you and we kind of had these discussions about I just really don't feel like I can do that and why.
1:41:07 Before we made a recommendation. I think that what you did today was able...
1:41:14 That was actually meeting too after we did that. So we've gotten all those things out there. We'll be anticipating the responses back to that. But it's kind of, you know, those things you hold off on, what we're going to see. But the others, if you didn't have any questions, you can go ahead and start playing with them while it's fresh in your mind as far as how they meet all of the strategy goals there. And it didn't take as long as we thought it was going to.
1:41:44 It really didn't, but we had plenty of time to debate and to see what was going on there. And what I was really happy with the result was that we were able to find everybody got a level of funding, but they also, we were able to...
1:42:04 Show where we came to those and give them recommendations on how to improve their chances for increased funding and higher matches in the future. And so our applicants that came were very happy with the result. And they felt that it was open, fair, understood where their challenges were. Great. Good. And so in terms of timeline,
1:42:32 These go to the town in April. Is that what I read? That's in June. Oh, in June. Okay. So we have a little time. So the next time we need to, we need to actually put something on a calendar. The next time that we need to meet about this, what do we want to have accomplished? Well, first of all, when will we get responses to the information that we're requesting? We can set a deadline. Yeah. Okay. I'll send out the request first thing next week. Okay.
1:43:00 A week would be great. I think a week is reasonable. Do you all? Yes. So then that means if they could get back to us by March 5th. Do you want to know by Friday the 15th or by Monday the 18th? Friday. Okay, so Friday the 15th, 5 p.m. Okay. Kind of thing? You believe you're going to be able to get that request to those people today? Is it basically? I think Monday she said. I think I'll send it out. I can try it for today, but let's set Monday and they have to have a full week to respond by Friday.
1:43:29 Right, and I don't think what we're asking for is anything that's going to take anybody too long to reply to. And so if they get back to you by 5 p.m. on the 15th, then that will give us the following week, the week of the 18th, the 22nd, to kind of look at stuff, have our scoring done. Looking at coming back here in two weeks?
1:43:51 Yep. I'm just trying to see. Yes. I'm going to be in time. Are you going to be available? Do you think get together in two weeks on the 22nd? Is that too tight of a timeline for us to come back with our scores? If you get the responses. If we have our responses by the 15th. I think that's reasonable. I would rather do it as soon because while our questions are fresh and our notes here, it will make it easier like that. And so we need to see if this room is available. Is Friday the 22nd something that would work for you, Kim?
1:44:22 And that would work for you? Yeah, it works for me. In the morning? I'm always a morning person too. Get things off my plate. So the 22nd MLR allocation meeting. I know you're going to send something, but I still have to put it on my calendar. Part two. Part two. Part two. Okay. That meeting, I would assume, would take no more than two hours.
1:44:59 I would think it would actually probably only be an hour, but you never know. We could end up getting into a complete disagreement on something, so it's always good to give yourself that buffer. 9 to 11? Yeah. 9 to 11 is more than sufficient, I would think. Yeah, that's fine. Sounds good. By the 22nd. And at that meeting, we should be able to have our scores done, which means you have a recommendation for a dollar amount, which means that we would come to an agreement, hopefully, so that we could then in turn present it to the board in April.
1:45:27 And so if we can find a date that would work for the board in April so that we can get that process, that would be fantastic. And then at that same time, I guess I can ask, we can find out about if there's any way to fast track. Is that a question I should ask Rob Patterson on Tuesday? Yes. Okay. Fast track, special projects, past allocation. Okay. I'm going to have to write like a doctor.
1:46:12 And then from there, once we do that in April, we can all vote. It can get to town council by May or June. Typically June. Okay. So we have some room. In case there's anything. Okay. How do you guys want to go? But if we can, to me, if we can check that box and move on. Yep. We have until June. That's great for everybody's lives. Yeah, look at the agenda and see how we can.
1:46:43 Get in there because it may. Yeah, this is much more efficient because we have, believe it or not, there's fewer applicants. But I think we also need to, do we need to also have a session for, on the 22nd, would this be a time for any of our participants or our applicants to come and speak to us? Okay. This, that would be, okay. That'll be good, the 22nd, like this is your time to come and talk in front of the board if you have anything to say, anything you want to talk about, any questions.
1:47:12 Okay. We'll be on that 20, on that 20 second. Great. We kind of know where we're going to be. Excellent. Yeah. So we've taken care of our next meeting agenda. Mm-hmm. And now do you just entertain a motion to adjourn, which I'm making? Yeah. And then I will, she'll second that. Yeah. Okay. All right. Adjourn to our next meeting on the 22nd at 9 a.m. It's right here. Fantastic. Thank you, everybody. Thank you. Thank you. All right. You are efficient, ladies.
1:47:44 Thank you guys. Yeah, thank you very much. It's really helpful for my first time. I know, right? I'm jumping in. I've been on the applying in some of the times. Good, you feel... Should they go like that? Well, um...