TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2020

Mammoth Lakes Recreation Special meeting

· recording 3 hr 21 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

437 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:02 Okay, we are recording. Good evening, everyone. Let's see, we're going to bring to order the public hearing and Board of Directors special meeting for Mammoth Lakes Recreation this Tuesday, June 16, 2020, and I've got 5.38 p.m.

0:28 Angela, why don't we start off with roll call, please. Bill Souser. Here. Eric Wasserman. Eric Wasserman. Oh, I can see you. He's muted. Rhonda Dugan. Here. Here. Catherine Taft. Here. Colin Fernie. Here. Heather Schaubmeyer. Here. Tamara Bankson. Here. David Page. Here.

1:04 And Craig Albright. Here. Thank you. All right. All present and accounted for. Let's start off with public comment on items not on the agenda. Angela, do we have any callers or public comments out there? I have not received any public comments. Okay. Well, we'll close to public comment and start our...

1:34 Public hearing and maybe an order of procedure before we get started. Matt, did you want to tackle these all one at a time going through the full process? Two complete votes. Two things to vote on and two complete votes. I'm sorry? Each one of the points.

2:11 On the public hearing, we should probably address individually. Yeah, so we'll go through and have a public hearing on each item. So why don't, Matt, why don't you start off with, let me outline the procedure we're going to follow. So for each one of these, then staff will make a statement and presentation with recommendation of allocations for the town council. And then we'll have questions from the board.

2:40 When we're done with that, then we'll call for testimony, rebuttal of previous testimony, and then close the public hearing. The board will then deliberate on the matter and arrive at a decision, and we'll do that for each of the four items. So Matt, why don't you, first of all, call this public meeting to order, or public hearing to order, and we'll start with item one.

3:08 Allocation for Measure U funding. Okay. And I'll need to recuse myself for that item and then I'll come back for the measure of our allocations. Very good. So I'm gonna actually defer this point over to Heather Schaubmeyer, who is their chair of our allocations committee and she will speak to the committee's recommendation for special project grants for fiscal year 1920, which is our current year. Hello all.

3:42 Thanks for being here. I appreciate it. We had, I think, a very successful allocations process. We did not have any new applicants other than our special project, Walk-In Nature, which was our one special project. We have a budget of $25,000 for. The applicant went in for $8738, and we made a recommendation for $3,000 on that. This is a new program. There were definitely some

4:12 Some things in the program that we had some conversations on that she's going to have to prove herself. There's going to be some follow-up with the staff on her to make sure that she's able to do her walk in nature. But we think with the situation with COVID and the adjustments that she made, she'll be able to do her walk in nature program in a successful manner. And again, she's going to need follow-up.

4:39 Something that we did discuss, everybody kind of has a little bit of background. I'm not sure if everybody got to kind of watch the allocation process, but we had a conversation about what COVID means and the fluidity of it constantly changing and how we can't really predict on what's going to happen tomorrow, let alone what's going to happen in three months, six months, and a year from now. So we are going to have to do, staff is going to have to do continual follow-up.

5:05 with these event producers, or excuse me, programmers, for several different reasons, just to make sure that they're staying afloat, making sure that they're staying relevant, and seeing what we can do to help them get through this process. And a year from now, it's probably gonna be the hardest allocation follow-up we'll have, because every event producer is having to change the way they do things, and they're gonna have to be able to show that they spent the funds.

5:33 in the manner they originally planned. So there's going to be some, next year's going to be interesting. By the way, that special event project funding for Walk in Nature was for 19-20 because that closed, closes on June 30th of 2020. And then our next fiscal programming goes into 2021, which is multi-year and our one-year programming.

6:00 So there was that. So moving forward, we have another $25,000 pot for special projects moving into 2021. There was the big elephant in the room, which was the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. They literally had made an announcement, a changing of the guard had occurred in their establishment, a changing of they're not going to be doing programming. So that was a big deal in the past.

6:27 You all know that there's been a bucket of money that has been put to the side for programming of the MAC. The MAC has been put on hold. There's been changes in their staff. So we had to have another meeting with Shira to kind of talk to her about what it is that she was going to be doing with the Mammoth Lakes Film Festival and with Repertory Theater. She is moving forward with that. She came in and talked to our staff for quite some time.

6:56 Answered a lot of heavy questions. Had some really aggressive funding already locked in for donations, which was really encouraging for all of us to hear. And just walk in nature now. Sorry, I was just reading a little note there. So we were very happy with her follow-through. We're a little bit nervous as a board of the allocations committee, excuse me.

7:25 We were a little bit nervous about what all she's going to be able to get accomplished, but it sounds like she's already done a lot of work in a very short amount of time, as she said before. She had a budget that she worked on solely for these events. She had people that donated money specifically for these events. So it did change the pot, though, for what we did give her. In the past, we have given Mammoth Lakes Foundation.

7:51 The organization itself, $56,000, which is what they requested for. They have agreed to be a pass-through for Shira until she gets her own non-profit set up. And it will be earmarked specifically for the Repertory Theater and for programming of that and for the Mammoth Lakes Film Festival.

8:12 If anybody has any questions about that, we might wanna address them now before we get into the multi-year funding because it was a one-year funding situation. Does anybody have any questions regarding that funding, $40,000? No? Cool, then we're gonna keep moving forward. From there... If I could just interject something. So just, Heather touched on this, but I just wanna reiterate for the board, for this specific...

8:42 Special project allocation. This again is for this fiscal year, 1920. As a reminder, special projects can be awarded at any time during the fiscal year. This is why this one's coming so late. What we've opted to do is, you know, this was brought to us. We examined it through the current allocation cycle, but we felt that there was an opportunity to put it under

9:10 Our current year's special project as there was none submitted previously. So just to clarify that before we get to item four. Okay. One question on that then. Isn't our special project funding normally $25,000? Correct. It is. So this $40,000 is from a combination of several years? No, no, no. So special projects, it was for a walk in nature.

9:42 That's the $3,000 that comes out of that $25,000 pot. Heather was talking about in advance of us getting to item four, there's some extra money that we had to look at this year because the amount that we had previously directed towards Mammoth Lakes Foundation and Repertory Theater had changed somewhat. So we'll tackle that when we get to item four. I think she just wanted to frame it up.

10:13 As we go into this discussion on item one. So the recommendation from allocation staff is for $3,000 to support Walk in Nature as a special project in fiscal year 1920. Yeah, I misunderstood. I was thinking that the foundation one was a special project, but this is just, we are reallocating what we would have given to the foundation over to Shira here, right?

10:40 I won't say it's a reallocation because special projects is a separate pool of money. There's $25,000 that is outside of our other programming pot. So this money, the $3,000 will come out of that special project pool of $25,000. So we'll have a balance then of $22,000 in that special project, which will roll over to fiscal year 2021.

11:06 And then the one-year program for Mammoth Lakes Foundation goes into the big pot of the 166. And the thing is, is that usually, Bill, so there's a process for people that start things out. Usually they start their special project, they kind of get their feet rolling. Then they go into a one-year funding. And it's kind of our opportunity to see them testing their waters before they go into the multi-year funding. Then the past, the last past three years.

11:35 Mammoth Lakes Foundation has been reapplying for that one-year funding, hoping that they would have the MAC built and that they would be getting, no longer needing our help, and that's why they did not go into the multi-year funding three years ago. So it's just been a continual one-year, one-year, one-year. Cool. So then we're gonna now go into the multi-year funding. The applicants that came in this year had been long-standing applicants.

12:04 With MLR and with Measure U, they've always, Chamber Music Unbound, whoever's looking for an accountant to find out who's theirs is, because their ability to do a P&L sheet is phenomenal. Their follow-through has always been fantastic. And they, yet again, they've been very flexible with the whole COVID situation, so I kind of want to go back to that real quick. Again, we are funding all of these programs.

12:34 As if everybody's going to be able to perform everything normal over the next 12 months. We're going to have to check in every three months to see how everybody's going. And there will be in a year from now, I'm sure some people that will have funds that will roll over. So we'll have to tackle that next year. And Heather, I'm sorry to interrupt again. Point of procedure, maybe we should just have the board make a recommendation only on special projects, which is item one, just because that's coming out of a different fiscal year. And then we can come back to...

13:03 our multi-year awardees and the other awardees in item four. So would you like to just go ahead and vote on the walk in nature? Is that what you're asking? Yes, please. Item one is fiscal year 1920 special projects and the programming for fiscal year 2021. Oh, I'm sorry. I think you're on the right track, Heather.

13:34 Okay, no worries. That's what I thought, so I can move forward? My mistake, sorry. Yeah, no worries. I have a quick question, Heather. Yes, sir. The $21,000 that we don't use in the special projects, that rolls into the other, it's not use or lose it, that goes moving forward as reserves to reallocate next year, right? Not specifically, well, Matt, go ahead, I'll let you answer, please. I'm sorry, can you repeat that, Eric? So we would have $21,000 left over because we're recommending three out of 25. I'm sorry, we have $22,000 left over?

14:03 Does that roll forwards for other funding or is it use or lose it? It goes back into the Measure U pot. So far, we haven't had to go outside of the $25,000. In that case, what we would do is go back and confer with Dan and town and see if we could make

14:32 A special project allocation outside of that $25,000. But it does go back into the Measure U fund. So it doesn't like disappear. It's not like we won't have access to that money later. Gotcha. So we're saving $22,000 by only allocating three. Yes. Okay. That's what I wanted to make sure. Okay. Thank you. To dovetail off of that, Matt, the amount.

14:52 That'll be available for special projects for 2021 would again be $25,000, right? That just gets replenished again to $25,000. Correct, correct. All right, good. From there we went on to multi-year funding for chamber music, unboundly recommended $26,000, Eastern Sierra Symphony $14,500,

15:22 Mono Arts Council, 30, then the library system, the full five. We, because Mammoth Lakes Foundation, the Repertory Theater, and the Film Festival, we didn't fund the full 56, that gave us another 16,000 to kind of spread out amongst all the different programmers. So it made that pot a little bit thicker, which was nice. We were able to then,

15:50 have a deliberation over our multi-year funding folks and everybody had an agreed amount and then we went back and kind of deliberated it and then after we did that we then had funds left over to discuss and that gave us an opportunity to change some of our funding for some of our already existing multi-year programmers which we've actually never been able to do in the past. So if you go down to the

16:19 Approved multi-year funded programs. Again, everything that we do is a recommendation. It's never a guaranteed amount. It's a recommendation that we then pass on to you all, that you all vote on, and then it goes to town council. And just because next year we're going to recommend somebody X amount of funds doesn't mean that we're going to be able to necessarily give that to them. So with the Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association, we gave them a little bit less money than we had said from the year before. I believe we said they...

16:47 I think we've recommended four last year. We changed that to three. Forest Island got to go up a little bit because of that. Friends of the Inyo got to go up a little bit because of that. Southern Mono stayed the same. Eastern Sierra Avalanche Center went up a little bit. And Sierra Classic Theater got to go up a little bit. So we were able to spread the funds out to all the different people and give everybody a little bit more, which was kind of nice. I think that Craig and Rhonda and Catherine did a fantastic job.

17:16 And Kim obviously getting everything set up and Matt having conversations with everybody that I think this allocation process went pretty smooth. And I think everybody felt really good about it. Does anybody have any questions about any of the decisions that we've made on that? My only questions, Heather, are the same ones that I ask every year. Everybody always asks for more than they actually need, hoping to get what they need. We do make sure, and with the check-ins later, that with what we've awarded these people,

17:47 They will be able to pull off their programs. Absolutely. So, Bill, we've had situations in the past where, I'll give an example, with Theater Classic Theater, where Allison had a program that she was doing with Susan, and then Susan left town, and so she was unable to perform one of their performances. And I believe it was like $4,000, if I'm correct. Instead of...

18:09 Saying, hey, you owe us that money back because she was in a multi-year program. We rolled those funds over to the following year and then awarded her less to supplement that. Does that make sense? So we're going to kind of be doing the same thing, I believe, when we get to next year. Most of these folks have been very flexible. They're finding ways like the, you know, Chamber of Music Unbound, you know, doing concerts in their front yards and everybody's using Zoom and people are doing virtual events and everybody's been really flexible and finding ways.

18:38 I tried to make everything happen. So it's going to be an interesting situation in 12 months from now to see what people were able to accomplish and what they weren't. And there's going to be definitely a lot of follow through on that. And I wish we could give everybody everything. But what we do, just so you know, Bill, I'm not sure if you were part of this last year, but we have a whole...

19:02 Scoring system that we then apply against the funds that were, at least that's how I do it. Everybody's got a different kind of method to their madness. But I take the, we have a form that we can go through and score in each category, zero to five, and how it's relevant to our guiding principles and the statement behind what Measure U is meant to be used for. And then within that, I take that number and put it against the funds that they're asking for.

19:31 And then from there, everybody kind of gave what their recommendation was for each one, and then we had a deliberation over those funds. We weren't too far off on most of them. The only one who got a full reward would be the library. They're really asking for a minimal amount, and next year they're asking for $2,500 versus $5,000. They had their justification behind what they needed those additional funds for, where they were getting other funds for, how they were doing their programming virtually, and it worked.

20:02 Heather, can I ask, do the entities that we fund, are they required to produce and submit a grant report at the end of the use of their funds? It's not a grant report, but yes, there's a whole report, a follow-through that Kim has, and I'm sure she can forward in the information that she does. Yes, I mean, it's P&Ls, it's full of tax returns. Just the use of the funds, yeah. Yep, use the funds, how it was used.

20:31 There's a great system in play. And Kim, if you want to follow up on that, you're more than welcome to because that's more of what you get to deal with. Yeah. Yeah, I'd just be interested to look at it in the future. Absolutely. But just curious what they report on. There's progress reports and performance reports. The progress reports come in during the program and then performance reports at the end with all the final follow-up with financials and receipts and programmatic goals being met.

21:01 Right. Perfect. Thank you. Heather, can I make a couple of comments? Please. Just for the rest of the board is having been through this process before and all of the applicants had submitted their programs, their budgets, and their requests prior to everything shutting down for COVID. And when we came back and revisited this project, the big

21:31 The big question for all of us on the committee is, how are they going to do anything? And based on what we saw and how could those programs evolve into an unknown or what they expect, what they thought they might do? And it was so...

21:52 encouraging to see every single applicant come through with not only what they could do in an unknown future, but what they were doing already. And as Heather had said, they were reaching out to their students, to some of their programs, online, YouTube, definitely using social media wherever they could, and they were making it work today.

22:22 When we're giving out this money, a lot of it had to be consideration. Would they even be able to use it? Would they have to sit on it and wait for something to happen? And no one did that. Everyone was doing it now. And it made our task a lot easier to see that everyone was working towards this and that we would be supporting programs that may not look the same as they do right now or even as they envisioned.

22:50 But they were going to be able to produce that. And that gave us a level of comfort. Some still may not be able to produce it. But we do have the ability to recoup funds that aren't used. There's very strict guidelines and performance standards that we have to do.

23:13 As MLR is becoming the de facto only organization that really looks at nonprofits devoted to arts and culture and recreation, we know that this money is going to be used throughout the community. And that's what made this job a little easier. It was good to be able to reshuffle funds, but to see that everybody was working on it right now. It was great to see the creativity that people also

23:46 came up with. And like you said, staying engaged and using different formats from YouTube to social media and everything they possibly could. I think it was a testament of the resilience of these people. I think they did a really great job personally. Does anybody else have any other questions about the recommendations? Nope. And that puts us at 166. If everybody feels good, Craig, I think we can move into a voting situation.

24:19 Excuse me, there's a public comment for the allocations. Any public comment? Yeah, me. Hi, welcome, Leslie. Sierra Classic Theater. And so I just kind of wanted to let you all know that we are doing Shakespeare in the Woods this year. I've been working on the budget for it, for having it with like a 50.

24:49 We're running an extra week, which, you know, in a sense has kind of increased our costs for Shakespeare in the Woods. Plus, like, if we're only doing a 50-person audience with social distancing and everything, it is a situation where we won't be making anywhere near as much money. And so I do have to say, like, right now, I kind of budgeted us out as, like,

25:13 Not having any Measure U and like losing like $10,000 this year. So having any sort of level of Measure U is pretty fabulous for us. We're also still looking at doing our children's program in the fall and we did lose our normal grant money that we get for that or in the winter, like the children's program. So yeah, thank you all for still doing Measure U and making this work for us. We're definitely very supportive of MLR.

25:43 So, yeah. Thank you. We really appreciate that. And we were able to, like I said, give you guys a little bit more than our original recommendations. So that felt really good to be able to do that. And I'm stoked that you guys can continue to do that. The Shakespeare, I've seen the social media. I saw the survey monkey that you did, putting all that out there. So thank you for continuing to do that event. I know people in the community are extremely happy about that. Any other public comments? Nope.

26:14 Okay, then Craig, do you think we can move into a voting situation? Yes, why don't we have a motion to approve the Measure U funding and special projects for fiscal year 2019-20 budget and for programming grants for fiscal year 2021. And Craig, I apologize, Bill just raised his hand. Oh, I'm sorry. That's okay.

26:44 No worries, Bill. Yeah, I don't know about the technical legalities of it, but normally what you would do is close the public hearing after public comments and then have committee deliberations and the vote. Okay. Thanks, Bill. I appreciate that. You have impressed me greatly over the last few months with your Zoom meeting leading skills. So I'm going to definitely follow your...

27:11 follow your recommendations. So if there's no other public comments, which I do not see anybody else on, so we'll close public comment and then further deliberation from the board and then we'll take a motion. Seeing no further deliberation from anyone, why don't we have a motion? I would make a motion.

27:42 to approve the Measure U special project and programming as recommended. I will second or Rhonda will second. Sorry. Okay, so we have a motion from Bill Souser and a second from Tamara Bankson. Any further discussion? And why don't we do a roll call?

28:18 Bill Souser.

28:20 Bill Souser. Yes.

28:21 Eric Wasserman.

28:22 Yes.

28:23 Rhonda Dugan.

28:25 Yes.

28:26 Catherine Taft.

28:28 Yes.

28:29 Colin Fernie.

28:31 Yes.

28:32 Heather Schaubmeyer.

28:34 Yes.

28:35 Tamara Bankson.

28:36 Yes.

28:38 Craig Albright.

28:40 Yes.

28:41 And David Page has recused himself.

28:43 Thank you.

28:45 Okay.

28:46 OKAY, MOTION PASSES.

28:48 And Heather, great work with the allocations committee and certainly Kim and Matt, you know, your support really made this. I would echo everything Rhonda was saying. It was an impressive process, not only, you know, the programming different entities and how on top of it they were.

29:17 I'm really proud of our community. And then we have a darn good process. So good job, everyone. I just want to say thank you to the allocations committee. I know it's a tremendously difficult process. And you guys have done a great job of streamlining it and making the process super smooth. So I know it's a big lift for everyone. So thank you for all your work on that. Well, thank you. It felt good to be able to get this done in June. So thank you.

29:49 All right. And so moving on to item two in our public hearing, and that is allocation of Measure R funding for Mammoth Lakes Trail System for fiscal year 2021. Matt, you want to take it away? You're muted. Matt? David would be back on or should be back on, but just to tee it up for him, this budget was submitted to the Mammoth Trails Committee.

30:23 They have recommended it be moved to our board for consideration as is. And then I will let David kind of take it from there. Sure, thanks, Matt. Just to remind everyone the context here on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System in the spring of 2017, based on a recommendation from MLR, from this body, the town council.

30:54 approved an allocation, one-time allocation of $500,000 in capital funds and $300,000 a year in operating expenses for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. The Mammoth Trails Committee is a subcommittee of MLR and has, we meet once a month to provide oversight of the ongoing budget. So we're tracking

31:20 the line items every month and getting a report back from the trails coordinator and the various contractors on the projects. So we're aware of what's happening kind of on a monthly basis. And then this would be our fourth fiscal year of that budget. So we're coming up on, you know, we have two more years essentially of the allocation that's been approved by the council.

31:49 So that just to give a little background, as Matt said, this is the budget that came forward from the trails coordinator. The total operating budget that has been suggested and that the trails committee is recommending is actually $30,000 more than the $300,000. We had quite a bit of discussion about how appropriate that was or whether that was appropriate and given the...

32:17 measure our constraints, but we determined that the amount of work that's happening warranted that slight increase in the operating budget. There's a big capital fund still in reserve of $683,500 as well as a new grant this year that came in from an OHV grant.

32:46 For work out in the Shady Rest Corridor on some motorized trails. So another $100,000 in that budget. I don't feel like I want to go through line by line on this, but if anyone has any questions, I can do my best to answer. And also Dan and Bill were in that meeting as well. So please correct me if I've missed anything or if you want to add anything to that. But we're overall really proud of the program and feeling like there's a lot of great work happening.

33:15 I'm sure you all saw there was a scoping notice for potentially moving forward on some of the trails in the Sharp area and in the Lakes Basin, and that's one of the reasons why there's this capital expenditure here is anticipating that there would be some fairly significant trail building over the next fiscal year, as well as likely some environmental review costs that would be incurred as part of the budget.

33:45 So that's kind of the high-level overview. Bill, Dan, did I miss anything? Anybody have any questions? If I can get my computer to unmute. No particular questions. The history of the $300,000 actually goes all the way back to the inception of Measure R and the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee, which became the Mammoth Trails Group. The extra $30,000 is not out of the Measure R budget, but out of general fund.

34:17 Revenues, which gives it an ability to do some things that Measure R can't do. So it's just an add-on that Dan thought was appropriate. And I agree. And with that, I go along. This is a great program. And I would go to move this forward. Thanks, Bill. Yeah, thanks for that addition. I have some staff comments, if we may.

34:53 So we'll get into this on the next item, but staff works pretty closely with both Town Trail crew and Joel, as well as MLTPA. I think when this budget was put before MTC, even though it was only two or three weeks ago, I think the landscape, as we all know with the COVID situation, continues to change.

35:22 One of the areas where we think the budget might be a little bit fat is on the trail days. Right now there's $5,000 being put to that. We know that the June event was canceled. The July event will most likely be canceled. Still probably too early to say about the August and September, but we would say right now it's...

35:51 You know, it's going to be challenging. The other area that we think might be a little bit steep is the Trail Host. Trail Host is a new program that the three organizations have been discussing. Mammoth Lakes Recreation was able to secure $5,000 this past year from People for Bikes and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area to pilot a Trail Host program that was bike-centric for the summer. We still have, we did a little bit of

36:21 modeling this winter for fat bikes and shady rest, but the bulk of that money still remains to be put forth towards the trail host program. So I think one of the recommendations we'd make is to pare down that $10,000, perhaps to $5,000, couple that up with the $4,000 that MLR can provide, and that would get you close back up to the original $10,000 ask. And then the trail days, you know, we may want to take into consideration pairing that down.

36:50 If those come back, then we can always go out and solicit funds. But as you'll see in the recommended R budget, we think pulling $10,000 back from this overall budget for trails, the $300,000 ask for Measure R, and then the $30,000 ask from general fund, we think pulling that $10,000 back would be key to success for Measure R.

37:24 I have a question. I'm in favor of everything that's already existing, but for some of the future planning, Mammoth's in an economic depression, and I don't see us cutting any budgets here. So while I am a huge proponent of trails and in favor of things, just being fiscally conservative, wouldn't it make sense, again, and I just don't understand some of the programs, anything that's being planned for the future, can't money be held in an escrow account and tabled for next year when we have a better economic situation, hopefully?

37:54 We have no revenue coming out of the town right now, and my understanding is we have a $4 billion deficit in the town's budget, so I just would like that addressed. Well, one of the things you need to remember, and Dan can address that better than I, is that these Measure R funds can only be spent for certain things. The $300,000 is an annual set-aside for the trails program that is...

38:24 David said earlier it has two more years yet to run. I am comfortable with the way we have set the town budget that we can function with this. If, however, everything goes sideways and we don't meet the expected revenues for Measure R, then we can come back as a council and revisit the whole thing and, you know, if we don't meet our goals that we set tomorrow for the budget, believe me, a lot of things will be looked at.

38:52 In terms of how do we make appropriate cuts moving forward? Okay, because like I said, I'm fine with everything, but just this seems like a time to be conservative and not planning building new things when, you know, we're worried about things that are a lot more severe if this continues having no revenue in the town. Yeah, one thing I would just say sort of philosophically, and this I suppose is a matter for debate, but I would argue that in the current circumstances,

39:23 The Mammoth Trails are one of the few things that we have to offer as an economic recovery tool. And any new projects that are happening are also creating jobs and handling what we're seeing as an increase in visitation, even if it's not an increase in revenue. That's great. I would say that being said, we should really be getting the lake space and open and using our trails. I am personally frustrated.

39:54 That we are kowtowing to people that might not understand that etiquette if the bathroom is closed says that you hold it. And, you know, if we're going to put all this money and invest in our trail system, let's have it open so us locals could enjoy it as well as our tourists. And then the only thing I would say on that is that that's really out of our purview, that the Forest Service manages a lot of that piece and they've made decisions on a regional.

40:22 level that we don't necessarily have control over. And that would be a place where I think we really do want to recommend investing in a trail host program because that puts us in a better position to be able to provide volunteer man hours when the Forest Service doesn't have staff and decides it can't manage. That's another thing that I hope that we continue to work on is bolstering our partnership agreements so that we do have more ability to

40:51 to control those resources when necessary. But I hear you on that for sure. Now that's great, Jeff, because if we're having to skip the game with money, we should be able to have some control that it's open or closed because it's really unfair to us that it's been closed this whole time. I've got a couple things that I've got questions on. Two things. One, when I hear Trailhost, it kind of crosses over with the conversation I was having with Friends of the Inyo and their Trailhost program.

41:21 So I want to, and I know that you all work together on different stuff. What was the amount that you were putting on for Trailhost? Sorry, on the budget. The Mammoth Lakes Trail System is requesting $10,000. Staff recommends that we pair that down to $5,000 and then supplement that with the $4,000 that we have from the People for Bikes Mammoth Mountain Grant.

41:50 And so I would definitely like to address that kind of crossover, David. And then my other thing would be, you know, Bill's mentioned a couple different times the restrictions on Measure U and these $30,000. Are we being specific about what the $30,000 would be used and why it can't be used out of the Measure R funds? The $30,000 is out of general fund, not Measure U. Excuse me, out of the Measure, sorry.

42:21 The $30,000 from Measure R, you were saying we need it out of the general fund because Measure R is restricted. What are those items that you want to use that $30,000 for? I don't know that I have any specific. Bill, let me address that. This is Dan Holler. We make a partial general fund contribution, and that covers mainly for primarily Joel's time. He does spend time working on

42:51 like town projects if we're dealing with developed MUPS that were not paid for by Measure R. He does some coordination with our Parks Department in those areas. He's done some work like in the Lakes Basin area with fire crews that are not Measure R related functions. And so the extent that he spends a portion of his time in those types of areas that are not Measure R eligible, we don't do a absolute hard hour for hour tracking there.

43:20 It's kind of a general estimate of where he kind of spends time. But the idea on there was some of that work is not Measure R-related project work or funding-based work for Measure R. And so we actually put all that in the trails budget because it does cross over in terms of like if he's working with the fire crew, working on the rock trail, that's absolutely a Measure R project up there. We can spend the money on the maintenance of trails.

43:49 that we're working through and then but some other stuff for example they were doing some tree cutting and some specialty work in the basin for some things that that would be a marginal question whether that's actually a Measure R related type expense but so we cover Joel's time in a number of areas that way or coordination like I say with the Parks Department working on our MUPS in town or something that's not related directly to Measure R so we want to provide funding from the general fund.

44:15 To offset those types of project areas so the question doesn't come up of utilizing him from Measure R on non-Measure R-related project work or not maintaining items that were actually constructed via Measure R and done accordingly from that element. So there's a, there's a, it's not a hard line in there, but we do believe there should be an adequate dollar amount from the general fund to help offset his work in areas that are non-Measure R-related. And then regarding the trail hose.

44:48 How is it that we're not overlapping on Friends of the Inyo? I know Friends of the Inyo seem to be concentrating on the Lake's Basin, which will hopefully be up and going by next month. What area are you specifically working on with that, David? Yeah, and that's a great question. And honestly, I'm going to have to defer to staff to really get into the nitty-gritty on that. We've been working with, you know, we've been in discussions with Friends of the Inyo about precisely that overlap for the last three years. You know, as...

45:17 As Matt said, our initial pilot program on the trail host program was winter focused and in the shady rest zone. And as far as I understand, the second phase is really to look at some of our bike related trail resources. And that's why the People for Bikes grants to look at, for example, the Mammoth Rock Trail, to have hosts there explaining, you know, what

45:45 Whether you can be there on an e-bike or on a motorized rig or not. But I think that some of that is still to be determined. And I think it's an important point you make there, Heather. And I know that both Joel and Matt and the whole staff is very aware of what Friends of Inyo is doing and where the overlap is. And I've always been advocating for making that overlap, you know, making that a real robust partnership between the two organizations so that we're

46:15 From a trail user standpoint, you know, when you're out there on the trails, you don't necessarily know or care which organization is funding the trail host. And so we should try to make that seamless from a visitor use perspective. And all I can say is they're working on that. I know, if I may, I know Joel requested to bring on two part-time staff for the program.

46:41 combination. We get a lot of demand out in the shady rest area and the trails out in there and then a few other places where they go, not necessarily in the Lakes Basin, but you'd ask about hiring now as I told him to actually hold on that for a moment, one getting to the new year versus the current year. The one I believe with the people for bikes component, those are more restricted in terms of actually being out on a bike and being on trails that

47:11 Either a multi-use or restricted to mountain biking, like the Panorama Dome maybe would be an example into the basin. Coming down into the Rock Trail and down through Old Mammoth in that area where you can do mountain biking. And they do information. They also do some information gathering, kind of non-obtrusively, but talking to people and getting information from them. They've gone out, Joel, and I think Matt went out with him, but they were out just doing it on their own time, if you will.

47:40 It's a non-normal Monday through Friday time. They were out on a weekend and extremely positive response just back to being helping people to direct them to different places where they can go. The Lakes Basin question, for example, yes, the road is closed and motorized, but you're more than willing and happy to take your bikes up there, go up in height, go up and utilize the facilities accordingly. You just can't drive up into the basin. So being able to provide that information to people was really beneficial. And so that really...

48:08 Heighten the need of, hey, can we start the program? And we said, well, let's wait until July 1 with a new budget, make sure we're ready to go with it. He has two staff people, I think, identified part-time to bring on to assist with that. And then the people for bikes, one would only come into Accenture where you're actually dealing with a bike-related or optional trail site, kind of what David mentioned too, making sure you're doing it appropriate for that.

48:34 type of use in the various trails. My understanding from a brief conversation here a week ago or 10 days ago with Joel in the program, so working through that, but they are extremely excited to get that out and going because of a lot of the questions they do get when they're out. And they followed up additionally with the Forest Service. I know they speak with them on some of the areas, high impact areas. How can they go out and help provide that type of information? Again, a lot of it being outside of the basin area where they're seeing

49:03 improved areas of access or numbers of people going up. And they do the trail counter so they kind of get a feel for where those high use areas are at that they can go out and assist people. Dan, there are some questions on a granular level, but while we've got you, can we take a step back and just get a little bit more broad scope of where budget's at for 19-20? I mean, I know we're approaching the end of the fiscal year.

49:29 We had a relatively conservative budget that I know we eclipsed in February, but then, you know, revenue dried up. So, you know, where are we tracking? Can you just give us, you know, budget for 19-20 and then budget for 20-21 and then where we're looking for 19-20 and that kind of stuff just to give a better sense of where we're at from a 10,000 foot level? Yeah, from a TOT standpoint, we did when we got through February and March, we hit those numbers.

49:59 What we really saw the drop off in that impacts both town budget to some degree as well as the Measure R related budget was a drop off in taxable sales. So the use tax for Measure R took a big hit. Last numbers I saw, we were actually in a negative balance with the state of about 21,000, I think it was, and looking at a very small amount coming in for April, May, and June.

50:25 And that's where we, you know, just over a million dollars estimated for revenue in the current year coming in for Measure R. About a half a million drop in sales tax on the town side. A little different in the math there because one is a transaction and use tax versus sales tax. So there's a little distinction in there that's important because it tends to put a...

50:45 If things are going well, it tends to put a little more money on the use tax side, the way that's allocated. So that was a hit to the Measure R side. We see a little drop-off in the Measure U side, which is all utility-based tax, utility user taxes. And with the shutdown, frankly, obviously, less utilities being utilized, which is a percentage of payment. So we did see a drop-off in there a little bit from budget as well. I don't remember.

51:12 The hard numbers are off the top of my head. I'd have to go back and look at the last report we did on that, but there was a decline in those areas as well. We anticipate that similar drop moving into next year. So looking at a million dollar budget revenue wise for Measure R versus the 1.35 or so that we had budgeted this year. And then a little bit of a drop in Measure U as well on that because of the lack of use and kind of just the unknowns going forward in that area as well.

51:42 Activity and how much opening we'll see. So town-wise, yeah, we looked at the general fund was about a $4 million cut. We've worked through that, balancing that out between budget reductions and some reserve uses within the general fund. Also doing that, our gas tax fund, we're using reserves to balance it out to meet the requirements for road maintenance and snow removal going into the next year. One of the big hits there was a snow load.

52:11 both snow year impacts the budget for next year in that area, for example. So we can get more details on the overall budget if you need it, but for the Measure R and U, the sales tax numbers are definitely dropping down significantly for Measure R and Measure U, a slight, a smaller drop, but a drop in the use tax revenue. So I would add to that, Colin, that it appears for Measure R,

52:37 In the 1920 budget, the budget we're currently going to end here in a couple of weeks, we're going to end up $74,000 upside down. So we're going to have to do some sort of a budget exercise to alter the budget to cover that deficit. And then next year's expended income, we're taking down to a million dollars. General fund side, we met our TOT expectations, came in way low on the sales tax, but we will meet our budget.

53:06 with the cuts that we've already made. The one for us is the 74,000 upside down on Measure R for the current fiscal year. Right. So basically, current fiscal year, 1920, we're coming up a little bit toward, you know, maybe a 5%, whereas next year, moving forward, we're looking at a 25-30%. Right. Exactly.

53:29 Well, yeah, the overall, the short this year in the operating budget there, I think this year the actual drop in revenue was pretty steep as well in 19, in the current year for the last quarter. I don't remember the hard dollar number, but it was most of that deficit is coming out of that. We would have had a small surplus originally in the budget, but that's been wiped out as well. And then can we just address, you know, Dan, David, Bill, you know, those of you that are more involved specifically on the MTC.

53:59 the specific granular recommendations from staff in terms of a slight reduction in budget regarding trail days and the host program. Can we speak to those specific questions? Colin, before we go there, I'd like to go back to the host program and the questions on the overlap between the two organizations or my old brain forgets it. Friends of the Inyo,

54:28 brought us, before MLR was formed, a proposal for the trail host program, but their charges we felt at that time were exorbitant. When we hire our own employees to do the trail host, all we're covering is the cost of the employees. When we partner with friends of the Inyo, we are not only paying for their employees, but for the added expense of the organization on top of it. So it's a much more expensive

54:58 prospect from my position, from my opinion, and having dealt with them in all of this before. Also, Heather, part of the host program will include Shady Rest and some motorized recreation areas eventually, and Friends of the Inyo is a decidedly anti-motorized organization. It is my understanding they're also one of the organizations that is going to try to stop us from

55:25 Building the new trails that up to this point were almost a shoo-in for Joel's crew to do. So I'm not sure they're the organization we want to be partnering with if they are anti-recreation. I don't think that's a mischaracterization, though. Yeah, thank you. Appropriate to say, but just for some context, folks, as it pertains to the host program, very briefly, how this program came about, the real genesis of it was when the decision was made.

55:55 to allow class one e-bikes on Mammoth Mountain ski area. And, you know, that was the first time that class one e-bikes were allowed on any soft surface trail, at least here in California. And so there was some concern that those bikes would be taken off the ski area property and used on other soft surface trails here in the community. And we wanted to try to get ahead of that.

56:25 One of the concerns is that with the e-bikes being one of the fastest growing segment in bike sales and the technology being such that right now you can look at an e-bike and even from five feet away not know it's an e-bike. They used to be very big with the batteries and kind of clunky and most of the major manufacturers now are making very streamlined, very aesthetically copacetic bikes to what we would see normally.

56:52 Us working with the Forest Service and other land management agencies, we wanted to figure out a way, not just how we could get ahead of it from a policy level, but actually make those decisions from an informed place. And so one of the things, as I think Dan mentioned, is that we wanted to get out there and do some counting and try to record where these incursions were taking place and get as much data as possible. So that was really the genesis of it. The concerns that Forest Service had was that, you know,

57:20 The people out there not act in a law enforcement capacity. So we didn't want anybody out there saying, hey, this is a closed trail. You're not allowed to be on there. So we really had to do some cooperative work with the land management people to have them trust that we could have folks out there just kind of accepting information. And so that was really the genesis of that. And that's why the program, the pilot program is geared towards bikes.

57:50 Sitting around the table, I think everybody has these aspirations, and MLR certainly shares that, is wouldn't it be great if we had something that was larger so we could service other trail users, whether those were hikers, other cyclists, non-motorized cyclists, motorized users out in shady routes and elsewhere. But again, I think that this program right now is still, it's almost embryonic stage. I won't say it's completely embryonic because we...

58:18 Just did a little bit of a brief pilot this winter out in Shady Rest, but we don't have any actual use yet on bikes out into the soft surface trail environment. So, you know, our position, our being MLR, is that always that we took this very slowly because there are some issues in how this manifests with the Forest Service. We want to make sure that it's not put in a role where these people who will be wearing vests and...

58:47 Have some identification on them, not be perceived as, again, law enforcement or any sort of enforcement. And then B, what kind of information are they going to be collecting and disseminating? So right now, you know, the trail ambassadors program that's run by FOI is largely an interpretive program. And if that's going to be the case, then, you know, I would want to make sure, and I'm sure Tamara probably has some thoughts on this. You know, you don't just roll out with an interpretive program. You know, those have to be structured.

59:16 Very carefully. And we want to make sure that the information that is disseminated is the correct information, which if you live in this town, it changes with the breeze. And so I think there's a lot of places that needs work and attention before we roll out robustly with the program. And so that's been the position for MLR is that we absolutely want to have a trail program. And we absolutely believe that there is...

59:43 The potential to have this program funded through Measure R and elsewhere, but how it manifests itself, I think we still need to have a lot of consideration on. So for that reason, we would like to see it piloted this year, certainly with the bikes. And then I think there is a bit of a need, you know, Joel's been out there at some of the trailheads just collecting some information. I think with the COVID situation resulting in the closures and just kind of making it challenging for our visitors and for our residents.

1:00:15 There is a need to have some people out there dispensing information, but again, I don't think that we have complete clarity on how that will be executed. From my part, if you were asking how I felt about the budget, as a Mammoth Lakes Trails member, I already voted for this. I'm very happy with moving it forward as is. Can we just specifically address those two items that were suggested to change, you know, the drop down?

1:00:47 From 10 to 5 on the host program with the 4,000 carryover would get us to 9 versus 10, but pretty much the same. And then looking at potentially whether or not we need to have the same dollar amount for the trail days programs in lieu of the fact that some of them are likely to be canceled. So just looking at those two specific items that were brought up.

1:01:15 Are those adjustments warranted? I've pretty much given you my opinion on it. I would leave them as is in the budget. David, you're on the trails committee and so is Dan. Any opinions? Well, I mean, honestly, I think if this body wanted to recommend trying to pull $10,000 out of the budget, I would not necessarily oppose that, but I would not be interested in a prescriptive cut. I would just say.

1:01:51 We need to take X amount out of it and let the trails coordinator figure out how to fix that. But I agree with Bill, having been through it line item by line item, I think it's a good solid budget. So I think it kind of comes back to Dan and to the board here to decide whether we can afford that budget or we need to ask for a reduction. I think it's, from my perspective, if I may, it's speaking really for sitting on the MTC board.

1:02:22 I think one of the things we did and what's really made the trail system work here was that five-year commitment. I think it was talked about earlier in terms of the second or third year of doing that and putting those dollars aside. And each year, throughout the year, we go through the budget. And if there's the $300,000 is really the recommendation from the MTC to go up. We do the line item detail. In the past, I think MLR, understanding the reason why now the full board level is really not.

1:02:51 Dove into the line items and requested adjustments there. The element for the trails side was if there's dollars throughout the year, money does get moved around between the specific line items, depending on actual costs as we get through the year. It's a best budget at the beginning of the year. And then if there's dollars that are unspent, they actually stay in the trails budget. And I think at one point in time, there was concerns over the budget, you know, being

1:03:18 Not being solid in the trails program, loses money, it goes back into other areas. And that could either be directed at the town level or MLR level. I think the goal was to try to protect the trails commitment funding. So that's tough to see that drop down. I understand the $10,000 request to go back on the other side. As David mentioned, if you did do that, I think it would go back to, you know, you would just go back to the trails coordinator slash MTLC and say, hey, we need to cut money out of here.

1:03:47 I know initially the request from the Trails that were coming forward was actually for a higher allocation of Measure R money into the program, which I frankly see in the revenue side was telling Joel, the Trails Manager side, that I didn't think that was in the cards, frankly, and getting to the MTC, that would be a hard sell to ask for additional dollars out of Measure R period for the overall budget. So they did work to stay within their budgeted allocation, what historically has been.

1:04:17 I guess the question, if you cut it this year, the question is how do you, you know, are you going to add it back to next year or are we making a fundamental shift in a reduced funding for the trails program going forward? And as you, I guess it's, I'm always concerned on the slippery slope on this stuff is this year is 10 grand. If we need 50 next year, do we take it out of here as well? So I'm really cautious on holding to those allocations, I think, in terms of the commitment we've made into this area.

1:04:46 And I would frankly, I believe this area actually has been a very good success for us. We do have some grant dollars in there with the SHRIC work. We've got other project dollars in there that will probably end up being light long-term for construction of new trails and work. And to see that diminished, I think it's really difficult because getting it back in the future becomes that much more difficult, frankly, in terms of adding dollars back into it in those areas.

1:05:15 Again, MTC hat, if you will, not speaking from a town perspective on this. We spent quite a bit of time on the budget on the beginning and throughout the year and doing the oversight on it. And again, I think it's been managed fairly effectively and fairly prudently. As I mentioned earlier, I know Joel wanted to start the host program early and this is a town hat going, well, your budget's not approved yet, so no, you can't hire people until the budget's approved. So for them to really get out there and get in front of it.

1:05:44 Whether they spend the full $10,000 down for the host program out there, I couldn't tell you right now, but I know they were very, very excited about the program to try to move that forward. So I would be cautious in terms of that. It doesn't seem like a lot, and some of it is backfilled with the other dollars to be able to do that, but if those are gone next year, you know, are we back to, you know, beefing it back up or not, I guess would be the other question. If it starts to go down, it's hard to add back usually.

1:06:12 So the recommendation as an MTC member more so than a town perspective would be I'm very comfortable with the 330 number in there for a budget. We'd actually put a little more general fund in last year for some work on our MUPS. We had the crews work with of sealing a lot of cracks and we reduced those dollars back out this year as that project was completed last year. So I know it made the budget tight this year for the MTC review and dollars going into it.

1:06:42 I guess from an MTC perspective, I think it'd be hard to really go and say, yeah, let's cut these programs back, not knowing where we'll end up on some of the other work. I'll slip in right now. Tamara, go ahead if you have something. I just have one last question. I appreciate all the work everybody's done on the line items, and I agree with you. I'm not an advocate of reducing if we don't have to at this point. But I just have one question. On the line items that you've gone through very specifically, is there any movement?

1:07:11 on any of those, if we find that, you know, we don't know what the year is going to hold for us, that we have a requirement in signage or PPE or trail, we need to increase trail hose, is there any movement on any of these line items, say we don't use something or we find a need for use within the fiscal year? Yeah, that's the process that we, so as a committee, we look at it every month.

1:07:36 And the trails coordinator comes to us and says, look, we need to reallocate. We need to move $5,000 from here over to the website. And so that's the level at which we're tracking it. So really, all we really need to do here is just to give the cap for the annual budget. Right, of use of funds. Yep. That helps me know where I stand. So I advocate for a reduction in it.

1:08:05 From my perspective, it would, you know, I'm not looking to micromanage or kind of get into the details because I know you guys have done a lot of work on that. I guess my broader question just to play devil's advocate is, is it appropriate philosophically to say we're going to hold the line on budget expenditures in the light of the environment where everybody's looking?

1:08:29 to shave some costs. So that's just my general philosophical question is it seems to me to be almost operating in a vacuum to say we're trying to protect the exact dollar amount spent on this particular program in light of the fact that we know that Measure R moving forward at least for fiscal 2021 is going to be reduced in terms of revenue generated. I just think it's a...

1:08:55 I'm not looking to necessarily like kind of get in and micromanage the line items of the budget, but. Yeah, I mean, I guess the question there would be, the really question to the MLR board isn't so much the line items, it would be the recommendation from the MTC was for $300,000 of Measure R funding. And if the recommendation changes and so, no, we're not going to support that, we'll support $290,000 in allocation.

1:09:21 For the trails program, then we would have the staff component come back and say, given that, okay, here's the stuff that we would recommend not doing. And Dan, is it, I know you mentioned this a little bit ago, but is it normal that we're infusing general fund money on top of the 300? For the last three years, when we brought Joel on, some of that, we were just charging him off to the general fund as a portion of his salary.

1:09:50 But we thought that kind of skewed the dollar amounts that we were putting into the trails program and stuff. So instead of charging him over to a fund over in the public works side or actually parks trail side, we just instead of charging him there, we took that dollar amount and just put it into the trails budget directly versus trying to make him allocate hours out on a regular basis. I think we had a pretty solid, you know.

1:10:16 I'll say the hour allocation is pretty close to where we've been on hitting with the allocations. And last year was really unique because we had them do a lot of work on the MUPS, doing working with the parks on a crack seal program. So we covered all that out of the general fund side, not out of the trail side as well. But yeah, so we ended up moving the dollars over. So it actually reflected that full cost in there versus charging him. I think it was split 75, 25 percentage.

1:10:44 So he was over the general fund in a different department, which then skewed that department because they had no control over that piece of their budget. Makes total sense to infuse some dollars from the general fund over there. So he has flexibility to work as he sees fit. You know, theoretically, the budget's not 300. I know it's 300 coming from R, but it's actually 330 that they have in terms of utilization. So I'm just wondering if we...

1:11:10 If we want to just stick at the 300 or if it's appropriate to have a conversation about any sort of shaving of that. Yeah, I'll say ultimately it's, you know, the recommendation of MTC was for 300 Measure R, ultimately the Measure R Board could make a, you know, different request for that. Again, remember this is a recommendation and it goes up to the town council to have that same discussion based on the input and information provided by this board.

1:11:38 So in light of all that, what I'd like us to do is to, you know, following our public hearing is let's, that'll be the end of questions from the board. We're gonna go and see if we have any public testimony and then I'll be looking for a motion either from the sounds of it for a 290 recommendation from the MLR board for Measure R funding

1:12:08 Or a $300,000, get a second, debate it, and vote on it. Because I think we've had pretty good discussion on the actual questions. Now it's just a matter of us getting some public testimony and then entertaining a motion. Craig, I have my hand up. I just want to clarify. We're voting on the program funding part for the $330,000, but what about that other $140,000 in the capital funding? Yes, vote.

1:12:37 Does it include us spending that extra 140? Are we voting yes or no based on the 330? The capital funding comes from a reserve that is already set aside. And so all we're voting on would be the Measure R allocation right now. Okay. The capital funding is coming from a reserve of $650,000 plus that is precisely set aside for capital funding.

1:13:07 Then there's the grant fund, which is out of our purview. And there's the general fund allocation of $30,000, which also would be out of our purview. Gotcha, because just stop telling all the other comments. I'm fine with the first part of it, but with the capital funding issue, I would want to know if that did not go forward, what the negative ramifications would be if those trials, can that be just held and delayed for one year?

1:13:34 Just because, again, operating in a vacuum in an economic depression, it just doesn't seem right to do new things. Well, again, the process for doing new trails is an extremely lengthy and complex process. And one of the reasons why that's out is because we've gotten to a place where the Forest Service has put out a scoping notice to do an environmental review and potentially give us permission to build a trail. And the reason we had that capital fund

1:14:04 on the side in the first place was to be nimble enough to be able to respond because if the district ranger were to approve this trails project and we didn't have the funding, we would lose the opportunity to build that trail. But we have that funding set aside precisely for when the opportunity arises to build a trail. Perfect, thanks for clarifying. I'm sorry, I'm naive. I just wanted to make sure I understood. Thank you. This trails was really, we're talking about, you guys have been working on this for about a year and a half, if I'm correct, yes?

1:14:32 Been working on it for 12 years. Okay. But I mean, like, this back and forth has been going on for at least a year and a half, specifically for this little final stage that you're talking about. Yeah, at least that. Yeah, I mean, it is a long story. It comes from a collaborative effort back in 2011. But, yeah. Well, great. Thank you. So, do we have any, no further board questions from the looks of it?

1:15:04 Thank you, by the way. I just want to say thank you to everybody for answering all those questions. It's a lot to go through and just wanted to say thank you. I know you guys do a lot of work on the back end and I'm not here to micromanage either, but thank you for answering those questions. Absolutely. Do we have any public comment testimony on this particular issue? Measure R funding. Angela? I have no one in the audience and no one has emailed in any comments.

1:15:34 Okay, excellent. Thank you very much. So I'll entertain a motion from the board. I would make a motion to move the trails budget forward as presented. I would second that. All right. Further discussion? And without further discussion, roll call. Wait, Rhonda's raising her hand. Oh, I'm sorry. Yeah. I'm seeing my hands.

1:16:09 That's okay. I'm used to it. Again, I appreciate everybody's hard work on this, but as a budget person, I do look at line by line, and I just wanted to echo Eric's concerns about making sure that we have done due diligence to provide budgets that are cognizant of the situation that we're in.

1:16:36 And I know that I do know that any cuts that we would make would be looking at the situation we're in and not something that's ongoing and changing setting policy. So I'm more in favor of bringing it down the $10,000 to the 290. Okay, Heather, do you have any? I'll go around and make sure everyone can, now that we have an actual motion on the table.

1:17:08 Heather, do you have any other comments? My only comment is I'm going to be okay with this budget because I know that there's been a lot of work that's been done on it. I think, again, kind of like my outlook on with events, I don't want to not fund someone so that if they are able to move forward that their hands are tied. I'm just hoping that there's going to be check-ins and fiscal responsibility as we're moving forward, which I'm sure there will be.

1:17:38 And so I'm going to be okay with it the way it is. Catherine, how about you? Yeah, I mean, I've listened to everything in both sides, and I can really argue it either way. You know, I just, speaking from the programming side, I think there might be overlap with the trail ambassadors, trail host program. I think Matt kind of presented a...

1:18:02 Another option for solving that if we were to reduce it, not that it's our task to do that now here today, but just knowing there are some options out there for kind of replenishing if we were to move a reduced budget forward makes me feel good about that, about going with the 290. Cool. How about moving on to Tamara, did you have any other additional comments?

1:18:30 No, I asked all the questions I needed to, and like I said, I appreciate everyone's hard work on all of the line items and seeing where we're at, and I trust that you've got that check-in and that we're watching the utilization of these funds, and I'm really happy to hear that they roll over so that there isn't any loss of it. If we were to need to pull back on something, that we wouldn't lose these funds, so I'm comfortable accepting it as it is.

1:19:01 And I too, like Catherine, I think I've heard from everybody on this issue. And, you know, if there's any more, by all means, raise your hand. But like Catherine, I can go either way. There's a little bit of an overlap there, you know, with Friends of the Inyo and, you know, the two ambassador programs.

1:19:24 You know, I guess I lean towards the, like my friend Eric, my fiscal conservatism, knowing that we've got cuts going all along throughout our town and in every business and household in our community. Even $10,000 may not seem like much in the big scheme of things, but, you know, I would lean to move to

1:19:54 Reduce it. But the motion on the table is the $300,000. So if I don't have any other further deliberation, look at every single one of you to see if I see a hand go up. And let's have a roll call, please. I just want to thank everybody for explaining that to me. And I wasn't trying to stall things on the 10-yard line. I just needed an explanation of how the capital funding works. So thank you. Cool. All right. Roll call.

1:20:25 Bill Souser. Yes. Eric Wasserman. Yes. Rhonda Dugan. No. Catherine Taft. Say no. Colin Fernie. No. Colin Fernie. No. Heather Schaubmeyer. Yes. Tamara Bankson. Yes. David Page. Yes. And Craig Albright.

1:21:00 And no. Passes 5-4 from my count. That's correct. Okay. Thank you very much, team. You know, like everyone said, you know, people could accuse us of getting in the weeds, but it's important that we understand, you know, all these little nuances of the work we're doing. So good questions overall. Bill, you got something for me?

1:21:28 Completely unrelated. Thank you guys all for the consideration of that. When we were talking, Colin asked some questions of Dan about the budget, and Dan said something about reserves. Colin, very important that everybody on this phone call understands that as conservative as we've run the budget, in next year's budget, we are not dipping into the economic for uncertainty or the other large reserve that we keep. These are coming out of airport reserves, CIP reserves.

1:21:57 Those sorts of things. So at this point, we are not yet having to go to the point of actually digging into our large reserves for, you know, emergency situations. Okay. Thanks for that, Bill. And important to know, because this is the biggest global emergency I think any of us will see in our lifetime.

1:22:25 Let's hope. Yeah. But hopefully I didn't jinx it. But that is, you know, very much a testament to, you know, the town council and staff for running a lean ship during these good years and stashing money away for a rainy day. So thank you for bringing that up, Bill, because that is important to know. All right. Moving on to allocation for Measure R funding for other expenditures.

1:22:54 for fiscal year 2021 budget with references of attachment three and four, I believe. And Matt, you want to take it away on that? Sure, thanks, Craig. So as Dan mentioned earlier, both the town and specifically our Measure R fund has been hit very hard with the fallout from the COVID outbreak.

1:23:24 We are losing significant amounts of money. You know, it's encouraging to see visitors coming into town, but we have no way of knowing, you know, what the future might hold for that. So the town of Mammoth Lakes has, you know, we're just finishing up our, we being MLR, we're just finishing up our

1:23:49 Third year of contract with them and that contract expires June 30th. And so tomorrow night the town council or staff will be making a presentation, town of Mammoth Lakes staff will be making a presentation to town council to consider options for MLR contract renewal. I believe staff's recommending a non-renewal. And so

1:24:20 From our standpoint, our staff here at MLR, we've looked at that and then we have come up with some recommendations that we think we can use in our funding, which will allow MLR to maintain a lessened amount of funding from Measure R in the town of Mammoth Lakes while still being able to live up to all of our obligations.

1:24:47 in overseeing Measure R and the trails budget and special projects. And the solution would be advantageous in that it should not theoretically cost anything out of the town general fund. So it won't cost them anything more than what's in R currently. And so I'll walk you through that again.

1:25:16 The drop in revenue during Q4 of 1920 has been significant. The latest numbers I had were approximately specifically out of our, I think Rob Patterson told me about $250,000 that may have grown. Those numbers I'm working on are probably several weeks old. But the town projects that these losses will likely continue through fiscal year 2021, duration to be determined and amount to be determined.

1:25:45 But for right now, as you look at the budget, they're estimating that the annual revenue, which was 1.3 million, just a little bit over 1.35 million, will drop down to 1 million. So we're expecting a loss of $300,000. So our analysis in Measure R, staff believes that we can work out a compromise, again, that will allow MLR to continue its work.

1:26:13 Without asking the town to commit any money from general fund. The basis of this is that in June of last year, approximately a year ago, town of Mammoth Lake staff came to Measure R and asked to direct $1.2 million from the Measure R reserve funds back to help fund the Community Recreation Center. And that was out of the 19-20 budget.

1:26:43 It was thought at that time that the construction bid, we had recently moved away from a hardened structure to a tin-style fabric structure that we would purchase from a company called Sprung, and that we would be able to secure a bid and get that project going this year. For those of you who've been tracking this, I think you would know that at the last town council meeting, Mammoth Lakes, town of Mammoth Lakes,

1:27:12 received four bids, all of them over the targeted amount by at least $1 million, some of them a few million dollars higher. So the town council instructed Public Works to go out and reconfigure that bid and then send it out again. You know, and it's not really the purpose of this call right now to talk about

1:27:42 That specifically, I'm sure we could address that at a later date, but I think it's clear right now that we're not going to hit the targeted construction timeline that we had talked about a year ago when we directed $1.2 million back towards the CRC. So understanding that this timeline is going to be probably lengthened by several months at the minimum, staff is recommending that

1:28:11 We move $100,000 of the $1.2 million set aside for the CRC back into reserves for Measure R. And then this would allow us to have a bit of a cushion. And so if you can go down to attachment four, I'll walk you through it. So as you see on the top line, that's the delta that we're expecting through the losses, the 1.35 dropping down to 1.2 in expected annual revenue.

1:28:40 And so going through here, the town had proposed a transfer of the Measure R pool of $300,000. Staff had recommended 290, but that just got passed for $300,000. Town is also recommending that there is no funding or funding is discontinued, the $192,000 be discontinued. Staff is recommending that

1:29:06 We'd be funded at a lesser amount of $142,000. That's a 26% reduction, leaving or yielding a net positive of $50,000 back to Measure R. Special projects, town did not make any reductions in that. They're still carrying over special projects. But bearing in mind, special projects for Measure R need to be put forth by the town, specifically, usually comes out of parks and recs.

1:29:35 We work very closely with Parks and Rec, Stuart and I, you know, the last project that we did obviously was the disc golf course, which we're excited and looking forward to opening very, very soon. It's a soft open right now, but we're just waiting on the signing to get that open. Then we'll have an opening party for that. But that was a very successful project. The next thing that was kind of in the hopper, so to speak, was we were looking at some sort of pump track or bike track facility.

1:30:03 That would be a great complement to the CRC. Right now, just as the CRC has gotten pushed forward, that has been kicked down the road a bit. So that's definitely not going to happen in fiscal year 2021. So we're demanding that that $25,000 be put back to Measure R. And then the rest of it was for maintenance and equipment replacement. We are recommending, staff recommending no reduction in that. That's work, that critical work that needs to happen through the town departments to get, you know, our recreational resources maintained and replaced if needed.

1:30:36 Audit services won't be touched. So basically under the annual expenses, what was listed out previously at $562,000, town had recommended cuts that would yield $370,000. And then through Measure R's recommendation, that amount is kind of right in between the $562,000 drops to $477,000.

1:31:05 The debt servicing, it will continue. That goes up. It was $612,000 in the past and change. It's now $614, $441. We haven't made any recommendations to alter that. Where we are making the recommendation, though, again, is out of the 19-20 allocated expenditure for the CRC listed on here as the multi-use facility. We would like to see $100,000 transferred back out of that pool.

1:31:35 That would then give us, if you see the change in fund balance, if they were to cut MLR completely, they would end up with $15,559 a measure, our leftover. With all of the money that we're recommending, it's going to be, was going to be $559,000. However, with the passage of the budget for the trails.

1:32:03 We'll probably have a Delta of just under $2,000, which, you know, going back, staff could either pull that out of the town agreement, or we could pull that out of reserves or something to make up that amount. Okay, on to board questions for staff. I have no questions, but I do have several comments, probably for later. Okay, thank you, Bill.

1:32:45 Questions for Matt? Craig, if I may, if I could ask one if Matt knows, it wasn't in here. I haven't looked or tried to track back through some old reports, but the current reserve balance that MLR has is unrestricted. Do you have a feel for that? Honestly, I just don't know and haven't looked. Approximately? Approximately, I would say that we're right around $200,000. Okay.

1:33:18 Unrestricted, right? No, that's not unrestricted. That's our amount in reserve right now. I don't have a fingertip feel about what our unrestricted is. I mean, there's a combined amount in there of the money that we received from the original 225 that was front-loaded. There's amounts in there for our restricted program. So we have significant amounts that are being held for everything from

1:33:46 Tangle Free Waters to Adopt-A-Trail to other facilities, the bridge that were scheduled to build up in Horseshoe Lake. And then we also have $50,000, just over $50,000 that was secured from PPP. So yeah, it's kind of a hodgepodge of different funding. I couldn't tell you what is unrestricted to an exact number or even in a prompt. All right, thanks.

1:34:20 Other questions from board members? Yes, I'd have a question for Dan. Can you talk to us more about that $100,000? What was that set aside for? What's it meant to be? I mean, the proposal to pull the $100,000 from the CRC? Yeah. Yeah, so the CRC budget was set at $13 million.

1:34:48 That included the, as Matt noted, the $1.2 million transfer over from the Measure R fund. The last round that came in, it would have been closer to $16 million. All in are a little over $16 million. So their direction was to go out and rebid that project, taking out some of the second story elements and some other elements within the CRC that allow the budget to be met in that $13 million range.

1:35:16 At this point, pulling those dollars out just means as far as doing a bid award, let's say we do get a good bid in, we would have to have a guarantee that we could actually award the bid, which means money in the bank, basically. So if the bid award was up to that, part of that $13 million has already been spent, if you will, on architecture and other things. So if we were short on that, then we'd have to cover the $100,000 out of other resources on the front end. But as Matt mentioned, the question there would be bringing it back in the future.

1:35:46 In terms of savings and or assuming revenues go up in year two, 21, 22 for that purpose. So that would shift all the ballpark. How much is in that reserve fund now that we've, that we're debt servicing at $650,000 a year? $650,000 is to the $5.5 million in financing that was set aside for the CRC and the bond documents. So that's the purpose of those funds for that.

1:36:16 And there's other general fund money and other money over there. So how much is in, you're saying it was 13 million, but some of that's already been spent. So what's actually in that reserve fund right now? I would guess it's about probably just over 11 million. I know 1.2 has been spent and then there's some additional on top of that. So maybe 1.5 at the most. So 1.5 minus 13 would be cash in that capital project fund.

1:36:42 Thanks. Do you anticipate going out to bid anytime soon on the CRC? Yes, we're actively going back out to, it's a red line of the current building plans and that would be put back out in the street either probably mid-July, first week, first meeting in August, it would go out for a, I can't remember if it's a 45 or 60 day turnaround, probably 45 day turnaround from the current. We anticipate the current.

1:37:10 The people bid on the last one, the four would probably likely bid again on the project. We have had discussions with all of them in terms of some of the elements in there that we would take out to bring the bid down and kind of broad stroke type discussions. If that happens, then we'd have the option whether we go into construction, any type of dirt work this fall at the earliest or if we put it into a winter suspension and wait till spring would be the question.

1:37:41 And that's really on that final timing of laying that out, of getting the bid docs back out and the information in. And can you articulate a little bit what you anticipate those red line items to be to bring the dollar amount down by like 3 million-ish? Yeah, a lot of it, we had a second story structure in there. That alone was about 1.2 million, 1.3 million.

1:38:08 Another couple hundred thousand, you had to put an outside stair access back out as a secondary access. So that was a large chunk of it. The other piece was if you're not doing the upstairs, then you didn't have to do the catwalk access and those types of things to over to a man lift that goes up to that versus an elevator component there. So that came down. And then the...

1:38:35 Some of the actual structural elements for like the staff area just becomes a large area versus carved up in the office space area. So more of a common work area versus a detailed staff area by offices and things of that nature. If it's a lot of that work, if it's just really, it's just stick built, it's a lot less expensive and actually that can be added into the current foundation in the future. The other piece on it was some of the finished work.

1:39:04 Was it a higher end versus needing to be there to get the same quality? We also had comments from looking at the bids that came in on the types of lighting and HVA system was spec'd at a higher dollar amount than I would say the bidders again, all of them identified some of those areas that

1:39:27 You really need to look at what you're specifying these areas because you can definitely reduce the cost areas there. So they identified between three and four million dollars that we could reduce. Again, they're not going to tell us exactly because they want to bid on the project again. So they're not going to tell the competitors, obviously, those types of reductions either. But the second story element of the facility was probably the single largest.

1:39:53 Hide them in there to try to get that additional 2,500 square feet or better of community space. They're still on the bottom area. There's still areas for that as well. But that second story was a big nut. And that's just steel pricing and putting pricing in those types of elements. And Dan, from what I saw from the presentation, wasn't it less of an exterior treatment as well? No, we did very little modifications to the exterior based on the design review from the planning commission. So that was.

1:40:26 There's a couple of minor items, I think, in that, but very little to design on the outside, not having to re-go through that design review process. We're actually looking at the one change on the outside was the parking area, not part of the bid here. We're looking at actually incorporating that into our downtown parking study and transit hub element. The park with the facility has been defined as a potential transit hub site.

1:40:54 If that's the case in there for parking and bus services, we would use related transit funding for the parking expansion and work there versus the CRC funding components. So some of that was modified back. We've been requested, we have a major stop in the parking lot here by Vons. We've been requested by the Vons management to move that stop. They've actually never permitted it to be in the parking lot. Here's my understanding.

1:41:24 They've asked us to move that. We've told them we're actually looking at the site at the park. Give us some time if we can move it. If they push back after this winter, then we'll need to move it regardless. Either put it in the park or somewhere else or eliminate it. Eliminating the stop would be problematic, I think, for a number of people. But the park site probably is a good alternative for that. And you can still do a stop on the road related to the purple and different lines that come through the area here. Is that the Mammoth Express stop?

1:41:53 It's right by the stairwell down by Blackhawk. Yeah, several of the lines go through. I don't remember. The purple line goes through. Yeah, the purple line and the Mammoth Express and a variety of lines. Yeah, there's a few of them that go through there, yeah. So the idea would be to move that stop over to the park by the facility. And we'd still have access that way to restrooms and trash and those types of elements. You know, Colin would have to walk further to work, but otherwise we're good.

1:42:23 We have no objection to the black tie. Right. No, no, it's good. It's good to have it there, frankly. I don't remember if you're writing a bus or not. Yeah, that's how it was previously at the old McDonald's. Yeah, we have no objection to the potential move. Correct. Yeah, it's, yeah, the one by the McDonald's there, then that was elements, but I'm not sure if that's moving out of there now or not. It could be. It's gone.

1:42:52 I know the old McDonald's one's gone, but that's now the Vons parking lot there. But the ownership here has asked us to remove that stop in there. There's problematic with trash and garbage and some other issues there. Plus, it's just a non-permitted stop, frankly, from the owner's perspective here in the shopping center. Matt, I have a question for you. You had said then that...

1:43:21 With us approving the transfer fund to the trail of $300 that you could be absorbing a little bit of that difference. So what do you think that number instead of $8,559 would be? You're muted too. That would be $1,500 more that we would have to find. So the rest of it would be absorbed somewhere.

1:43:54 Yeah. Okay. Thank you. I have a couple comments and questions real quick here. So when I'm looking at this, the debt that we've taken on with the multi-use facility, which we should put as the CRC, so we're consistent there, but as we're doing the CRC and we're taking on this debt of $614,000, if we did not, which we all voted upon, by the way, if we did not take that on, we would actually be in a positive over $600,000. Is that correct? So I guess with that,

1:44:25 thing in mind that kind of frustrates me to think that our organization is being held responsible fiscally for a decision that we all voted on because we haven't been able to move forward to the CRC because we can't agree on a price. So I'm going to put that out there that's extremely frustrating. Being in the conditions that we're at right now with

1:44:49 Interest rates, and this is a question for, you know, Colin and Eric, is there anything out there that we could look at to reduce that debt and the rate that we're paying it at? So those are just two comments that I just wanted to say that I find it extremely frustrating that we're being kind of held, our budget's kind of upside down, shall we say, because of this.

1:45:16 Let's, uh, other, other questions. Has the town been re-rated in terms of its bond rating, Dan, since the last, last time we went through that, or? Uh, you're muted, Dan. Uh, the town's bond rating in general, all of them are under review right now based on the COVID stuff from a, uh, I can't recall, I think it's, it's a drop from a stable to a uncertain, uh, just a second, I can tell you. Uh, with S&P, they were looking at it, looking at a lot of different areas.

1:45:49 See if I can find it real quick. And then while you're looking at that real quick, I guess the other thing was the $22,000 that we didn't spend in special projects. Can we put that anywhere in this budget? Sorry. Yeah, it's not jumping out of it right off, but it was going from a stable to a negative outlook based on the, didn't change the rating at this point and the interest rates on the bonds would not change. I think the average rate on those is like 2.2 or 2.3%. They're pretty low at the time.

1:46:24 The bonds are secured by Measure R funds, so they have the first call on that revenue regardless of our obligations here to choose that as far as that goes from that. So Dan, does that take us below triple B? No, no, no. We're still at an A-plus rating on that. It's just with the outlook. So it doesn't change the act. So it's still like in, I think it's A, I want to say A-plus, A-plus or A-plus, I think it's A-plus.

1:46:51 With a stable outlook, it would go to an A-plus with a negative outlook or a caution outlook. I forget the term they used. But still an A rating. Yeah. Right. So there would be no change in the cost on the debt regardless because it's fixed in terms of what was purchased in that debt structure. And what is the percent? Would you say 2.6 is what we're saying? 2.2, I believe. Let me see if I can find that. I was just looking at it the other night. Let me see if I can grab it here. Just a moment. Go ahead and continue.

1:47:21 We got a very good deal on it at 2% or just over 2%. I don't see us being able to better that. Yeah, that does sound quite good. Dan did a great job getting our rating up to an A-plus specifically so we can go out and achieve this. Yeah, I see that. Other questions for staff? Because if not...

1:47:54 Maybe if Dan's got that number and otherwise we'll, go ahead Dan. Yeah, so the interest rate is 2.23%. Yeah. So it was a. And what's the length of time on that, the duration of that note? It goes, what is it, a 10 year, goes from the 7, from October 17 to October 2027. That's a good rate. Yeah, it was very good, so.

1:48:21 And it has to be spent on something analogous to a CRC on that property? Yeah, it was tied to, in fact, the bond document includes a description of the project and stuff. So if we wanted to do something different, we'd have to go back and amend the bond documents accordingly and put that back out to the bond owners. It's no longer being used for the purposes that it was put out within the bond documents. Okay.

1:48:49 I mean, we could go through the process and just be a hoop to jump through and file all the paperwork regarding a change in it. Do we know if the Whitmore is going to be happening? You lost the Whitmore what? Is the pools happening? Is that part of this budget? The Whitmore Park Service maintenance? Is that part of the pool on the budget?

1:49:11 No, that's the actual, well, it's the park out there. We share the park maintenance out there based on the investments that was made by Measure R, a lot of that's the track and the fields in that area, not the pool itself. We fund that out of the general fund and we split that maintenance cost with the county. I'm just trying to find where there might be monies here and there that we know that we're not going to spend to try to help put a little bit of positive on the side. All right. If there's no other questions, Jim, what do you got? Dan, can you?

1:49:42 Clarify for me, the debt servicing is for the bond, the 5.5 million or so, and then the 1.2 million is separate, that was allocated from the reserves. Correct, so the bond reserves, 5.5 million, that's sitting in that capital construction fund, as is the 1.2 million that was saved over time in Mammoth and Measure R funding, and that was transferred over, so that's sitting in that capital up.

1:50:12 Project account for the CRC funding. With other funds that have been moved over there from other sources as well, not just those two. Thank you. So what I'm looking to do here then is if we don't have any more questions for staff, what I'd like to do is see if we have any public comment and testimony. And then if not,

1:50:42 Bill, you sounded like you had more comments to make, and I was trying to limit that as best I could to clarifying questions, but I think, Bill, maybe you'd like to start with some comments, but let me go to public first, if you will. Absolutely. Any public comment, Angela, anybody on? No, we have no public comments. Okay, great. Bill.

1:51:13 So when we're looking at what we're going to propose, first I will tell you that I don't think you're going to get council approval to move $100,000 out of CRC because we would have to then reduce the scope of the project, that extra $100,000. So I don't think that's something that's going to make it by council. A couple of you have seen a proposal that I have put together that is very similar to what Dan has put in the project.

1:51:41 I sort of asked for that to be included in this. I don't know whether it's appropriate or not because it has to do with the makeup of MLR, but there's a budget that goes along with that. Being a Brown Act unit, we need to, I can't speak to more than two or three of you on this. I still have one left if someone wants to call me before tomorrow's meeting. I would encourage you all.

1:52:09 I know we all like the idea of MLR and what it's doing. I would encourage you all to go to the contract with the town for the past three years and look very carefully at the deliverables and ask yourself how much has actually been delivered. In five years' time, MLR has gone well over the million-dollar mark in town funds.

1:52:34 Have we gotten anywhere near that in return from MLR? Some will say yes, some will say no. I will say no. I think at this point, because of the budget constraints, we're $175,000 upside down, and I don't have that in front of me right now. Because of that, I think that there are going to be asks from council to alter the makeup. I do not want to eliminate MLR, and I know some people think I do. Absolutely not.

1:53:05 The value of a nonprofit is huge. But I think under a hugely modified MLR, we can fulfill all of the projects we have ongoing and move forward and slowly regrow organically. Unfortunately, we would lose our executive director, a golfing pal of mine, if you will, in the process.

1:53:32 But I see no other way to move forward. To take it out of the trails budget, you have to remember the history of the trails budget. Once upon a time, or not once upon a time, at one time, there was an MLTSCC. When Measure R was first passed, it was passed by the voters for trails and recreation. We carved that out in the beginning.

1:53:59 At $300,000 a year, it was my intention at that point, I was chair of the rec commission, to move that forward as one-third of Measure R, not as a fixed figure. So they've gone since inception without an increase in their funding, and they've really done some great work. Whether that was prior to MLR or during MLR, it has worked very well under first Steve Spidell and now under Joel Rathje.

1:54:28 My proposed budget that I am going to try to bring forward to council tomorrow is to maintain MLR at a much reduced capacity and a reduced board and move it forward. We have $15,000. So I'm gonna recommend that probably 12,000 of that go to MLR to cover primarily the clerical end.

1:54:56 And that anything beyond that we need comes out of the excess of town tax dollars that are in the MLR account. Remembering that in our MLR contract, and again, I encourage you to get a hold of it, and I've already passed it on to, I think, Heather, and I think Colin has seen it. I know Colin has seen it because him and I helped write it. Anything extra we need to cover Kim's expense.

1:55:27 would come out of the reserves that are left of the 225 that the town put in to cover fundraising. And that leaves us, bear with me, anyway, that leaves us with about 2,000 in the account under the proposed 1 million. And I also will caution that when I did my budget review on my own,

1:56:01 I was putting in $900,000, not a million dollars is what we might expect in Measure R funds next year. Hey, Bill, right now, the item for discussion is a recommendation on Measure R funding. And I think when we start getting into how are we going to, what does MLR of the future look like?

1:56:28 That's a different agenda item and one that no doubt, as you said, from the results of town council, I think our task here is to give recommendations and options for the town council to then, you know, in their meeting tomorrow, work through. And so, you know, and as our town council

1:56:57 Member here, you know, I appreciate where, you know, you're coming from trying to balance this out and, but for our purposes, I think, you know, our conversation really needs to stay on, you know, are we going to accept or modify staff's recommendation here for these, for these allocations and, you know, and move as a board one way or the other on it.

1:57:27 Yes. However, and the reason I brought the rest of it up, and believe me, I've been wrestling with this a lot. The reason I brought it up that way is because, frankly, as a board in this, should have been more than one potential funding allocation. And to get to that point, you have to understand where I am as a council member. We're being brought forward. One option to move forward is from MLR. And there's more than one way to...

1:57:57 Skin this cat. Well, and I... Now shut up. I would like to separate the multi-use facility from the rest of this. I had some hesitations accepting it with the reductions that we had last go-round, but I'm going to say on the record, I am completely against the project if it's being gutted the way it is. We owe ourselves, as the town of Mammoth Lakes, to have a high-quality, world-class facility, and we're getting...

1:58:28 Piece of crap. I'll just go say it on the record. I don't like the way that is. I don't support anybody going to it at this point because what we voted for is not what we're being proposed now. There's no new plans in our packets to show us all these reductions. I'm flattered against it. So any motion that moves forward? Again, like I told Beryl, we're not here to, you know, this agenda item isn't

1:58:57 necessarily directly the CRC and whether we're for it or against it. It's whether this board, you know, wants to, you know, ask and request that town council look at, you know, this $100,000 allocation out of that fund, but that's irrelevant to whether as individuals were for or against the CRC. Let me amend my statements that when I look at attachment four,

1:59:27 And I see that there's money in there for the debt service. I want to be clear what I'm voting on that, because in other words, there's certain parts of what we're brought forward to us that I'm in favor of and certain monies that I'm against. So I just wanted that to be separated out so that I could vote accordingly. Okay. Thanks. Thanks. Other comments and deliberation? I would just... Well, I guess in... Oh, go ahead, Matt.

1:59:58 No, I was just thinking in the context of all that's just been said and the fact that we're talking about a fund balance, you know, which, I mean, we approved the bonding of really all the Measure R reserves two years ago with the promise that we were going to move forward that year on the CRC. So to talk about deliverables, let's talk about the deliverable on that one.

2:00:25 And I understand that we can't get that money back right now because of the way that it's financed. But I'm curious, is there a $1.2 million of that that measure our money that we could have back to work with? So forget about the $100,000, let's talk about $1.2 million. You're saying what I was saying, David, in a different angle, and that's what frustrates me about the budget.

2:00:58 If I can address that, hey, David, real quick, yeah, the measure R dollars allocated into that project to the 1.2 has not been spent and the front end dollars being spent down has been the town allocations of some early on general fund money and then some additional other dollars. I'd have to walk through the actual expenditure levels. Some of that may include measure R dollars out of that.

2:01:26 I'll say the one and a half or so that's been spent, mainly because we're not spending bond reserves until we actually have the project to fund. So I'd have to walk through that. But the vast majority, if not all, the $1.2 million that's been committed to that would still be sitting there for that purpose. If the recommendation from Measure MLR is more about no longer supporting the project than the requested council would be to move that $1.2 million back out of the project.

2:01:55 Which would either mean other funding sources for it or ultimately at that point it would kill the project. We'd go ahead and continue to pay off the bonds, if you will, over the next several years and then that debt payment would be gone. My guess is it would cost us- Or another option would be to bring it forward for reconsideration based on a new plan. Well, you'd end up with a completely new project. Yeah, you'd end up with something substantially different, which process-wise, yeah.

2:02:26 So at that point, my guess would be, I had to be up to the council, but the general fund dollars, about a million dollars into there, about 900 that hasn't been expended for sure, give or take. I could see that being yanked out too, and the project would just go away. It'd be a dead project at that point. Roughly, I just, again, that would have to be a larger policy discussion. Indeed, sure. So. Other, oh, Matt?

2:02:55 So I just wanted to speak to a point. I think this has been good conversation. I think as we just saw with the conversation about the trails budget, MLR has a fiduciary responsibility when it comes to Measure R to provide oversight. And I think we had a good conversation. And I think there was, it was nice, in my opinion, to see.

2:03:24 Some varying opinions on that. My concern always has been that MLR not be a rubber stamp, that the Mammoth Trails Committee has their say on it and their opinions. That gets put up to us, the board, or not us, but the board here to have their say. And that could differentiate from what the Trails Committee says or it could go along with that. And then it goes up to the town council. And again, the town council has the final decision. They could agree with us or they could not agree with us.

2:03:52 They understand their role pretty clearly. They don't, you know, as Bill points out, they're under no obligation to approve what we recommend. And a lot of times maybe they wouldn't approve. I think our decision right now shouldn't be putting forward something that the town council is or is not going to recommend. I don't think that should be a concern of ours. I think a concern of ours should be what is in the best interest of this town as it pertains to Measure R.

2:04:20 And the reason that staff put this forward is that, to David's point, we made a commitment of $1.2 million out of reserves. That was all of our rainy day money to this project. Because a year ago, we stood behind this project. We were told that, hey, here's a new option. We think we could do this. And we made that leap of faith as a board. It wasn't a clean vote. It wasn't a unanimous vote. That vote was made, frankly, without any backing paperwork. It wasn't on the agenda.

2:04:49 It got inserted in there as part of the discussion for Measure R financing for this current fiscal year. It took a lot of board members by surprise, but I think that the feeling in the room was we would go along and support that as a partner with town, as we've always been. Now we find ourselves in a position where all of our money that we would have relied on for a rainy day is now being committed back to a project that may or may not happen still.

2:05:13 And so what staff is recommending is that in the spirit of we don't want to see the CRC go away. We want to see it succeed. We're asking for a small amount, the minimal amount that we need to continue our organization to fulfill the roles and responsibilities that we've been charged with, that we've been tasked to do. And then frankly, if the project happens and we need to raise $100,000, then we'd raise $100,000. That's not hard to do. But MLR has never missed a fundraising goal since I've been here. In the last three years.

2:05:41 We have not missed a single fundraising goal that we've been tasked to do. We take our fundraising very seriously. You can imagine right now if we had gone out and raised against a project that did not make bid for the second time in a row, especially coming off an era where people are losing their jobs, having to put their businesses on hold, people would be howling. So I think it's important that when you look at MLR, we look at our fiduciary responsibility on what we need.

2:06:14 to do in terms of recommending that you measure R, which is public money. So I just want to kind of state that. I know everybody kind of is aware of that, but just feel like whether or not I think how that positions Trails specifically for the following year, we make those decisions every year out of Measure U the same way, right? Just because we don't fund a nonprofit to its full ask one year doesn't mean that we're not going to fund it fully to the next year. Same thing for Trails. Just because we don't fund it.

2:06:42 Fully for one year doesn't mean we don't have to fund it for the next year. We have the ability to make whatever recommendation we want at a Measure R. Whether or not the town council accepts that reservation is a whole different thing and out of our control. Same thing for this now. We're going to make a recommendation of $100,000 if this board approves it. Whether or not the council approves it, entirely up to them. But for us, we make the right recommendation that is right for MLR as we feel that we've been entrusted by the public with the public money. Thank you, Matt. I'd make a motion that

2:07:13 I'd make a motion that we recommend that $1.2 million be returned to the Measure R fund to be reconsidered if and when the CRC moves forward. I'll second that motion. Okay. We have a motion and a second. And the motion was to bring the entire $1.2 million in Measure R.

2:07:45 That was allocated for the CRC. Is that correct, David? Have I got that right? Correct. Okay. And we have a second discussion. Yeah. We have a problem with that in that I've already been told that what we're here to deal with is the recommendation on the Measure R budget to the town. The CRC and the money that's been set aside is not on our

2:08:16 agenda and not in the public meeting, which incidentally we're still in. We need to close the meeting and then go to deliberations. So if we are not going to entertain other ideas than this, because this is what's presented and what we're voting on, then I would ask that this is what we stick to, add the 1.2 onto our next agenda so that it can be legally and rightfully dealt with. Well, if I could...

2:08:41 If I could say something, in this attachment that we're looking at, which is attachment four, we have the 19-20 allocated MUF funding and moving of $100,000. So David, are you recommending that we adjust attachment four to be $1.2 million instead of $100,000? That you could do. If that's your recommendation, I think that's a different motion. Does that make sense? Well said. Yep.

2:09:11 That's what I'm suggesting. Okay. I will still second that, David. Further discussion? Just a quick comment on my end. You know, I did have a chance to talk to Bill at length the other day, kind of about this situation. I spoke to Matt and Eric as well. You know, I think it's important to recognize that ultimately we work at the pleasure of town council.

2:09:40 Obviously, I'm somebody that sat in that role, so I have a tremendous amount of respect for the position that Bill, you and your colleagues are in. I was lucky to be sandwiched on town council between flirting with bankruptcy and now a global pandemic. I don't envy the position that you are in, and I know that some tough decisions are going to have to be made. I'm interested to see how the conversation goes.

2:10:10 Tomorrow in terms of the five members, how they feel on the organization. I've only spoken to you. I haven't spoken to any other council members about this directly. But I think it's a little bit of an odd agenda item that we have in front of us because essentially we're being asked whether we follow a town staff recommendation that would eliminate the organization.

2:10:36 Or we go with a MLR staff recommendation that would balance the budget and keep the organization moving forward. And really, the only fundamental difference between those two proposals that we're seeing is the $100,000 or now potentially $1.2 million that's germane to the CRC. So it's a little bit difficult to wrap our heads around this agenda, but

2:11:03 Essentially what we're being asked is to recommend defunding our own organization to council, which is a weird position to be put in. So I respect the fact that whatever decision council makes is going to be a difficult decision. Sometimes I hear discussions out in the ether that people feel like when you go through crisis situations like this, there's very easy decisions to be made.

2:11:30 Easy cuts to be made that everybody's going to be on board with and comfortable. That is not the reality. It's choosing between a lesser of evils. So again, I don't envy the position that council is going to be faced with moving forward. They're going to have to make some tough decisions that are going to be difficult for some people to swallow. But again, as is germane to what we're being asked today, you know, moving forward, a recommendation to either

2:11:55 Move some funds around to preserve the organization or move forward a recommendation to defund the organization. That's a tough position to be put in. Yeah. Colin, thank you. If I may, Chairman, if I had a couple of comments, I think may be helpful. By all means. Thank you. Thank you. The options that...

2:12:17 Before Council, tomorrow isn't just a defunding or not of the organization. There's a couple different options laid out in there. Part of that is either, you know, several months or a few months out, wind down, there's a restructuring of the organization, which would impact that. One option is just let the contract run out as of June 30th. Yes, it would be over, it would be done, and the only question there would be from the organizational standpoint is if town dollars are left in

2:12:45 With MLR, the request for those to come back to the town and existing restricted reserves would be left with the organization, which is a reminder, it's still an independent 501c3. As Matt addressed earlier, their obligation is to make a recommendation to the town council regarding the budget. And I'll say in the budget discussion to the town council,

2:13:08 It's primarily showing a rollover budget because we did not have a recommendation at that point from MLR. It's noted in the staff report that way accordingly that there would be an expectation that there would be some type of proposal coming forward from MLR that would help inform the decisions at the town council level.

2:13:29 So I think that the concerns that Member Souser raised over some of the obligations and meeting expectations, et cetera, are there, and we will speak to those in detail tomorrow on that. But from a budgetary standpoint, the recommendation from MLR, I think you do have a couple of different choices that you could make a recommendation on. One is to...

2:13:54 I recommend full funding as kind of that rollover. It does show a deficit that puts that deficit item into the town council's hand to deal with accordingly. You can address it as Matt has suggested between a budget reduction and a shifting of revenues from the CRC reserves, if you will, back into MLR. As my earlier question, one of those was how much of a reserve is left in the MLR budget that's unrestricted because you can't.

2:14:22 Obviously, I don't think you could use restricted money to fund operations of the organization. But if you say there's $100,000 of the $200,000 plus or minus of unrestricted money, you could make a recommendation. You want to utilize those funds to cut the shortfall plus the reduction in the administrative cost of the organization. There's some options to do that to run that budget for as a way of, hey, we can address the financial shortfall through X.

2:14:50 And then the council question deals with accepting that budget or not and then looking at the structure of the organization and saying, do we want to enter into a new contract going forward with a new set of deliverables, different deliverables, no deliverables? How do they want to work with MLR going forward into the next fiscal year? And it's tight giving a timeline here, obviously.

2:15:18 That was one of the recommendations. There's a couple of months in there proposed is one option to work through that. What happens? Then the other option is the restructuring of the organization completely, doing some similar formal type of agreement and or letting the contract expire. That would be regardless of the budget at that point. But one of the elements to deal with would be a recommendation to the town council regarding the budget in there.

2:15:44 Would be beneficial just in terms of what does that look like from a budgetary structure and that measure our fund. So that was one request and staff did not necessarily come in and say cut out all the admin costs day one of the budget. It was noted there's a deficit. We did not propose a way to address it specifically because we didn't think that was our role. With the contract ending and how we go forward from a contractual relationship with Mammoth Lakes Recreation.

2:16:12 Then was the whole discussion of whether or not we would look at a new full-blown contract, whether it's a modified to allow more of a wind down component restructuring element, letting it just end as June 30, not renewing the contract. And that could be regardless of the budget that we don't wish to enter into a new agreement and or.

2:16:35 Kind of a combination of options, one of those that Bill touched on, but that would be restructuring the 501c3 into a different type of organization, if you will, still maintaining the independency of a 501c3, but obviously with more, if you will, council oversight as well, based on a restructuring of the board. So from that element, back to the earlier discussion, yes, you could make a recommendation to increase the 100,000 to 1.2 million, make that request.

2:17:05 Or you could turn around and say, if it's truly just a financial issue, we have X dollars of reserves. And again, I don't know those numbers. We would recommend utilizing those. That gives us time to go out and fundraise, do other things to keep the organization going. But then that comes back in ultimately a different discussion with the council will be what would a new contract, if there is one, look like. So there's a couple of elements here. One, that budget recommendation.

2:17:32 And then ultimately the recommendation of what does that mean going forward from an agreement with the town. I hope that doesn't muddy things up too badly over a little bit of clarification, but it is definitely some different pieces in here and the timing is unfortunate in one sense for this. So you have a couple of ways to move a budget recommendation forward and then we would anticipate a presentation tomorrow night regarding

2:17:59 Here's the value of MLR and how we would like to see you go forward in relationship with the town. Yeah. I would assume that presentation come forward. Yeah. And I appreciate the effort to clarify. I mean, simply put, this is kind of a messy agenda item. And, you know, I think it's well articulated to say this is a difficult thing because ultimately, again, I'll reiterate, we work at the pleasure of council and whatever direction comes from council in terms of the organization, you know.

2:18:27 We'll have to adjust to that. But what we're being presented today, from my vantage point, is essentially kind of three options, which is number one, moving forward a budget that essentially defunds the organization. The second option, which is proposed by MLR staff, is bringing a portion of the committed CRC funds back to balance the budget for a year moving forward. And now we've got a

2:18:56 You know, a motion on the table to say, you know, we want to take that a step further and bring the entire 1.2 back. So, you know, that's what we need to address right now because there's a motion in the second on the table. But ultimately, this is just our recommendation that goes to council and they'll do what they see fit with that recommendation. And I'd say, yeah, Colin, sorry, the third recommendation for that $100,000, you could just say we'll have a deficit and we will meet it out of our own reserves out of MLR. True, true. Thank you.

2:19:25 Those being another option that we have on the table. Right. You know, and I think. Assuming they're there. Outside, you know, thing that's entering into the conversation is, you know, does this organization continue to support the facility in its current iteration with a large amount of money committed over there? And I'm hearing from some other members that may not be the case. I can speak for myself that.

2:19:50 I can no longer support the facility in its current iteration because it's a far cry from the original journey that we went down, and I don't mean to get too far afield, but was really to produce a facility that this community could be proud of, and I'm not sure we're there anymore. So I think that's a third piece that's kind of entering into this conversation and making it a little bit difficult to wrap our heads around. So I will stop at that, but we do have a motion on the table.

2:20:19 You know, that I think we need to address. Yeah. And, you know, Dan and Colin, thank you for, you know, kind of distilling this down, you know, to what our objective is here. And, but in light of the motion on the table, which is the entire 1.2 that was allocated for the CRC,

2:20:47 If there's no more comment, I'd like to get that voted upon, and then we can... I do have a question on it. Yes. So, are you asking, and I want clarification in the motion, are you asking a 1.2 million come back over to MLR, or are you asking for it just to go back into the Measure R reserves? Into the Measure R reserves. Thank you.

2:21:17 Any further questions or discussion? I just want to add, I have a little bit of discomfort voting on the 1.2, just not kind of being prepared for that to be on the table. I realize it's an edit to the agenda we do have, but to pass a recommended budget from staff that I do feel prepared to vote on is one thing. If for sake of clarification there was a way to

2:21:48 keep these kind of clear and vote on this recommendation before revisiting that 1.2. I would feel more comfortable doing that. But again, I defer to the rest of the board.

2:21:59 Catherine, I totally understand where you're coming from because I'm the one who is frustrated by the $600,000 or the $1.2, however you want to look at it. I don't think that doing the $1.2 personally is going to solve anything. I think it's going to stir things from the bottom a little harder versus trying to get to a decision on what we originally planned to vote on.

2:22:23 And I would like it to be noted that we're voting on this, though, however, because our budget is upside down because of the commitment we made to the CRC. And that's where I think we're having that conversation of where I feel the same with you on that. I guess, and I apologize for kind of missing this, but I think Bill's question is important for us to drill down to because the proposal here is to bring money.

2:22:51 That was committed for Measure R reserves back to fund operations, the organization. So I'm sorry for missing that, but I just want to make sure we're clear on that. Well, from staff's perspective, the 1.2 is not MLR's money. That's the town's money. That's money that was in Measure R. If we pass, theoretically, probably most likely, if we were to say, hey, we want that 1.2 back into...

2:23:26 Measure R reserves, I could probably almost assuredly say our contract wouldn't be renewed. You know, so I, you know, I think that solves one problem. It doesn't solve the other problem. I mean, I agree. I, from a staff's perspective, I think they're, they're, it's kind of complaining two different issues. What staff's put forward is, again, something that we feel solves both the, the issue of funding out of ML, Measure R for MLR.

2:23:55 In a way that, again, we can still be supportive of the CRC project moving forward. And if it moves forward, you know, we have plenty of time right now, as Dan says, even if we put the project back out to bid in July with a 45-day, that pushes in December. By the time we get wheel motion, the most we'd be able to do is maybe do some grading. Actual construction probably wouldn't happen until springtime. That gives us between now and springtime to raise a million, not a million, but $100,000. That's not a problem.

2:24:27 So, I mean, from staff's perspective, that's why we put this forward as a recommendation because we think it's tenable, we think it solves problems and frankly gives us a year to sort all these different questions out so that we can come back a year from now and ask, you know, come to some common ground with the town on the future of MLR and the future of a lot of these projects that are funded through Measure R. But the proposal is to pull $100,000.

2:24:57 It was initially allocated for Measure R reserves back to essentially fulfill a budget shortfall of the organization, right? Correct. But again, that, you know, it seems a little bit, we could just as easily say, okay, we're going to move that money back into Measure R and keep MLR and pull $100,000 from Trails, right? I mean, it's, we could pick anything out of the Measure R budget to defund. The fact is, is that

2:25:28 You know, we're looking at defunding MLR. So you can't necessarily say that, you know, this is, we're looking to be ML, you know, fund MLR specifically. It's not like we're, how can I phrase this? We're looking to maintain all of the deliverables for the whole community out of Measure R that we have been. Trails, MLR.

2:25:55 Upkeep and facilities for, you know, the rec projects, the track, everything down at Whitmore. So we feel that the proposal that we've made, staff has made, is the best opportunity to do all of that as a whole. We're just a component of it. Yeah, I think, you know, that a key point that we really need to know and

2:26:25 With this budget shortfall that we have and how we're going to fund that is really that point of what are unrestricted funds that we currently have. When Dan highlighted that that was a third or fourth option, to me, that's the most tenable for everyone is that we have unrestricted funds and that

2:26:55 Should be, you know, the most likely to be used for during this time when we have, you know, a budget shortfall and we still do, as Matt was just saying, want to partner with the town to, you know, fulfill our mission. And so, but on the table right now, we need to take the 1.2.

2:27:23 Reserves all the way to its end, so I'd like to call the question, if we can. I mean, and, you know, I don't know if it's, from a parliamentary standpoint, if it's feasible to retract a motion, but, I mean, given Collins' distinction, which I think is a good one, I think I'm willing to retract it and get back to the original staff recommendation. But my concern is...

2:27:51 is that what's getting lost in the shuffle here, as Heather and others have mentioned, is that the reason that there is this, you know, whatever discussion's gonna happen tomorrow night about deliverables and budget shortfall is very wrapped up in where Measure R reserves have been housed, and I think that's based on some recommendations that are questionable, and I think we need to...

2:28:21 We need to have that discussion when it's appropriate, but it should be flagged. Yeah, frankly, I like the spirit of your motion, you know, but if you do want to amend that, you're welcome to do that, and then we would just need somebody else to second your amended motion. Yeah. So, I mean, I'm willing to amend the motion to move forward the budget recommendation staff is recommending. I'll second.

2:28:56 All right. We have a motion and a second to move forward with... Parliamentary here, Craig. Yes. I would need to hear from Eric, who seconded the first motion, if he's willing to... I was wondering that. I was starting to go through my Rosenberg's rules to see if I needed that. I was thinking of Eric getting involved with that. Thank you. He either needs to amend his second or retract it.

2:29:24 I think the cleanest thing to do would be to retract it and go with the new motion. Second. Second. Thank you, Bill. All right. And so with that, any other further discussion about the original staff recommendation? If not, I see no hands. Roll call. President Albright, can I please confirm who the second was from?

2:29:59 Catherine. Colin. Colin, that's right. Okay, that's what I had, I just wanted to clarify. Bill Souser? No. Eric Wasserman? Yes. Rhonda Dugan? Yes. Catherine Taft? Yes. Colin Verney? Yes. Heather Schaubmeyer? Yes. Tamara Bankson? Yes. David Page? Yes.

2:30:33 That was a yes. Yes. And Craig Albright. Yes. Thank you. Passes 8-1. All right, good discussion, team. Yeah, obviously, tomorrow, you know, the town council has some, you know, some tough conversations to go through, and hopefully, my hope would be that these, the discussion we had here tonight.

2:31:01 helps with that. And as Bill said earlier, provides council with more options. And because it is certainly trying times. Thank you for working through that. On to our next sheet. Allocate Measure U funding for other expenditures for the fiscal year 2020-21. Budget attachment five.

2:31:30 Matt, what have we got there? Thank you. Thank you, Greg. Going back actually to attachment three for a moment. Under Measure U, so Town of Mammoth Lake staff is recommending that an additional $100,000 be allocated for programming in the fiscal year 2021 Measure U budget. This, you know, this sounds great. This is something that we've been asking for for a while, so if we can get more programming money. The only thing that...

2:32:00 I think we're concerned about is we don't have a lot of backing information as far as how that money is intended to be used. You know, we would hope that it would be used for similar programming that we're doing right now, but we just want to make sure that it's, you know, if the intended use is for events, certainly there's other carve-outs in Measure U that Visit Mammoth and Carolyn is working with on the event site.

2:32:29 So we just need a little bit more direction from we being Mammoth Lakes Recreation, need a little bit more direction from town of Mammoth Lakes on how this extra $100,000 is intended to be used before we can feel comfortable allocating that. So I don't know if Dan, you want to speak to that? Yeah, I can speak to that. Thank you, Matt. And forgive the...

2:32:52 Typing there, I think there's a combination between the programming event statements, just thinking some of the programming we do is more event-based in terms of the concerts or plays or activities, which is tied more to that arts and culture type programming level. The intent there was to add it into that base programming type discussion that's been looked at before. It's been oversubscribed in the past, and I think...

2:33:16 MLR overall, and Heather, appreciate your work in the programming and working through that allocations committee. It's always tough to tell people no. The other hand on that is it seems like there's opportunities out there to actually grow the types of programming that we provide to the community through what I'm calling the arts and culture component of Measure U.

2:33:36 And the idea was that, I mean, you don't have to add the 100 grand there. You could recommend that back at the 166 number that is today and just let it fall to the bottom so you'd end up with a larger uncommitted fund balance. That would be appropriate as well. The thought process there, though, based on the last couple of years of discussion that I've been on the periphery of has been, this has been a challenge.

2:33:59 Challenging area to have adequate funding to meet some of the needs and to look at expanded programming in the area. So as we have the dollars available this year, frankly, one of those issues was do we add some additional money to the programming level? It's a placeholder from my perspective. Frankly, a recommendation from the board here can say, take it back to 166, put 50 in there, put 100 in there. Frankly, not a strong position one way or the other, but it seemed to be an area the last...

2:34:29 Again, a period of time that seemed to be light in terms of the demand versus what able to put out into the community for programming and really no dollars available to expand the programming level that we've been able to see Measure U support. So that was the thought process for the extra $100,000 in that line item. Again, up to this board whether they wish to support that, move it, leave it.

2:34:54 Frankly, it's not a hard recommendation from the town staff. It was based on previous discussions relating to programming and some shortfalls in that area. Thank you, Dan. Can I make a couple comments on this real quick, please? Dan and I have talked about this, and I know the timing's kind of odd right now with everything that's going on, especially after the conversation we just had. So I think clarification of where those funds are coming from would be important.

2:35:24 Another thing that Dan and I have discussed is I'm excited the idea of having more funds for programming because if the CRC moves forward, wouldn't it be great if more people out there, like the event producers that we have, not event producers, but the people that we have like the MAC or like the Symphony or like Chamber Music Unbound be able to do more events and program more.

2:35:49 At another facility. That's kind of the big picture aspect of this. So I guess, Dan, if you could clarify two things is, one, where were those funds be coming from? And two, are they a use them or lose them? No, the funding from that is just, you know, if you look at the, I think, attachment five there, there's 870,000 projected in revenues. If you took all of the kind of rollover plus some additions in there, the additional 100,000 for programming and walking through the other elements there.

2:36:18 You still end up with a fund balance of $172,000 plus left over still in that fund uncommitted. If you don't use those, they would basically fall down into that fund balance staying in the Measure U account for reallocation either back into programming or other projects that the MLR would be recommending at this point for the Measure U funding element. So it's not a use or lose necessary for Measure U.

2:36:45 It would be up to the board if they wish to retain that in the programming line item year over year from a carryover standpoint or not back into the programming. So, but I like the idea of how do we expand out our programming offering and looking tough year. I understand all the debate going around it, but there's definitely been a, I think a need highlighted in that area in discussions in the past. So it could go there or like I say, it could just drop to the bottom and that 172 number would just go to 272.

2:37:14 And a fund balance for Measure U for future project use. And it's also not meant to just go off and fully fund the existing programs. It's meant to add to our programs. Yeah, if you want to add a couple bucks to somebody, again, I'd leave that up to this board and their allocation process to do so. But the idea there was how do you expand out programming and really enhance what we've been able to achieve. Again, a lot of hard work from the group here. So I appreciate that. Thank you.

2:37:44 This is a question for Dan. On the annual revenue, we're looking at the utility taxes for telephone, electricity, and gas. I see an increase in the utility tax for telephone, but a slight decrease in electricity and gas. In light of COVID, and we're seeing, I mean, obviously in the last three months, we've had some major losses in revenue coming into the town. How realistic do you think?

2:38:11 This projection for revenue is, what's it based off of? We've tried to do a trend line. We went back and looked at the last couple of years of where we're at in the revenue side and what we're seeing this year coming in. And so this is a reduction from the current year, last year actual to the current year, it is a reduction down. The telephone one seems to be pretty steady in terms of

2:38:38 What's happened there and actually a small uptick based on actual revenues still coming in the current year. Given the COVID stuff, it doesn't look like the piece where we collect the telephone revenues from has actually diminished much. Electricity and gas are both, you know, kind of down just based on usage. Now, some of that from both sides of that always depends on the level of the winter. Again, a really harsh winter that tends to go up.

2:39:07 Looking at the current numbers and what we're seeing usage-wise and if there's less commercial activity, frankly, we anticipate some small declines in those areas. So the budget projections looking at what we're seeing right now and what we're kind of projecting moving forward, not seeing a big spike up or increase in those particular uses. Okay. I just don't want to be too aggressive on the revenue side, knowing what losses we've already had.

2:39:37 And based on the analysis on that, we haven't seen a dramatic drop, even with the COVID issue there. So, I mean, people are still paying their bills as far as the revenue coming in from that perspective. Just to follow up on Tamara's point there, are there actuals yet? Because I would think that March, April, and May, that...

2:40:02 Electricity usage would be down significantly. A, the mountain hasn't operated, nor have any hotels operated. I find it hard to believe we're not down at least 25%, if not more. Let me just see what I can pull up real quick for you here. Thank you. While Dan's looking that up, any other questions or staff? So from my vantage out here on the extremes of devil's advocacy, and I may have missed it.

2:40:35 In the earlier discussion about allocations, but is there a reason that we're recommending the continued $300,000 operations budget for the MAC given what we know about the situation on the MAC? David, I haven't broached that subject. I've only kind of done the first half of that. That was gonna be the second part of the discussion. I'm sorry. Okay, 10-4. So if I may real quick, last year's actuals came in

2:41:06 At 961. So we are looking at a pretty good reduction from that, almost $100,000 in total going down to the $870,000, $90,000 reduction there. And so that's based off that actual. And then I don't have a current year to date. The last number I had was 722, which is missing this last quarter. And then a couple, I think the...

2:41:33 A couple of payments come in in lump sums versus monthly. So there's a, we think it'll be just over, just under 900 if I remember correctly in the current year allocation of Measure U. I think I have some detail to that one. Let me, the one thing that's helped Measure U is the set aside for the MAC, which is two and a half million dollars. That is still generating interest income into the account as well, which is,

2:42:04 Offsetting some of that drop in the utility side. Yeah, because I think all the effects of this is going to be in Q2. Right, yeah. So I think, yeah, it'll be, and we tried to walk through that. Let me see if I have something here real quick. Yeah, the revenue estimate was a decline. We're showing $121,000 from $907.78. Let's got to look at that. Seems like there was one more payment coming in on that. I don't have it right in front of me there, so.

2:42:49 And so given the current budget balancing in there, there would be no loss of anything we're cutting at this point based on that. So there is a drop in revenue in the current year projected for this last quarter. So down to 778. There will probably be a little bit from June that comes in from that, but it won't be a lot. Thanks.

2:43:20 Any other questions for staff? If not, we'll move to if we have any public testimony. I have no public comments. And none. And so... Craig, just a quick comment on this. Yes. It's important to remember on everything because of the COVID and because of the volatility, the council is going to be looking at the overall budget, including R&U, quarterly.

2:43:51 And if the metrics as for what we expect in each quarter don't get met, then we will be altering it and sending it back to MLR to alter and come up with recommendations as well. Yes. Great. Thank you, Bill, for that clarification because, yeah, I've heard that on your town council meetings, this quarterly update, which I think it's a really good plan of making sure we stay on task during these uncertain times.

2:44:20 Thank you for that. To get back on my procedural, so we'll close the public hearing. I'm sorry, Craig, one more point. Yeah. So we talked about one of the points for Measure U, and then there's the second point that I just want to get some feedback from the board. As I'm sure everybody knows, the Mammoth Lakes Foundation has done some restructuring.

2:44:49 As part of that restructuring, they have put the efforts behind the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center, the MAC, in stasis was the phrasing that I was told. So, you know, it's definitely, I won't say definitely, but my understanding is it's not going away. They're just not moving forward on it right now. So under Measure U, we have $300,000 in programming money that kind of...

2:45:16 It's put forth every year. Again, one of those things that doesn't have to be used. It's just money that we, the town and MLR allocates to program the facility once it's built. And so I think this is a little bit of a same situation as we see with the CRC is that things being what they are, the likelihood of there being programming in there in the next fiscal year is probably unlikely.

2:45:43 We thought it would be worthwhile to have a discussion from our board if we want to continue funding that at $300,000 or make some other motion on it. Important to remember, however, that the funding for the MAC, and believe me, I wish their board would have made a solid decision because then there are a lot of other possibilities we could go through, but the funding from the bonds on the college side

2:46:16 It's tied to the fact that we have 2.5 in the bank and that we allocate 300,000 annually to it. We have been told that if we stop that, then the college is going to pull their, what it is, I don't remember, Dan, 6 million, 7 million dollars? 7.5, I believe. Yeah, so they would then pull their 7.5 million out of the project and effectively kill it. So I think it's important that we leave it there.

2:46:44 For now, remember, it gets rolled back into the fund at the end of every year. So we do end up allocating and spending. But I think to keep that project alive at all, that's what we need to do. Thank you for that, Bill. Yeah, that's helpful. Very important. It is very important. It also highlights, once again, that money is fairly untethered to any specific deliverables by the foundation.

2:47:18 for the time being. Yeah, it is sitting in the fund balance in the Measure U fund. The note in here that we had put forth for council, just additional clarification, the 300,000 dropping into that 2.5, which would go to 2.8. Prior to the reorganization of Mammoth Lakes Foundation, there had been a request to use one year of allocation of the

2:47:46 Operating expense, which again, this got shifted obviously with the change over there in the Mammoth Lakes Foundation side, was to allow that to bump up their allocation for Measure U for the project in part to offset some of the other costs associated with the upfront expenses for the project, both for a lot of permits that they have to pay for, permit fees, and then some of the architectural work to finalize plans. Obviously that is not moving forward at this point in time.

2:48:15 So again, these funds would be left sitting actually in the Measure U fund as a non-town project or a project that does not have a capital account created that we would transfer funding to. That has not happened. That would still take a formal resolution by the town to actually make a public purpose finding and to set those funds aside and have a schedule of drawdown or payment to Mammoth Lakes Foundation for the project once it

2:48:45 Moves forward. But the commitment, as Bill mentioned earlier, it's the, I'm trying to recall, they have, I think it's close to, I can't remember if it was 14 or 16 million in commitments, some money actually received from private donors as well as the town and the college. And all of those fit together. If any one of us pull out, frankly, then I think the project dies on its own accord at that point. The college was very clear without the town support, especially for the ongoing operations of the facility.

2:49:15 They would not commit capital funds to it. So that is an ongoing concern. And the allocation of those keeps it highlighted that that is ultimately, assuming it's built, that is a commitment from the Measure U to meet those operating needs over there up to that level. Again, in the interim, that money has gone into fund balance. Right now, there's about $3 million in fund balance, I think, in total sitting there.

2:49:44 If the $300,000 drops into that, I think that it goes up to about $3 million sitting there on top of the $2.8 that's noted there. So yeah, it goes up. Sorry, let me get my notes here. So you'd have a projected ending fund balance of $3 million right now with $2.5 million of that currently committed to the MAC. So there's another half a million in there. And then if the allocation of the $300,000 was to go into that reserve, it'd go up to $3.3 million.

2:50:14 So there's a fairly good chunk of change within that balance that isn't just committed to the MAC project. Based on what I'm hearing, it sounds like it's pretty important for them to get that $300,000 approved. And I'm going to ask, is there anybody from the organization out here for this meeting to speak on their behalf? Or have they submitted anything to us in writing asking us to continue to support?

2:50:39 Not that I'm aware of, and given, unless Matt's gotten something simple. I've had a brief conversation with Betsy Tuak, who's the new, I guess, Executive Director, assuming that's her title, for the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. Same question, was the project put on hold or on a status hiatus for the time being to figure out where they're going, or was it a killed project? The answer was no, it's definitely...

2:51:09 Not a project they've taken off the books yet. Part of that is tied to all the different funding mechanisms and the private donations going into it. So the comment there is the council has made a commit a couple times over of the 2.5 has been a formalized commitment, I believe by one resolution at least, that those funds are committed to that project, but they have not been formally allocated to the Mammoth Lakes Foundation.

2:51:36 For them to hold on to or to actually spend it down, that would take a separate action once the project is cleared to move forward. I think the absence of anybody from the organization to support it speaks volumes to me. Eric, if I could kind of address that. So like Dan, I've been in pretty close contact with Betsy. And I just think that the situation is so dynamic.

2:52:05 That, you know, I think they're cautious about, you know, I won't say paint themselves in the corner, but, you know, I think as Bill, or as Dan said, it's the project's in stasis. And so I would encourage the board not to take their, them not having someone on at this meeting as, you know, any sort of representation of ambivalence or negligence or anything. I mean, they're working hard to do, you know, what they need to do.

2:52:35 We've worked alongside the foundation for, you know, for my part for the last three years since I've been here and I can say nothing but great things about them. So, you know, I've asked that, you know, I can't tell you how to feel about it, but from our perspective, I wouldn't consider their absence derelict in any way. Okay. Let's see. And so since we did kind of start addressing the

2:53:08 the MAC. I'll double check to make sure we have no further public comment. Angela? I'm actually emailing with Betsy Truax. She wanted me to let you know that she is watching the meeting and I just responded to ask her if she had a public comment to make. So I'm just going to hold on for one second and see if she has anything. Perfect. I had a feeling, you know,

2:53:42 I had a feeling she might be listening in. So, great. We'll give it a second. Any further questions or thoughts? And we'll give Betsy a minute or two. I think we need to go ahead and move forward personally with the $300,000 on that. I think the foundation is right now in a very difficult position with COVID.

2:54:06 And I think that they will continue even though they're on a pause at this point. They've made years of commitment on this and I'm really hoping that they can get this project done. Yeah. And it doesn't, as Matt mentioned, it doesn't make any sense for us to kind of pull the rug out from under them. It buys them time to, you know, for it to become less dynamic. And so I would tend to agree. And so...

2:54:34 Anything, Angela? Otherwise, I'll close public comment. No, she has not responded. Okay. So we'll close public comment and now entertain a motion from the board to move forward in a decision. You know, I...

2:55:02 I echo the sentiments that have already been said. I would be supportive of continuing the $300,000 in support. I want to see us continue to push that project forward in hopes that this is a temporary pause and that will resume as normal at some point in the future. At risk of being a broken record, I...

2:55:26 I'm not sure personally that I feel like while I support the sentiment around additional funds towards programming, I'm not sure that today in this environment is the appropriate time to make that increase. I feel more comfortable leaving it where it's at and having that fall to the bottom line. So that would be my motion to approve the budget as proposed with one adjustment.

2:55:54 which is to move programming forward at 166 as opposed to 266. Leave the MAC 300 in there with a fund balance retained of 272, 780. Okay, we have a motion. Do I have a second? I will second. All right, bill on the second. Any further discussion?

2:56:23 I just want to comment. I support that as well because I feel, as Matt stated, I don't want deliverables attached to that extra $100,000 in programming. It's a little unclear the use of the funds. I think having it fall to the bottom line means it's available. So I am with you in supporting that. I don't think it's the proper time to add in $100,000 in programming. Further discussion?

2:56:54 I was just going to say, I think the timing's difficult. When we're talking about keeping, as much as I want, thank you, Dan, for proposing this, I want more money and events and programming as much as possible with a lot of the difficult conversations that are going on right now. I just don't know if the timing is right because of the earlier conversation that we had, I think takes priority.

2:57:21 I would concur with that. Looking at it differently, it's spending money that we don't know we're going to get, those projections. I kind of echo Eric's concern that with no utilities coming from commercial to speak of, that it's, I think we're being very optimistic that we're going to see those revenue projections. And unfortunately, it'd have to come out of this area.

2:57:51 So as much as I'd like to have a commitment right now for more money, it makes me uncomfortable there and knowing that a lot of the current things that we have awarded may or may not be able to produce in the manner that they expected and those expenses may change and we may be getting something back too. It's just too early to spend money.

2:58:20 Didn't commit money we don't have. So thank you. We'll be coming around if something happens to change that. But I think the conservative approach. I'd like to thank Angela. I just don't think we're going to be in a position, I echo everybody else's comments, but we're going to be in a lot more hurt than I think we realize a year from now. Okay, great. Angela, you had something? Yeah, I've got two comments have come in from Betsy Truax.

2:58:49 The first one says, I'd just like to affirm Bill and Dan's comments that the major funders for the MAC, including the town, all remain committed, contingent on the other major funders retaining their commitments. Her second comment that came in was, I am happy to bring forward a more formal request for the $300,000 at another time. I did not realize that would be part of this meeting. Okay, great. Thank you, Angela.

2:59:20 All right. Other more discussion? Seeing none. Roll call. May I please have clarification on the amendment to this motion as it was written on the agenda? Sure. I am proposing that we move the budget forward as proposed with one adjustment.

2:59:52 which would reduce the programming line item from $266 down to $166. And that $100,000 amendment would fall to the bottom line in the fund balance, moving that from $172,780 to $272,780. Thank you. Thanks for that clarification, Angela. Bill Souser. First space bar, yes.

3:00:27 Eric Wasserman. Yeah. Rhonda Dugan. Yes. Catherine Taft. Yes. Colin Fernie. Yes. Heather Schaubmeyer. Yes. Tamara Bankson. Yes. David Page. Yes. And Craig Albright. Yes. Thank you.

3:00:55 All right. I would like to say, Dan, let's put that on the agenda in six months from now, please. That would be my request. That was hard. I'm sorry. Thank you. Yes, that was very good. Let's see, where are we at next? Administrative items. Thank you guys for getting through those. That was a good discussion on all those items.

3:01:23 Administrative item is approved minutes from our regular board meeting, which was on March 10th, 2020. And your packet had those meeting minutes. Anyone like to move to approve those minutes? Motion to approve. I'll second. It feels like five years ago. It was a lifetime ago. Literally.

3:01:52 The longest three months of our lives. Oh my gosh. The second was, I'm sorry, was that Heather that was the second? Sure. Okay. And discussion? And all in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Angela, I'm going to recuse. I wasn't there. Okay. Opposed? I am going to recuse. I was not there as well. No. So,

3:02:24 7 and 2 abstains. If you don't mind, I'll go ahead and do a roll call vote, please. Okay, you bet. Bill Souser was recused. Eric Wasserman? Yes. Rhonda Dugan? Yes. Catherine Taft? Yes. Colin Fernie? Yes. Heather Schaubmeyer? Yes. Tamara Bankson? Yes. Excuse me, David Page? Abstain.

3:02:55 Abstaining. And Craig Albright? Yes. Thank you. And Colin, you said yes, but did you previously say you were recusing or abstaining from him? I'm a solid yes. All right. Excellent. Moving on to Executive Director's Report. You made it. Thank you, Craig. Thank you, Craig. So I'll keep this as brief as possible.

3:03:30 Obviously, tomorrow night, we're going in front of town council to make our case, if you will, why we believe that MLR should continue to partner with the town of Mammoth Lakes. We're number 19 on the agenda, I believe. David Page, Heather Schraubmeyer, and Craig Albright will be speaking on behalf with me, and so we're excited to make that presentation. Everything else...

3:03:59 Obviously tonight went pretty long anyways. I was hoping it would be a little bit shorter, but we have a lot of stuff to cover at our next meeting, which is gonna be July 7th. Briefly, that's gonna be a budget. We pushed that from this meeting to the 7th, just because it seemed rational that we didn't wanna really go over four different scenarios until we had a definitive direction or decision for direction from council. We'll also be talking about...

3:04:24 Strategic plan, I'm sure, will come into play here, depending on what those outcomes are. And then we have board elections. Some of the seats are coming up, so we'll be talking about those, as well as just a whole bunch of other stuff. A lot of exciting news on the programmatic side. By that time, we will have both of our new programs launched and fully functioning. I know Matt Perillo will be chomping at the bit to tell you about the new grant he just received with SNC for Buckeye Hot Springs.

3:04:54 That is for $79,000. So a really amazing job by him. I know that Kim's going to be wanting to talk to you about all the great work that she's doing on. So we look forward to the seventh. So I would say bring your big, super-sized cups of coffee to that. Otherwise, we're doing well with MLR. I think most of you know that we were successfully able to secure a PPP loan.

3:05:21 That's helped out a little bit for sure. And I think we're doing well, all things considered. We're, you know, as I mentioned to Ted in the sheet, unlike some of the other businesses, which were unfortunately forced to shut down, like food service and hotels, we're as busy as ever. We're as busy as we've ever been. We've got a lot of great things happening. So hopefully we can move forward without any interruption, because I think this is going to be a big year ahead and a big summer ahead for MLR. Greg, we can't hear you. You're muted still. Thank you.

3:06:03 We've all done it once tonight, right? Any questions for Matt? Seeing none, we'll quick board member updates and I'll start with you, Mr. Wasserman. You're muted. That was my turn. I've been traveling, going to sporting events and concerts. It's been just great. Oh yeah, wait, that was last time. No, basically just been working hard.

3:06:37 I do want to say, you know, I appreciate all the staff's work and everything tonight. This is a difficult meeting. I wish you guys the best at town council tomorrow. I want to say for the record, I support the organization. I think it's very important that we stay, you know, have our contract renewed. And, you know, we have delivered on what we've been asked since I've been on the board. And I'd love to see the organization continue to do that. Last part of my comments would be,

3:07:07 In these difficult financial times and just times in general, I think we should really be taking a good look at what is necessary, what is the need versus what is the want. And when it comes to the MR, to the CRC, I think that's something that should be completely tabled until it is able to be funded properly and not be squandering money in what I feel is a depression in this town. That's the end of my report. Thanks, Eric.

3:07:38 Yep. Rhonda, how about you up next? Just real quickly, thank you for all the hard work that staff has done on this and looking forward to tomorrow night and discussing deliverables for an organization the last five years that's been through two executive directors and having priorities and needs changed. I appreciate how nimble.

3:08:05 everyone has been and to step up to the program and Matt to all the new relationships that you have created and hope to leverage in the future because as a non-profit one of our things that we really want to do is look to where our funding sources in the future and I know there's exciting things out there for it. The only thing I just want to report is for those of you that

3:08:33 Have employees or yourselves, and I've seen a lot of people, you want to pass along the information, the food bank will be changing operations on June 26th, will be our last day of operating there, and then we transition to programs in with the MACA and other organizations. So, and the good news is the reason we're doing this is because the demand has sufficiently diminished.

3:09:01 Now that we're opening. So thank you to everyone that's helped to support that. Just as you may or may not know, I'm the numbers person. I've talked to everybody that's come through. That's nearly 10,000 households and we're in week 13 and we have fed 35,000 people plus throughout the Eastern Sierra. So the idea we thought we're going to do for two weeks.

3:09:30 Week 13. And thank you to everyone. And it's good to see that we're moving in a direction where it's not quite as necessary. All right. Thank you, Rhonda. Catherine? Yeah, I'll keep it brief having just done the allocations process. I just want to say how impressed I am with the town's commitment to culture and the desire to keep submitting these great proposals.

3:10:02 Even under the worst of circumstances. And just the kind of great work that Mammoth Lakes Recreation is doing, spearheaded by Matt and with Kim's guidance, you know, we just, I'm pumped. I'm psyched to get through this hard times. And I just want to compliment you all for your hard work. All right. Thanks, Catherine. Tamara? Just a couple points. One, just sharing what we've been doing at Mount Mount Community Foundation the last couple months.

3:10:33 We ran a PPE drive at the request of the hospital. We collected and laundered and worked with sewers all across the county, about 3,500 pieces of personal protective equipment that we distributed back to the hospital and throughout the county. We also ran a... All right, you got your mask, Rhonda. Good job. We also ran a...

3:11:00 A fund to help members of our community school districts. We collected close to $20,000 in donations and funded that back directly to people that needed some immediate and basic help right when COVID struck. So I was really proud to do that. And what that shows me is I work for, as an Executive Director, as a nonprofit as well. The value of a nonprofit, I think, is something that we really need to voice tomorrow night.

3:11:29 In the oversight of public funds and as a community servant. So I don't underestimate that at all. And I thank you, Matt, for your good work that you've done for us. And I'll be there to voice my support as well. That's it. All right. Thanks, Tamara. Colin? Yeah. You know, nothing crazy. It's obviously been an interesting month or a few months for all of us. They feel pretty fortunate to be

3:12:04 quarantined and at home in Mammoth Lakes as opposed to a lot of other places would not want to be in New York City through all this. So, you know, just been trying to take a pause and slow down and reprioritize some things, but getting outside a bunch and exercising and that's been great for, you know, physical and mental health. And it is really cool to see the resiliency of our community.

3:12:32 You know, how creative people are being to work through this pandemic. And it's nice to see all of you. Glad everyone's, you know, healthy and happy and very, very intrigued to see how things go tomorrow night at town council. So I'll be listening in on that as well. But thanks to everyone for putting in all the work throughout this period and hope to see you guys in person sometime soon. All right. Thanks, Colin.

3:13:01 Mr. Salzer. I'm not going to give a long update. I will tell you that in the way of social distancing, the only thing I've really done is gone fishing on Crowley and the percher biting, and they're damn good. I will say, however, much to everyone's chagrin, if possible, I would love to see us call a meeting one week from today, which just barely gives us time to do that, to respond to

3:13:31 Okay, cool. And that's it. All right. Awesome. Thank you, Bill.

3:14:02 Heather? Well, I've been working like most of you for the last three months. I have not organized nine closets. My front yard does not look like that amazing gardener's been here. And 10% of me was jealous that people had that time off and 90% of me was thankful for the job that I had. So we've gotten through this. I'm happy to see businesses reopening. I'm happy to be kind of doing my job in a normal-esque way. I'm hoping that we can do this in a...

3:14:34 Manner that is conservative enough so that we don't go back in the future. So that's kind of, I'm excited, I'm cautious and I'm scared and all those kind of funny feelings we have going on. Thank you to everybody in the allocations process for being involved, taking the time for that. We did a lot of work and then just everything stopped for three months and everybody picked it up together, Kim and Matt and Catherine and yourself, Craig and Rhonda, everybody.

3:15:03 Kind of hustled there at the end and we made it happen. So thank you. And thank you, Dan, for always pushing for us for those funds. I just couldn't make that commitment right now after everything else we went through. And bravo to us. I think that was the biggest argument discussions we've had in like two years. So it's good sometimes. There's passion. And I'm appreciative of the conversation we had today. So thank you. Indeed. And Mr. Page. Yeah, really quick.

3:15:36 referenced it earlier, but please be aware there's a live scoping period underway right now for trail out Solitude Canyon and also about seven miles worth of reroutes and some new trail mileage in the lakes basin. If you haven't seen that scoping notice, please reach out to Kim or Matt. They can forward that information to you. It's, as I said, about a decade's worth of

3:16:05 Collaborative planning and ideas. And we only get, we may only get another three weeks of public comment on this, depending on how it goes. So it'd be really good for everybody in the community to weigh in one way or another. Excellent. Thanks. Thanks, David. And good night, Schaubmeyer children. And I'll wrap it up with just, we are so excited that June 26th is not only the,

3:16:36 The end of the food bank in its current form, but also the reopening of Mammoth Mountain and some bike park action and moving towards, exactly, moving towards, you know, entertaining visitors here again. And I got to, you know, kind of lift a glass, which I will have shortly. Way to go, Bill.

3:17:06 Is, you know, Mayor Souser and Dan as our town manager and the EOC have done just some amazing work. I was telling a council member today that I've listened to more town council and Mono County supervisor meetings than I have in full meetings, not just

3:17:36 Oh, I'm going to come in and listen to my issue. And you guys have really done some great work. It's obvious how much you all care about our community. And we're lucky to have such good public servants. And so thank you. And I am super optimistic about the future. I think...

3:18:04 Once we get past COVID and we have a vaccine and the world goes back, it's going to be a new normal. And I think the new normal plays to Mammoth's strengths. I think people are going to learn, have learned that, you know what, maybe I don't need to live in the city. Maybe I don't need to leave my kids in school midweek. Maybe I need to come up and go skiing midweek and do homeschooling.

3:18:30 I think there's tons of positive stuff that once we can get through this mess, our community is really going to be well poised for the bright future. We all know it has the potential to reach. So I'm super optimistic. I look forward to the discussion tomorrow night. And yeah, that's all I have.

3:18:55 You know, we did have a request for, I kind of read a request for an agenda item in that we would have an agenda on, you know, a week from now after the town council meeting on the 17th. Do we want to endeavor to try to nail that time down now for staff to be able to get that going? I would recommend maybe we just get through tomorrow night and then we can reevaluate it Thursday morning. Okay.

3:19:25 And so, but at the end of tomorrow night or Thursday morning, get something on the, you know, on the calendar. Is everybody okay with that on the board? Yeah, I will be somewhat unavailable that week starting on the 24th, but if we wanted to do something the 22nd or the 23rd, that would work fine for me, just kind of FYI. Yeah, and Bill, you are saying sometime between

3:19:55 Say the 18th and the 23rd, right? Right, right. Okay. So there's a window in there. Anybody else have any concerns about those dates? I'd love to go somewhere, but I'm not going anywhere. All right. We'll work on that on Thursday and get that out. Does that still leave us enough time? Matt, Bill? Yeah, I mean, we would have to, if we made the decision on Thursday,

3:20:27 Understanding that we don't have an agenda now, so it's going to move. We couldn't put one together tomorrow. So Thursday, trying to put something together would be the earliest. Then we could agendize a meeting for, has to be 72 hours. So for Monday or Tuesday, is that correct, Kim? Yeah. Matt, I think it's a special meeting, so you just need a 24-hour notice. Okay. Thanks, Dan. Okay, that's good.

3:20:53 Otherwise, any other agenda items we want to get out there aside from $100,000 worth of programming six months from now? Anyway, no, and so we will adjourn. Thank you so much, everyone. Good discussions tonight. I appreciate all of you and look forward to working with you again here in the coming weeks. Thank you, everybody. Thanks, Craig.

3:21:23 Thanks, everyone. Thanks, everybody. Great to see you. Bye.