TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2019

Town Council

· recording 5 hr 38 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

711 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:24 Okay, I will call to order this workshop of the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes for October 2nd. Roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. I think we will hold the pledge until we start the regular meeting after this, if that's fine with you all. So at this point, Dan, you're going to open us up on the number one topic. Yes, thank you, Mayor, Councilmembers.

3:56 As we've been working through our solid waste agreement update franchise agreement, all along we've been talking about ultimately this will result in a new franchise agreement, also the new rate structure going forward. And so given the number of issues and stuff we're looking at over the next, I'll call it 20 years, but really the next five years,

4:19 As we look at our current operations transitioning into a change in operations with the closure of the landfill and just how we handle solid waste is going to change to a degree. And so part of that was coming back and looking at the rates and some previous council discussions. And part of that was to come back in and kind of get a third party on board with the town staff and rank with Mammoth's disposal and really spend some time taking a hard look at the rate structure, what goes into it.

4:49 What's that element? And so we looked at trying to break this up a little bit into a couple different things. One on the first side of the rate setting process is just really getting a good feel for what goes into rates. I mean, anecdotally, you probably all know to a certain level, but I think there's some uniquenesses and as we compare rates across agencies to what we do here in Mammoth Lakes. Also, in terms of that, if you go out and the rates go up or they stay the same or whatever the end

5:18 Goal is, end result is, I should say. We frankly want council members to have a good sense of information, say, well, that $350 a month rate, it actually includes all of these things. This is the element that goes into these rates. I mean, end of the day, the issue is going to be, what's the rate? But I think having that information, able to walk through and explain what goes into it, why is the rate set? And then...

5:45 The term of that as we look at, as we look at rate setting, most likely coming back in, it'd be a five-year period of time looking at some type of indexed increases over time and building into different factors. There's a number of elements. I think especially in this first five-year window as we look at leveling rates or ramping up rates, we'll have that discussion as we look at investment costs and those types of issues that will come into play.

6:12 The kickoff for this process this evening was really to take a look at with F&H consultants. As they start to dive into the rates, they're getting a bunch of information from the town, a bunch of information from Mammoth Disposal. They'll start to get pulled together, but I really wanted to have this discussion with council and staff, and so we feel good about as we come out with the rate, you have a good feel of how we got there and really what's in that rate.

6:38 And it's going to be different pieces of elements and things of that nature. And then ultimately that gets allocated back into the rate classes. What are we charging residential versus commercial versus multifamily, et cetera. The different pieces that go into that, and we'll talk about it this evening. Right now one of the big questions is recycling is losing money. I'll say hand over fist, but how do we build something into where that's not a...

7:05 You know, money losing proposition from a operator side and stuff as we deal with that. So there's some uniquenesses in the market. Ultimately, hopefully that turns around and we can rebuild into those different areas. But a number of pieces like that that I think are going to be critical as we look at our rate structure. I know still in talking to people anecdotally, it's recycling pays for itself because obviously every time I buy a

7:31 Limited Reuse Bottle. I actually fill these up and use them again at times. You know, I'm paying for that. So what do you mean recycling costs money to do? So a lot of issues that way as we walk through this, I think having a good understanding of that will help down the road. And as we explain it, as people ask you, it's not just here's the rate, take it or leave it. It's going to be, well, you understand this rate incorporates all these types of services.

7:57 I think that will be an important element to be able to speak to and understand. So with that, we have a PowerPoint. We'll walk through. It would be a good Q&A process. Marva from F&H is here to walk through that. So I'm going to hand it over to her, and she'll begin to walk through it, and I'll encourage you. If something's popping up, there's a question, if it doesn't make sense, or you need a different clarification, please ask or make sure you take a note so we remember to cover.

8:25 Your questions and comments as we need to through the process. There's a fairly broad and detailed level back and forth of issues to get our arms around for solid waste rates. Great. Thank you, Dan. Thank you. Good afternoon, I guess, Mayor and Council. Marva Sheehan, HF&H. A little bit of my background. I'm 27 years in the industry. I'm 13 as a controller for BFI Allied Waste.

8:53 Garbage companies, and then the last 14 as a consultant in the solid waste. I'm a CPA by training, and so numbers have been kind of where I've dealt with in that, and so, and rate setting. So tonight, and if you have questions, please feel free to just ask me. We can address them as you go. Not a problem. So, we're going to talk a bit. The one thing that is for sure, you guys are unique.

9:21 And then as Dan was referring to kind of the integrated services, it's not just a garbage can or it's not just garbage that is part of the services that Mammoth Disposal and others are doing for you. And then I'm going to talk just about some basic rate setting methodology, you know, of different ways of kind of looking at it, but just kind of give you some background of what we'll look at as we're setting the rates. And then we get in with questions. But again, if something comes up,

9:50 Feel free to ask me as we go. So yes, you are unique. This is not you. This is what any major urban area, they have the three carts, trucks go down, clip, clip, clip. No. This is you. So you've got terrain issues, as you know, weather issues, animal issues.

10:20 The part that most agencies have to deal with, you don't have those, you have your own unique ones, which presents its own challenges and own unique cost and cost structure to relate to that. So as a result of all that, again, one of your uniquenesses is you do have a significant self-haul activity of people that just take their garbage and trash to the transfer station, which is a very unique

10:51 And all of the agencies, and I've worked with over 100 different agencies, you are the first ones that I would say that such a significant amount of self-haul is taken to a transfer station. So as we talk about why it's not just garbage, I think for so long we've always just talked about our garbage rates, pick up the garbage. Well, legislation and just part of

11:20 Trying to address global warming and climate change, we are working with now that we're trying to keep materials out of the landfills. We want landfills to last longer. In your case, yours is ending. But we don't want to just arbitrarily fill them up. And working with just trying to limit.

11:41 The amount of different types of materials from a greenhouse gas effect. You have the recycling mandates with AB 939 and 341, and those are applicable to the town and to the businesses within the town. And so that's something that through your contract and with Mammoth Disposal on making sure everybody is on board with that. So while there might be a rate for a certain size garbage container, there is also

12:10 These additional costs with the recycling. And then 1383, which the regs just came out again today, draft regs. As a town right now, you're currently, we think you're going to be exempt from having to abide by keeping all the organics out.

12:32 It's really hard to say, and especially down the road after the five years on what's going to happen. So that's something that we're going to have to keep out in the discussion area, but down the road. Sorry, real quick. Our exemption for 1383 is due to? Population size. Population size. It's not rural or location. There's combinations of elevation, rural.

12:59 And size. And right now you're check, check, and check. But it's still unclear depending on if the state meets its diversion goals. If they don't, then basically they have wording that says they could come back. So that's really what could address it. So now again, it's more than just garbage. And while you don't have necessarily the three carts, I think this is something that we try to

13:28 Communicate to your community that it is more, that you have the ability to have more services than just your garbage, that there is the recycling. And with the recycling, there's a separate truck, separate driver, you know, to the point of there's a

13:48 The public tends to think that there's all kinds of money because you can take your aluminum can or used to take your aluminum can and get your money for it. You can get your CRV from your plastic bottles. Not thinking about there's the whole collection cost. There's the processing cost of that material, the bailing, the sorting, the bailing, and the shipping off to the end markets. And then

14:18 There's also, there was the era where, and I have the example, where mixed paper, which is the majority of recyclables collected, or 35% of it, you know, in 2017 or 2016, they were getting $100 a ton. Now, you're lucky to get 10, and back a year ago, we were paying up to $20 to $30 a ton to have them take it. And as China, and I've

14:48 The National Sword, which I'm not sure if you're how familiar you are with that, but in March of 18, they said, we don't want your garbage anymore. And so they reduced the contamination levels to 0.5%, which is very small. And so as a result, the materials going to other Asian markets and back to kind of your econ 101, we have all the material that was going to China.

15:17 is now going to Vietnam, Indonesia, India, but there's a significant supply that is reducing the price down. And so as a result, mixed paper, cardboard, which is the bulk of those materials, the price that they're getting has plummeted. The organics, which, you know, the whole processing, again, if yours is in a little different situation, but

15:46 Looking forward and as far as what you're going to do with your organics and as far as composting and what needs to happen there. Again, there's a collection and there's a processing cost. I think, again, there's the three material types and getting your community aware that that's out there and that that is the materials that we need to be diverting from the landfills. So right now,

16:16 Kind of how it's done, which as I said, is you are unique. You do have the limited curbside. There are some that do get it for solid waste and recyclables on the residential side. Commercial collection for your multifamily, four units and above, your commercial businesses, and those will get your solid waste and recycling have the ability to.

16:41 Receive that service. Roll off for construction and demolition. And then the transfer station for the drop off. All of that is your kind of solid waste collection system, which has, again, all these different components, which are what we will look at as we're setting the rates for the in the future. So as we talk about just kind of the basic rate setting methodology,

17:14 The first thing and what we'll be looking at is determining, we kind of have the short-term cost, what are the current collection costs, what are your transfer transport costs, the processing disposal, we're going to look at all of those costs, there's additional program costs, you have staff costs, some town related because you have town staff that are working on

17:40 Doing AB 939 reports and a lot of different requirements, as well as other solid waste diversion costs. So we'll look at kind of those short-term current costs, and we'll get those from Mammoth Disposal. We'll coordinate with the town on their costs. So we'll look at the whole system of the current costs. And then we'll also look at the long-term costs.

18:08 When you can no longer direct haul to the landfill, there's going to need to be a transfer component. So we're going to need to be looking long term as well on how the material is going to be taken to the landfill and you'll look at that transfer transport cost as well as the tip fee cost at the landfill, etc. And then...

18:32 We'll look at just any kind of legislative requirements, anything that's coming out of, that's coming down the road, either through 341 completing that or looking at any potential issues with 1383 or 1826, as well as looking at the new transfer station and how is that going to all

18:57 So we're going to be requesting those costs and Mammoth Disposal will be providing those costs by the service sector. So by your residential commercial, we'll get the collection costs by not only by material type. So we'll look and see what it costs for the solid waste. We'll look and see what it's costing either

19:30 We'll kind of recycling, we'll kind of evaluate how we're going to cost that part and any of the other material types that we're processing. We'll look at the transfer station both from the drop-off perspective as well as the transport transport activities and figuring how that's going to fit into the transfer station rate versus the collection rates. All of that is going to have to be evaluated very carefully and in tandem with working with Mammoth Disposal.

19:58 And then looking at your disposal and processing costs and looking at the recyclables. Again, right now, most contracts that we're looking at are where they used to get money from recyclables are now paying. And we're seeing anywhere, and this is Bay Area pricing, so qualify at that, but we're looking at it's

20:23 Probably $100 to $175 a ton is what we're seeing people have to pay to process that material, which is impacting rates right now. They have a number of special rate requests being looked at. So we'll get those projections, and we'll go through and make sure that the projections that Mammoth has put together, that those kind of internally all mathematically works, logically all fits together.

20:53 We'll compare it to kind of historical costs, look and see, does that just make sense? We'll look at industry benchmarks for similar, and we'll have to take, we've done some work up in Truckee, but again, that's a little different, but we'll come up with what is reasonable to do the comparisons. And then where we...

21:17 We'll need to if there's any adjustments which we'll work through with Mammoth Disposal and come up with those costs and then look at any significant variances at that point. Once we determine and depending on the compensation section, if you have a lot of contracts have what we refer to as operating ratios and it's while I say a lot of people

21:49 Perceive that as a guaranteed profit. That's not the case. We establish why the operating ratio is, and it's industry-wide, kind of 85 to 95. In my example, I use 95. I would say usually it's more in the upper 80s to 90. But we calculate that up to the cost.

22:16 So what we would look

22:46 And come up with, again, based on how your methodology is in the new agreement, we'll calculate what that compensation is. Once we're there, we're going to look at your current revenue sources. So we'll look at your current subscription levels. We'll look at the revenue you generated at the transfer station. We'll look at all the different sources of revenue that you currently have and compare that revenue to what we need as far as the compensation side. And big picture,

23:16 We'll look at what the rate adjustment needs to be. As we're looking at it, and we're looking at it by the service sector, it might be that the commercial rates are fine, or it might be that the residential rates are fine. You know, those are all that we'll look at kind of at the same time to determine what the right direction needs to go. And then, which kind of ties into the rate structure, so you can be

23:49 On how you establish that rate and what pieces need to go into it. For residential, you know, is it going to be, you know, it's going to usually you do one rate for residential for all services, which includes the recycling and diversion or green waste drop off. So we'll have kind of that integrated rate, but it's covering a multiple of material types.

24:19 Commercial, we'll look at it, again, by line of business or by the material collected, and we'll see what the rates need to be at that point, and then roll off by the material collected and the size container, depending on the box that is rented. And then we'll look at fixed costs, and those fixed costs, a lot of times the program costs would be more by

24:48 We'll allocate those in some other fashion that meets where the services are being done. So all of the fixed costs will get looked at at the same time. And again, we're looking at the actual costs so that we can get the rates to generate the revenue. So as we come up, there's a lot of different ways.

25:19 Once we come up with what those costs are, a lot of different ways of how to get to where we need to get to. We're looking at a five-year period. The examples, there are some that if it's a significant rate adjustment that want to do kind of the band-aid approach of let's just do it and then do just a CPI for the next four years, we can look at it where

25:46 We can take where we need to be in the five years and do a kind of flat across combinations thereof. There's a lot of different ways we can look at how we need to get there. We just want to have a plan to get to where we need to be at the end of the five-year period. And that's a lot of talking, but I'll be free to answer any kind of questions. Questions, John? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. A couple questions just to get oriented.

26:21 I think we're all interested in the uniqueness of who we are in our situation here. Can you speak a little bit about your firm and your experience working in rural environments and in unique environments? So we did work up with the town of Truckee, which had its own unique situations as well. We've also done

26:50 We've done work in Ridgecrest, so in areas that are kind of remote, which have their own situations. We've done significant work in the Central Valley, so in a more rural in the sense of not the traditional or not the real urban environment, so dealing with the issues of

27:18 Significant distances between homes and things like that from that side. And then we've done a number of different studies. I did the procurement workup with the Town of Paradise and looking at their unique situations as well. Was that post-fire? That was pre-fire. Pre-fire, okay. But worked with the hauler and, well, went through a procurement, worked through the selection of the hauler, and there was also some county pockets that we had to work.

27:45 Okay, Mr. Mayor, just a couple ideas to throw out on the table. I'm sure folks have some other things to think about. The first thing is that part of our uniqueness, and I talked with Dan about this a little bit, is starting to get, for lack of a better term, getting our hands around scope. You know, what is the scope of the project here? Our base population is about 8,000. We are a...

28:12 Recreation and tourism destinations. We have enormous swells of population. So we may go from 8,000 people to 40,000, 50,000 people. I think that's a factor that I think we'd want to understand how that gets incorporated into this. 75% of the land mass of our incorporated areas is federal public lands. So I think I would like to understand how we would anticipate, you know, those.

28:38 Opportunities or more likely constraints come into that. I think we all have an interest in making sure that we're not just picking up our own trash, but we're servicing the visitor population, which pays our bills, and making sure that they have a good experience when they're here.

28:53 And I'm also interested in the long-term volatile policy environment that we're trying to operate in. You alluded to that a little bit with the situation with China, but I think that these, I think it would be very important for us to be anticipating that there are going to be some things coming down the road. You know, when you have the President of the United States going after the policy, a number of different policies of the state in which we're incorporated, that can inject a whole

29:21 Variety of different volatile things into this that I think we would want to make sure we're anticipating those kinds of risks and that we're set up not to get caught flat-footed by that. And I guess the final thing would be if you have any information or expertise that can help us with

29:41 The unique opportunities we might have. So if we're small, rural, high altitude, are there grants, are there financing resources out of the state that can help us with things like composting? We had a grant from the Forest Service to do a wood utilization program that unfortunately didn't seem to go as far as we'd like. But what things can your firm bring to us to help maybe round out some of the opportunities we might have that might factor into the rate structure that we can work with our...

30:10 With our franchisees and our contractor kind of round this out to get to where we want to be. Absolutely. And that's one of the things we're working right now with Cal Recycle. We have this project that we're working directly with Cal Recycle on this 1383. But as a result, we're staying really in the loop of what's happening in Sacramento and Cal Recycle, which has a lot of funding available. So I think those are things that we could look at besides the kind of

30:40 The off-the-wall type. We're always looking for opportunities to connect ourselves to the state. We've done a lot of work, for example, with our general plan and our housing elements and things like that. We're actually head of most jurisdictions in the state that way, and we would love to hear about pilot projects, pilot opportunities, things like that. We would really like to be more connected to the state and the resources that the state has, especially when dealing with their mandates and the things that they want us to do. That's what I have.

31:12 Kirk, anything for me? Yeah, I'm a treasurer of a homeowner's association and the question that I get most is, okay, what's it going to cost for a three-yard bin? I mean, just the practical questions of, okay, do we have to increase our HOA fees because of the new state and assembly bills?

31:39 And so it would be really helpful to be able to get some sort of projections that go out five years so that you can say, okay, at the homeowners meeting, guess what? We've got four bins and we're going to have to increase it, whatever. So those financials are really important for...

32:03 You know, being able to put together budgets in the future for, I have 138 homeowners, so they're already, you know, going, okay, what are our fees going up in what areas? So they asked me that question. So it'd be really helpful. You know, this is helpful, recognizing, hey, this is coming, and guess what? We're gonna have to truck.

32:27 Truck trash. We're going to have to do this. And your rates are going to change and your HOA fees are going to change. And if we do an extra pickup or two during Christmas and holidays and weekends and everything else, which we do, then you can expect this. Absolutely. Kind of a couple of generic questions I have. So where in the past the operators were able to

32:57 Increased revenue by taking in recyclables, recycle them. So that is, what you're saying is that is no longer a source of revenue whatsoever. Either mixed paper or plastic or all the other things we so faithfully recycle is no longer a source of revenue. The revenue, it's pretty much, I would say, system-wide. By the time you process the material,

33:28 It's a net cost now. It costs us to do the right thing. And I think, you know, to a degree, it's always cost money to do the processing. We just kind of shouted over and said no. And I mean, back in the early 90s, again, as a controller at that time, I paid $32 a ton to get rid of mixed paper then. And then we kind of

33:57 You know, the boom in China and as their economy and they needed all of our material and that all, you know, made sense. And we did our, as soon as it got on the boat to China, we pat ourselves on the back and said, great recycling. And then basically we were sending garbage over there. And I, just two weeks ago, I'll go back from two and a half weeks in China on a personal part and they are recycling like crazy.

34:27 They're not needing our material. And their economy is such that they're generating their own cardboard and you see it. So we're in a different world now. I mean, this is a global economy. And right now, what's going to be happening, you know, we're hearing about some plants in the U.S. as far as for paper processing and mixed paper processing. Mixed paper is our biggest.

34:54 One that we're trying to figure out what to do with. The challenge we have is, and everything I hear, is we won't end up with a paper processing plant in California. The regs and permits and all of that, it will be very, very difficult for that to happen. So we're still going to be transporting it somewhere. There's several that are going up in the Midwest and several on the East Coast.

35:20 West Coast is still trying to figure it out. So those are recycled mills that are going to actually produce like real stock? Yeah, there's one in Ohio that's going back to the craft bags type they're using. And so what we're hoping is the entrepreneurial spirit in some way will figure out something on what we need to do with it. But I'm hearing a lot, and I mentioned a bit with Mayor beforehand, is

35:48 We've got to look at our packaging, and we've got to look at what are we doing, and I'm assuming you guys get Amazon here like every place else, and that's creating a whole other level of cardboard and packaging.

36:05 What are we going to be doing about that? That's probably what more of a legislative fix upon the manufacturers who continue to- And doing more producer responsibility on the takebacks and doing that. And there's a number of places that are starting that. And I think that's going to be the answer, I think, is we've got to stop it sooner before it gets to-

36:32 In the recycling cart or container. So that brings us to, in the U.S., kind of the long haul options. It's not going to be California because we won't even site a new solid waste. Probably not. So we're going to have to take it to other places that don't seem to object, like California does, to dumping all of this stuff there. So what states are sort of ground zero for accepting other states?

36:59 You know, we haven't really, it has not, because right now, because there's still some markets in Southeast Asia, and there's some minimal kind of going into Mexico, we haven't, you know, I'm not sure where that's going to come in. I think, you know, we're still able to move the material. So here, where we are right here, Nevada.

37:25 Yeah, probably. Would probably be the direction that would happen there. I think the, you know, what we're seeing a lot is the public education on the clean and dry and making sure that the materials that we are collecting. And, you know, we went through the period of just, you know, if in doubt, throw out the recycle bin because we want to recycle, we want to recycle. And that half-empty yogurt container.

37:55 Got all over the nice white mixed paper and now neither one is of any value. So there's a change and that's part of that public education and part of the programs that the town's going to need is educating. And you have a challenge because you have this transient population. But what I would hope is, I'm assuming a lot are coming from...

38:21 The LA area who are going through the same issues and are being told the same thing there. Now whether they remember it when they come here, I don't know. So you'll be factoring all this in then the rate setting is the potential for this large quantity of hauling, potentially no recycling that's worthy of anything that's all going to end up in a landfill in Nevada. Well, you know, that's the things that will work with, you know, your

38:50 The contractor with Mammoth, what's really the plan? I mean, part of the contract is there to be out in public ed and help doing all of that and doing the collection. So working together and saying, you know, and Waste Connections has operations all over. What are they doing in other places? You know, we'll explore all that we can and all the different options that are available.

39:17 When it comes, you know, if when you ever get to the organic side, you know, that's the issue. There is capacity. We don't have enough in the state of California enough places to take the organics for processing. So that in itself is going to be an issue over the next five to ten years. Okay, thank you. I have a question. So AB 939, that's already gone through.

39:46 Yes, AB 939 was back in the late 80s, and that was the first really recycling mandate that came into being, and that was saying that we were going to have 50, each agency had to have 50% by 2000, but there's still ongoing requirements with AB 939, and that focused on

40:15 That was at the agency level and mandates required and the town does reporting, annual reporting on how you're doing on your diversion numbers. Okay, you know, because I'm looking back in July at the Solid Waste Franchise Agreement Workshop and it's just, there was, it was the proposed AB 939C.

40:42 So that's not the same as the AB 939 recycling mandates? It's the same? It is. It's a fee to help offset the cost of complying with the mandate. Oh. So the proposed part was it's a proposed fee, not a proposed law. Oh, okay. Okay. Copy that. And then, oh, and another thing came up with it back in July was any parcel containing one or more units.

41:09 Is required to pay for service. But this is saying, does that still hold true today? Any parcel containing one or more units? Okay. But then they would go under residential rather than commercial. Okay. I'm clear. Thank you. So I have a couple. Going back to our uniqueness, I have had arguments with Dan and others on this.

41:47 Because of what I perceive as going to be the future mandates coming out for diversion rates, which I expect to go through the roof here in California, even though we have no solution in where to take it. As you're looking at the rate structure, are you also looking and working with them in terms of what type of pickup service, because that's going to make a huge difference. You alluded to the three different, you know, a green and a...

42:13 Plastic and can and I don't know anybody that can have that in Mammoth. So then the idea of a dirty Murph versus a clean Murph and the price structure I'm assuming would be hugely different for each. Out of the pricing process might we also get an idea of what will work here and then what that's going to cost. Kirk's homeowners aren't going to want three dumpsters every place they currently have a dumpster.

42:42 There's not room for it. It messes with snow storage, with parking, with, you know, it's, to me, it's the biggest conundrum. Eventually, how much are we going to subsidize? Because as the price goes up, people start dumping in the forest instead of throwing it in the trash cans. And we can't afford to have that happen because we are a resort economy. And I worry about that because I saw it happen previously here. So as we're looking at the prices,

43:10 Are we ferreting out just what is going to be required in order to live up to those state mandates and then pricing that out? Well, we will look at kind of what's required by the state mandates. Again, I mean, you're absolutely right. The uniqueness and the fact that, no, you don't. I mean, that was why, no, you don't have three carts. You don't have room for three carts. We get it. But at the same time,

43:40 The challenges of the MRFs and dirty MRFs, especially now with the requirement to have your recyclables being so clean makes it difficult to work through that. But these are things that we'll explore and figure out what's the best option. Obviously, pricing and costing is always important.

44:09 If rates get too high, then that's when illegal dumping and other things happen. So we understand that. And in the end, we need to generate sufficient revenue to pay for the services that are required and needed to provide for the town to meet your own desire for the

44:37 Clean, you know, how you want to be known as a community. I can expand on that a little bit as well, Mayor Sauser. So we've been working closely with Mammoth Disposal on the franchise agreement, and that is really the document that's going to outline and specify the types of service that they will be providing.

44:56 And obviously they've been working in our community for many years and they're very familiar with the challenges and uniquenesses here and they know what's going to work and what's not going to work. And so with all of that in mind, that is how the agreement is being drafted. And then the services that are required by the agreement are the things that Marva and her team will be incorporating into their analysis. Mr. Mayor, I've got a couple quick follow-up questions. John? So can you provide us,

45:27 I'm looking at you, Marv, but also our attorney here. One of the things we pride ourselves on being a mountain community is the resourcefulness and the creativity of the folks that live here, of all of us, because we are confronted with interesting, daunting challenges all the time, and we like to put our creativity and mindset to work to come up with solutions to these things. So is it possible for you or Andy to advise us on

45:56 I don't want to say work around state issues, but things like plastic bag bans or single-use recyclable, non-recyclable plastics. We have an economic interest in branding ourselves and being kind of a green destination. That's something that we may have an interest in down the road. But we find ourselves being hamstrung by edicts coming out of Sacramento that prevent us from doing that. And I'm wondering if between you and Andy,

46:24 If we can spend, you know, appropriately a little time brainstorming, how do we start finding things, solutions, so we can advise our visitors and guests, hey, don't come up here with, you know, you know, 24 packs of water bottles because that doesn't really fit in with our ethic. We have challenges doing stuff with that waste, but if there are things that we can do legislatively to start dealing with that, and then tied to that also is,

46:52 Is the value of the processing, of the pricing, is it related to the tonnage? In other words, if we're putting more stuff through our stream, does that of financial interest to the hauler, to the rates? So that if we're pursuing, say, policies that say, let's keep as much out of the stream as we possibly can,

47:17 Because there's too much packaging, there's too much crap just flying around all over the place, and we think it's in everybody's interest not to get it in the stream itself. Do those, would those policy objectives have anything, is that of a relationship with pricing? Is that of a relationship with the franchise agreement? And it would be interesting to understand how all that works. Yeah, I'll talk to the latter part, and you talk to the first part. Yes, I mean, one of the things as we look at

47:46 Projections. You know, there's, if we're looking at any, if you're doing any town ordinances, it's going to change what happens to materials. For example, there are a number of, I think Santa Cruz is now, you can't have the plastic bottles, kind of like at the airport in San Francisco. But those are things that we would.

48:12 We would look at. The disposal and processing that is all tonnage-based will have, you know, you have, when I'm looking at the cost, I have the collection cost, so I've got my labor cost, my truck cost, got all of that. One of the elements is the disposal slash processing cost, and that's a per ton calculation. So if my trash

48:36 Pens go down, then that would be reflected as we're looking at the cost. I'm just concerned about incentives. I mean, how are we incentivizing the pricing? If the right thing to do is to keep stuff out of the flow, I would want to be cautious about setting up a pricing scheme that's going to disincentivize doing something like that, as opposed to incentivizing, oh, put more stuff in the stream because everybody makes more money. So that's something I'd like to understand at some point.

49:03 Well, I mean, part of the franchise agreement is going to be to require, you know, disposal to do their absolute best they can to segregate stuff. And we'll have, you know, I think we already have an ordinance that requires people to segregate and we can do more outreach to explain to people what is and is not proper to put in the recycling and what has to go into the general stream. So we have...

49:23 Town requirements, and we can do outreach, and then we've got management disposal doing their part to do their very best to process it. With respect to your question about creativity, I mean, you know, I live in a mountain community, too, and we have come up with some creative ideas, and I'll be happy to work with HF&H to come up with more creative ideas. There are just some areas, though, where various interest groups, let's say, have gotten to the state and gotten the state to say that only the state can make rules and localities can't.

49:51 So as with bag bans. And so we're aware of what those are, where we can and can't do things, but where it's appropriate to have local rules, where it's helpful and where we're allowed to, I mean, yeah, we'll come up with creative ideas. Yeah, and there's something that we can, that we take a little time when we're doing this process to start pushing that a little bit to figure out what we can do. I'm just thinking like the three, the three bin thing in front of the house. What if you had a dumpster that had within the dumpster.

50:17 You had three things in the dumpster, but the truck could pick up the entire dumpster and dump all three things at once. Integrated truck. Yeah, something. I mean, again, creative thinking is a lot of fun. I know you enjoy it, but these are the kinds of things that we would, I don't know, want to kick the tires on and see what we can do to come up with some ideas. So I can tell you that at my day job, there are three full-time employees that do nothing but solid waste and recycling for the town.

50:47 And I'm absolutely going to plunder all of their best ideas. I'm going to be talking to them and saying, what are the cool things that we're doing? And then once I've plundered all their ideas, I'll share them with town staff. And that way you'll get the advantage of three FTEs worth of creativity that you're not paying for. We have a major ski resort here in town that is the pride of the community and pride of skiing in the Western United States. Their record environmentally and their leadership in these programs leaves a little bit to be desired.

51:16 And I think that that might be an opportunity for us to start working with them or at least using the power that we have legislatively to say, look, we need you guys to start doing something in terms of your stream. They're talking about some very ambitious ideas about how many skier visits they want to get up there. They're operating under a federal permit, which may have implications through the National Environmental Policy Act in terms of what kinds of effects that's having on...

51:42 The surrounding landscape. And I think we want to get properly teed up and aligned and maybe have those discussions with the significant ski resort we have here in the town. So on that particular issue, the mountain counts as what's known in state law as a large venue because they have more than 2,000 people a day. And I don't think that the current franchise agreement has properly classified them as such or hasn't called them out that way. But state law has requirements, and I became aware of this.

52:10 15 years ago, working on an agreement in Fontana, has requirements for large venues. It's already in the law. Interesting. And so I've already put into the draft, and I'm talking to Waste Connections as an attorney tomorrow about how we put stuff in the draft saying we need to get the mountain to comply. We're going to get a man at disposal to help us get in the mountain to comply. But, you know, we're already thinking about that kind of thing and how to address it. Because that large venue is a federal permittee.

52:37 So that's a question we brought before about federal stuff. Also, they are owned now by one of the greenest ski corporations in the world, or there's an equity part of the Aspen Skiing Corporation. This takes some very interesting leadership roles for that mountain back in Colorado. And we would love to take them as a model, look at the best practices they put in place. And if we have to do things legislative here to hold that large venue, is that what you're calling it? That large venue.

53:06 Consistent with the environmental interest of the town, the environmental policy of the state of California, we want to make sure that how we're putting this together, that that's all going to work. At least this one, Councilmember, is interested in that kind of stuff. Yeah. Okay, thank you. Going to the slide before this one, the rate adjustment options, there's A, B, and then C, which is a combination of option A and B.

53:35 How does that work out? That's really, I mean, basically, that's saying, okay, maybe we want to do, you know, instead of everything in year one, maybe it's spread over, it's higher year one, two, and then comes down in three, four, five. I mean, it really is just figuring out what do you think would be the best in order to

54:00 Get again to where we want to in the end. The challenge you have when you delay and you don't do instead of a 20% and then now you're down to a 4%, it ends up in the end because you've got to make up the dollars if you don't do it all in the first piece because once you've built it, then your 5% is taking up a bigger number.

54:31 It really depends on what you're going to want to do. And you really probably don't know until you see what those percentages or what the dollars are looking at. The one thing that I will say that we're trying, and I would say I probably didn't do as good a slide on this one, we're finding that it's much better to present dollars per month as your increase as opposed to percentages. And if I'm saying you're getting at $3 a month,

55:01 Increase. I mean, that might be 10 or 15 percent, which sounds awful. Three dollars is less than a Starbucks. I mean, it's like, you know, it's something that is a little easier for people to get behind or to understand as opposed to getting hung up on a, you know, 20 percent increase or something to that effect. So we'll, you know, we'll work with staff and we'll figure out kind of the best way and present with options.

55:30 I mean, I think the example would be is like on the front end, we're going to do capital investment. And so how much of that do we recover quickly versus spreading it out over time from that? And the other element to that is which rate payers end up paying that. The more you charge on the front end, the people here today pay. To the extent you extend it out, the rate might be higher, but then people five years, 10 years out are paying those rates. So there's a number of things you look at for some policy choices of high end, low end.

56:00 Move that out. The other element for us, and it would be a little different of a curve here most likely, is current rates and then the closure of the landfill and rates go up or change. How do we level that out if we want to or do we worry about it and try to get the rates? Well, we think they're going to be here, so let's level them now and hopefully does that limit rate increases down the road. We've also, the discussion we've been having looking at the franchise agreement has taken our current rate structure.

56:27 We'll get some tweaking to it, I'm sure, based on the information here. But is there a way to keep it pretty close to where we're at and be able to fund these things? And then it might be where it is. It's five years out, seven years out. Yeah, that's where we're going to have to take a hit in terms of some of the infrastructure costs or investment costs. All that stuff is kind of unknown right now as we're trying to work through that. I think the question, the policy question, I mean...

56:51 I like that you ripped a band-aid off today. Here's your 30% increase, and then it's a couple percentage points going forward. Or is it a 5, 6, 7% increase maybe over the next 10 years? I mean, we'll work through those issues, but I mean, there's options there to look at. And again, prior life, if you will, one of those questions was, I want to pay as less as I have to now, because if I'm not here 10 years from now, then I'm not going to be paying it anyway, so just keep my rates low.

57:16 Or I'm going to have a larger customer base so maybe the rates won't go up as much. Or there's all these other elements you want to look at and how do we impact our current rate paying base versus, may not change a lot, Frank, I don't say it's a huge changes over the next several years for us just we don't have that type of population growth projections.

57:36 And then the five years works with the franchise agreement that will be based on a five-year and then another five-year. Well, yeah, it's a franchise looking at 20. The five-year is if you do a CPI-based, and you can correct them wrong, under Prop 218, because you're not setting a hard rate. I think five is the longest you can go out. Oh, okay. Under the legal, is that? Yep. Okay. Yeah, that's why the five-year window is the maximum. You can do a shorter term.

58:05 Go. Question. If you can crystal ball this, if you will. Looking at what is coming down from the state and legislature, sort of CalRecycle and the legislative arm together, how do you position an entity like ours into trying to insulate against those mandates that may be coming down? You know, if you can kind of see, okay, we think the next thing they're going to do is maybe go after manufacturers of packaging.

58:35 You know, you got to cut that down. They're going to go after people who put a lot of packaging and things and you go buy it at Costco and you have this much packaging and that much product. You know, where do you see that coming down in the next three, four years? And then how do you position a franchise agreement to kind of buffer that? I think, you know, I think it's going to be really tough. I think one of the things that as we look through the numbers and kind of see where things are going out, there are

59:06 There are things that we could look at, you could, and I'd have to check to see if you can't, as far as a rate stabilization fund or something that you can set up, and I'm not sure if the town could do that, but sometimes I've had age where we'll, if we think there's something down the road, it's not necessarily, we don't want it into the rates and, you know, as much as we like Mammoth Disposal, we don't want them just to be able to keep that money, but to have, to accumulate some

59:37 Some funds to help mitigate that. Now, bear in mind that it has twofold. One is it creates a pool and maybe it does a public ed campaign, whatever this new mandate that comes in, that you could do a campaign for it. If you use it to truly offset the rates, it's a one-time hit to help do that, and you have to then make it up. However,

1:00:06 The benefit is you've already built your, you've already got your rates up and then you could stop contributing to that and you will be able to cover whatever the new costs that are coming in. So it just gives you some flexibility in the future. And where would those funds typically be held? I mean, would the town hold those funds? Usually in the town, yeah. Entities, you've worked with entities that have chosen to do that? And with respect to the franchise agreement, I mean, every...

1:00:33 The competently written Solid Ways Franchise Agreement has a clause that says that the jurisdiction can require the hauler to provide new programs and services in response to state mandates. And that's just in every one. And the haulers are always happy to do that as long as they get paid their cost of implementing the new programs. So I've never really had a problem getting haulers to do new stuff. Sometimes there's a little bit of back and forth about, okay, how much does it actually cost?

1:00:57 To provide the service. Right. And then the impact suddenly or gradually on a rate payer. Right. And then if you, as Marva said, if you have a rate civilization fund that the town is holding, you can sort of blend it in a little bit. And those are things, those, you know, we talked about being creative. I mean, that's, we're going to be trying to look at as many different options that are there. And for us, I think the biggest issue we're looking at is kind of that, it's good and bad. I mean, I think we're trying to work in.

1:01:28 Mono County, there's basically monthly it's 1,800 tons of waste, which other places are doing that, you know, daily or weekly, you know. So when you look at our tonnage rates, let's say you go with the packaging, it changes so it reduces the amount of flow into the facilities. If it's reducing the flow of recyclables that has a different, like cardboard, for example, it changes that net loss today.

1:01:56 The challenge on the garbage side, you size up the facility, in this case, a transfer station, will be sized to handle 1,800 tons of waste. To John's question, I think, if we get credit, let's say that goes down to 1,200. That doesn't change the debt component that you have that you're recovering. It will change maybe some of the haul costs and those elements and tipping fees. But for us, when you look at, real briefly, you look at the routes and structure, you're probably not going to change that.

1:02:26 We just don't have enough elasticity in our market to say, hey, if we really did this, we could reduce two trucks and four drivers and save money. It's most likely going to be zero, frankly, change. I hate to put it. Yeah, I mean, because there's a lot of it. Again, you're back to this, and we're not unique in this sense, but just the smallness of the service footprint. It's really hard to get any dramatic changes. Now, you get some, yeah, you're going to tweak around the edges, I think.

1:02:55 But the mandated stuff, I'd be more concerned in terms of the stuff that's going to add a whole new service where you have to have another vehicle. You've got to add another driver. You've got to add another collection bin, processing, those types of things. And to the creativity side on some of that would kick around. How do we get in the front of some of that? Maybe even do stuff like on organics. Do we start stuff even though it's not mandated? Do we want to get in front of something and say, does this work for us?

1:03:22 And again, I think there's a number of pieces that way. It's going to be very creative how we work through some of the elements and pieces that way. But again, stuff we're looking at, at least seeing that the flexibility in there, it's pretty limited just given the amount of waste we generate. And even if we had a 10% reduction going to the waste stream, it's...

1:03:43 Say that might be 10%, you don't put the landfill, but you're still paying all the same people to process the other 90%. Right, but again, in terms of the other incinerary benefits. But identity, yeah, and what we are. Brands, who we are, those kinds of things, you know, things we can pursue knowing it's not going to. There's other values, social values, if you will, and marketing values and identity values that aren't tied to what you're paying out in the rate. So, yeah, I agree. Thank you. Anything else from the dais?

1:04:14 Anyone in the audience wishing to ask any questions or have any answers? Come up here, have a seat. I think all this stuff will roll into this, especially look at the programs that help us to come out, some of the changes we're going to have to do in order to process waste in a more effective manner. The other unknown question out there, the counties are going through the same process, so they're going to be looking at an RFP going out for services.

1:04:45 And whether or not there's a combination of stuff in there to help operationally, we don't know yet. We would like to think we'd be able to join forces in some areas to reduce cost. We may end up just duplicating costs end of the day based on depending how that RFP goes out, what comes in on it. Because we just don't control any of that. So that's a whole other, that's another piece of the pie. But as I mentioned, 1,800 tons a month, right?

1:05:16 About 300 of that is probably, I'll say stuff that currently Mammoth Disposal doesn't handle. Most of that's the town a little bit, county stuff. So the marginal waste in that whole area is not a lot either. I think we do about 80%, give or take, of the waste stream to the landfill. So we're the primary producer there. So even with the whole county and you're not looking at huge operational shifts or changes.

1:05:50 Okay. Well, with nothing else, then, I will call an end to this workshop, and we will gavel us back at 6 p.m. Gavel us back to order. John, where am I out of here? John, if you'll reason me pledge, please. Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God.

1:09:35 Indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you for that, John. And we have no additions to the agenda that I know of. That is correct, Mr. Mayor. Okay. Public comments. Now is the time any member of the public wishing to speak on something that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. Please state your name and all of that for the record. You might be recognizing me by now, but I am Christy Williams. I work for MLTPA. I'm the project manager for the sustainable...

1:10:07 Recreation and Tourism Initiative, which is the Sierra Nevada Conservancy funded grant that the town accepted back in July. I'm here just to give you all a quick update. We had our first recreation stakeholder meeting down in Bishop last Thursday and looking at my phone because I jotted a couple notes, we had 60 plus people. On our flyer we actually say

1:10:33 All are welcome from Lone Pine to Markleyville. And we had people from Lone Pine to Markleyville attend, so that was very exciting. And if you all, I think most of you have subscribed already to our newsletter, well, or our email blasts, and I'll be sending one out tomorrow probably that gives links to photos, presentation slides, and that kind of thing if you want to get up to speed on the content of the meeting. But overall went very well, people.

1:11:01 Seem to be very collaborative, and we're happy to be meeting. Also, I want to remind you our next meeting is October 17th, down in Bishop again. It's part two of the kickoff, so it's definitely worth your time to come. And then we also, after we wrap that meeting, we're going to go into a series of regionally, well, smaller area-based meetings, and we will come to Mammoth for at least one of them. So I'll make sure to come back and let you all know when that Mammoth meeting will be.

1:11:30 Did anybody need these? I gave them out last week. Or not last week, last meeting. Anyone? Okay, thanks. Good evening, Mr. Mayor. Council John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I apologize I wasn't here last session to talk about air service, but I had issues with air service. We were in Chicago meeting with United Airlines, and that was during the wind event that week, and made it a little bit more challenging to get home.

1:11:59 Just wanted to give you an update not only about what's coming up for this winter for service but also where we are moving forward. We've had a number of meetings between myself and the town manager in Inyo and Mono County as well as a meeting last week with the FAA that was well attended by town staff as well. Start off with this winter. So we are basically running the same service that we did last year. So starting December 19th, we'll have seven-day-a-week service for San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Denver.

1:12:28 With United Airlines, United Airlines is flying straight through the fall here. You may recall in the past, we've never really had full 365 day a year service. This year, we decided to implement seven day a week service right through the fall. Typically, we would drop down to Thursday, Friday, Sunday, Monday service. When we switched from Alaska to United, we decided that it was time for us to be able to provide that connectivity and that consistency with the service.

1:12:57 We'll also be going back to work with JetSuiteX. JetSuiteX will be flying the four days a week, Thursday, Friday, Sunday, Monday, starting December 19th, and they will be flying out of Burbank and Orange County. We're looking at kind of the first couple weeks of April to be running most of the service because of the Easter coming on April 12 or 13th. In the meetings last week, we had some great conversations. The first meeting...

1:13:22 was regarding subsidies and how those were going to be taken care of. As you know, Mammoth Lakes Tourism can handle just the subsidy with the TBID for those passengers coming to Mammoth Lakes as guests, not as locals. We can't support the people that are going to Mount Whitney or Death Valley or staying in Bishop or locals that are coming into town. So there is a gap that will happen there, and we've had a conversation to figure out how to fill that gap. Inyo County has presented

1:13:51 To their supervisors down there, they will need to come up with some level of funding. And then obviously Mammoth Mountain Ski Area would be the other source that we're looking at and yet to be completely finalized, but I think we're in good shape there as far as what we need to come up with. The meetings that we had with the FAA last week were very productive as well. We had the Western Regional Director for the FAA.

1:14:12 We had the director from the San Francisco ADO airport districts, which is where our airport is located. The Bishop Airport, even though it's only 30 miles down the road, is in the Los Angeles district. And we had two representatives from Los Angeles as well. And we had the environmental supervisors based out of the Bay Area as well. So very good meetings with them. It seems that Bishop is on track right now to be Part 139 certified sometime early in 2020.

1:14:41 And with the idea of potentially starting commercial service as soon as October 1st, November 1st of 2020. So a year from now, we could be looking at that commercial service and that consistency of service down there. Again, the reason we're looking at Bishop is because of the reliability. Looking at the cancellation reports year to date for the summer, this past, this summer that we're in right now, which the summer season technically, summer, spring, summer, fall technically runs through October 31st. Right now, we're at about, we're at 26 and a half cancellations.

1:15:11 Our biggest year ever for summer cancellations, 2015, was 13.5 cancellations, so we're double. Now granted, again, we've added this seven-day-a-week service in the fall, but still not what we want to be doing. You know, right now we're sitting at about, if we don't have any other cancellations, we're sitting at about 12% cancellation for the summer, which is unacceptable.

1:15:32 Lots of good things moving on there. And I think that we're, we, in the meetings with United that we had in Chicago, they are set to basically transfer service when it becomes available. Continuing the booking process that people are coming to Mammoth with the idea that the flights eventually will shift from MMH to Bishop. And we've also had the conversations with JetSuiteX and a few other carriers. There's another company called Contour. And then we also had a conversation with Taos, New Mexico. The ski area owns their own planes. They have two.

1:16:02 Thank you. Thank you. It was gas. I ran out of gas.

1:16:36 Public comments still open. Anyone else wishing to make comment? I will close public comment and move on to reports from commissions and or departments. Do we have any commissions and or departments wishing to speak? Dan, did you threaten them? Yes. We're going to move on to council presentations. First up on the hit parade, we have

1:17:10 Approved the proclamation declaring October 2019 as Domestic Violence Awareness Month in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I am going to read a few words on this. Whereas advocates and organizations work on behalf of victims every day, domestic violence shelters and services, law enforcement officials, health care providers, court systems and legal aid providers, tribal organizations and others are all an integral part.

1:17:39 And we have Matthew with us from Wild Iris.

1:18:10 Wishing to speak? Well, I just wanted to, first of all, say thank you, Mayor, and thank you, distinguished members of the Town Council. This is Domestic Violence Awareness Month, and on behalf of everyone who works at Wild Iris and other community partners that are working with domestic violence and sexual assault in our community, I just want to say it's an honor to be recognized and for the community to be aware of this initiative. Thank you.

1:18:41 With that, I would entertain a motion. Make a motion to focus. I'll second it. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Hearing none, roll call, please, sir. How are we going to do it? Council Member Hough? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Council Member White White? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salter? Yes. Mayor Salter? Yes. Passes 5-0. All right. With that, we will present. I'm not sure you describe it as hit parade. It's the best choice of words.

1:19:22 Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I miss you. Moving on to staff presentations. First up is a presentation of Police Chief's Award. Number three. Number three. Ah, Mammoth Lakes Chamber. I told you I could get through these meetings quick. Good evening, Mayor and Town Councilors.

1:20:19 Ken Bringle, Executive Director for the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce, and Colonel Shapiro, who is our Workforce Housing Coordinator. I'll let him take over this in just a moment. But as you know, we've been talking for a long time about the number one issue facing our business community is workforce housing. In fact, we got a few emails today from some...

1:20:43 Members that are struggling with losing some people that they thought they had hired because they couldn't find housing here. So we've got some things, you know, in the works that we're working on, but not one program is a panacea. And, you know, we're part of what I call a full court press, our workforce housing program with what Mammoth Lakes Housing is doing, what you guys are doing with the parcel trying to get that workforce housing.

1:21:12 It's a full court press. And so doing that, we're trying to reach out to the people that need housing, employers that need their employees to have housing, and the second homeowner. And I'll let Curtis talk about that, kind of where we're at with our deliverables, as well as where we are with the website, which was one of the first things that we wanted to get going. So let me see. I think I had our...

1:21:42 Because you can reach the website in a couple different ways, but we were going to show you through the chamber's website. Good evening, everybody. Like Ken mentioned, I'm Chris Shapiro. I'm the Workforce Housing Coordinator at the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. And I wanted to show you guys the website tonight, as well as go over the deliverables real quick before we jump into the website. I wanted to give you guys a few updates on what's going on with it.

1:22:09 So we launched the website yesterday to the public, October 1st. And as of today, or as of right now, we've had 70 people sign up for it so far. This is a mix of renters, of course, and employers, as well as a few homeowners have reached out to us. And it looks like we're going to have some places lined up in the springtime, but nothing in the immediate future. And yeah, getting to the website. So we added this link here at the top.

1:22:40 Yeah, so we are on the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce website right here, and if you want to go to the Workforce Housing website, you just click on the Workforce Housing tab right here, and it takes you to mammothworkforcehousing.org, which is also accessible, of course, just by typing in the URL. So this is the landing page, the home page. I'll kind of glance over this. So it says, join us in creating a solution to the housing crisis in Mammoth Lakes.

1:23:07 We provide homeowners and Mammoth Lakes with qualified local workforce renters through our employment verification and roommate matching program. Whether you're seeking a home, have space to offer, or an employer or property manager, we'd love to connect with you. Then it scrolls down to tell us more about who you are with a little call to action buttons for homeowners, renters, employers, and property managers. A brief little about the problem. In 2018, 59.4% of all housing units and Mammoth Lakes were categorized.

1:23:36 As seasonal, recreational, or occasional use, these units accounted for nearly 83% of the town's vacant housing units. The program, the Mammoth Lakes Workforce Housing Program is a new program developed for homeowners, second homeowners, workforce employees, and business owners. The solution, through a qualifying process, we're able to match homeowners with local workforce renters, thereby increasing the housing availability and keeping more of our workforce here long term. A learn more button that connects to the about page.

1:24:05 If you keep going down, there's brief little how it works. Number one, local workforce employees join the Mammoth Lakes Workforce Housing Program in search of housing. Number two, workforce renters are matched with one another once their employment is verified. And number three, homeowners can be confident they'll be provided with local and qualified renters for their homes. Ensure that the community in Mammoth Lakes remains the same as you've come to know and love. Be a part of the solution to the housing crisis by renting your home to a local employee today. And if you scroll down, there's just...

1:24:34 Newsletter sign up and a bit about contact information. So we then have our about page, which is essentially what I just covered, just a little bit more in depth. We also have our frequently asked questions page. So these are for all the frequently asked questions, of course, just kind of a brief overview about the program, who it's run by, what it does, what we're responsible for, and then it breaks off to little sections about homeowners.

1:25:08 Renters, employers, property management and service companies. And we have just about everything covered in there so far. Any questions so far or am I moving too fast? Good. Yes, I do have a question. I mean, I've read your presentation. Do you have the funding necessary to achieve some of this? Because one, it's established a funding mechanism to subsidize first last month rent. I mean,

1:25:37 I want this to be successful. I'm reading this and I'm saying this is good. Okay. Do you guys have the funding? That is one of the things that was on, I think, the six month or 12 month. That's one of the things when we say in progress, that's what we're working on. We're trying to figure out that was supposed to have been completed within 12 months. And so we're with...

1:26:01 Curtis has done a great job of getting up this website, getting us going. We feel like we're ahead of where we thought we'd be. Now we're starting to look at some of those things, and the funding issue is going to be a big one. And so that's kind of where we're looking. We had some suggestions about how to use maybe our foundation to help raise some dollars for it. We're in the process now, okay, where do we go to start finding that funding?

1:26:29 Yeah, I think it's a great program, and I'm going, okay, hopefully there's funding for it, so, you know, I'm just kind of opening that door and saying, this is a good thing. We accept contributions. From council? And totally tax deductible through our foundation. All right. Any of you guys got questions so far? Okay, great. So I'll just go over the homeowner page.

1:26:57 All four of these pages essentially follow the same suit. They're just questionnaires for people to fill out for us to gather their information. I won't bore you with all the different questions throughout. So for the homeowner page, there's a little rent your home, contribute to a local community while providing an employee a place to call home. Rent your home through our workforce housing program today. Then if you scroll down, you can start the survey. See if I can figure out how to.

1:27:34 So the first question is first name. I can't figure out how to get this thing to scroll. Last name. I might be able to. One second here. Sorry about that. Yeah, so it won't let me. Probably the problem is you let me pull it up, and that's the problem. Yeah, I'm not sure why it's not letting me do the last show you what it's saying here. I think the screen is just a little bit too big for the format it's on. But anyways, I can assure you the questions are there.

1:28:48 Phone number. So what was the breakdown for the people that have already filled this out? Do you have employers, renters, and homeowner figures? I don't have an exact number. It was probably maybe 5% homeowners, 80% renters, and 15% employers, I want to say. It was largely...

1:29:36 The renters. Okay, I think this thing might be a little bit frozen here now. So this is email. Has to be real email, by the way. So you can't enter fake ones. This question, even though we can't see it, basically asks what challenges have held you back from renting long term in the future.

1:30:24 What we're trying to do here is gauge what people would be interested in as far as incentives we can offer further down the line that we may not have thought of. Is your home in Mammoth Lakes a primary residence, secondary residence, I own multiple homes or others? Type of home, single family home, townhome, condo, apartment, mobile home, and et cetera, there's an entry for other. This asks you to specify your home. Let me try this on Google Chrome real quick. Yeah, it seems to be a little bit smoother on here.

1:31:49 Keep going. This is total amount of bedrooms, I believe it asks you in your house. Total amount of bathrooms. How many are you willing to rent? Is your home currently rented? Which would you be interested in renting? Vacant homes, vacant rooms, both. Which sort of lease are you interested in annually, seasonally, or other? Do you allow pets? If you click no, it just keeps going. If you click yes, it says do you require a pet deposit, which...

1:32:41 More than not times, it's going to be yes. Do you allow smoking on the premises? Is there any other information you'd like to include? And that's the end of the survey. And then it says we'll reach out to you in the future with further steps and whatnot. I apologize you couldn't see the full questions. I'm not really sure what's going on with this thing. Oh, there we go. Do you guys want me to go back up and show the question? Is that fine? Continue. Okay.

1:33:12 Yeah, that's about it for the website. All of the renter, employer, and property management page all follow the same suit. Like I said, they're just different types of questions. I'll spare you guys going through those unless you want me to go through them or... Okay. Great, yeah. So we'll move on to the deliverables. So these are the deliverables as of the executed agreement on July 1st, 2019. 1A, database for contact development within four months of executed agreement.

1:33:45 Number one is initiate and establish one database of candidates for employer-assisted housing, including second homeowners, HOAs, short-term rental properties, hotels, RVs, trailer parks, and other candidates as identified, and that is completed and ongoing as we do have a database of all these people we can reach out to, and it's going to be ongoing because we're going to keep building that. We're not going to just go off an initial list. Number two, develop partnerships with local employers, housing managers, nonprofit, and others to

1:34:14 Create integrated long-term support and funding for the employer-assisted housing program. Once again, that is completed and ongoing. B, web-based applications within six months of executed agreement. Number one, research, identify, and deploy one roommate matching app website program, including contacting with appropriate third-party vendor. That one is completed three months ahead of time. Number two, develop and deploy one housing module on the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce website

1:34:44 Tracking with appropriate third-party vendor. That one is completed. As you guys saw, it's on the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce website. Number three, identify one appropriate local partner to maintain GIS database and provide recommendations for funding if required to town and other partners. We're exploring options on that. I've talked a little bit with Nolan and who talked to him about who I should talk to as far as setting up the GIS database and how we kind of want to go about that.

1:35:14 How that would look, because I do know there's a lot of training behind that and whatnot. So we are exploring options for that one. C, subsidized services within 12 months of executed agreement. Number one, establish one employer verification program to ensure homeowners they're renting to members of local workforce. That one is completed eight months in advance. We wanted to offer that as kind of one of our first incentives to homeowners to want to make the switch that we can guarantee that the person that they're renting here is a local workforce employee.

1:35:46 Number two, establish one funding mechanism to subsidize first and last month's rent. That one is exploring options. We've had ideas and we've talked about it briefly. We haven't really set any type of thing in concrete and moved forward with it yet. Number three, establish one funding mechanism to subsidize property management services for both.

1:36:07 EAH and STR slash LTR activities, including a request for proposal to existing private sector property management services to reduce costs and encourage the transition from nightly rental short term to longer rental. That's in progress as we've been working with property management around town and we're really focused on finding any property management which holds a broker's license so they can handle the leases and the background checks and credit checks for the tenants if the homeowners choose to go that route. So that one is in progress.

1:36:38 D, investment opportunities within 12 months of executed agreement. Number one, establish one investment pool for small business owners to set up workforce housing options for local businesses, which may include joint purchase of housing units, leasing of housing units, or other options to create dedicated workforce housing. This one is under discussion. Again, we're kind of looking at different ways how we would go about this, how we would maybe set up a contract.

1:37:08 We put ongoing for this one.

1:37:39 As kind of sort of throughout this whole thing, we're going to be looking at ways to fund it, and it's going to be a bit of a process to figure that out and get that down. Number two, short-term rental STR to long-term rental LTR conversion. So under 1A, property slash candidate outreach within three months of executed agreement, using established database for contact development, establish one contact list of homeowners.

1:38:06 Association managers, owners slash managers of cleaning company and lodging establishments, owners and managers that can help identify units for lodging accommodation to transition from short-term rentals to long-term rentals. This one is completed and ongoing as we're beginning to reach out to these people now. The website's done. To the back side, number two, using established database for contact development, initiate outreach to HOA managers, lodging establishments, and short-term rental homeowners to identify units available for long-term rental.

1:38:37 Once again, that's completed and ongoing. B, subsidized services within 12 months of executed agreement, identified property management that would be willing to contract to service units identified for short-term rental to long-term rental conversion. That one is completed and ongoing. Two, establish one program to provide assurance to homeowners to move to long-term rental programs. Example, master leases, employer guarantees. This one's in progress as we've been

1:39:06 Talking with property management companies on how an employer-backed lease would work and what they think of it and how we should go about it as well as the employer guaranteed. Establish one co-op program that includes a pool of short-term rentals to be used by homeowners who convert their homes to long-term rentals. This one is under discussion as we're not too sure in the framework on how that would work. If it's...

1:39:36 Do you want to say anything about this one? Well, yeah, the reality is, it sounds great to go from, gee, we ought to do that, and then all of a sudden, if you had homeowners that said, oh, we want either our employee to move out or you need to provide us lodging for the Christmas time, the cost of that and being able to try to provide that, it may be way beyond the capabilities of what.

1:40:05 This program can provide. So there may not be because coming up with a pool of rentals that second homeowners that have turned their short term into long term, they're all going to want to probably be on some of the same days. And how do you come up with that? How do you service that? So that's why it's under discussion. We're going to talk about it, but it's maybe a difficult one to.

1:40:30 To achieve. But we, you know, it came out through the community housing action plan that we ought to look at it, and we're looking at that possibility. So if we don't think that we can actually find some way to do that, we'll come back to you guys and talk about it. And then number three, program reporting. The chamber will provide the town council an update on activities and milestones reached at least twice per fiscal year. This one will be ongoing, of course, and we assume we'll come in here every quarter or so to give you guys updates.

1:40:59 Especially sometime in the late winter, early spring to let you know how it went over the winter and what we can expect as far as housing for the spring and summertime and what we're going to do for next winter. And that's it for the deliverables. Anybody have any questions or? John? I don't have any questions. I'm just thrilled. I think we're all thrilled to see this component coming forward as part of the full court press. The Community Housing Action Plan certainly envisioned a whole variety of different

1:41:28 Responses to this challenge. And good on you. Keep going. I think one thing is that the Cabin Fever Group, which is a group we talked to in the beginning about providing some of the website services, turned out to be kind of expensive. And Curtis here and Ken with his expert programming skills. Looking at you, Ken, were able to pull together a locally produced. Thank God we hired Curtis. Yeah, well, but to pull together a locally produced web platform that's doing all this work. And so I'm enormously encouraged and looking forward to seeing where this goes.

1:41:58 No, just it was great to meet me, Chris, and hear what all you're doing. I think you're on the right path and a little bit of perseverance to this to get us where we need to be. It's like you said, another way to get to where we need to be, so thank you. Kirk, I am encouraged that we have something started and going. So kudos to the both of you. The one thing that I think was missed, attention, we keep talking about how we can

1:42:30 Yeah, so I

1:43:00 While that may be obvious to some of us, you know, because they jam a lot of people in these Airbnbs and more times than not the places get wrecked, I want to be very careful with how we market that and approach that because I don't want to give off the assumption that we're guaranteeing their places aren't going to get wrecked so we aren't held responsible for it. But I do think that's a great idea and that's definitely a huge incentive that people need to consider. We actually had a good idea from one of the property management firms.

1:43:29 With the idea of maybe a certain percentage of the rent would go into our foundation and start to create a pool that if somebody's home got trashed or something through this program, they could come to the foundation board and ask for some assistance. It may not be 100% covered or whatever, but it would be a way that there would be some money available to be able to help hold harmless the homeowner.

1:43:58 So those are the things where we're looking at all those things and how you would structure that and make sure you'd understand that if you did it through our foundation, it wouldn't be an escrow account. It wouldn't be anything like that. It would be basically you get a tax deduction for putting that one or two percent into the foundation and it becomes an unlimited pool for us to use for workforce housing. Great idea.

1:44:21 And just to be clear, the foundation you are referring to is the Mammoth Lakes Community Foundation. The Mammoth Community Foundation, the one that the chamber owns. Correct. And that is our community foundation. People in the community are wondering what our community foundation is doing. This is a perfect, great example of that. So thank you. Again, anybody has a foundation that wants to give our foundation money, we'll take it. Yeah, we understand. Thank you. And if anybody owns a home here and wants to rent it out, visit our website. Or if you know somebody.

1:44:52 That was the second home here. Pass the website on to them, too. Any questions for them from the audience? Sandy Hogan, and I just congratulate Kim and Curtis for acting so quickly, putting this website together. 72 responses in one day. That's pretty darn impressive. One thing that I would like to maybe suggest, and you may have covered it. It's hard to hear it all, but

1:45:33 is that with some of our ones in the residential areas that have been, you know, cut off from their short-term rentals, some of them, we have an example actually up in the Noles that I think that had been under enforcement for a number of years, and what has happened, and I happened to ride with one of the renters on the bus,

1:46:00 That homeowner realized that, well, maybe if I just rented, it was a four bedroom or five bedroom or something like that, a big place. If I just rented a bedroom or two to a couple of employees, I could still use it with my family. And not only that, sometimes they offer shoveling services, things like that. So I don't know if you've reached out to some of the, quote, ones that were violators, but Rob and Ben Manning, I know, and Danny Oros can really.

1:46:30 Those are ones that we have on the list to contact because if they can't make money in the short-term market, there is a possibility of making the long-term rentals. Plus, we also are going to be approaching some of those people to say, maybe you don't rent the whole house, but...

1:46:46 During the wintertime when you're only coming up one or two weeks of winter, would you like to have somebody make sure the pipes don't freeze? Exactly. So rent out one room, they can help take care of it. So those are all things that are on the... Good. I'm glad. I didn't, you know, you probably covered that in your outreach, but I think that's a real important one because we have had, you know, violators that actually that's a way of the town saying, yeah, you can't do it this way, but here's how you can do it. And I think a lot of short-term renters...

1:47:15 Finding that they really don't make as much as they think they could. So anyway, just my comment and congratulations and I think thank you council for funding this initial startup because and the fact that you're going to go after other funding for it, that's great. Anyway, just my comments. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, Chief. Mr. Mayor, council members.

1:47:56 It's my honor tonight to present the Chief's Award to Cody Barrett, who I'll call up in just a few moments, but a little bit of a background. First, I was later when I found out what was happening and felt Cody felt comfortable enough to come to me about something that happened years ago. I was pretty honored by that, that he felt comfortable with that. And so we set up a private appointment. He told me about something that happened several years ago and wanted to make sure it never happened to anyone else ever again.

1:48:24 So he was willing to do whatever it takes to make sure that doesn't happen. So through investigations with my officers in the district attorney's office and Cody's incredible help, we were able to identify and have a great case against a certain individual. During that investigation, several other cases were identified as well as other crimes. And so currently he's in custody and hopefully we'll never do something like that again.

1:48:54 I will. All right. Well, I appreciate the opportunity to come before you this evening.

1:50:20 As your council is aware, I've been before you a couple of other times regarding county's radio system, or really it's the county and the town's radio system. It's a joint used system for both administrative and public safety purposes. As I've kind of talked about in the past, you know, this system is in need of repair and really replacement. And what I'm here to talk about tonight is the next step in the overall process in evaluating

1:50:50 What that roadmap looks like and the study that was commissioned by Mono County and the vendor of Federal Engineering, who we retained to perform that study and try to debrief you a little bit. So there's a fair bit to cover. I'm going to try to walk through it as quickly as possible, as I know there's plenty of other things on the agenda. But I want to start with just a little bit of background and show you guys a few familiar slides and remind you of how we got here and then kind of dig into the report itself.

1:51:16 Talk a little bit about through some of the key findings what we think some of the next steps in this really are. So as you'll recall, this has been a phased approach for us in Mono County. In 2015, the IT department took ownership of the county's radio system. And really for those first few years, we were focused on trying to better understand what system it really was or what we actually had in that system. And really through that,

1:51:43 Get a better understanding of the deficiencies in it. There was a certain amount of things that were broken, things that needed to be reprogrammed, and a variety of other kind of maintenance and deferred maintenance types of issues. And so we had commissioned a study back in 2015 with Delta Wireless to come in and provide a peer-to-peer assessment of that overall system and basically provide us with a several-year roadmap or work plan on how we could get that 30-year-old system to function.

1:52:11 More or less as well as it was designed to work 30 years ago. So we've been doing that work for the last several years. And really beginning this year, kind of mid last year, we started to pivot and start to look toward the future and really think about how we are going to get toward a next generation radio system. Some of that has been rooted in governance and starting to look at the relationship between the stakeholders and the parties using the system. And some of it is this report relate directly to design and the engineering of that new system itself.

1:52:41 So we've talked in the past about there being sort of these two parallel tracks, and really that is driven by the fact that we need to sort of build the new plane while we're flying the old one, I guess, so to speak. We can't just overnight essentially switch to this new system because of a variety of different reasons, including the fact that it's going to take us several years to build it, and we need to make sure that the existing one is functional as well as it can be.

1:53:07 But we also want to start to make some incremental improvements to that and do so in a very thoughtful and careful manner so that we don't throw money away or waste time and energy on things that are ultimately going to be superseded. So we're kind of getting to this point where the two are starting to converge a little bit more. And this study was really the first part in really understanding where we want to go.

1:53:32 And how we start to get there will be the work that's in front of us over the next several months and probably years. So we've also talked about there being sort of two different trajectories internally in terms of how we're managing this project. And one is very much technical. You know, that starts at the basic governance level, but it really has been driven by an understanding from a stakeholder level what the needs of the individuals using the system are.

1:54:01 And how we actually technically design around those needs in order to make sure we result in a positive outcome for them. The technical focus really is aimed at how we get to the new system, while the administrative side is focused more on how we're going to actually maintain that system from an administrative level. And so in this last year, we've been focused on developing the strategic engineering study.

1:54:27 On the more technical side, and then simultaneously working on more of a governance structure or a picture of what that looks like so that ultimately when the system's built, we're in a position where we are able to maintain that, to incrementally improve upon it, to make sure that we're fiscally sustainable in managing it, and ultimately we don't end up in the position that we are today again in another 20 years. So that's kind of a bit of background on how we got here. So let's dig into the study a little bit.

1:54:56 Basically, the study was commissioned by the county, about $50,000, and we brought in a very well-known vendor within this space who is known as Federal Engineering. They're based out of Fairfax, Virginia, and the task that we put to them was to basically design at an engineering level the next generation radio system for the county. So we didn't really want to...

1:55:22 Talk philosophically about what we wanted, but we wanted to get down kind of to brass tacks in terms of what this thing would need to look like. One of the things we wanted to, or one of the ways that we wanted to approach that was from a vendor agnostic perspective and really a standards-based approach. So rather than saying we want to go with a Motorola solution or a Kenwood solution or a vendor-wise solution, what we said is

1:55:49 In order to best meet our needs, when stakeholders say they want A, B, and C, what are the general technology standards or patterns, regardless of the vendor that would deliver those, that we would need to implement in order to get there and address those needs? So that's basically what they were working on for us. I've said this a couple times, but we wanted something that was stakeholder need driven. We didn't want the county or the IT department or any one agency to drive this conversation. We wanted the stakeholders to drive it. We wanted to know

1:56:17 If you're an EMS captain or a paramedic or a police chief or a deputy or anybody in the field, what do you need out of a radio system and what do you want it to do when you push the button to talk? And we have really been pressed by your counsel, by my board, by a lot of people with regard to how much it's going to cost. Just tell us how much money you need. And really what I've consistently been saying is I don't know because I don't know what we're designing for.

1:56:47 So the goal of this was to take kind of all of these first four points and have federal engineering develop a rough order of magnitude costing based on what we were saying we wanted and then basically provide a roadmap and some timeframes associated with that so we could start to figure out how we're going to actually get to that implementation and being able to build it. And really, we wanted them to come back with some alternatives. So we figured there were probably more than one way to skin the cat.

1:57:17 And we wanted to know what the pros and cons of doing it one way versus another would be. And really what that wound up being through this report was not really three distinct alternatives, but essentially three phases. And we'll talk a little bit about that. So the process that they went through for the study began with in-depth conversations with my team. And I want to recognize Kirk Hartstrom, who's here, as well as Eric Buckwin, who's our communications specialist.

1:57:45 These two guys really led a lot of this. You know, collectively, we kind of articulated some goals and desired outcomes, the things that really, really were important to us or the stakeholders, as well as some of the limitations that we knew. And that kind of was the kernel for a lot of the rest of the conversation to evolve. From that, again, we went to the stakeholders and we did a very, or federal engineering did a very focused conversation.

1:58:12 With them, it began with a survey. I think about 50 different people responded to that survey. And then they basically took the results of that and sat down with those stakeholder groups to try to dig into the details and understand exactly what they were asking for. From that, site visits took place. Federal staff came out. They looked at dispatch. They looked at Conway Summit, representative of probably the best site that we have in our network, and Casa Diablo, which is representative of basically the rest of the sites in the network to get an idea of

1:58:41 Sort of the state of affairs. And then we spent a fair bit of time looking at coverage mapping and analyzing sort of based on where sites are located, the types of coverage we would see and some of the issues that we needed to solve around. And this was a big deal for us because for a long time I've been very concerned about investing money in any one site until we knew that it was a site we actually needed, until we knew what we actually needed at that site. So I didn't know, for example, whether we needed a 40-foot tower or a 100-foot tower.

1:59:11 Or I didn't know if we actually needed this site or we needed a site, you know, down the road somewhere. So this was an important component for us and we'll talk a little bit about the outcomes of that. Just some more guiding principles that we were working off through this whole process. You know, the first I think is fairly obvious. We're working off of a 30-year-old system now. We wanted something that was modern, that was built to industry standards and really to public safety standards. We have a lot of issues with reliability in our existing system.

1:59:39 Because it's frankly been built incrementally over time and not professionally engineered in design. So we wanted something that basically alleviated those issues. Above all, we wanted it to be simple and easy to use. You know, what we often say within my team is that people don't have to know how it works. They just have to be able to use it, right? They want to be able to push the button to talk on the radio and people can hear them. They don't want to have to go through a lot of gyrations to actually make the radio system work.

2:00:07 We wanted something that was built to public safety standards. Our current radio system is not. We have a lot of reliability issues as a result of that, and that ranges the gamut from things not having grounding or lightning suppression to, you know, small towers being concreted into rucks in order to get some stability for that tower structure, and we wanted something that alleviated that. We've made a huge investment in this region in Digital 385, and we wanted to try to leverage that wherever it's...

2:00:37 And we also wanted to look beyond that at other emerging communication technologies and patterns, such as 5G, LTE, various different things like that, and make sure that we weren't missing the boat or potentially closing ourselves up to any opportunities within those spaces. And as it relates, we wanted to design something in a way that it could be extensible. So I've said a couple times now, we don't want to

2:01:06 Buy a $12 million mothball that in five years is going to be superseded by some new emerging technology. We want to make sure we're building something that can be extended, that can be integrated with other types of technologies as they emerge, and ultimately is going to last us for the lifespan of this investment and not be sort of overrun by something else coming. And last but definitely not least is something that we know and we can support.

2:01:31 We don't want to be locked into a totally proprietary system that requires a very hefty maintenance agreement with a vendor for all the variety of reasons that I think you guys can all speculate on. So Federal came back with a report, and as we sat down and we reviewed the initial findings in that and discussed it a bit, they had initially proposed sort of these three different alternatives. And as we started to look at them, it became fairly apparent that they weren't

2:02:01 Purely discrete things that really they were related in such a way that they became a little more additive. And so what we said was, hey, why don't you go back and rethink this and almost bring it back to us as though you could phase it. And basically what they brought back was essentially that. And the first phase or alternative that they proposed is essentially upgrading our existing system, but basically using a similar type of technology.

2:02:29 That we are using today. So that would be providing an upgraded VHF-based analog system. And we'll talk a little bit more about what that means. The second alternative or phase was to kind of build off of that and to layer onto it simulcast. And we'll talk a little bit more about what that means. And then the third was to kind of deliver what we really asked for in the front end and a lot of our stakeholders were asking for, which was a digital-based VHF system.

2:02:57 That is Phase 25 compliant. And so we know that basically regardless of the phase or the alternative that we end up in, we at the end of this are going to have some ongoing operations and maintenance. And so we also talked fairly extensively about that, that we don't want to build a system today and then end up again in this space in another 20 years. So we want to also think how do we program around.

2:03:22 The ongoing maintenance, upkeep, lifecycle replacement, and things like that in the system. And that goes back to some of those guiding principles a minute ago. So just to kind of talk a little bit more about what was in each of these. So really the pros, and this isn't purely to say that there's pros and cons with each, but just to kind of talk a little bit about some of the pros and cons of each. Really, obviously with this first phase, we're going to get an improved set of reliability.

2:03:50 And overall functionality of the system because frankly we're going to basically rebuild every single one of our tower sites and in doing that we're going to also layer on a more modern way of providing backhaul or service to each of those tower sites and to connect them back into the overall network. One of the biggest issues that we have in reliability is the way that the sites are interconnected right now mixed with the fact that the sites themselves aren't very well built. So just that alone

2:04:17 It's going to improve the stability of the system, and then it's going to also improve the coverage a little bit and some of the audio quality that's coming across that network. So even without changing the technology dramatically, we kind of score one point, I guess, so to speak. It would meet public safety standards, and really it's something that we know and could support. On the negative side,

2:04:40 You know, one of the biggest complaints that our first responders and field users have is that there's a big learning curve to this system. As you're driving down 395, you have to literally change the channel, the dial on your radio to different repeaters based on where you are in the county because you can't hit just any one repeater from every location. And what that also means is that you can't talk across the entire network. So that's called simulcast. And one of the big complaints that we have, especially on the sheriff's side, is

2:05:10 They have no idea what's going on in the North County if they're in the South County because those two repeaters are basically complete islands to each other. So that doesn't exist in this first phase. And then the third thing that we've been asked about a number of times is being able to encrypt certain voice traffic. So for certain cases, there's a need for privacy and security, whether that's for first responder safety or whether that's for patient safety and transport and various things like that.

2:05:38 And that is something called P25. And that's basically only available in this phase 2B. So moving on, the second kind of alternative or phase basically takes all the investment that was made in this first one, the tower improvements, the backhaul improvements, and everything like that, and layers onto it this new simulcast and voting system. So that basically takes the need to select channels out of the whole equation.

2:06:06 Now, with the simulcast and voted system, you can key up the mic. You choose whether you're talking on the law enforcement channel or the medic channel or the admin channel. And regardless of whether you're in Bridgeport or in Benton, you key up the mic, you hit a repeater, you talk across the network, and everybody can hear you without really having to know anything more about the system. So it also improves coverage, and that's because we have to add a few extra sites in order to be able to actually get this technology to work properly.

2:06:35 But it is incremental, like I said. So it's building off of that phase one investment. It's still an analog system. And really the biggest thing about that is that we miss out on some audio quality benefits that are there. And then we also miss out on the voice encryption piece. So the third phase, really, is to take everything that was built up to this point and to layer on top of that this digital voice encryption. And essentially...

2:07:04 That really is a function of licensing. So we basically are purchasing devices that are compliant to run in this digital space, in this ultimate goal of where we want to get to, but we're not paying for the licensing to use that feature. Essentially, it's a software feature. And so what we would basically do in order to jump from phase 2B or 2A to 2B would be to pay for that licensing and to turn on for the channels that we wanted this digital capability.

2:07:33 And the associated encryption that comes with that. That improves our audio quality dramatically. And again, you know, it becomes an incremental thing. I don't know if there's really truly a big downside to Phase 2B or that alternative, but clearly that is the most costly of the three. And, you know, we do need to be a little bit thoughtful about how we're implementing this because of the licensing implications and making sure that the radios

2:08:01 That are going to be using that space of the network, you know, can be upgraded based on the technical limitations there. So I want to talk a little bit about coverage. And basically, I'm not going to show you a picture of this, but I'll try to describe it to you. You know, essentially what we did was we started with the existing sites that we have. Those are all the ones in that first column that say yes. And they modeled what

2:08:31 Coverage basically looked like from those sites. And coverage, the mapping that was done came back in kind of three different colors. The first being places on the ground where you could grab a handheld radio off your belt and in a building talk to a repeater without any issues. So that might be in the hospital in the depths of the hospital in the ER where the police and sheriffs have problems being able to hit a repeater. The second best

2:08:56 Would be that you can't talk within a building very well, but you can stand on the street with a handheld radio, hit our repeaters. And then the next best would be in a vehicle being able to hit a repeater. And so essentially they laid that map out across the entire county and we looked at places where we had good coverage and bad coverage. And then what we did is we took a year's worth of call data and we laid it on top of there and we looked at places where there were gaps in coverage, but there were a density of calls.

2:09:25 So a few spots jumped out, one being the Antelope Valley, Walker-Coleville-Topaz area, where there isn't very good radio service in the valley, but there's actually a fair number of calls. And another was Down Canyon, the village area in June Lake, where there's, again, actually really poor radio service, but fairly high density of population and a large number of calls. So then what we basically had them do is to go back and to kind of reverse engineer

2:09:51 Where they would put sites in order to provide coverage in the areas that mattered the most to us. And then we took that and we kind of just did a comparison and said, okay, yeah, based on these new sites, we're getting coverage in 85% of the places that really matter to us or more, I think, actually. And we feel pretty good about that. We're never going to get 100% coverage. It's going to be too costly and it's impractical. But we wanted to cover the places that matter the most.

2:10:21 Were the right sites to do that or not? And so what we basically found was that we have a few sites that just don't make sense. There's no reason to keep them because it's costly to maintain them. And in one case, in the case of Sub Hill, we actually don't have a lease to be there. We're on an emergency holdover status. And ultimately, we need to abandon that site anyway. So this was really telling for us because you see there's basically four sites here.

2:10:46 That are going to get decommissioned. So we don't want to invest money in them. We didn't want to invest money in them before. And now we basically know those aren't the right sites. On the flip side, we know that there's a couple of new sites that we need. And we generally know that there's a few places that we could build those and that they would actually demand or give us the coverage that we actually want to see. So kind of switching over into what this all means from a cost standpoint. Basically what federal engineering did was they went back and they looked.

2:11:17 Based on the system design, and they projected cost based on known values and real numbers, so they chose kind of a certain class of radio, a certain class of repeater. They looked at labor rates, they looked at sales tax, various things like that, and they broke out cost into four major categories. The first being site improvements, and this is the work being done on the ground at the mountaintops to replace towers, to install new vaults, power systems, and various things like that.

2:11:47 The second was the technology and the radios that were sitting in those vaults or mounted to those towers. That's repeaters, that's microwave systems, various things like that. The third was the subscriber units. So these are radios on belts or radios in cars. And then the fourth was dispatch equipment. And essentially, for each alternative, the costs were broken down within those four categories. So really, what we see at the end of the day,

2:12:17 And alternative 2B is roughly a $11.7 million price tag. We can theoretically get there incrementally, and there's a variety of different conversations we can have around that. But each of these things is not mutually exclusive. So basically there is an incremental cost to move from this first phase or alternative to the alternative 2B, which is sort of the preferred alternative.

2:12:46 Then the conversation really switches to how we get there, right? So we started to have a little bit of this conversation with federal engineering, and one of the first questions that my team asked was, if we can do this in phases or incrementally, can we also bite off a chunk of, say, phase one and have the county manage a project to basically take a few million dollars and rebuild or build new, let's say, three sites?

2:13:14 And then the next year do a few more sites and the next year do a few more sites. And over the course of a few years, we've basically done the site builds and then we're in the phase of actually putting the technology in those sites. Theoretically, it's possible, but that really wasn't a recommendation that was, they did not believe that was a good way to go about it. And the number one reason was that we have a limited staff. Our staff is dedicated to trying to maintain this existing system, which is falling apart.

2:13:43 And we don't have expertise in managing a large project like this. And the best thing to do is to basically set our sights on where we want to get to, to bring a vendor in, and to hold them responsible for the entire project and to make sure that they understand the things that need to happen in order to get this thing done. So the recommendation really did become that we aim for Alternative 2B, recognizing that it's going to take us some time to get there.

2:14:11 And in getting there, we will probably be able to implement something that looks like Alternative 1 while we're continuing to work on some of the other sites that need to be built out because it's not going to be possible to rebuild all of these sites in one summer, for example. But ultimately hold one vendor responsible, single throat to choke, basically, and get this project completed that way. So we recognize that we need to look at a cost share on this. So currently this is a county-owned,

2:14:40 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:15:09 We do know that there are potential ways to sort of finance it through vendors often. So sometimes there are lease-to-own types of scenarios or programs that are offered by these vendors. And clearly, if we were going to go with something like that, we would want to look at the total nut that we actually are going after and not some smaller amount of that. Because ultimately, the incremental costs of getting from 1 to 2A to 2B are things that we would need to find a way to finance later.

2:15:38 And really, at the end of the day, it comes down to recognizing where we want to get to and just accepting that we need to find a way to get there. Another piece that we're talking about, and I think this relates to the fact that there are a variety of different ways that we really could raise revenue. We've listed out a few of them here, and clearly there's pros and cons to each of these.

2:16:03 What's not on this list are other exploratory things like grants and various things like that. And this is something we need to bring somebody in who is really an expert in this type of thing to help us analyze this. Janet Dutcher, the Mona County Finance Director, and I have been talking a little bit about that. And, you know, clearly we have some ideas, but really there are people that are very well equipped to help us with some of this kind of work. And part of the reason that that conversation is important in bringing somebody in who really understands

2:16:32 So basically, you know, we feel that

2:17:01 This gives us a good starting point to really understand what we're talking about now. Again, one of the things that you've asked me is how much does it cost? Well, we generally now have a rough idea of that. I'll say that basically what this study shows is that there is a rough order of magnitude out there that's about $11.7 million price tag. Now, that's probably high. The way that they budget and develop the numbers on this is conservative. And invariably, the next step...

2:17:30 In this really, to narrow that down to a more finite number, assuming we had the green light to kind of move forward, would be to release an RFP and to get multiple vendors to come back and to bid on that. And through that process, we're going to see that actual number looks probably a little bit different than that. And from federal's perspective, it should be less than that. How much less, we don't really know. But generally speaking, the idea was to kind of get us

2:17:57 into the conversation with more or less the scope or magnitude of what we think we're looking at. So we think that really it is critical to restart a conversation with all of these stakeholder agencies around governance because it is a chicken and an egg thing, but at the end of the day, we have to understand what is the relationship between all of the stakeholders within this long-term obligation and use of the system because that's going to be

2:18:26 And then through that, start to sketch out

2:18:54 What a funding plan would look like, whether that's going to be a tax measure or a bond or something else. Along the way, I mean, hopefully we can get through some of that in less than a year. But, you know, certainly we need to make some modest investments into the existing system. And we need to do that carefully and recognizing that some of that stuff may be sunk. And we need to be careful. But ultimately, where we need to get to is a place where we can

2:19:22 Draft a request for proposals, release that, and have vendors come in and start to bid on this and give us some ideas of exactly how we execute on this thing and how we get it done. So I think it's a fair bit to digest, but I'm happy to answer questions or kind of fill in any blanks if you guys have any. Sure.

2:19:45 Obviously the funding is the biggest issue and I guess this question goes to the town manager since we are, you know, multiple agencies and everything else. How does all of this get coordinated so that we can address the funding issue? I think Nate kind of hit on it. I think it's that you get all your partners in the room, if you will, that are going to be utilizing the system and obviously there's some larger ones, smaller ones across the fire districts, the town, the county, school, other maybe some other smaller users.

2:20:16 But as you pull those folks together, that question becomes almost kind of a restatement at the front end. The value to this to each agency is X. Is it something we all agree to? And then really working that through on what's kind of a cost-sharing element. And then as you get into that, then it's looking at how does that translate across the various user groups. In some cases, you'll make choices. If we have, sorry, I think it's 11 fire districts.

2:20:46 If they're all pretty much being funded by the county, then what does that mean for the county in terms of they don't have a tax base basically of their own, those types of elements. Or if the school districts are involved, there's more restrictions on their taxing authorities. So how do we balance that in there? So it may be a different mix of funding by the agencies. But I think you start with everybody in the room going, yes, this is something we want to move forward with. We're willing to partner into it. Here's how we can be a partner. I think we can help.

2:21:16 Shape that look of what that partnership begins to look like from that funding. I'll guarantee it won't be absolutely equitable across to everybody of you use it 3% of the time, you're paying 3% of the cost. That is the reality probably will not happen. I think we're all in it together in terms of needing a new system, and then we balance across what is our ability to step up and help fund the rebuild of the system, and then it's just a timing question for the money.

2:21:45 Nate, this is both counties. Are we also talking about Alpine? I mean, is this just Mono? This is just Mono. Okay. So we, and this is where things do get a little bit muddy and confusing. I mean, a couple of months ago, I was before you to talk about regional dispatch. And there's clearly a nexus or an overlap or however you want to describe that, a relationship between the two topics. And certainly if we did move to a regional consolidated dispatch model.

2:22:15 Then the City of Bishop, the Inyo County, Town of Mammoth Lakes, and Mono would all be basically operated out of that same facility, but they would still be discrete or disparate radio networks. And so the integration between those happens at the dispatch side, but doesn't necessarily mean the networks need to be designed exactly the same or things like that. There are considerations there that we have certainly put out.

2:22:43 And we're considered as part of this report development. And something that we would put out there again as we bring in a vendor through an RFP process, because we want to make sure we don't close off any doors or sort of box ourselves in. But this is a Mono County geography radio system. Who do we need to set up a meeting with the county? What? And begin the discussion. Yeah. I think, yeah, there's some internal staff work to go on that as we walk through this.

2:23:13 Getting the right players at the table to start with is very critical and how do you structure that technical side and the governance side and then ultimately back to the policy makers of how do you, here's your funding options that seem to make, you know, reasonable relationship to users and is it something we're willing to move forward with? So I will say that I made this presentation to my board yesterday and that was actually a recommendation that came out from them was

2:23:40 I know that there is a Town County Liaison Meeting, I think, in February. It was felt that that would be a very relevant topic for that conversation. And certainly there can be a fair bit of groundwork done between now and then. But at the minimum, I think that this can be part of that meeting, if not maybe a more dedicated special meeting between now and then. Thank you. So the JPA would be a combination of

2:24:09 Well, if you go to a formal JPA, it'd be all the user groups, basically. So it'd be a 7, 8, 9 member board. If you go that route versus an agreement route, there's a couple ways to look at the governance structure that we can do. And this is a different JPA than the other one that isn't developed? Correct. Okay. So we're just JPA. Okay. And just to add on to that, I think that there are...

2:24:36 If we go back to the regional dispatch conversation in the radio system being discrete things, if the regional dispatch does come to bear, that clearly is going to need a governance structure and an agreement around it, whether it's a JPA or whether it's an MOU or whatever that looks like, there clearly needs to be a governance structure to how that thing gets managed. Same thing is true for the radio system. And where it gets a little bit

2:25:02 Interesting, I guess, is not only do those things overlap, but if the regional dispatch doesn't come to fruition, the way that the conversation has emerged with regard to this radio system, which is shared by the county and the town and has operated principally out of the singular dispatch center in Bridgeport, is that a component of that dispatch operation should be part of this agreement, because you can't necessarily separate the one from the other, because they're not necessarily

2:25:32 Useful on their own. So it would be nice to know generally how things are going to look with regard to a regional approach with regard to dispatch versus, you know, just keeping it the way it is effectively because it could change or inform the governance structure a little bit. But that said, I mean, they are discrete things and they each deserve their own agreement effectively. Does that make sense?

2:26:01 There's multiple agencies involved there, too, so there's some distinctions between that. Yeah, that's a good point. In a little bit, you can go. Thanks for the presentation. It was very, very thorough. What is Inyo County currently running? What kind of system are they running? They are running a VHF system as well. They have a multi-phased effort to basically overhaul their entire system.

2:26:34 They've just finished doing a number of upgrades to that radio system, including installing microwave to improve the backhaul of the link between the radio sites and various things like that. And so they are definitely a step ahead of us at this point. And they are not necessarily in the 2B sort of stage. They are still in a slightly older, not necessarily older, but a slightly different way of actually

2:27:04 Delivering that radio network to the end user, but the backbone of that system is good, and they've invested money in it recently. And they don't run EMS except for Simons. Simons, that's correct, yeah. So there's two dispatch centers in Inno, and one's in Bishop and one's in Independence, and the Bishop dispatch actually does dispatch for Simons, and so they've got some interesting sort of overlaps. It's a little bit...

2:27:32 Cleaner, I guess, in Mono, just because EMS is part of the county, and certainly it's a little more contained in terms of how we have dispatch set up. So all of their fire districts run call, and they use INIO as base, NIH as their base hospital? Right. Okay. Would IT, Mono IT, continue to run lead on this?

2:27:58 As we go through trying to establish these various steps to go forward. So I think if I was to sort of forecast the way this would go in a perfect world, my team would be responsible for engaging with a partner which would likely be Federal Engineering since they wrote this report and in conjunction with them would craft a RFP. They would at a

2:28:27 That is, with a service agreement, with a contract in place with them, essentially help us through that RFP process. So they would help let it, they would collect responses, and then collectively we would review and evaluate those responses, and they would help us evaluate, you know, A versus B versus C. Basically through that process, you know, we'd come up with a decision, obviously we would, they would help us make that decision, but we would ultimately make the decision. And then at that point,

2:28:57 The IT department would probably step back at least a half step and let the vendor and potentially federal as an intermediary basically run that project. And, you know, we would make sure we hold them accountable to the deliverables that are there. But one of the services that federal provides besides just doing this type of thing is helping manage those projects really from cradle to grave. Yeah. Okay. On the encryption, the

2:29:29 Yeah, is that going to be, do you think, an FAA requirement going forward? I mean, is that what makes it really important to be ready for? So, I think there's a couple ways to answer that question. The first is that the P25 standard is, it's a standard which any federal grant,

2:30:00 Basically requires us to buy technology that is capable of being able to implement it in the future. So if we're going to use EMPG or Homeland Security money or anything else that's coming from a state or a federal source, we have to buy equipment that's P25 ready. Whether we actually license it to enable P25 or not remains to be seen. How much is the licensing? It varies, but I mean, when you look at the cost increment here between 2A and 2B,

2:30:29 That entire $1.7 million is licensing. The cost. Yeah. And that's every single device that's going to use that technology, repeaters and radios on the belts, radios in the cars. Not necessarily every radio would need to. So, for example, the admin network, there's no reason to implement that technology, most likely. So we wouldn't necessarily bear the cost of that across every single device. And then certain channels, like, for example, one that gets brought up a lot is the fire channel.

2:30:59 They may not be that interested in it, but some may be. And so you could run in a hybrid mode, essentially, on a channel where... Put it on the EMS in the hospital, but... Exactly. So EMS is running encrypted on FHIR channel, and FHIR is running unencrypted on that same channel. Which might save some licensing money. Right. So if we had medical-assisted dispatch, you definitely would need it in that, probably. Absolutely. Do you think you'd need it? I mean...

2:31:27 When you're dispatching EMS, do you need it in that, do you think, always? I mean, they are skirting HIPAA, clearly. But it's right on the edge. Even though it's nameless, it's sometimes not hard to tell what you're doing. It is. And I think that it gets easy to cross that line without really realizing it. I mean, you know, there's obviously...

2:31:53 It's very different than violating HIPAA in a knowing, willful way. But I think, again, for patient privacy, for officer safety, for whatever that descriptor should be, it has a lot of value. Okay, I think that's all I got. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Nate, excellent work per usual. I feel pretty confident that I'm making the distinction between the radio system

2:32:22 And the 911 dispatch conversation. In my mind, for purposes of our regional colleagues, pretty clear to me, we're talking about radio systems, and I'm not going to be conflating that or getting into that space of how they cross-pollinate.

2:32:37 I feel confident also that this is a 90% staff type of an effort. It gets very technical very quickly, and I look forward to the staffs working together on this to bring us the relevant things we need to know about. For the purposes of RFPs, RFQs, bidding, I'm assuming that's the counties the lead on all that? I mean, I think that that is a conversation that remains to be seen. I do think that that's where...

2:33:04 The chicken and egg around governance and funding really come to bear. Who else would it be? Well, I mean, it could be the town. It doesn't make sense, probably, but it could be. Or it could be an independent governance structure, potentially. So I think that those are really germane conversations, clearly. And there's obviously pros and cons to any which way that governance structure gets set up.

2:33:32 And who kind of serves as the lead on this. Okay. But I'm also, for the time being, at least any discussion around JPA or that kind of stuff, I'm looking to staff and to maybe some alternative models that may be more nimble, that may be better suited to doing something like this. So I'm certainly reserving taking that out of those larger conversations. And I would look to...

2:33:59 If you guys think it's going to be relevant to bring it back, get in front of the ESCOG, because that proposal is going to be going out to the four jurisdictions, we're meeting, I think, in October to do a final blessing of that proposal and to do a very specific outreach program to the four members of the ESCOG, and hopefully we're not going to be mixing and matching any oranges or apples or grapes or anything else. So if you're going to think that's important, that's a good opportunity to bring that forward. Otherwise...

2:34:27 We'll keep the ESCOG JPA thing focused for what that's about. And I think that makes sense. I mean, you know, really, at this point, if we're purely talking about the radio system, there isn't very much relationship to the ESCOG other than the potential for regional dispatch. And even at that level, the ESCOG is not really the right entity to manage or serve as a governance structure there. Now, would it be informative?

2:34:52 I mean, if so, I'd be happy to make a presentation at the ESCOG. I think we've had pretty profound issues with confusion around messaging. Certainly, and that's something the ESCOG is looking to regroup on that. We had a very interesting meeting with the Bishop City Council, and we want to make sure that as each of these very important regional efforts unfold, that they can be discreet and clear and people know what they're dealing with and they can vote accordingly whether they want to do it or not. But I think it's in all of our interests to be...

2:35:20 Really clear and concise about what these efforts are. But thank you very much. It's excellent work. I have just one quick question. Go ahead. Do our federal partners use all this also? Yeah, good question. So the short answer is, generally speaking, no. But where there does start to be overlap is in mutual aid and interagency types of things. So wildland fire is a classic example.

2:35:47 More often than not, Chief Freeball could speak to this. We are using their frequencies or we're using a local TAC channel or something like that. We have had conversations with the LM and the Forest Service and really those are the two main that are present here. The Park Service presence isn't very large. And the initial reactions both to looking at working out of their dispatch center or using their network and sites was

2:36:17 Lukewarm at best. I do think that before we go headlong into signing of a check or something like that, we want to go back to those conversations once more and just double, triple check. But generally it's the same the other direction as well. They're only using our frequencies in mutual aid type circumstances where they need to talk to us or they're on an event or incident which we're managing or running and they need to be able to communicate. But they are, for better or worse,

2:36:46 They're on there. Now, would we be more compatible with them on the 2B choice? So, you know, that was one of the big things that we talked about with federal engineering through this process was, and not to get into the technical weeds, but the state, so Caltransit CHP, use an 800 megahertz spectrum radio network. And that's basically completely different than the spectrum that we are working with here in VHF.

2:37:14 And so, you know, we said, well, would it make sense to look at an 800 megahertz system instead of a VHF system? And so federal engineering did that. They looked at it from the technical level as well as kind of the practical level. And, you know, most of the rest of the folks that we work with, and we work with a lot of other agencies or fire agencies especially, Inyo County, Alpine County, Douglas County, they're all on VHF. And so we need to make sure we can talk to Caltrans and CHP, which we can.

2:37:41 But we generally think that this is the right place to be, and it's not a change from where we are. So it wouldn't make us any more so or less so, really. Makes sense. Thanks. When we were talking about this four months, five months ago, it was a price tag around $9 million. So now we're looking, and I thought that was going to be the top level of service at that time. So now we're talking more $12 million.

2:38:12 For something six months ago was nine? Well, honestly, in my defense, I, when was pressed for a number, was very dodgy about giving anything. And I think I ballparked somewhere between five and 10. And it's clear that I'm off by an order of magnitude. And that's why we paid professionals to come in and do this analysis and evaluate it for us.

2:38:38 Well, I mean, I certainly support having some conversations about this and continue to explore. I think I prefer at this point maybe an MOU with the parties. And we're definitely going to have to look into the funding options because, I mean, I know it's important, but we're talking, you know, if it ends up being $12 million here, you know, we've got other projects that are, you know, millions here, millions there. I mean, that starts.

2:39:06 I kind of feel like it's almost kids asking for a new iPhone when the old iPhone is working, but it's going to have a life where it's not going to work anymore. So I'm just having a hard time swallowing that figure. And I mean, do you see, I know that Mono County got a nice grant for the jail facility. What's the potential for

2:39:35 For any kind of grants for this area. So that is a conversation that just came up yesterday. My previous research into grant funding for specifically radio communications really yielded very unfavorable results. However, Steve Barwick and a couple of our board members were at RCRC this last week.

2:40:04 And somebody from USDA approached them and did say that there was potentially grant money out of the USDA to help fund something like this. Based on the initial research that I've done, it's hard to really see if that's actually true, but certainly it is one of a variety of different financing options which we would clearly look at. And if we could leverage a grant, obviously we would love to do that first. You know, I think with respect to, and I understand,

2:40:32 It's a big nut to crack and certainly a large number to think about. You know, but and I'll let the chief speak to this. You know, I mean, we're spending millions of dollars on marketing and bringing people into this region. We need to make sure that we can support them and provide public safety with the resources they need to respond to natural disasters, to communicate and to be able to support those people. So is the old iPhone working? I would argue and, you know, the chief may argue it's not.

2:41:01 It works intermittently. It works on this side of the street, but not that side of the street. Is that a good system? I would argue it's not. And from my perspective, it's costly and challenging to maintain. And so we're at this point where we have to make some difficult decisions, and this is definitely one of those. Yeah. Well, you know, being on...

2:41:20 On town council, it's, I just feel like this is something that I hope people realize that Mammoth Lakes will most likely be the biggest contributor to said nut. So that's just my concern. If I can just speak from a little bit from my experiences being involved with EMS, it's amazing they're able to do what they do with the kind of system that they have.

2:41:47 In the morning, they try to do a radio check from the North County to see if they can even talk to the hospital that day because sometimes it doesn't work. They're out making a call. They're trying to talk to, you know, the hospital on what do we do next? What, you know, what kind of, you know, treatment should we institute now? And they don't get a response or they're having to patch it through another, you know, I mean, it's very poor for that.

2:42:14 You know, being involved with incidents of fire and different things, trying to communicate. It's amazing we patched it together as long as we have. So I would, you know, definitely understand that this has been a long time coming. We need to figure out how to make it work with a combination of partners and funding and everything that we can do. And even if we have to increment it in, I think this is the direction that, you know, I for one...

2:42:42 Understand and feel that we need to prioritize. Nate, I only have one or two little things. They ask most of the questions already. So you're almost off the hot seat. One, we're going to move some sites around because they should be in better locations. Have we started that conversation with the Forest Service or BLM, whoever has that line? Right now, the issue we're having is we can't even get permit for a snow pit, which is hugely needed, every bit as much as the radio communication.

2:43:15 Through the Forest Service. So I'm not sure how we're going to make that fly at this point. The other, you said something about replacing all the towers. You know, I've been to those towers in the wintertime. And if they can withstand the snow loads and the winds that they've withstood up till now, I'm not sure I care what conditions they were built under. Those babies are not moving anywhere. So if we don't have to, I would just assume not.

2:43:45 And then my final comment is because I'm not a tech, I don't know enough about radio communication, I need to be assured that what we're building here is not a Cadillac because it would be nice to have, but it is the UGO that we can afford. So all very good questions. I'll start with the last one, which is it's neither a UGO nor a Cadillac. I think we're looking at a very modest approach to solving our challenges. We did.

2:44:15 Push Federal a little bit to look at what the true Cadillac would be. And we evaluated that and looked hard at it and ultimately decided that there wasn't any reason for that. And so we scaled back from that in a very reasonable fashion. We also have a Yugo with three wheels right now. And so we're trying to build something that's going to last us.

2:44:43 For at least the next 20 years, and that we don't have to continue to maintain, you know, with antiquated technology. You know, that said, I think that your first two questions are extremely important, and part of the reason that starting this conversation quickly and moving as quickly as possible is the first point that you bring up. You know, the short answer is no. We have not approached the forest with regard to this study.

2:45:12 This study is a card to play in those conversations and to say that, look, we are dealing with sites that have been there for a very long time. In some cases, there have been places which they would prefer them not to be. And in many cases, we've got multiple towers. And this is to your second point. Do we need new towers? The short answer is yes. And part of the reason we need new towers is because for them to actually function according to the way that the system should work,

2:45:42 There needs to be enough height, for one, that they can see off of the brow of some of these very broad hills that they're sitting on, and two, for there to be enough separation between the antennas that are being used for transmit and receive that there is an interference. And what we have right now is a bunch of 20-foot towers scattered about on a site which has a larger footprint in environmental impact, and all those towers and antennas are at the same height, and so they just yell at each other when people are using the system.

2:46:09 So that contributes to a lot of interference and other issues there. So are the towers going to blow over? Well, they haven't, you're right. But do they function the way they should? No. Very good. The other question that I would ask, which you cannot answer today, you keep talking about how costly it is to maintain the system we have, but we know that there's going to be great maintenance costs in the system coming to, I would love to see that comparison as well.

2:46:39 Yeah, so we, that is a really good point as well. So that is one of the things that we asked to at least take a stab at within this report and to look at what life cycle cost would be. Because we know that, let's say, for example, we go to a bond, we're going to have to service debt and we're going to simultaneously, theoretically, going to have to pay maintenance on certain things and ultimately put some money toward replacing radios on belts and radios in vehicles.

2:47:07 That bears a cost. We need to put some money away for the 15-year lifespan that is in really a repeater's life cycle or a microwave dish's life cycle. And so, yes, there is a life cycle cost. And certainly, that's a much deeper analysis that needs to be done as we start looking at financing options. Thank you. Chief, you wanted to say something extra? Yeah. Well, nothing's ever obvious to me, but...

2:47:43 For the record, Frank Freevault, Mammoth Lakes Park Protection Chief. Just wanted to distill down a couple of points, and I'll speak tonight both as Mammoth Lakes Chief and then also the representative from the Mona County Fire Chiefs Association as we've been involved in the regional discussions on community communications. You know, the first thing I would say, someone told me this, I said, you know what you ought to do, Chief, is bring just an audible transcript of some radio traffic.

2:48:14 Sometimes those things are self-evident. As far as I can tell, if it weren't for Nate's crew, our Yugo would have died about nine months ago four different times, for sure. And so I can't, you know, two things I really want to give him a shout-out for is keeping the thing going while we're looking at how to fix it.

2:48:38 You know, and they've taken a lot of heat from everybody. Nobody's happy about all the, you know, why can't we do the whole thing? I think you've shown great restraint on not spending any more money on a site for a transient solution and yet somehow putting a Band-Aid on it long enough to get here today. It is, I'd say it's, you know, it's past its life cycle. We are having agonal breaths on the system. As far as the towers go, you know, I'm not a, I can't spell technical. I'm an end user, you know.

2:49:09 But one of the things that was very clear to me, when we had, several years ago, we had to do what was called narrow banding. When that happened, these sites, you're right, you've been to them, they're, you know, if they haven't died yet, physically, they probably won't. The problem is, their original locations were built on a band width where they were fairly optimal locations. Once we did narrow banding, we lost 60, 50 percent.

2:49:37 of the signal strength. So it's not so much that the towers might not last through a bunch more storms physically. It's that they're just too far apart given the frequencies that were allowed and the tolerances with the FCC. So that was a big change. It's a change for everybody. It's really hurting us. And we're all obviously still, you know, licking our wounds after the recession. And capital repair replacement is one of the first casualties as we come out of that. And so we're not alone in this.

2:50:10 For me, this radio system discussion sits on a tripod. There's the technical side, which Nate has done a great job summarizing for us. We have some clear options ahead of us that are technically based on good data. There's a financial leg to this tripod. And the few discussions I've been in, it doesn't seem like that we lack the physical tools.

2:50:40 And theoretically, the capacity is there. So out of the box, the physical part, while it's shocking and it's a nut and it competes against everything else, it in and of itself isn't a complete non-starter. The key, though, to me, which I think is very important, and back to your point, the governance side, I think, is far more important than we are addressing. That's a part of really what I kind of want to drumbeat here.

2:51:12 The degree to which we'll spend physical resources on this is going to be reflexive to the value of the service that we get out of it. If we're not going to move the needle on stakeholder needs, then what really is the value? And we all have to do a good job deciding where do we spend our money best. The same way that there are technical standards for the physical build of the system, the dispatch service itself actually has standards just as well.

2:51:41 Both for medical dispatch, for fire and police dispatch. And we need to make sure if we're going to, in my opinion, and in the opinion of the Mona County Fire Chiefs, if we're going to spend this kind of level of effort financially and technically, we want to make sure we spend the same level of effort really thinking through governance and the ability to have stakeholder-driven need not just on the technical side, but on the service side, which really has a lot to do with dispatch.

2:52:09 So I just want to underscore that I think that's a key piece. I don't think it can be overestimated how important it is. And I think that'll have a lot to do with our willingness to make long-term fiscal commitments. Also, Sheriff Brown is not here. I would encourage you if you've not seen her comments from this presentation yesterday, I thought they were spot on. She made it very clear this isn't a...

2:52:34 Amona County Sheriff's system and not Amona County Sheriff's discussion. They can't, you know, the control can't reside there. I won't speak for her. I would encourage you to look at her comments, but I thought they were insightful and very open to where we need to go in this discussion. That was very encouraging to me. I appreciated that. I believe that's all I have, unless you have any questions for me. Questions for Frank? No. At this point, any member of the audience wish to?

2:53:05 Make a comment or ask a question. All right, I'll bang the gavel on that too. Nate, thank you very much. Sure. Unless you have something to say and finish. Yeah, so I think just to kind of close that out, really the recommended action and I think clearly the next steps for us is to pursue additional conversations in the governance space and clearly that will kind of relate to this funding.

2:53:37 I think I'll coordinate with Dan and Steve and look at potentially getting something before both bodies in February, if not sooner. Mr. Mayor, do we want to adopt the option one? Well, I was just about to ask, we have a recommended motion. Is this something that you need a motion on or just consensus to continue to move forward? I think if you just give us the consensus to work through kind of that recommended process, that's fine. I don't need a formal action at this point.

2:54:10 I believe we still need to keep going down that, Lynda, John? Absolutely. So if you have the direction you need. Nate, was there anything from the executive summary you wanted to highlight, or did we pretty much, if we read through that, we... I don't think so. I mean, I think the meat of that was really in the presentation, and I'm happy to answer questions on it if there's anything that stood out to you, but... That was a good recommendation, I thought, in summary, so... Great, thank you.

2:54:42 Okay, moving on then. The next item up is information and staff direction related to recent Southern California Edison public safety power shutoff and related community communications. Dan, I'm going to let you start us off here. This is back on the agenda, Mayor, Council, based on your request in the last meeting where we've just gone through the public...

2:55:07 Safety power shutoff element, a lot of concerns from the community coming up and internally, a lot of work with the staff and dealing with communications and elements. And I think there's really a two-pronged approach that we've been looking at as we're coming in this evening. Part of that is just that whole communication string that actually goes from SCE into the organizations, you know, the public safety folks, et cetera.

2:55:32 How are we structured there and the information coming through and kind of setting up this last, the first time kind of mini OES almost or operational level and a process that makes sure that we're getting information readily, quickly, et cetera, and we're able to process that. Nate's team did a great job of building some tools to actually help with a lot of the information that we could do. And our concern is on part of that then is how do you get relevant information out to the community?

2:56:00 What is it that people need to know? What we don't want to get into is where I get 82 of these notices and so I start ignoring them and then the one that comes in and says, hey, it's imminent, it's going to happen. Then you go, whoa, wait a minute, what happened? Those types of things. The other side of the communications is really given this reality that we're living in, it's not just about a public safety power shutoff. It is our wildfire. It is our, you know, snowstorm.

2:56:30 Potential natural disaster hazards around us. And how are we communicating with our community to say, are you ready? Are we actually prepared from people who live here to people who visit here? You're here visiting from Poland and you don't speak English well. And so even if you do have a radio or don't know what's going on, how do we really help step up our game in terms of our outreach to our community and our guests?

2:56:56 For this element we're playing. And that's a whole other element on this. But on the front end of it, I think there's things we can improve on and look to. And we'll talk to some of that. We've had, I think, a good worker relationship through this with SCE. And representatives are here this evening to speak to some of those things. We do think the whole process can get improved. It's a new game for lots of folks, including us and them. And if you talk to people in PG&E territory, et cetera.

2:57:25 They're going through these same issues, in some cases worse in terms of shutoff. But again, the other downside to that, the last thing, you know, we'll complain about until there's actually a fire or an incident that happens because of, and then it's going to be, why didn't you? And we don't want to get into that second guessing game either in terms of what we're trying to protect against.

2:57:48 With that, we wanted to walk through an overview of where we're at. You've had some information in the packet that kind of talks about the whole program that was rolled out. I think the last couple rounds, there's been a lot of lessons learned on everybody's side. So we kind of want to walk through that. Where are we and what are we up to at this point in time in the communication level? And then what is that longer-term outreach to the community side, which again...

2:58:11 More difficult in one sense just because of time and resources and efforts that are required. So Nate has a little bit of a PowerPoint here to walk through on this one too. He's kind of the lead department in terms of a lot of the interaction here. He's going to do another one, yes. Better or worse. So, yeah, thank you, Dan. I think that's a really good introduction. And Stu and I are going to kind of tag team this, but I'm going to kick it off with some sort of further background information. And, you know, I will give deference to SCE, both Cal and Bob, who are here.

2:58:41 But I'm going to provide just a little bit of background on PSPS, and you can yank me off the stage if I say anything that's wrong. And it's sort of the response that they're providing from the communication and collaboration space of what they're working on. And then really we're going to talk what we're doing as agencies, both the county and the town, with regard to this. So I stole a few of your slides. Sorry. But basically I'm not going to go into why this is happening, but effectively the public safety power shutoff is

2:59:10 A de-energization of circuits to prevent wildfires. And really, you know, I think as Dan astutely said, I mean, we would rather have power at all times, but I think we'd far rather be without power than be dealing with a wildfire. And really, that's what the Public Safety Power Shutoff Program is designed to help prevent. You know, there are some decision points from SCE in terms of when and why they will de-energize.

2:59:39 And if there are questions on that, again, I will defer to Bob and Cal in terms of what those things are. But it's not just an arbitrary thing. It is based on some meteorological conditions and the potential for fire to actually occur. And that's qualified with real-time observations that are happening on the ground and some understanding of the impact of that de-energization on the community as a whole.

3:00:07 The leading up to any type of PSPS event, and through that event, there is a timeline which they have ideally represented and is more or less laid out here. What we're going to kind of talk about today is effectively, or tonight, is effectively the way that we're seeing this kind of come down the pike. And I may have a couple of pointed comments toward these guys, which they had heard from me before, and I think are certainly

3:00:36 And so what we're seeing is a need to sort of react to these things as they're coming to us and to try to work nimbly in order to

3:01:06 Provide good information to the public and to react as organizations. So, you know, I'll talk a little bit about what SCE is doing in terms of the interface with us. And again, Bob and Cal, if you guys want to fill in, feel free. But basically, going into any PSPS event, and incidentally, there are a number of circuits that are back on a monitor list for tomorrow, beginning at noon, throughout Mono County and the town of Mammoth Lakes that were put on this evening. And going into an event like that,

3:01:32 They establish an operations center, and they have instant command and liaison officers that are tracking those events. And we are coordinating with them and interfacing with them regularly. So leading into an event, we have an operations team, and I'll talk a little bit more about how we're dealing with that. And we're basically in regular contact with SCE, so we understand generally what's coming down the pike and how things are looking.

3:01:56 And then they also obviously have their messaging. And that messaging is somewhat driven by state requirements and also somewhat driven by the need to notify their customers as well as us as agencies so that we're prepared and aware of what's going on. So for better or worse, because of the moving target nature of the weather and some of these things, the way that things ideally should look and work in that first

3:02:24 Graphic that was shown and the way that they actually do don't always line up. And so we as agencies are basically reacting to this. And I'm just showing you a few examples of some of the messages that we're getting. This one on the left is one that I get as a facility manager for the county, indicating that there's a few sites that are basically under my responsibility that are going onto a watch list. The one on the right is an example of a customer notification.

3:02:51 A residential level or a business level that would come out. As an agency representative or somebody within incident command, we're also getting notified through their incident command at a higher level around what is actually happening. And so we are sent an email. We're actually preemptively sent a text with that email as well. And basically in that email, we are given information about what is essentially evolving.

3:03:21 In this case, as an example, this is just a snapshot of things that are happening on the ground, you know, circuits that are coming off of a monitor list and going back to an OK status or things that are changing and getting updated with a period of concern that may exist for that circuit. And so basically what we're doing internally is trying to decipher this information, work with SCE and...

3:03:47 Provide them feedback on some of the challenges that we're having in deciphering it and really processing it and then understanding how we're going to react to it. And really that's the meat of what we want to talk about tonight and Stu's going to focus on a bit as well. So how are we as agencies reacting and responding? You know, really what I've been saying is that this isn't really what any of us want and we might all be frustrated and generally

3:04:14 I want to beat up on SCE, and certainly that's anybody's purview. But frankly, it's not really helping the situation as these things are coming at us when we're right in the midst of dealing with them. And so the way that we are trying to sort of react, at least right now, is within the areas that we have control over. And really, that kind of falls into two big buckets from my perspective. One is more internally focused, and that's

3:04:40 Really understanding our assets and infrastructure and making sure that we are prepared. You know, Dan made reference to the visitors, the residents, the businesses that are here being prepared, but frankly, are we prepared as agencies? Can we last through a power outage, whether that's six hours or three days? And so we're doing a fair bit of business continuity planning ourselves, and we're looking at how we as departments or agencies are basically weathering

3:05:09 This outage. And I think the other point that Dan makes that's very good is that this is in some respects a proxy for another type of disaster as well. If we were in a fire or a major snow event or something like that, we may be faced with many of the very same types of circumstances that are being put on us by the PSPS. And so that internal evaluation is really important for us. At a practical level, we have 38

3:05:36 Ish circuits in Mono County. 35 of those belong to SCE. There's a few in the northern part of the county. I actually think it may be a few more than that, but basically the northern part of the county is served by Liberty Utility, and we are not dealing with PSPS events with them yet. But 35, the majority of the rest of the county is served by SCE, and that encompassed in 35 circuits serves about 50 different sites that we, my team, has infrastructure at, and that ranges from

3:06:05 Buildings like this to mountaintop repeater sites to the jail to community centers and every single one of those has varying levels of need prioritization and things that we need to address and make sure that we understand you know what needs to happen when the power is out there. So the other part of this is I'm saying basically managing some of that transference of risk from SCE to us as agencies and this is more sort of the external facets of

3:06:35 The work that we are trying to do. And the biggest part of that is messaging. And, you know, some of that has to do with how we are interpreting the information that's coming from SCE, deciphering it for our internal operations and being able to prepare or react to things that are happening in respect to these assets and infrastructure, as well as helping our public better understand what's going on, because the messaging isn't always super clear and it isn't always as timely as it could be. So,

3:07:04 That relates to ultimately our ability to provide continuity of emergency services, ensure that 911 stays operational, ensure that our public safety personnel in the field understand what's going on and can react and sort of be able to help in situations as needed. And that could relate or result in things like opening cooling or warming centers potentially in certain communities depending on time of day, time of year and things like that. So these are just a few examples and ways that we're sort of

3:07:34 Beginning to think or are already reacting. I'll talk a little bit about resources and we'll dig into this some more, but basically we do have basically an operations team and that is an important thing because there's a handful of us that are working actively, generally, regularly. I was joking with somebody the other day that it's sort of now all public safety power shut off all the time instead of all recreation all the time. But that ops team is really critically important in being

3:08:03 On the ground and interfacing with one another in the community. We obviously have great staff that lend a hand in some of that work, as well as really critical individuals within some of our agency partners, be that the school, the hospital, the variety of other entities that we regularly work with and that are out there supporting the public. We have a more practical level, some tools internally that Dan alluded to, my team.

3:08:30 Built a dashboard to help with internal operations and better understand the impact of the outages and potential impact of any one of these certain circuits going down, both in terms of our critical facilities, any kind of critical needs population that are within those circuits, generally have an understanding of the types of things that we need to put energy toward if that circuit was to go down, and this has become a planning tool for sort of internal work.

3:09:00 We associated with that have a collaborative site that's SharePoint based site that basically these agency partners and key staff within the organization work off of and use to share information real time more or less and collaborate effectively and share information so that generally we're sure that in doing our best to ensure that the messaging that's going out across those key individuals is consistent.

3:09:28 And that it's consistent and in line with what the information that we're getting from SCE is. And then last but certainly not least is the public information portal. And you all have seen this. It's on the Mono County homepage. It generally consists of a web application with a map embedded.

3:09:46 That shows the status of the circuits and a bit of narrative alongside of that. And that's something that's being maintained by my team. Just incidentally, I thought it was fun yesterday. I went and looked to see what kind of traffic that thing was getting. And over the last, like, 20 days or so, we've gotten about 22,000 hits on that, which is pretty incredible considering the small community that we have. And it does say something about the reach and the impact and interest that this has in people.

3:10:13 So I'm going to talk a little bit about action plan. And there's kind of three big kind of buckets or prongs to this. The first is, again, back to that internally facing business continuity and resiliency effort of work that we're trying to do. The second is in the management of the actual event itself and the messaging around it. And then the third is any external coordination with partners and the advocacy associated with it. I'm going to talk a little bit about the first, and then I'm going to let Stu kind of talk about the other two.

3:10:42 And so, you know, I did sort of already touch on most of this, and really the bottom line goal here is to ensure that we as an agency can continue to operate and to serve our internal needs as well as ultimately the public that we serve. And we're doing that through a variety of different ways. So the first is really looking at our departmental service delivery models and really understanding who needs what and what is critical. And as part of that, it's going back to our core services and the delivery thereof.

3:11:12 To understand where we need to put some energy and what things we really need to focus on making sure have some business continuity in place. The second really is a more practical public works engineering level thing, which is infrastructure. That's looking at our critical facilities. What are they? For example, like our community center, which could be used as a cooling and warming center. It doesn't have generator power.

3:11:36 We can't actually use it as a warming center or a cooling center for the public during public safety power shutoff. We've also been talking about should we have generator power to the entire town as opposed to our EOC and a small wing of the town. So this incidentally is a big conversation not just with town but with the county and looking at what our infrastructure needs are. And then the last is a little less sexy but it's kind of that policy aspects of things. So what are we doing in terms of response?

3:12:05 And how are we more or less reacting to things? You know, we've got some labor considerations more so, I think, on the county side than the town side. But when the power goes off, do staff go home? Or if the power's up in certain places but not others, you know, do some staff go home and not others? You know, and what is the knowledge and awareness generally of that? So with that, I'm going to turn it over to Stu to talk a little bit about messaging. Thanks. Got to take a breath.

3:12:36 First of all, I'd really like to acknowledge Nate and his team. I mean, we would not be where we are right now without a phenomenal amount of work in a really short period of time. So I just want to recognize that we all should be very proud of his team and his efforts. So I'm just going to cover this slide here. There's a couple of slides we want to talk about. This is really event messaging, sorry, event management messaging. And then we'll talk about external coordination and advocacy.

3:13:02 This one here is really just kind of managing the event. So it's kind of working with SCE each time there's an event, which is probably now there's an incident command team that's up. I think the last council meeting we were here, we ran off to a 7 o'clock briefing call. So we're very actively engaged in understanding the event, really trying to develop and understand what's happening. What should we be prepared for? What messaging? You know, should we start to kind of...

3:13:29 And how soon and how frequent and how timely that information needs to be shared. So that's a big part of what we're doing. And, you know, Nate briefly touched base on the ops team. And then we're kind of really radically and quite quickly kind of pulling together some planned labor resources to kind of deal with what we're faced with, which is kind of the new reality. So SCE coordination, these kind of go together. These are kind of the coordination with our SCE partners.

3:13:59 The collaboration with our agency partners. So that can mean just talking, conversing, sitting here, chatting to the public. But it's also conversing with our Eastern Sierra PIO team, Public Information Officer team. We met with that group a couple of days ago as well. It's a really important network. I think there's like 35 PIOs across the Eastern Sierra.

3:14:23 Just a great resource for us to tap into. That also includes whether we establish a virtual or a physical JIC. JIC is a joint information centre. So how we start to deal with that messaging. It's almost, you know, a pre-EOC kind of operational type of thing. So we're kind of scaling up to the needs and where the period of concern, what we're monitoring as well. A lot of technical terms, which is the next slide, so hopefully that'll help.

3:14:48 And then the last slide here is just making sure that we're using all our public information resources. So, you know, is that the network with the PIOs? That's all the channels with the town. And county-wide, you know, again, you know, I want to speak on behalf of, you know, Sheriff Braun, but we've really kind of collaborated in regards to the communication. You know, who's sending what? Who's on which list? How do we kind of refine?

3:15:13 Merge those lists to make sure we're not kind of creating redundant emails. How do we be more efficient? And how do we kind of produce messages in a timely, accurate fashion? So I can kind of go into a lot of that in a couple of slides, which I will. But firstly, this is a really important slide. We've spent a lot of time, and I think we still are kind of refining our terms with our SED partners. This is kind of a handbook of acronyms, right? And so, you know, I don't know.

3:15:43 Stuck with, loved with, challenged with. But we have general terms such as the POC, which is our period of concern. So anytime we open an event, we're now in kind of a period of concern. It's got different phases. We kind of have initial, which is kind of an update of a circuit warning, and we have kind of an update to that warning. So again, it does get a little bit confusing, so messaging is really important. On the SCE action list, they're on the monitor list. It can move from kind of monitor to imminent.

3:16:12 Which is really where we really ramp up our communication efforts becomes very significant very quickly. We de-energise, we re-energise, and then hopefully we see a lot of these, which is the averted technology, which is probably the best one you can see out there. And to really refine our communication, I'm going to just kind of lean over to this tiering section here.

3:16:38 The last two, three weeks, it's kind of been everything to everyone, which I don't think is very effective. So our goal here, and we just spent some time here in the last couple of days, kind of refining our tiers. I mean, what's our hierarchy of communication? You know, who needs to know what, when do they need to know it, how much do they need to know that they can kind of take that information that's actionable, which I think is really important. So tier one is the incident command team that really talks about, you know, sheriff, police, first responders, PIOs.

3:17:06 Our IT team and so forth, right? So they're the first group that's going to get that first notification. Tier 2 is kind of our agency partners, elected official, administrators, department heads, partner agency reps and so forth, which is kind of our second tier and our third tier is really our public. So we've kind of crafted some messaging based on that. So this looks really confusing. I kind of sent this to Nate. I sent a version of this to Nate and he kind of built this, which is pretty cool.

3:17:32 Mine was kind of multiple pages and Nate was able to put it on one. So again, very talented. This one talks about trigger points and process. So right on the top of the slide there, the trigger points and process is SCE. So everything kind of in the gray box on the top. And this mirrors the slide on page five of your presentation. So this is really talking about the timeline of SCE and their response, right? So it talks about the three days down to one day, the status change, moving to imminent.

3:18:02 De-energization and so forth. So this is the input. So if that's the input, what's the output? So what we look at here is kind of the agency response, which is in the middle there, which is the blue. And then you can see right at the bottom it talks about communication, public versus tier two. It gets pretty confusing. So Nate, again, did a great job. But each of these phases has different communication channels, different kind of triggers.

3:18:28 You can see while we're in yellow, and I'm a big colour guy, right, I keep passing it on to Nate, and I think everyone relates with colours, right? I mean, language, if we're talking about folks from Poland and Australia, language is key, right? Yeah, language is universal. So, yellow's good. Green's better, but yellow's good. Yellow just means we're being monitored. It's a period of concern. And that could be, you know, one, two, three, like you said, we've been in a three-day monitor status the last kind of, you know,

3:18:57 Weekend the event that we had. So that just keeps going on. But during that monitor status, we're getting calls, we're getting updates, we're getting three to four messages a day. So what's really relevant for the public? Well, we think at this point, the most relevant thing is the updated map. So Nate and his team get the information, they update that map. That is the public facing map. That is the kind of the main source of information to a public. And we're just going to push that information to tier two. Tier one is already getting that, but we're going to push that to tier two. So while it's yellow, kind of being monitored, it's all good.

3:19:27 Nothing to see here. Don't panic. It's okay. That's what we're doing. Now, when we get to orange, which is kind of the stop sign signal, you want to kind of be prepared. You might want to stop. You might want to put your foot on the gas, whatever it is. We've got to be ready. That monitor, sorry, that orange phase could be, we think, one minute to four hours. Guys, I'm looking at you guys over there. So orange is like one to four, or in the first instant, it just happened, right?

3:19:54 That's a pretty critical phase. So we really need to make sure that we are prepared with kind of a pretty significant, well-planned, strategic kind of communication plan. So orange is big time, right? So that really becomes that custom message, the email list, the subscriber lists. The sheriff will start pushing on the sheriff of the Facebook page. That is the imminent phase. We start to push on code red, I-pause. I mean, stuff's happening, right? So things are happening because we know a power outage is imminent.

3:20:24 Once we get to red, power's de-energized, we're off. That becomes just an immediate and a frequent update on kind of what the status of the power and the circuit and when we expect it to be potentially re-energized in the future. So again, it looks really complicated, but I think we've tried to work hard to kind of really narrow it down.

3:20:43 Segment the user groups and the hierarchy and the tiers there and kind of customize the channels for each of those groups, right? Personalize those messages. So it looks confusing, but I think we're making sense of that. The last slide here is, which is kind of Nate's three-legged stool here. I don't know if I like to talk about three-legged stools. The last one here is really the external coordination and advocacy. So the goal here is just to kind of mitigate the impacts of these events. And that's really kind of the coordination with SCE, OES, CPEC.

3:21:13 As well as residents and businesses, you know, so how do we kind of deal with this together? So that's engaging with our business and residential community. You know, we have a Chamber of Commerce meeting here tomorrow at 1030. We're going to talk about this impact to our businesses and our community members.

3:21:26 Access and functional needs of customer safety. So it's just really making sure that we understand the needs and how to ensure the safety of our customers. It could be just helping them find a good source of generators or help that they might need in their homes. Opening community centres. This is one that Nate mentioned on warming or cooling centres. Hopefully they're just going to be cooling centres, right? You guys can talk about that. Thanks, Bob. But again, we've just spent...

3:21:57 You know, a good amount of funds in our community centre and forest trails. Should that be ramped up in the future to become a, you know, cooling centre or a place to go for people to kind of charge their phones, hang out, you know, kind of perform those daily functions that they need to, you know, do in our community. And that's really the only community centre we have that could kind of serve that function. If we're in that position, this facility here, even though it has a generator, it's where we are. It's the kind of the IC, the ops team is here.

3:22:25 So we are really displacing a lot of the community members. We had some community members and our council came and charged their batteries and figured out what was going on, which is great. But for kind of a large scale event, you know, we should really consider that. And then collaboration with SCE operations in coordination with Cal OEA. So that's kind of it for the presentation. I don't know if Nate wants to wrap up. I don't know if Cal or Bob want to jump up and...

3:22:50 Cover any questions. If you have any questions for me, I can answer those now. No, I just want to say that the public information portal and the maps that Nate and his team created so quickly were just awesome. I mean, that was just answering every question I had, and I really appreciate it. So shout out to you guys. Yeah, it was world class. That's not a notification, by the way. It's okay. It's all right. That's a PSPS power notification. Any questions for me?

3:23:21 Mayor, did you want to... Let's go through Council and see if there's any questions on the presentation, Kirk. How is this information going to get out to the public? I mean, we're doing this presentation here as to Edison's response to how we just went through this event. You understand what I'm saying? My homeowners, the second homeowners and everything else, you know, what's the...

3:23:54 How are we going to get this out to them? Especially this site. Multi-tier, multi-agency kind of response, right? You want to tackle that first, Nate? Sure. So one of the things that we talked about with the PIO group yesterday, gosh, it's all kind of blurring together at this point, was sort of the need to get consistent information.

3:24:21 Out through all of the individual channels that we each have. Obviously, MLTs is very different than the towns, than the county. So we right now, most all of those channels are pointing back to the PSPS portal that is on the county site. And the discussion that happened yesterday was what other resources should be put on there. Clearly, we linked back to SCE's site. Bob threw out the really good idea, which we're going to implement, I think, tomorrow.

3:24:48 To put a banner there to encourage people to go to SCE and register for notifications if they haven't already done that. You know, preparedness kits, all that kind of stuff. So we're trying to kind of amass and build that as a good resource, whether it's a PSPS event or not. And then, I mean, I think in terms of how are we notifying the public, I'm not sure if you're saying during an event. Is that one of your questions? Well, it seems that we have a three-day prep period that we began. I'm looking at this.

3:25:17 I'm thinking about our guests in town. How do we reach out to them? So I'll let Cal or Bob speak to what they're doing. What I can tell you is the sheriff, in conjunction with the ops team, has basically committed that when circuits transition or are about to transition from that monitor status to that eminent status, which, again, could be in a minute or in four hours.

3:25:46 The Sheriff's Department is sending out a code red, which is a reverse 911 to anybody who's registered in that system, as well as an IPOS, which is essentially an Amber Alert notification or like notification on your cell phone. So whether you subscribe or not, if you're within the service area of any of our towers, you'll get that push notification that says power outages is imminent. For more information, visit

3:26:11 You know, the Mono County website. And then from there, we are working very closely with SCE and the ops team to make sure that the information that's flowing from them to us is basically being updated there. So I don't know, Cal, do you want to add to that? Well, just a few brief comments. Again, my name is Cal Rossi. For the record, I'm the government relations manager for Mono County.

3:26:40 I serve in two roles. Number one, a liaison for the elected officials and staff to the company, but also in terms of public safety power shutoff or any other event, I will also serve as the agency rep, which means that if there's an activation here at the county level, most likely Mr. Steens will tell me to get my car and get up here. And so under the incident command system,

3:27:09 You know, I'm the local embedded, and then I've worked with Bob Steens to make sure that your voice is heard and your priorities, more importantly, are heard during the incident. But real briefly, before I turn it over to our senior advisor, Bob Steens, I just wanted to take a brief moment to say thank you so much for the partnership, the staff.

3:27:34 During this last event and the collaboration was quite remarkable. In fact, I could say that, you know, not only are they leaders across our service territory in developing protocols in response to them.

3:27:55 A particular public safety power shutoff. But I'd also, I was sitting here thinking, listening to this, that I would really look at it as constructive collaboration. Because we not only talk about what went wrong, we talk about what went right. Between yesterday and Thursday, we're going to have six different meetings with the county of Mono Inyo. We met with the PIO group. We're meeting with the chamber. We're very, very committed.

3:28:25 To process improvement and working with the county in trying to make sure we get this right and your voice is heard. And again, Nate, Stuart Brown, Sheriff Brown, several of the council members stopped by during this event. And I just want not to monopolize the time, but take a little moment just to say thank you for the partnership. Bob.

3:28:52 Thanks, Callan. My name is Bob Steens. I'm a senior advisor in our public affairs group and manage our business resiliency and for the last, I don't know, two years I've been living this PSPS. I think someone else said PSPS all the time. That's my life lately. I want to first echo Cal's thanks and appreciation for the city and the county.

3:29:15 We realized, you know, we, Nate showed us that timeline. We realized, you know, obviously we did not live up to that timeline, especially the first outage. We went back and looked and we had a technical problem with our model, the coding in our model, which we quickly fixed, which was the reason we weren't able to provide the advanced notification.

3:29:37 Two weeks ago. But again, I want to thank the county, thank the city. Before I talk much, I want to remind people, do this every time I can, to go to sc.com slash PSPS and sign up for those alerts. I know you get a lot of them, but as we saw, now they're, you know, they are real. There is a real chance this could happen.

3:30:01 And I also acknowledge the Mono County website is great. I've been out meeting with other counties as part of my road trip and I pull up Mono County's website to show because it's just a great, really creative and good thinking and we're talking, Nate and I are talking tomorrow and over the next few days and how we can, you know, further enhance all the GIS stuff that I don't understand, but to make that work better.

3:30:28 Just a quick update. You know, we did, after the incident two weeks ago, observe some damage to our system. And while you can never say...

3:30:40 You know, it would have started a fire. It's the type of damage that could have started a fire that we noticed if we, but, you know, thankfully we did de-energize and that we do realize that is a major disturbance. Just going forward, some of the things I heard, some of just the changes we're going to be making to our system and, you know, we're learning with each one of these incidents and a lot of that is a result of.

3:31:02 We had an after action with Inyo County this afternoon, doing an after action with Mono County tomorrow. But our webpage is going to be, by the end of this month, displaying maps, more timely information and maps of public safety power shutoffs. We're working on a system, which we hope to have again in place early next month, where people who are like behind master meters, so mobile home residents, where it's a single meter.

3:31:31 Right now, that's the only person we know who to notify. But people, including visitors, could go in and register to be notified while they're up in this area. So that'll be coming up soon. And obviously, we'll work with the city and county as we roll that out. And we're obviously looking forward next year.

3:31:50 Because we're still developing this program to work with the city and the county to develop what we call resource centers, which are places that we work with the city and the county to identify places where we can come in and help, if necessary, provide a generator for this sort of warming cooling center, warming center that Nate and Stu worked about. So we're here to answer any questions, but again, can't do enough. Thanks for everybody's support on this. Okay.

3:32:23 Questions from Council? John? Yeah, I want to preface my comments by saying how impressed I am once again by the technical capacity of all the various members of our teams. This is all important work that you're talking about. It's work that has to be done. But I'm profoundly disappointed in terms of what we're talking about this evening because when the Council requested to agendize this item, it was not to get a PhD thesis on acronyms and technical stuff coming out of a variety of agencies.

3:32:52 They're doing things you have to do, but we are not addressing the community's needs through this discussion. We're not. And I'm profoundly disappointed about that. It's good that you guys can turn off your power lines. Fires aren't being started. The community is being affected by this. And it's not about the alerts. That's driving people crazy. It's our daily lives are being affected. It's nice to be referring to websites and electronic means and all that kind of stuff. But when your routers go down,

3:33:22 When there's no mitigation within the community to make sure that your Wi-Fi is still working, it's not useful. And I think the only term, I mean, this is all very interesting. I don't want to put anybody on a hot seat. That's not what I'm trying to do. I'm just frustrated that we need to address the citizens that we represent. We need to start representing their needs, right? So where are people who get food?

3:33:47 Where do people, if my AT&T phone fails, who's talking to AT&T to make sure that the cell service provider is going to work? And these are not questions you have to answer right now. But the focus of this has got to be on what do we do for the people living here, for our visitor population, so that they can engage effectively with these things when they happen. They're going to happen. It's very important that they do happen. But what are we doing now to make sure that our citizens and our visitors and guests, if the electricity goes off for 24 hours,

3:34:17 Where do they get food? How do they connect to internet systems? How do they connect to all this messaging? It's pretty mundane stuff. But this is the stuff that we have to focus on, that we have to deliver on behalf of our community. And excuse me if I'm a little bit frustrated, but these are the needs that we have to deal with as representatives of the community. I appreciate all this technical stuff you're doing. It's important. It's got to get done. But we represent human beings, businesses, and a visitor population of millions of people. Those are the people that we have to answer to.

3:34:46 Those are my thoughts, Mr. Mayor. So I'll provide an initial reaction to that, which may seem odd coming from the Director of IT, but I think the role that I and my team play in this at least partially addresses maybe some of your question. So there's two components to what we are focusing on as an agency and as my team is focusing on. The first is our internal ability to continue to respond, react.

3:35:14 Put up stop signs at intersections, respond to 911 calls, various different things like that during a power outage and making sure that our team has the resources they need. The second part of that is to work closely and to pressure firmly the utilities, the partners that we work with that provide service to end users, be that residents, businesses, visitors, whatever that might be. I was in a three-hour meeting today with AT&T. I'm going to be a two-hour meeting with them tomorrow.

3:35:43 We're having conversations with all of the utilities other than SCE around various different things with regard to service provision to making sure that we understand what they are doing, they understand the impact that this is having and that there is resiliency conversations happening around that. What I will say at a very specific and technical level, the AT&T network is being hardened and they are addressing the power and the resiliency issues that we faced in the first outage.

3:36:12 They were surprised. Some of that was due to messaging issues. Some of that was due to their own issues. Some of that was due to tenant-landlord issues with where their facilities are located. Those things are being addressed, and I can assure you we hammered on them very hard earlier this afternoon. Verizon, I'm generally knowledgeable that they have the necessary means in place to keep their facilities operational. Our network as a whole

3:36:41 Relys on Digital 385. That network is resilient. We were completely functional for all of the agency operations within that Frontier's network at the basic landline level remained up and operational. The places that we have problems are things that require power. So if you have a standard landline through Frontier and you have a phone that plugs into an AC jack,

3:37:09 Either so you can have a remote headset or fancy light on that phone, it's not going to work. So if you have the need to be able to potentially call 911 during a power outage, not only should you probably either get a Frontier landline or a Verizon or AT&T cell phone, but you should make sure that those things are charged and that if it's a landline, it doesn't require power. So this is the conversation we need to have. The specific granular.

3:37:39 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

3:37:57 Thank you.

3:38:20 We need to start investing in the reality of what we're going to have to do to be able to engage with these types of situations. So you could just, it's a simple yes or no kind of question. We don't want to, if there's nothing there, don't worry about it. We'll figure it out on our own, but we don't want to be chasing something if there's not any resources there to help us with this. At this time, there are not resources there. Thank you very much. Thank you for your clarity. Appreciate that. But I did want to mention that at the last meeting that we attended and there was some discussion,

3:38:48 about some of the vegetation hazardous fuels reduction. We are going to participate in that. It's in the process. But going back to your initial comments, I hear you. I agree with you. I know we have a lot more work to do. We started talking to the first responders.

3:39:12 To Nate, the Office of Emergency Services about a year ago, we felt it important to try to get the underlying, I guess, basics covered. How are we going to respond? How are you going to respond? We did have, as you know, last July, a town hall meeting to try to start the conversation. Excuse me, I think that town hall meeting happened in the night of a council meeting. Is that correct? Yes, it did. Okay, so that's, again.

3:39:37 That doesn't really cover the base. I just got a notice tonight while I'm sitting here that there's some kind of a meeting in Bishop tomorrow, that the messaging just went out tonight for meeting tomorrow in Bishop. Well, what we did is because we had a meeting in Mammoth, we noticed folks in Bishop and then some of the circuits.

3:39:56 That come into southern Mono County. So the customers, you know, that were kind of on that side all got noticed for that. And as you know, there's been some social media outreach on that because we felt it important to give folks in Mammoth and Mono County generally another bite at that apple. And to your point about the impacts on business, we are...

3:40:20 Meeting tomorrow with some business owners to have a discussion through the Chamber of Commerce about what we can do to improve the process and address some of the concerns. Is that an open public meeting? I think I would defer to Ken Bringle on that, but I think he limited that. Okay, so I'll be quiet here, Mr. Mayor, in a second. I'm just thinking that this is all well and good, but we need to start speaking directly with our constituents.

3:40:49 Identifying what the needs are, figuring out how we're going to get through things like this. One final question is, when there's snow on the ground, how are you guys going to deal with, I'm assuming if there's a certain amount of snow on the ground in Mammoth Lakes, we're not going to be subjected to PSPSs. Is that correct? If you look at the original matrix about wind,

3:41:09 About humidity, about fuel loads, and then the final kind of catch-all to this, and Bob can speak to this in maybe more detail, but the final catch-all to this is our folks on the ground providing that kind of information that, look, the moisture content's up, there's a foot of snow on the ground, and that goes to inform, along with the discussions with the Office of Emergency Services. Well, again, because we are a remote town and a...

3:41:36 Distant part of the state. A lot of times the state, we just had a conversation today about not quite understanding who we are and how we operate. But I would be really wanting, I hope to get definitive statement that says if you've got six inches or foot of snow on the ground and the snow levels as such, that you guys are not going to be doing PSPS events here. Because then if there's a wire that goes loose, it's basically landing on water.

3:42:00 Why would we need to be going? And this also goes to the community's mitigation of these kinds of challenges. If we've got 20,000, 30,000 people in town, if there are blizzards going on, this gets into a level of life-threatening circumstances that we're not in a position to deal with. And that gets beyond sort of inconveniences and things getting difficult to putting people's real lives at risk.

3:42:24 And also putting our destination and the reason why people come up here at risk. So I just hope that the conversations are going to be that specific to understand that, look, if there's three, four, five, six feet of snow on the ground, we're not going to be doing these things. And if you can't say anything about that now, we'd like to have a further conversation with you about that going forward so we can understand what kind of space we're actually in. So I can't say definitive, but I can say it's unlikely. I mean, it's because it's based on our fuel. Who makes that decision?

3:42:51 It's based on, the ultimate decision is based on our incident commander on the ground, but if there's, as you said, if there's several feet of snow, it's, again, I want to say never say never, but it is highly unlikely. Well, again, we don't talk about this now, but again, if that's something that we need to prepare for, that's something we didn't know about, and I think you guys are having these conversations. John, let me move it on to some other. Of course. I apologize. Linda. Thanks.

3:43:17 Thank you, everyone. Thank you for being here. Thanks for what you've said tonight. I think John spoke to some of the concerns that I've been having, and that is, initially, Stu and I talked, because I turned on a handheld radio, a little, you know, nine-volt radio, to listen to our local radio channels who were broadcasting what was recorded that morning.

3:43:39 There was nothing on there about what was happening because they didn't have a generator in place to transmit from their offices even though the towers were working. So that sort of goes back to when we talk about the granule issues of where do people get information if they don't have a cell phone, they don't have a computer, they don't know how to work Facebook, they don't know how to do websites. So that gets into that. And again, I'm not sure, I think SCE plays a part in that, but I think that the ultimate responsibility for advising our

3:44:08 Residents and our customers and our visitors lies within this government, the town government, that we have a responsibility to prepare people coming to town for these eventualities. I think that the lodging association has a huge part of it. Now you have people coming here, staying in rooms. What's in the room? Is there a flashlight? Is there something? Is there a nothing?

3:44:31 I thought of it was there was nothing. How about all the short-term rental, all the people that run, you know, short-term rentals, the Airbnbs and stuff, how do they prepare their visitors to be safe in these, you know, places? Okay, Snow Creek, all electric heat. Okay, that's probably not going to get too warm in there. You know, how are you going to get them around? How are you going to keep them warm? How are you going to do this? This is all very large, but I would not expect necessarily SCE to be the lead on that. I would expect this body.

3:44:58 And the bodies throughout the county of government, elected officials, to be really working with the emergency preparedness people and how we prepare as a community for that. Which grocery stores have a generator? Vons, yes. Which gas stations have a generator to pump gas? That's the information that we need to accumulate locally, get that out into people too. So I think that that is a subject for another meeting and for tonight.

3:45:26 You provided what you provided. Thank you. That was the agenda item. That's perfect. Now it's on us then to move ahead with direction to town staff and to be, okay, where do we go next to help our constituents deal with this, as I'm sure the county is going to be having that conversation too. So I'll just kind of allude to a couple of things that are happening, and I don't think we have the answers, but I think those are some of many of the right questions that we're asking. Tomorrow's business roundtable is obviously

3:45:56 Designed to provide some of that information and to brainstorm some of those very things. Tomorrow morning we have a hot wash and a review with SCE with a lot of those agency partners and some of the information that came out of the PIO conversation yesterday is going to inform that conversation tomorrow. And all of that is with the goal of trying to get all of these types of ideas and issues on the table.

3:46:18 So that ultimately we can start to build some plans. And this goes to this external coordination and advocacy as well as the internal piece. And I think, you know, this is kind of the new normal for us. And most of us are caught flat-footed. And I think we're trying to figure out how to react. So I do agree that as that stuff gets developed, it will need to come back. Which really shouldn't be a surprise. It's not like we don't have power outages here all the time. We live in inclement weather. We have power outages. I mean, we just all sort of are blissfully. Thank you.

3:46:48 I'm going to take a different look at this. I'm taking the opportunity to encourage people in town to be prepared for anything. All the earthquakes that we've had up here.

3:47:01 Didn't move my dial of being prepared for anything. Going with electricity for eight hours. I do have AT&T. I didn't have a cell phone. And even when we got re-energized in my area, it took a day to two days before my internet was back up and running and did not get any information from.

3:47:25 From the cable company that it was even out due to electricity. They wouldn't even divulge that. So I'm just going to put my two cents worth and, you know, go ahead and get those batteries, get those lights, get those candles, because it could be something that's totally unrelated to this.

3:47:43 I'm not depending on anybody to come knock on my door and help me in any kind of situation, and that's a hard way, and we do need to look after the people and the tourists, but it's going to take a lot of personal responsibility, so I think that my game was upped by about 50%, and I have a lot further to go, so I learned a good lesson. Kirk? Okay, I just have a couple of comments.

3:48:15 On the SCE side, somehow, we have to get those protocols tightened up to the point where we can make some changes. To say that when it goes to orange, what do we call that, eminent, that it could be shut off from one minute to four hours from that time frame.

3:48:35 To me is completely unacceptable. You're going to notify somebody who's at work and may need to get home because they have an elder on oxygen or whatever it is. I would rather see the power cut off an hour before it was absolutely necessary so that you can notify and people have a chance to perform than say, oh my God, look, we got a spark coming from this transformer or we've got extreme fire danger and we're going to shut it off.

3:49:05 Right now, because then people don't have a chance to perform. It would be helpful for me, and for a lot of other people I know, if we knew what some of the protocols were. So there are certain mile-an-hour winds, there's certain moisture content in the wood, there are decision points that your people are using to make those decisions. If we could somehow understand those better, then I can look and say, look, we're going to have 30 mile-an-hour winds.

3:49:32 I don't believe there will be a power shutoff tomorrow. I don't think the winds are going to come close to that. I can't say, but, you know, I've been a weather buff up here for an awful lot of years. But if we can somehow tighten those up, so instead of saying three days out, there is a chance. Because, you know, three days out from now, there's always a chance the electricity is going to go out. Somebody could hit a phone pole. Somebody could sort of tighten those up so that we're actually notifying of something that is.

3:50:00 More eminent to me makes more sense even if we have to proactively shut it off before it actually reaches critical because we know if it is or isn't. The people on the ground are looking at that. They know the moisture content of the duff. They know the lines. They know things I don't know. So that's really what I'm asking for is to get these protocols down to a point where we can actually notify somewhat in advance.

3:50:29 That there's at three o'clock there's going to be a shutoff. If it doesn't happen at three, yeah, then we're all the better for it. But if we know that that is when it's going to potentially happen, now I can plan for it. So thank you for that input. You know, we're constantly reevaluating as we go through these and learn, and your input's very important, and I'll make sure to take that back to our folks that are, including me, that are working on our planning for this. Thank you.

3:50:58 So, Mr. Mayor, if I could, I'd like to make a motion of sorts when you're ready for something like that. Yeah, can we take public comment first if there's public comment? Members of the public wishing to ask a question or speak on this. Chief, you got up there. Chief Revolt, I just want to provide a little more information you'd ask about levels of discussion with SCE with kind of boots on the ground on local conditions. Is that correct? Maybe.

3:51:28 Okay. I understood you were concerned. Are we having local granular conversations with SCE regarding local conditions in relation to their decision to do power shutoffs? Yes. I was speaking specifically to snow, I believe. Okay. I can tell you firsthand that I did receive such a call from one of the incident command team members. I'd worked with that person over the years here.

3:51:56 They said, look, we do have our local protocols that we're working on. I'd just like to, I wanted to reach out to you. Can you give me an idea of what you're seeing out there? And so, you know, I drove around a couple of different places in town and was kind of doing some FaceTime pictures so that they could see what the winds were doing. Okay. So to that, I'd be a supporter for SCE. I know they reached out to me to do that. Yeah. Bob would tell you I'm a supporter and I'm a critic.

3:52:21 He and I have had those discussions already. We had met before the first public safety power shutoff after the, I don't know, what did we call the discussion at the high school? Essentially, I politely said that's great as a warm fuzzy, but it's not nearly sufficient to handle the questions you're asking. And so we had started on the discussion to say, look, this is a transference of risk. We all understand that. We don't expect the SCU to solve our problems.

3:52:52 What we do expect to have, and my request specifically was, both to SCE and to Cal OES, our operational area is unique. Yes, and I think, and that's a very important point, because in my experience with Cal OES, when we're dealing with things like climate change mitigation and stuff like that, we talk about rain on snow events, they have no idea what we're talking about. They're catching up. And it's because we get them up here. The State Department is looking for young men like you to...

3:53:20 But I think, but as part of going forward, we need to start speaking specifically to Cal OES and Edison and others to articulate our specific and unique conditions, as you're saying. You would like to meet, I can meet with you, and I can show you the strings of discussion we're having, so at least you would know there's some level of that. But I would say one of the real benefits to this event, somebody's going to roll me in the alley here, this was an outstanding way to stress test ourselves. Sure. And we didn't have an event to go with it, thank goodness.

3:53:52 ATT got an earful for me when, you know, my phone service went down. If we had reached out to people on IPAWS, that wouldn't have worked. So we're having some pretty spirited discussions with some of our utilities on this. But at the end of the day, I concur that it is ultimately our responsibility to figure out how we're going to respond to these. But that said, we're asking for, from SCE and from Cal OES, additional attention.

3:54:20 To the lead time. Because the lead times of four hours aren't enough for us to get anything on the road to support us logistically because they'll shut down the highway to high-profile traffic for the same reasons. And so those are the angles we're trying to work on there. And also, Bob, you know, we asked for some maps because I know they've referenced them before. He got that information on Nate. Nate took care of business. And the only thing I would add to that is

3:54:45 That as we continue this conversation and we develop our responses and how we as a community are going to respond, things like snow on the ground is a specific condition to this community in this region. This needs to be directly factored in to what's going on and we need to have a specific articulation from SCE and Cal OES that understands.

3:55:06 That we need to know where we stand with that. Because if you've got to reserve the right to turn off the power in the middle of December when we've got 50,000 people in town, we have to start planning. And especially if there's no financial resources coming for us to help to deal with it, we just need to be able to start to plan and deal, anticipate those kinds of events. I believe that, can you put the criteria, that information, because I know I review it with Cal OES, but you've got criteria that you follow from a weather perspective.

3:55:34 And includes fuels, wind, some other considerations. So those are out there. If he can't get it to you, I'll attempt to get it to you through Kelly OAS. Look forward to having that discussion. Any other questions? No other questions. I want to make one other point. As someone who's lived in the mountains for almost all his life, I was actually dismayed at how unprepared.

3:56:00 The population of this town was to deal with this. This is not an uncommon event. This is something that in the not-too-distant past would happen for five, six, seven days at a time. And the population was prepared. We have become so complacent as to not even have a battery-powered flashlight that we know works in the house. Somehow we have to get that messaging out.

3:56:30 Our responsibility and the public's responsibility. I would politely say that that is the expectation for the residents. Right. For the transient population that we recruit heavily to come here, I don't think we can actually count on them to do that. That's going to be an extra logistical load for us. No, but perhaps there should be a flashlight in each unit. Could be. Thank you. Not expensive. Good evening, Mayor, Council.

3:57:02 Stacey Corliss, Mono County Board of Supervisors, to speak to this last slide. I would just really like to add that it's wonderful all the work our employees are doing coordinating with SCE and Cal OES, but there's another level to this, and I would urge the town and the county together to advocate for strengthening the policy around de-energization, and we do that through

3:57:26 The CPUC, I've already talked to Cal about this, you know, through our Rural Counties Association and our State Association of Counties. They are commenting on the rulemaking that CPUC is doing around de-energization. There are post-event reports that the utilities have to provide to CPUC. We can comment on all of those. We can use this experience to actually...

3:57:52 shape the regulatory policy, or at least I'd like to, at least that's how it's supposed to work. And we need to be communicating all of this to our legislators. I'm trying to do that. I'm sure others are. I'm sure the League of Cities is engaged in this. So let's, you know, take this frustration and this momentum we have around it to do something productive for all Californians who are going through this. Well said. Thank you. Thank you. Any other members of the public wishing to speak? John, you had a suggestion?

3:58:27 Yes, sir. I would like to propose a motion that we follow up on Chief Freehold's representations about the on-the-ground conditions analysis. Where did he go? Did he go to the bathroom? Okay. He ran away. We have that effect on people. But to follow up on that on-the-ground conditions analysis.

3:58:51 Communication to SCE and to Cal OAS with regards to de-energization with specific regard to snowfall and snow on the ground and to get a definitive response from that. The second part of my motion is that the Town Council, I believe, has the option to request spending from the joint bucket that's shared between Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the Town Council coming from Measure A funds for marketing. That we...

3:59:20 Prepare a request for funds from that joint bucket to be used to address the communities, to analyze and develop and understand the community's specific needs with regards to these PSPS events, and especially with regards with how we are going to engage and be effective with our visitor population in town should these events happen. And I don't know how much, I don't know, but I'm saying let's, let's, because there's no money coming from Edison to do this.

3:59:49 And that joint bucket, if we're a visitation, tourism-based place, we're going to have a lot of visitors in town that, to the point, when I lived on Davison, and people would show up in their Escalades fresh out of somewhere down south in their pajamas and their socks, and there's four feet of snow on the ground and four more feet coming, and they get stuck, and I, hey, can I help you out? Well, yeah, it's snowing, and where are your chains? Well, they're in the back.

4:00:18 Well, you got your pajamas on. I mean, this is the reality of what we deal with. And we have to start thinking about how we're going to, if potentially, if the power's going to go off and we've got 25,000, 30,000 people in town, we have to be, we know how to deal with this. We can help them out. John, you may have just made one of the longest motions I've ever heard. Thank you. I stopped. I can restate if needed. Jamie has all that. So, to restate. Yeah, restate it. Simple. Two cores.

4:00:47 A specific request to follow up with Cal OES and Edison to understand, to make clear that the conditions on the ground in Mammoth Lakes need to be factored in with PSPS events with regards, especially with regard to snowfall. Respectfully, that I believe has been addressed even though they have not told us we had 75 people, linemen on the ground and they do take precipitation, they take the wind measurements, they have a whole system that

4:01:17 As far as the ground, I went and talked to a bunch of people. I saw what they were doing. It was impressive. I understand. But what I heard from the representative from Edison was that they reserve the right to turn the power off whenever they feel it's appropriate to turn the power off. For fire danger. For fire danger. I mean, they have rules. Understood. Understood. But I would like to get for us to have a representation from Edison as to how snow will factor into that. John, I'm going to answer that for you a little bit.

4:01:44 I believe when there's snow in Mammoth, they will not shut circuits off in Mammoth because the fire danger doesn't exist. That's not what I heard from that. However, it takes lines coming from both directions to feed Mammoth, which are not always in snow conditions, and it could be that those are what triggers it. So I would like the first part of your motion to be more that they will communicate with us what the protocols are and as they change, because they are working on them all the time, to bring that forward.

4:02:14 Thank you. So that would be the first part of my motion? Yes. The second part would be for the town council to- One motion at a time. Okay. So I'm still not understanding what your motion is. Are we just asking for a policy, Edison, to provide us a policy as to when the trigger point policies? We're asking for, as Bill stated, we're asking for protocols, representation from protocols with regards to PSPS events, with regards to snowfall.

4:02:44 Then I would support that, yes.

4:02:46 What is your policy?

4:02:48 What is your protocol?

4:02:49 When are you going to do A, B, and C?

4:02:52 I have a motion.

4:02:55 Do I have a second?

4:02:59 I'll second it.

4:03:00 I have a motion and a second.

4:03:01 Any further deliberation?

4:03:05 Jamie?

4:03:06 No.

4:03:08 Yes.

4:03:09 Yes.

4:03:11 Yes.

4:03:12 Yes.

4:03:14 Thank you.

4:03:14 4-1.

4:03:15 Second motion.

4:03:16 Yes.

4:03:17 Is to, for the town council to work with staff.

4:03:20 to develop a proposal to the joint bucket, the tourism joint bucket, to develop a program to outreach to the community and visitors and guests in the event of a PSPS event to mitigate the effects of that event for our population. So basically to fund public outreach

4:03:48 To educate on possible PSPS. Yes, and to provide the granular, specific information that folks will need during such an event. Right. I have a motion. Do I have a second? Motion dies for lack of second. Dan, you wanted to say something. No. Dan, you always want to say something. Can I take another? Yes.

4:04:31 This was a five-year program. This isn't something we do in two council meetings.

4:05:01 So rather than a motion, if we were to instead give direction to staff that says... Yeah, I think staff has the direction they need.

4:05:28 Good. Okay. Does anybody bring this back to us and see what we bring this in? Does anybody at the dais feel the need to speak anymore on this subject? I would thank our partners from SCE for coming. We will now take a 10-minute break.

4:07:28 I'm keeping my car full of gas now. Okay, if we could all find our way back to our seats. We'll bang the gavel one more time. Do we still have our fearless leader somewhere in the room? No, I saw him go down the hall. Looks like we're waiting a minute. Sorry, I got you all excited for nothing.

4:08:02 You can get through consent, can't you? Yeah. Well, it depends, doesn't it? Well, it was a question. I thought it was a directive. Okay, I will call this meeting back to order and we'll see where we can get without Dan and the attorney. No. Next item is the consent agenda. Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of September 18. Adopt the resolution approving applications for per capita grant funds from the California drought, water, parts, climate.

4:08:52 Coastal Protection and Outdoor Access Act of 18. Award contract to Decoralight Industries, Inc. in the amount of 33-209 for a one-year pilot winter street animation project. Authorize Town Manager to execute Cardno Task Orders 1 and 2 for multi-use path project study reports as part of the existing on-call civil engineering services contract with Cardno.

4:09:20 Adopt resolution vacating a portion of an existing recreational trail easement and an irrevocable offer of dedication for a public trail easement as granted to the town and accept payment approval report number 20-09. Mr. Mayor, I will make a motion. I would like to pull 9 before you make the motion. Oh, okay. I'll make a motion to approve consent items 7, 8, 10, 11, and 12.

4:09:56 I'll second the motion. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Yes, Mr. Mayor over here. Yes, sir. Items, item number 10 and 11 were of concern to me. I spoke with town staff, but I just want to say that Councilmember Stapp has brought up the need for prioritization of public work efforts.

4:10:21 And while these don't fit into that, I just want to make sure that, you know, I'm really looking forward to doing some prioritization of our public work projects and those kinds of things. But my questions were satisfied, so I don't feel new to pull the item. So that's, I just wanted to say that. Okay, further deliberation? Jamie, please? Council Member Hawke? Yes. Council Member Statt? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tempsalcedo? Yes. Mayor Salsic? Yes. Mayor Salsic? Yes. Mr. Mayor?

4:10:47 Mr. Chair, I pulled number nine. I thought we had a council discussion that we were going to, because of the size of these, that we were going to just purchase three of them, put one in Old Mammoth on, you know, three different areas to see if the wind, if they held up in the wind rather than spend $33,000. That was my understanding. If I misunderstood, then, you know, I'm kind of opening a discussion with council.

4:11:17 What was your recollection? I heard that we were going to have enough that we could kind of get a visual of what it would look like with the different sizes as well as seeing the construction quality. I thought we were going to do a number of them to check wind to see one in Old Mammoth, one out. Yeah, I didn't. I was thinking it was the...

4:11:45 Rather than spend $33,000 and then find out that they don't hold up in the wind. The amount that we initially approved was $100,000. $100,000, three years. And then it was decided that we would do a pilot program and not order all of the snowflakes at once. And this is what the staff came back with with a pilot project and I am comfortable with it. A full number of these for the...

4:12:18 Whole area would be how many? Wasn't there 50 or some? Yeah, it was a bunch. Full program, 85 of them. I think this is 27. I just remembered that there was going to be a smaller number to test out because if I didn't remember three, I thought smaller. So if there's 85 would be a full thing. 10 is. We're doing. So how many are we purchasing? How many are we purchasing? 10. 10. 10 three-foot. Sorry, 27 is in the report.

4:12:45 In the proposed purchase. Are they going to be clustered in like Old Mammoth or where are they going to be located? Yeah, thank you for the questions. So we're going to do 10 three-foot snowflakes on a long Old Mammoth Road and they're going to be coordinated and adjacent to the bus shelters. Yeah, I read that. Yeah, and then we'll have 17 five-foot snowflakes on Main Street. I missed the 17. Okay. Yeah, I've got...

4:13:15 I expressed my concerns. Ten and 17. And frankly, it doesn't make any sense to make it a smaller number because an awful lot of the cost is in them putting it up and taking it down. So I'm comfortable with this. Plus they can do it all over town and test the different areas too. It's consistent with my recollections. Any further comments? Would somebody like to make a motion on it?

4:13:44 I'll make a motion that we approve item nine on the consent agenda award contract to Decrelight Industries. Second. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. 5-0. Moving on now to public hearings. And I will now open the public hearing on...

4:14:24 Consider approval of zoning code amendment 19-001 to implement the zoning code cleanup. Sandra. Thank you. I'm going to turn this presentation over to Michael Paterka, our assistant planner, who wrote the report and prepared all the attachments. All right. The purpose of the zoning code amendment is to correct minor reference inconsistencies and clarify specific development standards, update sections of this code to be consistent with recent changes in state law, and correct an error in the zoning map.

4:14:58 The corrections and clarifications to the zoning code include amending the allowed uses tables for commercial and residential districts to clarify that a use permit is required for fractional timeshare developments in the RMF2 zone and all commercial zoning districts. The solid waste and recyclable materials separation and storage section and the multifamily project section

4:15:21 will be amended to refer to the solid waste management and solid waste recycling chapters of the municipal code for solid waste and recycling bin requirements. Also, the number of parking spaces required section will be amended to clarify that clean air vehicle parking spaces count toward the total number of required parking spaces. As for updates due to changes in California state laws,

4:15:50 The personal services definition is being updated to require that all persons engaged in massage be certified by the California Massage Therapy Council. And also in accordance with Senate Bill 946, the mobile business section is being updated to include sidewalk vendors as a form of mobile vendor or mobile business. Additionally, a definition for sidewalk vendor has been added to the definition section and minor changes were made to other related definitions.

4:16:21 Finally, there's a correction to the zoning map for a parcel at 18 Tamarack Street. A lot merger occurred here back in 2003, and the zoning designation was never updated, which resulted in split zoning for the lot. This amendment will correct the zoning map by designating the entire parcel as rural residential equestrian overlay. All required findings have been met.

4:16:50 And the recommended motion is to waive the first reading and introduce by title only the ordinance making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approving Zoning Code Amendment 19-001 as recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission or as modified by the Town Council. And that concludes my presentation. Any members of the public wishing to speak on this matter in this public hearing? With that, I will close the public hearing.

4:17:23 And open council deliberations on the issue. I'm supportive of the item as presented. Supportive. Well, then give me a motion. Mr. Mayor, oh, I'm sorry. Councilmember Salcido, please. Okay. All right, I'll make a motion that...

4:17:44 The Town Council waived the first reading and introduced by title only. The ordinance making the required CEQA and Municipal Code Finanings and approved Zoning Amendment 19-001 as recommended by the Planning Economic Development Commission or as modified by Town Council. Second that. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberations? Yes. Council Member Stafford? Yes. Council Member Stafford? Yes. Council Member Stafford? Yes. Council Member Stafford? Yes. Council Member Stafford? Yes. Council Member Stafford? Yes. Council Member Stafford? Yes.

4:18:15 On the agenda, the next is a public hearing to update to Town of Mammoth Lake Municipal Code Section 3.13, Online Rental Platform. This item will be continued to the November 6th Town Council meeting, so if you're here to speak on that, please come November 6th. Moving on to policy matters, discussion and action on funding for the Trails Homeowners Association for fiscal year 18-19 winter snow shoveling. Dan.

4:18:47 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. This item has been before you before in different forms. We've had a substantial amount of discussions the last few months, actually, looking at different elements and options. Based on previous discussions with the Council, we had met with representatives from the Homeowners Association looking at a potential of funding for a portion of the work, but not the full amount once the bill was submitted, which is in your copy of the paid bill is in your packet.

4:19:16 The primary focus that we had, at least recollection with staff, was really talking about the easement leading off of the school district property, then into the easement between two of the property owners there on Wagon Wheel, and then across the street, and then ultimately it goes on down the drainage easement into the roadway.

4:19:39 The request for reimbursement was a much longer piece of easement than frankly I'll say any of the staff myself had a recollection of discussing. Doesn't mean that that wasn't a thought with the homeowners. The other questions that have been brought up is looking at the easement itself in terms of as it comes off the school property then across into the drainage easement. We do have a

4:20:04 Program set up with action outside of engineering firm to take a look at that. And if there is any recommended improvements to that drainage, we would come back to town council and make those findings known. And if we need to modify something on that basis for future drainage issues, we would bring that forward accordingly based on kind of a third party analysis of it, not just the staff side. So that's still in the process. So it's not complete at this point. The other questions that have come up on this was there is the question of just the easement itself.

4:20:33 The easement is at this point in the town through a dedication on the map that was a dedication of the public easement or an easement to the public. And the easement, the documents that we have on is for drainage purposes. And actually, there is no requirement obligations. It's spelled out in the easement document, so it's very short in terms of town's obligations to work with the easement.

4:21:01 The easement is a 20-foot easement. It has a number of encroachments in it from neighboring properties, which, again, we're not addressing those at this point in time, but long-term that may be something to look at if we actually are going to look at any modifications. The other question that comes up is the use of adjacent to the easement really for a trail to the school. There is no, nothing we can find, there is no public access easement.

4:21:29 Through the parcels or through our drainage easement, the work that was done there to allow for better access, if you will, of students, that was basically done by the HOA at that element. Depending on the time in the maps you looked at, it looked like it may have been somewhat in the easement, but mostly on private property adjacent to the easement. As far as we know, there's no permission to do that. The town is not granted any permission for

4:21:57 Pedestrian easement within the drainage easement. There's rocks in there and stuff and it would not be a safe place for pedestrians. So as it relates to any type of pedestrian access in there, to our knowledge there is no legal access. So we would not want to encourage frankly or remove snow accordingly for a public easement across there that does not exist for pedestrian purposes. The other piece was looking at the

4:22:25 School site project that was done and the improvements made there to the parking area. Question comes up relating to that to a town project and from a clarification standpoint, the rework of the parking area, the paving and those elements, that was a school district project. The designs went through the DSA, Department of State Architect.

4:22:49 The town was involved in that because we did end up funding part of the sidewalk work as part of the Safe Routes to School program, the pedestrian access. And then we were managing our project versus having the school district spend extra dollars to manage their side. We actually stepped in and did the management, I think, for free for the school district for the coordination of the contractor. But the actual design of the paving out there and the work was a school district property.

4:23:15 So if there's concerns over the impact from that to the drainage, one issue would be is, frankly, it's probably a school district question versus a town question. We believe in reviewing the maps and working on it. We did have input in looking at them. I think the actual flow and drainage across there has actually been improved versus impacted. There's some natural drainage in there that's been there, I believe, prior to even the subdivision being built, the stuff off of Meridian and those areas.

4:23:44 Again, we've gone through a lot of this in the past and different issues that were out there and elements of that, so I don't want to rehash all of those, but just some factual information there. If we need to clarify some of this, we can do that. I think the primary question before the town council tonight as we work through this is the HOA has done additional shoveling in that area and stuff.

4:24:07 Two big winters ago when we had the rain on snow event, I know there was concerns about flooding. To our knowledge, there's no damage on the area we're looking at. We had staff out there to do some shoveling, and we had elements that way and stuff at that point in time. Last year, we did not see any threat to flooding and issues, so we did not do shoveling on our own side or clear that or authorize any work within the easement.

4:24:36 Information there from the bill and stuff is before the council. Frankly, at this point, it would be more of a policy question to the council if you believe that there is adequate value in terms of paying a portion or none of the bill as presented to the town from the HOA in that process. We had had some preliminary discussions looking at a couple different things. One of those was we looked at some different options providing some funding and we had

4:25:04 Say some side conversations that I believe in at one council meeting that looking at maybe an up to a $5,000 amount in terms of offsetting some of that impact. The other side of it was that, you know, the whole question on the prevailing wage for a maintenance project, which the project falls into, the wages paid do meet that requirement. Whether or not the contractor is registered with the state, I have not done that research. I couldn't tell you if they're actually a qualified contractor from that perspective.

4:25:34 Andy can speak to the legal requirements of that if need be. The threshold there wouldn't require them to do the certified payroll in that element because it's under $15,000. So some of that issue gets in. And as the last few years, some changes at the State Department of Industrial Relations have really started to look at and crack down on the impact of prevailing wages. We have some other...

4:25:59 Experience of that within the town recently. So it is an issue that is being taken very seriously by the state. And we do not want to get sideways on that as it has penalties and interest as well as any back wages. We don't believe that would be an issue here. But so that's just an ongoing concern is not on this project, but the others as well as we deal with prevailing wage issues. So I can answer questions there. And I know the representatives and the homeowners association are here and what we want to present their

4:26:30 Items before the council as well at the request. I'll let Andy address some of the other technical or legal questions. Let me address the prevailing wage issue. The Department of Industrial Relations two years ago issued an opinion clearing up what had been 22 years of very fortunate for cities.

4:26:49 Confusion. Since 1995, the position had been that snow removal did not require the payment of prevailing wages based on an opinion the DIR gave Nevada County in 1995. And I think everyone had been studiously avoiding asking the question since then. But in 2017, El Dorado County, for reasons known only to them, finally did ask the question about snow removal. And DIR, sure enough, came back and said point blank.

4:27:13 No confusion about it. Yes, absolutely. Snow removal requires prevailing wages because it's considered maintenance. The state prevailing wage laws and the regulations that implement those laws.

4:27:24 Define maintenance as any recurring action to protect public property. In this case, we have an easement. So this is action to protect public property. No question at all that prevailing wages are required. But the amount of work is small enough that a registered contractor didn't have to be used, which is good because this one's not. But it's not just paying the actual employees prevailing wages. You have to make payments into an apprenticeship fund and you have to make payments for training that go to some central location.

4:27:53 So this contractor probably did not comply with the prevailing wage laws no matter how much they paid their workers because they probably didn't make those secondary payments. My understanding is that the town staff did inform the HOA in advance up front that they'd have to pay prevailing wages and that the HOA doesn't believe that that's necessary and so didn't direct their contractor to do that. So that's what I can tell you about that. I will point out that

4:28:23 Dan did mention very briefly the engineering question out here at the site, but that's not on the agenda. So no real discussion of engineering or who's responsible for drainage is really appropriate tonight. Really the only agenda item is does the town want to pay for some or all of the snow removal? With that, Linda, would you like to start us off this time? I have no questions for you. Kirk? They did the work.

4:28:58 And you're saying they're under-billing us because they didn't pay prevailing wage? What are you saying? I'm sorry. I mean, you know, you're... Okay. I'm saying that the contractor probably did not comply with the prevailing wage law. Okay, that's good. We're being asked to pay this. And is that the issue before us? State prevailing wage law... Or we can't pay this because they didn't pay prevailing wage? State prevailing wage law says that if we...

4:29:30 Directly or indirectly pay for work that requires prevailing wages. If we fail to specify that when we're making those payments, we, the town, are on the hook for any penalties and interest that arise as a result of a failure to pay prevailing wages. And you're saying this was a prevailing wage? No question about it. This is a prevailing wage job and prevailing wages, I'm fairly sure, were not paid. Now, it may be possible for the contractor to go back and retroactively fix it by making

4:29:58 Those apprenticeship and training payments, I don't know, but I will say that the Department of Industrial Relations has been looking at Mammoth, did recently ding a subcontractor on a town project for not paying prevailing wages. Whether they'd figure this one out, I don't know, but if the town pays for this work and prevailing wages were not paid and the failure to do that is not cured, we could end up liable for payment of penalties and interest.

4:30:28 Okay, just to clarify, so you're saying that even this bill right here may not be the actual total amount? Don't know. It's not itemized very well. It just simply says $60 an hour, but I don't know if $60 an hour was paid to the laborers with no ancillary payments being made or if $60 represents some wage paid to the laborers plus those ancillary payments that are required to be made. I simply don't know, but my suspicion is because this contractor...

4:30:57 Is not registered to pay prevailing wages, probably does not understand the details of prevailing wages, which are complicated. My guess is that probably those secondary payments were not made, so prevailing wages technically weren't really paid for this work. The hourly rate would meet prevailing wage requirements, but it's the other payments. The homeowners association was made aware of the fact that this was

4:31:25 So would this pertain to all

4:31:59 Payment? Any payment? The way the law is written, any public works project, quote unquote, over $1,000 requires prevailing wage. In the past, some cities have tried to say, well, you know, so the project was $20 and we kicked in only $1,000, so only the amount that we chipped in should require prevailing wages, and the courts have printed definitively shot that down. If a city chips in over the prevailing wage threshold, the entire project...

4:32:29 Even if it's a lot more than the city paid becomes prevailing wage. More questions or comments? I'm just really confused now because what I'm hearing, and please correct me if I'm wrong, is that if any amount that gets paid, then we're in basically breach of contract on a, I mean, not breach of contract, but we're breaking a law. It is my opinion, after having looked at this a fair bit,

4:33:06 That if the town pays for this work, having failed to specify prevailing wages in advance and prevailing wage requirements not having been met, it's my opinion that the town would then be on the hook for penalties and interest if those are assessed. Okay. Well, you guys are digesting that. Any members of the public wishing to speak on this? Peter Bernasconi, resident of the Trails and civil engineer. I just want to kind of go back a little bit of history of drainage issues in town.

4:33:43 Just to kind of give a little history on this project where we are today. And it's unfortunate that El Dorado County asked the question regarding this normal prevailing wage, but apparently they have and there was an answer. So some of the questions that come up about the trails is that it was low-income housing and it was changed, but really it's workforce housing. 80% of the houses are occupied by people that live and work in the community. So it is workforce housing and that

4:34:14 In that regard, provides a great spot for, you know, families to be, raise their kids, and the trails, HOA is the one that's been shoveling snow so the kids can get to school easily rather than going out to the street. So that's a good, it's just a point of what the trails is as far as the community goes. The town, you know, was originally developed by the county, under the county guidelines. Drainage wasn't a

4:34:43 Big priority at that time. But the county did recognize that there's a big issue with drainage within the town of Mammoth Lakes and authorized and paid for a drainage study which identified most of the areas where we have major drainage problems. And once the town was incorporated, we used to get lots of complaints regarding drainage issues and erosion issues and flooding issues. Those included red fur,

4:35:13 Hidden Valley Road Area, Sierra Valley Sites, a couple of different areas there, the trails, the bluffs, and the town funded through a loan, drainage loan through DWR, repair of many of those, red fur portions of Sierra Valley Sites, Hidden Valley Road.

4:35:35 And the trails, it was in the 2000 drainage projects. So those projects took care of much of the drainage problems that was happening every year almost, where there would be either rain on snow or a heavy rain event that would cause flooding. So with the trails specifically, there was most, and the other issue that happened and happens is that when plan checks are done,

4:36:04 And it, you know, what happened in the county and it happened at the town is that there's, there was this underlying thought not to change the topography of the, of the land as little as possible, which then created all these homes that are below the street. So if you're on the, below the street, there's an opportunity to flood more, more than if you're not above the street. So if your house or your driveway, your garage is higher than the street level, you're not going to flood because the water will flow over the street.

4:36:33 Versus the homes we're talking about now are actually below the street and have the tendency to flood. So one of the areas in the trails, you know, there was flooding on an ongoing basis. There was complaints. Council directed staff to fix those issues. We hired IWA engineering. They provided some analysis. They designed the project.

4:37:01 For all these separate areas. And the drainage complaints went away because the drainage problem went away. In this case, so something changed. So there's a joint project between the town and the school district, partially funded with grant funding safe routes to school project. Other parts were funded by the school. I'm not sure what the differences are. But essentially, something changed. It sounds like it's...

4:37:28 going to be analyzed, but it really needs to be analyzed. It's not a lot of work to look at the precondition, the postcondition, and what might help it, you know, because it should be a passive change that doesn't require shoveling or any other aspect in general for, you know, small storms, especially that would just, it would be, it would operate without the active participation of anybody that's adjacent to the drainage problem.

4:37:58 So the major change really is, and I don't want to get very technical about it, but the time and concentration change, which increases the flow, needs to be attenuated. So there's several ways to do that. An engineer can do it. It's probably a 10 to 15 hour engineering study for somebody to analyze those conditions and provide some recommendations on what can fix it without having something that needs to take active management on an ongoing basis.

4:38:28 To take care of the problem. And that's generally what's happened. Like in Sierra Valley sites, part of it was completed and part of it wasn't, you know, there needs to be, there was like two phases done, another phase wasn't funded. So there's some additional work throughout the community to do on these drainage problems that need to be, you know, changed so that it's a passive.

4:38:54 process to manage the drainage flow versus an active one, which requires people to get out and move snow or move ice or clean culverts. So that's basically what I wanted to say, and I would ask that the engineering study be done so that, you know, a solution can be found. Thank you, Pete. E.L. Smudgen, President of the Trails Hummer Association.

4:39:36 First, let me say, we had a very contentious meeting here about a year ago. And I stood here and I said, the Trails is willing to shovel that easement because we don't have enough time at this point to do a study and come up with an engineering solution. I said, if the Trails does it, it'll save the town money because we won't have to pay for bailing wage. Nobody on the dais not to pound.

4:40:07 Lawyer, not Dan, not Grady, stood up and said, can't do that, you've got to pay preventive wage. After that meeting, John and I, kind of outside with Tony, had an agreement, we're going to make this work. So, we started shoveling. Now, we didn't have a problem this past winter, because we shoveled it every snowstorm. So, there was no issue, basically, it was shoveled.

4:40:40 But I want to just point out a few things that aren't exactly accurate with the thing Dan prepared. The first one says the year he shoveled is greater than anticipated or discussed with the town staff. Well, after the first year of flooding, when the spring came, snow was gone. I think Dan was there, but Grady and Haislip were there, and we stood facing east.

4:41:14 On the east side of Widing Wheel Road and said, this is where we really had to do the shoveling, which is implied here as additional work. And Haislip said, what do you want me to do? I can put a 12-foot wide, 6-foot deep culvert here and drain the water. I said, if that's what it takes, that's what you have to do, but I think that would be overkill. Let's see. But like I said.

4:41:47 Grady and I've walked, I think John and I've walked the whole easement, so there should be no doubt that we were shoveling the street, behind the street, behind the house, just north of Tony's. Tony's is where the easement comes down the side. It goes under wagon wheel, continues east until it disappears under wagon wheel again. Okay, the bill you got,

4:42:24 The $11,640 doesn't include any money for shoveling the school path. I have another invoice here I can leave where we paid $3,000 to shovel riding wheel road west to where the steps come. We build a town in this going south from that point and then going east from the other side of the street. And the prevailing way, I didn't bring, I have an email from the state labor relations.

4:43:05 There was no mention of any of this other stuff that licensed prevailing wage payers.

4:43:37 Have to do. And it implied like, okay, if he was paying prevailing wage, and we came and asked, did you pay for prevailing wage, he could prove it. End of story, game over. Everybody's happy. Unfortunately, I didn't bring it, but I think you have a copy. Grady sent me an email, copied to Dan, saying, hey, I'm satisfied with the prevailing wage. Dan, go ahead and work with paying the trails. Then closing,

4:44:09 There was a 5,000 number kicked around based on how much we were paying to shovel the school. We didn't have a contract. It was just an estimate. But my argument would be when the town used up its street snow removal budget and then kept having to shovel or blow the streets, remove snow, they kept doing it because they had to. You can't just quit.

4:44:40 And you can't say, well, since we ran over the budget, we're going to take money away from you because we didn't agree to pay the overtime, yada, yada, yada. So my point is we started shoveling with everybody's knowledge. We had to keep shoveling because it would make no sense to quit halfway through the winter when we got to some arbitrary number. So any questions I can answer? I mean, I think we had a gentleman's agreement.

4:45:15 The trails with the town to do what we did, and I think we performed as best we could under the circumstances. We had a hell of a winter. I mean, it was the biggest one ever. I might say Mayor Sauser and I had a meeting, and he mentioned that there was no flooding in the big year that Walker Canyon got washed out. He said he was at the school while that rain on snow happened.

4:45:48 And I say that makes my case because he hadn't changed the parking lot then. We didn't have problems then. We didn't have any problems until by coincidence the parking lot got changed, the drainage. And to one other point, we won't come back to you next year for anything because we're not going to do this pain again. We're not going to shovel it. If damage happens, people will sue the town.

4:46:20 But no damage happened because we had ski patrollers, we had neighbors, we had fire department out there shoveling. Otherwise there probably would have been damaged. There was water under two houses in one garage as it was. I beseech you to pay us. That's more than half of our total reserve that we have in the association. Thank you. Sandy Hogan and I don't live in the trails.

4:47:00 But I'll tell you as a citizen, it seems like this is the town's job to fix this, not keep putting it off. I sat through it last year, and if our homeowners association had to pay for dedicated easements and drainage and streets, our homeowners association would be broke, because we don't have, you know, we collect 20 a year. I mean, this is, these are town.

4:47:29 Town streets, town easements, town drainage. And I mean, I sat in this last year. I mean, why doesn't this go to the top when you have drainage problems? I mean, it just should. But your motion tonight, from what I heard Andy say, was to pay the bill. And if somebody comes down on you or them, then maybe your motion should say you would pay also.

4:47:57 The penalty and the interest. They may not even come down on you. But, you know, I mean, this is ridiculous for me as a citizen to sit through this each year. It's a town issue. Fix it. Sorry. Mr. Mayor, Town Council, Michelle Quersfield, resident. I'm a teacher here in Mammoth. My husband works on escape patrol. My house was directly affected the day that the storms happened. There were two. And I have...

4:48:35 Videos and pictures and all this. We left our jobs to come home and protect our house. Thank goodness we didn't have damage. I didn't know at the time that there was even the chance to come back to the town and try and recoup some of the losses we could have potentially had to the tune of thousands of dollars. Our house would have been destroyed if we weren't home. If I was the second homeowner, my house would have been flooded completely all the way into my house, six feet of water under my home.

4:49:04 That's if I wasn't home. But I was. And everybody mobilized in my neighborhood. Thank goodness they did. I live in a good neighborhood with hardworking people. We have people who are retired. We have people who are real estate agents. We have other teachers in the neighborhood. We have families. That trail that those kids walk that is such a liability is a joy. I mean, those kids, they love it. They park their bikes. They walk through.

4:49:30 It's pretty special that we have that. I totally understand where it's a liability. I think that needs to be looked into. We're not asking for a lot here, but what we are asking is for you to solve something that happened because I'm not going to get into it. It's a problem that needs to be solved. And I really hope that you look into this and try and solve it and even consider helping us this year as well. My husband and I are looking into the possibility of us paying someone to shovel.

4:49:57 Because we fear so much that our house will flood and we have so much to lose and we don't have a lot of money. I don't have people to go to to give me money to pay for the shoveling. It's going to come out of my hard work and savings that we had for our retirement. I don't know what else to do. But the truth is the neighborhood in the trails, we open our doors for kids. They trick a treat. We use our own money to pay for candy. The town is willing to close.

4:50:25 The trail's down. People put a bin at the market. That's wonderful. But why should we do that? We do that because we care about living here. We care about the people in our town. We love the children in our town. All we're asking is for us to be treated with a little respect here, the respect that we did this honorably and based on a lot of discussions with these people in this room. We may not have it in writing, but it was an agreement that we had. And one of the agreements was that we would back off.

4:50:55 Not come to town council meetings to drop our legal arm, which we did. We respected that. We did what was asked. We're real people here, and we're just asking for a little help. Thank you. Anything else from the public? I will bring it back to the... I have questions. Yes, ask. I just want to know...

4:51:30 Would the school district have to pay prevailing wage? Because, and I know you said we can't talk about the drainage, but I just, from research over a couple of years, I do feel that some of the culpability is on the school district. Are they under the same rules for this? They would be. Yes. Okay.

4:51:55 And then if you could just walk us through also because the one thing is that I think it needs to be clarified if that what type of easement that it is because I'm not comfortable with the liability issue if it is if it's not a pedestrian easement and it's just a drainage easement and I sit here and knowingly

4:52:22 Do something that perpetuates a pedestrian easement, I think I'm not doing my job. It is not a pedestrian easement. It's a drainage easement only. Okay, thank you. No more questions at this time. John? So we need to speak within the parameters of the item that is in front of us. That being said,

4:52:54 I have been involved with Yale and others about trying to move this forward and get to a solution. And I will say that progress has been made. I am disappointed, frankly, with the town staff that it's going slower than it needs to. I believe things could be moving quicker. However, I believe we've made progress. I believe we're engineering issues, other things.

4:53:21 Issues, discussions about easements, we're getting there. Not as quickly as I would like, personally. But I need to represent to the Council that in my involvement with this, that the representations about prevailing wage was consistently made. And I've learned from my own personal difficult experience that this prevailing wage issue is enormously complicated. And it is not a space.

4:53:50 That you can wander into and have a like a citizen's engagement with this stuff. It's it is really complicated and it's Baroque and it's dealing with issues happening the rest of the state that doesn't affect us. But there's a lot of interest. They're interested in doing this. My recommendation to resolve this would be twofold. One is I'm entirely comfortable with the town.

4:54:20 Paying up to $5,000 as we originally agreed to. But I would need, and it sounds like, that the contractor, before we make a payment and before we expose the town to legal jeopardy, if the contractor could make the appropriate representations to our lawyer so that we know, because we had a discussion with this about the fuels group in the lake space and needed some more money to do.

4:54:44 Stuff they're doing up there. If the town puts money into something, it changes the color of the whole thing. And that could expose liabilities unknown to all of us that we don't want to get into. So if we can get to the contractor, have the contractor satisfy the things that Andy's talking about, which it sounds like it's not hard to do. Well, go ahead. So I'm looking at the prevailing wage rates for laborers, which is the classification for this. The basic hourly rate is $35 and change.

4:55:13 But then there's another $22.54 an hour worth of ancillary payments. So if the contractor paid a wage of $60 an hour, that's great, over-prevailing wage, except the contractor would still then be required to have paid the $22.50 in other stuff. So if we're asking the contractor to go back and make that $22.54 extra payment, the invoice is going to go up a fair bit.

4:55:42 Well, okay, this is the nature of this world of prevailing wages. It's technical, it's complicated, and it's got lawyers all over it. However, I would still put forward, if we can satisfy to make sure that the money we would put into this is not going to bring any liability to the town or any liability to you guys, then let's go ahead, pay $5,000, and let's keep the process moving forward. Why $5,000? Why would you be half pregnant?

4:56:11 Well, because that was the amount, that was the representation from the council, I believe, was we were willing to pay up to $5,000. And so I'm comfortable being in that area. But again, it's a cautionary tale about prevailing wage stuff. And it was repeatedly... Hang on, hang on, hang on. Let's not talk back and forth. If we need to ask more questions, then we will go back to... I can just share with the council that it was, the town staff consistently advised...

4:56:40 That this needs to be, this needs to work in the prevailing wage universe. And so I, there was no, from my perspective, there was no misunderstanding about that. Okay. Linda. No questions right now. I'm good for right now. I think we need to, we need to resolve this. And I think Pete Beresconi was saying, hey, we need this to be engineered. We need it to be fixed.

4:57:11 Rather than shoveling and everything else. So if this needs to be redesigned and redone, however, I mean, we need to have... It's not what we can deal with tonight. Tonight, the item before of us is how much... Fine, put it on the agenda. We're having an engineering group look at it. We don't necessarily agree that it's broke, but we're having it looked at, and if there is fixes, we'll bring that back. Yes. That is being worked on.

4:57:39 A fix as a... Yeah, but let's not dwell on this, guys. So let me ask the town manager, what did we agree to in regards to this payment? We had talked about this level up to $5,000. That number was out there. We did not necessarily agree to say, I'm sorry, we didn't say, shovel whatever and we'll pay it. That was not the discussion. I do understand the perspective of the homeowners.

4:58:08 And we did have the question of a propelling wage issue. From a pure staff perspective, even up to that, this isn't work that we've authorized that we would have done this last year. But that be as it may, the question before you is this is here. And if we paid $5,000, yeah, we're taking a risk there. And if you direct us to do that, we would go make it. Council has the authority to pay the... You can pay the full thing if you so directed us, yes. Legally?

4:58:40 You can legally pay it. You do have a legal obligation if it's challenged in terms of prevailing wage. Actually, we do and the contractor may as well. Will somebody challenge it? We do not know. Andy, your feedback? I think Dan's accurately summarized it. You can pay it and if there's any exposure, we'll end up wearing it. Don't give an hour number here. Okay, Linda? So there's no way then that we can

4:59:19 As we suggested, know beforehand, before we hand this money, whether or not this would meet the approval for prevailing wage. Well, you could, if you were so inclined, authorize payment contingent on having received assurances, as Councilmember Wentworth suggested, that the prevailing wage laws have been complied with, which will require the contractor to go back,

4:59:50 I mean, certainly that would be prudent. I mean, just looking at...

5:00:19 At the bill, it looks like, so it's $11,640 divided by, well, it's 194 hours. So the contractor, in order to comply with the permanent wage laws, would have to go back and pay $194 times $22.54. Right. So if the contractor is told to do that, he's going to cheerfully present a bill for just over $4,000 to the HOA.

5:00:51 All that being said, if we go back a year ago and we dealt with this last time, my position then was, I don't believe in a normal winter this needs to be shoveled. I, to this day, believe that. It was shoveled and there was some talk about us paying some portion. So while I don't believe it was necessary last year, I think it is necessary in a rain on snow event. It's necessary all over town whether our drainage is up to snuff or not.

5:01:18 And we have seen to it that that happens along with family and friends. That is what Mammoth is all about. When I have a need, believe me, I've got a whole crew of people I call on. I would be comfortable with John's suggestion, just in the name of fair play, I suppose, of doing up to the 5,000, providing it is not going to kick everything with his caveat. Just to review the numbers.

5:01:50 If we give the HOA 5,000, but we require them to make their contractor go back and make all those back payments, it will increase their costs by about 4,000. I understand that would be a wash, but that's why it is contingent upon finding out if it's going to do that or not. No, but then won't it bump it over the 15,000 mark, and what happens with that? That's a whole other issue. I would hope that DIR would understand this was an inadvertent mistake.

5:02:19 They would not require the contractor to have been not licensed, but registered. There are things I still don't know. They were billed for a certain number of hours, and they were billed at, what, $60 an hour. Right. How many shovelers were there? And how much profit is taken out prior to the shovelers getting paid? So at this point, we actually have no idea whether or not... So that's why John's potential motion in that if it is not going to kick...

5:02:49 This $5,000 is equitable in my mind. And so just to add to that, I think you're on the right track here, which is I think that we don't have enough information in the invoice to really make a representation as to whether it's conforming or not. And so I think without us having any specific technical knowledge, we're willing to do up to $5,000, but have a conversation with whoever and figure out if this thing is conforming or not.

5:03:18 I'm indulging the mayor. Can we do like a 10-minute break? Yeah. We will recess for 7.75 minutes. I'm going to wrap my head around this for a second. We will gavel this back to order, please. All right, so thank you. Just looking at other options to try to address this about the prevailing wage, talking to yell about it. I think we have a, without a whole lot of detail, I think we have a way forward to address this.

5:04:31 It'd be more under a settlement agreement type approach to the issue that we can work through. Talked it to Andy. So at this point, you would need no action this evening. And we would sit back down with the HOA and work this forward. Probably in the parameters as discussed this evening, but it would not need to come back to the council necessarily. Well, it's up to you. Come back on consent. So if you authorize us to...

5:05:02 Settled. So moved. Move forward. So wait, one thing. Yeah. Because Dan's extremely creative and brilliant approach isn't paying the HOA for shoveling. Correct. I don't, I'm not sure that you, it's not on the agenda for tonight. So I would suggest that we work something up and then bring it back probably just on the consent calendar. Okay, thank you all for that.

5:05:34 Moving on to provide council position on proposed resolutions. Oh, man, this is me. It's been so long since I looked at them now I don't even remember. So this... Two issues. Yeah, this is... Every year I am the representative for... Let's wait a minute here. Okay, so bringing this back. Every year as your league representative, as you voted me in, I go to the...

5:06:18 Congress, our convention, whatever we want to call it, and vote on the two resolutions that they bring forward every year. Since I've been doing this, they've never brought more than two forward, and sometimes they deal with things that we care about, and sometimes they don't. But I always show up and raise my hand as directed by my fellow council members. So what we're looking at this year are two resolutions.

5:06:44 One, calling upon the Public Utility Commission to expand the Rule 20A program for undergrounding overhead utilities to include projects in high fire hazard severity zones. How appropriate tonight that we deal with this. Yeah, my position is that we would, of course, vote yes on this, but do we need to vote or is consensus good, Dan? I think consensus probably gets us what we want. Yeah. Yes.

5:07:11 So I would be looking at your consensus on Resolution 1? Yep, yep. Okay, so we will now move on to Resolution 2, which has absolutely nothing to do with us, but is a feud between the Mexican and the U.S. and the California and the Arizona and everybody else on water flows in certain rivers and streams, and it has to do with it coming back as it goes from Mexico back into the U.S., horrifically polluted.

5:07:40 Of course, if we allowed all the water to flow through it that should flow through it, would it still be horrifically polluted? We don't know. But I see no reason not to vote for it any time we can increase water quality and those sorts of things. It's always a good thing. Okay, so I have what I need there. I will vote yes on both of those. There's a whole list of other cities that have written positions on this.

5:08:14 17 is consider restructuring of town staffing, including adding three new positions and funding plan. Dan. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Dan, shorter than normal. Correct. You have a staff report that outlines the proposal to fund three additional positions within the town's budget for this current year, one being an equipment mechanic trainee, the funding would be out of our

5:08:41 Revenues that we receive are dedicated for ESTA. The primary work for that trainee would be on the ESTA buses. We need additional maintenance work, and this would invite us to staff to do so. Parks maintenance worker is a result of a number of movements of bodies within the Public Works Department. It is funded primarily out of a reduction in part-time staff, so there's a no-net cost increase for that position. It's shifting around the current bodies. The request for an additional

5:09:11 Police officer position goes back to looking at moving Council Gold forward through a negotiation process to move as soon as possible, frankly, with additional positions so we can move to a 24-7 coverage component with the police department. The addition of this police officer will do that. It will give us that additional body we need for that coverage. And the funding for that will be a budget amendment, but utilizing

5:09:42 Cannabis tax revenues that are coming in much stronger than within the budget. One of the uses in the sample of uses that we put out to the voters when they approved that tax was that public safety would be one area for consideration of funding. So to do that, we would have those things going forward. We note the public works maintenance worker as a title will have a full-time position that's funded.

5:10:07 Currently, as a hybrid position, it would be 100% public works maintenance worker, so in lieu of hybrid, we'd have a different title as all for that position, but there's no funding related to it being requested. This really allows us to step up and meet a number of areas and some core service areas within the town. I'm glad to answer any questions. Okay, questions and or comments. No questions. I do have a question. I did receive...

5:10:37 Some communication on this with a question that I think I'm sorry here that I would like to look at funding the mechanics position from other sources stating that we don't have transit services in some areas like Old Mammoth that there will be additional transit services in the parcel in the future.

5:11:04 And if there's extra funding in TOT transit account, maybe it'd be better to look at setting up a reserve account for future and current service needs. Some ideas would be to fund the mechanic position from public works funding, charge ESTA directly for services rendered, set up a reimbursable account with ESTA.

5:11:26 Have S to fund the position directly from S to funds. And I think the basis of this is just funding permanent positions from the transit fees. So I thought that was a very good point. So fire away. All right. I can respond to that. Thank you.

5:11:45 The reason we're recommending actually to pay it from the ESTA fees and the TOT revenue fees that we actually have dedicated to transit is actually so we reduce the cost to ESTA in their operations. The shop rate that they pay is $108 an hour for work on their buses. If we fund this position from somewhere else and their primary job will be working on the buses, then this will cost ESTA.

5:12:09 $108 an hour for basically 2,000 hours a year of work. They'll actually be paying more. Our request for them to pay it directly out of that as a need for preventive maintenance on the buses. To the extent that this person is working on those and that there would be no labor billing to ESTA. Now, if we have to buy parts, tires, brakes, et cetera, we would be charging for parts because that would be a normal cost regardless.

5:12:36 But the labor component that normally would run a higher rate plus parts would not be charged to Estes. It would not increase their cost, which in turn, if we did that, it turns around and that charge would mean we would probably increase our contract rate. And so the same dollars we're talking about would pay for those services to a contract at a higher rate. So it would cost us more not to fund it out of here, bottom line.

5:13:03 Or we don't have to provide the quality of service that they're asking us to provide, which I think would be a mistake, just from a liability standpoint. Okay. So I hope that is right to have clarity. Well, it just, what I heard you say is that, yes, it's still, it would just cost them more, and that money would still be coming out of the transit reserves. Correct. Anyway. Correct. We'd be paying more out of the same pot. Okay. Good explanation, then. Thank you.

5:13:35 Any other questions? Comments? No, I'm prepared to make a motion. Do we have a public comment? Looks like I'm kind of quiet here, huh? Right, Measure A funding for transit was for free transit services in our community, not for staffing of mechanics.

5:14:04 Not for other things. I mean, it was for free transit services, and we are not providing that to all of our people in this town. Stacey Corliss has spoken to this to an awful lot. We know we need expansion of services in other areas. And one thing I heard from the very beginning was that, you know, we shouldn't be staffing positions. I frankly used to worry.

5:14:32 When we were first starting and I was on mobility and the ESTA contract was, frankly, we were paying for some of our staffing out of that and it used to worry me a lot because we shouldn't have been. It was somebody that was a department head and another department anyway. But the services should, it should be free.

5:15:00 And it should be for our citizens, not just to start hiring mechanics, because once we go down that route, ESTA is a separate board. I'm speaking also members of the LTC. ESTA, the JPA, gets money from local transportation funding. The town executes a contract with ESTA to provide certain services. It doesn't provide winter service. Actually, Mammoth Mountain executes a contract with ESTA.

5:15:31 To provide most of our winter service. The Reds Meadow Shuttle, the Forest Service, executes a contract with ESTA for that all in the summer. So we are one of three players within town. And of course, Reds is not free. But I guess what I'm saying is I don't like the idea of us going down that road. There is no transit reserve right now that I know of. Yes, there is. Is there much above the contract?

5:16:02 I guess we can look back and find that out. The fact is, then let's put more in there. The parcel is going to need transit. And Old Mammoth needs transit. And we know that. And Phil says that. But the problem is right now he's having trouble hiring staff. A lot of it because of drug testing and lots of other stuff. The mountain's having the same problems, whatever. Sooner or later that will be, you know, that'll level out.

5:16:31 But I guess what I'm just saying, let's provide the services that we promise people first. I don't care if it costs ESTA more. They're going to get more from the LTF, from the LTC, from other. They can raise fares elsewhere, you know. I mean, we're fare-free, and that's what we promised.

5:16:54 So, frankly, in other words, let the ESTA Board struggle with that. You guys are on ESTA, and if it costs a bit more, it'll cost a bit more. But, yeah, if I may on that, we do have funds in the ESTA Reserve component to fund this position, and ongoing revenue as we look at next year's budget, it would be built into that current revenue. The element here, I'd say where the cost lasts right now.

5:17:21 Like this winter, we fell behind on bus maintenance, which means we cannot provide the level of service that we need to provide. It'd be pretty easy to go to Eston and say, we're going to bring another mechanic on, so we're going to, right now, if we're billing you, I don't know the number, $200,000 or $300,000 a year for mechanic service, it's going to go up another $30,000 or $2,000 times $108,000, so you can do the math. Equivalent dollars.

5:17:51 For them to have their buses maintained. We have a contract with them for maintenance. We can charge them. They will not be able to make those payments. We will not maintain those buses and the service levels we provide will go down. They'll still be free, but it'll be less service because the cost will go up per hourly rate for what they can do. So it doesn't quite...

5:18:15 I understand what you're saying. So what you're asking us to do is not meet the maintenance requirements of the buses. They've actually increased that requirement, the number of hours of operation before they get inspected, which is the right thing to do. We don't have the current staffing to meet that requirement. We can do that. We will charge S to more. They will come back and say, great, we have to raise our rates, and we don't have the contract to do that, so we'll say cut the hours.

5:18:44 We don't want to reduce the level of services we're providing to our community, or we have to rehab another evaluation to go back and say, are we going to charge for services? In the wintertime. They may contract with somebody else. Maybe they'll contract with them. Whoa, I'm going to cut this off. Thank you. Yeah, I know. What we have is an argument going back and forth. I know, I know. And I'm just saying, keep our promises through Measure A for free transit services, too. That's what we're doing. That's what I'm saying. Sandy, thank you.

5:19:12 Don't start staffing mechanics. Anyway. Mr. Mayor, if I could, having listened to this, I'm inclined to go with the recommendation of the town manager. With that being said, I would make a motion if you're willing to entertain one. Let's go through comments first. I had a question. Is this a one-year funding from these funds, or would it be ongoing every year? The idea would be that it's an ongoing position we will need to meet the maintenance requirements on the buses. Our goal next year would try to build it into the ESTA.

5:19:43 Our transit budget, but not increase the charges to ESTA, otherwise we just have to like triple our budget in order to meet that same requirements. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions? Comments? This whole transit fund comes from 1% of TOT according to what was moved on. It comes from 1% in fees. That's where the dollars would be coming from. Yeah. And so...

5:20:11 We have about $1.3 million annually in the last four years, five years. And we're saying that we can't find that? No, see, that's what's going to help fund this position. Okay. So it's a political commitment we're keeping. Correct. Yeah, my take on this is exactly that. If this is a dedicated position for bus maintenance, then we are not only living up to the obligation,

5:20:40 We are enhancing the obligation for free. So as long as when that person is working on the buses, we are not charging the 108 an hour, then it is actually money saving for both us and ESTA. And if we can do that and then expand our services as well, I'm very comfortable with it. So John, I would now entertain the motion. Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

5:21:05 I would move that the Town Council approve funding for addition of the following positions, equipment, mechanic, trainee, parks, maintenance, worker, police officer, public works, maintenance worker as described in the agenda item. I second the motion. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.

5:21:35 Moving on to number 18, Discussion and Direction on Structured Goals and Expectations for October 9th Joint Town Council and Planic Economic and Development Commission meeting. I have to recuse myself from this as this deals specifically with the parcel. So because I have a conflict of property being too close, I will turn it over to Pro Tem. And if you would take it all in the other room so I don't have to move.

5:22:09 Sorry, we're staying here. Okay. Okay, let's go ahead and have a discussion direction on structure goals, expectations for this meeting. Sandra, I think you're going to talk to us about this.

5:22:26 Yes, I have a quick 30-minute presentation to start. Briefly, we did email out the expectations for Town Council and PDC meeting. I have extra copies in case any of the council members don't have this. But this is a document that Grady prepared just to kind of run through what our expectations are going into this meeting. So we have kind of a summary of the agenda and then of the points that we think we're going to be covering as we walk through the alternatives.

5:22:55 Page 2 kind of has the meat of the agenda and really kind of I think the details will be hashed out during the Town Council and PEDC question and answer session. So we're going to walk through each of the alternatives and then talk about the components of each alternatives as we go through them. So giving the Council and the Commission an opportunity to provide feedback on those alternatives as we walk through them.

5:23:21 Okay. Is there another hard copy somewhere around here? Yes. Because I have a mobile copy, but my eyes aren't going to see it right now. Cleland, you grab me one. Yeah. I'll take two. Oh, thank you for that. Oh, no, I already gave them. Oh, thank you. Getting punchy at this late hour. Okay.

5:23:48 So just kind of coming back, looking at each alternative, alternative one, two, and three, looking at the number of units, number of stories, how we're treating mill ditch in each of those alternatives, the parking and the funding gap. So to get the feedback from the council and the commission. And our goal through that process is to take the information that we hear on October 9th and put that into one single preferred plan, which will be presented to the council and the commission on December 11th.

5:24:17 And we would hope that the Council and Commission can accept that plan on December 11th, and then we can move forward with...

5:24:26 Working with the developer to move this process forward. And just a side note, on the developer, we will have an outline of our RFQ in the packet for next week. So you will be able to see kind of what we're looking for. It won't be the full RFQ, but we will have that available. With that, I'm happy to talk through any questions that you have or answer any questions about the handout that I provided. Okay, any council members have questions for Sandra?

5:24:56 A couple just quick things. One is I just got this yesterday and I just I've not had time to do what I need to do. So I'm going to take this and reconcile this against what's in the alternatives and prepare some stuff. Happy to hear about the RFQ. That's good. I have a concern that LWC in some of our previous meeting with the PEDC, I had a sense of a certain heavy handedness.

5:25:24 From Jen Daugherty as she's leading the discussion. I appreciated her trying to keep everybody on task, but I think it precluded a kind of openness of discussion, and I would appreciate if you would maybe share that with them so we're not in a super regimented, these are the only things we're going to talk about. I will have one thought, one idea that I've shared with you about

5:25:47 That whatever the alternative is, and we're not going to discuss about this tonight, but that we start to examine how do we, in the most expeditious manner possible, provide housing through this piece of property. Whether it's trailers, tiny homes, whatever it is, that that be, and that's not on this list anywhere, and I don't know where I would sneak that in.

5:26:10 But that's one idea that I would, just giving you a heads up, I want to bring that forward. The rest of it I have to do my due diligence. Sort of in that gap period between now and... Just when, to do an analysis to say what is the most expeditious way we could get housing on this property that doesn't preclude anything happening with the further development of the property, but we can get people on that property living there absolutely as expeditiously as possible. So those are my thoughts.

5:26:39 Madam Mayor, do I call you Madam Mayor Pro Tem or just Madam? Just, hello. Do I call you Madam? I get a look on that one, yeah. No, I'm great, thank you. Of course, my concern is the finances, you know, and so on number 11, the financial implication cost, the team is working to identify costs moving forward.

5:27:04 Entitlement design and all of that. So, I mean, it would be nice to see all the funding tools that we might be able to have. I know Ayman Novin did present a very brief presentation at the very last meeting, but we haven't had a discussion on that as to implementing any of those things.

5:27:27 According to Ivan, he said that we're looking at a $60 to $66 million gap for the parcel. So I think we need to get this out in front of the public, and if we're going to use some funding tool, we need to start educating the public as to what we're doing and why. And within the scope of this meeting, number 12 also deals with the funding issues, 11 and 12. Yes, I agree. 11 and 12.

5:27:55 Should be at the top of the list. Are there any comments from the public? No. All right. Moving on. Sandra, anything else to add to this at this point? I don't have anything else. I would just encourage the council members...

5:28:11 Even after this meeting, if you think of something, if you want to make sure we hit on it, please email me, let us know. We'll make sure we talk about it. And we're really looking forward to the meeting next week and, you know, productive meeting and kind of walking through all this and getting to some answers. I think your point about being well prepared to have that conversation is really important. Planning Commission is going to come to the table, you know, ready to talk about this stuff. I think we can do the same and really, you know, get...

5:28:39 Move along on this. This is an opportunity to do that, and I think we need to be ready to go. And we're happy to meet with the council members. I've sent a number of different emails out to you and to the commissioners, but we're happy to meet with you in advance of October 9th if you'd like to kind of just talk through alternatives, don't quite understand what each the difference is. We can kind of walk through a high level on the alternatives, answer any detailed questions that you have, and we've done that with a number of council members and commissioners at this point.

5:29:06 I also have a concern, and I expressed it with the council, and I think I've gotten some support, all the different funding things that we need. We talked about $12 million, and I don't know what our share is, the town, on the communications network that we need between the town, the fire district, and all the different other agencies. So we need to have this discussion in relationship to the budget shortfall on the parcel.

5:29:36 Oh, I'm sorry. Do I need to make a motion or is this a consensus? No, just a discussion. I mean, the whole idea, if we're missing something, tell us if you want to discuss that evening. That would really be helpful that afternoon. These are items that have come up in a variety of discussion points that we believe need to get discussed by the policymaking bodies so we can help. If we're missing something, let's...

5:30:04 The only question I had was we have public comment down after sort of the presentation alternatives. Did you, was there any reason to have that earlier or is that intentional? We just started, we really want to have the policy discussion, but through that, I mean, if they're, you're running the meeting, if you wish to take public comment somewhere else, that'll be up to you. We'll have it on the front end for nothing that's on the agenda. Okay.

5:30:31 How much debate and discussion do you want to have to pause us? Okay, here's where we're going. Do you want to give us input now? Or you can take it through the process. But you do have to take public comment before you make a decision. Right. Absolutely.

5:30:44 And then are we going to share any results from the online survey? Yes. Okay. Was that in here? I somehow didn't. It's not in here, but in your packet tomorrow that will be sent out tomorrow, we'll have the PowerPoint. So you'll have all of the information in advance. And so the PowerPoint does have all of that, and the staff report will have that too. Do you want to incorporate public comment as an item specifically versus just picking it up as part of a normal meeting?

5:31:14 So the people know they're going to have, at minimum, they're going to have a spot on the agenda to talk. And then after that would be final discussions and direction. And just another note that October 9th, we'll take all of that information, bring it back to you on December 11th. And it doesn't mean that on December 11th you can't say, wait, we want to do this different, that different. So there is kind of a second bite at the apple on December 11th. This is not the final whatever, can't ever change our mind decision. Yeah, yeah. Not that there will be one of those. Right, right. Okay.

5:31:44 And what time does that meeting start again? One o'clock. One o'clock, okay. One last thing, if we can get a, there's 82 people, you know, individual families on the Mammoth Lake Housing wait list. You know, a profile of them, because that might be, if we do the parcel in phases, we might want to look at that. And then the other part of it, I think, is that Mammoth Mountain has, in the past,

5:32:12 Tom Hodges has suggested looking at, you know, their acre or doing something. And I think we need to at least reach out and say, do you want to follow up? I mean, you know, because they might want to do something on the backside of it if we're working on the front side of it. Hey, just direction, if there's no other items and stuff for that, please review the information here and review the...

5:32:51 Alternatives and ready for hopefully what will be a fairly robust discussion with the Planning Commission. Excellent. Okay. If we're done with that item, then why don't we bring Mayor Sauser back into the Council. Can we start doing Councilmember reports now before we get back? Kirk, want to start? Mammoth Lake Housing had its evaluation of its Executive Director. You can do it. I had to shift.

5:33:21 Executive Director, and so we're going through a process of evaluating Patricia, and I think that went well. Things are going well with the outreach and with managing the list and moving forward on the Alpers property, Sierra Manor, and so that might be 11 units. We won't know if we get the CDBG grant for $3 million.

5:33:49 Three million to rehab the entire building. We should find that out within the next two months. And nothing to report. Nothing to report. September 20th, I journeyed to that technical advisory council I serve on, climate change with OPR. Very interesting day as usual. But became aware of something called Regions Rising Together, which is the governor's initiative to connect all the regions.

5:34:23 In the state to the state. And our time will come. Their focus now is on Riverside, on the Inland Empire and the Central Valley. That's where it's kind of kicking off in those two regions. But at some point, they're going to come knocking here. We're going to be knocking with them. It's a good way to get us connected to the resources of the state. I attended the kickoff meeting for the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative, but I want to advise my council members I am not there as a representative of the town council of the town.

5:34:51 I'm there in my capacity with MLTPA. So please do not, I won't give any reports here on that in the future. So the town thinks sometimes staff shows up and all the rest of it. So I'll leave it at that. And you can talk to Dan about that if you need to. And then September 27th, I met with Carl Roboto, who's doing some work on their destination framework. Had a good conversation with Carl. I hope you guys have a chance to meet with him as well. Yeah, I already met with him. It was good. Yeah, good.

5:35:20 So is that appropriate, I hope, what I said? Okay, good. Thank you. I left town the day after our last staff, or our last council meeting, I got back yesterday, so. She did nothing of any value. I did nothing, absolutely nothing. Dang. And, but I did want to bring up a topic around the tobacco. The, you know, if you were aware, the county had put in their flavor ban, which expires the end of, well.

5:35:49 The end of October. It will sunset. And so what they're going to do with that, how they're going to proceed, and how this council is prepared to discuss that. The idea of a like ordinance here in Mammoth as in a tandem sort of with the county and what that might be looking like. Dan, I know, has been meeting with Dr. Boo. Dan, did you want to give a little...

5:36:14 I'll keep it real short and sweet. Yeah, we've met with Dr. Boo and the police department's been working on it. What I would propose if it's, I'm going to look for head nods, is we'd bring an item back on November 6th for discussion and then get direction. Then we'd come back after that with a revised ordinance for consideration for adoption, but probably start off basically with the current county ordinance as a place to start from. You can modify it as you wish. So it'd be like a three-step process with a...

5:36:44 Discussion, introduction, and adoption if that's where you want to go. There's some other policy issues we'll have to walk through with that. But just if you want to see it is all I'm asking for tonight just for a future agenda item. Kind of based off the county? Yeah. Correct? Okay.

5:36:58 Excuse me, I did have something to report. Oh, good. Thanks to that, on September 19th, I did attend the Town County Liaison Meeting, and we did talk about that issue with the county as well as we talked a lot about waste. And it was a great meeting. We're not going to have... Pardon? About waste? About waste. Yes. My waste, your waste. Yeah. And...

5:37:28 Just the post-closure monitoring times and all sorts of fun things. And then also we did talk about the MOU after the meeting with Madera County. So I'll leave it at that. Okay. Thank you. I forgot about that. Any other reports? Seeing none, I will now adjourn this open session and move into closed session.

5:38:01 Adios, muchachos.