Town Council
· recording 3 hr 27 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
443 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
8:11 We'll call this Wednesday, May 1st, Town Council meeting to order. We are going to go into closed session pursuant to code, government code section 54957.6.A. And with that, take it away. Okay, we will go ahead and call this Town Council meeting to order.
10:13 Wednesday, May 1st, back from closed session. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. All accounted for. Mr. Stapp, we please lead us in the pledge. Please join with me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
10:49 Thank you. And now we will go to public comment section. You have five minutes to speak on something that is not on the agenda. Thank you very much. Five whole minutes. Five whole minutes. Good evening, everybody. Shira Dubrovner. Tonight I'm representing the Mammoth Lakes Film Festival, which we are exactly three weeks away from tonight. And I just wanted to give you an update of where we're at.
11:18 So far, attending press will be LA Times, Variety, Hollywood Reporter, along with a few other industry...
11:27 We also have distribution companies, a company called A24. They were responsible for Moonlight, which was the Academy Award winning film from two years ago. We have another distribution company called The Orchard, which is now called 1091, which is another really hot independent distribution company.
11:48 We have filmmakers coming from Kazakhstan, India, Australia. We have them coming from all around the world. We have over 100 filmmakers already telling us they're coming, and we'll probably be getting another 20 to 30 more coming. And we have about 70 passes left, so if you want to buy your passes, you should get them now.
12:11 And we're looking forward to a very successful year and what it does for the community. We're even trying to expand to do some screenings at the Mona Lake Visitor Center and just really grow the festival so it has the reputation that it deserves. And we are already getting that reputation from top filmmakers. Some of the films I asked how that...
12:36 The films that we got this year are very high level films. They're premiering at much bigger festivals like Tribeca or Sundance and they're now starting to submit to us because they want to be part of...
12:48 The Mammoth Lakes Film Festival, they want that to be part of their festival circuit. And so I've been asking them how they've heard about it. And a lot of them are telling us that much bigger directors that are pretty up there have been telling them to submit to us. So that's kind of exciting news. So hopefully I'll see all of you there, except for maybe Bill, because I know Bill doesn't like that kind of stuff.
13:11 But I want to thank you for all your support, and clearly we'll be sending out about the volunteers in the next 48 hours. Ask about that. Okay, great. So thank you again for all your support. I really appreciate it, and it's going to be a stellar year, so thank you. Okay, thank you. Those who just came in, we're in public comment. Anything not on the agenda tonight? Hello. Brandon Brocia, business owner in town and community member.
13:40 I have a big topic I want to bring up. I am very passionate about being green in Mammoth. I think it's a great cause to get behind for anyone and everyone in this community, including you as a very powerful board in our community. My topic to bring up today is a suggestion of a ban on single-use plastic bottles in Mammoth.
14:10 We were behind the plastic bag ban as it got rolled out. We really can't effectively do anything about it now that it's at the state level. But there are other communities in our state that have gotten ahead of it, and San Francisco is one of them. They have successfully banned these single-use plastic bottles and implemented it.
14:38 If it were to go to the state level, you know, it gets lobbied by the plastic bottle manufacturers, which is a billion dollar industry in the state of California, and it gets diluted. If we can get ahead of this and think of this as a very positive thing for us, I have some really scary stats to just share with you on plastic bottle use just in our community. And this is all based on just the
15:08 Amount of plastic bottles that are purchased by one of our retailers. One, okay? Seven pallets a week are purchased by one of our retailers. That is 12,096 bottles a week. One retailer. On an average, 10% of those nationwide are recycled.
15:41 15% are burned. We don't do that up here. That means 90% of those will go into our dump. On an annual basis, that puts right north of half a million bottles going to the dump a year. One retailer. If we don't take proactive steps now to get ahead of this, we don't need to beat a dead horse. We know what's happening at the dump. We know what's happening with recycling around the world right now. It's all going down.
16:16 We can't afford to sit back and wait for someone to figure this out. I think as a community, we can do this. We have great examples of it happening within our state right now. I just want to emphasize that it doesn't take into effect any other bottles sold anywhere else in town. It doesn't take into effect any other bottles brought in from outside of town. So when you count all that in, which I can't give you numbers on,
16:49 We could be north of like a million bottles very quickly, okay? I think it's a crisis, personally. There's a great opportunity here. There's town partnerships. The Rotary has already committed water filling stations around our entire community. Patagonia, Clean Canteen, the great outreach from corporations within our country that want to put green.
17:19 Policies in place would get behind this and want to sponsor these, these programs. Imagine just for a second what this would look like to our community. What our kids, our family members, our community members would see us doing as a community. Imagine what our visitors would take away as a snapshot of Mammoth. Mammoth Lakes, they do it green up there. Remember when we were in Mammoth, they were just doing it green.
17:49 You couldn't even buy the small bottles. I'm not saying we're banning people getting big jugs of water to go camping. I'm not saying that. I'm saying the little single-use plastic bottles just gone, gone, gone. I think we have an opportunity to be the innovators at this moment in the resort communities of California, not the imitators. I think we can lead this push and not wait for others to figure out and follow them. And I think it's a powerful message.
18:20 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, Town Council, Madam Chair, Councilmembers, Matt McLean, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. I only have about an hour. I had to break myself out of jail over at the hospital, and I promised my doctor I'd be back at 7 o'clock. But I wanted to thank you in advance for your support for our allocations.
18:57 I'm told I wasn't here, unfortunately, to kind of shepherd it through, but I'm told it was another year of successful process. And I did want to acknowledge the work by our committee members, Catherine Taft, Rhonda Dugan, and Heather Schaubmeyer, who did a fantastic job. Also, David Page, our president, our board president. And then,
19:26 I also want to acknowledge Kim Anaclario, who had this kind of just dropped in her lap, you know, first time through and did an amazing job, as well as Emily over at the chamber, who kind of came in and she was really experienced and mentored everybody through. So I wanted to publicly thank them. And again, thank you guys for my support. I haven't been around. It's meant a lot. Several of you reached out to me while I was gone, and it meant a lot.
19:54 The other thing I wanted to do, I know it's on Consent Agenda 14, I believe, and I won't be here for that, I've got to go back, but I did want to encourage you to please support the cost share agreement between the Town Mammoth Lakes and the Forest Service. It's really going to benefit the area up in the Lakes Basin, help us address some of the needs such as parking, restrooms, signage, things that really are critical for the guest experience. This is going to be, you know,
20:23 Just another step in what we hope will be a successful long-term partnership with the Forest Service in helping our guests experience and expand sustainable recreation in the eastern Sierra. I think you got a round of applause at the last meeting. I saw that. Yeah, I was very happy. I saw that on the internet. So thank you very much. I appreciate that. Thank you very much.
21:01 I just wanted to say thank you. We're out there cleaning it up, and so we see the evidence, and together we can do something amazing. So I think that it's a good time to start galvanizing these sort of efforts and clean this place up so we can be really proud. Thank you. Anybody else wishing to speak in public comment? Then we will go ahead and we will go to council member reports. John, I'll go ahead and start with you, please.
21:33 Okay, thank you, Madam Mayor. I've got a couple things. First thing is I've been wrestling with the local malady, and so I've missed a couple meetings. I apologize for that. I know how important it is for all of us to be attending these meetings and to share the information that we were at, so I apologize for that.
21:50 Hopefully I'm on the mend here. April 19th, I attended in Sacramento. I spoke to the Civic Spark Fellows in Sacramento about the urban-rural divide in the state of California. It's a very interesting discussion to have with those folks. On April 23rd, Madam Mayor, you and I attended the collaborative planning team, and I'm thinking there's some staff here. There were some questions that came up about... Reporting out on the...
22:15 Right, on the Res Meadow Road and questions about county jurisdictions and stuff like that, I think it would be of interest of all the council to hear some discussion, get some advice from staff on that. Then on April 24th, I attended a meeting with the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partners. This was the staff of the Indian National Forest, Hubbell-Tarabi National Forest, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, elected officials from Mono County and staff, Sierra Nevada Conservancy staff. We reviewed the recently awarded SNC grant.
22:43 And just kind of walked through what the deliverables are and trying to get people understanding what's in that. It was sort of an information sharing meeting, but it was good. April 25th, I attended the Mammoth Lakes Trails Committee meeting. And this is, I was speaking in public comment about an effort that Matt and I kind of got started last year on the e-bike program. As you all know, Mammoth Not Ski Areas has a sort of, I want to say it's not a special dispensation from the Forest Service, but e-bikes are allowed up in,
23:13 In the ski area. Certain types. They're allowed up in the ski area. E-bikes are not allowed at this point on Forest Service system trails. They're allowed on our MUPS. This is part of a national conversation. And People for Bikes, which sounds like a nice nonprofit, is actually like a lobbying organization for a multi-hundred million dollar e-bike industry, as is Bosch Motors. I had some conversations with a council member to say, this is great. We're going to need some help.
23:40 To mitigate the effects of where all these e-bikes will be going around town. And Matt was working on that. Matt was out for a little bit. I've kind of picked that up. I've been in touch with the ski area and with people for bikes and others. And I think it's important that we continue with this effort because we're going to have to deal with the...
23:58 The conflicts out on the ground where the public is confused. Why can't I ride an e-bike up on the mountain? Why can't I ride on the Mammoth Rock Trail? And so I'm following up with that, but I advise the Trails Committee that these efforts were in place and it's something that's important to follow up on. This is a huge national conversation going on around this stuff, and we're on the cutting edge of that as we're on the cutting edge of many things.
24:22 On April 29th, I met with Dan, and I sent an email to a variety of folks, E.L. Smugin and Tony Calisardo, their lawyer and our lawyer. This is following up on that trails drainage issue. And we identified, Dan and I identified, based on conversations with staff, of one, two, three, four, five very specific topics that staff needs to sit down with representatives and the homeowners.
24:48 And get real focused on this issue. There's a lot of moving parts to this, but I think we're in a good position to do this. I just wanted to make you guys aware that it's moving forward and things are happening. But Dan needs to pull together a meeting with these people. Good agendized, focused meeting and start checking these boxes off. And hopefully that will happen in the near future. Finally, I wanted to speak a little bit about...
25:11 Sustainable Recreation and Tourism. There's going to be a meeting later this week, I think that Dan's pulling together with representatives of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. As you guys all remember, back in the fall, we had a joint workshop with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and I was appointed to be some kind of a representative or something having to do with the...
25:29 Destination Management Plan Development. That was a topic we all talked about. And I had a couple of meetings with John Urdi. I was on a conference call with some folks that had done a similar effort over in San Luis Obispo County, which is a large county with 11 jurisdictions in it. And I engaged with that. I've thought about it. I've really focused on it. And I just wanted to share with you guys that based on my research, I'm not going to be part of this meeting on Friday, that I don't think that that's the way we should go.
25:58 The research that I've done indicates that these destination management plans tend to consolidate power in the marketing side of the equation. And it's very good at saying, well, someone else has got to do this, this, this, this, and this. So we do not get to a systemic, systematic approach to dealing with sustainability.
26:16 In destinations. And there's a number of articles, there's all kinds of stuff on the internet and articles being published. Moab is drowning in tourists and Utah is making Grant County spend millions a year more to invite more people. In Bend, Oregon, Visit Bend makes permanent strategy shift.
26:32 British Columbia Destination BC unveils first draft of 10-year Sea to Sky Tourism Plan. Sweeping document urges sustainable approach to growth management. Sedona, Arizona, Sedona City Council approved sustainable tourism plan from a group called Sustainable Brands, inspiring travelers to help preserve beloved destinations while we still can. This is the vernacular that's going on out there, and I think we need to be in that.
26:58 In that space and working in that environment. And I'm hoping that I'm confident Dan will give us all an opportunity for the Council to weigh in from a policy level to provide direction to Mammoth Lakes Tourism, to Mammoth Lakes Recreation. This is really what Mammoth Lakes Recreation was established to do, along with the Forest Service and the Town. So we really get to a good, sustainable focus on our destination for many years to come. And that's it. Thank you very much. Thank you.
27:27 What do you have for us, Mr. Bill? I have met with many staff members and stuff, but there's nothing reportable there. The only thing of note that I've done is participated wholly in Fishmas, and what an incredible weather-wise weekend it was. Fishing? Eh, not so much. But the weather was probably the best I have seen in my 61 years of being here. It was amazing.
27:55 And just to follow up on that, you were at Crowley? I was at Crowley, yes. So if I could hear an update on just the amount of people, the overall, besides the weather? I will tell you that if we compare it to any year in the 80s or early 90s, there was about 25% of the people that used to go. The number of campers along the shore is probably...
28:22 Half to two-thirds of what it was just 15 or 20 years ago. And personally, I put the blame for that on the fact that the fishing levels have decreased, not increased, gotten better. A friend of mine said it, and I don't say it because I love just to go fishing. But most of our guests don't come to Mammoth to fish. They come to Mammoth to catch. And if they don't, we lose them as customers.
28:53 And while a lot of the people that go to Crowley certainly camp down there, the vast majority stay in motels and condos and you see boats all over town. So it is a concern that perhaps down the road we need to delve into. But it was epic. Yes, I did catch fish on every boatload I took out, but it wasn't what it should have been.
29:16 And it just, I had a smile for four days I was at the lake. I can't say anything else. It was wonderful. Yeah. Thank you for going down there. Linda. I was out of town most of that time. I was back from the east in Pennsylvania, enjoying weather, not always pleasant. And I'm back, and that's all I have to report.
29:46 Este is still working on the Woodman turnaround. I mean, it seems to be an ongoing issue, and the number of riders that are actually out there and trying to pick up the kids that do utilize that service. Mammoth Lake Housing is still working on its strategic plan. I've been lobbied several times on the snow removal of our trails, especially out to Shady Rest.
30:14 You know, we've cleared an awful lot of them, but the crew, and I do defend the crew, they've done a good job, but they're also limited as to where they can be at one time. They're working on Main Street, trying to get the sidewalks in, and so, I mean, you know, the staff is stretched at this particular point in time. So some of the trails are going to just take a little bit longer before we get to them. I was lobbying on the Green New Deal, or the Green Re-Deal.
30:44 By several different constituents. And I think it's going to be a step-by-step process. Brandon, I think like getting rid of plastic bags, getting rid of, you know, the water bottles and those things is something that we've got to focus on. I absolutely agree with you. Mammoth Lake Tourism and the idea of a destination and sustainability was brought up again.
31:11 Thank you. Thank you.
31:42 I'd like to give a shout out to all the people who were at the community center. I'm giving it the nice little, I'm looking around to see if I see anybody. We had some good volunteers out there helping to repaint and do some other functions out there. There was a CPT, that's a collaborative planning team meeting that was on April 23rd. That is a meeting that I really encourage people to go. There are quarterly meetings.
32:11 We went six months without one because the last one was during the government shutdown, probably three-fourths of it, of the group that meet, they are affected by that. It's everything from town, county, Forest Service, all different federal lands, Caltrans, you can get a really good idea of what's going on.
32:38 Some highlights from that. There's still a pretty big push for on 395, the wildlife crossing the road. Depending on which way they go, it could be a shorter area or a larger area, but that's going to be a many, many, many tens of millions of dollar project. That's still in the works. There is an issue.
33:06 And I'm just going to see if we can put this on a future agenda to kind of give everyone a good update with what's going on the Reds Meadow Road. I realize I've been to probably more meetings. And the thing that came up in the CPT meeting is that Madera County is not really that into changing the boundary line.
33:35 The Red's Meadow Road, most of that is in Madera County. The town of Mammoth Lakes is the one that will be in charge of that road when it is built. We have a flap grant for it. I'm not going to sit here and bore everybody with all the details on the Red's Meadow Road, but right now Mono County is in talks, but it doesn't look that much.
34:01 Madeira, the officials are six hours away. They don't really understand what we're talking about with the whole Red's Meadow concept. And I'm not sure how much pool we would have as a town, even though that's going to be our road. Just to let you know, the project is 70%.
34:22 Not the physical part, but as far as the planning through the federal highways, it's 70% done. So these are some things that need to be addressed probably sooner rather than later. So I just think maybe a quick update on that Reds Road so everybody can get caught up on some of the issues that have to do with what will the towns...
34:47 How we're going to fit the town's responsibility with if it does stay Madera County, if they don't relinquish that land to Mono County. And then that's all. Let's see. Here's another thing. There are kiosks along 395.
35:06 And if anybody has been checking those out, they are getting slowly but surely replaced. And so if you pull off to one of those things, you may see now that they have some better graphics and they're trying to upgrade some of the other areas on the, there's 23 sites along 395. And that's all I have to report out. Are there any additions to the agenda?
35:31 None from staff members. Okay. And with that, we will go to reports from commissions and departments. Good evening. I'm Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. Just a quick update that the housing and safety element, the drafts, are available for public review. You received a presentation at your last meeting, a pretty thorough presentation on them both, but just a note for the public. They are available for public review, and the review period closes on May 10th.
35:57 We will have a Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting next Wednesday, May 8th, here in Sweet Z at 2 o'clock to take any comments that people have. People can provide comments via email, a letter, or they can just come to the Planning Commission and provide their comments verbally, and we'll take notes and respond to all those comments.
36:15 During this comment period, we're really just kind of listening, taking comments, and then when we come back for the public hearing process, we will have all the comments that were submitted along with written responses to every comment that was submitted as part of this project. So I'm happy to answer any questions. Just real quick, there's a rescheduling for the Yotel. Can you speak to that a little bit? Yeah, so due to some...
36:39 Conflicts with various Planning and Economic Development Commissioners. We had to reschedule the Yotel public hearing. So that's going to be Wednesday, May 15th at 9 a.m. here in Suite Z. So it will be just a single item. It will be the Yotel public hearing because we didn't have a quorum for that particular project at next Wednesday's meeting. Good. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Evening, Madam Mayor, Council, staff, members of the public, just a quick update from Parks and Rec.
37:14 Yes, do want to thank all our community for coming out and helping us with our community centre painting party. I'm calling it a party, not a project, because we want to celebrate all the great work that everybody's doing at the community centre. We hope to wrap up tomorrow, if not Friday, at the latest. It's going very well. We've had so far about 60 hours of volunteer support, so really appreciate it. Get some great photos, a lot of good before and aft.
37:40 Captures of our wonderful community and staff helping us out. Also want to kind of recognise Lauren Plum for being a phenomenal project manager through this whole deal. Apparently she's never really painted much before, so I was getting a crash course in painting. And then to Sierra Schultz from our engineering team as well, supporting that effort. Once we wrap up the painting project, the flooring team will come back in May 13, put in a new floor, and then we'll kind of wrap it up with some appliances, and we hope to reopen the community centre beginning of June.
38:09 And then we'll be re-evaluating the exterior portion of that project, see how we can get the siding fixed, replaced, painting, the stairs, and some other areas of lighting in the signage. So we'll kind of hopefully kind of pull that package together and get that done this summer. Just a quick summer camp update again. You know, we started April 1. We're still working really hard on getting a lot of our kids off the wait list and into the camps. We were able to open up 40 spots to the Waverave skate camps, which is terrific.
38:39 Steve Clawson came back in with our program, so we're excited about that. We've also added additional youth spots, youth theatre camp spots as well. I think we talked about that as well and adding camp spots to Adventure Wilderness and the skate camps like we talked about. So we've so far added, I believe, about 70 plus spots of the 200 wait list. So we're kind of working our way through that list. Little Sluggers is underway, volleyball playoffs tonight.
39:05 We talked about fish stocking really quickly. That program begins just before Memorial weekend. That program is back up to $100,000 level, which is great. We dipped down about just under $90,000 the last couple of years. So we're up to kind of our full contingent of 18,000 pounds of fish. So we hope that'll make a good difference. Next scheduled meeting of our commission is May 7th. That's coming up next Tuesday.
39:32 That'll be the ice rink season presentation, Whitmore Pool opening. That's scheduled for our lap swim on Monday, which will be great. A lot of excited people seeing water in the pool, staying in the pool, so we're fingers crossed. We'll also update the commission on the budget process, the recreation, community recreation centre, and then we have an update on our drone ordinance from our Forest Service partners, so we'll be coming back with that as well.
39:56 And they're just really quickly on the parks. You know, we're talking about trails, talking about parks. Staff are, we're trying to get as many resources to our parks as we can. A lot of our trails, we're hiring as quickly as we can. You know, we had a great support today with Joel and his inmate crew, so they really made a difference. If you've been under the 203 tunnel, they got that cleared today with chainsaws. So that's kind of what we're dealing with here on May 1st. Whitmore's fully open.
40:22 Community Centre tennis courts are still buried in snow, so we'll still get to that. Shady Rest Park, we opened up one field today. I do also want to thank Joel and his crew for spending a lot of time and hours out there picking up dog waste. Now that's a real problem at Shady Rest Park. We're really disappointed. It just seems like there's so much disregard for our community and our kids and using that park. It's not a dog park, it's a kid's park. So we really want to kind of look at addressing that in the future, so we've got some plans this year.
40:51 Mammoth Creek Park Restrooms, Charleston Park Restroom open. We're getting to the playground as quick as we can. So we're doing what we can when we can with the staff that we can at this time to get all our parks and facilities open. And Stu, the cleaning day has been moved to the 8th of June, is that right? Yes. So save the date. I just pushed that out today. I left a lot of copies in the back. So we've got the Facebook post. We've got media releases. So it's Saturday, June 8th. We hope that's going to be enough time to get the snow to melt.
41:19 So again, really looking for a lot of community support. The same town cleanup day station, Sierra Valley Sites, which is 407 Manzanita, will be up at the community center parking lot and then the transfer station as well. So bags will be available, we believe, on May 20 is what I've put here. So everybody can come and get their bags and start cleaning up. And hopefully we have a lot of time, some beautiful weather, to prepare and clean up before that day. And then you can get to that day and just drop all your waste at those stations. Try not to do it the day of.
41:47 So thank you for that. Stuart, going back to the, I guess it was Shady Rest Park that you're referring to with the dog waste. What meeting, is there going to be a conversation about that? Because some of the things that I've heard and read, it's reached like critical mass with that. And I'd like to know, and probably any dog lovers or people that walk their dogs out there would like to know.
42:17 When's a chance to hear some of the, hopefully some plans to help rectify that situation? We'll update our commission on Tuesday, just with kind of an update on our parks. It's certainly one of those items we'll talk about. We haven't scheduled anything as yet. We have some projects that are ongoing this summer at the park. You know, we've got some additional signage. We've got some fencing going up. You know, we'll move the poo ferry stations so they're more visible for people. It's just wintertime, you know, is kind of that.
42:45 Concern. We just don't have the oversight, the enforcement at this time of what we really need at that park. In the summertime, we have staff there. People can get into that park, and it's a lot more visible. Whether we put after webcam out there or something, I don't know, but it's just disappointing. Well, yeah, I think I was going more towards where people can take personal responsibility rather than have somebody else clean up. So there's no formal...
43:12 Discussion that's going to go on. It's just something you guys are still going to have to deal with. Okay. Well, I think that there probably will be some formal discussion. The two problem areas are our two main winter staging areas that are within the town. There was actually more trash and poop picked up at the tape than there was at Chady. So I'm sure that the Mammoth Trails group out of MLR will be involved in working on solutions for those trailheads.
43:42 As will Public Works and Park Department in town. So I'm sure there will be some conversation about how to work the problem out. But, you know, in the wintertime, especially as much snow as we had this year, you don't see it. But when the snow melts, you get the layers of excrement that have happened in every different storm and they become one very large pile. It's a problem we've had at Shady for years.
44:10 I think just to keep in mind the magic secret of the poo fairy, there is no poo fairy. Right. Clean up your waste. But we have learned lessons over the years on how to make it better. Yeah, we have. And I think in the trails program has established where good public works. There is a poo fairy program. It's sort of a pilot, but it's ripe for expansion. And I think that's something we will need to talk about. We agree. Yeah. Thank you. Okay. Thank you.
44:42 Good evening, Haislip Hayes, Engineering Manager, just a couple updates. Last week, our contractor began work on the south main retaining wall. Over the last week, they've managed to do all the earthwork, get it formed, and they poured concrete today. They'll strip forms, and then we'll have to let that cure for about a week before we get back to work on it, so the contractor will be moving.
45:03 Up the street to the area between Mountain and Sierra and beginning to work on the retaining walls there and then we'll start to slowly work its way back south. We'll provide updates to council at every meeting moving forward on the progress on the construction projects that we have this summer. We're also continuing to assess the lakes basin. Turns out there's still a lot of snow up there so we do not yet have a date as to when we will begin plowing the roads and getting that open to the public.
45:31 I do want to address one point on the Reds Meadow Road project. I'm happy to provide an update. Not a lot of progress has happened since we've been before Council, just a number of partner meetings about scheduling and programming as we get closer to actually building the road. But the agreements and the grants were crafted in such a way that whether Mono County
45:54 Or Madeira County has ownership of the land around there. It doesn't matter to the town. The agreements are with the U.S. Forest Service and federal highways, and we'll be able to build the project regardless of who retains the land around it. So I just want to let you know that it's all been built into the existing agreements. No matter what happens, we'll be in a position to move forward with that construction project. Thank you. Sorry, a couple questions. So the sidewalk on the south side of Main Street,
46:24 The goal just for the public's edification is to have a significant amount of construction complete by 4th of July weekend. And then if you could explain what the public should expect on the south side of Main Street for 4th of July for the parade and that kind of stuff.
46:37 Yeah, the contractor is going to work as diligently as possible to get as much work done before 4th of July as possible. We don't believe we'll have it substantially complete before the 4th of July. We'll get as much work done as possible. If we have gaps, we plan to fence it off, make it safe.
46:56 And then we've had a couple conversations with our partners in the parade about alternative ways that we can stage the public, align some of the parade routes to make sure that, you know, we're providing a great experience for our guests and visitors and also a safe one because you will be near potentially a construction site. There will be no construction during Fourth of July. That is prohibited in the contract. And the contractor is dedicated to working with the town to making the event great and working with the business community to make sure that.
47:24 The businesses are open during the event. Okay, good. Thank you. Good evening, Councilmembers. Joel Ratney, Trails Coordinator. Just wanted to touch on a couple of things that Stu was informing you about. I am mobilizing fire crews and some staff to help out with getting some pathway sections cleared. One example is, so some of the snow banks are really hard as a rock mixed in with...
47:56 You know, cinders and whatever else is in the snow. So it's really hard for anybody to clear it, even with shovels. And so today we cleared a section at the 203 tunnel with chainsaws and we're just trying to make it so that there's blockages for Stu and his team that we can get in there and clear it. Another example would be a couple of trees down. We can take care of those for him so he can continue clearing the pathways. We're trying to work together on these sort of things. And then also on the pickup,
48:26 It's encouraging to me having initiated a bit of an effort this season because it was hard to look at this spring. We've had a long winter, layers of waste around on the ground, different types of waste. And so we chose to act in different ways. And I can see different layers of things coming together to really address these problems. You talked about one way to address some of these problems. There's going to be other ways that we all come together.
48:52 And one really interesting thing, it's a cultural thing that came out of Scandinavia, it's called plogging, pick up litter jogging is the thing. I just started doing that with my kids and then it catches on, my neighbors are out there doing it and then I go to Mammoth Creek Park and there's a couple other people doing it. I'm just going to take all of us and I don't think it's acceptable to have that much waste on the ground in our community anymore so I would just say never again. We're not going to let it happen again.
49:17 And it just takes a little bit. It doesn't, it's not hard. I spend 30 minutes with my kids going from Snow Creek down to Mammoth Creek Park, and it's clean and half an hour walking. And we have fun along the way, making jokes. It's one of the, some of the most fun we've had. Picking up dog waste at Shady Rest with my friend Andrew. I had the best afternoon I've had all season.
49:41 I don't know why or how, but it was really fun. And so I just am encouraged by this, and I want to sort of spread the love on let's clean this place up. We could easily do this. It's so achievable. Joel, thank you. Because, you know, I do get lobbied, why are we getting these trails done? So the fact that they are ice and everything is important to let the community know that. I mean, you have to chip it away to get rid of some of those. Yeah, we're cutting bricks of...
50:11 Yeah. Stuff with chainsaws to clear that. Yeah. So, you know, it's going to be a challenge. Thank you for the job you're doing. Yeah, of course. Thank you. Is it big enough? Okay, good evening, everyone. Again, Cassandra Mance, Human Resources Manager. As many of you know, on April 24th, town employees showed support for sexual assault awareness and supported the Denim Day campaign. Denim Day is championed by a Los Angeles-based organization called Peace Over Violence.
50:51 The campaign began after a ruling by the Italian Supreme Court where a rape conviction was overturned because the justices felt that since the victim was wearing tight jeans, she must have helped the person who raped her remove them, therefore implying consent.
51:05 Wearing denim on Denim Day is considered a visible means of protest against the misconceptions that surround sexual violence, and year after year, town employees and elected officials have joined the millions of people around the world who support this cause. So thank you to everyone who participated. Special mention to Grady, who was out of town and did not want to be left out of the Denim Day photo. I love the barefoot look, too. Yeah, up there. I sat on the dials. Thank you.
51:37 So, yeah, Cassie, did you want to stay up here for this next portion? Because that'll be a nice, we're going to just let you go ahead and start us off on item two, which is a proclamation for public service recognition week. Okay, what would you like me to do? Oh, were you not told about this?
52:05 If I can jump in, if I can jump in, Madam Mayor, I'll have Cassie accept the proclamation on behalf of our employees, our HR department there, but each year we take a look at public service recognition for the, you know, the number of men and women that service our community, both through the town, the county, you know, fire department, the water district, the schools, et cetera, just a number of public officials out there, and as just kind of seen this evening, we make an impact on our community in a number of different ways.
52:34 Some of that very visible, some of it not. Whether we're out picking up trash and dog poo or building sidewalks or taking care of somebody in the office who has a need or, you know, helping the council in terms of working through policy decisions and, you know, dealing with a large variety of issues. And to be able to honor, I think, is important to do that. We do a lot of different public service for various reasons. It's, for the vast majority of us, at least myself, I know others in our organization, it's more than a job.
53:02 It's something we do because we enjoy it. I'd like to make a difference. For me, getting into local politics, if you will, never thought it'd be that political, the admin side, to actually make a difference in local communities. You can really make a difference there, whether it's patching potholes or, you know, streets or sidewalks or playgrounds, just where you make a difference in people's lives day to day. So it's a really powerful thing, and our public employees, I'm proud of all of our employees here at the town. They do a great job. They step up in a number of different areas.
53:32 I.e. painting a community center or, you know, day-to-day operations here, getting bills paid and those types of things. So my hat's off to our employees and for this next week we'll do a number of different things to recognize and for the work they do. Not always a welcome to some cases. We do some negative interactions, be that code enforcement or our chiefs back there. Now and again, you know, some of the police activities and stuff, but keeping the community safe is a high priority, but yet
54:01 Challenging at times. So hats off to our employees and just a heartfelt congratulations and thank you for the work of our public employees, not just for the town but in the area. But obviously here this evening I would say thank you to our employees of the town of Mammoth Lakes. They do a heck of a job for us. So if you want to look at the proclamation, Cassie can accept that on behalf of our employees. So should I go ahead and get a motion before I read a portion of this? Okay, I'll entertain a motion.
54:28 I would make a motion to approve the Proclamation for Public Service Recognition Week. I'll second that. Roll call, please. Council Member Stassio? Yes. Council Member Stassio? Yes. Council Member Stassio? Yes. Council Member Stassio? Yes. Council Member Stassio? Yep. Yes. Item passes 5-0. The Proclamation does state whereas public employees take not only jobs.
54:49 But oaths. And whereas many public servants, including military personnel, police officers, firefighters, border patrol officers, embassy employees, health care professionals, and other risk their lives.
55:01 Each day in service to the people of the United States and around the world and whereas without these public servants at every level continuity would be impossible in a democracy that regularly changes its leaders and elected officials and whereas local town staff provide services to this community including parks and road maintenance, public safety, planning and permitting, community recreation programs and many other services that contribute to our vibrant community.
55:30 And therefore, the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes does hereby proclaim to all citizens that May 5th through 11th, 2019 is Public Service Recognition Week. All citizens are encouraged to recognize the accomplishments and contributions of government employees and volunteers at all levels, federal, state, county, and town. And I'm going to go ahead and do you guys need a picture of everybody since?
56:00 We're also public service. Yeah, here, I'm going to go ahead and get everybody. Can we have our posters? Oh, well, let's sit down separately. I'm going to go ahead and do that. Come on, everyone's a public service except me, Brandon, and Teresa. You guys all should go up there. You know, it's there. Brandon says he'll take the photo. One guy's in the back.
56:36 Everyone at each other's back. Alright. One, two, three. Thank you guys.
57:10 You know what, I'll do mine once I think of the perfect thing to write. Yeah, I'll turn in my homework later. Okay, thank you very much. Now we are to item three, quarterly TOT enforcement update, third quarter, fiscal year, 2018-19. Rob, are you ready? Okay, sorry about that.
57:41 Yeah, okay. Well, okay. Sorry about that. I would have talked more slowly. So much excitement. Yeah. Okay, thank you. So as you know, we do come and talk to Council on a quarterly basis just to update with the activities that we are doing with our focus on enforcement. We have, as you know, invested quite a bit of time and energy in our host compliance platform.
58:32 Which does a lot of analysis and work for us. And part of this presentation of the quarterly updates is also letting the community know the level of activity that we are engaged in and what we're doing on a regular basis. The team works very hard with the enforcement activities. And I think it shows not only in the increased TOT, we take some credit for that. Hopefully MLT is not listening.
59:00 But we think that by getting people to who can legally remit on board with doing so is definitely a benefit for the town. The other thing we're doing or we're seeing is the more the effort is with host compliance, the accuracy and the swiftness by which it identifies new businesses that are out there, we have we're catching people very early. They'll sometimes within the first week of the ownership of their condo or the first week of putting
59:29 Activity out online, which I think is great from a revenue perspective. This is not supposed to be a revenue generating device. It's really supposed to be a leveling the playing field component. So revenues will go down as we have lower and smaller enforcement cases, but the activities we think are doing the appropriate thing. At our last presentation, Council asked us to give sort of a baseline of what it looks like.
59:56 If we're looking at a quarter, what does that look like as far as an overall year? So we did give you the year component, and this is a standard format we look at. So on the left-hand side, it's third quarter, which would be January through March of 2019. We have our two different enforcement case types, which would be zoning or revenue. In this particular time period, we opened 23 cases, which is pretty strong. We had 62 cases total year-to-date.
1:00:25 So as we've ramped up the processes, we're again moving fairly quickly. Seven of those zoning, 16 of them revenue. During that process, we do issue citations primarily to gain attention and at some point significantly gain attention if we're not getting anybody to respond to it. So there's a number of citations issued. Just for clarification purposes, we issue one citation for $500. We wait 15 days, giving them an opportunity to respond and come in.
1:00:54 Then we perform an assessment and issue a secondary $1,000 citation, wait a couple of days for them to receive both of those. And then after that point, we start issuing $1,000 a day citations. So it's kind of a ramping up process, if you will. So during that process, we've issued 36 citations. Six assessments were issued and 11 notices of determination. An assessment is when we don't have all the information necessary to determine the amount of rental activity.
1:01:24 And so we'll have to use our, it's a calculation that we use based upon rental activities of a normal business in town, and that's what we use for assessing the expected level of activity of anybody that we've identified. It would be a nightly rate against the occupancies of a business in town. And the notice of determination, though, is one where we do actually have their actual data, and we're saying here's what we're believing to be your taxes,
1:01:55 T-bid, penalties, entries, enforcement charges. And so those we had 11 during the process. And during that violations, we collected a total of $50,000 for the quarter. And you can see the breakdown from that. Any questions? We do like to give a snapshot of the, you know, we know that the advertisements and short-term rental availability is volatile within the town.
1:02:23 So we just give you the snapshots, a consistent look, saying that we have 3,160 units being advertised right now, and we had 29 added in the last month. Our goal was to have initially 95% of identification of short-term rentals, and right now we're at 97.1, so that's pretty strong. Even in host compliance's world, that's something they celebrate for us. So that's a pretty high number.
1:02:50 Talking about the progress updates, we did have a significant case, which it started clear back in September 25th of 2016. This was a very large case. It was a zoning violation. A nice house up by the Canyon Lodge was continuing to rent, and our enforcement efforts were a cost of doing business for them. We learned a lot from this particular one, some things to do, some things not to do.
1:03:18 But in this particular case, it came before Council. There was a total owed of $21,719. We allowed them to pay, once the determination was made, that they were going to owe the full amount. The taxes and T-bid, which is something I learned as a mistake, you don't do that initially. You're paying off the penalties and interest rather than the taxes because then interest does not continue to accrue.
1:03:45 I was doing a favor and got burned by it because they decided not to pay. We ended up running a lien out there on that and we collected the lien this month when they sold the property. So it was a little bit of a success on a long-term process. Talking a little bit about the rental data landscape, you talked about in 2019 we renewed 3,270 short-term rental businesses.
1:04:12 businesses, not businesses themselves, but units themselves that were legal rentals. We have 5,849 short-term rental listings out there active in April, 13 long-term listings, which is 31 days or more. We've had 90 new business tax certificates applied for in the third quarter, and 43 of those were for short-term rentals.
1:04:41 In seven of the last 12 months, we're record-breaking TOT revenues. And to wrap up, we just have a little bit about our current goals and things that we're working towards. And again, this is also a consistent look. Our online search engine host compliance, we're working on a weekly basis. Team has assignments on a daily basis, actually, to review that platform and look for new rental activities, and that's why they're getting on them so quickly.
1:05:09 And I think that's working pretty good. We're constantly changing our effective measurements. So before I said we had 95% identification was our target. But now it's really the time in which we identify them, how quickly we're rolling through those. And the other thing I'm seeing, we have some education opportunities, not only within
1:05:33 How we educate our businesses who are conducting short-term rentals in the laws of the town, but also just the community itself in the activities that we're out there. I've had conversations with folks and pretty well-versed folks in the town who believe that this was only a way of identifying the condo units. It wasn't something that was going to do houses or other things.
1:05:55 I think there's still an opportunity for education about the work that we're doing in enforcement and how that process is going. But for this one, we want to promote different streams of understanding. So we talked about doing webinars, things that people could go in and click on and watch a video that my team puts together that talks about how to do things right. We think that's important for people. If we can help them understand, here's the best practices that successful transient occupancy
1:06:24 businesses use, then we would minimize the impacts of, you know, doing things incorrectly and the cost it has on those people. Taxable items list, where we're doing some updates on that, just for clarity purposes. Town E News, again, just getting our word out and more sort of opportunity to celebrate the things that are going on. We are doing a letter to new property owners who purchased their properties in 18 and 19 that basically just talks about
1:06:52 How to do business if you want to transiently rent that. That's a part of the packet when a real estate agent sells a house that they have to sign off on that. But we just think it needs to be stepped up just a little bit more and come from our perspective because we can drive that point home a little bit better. And so those are some of the areas that we're working on really in education and training. The regional partnerships are still developing that. We have a good program we're going on right now where the team is reaching out to
1:07:20 I call it peer resorts, but similar people who are resort-based and heavily dependent upon transient occupancy tax to talk about their enforcement efforts and what they're doing as a team to work through that process. At the same time, we're sharing information. So I think that's kind of caught on. We've talked to several entities, I'd say probably 15 to 20 at this point.
1:07:43 And we are getting feedback from others that are saying, hey, we want that data you're collecting, because we think that there's information there that we can utilize and be better. So it's a two-way street, and I think that's pretty strong. The audit program, so we've conducted, now we have one multi-unit property management company and three property operators that we've audited this year, so three smaller and one major.
1:08:09 Which exceeds what we had planned for for the year. But as we're walking through this, it seems to be working pretty well. And we want to use data as a trend analysis audit. And again, just looking for outliers and folks that are having a different sort of business level than the rest of our universe.
1:08:26 By type, and that'll help us really identify where to look next. So we think we've got a good program. It's rolling. It's maturing. Our staff is phenomenal. They're doing an excellent job of helping each other as well as just helping the community understand the processes by which we need to collect these taxes. So that's my enforcement update. Do you have any questions? Thank you. Thank you, Rob. A couple thoughts.
1:08:53 Are we still number five or number six in the state in terms of how many listings we have? I have not seen any updates to that statistic, so I would assume that it's probably the same. Was it fifth or sixth? I think it was fifth. Okay. That's just an important thing to keep in mind. We're the fifth in the state in terms of this stuff. Online advertisements. Yeah.
1:09:16 And I think we all just want to commend you and your department for a really great job and how far this has come over the last couple of years. I think we've really made an enormous amount of progress. However, not however, but I think one tangential piece of this that's really important has to do with housing. It has to do with long-term rentals. And I know Dan and I had a conversation today about, well, gee, we really can't, there's no way to
1:09:42 Get long-term units into a data set so that we could track it. And I think we should maybe think about a way to do that. And I'm wondering, I'm assuming the money, the penalties, the interest, and that kind of stuff, does that go back into the general fund?
1:09:56 Yes, that's correct. Okay, so I'm just throwing out an idea that maybe there's a way to start to incentivizing long-term rental units to get registered so that we would actually pay them to register with us so that we can be tracking trends over time of our long-term rental inventory because that's a huge vulnerability. And as, I mean, it's the whole A&B nightly rental is kind of a chaotic market, but it continues to thrive. It continues to keep going.
1:10:22 And I would just suggest that anecdotally it's pulling from our long-term rental inventory. And that, again, we need to make decisions about housing and things like that. It's a hole we have. We don't know what's going on with our long-term rental unit inventory. So I'm just throwing out some ideas, but I think that may be something to, maybe with the success of this program, we could find a way to start figuring out a way to get some of that data in. But, again, congratulations. You guys done a great job with this, and keep up the good work. Okay.
1:10:54 Any more questions? Okay, thank you very much. We will now go to consent agenda. Item four, award the contract for the Mammoth Creek Park Inclusive Playground Accessible Trial Project to Play Corps Wisconsin Inc. doing business as Game Time, CEO Great Western Recreation, LLC, and the amount of...
1:11:16 770,000, 150, 65. Item 5, approve the resolution authorizing 25,000 in special event support for the 2019 Mammoth Festival of Beers and Bluza Palooza event. Item 6, accept the Mammoth Lakes Recreation fiscal year 18-19, measure U special project funding and fiscal year 2019-20, measure U one time and multi-year
1:11:46 Funding recommendations. Item seven, approve the resolution authorizing the application for and receipt of SB2 planning grant program funds. Item eight, waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance amending municipal code chapter 2.24.010 municipal general election. Item nine, accept payment approval report number 19-44, accept
1:12:11 Payment approval report number 19-45 and accept payment approval report number 19-46. Does anybody wish to pull anything from the consent calendar agenda? I'll entertain a motion. Madam Mayor, I'll make a motion to approve consent agenda as presented. Second the motion. Roll call, please. Councilmember Salcedo? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes.
1:12:40 Yes. Yes. Yes. Item passes 5-0. Policy matters. We will now go to Item 10, Appeal of Enforcement Charges for Transient Occupancy Tax Enforcement Case, Number 2018-49, 192 Hill Street. Hi. I'm going to hand this out.
1:13:10 I'm sorry, just point of order. Do we get a presentation from staff first? I was about to say. We'll take these right now. Staff is going to make a short presentation and then the floor is yours. Thank you. Thank you. So, ma'am, you can stand up there. That's no problem. It's not going to be a long presentation. In talking through just a little bit of what's in the staff report, town staff identified on February 12th of 2019
1:13:45 Property located at 192 Hill Drive, found on House Compliance. And if the owner was soliciting transient rentals less than 31 days in an unpermitted zone, the advertisement included minimum night stay of three nights, listed no taxes, and a rate of 98 per night. The advertisement included one customer review from January 2019. So staff, in a normal process, sent a $500 administrative citation on February 12th.
1:14:13 For code violations including operating a transient rental in an unpermitted zone. As we talked about a minute ago, the purpose of citations is to notify the operator of the municipal code and get them to contact the revenue team. So in this case, Ms. Bauer contacted the revenue team on February 19th, which is within the 15 days, and so that citation was waived. During the meeting, Ms. Bauer,
1:14:42 The team identified one rental had occurred on the property resulting in $436.56 in rental income. Since the rental occurred in January, the taxes from the period were not yet due, so there were no penalties and interests associated with this unpaid tax. The TOT, $56.75, and TBIT of $4.36 were paid during the February 19th meeting.
1:15:11 Process by which, you know, I give you a note in here, just running down the different charges associated with that. When we do have an enforcement case, we do charge $500 on all enforcement cases, and that is basically a recoverable cost associated with the time and expense that the team goes through and incurred by the town in conducting the enforcement case. In this particular appeal, Ms. Bauer is appealing that $500 charge.
1:15:39 That is the amount of the request tonight. And I'll turn it over to you. Okay. All right. Okay, well, thank you for listening to me and allowing me to appeal the $500. So I kind of followed his format on how I'm going to do this. So my recommendation is that you waive the $500 enforcement fee and enforce one of the following codes.
1:16:03 8.32.030D1, $100 for the first violation, or the 1.12.020, $100 for the first violation. As I went through the library of your municipal codes, it didn't say anything about having a warning or anything like that. It was just automatically, first violation, you're going to get fined. So I was like, okay, where did the $500 come from? So when I received the letter,
1:16:31 On the 19th, I immediately came to the town because I didn't want to escalate the issue. I wanted to resolve the issue. And in this letter, it's pretty, it doesn't say anything about being $1,000. It was $500. An initial fine of 500, it states, an initial fine of $500 will be assessed. You should not comply within 15 calendar days. And that's for the zoning violation. So I complied, I went in.
1:16:58 I paid my TOT, and quite frankly, I think I want to pay that tax because I want the city of or the town of Mammoth to have that money so that we can improve. So it was also thinking at that point I said, well, why not let the homeowner who is at home who lives there and just wants to rent their room, you guys could have additional tax money that would go into the fund.
1:17:27 Anyhow, so let me just going to read this. So I received the first violation with respect to the TOT. My husband and I were unaware that renting a room in our home while living and present in the property was a violation. After reviewing the notice, which was received on February 19, 2019, and immediately contacting the town of Mammoth in person on the same day, it seems that the spirit of the law 8.20, public nuisance.
1:17:55 Was not violated. I understand that ignorance of the law isn't an excuse, but the spirit of the law, enforcement, and fine schedules should fit the crime. Additionally, both muni codes, 8.32.030 and 1.12.020 state $100 for a first violation. So, you know, we had a choice 14 years ago where we were going to buy a second home.
1:18:21 And we chose Mammoth because we love Mammoth. It is the best place to be. California is awesome. I can ski in one day, drive home, and surf in the same day. All in the same day. Where else can you do that? Maybe New Zealand. I don't know, but I'm not moving there. So during the 14 years that we've owned this cabin, it has never been rented, except for the exception of January 24th through 27th, 2019.
1:18:48 The reason why we never rented it is my family and I are very particular about keeping our home clean. Having a stranger in our home seemed to be out of the question. But with the amount of snow we received and the cost to keep my roof shoveled, even though I was part of the shoveling crew to keep the expenses count down, I paid out over $5,000 in snow removal this year. $1,000 of it was for my regular snow removal for my driveway.
1:19:16 But $4,000 with me out there every other day, it seemed like, because we have a very low-pitched roof. It's comp. It's not metal. It doesn't sheet off. You have to get up there, and you have to shovel it off. So it was like, where the heck am I going to get this extra money from? So it was like, OK, so having a stranger rent a room became a necessity.
1:19:38 At the end of December, I knew I needed, had to do something to generate money for the unbudgeted snow removal. January 2019, I placed an ad on Airbnb. This is not January, and they saw it in January, so it wasn't like I was doing it for months and months or years like the people up on Canyon who just totally negated the whole thing and said they didn't want to pay it and it was all about them. I'm not saying it's all about me. I'm saying I just needed notice to understand the law, which I did not.
1:20:08 So I finally accepted. So anyhow, I immediately received requests, but I still felt uncomfortable. Well, I finally accepted a request from Nathan, January 24 to 27, and rented him a room while I was present during his stay. Even though it worked out well, I still felt uncomfortable and turned out requests for February 1 and 4, 8 and 12, 15 through 17. So I didn't want to do it. It was just I felt compelled.
1:20:37 To find a way to make up that money. So I basically turned down $1,300 and I was going to take, and I was up here that, like I said, shoveling snow. I was going to take it off and then my husband calls me and says, hey, we just got a letter from the town of Mammoth. They're trying to find us $500. So that's when I came in.
1:20:56 So, anyhow, since I was in town to shovel, I was immediately stopped by the town of Mammoth's and find out what I needed to do to stay in compliance and not be charged $500 mentioned in the letter. Nowhere did it say that it would be $1,000. Jenna Carter was the town rep that assisted me, who is absolutely the nicest person ever.
1:21:17 She collected the 14% TOT, which in the Muni code shows 13%, so I don't know if it was 14%, in the amount of $61. She told me that the $500 fee would be waived since I responded within the 15-day period. When she left the counter to speak with someone in finance, she came back and said I owed another $500 as a violation for illegal activity. At this point, I was beyond annoyed because another $500 was breaking the bank.
1:21:45 Plus, I only made $375 after paying the TOT. How could the fine be more than the money that I made on renting a room? At this point, I returned home, removed the listing, and sent the below letter to Jenna. Just to be clear, what is the illegal activity fine amount to be? I can't afford $500, especially since the only reason why I rented the one room in my cabin was to pay for snow removal.
1:22:12 As you know, we've had lots of snow, and my roof can't handle the load. I've owned my cabin for 14 years and have never rented this room on a nightly basis. For a first offense, this seems to be quite exorbitant, especially when I see in the Civil Code 8.82.030, it's $100 for the first violation. Regardless, they can't pay $500, and we'll follow up with a letter to the Town Council as well.
1:22:35 Having the opportunity to attend a special meeting today and listening to the presentation of the housing crisis, because I was here that day, so I thought I was going to stop in and see what's going on. It made no sense that the town of Mammoth wouldn't allow room rentals if the owner is present. It would generate additional income for the town of Mammoth for the housing crisis. Kirk Stapp stated that losing grant money for our housing issue is unacceptable, and in order to have a chance...
1:23:03 For those grant monies, Mammoth would need to come to the table with local money. What better way to generate additional income by allowing homeowners the ability to rent a room in their home, rent a room, not the whole place, rent a room for overnight visitors. The 14% on those rentals would be beneficial. Please let me know if the fine for 100 or 500 and the reason why it's not stated in the letter dated 2-13-19.
1:23:31 So to conclude, if there is to be a fine, please apply the $100 first violation fee. My action upon receipt of the letter was to rectify the issue, not escalate it. The spirit of the law in which a group of individuals can live harmoniously together require rules, regulations, and consequences. However, $500 consequence seems contrary to the income of $375. In the spirit of the law and goodwill, please wave the $500. Any questions?
1:24:04 Anything from, any questions from the council at this time? Thank you. Discussion? Okay. With that, if there's no discussion. If, Madam, if you want to ask for public comment, but we can also address the question that came up on the 13 versus 14 percent if you would like. Okay. Yeah. I will ask for a public comment at this time. Okay. Seeing none, I think some clarification.
1:24:50 on some of the things presented. I just received this. I don't think I received another letter on, well, I haven't, I just saw this. So there are some things that were addressed. Did you guys get a copy of this? I'd like to just clarify the codes and I guess that 13, 14 percent question as well. Yeah, so the TOT percent is 13.
1:25:19 TBID is 1%, so combined they're 14%. And so she mentioned the 61-12 paid is $56.75 in TOT, and then the $4.37 for TBID. So that's that component. Several of the comments were made regarding the first offense, and these are civil citations, if you will, which there are none issued in here. We issued that one first $500 citation.
1:25:48 And that is waived when she did come in within 15 days. And that's the process by which we use. The question here is the $500 enforcement charge. That's the minimum charge that we charge to all of our enforcement cases. And that's what's at play here. It's not associated with any of those references or those municipal codes that were brought up. It's the enforcement charge of recovering the cost of the activity of doing the enforcement work.
1:26:15 That's what we have at question. The only citation or civil penalty that was issued was the 500, and that one was waived. And that is to help us cover costs of staff to run the program. Yeah. Yes, if you could come up here and... Also in the codes, it also said that in order for you to have that enforcement fee, that there needs to be an itemized list.
1:26:45 Of what it was, and to say, oh, for postage, I'll tell you, for postage, it's in my computer. So, you're supposed to itemize it. You just arbitrarily, you're fining me $500, which...
1:27:06 Like I said, it seems pretty exorbitant for a one-time offense. And you don't have, according to your letter, you don't have the authority to change that. So that's why I'm here appealing to you to understand that it was really expensive this year. I mean, to be able to keep a second place. And, oh, you know, other people go, oh, you're lucky you could have a second place. But you know what?
1:27:28 I work two jobs. My husband works. We work. It's not like we're just like sitting around collecting money from a trust fund. It's hard. And so for us to come up here, I mean, that's what I'm saying. It's like there's no itemized list. What did the $500? You can't just say, oh, it was for postage and for administration. Well, you can say it because you did, but it's not fair. So in order to, we pay more than $50,000 a year just to have that software.
1:27:57 That does the analysis. And you made that up in one quarter. And that's part of the process. $55,000. Not in enforcement charges. But I mean, you're not, like you said earlier, this isn't supposed to be. I'm trying to answer your question with regard to what the costs are. We also have three individuals that are specifically working only on the enforcement, that whole revenue team. So there's a significant cost associated with.
1:28:23 Doing the enforcement activities with the town and the collection activities that we do as a tax department. So that's where the expense comes from and that's where we do some recovery of the cost of doing these enforcement cases. So are you supposed to have an itemized list of that $500 when you send out a letter?
1:28:41 No. The determination of the cost of that is a minimum of $500, and that's done through an analysis of the cost it takes to conduct the revenue. It's not your specific case to say that it cost me $500 to do your case. It's a standard practice by which you determine the fees you charge for those. And where is that fee schedule? Because I tried finding that fee schedule. I couldn't because you referenced 3.12, .280.
1:29:12 And then you reference that the occupant taxes to the town as required in this chapter is a public nuisance and the abated is provided in chapter 8.2. And in chapter 8.2, if you're going to bait it through there, it says first time offense, $100. So where's the $500? I don't have the code listed out in front of me to give you that number. Okay. I'm asking you to find me $100.
1:29:47 First time offense. Okay. Thank you. Andy, could you just follow up just with maybe some of the legalities of what we're hearing here? Well, I mean, I think that we are entitled to recover our costs, and it's not practical to have a detailed cost analysis of every letter that we send. I mean, I think it is fair, and I think that there is a...
1:30:11 A line item in the town's fee schedule that the council has adopted that establishes this, I think. So I think it's fair to have an estimate that, you know, we think that a basic code enforcement or basic TOT enforcement action is probably going to cost us at least $500. That's probably fair. But as to Ms. Bauer's point about it exceeds the amount that she made, I mean, it's up to the council to decide whether equity requires that you reduce the $500, which is entirely up to you.
1:30:39 Is there something that if since you don't live here, it's your second home and you come up. Well, during the summer. How much time do you spend up here per year, would you say? Four months. Okay.
1:30:58 When it comes to the $500, one thing that maybe you were talking about you did here that we have a housing shortage here. I know it makes you uncomfortable to have someone in your house, but if you did open your house and rent a room out for 12 months.
1:31:14 Therefore, adding much more to our community than even if you were renting it out and paying TOT, not only would you have someone that you could have in there who would help you with shoveling snow, with keeping up the yard, making sure that these other things, that is entirely within your right to rent the room out. There was in an election, what?
1:31:40 Four years ago? Four years ago. Four years ago, where this was a, everyone in town was very for or against this very specific ruling for, and it has to do with just trying to make this a very sustainable area for everyone to live in, so I do want to point that out to you, that that is an option for you to not only make income, also
1:32:09 Have some of these problems that you're having eliminated. So before you say anything else, I just wanted to pass it on to anybody else in town. Oh, okay. Andy, my question, thank you for being here. I know it's not easy to come and address a council like this, so thank you for that. But my question is to Andy. According to the analysis and discussion of the staff report,
1:32:32 Where we talk about, well first in the background where we talk about the enforcement cases of zoning violation, in analysis and discussion we talk about the $500 administrative citation, followed the violation code of 5.40.070. So is all this in order in the proper and correct way to enforce this action? I will tell you that the municipal code does not appear to have anything specific that says we can charge a $500 minimum.
1:33:03 Code enforcement fee. I mean, as I said, the council, I think, has adopted that by resolution, has adopted that fee. Yeah. A bit of housekeeping could perhaps be done to add that to the ordinance to make it more specific. Okay. Okay, but this, what's reflected in the staff report is accurate? Yes. There's nothing in the staff report that's inaccurate. I mean, it is accurate, but if Ms. Bauer or you are asking where specifically in the muni code does it say this $500 fee applies?
1:33:33 I can't point to a place. And that's my point, because if you were driving down the street on the highway at 65 miles an hour, because that's what our speed limit is on the highway, you're doing 65 miles, you get pulled over, and he's going to write you a ticket for going over the speed limit because you're doing 55, you're going to say, hey, it's 65 miles an hour. Oh, no, it's 55, but it's not posted. How do I know that it's 55?
1:34:00 So my point is, how do I know that that was going to be $500? I had no idea. Yeah, you know, actually, with road laws, there is a, if it's not posted, there is a minimum posted. So we're not going to get into that. I guess my question, Rob, would be, the one thing that I do not want, I don't think that, unfortunately, I don't think that you deserve any money for, through
1:34:27 Ill-gotten gains. So what is the difference between what has been paid out and what was taken in for this one rental case? Is it the... I think she gave that to you earlier. $375. Oh. Yeah. So I have problems with these cases every time they come forward.
1:35:01 As a person who is on the other side of Measure Z, Measure Z is what forces us not to allow you to rent. So there's nothing we can do. That was a voter initiative. And I think 500 is more than fair for the amount of time and heartache that goes into enforcing these. My only heartache is that you didn't make the 500, and 500 is hard to come up with. I understand that. And I'm just not sure where I want to go here. One of the reasons for these
1:35:31 And the fees and everything else we set up is to discourage others from doing the same thing. And it does get around town. Everybody in town knows you can't rent private rooms out in Mammoth. It's just, it's one of those things. You can't make money without having a business license. One of those things we all should know. So I'm not really sure exactly how I want to go here, but that's my only heartache. You talked to it earlier.
1:36:00 Should the fine be more than they made on the route. So I'm willing to go with whatever the rest of council is willing to go with. Personally, I could go with a reduction to $375 on the $500. I'm vacillating back and forth. Sure, I understand. It's really tough. And you all know I want to be hard-nosed on this because it is an illegal activity. And we are tasked.
1:36:27 We're doing the people's will. Right. And I just think that having heard the presentation from Rob on the TNT Enforcement Program and for those of us who have been around here for a while, how long it has taken to get to the point where we have some maturity in that program and we're seeing that this is actually kind of working. I don't have any problem if the council wants to review the fees overall and look at the program holistically.
1:36:54 I think that's appropriate. I have a hard time looking at individual cases and saying let's make an exception here or there because that, I think to your point, that encourages more activity coming from the council getting this kind of stuff and I think that would be inconsistent with the actions that the council's made for many years and I think this would be one, I think the first time since I've been here for several years that the council want to start getting into these things and
1:37:20 And I'm not asking any questions of the applicant. I'm not going to question representation she's made. I'm hearing it. I'm listening. I'm taking it for what it's worth. But from a policy perspective, I think we need to stick with where we're at. So with that, I'm prepared to make a motion. Excuse me, ma'am. Excuse me. I'm prepared to make a motion, Madam Mayor, if that's appropriate. I would like to speak first before you make a motion. This is for... Go ahead.
1:37:46 Discussion, please. Yeah, if you read the legal considerations, we're sitting in a semi-judiciary capacity. We're sitting to make a judgment on this. I'm not interested in changing the ordinance. I want the ordinance to say the thing. It sounds like there was a legitimate...
1:38:04 Breakdown in communications, and I'm willing to support the $100. I mean, the fact that you stood up there and said, hey, we're willing to pay something, you know, to me that is compelling. If she was asking for nothing, then that's another argument. But the fact that she's saying, hey, I'll pay $100, you know.
1:38:25 But I just, again, we sit in a semi-judiciary capacity, and I believe that, you know, there was some breakdown. I don't, I think that the town did the right thing, they did the right steps, but there's still a miscommunication that take place or a misunderstanding that took place, and I'm willing to accept the $100. I would continue to go back to the staff report where we quote,
1:38:53 5.40.070.0, point B, under lining up that the violation in the zoning requirement would be $500 for the first violation, $1,000 per second, and subsequent violation within three years. So I would support the full $500 violation fee. But your town attorney said it's not there. Just a clarification, that $500 citation was waived.
1:39:16 So that one because- That first one. That first one. There was no subsequent citation issued. This is about the enforcement charges, cost recovery for the team that does the work to do the enforcement. It is not a citation and it doesn't reference that code section that you talked about. So this code is not relevant? It was when we issued the first $500 citation. That's what got her to come in and talk to us. And then that was waived because she came in within the 15 days.
1:39:45 So that $500 citation has been waived. It's not there. But the $500 enforcement charge is the one that we're still enforcing. So again. Okay. With that, I'll go ahead and entertain a motion, please. Thank you, Madam Mayor. So I would move that the council make a finding of not compliance with the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code and uphold the notice of determination amount due $500 for enforcement fees. Do I get a second on that?
1:40:18 I'm sorry, John, again. I'm sorry. So I'm moving that the council make a finding of noncompliance with the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code and uphold the notice of determination amount due of $500 for the enforcement fee. I'll second that. Okay, further discussion? Yeah, words that say that it's $500. Your town attorney just said it's not.
1:40:45 Ask the town attorney. I don't want to reword what you said, so I'll let you go ahead and repeat that, Andy. What I said is that I think the council has previously adopted an enforcement charge by a resolution, and I also said that I can't point to a specific ordinance that refers to that. So the resolution was that...
1:41:07 That's what I'm remembering. It has been adopted by council, yes. We have a fee schedule in place that identifies this fee. But where is it in the municipal code for everyone else to know? Again, in further discussion before we vote, because of how small the rental was, I still would be comfortable in asking you to amend that to the 375. I think that's commensurate with the Crown.
1:41:41 Committed, no one is going to gain from, you know, ill-gotten gains, as you said, and I think that that is a great compromise. Kirk, I think $100 doesn't get us anything, but I think the $375 does send a message and doesn't lift the level of fine above what the infractions were.
1:42:07 And I just, for me, it's a matter of principle, so I'm keeping the motion intact. And you know what? That is a good point. Now I'm looking at the 375, which I have a level of comfort with. However, that means that the enforcement portion, which is the thing that is...
1:42:25 Catapulted us up to being the fifth in the state for this. What this basically means is the $375 would go, well, you know, you didn't make any money off this, but then again, we as a town lost money because no money came in for enforcement. So is there enough to, you're looking confused at me, Dan. What I'm saying is if she made $375 already,
1:42:53 If we go with $100, she made $275 off of breaking a rule. That's a good point. I agree with that. The $500, you know, that would still leave, you know, a little bit that went towards the enforcement on that is kind of the way. I just wanted to let you guys know where I was kind of thinking about that. But you did receive the TOT.
1:43:20 There's a motion on the floor. There is a motion. Did I get a second? Yes, Linda seconded. Oh, okay. Roll call, please. Yes. No. Yes. Yes, I'm going to stick with the original motion. Thank you.
1:43:50 I'm sorry about that. I do think at this point we've gotten to a point that consistency is something that we have to work with in this town. And thank you for your time. Even though it's not in your municode. So is there a way I can appeal your decision because it's not in the municode? That would be something that you could speak with Andy. You can take the town to court. Okay. Okay, thank you very much.
1:44:18 Okay, now we will be moving to the next item. Madam, I'm going to run to the bathroom real quick. Oh, you know what? Actually, we are going to take a seven-minute break, please. I know, you're going to laugh. Let's open this soda, and I did have my... Come on, this is the best thing ever. Okay. Okay.
1:45:27 Everyone hold up your single-use glasses. Change the law. I'm sending this right to Brandon. Change the law. But Chad, this one's compostable. It says right on it. Oh, come on. Stop. Okay, with that blackmail picture out of your way.
1:45:46 We will now reconvene the meeting, and we are on item 11, Appeal of Citations, Penalties, and Interests for Transient Occupancy Tax Enforcement Case Number 2018-54-5, Cornish Unit Number 5. And Rob, do I boot this one over to you? Yes, you do. Just give me one second here. So this one is a little bit different.
1:46:18 Then the last one, and actually different than what we usually conduct. As you know, when there are citations issued, we'd like to have a citation hearing in advance of any request to come and appeal before town council. In this particular case, Mr. Simpson was going to be in town today and wanted to conduct both on the same day. So we did have a citation hearing earlier today with our hearing officer, which was Chief Davis.
1:46:47 And so I did receive, just before the meeting, an update on his findings. Now, his findings will be rolled into what... Is that Chief Davis' findings? Yes. Okay. His findings will be rolled into, which he's upholding $1,500 in administrative citations. There was a total of $4,500 issued, so he's waived $3,000 in citations. He's upholding $1,500.
1:47:16 And I'll read his reasoning behind that. So on 5-1-19, Chief Davis conducted a hearing in regards to the above case. Present were Finance Director, Revenue Accountant Danny Earls, Revenue Specialist Jenna Carter, and the property owner Russell Stimson. The case was presented by Danny Earls, and Mr. Stimson was asking questions regarding
1:47:43 Several of the discussions we had about the mailings, the dates, and the amounts. So it's really looking for clarification because we had sent, in this particular case, we sent 41 different mailings to the property and a lot of them during the enforcement case process were certified mail and several of those had been signed for but Mr. Stimson did not recognize the signature that was given and possible explanation.
1:48:13 Really had no possible explanation of how that could have happened. Mr. Simpson said he never saw many of the mailings. He also explained his personal situation and lack of attention to the town and keeping current on payments. He does present a history of making payments, though late. He does honor his debts. In regards to the $500 enforcement charge and $1,000 citation and legal rental of the property due to the... And it's illegal because it was due to a canceled account. If you...
1:48:42 Remember, we go through a process by which we send notifications that we're going to cancel a business tax certificate for not filing returns, monthly returns. In this particular case, we had done that with Mr. Stimson, and his account had been canceled.
1:49:02 Based upon the timing of his arrival in Mammoth to pay his fees and fines, the first $1,000 citation was signed for and dated on March 19th of 2019, and then he arrived on March 21st to settle his accounts. I find that Mr. Stimson is responsible for the enforcement citation of $500 and an initial $1,000 administrative citation. There is a previous $1,000 citation mailed and not signed for dated March 14th, and two subsequent $1,000 citations sent March 20th and 21st, sent and signed for.
1:49:30 I'm not holding Mr. Stimson responsible for those three citations. One cannot be determined it was received, and the other two were the timing of the arrival in Mammoth. So in this particular case, that's his findings. So how that's going to change the presentation before you, the amount written in the appeal was $1,317. That will go up to $2,817.
1:49:58 And that includes the $1,500 that are upheld. So that will be the amount you're upholding or you are determining to change. Can you repeat, is it $2,877 even? $2,817.86. Thank you. So now I'll kind of give just a brief synopsis of part of the staff report. So in March...
1:50:28 March 5th of 2018, Mr. Stimson applied for a transient rental operator certificate, so a business tax certificate to rent legally. He is able to rent his property for transient rentals as long as he has the proper documentation for that or the proper tax. So the business tax and transient occupancy certificates were issued on March 15th of 2018. From March...
1:50:57 2018 to March 2019, we had 11 of the 12 monthly returns were remitted delinquent. So that means they were not filed on time. They were late. In many cases...
1:51:14 They would go a few months without any notification. And if we don't receive a tax return, even if there is no rental activity, we're unsure whether or not they're still in business. And so in order to keep our activities clean, we go through a process by which we mail notifications of, you know, your delinquent on your tax return payment or notifying us of our filing on the tax return. And after...
1:51:37 After we go through that process, we'll send a notice of intent to cancel your certificate, saying you clearly are out of business. And that's the process we had to go through several times throughout that period. Mr. Simpson did come into the office several times and make payments. But again, it was in delinquent amounts. So in those processes, during that time, I said we had 11 of the 12 monthly returns were remitted delinquent accruing penalties and interest, which Mr. Simpson paid.
1:52:09 There were 41 individual mailings sent to the address on file in compliance with the process of the municipal code. The account was closed on February 22, 2019. So on March 21, 2019, Mr. Stimson visited the town offices and presented his revenue documentation. So we had gone through, we had provided with an assessment, which is based upon our estimate. When Mr. Stimson brought the actual rental activity in, it was very close to that number.
1:52:38 And he had gross receipts during that time period of $27,970. So we went through the process with Mr. Simpson talking about what he needed to do to pay this in full and go through the process. So he did pay the notice of determination in full in order to begin his rental activity again. If he does that, we were going ahead and allowing him to continue the rental activity.
1:53:07 And so what we have here is he's paid for the TOT, which is $3,636.15, and the TBID of $279.70. And the request is for the penalties and interest of $1,163.90 and the TBID interest and penalties of $153.96. That's the amount that's being requested here as far as a
1:53:37 As the appeal process goes. And we're adding the $1,500 in citations to that, which were determined earlier today. And that's where we get to the $2,817.86. So Mr. Simpson is aware of the penalties and interest component of that. I mean, he incurred those through the process by which he came in and paid his late.
1:54:02 11 of the 12 returns were paid late, and those incurred penalties and interest as well, so he was familiar with that process. And so that's kind of the end of my presentation on that. Okay. I do have a question. I'm a little bit confused since I guess there was a meeting earlier today that had some additional information, so I'm looking. So when you say the $2,800, give or take,
1:54:31 That does not include the $500 enforcement charge? That actually is included in that number. I'm sort of unclear on this, too. I'm sorry. If you look at the Notice of Determination, if I read this right, he paid $8,590.04 to bring himself current. That's correct. That includes the $4,500 administrative citations.
1:55:03 In the statements from Chief Davis's
1:55:33 Review of the account. He's listing the $500 enforcement charge in there. It's actually a $500 initial citation. Mr. Stimson did not, is not appealing the $500 enforcement charge at all. Oh, okay. That's been paid. In fact, the entire amount has been paid. At this point, what is being appealed is the penalties and interest, which is the $1,300, and the $1,500 in citations that are being upheld.
1:56:00 So that was the initial $500 citation, which was signed for and not responded to within the 15 days. And then the first $1,000 citation that was issued subsequent to that. And then we do give a pause for someone to come in and talk to us during that time frame, which Mr. Stimson did. And that's why Chief Davis is not enforcing the last $3,000 citations.
1:56:29 The appeal here is the penalties and interest and a $500 citation and a $1,000 citation. Okay, so I've got $500, $1,000. What is the amount that gets us to $28,1788 and what is that for? And then the rest of that would be penalties and interest of $1,317.86. That's penalties and interest? That's penalties and interest. Thank you. Did you wish to speak on this matter? No, Madam Mayor and the council. First time.
1:57:02 Owner of this condominium, first time ever having any kind of a vacation rental. I hired a management company that I expected a little more from as far as communications, so I really didn't know that I was in violation. I expected a little more from them and didn't know where I was at that stage. Some of the mailings that were sent to me were sent to a P.O. box.
1:57:31 And I did not sign off for them. So I think maybe the owner of the PO Box may have signed for them. But I never did see them. So I really didn't know that I was, you know, this much in arrears. I'm sorry, PO Box in Mammoth Lakes or PO Box in LA, but it's not your PO Box? Well, they didn't have a complete address. They had the physical address of the location, but my unit number is 156. And there's probably 600 boxes there.
1:58:00 Oh. So I never received those. So, and I looked at the signature, didn't recognize the signature. It's not mine. It's not my ex-wife, who also gets mailed at the same location. So I can only assume that it may be the owner of that facility. Okay, thank you. You know, I respect the TOT. I understand the taxes. I have a history of coming up.
1:58:26 And working with Dan and Ben, they've helped me go through it. We've written the check right there. My mother fell. She lives in Hawaii. I was gone for about four months there. That's why I wasn't present to come this last time that I expected to be here. And I'm not a wealthy person. I'm just hoping to get a little more relief on some of this. I realize that ignorance is not really a reason, but
1:58:59 I have my reasons, and I had no idea that the fines would be this exorbitant. I really had no idea. Okay. Questions from council to staff at this moment? We're very comfortable with where we're at about this one. Okay. Any public comment on this subject matter? Seeing none, I will return it back to the council for any more discussion and a motion, please.
1:59:34 I'd like to make a motion that the council makes a finding of noncompliance with the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code and uphold a notice of determination due the $1,317.86 plus $1,500 for a total of, in citations, for a total of $2,817.86 of citations, penalties, and interest. I will second.
2:00:13 Okay. Further discussion? Yeah. So I can ask a question, Rob. This would mean, if her motion goes through, that he would receive a check back from the town for $3,000. That's correct. Yes. I'm fine with my second. Thank you. The only thing, just as a further discussion point, the last case was right on the margins. Small amounts, you know, all this kind of stuff. I think with the representations from staff, we have a...
2:00:40 Our fees in place at $500, things like this. You look at the time and effort staff has put into this, you can see where we have to pay these things. It's unfortunate, but that's just the reality of running a program like this. Yeah. And I'm hoping we have the correct address for the future, because it does sound like you were definitely trying your hardest there. Okay, well, there is a motion and a second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes.
2:01:09 Yes, motion passes 5-0. Thank you for your time, sir. Thank you for your time. Thank you. And now we will go ahead and move to item 12, the transient occupancy tax revenue reconciliation for three years, including fiscal years 2015-16 through 2017.
2:01:34 18. And I believe this was brought forward at a request, correct? Yeah, so this is something that I've received actually through a lot of correspondence with you council members individually. I think this is one of the things that you're asked most about when you're out and about in the community. And I will acknowledge while all this stuff is public and is presented, we do have 24.
2:02:01 Plus or minus council meetings a year where information is presented, council member decisions are made. So for the general public to track all the dollar spends, it's pretty unreasonable to have them understand where all those monies went. So I think it's a good exercise of reviewing the activity that was done, being able to present the numbers. I'm particularly proud of the spreadsheets put together. I think they're pretty cool.
2:02:30 But I do recognize there's more to be done from an aspect of giving you guys sort of a one-page report that says, you know, here's a summary I can carry around with me and present to folks. As long as you have that backup documentation behind on the reconciliations that says, here's really all the detail. We don't really need to read through a lot. There are a few things I would like to get confirmation from you guys.
2:02:58 With regard to the process by which we bring information in and discuss it, as well as to talk a little bit deeper about the reconciliations and some of the backup documentation, because it was a bit challenging not to put it together, but some of the information is on different resolutions which are stated to Council at different times. So I do quarterly presentations to you with regard to town finance position.
2:03:26 Often enough in these quarterly presentations, TOT is certainly the major revenue source that we discuss, but it's not the only revenue source that we discuss. And to try and not confuse the process with this reconciliation, I really focus on the TOT component. So some of the information you see as backup will have other revenues on it as far as budget adoption and budget amendments.
2:03:52 But they're really there just to show you that that was a full activity that occurred, including some of those TOT dollars that were assigned. And folks might find it a little bit confusing to say, well, I can't follow right through there. We've got either fund balance available or you're saying you're spending more money than there was a TOT. And it was because it was during maybe a fund balance presentation and it was just a little bit more activity going on. But when we come on a quarterly basis,
2:04:18 Like I said, usually I'll have a large amount of TOT to recognize, and then there'll be a lot of needs. So for example, a couple years ago with the 2017 winter storms, there were a lot of storm damage, a lot of snow impacts, and those were brought forward in one fell swoop to talk about from Council's perspective. So it's a little bit cleaner, but the reconciliations are solid. I gave you all the backup documentation and the resolution numbers to support them that really tell where that $16 million plus went.
2:04:46 For those three years in question. Now we are currently in fiscal year 18-19. We have not yet increased the TOT budget. So I'll come back to you on the 15th of May where the presentation looks like about $4.5 million. I'll be recommending we realize in TOT revenue for that budget perspective.
2:05:11 And at that point, we'll be talking about some spends. You guys will be making some decisions on those. And that will sort of start filling in the blanks for next year's reconciliation, if you will. But that question did come to me. We have yet to really allocate some of the excesses that we see. And I'm comfortable going to an $18 million budget on the 15th of May. I think that in looking at the analysis, if we finish this year with an average of the last three months of the last three years, we're going to be at 19.2.
2:05:41 If we show the 8% increase that we are over last year, we'll be somewhere around 19.5. So we have some strong numbers coming in, but that's not in this because we have not yet allocated any additional TOT, so nothing there. I did talk about the quarterlies. We do come in and talk about where we are. Sometimes there's recommendations for that. The purpose, in my opinion, is if we're going to budget on a very conservative basis, we need to be reactionary.
2:06:08 I'm bringing that to you. There's usually staff recommendations with regards to the revenue and expenditures. You have a chance to deliberate on that.
2:06:27 And we make the adjustments and move forward. So I think that's a sound practice. Tonight I'm asking for confirmation if that's still the way you would like to see things or if there would be a change in the format by which we present the financial information to the town. Maybe something that would be more clear to folks. But I'm just looking for discussion. And if someone has questions about any of the components, I'm not asking you to reaffirm how these monies were allocated by prior councils. Those ships have sailed.
2:06:55 If you will. And it's really just for understanding of how they sailed than it is for reaffirmation. So, yes. I had just a couple of, because when, on page 105, this 1718 summary, the additional, you're good. Okay. The additional general fund revenue of 12, 1.2. What was that?
2:07:29 So that one was trying to tie into other revenues that were reported because I didn't want to show a negative number at the bottom. So those were realized during the fund balance presentation. So you would see...
2:07:49 In the back pages, I mean, they're not related to T.O.T., but there are other five. So that wasn't anything to do with T.O.T.? Correct. That was my question. I believe that was the only year that I added in those excess dollars. Right, it's the only place I saw it. But in the backup documentation where we have the amendments, you would see them there. Okay, thanks. That's all I have. All I would like to say is I am very happy with how we're currently running the budget. I am very glad that this year, unlike some in the past, we have not had to allocate some of the
2:08:21 potential overages in the first, second, or third quarters due to emergencies so that we can look at this amount in the context of what projects we have going forward. So I appreciate all of this work, although it makes my head hurt. You're the numbers guy. I appreciate the point that this council has gotten to in how we handle the budget and future expenses. Madam Mayor.
2:08:53 I looked at the 15, 16 budgets all the way to, and I projected out the 18, 19 budget, the TOT, an estimation of about 19 million. If we add those four years together, we come up with $21,442,000. And what I get asked by the public is,
2:09:21 What happened to all the excess TOT? I've had a chance to talk to Rob and I would just like a one-page summary so that when somebody comes up to me and says, what have you done with all the excess TOT? I can say, okay, some of it went to the parcel purchase. Some of it went into reserve funds, which is, I think, an absolute legitimate.
2:09:44 You know, use of those dollars to make sure that we do have a downturn in the economy or whatever. But that was my focus and asking for this kind of thing. I also think that, you know, the quarterly review, you know, is a good thing, but I think it needs to be anchored with the budget that is adopted. So when we talk about the quarterly review, there needs to be some discussion, okay, are we...
2:10:13 And don't get me wrong, the TOT comes in major after the middle or at the end of December, January, February, and everything else. But we keep needing to look at, okay, where are we in relationship to the budget we adopted? So those are my two concerns. One is I want to be able to tell the people what happened to the $21 million in excess TOT, and I want to be able to anchor
2:10:41 Our budget discussion up here, rather than look at them just in a quarterly basis, that quarterly basis always goes back to looking at the adopted budget. So those are my two areas of concern. And those sound, I mean, I appreciate, I mean, but to do a roll-up like you're talking about, to get from this into a one-sheet,
2:11:03 I would imagine that might be something relatively easy to do with staff to just, okay, because, you know, roll, help me, roll me up and tell me, put it in the layman's language where these things went. So that hopefully should be pretty easy. I mean, I'm, honestly, I'm pretty happy with three pages because it gives me enough information to where I could say, okay, you know, housing reserve, you know, community commitments and community projects. Okay.
2:11:29 Remembering, and if I want to go back and refresh my memory of what those were, it's here. So this works for me. And the same conversation we have with constituents coming to me and saying, what have you done with all that excess TOT? And, you know, well, we did really good stuff, but that's not the answer people want to hear. Sure. So when I can go to this, actually, and, you know, speed it out a little bit, and then for those people who are more curious.
2:11:52 Being able to go back and say, you know, I mean, I've sat with people and said, okay, sit with me and let's look it back here because it's not easy. I mean, if Rob can put it in one page, I doubt if I'd be able to read it because it'd be really small. He'd cheat on the font. It'd have to be on two pages, you know, two sides. That's a really good point because having three pages, that may be the kind of thing where we've got the information, but then we have to do the exercise to roll it up to make a digestible constituent. So maybe that's...
2:12:18 This is getting a lot closer to one page than we were. If I could just a couple of things, Madam. I'm not criticizing this exercise at all. I'm just trying to tighten it down so the public can look at something and say, okay, I understand what the council has done, what they've approved. Because some of the previous...
2:12:43 And I do have all of them here. The previous presentations. If you want me to share them with you. The previous presentations have left me, shall we say, digging through packets and pages of materials. I just think that we've come, I mean, some of us who've been around back the pre-bankruptcy days when it was not technically possible to even produce this.
2:13:09 Despite committees and citizen outrage and all the rest of it, we couldn't even get to that. So I very commend staff and Dan and Rob with the great work you've done. I think we all feel pretty confident with how this is working. I'll just say that there will be, you know, it's a big budget. There's a lot of numbers. There may be times we have to adjust and do things like this, but I think that's good progress. There's two things that
2:13:37 That I want to, I think would be important going forward. And that is to start getting some data associated with this, with these presentations with the budget that has to do with our environment. Specifically having to do things with snow and snowfall and smoke. And this is important because the state of California, I mean, the policy of the state of California is to use controlled burns to manage the inventory.
2:14:07 of dead trees and fuels on the west side. And I think it's going to be critically important for us as a town to be able to make representations that say, and whatever we figure out what the metric is going to be, coming out of the Forest Service, smoke levels are from the air district, smoke levels were this, and we don't, you know, now get crazy about it, but look, we had a smoke situation going on from...
2:14:27 Middle of June to the middle of August and to be able to track, hey, our revenues community went down and we can make a correlation to that. And the other thing is with snow that we could, so we can make, just have some information that says, hey, we had a big snow year. Yeah, the TOT numbers do go up. We had a bad snow year, they do go down.
2:14:47 This is going to be, again, because if the state with climate change and all the ways they're going to be looking at these things, I think it's going to be critically important for us going forward to be able to have data that we can take to state agencies, all kinds of different places and say, look, you're burning priorities. They're happening on the west side in an air district. I'm not sure what air district on the west side is saying.
2:15:11 The San Joaquin Air District, which is not the great base, it's not our local air district. That air district over there says, oh, it's okay to have controlled burns. All the smoke is leaving that air district and coming over here. And we may need to be in a position to have to advocate to the state and back to that district to say, look.
2:15:29 You're creating hazardous conditions. You're destroying our economy, all the rest of it. So I would just request that we follow up with that and find a way to start making associations with smoke and snow to our monthly forecast. But that's it. Anything else on this item? Public comment about this item, please. Seeing none, I will turn it back over to Council for any more comments and a motion, please.
2:16:03 Do we need a motion or are you just looking for consensus? We're looking for the consent comments from Council. It sounds like overall the process we're using is accepted by the Council. Looking for a little more data when it comes in related to some correlation stuff. Anchoring it back to the adopted budget as we go forward so you have a point of reference, if I'm hearing that correctly. And we can do that as we bring elements in for you to look at.
2:16:31 I guess on the data side, if you could come back with some recommendations of what data you think we should correlate it to. Yeah, we'll have a few things. Yeah, the things you mentioned, there's a few others we can probably tell. Probably the air district, whatever, because that gives us good standing with the state on the air side and for snowfall, whatever you think is an appropriate, you know, reliable metric for that. And I just want to see a three-minute elevator pitch.
2:16:52 So I can just blurt it out to people. And a one-page summary of all the excess TOT. How big does that page have to be? Well, it's got to cover $21 million because I have already calculated how much money. Have you ever seen one font? It'll be about this size. Yeah. It'll be about that size right there. And we can just, like, flip it out in bonds.
2:17:20 Well, and in fact, what he's delivered here is the three years, and they are very small packages. If there's a constituent that really wants to know, ask him what year he's talking about and show him how the money was spent during that year. It gives them an opportunity to see how different councils have made different decisions. I'm very happy with what's in here. I think one page, you can't deliver enough information to tell a constituent anything about where the money went.
2:17:50 It doesn't work for me. Yeah. I like what's been done here. This is a good job as far as I'm concerned. Okay, so I think you got consensus on that one. Ted, come back. This was for you. So now we will go ahead and move on to item...
2:18:08 13, resolution to approve fiscal year 2019-20 project list to be submitted to California Transportation Commission, the CTC, for funding from the road maintenance and rehabilitation account funds under street and highways code section 2034, take it away, Hayes. Thank you. So, yes, we're looking to adopt a resolution this evening to approve a project list.
2:18:36 This resolution is required in order to receive funding from the SB1 RMRA, that is the Road Maintenance and Rehabilitation Account. If we do not submit a resolution, we do not receive our allocation on a monthly basis from the state. The funding in previous years, dating back to 2017, has gone towards the Meridian Boulevard curb and gutter replacement project. We are recommending a third phase of that project.
2:19:04 The timing is a little funny because of our construction season doesn't quite line up with the state's fiscal calendar. So last fall we completed phase one. This fall we'll complete phase two. And next year we will complete phase three. But right now we're approving phase three a year in advance. So that's why the timing seems a little awkward.
2:19:24 We're only slated to receive about $132,000 this year, so it's not a huge pot of money. We did fully fund phase one using these funds. We anticipate being able to fully fund phase two and three using these resources. That's really all I have, and I'm happy to field any questions related to this item. How much money from SB1 does it...
2:19:49 What's the average? Does it go up and down? What should our expectation be? It's about $130,000 a year. It's been fluctuating a couple thousand dollars the last two years. The first year was a little light because they were ramping up the program. So to pay ourselves back, we actually took a little bit longer than one year. But it's what it's looking to be for, you know, I don't see any change in that in the future. And it's not going to grow. It's tied to the gas tax. Thank you.
2:20:18 On the location, can you give me some wayfinding things in my mind? I can't picture where this is. Yeah, so phase one was up towards Lodestar and towards Eagle Lodge where the water district has a building up there, kind of that area. We did an ADA ramp. There was actually a little bit more than curb and gutter. We kind of fixed up some sidewalk and some ADA infrastructure.
2:20:46 The phase of summer will be down by Obsidian, going west towards Minaret, and then we're proposing as the third phase, Minaret moving up towards, going up the hill towards Little Star. So those are existing sidewalks that we're going to go in there? It's existing curb and gutter that's more or less failed, and it's always pretty low on the excitement level for, you know, replacement.
2:21:13 Deferred maintenance. So we figure it's a good opportunity to use these SB1 funds. They're going to great use. Helps to keep the road in good shape. Provides a better bike lane. Is it on the north side or the south side? It would be on the north side. The water, that water district where it's... No, this phase three. Phase three would be across the street from the bell-shaped parcel. Thank you. And on all three phases, it would basically go from Joaquin to Eagle Lodge.
2:21:43 Pretty close. There may be a little gap depending on how much funding we can stretch on that third phase. We may have to come back in a fourth phase to close out the north side before we move across the street. Thank you. And there's no match required for this, right? No. That's nice. Do we think that money's going to go up?
2:22:05 Don't we think that, wasn't that projected to increase? No, I think it's kind of balanced out. We would love for it to go up. We would love to get a larger allocation, but we're only budgeting at about $130,000 a year. I suppose as we become more and more efficient and legislate in more efficiency, this dollar amount is actually going to decrease, not increase. It's like smoking taxes, right? That's exactly right.
2:22:28 I would make a motion. Oh, wait a minute. Here, let me go ahead and take it out to public comment. Not seeing any public comment. You know what? You guys are public, too. So, okay. Seeing no public comment. Even the changes failed. Press took a picture. We'll take a picture in.
2:22:48 Okay, with that, I will entertain your motion there, Mr. Bill. I would make a motion to adopt a resolution approving the fiscal year 1920 project list to be submitted to the California Transportation Commission for funding of the road maintenance rehabilitation account funds under streets and highways code section 2034. Second. Roll call. Further discussion? Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yep.
2:23:19 Yes, item passes 5-0. We are now on item 14. Authorize the town manager to execute a challenge cost share agreement with the USDA Forest Service Pacific Southwest Region Inyo National Forest for recreation site management. And this was a, whoops, did I get to the wrong thing? Oh, and so Stuart, this is you.
2:23:50 It is. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'm just going to give you a brief overview of the staff report that you have in your packet. I'll just start from a little bit of the background. It's probably good context for the item. But US Forest Service and the town have been working over the past several years to certainly improve the overall recreation experience in the Lakes Basin. As we all know, as a direct result of the increasing volume of our summer guests,
2:24:20 Through our discussions has been the day use recreation facilities, which are the restrooms. Due to the financial resource limitations of the Indian National Forest, representatives approached the town with the goal of establishing a day use recreation facilities pilot program for the coming summer. Several meetings were conducted to explore the scope, details, responsibilities of the partners with the outcome to jointly participate in a challenge cost share agreement.
2:24:48 At the time of writing, the Challenge Cost Share Agreement is still under review by the Grants and Agreements Group. So Council action tonight we're really asking for is to authorise the Town Manager to execute the agreement, which we don't have, but it's coming. If the agreement is substantially changed from the original intent and the proposed operating plan, which is attached, we will return to Council for further discussion and consideration. So generally in the operating plan that you have before you in the exhibit,
2:25:17 Nine of the 20, there's 20 day-use recreation facilities located across the international forest, nine of which are maintained or identified and located within the municipal boundary of the Town of Mammoth Lakes. So what we're looking at is to agree that we're going to take over these nine day-use recreation facilities. They're up in Minaret Vista in the Lakes Basin with support from the U.S. Forest Service to really meet the needs of our expanding visitor population.
2:25:47 As part of the Challenge Cost Share Agreement, the Forest Service has agreed to reimburse the town for the actual expenses occurred, not to exceed $20,000. Responsibilities of both parties were identified, and that's kind of listed in the operating plan, but in general terms, the town, Parks Maintenance Department, Warren and his crew, will be responsible for cleaning and stocking those nine restroom facilities, including the removal and disposal of trash and the recycling.
2:26:16 In addition, as part of the agreement, the town is responsible for providing a vehicle, which is kind of that 20% match to the agreement. And we are planning on providing at this time approximately 150 days of service, weather dependent, through the summer and the fall, which provides a minimum five-day-a-week service. We'll look at expanding that service based on visitation and use.
2:26:42 If we have high demand times during holidays, periods of time that we know there's a lot of people in the lakes basin, we'll look to increase that service. Warren's pretty comfortable with this kind of scope of work. It means we're going to be hiring an additional employee that will just manage this for those five days a week. For a little bit of detail, we're looking at kind of a Thursday through Monday level of service.
2:27:08 Covering the weekend before and after. And then those Tuesday and Wednesday period of time will hopefully be able to cover some of that service with additional staff. They can kind of at least visit the restroom facilities. It would be at least one day, sorry, one time a day. We could look at kind of getting two times a day in those facilities. So something up in the Horseshoe Lake area, very busy. We believe we might be able to provide.
2:27:35 At least, you know, twice a day service, which I think will go a long way to increasing everybody's enjoyment of that area. We'll manage the program through the Parks and Rec Department. Warren, as I said, will manage it through the Forest Service. The Forest Service will be providing the recreation facility supplies, as in the toilet paper, the materials, gloves, you know, those type of things. If, for instance, a facility...
2:27:59 I know they call it a recreation facility, but it's really a restroom. If that restroom is damaged and not able to be used, we'll notify the Forest Service. They'll go ahead and schedule their staff to come up and maintain it, fix it, get it back in service. We are just solely tasked with servicing the restrooms themselves. So it's really just the day-to-day use, toilet paper, trash, recycling, those type of things. So we've been as clear as we can on the operating plan. As I said, it's attached. You can kind of see it in great detail.
2:28:28 And the responsibilities of both parties. So the recommendation was at this time to authorize the town manager to execute a challenge cost share agreement with the USDA Forest Service Pacific Southwest Region in your national forest for recreation site management. Margie did indicate that she was trying to make it this evening to speak in support of the program, not able to attend, but we're happy to entertain any questions you might have. Thank you. Okay, questions.
2:28:57 So, 150 days could go longer, could go shorter depending on weather? Correct. When we open the lake spaces. And the term of this agreement is through 2024, April, so we wouldn't be doing it in 2024, so it's really only 23. And the amount of money is $20,000. Yep. But if we spend more than that, then that's on us.
2:29:23 Do you anticipate that through the year 2023 this will cost us more than $20,000 a year? I think what we would like to, as we've kind of described this as a pilot program and as an opportunity for us to re-evaluate at the end of the year, so what we're really interested in understanding is really the scope of service that we're really able to provide. So if we really see it as a five-day-a-week service, we're probably comfortable with this scope.
2:29:48 If it does grow to seven-day week and now we're pushing into kind of, you know, early spring, you know, really late fall in October, November, that's really kind of pushing, you know, the operating plan and what we've discussed. Then will we take it back then? I believe we can go back to the Forest Service. Especially after the first year, because we set it up as a five-year agreement, basically, so we don't have to come back every year, party for the Forest Service timeframes. But we can go back in after the first year and say either, if it flat out doesn't work, we'd tell them that.
2:30:14 So this is the first year, I'm sorry. So, well, we worked through that, but it'd be set up for a longer term, but we could go back in and say, hey, either we need an amendment or we're not continuing or whatever. The other side, we're not sure yet, as soon as we get into it. We don't know if this is a, say, a five-hour-a-day round trip or a seven-hour. If it's less than a full workday, then that would actually free somebody up to spend maybe a couple of hours on our parks.
2:30:41 To support Warren's staff in some other areas so we would have another benefit to the town from that that we would pay for obviously not charging to the force of us. So we need to work that through. This is the first year, like last year they sort of asked us and we jumped in and did it, but this year... No, no, in the past all we've done is gone up and put up...
2:31:01 Port of toilets and trash receptacles at the beginning and end of the season before the concessionaires are there. We've never provided this level of service. So this is the first year we've had a formal agreement to do this work? To do this type of work, yes. And it was partly they had funding for it, but their recruitment time and elements to get somebody on board did not work well on their end. I think they'd get somebody on board about the time the season was over.
2:31:25 Well, I mean, I'm really anxious to see if this is successful and that we're able to provide, you know, clean restrooms, well-stocked for visitors and, you know, the experience that the staff person has that does this, how much work it's going to take. Okay, thank you. And I just wanted to confirm.
2:31:46 I know this is probably the third time you've had to say it, but the operating plan may be adjusted or the program terminated following the pilot program plan for this season. So even though it's a five-year contract, it's not a binding contract for five years. That is correct. Okay. Just wanted to make sure that was correct. I am actually...
2:32:10 Well, I have feelings on both sides of this. I've dealt with the Forest Service as long as I have. This is a hugely positive step for us to be able to affect the quality of services in the Lakes Basin. Several of these, as you read through it, are pit toilets. They can be opened early and late if we're the ones cleaning it. It actually gives us some semblance of control in the Lakes Basin that we haven't had before. So, for me...
2:32:37 Even if it costs us something. You know, we spend money on a lot of things. And our tourism is hugely important. So if we can effectively spread the people around a little better, give them a quality experience no matter where they go up there, that's all the more to us. I would like to see this as just the start of us and MLR getting involved up there and doing some of these things.
2:33:01 Yeah, if I could, just to flesh this out a little bit. So to be clear, the Forest Service is providing the funding for this, correct? So this is the Forest Service coming to us saying, we need your help, we need your staff to make this program happen. But up to $20,000. Sure. And what this is indicative of, and at the Recreation Partnership meeting last week, we heard from the Humboldt-Twabi Forest Service.
2:33:26 Who are in dire straits because the Forest Service seasonal hiring program is a disaster. The national policy says they have to hire people in the fall. They have to go through security checks, background checks. They get staff locked in place for the summer. Then it comes time, okay, it's April. We need you to report for work. Oh, I've taken another job. I can't do this. The staff is then, their hands are tied. They cannot go out and hire anybody else. So I would anticipate this is going to be just the tip of the iceberg of things coming forward.
2:33:56 A couple other things. So I'm hoping that, obviously we all applaud Dan and Stu and you doing the work to put this thing together. I think it's very important that there be a public outreach component to this. And I'm going to request that the trails coordinator through his blog, through all the communication tools that he has, he works with Stu to make the appropriate recommendations. But because all of these facilities where this work is happening are trailheads of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System.
2:34:23 And so I'm hoping that we can, through the Trail Days events, through the public outreach, it's a great example of sustainable recreation at work. And I think it's important to be coordinating that so that message is getting out. The other thing is I'm hoping that there's some kind of data, some sort of tracking component to this.
2:34:45 In terms of how many restrooms cleaned, level of service. Again, this goes back to the data needs that we have to be able to make representations to the Forest Service, to our partners. We have this conversation with MLT about visitation. This is part of a data set. The only other data that I know that's being collected are the 38 trail counters that the town owns that's been collecting data for the last five or ten years. That's the only on-the-ground data that's going to inform our conversations with MLT and the Forest Service.
2:35:14 This is where people are going and this is what they're doing. So if we get some information out of this, combine it with that, it's going to help paint the picture of what we're doing. I also want to just advise council members that the town has an MOU in place with the Forest Service for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. It has expired. The town of Mammoth Lakes has an MOU in place for the Mammoth Lakes Trails website.
2:35:39 That's expired. Matthew Perullo, who's been hired as the recreation coordinator, he's been tasked with doing these things. I'm assuming that this agreement, these kinds of things, that someone's going to be monitoring and managing this to make sure that, I mean, to your point, Cleland, that we want to be monitoring, make sure it's successful, but we're not going to let these things lapse. But that's part of the role that he can play in moving all this kind of stuff forward. I believe what you're referring to...
2:36:04 Linda, last year there was this word of the emergency running around last summer, which I think we all remember that the Forest Service is going, my God, we can't do this anymore. We're kind of scrambling to figure it out. I think that's where that was coming from. Right. And I'm hoping also that you can coordinate with the trails coordinator to identify when those high-impact weekends are going to be happening. I was over at Convict on Saturday, Fishmas, big opening. I mean, just overwhelmed.
2:36:32 No presence from Forest Service, no presence from the county, nobody on the ground, just hundreds and hundreds of thousands of people. I don't want to say thousands, I don't want to get hyperbolic, but these are the same situations in the lake space in the summertime. Memorial Day, Labor Day, when people are parking all over the place, there's no presence from anybody. Were the bathrooms open at Convict? The bathrooms may have been open. Convict, I don't know. I just, no, I just, I kind of drove through, I was checking out some ski lines and stuff like that, but I didn't, I didn't.
2:36:57 But it was busy. I mean, these are the things we've got to get into to make sure we have these big holidays that we're in good shape. So, and one final thing. Again, in the partnership meeting last week, toilets are a very, very high level of conversation. This had the Forest Service many years ago. You may know about this bill. LAWP may have.
2:37:26 I think the INU has about 35 different water systems that the LADWP may have helped to put in place 30 or 40 years ago. They have all run their useful life. So now, you know, LA's water is now at risk because the INU has got all these legacy water systems that are failing and it's threatening the water quality coming out of Los Angeles. This is a real partnership opportunity to go to the city of LA and say, look, thanks for putting these things in 40 years ago.
2:37:55 Forest Service has no money to fix or replace these things, the toilets and the water systems. Let's start talking to the city of Los Angeles about getting some money into that partnership to start fixing these toilets and these sanitation systems. And Nora Gamino, who's the forest engineer, has got some great ideas on this. And to your point about why we have flush toilets up in the lakes basin, that, you know, they have to be soon, the first freeze in the fall, we've got to shut it down. Dan's then got to get some temporary toilets up there so we can have full color viewing and all this other kind of stuff.
2:38:21 So there's a lot of great opportunities, and I think this is a great program. It's a great demonstration of that sustainable recreation piece to get people working together. So I just want to applaud your efforts for putting this together. Thank you. I did have another question also. Also, the second part with the financial considerations. When you say purchase a work vehicle for, are we talking about maybe
2:38:46 One that's already in our stock. Yeah, we'll look at whether we get a little used pickup or if we trade one down from existing into that element. We'll look at a couple options for a low-cost component to that, especially as, you know, for the pilot year, we may even use one older one we had ready to surplus if we keep it for the summer. But, yeah, so it'll be, well, that's part of our match. And so if we do a little nicer truck, it'd also use further park stuff and or it would stay in our fleet going forward if we don't continue the program.
2:39:15 Okay, but the financial consideration, there's a bunch of more money involved in that because it would be, are you saying if it goes? So what would happen there, we'd acquire it and say, right now we're guessing the cost of the body is about $15,000, $16,000, so we would also request reimbursement for a portion of the pickup truck, so we would end up getting that back over time, but we'd have to buy it obviously up front.
2:39:41 That would come with our vehicle replacement fund and work through that process. Okay, just because, I mean, it just seems to me this is not going to be a clean job. This is not going to be the same thing. That's why you have the back of a truck, you know, so we can hose it out. Right, but I just wanted to make sure when it says purchase a work vehicle that we're not talking about giving someone something that's bright and shiny so that we look good as we're cleaning up. Brand new Ford Explorer. Yeah, exactly. Lights and sirens. Yeah, it'll be an older work truck, frankly.
2:40:10 So how much is that going to add to the cost then? It depends. If it's out of our current fleet, very little. If we have to buy a used one, maybe, I don't know, $8,000 to $12,000 or something. So then it's already up to $32,000? Well, and that would be an ongoing reimbursement. That's part of our match, and also we can think of that as part of that submittal back in terms of reimbursement over time to recover the cost on that. So if it's a five-year program, we get the...
2:40:38 $5,000 back is just kind of what we're looking at over the five-year term. If you spend $20,000 on a vehicle, you get those dollars back. We think it's about $15,000 to $17,000 of labor. You know, depreciate the cost of the vehicle over those five years. It's $15,000-ish. There's the program. So the reimbursable cost is factoring in the cost of the vehicle, the acquisition of the vehicle. That's kind of how we built it together. And this is something that you think that there's...
2:41:06 I hate to do this. Is there any way that we can have this, I guess it's a different subject, but going back to earlier today, the whole poo fairy thing, I was wondering if there was any way we could kind of consolidate the whole.
2:41:21 We'll get there. We're going to get, these are parts of the puzzle. As we put the person on board, if they have excess time, they can help with our parks. Now, where they help and how they do that will be up to the needs of the parks. If it's help picking up dog feces, if we had that, yes. But it would be something that we would look and say, how do we utilize the person to best benefit our program overall? Yeah, because I know like up at Tamarack,
2:41:47 They've had challenges in the last couple. The Tamarack winter staff is supposed to clean the bathrooms and the Forest Service seasonal staff gets laid off like in September. So there's no one up there in the fall. The bathrooms get trashed to the point where Tamarack says, we're not going in there. We are not going to maintain, we're not going to clean that bathroom. We're not touching it. The bathroom stays in a state of disrepair all the way through the wintertime. So these are pieces of the puzzle.
2:42:14 We start doing this. We get the Pooferi program. We start kind of bringing these things together. We get in the business of successfully managing our assets and our excretal needs.
2:42:27 Human and canine, just saying. And it really wasn't a viable option to say we're not going to have the restroom service but a couple days a week. No, no, I understand. I'm just kind of looking at the bigger picture here with some of the other things. So I have no more questions on that except for I do, if I seem like I'm having a little bit of trouble wrapping my mind around that, just go use that first bathroom that we have here on the right-hand side and you'll see.
2:42:52 Even in buildings, it does not work, even though that's not Forest Service or taken care of by the town, so you'll see why I'm a little bit not happy about restrooms right now. Yeah, those are not our responsibility, by the way. No, I know, I realize that, but like I said, I just realized you guys didn't have the visual that I had earlier today, so I'm done with my questions. And your visuals, I hope.
2:43:13 I have some visuals I can share, but I'm not going there. No, this was something I walked into. At this point, Madam Mayor, I'd like to make a motion to authorize the town manager to execute a challenge cost share agreement with the USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Region, Indian National Forest for recreation site management. I'd like to second that. I'd like to add just a nuance to that, and I just defer to staff to make sure this is appropriate.
2:43:39 To add to your motion that we coordinate with the trails coordinator for... Without the motion, because that's outside the scope of the... Okay, but I want to make sure that the comments are not going to get lost. They're not. We have them for that, for Joel, like the blog, and I've already talked about getting photos. The communications work.
2:44:02 Pushing that out. And for any data you guys can collect so we kind of know what the level of service looks like and also be coordinating with him around high-impact weekends and events. Right, because that's part of the way we structure it. Right, just, okay, Labor Day is coming up. Let's schedule things in such a way so that we're going to be taking care of this stuff. Because this is the only presence on the ground in the Lakes Basin, our most high-impact events. And I think we need to take advantage of this to get...
2:44:28 Feedback and in data back so we know what the hell we're doing going forward. We'll have a good collection system because we have to report back. So I withdraw my amendment hearing these representations from staff. So I will withdraw. I'll just second your motion. Okay. Any further discussion? Roll call, please. Yes. Yes.
2:44:52 Yes, item passes 5-0 and that is behind us now. Let's go on to item number 15, waive bidding requirements and award contract for purchase of two new loaders to Cashman Equipment in the amount of $375,000 each for a total of $750,000.
2:45:20 I'm sorry. I just got that. Okay. And I'm bumping this over without Grady. I guess Hayes, you're going to take over this one? Yeah, I'm actually going to try to cover items. I'm actually going to try to cover items 15 and 16 at the same time. They are discrete resolutions. They need to be adopted separately, but the background information is very similar. So in the name of efficiency, we'll try to do two things at once, and I'll try not to confuse you too much.
2:45:46 The two contracts we're talking about are to replace two pieces of equipment. We consider the loader-blower combination one piece of equipment. That is a different manufacturer for the actual blower head. We've been before you a couple times now talking about the replacement of our aging fleet and the need for additional equipment. The pieces of equipment we're talking about are nearly 20 years old.
2:46:10 We do have to do a sole source resolution. There is only one Caterpillar dealer for this region. We are strictly a Caterpillar fleet, like same kind, helps with maintenance and efficiency. Cashman equipment out of Reno is the only dealer that is allowed to sell to this region. So in order to get through this process, we have to adopt a resolution awarding the bid directly to them as the sole source provider.
2:46:37 The same is for Kodiak, which is item 16. Kodiak is the only manufacturer of those blower heads. They're in Idaho, is that correct? Are they in Idaho? Yes. And that, those pieces of equipment are pretty much the only pieces of equipment that can manage the snow that we receive here in town. So again, it's a sole source resolution to award that contract directly to Kodiak to authorize them to start producing that piece of equipment for us.
2:47:06 With that, I'm happy to field any questions related to either item 15 or 16. So we're buying three things, two loaders and one blower. Yep. If you take these forward, we take them to two separate items. Items 15 would be the purchase of the two new loaders, and then we would consider the blower as a second item. I'm assuming that the loaders come in that price with the Baldur's and couplers already on them so that...
2:47:35 They will fit our current equipment and all of that? Yep, that's correct. Madam Mayor, I'll waive the, if there's no further discussion. I would just, the only comment I would offer is, again, the climate change group I deal with in Sacramento, I think the data really demonstrates that while temperatures, ambient temperatures may be rising, the amount of moisture coming our way, there's no, that looks like, there's nothing saying that's going to change.
2:48:05 And so given, even if the snow levels go up, we're going to be in this business, I would anticipate for a while, and it might even get more intense. So I'm thinking this is inappropriate for a lot of reasons, but I think it's a good thing to do. And if loaders can actually, they can do something other than snow. Oh, sure. Correct. So the loader blower is a unit, so it's just for that.
2:48:30 The other loader is utilized for still plow and for other purposes. Right. Okay. Like the poo fairings. Could they clean toilets? Sort of. They could just... Okay. I'm sorry. Continue on. Oh, did you go ahead and make a motion? Unless there's no further discussion?
2:48:50 I make a motion to waive the bidding requirements and award the contract for the purchase of two new loaders to Cashman Equipment in the amount of $375,000, each for a total of $750,000. I further make a motion to waive the bidding requirements and award the contract for purchase of new blower to Kodiak America in the amount of $430,000.
2:49:19 The first and the second motion. Nice. Nice combining of the two items. I tell you. Nice motioning. Any further discussion? Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yo. Yes. Item passes 5-0. Item 17, discuss the Junetown Council meeting schedule.
2:49:48 And this also, is this going to go to Dan? Oh, no, sorry. Yeah, the recommendation here is for June to do to accommodate some League of California training is the recommendation is to move our June 19th meeting to June 26th. That also spaces the meeting out a little stronger between the one meeting currently scheduled for July and the last meeting in June. It's just the following Wednesday, so hopefully if your calendars accommodate that.
2:50:17 Otherwise, with the training and with Member Salcido out of town, we would not have a quorum for the 19th. And rather than only have one meeting in June, the recommendation is to shift the date. So I'll make a motion that we... Yeah, no, I did have a question. So I'm sorry. The mayors and council members' executive forum, that's the training session and the dates are June... 19 to 21.
2:50:47 19th, I know, you're going, oh, okay, and, okay, yeah, those trainings are great, I won't be here because I'll be at that training, so I have nothing else to say on that one. Okay, so I will make a motion then to reschedule the June 19th, 2019 Town Council meeting to Wednesday, June 26th, 2019. Second. Any additional conversation? Public comment? No public comment?
2:51:19 Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Item passes 5-0. And now with that, we do need to recuse Bill Sauser from monthly update on the parcel. We'll take just a five-minute break just to stretch our legs here for a second. If you just note that the recusal is due to a conflict of interest due to the location of his property in proximity to the parcel. Yes. He has a conflict of interest, ergo the
2:51:51 I live too darn close. Yeah, you do. Yes, you do. He just made up a word. That's not made up. That's a word. That's true. Okay, we are back in session now for the final item on tonight's agenda, item 18, which is the monthly update on the parcel.
2:54:48 And take it away, Sandra. Thank you. So I'm here giving you your monthly update on the parcel progress.
2:54:57 So you recall that last month on April 3rd, you authorized a contract with Lisa Weiss Consulting for conceptual land use planning. And since April 3rd, we've worked to accomplish a number of steps in this process, both directly related to the LWC contract and outside of that contract. The staff report has a list of all the different accomplishments that we've made over the past month. I'll just kind of highlight a couple of them. Some of the highlights are we acquired some additional
2:55:27 We've updated the parcel webpage and tried to make it a little bit more user-friendly. Clearly that's a work in progress, updating the parcel webpage, getting more information.
2:55:56 I'm really kind of pushing out all of our information to the public on that webpage.
2:56:03 We are working on a contract with a Spanish translator. This person, Catherine Allen, I think is her name. She's a local and has worked on a lot of different projects for a lot of different agencies. She's got a very good reputation, a very, very good resume. So we're really excited to be able to work with her on this project. We're also putting together outreach cards. We're calling them outreach cards. It's kind of following on that business card discussion that we had on April 3rd about kind of something to hand out. So this will be something English.
2:56:32 On one side, Spanish. On the other side, that we can hand out. The council members can have some. If anyone needs any information, it's going to have kind of a link directly to the parcel. Web page is also with information on the project. And we should have those next week. We're also coordinating the public interest interviews for next week. It's May 7th and 8th.
2:56:54 Those interviews are done by Lisa Weiss Consulting and her team. So town staff are not sitting in on any of those interviews. And that's really consistent with how they conduct those types of interviews across the board for these types of projects. They really don't want town staff or city staff sitting in on there.
2:57:11 Because they are somewhat confidential. All of the information that comes out of those interviews is aggregated, so we'll get the information, but we won't know exactly who said what after that process. I think that they get better comments and better information through that process.
2:57:29 We are working with Mammoth Lakes Housing. We worked with Mammoth Lakes Housing to get letters out to invite some Spanish-speaking residents of MLH properties to participate. So we do have some Spanish speakers who will be participating in these interviews next week. We'll have our translator there at those interviews. We also put together the resolution for the SB2 grant funding, and we're working with Mammoth Lakes Housing to put together the application for the SB2 funding, which we will submit hopefully in the next couple of weeks.
2:57:59 And then we're also working on branding for the parcel project. We do have a draft brand that I can show the council. If I can get it up here. So this is what we're kind of coming up with. This is the...
2:58:17 Most recent version, I think this is likely the final or close to the final version, but this would be the branding that we would have on all of our materials, the webpage, kind of everything that goes out with a parcel. So, and we worked with the Pat Davis Design Group to put that together, and they've been working with Amy Callanan, our associate engineer, really kind of perfecting this and getting it to this spot. So, we'll be looking to include that on our, all of our outgoing materials.
2:58:47 Are there any questions on kind of what we've done to this point? I'll go through kind of our next steps and then just talk a little bit about ongoing items. I'm happy to take questions now or I can just kind of finish, go through my presentation. It's just tree. It's like mountains and sky. Tree and building. Let me see. Oh, wrong. It's not a cow. I'm not saying cow. There's no cow.
2:59:17 Oh, I'm sorry. Yes, okay, it makes sense now. It's like, sorry, it's so small. It's like sky, landscape, mountains, sky, that's what I see, grass, you know, tree. And then the shape of the colored area is the shape of the parcel. So, I don't know, Madam Mayor, I...
2:59:42 I've got some questions around public outreach and stuff like that, which most things you kind of touched on. I can continue. I can go through. I have a couple other kind of next steps that I can hit on and then maybe. Okay, sure. Sure, whatever you like. So just a little bit about the interested party interviews. The purpose of those interviews is to provide the consultant team and the town some more insight on what are high priority.
3:00:05 Considerations for the conceptual land use planning process from various local perspectives. So we're including interested parties who have participated in the past, you know, local governmental agencies, other local agencies and groups in these interviews. We have about 50 people and we're conducting 16 different interview slots. So we're working on scheduling all of that this week, finishing all the scheduling this week for the
3:00:29 The interviews next week. Our next step is to get Engage Mammoth Lakes, which is also quote unquote bang the table. So our kind of formal name for it is Engage Mammoth Lakes. We're working to get that up for public input. That's really an engagement tool. It's really intended to get information back from the community. You put information out, but you're also getting information back. So we've been really using our town webpage as pushing out information. And we haven't launched Engage Mammoth Lakes at this point because we don't really have anything to ask.
3:00:58 So what we're going to do is we're going to take the interview questions that we're using for next week's interviews and we're going to turn those into multiple choice and make it something that people can actually use online. Open-ended questions don't work very well on those types of things, but we will have the availability for people just to kind of type what they want. So we're working to put those questions into a format that will work online and we'll launch that the week of May 13th. So we'll push that out, push out Engage Mammoth Lakes with those questions.
3:01:27 So the people who may not get an interview with a consultant, they still have an opportunity to provide some responses to those questions that we'll be asking next week. And I think you mentioned the joint town council PEDC meeting on June 26. I apologize, the wrong date was in the staff report. But we're looking to have that joint meeting on June 26 with the Planning and Economic Development Commission.
3:01:50 And then a public charrette in August. We're still kind of working on those dates internally, and then we'll reach out to the council to check on your availability as well. And that charrette, just to kind of let the public know, I mean, a charrette is, it's a term basically that just talks about an intense
3:02:08 Period of designer planning activities. So it's basically all hands on deck trying to solve an issue and trying to answer some questions. So that's really what this charrette is. It's going to be a week of intense work on the parcel and conceptual land use planning process and hopefully ending up with a conceptual land use plan.
3:02:26 At the end of that process. And so it's really a working, it's an opportunity. The consultants are here. They're working the whole time. And we've done this before. We did it with a Main Street plan. We had those consultants here for a week, really working to put that all together during that week process.
3:02:42 And so just kind of hitting on community input. So we have community input throughout this whole process. So through the Engage Mammoth Lakes, through the Joint Town Council workshop on the 26th, June 26th, through these monthly updates that we're providing to the Town Council, the public charrette in August, and as well as any time any member of the public can reach out to either myself or Grady Dutton.
3:03:07 You know, who's the kind of lead on this project to talk about issues that they have or questions they have about that. And then just so the council is aware, we have ongoing items. So we have biweekly parcel meetings with our team with LWC. Mammoth Lakes Housing has been invited to those and participates as available. We'll continue to work on updating the web page to make it current and relevant.
3:03:31 And then briefing our town manager so he can pass on updates to the town council members between these monthly updates that you hear. So there was a request from Councilmember Wentworth to take a look at the parcel webpage. Maybe we can ask questions and then take a look at that webpage at the pleasure of the council. So that concludes my update. Okay. Okay. I like that. Thank you. That's really helpful. You're welcome. And I think it's, you know.
3:04:00 Good for the community to be able to hear that. I've been to the webpage a couple times, clicking through, and it seems like it's growing and getting a little bit more, I think, online, social media presence that people identify with and can see often enough to kind of follow progress is also a step. So, yeah, this is great. Thank you. I have some thoughts. I want to make it clear to staff that this is not an attempt to micromanage anything.
3:04:29 I'm just asking questions as a member of the public and also just making sure that we're doing everything we can to make this work.
3:04:38 One, my first question has to do with Mr. Sauser and his conflicts and the concern about when we're going to be scheduling these updates. It's now 10 after 9. There's no public in the room. I'm hoping that the town manager, we can maybe figure out a way to schedule this in the meetings. So even though the public may not want to be here at 9 o'clock, there are members of the public who tend to be here for the beginnings of our meetings. So if this update's happening earlier on the agenda, at least people might not even know what we're talking about, they get exposed to it.
3:05:08 So I'm not sure how to address that. Do you have any idea or way to see how many people watch this online at all? Well, there are ways of doing that. I mean, I'm sure Granicus, if they're watching it through Granicus on video, Jamie can provide us a report on that. But not through the cable. Not television. Television's different. So that's just a general concern. So I'm just going to hit on a couple things again. I'm just trying to get some questions answered. I'm not trying to manage or do anything. I'm just trying to get some questions answered.
3:05:38 And again, so the office space for the parcel, I'm sure that's going to have all the tools technologically you guys are going to need to do Skype, screen share sessions, work remotely with all kinds of different people. Those are the tools you're going to have to be able to make that work. Yes. Right, okay. So on the parcel webpage, just a couple thoughts on this. One is I did a Google search and it took me to the page.
3:06:05 Great. That's good. That's what we want. If I search for it from the town's website, it's not quite there. It kind of goes to something else. So I would encourage, again, I don't know who's managing the town website, but to put some kind of a button, I mean, get this little graphic and put a little something on the persistent navigation somewhere so that you hit on the nice little graphic, it'll take you right there. The other thing was there was nothing on the page yet of
3:06:31 I have for more information or to reach out to Grady Dutton, who's the project lead, so that it's clear. Send an email to Grady or call him so that it's clear I can get more information if I need it. The other thing I would add is, hey, I want to be on your list. And I appreciate the way that the website is set up is like to sign up for the list. It's like a different module within the website. It's a slightly different thing, but maybe we can make that idiot-proof and kind of easy to say, hey, I want to be on your email list.
3:06:58 So that's all good. The Spanish language stuff is great. I was a little confused about the postcards in here. I thought, I was thinking, oh my goodness, are we going to do a mailing? But I understand what we're talking about. They're just postcard size. Yeah, so that we can all have things to hand out to people. And I would encourage you to put a QR code on there. And if you want to put the URL for the webpage, that's fine. Maybe some folks like to sit there and type in URL addresses.
3:07:24 I personally don't. But I know that like all contemporary phones, like an iPhone, you don't need an app to access a QR code. You just point the camera at it and it will take you to the page. So it would be good to try to integrate that so those loops get closed easily.
3:07:46 So the branding, with the branding, I mean, this looks fine to me, I'm not going to get any comments about the aesthetics of it, but it's very useful for whoever you've contracted with to do this to produce a graphics kit that will produce a Facebook-ready image, an Instagram-ready image.
3:08:02 And if you could maybe share those with council members, because it's certainly for our social media pages, we've got a way to do that. It provides some instruction that says, hey, put this post on your Facebook page, and you click here and take to the parcel web page. We can all be directing traffic to that source. I think that would be really useful. And, okay, so the public interest interviews, I understand that. So these are intended to be done anonymously. There's no attribution to what people are saying?
3:08:31 Right, right. I mean, we know who's being interviewed, but we don't know ultimately who said what. So they'll kind of generally put all that information together, similar to what they did for the Mammoth Lakes Housing strategic planning process. So you kind of knew what the issues or the comments were, but you didn't actually know who said what. Sure. I think it would be helpful, at least for me, to understand the geography of the interests of the people who are interviewed.
3:08:58 There may be people who are just community members. They don't have a geographic interest. But I know we've been talking about kind of the geographic scope of this master plan and to what degree it gets into the surrounding neighborhood. So it would be helpful to know whether or not we can document that folks who have an interest, either property interest, that we can say as council members, well, we know that there are people with a geographic proximity to the project, that that was documented.
3:09:26 So another couple things is that I think it's going to be important. There's a lot of good outreach stuff here, but I think because of the short timeline we have for this, and all this is going to lead, Council's going to have to make some potentially very, we will make, I know we will make important decisions based on what this draft land use plan is going to say. So I think it would be very helpful to know if there's a doc, if the outreach work that we're doing, it's documented. You know, here was our outreach program.
3:09:53 These are all the things that we did. These are all the points of contact that we had. So we can have confidence that it was a robust and fully engaged program and people say, I didn't know about it and blah, blah, blah. We can all say, hey, Cleland handed out 300 of these outreach cards. Kirk handed out 1,000 of these cards. Come on, folks, we did everything we could and we can make sure we can drive people. We did better than you. Yeah, well, you guys, we're going to hand out thousands of these cards.
3:10:22 I'm very interested for the bang the table thing. I think we're all very interested in seeing that and seeing a demonstration of that. Again, it's another channel that we can point to constituents to say, look, and I'm assuming that the sign-up list you'd have on the webpage, you will use that to direct people to bang the table, right? And also be adding to the town's email list when you send out announcements and stuff that's going to go to all those different places? Okay, great.
3:10:51 Great. And I'm assuming if Grady's here or not here that you're certainly going to be on this. I'm available. Good. Okay. And so finally, I think I'm just a little concerned with the project schedule, just the wording of it, the semantics of it. You know, you could read this and it starts to feel a little bit kind of staff internal.
3:11:14 And I think there are people in the public who would say, I don't agree with them, and I think we're all trying to make sure we do as public a process as we can. This is heading for predetermined outcomes. This is heading for staff and the consultant are going to come up with something, and they're going to put something in front of us.
3:11:31 I know that's not our intention, but I would just be sensitive to the semantics when we lay out a schedule like this. So that's not something that people can take away from this. And so there's an internal charrette, and the public charrette's not till August. I don't know how I've been engaged with this thing. I'd just be sensitive to that so we don't get sandbagged to get kind of boxed in the corner with that. The other thing I would do is I would let's lock down some dates for this public charrette.
3:11:56 Every organization in town right now is locking in their summer schedule. Right, right. I mean, every, the summer is booked and we, let's get these dates locked down so all of us through our channels can start saying we're not putting events on, we're not doing things for those dates, we're going to keep that space open and we can drive people to it to make sure that we're not, you know, like the marathon's not happening in that day or something else. It's like.
3:12:19 We own that space, we occupy it, and we can drive people to it. And we're working on that. That's an item on our agenda tomorrow. Good. Okay, great. We're already working on that. Good. That would be great. And let us know what those days look like. Absolutely. So that's kind of all I got.
3:12:36 Okay. Good work. Did you want to look at the webpage or are you okay? I don't need to. I think it's good. I think it's fine. I think it would be nice to have the brand on it. But my concern is just those information things to make sure that so we're driving people to that. What we're doing is we're driving constituents to a database that is the outreach database. And it's important to start doing that sooner rather than later. Like in my experience, you don't wait.
3:13:00 To start collecting names when you launch your outreach tool, like the bang the table thing, you put something out there right away to say, get them on the list, get them on the list, get them on the list. And then when you roll out this engage Mammoth Lakes thing, it could be like a preliminary thing. It's kind of a tester. And you start building your audience that way. And then as we go forward, we get as many people in there as possible.
3:13:22 And we've been getting names as we've had different events. Anyone who's called or everyone that participated in the Walk the Parcel, we send an email and ask them to sign up in the Notify Me. So anytime anyone comes and asks about that, we are directing them to the Notify Me page. I hope that, did we get you any, from the Housing Summit, did you get any data out of that, information out of that?
3:13:42 I think we sent information. I think we might have sent an email or Mickey might have sent an email to them about that. We had that notify me page up back then as well. This has been up for a long time. So I don't remember, but I kind of think that Mickey had sent something. Maybe we just double check and see if there's a collection of names. Yeah, and so just kind of a side note is that the housing survey that we did in 2017, you recall we mentioned that at the last...
3:14:09 Council meeting. I sent an email out to all of the email addresses we had. It was about 400 email addresses related to the housing element. But as a tagline, I said, if you're interested in the parcel, the 25-acre property that the town bought, check, go here. So that's another 400.
3:14:26 Email addresses that we sent that out to you. And those people could, they might be locals, I don't know who they all are, but I did get that data and I did send that to them. So we are trying to really get people to sign up and get engaged with this. And so I think our goal is at the end of this process that we all can stand up and say we did everything we could to engage everyone. I think it's Stu's, all the great work that Stu does with the regular.
3:14:49 Just try to get the brand in there, get the link, sign up, sign up, sign up, feature it so that we can all have confidence and we have to start making these decisions later this year that you can say so many people were touched, so many people were out of reach. We really tried to cover all the bases. So nice work. Congratulations. And just keep it coming. And again, I'm just offering these as friendly observations. Thank you. Any questions or comments? Yes, I have comments.
3:15:17 More of an observation. You know, we're going through this lengthy process. I think the first thing that needs to happen is that we need to draw out schematics of what's happening so people have something concrete to discuss. If it's 300 units or 350 or whatever it is, where the roads are, where everything, it's really hard.
3:15:42 You know, to be going through different charrettes and everything or different, all the different meetings that we have had and really not, you know, you're just asking people to come up with ideas. What do you need? What does the business community need? What is this? And, you know, the fact is if they have something, you know, it's going to change. Even going through this whole process, it's going to evolve and it's going to morph as people,
3:16:11 Actually see the plan. So, I mean, if we're talking three stories, if we're talking 350 units, where the roads go and everything else, I just think that we could be much more productive if we take Haysip and then we put him...
3:16:29 And tell him to draw it out. And then he's completely responsible and we can beat up Haislip and say this is his idea and we're going to change it. But get town staff to put something up there that is concrete because all these steps, I do support the outreach and everything else, but I just think it needs to be anchored on something. Sure, but just to follow up on that, I'm assuming that part within the scope of work for the consultants is to start to produce.
3:16:59 These conceptual drawings. And I think that it... But the sooner it gets out there, you know, if we're going through all these, okay, we're going to talk to all these different people, I'll be very blunt about it. I mean, Mammoth Lake Housing...
3:17:12 We put a concrete proposal out there, ask for feedback, and then figure it out. Because the finances is going to drive a lot of this. And if we're going to have to go out and say, okay, wait a minute, if we're going to change the zoning, if we're going to change the AMI, it only goes up to 120. I mean, we need to be able to say...
3:17:35 Look at, say, hey, we need to change some of this to make it financially work. We need to get up to 180 AMI to make it work. I mean, those are the kinds of discussion that, and maybe it's just because I've been doing this for a while. Those are the kinds of discussions that people come to me and, you know, they're pushing on me. Well, wait a minute, what's going to happen?
3:17:56 Okay, can I ask a question about the Bang the Table tool? Does that allow, I mean, once you guys have figured out the preliminary things you want feedback from, I'm assuming that that tool can be used to put out a conceptual, the initial conceptual drawings and go out to that tool? Yes, that's what we need. Yes. Okay, good, perfect. I think the sooner a conceptual drawing gets out there, then I think the level of, I would say, engagement.
3:18:23 Feedback will be our pointed feedback, however you want to describe it. Concrete feedback is going to be a much more, I would think, you know, impactful on staff and on the final decision on what's going to be, you know, the number of units and the roads and everything else. The sooner we get to that, and part of it is, you know, I think these things are good.
3:18:50 But I just think that, you know, I would love to see us break ground next spring. I mean, that you love. No, no, sure. Couldn't agree with you more. Couldn't agree with you more. If housing is a crisis, I don't want to see us go past next spring. No, no, I couldn't agree with you more. But one question, would it be possible at some point to get a sense of when these first...
3:19:13 Conceptual things might be available. That would be incredibly useful. And to start having a date, like a street date, from the consultant of when this first round of conceptual drawings could be available. I'm not holding it to you now, but these are the kinds of things that we could all really use to know, hey, July 1st or middle of June, we're going to have our first things, first stuff coming out of staff. Again, that helps us drive people to that.
3:19:40 To the, it's what's called Managing Mammoth, is that what it's going to be called? Engage Mammoth Lakes. Engage Mammoth Lakes for the parcel. I mean, that would be really helpful for us to know when you think it's going to happen. We can start driving people to it and that would be great. I think that's a good point because I have no idea when the discussion appropriately would be to have around zoning, density, income levels, all that. I mean, when does that, before we have the, I mean, where is that in the?
3:20:07 So I think what happens is we look at the, we develop those conceptual land use plans, kind of looking at all of these different things, looking at financing, looking at all of the current zoning, looking at the opportunities and the constraints of the site. So it's really kind of, it's all that information is going to those conceptual land use planning plans. And then once we have those, I think then we step back and we say, all right.
3:20:31 What needs to be done to make these happen? Ultimately, we would say with that final conceptual land use plan, the goal is to get a final conceptual land use plan and for staff to be able to analyze it and say, okay, what needs to be done to make this happen? Everyone agrees this is what we want for the site right now. So what needs to be done to make this happen? So again, given that if we use this bang the table tool,
3:20:56 That's a good way to get out to the public some initial ideas. I would really encourage staff working with the consultants to get the app. Don't get it fully developed. Don't get it fully baked. Get just the things that you want the public to start familiarizing themselves with. And let's try to get those things out as soon as we can. So it's not, oh, we figured it out. It looks like this. It's like, look, here's the parcel. This is what it looks like. Get those easy steps out there.
3:21:25 And then get something up online so we can start driving people so they get familiar with the process. I remember like the Darren Dinsmore things. I mean, it was good, but initially it was like, how the hell do I work this? And what is my feedback? How do I know that I'm putting these things in a computer that someone's actually responding to it? I mean, it's a trusting relationship that you have to build. Yes, yes. Well, I mean, what I feel is that there's so many...
3:21:47 Converging information points. You know, what's going on at the state? You know, what are grant funding available? You know, all of these things are converging, you know, simultaneously, and how do we begin to sort those out? What, before you even, you know, are really seriously looking at conceptual land use, what are available, I mean...
3:22:08 There's just, yeah, there's so many things to sort. There's so many things to sort. No, no, we've got to start doing, you've got to start building up to it. We've got to start building up to it. We have a needs assessment. We know we're going to need 600 units in 2025. And we also know the AMI of those. So we've got some really foundational pieces to...
3:22:33 To create a layout and say, and this is what's driving it. And then we can start looking at, wait a minute, we've got to modify because of the funding tools. Where is the Senate bill funding? Where's the infrastructure? All those things begin to drive it. But I think...
3:22:54 There's an educational process with the people out there that when you approach it just in this fashion, it's almost like there isn't some foundational pieces and I think it's schematic of what...
3:23:09 Going to be there so that they have and say, hey, no, no, no, no. We need some 180 AMI to subsidize the 60% AMI. I think the questions you also brought up about height. I mean, even conceptual massing. Density, your neighbors, setbacks, wetlands.
3:23:27 What are we going to do with the wetlands? I mean, all these different kinds of... I mean, you know all this stuff, but the way we start... I know staff has all... You know, staff is sensitive to all this. You just spelled it all out. But I'm trying to think about, you know, the public and its level of participation. And I'll be very blunt about it. Most of our, you know...
3:23:48 A part of our community, the Hispanic community, does not participate in a lot of these. So it is our business community that hires them that their feedback is critical, you know, because they're the ones that are actually in interaction with those folks. Most of them, you know, have two jobs, but they do qualify for, you know, the low and the very low rental units that Mammoth Lake Housing has.
3:24:16 I mean, it's all across the board, but I'm just being very blunt about this. Oh, sure. Because I think that will make us a successful project. A couple other sort of communication outlets I think that we need to still think about. One of them is printed media. I think there are a certain amount of people who rely greatly on their primary information coming out of print media.
3:24:44 And I think we talked before about maybe having a monthly column, which maybe coincides with the update to the council, even if we have to buy the space to do that, to kind of put in information, because people will gather that. And another thing is I think there are some people that listen to radio. And there was been an offer made to me a couple times to go in and talk to on the radio. I don't necessarily think I'm the best source of that, but perhaps someone from the town might be.
3:25:13 To go in and, you know, agree to be asked some questions, give some answers, and there will be other people that listen to that. And I think those are maybe two other. Yeah, they're the regular, the community corners, the A shows that happen every week. I mean, that's free. They're always hungry to get people in to do that. I think the print thing is great because, again, from the branding perspective, if nothing else, to start getting a visualization to get something in the papers in color, oh, yeah, I'm getting this in my brain. Again, a QR code, take it to the site.
3:25:42 Yeah, so I think there's maybe a couple other ways to, and after that, you know, Sandra's going to learn how to Instagram that she said today. She's all over it. She's really excited. Awesome, sister. Is that little graphics kit and we all got a little thing we're all putting on our accounts? Mm-hmm. Driving people to the site? I mean, Facebook is evil, but it still exists, unfortunately, so I don't, you know. Yeah. Yeah, but it's own site rather than just clicked off the town, but it's own.
3:26:12 You know, Mammoth Lakes Parcel or however we want to name it. We are buying web addresses now so that we can direct it. It's still directed land and the right in the same place, but at least we can have some. So we're working on buying those web addresses now. Thank you so much for the update and keeping this like in the forefront of our minds. Any more questions or comments? Just real quick, any questions or comments for us?
3:26:40 No, I think we, the June 26th, the only kind of outstanding question was about the date, and I think we're good with that. Okay. And the date for the charrette and the date for the meeting? No, the date for the joint town council. Yeah. With PDC. And once, and we'll ask the council about the charrette week. Right. So it's in August, and I can't remember. I think we're looking at either the first or the third week of August. Okay. For that charrette week. Yeah, let's get that booked. And I am going to ask for public comment.
3:27:11 On the subject, seeing none, we will go ahead and adjourn this meeting. Thank you very much, everyone, to our next meeting on May 15th at 4 p.m. Thank you very much.