Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2019
Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board
· recording 2 hr 2 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
255 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:35 We'll call the June board meeting for Mammoth Lakes Tourism to order at 1-0-2. Angela, would you mind doing a roll call? Scott McGuire. Present. Brent Turuax. Here. John Morris. Here. Sean Turner. Hello. Kirk Schaubmeyer. Michael Ledesma. Here. Mayor Cleland-Hoff. Here. Eric Clark. Here. And Rhonda Dugan. Here. Thank you. All right. So we'll begin with
3:06 welcoming our newest seated board member. Rhonda, welcome to the MLT board. Nice to see you on this side after spending a lot of meetings in the audience. Appreciate your commitment to this. Want to go around with any board member comments? Mr. Truax, you want to start on this side? It's simple. My last meeting as a full board, unless something happens to show up at MLT, sorry, the town council meeting and advocate for anything, but...
3:38 It's been a pleasure and it's funny how eight years goes by very quickly. It's funny, it's kind of like raising kids. You look around one minute and you say, wow, they're six and then they're 12. Yeah, how'd that happen? But no, I feel very good about where this board's going and looking forward to the future. Doesn't mean I'm stepping and hiding away from anything. Don't anybody get any delusions that I'm just quietly in the sunset.
4:06 And likewise, this is my last full board meeting. It's been a pleasure and I'm stepping off essentially to concentrate on bigger, better things that likewise will be tourism oriented. I just want to say thanks to you guys for serving the board for as long as you did. You guys have both been here for longer terms than I have and your commitment to the board and the committees and so forth over the years has been amazing. And this group and this...
4:36 This board wouldn't be where it is without the both of you guys. I know you both very personally and see you offline a ton, so I know it's not a teary goodbye in that sense, but I certainly, for one, will miss both of you at our meetings. Thank you. I just like the fact that Sean told me I get free beer the rest of my life. What? You just have to drive to Reno to get it.
5:03 Mr. Morris? Oh, likewise. Thanks, guys. It's been a pleasure. Now you're making me feel really old on this board. I just want to say that the Snow Creek Golf Course will open a week from Friday. I know Sierra Star is opening. Sorry to steal your thunder. Sierra Star is opening on this Friday, but Snow Creek will open Friday the 14th. Driving range is open. We have passes for sale, and everything looks absolutely fantastic now that...
5:30 The snows have finally melted, so I hope everybody comes out and plays some rounds this year. Indeed. Sierra Star is opening tomorrow or Friday. The greens look great. They're in the best shape they've been in in many years, and we did a couple things differently, so we're really pleased with that. But that being said, after a big year, they're always in pretty good shape because they're covered and they're protected, so great to see.
5:56 Back to you, you gentlemen. Thank you very much for your service. Our community has benefited from it and appreciate it very much. Thank you. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm just trying to find the agenda here. You know what? Thank you so much. You know, I haven't even completed my first year on the board and thank you for all your patience and getting me up to speed and just really working to get MLT working in a great direction. I'm really pleased with
6:28 everything, and no small part to you guys, so I wish you the best of luck, and I know I'm going to see you guys around, so that's good as well. Thank you. I won't take it personally that you're leaving while I'm coming. I have one comment, if you wouldn't mind. Sure, I'll save my comments. We have an agenda item related to you guys, so I'll save my comments for that time.
6:56 Glad to see that summer decided to show up in the last couple days. Hopefully it sticks around. It's nice to actually sweat for the first time in a long time just because it's warm outside, so hopefully this stays. To that note, if people haven't seen it, the plows are up on Lake Mary Road to go up into the lake's basin. They've been going all morning. Started first thing this morning when Dakota went up there. I think they were up at Lake Mary already. So moving right along, obviously there's some good ice underneath that'll need to melt out, but at least they're getting the...
7:23 Five to ten foot drifts out of the way, which is amazing. The photos are crazy. So definitely check out our Instagram and Facebook to see where the progress is. But there's a lot of snow up there. I was thinking in the choice of swinter as our term that it has definitely been far more winter than spring. The appropriate values in there. We'll move on to public comment. If you have public comment, please make sure you state your name and your organization and keep your comments to under three minutes.
7:58 Real quick, I want to, Ken Bringle with the Executive Director of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. I wanted to bring up Curtis Shapiro. He's our new Workforce Housing Coordinator. Started on Monday. And he's already got it all figured out. So we're going to solve all those problems right away. But no, we're excited to have him on board. And he's a local.
8:26 He was born and raised here in Mammoth and gone for a while but is back and let's just say a few words. Yeah, I'm happy to join the Commerce and it's a great team. I'm really excited to be part of it and I can't wait to support the community and give back as much as I can. Welcome aboard. Thanks. Nice to meet you all. Anyone else? Hi there, Pamela, the Executive Director for the High Sierra Energy Foundation. Hi, I'm Leah Webb, also with the High Sierra Energy Foundation, the Green Business Coordinator.
9:03 So while we're providing public comment today, there's an integral relationship between sustainability and tourism, specifically placing high value on natural resources, which are a focal part of our local tourism economy. Protecting and communicating the importance of these natural resources key to our economic, environmental, and social sustainability, and that's what brought the Heiser Energy Foundation
9:28 to seek seed funding and start a green business program to support this message and highlight those businesses who are taking action in this arena. So Leah, I'll give you a little brief overview of the program. Yeah, so I've met many of you all through the business community and I just wanted to reiterate this program is a statewide verifiable online program and some of you are aware of that because you've started your own certification process. We look at energy, water efficiency,
9:56 conservation, pollution prevention, sustainable commuting, waste management, and also such measures as doing green business or doing business with other green businesses and local vendors as well. Also adhering to your own environmental policy statement that folks write for their own business. And this is part of a, so I think there's 34 programs statewide, over 4,000 businesses certified.
10:24 And there's now 12,000 businesses in the network because other states have joined. So we have a huge network. All available. Oh, do I have to talk on this? All available. I'm tall, so. You can stand. It's fine. It'll pick up your voice. You just need to be near it. Okay. It's all available with a simple click on your iPhone via Shop Green app. So you have access to local businesses and the 12,000 businesses across six states.
10:54 And I'm happy to share that with any of you. What do I do as the Green Business Coordinator? I provide free technical assistance, one-on-one businesses that might not otherwise have these types of techniques and expertise built into their businesses because they're small and they're just maybe, you know, one-owner type situation. We provide lots of marketing and promotion for the green business through the network and locally.
11:23 And we also provide a green marketplace for the consumers, which a recent study, 66% of, was it, global respondents, and 75% of millennials are actually willing to spend more to support products and services from companies that are committed to positive social and environmental impacts. So that's really great for the green economy. I also wanted to comment, what I've learned is we have,
11:53 Locally, we have a huge valuable identity with our green businesses, and this builds loyalty to Mammoth Lakes when people engage with those green businesses. It's a really valuable asset, so I was just here to share that with you guys today. So in closing, we'd like to have a larger conversation with the board about the program in more details and be placed on agenda for a future meeting.
12:19 Hear from you individually or from a designated employee to consider your own businesses being certified and to direct MLT staff to put a priority on MLT office, the office becoming certified, which should be a fairly easy lift and would show leadership in this area. Just a brief question. I know that you guys, with interest, if you have the 34 different communities, if we were able to have you come back, would you be able to tell us how our communities stack against, say, the Tahoes or the other?
12:48 areas as far as percentage of business and how we're trending. I know that Blue got certified and it's the first restaurant here, but do other communities have 50% of their restaurants? It's interesting, of all the other programs until just this last round of funding, Sierra Business Council also sought out the grant and the seed funding. They're all run by municipalities, either counties or cities. We were like the first non-profit that just said, you know, if we want this to happen.
13:16 We're going to take action and we're just going to do it ourselves and hope to gain some leverage and at that point then can go to counties, cities, water districts, potentially MLT, other stakeholders to fund this program to go forward. So Sierra Business Council just started this. We were the first mountain town, so they're just getting their program kicked off. And so we wouldn't have a comparable kind of example at this point. Okay.
13:45 Nice for me to lead. We can provide some data, though. We'd be happy, you know, if you have, if we are on the agenda, we're happy to, you know, if you have specific questions that you want us to include in the presentation, we'd be happy to look at that. San Francisco's program's been going on for 10 years, so they have a huge network, and it would be hard to necessarily compare. But we also have the ability to generate local reports on how much greenhouse gas savings we're already generating, so that's what the program does, is they really don't dial down to how many types of businesses. You're just,
14:15 Looking at how, what is the greenhouse gas savings by what we're doing locally. We can share that with you. Many of the measures, how much water is saved, how much energy is saved, I mean, and that's the best thing. When I wanted to start a program, it's like I wanted to do it with very, very verifiable results, and this California Green Business Network, just because of their longevity and putting the resources into building a really robust database, has all of that. So it's, when we, you know, it's not greenwash, it's like you can actually go and see what your savings are.
14:45 Thank you. Any other public comment? So the next up is the minutes. So we have both the approval of the May 7th board meeting minutes. We'll go through that first. And then there's the second approval for the special meeting minutes. I make a motion to approve the minutes from the May 7th meeting. Second. Any conversation? Yeah, I have a question that may lead to a suggestion of change. But because I wasn't here, reading through the minutes,
15:16 On page four of five, underneath the speaking from the floor, second paragraph, there was mention of the destination management plan being tabled. Then in the next paragraph, the third paragraph of that section, there was mention of funding being provided for that of $250,000. So reading through it, I was a little confused whether it got tabled or whether it actually got funded and we're moving ahead.
15:46 I'll give you the update. Both. So what happened was we tabled it as an organization. Last council meeting, we went to council to say that we wanted council to take up the drive on it and set the policy direction with it. And we suggested carving out $250,000 from the tours in reserve. What was decided was we didn't need to carve anything out, but just that it was a priority and that the money's there. So there was nothing allocated. So there'll be, I'm hoping council comes back to those.
16:15 in the next month or so with some plans and updates and then saying whether it's a $100,000 program or what coming from that tourism reserve. So we tabled it from this board in the sense that we wanted to get further direction from the town council? Yeah. At this point, I think the better way to say it is that we've turned the project over to council.
16:36 to provide the direction, and then we're willing to be part of the process as needed, but it's really- Maybe that's what we update in the minutes. Yeah, the ball is in council support to drive that program. Okay. Andrew, would you be able to make that note on the minutes on paragraph two, the clarification that the tabling of the destination marketing plan, that the correct term should be that the destination marketing plan was redirected to town council? So with that amendment, does your motion still stand?
17:08 Yes. In the second? Second stands. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Okay. One abstention. Glad to hear it's going forward. That would be at the discretion of council. Yeah. It sounds like that that is... Okay. And then we had the... We had the special board meeting of May 10th in the minutes from that meeting, which is predominantly a closed session. Do we have any questions about that meeting or those minutes?
17:38 Make a motion to approve as distributed. Second. Okay. Any conversation? All in favor? Aye. Thank you. So new business. John, you want to take us through the first part? And while you're doing that, this is our outgoing board member recognition. And I think that Paul is not here. And I think we understand why that is. But I know the commitment that you guys have made to this organization over time.
18:08 And that for a variety of reasons, when people lose their seats or give up their seats for whatever reason, it's a big shift. And I think that the mark that you guys have made on the community through this organization is pretty spectacular. And I know the time and the amount of hours and commitment that went into being here. I deeply appreciate that, especially the foundation that you've put into the organization for the last several years and look forward to it continuing on that foundation going forward. Thank you. Thank you. Yeah, much appreciated. I think the organization has definitely benefited from
18:38 your experience and bringing that to the board. So just as a small thank you, we have a piece to take with you and enjoy. Well, all right, thank you very much. Wow. Who's the photographer? These are all Vern Clevenger. Thanks. Great. Let me get this pen. What was that how you get this pen? Golden pencil. So, your backyard, so. Thank you. Absolutely.
19:13 We need to get a picture of you guys holding those. Okay. We'll do that at the end. How's that? That would be great. Thank you. And we will present Paul with his. Paul is in Phoenix right now. Committee updates. So I'll go through the first, which is the town contract committee. And what I'd like to do is I know we have Jeremy's going to be seated next month. We'll have a retail seat coming on board. But I would like to try and get.
19:48 two other people or at least one other person on the town contract. Eric, I know you've been gone, but as we go into this next phase, I want to make sure that we always have at least two board members available. I don't know what your schedule's like over the next couple weeks. If you're still around and interested in staying on part of that committee, but I'd like to try and get one more board member at this meeting that can commit to being on that committee as well. Happy to continue, indeed. And just early next week, I'm out of time.
20:17 Okay. Obviously, Cleveland, you're already as a representative from the town. Is anyone else keen on being on the committee? We're close on this, so maybe I'll give you an update so you know how far we are on the contracts. What exactly does this mean? They're really good meetings, actually, so it's not scary. They are. They tend to be long, but it's good. So where we're at this point is we're, I would say,
20:43 Almost 100% on the boilerplate language for the terms of the contract. It's gone back and forth between our attorney and Andy Morris, the town's attorney. So the goal is to have that done. At our last session, we discussed the scope of services and change from the prior contract is that the scope of services, we decided we would simplify the scope of services and do effectively what we determined as five buckets, which is one is...
21:07 Access and Transportation Awareness, so the marketing of things like air service, air service promotion, regional mobility, in-town transportation. So there's a bucket around that. And then Section C, or Section Exhibit B, would be the specific deliverables in that scope of services. So to try and simplify it for the next four years of the contract.
21:27 That's one bucket. The other bucket is specifically on the brand and community awareness. So that was brand voice, the community, domestic and international marketing, multi-season opportunities, sustainable visitation, the destination draw, like the recreation of the business community or the events that happen here, regional partnerships, public relations. And so the idea is that we would have these scopes of services and that each year there would be deliverables that tied into those scopes of services, but not every bullet point of the scope of services would have.
21:57 specific deliverable every year. So the scope of services would craft the general intent of the relationship and then each year we would have a specific set of deliverables from council going forward. Does that make sense? So then we had experiences and attractions was one of the buckets. So that's about event promotion, event development and support, activity promotion, talking about the diverse opportunities for recreation and experiences in the community, giving people reasons to visit.
22:26 So on and so forth. And then we had kind of two different channels around communication in market, which is the in market communication that's B2C, business to consumers. So things like wayfinding, maps, visitor guides, all that communication once the customer's here. And then a B2B component, which is really around the marketing education programs, local spending programs, how the organization specifically communicates to the business community that's part of TBID, part of the tourism industry. So those are the kind of five buckets.
22:56 In general, from the committee, John and I, who were there last time, felt like that was a decent scope of services. Town is going to take a look at that and come back, and then we'd be able to say, okay, now here are the specific deliverables. So that's really what that next committee meeting is going to be about, is which deliverables for the very first year tie specifically back to those exhibits, to the scope of services. Any questions on that? Okay.
23:27 Anyone find themselves with some free time to go sit in a room for four hours and go through a lot of legalese? Three hours. Three hours. Three hours. Okay. I do think right now it's putting the deliverables, the metrics, the deliverables at this point. I think most of it has been agreed upon, or at least in general. Yeah, so that'll be the real part, just getting the deliverables done and getting that signed off. Because with the process, as I understand it, is that the committee will work on some deliverables.
23:57 with Town. Town will review those, and then it'll come back to this board and then to Council, both of which have to agree on any amendments to come back together and change those amendments. It would come here for approval, then it'll go to Council for approval. I nominate Rhonda. You don't have the practice of the board member that's not in attendance. Okay. Thank you. Newbie.
24:31 Roped in. Vote for the person that's not in. We're going to add Kirk because he's not here. It was a good effort. Okay. And then the bylaws committee. So the bylaws committee was led by Paul. I don't think that it ever actually met. I would love to have someone that wanted to step into the bylaws, having gone through them for 2013. I don't think there's how often they've been looked at recently, but they're...
25:02 Probably pretty well thought through now at this point in time. I've made a number of comments in there, so I think I've got a good basis for people. They were last done in 2013. That's less critical, so I feel more comfortable with the bylaws. We can wait until the other seats are in and see if... I was going to do it the other way. Since I'm leaving, I was going to say that Mr. Goyko, who's coming on board, is a very organized individual who stays focused and gets things done. You're going to...
25:31 You're going to nominate the chamber seat to be on the committee and then vacate the seat. Jeremy, are you seeing how this works before you even come on the board? Okay. Well, we can table, I think, the addition to that one for the next meeting because it's not as critical because we have functioning there. I think with town and the contract, to be clear, from what we understand from the town prior, the organization does not get Mejuri funding unless a contract is in place. So there is definitely a time.
26:00 Critical nature where we have functioning bylaws now that if it's another 60 days because we're waiting for new people to get seated, I think that's fine. Duly noted though on the incoming seat. Jeremy's rethinking this. No, he's not. He's done it. He does an excellent job on the chamber board. Got it. Retail board seat.
26:31 I don't know if you guys want to comment on the retail board seat. We had three applicants that came in. We had Matt Hammer from Black Velvet Coffee and Shelter. We had Anita Westfall from Outdoor 365. And we had, I forget Patricia's last name. Vanders. Vanders, thank you, from Red Lily. So we interviewed Matt and we interviewed Patricia. Anita was unavailable after she sent her initial...
27:01 Interest email, and we didn't get a follow-up on either a CV or more of a detailed letter, and then when we finally did get in touch with her Monday, she was unavailable to be interviewed between now, between that time and here. So the committee met and talked and said, look, she's really busy and we understand, but it didn't feel like we should wait to seat the retail position for another interview.
27:26 And so went forward with the two interviews that we had and have a recommendation based off of that. In the minutes, it referenced that there was just one applicant prior to the May 8th deadline. That's correct. So it's a good question. So what happened on the May 8th deadline, we had that at the last board meeting and realized that for a variety of different reasons, our press release that went out to tell people that there was a deadline did not get published in either paper.
27:53 And so Laura asked if we could extend that deadline by a week so that we could re-push it through the chamber and make sure it went back out, trying to be very cautious that we didn't want anyone to feel like, oh, well, you didn't publish it, so you set a deadline. So we extended by a week. I think there were several board members who were really active in going out and asking people. I probably talked to a dozen people and a lot of I'm too busy. So we ended up with only the three applicants. Two, really.
28:23 I mean, I think it needed, she generally expressed interest, but she was on vacation, came back, was busy, then was sick, and so we said was that I would take her application in interest, and we'd bring it to the committee, and then the committee review it, and we'd bring it to the board that she had expressed interest, but understanding the time commitments didn't seem like it was viable. Any other comments on that? No, not on that. You expressed that perfectly.
28:54 You guys want to talk about the interviews? They were both in the last 48 hours. Yeah, I'd like to make comments. One of the things that was great about it is both applicants were excellent, very articulate, and I think either one of them would be great additions to this board. For me personally, I felt that what connected the best to me was Matt's vision of the future of the town.
29:23 I think he articulated that to me in a way that I feel like his addition to this board will help push this board in a positive direction. Not that Patricia wouldn't, but that he really articulated it well and seemed to have the energy and the drive to help make that happen. And to me, that was really the subtle difference between the two.
29:43 So I leaned in that direction. But again, both applicants seem very articulate, very knowledgeable about what we're doing here. And I think either one of them would have been good. I just felt lucky to be able to talk with them for an extended time and find out I wasn't familiar with either one of them and their businesses. So it was actually very informative. But I do think that for me,
30:13 Matt will be a really good fit for MLT moving forward in the future, and his energy and his enthusiasm for what he's getting into, I think he's got a pretty good idea of what it's going to entail, and so it was wonderful, and I don't think Patricia's here.
30:41 I certainly hope that she stays involved with everything as well because fascinating gal. So that was really nice. That was pretty telling in the interview that there was quite a bit of consistency between both of them and their inputs about feeling like education into the TBID payees about what TBID does, more business and community outreach on behalf of the organization into that business would be beneficial. I think this is something that's come up time and again.
31:11 One of the things that in the conversation, trying to think of how to paraphrase it on behalf of them, in speaking with Patricia, she's, the way I understood it, she said that she's been interested in trying to do more in town, interested in being more in the community, and quite literally I knocked on her door and she's like, oh, this could be something that would be that fit.
31:33 Matt was really pointed when he came to the meeting that he'd been thinking about it a lot. He spent the last year thinking about where he wants to get involved in the community and what he wants that to be. And that after that long consideration, he was very specific that the one place he wanted to put his energy was MLT. So I think they were both very interested in community engagement, but Matt being very specific, saying this is the organization where he wanted to dedicate that time and put forth that effort. So based on that, you can get it. The committee would recommend Matt Hammer for the retail seat.
32:06 Any questions or conversations? I have a couple questions. I don't know if you guys have anything, but I guess my first question is more of a comment. And I don't know if I'm on my own on this one or what, but it would be really helpful, I think, to have a more in-depth briefing of this process prior to the actual meeting, whether it's an incumbent or it's a vacancy, just because this is great dialogue, but it's not nearly enough.
32:33 to make an educated decision for those of us that weren't on the nominating committee. So that's my comment. Just for future stuff, I don't even know one of the candidates at all. One of the other candidates I know very well and I'm a huge supporter of personally and professionally. But it would be great to have all that information in front of me in depth so I could make a more educated decision. And then the second, the question I have is how much emphasis are we putting on the definition of the seat?
33:02 In other words, John Morris is our lodging seat. That makes sense to me. He runs a hotel, property management, and so forth. Are both candidates squarely in the definition of the seat is retail, correct? Correct. So that's my question. What is the definition of retail seat? Do both candidates fit clearly into that box of what the definition of the retail seat is?
33:31 With respect to what the representation is going to be to that seat's constituents. I think it's a good point. So a couple things. So in order to be able to have the retail seat, you have to have a retail business license in the town of Mammoth Lakes. Okay. So that's one component. So I think similar to it with Sean, where you have a beer, food, liquor license, and then also a retail component of that. That's where Matt comes in. Both of them have businesses that are...
33:59 Smaller percentages of their business of retail compared to their business. So a lot of what Patricia does is weddings and events where she's doing large, relatively high dollar flower arrangements and the like for weddings. So someone walking into her store and buying an item and walking out of her store with that item is far less of her business than what she does on the flower business. Same with Matt. So Matt said I think roughly 20% of his business is the retail. So he distributes coffee.
34:29 So they make and distribute coffee and alcohol through their two different businesses, and then they sell goods. And his retail business is about 20% of his business in both locations compared to the other side of it. That's why I think there was a pretty active engagement of going out and looking through the retail list and contacting people that were traditional, kind of more like an Anita that have a standalone, single, all I do is buy a good and then sell it to another person, traditional retail.
34:56 I think it would have been nice to have had more of that engagement. It's quite interesting that not, with the exception of Anita, not one single person that fit that traditional lens came forward and expressed interest. So that becomes a question. Yeah, clearly Anita's Outdoors 395, 365, I'm sorry, is a bullseye for retail. Correct. But these other two candidates, they're not a bullseye, but they're in the circle. Yeah, they do sell.
35:25 They do have a retail business license, they do sell retail, very similar to where Sean was with his organization, in both the wholesale, retail, distribution, and then also being a purveyor in the store. So it would be, I guess, probably similar to, to put Jeremy on the spot, like, yeah, like, where it's like, you know, the percentage of your business that is more rental versus retail, but there's still a sales transaction component of that. Do you want to ask a question? Yeah, that answered it clearly.
35:59 Scott, as you look forward to working with the bylaws here and just noticing the definition is vague for a point for a reason because it does allow for emerging businesses and it'll come through because what if you have a retail business that doesn't have a storefront and things so that's good but there is some opportunity within the bylaws to
36:23 further defined a little bit more about these businesses. So especially when you have crossovers. And I think in a community of this size and businesses of this size, crossover is definitely going to be where a lot of this lives there. So that would be probably a good place when you're looking at the bylaws to continue to define that a little bit more. Good note. Are you on that committee? I'd like this. Oh wait, not yet.
36:51 Oh, and what Michael said. I agree that to your first point, Michael, that I, you know, I've been on the nominating committee for a while in several different terms, and I think it would be a good idea if we could give a little more information to the board members prior to the meeting, just a little bit of a breakdown of our conversations and a little more background. So we're really just not putting people on the spot to make a snap decision on something that, I mean, I know they trust us as a committee, but it's nice to have an informed decision. So I think that would, that would help.
37:20 And it probably wouldn't, you know, if it wouldn't be too complicated. I think probably the way to do that going forward would be to have the letter of intent and then a summary of the interview shared out ahead of time. Preferably in the future we'd actually be able to have that interview completed within the timeline of posting something for us. I would just suggest it, you know, it always seems, to me it always seems like we butt up against the deadline.
37:45 So maybe we need to start the process. I mean, if it, you know, if we're talking about July 1st, maybe we need to start it in March. I mean, I know that's early, but maybe that's when we need to start posting things. Or maybe, I don't know when we did. I think it was April when we posted the... Well, this one's kind of unique. Well, yeah. Thanks to our friend Sean over here. We can throw that at Sean's first. Sean this time. Anyway. If possible. Something like that. Anyway. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Any other...
38:16 Comments or discussion? Is there a concern around a person that's not in a traditional brick and mortar seat? No, it was equally as much as this decision as it is in future decisions. If I'm considering not running for a third term in my terms a year away, so who would I consider a recruit from the community for that? I think one of the first people that comes to mind is Camille Miller. But I wondered,
38:47 Is she retail or is she restaurant? Could she fit into the restaurant? She probably fits in that the same way on the opposite spectrum because she's 20% of her revenue. I would say that she could absolutely fill the restaurant seat. Is it better to have somebody that's in the bullseye of that circle, I suppose? Joni Schaller, if it comes to mind.
39:11 You know, yeah, but what you're saying is if those people aren't interested, you go out to the next circle and the next circle. And is there a point, though, where let's say I couldn't be the lodging seat because I just don't. Right.
39:26 Osmosis doesn't cut it. You're located below larger. I work in the village. I stayed at a Holiday Inn Express. But anyways, no, you clarified that nicely, and Rhonda's comments too, so I'm good to go there. And the candidate that you guys, I don't honestly know the other candidate at all, and I'm very familiar with Mr. Hammers, personally and professionally, so it's a no-brainer there. Okay.
39:56 He's ready to vote. Do you have a motion on accepting the committee's recommendation? I move we accept a nominating committee recommendation to elect Matt to our board. I second. Okay, all in favor? Aye. I abstain. One abstention. Wise carries. And that will be a three-year seat starting July 1. Three-year seat starting July 1. All right. Yeah.
40:26 And when we go to our board and executive committee elections next month and when we start talking about our bylaws, I have some suggestions around the pacing of our timing, about when seats get seated and how they shift. We can go into it that time, but I think there's some things there where, given this change where this three-year seat came up earlier, it could work to our advantage where basically roughly every year we'd be seating.
40:55 Two to three seats. And that kind of creates this flow so that the overlapping at-large seats, the overlapping lodging seats, the retail seat, the restaurant seat, and when they happen, make sure that there's always, unless there's a resignation, there should always be six consistent board members every year. Because right now there's a place where like more leave come in. This kind of looking at it made it pretty straightforward to look at how those all line up.
41:26 Timing-wise. Okay. Next item. Staff holiday update, you want to talk? Yes, something we've actually talked about for a couple years now, and I wanted to make sure we got it on the agenda here, was to link MLT to the municipal staff federal holidays. Currently, we have five total. We've got Christmas Day, Thanksgiving Day, New Year's Day, and then we have two floating holidays. And I think in general, we're typically looking at federal holidays, maybe 12 days.
41:59 Including weeks like 4th of July, which we actually worked because of the parade, but Labor Day, Memorial Day, and the like. And the request would be to add those in for the staff. I think right now, while it might be your busiest times of the year in your restaurants or lodging properties, it's actually the slowest time for us because of the fact that we don't have the phone calls, we don't have the activity answering questions from folks on those days. All of our work is done by the time we get to President's Week. So, current request.
42:30 We also have challenges with staff, with kids, obviously, having school days off. We all have challenges with kids and staff, and I live that every day. My challenge is, I live, as you said, John, the other side of this. This is where I work, and I'm not having Christmas off in the last 20 years. It frames a portion of my head. It's a different business. It is a different business, but I also have a sales organization that reports to me as well.
42:55 I'm not a big fan of this. I'd rather have more flexibility in terms of PTO days. It's not the number of days. It's just when we're taking those holidays off, it's just a strict portion and they're off and then offices are closed and I just have a mental image of that. I'm not against the number of days and having flexible days and someone could take the day after Christmas if it happens to be a Sunday or whatever. That's not my issue. It's just those days sometimes are our busy days. It's the 4th of July. It's a big event and a lot of activities.
43:25 Just a clarifying point, because John and I had talked about this prior, which was that the idea of having 12 days mimics town and other organizations' standard holidays. And so it's not necessarily that every single staff member is going to be off on Labor Day or the 4th of July. It's that we would recognize that there are 12 paid holidays, but that if it is the Monday of President's Day and there are only two key staff that need to be there, those two key staff would be there that day.
43:54 And the rest of the staff would have that day off, and they would be able to take that as a day later. So carry that next step forward. If we designate those as holidays, that means I'm going to pay double time for a holiday, that or not? See, I'm a business person. For me, I have to pay double time. So am I having to pay that as a staff? I hope the staff knows I'm not trying to...
44:18 Take my way, I'm just trying to be fair in terms of what we do and where we're going, but I just had a vision of, okay, office is closed July 4th, anybody tries to call, okay, not so much what you explained, Scott, in terms of somebody there, just trying to, in my head, I visioned that the office is closed and nobody's there. Do you have what the proposed impact on the budget is in your, to be a part of employee benefits? As far as the... How would this change the budget that you proposed? It doesn't change the budget at all. It's all factored into pay.
44:50 The wages of the wages for 365. But as you said, it's going to be different costs. If you have all full-time employees that are not hourly. So there's no liability. In that statement, there's no liability to the holidays. So if you don't take it, you don't get it. No, that's not correct. I think what we're saying is if you...
45:14 If you don't take it, you would be able to take that day. So if you had to work Christmas Day because of something going on, you would be able to take that as a comp day at a later date that was appropriate. So the idea is that if you then resign and you haven't taken it, does it get paid out?
45:31 Is it accrued PTO? So there is. Some days are treated separately in a couple of laws, so you have to be careful there. That's why it's PTO, you pay it. That's DeRonda's question. Yeah, that there are costs in here. Also, I appreciate that it's part of the municipality, but this is also an NGO, but dedicated, to your point, tourism.
45:58 and the optics of this. I think I'm a little concerned about what are they doing in South Lake Tahoe, in Reno, those visitors boards in North Lake Tahoe. I appreciate that your staff doesn't all have responsibilities and duties as the rest of us seem to.
46:19 Take whether we have it or not. But do you have any comparisons for what they're doing there? Or are they aligned with the municipalities? I don't have that. I can look into that. I think after the nine years that I've been here, I think when we have been working the Labor Days and the Memorial Days, it's pretty much we're in the office and catching up on things or cleaning up our offices. It's not like we have people beating down the doors or even constituents calling us because you're too busy.
46:49 To further that comparison question, what is the actual amount? Is it vacation or is it PTO? And what does the team currently accrue? Does that match the town as well? So how much time is accrued and how many days are earned for the staff currently through their vacation?
47:16 Depends on their service. So you start at 15 days of vacation time? Start at 15 days. And you approve the three holidays, the two floaters, and that's it. There's no comp time, there's no other. So right now it's 20 days. Correct. And you're proposing to go to, for starting, you would add seven. So you'd add 27. Correct. Yeah.
47:46 What does town staff start at as far as PTO? PTO, I believe, well, again, I think it depends on the levels. I know that the managers in the town have a total of 47 days off a year, and that includes 11 days of administrative leave, that includes all the holidays. 47 days? 47 days? And that grows. And then they have vacation on top of that? No, that's all part of that. Oh, okay.
48:12 But I guess I'm asking, what do they start with? Again, I don't know what the base level employees start at versus the directors. I think the directors are at 47 days. I don't know what the person that works at the front desk gets. Just chiming in with what Rhonda and Brent said, I kind of think that even though it's maybe not the job, it's, I think, pretty important. If it's tourism, that's when we have the most tourist year.
48:41 Are the holidays? You know, 30 years, I don't think I have not worked a holiday. So I do think perception-wise, it's kind of very difficult in town not to have champions who are out there, you know, in any capacity. I guess my question would be, are we going to go work front desks and serve?
49:02 serves our guests. I mean, I've been on both sides. Yeah, I mean, that's like... And I understand, I've been on both sides. I've been on both sides for 30 years. I get the idea of working seven days a week for Christmas.
49:12 This is a different entity. I hear on this board all the time that, you know, tourists, tourists, they're the ones that are giving us our bread and butter. If they're so important, I wouldn't want to be out of the office on that day. I would want to be out of the field that day. In nine years, I've talked to probably 12 tourists on any of those given days coming to our office. Yeah, but that could be like a you thing. I mean, like, maybe you're not in your office. You're out and about. No, I'm just saying, you know, don't get your hackles up. It's just like...
49:42 Matter of fact, and I know you're there a lot on those days currently. I think it's more of an overall package. You know, what are we offering in terms of, because certainly if somebody wants to take Memorial Day, they can take a vacation day and take Memorial Day weekend, right? I mean, they have 15 days they can use.
50:02 So looking at the overall compensation package I think is where we should evaluate this and not just evaluate it on whether they're working on that holiday or not. That's a good point. Yeah. That's a great point. Well, it's so great we switched to the PTO. I mean, granted, it's a little different because we're a seven, like most businesses, we're seven days a week. 365, we never close. And we switched to a PTO model.
50:32 15 years ago, 20 years ago maybe, and it works great. I mean, we do staff our office seven days a week, so it's a little bit different, but PTO system works really well because it is a rolling system, it is easy to account for, you know, you know how much time you've accrued at any given time, and you can, you know, with the executive director or the manager's approval, you can schedule your time off as it need be, whether it's Memorial Day or whether it's Christmas or whatever.
51:01 So personally, I would be more in favor of that sort of a model rather than, you know, and John, I completely understand what you're saying and some, certainly some businesses probably are dead as can be on Christmas Day, but that being said... Take a vacation day. Yeah, take a vacation day and if it needs, you know, if you need to do a lottery system or however it works and one person is the unlucky sucker that has to be there on Christmas Day manning the ship, well...
51:28 That's pretty much what every business in this town does, I think. So, I mean, I personally would be more in favor of that. I actually think it's easier to manage. I really do. I was hesitant when we went to that system because we used to close for holidays some days and it has been a very, very easy system to manage. So, personally, I'm more in favor of a PTO schedule. Can I summarize some direction back? What's that? Yeah. So, what I hear to summarize direction back to John is that
51:57 The board is open to hearing input on changing the employee manual with vacation days, but would like to see those vacation days commensurate with other similar organizations, not just the town of Mammoth Lakes, with the consideration that it is not a carte blanche that the 12 holidays are always off, but that it may be a consideration that an increase in either PTO or vacation time could be considered by looking at others. So the task would be to come back to the board with
52:25 benchmarks of other organizations and some recommendations around that. And I heard also clear, sorry, just to finish up on that, while there may not be people in the office, I do think that from an optic standpoint, from what I heard from the organization, is that MLT having people in field, even if it's not in office, and being present on those key holidays is, sounds like it's something that should be considered in the value of that versus
52:55 Saying that everyone, and I know what it's like to have to work on weekends. I also know that staff is putting in a lot of hours and a lot of weekends. So I think that somewhere in between, here's all the holidays that are definitely off, and here's a way to, you know, you cover that event, I'll cover this event, which I know is already happening organically, but being able to systemize it in the employee handbook. That's what I heard.
53:16 And when we get there, Scott, just as portion, California law is pretty specific in terms of, if not pick on Emily, if all of a sudden John calls Emily on her day off, she's now working. You've got to be careful because you also pull somebody to employment that we need to make sure we're paying correctly. Even if she's not off that day, John starts sending emails, she's now on duty, and there's a certain requirement to pay a certain number of hours for that time. So just want to make sure we're clean on how we do that.
53:40 And also just to clarify, my staff and myself are 24-7. I mean, we're always on, always answering, always answering questions. I've always felt that. Yeah. We're never not available. Okay. Want to walk through budget? Yeah. The attachments that you have for this month are the ones that we have made adjustments to. So when we are approving the budget, we have V1 of the TBID budget, which we have not made any changes to from a financial standpoint.
54:15 We did have some historical information that we updated. We also had just some clarification steps, but the numbers are all the same. So what we were looking to approve here is both the TBID but also the Measure A budget. What you had attached was the revised Measure A budget, which included removing $50,000 from the event grant funding. We had gone to Town Council looking for $200,000 per year. That was what was built into the budget.
54:44 We reduced that by $50,000, which is what the Council will be hopefully approving tonight. So we have $150,000 set aside for event grant funding for this fiscal year and next fiscal year. Originally we asked for $200,000, it was in there as $200,000, so that's been reduced by $50,000. Any questions on that? The second thing that we had changed in the Measure A budget was in Lara's world on the PR side. We had talked about we had a very last-minute opportunity to bid on the Outdoor Media Summit.
55:14 And that was going to be a cost to us of about $30,000. Unfortunately, we did not get that conference. Again, it was a last-minute request. The organizers had been here a couple of years ago for a tech summit, and I think they, at the last second, thought, oh, we should have Mammoth put in a bid for this. So we did. Unfortunately, it didn't come here. I do think it is something that we can get down the road. So that was a reduction of $30,000.
55:41 But Lara has requested of that $30,000 that we took out to put $10,000 back in for crib strategy and content to really work to figure out how we can monetize the results of the crib and how we can best promote that so that we can talk about the people that are coming in here and thus drive traffic for a triathlete coming to train or a runner or cyclist or whoever. So that was the...
56:05 Those were the two big changes there. John, can you point out where these are? This is on Measure A we're talking about, correct? These are on Measure A. So if you go to the events budget. Which page is that on? Because I'm trying to find that. That particular one was on the PR budget, right, John? Yeah, it is. The crib strategy and control plan. Sure. Let's just start with the events. That's the first one. That's line 69 on the event budget. At the top of your budgets, it says events in the left-hand corner.
56:35 It's probably like page five. It's page six, and it's the very last line. It's almost the very end. It's the last item on the bottom. And again, it was put in originally as $200,000, and it's been updated to $150,000. And then PR, which would be page five, it's also the last line of that budget agency, $65,000. Yeah, line 89. But I guess the...
57:10 Just while we're looking for this, if you could explain, I know that we don't have a year on your comparison, can you explain the $45,000 light item for Mammoth Track Club and what that is varied from the year prior? Yeah, so previously we've been sponsoring them at $30,000 and so they requested a $15,000 increase.
57:27 And that doesn't, we're not seeing that as a, we're only seeing a $5,000 increase in that GL because there's some things that are no longer in that program? Correct. So in the past year, I had some spillover from the SATW conference last year that happened in June of last year. And so I had, in July, I had $15,000 year marked for any final costs left over from that conference. So that's been removed. And so basically,
57:55 balances out with the track club. Just to point a clarification, what John was saying, that the SATW program was supposed to be part of the Outdoor Blogger, the Outdoor Writers Network. When we didn't get that, some of those funds went to crib strategy, but some of those funds also went to cover the $15,000 increase requested for.
58:13 It's in the same... It was an original request, but it showed a greater difference because it was going somewhere else. The difference from the last pledge is we're not seeing as much of a variation at GL because losing both of those conferences, it's $15,000 if that's being reallocated back to the club. Correct. And SATW wasn't necessarily a loss, it was just the one-year conference. Yeah, we held it. It just...
58:36 And Sean, so if you look at the PR page on page five, it will be the last line there as well under the agency 65080. 650 what? 65080. It'll be the last line of that entire PR budget on page five. That's a page number, so that's why. Well, it's the one prior to the events page that you were just looking at, so it's. It's down on like line 90.
59:06 The single biggest change that we had in Measure A for PR, which was a conversation at the last meeting, was an increase of about $20,000 roughly to alignment PR, for alignment PR to be more engaged in the seasons that they hadn't been prior, correct? Correct. To help us drive more athletes to the crib. Do you see that, Sean? I do. Okay.
59:32 So the request would be we cut out the 30 but we put 10 back in for the crib strategy so that's a difference from our last conversation. Any other questions on that specifically? Two other things that Scott had asked for at the last meeting, he questioned the overhead growth over the last few years and in the past we hadn't budgeted the 2% that we pay the town for the TBID reconciliation so the town keeps 2% of the TBID revenue that comes in.
1:00:07 We hadn't actually budgeted that because it was taken out before we get our check, but now we take the full amount and we reduce it by that 2%, so that's why that overhead number went up. It has been budgeted the last couple of years, it just wasn't prior to that. Right, right, right, yeah. Yeah, last, I think, two or three years it's been actually budgeted. And then the other question was just regarding the actual TBID revenues because we had some numbers that were off, and so one of the attachments that you have is the actual information from the P&L.
1:00:35 The year-end P&L for each of the fiscal years to show the exact total that came to us, just to give you that idea. And that, again, takes out 1% of that state, or excuse me, 2% of that state with the town. So that might have been part of the descriptions as well. The other things that I don't always take into account, the penalties and interest that we get paid out is typically $30,000 to $40,000 a year. And then the tier 2 and 3 appeals come in right around $10,000 as well. And then normally there's not a lot coming in from prior years.
1:01:08 But sometimes, like last fiscal year, we had $5,000 come in from the prior year that was owed to us. So that's all I had for responding to questions from the previous meeting. But are there other questions that have come up in the meantime? We've talked to most board members and met with some personally to go through them. Something I'd like to throw out there, John, and it may be too late for this budget. Maybe it's something that has to be worked on for next year's budget. But if it could fit in here, I think it would be great.
1:01:42 Most certainly go under marketing, but on the heels of the public comment today regarding a sustainable environment, ecosystem with regard to tourism and sustainability, I think you and I have had a conversation offline for a long time, and I'm not throwing it in there for any other reason than their comments actually made me think of it and made me think that maybe now is better than another time.
1:02:10 I think it would be somewhere in the neighborhood of $15,000 to $20,000 of budget where we could go after the big four plastic straws, cups, bottles, and bags, petroleum-based products that don't biodegrade and are poisonous to the environment and clearly the biggest problems that we have nationally and globally, if you've ever...
1:02:33 been sailing and have seen these things out in the ocean and with our landfill issues that are coming up and so forth, could we budget enough to purchase Mammoth Lakes Tourism logo products with the exception obviously of the straws and then that are made from recycled materials and biodegradable that we could then offer to the business community retail
1:03:04 and food and beverage where we could take the lead on that initiative. I love what they're doing, but on a volunteer basis, I think it's going to be a lot tougher to get buy-in because I just know how expensive those items are to go from, you know, people use Styrofoam not because choice, but because it's 10 cents on the dollar of Trellis Earth, biodegradable products, and so forth.
1:03:32 In many cases, it's a function of affordability, not desire, right? So how do we help that along in the community? Can we take a leading role and leading effort there without losing money? I think we get every penny back. It could be a pass-through plus handling cost. And could we logo that stuff and sell it to the community and budget that now and then go source it and bring it in? To be clear, I'm saying let's buy.
1:04:02 2 million biodegradable bags that have the logo on it. And then we sell those to retail and food and beverage in the community at our cost so that they can... And it'll be a low cost because we'll buy them direct from China and we'll buy in such bulk that they'll be close to, equal to, or even lower than some of the environmentally unfriendly products they're buying now. My suggestion if it's...
1:04:29 Okay, with the board would be to develop a plan around that and then come back and talk about a budget. I wouldn't necessarily your mark dollars right now, but I think we can look at it and then come back as a, I didn't want to come back and ask for any additional funding, but I think we can build a plan around it and see what it makes sense and present it to the board as an option. Okay, that's fair enough and I'll lead that charge. I'll get the numbers, bring them back to the board and we'll go from there. Does the rest of the board work with that? I do.
1:04:56 Yeah, I just add to your comment on that, John, that I see that as part of the long-term plan as we do for this community. How do we represent ourselves to the world and to everything else? And not just these small things here, but there's many other things I think we could do as a community that are beneficial to us as businesses and beneficial to the environment as well. Yeah, we should lead that charge, given that we're at 8,000 feet with rivers, lakes, streams, and forests running in our backyard. And then secondly, it's something that, you know,
1:05:26 It's just the right thing to do. And I think affordability is the only issue. I think most people would agree with this and they'd say, yeah, that's great. I just can't afford it. I mean, you take my materials costs up 20, 30, 40, 50 percent, hanging on by a thread now kind of thing. Are you recommending we potentially look at subsidizing so people are still paying the same amount but we're giving them the product that doesn't kill the environment? Well, I buy a lot through China now.
1:05:55 New tariffs excluded. But I know that I can meet or exceed, I can get better pricing for better materials, but it's MOQ, right? It's how many units you're buying. So we're talking about hundreds of thousands, even millions of units to bring those costs down to where...
1:06:22 It's equal or better than what people are buying now with petroleum-based, styrofoam-based products. And every time I see a clamshell go out and it's styrofoam, it breaks my heart because I see that stuff out on trails and by lakes and things like that. But I also understand as a business owner that I can only do what I can afford to do, whether it's great for the environment or not. You know what I mean? So how do we, and I think this is really clearly in our wheelhouse of...
1:06:50 Tourism, because we're delivering an experience to the customer that's better, and we're going to attract people that are really interested in coming to places that have initiatives like this in place, right? I know I make those decisions every day. Well, a comment I was going to make is, you know, without going too much down this rabbit hole, because, you know, I know we're focusing on one thing specifically, but I'm actually thinking of events specifically, you know, we're about to...
1:07:16 buy 60,000 biodegradable cups. And it's very important to us that we're buying biodegradable. I could put Mammoth Brewing Company logo on it, but frankly, I'd be happy putting Mammoth Lakes logo on it. And if the tourism department were able to purchase those, you know, and I got to pay for those, you know, I got 30k terms from my supplier, but at the same time, if MLT were to buy 200,000, 250,000 cups to
1:07:45 I think that the optics on that would be much more visible. Maybe not just because I know you're watching these go out, but, you know, having the recycling bins on site at our different locations, at our different festivals would really pay off there. So just, you know, and again, I feel like we're going down in one specific, you know, line item here, but I just want to point that out. Michael, I'll just add to that list, biodegradable doggy bags.
1:08:10 And I do want to mention there are some things happening on the state level. I'm not really sure the deadlines on that. But there could be some things that are dictated by the state that we're going to have to follow. And I would be very cautious of us doing something that is going to work at odds, kind of like with the plastic bag. We were very proactive with that.
1:08:35 from a town basis, but then the state kind of tweaked it a little bit, and so it ended up costing a little bit more, and it didn't quite work out, so I think that we need to be cognizant of what's happening in the state of California about this issue, because it's not just us, so. Right, and I know we've got to move on. I just have one more comment. I want to say thank you to my colleague here, Sean, for those comments, because that is one of the issues that I've thought about, is I use logo stuff a lot, and it's, you have to make that decision to think of
1:09:03 The greatest amount of good for the greatest amount of people. And it's really refreshing and encouraging to hear you say that because you're going to do hundreds of thousands of cups that could easily have Mammoth Lakes Brewing on them. But to be willing to put that logo on it is really helpful to the overall buy and the ability to get more quantity and subsequently lower prices. And I share your comments. I would do the exact same thing for Margarita Festival and my...
1:09:30 Business products as well. It's a bigger issue than any one unit, and we all need to get on board. Single-use, you know, drinks, but these bags, cups, and straws are huge. If we can all get on board there, it'll make a huge difference. The last part of this, and I'm going to do it because I do have some budget questions, is the Benton Crossing landfill closes in three years. All of our solid waste will have to be moved somewhere else.
1:09:59 And it's not just MLTs charged to communicate, but this is a community-wide to not only our visitors and those that live here of how we can do this. So the timing of this, the clock is really ticking on it. And it's very important. It's extremely important because if you have to move your solid waste of any type out, you know what that's going to do to the cost.
1:10:27 So whatever we can do to get ahead of it is going to be worth our time. Well said. Ron D.C., you had some additional... Yeah, I do have some points of clarity, and you all forgive me of being new here, but I want to make sure I'm reading this right because a couple of these points are I want to make sure that I'm reading the amount of revenue that we're projecting here. And one place that I...
1:10:57 Need some clarity on is, I know there hasn't been a change from the TBID, the TBID budget of 516, but I want to make sure that I'm reading this right. On the TBID budget, on the revenues on 516, you have a note here on the cell C39 that the reserve of approximately $2 million is going to be reduced.
1:11:27 to 1.4, approximately 1.4 to balance the budget. And I see that actually happening in December of 5-6. However...
1:11:43 It looks like it did not actually come out of the reserve budget because that would bring the reserve budget down at the total at the end of the year to the $1.4 instead of the $2 million. Correct. The reason that I didn't take it out of the reserve is the same reason we didn't do it this year. We took $900,000 out of reserve last year and we're $928,000 ahead of TBID budget right now. So the reserve that we had planned on using, we aren't using. So it is estimated that if we
1:12:11 If we just hit budget on TBID and we reduce it by the reserve use, then it would be that amount. But at this point, I'm leaving it at the full amount that's in there. Well, that actually, since it actually is in a reserve in December, it should probably come out of December as well. Because then you would be looking at, if you use it in December, the budget would then calculate properly to 1.4. Because you're using it in December. The reserve would come to 1.4.
1:12:43 Because that would change your total number. I can do that. That's not a problem. I don't actually physically take the dollars out of the CDs until we need it. And like this year, we're not taking it out of the CDs. That's why I added the note, but I didn't take it out because it still will be at the $2,100,000,000. But I hope you understand that where I'm seeing is the perception is that we have $2 million. Well, we really are not planning to have $2 million.
1:13:10 And then if you look over at last year's totals in that same sheet there, so that those totals from last year of 1.14 and on down, those add up to 5.290. Is that what it's supposed to add up to? Which sheet are you looking at? And the same one there is actually R33.
1:13:38 That's supposed to, that would be the total of those items above it, correct? That is the total. Of the 1.14, 1 million of lines 9, 11, 13, and 15. Is that what I'm to assume? Is there, are there any other numbers in there? No, I think that's the last year total. Oh yeah, the last year total. Okay, well that. The cumulative.
1:14:06 Of those, okay. That includes the $500,000 investment below. Well, actually, that doesn't add up. That number in R33 is a hard number. When I added that up, it came to $4.5 million, and then when I add in the $500,000 below, that came to a different number. So I just... I'm adding up. If I take lines 9 through 15...
1:14:36 I get 4.528. Right. And then if you add in the 5, you're going to come up with the 500,000. That would be? 5,028,000. Uh-huh. Yeah. 528. Well, and the reason that I was questioning this is we're looking at an increase in TOT revenue.
1:15:08 Not a decrease. It's actually an 11% increase over this year in TBID revenue instead of 5% decrease. And most of that TBID revenue increase is coming from lodging. And there's a 25% increase in lodging projected in revenue over last year, which is actually this year, correct? The 2018-19? Which number is it?
1:15:40 V9 is 25. So we're projecting that we're going to make 25% more in TBID revenue for the upcoming year. Yes. And it's based off of actuals. Okay. Off of actuals. So, which is a pretty hefty percentage to increase. Well, last year we budgeted conservatively on that. And if you look back...
1:16:09 If you look back at the sheet that I gave you with the actuals collected, we have been, the last three years, we have done 1.33, 1.43, 1.18. In the lodging portion? In lodging. Okay. And so this lodging number, is that the budget or the actual? The 1.14? That was the budgeted number from last year. So would it be a little bit...
1:16:38 Better to look at it as what we're actually doing in there. It's just, I hate to saddle lodging with a 25% increase knowing that we've had, you know, what is our occupancy increase against that too. Well, we were very conservative with the budgeting this year because we weren't sure what to expect after the year that we had last year. So far this year.
1:17:07 So I guess to the point is I want to make sure that we're all comfortable with the numbers that we're budgeting because we're going to spend to those numbers and because I hear really loud and clear that from the council that the joint reserve is that's at their discretion.
1:17:31 I want us to make sure that we are well aware of what's coming in and how we want to use it so we are not at the end of the year and end of a period going back to have to do normal business looking at the joint reserve. And so if these numbers, if we're thinking that we have a $2 million reserve but is actually 1.4 if we spend the way this budget is, don't want to overcommit us in that area and make sure that our numbers are adding up.
1:18:00 I found a few places and we talked to it that the numbers just, that the totals weren't adding up. Maybe if you went by month, they would by the year, but we could throw our budget off. And I want to make sure right out of the bat that we are looking at true numbers. So that's my concern. So right now for this year, we had 1.14 budgeted. We're at 1.4 million with two months to go. And so I did take that number down.
1:18:26 From what I anticipate that we're going to end up at, we're probably going to end up over 1.5 million. And I did take it down for the budget. I didn't take it down dramatically, but I did take it down for the budget. Okay. So would it be actually fair to say that your project, if you're looking over last year, that 25% increase is actually a projected increase of how you're going to budget, not against what you're actually doing? Because you said you're, okay.
1:18:53 Yeah, I mean, I can always work in the actual numbers, and I think we've talked about that. I think that would be good because, you know, from a standpoint of, like, for John and for Brent, it's looking at increases, and also you had talked quite a bit about how can we get these increases in retail and restaurants.
1:19:16 Is there a possibility of seeing those, making more money? Are there options there? And knowing where growth can truly come from. Can it come from midweek? Have you maxed out your weekends? Those are the things that can help us maximize the revenue that we have control over. And that's where I was looking at that one.
1:19:38 Yeah, and Rhonda, just as from overall, I looked at the last several years, and we were 1-4, 1-3-5, we're going to be 1-5, I debated what's our new floor, is what I'm trying to be, I don't know. I think that's the question. What's my new level? What should that be at? Okay, that helps clear it up, because I found that in a couple other places. There is...
1:19:59 The LA Kings Partnership that's coming from the Joint Reserve, when is that projected to move over to within our regular budget so we're not looking at the reserve for that? It's not. It's committed for the entire life of that program. That's a $600,000 commitment from the town that was created three years ago. So do we feel that we could assume that within our budgets coming up instead of it coming from the Joint Reserve in the future? No, because I have to invoice the town every single year for the $100,000.
1:20:29 But the funds don't come to us until we get them from the town. That's why they're a pass-through, pretty much. But it's committed from the town. We have a council resolution that commits the six years of the $100,000. Okay. But it's not, but the funds haven't been turned over to us. No, I understand that part. I'm just questioning whether that's the best fund for it to come from. And then the last...
1:20:58 Measure A at this point? Are you still on the TBID? I'm sorry, it's probably, it's coming from it. I have it in here in a joint, a combined budget to give me where all of that looks from. And then the last question I had was regarding events. In your event budget, it shows, in the summary, it shows that we spent $25,000 in there, but it's actually not.
1:21:30 showing up in this year for the comparison. There's no expenditure in the event budget if you look on her tab there. But how much was the, I'm sorry, if, how much was the amount that was given through the special events grantee? The grant funding, again, it was another one of those pass-throughs from the town, $125 this year. So it was...
1:21:55 That was still $125,000. And so that is, and where is that showing up in the budgeting? That's showing up on line 69 on the event page. Okay. We did not own those dollars last year. Excuse me, I'm sorry. We didn't own those dollars last year. That was still through the town general fund. Understood. That's why they're not showing. Understood. Okay. And so with it now being $150,000 because that comes with the grant, do you feel that there's any need in that we can
1:22:24 We're confident that that money is going to be for the grant programming exclusively, right? Because I know that they had not given additional funds for that. Is there anywhere else that you're trying to do that program and you want to bring it back into? Are you talking about the $50,000 that was not approved by Council? $50,000 seed money? No, $50,000 seed money. The way that it was left with Council was that if we have an event like...
1:22:48 the dirt event that we're trying to bring in for next fall is that we would go back to the town and say, hey, we have this on an individual, on an as-need basis. Absolutely. I actually wanted to follow up with some questions with regard to the event funding. The town controlled that $125,000 last year. Correct. And MLT had $25,000 last year? Is that what I'm reading? No, so $25,000 was just the operating budget for the events department. Okay. So this year there is
1:23:16 76,181 for operating budget, and there's 150 for the event grants. The 25,000 was a placeholder, it was a brand new department, that's what we put in there. Okay, sorry, you just threw out those numbers quick before I was able to see them on the list. Would you say the 125 plus? No, so last year the 125 was not in our budget. We put $25,000 in because it was a brand new position that started in October, and we felt that that was what we needed to buy.
1:23:43 Caroline Computers and whatever travel she might need to do in the eight months of the fiscal year that she was going to be there. And that's where we defined a real budget for that this year. Okay. So the budget this year, and I'm going back and forth between the paper and spreadsheets here. Where was it? The total budget for events is $226,181, and that includes the $150,000 that's passed from the town. $150,000 or $125,000? $150,000. We were able to get the town to give us $150,000.
1:24:11 Which means that we can increase the amount that gets granted out to the local events. Okay. So 150 plus 76, is that what I'm hearing? Approximately? Yeah. This last year, a total amount was given out through the grant program of how much? 125. Okay. So this year we're planning on giving out all 226 of that? No, no, no. There's no 226. 76,000 is operating budget. Okay. That's Caroline going to Kansas last week to go to an event that we're looking to bring here.
1:24:39 That's for computers, that's advertising, that's all of our operating budget, just like any other department. The $150,000, so the $226,000 is a little misnomer. The total budget for Carolina is $76,181. The $150,000 is a pass-through, so we'll do the normal grant process, and then we will invoice the town for the amounts that we're going to hand out for the event grant funding next year. Okay.
1:25:06 My concern is just, you know, I would love to see, you know, with the grant program, it's, you know, I want to be careful because obviously Blues of Blues received some funds through the, but what I would actually like to see is a little bit more commitment made towards events going forward with, you know, what does an event site look like going forward? And I know that, you know, that's an ongoing discussion, something that, you know, we brought up before and I actually was just reminded.
1:25:34 of this is something that I find a huge frustration at Bluesapalooza is people are taking pictures and they want to post right away with the hashtag Visit Mammoth and they can't even get a text out let alone being able to get an Instagram post. I see that as something that I would love to see this department actually commit some funds towards making sure that
1:25:57 You know, that we've got, whether it's one of those temporary towers or whatever the case may be, but I'm feeling like we don't have enough money budgeted towards events. And I'm saying that not necessarily for the grant program, but just in the form of support. I know that we've got that budgeted here through the Measure A. Just to be clear, it doesn't look like there's any budgeted for TBID, for events through TBID. Yeah. I'd like for us to consider an increase for events, not necessarily for the grant program.
1:26:26 But specifically for Caroline's budget to increase some of the structure, some of the support structure that goes around events. Okay. And remember the TBID funds have to be used to provide specific benefit to the people that pay into it. So the lodging, restaurant, retail, ski area, not, the events don't pay into it. Not saying that supporting events doesn't support lodging, restaurant, retail in the grand scheme of things. We just have to be very careful with, you know, infrastructure that would go to support the events versus.
1:26:54 Directly support, because the law, the Prop 26 says it has to directly benefit people paying them. My Palooza Bar spent, paid a lot into the TBID this last year. Sure. As bar sales and retail sales do pay into the TBID. So I don't know if that can, you know, is an argument there. We can explore. So is the challenge to, you know, to find ways to funnel those funds.
1:27:19 And be real specific and directly. So if it's a marketing issue that benefits marketing for a particular event, maybe it's a village event, maybe it's a MAC event, maybe somewhere else, we would have to be very specific on the criteria of what it is. So it may not be universal marketing for all events.
1:27:42 There might be opportunities, but if we thoroughly bend that. Yeah, that's a good very well defined. And no problem on that. It's just that, you know, what I'm seeing happen with events, and I'm aware I'm an outgoing board member who has an event myself, but at the same time, we do pay into the bar sales and the merchandise sales do pay into the TBID, as do all of our vendors who attend the event itself. And what I'm saying is not necessarily with the grant program, although the grant program is
1:28:11 Very, very helpful. But that I would actually like to see Caroline have the ability to put money specific towards supporting events. And as it is right now, and I know that this is a delicate situation with regard to what an event site is going to look like going forward, but my comment with regard to a portable...
1:28:33 Mobile Tower. Last year was the first year that, you know, John, I know we talked about this, and a tower is very expensive, but at the same time might pay for itself quickly, just because at a Bluza Bluza event,
1:28:48 One of the biggest complaints we get at the front gate is I can't even send a text out of here. And when we're trying to get people putting a picture up on Instagram that says, hey, I'm at Bluza Pluza or Margarita Fest or any other event with the hashtag Visit Mammoth, I think that that would be a benefit for this department. Yeah, and of the 76,000 that we've committed from the Measure A budget, 50,000 of that is going towards advertising. So we are, we are, I mean, this is the
1:29:18 Second year, technically, of the program, so we'll continue to grow up. In the second year, I just, you know, and I'm aware that, you know, here we are on June 5th, trying to start a budget before we even have our next meeting, but just wanted to throw out there that I would like to see more money committed towards events in one way or another. Yeah, and we did increase 20% on the grant funding, which is hopefully appreciated by the events in town, so. I spent a lot of time going through spreadsheets, and I think we have a...
1:29:50 You have a decent budget here. I've had a lot of questions around it. I sent an email this morning from a friend of mine that works kind of in the investment industry, and he had a signature in the bottom of his, and I wrote it down, and when I read it, it struck me as appropriate for our budget conversation. It's a quote from The Art of War that says, strategy without tactics is the slowest route to victory. Tactics without strategy is the noise before defeat.
1:30:20 My biggest complaint about this budget, and John, you and I've talked about this, I'm okay with debating the budget here. I do not want to sit here next year and have a budget where we have a marketing plan, not a strategic plan, presented to us by the consultants that buy advertising on our behalf. I don't think we've delivered a strategic plan to the board. I don't think we've delivered a true strategic vision to the community. And I think approving a budget of several million dollars in absence of that is a dereliction of our duty as a board.
1:30:52 Kept doing the same thing, and we're spending the second largest budget in this community, outside of town, going forward, without having a very clear, this is the vision. I look at our TBID dollars, and I look at their reassessment, and lodging's gone up, and retail's gone up, but our TBID restaurant payees have been relatively flat for the last three years, and I don't see anything that says, how are we going to help our TBID payees make more money? I don't see strategic vision tied to trying to grow, and just to...
1:31:20 As we're going through talking about our bylaws, it says very specifically in our bylaws, the MLT purpose, the principal purpose of the corporation is to engage in such activities that are meant to improve the tourism industry in the town. And my concern is that we have a budget and the way our presentation of this budget has come is that I think we are fairly criticized by people in the community that oftentimes we are nothing more than a pass-through to the consultants that execute our marketing. And I think that until we have going forward,
1:31:49 A real strategic plan that talks about engagement in the community at a much deeper level than just this is the ad results and these are the numbers and this is the impressions that we get and talks really specifically about what are we doing to help the people that are paying into this to grow their business. We're missing something and I've tried to be subtle in asking about it and we've had these conversations before you and I met in private and I asked you specifically to make sure that you presented and not Samari or Marian Carson or anyone else but I still feel like without
1:32:20 We're getting into the details of all these Excel spreadsheets, and really we should be able to say this is the strategic plan, this is the marketing plan that matches the strategic plan, and these are the numbers to execute that marketing plan. And I think we're getting into the weeds and the numbers because people are trying to figure out how that is going to align to a strategy that's not really clearly articulated, and we need to fix that. So I support having a conversation today, but as a board, I'd propose that we do not have a budget review in the future.
1:32:50 at all without having a very clear strategic plan, not a marketing plan. And the town asks for this in our contract. We have to present to the town a strategic plan. I know there was some resistance to that. A marketing plan is not the same as a strategic plan. That's my piece. Agreed. Well said. I don't mean the contrary, Sully. Point taken. But remember where we came from.
1:33:17 Our direction was to raise money for the town initially. We've changed, this board has evolved and where we're going and I think where you're going is where the future of this organization is and I don't disagree with your general points but if you take the past, I'm more, I take to heart particularly the consultants coming in to make the presentation when we're
1:33:36 Buying them. I take that to most heart of your whole comment that we need to be driving the ship versus them. We use that term that the organization was created only to make money for town. But our bylaws specifically say the principal purpose of the corporation is to engage in such activities as are meant to improve the tourism industry in the town. No, sorry, I'm not disagreeing. I think money is a component of that. I'm not disagreeing with the creation. I'm just saying if you've got to take the totality of being on this board for the last eight years and the
1:34:06 Potential, the whole lawsuit and everything that's happened in this town, there's a period of time where direction kind of was a very singular focus for this organization, and that's changed, and I agree the future of what this organization is will continue to change, because we as a board will evolve, and you're also hitting on points where we will take a look at the future, and the role and what this board does is going to evolve even more. It's not going to be the same as what it was in the past. And I mean, if anyone's accountable, it's me. I've been the board chair since last year's budget was approved, so that's...
1:34:35 But with that. That's what I'm saying going forward. I think we really have to have that in place before we have these conversations. So with that, though, to help us kind of try to move along, I don't want to force you if you want more conversation, but I was going to make a motion if you wanted a motion. If you're ready. I didn't want to. We have one board member out that's probably likely back quickly by the sound of the flush. So you can wait a moment. We can have all parties involved, or you can continue forward.
1:35:05 I would move that the board accepts this budget, and I use the term budget because to me a budget is a guideline for an organization. It can always be changed within the year if the board so desires to change their direction. It's a budget's a guideline. We have to give direction to staff, but again, to me a budget's a guideline, so I would make the motion that we move forward with the budget as presented. Do you have a second? I second that. Do you have a second? Any dialogue? Any conversation?
1:35:42 Yeah, I got a question. If this is not approved, what would be our next steps? Well, we'd have to provide clear direction of what we expected to have happen in order for staff to be able to go back and look at the budget. And I know that in the past, with regard to the budget, we've, you know, it's carried over into the new year. And I guess my question is, you know, do we go forward with this?
1:36:10 Or do we need to schedule more meetings before July 1st? The budget is not approved as it is. I guess my question would be what are the stumbling blocks within the budget? I understand Scott's talk about the strategic direction moving forward, but what are the stumbling blocks at this point? Well, I'm late to the party. So, you know, with regard, I've missed the May meeting. So, you know, I was not able to have a more in-depth conversation about where we're at. You know, as I just pointed out, I'd like to see more money dedicated to events.
1:36:46 Small but in my mind important. I'm confused with the vision of the strategic directive and we've gone through a lot of objectives as to what we want to achieve as a board and what we want to do for the community and they do kind of come into numbers you know whether it's achieving the
1:37:15 TOT of $20 million in a year, whether it's achieving $1 million in TOT for 10 months or whatever it is. Those are kind of what I look at and say that that's been our strategy. We've really been trying to move in that direction. And I think that the marketing plan that has been presented
1:37:40 is a tactic of achieving that strategy. And so I'm confused as to where your concern is with, it sounds like you want to get more into the tactics or the tasks and the tactics to achieve a strategy, but are you changing the strategy of $20 million in revenue that we've all agreed to? That's not a strategy, that's a goal.
1:38:08 That is a strategy. No, the strategy, that's an end goal. There's things that you do to get there. What's the vision for the organization? So you have a strategy of reaching $20 million and you have a task of getting to that $20 million. Let me give you a, I'll pick on Michael, if that's okay. I promise it'll be nice. How long have you had Gomez's?
1:38:39 Well, Gomez's has been around since 93. I've had it for 12 years. And would you say your revenue's increased each year? Every year but one. And you've made some changes in your organization like discovering the benefit of a Bloody Mary bar and so you've made changes to your business that have helped things like Sunday brunch. That's correct. In the Gomez's analogy, I feel like that's where MLT's been, which is we've been doing something and it works and we make incremental changes to it and we grow and grow business.
1:39:08 What prompted you to go up in HUGS? Well, that's where I agree with what Eric's saying. The strategy of growing, I think it's semantics in some way, but the strategy of growing overall portfolio revenue and profitability. To me, that is very much a strategy. The vision of HUGS was to do something, was to increase your portfolio and revenue. Well, that's my strategy, is to hit that number, to increase portfolio revenue.
1:39:39 became an entity that served, that was a part of building that strategy. So you had to know that going and doing something different, like opening a new restaurant versus making a new Gomez's was the right way to do that, like opening a second location, correct? Like if your strategy is to increase your revenue, there's several ways you could have done that. You could have done that by opening another restaurant, you could have opened another different ways, right? Did you do the graphic design for the logo for Huggs?
1:40:08 Did I personally? Yeah, or did you contract it out? I drafted it and then contracted it out. Was your contractor the one that told you that having an ice cream business was going to be the right way to expand your portfolio and reach your strategy? Well, not the contractor. I know where you're going with this, but the short answer is... Yeah, I get the point too. I get it. I went to an ice cream convention to find out if that was an entity that made sense, was profitable and all that, and yes, those people did...
1:40:39 advise me that that industry and those units could be very, very successful. You explored things clearly outside your wheelhouse with the intent of trying to do something that was not just more of the same with more money after it as a way to grow your portfolio. Yeah, of course. And that's what I'm saying. I haven't seen a real clear articulation. We've had a decent budget. We've had decent growth. We've had decent numbers. I think that to say that
1:41:09 We're going from here to here to here every year, and our budget's going from here to here every year, and it's like, that's good. Things are good. That's fine. I don't know that that's the best, most efficient way to do things, and I have seen an aversion to asking questions around, what does that look like beyond that? And I think as a board, we should be able to explore that and look at that vision beyond what has been the rote thing that's got us thus far, and accepting that doing more of the same commensurate with the growth that's there is the only way forward.
1:41:39 May I speak to that? And I think to continue on the Gomez's example, you know, the question is, why did you do, why did you end up doing brunch? Why did you add brunch? For the same exact reasons. Because Sunday's slow and looking for something to drive business. Well, no, I have fixed costs and anything I can do to add revenue without exceeding fixed costs is extra profitable. In other words, more goes to the bottom. Well, and I guess the question is, you know, how is that different than us focusing on fall as a strategy?
1:42:10 If Michael's adding the Bloody Mary Bar to drive business on a Sunday because it's the way to expand on his current business, how is that different than what we're doing as one of our strategies with 10 months of viability with $20 million of TOT and going after the fall market to fill in the gap versus getting the 7 million skier at the mountain? Sure. I see that as a strategy. I don't see that as a strategic vision. I feel like we have been doing... I'll ask you a question. If this board came to you and said,
1:42:40 Your budget is now $3 million. How would you go execute that? And what component of that would be contractors are done in the house and how would that happen? And not saying that that's the direction we should go by any stretch of the imagination because I believe in the money we're spending and I believe what the organization does. I think what I've heard from the community time and again, we heard it in the interview process, is that there is not something there outside of buying advertising outside of this community.
1:43:08 This is perception, and I can see the look on your face, that outside of buying advertising outside of this community at high dollars through consultants, what are we doing to engage the people in town that pay into TBID? And when we have TBID people, and when I went and knocked on doors, we would be like, you're on the board and you understand it. The organization, I think, needs to have a very clear strategic vision that says, this is what we're doing based on the purpose. I understand that council gave us that, but our bylaws say, we're here to support the tourism industry.
1:43:38 And if people in the tourism industry that are paying into TBID don't feel supported by this organization, even if they're seeing the windfall of money that comes in because of outside advertising, we're missing something. And that's something that should be addressed in a strategic plan. And it's not coming up when we said, this is where work from marketing last year, and this is what we're going to spend to get that to work next year. We're missing a component of our business because we're going marketing plan to marketing plan based off of achievements and goals in those marketing plans instead of saying,
1:44:05 Holistically, this is what the organization stands for, and this is how we operate in the community. So it sounds like you're talking about education. So Mr. Chair, if I could, we have a motion and a second on the table. I don't know if we're off subject here, but I challenge us that this is a point made by everybody, and that you as chair, or if you continue on as chair, can lead this point forward. I don't want to speak any more to it, because I was leaving, I've said my piece to it. But we have a motion and a second on the table, so I would ask the chair a call for the question.
1:44:32 Is there any specific, any other conversation around that specific topic? Yeah, sorry Brent, because I think that the vernacular being used here is crossing over and I think it's really important to understand that and so Scott was making a point to help me understand that and I just want to verify that and that is is that I think you do believe in, let's call it a goal for now, a goal of 20 million dollars, right? That's been our goal.
1:45:00 And so we then need to have strategic initiatives to help us achieve that goal. And out of those strategic initiatives, we'll have certain tasks and tactics to achieve those. Is that a fair way of approaching that then? And I think there's a level of vision beyond that where if your organization has a set number of visitation, there's like the operational goals and the strategy on it. And what's more the strategic vision?
1:45:29 How did Altera happen? Altera didn't happen because someone was like, oh, this is how we're going to incrementally grow our numbers. Like there has to be a vision beyond just the rote day to day that I don't think the organization has articulated very well. We haven't dreamed outside of our own wheelhouse and our own budget on what's happening right now. And I think that's a miss. Right. Because I think as an organization, if we don't do that, it's going to be dictated to us by town. Right.
1:45:55 So where I think that we need clarity amongst us as board members is what that vision is, whether it's a strategic vision, a goal, or something to that, but have that vision. And then without that, where we don't have all that commonality and we're not focused, we're not all focused on that, we'll never get there. Caroline had a great conversation three months ago, I guess, in my office probably talking about events, and she was able to articulate.
1:46:24 Vision for what she had for events. And so in that, like when I heard the way she talked about events, whether I think another event or something else is there with the good numbers is like, because I understood what she wanted to accomplish really clearly, I didn't even raise those other questions because it was like, I was on board with her big idea. Yeah. And so whether or not I thought, well, running doesn't matter. I want this thing over here. How you accomplish the vision is, you know, a lot of different ideas or ways or paths, but.
1:46:53 The vision was clearly understood. And so just going back to the conversation, like, you know, Sean's questions around events. If there's a really clear vision of how events plays a component and we get into it, like, the dollars should line up with that. I hear Sean's comments are saying, I think something's missing from our vision around events. We shouldn't be having that conversation here. It should have happened all the way back at that strategic side.
1:47:20 Were you at the five-hour meeting we had at the Westin with, you know, if you have... You're talking about the one on May 1st of last year? Yeah. Yeah, that was an abomination. Sorry. In your opinion. In my opinion, if I, like, when I was working at larger companies, if a creative agency came in and spent five hours presenting a diatribe of information and numbers, and not, like, that to me was... I understand, in your entirety of your opinion. Yeah. I don't want to be... I was there. You mentioned me, so I'll...
1:47:49 address myself. I'm one of the largest TBID emitters here. I have a lot of confidence in our third-party marketing agency and the analytics accounting of that agency, SMARI, and I also am a huge supporter of not swallowing all of the costs and infrastructure of that expertise, right? For sure. If I want to train, if teachers are going to get trained how to defend themselves for school shootings,
1:48:17 I don't want them teaching themselves. I want an outside expert in law enforcement to come in and train them. Correct? Sure. So I, for one, have the confidence in them. And when I listen to that, I didn't see it as an abomination. What I saw was a strategic plan on how we utilize our dollars in the best way possible to garner the most amount of interest in our community and then process that to click-throughs or to visitation.
1:48:47 TOT aside, TBID dollars for me are spent on getting people to Mammoth that could possibly come to my business, right? So now if you don't have confidence in the third-party agency or the idea that we farm that out to a third-party agency, that's a fair position to take and we should discuss that. But I'm confused on how we're coming to this point where we're some rudderless ship that doesn't have any kind of vision or strategy.
1:49:16 Which is kind of what I hear saying. I just don't see it that way. I see it as a very clear strategy with a very clear goal of reaching. But to your point, I don't just say every year at Gomez is we're going to do this much dollars next year and then we don't have any kind of a vision or plan or strategy to accomplish it. It has to be adding brunch or so forth.
1:49:37 When we attack fall, when we attack fall colors and attack spring, to me, that's strategy. And could it be better? Possibly. Let's have that discussion. But I think to present it as if we're just some, like I said, rudderless ship without any vision or strategy. I'm not saying that we're rudderless ship. I think that we're missing an aspect. I have confidence in Marian Carson, but I think we've looked at marketing plans a lot. And I don't want to belabor this point. We can have this conversation.
1:50:05 I think we've looked at a lot of marketing plans. I think that May presentation was a marketing plan. I don't think I've heard a very clear, this is the vision for the organization for the next five years, holistically. Not numbers, not budgets, not goals, but like this is the vision. So a little more drill down into the how is what you're saying? I think we've been drilling into the how without actually saying why.
1:50:32 Well, again, I guess I used the fall as the example, and I guess that confuses me, because we, the board, very clearly came four years ago and said, we really want to see the leveling out of the valleys. And so we said, okay, we're going to go after the fall, and we went after the fall, and this is how we did it. So what, is that, is that not the right process? The board was involved with that. The board came back very clearly this year and said, we want to continue towards that 10-month viability. We want to continue towards fall. We increased spend in fall on advertising.
1:51:02 How do we know that was the best way to go forward? Versus smoke signals? I mean, I don't understand. I mean, what, as a marketing organization, that's what we do. What I guess was... That's a question. Are we a marketing organization or are we the tourism department for this town? Because when I read our bylaws, we should be more than just a marketing organization for the town. We should be... What do the bylaws say to improve the tourism economy, right?
1:51:27 Which includes things above and beyond marketing. And that's fine. And that's where I'm missing is I haven't seen a very clear vision how marketing is a component of what we do, but it shouldn't be the only thing we do. And I want to be cautious because I feel like our staff does exceptional work. I think you do great work. But what I've missed is saying, I think part of why we have detractors is because there's not a very clear, this is why we exist and why we're doing it.
1:51:55 Here's the goals, and here's how we're going to get there. We get to go through and we see predominantly, this is where we're spending money and these are the results. And I still hear in the community, well, why do we need you to do that? And until we can articulate that and say all of this feeds to that, that's what we're missing. What I understand you're saying, though, is we need to educate the community because your goal is $20 million, 10 months of viability. The way to get to that is to go after those shoulder seasons and to increase those times that are less than $1 million, less than $2 million.
1:52:24 Then we go out and we do the tactics to get that to happen. It happens, but we apparently don't educate the community well enough to let them know that we were going after filling your shoulder season and closing down the valley or bringing the valley up. To me, that's a very clear strategic direction is to have us go to... I don't think we're going to resolve this today. To Brent's point, I think we should carry on the conversation on the budget. I'm asking, is that not a strategic vision to say we want $20 million, 10 months of viability?
1:52:51 And then the tactics that come to us, we say, okay, we're going to go strategically, we're going to go after fall, and then here's how we're going to go after fall. We went after fall with Instagram stories, we went after fall with advertising, we went after fall with our marketing, with our owned, earned, paid. This is a longer conversation, because I don't think you and I are going to agree on what strategy. I'm just asking, is that not a strategy? You're asking for a question, and I'm telling you that the answer that I'm going to give you is not something I think we're going to resolve today. So we should focus on the budget so we can move forward. Okay. Could we get that motion restated?
1:53:21 Or just if I can hear it again. Before we do, just because I don't know if I can answer to my question, is if this budget is not approved today, what happens? I truly don't know. Well, the other side of that is, to Brett's point, the budget isn't precise. It's never precise, right? If we have a drought year and we're 30% off, whatever it is, right, the budget is not carved in stone, so we have, and it's close.
1:53:50 But we haven't heard anything egregious with respect to the budget. You know, Rhonda brought up some good clarification points. So for me, it's approve the budget. You don't have to deal with that. And if you have adjustments you need to make along the way, you make them. Because I think that's the point that I was trying to make. And, you know, strictly looking at this from a budgeting standpoint, you know, Scott, I think I, well, I don't want to speak to that, you know, just as far as getting the strategic.
1:54:16 Strategery lined up. But, you know, if we did want to shift money from this bucket to this bucket, this is the time to do that kind of thing. Correct? And I'm just asking the question as far as, you know, if this budget isn't approved here in the next, you know, theoretically three minutes, what is the process? This budget should have, those conversations were 90 days ago. Okay. Realistically. I made the comment about being late to the party. So,
1:54:48 My question was, if this budget is not approved today, what is the process? And I'm just curious what the answer to that is, and then let's take a vote. I think we had this situation two years ago where we didn't approve the budget and came back and had asked for a second time, correct? Well, no, I think just our timing put us into the July meeting to approve it. Okay, so there is the pathway for that. It depends on whether anyone thinks that's necessary. Just a point of order.
1:55:18 You want to restate the motion? Yeah. As best I can. Yeah. I move to accept the budget as presented with the understanding that the budget's a guideline and an operating document that is a guideline that is subject to change as this board moves forward, but it gives a substantial foundation for the staff to move forward with their direction. I know I'll rephrase that slightly, but does that make sense? I'll wait a second. I appreciate your rewording it.
1:55:50 And the second was from? I second. And second as restated? Yeah. As restated. Okay. We've had conversation. I don't think there's any other dialogue. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Okay. Budget approved. You need a break for a closed session. You need to recuse yourself? Oh, I'm definitely recusing myself from this. My concern is I'm just supposed to be attending a school event in 15 minutes.
1:56:24 And I know that we need to come back to some important stuff here. It's just the agenda for this meeting was from one to three. Are you proposing we don't go into closed session, we go to the other items? Well, I need to leave here in the next five minutes anyway, and I don't know if we're going to be able to get through the rest of the, you know, I'm actually wondering if I can leave and come back, but I don't know how long you expect to be in closed session for.
1:56:57 Okay, Town Council starts at 4. Oh, wow. And I'm hard cut off at 345, so just FYI. Do you want to do the contract review now and then we'll go to closed session? We can try to get through it. It's an important item. I don't want to, you know, I want to make sure we have enough time to get through it because there may be questions and so forth, but sure. Well, before we do that, how much were you paying Tim to sit around and listen to this?
1:57:26 Yeah, so, you know, if we could go and close session, I know this is important, but we've already run the clock for a bunch of stuff, so. Go into closed session, I'll make a phone call. Okay. There you go. You had a request for comment, Laura? You were asking about process? Can we do that after the closed session? Okay, thank you. We've lost two board members. So the report out is that we've provided direction to council for next steps.
1:58:17 And nothing further than that. Given timing and delays, I know we have a recommendation from the committee for John's contract is the next item. I don't think we can get through that in a reasonable period of time. I'd like to suggest that we have a special session for that. I'd like to ask when we have that special session that we have in addition to the recommendations from the committee that was shared in Granicus, I'd like to see some benchmarking data that goes along with that if we could, please. Sure.
1:58:50 Is everyone open to that? Have another session? Yep, so when? Good question. I'm out of town the 13th through the 19th. I don't know if we'll solve that right this minute. Probably have to do a doodle poll and see who's available with the goal of trying to do something in the next 10 days or less. You're leaving on the 13th? Are people around next week? Gone the first part of the week. I don't leave until late night, 13th, so I can do something in the morning.
1:59:26 Maybe something in the morning of the 13th would be possible. 13th? Okay. Can we give Laura an opportunity to address it? Laura, you had a comment you wanted to share with the board? Yeah. Just going back to the process from the retail board seat press release. As we all know, this organization is always criticized in regards to transparency. So I wanted to clarify some of the chairman's comments from earlier in response to some of the local media.
1:59:59 being upset with those comments. We did send out a press release. It was not a paid legal ad. The newspapers are not required to run a press release. Point number one, which I fully understand. We all fully understand. The deadline was originally May 1st, and we sent out the press release on April 15th. None of the papers picked it up. The Mammoth Times, I later found out it was because their editor
2:00:28 was in transition, so it didn't get picked up there. The sheet generally does not run our press releases, so I did not expect them to pick it up. So as of the May 1 deadline, we did have one applicant, but we were concerned, again, for transparency reasons, that it didn't run in the papers. So I requested that we extend it. The Mammoth Times told me that they would run it if we extended the deadline, which they did, and we received other applications.
2:00:58 I just wanted to clarify all that because we were highly criticized a little while ago. So I just wanted to make sure that everyone understands we are clear on those points. And that was the reason the process was the way it did. Sorry if I misunderstood that process. What's that? Sorry if I misunderstood that process. That's okay. Like I said, I just wanted to clarify. And going forward, the board may want to consider running the board seat applications as a legal ad.
2:01:26 I would suggest that. Then we have proof of record. Yeah, that's a good point. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Are we obligated to share our finances this time? Finances are posted, so they're available. Okay, so what we, I don't know if you've missed, given our time where we're at, we are going to suggest a special session to review the contract on the 13th. Fine. Okay. Okay. Okay. And Jamie's doing, it's like, get out of the way, because council's coming.
2:01:54 Our next meeting is scheduled for July 3rd. I guess you can talk about that at the next meeting, but the rescheduled meeting on the 13th, but that probably needs to be discussed, if that still works for everyone. Could you send out a doodle that's July 13th timing, or sorry, June 13th timing, and then also maybe the second week of July, if that's better for people to see when people are actually available? Okay.
2:02:19 I'll follow up. I mean, it's going to be busy. Yeah, I almost think you just keep it at the third. I'm fine as the third. I just don't know if everybody else. When we change them, I miss them. I'll be drinking. I'm working. Third is. Keep the third. That's fine. We'll work the third. Okay. I haven't sent it. Okay. With that, then the meeting is adjourned. Thank you. Eric, when the zip line open? Good question.