TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2019

Town Council

· recording 6 hr 37 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

3 findings

Transcript

820 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:32 You see, now it shows up that I already have it. But I've been looking in there for two days. I know how to spell Russ. No questions. Don't ask anything. Okay. If we are ready, I will open this workshop of the Town of Mammoth Lakes PEDC Commission and Town Council. And I'm going to immediately turn it over to Dan to get us started.

4:08 Sandra, to get it started. Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community Network. I even wrote Sandra down here, too.

4:17 So just a brief introduction before we start. The town entered into a contract with Cosmon companies to come here today to provide you with a workshop information on tax sharing agreements. As you know, the town has been approached formally and informally by different developers, hoteliers, about tax sharing agreements. So we thought it would be a good opportunity to bring an expert in the field here to give you kind of an information about the tax sharing agreements. And then he's here to answer kind of any questions that you have.

4:47 Thank you, Sandra. Thank you, Mayor, Councilmembers, and staff. As Sandra introduced, my name is Will Sohold. And can you all, can everybody hear me okay? Very good. Just please let me know if you can't hear me at any point in time.

5:06 Same with the audience. As introduced, I'm with Cosmont Companies. I've been with Cosmont for about 13 years. Prior to that, I served in the public sector in the school district, kind of on the development side, helping school districts develop schools, build schools, things like that. As introduced, we were retained by the city to come here and talk about structuring tax-sharing agreements. It's one of the things that we do and one of the things that I focus on especially. And so here we are. We've got kind of a three-act presentation today.

5:35 Really the bulk of the presentation is talking about structuring tax revenue, tax sharing agreements, things like that. However, Dan did have the opportunity to see a presentation from Larry Cosmont in Cosmont at the League of California Cities recently, and there were some elements of that presentation that Dan thought were relevant and of interest potentially.

5:55 To you guys. And so we've got that as kind of the first act. The second act, the bulk of it, the bulk of the presentation is really talking about how these types of arrangements are entered into and how they're structured, things like that. And then the last piece is just a little final element talking about special districts and different financing mechanisms that come with special districts, as we call them. So with that, you can see the outline here. I encourage you, please, if you have any questions at any point in time, I'm happy to answer them as they come up.

6:25 Come to, I'll let you know and we'll get through it. So the first part, we're going to talk a little bit about Cosmo and give you a little bit of background on why we're here as I've done a little bit. The first act is this retail and real estate trends, place versus space. Then we'll talk about why would we consider sharing revenue. We'll talk about the economics of hotel development, hotel operation, different risk factors that are relevant in those types of operations.

6:52 We'll get into structuring the pledge, the mechanisms, and then talk about some of the other considerations that might be relevant. And finally, as I said, that third act, talking about special districts. So Cosmont Companies were established in 1986. Been around quite some time. Excuse me, this is not going. Been around since 1986. We are focused on both the public and private sector. A lot of the work that we do is relating to either the public, a public or a private client.

7:20 So we understand both sides of the transaction very well. We never represent both a developer and a city as an example on the same transaction. But we do understand both sides of these types of deals. We do have national reach. We are focused on California. And we do have alliances. We have sister companies, effectively, that allow us to do.

7:40 Other things that are relevant in this type of work that we do. The first is Cosmont Realty. It's a separate legal entity as it needs to be. It is a brokerage firm licensed by the California Department of Real Estate. I'm a licensed real estate broker. Through that, we also have Cosmont Transaction Services, which recently, within the last eight years or so, was required by federal law that anybody practicing in municipal finance and which...

8:03 The service that we do starts to dip into that when we're dealing with real estate financing, things like that, that you have to be registered with the SEC and the MSRB. And so we've got cost amount transaction services, and we have people who are registered and licensed under that entity as well. Background on the workshop. So we were invited here, as was indicated, because the town anticipates receiving requests potentially for revenue sharing agreements, specifically transient occupancy tax.

8:31 Sharing agreements with hotels related to the development of those hotels. As I said, we negotiate these types of deals historically. We've always represented, I can't think of a single developer or hotel side, so we've always represented the public sector side when we negotiate these transactions. And we've done a variety of them, and so we have got a lot of experience, and that's why we were asked to come here and kind of give you a download onto what we look at in these types of deals and what we consider and give you kind of a primer.

9:01 If you might want to consider that. So moving on, the first piece is going to talk about, as I say, is this first act. It's just a general high-level discussion about what's going on in real estate. A lot of cities in California, Mammoth Lakes is a little bit unique in that it is not as focused on sales tax revenue as other cities. But a lot of cities in California, subsequent to the passage of Prop 13,

9:24 And the loss or effectively the freezing of property tax revenue or reduction of property tax revenue, however you want to characterize it, began to focus on retail. And that's really been a focus for a lot of cities over the last 30 plus years is how do we get more retail activity in town? How do we get the power center in here? How do we get these types of retailers, excuse me, so that we can generate sales tax revenue?

9:53 Sales tax revenue for our town because property tax is pretty locked up and fixed and most cities don't have the luxury that Mammoth Lakes has of the transient occupancy tax from hotels, VRB, those types of things. With the oncoming and onset and advent of the technology and implementation of technology in retail that has really changed the landscape for a lot of retailers. I'm sure everybody's aware retail is going through a dramatic shift. Physical brick and mortar retail is declining.

10:23 As a result of more internet sales, things like that, in the delivery of goods straight to home. And so as a result, it's really changing our physical space. You can kind of see it in, not just in Mammoth Lakes, you can see how some shops are performing at different levels than they used to be perhaps, but throughout the state of California. Why is that relevant? What's shifting is that we're now...

10:44 Focus on more on place as an activity center than a place to shop. And so the statement there, residential office, hospitality, all these different uses are blending together. And the focus in kind of the modern thought or the current thought, the current iteration of real estate design is that we're going back to kind of more of a sense of place. And oftentimes what we characterize more as a living room is being designed into all of these spaces. And so retail spaces are

11:12 Becoming more, have more living room type amenities. Hotels often have had the lobbies, but they're incorporating more retail components, things like that. What you're seeing here is a picture of a residential development that these are increasingly incorporating these living room spaces where people can come together, interact, and, and,

11:33 Have different types of interactions. This is a hotel lobby. What's changed in the lobby is now you've got, in many cases, kind of small shops, things like that. But it's a place for people to converge and create communication. This is a picture of WeWork. This is another trend that we're seeing a lot of that's kind of shared office space. But rather than having people in dedicated workspaces, we're more and more frequently using cohabitation spaces, shared workspace.

12:01 Spaces that are less defined. But bottom line, that's the kind of shift. So the shift is moving really to this blended use.

12:08 Residential and hospitality are becoming closer linked. You're seeing this in some types of developments that have condominium hotels or hotels with condominiums attached to it that people can purchase a condo, live in the condo, and have the amenities of the hotel, as an example. Experiential retail. So retail is moving from just a place to buy something to a place to try something out instead, and then you may go online and buy it subsequently. That's the problem. Best Buy faced when they became a showroom for Amazon, as an example.

12:37 Entertainment and Fitness. We're increasingly doing things more and more. Fitness has become an entertainment function. So when we're in group classes, things like that, you see the yoga amenities. These are all the types of occupants that are replacing your traditional retail. Now you have a yoga studio instead or a spin studio, things like that.

12:57 Food, grocery, and restaurant are kind of combining. We know we've always had the deli counter for a long time in the grocery store, but now there's more of a formal restaurant in many cases. So you can purchase food, you can eat there, those types of things. And then I talked a little about co-working and creative office that we're increasingly coming out of silos and dedicated office workspace to more flexible space for people who are telecommuting, working at home, things like that, that they have a physical location that they can go to and meet and interact with other people.

13:27 Retail used to be the destination. And I know that's not as relevant here in Mammoth Lakes because our focus is really on, at least in terms of revenue, hospitality, but obviously the mountain and fitness and being outdoors, things like that. But we've got the village is a perfect example of what we're talking about here, that it's a place. It's a place where hospitality merges with retail, with restaurants, with the mountain being right there, with fitness.

13:56 And so we've got fun, food, fashion, and fitness. And we're mixing all these things in the same place to create a sustainable operation that used to just be really a mall or a local shopping center. So we're now kind of splitting things up. It used to be that you get your retail amenity from your store. Now we're breaking that up into destination versus distribution. The destination, what once used to be the store where we picked up our goods,

14:27 It's now more experience-based. We're experiencing the retail more than purchasing something there. It's about having food there. The food is now an entertainment function, has been, but is now increasingly more relevant, that we can't eat online. We have to go somewhere if we want to go out and eat, focus on entertainment. The movie theater always has been a source of entertainment in our retail centers, things like that, but that's focusing or shifting now to other sources of entertainment, other activities.

14:55 Really blending all these uses together. And then on the distribution side, industrial property is becoming more and more relevant. We'd expect to see different distribution hubs, even in town, places for people to pick up, increasingly places for people to pick up goods that they've ordered online if they want to pick it up immediately. Or it can go as essentially a showroom to purchase something and it's delivered to their home. The concept of click and collect is that you purchase it online, you go to the store, it's ready for you. And then last mile delivery. So this is from the last distribution center.

15:24 To the actual, to someone's home, those, the location of the goods has shifted away from what would be this, this retail center here to a industrial warehouse down the road. So things are changing from that perspective. It is relevant, I think, for the, for Mammoth, less so in the sales tax and retail discussion and more so that.

15:47 The sense of place, that people want increasingly a sense of place to go. If you look at where people are going in town, what they're doing, I imagine the village is a good example. Maybe it's just people from out of town. I don't know where everybody goes for their fun, but I know that coming from out of town, a lot of people go to that location because it's got kind of that buzz, that activity when there's a lot of people there and there's a lot of options to satisfy all these different amenities. But the last piece of this is that housing

16:16 Has to be a priority as well. And housing helps activate these places when you have housing in proximity to these different amenities. People increasingly like not to get in their car if they don't have to. And so the ability to walk to these things and these amenities is nice to have. But all these amenities, and especially hospitality, require jobs. They're very job-intensive operations. And so we also need to support and provide housing.

16:45 To make sure those jobs have a place to sleep at night and people have a place to sleep in proximity, ideally, to their workplace to enhance that sense of space and place. So that's the first act. Now we're going to really start to get into the details of sharing tax revenue. And again, more of this is kind of technical stuff where we get into more technical things. So please feel free to ask questions as they come up if you have any.

17:13 So why consider sharing revenues? For the town of Mammoth Lakes, we are based heavily on transient occupancy tax. I think this says, yeah, 60%. The number, I think last year, was 58% of the revenue from the town came from transient occupancy tax. It's substantial. Most towns and most cities have a more reliance on property tax, sales tax, things like that as other sources of revenue. But for us, it's 60%. We're very reliant on it. We're very susceptible to variations.

17:43 In that revenue stream. And approximately 55% of that transient occupancy tax revenue comes between the months of December and March. So four months out of the year, we get more than half of our transient occupancy tax revenue. So you can obviously, and it's obvious, but you can obviously see how much we rely on people from out of town to come and stay at the hotels to support our town and the daily way of life. So tax sharing agreements.

18:12 Or can be appropriate for the right deal. When do we say, when does we, Cosomont, say we should enter into them? If it's a project that is expected to be a significant revenue generator, we might consider it. So a hotel that's going to generate a couple million dollars in property, excuse me, transient occupancy tax revenue from the get-go. That's a lot of money for our town. That's $23 million in an annual budget. $2 million more revenue would be substantial.

18:39 So we might consider it for that reason. A catalyst project that drives additional private investment. If there's a site in town or something like that, or a property in town that has not been developed, there's something keeping it from being developed, and it's also stifling the area around it, maybe we say we would invest in a project, if it's appropriate, to get something built that would also drive tertiary activity around that project.

19:08 Incentivize and encourage other development around it. The third one that you see up there in that sub bullet is a project that would be burdened or has a burden of extraordinary infrastructure or cost factors. So what does that mean? If, as an example, you've got a project that requires redoing the fire hydrant and the fire water line for seven miles to get the appropriate capacity, that cost is not just attributable to, let's say, the hotel that gets developed. Yes, the hotel.

19:37 That is asking for a sharing arrangement may be the trigger for that. They may be the last cause that requires that step up in infrastructure for that massive cost to re-pipe for seven miles, but they're not the only beneficiary, right? And so to burden that project with that particular cost, it creates a financial infeasibility that nothing will ever get built that requires that investment.

20:05 So we might consider looking at how do we support that development. And the last piece is a project that furthers our public policy goals. So maybe it's parking, maybe it's other affordable housing, maybe it's those types of amenities. We might consider doing a tax sharing arrangement in those circumstances. So now looking at transient occupancy tax, this is specific to town. This is since 2006, 2007. You can see pretty substantial growth in fiscal year 0607.

20:34 Total transient occupancy tax was $9.6 million. Now, last fiscal year, 2018-19, we're up to $20.2 million, so doubling in a little over 12 years, which is pretty substantial growth, massive growth, frankly. I think there's a couple of important takeaways here. You can see the total snowfall there as well, so you can do your own correlation if you like. But importantly, we've got years where we had some pretty substantial growth. 2015-2016, we had a 40% increase.

21:04 And transit occupancy tax, that's massive, right? That's unheard of. It's also a lot of variability for us as a town in terms of trying to budget and finance. And I know when I look at the financials for the town that there is a reserve. We're not counting on $20 million necessarily, it looks like, in TOT every year that we kind of step back our budgets based on more conservative numbers. But bottom line, a 40% bump in one year. What's interesting is that there was a 15% bump the next year.

21:33 So it kept going up at these substantial clips. On the downside, the worst it went down was 12%. And that, in one case, was after a year of 7% growth, and the other case was after a year of 19% growth. So those are big swings, but they're not cumulative problems, I would say. It's not going downhill on an extended basis. That when it did go down, it came back up. You've got the line there, the black line.

22:04 Identifies year-over-year change. And so you can see this kind of sawtooth pattern. But in no case was it worse than 12%. And even, importantly, even during the last recession, the Great Recession, the hits to transient occupancy tax really, in my mind, from what we see, really weren't that substantial, which is pretty amazing, pretty surprising. So there's some resiliency there as well, it seems, in the transient occupancy tax.

22:32 Now shifting to the fundamentals of hotel economics, just to give you kind of a primer on how hotel developers think, how they operate, how cities can look at hotels and look to try and facilitate the development of hotels if desired. Hotels are, by their very nature, very risky both to develop and risky to operate.

22:59 And that shows up as a function of investment. The cost both for developers and operators to get money to operate hotels and pay for the operation of hotels. And it also shows up in the cost of development of hotels. Debt providers, lenders, banks typically won't lend as much money to a hotel project as they would for another product type. The example I like to use is if you've got your house, they may lend.

23:25 Readily 80% loan to value on your house. You can get a loan for 80% of the cost of your house. There's certain loan programs you only have to have 3% down, right? A hotel typically is going to be maxing out at about 70% loan to value. It varies, but often 70% loan to value is pretty frequent. It also varies in economic conditions. Maybe it's 60% loan to value in certain circumstances. But what that does is it makes a developer or an operator have to bring more money to the table.

23:54 And more equity to the table. And that's very expensive money, very expensive equity, because it's higher, it's the nature of the operation is higher risk. And as a result of that higher risk, the hotel, both developer and operator, and sometimes they're the same, sometimes they're not, but they will require a higher level of

24:12 Return, higher rate of return, higher investment rate. You've got some kind of bar chart there talking about capitalization rates for other product types. This just gives you a sense as to where the market is at. These numbers for reference are LA County specific. We don't have numbers for Mammoth Lakes specific. But these are cap rate surveys from the first half of 2019. It's the most recent information out there. And generally,

24:39 Gives you an indication as to how investors typically look at these product types. It would be true, the scales would be true in town as well in terms of the hierarchy of investment and return as well. But bottom line, industrial property is considered essentially the least risky right now and that goes back to the shift from online sales to more, excuse me, from physical brick and mortar sales to more online sales, which then requires distribution.

25:08 Which is inherently done in industrial space. So there's a lot of demand for industrial space right now. Hence, people are willing to pay more. And when people are willing to pay more, that capitalization rate, that required rate of return goes down. So you see that range in the 4% there for industrial. Multifamily residential is historically considered the safest bet. And people are willing usually to pay the most money for a given amount of money in return from that investment right now.

25:36 In the 4.5% to 5%. This is all for really for Class A product and stabilized product. Office, you can see, considered a little bit more risky in the 5% to 6%. And interesting, retail now is, and sometimes office and retail kind of shift back and forth, but retail now commanding higher rates of return for level investment. And that's, again, a function of risk. The more risk a product type has, the higher that capitalization rate is going to be.

26:03 Then moving to hotels. So these are the bottom four in the tier here. Luxury hotels showing up at the 6% to 8% range. And again, this is for a stabilized product that an investor of a hotel, if the hotel costs $100,000, they would expect $6,000 to $8,000 in cash back that first year and growing thereafter, 6% to 8% rate of return. The full service hotel, considered a little bit more risky, 7% to 8%, select service, 7% to creeping into low 8s.

26:33 And then the economy level of hotels, 8% to 9% is pretty typical. Now again, these are stabilized products. If someone is going out to develop a hotel, let's say it's a full service hotel that's a 7% to 8% rate of return, they may be looking at a 10% to 12% rate of return on the development side just to get it to a stabilized operating level where they could sell it or realize kind of that 7% to 8% rate of return on an operating basis. But bottom line,

27:03 The higher the capitalization rate, the greater level of return developers require. Hotels are risky, so they require a greater level of return and a higher capitalization rate. The other thing that it does for hotels is that it makes early revenue very important. The higher your capitalization rate or rate of return, your required rate of return is, the more important money today is versus money tomorrow or a year from now or two years from now. If you're expecting or trying to achieve a 10%

27:32 Return on your investment. The dollar five years from now has much less value today than if you're trying to achieve a 5% rate of return. So that makes early money very important in a hotel deal. The other piece is that hotels take time to stabilize. It may take three or more years. It could take five years for a hotel to stabilize versus if you look at a residential project as an example, you may be at 95% occupancy within a year.

27:58 So you're already, you have a very quick ramp up with that type of product. Some retail projects, they have tenants, 80% of the space tenanted before they get under construction, as an example. Same with industrial, some office, things like that, that they already know who their customer is going to be before they put a shovel in the ground. Versus a hotel, you can do a market study. You think you know who your customer is going to be. We can look at the existing.

28:22 Performance of Hotels in Town. We can see how they move from day to day, month to month, and say, okay, there's this many hotel rooms in town, this many VRBO units in town. If we bring another 200 rooms or 300 rooms online, we think we're going to capture this much of the market share. We think the market's going to grow by this much. We think that's going to be our customer. But you don't know that until it's built.

28:44 And you don't start to achieve those market shares until you have proof of operating performance. People start talking to other people, say, hey, this is a great place. We stayed there. You should stay there. Those types of things. So you've got a long ramp up. We've got on the right hand side kind of this hypothetical chart. These are occupancy ratios are taken from true performance metrics. The ADR is hypothetical in this.

29:10 And then the gross room revenue is just a function of, I'm sorry, ADR means average daily rate. That's what a room says, or excuse me, what a hotel says to the market that they're going to charge. If you call them up and say, we're going to charge you $300 a night, you go to hotels.com or whatever, $300 a night, that's your average daily rate over a course of a year.

29:32 You multiply occupancy, so 68% in the first year by your average daily rate. That one hotel room is going to generate $74,500 in revenue in this example, gross revenue. Carrying it out over four years, you can see we've got the occupancy going from 68% in year one. In this case, this hotel is assumed to stabilize 75% in year three.

29:55 Doesn't grow anymore in terms of occupancy in year four, but the average daily rate, room rate keeps going up. Initially, it goes up more than kind of what would be considered a market rate because they're able to charge more as demand increases for that hotel. And then it stabilizes with the market. And so what you can see is in those first four years in this example, revenue goes from 100% or a baseline of, let's say, $100,000 to 120%. So it's grown by 20%.

30:24 In four years. So those initial years are very tough from a hotel because of the risk not knowing who the customer is and the revenues are typically lower in those first few years. So when you're trying to underwrite a loan payment for a hotel, you've got to satisfy the loan payment in year one, not just in year four when you've got more revenue. So you're kind of constrained early on. And so as a result,

30:53 Tax-sharing deals can have a big impact on the ability to underwrite this type of investment. So we've now got this carrying this example forward. And throughout this presentation, you're going to see essentially a series of hypotheticals. They're all kind of the same numbers. We tried to use the same numbers throughout. The revenues that you see as an example follows from the example I just gave you in terms of moving from 68% occupancy to 71, 75, 75, and then the room rate growth as well.

31:23 So we kind of carry that same growth pattern forward. As I said, the addition of that early transient occupancy tax revenue can have a big impact. The table shows you this hypothetical scenario. We've got gross revenues. We're just using simple big numbers, $100,000 in the first year in revenues for this hotel. Using the growth that I showed you, that would be $107,500 in year two, $117,000 in year three, $120,000 in year four.

31:53 We've assumed an operating margin of 30%. It's decent for a full-service hotel. And so as a result of that, we say, hotel and your one's going to make $100,000. They're going to net 30% of that, or $30,000. The other $70,000 goes to the cost of operating the hotel, reserves, those types of things. And so they've got $30,000 to pay the debt service back with, right?

32:18 We assume in this case the debt service is $25,000 a year. That first year, this DSCR, this debt service coverage ratio is 1.2. A bank is typically going to want 1.3 or more is that debt service coverage ratio. They're going to want the hotel to be making more money than it is in this scenario. And so the TOT or a share of TOT can help a bank.

32:46 Underwrite that same hotel differently. Under this scenario, down on the bottom half, we said, okay, well, what if we gave up 50% of our 13% transient occupancy tax to this hotel? Then that $30,000 in net income that the hotel generated year one would be augmented by another $6,500, half of our transient occupancy tax. And so that debt service payment, that $25,000 loan payment, is now compared to $36,000

33:16 $500 in cash, effectively, from the hotel and us. And so that debt service coverage ratio, the very last line in that chart, is 1.46. So we've moved from a 1.2 debt service coverage ratio to 1.46, and it grows very healthily thereafter. In the first scenario, the hotel didn't get to a satisfactory debt service coverage ratio from the bank's perspective until year three. It didn't get above 1.3 until year three when it hit.

33:45 1.4. So it just shows the potential impact of our revenue on the deal. And at 13%, we're effectively charging 13% of a big piece of a hotel's revenue, right? So room revenue is one piece of a hotel's revenue, food and beverage, things like that is another piece. Let's say 60, 70% of a full service hotel's revenue is coming from room revenue. We're adding effectively a 13% margin on 70% of their revenue.

34:14 So it's a big, big boost to their profit, potential kind of profit margin, how the numbers work out. So now talking a little bit about risk here, I talked about hotels are risky business, development of the hotels, especially risky, talking about some of the risk factors that we look at and what we'd be concerned about when we're helping a city or a town structure a transaction. First of all, construction risk is a major risk factor. We don't want, we're not in the

34:43 Business as a town of doing development, of taking on development risk, things like that. And so we want to be very careful about how we enter into any agreement. Construction risks include construction costs and construction delay. There's other ones, but those are the major ones. Construction costs would be change orders, unforeseen existing conditions. You dig into the ground and there's...

35:05 You know, there's oil in the ground. We've seen that before. So you've got to mitigate these conditions, right? You've got an oil well or something. Design omissions and defects. If you've got bad plans and you go to build a building and there's a beam through a bearing wall or something like that that needs to be redesigned or you've got heating and ventilation that needs to go through a bearing wall, things like that. Construction delay, weather, especially pertinent here, unforeseen conditions. Again, if you encounter a condition, site condition that you have to design around.

35:34 If you've got difficulty acquiring certain materials, and then importantly, this impacts the time of year of opening. If 55% of our revenue is coming from December through March, we don't want to open in May, right? We want to open probably in October, September, something like that. Construct, finish constructing over the summer if we can. Obviously, you've got building construction, timing with envelope, things like that. But ideally, we want in that first year.

35:59 We absolutely need to capture the whole year of revenue. And so if we have a delay that impacts our construction schedule and pushes us out where we're missing half of the first year based on the economics I just showed you, that can have a huge impact and a huge negative impact on the long-term viability of the hotel. That could send a hotel into bankruptcy in the first six months. So how do you mitigate construction risk?

36:21 A developer should do thorough due diligence on the site. You do a lot of inspections, a lot of testing. You know what you're getting into. You do very detailed design, so you have your architect make sure that there's a lot of technology now, 3D building model, things like that, that helps get around these design issues. But there are developers out there that have lower levels of design standard and then go to construct and then finish in the details when they get the rooms walled in, things like that. But a way to mitigate the risk is to do detailed design.

36:50 You can also do completion bonds or a GMAX contract. And this is sometimes similar to design build where you work with an architect and a contractor who are on the same team or has the same results as that. Completion bond says, puts up some money on behalf of the contractor or the lender. And a third-party contractor will come in if the contractor can't get the building completed. GMAX contract says, contractor, here's my...

37:18 Set of plans and specifications, essentially. Take a look at them. Tell me what you guarantee you're not going to charge me more than to build this building. And so that contractor's then on the hook for any financial overruns, things like that. So you get a guaranteed exposure, a guaranteed maximum exposure. How does this affect us? Well, we don't want to take on construction risk, as I've said. And to the extent possible, we would limit the revenue pledge until after the hotel's open, after commencement of operation, so that we know it's built, it's in place.

37:47 Getting it built is not going to be a concern for us. The next factor we look at is operating risk. As I talked about, we don't know who our customer is necessarily until they actually show up. We think we know who they are, but don't know for sure until they actually show up. And even if we have a good couple of years, we could have bad years down the road, and those can impact our viability over the long term.

38:12 Things like global events in the economy, substantial downturns in the economy as we looked at. Even during the Great Recession, we didn't get hit that much here, which is frankly pretty amazing. But then also weather and snowpack. And again, looking, thinking back to that variability in our TOT here in town, we have, it seems like we do really well when there's a lot of snow. And then we still do pretty well the next year, even if there's not a lot of snow or much less snow. So there's some...

38:38 It seems like we have some resilience to certain weather events. But if there was no snow one year, certainly that would be a big impact to us, right, if it was just too warm or something like that. And then operating costs is another factor that we've got a lot of different inputs to operating a hotel. You've got food costs, you've got labor costs, you've got utilities, things like that, that you may not, as a hotel operator, have a lot of control over. So there's exposure to that. And then so how do we mitigate these? A good hotel knows their...

39:06 They think their customer is and they're accurate on that and so they provide an appropriate product at an appropriate price point to get that customer in the door. They maintain appropriate reserves so they put money aside to refresh rooms and things like that. They're not operating on such thin margins that they can't reinvest in the property and that goes to the management practices. And then for us to protect against operating and business risk and this is really the variability in demand, the variability in TOT revenues.

39:33 We make the amount of our pledge, any pledge that we would be willing to provide, a function of hotel performance. We're not on the hook if it does poorly. We'll put it that way. And we're going to talk in a minute about how we can go about doing that. Financial risk. So last major risk for hotel operations, financial risk. One of the risks is financial leverage. I talked about that loan to value. If a hotel has too much leverage, then they may have too much debt.

40:00 They may see a little bit of operational risk, a decrease in demand. And if they're operating so thin, if they have so much debt that they can't make that debt service payment, obviously that could be a terminal event for them. Another piece is future lender demand and underwriting. Typically in the commercial world, you don't get a 30-year mortgage that's a fully amortizing mortgage. You get a shorter 5, 10, 20-year note. And so you've got exposure down the road to...

40:27 What the real estate market looks like, what the interest, the investment interest is, what interest rates are, things like that. At every period that you have to go to refinance. And so you could be in the market today and interest rates are phenomenal. And five years down the road, your interest rates could double easily. And so you've now got a debt service payment that's double on operations that haven't doubled, right? So exposure to future lender demand and interest rates.

40:54 How do we mitigate those things? Responsible use of debt, so don't have too high of leverage and debt service. So use of longer fixed-term financing, cap variable rates, and interest rate swaps. I'll break down each one of these. Use of longer. So I talked about oftentimes lenders are interested. A lender, a bank, wants to be on the hook for as short a period of time as possible, usually. And an operator or, you know.

41:20 Think about your house. You want as much certainty as possible, right? You want to be able to take out a 30-year note today and know that that's going to be your payment for the next 30 years. A bank says, no way. I don't know what the interest rates are going to be five years from now, 10 years from now. I'm not willing to take that risk. I'll give you a five-year loan at this rate. If you want to go to 10 years, it's got some bearable component to it, maybe. So the bank is going to be on the shorter end, but the operator can push for a longer, more certain.

41:50 Loan structure that has more of a fixed interest rate. Talked about cap variable rates. A lot of loans in the commercial market do have a function, if not exclusively be based on variable rates. You can establish a cap. You can also, the last piece, purchase an interest rate swap, which says if the interest rates go up for a fee, your payments will be fixed as a borrower.

42:16 And then mini perm or construction or semi-permanent loan. This is really on the construction side. A lot of times hotels and really any real estate is constructed on a construction loan. It then moves to a permanent loan. So the one lender, sometimes the same one, provides a construction loan at a certain rate, usually a variable rate, very short period of time just during construction. And then at the end of construction, maybe there's a little bit of a stabilization period depending on the product. Then they move to a permanent loan that's more in that 5, 10, 20 year range.

42:45 Increasingly, we see riskier product, i.e. hotels, move to kind of with this mini perm or a semi-permanent loan structure. So with a mini perm, you've got a construction loan wrapped up with a mini permanent loan. So maybe you've got a couple years after construction to really get stabilized, figure out your next financing piece. You don't have to immediately shift from construction to a permanent loan. So there's not that underwriting risk at the completion of construction, right?

43:13 The semi-permanent, construction to semi-permanent is the same thing. It's just a little bit longer time horizon. You've got a couple years to construct. You've then got maybe five years on the semi-permanent side. And so there's certainty associated with where you're going to be in the interest rate market and borrowing market when you finish construction and before you've stabilized your hotel occupancy. And then our protection here is that we would want to condition the pledge with protective financial covenants. If we do offer some sort of

43:42 Sales tax participation formula or pledge would say, okay, well, you can't have more than X percent loan to value, or you've got to make sure that you have this much runway, this much term on your loan, things like that. We'll talk about some other conditions in just a minute here as well. So actually, structuring a pledge, kind of talked about a little bit why you'd want to do it. Now it's...

44:08 Kind of some of the additional criteria as to what it should and shouldn't do. So it should facilitate the operation of a project that wouldn't occur but for the pledge. So we don't want to subsidize or look to support a project that doesn't need it, that's going to happen anyway. It would just be a gift of our money, right? We also want it to be a measured response, a precise response to an established financial need. We need to understand why the

44:36 The market, the private market will not allow or facilitate the development of this product. Is it a problem with the product? Is it something that the market just doesn't need? Or is there some other external condition that is precluding this thing from being developed? And then finally, it's got to benefit us, right? It's got to be a clear win for us. We're not just going to give away money and not have some return for that.

45:03 A revenue pledge should not facilitate the ongoing operation of a project that's just not sustainable. We saw this in some retail environments, that towns or cities would provide a subsidy to an existing retailer because their margins just weren't working and the towns or cities were so reliant on that sales tax revenue. It's just, it's not sustainable, right? You've got to make sure we're not subsidizing an operation that's just going to wither at some point down the road. We don't want to delay the inevitable.

45:32 We want something that will be successful but for this initial condition. We don't want to make up for a bad deal. We don't want to come in and help out a developer that overpaid for land, figured it out two years down the road, and says, by the way, I need some help. We want to make sure it's a project that made sense economically or makes sense economically, but there's some external factor that's keeping it from occurring. And then the last one, we don't want to unnecessarily expose ourselves to risk.

46:01 Got to condition our pledge in certain ways to protect ourselves as much as possible. There is inherently risk in these types of things, some risk, but we can protect ourselves to different degrees. So different ways to structure a pledge. You'll see, you know, if you look out in the world of these types of deals, you'll see that they're all done in a different number, any number of ways. You can do a percentage of revenues, and I'm going to go through each of these in just a minute more detail.

46:31 You can do a stated amount or a fixed amount that may or may not change with time so it can grow or it can go down. You can do a waterfall or a tiered structure where, you know, you get yours, we get ours, you get yours, we get ours, some measure of that. And then there are a lot of ways to limit the pledge. You can say we're only going to give you so much money. We'll do a floor every year or ceiling every year, a cap.

46:52 We'll do a fixed number of years, five years, 10 years, 20 years, whatever that is. We may have a termination on certain events. Again, we're going to talk about these in greater detail in just a moment. Or you may have a prescribed amount that once we give you $10 million in revenue, you're gone. You know, we're done. Have a good day. Thank you. So the first one, structuring a pledge based on a percentage of revenues. I got a little chart here, this hypothetical scenario.

47:18 In this case, we said we're going to keep 60% with the town. We're going to keep 60%. We're going to give 40% to the hotel operator. This is entirely performance-based, and we the town share in the upside and the downside. You've got this hypothetical bar chart. This is 10 years of performance. I've built in the first four years, excuse me, the first three years of the performance that we've been looking at originally. In year four, I said, I can't remember the exact number, but it's maybe like an 8% decline.

47:45 Year 4 to 5 is a 20% drop. Thank you very much. It's a 20% drop. So remember, we were at 12% in town over the last 12 years. It was the greatest drop we've had. This is showing a 20% drop. And then ramping back up over time. So in this chart, the green is us. The blue is the hotel. You can see under this scenario,

48:16 You know, we had a couple of good years when we started out. We had that 20% drop. Even with that 20% drop, we never really got below by much, kind of the original amount that we were getting. But we did have a major impact. It was a big hit. Hotel lost some revenues. Yes. Thank you. So, and maybe you cover it later. I don't know. When you structure something like this, you're making the assumption up front at what the nightly rate is going to be. However, in a town like Mammoth, we have seen...

48:45 That in the lean years, to get people in their beds, because they need people in their beds, we see price drops. Sure. Do you ever fix price in this, so you're going to get a percentage of what the average daily rate is, regardless what they pimp the price to? Yeah, absolutely. And that is absolutely kind of one of the next ones we start laying in. Absolutely spot on. Didn't mean to ask too soon. No, it's a perfect question. I always like it when the question comes before the next slide, so it's good. Because we're going in the right direction.

49:14 Correct. So the downside of this is that you are exposed to upside and downside, and so is the hotel. What you want to do is cover your downside, limit your downside, right? So the next one, a stated amount. This is kind of getting into what you're talking about. It's one way to achieve it. So in this case, we're going to say we get the first $60 in revenue out of $100 in revenue. We're going to keep the first $60 in transient occupancy tax revenue, and our costs go up over time as a town.

49:40 We don't have fixed operating costs, so we need to see a 3% or 5% growth, let's say, on an annual basis. So year one, 60 bucks. Year two, what is that, 66? What am I doing? That's close there. That's 10%. Sorry. Yes. Thank you. Someone's got it. I'm losing it. Sorry, guys. Yeah, 62. And then growing thereafter, right? So you've got this fixed amount that we get, and then anything on top of that,

50:09 For a period of time or some other defined way the hotel gets. So they're highly incentivized on performance. They're incentivized on performance regardless. They're not going to leave money on the table. If they can charge more for a room night, they're going to charge more for a room night. But they sometimes have capacity to do things like marketing, things like that, that they could invest additional money in a hotel to increase hotel performance.

50:35 And so they might get a bigger piece of that TOT pie in this case. So in this case, we have some downside protection. We're not entirely protected if revenue is below $60. If total TOT revenue is below $60, then we get cut into that, right? Our revenue is, we would not get the full $60 in that case. But we've got full downside protection. The downside is that we don't have upside coverage, right? If things are going really well, we're not going to get a piece of that necessarily. Yes, please.

51:01 Question? No? Okay. Sorry. So maybe we don't care. You know, we're a risk-averse organization traditionally. That's our mindset. So maybe we don't care. We just get our piece of pie for a fixed period of time, and then we'll move on. And then once there's no more agreement, we get everything, right? The last one is a waterfall. It's kind of a hybrid. And you can layer in elements from each of these, right? You can come up with whatever deal makes sense.

51:30 For us, if we have certain things that we need to achieve financially that we know are occurring for this period of time but not that period of time, we can structure around that. If a hotel operator or developer has certain things, certain financing covenants that they need to achieve and meet, we can structure around this. We can do this very prescribed, I like to use that word, it's very prescribed, very specific and measured response to the need. This waterfall agreement says, in this case,

51:56 We're going to take the first 60 bucks. This doesn't have a growth component in this example, but we could. But we're going to take the first 60 bucks. Hotel, you need $50 to solve your financing problems, right? So we're going to give you the next 50, and then we're going to take everything above that. So we get the first 60, hotel gets the next 50, and then anything on top of that, it comes back to us. So there's not an unlimited amount of revenue flowing to a hotel developer. It's only based on a need again.

52:24 We then have that same downside protection we had from the measured or stated amount. And we also participate in an excessive upside where we're doing really well. And then the hotel gets a known amount commensurate with its actual need. So there's a lot of different ways identified there. As I said, you can mix and match these to whatever is appropriate for a transaction. Now talking about how do we limit these pledges, right? Because we don't just want to give away money. We can have a floor.

52:52 That these layer into those other structure amounts I was just talking about where we or a hotel gets a stated minimum amount until a floor is hit, right? So we could be first in line. We could be second in line. Obviously, we want to be first in line. We could have a ceiling or a cap. So town or we or the hotel get a stated maximum amount or a certain percentage. You can mix that percentage with a cap until that cap is hit. We can do a fixed number of years, which we always do.

53:19 A fixed number of years. And so you say it's five years or 10 years or 20 years, perhaps in extreme cases. We can have it terminated upon certain events. We usually like to layer these in that if there's a cash out refinancing by the hotel operator, that means that they've done well. They've gotten their money out. We're done. You know, we're good. Hotels in operation. You don't need this city pledge anymore, town pledge anymore to help you operate.

53:42 And you can do that on a blanket refinance or just a regular refinance as well, whatever you want. You can do it on a sale of the hotel as well, excuse me. And then prescribed amount or value, try and shy away from these, but the notion is that the pledge terminates when a stated amount of revenue has been provided. The way we like to shy away from these is they're performance-based, but typically a developer wants this to be based on present value. And so when you're looking at an underwriting of a hotel,

54:12 We talked about capitalization rates, investment rates, things like that. They may want that discount rate, that required rate of return to be 6% or 8%. And so if we're trying to measure this revenue on a present value basis, that could take out, it could extend, poor performance could really extend the tail and the duration of our transient occupancy tax agreement. And we really don't want to measure money at 6% or 8% discount rate.

54:37 Our cost of capital as an entity is usually much lower than that, so we'd rather not kind of measure it that way. But that is an option, certainly. And I will say the last thing on it. Yes, please. Is that allowed? If you have a pledge, let's say a 10-year pledge, but you're five years into it, have you ever done a restructuring of that pledge, say five years in, so for another 10 years and then lower the requirements, almost like a refinance to lower the hotel years?

55:07 Yeah, we have seen, typically they're structured in advance, it's for a construction need typically, and so that's prescribed from the get-go. What I have seen is that down the road, a hotel doing well, they were interested in refinancing and wanted to extend or eliminate kind of some of these carve-out provisions or these termination provisions, and so the city did agree.

55:36 And we usually, we really like to structure these.

56:06 Away from profitability and more on the let's get this built and then you developer are responsible for achieving the profitability that you're after. So another alternative, and this is one that we definitely like quite a bit, is a debt service reserve fund, effectively. So if you think back to those coverage ratios and how big of an impact a little bit of TOT can have on coverage ratios, in a lender,

56:37 Is really just interested in getting their money back with interest, right? They don't want to own a hotel. They don't want this thing to go bankrupt. And so if we can somehow provide them comfort that they're going to get their money back, that can go a long way. This structure basically puts money into a bucket, our TOT money into a bucket. The developer doesn't get it. But if there's a problem with hotel operations within certain provisions, that money becomes available to help make debt service payments.

57:05 It is funded in amount by or measured by TOT. When these are structured, we're not giving TOT. We're giving revenue that is measured by TOT. But as I said, that can help the lender get comfortable with a loan. It can help them underwrite the project. It can result in lower interest rates, which helps increase profitability of the hotel, which helps make it financially feasible, and or higher loan ratios. So I talked about kind of the 60% to 70% loan-to-value ratios.

57:33 Maybe a lender is willing to take that up to 75% loan to value. And so that increased amount of debt helps the remaining balance of equity achieve a greater return, right? It's financial leverage that helps improve profitability and feasibility. And then it says can provide construction or mini perm lender comfort that a permanent loan is easier to underwrite.

57:57 The bank, the construction lender, the mini perm lender, that initial lender is really, as I said, concerned about getting their money back. Their concern is that after construction, someone's going to want to provide a loan to the hotel operator. And so if this debt service reserve fund can be in place, the initial lender that's not providing the loan down the road can get comfort that, yes, somebody is going to take out this, it's going to take out my first loan down the road. And so that gives them comfort as well.

58:26 When it's structured that way? Yeah. So we have been told that if we do this sort of a funding, it kicks in prevailing wages. So if you structure this, the pledge instead, you're not actually giving money unless an emergency happens. Does that kick prevailing wage for the whole project up front?

58:54 Or to do any of these kick prevailing wage. That's just what we've been told. Yeah. So you've got to talk to counsel. I just have to say that first. And I'm not a prevailing wage attorney. What we see is that subsidizing construction, pretty much without a doubt, will trigger prevailing wage unless there's a commensurate public benefit provided. So a public benefit in the amount of or equal to, excuse me, greater than or equal to the amount of the public investment.

59:23 An example would be a parking garage, that if we pay for a parking garage or subsidized project, that we get a parking garage delivered for us. That parking garage would have to be built with prevailing waste labor, typically, but it may not cause the rest of the project to be triggered prevailing wage. On the operating side, because a hotel is built, if we provide an operating backstop or subsidy, there's less, the hotel is already built at that point.

59:50 And so there's no labor to pay that prevailing wage piece on. But there may be operational implications, certainly. And so bottom line, it's always on a case-by-case basis. Prevailing wage law is very particular. But it has the potential not to be as likely to trigger prevailing wage. Put it that way, on the operating side, yeah. Has any of these things been through department's labor relations? Yes. So there's case law, there's litigation?

1:00:20 I think that there would be letter rulings, and certainly, yeah, from DIR, yeah, and I'm trying to think of specific case law. Operating covenants have been around for quite some time, and they don't, I haven't seen one triggered permailing wage, well, I say that. Some entities, it is very nuanced law and depends very much on the specific circumstances in the case, but.

1:00:50 Some cities will naturally, even with an operating covenant, say this is prevailing wage. Or they may say, that you, developer, have to pay prevailing wage. Or they may say, if this requires prevailing wage, that you have to pay that. And that doesn't necessarily absolve the town or city of any risk. I think ultimately there's some case law that says you, the town, city, cannot.

1:01:18 Put that on to somebody else. If that entity is unable to do it, you are still on the hook, basically, to pay for that premium. Unique, perhaps, to town is that I would expect that the cost of labor here is higher than other areas, and so maybe there's not a margin or as much of a margin between, let's call it market labor and prevailing wage labor. Does that answer your question? How long is this pledge?

1:01:47 How many years has this kind of activity been around, you know, such that, and you're right, it's very idiosyncratic, it's case by case, I mean, who knows who could show up and file a protest, a file claim against a project and say. Yeah, I haven't been alive long enough probably to know kind of the first one, but they have been around a long time, they have been scrutinized, and it is definitely case by case, you know, there's every transaction, and that's why we talk about

1:02:17 The negotiation and how do you structure. Every transaction is unique. So real quick, what's the difference between all this and development agreements? Development agreements, it's just sort of tala rasa, whatever the parties can agree to, it's fairly straightforward. How does this relate to the development agreement? A pledge can be implemented through a development agreement. I would say that that's an advance of construction. So going back to the prevailing wage, that would be a...

1:02:45 Concern, certainly more of a concern on through or through a development agreement. It can be implemented through an operating covenant after the hotel's constructed and operating, things like that. It can be implemented through leases. There's different ways to structure through a lease, things like that. But they've been around a long time. But again, it just, it comes down to a case by case basis for sure. Yeah. I think the safe way is to assume you're going to pay per million wage. That'd be the safest thing. Yeah. And sometimes that kills.

1:03:15 Any question or request for tax sharing? In many cases, let's say a developer comes to a town asking for $5 million on a $50 million project, let's say. So they're looking for 10% of their construction costs from the town. Prevailing wage could easily kick that up 20%, so adding $10 million to the project. So they've asked for a subsidy. We give them five, their costs go up by 10.

1:03:45 They're $5 million in the hole now, right? And then it's just you're chasing, you know, a negative thing. It's a safe assumption for sure. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. The cleanest way to do it would be to start with that assumption. Yeah. So this reserve, you put DOT revenue into a bucket, right? Often it's held by a third party in trust. And there are covenants that say if

1:04:16 XYZ happens if the hotel can't make its debt service payment, that this bucket is available with conditions and covenants, but it's available to make debt service. This next example, so continuing with the same numbers basically, we've got this hotel, $100,000 in operating revenue year one, 30% operating margin, so it's got $30,000 a year in net operating income, same debt service of $25,000, initial coverage ratio is 1.2.

1:04:46 The TOT, 100% of TOT is $13,000 in this case, right? So we've added now in this case 13% to the top line of this hotel. If we put that into a reserve fund in two years, we've got, and these numbers are, these ratios are right. You know, they're kind of in the ballpark. And so you can see in two years, we've got enough money set aside from our, from our TOT revenue debt service reserve. We're putting 100% in on this case. We've got enough to make.

1:05:15 The debt service for one year. That's substantial. So within two years, we could make one, the hotel could completely fail and we can make a payment. This is attractive to a bank because they're concerned at that kind of the initial operations. They are concerned about how to get their money back. And for them to do that, they've got kind of two things. One is they've got this loan to value ratio that they've only lent up to a certain percentage of the hotel's value. Let's say it's 70%.

1:05:44 The hotel's worth $100,000. The lender could foreclose on that hotel and sell that $100,000 asset, in theory, for $70,000 and fully recoup their investment, right, or their loan. The second piece that they need is time. They need time to foreclose and time to reposition that asset. These are kind of worst-case scenarios. Ideally, they would work with the existing operator.

1:06:13 If they needed to use some of those funds from this reserve to stabilize operations. But worst case scenario, they need a little bit of time to remove legally the existing operator, sell the asset and reposition it. And that's what this type of bucket can do. A year of debt service payments, two years probably ideal of debt service payments would achieve that. And when we've structured these in the past, we often ask or require a developer to put money aside as well. So the developer's money is in line first.

1:06:42 I got one bucket, go to the next bucket of Waterfall. Then our money becomes available. But it's only available in case really of emergency. The other thing is that we can require repayment provisions. If it is tapped into, it can be an extended repayment provision, you know, once a hotel is repositioned or sold, things like that, so that we do get our money back if it is ever used. Any questions so far?

1:07:11 Shifting gears again, so this is other considerations, just kind of broad philosophical discussion of hotels and what we should think about throughout these different options. TOT does pay for things in our town. Obviously, it's more apparent in Mammoth Lakes than in other cities, but so 58% of our revenue coming from TOT, that's how we pay for a lot of our municipal services, right? So we have to pay for things. A hotel does drive demand for services.

1:07:40 And so we don't want to give it all up, or we have to be very responsible about what we do give up. And then another piece is that we can elect to require public benefits if we do decide to offer a pledge. We can ask for things like, these are just pieces we've done in other deals. Meeting room access, reduce roommates for public services. An example of that is that in one city, police department had a desire to have access to hotel rooms, basically, if they had a domestic.

1:08:10 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:08:40 Some of the room nights from that new hotel are probably going to cannibalize other hotels in the area at least until the market can grow and attract additional room nights. So there is potential for cannibalization of existing hotel TOT revenues. Part of the function of that is that if we're giving up, let's just say 50% of revenues for a couple years at Hotel A and Hotel B, the existing hotel in town, we're getting 100% of their revenue.

1:09:07 Every person that goes and stays at Hotel A, we're losing 50% of that hotel revenue until the market grows. But traditionally, we do expect the market to grow and TOT to improve. And we would do that because 5 years, 10 years, whatever down the road, we would get 100% of the transient occupancy tax revenue and there would be market growth. The last slide here on other considerations, it may be a question of equity for existing hoteliers.

1:09:38 And it's a justified question, right? I didn't get a subsidy. Why do they get a subsidy? Or they got a subsidy. Where's my subsidy? It could also drive additional requests for revenue sharing. Every new hotel that comes to town, if you establish a precedent, everybody else will probably want to seek or at least evaluate the potential for a subsidy. To counter that, some public entities create very prescribed guidelines as to what they are or are not willing to do. And this does help counter that to some extent.

1:10:08 Prevailing wage also is certainly a factor, depending on how it's structured, that pushes people away from these types of deals as well. Sometimes it's just not worth it, but some municipalities will say we're only willing to give a pledge or a site-specific tax revenue agreement to full-service or luxury hotels because they bring in a lot of revenue for each room night.

1:10:30 They bring in patrons who tend to spend more money on other amenities in town. So there's ancillary benefits. There may be a minimum room count. So 150 rooms, 200 rooms, 250 rooms. Has to be of a significant enough scale that it makes sense for this transaction for us. Maximum number of years. We're only going to do it for up to five years, 10 years, 20 years. Maximum percentage of revenues. Doesn't hurt to say from the outset, you know, we're keeping 80% of our money, period.

1:10:59 We're not going to even entertain anything that's more than 80% or 60% or whatever it is. And then the last one is that only for new hotels or hotels with substantial renovations. And that's defined in various ways. But essentially creating a new hotel that requires this investment to get it off the ground and operating. So any questions on so far? Yeah, well, I think that looking at your schedule here,

1:11:25 This would be a good time to take a break so everyone can get up. Yeah, thank you. I'm sorry. Yeah, please. And we'll get back in five minutes. That's great. Thank you very much, Mayor. What are we doing? You take a break from five to six or are you here for the duration? Depends on when we get out of here. Usually I just stick, go downstairs and buy some. Okay. Thank you all. Will. Thank you, Mayor. So, I'm sorry. As a refresher now, we're...

1:12:16 Shifting gears, kind of that last act, special districts, just a couple of slides here to talk about these. Redevelopment agencies, as I think a lot of us know, went away recently. They've been replaced with a couple of different options, and some of these iterations of these were in place prior to redevelopment and during redevelopment. But they are fundamentally tax increment financing districts, similar to redevelopment. The difference is that how we get money into them has changed a little bit.

1:12:45 The big ones right now are EIFDs, Enhanced Infrastructure Financing Districts, and CREAs, which are related more to housing. These districts work best when we partner with other entities to pool our money with redevelopment agencies. We as a town could just establish an area and siphon off incremental revenue from all other affected taxing agencies. Now we have to have people kind of volunteer to put money into them.

1:13:13 But they still can be powerful. There is a lot of flexibility in designing geographic boundaries, especially for EIFDs. You can say we want this block to be in there and three houses two blocks down the road to be in it. You can define it however you want. They're typically funded with property tax revenues, but we can choose to allocate TOT if we wanted to because we've got a lot of TOT revenue in town, sales tax, vehicle license fees, those types of things.

1:13:41 A good example of this is that we could partner with Mono Lake, the county of Mono Lake, who gets, I think the number is 24 or 29 percent of the property tax revenue from every dollar of property tax revenue in town. We could partner with them and take our meager, sorry I forgot the number, but it's like four or five cents that we get from property tax revenue out of that dollar. We could put that together and try and solve an affordable housing program in town, things like that. And we could...

1:14:08 Take a specific project as an example. If we have a big development, we could say, this is in our EIFD. Property owner could say, yes, I agree. Property's in your EIFD. And then incremental revenue that's spun off of that property tax, whatever we want to assign to it, transient occupancy tax, could go into this EIFD and fund a specific program. And why would you do that? You do that because

1:14:30 You link up with that partner agency. You kind of get married with them. And so there's certainty about that piece. And there's also certainty from a financing perspective. So you kind of silo money into this district so that you could issue financing from those revenues that are going to accrue over time to get money up front to, as an example, build an affordable housing project. So in conclusion,

1:15:00 There are, I understand, there has been an interest from developers or a developer to enter into a tax-sharing agreement. You may see these coming down the road. It is the reality of hotel development in some instances, especially hotels on the higher end, higher end of the scale, you know, four-star, kind of five-star arrangements. They don't always pencil in those first couple years, and so that's why you might get those requests. The neat thing is, the second bullet there, you can make...

1:15:28 If you want to enter into an agreement, you can make whatever deal you want that's legal. So you can come up with whatever whiz-bang, fancy, complicated, simple deal that you want to do. If you want to write in some provision about they have to serve the best margarita in town or whatever, you can write that into a deal. Bottom line, though, any agreement should seek to minimize our risk. We've talked about some of the ways to do that.

1:15:55 And minimize the diversion of our revenue. As minimal, if we do want to, if we are willing to divert revenue, it should be the smallest amount possible that makes that or helps that deal work. And then we should be clear on our rationale if we elect to enter into it. We should be explicit as to why we're doing it, what we expect to get out of it, and we should establish kind of a basis for people down the road to say, here's why they did it, here's what they're willing to do, what they're not willing to do.

1:16:21 So that if it is a precedent, it's a precedent that we can continue with going forward. And then the last piece there is that we can, if we want to, implement a district where we can isolate incremental revenue from one project, i.e. a big hotel, to support another public policy goal, i.e. affordable housing in town. There are ways to do that. So with that, I've got one of my favorite pictures from Mammoth.

1:16:51 There and open to questions. It wasn't the best day of skiing, but that was a great shot, so great fun. So I have a question. Do you often see these agreements with hotels that are being rebuilt, or is it just typically newer hotels? It is typically or most frequently with new hotels. The rebuilt equation is

1:17:24 It sometimes happens. And it all goes back to a deal-by-deal basis that what is the level of investment required for that rebuilt hotel?

1:17:34 What are they, are they shifting in the marketplace? Are they adding a lot of new amenities, things like that? What is the fundamental need for it? But it is certainly an option for a repo hotel. And the argument for it would be that if you're moving a hotel from, let's say, $60 a night in a room rate to $300 a night in a room rate, that would be a lot of growth in transient occupancy tax. And if you can reasonably expect that they're going to be successful in making that transition, they just need a little bit of help, then maybe there's a reason to do that.

1:18:03 Would you see a decreased amount of years that you would give them a percentage of TOT since it's a remodel versus new? Yeah, I think the goal is always to minimize what we're giving them. And so to that end, and I didn't talk about it much, or if at all, but this can be a very intimate process and a perhaps uncomfortable process for a developer. But the expectation from our side as a public entity is that

1:18:32 We understand very clearly what their deal is, what their costs are, what they expect to make on a profit basis, because we have to understand that this is a warrant, this is a needed investment, right? And so it is very prescribed from that basis that we're looking under the hood, we're seeing what their books look like, what their profitability looks like, and what their expectation is on room revenue. And so we're going to seek to minimize our investment.

1:19:01 I think precisely the question is we're going to invest as little as possible to get that deal across the finish line. And you can also include provisions that if they do better than expected, that terminates the deal early, things like that. We want to help it get built. We want to get it across the finish line or make sure that those first few years of operation are stable, that they can operate and pay their debt service those first few years until they get stabilized.

1:19:31 And then we're out as much as possible. So there's not like an average amount of time that you do a TOT reduction. So, you know, is like a 20-year kind of a long time versus a 10-year? Yeah. Is it just case by case? It is case by case. Some cities, City of LA as an example, is frequently open to a 20-year deal. I think that's a long time. It depends on the other elements of it. You know, maybe it's a fixed amount for 20 years. So if you're saying $100,000 a year for 20 years.

1:20:00 Maybe that doesn't matter as much because 20 years from now, $100,000 isn't worth as much money. It doesn't have as much value to us. The flip side of that is that because a developer, usually their cost of capital is higher. They're paying higher interest rates. They're expecting more return on their equity investment. That when you drag it out that long, that 20th year has very little value for them today. So it's in their interest and it's in our interest.

1:20:28 To get it done as quickly as possible and solve that question as quickly as possible. My preference is kind of much shorter than that in recommendation. It also kind of goes back to we want to solve less the profitability of the project and more the financial feasibility of it. And those are linked, certainly. But that 20-year term often is to try and satisfy a...

1:20:57 A profit margin up front, you know, or can be. Sometimes it's to solve financing, but shorter is better, for sure. Thank you. I have a question about the risk factors and protections. You've got the hotel economics on page 20, and then on page 21, it says limit revenue pledge. Are we talking about the TOT revenue pledge until commencement of operations? Because, I mean... Yes, thank you, yeah.

1:21:26 Absolutely. So that would be, and I didn't define pledge, but. Right, because it couldn't be a TOT pledge. It is a TOT pledge, yeah. So that's the reference is limit revenue pledges, limit our TOT contributions until it's in operation. In other words. How would we get TOT if it wasn't in operation? Correct. So the alternative would be that in some, it's a risky proposition, but some entities will say, okay, we're going to give you $2 million, let's say, to help with construction.

1:21:56 And we're going to get repaid through TOT, or you're going to repay us through TOT revenues effectively, that they are willing to do an upfront contribution in advance of construction. And then that entity takes on construction risk as well. And then that goes on back to what John was talking about with the prevailing wage. Especially the prevailing wage, absolutely. Okay, thank you. I just wanted to clarify that. Yes, thank you. I have a quick question about the special districts.

1:22:20 I'm just specifically looking at bullet point number two, and it says when agencies partner to fund and promote goals, I'm assuming, and I think I heard you correctly, Will, where you said it's a voluntary partnership? Correct, yeah. So redevelopment that's no longer allowed in the state of California, there are no longer redevelopment agencies, that allowed us to form a redevelopment area and say we're going to take a snapshot in time as to what property taxes are right now.

1:22:48 And whatever grows, whatever growth there is in property tax, we, the town, get usually 80% of it or some massive percent of it. There are some prescribed amounts that had to go to schools, things like that. But we could take from, in this case, Mono County, fire districts, water districts, all those things. We could take fixed amounts of revenue from that. Now it is, okay, let's court Mono County.

1:23:15 And get them to agree that this is a good project to work on so that they are willing to give up their piece of property tax revenue that's going to come from this area to invest. And the case I gave was a hotel. If you have a hotel, it's an expensive development. Typically, if it's a large hotel, it's going to create a lot of new property tax revenue. That's not revenue that the county has or that we have right now. It only occurs when that hotel comes online. So we can take some or all of that.

1:23:44 New revenue, partner up with Mono County because they get such a big piece of property tax revenue and look to build affordable housing, as an example, or look to build a parking structure, things like that that benefit both agencies and entities with the goal that if we do that, we can either increase revenues by rising tide, lifting all boats in a property improvement area.

1:24:11 Or in the case of affordable housing, achieve a public policy goal. But it is voluntary. Are there cases in this day and age, Will, where another agency is brought in involuntarily? Not to my knowledge. That's a good question.

1:24:29 Okay, so let's say you have four, you're looking at four agencies to come in. So if three, you can't force one. Okay. Yeah. Oh, I see. Yeah, majority rules or something. Something along those lines. I'm just wondering if there's ever an example. I'd say it's pretty fair now. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. And requires good transactions. Yeah.

1:24:56 Well, can you bring in, so for example, if the county and the town went into a district, went into this agreement together, would they each get their own part of it? Is there any advantage to doing that? What do you mean by they each get their own part of it? Well, so, you know, the county would get the county share of increased value, and we would get what was in the town increased value. Is there any advantage to doing a double entity like that? So what happens is you form a district,

1:25:24 You group up, you know, you get married, county and the town, and that district now is kind of a separate entity that gets whatever revenue each entity has said they're going to contribute to it, right? So each entity makes an investment essentially into that district. And so if the county is getting, say, 29% of a dollar of property tax revenue, they may say we're willing to give 29%, they may say 20 cents on the dollar, 10 cents on the dollar.

1:25:52 Whatever it is, they divert that into that, in this case, let's say EIFD, Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District. We're putting in our four cents or whatever we decide we're going to do. And with that revenue, then, we can do a project together. The EIFD exists for a prescribed period of time. You've got typically 40 years plus, so you can issue bonds, things like that, and pay for those bonds with that property tax revenue.

1:26:22 That physical ownership of that project, continuing along with the affordable housing example, that may be a city contribution to an affordable housing developer that actually develops and operates the project so they would own it. We could agree that our share, our contribution to this district is a fixed amount because we're trying to solve, let's say, a bond payment or something like that.

1:26:51 So what I'm hearing here that I think is really important for all of us to understand is this is a

1:27:23 This is a voluntary thing. And that very clear and compelling rationale has to be identified between parties that can be communicated to the public, the public can understand why we're doing it. This is not a normal part of doing real estate or any kind of development. This is an extraordinary set of circumstances. That's right, and that's true both of the special districts and hotels, for sure. I want to make that clear. The second thing is...

1:27:52 A couple of years ago, we had a developer come to the, I think we had a joint meeting of the planning commission of the town and said, hey, we want to do a development agreement. Started laying out, I think, 26 different things. I think it was literally 26 different questions that we expected to get responses to. We never got a response to it. But part of that was to get into some kind of TOT type arrangement similar to something like this. And the town didn't have any independent data or any independent source of numbers to be able to

1:28:21 Entering the kind of sophisticated conversation we would have to have to figure out if a good deal was going to be made or not. So my question to you is what type of data or what things should the town maintain as an ongoing set of information, statistics, numbers, things like that, such that when someone shows up and says we want to do something, we've at least got some baseline information that would be useful in the conversations. And if the process were to proceed,

1:28:51 What is the best way for the town to get the type of third-party, objective, independent information necessary to engage and maybe figure out if this is going to be a good deal or not for the community? Yeah, absolutely. Good question. So in terms of information on hand, I think because it's a case-by-case basis, what matters most is the specifics of the project that's asking for assistance. You've got...

1:29:20 You know, you've got information on occupancy in town, things like that. After the fact, after somebody has purchased a piece of property, after they've figured out what they want to do with it, when they come to you, after the fact, you can still go back and figure it out. Let me just talk right there. So we may have people who may come into town and buy land, and they may be not, you know, understanding the specifics to save the cost of construction. Sure. They may not have done their kind of due diligence as to what land values actually are. Right.

1:29:50 And they may be coming to us to try to get them out of a hole that they got themselves into. And I think it would, I'm just thinking it would be useful for the town to be maintaining a set of statistics and numbers that say, well, what do you mean you thought it was only going to cost you 400 bucks a square foot to build? We all know that it's 750. So I'm just wondering if things that we should be maintaining so that we don't waste their time making proposals, we can say out of the box, this is what we're dealing with.

1:30:19 Yeah. I think that is an education process for sure. And if you can get to them before they buy the property, that's when that kind of stuff would matter. But that's not our business. Yeah. We're not in that business. Correct. So I would say that, and clearly what you don't want to do is help them get out of a hole. Perfect. Yeah. After the fact, when they come to you, there is information. The information that you need won't go away.

1:30:49 Meaning that you can go back and look at what they paid for the property. You can figure out if that's a reasonable amount. We can get comps on land in town. We can look at what has and has not been developed in town. We can look at construction costs. We can look at financing costs at that point in time when they come and make that request. And so, and I will say, it's usually very clear when somebody's paid too much money for a piece of property.

1:31:16 And so you can see that, and we're not in the business of helping them get out of a bind. But bottom line, I don't know, and I'll think about this after tonight as well, I don't know what you should keep track of to be able to make an educated decision more quickly. I think everything is kind of in the moment of when they make that request, that you have to understand construction costs at that moment in time.

1:31:43 Going forward, you have to understand interest rates at that point in time going forward. You have to understand hotel market performance at that time going forward. And those are things that there is a lot of information out there, and increasingly so over the last 20 years. There's a lot of data sources now. A lot of entities keep records on these types of things, property.

1:32:06 Hotel performance data is available. Anybody in this room could go out and buy performance data. My understanding is if a major development project comes into town and submit an application, that we can charge that proponent for doing the work necessary to process an application, correct? But if someone comes to us with a proposition like this and, well, it's a very technical, difficult kind of a thing, how do we respond? I mean, does it go to the town manager to say,

1:32:36 This is a sniff test thing. I think that if it's coming in front of the planning commission or the council, we would want to have some basing information to be able to have a conversation with the town manager that says, hey, you know, this doesn't make any sense on the face of it. Or there are a couple of indicators that make sense that this might make sense for us. Because we don't, in that previous scenario described, the developer stood up there and said, we want you to trust the numbers of our consultant to determine whether or not this is a good deal. And that was, we were in a bind right out of the box because we didn't know where do we go get that kind of thing.

1:33:05 Yeah, no, fair enough. So, what, typically, when we're asked to come in, there is a market study, or we have a market study done. We've been Cosmo. Correct, we've been Cosmo. If somebody says, look, we've got this developer, can you look at this? And oftentimes, we'll have a phone call, and we'll talk about kind of just...

1:33:30 Ballparking numbers, and that's the end of the discussion of a participation agreement, right? If it passes the SNF test, then the developer has to provide, we have to look under the hood, the developer provides their information, their numbers, and we see, did they pay too much for the land, as an example? What are their assumptions? And then if you continue to move down the road, then you say, okay, we need a market study, or the developer will provide a market study. There are third parties that will...

1:33:59 Typically, it's a third party that does that market city anyway. And so we look to that and look at the reasonableness of that and continue down the road just to see if it's a realistic assumption. And when we do that, the things that we're looking at are land price, construction costs, hotel market performance, operating margins, things like that, so that we can get a handle on what their profitability is and what the true need is for that request. But it goes back to it is a very...

1:34:29 Case by case basis. And, you know, there are questions that you can ask a developer and say, you know, what's your profit margin, right? And see what their response is. And then you get to try and validate that down the road. But if their profit is excessive, then you can right off the bat say it's not of interest. But it is a nuanced discussion. But in that scenario, you earn a contract to a public agency, to a town.

1:34:54 That's right. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. And as I said at the outset, we've never represented, to my knowledge, ever a private entity in structuring these. It's always a public entity that we've operated on or on behalf of. And often just a phone call is sufficient to see if it's worth proceeding. You don't charge for those phone calls, do you? Not usually. Only a foreign contract. First of all.

1:35:20 Yeah, first call is free, right? I'm generous. I'm happy to field calls. Yes, I was actually hoping for a Mammoth employee jacket, but we can get one of those. We don't do those. Yeah, fair enough. We have logo wear, but it's too big for you. Yeah, very good. Thank you.

1:35:48 There is a question of if it passes the SNF test. It is, again, very quick, but I think it is such a nuanced thing that each case is unique. I will say that if you have a kind of a stated policy that says, here's what we would consider, that may filter out some of the requests for you. You know, if you say you agree that, look, we're only doing four-star, five-star, full-service, luxury, 200 rooms or more, and

1:36:18 It's got to achieve these other things, then you may filter out some of those requests as well. Do you recommend setting that kind of policy? We're not interested in entertaining anything unless your nut is X size, you're more than 50 rooms, or your nightly rate is over 500? Yeah, I think it's not a bad idea. I think that if you feel like you're...

1:36:47 If you anticipate getting requests, that I think that with that first one, if you do decide that you want to enter into agreement, that first one you have a discussion about why are we doing this and what is that, what measurement, what's the lens that we should use to look through this deal as acceptable or not? And so that there's clarity both for that transaction but also the public as to why you're doing something.

1:37:17 And that sends a signal to a developer as to here's what we're looking for and here's what we're willing to consider. So the other question I have, which is really unrelated to this part, Cosmot works with an awful lot of different cities and towns, so you see a lot of things. Are you seeing any, what I would consider major projects, major as in the scale of Mammoth, not Los Angeles, moving forward that aren't asking for this? Because it sure seems to be where we are going.

1:37:47 As a country in whole is asking for the government to help make sure we don't lose money as private investors. Yeah, I think there are a lot of projects going forward. The nature of our business exposes us to a lot of projects that are trying to somehow interact with the public entity, be it through a lease or something else like that. There are a lot of projects going forward. It is heavily residential right now, for sale residential and for lease residential.

1:38:17 Probably had a zenith four years ago, five years ago, but rents have gone up dramatically throughout most real estate markets, and so those have made a lot of sense, especially with the rates of financing. But residential is a big one. Retail, not so much. Retail is shifting the landscape right now, and so developments that are retail may be asking for tax sharing, things like that. It depends on the location. A lot of times the...

1:38:45 The request comes because there's a substantial burden from the public sector on a project, be it infrastructure fees or specific improvements that need to be made. But I think generally the preference of a lot of developers is not to require a subsidy. There are things that come with that request that are burdensome. You're saying that one of the reasons for doing this, especially with a hotel, is in its first two.

1:39:14 One to five years. Yeah. You're trying to take that little bit of margin out and get it to where everybody's comfortable doing the deal and making things pencil. That's right. So if you structure it such that, okay, for the first five years, we're going to give you X. But then the 10th to 15th year, we want X back. Sure. To where it's more of a loan than a grant. Yeah. If that happens, does the issue with the

1:39:43 Prevailing wage. Prevailing wage still come in since you're not giving them a grant, you're essentially giving them a loan. Yeah. If it's a subsidized loan, then, and again, I'm not a prevailing wage attorney, and I can hear people screaming at me all over the place, back at the office and all that kind of stuff. If it's a subsidized loan, screaming at me for tiptoeing into prevailing wage law and discussion.

1:40:12 The fundamental test is usually is there a public benefit that's conferred? Are we giving public funds away? To answer that question, would a private party enter into that transaction? If we can match terms that a private party may offer, then it may not trigger prevailing wage. Are we getting a market rate benefit, in essence, for our underwriting? That said, if it's after the fact,

1:40:41 Hotel's been in business for a year and they're having trouble or something like that and they come to us and say, hey, can we do a TOT loan and you structure it that way? Maybe that passes the test. I think it goes back to that you can structure whatever you want structure and it goes back to the discussion of that early money is so important as you're talking about to a hotel and especially based on rates of return. And so if you say, look, we're happy getting our money back in year 10 or year.

1:41:07 15, then we will give up those first five years. That that's something that somebody may be attractive to a developer. It helps the financing when we get the money back. That's right. Absolutely. You can do a low-interest loan. That's about what you can do. If you forgive and give the loan principal, that's turned into a prevailing wage project. It's only been a year since the hotel project in Palm Springs got popped over a TOT revenue sharing agreement that was ordered retroactively to pay for prevailing wages.

1:41:36 Anything that we do along these lines, I would highly suggest that we get an opinion from DIR as to whether the structure of the deal triggers prevailing wages or not. Because as I recall, if prevailing wages are required and we neglect to require them of the developer, then we could end up being on the road for the penalties and the interest. Correct. That's everything. Any kind of subsidy, any prevailing wage, subsidized loan is about the only exception. There are some nuances to that.

1:42:05 So no matter what the structure is that we try to do, we should really get in demand. And I think even the subsidized loan can be a question as well. Yes. It's really important to emphasize that this whole prevailing wage issue goes in the Department of Labor Relations, I think it's called. It's enormously idiosyncratic. Anybody can file, can look at some aspect for a project and say, I don't like something, and file an appeal. It's not something to be...

1:42:33 The participating agencies will file that on the front end on their own volition. This is our deal. This is what we're doing. And then they'll give an opinion that at least you can rely on that. And it's binding. A validation, yeah. A letter and a validation, yeah. Well, even outside. And they've gone both directions, so it's, yeah. Even outside the brave angry wage, it'd be nice if we incentivize them to do the project, but then eventually get the money back. That's right.

1:42:58 And that's kind of the inherent idea behind what you were talking about as well as a backstop, essentially a financing backstop is that you've never out the money. It's available if it needs to be and you're repaid if it's used. The problem, of course, is they have to get their loan approvals prior to any of that money ever being available. Yeah, no, there's, yeah, you have to be very specific in how you structure it for sure.

1:43:26 You brought up in your presentation on special districts property tax revenue. Are you aware of how our property tax in Mammoth Lakes and the county is distributed? In terms of percentages? Yeah. Yeah, I'm very familiar that it's an extremely low percentage here in town. Yeah, that's what I was wondering. And if you're looking at the others participating,

1:43:52 Like the fire district just sent me a notice that they want to, you know, add a parcel tax to do their funding. The water district is very tight with their district. I don't think we're going to get participation, which means that it's all going to fall back on TOT. Pretty much. Because they're not going to give up their sales tax or their property tax. I think that I agree, especially with the special districts, that

1:44:19 Given the nature of their operations, you'd probably end the amount of revenue that they get. It may not be even worth going after seeking a partnership with them. But the county, I think, is 29% of a dollar in property tax revenue. And if the county has goals... The town, their special district, the town only gets less than 5% of property tax. And the water district is about 15 to 17, a fire district. And so they're...

1:44:46 Their agencies, independent agencies of their own. In addition to the county, separate from those entities. The county gets about 35%. Right. That's what I'm saying. 29 cents on the dollar. Yeah. Yeah. So on a dollar of property tax. But you would partner with the county? Correct. Yeah. You would partner with the county. In that case, you'd have to find a goal that the county has. And I'm using the assumption of affordable housing, that if the county has a common goal of providing affordable housing within the county.

1:45:14 That we would say we're going to put our four or five cents per dollar in property tax that we get. And the county's going to put in some portion as well. And we're going to get affordable housing delivered, that that's a benefit for the county as well. And the reason that it can make sense is, number one, it's new money, right? It's incremental revenue. So they're not losing money that they're currently getting, would be one argument.

1:45:40 The other argument in that case is that it's a public purpose that makes sense for both parties. The other time that it can make sense, aside from a public purpose, is if you are making improvements that enhance the physical environment that support other real estate investment. So that argument would be that you've got, let's say, a dollar in property tax revenue today, and if you do, if you...

1:46:08 Make these improvements to roads or going back to that fire hydrant example where you have to run a new fire line for seven miles, right? Super expensive and not something that the project can support. But if you, if we partner with the county to deliver that, that you could open up an increased property tax basis from $1 to $100, then maybe it makes sense for the county to give up a piece of its revenue to

1:46:38 Grow that property tax base to make that improvement that allows for incremental growth, basically. So you're increasing the size of the pie, right? By giving up a little piece of what they would otherwise get. And they wouldn't otherwise get that but for the EIFT. So it's making the investment. I understand the argument. On your TOT, how do you approach another

1:47:08 Hotelier that has been in existence, we're going to give a discount to this new development, and you touched on it, but the existing hotels in the village, they'll be paying their full TOT, and all of a sudden you're saying 5% or 8% or whatever for 10 years or 5 years. How do you justify that to them? Because they will be directly competing with it, or...

1:47:36 There'll be a luxury hotel, and because we have seasons and everything else, sometimes we're 80% occupancy and sometimes 100% occupancy. All of a sudden, these people will have more flexibility as far as competing against existing hoteliers. Yeah, it's a very real argument. It's the reality of the equity discussion. I think from a town's perspective...

1:48:02 And not necessarily the hotel's perspective, but the town's perspective first. I think I saw the occupancy next Friday is 97% of hotels over 50 rooms or something like that. So they're packed, right? So from our perspective, maybe there's room in the market for additional hotel rooms. From the hotel's perspective, increased activity can help everybody. It can...

1:48:28 Get more people into town can help the market grow and increase rates. But I think there's a very valid question of equity that doesn't have a perfect answer. I think from the town's perspective, it's an increase in revenue. It's an economic development move that is designed to help the overall town. So how many different kinds of incentives should we give a new hotel? I mean, the DIF fees have been dropped to 85%.

1:48:57 We eliminated inclusionary housing. And now we're talking about giving back TOT revenues to bring in this new product that will compete with existing. I mean, how many incentives should a town consider? I mean, just to get a new hotel that will compete with existing hotels? Maybe it's zero. You know, that's a policy question. Maybe you shouldn't.

1:49:22 I think that it's a philosophical question and a policy question and an economic development question that if there is something that is not happening in town that you as a council wants to happen and think should happen, that that's when you would consider it. That somebody would come to you and say, look, this doesn't make financial sense without this. And you look at it and you say, I agree or I don't agree.

1:49:51 If it doesn't make financial sense, you can say, yes, we're willing to do it, or no, we're not. And if you say, no, we're not, maybe they will go and do some other product that makes other financial sense. And so you have an absolute choice. This is not a requirement to, by any means, to enter into an agreement. So we have a lot of stock that could use refurbishing. There's definitely. So talk a little bit again about this application with.

1:50:20 Facilities that want to refurbish and that this would perhaps spur that activity? Yeah, absolutely. It's an interesting question and because normally these are focused on new hotels and others question about substantial rehab and I understand your question about the stock in town and so you could do an evaluation in town. You could look at kind of what rates are achieved where and try and get a handle on

1:50:50 Who's investing in what, really? And you could create a policy that says, look, if you as a hotel are willing to do XYZ level of investment, you can measure as a per room rate or per room or something like that, that we will give you a TOT rebate of up to X percent for X number of years and see if that's enough to incentivize reinvestment in the hotels. The fundamental question is why isn't reinvestment happening, right? And it's unique.

1:51:19 To every property owner, right? Some property owners call them coupon clippers, right? From the bond coupons that they're happy with what they've got. They have no loan, right? Own the property outright half for 30 years and they're happy, right? And so that individual may not benefit from or may not be incentivized by that type of

1:51:44 How do lenders view lending money for new construction as opposed to remodel?

1:52:13 I would say in blanket terms, broad terms, that new construction is riskier than existing, that you've got a track record at the existing hotel in terms of performance. I would also say that larger hotels can be easier to underwrite than smaller hotels, just given...

1:52:34 You usually have what's called a flag or a chain that goes with the hotel over 100 rooms or 100 room minimum is often the case. And so if we're talking about a smaller 50 room operation or something like that, it's harder for them to get the same level of underwriting or the same interest rates. They might pay more interest for that same loan. There is more comfort with...

1:52:58 Management operations or entities that are hotels that are managed by management companies rather than individuals typically I would say. But the track record of the existing operating hotel can be a benefit certainly for underwriting. So not that the waters are muddy enough yet. Let me muddy them some more. The vast majority of our rentals here are privately on condominium units. Could this sort of financing

1:53:27 Be used for a homeowner association. The problem is in any complex in town. They're individually rented by this agency, this agency, this agency. It's not even the homeowner association that rents them. So how, I don't see a way, but how could that possibly work in that scenario? Because our old product that does need rehab in most cases exists in those privately owned.

1:53:57 Homes, basically. Yeah, and it goes back to defining the fundamental question, why isn't it happening now? What's keeping the reinvestment from happening? In the case of condominiums, especially larger complexes, it's often a case of disparate ownership, and everybody coming to the HOA meeting and fighting, or nobody shows up at the HOA meeting. So it's a good question.

1:54:27 It may not help in that case. You know, it's a functional, a fundamental question of kind of the common interest of those types of entities. And I think that what you may find or the workout for things like that in the past that I've seen are common ownership that you see an individual or individuals aggregate holdings within a block. You know, it's just like a company in stock shares that

1:54:57 Individuals go out and buy sufficient shares of stock to have the voting rights for the HOA or the company to facilitate the changes that they want done. I think defining why things aren't happening first and then seeing what kind of solution would be appropriate is a good way to do that. But I think that it's very tough when you've got disparate ownership. Okay. Any more questions from the tables up here?

1:55:24 Do we have any questions from the audience that you haven't gotten your answers to? With that, Will, I will say thank you. Thank you, Mayor. And we will adjourn until 6 o'clock when we will start these standard council meetings. Thank you all.

1:59:34 Turn on my mic and call this puppy up. I will call the November 20 meeting of the Town Council to order roll call, please. Here. Sorry, here. Here. Here. Pledge of Allegiance, Jamie, please. I pledge allegiance to the United States of America, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Okay.

2:00:27 Public comments. This is the time any member of the public wishing to speak on anything that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. Very few public. Good evening. I'm Sharon Clark and I live in Mammoth Lakes. I want to thank you staff for providing such an in-depth and comprehensive financial report of the town's concerns and projects. This is critical information.

2:01:02 That is necessary, especially to the public. Thank you, Stat. And thank you, Town Council, for preserving and retrofitting our community center. Well done. It is a town asset that needed upgrading. However, it is inconsistent with your decision to abandon and trash our $2 million mammoth ice rink.

2:01:28 Thank you. Any other member of the public wishing to speak? With that, I will applaud.

2:02:01 I will close public comments. Dan, do we have any additions to the agenda? No, Mr. Mayor, we do not. From there, I will go to reports from commissions and our departments as needed. Don't argue. Just get up. Haislip Hayes, Engineering Manager. Just a quick update. We have completed the signage and wayfinding project. We've taken down...

2:02:32 All the conflicting signs that were right around there, but we still have a number of other signs to take around that are misinformation, so our town crews are cleaning up the clutter over the next couple of weeks, so we're looking forward to having that done and ready for the next season. We also finished up the Lower Main Street project. We are substantially complete, done our walkthroughs with Caltrans.

2:02:55 Let's just let the public know there are still a few punch list items out there. The contractor will be working here and there sporadically over the next couple weeks just to pick up little items. Have had a couple conversations with business owners. We're excited about the opportunities this project will provide. I do encourage the businesses to come forward and talk about animation and the opportunities that we can provide for that. And just really excited to be finished with that project. Thank you.

2:03:23 And the sign project is looking great. Thank you. When are we going to be putting up snowflakes? Oh, I'm sorry. Stu's raising his hand. I won't steal Stu's thunder. Mr. Mayor, if I could, I just want to call out to the Public Works and the Mammoth Lakes Tourism for the work on this wayfinding project. I think it's really difficult to underestimate what a huge difference this is making to this community and this town.

2:03:51 And this is a seismic event as far as I'm concerned. And I'm hoping that as you're a representative of the MLT board, other projects like this are going to come forward, that we find a way to work together to do these kinds of projects. Looking forward to the clutter being cleaned up and finished. But I think between the sidewalks on Main Street and the signage and wayfinding program, this town has a whole new look.

2:04:14 And I think it's remarkable, and I'm very proud to live here. I was proud before, but I'm a little bit prouder now. But thank you for all your hard work to you and the team, whoever made this thing happen. Thank you. Thank you. And on that, I've been hearing so many raves about it, but I did hear that the font was too small, but then I realized when I drove around that the smaller font is for pedestrian traffic.

2:04:37 Maybe that's just something that I know I'm going to tell people in the future. Well, that's not meant for if you're driving. Because people are like, I'm going to get in a wreck trying to read that font. They shouldn't be driving on the sidewalks. Yeah, they shouldn't. Feet first. Evening, Council. Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation. A few updates. Benefit of the community and Council. With the change in weather.

2:05:05 We are looking forward to ice making, looking at potentially Thursday, Friday evening. It's a three-night process, so we want to try and get the ice down before the next snowfall is maybe forecast for Tuesday. So we've got a little kind of three- or four-day window in there, but remember, whatever snow falls on the rink now, we actually have to remove before we start making ice. So we've got a few things to work out. We can't turn the chiller on, otherwise the ice, anyway. It's kind of a...

2:05:33 Weird process. Winter Street Animation. So we're planning to install our 27 snowflakes beginning around the 24th through the 26th. So that's next week. So that's good. And they're likely doing that at night, which makes sense. So when they install them, they know they're working and everything. And it's not to kind of interrupt any day-to-day activities around town. So there'll be traffic controls in the evening.

2:05:58 And that is, we talked about before, we've got 10 three-foot snowflakes and then we've got 17 five-foot snowflakes in the Old Mammoth Road and Main Street. So look for those. Just a quick programming update, gymnastics. We kicked off that program. It's been on hiatus for several years. So we've got a great instructor. So Kinsey's...

2:06:18 Looking after that program maybe Tuesday, Thursday. That's great. The first six-week session's already sold out, sold out in the first week, so that's great. So we'll have those additionally scheduled in the winter and then spring. Shady Rest is Golf Park. You know, we completed that project. We're still waiting on some signage to do, T signs and the info sign. We're trying to get those back here for kind of a ribbon cutting on December 4th, if we can make that. We'll see how we do.

2:06:42 Weather permitting, so fingers crossed, or not fingers crossed, if there's too much snow on the ground, obviously we won't worry about throwing a few discs around, but we'll look out for that, keep you updated. Commission again meets on December 3rd, we'll give them an update on our deferred maintenance program for the last year, additional money through council, which is great, and we'll also provide them with an update on our 2020 programming menu, which is full already, which is great.

2:07:09 And then, Commissioner, prepared and ready for your giant workshop on December 4th. Any questions? Thank you. Sounds great. Great. Appreciate it. Any other reports? Moving on to the consent agenda. We have approved the minutes of special meeting of November 6th, approved the minutes of the regular meeting of November 6th, approved extension of waste collection franchise agreement, and accept payment approval reports 2016-2017.

2:07:45 Does anyone want to pull anything from consent? Could I hear a motion? I'll make a motion that we approve the consent agenda. Second. I have a motion and two seconds. Any further deliberation? Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Consent passes.

2:08:12 Next, we have a public hearing, consideration of an ordinance adopting and amending the 2019 California Building Standards Code, including specific amendments to the Municipal Code, Chapter 15.24, Design Requirements. We are open. Tom, I will turn this over to you. Thank you. Well, good evening, Town Council. Tom Perry, Building Official, Town of Mammoth Lakes.

2:08:56 I'm here in front of you tonight to discuss a number of proposed amendments to our local code specific to Chapter 15, Buildings and Construction. Before we get into it here, I just wanted to make note of a few things. Back on the 6th of this month, we introduced the ordinance and set the public hearing. It's kind of a two-part deal. So tonight is that public hearing. Also, usually at this time when we're adopting new codes, which is one item we'll be discussing tonight,

2:09:24 We're usually the ones who are ratifying the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District's local code. However, we won't be doing that this evening because their local code is not quite ready for ratification just yet. So I anticipate getting a coming back in front of you either next month or the month after that with their ordinance to ratify. And if at any point in time you have any questions, just feel free to jump on in at any point. Quite all right.

2:09:54 So we have basically four main topics to discuss tonight with you. First topic is lofts, mezzanines, as they're called in the code. Our design criteria is topic number two, with primary focus on snow loads, but also includes seismic wind and frost.

2:10:13 Third topic is the adoption of the 2019 California Building Codes. And then the fourth topic here are going to be a series of miscellaneous edits and clarifications to our local code that just really are more so kind of a housekeeping clarifications to existing code sections we have in Chapter 15. So I'll start with lofts because that seems to be the most complicated topic of the four, so I'll just kind of jump into it. Just to get the...

2:10:41 Town Council up to speed with a little background with these lofts. As you probably know, we have hundreds and hundreds of condos in town. And when we're talking about lofts, we're primarily talking about lofts that are in condo units. They really don't occur a whole lot in single-family dwellings. These are really mainly lofts that we have in condo units. And so we have close to 900 condo units, I'm told, from a few different credible sources. How many of those units have lofts?

2:11:09 Not quite sure, but I think at least a couple hundred of them do. So we have a lot of lofts out there here in town. A lot of these condos and condo units with lofts were built in the 1970s. They go back all the way to 1964. The first condo complex was Nordica. And we have condos that were built all the way up until the 2000s. But the majority of them, it seems like, were built in the 70s. And as it turned out, a lot of the issues that we have with lofts are from that era, from the 1970s era.

2:11:37 Many condo units have lofts due to the nature of their use in limited building areas, so going back in time all the way to now, we've always had limited area with regard to where to, you know, how much we could build out, height limitations, so it was always an issue of trying to utilize every square foot possible in buildings to get people for overnight use on their ski trips when they came up from Southern California or wherever. Having worked for the county for close to eight years, I can safely say that there's very little regulation for buildings back.

2:12:05 Then back in the 70s, especially condo buildings here in Mammoth were no exception. So it seemed like there's very little oversight with regard to building inspection and plan review back then. And then the situation was even compounded or made worse with a number or a lot of unpermitted remodels that we had in these condo units over the decades. So that's some background on these lofts, kind of expounding a little bit more on the background.

2:12:32 Some of the loft safety issues have been present for years, and we, we being the town and also the fire department, have known of these safety issues for a long time, but really didn't address them unless there was a building permit associated with proposed alterations or whatever. Other than that, we usually left them alone because they were privately used, they were privately rented. We really weren't involved a whole lot with these things unless there was a permit. But the quality of life ordinance that

2:12:58 Just came to be not that long ago. Really changed this quite a bit where now we were formally issuing business tax certificates to allow people to reside overnight in these condos with these lofts. The primary hazard with these lofts, just so the council knows, is that associated with overnight use. And if there were a fire in a building, it would be people trying to escape or get out of the loft or the unit in the middle of the night when there's a fire. So that's the specific hazard we're kind of talking about with these lofts.

2:13:27 There's also a big concern from the public with how the town would or would not or how heavily they would be regulated. And there's a real economic concern there that was well voiced early on. And so we'll talk about that in a little bit more detail. So some of the safety issues we have with these lofts, I thought I'd just show you a few slides of a few.

2:13:52 Different lofts that have some of the most common safety issues that we find out there with these ones. This particular one you're seeing right here, it has more of a ladder configuration, more so than a set of stairs that serve as the means of egress from this loft. Even with the building codes in effect at the time of original construction, it was never legal to have a ladder, if you will. It had to be a set of stairs. So as you can tell, this is more of a ladder.

2:14:18 Lacks the handrails and guardrails that were even required back in the day with the code in effect at the time. And then the area of the loft is too small. Going back to the early 70s, a minimum of 70 square feet was prescribed for your minimum floor area for habitable areas and bedrooms. And this one is significantly less than that. The next slide here shows a bedroom that's accessed through a loft. We have a lot of these where you have a loft and there's a bedroom that, you know,

2:14:47 You access through a loft. And a real key feature here that's kind of at the center of this whole thing is that as I researched these issues, it became pretty evident to me that there's a big difference between an open loft, you know, that's open to the room below, and an enclosed bedroom. Because with an open loft, you can detect hazards, or the occupant can detect hazards a lot easier by way of sight, smell, and sound than if they were in an enclosed bedroom.

2:15:12 Smell the smoke. If there's a fire, they could hear commotion. They could see things much more easy than if they were in a kind of an enclosed bedroom like what you're seeing here. So this is a bedroom that has basically no escape rescue opening, meaning it's a window or an opening like that where if the occupant can't egress out through their regular set of stairs and egress system, if it's engulfed in flame, their last ditch effort to get out of that loft is through an escape rescue opening. That's what it's called.

2:15:40 So this particular bedroom that you're looking at doesn't have that, and we have a lot of these here in town. The other issue that you're seeing here in this one slide is that the head clearance is inadequate. Going back decades, there's always been a minimum head clearance. It's usually been an average of seven feet when you have a sloping ceiling like this. We have a lot of sloping ceiling conditions in these lofts because they're usually at the top level of the building.

2:16:09 Third one here is probably even worse than the one we just saw, potentially. The head clearance is even less. This is actually a loft that's accessed through another loft, if you can believe it, and we see a number of those. Back to this concept of them trying to utilize every square foot in a building to have people sleep. So this one, the head clearance is so low that the owner's elected to put carpet on the bottom side, it's the roof beam, so when you hit your head, it just doesn't hurt as bad when you do.

2:16:36 It's only a matter of time until you do, but it just doesn't hurt as bad when you have carpet on the bottom side of your roof beams. And so we've seen a number of these, actually. Also in here, too, you can't really see it very well. You can't see it at all, actually, in this slide, but it's going to be another ladder configuration that gives access to this loft here. So it's definitely very non-compliant. I had a question. I saw in the paperwork that there was something called a FURD.

2:17:02 Ceiling, F-U-R-R-E-D, what is that? A furred ceiling typically is a ceiling that has kind of a, it's a drop ceiling. So let's go back to this. So you see in this slide here, you have rough rafters, okay? These are, what is this? So a furred ceiling is like a, it's like a drop ceiling where someone would actually frame in a ceiling below these rafters here to affect like a flat ceiling.

2:17:30 So a furred ceiling is kind of like, if someone were to construct, if you look right here, see if this thing works, I wonder if it doesn't work as well as I had hoped it would, but basically, if you were to build like a two by four ceiling under those rafters, that would be a furred ceiling. Oh, okay. That would be a furred ceiling. Okay, thanks. Okay. So we have both safety concerns that...

2:17:57 We just went over that were well documented. We know they're out there. But also there's a lot of economic concerns as well that were voiced from the public. Economic concerns included a loss of revenue and a detrimental effect on local real estate values if transient rentals were heavily restricted. The thought was, and this is expressed to me by the Lodging Association, also the Board of Realtors, is that if there's somebody who wants to buy a second home, they're likely going to want to put that on the transient rental market.

2:18:26 And if they can't rent the whole unit out and realize full revenue, then they might buy a unit somewhere else like Truckee or Tahoe or wherever. So that was a real economic concern from the public if that were to occur. And that was made very well known to me in no unclear terms when we met in the May of 2016 when I first hired. We had a room full of people here, standing room only, and they were pretty concerned about it. So it was a big deal. It became very evident it was a big deal.

2:18:54 So in order to try to come up with a solution that would work for everybody to balance the safety and the economic concerns, it became pretty evident to me that large-scale public outreach was probably the way to go to kind of vet this with all the stakeholders that we had in the community to come up with a solution that would work for everybody or would accomplish that. So with the public outreach, I initially met with the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District to get a full understanding of what all the safety issues were.

2:19:23 And to get up to speed with what all the conditions were to get us to lead to the present situation. After I met with them, it became evident to me that it's probably a good idea that I form a task force of locals in the community in order to better vet this topic. And so we had a task force of seven people.

2:19:43 Five of which were from the public sector representing the real estate, lodging, design, construction, and private home inspecting industries, as well as somebody from the fire protection district and somebody from the planning commission. And so when I came up with kind of a rough idea of what I wanted or what I had in mind for a possible solution or kind of a fix for this, whatever you want to call it,

2:20:05 We met extensively. We had a very long meeting with this task force, and we talked about a lot of stuff, and a lot of their ideas and concerns were eventually weaved into what we have now for the draft ordinance that you have in front of you. But in addition to that, we also met with the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association, the Board of Realtors, the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association.

2:20:27 And also the Mammoth Lakes Board of Appeals and Advisory Committee to get their take on what they thought would be an acceptable solution to address both safety concerns and the economic concerns that were out there. So a proposed solution, what does it look like? Well...

2:20:45 We had to have some kind of quantifiable standards. We're all in agreement that there had to be some kind of quantifiable standards out there to kind of gauge or determine if a loft is safe or compliant or not in its as-built, unaltered state. You'd basically walk into a condo, you'd look at a loft, and the question would be, is this compliant? Is this safe? Can we use it as is now? Is it safe? And so in order to kind of come up with some of that criteria,

2:21:10 I basically went back all the way to the 1964 Uniform Building Code, and I have several versions of the Uniform Building Code that go back from 1964 to present time, and I basically picked and pulled all the code sections out of those various Uniform Building Codes that we could apply to the safety features that we have out there or the issues that we have out there as it relates to stairs and floor areas and ceiling heights and emergency egress.

2:21:39 Basically, that's kind of what you see in front of you. So all the red text there for the proposed code are those kind of code sections that go back in the last 50 or so years. A few key features of the solution, though, that I wanted to point out was that, as we talked about, as I mentioned, there's a big difference between an open loft and an enclosed bedroom. So one...

2:22:03 Another feature that we have in a proposed solution is that if you have a certain amount of openness in a loft to the room in which it's located, you don't need an escape rescue window, given the occupant's ability to detect hazards more readily than in a closed bedroom. And so we put our heads together, we determined that if a loft is at least 50% or more open to the room below, you don't need an escape rescue window, which actually helps a lot of lofts because a lot of these lofts didn't have them, just like we saw with a few ones before.

2:22:32 Another key feature that I added was also a flowchart that's included in your agenda packet. And so for me to get my mind around this whole loft issue, I really had to have kind of a visual depiction of all the moving parts and pieces, there's quite a few of them, to pull it all together to kind of craft the language that you see in front of you in your packet.

2:22:52 So that will be basically not part of the ordinance, but it'll be an informative supplement that the public can use to better understand this. And if approved by the council, that would be a handout we'd have at our front counter with our other handouts. But it really helps explain it and pull it together in case there's confusion with regard to the code language. The code language is pretty mundane. It reads like a code book.

2:23:15 Some people have, you know, struggled with that, but the flowchart's a very key feature to help people understand this. Another solution that we have weaved in there that has been widely accepted or liked by a lot of folks is called the net neutral revenue solution, where if you have a loft where remodeling or alteration is impractical, or if you have a situation where you have too low of a...

2:23:40 Head clearance, knowing that it's impossible to fix that, people aren't going to rip their roof off to get another three feet for head clearance. The net neutral revenue solution will allow the same amount of occupants that would normally be allowed to be in that unit, but the occupants in the loft would be redistributed to other habitable areas of the unit to sleep. So instead of allowing them to sleep overnight in the loft, they could sleep in another bedroom or a living room or something like that. So you still have the net same

2:24:08 Renters and hopefully the same revenue as you would. The only difference is you just can't have them sleep in the loft. We've actually used this solution a few times. There's been a few different condos that have been escrow or people wanted to buy. They wanted to put on the transit rental market and get a BTC for the unit. But they had really low head clearance. So we were able to affect this as kind of a last-ditch solution to help folks.

2:24:33 Be able to rent these units out and hopefully not lose revenue and headcount on the transient rentals. So that's my spiel on lofts. I'd like to pivot now to the next topic, which are going to be our design criteria with kind of emphasis on snow loads. I have a few pictures here that, it's not local, I just, those are on Google, but they represent Mammoth. That's kind of what we looked like, you know, this last season. But our local, our design criteria, basically,

2:25:04 Snow design criteria is the weight of snow on a roof that exerts force on a structure, and it can be quite extreme. Our snow load criteria that we have now was actually developed by a local engineer back in the early 80s and then put into our local code back in about the 85, 86, and it still is in our local code now and being utilized now. Ironically, there was an engineer that worked for that engineer. It was Bill Jenkins, by the way, that did this research years ago.

2:25:31 And then another local engineer, Kathy Cage, about three years ago at a meeting here at the Town Council when I was adopting the 2016 codes, somehow the topic came up and she suggested the council at the time that, hey, we should reevaluate our snow loads because they've been in our code for 30 plus years or so, whatever. And so the council thought it was a good idea and authorized me to engage a consultant to look at not only the snow load criteria, but also our other design criteria, which includes seismic, wind, and frost.

2:26:01 Keep in mind, this is before the big winter of 2016-2017. Just kind of keep that in mind because that's kind of a relevant point that I'll kind of address here in just a little bit. So snow load research and findings. The consultant used his in-house staff to do the research, but he also engaged a separate hydrologist and a structural engineer to conduct the analysis. So he had a really good team to kind of dive into this thing and really analyze it. Basically,

2:26:32 Town of Mammoth Lakes, we're in what's known as a case study area for snow loading because the international code will prescribe snow loads for a majority of the country, but areas that get a lot of snow like us are what's known as case study. So we're on our own to figure out our snow loads for our area. When you do that, you have to consider or analyze a minimum of 50 years of data that's codified in a state standard.

2:26:58 So the consultant used a total of 11 measuring stations to measure historical snowfall. The criteria for those stations were a sufficient period of record to provide a reasonable estimate for the 50-year snow water equivalent. They had to be reasonably proximate or close to the town of Mammoth Lakes and also provide a range of elevations that were similar to the town. So back to the winter of 2016-2017,

2:27:24 Did it have an impact on the consultant's findings? The short answer is no. Remember, we have 50 years of data, and that's a lot of data, and we had a lot of drought years weaved into those 50 years, so when you spread all that data out over 50 years, that one season as big as it was actually really didn't move the needle one way or another really with regard to the final conclusions of the consultant. The snow load research and findings, the consultant, after he did his work, recommended

2:27:54 That we do raise our snow loads. And his recommendations were raising them to 280 pounds a square foot at elevations of 8,300 feet or less. Now they're currently, it's 230 pounds a square foot at elevations of 8,500 feet or less. And he also recommended 470 pounds a square foot at elevations of 9,400 feet and above. Right now it's 300 at elevations above 8,500 feet. So fairly, fairly noticeable.

2:28:23 Or a significant increase in snow load was recommended by the consultant. As crazy as the winter of 2016-2017 was, it actually provided a real-world application of heavy snow loads. We got to see how buildings behaved and how they performed or didn't perform when we had extreme snow, and that was a very big, wet winter, if you recollect. It was only a couple years ago.

2:28:46 From that winter, we issued about 100 repair permits, give or take. Those are the ones we at least know of. And when we went through this, it became pretty evident to us that the vast majority of failures that occurred in these buildings were your 1970s-era buildings that had a lesser snow criteria than we have now. It was substantially less than the snow loads that we came up with in the 80s that we have in our code right now. So that was very, very evident to us as we went through that.

2:29:16 So, once again, public outreach seemed to be a good way to go to see if we're going to, what we're going to do, if anything, with the recommendations from the consultant. I met with the Bammoth Lakes Contractors Association, as we often meet. I also met with the building advisory group. And we basically, you know, talked it through. And they basically...

2:29:38 We're in favor of not increasing the snow loads, and it was really based on kind of the reason I mentioned before that the vast majority of these failures were from 1970 era buildings. Buildings that were constructed to our current snow load actually fared very, very well, surprisingly, as compared to those older buildings with a lesser snow load criteria. So the town, along with the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association and the Building Advisory Group, recommends not increasing the current snow load criteria.

2:30:08 For that reason, given that the vast majority of failures did occur with the lesser snow load criteria than what we have now. Moving on to seismic design, seismic basically, a little broad stroke, it's basically the lateral forces exerted on a structure during earthquakes, so that's a big deal, especially when you have snow on a roof, so it's required by code, you have seismic design in the structural design of buildings.

2:30:33 For the longest time, for many years, we had assigned a fixed variables for seismic calculations, which is unusual. Most jurisdictions don't do that, but for whatever reason or reasons, we did. Along with that, we also were recommending using a third of the ground snow load and seismic calculations. The current state code is actually only 20%, so both of those things are really, really conservative, very conservative, and we could never really find any basis as to

2:31:03 Why or how those found their way into our code, but they've just been there for a long time. So that was analyzed too by the consultant. The consultant basically recommended discontinuing the practice of specifying the minimum design values of these variables for seismic and also recommended discontinuing using the one-third snow load in the seismic design and go back to the code minimum of 20%.

2:31:25 That really affords the design professional a lot more flexibility to come up with a better design for seismic relative to the specific site because we could have different characteristics within our town. They could get this information from the USGS portal and that's really how it's done with most design professionals out there. It was kind of unusual that we did that here in town. So the town staff along with the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association and the Building Advisory Group agreed to discontinue using this fixed variable.

2:31:53 Fixed variables and go with 20% versus 33% for seismic design. Wind design basically is the force exerted on a building from excessive wind forces. Not quite as maybe critical as snow and seismic, but still important and still needs to be analyzed with the structural design of a building. We had had criteria that had been in our code that was really outdated. It was a lesser standard from a...

2:32:20 California Building Code criteria from way back when, don't know exactly when. So that presented a problem right there because we were already prescribing a standard that was less than a state standard, which is an issue. We really can't do that. The consultant analyzed 34 years of historical data from the Mammoth Yosemite Airport, and this data did not support an increase to state minimum wind speed. So the consultant recommended it's pretty easy. He just said, use the state minimums that we already have.

2:32:48 In the California building and residential codes, which we have to enforce, those are the minimum standards at the state level. And so the recommendation was to just have that in our code and nothing above that. So those are, the wind speeds there are for the two family dwellings and the different risk category buildings that we have out there with the associated wind speeds. Town staff, along with the MLCA, the Contractors Association, and also the Building Advisory Group agreed with the consultant's recommendation.

2:33:18 Frost line, last design criteria. If you don't have a certain depth on a concrete footing, you can get a phenomenon known as frost heave, and that's where frost can freeze and expand and cause uplift. And you can see the pictures on the right where you have foundational elements being heaved upward, and it could cause cracking and buckling of structural members. It doesn't happen all the time, but it's been known to happen from time to time. So there has to be a minimum frost depth in order to prevent this from happening.

2:33:48 Our code for a long time is prescribed 24 inches minimum depth for frost. The consultant evaluated our local design criteria. He used a lot of data from the Huntington Lake site. The other sites really didn't have enough data to do the analysis, but he used the Huntington Lake site. And the consultant recommendation basically was not to change the frost depth based on their analysis. And so, once again, we did agree with the consultant.

2:34:15 Along with the town staff and the contractors association and the building advisory group agreed with a consultant on this. Then the last series of proposed changes to our local code would be the miscellaneous changes I alluded to earlier. They're basically changes of an informative nature and provide clarifications to existing code sections.

2:34:37 Those would include explanation of risk category structures, clarification on minimum heights for vent terminals above the snow wasn't clearly identified, when you do have to hardwire smoke or LPG detectors, and also criteria for underfloor insulation for protection of underfloor plumbing. So those are the proposed changes that we are moving forward in front of you for our design criteria and our local code.

2:35:03 The other thing here, I just don't have a slide on it, but I'll just talk about it briefly, is the adoption of the 2019 building codes. Every three years, the state comes up with state building codes. I wish it was more like five or seven years, but it's every three years. So we have to go through this maneuver every three years to just update our local code to make it current with state standards. So it's just tonight will be the formal adoption of the 2019 building codes.

2:35:30 I would note that there are two appendices that I'm proposing to adopt as part of the 2019 California Residential Code, one of which is Appendix J, which is existing buildings and structures, which prescribes alternative standards for existing buildings, and the point of that appendix is to continue the use and reuse of existing buildings, and I thought that relevant to our town. Also, Appendix Q, tiny houses. We have a big housing thing kind of going on here in town and also in the state.

2:35:59 And the direction of the code definitely is going toward tiny houses and utilization of tiny houses and efficiency dwelling units and that kind of thing. So I have that also included as a recommended adoption for an appendix in the residential code. I'd like to turn it over now to the town council for any questions and comments that you may have. Is the appendix in our packet? It's going to be in the ordinance in Exhibit A, but not the full print, not the full text of it. Oh.

2:36:31 Okay. Any questions? I could provide, if you'd like to see that, I could provide that separately. I could certainly do that. But it was not included in your agenda packet. Full text of that appendix. Do we have any questions or comments from the floor? Seeing none, thank you, Tom. I will close the public hearing and bring it back to the council for deliberation and motion. No discussion. I'll make a motion if everybody's ready.

2:37:20 I recommend, I make a motion that the, we waive the full reading and introduce by title only the ordinance amending municipal code chapter 15.24 to include revised language in section 15.24.100 loft requirements update the wind and seismic criteria in sections 15.24.010 and 15.24.

2:37:47 Point zero to zero and correct minor errors. Do I need to keep reading or can I stop it there? I think you've got it, but I think the word introduced may be a holdover from the staff report from last time. It's actually adoption. You're leaving the full reading and adopting an ordinance. Adopt by title everything I said previously, ending with certain local amendments, additions, and deletions. Second the motion. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberations?

2:38:18 Jamie. Yes. Yes. Thanks for all your work. Yes. Thank you. Yes. Yes. Passes 5-0. Thank you, Tom. Thank you very much. Thank you for that flow chart. I love that. Yeah, it helps. Yeah, a lot. I needed it. I needed it. As bad as anyone else. So, yeah, it works pretty well. So, thanks. Okay, moving on to analysis of future options for town administrative offices.

2:38:52 Pam, you're starting us off on this one? Yep. Good evening, Councilmembers. Mayor Sauser, I'm Pam Kobylarz, Assistant to the Town Manager. This report is regarding an analysis for future options for town administrative offices. The town has been leasing its current office space since 1985, and our lease is set to expire on September 30, 2021.

2:39:16 In addition to that, in 2007, the town purchased property, which we call the McFlex parcel for the purpose of constructing future town facilities, including town offices and also along with Mono County and the hospital with the vision of a future civic center on that site. Several times previously, but most recently on January 16th of this year, the council has given staff direction to provide analysis of

2:39:45 Several options regarding future possibilities for town office facilities. Those two options primarily at this time will be continuing to lease office space or moving forward with construction of a new office building at the McFlex parcel.

2:40:04 At that January meeting where council provided direction, they did request that staff conduct a streamlined analysis and not spend too much time going into in-depth research or details on such an analysis. So with that in mind, our staff team of myself, Rob Patterson, the finance director, and Haislip Hayes and Sierra Schultz from the engineering department have spent a little time putting together an analysis of these two options for you.

2:40:31 We met with a representative from the USDA. They have a community facilities program that's both a grant and a loan program that helps to fund public facilities such as offices like this. A new office building would be eligible for this program. The funding is dependent upon the specifics of the project and the funds available at the time that you submit an application.

2:41:01 An interest rate that does change over time, but it doesn't change a lot over time, the interest rate that they told us they are working with at this point in time, I believe was 3.5%, and that's the number that we've used for this analysis. Rob will talk a little bit more about how the analysis was done, but just to give you a brief background of how we kind of came up with our assumptions that we used for this report, I wanted to give you that information.

2:41:25 And then regarding a lease, we just kind of used our current lease as a baseline for that. We assumed that the current rate per square feet would be comparable in a future lease. Obviously that goes up by CPI every year, so we assumed a comparable CPI to what our current lease is, and we estimated our future square footage needs.

2:41:50 Also, the common area fees that we currently pay, and then we extrapolated that out over a period of 30 years to come up with this basic analysis. I wanted to just briefly provide a little bit of background information about some of the planning work that the town has done over the last 10 or more years regarding the McFlex parcel and its vision of a civic center in town. So as I mentioned, the town did purchase the McFlex parcel in 2007.

2:42:19 The purchase documents for that property actually specifically refer to town offices as one of the envisioned uses for that site. Additionally, the 2007 general plan, 2008 master facilities plan, and numerous other planning documents that the town has put together over the past 10 or more years all refer to that property as the location for a future civic center.

2:42:46 And since that time that the property was purchased, the town, Mono County, and the Administrative Office of Courts have all helped to move forward that vision of a civic center by constructing new facilities on that site, which would be the police station, the courthouse that's currently there, and then Mono County is in the process of building their new offices right now.

2:43:10 There are no planning documents that I'm aware of that the town has that have a long-term community vision showing this location of town as a future town or other governmental office.

2:43:26 Furthermore, the town has made quite a significant financial investment into the McFlex parcel over a period of time. I have a chart in your staff report on page four that kind of outlines the various investments, but those total over $6.8 million towards furthering that vision of a civic center. One other step the town and Mono County have taken was that in April of 2007,

2:43:53 The two agencies worked together with HMC architects to conduct a design charrette for future office facilities at that site. The purpose of that process was to understand how uses could be shared between the two agencies, what the spatial needs were, infrastructure needs, and things like that. That information was used as a baseline for the assumptions of what...

2:44:19 The square footage needs would be in a future building that we used in our calculations for this report. So now I'm going to hand it over to Rob. He can kind of walk through the financial analysis that he conducted, and then I will go over the options and recommendations that are in your report. Thank you. As Pam talked on earlier, you know, the lease options that we're assuming will have similar experience to what we've had in the last agreement or the extensions.

2:44:48 And that calls for a minimum of a 3% or a CPI calculation not to exceed 7% on an annual basis for our rent costs. So we use that 3% to be a conservative number. We have, in my time here at the town, seen numbers higher than 3%, so they're not uncommon, especially in stronger times. So that was kind of a baseline that we used to carry that forward.

2:45:16 Some square footage that the town is currently, we're going to have to pick up a little bit of square footage associated with the county moving out. We're going to pick up some of that. Not a ton of it, but essentially a little bit to provide for some expansion that we need. So that's sort of the lease side of it. And you guys have the chart in the book there. We'll talk a little bit more about that.

2:45:42 Purchase and the build side, we used for an estimate on the cost of the building is $14.5 million. That's based on a square footage of 20,399 square feet. And the county's current building cost, which is $575 a square foot. But since we wouldn't begin the construction for another three years, that delay we're giving another 5% cost escalation per year.

2:46:10 So there's a 15% cost escalation on that cost per square foot. And then we have a million dollars added for site work and additional contingency. So that brings the building cost to $14.5 million. And the engineering team is confident that those numbers are accurate. So as Pam talked about earlier, the contents of the USDA loan, 40 years and 3.5% interest rate.

2:46:38 The one thing, and I'm not sure if you touched on that, was the potential for a 15%, up to a 15% grant match on a project of this type. We didn't use full 15% in the analysis. We backed that off to 10%, just thinking that we wanted to be a little bit conservative again in that approach. The other element that I have included in the numbers is common area maintenance cost. That's where I think the...

2:47:06 A significant benefit can be achieved from owning the building versus what we have here within this structure of this mall site, if you will. There are a number of different cost elements that are included in our CAM costs, like property taxes, management of the services, on-site management, as well as even administrative overcharges for

2:47:31 Bill processing and all those types of things. So there's a significant amount of cost in there. There's also the snow removal element. We're expecting some savings with the way the town plans to or could potentially do snow removal on the new site versus what we can do within a contracted basis here at our building. So I did significantly reduce the cost of snow removal, which is by far the biggest charge on a strong snow year, if you will.

2:48:01 And the way CAM works is they give us an estimate. We pay that estimate on a monthly basis, and then they give a reconciliation at the end of the year that says here's all the costs that we actually incurred, and then here's your portion of that. So we do have some lump sum payments that we make throughout the year. So it's not an insignificant dollar amount by any means. There's a couple of things that are specifically left out of the analysis. Certainly trying to...

2:48:29 I wanted to keep it as a straight comparison of here's what we would be paying on a rent basis and here's what we would be paying on a purchase basis.

2:48:56 The chart, as you see on your staff report, page 179, gives you 41 years of payments. So obviously one more year than the term of the loan. And the idea behind that was to sort of illustrate the point that across time, there is a point in time when the cost of the rent payments are going to exceed the cost of a facility.

2:49:23 Payment and CAM. That occurs around year 19 to 20, somewhere in that time frame, at which point we would start to pay more for rent than we would for a purchase of the building and the payoff of the loan and the debt. So that's a point of significance to reference. So from that point forward, rent does exceed

2:49:48 The increases that I'm carrying for cams and the increases that you'll see in the purchase and cam side is a 2% increase in annual cam costs because we do expect there's going to be some inflationary elements of some of the cam costs that we have in there, maintenance and other things. So as you go through that, looking at the total bottom line numbers, it is significant. There's about a $3 million savings in that over that.

2:50:15 41-year period. In that 41st year, I show that our drop down on the bottom is $113,000 from the purchase option. That's just covering the common area maintenance charges versus a lease payment, a rent payment of $1.210 million. So it's just, it's amazing how much of a change it happens. I mean, you guys know cost of, I mean, ownership versus renting, if you can do it, is a better function.

2:50:42 I wanted to kind of illustrate that in the process here. So available for any questions. I think the chart kind of speaks for itself. And if there's any questions about the analysis or any further analysis that we could do, I'd be happy to answer that. Questions for Kirk? Rob, I think he did an excellent job. I think, you know, for me, I have a very comfortable feeling where the council should go.

2:51:15 Here. I'd like to hear everybody else. Okay. John? I don't have any questions. I appreciate staff coming back with this analysis. It has the information that I need. Thank you. Linda? I have no questions at this time. Rob, maybe you said it in the purchase and cams, which is the maintenance on the building as well. In that figure, does that show the...

2:51:41 Every 20 years or so, the fact that we're going to have to replace roof and siding and those rebuild costs. No, I didn't. So we're trying to draw out differences are things that would be different between the two facilities versus an ownership versus a rent, if you will. So in the CAMS, I focused on the things that were clearly going to be different.

2:52:10 I think, so for example, if we had to replace the roof on our building here, even if the landlord had to replace the roof on it, that becomes a charge to us through the CAM process. In fact, we had that just recently, as it would be for our own building if we did our own. So those being comparable, I did not include them. But, and I also didn't include a factor for the newer building requiring less maintenance and perhaps

2:52:37 Even more extensive remodeling that would be necessary on our existing site to accomplish what we need to do with the town's offices. I think over time, as the town government will probably grow slightly, that we would probably need to do some significant remodels, which would have a significant cost associated with that. So not trying to stack the deck in any one side. I'm trying to give you guys really more flat plain to look at, and that was the approach.

2:53:04 One other thing that was not included in this analysis was the cost for utilities, and the assumption would be that a new building would be much more energy efficient than our current location, and there would likely be savings there as well. I do have some questions. Right now with the, because, you know, I do realize we're looking 40 years in the future. I, at this moment, as much as I would love to just go whole hog and start really

2:53:34 Pushing for a civic center for the town. I do have some reservations. And while I support beginning the lease negotiations for this property for another three years, our current lease, how are we set up as far as staff with everything else that we're going to be diving into that's like the meat of the meeting later on tonight?

2:54:03 What are we going to be looking at from staff time, energy, focus, purpose, going towards the formal pre-application to the USDA? What does that entail? I think that there would definitely be some staff time commitment probably for several months towards that. It's quite a lengthy application that they do require.

2:54:29 I think Pam nailed it. It is a lengthy process, but I think the staff time that's necessary will be

2:55:05 Kind of here and there, as we have to answer specific questions, we may have to do a quick analysis to give an appropriate response to the grant application. But in the grand scheme of the overall work program for the year, I think it's really not a heavy lift to get the application done.

2:55:21 I think also in terms of timing, if the council was to request that staff move forward with that pre-application process, it's a good time of year for the engineering team in terms of their capital project schedule because winter is not as busy for that as summer is for them. Is that fair? Fair enough. And so I'll...

2:55:43 Tonight, we're not saying, oh, we're going to get behind this. We're just looking to renew the lease or the options for the lease as well as start the very preliminary looking into getting that USDA grant, correct? Sure. If you want, I could just briefly walk through the options and kind of clarify what you have on the table before you to choose from, if that would be helpful. Is it anything different than what's in the package? No, it's not. I could just go into a bit more detail, though.

2:56:09 Which might help to answer your question. So the recommended option would be exactly what you were just talking about, both submitting a formal pre-application to the USDA and beginning lease negotiations for a minimum of a short-term lease with the options to extend that. The reason behind that being that even if we were to get...

2:56:31 Full support from you tonight that you want to move forward with a new building, that's not going to be ready before our lease expires in this space. So we're going to have to extend that for some period of time. What both of those things also allow us to do is to get more specific and detailed information.

2:56:50 That would inform a future decision for you whether you wanted to move forward with either of the options. As I said, we made some very what we felt were reasonable assumptions in this report tonight, but that's all they were was assumptions. And until we submit something to USDA and actually know what type of funding, what type of grant funding versus loans might be available to us, we are just speculating about that.

2:57:15 And we're also just speculating about the terms of a future lease. A landlord might want a higher than 3% CPI per year escalation. They might be charging more per square foot than we're currently paying. We don't know any of those things at this point in time until those discussions are had. This will give us time to buy a crystal ball. Right. Something like that. I have one question. Pam, if we were to do this pre-application, make the application, be notified that we had been awarded it,

2:57:43 How binding is that to move forward? And if we say, you know what, we've actually, we're going to wait three or four more years, would you then have to reapply? What's the length of time you can kind of keep that grant holding? It seems like the requirements for that are a little bit fuzzy. First of all, submitting a formal pre-application doesn't obligate the town to move forward any project in the future. In answer to your second question about timing,

2:58:12 Okay, thanks. Any other questions? Anyone from the...

2:58:44 Audience. I do want to make one comment. The camp is open-ended. I mean, if the roofs give, if the, you know, all the different problems, the electric, everything falls back on us. And so this is a, I don't know when this building would have been here a long time. And so if you want to give me the date and share it with the community. So I think this is the direction of a new facility.

2:59:14 That's more efficient and everything else as a responsible decision. Other comments? It's my problem getting my hands around it. I would love to have a new facility, of course. My problem with getting my hands around it is how much upside down we are for the first 15 years. And the obligations we currently have and the things that are on our plate later tonight could potentially, after I'm gone, eliminate the funding for this.

2:59:48 I certainly am not ready to make a decision if it isn't going to cost us too much in staff time or overburden them to do a pre-app just to find out how everybody's feeling. I have no problem with. But at this point then, if there are no other comments, I would entertain something from you all. So we're being asked to provide direct staff. Would you like a motion? Yeah, I was going to make a motion. There is a recommended motion. So then my motion would be that we...

3:00:16 Direct staff that we direct staff via option one to submit the formal pre-application and to simultaneously begin lease negotiations for a new lease in the current office space. Second that. Motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Go. Okay. The comment I have to make here is that I'm very conscious of what our current workspace is for staff.

3:00:44 And I believe it's really important that we provide the most comfortable, most easy to work in space possible. And if we go ahead and push this for three years, get a new lease, push for three years, then come back and then begin seriously planning to build based on kind of assessing what our workload is around housing and all the other projects that...

3:01:12 We make an effort and a commitment to making our current workspaces as pleasant as possible. So if we can do that simultaneously to doing the pre-application and the negotiations, I would like to kind of see that that would happen because I think people deserve and need a pleasant workspace. Thank you for that and I do address that in our next, my agenda item number nine. No further deliberation. Jamie, please. Yes.

3:01:46 Yes. No. Yes. Passes for one. Moving on to agenda item number eight. Consider approving the formation agreement for Eastern Sierra Council of Government Joint Powers Authority. Dan, are you going to... Yeah, I'll kick it off and then you have a... Jeff's here from the ESCOG as well as the representatives here in the council. The item before you is...

3:02:18 It's been, I think, over a year in the making, but it's the requests that are coming from the SCOG board who spent a lot of time putting together a potential joint powers agreement. I think Mono County took the lead in a lot of the legal drafting and then involved the attorneys from each of the potential member agencies. Andy was involved in that from our perspective to work through that. A draft agreement as approved by the SCOG board is attached for your consideration in that area.

3:02:49 The ESCOG board did unanimously recommend the approval of it with kind of a caveat there. They'd like you to vote it up or down because if it has to be amended by every agency, it kind of gets in this never-ending circle component on that to get there. The agreement limits the authority of the ESCOG in a couple different areas. There's some checks and balances. If you read through it, you'll see some of those areas there. I won't walk through a ton of those unless you have particular questions.

3:03:19 The duties and responsibilities are called out in the agreement, page 201 of the agenda packet, looks at those, looking at different areas, continuing to be a forum for discussion, it continues to look at different regional issues that the ESCOG could work to and be a part of that. I'm just going to get some highlights and I'll let the members speak to it in detail, but the financial considerations at this point,

3:03:45 There's a lot of discussion back and forth. There will be some additional work if it's approved to go forward. We're looking at a real rough estimated annual cost on a full-time basis. We've got a little over $100,000 a year. That would be allocated between the four members going forward on an annualized basis, just over $25,000. For this year, we would look at an agency cost of estimated $16,300, which is a partial year, so we would need to come back with a budget amendment if it's approved by the various agencies.

3:04:12 The other element to highlight in there, the clerical support, we currently provide that to the town, so that is a cost that is already being covered, if you will, so the net increase is a little less than the $16,000 through that process. It assumes only a part-time level of support going forward from an executive director level. Make some assumptions regarding, I think, Mono County continuing some of the legal services and potentially the fiscal analysis or fiscal duties with...

3:04:40 In your county, I believe, was the discussion and stuff of that nature, moving that out. We would continue to provide the clerking services, as I noted. So it's kind of gets spread out through that. There's a lot of other information in the JPA and the focus and those types of elements and the element for the SCOG. It would be a...

3:05:00 A significant shift in what the S-COG currently is is more of that information sharing component. This would shift it granting a certain level of additional authority and duties to the new JPA. It does not call it out as a formal council of governments as defined in the government code. So there is limited activity there and Andy could speak to that in detail in terms of some of the other things that formal COGs do in other areas and this would not.

3:05:28 Be placed in that same category as proposed here. So with that, I can address additional questions you may have in terms of the agreement before you, some of the other elements there. I will note the staff report was one that was kind of a common staff report that went to all four agencies or is in the process of going. Inyo County has taken action to approve the agreement. It will be going, I believe, to Bishop next, and I'm not sure.

3:05:56 Sure, the data goes to Mono County at this point for consideration. Better be moving through the four agencies. So we would not take any additional actions in the budget until after we've heard that all, assuming all four agencies approve it, it would come back at that point in time. But we'd want authorization accordingly, so that's not an issue at this point. With that, glad to answer any questions, or Andy can ask any of the legal questions in terms of the JPAs and what they do or don't do. Members here from...

3:06:23 Inyo County and Mono County can speak to it as well as our SCOG representatives. If the council pleases, I would like to hear from Mono County and Bishop Inyo County and our two representatives because that gives the rest of us some more open ideas on questions, if that's okay with the rest of you. Okay, but just to be clear,

3:06:53 Mono County has already voted on it. No. Okay, so Inyo County has voted on it, and SCOG has already voted on it. So we are going to be hearing from people who are supporters of this. Yes. Okay, so entities that have voted to implement this. No, Mono County has not voted. Well, Mono County hasn't. So you're going to be hearing from the SCOG representatives.

3:07:19 That's what you're going to hear from. Okay. So I guess then my next question would be, so everybody speaking is on ESCOG? Yes. And the ESCOG vote, was it unanimous or? Yes. Okay. I just want to clarify, I think that's a very important point for people to keep in mind. Yeah. This has already been, a group is coming forward saying, Right. We voted for this and now.

3:07:44 They want, and we've got two people who are also serving on that. But it gives us as a council a chance to ask the ESCOG representatives questions. Okay, very good. Gentlemen, well, you may want to, you both may want to come up to the podium so that questions can. Well, you said gentlemen, I can't. I got it, I got it. Good evening, Mr. Mayor. He's like the rest of us in the mountains, he wears flannel well. That's right.

3:08:18 Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of council. Thank you for the opportunity to talk to you, and it's lovely to see the snow up here and the rain and no power shutoffs in sight. So this is something that the ESCOG has been working on for several years at this point, and to sort of bring us up to speed.

3:08:40 We brought this to, this came before you earlier to conceptually give a heads up of yay or nay, continue working on this or not working on this. And we did the same thing with all of the different entities. And so we tweaked the agreement because there was some concern, I think sort of broadly through all of the different agencies that

3:09:02 That this organization not have any power that would supersede the power of the individual agencies. So we went back and we put some more work into it and put some safeguards onto it. So as far as the general programs that the ESCOG would take on, those would have to be approved unanimously by the boards of all four entities.

3:09:24 And then furthermore, any decision that's made in the implementation of those programs, any vote that would have to be taken in the ESCOG would have to have the affirmative vote of at least one member of all four entities in addition to a majority of the members of the ESCOG. So we tried to strike a balance between making sure that each entity basically has a veto over anything that ESCOG is doing while not...

3:09:52 Making it so onerous that nothing would ever get done. So I think we've discussed in the past what the benefits of working regionally on regional issues are. We're all small fish in this giant pond of California. And we have some areas where we differ and have differences of opinion, but we have areas where we have common goals.

3:10:18 Common aspirations and working together we can access different sources of funding, aggregate the sort of staff power that we have and really accomplish things that we would not be able to accomplish on our own.

3:10:34 So one little caveat. I know we said voted up or down with no changes, but there is a slight change. There's a small section that says that the members would be appointed to four-year terms, and that doesn't make any sense. And we're like, where did that come from? And it turns out it's in the current.

3:10:55 Agreement for ESCOG and that just got carried over by staff when they were drafting the new agreement. So we would ask you to make that small change when you approve it and your county did make that small change when we approved it. So in my opinion, we've put a lot of effort into it, tried to take into account the concerns of all of the different entities and yet build something that would be workable and efficient.

3:11:25 And I guess the last point is we're not inventing something completely brand new. There are, I can't remember the number, 47 different councils of governments throughout the state of California. You know, we are just trying to create an entity that gives us the ability, a tool to be able to access new funds and work as a region.

3:11:49 So with that, I can let Bob say a few words if you'd like, and I'd be happy to answer your questions. Jeff, if I could have a clarification, did you just strike the four years or did it go to a different number? We just changed it to at the pleasure of their nominating board. Okay, so it served a term at the pleasure, in this case, of the town council? Correct. Okay. Which in reality, that's what it is. You guys can fire Wentworth at any point from the ESCOG.

3:12:20 We do have to make sure that whatever the council approves is exactly the same language that the other agencies have approved or will approve. We can't have any deviation or difference between what some agencies are approving. So it would be helpful if we could get that language and maybe if you're inclined to approve this, you can make a motion to approve it with a change to have Section 402B precisely match the language that Inyo County adopted. Okay. Yes.

3:12:54 Good evening. It's snowing in June Lake, and I got a haircut today. I don't want to play the guilt card, but it was Harry driving down here. It's a truck inching along Dead Man, literally inching without chains. Chains are required, and I'm just really glad to be here to talk about this.

3:13:16 Thank you for being here. It's a regional thing, and you've heard me say many times, it's a region, damn it. And tonight on that road, I was saying, it's still a region, damn it. But I am glad to be here, and I would strongly encourage you to approve this agreement. I really, you know, just to, Jeff has, I think, summed it up pretty well in terms of how we got here. I would just want to remind you of really why I think it's a good.

3:13:42 A thing to do and why I will certainly encourage my colleagues on the Mono County Board of Supervisors to support it. I believe that this JPA will enable our region to work on common problems together much more effectively. The recreation economy, the opportunities for the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Partnership is a great example of that. That's a common problem, a common challenge we all share, both counties and both cities, and this helps us get farther than we otherwise would.

3:14:11 It enables us to fund and receive grants in that regard that we otherwise would. The other thing I don't want to lose, Jeff alluded to it in terms of where we are in the state, I think this will also give us visibility, visibility of the eastern Sierra that otherwise would not happen. I'm tired of people saying, where are you?

3:14:30 Both in the state and nationally. And I think this says we are on the eastern Sierra. We are a region, damn it, and we are two counties and two cities, and we stand for some great stuff. We're a wonderful place for entities that are doing great things, and we've come together to communicate and to provide a lot more resources and shared solutions to some of our challenges. I think we'll save money.

3:14:55 Jeff mentioned there are 47 councils of government. There are in California. There are actually 1,400 joint powers agreements or authorities of some type. They're all listed here. They're on the state website. They range from a couple of entities to several dozen. They exist. I don't think that those governments would have done that if it were a bad idea.

3:15:19 I do believe that we will avoid duplication. We will save resources in the long run as has happened in other areas. I think there will be more effectiveness and efficient services provided for the residents, certainly across the board. And then the classic thing we've stated all the time is that we're going to put ourselves in a better position to receive grants.

3:15:41 I'll be real honest with you. I spent, you know, over 30 years in Washington, D.C. working on budgets. And when we didn't have any other reason to cut something that they, you know, we were trying to cut, we'd say, well, have you coordinated with the other entities in your region? Well, why don't you go do that and maybe we'll consider that later.

3:15:58 We come in as a region, we're in a separate pile on the desk. We get more attention, particularly this administration is reaching out to rural areas, reaching out to regions, and I think that's not going to change any time in the future. There's not enough money for everybody. My standard line is there are tons of pigs at the trough, and we want to be separate from the pigs at the trough and be a region and get the assistance that will still help all four of us in terms of a lot of projects that we have.

3:16:27 There are several COGS in terms of the ones that Jeff mentioned. I want to mention a few of the rural ones. Butte County, Calaveras County, Humboldt County, Kern County, Kings County, Mendocino County, Merced County, just on the other side, Tulare County. Those are all councils of governments that have similar roles to what we're talking about. These JPAs that I've looked at don't have huge staffs. They have small staffs, and they have what we have proposed here as working through the agencies.

3:16:56 I really think that they're based on a philosophy of collaboration, which has been embraced certainly across the board in this state as well as nationally as the most effective way to face difficult regional challenges which transcend local government boundaries. And certainly our recreation challenge that is the first one out of the gate is an example of that. People don't...

3:17:24 People are simply not aware of the boundaries here. When they come up and visit, they cross boundaries all the time and they need to be served as best as possible. The minimal cost that it will take to support a JPA, I believe, will be surpassed by the increased revenue from grants and other financial assistance that would frankly otherwise not occur. The fear of losing control is a natural reaction to this, but I really think that's, again, more than offset by the increased success.

3:17:54 In addressing the shared problems that we have, support for our recreation-based economy being a good example. ESTA works. We all know ESTA. It provides and responded to a transit problem, and it's a great example of a JPA operating successfully. Finally, we all rise together, or we fall apart separately. A JPA is really how we do that.

3:18:19 We don't exist to maintain our local governments, I believe, in exactly the same form and substance every year. We exist to serve our 32,000 residents and the 4.5 million visitors that come up here every year. This means providing, in my opinion, the best quality of life for our residents and the most positive experience for our visitors. Forming a JPA will help us do that, and I urge your support for this agreement. Thank you.

3:18:54 I'm asking for your comments as our representative that voted to move this forward. Thank you very much. Thank you both for being here. Greatly stated, spot on, and I won't try to, you know, restate any of that other than, you know, the walls are down, we are a region, damn it, thank you, Bob, that will be your, on your tombstone, I think, we'll say that. We are a region, damn it. And we are called upon to collaborate.

3:19:22 We are no longer free to pretend that Mono County is in a vacuum, as is Inyo County. But I actually had a real-life thing that happened today. I'm on the board of the Pioneer Home Care, who deliver home care services and hospice services to both counties. And when they were talking about, they're now under sort of the umbrella of Northern Inyo Hospital, the district, Northern Inyo. And the fact that...

3:19:51 The ability to apply for grants and apply for financial assistance over time with this entity which, you know, operates on a shoestring. If they didn't have Northern India now helping, it probably wouldn't continue.

3:20:05 Being able to apply for a grant or something in the name of Pioneer Home Care as a region would be a perfect example of why the SCOG would be so beneficial. And I thought of that today, and I actually brought it up in our meeting, and Dr. Flannery from Northern Inyo, we were saying, you know, that would actually be a good, which brought to my mind the things we haven't thought of, the things that might possibly be beneficial.

3:20:31 with an ESCOG that could be served by that. Another one in my world would have been the two hospital districts who have over the years, you know, been really good at duplicating services and not working well together and now that's better, you know.

3:20:47 Challenges we were having recently have disappeared. But again, the ability to come up through SCOG in applying to people interested in funding and assisting rural communities like that I think would be priceless. So that's a couple other things I thought of today. I support this completely. I've enjoyed being on SCOG and learning more about this. And so thank you for being here. And thank you all for considering this question. Thank you. John? It is my pleasure to serve on the Mammoth Lakes Town Council.

3:21:16 It has been my pleasure for, I think it's six and a half years. And during that time, it has not just been my pleasure to serve on this council, but to serve on the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. It's been a great experience for me to work with local leaders and do the kinds of things that we get to do, but it's been an extra pleasure to be able to convene with colleagues from across this region and to discuss matters of regional interest.

3:21:43 But what's been striking to me from the beginning is the level of comedy, C-O-M-I-T-Y, with which that group has met and discussed things and shared ideas. It has been a real pleasure. I have not, I've heard rumors.

3:21:58 of regional rivalry and discord and historic this and that. I've never seen any evidence of that at the ESCOG. That has frankly encouraged me. I think all of us to pursue these things with the questions in front of us tonight. And we've been looking at this issue about having a financial ability to consume money on behalf of the region from the very beginning. I want to touch on a couple things that have gone on.

3:22:22 I spent a Christmas period a couple years ago working with Nate Greenberg and some folks from Ridgecrest to move the Broadband Consortium from a

3:22:46 I can't even remember the name of the Joint Powers Authority down in Inyokern somewhere where that broadband consortium was living that had, I don't even know if they had a building. It was very nice people, but tumbleweeds and joshua trees and that kind of stuff, to go through an enormous amount of very heavy lifting and work to move it over, to bring it into the ESCOG and establish the Inyomono Broadband Consortium on behalf of Digital 395 to represent our interest in that.

3:23:15 When it came time to put this thing together, it was like, well, we've got a grant. Someone's going to administer the grant. Who's going to do that? Well, City of Bishop kindly put their hands up in the spirit of comedy and regional cooperation. Okay, we'll take it on. We'll figure out a way to do this. And to their credit, they did. But it became clear over time that that is not a sustainable solution.

3:23:37 Staff changes happened down there. Things moved around. The broadband consortium met. The level of effort necessary and the burden on city bishop staff to do public meetings, to convene these things, to keep this thing open, it was falling on the backs of volunteers. Inevitably, the thing kind of ran out of gas. The grant was completed. There's a website up. But we did not necessarily do this opportunity with Digital 395 proud.

3:24:04 Trying to manage it by who's going to put their hand up and try to administer the grant from the state. We've recently, as we all know, been awarded a grant from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy for $620,000 for sustainable recreation and tourism. At the end of that grant, all the great work coming out of that is going to need a home. Thank goodness the town of Mammoth Lakes put its hand up and said, okay, we'll administer the grant, we'll do this stuff. But this is not a sustainable thing going forward. There are two additional things to add to this.

3:24:32 Mammoth Mountain Ski Area for a long time has been a local concern. It is in recent years they expanded. They have a couple of resorts from down south. But now Mammoth Resorts is part of an international corporate entity based out of Denver, Colorado. And with our questions around air service, it's very clear that Altera is now a regional player.

3:24:54 And that Mammoth Resorts is now a regional player. This is not something that's just about Mammoth Lakes anymore. This is a regional thing. And the other thing I would add is that I was at the California Economic Summit last week or so. Governor Newsom is framing a significant amount of effort into something called Regions Rise Together.

3:25:14 All the talk we've been having about regions, all of a sudden the governor and his administration is saying we want to reach out and connect with every corner of the state. Regions rise together. And I would just hope that as we continue to work on our efforts and bring things forward to the governor's attention, this administration's attention, and we finally get that opportunity to bring a couple million, we finally get out of six figures, we get into a seven-figure deal, and they say, okay, okay, okay, stop bugging us. Who do we write the check to? Who are we going to make out this check?

3:25:43 And we're not going to have to sit and look at each other and say, okay, well, who's going to manage this thing? Who's going to do the administration for, you know, a $25 million grant for regional housing efforts or something like that? We are not going to have the credibility necessary to bring the resources of the state to us if we can't do something as simple as establish a humble joint powers authority on behalf of this ESCOG.

3:26:10 Thank you. You have all spoken eloquently in support of the plan. Thank you. Kirk, questions? I second the motion. Questions?

3:26:39 If you want me to, I can go. No questions, if you have questions. I have more comments than questions. I'm not a government guy. I hate to see us put one more layer of government on top of one more layer of government on top of one more layer of government, which is why John sought to talk to me earlier today, but he couldn't because he's already talked to Linda because they're both on ESCOG. The Brown Act will not allow that.

3:27:06 And some of the things John said concerned me as well. One of them, that we need this agency to have the ability to consume money. I have a fear that this agency can do. It is great we can get a seven-figure grant. To administer that seven-figure grant, now we're talking about a director position, as we have with ESTA, because it's necessary. We're talking about secretarial staff. We're talking about a million dollars a year in potential staff.

3:27:37 To do this, how does that move forward? We can't, at $20,000 a year from each of the four entities, we're not going to have enough staff to do that type of grant, perhaps. If I could. Yes. These grants come with administrative funding. They do. However, in any economic downturn, the grants tend to dry up. And then we still have a bloated, are we in a position where we can pull this back down when that happens?

3:28:05 You had a comment. It's not a million in local. It's 100,000. To start. To start, right. But to administer the kind of programs we're talking about regionally. And I share your concern. Yeah. I understand. It's 100,000. We always say that to people. Why would I not know that? It's 100,000. And, Bill, you know, we should hold each other accountable if that number creeps up. And it will hopefully.

3:28:35 Creep up very little. But it's not a million. You know, it is not a million. You said a million, and that's like a terrible thing to go out there into the stratosphere. In either land, and I should not have said that. But down the road, I'm looking at the potential if it grows during economic good times. And one thing I've never seen a government entity do, except for the town of Mammoth Lakes when it was in bankruptcy, is shrink.

3:28:56 I've seen government shrink. When I was on the city council in Redlands, we shrank the government. 99 police officers went to 73 police officers. That shrank the government. Right. Anyway, that's not the point. So those are my concerns. And the grants will bring staff resources with them. Or we didn't write the grant right. Right. Because we've talked about that. That's the way it should be. That's the way the game is played.

3:29:22 That's the way the grants are administered. And so I share your concern, but I think we've got the ability to control that. That'll be cost of living, so I'm not going to say it's going to be $100,000 for 10 years, but it sure shouldn't go up by huge amounts. Yeah. The one thing that allays my fears is it can't go up without all four governments agreeing to it as you have it written in. So there is at least some control there.

3:29:49 And in terms of scope creep, I think Jeff referred to it a little bit, we can't do anything without the approval of the four entities. If I decide that, you know, we really need the JPA to get into snow removal on Dead Man Pass because it really affects all four of us on a late night at 7 o'clock, all four entities have to agree to that. And that's the way it is. We can't do a thing legally without that approval the way it's written. There's controls there.

3:30:21 Okay. I have to echo what Bill said about asking me to get behind another level of government is a tough ask. I think ESCOG is really strong right now. I think that you guys have been working very hard to get the JPA, but when the people change, we've got a lot of bulldogs, people who are, to re-quote you, playing the game.

3:30:54 When people aren't that will be taking SCOG positions in the future, two years from now, four years from now, six years, eight years, this could really come back to haunt us is my worry. I can count to three, however, so I'm not going to say anything else about it. Thank you for all the work. I don't see the need to become a JPA.

3:31:24 I'm sure you guys are all very passionate about it, and I appreciate that, and I will stop right there. Yeah, it worries me that I'm creating more government. At the same time, any of you that have been around for very long know that I've been harping at the supervisors going back to the 70s, that we need to be a region. So I believe in that, so I'm just, I'm so confused.

3:31:52 Well, Mr. Mayor, if I could, I'd like to help you by making a motion. That would be fine. And perhaps I can help you with our kind and gentle company present that may help you to come some clarity on your vote. Are you saying they will buy after the...

3:32:07 I'm not going to speak for them, but they're there and they're smiling and they're well-dressed. So I would move that the Town Council of Mammoth Lakes approve the proposed Eastern Sierra Council of Government Joint Powers Authority and the allocation of $16,300 per agency for initial startup funding for the remainder of fiscal year 1920 and that the proposed joint powers document be amended to have language consistent with that as approved by Inyo County. I'll second that.

3:32:35 I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie. No. Yes. Yes. Yes. Maybe. Yes. Passes 4-0. Sorry. Thank you for showering, gentlemen. Thank you. We will now take a short break. Thank you. It is something I've been harping at. I'll show you.

3:44:49 I'm sorry. I'm taking some of the supplements that are safe to help. I don't know if I would do that to help. Thank you. Ruin his diet. Getting used to it. Yeah. All right. Ooh. You want a jacket? I got a YouTube.

3:45:28 Moving on in the hit parade, we are now going to presentations of pre-audit financial results for fiscal 18-19. Mr. Rob. Yes, thank you. As you know, we do, maybe not often enough, but we do often budget presentations before council, primarily quarterly, talking about the performance throughout the year as well as how we finish the year.

3:46:01 Pre-audit fund balance means that we're just about to begin or we're in the process of the we've closed out the year. We're in the process of having the external auditors go through and do an audit on us. But this is where we were substantially certain that these are the amounts of dollars that we have available to spend enough to make decisions upon them. And I'd like to, before I start, kind of address for the legions of fans that are at home watching this.

3:46:29 If you have a staff report that was taken off earlier when it was first published, there was an error on that one. I despise errors, but I make them, so I have to atone to them. On the fund balance presentation, first slide here, we had allocated, I had not allocated enough to the tourism reserve, and so the way that this particular structure is built is

3:46:55 We have one pot of fund balance, and that's the $12.55 million. And then the other elements down below that are taken from that number. So the fact that the tourism reserve was substantially understated, it was about $1.050,000, I think, versus the $1.648,000.

3:47:17 Directly impacted the unrestricted fund balance for general fund, which is the dollars that we have to contribute and play with tonight. So if someone is reviewing this at home and has maybe those older documents that show a higher number, then it's going to be a confusing presentation.

3:47:34 I just wanted to address that, and then we'll jump into that. So the general fund balance, as we have on this particular one, these are the same elements that we show year over year. I don't think that there's questions on there. We have that long-term receivable for the vehicle replacement, which we're doing nicely about whittling that down. The Reserve for Economic Uncertainty at $3.7 million, that is considered fully funded. The operating reserve at $1.864 million.

3:48:03 Very substantially funded. I believe it's around 84%. And then the housing, transit, and tourism reserves are the dollars attributable to XSTOT that the allocations contribute to. So on that particular slide, the unrestricted fund balance, the dollars that we have to allocate are the $5.839 million based upon this slide. Then we have some items.

3:48:33 And many of these were addressed in our fourth quarter presentation where we have carryover commitments. These are projects that are established and started throughout the year or decisions that were made that have not fully been completed by the end of the year, meaning all the funds expended for that. And so what we'll do on that is we will reduce the budget in the prior year and increase the budget in the current year.

3:48:59 Most of that was done in the fourth quarter presentation, but by carrying these amounts over, we're basically saying, yes, we've made the budget movement, but we need to accommodate for the dollars that we need to spend, and that needs to come from the fund balance that was earned in the year, last year when it was decided to do these functions. So I listed those all out in detail, and we'll go through those unless there are questions about them.

3:49:24 But these are items that are essentially council decisions or things that we've planned to do and we still plan to do. That total is $3,021,000, which reduces our available fund balance down to $2.818 million. Typically at this time of year we talk about some project closeouts and in the general fund side there's not really a lot to talk about. I want to talk about a couple of items that were closed there, but we didn't really have a lot of shortfall.

3:50:01 Just one of the projects, the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure has $14,000 in funds necessary to close that project out. So staff's recommending that. And that will bring down the balance to $2.804. The next item is where we start to get into staff recommendations. Now, there are two items on the agenda tonight where we have substantial, where we have funding requests associated with fund balance.

3:50:33 These items on my staff report are sort of the more traditional and elemental items for normal operations of the town. They don't go into some of the larger requests that we'll be talking about on agenda item number 10. But we wanted to do these two items together on the agenda because they are basically one feeding off the other. So that's why I don't want to make it confusing to say that we have some staff recommendations here and then we have some broader ones on the next presentation, but in effect we do.

3:51:02 When we talk about the new reality we have of potential power outages on a consistent basis, the generator capacity for various town facilities is really a necessary item. Hazen team went through, did some analysis on the buildings. It's critical infrastructure that need the generator capabilities. That would include the town offices, some work in the ESTA building, and some work out at the yard.

3:51:32 And the community center, which is a place where people would convene in a disaster, if you will. And so that total is $280,000. We're also trying to go after a grant opportunity for that, but since the need is so significant, we wanted to put it on the request and set aside the funds for that. If we do get the grant opportunity, then those funds would become available for council action in the future.

3:51:57 The next item, the town offices and suite Z upgrades. Can I interrupt for a minute? The 280,000, how many generators is that? I believe that was four. Hayes would be a better. I believe that was four facilities. Four facilities. That's what I was wondering. Thank you. Yeah, so right now the town offices, 50% of them are covered with generator power as well as suite Z here. And ironically, it's all of the engineering that's covered with that power and all of accounting goes dark.

3:52:25 But this would basically bring the building up to full compliance on that. Thank you. Yeah. Town offices in Suite Z, Linda, this sort of addresses, we want to set aside some funds to upgrade the facilities and make them a little bit nicer, including, you know, carpeting, painting, different areas where necessary. It's not, you know, a lot that we're going to do, but it's really just sort of to keep things moving along nicely and just the refresh and upgrades that you really should do every few years to that. So that's the $75,000 that we're setting aside.

3:52:56 The police property evidence room, there are certainly some, I guess, changes in protocol and systems with regard to the evidence room and how it needs to be configured. So we did an audit recently on those, and there were some recommendations with how to improve that, and so we want to make sure that we put those in place.

3:53:18 That's the $27,000. Those will be actual physical infrastructure elements that we purchase and add to the evidence room for lockers and other items. There's a whole list of those if someone's interested in looking at the details of that. And then the flagpole for the town offices, $7,000. That's primarily the cost of that is the base structure, the concrete and other elements. And this would be, I believe, right out in front of Vaughn's.

3:53:46 We're kind of right now below us here. I think that we've struggled for years trying to have flag systems here at the office and the way they are located on top of the roof and require special equipment to get to have just become too difficult to have folks come and maintain. But the flip side, we don't want to do without it at our town offices. It's very important. The total of the SAC recommendations, and I broke these down as I did before in a one-time funding versus

3:54:13 ongoing annual funding. So the one-time funding is $389,000. For those folks at home, this is one of the areas you'll notice a change in. I had $150,000 set aside for the town fuel island replacement, and as I had to make some adjustments to the error that was made.

3:54:34 That was one of the items that was pulled aside. And the reason it was pulled aside is because the team, the engineering team, would not be able to get to that project until probably spring or fall, actually summer or fall of next year. And I'm hoping that within the next year we'll have the opportunity to request these funds, maybe third quarter from town council action. So I don't think it's all lost. It's a very critical need. And we'll get back to it. Questions? The next item talks about

3:55:05 Recommended funding for items that do include an annual ongoing expense. Both of these are associated with our police force. And one of them is the first item there is a wellness application called Cortico. And that is receiving really strong, positive comments across the board on providing our officers with and their families.

3:55:31 With an application that they carry on their phone, certainly, and it gives them the opportunity if there's any sort of employee assistance or things like that, any kind of, hey, things aren't going well right now, they have it at their fingertips and they can reach out and get support from either professionals that know how to handle those types of situations. And I'm not talking about how to do police work. I'm talking about

3:55:55 Your normal sort of psychological elements and different challenges that people may encounter. And it's just a strong benefit, I think, to provide to the officers and to give them an opportunity to have something that will support them in a time of need. So that's that particular request. And if Chief wanted to talk a bit more about that, you're welcome to come up. Chief, did you want to say anything about that system? Yeah, because I'm not clear on what...

3:56:25 That is. So if they need like, if there's like, go ahead, Chief. Yeah, it's a system that is an application on your phone and depending on the situation that the officer or family member might be having an issue with, they can scroll down and search through specifically, you know, family problem. And that'll get them and hit that and that'll get them in touch with psychologists throughout the country.

3:56:54 To be able to talk to one immediately or set something up in the future. It's a phone base and there's also articles, several things that are available on that specifically dialed towards the area that the person has issues with. And Cassie just came back from an HR class and seminar and it got reviewed by other agencies throughout the country that are using it.

3:57:19 Okay, other agencies other than police agencies? Because this is not- Currently it's directed at emergency services, but they're going to expand in the future to larger. Okay, so the $5,000 is overall for- $5,000 covers subscription for the police department. And it's not dependent on how many people that you have, or that's just a flat rate?

3:57:45 That is correct. And it's a structure built on the size of our police force, essentially. It's not a flat rate across the board. But I do want to, Mark, it is specifically tailored for law enforcement support. It's not something that I could employ across the town for town employees. Not at the moment, anyway. I think maybe the expansion of the futures is thinking about that. But it's really developed by law enforcement personnel to support.

3:58:13 Their teams and structures, and this is something that built into a program that they could share broadly with other agencies, and that's what they've done. They've created a business that apparently is very successful from a support standpoint. They're getting good reviews on their performance. It's like having a psychiatrist in the palm of your hand when you're in need, if you will. Yeah, I think everybody in town should be on that. Yeah.

3:58:42 Right now we're just going to spend the money on the people that have a gun on their hip. I want in on that. So going on to the next item, police mobile records management information system. I think it was a...

3:58:57 A pretty good write-up she provided in the staff report associated with that, but it's really access to data records and systems on the phones, the phone app. It has a little higher entry rate there for the $9,000 for year one, but then annual ongoing expenses of $900 significantly cheaper. So that's just really more resource time, energy, giving the folks the opportunity to have information they need at their fingertips without having to go beyond, back to their station or other ports to get the information.

3:59:27 The total recommendations are $403,000. Again, for the folks that may have an older version of that, I did have two other elements associated with funding the reserves at a little higher level that would actually bring us 100% in compliance with operating reserve as well as where we are with the REU. And those items were removed based upon not available funding.

3:59:53 The dollars that we have available, which you are going to see in item number 10, this $2,401,403, that's the dollars from the general fund that are available for allocation of my council tonight. And so that's a part of the next presentation, if you will. Just trying to tie those two together. So, Rob, there were no reserves that made to REU and operational?

4:00:16 There were no recommendations made for REU or operational. I think it was $292,000 that I had in the original presentation. Again, would bring us to $5.9 million in those two and fully fund both of them. So a great position to be in and certainly near and dear to my heart. But if we had to cut something, especially a mistake I made, that's one of the areas we're going to cut. Option number 10 to fund those if we want? No.

4:00:44 Well, you can make any recommendation you'd like, but it's not listed in the staff report as a recommendation. Okay. Some of these, and again, this fund balance presentation is really associated with here's the dollars available. General fund currently, I mean, certainly is the largest one there. But it's also an opportunity to talk about, you know, the other funds that are out there and just acknowledging that these balances exist. I think we've heard

4:01:15 Before, certainly when we were doing the budget presentation, that there are funds, and they're restricted for certain items, or they're held aside by our financial structure to achieve certain elements. And so they're there, and I just want to kind of draw a highlight and make sure that folks are aware that those functions are there. So the lead balance, I won't spend a lot of time on them, but the lead balance essentially keeps about 80% of the outstanding cost of our

4:01:44 Accrued hours of leave as a town so that if someone were to leave, someone who had many hours were to retire, that wouldn't create a burden on the department as it had to cover those leave hours. It would come out of this leave reserve and that's why we have it. We have 80% of the hours that are accrued on reserve.

4:02:04 And then the employee insurance benefit is for the vision and dental benefit that we have where folks accumulate balances that support those particular items. And again, those are reimbursement type items. Next most significant item, and I did this in order. That doesn't seem like it's out of order. It's just 101. Gas tax fund, as you know, is...

4:02:30 Is where most of our road repairs, most of our snow removal, or all of our snow removal comes from. And what we do is the general fund supports that significantly throughout the year. I think it was around $2.4 million, give or take, that we applied from the general fund to support that in 18 and 19. And so if we have dollars available in that fund, and these, again, the difference between, the fund balance is essentially a difference between the revenues

4:02:58 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

4:03:21 One completed, which was North Main Street. That's the north side of Main up towards the top where we had the retaining walls. That project was complete substantially last year, but we left it open based upon some trickling in of invoices. The $416,000, $244,000 credit is dollars coming back. And at Dan's direction, we want to kind of put those back into gas tax where they can fund future road projects.

4:03:50 That was sort of the idea here is that those dollars are going to come back 100% and go into that for future development. The Lower Main Street funding gap of $240,000, that's associated with the project that's just now completing. And that was sort of a known, based upon curb structures and systems from that project that we were going to have that. It wasn't an unknown item. We sort of had eyes on that for a while.

4:04:17 So the $240,000 is a funding request to support that shortfall. But in general, $176,244 is going back into gas tax. And again, that will be utilized probably in a larger project as we go, maybe not this coming year, not current year, but the next year, depending upon how we do asset management, or not asset management, but pavement systems monitoring.

4:04:43 So what that brings is that the restricted fund balance for gas tax is $1,051,800. And that, again, is available to spend. Measure R, Trails. As you know, Measure R, we account for that in two different ways. Measure R Trails is the carve-out specifically for trails, which is supported by the General Fund, not General Fund, supported by Fund 216, which is Measure R sales tax.

4:05:12 To the tune of $300,000 a year. A couple of years ago, we did set aside half a million dollars in additional capital, and that's primarily what's in this fund balance. And the way that works is Joel and team, as they plan projects for the year, they will plan to use that fund balance on larger construction projects. And so that's available for them. That's sort of a planned use of fund balance. And we don't recommend any adjustments to that. The only thing that we're carrying over that Sharps...

4:05:41 CEQA, NEPA, remaining balance. That's invoices that came in in August and September. But since this is as of June 30th, I had to hold over those dollars to show you that that's what was in there. But all I told, $670,000 is available for Measure R Trails. Measure R sales tax. This is Fund 216. This is where most of, well, this is where the revenue comes in from the actual tax.

4:06:11 That has a fund balance of $1,565,224. There are no carryover commitments for that, nor are there recommendations on this particular presentation. So that is available funding, and that will come into play for recommendations in item number 10. Measure U, user utility tax. That has a fund balance of $3.594 million.

4:06:41 With a commitment of $2.5 million to MAC funding. So we've carried that over for a couple years, and I think that project is teed up here for the spring, but the remaining unassigned fund balance is $1.094.222. No recommendations in this presentation, but in Agenda 10, we will have something. Airport Restricted Revenue Fund, that basically has two different components. So the Airport Operating Fund,

4:07:12 Is where revenue from the activities at the airport plus general fund support roll in to cover the expenditures of running the airport. As you can see that our general fund allocation was $677,000. And ironically, I mean not ironically, hopefully, miraculously perhaps, the expenditures and revenues were off by $552 for the year.

4:07:39 So, yeah, we're just good, as Dan said. Thank you, Dan. But what we do on that, essentially, is we won't pull those monies back into the general fund. We always leave them in the next section of our airport, which is the capital project fund. So if there's any excess revenues for the operating activity at the airport, we'll keep them in the airport capital projects fund. So in this particular one,

4:08:06 We had a starting balance at the prior year of $1.412 million. We had a couple of projects that we utilized some of those funds on to the tune of $13,211. And at the same time, we received some grant funds, $1.879. And then we received the restricted passenger facility charge of the $80,031.

4:08:34 Those dollars essentially have come in and increased the balance now to $1,481,976. So that's capital reserve sitting in the airport for future capital projects. I don't believe there are no recommendations at this point. We are trying to build that up for potential terminal work or any other items. One thing not captured in here, and Hayes and I were just talking about this, he's going to...

4:09:01 Discuss it later is some funds from the FAA that have been rolling over, and he'll be able to share those with you a little bit later, but I don't believe even the next one that we talk about any recommendation for utilizing that fund. Fractional Melrose, 858, so that's sort of an in lieu of TOT for a particular entity in town, and that has a fund balance of $259,648. This primarily covers a lot of the operating activity at the ice rink.

4:09:32 And that's staff and other things that are covered by that. There's some specific restrictions on how that can be utilized. I think it's locked into a time period of 2004, if I can, where we couldn't supplant any of the activity of the town that was in existence at that period of time. So this could be utilized for other town functions, but once we achieve

4:10:02 Sort of a higher level for that purposes of 2004 and 2005. The reason the ice rink is I don't think it was in existence at that time, so it's a new facility. The assessment districts, I put these in here just to show you the balances that, yes, there are assessment district balances that are out there.

4:10:23 And certainly what they're there to support, meaning the purposes. I'm not going to go through these in detail. I think they read better in the staff report than they do on a slide for that. But some of them do cover some debt service payments, so that's why they are substantially higher. But the bulk of them are for improvements, drainage, and snow removal. But Hayes and team do an excellent job of tracking those, as well as NBS, which is an entity that covers them.

4:10:53 We'll pause on them unless there are any questions as we go through that. Development impact fees, just looking at those as we're collecting these fees throughout the year. We accumulate them. There is some design. Dan asked me about this the other day. When are we going to make the corrections to these and adjustments to these? So I think look for some cleanup work that we want to do on these, and we'll get it done in fiscal 19-20.

4:11:28 But those are basically fees that are charged during the permitting process for specific purposes, and those are held aside for work to be done if something comes forward in that area. But I want to just, again, show you the balances that we have out there in these various funds. Then the vehicle replacement, this is always something that we talk about, certainly during the budget process, because there are needs of vehicles to be replaced.

4:11:59 The current balance in that is $8.722 million, and that represents dollars that are available within that as far as fund balance. The total vehicle replacement reserve account is higher. It's the $11,554 million, and the difference between the two is the outstanding balance of that loan. So every year that loan payment is $340,000 a year, and we'll make that payment with the budget process each year, which will reduce.

4:12:27 The $2.8 million and increase the $8.7 million. But then when we do buy vehicles, that certainly reduces the available balance as we've spent money on those vehicles. So I like the vehicle replacement program. We made some stringlining efforts this year. If you've been out to our facilities, it looks like a Ford dealership, which is good.

4:12:48 Talking about debt service,

4:13:18 And the Capital Reserve Fund has a balance of $263,043. The bulk of that is kind of coming in. If you remember, we do pull a full $2 million from the general fund to cover the settlement debt for the airport. And that is, as we renegotiated that and covered that with a loan or bond.

4:13:46 We have the ability to save around $130. It varies year over year. And so that's rolling over in this particular account, available to spend. But that's not recommended at this point with any adjustments, but we're accumulating that for other, I guess, future projects, if you will, council direction. And I want to talk about the different reserve accounts. You know, I displayed their fiscal year...

4:14:13 Fund balance at the beginning of the presentation. That was in that one chart that talked about those amounts. And on this particular one, the housing one that we're talking about here, it's really more the carryover commitments. And so these are contracts that council has awarded that are...

4:14:31 Transit Reserve, that has a fund balance of $1.509 million. Earlier this fiscal year,

4:15:02 And Council had made some decisions on use of funds. So in part, it was building three new bus shelters, replacing those. We had a Council presentation on those. That's the $330,000. A recommendation of transferring $400,000 to vehicle replacement for trolleys. And I think there's some...

4:15:28 Trailers in there as well. And then ESSA had a request, a grant match of $350,000, which Council had granted them. That was $1,080,000 of that $1.5 million. And then our recommendation, again, we're back to staff recommendations for one-time funding, is the transit building is in desperate need of some maintenance, which would be a roof replacement.

4:15:54 Heating and Air Conditioning Unit Replacement for that, and that is $350,000. So with that, all told, the uncommitted fund balance would drop to just $79,821. Does that create a new bay for the workers down? It does not create a new bay. The bays are existent there. It just puts a new roof on it and puts in a new heating and air conditioning unit. Thank you. Yes.

4:16:23 ESTA asks that we not put in a heater that burned the top of their buses. Okay. We'll put in an extra soft one that doesn't heat quite as well. And then Tourism Reserve has fund balance of $1,648,334 with just two carryover items. One of them was the King's contract, as you know, I think was a six-year deal. We're working through that. The outstanding balance coming from that is $300,000.

4:16:53 And then I think it was earlier this year or the Snowflake Project, the Winter Street Animation Project of $100,000 was designated from this reserve. And since those weren't expended, they were carried over. So total $400,000 carryover and available fund balance of $1.248 million. That is the conclusion of the fund balance presentation with some staff recommendations. So I'm available for questions or comments. Questions for Rob? Very well done. Thank you, Rob.

4:17:29 Thank you. Let's us all know where we stand. Thank you. I would entertain a motion to... Sorry, Mayor, if you want to take public comment. Public comment. John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. One question on that, the committed tourism reserve. Earlier this year, we did have two years at $150,000 for event grant funding. I didn't see that on there. I don't know if that should be in there. It could be. I would not...

4:18:10 I'd have to go back and take a look at that. Was that granted? It was awarded from the council for two years, $150 each year. Okay. So I figured that to probably stand on that sheet as well. Yep, absolutely. Okay. Those are judgments. I would look for a motion with that correction added. I'll make a motion to approve the resolution of the town council, the town of Mammoth Lakes.

4:18:42 Accepting the pre-audit update and amending the fiscal year 2019-20 budget as corrected. I second the motion. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Just to be clear, the Mr. Urdi's adjustment, is it clear what that is? Is it $150,000? I'm going to go back and review the council action taken on that and to see if...

4:19:11 Because it's not a matter of what was decided within the year was what was expended. So if it was $300,000 total for the two years, I'll have to look it up and get that direct. But I will go back and review that and make the adjustments to the fund balance. And then advise Council on what that final adjustment is. Thank you. Further deliberation. Jamie? Councilmember Hobbs? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Hobbs? Yes. Councilmember Hobbs? Yes.

4:19:41 Five. Wait a minute. Yes. Okay. Moving forward to item number 10. And you should all have a presentation in front of you, a new PowerPoint. Dan, you're leading us off here. Is this on Granicus right now currently? No. This one is not. Okay. No, it's not. We just completed today. So we'll upload it though so people will have it.

4:20:19 We're on granted because it's a staff report and the PowerPoint follows that pretty closely in terms of items and recommendations. The item before you, there's a couple different, excuse me, a couple different pieces to it on the front end. One of the recommendations was to prove a resolution with some of the recommended funding. We've actually bifurcated that resolution in the two pieces and we have a copy of that mainly because there's a separate resolution related to funding.

4:20:48 Potential funding for the parcel. You don't have that in front of you at this point. The parcel work, Mayor Sauser has to recuse himself on that, and so instead of having him take action on a resolution that he's recused from, he bifurcated that out. So same number, but we'll just have two resolutions. One will take an action by the five of you. The other one would be a resolution with just the four of you accordingly.

4:21:16 So just a heads up for that as we get to those points, we'll note that. The item before you is quite lengthy, if you will, a lot of issues in there. We have really tried to bring together a lot of things so that you can look at them in terms of context together. A number of these items, Councilmember Stapp has requested to have council discussion on, so they are identified in here and laid out, not particularly with his name by him, but definitely following up on some of the

4:21:46 Conversations we've had and some of the specific requests that he's made for consideration in here. So we're doing that element here. And we really are looking for some good council discussion, direction, and then some specific actions as well. I think we believe that the programs and items here follow the currently adopted council's strategic priorities, as well as some of the discussions and concern raised at our recent workshop in terms of areas that council.

4:22:14 I would love to see some additional effort and priority put on. And so that is reflective of the report in here. The other comment on the front end, there's a substantial amount of information presented in here. Yeah, it's not all inclusive, but this would have had another 40 pages to it.

4:22:32 As well as every detail of every project is not fully known, and we'll highlight that. So just a caveat on the front end, I mean, if you're looking for detail, detail information, getting down the weeds, that is not provided. We can get into questions where you have them. The same thing, we're hoping, though, there's adequate information here for you to make certain decisions on to provide direction and or to at least have a good open discussion so as we look to the future where we go. So all those elements will come through this.

4:23:01 We've broken this down into four sections looking at town government core services. That's one of the key elements in the last few budgets. We've talked about that of how do we continue to function and meet basic services. That includes our current budget process, our equipment and vehicles, a lot of stuff Rob just touched on, facilities improvements, whether it's in the building here or stuff in our parks and other areas that we do.

4:23:30 And then also future investment, and that's really looking at, we've been doing a lot of work the last few months here, but the last actually probably six months or better, in looking at personnel investments that we're still looking to. One of the key ones that you're aware of was getting the police department funded up at a point where we can go to 24-7 coverage, and that is scheduled to happen this March.

4:23:53 Second category will be major capital projects and maintenance programs. There's a number of items in there that we'll touch on, some direction and some clarifications and others that are out there that, frankly, again, we don't have all the data on, but we do want to be able to talk to those and let you know that they're on our list for of importance.

4:24:12 And then we'll talk about our town and partner housing programs. And these are elements that the town is working on, some of our near-term elements. We have some recommendations enhancing funding for protecting deed-restricted units. That's in partnership with Mammoth Lakes Housing, working with them on one of their key projects at 238 Sierra Manor Road, and then firming up the full contract funding for the chamber program we touched on.

4:24:40 And then the last item, we broke this out separately again because of the conflict that Mayor Sauser has. We will talk about funding options for the parcel, looking at use of current revenues, looking at some creative districts between the town and county, which again would be subject to county approval, and then also looking at some dedicated tax measures.

4:25:02 So that's kind of a brief outline. We'll be walking through that. We'll spend time. As we get into each item, if there are particular questions or issues that Councilmembers wish to bring up, please feel free to interrupt, and we will respond accordingly. With that, I'm going to have Rob touch on some of the core services. Yeah, so really recognize the size of this particular agenda item. We wanted to break it up into areas, basically, as you go through the slides there, the focus point is really toward this.

4:25:30 to establish what the next section is really going to cover and how we believe it's framed up. So we wanted to set that in at the conclusion of each of these sections. There'll be either a conclusion statement, basically to support what we think the focus was.

4:25:47 Or there'll be a decision point. So at that point, I think we'll be stopping, and the council will be discussing, deliberating, and voting on the items that are in front of them. And we try to structure it in such a way that it was similar to staff recommendations of a normal staff report. So core services is something, you know, the town, we take pride in the processes that we use for budgeting. I think, I don't need that.

4:26:16 Focus on living within our means. As you know, we've done that for the years, certainly since even before I got here. I think Dan started this process. And it's been very successful to give us the opportunity to go through what we just sat through, which is the availability to spend some funds on specific projects, but not overburden ourselves, meaning that I don't want to start the fiscal year with an expectation of very strong TOT dollars.

4:26:41 So it is a conservative approach. It gives us...

4:27:07 Resources for investment, as you've seen, we've done in roads and stuff. I know Hayes is almost telling me time out on the dollars available to spend on different projects because of staffing needs, but it's been effective, and we've been able to fund our reserves. So I think across the board in that area, very, very strong performance.

4:27:26 The vehicles and equipment, as you know, we've come to you for replacement of vehicles. I think we have a very sound program, not only of maintaining them, but of establishing financial means to replace them. And if you look at the vehicles that are traveling around town and things that we're getting out there, it's a solid plan. It works. It works very well.

4:27:49 The facilities and improvements, again, having those dollars available to spend from the budgeting process give us the opportunity to make amenity adjustments. And, you know, we celebrated some ribbon cuttings last council meeting, which is always fun to do. But again, I think that the standard of developing a resource pool to go out and have council make decisions on those is a sound function of our government. So it's a strong performance there. And then on personnel.

4:28:18 The level of service is something that as department heads we're always worrying about. Dan is very strategic in his thought processes and can develop structures and systems that really do fill in the gaps.

4:28:32 And don't think the same way that we've always thought in the past. They really challenge us to be collaborative across departments. We as department heads have a say in what we want to do from the personnel standpoint. I know there are people that believe that we used to have a lot more people to perform the services, and if we don't, maybe the services aren't as great. I wasn't around at that time, but I do know that we are getting the job done now and doing a great job of that.

4:29:00 That the personnel reviews and the work that Cassie does to bring that up for the department heads, Dan's strategic thinking around those and the collaborative efforts, I think it's a strong program. I don't think there's a deficiency there. And that's kind of what I wanted to talk about in the core services is that we've structured it through processes, we've structured it through systems that we believe are sound and functioning. So for that, we really don't have...

4:29:24 Any recommendations for change? We don't have any requests for change on that. I don't know if council has a different direction, but really the conclusion on the core services is that as a staff, we believe it's functioning well and would like to stand up to challenge if folks don't believe that that's the case. I'll add to that, as Rob mentioned, in looking to the future, we are identifying areas if we do need to add a body or part-time staff or take advantage of retirements and stuff.

4:29:53 As we leverage those types of things in, they will come forward accordingly, and the idea there is that they need to be sustainable for the long term. As this last budget year, we had some of those same discussions, and the staff report goes into a lot more detail. We weren't going to touch on all that. If you have questions, we can answer that. I would like to take a pause here. If there are any questions related to core services in areas either in the staff report or concerns by council members, now would be a great time to...

4:30:20 Raise those questions. Otherwise, I think we're doing a, you know, I'll say a fair to excellent job in our service level and delivery. And can we do better in some instances? Always. Will you hear complaints from people? Yes. And I think overall the feedback I'd say in the last few years that we've received from a broader standpoint has really been positive. And I think we've succeeded in a lot of areas of how we have rebuilt a lot of areas of the town organization and operations.

4:30:49 I did have a question just on the core services in the packet going down to that we have. How many 40 to 50 part-time staff do we have right now for the recreation department? Because here it says that it could be 40 to 50. And I know we do have a lot of people, but where are we running right now? It moves up and down between winter and summer. So right now we're kind of thin because we're hiring for the winter. No, I realize that, but just overall.

4:31:18 This says 40 to 50. Yeah, it really depends on the year and the level of services and the number of camps and all the activities of that we do in that part-time structure. So I say it's a range in there because any given year it could modify a little bit or we may end up with like throughout the summer hiring three different people maybe not here all the time. No, no, no, I realize all that but what I'm just saying is that that's what we have currently. That's not what we were looking to.

4:31:44 Correct. In case things change. That's what we've done right now. Right. This is in that ballpark we're doing. And that's all we needed. It may actually move up a little bit with new facilities. Oh, okay. Depending on the requirements of the programming. I.e., we have a new class somebody wants to take, we need to back, we need to fill that in, or we have a new camp. But the new programs and a new facility, yes, we could hire additional people. But currently, we're in that ballpark. 40 to 50. Okay. Thank you. Question? Yep.

4:32:13 I think I see the chief back there. Mike, when we had the discussions earlier, the idea of having, you know, 24-7, and my only question, I think, is, you know, are people doing 12-hour shifts or double shifts or anything else? The proposal to go to 24-7, the structure was to have enough staff to do 10-hour shifts, so you do a three-shift component, and so you end up with a

4:32:41 Overlap generally. Chief, if you want to come up, you might be able to speak to this. In the swing shift, if you will, the evening hours, there tends to be a higher call volume. It also allows us flexibility a little bit and just coverage if we need to call somebody in or somebody's out ill, it provides some flexibility to that. And we've kind of built that with the discussion with the chief and actually with the officers themselves, and so we'll be looking for some input from them as we make the transition.

4:33:09 But the Chief can speak to the details. Yeah, it's based on 410, which our officers are currently working. But with the additional staff, it'll allow us to have a day watch, which would be, and these aren't cast in stone yet, but from like 7 to 5, an afternoon or evening shift that would be 4 to 2, and then a night shift that would be, I think, 10 to 6. So that's how we'll get to that point with the additional officers that we've added.

4:33:34 And hopefully, because we have two officers that we're hiring, that we'll need to go through a full four-month training program. So that's why it's pushed out beyond a little further than we wanted. But we'll get there. Thank you. John? Yeah, just real quick. So to reconcile, like I know a lot of us take a lot of notes in this section, that first bit in the PowerPoint presentation, tracking along, I had this being basically pages

4:34:02 Two in our packet to the middle of page four. Correct. The next section is going to be section two, capital major maintenance projects. Correct. And that will end on page, what page will that end on that we have on our packet? Page 11? Correct. Okay. Just to clarify that so we can all follow along at home. Maybe a minor question, but at the end of this section on page four,

4:34:32 Opportunities and staffing levels necessary to meet projected work programs in the next seven plus or minus years. What is the rationale for seven plus or minus years? So what we're looking at with the kind of look at the strategic staffing levels is what we can pretty much look out to, and that's kind of a business cycle term for seven years, but as we begin to look at that, say seven plus or minus, in some cases we may be good for 10 years, I mean unknown, but given the level of work we see out there,

4:35:01 And things that are happening that we believe we can look at a staffing pattern to get out in front of versus each year coming in and moving stuff around. For example, right now, I'd say our fleet management staff are fully staffed at a level that should carry us, I'll say into that seven plus years. The road department, right now we're light because we have vacancies and trying to get to a minimum of 14 operators between full-time and part-time.

4:35:28 Chances are that will need to go up by one by the time we add additional streets and sidewalks. And as we look at the parcel build out, that will add a whole other set of staff there, which is probably in that time frame. So for staffing purposes, you guys are looking at a seven-year horizon. Yes, we're looking out here to say where should we get to and then what does that look like? What's the sustainable funding for it? Thank you very much. I only have one comment, I believe because of how we have handled budgets.

4:35:57 And come out of the recession and airport lawsuit that I am seeing a greater level of commitment between staff to work together on projects than I've ever seen in the town. And I am proud of you for that. And you need to be called out and thanked. We have created harmony where there did not used to be any, in my opinion. So thank you. That's my comment for what it's worth.

4:36:26 And, Mr. Mayor, I'll lead it to you. If you want to take public comment on a section, there's no recommendations here, but we'd ask that it stay focused on just that section. Right. Any public comment on this particular section, Town Corps Services? Seeing none, we will move on. John, you just had that comment. You weren't looking for a break, right? That's correct. No, no, no breaks. So, well, we'll have one eventually, believe me. Capital and major maintenance projects.

4:36:55 Yeah, again, this here's an area, again, that we have worked on, and as Rob mentioned in our budgeting process, for us to really be able to move this forward. And the real focus here is how we utilize dedicated funding sources to meet capital needs and maintenance, establish plan to monitor those things, to prioritize projects, execute capital projects. If you look at the amount of infrastructure work we've done the last several years,

4:37:20 It's gone through those elements, whether it was a new police station or whether it was repairing MUPS last year. It goes through that process. And a lot of that focus is on our core services of how do we do that, and then obviously we have the community expectations. We get areas of concern that we can go address through that process. And these have, I lumped this together with capital and major maintenance that are related, and we'll touch on a number of these items across the staff here.

4:37:50 But one of the first ones that we want to hit on is our solid waste program. This is a, it's a major substantial capital investment that's more by the private sector, if you will, waste connections, doing businesses, Mammoth Disposal versus heavy town dollars going into that. The solid waste program, we have been before Council several times with the work program. We're looking at a full service transfer station here in town. We're looking at ultimately

4:38:19 Alternatives for disposal of waste with the closure of Benton Crossing Landfill. You've authorized the purchase of a couple of parcels for storage issues in the business park by the airport. The other side to this, we have been in ongoing discussions with Mono County and where they're going. To my knowledge, they don't have their RFP yet for trash services, and so it's hard to know exactly where they're going, so we're working through that.

4:38:45 The element there is that we are not requesting any general fund or other dollars to go into the solid waste program. It is currently funded through dedicated revenues from the solid waste side, and ultimately the cost of the new facilities in the program will be put into a rate structure. You extended the franchise agreement in an earlier action this evening until end of April as we're working through a new franchise agreement.

4:39:10 The proposal there is a 20-year term, which actually allows for the amortization of a lot of cost over time versus seeing significant rate increases. We're working through that process right now with an outside consulting firm looking at the cost of those elements. And that will all ultimately come back to you through a new franchise agreement. It will come through through a new rate structure. And ultimately, how do we partner with the county elements? We're having those ongoing conversations with that.

4:39:37 And this here is one of those mandated programs, ultimately. We don't have a lot of, we can't say we're not going to do it. We have to say we will meet certain recycling standards. We have to meet other diversion credits. There's a whole lot of elements in there from the state side saying you will do these things. So we want to highlight that as a major program area we're working on. But it's staff time commitment right now versus either general fund or other dollar commitments from non-

4:40:04 Solid Waste Related Revenue. So we're able to do that. Again, I think part of that goes back to the structure has been discussed earlier, to be able to move that forward. The second one, we do a lot of work with streets, and I'm going to touch on this briefly, then you let Hays kind of walk through the program there. But ongoing maintenance, we currently allocate $580,000 a year out of the annual budget into that. As mentioned earlier, we have just over a million in fund balance staying over there.

4:40:31 We get about $130,000 plus or minus from SB1 funds each year. And we're always working in partnership with the county through the Local Transportation Commission on priority and utilizing state dollars. And there's other grants that go out. Haisen, correct me if I'm wrong here, but the sidewalk programs you're looking at is plus or minus $8 million with very little, if you will, town general fund dollars having to go into those projects to do that.

4:40:59 We have a lot of discussion over time about that needing to be a million dollars a year. To my knowledge, looking back at least 15 years, I don't think it's ever been bunded at that level from an operating budget. For the last several years, because of carryover dollars, because of better than anticipated TOT revenues and outside sources, we are spending a million plus or minus every year, and sometimes more, obviously, depending on the scope and size of projects.

4:41:27 To enhance our street systems and to try to maintain those. And we have a whole program related to that. And I'm going to have Hayes speak to that and how that program comes together and how it helps prioritize the dollars we have from basic maintenance to major reconstruction. Thanks, Dan. So there's a number of balances and budgets here. And I'll kind of talk about how we make decisions and recommendations based on those budgets and how you'll see those come forward to town council.

4:41:56 We are kind of transitioning right now for the last almost four years. Our focus has been on Main Street, implementing walk, bike, ride, implementing downtown revitalization, and Dan is right, to the tune of $8 million in funding. But now we've got to kind of get back to some of the deferred maintenance on streets and roads that we, because of staffing being focused on Main Street, we haven't been able to get to. So the first two items here, the ongoing maintenance and the current fund balance.

4:42:25 Pretty much the same bucket of money. And the way we prioritize that is not having pertussis or whatever it is I have. Is at the beginning of the year, we get our budgets June, July. All of our damage occurs over the winter.

4:42:42 So we don't spend that money right off the bat. We wait to see what the season brings us. That $580,000 also has to cover our stopgap. That's our cracked ceiling, our pothole repair, any damage that we receive from loaders or just vehicle traffic or whatever happens. So that's where our focus of that dollars goes initially. Now we've been saving the balance of that for a few years as we worked on Main Street. And we use a pavement management system that evaluates...

4:43:11 Pavement Condition Indexes to make decisions and recommendations on how to spend these funds. And I'll simplify this. This honestly deserves an entire presentation, and I'll probably bring that back when we make the recommendations on what streets and MUPS we're going to maintain. But very simply, on an annual basis, we do an evaluation of the streets using a standardized methodology for determining the conditions of the roads.

4:43:38 We plug that into a pavement management system that has every street and town listed. And then it goes and sorts it through a series of algorithms based on the traffic volume of the road, previous condition, and then kind of the degradation curve, how bad these roads go down, is it an arterial collector, and so forth. And then based on the output we're looking for, whether that's we want to raise the condition a certain amount for the entire town,

4:44:08 Or an area or region. Or if we only have so many dollars that we're going to plug in, the system will make a recommendation on how best to use those dollars. And then staff will review that, make sure it kind of jives with what we've seen on the ground. And that's how we kind of come to a decision point on what to fix first. It also will evaluate the treatments. We have programmed the system for the treatments that we do here in town. They're very specific. The fog seals, the chip seals, the reconstruction.

4:44:37 It only evaluates the type of work that we do here in town. This system is maintained by a very large Metropolitan Transportation Commission in the Bay Area. It's got a ton of people working on it. The system works very, very well for what we do. All of the algorithms are set to town, to the town, not to any other region. It actually follows what we have put in as input for the last decade and watches how the roads have

4:45:06 Started to degradate and the damage that we see over winter is actually the input and the output for the system. So we'll go through that analysis to make a recommendation on how to use these first two budgets. And it is our intent to try to couple that with some LTC funds. And those of you on the LTC saw a play for $2.7 million in programming for next year for streets and road and mop maintenance.

4:45:35 And so if all of that comes together and is approved, we're hoping to package up potentially a $4 million project for asphalt repair and MUPS and so forth. Now we'll go through this analysis to pick the best treatments and we'll bring that back to Town Council to later staff report and give this the time it really deserves. SB1 is a specific pot of money. I've been before you guys a couple of times with presentations on how to utilize those funds. Every April we have to get a Town Council resolution on how we're going to use those dollars.

4:46:04 And then we go out, build the projects, and then we pay ourselves back over time. So we just completed a project on Meridian. We'll be paying that off over the next year. And then we'll move on to the next project, which you guys will approve this coming April. I'm going to move on to the airport. Rob did a good job of talking about our capital reserves and our restricted reserves that come from PFCs. He mentioned that we do have entitlement dollars. Those are...

4:46:33 Just what they sound like. We're entitled to these grant funds by the FAA because we have so many employments. And we do have to submit a grant application to allocate those funds for specific projects. But that will come to you as part of an ACIP review actually at the next council meeting. And we'll go through the town's plan to use these dollars, leverage these dollars to complete improvements at the airport.

4:47:00 And I'll leave it at that. I mean, this, again, is going to get a full presentation at next council meeting. I'm going to talk a little bit about the deferred maintenance approach to things. As I did in the presentation, these are not all requests that are facing you here tonight. As you have approved several of these in advance, the 75,000 for town offices was on my prior presentation as well as the 280,000.

4:47:31 But the purpose of this essentially is as we've had funds available, we've expended them on that we've identified deferred maintenance. I think Stu and team for the parks area have done an excellent job of utilizing the funds that the council has allocated to them over the last two years to make significant improvements in our facilities. If you've been out to, I think, you know, Whitmore Track and certainly out to Shady Rest, you'll see the dollars at work.

4:47:57 And what they've been able to achieve with that is certainly in the community center as well as another one. So it's been effective and I want to commend the job that they've done. There is a request on this particular section for the $100,000 for parks deferred maintenance funding, which we'll get to here shortly. But just really wanted to list these out, not to put them in front of you again, but really to say more that we do a lot of work across the town staff in identifying

4:48:26 What we think, similar to what Chase went through with how pavement is evaluated, but really building structures and other things are evaluated for the need for work to be done on them. And that's what really prioritizes how we come forward with those requests, bring them before council, and request the dollars. So the only thing that's not, the two items not funded on this list, and the list total, well, I'm sorry, I'll clarify that. The two items not funded on this list currently is the $100,000, which I'll ask for now.

4:48:55 And the $150,000 for fuel tanks, which are there in the future. Assuming that you guys will allocate the $100,000 for the park's deferred maintenance, that total maintenance recommended of $1,135,000 doesn't include that $150,000. So that's what we would have spent or you guys have allocated the spend on that. So I think it's a very strong investment in the facilities and the structures of the town. And that sort of, I guess, summarizes the capital and maintenance.

4:49:25 Projects that we have out there and the methodology that you guys are taking. So in this particular area, so this is the conclusion of the sort of capital and major maintenance projects core services area. This is a pause point here where there's a policy decision to be made and staff is recommending Town Council to authorize $100,000 for the deferred maintenance of the park facilities and infrastructure to be completed fiscal year 19 and 20.

4:49:54 One question. On that $100,000 funding, was that reflected in your prior number nine agenda item? It was not. Okay, so this was an add-on to that. Okay. But everything else was in there. Yeah, so the items that were in that particular presentation were the $75,000 for the town offices.

4:50:12 And the $350,000 for the transit building coming out of transit reserve. And the power backups up $280,000 for the generator systems. The building stops of $330,000, the transit building stops, that was something that Council had allocated earlier. And I had listed it as a carryover item, but it wasn't incremental on that. And the $150,000 for the fuel tanks was still in number nine also.

4:50:38 That actually was on, that was part of the error carve-out, if you will. It's just going to haunt me forever. But you are not recommending that in this item either. That is not in this item either. No, because essentially, as you'll see in the staff report, is that $2.4 million will be ended.

4:51:00 An available general fund balance from agenda item number nine. That's set to cover a lot of these requests and these recommendations that staff is making in here. If we had the available funds, I would have requested the 150, but we don't have the available funds, as you'll see later, to cover all the items that we need to cover. So that will be covered, that will be requested probably in the springtime, and again, won't delay the project at all if it's allocated.

4:51:28 So, Mr. Mayor, just to be clear, so, Rob, you're taking us up through transit stops on the middle of page 8 with this section? Yeah, I was going to say the deferred maintenance, we carved out. So, was that the end? It was deferred maintenance at the end of this section? Yeah, I've got to come back and deal with the Community Recreation Center. We carved that out because it has a significant policy question for you there. It's on page 6 of the staff report. Right. I think we wanted to, yeah. So, I have a question on the deferred maintenance piece. Yes. At the LTC meeting, we heard

4:51:58 We had some discussion about the transit building and the roof and the heating system. And the county was talking about the heating system they use up in Bridgeport. That's a biomass-based facility. I understand it's German, it's very good, but it might be a little temperamental to its feedstock. I have been getting communication recently on an effort to do a major fuels reduction project, which we've all heard a rumor of.

4:52:27 It's called kind of the donut project that would go all the way around the town. So it's like the fuels reduction project in the lake space at times. I mean, it would go all around the entire town. So I'm wondering if it would be possible to get consideration as we start talking about a heating system down in the yard to explore the opportunity to do some sort of a biomass.

4:52:50 Heating type project because we're going to have all those fuel piles up in the lakes basin that frankly we don't know what to do with. I guess it's the plan is to burn them but given our tourism do we want to get into that and now we're looking at potential another enormous project far bigger than that one that's going to go all the way around the town and I would just

4:53:10 I'd have said this is maybe a good time to start. Let's start getting a little proactive and looking forward because if we're going to have those kinds of feedstock opportunities, and this is a relatively modest project to make something like this work. I've heard from a number of constituents with all the fuels, with all the dead trees, why aren't we doing, why can't we do something more with all this fuel stock rather than just burning it, which contributes to, you know, climate change issues and all kinds of other stuff. Why can't we put this stuff to work in a more reasonable way?

4:53:38 So I just request to have some consideration for that going forward. I think we agree with looking at that, that's the biomass and the wood innovations grant looking at. I think the cost to put in that size of a unit to make it effective for the transit facility would cost you more than probably double or triple what we have allocated for it. Frankly, on small scale, we looked at these for some small schools and the different elements and different things. And I know the county's one is very temperamental in terms of the scope and size of the...

4:54:05 Feedstock and the equipment you buy just to manage the feedstock in the room you need to do that. So I appreciate that thought process there, but it's probably. I think it's going to be a real issue. If this thing comes forward, we're generating a lot of piles of a lot of wood sitting out there in the landscape that it would be nice to figure out some plan to do something productive with it other than just burning it. We absolutely agree. If we can take that in between, I'll say, small wood product stuff, we know the.

4:54:32 Fuelwood folks in town, very interested. That's 40,000 acres they're talking about treating, I believe is the number.

4:54:38 And you think of the basin being 680 acres, so you're right, it is huge. It's going to be a huge project, and I think, again, to do something other than just burning it. Absolutely. If you run a biomass where you're creating either energy or you're creating other products out of it, it becomes really viable. The biggest challenge of not burning in the forest has been the cost of transporting that material to a facility, wherever it is, and then processing it, pre-processing it, and storing it.

4:55:05 Yeah, and I didn't mean to bring this up to get a full, I'm just pointing out to Council there's something going on out there that we could maybe do something. I think we've all thought about it, but let's move this discussion off. Thank you. I think they got some grants, too. So, questions on the last section.

4:55:23 Yeah, Haysa, on the pavement management system that you mentioned, I mean, are we keeping up with that, or how does the pavement management system, it evaluates all of our asphalt, and then it says, hey, this needs to be done. Can you explain the pavement management system and how the relationship is with the, or what the relationship is with overlays and expenditures? Okay.

4:55:51 So, again, we do an assessment, a standardized assessment on the streets and roads within town. We input that into the system, and then we ask it for certain outputs based on whether or not we want the town to increase its overall PCI, so we can ask for that as an output, and it'll tell you you have to expend X dollars to get there. Or we say we have so many dollars, tell us the best way to spend it.

4:56:19 And then it'll tell us what treatments where. It can be driven. We can drive it any way we want based on funding recommendations, based on budgets, based on a desire to increase the road to a certain level. Yeah. So there is an evaluation of the level and the condition of the roads, which is part of the formula. Oh, absolutely. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions?

4:56:46 No, do we need an action now for this? Yeah, we have an action here, but before we go there, I'm going to ask if there's anyone in the audience wishing to speak on this particular issue. I will bring it back to Council for its privilege. Okay, so we'd like a motion then? Mm-hmm. Okay. Direction for, yes, for the $100,000. You want to? Okay. If you make a motion, we'll actually have a resolution that's included. If we have consensus on that, then I won't have to amend a resolution.

4:57:13 So if I can just get consensus on the $100,000 as we hit the end, then I will make sure. Oh, so there's a, okay, so we will do that tonight? Yeah, it'll be tonight. Okay, so, all right. Is there any concern with that? So let's ask if we have consensus, John. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. So that would be consensus without a vote, sort of. Okay. Okay. Moving then to capital and major maintenance project. New amenities. Yeah.

4:57:42 New amenities. Yes. This was a discussion on the, it's gone through a couple name changes, but the multi, went from an ice rink to a multi-use facility to a community recreation center. So if we use the acronym CRC, it's for community recreation center. This is the proposed facility that's at Mammoth Creek Park West. We have gone through a number of different iterations on that, working through some preliminary.

4:58:07 Design work again, looking at funding alternatives that we can bring a project in. The previous direction from Council was to come back with a project that had a $13 million budget. That is what we'll be walking through and what is before you this evening. I guess to be kind of blunt about it, we've gotten to this point. We think we can bring a project in pretty positive within this budget that actually works and meets the majority of the programming needs.

4:58:35 If you do not want to continue to go forward that direction this evening, it would be appreciated, and we will quit working on this project, to be blunt. It's a lot of time and effort, and I think we're hopefully getting to the finish line with it, again, pending Council's direction this evening. The project goes through this, and we've allocated already $9.1 million, a little over that.

4:59:00 And some of that, about a little over $2 million of that, I believe, has been expended at this point through architectural work and design and what have you going through that. We've been trying to keep that number out there, not so much the expenditure side, knowing that we have a total budget to work within. So on the slide up there, the left side kind of walks through the current funding that's been allocated. That does include $5.5 million in bond proceeds that we're paying debt service on.

4:59:28 The project was not to go forward. We do not have a refunding option, I don't believe, on these, so we would continue to pay that debt down until it's paid off, and those bonds could be used for, we'd have to modify the project, but it could be utilized for a regular type element there. The item before you this evening was coming back and looking at what does it take to get back to the dollar amount that we need in the facility to meet the budget requirement.

4:59:58 So the request this evening is for just under $3.9 million in funding to be able to complete the facility. That includes a $920,000 contribution from the general fund. It includes the majority of the reserves currently as of June 30th in the Measure R fund and also the majority of the funds that are in Measure U currently as of June 30th.

5:00:22 Both of those funds will likely have additional reserves built up in the current year in terms based on at least the past few years of expenditures. I'll come back and touch on those in just a minute. The parks diff, there's $75,000 recommended. That's rounded up. It's $100 or $175 short, which I think we've already received into the fund this year. And then the Mello Roos component, the one restricted fund there for $250,000.

5:00:50 I wanted to come back to Measure R and U because this is a substantial investment of those dollars into a recreational amenity. We'd gone before with Mammoth Lakes Recreation a while back looking at the use of the reserves. I think they might have been a little smaller number at the time. We wanted to walk through this here. We will go back to them accordingly depending on the action from Council this evening. The use of Measure R reserves at the time was approved. The Measure U reserves were not approved.

5:01:19 Mammoth Lakes Recreation Component. That is a recommending body to the council, which you can accept or not accept their recommendations. You have final authority in those areas. But if you do go forward with that, we will want to go back to the MLR board and walk them through the information of what we're looking at expending here for this project. The other elements in there are dollars that are available. Again, the general fund dollars, that would be

5:01:47 Kind of left up to the council if you wish to commit that level of general fund to the project. Currently we've only committed $121,000 of general fund dollars, so relatively small amounts, just over a million dollars on over a $13 million project is, from a general fund standpoint, is fairly limited. The other question that has come up on this and we're reworking it based on the sprung structure where it's an enclosed facility would be the operational cost.

5:02:12 Looking at that, we still think on the general fund side, it should be less than $100,000 a year, additional costs from the town side between revenue generated, the current activity you know we have, and then the programming that goes into it. Some of the programming, we're working through that, which will be based ultimately on some additional funding and support raising, frankly, for some of the elements actually in the building that aren't critical, if you will, to get the building up and running.

5:02:39 But it does have added value in some of the areas which we would come back as we have funding for small dollar amounts in different areas. There's some options. We're looking for that and different ways to do that. But on the front end of this, the dollar amount represented here would allow us to complete the design and actually have money in the bank that we could actually go out and put a bid proposal out and say, yes, we can actually fund the bid. We're not bidding it kind of on the hope that additional dollars will come in.

5:03:09 And so it's, I think, a fairly straightforward item. There's been a lot of community debate and council discussion and expect a little more this evening. In terms of being able to move this project forward, it does, won't walk through the details on the project that's been presented in the past. And if Hayes can talk to the timeline at this point or any of the other elements as we're working through the design side.

5:03:34 We've gone through additional update on environmental, I think, that's been completed or nearly completed. And so at this point it would be do we have enough capital dollars to actually move forward with bidding a project? And that would be the recommendation that we would ask for consideration this evening. Okay, questions or comments? Who wants to start the show? I've got a quick question on the environmental. Can you give us an update on the environmental? Yeah, so maybe I'll just give you the overall.

5:04:04 Picture here. So when we were here in, I believe it was June, the Town Council recommendation was to move forward with the tensile fabric structure to take it back to rec commission and their committee and design review and then complete the environmental and bring it back to Town Council for award of the contract. We've worked with our consultants to come up with, frankly, Stuart's done a great job with our architects, a really innovative design.

5:04:32 We've made a number of changes to meet the community needs. You asked for, at that time it was a mezzanine for a community room. We actually found a way to get it to fit without being a mezzanine. We've made the appropriate environmental considerations and have an amendment prepared that will come before Town Council. At that time I'll do a comprehensive update on where we're at with the project, but we're on schedule for a bid sometime in February.

5:05:01 And it has already gone through rec commission and their group for review of the design. And it's an application is in for review from the planning commission side of things. And the environmental? It will come to the town council as an amendment. Okay. But do you need any update? I mean, how's that going or? Oh, we're in great shape. It's good moving. There's no issues with that. No issues. Good. Thank you. Well, because again, we only have to look at the environment, at the changes to the project. You only have to look at the impacts of.

5:05:28 The difference between what the project was before and what it is now. So the bulk of the environmental work remain exactly the same. Should be relatively minor changes, I think, largely in the area of aesthetics. Good. For the EIR just needs to be amended? As Andy stated, it's just we're looking at that delta. What was the change in the project and evaluating those impacts or actually the reduction in those impacts in some cases? Other questions?

5:06:01 No, I have comments, but before we go to comments, any questions or comments from the audience? Mr. Mayor and council members, Jeff Posey, it's been a while since I've seen you all. You all switched seats except for John. You're still in the same seat, buddy. I want to come just to show my support and the community support. It's kind of getting harder and harder to get people to come out to these meetings because I feel like the boy who cried wolf. It's been way too long and this is late. There's no kids that could come this late.

5:06:38 I've heard different things around town about, oh, it's a sprung structure, it's a bubble, it's ugly, whatever, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. From looking at the plans that these guys have provided, I mean, the old saying, don't judge a book by its cover, and it really doesn't matter what's on the inside that counts, and they've built a hell of a facility. It is going to be pretty awesome. With the elevated stands, the four locker rooms, the downstairs room, the upstairs room.

5:07:06 The level that you can look at on the rink from being up high. It's going to be pretty awesome. I also want to, do we change the name now? Are we Community Rec Center? Yeah. Let's go with that. That's cool. I appreciate that. Because, you know, it was the ice rink. And everyone talks about, oh, it's an ice rink. It's for such a small user group, ice rink, blah, blah, blah. Well, it truly is something for the entire community. And not just Mammoth. I mean, I have, I just started sign-ups for our adult hockey league. We've got a kid from Bridgeport playing.

5:07:36 June, Mammoth, McGee, Crowley, Sunny Slopes, Bishop. So this is pretty much for the entire community. And I was speaking to a friend down in Bishop. He coaches the high school team. And I could read you his text, if you don't mind. We were talking about, I was like, well, how many kids play roller hockey? And he said, well, we've got 320 kids and 50 adults. So that's close to 400 hockey players down in Bishop alone.

5:08:06 And let's see what he said here. Hope I'm not burning time. All right. He said, if you run across any ice in the hills, that would be good for the high school team. Can you let me know? They need ice. Will do. And I said, you guys should have them play as a beer league team to get the kids out there to get more ice time because they don't have any ice right now and they're already halfway through their hockey season in L.A. So then he said, that'd be great, but we can't do Tuesdays. It's for roller. And then I said, well,

5:08:36 They need the ice, right? And he said, yeah, they do. And I said, well, if only we had a roof and guaranteed slots for them to fit in. And he said, for sure, if it was reliable, the numbers would explode. And then I have this one from another buddy who I'm trying to get to play hockey. He's a hell of a hockey player, played college and everything, but he's, here's his thing. He said, I'm like, come on, you really need to play hockey. You know, dedicate one hour a week to play.

5:09:04 And he said, no thanks. Wasting time on a rink that isn't consistently open doesn't make sense for me. If I had a nine-to-five job, it would. Then he goes on to, well, between the weather and the rink, then he goes into his business thing. I can't commit. I'd rather put my feet up than freeze my butt off. Well, he didn't say butt, but. So, all right. I wrote some notes down. I didn't bring this on purpose. I left it at work. Let's see. Hard to get people to show up.

5:09:35 Okay, we're also the youth program. This year we have 42 kids signed up. I got this information from Patrick. He's watching now, so I'm going to throw some numbers at you. We're holding two tournaments. Right now we have 17 different teams plus our six teams. That's 23 different teams. 250 individual players are coming. And plus the Calder Classic, which runs over Christmas. I don't know how many teams he has. We have 13 USA Hockey certified coaches in town, which is quite a high number for our small population.

5:10:04 And the USA Hockey program, you have to go through a two-day course. You learn about hockey and the psychology of dealing with different age groups of kids, how they learn, what to teach them, and the way they see the game, because a 12-year-old sees it way different than an 8-year-old. And to go through that course, you also have to be SafeSport certified, which is a... Do you guys know SafeSport? Do I have to explain it? Okay. And that's like a 20-hour course that you have to go through. And then you have to take...

5:10:34 Maybe 15 or 20 hours worth of online courses to be a coach. So these parents have dedicated quite a bit of time just to be able to coach your kids. It's all volunteer. We don't pay anybody to do it. I'm not sure what other programs have to have, but from what I've heard, it's way more intense than just being a regular coach. It's a lot, and it costs a lot of money. The club doesn't pay for it. You have to pay for it out of your own pocket. But this area, I know...

5:11:03 You know, you look at the analytics, you look at hockey, and I know there's a Mammoth Times article saying rinks are closing. That's probably Patrick. This area is blowing up for hockey. We've been skating in the lakes for three weeks now, and I just posted two videos on Instagram. They got picked up by major people. Both of them have over 100,000 views. I've met people from San Francisco two weeks ago that came out to play. And then, I'll tell you, build the rink. It's for the whole community.

5:11:32 And it's been so, so long and these guys have worked so hard. I don't know how you do it because I came here fell asleep here and you guys do it twice a month. So good job. Thanks for, you know, keep plugging away. You haven't killed me yet, but I'd rather not come back. So let's get this thing done. Thank you. Thank you. I'm Sean.

5:12:01 Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commissioner, also owner of Mammoth Brewing Company and Bluza Palooza. And I'm going to talk quickly because you've got a lot of people here who I think are in support of this. I'm frankly very excited on the design of the building. I think it looks great. I'm sorry we can't get the original structure that we originally wanted, but I think actually staff has done an excellent job in designing what we've got.

5:12:26 The logo that's on it, the south-facing windows that we're able to open up, the additional space, it's not just an ice rink, and I think that's where I was going to go. First, I just want to say I think it is a very good design for what we've got, but with all due respect to Jeff and Patrick and everyone here, it's not an ice rink only. It is a community recreation center.

5:12:49 And for those of you who go drop off your kids at the ice rink, I just called it that, I'm sorry, the CRC that we've got right now in the summer, it's exposed, it's on concrete slab. You know, it's great that we have a meeting place like that, but I'm going to talk to staff about doing a little bit better job sale.

5:13:09 Thank you so much.

5:13:47 Good evening, everybody. Thank you again, as always, for all of your time and commitment and effort here. I wanted to, for the record, clarify, I think, what is a misunderstanding amongst the general public, not with council, but I've been approached by a lot of people in the past that have been concerned about the large percentage of these funds that are coming from the general funds.

5:14:16 And for the record, as you know, it's only 8% that we're requesting that's required out of the general fund, which is actually a very small, very modest amount. It's surprising that we can get this done only seeking 8% from the general fund. So with that being said, I want to bring up my latest concerns about the project, and that is that

5:14:45 If this doesn't go forward now, if we don't approve the project as the funds that are outlined tonight or sometime in the near term, I don't think this project's going to go forward ever. I seriously, genuinely believe that because if we can't do it now, I don't know when that's going to happen. We're in a time of strong economic prosperity and if we can't commit these funds at this time,

5:15:16 I'm not sure when that's going to happen. We have gained so much. I want to emphasize the gains that we've made, the commitment that's been made here by this council, previous councils, rec commission, previous rec commissioners, the public, the input for better or worse, the time, the meetings that have been held, the plan your parks, the financial commitment. It's $2 million that we've already spent.

5:15:48 What we paid for the property, looking back, we didn't buy the property to leave it fallow. Something needs to be put there. Otherwise, we could have kept it like Mammoth Creek Park East, just lease it, boom, you know, passive use. But we didn't do that. We spent a lot of money on the property. We've committed a lot of funds to the project already. And we stand to lose all that. We risk losing everything we've gained.

5:16:21 Everything we've committed to this project, it could all go down the drain if we don't move forward. We've rounded the track. We have gotten around the last corner, and we're looking at the finish line. And we've got to move. We've got to go forward. We've got to do this. Otherwise, I realistically don't see it happening.

5:16:47 This isn't a fiscally irresponsible decision. It's not precipitous. It's not well thought out. The staff has done an amazing job of methodically looking at all of our future financial needs, most importantly housing, and the $60 million that's anticipated to complete the housing project at the parcel.

5:17:16 And so this small amount, this 8%, shouldn't make or break that project. And clearly, according to the staff's report, it's not going to. The staff and that report has essentially built us a bridge to cross over to get this project done. I sincerely hope that all of these interests are taken into consideration with the housing needs and the needs of recreation.

5:17:48 And the deferred maintenance and everything else that the staff has addressed. I see this as a completely reasonable request. We need to move forward. We've got to get this job done. Otherwise, I don't see it happening. If not now, when? Thank you. That's all. Thank you. The podium is still open. Good evening, Council. Betsy Truex. I chair the Recreation Commission, and I'm also a community member, obviously, and I'm a parent.

5:18:26 I just want to just add to what Sean and Dan have said and to just reaffirm that this project remains the highest priority for the commission. It has been for several years now and certainly conceptually it goes back much longer than that as I'm sure many others in this room will attest. So you've all seen me here before along with other commissioners. Continuing to advocate for the project tonight is no different.

5:18:54 As others have said, our staff and architects have worked diligently in the face of escalating construction costs in a really volatile bidding environment. We have made a tremendous compromise in the design of the structure, resulting in significant cost savings, but maintaining the identified programming needs. The commission remains committed to making this facility one we can all be very proud of.

5:19:16 I very much appreciate Director Patterson's presentation and this comprehensive agenda item because it lays out all of these items and clearly demonstrates that these are not, they do not have to be either or projects. We know economic cycles are just that, cyclical, and the commission and I very much appreciate the funding that we've received for a long time deferred maintenance needs over the last couple of years. Of course, we're very proud of

5:19:42 The inclusive playground, the community center renovations, all the things we've been able to accomplish in our recent relative period of prosperity. I hope that tonight you will confirm this project and funding as presented without reservation because of the great benefits it will bring to our residents and our visitors. I'd like to close a little more personally. I was first appointed to the commission in 2012 to complete Tony Colisardo's term.

5:20:07 My daughter was entering kindergarten and I welcomed the opportunity to become more involved in my community. Now my daughter is in seventh grade.

5:20:16 Thank you so much. Thank you so much.

5:20:45 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. The podium is still open. Going once, going twice, gone. I will bring it back to the council for comments.

5:21:01 John, would you like to start us off? Yes, Mr. Mayor, I'm comfortable with the representations made by staff for the financing for the project, and I just, I don't know if you want us, I don't know what they need, if they need a consensus, or wait, if this is already into the resolution, technically I don't know how to proceed. If I may on that, ultimately, yeah, we'll be asking for consensus across the council. It will be part of the resolution, and if there's a split vote on that, we'll try to reflect that in the minutes. The resolution has all the budget amendments, so.

5:21:29 We may have to reflect that if there's not full support. Mr. Brown, I'm good with the financing representations as represented. We'll walk through that. I will concur that I am very content with the illustrious sort of layout of the funding here because all of us have a short memory and seeing what the general fund has contributed so far, I think, in the larger scheme of this town and our revenue and at the moment in time.

5:21:59 I think this is a very reasonable contribution. I think that we are, in the rest of this item, paying good note to our housing commitments, so I feel comfortable that we have been able to move strongly ahead with that and continue to do, and that for this to bring us to the 13, the staff has worked really hard, as a couple people said, might have been a bit disappointing, but I have...

5:22:24 Made it a point to try to visit these sprung units across, and I saw a really nice one of these back in the Midwest, and I'm very, very satisfied that this is going to be a great facility, a great asset for our community, a great asset for our youth, so it's time to go, in my opinion. Kirk? This is difficult because when I look at my priorities, this is down the list.

5:22:50 And I look at the capital costs. So Iman Novin, the financial advisor on the parcel, you know, he recommended that even low density at 350 to 400 units is $165,000 per unit. That's based on $440 a square foot. We need to purchase a couple of lots, maybe.

5:23:16 to get in and out of the parcel. I don't think that's necessary. Trash to Nevada, $12 million for this. I would like to see this go forward. Boy, it'd be great if we could eliminate the $920,000 out of the general fund. If that could happen, then I just think, gosh, I mean, it's done.

5:23:38 It's a done deal. But that $920,000 competes. So this gives me a real heartburn, you know, just because there's so many competing, and some of them, you know, we don't have a choice. We're going to have to deal with trash in Nevada, period. We're going to have to deal with some of these things. These budget expenses are coming. So I'd like to see it go forward, yes. I'd like to figure out some way to...

5:24:08 Get that $920,000 not coming out of general funds. I think this 8% general fund contribution to a major recreational facility is nothing. I think that this is leveraging general fund at 92% using other funds. I think it is a great facility as envisioned. The staff has done a wonderful job.

5:24:43 I don't believe we can put all of our money towards just one project ever. I'm not going to go off on the other issues here, but I believe that this should move forward. I congratulate staff on being able to pull this together, and I agree, Dan, that if we don't do this now, it is never going to get done, and that would be an absolute crime for this community.

5:25:12 With that, Dan, do you want to leave this in or do you want to rewrite your... No, we have a resolution that allows this to go forward just based on the council comments. I'm just assuming here, so we may have to have the record reflect that we have the 100,000 for the parks. It sounds like there was five folks for this one. If it's a split vote, we just want to be able to capture that in the minutes. Okay. We can do, but we do have a...

5:25:38 Draft resolution that addresses this if that was a direction from the council. I'm confused. So we're voting on this or we're not voting on this? I will need to have you vote on it. I mean, you can take a consensus right now. We will have a resolution if the majority says to go forward. So I will do exactly what I did last time. Consensus, John? Yes. Linda? Yes. Kirk? Maybe. No. And I am a yes.

5:26:10 Moving forward. Will that resolution come back then? I have it. Yeah, when we get to the end, we'll have you vote on that. Yeah, so we will vote on a resolution that covers everything that we have reached consensus on. So far, I don't have to go amend it, so that's what I was asking. Right. Partnerships. Sorry, I just wanted to pause for a second, so I guess I'll take my time. So the next section. Hold on. Are we?

5:26:50 This is not going along with the packet? It's going along with the packet? It's on page 8 of the packet. You've got to kind of connect the dots, but it's dynamic here. It's dynamic. Page 8 of the packet, we'll talk about the MAC, the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center, and the transit work and next-gen radio systems. The purpose of this section, and yes, the presentation did come together after the staff report was completed, and so there's some minor little pieces that are...

5:27:20 Or maybe shoulder to shoulder, but not quite in line. The section that we want to talk about next is, again, still under the capital and major projects and maintenance projects, but it's under the partnerships realm. And basically talking about the work that we do, mainly with NGOs, but also with Mono County, to try to leverage funds, leverage systems, and allocate funds that support others.

5:27:49 In the end, it's to benefit the community through either enhanced quality of life amenities or other things that we're able to produce with this collaborative effort. So this is really a call-out. There isn't a request in this section, if I can remember it correctly. It's really more of a commitment to this and continuing to get Council's input and make sure that there's commitment to these items.

5:28:16 The number one, as I talked about in my agenda item number nine, where we had carryover items, the Mammoth Arts and Community Center MAC has a contribution from Measure U of $2.5 million. That's still sitting there. That's...

5:28:32 That's still the recommendation both from staff and it's out there. There's a call out for talking about annual programming of $300,000. That has not been expended. But again, it's mainly to talk about the commitments that we have established through these partnerships. But the $300,000 is not something that is a part of the functions of today's budget. The next item in transit, there is some items out there. There's a bus stop.

5:29:02 Within the parking lot of Vons, if it's right, kind of a long black tie in the Vons area, that will need to be relocated. Funding for that has not been established on how that's going to be done. Or I think there's some issues to work out too with, we have the location plan, but there's some discussions and negotiations going on for that. So that's, you know, just acknowledging that those exist, but support of Transit S's work.

5:29:30 As we talked about earlier, we had the additional reserves of $400,000 in support of our transit facility and function and making sure we have dollars available to replace the trolleys and trailers, and as well as the grant match that we had supported for ESTA as they came forward to try to find additional fleet that we did earlier in the year. So again, partnerships is what this section is to talk about. The next-gen radio system.

5:29:59 And the dispatch center. The radio system, we don't have anything recommended at this time. It's unknown exactly how we're going to solve that problem, but by calling it out here is acknowledging that not just us, but regionally, we have a fairly large thing that we need to focus and solve for the near future.

5:30:22 The joint dispatch or the dispatched and joint feasibility study, that has been approved by council and now all four entities, Mono County, Inyo County, and Bishop, City of Bishop, to move forward with a feasibility study, which could, again, going back to the regional partnerships, provide a dispatch center that functions better for all of the entities as well as costing less money. So we think this is a strong approach when we talk about the capital projects and maintenance projects that we have out there.

5:30:52 And we're looking at really continuing those. I think, you know, Council's actions has had their hand on each one of those. Talking about, you know, the Civic Center, we did get support from Council earlier tonight, really to explore the next phases of that, as well as some marching orders, which, again, is really critical for staff to receive that type of information. I mean, we work hard on understanding what our next orders are to get clarification from Council is really beneficial.

5:31:22 And then there's some miscellaneous projects I think Hayes is going to talk a little bit about and how those are sort of designated. Thanks. And this is a big item within a big item. And again, this deserves its own meeting and its own conversation independent of this presentation. But just to get everyone on the same page, what we're talking about is master facilities planning and capital improvement planning.

5:31:49 And when I speak to master facilities planning, I'm talking about long-range planning, 10 years out, 20 years out. What is the hopes, dreams, visions of this community in a plan form? And then the capital improvement plan is really a short-term plan. That is a budget and scheduling tool that we use to program funding dollars that have been allocated to projects.

5:32:15 What we'll be doing with Council in a later exercise is we'll be taking all of the adopted plans, all of the mobility elements, bicycle plans, pedestrian plans, storm drain plans, and trails plans. We've already identified all the projects identified in all of those major plans. Grab walk, bike, ride, forthcoming mobility hub study. Bring all those projects together.

5:32:39 And then we'll put that into a master facilities plan. And then town council can work through funding those projects independently. I will say that our CIP isn't a classic CIP. It's very opportunistic. It's grant funded. It's what we are able to bring into this community. A classic CIP would be you have $10 million in resources every year. How are we going to program that for the next five years? That's how you typically see CIPs done in larger organizations.

5:33:08 We just don't have the kind of funding to make those types of commitments outside of $130,000 and SB1 money that we know is coming and our $580,000 that we have to reserve on an annual basis to repair the roads after each winter. So we don't really have the opportunity to do that long-range planning off of existing dollars. Our CIP is really based on the grant funding that we receive and the opportunities that we create for ourselves.

5:33:34 So again, we'll be coming back to Town Council with a bigger presentation and be looking for more direction on the future of Town Capital projects. I think that's an important note to make, that as we develop these projects, they're not just picking and choosing stuff out, but they actually do relate back to Town's adopted plans, especially those that have had the environmental work done in terms of that plan adoption and how they feed into the informing documents, such as the walk, bike, ride document or our downtown revitalization work.

5:34:06 Even the Housing Action Plan is an informing document versus an EIR approved or environmentally approved document. Real quick on this one, this here is an attachment A of the staff report. It's a summary statement. I don't want to walk through every item on here, but I just wanted this here kind of list out. I think there's 19 projects involved here that we've identified. These issues have come up at different times.

5:34:32 And really, we've tried to touch all these in terms of where we're at to make sure that things are moving forward accordingly. There's a lot of listing here in terms of, you know, our solid waste program, our streets program, our airport program. Those we have funding in place for, just confirming that. Multi-use facility at 3.9, we understand that that's kind of a split discussion here. Fuel tank program, future funding.

5:34:59 We've added money to the deferred maintenance elements there that are noted. We'd like confirmation continuing the funding for the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center, the MAC. The bus stops are moving forward. We do have a relocation of a bus stop we need to address. We're working with the property owners. We don't know the number on that. The next-gen radio system, a rough estimate was $12 million in terms of a project.

5:35:23 That's being refined even this week with the meeting and looking at technology and the other pieces. So we don't know the share of the cost of that to the town yet, and the final number will likely be different as well as we work through that. Rob mentioned the regional dispatch work. We have a feasibility study funded by the four agencies moving forward. We didn't spend a lot of time on the others, like the trailhead improvements and the Whitmore Park improvements, which are really grant-based.

5:35:50 We've Prop 68 money. We have dollars out there. We're seeing that. If we're successful, those projects will come back in accordingly based on the applications we have out. Hayes mentioned earlier the LTC working on dollars for roads and stuff and the potential significant reconstruction of a lot of our MUPs would really bring them up to a standard. Outdoor event site, a lot of discussion recently about that. Lawsuit settled out.

5:36:16 That will be an issue we'll need to look at in the future. Whether or not how much money that will involve the town is unknown at this point as we look into that. And a question was raised a while back, and I forget the setting right off, but on the aquatic facilities, one of the discussions that went with the Community Rec Center. At this point, that's not on our work program. It's a ways out in the future in terms of that perspective.

5:36:40 So this is a summary of 19 different, if you will, I think that's the right count, of projects that have been discussed, they've been talked about at different places, they've come forward. I know Councilmember Stapp has asked me some questions on some of these and tried to nail down that budget element. Frankly, on some of these, we do not know the final number, so I can't give you a budget number. The ones we can, the ones we're asking for, I just said, at this point, I mean, confirming kind of the list here and where we're at, most of these.

5:37:07 Are having some level of work done on them at this point. The ones where we have hard dollar requests, they are noted. If something is totally missing off here, I'd appreciate that. But the other side, if this generally represents the council's perspective, again, I'm not looking for 50 on every single item here walking through that. But this is a very significant work program that we'll be undertaking over the next.

5:37:31 18 to 24 months. And so kind of looking at this and confirming that level of work would be kind of greatly appreciated. Or if there's something missing or if you have any other comments related to any of these items, I'd appreciate that input. Comments, questions? The only thing, I don't know if it belongs on this or it's staff time.

5:38:00 We have had a previous presentation on developing a solar field down on the other side of the airport, and I'm just wondering if we could dedicate some staff time to looking into that, simply because the fact is that, you know, climate change is real, it's impacting us, and at this particular point we haven't done anything. Aspen is 100%, you know, carbon free, and we aren't.

5:38:30 So I'd like to see at least if the council concurs some staff time looking at that open space down there. I don't know if that's BLM property or Forest Service property. That would be the first step to find out who has it. But it's been disturbed. That's where all the tree stubs and everything else was stored for years. Yeah, it's Forest Service property, and then it's within the county. So we'd have to work with those two agencies to look at.

5:39:00 I don't want to add more work to all this, but I'll put a slash by that. The other request we've had off and on is looking at additional, I'm going to call them the type two charging stations in town, a couple of locations for that. We don't have them funded. That hasn't been a high priority, but it is something that we've looked at at a couple places. So I'd say that's in combination with the climate change question and that upcoming issue. So the solar project, and I'd add to that, maybe looking at a...

5:39:24 Type 2 charger station somewhere in town. Find out if there's grants. We can look at those types. I think the thing we learned a lot from the Aspen stuff and how this is all working is it may not be the kind of thing where we have to build something here, but if we can figure out a way to be getting power from sources that are renewable, there's a lot of ways to do this without having to actually go out and physically build something for ourselves.

5:39:52 That has solar fields in that are 50 miles away. Exactly. The idea is to try to create a balance. Yeah, and I think that that may be something that we could start, I'd love to start working with you on that a little bit to figure out some options to bring forward. But I think the Type 2 charging stations that came up at the LTC meeting this week, and that's something we could maybe, to build on this great successful event we have with Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the Wayfinding Project, I mean, I think this is going to affect.

5:40:17 Visitation because of people as electric vehicles. I mean, Ford's coming out with electric vehicles. It's not just going to be Teslas. And right now we don't have a non-Tesla charging.

5:40:28 And I'm totally in support. Yeah. So that's, Dan, I think that that's a project I'd like to see. We can start working on that, the charging stations for sure. And then you and I can maybe start talking about how to do something about this, about the offsets and getting power from other places and even looking at what we could do with the airport. I know Tom Painter has brought up the idea of a project that's very kind of preliminary to do a whole bunch of very interesting things with the airport, having to do with research.

5:40:54 Stuff that they're doing for snowpack surveys. And I'm hoping when we talk about the airport at the meeting in December, I'd like to hope that that's going to be part of that discussion. Even if it's preliminary, it's just, it's an idea, but it's something that could really be helpful as we move forward with the airport. To find a variety of different airports for the uses beyond just, because we had to grow and hold. We've got a lot of opportunity down. There's a lot of things to do with that. Any other questions on that summary list at all? I'm not taking that as a definitive list. No, it's just from a rat today. You guys are working right now?

5:41:23 Yeah, it'll, things will come and go as we have opportunity, but this does give us a work program that we're focused on. Sure. So do you want a consensus on this down the line here, Dan, on the, uh. I just, at this point, just if there's not consensus on an item, I'd rather just have people speak up. Are we good with that list, plus your additions? The type two charging, the additional charging stations. There's a couple there. And the charging station, absolutely. Yep. I'm not saying everybody up there is agreeing with everything on there, but the majority. Yeah. Yeah, I am agreeing.

5:41:54 I mean, when you say agreeing, yeah, there are certain things in here that this is in two different places. Are we talking about this right now, which is also on page 291, the packet that I guess. Yes.

5:42:25 Okay, when we're talking about the radio system, the funding share of the $12 million, I mean, we've already decided that we're still looking into that, but so I'm not at all. I don't know what that's going to look like. I still think there's a better answer out there. There very well could be. We don't know what our part is, so I just want to confirm that. Correct. We have to continue to work on it. I don't know the number. The Civic Center, you know, we just were confirming what we said earlier today. Correct. Okay, and oh, yeah, the other one was a multi-use facility.

5:42:55 In there. Thank you. I'm good. Thank you. Okay, moving on. So, we're going to transition to housing. If you want to take a short break, if you want us to dive through this section. No, we can take a short break. Because you have somebody bringing you a drink. Yes, I do. We will take a short break. Yeah, if you want to take a short break, and then we'll dive into housing. Thank you. Thank you.

5:44:18 This is crazy. I had to go work out.

5:44:48 Okay. Okay, here we are. We are on town. We are on town and partner housing program. Sorry about that. Yeah. But may it section three in the staff report and page 277 is where we'll be starting at. So.

5:45:37 Okay, Dan, go back with that now. You're doing what? It's page 277. It's section three in the staff report. Right. Town and partner housing programs. I'm working off your PowerPoint, Dan. The PowerPoint is the same up there, the focal point. This next section, we really wanted to spend some time on the dollars and the partnerships we've allocated and what we're recommending in terms of moving some stuff forward, working with the town programs, the code updates, and Sandra will touch on those.

5:46:06 We're also looking at that work we're doing with MLH and with the chamber on some elements that way and also setting aside some town dollars for different things. And all of this stuff ultimately feeds back into both what I would call the controlling state document, which is our housing element, and then the informing public document being the community housing action plan. So this really sets us this next section.

5:46:33 We've actually, earlier I mentioned we bifurcated this off so the mayor could stay and have the discussions through this. As we get to touch on the parcel, which has to be separate, Mr. Sauser will need to excuse himself for that discussion. So I'm going to turn to Sandra, kind of walk through where we're at with the partnership programs and some of the elements that build into that.

5:46:55 Thank you. So as you're aware, the town has a multifaceted housing program. Kind of the major component of our housing program is implementation of the housing element. The housing element, as you know, it's a state-mandated...

5:47:10 Element of our general plan. And the state uses it to allocate grant funding, amongst other things. So it's a really important piece of our program. You just approved the housing element in August of this year. And there's a number of actions that we need to take over the next eight years to implement the housing element. Along that, we have the Community Housing Action Plan. And that's really kind of an on-the-ground implementation measure.

5:47:36 of housing in town. So it's not regulated by the state and really kind of looking at some more local focused action items. This town council has allocated funding for housing 1.3 million remains and we're looking for using that to fund creative housing solutions.

5:47:58 Possibly public-private partnerships, something along those lines. But we're kind of trying to work through with our housing coordinator on different options for that.

5:48:07 In the staff report we mentioned a couple of different housing code updates. We will be coming before you at your December 18th meeting to give you a full update on the housing program and kind of an introduction about the code updates we're looking at. But we've seen some barriers to implementation of smaller housing projects.

5:48:30 Not a lot of developers have used the town's density bonus provisions, so we're trying to kind of look into that, see why that has occurred, and see if there's ways that we can make, increase the utilization of that.

5:48:42 Density bonus provision. So looking at also protecting deed restrictions, Mammoth Lakes Housing has put in a request to increase the amount of money in the revolving loan fund, increase another $300,000, so that would be $600,000 total. That money has been used in the past to buy back deed restrictions and preserve them and then resell them. And staff is recommending that that occurs, that $300,000 shift.

5:49:12 So looking at our partners and some of the housing program, you know, some of the work that they're doing right now.

5:49:20 Mammoth Lakes Housing purchased the 238 Sierra Mentor Road project, and they're looking to develop 11 units at that site. So they are looking for grant funding, kind of a variety of different funding sources for that, layering some home funding, possibly CDBG and some other funding. And the town, the staff report allocated.

5:49:43 The staff report outlines that we would be looking to possibly allocate $300,000 for the construction of that if the Mammoth Lakes Housing was short. Another program that they're working on right now is the Missing Middle Program. The town council allocated $101,000 several months back for that program, and that's really intended to provide homebuyer assistance for people who don't qualify for the low-income homebuyer assistance.

5:50:11 And then the Chamber Housing Program, we've funded $149,000 over a three-year time period. The Chamber has been working on that. They provided an update to the Council a couple months back, but their website's up to date, and there's some statistics in the staff report about kind of where they are with their program, and they will be coming back on a quarterly basis to report on that.

5:50:35 And then the last item here is just a summary of our funding commitments for housing. So just kind of showing where we are in total, a little bit over $2 million in our commitments to housing. And then, Dan, I think you wanted to hit on the summary page, the next one? Yes. Just as Sandra just mentioned, as we were talking earlier in terms of balancing a number of projects and priorities, we just were...

5:51:04 The recommendation moves up the current year allocation continuing of $2.1 million for housing. The $1.33 is remaining funding from the $2 million that was allocated before. We did purchase, working on closing on the purchase of the two units at Meridian Court. We're recommending those dollars stay there. As mentioned, allocating additional $300,000 into the revolving loan fund, $45,000 of the general fund.

5:51:33 $180,000 from in-lieu fees and $75,000 from a loan repayment that's in that fund. The other side was the support of MLH, the $300,000 for 238 here at Manor Road should they need those fundings. It helps, I think, in the grant applications if the town is supportive of the project. So we'd be looking at a letter of support for grant applications as well as the funding if that's necessary.

5:51:57 And then also the chamber program. We've allocated $24,000. I think we've actually paid that out. But we're recommending we fully fund that contract, the $125,000. There's $50,000 more this year than the next year and a half. The remainder of that would be paid, knowing that that set aside allows them to continue forward in the projects that they are working on. So the recommendation from a funding standpoint here.

5:52:24 Really is the $45,000 for the general fund into the evolving loan fund, the $180,000 from the in lieu and the $75,000 from the loan payment. Then the $300,000 for the Sierra Manor Road. That would be the recommended funding issues here. If there's any concerns either on the RLF or on the 238 Sierra Manor Road, we'd appreciate that discussion. And looking at, again, this heavier commitment.

5:52:53 From funds into the housing element in terms, and this is all outside of the parcel work, so these are funding for other housing projects and programs that are working and ongoing here in the community. We can answer any questions to that and these areas here for recommended funding. Discussion? Questions?

5:53:26 I think it's with the grants that are coming to purchase. I mean, we would be foolish not to move forward with this. No, not at this time. Thank you. John? I'm good. I think these are the right types of sort of incremental steps, but this is good. I'm going to have a general concern around the destination management plan, which is kind of a

5:54:03 Overall thing that's floating around out there as we start moving things around. I'm encouraged that we're moving things around. But I am very concerned that we kind of move the right, get the right things in the right places to move forward. But I'm supportive of this for sure. Okay. I'm sorry, were you looking for consensus? No. Comment and questions. And before I go to comments, I want to go to anybody in the audience that might want to speak to this.

5:54:32 I had one comment. Can I make it real quick before she... Okay, yeah, one minute. Yeah, come on. Lynda's going to make a comment first. Yeah, I just had a quick comment, and that was that I would love to see us spend this $300,000 on Sierra Manor Road as soon as possible.

5:54:45 Great, yeah, I just, Patricia Robertson, the Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing, I just wanted to say about 238 Sierra Manor Road that we've been securing additional partnerships with other groups in the region, including IMACA, who secured a grant to help with the project, and Mono County Social Services is exploring some funding for the project as well, and the acquisition of this

5:55:13 The land acquisition came with a donation from the seller. So there's a lot of different components and everyone's kind of coming together to make this project happen. So having some funding commitment from the town will obviously help with our grant applications, but it also shows that we're all trying to work together to make this project a reality. So I think that's really exciting.

5:55:38 I mentioned at your last meeting about the revolving loan fund and our limited ability to preserve the deed restrictions that we already have. And so I think increasing, our board believes and I believe that increasing the revolving loan fund so that we can continue to steward the investments that we've already made in affordable housing is a good place to put some money. So thank you. Thank you.

5:56:03 And that was kind of like my one question is when the grant applications are submitted in 2020, how fast is the turnaround on that? Because I think I'm eager for that too. Yeah, so we have a grant application due January 22nd and we should know about the awards in April. And then...

5:56:26 Another application will come out in January, and it will be due in April, so we'll find out about that one probably three to four months after April. Okay, so the July 2020 is pretty much when we're going to know where we stand with the grants. Yes. Okay, cool. Thank you. What are we looking for total to build those 11 units? It's just under $5 million. $5 million? Can I ask what we paid for it?

5:56:52 The acquisition costs were $1.25 and then there was a land donation of $50,000. Thank you. Okay. Any further comments up here? Then I am going to ask you to give me your consensus. John? Consensus? Linda? Yes, sir. Yes.

5:57:32 Okay, we're 5-0 consensus. Now, at this point. So, before you go anywhere on this one, I will ask, the resolution that's in your packet includes a recommendation of a million dollars. It's for the parcel, so I need to pull that out, so I do have an amended resolution that highlights the items here and the other ones that we've had consensus on. I can hand that out to you. We would look for approval of the resolution. The question there would be is if you want the minutes to reflect either a yes or no vote.

5:58:02 Primarily on the one item concern I think was over the funding for the Community Recreation Center. So we do want to be able to capture that if that's a concern so that it's accurately reflected. Right. So when the vote happens, you want those who want to vote differently on that to call it out during the vote, right? Correct. If they were saying...

5:58:26 If I'm voting yes on all items except for that or on all items as presented, that would be beneficial. I think they capture it correctly in the record. So the resolution is the same that's in your packet other than the million dollars for the recommendation that's tied to the parcel is not before you at this point. And you just need a motion to accept this resolution? Actually to adopt it. To approve it. To approve it, right. Right. Do I need to?

5:58:58 So you have to take a second, just look, and then it can get the clarity there. I can walk through any additional detail on it. But I'm sorry we had to bifurcate this out. So I tried to stretch the property to get me my 500 feet, but I'm sorry, I'm looking at what Rob just passed out. Right.

5:59:23 So I would approve the resolution, but on at least one or two of you, the concerns over the CRC, if you want to make your motion reflect that on those items you are abstaining or voting no, that is fine. Then the other items would go forward, which would be the housing program, the 100,000 for...

5:59:43 Different pieces and what have you that way. And the second page of that attachment is the budget amendments that are required to make for the decisions that have been brought forward in item number 10. So what you guys have voted on, those are just the accounting transactions that will be required from the budget perspective. So we usually, the resolution basically authorizes me to make those financial adjustments to the budgets. And that's the purpose of handing you both of those together. So the resolution and the budget amendment.

6:00:14 You would just want a motion to approve this resolution. I think the motion is simple. It's just to approve. From what I've heard, the recommendation would be to approve.

6:00:36 The resolution of the Town Council accepting the special project recommendations for use of fund balance and amending the FY19-20 budget as a title there. Individually, if you wish to vote in favor of the resolution with the exception of items related to a particular project, if you state that, then we can make the record reflect those concerns. Everything else?

6:01:01 The only one I think that I heard a concern on was on the CRC. Everything else seemed to have a 5-0 consensus. So with the CRC, can you advise the two folks who voted no which line items in there are the appropriate line items? Yeah, in there, they'll call them out. So item two, it talks about the transfer of capital to CRC project, the transfer again for that. And so each item on here, we're at reference to CRC. It's both sides of the accounting equation.

6:01:32 Right. Yeah. Correct. They don't want to vote to move money. That's the option. I mean, one option would be for somebody to make a motion to approve the resolution and just see if you end up with enough votes. Okay, Mr. Mayor, I'll make a resolution that the Town Council, Town of Mammoth Lakes, accept and approve resolution. Is it a resolution number? Okay. Entitled?

6:02:08 Accepting the special project recommendations for use of fund balance fiscal year 2018-19 and amending the fiscal year 2019-20 budget as presented by staff. Motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Yes. So either I can vote yes on everything or no on everything or...

6:02:36 You could make the statement that you'd like your vote to reflect no on the items related to the Community Recreation Center and yes on all other items. Okay. That's okay. You guys aren't setting me up for success here. Specifically...

6:02:59 If I pull out some of these numbers, you're saying that it'll still reflect a no vote? It depends on what you say. If you vote in favor of the resolution, you could say, but I'm opposed to those two things, but you're still voting in favor of the whole resolution, or you could vote against the resolution and say, this is why I'm voting against the resolution. There's not really a great way to do a partial yes or a partial no, but as Jamie said correctly, the record does reflect that you were opposed to those items.

6:03:32 Any further deliberation? Jamie? Yes, with a no on... I could be getting some of this wrong. Anything related to the CRC program. If I can do that, then I'm good with that. Thank you. Yes, with heartburn. Yes. Yes. Yes. It passes with heartburn and one no vote, if I understand it correctly. But that's perfect.

6:04:14 Now we will take another break because at this point I have to recuse from the next section. So I will be leaving all of you good folks. Okay, let's get this going and bring this up here. So on to parcel funding. Dan, are you going to leave this on? Yes, I am. Thank you.

6:10:11 And just given the lateness of the hour here, I'll shorten some of this up and some of it may have to come back for some additional direction of discussion, but we want you to be fresh. This is a very significant issue in terms of funding the parcel. I won't go through all the background. You've seen that several times. The two elements we've looked at at this is, one, looking at, first of all, a strategy to solve kind of funding gap on the parcel project. We have both a short-term and long-term proposal.

6:10:41 The funding need on the overall parcel, pick your number, but it's $60 million plus or minus depending how many units and how many grants and other things that go into play. We know that we're really going to have to look at that. But again, the timing's unknown in terms of the phasing. Ultimately, when we get a development team on board and we're working with them, they will have a strategy as well to move this forward. It'll depend on the ultimate grant structure, tax credits, other resources.

6:11:10 And so what we're dealing with right now is an estimate. So if we say we need $60 million, understanding that's going to be a plus or minus number. If we hit it right at $60, I'll be totally amazed. And then the other thing, the strategy side of this, I've taken a look at this to say if we had to, could we fund something like this out of our current revenue streams? Not saying that's probably the most ideal solution, but could we do that? So we took a look at that to say what could happen if we did that.

6:11:40 Looking at a TOT commitment and also a property tax share via tax requirement financing that would require county participation. We saw some earlier, several hours ago, talking about a tip district potential. We'd have to negotiate the county, obviously, and we're hoping they have a common goal of housing, and so that may be a potential. So I really want to look at the first phase. We've had a, sorry.

6:12:09 Which of the guys, Eman? Eman. Eman. Eman. Eman. Eman Development Group looking at a potential phasing plan, looking at a first phase that would have an estimated public funding gap that we'd need to step into in the $7.5 million plus or minus range. The assumptions that went into that was 138 plus or minus units, variety of sizes, looking at grants, tax credits.

6:12:36 Other revenue sources. They're walking through all that, and this would be a detail level. A little confusion there, but they assume that first phase project was a $60 million project. They have about $53, $52 million identified in funding. I vacillate on that a little bit because part of that was like a half a million or so, assuming that they would not pay impact fees on the affordable housing, the town fees. So that's in there.

6:13:03 The idea would be if you had funding committed by fall of 2021, that September-October timeframe, go out, get sticks on the ground, and ultimately could have units occupied in 2024. Kind of a rough element. We wanted to get a feel for what would it take to look at to get a phase one done. As I say, once we get a full development team, I'm assuming this will change somewhat.

6:13:31 The other next big project for us on the town side will really be to complete the environmental work. We have an estimate there of $300,000 to be able to do that. So next slide. The element there for this first phase is $7.5 million plus dollar amount we may need.

6:13:50 We are recommending, and this would be the other resolution we passed out, another additional allocation of a million dollars is kind of the remaining piece out of the current fund balance numbers. I think there's $36,000 left. That we would come back and say we need $300,000 for the EIR work and commit $700,000 at this point to the first phase of that development. We're starting to set money aside systematically so that we actually can...

6:14:17 Hit the ground running when we have a development team on board. The other more policy question here is looking at a potential pre-commitment of excess or additional TEOT over revenue, revenue over our budget. That would be looking at the next two years, the current year we're in right now and 2021. I think there's some assumptions obviously building here, but we're assuming there could be a generation of between $8.2 and $6.2 million.

6:14:46 Again, assuming revenue similar to what we've been achieving today. Again, we also look at the waiver of impact fees for that. If you take a look at recent historical perspective, if you look at the staff report, on page 18 of the staff report, or page 284 in the whole packet, this information here,

6:15:10 Kirk had asked for a follow-up on some allocations of previous TOT revenues and where they were spent and how we handled that. This is a summary that we put together for that purpose. It's all the detail of this we presented to Council a while back. But if you look at the last four years, we're generating about $18 million a year. The low was $15.7 million, the high being this year $20,100,000 in the report. It's actually the final is about $20,200,000.

6:15:38 And so we're looking at that revenue. If you take a look at how that's been utilized in the past, it's very similar to what we did earlier this evening. There's dollars in the restricted areas, tourism, transit, and housing, one-time money for housing. There's a number of other dollars in here that we have put into various areas, be it capital equipment, snow removal costs, a number of different areas, building up our reserves, all of those types of things. So utilizing this as a base, that question would be of that.

6:16:07 Being able to look at a future piece at that $18 to $17 million in an estimated total, why don't you go ahead and jump the slide, a total allocation. If we went into the current year budget and said, we think we're going to hit, yeah, this would be great. If we're going to hit $17 or $18 million in total revenue, we have a town budget, it's already set at $13.5.

6:16:34 And we need to live within our means for that operating budget. There's a piece of that $13,500 that goes to the town. There's a piece that goes to housing, transit, and tourism. And then the remainder piece falling out here will be showing that going to the parcel. And I do it next year, assuming an increase in the budget to $14,250. Again, that's a rough guess at this point. And then the same allocation down through that.

6:17:00 And so the areas where we have political commitments, we'd be retaining that base allocations to them. The budget change here, and you'd want to talk to each of our partners on it, would be that what has been an excess dedicated reserve to those three areas would go to the parcel first, at least up to that $17 or $18 million. If there's money over that, then that would be a council discussion. Do you want to put it back into those partners or other places?

6:17:27 And again, I run the two scenarios here, given flow start to the winter, maybe with the snow, but we've had another record summer, so we're going back and forth on that. If we commit $700,000 as recommended from current year funds, if you will, and then if you took either one of those scenarios on the chart here, either at a $17 million or $18 million total, fix the town budget accordingly,

6:17:57 You would generate between 6.9 and 8.9 million in revenue for the project as we go forward. And if we give up on impact fees, that could be another half a million dollar swing in that category. So when we look at that element on there, and we're looking at, again, not a hard known number for our first phase, but probably worst case seven and a half on the low end on up, maybe eight or nine million.

6:18:26 Difficult political choice here in terms of our budget process. We are still saying from an operating budget, we are very conservative. $13.5 for the current year from TOT, $14.250 for next year. The real question here is a give up or a trade off for housing is would you be willing to commit excess reserves that would otherwise go to transit, housing, and tourism?

6:18:51 Housing may be a little offset because we are funding it on housing, so maybe that's the easiest one to do, but to be able to do those elements. This does not touch the current reserves, for example, for MLT. We still have a million plus sitting there. I think some of that's been, we'll go through that and make sure the part for the event piece is covered in there. It may be in those dollars, making sure that that is still covered in that. But there is, we're not asking for any existing dollar allocations to be shifted.

6:19:20 From those areas into this particular structure. If we're able to do that, I think that allows it for the next two years, and again, we'd review this coming year in, you'd review it walking the next year, but we'd want to be able to work with our development team that comes up board and says, we have committed to generate somewhere between, you know, $7 million plus up to maybe $9 million to get a first phase of the project funded.

6:19:47 I have to be able to move something forward, get sticks in the ground, and hopefully to have people in homes in 2024. I think that's been a prior from the council to move that forward. Again, the next heavy lift will be, what about phase two, three, four, five, how many phases that get built into that? And so I would like to pause a little bit here and ask that question in terms, if the structure for the first...

6:20:14 Phase, these first couple of years, if this is viable, again, we'll have more work to do, but it would allow us to be able to commit to a development team that we are serious about setting money aside and meeting that first financial gap, if you will, what we believe we'll see in a phase one. Again, we don't know absolutely that number, but we know it's not going to be free. Okay, so questions for staff. Kirk?

6:20:44 It's the funding gap. Because, you know, we just, we had a funding gap on the month, you know, of $920,000. So it's almost like we need to have a discussion and prioritizing of looking at, you know, I go down, I keep adding to this list. We keep pointing to, you know, from the parcel to the, and there's been discussion about buying.

6:21:14 Well, this is the parcel. I think when we talk about funding, we've got to talk about

6:21:43 You know, the towns, you know, where we're going in several areas. But in regards to this discussion right now? I think we need to move forward. Housing is critical. Again, I'm looking at this and I'm saying, okay, how are we going to figure this out? But moving forward, yes. Figuring out the budget is another whole discussion. Okay. All right, thanks. Cleland? Yeah.

6:22:12 More questions for staff? Okay. John, questions for staff? I don't have any questions, but when it comes time for a motion, I need to have some discussion. Okay. So I'm going to ask for a public comment at this point. Yeah. Public comment? You do have some. Hi, again. John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I think we all recognize that the housing issue is a big one, and I think that it greatly affects the guest experience when we don't have enough staff or we don't.

6:22:47 The staff that we have gets tired and unfortunately doesn't provide great experience. That's the reality of where we are. I think that there was a good clarification here that I wasn't fully aware of that the existing funding that's in the account would still be available. It's more the future opportunities with what's going on in the account right now.

6:23:07 And moving forward. So I think that I would like to request that either Dan or Rob or both come to our December 4th board meeting and at least give a brief presentation to our boards that they understand.

6:23:21 That there's still funds out there because we did, we didn't get an allocation towards future events, but we've got Caroline Casey working very, very hard on bringing in some big events that we still need some funding for. And I think that if that pot is still there and that there's still an opportunity to present that to council, I think that the board should agree to that and believe that that's a good use of it. So I think in the grand scheme of things, I think it's the right direction for us. Thank you.

6:23:51 Any other comments? Okay, see none. Yeah, if we could make one other comment quickly before you come back to the council on it and a little bit discussions that a couple things are in the works that we're working on. One is, you know, we're working on a destination management plan looking at what does our future look like? And one of the elements in some of the pre-work on this, again, we don't have any draft documents ready. I'm hoping that'll be before you in February.

6:24:21 The element on one of the overarching themes through part of that is that we do have to address our housing situation almost regardless of the scenario and the direction we take in terms of being able to provide that quality visitor experience, and John expressed it very well there. We know we have other challenges in there in terms of our guest experience, be it too many people in the Lakes Basin to...

6:24:45 You know, just the over challenges in the town and the other impacts we have and peak days and all those types of things. So we want to make sure that fits that project is underway in terms of the initial part of that. I don't want to get too far out in front of that because I think it will inform some decisions when we come forward. We have a parking study in the downtown that's underway and working. That's going to come back and inform some of this. It may help actually with some of the discussions on parking in the parcel.

6:25:13 It allows us to look at this. My real desire here is looking at this two-year window is we get the environmental work done, we identify money for a phase one project, and we're actually really be able to make some, I think, good momentum on this project. The last thing we want to do is bring a team on board and say, yeah, by the way, we're not sure how we're able to help you. I just, we don't want to be in that position, that element of that.

6:25:42 There's other elements in the staff report talking about longer term funding. I can touch on that briefly a little bit later, but given late of the night, if we don't want to get into that tonight, we can push that off until a later date. The question before Council at this point that we are asking for consideration is a commitment of a million dollars, current revenue for the two elements we mentioned there, and then direction, I think, on that pre-commitment of the TOT revenue. That's going to take a little more work. We're going to have to come back and...

6:26:11 Highlight that. But I think that allows us to have a pot of dollars at least. I hate to use it theoretically, but there are dollars there that we can come back and spell that a little better, I think, and say, here is how we get to some dollars to move a project forward. And frankly, I mean, if you looked at 2024 and said we have 138 plus or minus units out of the ground that our people are actually living in, I think that would be a huge win for this community. Exactly. So what we're being asked to do in this resolution,

6:26:42 Is to allocate that $1 million from the 18-19 general fund into housing. Yeah, into housing would be for the first phase of the parcel. But if we only spent $250 on EIR, $50,000 would go into the $700 if it costs us $3.25. Maybe we have to take that out of the $700 number. But $1 million into the parcel project fund, if you will. Okay, so let's take this resolution then first. Is there any questions on this resolution to staff?

6:27:11 Yeah, so is the resolution just number one? Just number one. So what is number two? Number two, I'm looking for direction. Okay. And then we would bring that back. Those are two separate things. So let's take the resolution. Two separate. Sure. Okay, so you're okay? Quick question on the resolution? Yeah, I support number one. That's going to be an interesting discussion on number two. Okay, so call for the motion. You know what? Did you ask public comment? Sorry, I'm lost. Yeah, I thought we did. John, did you want to? John did, yeah, sorry. I'll make a motion to.

6:27:42 Increased general fund transfer out to capital for the parcel. Is that approved? Just approved the front page of that at the top. Oh, okay. Okay. Approved the resolution accepting the special project recommendations for use of fund balance 2018-19 and amending the 2019-20 budget. Then do I need to say item one? Okay. Second. Go ahead.

6:28:12 I second the motion. Okay. First and a second. Jamie? Oh, I'm sorry. Any more comments? Discussion? Nothing? Okay. Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. So now you would like us to take what format? So the question here was really looking at is there direction that would be a

6:28:40 For lack of a better term, I would call it a pre-commitment of future TOT revenue up to a dollar amount to support the first phase of the development of the parcel project.

6:28:50 This would be just for basically money this year and next year, the only two elements that we'd be looking at committing. It could impact and likely would in terms of the allocations to the areas of political commitment between housing, transit, and tourism. So just those two years? Just the two years, yeah. We're not longer term or some other issues, but I think we need to spend more time and be more fresh to deal with that. Okay. All right, questions for staff? I just think it's a broader discussion than just that.

6:29:24 Yes, but on the other hand, we can talk this to death. So, that's... Well, I know, I agree going forward with what we've already approved. We're talking about, you know, this commitment, you know, and its impact on our future budgets and everything else. It's going to be huge. Yeah, it is. And that's why I say it's a broader discussion. Yeah. And the number here is just...

6:29:54 This year, next year only. It's not the next 15 years as some of the other processes. Okay, so this is my thoughts on this. As a general idea, I understand staff's logic and rationale for doing this. However, this is a very risky move. I don't mind taking risks, but this is a very risky move. And this, we talked about our budget discipline before.

6:30:22 In the six years I've been on council, we've never done anything even remotely like this. Okay. So it's risky, but I appreciate the need for action. I appreciate the need to have, if we bring a developer on board, which we should have in January, February, right, for the RFQ, they're going to need to have some money to work with, so it makes sense that we have some resources to make this happen. However, I think we need to look at this as being very clearly stated that this is only for...

6:30:50 These two years. I think we need to be very clear to say that any money that comes in in excess of this goes back to the reserves. It's not because you mentioned what you said before was kind of open-ended. But it counts the directions. That's the direction. I like it. Okay. So I would say if anything above and beyond this go back into the reserves, I would like to understand what the contingency plan is going to be if we have two absolutely dead winners. Because when we're talking about TOT, you're not talking about a reliable funding source.

6:31:18 Who knows what might happen? What kinds of commitments are we going to be making on money that we don't know that we're going to have? I'd like to understand what that looks like. And I think I'm interested in the risk. I like taking it. But I think that the destination management plan has to be a part. And I'm not comfortable moving forward with this until that framework with the consultant that we have an opportunity to lay that out.

6:31:48 And to inform contracts with Mammoth Lake Tourism and others, because at this juncture, the equity, the money that we're spending to make these things happen is coming from our place, which is our most fundamental asset.

6:32:05 And if we're not investing back into our asset, we are compromising our ability to collect more of this money in the future. I don't mind making this move. I think it's something we need to do. It's a risky move, but I think we should take it. But I'm not comfortable taking it until the council has had.

6:32:21 My understanding was to be a workshop with the council, with a consultant to establish a framework for our values and principles around what our destination plan is going to look like going forward so we understand how we're going to make sure we're not just extracting from our environment and our place equity that we're not going to be able to get back down the road because we spent two years doing this and the condition of our destination gets further deteriorated.

6:32:49 So those are my thoughts. So what I'm hearing is sort of a lukewarm pre-commit of the TOT revenue above base. And if that's a good place to stop for this evening, then I think that saves our brains. Because in the original staff report, there was a very, very robust discussion of all the other possibilities of funding, which I think are beyond our capacity this evening. Yeah, we need to come back on our fresh...

6:33:16 Yeah. And so I think what I'm hearing is a strong interest in this pre-committing of TOT for the two years only. And then that will give us time then to get a builder developer on board, talk more about options, explore more of a lot of the things that were laid out here and move forward. But that gives us a step forward at least into the first phase, it sounds like. Yeah. Yeah, if I can address the risk piece, because this has been, this has been.

6:33:44 We're ahead of last year's.

6:34:09 If I could, one PSPS event, December 28th. I get it. I'm serious. I mean, that's not out of the question. So I understand the risk. What I want to say is to shield against that. One is, yes, we are pre-committing dollars to that level. We haven't gone to the developer and said, we will write you a $6 million check. Obviously the dollars aren't there. We will tell them, instead of...

6:34:36 People moving in 2024, they may be moving in 2025. We have flexibility there. But what I didn't want to do is bring somebody on board and saying, we're a partner here, $700,000, anything else, we have no idea. I don't think that's a great partnership to be able to walk into. Fully understand the risk we're taking. And again, in the same issue there, going to the town budget and our partner budgets, we're keeping that.

6:35:03 Conservative on purpose. So there's room in there. Maybe if we don't hit it, maybe this year we hit more, next year we don't. Maybe it's down this year. Fully understand that risk. Do that. But I want to be able to bring a partner on and say, we're serious about getting this done.

6:35:20 And I think I'm hearing that. Again, you'll have another bite of this apple, obviously, through that process. And who knows? They could come in and say, the first phase, we're going to shrink it down and we only need $5 million. So when is the balance this agenda item going to come back? Is there a next meeting? I'll look at that and see if there's enough. I want to make sure we have the time to digest it. So let me figure that out. And also, when is a date for this destination management? The last discussion I had with the consultant was February and I hadn't nailed down the first or second meeting. So I just...

6:35:49 I will nail that down. I appreciate it. Let's get that nailed down. Let's get that. I think that's a priority because if we're going to start moving these big things around, we need to get that. We need to know what we're doing. To Kirk's point, we need to know kind of where we're going, at least from a policy perspective, this is where we're going. And my guess is that's more than one meeting. It's a workshop. It's a discussion. It's going to be okay. Got all your input. Whatever it takes. And in the meantime, filling in the information that would be helpful in that discussion, like a discussion that's already been held with the...

6:36:17 The county and some things like that just to see. Yeah, and we can follow up on some of this stuff in here. We'll see some of that work. Because a lot of those items, it would involve an initiative, a referendum. So we've got to, you know, move on that because. Yeah, if you want to do a voter initiative, we need to bring that piece back and what type of tax measure or not or that weights to the destination management plan we can do. But we need to have those discussions. Just one other technical request. If we could, if staff is going to put a PowerPoint, it would be very helpful.

6:36:46 That the PowerPoint is directly in sync with our documentation. Yeah. I think we all spend a lot of time reading this, taking notes, and when the PowerPoint is out of sync with what we've got here, it just makes it challenging. Just appreciate if we keep these things in sync. But on the other hand, this was a very complete, great, you know, great bunch of information, and you guys worked hard on it, and that's noted, including this today, so thank you. Appreciate the discussion and the direction. It's been a heavy lift, and we got a long ways.

6:37:15 Hi, everybody. Good work tonight. Let's do this again in two weeks. So, if there's any... Why not? Thanks. Council member... If you want to have... Oh, I'm sorry. It doesn't really want to do council member reports. All right. We're done. No, I think we're done. Okay. All right. Thank you very much. Good night. Thank you very much. Thank you all. Have a wonderful holiday. Yes. Thank you. I look forward to getting together when we get back. Yeah.

6:37:44 I'm leaving, I started driving tomorrow at the 6th. Dan, thank you very much. Have a wonderful holiday.