TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2019

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 2 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

556 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:50 Okay, call this council meeting of June, August 7th. Here. Here. Yes. Here. Please join with me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

2:37 Public comments. This is the time on the agenda or anybody wishing to speak on anything that is not on the agenda to come forward, please. Thank you. Afternoon, Mayor, members of the Council. My name is Justin Nalder, Solid Waste Superintendent with Mono County. And I just wanted to stand up and kind of give you a real brief update on the happenings in the solid waste world as we approach closure for Benton Crossing Landfill.

3:12 Let you know that we've been steadily working and making progress through a comprehensive approach, developing an RFP and hosting Solid Waste Task Force meetings, of which the town has been present and contributing substantially. So we have a lot of good things in the works. We don't have anything that's definitive just yet, but it's looking good and we know that we're on.

3:39 A timeline and we fully anticipate to be on schedule to transition into whatever this new comprehensive approach may look like. With that, I will ask for any questions. What options are you looking at? I mean, what are the top options for dealing with this? And it kind of depends on what waste stream we're talking about and more than likely...

4:08 The waste streams will get partitioned. On the county side of things, we have another piece of property that's south of Mono Lake, Pumice Valley Landfill. It's already a permitted and operational landfill. We'll just modify the capacities that we're currently receiving. And so most of the waste that we receive could go through there.

4:33 And within the town, Mammoth Disposal is looking at expansion for waste types and amounts that they can receive. And as far as other waste streams, it's kind of to be determined who will handle those, but a transition will take place. It won't occur at Benton Crossing any longer. We'll still have all the same services, if not more, just in a different location. And how far along are you on looking at the finances of...

5:02 All of these changes that are taking place. A good question. And we're kind of in the preliminary phases of that. Depending on which element goes which direction, it may change. So we're still preliminary. Thank you. Any other questions? Thank you very much. Anyone else for public comment? Hello. I am Christy Williams.

5:39 With MLTPA, I was here last meeting. Excuse me. I am a project management specialist with MLTPA. And we're here to thank you for your vote of confidence last meeting. And sorry, I just ran up the stairs. I got caught at the signal. So here to thank you for your vote of confidence, to let you know that officially I have been designated by the MLTPA Foundation Board.

6:09 To manage the contract with the town and with MLTPA. Also want to introduce our operations manager, Gretchen Hasselbauer. Do you want to say anything? Quick update? Sure. I'm Gretchen Hasselbauer. I'm the new operations manager. Excited to be working for MLTPA and working with you guys in the future. So thank you. Thanks. Thank you. Any further public comments?

6:41 We will close public comments and move on to Councilmember Reports. John, we will start with you tonight. Thank you, Mayor Sauser. Yes. It has a nice ring to it. July 18th, I attended the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District meeting up in Merkleyville. The only will, I mean, there's a lot of interesting discussion, but the bylaws of the Air District will need to be updated to accommodate an alternate. So that's a...

7:11 Sort of a bureaucratic technical thing that will come back to us here at some point. I spent, July 19th, I spent about an hour with Bobby Tanner down in Red's Meadow, had a productive conversation on a number of topics, the things that he brought up of concern. We had a good conversation. July 22nd, MLH had a very interesting design workshop over at Starbucks for the MLH property over in Manor Road. Attended that, that was very interesting. July 22nd, I attended the Bishop City Council meeting on behalf of the ESCOT JPA.

7:40 It was an interesting discussion, a little bit of work to do there to get everything kind of lined up.

7:45 The Chamber Luncheon on July 23rd, Mark Brownlee was a featured speaker. He gave a very interesting presentation on where Mammoth Resorts are at and their infrastructure investments and all the things that they're working on. July 24th, I was fortunate to have a nice meeting with the parcel team, with Grady and the folks there, and we had a very interesting good conversation. It was very helpful. I also met with Curtis Shapiro for the Chamber Workforce Housing effort, and I was enormously impressed.

8:11 By the work that Curtis is doing and the Chamber is doing around workforce housing with their effort. I think that's going to be a very interesting complement to all the various housing things we're working on. It's great to see that coming together. Also, I think it was a very good thing to have gotten the Chamber its own contract and gotten it out from under MLT. August 3rd, the Trail Days event up in Coldwater. A little attendance, maybe not quite so big because Blues of Blues was...

8:35 You know, taking up everybody's attention. August 5th, on Monday, my last MLH board meeting. Thank the board and wish them luck. They've got a new strategic plan. We have a new representative on the board in Kirk Stapp. And new board, new strategic plan. I think there's a lot of great work coming, good to come out of that group. And yesterday, on behalf of the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, I journeyed back up to Markleyville in Alpine County.

8:59 Made a presentation and now Alpine County is very interested in joining in the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership. So that would mean Mono, Mammoth, Alpine, we'll see, get Inu and Bishop on there and that would be nice to get that whole region represented. Those are my updates. Thank you. Okay. I also met with Curtis Shapiro on the 25th and agree. Very impressive.

9:26 I think he's making great progress quickly in sort of what we had asked for and what we had wanted to see, so I feel pretty confident about that. Today I attended my first meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board and a couple of decisions were made there. Mr. Erdi, the Executive Director's contract was approved and the new chair into the coming year will be John Morris. So that's all I have your phone. Kirk. Yes.

9:56 I'd like to thank the town staff, Grady and his crew and everybody else and Joel. If you ride the bike trails, you'll see that all of the cracks and everything else have been covered. They've done an excellent job if you're out and about using bike trails. Mammoth Lake Housing, the architectural...

10:19 Representative was there on the Sierra Manor Road. We looked at three different major option. I think option two, 11 units that we can get there, plus snow storage, plus I think enough parking.

10:35 The parking is always the issue in conflict with the snow removal. We also got an update on the parcel update. Town staff is not happy with me because I keep bugging them about going faster and getting more done sooner.

10:55 Just really frustrating as a council member and seeing people living in the woods and everything else. And so staff has kind of chastised me for pushing on them, which I accept. Also, we went and looked at the housing mitigation ordinance summary, and we're making comments also on the general plan. A few comments.

11:24 Mostly just simply wordied wordage and the general plan. So both Patricia and Jennifer are making comments and hopefully those will be incorporated just for clarity. It's not that they're challenging it. It's just, you know, okay, what's the difference?

11:45 Between this definition, workforce housing and community housing and just, again, getting a good, clear document that the community can use. That's my update. Cleland. Let's see. So for Councilmember Reports, I did attend the Mono County Collaborative Planning Team CPT. That was on July 25th.

12:13 Thank you, Sandra and Kim, for the Resilient Mammoth Lakes Project information there. We had Matt Perillo with the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership give an update on that. And also, just one, another reminder for Southern California Edison, we did receive a...

12:34 A talk about the Edison Wildlife Mitigation Plan and Public Safety Power Shutoff Program. This is something that if you have not, please go to Southern California Edison and make sure that you're signed up for that because with the weather, we have had two different parts of the stages where they're going to cut off the power due to, it's based on weather reports and all this other stuff, but it's

13:00 Even to the extent if you have health issues to the problem that you're not able to leave your house, they'll even come knock on your door and let you know and give you a warning that, hey, you're not going to have electricity. So good reminder. And that's all I have to report. My report is pretty simple. I have met with several people, mostly from MLT in the last week. But more importantly,

13:28 I would like to move our council member reports back to the back of the agenda instead of the front of the agenda. For time purposes, I just think it works better. So with your approval, we will do that. Moving on to additions to the agenda. I understand we have one item that has come to our attention since the packet went out. So Dan or Andy, whichever of you would like to.

13:54 Yes, the town has been sued. We received a copy of a lawsuit on Monday. It has to do with challenging the TBID and the TOT ordinance, and it names the town, the Mountain, the Mountain's parent company, MLT, Mr. Gregory, Mr. Erty. It's an interesting...

14:14 Lawsuit. I'm not sure it has any merit whatsoever, but we should probably talk about it in closed session. So I would suggest that the council make the finding that there's need to take immediate action, which is true, and that came to the council's attention after the agenda was posted, which is also true. And if four of the five of you at least agree with that and make those findings, we can add it to the agenda as a closed session item. Do we need a motion for that or can we consensus? Let me read you the motion we need and then go from there.

14:41 It would be pursuant to Government Code Section 54954.2b2. The Council hereby determines that there is a need to take immediate action and that the need for the action came to the attention of the Town subsequent to the agenda being posted as specified in Subdivision A, the item being a closed session, conference with legal counsel, existing litigation pursuant to Paragraph 1 of Subdivision D of Section 54956.9.

15:09 Main Street Taxpayer Association versus Town of Mammoth Lakes.

15:14 Second.

15:16 Motion and a second. Any further deliberation?

15:19 Roll call, please.

15:20 Council Member Hall? Yes.

15:22 Council Member Stapp? Yes.

15:23 Council Member Webber? Yes.

15:24 Mayor Pro Tem, Celcius? Yes.

15:26 Mayor Selsen. Yes.

15:28 So we will add that to the end of tonight's...

15:33 You know, I have one other complaint to make.

15:36 Oh, please.

15:36 The last council made, period.

15:39 Last council meeting, I was appointed mayor. I thank you for your trust in me. And we had more items on the agenda than I've ever seen on an agenda. So that being said, I'm waiting anxiously for this week's packet. And there are more pages in it than I have ever seen in an agenda. This has got to be a conspiracy. Anyway, we will move on now. Staff presentations, quarterly TOT enforcement update. Rob, I'm assuming that's you.

16:12 Thank you, the department had our reports from commissions. Oh, yeah, you know what, I did not, I'm just moving us right along. We will go to reports from commissions and or departments as needed. Good evening, Town Council, Tom Perry, building official. I wanted to take this opportunity to give you a couple updates as to a few things going on in the building department. First thing I wanted to update you on is that we had a...

16:41 We had a class, a seminar this last Friday right here in Sweet C. It was specific to new California state codes that take effect on January 1st of 2020. So that's always a great concern to our builders and designers here in town. So we had a class last Friday specific to the new residential code requirements. I had a pretty unique opportunity to get a great presenter up here. It's a guy named Paul Armstrong who's been in the business for many, many years as a consultant.

17:11 He lives in Southern California, loves to come up to vacation in Mammoth. And he had offered about a year ago to come up to do a presentation for free, which is great because it usually runs about $1,200. So that was pretty cool. And he's also been presenting at large conventions for years, and he's one of the best presenters I've ever seen. So he was really good. It was quite the opportunity to get him up. So I put the word out, a lot of advertising on it.

17:37 It was well attended for our standards. It was 22 people, which for our little neck of the woods, that's a pretty good turnout. The crowd was very engaged. They were really into it, and it went well. And so I just want to let you know that we did do that. And I have another one actually in the wings for this fall specific to the energy code. There's some changes there on the energy front, probably more profound changes in that code than any other code coming up for the next code cycle.

18:06 So I have in the works right now somebody from the California Energy Commission who is tentatively committed to coming up in the fall to do a presentation on those code changes. So that's in the works as well. The second item, as you probably know, I got the, you know, go ahead to pursue pre-engineered or prescriptive designs, which are designs that the building public can use that are pre-engineered that save people the time and expense of having to get an engineer for specific jobs.

18:33 Those job types, this is a refresher, were exterior decks, guardrails, that kind of thing, stairs, handrails, and protective covers at entries where we have shedding snow on a front door, front entry. So those are, they're well underway. They started back in June. I expect to see probably

18:56 Some plans my way here to do a review on here really soon, probably no later than the end of the month. We'll do a review on it, just like how we do with the public. I think it's fair that we review what we do, just like how the public has a review from an outside independent reviewer. And then when it goes through that, once we get public input, of course it'll be...

19:17 Brand by the Contractors Association and other people in the public. I hope to have these designs ready to go sometime this fall. So just an update on that. So it's moving along pretty good. And then last item I just wanted to brief you on was I do have two items that I'll be bringing to you as a formal agenda item. One will be an update to our Chapter 15, which is buildings and construction specific to the topic of lofts, which, if you remember, was an issue some years ago.

19:45 Long story short is I had worked extensively with the public on trying to put together some type of policy that would work for them and also have the benefit of, you know, making sure that we have safe, compliant lofts here in town. So I'll be going into that in more detail when I present that, as well as I'll be giving you an update as to how it went with our snow load and our other design criteria.

20:08 Because we had that evaluated some time ago to see what our snow loads were doing and all that. So I'll be touching on that in more detail on that item as well. In addition, a couple other small edits to Chapter 15. It's looking like I'll bring that to you next month, sometime in September. Another item after that, later in the fall, definitely no later than December, will be the formal adoption of the new state codes. The new state codes take effect on January 1, 2020. And we usually do this.

20:36 Maneuver every three years at the formal adoption of said code, so that'll be coming up in the future. So just a brief update on a couple things. Any questions or comments from the board? Questions? Thank you. Okay, thank you. Good evening. Thank you, council members, Mr. Mayor. My name is Joel Rathje. I'm the trails coordinator for the town, and I just have several things to update you on. First, Bill, I'm happy to announce that the state has awarded our final

21:10 Grant approval for our OHV grant opportunity in Shady Rest in your craters area. That came in a couple nights ago. There's a 30-day appeal period. We don't expect an appeal, but there is that 30-day grace period. Secondly, the Horseshoe Lake Loop Bridge is constructed and finished and looks really great. That was a nice partnership between CAL FIRE, helped us move some material, International Forest Engineering staff.

21:38 Also, town staff and MLR helped to raise some money for the materials. It happened and it's done. And for our highest use soft surface trail in the lake's basin, that's a big deal to trail users. Kirk, thanks for mentioning the pathway crack filling. That goes from Mammoth Creek Park east, east of the tunnel there, all the way around to almost the RV park wrapping around so far. So we're getting there, steady and sure. It'll be done hopefully in the next several weeks.

22:06 I want to also express some gratitude to the folks that showed up to our trail day. I was out of town. Thanks to all those that helped us out. So the Southern Mono Historical Society made it really fun with some music, added another dimension to the event. So thanks to them.

22:21 Also, we're under construction on the Panorama Dome area on a mountain bike trail doing a reroute that was approved recently. That was really fun. I was out there today working in the dirt, making sure things were getting done right, and grateful to have that project going. Lastly, the Sherwins Area Recreation Plan Phase 2 decision memo has been signed by our ranger from the Mammoth District, so we'll be able to proceed with final design work on a trailhead for the Sherwins.

22:49 And also a piece of single track connecting to some other trails. So that's good news as well. That's all I have. If you have any questions, I'm happy to answer them. That's a lot. Thank you. It is a lot. Well done. Thank you. Any further staff? Okay, Rob, now I get to go on to you again. Yes, thank you. So tonight we're going to talk about our fourth quarter enforcement update.

23:19 As you're aware, we've done this. We do this quarterly, talking about the efforts that the revenue team is doing to utilize our host compliance software, as well as just, you know, analyzing the rental landscape, if you will, within the town. And this update is intended really to bring you up to speed on, you know, the activity that we see, the new items that we're seeing, the new issues that are arising from the efforts and the energy.

23:46 They were putting into it and just, you know, the accomplishments of the team. So I'm very proud of the work that they're doing. My main component about the enforcement was to utilize the tools that we were given. And with that was we wanted to do daily monitoring. So we're looking at that system at least an hour every single day looking for issues that are out there. What we find is we're catching, and I've talked about this before, we're catching

24:14 People within a couple of days of putting an ad up, it's very, very quick, which is good from the aspect of we're sort of doing a service to them to say, listen, before you get into too much trouble, perhaps with rentals that are illegal, you need to come to us and talk about doing this correctly. So I think it's been a pretty good service to the community, that level of effort and energy, and the team is really embracing it. Let me pull this up, so maybe.

24:45 Man, that's a long way away. This familiar chart is the activity that we do. So we certainly issue citations in order to get people's attention to say, we've identified your item out there and we see that you're doing some activity. We want you to come and talk to us. That first $500 citation, they have 15 days with which to respond to it. And if they do come and talk to us or call us in that 15 days, we waive that citation. If they don't, we'll have to enter.

25:23 To perform an assessment, start issuing larger citations, and again, the idea is to get their attention. We, in this last quarter, and I'll talk quarterly as well as yearly, because this one ended in June 30th, we issued a total of 42 citations in that three-month time period. And that's pretty substantial. That's about a third of what we did for the entire year. So you can see the effort and energy that was going on.

25:50 During that, we have a good process for the citations as well. For example, if prior to coming to council, there's a citation hearing that can be conducted to talk about the reasons why citations had to go as far as they did. And we've been working through those. We probably do, in the last month, we've probably done about six or seven citation hearings. And those have been very successful as far as identifying reasons and actually, frankly, reducing the number that we're...

26:19 We're enforcing in the citation world, which again is not our intent to drive up revenue from this process. It's really more compliance and quick response. Like I said, if they don't respond to the citation, we do an assessment. Our assessment is essentially three years worth of activity based upon their nightly rental rate and the average booking rate for a hotel in town. So it's fairly substantial. People get excited about that. It's usually larger than the actual activity.

26:48 But that's what an assessment is, and it takes a bit of effort for us to do that. So once we've done all this stuff, we're in an enforcement case, so that's where the enforcement charges actually come into play. The notice of determination, which is the NOD that's issued, that's the final sort of, we have your information, this is what we believe to be your billings and information that are out there that you owe taxes on and perhaps penalties and interest and so forth.

27:18 And so that's that level of activity. Again, fairly substantial in the last quarter. We had 17 of the 21 for the year. And then talking about the violations and dollars collected, again, really...

27:33 We've ramped down the budget expectations for these numbers over the last year, and this 19-20 is a smaller number as well because we're catching them sooner and those numbers are not expected to be large, even if we're doing a lot of activity and capturing people that are out there. So I'm happy with the performance. I think it's representative of what the council has wanted us to do with enforcement, and the team is doing well with that.

27:59 This is a little snapshot we talk about for host compliance, looking at the number of short-term rental units that are being advertised in the town, 3,329, and what was added in the last month. It's very seasonal based upon the time of the year. This one, you know, certainly 29 is not a big number. We'll see this into the hundreds when we get into the wintertime. But the identified number is 96.1. That exceeds our 95% target that we had out there. It's just at the beginning of the year.

28:30 A little bit about the updates. As we remember, we went back through the, in the quarter, we did a fee update. And in that fee process, we memorialized the $500 enforcement charge. That was one that we'd had people sort of challenged from time to time. And that is now a part of our fee structure that says there are two actual enforcement charges, one being a base 500, which covers cost of having the software cost of the team.

29:01 Spending time on that enforcement work, the amount of effort that goes into that, the mailings and all those different types of things. Those are cost recovery elements. The other one we have is for the base 500 plus any charges that we want to do. There are some very challenging enforcement cases where we have to actually go out and rent the facility. So if we rent the property, we will pay for it, but then we'll go ahead and charge them.

29:26 In the enforcement case for the cost it took to do that. So we recover those fees that are there, but really the idea is that we have this pretty robust program and we were going to actually cost us money to do. So the other thing, and really more of an update on things that we've seen, we started to see some scams out there where we've had an advertisement that was published on Airbnb and it was just a picture of a photo of a bed.

29:56 And it was advertising for a property that this person had no right to rent, did not have ownership of, but they were basically setting it up to say, go ahead and pay me the money, and then when you show up in town, there will be no facility for you to rent that you're in. So a complete scam. We do notify Airbnb about that and ask them, you know, please take this ad down, because ultimately it's going to impact us and people's experience within our town.

30:24 Thank you.

30:56 Talking about our current goals and efforts, you know, we've been working with post-compliance for a year now, a little more than a year, actually, and I've challenged the team with looking at the other modules, other things that we could possibly engage with the tool as it's developed over time, how we can utilize that. So that's one of the things we're going to be researching over the next three months is to see if there's something out there we can utilize, and if so, we may bring it forward as a request to council. We'll be a little bit more money than...

31:24 More spending, but we've seen so much value from the program that it's pretty strong and worthwhile. The educational and training, again, developing multiple streams of communication. That's what we find with most of our enforcement cases is that people need many different ways of being communicated with. And so they'll often, whatever we're using as a direct line of communication, whether it be the advertisements in the newspaper or other things, they weren't just really

31:52 Hitting home. So we gather the information from each of the enforcement cases. What information do you know and what information do you hear about from the town? And we try to find an alternate path with which we can communicate. And that way people are just educated. That's the key point is most of the people that get in trouble are ones that just don't understand that they're in business or know the right rules to follow. So we're doing a lot on town e-news. We're writing that in advance so we can get that stuff out there.

32:21 We're working on a taxable items list. It should be straightforward, but it's a little bit complicated based upon information from Airbnb or those folks when they're giving multiple charges, one to the person renting, one to the person who's renting the property, the other one who's the operator who's renting the property. There's different sets of charges.

32:43 I've been trying to figure out exactly which one is taxable. We've had some confusion around that with the community or with the business community. So we're working on just clarifying that and educating that process. We did a letter to new property owners. If you bought a home in 2018 or 19, then we sent that letter out. We're going to do that twice a year so we can capture folks and just sort of more of a public service, please be aware. It's something that's in the real estate agreements.

33:13 But we just found that it's a little bit more prevalent if we mail it out. It was successful. We're also exploring transient rental prohibited signs. When we say exploring that, it's the possibility of having these signs that are up in the non-zoned areas saying that this area is not legal for transient rental.

33:37 We'll kind of get it in the eyes of the people who are renting. If you're renting a place and you drive by a sign that says it's not legal to do that here, you might not want to do that. So that's something we're looking out to kind of fill in the blanks a little bit and bring back to council as a recommendation before we would do anything. But these would be signs similar to like a neighborhood watch size sign that would go in a particular area. The regional partnerships.

34:05 We've been working really good reaching out to peer sort of resorts and getting information from them about how they conduct these enforcement activities, the issues that they have with their transient rental community, and we're gleaning information from that. We're utilizing that to put it into our processes to improve them, but we're also building sort of a packet of here's what we do. What we're finding is Mammoth is...

34:30 Blessed with having the volumes that we do, so we have the opportunity to learn a lot more than other communities. So as we take a little bit from them, we're also sharing some of our best practices and processes, and I think it's been pretty productive for all involved. Talking about the audit program, last year we launched the audit program, and that has been pretty successful. We did twice as many as we had basically signed up to do.

35:00 This year, we have a target of 50 audits for small accounts and 10 large accounts. And they can take some serious amount of effort and energy, but I think at the end of the day, there's an educational piece to them, and we definitely have clarity around what's going on. And the word gets out. We're targeting sort of each of the rental areas, an item in each, so that the word will get out that we are doing audits and make sure that they're on the up and up.

35:33 I believe that's it. Any questions? On the rental data landscape, that was, you didn't quite, let's see, next page, four. Let me just get it popped up here. Okay, so where it says that there's 3,329 units identified by host compliance, and then there's over 5,000 short-term rental listings.

36:06 Does that mean that we're shy 2,000 some for recognizing or what's the difference? So that means there's 3,329 units out there and there are 5,000 advertisements for those units. So there will be multiple advertisements for some units. Oh, oh, okay. Yeah, that's just the number that are in flight. So that's the listing, not the... Okay, thank you. Yep, you're welcome. Any other questions? Yeah, a couple quick questions.

36:35 I noticed in here that there's a couple of long-term rentals listed in there. That's just people using the Airbnb platform to do long-term rentals 30 days or longer, correct? Yeah. Okay. One of the frustrations, I think, and one of the opportunities is how do we use this, the work that you're doing to start identifying an inventory of how many long-term units we have in town?

36:57 It's a gap that keeps kind of falling through the cracks. And I think when you guys start exploring the modules, it'd be really helpful to figure out if there's a way to start getting an inventory of how many long-term units we have. It goes to housing needs. We don't know what our inventory is for long-term rental units. It'd be really helpful to know that as we make decisions and allocate resources to do that. The other thing is I would really encourage you, I know Councilmember Salcido and I would be more than happy to join you in getting together with Curtis Shapiro.

37:27 And looking at, he's got a lot of very interesting data and technology tools that he's using as part of his program. And one of the things we did, we brought MLH, when Jennifer was the executive director, as part of your TOT team, started looking how we could cross-reference data sources, because I think it's very important that we don't ever get complacent with this Airbnb stuff. This stuff is constantly changing. I mean, I hear many stories about how it's going underground, and people aren't even using the platform anymore, but it's an ongoing, very vibrant.

37:56 Andy, I know that there were several lawsuits cooking around the community and in the country on

38:25 Airbnb platforms and controls, local controls on that. Any updates on that? Not really. There's litigation perking along in Boston and I think in New York. In Santa Monica, you know, where you recall that the city prevailed both in the trial court and at the Ninth Circuit. Airbnb has asked for the full Ninth Circuit or at least...

38:43 15 of them to rehear the case instead of just the three-judge panel. I don't think that that petition has been heard yet, but I am following that actively because as soon as we find out that Santa Monica has finally and ultimately prevailed in that litigation, which I think they will.

39:00 I anticipate that a number of cities, Mammoth among them, will be very interested in looking at an ordinance just like Santa Monica's. Santa Monica's ordinance essentially prohibits Airbnb from accepting rental listings for properties that are not registered to pay TOT. Okay, so it puts the onus on them. It does. There's some tricky...

39:21 Legal reasoning in there about why that is or is not legal, but that's the gist of it. Santa Monica wanted to have more control, and of course the platforms are not very happy about that. So if Santa Monica prevails, I think that ordinances based on that one, which we'll have already held up in court, will probably proliferate throughout the state. And I'll keep you posted. Thank you. Any other questions? Moving on. Thank you. Thank you. This is when I get to go and take a nap and turn the gavel.

39:56 Over to the Pro Tem. Do you want me to state for the record your conflict before you leave? Yeah, I have a conflict on the parcel. This is the parcel update. So I will be snoozing. Okay, so let's take this item on now, the parcel update. Great.

40:35 Thank you. I'm going to do a brief introduction. I'll turn it over to Amy and Sandra for some, and then I'll do a wrap-up at the end. One thing I'd like to point out is we're not going to read everything in the staff report. We would rarely do that. We assume that everybody's had a chance to look at it.

40:49 But because we consider this meeting another step and another piece of our public engagement, we are going to show on the screen some of the things that we're working on and everything else and go through it in some detail. Because, again, anybody who's in the audience or sitting at home, we want to make sure that they get it as well. And we want to take every opportunity we can to get to the public. Generally, in the last few weeks, though, since our last update, we've been prepping for the Plan the Parcel workshop. That's really...

41:16 Really the biggest chunk of that and we'll get into that. First off though I'd like to turn it over to Amy. Amy is coordinating with LWC and our other consultants and resources on the public engagement aspect. There's a couple things and meetings in the staff report that we have done since our last update including some

41:37 Some stuff we did at Softball, the Rotary Club, and others. And then also we just recently put some stuff up online. I'd like Amy to walk through that so that we can all understand how it is and how we use it, frankly. So with that, Amy, thank you. So you should have all received an email within the last few days inviting you to participate in the Engage Mammoth Lakes platform online in a couple of different ways. The first one is a

42:06 It's a brief survey. It's really just a one or two question survey around the development objectives that came out of the workshop in an effort to...

42:17 Ask the public their opinion and effectively ask them to rank their priority development objectives. We've included the survey on the Engage Mammoth Lakes platform asking people to choose their top 10 of the 25 or so development objectives. So we are already in the couple of days that it's been live. We've received a few responses. The second opportunity to participate online is a map your comments tool and it references these preliminary

42:47 Concept plans that you see up on the screen right now. These are background information on the parcel and the surrounding areas that are being used to prepare for the design workshop and to educate the public about the current existing conditions around the parcel and then with the effort of trying to solicit some feedback on what

43:15 What we may have missed? What other comments do you have that you don't see already represented on these posters, these maps? So there are five different maps here that are referenced in that engaged Mammoth Lakes online platform that we have asked the public to review. And then to go onto the map and drag a pin to the map and place a comment in a location on the map that may be relevant to the comment that they're

43:44 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

44:16 I don't know if you have any questions specifically about these maps or about the Engagement with Lakes platform before I move on. Yeah, where can you find these maps on the website? They're on the parcel website under the Conceptual Land Use Planning tab. Right. And under Preliminary Concept Plans. And if you also click on the link that was in the email sent out regarding the Engagement with Lakes platform, it should take you directly to the documents.

44:47 That's very good. I got to it through that. Great. Okay. It's also linked via the Engage Mammoth Lakes Map Your Comments tool. Got it. Okay. So these maps, yeah, there are PDFs that are separate. They're not part of the tool itself. They're not part of the tool. Right. We're using the Engage Mammoth Lakes tool not as a site to host information. We're hosting all of our information on the Town of Mammoth Lakes website. It's easier for us to control that way. And that way we can provide the links.

45:17 On engagement with legs to direct people to documents that they may want to review or see that are hosted on our website. Okay. Thank you. Welcome. Amy, a quick question. If you could describe after you get through this, make sure we touch on the two Spanish-speaking workshops we're going to do in August as well. That's nice. Right. Thank you.

45:39 Moving on from the Engage Mammoth Lakes, the next big thing that we have going on are two community meetings that will be presented in English but simultaneously translated into Spanish. We're using the services of Catherine Allen, a professional translator and interpreter who's based in Bishop. She's familiar to this community and does a lot of work for Mona County Office of Ed, Behavioral Health, the school districts, and whatnot. We've sent out invitations for that meeting via email.

46:08 Recently created a couple of flyers, double-sided, Spanish and English. So we are flyering the town, dropping off stacks at local businesses. I've asked several local community members to distribute the information to employees, staff, as much as we can to get the information about these meetings out there. The first meeting is going to be held on August 11th at the Aspen Village Community Center.

46:41 And the second meeting on Saturday, August 17th at the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And this is in partnership with Mammoth Lakes Housing, who is providing refreshments for the evening. So we're looking forward to hopefully hosting as many of the Spanish-speaking community as we can see. We've also created Facebook events for these particular events. Those are going to be promoted and pushed out through Facebook. I have requested several of our local

47:12 Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you.

47:37 And really quickly before we get to the design workshop, Chandler in the planning department has recorded a radio spot on KMMH. So if you are listening to any of our local radio channels, hopefully you will hear Chandler's lovely radio voice. And I believe he's doing an interview on the community corner. Is that next week? Yeah, next week. Okay. So and then that leads into the design workshop itself.

48:06 Are you going to take it? I can talk about that. I'll pull up the flyer, which is in your pack. No, not that one. One quick question before we get to that. Yes, I'm sorry. The transit stop data, did that come from ESTA? Because I know we've, it's been a little goofy getting exactly where, I just wonder where the source that data is for the transit stops, and if you believe it's reliable. The process has involved ESTA, it has involved our GIS data, as well as some.

48:37 Boots on the ground confirmation of transit stops and routes. So to the best of our knowledge, this is as accurate as we know at this time. Any other questions? Just a comment. Chandler came and spoke to Mammoth Voices last week and he did a great job. He and Sandra together were a great team and very impressive. So thank you for that. Just one quick question, Amy, before we move on to Sandra and the workshop and later.

49:10 Town Council PDC workshops. The outreach that we did, and again, this is for the benefit of the public that's in your staff report, though, you went to the softball games, and that was the success? You said you had a lot of good interaction? I think the softball game was the most successful of the four or five sort of information intent outreach events that we've had. It was...

49:33 Almost entirely or 100% locals and I'd say even 50% Spanish speakers. We had a lot of kids come by asking for tamales, but we sent them along with flyers to bring to the parents and it was fun, it was successful. We have to talk about it with staff, but we may have an opportunity to do that again next week during the softball playoff games in an effort to

50:02 Invite in-person community to both the Spanish meetings and the workshop the following week.

50:08 And we also went to Rotary. I think Chandler went and did that one. We got some great feedback, which is in your staff report, and if you have any questions about that. But I highlighted some of the information there because it was really insightful, you know, what their comments were. And we frankly engaged them, and I know Chandler did a great job at the end saying, okay, guys, now you're ambassadors. Now we need you to get out there and tell everybody else. And for the benefit of the public, I just want to ask again, if you have a group that would like to hear more about the parcel, we will schedule it. We will be there, but we're having trouble just...

50:38 It's getting people to call us. We've called them. If you know of anybody else, let them know, and we'll try our best to schedule it and get out there as individuals and get the word out, because that's really important in advance of the design workshop, especially. And then afterwards, when we have something to show everybody, we'll do it again. Thanks, Amy. Alexandra, talk about the workshop. Do you want to go to the flyer? Yes.

51:04 So this is included in your packet, and this has really been our kind of short version of what the multi-day design workshop will be. It's really kind of intended to just give people a brief idea of what we're doing each day.

51:19 And help to encourage people to attend. And so on this flyer here, we talk about drop-in for any amount of time at your convenience. But I think we are encouraging people, if you only have 15 minutes, come by for 15 minutes. But if you have more time, please come for as much time as you can. And generally, as this workshop will be going on, we'll be focusing on big...

51:42 Big items on Wednesday, so kind of major design items on Wednesday, and then kind of honing in on smaller and smaller and smaller throughout the week. So each evening there will be a studio pin-up from 4.30 to 5.30 on Wednesday, 7 to 8 on Thursday, and 6 to 8, I'm sorry, 6 to 8 is the closing presentation on Friday. But those studio pin-ups are an opportunity for the public to come in and kind of see what

52:07 What did we talk about during the day? What ideas came to the surface? What things are we talking about? And kind of where are we moving tomorrow? So that's a really good opportunity, I think, for the public. If they want to just kind of come in and see what happened that day, that's...

52:19 That's what I would recommend. And that's a time when we are taking comments from people. So that idea may not fit and that might not be quite right. So I think that's a really good opportunity for the public to come in and participate. Does anyone have any questions about the particular schedule for the design workshop? I can move on to kind of some information about what is a design workshop next. So our consultant...

52:47 Put this PowerPoint together just to give people an idea of what is a design workshop because not very many people have actually participated in one.

52:57 So, yeah, if you want to go to the second page. So a design workshop isn't just a one-day brainstorming event. It's not, you know, a marathon where everyone has to be there all the entire time of the entire workshop, and it's not just a really, really long meeting. What it is is really working together to design a project, and it's a process that's open to really all interested parties, and we encourage interested parties, like I mentioned, to attend.

53:25 With feedback loops. So that's really that open studio pinup where we're kind of checking in, how are we doing, are we on the right track? And the goal is that it results in a detailed feasible plan. The key word, I think, being feasible. So fiscally, financially feasible, and feasible on the ground. So design workshop readiness, what does it take? So it takes, you know, people, it takes information, data, the place, and...

53:53 All of us working together to be ready for the design workshop. So just some slides on kind of who attends the design workshop and our roles. So we have the team, that's the consultants and the staff team. So a multidisciplinary team of specialists kind of using all of our information along with that local expertise of stakeholders to develop a feasible plan.

54:16 And then the stakeholders, you know, they're there to give us their local expertise. So I think that that's the opportunity for them to bring up things that, you know, the consultants or the staff might not know about the parcel. Maybe they live adjacent to the parcel. They know there's certain issues with property there. So that's their opportunity to help us get more information about the site. And this slide just kind of describes that feedback loop. So kind of developing those.

54:44 Alternative concepts, talking about our preferred alternatives, testing those, and then ending up with refined preferred alternatives.

54:53 And then the other slides are just kind of some visuals of what will happen. So you see that group all looking at those maps. So our consultants will be actually drawing plans this entire time. So during the open studio time, that's a time for the public to come in to talk to the consultants, to talk to staff, and to watch those designers really kind of designing the site based on the public and the staff comments. And we'll have visual...

55:21 Preference Feedback Survey, so it'll be an opportunity for people to say, well, I really like this type of a building, but not this, and you can see that these participants are doing that there. And then the open studio is that, also that designing, showing someone actually drawing those plans there. And then the pin-up review at the end of the day, each day on Tuesday, I'm...

55:44 Yeah, Wednesday and Thursday, where the public is able to come in and really kind of comment, and we refine those concepts kind of right on the spot there as we're talking.

55:54 And then finally, reporting back and listening. So listening to the community, listening to what we've heard, and kind of telling the community what's happened that day. And then the next slide, looking at documenting our stakeholder feedback. So the key is to really, I think, be clear to the stakeholders and clear to the council and commission.

56:18 How this process evolved and really being really good about the documentation on how we kind of came to that so that if there's a question later on about why didn't you include that we can go back and say well we looked at this but this is the reason why we didn't include that. And then the last slide about the design workshop is that those ideas are pinned up throughout the process so everyone can come and see all those comments. And then I think that's it for this.

56:46 for this slideshow. So go ahead. A couple of things about the workshop specifically and also the MLH board meeting. We went on Monday night and we described what was going to happen at the workshop. Again, we encourage the board. It's great if people can come by for 15 minutes and you're welcome and please do, but the longer you can stay the better. I didn't want to...

57:06 I didn't want to let people off the hook, frankly, by saying just come by for a few minutes. We want them to dedicate as much time as they can because the design will build over the days. And if you only come at the first 15 minutes or the last, you'll say what happened in between and what happened. So we just encourage people to do that. Specifically, though, we also described to them that the reason we were doing it this way and the reason we didn't have a plan with some of the comments we got from Rotary and others is that

57:31 We actually heard from people saying, well, you guys just, you already know what you're going to do. And I want to make it clear that that is not the case at all. And I think MLH board heard that very loud and clear. The idea is, no, we're going through a very deliberate process for a reason. It needs to stand up to the test of time. So again, we made that very clear.

57:50 That came up because we were talking to MLH about their participation in the whole process. We've actually set aside time during this entire workshop, even though the public will be there as well. I think it's during one of the pin-up sessions for the whole MLH board to actually schedule time to be there together.

58:06 We talked to them about making sure that they do what they need to in terms of noticing. That's for them to manage, not for us. But if they're all going to be there at a table discussing the parcel, that's something that, in our opinion, needs to be noticed. And Patricia absolutely understands that. So they'll handle that. The reason I mention that is because we're also encouraging Town Council to be there for

58:28 Parts are all of this workshop. And we've actually discussed it between the three of us earlier today and said, OK, what does that mean and what are some of the things we need to look out for? So with that, I'll turn over to a second to Dan and Andy to describe how you all need to be careful or not or what we need to notice or not. Thank you. Bottom line, all of you can come through, just no more than two at a time. How do we figure that out? You can let us know in advance on that.

58:54 Or if you're all going to be there, then we'd have to do a formal agenda. You'd have to have a time where you would sit as a body and take comment and then do stuff. But can't we just go to a public meeting as long as we're not talking with each other? This is a different structure. Yeah, so the Brown Act has three specific exemptions that says that you can go to certain types of gatherings without having it be a Brown Act meeting.

59:19 This doesn't really fit into any of them very well. We looked at that pretty closely. One category requires that it be a meeting organized by somebody who's not the town, so that's clearly out. There's another one that just definitionally doesn't fit. Then there's one that's sort of close, but it's for gatherings on a topic of kind of general community interest, and this is not quite exactly that because this is more specific. So I think the cleanest thing to do is for council members to let staff know,

59:49 Who's planning on being there? And if we get indications from at least three of you that you are planning on being there for a given session, we'll just agendize it as a meeting. So when would you like to have that? You need to have at least 72 hours in advance, right? It's 24 hours in advance because it would be a special meeting. But we're not going to get the agenda out in five minutes. So ideally, if you could let us know a couple days in advance. What if we just agendize the whole thing?

1:00:13 You have to generalize each of the segments or something. Separately. If you don't show up and you don't have a meeting, we just have to notice that. That would make it more complicated. We could do that, but it's a little...

1:00:24 What about the actual presentations, like the summary, the opening, and the closing? Would those be exceptions to that, where we just basically sit and hear a presentation as opposed to participating? What I was going to suggest, Dan, is that those two times, because those are set times, you know, Friday night from 6 to 8, and then Friday night from 6 to 8, you know, the team might suggest that those two we do notice, because then...

1:00:49 Everybody can be there and listen. I would suggest if we're going to do that and you're all there together, we would notice that. It doesn't get out of the exemptions for gathering together on a matter of an item that will be coming to you. Let's talk about it a little bit here then. Cleland, Kirk, is there a thought that you would definitely be at the opening and closing? Well, if you think we need to be there, yes. Is Bill allowed to attend these? Okay, so just the four of us anyway.

1:01:22 Okay. So, I mean, I know I will be at as much as I can be, but I know that I definitely want to be at the opening and the closing. John, Bob? I think what I'm going to do is I'm going to look at, now that I have this information, I'm going to look at the whole thing and I'll provide to staff the sessions I want to be at.

1:01:42 And then let they can, I think if we just get our time to things we want to be at, just get it to these guys as soon as possible, then they can figure out how to notice it. So what would be your ideal time for that as soon as possible? Friday before that. Okay. But even before that, if we can. Yeah. B is the what? Yeah. 7th, 16th? 16th. 16th. Which is, yeah, next Friday. So we'd suggest that maybe by next.

1:02:08 No later than that. Wednesday would be nice. Yeah. And we can coordinate that. But again, we will anticipate the need to notice the opening and closing. And if we don't have to do it, or we may, again, it's not a problem if we notice it and we don't have a quorum, it's not a big deal. But we've done our job. So that's just extra work for Jamie. And then we would then have to note that this is an officially noticed meeting if we did notice it for that. Yeah, we'd send the agendas out so you'd see them and then we'd work through that.

1:02:34 But you'd have to do a little bit of work there because you'd have to like take comment on items not being considered. Well, would everyone be comfortable in and letting the town staff know when we're going to be there by say the middle of next week and if it looks like there's a threesome in any of those and we should coordinate. Okay, so let's do that then. What about like boards of like say if MLR and MLT and all those different organizations they want to be coming to this, how does that get dealt with? If those boards want to come to the charrettes.

1:03:04 Yeah, I mean, if they just come as individuals, and it just so happens that you start getting quorums and meetings, how are you guys going to handle all that? They actually might be able to come using the second of the three Brown Act exemptions, since this would be a gathering not organized by those bodies. Okay. Nor would they be voting on those issues. Nor would they be voting, but it's, for some of them, it could be within their subject matter jurisdiction, so it could be a Brown Act issue, but like I said, if, since they would not have been the ones organizing, it probably fits into the second category of exemption.

1:03:33 Okay, so we'll say that this thing only applies to Council and then all the rest of them will just encourage everybody to show up.

1:03:40 The only difference being, again, with MLH, they've specifically requested a time together to meet with the consultants and do this, so we've advised that that certainly sounds like a different kind of meeting, which we absolutely welcome and encourage, but that is a little different. The others, you're right, they've got to figure it out. Because I saw an email today, I'm assuming that MLT, MLR, are going to use their channels to push this information out. I certainly hope so. Yeah, and we'll be encouraging them to do that.

1:04:06 It sounds like there's not going to be a Brown Act issue with that, so they can all just show up and the members can show up. Amy, you had a couple more things. Before we move off the topic of the design workshop, well, I have two things. One, on the design workshop, I just wanted to let you know that we, in addition to the live streaming and the recording of the video available through Granicus, we were planning on live streaming the opening and closing presentations and the brown bag lunches on Facebook, which also gives Facebook viewers the opportunity to comment.

1:04:36 I don't want to advertise that as a substitute for appearing at the workshop, but it is an option for those who aren't available to attend. And then moving on to further outreach and joint workshops down the road, we have had on our schedule for a while the joint Town Council Planning Commission meetings, workshops number two and three for October 2nd and December 4th.

1:05:02 Those dates are rapidly getting filled with other workshop opportunities, and we are suggesting to move those to the regular Planning Commission meetings the following weeks, so October 9th and December 11th, unless there is an objection.

1:05:16 And if we could have some kind of consensus on that, because we'd like to start getting that information out to the public tomorrow, frankly. So our suggestion, again, is October 9th and December 11th, which is, that's the normal PEDC meetings, correct? That would be the normal Planning Commission meeting date. And it seemed very natural, but we do need to tie that down as quickly as possible. The information out there already is October 2nd, so we want to get it out. Time of day for those, Sandra, though, might be a bit earlier.

1:05:42 We might look at starting the meeting earlier so that the commission can still conduct their regular business after the end of this, or we'll take a look at that, but I would anticipate that it would be after lunch at some point on those days. You're saying October 9th? 9th. Not the 2nd. Correct. And December 11th? And December 11th. Correct. I am available on the 9th. Yeah, it's fine. Okay. I look fine. Thank you. Okay. Then we'll roll with it and update our information.

1:06:11 And that would be during the regular PEDC meeting or afterwards? Or likely maybe starting the PEDC meeting at 1 o'clock or having the joint meeting at 1 a little bit early. You'll let us know. Yes. And we can talk about how to notice it. It can be a special town council meeting and whatever, but we'll figure that out before we get there, how it's legally noticed. But the point is it's a joint meeting. Okay. Thank you. There's a couple things in the staff report starting on your

1:06:45 Packet page 18, staff report page 4. There are a lot of things we're working on that we don't give updates at every meeting on because our focus has been on public engagement and public outreach. Well, it was actually, Councilmember Wentworth mentioned that we met with him on a few things and we realized that

1:07:03 Frankly, there are a lot of things in the work part, and we need to make sure that you guys know we're actually working on these things. And it was, again, a lot came out of that that was very valuable. So I've listed three of them. As I say in the first sentence, we, or the second sentence, we're not really prepared to discuss this in detail. We don't have the answers yet, but we want to let you know that we have a full team working on that. First is the fiscal analysis. We've been talking about that from the first day, and we will to the last, and on into the future.

1:07:29 We have both Kaiser Marsen, who will be available for the workshop by phone, and Novin Development, who will be part of the LWC team, who will be at the workshops in person, and who, frankly, will be running different scenarios. If somebody says, gee, we'd like 12 acres of open space, we can go, okay, that means, boom. We can tell them what that means, some of it financially, and they do have information already on some construction costs, I mean, all those types of things. Again, I don't want to go into a lot of detail because I don't know all of it.

1:07:58 The point is, they're there. So we're working on that every day. And we're also already looking at various opportunities for funding sources that are out there. You know, we started to talk to Patricia about some of the programs she's aware of. Noven's aware of them, LOWC as well. We're looking at some of the costs of the soft costs of public outreach and what we're doing now. The hard cost of infrastructure construction. Because even in our next item, which is the update on our CIP, you'll see...

1:08:25 We're doing project study reports now for the possibility of parcel infrastructure looking for SIP funding in the future. All those things are happening. Second is developer solicitation. I actually got another email and phone call last week from somebody else down in LA through another contact that said, hey, I might be interested. So right now we're just kind of stoking the interest and seeing who's out there. But that's a very serious issue. The key part of this is

1:08:53 When we get to December and we have a conceptual land use plan, a preferred one, and a recommendation, and this council has a chance to consider that,

1:09:01 Our team would frankly like to have an RFQ, a request for qualifications for development teams already on the street and hopefully, and I'm not sure we can do this because this is August already, but actually get information back and some responses back. If we don't have responses, there will be teams that are very aware of the project. The RFQ will at least be out and hopefully they'll show up and actually have comment about what we're doing in the plan. The big part though is we don't want to get to December.

1:09:28 Have the Council on December 11th say, hey, great, that's your conceptual plan, go get them, and then have a stall of two to three months while we start another process. We expect that RFQ to be written and for us to move right through the holidays. Frankly, it's not a bad time to have a RFQ out because we can't do as much during the holidays here. We're busy with a lot of other things, but developers and things outside can be preparing their information to get them right back to us. The third item...

1:09:57 That we have not done a lot of research on yet, although I did bring it up to the MLH Board the other day, is property management. Let's look to the future to say five years out now and maybe there's 200 units already built because there's absorption, there's everything else. That's not a goal or commitment. That's just a number for tonight.

1:10:15 Okay, how are we managing those units? Is there a 100-unit apartment building that's managed by a developer and we just work with them? Is MLH involved and to what extent? Is it town staff? Regardless of who it is, there is not the staff on staff anywhere in this town right now to handle that. It just doesn't exist. We're not set up for that. So we're looking at...

1:10:37 Other communities seeing what they're doing. We had a great conversation the other day, by the way, following up on the housing summit with Lori Best from Breckenridge. She was on the phone with our consultant team, and they got a great deal of good information out of that. And frankly, we got a couple of volunteers to go.

1:10:53 To Breckenridge this winter and check out what they're doing, of course. But the point is, it's really important to, you know, for the consultants on their own nickel. How was that? The idea is, though, as we're doing that research, and again, by the time we get to you in December, we'll have at least, hey, these are some of the ways we can do that. Because there's a huge, that to me is the longest term cost issue. We'll find the money for infrastructure, we'll get a development partner, but in 20 or 30 years.

1:11:21 We'll have deed restricted units. We'll have to have a program in place. And how that works in the town, who does it, and what the needs are, is something we're looking at. So again, that's just three items. And I don't have a lot of detail. I'm happy to answer any questions I can answer on that. But the point is we're

1:11:41 In earnest working on those and expect by the time we get to December, we'll have a plan laid out for how we can manage some of those things and something for you to consider. So with that, I think that's our update and we're all happy to answer any questions we can. Okay. Will you be taking public comment? I'm going to right now. Okay. Good idea. Okay, any public comment on this issue? I don't see none. Any more discussion here? I have comments. Let's go.

1:12:11 And Grady's well aware of him because he was at the Mammoth Lake Housing, and I expressed to him, I really feel that we need to start getting some real hard numbers out there, you know, as to what the zoning is, you know, it's 177, what's the, what's the,

1:12:29 Affordable Housing Overlay on that. What's the Mammoth Lake Housing wait list, the 77 people on that, and where do they fit financially? What can they afford? Because that's going to drive product type. Phasing is also a very important part of this. We're not going to go out and have Grady build 250 units or whatever at one time. So how are we going to walk through this? And how is that going to impact?

1:12:58 Our housing need and the housing within the community. The chamber is reaching out trying to do some units and capture some of those. So I worry about creating expectations in the community that somehow this is the...

1:13:18 This is a solution. And it's not, you know, it's going to, once we get moving on this, it's going to be over. Well, if it takes four years to do it in phases and everything else, you have to understand that right now we have a deficit of 256 units. And in four years, we're going to have another deficit. So if you look at, we can get maybe 300.

1:13:41 350 units within there in two years or four years from now, we're going to still have a 200 unit deficit. So, you know, we need to be looking as a council, okay, do we need to...

1:13:54 Purchase property. Do we need to talk to the Forest Service? Do we need to, who, where do we, you know, reach out? The other thing that I think is really important is if you look at this financial analysis, you know, it says local, private, state funding. A lot of that's drying up because of the fact, or more competitive because of Donald Trump, to be very blunt about it. I mean, he cut that corporate tax from 35 down to

1:14:20 22%, 21%, which means that corporations aren't buying the low interest tax credits. And so with that, it's going to be harder to actually fund that.

1:14:34 That funding is repaid. That loan is repaid through the rents and everything else. The other thing that's going to be driving this is what is our target level? If we're looking at 30% AMI instead of 50 or 80 or 120 or 180, because it seems to be the range now, according to the NEED study, is at both ends of the continuum. So not only the people that are making 180% of AMI, but the people that are making

1:15:03 30% of the AMI. Those are our two different needs. So one of the things that is going to have to come forward sooner or later is what's the zoning and the overlay on this. That is going to be a huge discussion in the community because the community voted back in 1988 as to what should be on that particular piece of property. So there's going to be a lot of debate on that. All I'm saying is that

1:15:30 Trying to get the hard numbers out there, you know, I think is really important so that, you know,

1:15:37 It's not a blank sheet of paper. It's not a blank piece of property that has no kind of zoning or anything else. And so I just have a lot of different concerns that we're creating an expectation with the public and with some of the groups that we're working with that, oh, yeah, we can do this. Well, it's going to take some steps to do it, and it's going to take funding to do it. So I guess I have a level of concern.

1:16:05 You know, and I think the biggest concern is if you read our financial analysis, it says the final list of sources will likely include private, you know, local, state, and federal funding. And then also a funding stream for housing programs must begin to be addressed early in the process. That means us. I mean, are we...

1:16:25 Are we going to do a TOT increase? Or what are we going to do to get a funding stream for this? Because it's going to take dollars for us to do it. So I keep expressing this, trying to get numbers out there, trying to get the idea of phasing.

1:16:47 2016, Mammoth Lake Housing looked at just 43 units that were the first phase of that, of developing, you know, beginning to develop the parcel. So we've got an uphill battle. The business community needs to know, you know, you've got to do some, you know, soul searching as to where you're going to invest.

1:17:08 To keep your employees and everything else. So it's not just a problem at council level, it's also going to impact our business community, the mountain and everything else. So I just want to keep pushing that out there so the public understands that, oh, the council's going to fix it. Well, we're going to do everything we can and we're still going to be behind and actually achieving some of this. So there's my spiel.

1:17:39 Thank you, Kirk. Comments? Staff? Comments? I've got a bunch of comments. You do? Yeah. Okay. So thank you for that, Kirk. I think this is a broad, kind of a broad brush look, but I think we can maybe drill down a little bit into some kind of specific things to address. One is I just want to really commend staff on the work that's been done on the outreach program. The spurs were applied.

1:18:03 Perhaps, but I think it's a credible program, and I think that we've all looked at getting as much public engagement as we can, but I think that the town is certainly putting on a credible outreach effort for the community to be engaged, and considering the times that we're living in, if you cannot participate even in your local democracy, I think that's another conversation, but I think there's a good, credible effort, and I participate, looking forward to participating in it further.

1:18:31 Where we're at right now, my understanding, and you can confirm whether I'm on the right page of this or not, is we're setting the outer limits of the framework of what the project is going to look like when it gets built. Is that fair to say? So we're looking to get very specific community feedback on things like height, things like the wetlands.

1:18:55 Some of the topics that came up. And I just want to emphasize how important it is going to be to come out of this specific workshop with a set of parameters that when we go into making zoning changes or doing things like that, we know where the third rails are. We know exactly what those things are. And again, to encourage you guys and the consultants to ask those really, really tough questions. Don't softball it. I mean, we need to know what the community's real values are.

1:19:22 Don't pave the wetlands or don't go more than seven stories in the air. Whatever those things are, we need to know those things. Is that appropriate? Okay. The second thing is that from the perspective of zoning and doing what we may have to do to change zoning for the project, I think it really needs to be a goal of ours to only do it once.

1:19:47 And that, so that may need, I don't think we'll be able to change zoning based on what's coming out of this conceptual land use plan in this process. I think we're either going to have to, we'll have to have a developer on board. We're going to have to have someone saying, okay, we understand this larger framework.

1:20:04 But to get a project that's going to work, that's going to pencil, that's going to be able to happen, it's going to look something more like this, which we don't know yet. And then if we have to make zoning changes and things like that, we do it once. And we're doing it to a project. It could be conceptual, but we're doing it to a project that we think we're actually going to do. We don't want to do it twice. I think we really want to. And so whatever you guys need to have on board and in place to be able to do that, I think that that's important.

1:20:31 I think also the issue about the developer, I think we've talked about this a little bit, I would really encourage staff to get that RFQ out as soon as you possibly can, because I think we're going to have to do a handoff between this process to a body, a company, someone that's going to say, okay, I wanted to build this thing for you, and we need them to be kicking back at us to saying, well, your values are contradictory, we can't do this, we've got to do this, and get into

1:21:00 Working with a party that will have skin in the game is actually going to build this stuff. So when we make the zoning changes and things like that, it's all happening at the same time. And I would like, frankly, to have someone here in December, whenever we're making these final decisions, who's not someone who's auditioning for the part, but someone who's got the role, right? So they're saying, you know, because they may, if they're just auditioning, they may say, well, this, I'll say this, I'll say that.

1:21:25 If they are skin in the game, they're going to be the person doing it. That's going to be the feedback that we're going to need because then we can hold them to what it is they say that they're going to do or they're not going to do. A couple other things. I think the maps look great. And is the plotter working in the office? The nice big plotter that makes nice big maps? Yes. So could we maybe print those maps out? Yes. And because you've got all this nice big empty real estate over there and start getting those things up on the wall, that would be great.

1:21:53 I would recommend checking with Joel. He's got a group of people that meets every Tuesday mornings. I think we'd love to hear something about, you know, that outreaches Forest Service, MLR, a bunch of other folks. That might be a good group to go to to talk to. And I think that's the final caveat is the members of the team that you have, the low-income developer, the finance people, when this contract is over, they're going to go away.

1:22:24 Right. And so we need to start getting with the people that are going to be our partners to develop and build this stuff. We need them, folks with skin in the game, with us here as soon as we can get them here so we can start doing it. And that's, those are my comments. Thank you. Thank you. Cleland, any comment? Yeah, I concur with Kirk and I think John states some really good information. There are other groups in the community that certainly we can reach out to, I believe. But as far as those days.

1:22:50 You know, getting people there to talk about it, I think that's pivotal. I think we can all play a part in that, again, people. And then, as far as the developer goes, when we are talking about putting that RFP out, that's going to take a while to vet these people. So, you know, probably the sooner we, you know, launch that, the better, because to get it even delivered by, I know, December is ambitious, you know, and so I think we need to be a little bit realistic about that.

1:23:14 You know, what we're going to be asking for. And I think some of it will be informed by what, you know, these next days will be, but certainly, you know, starting those conversations so that we can make, you know, right decision on the first kind of launch of that. And I think the things that you referred to, Kirk, are things that should be happening, you know, on, you know, tracks all running in the same direction, but not waiting for one terrain to get there before you start the next one, because these are things that all will be considered, you know, sort of at the same time. So the sooner we get on that, I agree.

1:23:41 So there's no other comments. Anything else to add from staff? Yes, yes, probably comment. Thank you. Hi, my name is Kathy Cage. Just a couple comment. The schedule of your workshop tends to favor people who are institutional or professional in the world of some sort. So it's a lot of time, a lot of meetings. So I suspect, you know, usually the old rule says decisions are made by people who show up, I fear, about what the...

1:24:14 Result will be based on that because of my second comment that if you don't end up with something that is visionary and inspirational, I think you have a real hard time raising enough local funds to make it happen, which I think you need. We've talked about it before. I think that the housing crisis is so, you know, intense in town that we need to pass some kind of a bond measure, a parcel tax, something like that that gets a sizable amount of money into that to happen.

1:24:44 But if it ends up looking same old, same old, it's going to be harder to have that passed. I'm not saying it wouldn't, but I would feel very disappointed if we don't end up with something that you could characterize that way, visionary and inspirational. Thank you. Thank you. Any other comments from the public? Seeing done. Okay, there was no motion to be made on this, but rather to receive the information.

1:25:10 So thank you to everyone. And while we ask Mr. Mayor Sauser to come back, let's take a 10-minute break. We're going to take a break? Yep. Okay. A few flyers for the Spanish meetings? Pardon? Can I leave you with a couple of flyers for the Spanish meetings? I've been passing them out all over the place. You gave me a whole stack. Wait a minute. It was a different one. No, these are different. These are for the Spanish meetings in particular, so they're English and Spanish meetings. I have a lot of connections with the Hispanic community. Would you like more? Well, give me a couple more.

1:26:29 We are still muted. In the meeting, next up on the hit parade is to receive an update on the town's capital improvement projects. Brady, take it away. Thank you. Two parts to this. First of all, I'm just going to introduce Sierra Schultz again, our assistant engineer, who will go through the detail of the projects. I will interject as opposed to interrupt to add some detail to some of them as we go, and we've talked about that.

1:27:44 And understand this is a brief overview. At the end, I will wrap up what we're going to do with some of this information moving forward and how we're going to work towards next budget year, very frankly, to get you a lot more detail in a more of a booklet format. So with that, I'll turn over to Sierra to walk through the presentation. Thank you.

1:28:05 Hi, this is the capital improvements update. We'll be running through our active projects and then going through the projects that will be going on next year and then future projects that we will also be doing project study reports for and I'll go through quickly what a project study report is when I get there.

1:28:25 For our active projects, right now we have our three Main Street projects. The first phase was North Main Street between Mountain Boulevard and Minaret Boulevard. The construction is complete and we're just closing out paperwork. The second phase was the Minaret sidewalk near the brewery between Main Street and...

1:28:49 80-50 going up Minaret, and so that construction has also just been completed, and we're just closing out the project paperwork. And then we have Phase 3, which the first part of Phase 3 was completed last fall. That was between the post office and Forest Trail. And then currently along the north side of Main Street, between Mountain Boulevard and Sierra Boulevard, they're doing construction. They're doing sidewalks this week.

1:29:17 And hopefully going to have sidewalks open in the next two weeks. That won't be a completed thing for everything in that area, such as maybe a bus shelter here and there, but the sidewalk should be complete. On the south side, they will be moving to that side a week from Monday is what's scheduled right now. They'll be setting up full traffic controls, taking those parking areas, and really just trying to knock it out quickly.

1:29:45 The next project is a Lower Main Street retaining wall. This is also substantially complete. It's a retaining wall out front of the fun shop. The design of this really goes hand in hand with Lower Main Street and making all that design fit together. And before Sierra moves on to the next one, one very important component of the Main Street project is what we do with all the dirt.

1:30:10 What we do with all the pockets, what we do with all those spaces. On the north side, we have a very good idea how it's working now, and I was happy to see a family of what looked like eight people on bicycles using that thing, and the sidewalk is wide enough where it works. It works for pedestrian, bicyclists, where they can all share it, but what's missing is some of the animation, and that's completely missing on the south side. Of course, we haven't even started yet. We thought a couple of years ago, gee, let's do a plan for this. We realize, especially after completing the north side,

1:30:39 Until we're done, we don't...

1:30:40 We're not really sure which trees are gone and which aren't, very frankly, because we're out there and we make judgment calls in the field. Which rock goes where, it really does make a difference. So what we're expecting to do is by the end of this year, the project will be substantially complete, which will be the sidewalk is there, the curb's there, the parking's there. It may not be 100% cleaned up because we do have a short construction season, but it'll be usable for the public and clear over the winter. But at the end of this year, we're going to walk that entire sidewalk north end.

1:31:10 So that's an important component. Also bringing Joel into it because part of that is

1:31:36 On the trail system, frankly, and we need to bring him in. But we're going to do that at the end of this season when we know what it looks like in the field, not before, not guessing. We'll do it together in the field. And then over the winter, we'll come up with a design. We'll come up with something that we can go back to town council for. And hopefully next spring, we're then installing some features. We're installing some animation. We've worked with the business. And we have moving forward. It's not a project that's listed because it's, to me, it's an appurtenance to what we're already doing.

1:32:06 I understand the importance of that as well because animation is what it's all about for that part. So not a lot of detail there, but I want to let you know that that's really important as a next step. So go ahead. Thank you. And our next project is the Community Recreation Center. So our consultants are still working on the design and buttoning some things up there. We expect to be able to go out to bid early in 2020 and construct next.

1:32:34 Spring or Summer. Do you have any other? Yeah, two pieces on that. The first step is, of course, is working on the environmental part of that, what we have to do there. And community development is already working with the consultant on that and to make sure that that's covered very clearly. And then there will be design available over the winter to come back and show you where we're headed and everything else, certainly before we bid something. So, again, that's a work in progress.

1:32:59 Each one of these we can get into detail in 20 minutes on each, so I don't want to do that tonight. But understand we're doing precisely as directed by Town Council at the last meeting, which is go to the environmental, go to the design, here's your dollar limit, that's all there is to it, and we'll come back with regular reports once we get closer to the end of the environmental process. So thank you, Sarah.

1:33:20 We also have our parks maintenance projects. This includes the community center, which the interior painting was completed, the interior flooring was completed, and the next steps is we currently have a bid out right now for the exterior maintenance of the building. This includes kind of just fixing up some shingles, adding some siding, painting it.

1:33:46 Making it look better, fixing a few roof shingles and things so it also functions better. And we'll be opening bids next week and we'll be coming back with what we receive. Next we have the parks fencing.

1:34:01 That project's currently going on. This is a large section of fencing out at Shady Rest Park. They've already installed the post and should be finishing this up in the next couple weeks. It's also some maintenance of fences at the tennis courts and the ice rink, as well as some gates down at Whitmower Pool. Another project is SB1 Phase 2 Meridian Curb and Gutter. This is on the agenda for tonight to be awarded.

1:34:31 It's basically curb and gutter maintenance from Obsidian Place driveway up to the corner at Minaret along Meridian and then just past on the other side going up from Minaret up Meridian. That curb and gutter really needs the repairs and so that is that project and should be starting in a couple weeks depending what is decided tonight.

1:34:55 Municipal Wayfinding, that project has started this week. You might see them out and about digging holes everywhere around town. They are really scattered everywhere, and this will go for the next few months and be completed before wintertime. Mammoth Creek Playground Phase 2, this was already completed prior to July 4th. We've seen everyone using all the new, you know, they love the playground and...

1:35:23 This was just an addition of more of the rubber surfacing, and that was open before July 4th. For next year, we are planning the transit shelters. This is replacing the old three. One is right outside of Vons out here. There's two along Main Street, one at the post office and one at Forest Trail. This was approved to move forward at the last council meeting.

1:35:51 We have parks maintenance, which we have not yet defined. We're going to kind of see where we end up at the end of this year, where we're at budget-wise, and then form a scope to move forward with for next year's projects. Street rehabilitation. We are currently looking at our pavement.

1:36:11 Condition Index and running some scenarios on what might be the best projects to move forward with next year. We're planning on anywhere from $500,000 to $1.5 million being the funding, depending if we get stiff funding, that we will be requesting this fall.

1:36:29 If I could add to that one, we recognize that last year we did Upper Hillside and it's a pretty good sized project here in town. This year we really focused on Main Street, as you know, and with that we also improve, we'll be improving a considerable portion of the frontage road because as we're building South Main Street, we're rebuilding a chunk of the frontage road so we're not doing a major road project this year. We're absolutely cognizant that we have to get back on that so that's what this project is. We expect to have at least $600,000.

1:36:58 And maybe as much as aid of road rehab funds available, depending on what's left over from this year when we finish Main Street. But in addition to that, we're proposing some STIP funding so that we can get a project that's much larger than that, hopefully get somewhere between 600,000 and a million and a half. The reason it may not all get built next summer, of course, is the STIP cycle.

1:37:19 Is very set in Sacramento. We don't have a lot of flexibility. If we can get to a CTC meeting in June, great. If they push us to July, that's what we have to do. And we get the whatever the form that is, the 76 form? E-76. The E-76 form. Thank you.

1:37:37 We can't advertise the project until we get that. So while we may end up with having a two-phase project where early in the summer we bid a project that's a half a million dollars with available town funds, but we also have one design that has to go through the Caltrans process so we can build that later in the summer and it may go over into the next season. But the key is we really...

1:37:57 We want to be spending a million dollars a year on roads. Our budget shows 580. That's great. But any time we can take advantage of SIP funds or other, we know how important that is. So we're very focused on that. I just wanted to expand on that for a benefit. It's not just street rehab. We get it. We really do understand. We need to have a long way to go. And we're fully cognizant that we did not do a large project this year. We did some rehab, or we are doing some rehab on the frontage roads, but a lot more to be done. So thank you. Sierra.

1:38:25 And as Grady said, the scheduling also applies to the multi-use path maintenance. This funding is already pretty much set aside. It's $1.5 million to do full rehab on portions of our multi-use paths. We just have to go through the channels to get the funding, so we might end up in a similar situation schedule-wise, but we would like to do most of the work next fall.

1:38:52 We have the SB1 project, which is really just more curb and gutter maintenance along Meridian and hopefully possibly one of the last phases to get that along the north side all redone. We have the North Village Benefit Assessment District sidewalk maintenance. This will be along Forest Trail from Minarit.

1:39:14 Boulevard to Hillside Drive, kind of by the hotel entrance there going under the bridge. That sidewalk is really beat up so we'll be using Benefit Assessment District funds to replace and maintain that sidewalk. We have the Lake Mary Road sidewalk which is adjacent to the brewery along Lake Mary Road between Minaret and Canyon Boulevard. This will be a private public partnership as the

1:39:42 Brewery moves forward with doing some improvements to their own site, and we're coordinating with them to do a sidewalk along there. I have to mention that one because I frankly heard about this two weeks ago myself, and what happened was the brewery came in and said, hey, we want to do some landscaping along Lake Mary Road. We want to fix up our frontage, and we said, no, time out. If you're going to do something and spend money along that frontage, let's get together and fix that stretch. So, again, it's an opportunity to leverage.

1:40:11 Private funds and our own and do it right working with the brewery. So I was very happy to hear it. It just came around recently. We wanted to make sure it got added to the list because we do look for those and that came in great. We didn't want them to spend money on landscaping that we might tear out. Plus it was a great opportunity to put a little bit of town funds into it. I think it's $50,000 or $60,000 maybe. Maybe a little more. We haven't completely scoped it. But understand that we wanted to take advantage of that. So I was very glad to hear about that when I got back. Thanks.

1:40:42 We have also the Old Mammoth Road beautification project, which I presented the last council meeting. This will be landscaping along Old Mammoth Road from Mammoth Creek Park to Main Street, and this is planned for next summer. If I could give a, go ahead to the next slide, though. Yeah, you're right. A quick, sort of an update on this. The parcel infrastructure is one, and then the next slide has even more projects.

1:41:09 We're not sure when or which things we can actually do, but a project study report is something that we do with Caltrans, which makes it eligible for STIP funding and other opportunities, active transportation program, those types of things. So the idea is be ready. Get out there and be ready. What we found is that other agencies aren't ready, so when...

1:41:31 Opportunity comes along and we say we have a, you know, we're good. It really makes a big difference and we've taken advantage of that here in town before. So that's why.

1:41:40 Not necessarily on this list, but especially on the next page, you may see projects and go, wait, we're not really ready to do that. That might be true. But if we do the project study report, it will be a future council decision as whether to go forward or not. But we're ready to do so and we can take advantage of things as they come along. Yeah, the project study report is really just an engineer report, a feasibility report that addresses environmental, design, right of way, those to just show that the project's even feasible and you have to have it to request funding.

1:42:10 So for the parcel, we'll be looking at all types of infrastructure, such as drainage, roads, sidewalks, traffic signals, pretty much anything that we maybe all use those funds to build, we'll include in the PSR. We're also doing PSRs on other projects, such as the South Main Mupp. This is from

1:42:33 Joaquin to Minaret. So this goes along Main Street from Joaquin up to Minaret on the south side. So it would be a multi-use path rather than a sidewalk kind of tying into the Lake Mary bike path. The Minaret map goes from Lake Mary Road down to Old Mammoth Road. That's another important project I think we could all agree on. Lakes, Basin,

1:43:01 Multi-use path, this one goes around Lake Mary Road, kind of around Lake Mary, and up to Lake George. Laurel Mountain Sidewalks, whether this be one side or both sides on the whole stretch of Laurel Mountain Road. Old Mammoth Road, multi-use path from Waterford to Woodman and Red Fur.

1:43:24 Multi-use path connectors such as Majestic Pines, Hill Lake Mary, possibly through Hidden Valley and making that connection. And again, these are all things that have come out of either the mobility element or the trail system. I mean, all those things. I don't want to get in a lot of detail again, but the point is we're trying to do the planning and some of that environmental for them now so that when...

1:43:47 The council says, yes, let's move forward. We're ready to do so. It doesn't take a huge amount of investment to do that, but it puts us in a great position to move forward later. Yeah, and we can prioritize these with council on how we'd want to move forward. We also have future projects, and some of these may or may not have a PSR associated, but the Reds Meadow Road is planned for major construction in 2022 and 23. They might do some minor

1:44:17 Prep work prior to that, but those will be the main construction years. The Community Recreation Center Transit Hub at Mammoth Creek Park, that will also be considered and most likely be additional parking spaces, bus shelter, and other things might come with that as well.

1:44:43 SB1 projects, this will be a continuation of curb and gutter, possibly other minor repair on an annual basis. Mobility hub projects, we currently have a consultant on board for the mobility hub study, so that may lead into future projects. Additional MUP and road maintenance and rehabilitation projects, this will be an annual maintenance projects for these three.

1:45:14 And have not yet been scoped out. And then we have the airport, which reminds me of one current project we also have as an active project I didn't see on the list. And that's the segmented circle and wind cone. That's happening down at the airport starting on Monday. So that will be going on for about six weeks. We don't have a lot of detail in on the airport CIP. We presented the list.

1:45:41 A few months ago, we just had a kickoff in the last two weeks, both for the EA and for the ALP, the airport layout plan update. So we're starting on those as well. In September, we're trying to put a report to come back to you of the first meeting in September with more of an update on the airport projects and a little bit more information on air service, what we know, because FAA is coming to town September 25th. I've mentioned that before, and we want to make sure the council is on the same page we are.

1:46:08 When we all meet with FAA. So there's not a lot of detail here. We've had it just a couple of months ago, and we'll get it back again in early September for the work at the airport. Okay. I believe that's it. So if there's any questions, comments? As a wrap-up, if I can do this, we, again, you see on page 42 of your pack-up how this plays into some of the other things we're doing. We have not, in the last...

1:46:35 Five years since I've been here, really updated our master facilities plan and done a CIP booklet. Part of that was because we were coming out, believe it or not, even in 2013-14, coming out of being in a place where we didn't have any funds for capital projects and everything was a struggle. We do not have a...

1:46:54 You know, a lot of extra funds by now, but at least we think we have a better handle on where we are financially and year to year and our budgeting, you know, you've all witnessed and been a big part of that process. So one of the things that we did do about four years ago was update our diff nexus study, our development impact fee nexus study. Well, it's time to do that again. So we actually had a meeting the other day with staff and kicked off that effort.

1:47:18 In order to do the DIF study, first you really do have to update your master facilities plan. We need to look...

1:47:24 5, 10, and even 20 years out on some things to see what projects should be included in that diff analysis in the next study. So we're undertaking an effort right now to go back through all the town facilities, see what is not on the list from before, or see what's on there that doesn't belong. We'll produce a master facilities plan, a very detailed and companion capital improvement program in booklet form, all this information in a single page per project, all that type of thing to get ready for that diff. And the idea is that we can accomplish that work.

1:47:54 By March so that everything can be to you. You can have that plan. You can approve that. And that feeds right into the budget cycle for next year. So again, there's a lot of detail there. But I wanted to again mention that's part of the work program. This is not in isolation. We don't just pick projects. But we need to formalize that master facilities plan and make sure that it's of record so it's something to be adopted by by town council. So with that, any questions you have of us here or either as prepared as we can be?

1:48:23 So by next March we can anticipate more of a formal, you know, going forward kind of approval plan sort of? Correct. And where possible we identify the funding sources. Where we don't, we give some suggestions where we're going to be looking in the future, things like that. But it'll all be wrapped up. It'll have cost estimates, a rough idea or a recommendation for schedule. But again, this looks 5, 10, and even 20 years out in some aspect. Other questions? John?

1:48:53 So, Public Works, obviously, you guys are doing a really excellent job. I'm hearing a lot of compliments from folks. The work on Main Street, how this is really changing. It's opening up a vision of what this community can be, how we look and how we present ourselves to the world. You guys are doing an excellent job with that and to be commended for these efforts. A couple things, talking about 15-, 20-year plans. I'm concerned about where Walk, Bike, Ride is fitting to this.

1:49:21 And I'm very concerned that we're going to build out. I'm concerned, like, again, the map that we see up here is just that five miles of the town's municipal world. All of us have been up the lakes basin this summer. The lakes basin is now looking like Labor Day every weekend. It's looking like Memorial Day every weekend. And the council is going to be having, we're going to get into the overtourism business. We're going to start talking about how we strike that balance between visitation and what our place can support.

1:49:51 And so the roads in the Lakes Basin and all those campgrounds are, I mean, they're a disaster at this point. And I think we have to be very careful that we don't start, we're going to beautify, make this place look great, but then the destinations, the experiences that people are coming here to enjoy, they're driving on roads like in the cold water campgrounds where they're going to be breaking axles and destroying rims and all the rest of it. And I think the walk, bike, ride program lays out how we strike that balance.

1:50:19 And I'm going to be very interested when you come back to figure out how we're going to strike that balance because we can't do this and not do that. Remind all of us there's going to be a brand new road going to Red's Meadow that's going to be built to the specs that the town wants for maintenance and all the rest of it. It's going to be a beautiful thing. We're going to be extending ourselves into that area. The Lakes Basin, we got to get caught up on this. This is going to be a real problem down the road.

1:50:46 With that in mind, I would love to get an update on the infamous Sarbanes grant that was put in place maybe a decade ago, and you guys have done an excellent job at just hiding it from all the rest of us all these years. I would really like to know what, let's get an update on that, because we've never had one, and it'd be great to get that.

1:51:07 For construction costs, and this is something I failed to mention a little bit when we're talking about the parcel. What are we using as baseline for construction costs? I know we had some issues with what happened with the community recreation center. I think we've sort of gotten through all that. I know the mountain has gotten, had some projects go up for bib where the numbers are coming back, you know, 20, 30, 40 percent. And I would hope that when we're starting to talk about numbers for what we're anticipating costs in these projects, that we're using something that's a baseline that's

1:51:37 Actually, what's going to cost to build things around here. So that's a concern. I think now where does that, the SB1 grant for the parking in downtown, where is, I mean, that needs to fit into all this because we're looking at build, we're building out our transportation infrastructure right now between where the park is going to be in town, what's going to be happening on the parcel. This is, this is will be the future of this town for the next hundred years.

1:52:04 And I think at some point we need to start looking at, again, back to the walk, bike, ride plan and saying this is where everything is going to be going. It'd be very helpful for me, I think, for the council to see these projects you're talking about within that context and especially the connectivity between the urban core of town and all the recreation destinations that people are coming up here to use and enjoy. It'd be very helpful to see that stuff in that context. Reds Meadow Road, is that, I've heard some rumor that the construction costs down there were

1:52:32 The Federal Highways was maybe saying this thing is just going to be too expensive. We're not going to build it. Is that just a rumor? I was at the last couple of meetings, especially 70% design, and that was not a topic at all. There was a recognition that certain costs have gone up. But once a project's in that pipeline, they're going to find the funds to do it, as far as I've heard. I have not heard for one second that it's not going forward for any reason. No. I think where that may have come in is that the...

1:53:00 Bulk of the money may go to the first 2.3 miles, the upper portion of it, whereas the lower portion, but that's the only thing I've heard about, any lack of funds. Yeah, and it's not a lack of funds based on the project that was submitted and approved by any means. That's just the fact of the project. It's all like that. I haven't heard from anybody, including Wendy from Federal Highways or the Forest Service, that it's not going forward for any reason. Like I said, their schedule is more like, gee, you know, maybe in 20...

1:53:29 Late 2020, early 2021, we'll start cutting down trees. I mean, they're very, you know, aggressive on it. Okay, good. So my final point would be that if you could, because a lot of this is going to go through the LTC, and I think we would like to get some briefings and some work with staff in advance. I think a lot of times we go in there, it feels very much like a Mono County effort. We'd like to make sure we're representing on behalf of the town and we know how to, all these things you guys are working on, we can advocate for that effectively. So that's it. Thank you.

1:53:59 Other questions? I don't have a question, I just have a couple comments. Okay, before the comments, anybody from the audience wish to ask a question? Kirk, back to your comment. I think your bus shelters are fantastic. I think some people, better looking in some people's houses. Sorry if that's your house out there. They cost as much as some people's houses. Yeah, they are expensive, but they sure are nice. I mean,

1:54:30 I take my hat off. Whoever designed it, and they're really great. We're trying to spend a million dollars or budgeting a million dollars for road rehab a year. Did you say we budget about $580,000, and you're getting STIP funds to meet that criteria?

1:54:50 Well, again, we don't get to make the decision on STIP, actually, you know, LTC is the final, but the money's available, and it's money available for the town to designate, so we're recommending, we will be recommending to LTC that some of those funds to the town be used for this purpose, that's correct, because we need to augment it, that 580 is not enough, and we need to see what else we can do. Thank you. That's excellent.

1:55:15 And I don't have anything else other than John Artur's signs. I mean, you've designed those. I'm not too sure did. On the bike trails, when people come to the signs. Yes. I mean, it's really fun to watch them try to figure out where they are. It's really excellent, by the way. You've pushed trails, and I compliment you. The signs.

1:55:39 The people are using compasses with their iPhones and everything else to figure out which way to go. It's great. There's only so much we can do. Any other questions? Okay, thank you. Yes? I asked for you a minute ago. Sorry, Kathy Cage. There's an effort that is fairly popular in downtown and other places to include a refill of...

1:56:15 Water in pretty much all the public shelters and along the pathways and so forth. We don't have any of that. And we have a water district that has a ton of money. And I've been told.

1:56:26 By someone who knows that they have never been asked, you know, for anything to be included in part of the design of some of these kinds of things. The idea is to reduce the single water bottle use stuff. So I just want to suggest to maybe try to get together with the water district. They have, there are some great, you know, freeze temperature designs for water fixtures too that could be employed and included in a lot of our, you know.

1:56:52 If I could. If I could just. Mammoth Lakes Recreation has been bringing that up repeatedly. And again, I would point the water district and staff to the walk, bike, ride program. And in the transit hubs, the transit trail hubs.

1:57:06 There is a menu of what types of things should be available there. So it's there. I know funding is sometimes an issue, but, you know, they have some dough. You know somebody at the water district, I'm assuming. And we're doing two of them. We're doing two of them right now. You got an update about recently from Stu on that. We have two of those filling stations that are going in fairly soon. And on that topic at MLT today, we discussed the...

1:57:31 Margarita Festival coming up this weekend at the Village, and it's, I understand, as close as being green certified as possible, and there will be filling stations there courtesy of the water district there with vessels to fill and use while you're at the, so, you know, we're getting more aware, and so I think that's a great, great time, but so, I mean, everyone should go to the Margarita Festival just to test the water. That's why I'll be going. Yeah. Thank you.

1:58:01 Moving on to consent agenda. Anybody wish to pull anything from consent? If not, I would accept a motion. I'll make a motion to accept the consent agenda. I need to read it. Oh, that's right. You need to read it first. Okay. Consent agenda. Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of July 17. Approve the memoranda of understanding between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and the Mammoth Lakes General Employees Association, the Mammoth Lakes Management Employees Association, and the Mammoth Lakes...

1:58:29 Police Officers Association and the Mammoth Lakes Public Work Employees Association. Number six, approve the resolution adopting the 19-20-2021 and 21-22 compensation schedules for the Mammoth Lakes General Employees Association, the Mammoth Lakes Management Employees Association and the Mammoth Lakes Police Officers Association and the Mammoth Lakes Police Officers is twice. Okay, I won't read it the second time.

1:58:57 Appoint seven, appoint Leslie and Hoxie to fill the public at large vacancy on the Solid Waste Task Force for a two-year term commencing July 25 and ending on July 24, 2021. Award the contract as eight, reward the contract as space construction and the amount of $137,812.75 for the SB1 Phase II Meridian Curb and Gutter Project and accept payment approval report numbers

1:59:26 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 21, 2002, 1965. Most of those were good years. Now I would entertain. Now I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. I'll second the motion. Motion and second. Any further deliberation? Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

2:00:02 Consent accepted. We will now open a public hearing to consider adopting a resolution making the required findings for approval of a general plan amendment 19-001 to update the housing and safety elements of the general plan, including adoption of an addendum to the 2014 housing element initial study negative declaration. Sandra.

2:00:35 Thank you. Thank you. So I'll turn it over to Kim Cook, our associate planner. Michelle will introduce the project and then introduce our consultants who will walk through some slides for you. Thank you. Good evening. So this is our second public hearing for this general plan amendment, and it's really the culmination of the Resilient Mammoth Lakes project, which was comprised of three primary components.

2:01:01 Including a housing element update, safety element update, and a climate change, climate adaptation and resiliency strategies grant. And these project components are related through specific legislative requirements, which will be described in greater detail by our consultant team.

2:01:21 And so in your staff reports we've provided a background on how we've come to this point in the project and a description of each of the project components. And we are, we've held a public hearing with the Planning and Economic Development Commission that occurred on July 10th. And they provided a recommendation to Town Council for approval of the resolution that was included in your packets.

2:01:50 So with that, I'm going to turn it over to our consultant team, and we have Aaron Fannenstiel and Amy Sinsheimer of PlaceWorks and Atlas Planning. Good evening, Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, and Councilmembers. I'm Aaron Fannenstiel with Atlas Planning, and I'm going to walk you through a little bit about what we're going to talk about tonight. So one of the big questions we had was

2:02:17 How did we ultimately get to tonight? And it started a long time ago when the state said we need to have a general plan and it has to cover seven specific topics. And so tonight we're only going to focus on two, thankfully, which will be the housing element, the safety element. But what you can see with that is that there's a lot that actually goes into both the housing element and the safety element. And so we're going to take a quick step back.

2:02:45 So as we know it, Brazilian Mammoth Lakes is, before tonight, with the housing element and the safety element that you'd be adopting. But there's more to those two particular elements. What is happening is that your community has been changing for quite some time. And a couple of years ago, you went through a process to look at housing and created a housing action plan that really formed the basis of

2:03:12 What are we going to do to house the community of Mammoth Lakes in the future? And then, of course, the state decided, well, let's go ahead and complicate things a little bit more, and let's create a lot of legislation that is going to roll down to the local jurisdictions on what you need to do when it comes to housing. And so what Amy is going to do then is walk you through the housing element that's before you that addresses all of these needs.

2:03:40 Of course, the legislature really likes to complicate things more so because they don't like to just deal with the housing element. And so last year, they adopted SB 1035, which is really a continuation of previous legislation where it's binding the housing element and the safety element together. And so as all of this has been going on,

2:04:08 The town had an opportunity through a program called CEPAW to look at one of the big issues affecting a lot of communities like yours around wildfire. And so I had an opportunity to work with the CEPAW team about a year and a half ago, I think is when...

2:04:28 That completed. And that really set the foundation for trying to address many of the hazards concerns within the community that ultimately, thankfully from the legislature, again, they said you need to start addressing climate change within your safety element as well as a number of other updates. So SB 379 went into effect in 2017 requiring all

2:04:56 jurisdictions in California to address climate change within their general plan. Most of that really focuses on updates in the safety element. And so that's contributing to tonight's work and the work of Brazilian Mammoth Lakes. Thankfully, Mono County and the town as a participant also went through an update to the...

2:05:22 The county's multi-jurisexual hazard mitigation plan. So that's one thing that really helps the town and really rounds things out when it comes to resilient Mammoth Lakes. For those that participate in the process and just to make sure you're aware, having the hazard mitigation plan opens the door to a whole new set of funding.

2:05:46 A lot of what was put into the updated safety element and into Resilient Mammoth Lakes really tries to tap into and provide opportunities to really leverage that funding to address some of the community's needs.

2:06:00 And then finally, in 2014, Senate Bill 1241 was passed. And this is really where another state agency started getting involved with dealing with hazards at the local level. And this is where CAL FIRE now plays a very significant role for those communities that have either state responsibility areas or very high fire hazard severity zones.

2:06:22 You have the luxury of not only having very high fire hazard disparity zones, but being surrounded by a lot of state responsibility areas. So it's a double whammy for you. And so really, this is the culmination tonight of Brazilian Mammoth Lakes, but there are so many pieces and so much work that's been put into this over the years. We really wanted to make sure that we had a way to recognize that and that while you're taking action on elements, they're not...

2:06:51 You know, elements that were developed in a vacuum. There's been a lot of input, feedback, and coordination amongst not only, you know, town departments, but other agencies, stakeholders, and groups that, you know, are very concerned about the future of Mammoth Lakes. And so tonight, you know, we want to focus on resilient Mammoth Lakes, look at the big picture.

2:07:17 You know, the goals for the project, it was really about addressing the safety and well-being of all aspects of Mammoth Lakes, looking at housing challenges and how you can maintain a strong housing sector while improving affordability and equity. And so, again, those key components that Kim had mentioned is the climate change vulnerability assessment and adaptation strategies, then the housing element and the safety element and how all three of those are really working together to hopefully create a more resilient community in the future.

2:07:47 I went over the legislative framework. I don't think I really need to beat that up too much. Really, these changes were kind of the impetus. And then when it came to SB 1035, that's really the bridge where all communities now, when they're opening up their housing elements, are starting to now trigger making sure that they're complying with SB 1241 and 379. And you're ahead of the game in comparison to a lot of communities, which is great to hear.

2:08:15 So the climate change impacts, just wanted to give you a quick overview. When we conducted the vulnerability assessment working with town staff, we really focused in on these 10 key hazards, climate change hazards, focused our efforts on these.

2:08:36 One of the big ones that really came out of not only CPAP, but really hearing from the community and from key stakeholders was the concerns over smoke and ash. That's really unique to your community, unlike a lot of other communities that are close in proximity to wildfire hazard zones or having to deal with wildfire hazards. So we really tried to pay deference to that through this process. And then...

2:09:03 When we look at sensitivities, you know, this is really starting to break down what aspects of the community may be most vulnerable. And so you look at it from the population standpoint. Do you have a lot of young people, a lot of older people, and those within your demographics that may have an increased

2:09:27 Vulnerability, whether it be due to immunocompromisation, you know, or health concerns or any other conditions. We then want to look at buildings and infrastructure. You know, the older the buildings and infrastructure, the...

2:09:42 Greater the likelihood that they could be impacted by future events. You know, what are some of the important economic assets? And that was something that we heard from our stakeholders when we conducted the vulnerability assessment process is that there are some key assets within the community. Even some discussed tonight like the Lakes District and a lot of the economy of the community that's based on tourism and the influx of temporary populations.

2:10:10 Ecosystems and natural resources were definitely a concern for a lot of the stakeholders. And then what are some of the key community services that either help to ensure that this town is connected to the rest of the world or that we need to consider to ensure the town is not too isolated.

2:10:32 And so using all of that, the major vulnerabilities identify seniors living alone are vulnerable to the most exposures of any group that we looked at. Single access roads were a big concern, especially those that are highly susceptible to flooding, storms, landslides, and forestry pests. Drought, wildfire, severe weather, and smoke and ash are

2:10:59 Thought to be the largest vulnerabilities to the town's economy. The mixed conifer forests are really one of the most vulnerable ecosystems for the area and that vital goods are highly vulnerable to multiple hazards that can isolate the town. And this is something we heard a lot in that something happens up in Mammoth and it could be hours before

2:11:23 Resources that are desperately needed may actually make it to town. And so we had to make sure that we took that into consideration. And then...

2:11:32 As we moved into the safety element, one of the things we really worked hard to do was, through the vulnerability assessment, developing a number of adaptation strategies and making sure that those got weaved in to the goals, policies, and actions that you see in the element. One of the things that you'll probably recognize is that the difference between the previous element

2:11:59 And this one is very robust. There's a lot more information. There's a lot more policy that town staff is going to be using and overseeing. And there's a lot more action that comes out of this element in hopes that it's really helping the community move forward towards becoming more resilient. Some items that we wanted to identify.

2:12:29 You know, one new item, creating equitable and affordable snow removal options for low-income and older residents. We heard a lot about snow removal in that there were some incidents in some, you know, years where snow removal actually...

2:12:44 became an obstacle for residents. And so ensuring that we were able to give town staff some tools to be able to help with that. Encourage residents on single access roads to maintain emergency supplies to at least three days.

2:13:00 You know, this is obviously a concern not only for Mammoth, but for many communities. Even down in Southern California where I live, I live next door to communities that actually have the very same conditions that Mammoth has because they've got single access roads along a very steep and narrow canyon that has a one way and one way out for a lot of these residents. So while

2:13:28 It may seem unique. You're not the only ones challenged by this, but we want to make sure you have the tools. And then evaluate future development applications for their potential impacts on risk reduction. So this is one of those outcomes.

2:13:43 Where we are looking at and through the process of reviewing the safety element with CAL FIRE staff, making sure that any new development that comes in is taking into consideration a lot of the concerns that CAL FIRE has identified through the SB 1241 process so that

2:14:03 Thanks, Aaron. Good evening. So I'm going to give

2:14:37 An overview, it will definitely not cover everything that we've done with the housing element, but I have been leading our team on the housing element update, and as Erin mentioned, it is part of the required elements for your general plan. It looks at your existing conditions for housing, as well as what are the projected needs, what do the trends look like going forward. It is reviewed by the state.

2:15:05 The Housing and Community Development Department. So we've gone through that process with them. And they have what is called conditionally certified the document. They've issued a letter to the town. And once the element is adopted, it will be resubmitted to them for their final certification review. And we expect, because you've received the conditional certification, that there won't be new issues raised.

2:15:31 That's usually how it goes. They do have that final look that happens after adoption. You are moving into what is called the sixth round of the housing element. So the housing element has been in place as a California requirement since about 1970. And your time frame starts this month and goes for eight years to 2027. So we're planning for that time frame.

2:15:58 By being in compliance with the law and doing this update and going through the review with the state and with your community and decision makers, you are eligible for funding from the state and also you're in compliance with the law, which means that you have a general plan that's updated as well as being less open to legal challenges related to housing.

2:16:31 High-level overview of what we've done. We've looked at your goals, policies, and actions from your last housing element from five years ago and updated those based on the work that has happened that Aaron described as part of the housing element as well as before on the topic of housing. We have also done community input and received input from the state, of course, as I mentioned, to update the document.

2:17:00 We are also responding to the package of housing laws that have increased over the last couple of years. So there were about 15 new laws in 2017, about 10 last year, and others before that that we are addressing as needed in this document. We are also taking a look at what sites you have available for housing.

2:17:23 The parcel is obviously one of those major sites, but there are quite a few others that are identified in the document for all types of housing from affordable housing to above moderate or market rate housing and then also looking at what are the needs of different groups who sometimes have a harder time affording or finding housing. We have a summary of all the input that was received in the document as well.

2:17:56 Most of the rest of my slides are going to be an update on what is new in the action section of the document. So there are a lot of actions and they've all been looked at and I think every single one has been revised at least to some extent. We've looked at what the timing goals are for the actions as well as who is responsible either at the town or in the community for working on.

2:18:22 Implementing those actions. But there are 12 actions that are appearing for the first time in this housing element. So I'm not going to read the text of all of them, but the text is up here on the screen if you want to read it. And I'll give an overview of each one. So this first one.

2:18:40 Action H1E4 addresses a new state law that was passed last year. That was Assembly Bill 2162. And this adds to the requirements related to allowing supportive housing in your local zoning. So there was a law in 2007 that addressed supportive housing. And then this adds to what the zoning requirements are. And it basically requires them to be allowed without discretionary review.

2:19:07 More broadly in a few other details about the standards. So Action H1E5, this is another state law requirement. The Employee Housing Act is something in state health and safety code that requires that you treat housing for employees the same way that you would treat single-family housing. So it calls for it to be explicit.

2:19:34 Explicitly called out in your zoning that it is allowed. And then there are also there's another section that addresses larger employee housing structures. Action H1F1. This one is for the parcel. So basically to go through the process that you've already embarked on to do the conceptual design and planning process and to look for ways to make housing happen.

2:20:05 Action H2A3 is a landlord pilot program, so this would be to work with landlords and Mammoth Mountain to possibly have the first and last rental deposit and rent program, and I understand this is already underway. Action H2A4, this is to basically research and

2:20:39 Gather data about a program that would build upon the existing homebuyer assistance program. This would involve possibly down payments and second mortgages and also some direct outreach with employers about this type of program. Action H2A5. So this is to continue to explore placing a dedicated local tax initiative on the ballots. This is something that came out of your action plan process.

2:21:10 Including it in the housing element. Action H2A6 is related to mobile homes. So this is to work to maintain the affordability of mobile homes. So looking for ways to keep them in good condition and also to have them not go away and possibly add some if that becomes an option. Action H2D2, this is also related to the action plan or came out of the action plan.

2:21:41 Explore the possibility of establishing a long-term rental housing inspection program. So this is another one to look into this and then make a decision about whether it makes sense during this planning period. Action H2E2. So this is another rental housing related action. So this would be to establish a tenant-landlord matching program to increase opportunities for seasonal employees.

2:22:14 They could stay year-round or have more opportunities, and it could also include a jobs component. Action H4D1, this is also a state law requirement to look at your zoning related to accessory dwelling units and make sure it's up-to-date with state law. And by the time that happens, there might be some new laws that pass this year. It's very likely. I think there are about six or seven pending last time I checked.

2:22:45 And that goes along with Action H4D2, which is to promote accessory dwelling units, which are allowed by state law in certain circumstances, and to look into ways that they can be facilitated either through the zoning, exploring variances, so not just to comply with state law, but to make sure that people know about this opportunity and to look at.

2:23:13 You know, any issues with financing, possibly to put in place some incentives. So this is another one to explore a program and see what makes the most sense here. Action H4E2. So this is related to short-term rentals and basically another one to look into establishing a program that could include quite a few components, but to

2:23:45 Strike that balance between allowing short-term rentals and that opportunity for visitors but also minimizing or evaluating the impacts related to long-term rentals and the local community. So there's a lot here in this one. I'm not going to read all of it but there's a lot of ideas of how that can be done moving forward. And I wanted to note that

2:24:12 We are planning to revise the document based on some input or some comments from the PEDC meeting. So it was determined that there is the category for extremely low income in the document, and that's part of the regional housing needs numbers. And there...

2:24:34 is a plan that provides the town with those numbers and part of that plan actually provides a percentage of the overall RHNA or regional housing needs number that should be for extremely low income households and that number is now the

2:24:54 The plan moving forward is to apply that 6.9% to the overall RHNA number for the town of Mammoth Lakes. The way it's presented in that RHNA plan is for the whole county. So that's going to make some minor changes to three tables in the document. It doesn't change the analysis anywhere else. So that was to be consistent with some other housing work at the town, and we can answer questions about that if anyone has more questions.

2:25:23 And I believe, Kim, were you going to take this next one? Thank you. So now we are recommending to Town Council to adopt the attached resolution making the required findings for approval of General Plan Amendment GPA 19-001 and the addendum to the 2014 Housing Element Initial Study Negative Declaration as recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission.

2:25:54 It is also recommended that the Town Council consider accepting the final CEPA recommendations that are dated October 31, 2018, and the 2019 Town of Mammoth Lakes Climate Change Vulnerability Assessment. These two documents are relevant to the general plan safety element update since they provided the basis for new and updated goals and policies as well as actions that were included in the safety element update document.

2:26:23 We're available for any questions if the town council would like to ask. Questions? Kirk? Do we want to hear from the public first? We can. I usually would ask us questions and I would go to the... And then back to us for comments. Yeah. On the action plan, you know, the...

2:26:49 It says we're going to, well, I can read one, continue to explore placing a dedicated local tax initiative on, this is A2, A5 ballot. I mean, it says explore. I mean, the action plan is not directive in the sense you will. I mean, so when I read the action plan, it's not directing the town or council or giving us advice to go forward.

2:27:18 on these actions. So how does that work? I mean, you know, reading the staff report, again, I go through these actions. I think they're all important. I want to support them. But the way it reads is that you might or might not.

2:27:34 I think after this document is adopted, then we would take all of these action items and create a work program to move those forward. So work with the town manager to look at all of the action items and identify the priority action items that we would move forward with. So the 12 action plans, sooner or later, some of these will come to the town council? Correct.

2:27:55 Or most of them will come to the Town Council. Ideally, right. And the Town Council need to either implement them or not. Correct. And what now, that leads to the question of how does that impact the housing element? I mean, what is the relationship if we don't do this?

2:28:12 We would report on it. So if we go through a process, for example, to look at a local tax and we determine that it's not viable, it's just not the right time, we would report on that in eight years to the state. We would say we explored this item and we didn't move forward for these reasons. So the housing plan stays the same, even though the action did not move forward. Right. The housing element will remain the same until eight years from now. So the housing element sits up there, which I...

2:28:40 Going through it, I think you guys did a great job. That's not the issue. It's the implementing policies that underlie it that makes it a viable document. And that really gets down to staff work program, right. Thank you. Mr. Mayor, I have one question. On RHNA, and I don't know who can answer this question, who is responsible, who are we accountable for, for RHNA in

2:29:08 A region like ours with one incorporated town and a county, is it the state, is it the housing, who's responsible for that? Who develops the RHNA number? Who holds us, who's holding us accountable for the goals we meet relative to RHNA? The state. The state. And that's directly out of Sacramento? Yes. There's nobody in between, it's the state directly does. That's my understanding. It's a little, you know, each region is a little different in how they...

2:29:35 Roll out the RHNA numbers, but my understanding is that the state has, especially based on some of the more recent laws, has more enforcement ability related to RHNA.

2:29:48 Either getting accomplished or not. And then there is also the potential for legal action related to affordable housing projects, but usually that's more, you know, that comes from somebody in the community or some kind of advocacy group, and that's usually related to a particular project because there is a law, SB 166, that was passed in 2017 that does hold you more accountable to the numbers and the income.

2:30:17 Groups that are listed in your housing element. There may be more of a tie between the housing element, the state, and legal action that could potentially happen, but that's not something that has happened that much yet. So did things like COGS get involved in this thing, or is it just jurisdiction to the state? COGS are very involved with developing the arena, like where I live in San Luis Obispo.

2:30:44 Just went through the, we have our final RHNA plan right now. We're a little bit behind this region and the COG leads that effort with all of the jurisdictions. But because you are getting your RHNA directly from the state, it's different here. But in terms of reporting on the RHNA and, you know, actually building or permitting units in response to those numbers, that's, you're responsible to the state.

2:31:11 Everything she said is completely correct. There is an open issue about whether forming SCOG as a proper JPA will result in SCOG being the RHNA generator for the region. That's something that the city attorneys and county councils are trying to figure out. Okay, but is that joint powers agreement or joint powers authority? Are those distinctions in there? Well, the way the RHNA law works, it says that where there's a COG, the COG does it.

2:31:41 Which would kind of suggest that if SCOG becomes more of a JPA, that it would sort of, by statute, inherit that responsibility. On the other hand, there is the point that a JPA only has the powers that it's given. And so if the four entities don't intend to give SCOG the authority to do RHNA numbers, that it wouldn't have that authority. So how to reconcile that apparent contradiction is something that the four of us are still working on.

2:32:11 Okay, thank you. Kirk, you had another? Just to let people know, RENA is, we're used to all of this, but the RENA is a regional housing needs assessment, and our RENA number is 155 units, but when we do our needs assessment, we're up to like 265, so we're struggling with a much higher number than the RENA number. I have a question.

2:32:38 Mammoth Lake Housing submitted just some cleanup language. I wondered if that got into the final thing. You know, the idea of it is possible to add a definition section, you know, to the document utilizing the terms community housing, affordable, and workforce housing so that there isn't a confusion as to that. I don't know if that was done or not. This came late. I mean, you know.

2:33:06 So I don't know if some of this information got into the document. We did get those comments earlier in the process as well. So we did add the existing town definition of workforce housing. It's in your municipal code. We explained what we mean by affordable housing using the state definition because that's very much the requirement for the housing element. And then we did not use the term community housing in this document.

2:33:36 Because that seemed confusing with affordable and community being used. And if the staff wants to respond, they can as well. No, I was curious if I got in there. The other thing I have a question is seasonal housing. I mean, that's in the document. So how is the town supposed to deal with seasonal housing?

2:34:06 Well, there is at least, I believe there's one, maybe two actions to address some needs of seasonal residents, and it's something that the town has identified as a unique group here. It's not something that the state requires that we look at in the housing element. So I think there are some action items to move forward with more analysis related to seasonal housing needs.

2:34:33 Yeah, I've read the town will work with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area on a pilot program to develop a model policy for employees to provide first and last rental deposits. So I'm not sure how that addresses housing. I have one other. You might want to add, these are all the different acronyms that, and it goes on for pages. You might want to add something that explains.

2:35:01 You know, what CALPAW is and what, you know, the PEDC, the HEC, the CCAC, something so that somebody, when you're reading, these two pages are just taken out of the staff report. And so when you're reading it, you're saying, well, wait a minute, what does this mean? And it's just a suggestion. So that makes it a little bit more user-friendly because I had to look up several of them.

2:35:31 Thank you. Any further questions? Questions from the public? Yep. Hi, my name is Kathy Cage and I'll apologize in advance. I can recognize I'm at the tail end of this whole general plan update process, but I have a particular interest in ADUs and

2:35:59 The limitations to which you can do an ADU in this town are very significant. And my husband and I were contemplating trying to put one on our property. And the zoning standards are so prohibitive that it occurred to me that before you adopt this, I don't get another bite at this until 2027, that at the public hearing, I'm going to suggest some consideration of some adjusted language in your policies and actions relative to things.

2:36:32 But it changes the tone. Just when the public hearing is over, it's done. So the first three of my suggestions are a different tone relative to ADUs. So the first one has to do with your policy H.4.D. Currently, it says continue to allow accessory dealing, use it by rights. That's very passive.

2:36:59 And I wanted to challenge you. What we're missing is an opportunity for a policy-level direction from you guys to staff to actually take a hard look at our development standards to actually try to incentivize. This is a very passive, oh, we'll try to allow it. You're allowed to by right. But the truth is our development standards are prohibitive. So if you start at that policy level and change the wording to incentivize development,

2:37:28 And what you're trying to do, in my opinion, is to motivate market forces, okay? There's been a lot of conversation around this, you know, trying to develop ADUs. People are talking about maybe doing a little design build firm that has like a little standard cabin and you can, if it fits in the back of your property, wouldn't it be great to put one of those back there? Like a little 800 square foot thing. Well, you can't do it with our development standards. You just can't.

2:37:52 So then we move to my, so if you change the policy level on H.4.2 to something more directive, like incentivize, then you can go to the next one, which is underneath that, which is, it says that one about promoting the development, and that really talks about just letting people know they can do it. Well, that's great. You know, we know it.

2:38:14 And the only thing it talks about is variances. And variances are kind of like changes around the edges of the development standard. They're not really a significant change.

2:38:25 If you want some significant difference, if you want to develop some long-term rental housing in single-family neighborhoods where they can't be transient rentals, they have to be long-term housing, if you want to try to incentivate market forces to try to do that, you've got to do more than just work with variances. That's just like around the edges on the development standards. I'll give you for instance, you can only develop, you know, cover 40% of your lot in single-family residences.

2:38:52 You're going to have two houses on it now. Like if you do a garage size little cabin, you've got to go to multifamily type standards for that kind of thing to be feasible, you know, but the staff doesn't have the authorization to go out and go after that kind of thing or look at it or consider it or anything like that. But changing this kind of verbiage in the actions and the policy level.

2:39:14 Would give them some direction. Hey, go out and evaluate the implications for ADUs that are for long-term rentals. You can go to the multifamily development standards. You can have a smaller side yard setback. You can consider having an agreement for the Forest Service to store snow on if you're bordering up the Forest Service. I mean, there's lots of things we could do that our current development standards don't allow. And something this broad, like the element in the general plan,

2:39:43 If you shift it to something more forceful or something, it would give the staff the direction that it's important.

2:39:55 The third one had to do with something that I've just been doing personally because I've been looking to try to get an ADU and what are the limitations to it. It's not just the town. It's the water district. They have a whole fixture count thing. You've got the fire district. They have all their sprinkling. They have all these things. So my suggestion is no one's really working on taking a hard look at the limitations to the cost of construction. That's fundamentally what I'm talking about, the cost of construction in this town.

2:40:24 And there's lots of contributors to that. And so I wanted to, I don't know if it belongs in this document, but maybe it doesn't belong in the document, but I'd love for you guys to do it. Take a policy level lead to get together with the three major agencies that govern development standards in this town. And that's the town, the water district, and the fire district. Other people have fees, but those three agencies govern what you can do in your new development.

2:40:53 Really try to make it be a policy objective at the water district, at the fire district. I don't really see that happening. You know, so here I'm a private person trying to go in and get board numbers. Can you guys, you know, take a look at how you can incentivize affordable housing or ADUs or something? Can I go just a little longer? I don't think we have a whole, we don't have 25 people standing out here to give you an input. We do have a lot more agenda to go. All right.

2:41:18 So that's that. So that was my third one. And then the last two are unrelated to ADUs. Those three are related to ADUs. But they have to do with the first, my fourth comment was just a critique of the section about the unsheltered homeless. And my critique is that it didn't mention some of one of our unique populations of our unsheltered homeless. People live in vehicles. We all know that happens. It's not mentioned at all in the housing thing.

2:41:45 Look, you don't have to change the plan about it, but most of us who live here know that that is a big segment. Like, where are 50 people living in Mammoth in January?

2:41:53 Most of them are in their vehicles, or some of them are in their vehicles. And those, who knows if you can comment all of them. And that leads to my last comment in the suggestion. Again, I don't know if it belongs in the plan, but I would love for you guys to consider something. For those people that work in town that live in their vehicles, again, they're not vagrants. They're people who work in town. We have an underused parking lot where the Tesla charging stations are.

2:42:20 What do we consider allowing people who work in town to park there overnight and not get rousted? I get that we have management issues with snow removal in the winter. You don't want like Ma Joad setting up her cooking station there, you know, in the parking area. But there are two really prominent resort communities that do a great job with just that kind of thing.

2:42:42 One is Santa Barbara. They have a management plan. They've been doing it for years. They've got 137 spaces where they allow people to park overnight. They've got a great management plan. And the other one's Malibu. At Zuma Beach, every year, they bring seasonal lifeguards in. They let them live in their vehicles right there in Zuma Beach. They've been doing it for 60 years very successfully. And I'd like you to consider maybe using one of our public resources along those lines. Thank you. Thank you. Any other public comment? If not, I will.

2:43:15 Close the public hearing and bring it back to Council for deliberation and watch John clean up. With the comments that were submitted by Mammoth Lake Housing incorporated into the document, if we approve it tonight, do we have to modify it in a week from now?

2:43:42 The final attachment in your packet goes through the comments and responses, how things were or were not incorporated. So some of Mammoth Lakes Housing comments were incorporated and some were not. So it just kind of goes through all those details. Thank you. Any others? John? Well, I just have a question. Ms. Cage brought up a number of ideas. This is obviously very, very late. This is you can't get later in the process.

2:44:15 And I just want a technical sense from staff of if we were to consider these things. I'm not saying that I support them putting them in here, but I'm just wondering, understanding what is involved in the process at this point to consider something like this coming at the last minute. I think I'd like to ask our consultant kind of what the HCD is. So generally we would have to go.

2:44:37 We do have to submit a final document back to HCD. And so they're generally looking for very minor changes to come back after they've given us their conditional approval. So maybe, Amy, you could expand a little bit on kind of the comments and your thought about maybe what HCD would think about the changes. Yeah, I would say changes related to accessory dwelling units. It would probably at least require us to touch base with them.

2:45:00 I think we need to...

2:45:28 They could be policy things that are in support of an adopted. Potentially, or ordinances that are not part of the housing element. Because we've only just heard this, we need to think through how it would all fit. I don't see revisions to development standards. While that's maybe something we want to look at, I don't think adding it to this is where we need to go. If we're going to do it, we need to go and revise those development standards. That's a whole different process.

2:45:59 Board-level thing that she suggests here. If we want to do that, again, that's outside of the scope of the housing element. We can do it. So we can do it. I don't see anything that Kathy is suggesting here that would prevent us from moving forward on this tonight if that's what we chose to do. Question. To the consultants, is it part of many other entities' plan to speak to homelessness within that, or is that something that's out of sort of the...

2:46:29 Out of the view of the general plan housing element. It varies, but I would say more often than not there are separate efforts. It's very much targeted towards homelessness because it's such a big issue. But it definitely is part of the populations that are evaluated in the housing element. Obviously, that's what we were just talking about.

2:46:55 So you could include more actions related to homelessness if you don't have another planning effort focused on homelessness. So you could call it out at least as a concern within the housing element. Yeah, and there are some actions that include the needs of homeless, but they're not as specific as a safe parking program.

2:47:17 You know, something along those lines. One other answer to a question. What is the state definition within this document of supportive housing? Like, what populations are included in supportive housing? So supportive housing, I probably can't recite it verbatim, but there is a very specific state definition. It's basically housing that provides long-term housing. So it's not transitional, and it's not emergency shelter, and it has services.

2:47:46 That go along with just providing a place to live. So it's focused on certain populations that need support where they live. Is there more physical support or would it be around, you know, chronically mental ill? I believe it could be either or. So it's a larger. It's a little bit broader than for only one particular population, but yeah, it would include folks who need actual help.

2:48:13 Assistance physically and also like supportive programs and services. Okay. Thank you. So Mr. Mayor, I just would just comment how proud I think we should all be of this work. And this is just, I mean, this is just state of the art, highest level professional work integrating a number of very complex planning mandated efforts. We were the first in the state to get a grant.

2:48:44 For CEPA. Other jurisdictions in the state have followed. With all the horrible and tragic things that have happened around wildfire, it's interesting to look back and say how far ahead we were on the curve with all this stuff. I think that the consultants could maybe advise that we may be, I think, one of the first groupings of communities in the entire state of California to get through this entire process with all the attendant pieces going with it.

2:49:09 I just think this is staff work of the highest caliber. And between the staff and the consultant team and the community that participated in these things, this is something we shall be enormously proud of. And I support it as presented. And I'm ready to make a motion if that's a desire of the folks. I am ready. Mr. Mayor, I'll make a motion.

2:49:31 That the Council adopt the attached resolution making the required findings for approval of a general plan amendment GPA 19-001 to update the housing and safety elements of the general plan including adoption of an addendum to the 2014 housing element initial study negative declaration. Is that the desired motion from staff? I'll second that. Motion to second. Any further deliberation? Not deliberation, but I think to echo John's comments that this is...

2:50:00 This is a daunting task, multi, you know, multi-effort, many staff. This is a great, great plan. As Sandra said, without a work plan now to go along with it to say, okay, this is a great plan, where do we go with it now as opposed to just, you know, kind of dusting it off every few years. That to me is so important, such a pivotal piece because, you know, now bringing that back. Do you have comments or ideas about when that might, when we might see, like, some of that?

2:50:29 After the final approval, which could still be how long? I think the final approval we're expecting the next, I think they have 60 days to give us our final approval. 90. 90. So we're still months out from the final stamp of approval. So after that time then we'll, okay, thank you. Any further comments or questions? So the 12 action items in there in the staff report, those will be followed up by staff. They don't become part of this. Those are part of the housing element.

2:50:59 Then they will be required to be brought back to us. Thank you. Those are the items, including the other action items that are continuing from the previous housing element that will all become part of the work program, correct? Thank you. Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Hobbs? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Hobbs? Yes. Councilmember Hobbs? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Yes. Mayor Schauser? Yes.

2:51:22 It passes 5-0. Does the council want to take separate action on the accepting the final CEPA recommendations? Sure. Of course. I would so move that the council adopt detached. What am I doing here? The second bullet point. Okay. Wait, let me. Did the town council accept?

2:51:45 The final CEPAW recommendations date October 31, 2018, and the 2019 Town of Mammoth Lakes Climate Change Vulnerability Assessment. Mr. Attorney, can we do that since it is not called out in the, while it is in the agenda item in the write-up, it is not on the agenda? Given that it's not in the agenda, it's not exactly called out, and it isn't quite.

2:52:16 Necessary. This is not a required finding for approval of the general plan amendment, I think. Right. No. This is just a housekeeping type item. I think it would be better to agendize it for a future meeting. Agendize this for a future meeting. Yes. Thank you. I withdraw my motion, but I'll make it the next time you guys get this thing on the agenda. Huh? Yeah. Or Linda might. Yeah, sure. We all might. Okay.

2:52:42 One just quick final note is how do we our general plan is now turning into the strikethrough underlying kind of thing. All the printed versions of the general plan are now getting increasingly out of date. We need to figure out how we're going to.

2:52:55 Deal with that. So we have updated the website version that includes all the changes up to tonight, so it doesn't include these changes, so we'll work on incorporating all these changes. That will be up on the webpage, and then we'll poll a council likely printing up a handful of hard copies for people who are looking for them. Okay. Good. Okay, thank you. And then just real briefly, I'd like to just thank Kim Cook for all her work on this Resilient Mammoth Lakes project. She really kind of...

2:53:21 Yeah, did a really great job, and just recently was promoted to associate planner, so also congratulate her on that, and we're really excited to continue to work with Kim and all these projects. Congratulations. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Obviously, it was huge. It was heavy. It was a good deal of heavy lifting. Thank you all. Moving on to policy matters. Discuss possible regional consolidated dispatch operations.

2:53:50 Is this going to be Nate or Pam and Nate or Nate and Rob or whoever? Combination thereof. So we're going to do a little bit of a tag team tonight on the presentation. Folks that have been working on this, mainly from the town, certainly with Nate's support, Pam as instrumental, as well as Al and myself.

2:54:41 Meeting over the last couple of months with the Inyo, Mono, Bishop, and Town of Mammoth Lakes looking to explore the opportunity of regional dispatch that would support, you know, all those entities and be able to really enhance the level of service while cost sharing, if you will, or reducing the cost to provide those services.

2:55:08 In the staff report, there's some details regarding the cost that we've seen. Right now, we contract with Mono County, the sheriff's office. They provide our dispatch services. It's based upon the call volume is how that's distributed, but it's been conducted out of the jail facilities in Bridgeport.

2:55:31 And as costs escalate, especially with employee costs and different negotiation components, that's increased quite a bit over the last couple of years. So for the town, it's a cost perspective. Primarily, there's some, again, enhanced levels of service that we would expect from a bigger and broader group. But right now, we're really looking at this regional impact and how we can work together.

2:56:00 Nate is here tonight to give the presentation. I'll follow it up at the end, talking a little about the cost of the request. And hopefully we get some input from you on whether you want to proceed with the $25,000 request we have at the end. And if so, we would bring it back in a consent agenda item for next council. But we'd want to get through that point. So I'll turn it over to Nate to take off. Great. Thank you, Rob.

2:56:26 I'll try to kind of move through this as quickly as possible. The arrangement of the slides that I will present are slightly different than what was included in your packet. The content is largely the same. So I just want to kind of touch on some of the high points and sort of how we got to where we're at and generally the things that we believe are beneficial through potentially looking at this as a solution and if it is a favorable or desirable.

2:56:53 Direction, sort of what the road ahead would look like. So just to kind of level the playing field and make sure everybody understands, the current conditions of dispatch for emergency services in the two-county area include three separate dispatch centers. Those are often referred to as PSAPs or Public Safety Answering Points. Mono County has one, as you are all probably aware, that is located in Bridgeport. It's in the jail.

2:57:20 The Mono County Dispatch services the law departments of both the sheriff and MLPD as well as 11 unincorporated and incorporated fire departments plus emergency medical services from the county. There's also some administrative functions that happen out of there. But one of the unique things about Mono County Dispatch is that the 17 or so FTEs that are allocated

2:57:49 Within that operation serve both as jailers as well as dispatchers. And that creates some challenges that we'll talk a little bit about. In Inyo County, there are two separate PSAPs, one serving the unincorporated portion of the county that's located in the jail as well. The difference is that the folks that staff the dispatch operation are not jailers. They are solely dispatchers.

2:58:13 That's a slightly smaller staff, about six FTEs, and they handle the share of fire and ambulance services as well as some ancillary operations outside of the county. And then there is a dispatch in Bishop, and they dispatch for the incorporated portion. They're both the city police and fire, and they have a slightly smaller staff even. But all told, we're looking at about 28.

2:58:40 FTEs across all three agencies, and the call volumes being what they are, there's generally a surplus of staff among all three of those dispatch centers. So one of the major things that's driving this conversation really is sort of several different facets of projects or initiatives that are happening at the county and at the town to a certain degree.

2:59:08 And so I really got involved in this conversation about 18 plus months ago when the new jail construction conversation started to emerge with the county. So again, as you probably are all aware, Mono County is in the process of building or designing and building a new jail facility in Bridgeport. And the foregone conclusion with that was that dispatch would just move in occupy space in that new jail.

2:59:35 And we started to realize through a number of different projects that are happening that that may be something that we should really evaluate more closely before just assuming that that is the best path forward.

2:59:47 An opportunity we probably won't see again for quite a while, and it makes a lot of sense to evaluate opportunities as we're designing that facility as opposed to just assume that we would actually design it around dispatch being there. So that had some time elements associated with it and became kind of the initial driver. The next one, which I've come and spoken with you before about, is the overall radio and communication efforts that are happening at the county. And there are several different

3:00:16 Projects within these three large umbrella areas that I sort of have shown here. One is the overall governance structure of what the radio system will look like in the future and how we manage and fund that and things like that. And that certainly does touch dispatch a little bit. But the two that are very, very closely connected

3:00:37 Are the system design itself, the engineering, and the technology behind what happens when you push the button on the radio to talk, and then ultimately the role the dispatch plays in that system. You know, more often than not, field personnel are not talking to one another, they are talking to dispatch. And so the way that dispatch is designed and operates really clearly influences some of the design of that.

3:01:03 The technology behind the system as well as the inverse of that. And so we really wanted to start asking some of these hard questions before we get headlong into a multimillion dollar effort only to realize that we may want to do something different that could change the course of actions along the way. Sitting in the center of all of these things are a bunch of other technology projects looking at our portfolio with MIT. I think we have about 60 different projects that we're working on that touch the emergency management space.

3:01:33 And I would say 80% of those have some relationship to dispatch and operations. And again, if dispatch looks one way, those projects need to go a certain way. And if it looks something different, they look and feel entirely different. And so, again, rather than investing a lot of time and money.

3:01:53 into sort of developing and rolling out technology. We want to clearly know where we're trying to get to in five, ten plus years so that we're not double spending time and money. We know that we've got some operational challenges, and Rob alluded to these. You know, at the surface, most fundamentally, the county has an ongoing challenge with recruitment and retention of dispatchers. Because of the dual-duty role that is

3:02:20 served by those individuals. Some come into the position wanting to be jailers, not dispatchers, and some wanting to be dispatchers and not jailers. Some want to be both, but invariably it's a very challenging environment to be in, regardless of what your skill set and interest is. You're being stressed in one fashion or another based on the very challenging facets of those jobs. Combined with location and a variety of other factors, it's just challenging to find people who can really fill those roles.

3:02:50 And, you know, associated with that, we see cost escalations, as Rob referred to. You know, those are driven sometimes by overtime because of lack of staff and sometimes a variety of other facets. And so we believe that there are probably ways to improve operations as a whole if you start to separate those duties out. And then related to that is really improving customer service.

3:03:14 So, you know, we also believe and have heard from a lot of the stakeholders and people dependent upon dispatch that they'd like to see other things happen. And I think the county would fully support those things happening if some of the other conditions that I was referring to earlier weren't actually present. So we're trying to find a way to solve around all of those things. So, you know, as I referred to at the beginning, you know, we started to really look at what the current conditions were like and think about what dispatch could be.

3:03:42 Especially if we were able to separate it from the jail. And there was an initial meeting a little over a year ago with a handful of key stakeholders, the sheriffs, the chiefs of police, some fire agency personnel, just to kind of test the waters. And it did seem through that initial conversation that there was some potential support for this. There wasn't a lot of animosity or pushback at least around it. But things kind of simmered for a little bit.

3:04:09 And over the last several months, we've kind of picked the conversations back up just given how the conversation and the work that's being done around the radio system design has been proceeding and the timing of the jail project and things like that. And so we've had a couple of other key stakeholder meetings with about 14 or so personnel from the four major agencies in Yonmono County, City of Bishop, and Town of Mammoth Lakes.

3:04:34 And all agencies really see value in consolidation. I think it's not to say that there aren't some concerns or aren't some places that we have apprehension, but in general, there's interest in trying to move the conversation forward. So with that, we started to evaluate some other examples in the state. We've been talking to the state.

3:04:54 We went and talked to some of these other agencies that have been successful in implementing things, as well as there's actually a fair bit of experience within this group of 14 or so with regional dispatch throughout their careers in other places. And so we started to pull some of that information together and really try to get a better understanding of how we'd move this forward. I won't talk too much about this, but there are a few really key organizations or counties.

3:05:21 In the state that have been looked to or are in the process of actually doing this and generally have been successful, Santa Cruz probably leads that charge. Clint Quilter, who's the County Administrative Officer in Inyo, was the City Manager at Hollister, and Hollister and San Medino joined forces with Santa Cruz.

3:05:44 Basically to consolidate and have a regional dispatch center there. So he's very familiar with how that operation works. It's been looked at as a very good model and generally has been quite successful. Imperial County is in the process of going through this. They just finished a feasibility study and we've been talking to them. And then there's a couple of other examples in the northern part of the state. Reading.

3:06:08 And Shasta County with Shascom, and there's another one in Yolo County. And so we're trying to look at and better understand what worked well, what didn't work, and certainly not go into this headlong without some of that information. So, you know, as I said a moment ago, we believe there's some opportunities. And, you know, I think one of the first is that we actually have people at the table who are engaged and are interested in this, that are supportive of this. Leadership within these agencies, you know, obviously can change.

3:06:37 And we believe that kind of striking while the iron's hot in terms of moving the conversation forward is important given the leadership that is in play right now. We believe there is an opportunity potentially to consolidate the three separate PSAPs into one in Bishop. Bishop has been very successful, or I should say successful, in actually their recruitment and retention efforts. And so they've generally been able to find...

3:07:05 Personnel and keep them. And they've been quite happy with their dispatchers there. And so we believe there are some opportunities there matched with sort of the existing size and footprint, opportunities to potentially scale, and generally the fact that, you know,

3:07:21 With these three dispatch centers, we have more capacity than we typically need. And so we think we probably do need to grow a little bit. But initially, we probably could start out and leverage some of the existing resources that are there. As referred to by Rob sort of tangentially, and I sort of referred to as well, there are some issues with governance. And I can say that I think

3:07:46 The way that the dispatch is structured now, there isn't really a formal seat at the table for the town around how dispatch operates, despite the town contracting that service with the county. And I think that there is an opportunity to really evaluate through a governance structure that is more modernized how that situation could be improved and how dispatch operations could generally be improved. I think with that obviously comes some challenges.

3:08:14 But some potential benefits around operations and maintenance, potential for funding, technology coordination and various things like that. We all collaborate on a mutual aid and response level as it is. And so it makes sense to tie some of the brains behind that operation back together as well and to coordinate on the back end. And then the last is certainly not the least, which is it's a resilient solution that's theoretically scalable. And that's through economies of scale.

3:08:41 As well as through being able to really build a system that can work well and can stand up against the tests of disaster and, you know, other potential things that can take down these centers. So, you know, the road ahead, I think, is a little bit fuzzy depending on some critical decisions that need to be made along the way. But really this is kind of the first major stop in that.

3:09:07 We are here before you tonight to sort of get a general level of engagement, I guess, from your council. This will be going to the Mono County Board of Supervisors and Inyo County Board of Supervisors as well as the Bishop City Council in the coming weeks. And then we'll be getting back together to really talk about the path forward. The goal really is to try to obtain that authority and approval and secure some money.

3:09:34 How do you make the transition from

3:10:03 A dispatcher in Mono County to Bishop if that was so desired and various things like that. It's more than what we could do internally from our capacity and knowledge. So hopefully we would actually reach out and retain that consultant and then through that basically work toward an implementation plan and that would really start with kind of the governance pieces of this and something that we'd like to try to move as efficiently as possible on just given that outside pressure from the jail construction. So really with that

3:10:32 And I'm sorry, this is a slide that was actually from the county's deck. I think there's actually only two requests before you this evening, and I'll let Rob cover those. Yeah, there's a couple points I'd like to reiterate. And very good job, Nate, with the presentation. Thank you. I think the key point is that Mammoth is in a unique position because we contract right now. We're the only one of the agencies that are involved that are dependent upon someone else to do this function for us.

3:11:02 What that means is as we go forward as Inyo or Mono or Bishop look to go through this process, they're going to be changing from full control over their entity and their process to a joint group that has a joint control function. So that in itself is going to be a bit of a change. So that level of work, effort, and design and construction that we need that professional approach with would help that process significantly.

3:11:31 For us, it's kind of a no-brainer. We have to do that currently today, but I think for these other entities, it's going to be a significant stepping point. As Nate said, the agencies have completed this. The work that is there, the consultants are there that can perform this function very well. We're asking for the 25,000. It's up to, I think we believe that each entity would contribute the same amount.

3:11:55 But we believe that we would be able to probably come in significantly under that, if not have some other opportunities for funding sources, grant type functions. But the request tonight is for the $25,000 or just deliberation on that and direction for staff to bring back. The source of that funding would be essentially general fund fund balance is later on tonight, fourth quarter, I'm going to present. There's no recommendation for it in the fourth quarter.

3:12:25 But there will be a significant portion of funding that goes into general fund balance tonight from that, and the money would be available from that. So that would be the source of funds. Any questions? So we would then be contributing $25,000 towards this feasibility study along with the county, along with Inyo, along with Simons? City of Bishop.

3:12:50 Yeah, so the goal was to have the City of Bishop, Town of Mammoth Lakes, Inyo, and Mono County all contribute $25,000 each. They would be for the feasibility study and an implementation plan. Who dispatches for Inyo share? Inyo County. So they would be in it too then? Yeah. So not just the Town of Bishop. No, Bishop and Inyo both. Okay, both. Okay, that's what it is. And then the other question I have is, are we seriously considering the component of emergency medical dispatch?

3:13:17 As opposed to just a plain old dispatch as we had before. Some of our remote areas of the county can really benefit from that level of dispatch services, and it was a no-go with the amount of county service, you know. Right, yeah, and it is one of the things that we've talked about at the table. I think, obviously, both counties really see the value in that, and I think that that's one of those economy of scale types of things that could potentially start to emerge. Enhancement of services, yeah. Okay, and then computer aid to dispatch.

3:13:44 As much as possible, too. Yeah, so the one good thing, and this is obviously an opportunity, and as we get down into the weeds on technology things, you know, a lot of the stuff starts to emerge, but all four of these agencies are standardized on the same CAD system, the same computer automated dispatch and record system, which is a value to us now.

3:14:05 And it would help just sort of streamline some of that going forward. There still need to be some changes, but it makes things a lot cleaner and easier. Okay. And then last question was, if we were to kind of proceed with this, then would the jail not be designed with a big, robust dispatch capability, or would they still put it in in case they needed it? How would they? Yeah, that's a great question, and I think that's something that we would probably deliberate through the feasibility study.

3:14:35 Most likely what would end up happening is that we would retain at least a position there just for the reason of resiliency and redundancy. If anything was to ever happen, we do have the opportunity to have some backup. The bigger question and kind of complication, and this is something that we're starting to talk to the state a little bit about, is whether that PSAP...

3:14:58 So there's a few details there that need to be worked out, but I think principally,

3:15:28 There wouldn't be any difficulty in doing that other than the cost in life cycle replacements. So basically we've got a consolidated kind of dispatch center between all these entities within the two counties? Correct. Not any determination where that would live or what it would look like? The supposition right now is that Bishop is probably the best place, but again through the study we may find something completely different. And nobody down there that dispatches also is a jailer in New County? Yeah, nor Bishop obviously.

3:15:58 So I think that it sounds like an excellent idea. I think it makes just imminent sense. I'm hoping that, I would assume, but I want to make sure that it's clear that Digital 395 is going to be the technical background for this whole thing, right? We're not going to get in a position where that infrastructure is second tier to Verizon or Frontier or some other silly stuff like that. Yeah, I won't get into the weeds on the complications of all of this, but one of the things that is making this

3:16:28 possible and much easier is the fact that there is a digital 395 presence at all three of these PSAPs currently, which facilitates and streamlines that consolidation and would also allow for there to be a redundant site someplace else without a significant investment. Now, there's a lot of other little nitty-gritty things to that as Next Generation 911 rolls out and things like that. You know, there's some devil in the details, but generally speaking, that is...

3:16:56 I mean, we have state-of-the-art, you know, glass broadband infrastructure. It should be able to, if it can't work for anything else, it should work for this, I would think. Yeah, and I think the state, you know, interestingly enough, recognizes there are some very unique opportunities that exist here that don't elsewhere in the rest of the state. And so they're very intrigued, I guess, by this project and some of the potential facets of it. Okay, and how would search and rescue time, is there an opportunity to start getting

3:17:25 A little bit mature with our search and rescue things that are going to be throughout the region. Well, if you're talking about the quality of communication within the county? I'm just, you know, if we're putting together something like this, it's going to be, I would assume, kind of a state-of-the-art system throughout at least two counties when we're dealing with search and rescue. I'm thinking in terms of how we...

3:17:53 We're moving air service to Bishop. We're looking at really putting this region on the map as a recreation tourism destination. You can have more people doing more foolish kind of crazy things. I would hope that this capacity, whatever we build into this thing, is going to be able to extend to those kinds of needs as well. Yeah, I mean, I can speak to being on the search and rescue team. The work that we're doing...

3:18:18 The support of the new radio systems would be significant for us because that's one of the issues we have is communication throughout the broad area of that. And we are working very hard as far as getting the most robust search and rescue group we can possibly put together because of what we're dealing with, just what you described. We have so many people recreating out there and the opportunities that we have. In the last two years I've been involved, we've had some spectacular missions which have...

3:18:47 You know, given us a bit more reach and breadth and understanding. We were just recently recognized by Mono County for those efforts and that was a really good process. But so yeah, we're gaining notoriety for that. I think there's a lot of conversation in the airwaves regarding that. So I think people understand when they come to the county that they're in pretty good shape.

3:19:10 Yeah, I mean, that's another thing that we should be investing in as part of this. So how does the Forest Service and the Park Service and BLM, how would they fit into all this? That's a great question. So they are dispatched currently out of the supervisor's office in Bishop there on Lyme Street. We initially, and this has probably been almost two years ago now, had approached them to see if it was possible to consolidate services there, and there wasn't really an interest at that point in time.

3:19:38 I think through the feasibility study we would not want to leave any stone unturned and go back and look at that as a potential option, but there wasn't a lot of interest at the time. And they have a fairly different type of operation than we do. It's all federal stuff. Yeah, right. And just the 24-7 nature and the types of calls and things that they're dealing with are a little bit different as well. So I don't know that it would make sense, but I think that it would make sense to at least go back and evaluate it again. Okay.

3:20:07 Thank you very much. And what do we currently pay Mono County for dispatch services? 75? I'm sorry? What do we currently pay Mono County for dispatch services? It is just under $400,000, $396,000. Okay. I'm excited.

3:20:29 By the potential of looking into this, but there are so many pitfalls that I can see that are going to have to be, you know, someone's going to really have to dot the I's and cross the T's from what entity is paying what to how many FTEs are required. I'm assuming there are studies that show on call volume how many people you should have. I find just from reading the report and the numbers you put up there, it kind of odd that Mono County Dispatch

3:20:56 Has more FTEs than Bishop and Inyo County combined? So hopefully this study that I am fully in support of can shake those answers out when you come back to me with a report to let me know how it's going to be funded by the four entities, who pays what, what the overarching, is it going to be like an ESTA with a governing board? Is it going to be, you know, there's a lot of things, is it another?

3:21:25 JPA board, or is it, it, it, it, so yeah, that's me. Any other questions and comments? I'm prepared to make a motion if you'd like to accept one. Make it. Mr. Mayor, I would recommend that the town staff, the town council authorize the town staff to continue the regional dispatch conversation with other local agencies and that the town council set aside $25,000 from the fourth quarter budget to produce a feasibility study and implementation plan for regional dispatch. Okay.

3:21:53 I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes, 5-0. Moving on to item number 12, fourth quarter fiscal year 18-19 budget review, Rob. Okay, thank you very much. So as you know, we talk about the budget as often as you guys let me come in and talk about it.

3:22:28 And this fourth quarter is usually the time of year where it's really wrapping things up. We don't have a ton of expenditure items to discuss. We talk about the revenue as we go through the process. I'll just briefly talk about it. So the fall, we talk about fund balance from the prior fiscal year, which means that this is 18-19 actuals.

3:23:00 We'll get another chance to look at these numbers, especially the fund balances as we get right before the audit starts and that process works. So that's the first presentation of the year, and it's really the close of last year. Mid-year, we usually talk about the snow-related impacts and different things that are going on, a check-in for how we're doing for the middle of the year, both revenue and expenditure-wise. Not a lot of changes happen there. Third quarter is when...

3:23:25 We've realized all the snow-related impacts. We realize where the revenues are coming in stronger than expected, and we'll make significant moves there. So we did the third quarter in the middle of May as a presentation, and we made some significant moves at that point. This is really just fine-tuning at the end of it, where we talk about this is where we came in with all the revenue components and if there's any financial or expenditure costs that come forward. So we'll certainly talk first about the transient occupancy tax.

3:23:54 And this year, if folks haven't heard, we expect to hit 20.1 million for 18-19 as far as a number, which is a very, very big number. But that's kind of where we've been trending throughout the process and it's remained strong. We did realize that. We had records in nine months of last year for an all-time record.

3:24:22 The key here we're going to recognize, or we're recommending $2.1 million in additional budget be realized for that fourth quarter. Now, of course, that'll have impacts to the reserve components, which is tourism, transit, and housing. As Council has directed us, we keep those, the same rates of allocation occur to the reserve accounts after the budget is reached, and so we'll have a strong year for all of those groups.

3:24:52 But that's, I listed it on here, but we'll talk about it in a little bit as an expense, because that's really talking about revenues and expenditures. Some other areas that I want to talk about for revenue, again, as we get into fine tuning, I talk about other TOT elements, which essentially are the penalties and interest, the violations that we have out there. And the way I've listed it on this report is I showed the adopted budget.

3:25:21 Which is adopted or amended budget prior to this presentation. And then the middle is the requested change. And then the final one would be with that requested change, what would be the new amended budget? So that's the format that I'm using here. I think that was a recommendation from Council to follow this process fairly clearly. And I like the way it looks because it gives you a sense of overall what was the highest level we achieved.

3:25:48 For that particular revenue item or expenditure item, if you look at it later when we talk about expenditures. So it gives you a real strong sense of how those all performed. In the other TOT elements, again, fine-tuning. It's $87,700 in additional revenue that we want to realize from those elements. Business tax, as you know, has been very, very strong. The team, Sandra's team, has been working really hard on that.

3:26:16 And those are restricted for the support of business. I'm sorry, not business tax. I'm getting ahead of myself. Business tax, that's still in my team. We work really hard on the process of renewal, and that is essentially an annual process where the business tax certificates are renewed. We've developed our processes throughout the year where we're working through the education piece. We're working through

3:26:45 Components where we're reaching out to them multiple times through a year. We're just making sure that we have it clean, meaning the businesses that are in business are still there and paying the tax and legal and the ones that decide not to get off of that process. But we've worked through that, so that's why the penalties and interests are there, the application fees and just the strength of the economy in our businesses locally.

3:27:10 Over the last two years at least have been have driven these numbers up pretty strongly. So I'd also like to focus on cannabis tax there. You can see that our amended budget is $104,000 for the year and that is representative of really the last quarter's strength. We had one entity that was functioning for most of the year and in fact not just missed one month of the year.

3:27:35 And then we had two other, one other retail establishment and then some fluids manufacturing and other facilities out at the industrial park that just started to ramp up really in the last quarter. So the expectation is we're going to be running somewhere around $20,000 to $22,000 a month in revenue from cannabis tax. And that's, you know, kind of, we didn't budget that high for this coming fiscal year.

3:28:04 But that's something that's been pretty strong and hope it remains so. So that's one good one to point out. And then now we'll talk about building fees. You can see $881,000 is what we expect to hit for the year as far as revenue on that, the building permits. And that's just the strength of what's going on within the town. And that's, you know, not a lot of major projects, essentially. Those are just the work that's going on. Planning, zoning, and other master fees.

3:28:32 Categorize them, if you will, into their same areas. With other revenues, again, just really clean up stuff. The one I want to point out in that is the interest from the county. So the county we have, only the Reserve for Economic Uncertainty is in the county pool. And so we have, we don't really budget any interest for that particular line item because we just

3:29:00 Don't want to have expectations on that. If we budget that, that would be a part of general fund revenue. And the idea here is that anything that we earn in that particular bucket would then go to the REU. It would stay in that. But the strength of that $93,000 for the year is pretty strong. And so that attributed to the interest rates that are out there and how they've performed.

3:29:26 In summary on the general fund revenues, in the fourth quarter we're going to realize $2.686 million across those five different groups that I put together there for you. And that sort of represents the revenue component. Any questions so far? Let's talk now a little bit about expenses.

3:29:50 Again, expenses, there aren't anything of significance. If I could categorize them, they would be like year-end finalization and either true-ups or adjustments that need to be made. But they're really, we try to capture in the third quarter all the real expense elements that are going above and beyond. So the first line item there, the TOT bonus program, it was earned based upon the budget excess for TOT revenue.

3:30:18 And there's 57 participants. That total cost is $154,500. And just really a quick recap of that is what we do is we take the TOT revenue over and above the budget. We take out all of the TOT attributed to either transit, tourism, or housing. So we kind of net down just to the town's portion of that. And then the pool size is just 5% of that excess. So we try to keep it.

3:30:47 You know, a very narrow group there. And then we say, okay, in that, a maximum of $3,000 is the bonus. So that process, that's sort of a briefing on how that goes, but that total cost for the year is $154,500. I listed in here the $93,000 for the interest from the county to go to REU because I realized the revenue on that front side. I'm realizing the expense on this side so that the money doesn't show. At the end of this, you'll have a

3:31:17 Bucket of available dollars, which will be general fund. And so if I left the revenue in there without showing the expenditure side, then we would have more expected funds to be able to be spent. So put it in on both sides. So the recommendation will be that we convert all of that $93,000 in revenue into the REU, which will drive that number up. We're at 3.76 now. So that would go up.

3:31:46 Just a little bit higher. On the police expenditure, this was a last minute item that had just come in in the month of June, and it is really kind of collaborating with Mono County District Attorney on a contract that they established with Washoe County to perform forensic investigations. It's a very highly specialized set of...

3:32:10 The level of investigation, the intent of the police department and the $10,000 would be just our portion of that contract. And the intent there would be we would use that for any major cases, but it would help expedite those hopefully to successful understanding what happened. But that's really a highly specialized component right now. There's entities throughout the state that do it, but we'd have to pay for that. So this contract would be beneficial. And then finally, there's a couple of cleanup items.

3:32:39 We sold a paver last year, and it was categorized as a general fund revenue. And what happened is it ended up hitting the general fund fund balance last year, and it really belonged to transfer to garage services. So the request here is basically we're going to be moving it from general fund fund balance over to garage services.

3:33:05 And that's the $37,600. And then finally, we've had an open accounts receivable slash bad debt from 2011 and 12 on a capital project, and that amounted to $85,691. We've been trying to collect on that and work through the process, but we've determined that the outcome is not going to be successful, certainly as things age, they get more and more challenging to collect.

3:33:34 That $85,691 is a write-off, and that's just to clean up our outstanding receivables to really what we expect to receive, and that's certainly not going to be one of those. So of the three different sections, the total expenditures is $380,791, and that represents expenditure components. Catch up on my page here. Talking about the summary, try to bring it all together on one. Talking about the revenue at the top.

3:34:06 Again, back to the five components we talked about, the $2.686 million. Highlight the political commitments because they have to come out of that number of availability. So that's $654,000 that would go to those three different reserves. Leaving available funds of $2,032,000, and from that we would take out that $380,791 we just talked about.

3:34:33 Available general fund of $1.651 million. Now staff has no recommendations for utilization of that tonight, so the recommendation would be that we let that go into fund balance for general fund, and that would be available for review and allocation by council direction in the future. We would get an opportunity to talk about that again in, I believe it's going to be November 20th, based upon some timing.

3:35:00 And availability of all council members, that we would be able to come back and talk about these pre-audit fund balance numbers and give council the opportunity to both understand what we have in these funds, what we've earmarked them for, allocated them for in the past, and make adjustments to that or either allocate these funds. So are there any questions regarding the fourth quarter update so far? I mean, I did one more slide.

3:35:29 Of course I have questions. No, this is excellent, but it's a snapshot of the quarter, and so I have asked Rob to put together what's happened to all the excess TOT, and so hopefully in the future we'll...

3:35:43 We'll get a presentation of how those dollars, because I periodically get asked, we're looking at about $21 million over our operational budget over a four-year period of time. So, you know, people ask me, well, what happened to all of that? So he's done an excellent job of outlining where those expenditures went, and we've accomplished, and I think it's very important to show what has been accomplished. And I agree, we've accomplished a lot by...

3:36:12 Running the budget in this manner, so I'm very pleased with it. Any questions? I would then entertain a motion. Mr. Mayor, I will move that the Town Council, having received the budget report for fourth quarter fiscal year 2018-19, that we adopt the resolution amending fiscal year 2018-19 budget as outlined in the Attachment A budget adjustments.

3:36:37 In fiscal year 2019-20 budget, as it outlined in the patch would be budget adjustments. Second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Passes 5-0. Moving on to item.

3:37:04 So, Rob, you're not going to talk about the carryover right now? I was just going to, I was, I got a little ahead of myself and you guys took it and ran with it, so I'm totally happy to talk just real briefly about this. And essentially what the carryover fund is, is when we have, or you have allocated funding for a particular process or something that we're spending money on, it would be a project or

3:37:32 A consulting for a particular service. If we haven't spent that money within the year and we do anticipate more of those invoices to come or more activity to come in the next fiscal year, we'll go through and say these are the...

3:37:48 This is the remaining payments that we expect to make within this function. And we need to take those dollars out of the budget from 1819 and move them into 1920. And so what you have on this particular page is the adjustments that we have and the items that we still expect to spend on those allocated dollars. And that just keeps it really clean across fiscal years and makes it easy for us to get the budget associated with the activity, if that makes sense.

3:38:18 Thank you for asking and clarification. Okay. Okay, moving on to the affordable housing credit valuation policy. I have to stand up. Yeah, normally it's been long enough I would call for a break. If you would like, I will do that. I'm just trying to power through this. We will take a five-minute break. Thank you. Sorry. It gives Nolan time to set up anyway. We'll move on.

3:39:47 To the next item. Thank you. Dust off that throne. Affordable housing credit valuation policy. Thank you. So the purpose of this policy is to establish a monetary value for existing housing credits. These credits were provided to developers for completing the required housing mitigation in advance of the project that created the demand.

3:40:24 Under the previous housing ordinance, these credits were classified as full-time employee equivalents or FTEEs and employee housing units or EHUs. These are both used to identify the amount of housing mitigation that was required in the past. We're also used to identify the number of credits provided for various actions such as constructing affordable housing or providing land that could be used for affordable housing purposes.

3:40:50 An FTE is a unit of measurement intended to identify the number of full-time year-round employees that a project would generate, whereas an EHU is intended to identify the actual number of sleeping areas and is considered to equal one bedroom. An EHU is considered to be 58.5% of an FTE. The policy applies the methodology used in the Town's 2015 Nexus Study to determine the value of the fee.

3:41:18 Also, if the NEXUS study is updated, which we are looking at an update for the next year, the value of the housing credits would be adjusted accordingly. For reference purposes, the existing housing credits include the Dempsey-Snow Creek credits consisting of 16.5 FTEEs assigned to the Snow Creek 8 project and 40.41 FTEEs that are assigned to the Yotelpad project. These previously were Dempsey credits.

3:41:49 Then also the Intrastar credits, previously the IntraWest credits, those consist of 54 EHUs. Moving on to how the value of the credits was established, the proposed methodology utilized a method similar to that used for establishing the housing fees in the 2015 NEXUS study. In that study, the recommended housing impact fees were calculated by first calculating the subsidy or financing gap for the development of affordable housing units,

3:42:22 This is calculated for the various income categories by taking the production cost for a two-bedroom, 900-square-foot unit, calculated $283,800, and subtracting the supportable price for the various income levels from that cost. As shown here in this middle column here, there is a financing gap for all income categories with the exception of the above moderate level.

3:42:49 The next study then determined what portion of the subsidy would be applied to the mitigation fee and determined that only 30% of the subsidy for income levels of 60% AMI and below was applicable because the other 70% was assumed to be covered by such sources as the town or MLH through grants and other programs. And so the subsidy after those fees is shown here on the bottom.

3:43:18 Those subsidies were then divided by two since the production cost was based on a two-bedroom unit and an EHU is considered to be a one-bedroom. This is shown here in Table 2. Again, there is no subsidy shown for the above moderate since there was no subsidy provided.

3:43:42 Next, the proportion of affordability levels was set using the town's 2019 to 2027 regional housing needs allocation arena. This table identifies the mix for moderate income levels and below, only since there's, again, not a financing gap for above moderate. So those percentages or the mix are shown here in table three.

3:44:13 And lastly, the percentages in Table 3 were multiplied with the values in Table 2 to determine the blended value for an EHU. The values for the income levels were then added together to determine the value of the EHU. Using this methodology, the EHU value would be $24,908. The value for an FTEE was then determined by multiplying the blended EHU value by 58.5%.

3:44:41 And the FTEE value would be $14,571. This is shown here in Table 4, the EHU, as well as the FTEE. This slide shows how the fee credit would be applied to a project. The example used here is for a 125-room hotel project where the developer owns 40.41 FTEE credits.

3:45:09 Those 40.41 FTEE credits would be multiplied by the FTEE value. So you'd have a total value of $588,814. Next, the housing in lieu fee that if they didn't have credits would be determined by multiplying the number of hotel rooms by the current fee set by the fee schedule. So in this example, that fee that they would owe would be $462,500.

3:45:38 And then the difference between them, so if the value of the FTEE credits is greater than the housing in lieu fee, the developer would retain that additional amount in the form of FTEE credits. So in this example here, there's a difference of $126,314 remaining, which means they would retain 8.11 FTEEs.

3:46:06 Ultimately, the developer could transfer those to other properties pursuant to the housing ordinance. Alternatively, if the FTE credit was less than the in-lieu fee, the developer would be required to cover the difference. This could be through the payment of the additional in-lieu fee amount, or they could use one of the other mitigation options specified in the housing ordinance. So in this example, it's for a 200-room hotel project, same amount of FTE credits.

3:46:36 The required fee would be $740,000. So they would owe $151,186 in additional mitigation. So the use of these credits would be documented in an agreement between the town and the owner of the credits. That would state the number of the credits, the value, and if there's any remaining credits for future use. Also, some factors that would affect the value of the credits include a change in the housing fees.

3:47:07 A higher fee would reduce the overall value of the credits under this policy. Also, if there's a change in the NEXUS study, so if the subsidy or financing gap, if that value were to increase, the value of the fees would also increase accordingly. And also, it won't change until 2028, but if we have a higher RHNA, that could also increase the value of the credits.

3:47:36 So this last slide just shows, using this policy, what the value of all the outstanding credits would be. So Yotel Pad, they have a value of $588,814. Snow Creek 8, the value would be $240,422. And Intrastar would have a value of about $1.5 million.

3:48:03 So that concludes my presentation on the housing credit policy. Staff's recommendation would be to adopt the resolution for the housing, affordable housing credit valuation policy. Questions start with Cleland? Nothing? Lynda? Kirk? So the DIF fee impacts the valuation? What the DIF, our current DIF, what's the relationship?

3:48:36 To the FTE and to these credits, is there any relationship? Development impact fee or the housing mitigation fee? Yeah. So he's got 40 units. Okay, so yeah, on this one, if the current housing impact fee were to increase, so in this example is $3,700 even though the current fee is $4,000, so the ultimate value would...

3:49:06 Or if the fee went up to $6,000, the ultimate value of those FTE credits would be reduced because the difference would be smaller. So when they reduced the hotel rooms from $11,000 to $3,700, when they made that change, that has a huge impact here. Correct. And then it's a smaller gap now that the fee's been increased to $4,000 for hotel rooms.

3:49:38 Thank you. John? Is this the complete inventory of all the credits that are in the system at this point? At this point, yes. If a developer were to build on-site units or do off-site units or donate land under the current housing ordinance, if that value was higher than what the fee would be, they would also be assigned credits under the current ordinance, but nobody has elected to do that. Anyone from the public wishing?

3:50:17 Good evening, Mayor Sauser and Councilmembers. Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. So just so you guys know, I'm InterStar, the last man standing as far as we're the ones that inherited the credits from InterWest. And so we've got a pretty big vested interest in this issue here.

3:50:42 Real quick, I did participate in the review of this with Sandra and Jen Daugherty from Lisa Weiss when she helped develop the analysis. And, you know, we're fully in support of the methodology. It just occurred to me, though, as I was reviewing this here, I got a couple questions with regards to...

3:51:06 The non-static nature of the value. And I think as Nolan pointed out, he mentioned to you guys that the values were in establishing the fee or the credit amount were based on the Nexus study. And the Nexus study was approved in 2015, correct? So, for example, could you go back to table two, I think it is? I'm sorry, go back to table one. There you go.

3:51:38 The production cost noted there is $283,800 for it. Down on the bottom there says that development prototype is a two-bedroom, 900-square-foot unit. So that equates to $315 a square foot for the production cost of the unit. And as you note, it's the same value across for all incomes, right? So that's the value of cost to build that unit. And then you go through the calculus of what the...

3:52:06 And so my point is, is that I believe that those

3:52:33 You know, the language in the policy is a little

3:53:04 This is a little vague on the actual updating of the, it says right here, affordable housing credit valuation policy be reviewed in conjunction with the review of the affordable housing, affordable workforce housing fee nexus study and fee recommendation in the updated as necessary. In the staff report, it says, lost my spot here in the staff report, this is said that it'll be reviewed periodically by the development director.

3:53:50 So my only question is if somebody, so if we come in asking for a credit and we say, look, we don't think that the 315 a square foot is any longer a valid production cost. Obviously, if it's higher, then that's going to increase the value of the credit. So my question is how much flexibility is there at the time that a credit is requested to reevaluate? I mean, I think we wouldn't.

3:54:21 Be looking to make changes to the assumptions made in the Nexus study kind of on an ad hoc basis. So we would look to the next the Nexus study that we would adopt next year to help provide that information and then update that every five years. So we're not looking to kind of make assumptions about any components of the Nexus study on an ad hoc basis without kind of going through the proper process.

3:55:07 And we can, we can, I mean, we are, like I said, we're kicking off the housing, the Nexus study right now, and it's definitely going to be a public process, so we would encourage that type of information to be included as we discuss that and move forward. Our goal is to have that policy or the Nexus study adopted mid next year, probably mid to late next year, 2020, but I think that's a good comment that we can take into account as we look to update the Nexus study.

3:55:35 And my comment to that would be, while certainly building costs have gone up, so the value of that, the FTEE should go up as well, but it actually should be set on the value of how much we have changed the housing mitigation fee. Since we have not significantly increased the housing mitigation fee, I would not want to go back and change how much your FTEE is worth based on the inflation of

3:56:05 Building, because we've kept the fees artificially low to, you know, to help the building community already. So they're connected.

3:56:44 So, I guess my concern is that the policy language just cites the nexus that if you're in that by your cycle and inflation increases, you're kind of hitting the short end. So, I would want to have, I would have furnishing some ability to tie it to a cost index or something.

3:57:16 It doesn't prohibit us from updating the Nexus study would make those modifications and changes. If we've seen that type of change, I guess the question, the pushback on that or the other impact would be

3:57:44 Using that number to help set the fee in the Nexus study is very important because if that goes to $400 or $500 a square foot, then that fee goes up maybe even more dramatically than what the valuation does. So when you do that offset, it may or may not work to the advantage of the credit holder. So I think you'd want to be careful because the same thing, if that goes down to $250, then that goes the other direction. I mean, if you see a decrease in cost.

3:58:14 Whether that happens or not. But I think you want to be careful in terms of how often you'd update that because then that would potentially have to come back and that would be a justification to increase the fee accordingly as well because that changes the next study values that it's created on. We did a lot of discussion in the next study on what is that construction value and there's a push not to make that too high.

3:58:40 So there is, I just, I wanted to, we'd have to think it through, because I think the impact could be, yeah. So you want to be, yeah, so I was just saying it has a cap in there, which we're under, so I just want to be cautious of what that means. Yeah. I understand the comment.

3:59:20 Thank you, John. Okay, moving forward, any other comments from Council? I'm ready. I'll make a motion to adopt the attached resolution establishing the affordable housing credit valuation policy. Second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie, please. Yes. Yes.

4:00:03 Yes. Yes. Yes. Resolution passes. The motion passes 5-0. Moving on to item number 14, resolution setting compensation benefits and other terms and conditions of employment for fiscal year 19-20, fiscal year 20-21-22 for specified non-represented town positions. Yes. Mr. Mayor. Yes.

4:00:30 This is the last piece of our negotiation process with employees. These are not represented by a formal union. We've gone through a number of different discussions on that, the proposals outlined in the staff report. In the sense of time, I won't walk through all the details of it. You've seen some discussions through the closed session negotiation process. I can address any particular questions there. It does kind of walk through the various changes and modifications that would go to the non-represented employees.

4:00:58 There's other elements in those that contracts and stuff that would go forward and also in accordance with other town policies and other elements that are added into that element of what they're eligible for as being full-time employees with the town. And we have a lot of state and federal laws that apply to benefit packages, et cetera. So if there's any questions, I can address those specifically. The staff report kind of walks through the various financial changes and I'd be glad to address any questions that the council may have.

4:01:27 Questions, Kirk? Cleland? None. None here either. I would entertain a motion. I'll make a motion that we adopt a resolution related to compensation benefits and other terms and conditions of employment for fiscal years 2019 through 20 through 21, 22 for specified non-represented town positions. Second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation?

4:02:01 Jamie, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. We will now move into a closed session on the special item we added today. Dan, do we need to go into the cozy little room or can we accomplish that here? Being the last item on the agenda, we can accomplish that here if you give us a moment to clean up the room. Yep. But you're on the clock.