TransparentMammoth

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2019

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)

· recording 1 hr 55 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

231 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:05 Sorry, he's not wanting to click over. Lindsay Barksdale? Here. Zariah Cruz? Here. Tom Hodges? Here. Giselle Kenney? Here. Jennifer Kreitz? Here. Kirk Stapp? Here. Agnes Viansen? Here. And Richard Pleistad? Present. Thank you. Now is the time for public comments, if there's any public comments.

0:35 If there are no public comments, we'll move to agenda item number three is the introduction of new Latino housing advocate group leader, Judith. Great. Oh, well, thank you. So, I just have a little staff report here. As you probably remember, in April, the board of directors directed staff to move forward with the recruitment of a Latino housing advocacy group leader position in

1:01 Coordination with Mono County Behavioral Health, funded through some grant funds that they had received. And in August, the board approved the MOU with Mono County to move forward with that position. And we initiated a 60-day recruitment for that position. We had four applicants and conducted two interviews. And Judith was selected for the position and she started

1:29 Almost two weeks ago. Judith moved to Mammoth Lakes in 2006, and she has studied tourism and marketing, and also has a diploma in social work from Cerro Coso Community College, and she's passionate about serving our community. She's an active volunteer with Lions Club, the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, and with the trails.

1:57 And she's very excited about making a contribution to our community through this position. So I just want to introduce Judith to the board and welcome her to the team. Yes, I was hiring to bring here the Latino voice. And the main project is to improve the participation of the Latino community.

2:30 We'll move to agenda item four, which is approval of the minutes from the November 4, 2019, regular board meeting. Any corrections or deletions? If I can have a motion. I'll make a motion to approve the minutes of the November 4, 2019, regular board meeting. I'll second.

3:03 Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. We'll move to Agenda Item 5, approval of the minutes from the November 18, 2019 Special Board Meeting. Any corrections, deletions, additions? If I can have a motion? We'll make a motion to approve the minutes from the November 18, 2019 Special Board Meeting. Second? All second. Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye.

3:34 Motion passes unanimously. Agenda item six, cancel the regular board meeting scheduled for January 6, 2020. This is an action item. Discussion? Patricia? Yeah, so we have talked about canceling the January meeting. Just, so let's see, it's December.

3:56 So my due date is December 16th, and so I just didn't think I would have time to prepare materials for a board meeting on January 6th. So I'm asking that the board consider canceling the January board meeting and that we would reconvene in February. Discussion? I think it's reasonable, I mean, everybody's going to be pretty busy with the holidays as it is. Yes. Well planned. Thank you. Thank you, Agnes.

4:28 This is an action item. If I can have a motion. I will make a motion that we cancel the regular board meeting scheduled for January 6, 2020. I will second. Then moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. We move to agenda item 7. The board will receive a presentation for Mono County Behavioral Health on housing topics.

4:52 Okay, so this item is being brought before you this evening because the board has showed some interest in learning more about what other jurisdictions in the region are doing around housing. There's a lot going on between Mono County

5:13 Planning Department, Mono County Board of Supervisors, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Lakes Housing, the Chamber, and so I invited Amanda Greenberg here this evening to talk about what Mono County Behavioral Health is doing in terms of housing, which is also another handful of really exciting projects. So I'll just hand it over to Amanda. Okay, thanks. I have some handouts for you.

5:42 This is a project that is not the first one up. This is up in Walker, the dream up in Walker, but, you know, for down in the minute. So, as Patricia mentioned, I'm Amanda from Mono County Behavioral Health, and I'm our Mental Health Services Act Coordinator.

6:01 And the Mental Health Services Act is a California state tax, also called Proposition 63, or the Millionaire's Tax, aptly nicknamed because it places a 1% tax on individuals with personal incomes over $1 million. So that funding is

6:20 Really amazing. It gets reallocated across this to county mental health systems across the state and can be used for a variety of programs from individual services to community projects, prevention campaigns, and housing. And so that's kind of the way that we ended up in housing. We have some funds that are available to provide housing here in Mammoth for folks with, or in Mono County, for folks with mental illness.

6:50 We obviously know that affordable housing is a huge issue here in Mammoth as well as across the whole county and that really our most vulnerable residents are hit the hardest by the affordable housing crisis and mental health folks are certainly among our most vulnerable residents here in Mono County. We also know that

7:12 Research has shown that when individuals with mental illness are housed, they have much better outcomes across the board, from hospitalizations to just general recovery from their mental illness. And we also know that one of the best ways, the most effective ways to house people with mental illness is

7:34 Through permanent supportive housing. And so that means not only that the housing is permanent, not transitional, but that there are supportive services on site.

7:43 The other interesting piece of the housing puzzle when it comes to behavioral health is the No Place Like Home program. And so the No Place Like Home program, you might have heard of it, I think it was on the November 2018 ballot, we all voted on it. And essentially, it takes 1% off the top of the Mental Health Services Act funds, and it turns that funding into a grant program.

8:09 And so Mono County is eligible for $500,000 in a non-competitive grant pot. You still have to meet a bunch of minimum requirements and go through a whole process, but there's also a competitive side of that funding as well, and that's, again, for housing for folks with mental illness. So any questions about that kind of broader picture about how we ended up in the housing sector and where our funding comes from?

8:39 The $500,000, I mean, what's the restrictions on that? Well, for the $500,000 itself, it's complicated because they're the two sides of the grant. Essentially, I believe that at least 50% of the units funded with that housing have to be for folks with mental illness or has to be in a larger project.

9:07 All of that funding has to be put towards the units that are set aside for folks with mental illness, but then within the larger project, say you have a 10-unit project, then no more than five units can be for individuals with mental illness. Does that make sense? So it's a stigma reduction endeavor so that you don't have a large concentration of a certain population in one housing development.

9:36 And the other half? General affordable housing. So you could partner with the mountain or partner with Mammoth Lake Housing on that or with the town? On the $250,000? Well, it would be for the full $500,000, but you could. The complicated thing is that there are minimum threshold requirements around

9:59 Having done, the developer has to have experience doing permanent supportive housing. There's a handful of things that actually make it fairly difficult for rural counties to apply for. But what you could do is partner with a partner with a partner. Which is actually, which is actually.

10:20 Probably the best way to do it, right? Because we have partners on the ground who know the needs of the local community and are here creating those relationships, but then we don't have the experience points, so you have to partner with somebody who has the experience points, and then you build this, like, coalition. Yeah. But it's still difficult. Yeah, there's also a weird loophole where you, the...

10:46 For No Place Like Home, either you have to do a shared housing situation, if it's less than five units, or if it's five units or more, then you can have individual units. So, for example, you couldn't have two, say, okay, with $500,000, we could fund two units.

11:08 They can't be two separate units. It has to be shared housing. So there is kind of some weird barriers to the funding that are a little bit challenging. So you have to buy a duplex, triplex, fourplex? Those are individual units. Okay. So it would have to be, you know, a two-bedroom house with a shared kitchen would qualify as shared housing, which is much more complicated to operate, basically. Yeah. Any other questions about No Place Like Home?

11:39 Anything else? Okay. So the first project that we're working on is a permanent supportive housing project here in Mammoth. So about two years ago, the Behavioral Health Department started dreaming of and planning for an affordable housing development of about 30 to 45 units that would have a set aside of units specifically for folks with mental illness.

12:03 Since then, we put out an RFQ and we selected Integrity Housing as our development partner. So they're a non-profit affordable housing developer based out of Irvine and they have a lot of interest here in Mammoth Lakes. And for the last year, we've been working with them to identify a one to two acre site for the project.

12:25 And our next step is to enter into a financial agreement with them as we continue to look for a site. Our department has about $2 million to contribute to the project as well as that $500,000 non-competitive No Place Like Home funding, which makes more sense in a greater capital stack.

12:44 For a project like this. And the idea is that, or the goal is that the rest of the funding for the project would come from a low-income housing tax credit program or potentially from the competitive No Place Like Home funds. Integrity also has experience with other funding models, so we have faith that once we identify a site and get to where we can move forward that they will, you know, take the financials and run from there.

13:12 And then as far as a vision for the project, aside from the 30 to 45 units, we are planning to have a wellness center or some type of community space on site to provide those supportive services. And then ideally some offices or space for case management.

13:31 If we're dreaming big, having Medi-Cal eligibility workers on site once a week or once a month, WIC checks on site once a week, once a month, other types of services and outreach available. And then if we're dreaming really, really big, something like a daycare or a preschool co-located there as well would be amazing. So any questions about the Mammoth Permanent Supportive Housing Project?

13:54 So I do have a quick question. So based on what you said, less than 50% of the units have to be the permanent supportive set aside if to use no place like home. Correct. Yeah. And then what would integrity developments involvement be after?

14:12 Occupancy. They would serve as the owner and operator. So they would contract with a local property manager or hire someone and send them up here to serve as a property manager. Or the supportive component as well? The supportive component they would essentially contract with us. Or there would be some type of MOU in kind where we would be providing the supportive services. With the uses that you're describing on the site in addition to the residences, it sounds like you'd have to have

14:40 As far as zoning is concerned, you'd have to be potentially in a commercial zone. Is that true? Potentially. I think that that's something that we, as sites become available, we've been corresponding with the town around what the process would look like there. Right, right. There's not a lot of, as you talk to me about, is there anything out there I'm like, I don't, you know, there's a handful of places, right? So, I know a few on Main Street there.

15:08 There were some dealings going on that sound like those things went stale and didn't happen, like the old La Sierra site is an acre property, which seems like it would be a pretty good site, although I hear the owners are based in Texas and high expectations on value, so some challenges there. Yeah, it is a very nice flat site, though, as opposed to some of the other sites in town that are on the market. Yeah. So we're exploring all options and working with a local realtor, so it's been...

15:37 I describe it as surfing. It's just like you're riding the wave, and sometimes you're really high on the wave, and sometimes you're really low on the wave. Not that I surf. That's kind of a bad example. Imagine what it would feel like. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. All right. So the second project that we're working on is still in the needs assessment phase, and it's the Walker Small House project.

16:03 Right now, and that's the pictures that you have in front of you are examples of what this project could look like. And although it's still, you know, we're discovering that housing, the need for housing up in Walker kind of ebbs and flows for the population that we're working with. And so

16:25 We're still determining whether there's a need for the project, long-term and short-term, I suppose, but I think it's such an interesting model that's really quite easily replicable in the scheme of housing that I wanted to bring it forward to you all regardless. So the partner for this project would be the Stanislaus County Housing Authority, which, as you may know, serves as our Mono County's Public Housing Authority and manages our Section 8 vouchers.

16:53 And the project would be four one-bedroom homes, small homes that are 560 square feet, so bigger than a tiny home. And they're all modular, but built to stick-built codes. They're ADA accessible, and they fit on a quarter acre.

17:12 And so you can get four of them on a quarter acre. And they're also very affordable. So the cost to construct, including kind of the septic and some of the infrastructure for four units is about $650,000. So the idea for this project is that we would partner with the Stanislaus County Housing Authority. They would serve as the owner and operator, contract with a local property manager, and that we would refer clients to those units.

17:41 The land that we have for that project is behind the Walker Wellness Center, which is kind of right along Highway 395 up in Walker, and with some of the road shop parcel that's up there actually backs up to the wellness center, so there's kind of enough space straddling those two parcels. So in both this model and then again in the Mammoth model, clients will pay a portion of the rent. So rent's not free, but it's certainly subsidized.

18:10 Any questions on the Walker Project? So this isn't specifically, this is an idea or an example of something that was done somewhere else. Yeah, so that's from Glendale, actually. So I think that the San Isla's Housing Authority has done this project in at least three other counties, I want to say. It's been a long time since I've spoken with them about it. This kind of has been a little bit, this project has been on hold. But yeah, I think that they're doing it pretty successfully in other.

18:40 In other counties. Right. I mean, I like the idea that it, you know, a simple form to the actual housing unit itself that still can have some nice finishes in it and still be a really decent one-bedroom home to live in and you keep it, the construction is simple and straightforward so that you can keep the cost down. I think it's a good prototype for, you know, possibly accessory dwelling units in our community, for example, something like that. Yeah.

19:07 Is there an ongoing rental subsidy source included in this model or is the construction so cheap and the management so cheap that whatever they pay in rent covers the costs? I think that the way that we had structured the tentative draft, very draft pro forma, and it's been almost a year since I've looked at that pro forma, but the idea was that the rents would be

19:34 Somewhere around $450 or $500 a month and that cost would cover the operating costs because of the heavy subsidy to get the project constructed and then the land for the project as well. Right, so the land is free, the units are affordable to construct and the management costs maybe are low and so $500 a month pencils. Yeah. What would be the occupancy?

20:05 That's a good question, like the number of people. I think that they were saying that about two people is, you know, would be the ideal. Okay. Yeah. Yeah, but, you know, it's interesting at the same time, like, these can be configured to be duplexes or tribe, like a...

20:23 Fourplex. They can have, they can extend the roof line so that it's a shared roof line. There's a lot of, and like a covered walkway in between the homes. There's interesting things that they're doing with them. And I want to say that there were two and three bedroom models of the same, the same idea. It was pretty easy to add an extra bedroom. You talked about still sort of assessing the need for that, for these houses in Walker.

20:51 How would you have people get on a list or just people apply sort of like we do get on a waiting list and fill them? Well, I think because, you know, because of the specific population, the folks with mental illness that we would be serving with these homes, we kind of have an idea. Yeah.

21:10 Yeah. But, you know, the other possibilities that we're considering for this is maybe we don't need four units for mental health folks. Maybe we only need two and maybe one could be funded as a transitional housing unit by some other entity and maybe the county would want to pay for one or, you know, something like that. Those are all just ideas that have been floated and tossed around that maybe this is a joint venture between a handful of different groups. Or maybe there's some funding. I have no idea.

21:40 You know, the agencies on aging and that, you know, there's a high percentage of senior population up in Walker. So, I don't know. I think there's some creative solutions, certainly, that we could approach. So, that's all I have for you this evening. Any other questions I can answer for you? I'm not as in the know about the Davison property in Mammoth.

22:05 Yeah. Is that anything to do with your department or separate? Yes, it was. So we actually owned the Davis, the 71 Davison Road property and operated it as a sober living facility until 2011 and then it sat vacant and as you may know came under some significant disrepair.

22:26 And, yeah, we closed escrow, I think, October 31st. The county decided to sell it with a deed restriction for affordable housing to a developer based out of Tahoe. Yeah, so we'll see what happens. I know they're very excited to do something for the community there, and obviously the county is very excited to have them do that per the deed restriction. Yeah, perfect. Yeah, you're welcome.

22:54 All right. Thanks, everyone. Have a good night. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item 8, which is review. I just had a few couple more things. Sorry. I just wanted to also note that Mono County previously owned a condo in June Lake that they sold to IMACA for transitional housing. So IMACA will own and operate that condo unit in June Lake for those facing homelessness.

23:23 And then the Board of Supervisors will adopt their housing mitigation ordinance on December 10th at their December 10th meeting, which is next Tuesday. And that ordinance is pretty complex. There's some waivers in terms of who pays the fee. The fee is substantially reduced.

23:53 But if you're interested, I'm happy to talk more about that as well. Or you can watch their meeting on Granicus on December 10th. And that's all I have for updates from Mono County. Any questions? Now we'll move to Agenda Item 8, review and accept the June 30, 2019 audit statement. Okay, so the auditors came and visited us in September. We spent the day with them.

24:25 They sent us the draft financial statements, which are in your packet. I just wanted to point out on page two, you'll see a lot of things, but I wanted to point out that you'll see our Cal Home notes receivable. Those are all the loans that we've done for households to purchase mobile homes, and that's $74,000 in outstanding debt owed to Mammoth Lakes Housing for that program.

24:58 Just beneath that number, $74,000 is our reserves for Star Apartments and 238 Sierra Manor Road, totaling $426,000. And then if you read the report, you'll see there's some different mortgages that we have out on properties, detailing the amounts that we owe and the payments that we made over the last 12 months. And you'll see there's a letter to the board on page 15.

25:39 And that on page 19 you'll see there were no audit findings. So that's very exciting. I'm happy to present this to you this evening and have you adopt it for the public. Questions? I have a motion. This is an action item. I'll move to approve or accept the June 30, 2019 audit statements. I'll second it. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. We'll move to agenda item 9.

26:15 The parcel update. Okay, so I sent to the board the preferred plan for the parcel for you to review. We've had some staff involvement this month, mostly parking survey outreach to current tenants and those on the waiting list for affordable housing.

26:50 To get a sense of how many cars people have, where they're parking them, if they have less spaces than what they own, and what their household size is, for example. Jake and I probably spent about five hours total in the field and on the phone talking to individuals, and we thought it was really interesting. Some households have more cars than spaces that they're permitted.

27:20 They park them on the street. They park them at Bonds. They park them at Snow Creek Athletic Club. They park them at work. So there's no shortage of cars despite having a shortage of parking spaces. I think I tried to incorporate that information into the draft letter for the board to approve this evening. So that's mostly what we spent our time doing this month was coordinating that outreach.

27:51 The next steps are for the board to review the draft letter that I provided in the packet this evening. And then I can submit it for the December 11th public workshop. And then at that workshop, the town council will accept the preferred land use conceptual plan.

28:22 And then the town released an RFQ to engage a developer in the development process. And they held a conference on November 21st. And responses are due, I think they're due December 19th. So I've also been fielding questions from developers regarding potential partnerships, what MLH's role would look like in the future, all kinds of questions about what that would look like.

29:02 As the community moves forward with this really large undertaking. So I've had a couple of calls about that as well. So attached to this agenda item is the draft letter from the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lakes Housing. And the highlighted portions are things that I've added to the letter we sent, the last letter that we sent.

29:33 And then I tried to strike through things that I had deleted. So a lot of the letter might appear the same. I thought that we would want to reiterate some of the comments we made previously that we felt either we were in alignment with the preferred plan or if we were not in alignment with the preferred plan we would want to reiterate those. And then there was just a few things that I had deleted which aren't showing in this packet.

30:07 It should be in the one that I emailed you. So I don't know if you want to go line by line, or number item by numbered item, or what is your preference? I think that's a good idea. Okay. I just have to find my copy. Number one is diversity, equity, and inclusion, and I had added some concrete suggestions that were brought up at the last board meeting about specific ways that we thought the town could

30:57 Continue to involve the Hispanic community. And I'm happy to change it, add things, or at the pleasure of the board. Any public, any comments? So the final, oh sorry. Go ahead. The final draft will be on December 11th, right? Yes. So this outreach for the community is going to keep going? Potentially it could, yeah. I mean, I

31:36 Foresee if a developer is brought on board and the developer's ideas maybe differ a little bit or maybe they need some more specific feedback about unit sizes, there could potentially be more outreach. Further discussion on diversity, equity, and inclusion? We'll move to community amenities. Under community amenity, I've added some...

32:08 Information about... Childcare. Yeah, sorry, I'm just not sure that the right draft is in the packet. Yeah, so I added some information about community amenity, which I was trying to emphasize the need for community amenity as childcare, specifically, from what we've heard from IMACA.

32:43 And the community in general that this is a critical need and that we should stress this to a greater degree. Do you have, does it have a red line in it? Okay. Just highlighted. You know, my only, the thing that caught my attention was the last sentence that you said that the facility should serve the entire community and not be limited to a smaller resident serving community facility. You know, I think that's

33:15 I'm not quite sure if we, if I support that, I just, just because I think it would be gigantic. I mean, knowing what the need, you know, based on my experience with the daycare that the mountain provides, there's, you know, the size requirements of the state and so forth, it becomes very space intensive if you go, you know, the number of children back in you can have per care provider and so forth, it gets to be very, very difficult and I think of this, you know,

33:44 The development of the site is going to likely house over a thousand residents, and so there'll be a significant number of preschool children that'll need daycare just within that neighborhood. I think you'd be hard-pressed just to meet the needs of the neighborhood, much less take it on the community. So I'm not sure that, you know, this fits the bill for solving the overall community need for daycare like, you know, is being pursued by...

34:15 MCOE and so forth. I'm just curious what the thought is there on that because something that large could take a couple acres potentially if you're trying to accommodate the whole community in one daycare facility. Well, and I guess I'll just respond briefly with what I think my intention was, was that not that it would serve the entire unmet need, which is 275 spaces, but that it would be open to

34:44 People who didn't just live in that neighborhood. So anyone could apply and be eligible? And it wouldn't just be like, oh, you have to live at the parcel to qualify. Yeah, that was how I read it. I mean, I do agree that there probably is a need, enough need within the parcel, potential occupants, but... Priority would be given to residents. Yeah, that's the... Priority is the issue.

35:15 I mean, obviously, if you didn't have enough people within the development, that you certainly would want to utilize the capacity, and you could take people from outside, but maybe you would open it to people outside the neighborhood if based on availability or something to that effect. And I think in our previous letter, we had cited a number of 75 slots, which is what First Five is recommending as well. So maybe that's something we could think about incorporating.

35:45 It's not in this draft, it's a little more vague. To have a facility big enough to at least 75 or more. But maybe it's not a priority for this board. And this square footage for child was 1.70? Did you say square footage? Yeah. So just to think about how large it's needed. Yes. Right. So you're talking about 5,000 square foot facility for 75 kids, something like that? Mm-hmm. It's large.

36:18 But this is a suggestion. Yeah, I get it. I think we could, it's not that we're asking for a 5,000 square foot. I mean, I guess the point is that there's, the need will far exceed what we can provide, right? Regardless, but. It might be nice to kind of have like a, like a fair minimum, like almost like an expect to like at least get to this certain amount so that it doesn't just become like a child care unit that only serves.

36:50 20 or something like that. Like something to be like, let's aim for this amount and then from there. Yeah, I think that in the preferred plan they use the word small and I think that's kind of where I was like, well, is that really what we're aiming for? What does that mean? How small? When the need is so great? So maybe they should consider a larger facility given the fact that there's a demand for 241 slots within the community that would end up being about.

37:26 A tenth or better of our community living here. Consider a larger facility. Consider a larger facility. Given the documented need. Recommend you partner with the other authorities within the community to have good information on it. Yeah, I think we want to be careful of putting a number of children kind of requirements because we don't know like there may be grant fundings and various things and because

38:01 I think it's in the document that talks about, you know, they'll still have to figure out who's running it, who's doing all of that. So I think, yeah, being a little more vague, but just saying the larger the better to serve the need, better than smaller. But do you feel okay, Tom, taking out the resident serving community facility and opening it? Because that's really what that last sentence is saying, to serve the entire community. Yeah, I mean, I think, I guess my...

38:31 I don't really want to do the wordsmithing, but just something of the effect that could open it to people outside of the development based on, but priority would be given to local residents or something. Yeah, open to the community, but prioritized for. Prioritized to local residents just, again, for reducing vehicle miles travel and all other things, right? It's in the community, you want to take kids there. Yeah, okay. You know, the other aspect of daycare that probably is an area that can help is just,

39:01 In-home daycare, you know, that state-of-home mother that can have their child and you can have up to five other, you know, six kids under one adult for home daycare. But I don't know if that's something we want to add or make a note of, but, you know, there's potential if, you know, if there were half a dozen local residents that were offering in-home daycare, you could literally pick up another 30 spots of daycare, right?

39:32 Does the zoning for that area allow for that, for businesses? That's a good question. You can't, you can't not, I think you can't, you cannot not allow it. Yeah. Okay. You can't not not allow it. You cannot. You cannot. You cannot prohibit it. You can't prohibit, yes. Okay, so it is allowed to be anywhere where people live. Yeah, it's like the home occupation law.

40:01 I guess I don't know if that really has any impact necessarily on a comment. My question was only in that if they're going to be changing some sort of zoning and things, maybe it is worth bringing up if necessary, but maybe not then. Just leave it up to people. We do in the first paragraph talk about a purpose-built facility for childcare as well as a separate programmed community center, and then we didn't address that as much. And I don't know if we... The community center portion? Yeah.

40:31 I mean, I read that as a separate building. And is that, because I didn't see that in any of the documents in the preferred plan. It really just spoke to child care at least as much as what I remember seeing. And when we say programmed, what do we mean maybe by that? I think we were thinking after school program for kids whose parents work until five or six or seven.

41:02 In the evening. Or art classes. Sorry. Do you think it would be good to have it at two-story and then the second story can be used for after-school programs? Because right now we have the community center where they're providing or offering gymnastics and then we have the Snow Creek Athletic Club with ballet and all that stuff. But then we can use that for music or painting. And that would be...

41:31 Yeah, maybe we want to just, instead of a separate center, maybe a separate community space on the site, or maybe on the site. I guess for me, I'm wondering if we need to say that there needs to be various buildings. I just read that as two buildings. And maybe just to be sure that it's space within one building. I don't know. Community space. Yeah. Okay. Further discussion on the community amenities?

42:06 We'll move to income service, income level served. This is, this is, to get the grants, we, I mean, it's pretty much locked in. And so this comment hasn't changed from the last comment. We may, we're just saying that we agree with the preferred plan, which is to serve up to 120% of the area median income. And then a mix of, any further discussion on that? We'll move to mix of tenure. So, yeah, I just, I think the council is saying all rentals.

42:41 I thought I had seen something in the preferred plan that said it would be mostly rentals, but I did just try to emphasize here that we have a large ownership need, especially since the San Joaquin Villas unit hit the market. We've seen a lot of people expressing that they can't afford to buy or stay in this community, hospital workers, maintenance workers, mountain employees.

43:09 That want to stay and make Mammoth Lakes their home, but if they could buy and build equity somewhere else, that they're going to make that choice. So I tried to add a paragraph here which expressed that need in our community, but I'm happy to hear feedback from the board. Yeah, the first two phases are only rentals, and so that would be maybe something if we do want to address.

43:41 Thinking that the third phase is many years down the road, recommending that there are some more ownership places within the first couple of phases, if we want to be so specific as to that, or just leave it as we stated, that we do still think it's important to have a mix of both. You know, I guess my thought is that you could probably more cost-effectively serve the home ownership need through

44:18 Mortgage Assistance acquiring market rate product today, potentially, and or subsidy, rather, to bridge the gap for affordability cheaper than you could build new and make it for sale. And I know that there's a real challenge in the funding for ownership units particularly, right? And then especially as you get into the higher income levels, it's really challenging.

44:52 I'm just wondering whether just from a strategic standpoint for the community, I mean, you're better served by trying to facilitate a different program that, you know, if you can provide people, I mean, literally just say, oh, provide a subsidy with a deed restriction that, you know, give you a hundred grand subsidy to buy a unit, an existing condo, would be more cost effective than trying to build one that costs us, you know, $450,000 a bill. You know what I'm saying? Yeah. So I'm just, I'm not,

45:24 I'm not saying there's not a need. I think there is. Absolutely. I just don't know whether this is the right place and or the most cost-effective way to do it. And so there are funding sources that will do homeownership. Their Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities Program, the Cap-and-Trade Program, will provide subsidy for homeownership up to 120% AMI.

45:49 As well as CalHome and some other grant funding sources. It's obviously more difficult, like you said. There's not as many grants and opportunities for that AMI level or for ownership in that way. But I think what we do see is that these clients, it's still a really large subsidy.

46:12 Right. They can qualify for a mortgage of $250,000 or maybe $300,000 and the purchase price is $500,000 or something like that. I mean today. Let's say today, right? Right, right. So I think that there's value in creating.

46:30 Ownership opportunities that maintain the affordability in the long term. If you can do that with a mortgage assistance program, which hopefully we will see with the town's moderate income down payment assistance program that we approved last year, see how that works, and then we'll have a better idea of how that model looks. I think in the office we just see the limited availability of below market rate units and the number of people that...

47:00 Are interested in them. Further discussion? Leave it the way it is? I mean, you know, it's just, it's sort of. Yeah, it's just data. Right. It doesn't say how many units are. Right, right. I don't have too much hardware with it. I mean, I think it does. I mean, you know, it's a good point. There's obviously a need in the community for that. How we do it maybe is another question. Okay. We'll move to site density.

47:42 So on site density, I left the comment essentially the same. I added a comment that Lindsay had brought up at our last meeting, which was a concern that the higher you build, the more units you'll have, and then the less space for surface parking you'll have for the more people that you're adding. And then I added the comment about

48:15 Regarding the net density, because I still haven't seen any documentation about what the net density of the site will be. And that was a leftover comment from our previous letter. I just reworded it. And so there was some red line on this comment, but I've just reworded the comment. So in the previous draft of the

48:43 Plan alternatives. There was a comparison between the parcel and the surrounding neighborhoods in the density, but those neighborhoods already have roads and infrastructure and parks taken out, whereas the parcel's blank. So when you're saying that you can put 450 units on there, but you haven't subtracted out all these other things, it's actually, the density will actually be much higher than what is stated. Oh, got it. Okay.

49:14 To say it's 17 units per acre or 25 units per acre. If you say it's 25 now at the 433 or whatnot, then... When you take the roads out, it's actually 30 units per acre. The road, the water, the pathway, walking paths, the ditch. And so that analysis still hasn't been provided for the community to really get a sense of the livability? Okay. So going up...

49:41 One alternative, but every time you go up and you add another unit, you end up looking at at least one vehicle or two. And I'm of two sides. I don't mind going up to then save green space, things like that, but if you go up and then lose the ability to have the tuck under parking for all of those units. Well, I think if you get to a certain point, you get to more of a understructured parking.

50:10 Scenario. Multi-level, potentially, or? Or at least a full underlayer of parking beneath like three flats of apartments above kind of a thing. Yeah. You know, like The Village or JSL. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay. Kind of a thing, right. That gives you a few extra spots than just what they're considering this tuck under concept. Right, right. But then your cost of construction goes up. Yeah. Substantial. I think it's going to be driven heavily by the developer they pick and how they kind of put it all together. I mean, in the preferred plan,

50:40 It says it identifies 400 to 450 affordable housing units. I think that's the bookends. Yes, somewhere there's a specific number. But I think too, I think a little bit of that is going to come down to, again, which developer they choose and then just how they're able to put together the financing.

51:10 Where they think the opportunities are with grants and so forth to help, you know, lower the gap and so forth. So it's, I think there's, it's a little fluid and I think it's probably smart not to lock it in exactly, but, but I think, you know, pointing out that, hey, it needs to be an honest discussion about livability and hopefully, you know, when they get a developer on board, they have experience with, you know, similar type projects in their portfolio that there's some examples that they can point us to to look at.

51:37 Given a better idea of, you know, okay, is that a livable development and how does that feel? Knowing all the other issues that we deal with this snow storage and everything else that we deal with in the wintertime, right? Yeah, because I thought we've had a few discussions on requirements for elevators and accessibility as you go up as well. It seems like to add that cost to get another level, which also makes it hard for parking other things, doesn't maybe seem worth it.

52:08 That's a requirement of code, regardless. Yeah. Further discussion? Resident and guest parking. This is the big one. Okay, so in the first paragraph, this remains the same as our last comment, except for that I deleted the sentence that said we wanted to see an analysis of smaller structured parking scenarios dispersed throughout the site. I deleted that part.

52:40 And then in the next paragraph I deleted the first sentence which said that the design alternatives did not illustrate a parking allocation plan on a per unit basis because there was some analysis done on that in the preferred plan. And then I added the highlighted sentence. In the next paragraph you'll see the parking ratios at our current affordable housing complexes which

53:10 which are only parking spaces per unit that doesn't include guest parking or ADA parking and in the highlighted sentence that I added you'll note that the 1.3 spaces per unit includes guest parking and ADA required spaces so those spots would be subtracted from the per unit spaces on the site

53:41 And then I just added some comments about the outreach that we did on parking. And that's what I have for parking. Were you able to actually determine a ratio based on your survey or is it just more of this anecdotal feedback? It's pretty anecdotal. I mean, I think we maybe reached 20 to 25 people. It was taking about 15 to 20 minutes per.

54:12 Person to have the conversation. So it was really time intensive. So I don't think that the consultants will see the data as conclusive, but definitely anecdotal. I think you can see from the parking ratios that we have that even the 1.5 at Aspen Village isn't sufficient, although that complex is very far from amenities.

54:42 Would be the trade-off. Yeah. And not accessed well by public transit. Yeah, that it's different from the parcel. And we often get clients who live at Aspen Village apply to be back on the waiting list to move to complexes that are closer to town so the kids can walk to school. So I know that that's a preferred location and they have more parking. Yeah, I found it interesting in the...

55:15 The preferred plan, page 35, they have their table on which type of buildings would have which size units and how many parking spaces. And it just doesn't really make sense. They talk about that two and three bedrooms have 1.5 spaces, but yet a duplex A with two three bedroom units has four parking spots.

55:46 Assume two spots per three-bedroom unit, but then in different buildings that have, like there's one building that doesn't even have enough parking spaces for one unit because it has a bunch of studios which get a half space. So it just seems, I don't know, how are you? It seems a little bit, I mean, I get it's going off the math, but if you're looking at actual units.

56:14 Like, how does a studio get a half space? And maybe this is just what I don't understand in parking language, but... So 50% of the units would get one space and 50% would get no spaces. And they would just then have cheaper rent or you're just out of luck if you're getting late? Not necessarily. You would just not have anywhere to park your car and then you'd be parking it at bonds or somewhere else. Yeah. Yeah, it's tough. Or you might not have a car. I mean, knowing you don't own a vehicle or something like that, I would imagine.

56:43 Well, but that's what we have already at, right? You rent at Aspen Village, you only get one parking space. You still have two cars. You park at Snow Creek overnight. Because then the other... But you can't enforce what people can buy with their money. You can only enforce if they're going to park in your parking space or not. And then the other thing that I thought to park, I mean that, I see what they're...

57:12 Do in with the numbers and it'll just be what it is. I mean, I'd like it to at least, seems like every unit should have a parking space. But there is then in the map of the on-street parking and it looks like the northwest corner, which would be I think phase four, has no on-street parking near it at all. And then also in the sort of southeast corner has no on-street parking. So my other suggestion would be

57:41 To space out their on-street parking a little bit and it's because it seems very heavy to that northeast corner. They were based on my sort of glance at it. It appears that they're putting the on-street parking by the higher density buildings. Okay. Versus the lower density stuff that you're just mentioning, the southeast and the northwest corners are lower density that

58:12 That have adequate tuck-under parking. Because of the size? Because they're smaller, less dense. Okay. Yeah, but what about like, I have a car topper. Right, right. Or even guest parking. Yeah. Yeah, I just thought, I didn't know if we'd feel comfortable as a board. Sorry, you'll have to. If you're living here, you won't have to have that, probably. It's off when you get home, put it on when you leave in the morning.

58:45 Yeah, it just seemed sort of, and that makes sense that it's by size, but I thought if there was a way to add a bit more street parking and some of these other... Could you tell me what page that's on, Lindsay? Page 24 is where it shows the on-street parking spaces. And is there consensus to add a comment about that? I guess what I would be asking the board, if you feel the same, is just to ensure that there's...

59:18 Parking in various locations spread throughout the property or something. But I'm up for whatever the board feels. I mean, I think, you know, the narrative here just sort of points out the fact that the ratios have always proven to be light, right? And that you need to seriously consider that when they're going through the design process and that, you know, that we may not be able to comply with.

1:00:01 One-to-one for sure, even one and a half to one. I mean, that's what you're basically saying. Yeah, I think it's hard to measure because the example is very unique because it's far away from everything. Right. So it's hard to compare to a site that's going to be amenity-rich. And where there's going to be studios. Right. Right, so it's different.

1:00:36 Yeah. That's true. But I think maybe Lindsay's saying one way to potentially maybe increase parking would be to have more on-street parking. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, and I don't know, I mean, I don't know that the drawings are necessarily to scale for width of streets and where street parking fits, but so just if that was a suggestion we wanted to make to spread the on-street parking out. Or optimize or something like that. Yeah.

1:01:08 Maximize, optimize. Okay. Opportunities for on-street parking to accommodate oversized vehicles and guest overflow, etc. Yeah. Okay. I don't think anybody's, they're not going to build a structured parking garage just by nature of the fact that the way it's going to get phased, individual phased can't support building a structured parking garage. If you look at it holistically, you probably wouldn't, it could make some sense and maybe you could find some money to do that, but I mean, it's always a challenge.

1:01:49 So now I think the intent is to try to accommodate it on each individual development based on either whatever the combination of tuck under street parking and or if it's a more higher density building it would be under structure parking but that there wouldn't be any centralized parking so to speak. I like the language that says not to plan for something that may not come. I think that just read well and made sense.

1:02:20 Do what we're going to need for what's being built. And if a parking structure happens, great, it's in addition to. Move to enhanced mobility infrastructure. So the only change to this paragraph from our previous letter is that I deleted the final sentence, which said, an application for and utilization of the

1:02:50 Cap and trade program should be included in the RFP for phase one, which it was, and so I deleted it. Discussion? Accessibility requirements? I didn't make any changes to this comment. And I'm happy to delete it if the board feels like it's already been addressed, or if we want to just leave it in. I wasn't quite sure. You can leave it in. I guess my feeling is it's prescribed by building code regardless.

1:03:26 So, I don't know that it's absolutely necessary, but, I mean, there's no harm in having a mention, I suppose. So, discussion on 7 through 13? Mm-hmm.

1:03:43 Oh, one thing is that I did delete a previous number 12, which was in regards to the mill ditch. We recommend a treatment for the mill ditch that promotes natural resource preservation, livability, and quality of life by providing animal habitat, open space, and recreational opportunities for residents. I deleted that because I felt like it had been incorporated into the preferred plan. Yeah. Yeah. Okay.

1:04:09 Yeah, I would, the accessibility requirements, I think we probably could take out, just make the letter a little shorter, drive home our other points, but. Right, and it's mandated regardless. Yeah. I'm happy to take it out. Sure. And then for the current number 10 sun exposure, I'd like to keep that in, even, we said it before, but what I found in the preferred plan was they talk a lot about the street layout and melting of the streets.

1:04:40 Based on their alignment, but I still didn't read anything as much as I wanted about the alignment of the buildings for individual units to have access to sun. And so I just thought that was it. And when I think about sun exposure, I think about like my back deck or something like that and not so much about streets, which I should think more streets, but I didn't hear anything about individual unit sun.

1:05:06 Okay, and our comment says in order to provide natural sunlight into the units and to promote snow melt on the buildings? I mean, that's like for sidewalks, for things like that maybe, but yeah, I like that we say about units because I didn't see it in there. Okay, so I'll just leave it the way it is. Yeah. So I just thought that was a good one to keep. Okay. And then solar energy infrastructure.

1:05:36 Are there, have there been, has there been talk about that on the parcel property? Again, it's going to be required by building code that there's a certain amount of, based on whatever the currently adopted code is when they implement, they're going to have to provide for a certain amount of on-site self-sufficiency. Okay. You know, solar panels. Okay. So, and that would be in buildings then?

1:06:05 So they would be looking at their layouts. Maybe that's why they don't have to talk about it. Because they already would have to. Okay. And then number 12, the MLH role. It does at the end sort of the action table and time frame. There are a lot of things that talk about MLH helping with. And I just wanted to make sure that we were ready for that.

1:06:39 Looking ahead toward it and that it was nothing so far outside of what we already do. So it was the land trust model, which we talk about. Staffing, tenant assistant programs, I think we're pretty well ready to do that. We've talked about that in our strategic plan. Development of on-site management, we've talked about that a little bit. Hiring the fee developer.

1:07:19 To build out on behalf of town and in partnership with Mammoth Lakes Housing, I don't really know what that would mean. Review funding deadlines, include and analyze streamlining opportunities, pursue Section 8 project-based vouchers. We've talked a little bit about that. And then just with funding gap and various grants, I assume that's fine, working with developers to align funding options. So anyway, just...

1:07:54 I just noticed MLH came up a lot. Yeah, I think that's a good point. I think that a lot of those items generally fall under our contract with the town, so as we have staff capacity, we would participate in those conversations. Perfect. I had one question in there, and I don't know, Tom or Patricia, you may know. Resolved error in the Parcels Property Boundary Survey? What is that? It sounds like a technicality. Based on the survey.

1:08:26 Legal description, maybe the thing doesn't close. Yeah. Or the little housing project that exists now, there's some question as to setback and everything. Okay. I was just curious. Yeah, I'm sure it's just something to be resolved with the civil engineer. Okay. And then there's no other changes through the final comment on timing and financing. There's no changes, so.

1:08:57 I guess we just talk about how we think it should be expeditious and that a timeline of funding opportunities would be beneficial. So upcoming grant cycles and things like that. And then I tried to think of a creative way to conclude the letter, but I didn't, so it's the same conclusion. Sorry. Nobody else provided you input then. Yeah. I think it was very well written. Thank you. Oh, thank you.

1:09:38 I can make those comments, those adjustments to the letter, and then we'll submit it in time for the public meeting on December 11th, which is at 1 p.m. here in Sweet Z. For the discussion? Oh, do you need to have an action? I don't think so. Staff direction, I think. I don't see her, ma'am. No, this letter was... Oh, it's action. Yeah. It is action. If you don't mind making an action.

1:10:18 So approve it as amended. I'll make a motion to approve the letter as amended. In our discussion. I'll second the motion. Good move and seconded. Further discussion. All those in favor? Aye. Those are good comments. Thank you. Everybody. We'll move to agenda item 10, receive an update regarding 238 Sierra Manor Road.

1:10:56 So here's our monthly update on 238 Sierra Mander Road, which is our commercial property that we purchased to convert to 11 one-bedroom apartments. I have some information here about upcoming funding opportunities. So the home application is due January 22nd, which we're working on quite a bit. We should be eligible for up to approximately $2 million through that grant program.

1:11:31 The CDBG application will be due in April, which should be up to $3 million, I believe. IMACA has secured grant funding up to $60,000 for our project. The Town of Mammoth Lakes approved $300,000 allocation at their November 20th Town Council meeting. Mono County Social Services is applying for about $150,000 towards the project. We had the previous owner donated $50,000.

1:12:04 And we have equity of approximately $700,000 in the project. So that's just an update for the board to see kind of how this project's coming together as a community partnership. The board approved the full contract with Kevin Daly Architects so that we're moving forward with them to get our plans in enough readiness so that we can get points on the grant applications.

1:12:38 So we're working with them on that. And then, I can't think of anything else. Very exciting. Lots of small components that we're working to put together for the grant. You got a preliminary estimate. Yes, we did. We got cost estimates for the rehab, which came in around $3.5 million.

1:13:06 The board needs to approve the attached resolution, which authorizes our organization to apply for the home grant application. So, if we were to obtain the home grant for $2 million, and then you added the other commitments or preliminary commitments on town, Amaka, local county social services, I mean, you might be able to fund the remainder then through a loan? Yes. Essentially, right? That's right. Okay. Which would be...

1:13:37 Paid for through the rent proceeds. Mm-hmm. Right. Great. Yeah. So piece by piece. Regardless of whether we were able to get the CDBG grant. Mm-hmm. Right. So would you know, would you hear back on the home grant prior to the application for the CDBG grant? Or is that too tight? Because it says April 20th for the CDBG and the... We would have to apply before we find out, probably. Okay. Because the home application is due...

1:14:11 Oh, well, we might know, but probably not. Okay. Likely not. So we would apply for both and? Yeah. We could always, we could get fully funded, I suppose. I guess. Yeah. Well, that's what I hope. Fully funded. Okay, gotcha. Save town's 300 grand for something else. Yeah, good, like down payment assistance. Yeah, you did. Do more middle income mortgage assistance. Yeah, exactly.

1:14:43 It looks like in the points for the home application, you get more points for better plans, more developed plans. Is that something that the board needs to take any action on if we want to get that from Kevin Daly Architects to then include in the application? Well, we've thought a little bit about this and it's only three points. And so for the financial investment to get the plans...

1:15:11 To that readiness point level. It's a difference of points, not an additional, I see. Yeah, it's only three points, so it didn't seem like it would be worth a conversation around that. Okay. We're at the seven point level right now. That's right. I got you. Okay. But yeah, you have to spend hundreds of thousand dollars to get. To like rush it through. Yeah. Over the holidays. That makes sense. Get us together. Okay, perfect.

1:15:39 And so I have attached a resolution which authorizes Mammoth Lakes Housing to submit the grant application for up to $2 million for the rental new construction project located at 238 Sierra Manor Road to convert two commercial buildings to 11 one-bedroom apartments.

1:16:03 It authorizes the Executive Director or his or her designee to execute in the name of the applicant, Mammoth Lakes Housing, the required documents associated with the grant application and potential award. Is that the motion? Yes, please. Be moved. I will second. Be moved. 19-03. Be moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye.

1:16:44 We'll move to agenda item 11, Mammoth Lake Housing 2019-23, Strategic Plan. This is just an informational item for the board. It's a little output of our strategic planning prioritization process that we went through at the November meeting. So I attached

1:17:10 A spreadsheet which shows the board's priorities that were identified during that meeting and which focus areas they fall under. And then page three is the list of items that have already been completed. And on page five is the list of ongoing items that is mostly a lot of grant management and deed restriction stewardship that we're doing consistently. And then

1:17:47 I just wanted to, sometimes it's easier for people to get perspective when they can see all of the strategic items and then highlighted the ones which are our priorities. So this, starting on page eight is just the entire strategic plan and then what the board identified as priorities. And then the next attachment is the work program for fiscal year 2019-2020 with red lines of

1:18:25 Updated items that maybe have been completed. And then some reference to which items are actually in the strategic plan. And you can see which contract they fall under, whether it's the town or a grant agreement that we have. But on the final page 9, well 8 and 9, you'll see that there's

1:18:59 MLH Strategic Plan Other Category, which is a lot of new stuff that we've added since performing our strategic plan and then the priorities identified at the November meeting. And those include, you know, the governance trainings, development opportunities, engage the developer community, exploring property management, fundraising and marketing.

1:19:31 And then some internal systems items. And so I just wanted to provide an update on this so that the board was aware of what we were working on. Questions? This is an information item. If there are no questions, thank you for the information. It's good. You're welcome. I would just add, I guess, general comment that as we work in our individual committees that we focus on these highlighted strategies and tasks. Yes, thank you. That's an excellent point. And I think

1:20:12 The perfect outcome for our prioritization session is kind of refocusing. We identified some priorities from the strategic plan, which has like 45 items. So that first page of what the board identified as priorities should be what we're all thinking about in the forefront of our minds. Discussion? If not, we'll move to agenda item 12. The board will consider the merits of an application for the California

1:20:50 Coalition for Rural Housing, Rural West Internship Program for Diversity in Nonprofit Housing and Community Develop. And this is an action item? Yes, so the board approved an application to this program in December of 2018, and we were awarded and recruited Jake Castro, who's been our intern starting in June.

1:21:17 And so the opportunity to apply for this program, again, is here upon us. And the grant program allows for us to have a part-time intern for up to 1,320 hours out of the 12-month period at a cost of 60%.

1:21:41 So that the grant covers 40% of their wages. So it's a good way for us to leverage money for extra capacity. I provided a lot of information about the internship program and the different training opportunities that they provide to the intern. Some of the work program items that our intern is learning about is

1:22:14 Real estate development, affordable housing development, asset management, housing rehab, and lending. And so Jake has been working with us a lot on our grant applications for 238 Sierra Manor Road. He's also working a lot on deed restriction stewardship, helping to maintain the community assets that we already have. He's also helping a lot with outreach for the parcel.

1:22:44 Like I noted previously, which frees up some of my time to be able to do other things. And so on page three, I just provided a draft financial analysis of the cost to have the intern for a 12-month period. And then there's a timeline on page four. And so the application's really simple. It's a Word document. I just fill out a little bit about Mammoth Lakes Housing, what we think the intern would be working on.

1:23:21 At our organization. I would know whether that the board approved the application. It's pretty simple. So if the board wants to go in that direction, it's not a big time commitment for me. Discussion? So the presumption is then if we apply and we're successful, then we'll still have to commit funds to fund differences like we did this last time. Yeah, that's right.

1:23:51 I think it's like eight for us and four from the grant. Okay. Something, total about 15. So it sounds as if you're very happy with, you know, the work effort that you got from Jake and that's been helpful to free up some of your time, which is valuable. Yeah. So it's been well worth the effort and nominal expense that we've incurred, right? Yeah, I believe so. And we have money in our budget.

1:24:17 This next fiscal year. Yeah, and so I did a rough budget analysis. I mean, we're not ready to dive into next year's budget, but it seems like in what we had allocated for last year is reasonable to allocate in next year as well. For the application, can Jake apply again, or does it have to be a new person?

1:24:41 That's a good question. I don't know if that would make him ineligible, but his plan is to transfer to a four-year university, so he would be leaving that area. Okay, so you'd be recruiting somebody new anyway. He's done a great job. So we need to make a motion? Yes, we need to make a motion. That's an action item. I would make a motion to apply for the California Coalition for Rural Housing Rural West Internship Program.

1:25:17 for diversity and non-profit housing and community development. Second. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. We'll move to agenda item 13, Mammoth Lake Housing Monthly Update. Okay, this is my last item, I think. I did want to, let's see. I know I have some exciting stuff in here, but let me just find it. I guess I will just,

1:26:10 Say on page 6 under apartment vacancy rate, we will be tracking the apartment vacancy rate starting in January. So that's an upcoming work program item that we complete every year in January. So it was completed last year and the vacancy rate was less than 1%. And so we'll do it again in January this year and see what it is this year.

1:26:39 We're working through the deed restricted units that the board authorized to buy back. One of the units we closed on the 22nd, so we own the unit, and there'll be some rehabilitation needs at that unit before we prepare it for resale, so we'll be working through that. And then one of the other units is currently in escrow with an eligible household, so they're scheduled to close December 22nd.

1:27:14 I guess I'll note the median home sales prices on page 7. Condos are $460,000 median year to date and single family homes are $792,000. And then under partnerships, I wanted to let you all know that the town council approved the $300,000 towards 238 Sierra Manor Road as well as $300,000.

1:27:50 An additional $300,000 to the revolving loan fund to protect deed restricted units. So now there's $600 available at the town and $300 available in the county so that if we ever are faced with multiple units at once coming up, we should be able to preserve them all. And I wrote the town council a thank you letter so I'll just share that with the board.

1:28:15 I sent it as a public comment, so I don't know if I'll be at their meeting on Wednesday. But if you want to read it, you guys can read it. So that's really exciting. I felt compelled to write a thank you letter because I felt like the council really made a strong commitment to community housing programs at that meeting. And so I was really impressed with their

1:28:47 Their political will on that. We held a homebuyer education class on November 12th. Wasn't it on the 4th? It was on the 4th. On November 4th, I believe it was. And I think five or six households attended that class and all of them, I think, found it really useful. So I think under our contract with the town, we hold those twice a year.

1:29:23 And then I wanted to make the board aware that there have been some massive tenant evictions in Inyo County in the city of Bishop. And so we've been fielding some calls from tenants about what's going on there. But the lead agency on those issues right now is the California Indian Legal Services. They have an office located in Bishop. And so they've been...

1:29:52 They brought an emergency ordinance before Inyo County and the City of Bishop City Council, and both of them passed this urgency ordinance to implement AB 1482 before the January 1 deadline, because it's a state law that takes effect January 1. Well, Inyo County and City of Bishop said we wanted to take effect earlier, which means you have to have

1:30:21 Just cause to evict your tenants. So a lot of those tenants are working through the legal process with California Indian Legal Services to make sure that they're new landlords that have bought the properties that are evicting the tenants. So they're working through that process to make sure everything's legal and that they're within their rights and things like that. So we fielded a few calls about that and it's certainly...

1:30:50 An interesting and relevant topic to our work that we do. I don't know. I don't know. This is on 395, kind of by where Petit Pantry is. Oh, okay. That area. Oh, okay. Bishop Creek Chevron area. Yeah. Oh, I wanted to say that Director Barksdale and I attended a PSIA Aussie.

1:31:24 Meeting at the Mountain to talk about what we're doing for housing and how that organization could potentially partner or participate in their respective communities around housing. And that's the Professional Ski Instructors of America and the American Association of Snowboard Instructors organization. So it was a big group and I thought it was great.

1:31:54 I look forward to working with them more. And then my last comment is that we coordinated a volunteer opportunity for the board to write thank you letters to the court appointed special advocates for children on the 21st of November and we had four board members and some family members and we wrote I think 20 or 25 thank you cards.

1:32:22 To those volunteers who help youth navigate the court system when their families are going through rough times. So that was very fulfilling and I think our board members enjoyed it. So I hope we can do something like that again. I think that's all I have. We'll move to Agenda 14 update from committees. Governments committee that has not met. Diversity, equity, inclusion.

1:33:09 Nope. Program and housing development? Yeah. So we did actually meet. Myself and Jennifer. And, you know, we're just kind of regrouping a bit. And what we decided was that, you know, in accordance with our strategic update here, that, you know, we're certainly going to do everything we can to assist with focusing on the completing the development of Sierra Manor Road project. But then we also,

1:33:42 agreed as a group that an area where we felt like we could maybe move the needle in terms of delivering units would be to maybe take a little bit of a put an effort at the facilitation of accessory dwelling units for the community. So we agreed that we would reach out to the town manager and see if we can schedule a meeting, which Jennifer did send out a note to try to see if we can work out a schedule with Dan Holler to get together.

1:34:13 Talk about what we can do as a committee to help facilitate moving the ADU effort forward. And as much as could we facilitate spearheading, getting some standard plans put together that would work in our different neighborhoods in the community, maybe it's something that we could solicit a proposal from some local architects to help put that together, come back with

1:34:42 You know, a funding request to either a combination of Mammoth Lakes Housing and or the town to, you know, fund the putting together a standard set of plans that would then, as well as a sort of a pro forma outline for homeowners so that would facilitate their ability to potentially actually build ADU. So we feel like it's, you know, the program, all the elements are in place, but it's really still very difficult for an individual homeowner just to say, oh, I'm going to go build a unit.

1:35:11 Have no idea what they're facing with respect to plans and permits and all that. And the feeling was if we can get a set of plans, you know, some plans that could be applied to multiple different parcels in the community that we could, you know, we as a community could fund it, have them already done so that it's just sort of off the shelf for a homeowner to come in and maybe they pay a nominal fee and it's real simple and cost effective for them to go build an ADU, something like this, right?

1:35:41 If they have space available in their property and then also have some outline sketch of what that would cost and what they could realize in rent and so forth so that maybe we could actually facilitate the development of ADUs as a more immediate way to deliver units in the community without getting too, you know, because obviously a lot going on with the parcel. There's other people looking at other properties in town. We don't want to duplicate effort. That's the other thing we wanted.

1:36:09 Check with Dan, because I know the town's been pursuing some quarter acre, third acre parcels in the Sierra Valley sites as potential sites developing. So we don't need everybody doing the same thing, but that's why we want to meet with Dan first so we can kind of narrow in on where can we be effective in our time and focus on that. And then we're also going to make some efforts here in the coming months to reach out to some different affordable housing lenders and just try to see if there's other types of

1:36:38 Loan programs out there and or source of funds that we could utilize possibly for smaller kind of projects like 238 Sierra Manor Road, for example, because that's sort of a seems like a niche market, right? I mean, it seems like there's plenty of stuff out there for the bigger stuff like the parcel, but you know, there are opportunities for these smaller things and if there's...

1:37:02 You know, other things, other types of programs out there maybe that we're not aware of or just at least try to get some feelers out. I was going to call some of the people I met at that affordable housing finance conference last spring and follow up with them again and say, hey, is there other things that we could do for, like this project, for example. So, so anyway, so we'll, we'll try to resolve to make some efforts here. But, yeah, that's an update from us. Have you reached out to HUD?

1:37:32 Ken Bringwell of the Chamber of Commerce because it sounds like we've got a lot of overlap and it might be able to because they've hired an individual to almost do it's going to be some of the similar reaching out to the business community but reaching out to homeowners too so you might want to talk to Ken and see if you can because they've hired a full-time staff person to do this and so if you can coordinate with him it might be

1:38:01 Way to better focus on all of this. Yeah, certainly. Okay, that's a good suggestion. Yeah. Marketing and communication. Yeah, so we met just before this, which is good because this is the first time since Lindsay just joined for us to kind of like get things together. Our first thing that we're going to work on, so we're going to meet the next two Mondays to get this going before the holidays.

1:38:31 We're going to first kind of work on like basically what is the message of Mammoth Lakes Housing and what we're trying to put out to the community and kind of creating a good info page on 238 of like what we've done, like plans and kind of if there's a way to like ask for donations and if we were to ask what we'd be kind of wanting them to be geared towards. We also want to like focus on like how to best disseminate the message.

1:38:59 And like effectiveness like of creating pamphlets or sending out emails or utilizing social media and just building like a better presence on social media in general for Mammoth Lakes Housing and how to best go about that and kind of focusing on like who exactly we want to target. So the next two weeks we're going to focus on basically mainly just the message and then once we get that figured out how to best make just the community aware of that and how to have a better presence in the community and then how to

1:39:29 Utilize that presence to gain donations and stuff like that. Move to workforce housing program steering committee. Richard? Oh, no, they did that one already. Okay. Yeah, I combined them. Yeah. All right. Board member reports. I can't think of something. Sorry.

1:40:07 Just like Patricia said, we presented to the PSIA and Aussie and I see some of those people through my work so I'll try to keep following up with anybody I know. They were a range of people from really California, Nevada, Lake Tahoe, Mammoth mostly representing various resorts and resort communities so hopefully something comes of it. We tried to give them an overview of what we're doing and

1:40:35 Patricia and I brainstormed a few ideas that maybe they could do with their members using the middle income loan program. And as an example, they as an organization could raise money, put a loan program together for some of their instructors to apply for, something like that. They already have a great scholarship program. So they have a kind of a way of raising money and giving it out.

1:41:05 Maybe if they did that, but for housing, could be interesting. And then I wrote thank you cards at Wild Iris. It was very interesting. I was terrible at it. I got too distracted talking and kept messing up. I was the most inefficient thank you card writer. But the other thing I just wanted to mention with that, they are doing their coat drive right now. And Matthew, the Executive Director of Wild Iris, was just speaking to the need of winter clothes for people who might have to leave their housing.

1:41:35 Quickly, and not have things with them, so, and I, yeah, so, just for us to spread to your people, I believe they take their donations at Wild Iris, they're open, roughly business hours, so, yeah. Make sure that's in the minutes. Yeah, I've got a couple things. So,

1:42:08 With the blessings of the ruler of God here, we've got a lot of snow, so just for you guys' information, the mountain's going to be in full operation starting this Saturday. All the base lodges will be open, Eagle and Canyon, and all the terrain will be open, which also means we're gearing up a little bit ahead of schedule in terms of our staffing, and we'll be fully staffed up here quickly. So we'll be at the precipice, the peak of housing demand here in the coming weeks.

1:42:38 In the community, just so, I guess we'll keep an eye on things, right? See how things go. We're maxed out with our housing and have a wait list as it is, so. It'll be interesting and we sold a lot more passes than we did last year, so it'll be interesting to see what effect that has on visitation. Numbers were a little soft this weekend, Thanksgiving rather, but I think we expect there's a lot of built up demand, especially now that the snow's coming.

1:43:07 Expect to be very, very busy this two peak weeks of Christmas, New Year's holidays, so hold on to your britches, here we go. And then I think we just also mentioned I'm participating in a citizens group that's been taking a little closer look at some of the preliminary pro formas that are being prepared by a Noven Development Group, a consultant to the town for the parcel. And that was interesting, kind of getting into the details and the weeds on that a bit. And the first phase,

1:43:37 Project, it was 138 units, I believe. I think it's interesting to know because they identified the funding gap as like around $5 million on this first phase, even though the overall project is still roughly a $60 million gap potentially on the whole build out, even though a quarter of the units in the first phase, there's only about a $5 to $6 million gap, but it's because there's a higher level of lower income, so there's more.

1:44:07 Grants and so forth that they're assuming that can be obtained to subsidize it. And so I think it's just an interesting point because to understand that, you know, as you get into higher AMI levels, there's less funding, public funding available. Therefore, there's a bigger gap to fill that has to probably come from local sources, you know, from the town. So, you know, it'll get more expensive, obviously, if the subsequent phases are higher AMI levels.

1:44:37 So it all, it's very intricate as you look at the performance and how that all works out. So I think it's just a, just wanted to point out to you guys, because it's not like a straight, go build out units and it's the same amount of gap funding per unit. It all depends on the AMI levels and what programs are being qualified for and that are helping subsidize the development. So, and they also made an assumption there would be no Section 8 rent. There's just such a small amount in the.

1:45:05 County at large anyways, that they weren't assuming any, um, Project, yeah, Project-based Section 8 vouchers. Which, which, you know, I think that overall, I mean, that was very, as we really got into it, they're doing a really good job, and they're very, very thorough, they were very, very conservative in their assumptions, both on the construction costs and development side, as well as, as the, you know, the rent side, everything else, the sources of income and so forth, so.

1:45:34 So I think they're kind of painting a, I don't want to say worst case scenario, or just, you know, like I say, conservative approach at it. So, you know, it's going to be pretty exciting, I think, as they get responses to these RFQs and see what developers are out there and what, you know, their input's going to be on it. But, you know, as painful as it was taking all this time to put together this community effort, going through the community outreach and so forth, I think it...

1:46:01 I think in the long run it's going to be a benefit to the overall development of the parcel and as much as people are well informed about it. I think it also puts us in a much better position to explain to the developer what our expectations are and what we want and what we need and there's a much better roadmap to work from versus just giving them a blank slate and say go for it. I think it would have, you know, could have been, you know, we could have run into some trouble.

1:46:28 At this point, I think everything's poised to really get going, so it's just a question of how quickly units can be delivered. I think based on the time frames that I saw, the potential, if in a really fast-track development process, because there's a lot of environmental approvals that have to happen this next year, that can take some time. But building that in, the earliest wildly optimistic delivery would probably be the fall of 2022.

1:46:55 So to get the first units, this first phase delivered, so just to kind of put it out there is, you know, that's three years away. So something to keep in mind. So the idea of trying to figure out ways to make ADUs, get some program going on that quicker, but even that might take all the next year to get that figured out if somebody could go build the year after, you know, that's two years out, right? So we're still going to be in this quandary here of having to shortage of housing for a bit.

1:47:26 And there's no real immediate solutions to that. It doesn't appear. That's my individual thoughts. Agnes? Yeah, I got two quick things. I don't know if it makes sense or if it came up in your ADA discussion about, I noticed that there is a, you know, whichever Facebook page it was, but it was like an invite to, hey, we're a group of car campers. Is anyone interested in kind of joining up together so that we can

1:48:00 I don't know if it's like work together, but like where are you camping tonight? Maybe I'll camp at the same place. Like be safe. Yeah. What's that? I didn't see it. That's interesting. Yeah. So it's like Mammoth Lakes car camping or something. That's actually really seems like a real useful thing because there's a lot of people out there that are choosing to live in their camp because it's they're doing it. So the question is but then

1:48:27 You think about it, if you were going to go out and sleep in your van or your car or whatever, it's like, where can you actually go do that without somebody saying, you're not supposed to be here overnight, right? Right, yeah, and so that's why I bring it up, like, you know, like, is there any movement anywhere in, or like, where does that start to, like, let's have a discussion of where could that place be? Maybe at the council, something should be addressed, because it's a good point. I mean, they're doing it anyways. They're doing it anyways, so make it safe, make it...

1:48:57 Legal. Instead of people having us. Especially, I feel like right now with the cold. A few years ago, one of my family members died frozen because he was sleeping in his car. Oh my goodness, really? Yeah. Right. No insulation. I mean, some people have these fancy insulated vans, right? But some people are on their civics. No insulation. So if they can have information on how to be able to sit down. A safe place. Yeah.

1:49:25 I mean, again, I don't know. I'm not saying that, whatever, but there's a parking right. There's the propane tank. Yeah. And then it needs money and someone to manage it. Like I said, a bathroom dumpster. Anyways, I just noticed that people are doing it. What can we do to support it? That might be work, like town, working with Forest Service to open up things or allow something.

1:49:52 In the meantime. Because the same point is, like you say, we'll go to the Mammoth Mountain RV Park, but it's like, well, they don't want to pay 35 bucks tonight or whatever, right? We're trying to do it on the cheap and... We're trying to do it on the cheap, but then you also see parking spaces being advertised, like, hey camp, or... Oh, yeah. Oh, really? Like, parking my driveway? Yeah. Interesting. Yeah. I mean, it's a reality, right?

1:50:18 Sort of an underground reality. Well, I will just say that IMACA is exploring the concept of setting up a safe parking lot in Bishop at the Catholic Church, I believe, and that they have initiated an MOU with the church in order for the parkers to use the restrooms there overnight. And so that's a conversation.

1:50:47 That maybe the town or, you know, that we could have about what does that look like in Mammoth? Yeah. I mean, it's a kind of a, you know, if you go out and say, well, we're going to make this parking lot a safe, free place to park, then all of a sudden you create this sort of impromptu campground. Right. And then you create a whole other source of issues and problems. Yeah. Yeah, I think it still fits in somewhere, though, too. Yeah. Yeah.

1:51:16 Well, and I think it was last year that there was the woman in Tahoe who was sleeping in her car and got plowed in, and they did find her for a couple days, which I'm just like waiting to happen. Okay, and then tomorrow is Giving Tuesday, so for my own non-profit, we have been running a campaign for the last few weeks.

1:51:46 You know, we have a board match, we, Facebook does match, up to a certain amount, it's, it's gone pretty quick, um, but, uh, just in the spirit of giving, you know, I, I, in my own budget, I don't have a term, but I try and pick, say, ten non-profits, local or otherwise, and maybe it's five or ten bucks each, and so, if you can, it's a big day for, not big day for non-profits.

1:52:28 Just to give you guys a heads up, does anybody know where the old elementary school used to be? Down by Hot Creek? Yeah, down by Hot Creek. I mean, there's a huge asphalt slab down there. I'll ask the town manager to at least take a look at that and see if that could be a place for, because it used to have septic tanks and everything for the elementary school. Interesting.

1:52:53 You know, it's just, you know, you're bringing that up and I started saying, wait a minute, we have a place and it's, you know, in pretty much. Yeah, less snow and everything. And it, and the road gets plowed because of, because the fish hatchery. Obviously we'd have to work with the fish hatchery and everything else to get that. But anyway, I will try to bring that up with the town manager. And I don't think the,

1:53:23 I don't think I have anything else other than I'll follow up on that. And they, the town council will be looking at funding sources for this. And this is off the record on the camera, but you know, the idea of looking at the 13 points of T.O.T. each point is worth about

1:53:48 $1,350,000, so if you shift those around, those are advisory votes, but if the council wants to take something back out to the community and shift some money because of the T-bid from marketing or something because their organization, Mammoth Lake,

1:54:11 Tourism, you know, is looking at, hey, we've got a problem, and so they're really accepting some of the burden of housing also. So there has been discussion about shifting some of that TOT, and I, and, you know, nothing permanent, but there's discussions going on. They're saying, you know, we represent the business community. If the business community doesn't have housing and workers, guess what?

1:54:36 We have a problem, so we've got to chip in, too. So I've had a couple of discussions with board members, and we'll see what the presentation is on Wednesday, if and in, you know, and their board is meeting, too, to discuss about it. Wait a minute. We have no workers. We've got to figure out the housing element, also. So I think they're on top of it. That's all I have.

1:55:06 If there's anything else, we will adjourn to the regular board meeting on February 3rd. And have a happy new year, and Christmas, and everything else in between.