TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2020

Town Council

· recording 2 hr 42 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

341 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:29 Here. Here. Here. Here. Passes 5-0. Pledge of Allegiance. Cassie is going to lead us in a pledge tonight. And to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, this is for all.

2:33 Public comments, this is the time when any member of the public wishes to speak on something that is not on the agenda. I will close public comments. Additions to the agenda, I have heard of no urgency items that we need to... There are no additions or subtractions from the agenda. So we will go to reports from commissions and or departments. Hi, Grady Dutton, Public Works Director. Two quick things tonight. One is I want to briefly mention just a quick informational update on the parcel.

3:12 That's all it is regarding the RFQ process. I did send out an email stating that we received five responses. We actually received six because one of them did not have a paper copy. I didn't count it immediately, but that didn't disqualify them. It just lost them a couple of points. So we received six responses. Staff has done their initial read-through. We're actually meeting tomorrow morning to go through those and be prepared to make a recommendation to cut that down to three or four for the interview process. We expect the interview process to happen sometime in February. We're going to

3:41 Formalize our interview panel, and we're going to get everybody involved at that time in February. So we're looking forward to it. I would say that we had a number of high-quality responses. We were very excited about that. So we did get the interest we were hoping for. Second item is on airport issues. Just a quick update. It's actually for Inyo County on some bishop issues. You kind of noticed, I think, last Friday about a scoping meeting they're doing for their EA for their environmental work.

4:08 They're actually going to have two. One is on January 22nd down in Bishop at Bishop City Hall. I believe that starts at 6.30, but if you could check the notice. The second is here in Mammoth in Suite Z on January 27th at 6 o'clock. And that really is just a scoping to take comments on what they're going to look at for their project, which they call out as initiation of air service into Bishop Airport and certification for Part 139 status. That's their project.

4:38 Responses to that scoping meeting are due on February 6th, so staff is going to prepare a letter for response with that, and we expect to bring it to Town Council on February 5th, so you can see it before it goes off to Inyo County. Another item is we do have a meeting with FAA on January 30th in Los Angeles. I've been attending those regularly. It's about a...

5:00 Every month or so we've been having those meetings. FAA is very interested in making sure that Bishop continues to make progress so we get together with MLT, MMSA, Inyo County, Caltrans, Division of Aeronautics, and the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and we just give updates on our respective airport progress. That's why we'll be going to that, and I'll be able to provide an update for that on February 5th when we come to Town Council. Thank you.

5:23 Just, Mr. Mayor, just one question. Great, if you could just clarify for the public's benefit exactly what the response is, what were the five respondees responding to? The request for qualifications was really just that, for qualifications for a future development partner for the town to develop the parcel. In the RFQ, though, it did say we're going to pick one or two or three. We're really going to come in with a response for that.

5:51 For qualification. Then we got some good qualified firms. Good. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Director. Just a couple quick updates. I wanted to let the council know that my department will be releasing a request for qualifications for CEQA and NEPA work.

6:15 It's basically just to refresh our current list. We have a short list of consultants that we pick from for environmental impact reports, negative declarations, those types of things. So we're going to refresh that list in advance of the parcel project moving forward. So the intent is once we move forward the parcel project, we'll be able to have an updated list of consultants that we can choose from to do the analysis for CEQA and NEPA for that project. Another note that the Planning and Economic Development Commission met last week, and they did approve the

6:45 Revised design for the Community Recreation Center. So you'll hear a little bit more about that tonight on your agenda.

6:52 And just a note that the Planning and Economic Development Commission, two of the members and I will be going to Sacramento in March for the Planning Commission Academy with the League of California Cities. So it'll be a really good opportunity. I know the council often goes to those league meetings, and none of our commissioners have ever gone to any of that type of training before, so it's kind of exciting for the commission and for myself to go and attend that training. And that's all I have.

7:18 Just one thought, Sandra. It's a great thing that you guys are going to Sacramento to do that. The town probably does not have a Lyft or an Uber account, but I would really encourage you and the members of the commission to take advantage of the multimodal transportation opportunities that are in Sacramento. From a Lyft or an Uber app, you can get an e-bike, you can get a Lyft, you can get a scooter. I think it'd be really good to start exposing that, expose yourself to that.

7:44 So these multimodal opportunities we've got and how we're going to be incorporating those, if we can, around here, that'd be a great opportunity, I think. Okay, thank you. Anything else? Can we get a timeline as to, you know, our outreach and also our contracts before we actually get a turnkey on a unit on the parcel? I mean, how far are we looking out? I mean, we have to go through an environmental impact and that's going to take how many months?

8:14 I would say a typical EIR is anywhere between nine months and a year. It just depends. And so, again, I ask the question, you know, turnkey. When can we expect units that we could actually rent or sell?

8:32 I think we'll know more when we get the development team on board. I walked in kind of as Grady was finishing up his discussion about the RFQs for the development team, but in looking at those, they have a variety of different timelines, kind of depending on the town doing the entitlements, the developer doing the entitlements, those types of things. So I think we'll have a better answer once we get through that process and we pick our developer. I don't know, Grady, if you have anything else to add. Yeah.

8:56 It's just that some of the business community comes to me and said, when are the units going to be available? Right, and we understand that. Because they're looking at staffing issues. Right, right. No, we understand that. Thank you. Thank you. Any other departments or commissions? Grady, you're back up for introductions. Thanks. I'd like to introduce the engineering group's most recent employee. Last name. Brownlee. Thank you. Just making sure it goes for that. Sorry. I know it's on here.

9:43 I did ask actually Colin to put this together, but I did have it fact-checked, so it is accurate. Originally from the eastern shore of Maryland, Colin attended school at Union College near Albany, New York, studying mechanical engineering with a minor in energy studies. He graduated just this past June. He has spent summers working various internships in other mountain towns before moving to Mammoth in July to begin an internship with our engineering department. He was drawn to Mammoth, of course, for its small community and excellent outdoor recreation.

10:11 Particularly the climbing and skiing. Since moving in town, he's enjoyed making a direct impact on the community through his work and meeting so many people with shared interests. With that call, I invite you if you'd like to say a couple of words, you may or may not, and then you can go up and meet the town. Sure. Thank you. Yeah, I just want to say thank you to everyone. I've only been in Mammoth for about six months, but I felt very welcome so far. Been a great experience working for the town so far. And again, like I said, I really like having a direct impact on the community.

10:38 And then everybody in town has been very welcoming. And I look forward to many more years here. Colin, welcome to the team. Welcome. Okay, moving on, we have a new parks maintenance worker who's going to be introduced by Warren. Good evening, Council. Warren, parks manager. I'm actually here tonight to introduce Eric Kinsey. Eric Kinsey actually...

11:29 Been on with us for about a couple months now. Great guy. He's been in the area for many years. He really enjoys the Mammoth area. Been visiting and enjoying the eastern Sears for quite a while now. He had worked for Tuolumne Meadows for about 10 years, seasonal. He was really enjoying that, but him and his wife decided, his wife Anna, decided to come to Mammoth Lakes in 2012 and make this their

11:58 Full-Time Spot. Eric recently had been working for the U.S. Forest Service in their facility maintenance. I actually worked with one of his old supervisors, and he was a little upset that I did steal Eric away from the Forest Service, so that's a good thing I feel. Eric is extremely a go-getter. He's got...

12:20 A lot of ambition of what he's been doing. He's been working over at the ice rink the last couple weeks, doing some repairs over there, and the stuff that's been coming out has been top-notch work, and we really enjoy having him aboard. So I think Eric's going to be a huge asset to the town in general, and we're really happy to have him on board. Thanks. Would you like to say anything, Eric? Welcome on board. You want to give us anything about yourself?

12:44 I'll just give a little personal anecdote is that my career really started when I was 13 with John Connolly putting in the skate park over at Shady Rest. And that was when John was just starting his career with parks maintenance. And so there's some sort of passing of the torch taking place here. And I passed by with John a few weeks ago and got to chat with him about it. And he really had nothing but good things to say about parks and recreation. So I'm just pleased to be joining up. Glad to have you on board. Yeah. Thank you.

13:16 Welcome. Welcome. You want us down there? That's okay? Yeah. Yeah, stretch. Walk around a little bit before we... We're going down. We're going to place this way. We're going to place this way. Beat the photo, too. I'm taking the photo. I'm a town photographer. And I can't see you at all. There we go.

13:54 One, two, three, smile. Thanks, everybody. Okay. Moving on from that, the next item on the agenda is a presentation on town accomplishments. I will tell you all that Stu and crew have

14:37 Made a great presentation here. We are not going to go through this whole presentation tonight. They are available in back. If you want to see all the things the town has done and where we are even going forward, that is it. I'm going to touch on a couple of what I consider highlights out of it and then ask the other council members if they want to add anything to it. The first thing I want to say is that these new chairs are wonderful.

15:03 This is great for a guy with back issues and other things going on. How nice to have a comfortable chair again. Thank you. Housing. I'm going to start with housing. Highlight for me in housing over the last three years has been the fact that we have allocated $12.5 million plus $12.5 million to housing in three years. I hear people grumbling all the time, and I read it in the paper.

15:29 How, if this is our number one priority, why aren't we spending money? Ladies and gentlemen, we've allocated an average of over $4 million a year. On our budget, that is huge. We are also, in terms of housing, going, and it's on our agenda tonight, we're going to go out to a vote for an increase in our transient occupancy tax to dedicate as a special tax to housing.

15:56 The Community Rec Center continues to move forward, and if any of you got a chance to see the virtual reality presentation the other day, it is stellar. It is going to be a great facility. In collaboration with the Forest Service and MLR and town and everybody else, we were able to raise the funds for and replace the broken bridge at Horseshoe. This is a huge accomplishment because it is working with several agencies and partners.

16:25 Crews to put it all together. We have also, for the first time, managed to find money for maintenance on our multi-use paths, which is something we haven't done before. That is huge. In our budget, hopefully starting in March, we are going to be shifting to a 24-7 police presence, which we have not had in some time. That is huge. And still managing to maintain our conservative budget.

16:54 We have had new hires on the police department and as you see all over the place to strengthen our team here and we have a great team. Our staff does a wonderful job. To me, the biggest accomplishment over this last year was we held the line on how we do the budget. Because of how councils before this changed the way the budget is viewed and done to a more conservative platform, we have managed to come up with the money

17:24 To do millions of dollars in maintenance on parks and town facilities, to build a police station, to put $12 million in three years into housing, and to me it is a direct result of how we run the budget now. It has been hugely successful, and I hope we can continue to move forward on this plane.

17:50 So that we have the excess at the end of every year to allocate to the necessary projects. And that is my take on our accomplishments. If there's something that each of you would like to add or subtract, I'm more than willing to hear it. Good job. I didn't know we were going to speak on this, but I think you covered a lot of the points. And I, too, am enjoying the chairs, except for I've got this much space between my feet and the ground.

18:20 I'll take a block next time. All I want to say is that the snow removal has been very good this year. Of course, we haven't had much snow. But last year, when we had 170% of normal, the crews did a great job. So, you know, they're there. So when it does come, and it might happen tomorrow or next week, the crew is ready to move on it. So I compliment them on the work they do.

18:51 No, really good summary. Really nice presentation by staff. Two things. I think our sidewalks on Main Street are phenomenal. Not just are they there, but they're actually plowed in the winter thanks to staff. And when I drive down there, I see people walking and really enjoying it. And I think that's been phenomenal. Not just because they're great to have, but the safety factor of that is also. We know more, you know,

19:19 Swerving around, skiers walking down Main Street without any sidewalks, so that's a happy thing, I think. And the other thing is just I really am excited for the disc golf course. I think it's a good addition to our kind of plate of offerings for people, and it's very affordable. All you have to do is have the discs, and families can go out there, and I think it's great for...

19:43 Locals and families and tourism, I think it's a huge win. So good on us to get that done with the Forest Service. So those are two of my favorite kind of additions. Excellent. John? Mr. Mayor, I want to echo many of your sentiments, certainly on the budgeting and not so much, I mean...

20:03 The budgeting process is great. Our discipline has been good for all kinds of good fiscal reasons, but it's providing a level of stability and balance and focus, which I think is really allowing the staff and all the members of the team to really do their best work.

20:18 And I can't even begin to talk about all the great things that have happened this year. It's in this document, but I think I want to echo Linda's comment about Main Street. I think there's been a lot of talk in past years about being developer ready. And maybe there's a lot of that stuff in the back of the house and documents and things like that. But I think now with what Main Street looks like and the vibrancy that's going on in this community, I think we're sending the message out that needs to be said.

20:44 Look how good we look. Look how much fun we all have up here. And, you know, we're ready for the challenges that are coming our way, so I'm very excited about all that. My only comment is that I have a profound interest, I think we all do, in figuring out a way to getting these accomplishments into our local news cycle and getting it in there on a weekly or a biweekly basis. This is a great document. It's great to see it all, but let's every week, every two weeks.

21:13 We could take a lesson from Mammoth Lakes Tourism, our marketing folks who buy dedicated space to newspapers every couple weeks and hear the top five things that we're doing and I really would hope we can come back to that and we can do that because we're doing really good and interesting stuff. I'm very proud to be a member of this council and proud to be a member of this organization.

21:34 Thank you. I'd like to add just a couple things, too, if I may, regarding this. I do want to thank the staff that put this together. I think it's a document that we can all be very proud of. It's only the accomplishments that are in it. And hearing you, John, you're exactly right. We really need to share some of the more positive things that we're working on, because there's a lot of things that we do. And I think once a year is probably not enough.

21:55 In a cycle with which we're presenting this out to the community so they can see those things and maybe get more involved in that is a good thing. We all love sharing positive thoughts, but the team did a great job in putting this together and very proud of it. If I can add to that, we had 14 objectives and we made movement on each of them. So if you're looking at this document on town accomplishments, you know,

22:22 Count up the objective and look at the progress that has been made on each one of them. Important for the people out there to understand, Kirk, what you just brought up. This is based on our previous work of priorities and goals. And they are all laid out here and the movement that has been made on every one of them, as you say, is highlighted here. So I encourage you to pick this up and look at it. It is a great...

22:49 Presentation. It was a good job. Attaboy, Stu. Okay. Anyone from the audience wish to comment on that? Yes. I'd just like to say I think the signs are so nice because people never knew before. Even living here, you'd go, it's, you know, after that brown building. So now it's so nice to have signs. I really appreciate that and I think that will help with traffic flow. Thank you. Thank you.

23:20 I will move on then to consent. Anybody wish to pull anything from consent? Mr. Mayor, I would like to pull item number 11 and 12. Okay, we will pull 11 and 12. I can, if you like. So here's the consent. Approve the minutes of the special meeting of December 11. Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of December 18. Accept and file the SB 165 tax accountability report.

23:56 For North Village, I dropped a resolution adopting the Mammoth Yosemite Airport Capital Improvement Plan. Approved the supplemental agreement for engineering design and construction management of the wildlife security fence project at the airport. Approved supplemental agreement for the engineering design and construction management of the security gates and terminal area fencing at Mammoth Airport.

24:22 Approved the supplemental agreement for the engineering, design, and construction management on the reconstruction of the town hangar, taxi lane, and slurry seal taxiway projects at the Mammoth Airport. Authorized the mayor to sign a letter to Cook has been pulled. Authorized to the mayor to sign another letter to Cook has been pulled. And accept payment approval reports 2022.

24:51 2022 and 2023. I'd like to just make a comment on agenda item 10.

25:01 Is that this is ongoing. We have multiple partners, you know, Inyo, Bishop, and everything else. So this will come back to us, just to let the public know, this will come back to us to look at all these different partnerships and the financial arrangements that need to be put in place. We want to move forward on the airport, and also Bishop and Inyo want to move forward on their airport. So a lot of issues with Bishop, Mammoth Lake Tourism, Mammoth Lake Skiri, the T-Bag.

25:30 There's cattle leases down at the Bishop Airport. Got a lot of issues to deal with here, and I'm glad to see that we're moving forward on it. Very good. I would accept a motion. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Council approve the consent agenda items as you've listed them. Public comment on?

26:00 I'll second the motion so that that motion is on the floor. Got it. That's right. Sandy? Sure. Yes, I was hoping that the item 8 would also be pulled so we could discuss that a little bit because it was unclear to me if that was actually going out for bid for construction or if it's... Okay, we will also pull agenda item 8. Thank you. Sandy Hogan. Now would anybody like to redo their...

26:36 I will redo the motion as amended to pull item eight as well. I'll amend my second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Roll call. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. 5-0. Let's go to item number eight. Sandy, you asked for us to pull this. Would you like to ask questions or?

27:12 Yes, I guess so. Right. As I recall last year, this one has to do with the fencing and the wildlife crossing issue that's been up before the LTC in many years. Actually, Larry Johnson was very much in favor of holding this up. And I believe that Grady told us that last year, or you're...

27:40 Or so before that, you know, as long as the airport plan, improvement plan is actually approved, then the various projects don't necessarily have to move right away. And this is one that was very important to the LTC in that actually Caltrans, believe it or not, is actually doing the PSR, the

28:06 Project Study Report. They volunteered their staff to do it for wildlife crossings because if we just build the fence, then what happens is the deer cross the highway, run into this eight-foot chain-link fence, and then they cross it back, which doubles the chance of mortality.

28:31 It doubles the chance of collisions with vehicles, whatever. And so that's why it's been a long-term issue with the LTC. And that's why they have the Wildlife Crossing Committee, which I believe is meeting next week. I think that was brought up at this week's LTC meeting. And we know that Tim Taylor with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife has been kind of in charge of the committee and he's searching for funding. And it takes a long time. But I guess the main thing with this one,

29:00 Maybe I'm reading it wrong, but if construction can be held up, it would be very important for that committee and for the commitments that have been made in the past, whatever. So that's some of my committee. I do have other comments, but perhaps the question to Grady would be appropriate. Yes, thank you, Sandy. That's actually a very good question, of course.

29:29 It's actually related to item number nine because when we looked at the fence project knowing that we had work to do with the Forest Service and on the crossing issues, we also recognized that we had some security issues and access issues on the north side related to the vehicle gate and the pedestrian gate. So if you look at item nine, you'll see we actually separated.

29:47 The wildlife fence that goes all around the airport from the smaller section in the area of Hot Creek so we can move forward with that. We wanted to get it redesigned and we certainly won't go forward before the environmental work is completely done with Forest Service and everybody else. But we wanted to separate it so we could make sure that we got that security fencing done. So thank you. Perfect. Thank you very much for clarifying that. Okay. Okay. With that, I would entertain a motion on 8. Oh, I'll make a motion to approve agenda item number 8.

30:20 I'll second that. Motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yep. 5-0. So we have asked for 11 and 12 both to be pulled? I had a comment on both of these and it was in regards to the letter from the town to Paul Cook.

30:54 Congressman, and that is that if you refer to the RCRC letter, which follows each one of these, there is a pretty substantial number of people that were CC'd on it, and I just suggested that we add that same list of CC's to our town letter rather than just have it go only to Congressman Cook's office and then stop there. So I think if we, both of these items, if we follow the

31:21 CC list on the RCRC letter, I think that it is, will be more meaningful. So that was my suggestion. Is that on both? Is that on 11 and 12? No, actually no, I correct that. Okay, so let's deal with it individually. So now number 11, which is the letter regarding the public safety power shutdowns that we make sure the CCs include the list from RCRC, so that would be number 11.

31:53 Comments or questions? Kirk? No, I support. Okay. Getting the information out there. There is a typo, though, that it's been fixed. Okay. Cleland? Nothing. John? Real quick, a little bit of context. On a visit back to D.C., I met with Congressman Cook's staff and advised them that we were having these two problems, which is the sort of the origination of both of these letters, which is a very good thing. Great staff has followed up, but that's good.

32:22 There's one other issue having to do with something called the Townside Act, which has to do with, as a public agency, our ability to exchange land with the federal government. Congressman Cook's office has requested a letter on that as well. It may take a little staff work to figure out exactly what we'd like to propose, but I think it'd be a very good thing to get that. And I know that that is being worked on.

32:44 Yeah, and get our bundle of stuff in place so that we can get it to Congressman Cook, get a package in place so whoever the next congressional representative is, they could maybe hand it off to that person. We could even use it as a part of the campaign to see, make sure that our candidates support this thing we're going to try to do. So there's another piece to this to follow. That's all I had to say. Thank you. I have no problem adding the CCs that are on the other list. That's really what the question is. Are you in concurrence that we should add those CCs? Yeah.

33:12 Just one more comment. I think that if you take a moment to read through the letter from RCRC, that their list of suggestions and mitigation to the power shutoffs are very, very reasonable. So if you, you know, the issues we're having and the concerns we had about these shutoffs and the procedures that the utility was using, I think this addresses it well. And interestingly, it comes, the chair of RCRC right now,

33:41 Is Matt Kingsley, who is also a member of the Inu County Board of Supervisors, so it's very local and we appreciate that immensely, so yeah, that's all I have. Thank you. So then would you make a motion? Yes, I will make a motion to approve item number 11, agenda item number 11. With the addition of the CCs. With the addition of the CCs at the end of the letter, in concert with the CCs listed in the RCRC letter. I second the motion.

34:09 I have a motion and a second. Any member of the audience wishing to speak? More deliberations here? Yeah, I just, the number of requirements, you know, 17, and I think they're all relevant as to informing the public, informing the town, informing the fire district, and everybody else as to what's going on as far as our utilities, electric utilities. So the number of requirements I think is very important to keep those in there.

34:39 To make sure that they are meeting those requirements. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Passes 5-0. Lynda, you're up again. Okay, and then on to number 12. Now, this is a letter from town to Suddenlink. And as many of you are aware, there's been some concerns with Suddenlink, particularly around customer service. And this letter is to...

35:12 begin a paper trail, if you will, of that. I know that we've also met with some representatives from Suddenlink around this, and that there are no CCs on here. I mean, I would think, you know, minimally it would be the, you know, the CPUC, maybe Mono County, I mean, whatever. We think I would defer to staff and maybe Andy to sort of come up with a list of appropriate, or if people here have thoughts about who maybe that should be CC'd to, I think we should...

35:41 Make this also a little bit more touching more people than just Congressman Cook. You might consider adding the CPUC video franchising division. I think they have an office. It's like an office of ratepayer advocate, but it's called something else. And they are the body within the CPUC that is intended to field customer complaints. So I think that would be a useful addition. It doesn't have to change the substance of the letter. Just I think we should include them.

36:09 Okay, so you can work with staff to make sure that we have the right context on that, and I think that would be useful. Do we need a motion? Is to approve it, adding the... Is there any discussion? Anybody want to comment on it? No, I don't. No, I support. Okay. Okay, then I will make a motion to approve agenda item number 12 with the copies going to minimally CPUC and others as identified by town attorney and town staff.

36:41 I'm second.

36:43 Motion and a second.

36:45 Any further deliberation?

36:48 Jamie.

36:49 Council Member Hawke?

36:50 Yes.

36:50 Council Member Stapp?

36:51 Yes.

36:51 Council Member Whitmore?

36:52 Yes.

36:53 Mayor Pro Tem, Celcius?

36:54 Yes.

36:55 Yes.

36:56 I get more complaints on them than anyone else in town.

37:01 I would love, Andy, at some point for us to look at our franchise agreement and see if there isn't something that we can do to turn the screws a little bit.

37:09 You know...

37:11 With the change in the law back in 2006, we no longer have a franchise agreement. It's instead a statewide franchise agreement, and there's no document that you can look at and say this is the agreement. Instead, the parameters of all the agreements that are issued by the CPUC are kind of set forth in something called DivCA, which is in the public utilities code that the phone companies basically wrote because they wanted to become cable companies. So we have almost no leverage. We are...

37:35 We're required to enforce some relatively toothless customer service standards that are in the law, and we can certainly look and see if Suddenlink has violated any of those, but because they were written by the people that are going to be governed by them, they're not real strong, and if we do manage to issue any fines, I think we have to submit half the fine amounts to the CPUC, but we can certainly look and see. I'll need to talk to staff to find out exactly what Suddenlink is doing here. They're pretty poor where I live as well, and if there is a way to

38:05 To tell them that they're not meeting their obligations, we'll do that. Thank you. And Mr. Mayor, I would really encourage that effort. Even if whatever you can find is granular, it's seemingly immaterial. I mean, Al Capone, what did he go to jail for? Tax evasion. Yeah, exactly. So if we have to find something on Suddenlink and their parent company, Altus, whatever that is, I think it's worth doing to give us something to try to pursue. Because I hear from folks all the time about the same thing.

38:39 Okay, moving on then to item number 14 in policy matters. Consider an ordinance banning flavored tobacco. Andy. So you recall that we were before you in November with something along these lines looking for some direction as to what the council would like to do. We thought we heard kind of a consensus to come back and bring you an ordinance that is very, very similar to the Mono County ordinance. So that's what is in the packet.

39:09 The heart of the Mono County Ordinance and the heart of this one are the same. They're substantively identical.

39:17 The core of each of them is a pair of definitions. One is flavored tobacco, because both the county ordinance and this draft ordinance say that the sale of flavored tobacco products would be prohibited. And then the definition of flavored tobacco gets into what's called a characterizing flavor. It's an odd phrase, but that's what everyone seems to be using. So a characterizing flavor would include fruit flavors, menthol.

39:40 Just all kinds of things. So in accordance with the direction that we received at the last meeting on this, this is a complete ban. There's no phase-in period other than allowing retailers to sell the stock they have on hand, but they can't buy any more stock. Some cities that have done this have imposed, in addition to that, an absolute deadline so you can sell your existing stock but only until a certain date. Some have had delayed implementation, so this ban is going to go into effect in 30 days.

40:09 This one does neither. Mono County, as you know, had a kind of a phase-in period, which is now expired. So this one reflects the county's ordinance in its current and final form. That's about it. I will also note that there is at least one bill pending at the state legislature that would, if adopted, enact a statewide ban, and the definitions in this draft ordinance are consistent with the definitions that would be in that bill if it were to become law.

40:41 We get a weekly handout on what the state is doing, so that's my question. It says the California bill will ban flavored tobacco sales going further than the feds, including menthol cigarettes. So are we in sync with what just is evolving at the state level? This is consistent with that. I mean, some of the definitions are the same. There are a couple other things that might be slightly different, but...

41:06 You know, this has just been introduced. So there's a very similar bill last year that was introduced, and then it kind of didn't go anywhere. That bill has kind of been revived with a different bill number, and that's the one that was just introduced this month. And, you know, who knows what its prospects are. But if the town adopts, if the council adopts this ordinance, we'd be getting out in front of what the state is doing. There's not a preemption issue. There's not a conflict issue. So this ordinance, if adopted, would...

41:32 Would work perfectly well with a statewide ban, just that we would have this one in effect well in advance of a statewide ban taking effect. Thank you. Questions? I don't have any questions. Okay, then I will call for comments from the audience. I'm Debbie Schnod from Mono County Office of Education, and one of my jobs is the tobacco use prevention education person.

42:07 And I'm here tonight just to hopefully clap for you. And I'm really excited with the prospect of you adopting this ban even ahead of the state and federal because we know that that gets pretty bogged down. And there's a lot of children at risk every single day.

42:32 Next week I have a meeting with a bunch of children from the middle school and the high school that have been caught with vaping devices, and so I'm going to do some education with them and work on some projects that hopefully then they will turn around and share with their peers the dangers that we know of vaping. So, you know, I'm just hoping with all of my heart that you guys take this really seriously and know that there's many, many children.

43:01 That are paying the consequence of big tobacco kind of doing another around, you know, around the corner and getting another generation of young people hooked. So I just want to say thank you for taking the time to think about it. And thanks. Good evening, Mayor. Good evening, guys. Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. A little bit shaken.

43:46 I'm sorry. I just want to thank you to have me here in the meeting. Give us your name. Rami. I'm the owner for the smoke shop. Yeah. I'm sorry. And I want to thank you to have me here in this meeting to listen to me for a little bit. And I'm sure I'm here. I'm not going to make you to stop it or

44:14 Thank you for everything you guys been doing here in the town. And for if you guys see here, I'm the only business owner here in town because basically I'm the only person I sell the vape in town from the retail business in town. And I know it's been hard in you guys to make decisions for this situation.

44:43 And I just want to ask you guys with full heart, if you, I know you guys are going to do something, I'm sure if you guys want to do something, just like, don't be, don't be rough in me, just like, work with me, because I'm, I'm the only person I'm getting hurt from the whole situation. Not because you, nothing attack me personally, I know that you guys doing your own job, and I thank you for that.

45:13 You know, the reason is, I know the state law is going to do it, as California state is going to do it. We don't know when exactly they're going to do it. Just like, again, if something is going to happen tonight, please, I'm asking you, give me good time, because I have lots of inventory, and I'm the only person I have in town. And I thank you for everything you guys did.

45:42 And I'm not going to take more time from your time. I know you guys want to go to see the kids and family and wife. God bless you. Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else from the public wishing to speak on this? Okay, John, I'll bring it back to you. I have one quick question. In the resolution before us...

46:04 How much time is allowed for the disposition of inventory and stock and those kinds of things? As I said, there is not a specific deadline in here. Some ordinances have had that. This one does not. You can certainly add that if that's something the council would like to do. But at the moment, it's just sell your existing stock, can't buy any more. Okay. I'm good with that. Thank you.

46:31 I have the same concerns, John, because it says there's no final cutoff date by which existing supplies must be sold, although both of those could be added. So a year out or nine months out or whatever, I don't know. We need to work with him to find out what kind of inventory he has. So I want to stop this. Sure. But this is somewhat arbitrary in the sense

47:01 It doesn't say when the cutoff is. Well, I think one option would be to ask any retailers in town that are currently selling these products to work with us by giving us a list of what they have on hand, giving us an estimate of how much inventory they have, how many boxes, how many cartons, how many whatever it is.

47:23 And giving us kind of an estimate of when they anticipate selling through all that. And then that would at least give us a baseline and a way of going back to them and checking up. I mean, I think it would be in their best interest to work with us on that so that we are not citing them for selling off their existing inventory legitimately. But that could be an approach. Or if you'd like to have a date, we'll have a date. Well, I think we need to talk to the gentleman and find out what kind of inventory you have.

47:53 And then we need to have a cutoff date. That's just one council person. I believe we have to have a cutoff date. No, I can agree with that. I think the other question is whether I'm assuming, and I may not be right, is that this inventory can be sold on the wholesale market to another state. We're not selling whatever is in this inventory into our community. We could maybe do a combination of set a date, but the understanding that hopefully a lot of this stuff can be sold.

48:21 I don't know, back to wherever it came from or returned or sold somewhere else. I don't know that business, so I don't know. But I would not like to see the entire inventory just sold out into our community. But I don't want it open. No, exactly. Sure. Okay. There has to be a cutoff date. Let's continue with Council. Comments, Cleland? Okay. I have the same problems with this that I had last time. First,

48:50 It is my belief, after talking to many retailers in Mammoth, that the bulk of these products is not being bought locally, it's being bought online and shipped in. Kids are very good at doing that. And talking to the gentleman from the local smoke shop, he's not selling enough product for what he's selling to be making the impact we're being told is being made in our schools. So I have that issue. Stopping it locally is not going to stop that.

49:18 I got attacked after the last time because somebody sent out some kind of a flyer saying that I was not for our kids and didn't support a smoking ban for our kids. Nothing could be further from the truth. I am in favor of banning the flavored vape products that are becoming so popular with the youth and that are getting them addicted to nicotine. I have no problem doing things to cut that off.

49:45 Currently the age is 18 and it's going to go up to 21 or there may be a state ban. Irrespective of that, I believe that this is not aimed at kids. Menthol cigarettes, cigars and cigarillos, chewing tobacco and snuff with flavors have been around since before I was born. These are not new products. These are not products that are being used primarily by kids. These are products that adults are using that have made the conscious decision to do that.

50:17 My personal belief system, I have a problem creating government regulations that tell adults how they have to respond. There is no one who is more death on cigarettes, ask my friends who smoke, than me because I have major lung issues without having ever smoked. But I believe that this is an overreach. This is a government overreach. It's just my belief system.

50:45 If you want to ban the vaping products, raise the age of locals to 21, we have done, and the chief isn't here, Eric is here, I know we have done stings, how many shops have we caught selling to underage? I don't have the stats on what we got from the sting, but I can tell you, I talked to Officer Hanson since October 19th.

51:20 Just from the schools alone, we've taken 20 devices, and yesterday we took six devices. And the thing that's becoming more popular now, more prevalent, is the single-use device that doesn't require a recharge, and they can use it, you know, six, eight times before it's...

51:41 All used up and then they throw it away. It looks like a little syringe. So that's the, I mean, I just got briefed on this tonight and I did look at the staff report that was submitted by Mr. Morris to council and I would agree with the analysis but I do think it's going to be an issue on how this is regulated and how we, you know.

52:04 Look at the stock and the inventory and figure out this online issue. I think you're absolutely correct. It's going to be a difficult thing to combat based on what people have in stock because of the online issue. But seeing these single-use devices coming in now and the prevalency of that, which is a fairly new thing, tells me that it's evolving. I can get you the report on how many...

52:32 Arrests and how many things that we got in that sting operation. In fact, I could get a hold of Officer Hanson. I told him I was going to be here tonight and get that information for you. And that being said, if you want to add the ban on single-use vape products, I have no issue with that because they're aimed at kids again. I just have an issue with products that have been around for generations and adding them into this list. Do kids...

53:01 Start with these things? You bet. Normally, the kids that start with these things start with parents that have them. So now are we going to tell parents how they have to raise their children? I mean, it all leads into a very murky political field for me. How much power as government do we want to take from the people and place in our own hands because we know better? Is menthol meant? And then where does it go from there? Yeah. Thank you. And I do believe there were two.

53:30 Two offending places in town that sold once each. That's what he said last time. Yeah, and I could get you those exact numbers. No, it was two is what he said at the last meeting about this. Okay, so. May I speak now? Yes. Okay. As I've shared with you before, I worked with the tobacco program for many years as public health director. And what we know about

53:58 These products is it's about the nicotine, you know, that the flavors in themselves are not of harm. What the harm of the flavors is, it's the gateway to nicotine addiction. And for any adult in the room who has been a smoker, quitting smoking is one of the most difficult things that I hear people relate. I was not a smoker. I smoked as a child because my parents were both heavy smokers, so I didn't need to smoke because they were smoking. And so what...

54:27 What we worked on all these years was trying to reduce the number of youth smoking because it is a gateway to becoming a lifelong smoker. We were doing really well, really well. And as Debbie alluded, the end run around was from the tobacco companies. Well, if we can't get them with traditional tobacco products, what can we do?

54:51 So the vaping stuff was initially marketed as, well, helping adults quit smoking, but quickly evolved into, and there's now lawsuits going on, proving the fact that these tobacco companies intentionally targeted youth to bring them into the nicotine world, if you will. We also know that, yes, even though menthol has been around for a really long time, it was initially invented to mask the nasty flavor of raw tobacco. That's true. But at this point,

55:21 Majority of youth who are smoking, particularly girls 14 to 17, their flavor of choice is 90th percentile of menthol. So menthol is definitely that hook. Now, if you believe that tobacco causes harm, if you believe tobacco causes disease, and it's one of the, it's probably the most prevalent behavior that leads to chronic disease.

55:48 Then if your goal is to stop people from becoming addicted to nicotine, then I think under the education level and under the pillars of sort of prevention, the pillar that is the largest is that pillar of policy. And if we have the ability to set the policy to make it not as attractive for teens to become addicted to nicotine, then that's one small step we can do. We don't know how much locally...

56:16 Purchased flavored tobacco is actually goes into our youth because we can't track that. Adults buy it. You know, the age for, you know, purchasing tobacco is such no one can buy it. We've been doing stings for, you know, 20 years and more than I know of. And it has started out really high and over the years, I think.

56:38 You know, people who sell tobacco in the county and town know that we've had a very diligent enforcement program over the years, so I would not expect it to be much higher. Two is actually a pretty high number, because we many times would get zero for town, and that was what our goal was. So yes, I do advocate for this. I think it's an action that we can take to protect youth.

57:01 And if it makes tobacco less attractive for adults because they can no longer buy the menthol, we'll see what happens when the federal ban comes in, when and if it does. They're getting into a lot, but they excluded menthol. The state legislation is identical to this, so that's where I feel about that piece. As far as getting rid of product in town, remember, it's more than just tobacco shops. It's the liquor stores, the market, they all sell tobacco.

57:29 So it will be on all of them also to, you know, not buy any further stock. So putting a date on it, I mean, I would be willing to even go out as far as six months myself to be really fair to people who hold a good deal of stock and not wanting to penalize someone for having done what was a legal activity for a long time. And I don't think that we should be punitive with that. But I think us getting ahead of even what the state ban might possibly be is good policy on the part of our town. That's what I have to say.

58:00 I can add more. I have talked to two teachers, and it is happening to add, in our middle school, and even our middle school starts at sixth grade, so pretty young. If you do the research on this, I mean, there has been 37 deaths that have been related to this. You know, the kids have gone overboard on it, and that's not...

58:27 You know, there's a parenting issue there. And there certainly is the bill, I agree, there's the online issue. They will continue to buy it online until the federal government steps in. But that, you know, all we can do is send something to our senators and Congressman Cook and say, hey, this is an issue and you need to be putting, you need to be dealing with it. It is a gateway, it is a gateway drug, nicotine.

58:54 And I think we need to do as much as possible. Okay. With that, I think we have all had our say. If someone wants to make a motion or not, I would entertain it. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council waive the first reading and read by title only the draft ordinance banning the sale of flavored tobacco products in Mammoth Lakes with an expiration date, a hard date for liquidation of inventory by Election Day, Tuesday, November 3, 2020. I'll second the motion.

59:28 So while you're delivering on the motion, so the way that would get stitched in is it would be an amendment to subsection D of draft section 9.24.080 that would amend section D to say that a retailer's inventory includes et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, may continue to sell the products until

59:51 Supply is exhausted or November 2nd, 2020, whichever comes first, comma, but shall not thereafter order new supplies. November 3rd. November 3rd, yes, sorry. What he said. I will support the attorney. I have a motion and a second without any other deliberation. I will call for the roll call vote, please. No. Yes. Yes. Yes. No. And again, it's not the ban on what is...

1:00:23 The kids are going after. It is, in my opinion, the overreach that this does. Moving on. Thank you all. Yes, Deb. It passes. I appreciate the effort put in by all of you that are writing the policy.

1:00:52 You know, when I sit with those kids and watch them in tears because of the addiction that they have and know that their brains are being rewired, I believe with all of my heart and with all that I've read and all that I do every day to help prevent this, that it's the right choice and I really, really am.

1:01:15 Excited and happy that we're moving forward with this. And thank you for joining with the school district and the county office of education with our policies of no tobacco. Thank you. Thank you. Hopefully you'll still talk to me. Well, no. I mean, now that that's done, I guess we can work on an alcohol ban as well because that is a very, very dire situation.

1:01:41 With our kids as well. And I find it very strange that that is not brought up as a viable solution as well. Or the number one killer of our youth automobiles. If I may. I just want to thank all the people who have advocated for tobacco control over the years, not just with this item, but, you know, going back to, I believe, the early 90s is when we first got some funding coming from the state, the state tobacco tax that came out and the really hard work. So thanks to the...

1:02:10 County Health Department, Office of Education, and all the other advocates, so thank you to everyone. Okay, moving on to an update on the new multi-use facility, Community Recreation Centre at Mammoth Creek Park. Thank you, Mayor. Stuart Brown, Parks Recreation Director. Grady is here in support. Hayes was not able to be here, so I'll run point on the project and the update this evening. Try and keep it brief.

1:02:47 So we're just going to give you an update on progress to date of the Community Recreation Centre at Mammoth Creek Park. November 20, Town Council did affirm their commitment to the facility, voting to approve the complete $13 million funding package. I'm going to cover those items in the staff report this evening, starting with the facility design and aesthetics, building plans and middle and cost estimates, walking through kind of the project schedule as we are or have today.

1:03:16 The environmental and planning update, which Sandra briefly touched on. And then we'll wrap up with kind of facility operations and programming. So HMC and staff met on January 8th to review and discuss the interior and exterior design finishes, which is a little bit of what you're seeing on the screen. The most recent schematic design and the interior and exterior materials. Those materials were part of the package from two years ago, the previous project. So we're able to kind of get ahead of the...

1:03:45 A lot of the work that goes into fitting out a 40,000 square foot building. And as everyone was excited about, we were also able to view the facility in 3D, which was great. What we weren't able to see in 3D was the interior. So we hope to have those interior renderings up to council and the 3D headsets at a future time. But they certainly gave you a different and I think more realistic, you know, look, expectation of what that facility is going to be. And the functionality wise, we couldn't be happier.

1:04:15 What that facility is going to provide our community. So while we have the renderings up on the screen, they're also in your packet and for the benefit of the public. The first rendering here shows you different views of the facility. The first one, kind of that top left, shows you looking from essentially the street or closer to where the corner of the parking, the existing parking area is right now.

1:04:44 We didn't impose the playground, but the playground would be where that person is kind of walking on the left there. So the playground is going to stay. It is. We've obviously reorientated, so it's permanent. We're not moving that again. But you can see there's a far greater access and sense of arrival to the facility, as you can see on that top left image.

1:05:07 You can also see a lot of the facade, the trellises that we hope that will be complementary to the sprung structure. The lower image there shows you the view from the enhanced parking lot. The parking lot is not part of this $13 million project. And then the images on the right just show you the views from, again, the south side, sorry, the east side of the facility.

1:05:35 The middle one there shows you from kind of Mammoth Creek Park if you're walking down the trail and then the other one as well from kind of the back of the building. So some good perspectives. This just shows you some elevations again from north, south, east and west. What we're really super excited about is that lower image that's looking from the south to the facility. You can see just a lot of the glazed windows. So again, I'll give you that kind of inside out.

1:06:02 Look and feel of the facility. So if you're inside the facility, you look towards the Mammoth Sherwins, which would be spectacular. And then in summertime, we have three roller doors, kind of strategically located that they'll align with each of those kind of interior court spaces. So they get a kind of a nice flow through of air in and out of the facility. So you can see we've tried to combine a combination of...

1:06:25 A large building but kind of breaking it up with glazed windows, some good facade, some aesthetics. And the colours, this is kind of what we presented to the PEDC Design Review Committee and the committee on January 8th shows you the current colour palette and that's using kind of the white colour, the grey and the blue which is consistent with the logo of the town. So that's kind of our branded colours.

1:06:54 And then you can see the other materials, you know, the wood colours, the grey concrete. So it's very, what we believe, you know, aligned with certainly the brand, the colour and the environment. So that's kind of where we're at with the designs. The next phase of this, as it went to the PDC, as Sandra stated, the PDC did approve the project.

1:07:24 They did request, however, that it come back for consideration of additional colour choices and potential placement of a larger town logo on the building, on the south side of the building there. So we're going to look at those options and kind of bring those back to the entire Planning and Economic Development Commission at a future time. So that...

1:07:51 Kind of leaves us where we're at with that project. This doesn't slow the schedule down. That was, you know, something that we wanted to be reassured with. And Hayes affirmed that if we can keep moving forward, we have approval for the environmental work, they approved the amendment. It's just going to be kind of the colour choice. Sprung is actually with HMC tomorrow, so they're going through a lot of those details. So we believe we're kind of on schedule.

1:08:19 As I said, the plans were submitted. The town has them. They're under review. The PDC affirmed the addendum. And then we're working with HMC right now on getting the project to bid in February slash March. So that's kind of our latest time frame there with hopefully a return back to council for the potential funding of the contract in early spring.

1:08:48 Our project schedule. Hayes isn't here, but he's assured me that we're on track. So I know Grady's here, you can kind of jump in at any time, but that's where we are at on that schedule. As far as facility operations, you know, as we discuss this with the commission every month, and, you know, although the type of facility has changed, the goals, objectives, and certainly the vision for the facility have not, right? So it's...

1:09:15 It's a phenomenal community recreation centre. And as we have been working over the last five years with the Recreation Commission, really engage with the community on affirming the programming. We've done a lot of work with comparable facilities. And then as you can see on this little table I've provided for you in your staff packet, it walks through our current work program to get us to a draft kind of operations and management plan by April, May of this year.

1:09:44 A little daunting, but we're making progress. So what that plan will do is will kind of guide us as we move forward with a potential opening and ribbon cutting of the facility. What we're kind of slating for is Memorial Weekend 2021. It's not that far away. This facility goes up very quickly.

1:10:06 We are tentatively building a schedule that will open Memorial. We'll start with summer, clearly. So our first winter operations would be November 21, going through April of 2022. So we have the scope of work. I can kind of go in a little bit more detail, but we spent considerable time looking at a lot of comparable facilities, winter, summer. We've updated those playbooks.

1:10:32 Pretty much finalise kind of how we see summer operating right now and then we're working through our winter operations. We're receiving design input from our ad hoc committee which has been great. So that's our recreation commission and Mammoth Lakes recreation ad hoc committee. They're seeing everything that we're seeing. So they're providing great input, feedback and comments not only on kind of the design and the aesthetics and breaking up the facade of the building but also on the programming. So that's been very helpful.

1:10:58 And we'll also, through this plan, get through kind of what we see as our proposed staffing and then how we look at our fee schedule again with kind of those revenue expense projections later in March. Okay. So that's really it. I'm happy to answer any questions. If they're technically in nature, I'm going to look at Grady and Grady can kind of come up. You know, I can cover probably the general questions. And then I know Betsy is here and I know Matt is here as well.

1:11:27 And really the next phase for this project is as the building moves towards bid and awarding of the bid, that's when we really start launching more aggressively the project to the public. You know, that's going to be kind of this big public launch. We'd like to get the goggles back, get some nice big renderings of the facility and really showcase and hopefully, you know, seek and gain a lot more what we believe public awareness, public understanding and excitement for this amazing facility.

1:11:52 Okay, I will come to the Council for questions. Start with two. My question is, when the bids come in and it's over $13 million, where do we go? What's the step there? There's a lot of ways to answer that question. I'd like to... Grady is here, so perhaps Grady will answer that. No, the staff committed, as per Council direction, very frankly, to come in with a project of $13 million. If it's $13 million and $100,000, then...

1:12:19 Well, sure, we might come back and say, okay, I mean, $100,000, but the commitment is, no, we won't do that. If we see those bids, we will look at the project and see if there's something that he doesn't want to do that we'll have to take out to get it to that budget. That's our commitment. We don't, we're not expecting it to do that. Are you expecting it to come in under? Correct. Significantly under?

1:12:44 We are updating our cost estimates daily. And frankly, as Stu said, the architect is meeting again with Sprung tomorrow and update them again. So we're watching it extremely closely. Every time they meet, they talk budget. And we're extremely confident that this will make it under $13 million for a total all-in budget. And where it says $100,000 for operating, is that just staffing equipment? Is that heating? Is that all?

1:13:11 I think I'm going to be able to provide a lot more update. That's only talking about, you know, what we believe or what Dan believes. Again, we're very premature. We haven't really kind of run a lot of the numbers yet. That would be the maximum general fund subsidy for the building. $100,000 a year would be? The general fund. Okay. And then also, and not picking on the police station, but I do know that after it was built...

1:13:36 And it was still very new. There's a drain that did not drain. Then there was an update needed on where they store the stuff that they've got to store that you can't evidence locker room or whatever. How many, what recourse are we going to have if it's coming in at $13 million and that's all fine and good, but then

1:14:01 There's a whoopsie and there's a drain or a machine that doesn't make ice the way it's supposed to. How do we protect ourselves against that type of financial burden that's going to come up? Because they will come up. I mean, you guys have done construction before. You know something will come up.

1:14:18 What do we have as a recourse when things that we're frankly not budgeted for and we've stretched it pretty thin already, where do we go from there? Well, let me describe our approach to that very frankly and with the police station, as you know, once we got our all-in costs, we came in almost spot-on budget. Again, I don't have those numbers in front of me, but it was that close. There were a couple of things. Frankly, on a police station, a $3 million project, if all you have is a drain and a door,

1:14:47 That's really good. So I appreciate your question because there will be something that comes up. There is no perfectly designed or construction project. Having said that, there's a variety of ways to look at it. If something we missed, okay, with all the time you guys have spent on it, I don't expect to see that, but if we saw something like, oh, shoot, we forgot that door, that's on us.

1:15:06 If, on the other hand, it was within the architect's responsibility to design something and they made an error, there is something called errors and emissions, and that's something we can consider to get them to participate in whatever fix or repair that has to be done. We've actually used that in town many times that we go out in the field and we see something and the engineer, as an example, will come out and fix it for free or they'll come out and redesign for free.

1:15:30 Certainly if a contractor does something that's not within the specification and that has to be fixed, that's on them. And there's this warranty period and there's also a construction defect period we have to look at. The other thing that we do during construction, and you don't see the day-to-day activity being here. In fact, I didn't either on the police station. I wasn't out there every day. I made sure I got out there every week or two. If something comes up during construction that we go, you know, this is great, it works, but we could do this a little bit better, our commitment,

1:16:00 And Stu's on board with this is we will find something else that just has to go to balance that. We will take something else out that may be not as essential. I mean, there's always something that you can say, well, you're under construction now. Let's delete that storage area because we have to put in that door. I'm just letting you know that's the approach. So we have a lot of tools. We employ them on every single project to try to make sure we do stay within budget. Thank you. Perfect.

1:16:27 I don't know if everybody on the council got this major capital project and major maintenance. So there's a number of issues on here and 14 of them, you know, state cost to be determined. You know, so, you know, when I look at this, I look at it in relationship to the airport.

1:16:49 Housing, $7 million shortfall for the first phase. We've never had, as a council, a discussion about all of our capital projects in a priority.

1:17:01 So this is not a high priority to me. I mean, if we're going to spend money, it's going to be on workforce housing would be my number one priority. And don't get me wrong, you know, I recognize Measure U is coming up with a $6 million bond, but we're still talking about $3.65 million from the general fund. Council has not discussed all the capital projects that are on the table. It's very difficult for me.

1:17:30 to support this without having that discussion. John. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. So I received these renderings a little while ago. I think it was a rec commission packet. And I was elsewhere. I was out and about. And I studied that elevation in the top left.

1:18:05 My background, what I've done over the course of my life has been involved a lot with sort of visual types of things. And I really looked at it once, looked at it twice, and then I looked at it a third time and said, that's it. They've nailed it. And so I'm enormously supportive of this project. I thank Cleveland, your budget constraints. It's a hard number. The council's advised. It's $13 million. Most of this money is coming from

1:18:35 Measure R coming from sources outside of the general fund. And so if the general fund can leverage a project like this, I think it's a good thing. And I think the most important thing is that the heart and soul of this structure is what's going to be happening within. And I think we found a way at the end of the day to provide a facility for programming for the young folk, for the old folk, for all us folk, and frankly for a region. I was at the ESAC

1:19:04 Fundraising event for the weekend, ran into some folks from Bishop, folks on the council down there. They said, man, I started asking around about hockey. I had no idea how crazy people are in Bishop for hockey and how, you know, what the vibrancy of that audience is. So I think it's, I'm very supportive of this. I think it's going to be a good thing for the community. I do have a concern that's above and beyond this project. And since November, we've gotten this sort of gradually building snowball around mobility.

1:19:33 I'll talk about the LTC committee meeting that we had earlier this week. We now have three major, they're not just capital project ideas, they're things that are getting built. We're going to build housing on the parcel. We've got seven and a half million bucks and we're going to get to the CEQA and the rest of it. We'll be building things over there. That's going to happen. Timing, whatever it's going to be, that's going to happen over there. The county has, wouldn't you know it, pulled out all the stops and they've built a new building, the Civic Center over here.

1:20:02 We're by the courthouse. That's going to be, they're moving in, I think, this spring, right? And now we're going to have this thing that's going to be up in a year or so. And the mobility challenges, these are the challenges of our successes. Again, as we said in the parcel thing, we have got to get our walk, bike, ride, our mobility, all the rest of it to make sure that these things are going to work, that people are going to be able to get around town, get to these things in a way that's consistent with the feet first,

1:20:32 Bill, to your point about how we've been budgeting and how we've been buying this kind of, you know, stability of this organization.

1:20:59 That when folks get together and this team gets together and does the work that they can do, they can surmount challenges, they can deal with bids that come in millions of dollars over, go back to the well, keep working it, keep working it, and come up with a project I think is really worthy of this place. So I'm supportive. Linda. Thank you. Yes, I too am supportive of this, notwithstanding some of Kirk's comments. But we founded MLR for a reason.

1:21:27 And we passed that tax initiative for a reason, and that was to provide funding for other things besides, you know, housing, which I agree is my top priority also. So seeing those funds being put to use to, you know, begin this project, complete this project with comparatively, you know, small amount of general funds, although there will be ongoing general funds, but I believe it is a function of town government to also provide for

1:21:57 Recreation in addition to the housing initiative we've started now. And I believe that MLR has been, you know, in place and I look forward to talking to and I see

1:22:09 Matt and the audience about MLR's ongoing contributions and fundraising opportunities now that we have a project we can actually, you know, get our teeth into and if we could entertain a moment to let Matt speak to that, that would be great. So yes, I am supportive of this. I think it'll be a great, when we walked out the other day and there was trash upstairs and we talked about how many kids after school.

1:22:34 Come and hang out here down by Starbucks across the street in Sierra Center Mall. I'm hoping that this will also begin to give them a place to gather in a safe way. And so I think that we, you know, we can have dual priorities, I think, at times. And at this point, I think it's time to move on this. So, supportive. I think we've already moved. Decision's been made. All of what you both said is true.

1:23:01 I would like to point out that the general fund contribution is $1 million. I'm not sure that's what I heard earlier, but that's where the general fund, which comes in at 8% of the total cost. So 92% of this is being borne other than the general fund, and that is great leveraging of general fund dollars. I think it's great. I'm glad you brought up the kids in here because sometimes, I mean, I've seen 10, 12 kids up here to give, to give.

1:23:31 Youth a place that they can drop in safely at, yet not feel overwhelmed by, yeah, is just huge. With that, I would ask if anyone in the audience would like to make a comment on this. Good evening, Mr. Mayor and Council, Matt McLean, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Recreation. First, I'd like to say congratulations to staff for doing what we feel is such an incredible job of

1:24:06 Being persistent and putting together a product that we feel really meets the needs and expectations of the town. We've talked about it quite a bit recently at our board meeting, which was last week, certainly through the ad hoc process. And I think especially after seeing the new renderings, we had a chance to look at the VR presentation and it was just mind-blowing. I think we have...

1:24:34 I think we'll in some ways set the standard, not just for this community, but I think for maybe other small communities that want to have similar type of resources. So, Lynda, in regards to your question, I would borrow a phrase from Elizabeth Warren and say, yes, we have a plan for that. And so what I propose is that we come back to you sometime in February, whether it's the first meeting or the second meeting, and make a full presentation of, you know, we've spent the last

1:25:04 Better part of two years, kind of getting our ducks lined up in a row, and we're actually really enthusiastic and excited now to be in a position where we can pull the trigger on those. And so we can come back and do a full presentation of our fundraising plan and talk about some of the things that hopefully we'll be rolling out in the next weeks or months. Thank you.

1:25:33 Good evening, Council. Betsy Trex. I chair the Recreation Commission, and I also sit on the ad hoc for this particular facility, which has been a very long time in coming to this point. And all I really want to add to what's already been said are two things. One, it's been a really great process. I'm really appreciative of the level to which staff have included the commission, and particularly our ad hoc.

1:25:56 With, you know, representation from MLR in the decision-making process. I mean, we've been right there at the table with the architect and, you know, I spend some time with, you know, other recreation commissioners and that doesn't always happen. So I'm just very appreciative of that. I think that, you know, we all feel really strongly that this is a great product. I'm personally really happy that the materials that we first saw.

1:26:20 And the original iterations of the project have been retained. This is going to be a really, really, you know, this is a facility the community will be really proud of. And I hope that, you know, housing is really, you know, it's a critical need in the community. But, you know, this product is going to have huge community benefit across the entire community. So I hope that, you know, we can always kind of keep that in mind as well.

1:26:41 Then the other thing I just want to add is that staff has really done a great job with some peer review of the facility. So they're not just kind of out there making this stuff up. They've talked to a lot of experts, a lot of professionals. Even last spring at the California Park and Rec Society Conference, Stu and I went to a session that talked about like

1:27:01 Getting your project from drawings to handing over the keys and the things that you need to be aware of when your staff is taking possession of a project, which was really eye-opening and I think really influenced some of the decisions along the way. So I'm just, I'm really proud of it and really excited to roll it out in its current iteration of the community. The VR was really cool and all of you who saw that know. So that's all I just wanted to add. So thank you. Thank you. Anyone else from the public? Okay.

1:27:32 We will then move on to number 16, waive the reading and introduce by title the ordinance amending municipal code title six animals. Jamie, you're up on this one. Cool. No, by animals, we're not talking council. Town staff, including PD personnel and the town attorney have reviewed title six animals of the town of Mammoth Lakes municipal code.

1:28:04 And propose the attached revisions. The revisions are based on updating the code to comply with current laws and practices, to fix typos that currently exist in the code, and to delete chapters that no longer pertain. The proposed changes are attached in a redline version of Title VI, and staff is happy to answer any questions you may have about it. Thank you. And I believe, first up, we're going to have Officer Hugelman. I talked to the chief earlier today, who is incapable of...

1:28:33 Coming down. He's been incapacitated. He is incapacitated after having neck surgery. Uh, and you are going to bring us his concerns. Yeah, absolutely. Um, reviewing his policy, um, under definitions at large, um, control and visual, uh, and voice control, that's new. And we were not advised at the police department of that.

1:29:03 Mr. Mayor, if I could just interrupt for a second. When I spoke with staff today, I was advised that this, because we have a

1:29:31 There's a lot of controversy going on in the community around Shady Rest Park, around dogs and dog waste. It's a very challenging situation we're in right now. And representation I was advised by staff was this was sort of a technical update and that this was not in any way related to what's going on out in Shady Rest and the challenges of an overlapping Forest Service and town jurisdiction dealing with animals.

1:29:54 And so I would hope that we are dealing with a technical update to the code and we're not going to start getting into issues about enforcement and law and everything else because that's that would be unfortunate because I think we would we would be inadvertently getting ourselves into a situation that we I don't think I'm not prepared to get into at this point. It is a technical update to the code.

1:30:19 I review several co-chapters every year. This is just another co-chapter that I reviewed. Sergeant Heilman and Crystal Stewart at the police station both reviewed this ordinance and agreed to it. So it's nothing about the issues that are going on. I understand. But I think when we start getting into issues around voice command and voice call, I'm hoping that I'm very supportive of moving this forward as a technical thing.

1:30:48 But if we're getting into any issues of policy and things like that, I would be hesitant. So I'd just offer that. Thank you. Let me offer up a suggestion. I don't exactly know where that change to the at-large definition came from, but it's easy enough to undo that proposed change. So the code currently says that at-large means not under the immediate control of a person by means of an enclosure, leash, rope, chain, or other means of effective physical control.

1:31:16 We are adding off the premises of its owner, but to reflect what it currently says about needing to be on a leash, it could simply be revised to say not under control of the owner by means of an enclosure, leash, rope, chain. So all we would have to do is delete the phrase by visual and voice control or, and then we have no problem.

1:31:41 Yeah, and that, to my reading, represents the status quo, and I'm okay with that. So, question. So this existed. We decided to go in and clean it up. So, Eric, you're saying that the whole commentary about at-large should be removed, and it's already in here. So my question is, who went in and made these corrections? Was it a conferencing between police chief and town? Was it somebody in town? Who?

1:32:11 Who decided to make these? I made the revisions based on reading Mono County code and another example of a code that the town attorney advised me to use. I had many questions because I don't deal with animals, so then I spoke to Sergeant Heilman and Crystal Stewart.

1:32:29 At the police station to make sure that we were actually following some of the things that they said, or do we need to delete them, or there was weird things in there about fines, and I know those were outdated, so I met with them, we made sure everything was following their processes, and then we brought it forward. So I guess my question is that, you know, that's fine. I mean, I don't see any huge red flags, and if this is a cleanup of a

1:32:59 of the code, then it's time to just do that a little bit by a little bit or it all blows up. But on a larger platform, you know, some of the questions I have about this is where it refers to the fact that, you know, sort of de facto, the Mammoth Police Department is the acting, you know, animal control. What it doesn't speak to is what, and it lines up the duties that that entails back a little bit further.

1:33:26 But my question would be, what training is provided for Mammoth Lakes police officers to be able to do even the minimal amount of duties outlined in this code? And should that be spoken to in a later sort of, you know, amendment of this code in general?

1:33:45 Correct, and I appreciate the work that's been done to look over this policy. Again, I think it needs to be reviewed administratively so that we know what kind of training's involved to take care of these issues, what is visual and voice command, and how are those people and animals certified for that. And also, it doesn't...

1:34:08 There's nothing in here under the dog at large section, which would be the authority section that we use to cite on, also describing what visual and voice command is. So that would also need you to be added if that was the direction that we were going. But to answer your original question, yes, it would require a certification and training, and there would be some animal control training involved with

1:34:37 With officers to go to that training and know how to use capture poles and so on, just like you would have with any municipality with animal control. I don't think it's safe to ask these officers to do something that they haven't been trained to do. And this is not something perhaps we can address tonight, but I think later on it's a bigger issue. Yeah, I think we would need to research the visual and voice control on what that means. There are other...

1:35:05 So I think, if I may, I think there's a bit of a confusion with two different issues here that have been brought up. I think Andy,

1:35:34 We addressed the by visual or voice control element already, and if we remove that specifically from the at-large definition, that would actually clear it up nicely, and that is no longer a part of the process. I think more the question was for this ordinance also discussed as an animal control officer, and in the absence of an animal control officer, those duties then fall on the police department, and I think the question is

1:35:59 What maybe is in the standard level of training of police that would support animal control or what additional training could be necessary if I captured that right. And what are we doing now? I mean, how are we preparing officers now to do these minimal duties? Officers receive, I believe it's a four-hour block in the basic academy on animal control issues, but it's not what you would really want in a position of animal.

1:36:27 Services for what we're trying to implement here. So I'm going to bring this back a little. For the purposes of what we're doing tonight, we are just looking at the cleanup of this and not the training of our personnel or who is going to do that. So I would like to rein us in a little. I talked to Jamie earlier and she has no heartache over just removing that. And I talked to the chief. And at this point in our society, the way we're headed and as litigous as we've become.

1:36:58 While I believe in visual and voice control of dogs and believe it's possible, and I've done that with my own pets in the past, I don't believe that it's possible in all cases, and you can never guarantee a dog is not going to jump. So as long as we are using prudent enforcement tactics and not becoming dog Nazis, which I've been assured we will not, I have no problem.

1:37:24 Just removing the by visual and voice control. Those one, two, three, four, five words. Thank you. And I think that that solves all the issues for tonight unless somebody has heartache over not being allowed to try and keep their dog from chasing a rabbit by saying no. I would entertain such a motion. I just have comments.

1:37:53 We have some language in there and maybe Andy can respond to it. When you say vicious dog threatened, I mean one person is threatened and another person is no big deal. So on vicious dogs, it has threatened. I don't know if that creates a problem for our enforcement of it because

1:38:17 It's ambiguous. What does threatened mean? Well, there's a definition that is set out here. Yeah, but I mean, do we need to take threatened out of this? No, because it's an actual... Okay, and then my other concern was over on page 12, or 8 of 12, interfering with use of street prohibited.

1:38:42 And it has the word worry in there, large, which attacks, worries, or barks at pedestrians. You know, what's the definition of worry? I mean, somebody just calls the police and say, that dog worries me? I just, I want a clean ordinance. I support this very strongly, but I don't want somebody calling the police saying, that chihuahua worries me.

1:39:10 Well, typically what we get is people... So that's not what this is intended to mean. There's an older use of worrying that really is only used in the context of animals. Here's the dictionary definition of it. To seize, especially by the throat, with the teeth, and shake or mingle as one animal does to another. That's what worry means in this context. It doesn't mean... So there is a definition to it. Yeah. Okay, thank you.

1:39:50 So, Mr. Mayor, I think that the enormous bear in the room is the United States Forest Service. And so when dealing with people involved in these animal issues, they're walking their dogs on federal land, you know, there is a consistent, persistent, and ongoing confusion as to whose authority, you know, whose sets of rules and regulations are we supposed to be abiding by.

1:40:20 Who does not have authority over this? And, you know, we could do a little cleanup here, that's nice, but that is not getting to the fundamental issues that we have in this town, which is these overlapping jurisdictions of the federal government and the town. As I already said, what we're here for tonight is to clean up our ordinance, not to determine exactly where our ordinance is going to be enforced and where we are unable to enforce it because it's federal jurisdiction. Okay, but I think I can ask this question to the town attorney.

1:40:48 Where, what, what geography will this be in effect? I mean, in general, ordinances apply within the town limits of the town of Mammoth Lakes. Okay, okay, but let's go municipal boundary, planning area, what? The town limits of the town of Mammoth Lakes. So that, and 75% of that landscape is federal land. Right, so that's generally the answer. If there's something in the Forest Service regulations that preempts our ability to enforce,

1:41:18 Ranger Hogan may be able to help us with that. That's when we might not be able to enforce it. But the general rule is that we can enforce even a Forest Service land. If I could, could I just finish this line of questioning real quick? We can no longer be dealing in a world of maybes and kind of in some things. There's a significant amount of heartache coming out of this situation in Shady Rest.

1:41:44 And it's bubbling up to the acting staff of the Forest Service, the current staff of the Forest Service, the leadership of the Forest Service, the Recreation Department, our police department, the community. This thing is going to blow up. It's already blowing up. And I think, again, we can adopt a bunch of cleanup. That's fine. But we cannot dodge this issue a whole lot longer. I can't give you a definitive answer to your question as I sit here.

1:42:09 Okay, well that's, we need, because the public is going, well, who's in charge? Yeah, so let's ask for that to be agendized. Yes, I would. And bring that back. Yep. But let's not deal with it tonight, Sandy. Perhaps as a former federal law enforcement officer for the Forest Service, the Forest Service, unless it's changed since I've retired, does not enforce, in other words, county ordinances, town ordinances, unless we...

1:42:34 We specifically adopt that into the Code of Federal Regulations. And to my knowledge, a dog on leash, no. This county has a leash law for dogs, and so the Forest Service would not enforce that unless it specifically spells it out. And I don't even know that the forest supervisor can do it. It's been too long for me. I think generally that comes under a regional

1:43:04 CFR. So I don't think that's an issue. So the Forest Service should not be called into it, their law enforcement officers, unless there's a specific law that they can enforce, a county law, a state law, in other words that goes with state fire laws, things like that. We have the Forest Service operates under the Code of Federal Regulations, specifically.

1:43:33 And they are laid out in a little booklet just like Officer Eagleman's got, you know, and that's it. And if it's not there, it's not there. And I don't think dogs on leash. For instance, in Lake Tahoe, yes, there are specific ones for some of the beaches spelled out in the Code of Federal Regulations. Otherwise, no, if that helps. I think, Andy, what we're going to be looking for in the future is

1:44:01 I believe that what John is referring to is dog owners who are saying I don't have to live up to the town code because I'm on Forest Service land. However, it is my belief in working with Sandy and others before her and after her that if it's a property that is administered by the town under a special use permit, then town ordinance could be enforced by the town. And I think those are the clarifications that we're looking for.

1:44:25 And I would offer that there's been an email chain going back and forth the last two weeks between press releases going out from the Indian National Forest being contradicted by what the town police department is doing, what the citizens are doing. Now we're using public money to have people out in Shady Rest Park to try to enforce a completely contradictory set of laws and regulations. We have citizens of the committee threatening legal action against the town to get these issues resolved.

1:44:55 This is not something that we can turn away from. Right, so we will bring this back. And we have a commitment from you to do this, is that correct? Yes, absolutely. Okay. Yes. And I would encourage you for that to be talking with Joel Ratchie, the trails coordinator. Yes. With MLR, with Matthew Perillo, the sustainable recreation coordinator, and the staff of the Indian National Forest. Yes. Okay. Yeah.

1:45:13 I just want to reiterate the point that was made earlier that this is just a standard update, the timing of which is perhaps unfortunate with the connection of all the other things that have gone on over the last couple of weeks, but it is in no relation to those that are up there. It's simply what came up on the schedule to get accomplished. So just want to reiterate that if folks are making the connection between the two. I know you're not in this particular case, but I think folks may easily do that, and I just want to make that point clear, but we definitely can bring it back for some clarity on that.

1:45:44 I do have one other thing totally unrelated to anything that's been brought up so far. In this, when it says that a dog needs spay or neutered by four months, in an effort maybe to get more people to license their dogs, is there any solid reason why we're keeping it at the four months instead of maybe six months? Just because if you get a dog and they're 12 weeks old,

1:46:13 Andy, is there any like

1:46:44 Bigger law that dictates that it's got to be that four months. Can we stretch it to six months when you're licensing your dog if they're not fixed because it's... I don't know. I don't know as I sit here, but I can find the answer. Okay, because that just seems... And in the past when I have registered my dog, gotten my dog's license, the timing gets to be a little silly because every time I get a puppy, the first month that I have the dog, you know, I'm, you know,

1:47:14 Raising a new puppy. And can I vote on this if I got a dog from Eric 14 years ago? No, it was just something I just noticed in there that gives some people some wiggle room, some time to get their dog fixed. Is that a change from the old? You know what? It's not a change, but there is in the red line. There is a six down there, which made me think, oh, that could help people just with the licensing.

1:47:43 Oh, so that's why it is. It's Mono County. Okay. All right. So that's still going to stay four months. You can ask us to change it, I suppose. I would like to know which, what do you, what do you want? If you, on the red line, copy, it's on page 201 under the license required and the fee.

1:48:22 I don't know the rate right now. Maybe it's $15 for a dog license, but if your dog is not fixed, it's like $60. And, you know, that money could go towards dog training lessons. Just speaking from personal experience, you've got about a month time to get your dog fixed, or, you know, you get dinged a little bit more money. Sorry. That's fine. If you would like to.

1:48:54 Ask to have that change to six. Unless someone has a really good argument, why not? Well, my impression is that there's a lot of places in here that we may want to talk about, that being one of them, certainly. I had a couple others myself, so, you know, if we were to bring this back.

1:49:14 After we sort of do minimal, you know, changes to it and address all those things that any one of us may have when we have more time to kind of consider and maybe there's some scientific reason that Mono County made it four months, I mean, who knows, but, you know, rather than go in and kind of chop at this now, can we do it in one visit later and do it all kind of together with that?

1:49:50 So I'm willing to support this in the spirit of staff saying this is a series of technical updates with the commitment from you, Mr. Mayor, that we need to have a larger and much more substantive conversation around.

1:50:03 These things. Around the enforcement. Around the enforcement and around the issues that are, I don't know exactly what all the issues are, but they're burning, they're hot, we're getting threats of litigation and all kinds of other stuff. So, fine, let's get this on the books. It'll make people happy in the short term, but we need to really get into very serious discussions. What I'm hearing now is that other council members would like to offer up other changes. Or clarifications, sir. Or clarifications.

1:50:33 And if you have a bunch more you want to go over, then we need to go over those so that they can be brought back with those changes. If I'm hearing from the police department that they would like more time to go over the thing in whole, I have no problem with that. I don't think it costs us anything, does it, Jamie, other than your time, which is precious to me, of course. So if I can get consensus from the rest of you.

1:51:02 I would move this just down the road at the request of the police department to give them more time to administratively go over it. And I, well, beyond that, if we can also get some clarity on the decisions that want to be changed so that we can at least address those. We understand removing that visual and verbal control and perhaps the six months that there's a consensus on that, if I can get a consensus from.

1:51:27 Council that that's the time change that we want to make for that. I have no problem with any of those. And maybe speak to training within the body of this for the police department. We can do that. If they'd like to maybe weigh in on that. We can. And would it be appropriate to bring all these other issues into this as well? I think it'd be beneficial if we could bring this in separate and then maybe have that as a second agenda item. I'm just saying, the timing of it, if you're talking six months, this is not going to wait.

1:51:56 Those are the things they're not going to wait for six months. No, that's fine. I would expect to see this back at probably the first meeting in March or the last meeting of February. It certainly can be done within that time frame. I'm imagining these minor edits could be done by the next meeting, if necessary, is allowing the administrative staff of the police department to do a thorough review on it. I want to wait until the chief's off drugs. I'd recommend that we bring it back on the 19th of February.

1:52:26 And I have no problem with that. I would concur. So with your permission, that's what we will do. We will table 16 and move on to item 17, discussed a tax measure. And that's going to be Andy again. We will take a five-minute break. Okay, we will...

2:03:52 Reconvene our meeting and discuss the tax ballot measures. Indy? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. At the last meeting, you'll recall the council talked about the idea of putting a measure on the ballot for November. There was some discussion about whether that should be a general tax or special tax. I think there was a consensus about it being housing-related. And I was asked to put together a timeline.

2:04:17 of steps that have to be taken, which I've now done. This timeline is keyed to the November 3rd election date. There's a number of things that have to happen and this table I put together shows the deadline for accomplishing each of those things. They're mostly pretty far out, but you'll find that those dates will come up on us pretty quickly.

2:04:41 The really key deadline is we have to deliver a notice to the county clerk, a notice of election by July 1st, which is going to be right up on us quickly. So in advance of that, we've identified some things as to which we'd like some further direction so we know what we're meant to be doing between now and July 1st. There are a lot of different approaches that cities can take in getting...

2:05:07 Ballot measures together. There's not a single right or wrong way. It's really up to you to decide what makes sense for this community and in this context. So it's fairly common, but not universal, that you have some kind of stakeholder outreach and engagement. At my day job in Truckee, we're putting something on the ballot for November. It's going to be a TOT measure. It's probably going to be a special tax, and it's going to fund housing. So if that sounds familiar. Wait, can you say that again? I'm just... Yeah.

2:05:37 Okay. Okay, fine. He just said what we just said. Yeah. Okay, good. Yeah, check that out. Cool. So the town of Truckee decided that they wanted to do stakeholder outreach and engagement. There have now been three meetings of a committee that was formed, and I think that what they tried to do, and this is kind of orthodox approach here, is you want to try to get some people involved to really care, you know, stakeholders. So in Truckee, it was members of the lodging community. It was also some people.

2:06:07 That might be potential advocates for the measure once it gets placed on the ballot because, of course, the town cannot be. So if you do it right, you have a way of identifying people that might be willing to carry the torch and also bringing people in who might have concerns about a ballot measure and letting them speak their piece and having their opinions be heard. And sometimes that can kind of blunt some potential opposition or head off the potential opposition. In Truckee's case, this committee...

2:06:35 It has something like 15 or 21 people on it, which is a little bit unwieldy, but they've met a bunch, and they've kind of hammered out a consensus as to doing special versus general and how long to have it go. I think it's going to be 20 years. So one question for you to think about, and you don't have to decide tonight, but the sooner the better, is do you want to do any kind of stakeholder engagement? Do you want to have some kind of organized group? Do you just want to kind of informally talk to some people in the community that might have an opinion?

2:07:04 Either with or without that, we're going to have to finalize the proposed tax rate and the tax type. I think that what I heard last time is probably it's a 1% special tax, but that hasn't been totally pinned down yet. If you do have it as a special tax, then we have to write something that explains precisely what the tax revenue can be used for, which is very important because, of course, the special tax, you're limited to exactly what the voters approve, no more nor less. So we'll have to give some thought to

2:07:32 How you want to word a housing-related tax measure. And then finally, well, no, I guess that's it. I kind of squished the second and third bullet points together. So do you want to do some outreach? What kind of tax do you want it to be? If it's special, help us figure out how to write it. These are the kinds of things that need to start percolating around in your brains because July 1st will come quickly. And we need to have all this squared away in advance of that. That's really all I have. So talk amongst yourselves.

2:08:02 About what? Okay. Kurt, do you want to start us off here? Yeah, sure. Talked to a couple of lodge owners, and, you know, they have a certain level of concern, but they also have a certain level of needs, you know, maids and, you know, those maintenance people and everything else. So the two people that I did talk to that own large...

2:08:34 Complexes, you know, they are, they're, they want to know how this is going to work. There's also a certain amount of trepidation in the sense that, you know, some of the previous money that went to housing, don't get me wrong, I, you know, recognize that airport litigation, everything else, and now the money that's being funneled into the parcel and everything else more than makes up for that one.

2:09:00 One point of the 13 points. So I think this is doable. It depends if we have an opposition, you know, and there are people that just oppose any taxes. And there's also the question which has come up, you know, a live tax. And that's been brought up and discussed with me. The fact that

2:09:26 The Mountain is busing people down to Bishop for housing and everything else. So when we talk about dedicated to housing, you know, it's more complex than just, okay, we want to do a one point increase in our TOT. So I think there's some, you know, I think there's, you know.

2:09:51 Well, okay, let's talk about this for a second.

2:10:18 Any body or group that the council forms, takes action to form, becomes a Brown Act body with all the limitations that go with that. If something happens kind of more organically out in the community, then it's not a Brown Act body as long as no more than two council members sit on it. So that's the crucial question. Who's going to form it and thus is it going to be a Brown Act body or not? So historically they've always been organic in the sense that council, you know,

2:10:47 Kind of, you know, this is important. I want it. And so they kind of almost self-appoint them and then work with the community. I'm going to pull this back in a little before I turn it over to everybody else. What I want us to decide here, I believe as a council, tell me if you disagree that what Andy said is correct. We have agreed that we want to put forward a tax and a special tax and a 1% TOT.

2:11:13 So I would like to hold us to that in conversation. What I think we need to hear from you specifically, Council, is whether we want to do a stakeholder outreach. I think to tell Andy that we all agree on the and maybe put it in a motion of the rate and type and the purpose has already been. So that's I would like to keep us in the.

2:11:41 Let's start on the stakeholder outreach and go from there so that we can keep our comments concise. Okay, well, I have a couple of thoughts on that. When you say stakeholder outreach, you know, forming these ad hoc committees and subcommittees are always a little cumbersome and then they end up Brown Act and you've got a lot of stuff to do. So what if we were to ask staff to maybe reach out to, for example, the Lodging Association and

2:12:11 Chamber of Commerce, some of those larger groups which represent some of the bigger stakeholders in this process and kind of then maybe get some feedback on that while we have, you know, we've already kind of decided that we're going to do a 1% bump, whether it's a general or special.

2:12:34 We've sort of talked about a special. I would just be interested personally in seeing that that were broad enough to consider a lot of eventualities in housing that we may not even be thinking of at this point that may arise in later years. I know that, you know, the general tax for the, some of the items we've had have been held to the political commitment for the most part. So, you know, is there a pro or con against that? I think I would need that.

2:13:05 You know, that's what we need. But as far as the stakeholder outreach, to keep it a little simple at first, and I'd like maybe some feedback from Acting Town Manager to see how that might play with staff, and what do you think? Yeah, we can certainly, I was just thinking through that process as you were speaking, we have good

2:13:31 Contact with certainly both the lodging and the chamber, which to me would be a logical approach getting potentially some folks that may have consternation about a new tax in that area that would affect their businesses. We'd probably think too a little broadly about some of the people who would be in favor of that and try to reach out to them as well. But I don't think that's something that can't be done by my staff and certainly my staff from the tax collection department. Those folks would be happy to.

2:14:00 Have those conversations, attend those meetings and present that as trying to get that feedback. My question would be the form in which it comes back to you, staff reports and so forth. That would be looking for a bit of direction on what you expect on that. But as far as conducting the outreach and bringing the information back, absolutely, we can do that. Yeah, I will point out that

2:14:26 Ballotpedia, which is a wonderful website. You can access through that website the text of every ballot measure in the last some number of years in California. So we can certainly look at all the housing-specific special taxes that have been proposed in the last several years and try to get a sense of exactly how they worded what the tax revenue can be used for. So we should have a number of examples that we can draw from.

2:14:52 Crafting our language. That's a really good idea because then you could kind of see. But remembering that the special tax is a higher threshold too as opposed to a general tax. So there's that to consider also. So those are my thoughts. John? So, Mr. Mayor, I'm starting from the supposition that we have voted to move ahead with a 1% special tax TOT. We're going to do that. Okay.

2:15:19 That's the ballpark they're in right now, so I'm starting from that assumption. That being said, in terms of outreach, I think the groups that if staff wants to reach out to, the chamber, the members of the Housing Summit group, MLH, potentially some folks in the county who would be interested in this, and very importantly is to find a way to have someone who can speak on behalf of a public housing developer. I know we've had an RFQ out.

2:15:48 We won't be able to get those folks involved, but the group that helped us through that, our sort of conceptual master plan, I think we still have access to some of those folks, I think to get some technical advice from them. The technical advice that we need specifically is to be on the expenditure plan, which is we, I'm calling it that for lack, there may be a more apt phrase, but it's the language that says this is what this is going to do, and that's going to be technical.

2:16:16 And that's critically important. But I think, again, developers, people who are going to be town staff, who we need the language to say this to make sure it's going to achieve the housing objectives we want to see. So I would be very interested in seeing that back. I think one of the great virtues of doing a special tax is, A, if we went through that whole thing with the airport litigation, Measure R, Measure U, they were not in play. Special tax monies.

2:16:43 We get sued by someone, they can't get their hands on that. That's exempt from that stuff, which is a good thing for a lot of reasons. And also, in the special tax language, we as individual council members or the advocates, they can say specifically what it's going to be for. If it's just a general tax, all you can say is, well, it's going in the general fund and...

2:17:04 You've got to kind of tap dance around it. You cannot say what you're going to do with it other than it's going to show the general fund. Yeah, the way that those are typically worded is you would say something like, shall a tax be adopted to provide funds for essential municipal services such as, and then you list all the things you think the voters like the most, like such as police, parks and recreation, housing. I mean, you can't specifically legally earmark it, but you can still list whatever you think people are going to like. Sure.

2:17:32 But just in my experience running these kinds of things in this community, it's a huge bonus to be able to say it's going to be for this. It's not going to go in the general fund. It can't be spent on anything else but that. So those are my recommendations for outreach. And I'm very interested in seeing the specific language of what it's going to be spent on. And I would also encourage us to do this sooner rather than later. I don't want to rush it.

2:17:58 But I think the sooner that the council can say, look, here's our language, we like it, we've got some people involved who want to do it, and to say, look, we think this is a good question, so that everybody knows it's coming, it's going to be on the ballot, people can, in the community, on the organic side, can start to organize, get their act together, and start getting a campaign to make this thing happen. Those are my thoughts. Thank you. Thank you. Andy, I just have one question. I know.

2:18:25 Last year, two years ago, there was something coming up that was going to change anything that was voted on that was not a two-thirds vote. Do you remember that? Is that still anything in the atmosphere in California? I'm not aware of anything in the law currently that has changed that. No, it was up for it. They were talking about it a year or two ago, but I...

2:18:49 It might have been some. I had to drop the ball on where that conversation went. I remember it. They wanted to pass a rule so that any tax measure had to be a supermajority. Right. That didn't go anywhere. Okay. So we don't have to worry about that. Okay. Thank you. And I just remember as I was sitting here, I've already written the housing language for the Truckee tax measure, so I have a draft of it that I can share. And take that and please run it through our staff and run it through, I think we, what was the name of the group that did that, this really?

2:19:18 Wonderful exercise we just completed that Jen Daugherty was involved. What was the name of that? Novin. Novin. Those folks, we still have access to them. I think they would be a great resource to look at whatever Andy's language is and stress test it and just see if it's going to work for us. Well, my take on it is we need two different sets of outreaches. One, we need an outreach of our local business community to find out whether a 1% raise in TOT is palatable.

2:19:47 And I would not want to vote on taking that forward completely until we heard from them. So I would like to hear from Lodging, the Chamber, Mammoth Lakes Tourism specifically. And I would like to have their boards take a vote on up or down on this so that I know where our business community stands in terms of support with this. And that is outreach number one. And I believe that needs to happen before.

2:20:14 It comes back to us to decide whether we're specifically moving it forward. Then once we decide to specifically move it forward, the outreach, John, that you're talking about with housing groups and what may expenses be and all of that, we don't waste staff time on that until we know for sure we're moving the whole thing forward. I don't want them going out to the builders and saying, you know, what do we need to put in our expenditure plan because that is the important plan that we didn't get quite right.

2:20:45 I don't know that we need to know that up front prior to voting on whether to move this forward or not. I just need to know from the local...

2:21:13 Business community if they will support it if we move it forward. So what kind of a question would you put to them? Flat out. The council is considering coming forward with a 1% increase in TOT as a special tax designated for housing needs. Right. Just that. Just that. That high level kind of an idea. That high level. And then have them vote on that at their boards and bring that back to us.

2:21:40 Which then gives us the power of the people to move this forward and then do all the things you're talking about. Being a little bit not so risk-averse, it would be nice to have that, but I personally think this is so important for so many different reasons. I would hope that the council, if they can't get it agendized or they don't vote, we're not going to wait for that. No, if they can't get it done in a timely fashion, I agree. We pull on our big boy pants and make decisions. I can't say that.

2:22:10 I know. In public, no less. And our ethics trainer is sitting here with me. So that's the way I would like to see this. And if I could get a consensus on that, we could give staff direction and move this along. Kirk? Yeah.

2:22:34 These are current future obligations. The airport, the IT, five to seven million, the parcel, the solid waste. Do we want to have a broader...

2:22:45 Do you want to have a broader discussion? We have 13 points. Seven points historically went to municipal service. One and a half point to capital project. Two and a half point to tourism. One point to transit and one point to housing. So we want to add two points to housing by increasing the TOT, which is about a million three annually. Right. I'm just saying that on our plate we have more.

2:23:13 Issues than this. And so when I look at this, do we want to adjust any of the other, if we're going to go out, do we want to make any kind of adjustment on, you know, what has been political commitments historically? I think that those, the political commitments, we have the ability to change, should we want to.

2:23:36 Makes it harder to get the community to support us. But that reinforces the argument. If it's the kind of proposition that we're making, we or future councils will not have the ability to make those changes. And I think it's an important question to put to the public. If the public says, no, we're not willing to tax basically the visitor, which is a TOT tax, we're imposing a fee.

2:24:02 On the people who are coming here who have expectations that they'll go to a restaurant and they'll have a waiter. They'll go to a ski shop and there'll be someone working in the ski shop to help them fit their boots. It's like it's kind of the cost of doing business. If this were to fail and the community doesn't want to do something like that, well then we can come back to these, make adjustments to these things to measure A if we need to do that. We could come back and do that at that point. Hopefully this will happen. It will go forward. It'll get passed.

2:24:29 And we'll know where the voters are and where we're at with this thing. Well, as I said, I think that the council has other things there we might want to look at other than just housing. I mean, don't get me wrong, I'm a huge advocate of housing, you know that. But in the same respect, we have, you know, certain things that we need to do.

2:24:56 For example, let's look at roads. We are budgeting $580,000 and we should probably be budgeting a million. You know, I'm good with where we're at right now in terms of this question around this item tonight. Well, we're discussing this, how to bring it forward.

2:25:12 How to bring what forward? So, Kirk, what are you asking? Yeah, wait a minute. I support the 1%. I got it. Okay, good. Yeah, and so, but I'm looking at how it, how we're going to bring it forward, you know, as far as getting a two-thirds vote. That's not easy. So, are what you, I'm confused. No opposition. By what you're telling me, are you asking us to increase that?

2:25:35 And bring it back that way to cover other goods? Are you asking us, I'm confused by what you're asking us, or the direction you're giving to staff, or that you would like us to give to staff? Because the question right now is, do we want to send this forward with the outreach that we have asked for, as I laid out or as John laid out, either way, to move forward? So, are you asking us to bring it back in some other context?

2:26:04 Well, I'm asking, I'm saying yes to the 1%. I am saying how do we bring this forward? It's the campaign that I'm looking at. Well, that's, that's, we got to do what Bill's talking about. We got to do that first. Well, I've already said yes. Good. Okay, good. So we're good. Yeah. Clueland? All right. Consensus? Yeah. Nod. Yes. Okay. Consensus on bringing it in the two-fold way that I suggested, or...

2:26:36 In bringing in all the extras that John was talking about, there are sort of two proposals here. Yeah, one is like the expenditure plan piece and the technical piece and then this outreach piece, I guess of a combo of what you and I are talking about. So I understood that you guys too.

2:26:52 Because there was actually three different proposals there, but Bill, I believe yours captured both of those, which would be the outreach for the communities that would be affected by that, or the businesses, and then John, yours was more around exactly what the scoping of the language was in that. Yeah, and I'm calling out the expenditure plan to make sure that...

2:27:12 If Andy's got a draft, great. Yeah. And just, you know, stress and means test that through our local lens. Absolutely. And that's understood. I think Andy's got something else with. Yeah. A couple things about that. The ballot language is limited to 75 words. It's a legal language. The voters, when they vote, they're voting on that language. But because it's only 75 words, it's not detailed in any way. So it's not an expenditure plan in the usual sense that you might think of. I mean, we're going to live or die with 75 words. And I'll send the draft I have.

2:27:42 The other thing is I just wanted to be absolutely clear on this. Nobody stuck to the table. Nobody has discussed a sunset date. So I'm assuming that what you mean is an increase in perpetuity rather than one that's going to sunset after a certain period of time. But I want to make sure. For me, perpetuity. It has to be. This is what's going to cover the ongoing O&M on whatever massive project we end up finishing. Fair enough. I just wanted to make sure that we had clear understanding. So staff?

2:28:12 Do you have what you need now from us in consensus to bring us back what we need? Yes, I believe I do. If I could reiterate, we are going to public outreach sort of arms. One would be to talk about what is being proposed as a 1% special tax on TOT that will not have a sunset date and whether we get a thumb up or a thumb down from the lodging community, the chamber, MLT.

2:28:40 And have those boards make a decision on those for us, which having the boards make a decision could take a little bit more time, perhaps. But I think that's the proper way to do that. And the second one would be around the scoping of the language and making sure that it covers a broad enough sense that the special tax will be able to be used on all things associated with housing that we believe within 75 words. And there's a list of folks that are in the housing area, including the recent developers we used for the parcel.

2:29:09 We would want to reach out to. Two minor additions. Linda mentioned MLH with one of those groups to see if they're willing to vote on it. The only other thing I would add is that we do this, again, I don't want to rush it, but do it deliberately. I think it's going to be important for everybody to have our direction, our decision clear, and do it with as much advance notice as is reasonable so that the organic thing out there gives them time to get organized and start doing what they've got to do to run a successful campaign.

2:29:40 So do we want an actual motion on this? No, I think consensus is all I needed. Thank you. I think we have now covered it to death. Okay. Good. Moving on then. We are now going to segue and let's have council member reports real quick.

2:30:06 I attended the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority meeting in Bishop with Bill. Nothing to report out from that meeting. Kirk? I'm trying to find my notes. Sorry. Okay, well, Kirk is looking. Let's go to John. Thank you, sir. December 19th, the Chamber Workforce Housing Meeting. And if you hear anybody in town who's really stressed about housing, problems trying to find housing for their staff, send them over to the Chamber and their Workforce Housing Group.

2:30:40 Because they're doing, they're matching, they're trying to make things happen, that's a good place to send them. January 8th is the 2020 Tahoe Tour with a gentleman named Lenny Mendoza, who is the head of GOBIZ, which is the California Governor Newsom's Office of Economic Development. Very interesting conversations, it's important. Because this Regions Rise Together effort, which I've mentioned a couple times, they've been focused on the Inland Empire and the Central Valley.

2:31:09 In the most recent budget that the governor announced last Friday, he wants to fund four positions. So inland empire, central valley, central coast, north coast. When is the eastern, when is our time coming? We got to get ready for that. So it's coming. I'm more than happy to share any information on that if you'd like. January 9th, the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District.

2:31:33 Pretty unanimous support around controlled burning and struggling with the issues of mechanical burns and things like that. I would add that, and I'll direct this a little bit to Rob, there's a group called the Plumas Corporation that is a non-profit that is looking to do with state money the fuels thinning work that we refer to as the donut. I think you guys know what that is. It's a massive...

2:31:57 Fuels treatment thing all the way around the town of Mammoth Lakes. And I think the question of how that may or may not affect our recreation economy should be of significant concern to the council. I was at a meeting with the Forest Service staffs, so that's brewing out there. I would encourage all of us to keep an eye on that. And then I attended the LTC meeting on the Monday of this week. I want to congratulate Mayor Pro Tem Linda Salcido, now the chair of the Marnell County Local Transportation Commission. Congratulations.

2:32:26 And a couple nice updates. Electric buses are coming to Yartz, which is a great development to see Yartz move forward with that. There is a state mandate that I don't know exactly what the dates are. All new buses purchased will have to be electric. And it's coming soon. So soon that people are starting to get actually pretty nervous about it. There's representation that there will be cameras from Caltrans on our passes, like they have in like Tahoe places, like they're working getting that stuff figured out.

2:32:55 And that there's going to be some construction up in Tuolumne Meadows next summer is what we heard. Yeah, so it'll be two years worth of construction starting in Tuolumne next summer, which is something that kind of, there's a big plan that's been in the works for many, many years. It looks like they're actually going to start doing that. So that's something to pay attention to. But I really want to bring to all of our attention.

2:33:15 Some challenges that we're having with what's called the Regional Transportation Plan. Mono County made an effort to get it updated. They needed it updated for their general plan, having to do with their housing element. And frankly, the effort was really not satisfactory in the sense that the towns, the articulation of what the town is doing and the town's interest is not in that document. I'm not sure exactly what happened, but...

2:33:40 The things we have to represent in that regional transportation plan that's going to expose us well to funding from the state for the parcel is not in that document. The articulation of where we are at with air service in the airport is not properly represented in that document. Walk, bike, ride is not properly represented in that document. And I think it's something that the county staff is aware of.

2:34:02 But it got to the point where we could not, we tabled the minutes for the last meeting because the representation of what was going on was this was sufficiently complex that we've got a little bit of a challenge here that we have to address. Myself and Supervisor Kreitz are very much on the same page with us. It may be not a point of discussion when we have the joint meeting with Monroe County Supervisors. We don't have to go on at length, but we need to focus on that. We need to direct our staff to make sure they're involved in that.

2:34:31 It needs to be updated to properly and accurately represent what the town is doing with transportation mobility. And right now it's not there. So I just want to make sure I bring that to your attention. And as I mentioned earlier, parcel, Civic Center, Community Recreation Center, folks, we got to get big time in the mobility business. I mean, we need to make sure that all these places are working. The Civic Center, for example, there's no sidewalk to go from the road into the building.

2:35:00 And this is, look, they had to get it done quick, you know, good on them, they got it done, but there's, we got to get all this stuff to work. It's a huge opportunity for us as a community. I think when we start dealing with Altera Mountain Corporation, Mammoth Resorts, and whatever they're going to be bringing forward development-wise, if we continue to have our act together around mobility and how we're going to make all this stuff work, which we can do, we're in a good position to partner with them to make this a very successful set of solutions going forward.

2:35:28 I just wanted to bring that to all of your attention. Thank you. Thank you, sir. That's it. Thank you. Found your notes? Yes. So, you know, capital major projects. I think, again, I think that the council needs to have a workshop on this to prioritize what our council thinks. So, asking staff to agendize a discussion about what are all the capital projects that we have, you know, out in front of us or challenges.

2:35:58 So that's all. And yes, I've talked to staff. Yes, I've talked to multiple people in the community about some of these projects. That's all I have to report. Okay, Cleland, you already did yours. Cleland did mine. I went to ESTA as well. That's the only meeting I've been in. Yes, talked to a lot of people. I can tell you what I didn't do. I didn't go to LTC. I had a more fun thing to do in Carson City on a tooth, which, as we know,

2:36:28 Take care of first. And then I did go to the ethics training today, which was well done. Thank you, Andy. Yeah, I think we all did. We got a big A plus for that. But you didn't talk to each other about it, which was great. No, not until we got here, and now we can all talk about it. It was exciting. The jokes. Can we talk about the jokes for a second? Good job, Andy. And I think it is useful, and I was happy to see that so many representatives from the...

2:36:54 MLT, MLH, and all the commissions. There was a lot of people there. I'd just like to appreciate Jamie because Jamie is really the one that organizes it. Jamie is the one who remembers to invite everybody. And I think it's a wonderful public service for the town to provide where we're really encouraging nonprofits and other governmental entities. We're really trying to serve as a leader and trying to encourage everybody to get compliant. So thank you to Jamie for putting it all together.

2:37:19 That's what I thought, Annie, for your tone and your presentation, which was entertaining and interesting and good. I felt a real kind of esprit de corps with everybody in the room today. I just felt like all the people who were showing up to provide public service for the community was a good vibe. It was a good feeling. Yeah. Sometimes I would like to add up all those people. Like how many people serve sort of without any reimbursement at all on our commissions?

2:37:44 Are not NGOs. I mean, that's a big number. And I think the community needs to take note of that. How many people are out there that participate in the process of local government? It's impressive. It's very impressive. So that's all I got. Okay. That being said, we are now going to segue. Instead of going into closed session, we are going to change over to a meeting of the Board of Trustees of the Mammoth...

2:38:12 Lakes Municipal Service Corporation. And technically at this point, I should probably turn it over to Cleland, who currently is president. I am president. And since we do this once a year, I've forgotten protocol. Do I need to ask for a roll call? Roll call, please. Do we have to adjourn? No. Yes. Hello. Yes. Present.

2:38:47 Secretary Bill Sauser? Yes. Here. All accounted for. Any public comments? Seeing none. Our policy matters. We have the election of officers, president, secretary, and treasurer. And the way this normally flows is

2:39:13 Or the way it's been done in the past is the mayor normally ends up as president. I was about to say I'll entertain a motion if anybody would like to. Madam President, I would nominate the town's current mayor, Mr. Bill Sauser, to be president of the corporation. I will second that. Okay. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0 for the position of secretary.

2:39:48 I nominate Linda Salcido. Second. Second. Roll call, please. Trustee Salcido. Yes. Trustee? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. I liked it better when I was Trustee Bill. Trustee Bill. Trustee Bill. At this point, do I turn it over to the new president? Do or do I continue and ask for... Okay. Then I'll go ahead and...

2:40:26 For the Office of Treasure, I would nominate Kirk Stapp. Second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Item passes 5-0, and I will now turn it over to the new president, Bill Sauser. I would entertain a motion to accept the annual report. Second.

2:41:05 All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Passes 5-0. I like that. Does anybody want to hear the report? Or do you just want to vote on it? Wait a minute. Oh, wait a minute. You've read it deeply. No. So we will now move on to consent agenda, which is to approve the minutes of the meeting of January 23, 2019. I'm sorry. I did see a typo. It says Finance Director Rob Clark.

2:41:36 Under item two. Oh, good catch. Good catch. Oh, on the minutes from last year under item two. Okay. You want me to make a motion that we accept the minutes? Make it. I'm making a motion that we accept the minutes as correct and second. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? 5-0. I will now adjourn this meeting.

2:42:18 of the, what do we call ourselves again, the Municipal Services Corp. Thank you. Now we will go on to the closed session and we will take a short break so that we can just hold the closed session right here. Clear the room.