Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2019
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 2 hr 29 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
316 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:36 We are expecting our fifth commissioner to arrive, and we're getting some technical difficulties worked out as well. So at this time, I'd like to call to order the November 13th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. We will start off with a roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Present. Present. If everyone would please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Commissioner Kennedy, would you care to lead us? The Pledge of Allegiance.
1:21 To the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, and under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, everyone. I'd like to invite the public to come up to the podium if anybody would like to address the commission during public comment. I would ask if anybody has public comment in regards to anything on our business agenda or our business matters that you reframe at this time and hold on to your comments until you have a chance.
1:52 to speak at the appropriate time. So would anybody from the public like to come up and talk about anything? Public comment? Hazel Pays, Engineering Manager, Public Works, asked to give an update on two items, the Community Recreation Center and the Snow Pit. I'll start with the CRC. We've received design updates from HMC Architects.
2:27 We ran them through the Recreation Commission Ad Hoc Committee and they gave us some comments back. We are preparing an application for design review through Sandra and company and that will be moving through Planning Commission and so forth here shortly. We're still on schedule for bringing that forward for council review and approval sometime in December and January. So we're moving forward and things are starting to look pretty good.
2:54 Snow pit. I'll try to keep this short so I ask questions if you need to. Snow pit is a critical piece of infrastructure to this town for snow removal operations. I don't think that needs to be debated. The town has been working with the Forest Service on a new permit for the use of the pit since last year. Last year we received only a one-year temporary operating permit.
3:16 In October, we received a number of conditions related to the pit in order to operate it this year. We did receive a verbal commitment from the Forest Service that they would allow us to operate under those conditions. The conditions that they set dynamically changed the way we had to operate that permit. We had to reconstruct a new bid package for our contractors from scratch and pad that out in two days.
3:46 Those changes, the town or the contractor can no longer charge fees for the use of the pit. We have to monitor it full time. So someone has to be on site managing all the trucks going in and out and checking for diesel being used as a release compound. The town will be obligated to provide regular testing of the snow to make sure that no one using any type of petroleum product for release compound. We have to do a different cleanup mechanism.
4:15 And with all these changes, there was some trepidation in the contracting community about taking on such a new project without having really vetted it completely. So we didn't receive any bids on the contract to manage the pit. That's actually good news because the public contract code now allows us to
4:39 Negotiate directly with the contractor on the management of the pit. So we have some follow-up meetings tomorrow and the next day with some contractors that are interested in actually doing the work, and we'll be working with them on kind of addressing their concerns, and we'll be bringing back a contract to town council we expect on December 4th. So it is our expectation that we will have the pit fully operational for the community this winter when it does decide to arrive.
5:05 With that, I'm happy to field any questions. I feel like I'm rambling at this point. No. Anybody have questions for Hayes concerning the snow pit or the other item? On the snow pit, the thing that sort of gets under my craw a little bit, I spoke to you earlier, and it sounds as though what they're saying is they don't want anybody making money on the pit. And, okay. But at the same time, it seems as though the alternative is to have the town provide the pit without charging for it.
5:34 But it seems to me what we're doing is we're subsidizing people who have not made proper snow storage decisions in the past. So is there some mechanism by which the town is going to recoup this money that they're putting out of their coffers so that it doesn't end up subsidizing people that made bad decisions in the past? So I heard a couple questions in here, and so I'll try to address them separately.
6:02 One, as far as subsidizing businesses, I don't disagree with you. There are individuals, businesses that will be able to take advantage of the fact that we are not charging for this service. But we look at this, the snow pit, a little bit more macroscopically. It's for the entire community. If the town doesn't have it ourselves, then we can't clear the streets, roads, sidewalks, mobs, and all the other amenities that we provide for this community. So we need it. Yeah, some individuals may be able to take advantage of them not having to pay for it.
6:32 But when you look at the grand scheme of things, that's really a very small component of the benefit that the snow pit provides. As far as charging, the Forest Service basically has a list of things they can permit for, and they're very specific. And if you start to work outside of the box, they don't have a mechanism to build a town or build that contractor. And so in this instance,
6:58 The reason they're not allowing them to charge is because the pit is actually being operated by a subcontractor of the town. They do not have a mechanism to charge them because they always get their cut. And so for this season, in order to move it forward, yeah, the town is subsidizing everything. We are paying for the full operation of the pit. Moving forward.
7:16 We were planning on coming back to Town Council with a fee structure where the town would be charging the truckers or the hauling, the snow removal operators a fee for using the pit. Now, because this came to us at the 11th hour in October, we don't have time to actually write a new fee schedule, take it to Town Council, and then tell the truckers and the snow removal operators, hey, by the way, we're totally changing the game on you at the 11th hour. That just didn't feel appropriate. So, moving forward.
7:45 We plan to come back to Town Council if the Forest Service agrees with our plan sometime late spring, maybe early summer with a new fee schedule and a whole new program for operating the pit. And hopefully at that time we will have a long-term lease on the pit so that we're not doing this on an annual basis. Does that help answer those questions? It answers the question, but it sounds like a freebie this year and we'll fix it next year. That's pretty much it, yeah. Hayes, do you foresee having a multi-year contract after this?
8:15 Contract cycle? That is our goal, and that is what the town manager and myself are working towards. Got it. The only other question I had for you, Hayes, is Main Street, the sidewalk looks great. What would be the expected timeline for a complete wrap-up? So they are, they took the blankets off today. They're pulling down the traffic controls today. There's a few punch list items, some light standards that need to go in, some minor electrical work. There is a couple minor.
8:42 Pieces of concrete that need to be fixed. I met with the contractor this morning. They're saying by Friday, as far as the public is concerned, it'll be substantially complete. We do anticipate probably a good month or so of little pickup items, and we haven't got a punch list from Caltrans. There's always little things that the public really doesn't see, but as far as they're concerned by this weekend, it's open for business. Like I said, I personally think it looks fantastic. Thank you. Well done. Quickly, just on behalf of this commission.
9:11 Our sincere condolences on the recent loss of one of your staff members. Appreciate that. Thank you, Hais. Thank you. Any other member of the public like to address the commission during public comment? Then I will close public comment and we'll move on to business matters. Item number one, consider approval of design review 19-003 and adjustment 19-002.
9:41 Thank you Chandler. Thank you.
10:08 So yes, this is for design review and height adjustment applications DR-1903 and ADJ-1902 for the Mammoth Hotel project at 452 Old Mammoth Road. So a quick summary, the proposed project would consist of a complete renovation and remodel of the existing three-story Sierra Center Mall building to create a new four-story, 164-room boutique luxury hotel with accessory restaurant retail and office uses.
10:38 Part of its application, this is just a note for design review, the applicant is requesting the approval of a 10% height adjustment to allow for the total building height to reach 49.5 feet, where 45 feet is the maximum otherwise allowed, so a 4.5 foot adjustment, 10%. This would otherwise be an administrative review, but it is, since they're already in design review, they have the ability just to roll it into that, so that's what we did. So, quick overview of the purpose of design review.
11:07 It's to implement general plan policies related to community design and character, to promote excellence in site planning and design to complement the natural environment and enhance the image of the town as a mountain resort community, and to ensure that the architectural design of structures and their materials and colors are appropriate to the function of the project and visually harmonious with surrounding development. So the site location, as you all know, it is right over there.
11:34 At the intersection of Meridian Boulevard and Old Mammoth Road. Just some shots of the surrounding context. To the north of the site is an existing multi-use building that has ground floor retail with residential uses above. The top right picture is looking from Old Mammoth Road to the south of the site. And just to your left there would be where the new 540 project is under construction.
12:03 The bottom left shot is of the existing trash pickup enclosure area. That's at the north side of the site on Meridian Boulevard. To the left of that is the parking for the multi-use structure shown in the top left picture, and then to the right of that are the Mammoth Sierra townhomes. So some background. The existing building is roughly 100,633 square feet in size. It was constructed in the early 1980s before the town was incorporated. It's currently considered non-conforming.
12:32 As to parking and other zoning standards, doesn't meet our parking requirements and does not meet existing setbacks. And then there's a variety of commercial district development standards that were put in place since that building was constructed that it's not compliant with. And per municipal code section 17140, the existing non-conforming structure may be remodeled and expanded as long as the building itself is not completely demolished.
12:58 And as long as the addition is no more than 25% of the existing floor area. So just a quick process overview. The application was submitted June 27th. Staff issued our initial review comments on July 23rd. Plans were resubmitted in early September. It then had two ADP meetings, advisory design panel meetings, the first on September 20th, second on October 22nd.
13:26 The minutes from those meetings and the applicant responses to those minutes are included as an attachment in your packet. Public notice, we voluntarily sent public notice to nearby property owners. We did that on October 28th within 300 feet of the subject property. Final plans were submitted on November 7th and here we are on the 13th at the PEDC hearing.
13:52 So a bit about the site zoning. The site is zoned OMR, or Old Mammoth Road. It's intended to be an arts and culture district, medium-scale commercial development, community-serving retail, galleries, office, and service uses are among the uses listed. It calls for a mix and intensity of uses in a pedestrian-scale environment at a scale and form that is appropriate to the neighborhood context and adjacent residential uses and forms. It has a maximum FAR of 2.0.
14:21 And it's intended to be consistent with the Commercial 2 land use designation in the general plan, which I will explain right now. So this image is from the general plan. The star is where the site is located. As you can see, it's located in the C2 land use designation. This allows for the community's medium and large scale commercial mixed uses. And intended uses include retail and office space for services, as well as visitor lodging and residential uses. And that language is from the general plan.
14:51 Also in the general plan, it's shown as being in the Old Mammoth Road character district. That's described as the intent is to invite pedestrian activity, provide gathering places, opportunities for interaction, high level of detail, attractive storefronts, very pedestrian oriented, walkable, vibrant, accessible, distinctive mountain architecture, streetscapes should be safe and designed for
15:18 Pedestrians, so street furniture, trees, flowers, planters, et cetera, and the goal is to improve connectivity and circulation with bike and pedestrian paths, new sidewalks, and other multimodal transportation facilities. So the project proposal, as I kind of mentioned before, so it would include the demolition of all the existing interior improvements and mechanical systems down to the basic structural components, and so that's in keeping with the
15:48 Expansion of Nonconforming Structures section of the code. Structural upgrades in the garage and in other major structural areas to meet current building code requirements. And then addition of a fourth floor, including a new restaurant, hotel suites, common areas, and a partially open pool deck. And then the project will be reconstructed with all new materials, mechanical systems, new interiors, and then closed in with new exterior windows and facades.
16:16 The floor area of the proposed fourth floor addition is just over 24,000 square feet, so it's within that 25% maximum allowance. And the total building height proposed, as I mentioned, is 49.5 feet, which is a 10% adjustment over the 45-foot zoning allowance. So these are just images of the renderings. As you can see here, this is kind of showing just the exterior of the site with the reskinning of the building.
16:45 Oh, I just realized I forgot the materials board. It's in my office. I can go get that if needed. Or Hayes can go get it. Thanks, Aze. But the proposed material mix, it's a mix of composite siding, new awnings with weathered steel, a variety of kind of natural colored elements, new windows with
17:11 Aluminum frames that are set out from the building to create some contrast and shadowing. And then to jump into the site improvements, the project also proposes a new outdoor seating area for the proposed restaurant use, new landscaping in the parking lot and along Old Mammoth Road, a new covered bus shelter, a small pocket park at the southwest corner, southeast corner of the site, with seating, bike racks and a bike repair station.
17:39 They're also proposing to reorient the existing site access to improve pedestrian safety, create a new covered accessible pedestrian walkway that goes from the street to the main entrance of the building, and new textured pavement at pedestrian crossings at the main entrances and then also in front of the Port Cochere there. So these images are just kind of intended to show some of the proposed streetscape improvements. The top left is the pocket park area at the south part of the site, and you can see the white.
18:08 Bicycle icon, which would be where the bike repair station would be. And then further north along Old Mammoth Road, there's the covered bus stop, and you can see the seating area underneath the proposed restaurant further to the north there. So just to mention parking quickly, because the site is currently non-conforming as to parking. So currently, based on our parking requirements, there are
18:35 280 spaces required for the existing use. There are 193 spaces actually on the ground. Those are split between surface and garage spaces. The proposed project would reduce the number of parking spaces provided on site from 193 to 185, but it's also reducing the parking requirement by 51 spaces to a total of 236. So overall, it is, in terms of our code and what our code requires for parking,
19:04 The proposed project versus the existing situation is reducing the deficit in what they're not meeting with our code. They're going from 87 space deficit to 51 space deficit. So reducing the degree of nonconformity overall. Parking for the project would continue to be provided by the existing service lot and the garage with valet service proposed during the peak season.
19:28 And one of the conditions of approval does require a valet and parking management plan. So we have not totally finalized the exact hours and dates of the valet, but that is something that we are requiring them to provide. So just to jump into the key issues that are also, this is kind of how I formatted the staff report. So key issue number one is, does the proposed project meet the design review criteria? And can we make the required findings?
20:00 Biggest design review criterion, the first one, essentially requires that the site design and building design elements combine together in an attractive and visually cohesive manner that is compatible with the desired architectural character of the area in a mountain resort community, encourages increased pedestrian activity, and promotes compatibility among neighboring land uses. So in terms of the site design,
20:25 As I mentioned before, because this is considered an expansion of an existing non-conforming structure, the building footprint is staying the same. The overall footprint of the building is not changing. They are adding a new outdoor seating area, which you can see in the top left corner there of the site plan. As I mentioned, they're angling the existing site accesses and adding textured paving.
20:54 Providing new landscaping on the parking lot along Old Mammoth Road, where currently there is none, if any, because there's a little bit of landscaping on the southeast corner currently, but that's about it. New bus shelter and the existing bus turnout, a new pocket park at the south part of the site, and then pedestrian access from the street, which, if you look at the site plan on the left side, basically from the seating area, it...
21:20 Follows the contour of the building and goes behind the garage access there. So that's where it's currently you have to walk across the parking lot in front of the garage access to get into the main building entry. In terms of building design, the project is using a variety of durable facade materials. Staff believes it to be a visually cohesive design. There's clear delineation between stories, a good mix of materials without being too many materials.
21:52 Overall, the effect is to create a fairly modern aesthetic with traditional elements that are appropriate for a luxury hotel in a mountain resort town. A largely natural color palette, providing new entry window and balcony elements, new storefront windows and awnings at street level, providing new building articulation so you can see at the north.
22:15 East corner of the site above the proposed restaurant seating area. They've added some recessed balconies there and then set the fourth story balcony on top. Similarly, the bottom two images are the trash enclosure on Meridian Boulevard to the north, and then the left image is the far south side of the building, so the top of the upside down L, I guess. In those cases as well, you can see that they've added recessed balcony features on the upper stories.
22:44 to provide some relief there in articulation. So overall, staff finds that the site and building design encourage pedestrian activity, promote compatibility with neighboring land uses, and improve the architectural character of the area. These are some more renderings that were included with the plan set in your packet. These are showing kind of from the parking lot, looking in the building entry, and then the bottom two images are looking from the west across the Mammoth Sierra townhome, just to provide an idea of the scale.
23:16 And then looking from the north, from the parking lot of the multi-use building just to the north. So both of those walls currently have no windows. They're essentially back of house. So as you can see, they're adding significant facade articulation, windows, balconies, et cetera. So other design review criteria relate to streetscape improvements. We found that the proposed streetscape improvements meet the intent of the commercial district standards.
23:46 Basically to increase activity and interaction along the street, so by providing the outdoor seating area, improved landscaping and pedestrian amenities such as the crosswalks, it's meeting that intent, parking lot improvements, there are a variety of things that they're supposed to accomplish in the design review criteria including buffering surrounding uses, mitigating stormwater runoff and urban heat island effect.
24:10 Preventing pedestrian vehicle conflicts and improving safety. So we believe that compared, especially compared to the existing situation, it does all of those things. The lighting is required to meet town standards. So they haven't provided a lighting plan yet, but that's included in the conditions of approval. And then landscaping enhances the building features, promotes a natural aesthetic, and helps relate the building to the surrounding landscape.
24:36 So the last piece of the design review criteria and a requirement anyways would be consistency with the municipal code. So as I mentioned, this project is occurring under the code section that allows for expansions to non-conforming structures. The proposed addition is 24.4% of the existing floor area, so it's within the maximum 25% allowable. The project maintains existing setbacks, building footprint, and existing separation between buildings.
25:05 The project FAR is at 1.48, which is within the 2.0 that's allowed in the zone. And as I mentioned, the project reduces the degree of nonconformity with regards to parking by decreasing the existing parking deficit. In terms of snow storage, because I know this has been brought up by some public comments as well. So the OMR zone requires a snow storage area equal to 60% of all uncovered parking and driveway areas. So in this case, that would be 22,000 square feet.
25:36 They do not have that. They are proposing to use the pocket park as snow storage in the winter and to trucks to haul snow offsite, essentially, which is allowed through the code. The code allows you to reduce your onsite snow storage requirements if the owner commits to haul snow from the property. So we have in the conditions of approval that they are required to provide a snow removal and storage management plan that has to be approved by the public works director.
26:04 They have met snow storage requirements. In terms of general plan consistency, the definitions that I gave before with the Old Mammoth Road character district and the C2 land use designation, we find that the project is consistent with both of those and that it provides new lodging use. It has accessory restaurant and retail uses. Those are all uses that are mentioned in the definitions. The FAR of roughly 1.48 is consistent with the 2.0.
26:33 mentioned in the C2 land use designation, and then it also significantly enhances the streetscape by providing the seating area, crosswalks, covered bus stop, etc. Additional general plan analysis, I wouldn't go through, I wasn't going to go through all the policies, but there is the table in your staff report if you would like to look deeper into those. The town design guidelines, as I mentioned in the staff report as well, so the design review process is largely intended to implement the recommendations of the town design guidelines.
27:04 The design review criteria are intended to encompass the primary design objectives included in the design guidelines. In this case, after reviewing both the design guidelines and the design review criteria, staff finds that the design review criteria analysis adequately addresses those elements of the design guidelines that apply to the project. So we are basically joining the two and saying that the design review analysis meets this requirement as well.
27:33 So key issue number two, can findings be made for approval of a height adjustment? So the height adjustment findings, either they have to make the findings for a variance, which they did not do and cannot do necessarily, or you have to show that there's a significant public benefit that will occur, or that there will be increased pedestrian or increased public safety. So in this case, really kind of BNC, public benefit and public safety are combined.
28:03 We're going to focus on the public benefits. So the streetscape activation, staff is considering a public benefit, the outdoor seating area, the landscaping and screening, overall just kind of aesthetic improvements to the site. The covered bus stop, right now there is currently not a covered bus stop there, so you just have to stand there. So the applicant would be paying for that. The pocket park with public seating and bicycle amenities, that would be open to the public as well.
28:28 In terms of improved public safety, the reorienting the existing curb cuts and adding the textured pavers at those areas, and then the new covered pedestrian pathway, we found was a very significant increase in public safety compared to the existing situation. So also, as mentioned in the staff report, there is a permanent maintenance agreement required. So as part of the approval, the applicant will be required to provide an agreement that determines
28:57 It dictates that they will essentially never close these elements to the public, so they will remain open and accessible to the public, and that the maintenance of these facilities will be paid for by the applicant or property owner in perpetuity. So key issue number three is the proposed project consistent with CEQA. So we found that the project is categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to CEQA guidelines 15332 and field development projects.
29:30 We found the project to be consistent with the general plan and zoning code. It occurs within city limits on a project site of less than five acres, substantially surrounded by urban uses. It has no value as habitat for endangered, rare, that's supposed to say rare, or threatened species because it is completely developed. The approval would not result in any significant effects related to traffic, noise, air quality, or water quality. The scope of the project is well within what is allowed per the zoning in terms of intensity of land use.
29:58 And the site can be adequately served by all required utilities and public services. So just a bit on public comment, we've been getting some just over the last few days. As I mentioned, we sent notice to property owners within 300 feet of the property. We've received comments expressing concerns over parking, snow removal, noise, drainage, shading, and construction impacts. We've also received now three letters of support from neighboring property owners, but at the time of...
30:29 This presentation, it was two, got one like five minutes ago. So I'm just going to very quickly kind of try to address some of these and then if you have questions about any of them or would like to discuss further, please let me know. So in terms of parking, the applicant did provide a parking study. It's included as an attachment. So they did analysis that we verified basically indicating that the level of parking they're providing is adequate when used in conjunction with valet service during peak seasons.
30:58 Also, as I mentioned before, in terms of the actual municipal code, this project represents an improvement in the existing conditions. Right now, they're more severely under-parked than they will be once this project is built. So in terms of parking, we feel that the parking impacts of this project are actually not going to be significant and that they are meeting the intent of the code.
31:25 Snow removal, as I just mentioned, they are required to provide a snow removal and management plan, so that is, there were some concerns about potentially them shelving snow onto other people's property, they will not be allowed to do that, they have to manage their own snow. There was also some concern about, I believe one of the neighboring property owners currently stores snow by pushing it against the north side of the building. That's technically not allowed by code, I believe, so I don't
31:55 I think that adding windows or adding activity to that side of the building is really removing anyone's ability to manage their own snow in an appropriate manner. In terms of noise, the town is subject to a noise ordinance, so if there are, if neighbors do find it to be too noisy, there is an existing avenue that they can make a complaint and that we can conduct enforcement if necessary. They will be subject to all the existing noise standards. In terms of drainage, they're required to
32:25 Provide stormwater drainage on site. That's detailed in the conditions of approval, and they will have to meet all the town engineering standards in that regard. In terms of shading, one property owner expressed concern about shading between existing and proposed conditions. I think that the
32:48 More important comparison to make here is that they are allowed to go to 45 feet by right. So right now they're not 45 feet, but they wouldn't even have to really ask us if they decided they wanted to, I mean they would have to get a building permit, but if they wanted to say increase their ceiling heights on all three floors and just go right to 45 feet, they could do that currently just by right. So the difference is not really between what's there now and the 49 and a half feet, it's what they can do by right and the 49 and a half feet. So the four and a half foot difference
33:17 Does create additional shading, obviously, but it is, especially on the north side of the site, it is a very minor increase in the overall level of shading under the worst case scenario, which is the winter solstice. We do have some diagrams prepared by the applicant to look at if you'd like to discuss that further. Unfortunately, shading is not one of the criteria used to determine whether height adjustment is allowed. It's all based on the public benefit or the public safety component.
33:47 So staff feels comfortable overall with the increased level of shading on the site as a result of the height adjustment. And then in terms of construction, same as a few of the earlier ones, we do have existing ordinances that require mitigation of construction impacts on neighboring properties. There is a condition of approval that states that if basically if they begin demolition or construction,
34:14 And do not finish it in a timely manner that the town has the ability to pursue nuisance abatement. So there are some teeth included in the conditions of approval that are designed to prevent the project from either having significant impacts or going on for too long. That is about it. Oh, here's the shading study. So I figured I could just show this now. So in terms of the shade, so the image on the left is the 45-foot height shade.
34:45 And the image on the right is the 49.5 foot. So the analysis there with the shadow is based on the property to the north. And so under the 45 feet, you'd have about 86% shade, winter solstice at noon. And under the 49.5 feet, you'd have about 94% shade, so an increase of about 8% in the overall.
35:12 amount of the neighboring property that would be shaded during the darkest of the winter months. So in closing, staff recommends that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached PDC resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving design review application DR19003 and adjustment application ADJ19002 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. Now I'm happy to answer any questions. Thank you, Chandler.
35:46 Does anyone have any questions for staff before we invite the applicant up for a presentation? No. Can staff explain a little bit more about the permanent maintenance agreement? What does that consist of? Yeah. So we don't have it yet, but we did make this decision with our town attorney, with Andy. Initially, we had been wondering whether we should get public access easements on the property or something like that.
36:21 But in speaking with him, he said that he had just done a similar agreement for a project in Truckee and that this is actually kind of a cleaner, slightly less bulky way of achieving the same thing as a public access easement. So it'll just be basically an agreement that has one clause that says that no property owner shall ever restrict access to or make non-public the amenities that are designated as public benefits.
36:49 And that will outline basically a maintenance schedule, so when the property owner has to clean them up, whether it's annually, and basically indicating that the property owner is required to pay for that maintenance. So you're saying this applies specifically to easement, not really anything common area related? No, so we're not requiring easements from the property owner. So this is essentially...
37:19 The equivalent of a public access easement, only it's just in the form of a detailed verbal agreement. So instead of actually putting a physical easement on the property, we are just going to write out the specifics of how they're required to maintain the public benefits. Okay. So for example, the bus station, the bus stop, the applicant is going to be doing the
37:49 Reconstruction of it, I guess. Correct. Right. Are you going to require them to maintain that bus stop as well? Purpose of public benefit. Right. I believe so, although the bus stop is technically located in the town right-of-way. I understand, but since they're paying for it. Right. Yeah, I mean, honestly, we had not gotten to that level of detail.
38:16 Basically, we had just talked with Andy and decided that we were confident that we would be able to create an agreement that maintained the aspects of the project that we're calling public benefit in perpetuity. So if we feel like that includes them having to remove snow from the bus stop or remove trash or something like that, then that could be included. I'm not advocating either way. I'm just wondering.
38:43 Yeah. You know, when we have these maintenance agreements between the town and property owners. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I suppose it would just be, you know, whatever we decide is most efficient. I mean, if there's an existing town, like, cleanup vehicle or something that's already going and cleaning up the bus turnout, then maybe it makes the most sense for the town to clean the bus stop, too. But, yeah, those are all details that...
39:12 I believe we're just going to work out prior to building permit. Any other questions for staff at this time? No. Thank you, Chandler. Thank you. I'd like to invite the applicant to come up to the podium and make a presentation to the commission. I think Jeffrey's going to have, you want to make sure your presentation is ready, and then I'll have a few words, and some of it will be repetitive, so I'll apologize in advance. And then Jeffrey and...
39:48 I guess I'll start off by, this is Jeffrey Kim from Gensler, who is the lead on the project architecture and along with me, I brought Andrew Brady, who's been helping us with land use and working through the ADP process and then two of my partners, Ralph Lockhart and Leo Pratz are here today as well, so thank you for giving us this opportunity. Okay, let me start off here. Okay.
40:21 Thanks for the opportunity to continue the process of design review for our hotel renovation for Sierra Center that commenced with the advisory design panel and is now before the Planning and Economic Development Commission today. We really appreciate all the time that PDEC members, advisory design panel members and staff have put into the process and our team really appreciates all the input. It's really been great.
40:50 Before I start my presentation of our plans, let me take a moment to discuss our passion for the definition of team, and we brought this up through the ADP process. For us, team is, you know, a long-term part of this community, and we think the community plus the town of Mammoth Lakes, the design team and the developer are the team. And one of the things that together over the last several months, we've collaborated, and I think it's been a really positive process that
41:19 With everybody's input, I think the project you see before you today is a much better project than it started out back in July. In this submittal to the Planning and Economic Development Commission, we bring forward a 164-room community-centric hotel that brings in locals and visitors and becomes the authentic place to meet in Mammoth for all kinds of diverse people and events to organically collaborate, celebrate, and just have fun. Our team
41:49 Our team took all the comments from the two previous ADP meetings and also staff input and incorporated it in the submittal that's before you today. The team believes that by incorporating many of the comments made at the September 20th and October 22nd ADP meetings into this revised submittal that the project is better at meeting the combined development goals of both the community, as stated by the points that Chandler made and our development team.
42:17 Before I turn over the project to Jeffrey Kim of Gensler, our project architect, I'd like to go over some of the specifics of the hotel as it relates to the request before you. The project takes an outdated and underutilized building and adaptively reuses it, creating a vibrant new act of use. As will be further addressed by our architect, the project replaces the blank walls and outdated design of the existing building using its old structure to create visually appealing, well-designed modern building.
42:48 The project will activate and beautify the street frontage along Old Mammoth Road, providing a new street facing restaurant use with outdoor patio space, a pocket park, landscaping, bicycle amenities, storage, a new bus stop, and public seating. By adaptively reusing an existing building, we are substantially decreasing the construction impacts on the community that would result from a similarly scaled new construction.
43:16 The project would also provide new pedestrian transit-oriented amenities, creating a new covered bus stop on Old Mammoth Road, substantially increased bicycle parking, and substantially increasing pedestrian access to the building with a new protected walkway. The project would provide new hotel, meeting, event, and restaurant uses that would expand the town's hospitality offerings, providing jobs and amenities for new and additional visitors to experience the wide offerings.
43:45 And natural beauty of the town of Mammoth Lakes has to offer, expanding the existing potential of the city's vital tourism industry. And finally, and more importantly, the new hotel would also provide substantial monetary benefits to the town of Mammoth Lakes in the form of transit occupancy taxes, tourism business improvement district funds, sales tax revenues, which the city would be able to use to provide new and improved services and facilities to the residents of Mammoth Lakes.
44:15 And your guess, our general estimate is something in the neighborhood of $2.5 million a year to the town general fund through various different taxes, TBID, TOT, property tax sharing. The Gensler team will go into depth on how we address the previous ADP comments and how the materials will interact with the surroundings and architecture to make the hotel come alive. To sum it up, our team looks forward to discussing the submittal in depth.
44:42 And for the presentation of the design elements, I'm going to ask Jeffrey Kim to come up and go through a presentation. Thanks very much. Thank you. Hi, I'm Jeffrey Kim from Gensler. Thank you so much for the opportunity to present this project. And Sandra and Chandler have been vital in terms of the process. And thank you so much. Chandler did an amazing job. So it makes my job super easy. And thank you, Drew's team. They've been very collaborative.
45:11 We do appreciate the community's comments as well, both constructive and positive. So thank you as well. So I'm going to go over kind of more of the conceptual ideas of how this project came about. You know, we're definitely inspired by the mountain and the community. Jeffrey, can you speak in the mic more? Sure, absolutely. Thank you. Is that better? Okay, great. So our inspiration is the mountain.
45:42 The community, the beautiful trees, the light. So we want to kind of mimic nature. We love the colors of the trees and the amber kind of colors of the bark, the kind of changing seasons. So that was our main inspiration for the architecture. And these two kind of images were the most pivotal inspiration. One is kind of walking down this kind of long pathway lined with vertical trees.
46:11 And this little house on the right, it's kind of a modern interpretation, having the varying colors of the siding across, kind of the black frame windows, so kind of the frame's supposed to go away, but also accent your view. And the tree in the foreground, as well as the kind of sort of warmer concrete base. So we want to use materials that last, but also mimic nature.
46:38 So we consider like translating that nature to art into the architecture. And this one, this other house, this kind of warm color of the light coming through the windows, we imagine the light to be very kind of welcoming and subdued so that it becomes part of the community. You see kind of that activity at the hotel. But you see on, in this image, you see kind of the various striations of the material. So it kind of mimics, you know, just the bark lines that you see on the trees.
47:11 And definitely the kind of the most used activity up here, I guess, is kind of trekking through the snow, either snowboarding or skiing. So this project is an adaptive reuse project. And so the kind of existing datums on the building is basically this long bar and this bar that comes to Old Mammoth. So we wanted to kind of redirect the focus to a central point. So it's to this point.
47:41 Instead of looking at the building and not knowing where to go, your pathway is very clear. And then we want to mimic the kind of snow lines, the playful lines that you do while you're up in the mountain. So this is a photo-imposed of the building. As you can see, we haven't changed the footprint. It's exactly what it was before. We did change the height a bit. So the kind of added community benefit, things...
48:14 What we try to do is we have outdoor street dining, so to make the street sort of more vibrant, also covered outdoor dining, a community park, we hope that it's used a lot, it's about 2,600 square feet, kind of, we want to blur the lines so the park is not definitive, so I can't give you an exact number, but it's about 2,500 to 2,600, depending on how you count it, a bike station for the summers or whenever the weather's great for you to bike around, and a
48:43 Covered pedestrian path so the people coming into our building can kind of experience the lines as well as just be safe and not walk in front of a car. And we wanted to also slow down that path. So, you know, going through kind of like a rubble walkway, we put pavers along all the entry points so that it slows people down. And a bus stop. I mean, currently, I think this morning, woke up, saw somebody sitting on the rock and felt bad for them. So we're putting a covered bus stop.
49:13 Seating. And one thing we didn't add to it's also we're putting a kind of low level fence that's kind of playful with the lines that we're using, the kind of vertical lines again, that covers the parking so you don't just look into a parking lot but you see kind of a layered experience to see the architecture. So here are kind of the points that we were putting into as a community improvement. So here is the outdoor dining.
49:44 And then the path that you would take from this part, from Old Mammoth, is you go from a covered walkway and then into this path and then right here to straight to the building. So all of this is covered. All the shaded areas is covered. And it's a pretty generous pathway. It's eight feet wide at the slimmest point and about 12 feet wide at most points. And one thing that wasn't mentioned is we actually, we could have kept some of the parking spaces
50:13 The way it was. But we increased them to 10 by 20 feet by the new guidelines on the surface parking. So that also is kind of better for everyone. And another kind of added benefit, we believe, is this fence that blocks out a lot of the kind of the sight lines from the cars. Added bus stop here, seating covered. And this kind of community park.
50:42 with this bike station and additional bike parking beyond the requirements that are required for this building. So outdoor street dining is very important. We want this place to be vibrant all year long. Community park, kids can play, and a bike station. So you can stop, fix your bike, have a drink, stay for a bit. And a paving system that kind of mimics
51:17 The kind of natural landscapes of having leaves up. So again, our concept is to use kind of architectural materials to mimic nature. So we want it to be more playful with the paving with varying colors. And a bus station that's covered on three sides. And the top, I guess it's four. And rooftop dining. We think the rooftop dining would add a great benefit for the amazing views. I think Drew and I went up onto the rooftop and you can just see every mountain range.
51:52 It'll be a great community benefit. So here, kind of, is an overview of the building from Old Mammoth Road if you're a bird. So it's kind of bird's eye view. So you look at the parking from this view, but from the ground level you wouldn't see it. But here's the parking, the pocket park on the left. Here's the kind of new bus station. You see the paving as an entry point and the outdoor dining. So the pocket park, try to blur the kind of edges of where
52:28 The kind of foliage the area is versus the paving area. Added some boulders, added this board form concrete wall that kind of gives that rough refined look, I would say. So it imprints the kind of natural wood into the concrete. Closer view of the park and the bike station. And here's the bus station and basically we're using like Corten.
53:02 Bronze, colored materials with a kind of wood bench with a concrete back and glass to surround to protect from the wind. And the outdoor cafe here. Here's kind of the new, basically updated entry side of the southeast facade. And here, the image is a little stretched out, so it's a little bit more compact than showed, but that's your lobby entrance, which is covered as well. And you kind of see the...
53:42 Kind of varying board widths here, the variations in colors, which you see, if you look up a little bit closer, there's little different textures and colors, so we try to update that. And I'll have a board on the screen that will be bigger, but, yeah, so everyone can see. So we're trying to vary both texture, slight color variation, and then having these kind of vertical fins on the bottom to mimic that, and the vertical slats as well as the tree.
54:13 And here's kind of a night vision of what the kind of amber light would be onto the building. Here's kind of another vantage point of the southeast facade. And here, you know, it's all covered. We want to keep that board form of material and glass so that you can see all the F&B and retail elements. So here's kind of a view of the covered walkway. So we curved the kind of edges.
54:52 I think it was suggested by the commission to increase the curves and we did as much as possible. I think there were three feet and then we changed it to six feet. So you can kind of see that same kind of playful curves as you walk in. Here's another vantage point of that. And this is another request. I think we've changed the angles here to kind of mimic all the way across as it comes down. And here is the north side of the property.
55:31 It's basically CMU with these kind of accent metal frames that jet out a little bit and then we would put that composite material that mimics wood, put a little bit of what we did in the front, that vertical slats, weathered steel, the frame again, and that same kind of architectural move that happens on the Mammoth Road side on the Meridian side. And then these windows are quite small and they're all pushed slightly back.
56:01 So it has kind of a frame-focused view that's a little bit away from these residents here. So yeah, these are small balconies that recess back, and then the windows are very small. And I think one great improvement right now is the garbage area, the loading dock is open. Now it's all enclosed. There'll be a door. So our mess will stay not street fun. And here's the west elevation. So we mimic...
56:43 Kind of similar materials on the backside, same rhythms, and here's the south elevation, the walkways across, that's kind of maintained, updated, and the kind of varying striations on the facade. And as you can see, probably a little clearer here, is it comes out about 11 inches for the frame to give an added shadow and detail. So these are material selection. So we're using basically a clear glass on the bottom level.
57:19 And kind of a low-e glass for the rooms, a dark metal anodized aluminum frame that juts out, weathered steel, bronze railings, cement board that's painted, and then these kind of composite materials that basically give different textures and varying colors. So we're using both light, we're using light as the accent and a darker as the main body of the materials.
57:50 And we're trying to use natural wood on the underside of the ceiling, so wherever you can see very close in the spaces, you see the kind of natural materials. And this is the brow of the canopy. This is kind of almond color. And then the mechanical enclosure is a little bit lighter. And the existing concrete block wall, we wanted to keep it in the same spirit of all the other materials, so it's a warm brown color.
58:19 And the paving material, you can see there's a little speckle to it, so it gives kind of a glitter to it on the ground. And the board from concrete, which would use a warm gray material. So we did some shadow studies, and so basically I think Chandler covered them, but we wanted to show all the kind of time through the equinoxes. This is the spring equinox, summer and winter, which is kind of the worst case scenario. Thank you. Thank you.
59:03 Any other presentations from the applicant? No? Okay. Would you prepare to answer questions? Yep. I'm going to open it up right now to my fellow commissioners. Anybody at this time have questions for either staff or the applicant before we welcome the public to address us with public comment? Has either the applicant or staff reached out to any of these or responded to public comments as relates to
59:35 The shadow studies that we have with? No. Responded to? Correct. No. I got that comment yesterday afternoon at about 4. Okay. I think. So, yeah, I was just trying to write this presentation, et cetera. But I will. Any other questions for staff or the applicant? I think question for staff is, are there...
1:00:03 Are there other instances in Mammoth Lakes where a private developer or builder has the bus stop or are all of the other bus stops town maintained and built? Thank you. I'd like to follow up on that question actually. In the presentation, the aesthetics of the bus stop in front of the proposed hotel are much different than the aesthetics of the other bus stops throughout the community. Chandler, would you mind just
1:00:36 Maybe walking the commission through is that the final rendition of what that bus stop is going to look like or will they be more aligned with the other bus stops throughout the town? So that is still kind of up in the air. We have a condition of approval that basically requires that the Public Works Director approve the final bus stop design. I can let Hayes speak to it more if he wants. I think Public Works would prefer to have our standard
1:01:05 Town bus stop. That being said, the applicant did get some direction from the advisory design panel that they really liked the idea of the bus stop kind of blending in with the site and with the building. So we kind of had two opposing ideas about what the bus stop should look like. So yeah, that's to be worked out, but I think that any feedback that the board would want to provide in that regard would be...
1:01:35 Very helpful. So just for clarification for this room and this body, the applicant is paying for the bus stop out of their resources, but who is making the final decision? That would be the Director of Public Works, so Grady Dutton? Yep, the bus stop will be located in the right-of-way, so in the end, the town has to approve what gets built there. So yeah, it will be Grady slash Hayes. Okay.
1:02:04 So one clarification is, according to our plans, I think the bus stop is actually on our property line. Oh. It's not in the right of way, and this is why we're adding this as a public benefit, so the property lines show that the bus stop is there, because right now there's not room enough for a bus stop if it wasn't built on the property line. Got it. Yeah. Thank you for that. Oh, yeah. Has public work confirmed that?
1:02:33 That it's on the property? Yeah. I don't know that they've had, like, an independent survey or anything. Yeah, really, it's just built into the conditions of approval that they have to approve the final design. But the survey was done, though, right? Yeah, the survey shows that. It does look, based on, I mean, just based on looking at it there, it looks like I was wrong and that it is on their property. Yeah, because the property line's here, out here, straight line. But I think that it was within, Hayes, correct me if I'm wrong, our encroachment area, the public work.
1:03:01 Doesn't the town have an encroachment over that area? Correct. There's an encroachment area for the bus turnout that was constructed back in 2005 as part of the old Mammoth Road Rehabilitation Project. I think Chandler's assessment is pretty much spot on. You know, this still needs to be worked out. And the condition of approval put the final decision back in public works.
1:03:32 Based on the need for a maintenance agreement and the final location, the bus shelter will determine how this proceeds. We do have a conflict between the Public Works Department desire to have a consistent bus shelter within our public rights of way, but that does not preclude a private developer from having something on their private property. So depending on where this ultimately lands will help to guide the decision for Grady to...
1:03:58 What it's going to ultimately look like. If they propose to put it on their property and it's wholly within their right-of-way and they commit to those agreements that allow the public to use it and to maintain it in perpetuity, that'll help to guide a decision versus if it's on the town of Mammoth Lakes property and we're ultimately going to be responsible for it. So I think we would welcome comments from the commission on this item and if there's consensus on it, we would love to hear that.
1:04:25 Okay. And I do have some back pocket images. I've got a Google Street View of one of the existing town bus stops versus what they're proposing, if that would be helpful to see them side by side. I can bring it up. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. So one kind of clarification, just wanted to show, it didn't show well in our drawing, it's more of a illustrative drawing, but this is the property line right here, and the bus stop is here. Okay.
1:04:55 Maybe when we do our deliberations, we can submit our comments for public record on what we personally think would be the best course of action for the bus stop. I've got another couple quick questions for the applicant. Drew, if you wouldn't mind. Between the two restaurants, what do you foresee the staffing level being? So the operational plan of the hotel, I mean, just it...
1:05:25 I'm not deliberately to go into details about who the flag is and that stuff yet because those have not been finalized, but they're very close to being finalized. But the operational plan would be the cafe and stuff that's downstairs and the upstairs. I mean, it'd be, you know, I just don't have a concrete answer on that. I mean, we're going to have...
1:05:48 A sizable restaurant on the roof and we're going to have a cafe downstairs plus we're going to have staff in the hotel. My guess based on other hotels in Mammoth that, you know, our staff is going to be anywhere from 40 to 60 people probably when the whole thing's staffed out that rotates. Between the hotel staff and the restaurant staff. Yeah, I mean, that's a maximum, you know, and they won't all be there at the same time because they're doing shifts, but I mean, yeah, that's an operational detail that I would have to.
1:06:15 get you more information on that because we're bringing essentially a four-star operator into this and they're really going to dictate the levels of staff that is commensurate with an operation of that quality.
1:06:29 As a developer, that's really, you know, I look to the hotelier to really advise the exact staff levels. But in terms of code compliance and having the parking that is required based on the square footage of each of these facilities, that was included in the staff report and in our parking analysis. So that's how we've approached it so far. Got it. So the parking analysis, the number of parking spots below surface and above surface, you're also including employee parking in there.
1:06:58 I believe the analysis include the total parking requirements of the site. Okay. The other question I have is in the plans, you have the fort that will remain on the ground floor of the building. Is that still?
1:07:14 Well, that's obviously a business agreement between us and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. We've had very positive, cooperative conversations to include that kind of a use in there. We think it's a community benefit on top of the actual synergy of working with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. I think Tom Hodges is here and he'll talk a little bit about that. But I think our general idea is to create a really, you know, this part of Old Mammoth Road I think has a chance to be really...
1:07:39 Developed and get a lot of activity going and it is kind of the local side of town versus being up at the village which is a more visitor centric town and we really want to maintain kind of a place to hang, meet, work a little bit and come to this property so it's a community asset not just a hotel. Correct, okay. And then my last question before we go to public comment at least from me personally is
1:08:06 The rooftop pool, will that be something, an amenity open to the public or is that for guests of the hotel? It'll be available for the public to access. I haven't deserved, obviously public can come. There might be a service fee to go up there and use the facilities like it would be at most hotels, but it would be accessible to the public and obviously coming up to the restaurants, that would be accessible to the public. Matter of fact.
1:08:33 It's part of our business plan to make sure people do. I invite everyone to come up on that deck. I think it's going to be an amazing sunset cocktail to have when it's all finished. Thank you. Thank you, Drew. Any questions for the staff or the applicant? I have one other question. Can you confirm, is this a smaller footprint for the fort, the way the plans are laid out than it currently is? In actual square footage, that is a placeholder. So the exact relationship of...
1:08:59 How the interior of the hotel will be laid out. We're in the process of bringing on interior design teams and a hotelier that the space plan inside are just essentially calculations so that we can come up with an accurate parking plan. But those may get moved around. We may have common areas bleeding into the fort. It's all subject to, but we intend to really create a vibrant meeting place. So it'll be a place that you're definitely going to want to come in and hang out.
1:09:28 Thank you. Thank you, Drew. Drew, I'm sorry. Please. Sure. I have a couple other questions. You said that there's two restaurants, one downstairs, one upstairs. Correct. Right? And you have one retail space, according to the parking city I was reading in here. Is that correct? I think that's correct. It's combined floor area. It's combined floor area, so I'm not sure exactly how they broke it out. Okay. Yes.
1:09:59 So given the parking requirement that we have, that was stated in here, and the traffic study that you have done, but at the same time you're saying that you're not sure what the hotel operator and the number of employees that they may have, so I wasn't quite sure if...
1:10:27 So I think, if I may, I think you're asking two different questions. One is, what's the level of service provided? And then what's the code? And Andrew can probably talk more to this, but what's the code requirement that we're required to meet in terms of trying to reduce our footprint from the existing code requirements that we are? And that's kind of how we calculate it. I mean, Andrew, you want to? Well, I know the parking requirements, according to code,
1:10:56 You have what you have with your current design. That's fine. I'm just wondering with the type of hotel operation that you're going to have in the retail and restaurant and so forth, and given that with the traffic study that you provided, you're saying that with this traffic study, it can accommodate so many trips and so forth, so many vehicles and so forth, but you're not really telling us the
1:11:25 The size of the operation that you will actually have. So without knowing the size of the operation, how would you know? Why don't you go ahead? Thank you, commissioners. My name is Andrew Brady, counsel for the developer. We base the parking ratios based on the municipal code ratios for the use. So where you see one retail, that is just the combined square footage of retail. And those are set by the city in consideration of, you know,
1:11:55 National Parking Studies that assess what is an appropriate level of parking for a given use. So we're consistent with the code requirement for use.
1:12:04 There is a small deficit from code, but I think as we show in the parking study, we believe that with the valet parking, with the parking layout, with the conservative analysis we've done, that we will be in excess of actual demand for what we anticipate the use to be. And there's some margin of error in there. There's a number of areas where I think with the valet, we can get more cars in the garage. So I think we have very low level of concern about our actual ability to park. And then beyond that, we just park to the code requirement because
1:12:33 You know, at the stage at which we're getting approvals from you all, you know, it's often before we get real operational details down, and so we base it on the city's code requirements. And I'm just going to chime in real quick, if that's okay. So in terms of parking requirements, so office and retail actually have the same requirement. So restaurants have a higher requirement, and the hotel use is based on room count.
1:12:58 So the room count is set. If they change that, it's an amendment to the design review. They're back in the process. So basically the only thing that would increase the amount of required parking per our code is if they increased the restaurant square footage and decreased, you know, took that out of either the retail or office. But in terms of retail and office kind of like bleeding together, it's all the same parking requirement. So as long as the overall square footage of office and retail stays the same, then the parking requirement doesn't change.
1:13:28 Earlier, staff mentioned, or you mentioned that there's going to be a valet requirement as part of the conditions of approval. Condition of approval? Okay. Does that actually speak to, they're asking, or they're advocating here that they would provide six valet attendants during peak season. Is that something that it's actually stated on the agreement, or is that something that's just
1:13:58 A number that was arbitrarily suggested according to this report. Yeah, I can't really speak to the methodology of the traffic study. I can let them do that. So if you look at the traffic report, that number of valets is determined in the number of space. It actually is not an arbitrary number. It's a number that's based on an assessment of...
1:14:21 The number of cars that are coming in and how many valets we think we need to adequately park that to avoid queuing. As one of the conditions of approval, there's a valet parking plan that will have to be approved prior to the issuance of a building permit where those specific terms and requirements will be set out. Thank you. Any other questions? I had a question, I suppose, for Drew. What is the number of people employed there now, outside of the county, the lower level retail?
1:14:50 That's a great question and I don't know. I know the county I think has 120 or 130 employees over there. I don't know. I mean they come and go. I don't have a count of individual tenants. How many businesses are in there? Well, the current occupancy is about 65%. I think there are
1:15:19 13 or 14 businesses currently, including the county. And is there going to be any accommodation made for relocating those existing businesses? We actually are in, I mean, you know, it's kind of like it's our little family. And yes, we are talking to all the tenants and trying to assist them as much as possible.
1:15:41 to relocate them and in some cases we're even assisting them with construction services and helping them with lease negotiations and trying to
1:15:51 And allowing them to take improvements out of the building when it's done. So if there's any serviceable hoods or other equipment that they might be able to reinstall at another location, we're allowing them to do so. Because we think we have some really cool, vibrant businesses in there. And if we can help them in any way, that's our intent, to try and help them. And we've been actively working with several. I think even one of them's here today that's going to...
1:16:15 Make a comment, but, you know, this is our community and those are part of our, that's been kind of a little family of ours for years now and, you know, we want to see them all land on their feet as best as we could possibly do it. So, if that answers your question. Sort of, not really. Any other questions? Thank you, Drew. You got it. I'd like to invite the public up for public comment. I do believe Jamie is going to issue, is it three minute or five minute? Five minute allowance per
1:16:47 person, so if you can, please, please be succinct. Please come up to the podium. State your name. This is being recorded and being watched at home as well. Thank you.
1:17:00 Hi. Hi, Paul. Hi, Jessica. I'm Hidetoshi Seike. I'm Hidetoshi Seike. I'm Hidetoshi Seike. I'm Hidetoshi Seike. I'm Hidetoshi Seike. And I am the owner of the Summer Restaurant. And I think my restaurant is the biggest space. My restaurant is the biggest in the shopping mall. And before I start,
1:17:16 I 100% support for the hotel renovation at the Seattle Center. I opened a business two years ago, and I know it's only for two years, but I know a little bit about the town. I know, and I'm sure Mammoth Lakes needs a really nice hotel, a nice restaurant, like a fancy hotel, fancy restaurant. So if they build such a nice hotel, it's going to be a great asset of the Mammoth Lakes. I'm sure about that.
1:17:47 And yes, I'm sad that I have to move up from there because 2019 sales of the summer restaurant is planning to finish 135% to 140% versus 2018. So my business is going to be bigger in the future. So I'm sad about that. But I know, now I know how to manage a restaurant in this town. So I'm planning to open a new restaurant next year.
1:18:17 And Drew, Ralph, and Flatter, Leo, they're really supportive. They are always trying to help me. So I'm not worrying about that. So what I want to say is the hotel is going to be, I think it's going to be great. And it's going to be good for the Mammoth Lakes as well. Yes. So that's my comment for today. Do you have any questions?
1:18:45 No, but thank you, and thank you for the positive outlook on the future Mammoth Lakes. Yes, great, thank you. Thank you. Hi, good afternoon, my name is Mel Hager, and I work for the ownership group of the Minaret Village Mall, this building, and I'll keep it brief. You know, I think our main concern is the parking requirements. It was mentioned by staff that the new use of the hotel would
1:19:27 Improve the deficit from what's currently there, but given the significant vacancy at the Sierra Mall, the current deficit doesn't really manifest itself, and I think the hotel won't be significantly vacant, so I think there the deficit would manifest itself, so we would like to see perhaps a stricter requirement to parking to hold it to the code.
1:19:57 And, you know, just to be clear, we're not against the project necessarily, just saying that we feel there needs to be a stricter enforcement of the parking requirements and that, you know, we want to know what the hotel will do to ensure that people don't park on our property. I didn't see any mention in the reports about the valets.
1:20:26 The valet parking or regular parking, whether that's going to be provided free of charge or not. And that's something we wanted to know because if they're charging $40 or $30 for valet parking, I think a lot of people are going to opt maybe to walk across the street. And that's pretty much it for our comments. And especially when taking into account the allotment for snow storage, we feel the parking is very light. And thank you. Thank you.
1:21:05 Thank you, Matthew Lehman, speaking today as a citizen and also as an owner of the property where the AT&T space is located just to the north of the Sierra Center Mall. I'll start as a citizen. I'm in favor of the project. I think it's nice to see something happen over there. I certainly encourage something other than what's there now. As an owner and also as a board member for that
1:21:34 Commercial condominium complex called Meridian Commons over there. I have two items I want to address, and I think Patricia Vanders is going to address a few more, but my primary concerns, I think some of the other owners have expressed it, I haven't written anything in or called, but one would be parking. I think just as this mall is concerned about, especially if there's going to be a fee, people are going to go to the least common denominator, which is the free parking to the north. So we already,
1:22:04 On occasion get issues with that. So we can see that being amplified. So we certainly have concerns over that and are hoping that there's some sort of solution that we can find to alleviate the parking issues there now or that could potentially come. The next is shading. I think same thing. We had some owners comment on that. I, to this point, haven't commented on it.
1:22:28 I do think, and I know it's only about an 8% difference in shading, but if you do look at it, you'll see that that shading starts to creep over from the property and onto the street. And a couple years ago, we had a pretty serious issue over there because of the shading and the snow and the ice and everything else going on. But one of the problems we have is that property sits below grade.
1:22:52 And when the ice built up over there and all the sewers, the storm sewers in town backed up because it was cold and the slush was now coming down the drains, it didn't have an opportunity to melt, that slush, ice, everything that had built up started funneling down into the lower, into our property and then ultimately into our stores.
1:23:14 You know, while it may not seem like a big issue, it can become a big issue. So is it just a shading issue or is it a safety issue and a health issue? And I think it is the latter. So I think it is something that shouldn't be ignored as far as the shading. It's something we probably do need to address. And I did look at some of the design, I think some options for it. Again, I'm not opposed to the project overall.
1:23:42 I saw on the south part of the project, the southern wing, there was more of a trellised type of roof line over there, probably for the pool area, and I think if they had that type of roof line over on the north side, where obviously we're on the north end of that property, it would probably give less of an impact and allow light penetration to come through. So I think there is some sort of a solution. Again, I'm not here to.
1:24:09 Try to shoot the project down as a whole. I just don't want to see our property on the north end be already impacted further than it is. So with that, that's about all I had in HIDE. We have some property over here I can probably put you in if you need help with it. So before the other guys get there, happy to help you with it. So all right, thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon, Commissioners. Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain.
1:24:44 You know, I think you guys need to look at this project in the context of where Mammoth is currently and where we've been. And, I mean, I personally have to say I'm blown away. I mean, the fact that somebody's bringing a pure hotel project to the Planning Commission to the town for approval, first time in, I don't know how long it's been since there's been a pure hotel built in this community. It's been decades and decades.
1:25:12 And I understand the distinction for Jesco's new to the commission that, you know, this is hotel. It's not condo hotel. So you're not selling condos in order to create the hospitality, the transient bed. It's going to be developed as a pure hotel. So, I mean, we were, you know, crawling all over ourselves to try to get somebody to build a hotel in this community, you know, 10, 15 years ago when we got condo hotels. And so the fact that you actually got somebody who's willing to, you know,
1:25:41 Is bold about Mammoth, understands Mammoth, understands where our occupancy trends are going and where our ADRs are and can pull together a hotel is amazing, amazing. I don't want you guys to lose sight of that fact. And, you know, this property, you know, was mentioned and I want to highlight it as much as I possibly can, the fact that, you know, this is going to create, you know, conversion of a commercial.
1:26:07 A tired commercial property in our community, with all due respect here, just to use this, sorely in need of redevelopment, and I think, you know, this idea of adaptive redevelopment is kind of a great way to put it. I would say it's a bold adaptive redevelopment to create a hotel use, but it works perfectly. You're going to preserve the bones of this building. It's going to shorten the construction schedule by, you know, probably six to eight months over if it was a complete teardown and rebuild. So, I mean, there's just some huge, great...
1:26:37 aspects of this project that I think you guys need to recognize that, you know, how special this is. Yeah, and then with respect to the TOT, you know, based on numbers that we know, Mammoth knows, and operating the village, which we've shared with Drew, you know, I mean, this property is likely going to generate at least a million dollars in annual incremental TOT to this community. A million dollars.
1:27:05 Year after year after year after year. I mean, think about it. That's going to pay for our multi-use facility. It's called something different now. Can't keep up with the name changes. But I mean, you know, I mean, these are things that speak so strongly to, you know, our economic development of our community that need to happen. And in growing TOT is, you know,
1:27:28 Paramount to our future and being able to create revenue streams that are going to be sustainable and that are going to fund, you know, the municipal facilities we want to develop to help subsidize the development of affordable community housing in the parcel. You know, this is where the rubber meets the road. So, you know, not to mention it's going to create incremental T bid as well.
1:27:55 So, I mean, from an economic development standpoint, which you guys are the Planning and Economic Development Commission, this project is a home run. So, from that respect. So, I just, I want to wave my arms and say, hey, hey, guys, that is huge. You know, understand how huge that is. This hasn't come by, come to the, to you guys in over 20 years, to any former Planning Commission. So, that, you know, that is significant. And then, you know, the other thing too.
1:28:23 We need new lodging beds. The last product that was built was the Westin. That was 2008. So it's been over a decade since we've had new lodging. Our guests want nicer products. There's a good chance property like this could attract a national flag. That's huge. That's huge in how we're going to accommodate our guests that are coming here. I can tell you guys that our icon past sales have been
1:28:52 Growth has been tremendous this past year over last year, and I expect as a result of the fact that we've got, you know, nearly double the number of icon passes sold in Southern California than last year. There's going to be a huge demand for lodging, and we, you know, in a village, we're already, you know, pretty full on occupancy on weekends and holidays with our lodging, you know, in the village in the Westin, in Juniper.
1:29:19 So, you know, just from that respect, this is sorely needed just to serve our guests who are visiting in our community. So keep that in mind as well. And then, with respect to parking, it's really not my place to talk too much about it, but I did want to point out a few things. I mean, the fact that this property is, you know, really within walking distance from the majority of our locals' housing. So, you know, I don't...
1:29:46 Personally see it as much of an issue for employees. I think the majority of employees are going to walk to work here. I mean, it's right in the core of our community. So I think that's a huge win. And then also, the parking ratios that are in municipal code for restaurant use, I was looking at the table on the plans, 6.6 per 1,000 square feet for restaurant use. And it is noted that in the village, it's much lower. It's at 3.5 spaces per 1,000 square feet for restaurant. And I think the fact that
1:30:15 You know, you've got 164 hotel rooms on site. A lot of those people are going to be using the hotel. They're already going to be parked in the parking that's provided for the room that's covered. So I honestly don't think the demand is going to be anywhere close to what's, you know, called out in the municipal code. I think if you did a more rigorous analysis of that, you would realize that it's probably going to be fine, especially with the use of valet. And then with regards to the fort, yeah, I mean, we're...
1:30:41 We've certainly been in close contact with Drew through the whole process and we're very much supportive of continuing that initiative and we're going to certainly work with Drew to figure that out and how we can accommodate in the new construction and the redevelopment of the property to continue to incorporate that use in the property which we think is a great benefit for our community and I think it actually it's even more so as a hotel property because if
1:31:10 You know, our pass holders come up and want to stay longer, then they can lodge in that property, and then they have a place where they can work remotely. That exactly fits the bill of what that program is all about. So those are my thoughts. Thank you. Thank you, Tom. Thank you. Good afternoon. Dave Harvey. I'm speaking today as a general citizen of Mammoth, and everything Tom just said, you can take that from me also.
1:31:49 Pure Hotel is something we've all been looking for for many decades. I can think back at least 25 years. So this product is right time, right place. We talk about problems such as parking. One of the things that we've
1:32:20 worked on over the years is getting to be a pedestrian friendly community and giving people an alternative and this particular problem that I hear today, this afternoon, has to do with education and changing people's minds. If we want to be a
1:32:53 Pedestrian community, then we have to support that. We have to advertise a bit. People have to understand that that's available out there. People should come to Mammoth and park one time and then go catch the bus. It's a simple concept, but we spent a lot of years, a lot of time, a lot of effort trying to get the community in that direction.
1:33:25 We're getting close. As the last three years, going on four years now, the Historical Society has put together a program that we call History Trolley Program. Any of you that have ever been on the History Trolley, going from the village on up to the lakes basin, get entertained.
1:33:55 By the local thespians in the area. And we would like to expand that program as soon as we can. And it's been funded the last three years and we have plenty of people that are ready to get more involved in the trolley program.
1:34:27 And do this performance, if you will, in the town area. What we have found is that ridership in the Lakes Basin went off the charts. And this was a great thing. But people just have to be educated. And getting over the parking issue, we've been doing that for a whole lot of years. And we look at other places that have had success.
1:34:55 I'm fully in favor.
1:35:28 of this project. And I think, from what I can see, y'all have done a great job on it so far. Now we'll just get the bow and tie it up and get something going. Thank you so much. Thank you, David. Thank you. Hi, everyone. I'm Patricia Vanders. I'm an owner and on the HOA board at Meridian Commons. I'm also a renter here in Sierra Center Mall. I have the flower shop right over there, so this kind of impacts my whole world.
1:36:09 Not to be redundant on the parking issue, but as much as I'd love to have it all be a pedestrian situation, I like to park at my home, and I also have a delivery service through my business, so parking is a major concern on both levels for me on that.
1:36:26 More importantly, not to be repetitive about what Matthew has already said regarding our complex. Being an owner on the backside of the building, privacy would be an issue for me. Having all of these new windows looking right into my condo is not the most savory idea.
1:36:42 The hike concession also, we struggle so much in that parking lot with the ice never melting, and you can see a line just completely defined where the shadow hits. Aside from scraping up the entire asphalt, the ice maintains there pretty much all winter long. So this would extend that to the entire parking lot, which is very much a safety issue, ice skating into my front door when I get home from work, right?
1:37:08 So I guess that just keeping it really, really concise, but the privacy issues, the safety impacts, if we could have like what we saw on the pictures with the light that penetrated through on the opposite end, what I noticed on our end was an even higher metal structure, which I'm not really sure what that is, but that would create even more shadow on our end of the building. And as residents there, if we could get into the plan, something that light could penetrate.
1:37:36 That would be very helpful in our parking lot situation. I am very much an advocate of having that restoration happen on this end of town. I think it's long overdue and I am very much an advocate for that. I just hope that we can all work together so that our livability is not impacted.
1:37:55 Meridian Commons. And then as well, you know, with the parking, if it does leak over into our mall as tenants, if we have to compensate for, say, parking attendants, people enforcing parking here, that will increase our camps as renters in this mall. And so that is also a concern of mine. And I guess that's all that I have to say. Thank you. Thank you.
1:38:27 Good afternoon, my name is Tim Holman, excuse me, here on behalf of the HOA and board at Horizons 4. Concise and simple, we're excited by the project for what it'll do for our property values, what it'll do for our neighborhood.
1:38:43 Promoting the pedestrian idea, very supportive of that. And grateful for the knowledge of this meeting. Our owners sent me to say thank you, that they were made aware far in advance of what was going on and the information that was provided. So we appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Tony. Anyone else for public comment? Hello, my name is Taylor Ludwick. I own Bishop Veterinary Hospital. I'm a tenant just down the way from Patricia.
1:39:19 I do love the vision. I think it's, I think that the town is going to be well served. We service lots of transient pets as well that, excuse me, that come, I don't know if this will be a pet friendly establishment, many are, and so we are one of the folks in town that service that need. Pedestrian traffic sometimes is doable with a pet coming to the veterinary hospital, but I did, you know, this year there was maybe three days that
1:39:48 I can remember having ample parking even at this current level. And so this is redundant, but I want to emphasize that we look closely at ways to manage, and my business especially, we need close parking, not just parking anywhere. So that's a concern of ours. So thanks for your consideration. Thank you. Thank you. I'm Shannon, staff owner of a condo at Chateau Sierra. And this is a really stupid little...
1:40:26 Thing that I'm going to say, but do you see why there's three and a half walls here? Because the wind blows. So the bus stop, you need three and a half walls. Three walls isn't going to cut it. We huddle behind that half a wall when the wind blows waiting for the bus. Dumb little statement, but pay attention to what's going on. I appreciate it. Thank you. Any other comments? Speak now. Forever hold your peace.
1:40:55 Therefore, I will close public comment, and I would like to give the applicant the opportunity to address anything that was brought up in public comment, if he so chooses, if not. I think we'd simply ask, if the commission has any concerns about the issues raised, we're more than happy to address them, understanding the public comments. We think the concerns have been addressed by the staff report, particularly with respect to parking.
1:41:30 To be clear, we are meeting the code requirement. And if there's any questions or concerns about operationally how that's going to work, we're happy to sort of address those on a question-by-question basis. I do have a quick question. Would you guys mind, in real basic strokes, kind of outlining the business model for the valet service?
1:41:50 Will it be a charge? It will be incorporated into the... I think this will address a lot of the key concerns that were reflected by the neighboring business owners about overflow parking going into their adjacent and separate lots. This is an all-valet project, and as an all-valet project...
1:42:12 The anticipated plan for this, as is the case with hotels that do this, is that there's going to be a resort fee. And the valet parking is subsumed within a resort fee that everyone's paying. So to us, it's not realistic where if you're paying the resort fee, you're not going to go park far away and walk when you're already paying for valet anyway. So I anticipate that that will induce people to use the valet and not use neighboring parking. So the experience for the person who's, let's say, pulling up.
1:42:40 To go eat at the restaurant or checking in for their nightly hotel, they're not going to pull up and see a sign that says valet $25? No. Okay. So what you're saying is valet is going to be free per your commitment? There may be a chart. I think for just a restaurant guess, maybe, but it's not, you know, I don't think there's any plan that would be anything in the range of $25. No. I mean, and probably, I mean, again, this is...
1:43:05 Again, this is into the business operation by the operator, but typically in order to get patronage of the restaurant and keep the activity level up, they usually offer various different kind of degrees of free for the hour or, you know.
1:43:20 Some kind of thing like that. Since I don't have an operational plan, I don't know exactly what that's going to be, but the main impact that I would be concerned about is people saying, I'm going to stay in the hotel, but I want to get out of a resort fee, but it's going to be included as part of their room rate. So they're going to get free valet parking if you're staying at the hotel, and we'll have attendants there to take their car and handle it for them. So they just drive up and it's handled.
1:43:48 And just to the point that, you know. That's part, I was just going to say, that's part of the plan we have to, as part of our conditions for the building permit, we have to vet that completely out and give it to staff and go through it and make sure that it meets all the standards that are required. And, you know, our, you know, just not to sort of beat the dead horse, our parkings.
1:44:08 Our parking study does demonstrate that parking, and it's a conservative analysis, will be able to meet the entire demand at the peak possible use estimated. So we don't think there's going to be any point where there's going to be any need for anybody to park elsewhere. Got it. Drew, do you currently have any sort of a thought as to airport shuttle? Are you going to offer that to your guests, especially with the airport relocating down valley to Bishop?
1:44:36 So as integral to our operational plan is to have several shuttles as part of the operation of the hotel. Probably one would be just dedicated to going down to the airport and one would be dedicated to giving the guests an experience within town. And then that's supplanted by the trolley service and the bus service. But we really want to make our guests feel like they're...
1:45:02 They're covered if they want to go around town and they don't want to use their vehicle. I mean, we're definitely going to come from a sustainability aspect. We don't want people to drive more than they have to. And we really want to have kind of a sense of place that once they get there, there are the means. I mean, obviously, they have the option if they want to, but there's the means to get them to the hill to go skiing, to go different attractions in town. And actually, one of the...
1:45:24 Key operational parts of the hotel is to create a lot of, you know, it's our thesis, it's an adventure hotel. So people will come here to start their adventures within our community. So they will come here and we will help facilitate them understanding all the amazing things that are surrounding our community, which most people don't know that much about, and help facilitate them with, you know, vans to take them out for a hike.
1:45:49 Vans to take their bikes for long-time bike rides. They want to do winter-type stuff, taking them out to the snowmobile adventures or taking them up to the mountain. We're working with the mountain right now to create some kind of pickup station at, you know, major...
1:46:04 Points of the mountains so that, you know, we're talking about things like an app where our guests can say, hey, I'm ready to go. I want to come back to the hotel. And the van puts them in the queue, picks them up. So we're going to get very creative about trying to really, you know, our goal is going to be very sustainable. We really want to have low impact. We're going to really try and look at all of our carbon footprint activities and try and have an operation that really takes the level of design and experience to a whole other level that's not here presently. Thank you.
1:46:34 Quick comment on parking. And I think it's available with the town website. The parking analysis by LSA should be included in the materials that you have. Ralph Lockhart, by the way. It looks like the, you know, it's a very, I think, a very robust study. And it looks like the proposed use will actually be less parking than is currently used now. And they've done peak analysis.
1:47:03 For hotel on Saturday nights and a variety of things in the study itself. So I would encourage those that have a concern. I think it actually will be mitigated and be better than it currently is with existing use in the county and the various restaurants and retail uses that are there now. Thank you, Ralph. Any other questions that you have? I don't. Does anyone else in the commission have further questions for?
1:47:31 Either staff or the applicant before we bring it back to commission discussion, deliberation. No? Thank you. Thank you for your patience as well. All right, so I'm going to bring it back up here to the dais guys and maybe we can talk a little bit about it, your thoughts, what you're leaning towards with this project. I also would like to hear everyone's thoughts on their preferred rendition of the bus stop, whether you want the classic town wood A-frame.
1:48:03 The more contemporary glass flat top roof one. So, I think the architect just knocked it out of the park. This is light years better than what's there now. You're taking a bunker and making it into an amenity, which is a pretty skillful job getting it done. I do have concerns about the parking. You know, that place has been marginal on parking when it's been half empty.
1:48:36 It's in the past had snow storage availability that is no longer viable with the buildings that are going in next door. And, you know, rather than get so draconian as to say, you know, bring down the number of rooms to make it fit, I think that there ought to be some sort of requirement that valet isn't necessarily free, but that it's at least free with validation or something along those, you know, lines.
1:49:03 I know there's been a problem in the past with people going in there and, you know, parking for the course of the storm and taking up spaces and coming back four days later because they didn't have chains. I assume that the validation, Valley Park and putting an end to that, but that had been a big impact in there in the past. And that was not one of the, it got by because it was half empty and we all hope there won't be half empty anymore.
1:49:31 So I think that if we're going to allow this level of below standard parking, even though it's less below standard than it was, there's going to have to be some sort of a free or free with validation or some requirement, not just a thought for parking. Thank you. Paul? Well, to answer the first questions that we have about the design review, whether the project meets the criteria,
1:50:03 of the Muni code. Given that I participated in ADP sessions, you know, I certainly believe that, you know, we met the criteria and we do like the applicant's design of the bus stop. However, I, you know, I can't say, I mean, our current design with what we have in town, I mean, that's certainly, it's a very
1:50:33 It's a very beautiful design as well. So I think it's something that I would yield to public works and hopefully they would take these things into consideration with what ADP has to say and so forth. Okay. I have to agree with Tom as to the opportunity what this project will bring.
1:51:05 to the table, to the town. Certainly, I have concerns about, I don't have too much concern about parking because I think, you know, that's a programming issue that, you know, with a robust, appropriate valet programming, I think we can solve that problem and hopefully, you know, the applicants will be able to address that to satisfy, you know, the neighboring concerns.
1:51:34 I do have one concern that's something that Matthew brought up about the safety issue, health and safety issue in that corner between Old Mammoth and Meridian. And certainly that's personal experience. I know that's a really icy area. And I think that's probably something that maybe public works can address internally.
1:52:04 I don't know if that's something that the applicant can actually solve the problem by themselves. And you're speaking to the drainage issue. Correct. Got it. And the icing issue, of course. Okay. And as to the key issue number two about the height, I think staff had mentioned that this is by right.
1:52:33 They can go up to 45 or 49? 45 feet. And I think there's, we're only, we're only talking about a portion of the structure that is currently at about 40, with the mechanical room, it's about 45? 49. 49? You know, that's... Okay. So, I think, you know, given that data, I think because it's such a small footprint,
1:53:06 My personal opinion, I think, you know, that's acceptable to me. Okay. And I can't remember what the key issue number three is. Yeah, so I'm in agreement with that, so. Okay. Jennifer? First, I'd like to say, Chandler, you did an amazing job with the staff report. Thank you very much for that. I really...
1:53:35 Feel that this project is going to revitalize Old Mammoth Road, and we've had other project ideas come forward that requested a developmental agreement. I really appreciate you guys doing this independently and not expecting the town to contribute. I believe that the TOTs that it's going to bring is going to be invaluable for the things that we want to do in the future, including housing.
1:54:07 I think it's going to be a tremendous project. Again, I'm not so concerned about parking. I think that if we can have an agreement that the valet parking makes sure that it's free for those guests who are staying, that would be great. But I'd like to see that kind of in writing, an agreement so that it's not just revoked whenever by whoever takes over the hotel.
1:54:38 And as far as the bus stop, I was also participating in the ADP and there was mixed emotion regarding this bus stop. I am kind of inclined to go with maintain the bus stops we have in town. I'd like it to be consistent everywhere throughout town.
1:55:05 There was someone who commented on the more sides. When this was presented to us, it had just the back, and we requested the two sides for snow, and I really think that the structure that we have with the town, where we have that extra little barrier, I think that's needed, especially in that spot.
1:55:26 That spot's pretty open and gets a lot of snow and wind and whatnot. So I would be more inclined to go with our consistent bus stop that we have throughout the town. I think that's a beautiful one and it blends with the hotel really well. Maybe if we, I'd even be okay if we did like something that's in between, but I'd like to try to stay consistent with our view throughout town so that we don't have all these different bus stops popping up again that just...
1:55:53 It doesn't mesh. We have a plan for this town. Let's continue on our plan and not try to deviate from that. And that's all I have to say about that. Thank you. First, I want to thank the applicant for the extreme attention to detail and the mimicking of the natural beauty of Mammoth. I think that's sorely missed in a lot of our construction here and the fact that you're bringing in
1:56:18 The things about Mammoth that made us all move here, the light and the trees and the snow into the natural design is phenomenal. So thank you for doing that. In an ideal world, I would have loved to see this flipped where we've got the parking behind it consistent with downtime revitalization. I know that's not on the table, but I want to thank you guys also for making this parking lot as little of an eyesore as you possibly could. It looks...
1:56:45 Amazing. So it's really nice to see that. The parking issue, I highly, highly encourage you to what the other commissioners have said to waive, you know, have no valet fees for guests, but also have some sort of validation program for people coming into the restaurant. I think if you want this to be a vibrant local space, it needs to be available for locals without a valet fee.
1:57:10 I'm not too concerned about the parking if that's the case. And then as for the bus stop, I totally agree with wanting the town to look consistent. Although I think if you put that bus stop where it blends in with this, it's going to look pretty bad. So I don't really like the sticking with the town style here. And I think that one of the things that the applicant has done for the aesthetics overall is that fence.
1:57:39 That transforms the way the parking lot looks from the sidewalk, and if we just put the bus stop and then this weird fence behind it, that feels pretty odd to me. So I feel good about the bus stop on the left if we could get the three and a half walls like the woman who was here was saying. I think that's important. And then even if it looks this way but has the three and a half walls, if we can just get the town logo on it, I think that kind of serves the purpose. So thank you for being here and thank you for being willing to invest the time and everything.
1:58:09 Thank you. I'm just going to close it out here. I am 100% in favor of this project. I think it's an absolute home run. I've heard that mentioned a couple of times here. I kind of view it as a double win for Mammoth Lakes. You're taking a commercial property that is a little bit tired and half vacant, as has been mentioned, and you're transforming it into a vibrant part of the future of Mammoth Lakes. And the little snippet that was dropped earlier that you're...
1:58:37 Possibly looking at flagging it as a four-star property, kind of makes it a triple win. That's a price point that this town is really lacking compared to our peer resorts around North America. I know that because I'm part of the marketing force for this town. So I think you guys will be really, really adding to the overall inventory of what we need. I also really want to advocate
1:59:03 That you try everything possible to continuation of your partnership with the mountain and have the fort space continue in there. I think that's a key piece to this community and it would be a really...
1:59:14 A positive asset to the overall amenity of the future hotel. I also would highly encourage you guys to continue your positive relationship with your neighbors, whether they be residential or commercial. Most of the letters that we received, either for or against the project, have all indicated that they have a positive relationship with you guys. So I'd love to see that continue going forward.
1:59:38 And then the parking issue, I would really like the idea, I really like the idea of the valet being either wrapped in, the valet fee being wrapped into the resort fee or there being some sort of a validation fee for the customers using either the cafe.
1:59:55 Or the restaurant on the roof, or even possibly the fort, if there's some way you can do that. I know right now the fort has an annual fee or a monthly fee. I'm not really sure how that would work, but I would highly encourage you guys to explore that. So having said that, I think I would be willing to entertain a motion if anybody would like to put one forth. I'll make a motion to adopt the PEDC resolution of finding the acquisition by the town.
2:00:26 I'm sorry, this is the wrong one. Let me go to the first one. Okay, let's see here. I'll make a motion to adopt the attached PDC resolution, making the required design review, height adjustment and SQL findings and approving design review application number DR.
2:01:11 19-003 and adjustment application ADJ 19-002. I'll second that. We have a vote, please, Jamie. Do they need with conditions recommended by staff? Yes. You have to add with conditions as recommended by staff to the motion. Oh, yeah, I'm sorry, yeah, with condition as recommended by staff. Is the second amended as well, Jennifer? Yes. Sorry. Commissioner Chang?
2:01:44 Yes. Commissioner Eckert. Yes. Commissioner Kennedy. Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs. Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Congratulations, gentlemen. Thank you. And staff, I would just like to throw in, I like the traditional bus stop. The standard bus stop throughout the community. I think that would be my personal favorite. But I'm okay with like a kind of a hybrid. I want a hybrid too. Yeah. I think it's important. When you're discussing the bus stop, I just want you to know we have a, we looked at the existing child.
2:02:17 Hayes provided us with the existing bus stop and we have a space issue. So we don't have the depth from our property line to where the parking starts. I think we've only got less than six feet. I mean, we were happy to work with staff to figure out a way that...
2:02:48 Can maybe be a blend and get that three sides in to see if we could, but we have a little bit of a space issue there. So it's not, I mean, I think your current bus stop is over eight feet deep and then it's got the sides with it and I don't think we have that much space. So we're kind of doing a shoehorn. I mean, obviously it's a great improvement over sitting on a rock waiting for the bus. So we're gonna, you know, we'll work with staff diligently to try and compromise and get you.
2:03:17 You know, the best bus stop we can fit in there, but obviously the other issue everyone raises is parking. So if we go too far, now you're impinging on the parking spaces, which is also a critical concern. So that's the balance we have to play. So I just wanted to mention that. Then I will ask staff if you could keep the commission updated as to the design of the bus stop as it goes forward.
2:03:37 Yeah, I think the existing ones would look awful weird with that. It would look so weird. They put so much effort into this beautiful thing. The other one's going to get blown over. Well, that's true. Thank you, gentlemen. A hybrid. Thank you very much for your attentive and listening to us. And I must say that the work of staff, the members on this board, and also in the ADP process has really been collaborative. And I think this is a, you know, it's a good news.
2:04:07 Story for other developers that want to come and invest their capital to, as Tom said, you know, maybe do some new true hotels. And I'm a big believer in Mammoth. I'll meet up with you and we'll talk about how to promote that. I appreciate that and I appreciate the faith in this community. Thank you for your feedback on the ADP. Thank you. It was a great process. Great. I'm glad to hear that.
2:04:29 All right, we're going to move on to business matter number two. Consider a determination of general plan conformity pursuant to Government Code Section 65402 regarding the acquisition of two condominium units in the Meridian Court Complex located at 550 Mono Street. And I do believe Sandra is our contact. Thank you.
2:04:51 As you have read in the staff report, the town is currently pursuing the purchase of two condominium units in the Meridian Court Complex. State law requires that the Planning and Economic Development Commission make a finding of general plan consistency before we can actually purchase the units. You did this for the parcel project as well.
2:05:14 You did this for the parcel project as well. So this is really kind of just a checklist item. Staff has prepared a staff report that shows that indeed general plan consistency is achieved with the purchase of these units. And so staff would recommend that the Planning and Economic Development Commission make a finding that these two units are in conformance with the general plan and adopt the attached resolution that's included in your staff report. I'm available for any questions that you have on this item.
2:05:44 Any questions for Sandra, commissioners? With your staff report, you talked about that we lost units in the past. Yes. So how do you lose a unit, first of all? And now we're buying, were these units that we're purchasing?
2:06:11 Were the units that we lost in the first place? When we say lost, we mean we lost the deed restriction. The town did not own these units but had placed a deed restriction on them and due to the changes, the economic downturn, we lost the deed restriction on the units because we can't overly limit a property owner's right to resell a unit. So we have limitations on the deed restriction, the resale of units. What I'm saying is the town initially owned the units first, right?
2:06:38 And then sold the property to the homeowners that qualify under the restriction guidelines. The units, I think, were originally owned by Mammoth Lakes Housing and sold by Mammoth Lakes Housing through grants with the town. So it was a town project. Indirectly as town's property or funded property. And then it was sold to property owner that qualify under the restriction guideline. And then subsequent to that, through time,
2:07:08 They sold it to other people that perhaps did not qualify under the restriction. They got the restriction lifted before they sold it. I think the town had the first right of refusal on the sale, and as Sandra was saying, during the economic downturn, the town did not have the economic resources to actually purchase.
2:07:28 The units, so therefore they went to market rate. Is that kind of the process? That's part of it. A large number of units came on the market at the same time, right basically as the economic downturn started. And so a lot of these units ultimately were sold as at market rate, which was actually below the deed restriction price at the time. So it just didn't, there was no ability to maintain a deed restriction that was actually higher than the market rate price.
2:07:55 So if that makes sense. Okay. So when you use the word lost, you're not saying that you lost track of these property came back online for resale and then town was not notified that the property was for resale and so then town did not or didn't have the opportunity to participate and purchase that property back from the existing homeowner. Am I correct?
2:08:26 Yes. When I say lost, what I mean is that the deed restriction was removed. So lost is just we lost the deed restriction. We didn't lose track of the units. It was really just losing the deed restriction when they came up for purchase. How does it get removed, like technically speaking? No one can probably speak to the specifics of deed restrictions. So with the deed restriction, when MLH, we had the first right of refusal when we didn't take action on that.
2:08:57 Then the owner can request that the town record a rescission of the deed restriction on title. So it actually gets recorded that the deed restriction has then been removed. Okay. And now we're going to purchase these properties. We will place deed restriction on these properties.
2:09:20 Am I correct? Is that helpful? We could. We could purchase, we could put a deed restriction on them and resell them. I don't think the town council has made a final decision about what they're going to do with these units, but we could hold them. We could use them for staff. Like if we have new employees who come in who need a place to live, we have a couple of units right now that we use for that. These could be for that. We could resell them. We could put them into the rental pool. Just rent, like, low-income, affordable rent.
2:09:46 So there's a number of different options that the town can do with these units in the future. Would any of those options involve the town buying it back and not putting a deed restriction back on it? Well, I mean, if we owned it and we were using it for employees, we probably wouldn't put a deed restriction on it at this point. I think we would only put the deed restriction on it if we were selling it, but we would rent it, if we were renting it kind of to the affordable housing market, we would rent it at affordable rates.
2:10:13 We may put a deed restriction on it, but I would assume that if we put the deed restriction on it, it would only be if we were going to resell the units. And when we put them on rental for rental purpose, is municipality under the same guideline as what California has just published about affordable housing rent control rule? Yes. Okay. I don't think those apply because they're single-family or single-titled units.
2:10:42 You're just asking whether or not we have to comply with the new state law regarding rent control. Correct. Do you know, does it apply to single condos? I think it applies to condos or homes that are titled individually. I don't know the answer to that question. I don't know if you... Some of it will depend on how they're ultimately owned. I know if it's owned by a corporation, you are still subject to it, so I'm not sure if the town ownership is considered a corporation or not. We can follow up on that.
2:11:11 Because it's not owned by individual homeowner. So in that case, and I don't remember if a public entity is considered one of the restrictions for, yeah, anyways. Okay, got it. Any other questions for Sandra or Nolan? I have a question. Why is this being done through the town and not through Mammoth Lakes Housing? The town has the funding. We have the funding in our general fund right now. We have...
2:11:42 The Town Council allocated $2 million for funding, and so we're just using our town money. Gotcha. And Mammoth Lakes Housing manages the, they use the town's funding as well, the Revolving Loan Fund, to purchase, to do the same thing as what we're doing. Although they're always selling those units back. So they're purchasing units to preserve the deed restrictions.
2:12:03 Placing a new deed restriction on the units and then reselling them at the deed restriction rate. So it's similar to what the Mammoth Lakes Housing is doing, except for the fact that we might keep these units for some period of time. Gotcha. Okay. Thank you. And Sandra, just refresh me. The deed restriction has a shelf life of 50 years and refreshes every time there's a change in ownership. Is that...
2:12:26 I think it's longer, isn't it? The standard term is 55 years, and then it refreshes every time it's a new ownership recorded on title. Got it. Thank you. So that 55 restarts each time it sells? Every time there's a change of ownership. But every time the property is sold, the first right of refusal comes to either the town or Mammoth Lakes Housing, and if we don't exercise our first right of refusal, they can sell it.
2:12:49 Like Nolan mentioned, they can request that the deed restriction be removed. So if we had another big economic downturn, we didn't have the money to purchase those units back, that it could happen again. Got it. Okay. Any other questions, concerns, comments, commissioners? No. No? You need a motion for this one, Sandra, I'm assuming? Public comment? Anybody from the public would like to make a comment on business matter number two? Thank you, Jamie.
2:13:23 We've missed you, Tom. Tom Hodges. I'm actually on the board of MLH and just really just more for your guys' benefit that there is that revolving loan fund that the town and the county both contribute to to buy back deed restrictions as needed. I know in this case it's not the situation we're talking about, but just for your own benefit in the future, understand that I want to say there's...
2:13:48 Upwards, I can't remember the exact number, it's like a million bucks. Three, so it's two separate revolving loan funds, one with the town, it's 300 right now, one with the county, I believe is also 300. Three, yes, we have 600. 600. We've talked about, you know, potentially maybe increasing that, possibly, but, you know, I think that would just be a separate action with council if it needed to be done, but if there were a bunch of units that came on at the same time, because.
2:14:11 But in any event, there is a program in place to address that issue as it comes up so that we don't lose those deed restrictions like we did last time when we had a big downturn. Thank you. Because it's a lot cheaper to maintain existing than to build new, right? Well, Senator, is there any reason not to require that if we're going to buy these units and we put the deed restriction on now? I mean, there could be 20 years from now they come to a point where they have to sell them and they need the money and...
2:14:40 Then they're not deed restricted again. Why don't we just put the deed restricted on now? I mean, I think that's a question to pose to the Town Council. I think that we can certainly let the Town Council know that that's a concern of the commissions, and you would recommend placing a deed restriction on them as soon as we purchase them. I mean, the Town has committed. We've used dedicated housing funds for this purchase, or we're using it, or funds that have been set aside for housing purposes.
2:15:05 So I think the town's committed to using these for affordable housing, and if we return them back to the market, adding a deed restriction to them. But we can certainly, you know, recommend to the town council that we place a deed restriction on them when we purchase them. But that could limit us if we end up deciding to use these for new employees. Some of the new employees may not qualify for, you know, for the deed restriction or for the affordable rates.
2:15:36 Does MLH and Thomas here have any opinion as to if that's, you know, that suggestion that was made just now? So I can't speak for the board, right? I'm just an individual, but I mean, I think it's serving the purpose of providing housing for local workforce. So, and understand that, you know, deed restrictions, there's different AMI levels, right, that are served, so I think to Sandra's point.
2:16:07 As I understand this scenario, I don't think it really makes a difference because I'm confident the town's going to utilize it to house whether it's their staff or they'll encumber it later if they're going to sell it. Depending on what the AMI level is, if it's 80%, then if you make more than 80%, then you don't qualify to use it if you're 100% or 120%.
2:16:37 So I think it probably makes sense to just not unnecessarily encumbered at this point. It certainly seems like it will be utilized for staff housing one way or the other. Thank you. Any other questions, comments, discussion? You may like to venture a motion. Sure. I'll make a motion to adopt the attached PDC resolution, like I did earlier, finding the acquisition by the town of two town condo units located at 550 Mono Street,
2:17:15 G101, M550, Mono Street, is that aye? Aye, 101, to be in conformance with the general plan. I second. Jamie, may we get a vote, please? Sure. Commissioner Chain? Yes. Commissioner Hecker? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Randerers? Yes. Matter passes, 5-0. Thank you. Thank you.
2:17:47 Okay, we'll move on to business matter item number three. Consider appointing alternates to planning and economic development committees, and we do have two committees, I believe, mobility and design review. Our staff contact today is Sandra.
2:18:02 Thank you. A very, very brief report. We have not appointed alternates to committees in the past, but we found that it might be helpful to have alternates appointed to the committees in case committee members are out of town so we can still hold either the design committee or mobility committee meetings. So we're just posing this question to the commission to appoint an alternate to design committee and an alternate to mobility committee. And this can be just...
2:18:31 It doesn't require a formal motion and it can just be a consensus action by the council on this. Okay. Well, first of all, I'll bounce it over to Greg since I believe you're the free agent. I'm the free agent. I'd be back up for mobility. You don't want me on design review. I'd be happy to be back up for design if needed. Okay. Consensus? Everyone all in favor? Yes. Okay. Thank you. Thank you.
2:18:59 All right, we'll jump. I'm sorry. Yep. So how will that work if the two committee members can't participate, one or two can't participate, then the alternate jumps in? Is that how it works? So if we're going to schedule a meeting and one of the two main committee members cannot participate, we would ask the alternate to participate. Right. But at no point would three ever be? No. Because then it becomes a planning and economic development commission meeting.
2:19:30 Thank you. You're welcome. Consent agenda. Did you guys have a chance to take a peek at consent agenda item number one slash four, the draft summary of our workshop? Is there anything you guys want to poll or discuss or no? I don't think so. Is there a motion out there to approve the consent agenda? I will make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Second. Angela, vote please.
2:20:11 I didn't see her step in. I didn't either. I was like, whoa. Nice job, Michael. Commissioner Jane. Yes. Commissioner Eckhart. Abstain. Commissioner Kennedy. Yes. Vice Chair Borough. Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Consent agenda passes. And thank you for organizing that workshop. I thought it was very, very productive. Some great ideas came out of there. Really excited that Mill Creek. Hitch.
2:20:40 Is being rebranded. Commissioner Reports, anything else that you guys, maybe we'll jump with Jessica this time, we'll start left or right. I think we just got approved in the consent agenda. Oh, yes. That's together. Yes. I don't have any updates. Thank you. We had two design committee meetings, or ADP meetings, for the Sierra Center Mall project, and I think
2:21:14 I don't need to go into detail because we discussed that pretty lengthy here today. And then it's not, I would just like to say thank you, Tom, for coming to our meeting today. I've really missed you. And I was hoping that you could give us updates on the mountain at an upcoming meeting. I am going to do that. That would be great. We're going to pin down our capital plan. In the near months, I'm going to get in here soon.
2:21:42 That would be great. We would love to see you and hear what the mountain has planned for our town and community. Thank you. Let's see. Commissioner reports from me. I'd like to thank the Trails HOA, the Trails Ownership Group, for another successful Halloween. I was down there with my kids, and they definitely looted a lot of the Halloween candy, so I thought it was great. It's a really cool community event. I think it's right up there with Town Cleanup Day.
2:22:12 It's very, very social gathering, so. I don't think you said hi. I can't, I did, I swung, I swung by, but you guys were knee-deep in people, but no, it's a great, it's a great evening, and I know it's a lot of burden on the homeowners down there, so thank you to them. I'd love to know what the numbers were on the mountain from opening day. It sure seemed busy Saturday. Just shy of 3,000. Fantastic.
2:22:38 Considering the amount of open terrain, that's really, and I'm not being tongue-in-cheek, that's, that's a. Temps are improving this, yeah. We'll be making a lot more snow coming up here for the next, next little stretch. Got it, but yeah, it was, people were very excited on Saturday to be out there, very festive atmosphere. People were fired up on the new beanies, the new design giveaway. So, again, it's a program that.
2:23:06 Hopefully always is continued even with the Altera ownership that the Beanie program. I didn't get a chance to see is the Beanie billboard on 395 green? Yeah, they changed it. Got it. Yeah, yeah. That's cool as well. And that'll be it for me. Commissioner Chang. Nothing. I just want to go back to the snow pit thing again. I talked with Hayes quite a bit about it earlier, but the problem we've got is the four surfaces really kind of.
2:23:36 Put their heels in and they came up with conditions that almost seemed like were made so difficult to make them impossible to work with. So now what's happening is no contractor is going to bid on this contract because they can't make any money at it. So what's going to end up happening is they're going to have to rewrite it. The town is going to have to pay a contractor. They're going to have a hard time finding somebody even to do that X number of dollars a year. So the whole town is going to end up paying.
2:24:06 Have the snow pit function, which is absolutely mandatory. We need it more than we need water coming in almost. But some of the property owners here in town over the years have bought the lot next door. They've done other things to mitigate the cost of snow hauling. And under this current scenario, they're going to get the short end of the stick because the people who have not done that kind of work in the past are going to have their snow hauled. The whole thing's going to be done for them.
2:24:35 Unless the town can come up with some way of recouping that money to the satisfaction of the Forest Service, it's just not going to be fair. That's it. Thank you. Director's report. Thank you. A reminder that next Wednesday at 3 o'clock you have a joint meeting with the town council.
2:24:58 You will receive a presentation from Cosmont Companies, not Larry Cosmont, but one of his associates, on tax sharing agreements. I've seen the draft presentation, and I think it's going to be extremely informative. I've encouraged my staff to attend. So I think it's going to be a really great opportunity to just listen about tax sharing agreements, development agreements, answer some of the questions that had come up during the Old Mammoth Place development agreement request.
2:25:28 Pretty excited to hear the presentation next week. And then on December 11th, the commission minus Commissioner Eckert will hold another joint town council meeting or another joint meeting with the town council on the parcel. So you'll be looking at the final preferred plan and making a decision. The commission and the council will be making a decision that night on the preferred plan. So that will be exciting.
2:25:55 We will be starting that meeting at 1 o'clock, like we did for the meeting last month. And so the staff, we have some other business matters for the commission for December, so we may be requesting that you all show up earlier in the day to meet to talk about just those other items. So Commissioner Eckert, we would request that you come for that portion, items that you're not conflicted on. So we have a couple different items. We have the annual planning reports that we provide on an annual basis.
2:26:25 And I can't think about the top of my head. Oh, Nolan will be putting together a comprehensive presentation on housing. So that'll be really informative on kind of our whole housing program. We'll not talk about the parcel during that presentation, but we'll update you on ADUs, update you on recent legislation that's changed, update you on kind of what we're doing for housing. So I think that'll be really informative.
2:26:49 So I will send out an email shortly once we've firmed up the number of items we have to request some earlier time with you all that day. Also an update on the La Sierra demolition. We have been working closely with the property owner. We did post the property with a notice of intent to abate. The property owner had been kind of dragging their feet on pulling their demolition permit and actually removing the building. So they did conduct an asbestos.
2:27:19 Inspection on Monday of this week. So they've done the inspection. They'll get the results this week to determine if there is asbestos and if so, how much there is and then what that looks like taking that out. So we're still working with them closely to try to get that building removed as soon as possible. Hopefully before the end of this year, calendar year. That would be amazing.
2:27:41 It would be amazing. And then another request was to just provide a brief update on the parcel request for qualifications. We did issue a request for qualifications last Friday. It closes, I think, December.
2:27:57 And I think maybe it's December 15th. I can't remember the closing date off the top of my head. But we're just looking for qualified firms that we can start discussions with on the future development of the parcel. So once we will have a list of qualified firms, we'll narrow it down to some rankings. So we'll have like number one, two, three, and we will start negotiations with the number one firm. If we can come to an agreement with the number one firm, we'll kind of set the others aside. If we can't come to agreements with the first firm, we would go to the second or third like that.
2:28:26 It might be an opportunity for us to say, Grady has mentioned at public meetings that we may like some aspects of the first firm and some aspects of the second firm and ask the two to work together. So that would all come, though, after the December 11th Planning Commission meeting. And that's my report. Thank you. Thank you for that report. All right, I'm going to adjourn this meeting, guys and commissioners. Our next meeting will be held on December 11th here in Suite Z.
2:28:55 Time to be determined. Right, so the formal, your special meeting will start at 1 with the council and that actually will be another, it'll be actually a town council meeting that you all attend. But we may have a regular meeting before that, maybe like at noon you said. Or possibly, I was thinking of trying to ask you all maybe like at 10 so that you have time for lunch.
2:29:15 Got it. Something like that from 10 to 12 and then from 12 to 1 you can have lunch and then 1 o'clock the council meeting but I'll reach out to you on that. Okay. But for now you can adjourn to your special meeting at 1 o'clock on the 11th. On Wednesday the, or on, yeah, December 11th. Correct. Okay, I'll adjourn with that. Thank you. Thank you.