TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2020

Town Council

· recording 3 hr 57 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

482 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Hello? Can you hear me? Yes. Oh, hi. I'm the attorney for Mr. Marari. I just was checking to see if I've linked in properly. I'd say you're in, and anybody who's not ready, please mute themselves until the time comes, because we'll have... Okay, sure. No worries. I thought I'd let you know. Yeah. Okay, thank you. It's a little bit of a new adventure here with the Zoom conferencing, but... I understand. We're all learning, so...

0:47 I appreciate that. Thank you very much. You betcha. Thanks for the date catch. Let's see how it works. You can see it's a city council. I want to just show you. You can see city council. It's a town meeting. That's where we're. She's a mammoth. She's a mammoth. Rosie. Excuse me, sir. You may want to mute yourself. Okay, sure. I'm sorry. We can all hear what you're saying. So you just may want to hit that mute button. Okay, I'm sorry. No.

1:59 Mine with us. So it looks like we're waiting for Kirk still? Yes, I was just on the phone with Kirk, and he is actually on his way down to the chamber. She's having some technical difficulties getting on, so he's going to be joining in Sweet Z. Okay. And for the appeal hearing that is later on, I think the attorney may have, I'm sorry, I don't know your name, has joined for this meeting.

2:46 This first probably two hours is going to be budget presentation. If you'd like to call in at six o'clock, it might be closer to the time frame of when we'd be addressing that. Not that I don't want you to listen to me for two hours, but. No, no, no, no, that's fine. I appreciate that. I had assumed, because I've done a lot of council work over the years, but I'd assume for what I saw on the agenda that you were just going to have the approval of the meeting.

3:14 And so that would not, it would go pretty quickly, but I'll call in at six and I'll tell Mr. Marari to call in at six then too. Thank you. Okay, appreciate it. Thanks so much. Hey Rob, this is Phillip on the Inyo. 6.30 was the time that I was told for our piece of it, but has that changed? Yeah, no, Phil, that still can be about right. It'll be about that timeframe, maybe a little before, but probably not. Okay, I'll be back around six o'clock.

3:43 Yeah. Thank you. Should we call in at about, what, 615? Is that more likely than 6? 6 will work. Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you. Bye. I don't know how to get out. On the bottom right should be a leave button. Dan, are you the only one in Sweet Z at this point? Don't forget me. Jamie's here. Ah, Jamie. Yes. Yeah, but Jamie, I can't see you.

4:40 She has control of the cameras, so you don't get to. Sandra, are you in your office or at home? I'm at home. I'm at home. Thank you. I want to figure out how to make mine work. I can help you. I would love that. I have a beautiful picture of Mammoth Mountain without chair three or the gondolas or any of that on it that I would love to have as my background, but I haven't figured it out yet. All right. I'll find the time and I'll help you put it up there. All right. Bill, I'll come over and set it up and it'll be a picture of me.

5:23 Mind you. Good. Rob, a picture of you at this point would have too much reflection. Yeah, but Rob, you know he's running Windows 2 over there, right? Hey, according to my computer, I have a touchscreen. Can you feel it? Okay. Well, I sort of compelled to go ahead and start this thing, and Kirk will just join us when he gets here.

6:01 Jamie, roll call, please. Councilmember Hoff. Here. Councilmember Stapp is absent. Councilmember Wentworth. Here. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Here. Mayor Souser. Here. Senator, would you like to lead us in the pledge? Sure. Please rise and join me in reciting the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic.

6:34 For which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Thank you. Public comments, Jamie, other than those that we received in the packet, which I am assuming are up on the site? Yes, they're on the website. No additional public comments. Okay. So you all have those.

7:07 I need more space. Who's going to come and build me a bigger office? Agenda item one is our workshop. First, we don't have any additions, do we, Dan? We do not. And reports from commissions and or departments. Yeah, Grady. Thank you. Yes, we do have several. I'll get to them pretty quickly. We also have Hayes on the line and some of the engineering stuff. The two that I'll report on is one at the airport.

7:40 We have received bids for all three projects that we've talked about. Two of them will come before you on June 3rd, the Taxi Lane and the Taxi Away projects together on June 17th, which is the security gates and fencing. We do have an FAA meeting tomorrow by phone and Zoom, of course, to talk about leadership and their progress. And I've already let MLT know, Mr. Erdi, know that immediately after that meeting, I'm going to request that we get some kind of an update on...

8:08 Where we're going and what's happening down in Bishop and what we look at for air service for this coming year or whatever he knows at that time. So that's the airport update, but you'll hear more in your next meeting. The other is with the parcel. We had another of our biweekly regular updates today. It went very well. Again, I already have a draft agreement that Andy has sent me and I've gotten most of the way through it and I'll set up a time for Andy to go through that.

8:36 And they are still pushing forward on what they expect to be able to do from an environmental standpoint. We're starting some of the on-site surveys for cultural and biology. So yeah, we're making some good progress there. And we do expect a formal agenda item on June 3rd, a presentation from the team on the progress on the parcel and what you can expect. With that, I'd like to turn it over to Hayes to talk about some of the engineering and road aspects.

9:04 Hey, it's finished with the lakes basin at the end because that would be will be the one that will be more most complicated, I guess is the best way to put it. So go ahead. Thank you. Yeah, we'll save the most exciting for last. So we've got a lot of work going on in town. We did see a lot of the development work kind of fall off with the private, the encroachments, the utility stuff is just moving right along. And we've seen a lot of applications going through.

9:34 Of note, the elementary school is going to be doing some trenching work to tie in a water line. We will have some significant traffic controls out on Meridian Boulevard in front of the elementary school here in the next few weeks while they do that tie-in. On Old Mammoth Road, the 540 project is going to be tying in a sewer line. They're going to be closing the center lane for about two weeks. That work is scheduled to begin on June 1st.

10:00 There will be temporary travel lane closures, but that'll be flagged and managed, and the roads would be open in the evening with plates. We also anticipate a fair amount of utility work throughout town. Most of that will be limited to the shoulders, but a lot of telephone pole repairs, some switch gear going in for SCE, and that's going to be throughout town. I was asked to touch on the signals.

10:26 Of note, the Minaret and Meridian signal, we have that currently in flash. That was our choice to do so. We've actually received a lot of positive feedback. That signal does, most times, can be just a stop sign. And we'll probably leave it in recall until we see an uptick in visitation. The old Mammoth Road and Meridian signal, we have had that signal rewired to fix a number of shorts. We have had it reprogrammed.

10:54 It worked better, but at the end of the day, we found out our pedestrian controller had failed. So we had a delay in the signal. It would actually, you'd have to pull off to get a green light, red light, and it would wait for heads that, whether or not they hit the button to go through. And that's why that signal was running so slow. So we made the choice to put that in flash because we didn't have a lot of traffic. We are prepared to put that back and turn it on. It works safely. It's just a little slow.

11:21 This weekend, if we do see an uptick in visitation, we have ordered the new controller. It's supposed to be shipped and received next week, and we will install that right away and flip the switch on that signal. We took delivery of our new loader and blower on Friday, and we have the president of Kodiak here as we tested it up at Internet Vista today. I have to report that thing is running great, no issues. We haven't named it yet, but we'll let you know when we do.

11:51 We are continuing a healthy amount of road work throughout town. Nothing major, a lot of pothole repair. You've seen the paint crews out. We paint the entire town every year. Just want the public to know, just kind of keep an eye out for those guys. They're everywhere. And we haven't had any major failures, so that was great. Last, the Lakes Basin. Grady and I have spent a lot of time talking with our partners about the Lakes Basin, the Forest Service.

12:20 The ski area, the contractor's working. Contractor Arbor Works working for SCE and some of the principal space work. I think it's upwards of 2,000 trees. Talk to those guys. They're willing to work with the town. They're working quickly to get out of here. Those of you who have been up there have probably seen the significant tree plow in the slash piles. They will not be working on Sunday or Monday of this weekend.

12:49 They will no longer be working on our bike path other than isolated tree falls and so forth that they can't avoid. Our crews are up there working fixing signs, fences, some of the guardrail. Warren and his crew cleared the path all the way to Poconobe as of this morning and swept it. And we'll work next week to clear all the way to Horseshoe. There is still some snow out there, some snow fields that need to be navigated.

13:18 And it's better to let those melt out before we try to do it. We are policing at the request of the U.S. Forest Service dumpsters and porta-potties at a specified location. And that will be to supplement what's already up there with SCE. SCE does not have a problem, excuse me, SCE's contractor does not have an issue with the public using their facilities. They're not going to be the porta-potty police. But we're going to manage the situation jointly and try to provide facilities for.

13:47 The public. We are going to take some measures this weekend. We do not know what this weekend will bring, Memorial Day, Holiday. So we're going to just prepare for a normal non-COVID type weekend. We spoke with the ski area and they have left on Amarac parking as a lot to help manage any space and traffic. We're seeing additional signage right now. No parking.

14:16 And we're going to place some signage to direct people into Tamarack to park as overflow and try to manage it. We do have crews on staff the entire weekend that will be kind of running around town making sure that everything is in place and we'll call audibles as necessary working with the PD to manage traffic if things get out of hand. And we're taking similar measures at the gate down in Old Man's Brook that typically doesn't see as much traffic other than people hitting the Rob Trail.

14:46 One last thing, we are working with the Forest Service to schedule a meeting with our partners. That's the usual Reds Meadow Lakes Basin concessionaire kind of partner meeting. We are having that next week on the 28th where I'm hoping we'll have some more information on the opening dates and so forth that we can provide to the public. With that, if there's any questions, I'll do whatever I can. Yeah, I do have a question, Hayes.

15:16 On the signal at Minaret and Meridian, that has been a problem. I have actually gotten a couple of very thankful calls from bicyclists who can now get through the intersection. You know, I drive a very large motorcycle, and it won't trip that light either. I know there's a sensor in the ground. Can we get it marked in such a way that those of us on vehicles can actually know where it is to drive over it to get that light to change?

15:45 I can't tell you how many times I've just blown the red light because my bike wouldn't make a change. I don't see Al on, so I think you're okay. But, yeah, we'll take a look at that. We actually had a professional signal company come up and do some testing and some work on that signal. And so it should function better once we flip it. And we can set the timing a little bit different if it doesn't work as anticipated.

16:13 We're also working on a contract with that company to do regular maintenance on it so it doesn't, some of the sensors get a little wonky with the wind and the weather and then they just don't trigger as well. So we're going to be working towards a maintenance contract to make sure that it's regularly adjusted, if you will. Thank you. John, did I see you had a question? Yes, Mr. Mayor, thank you very much. Dan, it's kind of a question for you and for Grady and for Hayes. We went through a very,

16:45 Interesting process around Forest Service closures, Lakes Basin, Resmeta Road, all that kind of stuff. It sounds like things are getting deployed. I'm just wondering who on the town side is going to be kind of the point of contact and accountability and management for all that stuff as we go forward. Is that going to stay in public works? Is that going to be with Stu? Is that going to be with you? Just as we all have to, there may be audibles and things we have to deal with. How do you see that working?

17:13 Yeah, we actually talk quite a bit and Hayes will raise his hand and say in terms of operationally what the town is doing in support, that's him. If any conversations do occur outside of that, either yourself or Gordon talks to Dan, everybody's on board to make sure we all have the same information, but the single point of contact for the detail will be Hayes with clearly Dan, anything he hears from the Forest Service, we'll pass along and coordinate it. That sound good, guys?

17:42 I may have a couple follow-ups for you. Yeah, I'm around. Okay. And for right now, the program is that the gate stays closed, but the Lake Space and Path will be open. Is that the general idea? That is correct. So the Lake Space, everything out there is open to pedestrians, bicycles. Vehicular traffic is limited to folks with gate access. That's our concessionaires.

18:08 And the contractors working in the basin. But everything is open to the public and the contractors and the people working up there will be providing traffic control on both fronts for both the road and the bike path. Okay. And do we anticipate that? Is that the summer's program or is that sort of where we're at for the moment? The last I heard, I think I can report that the contractor is working to be done by the middle of the month. And so that issue will resolve itself and then we'll be working with the Forest Service on.

18:38 An opening date for the public. And I think we'll have more information coming out of our meeting next week that I can report on. Good, because I know there'll be a lot of discussion on sanitation, bathrooms, all that kind of stuff. Oh, it's already started. All right, thank you very much. Thank you, Hayes. Any other questions? I have a couple of questions. Thank you, Hayes. On these porta-potties that we're putting up there, you said there was five of them we're putting around the area.

19:06 The question are, what guidance are we going to follow for sanitation, cleaning, are hand sanitizers going to be available at these sites? The only thing worse than not having a port-a-potty is having a really nasty, gross port-a-potty. So what are the guidelines that we are trying to follow? Yeah, thank you. And that is really critical. Six of the facilities up there are being managed by SCB.

19:35 The town is going to place two or three of our own. The guidance we're giving them is to, of course, have the hand sanitizer in each one of them and that they're to be cleaned every other day. Only every other day? That is the current guidance. We are waiting for the Forest Service. My understanding is they received federal guidelines yesterday that have not been interpreted and handed down to us yet. If that changes, we will follow whatever guidelines they present to us.

20:06 Okay, so these are forest service guidelines for restroom maintenance. Correct. Okay. All right. Well, as long as we got a rule book, that's what counts. Thank you. Anything else? Seeing none, thank you, gentlemen. Any other commissions or departments to report? I will raise my hand. Mayor Sowers, I'll just give you a quick recreation update of all the items that my colleague didn't cover. I'll talk about all the fun stuff. So today,

20:42 Money County, as you know, was approved to transition into expanded stage two. With that, we are going to reopen Vulcan Brothers Skate Park and Shady Rest Park. So we're looking at trying to get those open as early as tomorrow, if we can, fingers crossed, or Friday at the latest. They will have significant and increasing signage regarding mitigation.

21:07 Required distance requirements, hygiene and so forth. So you'll see both those parks with distinctive signage, making sure the public adhere to as best they can, those state guidelines. Other updates, Sierra Star Golf Course opens Friday, Snow Creek Driving Range will also open Friday, Snow Creek Tennis Courts are permitted to open. As we talked about before, public restrooms, Mammoth Creek Park, Charleston Park are open, Mona County Playgrounds and Skate Parks.

21:37 Still closed. With under fire restrictions in both the Humboldt-Tayobi and International Forest. And as we talked about before, Stage 3 includes the Whitmore Pool, our mini playgrounds and our picnic areas. So we'll provide a more detailed update tomorrow on the community conversation at 5.30. And we also have representatives from Mammoth Resort speaking tomorrow night as well about their updates.

22:05 That's all I had at this time. Thank you. Cleland. Hi. Stuart, I have a question for you. I received a phone call. Obviously, we didn't have a town cleanup this year, and somebody was proposing maybe if we had some kind of social distancing cleanup. Has that been talked about? Because that would be you, correct? Yes.

22:36 Town Cleanup is actually part of Sandra's department with Jenna, but we're all kind of doing what we can to make it work. But yeah, no, thanks for the question. We've had a couple of conversations with Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. So they've actually come forward to ask how they can assist in some type of scaled town cleanup day. So we had a conversation this afternoon. We have a meeting on Friday with Mammoth Disposal. So what we really need to understand is what they are capable of helping us do.

23:06 It's certainly not going to be the same scale, but how can the community really come out and if they can grab some bags, you know, clean up some trash and then primarily for defensible space, you know, manage any pine needles and green waste. So that's kind of our priority at this time. Okay, thank you. No, thank you. Any other questions for Stuart? Seeing none, any other commissions or departments? Seeing none, we will move on to the workshop.

23:40 Just please review. Rob. Yes, thank you. So this is really, other than the revenue that we discussed back in March, this is kind of our first time to talk about expenditures and other elements within the budget. And as you can imagine, this year's budget preparation has been really quite difficult as we are really uncertain of when we'll open up as a town, when we certainly will invite guests back in from our transient rental.

24:11 In fact, as was mentioned, we've extended that today again through June 30th. And so it's difficult to say the least. One of the things that the council asked us to do was to bring forward three different scenarios. So what we looking through on a revenue base at different scenarios, we started with what I'll call

24:37 You know, a pretty rough one. And that would be actually the highest level. In your staff report, it's called Path A. And it's, and Jamie, do you have the option to show the presentation? No, Rob, you should share your screen. That's going to be a challenge because I'm on a different device. It doesn't have it on it. You want me to bring it up on mine, Rob? Sure.

25:11 I can try. Okay, I got to get out of this. I've got the PowerPoint version, Mr. Mayor, if you need that, I can do that as well. Yeah, John, if you've got it up already and want to share screen. That's where I'm going to it. Let's see if I'm going to get this. Sorry that I didn't have this squared up in advance, guys. I apologize for that. I thought it was pretty different. One of the things that we've always done, I'll keep talking while you're looking for that, is we've always, we've always

25:52 Budgeted very conservatively. This year, talking a little bit about 1920, that has been very beneficial for us. As you know, we budgeted the TOT revenue at $13.5 million. We had achieved that in slightly more through February, which is about the time everything shut off. And by having those smaller sort of revenue streams, we do constrict the size of our organization.

26:18 We keep ourselves nimble. We keep ourselves... One second. Yep. You got it, John, because I got it as well. How's that? Perfect. Okay, just give me the next slide, Q, Rob. We'll do that. I will do that. And you can go to the next slide. That's the first one with... Okay. So...

26:48 So back to our conservative budgeting, you know, we do that every year basically to keep ourselves lean and able to do that. So for 19 and 20, that was very beneficial because we're able to kind of weather being shut down a little bit and not have to make drastic cuts. I know we've had people in the past want us to really, you know, budget that TOT number up where it's more realistic of what we expect to achieve, but that would have been disastrous for us this year. So I want to keep on that same bent.

27:17 of having conservative and sort of prudent approach to this. So when we started talking about three different scenarios, and I was anticipating 1920, we were trending ahead of our highest TOT year in every month up until February. So to say that we would have ended somewhere with a full year, we would have ended somewhere close to 20 million is not unrealistic at all.

27:47 Right now we're probably going to come in somewhere around 15 and a half to 16. But this budget, we started with the three scenarios. Scenario A, the top line number was 12.5 million. So that would be a million dollars off of what we had in the prior year and almost two million dollars off of what I presented to you in March. And that represents the top line. That represents...

28:12 Opening up here pretty soon, expecting some sort of a hangover and a lag as people sort of get comfortable traveling and may decide to come to Mammoth. And it's a strong winter month and kicking back up in the spring, almost back to normal. So when I do the projections here in front of you on the screen, there are the different scenarios are there that the purple line on top.

28:39 Would be our typical year, our normal year. The line, the blue line is the one I'm talking about right now, path A. And so that's a pretty rosy outlook. I did not feel comfortable presenting you a budget that utilized that as a starting point. And I'll use that term throughout this presentation is this budget is really getting us through the starting gate. And I think it's...

29:04 It's got a few elements of it that are prudent when you talk about budgeting and we'll get to those. The second path, path B, which is the one, by the way, I'm recommending and the one that I built the budget on has a TOT number for 2021 of $11.2 million. And so you can see that's like $7.8 million less than we really anticipated getting this year and it pulled $3 million.

29:31 Plus 3,500,000 less than what I presented to you in March. So that is a pretty deep cut TOT number and presentation. That represents a very, very slow start. So that would have us rolling through the first three months about 30% of capacity or 30% of normal and then picking up to maybe 50% of normal through the fall months and even into the winter months.

30:01 It doesn't start to ramp up into the 60 and 70 percentage rate somewhere around late January into February. And then we do kind of pick up in the spring as if we're making our way out of it. So that would be, that's where I'm comfortable right now is presenting that to you. And it does hinge on a few things. Like, for example, the mountains certainly have to open in the wintertime for this. It basically erases most of the summer.

30:30 And then just has sort of a get back to business approach for the fall. And as I said, the springtime is in pretty good shape. So that's the one I'm recommending. We do have a path C and that would be, you know, where much deeper impact is held. And so that one is about 9.3 million for TOT. And that involves, you know, maybe the mountain having very limited capacity for the wintertime.

30:59 And, or just a second wave that comes in and really requires us to shut down again for a significant period of time. That one, I don't have, the numbers I have in the budget today that we're going to go through are not reflective of that revenue stream and that level. How we're approaching this, and we'll get to this a little bit later as well, is we have trigger points throughout the year, and I've set three of them out there, where we look at

31:28 The performance of the TOT number, and if it's not on target with the 11.2, then depending upon whether it's deeply below or just slightly below, we'll have to make further decisions on constriction and other probably much tougher decisions. The same would go for other guiding factors like whether the mountain decides to not open or is unable to open for some reason, do it on order.

31:57 So we would be making decisions throughout the year. And I think that we've demonstrated the nimbleness to do so. And we're prepared to do that. So I'm very comfortable with, and you can go to the next slide. I'm very comfortable with plan B or path B. And I didn't read through all the different scenarios of why we believe path B is what some of the impacts are. Certainly the international travel, we believe that to be shut down for a period of time.

32:25 And just what those particular elements are. But what I want to do now is pause and get council confirmation that they're comfortable with with path B so we can move on the presentation. Council, just start with Kirk. Driving around town in the council chamber, by the way, driving around town, I mean, everything is empty.

32:54 I think Path B is acceptable, but I think we're going to have to review it in maybe three months to see the impacts of what's happening. That's my comment. Thank you. I accept Rob's presentation, where he's going, but I do think that we need to review this on a quarterly basis. Thank you. Cleland?

33:28 I'm very comfortable with Rob's suggestion. And I hope that that is the way everything pans out. Thank you. Well, actually, I hope it pans out better than that. But yeah, John. Thank you, Rob. I'm looking at all this as some really good work by staff to put together a framework.

33:59 And a range of scenarios for the council to be able to look at as we go into this. None of us have any crystal balls. None of us have any idea what's going to happen. B seems like a good place to start. It's what you're recommending. So it's a good place to start. I've got my eyes on C, not because I'm a pessimist, but because I know in these situations, you probably want to be planning for the worst.

34:25 But right now, we don't have any data. We don't have any information that tells us we have to go that way. And so, Rob, I'm looking forward to hearing about your trigger points. And I think we're all counting on the nimbleness of our organization in this community to be able to adapt to whatever comes our way. So I like the approach. Good with B for the moment. And I think to Kirk's point, and sure, all of our points, we're going to be checking in on this with your trigger points, and we'll see what happens, and we'll go adjust accordingly. So I'm good with this for now.

34:55 Thank you. For me personally, I'm very comfortable with this. I spent a whole lot of time at the outset going over all these numbers myself and I think Rob has done a great job and been even a little more conservative than I was. So I'm very happy moving forward with B. Mr. Mayor, the Mayor Pro Tem. Linda. Donde esta? Yeah, thank you. No, Rob, I really appreciate this work. It lays it out very understandably for not only the council.

35:29 But I think for our community and our constituents, I too would tend to probably go a bit more pessimistic than this, but that comes with some unintended consequences immediately that I don't think we need to trigger right now. So certainly keeping a day by day, month by month, quarter by quarter look at this, I'm content to move ahead with B and thanks for all the hard work. Thank you. Thank you for that. John, next slide. Yeah, back one.

36:04 Oh, sorry. There you go. Sorry, Rob. You're good. So I wanted to kind of lead you through a couple of other changes. So with TOT, certainly sales tax has an immediate impact. We, you know, visitation, obviously people are here buying products and we're just starting to get this with the attestation and getting our...

36:31 I guess deep into phase two will help some of the businesses get back on their feet or start to get back on their feet. But that sales tax number really dependent upon visitation. And so what I try to do here is what I presented to you on March 18th was a total revenue of general fund of $24,016,000. Right now, the only two line items that I'm really impacting are TOT.

36:55 Which is reducing from 14.25 down to 11.2. And sales tax from 2.7 down to 1.85. Those reflect similarly impacts of visitation. There are some other, as we're constantly adjusting the revenue as we go through and get more information. So that's what that other revenue adjustments of 163 is. And brings us down to a presentation today.

37:23 Total general fund revenue of $20,279,000. That's pretty low. Again, $3.7 million less or 15.6%. That's what's built into plan B. And that's the full revenue impact, if you will, of what I'm presenting to you tonight. I do want to get any questions here. Maybe this one's just a little more, if silence might be golden, if you have any concerns, tell me about it. Otherwise, we can move forward.

37:53 Rob, one question. So these two, these elements here only take into account the TOT and sales tax. They don't talk about our other revenue streams. These are just focused on those two things, correct? Yes, that's correct. And the way I'm laying out this presentation is really, you know, the COVID impacts up in the front, how it sort of morphed our approach to the budget and the changes that we've made. We will get to some details later on to talk about that.

38:21 But what I'm trying to display here is just what I believe to be impacted within this current fiscal year. If there are next year, for example, if we're still, there could be a significant impact of property tax next year, but it is delayed a year because it takes a little bit of time for the values and such to be impacted by what we're experiencing. So that's really the only other one that I have concern about.

38:48 Yeah, we'll get to more details, but this is really just sort of under the veil of COVID and changes that I made in revenue. Okay, thank you. Yes, I have a, Rob, I have a question. When will we discuss Mammoth Lake Tourism in their budget since we're disinviting people to come up? So it's not just Mammoth Lake Tourism, it's ESTA and also, you know, both of those.

39:17 What are those budgets look like? So we definitely will have to talk about the allocation of measure eight dollars to to tourism. And that is definitely impacted because it's tied to the 11.2 number. So it's significantly lower than what has been in prior years. S does a little bit bigger challenge because that has a contract that is associated with that. We've got some discussions we'll talk about later on that as well.

39:47 We'll need some reserve from transit to fill the blanks in on that. But with regard to MLT's presentation, we have a few meetings to go and bring us up to speed. We're probably two months behind on the proper process by which MLT was to bring information to council. They're supposed to bring their strategy and deliverables draft form in April for discussion.

40:14 And getting input from the council on just what they're planning to deliver and how. And at that point, once you've given them your feedback on those, they are to come back after they work through it in the month of May, come back and work through it with you in June for final adoption. And that's really more their deliverable and strategies for the contract. That, as I said, based on all this has been delayed a little bit.

40:38 And we are working on that right now and expect to have that coming back probably by the end of June. So you'll have some clarity around what MLT's plans are. Thank you. Next slide, John. So what I wanted to talk about here is on the general fund, just sort of the approach we took with the expenditures and the starting point. I approached this as if it were a normal budgeted year. And I looked at all of certainly the commitments that we have, all of the plans, all of the contracts.

41:14 All of the agreements with the employees, everything was taken as it was planned to be taken. I built a budget from that. All the transfers that the general fund typically supports and no really planned use of fund balance because I needed to see, number one, a complete budget, but two, understanding where we should be in a good year. And so this is where I started.

41:42 But the next several slides will be then the reductions that were made from that point. But what I wanted to give you is we took this very similar to a normal budget year and made sure that we had everything accounted for and nothing was lost or missed. And then from there, we established what our baseline expenditures were. And I think that's on the next slide. That's not on the next slide, but that's fine. The next slide, go ahead.

42:11 Is total labor cost. And as I said, we built in, we had some from negotiations, we had some commitments that we established for July 1. We're still working through that process. Those are all captured in here. There are no staff reductions in here. There are certainly increases in expenditures, which we can't control. You'll see that the health insurance premiums are up 10%. The PERS is up 11.21%.

42:41 And these numbers reflect certainly a few new employees that have been added throughout the year, but really true cost per employee increases that we're facing. There was slightly a downtick in workers' comp, which is good. We've had a good year on that. And then salaries reflect the 4.7. So overall, total labor went up 790,000 or 6.51% over the prior year. So next slide. So when I talked about the starting point,

43:12 We went through kind of a little bit about the general fund and the changes and adjustments that I made to that. The projected expenditures are reflecting what I just described to you, my approach of looking at all the commitments and all the elements, making sure that we had them identified and put it in there. So when we start this process, we are upside down by $3.6 million, which is fairly significant. Next slide.

43:44 What we've been doing, the executive leadership team has been meeting every Friday and working through just different scenarios and different ideas for addressing that particular deficit and how we can approach it. And I think the ideas have been very creative. And we've tried to come up with items that are less impactful, but still very prudent to reducing expenses.

44:11 And hopefully they're palatable for you as we go through the process and you'll see what they look like and you can answer. So what I've done is on each one of the deductions or reductions, I have put them on their own slide. And if there's a council direction on them, then we'll ask that. But just want to walk through and just see if there's any questions. And so the cancellation of the summer recreation programs, there's really a couple of reasons for that. Certainly the...

44:39 That is a gathering, if you will, and those are currently not permissible by the governor's orders, but also just really how would we do that and keep people safe and bringing folks together and trying to teach them and train them and do things in a camp environment and how do you keep them, you know, covered up and distance enough to be safe and just really trying to pull that together and understand that, plus setting that whole process up. I mean, Stu and team do a tremendous job every year and they make it look easy, but...

45:07 It's like landing on the moon to get all that stuff prepared and ready to go in advance. And so when you think about the uncertainty of whether or not group gatherings will be allowed, they made the decision fairly early to cancel the programs. That had twofold effect. It reduces the revenue for the current year because we capture those revenues here in this spring timeframe. And then on the backside, the 2021 budget, it's the staff and supplies expense that's reduced.

45:37 So the net savings here I've got is $124,385, and that's what we reflected in 2021's expenditures. Next slide. This one is staff reductions. So we did, basically when the pandemic hit, we did shut down most of our part-time or temporary employees, and basically they were kind of ending out of their shift in the time period, but we did stop that pretty early.

46:09 We did decide to eliminate three of the temporary parks maintenance workers. That's based primarily on not needing to support as much of the summer programs that are out there and keeping the facilities and stuff clean. But we do still have, and we still have three that are on us. That was, there's a total of six, I believe, and we cut down to three. The recreation supervisor, it's a position that's currently vacant and it won't be filled.

46:37 Until probably the fourth quarter of 2021, provided how we're doing economically. And that would be brought on at that time frame in order to facilitate the summer programs we anticipate for the summer of 21. But right now, based upon the cancellation of the summer programs, we felt we could forego that. We did eliminate two temporary snow removal operators. Last year, Dan had a good idea to make some adjustments to our staff and structure.

47:04 And we did bring on some full-time employees. And so that sort of facilitated, I won't say a reduction in service, but putting a bit more on the full-time staff and eliminating two of the temporary snow removal operators. The assistant engineer position, that it is vacant. We did fly the position and we did have some folks that were interested in applying for it, but we decided to put that one on hold for the year.

47:32 So that will not be filled this coming year, 2021. And that's primarily due to the reduced capital projects and schedule for the fiscal year, but also really what we're trying to do as a cost savings aspect. Same for the engineering intern. Every year we hire someone to spend the time out there that has to monitor the jobs and the performance of what's going on on the job sites. And they spend all day out there watching everything that goes on. And it's frankly a requirement.

47:59 But that's a good position for someone coming into the town, but we just couldn't swing it for this year. So all told, the staff reductions element is $241,000. That's salary and benefits. Next slide. Airport operations. This was really an absolute saving grace here for the year. FAA stepped up when this pandemic hit.

48:29 Whereas most of the other agencies require you to expend funds and then document the heck out of everything and then go back and try to receive reimbursement at some point in the distant future sometimes. FAA came out and said, we're going to allocate money to support the operations of these airports so that they can keep going. So Mammoth Yosemite Airport received just under $1.1 million in grant funding.

48:57 Basically to say you can fund your operation with this. You can pay for anything that has to do with the operation of that airport starting from January 20th, 2020 until you spend the money. And so that was extremely beneficial for us because what it allowed us to do, if you know, General Fund supports the airport fairly extensively each year in the operations arena.

49:24 And this year, based upon establishing the budget as I had, the airport operations were going to require a general fund transfer of $619,434. So not only are we going to save a little bit of money in the current fiscal year, we anticipate covering the entire next year and then still having some funds available for either some equipment we may need to buy or to fund operations into the 21-22 timeframe.

49:54 A huge win for Grady and Hayes and Sierra for finding that and getting it to us. But that's a big part of helping to balance this budget. Next slide. So the settlement payment variance. As you know, a few years ago, we went out and refinanced our airport settlement, our MLLA settlement debt, where we were paying $2 million a year.

50:26 That was reduced down to around 1.86 on average. It changes year over year depending upon a few different factors. We had decided or through council action decided that we were going to go ahead and allocate the $2 million that we were used to paying over there and that those funds, the difference between them would sit in what we call a future capital account. So we've been accumulating some funds over there which will be reserve funds we could use for potential deeper dives if we need to.

50:56 But we decided this year to say we're only going to transfer to the debt payment exactly the amount that's required. And so that change in process, which is a policy question for you tonight, and I'll need to get you guys to kind of weigh in on that for me, but that would provide another $132,713 in savings. So again, it's not...

51:22 Short paying anything is simply changing a process that we use to generate revenue for future capital projects. So if I can pause there, if there's any questions on what I've said so far, or if I can get some direction from council on this particular request. What I'd like to do here, guys, is hear your comments and get a motion as to what to do with this. So, John, let's start with you.

51:52 I am good with this as Rob has presented. Thank you. Linda? Yes, I agree. I think this is smart financing. I have no problem with this at all. Thank you. Kirk? I agree. All right. So now I would accept a motion.

52:22 That motion would be to. Yeah, Bill, it's up to you if you want to take a vote on each of these or just give us direction to put it in the final budget that be adopted with the agreed to staff direction can be handled either way. Yeah, I would prefer since we're dealing with dollars that council voted, Dan, if that's all right with you. Yeah, you have that option. Thanks. So if somebody would like to. So I'll try to make that motion. So make a motion that town council direct.

52:52 Transferring the $2 million in debt service, future capital in order to accumulate funding for future capital projects. Will that do it? No. What you're requesting, sorry, that would take the 132 we just talked about and put it over. I think the motion would be is to utilize any net savings from the $2 million.

53:20 Committed to the payment for the general fund savings program. I think the clean motion. That's what my motion was. I think the clean motion is simply to only allocate what is necessary to pay that debt. Either way, yes. Will that do it? That'll do it. Okay, so motion in that, to that regards. I'll second the motion. And I have a second. Jamie? Council Member Hoff? Yes. Council Member Stapp?

53:50 Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido. Yes. Mayor Sauser. Yep. Passage five off. Thank you. And for those that may be listening at home, the reason we have to do that is essentially because that was prior council direction to perform that sort of capital dollar generation process that way. So we're changing direction. We need to get approval for that. Next slide.

54:21 So the vehicle replacement loan, as you know, fairly significant impact for the town was part of the cash flow for operations, the plan to provide cash flow for operations was to take a loan out of the vehicle replacement program. That is certainly the largest sort of cash on hand fund that we hold other than probably the general fund.

54:48 It does have a significant cash value in it. And so the loan was taken out of that as around 4.6 million, if I remember correctly. And the payment schedule is $340,000 a year. And since I've been here, or Dan's been here, we've been making that payment every year as part of our normal debt service. And it's an internal loan, so we're just paying ourselves back. It does help us when we're doing a lot of vehicle acquisitions, which we're not.

55:18 I'm not recommending any this year. So the request is that we want to delay the payment of this $340,000 internal loan for two years. That doesn't have a significant impact on the vehicle replacement program. That simply means that the life cycle may be going a little bit further out on some of the vehicles, if you will. And that's to do with some adjustments I'm going to make later on.

55:44 The 340 doesn't really have an impact on that. It will extend the payment out to 2030, so add two years onto the back of that payment. But for the next two years, I'd like to save $340,000 each year, $680,000 total. And that requires council policy as well. So once again, I would like to hear from you and get a motion to delay payment to the vehicle replacement fund for two years. John. Just Rob, real quick.

56:16 The consequences of this? I don't really see anything. There's no interest being charged on this, certainly, because it's all internal. It's all our own loan. The only challenge is when we have to buy a piece of equipment. When we do this payment, it increases the amount of cash on hand available to buy that piece of equipment. So right now, each of the vehicles have a portion of that loan taken away from them.

56:46 So if we have to buy something, we have to add back into that. As I said, we're not making any purchases this year. So that really won't impact us. I anticipate some having to buy something next year because we have so many vehicles that some will need to be replaced. So it may have a slight impact there and require some general fund dollars. But beyond that, there are no impacts I can see. I'm assuming the fleet's in good enough shape that we can get by for a couple years.

57:14 Last two years, we've invested heavily in the fleet. You see a lot of nice new pickups and stuff running around town. And we definitely have turned the corner on that. And frankly, part of the last challenge that town impacted was they did have to stop buying vehicles and we kind of dug a big hole. So I don't want to do that again. We'll keep on top of that. And Lon does an excellent job of preparing the fleet as well as letting us know what truly needs to be replaced. Okay. Thank you.

57:44 Linda? No, sounds smart. Thank you. Cleland? All good. Kirk? I support it. And I'm good with this. So if I could get a motion to delay payments on the vehicle replacement fund loan for two years? So moved. Second. I have a motion from Cleland, a second from Kirk. Jamie? Councilmember Hoff? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth?

58:21 Yeah. Mayor Pro Temp-Salcido? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. 5-0. Thank you. Next slide, please. So comprehensive leave accrual, this is one of those items, if you as an employee use your leave that you accrue on an annual basis, then the wage that we have or the expenditure we have as the town will just simply be the salary and the benefits of that employee.

58:53 When someone accrues time off but doesn't use them, so they increase their lead bank, we reflect that as an additional expenditure because the people are earning those hours to be taken at a later time and it is possible then for them to take more time than allotted and we just need to account for that expense. One of the things that we...

59:21 We decided to do, or at least to recommend, is to reduce that by 50%. And this is really just the accounting aspect of that. So it could leave us a little bit upside down if all the employees took all their leave at once. We do have a fund balance that supports 85% of all the leave balances that are out there. I don't anticipate this to be a big problem. It's not something that we can do continuously.

59:48 It's something that's really a short-term approach. And so this is one of those things that it'll come off now if you guys approve this and just be a slight reduction. Again, 114,488, but it will roll back on in subsequent years. So any questions or I do need a policy on this as well. Questions or comments? John? Cleland? Linda? Kirk?

1:00:27 And none from me. So I would take a motion to reverse our previous policy and collect for the next year only 50% of the comprehensive leave accrual. So moved. Who moved it? I missed it. That was me, Kirk. Thank you, Kirk. I'll second. First from Kirk, second from John, Jamie. Councilmember Hough? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth?

1:01:00 Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Yes. Mayor Sauser. Yes. 5-0. Thank you. Next slide. One of the things that we worked most diligently on was the department budget reductions. As I talked about at the beginning of the presentation, we don't really have heavy budgets in any particular area. We do have, I think, a very good training program, something that...

1:01:31 Provides for the education of our employees and keeps them up to date on the things that are out there as well as some of our different services or supplies and different things like that. We don't go too crazy. But what we ask them to do is really significantly cut that for the year. We were challenged with finding $200,000 and for the most part that was achieved.

1:01:59 We did have, you know, there's a variance you see it's 179,000. Some of those dollars were achieved in airport and I'm not going to double dip on those numbers because general fund is being supported from the FAA CARES Act. So departments went through that. We slashed the budgets on our training down to the bare minimum. So just what is absolutely required for the year, even for challenging with new employees coming on, if we do have to bring some folks on.

1:02:27 That will cause a problem. We did look at overtime and contractual services, which sometimes supports positions that we may not have within the town. They support functions that are performed. Those items could have a level of impact that is visible by the community, including core service areas like snow removal and such. But we did have to reduce down some of the anticipated overtime. So with all those things rolled in,

1:02:57 We did achieve again $179,000. The challenge with items like this is they cannot be turned off for very long or you start to see degrading capabilities or degrading functionality of the team or just service levels expected by the community. So when they roll back on, they almost have a doubling effect because they weren't there last year. They're a part of your normal operations and they're coming back on next year.

1:03:24 I'm more concerned about these short-term savings elements because they don't provide for long-term reduction of expenditures, which we really need in something like we're facing. But these are really short-term solutions to that. So the 179 is the recommendation from staff on this. Next slide. John, there you go. Salary savings, this one I'll say is pending.

1:03:57 We are working with employee contracts for there's a 2.5% pay adjustment scheduled for July 1. We're posing that that be delayed or put on hold for one full year, at which time we're actually adding an additional year at the end of the contract, which would pick up that 2.5%. And we pose that out to the associations as well as all of our leadership staff.

1:04:26 And so that's still in the process. I mean, we just did presentations last week. We had very good favorable comments coming back through that, but we just haven't had enough, haven't given enough time for full response on that. But I did have an anticipated number in here, the impact of that. Along with our retirement incentive program, we're exploring an opportunity. We've got some folks that are able to retire.

1:04:55 We're looking at some kind of an incentive program that may facilitate that. But those two items combined, again, very, I hate to be gray on them, but they are aspirational at this point, and we're working through that process. But that savings is anticipated at $200,000 for those two items combined. And if we don't achieve that, then we've certainly got opportunities or plan Bs, if you will, to make that number.

1:05:22 So we'll have, and Dan, you may weigh in on this a little bit because I know we have a closed session item a little bit later. So does this require council, we don't have the new salary schedule and such for that. Is this a secondary meeting? Yeah, there's no action on this this evening until after we finalize closed session this evening and then the other steps we need to take to formalize any future agreement. Thank you. So next slide. General fund support of transportation.

1:05:55 We're talking here, and this Kirk will answer a little bit of the question you asked earlier, discussing the allocation of TOT dollars to support tourism, transit, and housing. With TOT set at $11.2 million, it provides $732,300 for transit. There's also an additional element, that $116,500 in revenue, that's a transit fee.

1:06:23 That is charged against, I think it's a resort and commercial properties. And that supports ESTA essentially for the bus services that go around. The total expenditures that I have in the budget are $977,220. That's a little bit of staff that does some cleaning and maintenance on the bus shelters themselves, but primarily that's ESTA's contract. So we've got some heavy expenditures, I guess.

1:06:51 In advance of the revenues that we are anticipating. We do have the transit reserve that is available to support just this very thing. So staff is recommending that we utilize some monies from transit reserve, $128,502 to set the budget and start the year. So this would be a use of reserve and I will need council authorization for that use of transit reserve.

1:07:22 Okay, any comment on this one? John? Yeah, Rob or Dan, I'm wondering if you could talk a little bit. We're moving into Phase 2, the more aggressive part of Phase 2 with the state reopening. And can you talk a little bit about transit as an essential service, how it fits into the state's program and also the reality of the desirability of retaining staff for us to?

1:07:52 The problems may improve if we don't do that. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Councilmember Wentworth. The public transportation or the governor's order defining essential services does qualify there for the public transit component. We have been working with ESTA on the level and the scope of the services provided in town. We just recently reviewed some transit numbers, which

1:08:17 If you just anecdotally watch, they are very low, and that bears out in some of the numbers in terms of current ridership. However, as we move into stage two, the expanded version, as we get more retail and restaurant openings and some other miscellaneous services that can open underneath that category, we would anticipate a little uptick in terms of ridership.

1:08:43 I know a couple of businesses in the village have reached out about opening. There'll be some more on Main Street that'll open. Restaurants that can go to full dining would have a little more opportunity for people to come and be there. And so that would enhance both the number of people working, needing transportation potentially, and also customers, especially in the front end of this where a lot of the customers will be local and may...

1:09:09 End up wanting to ride the transit versus driving or walking to the various places. But I think we would see a minimum of CF ticket employees as they go back to work. So the need for the transit is still there. We have looked at do we reduce some of the routes or modify some based on the ridership. It is an ongoing monitoring program that we're looking at. We'll see what happens over the next couple of weeks with the change in the

1:09:38 Businesses that can open up the retail and the restaurants. And if we end up with that higher demand, continue the current routes. If not, we'll be looking at doing a little trimming out of some of the route side. The other, historically with ESTA, one of our challenges has been getting qualified drivers for our bus fleet there, working through ESTA. And by keeping the current ones running, what we're doing, we've actually been able to maintain that. And for those...

1:10:05 Folks who really do need that transportation, it's definitely been a benefit. So this helps us maintain the right staffing levels there to continue to be able to provide those services. And if we do take a fairly large uptick here in the future, that transit system is used quite heavily, both by locals and visitors. Great. Thank you very much. Linda? No, I'm fine with this. Thank you. Cleland? Good. Kirk?

1:10:42 Does this take a motion to authorize the use of the transit reserves? Yes, it does. I support the use, yes. And if I need to, I'll make the motion. I just want to say how important I believe this bus service is. We have pushed feet first in town. We've asked our employees not to have cars or drive. And I realize that ridership is low right now, but there is still one of our workforce that is working using it to a certain extent.

1:11:19 I think it is imperative that we keep this. It has been suggested that we call it to save money, but I think this is hugely important to keep continuity and keep it moving forward. So I would entertain that motion, Kirk, to use transit reserves. I'll make the motion to authorize the use of the transit reserve, 128,520. I'll second that. I have a motion from Kirk, a second from Linda. Jamie, please.

1:11:52 Council Member Hoff? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. 5-0. Okay, next slide. This one, we kind of went back and forth on gas tax. As you know, it's challenging to budget this particular fund in a good year because we have to anticipate what the snow levels are going to be.

1:12:25 And then we also have to deal with the revenue that we receive from the state, which is a year behind. So in this particular case, as you can remember, the snow levels and the snow removal efforts that we had this last year, I'm not anticipating a great deal of revenue coming from snow removal. In fact, it's the lowest I've budgeted since the time I've been here. That being said, we do have an expenditure level that is...

1:12:53 Consistent with a typical snow year, which is how we approach that. We don't, you know, go too heavy or too light. And we do have, and so general fund basically fills in the gap, the difference between what we receive in gas taxes revenues and what we expend on roads and other elements. We did have the option of reducing the capital projects or road rehabilitation programs, if you will.

1:13:22 That are there. We budget about 580,000. We actually budgeted that at full value this year. Those monies are typically not spent until the springtime and Grady and Hazen team do an excellent job of making decisions on whether or not it looks good to spend those monies or if they want to hold them over for another year for a larger project that may be facing us. So we've got a lot of moving parts in this particular one.

1:13:51 As we said, we build up fund balance through the revenues that we have and how we choose to spend them. We have enough balance in there to cover about $500,000 in a reduction and transfer from general funds. So what I'm asking for here is to allow us to use some of the fund balance that resides in gas tax.

1:14:19 To support the planned operations as we have budgeted, which would reduce the general fund transfer to gas tax for fiscal year 2021. That's savings of $500,000 is what I'm requesting. And I will need council's input and authorization to use gas tax fund balance very similar to what we did for the transit reserve for this purpose. Thank you, Rob. Let's start at the bottom this time with Kirk.

1:14:49 Rob, if I'm understanding this correctly, what we're doing is leveraging dollars for 2021 and utilizing those dollars for this year. Is that correct? No, it would almost be the opposite. So we have savings from this year and prior years that are being held in gas tax, and we're saying we want to utilize those dollars to cover...

1:15:19 Planned expenditures for 2021 for next year. Okay. I bet I understand it now. I don't have any other questions, Bill. Cleland. So I'm sorry, Rob, walk me through that one more time, what you just answered to Kirk. Sure. So when we have each year, when we look at the funds and we have revenues and expenditures, the difference between those.

1:15:56 Will it be an adjustment to fund balance? So if we have higher revenues and we have expenditures in a particular year, we'll build up a fund balance. It's very similar to a savings account. And in prior years, we have done just that with gas tax. So we have a fund balance of about $1.1 million in gas tax, which would typically be used on a large project of road rehabilitation or even a grant project to support a grant project that...

1:16:24 Hayes and Grady and team put together. But we have those funds available to be used only in gas tax. And so what my recommendation is, is that we are going to basically build a budget that has a deficit balance. And we're going to anticipate, or I call it a planned use of fund balance to fill in that gap. So we'll reduce that $1.1 million down to $600,000 if everything comes out the way it's planned.

1:16:53 Okay, so what would be the downside of this? We would not have as much money for future projects on roads, or if we have an impactful snow year, we may have some trouble. Again, we'll have to impact the general fund to support that, but that's the danger, if you will, is not having those good reserves for snow. Okay, that was my question. Thank you.

1:17:24 Linda. So, thanks, Rob. This is the lottery that we play and hoping for not such a terrible year that we'd have to throw in a lot of money next year to plow, but yet we need a really good snow year for everything else. So, hopefully it's somewhere safely in the middle of all that. That's a good way to put it. Good job. I'm good, thank you. Okay, then I'm looking for a motion.

1:17:59 To authorize the use of gas tax fund reserves. So moved. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie. Council Member Hoff? Yes. Council Member Stapp? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. That is 5-0. Thank you. Next slide. So this kind of concludes the recommended reductions.

1:18:34 Again, I think we as a team looking through the process, these are the cuts that we felt like we could make or the recommendations we felt we could make that don't go too deep initially. So we still have a deficit here of $956,270. And that's again where the expenditures, planned expenditures after these reductions compared to the revenues that I'm anticipating.

1:19:03 are upside down. So it's under a million dollars, it's 956 and I've got some solutions to fill that in. So if we can go on to the next slide. So the recommended use of reserves, there are three components identified again to start our budget process for 2021 and bring that into balance. The first item is if you remember back, I think it was in the spring of

1:19:34 2018-2019, Town Council allocated that $2 million of general fund to support special projects to produce housing. From that, we bought a couple of employee housing condos within the town. And then we actually just recently pulled a million dollars out of that. So those were around $667,000.

1:19:59 We requested from council maybe two meetings ago a million dollars to go into our COVID-19 response to the pandemic. And so that's funding some of the EOC work as well as some of the projects that are kind of giving back to the community like the rent reductions and so forth. But that left a $334,554 in those originally allocated general fund dollars.

1:20:24 I'm recommending that those items be pulled out and utilized as part of the balancing program for the operations of 2021. The second item is the airport funding for the CARES Act. I talked a little bit about that earlier. This savings here is what we anticipate receiving by covering some of the operations of 1920, so our current fiscal year.

1:20:52 As I said earlier, we can go back to January 20th of 2020. And we anticipate having around $300,000 in expenditures that will be covered. Now, if they're covered by that CARES Act grant, then they will not require general fund support. So those will free up some dollars to be used. Again, dollars we're saving this year to be used for balancing the budget next year. And finally, I believe, you know, based upon our

1:21:20 Revenue performance and how we've cut down on expenditures. We should have available dollars within general fund. It's very challenging to try to come up with a fund balance mid-year because, again, the fund balance is dictated by your total expenditures compared to your total revenue. And it's an estimate at this point, but I believe we're in pretty good shape to be able to fund the $321,000.

1:21:46 One of these requests is essentially reallocation, reallocating dollars that the council has already decided to use on housing. And then the second two are savings we anticipate for the current fiscal year that can be carried forward. Very similar to what we described as use fund balance for gas tax, but it would be utilizing these dollars to balance that budget. So down at the bottom, I have the chart that shows the three different components I'm recommending.

1:22:14 Add an additional $956,270 to the revenue side and balance out our budget. Any questions? We've already discussed, so I'm assuming we don't need a motion on those? Dan, do we need a motion on those? Or is it a staff direction?

1:22:40 Yeah, just staff direction, because we'll be coming back with some final numbers on the general fund savings and a couple other areas there. So I think that is fine, just that there's direction to utilize these reserves for the balancing of the budget. Yeah, so with that, I will take comments, starting with Linda. Thank you. You know, certainly I hate to see that $334,000 that we had held on to so far taken, but I don't see them.

1:23:11 I look back through the work you did, Rob, and all department heads have worked to try to get this budget into a manageable state, and we're just hoping that we'll be able to put that back in as we fully open and bring our tourism back, that we'll be able to replenish that money we had set aside for housing. No other questions? Newland? Pass for the moment. Come back to me, please. Okay. Kirk?

1:23:46 I support staff's recommendation to reserves. I support this. I think for the public listening, it's important to point out that the general fund allocation to housing was a special accrual of money we were able to put together for housing opportunities. I'm assuming and hoping as we go forward that our priority on the parcel and housing in general, if we get to some sticky questions on that,

1:24:21 We'll deal with it, but with this presentation, I'm okay with this, with these reserves as presented. Jay and Cleland, you wanted me to come back to you. Yes, and I'm sorry to bring this up because I know it's not a popular subject, but do we still have the million dollars from the general fund that's going to potential project, the CRC?

1:24:54 Yes, that's still allocated over there. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Rob, you got what you needed there? Yes. Yes, I did. Thank you. Thank you. Next slide, please. So I'm going to switch gears now. What I just described essentially was the budget process that we took forward and how we ended up with a deficit, how it was balanced.

1:25:38 Now I want to talk a little bit about the TOT revenue checkpoints that I described earlier. As you know, we need to keep a very sharp eye on the performance throughout the year. And so I laid out these sort of financial markers throughout the year. And they would represent, again, the $11.2 million. Please mute your phone. $11.2 million of TOT revenue expected and how it would lay out in a typical year. We've got those.

1:26:07 And the dates that I have displayed for you would be just beyond when we expect to collect those revenues. So we will be sort of formally looking into it at that point, making sure that everything seems to good. It's a bit of a litmus test. And again, if things are off just slightly, we could make some cuts potentially or utilize some reserves I'll talk about here in a minute.

1:26:33 But if things are off drastically, then there'll be some serious conversations that we're making regarding the expenditures. So I'm comfortable with these, the timing of them. As described earlier, if there are other events outside of just the sort of the TOT revenue indicators that tell us otherwise or tell us that we need to be concerned and making some deeper decisions, we'll have eyes on those as well. Again, what the mountain does for the wintertime is a key point of that.

1:27:03 And just whether we have a second wave of the pandemic, whether we're shutting down, all those types of things will be taken into consideration. But we do, as a staff, have worked through, you know, what alternate scenarios are. In the staff report, you'll see, you know, there's, we want to be a little optimistic. There are some thoughts that maybe we'll overperform this 11.2. So we want to talk about some of the cuts that we've made, how we would add those back in and a priority. And so we continue to work on that.

1:27:30 Now that we have a budget in front of you and that we'll be meeting again tomorrow or Friday on that. But also just how we approach the deeper dives. But that's the trigger point. And next slide if there are no questions. John? Yes, real quick. So the number, Rob, checkpoint number one, that's your sort of benchmark as to where we should be with TOT revenue, those various places, right? Yeah, so what we have, we don't budget TOT by month.

1:28:02 But I do certainly have a lot of historical data with which we can forecast where it should be. And so when I lay in the TOT of 11.2 million, it would dictate by through September, we should have $1.2 million in revenue. So yeah, those are the checkpoints based upon the 11.2 million and what we would, the typical distribution of TOT across the year. Okay. And I appreciate your previous comments about nimbleness.

1:28:30 And your previous comments just now about existential outside events come in. This just gives us a framework within which to be making decisions in a way to figure out where we're at. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Next slide then. Yep. Sorry, Mr. Mayor, next slide. Rob, next slide. Yeah. Yep. Thank you. So a couple of points that I want to make. You know, we've done a couple of things. Certainly there's already.

1:28:58 Reserve for Economic Uncertainty and Operating Reserve that are out there and available. We are not addressing those particular items right now. We are holding them for what could potentially be an extended period of time, which we cannot sort of weather with these smaller cuts or temporary cuts. But we're also, you know, we've got to have some

1:29:29 Dollars available to us in case we are truly impacted by another sort of catastrophic event. I mean, that can happen. So we are leaving the REU and the operating reserve fully intact as a plan to start 2021. That's around $5.6 million in available funds. We also went through, though, and identified other areas by which we had either allocated

1:29:54 General fund dollars through excess general fund dollars in prior years to particular projects and where we may hold on to those projects or defer them a little bit to provide just a bit more cushion in case we need it. As I've described to many people here within the office is we really don't know what we're facing and the duration of time with which we have to recover or will take to recover.

1:30:21 So by holding on to as much of the dollars as we possibly can, we will provide ourselves an opportunity to at least continue the government operations, especially the core services that we need. So we've identified these particular elements as additional reserves. And again, you can read through them. I'm not going to read them all to you. Some of them are truly allocation of funds over to projects. Other ones are dollars that we have kept.

1:30:50 Diana Balance available for our project, like the airport capital. The same thing for the code compliance on blighted buildings. We set that aside maybe a year and a half ago or so. The generator project, we set aside a full $280,000, but we received a grant to support the majority of that. So that $280,000, $180,000 of it is available to come back. That's basically the amount of the grant plus some of the expenses we had.

1:31:20 Some of the deferred maintenance projects, the upgrades to Suite Z and the town offices, we're just sort of putting those off. And they're on hold right now, but those monies, the 1.950 could be available or made available for general fund operations. So that's how I've got that listed out there. And that would be added on to the RNU, the Reserve for Economic Uncertainty and the Operating Reserve of 5.6 million.

1:31:46 Just under $7.5 million for general fund. And I think that's a pretty good place to sort of nest egg to start on. We talked a little bit below about the transit items. So Town Council authorized the use of transit reserve for some three-bus shelter replacements. Those are on hold. And those monies could be pulled back into the transit reserve and utilized to support.

1:32:12 Ask that maybe for next year, for example, if we do have multiple years of low TOT. The same thing is the grant match for the purchase of the buses. I don't think that that's gone through. So those dollars are still sitting there available. So that 662 represents what could come in just to support the transit function for the town. It would not be able to be used for general fund at all. But again, that's still a strong benefit. Next slide.

1:32:41 Now we kind of switch into talking about the budget. This is where I would normally discuss our budget and start the process. And I'm going to kind of move through these fairly quickly as we've spent a great deal of time talking about really the major components of these. But we'll kind of cruise through. So general fund in general, I try to show you every year what the major revenue components are and how they compare to prior years. So you'll see here just

1:33:09 We're down $2.9 million to what we budgeted at the beginning of 2019-2020. This is different than the number that I showed you before. That number to begin showing like 15% down was what we were projecting the budget to be for 2021. So that's the differences here. And in property tax, there's several components. And on the next slide, I'll show you a little bit of a breakdown of those. So that number is...

1:33:37 Is fairly consistent. But these are the major components and how they've changed in this current budget to what they were prior to your budget. Next slide. Breaking down those revenue streams a little bit more. And what I like to show here is just the percentage of dependence on those. You know, our TOT number sometimes climbs as high as is almost 70% of actual. And we typically budget somewhere around 60 to 62%. So for this year, it's 55.2.

1:34:08 Again, the property tax is actually made up of two components in here. It's the second line item and the fifth line item, the property tax in lieu. That's the $3.8 million total. And just showing you just where the rest of our revenues sort of come from. If there are any questions, I can certainly answer them. If not, let's go on to the next slide. Giving you a sense of the expenditures, you know, we look at how we break up that pie for the general fund, where the money goes.

1:34:42 I think this is a good one to show you in a glance where the expenditures of $21,429,000. And this is reflective of the adjustments that I requested in this presentation. So this is a net amount, if you will, getting down to the $21,429,000. If no questions, we can go to the next slide. I'll show you here the town departments, and these are general fund departments. I'll show you the prior two years actual.

1:35:14 I don't show you the current year actual because it's not complete and I don't want to show reduced numbers that are simply just inaccurate for a complete year. So we do show the prior two years complete numbers by departments and then I show you the budget that we started last year with and then the proposed budget for the current year, the variance of that and then the percentage that breaks down.

1:35:40 You can see sort of where some of the cuts were taken as we talked about the departmental cuts throughout the year. I'm sorry, with the departmental cuts that were made for balancing the budget and those separate decisions, as well as I think transit services, tourism and such is in here as well. You can see that's down 415,000 or 17%. That would be money transferred to MLT for measure A allocations. And then the transfer out.

1:36:10 That essentially is what covers the debt service. It's what covers support of the airport. It's what covers support of gas tax. And so you can see that one's down fairly significantly based upon utilizing the CARES Act monies for the FAA, for airport, as well as the gas tax decision that we just made. If no questions, we can go on. Solid Waste Fund. This is a...

1:36:40 Pretty much a brand new fund. I think we've had it for just two years now. It started with some grant funding that we received on that and didn't actually budget it last year, which was my mistake. But this year we did pick it up in the mid-year. But the budget expectations, I think a little bit of waste connections, there's some fees associated with that. The parcel fee is in there, which supports the...

1:37:08 The closure of the landfill in the future. And primarily we have a little bit of labor and some contractual services, which is associated with, and Dan can probably speak to this, you know, planned projects or development that we would go in solid waste. Dan, do you want to add something to that? Yeah, it's the new fund of that franchise fees that will be allocated there to use for services required for like our recycling that's done for the town.

1:37:38 Some of those types of other services. So that'll be captured here in this fund. And then we have some grant dollars that flow through here as well. Next slide. This is gas tax. We talked kind of extensively about that. This just shows you, again, the same look and feel showing you prior to complete years, as well as the budget for last year and the budget for current year.

1:38:06 You can see gas tax budget, which starts the year out typically conservatively, even the 1.5 actual has gone up a little bit this year. It just shows you where we're starting out the year. So fairly steep decline in that particular area. Then you've got the expenditures and they're really broken down by departments. So those departments would be how we segregate.

1:38:34 The expenditures and part of it is what is reimbursed by snow removal, what is reimbursed by general gas tax, and then what is covered by fund balance. But this look is to give you a sense of where the expenditures are and what they're planning for the year. So as I described earlier in my presentation on reductions, you can see the revenue is $3,910,000 versus an expenditure.

1:39:03 A 4.4 million, including the transfers out. And so that's that $500,000 use of fund balance that we described earlier. So that's been approved now by you. So we can move on to that. Next slide. I think shows a graph of this. Yeah. Just giving you a sense of that. It's really not, it doesn't include transfers out. That's why the 4.1 million versus the 4.4. But just showing you graphically, you know, where we spend our money within gas tax.

1:39:32 Next slide, please. So Measure R. So Measure R is consisted of Fund 215 and 216. 216 is where the revenue comes in from sales tax. And as I described earlier, sales tax, we're anticipating, I know on the general fund side, I had about 32% reduction in sales tax. For Measure R, a little bit more, a little bit less conservative and down to 20%.

1:40:03 5% in here. It was budgeted at 1.350 last year and anticipating it to be around a million dollars. The expenditures in here, there is a $300,000 annual transfer to Fund 215, which is where we retain all the expenditures associated with construction of trails and the work that is done by Joel Rathje and his team on trail maintenance. And so that's $300,000 goes over there annually to support that.

1:40:33 The MLR agreement for administration, that's $192,000, is transferred to MLR for covering their staff expenses and others. There is a $25,000 special project assignment, which is really for MLR to have a special project. They have funds available to act quickly on that. Some of those things come up. We've got trails and park maintenance, Whitmore Park maintenance. Those are supporting some of the town's activities with regard to recreation.

1:41:03 It's a total of $37,000 for those supported. It's really staff time to work at those parks. And then we have equipment replacement and equipment maintenance. And those are items that are purchased by Measure R. And then audit services. So the Measure R funds are audited every year for that expenditure. A few years ago, we worked with MLR and developed these static set of expenditures.

1:41:31 And so that's something we've carried forward at least for the last three or four years. We probably could revisit that in the future, but don't need additional moving parts at this time. So the multi-use facility funding, as you know, we acquired a bond probably about two years ago in support of building the CRC now is what it's called. They just leave the original name in there. But that $614,000 is the debt payment for this current year, and that fluctuates.

1:42:00 Again, slightly year over year. But the total expenditures are $1,176,441, leaving a deficit of $176,441. So again, based upon planned revenue, which I think is less conservative than I'm doing for the general fund, we're still upside down by a significant portion. So I think as we go into perhaps the next phase of the budget, we'll have to figure out.

1:42:28 How we're going to collectively do that, but I don't have that request of you tonight. No questions? Next slide. Any questions on that? Next slide, John. Measure U. So that's made up, that's used for utility tax, comes in from phone bills, electric bills, and gas bills, etc. We have a fairly static year-over-year comparison on revenues. Gas tax, gas is down a little bit this year.

1:43:02 And again, that has some

1:43:32 Increments this year. So programming, we did add some dollars to programming, which supports events that are held within the town. And the idea behind that was with the summer being shut down this year, we anticipate the need for more support of the programs to start next year. So again, those where the funds are typically allocated is for the summer of 21-22.

1:44:00 And so we're holding those expenses just a little bit higher in there. The recreation coordinator position, $75,000, that's up $5,000 from prior year. And that's just a portion of that account or a portion of that position is funded by Measure U, the rest by the town and a little bit by the county. And so that's the portion there.

1:44:21 Special projects, very similar to what they described in Measure R. Those are projects that can be acted upon quickly by MLR. Transit services, those would be for special events within the town. We pay for ESTA bus coverage for those so that we have extra coverage, and that comes out of Measure U, as well as some contract processing where the town performs those services.

1:44:48 Review of contracts, and that's based upon the number of contracts we review. Same for the equipment replacement and same for the audit services of $4,000. I do show in there the $300,000 set aside for MAC operating expense. That's really a future expense, but I like to keep it visually in front of you so we can get a sense of where the revenues are tracking and then where the future committed dollars are also tracking. So $157,780 represents

1:45:17 You know, the change in fund balance, which is a positive thing at building that savings account, if you will, based upon the budget, the plan for the year. Next slide. So this is the TBID. And TBID is funds basically that belong to MLT. They just pass through the town because my team, the revenue team, collects TBID along with our TOT from our revenue perspective.

1:45:50 We collect that, we pass that through to MLT, and we retain 2% of that, which would be a collection fee, if you will, to fund essentially staff time utilized in that collection effort. As you can see, and this was really a sort of thumbnail sort of approach to what the impacts are for the town that were performed by Dan and I, and they're down fairly significantly, 37%.

1:46:19 So last year we budgeted for $4.5 million. We're anticipating a $2.8 million. MLT has done some work on an analysis and you will see that reflected in the final budget. It's about $446,000 higher. I've got that note on the bottom there. I think it was $3.2 million, $3.246. That will essentially not impact our funds at all. It just shows that it'll be transferring over to

1:46:46 To MLT, and then we will have just this higher amount of our 2%, if you will. But those are simply pass-through dollars. Next slide. This is the airport fund. We've talked a little bit about that. And, you know, there are some revenues that are received by the airport, certainly passenger facility fees, which are reserved solely for use on capital projects. They cannot be used for operations.

1:47:16 There's car rental fees, I'm sorry, revenue items, and terminal rent and other hangar ground leases and other revenues. So I try to give you a little bit of a sense of how they look in comparison. The grant entitlements, there are three projects that are planned for this year. We're going to talk more extensively about capital projects, I believe, on the 17th of June. And so the capital projects that are going forward, typically,

1:47:44 The FAA grant monies to support those projects is somewhere around 92% of the cost of the project. And based on the COVID-19 response, FAA has waived our matching component, that 8%. And so what's reflected in there is the full cost of those three projects that are anticipated by Hayes and Grady and team. And that would be funded 100% by FAA. The second line item of the FAA CARES Act represents the...

1:48:14 What the support for the airport will be that would typically have come from general fund, but based upon our conversations earlier coming out of this CARES Act. So our general fund transfers you see is zero. Last year was budgeted at $580,000, $582,000. So big help from that process. And then down below, you know, we talk about the expenditures. There are operating expenditures and there are capital project expenditures.

1:48:41 So you'll see the capital projects equal the amount of the grant plus the $75,000 in passenger facility fees. But the other expenditures are just what it takes for us to run the airport and be a Part 139 certified airport, as well as the staff that's required there and the snow removal and all those things. So airport always balances out to zero. If the actual comes out different, we've left those dollars in the airport in the past.

1:49:07 To build up the fund balance for future capital projects, our general fund contribution to that. And again, to start the year as a plan, it's always in balance. Next slide. And that just shows you graphically the operational side of it. It doesn't show the capital project side, but that's just what it takes to run the airport. Most of it labor and labor cost from operations. But just graphically want to display it for you. Next slide.

1:49:42 Housing programs. This one is just grant revenue that we go after on an annual basis. The source of revenue, that's whatever we capture is pretty much going out in programs. So we just kind of had anticipated dollars there. This one's, again, in balance with anticipated revenues and reserves. And that's really an estimate depending upon what grant programs are out there. And I have no idea the impact to housing programs that the COVID-19 response.

1:50:11 And the potential impact of available revenue will be for those, but going ahead and planning as we usually do for the housing programs. Next slide. LTC, that we receive an allocation of $75,000 a year. We have a planned use of labor that we set aside. I will say that typically

1:50:39 We do a good job of combining information between the town and county on a project. We can combine funds even from that purpose. But we'll hold those across for a larger project that we want to work on. And LTC, I'd like to show it in balance. So I'm showing that labor expenditure because that is a potential. And the $75,000 is an estimate to start the year. I think that's a baseline estimate to start the year. But that one's in balance. Next slide, please. Development impact.

1:51:11 Fees, showing really just what's anticipated for each one of these, and they are directly tied to the building permit fees and such that are taken. And so those estimates there are provided to a pretty strong building year. Our building permit revenue is around $670,000, which is up over

1:51:41 The last several years. Now the concern in that is that available capital for projects is in question, but those will have an impact on those funds. And we hold these impact fees in trust for other agencies for the most part. Some of them are our own, but other agencies, and they do all have fund balances associated with them, but they have specific purposes for which they could be used. But the funds are generated through the application for building permits.

1:52:09 That are done by our building team. And I'll have a little bit more information on that on the 6-17 presentation, June 17. Next slide, please. Same thing with the budget assessment districts. I believe that Sierra and Grady and Hayes are bringing forward some recommendations from NBS on how we account for these assessment districts. And that...

1:52:38 That information will be provided in greater detail on the 617 where I'll talk about what it is we do with these monies, how they are accrued, and then also how they're planning to be expended for the coming year and what their fund balances are. So look for a little bit larger presentation on that. But right now, as we have this budgeted, this is a plan. It doesn't really tell you a lot, but they're all represented there. And some of them have fairly significant.

1:53:06 Revenue and Expenditures, but those are ones that have debt payments associated with them. So again, much broader presentation on 617. Next slide. Fractional Melrose is one where we collect the revenue assessments on some properties and some parcels where we collect this in lieu of a TOT. And we have that budget, as you can see, that's kind of

1:53:37 Going down a little bit over the year. I think some of those parcels may be transitioning out of that particular program. But those funds are utilized to support the multi-use facility, which is our current ice rink, and can be utilized for other expenditures. There's a calculation that says the expenditures have to be more than they were in 2004.

1:54:06 So for example, if we had more police officers than we did in 2004, we could utilize some of these particular funds to support that, but we haven't achieved that and we likely won't. But these would be new facilities that have come online since then, so the operations for those facilities can be covered a portion with those revenues. So we schedule that every year and you can see a little bit of a breakdown of how they performed and how we're planning on for the next year. Next slide.

1:54:37 Talking about the debt service, I do have actually a pretty cool graph that shows all of our debt service that we have for the town. This particular one is just a snapshot of what we have running through debt service. Not all of it is really the liability of the town itself or the general fund. So I've broken those out. Certainly the lease bond for the police facility that built our new police facility.

1:55:07 As well as the taxable judgment obligation bonds for MLA debt. Those are the two coming out of the general fund. And then we have the installment sales agreement for the multi-use facility or the CRC. That one is coming out of measure R. And then the other, the final two are coming out of some of the assessment, the benefit districts, the assessment districts. So that's the total look at our debt service. Next slide, please.

1:55:37 So that brings us to the conclusion. I just wanted to make mention that I believe as I started off by saying that this is a good starting position to get us across the starting line of fiscal year 2021. I think it's prudent. It covers what we need to have covered as well as a very conservative approach on the revenue side. We are prepared to make additional adjustments. We're working on this every day.

1:56:06 And as I said, we're working through as more information is obtained. We have alternative scenarios that we will be able to action upon if we hit those trigger points for decisions. What you provided me tonight will assist us in developing the final budget for the 17th. And if there are any questions, I'd love to hear them. Any questions from council? Go ahead, John. Rob, real quick. Thanks for the thoroughness of this.

1:56:39 The only thing that's missing here, which is not perhaps in your wheelhouse, is for, I think, for the council to revisit or just check in on our priorities going forward so that we can give you a North Star, a series of North Stars. So as you're making decisions, we start making, you know, what we're going to spend on, what we're not going to spend on. That may be something we need to do in the coming weeks. We've got priorities established.

1:57:08 Thank you, Rob. You're welcome. That being said,

1:57:45 I realize we're all at our homes and it's very comfortable, but we've sat for two hours. So if you want to get up at this point and get yourself a drink or whatever you need, let's take about a five-minute break for that. Thank you. Thank you, Bill. Good. Thank you. Linda and Cleland, when you get back to station, turn on your video so I know you're there. Okay, I believe we are now all back up.

2:00:31 So I'm going to move on to the consent agenda. I will read it very quickly. Approve minutes of the special meeting of April 29. Approve minutes of the regular meeting of May 6. Approve minutes of the special meeting of May 12. Approve as a resolution continuing the local emergency regarding PSPS. Approve the resolution continuing the local emergency regarding COVID-19. And two accept payment approval reports, 2039 and 2040.

2:01:02 Anybody wish to pull anything from consent? Hearing none, I would entertain a motion. I'll make a motion that we approve the consent agenda. I'll second the motion. First from Cleland, a second from Kirk. Jamie? Councilmember Hoff? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Consent passes 5-0. Moving on to policy matter.

2:01:37 Number eight, appeal of TOT, TBID penalties and interest for Best Western High Sierra Hotel. Rob, I'm assuming you're starting us off there? Yes, that's correct. So, as you know, we've talked about, you know, the February TOT was due on March 20th. And all this information for the COVID-19 impacts and stuff started slightly before.

2:02:10 The due date on that. We as a group made the decision not to delay the TOT due because those monies from February should be held in a trust and paid to the town. We did, however, delay the running of penalties and interest. So typically on a collection of the 20th, on the 21st, we would come in and run a penalty and interest routine, which starts the process by which

2:02:39 Someone is late. In this particular case, we delayed that for a full seven days and ran that on Friday the 27th. And the resulting of that, since Best Western had not been late before, they were eligible for, in the three-year period previous, they're eligible for 1% penalty per day of late.

2:03:08 That was significant for them because, well, it wasn't significant, but it did start the process a little bit later. So the 1% per day, they actually achieved a 14% penalty rather than a 15% penalty, which is typically what's achieved by a normal operator who's been late before. That delay reduced their P&I by $463,000. Sorry, I'm thinking budget terms here.

2:03:37 Best Western did make the payment. They did pay the outstanding TOT. They did pay the penalties and interest. Their request has been basically cash flow based so far, saying that the decision to pay the taxes was lowered on the list from other operating expenses. But I will let them speak to their defense on that.

2:04:06 Upheld penalties and interest on TOT collections to keep the playing field level and fair for those who do make the payments on time, which we much appreciate. And so my recommendation, a staff recommendation is that we uphold the penalties and interest, which in total amount is $7,155.82 that's accrued for late payment by Best Western.

2:04:34 Now for folks who are here representing Best Western, your opportunity to defend the late payment aspect. Go ahead and speak up. Yes, hi. My name is Frank Weiser. I'm the attorney for Best Western, and it's law officers of Frank A. Weiser. I'm at 3460 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 1212 here in Los Angeles. And I had sent an email.

2:05:01 The other day, and I wondered if you had received it, and I would like to have that part of the administrative record. I'd raise certain legal objections to the T.O.T. Was that received? Yes, that was received. Okay, and I want to start out that, you know, I do a lot of work, I mean, over 40 years in the, primarily the Asian Indian motel community. I've done a lot of work in the T.O.T. area. I have a lot of public work in the area.

2:05:30 Two significant cases I think may bear here are the San Bernardino Hotel Motel Association versus City of San Bernardino. I cited it in my email, 59 Cal F4, 2-37-1997, and a corollary case in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Patel versus City of San Bernardino at 310-F3-1134 in 2002.

2:05:54 I have raised certain constitutional objections to the TOT ordinance in general, and I'm raising it here only because, I mean, we have a taxpayer here who is a little different than some of the other taxpayers you might see in some of my cases. This is a taxpayer who has diligently paid the TOT over the years, has not been late. Even here, and I know Mr. Marari for many years now, and he's a client of mine for many years, but he's a...

2:06:23 Person who has paid it. He even paid this one, even though he was protesting the fact that why was he being charged interest and penalties. He was caught in the middle with the COVID-19 and chargebacks that were occurring that time. He's closed now. He's under dire financial problems, as I understand the city. But I mean, we have here a person who is in good faith, tried to cooperate.

2:06:48 These are being raised as a defensive measure only. I'm sensitive to the fact that all the cities now in the state are having serious, serious budget deficits. And we're not trying to raise this just as a general objection. But I think that, you know, in a case like this where you have a taxpayer who has been paying, even paid the penalty here to show his good faith, there should be some more consideration than just a 1% credit.

2:07:18 I think one of the things he has raised to me, and I think it is a valid objection, it came up in my San Bernardino case, the federal Patel versus San Bernardino case, is that years ago, when I overturned the San Bernardino TOT ordinance, I then challenged the collection of the tax as being an unconstitutional taking of property.

2:07:46 And the Ninth Circuit ruled, if you look at that case, it's a published opinion. The Ninth Circuit ruled that the issue is, is if you put a motel operator under the burden of collecting an unconstitutional tax, and there's no benefits to the operator other than collecting it for the city, that may raise serious constitutional issues. Well, here I think the problem is, Mr. Maraudi has indicated to me, he's collected this tax.

2:08:15 He's paid it over. He has to foot the bill every month with credit card charges that are being paid because of the fact that the customers come in, they pay on credit cards, and he has certain charges that the Expedia and various other companies charge him. So he's taking money out of his own pocket, not just being a pure tax collector for the city, and there's no deficit to him. And now he's being taxed.

2:08:43 In addition, a $7,000 penalty. So that being said, I really think there's some equities here. We can talk about all the legal challenges, but I don't think that's what we want to get to here. I just want to demonstrate here that if you add up all the legal aspects to this, but you look at it also from the equitable standpoint, and I think you as a city have the ability.

2:09:09 Equitably to waive this or make some kind of an adjustment here. I think consideration has to be given to a taxpayer here. Maybe a credit back to future TOTs that are collected, but something should be done because he is a good upstanding operator in your city. As I understand it, you've never had a problem with him and you've never actually penalized him for any late payments on TOT for a good many years.

2:09:37 So with that being said, I would turn it over to Mr. Marari to explain to you the details of why he was late, what the problems were that he was having and the crunch he was having with the chargebacks. And thank you for giving us this opportunity. Thanks, Frank. Thanks, Mayor and City Council. My name is Bipin. Do you guys hear me okay?

2:10:06 I hear you. Okay. Yeah. So actually I'm doing the business in Mammoth from actually 1995 and we are not late in a single day except this COVID-19. So my request to humble request to the city council and everyone to check that and help out to the business who business can help out to the city who bring in the really high revenue for the city. We operate the very high profile hotel.

2:10:34 And we bring the high number of TOT for that. And we incur the cost. So just to give you the example, like every year, I incur the cost to collect the TOT tax, minimum $15,000 every year. That we had not charged to the city of Mammoth Lakes any given time because we believe the city is our partner and we work with the city. However, on this kind of pandemic situation, when the mountain is shut down, when the people are canceling the...

2:11:01 Reservation left and right and they asking their money is refund right away because it's all credit card money so that money can be go away from there. All this reconciliation and everything it's take time to us to that in those kind of situation also if the town collector is not going to understanding then I think I'm seeing that this is kind of a little bit.

2:11:23 So I'm hoping this point right now, Town Council will be

2:11:53 Consider and refund those money to us because this is a very valuable money we put in our own assets there and bring the more money for the town of Mammoth Lakes. Thank you. Thank you. With that, let's go to council questions of staff or owners. John? Yes. So, Rob, in terms of the

2:12:26 I'm hearing two matters in front of us. One is maybe a question for you. One is just I will defer to Andy on some of the legal and constitutional issues. But the transaction has been completed, correct? The penalties were assessed. Everything's been paid. Mr. Rari is in good standing at this point. Everything's settled. Is that fair to say? Yes, absolutely. So as the taxes were paid and the penalties and interest,

2:12:56 Calculated. They have also been paid at this point. And I think there's actually a credit because you paid the full amount. There was that 1% reduction that's out there. Thank you very much for doing that. And thank you very much for being where we're at. It's not quite clear to me what the question, it sounds like there's some questions about legality of TOT and things like that. And I'm going to defer to the town's attorney on that. I'm not going to get into any of that kind of stuff, but that was my question. Thank you. Thank you, John.

2:13:27 Linda? Yes, those were my questions too. Again, thank you for bringing everything current at this point. That's good to hear. And as far as the question on the legality and appropriateness of TOT, I feel like that's been settled well, but also I would defer to our town attorney for that. So thank you. Cleland?

2:14:08 I'm going to be abstaining on this one. Thank you. Hey, Bill. Mr. Mayor, if I may, Cleland just asked about that earlier on some work relationships and referrals from work and stuff to the Best Western here in town and stuff. So she had a probably not a technically a legal conflict, but very much a perceived conflict of interest potentially for ruling on this matter. So she's asked if she would abstain.

2:14:41 And just to clarify, because this is not a technical conflict of interest, Councilmember Hoff is not required to drop off the call or turn off video or mute herself because this is simply a self-directed abstention. So she can continue to sit in if she likes. Thank you, Andy. I have no real questions on this one. I think that the payments have been made appropriately and we all just need to move on.

2:15:14 With that, Andy, you have anything else in what you've heard that you would like to speak to on this? Well, Mr. Weiser has referred to a couple of cases. I mean, I did try to call him this morning to see if I could get him to explain his theories and didn't hear back. But the cases he's talking about have to do with the collection of attacks that the court found was illegal. I'm not aware of anything that would make our TOT illegal.

2:15:40 Thank you, Andy. Can I address that? Sure.

2:16:10 Just very briefly, and I'm sorry, perhaps I didn't give you my cell phone number in my email the other day, so I had not picked up my messages from my voicemail at my office, but essentially there are multiple challenges to the DOT. I mean, there's a challenge based on the Britt versus City Pomona case that was used in the San Bernardino case that I litigated.

2:16:40 Where the Second District Court of Appeals found that the TOT doesn't necessarily make a rational distinction between taxing transit lodgings versus permanent lodgings in general. And I think that that's a challenge that would be generally made to TOT in general. I do think there's a due process objection. I don't think Mammoth Lake has updated their TOT ordinance in conformance with City of San Dino.

2:17:10 That I am making here is that the collection of the tax, the manner in which the tax is collected, in which the operator has to actually foot costs out of their own pocket in collecting the tax on behalf of the city without any kind of remuneration based on the Ninth Circuit case and the language that was in there that was written by Judge Browning.

2:17:36 The late Judge Browning, one of the head judges of the Ninth Circuit, does raise very serious due process issues. And that, I think, goes to the nub of what Mr. Morari is talking about. And that is, he's for years and years collected taxes. I think he just stated that he had $15,000, if I'm not mistaken, in charges or payments that he's made on his credit card charges over an annual basis. So he's footing a big, big,

2:18:06 And so...

2:18:31 I would just ask the council to really consider that you've got a taxpayer here who's a good, good motel operator who brings in that revenue to the city, will bring in revenue. Apparently Best Western is one of the top front motels you have there in the town. It seems to me foolish to be arguing over $7,000 and fighting it if there can't be a resolution over this. So thank you. Okay, council, any further questions?

2:19:03 Or comments. I would then entertain an idea or a motion. I don't know if there's any action we need to take here. There is. Well, this is an appeal, and so the council needs to dispose of the appeal, either by granting the appeal or by denying the appeal, or by taking some third path and giving Mr. Brari some kind of relief, if not the entire relief that he's asked for.

2:19:44 Again, this is being framed in the context of a bunch of legal citations that I don't feel any comfort being able to respond to any of that. I would then at that point say let's deny the appeal. I don't understand. Well, because Mr. Berari's attorney has made a threat of litigation against the town, you could take the appeal under submission and direct me to go back and do

2:20:15 Additional research, I suppose, and then I could talk to you about it in closed session. Closed session, of course, being justified because we have a threat of litigation. Well, then I would suggest maybe we do that. Yeah, for me, I would be comfortable in just moving forward and upholding the penalties and fees, whatever the council would like. So I would like to hear from Linda and Kirk on this as well. Would it be appropriate at this point to...

2:20:46 Just sort of make a statement in regards to our track record of upholding penalties and interest on late TOT payments. I think this council has been consistent in holding those late TOT payments responsible for the penalties and interest. And I would hear nothing compelling in this case to take a different

2:21:15 That being said, I would also concur with Andy's comments about continuing to look and to investigate this. But at this point, I would feel comfortable making the finding of non-compliance and upholding the penalties and interest as listed in the report. Is that a motion? I could make it a motion. Yes, that is a motion.

2:21:46 Thank you. I'll second the motion. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? The only thing I would add is that I think the council would like to hear advice from our town attorney in a closed session as appropriate as to what the legal framework of all this is. And John, I would agree in terms of the threatened lawsuit.

2:22:16 I read the letter and that's what I feel it is, is a threat to be held over us, not a way I prefer to do business in Mammoth. So I am very comfortable moving forward. Any other deliberation? If not, I... Bill, I have a comment. I think it's an opportunity for me to say to Mr. Murari, you have been a valued member of our community since 1995. I know that you have...

2:22:47 You run a good business and you've been a good participatory community member. So I just wanted to take a moment to say that your assertions of being all of that do not fall on deaf ears. And so thank you for that also. And I hope that we can come to a resolution on this. Thank you. Can I say something, please?

2:23:12 Yeah, so I think, I know that politically, I think it's taking on, that's what the Franks say, that we are threatening, we are not threatening to the town, we are trying to present to the town, to the right side also, when the staff is presenting their side, we are presenting our side, and how much cost and everything is incurred to collect this tax also, which is we never charged to the city. That's one thing. And second thing, like I said, from 1995, we...

2:23:40 We bring a lot of tax and we have never laid on this thing. It's not like our practice to do the late and everything. We do a lot of community work and everything also. What my major take here is when we talk to the staff and everything and they say that, oh, I don't think so that city council can overturn this kind of decision. That point I felt like I say, okay, what is going on here? I say either that they run the city council or either city council have their independent rights to run themselves.

2:24:10 We bring money to the town and we done

2:24:37 And we incur a lot of expense, which is we never had said to you guys, like if I come to the city right now to pay the TOT with my credit card, you go and charge me 3% more because you guys are going to say that, okay, that extra cost to you guys. So the customer who come to my hotel and what I'm collecting the tax for behalf of you guys is going to cost me 3% more to me. We never had charged back to you guys. And none of the constitution also say that we need to incur this cost.

2:25:06 But we have a good faith, good trust with Town as our partner. And we've done that for the town. So my attorney has not threatening. I think you guys can take politically whichever way you guys want to. He has not threatening. He is just telling us what is going on. And we're trying to, I'm trying to tell Town to refund that money to us. We paid it in good faith also. But Town can refund that money or give the credit on the for the TOT and everything when we open.

2:25:34 That's what we are asking from here. But it's all up to you guys. Thank you. If I could interject, this is Brent. I've lived in town for since, I think, 2005. Worked not just for Mr. Moriah, but for the mountain and Jeff DeSalvo up at Mammoth Ski and Racket.

2:25:59 And but on this matter, I just want to bring the local face to it and respect that, you know, this hotel through me and my wife's management, we're very closely with everybody and we appreciate what everybody does in town and that we do do this as a community. That part of my perspective on it is, is that that money is actually the hit of that money.

2:26:27 At this time, when it was something that was really directed by the county and the town, as a mitigating factor, I understand the payment necessity of being paid on time for taxes, totally understand that under normal circumstances, I would not even be arguing in our favor against or for the return of those penalties. But in this one situation, which was pretty much

2:26:54 You know, out of our control in the sense that we really did have to readjust very quickly to a very rapidly changing situation. And in the current status of really trying to take care of our employees, that money, in a sense, is money that I can use for our staff to keep our staff essentially solvent within this town, which is a big problem for everybody right now. And I would hope that you just kind of consider that, that that is not money that's going back to

2:27:22 To Mr. Morari and the ownership. But that is money that I use locally to keep this business running to the benefit of the town, the guests, but also the employees, which are very important to me personally. And I thank you for that consideration. And I'll go back on mute. Thank you, Brent. Any further deliberations? I have a motion. Yeah, John. Just real quick. I'm just concerned by the conflation of a number of different issues here.

2:27:54 And so I'm supportive of Councilmember Salcido's motion. Thank you, John. And you know, my number is listed, Brent. If you or Mr. Morori wants to call me and talk after this, I certainly would explain my position. I don't want to get into a back and forth in the meeting. I would call for the item, Jamie. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes.

2:28:30 Mayor Pro Temp Salcido? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. Passes 4-0 with one abstention. Gentlemen, thank you all for your time. We do appreciate it. Moving forward then with COVID update, Dan. Yes, thank you, Mayor. We do have a PowerPoint here. See if I can get it to show up on your screen. And we'll dive into that work.

2:29:05 We've emailed out to Council beforehand with technology to do what it's supposed to here. While the Town Manager is bringing up the presentation, I wanted to read a public comment I received by email. It was from Michaela Vargas. She says, it was with great dismay that we learned today the Town Manager requested Dr. Boo issue a new order extending the short-term rental ban for another month.

2:29:30 Over the past four weeks, our town residents have spoken up in community and county supervisor meetings, and the Board of Supervisors clearly acknowledged the critical danger that our town faces by not having tourism this summer. That is why the County Board of Supervisors last Thursday requested that Dr. Boo refrain from extending the short-term rental ban. Why is the town of Mammoth Lakes acting against this? Thank you. Thank you. That's definitely one of the items we'll speak to this evening as we go forward. I want to note that

2:30:05 You know, Dan, I'd like to speak to that real quick. If you go and you look at what Dr. Boo wrote and what the county wrote, their position and ours is the same, that the state has ordered no short-term rentals. While they have asked him to couch it differently, they show in the document that Dan very nicely sent around to all of us that the county has closed for short-term rentals as well as us. Thank you. Sorry, Dan. That is correct.

2:30:38 I wanted to really walk into kind of our progress forward on how we've been working the last several weeks to move forward on the path to opening up the town where we can and where we can take positive steps. I was going to note that Frank Freevault, our fire chief and our director for the O.C. is here and Dr. Boo is also.

2:31:03 On the call, Zoom this evening as well to provide additional information. Oh, it should be coming through the mic here. I'll make sure I speak loud and that it comes through. The first one, for the last several weeks, we really have taken Mammoth Lakes Continues for a community first emphasis. A lot of things that we've been working on with the community. We have been partnering with Mono County and others.

2:31:38 A lot of our nonprofits, our community, our private sector supporters as well. Some of the initial elements the town did was the renter and commercial tenant eviction protections that went forward. We took a lead out to secure hotel rooms at the Sierra Nevada Resort for housing, for quarantine and isolation purposes, for essential workers, for those who may be experiencing homelessness.

2:32:05 Or as we actually had some experience with some weather into March or April, in April, we actually had some people stranded and needed a place to stay. And so by having that available, we're able to meet those needs. We do spell out all of those types of needs in our short-term rental ordinance. One of the things we wanted to, or the ban element, the order going forward, we wanted to make it clear that there are various uses for hotel property still within the town.

2:32:35 stepped up to house critical workforce here in the community, which has been greatly appreciated working through that process each time. We've also worked with the community food security efforts through the EOC, through Mona County, MLT, IMACA, and others for making sure that anybody who was in need of a meal, if you will, or food for their families had places to go and ways to secure that. That's been a huge

2:33:04 Outreach effort continues to today. We also did a rental assistance program for a number of people in Mammoth Lakes. We put up $200,000 for that. Mono County is looking at augmenting that program as well. We've also received some donations into that. And the program is being administered by Mammoth Lakes Housing. As of today, they've spent about $42,000 for 86 households.

2:33:33 People are definitely stepping up and taking advantage of that program. We'll continue to monitor that as we move forward over the next several days and weeks and going into the month of June. And then also, I'm going to have Chief Freefall speak to this briefly, but a lot of work on PPE, the personal protective equipment for local businesses, and how we're helping set that up and spread that out.

2:34:03 EOC has authorized, or as the commanders, we've authorized funding for that. But I wanted the chief to speak to that particularly and the level of items and the need and how that is progressing. All right. Thank you, Dan. Councilmembers, good evening. So just a quick snapshot as part of the economic recovery branch in recognition that businesses would be under a lot of stress with this incident. About a month ago, we started pulling together

2:34:36 Supply inventory in addition to what we would need for the essential services and emergency workers and we're beginning to now distribute really masks, hand sanitizer, disinfectant. Some of the business sectors need goggles and some gloves and so we're beginning to distribute those items as of this week through the

2:35:05 Chambers of Commerce throughout Mono County. And so we're using that as our distribution method. Planning assumptions were to generally try to provide these consumables for about eight weeks, give or take on pricing and logistic availability and the ability of the businesses to secure their own logistical chains during that time. So that work continues.

2:35:33 Anticipate a big uptick in those requests as we've now advanced into full stage two. I think it's been a positive program and definitely well-received by the community in terms of how we help them proceed through this. And as Council is aware, we went into kind of the preliminary stage two and then into full stage two here, the expanded stage two I'll talk about in a moment.

2:36:05 Over the last weekend as we started into the kind of the preliminary there was a number of areas that we had requests for related to curbside pickup and could that apply to some of the limited term use items i.e. rental like a mountain bike or an area we went through quite a process to provide some guidance for stores engaged in that we provided information out with some guidance for

2:36:35 Our local golf courses, both Sierra Star and Snow Creek, and also for the driving range at Snow Creek, and also for some private tennis courts that have all gotten that advice and laying out the health requirements. And back up one statement in here, all of this has been overlaid kind of from that public health perspective. How do we really try to make sure as we go forward, we don't end up with a...

2:37:03 Upswing or resurgence of COVID-19 in our community. But I know the stores, it was kind of a, it was a benefit to them for several of them who got out and did some work. Sierra Star is opening up this Friday, as is the driving range out at Snow Creek. So both of those businesses taking advantage of that support and advice that we're able to provide under.

2:37:27 The guidance in the governor's office looking at various things that people can go out and do and the exercise elements. Screen froze up. We're really looking at really how do we prepare to go forward for our next. We have received our Aditas attestation that Dr. Boo put forward to the state.

2:38:01 I want him to speak briefly to some of the criteria that we were working through to be able to get the approvals and be able to move forward into the next level or what's called an expanded stage two. We had to meet a number of specific criteria as we submitted that information. A lot of strong effort going into that. I think we got the form laid on.

2:38:31 Monday, put it out on Tuesday, got approval on Wednesday, today about noon. So I was going to ask Dr. Boo if he could just kind of touch on the criteria, the elements that we had to make sure that we're conforming to. And then also some of the criteria we're looking at that would require us to ratchet backwards should we not continue in the positive area meeting the positive metrics that are out before us.

2:39:03 Yeah, hi, thanks, Dan. Tom Boo, County Health Officer. Good evening, Mayor Sauser and members of the Town Council. Yeah, so the CDC, I mean the CDPH attestation form for a variance to let us do a complete stage two, they removed the requirement that was a problem for us last week, the number of cases in two weeks, and instead we had to attest that the hospital was,

2:39:33 Still quiet and doing fine, had plenty of capacity. And then there was a couple of other sort of community testing-based criteria that you could opt for. And we easily met one that required that the percentage of tests that are done that are positive be less than 8%. And we were less than, over the previous seven days, we were less than 2%. And then there were

2:40:02 There was a number of other criteria that were unchanged from the previous version of the attestation that we were not able to submit, including requirements for PPE for the hospital and for essential workers. Epidemiological case contact tracing capacity was an important one.

2:40:35 Ability to provide for vulnerable populations. There's a lot, you know, a lot of impact throughout the state, throughout the nation on skilled nursing homes. And there was, you know, some questions about that, which don't apply to us, but, you know, we did have to describe our ability to provide for community dwelling, vulnerable people, et cetera.

2:41:00 Those were kind of the main points. And then as far as they want to know what we're going to track, what might be triggers for us going forward, because we do all expect that with less radical social distancing, with more human movement, economic activity, we will see an uptick in disease. Seeing that around the world, I hear that Italy's got a pretty good spike.

2:41:30 Right now. But, you know, we would track, we're tracking the number of people that call the nurse hotline who are sick, and if we had, I believe I said a 300% increase over a week's time in calls to the nurse hotline and referrals for testing, if the number of people who are tested that are positive increases dramatically from our current

2:41:59 Baseline to 12%. That would be a red flag for me. Similarly, if there were three severe COVID-19 patients, probably people that need hospitalization, although the definitions for severe might include people who don't require hospitalization, but would need to be followed very closely as an outpatient. But three severe cases within a week would be of concern to me.

2:42:29 Certainly if our case contact team is not able to keep up with the number of new cases in order to effectively and efficiently isolate the sick and quarantine the exposed and perform testing on them. And I picked some fairly arbitrary numbers on that. I believe I said that if they're not able to.

2:42:57 Make contact with each case, with 80% of new cases within 24 hours, or if they're not able to contact 75% of the contacts of each new case within 24 hours of intervening the case, that would be a sign that, for a couple of days, that might not mean much, but if it was sustained over some days, period of time, a week, it would mean that

2:43:26 We were losing control that our ability to contain COVID-19 in the community was really in jeopardy. And they did ask, you know, what we do about it. And, you know, I find that a somewhat challenging question to answer and said that it would depend on what we knew about which demographic groups, parts of the county or town are most affected, whether it's certain

2:43:54 Business economic sectors, or perhaps if we had indications that there was more disease centered in the schools when they're open, our responses could differ substantially depending on what's going on. Obviously, we'd want to try to take the least restrictive but effective approach.

2:44:20 And it could vary. It might just be a matter of increasing education, increasing testing, you know, trying to get, you know, people to adhere more if it's appropriate to, you know, to distancing and hygiene measures, covering their faces, et cetera. But it might mean rolling back on the advances we've made and coming out of stage one.

2:44:47 And if it's a school-based problem, it could involve shutting down the schools for a little while, something like that. So I think basically we just have to kind of take that one as it comes, but I did have to provide some information about our thinking, my thinking in that regard. So happy to answer questions now or later. Thank you. If there's any questions for Dr. Bu on the attestation form, that would be...

2:45:19 Great to ask the question if you have one. Any questions, guys? If not, I mean, it was great to see it approved today. That really allows us to move into what we refer to as expanded stage two. Probably the two biggest benefits there is the opening of retail stores for regular walk-in customers and also the dine-in, seated dining for restaurants, both inside and outside.

2:45:52 We've done a lot of work for putting together the business guidelines, and I was going to ask Frank again to give an update on where we're at with our online portal for businesses to go on. They have to be able to self-attest if they meet the public health guidelines, and we're trying to make that as simple as possible for the various businesses. They put together their own plans for implementing the mitigation measures. Frank, can you touch on the status of that online tool?

2:46:23 Certainly. Thank you, Dan. As mentioned, we received that approval from CDPH a little afternoon today. We have since received Dr. Boo's finalized local guidance for business reopening in addition to the sector-specific state guidance that's on their website already. One of the goals we had several weeks ago

2:46:50 Again, when we started the logistical buildup to support businesses, we wanted to come up with a strategy that would not slow the businesses down once we got approval. We knew that there would be, you know, obviously everybody, you know, trying to get ready and moving at the same time. So the approach that we took was to, in addition to helping the businesses with the logistical support they may need, we wanted to make a very easily accessible and streamlined

2:47:20 So we should be finished up by tomorrow afternoon where we're reconciling the local orders by Dr. Bu along with the state sector specific orders that exist. We have those on an online web portal that a business person can go to and essentially just go through and verify.

2:47:44 A test, if you will, like we did as a county, that they have met those guidelines. The guidelines are laid out there for them. There are a bunch of resources there that would help them with employee training, guidance on how to do cleaning, all kinds of things that are resources for them. And essentially as they go through and then complete that process, we've made sure that that format also meets the state requirement for a site-specific business plan.

2:48:14 I've talked to a number of business owners who, you know, taken the basic guidance from the state and put all kinds of different approaches to it. And we thought this way we could just verify for them to look by going through this process, essentially clicking through on verification. You'll meet that site-specific set of guidelines. So those are inserted. Then when they complete to that process and they confirm that, you know, everything they've put in there is accurate and true,

2:48:45 It also generates for them a certificate of completion of those guidelines for Monon County Public Health. And the idea is for them to be able to place that prominently on a window into their business. We think that's important for them. They've gone through a lot of work to get that done. It gives the patrons a sense of certainty that business has set up a safe experience for them.

2:49:15 We also then have that in the database that's helped us get that message out at the marketing level that Mono County and Mammoth Lakes have done the necessary work to entertain tourists safely. It would also help us as we then do quality assurance checks. We didn't want to slow down the businesses requiring some kind of an inspection before they could open, but we do want to do interagency quality assurance with

2:49:44 Code compliance officers from the county and the town. We'll do some of that work together. And then once they're comfortable with the process, we'll devolve those back into their normal organizations, just like they do today with various types of code enforcement items. I say code enforcement just because that's the, you know, the origin of where they would come from. But really our emphasis here is to be educators and influencers, supporters, helping businesses get going.

2:50:13 And then just make sure if they have any questions out there locally, we can clear anything up. And if we do have the one or two that decide not to conduct business safely, then for the protection of our visitors and our residents here, we'd take whatever steps are necessary to make sure they comply with those items or don't expose businesses and employees in an appropriate way. I think that's the bulk of it. Thank you, Chief.

2:50:49 And in light of that, as we're working with businesses, one of the other things we did was prepared some interim modifications for zoning regulations and put those out in anticipation of being able to get into stage two. That deals a lot with the signage and outdoor use. And I think Sandra is still in the line. I was going to ask her because I don't have it in front of me. I was going to ask her on some of the key elements that we actually modified.

2:51:17 anticipating that we'd be able to be here and that some of the mitigation measures and stuff would actually be better met if we had some flexibilities in our zoning standards and requirements. So I think Sandra is still in the line. If she could just kind of highlight a couple of things that we've done to try to benefit our restaurants and our retail shopping. Sure, Dan, I'm happy to do that. So we took a look at our outdoor dining requirements and provided

2:51:44 The allowance to provide outdoor dining in required parking areas. So taking up some of that required parking so that they can, restaurants can get that spacing that they need. We also allow outdoor display and sales. So normally we only allow three outdoor display and sales per year, typically on kind of our big holiday weekends.

2:52:08 But now we're allowing that through the rest of the year, through September 30th, I believe. So that gives the businesses the ability to put some of their displays outside so people can be in the retail business and then can also be outside as well and kind of, like I said before, get that spacing they needed. Additional provisions allowing temporary signage, so banners. We heard from businesses that they wanted to have some welcome back to Mammoth Lakes type banners.

2:52:36 You know, sale, that type of stuff. So really allowing them to do that as well. And outdoor seating areas for retail businesses with the limitations on the future limitations on the number of people inside the retail businesses that we anticipate, this would allow people to kind of sit outside to wait to come in and go cycle in there. And so that's about it. We did maintain kind of all of our regular.

2:53:04 Zoning code requirements outside of those. And I've received a number of different requests already today with people who are looking to kind of set that up. So I think people are really interested in it and we're responding to those questions kind of as they come in. If I may on that, we've also set up kind of a little weekly round table with a group of several local businessmen here and businesses here in Mammoth. And they've had some great comments and questions and issues. And that's where some of the modifications came out of.

2:53:35 Having a discussion with businesses on how do we help them be successful in moving in through this pandemic, if you will, and getting into this section of the stage two. And again, one of the key issues in doing this is we can get the businesses open. We give them a lot of flexibility in how they can structure what they're doing and look at other options that can benefit them. The key issue that is still probably the

2:54:05 Most significant challenge is having the proper customer base to make the businesses successful. And for the town of Mammoth Lakes and largely Mono County, that means visitors coming into the county. We need to have other people coming in and being here and willing and able to spend their dollars on the types of offerings that our communities offer. Under the current

2:54:34 Governor's order for people to stay at home and as implemented through the public health officer at the state level's orders, the real issue there is a ban on non-essential travel. And that is true regardless of what we do with our short-term rentals. The ban is still there. There's some other elements to that. It applies across the state.

2:55:01 We've had a lot of conversations where people are asking why are other communities allowing short-term rentals or hotels to be open, and I actually had a conversation earlier today with the state Cal OES side representative there, and they fully understand what they're seeing happening, and their statement is that type of activity does go against the governor's order and the public health orders. Their biggest challenge is the ability to...

2:55:29 So what we were trying to do as we looked at our own short-term rental ordinance and the activity there was really looking at trying to provide some community clarity and provide some additional opportunities as we look to the future.

2:55:57 One of the questions we heard repeatedly in some of our community conversations was a question about second homeowners, people who own a unit here in Mammoth Lakes, and this pushed the fact that they should not be here. And that was probably one of the most difficult ones to look at because one of the essential elements in the governor's stuff deals with building safety, security, public health related items to that.

2:56:25 Being able to be at your property and choosing that in this case, if you wanted to make Mammoth your permanent residence for a period of time and you own a home here that you could do that. So trying to clarify that as a second homeowners do have that ability and right to come and check on their property. We had several phone calls. I took several myself just in terms of people wanting to come up and

2:56:49 The house has been vacant for a number of months. They need to check on it. They have a security system that is acting up. They want to make sure that they can correct it and fix it. Or they have a sensor, one in a water heater system that looked to be acting up. And the last thing we want to do is have somebody's home damaged or worst case something happened, it would catch fire and damage other homes as well as their own. So we wanted to clarify when we talk about banning short-term rentals.

2:57:18 Second, homeowners are excluded from that type of a ban. The other element for doing that here in the town of Mammoth Lakes is just giving the vast number of short-term rentals that we have and knowing that we still have people who do it illegally. In this environment, they tend to pop up a little sooner than if there's a bunch of other ads out there and those types of elements that we're able to crack down on those.

2:57:44 Potentially that are doing it illegally. Those that have a tax certificate but choose to violate the order at the state level and now at the town level continuing to reach out and rent to people, again, we don't want to encourage that type of action here in the community either. And I think Rob Patterson's still on. He can speak to some of the challenges that he has with his team in this area. And the ability to enforce a local order.

2:58:11 It's actually stronger, we believe, for our finance department than what the statewide order allows us to do. The statewide order by the health officer actually directs the various sheriffs and chiefs of police to do enforcement efforts, and we really don't want to dump this on our police department. It belongs within our finance department. It has the tools and the expertise to do so. I'll talk a little more about a couple other exemptions, and I just wanted to have...

2:58:39 Rob touched briefly on the enforcement process. The other thing that we... Go ahead. The other element that we did for clarification in our order, we actually took out the... We had the terms of RV parks and campgrounds in there, and that was creating conflict over our ability to regulate federal lands and what did that look like, and there was a fair amount of...

2:59:06 Kind of ambiguity in some of the other things that we have seen happening across the state in Alaska. Phillip descents from the Forest Service to speak to this in a moment and their plans as they go forward. Same thing dealing with some of the different owners of permittees in federal land. So we wanted to be able to set those aside so we could deal with it. Everything from the question of if I go backpacking, can I actually go camping?

2:59:32 The forest allows dispersed camping. Well, if we're saying you can't do that is how do we deal with those types of issues? So we had a lot of conflict there. We wanted to make clear that those are outside of at least the town's ban on transient rentals. And then also just the public health side of that. One of our challenges, we'll talk a little more about this shortly, but the number of people that could show up legally or illegal for that process is back to that.

3:00:02 Surge of people into our community and that risk, the metrics that Dr. Boo talked about earlier, if we start to see upticks and other conflicts, frankly, the last thing we want to see happen is that we have to ratchet backwards on our opening program and plan. That is something I know the state is watching and looking at as well, statewide as well as across various counties. So before I go on with that, let me have Rob talk just briefly to the enforcement element.

3:00:30 And ongoing review. And then the last piece of this, when we were discussing some of this with the lodging people here in town, a little bit of a mixed response, but I think they wanted to have a hard date that they could work with with their calendars versus the open-ended element that now is currently in the county, which is under the governor's order until such time that it has changed. So they really don't have a

3:00:58 Any type of way to build out or do reservations without just reminding everybody that they have, will potentially have to cancel the reservations if that order is not modified. Sorry, Rob, if you want to touch briefly on the enforcement side and our efforts there. Yes, thank you, Dan. You know, and I want to kind of reiterate a point is that we're not in the game of enforcement to be difficult and challenging for people. It's really to level the playing field.

3:01:27 You know, for the people that are abiding by the restrictions that are there and those that are not. And we definitely want to come down on those that are not. Otherwise, it's just chaos and loss of absolute control. Some of the feedback that we have received, and Dan touched on this a little bit, is the benefit of having a specific date with which we can go out to. For my team, we can check calendars via our electronic systems.

3:01:50 And know whether or not people are blocking off their calendars in accordance with the order. And we can make phone calls associated with that. So we can make sure everyone's kind of following the same piece. But to have something open-ended, like for example, if we would allow for this particular health order that was through the end of May to expire, that would send a message to some percentage of the people that, yeah, it's okay to start renting now, even though it's not. And then there would be others who would understand that and heed.

3:02:20 We have extensive

3:02:49 Extensive tools at our disposal up to and including revoking someone's business tax certificate for up to 12 months for violating the order. Now, I'm certainly not going to start with that, but that depending upon the severity of the infraction, meaning someone who should well know better and certainly does and chooses to ignore it, I would not hesitate to pause them for three months. And if they continue that, go on for another 12 months. I mean, it's just we all have to be.

3:03:18 On the same side of this and working in the same direction. So that's sort of the enforcement effort. So we want to come in my team. They spend a lot of time doing a lot of heavy lifting and I appreciate that. But it's really in support of those that are following the orders more than it is to be challenging and difficult for the others. Thank you, Rob. As you mentioned too, I think it's a lot easier to police our hotels who have really stepped up and embraced the challenges than it is some of the...

3:03:47 You know, VRBOs or Airbnb or smaller projects out there. The larger condo projects were some that definitely had requested this type of information as well so they could actually inform their guests and plan and look to the future. So I think it's a positive step the town's done versus leaving it open-ended and without some of the clarity that members of our community were asking for.

3:04:13 The other thing we've been just recently really been able to step into is opening up some more public spaces. Stu mentioned a little bit at the beginning of the meeting, but the skate park will be going forward shortly. I think Thursday's tomorrow or Friday's the date for that. We've worked with the Forest Service to move forward opening up Shady Rest Park for passive activity there. The disc golf course will be getting set up and getting that open. Whitmore Park is a large play area can open.

3:04:42 Our bike paths in town, our MUPS, our multi-use paths, they are open people for recreating on those, walking and biking, jogging, substantial use with that. The Lake Mary bike path is in the process of being cleared. Hopefully the next few days with the warm weather, it'll be completely open on up to Horseshoe. And then all of that still requires mitigation measures. And that's one of the ongoing comments we hear that

3:05:11 As people are out and potentially interacting with others, they do need to keep in mind face coverings. They need to keep in mind the six foot of distancing. Any type of group activity currently is prohibited unless it's the same family unit or those household living unit who live together can recreate together, if you will. So maintaining that element, that's one of our challenges. We've looked at kind of this.

3:05:38 Informational process, educational process on the enforcement side that deals with signage. The police department, I think Al's still on, was looking at even the potential. We did it with snow packing on top of vehicles. It's a problem. A little like three by five card and stuff. Hey, by the way, are you aware, you know, these are the rules in town, you know, try to act that way. The other thing, it seems as people are out, if there's more people,

3:06:07 Actually, complying, those who are watching in the area tend to step up and comply as well. So overall, I think our community has stepped up in a number of areas and are doing a good job. We do have the outliers, obviously, that choose not to follow the rules. And also, as people come in and visit from out of state, which we cannot prohibit under our orders, now and again, they're not quite familiar with the amount of the distancing or the face covering requirements.

3:06:36 The idea to continue to wash your hands and continue to move forward in that perspective. I mentioned earlier that all of this is set up to maintain the public health element that we're trying to move forward with, that we want to maintain and gain in our metrics. We truly do want our businesses to be successful and healthful as they go forward, as they open. We want to make sure they have the proper PPE that people come in.

3:07:06 They understand that it's a safe environment to be. The other balance to this, we've had personally and other comments related to employees who are very concerned about going back to work and having a lot of visitors coming through where they're working at, be that in a restaurant or in a

3:07:24 Other high traffic business that can open. And there is that concern on the employee side. So we're trying to balance this public health requirement issue and this idea of security and safety to the extent possible. Frankly, knowing that we will see an increase, we believe, in COVID-19 in the community. And that is an area of concern, but one of knowing that would happen. Ultimately, that spread and hopefully what would be natural immunity coming from some of that.

3:07:54 I'm going to let me pause there before I start talking about the work in partnership with our federal agencies and others. If there's any questions, Mr. Mayor, on the items we've touched on to date or through the last hour or so, and then we'll dive into the last few. Any other questions? No, Dan, I was just typing you a note here on the last. We're going to let the Foreign Service respond. Yes, I will. So let me. Thank you. Yes.

3:08:26 One of the key issues that we've been working on is looking out how do we pair both local residents, folks here in Mono County, Mammoth, you know, Bishop, you know, the areas around where people come and recreate in this region from. How do we really get ready for that? And then also for visitors who are up, whether they're second homeowners or out of state or traveling in violation of the governor's order, frankly.

3:08:54 And we've been beginning to work with our private folks, local folks, and our federal partners, looking at that going. As folks come up, and if you go up into the Lakes Basin, there is a lot of tree work going on. There's some safety issues there. We are stepping up and saying, how can we help up in there with trash and with toilets and all of those types of things to help that be a better visitor experience and experience for our local residents as they're up.

3:09:23 Recreating in that particular area. A lot of the trailheads have some of the same challenges and so we're looking how do we step in and partner with the Forest Service in some areas there and doing that. And what we're seeing though is a lot of pressure to open things up. We have a lot of dispersed camping going on in different areas of the county and frankly the region. We're looking at those. There's a lot of push on fishing season to open just as soon as possible, you know, even this weekend.

3:09:53 That, frankly, is somewhat concerning because if we get a lot of people coming up who aren't locals going out, you know, where do we put them? How do we manage that? How do we end up with that extra people in town? Looking at how do we open up some of our marinas and boating, some of that as under permittees, another thing. I think if it's a single person or a family unit in a boat, that's probably allowed as a recreational activity.

3:10:19 Obviously, I mentioned hiking and biking and the activities going on there. We have people out off-roading doing that. I think a lot of people are stuck at home actually have free time and are actually getting out and enjoying our recreational areas. So deal there. And then, of course, the question came up on camping campsites and also looking out to dispersed camping. And one of the concerns we've had with dispersed camping is with the fire season.

3:10:47 Quickly approaching and the fire restrictions in place already. That obviously is a concern. We also have a concern over increasing trash and improper disposal of human waste out in the forest. I think one of the biggest questions have raised up on that is the camping component or the campground elements. And so I wanted to fill the sense to talk about that from the Forest Service perspective. We've been looking at their orders. And again, how do we come alongside?

3:11:14 Frankly, help move some of that potentially forward. We're seeing other forests within the state open up some camping areas and would love to be able to provide some level of area of that within our community and within the county. So dealing with two different forests and regions there as well. So Phil, if you're still on, if I could have you speak to where the Forest Service is. I know I think you had your leadership team meeting. I think it was today. Meetings blur into each other here.

3:11:43 And then we have Gordon Martin on the call as well to talk with the work that we've talked to him about partnering with in the Lakes Basin, Reds Meadow, and here in town as well. And he also covers the Mono District, so some aspects around that area as well. So I'm going to turn it over to our federal partners at this point to speak to some of these issues. Thank you. Well, thank you, Dan, and thanks to the council for inviting us. Both Gordon and I are on.

3:12:12 Some other questions we can't answer come up, but just wanted to briefly summarize where we're at and what we're thinking about moving forward. As you all know, we've got a closure of our developed recreation sites through June 30th. This is an extension of the existing closure, so no additions, no changes at this point to that, but it is specific to the forest as our region moved away from having something that's region-wide.

3:12:42 To allow forests to adjust to whatever the conditions are locally. So that's why you do see some forests that are ready to either themselves or through concessionaires open up some of those facilities. We're not there yet, quite frankly. But we are working closely first with our concessionaires to get them to a place where they can safely open their campgrounds. A lot of them are targeting that June 1st date.

3:13:10 Several of them, particularly in Mono County, don't even have the campground hosts on site yet. They need to show up, be on site, establish that they're safe and healthy. They have the PPE they need to do, the facilities cleaning, and then do all the regular work that needs to be done to open a campground by cutting trees.

3:13:30 You know, doing minor repairs, getting water systems operating, all of that stuff that we would normally be doing, you know, a month or so before now is taking place and just started taking place in the past few days. So I liked what you said about, you know, we just because we can open whenever that date comes doesn't mean that we're able to. And the way we look at what we're able to do is dependent on either ourselves or the applicable permittee.

3:13:56 Having a COVID plan in place to implement all of those mitigations that are necessary, have the proper staff to be able to do it and have the PPE to do it safely. And the one element that we're still waiting on, our final guidance on, and we should be getting, I was told yesterday, now we're supposed to get it tomorrow, is the cleaning protocol for our recreation facilities. I don't wanna create sort of

3:14:25 Hypothetical situations, but it looks like for the facilities that we and our concessionaires maintain those fixed restrooms, permanent restrooms, that we're going to have to be doing it at least daily with quite a bit amount of PPE for those folks that are doing it.

3:14:40 One, it's having the number of folks to do that work. We're not staffed at that level and we'll likely have to have facilities closed the entire season, at least some of them, right? So, and then procuring the PPE to allow them to do the work at those sites we identify as the most critical with the staff that we have. So, for our concessionaires, they're starting to get folks on site and do all that work. It usually takes two to three weeks and that's what we're looking at for them, I think.

3:15:08 With the understanding or belief, you know, that the state orders will be relaxed because obviously that's another component that needs to take place before we or our partners or concessionaires open up any campgrounds is that travel, non-essential travel, tourism, the folks that visit our campgrounds and stay there would be permitted.

3:15:30 Under the governor's order or lack thereof. And then when it comes to our facilities, our folks are starting to come on next week. Several of them are coming from out of the area and have to self-isolate for a couple weeks before they can engage in the type of work that we're talking about. So we're probably a little bit further out on the campgrounds that the Forest Service manages directly and other related facilities. And then the third wheel of this is our other permitted sites, the resorts, the marinas.

3:15:58 And those types of things. So a similar process they need to go through as the concessionaires do to develop a plan. But we're not at this point entertaining, authorizing them to go back to serving the public with the lodging facilities or recreation equipment at the marinas and that sort of thing.

3:16:17 Until we get that governor's order, that stage three, where we want to be. But we're looking at some of those on an individual level. And then I think Gordon will probably talk more to, you know, how maybe the town or the county can help us get to where we need to be. Portable restrooms are a big question mark for me because

3:16:36 Do they need to be maintained at the same level we would maintain fixed facilities? I don't know the answer to that question, but I do know we need to at least communicate with the public when or how frequently they are being cleaned. And typically that's in a port-a-john with some sort of, you know, log that indicates when it was last cleaned.

3:16:55 We may have a similar requirement there that they have to be cleaned daily. So obviously, even if you have a contractor do that, they only have so much staff, they only have so much capacity, and whoever's paying for it only has so much money to do that work. So there's still a lot more questions than answers, but I think we're starting to get to a place where we know what questions we need answered in order to get to that next step. I'll let Gordon take it from there. Good evening. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, council members.

3:17:29 Yeah, the, we need to keep in mind that this is a gradual approach, even when we do get the authority to open things up. Just like in a normal year as the snow melts out, we gradually open up things, you know, we start here, we start there. We're going to have to go through that process.

3:17:55 Anyway, even when conditions are right that we open up. And as Phillip said, a lot of it's going to depend on what we can do. And I've been working with Matt and Dan and Hayes to develop, well, you know, see what we can do. They've been very helpful in assisting and providing.

3:18:25 Portable restrooms and dumpsters before we can get in and open up our sites to allow that to happen. You know, there's a lot of work to do that we do every year to do these things, but we're starting that a little bit later than we might have. That's the removal of the hazard trees, getting the water systems on, making sure the roads are on.

3:18:54 in good repair. All of that stuff is something that we need to make sure that we're getting done before we get out there. I think Phillip covered most of everything else that I was going to cover. So, you know, if we can answer any of your questions, please let us know.

3:19:26 Thank you, Gordon. If there are questions from Council on the Forest Service side that we need to ask at this point as we work with partnering up on that, we will be asking Council from additional funding in terms of helping with some staffing and some of the port of toilets and the maintenance of those as well as with dumpsters. We've done some outreach to Mammoth Disposal who supply some of those port of toilets to get a cleaning regimen if they have guidance.

3:19:53 Industry guidance and or CDC type guidance that covers that so we can make sure that we're meeting those requirements. Same issue of getting our own staff the proper PPE for doing that type of work. And also looking at some of the vault toilets that we've helped with in the past, that same standards will be interesting to see the federal guidelines as they ultimately get out and posted that we can look at. We will have additional conversations regarding some of the, I'll say the

3:20:22 Marinas are something, not so much some of the resorts in terms of units being rented, but having people be able to almost from a retail standpoint to be able to operate. Again, there's different guidelines and different elements they'd have to provide there. But looking at the ability to have some of those types of activities open up for folks from the recreational side, a lot of demand, frankly, coming out of that just from the local community. It's not just people traveling to Mammoth to do that. And so there's that.

3:20:51 Element here. And then we'll be looking at options in terms of just the health and safety of dispersed camping and some challenges that we see in that area as well. So it's a multifaceted challenge before us. Definitely one that we want to be able to move through in a measured way. I think it is that slow go step at a time and make sure we're opening stuff as it's appropriate to do so. And that we're addressing the.

3:21:17 Health concerns and understanding the needs of concessionaires and the Forest Service staffing challenges there. And we had slowed, we had the process slowed down initially on purpose, knowing that we're in this pandemic and it wouldn't do a lot of good to have a whole bunch of people here to open something up that you can't utilize. And so we have been cautiously walking through that. We will be looking, working on some time frames for the lake space and as well as ultimately for Red's Meadow for...

3:21:44 So no opening in there and different activities. It can happen, at least at the local level. So with that, Mr. Meritor, is there any questions related to that or from other council members? Questions, folks? John? I think Cleland had a question from before. Yeah, just because I did receive a phone call, I just want to clarify any kind of gathering in any place. Some people have expressed an interest of getting

3:22:18 10 cars together somewhere, 20 cars maybe with people six feet away. My understanding is that is not approved at this point. They're looking for next weekend, I believe on Friday night. Figured I'd just ask right now.

3:22:47 I think Dr. Boo could speak to that. I believe if it's a gathering, if they all stay in their vehicles and they park, okay, I think they could probably do that. But as soon as they get out and start mingling with one another, they will be a illegal gathering unless they're all currently living in the same house together. And Dr. Boo, if I've misspoken there. No. Hi, Dan. I mean, the state order basically, I think just says no gatherings will occur, shall occur in stage two.

3:23:19 Yeah, exactly what constitutes a gathering. I mean, I think it's almost one for the, you know, for the attorneys, but I agree with your interpretation, but I'm a doctor.

3:23:29 Yeah, I'm not sure where they would be able to execute this on Forest Service land regardless, but yeah, gatherings at 10 or more. This is why our group campsites, for example, that's going to be later, if at all, that we ever get to that point where we have group campsites because by their very nature, there are more than 10 people and multiple households at least getting together.

3:23:52 Okay, you know, I appreciate that because now I can just have people go back and watch this portion of the meeting and it won't be coming from me. So I appreciate that. Thank you, fellas. But there is the overarching question for all of this of enforcement.

3:24:11 That's a really fair question. We have very limited enforcement capability. We have three law enforcement officers for the two million acres that make up the Indian National Forest. They're the only folks that at this point we're having actually go and do any close contact with individuals and that's...

3:24:29 It's exclusively when there's some sort of health or safety issue related there, you know, fight or a fire or something of that nature. We have a lot of folks, including our prevention patrols, that are forest protection officers and able to enforce.

3:24:44 This order, but quite frankly, we're not having them go out in the field and do that type of work. We're really focused on education, continuing the message that the governor's order is in effect. You're not supposed to be traveling from outside of the area, and you're not going to be able to find a place to stay most likely if you do. So that's worked very effectively so far, but...

3:25:07 People are getting the itch to leave. It's Memorial Day weekend. We understand that the adherence to that is going to continue to dwindle the longer that we go on with this. So we're doing the best we can with what we've got. Understood. You know, there's really little ability on the part of any of our agencies to enforce these best practices, if you will.

3:25:29 We are monitoring that type of activity, you know, and that's what most of our folks out in the field are doing. They're also looking at these are the areas that have been damaged or there's excessive human waste or trash. So we know when we get to that point where we're getting closer to being able to reopen, what we need to do before we can even enter the facilities to clean them or we got to clean up outside of them. So we're doing a lot of that. And I just want to make one other point that's a little separate.

3:25:54 You know, I understand the need for folks locally to be able to access places like a marina, but we can't allow access for one group and not another. We're not able to do that as a federal government and very difficult, if not impossible, to distinguish between the two in any sort of legal way. So we're not really entertaining that as an approach that could be effective for us. Thank you, Philip. Appreciate it. Yeah, John, go ahead.

3:26:24 Yeah, I just want to thank Philip, Tammy, Gordon for coming here this evening. I think what's very clear to us is that the staffs are all working very, very closely together. And I think that that's where a lot of this activity has to happen. I think we need to really commend the community of Mammoth Lakes for having made the investments. Things like trails coordinators, trails programs, sustainable recreation coordinators to be able to provide the staff, the bodies that we need to make all this stuff work.

3:26:54 And I think we're all, as a council, and again, I don't want to speak on behalf of the council, but looking forward to doing whatever we can to work with our federal partners for a successful summer. If we need to advocate to the federal government on behalf of our community and our residents, then we will do that. But I just want to thank you all for showing up and for the spirit of cooperation going forward. And you certainly have the commitment of this council to really...

3:27:19 To continue to serve as a model for sustainable recreation and cooperation between federal agencies and gateway communities. We're going to do everything we can to make this stuff successful. So I just want to thank you for your time for coming this evening. And I'm very much looking forward to the work effort we're going to do together to be a model for the county, the region, and the nation about how to take on these kinds of challenges and make these things work. And that's all I have to say.

3:27:47 I think we all know the things that are going to be happening on the staff level. I think that the EOC has now put in place with Dr. Boo and Frank and Dan and Mr. Lawton in Mono County. We've gotten this to stage two in a way, and the great work has been done there. We've established a foundation we can move forward. Dan, I'd like to at some point talk about that fishing opener conversation when it's an appropriate time to do that. That may not be. Yeah, because I mean, that ties into a lot of the issues here in terms of if there's a push.

3:28:16 Right now, I believe the opening date would be June 1. I know the county was having a discussion about trying to look at maybe an earlier opening, making a request to the Director of California Fish and Wildlife. And our biggest concern over that from the town perspective really was the number of people coming in, again, with no place to stay. If that goes out that says, hey, we're open for fishinging, people read that as we're open for a place to stay if I come and fish.

3:28:45 Versus just locals going out, which would be great. But the concern there is that twofold. One is not having a place to stay, so then it's back to the either illegal activity and renting or it's staying in the forest, dispersing out accordingly. And or the other element to that too comes in that we anticipate a lot of those folks would be coming through Mammoth Lakes with the new opening and as well as our other communities with retail and

3:29:14 Restaurants in that issue areas. And again, we're back to how do we manage that in a way that doesn't result in a, you know, unanticipated spike in the COVID activity that we see in our community. So trying to balance that out until we're actually ready. It'd be nice if we had places they could stay and they can do some of their own cooking and management.

3:29:38 Better hygiene, if you will, may be available through that type of a process as well, just in terms of hand washing and face coverings and those types of pieces. So while it's great to have it open, a lot of local folks I know would love to go out and take advantage of it. And the same question that runs into is you can't open it for locals only and tell everybody else they can't come in. And or we have a lot of people coming across state lines as well for those types of activities.

3:30:08 It's been an ongoing discussion. I know Chief Freevault has been in the middle of that, so I'll have him speak to some of that as well. And last comment beforehand, it's been good having several of these of our federal cooperators on a regular meeting with the EOC each week. That's been a benefit as well. So, Frank, if you want to weigh in on some of those items. Just one quick item. First of all, again, thanks to our local federal partners. We meet weekly.

3:30:36 On items, Gordon and his staff, and that's been very helpful. Quickly do a share screen item on something that I think will help explain why we are really wanting to make sure we have our game on as we enter this next phase. This comes from the, let's see here, I have to pull it up here, give me just one second, I apologize. Here we go. Okay, can you see my screen there? Yes.

3:31:29 Okay. So this comes off the state's website just on, you know, essentially where are these cases at. And you're all very familiar with what our drive market is. And this is the, you know, the activity of cases by county. And so as we, you know, prepare for this next stage, you know, we can see that we're in a spot to receive as a part of our tourism base.

3:31:58 A part of the state that's been hit very hard by infection. So we think we're ready. I don't think there's a whole lot else we can do to be prepared. We've had great cooperation with our Montana County residents in Town of Mammoth Lakes. But just as a reminder, as we go forward, if you're wondering why sometimes we pause just a minute or we're thinking, you know, just a couple more seconds before approving something or, you know, being totally optimistic about everything.

3:32:27 I just want to be clear. We understand this is where the infection's at in the state. This is where our economy comes from. We just really want to make sure we're thinking these things through. Okay. Thank you, Dan. And thank you again to our federal partners. It's been great the last couple months here as we've worked with you on a weekly basis. And I think just in terms of the phishing opener, I think if it's a question of a week, I think what's been really emphasized over the last couple weeks is that EOC's worked so hard to get us to the stage two opener.

3:32:57 You know, as goes Mammoth Lakes. Unfortunately, a lot of the cases tend to seem to want to pop up in Mammoth Lakes. And if that happens in Mammoth Lakes, it's going to affect the fate of Levining, Bridgeport, our brothers and sisters in the county up in the north part of the county. And we certainly don't want to do, draw anything into the town of Mammoth Lakes that's going to affect the fate of the economic fate of the rest of the county. And I think waiting a week, I don't think it's too much to ask for all of us because we are all in this together.

3:33:27 And we don't want to inadvertently do something that's going to affect the economic future of the entire county, the entire region. If we can take another week and give the EOC and all of our partners some time to get ready for this, the fishing opener, so we can do it responsibly. We've got a great opportunity now being in stage two. We don't want to blow it. We want to be smart. We want to be proactive. We want to set an example. That's one council member's perspective. So thank you.

3:33:59 Other comments or questions for our federal partners are on the items touched on here. If not, we have one other item to cover as we look into our stage two and the support there and expanding out to help our businesses. But open it up for any other questions or comments from the other folks that are on the Zoom here, if anybody else wants to speak to these items or not. And I don't know if we've received anything else, Jamie. You know, Dan, one thing I wanted to point out.

3:34:31 A lot earlier on the lodging request was how many of the lodging partners had asked for this extension as well. This wasn't done by you and just the EOC. None of these decisions are being made without outside input. So that goes with the Forest Service, that goes with everything we're doing. I think there's a lot that don't understand that. So I just wanted to get that out there a little late in the game, but I did.

3:34:57 Yeah, a lot of this discussion, as I mentioned, there's groups of community members, it's the weekly meetings, EOC activities, the community conversations, meetings like that, where a lot of different comments and information is definitely coming together and being sensitized, and then, frankly, making the best decisions that we can make, and hopefully we're doing it correctly most of the time, if not beyond that, so. Yeah, I just...

3:35:28 Wanted to say good evening to everyone. And I'm thankful to my rangers. I wasn't sure I could make it tonight. Yeah. And I just, I want to thank the town of Mammoth Lake mayor and the council for all your support during this really difficult time. You know, I think the values that we look to every day is how to, you know, thread that needle.

3:35:58 Between public service and providing great public service and continuing to provide safety to our employees and the publics that we serve. And I know that you all share those same values. I sense that every time that we meet. The last couple of days have been a little bit challenging. There's been some desire to maybe open some things up more quickly than we can do.

3:36:27 And so I just want to thank you for your continued support. We're doing the best we can to thread that needle with those values of public service and safety for everyone. So just appreciate it. And Rangers, good job tonight. Good to see you. Thank you, Tammy. Thank you, Tammy. All right. Anything else from the Rangers there? Are you guys good?

3:37:05 You don't have to make comments here if we're done. I'm looking at Dr. Boo and Frank as well prior to going back to a shared screen here. Not hearing anything right off. I wanted to jump into the last item we had, which was really kind of a last piece of a lot of our community investment program as we look at putting some of our community first and how do we look going through this.

3:37:39 Struggle with the economic challenges that's been before us. Many small businesses are and continue to struggle, and they will. The element here was trying to look at across the state at some other programs here that are coming forward. Sandra Moberly has done some work on this, and she'd actually put together a write-up that I didn't get sent out to you in advance, so if she has it in front of her, she can speak to some of the findings that we've been looking at.

3:38:08 The economic recovery team did a good job of doing a survey out. I think that they're, I'm not sure if the updated one is back yet, but talking to a lot of our smaller businesses and the challenges that they're facing. And is there a way that we can step up and be able to define a proper public purpose to invest in those small businesses? Andy Morris is very helpful in that area, making sure we're utilizing town funds correctly.

3:38:38 But a lot of that takes a look at, you know, how do we protect jobs? How do we not have blighted buildings, if you will? How do we protect our tax base? A lot of the communities out there are focused on their brick and mortar type stores and businesses for the vitality of their various shopping areas and downtowns and communities as a visual element. Again, kind of goes back to the blight elements in terms of communities that you don't like to see.

3:39:07 And then a lot of it is focused on smaller businesses. That's always a defining question of what does that mean? Is it people? Is it income? Is it other things of that nature looking at key needs? Is it rent assistance? Is it...

3:39:31 Some employee type payment assistance, something that they're not eligible out of the federal or state programs. How do we step up into that? And what do we set as a time frame if we do something? What do we look at? You know, businesses were up and operating well up until mid-March when the shutdown happened. The success expectation. If you actually support a business, you know, what is that element that they're going to be up and running?

3:39:59 90 days, you know, 120 days down the road. And looking at that need and trying to nail that down as well, similar to our rental assistance program. We've talked about it potentially from a town doing some seed funding. We'd have to determine amount and source for that. And then looking for council comments to that. Before I come back to council, let me ask Sandra to kind of touch on some of the items and some of the findings we had of the survey data.

3:40:27 And information that we got from our business community across the county. This isn't just Mammoth-centric in the process of gaining information. Sure, Dan. I'm happy to talk a little bit about it. In mid-April, Mona County Economic Development, they conducted a survey, and the respondents to the survey were overwhelmingly small businesses. They had 85% of the respondents reporting that they had less than 10 part-time employees.

3:40:57 And at that time, 92% of the businesses reported that they were operating at reduced revenue levels, and 50% of them weren't receiving any revenue at that time. That survey, there was a number of different requests that the businesses had in the survey, and we've actually, the EOC, the town, the county has actually gone through and done a lot of different things.

3:41:22 So looking to help with confidence building for reopening, communications, the rental assistance program, gift card drive, best practices for reopening. So a lot of things that were suggested in that survey have actually been completed, which is great. There was one request for localized forgivable grants. So something where the town could provide grants, small grants to businesses.

3:41:48 So we took a look at a couple of different other grant programs. The city of Novato has a grant program. It's pretty basic. They provide grants, awards of up to $5,000. And it's really for small businesses. So they really see small businesses kind of the core of their community and the businesses that might not make it through this without help.

3:42:12 So they don't allow grants for like home-based businesses or franchises or those types of things, but small businesses. And then Nevada County has a relief fund. It's a broad fund. It's a broad kind of program. There's a bunch of different components to it. They do have a micro grant program as well, which is also $5,000.

3:42:33 They have a lot more requirements with their grant fund and it's being administered by the Sierra Business Council. So they're kind of going through and looking at it, but it all is intended for small businesses. So we have some good examples of different micro grant programs. And I think, you know, we're just kind of posing the question to the council, whether or not you'd like us to take a look at this, bring something back, you know, or if you have any other ideas on it.

3:43:05 Thank you, Sandra. And so kind of laying out just a concept here at this point, kind of like we do with the rental assistance program for some direction from town council to move this forward if that's a desire. If not, we'll let it drop here versus putting a lot of effort into it. The other element, just as a heads up, we've done other outreach. I have talking with the Mammoth Community Water District, for example. I believe they have an item on their agenda tomorrow.

3:43:31 They'll put a letter of support in for it, get it done tonight still, but it would be, just got news about it earlier today, so looking at up to a 25% water and sewer bill reduction for in the community is a way of helping people, again, just who can't meet their bill payment, but it would be across the board, and it's sizable, I mean, it's about $100,000 equivalent per month for the three months, so about $300,000 of

3:44:00 Kind of across the board benefit to our community members who have water and sewer bills within the community. So that was great to hear that, that they were stepping up and looking at how could they step up and help local businesses. That was great. And homeowners as well, et cetera. Similar to the stuff we're looking at. Ours has been a little more focused on terms of rental or in terms of what we're looking at here for our small businesses. But those types of things coming together and those community partners and discussions have been

3:44:30 Really positive to see other agencies stepping up where they can help. So with that, we're looking at council comments, discussion. Again, we don't want to make a program that is so complicated that we can't implement it. We need something that's relatively flexible and I'll say relatively quick for some businesses. I've talked to half a dozen or so that, you know, they're falling behind on some rent and their fear is I'll never get caught up until, you know,

3:44:59 Two seasons out, so need a couple of fantastic years to be able to get caught up. I've had conversations with some landlords, business landlords, asking them those same questions. They're kind of in the same boat, depending how invested they are in terms of making loan payments or tax payments or other elements that they have to do. So kind of a two-edged sword through that level as well.

3:45:26 Anyway, looking for council comment, ideas, if there's a desire to see this move forward, we could bring something back relatively quickly. Sandra's done a lot of work on it to look at how do we step up now and look at some help for our local businesses, similar as we've done for our renters and just families in general in the community. Yeah, Cleland, go ahead. Oh, I'm...

3:45:53 Encouraged to hear this type of conversation. I'm interested in hearing whatever we can do to help the small businesses. And, you know, I've been looking into different, but I like what Sandra was talking about. And, yeah, let's go for it. Let's pursue. And that's very heartening also about the Water District as well. So thank you for that update, Dan.

3:46:23 Linda? Yes, absolutely. Sandra, thank you for doing this background work. I'm sure there's a lot of things out there and learning more about them, how these are funded, how they're administered. Yeah, absolutely. Anything we can do to help the burden of these businesses, especially our smaller businesses. I've talked to a couple of people that just...

3:46:48 You know, broke my heart. It's like no income. My landlord wants their money. What am I supposed to do? You know, so, and also a lot of people are not receiving the loans that they have already applied for through the federal government. So put all that together. I think anything that we can do community first, this is absolutely great. So, yeah. Thank you, Bill. Community first. Dan, really heartened to see the work, you and the staff, everybody's working on this.

3:47:19 Looking forward to seeing what you come up with. A couple of thoughts. One is the transition of things like the food bank into, if it's going to be a maca, whatever it is, with the sense that we're in this for the long haul. We may not need it, but if we do need it going into next fall, next winter, that we've set up our systems and our institutions so that we can be in this for a year. You know, God willing, hopefully we're not going anywhere near that, but so that we can do that. Food bank.

3:47:50 Thank you.

3:48:16 Looking forward for your ideas, thoughts, and suggestions, and this being at the heart of the tough decisions left to make going down the road. So thank you. Kirk, any comment? I'm very supportive. That's my comment. Thank you. For me, I want to say this. This town lives on the backs of its small businessmen. Mammoth Mountain is a huge concern, and yes, people come to ski, but it is the little businessman that established this place and keeps it going.

3:48:47 As being one of those, I have not drawn anything myself in three months. And while I am fine and don't need this, I fully support us doing something. My only caveat is I need to see where we're drawing that money from to sustain the program. Because it could indeed be in a longer term than I anticipate, being that I'm fairly, you know, positive about these things.

3:49:15 So hopefully, Dan, that gives you what you need on that. Any other comments related to that or to the COVID update in general? Thank you. Thank you for all the hard work you guys are doing. Bill, I don't want to be on the dark side of things, but if we kind of plan on the worst side of things, then hopefully we'll be good for it when it's not as bad as we all hope it's not going to be. It was just pointed out to me that I said businessman and I didn't say business women. So obviously I include those all.

3:49:46 Businesses. There you go. No, I think we're doing, you know, this is tough, but I'll tell you, our staff in all areas have just excelled. Every morning when I log on and start doing stuff, I'm just amazed. So thank you to everyone. I have one more comment on that. And it's not really about this that we're giving out. Was Dan and Rob in the lead on our finances as a town?

3:50:17 We have kept an incredible conservative budget moving forward. It is that budget and the way we have all handled this as a town that puts us in a position in these tough times to do the rental assistance and to do the small business assistance. If we had been running as business as usual, none of this would happen. So I have a passion for that budget and how we do it. And hopefully we can continue to.

3:50:45 Move this town forward in that manner. Dan, back to you. Yeah, with that, we'll continue to work through that program, bring that back. We'll continue to work through the stage two, expanded stage two level of our businesses and try to respond as we can. We've got a number of requests that come up on this and Dr. Boo fills with the same issue, everything from how do we get created for a little league game to

3:51:18 Fishing, guiding and pack stations and a number of other things that have popped up and it's just really, really difficult at times in the decision-making process that we find ourselves in and wanting to say yes to things at times that we probably can't and others, how do we creatively get there, walking that fine line of the legal aspects that we have to watch and walk through, but very, very

3:51:46 Encouraged by the decisions we do make and be able to stand by those and be supportive and working with our federal partners and others, we do see ourselves coming out the other side of this in a positive way and stronger and a lot of different elements of our community that will be strengthened from this process. Before I leave the COVID update, I was going to give Dr. Boo one more if he wants to say anything related to the work.

3:52:13 He's looking a little more refreshed than he did a couple of nights ago, so that's good to see. I'm happy to take any questions. I mean, the development of the business guidelines, guidance was also really challenging, just not enough evidence about COVID-19 and the risks of transmission in different settings to go by and, you know, looking at what was out there and, you know, had a lot of support from.

3:52:42 From some good county folks. But the objective, of course, is to be safe to allow us to operate. But I know that a lot of these new ways of life are gonna be cumbersome. And I just maybe should emphasize that the guidance that we...

3:53:08 Put out. It's the best we can do it, you know, at this time. And, you know, it's a fluid situation. And as we learn more about what is and isn't necessary, certainly expect to modify things. You know, we tried to be flexible where we could. You know, like initially we thought, you know, it's mandatory to launder betting between each guest. We thought that was...

3:53:32 Probably normal and standard, but then found out it's, you know, that some outer coverings are not routinely laundered and there's not even the laundry capacity in the town of Mammoth Lakes to launder all the duvets and bedspreads of, you know, of all the lodging. And so we've made it a recommendation, but I'm asking that businesses, you know, make their practices easily available to the public. And we...

3:53:59 Last week, the state just came out with restaurant guidance as we were trying to put the finishing touches in our guidance. They put out some more industry guidance. So we had to go back and take a look at where we matched up and where we didn't. And there was an interesting thing. I don't know how useful it might prove to restaurant owners, but I hope it will be of...

3:54:24 Some value. There's now an alternative to a strict six-foot spacing requirement between tables where if there are impermeable barriers between the tables, the spacing can be reduced. And so that's probably going to take some creative thinking. It might work for some business owners and not for others. Certainly from a public health standpoint, I heartily support the idea of outdoor dining.

3:54:53 But again, asking business owners, restaurant owners to check with town planning offices to make sure there's no zoning problems and things like that. So yeah, a lot of work and I hope it helps keep us safe. Thanks. So Tom, I have to ask you, how have you liked this little part-time public health officer for Mono County gig? How's that working out for you?

3:55:25 No comment. My quality of life is not great right now. Thank you for everything you're doing, Tom. I know it's been something you stepped into and yeah, you're still here. You get real points for that. Thanks, Linda. I've been neglecting my patience in Bishop for sure. He needs a raise. Talk to the county. Everybody deserves a raise in this, that's for sure. You're doing a great job.

3:56:00 Dr. Boo, thank you so much for all your help. Thank you all. I guess I'll take my leave. Good night. Thank you, Tom. If no other questions for us, that would conclude our update on the COVID-19 pandemic and our work. All right. Thank you, Dan. Thanks to everybody that is working so hard on this. It is, if nothing else, contentious. Moving on then to Council Member Reports. John.

3:56:35 All COVID all the time. That's all I got. Thank you. You got it. Linda? Same old, same old. Cleland? Yep. All COVID all the time, just like John said. Kirk? Same, same. And me. I'm not all COVID all the time. I am dealing with a lot of other things, but I am definitely talking COVID. So moving on from that, we will go.

3:57:09 to a closed session, a closed session item, so I need everybody that is not part of the closed group.