TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2011

Town Council Special meeting

· recording 1 hr 15 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

161 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Councilmember Eastman? Here. Councilmember Layman? Here. Councilmember Wood? Mayor Pro Tem, Bacon? Here. Mayor Harvey? Here. At this time, we will open the podium for public comment. If there's something that is not on the agenda that anyone in the public would like to comment on, you may do so at this time, and please keep your comments for five minutes or less. And if there isn't anyone, I just have one comment I would like to, or a notice I'd like to make that

0:25 Our February 16th Council Meeting had originally been scheduled for a workshop to start at 5 p.m. that day, but due to the inability of a number of the planning commissioners to make it at that time, we're just going to postpone that until a later date, which we will announce then. So the Council Meeting on the 16th will start at 6 p.m. and not 5. Can I follow up on that? You may.

0:52 For anyone who watches Weather Underground, an addendum to what Skip just said is that apparently around the 15th of this month, which is another week, there will be a return of winter to the High Sierra. I'll see in a big way. Hopefully in a big way. We can only hope. All righty. With that, we will begin our workshop and turn it over to Mr. Clark.

1:19 Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council. As you recall, the Municipal Finance Committee, which you're sitting as and you've appointed yourself to, came out of our discussions of how to go about deciding how to work with Measure U. And when that conversation came up, we said, you know, maybe we should step back and look at our whole capital financing scheme, including Measure U and Measure R and other sources, and make sure that we're following the best practices.

1:48 And the reason we said that is because in your discussions on Measure R, and I think the same thing would come up with Measure U, there were many questions that were asked but not answered. And some of those had to do with how do you take something like Measure R and fund a major project? How do you decide how much money to set aside to maintain projects that are built with these funding sources? And how do you leverage these funds by bringing in other money?

2:16 The Council approved a contract with Walter Kieser of EPS, and I think you all know Walter, who has helped us with a number of projects. He is very familiar with the current methods and the best practices for capital planning, the practices that are undertaken by many other cities and many of his clients, and he's here to lead a series of three workshops.

2:39 To expose those ideas, bring everybody up to speed, and kind of lay the table for you guys to make decisions about how we do this. So I'll turn it over to Walter. Thank you, Rob, very much. Again, my name is Walter. I'm a managing principal with the firm Economic and Planning Systems with offices in Berkeley, Denver, and Sacramento. And as I said, it's a pleasure to be here. I see this work that you've invited me to help you with as...

3:09 So I do have, because of that earlier work, I have a lot of

3:39 Understanding about what goes on here for the good, the bad, and the ugly, all those things. So I do understand what goes on here and some of the issues that you're facing from a budgetary standpoint, capital standpoint, economic standpoint, et cetera, et cetera. As a part of my practice, we do a lot of work dealing with the creation of funding programs of one sort or another, how to spend special funds.

4:07 The creation of capital financing plans, the allocation of restricted bond measures for particular kinds of projects like transportation or recreation. The very common problem and the problem that you face here is I consider set piece. It's a standard, this is right out of the book kind of problem that you have about what you do when you have all these needs, sometimes competing needs.

4:34 And you have a steady and reliable, hopefully, and growing revenue source. Well, how do you make the best sense of that? So these workshops are going to work us through that. And Rob and I put together the staff report that provides you and the public with some background information. I don't want to go.

5:00 Through this too much, what I prefer to do is to walk you through a process like the normal, if you will, the norm for doing this, and use that as a way of talking about some issues that are specific here. The purpose of tonight's, as Rob said, there's three workshops we're going to do over the next month or so.

5:23 And the purpose of this first workshop is to make sure that you're comfortable going in this direction. Because if you're not, we won't go there. We'll go some other direction. But what I want to do is present you with what I consider to be a professional or standard budgeting norm for how to do this, how I've done it many other times, and how this problem is solved elsewhere. And if you like it, if you go, yeah, that's kind of sort of what we want to do, then what's going to happen is we're going to go,

5:52 From the broad topic that you give approval of, hopefully, or not tonight, down into more technical work that would actually help us run through this cycle, technically. At least as an example. It may not be the real thing, but we'll get down into actually considering a range of capital projects.

6:20 And developing a set of ranking criteria and coming up with a provisional decision-making set just as an exercise. Again, there may be reasons why sometime subsequent you're going to want to go through this process again, but this will be kind of a demonstration to show you and to gain some confidence with how this works. And what will happen is that myself and staff will serve obviously as

6:50 As a support to you in this exercise. The other thing I would say that I think you're quite well aware of is that here in Mammoth Lakes, as always, but I think particularly now, there's a lot of moving parts. You've got a lot of things moving around and a lot of things that you're trying to accomplish. And what we'd like to be able to do through this exercise is to bring it into harmony with the work that Ray...

7:18 Jarvis is doing on the capital planning side, the resort investment work and planning work that Mark is proceeding with. Some of these other efforts, we want them to ultimately all be integrated. And this funding process is a way or one of the ways in which you can bring all of those things into harmony rather than this being kind of just a grab bag and you're faced with kind of one-off decisions every other week. And so I really do see this as an opportunity for adding a strategic...

7:47 And again, we can talk more about that as time goes on. And I think all of those moving parts, so to speak, are actually a part of this. One thing that I would, another moving part, if you will, that I'm also working on, as you know, with Mark is, that relates strongly to all this, is a development forecast.

8:16 And the development forecast that we're doing is typical of the work that we've done in other resort communities where we're looking at futures that are basically dependent on what you do here in the way of investment, attracting visitors, of developing the community, et cetera, et cetera. And it's not like you can just sit back and

8:46 And do nothing or just kind of be passive and things are going to just happen automatically. We think that in resort communities there has to be a strategic investment program, a renewal process that goes on all the time to maintain, let alone increase your economic competitiveness and those sorts of things. So that's what we're going to be talking about. Does that make sense?

9:13 A good starting point. And please, as I'm talking, if anything doesn't make sense, this is kind of a workshop, so just interrupt me and ask me questions. Sometimes I get excited and talk fast. So the first part of this is that we have available to us a series of special funds that the voters, in their judgment, have made available to the town.

9:41 You have this Measure R, which is a sales tax override that is dedicated for recreation projects. You have Measure U, which is an upgrade or a renewal of the utility users tax at 2.5% on the bill. And then you have the TOT. Now, right now, you have a portion of that TOT that is dedicated to capital projects.

10:10 Theoretically or potentially some more of that could be. When we worked on the CFFC work, we talked about as a way of controlling the amount of costs that are in that development impact fee.

10:22 Walter, I have a question. We're not currently doing that 2% out of the TOT. We're not. Right. That's a future. That's an idea. Right. Okay. That's why I was thinking it's not already 2%. It's not already done. Okay. But it's one of those things that was a recommendation that council, when we made a decision, when you gave direction on the decisions that surround it.

10:49 The fee adjustment, that was one of the directions that you, the council gave. Well, I think the council accepted and said, gee, in future years when there is more money, it sounds like it might be an idea. Well, I'm just being honest. I wanted a round number, okay? So the reason I, and you know, this is all variable because not only do you have those, that particular fund being variable, but you also have, you know, the economy and all these other things that are going to affect that funding.

11:17 But just for fun, and I just wanted a round number just so we could have something conceptual to talk about, you know, those funds, if you did that in year 2012 or whatever, you know, you'd be working with about $4 million of cash annually. So that's kind of the first step. Now, what's going to happen is obviously that those, actually in time, those revenues are going to change.

11:46 As the economy improves and as you achieve some level of reinvestment in the resort, you know, those numbers are going to rise. They'll rise as a function of that success. One of the things we'll be doing with our development forecast is providing you with technically consistent, if you will, forecasts of those revenues who can look at this in the future and say, well, geez, in this five-year cycle we may be playing with...

12:11 $4 million a year or something less than that depending on the TOT. But in the next five-year cycle, you know, that number is going to be higher. So the first box is really all about the money that you have available from those existing sources of funding that are at least conceptually available for doing these things. Funds available for capital improvement specific. Yes, that is right.

12:36 Funds available totally from those sources. Well, I don't think that's what you're saying. I think Walter's suggesting that it's available for capital, but that would be part of the question. Yeah. I mean, that they're available for capital projects, that's why, generally speaking, and not exclusively, because the language in the measures provides some variation there, but the logic that we're going with here is to maximize the funding for capital projects within a prudent framework.

13:06 So we're not, as you'll see in a moment with the next step, that we're going to be making another move with that money, but the first move is we're setting aside special funds to help with our resort investment process, building community facilities, building resort facilities, et cetera, et cetera. The first thing that happens nowadays in this kind of an environment is where you say, well, geez, it's great to fund things, but you've got to

13:36 Do some other things while you're building them. You've got to make sure that you maintain them at a reasonable level. You have to make sure that when they're broken or old that you can replace them. And finally, you may have to or may want to operate them at some level. So the first thing that we would want to be doing in this process, this normal process that I'm describing to you, is to make an allocation.

14:05 Of the available funds, a kind of policy allocation that says, well, we think that it's reasonable to take that 100% of funding, whatever that might be, and say 80% of it is going to go for project funding, capital, one way or the other. We're going to keep some of it and sink it away in a fund that we're not going to touch.

14:28 That will be available to us to help replace those facilities when they break after their 20-year life or however long their life may be. And then facility maintenance is another item of all the things you need to do to keep those facilities in shape. And then project planning and operations, you may want to allocate some funding to that. This first level basically is designed to say

14:54 When you build things, you want to take care of them, you want to replace them, and you want to operate them. And we can make those numbers I put in there, again, just purely for examples, they're kind of numbers that we've used, or general numbers that we may have used elsewhere, but that would be the council's decision to say, well, how do you want to balance those? And there may be some technical questions that arise around that, well, how much do you need? Those kinds of questions. And a staff, myself, will try to help you answer those questions.

15:23 At the end of the day, once you've made those decisions, you have a certain amount of money that you've then said, okay, we're going to take $4 million that we have available per year for the next five years, we're going to take $3 million of it, or $3.2, and we're going to use it for projects. Now the next question arises is, okay, well how are you going to use that money? And basically you have two choices. You can use that money for pay-as-you-go,

15:50 Cash out the door. Here's some money. Let's build something. Or you can leverage it with debt service. So those two boxes over there on the left below project funding are basically an arbitrary allocation. You say, well, how about if we take some of that money and just use it for annual cash awards? Because, you know, you never know. The small projects come up, and you may want to allocate it to those small projects that achieve the kinds of things we're trying to achieve and that are consistent with the

16:20 The statutes or the ordinances, et cetera, et cetera. But to really get something going here, the big move is you're going to have to issue some debt like you've done in the past, like the recent certificate of participation that is going to be defused during this fiscal year. So what we're saying is, okay, let's just for fun say that we take 10% of that money.

16:47 And put it towards cash awards, cash things that you would appropriate annually in your normal fashion, and take some other fraction of it and use it for debt service. What's going to happen then is you're going to, the next question that arises in that arrow that moves off to the right says, well, geez, how much debt capacity do we get if we have that much money that we can devote to debt service? Well, the answer is it depends on how you borrow the money. If you use a certificate of participation,

17:17 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

17:46 So anyway, we won't know exactly how much cash is available until you make a decision about which of those instruments and those kinds of things, and we will get into that a little bit technically as a part of our next workshop, if you're comfortable with where we're going here. Now the fun starts at the next step, because the fun starts as, okay, now,

18:14 We figured out how much money we have to spend on projects for a five-year period or so. How are we going to figure out what to spend the money on? And basically there's the formal process for this involves kind of two sort of factors. We show on the left side here of the chart the sources of these capital projects.

18:44 The capital improvement program, your master facility plans, such as the recent work that the rec committee has done, the resort investment strategy projects that Mark is talking about. So you already have a body of projects that are, as I said earlier, that work is being done on to clean them up.

19:06 Get them to the point where you can say, yes, this is a project that has merit and we want to consider funding. We just don't know what its priority is stacked up against all the other projects. So those are the candidate projects. But they have to be, in the normal system, they can't be fly, they have to come, everything's got to come through that. Somebody can't walk through the door in year three and say, geez, I really want to do this other thing. No, that's not going to work. Get in line for the next five year cycle.

19:37 Amend the CIP, develop a master facility plan, dot, dot, dot. Bring some things, bring the project through the normal process of getting ready for funding through the existing and or future capital financing mechanisms that the town operates. So that's what we do on that candidate project side. But what you're going to have

20:03 Like you do now, is a lot of projects, and like when we looked at the capital facilities financing fee originally, there was a, I don't know, $100 million worth of projects? No, more. There was, I don't remember, it was hundreds of those, $400 million worth of projects. Well, the $400 million worth of projects, you know, how are you going to fund that? How are you going to eat that elephant?

20:29 And so this process here is a way of answering that question. You put them all out there and say, well, we don't really know for sure how to eat this elephant. And if we just don't have any guidance or plan, what will happen is just going to be, as they talk about in management studies, swords and shields every year, you know, just battling it out. Whoever's got the loudest voice or the squeakiest wheel wins, and that's the way it works.

20:58 That may not be the most consistent way of approaching the kind of strategy that you need to do some of the things you want to do with your town and resort. So this process is a way of saying, okay, let's try and lend some logic to this. How do you do that? Well, the answer is that you come up with a set of ranking criteria, a ranking criteria process, in which you say, there are a number of considerations.

21:26 That would lend to make a project more equal than the next project. Some of it may have to do with the revenue restrictions, that is to say the priorities that the voters have set forth. Some may have to do with the general plan policies that Mark is working on, the so-called resort investment and public facilities element that will have goals and policies and standards in it and those sorts of things.

21:52 There's the whole topic of infrastructure phasing and linkage, of the order in which things can happen or need to happen that may influence decision. There's also the availability of matching funds. If somebody came along, a state agency or something, came along and said, geez, we'll give you 80% if you fund locally 20%, well, that might kick the project up a notch or two.

22:17 Obviously, similarly to that, you have these development agreements and CBiz community benefits, that is to say developers that may be willing to do something a little bit extra because of the benefits conferred through the development agreement or the CBiz. So that may be a thing that, again, kind of a matching situation that might give a project a higher set of points.

22:46 But what happens through this is that you basically set up those criteria and run through a process of point scoring the projects based upon these criteria. And once you've done that, they just wind up in a long list from top rank to last rank. Normally when this is done, and I've done it many times, people look at it and go, nah, we don't like that. And it causes you to go back and reconsider.

23:15 Some of the ways, the ranking and the criteria that you're using and stuff like that, but that's fine, that's part of the process. But at the end of the day, what you say is, well, you've got this long, you've got $400 million worth of projects, you've got $20 million or $30 million to spend in the next five years, so let's take the top five projects or eight projects or however many there are on there, and basically those are the ones that get funded, and you can build them.

23:43 And the others are deferred until the next cycle. And that's basically the way it works. Once you've made those funding decisions, of course, you've then got to take the funding actions, which means going out, issuing the debt, and doing all those exercises that you've done before many times. So this is the process that when I talk to Rob about this,

24:13 Knowing what I knew about what you've been doing before and also this idea of wanting to lend more order to the Measure R, Measure U, TOT, Project Funding. This is the idea that I have. Questions? Okay, Walter, back up there where you've taken the dollar amount, whatever it is, and you've broken into the four pieces.

24:37 I'm having a hard time understanding how a 5% replacement fund would ever give you the money to replace something. I mean, what are you talking about, life cycles of 40 years? Well, 5% would be life cycles for 20 years. For 20, but if you, okay.

24:54 And so are you saying that these are just like estimates and you'd actually work it out so if project number one goes through you'd have its life cycle just like a replacement study? Yes. Okay. Then when you get it down a little bit farther and you talk about let's say whatever the project is was made up of

25:19 90% federal funds like we got on Lake Mary Bike Path for some of those pieces. Then your replacement cost is going to have to be higher because you're not going to get that grant the second time, right? Yes, that is correct. And yes, the sinking fund will never be perfect because just for what the reasons you're saying. You're never going to get it just right. But would you rather have a situation where you were building a fund over time that was...

25:49 Restricted and hidden away that when those replacement needs were there that you could rely upon, perhaps not 100%, but at least in some measure, to fund. So it's not a perfect process. We can certainly do better by reference to the kind of analysis you were suggesting that dialing that number around. But at the end of the day, it's going to be somewhere in that the numbers that I've worked with over time have been 5-10% for doing that.

26:18 You're right, the matching fund thing kind of messes up the calculation for obvious reasons. The point here is not to just, it's not math here that we're trying to nail. It's just trying to be responsible, trying to set aside funds that's going to make the process of replacement easier in the future. Same thing with maintenance, you know, or operations for that matter. You know, these may not be perfect. And by the way,

26:48 First of all, these are just guesses for purposes of discussions like this, but year to year, you're going to need to fiddle with this to get this right. You're going to have a situation where the numbers, the budgeted numbers, will not be exactly consistent with this. This is just a process for setting aside monies to make those maintenance decisions, to minimize those operating decisions on other general fund resources.

27:14 What you don't want to do is build yourself into a budget problem, a worse budget problem. And doing this kind of process with these special funds is an insurance policy against them. Is it perfect? No. But is it hopefully responsible and minimize the future problems that you'll have balancing your general fund? We would hope so. That's the logic.

27:40 Speaking of budget problems and with your background and knowledge in this area, this is all with the understanding that prior to the town being eligible for COP or any other funding sources, it's reasonable to believe that we must resolve the Hot Creek lawsuit prior to any borrowing. Yeah, it would be tough to go to market with that on an open item.

28:09 Yeah, there's no question about that. And honestly, I'm aware of the situation, and Rob has obviously shared those numbers with me, not a pretty situation. But at the same time, not, I mean, it seems to me, just looking at the numbers, while it's very not pretty, it seems to me that it's at least potentially manageable. And once the settlement can be resolved, then...

28:39 It's there, and then, yes, you can go to market. I'm just saying it would be, if we want to look at this as a reality, the other reality is that we need to have emphasis on settling that lawsuit sooner rather than later. Sure.

28:56 Well, and what this is really telling to me is what the original measure, our steering committee said in the document that they brought to council is saying, you know, you have to identify all your costs for each of those projects up front instead of what we had been doing in the interim so that we do need, and this gives us a way to get back to that recommendation. And to better estimate the expenses in each category. Yeah.

29:25 We don't currently have a sinking fund, do we, Rob? Not for a capital fund. Do we have a maintenance fund? We don't have a maintenance fund, but we allocate certain amounts for maintenance. So, for example, with streets, we know, we have an engineering study that tells us how much we need to spend per year in order to keep the streets at the level that we like them at. Okay. And we're working up to that number. It's like a million dollars, and we went from about $200,000 four or five years ago to $750,000 a year now.

29:54 With park maintenance, most of our facilities are recreation facilities. We haven't really done that. I think we're under budget. We're not spending enough money for that. So we definitely need to work towards a higher number in that area as well. Right. I guess even if we didn't get a COP and we ended up funding something with cash, we should still be doing that. Yeah. Yes, indeed. Rob, what were the replacement funds we have? I know we have vehicle. Do we have anything else?

30:23 That's the only fund where there's actually seeking funds. So like computer equipment or replacing that old system, we don't have those yet. That's a case of go. And you can see the result of that. We have areas like the police department where the computers are being completely available. The other thing I would point out with the road fund, for example, it was funded at a normal level. Then you robbed it because of your budget problems.

30:54 And now it's back to where it was before. It wasn't like it went from 200 to 750 to that bad level. Then it went down, then it came back up. So I think that was a misrepresentation. Well, that's not exactly true because it did go to zero to about 500,000. It's because we had grant money that came in on a long-time basis. So we're pretty consistent. Yeah. Yeah. This, that topic, what we just drifted into about, say, road funds,

31:21 You know, the same, we're talking about something special here, not the roads and sewers and all those other things, but the same principles apply there. You know, you really do want, and in our work, you know, we think that it's coming back to Joe's point on this, that these sinking funds or maintenance allocations are never perfect.

31:42 But they're a lot better than not doing anything. Because what happens is that they're like an insurance policy against downturns like we're in now in difficult times when you can rely on these basically reserved funds to take care of things and not be in a situation of having to decide, well, we're not going to water the grass or mow the grass or resurface the streets.

32:09 We're going to basically erode our capital assets. It's just really a good idea to try to do this, whether it's in the road fund. Here we're talking about special funds and special projects, which are community facilities, resort facilities, using these particular special funds. Mr. Keeter, one question. Joe looked at the replacement thing. What jumped out at me was the automation side. In your experience, what...

32:38 How does that number fluctuate, between five and one? It can be, it's just all, that is a policy decision, because that this, there's no, there is no rule. We normally here, we spend, it seems like we spend a lot of money on operations here, more so than maybe it might happen in other places, just because of the size of the population, so like an ice rink, for example. Right. It would be good to,

33:05 Figure out ways to operate facilities at the least cost possible so you can... Where have you seen that number? In other words, where have you seen that number? Five or what? Well, yeah, sure, sure. Like, for example, let's just say for fun that you were publicly financing a convention center. Yeah, that number would have to... Operations, heating, cooling, operating a convention center is going to push that number up to 15, 20%. Is that what you want to do with those monies? That's what this...

33:34 Council is going to decide. Yes? One point, Ted. In Park City, actually, they will budget to three separate levels of service. They ask by departments, and there's the normal, there's the high level, there's the low level, and it's a very effective way of showing what you would cut out, and the departments do it. It's done, the departments get together, the employees will decide how to budget 10% below normal.

34:03 5%? Yeah. Yeah, this, again, this, this, it's very important just to keep in mind here, this, we're dealing here with a very special case of, of source of revenues that voters have entrusted to you to use in, in, in, in a way that is most beneficial to the community and most responsible. And it, it seems to me that the way to do that is to emphasize project funding.

34:32 And big project funding. That's my instinct here, based on everything I know about Mammoth Lakes. And to not, I mean, I hate to use the term, but waste away these special resources on quote-unquote operations that might otherwise be funded by general fund sources. You know, we don't want these special funds to be, you know, de facto general funds. I think that's the trust, the issue that we have here.

35:01 And so you want to try prudently to maximize the project funding, I think. Well, and I could agree with that, Walter, but essentially, if we take that 2% out of TOT, we just took that 2% out of the general fund. Well. Because that's where it goes now. Well, that's fine. Again, that's a decision that you need to make as you go forward here. You do have a budget issue, and the settlement agreement, of course, is going to be part of that.

35:31 There will be a reality here. And by the way, we can, as a part of this process, we can dial in on that and ask those questions. Again, I just did this because I wanted to have a round number. Right, and I think this works as an example, but I want to make sure everybody understands that that's essentially saying the 2% of TOT that's going into general fund right now.

35:53 Is going into these projects. And the use of that money, again, the question here is, the 2% target was, came, I did not invent that, again, it came out of the CFFC recommendations who were trying to figure out ways to create a more stable and broadly based source of funding for capital projects and didn't have to rely on development that was going to happen.

36:21 Can I make a comment on that, though? One of the things that's happened is that we've gone into a recession and we've pushed down the number of employees to a much lower level than what we had before. And so I think part of the thinking that the CFMC had was that as we grow out of the recession, instead of adding back employees, you have choices. You can add more employees and more services, or you can add more money and capital.

36:45 And I'm actually looking forward to the point where we have a little bit better project accounting because Matthew was saying, and I agree with him, is we could be spending that much on operations and maintenance of some of our things without knowing it at this point. Or hidden costs.

37:15 That you're not even accounting for now. That's what I mean. Yeah. Yeah. And that's basically not a proven way to budget. So this discussion we're having is a very good one because this is exactly the kinds of questions and decisions you'll need to make. In other words, we have to enliven each of those boxes, ask those hard questions, and you'll need to make a decision. But remember that even then,

37:44 It's just a policy you're making, just a framework for establishing a five-year funding target if for some reason something happens or something changes or whatever. You're not really committing funds until you issue that debt. So that's the moment of truth. So until then, you can make adjustments here.

38:14 You know, there's obviously the need to be, have some flex here, but what we're trying to do is try to establish a rational basis for deciding what's most important to build out of this long list of stuff. That's what we're trying to do. Not necessarily predict with precision how much money you're going to have available from you to get, for whatever reason. Yes.

38:41 You talk about this issue of debt. Is there a particular point where you would feel if the debt was too expensive, where you'd kind of keep the power dry and save the money? I mean, what percentage is that at, the 8%? I mean, I know that right now the beauty markets are a disaster, so I don't know if you'd go out and issue debt right now. Well, that's right. This is not a time to be barred, well, it all depends, but generally speaking, you're right, credit markets are...

39:10 A little tight, as they say, in the union market. But yeah, we're not talking about doing any of this tomorrow. I'm just asking, is there a particular level where you would feel comfortable, like at a certain interest rate? You know, no one, let's just run, to answer your question, I'll run a scenario. Let's say that we went through a process like this in this calendar year. You know, we really did.

39:37 And we went through this workshop process, but then you were confident about it, and then you went through it in some more detail to really nail some of the questions that you're bringing up. And then we said, okay, we've got our five-year projects, and now it's the end of the year. And we said, well, we've figured out, we've got this money, and it's basically accumulating, the cash is accumulating in an account. We haven't spent it yet.

40:05 The amount that's available for a debt service is just sitting there. We haven't built anything. We haven't committed anything. And you know what projects you want to build. And at that point, you look at the market. And you go, and the break-even, there's no way of exactly saying that because it depends on the type of instrument, the term of it and all those other things. But your point is well taken that at the present time, this is not the time we would be issuing debt. A year from now, we may.

40:32 I'm not making a point. I'm actually just asking you, like, are you comfortable with 5%, 7%? There is not a straight answer to that question. It depends on circumstances. You know, it depends on what the leverage that you're getting from that interest rate. It depends on a variety of considerations. You cannot say that 5.5% is a tipping point.

41:00 It's just, isn't there, there's not, I can't do that. No public finance person would ever do that because you don't know what else is going on. It all has to do with factors of inflation, of opportunities that are created from other funding sources and a whole variety of other considerations. There is a decision point. There's no doubt. But it's not one that you can just simply say, well, we're going to write in there a trigger of seven points.

41:28 My guess is it's probably similar to financing a home. It may cost you more in interest, but if you can get the construction costs for significantly less, you might say, okay, it's a good idea. Yeah, well, that's right. It's a tipping point. Now, again, the point is a very, very good point. And we would want to have a go-no-go kind of decision here about what is in the bond measure.

41:55 Whether it's a certificate, whether it's some other instrument, all of those things are something you do later. But even if you didn't issue because conditions weren't right, you would be in a good position because you would be accumulating funds that will help you cover that debt service when it ultimately starts, or you can issue less debt because you have cash. So you write, you just issue less debt.

42:24 And you know what you're doing. That is to say, you know what your priorities are. This is the most important thing. You know that the highest ranking thing for you to do with these funds is this project. And that's something that doesn't exist right now. And that, I think, would be very, very, very valuable. And this idea of leveraging, assuming that conditions are right, gives you the ability to achieve these projects.

42:52 A lot faster than waiting around for the cash to just sum up in annual awards. And that gives you the ability to use these valuable, precious funding resources that voters have created to fund some big projects that really gets a bang for the community and for the resort. Other questions?

43:24 No question. I just have a comment. What I like about this, this really ties in well with when we were talking about restructuring our budget, it was a component of our budget that I think we felt was missing was when we had all these assets, how we were going to allocate for depreciation and things like that, which, you know, we have certain things breaking down. It's like, well, where to get the money for that? I think this kind of covers that, and it'd be nice to be able to see that along the way.

43:54 Yeah, and again, this is a bit of a special case, but the same logic applies, and I certainly think that your work on the budget where you're trying to take care of some of these things and give yourself a little more insulation against future events is a really good idea and improved. But this, we're really talking about here, I think, this idea of building, maximizing,

44:24 The time in which you can build some of these facilities that people have been talking about and fiddling around with for a very, very long time, but unable to achieve simply because it was using the money around. And the work that the CFFC did to say, well, that was a nice plan to think you were going to get $400 million out of developers, that was a good plan, but if there's not any development, you're not going to get any money.

44:49 And if the burden of those kinds of charges are chasing people away, that's also not a good thing. So we want to strike a balance here, and that's what this kind of a plan will help us do. So that's, again, how this kind of thing would work. The next step would be more at a technical level.

45:18 And we can actually go through the process of asking some, documenting some specific questions, some of which you've already asked about this, about what the appropriate numbers in these boxes are. But remember that even when we do that, it's still an exercise. We're not adopting a budget. We're just kind of playing around here, just going through a process to get us to

45:46 The ability to make some decisions about projects. So it's a little, or the precision that we're seeking with the numbers in those boxes is a little less than it might be, say, if you were doing like in a so-called pavement management program for your roads. That's just straight away. You know, that's math. You're going to say, well, you know, you need to sink about $5,000 a lane mile.

46:13 Every year to make sure that you can seal, overlay, and rebuild that road in a timely way. And that's just, the engineers will just, and that number's, you can calculate right to admit, these numbers are going to be a little different. Walter, I do have another question, and it was something that was in the agenda information, and

46:38 If we get a COP or some other kind of bonding for Project X in the future, is the presumption that you've pulled out replacement O&M, etc., out of that because you cannot bond for those things? Yes. Yeah, I mean, in other words, you're only...

47:03 What the certificate does, or any, really, any of these kind of bond, whatever technique we use, you're pledging money. You're pledging a specific amount of money that comes from a source. And there will be, undoubtedly, be some coverage requirements and these sorts of things, and that will all get worked out. And you have a model in the certificate that you recently, this and this last six years.

47:30 No. Okay. You wouldn't.

48:00 The answer is, though, that you wouldn't, that's not the point. That's not what you're doing. You're really, the maintenance money is just being appropriated annually. You know, you're just, that's your, somebody says, you know, we've got to mow the grass, it costs this much. Replacement, again, we're just putting a certain amount of money in a piggy bank and burying it away for some future date. We don't need the bond for that.

48:25 Maybe later you can use that money as a part of a bond to do replacement, but you're just putting money away and hiding it. Operations, again, is money you're appropriating and expending annually. So, no, you don't bond for those things. You're just bonding for the project part and you're allocating a certain fraction to them. I have another question that's not really related to this, but it was in the agenda bill, is we are being, again, told about this proposed resort.

48:57 investment strategy or the resort investment element of the general plan, etc. And, you know, I was hoping that would be one of the things we would talk about more than at the Planning Commission study session that we just canceled.

49:13 I'm not clear, and I know from a conversation that Rick and I had as the recreation subgroup, is none of us are really sure what we're expecting out of that. We're just getting told that we're getting something, and I don't know if anybody else is interested in having that brought forward maybe at the next time so that we can understand really what that is. Because I get confused between that.

49:35 And the CIP that other people are working on, and we've got all these parallel tracks, but do we really understand how they work together at the end? Not for tonight, because I, you know, we, just having something told to us, we need to. If I could give you a. This is a cold, just a little background. Would you talk for me? Okay. Hey, this is a good one. You've got him. So, with the CFFC report,

50:05 I don't expect you to remember it, but it was a cover by Walter, and then there were two separate attachments that Ray and I had prepared with it. One was an audit of all of our plans, and as we reviewed all of the plans, we found that the projected population is supposed to be 10,000 people last year, and so we found that our analyses were not very...

50:31 They weren't accurate. They weren't thorough. They weren't updated. The linkages and the material that you find, the policy stuff that's in these master plans wasn't complete. So they need to be, if you want to be able to do that and plan and build for the future, you should have reliable forecast information, and that's what Walter's working on now. You should size your facilities to meet that forecast. So, you know, what is the housing?

51:00 Demand that we should be working for and towards out of the housing elements. If you don't have an accurate forecast, you're just making it up and you might be way over, you might be way under, who knows? So that's one important element of this investment element. The other aspect of it is very much in line with what's going on here. Our documents, the master plans, there's nothing that describes the trigger of when a facility is needed.

51:30 Is it needed when the population has grown by 10%? Is it needed to drive visitation? There's nothing in there. There is absolutely no return on investment analysis. If in a scenario like this, one of the things you want to try to do is develop your fiscal revenues to support the bond measures. If your fiscal revenue stream is stagnant, then you're not growing capacity to pay for successive bond issues. You don't want to just do one.

52:00 You're probably doing one and two and three and four in different series with different funding sources. So none of our planning documents have an analysis of what you're getting and why you're making that decision. So return on investment, are you driving visitation? In visitation, what would a 5% increase in annual occupancy rates in town mean to us financially? And then if you have a project that is...

52:29 We're going to create graphs that's not driving visitation, or you're going to create an events menu that is drawing people with programming to town. You're going to get a different outcome. So this and the successive projects behind that should be focused on hopefully fiscal, economic, and business stability first. So the resort element, and it's called the resort investment and public facilities element.

52:59 Because it's not just public facilities, it's the related program that comes with the hotel. So if you had a hotel that had some conference space, it is now their part to fill that conference space that supports the overall business economy. So the aspect of investment, whether it's public or private, should be expressed in a planning document. The resort element itself is broad and high level.

53:28 And many of its contents are already expressed in the CFFC work. The other aspect of it, from top all the way to the bottom, is the capital improvement program. And so Ray and I are doing the development, and we have other people working on five-year capital improvement programs for every subject, so that you can see the recreation subject, and it's prioritized in that way. You can see the storm drain.

53:57 Subject, Prioritize, and then across the board you're able to evaluate the priorities from subject to subject to subject to subject. And so that element and taking it all the way down into the asset management policies that you can see in the CIP program is what that program is for. And the amount of work that goes into it because the plans and documents aren't adequate, some of them aren't complete.

54:24 Trail System Master Plan is probably the best one we have now. And to get them up to that speed, but also to set the policies so that the future documents are telling you, you know, what the program is, when you need it, what its phasing is, and a return on investment, you're going to need that. Or you should want it. But it's a fair statement, Mark, that at current, to Jo's point about this being a little nascent or...

54:55 That this point is true and that there's work that needs to be done to get that nice clean list and for you to understand what exactly we're talking about. Well, and that's been my concern for the last several months is we're expecting a lot of things to miraculously appear in June and it's just, you know, is this really going to happen? Is it really going to come together? And how's it going to fit in with rec strats? Sandy, yeah.

55:27 Sandy Hogan and a member of the Budget Reformatting Committee, but my comments are as an individual member of that committee, and I want to commend Walter and the council for this, because my great worries and what I kept seeing was we had a lot of unconnected pieces and a planning process, you know, CIP and you have the facilities master plan and direct priorities, but nothing was really integrated.

55:56 Is a process that makes sense to me. And it's your future planning. Whether you implement it this year or next year or pieces or whatever, at least it ties all the big picture together. We have a CIP. Mobility Commission, you know, we review that each year. We try to make comments on it. It's always being developed. It's always in a state of flux. But slowly but surely, it's better every year.

56:23 And that's the way with your CIP, which was developed in 2007, not the CIP, I'm sorry, the Facilities Master Plan. All of these are pieces of a whole, but what was bothering me and my expertise on the Budget Reformatting Committee had to do with project and process, the planning process, how do you lay out projects, how do you lay out funding, especially when you have multiple funding sources and sometimes they pop up and sometimes they don't. And I guess what I see here is for the first time,

56:51 A real framework I think that's going to work. And as Walter says, it's not perfect because these are always going to evolve, but this is the first time when all of these pieces are being tied together. So you can kind of see the planning process for projects, facilities is what we're talking about here primarily.

57:13 Because there are other planning projects, that's a whole separate thing that, you know, can be worked on, I'm sure. But this one does tie it together. And, you know, I especially like the top, the project funding. You know, you look at a project and you need to know things about it. How well is it planned out? What is it going to cost you? What is its expected lifetime? Is it 40 years? Is it 10 years? What do you have to replace within 10 years or 40 years? And that will allow you to make some really good decisions.

57:42 You may just set aside a small amount. But there are grants out there, and that small amount in one sinking fund may make a match, you know, with the state. A lot of these are feds that are 90%, and some of them don't even require matches. So, frankly, as I say, speaking for myself, this is the part of our budget reformatting that we really didn't get into because our scope was pretty tight, and it was much more on, you know, the spreadsheets and the actual budget.

58:10 Format type of thing. But this is what I was hoping to be able to see start being implemented. And I was frankly very worried about all these separate studies. I love it. See them finally tied together where they make sense. So I want to thank you and congratulate you guys for pushing forward with this in spite of hard times. But you've got to plan for success. You've got to have fallbacks. But you always have to plan for success because we're going to come back. So anyway, my comments. Thank you.

58:40 Thank you, Shannon. Thank you, and I do know that that budget reform is going on, and although there are a lot of things going on, that's bad news, but it's also good news, because it means that you can kind of recreate and do things a little differently than have been before, and problems are good, you get to solve them.

59:06 The things that I, at least my experience here in the last few years, suggests that that it's totally, we have good ability to do that if we can bring all these things into some harmony and focus, which is what has been lacking. The process that we would, the way that we would proceed from this evening would be to

59:36 What I would want to do is to, at the next workshop, start being more tangible on both the candidate project side and on these criteria side. Normally, I've actually already done this because I did a little piece on this as a part of the CFFC work, and Mark and Ray did some of this work too. We actually started.

1:00:05 began to create a priority, project priority system. So I'm going to just dredge that work up that I did, because that's another thing, to make use of what you've already invested money in for this process, and say, okay, let's look at that and work through it. And so what it winds up being is literally you're going to say,

1:00:30 That if the project implements the general plan, now the question of course is, what is the general plan? That's your point, you haven't seen this yet, or this part of it anyway, but that's going to be a criteria. Or another example of a criteria would be, this relates to something that Mark said about phasing and linkage. Is this project necessary to

1:00:59 You're related to some trigger of some sort, population, the advent of some private project or something else. That's a criteria that would then tend to advance that project up in its ranking. One of the other things that you do with these criteria, and there may be five or eight of them, is you also weight them, because some criteria are more important than others.

1:01:27 And the ultimate scoring is done by a composite of the raw ranking and the weighting of the project. But I would literally get into that. When I've done this before with this exercise, and I've done this exact exercise with a lot of different elected groups of elected officials, it's always been very interesting, just the discussion of what represents.

1:01:54 What is most important is a very interesting discussion. So setting these criteria, although it's a sort of technical thing, it actually brings up all sorts of stuff, which is always very interesting to do. So that's what we would be talking about doing, again, all as an exercise. And so even on the capital side, even though the lists and things that we have right now may not be perfect, you know, I would have Ray say, in two weeks' time, say, well, let's just...

1:02:24 Come up with, dig out the old master facilities plan list, which we have and worked with during CFFC or some variant of that, and just, it's not perfect. It may not have everything or may have things on it that you don't want to fund anymore. But just for an exercise, we'll develop or agree about that list. And what would happen is that if we get through that process in the next workshop,

1:02:52 We would go away, staff and myself would go away, and actually go through the process of ranking and scoring based upon the criteria that you set forth, and just as a demonstration. Well, as a demonstration, if you've already done some work, is it possible for you to bring, like,

1:03:11 Three examples that come from three of the different areas within this and just work with those since we're just using them as exemplars instead of having to go back and go through some old plan, you know, like one that maybe was going to be mostly bond funded, one that was going to be half grant or something like that, just to give us something to play with in the discussion of the ranking criteria. Yes, that's an excellent, yeah. Instead of...

1:03:39 Going, you know, because, I'm sorry, the 2007 plan, we all know it's old. Yeah. That's fine. Yes, I, yes, and Mark, that's something you and Ray and I can talk about tomorrow, but I absolutely agree. So, I'm looking at something that when we get to the things of deciding what would be your criteria and how you might rank them, there's differences between the exemplars, so we have something to talk about. Right. Yeah. Yeah, the, yes, and my only caution is that, like, the point you made earlier, that

1:04:08 That may not be the whole deck. No, and since it's only for a practice session, we're not approving any of those at this point because we know that all those things have to be resized, etc. It's an exercise with using real things, recognizing that most of the things that you've assumed and stuff are incomplete or perhaps not entirely accurate, but it's a purpose. We're talking here about developing a decision-making system.

1:04:38 Not a particular outcome, at least for this thing that we're doing here in these working sessions. No, because we won't have the updated information. Exactly. And then once you have the system, you would then set that aside and you would go over the next period of time, the work that Mark and Ray and others are doing would come to fruition in June or whenever.

1:05:05 And you may have some better information about the settlement that gives us some more confidence about moving forward with something like this. There may be some technical questions about how to dial better, given the mix of projects that we're talking about, how to dial that top-level allocation. That was really the question you asked at the outset.

1:05:31 And because let's say we come up with – we sort of cycle through this and we say, well, the projects that are at the top of the list, you know, geez, it's going to cost more to operate than that. So then we've got to cycle back through and kind of fiddle with that to get it right. But at least you have a process for making those decisions. And, Walter, there's one other thing that when we discussed this as a council last fall, we were kind of looking for a –

1:05:58 What were we calling it? A toolbox of what kind of, you know, how municipal finance, how municipal dollars work. And that was covered a little bit under CFFC, but will this next step just give us kind of like a primer for anyone who isn't ready yet in bonds and all the other options that we have? Yes, there are a standard set of techniques.

1:06:28 There's a tendency, there's been a tendency to use certificates. Municipalities are very fond of certificates because they have a relatively low cost of issuance by comparison. They also tend to be shorter term so that it's kind of like having a 15-year mortgage on your house rather than a 30. And so you get a little less leverage.

1:06:55 But you, but you, you, you defease the issue faster and then you can cycle, you can get your money back and go again. So, and this comes to the question about that, all of those issues about, you know, how much leverage you're getting and how much the interest rates are and all those kinds of things, it's, you're really just, it's a balancing point. So yeah, we'll, we'll have a, we'll talk about those different mechanisms.

1:07:22 All of these mechanisms are ultimately, even though you pledge revenues, like you say we're going to pledge these special funds, they're all full faith and credit. You know, that's what they're secured by. No matter, all of these that we're going to be talking about, whether it's a tax revenue anticipation note or some kind of escrow bond or some kind of cop or any of these other things, they all are full faith and credit instruments.

1:07:51 They're not like a GO bond that's secured with the land or a special tax that's secured by a special tax. They're all full payment credit, which means that issues like the settlement and other budget issues come into play when you go to market. And so we're going to want to, and this also relates back to the topic about the budget,

1:08:17 Hopefully in this next year or two before we actually go to market with something like this, all of that stuff can be cleaned up and you can be on a stronger footing. I have a question as far as the candidate projects. Is this system that we're looking at here really just to determine what funding avenue to go with or is it actually a tool to be used to help prioritize which projects to go with? It's both.

1:08:48 Okay. And one leads you to the other because one basically, the box there that says all the stuff up top is to say how much money do we have to spend? So it's that. So that's both. The first thing you say is we've got 30 million bucks to spend or we think we can issue responsibly and prudently 30 million dollars. What do we got on a list that adds up to 30 million dollars? Right. And so that's where the priority comes in. So it's both.

1:09:16 I guess you may envision this, that we may be looking at a more general, if we had 20 projects and we could only afford to fund, let's say, 10 of them, would we do that initially and then filter those down through? Yes. Okay, versus filtering all of them through and saying, okay, here's what may work best? That is correct. We would want to, again, when I came to work on the fee project, I looked at that list and I went, oh my God.

1:09:44 That's $400 million. Where's that going to come from? Knowing what I knew about the rate of development and other sources and things. And the big move or the most important aspect of that whole exercise was really setting, I think Rob said, setting the underpinning for this kind of system. It says, let's get real here. You know, if you want to build stuff, you've got to figure out how to raise money.

1:10:11 You know, in big enough piles so that you can actually take some of this stuff down, whether it's funded with fees or maybe special revenues or other special debt that you do. So, yes, it's all about, this is all about setting forth a rational basis for, well, I'll say, eating the elephant, building your way into the future, deciding what is the most high value, most important, most critical project on a very long list. You are not abandoning.

1:10:40 Or saying that some project is not needed or not valuable, you're just saying we're not going to fund it in the next five years. We're going to fund it five years down the pipe when we really need it or we need it because of demand or whatever. Okay. Both is the answer to your question. Both outcomes. And the other thing too is that

1:11:10 This does nest within the budget. It nests within the fee, the diff program. It may nest within some completely unrelated funding measure that you do later, the general obligation. These are all, they're all part of the same thing, but this, what we're doing here relates to these three

1:11:39 Sources that you have available for capital projects and trying to maximize your utility. But yes, what we'll do for this next round is consistent with what Councilman of the Bank has said. We won't start from scratch. We'll bring the things that we've done. We'll dredge up the work that we did that really actually...

1:12:09 In the CFC crisis, that never really saw the light of day. We never really brought that forward in any material way, but we can at this time. And similarly, we can come up with, dredge up from the various lists and project things, those projects that we think may have merit going forward, just to give us something to work with.

1:12:37 As a starting point. As Mark said, certainly the rec master plan is, I think, well done and has a number of projects in it. And there are any number of other projects that I think are ones that we're pretty sure are going to be on the ultimate list. So let's just put them on a sort of tentative list for working on the business. Mark, do you think that's possible? Other questions?

1:13:06 Other questions? No, I just, for the benefit of those that are going to listen to the webcaster later, can you remind us when the next session is? March 9th. March 9th. Okay. Tentatively, maybe that's going to be just on my calendar. I would be subject, of course, to all of your calendars and all that. What do I have on there? If there are no other questions, we will...

1:13:40 Adjourn this meeting until our next regular council meeting, February 16th at 6 p.m. in the county chambers. Thank you, Walter. Thank you for your help. A pleasure. I look forward to this. Thank you. Jamie, did you want to keep this for Rick? Are you going to be there in the morning?