TransparentMammoth

Trails Committee · 2019

Trails Committee

· recording 2 hr 15 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

292 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:11 Daniel, how are you? I'm great. All right, we're calling this meeting to order at 3.04, Mammoth Trails Committee meeting, last one of the year. Welcome. Thanks for all for coming. Busy time of year. Angie, could you give us a roll call to get us started, please? Finley Torrance. Dan Holler. Here. John Mueller. Bill Souser. Yep. Elise Howell. Here.

0:44 And David Page. Here. Thank you. Thank you. So kick us off. Any public comments on items not on the agenda? You guys got anything you want to brace us with? There being none, let's move right into the approval of special meeting minutes for October 31st. I move to approve. I move to approve. I move to approve. I will second. Motion and second. Any further discussion on the meeting minutes? Any tweaks?

1:18 All those in favor of approving the minutes say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. I guess we'll just go ahead and shift it over to Joel for items two through nine. Go ahead and just walk us through. Very good. Thank you, David. Thank you all for joining us. First item I'd like to discuss with the committee today is winter grooming needs. As you know,

1:53 We are grooming in Shady Rest. We got some enough adequate snowfall to begin the program nice and early this year. And we are operating with equipment that is fairly old. We fix equipment over the course of a season consistently. It does break down. We're using the same equipment that Mammoth Nordic provided many years ago. I think maybe, I want to say 12 or 15 years ago.

2:23 The Nordoni, the famous Nordoni. It's an Italian machine. The manufacturer no longer manufactures them. Mammoth Mountain Resort recently asked us if we wanted theirs. We said yes so we could cannibalize it for parts. The reason they chose to get rid of theirs is because it's no longer supported with parts or anything from Italy. So today we want to start having a discussion about how to replace that equipment. I want to get a sense.

2:53 of, you know, how big do we want to go? I've heard in the past several years everything from we need a full-blown snowcat to let's just get a snowmobile and see if that works. So, you know, this image I've put together probably isn't the kind of detail that we need around this discussion, but here I'm just trying to illustrate that we have some choices.

3:18 Some less expensive choices, and we could go full-blown piston bully electric as of this year. They have electric snowcats that they are now selling to ski areas across the world. They have biodiesel snowcats that marginally are okay. For the NORDONI program to do the Shady Rest winter grooming, you can see in the upper left,

3:44 That is something that we already have, that drag behind, that is called a Tid Tech Groomer. We have that. And I don't know what you call that little buggy, Bill. This is a side-by-side OHV. That particular one's a Polaris. Right, so that would run. They have what they call mat tracks on it. Put tires on it for the summer, tracks on it for the winter. That could work. We'd want to test it first in some Mammoth snowpack.

4:14 To make sure that we could actually get through four feet of wet, heavy snow. We'd want to really do some testing before we purchase anything. But I'd like to get a sense and some direction as to how big do we want to go. I've talked to Dan about this over time. It's definitely not the snowcat option, we don't think. But I would like to maybe get some feedback from you guys. What kind of money should we look to spend?

4:44 I know Dan would have a pretty good grasp on that. Maybe Matt with MLR would have a good grasp on that toward the future, how much money might be available. I kind of like the idea of a machine that we could also use in the summer. If a side-by-side machine would work, I see that as pretty ideal for our whole program. I'm more than happy to kick this off.

5:14 I believe and have always believed, and this goes back to the start of Measure R, that the town should have in its fleet of vehicles a full-size snowcat. And that's for several reasons. That is not just for grooming our cross-country, Nordic, dog walking, everything else. But we don't know what's going to happen with the lawsuits that keep getting piled on, the green sticker program, whether that stays available, and that's almost 100 miles of groomed trail we wouldn't be able to groom.

5:41 Also, for major events and major winters, just as a rescue vehicle, it makes sense. However, that being said, I don't think it's something we can afford in the next three to five years. I think that Measure R is going to be well spoken for in that time frame. I am very intrigued by the side-by-side with the tracks on it. Your total investment in that machine, unless I...

6:10 Haven't looked at, and they've gone up significantly, probably about 20 grand with everything we need for winter and summer, which is a very doable thing. My question with it is the same as you. Will it pull without getting stuck, without pre-grooming our implements, which we have two of? Anything halfway in between to me doesn't make...

6:40 Any sense. The mid-sized versions have never worked well. So I think for right now, I think that definitely, long term, this town needs a full-size piece of equipment for rescue operations, for grooming operations, for a million different things. It just makes sense for the town to have one. Available for the PD to do Lakes Basin. I mean, it's just, it's an invaluable piece of equipment.

7:10 But for next year, which is when we're probably going to need this, the Nordoni was not a good piece of equipment when it was brand new, so I am surprised we've managed to nurse it along as long as we have. Takes practice. I am hoping. I have a friend who said he's going to put those tracks on his side-by-side this year, and I'm hoping to borrow it to get a chance for us to go out and see what we think.

7:37 I would be unwilling to make that decision without seeing one in operation. I know the gentleman that used to own the Polaris shop here in town groomed for some people up in the Knolls unofficially, using one with a drag so it can be done. But for me, right now, that's the direction I see us going for the next four or five years would be one of those with the tracks on it. Excellent.

8:06 Jump in, kind of some of our comments, we've had discussions before on Piston Bully for the Town, the big snowcat element there, if you did that, that wouldn't just be a measure of our expenditure, that'd be multiple, because it's not just committed to trails, and it'll be a tug of war where it goes, where it lives, and the maintenance on it, and training people how to drive it, because all the cops will want to spend time in it, which, not for the necessary for rescuing people, just fun to drive. So, anyway, some of their staff might want to learn how to drive them, too, just for fun.

8:36 Well, and Dan, that's a good thing, not a bad thing. No, but I mean, long term, that, something out there, potentially, I'm just, sorry, a little bit, kidding a little bit, but it's, long term, the town, do we need one? We'll see. I mean, if we, if we really do, when we have needed access, I think, I thought the sheriff bought one a while back, or was going to, I'm not sure if they did or not, but we've also borrowed out of the mountain, I know for search and rescue, when necessary, they've been a good partner in those areas, but I would agree with Bill in the short term, looking at, you know, do we look at a type of a hybrid vehicle that.

9:04 Assuming it works. Right. I don't mind taking a look at that. Again, whether that's 100% a major R-funded purchase or not, it'll be a different discussion there in terms of how we're going to use it within the program and what have you. And then I don't know, I'm assuming, Joel, it's set up for our type of implements that would be simple enough to be able to pull something that we currently have out there. Yeah, in fact, the one in the... I don't know if that's quite like art. It's precisely the same product. Is that the same piece there? Yeah. Same product.

9:32 We have a couple there, so I'm assuming at that point we wouldn't be buying new implements, just the vehicle. Just the vehicle. Right. So far. Joel, does our one implement have wheels that lower so you can do it on pavement? Yeah, that particular one is functional that way. We can go across the road with it. What makes that piece of equipment even more attractive is those are all rubber tracks. Yeah.

10:02 So in a town-owned vehicle, they can drive around on roads as well, just as a snow removal piece of equipment. So it would make it available for us to groom trails on both sides of town. Besides Shady Rest, we could do the meadow by just simply driving it down Old Mammoth Road and back off into the snow and groom. With proper permits in place or agreements to do that, of course, we can take it wherever it was needed. That's an interesting point.

10:33 Yeah, I don't have anything to add other than that. I think Dan's point is a good one. If we were to get into a big full-on piston bully and the town was wanting to have a piece of that too, it could really impact our small grooming program. We should probably have a dedicated machine for the grooming program. Yeah, I would agree with that because I think all of a sudden it gets yanked out and that becomes a secondary purpose versus a primary purpose. And then the only other piece, if we're talking about looking forward and potentially grooming elements of the mop or...

11:02 Or in the meadow, you know, let's just consider the fact that there might be tunnels that it would need to go through. Right. Yeah, and you want to make sure that it can do that on Basin. I've always thought it'd be awfully nice to have a groomed track up to the lakes basin, but you can't get a big piston bully underneath that bridge. Right. So. Good. It'd be nice if we had, you know, one that we could demo at some level so we could actually make sure it works out. Yeah, I'm going to try to make that happen.

11:34 So, I mean, we can work down that. I wouldn't commit any dollars to it at this point, but if you want to do a little research on what that takes and rough cost estimates would be nice to know. Yeah, it'd be a small investment for me to do some investigative work on a side-by-side and the potential for us to use one of those. Right, and it would help in the summertime for the trail program. I'm sure we've added up utility box and regular tires, et cetera. And consult with Matt about what seems like a possible fundraising piece.

12:02 Yeah. I'm looking at them now. It seems like they're pretty directly in a good fundraising window in terms of how much we need to raise. I think remaining independent, having our own grooming implement is important. I agree with that. I agree, too, because I know what will happen to the other one. Right. Thank you for the clarity. That's pretty clear to me. Jail host program. Thank you.

12:37 Next item, trail host program. I've attached a message from the district ranger, effectively giving us the green light for a pilot program to begin. My ambitious goal for this is to have a presence in Shady Rest Park and at the Welcome Center, both sides, not all day, but parts of the day on holidays and weekends beginning on the 21st of December.

13:05 And that's going to begin with people like me, people like Gretchen, who we already work with, to really try to break what we think we've created, right? I'm going to use our data cataloger. We'll get our muscle memory so we can do it quickly, talking to people. We're going to do some trial and error as a pilot program. We're going to probably have a table set up with a Mammoth Lakes Trail System apron like we do at the trail days.

13:32 A nice touch might be on a busy Saturday morning to have a thermos of hot cocoa. We'll be armed with a backpack full of handouts, our handout maps of information, things like that, etiquette information with our handouts, and be ready to interact with people in a pleasant way to provide good information, not in a way where we can't provide a regulatory presence. We're not going to be having a badge.

13:59 Our goal is to make sure that trail users are having fun out there. We can help people to park properly, things like that at the parking lot. We can ask them if they need help of any kind. So that's our goal. I've also attached the latest iteration post-editing from Forest Service feedback, MLR feedback, working with Kim and Matt. And so this iteration was from...

14:27 November 14th, and that's what we presented to the District Ranger for approval. So in this packet is what he saw. It's a pretty ambitious timeline, but I'm going to try to start small. Right there at Shady Rest, I think, is a perfect opportunity. We do allow winter fat biking out there. It's a relatively new introduction of a user group to the system just a couple seasons ago when that became legal. So we'll definitely have

14:59 Some good things to discuss around winter fat biking to help people to understand, yes, they're allowed here, and help people to understand the etiquette of how to ride a fat bike without intruding on other users. First of all, congrats on getting the approval. It's great. I'm excited. We've been talking about this for a long time. On that note, I do feel like we were, as a committee, very involved in an earlier iteration of this and looking at a

15:33 A variety of different proposals back when it was Trail Corps, it was Trail Ambassadors, should there be user groups, should there not be user groups plugging in, who's going to manage it, who's not, and then we fast forward eight months and suddenly, oh, we're approved, and it's a version that we haven't seen, so that's, which, I mean, you know, we don't want to micromanage, I'm excited that we're doing it, but I think, and I like where you're going with it, but I just would suggest that now that we're

16:00 Now that the door's open for it and that we get a chance to kind of pilot it, can we circle back and have a kind of a strategic discussion to kind of close the loop on some of the earlier discussions that we had about what this looks like as a long-term project? That's the nature of a pilot program, in my view. There's plenty of opportunity for this to be pliable. We want to improve it based on feedback, right? That's the whole purpose of this.

16:29 Of course. And I think it's important to realize that the initial kind of funding for this is coming from a grant from People for Bikes and from Mammoth Mountain. So I think on this first iteration, we're going to be looking at primarily, even though it's going to be kind of, certainly as we roll out in the winter, interact with different users, but primarily the data that we're hoping to mine from this is going to be bike-centric. That's what's going to be report back to the

17:00 Grand Tour. And I think one of the great things is that they're very excited. I just was down speaking with them last week about how specifically e-bikes, which is how this kind of whole thing got kicked off, is interacting with other trail users. And so they want to know, you know,

17:21 What are the potential conflicts? Or are they just assimilating into it with no conflicts or little conflicts? They don't have any data and that the industry is in dire need of that data and they want to be able to share that with their retailers. The good opportunity for us is that this is not happening anywhere else. In their slide, they were very specific about e-bikes only being able to be used on soft surface trails at two places in the country right now, one of them being Mammoth Mountain.

17:51 Both in the winter with the winter fat biking and then of course in the summer, not only will we be able to kind of pilot this program and figure out what's the kind of right methodology for it, that will give us an opportunity as we expand out and try to gain these similar insights into other sorts of trail usage, whether that is Nordic, whether that is OSV, whether that is...

18:18 Equestrian, however we do that, we really want to use the learnings now to kind of help us build a template so that, you know, as we launch and expand this program, we're making the right moves out of the box. We're self-training, so, you know, we're going to be seeing how this goes. I was essentially a trail host for 11 years in a park that I managed, but I didn't call myself a trail host. A lot of experience in interaction with trail users.

18:47 Along the way, and I'll apply all that experience to this and put that in there, but this is unique in that I now have a data capture device to get that data about the people we interact with. I'll get photos, things like that, which is different, and so we're going to get that out of this. I also expect a nice response from the trailers themselves. They always light up when they see us out there.

19:15 If we're grooming, they light up and want to talk. If they see me out there with my kids, they light up and want to talk. So I would expect just a nice response from our trail users of community to know that we're out there, that we care, and here's a hot cocoa. Also, more importantly for me, for the operation, is I want to learn this winter about logistics. What times of day should we be sending people out? Where should we be sending them? And learn...

19:43 About the logistics and how to tune this so that in the spring when we're out on the Mammoth Rock Trail, you know, we've had a little bit of experience. So you anticipate maybe at one of our early summer meetings maybe we can revisit this and kind of look at a bigger picture how this might work with other groups? I would say over time this is a new program for us. We should have an opportunity, if you want it, with the committee to tune this thing at every meeting you have if you so desire.

20:13 I think this will end up being a pretty valuable, important program. So I would open that up to, you know, anytime we want to make adjustments for the benefit of the program, it's worthy. The question was, I know this initial stuff is funded through the People for Bikes and the Mammoth Mountain stuff. As we have people out there on the trails, are they going to be

20:41 MLR staff, MLTPA staff, or only town staff. What's the, the who's out there with authority to do this will be who is my question. I know. Right now, what I'm comfortable with is the people I work directly with day in, day out. And of that group, just a couple of us to start with that I really implicitly trust on these things to be representing what we really need us to represent. It's going to be, ultimately.

21:10 Are they volunteers? No. Are we paying them an hourly rate of X? And if town staff is doing it like yourself, then you're not paying yourself out of somebody else's dollars for that. Sorry, as a management employee, if this is part of your duties, then that's a, we just, it's a logistical issue for us to work through. Sure. I don't know how that works with some of the other staff, so I just want to make sure that how we work that through, and I don't remember the dollar amounts.

21:39 How long does that last? And as we get into the summer, we start to do the expanded out. The who becomes important in that. And again, who are they hired by, et cetera. That goes into workers' comp and insurance, all those types of issues we got to deal with. But anyway, but I guess bottom line, it's not a volunteer program at this point. It is very much, I hear there's paid people out there at the various sites. It comes down to one word, control. I need to be able to control this.

22:08 To an extent now. I don't feel comfortable sending volunteers out at this point. Right now, for this pilot program, I plan to use MLTPA staff, who we currently have a contract with, and town trail crew staff. We have the contract with them, but I'm going to see if that's being paid out of the other funds, not a Measure R money. It's Measure R.

22:29 I thought we had funding for this coming from other places, too. We do. What funding was approved in Measure R was the development of this program. And the pilot program is a continuation of development. I just be cautious on that because we told friends of the Inyo, no, we're not going to fund these types of programs out of Measure R. So I just want to be cautious of how we're doing that because this is recreation in general, but it's a little different than what's specifically called out, I guess.

22:59 Just a caution as we look forward to it. So a caution, to me, it needs to be kind of binary. Either we go or we don't. And if we can't use Measure R, then I won't. I won't make that call right now if I haven't gone back and looked at it in detail on it. But I think that's just one of the cautions there in saying, because when I see it happening, it's going to work. People like it. So now we have two people. Now we have four people. Now we have 10 people. And now you have an unsustainable funded.

23:28 Yeah, I think setting up some milestones where there's a decision-making point where we look back and say, okay, this is where the pilot ends and where we start to scale it and what's the funding mechanism as we start to scale and also to the point of Friends of the Inyo, how does it match up with what they're doing, how does it match up with what other user groups might be doing or could be doing, just so that we're not just blazing forward and saying, this is awesome.

23:55 Yes, at some point coming back and having that check. And I don't have a magic time frame where that hits us. I think it's a caution. Maybe here's one thing we could agree on today or that I could get some good assurity on. For Shady Rest, during the holiday season, say Martin Luther King weekend, President's Day weekend, we are doing a pilot program on the winter trails in Shady Rest to further develop this program. Awesome.

24:22 And I will plan to use our program dollars to do that development of the program to try to make it real. And then beyond that, we'll have to consider, especially spring, we'll feel good about the funding that's already been secured. Yeah. Well, in the funding that we received, there's money in that budget that we submitted for to pay staff to do that. I think the concern that in working with Joel as we roll this out,

24:51 Certainly initially, is that one of the big, big concerns from the Forest Service is that the people that we have out as hosts are not acting in any sort of enforcement capacity, right? So that's why I think Joel wants to have a really kind of small circle of people that he trusts won't do that, won't overextend that, because that would probably also stop this program in its tracks. So I think what we're trying to do is balance that

25:21 Need to make sure that we roll out in the correct way, but we do have money built into the budget that we submitted to people for bikes and Mammoth Mountain to pay staff to do that. Yeah, and it seems like the model that you've established for trail crew is a good one where you train up a series, you know, say four leads and then maybe eventually that can transfer into having some volunteers that are working underneath those leads. But then those leads.

25:48 So I have no problem with using Measure R dollars for this. I think it's legitimate. My concerns going in were the liability issues and the workman's comp issues and those things. So I know working with the Forest Service in the past and the MOUs that we've worked under as volunteers, we either signed waivers or provided our own or showed some proof of. And I'm assuming the same thing goes here. But if they're already on your trail crew, then they're already being...

26:17 Paid for that, and you're just assigning them to a different type of task for the day. We're not altering that employment picture. That's correct. Lisa, did you have anything? No, I was most concerned about liability and who would be taking the liability. That'll be that employment site. It's like if Joel's out there on behalf and he's a town employee, if something happens, that's on the town.

26:47 If MLTPA staff is out there as a contractor of the town and if something happens, that's on their liabilities side of the house. I think it's always difficult when you get the volunteers, that's where it always starts to get a little more, but yeah. Especially if it's an ongoing regular every week. And the distinction with the volunteers that we always, the protocol we always follow is they do sign a waiver that we have prepared already for any volunteer event that we have similar to the trail days or anything else. Public comment on this?

27:22 Would you like me to go up there? Please, please. Introduce yourself to the vast audience at home. Yes. Folks at home, my name is Alex Urtod, Stewardship Director for Friends of Inyo. So the one question I guess I do have is in the literature that was provided, I guess there wasn't any mention of going out to Shady Rest and setting up tables and kind of what you describe. And then

27:52 It also seems apple and oranges to then, you know, you were talking about going out into the rock trail or here or there. Different spots, I guess, is there like a timeline of where you see it going? I know it's a pilot program, some of the developmental phases, but I guess that's just what, as a bystander or someone just looking along, would be interesting to kind of see how it fleshes out. Because in the...

28:22 Document, you know, it talks a lot about, like, user engagement. It doesn't really exactly say what ways that'll be being done, if that makes sense. Help me understand your question. Well, so there's a large difference, like, practically speaking, between setting up a table at the visitor center and having, you know, paid staff going out onto trails and interacting with the public, right? So...

28:53 Okay, I think I understand. The kind of detail that I've provided in providing like an example of we hope to go to Shady Rest and put the table or whatever, the table's not necessary. Oh, okay. It's the kind of granular thing that might be written up in like a more detailed training manual once we work out some of these kinks like oh absolutely we have to have the table set up. It's analogous to our trail day write-up where we don't specify how many tables but

29:20 In our logistics meeting before the event, we specify four tables, please. It's kind of at that level where a lot of the logistics are not included in this, like an encyclopedia or something, but this is trying to describe more high level, what is this? We are going to have to fill in a lot of these gaps with, yes, we need four tables on Saturdays, and guess what? We're going to go for two and a half hours.

29:47 At the Welcome Center. We don't know what to expect quite yet. We don't know how many staff we're going to have this summer. There's some questions I have, some questions they're going to have, some kinks to work out. I'm trying to understand your question a little bit better. And I think I can maybe rephrase it. So the Trail Host Program, the aim is to capture, like you want to make people's recreation experiences better. Correct.

30:14 We want to make sure, like, they're not out there going, boy, where do I go? For sure. Where do I park? Absolutely. But is there, I guess, so it's just wholesale, whatever way that can be done is what you're aiming for, as opposed to, like, we want to meet them. And maybe I was just filling in the gaps myself when you were talking about the visitor center. It was like, okay, meeting them where they are at the trailheads, parking lots versus presences out on the trail.

30:42 I think it's twofold. So what we're rolling out with is there's obviously a need to have some people out there because it's a high-use, multi-use area to provide some interaction and offer some information about, hey, there's a great place to go ride your bike. Here's a great, if you want to go, here's that trail. There's some of that need. Specific to the grant,

31:07 There's also a need that as people are out recreating on bicycles specifically, what do those interactions look like from a user perspective? So if we have winter fat biking, which is now allowed on those trails out in Shady Rest, how is that intersecting with our Nordic users? How is that working intersecting with other users trying to compile that data?

31:32 And then what we're going to do is supply that back to people for bikes who are going to share that with the bike industry. Because what's happening is that, and you're well aware of this, is that as people go out and they're starting to use both e-bikes and other bikes, there's always been some tension between users on trails. And so we're trying to identify, at least for the purposes of this specific grant, what some of those...

31:59 Interactions might look like. And let's say that they go and they do a two-mile loop. And on that two-mile loop, they encounter seven Nordic skiers, maybe two snowmobilers, and maybe someone snowshoeing. And then out of all those interactions, everybody smiles and waves and gets along except for one person's very upset.

32:17 So we would log all that and see like what's happening and that we can get a clear picture of what these interactions look like. That way we can do a better job of making decisions on how to manage these trails. You know, when we start doing work to expand the winter staging area, you know, what's the kind, what does that need to look like? It better informs the same thing in the summer when we roll out the, you know, what we're going to do for the summer. You know, find out, again, we're not out there in an enforcement capacity. We want to be like,

32:46 Great, how'd you find out about this trail? You know, then we hear like, oh, I run the bike from here and they told us to ride up the multi-use path and come down. So we know that we need to do some education perhaps at the retail stores. You know, so there's, I think there's a lot of information gathering. But that said, there is absolutely a need to have presence out.

33:05 Not just on our winter trails, but on our summer trails to do some education about how to have low impact usage of the land, how to enjoy yourself. I mean, if someone's going to head out someplace where they're ill-equipped, making sure that someone might want to point that out. It's about trail etiquette. Yeah. And all of this, I think what the result is, is that our goal is to have people have more fun.

33:31 People have the most amount of fun when they know how to use the trail resources properly, they're properly outfitted, and they show respect to their fellow users. That creates an environment where we all have fun and our trails are sustainably used. So I would just say from my point of view, I would love to see as this program develops over the next four to six months, if we can just...

33:55 Put together and some of the work you've already done, whether it's in that grant application and agreement, which probably would have been good to attach here so that the public can kind of see what the scope of work is on that piece of it. And some of the work you've already done in that Trail Corps proposal that you put together like a year ago. But to do it again and do it kind of as a strategic plan, it doesn't have to be a...

34:19 A thousand page document, but like a four to five page kind of here's the mission of this thing and here's our vision for it over time as a basis for fundraising, as a basis for making decisions about how to scale it, as a basis for all kinds of so that, you know, because we can talk about it, that's great, but it'd be neat to get it on paper so everybody can kind of get their heads around it. But I think it's an awesome program, it sounds like. The best tool for me to be able to do that is to go do it. Great, that's awesome. Right, to go.

34:48 For a period of time. And then let's set the pilot, you know, is done and now let's move forward into a real program. For me, the value of a host program, which has been needed for a long time, winter and summer, is the people not out on the trails greeting and meeting on the trails, but at the trail heads. The amount of hours I have spent in the last...

35:12 50 plus years at our trailheads telling people what trails offer, what type of experiences. If you're looking to get away from motorized completely, look, here's what you can do. If you're looking for ungroomed, steep and deep, here's where you can go. And if you're stupid enough to park in the middle of the turnaround zone, someone to say, you know, please, could you not park here? Because it doesn't make any sense. So I'm hoping...

35:38 That's the kind of long, enduring program that's brought forward. The data, who, how many? I know there's enough people out there to warrant what we're doing already. So for me as an individual up here on this board, that is less important than being a true host. The people who are out there need to know the trail system. And I'm trying to teach Joel as we go. And they need to know

36:05 By talking to somebody what their skill level is so that they can lead them into the right direction so that the people, whether they're locals or tourists, go out and have a great experience on the land without doing damage and then come back appropriately. So I'm very anxious to see this pilot program and to see what kind of feedback we get at the end of it because I think in terms of the quality of experience, this could be huge. Just a last impression, I want to...

36:35 Try to clarify is, yes, we have a nice private funding stream and it's bike-centric. I do want to develop this program, I think, with all user groups in mind and that we would likely get other types of funding toward the future so this is not just bike-centric. No. Yeah. This is just a starting point. And I think to your point and I think some conversations that I've had with Wendy is that

37:04 As this grows, I think there's going to be opportunity and probably need to pull in partners who either are experienced or have a deep knowledge of the audiences that are going to be communicating to you. So for example, if we're talking to OSV users, I wouldn't be the person to talk to that. We'd want to have someone who understands that community, understands their values, has their vernacular. Those are things.

37:32 Thank you. And then just as was alluded to in

38:02 I think comments by the board. Frenzino is, you know, we have our trail ambassador program, similar, and we're very excited to work all together on making this whole program as robust as possible. Thanks. Thanks, Alex. Yeah, and on that note, the only other thing I would add is that this is right now skewed a lot toward user experience, which I think is super important, but the flip side of it also is

38:26 You know, that interpretive piece of how best to interact with the landscape and the Leave No Trace principles. And, you know, this is one of the few opportunities that we have for face-to-face interaction with our users as they, you know, they may not stop by the ranger district. They may just go straight out onto the trails. And so here's a chance to actually do some teaching. Well, and not only do some teaching, but I think also...

38:54 Kind of blaze some trail in terms of knowledge, right? Because there are huge information gaps out there, not just related to bikes, but other places. And I think that's kind of what we always have aspired to here in Mammoth is to be a leader. And part of being a leader is, you know, breaking new ground and sharing those kind of discoveries with other communities, other people. Super excited. Thanks for leading the charge. Anything else? Anybody else?

39:22 Okay, let's move on to Adopt-A-Trail, another exciting program. Adopt-A-Trail, same day, same approval. Same meeting, two separate programs, but the District Ranger approved this Adopt-A-Trail program. We did edit this document with Kim's help, MLTPA staff, myself, with Forest Service feedback from Adam Barnett, specifically.

39:52 The Adopt-A-Trail Program, our goal is spring slash early summer. What we've done so far, right after we got permission, was we developed 11 specific facilities slash lakes in our large inventory to start with, so it's not so confusing to look at the map, but we'll have 11 things that people could adopt.

40:21 MLR is going to create a web page on their website that we will embed an interactive map into. That map will be sort of a menu of choices people can look at to potentially adopt a facility. This is not on a fast track like the host program. Like, we're not aiming for December 21st with this. Just want to make that clear.

40:52 But I do have confidence that spring, early summer, we should have a good time. I think there's going to be a lot of demand. I think people are going to want to buy into this program. The careful work that we have before us, though, where we have to be very careful is assigning values to these facilities so that we have enough resources for the program to keep being sustained. So that's the good work that we have before us as a technical team.

41:20 We're going to work with the Forest Service, MLR, to figure out good values to place on these facilities. That work is forthcoming. We have some rough ideas based on like a per foot on trails, but as you know, some of our worst problems are around our lakes, and so I think it's going to be a little tricky to assign a value to, say, Lake Mary, but we're going to do that good work.

41:56 Any questions, comments from the city? Good with it. On the 11 there, Joe, you take the Lakes Basin Path. I'm assuming that's segmented out and not adopting the whole path. We've segmented out into two pieces. We think they're going to be quite valuable. Is that the detail? Is that the detail on the other page? Because someone's looking at that 11. Hey, that'd be cool to adopt and you find out it's actually, you know. Yeah. That's where the map will come in. You'll be able to see like, oh, it's this piece precisely. It'll say how many feet.

42:26 Linear feet. Likewise with the lakes, we'll know how far you have to walk around the lake. That's going to be a part of the math. We've figured that out. Thanks. Yeah. And I'll be sharing this along the way with the committee as we develop this. Each time we meet, this will be on your agenda. I'll share with you the map, all the details, all the values as we move ahead. It's good to see it move forward. Yeah, it's amazing. It's awesome. This fits squarely into

42:58 The Forest Plan Revision, Inyo National Forest Plan Revision, as one of their goals is to have communities engage and adopt the trail programs and things like that. So I think Gordon was thrilled to have this being checked off early on right after they've adopted their new plan. Any public comment on this? Okay. Very much. Very exciting. Next up, I just wanted to...

43:32 Share the Winter Recreation Handout. We made a couple of edits to it this season, and I wanted to create some awareness as well. This is a PDF document that we've created as an 8.5 by 11 handout, and you can find it on mammothtrails.org, right below the interactive map. There's a link there with several handouts. This is one of them. Kirsten and I basically re-engineered a PDF.

44:02 That the Forest Service had from years past. We do not have the original files for this, but we were able to dissect it and create a map that we can edit over time. It's come up recently that the larger brochure that the Forest Service produced, I think five or six years ago, may have been even further back, there's a demand for that to be edited, revised, and all we've had control over so far is this handout map.

44:32 So I'm going to engage with the Forest Service on a reprinting of that larger brochure map that people seem to like a lot. There's a pretty good cost associated with that. It'll require digital editing and a reprinting. So for now, though, we have this handout that people can use that is updated. We increased the font sizes so that people can read it 8-9 by 11. The original map is actually much larger.

45:00 Then you can't read the words if you print it this small. But we've added some blue diamond routes. We've corrected shady rest routes and made a number of different edits across the map. You'll notice that the language in the wilderness, there's no bikes and things like that. We added that based on feedback from Forest Service. People like Stacy Corliss chimed in on that. And I just wanted you to be aware that we have this handout.

45:30 So it would appear to me, Joel, that this is based on the original winter use map, or at least the winter use trails is. And the history of that, of course, is that it was originally produced by the town of Mammoth Lakes out of the marketing department with partnership with the Forest Service and aid from the green sticker grants that were done. It was reproduced every two years. I didn't realize we weren't still getting those grants and reproducing it.

45:58 I would love to see us go back to that partnership, get Mr. Erty involved again, and apply for that grant, but if we can't get the grant from Green Sticker, certainly this is a tourist piece that in my opinion, Dan may disagree with me, we love to disagree, but in my opinion fits exactly into what they should be producing. The original had both the Blue Diamond Trails and the Orange Diamond Trails in it and the open and closed areas, and it's a great piece.

46:27 Rid of thousands of those a year to both segments. I would love to see us go back to that kind of reliability with that piece. It is a hugely important piece. And if you want to see the iterations of them, I probably have several different iterations in my map box at home. You say this is one of some or is this the only one? This is the winter recreation handout. Period. Yeah.

46:54 We have one winter recreation handout, we have a Shady Rest winter trails handout, we have a summer recreation handout, and we have an e-bike information handout. So you have two for the winter though, this one on total, then one just for Shady Rest? Shady Rest has its own. Important to note there, Joel, that the summer use map was exactly the same thing. That was a green sticker funded.

47:19 Put together by the town of Mammoth Lakes Tourism Department with help from the Forest Service and the local user groups and support for the grants that way. Sandy will remember she was with us through most of that. Really important pieces, both of them paid for out of a legitimate source. So I should understand one thing. Who was the lead on that map project at the time?

47:48 Was it Parks and Rec or Forest Service? I was told it was... In terms of the grants, it flopped back and forth between the town and the Forest Service. The original winter use map, I would say the lead was actually the old Snowmobile Association pushing the Forest Service, but Forest Service personnel had to approve every step we did and every process we went through as they would have to do it today as well. But the original push was...

48:18 User groups going to the state and asking for the money. Ralph McMullen in the town of Mammoth Lakes Marketing Department funded the bills that weren't funded by the green sticker folk. I just want to understand where the baton is so I can pick it up and run with it. Yeah, well, I am surprised it has been dropped. Under five feet of snow. Yeah. Yeah, if it has been dropped, I would say the drop probably occurred in the marketing department.

48:48 MLT. No, actually, probably Joel before MLT. I'm not sure. Has MLT actually produced these in the past at all? Or was it free? You know, and I'm not sure if MLT did. So it was back when it was still in town. Actually, I think this would be a great production for MLT. It would be a great production for MLT. I agree. Michael Morris might be your best bet. Because, you know, Michael.

49:13 Ran the program pretty much and worked with everybody. I mean, it was, even when I came in 1995, it was really going wonderfully. I think we had a history of grants at that point, so I'd go set up an appointment with him and, of course, Rick, the board's long gone, but Michael's still there, so. All I need is an excuse to go see Michael.

49:35 Yes, exactly. It's always fun. I haven't talked to Mike in a long time. I'd love to be part of it. Always fun. Yeah, you should. Yes. Because, yeah, the two of you. We worked on all of this together. All of that. That was even pre-'95, right? Yeah. Yeah. She's making me sound old. So, while we're working on another production, we're going to keep this updated. Yeah. Yes. No, it's good. With current information so people have it. And all the lines are correct now.

50:09 The text should be up to date. If you find anything, please let me know and we can easily make the edit. Is this just available online? If you go to mammothtrails.org, right below the interactive map, you'll see. We're not producing it with a handout. I'm not printing them. Well, what's nice about it is you can enlarge it to the point where it's very usable and print just that section. Yeah. You can print your own if you want. Yeah.

50:43 The question is, yeah, two-sided handouts. I mean, I appreciate the references to MLT. I don't know why, you know, this stuff comes up and there's like a wall, like there's no communication between us and the destination marketing organization, but like... We're breaking them down. Are you? I thought you were just giving them more money. No, we're giving them less money. Anyway, it would be really good to engage our public-facing...

51:10 Tourism Marketing Organization with this kind of communication effort so that it's not, you know, we're not just operating on our own. Even though we're obviously the ones, you're the one who knows the system and it all looks great. Just one note, you know, obviously as we go through subpart C there will be a whole new official, you know, motor vehicle use map but that will probably be three, four years down the road so no big deal. But one trend that has

51:38 begun to be mentioned region-wide that I think is a really interesting one and useful to think about is the idea of printing both a motorized winter use map and a non-motorized winter use map because often people go in and they want to know like where can I go snowmobiling or where can I go backcountry skiing and to try and cram all that onto the same map sometimes is not very useful for either group.

52:05 But the knowledge of where those other user groups are is also important. Yeah, that is true, but I think a lot of times what happens on other, it's not, it's easier on our forests than other forests, but some of these forests, people walk into the ranger district and they want to know, you know, where can I go snowshoeing? And that's not on this map. What's on this map is where can I go snowmobiling? And I think that for snowmobilers too, that bums them out because it's like, hey, this is where we go snowmobiling.

52:33 It says right here on the map, and you knew that, and then you come here and you complain about it. So it'd be good to have that handout that's like, oh, you want to not- You kind of like the idea. Here's where you go. Yeah, it's kind of like on it, and then here's the detail of it. Here's that you could, you know, that big picture. Then I agree, it'd be nice to go, great, here's the snowmobile side, or here's the backcountry side. Yeah. What do I want? Where do I want to go? What do I want to do? Except, of course, that the non-motorized side encompasses everything.

53:00 I mean, but where do I want to go where there's actually, like the Blue Diamond Trail, that's not everywhere. No. But how do I know where it's at? This here's a little hard to read at times. So, but having a blow up or having some of that detail, that's down the road, but definitely be nice to have if you're out there looking for a particular. Anyway, great, great materials. Yeah, this is good. Good stuff with what we got. Any public comment? Last thing, Joel, on this. I know we referenced the.

53:27 Tourism, everything on here. I'm not sure if we should have their logo, the Mammoth Lakes logo on that front page there somewhere, but we have all their information there for lodging, visitor information, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, blah, blah, blah. So just either there, blah, blah, blah, same, but the town logo on there, so. It would have been extracted from the brochure, so we can pull it. Not a big deal. Great. Grant updates. Yeah. Grant application updates, I think.

54:06 Matt, if you wouldn't mind joining me for this next item. Kind of just like you did last night. You can hit it right now with these two. That'd be perfect. Matt and I are becoming a team. Thanks. I was just going to say that. And you're green. Great. So we're looking at the recreational trails and greenways grant opportunity that was submitted by the town of Mammoth Lakes.

54:45 So this opportunity is still pending under review with the state. Intent to award would be announced come June time. The big takeaway from this opportunity is twofold. You can see identified on the map, Joel, the Sherwins trailhead there.

55:01 For which NEPA and CEQA is currently complete and authorized for construction by the Mammoth District Ranger. No source of funding yet has been identified for that. So while we have authorization to proceed, we don't have the funding. So that would be a huge win for this effort is to identify that funding through this grant should that come in.

55:23 And that makes a logical connection between the Sherwins Trailhead, which is a true four-season trailhead. It's extremely busy, like even right now. And it makes that connection to Mammoth Creek Park and the state definition of a disadvantaged community. So thanks to the multi-use pathway system, this is really seen as a holistic part of a walk-bike-ride measure where...

55:48 It integrates the trail system into transportation and recreation and reducing carbon footprint and a sense of community. So a few different aspects to the grant. You can see there, what's the total mile of trails? 30 miles? 35. Well, this map, if you're looking at the map, you can see in the legend we broke it down into phases.

56:17 And mileages are listed on the right side of each text block. And if you just add up the green and yellow lines, I can't read it from here, but I think it's 35 miles. Is it 35? Yeah. So anyway, you can see those numbers right there on the map. I just can't see them looking at the monitor. Yeah, it's there. So it's 35. It's 35. Thanks. I should have that number in my pocket. But like Joel said, it is a number of different phases here. You can see on the lower or southwest.

56:46 Portion of the map there in the lake space and trails connecting each lake to one another. So again, kind of emphasizing the opportunity for users to be able to walk from one lake to another rather than having to park, repark their vehicle. If you go to a busy trailhead on a weekend.

57:06 In Horseshoe or Lake Mary, you see those guerrilla parking jobs everywhere. So this is just one more effort to try and reduce that. And then the yellow line on the south or bottom part of that screen is the Solitude Canyon Trail, which Joel has discussed with this committee at length. But it's a connection over the Sherwins. This route was designed and developed in partnership with the Forest Service. We've walked the trail. We've looked at

57:33 Different potential alignments and those which are least likely to have impacts on wildlife, SHPO, heritage sites. So a number of different factors went into this proposed trial alignment. And important to note is that this grant is both a planning and implementation grant.

57:55 Many are either or. This one is both. So one outcome from this grant should be awarded is that these proposed alignments will actually go through the NEPA heritage process and be fine-tuned. So this is not the trail as it will exist on the landscape necessarily. And several factors, public comments, consultation with tribes, all of that will be integrated into this planning process and the NEPA process.

58:25 I just want to add one thing. The lines you're looking at on this map were filtered through a process where I met with senior Inyo National Forest staff and specialists over the course of almost a full day where I shared with them about 70 miles of design lines that we have. Over the course of the last four years, I have been all over the landscape trying to figure out where some well-designed trails can go.

58:55 So out of that 70 or so, we're down to this. And the reason why they were filtered out mostly is because of archaeological heritage reasons. And these are the lines that made it through the cleanest. Every other line that we looked at, there were issues of some kind. And I don't need to get into the details of what, but these are the lines that senior staff agreed.

59:21 Would be the least invasive to the landscape for us to add another project, a trail project. So the Solitude Canyon line doesn't go near riparian areas or sensitive habitat. It avoids known archaeological sites. We have some data for that area. Especially in the Lakes Basin, those lines were the cleanest of any that we had in concept. From the labs, the Lakes Basin Special Study, those lines work the best.

59:51 The Forest Supervisor, Tammy Randall Parker, provided direction to senior staff to figure out how to get the next phase of project, what lines are going to work the best, you know, how can we be expediting some projects so we don't take three to five years to get through process, and this is our best way forward. Question on the trailhead, the Sherwin's trailhead, that's already gone through the NEPA sequel, I don't recall, do we have that under a permit of some sort?

1:00:23 So, Dan, that will be captured under the special use permit. The intention of the special use permit application, which is in right now and being under review with the Forest Service, is that it gives us the opportunity to have an operating plan, which is updated each year annually, right?

1:00:41 With that application, we would be able to capture this trailhead. And it is a requirement, as you know, of the Forest Service, that new construction, a new restroom, which is needed there, they don't have the capacity to keep up with. Let me jump ahead. I don't have a question on it. One was that as we look at that parking area, because we already own an easement on the road going in, one of the options was looking at USDA ARD grant dollars that you can do a trailhead with.

1:01:07 The Forest Service, we'd probably have to have more than just a use permit, was the comment, if we had like an easement. That's actually a pure grant fund, I think up to $200,000, somewhere in that ballpark. And that money's available, at least it sounded like it was kind of an ongoing application process. You can't do it on direct federal land, so it'd have to come to us. It sounded like a rough conversation, but it sounded like above just the use permit side, so it'd be something we'd look at from an easement standpoint.

1:01:37 The other questions for the trailhead there real quick that we're seeing, especially with the winter storms and stuff, is actually has to be coming at an overnight camping location for cars and RVs and vans. Our concern really is getting people trapped back in there and then having to pull our road crews off of road maintenance to clear it out. And so I'm not sure if we have any signage out there or if it is or isn't.

1:02:04 Is it appropriate for overnight parking? If it's allowed in the Forest Service or not, I don't know. That's the other question. Ultimately, is if we take it on, that would be something to look at. But right now, our road crews are very concerned because they're not necessarily in a big storm other than working with the propane delivery systems, not set up to actually plow that for people to get in and out of there with their vehicles that they're parking back there.

1:02:32 Overnight parking. My take on this is that the informality of this place today is the problem, and that if it becomes a formal trailhead that somebody's taking care of, we could put the signs up, we can patrol it appropriately. Yes, my question right now is whether we can or can't. We actually had a discussion earlier with the road guys going. If they get a call from PD to say, can you go plow out so somebody can get back into town with their vehicle, the initial answer in the middle of a storm is going to be, no, we cannot.

1:03:00 Understood. So I don't know if we need to work with the Forest Service. I don't know if they allow overnight parking as a matter of right out there, if there's no one to say no to. So anyway, bigger issue, but don't need an answer right now on that. But down the road on that is one, with the USDA Rural Development Dollar grant, we could actually look at a couple of these trailheads. It was one thing that they said they could fund.

1:03:27 But we need to have a different level of authority on the ground versus federal ownership. So, you know, that question's there. And an easement would do that. So that was the question for this. But then just today that came up and talked with our road crew and one of their concerns on people getting trapped back in there. They're concerned today, right? I mean, that's their concern today. Yeah, their concern is like this weekend where it snows and there's people camping back there. We are probably not going to be the rescue crew to plow out so they can drive out. They may be able to walk out.

1:03:56 Just FYI, I don't, and I don't know if the Forest Service stands on that at all or if it's. I just, I'm seeing that as a constant. If it's illegal. There's always going to be a concern about people. I mean, if you can park overnight out there legally, then I don't, I'm not worried about it. Park at your own risk. But on the other hand, it's. The important piece is to just make the signage clear that you're parking at your own risk if you get stuck back here. Yeah. Because it's not just people camping, right? I mean, theoretically, people would be.

1:04:24 Kicking off from there for an overnight trip and parking their car. Exactly. We've had people do that, too. They just get stuck out there. Then we often get a call, come plow them out. And so that's anywhere from an hour to four hours of blower time, et cetera. We're not going to do it. Now, we coordinate with Mayor Gas for access out there, but that's a different need. Just thing occurs to me, if we have an operating plan that's formalized, part of the operating plan could anticipate weather.

1:04:52 Close the road or the access out of the storm and try to manage it better because today we're not doing anything. We're looking at that was one of the discussions because we have an easement on the road is closing that road. The question is how much of a hard closure do we do? If it's a sign. I mean, I've had to blaze myself out there. Exactly. Because I want to go skiing out there. I know I'm assuming the risk. Right. And if it's a winter access point, then do we want to close the road versus?

1:05:19 Yeah. If you close it with somebody's car in there because they took off yesterday. Right. It's okay if we're going to stop plowing it. But anyway, just FYI for that. But the other thing I just really wanted to highlight was that grant component. I'll try to get some additional information passed out on to you, Joel. But if it requires getting an easement on that, which gives us more authority over the parking lot in the future.

1:05:40 That would be great from that perspective probably, but it may be a way to actually get the trailhead funded. So would it be appropriate to file or to submit a concurrent grant application to here while we're waiting to see? I mean, we could. We'll track down the grant information. I think if it'll actually fund a trailhead restroom, signage, parking is what we talked to them about, and they seem to say, yeah. We've applied for that with this grant. I understand we applied for that here, but if we apply for the other one with it, I mean.

1:06:09 Doesn't hurt us to do too, right? Yeah. If you get a yes. Just increases the odds. Yeah. Worst case you can do is say no to something or you can expand out what you're doing. Doesn't hurt our chances. So anyway. Well, I am here to walk in and hand with both agencies and fill in the gaps here and answer these questions. So I am here to fill that capacity and can bring back information from the agency and see.

1:06:32 What exactly the answer is out there. I don't see this as operating too unlike Shady Rest Park, which is under special use permit. Multiple jurisdictions and enforcement out there and disperse camping, overnight camping is not allowed. So I would imagine it would be similar. Based on which grant and which use permit is required, that might change.

1:06:57 I don't know if this was you could actually park out there overnight today with no issues from the Forest Service side. I don't believe so, but I don't want to hazard that guess. I don't know the answer to that. It's not posted. So it may be fine, but just my concern is getting somebody trapped back there and having a bad outcome. Yeah, the snow drifts certainly roll in on that easement. I think we have the Icon Pass to thank a little bit for some folks camping out out there. I thought for skiing, but that's not part of their passing program.

1:07:27 Not in hashtag man life. Yeah, hashtag man life, that's right. Anyway, just FYI for that. It is an interesting question that I'd love to have the answer to. So dispersed camping on the Inyo National Forest as it used to be handled in Sandy's days.

1:07:45 If there's an open campground, if the Forest Service has a campground, then you're not allowed to disperse camp with an X number of miles from that campground. But with the campgrounds closed for the winter, does that change the rule? And I should know the answer, but I don't know the answer. So, Matt, I would love to know. Yeah, generally. Your stance is, I'm dispersed camping in the winter when the campgrounds are closed. Generally dispersed camping. Or whether that is a...

1:08:10 Use permit by use permit. I mean, it's not allowed on the mountain parking lots because it is excluded out of their use permit. Generally, dispersed camping is permitted by the forest. There are exceptions to that that are typically trailheads and developed or semi-improved recreation sites, which this is not a formal trailhead, so it really lives in that gray area. It may well be legal. And if it is, it's good to know, but also just how do we let people know that...

1:08:39 You may be camping for longer than you're planning on. Go out to the tubs in a snowstorm. Come back in April and get your car. Did you guys want to cover the OHV grant too? Briefly. Yeah. We got a draft agreement from the state yesterday.

1:09:04 So I'll be bringing that to Town Council at the next opportunity. I'll work with Dan on getting that on the agenda for acceptance. But we did get the agreement yesterday from the state. Anything else to add? That really captures it. Yeah, so final agreements in. For reference, this is for planning grant. Planning grant, three-year planning grant, shady rest in your credit. We hope single track.

1:09:32 It's an effort to improve and enhance existing OHV facilities, staging areas, but also I think it's very important that we reconcile the issue we have of only several miles of disjointed trail experience for people. So there's a lot of pent-up demand for a real trail experience. And we talked about that a little bit last night with Mark at the meeting who pointed out that

1:09:58 You know, a road experience is different from a trail experience. And that's what the trail users seek to our north is an actual trail experience. So I'm hoping that through this process we create a real system that works for recreational trail users responsibly and sustainably. I would only add that this is very much a partnership.

1:10:23 Opportunity. It is outside of town's jurisdictional boundary. And I'll be working closely with the county, Tony Dublino, on every aspect of this tracking. And there's a lot of interest in the community in June to make that next leap from Dead Man Summit to June Lake and fill in some of these blanks and make some loops that are logical and make sense and keep people on trail and not lost. So the county's interested. I'm engaged.

1:10:53 And we don't know what we don't know, but this planning grant will help us figure that out. Is there a possibility of analyzing purpose-built e-bike trails also concurrently, like as a separate trail facility? So I'm a multi-use thinker. I would not consider, as an example, like an exclusive e-bike trail. I would think of trails that are designed that are great for e-biking. That aren't going to get washed out. Yes.

1:11:24 You know, designed for motorized use, right? E-bikes are a motor. They have a motor. So far, the federal government, at least on the USDA side, agrees with that. And that's the, I have to operate in that world so far, that it's a motorized device. And so, these trails would need to be motor friendly. It's an OHV planning grant. So, the money can't be paid, can't be used to develop a non-motorized trail system. So,

1:11:53 Any trail that comes out of this process would be e-bike friendly. So you've opened up another can of worms in this pea brain of mine. Uh-oh. If e-bikes are considered motorized, then my interpretation would be that they have to carry a green sticker to operate on the Inyo National Forest. Except they don't use gas. Motorized is motorized. But the green sticker thing is tied to a gas tax.

1:12:21 Yeah. That came up at that conference. And if you, I mean, because right now you don't have to register an e-bike, right? If you buy a motorcycle, you buy a car, you buy all these other vehicles, snowmobile, you have to register them. You do not have to register an e-bike. So it really depends on who you talk to if motor, if e-bikes qualifies as a motorized vehicle. You don't have to register a moped, but it still has to operate under the rules of motorized motorcycles when it's on the road. So it's...

1:12:50 It just flashed that, you know, that's how those trails get paid for. I think the system here is they can't go on soft surface trails unless they're motorized trails. Right. So it's more of, yes, you could use them on motorized trails even though they're motorized or not from a green sticker standpoint. If it's just pure soft surface mountain biking, then they can't be used on the soft surface trails. Right, I understand that. But the green sticker part is, does the state...

1:13:16 Charge for a registration for e-bikes, and the answer is no, so then they're not under the green sticker. So they kind of fall in this weird netherland that everyone's still trying to figure out. They probably should. Which, down the road, yeah, it's... Yeah. Interestingly, actual dirt bikes, motorcycles, are now going electric. So, there's that. But you're still registering them. You still have the impression of them. Exactly, so... Anyway. Brave New World.

1:13:45 Great, thanks guys, thanks for moving those projects forward. Public comment on that? Sandy Hogan. Yeah, David mentioned the washout or the, yeah. One of the things you might, I don't know if you've ever dealt with the San Bernardino National Forest, the OHV coordinator there. I have not. And probably, I'm assuming they still have an OHV coordinator that was...

1:14:17 Elevated to, I think, a forest position. I had one that worked for me when I was the ranger there, and we had wonderful, it was kind of the model of Southern California for your trails, and trail hardening was a big issue there. And so, you know, maybe just double check, go and see if there is an OHV coordinator. His name used to be John Wamba, but I think he's probably gone. He's, who knows? Angelese National Forest.

1:14:46 Yeah, the San Bernardino National Forest, right, right. And probably the mountaintop ranger district now. They used to be two separate ranger districts and combined them. But, yeah, because the terrain there was pretty tough and rugged in a lot of places, and hardening was really an art that I'd never even heard of. No, and it's multiple layers, too, because, I mean, I've spent a lot of time on the west side this summer looking at...

1:15:13 Trails in the OHV System, a lot of trails that were built to be single track have been widened by the side-by-side users and then so the motorcycle people are pissed off and then the MTB people are relegated to those same trails and yeah, there are long sand pits that they can't get through. So as you're planning, trying to figure out ways to pioneer a system that works for everybody will be interesting and complex.

1:15:43 It will be. We'll have some time to figure it out. And I understand that no matter what we produce, somebody's going to have something to say about it. And that's okay. Greatest good for the greatest number. Let's get there at least. Multi-use. I mean, this is going to be a multi-use system that has to come out of this that includes as many user groups as possible. Thanks. Let's talk about this Mammoth Rock Trail reroute. Okay, thank you.

1:16:16 Several seasons ago, we had the pleasure of working with a recreation officer with Inyo National Forest. His name was Kerry Wood, and he helped me design a number of trails. The last map showed a lot of those miles around Sierra Meadows and above, but this was one line that we designed together. The lower third or so, you can see the purple line on the map. That is our proposed reroute to...

1:16:44 Create a more sustainable alignment that doesn't turn into a roadie ditch. It becomes a stream in the spring. And so this is going to take care of that in a similar way that we did with the Panorama Mountain Bike Trail. This will be a more substantial project. We have to be very careful about, you know, very multi-use. It has to be horse and mule friendly, as an example.

1:17:14 And so this will be constructed as one of the first things we do next season. Cool. So this has got the approval from the Ranger District to move forward? This is approved. We're waiting for one more T to cross with their wildlife biologist. But the archaeologist walked this and has a report ready. And it's just one last paragraph in the report. Very good. What's the distance? You know? This is going to be about a...

1:17:44 Quarter, just over a quarter mile. Not very long. Be fairly quick construction for us. And then you go through and obliterate the other trail. Exactly. Joel, what are the guidelines you use for horse and mule? The guidelines I have in a nice manual that the Forest Service publishes. The last one was from 2007, and it has specifications drawn for us, like the bench has to be, you know, 2% outsloped.

1:18:15 It gives us all the specifications necessary for a multi-use trail, a multi-use non-motorized trail. Is there a line of sight guideline as well? Yeah, that's a little more nebulous. They do talk about, you know, limbing up trees for sight lines and things like that, yes. And I have separate guidelines for line of sight in a different publication. That would be my only...

1:18:39 Feedback and criticism of one of the new trails that was, we've talked about it already, but the connector from the... The upper part of the Meadow Trail connector. Yes. Yeah. It's just, in my opinion, it's not multi-user at all when it comes to equestrians. So I think, you know, especially when you work on this part, that equestrians use this area all the time. And I know there aren't as many trees and rocks and...

1:19:07 The hillside is, you know, line of sight is pretty much clear in this area, but as you continue to develop, especially in this rock trail area with the mountain bikes coming down, it's... Sure, I was careful to say that, to say that, you know, we know that horses and mules need to use this. But I feel like you've already created a trail that you say is multi-user, and in reality...

1:19:34 As part of both user groups, as a mountain biker and horseback rider, I don't think it is truly a safe multi-use trail. I should clarify something too. That was Sharp ID 18. And that was one of only two concepts out of the Sherman's Area Recreation Plan that actually directed me to make it fun for mountain biking. No other Sharp ID said that. The Meadow Trail Connector followed that prescription.

1:20:03 The Panorama Mountain Bike Trail is the same, and there's another concept that we hope gets built up on Panorama Dome that has the same exact prescription, and it says it right in the plan, just like Sharp ID 9B next to Sierra Meadows says, pay careful attention to make sure that this concept makes it fun for horses. So the people back then, the Sherwins Working Group,

1:20:30 Made those prescriptions for someone like me to build that. Right. So the Meadow Trail Connector was balancing the direction from the Shermans Working Group with multi-use. And then the Mammoth Rock Trail Connector had a different prescription, which was very, you know, keep it plain Jane. It didn't speak to any specific user group. So that's why, as an example, the Mammoth Rock Trail Connector is different from the Meadow Trail Connector. Right. It's very open.

1:21:01 I think it's a valid comment, though, if you're saying it's multi-use components and the prescription side of it, but line of sight for horses gets dangerous there if you're mixing it with mountain bikes is what I'm hearing. And so all of a sudden it is, but it isn't. Yeah, I think when we're making maps and making suggestions and having a host program and all of that, that's something to keep in mind. It's a black diamond horse trail. Yeah. Double black. Double black.

1:21:33 But there are certain horses who would have no problem with it if there's no collision. But there are other... But especially that part, people are screaming on that thing. Yeah. Coming down. You want to be able to see. So you have to see for a long distance. And right now you can. You can see for, you know, as soon as they come out of the trees there. And there are definitely areas that people avoid because there aren't line of sight. You know, they're on the Rock Trail. But that is a major thoroughfare.

1:22:00 I think for both hikers, bikers, you know, requesters. Any public comment on that? All right, moving along. Mammothtrails.org. Roadshow. Roadshow. So I just wanted to briefly explain that I've been visiting with Visit Mammoth as an example, the Welcome Center with Forest Service staff and ECU staff.

1:22:38 Giving them an overview of mammothtrails.org, how they can use it to help people, how they can use the map, how they can download the map handouts, how they can check on trail conditions, keep up with some trail news. Just really sharing them the capacity that we have built. So I visited with Footloose Sports so far, the Welcome Center staff, Visit Mammoth staff, really all of them. And we have a few other things scheduled. I don't remember the exact dates.

1:23:07 Gretchen's helping me with that, but I'll be visiting Lake Kytrid Sports as an example, just trying to create some comfort and familiarity around mammothtrails.org. Separately, today, our webmaster, Nicole, held a partner meeting. This is the meeting we have twice a year. Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Forest Service, Town of Mammoth Lakes, where we go over

1:23:39 Sort of what we saw activity-wise over the course of the year. So what trends are we seeing? Basically, more people are using phones, obviously. Increased traffic in some areas. A lot of interest in OHV facilities. It comes up, I think, as number four on the site. Number one, devil's post pile. A lot of interest there. So we had a discussion around that.

1:24:08 And some of the issues that the National Park Service deals with. That happened today, just before this meeting. Also, we're having to deal with an issue with our server. Our current service provider was purchased by GoDaddy. And we've found another service provider that will be less expensive and offer

1:24:33 the kind of infrastructure that we need for mammothtrails.org. Just wanted to report out that we'll have some savings with that when we do transfer it. We've not transferred the site yet. And that's all I have to share on this item. Thank you again for that conditions page. I think that's really turning out well.

1:24:57 Super useful, like now that the grooming, like the last time it was groomed is reported on there at all times, so you can check and see that it was groomed last night. I'll put it up on the screen there so you can see it. It brings together the avalanche forecast, the condition of shady rest trails. You would see a lot more green bars in the summer, but we have erased all the conditions for the summer trails. So right now we're focused on the shady rest trails, and then when Jeremy DeSalle starts grooming the OSV network,

1:25:27 We think they're going to want to use this to be able to provide that information as well. Any questions on anything? Move on to the trail counter report. In your packet, you have a fairly extensive report from our GIS manager with MLTPA, Andrew Mulford. On the first page, you'll see this graph, and he's explaining that we have 38 locations. We now have 40. Mammoth Creek Park is always the big winner.

1:26:22 I think for obvious reasons. And there's some other trends that might be of interest to you. Anything around Horseshoe Lake, Duck Pass are the big winners. And we put together three seasons of data to compare in the chart. And further on in the report, we share sort of theories or hypotheses about why certain anomalies occur. We think that smoke affects things.

1:26:52 And also snowpack. So as an example, last season, people weren't really able to hike a lot in the Lakes Basin until July. And then the season before, we had a really smoky August, and numbers seemed to dip in a lot of the Lakes Basin areas. We think our hypothesis is that the smoke was it. Interestingly, in our mammothtrails.org partner meeting today, we found a correlation between web traffic and trail counter data.

1:27:22 So July, everybody's checking out the website, and they're also exploring the trail system the most, but really precise correlation between web traffic and trail use. So nice to see that data validated. In the report, you can also see where we have them located. We have a nice map where you can see where we have them.

1:27:50 This graph, the daily total counts at the Sherwins user trail location. This is the most interesting data counter to me right now. This is located in the meadow where we have no formal trail system facilities. It's all user created trails. And we can see that there's lots of activity out there. A lot of people using that trail system. And the reason I'm interested in this data is because I would really like to work with the district.

1:28:19 To create a formal trail system out there. And we know there's a lot of resources out there to contend with. But this shows that the current condition, the reality, is that people are out there. And right now, we have no signage. We can't put these trails on maps. We can't put a trail host out there, really, as an example. And I recognize that a lot of folks like it that way, the way it is.

1:28:47 But the count showed that we have heavy use in an area where we should probably have a wayfinding sign or two and be able to include these trails on our literature for people to go hike and go ride bikes. A lot of these user-created trails are not sustainably designed or well built and need to be rerouted into areas where we're not having impacts on the meadow. Joel, where's the counter located? It's located...

1:29:18 Just in on public lands near the golf course right off of Tamarack Street. So as you come from Tamarack Street and travel south, right after the fence line where the Snow Creek Golf Course is, you could look for a post near the counter. And I have seen a fair number of e-bikes out in the meadow as well. I've gotten many reports of e-bikes. The thing is, those trails don't exist.

1:29:50 Can they be on them? I think so. I don't see why not. Unless it's... Wouldn't it be technically considered overriding off trail? Which you're allowed to do. You are allowed to do that. On a mountain bike, you can ride through the Jeffrey Pine Forest. As long as you don't build a trail, you are allowed to do that. So they allow motorized in the meadow. Oh, because the snowmobiles go out there in the winter.

1:30:19 That's an excellent point, too. You bring this up. This is great. Having a user-created trail system that is completely not formal opens up all these questions, doesn't it? It's an unmanaged trail system right next to our community. And so this data allows us to start telling the story to our federal partners that we have people using it now.

1:30:47 The fear, of course, however, especially there, if we push for trails too hard, is that there is a lot of arc out there, and we may end up in much worse position by trying to make it a managed trail system than where we are today. I don't know the answer, but I've certainly seen a lot of things that I care foreclosed in the course of the last 20 or 30 years by somebody's name because we have pursued one thing or another. So in other words, by opening up the subject,

1:31:17 And looking under the ground, we may find that those user trails need to go away. Right. The user trails that are out there have been there for thousands of years. Yes. I can't speak for a thousand, I can only speak for 60 plus, but yes. I can, because they're telling me that people have been there for thousands of years. I'm not arguing that point. So. And the fact that those people were there a thousand years ago and left artifacts now gives certain people the excuse to close it.

1:31:47 Due to those artifacts. Well, let me clarify this for you. The grant that we've applied for, for $1.8 million, is asking for money to deliver a trail that mitigates impacts to those important resources. It's a money issue at this point. We need to be able to afford

1:32:12 To cap or do those things that the archaeologist says we have to do that are expensive to do. We may have to bring in material to get six inches above the ground to put it up. We may have to use things like boardwalks. Whatever they prescribe is going to cost a lot of money. I think that we've had those discussions with the district about if they decide to close it and what that might mean. They don't want to go down that road.

1:32:39 They would choose to mitigate impacts by spending money to make sure that nobody digs under the ground or nobody disturbs what's under the ground. And all of those mitigation projects cost a lot of money, is my take on it. Thanks for that. It's so cool to start having some data to visualize what we're doing here. Moving on to number 11, or are we, has Matt given his report?

1:33:21 He seems to have. Which, actually, we'll be going next to 10, right? I don't have a 10, so no. Yeah, photo gallery. She sent it twice because 10 didn't appear once. Oh, yeah. Yeah, it's not in my packet, but go for it. 10, photo library. All right. Hi, I'm Trevor Van Winkle. I'm the MLTPA photo librarian and digital asset manager. I just wanted to give a short presentation on kind of the operations of the photo library and

1:33:51 How it's used, the kind of tool that it can be for everyone just involved in the trail system. Do you have a presentation here? Ah, here we go. All right. So the MLTPA, sorry, Mammoth Lakes Trail System Photo Library is a collection of about 10 to 20 years worth of photographs, the earliest ones beginning in 2000. Go to the next slide. There are currently around

1:34:21 79,000 individual photos in the library, which, as you can probably guess, if they're not properly managed and organized, basically become 79,000 useless photographs because you can't find subjects or what you're looking for, what you need for a specific project, and that's what the photo library systems are put in place for. Next slide. This is just a sample of some of the more recent photography in here. As you can see, we have everything from

1:34:48 Different activities on the trail system, facilities, locations, shoots with models for use with experiences on the Mammoth Trails website. Along with that, in the library, there's a lot of photographs from events, such as the trail days or public meetings, for the purposes of documentation and promotion of future events, to make sure that's available.

1:35:13 Basically, this is a simplified version of the workflow. Basically, we go from digital photography taken by usually myself as the field photographer. Sometimes Joel is kind enough to use his incredible photography and skills and allow us to bring those into the photo library or when they're taken in the process of data collection. They're also brought in and cataloged. They're brought in through

1:35:36 An Adobe DNG converter just to make sure there's a consistent file structure and format throughout the entire library. Adobe Bridge is a digital asset management program that we use to keyword, rename, and organize the photos to make sure that they are usable within the library. At the end of the process, they're all brought into Lightroom, which is another Adobe product that's basically a digital photo library that's...

1:36:01 A database that's searchable, filterable, and incredibly robust for exporting for a variety of uses such as web galleries like what you see on mammothrails.org, print materials such as marketing materials for the Trail Days events or other trail system events and for other communications. And just in terms of what the system is, it's...

1:36:27 There's the photo library computer, which is where all of the work is done. The photos are not stored on the hard drive of that computer. They're stored on a separate device called a Drobo, which is essentially a self-protecting, self-backup data storage device. A second Drobo is used as a consistent backup, so we make sure that if one does go down, then we have that backup ready to go to replace it so the operations of the library will continue unhindered.

1:36:57 And then just in case all of those systems are lost somehow in an earthquake or a fire or some kind of drastic event, we have an external hard drive that every week is backed up and then taken off site, stored somewhere securely to make sure in the worst case scenario we'll still have access to all of that material. We use a very consistent and very robust file organization system based on

1:37:25 MLTPA's project codes, which are all historically consistent and stored to make sure we know exactly what's where. There's no hunting through a hard drive for that one photo you're looking for. You know exactly where to find it. And then the next. And then within those folders, they all have a very consistent naming convention that makes sure they're easy to find, easy to use. Next.

1:37:55 Basically the way this works for using these photographs for an outside organization or for use within the trail system is through the image request process. Basically this form is available on MLTPA.org under the map with trail system photo library page.

1:38:15 Essentially, it's a list of requirements for what kind of photos you need, what you want in those photos in terms of locations or activities, what the use of them will be, who you are contacting, just to make sure we're giving these resources to the right people and that we know and can track where they went. And then this form is then used to help me as the photo librarian provide you with the photo assets that you need.

1:38:45 Go to the next photo. Essentially, since all of the photos in the library have been keyworded with the subject, the location, what kind of event is portrayed in them, as soon as they're brought in, basically in Lightroom, I can just do essentially a Google search for whatever I need or the organization needs for a certain use. And then every single photo that has, say in this example, Crystal Craig will

1:39:14 Come up and I'll be able to go through that, make selects of the best photos in terms of just appearance, technical use and the necessary requirements of the project it's going to be used for. Then it can be exported for, you know, to a variety of different delivery methods either through email or through Dropbox, external hard drive or CD for larger files or larger exports and just to make sure that they can be

1:39:43 Distributed effectively. All right. And that's essentially it. My email is photo at MLTPA.org. Easy to remember. That's the best way to put in a photo request and make sure you can communicate that clearly. Thank you. Any questions? So if I want to go and browse the photos that are in our library, can I do that or do I have to fill out a request form with exactly what I want to see and I'm going to be showing only those?

1:40:11 You fill out a form and I will send you a large selection of images that fit those needs. Basically, we want to generally avoid having other people perusing the library or utilizing it just because if someone who doesn't know how the library works completely moves a folder around or changes a name or they want, oh, I don't want to see that photo because I don't like it anymore and they accidentally delete it from the hard drive entirely.

1:40:39 We just want to avoid potential for misuse and data loss that way. So there is kind of a just a way. This is the best way we've found to make sure it can be distributed effectively but still protect the integrity of the database as it exists. Theoretically, Bill Souser can make an appointment with you. Yes, exactly. Yeah. If you need to, yeah, you could come in and, you know, I could sit with you. We can go through the entire list and make sure that, you know.

1:41:10 You can find exactly what you're looking for. Do we get many requests from news organizations or others that are doing stories in our area or do they find that system a little too cumbersome and time consuming to make it worth their while? We haven't had anyone from news media use this program or the image request form specifically but they have requested from specific events like our public meetings that media was for and they want extra.

1:41:37 Photographic content for, they saw me taking photos there, so they usually contact me directly and then I send them selects with approval from the project lead to use in the media. We've had, you know, MLR has used some photos through this process for promotional use and that kind of thing. I've actually had a middle school student contact me asking for permission to use one of our photos in a project that they were doing, which was...

1:42:07 Kind of fun to see. But it's, yeah, the process is really, it's fairly flexible. That's just kind of the main way to get that information to me and kind of that request form is designed to be as comprehensive as possible so I get you only exactly what you need. But yeah, that's...

1:42:27 Yeah, it just, I'm not familiar with the system, but I know it is a huge number of photos and an opportunity for a lot of people. Exactly. And I'm wondering if we're making it hard enough for them to get into that it just isn't being used to the extent that it could be. I don't think the other... I know there are ways to manage systems like this where someone can actually look it up and browse it. I am familiar with the software that they use in museums as an example for some strange reason.

1:42:57 And they cannot move or delete files, yet they can visually go in and look at them. So I'm just trying to get my hand around. There would just be a lot of additional requirements for that in terms of hosting, you know, server space, the service to host those galleries. We use Syncopa as an example for just the mammothtrails.org photo galleries and just between what's already on there for those specific galleries.

1:43:26 We've pretty much completely, we've used a large portion of our allotted photo uploads there, so it would get a little bit expensive to try and have a web-hosted gallery like that. I think the reason the process hasn't been used much is because a lot of people just don't know it's there, which is part of the reason why I'm here, to try and communicate a little bit more effectively that this is a resource for everyone to use and utilize, and I would love to have more requests on my desk.

1:43:56 You know, in the future to make sure this is being used to its fullest potential and we're getting the most mileage out of these photos as we can. One idea would be, I mean, aside from the complexity of getting a request in, which seems reasonable to me, but how would anyone know that this photo library exists unless they happen to go to the MLTPA website? I know you guys hate when I'm...

1:44:24 Suggest making changes to the MLTS.org or to the Mammoth Trails. But a simple one, we have about, at the bottom of the MammothTrails.org website, we have about contact terms, privacy trail news. We could add one more that would be photo library contact. So that, you know, if I were a reporter and I was like, oh, MammothTrails.org has some killer photography and I'd like to use it, I wouldn't have any idea from that how to...

1:44:52 I mean, I suppose you could send an email, but... Yeah, but you wouldn't think, yeah, where do I go? Just a thought. Which is, I would have thought by now that it would be used by our lodging partners in brochure creation, but rather than hiring an expensive photographer, we've got the assets for them already. There's a lot of, not just news outlets, but there's a lot of reasons to use photographs for a lot of different things. Exactly, and there's some very high quality photography in there from my predecessors and from Joel and from...

1:45:19 I'm rather proud of some of the photos I've taken as well, but there's some very good stuff in there that I think people would be very enthusiastic about using if they knew about this process. So I would agree that some steps need to be taken to make sure it's more effectively communicated. And if somebody's using it for any purpose, commercial or otherwise, they assume that there's a protocol for giving credit to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. Yes, I believe there is. It's in our... Because we're just giving away stock photos. Yeah, exactly.

1:45:49 Credit would be required at the very least. Cool. If there's an interest in making these widely available, it's simply a matter of cost. That's what it is. Yeah, I mean, I think just the first thing is to make sure people understand that there is a library and then let's see where we go with that. We can build a website where people can peruse and choose just like Bill's talking about. I know how to make them and it's a matter of cost. I think that would only really make sense if we were charging for...

1:46:17 Use for commercial purposes, and then it would pay for, it could potentially pay for itself. I would say from a marketing, aside from marketing, you know, letting people know it's out there, but we use it, and it's really effective for us because we let them know what we're looking for, and, you know, Trevor always sends over, like, good pictures. They are almost always usable, so I think it's really well set up. We have a librarian. That's awesome.

1:46:46 Yeah, I'm sure if you let the Chamber of Commerce know, there would be people who would use them. Yeah, for sure. And I would very much be enthusiastic about that. All right, we're coming up on five here. I want to get through two hours here. Go ahead. Sandy Hogan. My main question was, we've invested like tens of thousands of dollars on these photos, and it's a town asset. So does the town also get the weekly backup so that...

1:47:15 In other words, so that the town owns this, the library, in other words, do we get the backup? Does it go to our IT? The town does not have a hard drive here on site with these photos on it, no. Not today. Why not? We have a system in place with a contractor that assures us they have three locations where these are stored safely. Yeah, but it's a town asset. My point is, all of those photos belong to the town.

1:47:46 So maybe we ought to consider. We could actually ask for those to all be sitting on a server. We haven't just storage space and stuff. We haven't pursued that recently with that. We had a discussion, I think. Well, but I mean, I'll bet Nate could figure that one out. I guess my point is. Maybe more importantly, it's just that make sure that the town has the passwords to access where that, I mean, if it's living in the cloud, that's fine. Yeah, exactly. It's just make sure that the town has the keys to it.

1:48:12 You got it. There's some way to do it. But just the weekly, because I think I asked this question a few months ago. Yeah, I think we had some of that on there. And it sounded like, well, once in a while, maybe there's a dump. It was kind of fuzzy. But there are ways to do it. If it's in the cloud, exactly. Do we have a secure password to get there? Not to change it necessarily or whatever, but at least for Nate to get in there.

1:48:41 Thanks, Trevor. Great work. Matt, you got anything you want to add? You're working on a couple things. I'll keep it very brief. Yeah, it is indeed almost 5 o'clock, so I will keep it brief, and that should be pretty easy. Joel's addressed a lot of what...

1:49:03 I've been working on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. Obviously, lots of different projects and opportunities in the works, Mono County-wide, and I won't address those today, but if you'd like to attend the MLR board meeting, or you already are, then you'd receive that update there. For the town, MOU special use permits were touched on briefly. Just a quick update to the board.

1:49:25 Mammoth Lakes Trail System and the website MOU are currently under review with the Forest Service. It looks like those are going forward as planned. That's a renewal of an expired MOU. The application for the special use permit is currently under review. That's just the application to then proceed and get into the Forest Service System and start working out some of the details of that and some of those gaps.

1:49:47 Kind of were brought to light today by Dan with looking at new infrastructure, new construction, trailheads, and what authority we need to enforce both municipal code or Forest Service code. And it is very important to the Forest Service and worth mentioning that those areas that are developed, rec sites managed by the town, still are, it's still known by the visitor that it's under.

1:50:09 Permit by Inyo National Forest, right? So you have that overlap of both federal and state jurisdiction, which is important and worth mentioning as it addresses overnight camping and dispersed parking and dogs off leashes and many, many things. Authorization has been granted by the Mammoth District Ranger to proceed with planning parking lot improvements at the winter

1:50:34 Recreation, the site of the winter closure at Shady Rest Park as it currently exists. So no funding yet has been identified for that. However, it is the recommendation of the forest and the town going forward to fix the existing problem there, which is an overrun parking insufficient area for the plow to turn around.

1:50:56 It's causing erosion problems as we cut further and further into that bank. So we do have permission to proceed with Inyo National Forest Engineering and the Mammoth Mono District to look at what that would look like. And we would be very remiss to not look at taking a sizable enough section of that already disturbed area to create a loop so that you can pull a trailer through there, a large vehicle, and also a plow.

1:51:19 This comes back to public safety, children, I almost said children off leashes, but dogs off leashes, children off leashes, a lot going on out there, and it was a recommendation, very much supported by the forest to look at how we can fix those current site conditions.

1:51:40 Trail host program. I don't have much to add except that a lot of that data that will be potentially collected by the winter iteration of this pilot program can help inform the next item on our agenda, which is that NEPA subpart C. Who's out there, when, and why is a huge question. The Forest Service would certainly accept help in answering that question.

1:52:04 Adopt-A-Trail Program. Both the Adopt-A-Trail Program and Trail Host Program were called out by name in the MOU. I think that's worthy of note and maybe wasn't mentioned. Adopt-A-Trail is also mentioned by name in the Forest Management Plan, which was signed by Tammy Randall-Parker, the Forest Supervisor of Montagel.

1:52:24 And there's some language in there that says, you know, address blank and blank and blank by within 10 years. Well, we have addressed Adopt-A-Trail within 10 days. So that's really great. They've met this program with total enthusiasm. They're excited about it. And we'll work through some of the details with the pilot program. It is very much a pilot program. There's going to be issues to work through, but we're going to work through them.

1:52:54 Lastly, funding opportunities. We touched on the recreational trails and greenways. We touched on the OHV Shady Rest Inyo Craters Grant. One thing that you had mentioned that brought to my attention, recreational trails program is a grant available. The application is due in February, but Bill, you brought it to my attention. You mentioned printing

1:53:21 Grant opportunities that can provide printed maps and visitor information. And unless I'm mistaken, I think Mono County has historically utilized that grant to print their back roads tours guides.

1:53:34 So there's potentially another opportunity. I will be sitting down with Dan and Joel and The Forest and Tony Dablino with the county to kind of knock our heads together and brainstorm and make a good recommendation for where we can utilize that grant or what we should be prioritizing with our application. But that is one potential there, or one among many.

1:54:01 I think that's it on the funding department front. A quick update on the ESSRP. Yesterday was the first of eight meetings that will be held for the connection to the Eastern Sierra visitor audience tract of the SNC grant that was ordered to the town.

1:54:23 So this was an invitation for boots on the ground operations and regional destination marketers to sit in the same room and talk about what issues they were facing and also how can we better coalesce our message with the visiting public and get that out there. So I know destination tourism, David, had come up a couple times in this conversation and it comes up and it really impacts and influences absolutely everything I'm doing. So yesterday's meeting was

1:54:52 Groundbreaking and many of the different partners and agencies got introduced in the same room at the same time and I hope to come back with an update.

1:55:02 As this process goes on and let you know where we stand. And Mammoth Lakes Recreation will be providing an asset report for the next meeting and how we can help with this messaging. And this committee is very integral to that whole process. So I was happy to represent MLR yesterday. And I'll continue to update you as that track moves along. Very good. Thanks for all that. Was that brief enough? That was awesome. Perfect. Questions? Questions from the public?

1:55:34 Thanks, Matt. Thank you. And I don't know if you want to stay up, Matt, for this, or whatever, you got a microphone there. Joel, Matt, did you guys want to tee up this winter recreation planning thing? Sure. So item 12, winter recreation in Inyo National Forest, subpart C planning update. So subpart C is similar to travel management that occurred here.

1:56:07 Think of it as dry season or summer season, travel management planning. This community went through that. International Forest went through that. About 10 years ago that was initiated, I think. Subpart C is a part of that, however, for winter. So analogous to that effort, but for winter. And update, I think you probably have the best update or freshest information, David, on this specific topic.

1:56:37 But it's on here so that we can get ahead of this. It's coming at us. And we'd like to consider talking to our neighbors about this before we enter formal process. Yeah, a couple things I would add. As far as timeline goes, as part of the record of decision on the forest plan, the Inyo committed to starting scoping on subpart C within a year of signing the record of decision, which

1:57:05 From everything that I understand, talking to Forest Service staff is looking like October, ideally, this coming year. So October 2020, they would open a scoping process. Bill and I and others were involved in sort of a pre-scoping, a very just basically sit around a table with maps and say, you know, let's look at winter motorized recreation.

1:57:30 But this will be much more in-depth and a full public process with public comment. One of the opportunities that I think we have compared to the six other forests that I've been working on, each of those forests has, well, five of the forests were under a specific litigation settlement that forced the Forest Service to have an alternative that was supposedly the current situation.

1:57:57 One alternative that was submitted by non-motorized groups and one alternative that was submitted by motorized groups. So the process was set up to be contentious from the very beginning to say, you know, this is it. It's either or. One group wants this. One group wants this. And so we're going to fight about it for three years. The opportunity that we have here is that they're not constrained by that on the one hand. On the other hand,

1:58:22 What is now sort of being pioneered on the Lake Tahoe Basin's version of subpart C planning is that they've opened the scope to not just say this is just strictly about designating where over snow vehicles can and can't go. It's also about parking and staging. It's also about where is snow play happening. It's about sort of a much broader winter recreation plan.

1:58:47 Which I think is exciting because that touches on a lot of the things that we're talking about and an opportunity to bring the Forest Service on board with a much bigger sort of 20-year winter recreation plan that involves trailheads and parking and snow play and connectivity between different user groups.

1:59:07 So all of that is preamble to say we basically have 10 months, I think, as an opportunity for us to come together as a community of stakeholders and potentially map out a bit of an alternative to give to the forest at scoping and say, here's our vision of what this might look like.

1:59:28 Pretty broad community buy-in, which I think the forest, from what they've expressed to me, both at the regional level and locally and nationally, they would love that. If we could come up with something that says, you know, here's the sort of least contentious path toward a good winter recreation plan, it would be awesome. Of course, we are going to have national groups and local groups come in with their baggage and try and blow that up, but...

1:59:54 To the extent that we can be strong and think seriously and holistically about how we do this, we could potentially come out with a winter recreation plan that people can buy into. So my suggestion would be that we, as a committee, recommend to MLR to form an ad hoc to begin to look at this and to bring in stakeholders and begin to map out how we would approach a community alternative for winter recreation planning.

2:00:23 And that the second piece of it would be that we recommend to ML artists set some money aside for that so we can get some facilitation and we can build a winter rec plan that works for everybody. And I would concur with that. The best way to move forward, the summer plan, the travel management plan, we formed a team called the Collaborative Action Team and we met several times and actually came to consensus between the user groups on several things. With that plan, our hands were tied because there was a certain predetermined amount of closure.

2:00:53 With this, I don't think that any of the lawsuits have created that yet, so there is no predetermined amount of closure open, so I would love to see us set aside a focused group of stakeholders that we know can work together to see if we can come up with an alternative that makes great sense. You guys, thoughts? I think having the community working group look at this is a great idea, you know, get stakeholders involved all the way around.

2:01:25 We have a lot of access and issues out there. Now and again, it comes up, well, that's going to get addressed. And here it is. It's here. So it's time to have a lot of folks step up into that. Yeah, that's a great idea. I agree. So, I mean, if you just want consensus in terms of kind of that working group, that'd be great. Sandy Hogan again, you know, I think it was great that we were excluded from that, and I believe it's because of our long history.

2:01:56 Of really, you know, the user groups working together. We actually did it even in the summertime, working on stuff. We were almost a pilot. Bill used to give up his Monday night football and so did John Connolly who rode single track and a whole bunch of people and we used to get together and we were the pilot actually for the summer travel plan and I was very happy that we weren't doing the winter at the same time.

2:02:24 Just because it would have been too much. But realize it's the whole forest. OK. We were excluded. But you know, you've got Kennedy Meadows down there. And you've got a whole bunch of stuff on the other end that is still. And so sometimes, remember, our challenge was getting the trust of some of those folks from down there. But because we did work together well up here. So I think, you know, that idea of you guys maybe all

2:02:53 Joel and Matt and Bill, you guys getting with Mike? I mean, because he's got so much history and boy, I'll tell you, that could be a real impetus for the whole forest, just having, you know, such good cooperation because I think you still have your user groups, your non-motorized user groups are still, you know, we have a good program up here and I think other...

2:03:21 Other people realize that. The non-motorized groups, so build on it and be the example for the rest of the forest. I mean, that's great, I think. And that, with your, especially your knowledge, having worked with those five.

2:03:36 Yeah, there were a lot of contentious issues. I remember the Tahoe especially, I think, wasn't it? Not the basin, but the Tahoe. Yeah, well, now we're in the LTVMU, and it's super contentious. Well, I know you are now, but the originally worst ones were, I think, the Tahoe National, as I recall, or maybe it was the El Dorado. I can't remember. It was that west side. They were all that. You know, that west side group. Thanks. Anything else?

2:04:01 The other question we had here was as far as prioritizing data collection in the winter recreation. Are we doing that now? That has to do with engaging with Janelle, actually. Apparently they have a couple of data collectors with cameras that can distinguish between user types. We don't have those counters for our program. We have infrared counters. And so we seek direction to quickly get those up wherever they see fit.

2:04:29 Yeah, I mean, so you're asking the Forest Service to do that? Yes. I mean, I don't have a problem going after that. I wasn't sure if it was our stuff that we were using to collect. It's not our hardware, but we've offered to help install it and make sure that it stays functional. Does any of our counters actually help, though? I mean, if you're looking, like, at the cross-country trails out there at Shady Rest, I mean, are we counting it? Are we collecting data on that at all? We are collecting data ourselves with our counter. We don't have the cameras. Right, or just data. I mean, it's the click or whatever.

2:04:58 Yeah, we have one. It's just total use, not by segment. But how many people are utilizing that? I see the over snow activity out there. I mean, I know the title. I mean, total use is going to be helpful, but I think, you know, for when we bring stakeholders to understand usage, I think you need both. Right. Is it X, Y, or Z type use, though? And those cameras are useful because we can extrapolate. We can use the infrared data, and then we can extrapolate those samplings of the photos.

2:05:28 So I guess if the request here is actually, it's not so much that you guys, MLTS staff doing this, but it's getting the Forest Service to utilize their assessment. Yeah, I think we should encourage them to do that. It's going to be good data to have, right? I think we're going to need that in different locations and different types. It sounded like some of what you're talking about collecting with trail hosts, too, is going to be relevant in terms of who's where.

2:05:50 Absolutely. I think good data collection. Who's satisfied? Who's satisfied? We get going on this year, especially if we got 10 months to get it done in. You're looking at this one or maybe in a little bit. Yeah, this is sort of the winner. Yeah, we should be diving in this full boat then, so I think that we can. Yeah, I'd just add, yeah, initial feedback from the forest was very supportive to have some sort of public outreach convening of stakeholders.

2:06:15 The intention being to find whatever common ground we can prior to them embarking on this subpart C. The idea being to not divide the baby, right, that's come up. And there are, I would imagine, some potential contentious issues that might come out of this, but anything we can do as a partner to help front load that for the Forest Service has been definitely smiled upon.

2:06:41 Determined by the outcomes today and what direction we want to take, I'll make sure to work very closely with the Forest Service so we don't get too far out ahead of them on this would be my only caution. Yep. Sure. We're actually requesting to use their stuff or have them go out and put their stuff up to collect data. So we shouldn't be in front of them at that point. We should be with them. Yeah, and my point of contact's out for that specific issue is currently out of the office, but it is on our desk, so we'll have an answer on that shortly.

2:07:13 So these are action items. I think you guys need to have some sort of... Do you want us to make a motion and approve it? I think so. Let's list it as a winter recreation planning update. I think the request there would be make a motion to direct Mammoth Lakes Recreation to develop an ad hoc working group to provide input on the national forest subpart C planning update. I will second that motion. Yes.

2:07:45 Did you guys hear that? No, I'm sorry. We just made a motion that you create the MLR created ad hoc working group to provide information at the Inyo National Forest on subpart C planning update. Perfect. And we have it seconded. Any further discussion on that? All those in favor? Aye. Aye. That's four of us, right? Yeah. So then there are none opposed and the motion passes.

2:08:17 Great, thank you. A quick round of committee member reports. Anybody got anything they want to report on? Yes. Yeah, let me, sorry, I was going to. Yeah, the other, that's what I was asking the question on is we're not actually, are we actually requesting MLTS to prioritize data collection or are we asking them to?

2:08:37 Maybe it's more of a consensus discussion here, but to coordinate with the Forest Service to collect data, is that actually what we're asking for? I believe so. Well, it seems like a combination of whatever data collection we're already doing, we're going to look at how that applies in winter. Yeah. We need to continue to collect data for MLTS that we're doing, and we need to coordinate the Forest Service for additional data collection on winter recreation. Yes. All of our infrastructure is installed and counting.

2:09:02 I guess, I don't know if he formal actions say, yes, go do that, or if he is consensus say, yeah, continue to collect our data and coordinate to get additional data with the Forest Service. But if the Forest Service, for example, says, well, okay, you can use our cameras, we don't have the staff to do that, then they would do that work. We need the information, so go get the data.

2:09:20 Yeah, and we really need to walk very closely hand in hand with the agency on this for that data to actually be used by them comes to Part C because if it's found to be biased or to not meet the criteria that they have, it's just going to be thrown out. So what we're saying is go coordinate with them on data collection as necessary? Yes. Go do that. I feel like we have consensus on that. Is that enough for you guys or do we? I know what you're doing. Sounds good to me. Thanks. Great.

2:09:49 Committee member reports, anybody got anything? I'm going to ride Sunday. Nice. I'll tell you more then. Yeah. I've had some concern about people just camping out in the forest in general, both in Sherwin Creek area as well as the Shady Rest area. I've heard of at least two people whose dogs have eaten human feces.

2:10:16 It had THC, high amounts of THC in it, and it was a horrible experience for these dogs. I mean, near-death experiences for the dogs. And I don't know if that's something that maybe you could go to the Forest Service and just express concern. I don't know what they're doing to regulate that. It's definitely an issue. That's putting it pretty mildly. Yeah, it's an issue.

2:10:46 Meeting yesterday with the regional stakeholders and marketing team, if there was one common theme, and Alex, if you're still here, it was poop, feces, human and pet waste management. It's a problem that plagues the forest, it plagues the BLM, it plagues the town, the county. It's difficult to monitor. It's multifaceted. The point's well taken. Some strategies I hope to come out of.

2:11:12 The CSSRP, some common grounds, some best practices. Issues at Shady Rest are maybe different than those up at Horseshoe Lake where again users and having a trail presence with the trail host program that can at least inform some of the activity at Shady Rest where frankly, personally, I believe it's more of a local issue than it is a visitor issue. So it's a really dynamic issue. It's a huge issue.

2:11:38 And the Forest Service is struggling to find an answer, as are we all. But I will continue to update the committee with anything and everything I have on that front. And we're doing our part here with Poo Ferry stations. We're looking at similar measures out at the hot springs. We're looking at watershed quality. I think we've got a better handle, honestly, with pet waste than we do with human waste.

2:12:06 I mean, I know several of my friends whose dogs have gotten very ill after eating human feces for that same reason. And the vets, you know, they took them down to the bishop vet and they diagnosed it like in 30 seconds. They're like, yeah, the dog's stoned. We'll keep trying, yeah. And I think the ESRP is a great place to address it. Rec Commission.

2:12:35 I don't know if you've listened to any of the rec commission meetings, but it's a hot topic there too. Dan McConnell's really hot on it. Just one last thing in closing. We have an empty seat that we need to fill, and just if we could be conscious of that. We don't have necessarily a formal process for that, but I would say, I mean, a couple people have expressed interest in the seat, and I think we should fill it for reasons of...

2:13:06 Having a quorum at all times and also being representative. A particular user group? Well, traditionally we've had a mountain bike user group represented. I think our matrix is pretty good right now. I'm not sure. That's a discussion I think we need to have. I would say that we should be open to accepting a resume and a cover letter saying what...

2:13:33 Contributions that person could make to the committee and to the trail system. And I think it's something we should have on the agenda for our next meeting to whatever, formalize the process or vet nominations or we just need to move forward on. Are we got anything out there asking for nominations? Is that more of a word of mouth?

2:13:52 Sorry, I just don't know. Yeah, I don't know either. I think we need to get, I think we should get the word out and we should, we should, if you know somebody who wants to do it, please nominate them. Please tell them to send in a resume and a cover letter. Yeah, cover letter of some sort. Yeah, have them just reach out to me and I'll let them know what they need to submit. All right, so you'll be the clearinghouse for that? Yes, absolutely. Point of contact. Great. And if I can make just two more announcements tomorrow night.

2:14:19 We are doing a screening in partnership with Wave Rave. We're going to be screening the movie Road List, which is a TGR movie about human-powered access, and we're going to be using the proceeds from that showing to support our winter recreation. Hopefully, maybe might need some help with our trail beacon checkers. We'll be directing those funds back to that. And then next Thursday, we're having an open house at our office at 5.30? 5. 5 o'clock. So please come by.

2:14:49 We'll have a cocoa bar and some s'mores and other little goodies, Christmas goodies. Where is that film being shown? The film's being shown at Wave Rave, and that's at 8.30. And that is next, what day, your open house? It's next Thursday. The 19th. Yes. Well, that fills up that week. I'll be at the premiere of Star Wars somewhere. There you go. Sorry. Okay.

2:15:23 Awesome. Thank you very much. Meeting adjourned.