Town Council
· recording 1 hr 59 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
266 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
6:22 What are the driving forces that are impacting Mammoth Lakes? We try and identify uncertainties, develop a range of plausible scenarios, and these are stories. They're not what I say you have to do. These are stories for you to react to.
6:37 And to provide input. And you're free to take a little of this and a little of that if you like and make your own scenario. These are designed, these stories and scenarios are designed to generate input, ideas and thoughts. And then we take a look at the implications.
6:54 Of each, and then how do you develop a strategy to implement a particular scenario? The methodology is really straightforward. We've met with key stakeholders. I appreciate the opportunity to talk to each one of you in depth, the staff and whatnot, and so very, very insightful.
7:15 We analyze that information. What are you guys all saying? What are the key trends? What are the themes? How do we pull that together? And now we're at a point where we present this information back to you and get your thoughts and then perhaps move forward with some sort of finalized strategy, scenario, and document. The benefits are several.
7:37 To help manage the impact of significant change. There is significant changes happen to Mammoth Lakes. More will happen over time. You want to develop a common framework.
7:49 With how to envision this future. And that's important in a community level because you have so many different perspectives. And what you want to do is at least begin to have a common story, a common framework to say, hey, this is the direction we want to move forward in, or at least we want to begin to look at in a closer way. And then we want to help manage the uncertainty of things that might impact the community and the destination.
8:14 How do we get to this situation? And again, this situation is statewide, and I'll refer to the state, but know that it is an impact everywhere. First, the significant California population growth. We're now at 40 million people up from 20 million decades ago when Mammoth probably got its start. It's anticipated that there'll be 46 million.
8:39 In the next 15 or 20 years or so, so the population growth is not going away anytime soon. We've had very strong economic growth, both at the national level and the state level, and you know you've heard the economic indicators and the economic reports and so forth, and that has provided a very robust spending environment for people, and vacations are at the top of that discretionary spend.
9:05 TBID funding, Tourism Business Improvement District funding, which you have here. Well, you're not the only one. There's over 110 of them in California, and there's now over 300 million more dollars today promoting tourism than there was, say, 20 years ago. And this has created an incredible competition in tourism.
9:25 And then finally, the impact of technology has sort of come forefront to each one of these tourism destinations. The shared economy, Airbnb, has been transformational, both in this community and other communities, in terms of its impact on lodging and housing and so forth. The way people use information now to select a destination, to find out about a destination once they're here, the technology has literally transformed the industry.
9:54 When we look at the town of Mammoth Lakes, you guys have experienced incredible growth. You've doubled your TOT since I think 2009, 2010.
10:03 Which is outstanding for the town and the community, stakeholders and so forth. From a revenue standpoint, very, very positive. You track well with spending across California's tourism industry. You're right in line with the overall tourism growth of the state. And so I think that's, again, very positive to where you are. But there's additional factors impacting the town.
10:28 That, you know, you need to be considerate of. First is the Mammoth ski area and how that dynamic with Altera begins to impact.
10:36 The community, and that again impacts a lot of, that's happening in a lot of different communities. The vacation rental issue is obviously key. Labor supply is absolutely essential, and it is a challenge because it's interrelated with housing, and housing security is really the issue. It's people, even if they have a house, they're insecure about that housing, or if they have a rental property, they're insecure, and that makes it really tough to have a high morale.
11:06 A workforce with a esprit de corps in a community. The airport shift to Bishop obviously could change the dynamics significantly in terms of a regional play.
11:17 The housing in Mammoth Lakes, and again, you are certainly not alone on this housing issue. Every destination I even touch in California has a very similar issue, and in fact, that speaks to the whole notion of the state is about a million housing units short of what it needs, and we feel that all the way down to the rural parts of the state. And then finally,
11:39 The tourism world has gotten very, very competitive for several reasons. One, the TBID funding that fuels it. But two, cities and counties and municipalities have recognized the economic importance of tourism in their economic development portfolio. Before, it was this sort of sleepy thing on the side, and then the recession hit, and after the recession, everybody got...
12:01 Really interested in tourism. And so what that's done is create a convergence of issues. You have industry changes impacting with local community quality of life. And that's where you find yourself in many destinations and communities find themselves right at this nexus of convergence. So the key impacts that I identified through my conversations with everyone was
12:27 There is a part of local residents that get alienated at times, and there's reasons for that with regard to tourism. There are at times degraded visitor experience, both from an environmental standpoint or a crowding standpoint. Certainly impacted infrastructure.
12:44 Is something we see impacted potential damage to the environment for overuse and overcrowding and so forth. Public safety is an issue because as you have more and more people coming into town, you don't necessarily, you want to always maintain the ability to have public safety for
13:05 For these visitors. And then finally, you know, one of the underlying issues, which we'll talk a little bit later, is the fundamental tourism business model, which we've all been working off of for 40 years. And that is grow the business more and more and more. And that's not necessarily wrong, but it needs to be re-looked at and re-channeled as you move forward.
13:25 So why is this important? There's a concept, if you go back to your basic sociology class, there's a concept called the social exchange, which is still an incredibly important concept not to lose sight of, and that basically is tourism is reliant on the goodwill and support of local residents. They have to be supportive of it. And you need them to provide a consistently high level of service. You want them to have a vibrant community that has a culture and expresses itself.
13:54 And if that resident attitude is favorable to visitors, they tend to support more and more tourism or tourism development and so forth. And so that's a very key piece. And on the other hand, if that feeling towards tourism turns negative, it begins to inhibit the experience and the rest of sort of the tourism system within a community.
14:20 And so from a tourism perspective, the town of Mammoth Lakes residents see the cost and benefit of tourism in a positive framework. They're more apt to be open to change regarding tourism and some of the things that tourism brings. But not all residents have a uniform view of it.
14:39 The social exchange in tourism in Mammoth has different perspectives and some of the conversation I've had, it's different. Some folks are really, you know, sort of upset about congestion in the lakes basin in terms of their ability to use it as perhaps they have in the past. Others are simply...
14:59 You know, concerned about affordable housing and housing security. And even others I've heard are just, they can't get to the grocery store at certain times of the weekend or the day and whatnot. And so again, it's not all uniform, but these are palpable and real issues that are out there in the community. So there's four primary elements that are entities that are involved in this tourism system within Mammoth. You've got residents, you've got visitors, you've got local government, which is your role. And then you've got industry.
15:28 And this creates this interaction with tourism, all these four components working together, sometimes in balance, sometimes not in balance. And the key is to have this balance. And that balance is guided by what I call the invisible hand of agreement and cooperation.
15:48 You can't put your fingers on it, but there's a cooperation amongst all these entities that moves things in a certain direction. And when that cooperation sort of falters, it impacts the entire system. So there are impacts, and what you want to do is keep this balance.
16:08 You know, a thriving economy and population growth have impacted the town of Mammoth on many weekends throughout the year, and that has certain impacts. The advent of Airbnb has had an impact on that system. Corporations, you know, when they're here, do they recapitalize? Do they invest? Do they export earnings? What do they do? That has an impact and a dimension to the whole issue. And then local government.
16:36 You know, if local government increases taxes and regulatory issues, that has an impact also. And so again, it's a balancing act that I think is key to understand.
16:48 So when we look at sustainability and competitiveness, we really look at four different elements. The first is the environment, tourism policy, infrastructure, and then natural and cultural resources. All of these together comprise sustainability and competitiveness. And competitiveness is often viewed through these different perspectives. A lot of times it's not viewed holistically.
17:11 You know, a lot of times it's viewed just from a singular perspective depending on the group or the interest that somebody might have. These systems, these all have to work together in a system that makes sense. They are all independent of each other but they all benefit from a strong tourism or balanced tourism.
17:35 And it's the management of that system that's absolutely essential for it to be successful in Mammoth Lakes. So when we look at the sustainability system real quickly, not all players have control of that system. In fact, nobody has control of that system. You have a piece of control of that system. But nobody has a totality of that system. And that's what makes it very, very interesting. The lodging industry may control lodging.
18:05 But they don't control transportation, for example. The ski resort and the Forest Service may control a significant recreational element, but they don't control other elements. So you see the dynamic that happens. Everybody has their own perspective and their own look at the system, but nobody has a holistic management, and that's why that system balance is absolutely crucial to get to. So again,
18:34 It's a tricky, tricky balance. And up until maybe recently in the past four or five years, that balance has been easy because we haven't had those exogenous impacts on communities and tourism destinations like you're feeling today. So that's sort of the background. There's plenty more in that report. And so you have to get to a fundamental question at this point. And that is, do you need to look at making some changes or are you in fact good?
19:03 Where you are. And so I'm going to throw that question out to you guys just to get some feedback. But that's sort of at the point where we're at. And if you're interested in going forward, then I can show you some different thoughts. But what do you guys think? Folks, who wants to ask us questions first? I have a question. So this is pretty much following along with the report that we have because
19:37 Yes. I cannot read this and I'm kind of just. Yeah, it's all in the report. Oh, okay. It's all there. Okay. So for me, since nobody else wants to talk and I love to, it's a very confusing strategy. How do we go forward? Some of the things that are proposed both in the, not the status quo, but the other two methods you have in there and forgive me for my mind not coming up with your verbiage real quick.
20:07 Would be that it would appear we were going for a more high-end clientele in order to limit the numbers to bring us into a better balance. My confliction with that is generally the higher-end strata tends to be much more impulsive in terms of, boy, this resort's looking better this year than this resort. And as the economy goes back down, the economy's never...
20:36 Stay the same forever, then we lose the ability to go back after those middle class which have built us in the first place. So I look at all three of these and go, yeah, this looks so good on paper. But how do you do that and still build in the reliability, to me, of that middle class that built us and continue to sustain us? It's a great question, Mr. Mayor, and you're right, you've brought up...
21:02 Two different strategies. One is sort of the destination management strategy option, and the other is what we call destination balance. I think that whatever this community chooses, the marketing side of Mammoth with Mammoth Lakes Tourism adjusts. They'll figure out how to get...
21:23 If you decide you want to target higher end and move in that direction, they'll figure out how to do that. Whether people make a decision short term or long term, you don't let operational issues stand in front of a marketing solution. And they'll adjust and figure out how to do it as other destinations have. And they're already doing that in some level. So I wouldn't be concerned with the marketing adaptation. It's more along the lines of
21:51 Where do you see the direction generally going for the town? They'll adjust. Marketing always adjusts. If I may jump in on that, we haven't really walked to the three scenarios you're jumping to there. We can walk through those in detail. The question is, do we need to go anywhere is the question right now. Do we see a convergence where we're having some challenges in terms of managing the tourism model that we're currently in?
22:16 Whether it's today or in the near term that we want to begin to look at that and how do we want to direct our destination? What do we want to look like three years, five years, ten years from now? Or do we continue to do what we're doing? Let's just get as many people, I'll put it bluntly, just get as many people here as you can as possible and let them come up and enjoy the out of our destination. So I guess we can walk to the scenarios.
22:41 But if the issue is we're fine, we don't need to do anything, then we just charge ahead as we always have. Or do we need to make... Since I started this show, I'm going to allow myself to go a little further. There are several assumptions made in your report, a well-written report, that before I can make the decision, do we have to go forward or not, I need to know. We just had a record T.O.T. in December.
23:04 In terms of money, but not a record T.O.T. in terms of occupancy percentages. So we are already seeing that our T.O.T. is affected perhaps more by what our hoteliers are getting for their rooms than by the numbers of people. And we've never identified the numbers of people coming to know whether there really is a numbers problem or whether we have a problem where the locals want more days in the year where the tourists aren't here so they can recreate without them.
23:31 What is that degradation? Without answers to those questions, it's hard for me to determine, do we need to go forward with a different strategy to save ourselves, or are we good? Yeah, and in the second scenario, destination management, you'll note that I have destination modeling in there.
23:52 To get exactly to those issues that you're talking about. How many people, what's the revenue per visitor, when do they come, when are potential other times of the year they can come. But you're not doing that destination modeling, you don't have that right now. That would be part of taking a step away from the status quo. Okay, wherever you end, that's just the step I think you really need to take away from the status quo of what you have today.
24:21 So yes, I agree with you, and I have made provisions for that as a step. Okay, that being said, I will shut up for a minute. John, or Linda, go ahead. Thank you for clarifying where we are on this. You asked the questions, are we okay with where we are now? No, I don't think we're where we want to be right now. We've got housing issues, we have sustainability issues, we have forest service issues, we have overcrowding issues, we have, you know,
24:51 Lakes basins that are so impacted, and no, we can't get the bathrooms cleaned. So, I mean, yes, there's a lot of definite things. So, the question, if you want to stick to the question you asked is, no, what we're doing now is not enough. What we're doing now is not sustainable. So, then the next question is, okay, what do we do about it then, and what are the priorities? So, I assume you're going to lead us through that. I will. I answered the question. I appreciate that. Others? Oh, go ahead, John.
25:20 Go ahead. Oh, okay. I don't think we're on any kind of right track right now with the changes that are going on here. When I had a conversation with you about this, I felt that I was expressing a different side from your facial expressions that you maybe had not heard. I think one of the biggest, well, we'll get down that down the road, but we have a lot of challenges and
25:50 I do not see a sustainable Mammoth Lakes if we do not make some corrections and quickly. Yes, and I certainly took to heart your key issues and have built them into the scenarios. I did see something, so thank you. Okay, John. Councilman. Thank you. So I agree with Councilmembers Salcido and Hoff. I base this on some anecdotal information. I see the most valuable asset that we have in this community is our place.
26:20 And I see the place being actively degraded, and it's getting worse. I've only been here for 20 years, but I'm seeing it getting actively becoming degraded. I hear from constituents consistently on this mix of the balance of tourism, and I think you've very correctly identified that fine line of support for tourism versus coming outright hostile to it. That's something that we cannot afford to do. We don't have a plan B. We have to...
26:48 In the moment, we have to find a balance for that. I think that the relocation of the leadership of Mammoth Mountain Ski Area from here to Denver, Colorado, meaning that Mammoth Resorts is now one of 25 franchises and a satellite. You talked about the exporting of profit and capital and those kinds of things.
27:08 It is leaving here and going to Denver. Whether or not it comes back, that's going to be going through a massive multi-billion dollar filter at this point. It's going to be a public company. And so I think that we have to get into this systemic business. We have to do that kind of stuff because I think that we as a community have an opportunity to define ourselves.
27:33 Without maybe the kind of historic interference that's come from Mammoth Resorts in the ski area, we have an opportunity to define ourselves as a destination. It's a critical opportunity. I think one thing, a little bit of a frustration is, how do we get from what you've outlined here to the hows? The initiation of this process was to inform the contracts.
27:55 With Mammoth Lakes Tourism and Mammoth Lakes Recreation. And so I'm very keen about how do we get from all this to giving specific direction to those, our components of the systemic management so we can manage this thing. That's not in here yet, but I'm assuming we'll get to that. But those are my thoughts. Okay. Thank you. Councilman Burke. Here, I've read this twice.
28:20 You have all these different suggestions in here and three different scenarios and the destination balance. And then your last sentence in your report, the models start with the end in mind and ask the basic question, what is the end game and what does it look like from the perspective of all concerns?
28:39 We still, you don't identify all the concerns in here by those that are concerned, the entities from lodging to the mountain to tourism, all of that. Until the question is answered, it is near impossible to find a solution. Okay, then, you know.
28:58 Again, you pose these questions. I wish you would have let us know that you want us to come up with these different answers because you don't pose that question in here. So I assumed you were going to give us some sort of, you know, these are action items or anything else because I talked to the town manager and I said, where are the action items? What are we going to do with this report? Got good information in it.
29:23 It does. It really does. And now, what's the first step, second step, third step? What are we supposed to do? A great perspective, and I think what I'm looking for, the report looks for, is conceptual direction. This is not a finished document. It's got to come back with steps. But to fill the steps out, you've got to begin to say, okay, let's lean in this direction. We definitely don't want to do that, but we want to look over here. And then from that, you'll get a lot more meat on the bones.
29:52 At the next iteration of this report. Again, this report is a creative document. It's not me saying you've got to do this. It's, hey, here's some options. Let's get some feedback and ideas and then...
30:04 We'll bring it back, but we have to at least know what direction we want to begin to move. A good idea if you outlined, you know, what are the problems? Okay, we have overcrowding on the weekend. We obviously have parking issues up in the Lakes Basin. We have people that are just driving off into the woods, parking and everything else. You know, it'd be really helpful.
30:26 To identify what are the issues that are impacting, yes, overcrowding on certain, on the weekends and that sort of thing, as well as camping in the woods and everything else that is going on and couch surfing and all these different things are happening and we're aware of it and the thing is that I'm not understanding, you have good information in the report, I'm not understanding how we move forward.
30:51 Well, I think if we get into the scenarios, you'll see all this fleshed out in a much deeper way, and hopefully then I'll answer some of your questions, and if not, we'll take another look at it. Well, you have three scenarios, status quo, designate management, and destination balance. So, yes, obviously we have a destination management. We need to, we recognize we have issues. You know, destination balance.
31:16 That's another whole issue, shifting it over to midweek instead of this. And then you have the caring capacity of how does those people that own units and everything else, Airbnb or hoteliers or whatever, how do they deal with this? Exactly right. Destination balance is a big shift.
31:38 I'm not going to kid you. It is a big shift for a community to begin to say, you know, we're going to move in this direction as a whole community or direction. That's a big shift. But it's there as an option for you to look at. It may not be something you're interested in. It may be something you might want to aspire to. But it is a big shift. Make no mistake. But I was trying to put up three different scenarios.
32:02 For you guys to consider and look at, not just a straightforward, here's a direction and here's the 10 steps to get there, but hey, here's different ways to look at the issue. So with that in mind, you've asked us a question and I think we have each answered whether we think we need to move on or not. There are some big smiles on the back row back there. So I would like to turn this to the audience knowing that we have limited time and prompting them with that.
32:28 To hear the response of some of our business partners, and we have several of them here with us, as to whether we need to move something like this forward or not. So with that, I would ask you to come, those of you who would, John and John, you both would be included in that, to come up and answer the same question that we had to answer a moment ago. Not that I would ever put anybody on the spot, mind you. So Brent Truax here at Nevada Resort Spa.
33:00 Mr. Mayor, Town Council. I'm going to do it a little differently. I know you asked the question, but I'm going to ask the reverse question. I'm almost agreeing where Kirk's going and some of the comments. We've got a document here that is kind of asking certain questions, but it's not what I was expecting to see as part of our workshop. I was there when we did the workshop with the Town Council before. I was kind of envisioning that we were going to address some of the other issues that we were talking about. Linda brought up some of those, too. Let's take, for instance, the lakes basin.
33:28 Is that an issue of number of traffic? Do we need to revision how we do that? Do we need to have buses that only go up there? I know that Carl's going to say that it's all going to come down the road, but I'm not seeing a document that leads me into those. I've seen a document that's giving me three different scenarios, and it doesn't really address where I thought we were headed with some of this stuff. I'll dare to venture on this and ask on the other side.
33:50 Is SMG the right consultant? Do we need somebody else to come in that maybe has a different vision that's going to come differently? SMG's done a lot of work for this town. I'm not trying to say you've done bad work. I'm just saying, is this time? Because we've got plans for SMG from the last 30 years, 25 years. Is this the right entity? Do we need to have more people come back with other suggestions? I'm just throwing it out as a thought, not as initially an action.
34:14 I mean, we kind of all agreed, and I thought when we sat, I say all agreed, those who were on MLT Board at the time, Town Council, that we needed to look at something like this because we have issues and we don't really see where we are going down the road.
34:25 I still think that's the case. We still are trying to figure out what are we. Is the mountain a major component? Do we need other businesses to come to town to help augment where we are? It's not just the overall tourism. It's also about how we look in 20 years from now. Do we need land from the Forest Service to do some other things in the lower part of the area? Again, a little granular, but what I see is different options, and they may be great leads to those portions on the options.
34:54 But I've not really seen a plan here that gets to what we were talking about before. So I'll leave it at that. I'd be glad to provide written comments on those. But if I made sense on where I was going with that, I hope I did. Thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon, John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I think that the meeting started off with a conversation about the workshop that we had and the presentation that Mammoth Lakes Tourism had with regards to a destination management strategy. And the price tag was pretty sizable. We were looking at a $200,000.
35:29 Program to go soup to nuts. I think what you've asked for and what you've got from SMG is a starting point. I think the scenarios that are in there, I've also read it multiple times, and I think what it is is it's saying, okay, these are the options. There are a hell of a lot of other steps. This is not done based on these scenarios. These scenarios aren't designed to solve the problem. It's to identify the problems, and I think now comes the hard work of, okay, how are we going forward with that?
35:58 Obviously, your input is critically important. I think when we look at these things and we talk about things like overcrowding and we talk about things where we've got a tremendous asset on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday here during the winter where you can fire a cannon up most of the trails on the mountain and there's nobody on the hill. And then the opposite happens on Saturdays and Sundays where you have 20,000 people on the hill.
36:23 And the experience is degraded. And I think that happens in the summertime where, you know, it's a lot more steady traffic, not just weekends. So at our board meeting on March 4th, we're talking about our strategies moving forward for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I understand that this plan isn't complete, but I don't think that it was meant to be complete. I think this is, these are the bones and I think we need to put the meat on the bones. So at our board meeting on March 4th, we'll be presenting strategy to our board. Again, it's open to the public at one o'clock on the, on the.
36:52 The fourth of March. And we are going to talk about some of those things. How do we redirect traffic? How do we drive that midweek business versus that weekend business? You know, do we follow the lead of some of our peer resorts where North Lake Tahoe has said in the summertime, we're not going to advertise and try and get San Francisco to drive over. We're going to go after the destination visitor. And I think that ties in with things like the air messaging. It also ties in with some of the other pieces where we're trying to get people that are going to
37:20 Be the right visitor. They're going to come and stay longer, spend more money, and hopefully be a little more respectful to our environment. Another big piece of what we're working on is that stewardship messaging. We want to make sure that when people come here that they recognize that they don't leave their brain in Los Angeles or Houston or Boston, that they come here and they respect what they're utilizing. And so we've already been working on fairly sizable campaigns that will be coming out this summer towards the stewardship message, not only to educate the visitors.
37:49 But also to educate our residents. And I think when we start to look at all the different stakeholders that are out there, you know, I pose the question almost any time it comes up with over-tourism. You know, I think there are impacts on environment, but who feels that we're over-tourismed? Is it the visitor? Is it the business owner? Because I haven't heard a lot of people that own businesses complaining that they're too busy or making too much money. Is it the second homeowner? Is it the resident?
38:17 Or is it the frontline person? So I think we need to define a lot of these things because I'm not convinced that we're talking from the same piece. I think that we've got a lot of busy weekends that come through here. And how do we regulate those? How do we maintain those so that they're not getting overcrowded in the Lakes Basin? And I think that's really where the town comes into it. You know, we can work on the tourism side and we can try and redirect people.
38:44 Instead of everybody going up to Duck Lake, how do we get them going into TJ and Baird? We can educate people. But I think when we start to talk about parking in the Lakes Basin or other options for infrastructure, that's where the town comes in. So I think that in reading through this and looking at the balanced scenario, number three, I think that it makes sense that we need to figure out how to balance this. And Bill, to your point, one of the questions that I had or one of the comments that I had with Carl was,
39:12 You know, we don't want to become an exclusive resort where you're only here if you're, you know, making half a million dollars a year. But I also think that we have to look at it from the standpoint of how can we work the most basic principle of economics, which is supply and demand. You know, if we have too many people here, you know, if you have too many people anywhere, you start, if you have that much demand, you start to raise your prices. You know, you look at the hotels. You can buy a hotel room six months in advance at a place for $199.
39:42 Three days out, it's $600. Same thing with airlines. And I think it's about yield management. We've talked about education of our business community. One of the things that I always have concern with is last year we did well over $3 million in TOT in the month of January. And then in July we do about $1.7 million. So we're doing almost half the revenue. And I think July we have more people here.
40:08 So I think there's a management not only of the destination but I think of the messaging and also of the education of the businesses in town that I guess I'm wrong. No, I think there's a lot of education and that's one of the big things that we're working on. So again, working on the destination visitors, trying to fill the need times and working on that education and stewardship. So I think that this is the first step. There is a lot of meat that needs to be put on the bones but I think the idea is to say do we feel that we need to move forward with this and I think we do.
40:41 Thank you. Tom Cage, business owner. I'm glad John got up and said what he was doing about the stewardship, about talking about TOT, the record numbers. Business, even though our snow has been very lean, is not off very much. For me personally, between a very mature business that's been around through January, we're off 6% after a record year.
41:18 I look at a plan like this and I say, what do we have at the end of it other than a nice binder on a shelf with many other plans we've spent a lot of money on? This to me is a plan you put together when your MLT has failed you. This MLT has not failed the community. This MLT is planning for the future. This MLT is meeting next week about strategies.
41:42 I would think maybe after that they would get together with Mammoth Mountain and meet on strategic alliances, partnerships, future plans. The mountain has invested a lot and is continuing to invest in summertime activities for a year-round destination resort experience. We've started to work on housing. You've helped the traffic in the lakes basin with the trolleys.
42:10 We have building going on in town. We have investment going on in town. I don't understand the meat that John wants to put on the bone because I think he's doing that. I think the town is doing that. I think that there are other entities that are being educated about that, private businesses as well as other groups in town.
42:34 The Chamber is doing things like that. So I'm confused why you would spend money to put the meat on the bone because this is a very nice, clean presentation that consultants do all the time. This is their job other than to ask you to borrow your watch so that they can tell you what time it is. That's the definition of a consultant. That's what you have here. And quite honestly, good, bad, or indifferent work in the past, present, or future.
43:02 I think there are people here that know Mammoth a whole lot better that can do the work and are doing the work to fulfill the needs of putting the meat on the bone. So personally, I hope the council looks at it and says, at the end, what do we have that we use? And if the council's not using it, what at the end does John have at MLT that he's going to use?
43:26 And if he says, well, I'm going to use this and this and this and it's the starting point and it goes down the road, well, then John can pay for it out of his budget. But I don't think that it's something that, you know, if the town council sees a final need, well, then that's what you'll determine today. But otherwise, I think that a lot of what is being talked about in between these lines on this report.
43:48 Are being done by the qualified people that we have here. And unless the town council thinks the MLT is not doing a good job, and you need to reset a strategic plan, you know, I just don't understand why you would go forward with this. Thank you. Anyone else? Okay, I will bring it back. You want to say something, Sandy? Sandy Hogan. And my whole life has been spent pretty much in resort towns.
44:24 We're serving the public starting with Knott's Berry Farm at 16 and Disneyland for a few more years, myself through college and of course Heavenly Valley, worked there for many years and my forest service life has always been in resort towns because I love them. But I think it's a great topic that you're asking and I think Carl has given you some scenarios to look at.
44:52 Bill's comments and most of your comments really kind of summarize mine. We have a wonderful town. We've got wonderful assets. How do you balance them? And that's the question that's being, you know, what are the elements that you need to fix? And you can't fix them all at once, you know? And so he's just asking, where do you want to go? The last one, frankly, scares me a little bit. I just came from skiing in a very Courchevel.
45:21 The last place I'd want us to ever be. I took a day off to just go explore and walk around the town, and there's Prada, and there's Dior, and there's all of this stuff. And you know, the middle class, I guess the first thing when I read this I thought, and maybe it's an appropriate time to say it, what would Dave do? Dave created a town that to me, we're blue collar, and why not?
45:48 And the folks that come up here and that have made it, you know, great, they come from Southern California. I heard 15 years ago that, oh, we've become a destination resort, like we're going to forget about Southern California. They're going to be with us forever. This is their mountain. But what I'm seeing right now, actually, with this Icon Pass and the blackout days and whatever, because I ski as much as I can, it's been my life, I've seen a leveling, actually.
46:17 And even in things like school vacations, right now it's winter break. And so there's a lot of midweek here. And I know we've got spring break. I didn't have these things when I grew up. You didn't either, a lot of us. But, you know, there is a lot of leveling that's going on. So I think analyzing that, working with the town, and the town working with the mountain, but also the Forest Service has a lot of figures. I know that they're short, very, very short of...
46:46 You know, staff. But they also have figures that can be very helpful, I think. And working with them and relying on what they have, even if it's imperfect, sometimes gives you trends. So maybe working with that relationship, I think they have a winter sports planner now, I'm not sure, recreation officer, those are the ones you should probably be talking to because they're going to know what's going on on the ground and that's what we're talking about, where we want to go.
47:16 To me, I like the second one, which tells me that there is balance. I don't like the title of the third one, Destination Balance, or whatever it is. That doesn't make sense to me, yes, because that sounds like, oh, but what I read into it was, well, let's just kind of move towards the rich folks, and frankly, that has worried me for years when I see what's going on with the world of lift tickets and things like that. I mean, right now, I mean, during weekends, whatever, it's a hundred and
47:46 $99 for a Lyft ticket. I mean, that's just, I look at families and I go, how can you grow the industry? Because the industry has been a big part of my life. How can you grow that industry if you're doing, you know, pricing people out? I just, so I don't know the answer to that one. But, you know, I think there are some good things going on. So finding those trends.
48:14 But finding the things we need to fix, our housing, absolutely. If you don't have happy employees, you're not going to have happy visitors. And that's a quote of Cleland's, and she's absolutely right. So anyway, just some comments from somebody that lives here. I love tourism. I love resort places. It's good for us. Not all retirees are cranky old, it's mine. I want it, but I want the same thing. I want a good balance. That's what's necessary here.
48:44 I'm not sure this is exactly the right forum for this comment, but there was a time not too long ago when the town didn't spend as much money on everything as it does on tourism now. We're spending, coming up on $20 million a year, and yet we don't have places to put people to live. We have families that live here that their kids to be fifth, sixth grade, they leave because they can't make it here.
49:21 So, to John's point, I don't know any businessman that doesn't think he needs to make less money or that, you know, there aren't too many people coming. I do know a lot of businessmen who are saying they can't get anybody to work for them, who are saying the people they have are leaving. And eventually, do we really want to end up being, you know, Montecito or something where you have a bunch of business owners and a bunch of tourists and nobody else?
49:51 So I'd like to see us focus a little bit more on the people who live here and not focus less on the people who come because they're the ones that we all live off of and that's never going to change. John said we don't have a plan B. Why don't we have a plan B? How about we start on a plan B? We don't have a dry cleaner in this town. Come on, let's have a little bit more community and maintain our tourism, increase the quality of it.
50:19 Clean up some of the messes we have, but let's spend a lot more money on the people who are here. Carl? Mr. Mayor? Can I just make a comment? These are great comments, and exactly what I was hoping for, but I think they illustrate the need of balance. You hear from tourism, you hear from business owners, you hear from community members, and that's the balance dynamic that is out of balance.
50:51 And how do you get in there? And that's what scenario do you want to follow to sort of balance it all? Or do you want to take one at a time? Or do you want to discard one? Or whatever. But that's the framework, the holistic framework you want to begin to look at is all of that. And I think that's what I try to do in these scenarios and say, OK, you've got a status quo. You can leave it as is.
51:12 If you want, you've got this destination management scenario, and that is a great scenario, or you've got this other thing that's probably a little bit more radical. And when we talk about balance, it's economic balance. Supply, I understand that, and I appreciate the nuanced comment, but I was thinking in terms of supply and demand, price equilibrium balance. But I think that this is exactly the challenge.
51:37 That your community and mine in South Lake Tahoe and Santa Barbara and everyone else is out there trying to grapple with. So these are great comments, exactly what you look for. Okay. Sure comment. But if we focus back, Carl, for a minute on the key issues facing town, the list that you did there, and if we agree that those are essentially correct, then I think it gives us a place to jump off from.
52:04 Yes. I mean, I think we can circle back to that and not necessarily take any one of those three scenarios as we're going to do that one, but rather components of each of them that might answer some of these questions, I think we can focus back around. Absolutely. You create your own scenario. That's what this process is designed to do. Exactly right. If you go back and look at these issues, is this the one you were referring to? Well, we have a different presentation than you do. Yes. Oh, okay.
52:33 So if you look at the issue of, hang on one second, let's go, you have, these are the impacts of what you have today, okay, and those impacts are you have, at the convergence you have these impacts, you have some alienated residents, you have some degraded visitor experience, you have some impacted infrastructure.
53:04 You have impacted potential damage to the environment. You have some public safety issues that you need to manage effectively. Not that you aren't, but you've got to be cognizant of them if you keep growing and growing and growing. And all of those are tied to a fundamental business model that tourism destinations have. And how do you manage that model is really what you're after, is how do we take the current business model that we've had and has brought us success?
53:33 There's no question about it, but how do you manage now? How do you optimize? How do you refine those efforts to get to a place that balances all four of those categories, the resident, tourism, stakeholders in the town? That's the key of where you want to get to, in my view, as you look forward. You know, one was left off of that, and that was impacts to local culture.
54:00 And that's a little misleading, but it's about the impacts to our local population. You know, and you mentioned in here, you know, the patterns and the rhythms that people have here, like where do we shop? Where do we eat? When do we go out in public? When do we go out and try to enjoy some of these? And I think that's a really important issue, because if our tourism is impacting anything, that kind of encompasses everything along with, you know, alienated locals. It all kind of goes together there.
54:28 And that's one thing that I'm really concerned about is that, you know, we don't have enough places to, you know, live. We're working on that. We don't have enough, you know, but this is a big piece of it because that is at the end of it all. If we continue to stress that we are a community first, then it brings us back to this as the paramount. Yes. In fact, from a tourism standpoint, local culture is probably one of the premier issues of differentiation of a destination.
54:57 If you look around, most of your competitive destinations have very similar attributes that you have. They have golf courses, they have bike trails, hiking trails, restaurants, and all the rest. What really makes you unique is your culture and the authenticity and capturing that, and that's what gives...
55:14 Mammoth Lakes, it's differentiation. It's different than Lake Tahoe. It's different than Santa Barbara. It's different than everywhere else. And you do want to manage that. You do want to take care of that. But that gets impacted when there's not enough housing or there's housing insecurity or what have you. And so, yeah, you're absolutely right. These scenarios, I mean, I can quickly just say, if you're good with where you're at,
55:41 And kind of let everyone do their thing, the chamber, Mammoth Lakes Tourism and so forth. You're good. That is scenario one. That is a decision and that is scenario one.
55:51 Let it roll. Scenario two is a more proactive approach to, you know, all these things that we're talking about with responsibilities and management from the town to Mammoth Lakes Tourism, even the community. You know, one of the things that I don't see here that I see in other communities, and I don't want to offend anyone, but I don't see a really aggressive, proactive, protect the environment feel. It may be here, I just haven't felt it like I feel in some other communities.
56:20 But these are things that you want to begin to more proactively manage. That's the destination management strategy. And the destination balance is to begin to say, you know what? We're going to move in this whole different direction. We're going to move up market. And we're going to really use pricing in an extreme way to manage the demand for the destination. And again, that's just designed to spread these approaches out for you.
56:48 Mr. Mayor, if I could, when you're ready, have some comments. Go ahead. Okay, I'm not sure how you want to end up this workshop. If you just want us to provide comments for staff to collect, then that will inform the next step. But I've got some comments based on what I've heard. And I want to start first with Greg Eckert's comment, because that is the absolute critical question.
57:14 And it's defining because the question that Greg brings up about community, it's important to understand that that is not unique to Mammoth Lakes. The Sustainable Recreation Tourism Initiative that's going up and down the region, the same concerns are in Lone Pine, Big Pine, Bishop, here, and you're going to hear it all the way up to the border, up to Tahoe. And we have to find the balance between having a vibrant
57:43 Viable community and its integration in with the recreation and tourism economy. That's the balance that we have to strike. And the point about the mountain now being located in Denver is very important because the mountain in conversations and things, Linda, some of the things we've attended, the mountain is looking to work very much within their permit area.
58:07 They want to work within the mountain and develop hotels and things that are going to feed what they're doing up there. And I'm going to anticipate that there's going to be less of an interest of what happens in the town versus what's going to be happening within the landscape that they control. So when they're making decisions in Denver about where to invest hundreds of millions of dollars, they're going to be saying, well, how is that investment going to serve?
58:28 Their profit center, which is at the resort, which makes complete sense. So this is the opportunity that we have, again, back to Greg's point. How do we thrive as a community? How do we make sure we have a workforce? How do we make sure we are a community? And the questions in front of us are, if we do not rise to those challenges, we are going to be a pass-through. They're just going to drive right up the state highway and go to the resort. And we are, we, by...
58:55 Perhaps our failures to act and our failure to engage, we are not going to be able to realize the destiny of being a viable community. So I want to thank you for bringing that point up. And the point about the plan B's, yeah, we got to figure this out. We have to take the status quo model that's working right now. It's giving us seven, eight million dollars to help us build the first phases of the parcel.
59:15 Okay, that's all good, but how do we transition into a balance and economic model that's going to work for this community so we will be a community in balance with the tourism and recreation economy? A couple other observations. I think that we, I very much appreciate Tom Cage's comment about doing this locally. This has to be done and developed and built locally. Carl, you're...
59:37 Doing the things you need to do to bring these things to our attention, to bring examples from the outside. But I think that the town, frankly, we failed a little bit on this. We're not playing the kind of convening and facilitating role that we need to play. We have contracts with MLR and MLT, and I very much appreciate the entire, I think the whole MLT staff is here today. Thanks for your attention to this. I'm frankly the other partners in this that aren't here today that I wish.
1:00:00 Would have shown up. I'm channeling a lot of voices, a lot of phone calls, a lot of emails are not here today. They wish they had been there, but I'm trying to represent on their behalf. And I think, you know, I'll stop with this final observation. The idea is, Sandy, your point about skiing, you know, skiing as an activity for a family of four, is that a thousand bucks out the door every day?
1:00:26 I mean, it's turning into that kind of activity. But we have recreation assets from federal public lands that don't cost anything. They're free to the public. So these are part of these balancing interests we're going to have to figure out how to navigate. So I very much support moving forward. I think we need to do it locally. I think we need to own it locally. I think the town, we've got some work to do to figure out how to make all that stuff work. And I've got some more comments, but that's enough for now, I'm sure.
1:00:56 I found it really interesting, the Bend Pledge for visitors. Here, here. Yes. Indeed. And I think that as a town, we have woefully left this kind of mentality behind. And personally, it's becoming a real hardship. Companies that are now renting their places on Airbnb, there used to be a two-car minimum. People would keep to that.
1:01:25 Then it was like, well, you know, you can have additional parking, a third spot. Now people are bringing up five and six cars because they're all bringing up their cars. They're making their own parking spaces. I would love to have a little sticker that I can just put on people's cars that just says simply, this is not a parking space. Thank you. It's not a ticket. If there is any way, and I think John brought it up, that we need to educate the visitors.
1:01:54 We haven't been doing it, and it's getting worse, and I think that that is creating the biggest impact. If there is some way that we can get all in as a community and have something with this model, I think that will probably be the first step, regardless of what direction we're going in, and we've got to let people know how they are going to treat us and what we expect as a community from them.
1:02:22 They're paying good money, but they're not paying good money to run rampant in this town. And I think that is one of the key flips. And I think my conversations with John Urdi, you know, there's a clear understanding that these visitors got to become more and more, you know, caring and stewards of the place. And how do you get that message? How do you flip that mindset? How do you flip that dynamic? What you guys are all talking about are the characteristics of Model 2.
1:02:51 Oh, option two. Everything you're saying is along those characteristics. Yeah, there's some other things. I'll give you a great example. One of the things you guys do a great job at, you track money really well. You track revenue, you track TOT, you track money, but nobody counts visitors. Nobody counts visitors. We don't know what the revenue per visitor is, or we don't know what the volume is.
1:03:20 How do you manage without having that kind of data in addition to what you have? And that's proactively managing to say, hey, how do we optimize? We know we're getting this many bodies on these kinds of days or this season. And how do we proactively manage those numbers? That's really the difference between what you have and sort of model two destination management. It's just a much more aggressive approach to it.
1:03:48 And then model three, you know, option three is a wholesale rethinking of the destination. You know, hey, we want to be, we want to move upscale and compete in a different way, in a different level, and a different track. That may happen 20 years from now, or as a council, you could say, you know what, we're going to go hell-bent for leather, and that's us. Probably not. So the characteristics of what I'm hearing is you're centering around, you know, option two, and what does that mean in greater depth and detail?
1:04:18 To everyone concerned. Well, I guess I just, I read this, what's the action plan? What are we, what do, what are we actually going to do? What's the town manager going to do? What is John Erty going to do? Read it, what's, you know, do we have a, you know, step one, step two, step three, what do we, if we accept this, which I think a lot of it, I do accept your insights and your perspective overcrowding and everything else, and
1:04:51 We don't control at all the Forest Service, Mammoth Mountain, all of these other partners. So what's our first step? The first step is if you were to say, hey, Carl, we tend to center on option two, then I would come back at another meeting with that really fleshed out in detail. Say, here's what those steps are. Can't the manager do that rather than paying a consultant? It's already in the contract. I do it anyways. All right.
1:05:19 But the key was to get this input, to hear what the objections were, to hear what the possibilities were, and then to say, okay, we tend to center around here, and now we'll flush that out in greater detail, so you do have an action plan moving forward. So, for my part, several important things. Yes. One, if we move this forward, regardless of the level, this has to be a close and coordinated effort.
1:05:50 With Mammoth Lakes Tourism and our other partners. Absolutely. It does not work otherwise. I don't want to see them going off on their own and us going off on our own. So whoever and whatever decision we decide on needs to be a joint effort between those organizations so that we have a concerted effort moving forward. Agreed. Two, our difference between most of those other resorts that we're talking about and the examples given in here is that we don't have a resort. Not even the great Mammoth Mountain.
1:06:18 owns a bed base in town. The bed base is owned by thousands of individual owners at John's Place and at other places like that who are ultimately going to decide what price point we become because they're going to change their prices and they're going to tell their management company and if he won't do it incidentally they will move to a management company that will they're going to tell him what price point they need to be at to get the number of visitations in their units they want. So some of the math in here that works in other places
1:06:48 It would be impossible, in my opinion, for this town council to say we want to go to level three and we want to price ourselves to the point where we no longer have over-tourism. I happen not to believe we have over-tourism. I think we have pushed our number of tourists on the Indian National Forest to an ever-decreasing space, which is a problem for me, but I think that can be solved.
1:07:13 But in terms of what scenario we go down and what our ability is as a government agency or as an NGO or as the lodging association or the chamber of commerce to set prices doesn't exist. Agreed. Because our bed base is a condominium bed base. It is not a resort bed base. I have no problem moving forward. I do want to know.
1:07:37 Counting visitors in a VRBO and bed sharing and house swapping and all of these other environments is also next to impossible. But I would love to see us try to get a handle on how many people are actually in the lake basin. How different is that from the 60s and 70s? You know, the Indian National Forest has been serving 3 million customers a year since I was a little boy. We charge them more. They do different things. We complained because we were giving them things outside of town.
1:08:06 Local hoteliers and such. We wanted them to stay in town. Now they're staying in town and we have too many. So these are all things that have to be solved, but coordinated has to be. In terms of pricing ourselves where we want to go, we simply don't have the tools necessary. I wouldn't want to see a government strong enough to be able to tell individual homeowners what they can and can't charge.
1:08:30 I share your concern, Mr. Mayor. I do. So with those things said, moving forward, from other than where we are, I agree. I would like to see a plan come back that has the backing of MLT or is in concert with what they're doing, and I hopefully can go to that March 4 meeting. But that's my comments. Yeah, and I appreciate those comments. If I could just respond real quickly. I don't disagree with all. I think...
1:08:58 The opportunity you have is to balance these different players. At a basic level, that's a key thing to balance. And absolutely, it has to go forward with MLT. There's no question. They're a key player. They have the horsepower. They have the voice and so forth. And so to do it...
1:09:17 Any of this independently, that's the key, is to begin to have that invisible hand of cooperation of everybody moving in the same direction. That's the implementation goal you want to get to. In terms of pricing, absolutely the government can't, nor should they, nor should MLT get into pricing issues. You can't, but you can educate about pricing. You can begin to say,
1:09:42 What is yield management? How can we use it better? What are some of the tools that we can educate our local community to use more effectively in looking at pricing to manage demand? Make no mistake, pricing is what manages volume in the tourism world. There's no hidden secret, but it's a challenge.
1:10:02 But there's nothing wrong with educating local restaurants or lodging owners or what have you to look at that. Some of the things I see out there, some restaurants use weekend menus and midweek menus because they want to control demand. Disneyland just went to $200 a ticket. Not for the money. They want to manage demand. And there's a lot of countries now you're paying a head tax when you get off a cruise ship.
1:10:28 And I'm saying you have to do that, but price does play a role, and it's not your job, and it's not MLT's job to say, here's what the pricing should be, but it is somebody's job to educate, to say, hey, how can we optimize this, and how can we get the best out of it? So, Mr. Mayor, if I could real quick, I just want to support your comments, I want to support Kirk's comments, all of our comments, frankly, what I've heard up here, direction of the town manager, that what comes back to us next needs to be an action plan.
1:10:56 It needs to be holistic and all kind of hands on deck of the resources that we have to work with. And I want to emphasize that all the NGOs we work with, we have contracts with them. And as long as I've been on the council, it's always been the desire of councils to inform those agreements.
1:11:16 Around policy direction coming from the council. So I want to make sure that when, and if this is a problem in terms of staffing and bandwidth and things that you have, please let us know. We need to know that. But I just want to build upon what all you guys have said to make it very clear to the town manager that that's the expectation coming back to this. That the next thing comes back to us is an action plan. It's been vetted through our partners. We all know what we're doing. If we have to allocate resources to it or whatever, the next step is an action plan. I just want to be
1:11:45 Point out, you know, we went through a thing with information technology that was intended to bring all the partners together, and that effort failed. The town did not do the things it needed to do to make that happen. I have no interest in a repeat of that. So just as a cautionary note to the town manager and the staff, the council, I think, is very interested in having a coordinated, focused, engaged, local-based effort to do this. So those are my thoughts.
1:12:13 Okay, Dan, I think we've provided you with what you need to bring back your... Yeah, if I just may summarize that real quick, too, I think the reason we structured this was from some of the comments and discussion was I think there was a feeling in some cases that actually what we're doing is working, so we really don't need to be overly proactive and go out and do some of this effort. The other side of that was just the opposite. In some discussions with folks, it was like we really need to get much more proactive. How do you not have, you know,
1:12:43 Parking Armageddon on high-impact weekends, et cetera. And so in looking at all these different issues was, is there a general consensus in terms of, yes, we need to do something, but in a managed or moderate approach, and that's kind of what I'm hearing on the scenario two kind of layout here without going through all these, given most of the comments. It tends to follow that not to be overly aggressive in terms of where we're, you know, in one end of the spectrum.
1:13:10 But also just letting things go the way they've been going doesn't sound like that's an option either. So really that's what we're trying to get to the council on at this point. It wasn't here's the five steps to take. The question was is there a general agreement that we need to do something at a measured level or at a very, very aggressive level? Maybe you could turn around and say we want to cap short-term rentals at 500 in the town and put a moratorium on them. Not hearing that. I mean, you know, you could get that aggressive on something or not.
1:13:39 And so we will come back, I'll say building off of what I'll call scenario two in here. We didn't spend time walking through each of those, but really kind of that managed approach in terms of the steps that we're hearing from the community as well as from the council at this point in terms of, I think we do need to bring this in and say how do we manage some of these issues that we're feeling and seeing, whether it's overcrowded parking at a condo complex or whether it's...
1:14:03 You know, no place to park in the Lake's Basin. There's a balancing act through that process. How do we talk to our community? How do we talk to our visitors? But it's in that space, kind of in the middle of the road, if you will, that it sounds like is the general direction. Yes, we need to do something, but we don't need to go overboard. Start it out moderate and give us room to go more aggressive. You can grow down the road.
1:14:26 I just, but Dan, again, in your comments, I just, I just go back. So the action plan, I understand that, and with other people involved. The other, the action plan, the folks that the council has the ability to contract with to do this work, that, I just want to make sure we're clear, we're not getting fuzzy on this. No, I was saying, but that work is going to take work to define what exactly does MLT do or does XYZ process. But again, from my standpoint, the important thing is, and I'm not somebody who works for. For partnerships.
1:14:50 Too much information to drive my decision-making. But right now, this is being driven by a the sky is falling mentality. We are overcrowded. We are over-touristed. We need the facts to go with that to show that indeed we are and it's not just our perception. So that's the next little bit that I'm looking for really is what are the facts and then that should drive whatever product we drive out of that.
1:15:19 Well, I'm not, again, if we need to talk about this, I think that there's, I don't want to wait to have a bunch of data collection that could take a year or something to put in front of us to make this decision. I think we can move forward with the level, the second scenario is described. I think getting, we've asked for data resources in the past, and I think we've asked for things about how many people are on the landscape, and there's a lot of data that we've talked about that's in the host compliance stuff.
1:15:47 Around nightly rentals. I mean, there's a lot of data resources out there. I think we can move forward with this direction that you articulated, but with the expectation that we're going to have data and resources to support what may be elements of the action plan. Does that sound about right? Yeah. Okay, good. I mean, we have the data around hotels and people that are, you have a large space. The data that is really hard to get to is that data around single nightly rentals.
1:16:16 And there's some piece of it within TOT payment, business licenses, all of that that's within that. But that's the piece that's missing. We don't know how many short-term nightly rentals there are rented at any given time.
1:16:30 I have not heard a single business in town go, wow, I've got so many employees, I don't know what to do. I think that is a place where the sky is falling in this town. So I don't think I'm being alarmist. I hear it from the business community all the time. And that is going to be something that I would really like to be very aggressive about. And I believe we've created a plan already to be very aggressive.
1:16:58 And to continue to get the data. And allocated the funding to do that. Yeah, and to get the data, because you really can't make decisions that aren't based on data.
1:17:05 But there's a lot of things we don't know. In here and up at this dais over and over, we talk about the fact that we've lost so many long-term rentals to VRBO. We don't know that. Exactly. I mean, I've been doing work in condos for years and years, and the bulk of them have never been in long-term rentals because the owners want usage of those units. That's why they buy them. So we don't even know that little figure. We just use it.
1:17:32 Yes, sir. Counting is part of destination management. Yes. It's in that scenario. You've got to count what you have to manage what you have. It's exactly right. Okay, Dan, trying to build in a break before 6. Are we good? Yes. Just real quickly, I want to thank you guys, Mr. Mayor and the council. Appreciate the dialogue. I want to thank the community.
1:17:57 These things are always, you know, different perspectives and opinions, and I appreciate them all. But at the end of the day, you center down around scenario two. Now we'll go back to and build that out and flesh that out and bring it back to you with some deep meat on the bones and go from there. So I appreciate it and thank you. Thank you. With that, we will adjourn until six.
1:20:14 Dan, is Linda hiding behind the partition back there, or is she in another room? Well, I got everybody here but the council. I'm in no hurry today. Yeah. Mr. Mayor, you want to get the consent agenda done? Well, why don't we just go ahead and open this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council and do a roll call, please. Council Member Hawke? Here. Council Member Hawke? Here. Council Member Hawke? Here. Council Member Hawke? Here. Council Member Hawke? Here. Here.
1:21:14 Yeah, yes, me too. Okay, moving on to the Pledge of Allegiance. Dan is going to lead us in the pledge tonight. Thank you, Dan. Moving on to public comments.
1:21:50 This is the time any member of the public wishes to make a comment on anything that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. I'm Robert Yoki. I'm the president of the Mammoth Museum as well as owner of the gallery at Twin Lakes. In regards to a possible land convenience deal between the town of Mammoth Lakes and the United States Forest Service, the board of directors of the Mammoth Museum would like to tell you that we fully support this idea.
1:22:22 Museum requests that the building that we currently occupy, the Hayden Cabin, as well as the property and the grounds that we sit on Long Mammoth Creek, to be included in that potential conveyance. Our museum could better serve the public if the town was our landlord. We understand that Congressman Paul Cook's office is waiting to get a land conveyance proposal from the town manager's office here, so I ask Mayor Sauser to put this item on the next agenda so the council can bring it up for discussion.
1:22:51 And then we would ask the Council to authorize the Town Manager, Dan Holler, to prepare the proposal and to deliver it to Congressman Cook's office as soon as possible. Robert, thank you. Any other member of the public wishing to make a comment in public comments? I will then close public comments and move on. Dan, I'm assuming no, not that I would let you put one in, but no additions to the agenda. Thank you. Reports from commissions and or departments as needed.
1:23:27 Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Director. A couple of updates. The Planning and Economic Development Commission met last week. They considered a zoning code amendment and a general plan amendment for housing density bonus changes, and they did recommend approval of that to the Town Council, so that will be on your March 4th agenda. They also discussed the potential 1% TOT tax.
1:23:51 Ballot measure. They had a number of different comments that Dan will be presenting to you on March 4th as well, but it was a good discussion.
1:24:01 I think their information will be helpful to the Council. Also, a brief update on the parcel. We conducted interviews with developers last week. We narrowed it down to two. Grady will be visiting one of the developers' offices next week, and then we will come back and do some final decision-making and then come back to Council with a recommendation. And I'm happy to answer any questions about any of those items. Once we select a developer, what's the time frame for...
1:24:31 Breaking ground. I mean, I think that we're looking for entitlements next year, entitlements this year, next year, completing our entitlements next year, and then looking to try to break ground as early, hopefully, as the end of 2022, 2023. I think that would be ideal. I keep asking that question for the public's benefit because I get asked a lot. Right, right. When are they going to turnkey? I think we'll, as we go through the process, we'll know more once we kind of...
1:25:00 Narrow everything down. I think we'll have more detailed dates. Thank you. Thank you. Evening. Mayor, Council, staff, community members have a few updates from Parks and Rec. I'm just going to start with kind of our department reorganisation. We've been busy the last several months. I just want to give you a brief update on where we're at and where we're going.
1:25:29 So the reorganisation really kind of expands on 2015-16 when we merged parks maintenance with recreation. So we became the Parks and Recreation Department. So we're continuing that expansion. The primary focus has always been on delivering core services, and that's combined with the systematic management and maintenance of our amenities. And the big one, with the opening of the Community Recreation Centre in the summer of 2021, necessitates this reorganisation.
1:25:56 So recent staffing changes we've made has been the promotion of parks maintenance worker Marco Macias to the lead parks maintenance worker. We recently promoted recreation supervisor Katrina Kelly to the recreation manager position. We're currently recruiting for the new recreation supervisor to oversee our recreation programming. And then in the next year, we're looking at recruiting a new supervisor to oversee the programming and operations
1:26:26 Primarily of the new Community Recreation Centre. So that's kind of our change. So right now there's no net increase in staffing of number of people. It's just realigned, repositioned them to maximise their effect and the input on our department. We have a team of superstars, as you know, if you've been by. We really value teamwork, we strive for excellence, and we hold each other accountable to the high standards our department culture expects and demands. So thank you for your support.
1:26:55 In programming news, I know John just left. He's a team, he's a member of Team Feisty. They played in the final last night against just the tip. It's the Adult Hockey League final that was last night. Unfortunately, they lost 5-4, sadly. But any time next year, they'll hopefully get back on the ice again. Semi-finals of the Curling League schedules tonight, and the finals will be on Sunday night. This Friday is free skate night at the ice rink.
1:27:22 And anybody that wears their favourite NHL jersey will receive a complimentary hot chocolate on us. It's also a hockey weekend across America. So we're trying to partner with that and promote hockey as well. And then if you're at the rink this weekend, some highs, some lows. I'll cover the highs. So Mammoth Lakes Youth Hockey hosted the President's Day tournament. This was supported by the special event funding and their program. It's a big fundraiser for them.
1:27:49 Really want to kind of personally acknowledge Patrick Bernard, the President. I know he's been before you, you know, several times speaking about, you know, tournaments and the needs for, you know, these type of events in our community and certainly a facility to maintain and support these wonderful tournaments. Also want to recognise Vice President Chris Hodges, Secretary Paul Jeffrey, the entire coaching staff, all the volunteers, the referees that came out, staff and CAT, really for going above and beyond.
1:28:18 Under really trying conditions. So the rink essentially melted each day. We covered it as best we can, but in the middle of the rink was liquid. So we weren't able to really host many evening games. They were all done from 6am to 10am in the morning. So that was our whole president's weekend. But again, everyone had a fantastic time. We valued the economic impact at probably around $100,000. 16 teams came from around the state.
1:28:45 The winning team is actually the Pasadena Maple Leafs. Ironically, their home rink is a sprung structure as well. I thought that was very telling. Sadly, though, due to summer in the Sierra this winter, the ice rink can only operate in the evening and we're scheduled to close on Sunday, March 1st. Looking ahead, just quickly, USports funding application period is open February 24th, which is Monday.
1:29:11 Applications close on March 13 for the Tony Colisato Scholarship Fund, where if you do jump on that website, you can now make an online donation. And we received a very generous donation from Andrea on behalf of Tony to that fund recently as well. So we're really proud of that program and the impact we'll be able to make on our community. So really exciting. And our Summer Recreation Expo is on March 31st at the High School Gym.
1:29:37 Finally, the bid posting for the Community Recreation Centre is scheduled for Friday, February 28th. We'll be back in front of Council on March 4th with an update to Council. And also Matt from MLR will make a presentation on fundraising for that facility. So that's all I had. Thank you. Any questions? Questions? Just March 4th, will you be announcing the results of the bids or no? Just an update on what's in the bid. So what we're actually bidding for.
1:30:09 And then Matt will be making his presentation regarding kind of campaign fundraising. And when does the town anticipate that there'll be the results of the bids? I think we'll be back in April. I think Hayes is looking at kind of the 45-day process. The school goes out to bid on March 6th. So we're trying to time those two bids together. That's a pretty large bid as well. So from an economy scale and awareness, we're trying to capture some larger contractors looking to come in the area. That's why we're doing that date.
1:30:41 Thank you. Thank you, Stu. Good evening, Town Council. Rob Patterson, Admin Services Finance Director. Very exciting news. I wanted to tell you about our upcoming budget calendar. As you know, we're beginning fiscal year 2021 budget preparation. We'll be before you, actually this week I'm putting together instructions for department heads, which we'll talk about service level discussion and parameters around the budget. We will have
1:31:13 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:31:43 The preliminary and the town manager tentative, which will happen in May, and then the final budget adoption, which we're targeting for June 3rd. So again, we're doing a little bit less than we did last year. We had quite a bit more workshops and discussion, and we're kind of narrowing it down into a more concise process. So hopefully that's going to work for us all, but we'll be done hopefully by June 3rd.
1:32:09 Are you going to have the opportunity like you did last year for department heads to come and kind of speak to council about their departments and budget, that sort of thing? We certainly can. That's not in the plan at the moment, but we're developing the plan, so if that's a request, and Dan and I will talk about it, we certainly can do that. I think it was really beneficial for them to present last year. It really worked well. I mean, I personally enjoyed it, and I also think it gives the department heads an opportunity.
1:32:38 Showcase their department and talk about their good work and their plans, but I don't know how the rest of the council feels about that. Any other questions? So the snow removal budget, does that get carried forward, that money that was set aside for this year? So the snow removal budget does remain in what we call gas tax fund 210. That will carry forward to the next year, and it's important to do that because we end up with, you know, we'll get
1:33:08 We have revenue next year that supports half of the expenditures for the current year, so I don't expect more than a very small amount of money next year, and so we need to carry that forward in case we have a bigger year. So the gas tax fund is always a year behind? The revenue for snow removal is always a year behind, yes. There is other gas tax elements that are sort of on par and scheduled. Thank you. Moving on from that, we will go to consent agenda.
1:33:43 Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of February 5 and accept payment approval reports number 2027. I'll make a motion to approve consent agenda items 2 and 3. Motion to second any further deliberation. Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Passes 5-0. We will now move into public hearings. I will.
1:34:15 Open the public hearing to approve by resolution the 2020-2021 Park and Recreation Department fee schedule amendments. Stu, if you'd like to start us out here. Thank you, Mayor. Just a little brief introduction. So we're here before you at this time every year, as you know in February, to approve by resolution the 2021 Parks and Recreation Department fee schedule amendments. So the department annually reviews and recommends appropriate fees.
1:34:44 For the many youth and adult summer camps and programs, including the establishment of fees for facility reservations. These fees are presented to the Recreation Commission and Town Council for approval. This happens after an extensive and exhaustive analysis of the services, the costs reasonably borne of providing those services, the beneficiaries of those services, and the revenues produced by those paying fees and charges for special services. On December 3rd, 2019, the Recreation Commission by consensus approved
1:35:12 The 2020 Parks and Recreation Department Annual Programming Menu, and recently on February 4th, by motion, accepted the fee schedule amendments before you. Proposed fee amendments aligned with the Consumer Price Index, CPI in the Los Angeles area. In 2019, the CPI rose 3%. Based on this growth and historical changes to our fees, staff is proposing to increase certain fees that are directly impacted by CPI, such as summer camps and programs, by a modest 2%.
1:35:43 Staff has provided an overview of the proposed fee schedule in your packet. We provided an overview of kind of the changes in the staff report. Happy to go through them with you if you need to. With the proposed fee amendments bolded and highlighted in yellow in Exhibit B. Happy to answer any questions regarding this item. Thank you. Questions for Stu? Just real quick, the CPI index is from Los Angeles? Los Angeles, yep. Is that what the town uses as the standard benchmark? We use that every year.
1:36:13 Every year? Every year. CPI index for? Los Angeles. Los Angeles County or City or? Los Angeles area? Yeah, it's a broader area. It's a broader area. But that's used for their fee analysis. Some of the other areas have different indexes based on the post. And that was at 3%. And it's what they call the all-urban consumers. It's a CPIU. And that talks about the rise. It speaks a little bit about it in the staff report there. So that's pretty much our standard. You know, we just look at that and just...
1:36:41 If we keep that 2%, then we just keep track of those expenses. Thank you. So that's typically how we manage it. First on the community centre fees? Yep. So we had never before charged for the setup or deposit with alcohol. I mean, those are new charges this year? So interestingly, we actually had a key deposit at the community centre as well, and then we changed the door code lock, so we kind of eliminated that as well. So we have... I'm going to just go to this sheet. I know you've got a really small one. I apologise. I probably should have had a...
1:37:10 Bigger one. Oh, no, these are plenty big. You're okay? Oh, good. So we have set up charge, a large group surcharge there. We have a deposit with alcohol at $300, deposit without alcohol at $150. So that's kind of... She was asking are those new. No, they've always been there.
1:37:32 Oh, okay. So it doesn't show last year. It's just this is the new one. We haven't changed those. The only one we've changed is that kind of rental fee up 2% to $22.50 and $28. Okay. And then we don't, like you said, charge that key deposit anymore. We've added a little bit on tournament rental fees. Typically, we provide staff for that. So there's additional costs. So we're just trying to recapture that cost of providing those services. And then most of the changes you can really see, apart from facilities, are really kind of our program. So that's essentially our summer camps.
1:38:01 Those programs just go up by 2% every year. Other questions? Seeing no questions, anyone from the public have any questions or comments on this? Seeing none, I will close the public hearing and move on to deliberations or whatever council desires. It just looked very reasonable to me. Would someone like to make a motion in that case? I could do a motion.
1:38:36 I can make a motion that we approve by resolution the 2021 Parks and Recreation Department fee schedule amendments. I have a second. I have a second. First, any second? Any further deliberation? Jamie, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Passes 5-0. Thank you. Moving on to policy matters.
1:39:04 Yes. Mr. Mayor, I'm going to recuse myself on this item. MLTPA has a tangential relationship, I think, in the interest of transparency and perceived conflicts. I'm going to step out on this one. Thank you, June. John is stepping out. I think there's a song, a whole musical, in fact. Okay. Sandra. Thank you. The item before you tonight is the consideration of a consulting agreement with...
1:39:37 Place Works Incorporated for Climate Adaptation and Resilience Assessment Services. As described in your staff report, the town was awarded a multi-year grant, a little over $600,000 from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. The grant is funding a variety of different items, including planning, public outreach, and preliminary project identification to enhance our region's recreational amenities. This project before you, the
1:40:07 This consulting agreement before you will result in one component of that grant being satisfied. So this is the, as described in the scope of work that's attached, this is the resiliency strategies and environmental assessment analysis. So staff recommends that you enter into this contract and authorize the town manager to sign this agreement. And I'm happy to answer any questions you have. Also we have Christy Williams here from MLTPA.
1:40:36 Who's happy to speak on kind of any details of this project as well. So then that completes my presentation. I'm happy to answer any questions. So what will be the output of this process? The output will be climate adaptation and resilience strategies.
1:40:55 This will be looking at an economic, we will have an economic model, so a natural capital assessment, so value for kind of everything that's around here, so we will have a value kind of for our recreation amenities. Also, there will be recommendations for preserving those, so recommendations.
1:41:11 Different types of recommendations. I don't quite know what the results will be at this point because we're just kind of kicking this off. But as a note, PlaceWorks is also the consulting firm that did prepare our safety element for the general plan. And so some of the work that they've done in this will be in the general plan work will be able to utilize for this project. And then Christy can answer any of the questions. One of the key elements on that too is an informing document. We start to look at projects and we look at down the road of what the outcome of the overall grant is.
1:41:41 How do we line those up to make sure those projects are also then in line with the environmental and the resiliency planning that's been done here in identification that way? So we're working in sync as we look to the future sustainability of the region. My one question under on page 92, the data needs, the recreational use data includes the number of visitors and recreational uses. Who's going to be
1:42:14 Gathering that information because from earlier conversations this is going to help in a lot of different ways so I just want to know the game plan for who's going to be leading the charge to be able to get that data. I think the plan is that MLTPA will do as much as they can to gather data for the consultant to try to keep the cost down because this is not to exceed contract so MLTPA will be reaching out and trying to pull this data some of the data we have so we have
1:42:43 We have data about skier visits. We have data about campgrounds, kind of that type of stuff. But the missing components, MLTPA will be working to track that down as much as they can. And then the consultant would step in and kind of do some more data gathering. Beautiful. Thank you. How does Mammoth Mountain fit into this? I don't see them mentioned once.
1:43:08 I mean, they're not a part of this analysis, but they clearly are, you know, a partner in this project. I mean, clearly we're going to be asking them for data. We'll be analyzing their impacts. Mm-hmm. Looking for information, too. Yeah, right. Clearly they're a recreation amenity. It's in our area. I just didn't see it. It doesn't seem to be mentioned in here. They're not called out specifically. They would be a recreational amenity and a...
1:43:36 I'm not a partner out there, but there are several different other agencies that aren't called out specifically that we would be getting out. Amanda Mountain isn't. They're not, no, along with others that are not. They're their biggest employer, it seems that they should be called out as participating in this and analyzing the impacts. Any other questions? Comments? No. Anyone in the public wishing to comment on this?
1:44:16 Hi, Christy Williams, the Project Manager for the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative. I don't have too much to add, just Sandra and Dan led the charge in getting this teed up, but they have kept me in the loop, and I feel good about it. We've really beat up the scope. I feel that it will allow us to...
1:44:38 Produce the deliverable that's required in the grant. Matt Driscoll is with the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. He's here. He's reviewed it as well. And I think we're teeing it up to get some good work done. As a reminder, my job is to make sure we're on time, we're on budget, and that we're producing good work. And I'm confident that this agreement is the right contractor, and it's going to be the right deliverables. Quick answer to your question about Mammoth Mountain, they're on Forest Service land.
1:45:08 A lot of the environmental data, I believe, will be coming from Forest Service documents as well. They won't participate necessarily in giving input, but if there's information we need from them, then absolutely, we would track that down. But it would be up to the PlaceWorks consultants to aggregate that and put it in their report. Thank you. Does that answer it?
1:45:32 Well, you keep using the term aggregate, and, you know, when I see aggregate on page five mentioned seven times, my understanding is we're going to have to look at everybody to get the aggregate impacts of climate change, that from ESTA to Mammoth Mountain to their buses, and are we going to switch to electric buses?
1:45:58 And as a reminder, this is a regional effort. And so Manzanar is in it. Yosemite is in the region, right? Like there's a lot of big players in the region. And so calling out Mammoth Mountain maybe wasn't quite appropriate at this stage.
1:46:12 But we are absolutely, those are the partners of the partnership. It's the Forest Service, it's the counties, the national parks, the state parks, they're all sitting at the table with us, BLM, DMV, and, or not DMV, Caltrans, Sierra Nevada Conservancy. And so, yes, they are all, think of it as a geographical region. And our understanding from PlaceWorks is that
1:46:38 You know, the science is the science. And so when we say aggregate, like the science doesn't really change. It is what it is, and a lot of the data is there, but they're going to look at it from a sustainable recreation and tourism perspective. And that's the difference. It's regional and it's specific to sustainable recreation and tourism. Just to be clear, I have very...
1:46:56 We strongly support this. I mean, we need these climate models to be able to make intelligent decisions on purchases for equipment and every other thing, as well as potential solar fuel down at the airport since that land has been disturbed. We are so excited to see the results. And Cleland, to your point, like, it's just super relevant. And this report will belong to you, right? I mean, you will be able to use it for so many other efforts. I sat in on your previous workshop.
1:47:25 It will be really great for that as well. So, Christy, would it be accurate to say then that whatever information that the permittees are required to give to the Forest Service over time for the years or whatever when these permits are held, we will have access to that data as part of this study?
1:47:47 I think that's accurate. I've hesitated to dive too far into the project, and so so much of this is we don't quite know what we're going to get into, as Sandra mentioned, but we already have, like, Region 5 in the Forest Service has significant data, and we already have access to that. We're talking frequently with Tammy Randall Parker's office, specifically for INYO, and not to mention the national parks have significant data.
1:48:15 Mammoth Mountain will have very specific ski or visit data and some recreation use data, but we're excited to pull information and have them, these experts, put it together and tell us what we've got and what we need to do. Because if that feels challenging, the time for us to get, this I think is a really great way to at least see it, as you said, in the aggregate so we know what's going on. Yes, exactly, as a region. As a reminder, it's a regional effort.
1:48:41 Unfortunately, in their contract with the Forest Service, as I understand it, and I have asked these questions very recently, anything the Mountain considers proprietary information that they have to give to the Forest Service cannot be given back out to third party. So there may be some things we well want to know from the Mountain that we have no leverage to actually achieve. We'll see. That's a good heads up. Yeah, I wasn't aware of that. But if we do need to...
1:49:10 Track stuff down that they are willing to share. That is a role that I think MLTPA would play. That said, if they're a privately owned company, right? They don't necessarily have to share everything. Thank you. Any further questions or comments? I am aware of the same relationship. I'll go ahead and make a motion that we authorize a consulting agreement with PlaceWorks, Inc. for climate adaptation and resilience assessment services. Second.
1:49:39 I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Passes 4-0. Thank you. If someone would like to tell John he can come back in now.
1:50:09 You're not supposed to tell them. Just kidding. Sorry, Jamie. Kirk was trying to not give you the heads up. Oh, good. Good. On live television? To an audience of about 12? And a half. And a half? Right. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yes, sir. Moving on to policy item number six, provide direction regarding town position on SB 54 and AB 1080.
1:50:38 Dan. Yes, Mr. Mayor. Both these bills are identical bills in two sides of the legislature. They deal with placing restrictions on or creating a framework for managing plastic pollution and waste through what's being manufactured, what's coming out of the products and things of that nature. It kind of walks through that, a lot of the single package type items and, you know, how do you reduce
1:51:05 We've got both bills here because they were designed to be companion bills, if you will, on both sides of the House and the Senate. They've actually
1:51:35 I think have been sent to the opposite houses, so comments on the assembly bill will go to the Senate side and vice versa on the Senate bill. For that, there's a couple of draft letters in here taking a couple tweaks for the town perspective, but basically in line with recommendations from the League of California Cities. I think there's a fair amount of support from the cities and counties in terms of managing this side of the recycling stream of waste coming into the...
1:52:01 Questions or comments? Well, the comment is, I think the
1:52:33 This is weak in the extreme. Giving him 10 years to do something we took, what, five years to win World War II, I think is ridiculous. You're asking Cal Recycle to do the work, so 10 years may be a... I think it's sad. I think it's just pathetic. So, yeah, of course I'm in favor of the letter, but I think it's ridiculous. Any other comments? I support Linda's comments.
1:52:59 Well, my first knee-jerk reaction when I read use of the single-use containers, I asked Dan if this means I have to go from buying six packs of beer to kegs. Of course. That's at least you can do. Because that would eliminate the single-use container. With that, I would ask for a motion. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve and submit to the appropriate venue in the State of California letters of support for the two
1:53:29 State bills as identified.
1:53:33 Does that work?
1:53:34 I have a motion.
1:53:37 I'll second it.
1:53:38 I have a motion and a second.
1:53:40 Any further deliberation?
1:53:43 Jamie?
1:53:44 Yes.
1:53:46 Yes.
1:53:47 Yes.
1:53:49 Yes.
1:53:51 Passes 5-0.
1:53:53 With that, we will move on to Councilmember Reports.
1:53:58 Go ahead, Cleland. Okay, on February 14th, along with Mayor Bill Sauser, I attended the ESTA meeting, and it was very interesting. And then on February 18th, along with the rest of the council, I attended the special joint meeting with the county supervisors and the town council. That's my report. Who would like to go next? Kirk?
1:54:28 Sure. I asked several questions from Edison at that meeting as to, you know, what are the actions? What are you doing? So I did get a letter back. Oh, good. And it's very evasive. So they have not nailed down anything in the letter. So anyway, they at least said they were going to write me, and they did. Okay. And so I got nothing.
1:54:55 Also, the Treasurer's Oversight Committee, I sat through that meeting on February 13th, and, you know, they really, he really does an excellent job, you know, and all I can say, he does an excellent job. My only criticism is that, you know, from Orange County back in the 70s, you know,
1:55:22 Lost all their money because they were gambling, basically. And now we have to be so conservative that the average interest rate is about 2.5%. I mean, I would trust Rob to be able to do better than that or just about anybody on town staff. Anyway, that's my report, other than I'm a little frustrated at the interest levels. John.
1:55:50 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. On February 10th, I participated in the Turns for Tony, Turns for Tony Colisardo. I challenged the great, I channeled the great spirit and soul of Mr. Colisardo, brought all of us with us on that thing. It was great. I miss Tony. I think we all do. But his spirit shines bright. February 14th, I attended the ESCOG meeting with Councilmember Salcido. The ESCOG is now a joint powers authority.
1:56:20 It exists. It lives. It breathes. There's a fair amount of work to do to get it kind of up and running. Stacey Corliss is the chair. Karen Schwartz is the vice chair. I want to thank Dan Holler and a whole cadre of lawyers that are out there somewhere in space who helped kind of bring this whole thing together. So that's a good step forward. February 14th, I attended a meeting, again, with Councilmember Salcido. You may have things to add to all this.
1:56:51 Linda, myself, the District Ranger, the Forest Supervisor, the Town Manager. We had a very good and constructive meeting, a frank meeting on a number of topics. A number of items came out of that. I'm going to try to get my notes and my minutes back to Dan and the group so we can follow up on those things. But I do want to, Mr. Yoki's comment about agendizing that land conveyance. That was very particular and specific.
1:57:18 Point of discussion in that meeting, and I think we need to get that agendized, we need to start moving on that. So I would support, if that's the pleasure of the Mayor to bring that forward, I would support that. That was my report, thank you. Linda. Everything that John said, except I wasn't at ESCOG, because I was... Oh, that's right, you weren't there. I wasn't there, but I was there that afternoon for the Forest Service meeting. Right.
1:57:40 But on the 11th, February 11th, I spent the day with staff and some community members in talking to three potential developer builders and a great day, really good solid presentations by some very talented people and I look forward to the next steps and that as we've eliminated or we've moved on now with two potential and had some more questions that came up after that but it was a good
1:58:06 A very good day. And the 14th and yesterday and Mammoth Voices, I attended Mammoth Voices, which was on the 6th and that was the candidates for District 2, Rhonda Dugan and
1:58:23 Josh Rhodes, who were the two candidates, and now there is another candidate who has thrown their hat in the ring for a writing candidate, so that will get more interesting, but that was a very good meeting and well attended, and I think that is, well, we all went to the joint meeting yesterday, so that's it. Thank you. Okay, I was allowed by our esteemed leader over there, Dan, to attend a department head meeting on, I think it was the 13th.
1:58:53 And I find those always enjoyable to get a chance to interact with our staff. I attended the ESTA meeting. We did discuss, I got started on a strategic plan. Sorry, a little brain issue there. And it'll be interesting to see how that is going to play out moving forward. And I attended the joint meeting with the supervisors and found that interesting as well. And that is it for me.
1:59:27 That's it for us. Thank you, buddy. Well, I told, I told, then we'd get out of here at 7.30, so I guess we're going to have to have a sing-along. No, I don't, no, I don't think we're going to have a sing-along. With that, I will close this meeting of the Town Council. Thank you all. Good job. Yeah, I missed the department of meeting, and I missed desk.