TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2019

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board Special meeting

· recording 23 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

44 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:58 Muted over there, yeah. Okay. Let's go ahead and call the meeting to order five minutes after two. Thank you, everybody, for being here on short notice. We really appreciate it. John Morris, Scott McGuire, Rhonda Dugan, Jeremy Goyko, Matt Hammer, here. Michael Ledesma, here. Linda Salcido, here. And Eric Clark, here. Thank you. Okay, great. We'll go ahead and move to public comment. Oh, hey, Jeremy.

3:40 Okay, seeing no public comment, we'll table the minutes and new business. So what we're here to discuss is talk about MLT support and future funding for the parcel. And we did have a brief TBID committee meeting on Monday.

4:04 What is today? Today's Monday. Last week. Friday. Friday. Thank you. Boy, it's been a whirlwind. And we discussed some TBID issues, but we talked a little bit about this issue as well, which spurred this meeting today. So what I'd like to do is actually have Dan. I know, Dan, you've got to go, so I'd like to have you present for a minute if you could talk to us a little bit about funding and so forth. Yes, thank you, Dan Holler, town manager. I'm sorry. Yeah, we have a...

4:32 Conference call going with Airbnb on related issues. So anyway, in terms of a discussion with town council, we had a lot of discussion regarding funding for the parcel project and housing in terms of the needs in the community. The recommendations that we took to council last week and we had concurrence to moving forward on that, we'll come back with a policy item to confirm that. But one was an allocation of current dollars, a million dollars set aside for that, $300,000 for

5:00 EIR work we're going to assume we're going to have to undertake here shortly, and $700,000 going into the first phase of the project. The $700,000 number helps tie into a very preliminary discussion on our first phase project cost. It could be as far as needing additional funding outside of grants and those types of things in the $7.5 to $8 million range pending on

5:24 Some of the other elements that are projected to come into that. So the request of Town Council was how do we get the first couple of years of this in place? Funding-wise, we're looking at that term before it come under construction. The idea would be to have people in homes in 2024.

5:38 First phase, so we're out of little ways. The request was to look at the pre-commitment, if you will, of excess TOT dollars that could go into the housing component. Those excess dollars would include, you know, first of all, you'd have a set budget like we do now for the town. We're at $13,500 this year, and next year the projection was $14,250. So it'd be working on the current year and next year, the two years that we were looking at. The element there would be to put any excess TOT.

6:08 into that up to a set amount of $17 million or $18 million were the two numbers we looked at, a minimum looking at if you had a $17 million hit, everything up to that, this excess over the normal allocations to our political commitments and to the town itself would go to the housing fund, if you will. The goal on that would be in those two years to be able to generate between $6.2 to $8 million in terms of being able to fund that.

6:36 Initial phase of the project. It does not impact current reserves set aside either whether it's restricted for MLT or transit or housing, the three areas for that. And I'm going to forget the number. There's a million plus in the MLT fund. It's actually about a million four with some commitments or a little better than that. So we'd want to walk through that. And the majority of the revenue that's sitting there, I believe, is a big chunk of it's already.

7:04 committed to various things. And so we don't want to impact that anything that's been committed. And frankly, the current reserves in there from a staff perspective would be to leave that committed to the tourism side. So give some flexibility as you look in the next year or two. But the idea on that was the priority of the housing and needing that was how do we start to reach out to the various development groups? And we had a pre-meeting this past week, good turnout, about 12 firms represented of an interest in the project.

7:32 And part of that is saying, yes, we're committing dollars for that first phase so it can get rolling and make that happen. I think that's a huge statement to some of the developers that do this for a living, looking at that, saying the town's serious about moving this project forward. So that includes committing the land, basically, with no expectation of financial return on the dirt. The idea would be over the next two years, we'd have somewhere between $7 and $8 million that could go into a phase one project.

8:00 So, and then on top of that, you'd have waivers and fees and things of that nature that soft costs to go into that. I think the key issue here would be that it's that pre-commitment of, not would be the base budget, but the excess over top of that base allocation to, in this case, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, at least for the next two years, that would be pre-committed into the housing project.

8:21 And the two-year window was done on purpose looking at that. If we want to come back and look at a tax measure, we want to look at other ongoing sources. That actually gives us time to do that, whether we look at a 2020 or a 22 election. If we have to go for a special tax, that would buy time to do that. If we have to look at additional commitments in the future, if it's all in town, then we'd come back and have those discussions. Also having discussions with...

8:46 The county in terms of potential EFID type structures or tax increment financing structures. So trying to bring other partners into the table. The key element here was what type of commitment can we make to a phase one development in order to help entice, if you will, an affordable housing developer and team that's serious about moving a project pretty quickly into the community and getting them on board. I'm going to say the February, March time frame. So we actually have a project up and running at that point.

9:14 And again, the pre-commitment of dollars would be the request for consideration here, at least to the next, I'll say two years, the current year excess and the next fiscal year, so it's those two fiscal years, would not impact current reserves and again, would, you'd have a little bump next year based on what we're projecting for a base town budget. So I can answer any quick questions on that? Just a quick question, Dan. So the, would the first year of these

9:39 Excess reserves be the end of this fiscal year, 1920? Correct. Yeah, so what we're in right now is to be 1920 and 2021, and then if you went to a voter initiative in 22, then that would be the, going forward there, or if you went 20 would be the earliest, November 20 would be the earliest that we could look at from an election standpoint, if we go to a dedicated tax measure, which again hasn't been decided at this point, but that'd be back for council discussion, probably more than on one occasion.

10:09 To be able to have that discussion. So, and then the current dollars that are sitting in there would continue to be in the reserve. I'd say the vast majority of that's been committed, if I'm going through my head. Some of the numbers we didn't have the other night, but I think the vast majority of that has been pre-committed. There's not a whole lot of excess. There'd be some of it. So, that's not something we're relying on. So, any other questions or clarifying comments? Linda can fill in the gaps you reserve.

10:37 So that commitment to the housing and the priority of that particular project with the parcel, obviously. Any other questions for Dan? I know he's got to go. Thanks. Thank you very much. Thank you. Sorry, I need to split. Thanks for the update. Appreciate it. So hopefully that helps. Thank you. Thank you very much for the deliberation. Appreciate it. All right. So with that, we kind of knew that that was the case.

11:05 So one of the things that we had talked about, it was not necessarily on the TBID subject, but in our little TBID meeting, our committee meeting we had was the, well, obviously it was a very passionate discussion, I'd say, and we all agreed that, you know, housing is absolutely the number one issue that's, whoops. We lost Mark. Okay. It's the number one issue that's facing all of our businesses. We all know that getting people to, trying to get people to stay to,

11:35 Trying to hire people, excuse me, in our businesses is virtually impossible right now because of the housing shortage. So we had a lot of discussion about that. And part of what we threw out there was we kind of knew that this was coming. And we felt like we wanted to get out in front of this problem a little bit more. And to be honest, give Mammoth Lakes Tourism a little bit better PR. We'd like to allocate more than just the two years to this. We'd like to discuss.

12:03 More like four years of the reserves going to housing because let's face it, it's not going to be solved in two years and there's going to be more money that's needed in two years. And financially, we're in pretty good shape. Budgets are good for MLT and I think we've got a lot of the projects that we've got lined out for MLT are already in place. We don't really have anything new that we're specifically looking at. So allocating those excess dollars.

12:32 directly to housing for, you know, if we can go, if we can double what the town's essentially asking, not asking for, but redirecting, and we can double that, I think that looks, makes us look a little better. It's not, the main, the emphasis of that is mostly because it's needed. You know, it is needed. We've got to be able to get people to move here, live here, and...

12:54 You know, take up the jobs that we have that are empty. So that's kind of the gist of why we haven't held the meeting. We want to discuss that and see what the overall pleasure of the board was and try to move forward and kind of get out in front of this a little bit with some good positive PR. So with that, I'll turn it over for discussion. I just said, thanks, John. As a part of the committee in the meeting last Friday, you know, we've been talking about this initiative on and off.

13:26 Either in meetings or one-on-ones, outside of meetings, the issue of housing in Mammoth Lakes. And for me, it's more an available housing issue than it is an affordable housing issue. And I know that sounds perhaps nuanced, but I think it's an important distinguishment because when we talk about people living in cars, they can afford to pay their share of a one-bedroom in a four-bedroom house or a studio apartment.

13:54 Residence is not available for them, correct? It's an availability issue. I don't think our rents are that much higher than Southern California rents or any other areas. There just is no inventory available. And I think it sends the wrong message to say affordable because that implies, in my opinion, that we have a lot of housing available, but it's just not obtainable. It's not affordable. It's not accessible. So for me, it's an available issue, and I know we've had this discussion on and off over the years.

14:23 And I think it's important for us to, in the conclusion that we came to on Friday that we've also come to in the past is that this is an issue that greatly impacts the business community. So it is an issue that we, in terms of visitation, customer experience and everything else, this is something that's, it impacts every business in this community to the extent that you can or cannot obtain and keep and retain employees and so forth.

14:52 I fully support the move, I think, our leadership and our allocation of these dollars to the community in a way that also supports our charter. It's all in line, and I personally remain entirely in favor of the move. I'll add to that a little bit. Thanks, Michael. That was well said.

15:21 The crisis, it's not a crisis, but the challenge that we have in front of us is real, and it's going to continue to be real, just like you said, John. There's going to be money needed to help solve this for many years to come. And when we look at it from a mountain perspective, we currently have 530 beds, roughly. They're full right now.

15:46 and we are unable to promise anybody a bed at this point in time so they're living in cars as well and as we look at our funding mechanisms and we see that we have this joint reserve with the town and we know that we're being successful with

16:08 attracting tourism already to our community. I think that applying these funds to this challenge is absolutely appropriate and will benefit us all in our industry, the tourism industry here in the community. So I'm in all favor for it as well. Any other discussion? I would echo the exact same thing. I have, between my two businesses, 40 employees, and 20% of those employees are living in their cars.

16:39 Because there is not an availability. I had one employee put in for a room in a house, and there were 50 people for the same room. Obviously, like, I'm calling people, this guy's amazing, this lady's fantastic. We cannot run successful business and give our tourists the service and the quality that I would like to get without more employees.

17:09 Without the available housing. So I 100% agree. This is something that we need to dive into as hard as we can. I think this is an excellent way to do it. And that's a great point about the car thing. Even if you have an employee that's got the best intentions, it's difficult living in a car. Having not done it myself, I can imagine how difficult it must be. And, you know, hard to come to work with more of a...

17:37 Smile on your face and a positive attitude when you're dealing with that situation. So getting those people into available housing is going to make their lives a whole lot better and happier, more comfortable and so forth. And that certainly makes better staff for all of us, I would think. So, yeah. So I guess, do we want to motion? Yeah, and I think just to throw one more thing in here, I think when we talk about going from two years to four years, the total potential.

18:07 for the contribution from this fund is $4 to $6 million, really. You know, I think if you look at where we are even currently with the first three months of the fiscal year in the books, the tourism reserve for this year is already at $300,000, $400,000. I mean, it's, we're ahead of last year, we're ahead of budget, and I think that realistically it's probably a million to a million and a half dollars a year moving forward that would go back to this cost. So when Dan says that the goal is to get, you know, $7.5 to $8 million in the first couple of years, I think we can get there.

18:35 Realistically, and probably a little bit on the positive side, and then to the point of the fact that this isn't going to go away after two years, it's imperative that we continue that with at least the two-year extension to it. I think that really shows a commitment to our business community and the fact that we recognize that this is the number one issue for most of our employers.

18:56 And I think that long term, and at council last Wednesday night, I mentioned that the biggest challenge is when we don't have the housing and we don't have the employees, your employees are working overtime, it's costing you more money, they're getting burned out, and ultimately in the long run, no matter how great the employee is, they're going to suffer in the service side because they just get burned out. So this is a very important piece for us to...

19:21 Build for our future and make sure that we can remain successful because it's great that we have a ton of people coming here, but if they start having poor experiences, then we're going to go backwards and we don't want to do that. Yeah. And I think the idea, of course, with the four-year deal is that even though council is already looking at just a two-year, hopefully this gives them a little bit more to look forward to of those years, not having to kind of recalibrate, maybe that changes some things. Obviously, the amount of the overage is going to depend.

19:50 You know, on what kind of years we have. Also, how council does their budget. If, you know, if we go from 13.5 to 18 for a town budget, there might not be much overage, but that would be good because the funds would be used during the year and whatever. That's fine. So that's, of course, council's discretion and town's discretion, how they do that. But I think it's just, yeah, I think we're all in agreement. It's a good move. We all know what the situation is and it certainly is something that...

20:16 That I feel personally that there's always a lot of question about exactly what does MLT do? How did they spend the funds? That sort of thing. And I just think this is an extremely good, positive use of funds that the community will be happy about. It's a really good move for us just to do this. So with that, can we get a motion? Anybody like to make a motion? Craft one? It should be pretty simple.

20:46 The wheels are turning in Michael's head. Yeah. What's the appropriate motion? The language? Anybody? I can take a stab at it if you guys want me to. I would make a motion that we vote to dedicate the excess TOT, which would normally go into reserves for the next four years, to housing. Pure and simple.

21:21 The housing. Does it need to be stated that it's specifically for the parcel? Or is it just housing in general? Because my understanding was that it's specifically for the parcel. Am I wrong? That's how it was put together in the agenda item, which we didn't actually get to that piece of it. We kind of, you know, ended before that. But that was what was in the discussion. I'd like that to be clear. Because I want this going towards the parcel. I want that.

21:50 To be made clear. I can restate. Does that make sense? Yeah. I'll be happy to restate then. Then we vote to make a motion that we vote to dedicate our excess TOT reserves for the next four years to fund the parcel workforce housing project. A second. All in favor? Aye. Anyone opposed?

22:19 Okay, motion passes unanimously. Thank you, everybody. And I want to clarify that. Yeah, sure. He had originally first, but then you just made the motion with the new... Right, I amended my motion. Okay, so on for the moving in and the desma. Yeah. Awesome. Anything else to discuss? We're good. Everybody, thank you very much for being here on short notice. We really appreciate it. Hope everybody here and all you guys have an excellent Thanksgiving. You guys, especially in the room right there, you guys kick it. You're awesome.

22:51 We appreciate all the work you do. Enjoy your holiday. Well, I don't know if any of us would get a holiday. Enjoy having all the guests here and having it full again. We'll see you all soon. We are adjourned. Thank you.