TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2011

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 3 hr 25 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

429 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 All right. We will call the meeting of Mammoth Lakes Planning Commission February 9th to order. And if you'll please rise and join Commissioner Tanney in the Pledge of Allegiance. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, under God, nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:30 Can I have a roll call, please? I was distracted. I'm sorry. Here. Here. Here. All right. Thank you for that. All right. We will now go to reports from the commission. And Commissioner Clark? Yes. I have visited both Green Mountain.

0:58 New business on January 26th, and Mammoth Lakes Wellness on February 2nd. These were new businesses that we just approved the projects a couple of months ago, and I was interested in seeing if they complied with all we ask. They did. Great. Thank you. That's it. Commissioner Ratani?

1:19 Yes, I have a few. I just want to say again what a great job the Lutheran Church did with their paint job. You know, they laugh at us about being fussy about colors and stuff. In fact, I wasn't even sure that color scheme was going to work. And paint costs the same no matter what color it is. And when the right colors were chosen, it's a huge, huge improvement. That's true. I did twist your own on that one. I know you did. But anyway, I'm glad you did because it turned out beautifully.

1:43 I'd like to commend the mountain on the Ski Back Bridge. If you haven't seen it yet, drive up to the village and look at it. It is an instant classic. It is just very, very well done. I'm very happy to see it. I'd also like to commend Fireside Condos on their rehab. They've done a very good job with that. It's not only a big improvement, it looks good in itself. And I would like to say that our neighbors just visited Steamboat.

2:07 And I was sad hearing their description of their wonderful long weekend skiing with family because Steamboat has a walkable downtown with 12 foot wide sidewalks. And they said how nice it was to be able to walk on the 12 foot wide sidewalks with all the people who were visiting. That's all I have to say. Thank you. And I'll just add in for the public and those here in the audience. I believe it is Friday at 11 a.m. is the ribbon cutting for the ski back rail. So it's a great thing and a great thing the mountain got it done in the community.

2:36 It's beautiful. One thing, yesterday I attended a meeting of the, of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. It was a presentation by Hornal Anderson Design, which is the same firm that did the, the branding exercise for the Mammoth, for the mountain a few years ago. And they have, they presented two preliminary options for designs for branding for the town. It was interesting to see.

3:05 I can't say too much about them because it's in a preliminary stage and it didn't want anything released about it outside of the meeting. But it's an interesting exercise to see presented. You said two options? Yes. Great. Okay. Now I just wanted to share with the commission and staff, over the next six weeks, starting this coming week, I'm going to be out of town quite a bit for some health-related issues. So just for the commission, I am trying to schedule everything when it's not during our meetings.

3:37 But if I'm not able to, then I probably will miss a few meetings over the next six weeks. And as for zoning and that, I think I can call in, and so I'll get that scheduled with SAP. But I'll work with Mark, and I'll let him let you know if any meetings I won't be able to be in. All right, then. We will move on to comments from the public. Anyone wishing to address the commission on anything not on today's agenda? Ellen.

4:06 Just wanted to take the opportunity to announce a couple of upcoming public meetings that we hope to get people to come to. The first is on Wednesday, February 23rd. We're having a public workshop and listening session with the Planning Commission for the Sierra Valley Sides. This is the first meeting that will kick off the district planning process. Really a chance to hear issues from folks that live in the Sierra Valley Sides, people that care about

4:34 about that neighborhood and really have a very open meeting to hear the various issues and concerns that we'll be looking at in the district planning process. Again, that's on Wednesday, February 23rd, starting at 5 here. The second meeting to announce is happening the following day on Thursday, the 24th, also starting at 5, which is the first public workshop for the South District's neighborhood district plan. We went through the framework process with you.

5:02 And yesterday had a very productive meeting with the focus group for that project. And we'll be taking similar materials, looking at issues, opportunities, constraints, and looking at preliminary concepts for the area at that meeting on the 24th. We're going to ask Thursday, the 24th, we'll be having that meeting for the South District. As we're hearing in the paper, we're hoping to get, particularly for the Sierra Valley sites.

5:29 Workshop word out through neighbors and putting up flyers around town and so on to get good attendance at that meeting. My public comment, thank you. Thank you, Alan. Anyone else wishing to address the commission? All right, we do have another public comment time at the end of the meeting if anything comes up for you. All right, with that, we'll move on. We have no presentations today. It takes us into our consent agenda, which is the minutes of January 26, 2011 meeting. Are there any comments, changes, or emotion?

6:01 I have a correction. Page 1. And we just simply need to eliminate one sentence. She said that she had driven Tamarack Road under add this discussion to the next agenda. That little sentence has caused us some difficulty, but I didn't just say it there. It was a part of a correction on the next page.

6:30 So just eliminate that sentence, please. She said that she had driven that. Yes, I had done that in the prior meeting. And if there are no other corrections, I move we approve. Are there any? I move we approve the minutes with that correction. I'll second. All in favor? Aye. All right then, we can move on to, we have no public hearings today, so it takes us into business matters.

7:00 First of which is our zoning code update workshop. This is on our sign chapter. It's a very big chapter. We've got a lot of work going on with our zoning code users group. Again, for the public, Jay and I do sit on that group along with Bruce Woodward, Dave Harvey, Jim Smith, Bill Taylor. Oh, and Mary Handel from Mammoth View Britannia Properties.

7:32 So with that, we will open this up and Jen, welcome. Thank you. Thank you, Chair Barrett. As Tony mentioned, this draft sign chapter is a comprehensive update to the town's sign regulations to reflect and support the town's goals of being more progressive with our regulations and more business friendly. The draft standards are also proposed.

8:00 to meet the community design goals as well as economic development goals. A workshop will also be held with Town Council next Wednesday the 16th at 6 p.m. in similar format and content. The input and recommendations from the Planning Commission and public today will be forwarded on to Town Council for their consideration and discussion.

8:22 Legal review is also underway for this chapter, and we anticipate that there will be revisions from that legal review to the verbiage in the draft chapter. After these workshops and the legal review is complete, we will conclude the CEQA review, which is underway. We anticipate that will be a NEGDAC or mitigated NEGDAC, which will be completed prior to the public hearings on this draft chapter. With that, I'd like to start with a presentation on design intent.

8:51 that helped us draft these standards. For the members of the audience, just so you know, we are going to take public comment during this too. It is a business matter, but it's important to hear from you, so we will take those comments before we deliberate or discuss anything. I think Mark's back there. For the basics of what a sign purpose is, signs include commercial signs, government signs, informational signs, but their goal is to identify and advertise.

9:35 Provide public information. It includes directional and wayfinding signs. They also play an important role in enhancing community character and streetscapes as well. And signs help to express individuality and creativity. We came up with some objectives for our sign code update. We ran these by the zoning code users group and further refined them with the planning commission.

10:03 Some of these objectives include recognizing the needs of various types of businesses, supporting local economy, creating user-friendly regulations. That's a broad goal for the entire zoning code update, and it's very important for signage, which has been confusing for users and businesses in the past. Strengthening the identity of the community as a premier year-round destination resort. Signage plays an important role in that.

10:32 And encouraging creative designs that enhance our streetscapes. The village at Mammoth, up in the North Village, they do allow for more creative types of signage in a pedestrian environment that has been very successful. And there was a lot of feedback that businesses, sign companies, the public likes the way that that works. And so we took a lot of input from the village in terms of drafting some revisions to the chapter.

11:02 An important goal in all sign code regulations is to discourage visual clutter and negative impacts to the public realm. Sign likes, we drafted this as kind of a preliminary way to understand what types of sign designs and concepts are attractive and appealing here in Mammoth. Obviously, well-designed and unique signage, signs that are consistent with the Mammoth character being

11:33 Alpine, forested, attractive community event and information signs, being pedestrian friendly, being clear, simple and easy to read, as well as being durable and low maintenance. And I talked about the village as well. Dislikes, these may be obvious, but it's good to point them out. Distasteful or overly bright, internally illuminated signs, signs that are large, cluttered,

12:03 or unsightly, monotonous sign design and application, not being consistent or reflecting, local materials, attention attracting signs, and unmaintained signs. This is an example, we'll have photo examples throughout this presentation. Some of them are in town and some of them are elsewhere, but it's helpful to get an understanding visually in terms of what works and what doesn't. The signs on the left show

12:37 Unique signs that reflect the businesses that they advertise and identify. Some dislikes that we have are some of the malls around town with strict master sign plans that limit the businesses to specific colors, sizes, shapes. Again, in the village, pedestrian-friendly and unique signs are attractive and appealing. Obviously, large pull signs that aren't integrated with the landscape.

13:12 Are not appealing, they're not inviting, and it doesn't reflect our tourist destination here in Mammoth. Clear, thoughtful, and easy to read signs. Throughout town, it's easy to catch someone's attention and understand in less than a second what the sign is identifying. Clutter is overwhelming, distracting to pedestrians and vehicles, and we're not supporting that in our proposed chapter.

13:44 Durable and low maintenance materials are really important in our snowy environment and winter climate. We get strong winds, heavy snow, and signs need to be able to support those conditions and not be easily damaged and require costly maintenance year after year. Some examples of attention attracting signs.

14:10 These have never been permitted in Mammoth and we're proposing to continue that. Throughout our workshops and extensive outreach contacting business owners, local sign companies, there was a pretty overwhelming support for signs using halo type illumination. This is putting a light source behind an opaque lettering or design.

14:40 in a sign so that it emits a halo type effect around the lettering. So those are some examples that we think represent halo lighting and it's elegant and attractive. Obviously opposite to that we have some ostentatious and kind of overly bright signs that you might find in Vegas or elsewhere that just doesn't really represent Mammoth. So trying to find a

15:11 The right balance of using internal illumination attractively and appropriately is important. Banners have always been kind of an area of consideration with our sign regulations. Businesses like having some temporary ways to advertise sales or promotions. The problem with banners sometimes is they are

15:40 Placed in an ad hoc manner, they aren't thoughtfully located or designed. And the banners on the left, those were actually examples provided by Alpine signs of some examples of more thoughtfully designed banners. Changing message signs are something that are used pretty frequently to convey changing businesses that have messages or events that change throughout the year.

16:12 Electronic message signs shown on the left, those are currently prohibited by our code, but our draft chapter is looking at ways to incorporate those types of signs for certain public uses to advertise different events or even winter conditions, road conditions, things of that nature. Changeable copy size signs are currently allowed. You'll see them

16:39 Here for the minaret theaters and also for Mammoth properties. So that's another way to communicate changing messages as well. And another comment that came up throughout our workshops also is like in the village which allows neon detailing on signs. If there's a way to incorporate that throughout town that's done in an attractive and artistic manner. So these are some examples of signs that we thought conveyed that.

17:13 Across the street banners, this has come up. It came up in our workshop in August with event organizers in town looking at better ways to advertise for events. And the current code does allow for across the street banners. We just unfortunately don't have a support structure for that right now. So we would continue to allow across the street banners in our current draft chapter. This slide is a little bit out of context, but I did want to include it here because

17:44 We did have some questions in the zoning code users group about this. One issue that came up in some of our workshops is that some of the businesses, especially on Main Street with such a large right-of-way, don't feel that they are able to adequately identify themselves and communicate with drivers and vehicles on the street. And in some of our comparison codes, they did provide allowances for additional sign area for buildings and signs that are set back.

18:14 A great distance from the street. And so here we are proposing to include that in our draft chapter. And it would only apply in very limited circumstances where buildings and their signs are set back over 140 feet from the center line, which pretty much limits this to Main Street. And so some examples of those buildings would be Stellar Brew or John's Pizza or Schatz. Those are set back.

18:43 Over 140 feet from the center line. And so what we're proposing is to allow a 20% increase in the aggregate sign area for those buildings. So that wouldn't allow you to increase your sign over the maximum sign size is limited in the code, but it would allow your area to be increased. So here in this example, it's showing that you could have, if a business was allowed 40 square feet of signage, say they had a

19:13 60-foot business frontage. They could install a 30-square-foot monument sign and a 10-square-foot wall sign totaling 40 square feet. If they were located more than 140 feet from the center line, they would be allowed an additional 20%, which would be 8 square feet. Now, they couldn't increase their monument sign because we don't allow signs greater than 30 square feet, but they could increase their wall sign to 18 square feet for a total of 48 square feet of signage.

19:45 Legal considerations are extremely important in sign regulations. They're commonly challenged, and so we're working really hard to have a legally sound chapter. First Amendment, freedom of speech, sign content is protected. So that is basically limiting signs or restricting signs based on the sign type rather than the content of the sign. So regulating signs based on

20:14 Being a monument sign or a wall sign rather than the content of what's on the sign. The Fifth Amendment as well, private property cannot be taken without just compensation. This applies to ideas like amortization, which was raised by Mr. Taylor's comments. So basically that we couldn't require a non-conforming sign to be removed without providing payment or compensation for that.

20:44 Due process, obviously, their regulations are fair and reasonable. And then federal law does regulate federally registered trademarks. So the town cannot require one of those registered marks to be altered. But we can limit signs in terms of sign size, number, height, and location. And like I said previously, our legal review is ongoing and underway with this draft chapter.

21:17 So with that, that's our design intent presentation. And unless there's questions on design intent, I would like to do a PowerPoint that summarizes the major changes being proposed for the chapter and the questions that we've posed for you. So are there any questions specific to what Jen has just asked? Yes, Jen, could you go back to the slide with me on, please? On some of the designs, on some of the examples you've chosen, not

21:59 Thank you. Thank you.

22:27 The tube of neon or the tube of LED neon, so there's no opaque surface between the neon and the view. For instance, Elizabeth, the grow marketing sign, if you look at the branch, that branch is halo lit, but the leaves are neon tubes that are bent. Marketing is cut out with a backlighting and grow is halo, so it's only the leaves on it that are neon tubes.

22:57 Kind of diving, that's all entirely neon bent, artistically done, neon tubing that's been bent, as they do, and formed. You're right, Elizabeth, if you look at the pig, the words pig, you have, it's similar because the letters are dark, and the neon makes it look like halo lighting, but it's a different structure, even though the effect is not dissimilar.

23:26 Okay. And pork with an attitude, that's neon bent into... That's all neon bent, yeah. And that's actually the name of the business, too. Okay, thank you. Okay. Jen, the sign that was Juniper Home, I think the monument sign? Juniper Ridge. Juniper Ridge. What is the size? Juniper Springs. Juniper Springs. Do you happen to know? Off the top of my head, I don't know, but I would guess 30 square feet.

23:59 And that's all we're allowing. Dustin, we're not proposing to change the maximum sign size of 30 square feet. Thank you. The 30 square feet would be the rectangular portion. That whole thing is considerably bigger than that with the support structure. Correct. For the area calculation, we would be looking at the sign itself, not including the structure. And we don't have anything in there right now considering the structure and the size of it. I know in the letter from the Board of Realtors today I read about that.

24:29 The way the draft chapter is written for measuring sign area would not include the support structure. Any other questions for Jen regarding the specific part of the presentation? Okay, well, go ahead and move on, Jen. And for you folks in the public, if you do have questions as we move through it, we'll go back to the PowerPoint for you to address those. Here, this is just taking information straight out of your staff report. I think having it up on the screen now.

25:05 Make it a little bit easier to refer to and go through. So the draft sign chapter, as I mentioned, we used a lot of sources and feedback from the public and public outreach to draft these chapters, including the August Planning Commission workshop, zoning code users group, public outreach, including notification for three weeks in both papers.

25:31 And this draft chapter was published on the web over two weeks before this workshop. Also input from local sign companies, which has been really helpful in businesses. Looking at our comparison codes, we did utilize considerably more comparison codes in the sign chapter than we have in some of our other sections of the zoning code update that has been more straightforward. And obviously our general plan goals and policies.

26:01 So the first major change which we have talked about is allowing halo lit signs. We'd be allowing those only in non-residential zones, only one sign per business and no more than 20 square feet. The 20 square feet comes from the village. The village regulates or limits their signs to 20 square feet as well. And currently this type of internal illumination is prohibited.

26:30 elsewhere in town outside the village. Can I ask a question about this slide? Yes. So you say non-residential zones, that means a condominium project could not use a halo lit sign? Not one in a residential zone. Okay, which is RMF? Right, RMF, residential multifamily one, two, rural residential, residential single family. We do have some condominium complexes in commercial lodging zones as well.

27:00 So this is strictly limiting it based on zones. So in other words, Mountain Back, Seasons 4? Those are in RMF 2. Right. So they would not be permitted in Halo. Signs with neon details being allowed, same as Halo, they would not be allowed in residential zones. Only one sign per business. Not...

27:28 Allowed to be larger than 20 square feet, same as Halo, except also not allowed on monument signs. The concern there was potential conflict or distraction for vehicles adjacent to the right-of-way. Allowing electronic message signs is also something being proposed in the code or the draft chapter. We'll probably have to have some additional legal review on this to make sure the way that we

28:01 Allow it or limit it is legally sound. Suggestions were only allowing it in the public and quasi-public zone, which would apply to the schools, which is where these types of signs are frequently used, as well as located at the entrance to town if there would be one for events and road information and that type of content. So you're saying here a sign like that couldn't be used for a volunteer?

28:30 Nonprofit organization sponsoring an event like Looza Falooza, you know, Jazz or any of those. A sign like this could not be used for that purpose. Well, I think we're not going to be regulating it based on the uses per se, only because we wouldn't want to get into any content-based regulation, which might result in legal issues. So, like I said, I think there's definitely some more work that we're going to have to put into this, and especially with our town attorney.

29:00 But right now the suggestion has made by the users group to limit it only to public and quasi-public zone, which wouldn't strictly limit it based on who could use it, just the location in that zone. And I think that would solve what you're going to, Elizabeth, and that is if there was a town reader board sign, monument sign, on 203, which I'll make another mention here too, that non-profit would be allowed to use that as a public.

29:29 And it's a governmental sign, so they would be allowed to put their information up if we get past California. So one thing I want to just bring up, driving up 395, been flying a lot but driving up, recently noted that going through Lone Pine, Big Pine, I don't know if any of you have noticed it, but the schools on 395, directly on the highway, and another building have LED reader boards that are actually putting a message across, an LED.

29:58 So I guess my question for you for today to take back to Caltrans is why is that acceptable and why is it not acceptable for us on Highway 203? It doesn't make sense. And that may solve a lot of these issues if we can get that answered. And one limitation that is being proposed in a draft chapter for these types of science is that we wouldn't allow to have moving or flashing messages. So you couldn't have the scrolling or flashing messages.

30:27 Obviously the messages can be changed, but they have to be static when they're lit. Are you recommending a limitation on wattage? That is not included in the draft chapter currently. We do have a general sign lighting standards that say that sign lighting I think should be minimum to the intensity necessary, but we could definitely incorporate something like that too. Okay, thank you. Jen, also just...

30:57 A follow-up on the scrolling message you were saying here too. If it was a sign and it said, you know, welcome to Mammoth, and then that goes away and it says July 4th activities, how is that different from flashing and scrolling, I know? Because most of these signs are LED now, so I'm assuming what you're saying is it has a sentence that just continues to scroll and continues to repeat versus a message that would scroll.

31:27 Is there a difference? So I think what you're saying is that at the same time you would want one message to say 4th of July event, then that would go off and another message would come up? Yeah, I could say the dates for it, for instance. You're not going to be able to get a full message on one reader board, so it is going to have to change and rotate, but I just think just getting into semantics and the verbiage we're using so we don't get caught up with something in the future like we've had in the past.

31:56 inconsistencies. So right now, the way it's drafted, it would not allow that changing of messages, but we can refine that, definitely, because the purpose would be able to have an adequate space to notify. Maybe the way to do that is to define flashing. You know, flashing is changing more frequently than X seconds or something like that. I mean, I can see, you know.

32:24 49-cent wing, does 49-cent wings, 49-cent, that I think is what you're saying, but. Correct. Yeah, but if it's, yeah, every couple minutes it's changing to something different, then I think we should allow that. One more question here, thinking about design of this type of sign. In your research, did you find any of these signs that had eyebrow roofs over them, maybe even of corrugated metal, similar to what's done on the Lake Mary bike path, as part of their structure and design? Or were they all just?

32:54 You know, freestanding open at the top. There was no eyebrow roof. Do you know what I mean? Yeah, I understand what you're saying. I don't recall that detail. I don't think there's any reason why it wouldn't work. But you didn't happen to find a picture of one? No, I didn't. And I actually have some questions later on when we get into this, but that may follow that for you. Oh, okay, good. Another major change being proposed with the draft chapter is to allow sales and promotional banners subject to limitations.

33:28 These types of banners are currently prohibited. So the draft language would be that these types of banners could be allowed for no longer than a total of 30 days per calendar year. And that could be non-consecutive or consecutive days. We do also include in the draft chapter that these signs shouldn't be overly dissimilar or distracting or bright or disarming.

33:57 Disharmonious with the property that they're located as well. We talked about this provision about allowing a 20% increase in aggregate sign area for signs and buildings set back over 140 feet from the street center line. Another change that we're proposing is that pedestrian oriented signs that are less than six square feet or less, that one of those per business would not count towards the

34:32 Total Allowable Sign Area. That's based on comments that we've had requesting that there be more pedestrian-oriented signs in town. Some additional changes that we're proposing include that the sign area calculation be based off business frontage instead of building frontage. It's a small change, but it does allow for a little more clarity for multi-unit structures that aren't subject to master sign plans.

35:04 Allowing a minimum sign area of 12 square feet regardless of the length of business frontage. So for a really small business, no matter what, they would still be allowed to have 12 square feet of signage. Mall identification signs would not be counted towards total sign area. So that's Sierra Center Mall, Mammoth Mall, not identifying any businesses within the mall. But that shouldn't reduce the business's opportunity and area to advertise.

35:35 We have included more flexible size regulations for real estate signs, so increasing the area and number of signs for multi-tenant commercial properties, or multi-tenant properties and for commercial properties, requiring durable materials for monument signs adjacent to the right-of-way. We've already had two signs destroyed this December, so this was a request from Public Works.

36:02 That master signed programs are required for four or more businesses or tenants instead of three. And then we've also included or will include tables and graphics so that the chapter is easier to use. So that's a summary of the major changes. I can answer any questions you have of those. Otherwise, I thought we could go through the questions posed in the staff report. If we could...

36:31 I think what I'd like to do first, just as I'd like to follow this, but first, if there's any questions commissioners have of Jen that are specific to what she's just presented that are not commentary, but, you know, a question that we need answered to go forward. Nothing that we'll discuss or have consensus, because I do want to hear from the public. Okay, I did write questions in my staff report, but I do have a question on this particular.

36:56 Particular presentation, don't turn the lights on so you can read these. Okay. Can you go back to the pedestrian signs? This would be one for business. Is that what the recommendation is? Yes. What do you do with a large business that covers a large area and has multiple activities? Would they only be permitted one sign? I'm thinking just as an example. Would be Sierra Nevada Lodge, Raptors Restaurant, Skating Rink, Miniature Golf.

37:24 I mean, how many pedestrian signs could they have? That's a master sign plan, though. They would be doing a master sign plan, so this wouldn't apply to them. But even without a master sign plan, all this says is that this one isn't counted towards the total. They could have others if they chose to. I didn't read it. They could have others. This is only talking about counting it towards the total allowable sign area. But if they had other signs, it would be part of the total allowable sign area? If they had other pedestrian signs, yeah.

37:56 So this would actually allow more signs, more sign and more sign area, because you would be taking a sign, a pedestrian oriented sign that would have, under the current regulations, been counted towards sign area. And so now this sign wouldn't be. Okay. We can discuss that one later then. I do have a few questions from the staff report. Sure. So let's go through then, Jen, if we could. We'll just go through this.

38:26 Sure, sure. What I wouldn't, I mean, what I'd like to do is just get the questions out there, get your answer, not really discuss it, though, until we hear from the public, so. Yeah, no, I just have some questions, yeah. Okay, so we'll do that. Jen, you said 11 listening sessions, extensive outreach. How many people and or how many businesses do you think participated? Well, we had meetings, and Mark may be able to expand on that.

38:56 Personally, I had direct contact with various business owners, probably a handful that either contacted me via phone or email directly asking questions about the sign chapter. And in our zoning code users group, we do have Dave Harvey in there as well. And I guess through the listening sessions, I'm just not sure in terms of

39:24 All the meetings, exactly what business groups were represented, but I believe the Chamber of Commerce was one of them. Yeah, I would say, Elizabeth, that we had just between what Sandra, Mark, myself and Jay were part of well over 150 people that we actually, I mean, when you take Lions Rotary Chamber, Contractors Association, the Board of Realtors, I mean, we hit the village.

39:53 Tenants, you know, we went throughout the entire town, so anywhere between, what, 12 to 50 people at a time or more. So that, you think more than half the business owners participated? Business owners themselves? Yeah. Well, I mean... Half, less than half? I don't know if we could say that, because if you went by business licenses, the town, the number of business licenses far outweighs that number, so... But I think that, I mean...

40:22 And Jay can, you know, maybe offer too. My personal opinion is that yes, we did have a lot of participation from the business community. Could we have had more? Of course. And I'm sure, and I see people here today that weren't at some of the meetings, so we'll hear from them today. And, but I think it was a very fluid process that, one of the best ones that we've had in our town for a number of years. Okay. I wanted to ask you about coding, oh no, banners, I'll ask you about banners. Who's going to monitor the?

40:57 No more than 30 days a year. Who's going to be keeping the tally? Well, I think something that Truckee does is they do have an annual permit process for those types of temporary signs that they renew every year or can modify or change every year. Some cities have one position strictly for sign enforcement. Carmel does. They have one person that their full-time job is.

41:25 Enforcing signed regulations. So I think the approach that we've been taking now is we have a code compliance committee that tries to handle all code compliance efforts broadly. So I think that would probably be under their purview. As I recall, Jen, correct me if I'm wrong, currently those banners are not allowed. Correct. Under the new proposed provisions, they will be allowed certain restrictions.

41:55 There will still be a permit required, correct? Yes. So if they're complying with the new code, they will have to come in and have a permit so the town will have a record of when they're applying to use the banner. They'll be able to keep track of it that way. You probably still have some that aren't complying and you've still got to follow up with that. Yes. But the new provision will require a permit, so there is a procedure connected to that. At this point in time, we have not been very aggressive in enforcing the signed code.

42:25 Because this very item is coming forward. And at the same time, our workload and our resources are shifted to all the items that we know we're working on. When we start knocking off the zoning code update, district planning, we intend to have more staff resources, more planning resources directed to code compliance efforts. And I'd just say maybe go back six years and our...

42:52 Count history and before and not use the last four years of the economic downturn and rebellion. When we're thinking about banners, I mean, of course, we've seen a lot more of the businesses that needed to do it, and that's why we've kind of been relaxed with it, as we should be because of the economy. So I think we need to go back, you know, go back four or five years and think about was there really an overabundance of banners around town? And I, my position would be there wasn't. So I think that, you know, this...

43:22 Ordinance and the way it's coming forward is going to be sufficient for the banners. And I would like to add also, in the draft chapter, we do have a provision in here that would require, and this may or may not stay, would require a bond for temporary banners with their permits. And so if the banner wasn't taken down within two days of hitting that end of their 30 days or display period, that we could revoke that bond as well. So that does put a bit of pressure for compliance as well.

43:52 In your research on this, I know you've done extensive research, did you find new substances that make better message boards than the plastic ones that crack in yellow, and what are they using for changeable message boards and marquees nowadays? For the internally lit electronic message? No, for the changeable message, the changeable message, which you put up there as an option. I did not look into materials for that in detail, no. The sign companies may have.

44:22 Some suggestions on that. Okay, my other questions are on the specific issues, so I'll wait until we get to those. Commissioner Clark? Minor specific. If we could, Jen, what I'd like to do is see for members of the public to address this now and what you got through in the last two presentations, if you'd maybe be available to go back to the slide if they'd like. So, you know, this isn't a public hearing, but we do want to hear from you, so anyone wishing to come forward, please state your name.

44:53 What is your thoughts, recommendations, or ideas? John Veruck, good afternoon. Just some comments, and just to make sure, I don't know where it's going, but as a few of you know, the old law was written by the bureaucrats, and we had nothing to do with, except pay the fee. So I'm glad to see that we're following 25 years, we're doing something. And when you come up with this, I hope that, I think there's one person on the committee who's actually,

45:25 Done a sign. And I hope that when you guys look at these signs, remember that we have to pay for these. So it's very, very important, the cost. Like I think I've said to you before, 501 in the plaza, which is the old Ace building, I've got $11,000 in fees in that building so far. And you can't read the signs. For your signs, John, or just the fees? The summary of the fees, the engineering costs, and what time? Maybe about $15,000 by the time the signs are built.

45:55 So, and I don't know where you're going with this, but the monument signs, I'm assuming that you're not changing the monument sign as far as listing the individual businesses. I mean, I kind of like the idea of the monument signs, but not to have a big, you know, 15 different names on it, so I don't know if that's where you're going. That'd be my recommendation, leave the monument signs, but don't put all the different businesses down.

46:21 The square footage, definitely, we've got to find some way to increase that square footage, and I think they're doing that, so it's not really dependent upon the building itself, but the square footage decides, so it's the proportions of the building, but we're limited in some cases to square inches, not square feet. Time limit, I'm assuming, I didn't see anything about the 10 year, so I'm hoping that 10 years is going to disappear. And again, the cost, there was something mentioned about a bond for banners just now.

46:50 That's pretty good idea. Or you just maybe have to put a deposit down or something like that instead of buying a bond. So those are my other comments. You're speaking regarding non-conforming signs that are already. No, they were talking about a bond for 30 days for banners. Oh, for banners. Instead of paying for a bond, just put a deposit. Bonds are going to cost you money. Just a thought in the comments. Thank you. Thank you. Podium is open. If anyone else, you're fine. Just state your name for her. So she gets it in the record.

47:23 Hi, Carrie Myers. I have InTouch, Michael Spa and the Main Street Center. I apologize. I must have been asleep when there was all this other public comment. I didn't realize any of this was going on. So my business, I'm on my 12th year, and we were required to get a master sign plan. I spent $70,000 building my business before the sign plan was gone. I think it was a...

47:50 $1,500 for our design plan after my business was built. It turned out it was not legal for me to have a sign on the side of the building that my business has the main exposure, which is basically an outlet mall. And I know that there's several, there's examples of these types of businesses that have built signs, you know, when they have what happened to be on a corner, for instance. So you're talking about a projecting sign.

48:20 No, not a projecting sign. Many examples are on Old Mammoth Road. Like, they have a sign facing Old Mammoth Road, but their business is on a corner. So then they have another sign on the corner, on the other fake side of the building. And I've been driving up Main Street and Old Mammoth, you know, noticing how many businesses have this situation, and it's not common.

48:47 But there are quite a few. There's an example on South Old Mammoth Road. That business was put in after my business, and they have a sign in the front and on both sides of the building. And I kind of fought with this. We were allowed a directory listing. I had Dave go to get a permit to make me a sign once, and the person that was working at the town at the time said, oh, I changed my mind on that. It's not allowed.

49:16 I had a 30-day temporary, and we had our sign on the backside of the building. Definite, definite, obvious increase in business. I could show you my numbers. But I got a request to take the sign down. My, I'm sorry. That's okay. You're fine. My neighbor has a grandfather, and his sign is really beautiful, and it's right above his business, and I'm really glad it faces the other way.

49:46 And what was the point of that? I don't know. I'm happy for him. I think I have a different point for that than I forgot. And I tried to take this up with my landlord, but it requires another master sign permit, and it's too much money for all the businesses don't want to go in for, you know, my sake for that. And I think there should be consideration for...

50:14 You know, where people, if there is a other, do you understand what I'm talking about? You're talking about the building, if it's perpendicular to the street, and you don't have frontage on the street, but you're perpendicular to the street, which is what your building is, you want a sign on both sides, because you don't have frontage on the street. And, you know, I know, well, like we have the banner sign, that's the,

50:40 Mall sign, and then we're all allowed our 20 square foot signs, and ours are a little bit monotonous because it was very strict 12 years ago that they had to be this way, and, um, but it would, you know, it would obviously, so I have one sign for my business, um, but I can't have a second sign on the, really, I mean, when I pick my location,

51:06 My walls are probably 20 feet from the Polo factory outlet, but I'm not allowed to sign. That's my greatest square footage of my business, and I'm not allowed to sign facing the Polo factory outlet. Because that's considered the back side of the building. It's not the greenish way where you're at. And, you know, I do have a sign facing Main Street, but I think there's a lot more exposure from guests, potential guests.

51:35 Seeing the sign from, you know, I thought that I had a great business location because it's facing the factory outlet walls, but I'm not allowed to have a sign facing the factory outlet walls. That's clear. We understand. Okay. Thank you. And Jen, you got that? Go ahead, Jen. Okay. And then I think everything else was probably addressed at all these other meetings. I feel like there's an inequity of enforcement. I counted last summer six banners on a

52:06 Refurbished business on Old Mammoth Road and I had a complaint about my mall I think because there's some issues with the mall owner and you know we put a sign up in the afternoon and take it down and I just think that there's a little bit of inequity of who knows who and I guess I did finally see I understood that

52:36 Not the grandfathering I saw, but there was legal issues with that because I think that, yeah, that's kind of interesting that some people just can do whatever they want. Okay, thank you. Thank you. You said we understood, but I'm not sure I understand. Can we follow up with Jen a little bit? Oh, please. Yeah, please. First question I have, Jen, is that an issue that's purely within the signed plan for that mall, or is there something separate from that?

53:06 That's one thing I'm confused about. It could be both. Could be both? I think it's probably both. The way that the sign code reads is that signs should be or shall be located on the business frontage where there's the primary entrance to the business. So I can understand. I definitely understand the issue. I understand.

53:31 Where the concern is there. So is that second sign that she's talking about prohibited because of that? Because it wouldn't be on the frontage of her business? Yes. Okay. I want to talk about this in discussion. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Because I'm thinking of dominoes. Yeah, no, I think, yeah, when it comes... Let's talk about this. And Carrie, when we have our discussion, this will come up again, so you need to stay around, okay? Yeah, we're going to talk. Anyone else wishing to...

54:07 My name is John Mueller. I own John Speetsworths. Would current non-conforming designs be grandfathered in, or would people be forced to remove their... That's one of the issues that the Planning Commission is going to have to consider. In the big scheme of non-conforming...

54:34 Development standards, whether it's a use or a building or property condition or a sign, typically the code establishes that it's grandfathered until some significant event happens. And so when there's some level of damage of a certain value, typically it's meant to be brought into code compliance. The comment that you've received from Mr. Taylor is,

55:01 That perhaps you should have a more aggressive approach where you're giving people some clock to work within, whatever the time frame is. Say everybody has to conform in 15 years. And so it's a policy issue for the Planning Commission where you should be weighing the rights and expectations that people have when they got their sign and they went through the rules and regulations and processes at the time versus

55:30 And I would hate to have to...

55:54 Change my sign-out because maybe you guys don't like the color or some, there's different people now that have different likes and wants, but then again, we're always picking on Mammoth Liquor. I think we'd all like to see that go away, but if that never goes away, then I think we're kind of wasting our time with this whole sign-out. And we'll be doing that under discussion also, Jim. Okay. I think...

56:21 The main issue I have, I mean, a lot of the stuff I like, I like the creative signs, and I wish a lot more people would upgrade their signs, and I've been wanting to upgrade my monument sign for quite some time now, and when I put that sign in, I was limited to 30 square feet, and they allowed back then, last time they did this, they allowed 30 square feet, and then they said you could have two business signs there, and I found by having two signs within 30 feet, you can't read it.

56:51 So at this point, I don't know what to do with it. I'm not going to put money into another 30 square foot sign if you can't read it. And I don't know if I should put the name of the building there, Rivers Jamal, which no one really uses anymore, or just one sign for my business, which isn't really fair to other businesses. So I'm kind of on a standstill still because, you know, the sign, the room that I have right now, 30 square feet, is not legible.

57:20 So that's an issue I don't know because I'm sitting in a hole and also a 12-foot height is also an issue because I'm sitting six feet below Main Street and obviously I'm trying to reach people on Main Street. So those are just some issues that I have with my property. Also, when you have a smaller property pushed back farther and you have multiple businesses, the size of the signs gets smaller.

57:47 And that's another consideration. The signs should be proportional and they should be able to be read by people on Main Street. So I think those are, I like where this is going, but unfortunately I have kind of a screwed up location. So are you looking more for your monument sign to be able to have all three businesses?

58:08 You have four businesses there. That would be on it but legible too. Probably two. I think having more than two gets too busy. But if I'm allowed to put two there, it should be large enough to read. And if that's going to be the case, then maybe we should change it. You can only have one. Because 30 square feet is big enough for one, not two. So one or the other. John, as a business owner, what to you would be a reasonable length of time to depreciate a sign and change it out?

58:38 I mean, you've been in business a long time, you know. You know, I'd say a sign will last a good 10 years. You know, they paint them and keep them going. Probably 10 years. Thank you. That's all the questions I have. Thank you. Thank you, John. Follow-up. Sure. A follow-up for you, John. John? Well, it's for Jen, I think. Okay, for Jen. Jen, do you know if his property would apply? Would that 140 square foot setback exception apply? The signs on the building would apply?

59:13 So the building would get an extra 20% of sign area for the signs on the building. Now the monument sign is not located 140 feet from the center line, so it wouldn't apply to the monument sign. And we didn't use any kind of calculation for the fact that Main Street is going up and they're so far down that really their kind of viewable space for Main Street is really gone, did we?

59:39 Yeah, I mean, we do allow for height increases up to 16 square feet, which is similar to what the code has now, but that is really the way it's described now is that it's for areas where snow removal equipment can't access, but we could revise that too. So would we be able to perhaps come up with language that would allow for something where the road is going up, there going down?

1:00:07 And it's just one area of town, or is that considered spot zoning? No, you know, I think the biggest issue, the purpose of the design program is to make sure businesses are identified, and you're still achieving the graphic design package and the image that you want from the community. And so, you know, this is a UD condition. Drivers, and it's not only that they're far away, the drivers are looking straight ahead. And the farther, more leaping angle...

1:00:35 Yeah, they might run off the road, but it's just harder to see. And so we can certainly come up with different design considerations for that. And we're also conscious of other factors like trees. You know, with the Lutheran Church, this is a sidebar, you know, we modified our free structure because we can, because the permit cost to get the design review.

1:01:02 Was so high. And in a situation where we're trying to encourage people to improve their properties, keep them well maintained and painted and have attractive and conforming signs, you know, I'm sure we want to strike the appropriate balance between cost recovery and general fund impact to achieving business support. So with trees on site, the costs of maintaining a non-conforming structure.

1:01:31 You know, hopefully we'll consider all of those factors as well as the design and view perspective for two or three. Thank you. Sure. Jen, to go back to John's situation, there are three businesses, so would each get a sign increase 20% because they're 140 feet from road rider? Yes. Thank you. John, did you have another?

1:02:00 I have a comment on John Mueller's comment about the sign, the length of the sign, or the time. I don't think there needs it. There should be a time. And 10 years is really too short. If you look at our existing ordinance, we've got monument signs that are non-conforming that are 25, 30 years old. And they're going to be there. And also, I think, one of the constitutional amendments of the five that says, you know, has a take.

1:02:25 If you want to pay for that sign and take it down, some of those signs are very expensive. So I'd be totally opposed to any kind of a length of time to have a sign up, as long as it's maintained properly. Thank you. All right, anyone else? Okay, so let's move on through our process here. Thank you, folks. There'll still be time if there's anything else for you to bring up to us. So if we can get back to the staff report now. Have that slide up there, Jen, but I think that's what you have, right? Okay, so.

1:03:06 Let's go ahead and go up that direction. So what I've done here is I've identified the questions that are posed in your staff report and I've also included from the comments we've received so far from Mr. Taylor and the Mammoth Board of Realtors as well. And then obviously any other public comments and questions. So the first question in the staff report is very general related to the issues that were identified previously. And the question is just,

1:03:37 Does the proposed draft sign chapter address the issues raised during the issues workshop and outreach efforts? And I have included the zoning code users group consensus, which is users group met last Wednesday. And the zoning code users group expressed that the proposed draft chapter provides an appropriate middle ground to address issues raised with the current sign regulations. Commissioner Clark? I don't know how you're proceeding, but...

1:04:05 I have individual questions all the way, so do you want to do it now, or do you want to go through the questions? Let's go through the questions that Jen has presented to us, and you may have some overlapping ones there, but let's go through these questions first, and then we can come back through for specific questions that you have. So if you have an overlapping question, then, or if it's not, answer it twice. Okay. I don't... I guess the question now is, you know, as she has said, do we feel, you know, is there consensus that...

1:04:36 The proposed draft signed chapter addresses the issues raised during the workshops and outreach. Mainly so. Mainly so. Is that what you're looking for in general? Yeah, we're just looking for general. Except for the unique circumstance where a business is in a building perpendicular to the main thoroughfare or in an unusual spot like John's business where it's down well below grade.

1:05:02 I'm not sure that's been adequately addressed, but we'll find that out as we talk. Okay. Yeah, and I, again, I concur that we will root out these issues with, like, John's issue and Carrie's issues as we move along. So, move on to number two. So, 2A, the question is, is it appropriate to allow halo-lip signs subject to the limitations in the draft chapter, which we talked about?

1:05:31 And the zoning code users group consensus was yes, halo signs are attractive and the proposed limitations are appropriate. Yes. Commissioner Canning? The halo, absolutely. Okay. The next is signs with neon details. Is it appropriate to allow signs with neon details subject to the limitations that we talked about? It goes on further to ask, is the description of allowable neon details in the chapter appropriate?

1:06:01 Or should an additional description of intent be included, such as neon elements are intended to provide accessory graphics and artistic elements to a sign? Right now it's just described as neon details and it's a little bit of an awkward description describing that the entire copy or border couldn't be neon details and I think that description might be more helpful.

1:06:30 The zoning code users group consensus was that an expanded description would be appropriate and that providing photos as examples would be useful. The zoning code users group didn't get to see the photos that we provided today, so I think that helps to give a little bit more information. The users group also mentioned that neon details should allow for similar products to neon that achieve the same result, such as LED neon, which is absolutely correct.

1:06:58 And I think we should expand the definition of neon to make sure that that can be done. And the other question that the user group asked was whether dimming neon is feasible. Dimming LED neon is definitely feasible. Dimming neon, I've had mixed results. I contacted Grass Valley and they said they hadn't had any direct experience with it, but potentially using different types of ballast to utilize different amounts of

1:07:26 Electrical current going through could possibly do that. Commissioner Corbett? Yes. Commissioner Fenn? I got some issues with this. I wish you could show both screens at once, but I know you can't do that on your laptop. I think the neon details in the market sign that was on the left with the leaves and then the, you know, the backlit words was good. I didn't think the pig was successful because you couldn't read the writing when it was done in neon. And so I would favor

1:07:58 And I like neon, I like neon art, but I would favor neon details, but not a neon sign where the letters were in neon. I find them more difficult to read, and I don't think they add to the design of the sign. I think a combination of neon details and halo lit is much more successful. And I think we have to remember how many of our visitors are in motorized transportation, you know, and so they've got to be able to read it as they go by. That's ridiculous.

1:08:28 I think it's good like it is, but there's, my recollection in the Zona Cone User Group meeting was we kind of sat there and struggled with how do we crisply define what's acceptable and what isn't when you go beyond just talking about neon details, and we couldn't do it. I have a feeling this is one section that no matter what we put there, somebody that wants to push the envelope is going to come up with something that we'll be able to say we don't.

1:08:58 We think goes beyond, but find it hard to define what that is. So I don't know what more we can do with the wording there. And for myself, Jen, I just, I think what we've got going is it's a good start. You know, I apologize to you. I had quite a collection of photographs of artistically done neon signs from San Francisco, from Vancouver, and I hadn't put them on my computer after when we got on fire, so they were all destroyed. I tried looking for some examples for Jen. Couldn't find them, but...

1:09:27 What I did do is I contacted Laurie and Mike Vance and Warden Nadine Jones, who are both up in Canada, and I've asked for them to send down some photos to us because Vancouver is known as the neon center of the world for signs. They have a museum up there for it, in fact, going all the way back to the 1800s. So I think that would give us a good representation of what artistic neon is, and I disagree with Elizabeth on the pig sign, only...

1:09:56 Knowing what that really is, that when you have neon tubing, it's just an artistic manner in which it's blown and it's shaped. And so, I couldn't read the words. So, you know, I think that we need to allow for that artistic ability of a business that they could produce at maybe quite an expense a neon sign. Let's, I'll use Lacan Nookie, for example, that had the Hula Girl with, and it said Lacan Nookie.

1:10:23 That would all be part of the neon that they would be using in the different gases that are used for neon. I think the dimming, you know, my opinion of that working with neon in the past is with the different ballasts and transformers you have to use for the different gases, I don't really think that's something we should have in our code because it will affect the way that that sign operates. But things change every day with technology, so you never know.

1:10:51 I just think that we need to allow enough flexibility that, you know, a sign that is done in neon, like, you know, when we first did the village sign, I think we need to all remember when we did the village sign ordinance. It was different than the rest of the town. It had neon, it had halo. And, you know, what was going on is that that business owner would go to the town, the staff, the administratively would look at it, you'd have a small maquette, a makeup of the sign.

1:11:19 And if it was a question of our campaign planning project. And I think that neon is something, a neon sign is something that we probably should follow the same procedure with. That it would go through town staff administratively. If there's an issue, then it would come to the design review or planning commission. Because it is something new that we're putting in. And that would take care of individual tastes and, you know, we could actually look at it to where we're not using our own preference, but the body of how the sign was constructed.

1:11:48 Well, my comment, it wasn't from taste, it was from legibility. And the letters that I used the pig sign as an example weren't legible. See, but they were to me is what I'm saying. So could legibility, you know, not trying to put so many letters crowded and neon in the defined space, you know, be a correct criterion? I think that's probably more appropriate in some updated sign design guidelines. Okay. But I think regulating, like, lettering height and space. Just legibility.

1:12:18 Just is it easily readable as you're driving by? Well, and the pictures are going to make all the difference. I mean, they're going to make, I think, from what you said, are we going to get those pictures? Well, I've asked for them to send us some down, so I'm sorry. It's kind of the last two days I asked for them. Okay. But, you know, there's other, if you go on the Internet, too, I mean, I went on to help Jim, and there are so many variations, and when you look at a non, you know, three-dimensional sign, it's really hard to...

1:12:44 To see that, like in my, what I would suggest to you, Elizabeth, is that sign, if you actually saw the sign in person, you probably would be able to read it. Oh, because it was a small photograph? Yeah. You're doing the photographs, they're one-dimensional, they're not three or two-dimensional, and so you're, you know, it's difficult on something like that. Okay, but of course the pig says it all. And the thing you have to remember is, a business, the main thing about a business is you want your sign, and I'm speaking as a business owner,

1:13:14 You want your sign to say who you are, what you are, what you're doing. And a business owner, I can't imagine a business owner spending the money on a neon sign, which is not the thousands, but the tens of thousands of dollars to do. That wouldn't assist their business. That just isn't logical and doesn't make sense. In your package on page 70, you have the color.

1:13:41 Printed version of the PowerPoint slide. Right. And you'll see that the pork with an attitude looks to be a projecting sign that's most likely designed for a pedestrian view, and it's not designed, I would think, from somebody driving 35 miles an hour by. And so, in any kind of sign, it's designed to a particular audience, a view, and they're traveling at a particular speed. I know.

1:14:10 If it's not legible, whether it's wood or paint or whatever the material, it's not an effective sign. I could read it better in the printout than I could on the screen. And then imagine the sign is probably four by six. Oh, yeah, exactly. I have a general question before we go further. Can I ask a general question? Sure, go ahead. I want to be sure I understand this. I know Planning Commission has discretion, but our goal here is to have a very user-friendly, updated sign code.

1:14:37 Buy in an agreement from everybody as much as we can so someone can come and know what the rules are, what they can do. But what discretion do we have over a sign that might push the envelope or staff has some, I mean right now we have subcommittees and there are two members of the Planning Commission on each of our what, five or six subcommittees and then if they don't agree then it comes to the whole commission. Would a sign issue still be the same as it is now so that wouldn't change?

1:15:07 I think the sign subcommittee will be really important when we start implementing the updated sign chapter again. Okay, and so we would still have discretion over a design in dispute with the commission? We would still, as long as the sign committee was still established, future commissions could say they don't want one. I mean, so you have to keep that in mind. You know, currently we have a sign committee and I don't see it going away, so.

1:15:34 Okay, well, when we get to the discussion of the special cases where people are in, you know, different locations or buildings that are oriented differently, okay, we'll get there then. Okay, Jen? Okay, the next sign is related to the electronic message signs. Is it appropriate to allow electronic message signs subject to the limitations in the draft chapter, and should these signs...

1:16:06 We've gone a little bit further than this already. Should these signs be allowed for public, quasi-public and non-profit uses or limited only to public and quasi-public uses? The zoning code users group consensus was electronic message signs should be only allowed in the public and quasi-public zone. Careful consideration will be necessary to ensure that the intent and limitations of this regulation are legal. Quasi-public zone?

1:16:35 The public and quasi-public zone is the zone that encompasses the schools, the water district property, and the south property coming along Main Street on 203 into town. The courthouse is on public and quasi-public. Zone, the hospital's public and quasi-public zone. Zone. Okay, I just wasn't accustomed to that.

1:17:02 It is, it's an established zone in town. Quasi-public zone. Yeah. The hospital would be the same. Right, exactly. Okay, now I'm, thank you. Sure. And, yes, I have a problem. Commissioner Kenny? I'm very much in favor of message signs, letting people know what's going on in town. If this is the best way to do it with an electronic sign, then, you know, it will be the best way to do it. I'm concerned about public and quasi-public.

1:17:33 How many signs we're going to have? The whole idea with all this planning is to eliminate clutter and have good design throughout town. I'm also concerned not only about the clutter but about the brightness because in both Las Vegas and Reno and any, you know, resort town that has gambling, they're so bright they're actually glary and I would hate to think that that would be, I mean, I'm really concerned about how bright they are.

1:18:04 Because that would be counterproductive and it wouldn't, it doesn't necessarily fall under the outdoor lighting ordinance, you know, I don't, well no, it's not shielded and down directed but that it can't be assigned so, you know, there we are. So I'd be very concerned about that. Just for additional clarification, properties in the public and quasi-public zone are quite large and this would regulate those signs to one per property and since they are so expensive to construct and install, I think that

1:18:33 Would indirectly limit that as well. Well, and all of them aren't going to want one. Sure. I just want some clarification also on the messaging. It's a little unclear. So can you elaborate on that? I think you know where I'm going with it. The same comment previously to allow the message to change but not the flashings. Well, and also just, you know, when we say nonprofit uses only or it's...

1:19:08 If it's a town sign, you know, we used to have the monument sign at footless on the corner there, so if there would be a town sign that had, that was operated by the town to advertise events, I want to make sure that that language isn't saying that that would be excluded unless they're a non-profit. I think we are moving away, I think we are moving away from the limitation on the uses, and strictly for the public quasi-public zone.

1:19:38 That's because that's what the consensus was from CUG. And I want to make sure your folks understand that we're allowing, if it's a for-profit event, that they would still be able to utilize that sign. Because we're going by this consensus. I think the issue of what would be placed on the sign is who owns the sign. So right now, we've received

1:20:06 Frequent requests from the school district for this type of sign at the high school. And there's a high school, a middle school, and an elementary school. We received a request from the college in Mammoth Lakes Foundation as they start to develop their performance facility. They want to be able to have message-changing signs that tell you what's coming. And I think the challenge goes back to content.

1:20:36 Once you allow a sign, then other people generally can have that same sign. Restricting size and construction standards is one approach, which is the bulk of this. And the other idea is to focus it in particular land use cells, which is legal. So then if it's, let's say it's a town-owned sign, the town would control the message that would be placed.

1:21:05 If it wasn't a townhome sign, then that entity would probably control what was placed. And this is not including interior signs that businesses can use that actually are LED signs announcing something. This is strictly... Exactly. Yeah. You say interior, you mean inside their window? Well, you have a business and inside your window you put a sign that says, you know, 49 cent weeks. That's...

1:21:33 Interior of the business. Where have you been eating lately? Pennsylvania. So there's those signs that people could have. It's no different than the open sign or a Budweiser sign that's inside of a business in the window. So it is excluding them. The beer signs in the windows are okay, you're saying.

1:22:00 I didn't follow that. I didn't follow what you said. Well, that's what I want to be clear is that this isn't changing those uses from an interior of a business. Right now, the code limits neon signs to only be the open signs of two and a half square feet. Right now is the current code. And with the proposed code, we would allow this, looking to allow the signs with neon detailing. Now, those would still be allowed.

1:22:26 The electronic message signs is talking about a totally different animal. I understand. And that's what I'm saying, though. There are the signs, and I forget the neon, maybe the Budweiser was the wrong one to use, but, you know, a message board that would be inside a business that says, now serving breakfast, and it's an LED message sign that's going, you know, perpetuity throughout the day, or dinner, or 49 cent wings. I mean, these are excluded, is what I'm trying to say.

1:22:53 The way the proposed code is drafted, it wouldn't allow you to have a scrolling or LED sign saying dinner specials. So that wouldn't be allowed through the way that this is. On the interior of the business. Correct. If it's visible. Correct. If it's visible. That's what we're talking about here. I mean, in the front window, right? Correct. You could have changeable copy would be allowed to utilize that.

1:23:23 The internal electronic message or neon type sign wouldn't be allowed for that type of message for businesses. The way this is drafted now. Okay, something that hasn't been raised with these message signs, is this letters only? There's no images? Like if it's Winterfest, there's no snowboarder jumping?

1:23:51 In the air, or if it's in the summer, there's nobody drinking beer, or a musician playing a saxophone, you see footage of that alternating with the announcement of the event, which is the kind of thing you see, you know, in the big city like Las Vegas. There's nothing expressed here, so can people say, oh, I want to put that with my event? Or a 32 or larger LED screen that's on the inside of the business that's running a loop of snowboarding on the mountain.

1:24:19 Is that going to be excluded, Dawn, because of this? This would provide more flexibility to allow businesses more in terms of use of LED neon than we currently have in the code. But Elizabeth's question is directed to the content. She framed it in terms of image versus text, but as I understand it, we're not focusing on content at all. Correct. We wouldn't be limiting that. So the electronic.

1:24:54 Message sign could have images as well as text. Is that correct? That's my understanding. Because we're not, the regulation doesn't speak to the content, to the message that's being put on that sign. And I'm just trying to say that messaging sign could be a TV screen that has, you know, a DVD connected to it that's running a loop continuously. No, I'm talking about in the public and quasi-public. What the public sees. Oh, you can talk about that. Okay. Yeah, I'm not talking about inside the business. I'm talking about what the public.

1:25:24 Sees, what the visitor who comes to town sees, is it a sign along the highway, outside the right of way, that has, you know, footage. I think that... Do you know what I'm saying? Yeah. What's most useful to us is not asking, you know, exactly what we can't do, but to be more focused on what you want to try to achieve. Yeah, exactly. I don't know, we'd have to... It might be that we could limit it to words.

1:25:53 But I think what you're saying is you don't want to see a Las Vegas or Palmdale bright, flashy sun, one that looks overly commercial, overly garish, which has a lot of movement and animation, maybe a Carson City kind of sign. So you don't want that. On the other hand, if it's only little yellow lights that say welcome, that might not meet your objectives either.

1:26:20 No, that's a lost opportunity. And so if your intent is to not be what I just described, we can look at that and see if we can craft more regulations. And what will happen is ultimately if we can't limit it, then you should ask yourself if you want it, want to allow it. And you're weighing not only the visual objectives, but as, you know, we've...

1:26:49 We've heard time and time again over the last six years, you know, we want to be an events and festival community. And so how does this help achieve that objective? And then you're asking us what limitations can be applied to make sure that it's not garish. And so if that's some consensus, we'll do more homework on that. So let me frame it in a different way. Sam's Woodside, private property, events are held there.

1:27:19 If the owner desired to continue that site indefinitely for events and they wished to put a sign up, it wouldn't be allowed. That property is not located in the public or quasi-public zone. I'm just interested in keeping...

1:27:37 I don't want to use the word special because it's so overused and so hackneyed, but, you know, people like to go visit places that are different from where they come from, and I don't want to look like every place else. I want the first impression to be, you know, the village and the trees that the general plan talks about, the mountains, all the rest of it, and I don't want a lot of screens, you know, with all this stuff happening, which is just, it's sort of couch potato vacations, you know, you just sit in your car and watch the screens of what you could be doing yourself or watching people do.

1:28:05 For real, you know, not through the magic of television. Do you know what I'm saying? I want it just to be a special experience when you get here and not be like where you came from or be like everywhere else. And I'm worried about this slippery slope here with the message, the signs that end up being, you know.

1:28:27 Footage of all the stuff that's happening on the hill and happening elsewhere, and it's fun to see, but I don't necessarily want that to be visitors' first impression when they come to town. Because this is a workshop. We're seeking comments from the public, but your questions and comments, we'll take them forward to the council, and then we'll come back after we've done more thorough legal review and respond to you. And so you have some other items on the agenda, so I'd like you to, if you could, to...

1:28:52 Keep moving through and ask your question. Yeah, and I just wanted to state, you know, Elizabeth, I disagree with you in that last statement you made, only because we're all over 50. We're talking now 10, 15, 20 years from now about the youth of today that are in their 20s that will be 40 and 50 in the future, and they are technology-oriented, and that's, I mean, that's what their focus is. And so our thoughts of, as you mentioned about, you know, you don't want the technology in that, I think we have to look down the road that

1:29:23 Technology is still the future, so I disagree that we shouldn't involve a lot of technology in our code as we move forward. No, that wasn't what I was saying. That wasn't what I was saying. I was saying it's the virtual experience versus the actual experience, whether you're a spectator of the actual experience or doing it, as opposed to the virtual experience and seeing it on a screen. You can see that at home in your living room or on your computer, and I want being here to be...

1:29:52 That's why we're all working so hard, you know. That's how I feel about it. That's okay. I think the virtual experience is just as important. Just my comment. Okay. Okay. The next question is about banners. Is it appropriate to allow banners for sales and promotions subject to the limitations that we talked about? The zoning code users group consensus was that the proposed limitations appear appropriate. Yes. Commissioner Kenny?

1:30:19 Did you talk about securely affixed so we don't have the droopy drawers banners? Because with the wind that's a real problem and they're just rarely are they stretched taut and clear and you know they just look saggy and we can add that. I think we somewhere in there I recall some general language requiring signs to be in good repair and maintain and it might be covered by that. That's true. I'll make sure.

1:30:56 This question is just asking if the increase in total allowable aggregate sign area, if the building and sign are 140 feet from the center line is appropriate. Oh, sorry, the users group consensus was that this provision would only apply in very limited circumstances and seems appropriate for those circumstances. Yes. That's fine. Yeah, the only thing I'd like to add is I really would like staff to be proactive with those specific businesses like Barry, John, and...

1:31:26 And as we move through this process to ensure that we're getting the right correct verbiage for it and size before it goes to council. Okay. Okay. So I'm taking that to mean that in those places where we have special conditions, you know, we want to be able to understand what businesses currently are looking for and then come up with language that...

1:31:56 allows flexibility for unique sites. Yeah, I'd like to see staff get more flexibility than they currently have with that to work with specific business owners that have those isolated situations. Yeah. Maybe it's obvious, but the thing I'd like to add to that is we have two specific examples, but we want you to try to do something that's a tougher job than just that is try to generalize those into so that you come up with some language that

1:32:24 allows flexibility even in some situations we don't know about yet. And we wouldn't write it in the way that we would do a normal variance because it's not a variance. This is an upfront acknowledgement. Correct. Okay. This question is, should the one six-square-foot pedestrian-oriented sign not count towards total allowable sign area? So one of those per business. Yes.

1:32:52 Well, I had the question about that before and only one business that I could think of that's, you know, actively improving in Mammoth and that's Sierra Nevada Lodge and all the appartinent businesses and they've got all these different uses and they have a long frontage and it seems restrictive for them because here they're trying to do things to provide amenities to the community and I think in that case this is sort of punitive.

1:33:17 It seems like they ought to be able to have four signs of the individual activities. But that's going to be another, that's a master sign plan that they will be doing for that property. And maybe Mark, can you? We have two different conditions. So picture a small business, Nick and Willys. So this regulation would allow Nick and Willys to have one sign, smaller sign that doesn't count to their overall sign regulations.

1:33:45 The situation with Sierra Nevada Lodge is they have a very large property. And regardless of the ownership, there are essentially the former ocean harvest site, the lodge conference room that's way to the west on the property site, then rafters, now a temporary use facility, and then the hotel itself. And this isn't intended to address.

1:34:15 That type of a large, uniform property. What we should have is the ability to have a master sign plan that takes the intent of this and applies it to that unique situation. And in addition to that, on that particular site, especially if you look at properties on Old Mammoth Road, where people have chosen to place the driveway entrance markers, many of them are not visible.

1:34:43 And so you're not even able to see the entrance into the parking lot until you passed it. And so I think what you want overall is to have flexibility for these larger sites so that people can see it neatly, cleanly, with the appropriate character, get to the site and navigate to it and then through it. And so that would be the intent. So you're sitting a lot of intent in this sign code and the master sign plan allows flexibility.

1:35:13 For the larger properties to achieve it. And we've already stated that a master sign plan comes after three businesses or four? Four or more. But if a smaller property wants to have a master sign plan, they can. Right. And one other thing about a master sign plan is if this facility, if let's say they chose a particular style to how they wanted to organize their sign,

1:35:39 It's not our intent to force everybody to have an individually unique sign. So a master sign plan is meant to allow a tailored package to that more unified and uniform property. It might allow a lot of flexibility. It might not be flexible. Okay, thank you. That helps. Thank you. Okay. I think this is the last one. Should projecting signs be allowed on the second story of the structure?

1:36:10 The current draft chapter would only allow projecting signs for ground level businesses, which is consistent with the way the current code is written. And the projecting signs are literally projecting from the side of the building. And the reason those are proposed for ground level businesses is that they are generally pedestrian oriented and limited to 12 square feet. The users group consensus was that

1:36:39 Projecting signs should be located at the main pedestrian entrance of a business. It does not seem appropriate to locate projecting signs along the second story of a structure where there is no pedestrian access. And I agree with that position. Okay, I'd like to hear from the zoning code users group on this. What if you're in our mixed-use facility, second floor is offices, third floor is residential, first floor is retail, and what if you had a law firm on the second floor? What if you had...

1:37:10 Design firm on the second floor. Does that mean they could not have a projecting sign? What was the rationale for not having projecting signs from the second floor? Well, if I may, I had an issue with this because I felt that second floors of buildings should have projecting signs because you have the pedestrian walkway. I think what this is saying is where there is no pedestrian walkway, I'll use Mammoth Mall.

1:37:35 You have a second floor, but there's no exterior walkway for pedestrians like you have on the first floor. It's all interior. So why would you need a projecting sign coming off the second floor when there's not a pedestrian walkway on that floor? Oh, I was thinking in terms of walking down a sidewalk and you're going to an address and you're checking the numbers and you look up and then you see, you know, so-and-so.

1:38:02 Attorneys at Law or something or some business that was on or some wellness claim. No, I can't use wellness claim. But some business that was on the second floor, I didn't see the reason for not having it. So look at this. In a mixed use property. So this is, well, this isn't mixed use really. Well, can I just make sure we're clear? You can have signs on the walls. Yeah. And typically a projecting sign is.

1:38:29 Projecting from the building wall, and it's designed to bring in, walk in street level traffic. And typically, you know, we see that at the ground floor. And for those businesses that are on the upper floor, the way to get to the door, you want to get to the door. And so the door is someplace else. So it's main entry into the building that will take you to stairs or an elevator.

1:38:56 And so that's kind of the traditional thinking about having projecting signs at the ground level. But you take the village, Elizabeth, you take the inside plaza walk, like where my business used to be located, that's considered the second floor of that building. Because you have the ground level, which is on the minute or up, and then you come upstairs, and you go interior. That's a problem. So you have projecting signs. So that's allowable, because it has a pedestrian walkway.

1:39:28 Yeah, no, I understand what you're saying. Now, if, like, and I used another example I was using was Roberto's. When Roberto's built their second floor, it's still Roberto's, but if that was a second floor business separate, separate entrance, then they should be allowed to have a projecting sign off that second floor because Old Mammoth Road is a pedestrian walkway. Whereas here in this hallway,

1:39:56 It doesn't make sense on the interior, projecting signs coming out that people are going to walk into. Well, and I think a project, even if it's above Roberto's and it's a different business, I think it would look strange to have a sign. I mean, the wall sign would be sufficient in my, so that's why I didn't have any problem with this. Some concerns may also be potential impacts to the corridor, having projecting signs that may project up to six feet.

1:40:25 Out from the building? Okay, you persuaded me right there. Yeah, and I was thinking of Sierra Nevada Lodge, too, on the new building that would go in, and they have the second floor, and what I had brought forward is the fact that you've got, you know, we're encouraging people to do setbacks on their property, so they could have a second floor exterior area with retail, but that's allowable because it's a pedestrian walkway. Okay.

1:40:50 So, you know. Then I'm good with it. If they have their interior, like in their model with the greenhouse, that kind of farmer's market thing, they would also be able to have projecting signs because there's a pedestrian logway. So that's, because I had the issues with it too, and that's what resolved them for me. Okay. Any other comments? Jen? Okay.

1:41:15 A couple of slides I have here just reflect the comments that we've received so far from Mr. Taylor and the Mammoth Board of Realtors. Yeah, let me just, is there anyone in the public that wants to address what we just went through, the questions that we just went through at all? Okay. All right, yeah, so if we can move on to the Board of Realtors, and for the public, there should be copies in the back there of letters we received from the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors regarding real estate signs, and then from Mr. Taylor regarding the...

1:41:46 Nonconforming signs. I personally didn't put them there, but what I am going to do, because I didn't know if anybody would bring anything to the meeting, I do post them on the system, so if someone looks later, if not tomorrow morning, I will include all the handouts. Does anyone in the audience wish to see these, because you're welcome to use mine if you'd like to? I do have them summarized here, too, so we can go through them pretty quickly.

1:42:11 So Mr. Taylor's comments related to amortization, which has been brought up a couple of times, which is proposing to have a period, a length of time that allows for depreciation of the value of a sign for an owner that is non-conforming. So what that would mean is if there is a non-conforming sign, have a proposed provision that says that those signs have a

1:42:40 A useful sign life of 10 years, 15 years, and they may continue their sign for 10 or 15 years, then at the end of 10 or 15 years, those signs must be removed. That avoids the Fifth Amendment issue of providing compensation for the taking of public property and has been validated by the courts as a constitutional way to allow for the removal of non-conforming signs. Jen, if we can amplify on that just a little bit so people understand that. The way I understand that is that

1:43:10 You can't take property without just compensation, but the amortization theory is that all of these signs over some period of time reduce in value to where you aren't taking anything. That's essentially what you're doing. Yes, thank you. And so the specific issues that were brought up are non-conforming signs that are in our commercial zones, such as pull signs and things like that. And Mr. Taylor specifically called out

1:43:40 Four questions of ways to deal with these signs. The first question is if the commission and council, if you're concerned enough about the impact of the few remaining whole signs or other non-conforming signs on the town's image, that would you want to act to have them removed? And the options to do that would be including an amortization provision, which we just discussed.

1:44:05 You could pay to have them removed, not include any amortization, just pay the fair market value of the sign and the cost to remove the sign. Or are you willing to take a more passive role, which we've done in the past, through attrition with as properties redevelop that they remove their non-conforming signs? Commissioner Clark? It might depend on how many signs we have that are really old and how many that are really new.

1:44:39 But I think we have to put some limit. I mean, if we expect to have everybody conforming at some time. So I don't know if it's 10 years. I don't know. John suggested his was, I don't know, how old did you say yours was? But I don't know. Well, I think also it comes into that the replacement of the design cost is much more than the sign originally cost. That's true.

1:45:08 So I think really what we need to do is say, you know, how long are we willing to allow these current owners to conform? Is it the 10 years? Is it 15? Is it 30? That's the direction we want to go. I'm not really into having volunteer groups go around and police the businesses. I just don't think that's good form or practice. If it's going to be somebody to do inventory, then I expect it to be staff.

1:45:36 And Council would have to direct that in the work plan. So, and I think we're speaking of very few signs, and again, it comes down to what someone's personal taste is I'm assigned to. Elizabeth? Well, I agree with Bill's letter here. I remember at our November 17th meeting with Town Council, we talked about what are some things we could do, small projects with big impact, and the first one was paint and polish way beyond.

1:46:07 Town cleanup. I mean, really make an effort. And there are some signs that are real eyesores. And I would like, we can't wait for attrition, in my view. I would like to see what we could do to, you know, get those signs improved, updated, whatever, whether it means the town has to buy them or if you buy them at fair market value, does that mean you have to pay for replacement of the sign? Yes. Okay, you have to pay for replacement of the sign. But

1:46:35 You know, they really, the traditional sore thumb, they really stick out, and I don't think they add to the town's character. I think it's just a lot of visual clutter, and I would like to see a proactive effort made to remove some of the worst offenders. You may, because Bill wasn't specific, I'm kind of curious to specifics. No, I'm not going to mention specifics, but, you know, signs that are broken, cluttered, poorly designed.

1:47:04 Leftover from the 60s? There are different issues that you're talking about, and perhaps we'll come back to you with this when we return. One, for those signs that are broken and disrepair, they need to be maintained. That's a different issue than this. Another issue is, you know, what is the best way to achieve your ends? So if you want to see conformance with the code, you know, you might find, and we'll talk to business owners, if...

1:47:30 With these regulations that are a little less restrictive and maybe more meeting their needs, maybe there's some incentive way for them to upgrade their signs over time. And then, of course, we can look into the amortization issues with you and report back on that. And I think in terms of those that are truly really old, there are signs out there that are just polls that are out there.

1:47:59 And, you know, maybe that's a different condition than anything that we've talked about. So if there's some consensus that those are the major themes, we'll address that when we come back. Is there some way to do incentives with teeth? I mean, I know that's sort of, I guess that's a carrot and stick, isn't it? Incentives are always the best, but then do we have plan B? Waive all fees. Waive fees, buy out the existing sign. I mean, I think that's, but those are all financial issues that the council would have to determine.

1:48:27 That they'd be willing to do. Well, and it may depend on how many we're talking about in town. Yeah, so maybe let me ask a question for you. How many do you think there are in town? I'm just curious. In your opinion, I'm just trying to get an idea because, you know, Bill says something that there's no specifics, and so, I mean, is it one or two? Is it 20? Oh, no, no, no, less than half a dozen.

1:48:52 Yeah. And I think if we did an amortization provision, it would apply to all non-conforming signs. So you couldn't pick and choose which signs. It would be all signs that are non-conforming with the code as written. Okay. That's a good point. I think it would be a more extensive list than just the most conspicuous. Okay. Thank you. We got that. Jay has some other comments. Can I say something? You may.

1:49:21 Four things I see going back and forth here. The first one is as to the desirability of removing non-conforming signs, I don't think I've heard anybody say that they want them to stay there, period, without any other considerations. The only person I heard say something that might be construed like that was Mr. Baruch, but I don't think he was saying that. He was making a point about how much money some people have invested.

1:49:49 in nonconforming signs, which, you know, we're trying to take into account. So the first thing I think that we can all agree on, and I'm pretty sure everybody at zoning code user group, and we've talked about this, agreed that all other things being equal, we'd like to see those signs go away. So what's left are how long do we wait and how much are we willing to pay for this?

1:50:16 We keep talking about we have different positions on that. I think maybe at this point all we can do is let staff see if they can come up with some creative ideas for some kind of a process that we can agree on that gives nonconforming, the owners of nonconforming signs enough time to do whatever we want them to do and ameliorates the cost as much as possible. So the only other thing I see that we didn't really have good answers on is what's out there.

1:50:45 So, you know, it might help to have an inventory to see what we're talking about. Yeah, and I agree with the inventory. I just think that staff should do it. And as I said with, you know, I think this amortization and the monies, that's a council issue. We would be, if we did include an amortization provision, we would have to do that inventory within four months of it becoming effective. And I did discuss with

1:51:14 With Bill, the inventory, and he even mentioned, I don't know if he mentioned it in his email, but the possibility of volunteers doing that, and that to me seemed like a possible way to do it with a minimal cost and not have a lot of staff time in it, if staff thinks that's workable. I think that's good consensus for his comments. The next letter we received was from the Board of Realtors.

1:51:42 And they had a handful of comments related to open house signs in particular, as well as other real estate signs. And their first comment related to locations of open house signs and that the draft code is written to say that open house signs would not be allowed within the public right-of-way. I'm sorry, Jen. Mark, could you for me, please? I should have had you already do this. I just want to be clear.

1:52:10 Our community appears to be having this perception word thrown around quite a bit lately. I just saw it at everyone. My spouse is a realtor, so I want to make sure that Mark answers the question that I can participate in this discussion. Typically, one, this is a workshop. Two, conflicts of interest exist when you have some noted revenue stream that's uniquely and directly related to the decision that would be made.

1:52:38 The rule of 500 feet, for example, is one, and then that rule is made not applicable if the decisions of the material would apply to some large percentage of, say, all residential projects or all commercial properties in the town. And so in this case, my opinion would be that, and I'm not an attorney, is that the real estate signs are pervasive and they...

1:53:07 They apply everywhere to the community, so no one would have that 500-foot kind of conflict. We will check with our legal counsel as we move forward on this to make sure that we're not unique to your particular income item. But with that said, this is a workshop, and you're not taking actions, you're not making recommendations. I just needed that to be said. Thank you.

1:53:37 The current code, in terms of open house signs, does have strict limitations of where they can be located. The current code states, off-site open house signs shall not be placed in landscape medians, on any paved portion of the public right-of-way or pedestrian ways, shall not be placed where these may impede vehicular or pedestrian travel, and shall not be attached to any vehicle, snow pole, any public utility poles, trees, or signs.

1:54:06 Now that does allow for the right of way that is between a sidewalk and the edge of right of way to be used for offsite open house signs. So the way the current code is written would be more restrictive in that sense. But we are working with legal counsel because there is a concern about that being a potential content based regulation because

1:54:33 You're allowing a certain type of sign based on their content to be located in an area where other signs would not be allowed. So I think on the town side, we're going to be doing more research into that to see if we can find an acceptable way to deal with that for both the realtors and our legal counsel. So as I understand the way this current language reads versus the new code,

1:55:04 The new code, instead of making distinctions about different kinds of public right-of-way, says no public right-of-way, no signs in public right-of-way. For the open house signs specifically. Right. And if we went back to the way this reads, why was the recommendation to change it from the current language?

1:55:28 Because by allowing a real estate sign to be located in the right of way, notwithstanding all these areas where they're not wouldn't be allowed, it would still be allowing a real estate sign, which is a sign based on the type of content of the sign, it's not a monument sign or a hanging sign. It's okay, I understand. So I think one of the examples that was used...

1:55:52 I'll just bring it up as the anti-Obama sign that had him with the looking like Hitler. You know, that would be allowed all through the right-of-ways if you allow real estate. I think it's going to create a lot of problems for the real estate community and for our town in the future saying you can't have real estate signs in the right-of-way because how are you going to direct somebody to get to a house in, let's say, the Knolls?

1:56:23 If you can't put a sign out on the road directing them to turn left into the Knolls, because that's the town right-of-way, how does a person know there's an open house there? If you look at Minaret and Meridian, the four corners, where you see open house signs directing people to Starwood or up to JSL, if you stop that, it's going to make it very difficult.

1:56:52 One of my arguments to this is that, you know, when I go out of town, my family goes down in Newport to Huntington, I mean, I want to get away for a few hours. We go driving around looking for open house signs just to see the homes. You know, you want to see a house on Lind Isle, so there's a sign pointing you there, so you go and see it. It's going to create us problems, I think, and we need to have a legal, I think, legal come in on this, too, because it's, I think, disenfranchising the realtors.

1:57:21 The sellers and the buyers, both, from being able to sell their properties. So it's a big question. What if you allowed signs that were for directional purposes, something like that? But aren't they also limited in hours per day? Well, that's what they're asking for. They're saying here that they would like them to be limited to no more than four hours to eight hours.

1:57:51 You know, I think they should be limited to four hours myself. That's about what an open house generally is. It's either in the morning or afternoon. And that's going to be unique to other signs that are maybe wanting to be in a right-of-way. Political signs. Political signs have their own specifications. Yard sale signs. Garage sale or whatever.

1:58:16 I think we're going to work with our attorney to see what's the best solution. I mean, personally, I just think if we allow, if we basically come in and we say, you know, allow for four hours at a time in any one given day, then you're going to alleviate that issue. So is it safe, I'm hearing some consensus, that it's not your intent to preclude real estate signs, nor is it in your, you're not also wanting to have

1:58:44 Real estate signs everywhere, and you want the public right of way to be safe, pedestrians and vehicles to move safely and operate, and you want to make sure that the inappropriate placement of signs on telephone poles and trees, you want to avoid that, nothing taped up to a mailbox. For instance, yeah, I don't want to see somebody drive into town and see a sign that says open house.

1:59:11 at the corner of the T intersection down here, Gold Mammoth and 203, pointing towards the Knolls, and then another one up at Whistee Creek, pointing towards the Knolls, and then another one at Minaret and Knolls Drive. I mean, that's ridiculous. But if it was one on Knolls Drive, at the entrance, which is in the right of way, I think that should be allowed. So I think it's within reason of what we're doing.

1:59:35 Got it. Thank you. So we'll sum that and come back to you. Did we decide how long? Four hours? Eight hours? That's actually a question coming up to us. Yeah, she's coming up to us. We will come back to you with a package of items. With number of signs and hours. Thank you. And location and care and maintenance, all that. Okay. But we're all okay with it. I mean, it shouldn't be on snow poles or utility poles, trees or anything like that, correct? Yep.

2:00:02 Okay, Jen, go ahead. Okay, the next comment was the desire to increase the allowed number of off-site open house signs to six. The current code allowed three. The proposed draft chapter is allowing up to four, and they're requesting up to six, which they said in their comments probably wouldn't be used very frequently, typically probably be four, but they want to have that flexibility.

2:00:28 And, you know, speaking with Mark and I, and actually Jay, we were at the Board of Relators meeting, and then, would you stick around for that meeting we had with Kathy Richardson? I don't think you did, who is their Board of Relators Sign Committee. You know, it came up about the fact that, and I'll use again, Minaret and Meridian, if you had two signs there directing to Starwood, you then have to have another sign directing into the Starwood entrance, and then...

2:00:57 You have to have another one directing down to the home. And, you know, it could be on a cul-de-sac or, you know, if you use the knolls or something. So the idea is more like five to six that they would actually need for specific areas, particularly in the knolls also for some of the homes that are back up in, you know, the top. You know, one, living with a realtor and knowing a lot of realtors, a lot of them are lazy about putting signs out anyway, so, you know, you don't see.

2:01:25 I don't think you're going to see people putting out, you know, multiple signs like that at all times, but I don't know, I think we need to give them a little bit more. I don't know, Jeff, to six at all. Yeah, I think six, I mean, it's, you're not going to see it as much, I don't think, but. Well, and they're only going to be up for four hours. Yeah, they're only up, exactly. I can't leave them overnight. Six seems like a bit much, but I don't know. For the sake of consensus. Well, and I keep going back to four hours. Yeah.

2:01:57 And you're not going to see them in areas where they don't need that money because really they don't want to put them out and have to pick them back up. And one on site. Yeah. That's really only five out in the hinterland. That's really allowing seven. No. No. No, one on site plus four. Plus six. No. No, plus five. So five off site plus one on site. Okay. Is that what they're requesting? Yeah. Yeah. When we had our discussion, I did read this all the way through.

2:02:24 One on-site and five off-sites. That's what it says. Okay. They had wanted seven, and then they wrote this out and said they would mitigate to six. Okay. So it's actually only requesting one additional off-site. Yeah, so it's really one additional. Okay. The next one is what we've just talked about in terms of the limited hour of display. The Realtors recommended between 48 hours. Our current code and the way that this proposed code is drafted, we limit that between dawn and dusk.

2:02:56 And I think that is easier in terms of enforcement rather than doing a timer when the four hours or eight hours starts. So I don't know how you guys feel about if that's still acceptable considering the off-site number and the duration. Well, when you talk about enforcement, dawn to dust makes sense. I mean, I can't imagine somebody going out and... That's going counter to what we just said, though. I know.

2:03:23 If you're going to increase the number of signs and reduce the number of hours, you've got them out there. If I could, I think that this is now all related, and so you've already asked for timing questions, so I think we want to come back with a salient. Well, and here's the deal, too. If you have a collector that does a home, they do it for four hours from whatever, you know, we see, somebody to hear from them, I don't see.

2:03:47 You know, like 9 to noon, and then you'll see it. They pick it up. Yeah, they pick it up, and then you'll see another realtor go out from 1 to 5 or something. So I think it's just we have to rely that, you know, we haven't seen really abuses of it. I mean, up at the corner of Lake Mary at Whiskey Creek, we do a lot with a lot of the signs out there. Okay. Should we continue? Please. Yes.

2:04:14 We just do have to get to the other items. Okay, I think this will be quick. These are the last three items. The Realtors also had concern that the draft chapter allowed commercial real estate signs to be up to 12 square feet, not including the structure, and recommends that the structure be included in the area of those signs. I think for the sake of town staff permitting and measuring sign area.

2:04:41 If that's the concern, I would prefer that the sign area be reduced from 12 square feet rather than saying the structure would have to be calculated in terms of sign area. The 12 square feet came from research of comparison codes and talking to some other realtors in town a couple years ago. Elizabeth? I have a comment here I'll just throw out here. It's just, this seems like, is this minutia what we have to?

2:05:14 It just seems like this could be synthesized. You know, we're having a workshop and we're just so bogged down in this minutia. I don't consider this minutia. If I drive down and I'm sorry, John, I see you out there, Verruc, but when I come down by Stonegate and I see that huge sign out there, the real estate sign and the way the structure is done on it, I think it's, I don't care for that. I don't think it should be allowed. That's a good point. And when I get farther down the road, I see solstice that's been up there forever with that huge structure.

2:05:43 I think that we need to have some control over that. I mean, the Highmark sign, like across the street from Mammoth Mall was obnoxious. Or whatever it was, Drew Hilt's sign that was up there. Is that Highmark or, yeah, it's Highmark. I just think that, you know, that we, commercial signs, we need to look at that. I mean, you know, could Sierra Center Mall on the side of their building put up a, you know, a sign? Could they put one on the road like they did? I think the structure has to be involved.

2:06:11 You know, in it. Is it going to have ropes tying it down? Is it... So I don't think it's minutiae. I think it's important. If you care so much about the business signs and everything else we're doing, we've got to pay attention to this also because... Okay, you're right. ...that Stonegate sign and Solstice has been up there for quite a long time. They're not just up there for a day. The difference between a large leasing sign... I'm sorry, John. I know I called you out. Sorry. I won't. The difference between... Give me a loan. ...for sale and a business sign and a large leasing sign.

2:06:41 is the sense of permanence, how long will it be up. And at some point in time, the sign that's proposing or intending to lease, if it's up for such a long period of time that it's almost permanent, then you should be concerned about it as a regular sign and how does it comply with all of the other signs. And if it's up for a year or two years, and it's not a project sign, it's not under construction.

2:07:08 I think the way that I would look at it is it's the non-temporary, temporary sign. So can we have a time period then and say over a certain length of time? Right now the real estate signs are allowed to be up for as long as the property is available for sale or lease. So I don't know how we would limit that. We're happy to come back with some alternatives for you to consider. What about if the structure that's going to be used for the sign?

2:07:39 You know, an administrative review of it, and if you felt it needed to go further, it goes to design review or something. We can do that, but I think what you should frame is the question that I just posed. You know, if it's going to be up so long, if it can be up for as long as a building would be leased, you should think of it as a sign. And so we can come back again with some options for you dealing with these questions. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions on that or any comments?

2:08:10 Go ahead, Jen. The second to last was just a question if those larger signs can be attached to a building or if their placement's regulated by CCNRs. This sign would be regulated based on whatever type of sign it is in our code, so in terms of placement, if it's monument sign, wall sign, et cetera. The last comment is requesting administrative review, which Tony mentioned, for approval for semi-permanent commercial real estate signs and to conduct yearly inspections.

2:08:38 As Mark alluded to, we do require permits for site development signs and site construction signs, which are probably the signs that some of those complaints may be related to because they are larger. And we do require permits for those, and so we will review the structure and how they're erected and displayed for that, and they do have expiration dates as well. So we'll include that when we come back.

2:09:08 Any other questions, comments? Okay, then how about the issue of the buildings that have unique circumstances, either below grade and set far back or perpendicular to the roads such as dominoes where the traditional back of the building is seen from the street? So you gave us some comments to look at that, so we will meet with some of our unique business people.

2:09:32 Okay, so we don't need to discuss that any further? No, it's where he asked if he would meet with them. They can get all those comments to bring back to us. So we're not just throwing fishing dishes out. Good. Good. Okay, that's great. Okay, thank you very much for your time. Thank you, Jen. That was a good staff report. Excellent. Next item? Next item. No other comments on this?

2:09:54 Greg? Anything from the public? John, go ahead. I'm sorry. I know you guys are a good kind of finish. I want one last comment, and that's the height of monument signs. And an example is Century 21. Tony, I think you remember that it took about three or four years to get that approved. The height is eight feet. And unfortunately, when the town blows that corner, it blows at nine feet. So I don't know if I want it goes 12 feet, but I'm just saying that the height of monument signs could be a problem on corners. Thank you.

2:10:24 That's a good point. John, go ahead. I have one quick comment. Regarding the amortization of the signs, one of my fears is if, let's say tomorrow, as soon as we have this new sign ordinance put into effect, if I get a new sign, then in nine years we have a new planning commission that decides that they don't want me to have the extra 20%, and now my sign is not performing, and I have to get a new sign in 10 years. So as much as I'd like some of these eyesore signs to go away, I don't want to fall into that same.

2:10:54 Categories. I think that's something to be aware of. That's a good point. Very good point. Thank you. Mark, you'll get that done. Yes. All right. Thank you. We're not leaving the sign.

2:11:09 Did you have more questions? Oh, yeah. Okay, well, okay. Panic. Okay, no, go ahead. Okay, well, I guess I'd need to talk specifically about the ones that I'm very concerned about. Okay. I have a whole list of pages, and I thought you had some, too, Elizabeth, maybe. No, I asked my questions. Oh, did you? Okay. So tell me what page you're going to share. All right, well, page 10, it talks about, you don't need to go here, I'll just talk about it, multi-tenant signs in a condominium complex.

2:11:38 Unit that is for sale has to have a sign? They don't have to have a sign. They're allowed to have a sign. But it just seems like that's a lot of signs. They're individual properties. Okay. Yeah, it's just laws. They're individually owned. Okay. Okay. Where you talk about commission throughout, should that be specifically planning commission, or is that understood? It would be understood. It would be understood.

2:12:07 On down, page 25, political signs, it talks about wooden posts. I think we might want to include wire frame with that. I'm sorry, and Commissioner Clark, are you saying the hand-printed numbers? Yes, hand-printed numbers. I don't know if anybody else, but it says wooden, number four up there, political signs. You know, now that you bring that up, I'm going to raise a question, and we're going to go through this anyway.

2:12:42 14 days. I mean, I've run for office. I don't leave my signs up for 14 days. They come down the next day. Why 14 days? Why are we allowing signs to be up for that long? I missed that. That's ridiculous. Yes, it's on. I haven't. 14 days. So we will look at a shorter period of time. Yeah, I mean, I...

2:13:00 I can tell you a number of times, John Eastman and I, 5.30 the next morning after a campaign, we're out there pulling signs up. I'd like to say 24 hours. I'd like to say 24 hours. I would say 24 hours or 72 hours. Certainly no more than, more than, I mean, it's certainly not 14 days. Next, what's the next one? I don't remember what page that was on, but this, page 25, should we include the wireframes or no?

2:13:29 Okay. Well, nobody uses wooden posts anymore is all I'm saying. They just aren't used. Wireframes are used. Okay. Are we going to look at 44 with the airport signs or no? Page 44. We're letting that stay. That size? Yes. That size specifically came out of the development agreement with Hot Creek.

2:13:59 We're not messing with it. Okay, page 45, I was concerned about non-conforming signs. I wrote a letter about that sign a long time ago. I'm sorry, Elizabeth? No, the airport's on. That's just like in the distant dark. Non-conforming signs. What? Non-conforming. So you're on page 45, 17.48, 130? Page 45.

2:14:31 Yes, B. Okay. Nonconforming. I just think 90 days is too long. That's actually based off of state law. State law? For, uh-huh. Oh, I apologize. 90 days is for abandoned signs. I believe actually this provision might actually also come from state law for restoration of the nonconforming sign if less than 50% is destroyed. That's just saying, so if a sign gets halfway destroyed or quarter way destroyed. Less.

2:15:02 Or, you know, less than 50%. They have, they can, if they start it within 90 days, they can repair the sign and leave it up. And I can confirm that with our town attorney. So you think at state we don't have any choice? That's my understanding and I can confirm that. Okay, then the next page, on page 46, that they then, if they do not comply, then they still have 30 more days before the sign is taken down by the town. And again, that's state law.

2:15:33 My apologies, what section are you on? Page 46, 47, where it says, well it's actually 47, 17, 48, 140, number B, page 47. So that section is talking specifically about abandoned signs, it's not related to non-conformal signs. Right, that section is. Correct. And is that state law?

2:15:59 That is my understanding as well. Okay. So we don't have – so they get four months, basically. No, that's an – this is speaking specifically to abandoned signs, not non-conforming. Right. But this abandoned sign, they have – 90 days. Oh, I see what you're doing. 90 days plus 30 more. Right. So we get the gist of the question, which is, is it state law? If it's not, then we can do so. Okay. Thank you. That's it. Okay. Great.

2:16:26 We will move on now. Thank you, everyone, for your participation in that last issue. We will move on to a report on Mammoth View and Mr. Wardlaw. This is a policy matter and we are seeking from you, not answers on the project, not opinions about the project, but what is the methodology that's appropriate to review this project? So Mammoth View,

2:16:52 Request for fee modification and financial participation. The staff report is to present to you one, a request which is attached by the applicants who are here today, that the town cap, reduce or waive certain development fees and participate financially in certain elements of the project. What we don't want to do is talk about the elements of the project. They may or may not be valid.

2:17:21 Rather, what's more important is to seek your direction and input on the issues that should be studied and the financial policy analysis that should be conducted to process this request and seek direction as to whether the town or the applicant should fund this analysis. Walter is here. This is Walter. Hi, Walter.

2:17:50 The town of Mammoth Lakes has received a use permit and tentative tract map application for the proposed Mammoth View project. This has been presented to you in the concept review, and it's gone through and completed the concept review, which has included staff review, advisory design panel review, and planning commission workshop comments. By going through that level of development, the project, in their minds, is fairly well known.

2:18:19 And what they're facing is a financial issue, whether they can proceed or not. And so rather than proceeding through the use permit application, spending a lot of time and money and finding out that they may or may not be able to proceed, they would prefer to focus next on the issues posed in their letter, which is generally the total cost of developing and at this particular time in...

2:18:47 in the recession and in Mammoth's history. The reasons that they have suggested, which some of them may indeed have merit, we don't know, and that's why we conduct this analysis, is that this is a lodging project and a residential project. It is on the Mammoth Mountain, Mammoth View

2:19:16 Intersection, so as part of our Main Street plan. And so some of the things that we might consider with this is as it would implement one of our important new district studies, that might be a benefit to us. As a project that is conforming to our zoning and general plan standards, that perhaps is of interest to us as a project that could potentially show investment in the community and cause

2:19:44 Both short-term and long-term indirect benefits like jobs, that might be interesting to us. And from their perspective, they're suggesting that supporting the development program that would provide nightly lodging through the residential units that could be in a rental pool and a boutique hotel would result in increased town revenues, which would be sales tax, property tax, and transient occupancy tax.

2:20:13 They're suggesting that we consider supporting the signing of a brand hotel intended to increase hotel occupancy and visitor market recognition of the town. And we have been told that brand hotels add value to the community and are different than smaller non-brand hotels. I don't know that that's true or not.

2:20:42 Construction and implementation of their project and earlier operation of the project. So we would see an earlier flow of revenues. And earlier means that it would not now be feasible in their minds. And then finally in their letters they have suggested that we participate in a geothermal system. And I don't think the subject for us right now is...

2:21:06 Whether that's useful or not. It's some form of financial participation. Whether it went into a parking structure or an off-site improvement like a sidewalk or Main Street, that's the idea of participation. We certainly couldn't participate in a gift of public funds. So, with that general context, we do believe that the project has merit, and we think that it's posing a couple of...

2:21:34 Major questions. One is the financial analysis. Does any of this make sense to us? Is it practical? Is it feasible? Does it work within this current foreseeable marketplace? Are their numbers accurate? And we would conduct that analysis by hiring an outside real estate economic firm that was qualified and experienced like Kaiser Marston or Economic Planning Assistant.

2:22:03 Through this process, we've worked with the design review committee on this so that we didn't create a quorum issue because they have worked on it from the design review aspect. And we framed the issues that the financial analysis should consider, which I've summed already for you. We sent out proposals, a request for proposal scope of work to both Kaiser Marston and EPS, and the committee and staff felt that EPS was

2:22:33 The better of the two primarily through their experience now in the town and the related work that they're doing. The scope of work is attached and it looks to be a thorough scope and the estimated budget for that effort is $15,000. If additional work, we would expect the applicant to provide substantial information, share performance so that Mr. Kieser could do that work.

2:23:00 If they didn't, Mr. Kieser would have to do that work, which would be an added cost. The committee and staff agreed that EPS would be a preferred consultant for this effort. The more difficult analysis is policy. How does the town respond to a request like this? We all know that we're still in a recession. We're seeing halting job growth. Maybe we've bottomed out, maybe we haven't.

2:23:29 What we do for one applicant purportedly we would do for other applicants that show similar merit. The existing development impact fee policy allows the town to participate and negotiate future TOT to development impact relationships. But this goes a little bit beyond that. And we think that it's such a significant and important request.

2:23:56 That we should do this in a very open, transparent way so that it can stand the test of not only criticism, but it can last and be employed as other projects go forward, whatever the outcome and the answer is. So to that end, we have framed a methodology that is really asking, do our current regulatory mechanisms...

2:24:26 and does our regulatory approach, will it implement the vision that has been expressed in all of our documents? The general plan, the master plans that have been prepared, and the district studies that are completed and still being formulated actually pose a very, very different future for this town than what we have now. Main Street calls for

2:24:55 A different Main Street. It calls for buildings to, over time, be developed on the frontage roads. And it calls for a Main Street environment where shops and stores and restaurants are up to a very well-designed sidewalk that is also landscaped. And you see a completely different streetscape along Main Street. That will not happen only by the town taking action.

2:25:23 It requires investment from the private sector and where developers obtain their funding through capital and equity markets. And if we can express the idea of the plan as a very bold, visionary plan and just accept that the general plan and those studies contain that information.

2:25:45 And that the regulations that will come from the zoning code update, a very firm and fixed understanding of height, whether it's 35 feet or 47 feet, that we're not speaking to those regulations. We're really asking ourselves, how do we approach this in a way of attracting investment? Are we making it difficult? Are we making it easy? Do our development impact fees support the implementation of...

2:26:15 That vision. Are we asking for pennies up front in the total scheme of things versus developing the long-term revenue stream that's necessary to fund and build everything that we think that we want out of this community? So to form that analysis, we've posed the general plan and the triple bottom line as the vision that's meant to be achieved.

2:26:43 Then we've identified the essence of our regulations, how responsive and flexible we are, our fees, are they reflective of the market or are they inflexible, development impact fees, and how we view fiscal benefits and indirect benefits like jobs and short-term construction jobs and long-term employment that would be provided through the new hotel or the new restaurant. And then finally,

2:27:13 I think it's very well known and accepted that if a community is a very difficult place to work, decisions and policies are arbitrary and capricious, things are confounded and confused, that won't be an attractive place for investment. Those investors can find other places to invest their funds. The idea of momentum.

2:27:42 Being a can-do community, a community that knows what it wants and is prepared to support that kind of future. One that has clear fiscal strategies. Are the town's monies directed in places that also support that vision? And so is there a clear, compelling business strategy? So comparing the regulations to that plan is then probably best done by trying to describe

2:28:13 What the different future alternatives could be. And I think everybody has heard more or less the phrase from Arnold Schwarzenegger, former governor, that this place hasn't changed since the 80s. And to some degree that's true. When we look at other communities, peer resorts or California communities, and the success that they've had in filling their existing buildings, supporting businesses.

2:28:41 And then seeing the appropriate forms of investment and development, many communities have taken great strides. They have very progressive transit programs that are funded in part or in all through public participation. So the futures that we have posed is one of low plan achievement. So we're not really, even though we have the plan, we're not well geared to achieve it. The next level up is partial plan achievement.

2:29:11 And I think that represents for us the idea that, you know, we've made some inroads. The development agreement with Snow Creek is starting to look at the unique site conditions that were posed, and we did some form of negotiation. The Old Mammoth Place project, the incentive zoning program was tailored to be more specific to achieving the town's objectives and the applicant's objectives on that site.

2:29:39 But they didn't address the fundamental overarching aspects of the economy. Then the next degree is a modest plan achievement. We're probably making inroads on development. We're starting to see an increase of visitation. But we're still lagging behind the marketplace and our ability to attract resort investment. And then the final future is one of full plan achievement.

2:30:08 So our objective today,

2:30:38 is to pose this method, and I'm trying to be brief because of the time that's left, and try to frame a thought process and see if the Planning Commission feels that this method, both the financial and the policy work, the analysis, and they mutually support one another. You can't do one without the other. If this would provide information for you to be able to weigh in and consider the request.

2:31:07 So this is not the analysis, it's the proposed method of an analysis. I've had a number of council members in the past week express to me that their concern with Community Development and Planning Commission has been our work program and that they feel that there are two priorities and that is completion of the zoning code update and completion of district plan. So where does this fit in at with the work program?

2:31:38 And should this have not gone to council first and then come back to us? Those are good questions. So first, the first question is, you have received an application for a use permit, and we must process that application. So we have to staff this, regardless of what items are. And you know that principally we've taken most of our work.

2:32:04 Assign current permit work to Pam Kobylarz and under the supervision of Sandra. So we're able to staff this effort, but this represents a significant policy. And I think another way to deal with this is you can look at the applicant and say we're too busy to handle your request for a fee modification. You need not consider that application. However, what we find

2:32:33 Interesting is, as mentioned in this report, we have a number of related studies that are going on. One, we're working on a resort investment, public facility settlement, which is trying to rationalize the priorities of investment in this community with the intent of achieving the plan vision. And so do we have our public monies invested so that there's a real return on investment? And that's both

2:33:02 A facility and a financial issue that relates to TOT and attracting visitors to the community. Another issue, another effort that's going on is the Town Council Finance Committee, which they'll be meeting tonight at 6, one of the reasons Walter is here. And that is very similar and overlapping with the resort investment element, also very focused on the fiscal aspects of the town.

2:33:30 And how Measure R and Measure U can be harnessed to implement projects and, again, achieve return on investment. And then finally, we have the Development Forecast Program that is being conducted by Walter. That is a direct outgrowth of the CFFC work to make sure that as we've projected these futures, if you will, that we understand the programs that we should be designing to.

2:33:57 And if we're building, say,

2:34:24 A certain facility, what should it be designed to? What is the affordable housing program that we should be designed to? That number will directly flow into the housing limits. So the question about our priorities, we have to staff the application itself, and I think that this policy work relates to and is not necessarily a new item in our workload. In terms of taking this to the council,

2:34:51 We thought it most appropriate to bring it first to the Planning Commission so that there was a recommendation from this body who the Council feels is the economic development body of the town. That's what they told you at your last joint session. We could have gone faster and gone to the Council, but we felt that getting the input from the Commission itself, who has also seen the concept review and have some sense of the merits of the project itself, was beneficial.

2:35:21 Questions? Questions or comments? No, I don't have any questions. All right then. Is the applicant going to you? Do you wish to address this at all? Well, basically, you know, we're here, you know, direct questions about us, about the project. So, you know, really the fee request from our point of view stems from twofold. One is...

2:35:56 Building a hotel is basically a challenge economically, but most importantly, the current fee structure is really a disincentive for developers to build hotels because we could actually build a fully four-sale product and the fees end up being lower than if we build a hotel that generates TOT.

2:36:23 For the town. And for us, I think that wraps into the policy issues that Mark illustrated. But if you have any questions, we're here for you guys. Any questions, Hector? No. Okay. And let's move into your discussion. I think this is a really thoughtful analysis of how to get where we think we want to go according to the general plan or how not to get there.

2:36:54 And this poses questions that have needed to be asked for a long, long time. And I'm very glad it came to Planning Commission first. This is a case where the recession is turning out maybe to be a boon for us because we're forced into sort of crisis mode and we're sort of thinking of different scenarios. Oh, gee, this is really serious. We all know that. But how are we going to get out of it? And these four different...

2:37:24 Options, I would, I would like to hear the council discussion of that, I like the way Mark has laid this out, and I think this is absolutely relevant, useful, and necessary, so I support this going to council, that's it. Commissioner. Are you saying that you support what, Elizabeth? The hiring ESP or no, or what? EPS, yes, definitely. Sorry about that. For this project and just the

2:37:53 Discussing these scenarios and how it relates to the request of the applicant who, you know, there's no financial incentive for us to build a hotel and we want some consideration and this is why and so I think council needs to have that discussion. I agree. Okay. I think if we approve this and go ahead and have the study from EPS and then look at the policy issues and conclude that

2:38:24 We should keep doing the things the same way we are, then in hindsight we'll say, well, this wasn't worth it. But the likelihood of that being the outcome I think is exceedingly low. I think it's much more likely that we're going to conclude that there's a lot we can do, that we ought to be restructuring our policy towards what Mark identified as the fourth alternative full plan achievement.

2:38:50 So I'm highly supportive of going ahead with this. Yeah, and I, you know, my point, I guess, about council is I think it should have gone straight to council because the full plan achievement is what it's all about. Absolutely. I have no issues with this. It should go to council. It's up to them and they can send it back to us so we know what we're working with. You know, my position has been all along that fees should be reduced on all levels. We should have already done it. It should have been done two years ago, more than what they have been.

2:39:21 Fine with this going. I think it needs to go to council and get back to us immediately so we can get sticks in the ground and start having our town become healthy again. Well, without looking at what the results are from EPS, I mean, that's what I want to see. I want to see the study. Oh, no, that's just my opinion is we should have already reduced, but if it takes spending $15,000 on the town's part to get an answer, then that's what the council could do. Well, I think this is somewhat unique.

2:39:49 Approach, and I think it's excellent, but I'd like to see the data support it. And I agree with you, Jay, that it's going to be very, very small, but it's not going to support moving forward. All right, so is there a motion? Go forward. I guess option one is where I'm. Where is that your motion? That is my motion, that option one would recommend that town council move forward with the EPS contract.

2:40:23 Is there a second? I'll second that. Any further discussion? Can we have a roll call, please? Mr. Clark? Aye. Chair Barrett? Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Okay, the motion passes. It's up to council. Thanks for coming, Hector. Do you know which meeting this will be discussed at council? Next meeting. Next meeting.

2:40:51 Okay. So may I recommend that our design committee of Jay and Elizabeth, if they wish to be there, to give any Planning Commission input, that they be there? If you wish. I'd like to. I can't be. I'll be out of town. Okay. Well, Elizabeth, since you were on this committee, you and Jay, so if you're comfortable with that. Okay. All right. We will move on to our preparation for our Joint Town Council Planning Commission study session. And Mark.

2:41:23 This is preparation for your next joint session, which is also scheduled for the 16th, I believe, at 5 p.m. When is it? Your joints. 16th. Yes. So I'm not going to be there. Next Wednesday we have a joint session? Yeah. So you're not here and you're not here? I will. Well, let's hold this item, but if it turns out that we don't have a full meeting, we may wish to postpone this.

2:41:50 Sounds like three. If you two aren't going to be here. Rhonda won't be here. Rhonda won't be here. That's three of the members. So is there a joint session or not? I don't have that on my calendar. Are you here on this? You didn't have it on your calendar? No, I'm in town on the 16th, but I didn't know there was a joint session. Well, that still only leaves two of us to attend. So we'll work that out. Okay. I think it'd be useful to have this discussion while you're here, if you still wish to. Have this discussion right now today? Yeah. Okay.

2:42:22 Okay, so if the meeting's canceled for the 16th, you'll have the information and move it to the next day. You know, as we're going through the zoning code, one of the clear objectives of this code is to be clear, decisive, and set regulations that end that sense of policy squishiness that we have.

2:42:47 And building height is one of those most important items, and it's been one of the most controversial. Mayor Harvey has suggested that he would like to have a joint session discussion about how we establish the building height requirements of the zoning code. You have already done and experienced, as has the town council, a number of projects.

2:43:15 The Snow Creek Project, the Clearwater Project, and the subsequent Old Mammoth Place. You've gone through the district planning studies. You've completed the Mammoth Crossings projects. And we think that this is a great opportunity for you, the Planning Commission, to frame the method about how you work effectively with the council to close out and establish these building heights.

2:43:45 Some of the issues that we think you should consider in a way, and we know this already, the code is just horrible about establishing building standards, and we've made a lot of improvements in the recent work, but still controversy remains. Our building standards are unclear.

2:44:07 Keep showing you that one little thumbnail sketch of something that looks like a house but it might not be a house. That's the only graphic in the whole code. The code doesn't address mechanical features and we all know that buildings have roofs and then on those roofs we have elevators and stairwells and we have duct work and we have heating units and cooling units and those aren't well addressed. View corridors.

2:44:35 Not every street is a view corridor. We all have a sense of the unique, magical setting that we're in. But some streets, especially because they will have higher levels of development than, say, a single-family home, need greater attention and care than other streets. And so how should we address the protection of those specific corridors? And what we shouldn't have are more amorphous standards that say,

2:45:04 Protect all views. Because that's not useful. That's not clear to a developer. It's not clear to an architect. It's not clear to us. And so we want to be as precise as we can. Vistas and views. And from what, as you recall, on Old Mammoth Place, we looked at the sidewalks and we looked at vistas, down view corridors, and to what extent

2:45:31 Views up the town, how do those play into our regulations? We certainly now are pretty thorough on sun, shade, and shadow impacts, but the code is not. Building height within tree canopy, we'd like to close that out, be very clear there. Neighborhood pattern and the transition of a commercial district to a residential district, we want to be sure we can cover those issues. Building construction techniques matter.

2:46:00 The building code sets up different standards for different types of construction. So wood frame construction is different than concrete. Fire protected above parking structures are different than a building on the ground. So those affect building construction and what the buildings look like. Economics.

2:46:24 We all know that economics has some factor in our decision making. Some people feel that the land prices have allowed intensity to change. I don't know that that's true, but how do we deal with that? Building articulation, just the mass and form, which you've dealt with now in having shaped buildings, are there alternatives where building mass can move around in lieu of another location?

2:46:51 Could you add to that, since I'm sure this list will be transposed, you know, when we have our discussion building and roof articulation? Yes. I'd be really specific about that because when people get so hung up on the height, they don't think about, you know, perfectly flat roof. And Mark, too, I mean, I think we've all read this. Do you want to go through each one like you're doing? No, I don't. Okay, because I don't think you need to myself. So if I may, could I?

2:47:22 Start with Elizabeth. Elizabeth, on 1 through 6, do you have anything that you'd like to add on? We can discuss some, but is there anything you'd like to add on first to any of these issues? No. Well, let's see. Sloped roof and pitched roof. I'm thinking about the, what do they call it, the 4 and 10 pitch? What is that? 4 and 10 pitch. 4 and 10 pitch? And I'm thinking sort of how boring that is.

2:47:55 But that would have to do with roof articulation. Maybe a little bit more about the pitch of a roof. Because a lot of these, to comply with a letter of whatever is finally decided upon, can end up in some really boring, ugly architecture. That's what I'm thinking. Anything else you'd like to add? No, that would be it. Commissioner Clark? Under two, I would like to add neighborhood compatibility. That's it. That's it. Okay. No, I don't have anything to add. I thought it was very complete.

2:48:35 And I felt this was a very complete list also. I have nothing to add. Is there anything that any commissioner feels should not be on this list on items one through six? I like how it will really focus the discussion. It's just very specific. You can get your hands around it. And then, okay, so my question then is we deal with this on an every day, every week basis as a planning commission. And I'm not saying that council doesn't, but

2:49:07 I think as much information, visual information, that we could provide to council on these, from slope to parapet to pitched roofs to, you know, anything and everything, appurtenances and what they really are, anything and everything that we do in a visual way to show them and demonstrate will keep the conversation going because there's a lot to get through here and I can't see us getting through all of this in one session and if we could, that would be wonderful.

2:49:37 But I think the more information they have ahead of time by way of visuals and explanation, terminology, what it means, the better off we're going to be to come to a good conclusion. Yeah. And I agree. And my way of characterizing that would be quantitative information. That, you know, if we start talking about a village and the trees and don't get beyond that, we don't have any framework for making decisions. Exactly. That's good. And I'll follow up on that. You know, my interpretation, my...

2:50:06 perception of what a village in the trees is, is Mammoth Lake is surrounded by the forest. We're a village in the trees. Others, it's how many trees are on a piece of property. So I think that we really have to be careful to just, I mean, we need to have success here and to move forward. And in order to do that, you know, we need good information from the council. So let's give them as much information as possible.

2:50:29 How does the commission feel about photographs like Jen showed in her report? Absolutely, that's what I'm speaking of. With good and not good, you know, the contrast. Right. Okay. Yeah, but the explanation goes with that, too. Yes. You know, like where you brought up the pig thing with not being able to read that. Well, we were able to read it, so.

2:50:51 We have to be sure that what we're showing them is something that's going to have a positive outcome. And some of this isn't easy. I think back to the hearing on Old Mammoth Place, and I am still talking with people who don't understand that analysis. It's a struggle, but we need to try as much as we can to make that understandable to the council. Actually, every one of these...

2:51:19 Points has to have the images to go with it. I mean, that's a big PowerPoint. Yeah. But it's a lot of time to get through all of this. I know. But it won't be a productive, there's the word I'm looking for, productive discussion, unless we do. Yeah, and that's my point. Also, perhaps, going on with Sharon about neighborhoods, you know, I think that we have to look at districts for this and apply it to each individual district. So...

2:51:47 However you would like to take it. Let's add that to number two. But we need to say it because we're talking about district planning and that's what this comes in at because what's good in one district may not be good with the neighborhood in another district and that's what we have to resolve for the general plan and zoning code updates so we're complete. I was concerned about your somewhere in the staff report it said that so many of our undeveloped lots are

2:52:12 And we only have very few left, and the ones that are... I know about slope. I live on one, but is that going to create even more problems? Well, I think the point of that, if I may, is that we have very few lots left, and the ones that are left are very hard to build lots. So what we're doing, are we just doing a lot of work that's only going to apply to some lots like that? They're going to come back for variances anyway? Do we leave them alone? No, I think...

2:52:41 Is that addressed specifically here, Mark, you think? Yes. Okay. Okay. You know, what's going to be artful about this conversation is we want to have, we want to make sure that we understand the path to complete the zoning code and making sure that you've heard the council and put in direction and you have the methodology so that

2:53:09 If there's information you need to be able to make decisions, that we're providing that information, and that we're not making decisions on beliefs. And all the information is presented, and then at that final hearing, when it's adopted, we just keep moving. And then I have to ask you the question, too. Looking at all of this, did we really think we would get through in an hour?

2:53:37 Well, see, I don't think this is the answer time. This is not the place where I think human consensus form are saying, okay, we all think 37 feet is the height for that zone. I think it's how are you getting to the height determination. And still, I'll still leave it there. There's a lot. I mean, I think that we need to have more than an hour myself even to come up with the direction that we're going to go. I don't think we're going to get through this in an hour.

2:54:07 Speak to the mayor to see how we'd like to handle the schedule in a different way. Yeah, maybe showing, yes, but this outline, there's a lot. Unless I'm missing something, I mean. Maybe should there be a presentation and then the discussion at a subsequent meeting? That's what I'm thinking, yes. Just the presentation, it's more than education. I would much rather not...

2:54:29 Do it that way. I'd rather schedule two hours sometimes so we get the presentation and the discussion at the same time. And they will have the packet ahead of time so they will have seen that. Well, I just think I'd rather do that. And I would like to see this happen. I mean, this is very critical. The reason our general plan, the land use, was left alone was because of this issue right here.

2:54:54 I think as much public input if it even requires a Saturday workshop like we've done in the past. You know, this issue here that we're looking at is the crux of our general planning where we stalled out for years and it's not going to get completed in a productive way in just one or two meetings. And we need as much public input because when you talk to the public, hype and massing are the major things they look at.

2:55:23 No matter what we've done here and how we've tried to get it out to the public of why projects have been approved, as Jay said, they still don't get it. We're not doing our job explaining it. We need to. We need to educate them and work with them in that. Do you think a Saturday workshop or an evening workshop? I think having both. I mean, I think we need to... I don't think we're going to get this... I wouldn't be comfortable in one two-hour meeting or two one-hour meetings saying, okay, we've got direction here. I just...

2:55:51 We need to be exact on this because this is what the general plan has been waiting for. We do what we need to do, whatever it takes to get it resolved. That's right, yeah. So however long it takes. Thank you. Okay, any other questions on that? Comments? All right, we will move on to fiscal year 11-12 work program development. Mr. Wardlaw, again. There is 6 o'clock in the evening. I have to tell the council we will.

2:56:35 So, we've held a, the Planning Commission has held a few meetings. You've received the Destination Resort Community Economic Development Strategy Progress Report, and we are formulating work programs now, and Ray Jarvis was going to be here with us. I don't know if he'll be able to make it now.

2:57:02 This is a, I want to review this with you to make sure that we've captured your comments that you've made to us during your discussion of this progress report and also during your discussion of visitor experience and what we're trying to achieve. So let me explain what this is. In the resort strategy, there are a series of objectives, a lot of objectives, and we're very pointed in

2:57:30 Stating an objective, a task to complete, and we gave it a time frame. And because of budget issues and changes in circumstances and situations for the town, we completed a lot of this work, but a lot of the work was not completed. So this is a table to illustrate in the most simplest of ways the

2:57:56 Completion of the objectives that were listed and showing them phased over a period of time. And if you just turn to page two, I can explain how this table works. The first column includes a major initiative theme, like air service, and the link, where the objective item came from. And they're all from the resort strategy, unless noted otherwise, like the general plan.

2:58:26 Planning Commission comments are stated. Then we speak specifically to what the objective is. Complete mobility plan. So get the mobility plan done. The next four columns represent fiscal years. The first is where we are today. We're still in fiscal year 10-11. And now we're looking to the next three years because so many of our work programs take two to three years to complete.

2:58:55 This shows you how it flows through time and the sequence. And in one way, this represents a sense of priority because if you're going to work on it this year or next year, that's more important for some reason than working on it in the third year. So with that then, we have some terms. On page one of the document,

2:59:21 We've listed all the abbreviations that we've used. I might have missed one or two, but this is just defining what these acronyms or abbreviations mean. And then in terms of terms used, it's a little more complex. So if you look at page two, I'll walk through some of the terms. When we use the word complete in regular font, it means that we're on track to complete

2:59:48 In a certain period of time. So for the mobility plan, we will have a mobility plan drafted to be complete this fiscal year. We expect to have a draft down in April, for example. And then on the next fiscal year, 11-12, should we wish to proceed, CEQA will be required because there are new roadways shown in the mobility plan. If the word complete and the objective is shown in italics,

3:00:14 It's really already done. So we completed it this year and we moved on. When we put the word complete into a future fiscal year, our objective would be then to complete that effort in that program in the year 2011 or 2012 program. New work items are shown in bold. So if you go to page 3, and just south of the center you'll see rec strats.

3:00:45 And increased code compliance and increased care and quality. Those are new items. And so they're, believe it or not, they're darker than the others. And then on the linkage side, Planning Commission talked about increasing the level of maintenance of our public places, so we added that. The Planning Commission has talked about increased code compliance, so we added that. And the Town Council and the Rec Commission

3:01:11 And then you will see also, we can stay on this page, page three, looking at the items that says increased care and quality of public places maintenance. We would start that effort. So that's really a staffing issue. And then after that, it becomes an ongoing program. So it's become part of our administrative culture.

3:01:41 Thinking that it's continually staffed. Above that, under the Trail System and Parks and Recreation Master Plan, you'll see the word implementation. So that means we've completed the planning aspect of it, and now we're moving into implementation. And then below that, in parentheses, you'll see CIP, so our capital improvement program. So the place that you would look for those items would no longer be here. They would be embedded in our CIP program.

3:02:09 that Ray maintains. So, if I could walk you through this, starting on page two, air service is an ongoing program now. So we will see CIP efforts, but we're really staffed up and all the partners are working towards maintaining and increasing commercial air service. On the mobility plan,

3:02:34 We're on target to complete that and, if funded, conduct CEQA next year. And then throughout this document with different subheadings like the Mobility Plan or Parks and Recreation Plan, you'll see the idea of a Facilities Finance Plan. So the idea is once you've completed that Master Plan document, you need to develop in detail and specific the facilities that implement it.

3:02:58 And we would now roll that into what we would call a public facilities and financing plan. So one document that shows everything that's a public facilities program, parks, trails, the mobility program, and it would be the largest order of plan in detail, and then it would be implemented within the five-year CIP as set by priorities. So it represents a document that says that is the public facilities plan.

3:03:28 And we do not now have all of that information in one document. It's spread throughout the wind. The townwide parking plan, that becomes a public facility, so it would be embedded in that effort. And so now what you see is in the year 2011 and 12, we're starting to frame up what look to be just the resort strategy implementation items moving into the next successive years.

3:03:59 Wayfinding, that trail system master plan includes the specification package for trails well wayfinding and that will be substantially complete with the trail system master plan and then that rolls through implementation now through the CIP program and many partners are involved so we're not trying to define it we're just trying to give you that quick glance of how it lays out in priority and it will be a multi-year effort you know sign by sign

3:04:29 Batch by Batch. The particular way finding system, you can't see it up on the wall, but we've already drafted the idea of where decisions are made, and we've developed a graphic design package that will relate also to branding, so that if we would complete that through this neighborhood district planning effort, so that it could be implemented by hiring the correct firm to prepare specifications.

3:04:59 And then roll through implementation. So that starts to become a CIP effort. And we see that as one of those momentum projects that resulted from Main Street. At the bottom of the page, we have developed meeting and conference spaces. So that was a high-level strategy, but it's obviously related to private sector activities. So we might include our standards in the resort investment element and the zoning code update with incentive zoning programs.

3:05:29 But its true implementation, I think, will be primarily market-based. So before I go on, we think that this is a useful tool to sort out priorities. So if you'd like to use this and work within this, we'd like to hear from you and make sure that we've captured your comments. Maybe we just do it page by page so I don't have to go through the whole thing and then we'll go back. Thank you.

3:06:02 Let's just go page by page. So start off page two. Commissioner Clark? No questions? Is that more comments? Tammy? I would like some of those notes, like implementation would be market-based for meeting and conference spaces. I don't think that would clutter up your... It's the footnote. Footnote number one, implemented through future private sector activity.

3:06:31 I think my glasses checked out, I'm having trouble today. Okay, use it as a footnote then. The only thing I see in this whole document is, and maybe I'm missing it, because what I'm saying is I don't see is the O&M and how we're going to pay to build them. I mean, is that something that we should know before we go down a road? It seems like historically we go down roads to develop.

3:06:59 Implement it, and then we find we don't have the funds, nor do we have, have we even thought about O&M's. So, in that previous item, I mentioned the resort investment element and the finance committee. So, Walter's here tonight to start talking to the town council about what I think are the principles of public facilities financing. And the very first thing we should do is, when we start with a project, we need to understand the full life cycle costs.

3:07:27 including this from beginning to end and then the operations and maintenance. Ray and I right now are working to develop the policy structure that starts in the highest order of a general plan element and building all the way down into the capital improvement program. The capital improvement program includes the capital projects and also asset management. Asset management is

3:07:55 Maintain what you have, preserve the value of that asset, avoid future costs, increases from deferred maintenance issues. So effectively, once you have a project, your first priority should be to take care of it, or else you'll end up replacing that in a much sooner time for it. So we're working to that. So Ray and I are writing that, and we're working with Walter on that element. And at the same time,

3:08:25 Ray has staff dedicated to developing a very comprehensive five-year CIP. You have to start with the structure first by subject, storm drain, parks and rec, and we came to you I think in October asking for input on facilities and you gave us direction. We're working on that now. So you'll see this come forward and to some extent...

3:08:52 You know, you never know everything you need to know to do a work program, so you'll find items as we proceed, like under rec strats. We don't know exactly what will result, so the implementation is to be determined. Okay. That answers it. Okay. So anything else on page two? Page three? This is the first time we've seen this. I would like opportunity if I, as I study it.

3:09:19 More thoroughly to be able to email you if I have a concern. That's kind of where I'm coming from. And, you know, this is most essentially a communication tool. Are we all saying the same thing? Are we all on the same page? And ultimately, this has to go to council because, or it can help the council in determining where they want to direct their staff resources. What's the pleasure of the rest of the commission? As Commissioner Clark just requested about emailing because of not having time.

3:09:46 Well, it's terribly clear. I mean, it's very concise. So it's just a matter of studying it as far as I think. Should we continue to go page by page and then you can email any other comments you have? It's okay with me. Okay. Commissioner Pennington, page three? No, nothing on three. Commissioner Duncan? Just a matter of form. Maybe there's not a better way to do it, Mark, but the...

3:10:15 Showing the difference based on bold versus italic, it doesn't pop out at me very well. That's a good point. The italics did. The italics did, yeah. Page four. One thing, there is no footnote for two. You cut the number, but no footnote. It was just a thought. There should be a footnote. Page four. Anything right now, jumping out.

3:10:49 I'm going to put this in my copy of the general plan. I just refer to it regularly. One aside. I went through the entire action table of the general plan, and most, if not all, of those items are embedded in one way in these items. So we always try to stay current on the one- and five-year implementation items there. Commissioner Duncan? Page 5? Yes. What is this implement a gateway monumentation plan?

3:11:17 I thought that was a community project. The general plan community item is C3A1. There's a specific action that says implement a gateway plan. And the reason I put this in is, again, you can't see it, but district planning processes is leading to a hierarchy of information. So the one gateway, the community messaging.

3:11:45 District marking in some way, and then the wayfinding palette. And so if we end up proceeding with that, it should be to the fore and people should say yes or no. And so this is the way that says, hey, should we work on this project? And it's derived also from the Main Street program that talked about momentum projects. What can we do in small steps that we can afford that show progress to the planet?

3:12:14 Okay, does this mean you don't think it can happen this summer? No, no, no, this is a bigger, this is the biggest thing. Okay, it has one piece of it. And you're talking about gateways to districts too, aren't you? Yes. Okay, I understand. Okay, anything else on 5? On page 6? On 4? Nothing jumps out. Um, complete green building code standards, I thought that the new California

3:12:48 Standards came in effect January 2010. So how can we put that off until they are in effect? And so we're not modifying the state standards. The reason we have a note here that says complete via the sustainable communities. The grant that we got for the general plan. Yes. Okay. It's probable that through that grant program we will have additional building code standards. Oh, good. And so I just note that. Good. The relationship.

3:13:16 Who's your thinking? No. Okay, page 7. Just a second, one more on 6. Adopt tree preservation and restoration. Does restoration apply to replacement trees when they're in construction? This is a statement straight from the general plan, and it's something... Restoration? I don't remember that wording. It's probably replanting. Yeah, okay. But it's verbatim. I didn't make it up. So this was one of the items that you talked about during...

3:13:45 Where was height and density appropriate? And your comments were, we ought to have better tree preservation standards to apply through site planning process. And so maybe you want to push it off in a different priority, but you're showing it. And I'm not exactly sure that we can staff all of this. The next step is to build hours to resource it. Okay, page 7, 10.

3:14:15 This interpretive signage program, boy, that keeps being pushed off and pushed off because I know it's not as high a priority as storm drains and other things, but who would be doing that? It would either be the Arts Commission or it could be a number of groups. It also could be a team. It could be collaborative, you're saying? Yeah, it could be a staff project where we go to commissions to attain input. Can we just make sure it doesn't end up like previous to where it comes to us after it's already been?

3:14:45 Planned, ordered, and here's what you get? Oh, yes. Yes. Absolutely. Yes. Absolutely. Absolutely. In her nice way. I'm just going to be blunt. Okay. Page 8. Oh, I'm sorry. The last one on Saturday, Mark, evaluate quarterly economic performance. Does that get done in-house? You know, I was a little generous with this.

3:15:17 With the MTRIP information we're getting, we do get confidential information about sales tax revenues. We do have a monthly report now that goes to Council about TOT, and so we're doing it. Could we do it better? Maybe. The fact is we are now doing it, and perhaps it becomes more consolidated, more focused, but we are spending time on that effort. Thank you.

3:15:48 Commissioner Clark? He calls Commissioner Clark when she just turns a page. You can start with somebody else for a change. Commissioner Tenney? I mean, she's going right and left. I know what you're doing, but I... Okay, why are we up to funding code compliance? Let's see, we're funding code compliance 1.13A, and then that goes back to page 2, I think? Increase code compliance.

3:16:17 Are they coordinated there? One's probably using current staff to increase the code compliance. Is it at the same time? Starting and, yeah, it's the same year. Yeah. You know, you do try to change the words from the resort strategy so that it's not the perfect fit that can keep the continuity and not move into some kind of agreement program. And what we would do through code compliance if the town council wanted to add.

3:16:42 was, you know, we'd shift staff resources, existing staff to it. Yeah. I do want to point out one thing on page 8, and I think this is important. The third line, which says Objective 112D, E, F, and G, that is, there is, whatever that is, four different items. That's the essence of an economic development program, which you asked for strongly at your last workshop. And so, you know, we think that, you know,

3:17:11 You felt that that was a priority, and it is shown in this resort strategy program, so it has linkage and importance. Okay. Any other comments? Page 8. The last item overhaul of the town's website is the amount of funding necessary once that's done to...

3:17:36 Obviously, there's ongoing maintenance on any website, but is that low enough that it doesn't need to be put in here? No, it's done. We finished it, and now I think some of these things, I didn't want to put ongoing in every line. I think we got over that major thing, and we're trying to always keep up with what's fresh on our website. And there'll be little upgrades that add now and now. So if we try to do something better with the website to make Planning Commission agendas,

3:18:06 More user friendly. Oh yeah. To the person who goes to the town website and then they have to go and search it out to find Planning Commission and then they have to search out how they're going to get to the agenda because it doesn't tell you. And when you look at other items on it, I believe it says view other items, if you do click on that, then it will take you to a calendar that has town council, rec commission, planning commission, and then you have to search out the agenda.

3:18:34 It's not user-friendly. I've heard that for many, many people. It's not user-friendly. It's really not user-friendly for commission or for council. I'll look into it, yeah. I know that's a little off. I've ended up, that it's, yeah. Well, I think it's a proposed. Very well done. Okay, we're on page nine. Page nine. You know, Mark, I haven't seen anything here about increased visitation by. And here we've got prioritize visitor driving services programs and projects.

3:19:05 I just wish the phrase increased visitation, because that's what we identified as what we need to do to improve our economy, is increased visitation. 5% will do wonders. Oh, it'll do wonders. And I wish those words were in here. I don't like the verbiage on 1.13H. Yeah, that's true. So you're not only talking about seats, but number of flights. Exactly. I just wish that phrase were here.

3:19:38 Oh. Well, I don't like a theory. I don't like that phrase. It's just, it sounds like the planning speak. This is just an implementation tape from Dr. Seuss. I know, I know. This isn't only for the puppets, it's ours. It's staff, it's a council size. Okay. Maybe over the town logo or something, increase visitation. And remember that annual report is just a synopsis of the whole resort strategy.

3:20:06 But to increase visitation, you must provide value. Yes, yes, yes. And I think that's the ongoing priority mission. Perceived value and adopted value. I notice how many familiar faces I used to see around all the time. I don't see anymore. I think they've moved.

3:20:26 Well, we don't see John Walters as many of our meetings. We don't see any of these folks. Well, I don't know about John, but people who were in business here, you know, people who were still working, had kids, and you just used to, even if you didn't know them, you used to seeing them in bonds. Most of them moved away. Yeah, I know, and it makes you very sad. I mean, have you seen the current census? We've dropped in census. Are the numbers down? Yeah, if you go to the U.S. census, you can look it up. Mono County has dropped. We're down to, like, roughly, it's about 13,000.

3:20:56 Mammoth Lakes went from 8,400 down to 7,200. Oh, my goodness. So, I actually thought it was going to be a bigger drop. I thought we were going to be in the low sixes, but, so, yes? Okay. So, we received a letter dated February 8th, we received it on the 8th, and I will speak to our legal counsel about how best to address these issues, and then we'll report back to you.

3:21:26 As a body and or separate. What do you do about just errors out of the air? I mean, what they've written here is not true. It is our understanding. I mean, it's not true. We respond to it factually after we have the facts. Okay, so do you need a letter or? No. You know, we'll, either myself or the town attorney, we'll contact you to make sure that we have the facts and the understanding. Okay, fine. And then we'll deal with it.

3:21:54 The questions as best we can. Also, so tonight... But be prepared, just from experience, now that I've read through this, just have your ducks in and order your answers, especially if they go to the FPPC, because then you'll get a personal letter that you have to respond to. What is behind this? Can you share that with us? I don't know anything more than the letter says. I mean, are they advocates for the applicant? No one knows or no one can share?

3:22:22 I just, this came out of the blue. I'm just, I don't think that's actually germane. I think that we have a letter that has made some statements and that we should research them and respond factually. Good. And not suppose what. That isn't what's relevant. Okay. There's some accusations, too. It's really quite surprising. That concludes my report.

3:22:50 Questions about the March meetings? And I was concerned about the second March meeting when I have to leave early, so I don't know if we could schedule that day earlier. Commissioner Clark asked me earlier about, what's up, the 23rd, second meeting date? March 23rd. March 23rd, if perhaps we could have a 9 a.m. start date time for that meeting versus the two so that she could attend the meeting.

3:23:22 And then go on her vacation. So, I mean, I have no issue with that unless others do. I would also ask again, could we consider starting earlier in the afternoon? 1.30 or 1? Whenever you guys want to meet. Because now it's 5.30, you know, and I just... That's 5.25. That's 5.25. It's only three and a half hours. Yeah, it's... We used to have eight-hour meetings. We used to start... I know, but this is... It's late for staff, and it really makes...

3:23:49 All the staff who have childcare issues really antsy about 4.30 when things are running long, and for us to start a half hour, hour earlier, I don't see why it would be. I'd like to be an hour, so if we're going to start earlier, I'd like to do it at once. So how about if we put this on the agenda for a discussion so we're not, because it needs to be agendized, and have staff give us their recommendation also, because you keep saying about that, but then I ask them and they all say, no, we like 2 o'clock, so.

3:24:18 Well, I haven't heard specifically they like 2 o'clock, but they like afternoon. Do we have enough of us to meet those two meetings in March? I think you had the meeting, but Mr. Plum probably wanted as many of you that... Yeah, I have to recuse myself from the Plum project, so he would like to see... Well, I'm just saying for the benefit of all that on the 23rd, I have to be gone by 3 o'clock.

3:24:48 Regardless of when we... Yeah, we'll work it out. Yeah. We'll work it out. And what happens with this joint meeting that's being postponed again with Council? Well, we don't know if it's postponed yet. He has to talk to Mayor Harvey and let him know that he's only going to have two possibly... Just us? You and I. Oh, my goodness. Yeah, and that's... My apologies. I just tried to schedule my...

3:25:15 Treatments that are a non-planning commission week. And we all do that, you know, and just try and plan around a schedule. And I know that, I know that, oh, so hang on, are we, are we finished? Sorry. That's something I pull, look at you. So, so briefing matters, are we on director's report, anything, Mark? Nothing else.

3:25:42 Okay. And now we will go to announcement of future special meetings. None. Comments from the public. Seeing no one in the audience, we will conclude. No comments from the public. And we will adjourn to our regular scheduled meeting of February 23rd. Thank you all very much.