TransparentMammoth

Other meetings · 2020

Other meetings

· recording 1 hr 32 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

193 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:02 Okay, we're ready to go. Excellent. Good morning. I will now call to order the regular meeting of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments Joint Powers Authority for June 12, 2020. Please join me now in the Pledge of Allegiance. Ready, begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands.

0:36 One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. And thank you, Bishop City Council Member Jim Ellis, for having a lovely American flag on display for us this morning. It's come in pretty handy lately. We will begin today's meeting. First, we'll do, Angie, could we please do roll call?

1:07 Yes, ma'am. Supervisor Corliss? Here. Supervisor Gardner? Here. Council Member Salcido? Here. Council Member Wentworth? Here. Supervisor Griffith? Here. Supervisor Tothero? Here. Council Member Ellis? Here. And Council Member Schwartz is absent. Thank you. Thanks. And now we'll move to item four, public comment. Is there any public comment on items?

1:37 Not appearing on this morning's agenda. I've received no comments via email and I have no one in the audience. All right. Then we will move on to item five. Approval of the minutes of the May 15th, 2020 special meeting. Those were included in our agenda packet. Are there any comments or need to discuss the meeting minutes?

2:02 I could just make a quick comment. It looks like my last name might be misspelled in a few places. I know it's a really tough one, but it looks like the second H is missing in a few instances. Good. Well, let's definitely amend the minutes to spell your name correctly. Any other changes needed to the minutes? I'd look for a motion to approve the minutes as amended. Okay.

2:35 All right, we have a motion by Supervisor Griffiths, a second by Supervisor Gardner. Is there any further discussion or public comment on this item? Hearing none, please call for the vote. Sorry, I was muted. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Council Member Salcedo? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Supervisor Totharo? Aye.

3:13 And Council Member Ellis. Yes. Thank you. All right. Now moving on to item six. I'm looking to my colleague, Council Member Wentworth, who's going to lead us through really the next three items. So we can kind of take six, seven, or really four items, six, seven, eight, and nine together. Is that correct? Yes. If that's a pleasure of the chair, I think it'll be

3:45 Easier, more efficient to do that. There have been some updates since I submitted the slide packet to Angie for the packet that hopefully make for a more efficient presentation and let everybody in on some very important and interesting breaking news. So if it's possible, if I could share my screen and just share some slides. That'd be great. So I will let you lead us through this discussion and then these four items are...

4:13 For discussion only. So we'll look forward to the presentation and then turn it back to discussion. And I'm going to mute myself. Thank you very much. So some of you will recognize some of these slides that came out of the ESSRP partner meeting that happened earlier this week, if you can believe it. That can't be right. It's probably, you know, it was two weeks back. And I really wanted to...

4:40 Make sure we can have a discussion along the way if we need to. So if anybody's got something that they want to stop and pause and talk about, and let's really try to look at this through the lens of the ESCOG, the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, and sort of flesh things out as needed. And Stacy, there might be a little bit of a place for you to provide an update along the way on one of these items. So we'll just go through this one at a time. So this is what the partnership meeting slides look like.

5:09 We heard some interesting updates on partner efforts, things that are going on out there that affect the partnership, affect the public. Tammy Randall Parker gave an update on a partnership effort she's working on with LADWP. There are some pilot projects she's talking about. I'm hoping, I'm assuming that Dan and Jeff, you may have some insights into what's going on with this. She says she's going to be rolling something out in June, so we can look forward to that.

5:39 The initiative, the SRTI, the Sustainable Recreation Tourism Initiative, is moving into an online virtual space, as everything is these days. And there was an update on how that was going to work. There were two, there's a webpage that's been produced around website closures. It's been shared out with various jurisdictions and various NGOs and partners to give information on recreation closures. And then there was an update on the Innovative Finance for National Forest Grant Program, which we'll get to in a second.

6:08 So the portal for all the projects for the SRTI will look like this. This will be launched in the coming weeks. I'll give you some more information about that, but we shared this with the partnership. This is what the page looks like for all the recreation closure information. This is being maintained by MLTPA, a local nonprofit, to provide information about closure information that's being shared out. It's actually adding a fair amount of activity.

6:37 As a webpage, it's getting 1,000 plus views and things like that. It's hopefully something that's hopeful for our recreation audience. And then we hit on this Innovative Finance for National Forest Grant Program. So the grant has been awarded. And this is a project, a program. These are the kinds of things that could go through the ESCOG. These are the kinds of opportunities that the ESCOG, once we get kind of fully organized, these are the things that we can be doing as the ESCOG.

7:06 Right now, it's going through MLTPAs, which is providing the project administration for it. The significant amount of the grant is going to a group called Quantified Ventures, which is a nationally known consulting organization that's working to help the Forest Service with recreation infrastructure. This is all about trying to find alternative ways to finance and maintain recreation infrastructure. This is in text from the press release.

7:35 It was a nationally visible thing. 1.8 million grants announced for innovative finance for national forest programs. This is a national thing. These are the kinds of things that the ESCOG could very easily be applying for, be getting awarded for, to help support costs of staff, to help do the things, to build the capacity and bandwidth we would do to do things. So this contract is going to go into effect in the next week or so. This program will get started.

8:05 This idea was the brainchild of Nora Gamina, who's the forest engineer in the Indian National Forest. And so this is good. This is coming forward. This is happening. Then we went in the ESSRP meeting. We went on to get a variety of different updates. What's nice about the ESSRP, it's an information sharing group pretty much at this point. So as late changing things happen, we can adjust the agenda accordingly.

8:33 Stacey Corliss gave a very interesting update. I don't know if you want to share anything, Stacey, about the work you've been doing with the other counties on the west side, but there's an opportunity to share some of those kinds of things. If you want to say anything, fine. If you don't, you don't have to. Do you want me to do that now? Yeah, just maybe share with the group and just reiterate the kinds of things you're doing with around Yosemite and those west side counties. Yeah, I think it was actually a really successful model for planning and advocacy.

8:59 It's not a title or acronym that rolls off the tongue easily. The Yosemite Gateway Area Regional, the Gateway Area Coordination Team, the YGACT. But that's led by Yosemite National Park, Mariposa County, Tuolumne County, Madera County, and Mono County. I was invited in after this effort had formed.

9:25 It really started out because Mariposa's health officer, for a brief time at the beginning of the pandemic, was covering for the other two west side counties. And so it got them going in a coordinated fashion really early. But we started our advocacy first. Well, first it was planning with Yosemite National Park. Of course, the Department of the Interior was...

9:50 kind of putting some pressure on Yosemite and other national parks to have, you know, reopening plans and get open as soon as possible. But the Park Service leadership in Yosemite wanted to wait and make sure that the neighboring counties were ready for the impact, particularly around short-term rental, lodging, and campgrounds. So our first advocacy effort was to send communication to the state around

10:17 Opening campgrounds as soon as possible. And then a week ahead of, I guess it was two Fridays ago, we sent a letter regarding short-term rentals that the park was planning to open this week as it did, and that the gateway counties, especially the west side gateway counties, absolutely had to have the ability to legally allow their hotels and short-term rental operators to accommodate visitors.

10:45 And so, as we all know now, those efforts were successful. And I think having the support of the National Park Service and showing that we were working in a coordinated regional fashion with the support and guidance of our health officers really helped. And the group is still meeting as we continue reopening and pandemic response.

11:13 Yeah, I think it was fortuitous to have a partnership in place because as things are changing so quickly on the ground and counties, regions are kind of self-selecting, reorganizing around things that are happening very quickly. It was great. Obviously, it's great, Stacey, for you guys to do that kind of work, but to have a forum that we could share with the regional partners to say these are the kinds of things that are going on. So that was great. We also heard, I think, from Dr. Boo, gave an update.

11:41 And I think as part of this kind of larger discussion, we established a sense that everybody was kind of on the same page across the three counties, across the federal agencies. There was a sense of, okay, we're sitting in a common space, which was helpful. We then moved on and as part of the regular meeting, got updates from each of the partners. We started with the state jurisdictions because they were obviously being guided by guidance coming out of the state of California.

12:11 Useful, again, just information sharing, people, different agencies sharing where they're at, what they were doing. LADWP, haven't gotten them participating yet. They've been showing up some, not so much other times, but we have to be good to get them part of it. But then leading with the state agencies, then the federal agencies could say, okay, well, we are actually going to be tiering to the guidance coming out of the local public health officers. And this is a big point of concern, as I think, as we all went into this at the beginning.

12:40 How would the federal agencies align with local public health officers? Would they tier to them? Would they say, we have authority from the federal government, we can do whatever we want to do? It's been very interesting to see how this is all rolled out. I think at the end of the day, it's been very clear that they have wanted to go absolutely in lockstep and following the guidance of local health officers. It was an interesting thing to be able to see how all this.

13:05 Kind of turned out. What's been interesting also with this is the participation of the Park Service. All the Park Service units, they have a designated representative through Bernadette Johnson, but I think the supervisor of Yosemite National Park was on the call as were some of her assistance. As you may know, the Devil's Postpile, Deanna Doolin, announced her retirement. So there's some things going on with the Park Service. And we'll talk about that Rivers Trails Conservation Assistance Grant.

13:33 That's in place for the partnership that should be coming online at some point. So we'll talk about in a second. We then started, we hit on and talked about messaging a little bit. And this is the messaging that the Forest Service has produced. And we shared what's happening on a national level. This is a national campaign about recreate responsibly. You can see it's all a bunch of organizations from across the country that they're doing this. And this is, you can see some of this.

14:00 Collateral and some of the stuff showing up in your feeds around any of these organizations you may be associated with. It's also been interesting is what Tahoe is doing. If we think in California, we've been having these discussions around regions. They've stepped up in a pretty significant way, a responsible recreation branding campaign that is on posters, signs, social media, it's distributable. It seemed like an interesting model.

14:28 And there's an opportunity for us to do something similar here in the Eastern Sierra through the partnership. Probably maybe not as ambitious as what they're doing in Tahoe, but I think these tools will be available, I think, in the next week or so. Again, MLTPA is going to provide the graphics and all the collateral pieces. If any of the agencies want to do production, if you want to print posters, if you want to do that kind of stuff, that'll be on.

14:54 The dime of those agencies, those partners want to use it, but at least we have something in our back pockets to be able to use to be able to distribute out across our region. Certainly, especially as visitors, folks really start to return in earnest. We're going to use the Tahoe playbook, how they've set it up, what the directions are like. It'll be hosted on a Google shared drive, very easy to access. Anybody can get access to it. Download these things and we can have a regional message or regional kind of...

15:23 You know, name, brand for ourselves around responsible recreation in the Eastern Sierra. Not perfect, but it'll be something. And again, the degree to which the partnership and the ESCOG is, it starts to merge or tries to merge to do these kinds of things. These are the kinds of things that we could be doing on behalf of the region when these kinds of circumstances arise. Tahoe, I'm pretty sure it's going through the TRPA, the Tahoe Regional Planning Authority, which is an authority which has staff, which has money and resources to do things.

15:52 That's something we can maybe be aspiring to, but this is an example of the kinds of things that we can maybe be doing. And this ties back into the initiative. This is the members of the Visitor Connection Working Group. So as that communication collateral gets developed, we've got, you know, 25 different NGO and partner communicators who can take all that stuff. Their audience is in the millions.

16:13 I mean, it's in the several millions of people that they are communicating with on a regular basis that we can get the message out about how to recreate responsibly in the Eastern Sierra. So it's another example of how the different bits and pieces come together around a regional voice and a regional identity for the Eastern Sierra. So that's a basic preview of what happens in this ESSRP meetings.

16:37 It's information sharing. It's informal. It's flexible. It's agile. It can change at the last minute. There's no Brown Act requirements for any of this stuff. And I think it's been a useful forum so far. It's a good model and set of ideas for the ESCOG. And I'm going to give you an update on some things happening with the initiative now. Any questions or discussion or thoughts on the partnership meeting so far?

17:05 Everybody's happy. Okay, good. So we'll just, I'll give you some updates on this real quick. So the rec, there are four tracks in that initiative grant. This is that $620,000 grant from Prop 68 in the state of California. The recreation stakeholder meetings, which were intended to be in person across the region, obviously that can't happen anymore due to COVID. So this is all going to be migrated to an online web portal. I showed you a brief shot of that at the beginning of the presentation. And that should be up and live mid-June.

17:35 And we're actually pretty confident that we may actually get better project ideas and project feedback and information through that web portal than we may be getting in those in-person meetings. We'll see how it goes, but it's going to be up mid-June, hopefully, and then we'll do a very significant marketing and outreach program to get the public involved and engaged. It's going to be great for local residents, local communities, but also for the wider...

18:00 Eastern Sierra Recreation audience because it's going to be web-based. You're not going to have to come to the east side to participate in these meetings and get your project ideas going forward. So it could have a significantly larger reach. The Climate Vulnerability Assessment, there's been some very exciting things happening this week. And so I'm going to share a couple of web pages to give you an idea of what's happening with that. Give me one second here.

18:35 Okay. Sorry. I'm maneuvering my tools. Here we go. So the initiative has contracted with a group called PlaceWorks to do the vulnerability assessment. PlaceWorks is probably the foremost climate change consultant working in the state of California. They're writing all the major documents for the state's climate change programs. They're also partnered with a group called ICF.

19:14 This is a bunch of what we hope are high-powered economists out of the East Coast who are going to be doing the natural resources evaluation and the evaluation of the value of the outdoor recreation economy in the Eastern Sierra. So these are the two specific deliverables coming out of that group. What popped up just this last week is something called the Sierra Nevada Recreation and Infrastructure Vulnerability Assessment and Adaptation Strategy Partnership. This is actually an effort of the U.S. foresters.

19:42 So they have been working in parallel on exactly the type of data development that are going to be needed by PlaceWorks and ICF to do a very, very thorough and contemporary analysis of the value of the outdoor recreation economy in the Eastern Sierra.

20:02 And provide all the data inputs for that vulnerability assessment, which is a pretty exciting thing. I've been involved with them about a year ago, but I was not aware that they were so far along with their project, and they're actually publishing their paper and they're publishing their GIS data. This is a story map, and I can share these links later, that the effects of climate change and infrastructure and recreation in California. This is an incredibly timely document that they produce. And we've set up a meeting for next week.

20:30 Between this Forest Service team and PlaceWorks and ICF, so they can start sharing all the data, rather than going back and reading forest plans from the 1980s, they could be actually working on the contemporaneous data that's with us. Like I said, I share all these links. But you can see here, they've put together a very robust data set. It comes from the Forest Service, which is really great. There's a lot of data. It's all in GIS, and there's a lot of data in the back of the house.

20:59 that we can be using as well. In addition to that, we've reached out to the Outdoor Alliance. They developed a lot of data around recreation uses in the Eastern Sierra as part of their advocacy of the Inyo National Forest Management Plan. So they've got every little recreation activity you could possibly think of in their GIS data sets. They also have

21:24 Use data, how many, you know, how, with what frequency people are using these various recreation activities that the Forest Service doesn't have, that we're working with the Outdoor Alliance to try to develop that data and make appropriate arrangements so that this information can flow into place works and flow into ICF so that we can have an even better economic valuation of the value of the economy, the outdoor recreation economy here in the Eastern Sierra. So these are some very exciting things that have come together just this week.

21:53 I was having an enthusiasm overload. I think it was Wednesday. But this is all very exciting stuff to see all this stuff coming together this way. This is the technical report that that Forest Service group has produced. It's not ready for publication yet. It's in queue to get printed up with pictures and all the glossy stuff and all the rest of it. But it's all this stuff is here. So this is a very exciting things that have come together, especially

22:22 For the Eastern Sierra, because we, through that grant with Prop 68, we are the replicable model for the state. And as Stacey talked about earlier, this groupings around regional needs, about regional articulations, that ties back very specifically to the effort that the state of California is working on with this.

22:48 And I participate in something called the ICARP Technical Advisory Council for the Governor's Office of Planning and Research. The Region's Rise Together program lives in that group. We had a meeting on Wednesday. And for the state to understand that their policy goal around climate change is moving forward through a sustainable recreation program in Eastern Sierra is a very exciting thing for them. And it's something that puts us on the radar and on the map with a very distinctive set of opportunities.

23:18 We're all living in a powerful and extra chaotic, historically significant period. And it's hard to know what level of political commitment the state's going to maintain until regions rise together. It's hard to know. I mean, you guys, the county level, you guys probably have a much better idea than we do in the Humboldtown level as to what's going on up there. But this is still alive, theoretically.

23:42 And the role of the Eastern Sierra as the replicable model for the state around advancing state policy objectives, economic development, all the rest of it through this program, it's pretty exciting. So we're on the radar, and I think through the SRTI, we're going to be producing a very interesting, very compelling vulnerability assessment around outdoor recreation, tourism, our economic bread and butter, and that's on track. And all these people can work virtually, so this is going to keep happening.

24:12 So it was a pretty interesting week as far as those things were concerned. So then back to the SRTI. So the Visitor Connection Working Group, that's a group of 25 people who are messengers to people who get the message out to the larger world. They've got a meeting coming up next week. They're working on their messaging. What is the voice? What is the message of the Eastern Sierra coming from them? And then...

24:38 All of this rolls up into project prioritization, which will be happening in 2021. Who knows what projects and what things we're going to be needing by the time we get to 2021. But the vessel is there, the container is there, all the communication outreach tools are there to keep this thing moving forward. And we'll certainly be reaching out to you for all of us and all of our constituents. It's a point of engagement. I mean, this is the toolkit to reimagine the future of the Eastern Sierra.

25:05 And as difficult and as challenging as that sometimes sounds, it also sometimes sounds like the greatest opportunity we ever could have had. And the degree to which we get inputs and things are coming into this, it could bode very well for the future of the Eastern Sierra. And the role the ESCOG could play in this, who knows, but this is coming and this is going to happen. On the Rivers Trails and Conservation Assistant Grant for the National Park Service,

25:32 We had a brief call with them about a month ago, but they were pretty overwhelmed. I'm going to go back and follow back up with them. This is certainly something that the air service in Inyo County was enormously compelling and a great interest of the park service. And we'll just have to see as things come together. It's a chit. It's a grant. It's there, I think, as we move through.

26:00 The new world of COVID, the new world of ski resorts, the new world of air service. We see what that all looks like. This is in our back pocket. We can figure out what we want to do with it. Certainly around the non-winter, the non-snow-based recreation, there's an enormous need for this. We'll just see where that goes. The other thing was the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator. You may have all, I'm sure you all know the name of Matt Ferrello. He's really been doing very important.

26:27 Liaison and coordination work up here in Mammoth County with Mammoth Lakes. I know he's doing work in Bishop and Inyo County as well. You know, it's something to be thinking about, but it's proving to be invaluable as a liaison with the Forest Service. I think he's doing especially great work with Mammoth County. Just doing the most basic connections of crossing T's, dotting I's, liaisoning with the District Ranger, with the Forest Service staff on both the HD and the Inyo National Forest.

26:55 It's really, I think it's proven to be enormously successful. Mammoth Lakes Recreation is going to be going through some changes, I'm pretty sure. I don't, as a council member, I haven't gotten the packet yet. I think it's coming out today. But I think there's going to be some discussion about that happening in the next weeks or so. We'll see how all that goes. Then, of course, as part of the ESSRP meeting, we talked about the ESCOG. And we advised everybody that this meeting was happening today.

27:23 The ESSRP has a governance committee, and Bob's been doing some great work with that to get that all organized and at the appropriate time. When the ESCOG is ready to have a conversation with the ESRCP and the local agencies to figure out how we go forward, what the needs are, what should be the goals and objectives, how to do all this, this is all queued up and ready to go if and when the time gets right. And of course, there's always a thank you slide and a reminder that the next meeting is coming up July 6th.

27:52 And Stacy, so that pretty much covers it. I think we just covered six, seven, eight, and nine. And so I will stop sharing and throw it back to any discussions or questions amongst ESCOG. Thank you. Yeah, are there any questions or comments from board members? John, you kind of went through one of the slides quick. The little fun signs that had like a kid on there, public distance. Is that Tahoe?

28:25 That's in Tahoe. And that's their program. And we're going to produce a program very similar to that for the Eastern Sierra. And we'll let you know when you've got it, when it's available. And you'll be able to download flyers, big posters for outside of businesses, flyers to put in the windows of businesses, things for social media, Instagram, Facebook, things like that with some suggestive messaging. It's modest, but I think if we all use it, it could be useful and helpful.

28:53 It's an example of the kind of program that we could build into. I kind of like the fun component of it. I work for DWP and we have the most generic signs that are almost redundant where you don't even read them anymore. They're just blue and white and a lot of signs. Something that's kind of simple and fun is different. You know, you see signs every single place you go, but something different that pops out a little bit. I like that concept.

29:19 Yeah, and we hope in the next week or so we'll have something and we'll get out to you guys. It'll be downloadable off of a Google Drive. Very simple thing and do with it whatever you will. John, I had a question. You know, you go, you live within this world and so all of these pieces and these agencies make a lot of sense to you just automatically. I find that I lose track of who's where and who's under what. Is there a kind of a...

29:50 At a glance, boxes with names in them that we could have as a sort of a cheat sheet. And maybe this is just me. Everyone else totally gets it and understands where all these different agencies are and what they're doing. But that's just my own request, I guess. Is there a way that you could take information your brain has and put it in a, you know, at a glance? I think the most efficient way to do that, Linda, is

30:15 I'm more than happy to carve out some time and you and I can just sit down. I can do it with any member of the group if we want to. We can just walk through it one step at a time. It actually, I think to do something like you're talking about would actually make it worse. Is that it going to be worse? Yeah. So I think that if you or any member of the ESCOG or the public for that matter, anybody would want to sit down and just kind of walk through it slowly, deliberately, one step at a time.

30:43 The reason I think why a lot of this is kind of confusing is because things are changing very, very quickly and things are happening very fast. In a normal world, it would be probably a little bit more deliberate, a little bit more one step at a time. But as needs and COVID and other things are driving needs within agencies, things are happening quickly. But I'm more than happy. We'll find maybe over the weekend, take an hour or two and we'll sit down and just kind of go through this.

31:13 One step at a time, and that's, for anybody else that's interested, I'm more than happy to do that. I guess I'm going to validate what Linda said. Jeff, would you like to be part of the group? Maybe, depending upon the time, but can you... Hey, I'm doing well. Hey, I want to know if you'd get state guidance out for opening up movie theaters. Yeah, can you mute yourself? So, I want to give you a heads up on that. They do have limits in terms of...

31:43 Dan Holler, you need to move yourself. Yeah, 25% capacity or 100 people, whichever is less, distancing and stuff like that. I just muted him from here. Thank you, Angie. It happens in the past of us, the mute or unmute feature getting away. Go ahead. So I will share that presentation and I will share all those links that I just showed and I'll get them to...

32:13 I'll get them to Angie. She can share them out to the group. And then anybody, again, I will take whatever time folks need and we'll sit down and just kind of go through this one step at a time and make it clear. I think it's in all of our interest to do that. And Jeff, you've left us for the moment, but I know you'll come back. But again, seriously, that's a standing offer. So I'll get that stuff available, get out through Angie, and then we'll make the time to sit down and go through some of this stuff. Yeah, and I think it just...

32:42 Linda's comment is a good reminder to all of us that there are a lot of moving parts and it is confusing. So we really have a huge responsibility as kind of the proponents of sustainable recreation and regional partnerships to do our best to try to explain this, I mean, not only to each other, but to the public, both to our residents and to our visitors.

33:09 To periodically check in with them and say, so not, you know, especially with the visitor outreach group of the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative, you know, I still really hope that that group can somehow do some polling or surveying of the visitor audience to see what their thoughts are on it, rather than just, well, let's come up with ideas, our ideas, and push it out.

33:37 How could we, how could it come from the ground up? How could it come from the people we're trying to message to? That's still something, it seems to me, is often missing in our discussions, and just Linda's comments reminded me of that, because, and it's come up for me and for our board a lot, I think, just in COVID-19, we can talk about this in a little bit, just with the confusion around what's opening and who's responsible and people, and of course, in that context.

34:05 People can get real angry and afraid and have really strong emotions and just something to, you know, all of this is going to get mixed together over the next few months. So whatever we can do to be like, hey, here's this agency and this project and it's related to this. And yeah, and by the way, please use a campground and don't have a fire. Go ahead, Supervisor Gray. Yeah, I was just going to say, I don't know, Linda, with...

34:36 Whether this is what you had in mind, but a visual portrayal of every agency in the Eastern Sierra involved in recreation with some sort of creative lines, dotted lines and other assorted connections would be incredibly useful. So that, and frankly, on one page, not a huge poster, but figure out how to do it on one page. And then separate from that, I mean, this conversation

35:03 Sort of suggests to me, we need that for everything in the Eastern Sierra. So that just to Stacey's point, when somebody says, I don't understand how COVID is, you know, involving all these agencies, we can have a thing that says, here's all the jurisdictions that exist in the Eastern Sierra on one page, so that people quickly can get a sense of, oh, I get it, federal, state, local. It's a challenge, especially if we do it visually, not with narrative.

35:30 But figure out how to do that. We used to do that at the federal level to show, unfortunately, our motives were different. We did it at the federal level to show what a mess it was. And we'd have all these lines and all these agencies and everything. We need to do it here to show perhaps the complications and imply the mess, but at least do it to explain the interrelationships and the dependencies. And it's not impossible to do, but visually, it really makes the point really fast. And I'd be glad to.

35:59 to get involved in that because it can be a challenging yet fun exercise. Thank you because, you know, sometimes you, I sit here silently and I think everyone else gets this except me, right? Obviously, John and I have sat before poor John and gone through this and make notes and it's still, I just lose it now. Ask me COVID, got that. I can tell you that COVID upside down and backwards probably, but this is, you know, so I'll continue to, you know, meet with you, John, and you can.

36:31 Continue my education. I'm glad that I'm not the only one that sometimes sits here and says. Yeah, I apologize for sharing the back of the house. I mean, this truly is the back of the house that you're seeing, but you get a sense of what's going on. But to Bob's point and to Stacey's point, everybody's point, there is a way to articulate that, to do it visually in a way that you can get to that easy to digest level.

36:59 I think the challenge for the ESCOG and the partnership and other things is to what degree the region is going to invest in that and say that this is something that's important and make a commitment to doing that over the long term as part of who we are as a region. The pieces are all there and it can be done and then we just have to, I guess, figure out is this something we want to do? Do we want to invest in it? Is this in our economic, social and the interest of the natural resources?

37:28 We'll see how that conversation is engaged, and we'll see what we go with. Thank you, John. Thank you all for all your really hard work and dedication to these projects. Of course. Stacey, from a Brown Act perspective, if I want to put together an email with the links and with the presentation and all the rest of it, can I send that out to the ESCOG directly, or do I need to go through Angie to do something like that? I'm going to look to our council, Grace, to answer that. Oh, Grace, sorry. Yeah, you can tell us about that. Sorry.

38:00 Yes, go ahead. You can send that out if you just want to distribute some information summing up what was discussed, you know, at this meeting with additional info. That's fine. Okay, good. I'll do that. I'll do that this afternoon. Thank you very much. Maybe just BCC all of us so we don't accidentally reply all. Okay. I don't know how to do that. I'll ask someone who knows. I'll say don't reply all at the very top of the message and I'll just... There you go. That works too. There you go. Good.

38:29 Great, thank you. Is there any other, did we have any public comments, Angie, on items 6, 7, 8, or 9? No, I received no comments. All right, and so I think that wraps up board discussion, great discussion, and really an important focus point for this JPA, as John pointed out. So we will now move on to item 10, discussion and direction.

38:57 I guess possible action on COVID-19 regional impacts and response, including discussion, decisions and actions by public land managers and or other agencies. I'm not sure who's leading us through this, but maybe do we. Hi, Stacey. Oh, Dan, do you want to lead us? Yeah, this is Dan. Sorry. Let me. Too many things going on this morning.

39:29 Yeah, we won the item on there just so we get a feel for kind of what's happening in Mono County, Inyo County. And then if there's some feedback on some of the other gateway communities, a lot of that is are we kind of moving in the same direction or not? There's a couple of different elements going on across the communities. And if there's any desire in terms of sharing information that way. I know there's a lot of stuff opening up this weekend in Mono County and other counties, assuming Inyo as well.

39:58 We're looking at a bifurcated opening of lodging with lodging coming online in the town of Mammoth Lakes on the 19th. The other last night additional guidance came out for some other industries to open up in terms of personal care services such as nails or facials or massage or those types of things, tattoo parlors, etc. I guess it's considered body art so they can open.

40:25 Anyway, just wanted to kind of check on that. We're getting the Forest Service is moving through their opening. We got an update on that for the various campgrounds and the process they're going through. We are working with Mammoth Mountain, trying to see if we can assist them in opening up their bike park, for example, for activity. The lakes basin in Mono County are here at least, and out of Mammoth is still closed at this point until we get the SCE project wrapped up in terms of tree removal.

40:54 Those types of things out there. So didn't know if there's any other differences across the region in terms of BLM and Whitney Portal, for example. Then the HT is, I think, following a similar pattern in Mono County. But it's an opportunity to say, how are we doing? Are we on the same page with things? Lodging probably being the biggest issue. And then obviously all that weighs into ultimately how do we kind of manage the public health side of this in terms of potential impacts.

41:23 And then also messaging out to our visitors, not for their safety and their concerns as they come up, but also for our employees and trying to address some of the concern they've raised over just going back to work and a lot of little fear and trepidation, I think, in terms of what may happen. So just trying to check on this one, give you all a chance to have a conversation around that, what's going on in the various communities. And are we generally kind of moving in the same direction? A lot of the state guidance is driving that.

41:52 That was the goal of this item. Great, thank you. So I think we maybe move along to reports from each agency. Inyo County, do you want to start us off? Jeff, Dan? Or Clint? I see we have Clint. Yeah, I think if Clint is available in his black box there, because I could give some information, but it wouldn't necessarily be correct. Well, there he is. We'd love correct information.

42:26 Sure, so Inyo County, we are the stuff that the guidance came, the businesses the guidance came out on on Friday. We've been working on attestation since then. Those will all be opening today, which includes short-term lodging. In addition to that, guidance on theaters came out on Monday evening or early Tuesday. So we've been working on that. Our theater will be opening Friday.

42:57 Sometime today, attestation is, or I'm sorry, guidance is supposed to be coming out on personal care services. My understanding from our public health folks is there was a, there was a, not a divergence, but a failure of communication between administration and public health. And public health was actually kind of surprised that the guidance was coming out on personal care things. And I think there was kind of a push to move that back that was unsuccessful.

43:29 By state public health. So based on that, we're looking at that carefully. We're going to kind of see what happens this week based on the openings that we previously had. And then our public health folks are going to make a determination on when we feel comfortable having those things open. However, we are encouraging all of those businesses once the guidance comes out to follow that guidance and be prepared and get their attestations done for whatever point they are.

44:00 I'm able to move forward with that. Working with a variety of folks on things that are kind of, when the guidance has come out, there's stuff that's in between. And so working out and trying to fit those in between things are where we give somebody something that says,

44:18 You know, for example, the Badwater race, they're looking at how that works. And so there's guidance for professional sports without audiences. There's guidance for, you know, recreational activities. And so kind of looking at a variety of those things and seeing if there's a plan that can be come up with that makes that work. I think as was mentioned earlier yesterday, the Forest Service released where they're at with the bulk of their campgrounds. Here the BLM has opened.

44:47 Tuttle Creek, Horton, and next to Tinamaha, Goodell have opened. I think they're going to be, that's what's happening in Inyo County. The Forest Service opened, Mown Pine Campground, and Upper and Lower Grays last week. They're opening up some more, a fair amount more today in the Bishop Creek drainage. And then right now,

45:21 Their concessionaire will likely be prepared to open Whitney Portal on the 19th. And that's information that we just recently got. So we would expect Whitney Portal to possibly be open next Friday. So that's kind of an update on where we're at on stuff. All of our county-operated campgrounds will be opening today as well. They've been closed. We haven't opened any of ours. We wanted to allow the private campgrounds.

45:51 To get the business without, you know, they needed a lot more than we do at the county. So we gave a couple of weeks before we opened our county campgrounds and we'll be doing that today. So that's kind of our update. Great, thank you. Any questions, comments, Inyo? Clint, so you guys, there was discussion around Whitney Portal on the road. You guys are okay with going ahead with all that, it sounds like? Yeah, at this point. Okay, good, thanks.

46:28 Anything else? I think I would just comment that, Clint, the discussion around bad water is a perfect example of our, you know, the types of regional issues that we have that other places in the state might not. And, you know, great, great place for advocacy and consideration working together on that. Yeah, that's a good point. We wouldn't want to deprive people of their, you know, self-torture experience with bad water.

46:57 Exactly. There might be more people who want to do it this year just because people want to get out of their house and go to Death Valley. Right. All right. Let's see. We've already... How about City of Bishop? Ron? Thank you. Good morning. City of Bishop adopted a budget for 2020-2021. We're down about 23% for next year.

47:39 Revenue projections. So we're barely hanging on, not doing any new hiring, not doing salary increases on the COLA July 1, increasing the amount of employees and retirees have to pay on medical insurance, that type of thing.

48:09 But hopefully with these reopening revenues will begin to get better and we'll be looking at that every 60 to 90 days. There certainly is more traffic in town the last week or so. Jim, do you have anything to add? As it relates to ESCOG, like I know we, with our budget being a little short this next year, we did approve a, going on in November ballot, a 1% TUT.

48:44 Tax, which hopefully if it passes will give us in the neighborhood about $1.6 million to $1.8 million a year, which I think will enable us to play a little bit better in some of this sustainable recreation and help out with some of the regional partnership roles. So hoping that passes and gives us some room to, you know, right now the city can do what we need to do.

49:12 But this maybe will take us to the next step where we can do part of the trails around Bishop or, you know, do some infrastructure improvements that help out the whole picture. So I think it's something that needs to be able to move to 8.75%, which is still, what, percent and a half below LA County. So when people come up here, they'll be getting a big deal. So it'll all be good. Kim, if I could ask, is that a sales tax increase or TOT? T-U-T.

49:43 It's the same as sales tax. It's transitional use tax. Okay, so it's on top of the sales tax, though. Yeah, it's transaction and use tax, which is a distinction in the state for certain types of things, how they're taxed, but it's basically a sales tax. Okay, okay, so it's across all transactions, all retail, all everything. Yeah. Okay, thank you. Interesting. John, did you have a comment?

50:12 No, I just, I was supportive of that. I think if Jim, Karen, or Ron, Mammoth Lakes, we've done some of that kind of activity, we'd be more than happy to, I can reach out to you guys at some point and just see if we could be with any sharing experiences, any campaign, things like that. We'd love to help you guys out with that. That'd be great. Yeah. Thank you. Yeah, for sure. I think that's interesting. I know about Mono County, we've been having discussions about a possible TOT.

50:42 Increase or formation of a T-bid in the unincorporated areas of the county, but, you know, it's just stayed at the discussion level so far, but I know we're very, obviously, all our budgets are impacted and interested in revenue generation, so we'll be rooting for our friends in Bishop and, you know, watching the election results. For Mono County, unfortunately, our new CAO, Bob Lawton,

51:12 We appointed him as CAO earlier this month. It just looks like he wasn't able to join us. Oh, John, did you have another comment? Me, no. Sorry, I'm just moving around. He's unmuted, so I wasn't sure. I'm sorry. That's okay. You weren't being noisy. I just pay attention, you know, when sharing these things to see if the microphone opens up. Okay, that's good. That's a good, good to know what everybody's indicators are. Yes, that's good. All right.

51:42 You can also just raise your hands or whatever you want to do. For Mono County, so Bob Gardner and I can just tag team this. Dan gave a kind of a good update from our EOC, but today is a big day. Lodging opens in the unincorporated areas of the county. We got a lot of campground openings. All the campgrounds on the Bridgeport Ranger District at the Humboldt-Hoyabe National Forest are opening today.

52:11 Campgrounds in the June Lake area, a couple campgrounds in town, and some campgrounds in southern Mono County, including Convict, McGee, a couple of the lower Rock Creek campgrounds are opening. We have a county campground, but I don't think it's open yet, but it's in Bob's district. Is it opening? It opened yesterday. Oh, okay. So our Lundy campground opened. And then Tioga Pass opens.

52:39 Of course, on Monday, so that'll, we'll see how the new mandatory day use reservation system works out. It seems like there's still availability if you go on recreation.gov, you know, we'll see how that, how that impact, the traditional open Tioga Pass and the people come to Mono County, we'll see how it's impacted by COVID and this reservation system.

53:09 Any other discussion on whether it's recreation impacts, other COVID-related discussion? Yeah, John, go ahead. Yeah, we've all done a great job to get to where we are. Both counties are showing, look, we all kind of seem to be in the same space. We'll do what we can to reach out to the audience. I guess the question I've got is, are we,

53:44 Well positioned, I know, I'm assuming we are, we're talking with each other. So when the spike happens, and when the other, you know, part of the story starts to happen, and I think, I'm sure there's lessons we could all learn getting to where we are now. How do we kind of take advantage of that and start thinking a little bit about, you know, having those contingencies plans in place so that the numbers start to go up, we start to get in trouble again, we got to ramp things back.

54:14 How we're all going to do that together and successfully. And the one thing I just throw out there is that I know Dan and Mammoth Resorts, which affects both Mammoth and Bob's District, June Lake and Monroe County, starting to get into some good operational discussions about how we are going, what their plan is going to be for the ski area reopening, how we're going to work together truly as partners to make all this stuff happen. That's going to affect Inyo County, I'm sure.

54:41 And we don't have to have the discussion now, but I'm hoping we can start getting proactive about that and figure out in case we need it, we know how we're all going to manage that. Because a lot of the businesses that have opened up now, they're going to have a fighting chance of the summer, and that's great. But if we have to come back and say, look, it's getting bad again, that could be really, you think this was tough, that could put a lot of businesses over the edge.

55:08 And I think it's something to be thinking about and I throw that out to the group to see how we want to start maybe thinking and talking about that. I have some thoughts on that and I don't really have solutions, just some observations that I think some better communication with our federal partners would be good. It seems like we have not always been on the same page and we've been, you know.

55:39 Definitely going in different directions at different times. So improving that communication, especially with the Forest Service, I think would be really important. And I think historians, when they look at what we've done so far, they'll be like, oh, Inyo County, Mono County, and the town and city, we're pretty darn close in coordination with how they did things. But when we were doing it in real time,

56:07 It seemed like every little decision had an outsized importance to it. And the public would sort of play one agency off of the other. It'd be like, oh, Inyo County took X action three days before Mono County did, and Mono County would be totally getting beaten up about that. And then...

56:33 A day later, Mono County would do something three days before Inyo County did it. And Inyo County, people would say, you know, why can't you be more like Mono County? The same thing sort of happened at the beginning when, you know, the public was really emotional and upset about that we weren't doing enough. And people would say, oh, well, Mono County Public Health has an Instagram page and you guys don't have that. You guys must not care about the people.

57:03 And there were flip side stuff too. People would say, oh, well, Dr. Richardson did X and Dr. Boo hasn't done that. Like Mono County, your response is lacking. So it's just an observation. I don't think we have any real idea whether we're going to have some spikes in the fall. You know, I think it's likely.

57:25 Just my gut reactions to those likely, and I'm not sure it's going to be enough that we have to totally tamp everything down again, but it could. And I think it's, and then as elected officials, we don't necessarily know what's going on either because it happens inside the EOC. So I guess to the administrators who are with us, you know, I think you guys have been doing an amazing job. I think the EOCs have been doing an amazing job, you know, both on the

57:55 The shutdown side and the open up side. But I do think, you know, maintaining those lines of communication and trying to make sure we are as coordinated as possible is really important. And Jeff, I would just add that those are exactly the kinds of lessons learned. I think we should actually maybe take that next step and kind of lock those things a little bit. And I would say, especially with the federal folks, because what happened with them was whatever they were saying is what they were saying.

58:25 But at the end of the day, their actions spoke a lot louder than their words. And I think that we can really learn from that, and we can use that as being predictive information. And I think that that may be very helpful as we go in to anticipate that, that they're going to defer to our public health officers. And I think we weren't sure how that was going to work, but I think that was pretty apparent to me by the end of the day. Right, and that, I think, one thing...

58:52 Communication is the biggest thing here. You know, the two county EOCs had their hands full responding to the pandemic and, you know, working on a lot of details, but the JICs, the communications arms of the EOCs, you know, that maybe could be something that the ESCOG maybe, you know, makes some kind of recommendation. If, say, we were going to put together maybe a...

59:18 Comment, lessons learned type thing. That might be something for us to consider doing. I think really tightening the messaging down, you know, and having a person-to-person assigning one person from each EOC who's on the JIC. I know that from a higher level, the unified commanders were talking to each other. But it came down to the communication, knowing what was coming next.

59:46 How we would talk about it and message it, how we handle the, you know, it kind of felt like parental nature of like, well, you know, did your mother say yes? Are you coming to dad now because mom said no? You know, because we, and oftentimes that felt like, you know, we were engaging, especially at least on Mono County, some very heated.

1:00:14 emotional public comments and comments from elected officials. I think having clear communication or talking points that we worked on together around things would have toned that down a little bit and cooler heads could prevail. Yeah, I'll totally agree with Stacey on that. And I think it's something that, you know, we'll never be able to get perfect.

1:00:43 And even if we were 100% aligned as a region, we would still get what I get from people is they say, well, you know, in Modoc County, they're doing this or in Shasta County or in Virginia, they're doing this. And so we'll never be able to solve it completely. But having us, you know, with a consistent message as possible regionally, I think would be really helpful.

1:01:09 Yeah, and then engaging us, you know, elected officials in pushing that message out. Bob? I would just say, and I know maybe source of disagreement from some, having to do it over again, it is a region, damn it. We should have one EOC for the region.

1:01:32 And then we all suck it up and communicate and do just what you're talking about. And have the federal agencies and the state agencies be connected to that one EOC. And then communication and coordination and collaboration would be more facilitated. That's hard politically. And we would have to suck it up, as I say, and deal with that. But that would have made a big difference in just...

1:01:59 The things that the examples that you mentioned, Jeff, and other things. But we've got to kind of decide if we want to do that. I heard a great thing the other day that said a lot of these things really come down to do we have the political will to do it? So I just leave that out there. Well, Bob, you know, on that note, what I think the Yosemite Area Gateway Coordination Team was a perfect, that was a formal effort led by Mariposa. The meetings were

1:02:28 Convened and led by Mariposa County's EOC and facilitated by their health officers. So, but included elected officials. So I would be, there would be, and they, you know, different counties use different models in their EOCs. Both Mariposa and Tuolumne actually have the chair of the board of supervisors in the EOC. But there were weekly calls and they were formal and they were only like 45 minutes and it was like,

1:02:57 Let's get our stuff together. So that's a good model too. Jim? I think there's some great points here. Jeff, you touched on one too. The, we all have so many different needs though. It's kind of, it's difficult. Bob, I agree, you know, one commander, one point is a great spot, but Mammoth's needs, Inyo, Mono County, Inyo County, they're all a little different, which makes it difficult. So I think this is going to be a great learning experience to see, because this is going to come again. And it might not be COVID-19, it might be,

1:03:28 Next COVID version 2.0 come in two years from now. But I think it's a chance for us to see what we can do. But there needs to be kind of a set message, like Mono County's open up, Inyo County's open up, that's great. But when I go on to the state website, travel ban's still there. So you're saying don't travel, but you're opening everything up to travel. And that's probably the number one question I get from constituents and people I work with is,

1:03:58 The travel ban's in effect, but go out to Main Street right now and watch camper, camper, camper, car with bikes all over the back. There's a mixed message, which we're doing the best we can to do what we need to do, but the state's opening up the gates and expecting us to deal with the cows all running out, but telling us we can't chase them. It's just a, I think there's been a lot of stuff I think we need to learn from, and it's great that we have these conversations, and Stacey, you're right.

1:04:27 You know, the groups that get together, similar to whatever your little wordage was, YTP, W, R, S, Q. I think we need to kind of keep that, but it's difficult. So I think we're doing a great job. Hats off to each and every one of you for a great job we've done, and we'll do better. So, Jimmy, interesting thing that the state did was they changed the travel ban to say,

1:04:55 Recreational leisure travel is prohibited to is highly discouraged because they had to do something to make it make sense. Yeah, that makes sense now. Well, kind of a mixed message, but at least you don't, you're not openly defying state orders. No, but it puts us in a weird spot where it's a free-for-all, you know, to travel, but...

1:05:24 You don't have the campgrounds to support it. It hurts each of us on our public lands. We saw what happened, and I think we did a great job of managing it the best we can. But it gives us a, you know, we can look back and give us a roadmap now to where to go for the future. So I think we'll be okay. One thing I want to bring up, and I don't want to have this go on forever, so I'm sorry to continue. The issue of messaging and communication, you know, a lot of questions have come up in the...

1:05:54 community meetings in Mammoth and Mono around advertising the local lodging guidance. Dan, I don't know if it's still in there, but originally when our EOC put out guidance ahead of the state's guidance, it asked lodging and short-term rental operators to not advertise. And some of our, especially out in the county, they

1:06:20 They didn't like that, and they thought that was unclear, and they didn't know if they could have their website up. But then on the other hand, we get messages from people saying, well, you're going to tell everybody they could come back now. What's the messaging? So I think another regional point of focus over the next couple of weeks could be, yeah, what level of marketing are we doing? And one particular point I think is a big concern for all of us was,

1:06:45 The proliferation of dispersed camping. And personally, that's something that really frustrated me that the Forest Service was able to close recreation facilities but not do anything about dispersed camping. And I get it. It's a tough management issue. But, you know, we still have speed limits even though you can't catch everybody who's speeding. And I worry personally that some of these folks who are out there now aren't going to ever go back to a campground because they can just boondock and, you know.

1:07:14 Whatever, in their giant RVs. So any thoughts on that, John? Yeah, I think, Stacey, the point around the marketing messaging is that's a big enchilada. The town is going to be engaging with MLT. Through that Visitor Connection Working Group with the initiative, we've got all those people are at a table. I know Bishop Beneno's got great capacity, great people working down there. They all tend to kind of work with each other.

1:07:44 In a parallel universe, it's kind of hard to know how we actually get to them. But that, I think, is an interesting thing to be thinking about going forward. I thought that Tahoe billboard, wasn't it a Tahoe billboard, John, that said your number one priority is to not go number two in the woods? And I thought that was a pretty good billboard. I thought, let's just put that right up. Let's do that. A couple of those on 395 in both times. That'd be great. Yeah.

1:08:18 Let's do it. And I honestly, I think that the stuff that's before us now, the camping and stuff, I think it's actually going to be increased over prior years. People are looking to get out. They've been locked up. They can't travel internationally. They can't do the stuff they want to. I think we're going to see big numbers. So unless we get, you know, it's great to see the campgrounds opening because you are going to see, I think, just my opinion, an increase in people. You know, this is a quick, easy escape.

1:08:48 And people are longing for something. So I think that's coming. All right. Any other thoughts on item 10? Any COVID-related regional response issues that we haven't hit yet? All right. Then moving on to item 11, board member reports on local, regional, state, and federal matters related to ESCOG JPA interests. Who would like to start? Who has a report for us?

1:09:22 You know, it's hard to know where to start on this, but I've been very involved with the CSAC, California State Association of Counties, lots of moving parts on the state side, lots of moving parts on the federal side, and as chair of the Health and Human Services Policy Committee, we've just had tons of discussion around 91.

1:09:51 And 2000, and I can't remember the number now, the realignment, 2011 realignment. And so for those folks not familiar with all of that, that's basically the funding for all of our health and human services programs. And it's a very complicated formula that determines it, but it's never actually

1:10:20 gone down. The needs are always increasing, but the money has, in the past recessions, it's not kept up with the needs, but it's actually scheduled to go down. And so, and the state may have actually taken action last night, I don't know, but they're very close to trying to figure out what they're going to do with the backfill. But we're looking at an increase.

1:10:47 Health and Human Services needs because of the pandemic and the, you know, ensuing economic fallout from that while looking at dramatically lower resources to be able to meet that need. And it gets very complicated because there are entitlements, things that we are required to do with that money. And then there are, Linda probably could explain all of this better than I could.

1:11:16 It's a very fluid and scary situation with a huge part of our budget. And so we're trying to keep on top of that. Thanks. Yeah. So does CSAC have hope that the legislative proposal to do the backfill will be accepted by the administration?

1:11:42 We're cautiously optimistic. I guess we're confident that they're going to do something because I think the administration, they do understand the situation, but they're really in a tough spot. I mean, because something's going to have to take a big cut. And, you know, probably everybody's going to be unhappy.

1:12:14 with what happens. So we'll see. Keep our fingers crossed. We'll stick with Inyo. Dan, do you have a report? All right. Move to Bishop. Jim? No, I think we did it earlier. We talked about our TUT and where we're at, so we're good. Great. Mammoth, Linda and John. Okay, I'll go first.

1:12:52 I think, Stacey and Jim, I think we had a little item for us to do on the ESCOG JPA side of looking at staffing, and I'm very sensitive to what's going on at Bishop. I can reach out offline and see, because maybe there's an opportunity there. If there's not, then we could have that conversation. And City of Bishop, I will reach out to you guys about some campaign, you know, assistance, if that might.

1:13:20 If I can help with that, we do some good things up here in Mammoth. Mammoth, we're in relatively good shape. I guess we learned our lesson from the flirtation with bankruptcy a couple of years ago. And so we're not terrible, but we're going to be getting into some hard discussions here coming up soon. And I think that certainly have an eye on ski resorts.

1:13:50 How that's going to work. And I'm really looking forward to Dan and Mammoth Resorts and Altair just getting everybody together and trying to be as ahead of that as we can possibly be. So we're not making decisions in November. We're not making decisions. I mean, just imagine from the business's perspective, from a public safety perspective, we are at 8,000 feet. It does snow a lot up here. We need to really understand what we're going to be doing going into next winter. So looking forward to that, to that work.

1:14:19 I think that's about it. I don't know, Linda, what else would you like to add or do you have to add? No, I don't think there's anything I need to add. Thank you for doing that. I think we've covered everything. Appreciate that. All right, Mono County, Bob? Yeah, I think we've begun our budget. We moved up our budget calendar the last year, but we've slipped it back to the August, September timeline. And so we'll be working through that in the summer. Things will be tight. I don't think they're as tight as perhaps the,

1:14:54 We thought they might be, but we'll see how things go through the summer in terms of the revenue coming back. The housing project known as the Tioga Inn that has been moving through the process over the last several months and is scheduled now to come to our board June 29th and 30th. There's been a lot of interest in that project. And then we've had a lot of recent concern. Southern California Edison is up here doing an extremely...

1:15:21 Heavy amount of vegetation management tree trimming and had obviously welcomed that from a wildfire prevention standpoint. A lot of concern from residents about the number of trees and the way it's been handled and we'll be participating in their community meeting next Tuesday. But SCE is already right now working with individual homeowners to try to address some of those concerns. So that's just something that's ongoing and we're in the midst of that.

1:15:50 Yeah, I think for our friends in Inyo and Bishop, the scale of this, it's two parts of vegetation management and hazard tree removal in the Mammoth Lakes Basin, Town of Mammoth, June Lake, and then on other areas of the Inyo National Forest around June is, I mean, it's hard to find, it's massive.

1:16:14 What, Dan? I mean, I would guess thousands of, probably 20,000 trees, between 10 and 20,000 trees. I don't know if it's that big. I think the basin is 3,000 basically between the SCE and the, some beetle kill and stuff like that, but about 3,000 in the basin and smaller numbers in June. I don't remember the, I don't remember the total, but. Yeah, it's a lot. If you really get into it, this goes back to Linda's point earlier, I just write down within the sound of my voice.

1:16:43 If you actually put on a piece of paper the number of jurisdictions involved in maybe a, I don't know, 200 or 300 square foot area, private property owners, Caltrans, U.S. Forest Service, private business, SCE, in terms of who owns and who's involved in simply cutting a tree down, it's an interesting diagram and something that everybody says, well, that's...

1:17:06 That's my tree. That's true. But that tree is not your tree. And you may not want that tree to be cut down, but you don't have a say in that. And some do and some don't. It's been a mess just trying to understand, again, within a few feet of one tree versus another. We did that Mono County back on April 30th, we invited Edison to give us a presentation on their upcoming work. But I think only about 20 people listened in and, you know, nothing like having a

1:17:35 Contract crew show up and start cutting trees down on, and I think in June, yeah, in June it's, you know, there's, and in Mammoth too, there's forest service properties in between private properties, so it really gets people upset and confused when they see the work happening. You know, it's an incredible investment though in our area. I asked Edison to give me an estimate on the cost of the lake space and project alone.

1:18:05 I was told it was about $18 million. So that's pretty major. Yeah, John? Yeah, Stacey, you mentioned there's some kind of a meeting coming up with Edison. Oh, yeah. So Tuesday, and you all should have gotten this information. If not, we can ask Angie to send it out. They're doing, these are kind of, I don't mean to sound negative, but they're canned presentations on SCE's updated wildfire mitigation program. So Tuesday the 16th.

1:18:34 Dan, do you, or Bob, do you, or I don't remember the time, maybe. Six o'clock. It's six o'clock Tuesday evening, and there is a question and answer opportunity, which frankly, I think they're open to expanding. I told them we did not want to see a lot of dog and pony shows that we'd already seen, that they could put out a little bit of information, but we really needed to have the opportunity for residents to be able to say, what's going on? What's the legal situation? What are my rights? How much distance from this kind of line and that kind of line?

1:19:02 And they seem very open to that. You can submit questions ahead of time. You can submit questions during the event. They seem to be open to expanding it based on the demand, which is growing. This is also Inyo County's meeting. This is our regional wildfire mitigation update. So really, Inyo County and Bishop folks should know about it too, hopefully. And that link, where's the best way to get that link, do you think?

1:19:31 We can have Angie send it out to everybody. Okay, cool. Great. Thank you. And I'll add to Bob's point. Again, I always have to give you our Civic Center update. We, Mono County has completely moved out of its offices at Sierra Center Mall, which is major. And, you know, everything's getting moved into the Civic Center. I think now our, you know, hopefully occupancy date would be

1:20:03 The beginning of July. Obviously, most of our staff is still working remotely. We still have offices open in a limited capacity in Minaret Mall by bonds. But we're hoping soon when conditions allow to have a grand opening and welcome everybody to our new Civic Center building. I think the last thing we're waiting for is an elevator inspection.

1:20:26 And then one thing I wanted to bring to everybody's attention, I know John has been working on this, there's some great legislation that's poised to make its way through Congress that could bring a lot of funding to the Forest Service and BLM and Park Service for deferred maintenance and infrastructure backlog. So we're hoping the Great American Outdoors Act makes its way through and is signed by the President. John, do you have any updates on status of that?

1:20:56 Don't. Bob's got something as well. Real quick, Dan, we've got a letter that I hope you signed. And we're hearing things that Congressman Cook may be amenable. But I think, you know, this may be the only stimulus that comes out of the federal government for local county government. This may be the only thing that we get. And so I encourage all of us.

1:21:22 I'm tracking it so we can get information out to everybody, but if you're calling Cook's office for whatever reason, hey, by the way, he's going to vote for that great outdoor act, right? It's one of the probably, you know, outdoor recreation, the only thing it gets bipartisan support anywhere. Even if you don't like recreation, you know, the Forest Service has a $6 billion infrastructure backlog to fix things like roads for fighting fire and, you know, getting places, so.

1:21:51 Yeah, it's a great big deal. Yeah, that bill is supposed to be, I think, pushed by the Senate early next week, and they expect the House to support it, and the President has said he will sign it. It's got the big deferred maintenance for all public lands agencies in it, as well as the Land and Water Conservation Fund authorization, and it looks like it's a train pulling out that's a good train pulling out.

1:22:14 On any other COVID assistance, they said the other day they thought it would be no sooner than the end of July if anything is approved at this point. And the only thing they may approve is to end the unemployment stuff, which is, that's a whole other deal. All right, any other updates? Did I get everybody? I guess just a couple of things. I don't know if Clint is still available to give an airport update.

1:22:46 Oh, that would be good. Yeah. That would be great. Yeah. Thanks. Funny how things that were really important not that long ago are... They're still important. They're still important. Right. So, yeah, it looks like Clint is still busy doing something else. But so basically, my understanding is the anticipated start of commercial service at the Bishop Airport this fall is not going to happen due to...

1:23:15 COVID and the fallout. We continue to make the infrastructure improvements and in a way not having the deadline of this fall is not a terrible thing because it allows us to get it right and make sure we cross all the T's and dot all the I's. So we continue to move forward and

1:23:44 Continue to be in discussion with our partners and maybe Clint has an update better than what I just said. So that determination hasn't been made yet. We're still working through where we're going to be at with working through with the FAA, with our partners, with MLT and with the Mountain.

1:24:08 And with our staff to make a determination and we'll figure something out probably in the next couple of weeks about where we're going to be at. Great. And just one other thing that I wanted to bring up that I don't think there's no action to be taken, but I have been getting a lot of comments from people regarding the Black Lives Matter protests and people are looking at our law enforcement budgets in a way that I've never seen before.

1:24:40 I don't know if anybody else is getting that too, but I think we're in unprecedented times in many ways, and it'll just be interesting to see where we move forward with this. I'm sure if we all look at our budgets, the percentage that we spend on law enforcement, pretty up there, and people are looking at that in a way that I've never seen before.

1:25:05 One thing that we're doing, Sheriff Braun is doing a presentation at our board meeting on Tuesday to address some of the concerns and looking at the specific points from the 8 Can't Wait website and movement and to address how our sheriff's department and county are addressing those or implementing those. So I hope that's just the beginning of a bigger conversation.

1:25:34 Happy to share whatever comes out of that with ESCOG. And for those who aren't familiar, can you tell us what the eight can't wait are? Just a general idea. The internet can tell me. Why don't we hear from John and then I'll pull that up so it could be exact and specific. Thank you, Stacey. On the airport side of things, just so everybody knows, there is a grant, an FAA grant that's come in.

1:26:03 For Mammoth, we will be doing some work on the airport. Dan can provide any details, but we are still fully aligned with the regional approach. I just don't want to have any misunderstandings. We're doing some aprons, some work on runways and infrastructure and that kind of stuff, so don't let anybody get confused in that. I think that, as Clint mentioned, between MLT and the mountain, those are kind of the big drivers in all kinds of things.

1:26:32 And there's been some interesting discussions at the MLT board about subsidy for air service coming out of Denver. Those things are kind of, those conversations are obviously still happening. And right now they're kind of happening at the MLT board. They're happening with Inyo County. And I think it's going to be certainly interested in the town and all of us to start focusing in on that. And let's figure out, you know, kind of exactly how things are going to work, what we can anticipate, what we think is going to happen and all that kind of stuff.

1:27:02 The Town Council, our relationship to M.O.T. is through Measure A money. They obviously have a T-bid. That's their own thing. But the Council's anxious to start having some really engaged conversations with M.O.T. and a bunch of different fronts. And we haven't gotten there yet, so we'll be getting there soon. So, sorry, Stacey. Yeah, so the A, now, and of course, for, I think, for our law enforcement in the Eastern Sierra, I don't, we haven't had an officer involved shooting, at least in Mono County, in some.

1:27:31 Time, maybe a century. It's been a long time. We had one a year ago or two years ago. Yeah. But I think there's a bigger, you know, looking at their website, you know, the bigger goal is showing that more restrictive use of force policies can reduce killings by police and save lives. But the bigger, you know, idea is how do we maybe don't address

1:27:56 How do we bring more equity into the conversation, you know, around law enforcement and the justice system? So, you know, but the eight specific policies, and Ingrid will address these next week, is banning choke holds and strangle holds, requiring de-escalation, require warning before shooting, requires exhaust all alternatives before shooting, duty to intervene, ban shooting and moving vehicles, require use of force continuum.

1:28:24 And require comprehensive reporting. So we'll start there, but I think probably for all of us in our rural, peaceful areas, it's a bigger conversation about equity, diversity, equity, inclusion, and systemic bias in the criminal justice system. If I could just say, there's racial issues and there's economic inequality, and these are connected.

1:28:55 The more we don't deal with both of those, the worse it's going to get. And so some of this is a wake-up call that we've got to deal with, whether we're in suburban or urban areas or whether we're in a rural area. And I think some of the issues that have been raised to our board are going to get into a lot of those things. Yeah, we're looking forward to your discussion on that. And again, thanking the county for their leadership in these kinds of things, and we look forward to how that will work with the town.

1:29:24 Looking forward to that. All right. If we're done with reports, item 12 is to discuss and set a date for a special meeting to adopt the resolution adopting the ESCOG-JPA conflict of interest code. Our proposed dates are July 1st or 2nd at 8.30 a.m. Can we...

1:29:46 Just jump in for a minute to give you guys some more options. From a legal perspective, we just have to have this done by July 7th. So you do also have the option of July 6th or 7th, although the 7th would be cutting it awfully close. We need to have the meeting first thing in the morning and then send someone scurrying over to the post office to get it postmarked in time. So realistically, it looks like...

1:30:09 First, second, third, if, you know, people aren't on vacation, but I think that date's kind of out, and sixth are the best options. I'm good for the first or second. Yeah, raise your hand. You know, is there, so let's start with the first or second. Who, I'll start with the first. Who could meet Wednesday, July 1st at 8.30 a.m.? And Grace, this is just a one-item thing, right? This will be quick.

1:30:39 Exactly. All you need to do is approve a resolution adopting the Conflict of Interest Code. In an unlikely event that we get extensive public comment on it, you would need to consider those public comments and act as you see fit, but don't think that's going to happen. All right, so raising hands for Wednesday, July 1st at 8.30. Okay, there we have it. Wednesday, July 1st, 8.30 a.m. That way it gives us plenty of time. You don't have to rush over and make it official. All right, thanks for making that easy.

1:31:08 And so then we'll adjourn. And as always, you know, I'm sure Angie would appreciate, and you can include me in any items you have for our next meeting, which I believe would be on August 14th. Anyway, we'll adjourn to the next meeting. Thanks, everyone. Hey, Stacey, real quick.

1:31:37 I think it's on the, we need to set a special meeting for that first week of July. Yeah, we already did it. July 1st. We already did it. Okay, thanks. Sorry, I had in between meetings. It's okay. Okay, so we'll actually be. We're all set. Yeah, we'll actually be adjourning to the special meeting on July 1st. Right, of course, yeah. But can you remind us all again when our next regular meeting is? Let me look at my calendar. I believe it's Friday.

1:32:04 Friday, August 13th, but let me just check the date for sure. I'm sorry, Friday, August 14th would be the next ESCOG meeting. I did not be available for Friday the 13th, sorry. Well, fortunately, you don't have to. All right, thanks, everyone. Have a great weekend. Thank you all. Great to see you all. Thanks, Angie.