TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2025

Town Council

at 15:00 · recording 2 hr 47 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

359 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:09 But that's interesting because everybody needs them eventually. We have two more minutes. Got my packet. I had LASIK and I had like the whatever it's called. But I just hit the wall and I can't see anything to read without my glasses. All right. I did that. I'm waiting for Pam.

0:53 Is she going to make it? Okay, but never second in our hearts. All right. Welcome, everyone. Oh, yes, just in time. Welcome, everyone. I'm welcoming you to the regular town council meeting for Wednesday, October 15th for Mammoth Lakes Town Council. So, Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Salzer? Yes. Councilmember Turex? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes, here.

1:26 Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Here. Mayor Bubser? Here. And Pam, will you please lead us in the pledge. Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. And before I take public comments, I would like to make a special welcome to our

2:03 Former Town Manager, Dan Holler, it's nice to see you here in town. All right, with that, are there any public comments for anything not otherwise on the agenda? Please approach the podium. You just bumped Brianna. Mayor Bubster, Council, pleasure to be here. As you mentioned, it's been great. It's gone for a few years now, but it's really neat. Still proudly wearing the logo for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. But it just worked out being here this weekend for other issues.

2:37 It is just really exciting to see projects come to fruition that are 10, 15, 30 years in the making. But it was great. It just worked out that way with the access apartments that we all worked on and the housing stuff, going through the parcels, seeing some of that work done. The ice rink, rent center, boulder, all things kids. As he used to tell us, we want programming from one year to 100 years old. I think we have it there.

3:06 It's really exciting to see that and to have been a part of that to come back and then see the vision being fulfilled. It is really gratifying. So congratulations to you all and to the staff. I know we have Pam here shortly. Ten years plus working with her has been great. So those types of elements. But really to see that vision cast, carried out and implemented and the other things that are still coming. The theater and the new town offices are just...

3:35 Really exciting to have been a part of it and then see it move forward. It's very, very exciting. So thank you for years of great service and continue the path forward. Thank you so much. Wonderful to see you. Thanks for coming. Good afternoon. Mayor, Mayor, Mayor, Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem and Council, Brianna Glico with the Mayor of Lakes Chamber of Commerce.

4:01 I just wanted to highlight a couple things going on. Today is actually Support Your Vocal Chamber of Commerce Day, Wednesday, October 15th. So we put out a little video just highlighting some of the work that our chamber has done, is doing.

4:16 Highlighted that we're the team behind the 4th of July parade. Not everybody knows that, as I know you all do. But just wanted to highlight, you know, our chamber really focuses with your support, which we so much appreciate, to really foster communication, economic clarity, quality of life, and create meaningful employment opportunity for our students. We've really been working and...

4:38 Our staff has been participating in the Community and Economic Development Workshop that Erin Wilshire is overseeing. And we've only had one session so far, but something that's really come up is how to partner with other community organizations to build a resilient economy, in our case, and really promote community-wide prosperity. So it's been really great to get to know some of the other players in town in a better way.

5:05 Check out the video if you haven't seen it. It's on social media. We did recently conduct a membership survey. So this was our second annual one that we've done. We just started it last year. So last year we conducted it in July, just after the parade. This year we did it in September. But one thing that really came up that came up last year as well, but I think even more so this year, the main thing that we're hearing from our businesses is just inflation and cost of running a business makes it

5:35 It's very difficult to operate a business in town, which you all know.

5:42 We did, in the survey, we get a net promoter score that comes out as a part of that, and it went up 150% compared to last July, so it's really great to see that our members are finding value in the chamber and in our programming. Our team, myself and Gina Van Hess, our communications director, have been in place since July of last year, so I hope that...

6:06 You know, to me, it really shows that what the work that we're doing is making a difference. So I wanted to highlight that. And then just a couple things coming up in our business world. We'll be doing a ribbon cutting for $3.95 financial planning next Tuesday, October 21st. They don't have a physical brick-and-mortar location, so we'll be doing it at the fun shop.

6:32 Finances and fun. Next Tuesday, October 21st over at the Fun Shop on Main Street from 4 to 5. So please join us if you're able. We also have a retailer that's going to be opening up on Saturday, November 1st, Mammoth Mercantile, long awaited. So really exciting to see them open up in the new outpost remodeled, excuse me, outpost area. So they're located in

7:00 The Mammoth Mall slash Outpost. And so they're going to be doing a grand opening and ribbon cutting on Saturday, November 1st from 4 to 6 with the ribbon cutting at 5. And then our signature, one of our signature events, Business Excellence Awards coming up on Thursday, November 6th. I think I'd mentioned here that we had our record number of nominations and votes. So Gina, our communications director, did really great at trying to get

7:26 Interest and nominations from the community, so huge thank you to her. We are almost sold out of tickets, so if any of you in this room are hoping to attend, please get your tickets, because they will be gone soon. And then we will be partnering with Access Mammoth, formerly Disabled Sports Eastern Sierra, to do a Power Lunch on Wednesday, November 12th. We're really going to focus it on...

7:52 Access Mammoth's kind of rebrand and name change and what it's like for a business nonprofit in their case to go through that. So that'll be at Mammoth Coffee Roasting Company on Wednesday, November 12th at noon. And then last thing coming up in November, we are doing a business after hours with a better fireplace and clean sweep. So that's going to be on Tuesday, November 18th from 5 to 7. So lots going on with the businesses in town and I hope some of you will be able to make some of that. Thank you.

8:22 Thank you. Good evening, Council. Betsy Truax, Vice President of Community Engagement for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Just wanted to share a couple things. First of all, I just wanted to thank everyone who took time to meet with or attend the events that we had with Hunden Partners, who were here in town two weeks ago working on our destination stewardship plan. So really appreciate everyone who came out for that. They will make one more site visit before delivering their final report.

8:55 Community Coffee, next Community Coffee is Thursday, October 30th at 8.30 a.m. on Zoom, and we'll have Don Johnson from the National Weather Service in Reno giving us a winter outlook, so that's always a well-attended and much-anticipated program, so hope you will all tune in. Special events funding applications for the $350,000 allocation for special events for 2026.

9:21 Will open on November 14th and close on December 15th. So we'll be pushing out some announcements and communications about that starting this week. Looking forward to beginning our winter community skate nights in partnership with the town. So those will take place on the first Tuesday of each month from 7.45 to 9.15 p.m. So hope to see some of you over at the rink for that. And finally, on the back table, you'll see a few maps. This is a...

9:49 New little mini campaign that Mammoth Lakes Tourism just launched called Opry Adventure Eats and it pairs a local activity with a local restaurant. So really just trying to encourage people to get out and not only explore our beautiful area but then to visit our local restaurants afterward. And so this is not a comprehensive list of every restaurant in town that wouldn't quite have fit on the map but we'll continue to update this going forward. So thanks very much. Thank you.

10:19 Any other public comments for anything not otherwise on the agenda? Madam Mayor and Councilmembers, boy, what a treat. Make sure you say your name for everybody online. I'm sorry. That's okay. I want to thank Dan Holler. He thanked everybody in the room for what they did. Also nice to see Brent Truax back in town. Haven't seen him in a while. Just teasing. I'm glad I got my drug record. You what? Never mind.

11:00 Madam Mayor and Councilmembers, it's been almost two months ago that I appeared before your body and we talked about bears and I proposed at that time to form an independent committee, I say independent would be community members, council members, town staff as appropriate to discuss

11:30 Bears and Wildlife Management and Mammoth Lakes. And since that time, I haven't heard a peep from any of the council members or town staff. I did call Councilmember Sauser and went over and visited with him for a while. He was not interested in agendizing this for council and community discussion. So I'd like to ask the council this evening, not now, obviously, it's not agendized, but...

11:58 In the interim of council would consider agendizing and having a discussion with yourselves, with staff and with the community about the possibility of forming this committee. It only takes one council member, one out of five to agendize this. So I'm hoping that there's one member who will consider agendizing it. Thank you. Thank you.

12:32 Any other public comments or any online, Jamie? No. Okay. Anyone else? All right. Then with that, are there any additions to the agenda this evening? No, Madam Mayor. There are no adjustments to the agenda this evening. All right. So we are on to presentations. So Mr. Patterson, I imagine you will bring up our one and only Pam Kobylarz.

13:06 Good evening, Council, Rob Patterson, Town Manager. And yes, the one and only Pam Kobylarz is here with us tonight. And celebrating her 20th anniversary with the town. So that's quite an incredible milestone, as you can imagine, a career itself, but in one particular place for 20 years is quite amazing. So I'll go through a little bit of a background of history, if you will, for Pam's time with the town, and then talk a little bit about how much she does for me and how much she means to the town.

13:36 So Pam started 2005 as an assistant planner because she wanted a real job in a ski town. So growing up in skiing and snowboarding in Washington State, she went to school, I think, Western Washington University in human and international geography and minor in geographic information systems. But coming to Mammoth, she wanted to settle in a place like this.

14:01 And thought that working for the town would be a good career, and I think that's pounded out pretty well for her, and she's done an excellent job on that. The first job assistant planner, associate planner, that was roughly 2005 to January 2012. In that capacity, she was a project manager for the Clearwater Specific Plan, project manager for several affordable housing development applications, the Jefferies and the Manzanita Apartments, and developed and implemented the town of Mammoth Lakes TOT Enforcement Program.

14:30 So that's a pretty important program for us that we've utilized for years to come. And you're going to hear a presentation on its evolution tonight, certified properties. She also developed the zoning color designations that you see on our zoning map today. So that's something that we all use and rely on on a regular basis. It's right back there. After that, she went into the administrative assistant to the town manager. That was January 2012.

14:58 Roughly through May of 2015 in that capacity. That was a tough time. That was obviously during the town was going through the bankruptcy at that time. Some of the work that she performed was developed, implemented, and oversaw the employee engagement program. We have a robust program within town where employees are, we have a group of employees that design all of the programs that we recognize and appreciate our employees with, and Pam was part of bringing that together.

15:28 Acting as Planning and Economic Development Commission Secretary. Also served as an acting personnel in risk management for about eight months. So really important aspects of the job. And then in 2015, she became the assistant to the town manager, which she is today. So for the last 10 years, she's been in the role that she is. Projects noteworthy and accomplishments, which there are a lot, oversaw an updated negotiation with the town's solid waste franchise agreement, which resulted in the adoption of new rates and a 20-year agreement.

15:58 Oversees the ongoing partnership with Mammoth Disposal, including facilitating compliance and state mandates and management of the town's sustainability programs. She's also responsible for the development of the town's plastic water bottle ban and styrofoam food container ban and the implementation plan for both. So those are a couple of highlights from her career. What I'd like to talk a little bit about is how much Pam means to me and what she does for our organization.

16:24 So Pam, unfortunately, has to sit in an office that's very, very close to mine, which means she is the one that is right there when I need her and when things go sideways, which is several times a day. It's almost on a schedule. So Pam gets to deal with that. She gets the brunt of that. And she does a phenomenal job, right? I mean, I wouldn't really be able to be successful if I didn't have someone like Pam and the rest of the executive staff that

16:50 I depend on so much. And so I go in often, have a lot of needs, especially maybe grammar and or spell checking. I know my predecessor had similar issues with that, but we rely so heavily on you. I think it means a lot to me. It helps my day get done, frankly. And as you know, I come in and talk almost every hour about things and challenges and so forth.

17:16 That means a lot to me, and I really appreciate the job that you do for the town. I know it's sometimes thankless because, you know, we get to deal with all the things that are very challenging. And so I appreciate having you by my side to complete that and get that stuff done. So you do a phenomenal job, and I thank you for that. Thank you. So would you like to say a few things? I don't have anything prepared, but there was a whole backside of accomplishments that Rob didn't even touch on.

17:44 I've worked on so many different things in so many capacities over the years. One of the things I really enjoy about my job is I get to work with almost every employee that we have here at the town through my risk management efforts and the employee engagement and just communication coming from the town manager's office. And I just really appreciate getting to interact with all of our employees and all the departments at different levels.

18:08 And just really grateful for the opportunity to be a part of this organization and have an impact on the community and just get to work on a whole variety of different things and learn new things every day. So thank you. Thank you. Should we go down? That's all I do. All right.

18:44 There you go.

19:29 All right. Is it Rob again for introductions or who's doing introductions? Oh, it might be Megan. So we have new revenue specialist Carlotta and new parks hybrid worker. Okay. Megan Chapman, Finance Director. I'm pleased to present our new addition to the team. Lealana Kealaba has been with us for five weeks. Hopefully I didn't.

19:55 That's okay. LK. She's been with us for five weeks. She's a great addition to the team. She worked in our community on the other end of TOT, and now she's on our team, and she's going to be working on enforcement. So we're very happy to have her. We're very excited to have LK join the team. LK. She's been doing a great job so far. She's already been cleaning up some of our registration numbers for our online advertisements. A few people who are advertising.

20:26 Over occupancy and as well as opening in a couple of enforcement cases. So we're off to a great start. Thank you. Thank you. I'm Lena Alaka'ili Ava and I've been working in the private sector for a long time. I moved to Mammoth in 1990 and I'm excited to be part of this team. I love the finance team I'm working for and I look forward to serving the public in this new capacity.

20:52 And any questions or anything else? Come on up. Thank you so much. Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you. Good to see you. You too. Congratulations. Thank you. Thank you. Madam Mayor, on item 7.2, I was just notified that our worker, Mr. Russell, Christopher Russell, is out doing

21:23 Okay. Well, I hope that we'll be able to welcome him at a future meeting. Yes. We do not let people out of this opportunity just because they're busy. So we'll be back another time. Thank you. Yes. All right. Then moving on to item 8.1, the proclamation for declaring October 2025 as Domestic Violence Prevention Month.

21:51 Jamie, is someone here to receive this proclamation or are we? Oh, great. Okay. Yeah, do you want to come up to the podium? Thank you. Hello. And please introduce yourself for everyone who's online who's not. Good evening. My name is Janet Lopez and I'm the DBSA coordinator, program coordinator for Wild Iris. And? I'm Luisana Baides. I'm the traveling community outreach advocate for Wild Iris.

22:26 Terrific. Thank you so much for being here. So first I read the proclamation and then we vote, correct? Sure. Yeah, is there anything you want to say before? No. Okay. All right, great. I just want to make sure I got this right. I will paraphrase, but this is a proclamation of the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, proclaiming October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month. So whereas,

22:56 Although progress has been made toward breaking the cycle of domestic violence and supporting victims and their families in the town of Mammoth Lakes, much work remains to be done. And whereas Wild Iris has served over a thousand survivors of domestic violence and sexual assault over the last year and advocates, law enforcement officials, health care providers, court systems, tribal organizations and others are an integral part of the effort to end domestic violence in the Eastern Sierra and must be recognized.

23:26 And applauded for their work. And whereas victims of domestic violence embody incredible strength and resilience and there is a need to increase public awareness and understanding of domestic violence and the needs of survivors.

23:41 And whereas the legislature recognizes the vital role that all Californians play in preventing and one day ending domestic violence, now therefore let it be resolved that in recognition of the important work done by Wild Iris and all victim service providers,

23:57 The Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes hereby proclaims that the month of October 2025 is domestic violence awareness month in the town of Mammoth Lakes and encourages all residents to observe domestic violence awareness month. And so may I have a motion to... I would make a motion to proclaim October 2025 is domestic violence prevention month. I'll second. Great. Jamie, could you please call the roll?

24:24 Councilmember Sauser? Yep. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. And do you want to head down and we'll present the presentation? Thank you so much for coming. Thank you so much for doing this. Thank you. Thank you. Well, thank you so much. All right. We are on to item 9.1.

25:23 This is reports from commissions and or departments. And I see Nolan is first in line. That is correct. I had to beat Stu up here. So I just wanted to give a brief update on the status of lease to locals since we extended the contract at the end of June there. We extended that contract through December 31st.

25:50 With a change structure to pay them as a performance-based rather than a flat fee each month. So since the end of June, they have leased up nine additional properties. So they had done 10 properties in the first year and they've done nine properties in the last three months. So I think that's pretty successful based on just the extensions. So that 19 properties total leased through the program with 52 people housed.

26:19 It was approximately about $325,000 that was committed for subsidy. $193,000 of that's been committed. And there's $116,000 remaining. So my math might be off. It might have been about $315,000 that was committed. So I want to give that brief update on just where the program's at as of now. Thank you. Any questions? All right. Thank you very much.

26:51 Good afternoon. Haislip Hayes, Director of Public Works. Just a quick update. Before the storm, we did close the gates to the lake space, and just for abundance of caution, this morning our crews went up there and started to clear that snow. We don't typically do snow removal in the winter there, so we do not have snow poles in the ground, so they have to be very careful about how they conduct operations. We also don't have anything delineated for parking spaces. So as we speak, Lawson is up there just kind of looking things over, making sure that it's safe for the public.

27:20 To access the site, use the roads, have parking. If it is clear and we feel comfortable opening it to the public, they'll open it up this evening. If not, I suspect it'll be no later than this morning. Also, since I'm up here, if you have any questions on the written CIP update, I'm happy to answer them. Questions? Yes. I just have a question on the Lakes Basin. It was our understanding that the Town and the Forest Service had coordinated to close on October 14th, and that was going to be it.

27:50 Are you saying that the gate will swing and it'll be open tomorrow? Correct. It'll be open to traffic tomorrow. Okay. Until a snow event? Until such time that winter weather closes it for good or, you know, the ski area needs to farm the snow for the cross-country, for Tamarack. Okay. And all the crews up in cold water can get to keep doing whatever they do? The first thing we did this morning was cut a path just for that crew. And then they went about clearing the other roads and parking areas and so forth.

28:19 Okay, good. Thank you. I just have a comment. Go ahead. I have a comment on the Mountain Boulevard crosswalk project. I guess I'm a little disappointed seeing on there that it will probably not happen until the South Main MUP happens, and I think that that's a really important crosswalk for us to put in, so I would urge us to put that in before we're going to do the MUP on the other side.

28:49 And my question is, does anyone know how much longer that Coldwater Campground project is expected to go to completion? I do not know, but I can have Lawson shoot yourself and Rob an email with those details. Okay, that'd be great, just to see if they're going to have a chance to finish it. I was up there last week and heard them working.

29:12 Like crazy. No, they're working 12-hour shifts. Yeah. And their goal is to get what they have to get done in this season. Okay. Let's hope for that. Yep. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Madam Mayor, I have something else to add as well. If you could just give me one second. Sure. Oh, I'm jumping in front of Stewie. I'm sorry about that. Go ahead, Stew. I'll get my stuff together, please. Afternoon. Madam Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, members of Council, staff, and the public. Just a little update from...

29:46 Parks and Recreation. The Parks and Recreation Master Plan process, as you know, is underway. We're working with that team on finalising a lot of the community engagement, which is going to ramp up here in November. So the big item that we start to put together and work towards and encourage our community to participate in is the Community Needs Assessment Survey. The last one we did was 2007, 17 years ago, and that pretty much built...

30:14 Mammoth to what we see today with our recreation amenities. So we're really looking forward to launching that survey. It'll be coming out in a printed survey through everybody in the town of Mammoth Lakes through their mailbox. And then we'll follow up with a digital survey. You get a little postcard and you can complete it at that time. So either do it through the print survey or through the digital survey. Large survey, but we're really looking for what's next. So looking forward to

30:42 Launching that in November. The consultants were at the expo, which was great if you had a chance to meet them. Wonderful team, we're really excited about what they'll do and how they can help us through this process. We've launched the website, so if you've had a chance to get on the town homepage, you can click on Parks and Recreation and click right into the master plan page, where you will see lots of fun stuff, lots of bright colours, really linked up and integrated with.

31:11 Our parks and recreation colours, very bright, so we have project fact sheets in English and Spanish, so if you'd like to follow along and understand kind of what we're doing in and throughout the community, you'll be able to kind of follow that through the fact sheet and the website. The other item on the master plan is that we've finalised the advisory committee, so that committee is all ready to go. We've appointed three community at large members, and as I reported last time, we had over 20, which was great.

31:40 So really pleasing to see that much interest in kind of our master plan process. Our first meeting will be October 27th at 5.30 and that'll be right here in Sweetsea and members of the public are welcome to attend. Following along from the park and rec master plan, some fun stuff, we will be hosting our annual haunted rink and that is Friday, November 24th, sorry, October 24th, my mistake.

32:10 Which is Friday week, and that'll be at the Community Recreation Center. Again, just a fun event, spooky good time for all. So look for that, it'll go out through the schools and so forth, and I believe that is from four to seven, five to seven, Amanda, is that about right? Five to seven, four to seven? I didn't look at the flyer today, but I think that sounds about right. Sounds about right. Okay, let's work on that. Stu's not keeping up with his team.

32:38 But a wonderful event at the Community Recreation Center. That will be free for our members and then just $5 for non-skating folks who want to come in. And then finally, membership month is October. So if you haven't purchased your annual membership at 50% off, this is the month to do it. And you can do that in person Monday through Friday, 1 to 5 p.m. at the Community Recreation Center with our staff. And that's all ahead. Questions? I had a question, but I had to look back to see what it was.

33:10 That's okay. Oh, could you let us know who the members of the advisory committee are? Yep, so we appointed to that board, to the committee, Pat Agnich, if you know Pat, Sierra Born, and Mia Rondelli. They're our three community at large members. And they're very excited to be on the committee. And then for these, you're having the meetings of the committee that are open to the public.

33:39 And just remind me, will there be public outreach meetings that are outside of Suite Z? Because as we know, for some reason, people are shy to come here. Yeah, our community is very shy, aren't they? So the outreach effort, I'll just kind of scan up here. So the first one was that pop-up booth will have multiple, the community survey will follow, and then we'll have the kind of more traditional community workshops. Okay. Right, so that's when we'll invite members of the community to come in and just...

34:09 Make sure they have their voice. And then we have five at this time stakeholder focus group meetings. So we'll kind of go after specific user groups, folks. And then we have the advisory committee meetings. We have parks and recreation community meetings. And then we're looking to kind of host who else would like to come forth and spend some time talking about parks and recreation and who wouldn't. Okay, great. And remind me how you'll recruit for the focus groups. So that's kind of a targeted.

34:37 Avenue right now that we're kind of narrowing in on and we're going to have a discussion with our advisory committee on the 27th. Okay. Just to kind of validate those focus group meeting and how we can further reach our community members. But they will all get an invitation essentially through email. Okay. Thank you so much. Anyone? Okay. Thank you. Okay. Now I'll jump in if I may. Certainly. I have a little update.

35:06 One of the things that's kind of come to me recently is referencing the new facility we're building, the theater, and the naming of that theater in sort of our acronym we use now, which is the MAC. Currently, in our purchase and sale agreement with Mammoth Lakes Foundation, the naming of the facility was covered clearly in one of the sections, and it was a component of the

35:34 The agreement, if you will. The agreement itself does reference MAC about 28 times in here because the acronym is tied to the current name of the facility which has been affectionately known as the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center probably for more than a decade now. However, once the facility is complete, the name of the facility has been dictated by this purchase and sale agreement.

36:04 The facility will be called the Dave and Roma McCoy Arts and Cultural Center. So nowhere on the facility will the term MAC be referenced. The Edison Theater as that's known today will be sort of absorbed in the whole entire complex will be the Dave and Roma McCoy Arts and Cultural Center. So the specific language within the purchase and sale agreement dictates that upon completion of the construction,

36:30 The MAC shall be named Dave and Roma McCoy Arts and Cultural Center. So a little bit of a timing process. I think you'll see, you know, the town sort of transitioning away from maybe the use of the term MAC in that process. We'll try desperately not to call it the DRAW MAC. That would be the acronym that would be from the new name, but we'll work on that.

36:52 But I think the issue is that there's some competition for Mono Arts Council, who is also known as the MAC. So I think we want to sort of segregate that a little bit, and we'll work towards that with regard to town notices going forward. But I wanted to kind of just address exactly how the naming of the facility is dictated, and it's been done legally through a purchase and sale agreement. Second item I'd want to just show is, it's super hard to see with my white shirt, is

37:21 This is one of the metal bottles, so it's an aluminum bottle that is reusable and can be refilled, I think, probably indefinitely. It seems to be really sturdy. It's been able to survive life with me for at least a couple of weeks. And so this is in response to, I think it was on page two of Pam's accomplishments, honestly. This is in response to

37:46 The plastic water bottle ban and the need for sort of personal water options for our public events and our sort of events that we have within town. Our goal is to design this in such a way and we'll probably have the marketing logo on it. We'll definitely have the marketing logo on it and possibly some other QR code references to some potential to donate for

38:10 Funds associated with either Clean Up the Lake or other things that the town is interested in promoting at that time. But our goal in this is to build the program in such a way that someone who's having a special event can purchase this directly from one of our local distributors.

38:27 Really cost-effective. Pam did an excellent job. And our first quotes were somewhere in the $6 per bottle range, which is astronomical. And I think this one is somewhere in $1 to $1.50. So it's much more reasonable. And our intent is to make sure that the vendors can buy that and then receive it like next day. So the logistics are all handled, all those types of things, or within the week, I should say. And then they can sell it.

38:52 That's great. Thank you. Any questions? No, it's great. Thank you.

39:20 One question, Rob. As we look at that process, are we going to be looking at adding water stations throughout the community for people to fill those up? So we do have a program like that going on right now. We're trying to, I think we had 10 stations that were identified. There was obviously some logistics to work out with our climate, and so we're working on that process. We do have that intention, but with regard to the

39:50 Special events that go on in town. The water district has a mobile refilling station that they're, I think they have two actually, that they can deploy at those so that people who are milling about it, maybe an area you couldn't even have water filling stations, that they would be able to refill at that point for those special events. And then in addition to that, I think throughout town and maybe MUP related, there'll be some other opportunities to have these refilling stations out there. So it's definitely on our radar. I think there's some logistical challenges to solve for.

40:22 Thank you. Any other questions? I bet we will see a lot fewer of those when we're cleaning up on Trashy Thursdays than we see of the plastic bottles. I bet I picked up 500 bottles this summer at Trashy Thursdays. And I bet Betsy Truax picked up more. So it's terrific. It's a really good step forward. Thank you. So that is all of the reports, I believe. And we're moving on to item 10.1, which is the certified properties update.

41:09 Ben, you can be wherever you want to be, but if you want to go up there, that's fine. Okay, so today we've got a crew from our finance crew here, led by Megan Chapman, who's our finance director, and we have Ben Manning, who is our revenue accountant, and they're going to talk to you about our certified properties program, and I'm going to try not to say too many things, but...

42:09 It's really a great program, something that was born out of a lot of effort, maybe post-COVID, to engage with our property owners and improve our program, which is already, I'm going to call it a world-class program. I may be a little bit jaded in that space or a little bit committed to it, but I'll turn it over to Megan, and you guys can take it away. Thank you, Rob. So this program, I'm very proud to be moving this forward. It's something that's been in place.

42:38 Had council support and action back in 2023. So I feel like we're finally completing and taking the program over the finish line. The idea behind the program back in 2023 was to create a better connection with the property owner. That was something that we felt that we were lacking was actually a contact with the owner themselves instead of the operator who were operating the STRs and nightly rentals.

43:05 We also wanted to get better location data for rental analysis, so we had a better idea for what our community was doing in our various different areas. We wanted to upgrade the municipal code for better enforcement. We also wanted to take advantage of technological advancements with the changing STR landscape, and we wanted to further collect statistical analysis data for reporting. So we moved the program forward.

43:33 And the program is actually right in line with state legislation. The governor just signed SB 346 this week. So all of the program elements that Rob envisioned back in 2023 is right in line with what we're doing at the state level. And that was just signed this week. So that's very exciting. The SB 346 is also known as the Short-Term Rental Facilitator Act of 2025. And the purpose is to basically legalize

44:03 Local agencies and give them enforcement for lodging taxes and regulations. So we're right in line with what we're doing at the state level. Some of the key components of the Certified Property Program, our old program, businesses would register properties for nightly rentals and that would lead to

44:34 You know, one property having multiple certificates, even though it's just one property. With the new program, we really wanted to get a connection to the owner of the property because the owner of the property is actually the party that is responsible for the taxes. We've launched mandatory inspections in the previous program. People were more or less grandfathered in.

45:01 And that's gone away. Now we want to make sure that all of these nightly rentals are ready and safe, ready to hit the market. Property owners are going to have to pay an annual fee now to register. And we are also collecting the cleaning services as well as the local emergency, local 24-hour emergency contact for the business. And those are all going to be connected to those individual properties.

45:32 Lastly, like I briefly mentioned, we kind of redeveloped our registration numbers so that they're a bit more uniform and in line, and that way it becomes much easier to identify where the property is on those online advertisements. I'd also like to recognize some of the members of the finance team that aren't with us tonight. This was not an isolated effort.

46:00 Came with a great vision from Rob and was executed by the finance team at the time. Danny Earls, who's now moved over to the managing accountant role, was the previous revenue accountant and he was charged with changing some of the municipal code. So I want to recognize him for all the work that was done prior to this point. Also, Sean Troy for his participation in the development of the Certified Property App.

46:24 He was an integral part of not only the application development that we're now using, but also with building and training the team for how we're going to use the application. And lastly, I'd like to recognize the entire revenue team, Lupita Lopez, Marcy Castro, and Leilana Keila-Awa for their professionalism and patience with the launching of the application. They've been doing a great job.

46:50 Getting the application to where it is today and being able to remit TOT on a monthly basis. Taking a step back from the recognition, looking at where we've come from to get to this point, back in April of 2024 was when we embarked on creating the application and that's basically a piece of software that was developed specifically for our needs with the TOT remittance. Back in May of this year,

47:17 We opened up the application for use for a select group of users, and that was our trial in our community, and then we launched the application to all of the operators in town. So we did experience some growing pains, but at this point, all but a few are using the new application, and we've worked through all of the quirks and kinks from the new software program, and I think at this point, the two complaints that we still have are that

47:44 The application don't save payment information and that people can't pay their taxes with their smartphones. So those are our repeated complaints that we're looking at and we'll bring forward as needed. A couple of quick stats. We have 3,540 certified properties in the program currently with 1,384 businesses that manage those properties.

48:13 Of those 1,384 operators, 20 are still using paper returns, but the majority of them are all using the online payment portal. And of those, there's 2,979 properties that are actively advertising with 11,456 active listings. So I just want to point out that number is quite large for a small team. And having these registration numbers

48:43 This new program in place should help to manage that large number of listings. Moving forward, the Certified Property Program will provide location data. It will also provide vacancy statistics that will be able to keep track of how many possible nights a unit can be rented, how many of those nights are owner-occupied, as well as how many actual nightly rentals there are. We will collect that data and bring that data back.

49:14 I wanted to add this slide as kind of a visual representation of what we're talking about. This is a complex in town that has one business that has the lion's share of the properties there. And in the past, we could only kind of give an estimation of what we thought was coming out of this complex. Now, you can see that with that heat map, we can really drill down to

49:49 Really the individual property level, which is going to be super powerful for us. I want to point out that we've partnered with Decker Technologies and they have some data scraping technology that gives us really a good idea of what's happening on an individual property level and we can use that data to kind of compare and contrast with what people are remitting and that should be a really powerful tool.

50:20 Can I ask a question about this slide? Sure. I like your color coding. I just would love a key. So yellow is not as much and purple is more. So yes, I absolutely agree with you. And we went back and forth on this slide. I have to protect people's property information. There's a street there that we blurred out.

50:48 We've twisted it 180 degrees in all sorts of ways so that you can't tell who those are because trying to protect people's information. So to explain it though, the yellow means the most activity and those blue and purples are almost no activity. Okay. And then what's the green on the right? The green is kind of, I don't know what that is. The green is the operator. So prior to the launch of the new application, we were only able to get

51:18 Total remittance by operator. So on the left is the green, so that would be a single operator for all of those units. So now we're able to get the information per unit, which is on the right, so you can see the division of each unit with, as Ben said, the most nightly rentals is the yellow color code on top and the least on the bottom. But then there are a few with green on the right, so those are just different operators? I believe.

51:44 I think so. Over time, I think that this is a before and after picture, and I think there's some movement on those units. Okay. Again, this is just a visual representation of what the data that we have. Again, I have to be careful with what we share publicly because that is proprietary information.

52:05 I was just unsure how to interpret the color. Looking at that, I thought purple was rented frequently and yellow was not, so it was the opposite. I mean, maybe just put heavy use, light use, or something. I don't know. Then I would know how to read that color-coded map. Thank you. Yeah. And I would say, moving forward, obviously, I can't just share what, hey, look at this guy made this month. That's not appropriate. I think what's more powerful for...

52:30 These sorts of presentations are looking at it on a complex level and perhaps even on a zoning level. You know, that will create a little bit more of an indicator of what's going on in our community. So are these based on TOT receipts in terms of how busy they are? Are we able to capture so some of these units that are rented a lot are rented a lot because the owner doesn't use them?

52:56 So are we able to capture when the owners are here on our paperwork as well so that we have an idea of what the total occupancy is regardless whether it's an owner occupied, a guest, or a paying visitor? Yeah, that is correct. One of the things that came out of the Certified Property Program is that every business to indicate on an individual...

53:15 How many nights did you try and rent the property for? How many nights did you rent the property for? And the newest addition is how many owner-occupied nights there are. So if you look at some of those purple guys, it would be really helpful to know, was the owner living there the whole time or did it just sit empty? And so we're hoping to capture that statistical data moving forward. Yeah, I just say that so when people look at ones that are rented more than others, it doesn't mean occupied more.

53:44 It just means that they were rented more? Possibly. We will clean the views up when they come back, as you've asked. And just to circle back to the importance of the certified property application, as we know, the town is a destination resort. 60% of the operating budget for the town comes from TOT and nightly rentals. So as we invest our revenues, we do...

54:18 This slide shows the annual volume of baseline TOT for the previous 10 years.

54:51 If we look at that, you can see that there's a pretty steady growth outside of the COVID years. If we were to extend this graph 10 years prior to that, you would see a pretty relatively flat graph, which is between 9.6 and 11.7. So just want to indicate how much we've been growing in the last 10 years. I'd like to add something to that, if I may.

55:23 One of the key milestones at that point in time was the introduction to our TBIT. So that is when we started to enhance our marketing efforts and energies, and you can see the growth there that's been quite steady, if you will. You could draw a line from the introduction to that to where we are today in our capture. And what we're seeing, even the last couple of years, is almost a rounding off. You know, we've gone up, and I'm hoping that that's the new plateau that, you know, John...

55:51 I'm sorry, Ben. Ben talked about a plateau that we were on prior to the introduction of TBID, and I'm hoping our new plateau lives somewhere in the high 29s, potentially low 30s when we get some of these other facilities open, like the limelight and some other things that are currently in design phase.

56:11 I'm excited about what we're seeing on this graph and, you know, what the future kind of holds for us in this space. But I command the team, although I think they took out my slide because I was supposed to talk about one slide, but I think it's not in here anymore, so I don't have to just freestyle it. But just really, this is how we collect the revenue for our town, right? This is the mechanism by which we do that. It's incredibly important.

56:36 To do that function, obviously, but also to do it in such a way that is seamless for the community. And so the things that Ben was talking about with the data that we're collecting, we've had a lot of that stuff on our remittance forms for years, but it's just not been able to be provided because of the bringing together of all of the properties under one number. This system separates that out. So it's really incredibly powerful. I think we kind of just

57:06 Generally talked about some of the data information that can be provided. I think the sky's the limit for data that we were going to be able to pull from this information and how we can tailor that directly to your needs. So I'm very, very excited about it. I know we've struggled to get to this point and I appreciate you guys keeping the customers at the forefront of your thought in that process. But I'll let you guys continue with your presentation. That was my slide. One comment on the baseline.

57:34 I would be interested in seeing a comparison of the TOT versus occupancy to give us an idea of how much of that increase is based on rate versus actual numbers of people because that's something we talk about all the time and how at risk we may or may not be for drastic changes, pricing changes and things like that. And I'd even add to that because

58:01 To me, I was going to say the same thing, but in addition, it's the number of rental properties on top of that as well, seeing what's the fluctuation. Is our gain just rate going up, or is the number of properties changing, or what's happening to give us an idea of what's taking place in the market? This slide is baseline, so 13%. So all of the changes to TOT.

58:24 All of the slides are based on. But like, for instance, in 2023, did we have 3,400 rental units in 2024? Did we have 3,229? Is the rate, you know, are we having rate reductions? Because as we see economy, and I'm just going too far in this, but when you see economy, you wonder, okay, if all of a sudden we had a decline in the economy, these people sabotage their rate, and all of a sudden we got all these people out there with a very low rate, and that's causing an issue, you know, just looking ahead at how we have data that can help us look forward.

58:53 Yeah, this system will absolutely give you the ADR movement. It will track that system when you think about just what the information they talked about collecting. You'll know the revenue by unit. You know, the nights rented by that unit, you can calculate the ADRs right from that number alone. And so they'll be able to monitor and track the movement of that. Because you're right, that's a very, very important category. When you look at ADRs, if the business is not there, people have to start lowering their ADRs, which means

59:22 That not only do we not have enough people, as many people, we also have lower rates. So it's a little bit of a precipice to, you know, a free fall we don't want to encounter. So ADRs are very important. And we do get information anecdotally, but it's not, you know, true and intimate knowledge. And I think we're going to get that from this system. Absolutely. Happy to bring it back. Moving on, this is the TOT baseline of monthly trends for the past four years.

59:51 As you can see, we do still have shoulder seasons that seem to have shrunk. Our low times continue to be September through November and then May and June. But I would like to highlight that if we just look at last year, which is the light blue line, we really just had a low in November and May. And that's something that we should be happy about.

1:00:16 Also want to note that our lows are around the $1 million mark. So if we average September through November and May and June over the last four years, our lows are $1 million. Last year came in as the second highest grossing year just behind $22 and $23, which came in at $29.5 million. Last year we had record-breaking months for both August 2024 and March 2025.

1:00:51 And then the numbers just came in for August, and that's actually breaking the record yet again. So we are experiencing a bit of a boom, but this is the breakdown by month. And then we'd just like to close with the information before you today is demonstrating that the town business model is thriving and changing. So with the growth, we are capturing data to inform program enhancements as our community changes.

1:01:22 We will collect data to better understand our community, to see what the community needs are, as well as our visitors. And as we can see with the growth, the town continues to be committed to sustainability, and we will continue to collect statistical data to inform policy decisions in the future. Any other questions? Yes. So one of the things this model was put into place for was we had a feeling.

1:01:55 That there are no people out there who are renting and not being registered within the system. At this point in time, what is your feeling in terms of how many are we missing out in terms of not having them remit their TOT as required? We have 100% compliance with all the rentals we know about. That's an oldie but a goodie.

1:02:20 No, there are some that are still out there, obviously. As I mentioned earlier, we just opened a couple of enforcement cases. I would think of the town as kind of like a garden, that the more you stay on top of maintaining these things, the less enforcement cases you're going to see. Now, if we get behind and distracted with other priorities, you'll see that the weeds will start to pop up.

1:02:49 You know, we certainly have some strategies to try and, how do I want to say this, deter people from having some, doing these illegal activities. Something that we kind of brushed over is the municipal code updates gives us a bit more teeth, especially for repeat offenders. And I think that's a big part of what we face, that if I catch someone going, renting illegally,

1:03:17 We're roughly going to take about 30% of what they've collected. And that what's remaining, you know, you have a 70% is what's remaining they get to keep. So with these enhanced, you know, deterrents, I think when we start to really see these increased fines and penalties for refeed offenders, you're going to see that these enforcement cases should drop off. Additionally, I think that our registration numbers being a bit more unified.

1:03:47 Thank you so much.

1:04:16 Moving to the certified property, I keep saying program, what we're allowing property owners to do is once they have their number, they can then just take that number and partner with any property manager in town. There's no more registration, getting a TOT certificate with us. It's already done. It's done for the year. And that allows property owners kind of that flexibility of moving between property managers. And we know exactly where they go because that number is, there's only one number and it's easier to track.

1:04:46 I'd like to add to that a little bit because the premise of the system being built because we had big gaps in our collections before I think was a bit of a misnomer within the community. I think there was a lot of people that felt I heard, you know, as much as, oh, you guys aren't collecting 40% of the activity in town. And that, I'd say that's completely false. And we've said that for years now. I think our tools for enforcement

1:05:12 And for dragnet activities of identifying staff is pretty robust. People have, as Ben was trying to allude to there, people have had it land on their forehead and they're realizing the depth at which we can capture that stuff. I would say our focus and activity for this is more of a gap.

1:05:31 Created by technology. So as these online platforms have grown, people who own a property in town have now the ability to, I'm going to say, go into business for yourselves and rent your home, but they never really looked at it in that way, right? They thought, oh, I'm just going to make some extra cash. They didn't think of themselves as going into business. So we had property owners who were doing it.

1:05:57 But not necessarily realizing they're running a business. So all the expectations, all the licensure, all the requirements that are associated with that was lost on a lot of the business owners. And those were, you know, enforcement cases, right, often enough because they just didn't quite get that, oh gosh, I am doing business here. So what we didn't have as a community or as an organization was a connection to that property owner because a lot of things...

1:06:21 You know, they're run through either property management companies if they're legitimate or they may have not have been registered at all. So in this particular case, we are really, the main focus is connecting to that owner.

1:06:33 And so we now have a relationship with the owner. We never had that before if they were going through property agencies. So we can now reach out and have direct connections to them, direct communications to them, things like COVID that went on when we had closures and stuff like that. We can communicate because the ultimate responsible party for the activity and going on within their residence is the owner, irregardless of whether they have a property management company.

1:06:58 At the end of the day, when we're placing liens and we're going after things, it's with the owner of the property. So this gives us that direct connection. It gives us a way of reaching out to them and having a conversation. And then I saw anecdotally to that, the data collection from the statistical information is the other great benefit. So those are the two main things, I think, that happened there. But the enforcement's been strong for 10 years. Yeah, and I know I agree with you, Robert. There's been work, not only how much, but millions of dollars that was left on the table, et cetera. Two other quick questions. One is,

1:07:27 How is the certification going in terms of with people's properties inspections? And the reason I ask this question is because when this came out, there was a lot of discussion in regards to people being, oh, it's going to be more onerous. I've had no one come to me and say I've had an issue. It's been very quiet from that standpoint. So sometimes you infer that everything's good because no one's complaining. But I just want to make sure from that standpoint with people being able to get their inspections and going through that process.

1:07:55 Are we feeling good about that and feeling that people are able to accomplish that readily? That's a great question. As I alluded to, inspection requirements is a big aspect of what we've done. I believe we had roughly about 1,500 units that had never been inspected. Again, the idea being that I've been renting my property since 1984.

1:08:19 You know, I'm more or less grandfathered in. And with that update to the municipal code, we've closed that loop. This year we sent out about 750 inspection requirements to those units that have never been inspected. And I believe we're close, we're down to about 100 left that need to get it done. So there will be an effort to herd those people across the finish line. Though if they don't get their unit inspected, they don't get to rent.

1:08:49 So you might hear some grumblings at the end of the year when that happens. So that is possible. But the plan is to do 750 of the units that have never been inspected this year and about 750 of those units next year. And then that's going to clean up all of those units that we've never seen before. And then we're just going to re-inspect every four years as these inspections expire.

1:09:14 We did kind of do some easy updates to how we do these inspections, a little bit more clarity and something that briefly I want to add is that we are actually requiring a signature from the property owner, making sure that they understand the condition of their unit.

1:09:33 I'd like to add something to that, too. I'm not going to add to everything you say. Pardon us. This is probably near and dear to my heart. I'm going to say that out loud. The inspections that Ben was referencing isn't a town function, so it is a requirement to be an operator to have your property inspected. However, the inspectors themselves are third-party to the town. They're not town employees. They're their own businesses.

1:09:58 Ben has a list of those, and so when someone's seeking an opportunity to have their property inspected, you know, they can choose from the list, give that person a call, schedule. It's very similar to getting an appraisal in a house and those types of things. They're a specialized group that does that, but they are not town employees whatsoever, so. In the program, have we noticed any change in, call it sponsorship, where the individuals who are renting used to go with an agency and now they're doing it on their own?

1:10:29 I was worried that we would be pushing them to do this on their own. And I think as a town, we're better off if they're represented by a local group rather than individuals. Have we seen any change in this? Or will we be able to tell that as we move through this easily? I don't have that data offhand. Personally, I don't think that is the case. I think it's been business as usual for the last couple of years. Certainly, I think something we have noticed is that

1:10:57 The ability for people to move between property management a little bit quicker, kind of, it creates for a funny story where you just see this property sort of bouncing from property manager to property manager. We're seeing that a bit quicker than normal, but I would say on average it's 50-50 in the sense that a lot of people will open their own business to try it out.

1:11:23 And then they'll either choose to go to the property manager or not. But I wouldn't say there was much change. I could definitely do some research to see that, to confirm that, but I don't think so. The other question related to that would be, are we seeing some of those managers get certified to do the inspections on their own, and is that counter to what we're looking for, or is that allowable? Great question. Again, the certified property program...

1:11:51 The only person who can have a CP, as we affectionately call it, is a property owner. Businesses do not hold certificates for nightly rental. Only property owners have the ability to register their properties for nightly rentals. We do allow businesses to register for property owners on their behalf, but, you know, we do need to make sure that we have that direct connection to that property owner.

1:12:16 If something's going awry, if a property manager's not doing the right thing, we need to contact those owners immediately. So that's kind of the purpose there. So the real question there is, do we have property management companies that are in the business of inspecting the properties to get through their inspection? Or does that take a different... No, there's five approved property inspectors.

1:12:40 They either have to have a NACHI or an ICC certification or they've had to have been a general contractor with I think about five or ten years of experience or a combination of all three of those things. So to get onto that inspection list, you have to have those three things and then you also have to do an interview with either with Nolan and Tom and myself just to make sure that

1:13:08 These people are representing the community and we want to make sure that their health and safety standards are up to par. Brian, did you have a follow-up? I'm good. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions? I have a comment. I have a comment. Go ahead. Go ahead. Is it time for a comment? Yeah, it's fine because do we have to take public comments on it? Okay, so would it be now before John makes a comment? Is there any public comment on this item? Jamie, is there anyone online?

1:13:42 Okay, then I think it would be time for your comment, Council Member Wentworth. Just a quick look back on all this. This program came out of a moratorium that was declared by the Town Council at the time. It was a very difficult period. Measure L was one of the more immediate things that came out of this. But to see this program come out of this, I think as one Council Member, I think we've really moved into, we've established.

1:14:10 A model short-term rental program here in Mammoth Lakes. That was a very difficult period. You said some very nice things, astute things today about leadership in communities and what it takes to see something through, get it to the other side and see it implemented. And I think that the entire team here, I think we can pat ourselves a little bit on the back. So I think the results coming out of this were the kinds of things I was certainly hoping and expecting to see. So thank you. Well said. Thank you so much.

1:14:41 All right. So we are moving on to item 10.2. So this will be to discuss the $7.2 million funding request for Kingfisher II at the parcel. So this is also known as phase 2.2. Great. Thank you. As noted, this item is to discuss the $7.2 million request from Pacific West companies for the Kingfisher II.

1:15:14 I'm at the parcel. The parcel project, as we all know, is a key component of the Town's Housing Now effort. It is envisioned to be developed with up to 450 units of workforce housing at a range of AMIs and unit sizes. To assist in the development, the Town has partnered with Pacific West Companies through a disposition and development agreement to build out the project over multiple phases, and they sort of refer to that as the developer.

1:15:41 To date, the Sawyer or Phase 1 has been completed with 81 units and Kingfisher 1 is under construction with 76 units. Kingfisher 1 and Kingfisher 2 collectively make up Phase 2 of the project and will provide a total of 148 units. One thing to kind of highlight that's exciting is for anyone who hasn't driven through the parcel development in the last few weeks is all the mods for Kingfisher 1 have been set and the units have been dried in ahead of the snow.

1:16:10 So it's pretty exciting to just see that progress out there in that phase. The Kingfisher 2 project, the one we're discussing tonight, is the second sub-phase of phase 2 and is shovel-ready, meaning building permits are nearly ready to be issued should they receive funding. So currently Pacific has an application into the state for tax credits for approximately $36 million, amongst other funding sources also committed to that project.

1:16:37 This phase includes 72 units, consists of 15 studio units, 12 one-bedroom units, 27 two-bedroom units, and 18 three-bedroom units, with AMIs ranging from 30% to 80% AMI. Of those, 29 units will be for households with incomes less than or equal to 50% AMI, and 43 units will be for households with incomes above 50% AMI, with the average AMI being at 60%.

1:17:06 As we discussed, the item tonight is an informational item to discuss the request for the additional $7.2 million for the project, which the developers indicated is necessary to make their tax credit application competitive. The town previously committed $7.8 million for the entire Phase 2 project, in addition to a loan for the value of the land and impact fees. So the request tonight would be in addition to that $7.8 million.

1:17:36 Seems I got kicked out of Zoom, perhaps. Let's try this again.

1:18:33 I'm so used to having two screens when I'm on Zoom that I'm really not particularly efficient here. Okay, so, okay, thanks for your patience. A little delay, but thank you for having me. Big thank you, Nolan, for the presentation and his team for having me here today. Caleb Rube, CEO and President of Pacific Company, I believe, and available as we move forward through this presentation. This is...

1:19:17 Kind of an ask to be here, so I really appreciate us seeing the urgency here at this particular date. So I just want to give a big shout out to the partnership that we've had with Public Works, Planning, obviously City Manager's Office, but also just helping us get me here tonight to make this request in person. All right, so real quick, I'm going to do a quick overview of the parcel. I will not repeat anything that you've already heard or that you already know, but I do think it's important to level set a little bit.

1:19:48 Then I'll go through today's request and talk to you a little bit about how it compares or not to other projects, both in Mammoth and throughout the state, and then talk through what next steps could look like. I'm pretty informal. Feel free to interrupt if you'd like, if you have questions on anything that I'm talking about. But what you see here, you guys know the master plan behind. Nolan gave you a really good sort of baseline of where we are.

1:20:18 Almost 100% leased up. I think the lowest, I think we might have had one vacancy in this past month. So it's doing really great in our mind in that respect. The Kingfisher, those 76 units are all on site. I got to look at it today and you can see the image on the right was from last week. The homeowner, the Kingfisher 2 is what we're talking about today. That's the 72 units, which is in the green area in the northeast corner, the upper right.

1:20:46 I wanted to make sure it was your right as well. And then the homeownership phase is in the lower corner, and that's on pause indefinitely, but we did have about 36 to 48 units planned there at one point. Went through pre-development and planning applications, but it's on a pause. So with that, just a quick background. I won't go through everything on this slide, but the partnership has been going on since, you know, it was a 22-acre blank parcel. And so it's...

1:21:13 I mean, you should be so proud of what we've done here, but also the access apartments, all the things that you guys have done in regards to housing. It's been really tremendous to watch since 2019. I have 2020 up here, but really, I was here pre-COVID, and so that's the big, you know, I have that as the marker in my mind. We probably all do to some extent.

1:21:33 But we got the master plan adopted. We moved forward with the Sawyer. In the meantime, as Sawyer was being constructed through Epic Snow, through COVID, et cetera, we got Kingfisher entitled. We got the home ownership phase kicked off. We got Kingfisher funded and under construction. And now it looks like we're going to get Kingfisher II funded. And we've gotten the Sawyer fully leased up. So I think the development team, we, have a lot to really

1:22:02 Give ourselves kudos for. So with that said, I want to go through some sort of data points that Caleb and I have gone over. And it's taken us a bit to get this information to you, but it's definitely timely. This is a, I won't go through all the numbers, but at the end of the day, this is a budget to actuals. I'm having a little bit of a hard time seeing it because of the imagery, but.

1:22:31 Of the Sawyer, of the first 81 units. So, you know, the bottom line in bold is kind of the summary, right? Over budget. The percent change in the far right, and you'll see this slide similar for both Kingfisher I and then Kingfisher II, what we're projecting. But you can see those areas that are negative 100%.

1:22:52 I just want to be really clear, and Caleb can speak to this as well, that is 100% of the contractor overhead and profit went back into the project cost. 100% of the developer fee went back into the project cost. Those are the big ones because everything else you can see increased. Everything from impact fees, I mean, you guys felt it with the hockey rink. I mean, this is not news, but it is real.

1:23:20 So with that said, I mentioned this briefly, but I did want to talk a little bit about the operations of the Sawyer. It is complete. 62 households are currently on the wait list. The lowest occupancy rate in 2025 year-to-date has been 94%. That's very good. That's very, very good. There have been 10 move-outs since the beginning of this year. Of those 10, 5 of them, so 50% of them.

1:23:46 Our specifically high needs population that are receiving services through Mono County Health and Human Services, and they just needed additional supportive services. So that's a difficult population to serve. Pacific companies and I do a lot of these mixed income properties right now. The state's money is really focused there.

1:24:06 It is common to see a lot of turnover the first couple years of a project with this particular population, finding folks that can live independently on their own with the services that are provided here. Two, couldn't afford the rent. One person left the region, one person had medical issues, and there was one other that didn't explain in a meaningful way. So I just wanted to set that stage for how the Sawyer is doing. Kingfisher II, under construction, we're really excited about that. Sorry, can I ask a question in regards?

1:24:35 Please, Councilmember. And we're still requiring that they have to meet AMI requirements each year? They have to get recertified each year in order to stay there? They get recertified each year. There's different rules at how much, how high their AMI can go. I don't believe the federal requirements require people to be kicked out when they go higher. I do think it's a policy that when people get to a certain income, they are...

1:25:04 We're asked to leave. That has not happened as far as I know here. Does that answer your question? Yeah, that's actually great. The heart of the question is because people are concerned that if they all of a sudden got a promotion or something, all of a sudden got kicked out of the facility because they all of a sudden were making more money. Sheldon, they have to go up to 140% of median before we can even ask. And so it's a big jump from current levels to where they actually get asked. And then technically they can't even be.

1:25:33 Evicted for that reason. If we had a mixed income project with market rate units, then theoretically what happens is the market rate unit would become a market rate unit, that previously affordable unit, and then the market rate unit would convert to affordable by law. But we do not have that since it's 100% affordable. May I ask you a question? I see you said there are 62 households on the wait list. Is that from your original list?

1:26:00 For the project that you filled from or is this a secondary wait list? I know you started a wait list or an interest list when we were constructing the project and I believe it was like hundreds of people on the list. Is that that list has now been whittled down to this 62 households on the wait list or did you start a new list? I would have to confirm.

1:26:26 We didn't get through everybody on the initial interest list because there were so many hundreds of people. So I suspect these are folks that were interested and on the list and then did some level of income qualification and are still interested but didn't get, they were either, we only had 30% units open or we only had 80% units and they didn't fit into the 80 or they, so that's what happens, right? You get folks in, you've got certain units open, they have too big of a household, too small of a household.

1:26:55 Aren't fitting the AMI. So I can confirm that and follow up to make sure. But the interest list was started, there was like a few of them going on, I think, as part of the challenge with the Sawyer. So I don't know that that list is particularly important at this juncture because it's so old. Okay, thank you. I think it started in 2020. I mean, Sheldon, these folks would be all people that would move into Kingfisher.

1:27:23 Because there would be something probably available for them, you know, when that project got completed. Yes. But we haven't started an interest list for Kingfisher yet, and Kayla's looking at me, why am I talking about this? It's important because it really took a lot of effort and energy because we learned, and we learned a lot, but we learned that starting an interest list two years before opening or a year and a half before opening is just simply too soon. Buckingham does this for, this is their industry. It's...

1:27:51 It only works when people know when they can move in. Otherwise, they are giving notice and having to go back in and there's delays. And so we really want to stay away from doing that this time around. So I want to be really clear it's not for the Kingfisher yet. Does that answer your question? Yeah, I mean, I was just wondering if that's, you know, everyone who's interested that you have 62 people on a wait list. Yeah, I can find out.

1:28:21 So this is a similar slide for the Kingfisher, the first phase, the 76 units that you see going up now. Again, we've done better in the black. I mean, you all know this. You have incredibly high cost.

1:28:39 Construction season is complicated and difficult, but again, there's a substantial percent change from budget to actual. A lot of that is the things I talked about in your staff report or that made it into your staff report in the memo, which is interest rates, equity pricing, things in the marketplace that nobody has any control over. But at the end of the day, that project is, you know, slightly over budget and you can see those percent changes of items that are going back into the project.

1:29:09 Again, contractor overhead and profit and developer fee. Now, that could get better over time. We should see. Caleb, do you want to add anything to that? No, I mean, it's just the reality of where we are now. I mean, we're trying to improve it. We're trying to become more efficient, trying to figure out, you know, try to increase the subcontractor base. The more activity you have in place, you know, you get the chance to have more people interested. You know, the market is...

1:29:38 Sort of, you know, cross the stage somewhat slower right now. Reno still was doing well, so, you know, it just has been hard to bring people to Mammoth, just like it always is. I mean, it's, our concrete podiums were built out of the Bay Area, subcontractor base, so just to give you a data point, and that would be the case again. So it's a challenge. Just, it always is.

1:30:04 So what I'm here to talk to you about tonight, Nolan gave a really good overview. This is 72 units in the upper right hand. It's a little confusing because I used gray, but the area in the back is building B, so phase two will include that podium unit with the surface parking around it to the outside of the site, coupled with the more passive open space. This is not like the public park that exists today.

1:30:32 Over in front of the Sawyer. It's a much more passive design. So I just wanted to remind you what we're actually talking about. And then again, this budget to estimated actuals. And Kayla and I got into it a little bit in a very friendly way. But I was like, how could this have changed from budget to actual knowing we just submitted in September? And so it's not that it has changed.

1:30:59 We max, and Caleb could probably explain it better than I, but this budget column should really be called application maximum. So we've maxed out what we can ask for from the state, and your costs are higher. So in maxing that out, we know that we are kind of under budget, which is why we had asked for additional money back in June, knowing that it looks like we might actually get funded, which I can talk about in a minute, but knowing that it looks like we might actually get funded.

1:31:28 We're looking at it going, okay, this is under budget from day one. We can't do this again. This is the percent that we believe has changed on the far right, and this is the reason why we're asking for additional funds. So I know I don't want to be, I love coming to Mammoth. I don't want to be here asking, but it is the reality of what the situation is, to Caleb's point.

1:31:52 So again, we're requesting, I think you saw in your staff report, $7.2 million from the town of Mammoth Lakes for the 72 units. That's basically an additional $100,000 a door in addition to the deferred developer fees that have already been committed as well as the appraised land value that's already been committed. We're using that to leverage this $42 million that we believe will be awarded by the state in tax credits, bonds, and state tax credits.

1:32:19 As you may have seen in the staff report, I think it's very, I didn't break out the 42 million, but it's from those three sources. Again, federal credits, state credits, tax-exempt bonds. Those state credits will not be, there will not be very many of them in the future, or at least in 2026 and likely 2027. So that's an incredibly valuable source of gap financing that we don't believe we'll have access to, coupled with some different industry changes. There's an old saying,

1:32:48 In development, it was never cheaper to develop yesterday. You know, it's always going to be cheaper to develop yesterday than it will be tomorrow. So that's the situation that we're looking at. Again, we've still got HCD funding, we've got land and fees, and then we have these B bonds developer fee equity, as well as this additional request making up the maximum. And again, in your staff report, I outlined a way.

1:33:12 To make the $7.2 million request over time at particular milestones. Obviously a closing would be the land and fees. That's no money out of pocket. That's just a lien on the property. Then maybe grading completion in a year, construction completion, and then permanent loan conversion. Those, you know, 30%-ish numbers of the $7.2 million appallit cash loan, for lack of better words, we're requesting.

1:33:40 So it's a commitment now, but it would come over time. And so I think it's important, and this is really Caleb's point, is it's important to see where we are in relationship to the state of California and in relationship to the town. And so we went back and drew some data that was available. This is other 4% tax credit projects that have been funded in the rural set-aside or the rural pool that we are competing in.

1:34:10 So you can see the names of the cities there, the number of units, the total cost per unit, and the subsidy per unit. So this is the scenario that you see on the bottom line is assuming there's a $7.2 million additional subsidy to phase two. So you can see here our tiebreaker is very low, and that is not assuming the additional $7.2 million, I should be clear. Our unit count, it's just sort of like in the range of

1:34:38 It's meaningful. It's definitely higher than the average total cost per unit. I mean, as unique as Mammoth is in so many ways, it's really expensive to build, as you can see. Scotts Valley is, you know, well over. Other places are a little bit under. But we're in the running, I would say. We're not totally out of reasonableness. And then the subsidy per unit is also very much in the running, just a little bit less of sort of the average of 20-25s.

1:35:08 Competition. So I wanted to put that in perspective because it feels like a big ask, but it is really what it takes to develop affordable housing in the state right now. And so what does that look like in Mammoth? I just went through online and looked at the publicly available information on the great projects that you guys are doing, and that includes the homeownership, permanent supportive housing at Innsbruck, the access apartments, which are, you know, middle income or

1:35:35 And you can see that our total support in the yellow box, I should say, the total support is still substantially less than what you average supporting other projects. So that's just a fact. That's not a concern or anything else. I just want to put it in perspective that this is how much it takes.

1:36:05 to develop in this town. We're not an anomaly one way or another. I think what the anomaly was is this number here in phase one of the Sawyer, and we showed you why that doesn't work. So Kingfisher, just the schedule. If we do get funded in this round, we've got a preliminary

1:36:29 We've got a preliminary scoring letter last week. The process typically goes, there could always be changes, but typically you get a preliminary scoring letter if you don't have any concerns with it, which we didn't. We would get notice that we get funding, you know, two to three weeks before their meeting where they award. They're scheduled, meaning SIDLAC and TCAC, they're scheduled to award on November 19th at their next meeting.

1:36:52 They have given some inclination. They had a record number of applications this year. They've given some inclination that they may move that November 19th meeting back to December, but given that we've got a scoring letter and given that we are in the rural set-aside, which is one of the state's highest priorities, we don't believe, it doesn't seem, we don't seem to think that it'll get delayed to that extent.

1:37:17 We, I mean, I think Caleb would agree, we're not in a position to be able to accept that $40 million of state funds without additional gap funding. If we were to get the additional gap funding, we would be required to start construction 180 days after that award, assuming that award is in November, that would bring us to May. We would be required to be able to start construction then. We would hope to do that. We're practically at building permits. We'd also hope to have a two-year construction period, and we would try to lease up within.

1:37:48 Three to six months after that. We know things change and things happen, but that is where we are today. So my understanding from next steps would be that we would ask you to take action on this request in November. And with that action, we would be requesting a commitment letter, like just a pretty simple one-page commitment letter that we could help use to find our equity and debt to move the project forward.

1:38:19 So I went through a lot of numbers quickly. I don't know if you have any additional questions for Caleb or I, but we're happy to stand for them. I've got a couple questions. Just going back to, you said you might are able to talk about the funding. You got a pre-letter. What does that indicate to you in terms of that that $40 million might be forthcoming as a funding allocation for this?

1:38:48 It indicates to us that we will be getting it. And I just want to be really clear, of the 149 applications that were submitted across the state, we were by far the lowest tiebreaker score. Meaning, the tiebreaker score is basically, it's kind of an efficiency of how much public dollar, or how much money you're using that's not state money. You know, that's what they are prioritizing.

1:39:15 I think we were either the lowest of the 149 applications or maybe there was one lower than us. The reason that this project would ever rise to the top, we've gone through five or six rounds and it's never gotten funding. Again, the reason why we asked for it in June and then let it sit, because we just didn't really think it would get funded, is because there's a huge, the state allowed a lot of bonds to be put back into the pool last round.

1:39:44 And that has helped sort of clean up and clear up the pipeline, if you will, for rural projects. But there's just not a lot of large rural projects that are doing this right now. They got funded in the last couple rounds. So it's really a little bit of luck. And I will say I work with other developers around the state, but the Pacific Companies is probably the best at just continuing to throw the wet noodle at the wall, and it'll eventually stick. It just takes a little luck. It takes a lot of skill.

1:40:12 It's just a lot about timing and what else has moved through the pipeline and what drops off because they, you know, the developer can't figure it out or they lose the land or the money goes away or whatever the reason is. So, Caleb, I don't know if you want to add anything to that? No, I mean, we continued, we got like second place a couple times in the points, so points are first and we've just been getting beat by one lower cost project every time. We're in a high resource area, which means

1:40:41 It scores the maximum points, you know, one point more than most other applications in the state, but the problem is, is there's not much money in the rules set aside, so we've been getting beat. And this time, with the additional bonds that the federal tax law change produced, as well as some return of bonds for developers that couldn't make projects work, there was more money than usual in the rural area, and so we were able to get in there and get those precious state credits as well, was a huge...

1:41:10 You know, benefit to the project. That was like 14 million in state credits, which translates to about 10 or 12 million in subsidy for the project. So it was, you know, and within the scoring letter we got, which basically says, you've scored all your points and you've met your threshold requirements. And so they're essentially notifying us ahead of time that the application is being reviewed and considered for formal award at the November or December meeting, whichever they choose.

1:41:39 And so whenever you get a scoring letter, it's 95% probability or greater that you're going to actually get an award at the meeting when they have it. And then just one more in terms of hypothetically, if, for instance, you're saying that it's based on 60% AMI for this project, if that was a higher AMI, would that impact that potential to get award state funding or would that not impact that so much?

1:42:09 Yeah, we can't go above an average of 60. So we have units all the way up to 80 in this project and all the way down to 30. But we have to average 60 to qualify for the federal credit. If that average goes above that, we no longer are a tax credit qualifying project. So we would not be eligible. Actually, what the state favors in the program is deeper targeting.

1:42:34 of average affordability. So, for example, many projects, if we were deeper targeting at 40% AMI, we'd actually score better in the competition, have a better tiebreaker than that low tiebreaker Shelyn showed you. So, you know, the state kind of rewards deeper targeting, which also makes it hard because in Mammoth, I mean, we definitely have a lot more than normal

1:43:02 Residents that attempt to apply and they, you know, they're over income, even at the 80% level. So we're really trying to figure out how to do more, you know, higher income units and make that a priority for as many phases as we can going forward after we finish the Kingfisher phases. All the units are needed and in demand, don't get me wrong, but there is a, you know, an unusually higher ratio of over income applicants than we typically see in rural areas.

1:43:33 But not particularly unique to high amenity resort communities. Yeah. Rucky, we've seen it too. Same situation. Can I ask you, what's your cost per square foot to build here? So it varies, but I can say it's probably pushing about, you know, between 600 and 700 a square foot, is my guess.

1:44:02 That does include, you know, kind of, if you net out the developer fees that we're allowed to put into the project's budget to generate additional tax credits. In her presentation, she's showing you the net amount that we get paid. So if you were to take that out, it probably drops into the high fives, I would say, kind of as a baseline. I mean, the Kingfisher II budget right now is...

1:44:30 Essentially going to end up probably in the high fives to low sixes at the end of the day based on actual costs we've been able to determine. So how does that ferret out then with the fact that you are doing the pre-builds? So I thought the whole idea of the prefab was to bring that square foot cost way down. 600 to 800 a square foot is what regular stick construction in Mammoth is costing already. Where is the savings coming from the prefab?

1:44:59 Construction then. I'm a little confused there. Thank you. Yeah, it's okay. Go ahead, John. You want to answer? Well, I was going to just give you the quick answer because it's a very good question that I get asked a lot and then I would give it over to Caleb if you want more details. But the quick answer is that modular does not save money. And I don't think many people these days, now that we're learning a lot more about it, would argue that it does. But what it does save is time.

1:45:27 And it is critical. I think it's critical in this type of building area where you have very small building windows to save that time. It also helps when you have limited labor. Caleb can go into a lot more detail, but at the end of the day, I don't know that modular is particularly less expensive than stick-built in a lot of markets. And I would just say for this market,

1:45:55 You know, depending on what kind of spec level you're talking about. We also are paying state prevailing wages, which is something that's different than probably the projects, you know, you might be talking about that are market-based. And those wage rates definitely increase the cost artificially. Just to give you a baseline, the modular component of a project is about 40%, meaning like what the factory, you know, for cost, transportation, shipping, all that, sales tax is about 40% of the budget.

1:46:25 And the remainder is effectively on-site construction, concrete site completion, all the things you would normally think of, siding, et cetera. So there is a meaningful component that's external as well. Are you paying prevailing to the people building the modular? No, not in the factory. We don't have to pay prevailing for that. It's just for the on-site activities. Anybody showing up on-site would have to pay prevailing. We'd have to pay prevailing wages.

1:46:57 I have some questions, Madam Mayor? Yeah, go ahead. So, first, I want to just thank you all for the contributions you're making. Seeing it on the chart, appreciate that, and thank you. A couple sort of maybe obvious questions. In the presentation, you mentioned a soft loan. What is a soft loan?

1:47:17 Thank you, Councilmember. It's a good question. Thanks for calling me. I use a lot of the lingo and sometimes don't realize I'm using it. Soft loan generally is what the town has given on the other phases, which is a longer term, but below market rate, and it's paid based on residual receipts. So it's paid back annually based on the project's cash flow, and that is how at the state level, that is how they determine whether or not it gets to count towards your tiebreaker.

1:47:44 Okay. So if it is a hard loan, like your mortgage, it will not count as sort of, it will not give you the benefit of local subsidy, and the project can't afford it. So it's like it's a private loan, basically? It's a public loan at the low market rates, and it gets paid back based on the project's annual cash flow. But it has to be said, in fairness, it doesn't always get paid back. Absolutely. Because sometimes there are no residual receipts. Right. Isn't that usually what happens?

1:48:10 I would say generally, yes. That's generally how it goes, that the entire loan does not get paid back. I would say generally that's how it goes. The entire loan does not get paid back in the first 15 years. Upon refinancing, it could. Okay. Do you think that's fair, Caleb? You have more experience. Yeah, I mean, it depends on the amount. So, I mean, to Andy's point, I would say in this case, you know, at a 15-year event, that that repayment is unlikely, okay, in full.

1:48:39 What is true is that when that does happen, the town is at the table as a lender to consent to any refinance or any other structure of the project. As a lender, they have rights that are unusual to the grant situation or something else. But in the rural areas, because the incomes are not as high, I would say it's more likely than not that the loans don't get paid off.

1:49:04 I mean, Andy would know this. We had one in Truckee where it wasn't one of our projects, but the town actually did get paid off on their home loan, and then they used that home loan to support a new project of ours. So it happens, but I would say it's more rare than common. Okay, so on the question of risk and where we're at in this funding cycle with decisions having to be made relatively quickly, if the town and the council are not making a decision tonight, to be clear, I'm just kind of gaming some scenarios out.

1:49:32 If the council in the town would eventually say, you know what, we don't want to pursue this, is it at that point for Pacific and for future phases of the parcel a no harm, no foul situation? Because I'm thinking that it's much riskier if you were to make a representation to the state, yeah, we want to accept the $40 million without having secured a commitment from the town. That's the risky situation. It's a black mark on credit.

1:50:02 Do I have that right? Yes, you have that right. That's correct. Okay. All right. So we're all talking. No one's made any decisions yet. And then, so the decision point, we've talked about that, November 5th, currently now, that's what it's scheduled in terms of our agendas and things like that. In terms of the things that you've talked about,

1:50:30 Which we've talked about building in Mammoth. Obviously, the big winner was a challenge. But the issues of subs, the issues of being able to work more efficiently. Is this something, Caleb, probably to both of you, is this something that you think we can actually solve for? Or do you think the conditions that you're seeing with the Sawyer and Kingfisher One are just the nature of doing business and building in Mammoth Lakes? Do you anticipate getting to any more efficiencies down the road?

1:50:57 You know, I do in the sense of like the infrastructure is now all completed. That's a big factor. You know, future phases are not going to be burdened with that. There's, you know, there's obviously, you know, more phases equals more attention from a subcontractor base. The thing that works against this potentially is if the market heats up and we can't, we can no longer attract, let's say, from...

1:51:23 The external areas of the state to Mammoth anymore. That's a risk we would have to face. Interest rates obviously are a risk. But, you know, at the end of the day, you can kind of see what it's taking in the state of California to build projects in rural areas and building projects in general. A lot of other policy issues are kind of coming on top of these projects to make them cost more expensive. And so whether it's climate change related things or other policies the state has to pay for vainly wages, those impact the project.

1:51:51 The other thing I would just say is that, you know, the state also is fully aware of the need for this gap financing, because what really we're talking about tonight from the town is gap financing. How do you fill the gap between, you know, the project costs and what the property can support on a permanent mortgage basis and these tax credits, which the tax credits, by the way, now, the federal tax credits are going to be a lot easier to get.

1:52:17 than they have been in years past because of the tax law change that just happened at the federal level. It effectively doubled the amount of projects that can be funded with the federal tax credit. And so that's a positive thing that's happened, but there's still this gap that exists, and the state is working on, there's a bill currently at the legislature, which will probably get moved when the session resumes, of a $10 billion, probably will go down to about a $6 billion affordable housing bond.

1:52:45 And as you might recall, in many past projects we've done, we've been able to access those state resources to fund projects in rural areas. The reality is, is those resources have ran out, and they need to be replenished, and that's the idea behind a state bond. So there's kind of multiple ways to get there, you know, in the future, let's say, you know, next year, year after. But for now, there are no gap financing sources really out there, and so hence the help from the town that we're asking for.

1:53:12 Okay, so another question, we sort of flirted with this discussion about the waiting list, and I hear you, I mean, we've gone through that experience, we know what that's all about. It would be helpful to get some representation from the town as to where we're at from the need perspective. Going back, we don't have to answer that now, but just, you know, what we're looking at in terms of what the need is. I'm hearing from constituents.

1:53:40 Hey, this is great, but Caleb, as you said, it's not, we're not in the sweet spot for the overall, the Housing Now program over the long term. This is a key sector, it's an important thing to be filling, but the sweet spot is 80 to 200. And so that's, it would be good to get some kind of representation from staff, not now, but that might help inform this decision as we go forward.

1:54:08 And the scoring letter, when did you guys get that? Was that in May or June? No, just the other day. You know the exact date of that? I feel like it was last Thursday. They're just putting them out. I mean, the applications were due, you know, a few weeks ago, maybe a month ago, and they're scoring applications. So we just got that literally in the past 10 days. Okay. And so you talked about the average AMI of what – do you know what the average AMI of the Sawyer –

1:54:38 Okay, so that, you've hit a number, but is that number, if it's 60%, is that actually, is that actually the,

1:55:09 Is it lower than that? I mean, can it be lower than that? It can only be lower. It can't be higher. And so, you know, that's where that one averages is 60%. And any tax credit project, you know, if we're going to access those federal credits, would also have to average 60%. And so the range...

1:55:28 The range basically is from 30 to 80 is sort of the range. You can go all the way up to 80 before you really, you can't exceed 80% under any circumstances. I'll just kind of repeat the question. The people, what is in there right now, is it below 60? Yeah, the average I couldn't tell you, but what I could say is that for every level of income there would be there, which would be 30, 50, 60, and 80.

1:55:52 All of those units would be filled by people making at that number or below as of the time they moved in. Could they have made more money and still be living there? Yes, that could have happened, like people's incomes could have went up. But usually, I mean, you have to qualify being at the level or below based on household size. Okay. I'm done. Thank you. Okay. Good questions, John. Thank you. So in the absence of this funding, are you all able to keep building out the parcel?

1:56:22 Well, absent funding from somewhere, we are not. I mean, you can see kind of how we've operated and the other slides show that. I mean, we get behind a project, we commit to it, we've lost money building these first two phases. We'll try to recover everything we can, but as of now, we're down. And so going forward, it's like, hey, we just can't keep doing this.

1:56:52 You know, on an ongoing basis. And we're trying to, you know, make the future phases, and now that we kind of have all the data sets and know what our realities are and costs and everything else, we're trying to set up the future phases for success. And so, you know, going forward, we probably, just as a baseline, to do a tax credit rental unit, we probably need an average of about $100,000.

1:57:18 Per unit to make projects work using tax credit financing. If you go above tax credit financing and say go above 80, the subsidy likely would go up because you lose all those federal tax credits going forward because you don't qualify anymore as a, you know, like you can see that from your numbers, right, from your various projects that you guys have done kind of independently, the subsidy you actually need to do those projects is greater because you do lose those federal credits. Even though you're making more money in rent,

1:57:47 And can have a higher loan, you lose, you know, millions of dollars of federal credit support to make it work. So, you know, higher AMI levels generate a need for more subsidy per unit until you get to a point where you start running into maybe a for sale project, which is something we need to focus on as well, where you start generating sales prices enough to cover your unit costs.

1:58:12 In which case, you know, you sort of get back to more of a lower subsidy amount potentially going forward. So, I mean, in this home ownership one you have there, that was, you know, pretty high at $195, but depending on what you sell the homes at and all that, you could see a lower subsidy amount in those situations. And then my question, I guess I'm just observing your Kingfisher I, the project cost is $44 million for 76 units, and now we're looking at

1:58:42 Kingfisher 2, it's 56 million for 72 units. So it's four fewer units and $12 million more. Yeah, the big delta there, what you're seeing missing from the costs of the Kingfisher 1 are what are otherwise normal contractor fees and developer fees that would be paid. And so you'd add those back in. I mean, these actual costs are basically absent any

1:59:10 You know, any contractor fees or developer fees or, you know, of the like as part of the project budget, whereas the Kingfisher 2 does have those things included as if they would be paid. And then the other thing about Kingfisher 2, just to know, is that's a podium construction, so the concrete podium deck itself and that structure is pretty expensive, whereas the Kingfisher 1 is tuck under parking underneath garden style walk-up buildings, so there's just a lower cost structure associated with

1:59:39 With those type of apartments based on the construction type. Okay. Thank you for that. Can I just kind of clarify, like, what were the expectations from the start for, you know, the town's portion? Oh, and then I had one other question that slipped my mind that I just want to say so I don't forget. Will you be recuperating your developer's fees that you so far have put into the project?

2:00:06 Over the year before any loans get paid back or? No, we pretty much when, you know, the cash flow that we generate from the project, you know, has a bunch of rules attached to it. So, you know, we have to split it with the town. Our deferred developer fees do have priority in the cash flow waterfall generally. I don't remember how these are set up, but cash flow from the property is just.

2:00:32 You know, deferred developer fees, which we're supposed to try to collect through cash flow. It's just cash flow by another name. So you would collect cash flow, you would collect deferred developer fees either way. But we will not, you know, largely be getting these back. These amounts might have some senior priority of repayment over, let's say, the town's loans in the documents. So there might be a little bit generated there. So over the course of 15 years, maybe, you know, maybe $400,000 of that would get recuperated or something like that.

2:01:02 The short answer is no, not from the project's financing sources in either case. Okay. Thank you. Yeah. Are those all your questions? No, I had the other question that you didn't answer yet, but I've forgotten it, so do you remember it? Councilmember, your other question was what were our expectations at the beginning? Yes. And it's a very fair question, and nobody's got a crystal ball. So, you know, in 2019,

2:01:30 We had a community approved plan that was not adopted. We went through the process of master planning that was a bunch of pre-development costs. And the world has changed substantially. So there was always, there has not been a time in my career, and I've been in low income housing tax credit development since the early 2000s, that you've been able to do these regularly without

2:01:58 Additional sources of funds. Now, whether that's from the town or you could use state funds, there was a time when you could just get some home funds or some CDBG funds and use tax credits and it would all work. But that is not the case now as you see from the numbers from across the state. So I think the short story is there was never a clear request in the DDA. It's always been understood that it would include deferred impact fees and deferred land value, which, you know.

2:02:24 Almost any project that I've worked in California does that. And what the additional gap would be is what we've been asking for over the years, right? It's just what we've thought is needed. And then with interest rates and equity pricing and all these other things, it just changes. Caleb, you might have a better response, but at the end of the day. No, I think it's accurate. I mean, it's always a, you know, we take these projects on.

2:02:50 And the landscape, obviously in a multi-phase, multi-year project, it's way more challenging to figure out because you've got so many phases to do. But we try our best to get as much money as we can from the state or any other source that we can. And in fact, in the next phase of this Kingfisher project, we've been able to source another big chunk from private sources to come into this project.

2:03:18 We're trying our best to close the gap any way we can, but the costs are the reality of where we are, and we're going to continue to try to look everywhere we can. What I don't want to do is I don't want to take down an award from the state, and then we've never turned an award back ever, and we've always executed on everything, even if we've lost money, and so that's why you see these first two phases actually happening, because when we figure out our costs, we're just

2:03:47 We're committed to the project, the lenders and investors, and our credit is all behind it. So what we're trying to do is not get in the situation yet again with the third phase and be at risk like this. And so we're trying to shore it up now and set the course for the future as well so we don't end up subsidizing these projects that we're building. Okay. And then one other question. Sorry.

2:04:14 When the Kingfisher was one project, before you split it into two projects, and the town committed $7.8 million, was that initially understood to be for the whole Kingfisher project, or was that always intended to be for the first phase of the Kingfisher project? No, that was understood to be for the whole phase, and I can tell you why the shift.

2:04:43 We were not competitive and not winning the competition for the credit. So we moved the whole contribution into the first phase so that the first phase could have a chance to get funded at all. And so that money was there to kind of improve our competitiveness. And basically what it amounted to is we were asking for state tax credits.

2:05:08 And, you know, we had to lower, because part of the way the state judges the applications who's going to be successful in this tiebreaker is they count the bonds you're requesting and they count the state tax credits. Those are the two resources they count relative to the public benefit you're delivering. So our state tax credit ask had to be reduced substantially so that we would then be competitive enough to win. And your gap money for the whole project essentially allowed us to lower that request for state credits.

2:05:37 For that first phase. And that's the only way, actually, that the first phase is even off the deck right now. Otherwise, we'd still be stuck. And if I may add, that was a discussion that was had, you know, with staff very much at the time of we've gone in twice with 148 units. We don't have a chance. I mean, we like didn't have a chance. We kind of went in knowing we didn't really have a chance, but that's kind of all we could do.

2:06:05 And how do you feel if we put it all and go for it with getting at least something in the ground? So that was a discussion that was had. It was, you know, quite a while ago now. And then we would just, we just got that, you know, phase two was always designed to be flexible enough to be able to phase it. You know, so it was not like unknown that we were ever thinking of it phasing it. It was really just about how we could make it competitive to get it started.

2:06:36 So I think that answers your question, but it was quite a few years ago now, and a lot of, you know, a lot's changed. Thank you. Questions? Questions? Any more questions? Good, thank you. Okay, so my only question, because I think there were a lot of excellent questions brought up, is, so I just want to clarify that if we don't go forward and request that staff brings to us at the next meeting this

2:07:07 Thank you. Thank you.

2:07:29 But since at the end of the year, they don't like that because then they can't figure out how to allocate the money to another project in time and do all the work, the paperwork to get it approved. So we really want to tell staff, you know, by the time the meeting comes around, hey, we're not taking this award or we are taking this award. If we're taking the award, we don't do anything. But if we're not taking the award, we withdraw the application. Then they don't actually approve it. Understood.

2:07:56 Obviously, that would be not optimal for your reputation, but would that also impact the town's reputation? You know, as much as I might like to say it would, for reasons of incentivizing you, I'm compelled to just tell you how it is, like I always do, which is that the state doesn't really look at that kind of stuff, at the tax credit.

2:08:21 Agencies, they're not really studying that. Now, if this was HCD or one of the other gap financing sources that the state runs, yeah. I'd say if the town was an applicant, a co-applicant or in the application structure, then yes, that would be a problem. But when we submitted this application, we didn't include any of these resources in the application.

2:08:43 So it wouldn't be like the town's revoking their commitment, and that's causing us to have to withdraw the application. You know, in that case, I think it would be fair to say the town's reputation might be stained a little bit from reneging on a financing commitment, but since you haven't made one, no such commitment exists, and I don't see any reputational risk for the town. Thank you. And then the last question is, if you withdraw the application, what does the future look like for Phase 2B of the Kingfisher?

2:09:14 We would have to sit there probably and wait for, you know, the next opportunity. If the state passes a bond, let's say they pass a bond in 2026, those monies would start to flow potentially 2027 with applications, etc. You know, we'd have to obviously just study, you know, is there any other gap financing sources out there that we could get that really isn't, but other than the bond. So that would be kind of, we'd be on pause for a couple years probably.

2:09:44 Thank you. So, Shelly, did you have something to add? I did, if you don't mind. Caleb, you might be prepared to speak to this. I'm not sure. The IIG monies are one.

2:10:14 That we... Sorry, what's that acronym? Sorry. Infill Infrastructure Grant. Is that state or federal? That's state. That's the HCD money. I don't think it would affect the reputation at all. I didn't want to go there as much as it... There are only certain things that IAG can pay for, and I've worked very closely with Hayes on this. It's public infrastructure and the podium parking related to affordable units.

2:10:40 So we didn't have a lot of, we had a ton of IIG to spend for the Sawyer, right, because it was a vacant site, needed a bunch of infrastructure. We did not, and it had podium parking. We did not have that much IIG funds for Kingfisher I, because it's not podium, and the roads were built. Kingfisher II, we do have IIG funds available. Those have an end date, a by-spend date of, I think it's late, I think it's July 2027.

2:11:07 We've got some time there, but those are a very valuable source of funds that if we don't get them from HCD, we have to get them from elsewhere that would help fund, that do help fund Kingfisher II currently that we would be at risk of perhaps losing if we can't make something happen. Just to clarify that, so if we don't build Kingfisher II by whatever that end date is on those infill grant funds, is a town going to be obligated to repay money back to the state?

2:11:38 There will be some repayment probably if we didn't build two. So just to recap quick on this, and I don't have the exact data, but I can just give you a good recap for your policy thoughts. We've got about $20 million award, and roughly about $10 million of that would be considered spent, including $3.6 million on this current phase we're talking about here where we're talking about whether to accept this award or not.

2:12:04 The total deal with the state is deliver roughly 400 units. It's a little more than that, but it's roughly 400 units for $20 million. So if we, let's say, only deliver half that amount, then we have to essentially surrender the award for the other 10. And I haven't done the math, but there could be a little bit of obligation there. I mean, it would be meaningful obligation if we didn't do this final phase of Kingfisher.

2:12:33 But, you know, there would be potentially some payback that would be needed to occur with the money that has been drawn and has been spent of that infill infrastructure grant. It's not a huge number. I mean, it's not like five million or anything, but is it a million or two? Yeah, it probably is somewhere in that range. Okay, so could just, I think the council would need to, either from you guys or from staff, along with that need number, but would whatever the analysis of what that looks like, that would be helpful.

2:13:02 Okay, we can prepare that for staff's review. That would be great. Thank you. Thank you. All right. I think those are all my questions. I don't see any additional questions from Council. Is there any public comment on this item? No one online? Okay. So then it's really just us giving you feedback on what we'd like to see for the next meeting, correct? So discussion. Who would like to go first?

2:13:32 You know, it's already set up. Bring it back to the November 5 meeting with a packet that goes through all the different profit and loss pieces of this, and we have staff that are very good at that. Okay. I just come back to Rob, is that what you're looking for, exactly what Bill just stated? Is that the kind of direction you're looking for, or do we need to do anything differently? I think what I've heard tonight, the collective discussion, is going to help me, and we are certainly in contact with Shell and Caleb.

2:14:01 In the discussion, I think we can bring back staff reports that support what we're hearing. I think I'm comfortable. I would concur with Bill. Okay. I just want to make sure that the other council members, anything you want to add specifically, sir? No, I think all the questions are relevant. I don't think we're going to make any summary or representation of the questions that you've heard, but I think you guys get together and talk and we'll see what happens in November. Anything else to add? That's fine. We don't have to deliberate. Okay.

2:14:32 Just making sure, and Caleb and Chellin, thank you for bringing this to our attention and making yourselves available. I guess we will see you all at the next meeting. Yes, thank you guys very much. Have a good night. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Caleb. Thank you, Chellin. One note to add. Councilmember Wentworth's question about the needs. We will, at the November 5th meeting, be having the consultant on our housing needs assessment, providing a draft summary of the

2:15:00 The needs assessment results and the survey results. Perfect. Okay. Great. Well, if I could, I would, it would be difficult, it would be a challenge for council to get that information at the same time that we're considering this. So those numbers coming out, that needs assessment, if we could get those in advance. When do we get them? The Thursday before? Yeah, we can definitely share them out once we have them. I have not seen them yet, those results, but once we do get them, I believe we have a meeting,

2:15:30 When we have the next meeting with that group, but I'll get the exact date when it was to hopefully share out. I would imagine there's some analysis that goes, I think some analysis that's germane this project and this item, and I don't think we're not going to be positioned to try to do that type of analysis on the fly. So I'd like, I would think it'd be important to staff to do that analysis based on those numbers, right? Yes, that's what we intend to have in the staff report. Great, okay, thank you. And then I would imagine in terms of the agenda order, that item would come for

2:16:00 Correct. That will be a presentation item. Okay. Great. Thank you. Thank you very much for helping inform us so we can have some time to talk about this before we vote. All right. Terrific. So next is an agenda. So item thing that consent agenda. No. Okay. All right. Thank you.

2:16:24 I don't want a regular meeting of September 17th, 11-2, accept the project report railroad extension, 3, accept the project closeout report, 25 slurry and fog seal, 11-4, approve signing of the audiment letters paid money for prep, financial statements and audit for fiscal year 24-25, 11-5, approve and adopt the resolution conditions of benefits for limited term employees and will resolute 20-79.

2:16:48 11, approve and adopt the resolution establishing compensation schedules for limited term employees effective October 27, 2025 and October 26, 2026 and repeal resolution 2378. 11, update and approve to continue the emergency installation of above ground waste oil time commerce drive.

2:17:06 Check register $925 in the amount of $783. Check register $925 in the amount of $2,200,673. Check register $825 in the amount of $836,61. Check register $825 in the amount of $139,504.60. Check register $10,120,000.

2:17:26 We are spending a lot of money. I have never read that many check registers all at once. I guess that's things, right? We canceled the meeting, so. Oh, okay, okay. Got it. But still, that's still. Come on, this is a big one. For anyone who's paying attention, Biggie. All right, so I'll. So moved as presented. Great. Jane, please call the roll.

2:17:53 Councilmember Sauser. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice. Yes. Mayor Bobser. Thank you. Well, we are things where I get to bang the gavel. So, this time in place for the public issuance of revenue connect authority to finance high-speed fiber optic of the town. Are there any protests? No. Okay.

2:18:14 It's now President Spice on Connect Authority. After that, we will comment and question written or oral protests for many interested persons. When all comments have been received, the hearing will be closed. Take Hayes and Barbara. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:18:39 One of our affiliates ago, an update at that, and also some action on your part. Remember most of what I said, and I'll do a little overview. Select Authority, as you know, Joint Powers Authority. It's just a full blue there on the side. Membership, all rights and privilege to the town of Mammoth Lakes as a result. You saw this slide when I was here last, but our program of work are those three bullets on the slide. On the bottom right, to see about today is the open access municipal broadband deployment.

2:19:09 Because that's what we're doing here, hopefully, in partnership with the Town of Mammoth Lakes to bring fiber infrastructure across the town. So, with the award from California Point Four, the total awards that were awarded to Golden State Connect Authority in round one, which was delineated by the CPUC in February of this year, with six counties that moved to two awarded in REN.

2:19:37 Town of Mammoth Lakes being one of those there for an award of $4.158 million. We do have four applications pending just by way of background in round two for those counties that you see at the bottom of the slide. The other two counties that make up round two that are not listed there are Orange County and Contra Costa County, which of course are not our member counties.

2:20:02 These are the partners. I just want to comment on this slide just for a second. Golden State Connect Authority is the joint powers authority. It is the entity to which the grants are made and the financing, construction, owning, operating, and maintaining of the system will take place. But for community marketing purposes, what you will see in your community and across all communities is the marketing name Golden State Fiber.

2:20:29 It is just a name, it's just a brand. The entity remains Golden State Connect Authority, the JPA. We are partnering with Utopia Fiber, currently the largest open access, last mile network administrator in the U.S. We expect to pass them very soon in size and scope, but they have more than 20 years of experience doing what they're going to help us do here.

2:20:53 And then Tilson is our design engineering firm from the very beginning about three years ago with our local agency technical assistance grant all the way through design services for this project. I will skip this slide because you all heard it. We're building an open access system, which means we

2:21:12 Finance, Construct, Own, Operate, Maintain the infrastructure as a governmental entity, and we invite providers onto the network very much like airports, the model for airports. These are of course some of the benefits that we bring. We are building only a fiber network. You won't see any alternative technologies owned, operated, and maintained by Golden State Connect Authority, which means that the entirety of the town of

2:21:40 Mammoth Lakes will be the recipient of that fiber network. We will deliver a single strand to each address within the town of Mammoth Lakes within our project area as we are required to do as recipients of this grant. And we'll start at gig speed offerings. There'll be a gig speed offering for residences and a 10 gig offering for businesses right out of the chute.

2:22:09 If a resident wants more than that, we will work with that situation, but that's a pretty robust offering for us. You refer them to a psychiatrist. Yeah, I was going to say, what would they do with that? What else do you have that you don't need? These are just highlighting some of the requirements under the grant, and they're all key to what I've mentioned, 100% fiber. We are required to provide access to every address within our project area. In this case, it's the entirety of the town of Mammoth Lakes.

2:22:38 And the minimum speed that we will offer as required under the grant is 100 symmetrical. That is the minimum, and we are doing it begrudgingly because very few people buy that now when they buy fiber services. They start at higher levels. Not quite the 10 gig level, but...

2:23:00 Getting into the meat of the project area here now, you all have seen this slide too, the big orange blobs. This is the project area as delineated in the grant. This is the area that we're required to serve.

2:23:13 This slide shows the middle mile that we'll be connecting to, which is an element of digital 395 that comes often into town. We'll be connecting, I think it's Forest Trail, I'm doing this from memory, Forest Trail is where our connection point will be with the Department of Technology who oversees the state middle mile. They also are committed to building the extension or acquiring the extension out to the mountain.

2:23:42 Which currently is not in their portfolio, but we're holding them accountable for getting us out there because when we applied for these dollars they said they would. So we'll connect all the way out to the mountain as promised and as awarded in our grant. The nice thing about this is in this case the middle mile exists that comes into town. So once

2:24:08 The snow melts next spring, we can start construction because we've got access to that existing middle mile, which is not the case in all of our other six project areas. So that's a nice thing down here.

2:24:21 This is phase one. Phase one is the first 40 miles of the town of Mammoth Lakes project and you can see there we're starting up in the entrance as you come into town and then building out the area you see there. The two red dots are hut locations. So huts are where the connection to the middle mile occurs.

2:24:41 The middle mile goes into the hut. All the electronic components sit in the hut. And what comes out of the hut are the fiber strands that will go to the actual addresses. It's very simply put from a non-engineer. But in this case, you see two hut locations. The number of huts are determined by two factors. Number one, by the number of addresses that they will serve. Or, and that is a determinant factor here because of the density.

2:25:10 Or in more rural parts of the state, the determinant factor would be the distance from the hut to the address. In this case, due to the number of addresses in the town of Mammoth Lakes, it was determined that we needed two hut locations. We worked with staff, feels like for a couple of years now, to identify and determine these locations. And the first one here is

2:25:39 You're going to have to tell me where this is. Up Forest Trail in Minaret. I'm sorry. Thank you. At Minaret. It's at the edge of the parking lot there that you see. I do have a picture of what the hut looks like and showed you a schematic last time I was here. But it's roughly a 12 by 25 foot pad on which a structure, a prefabricated structure sits and a backup power generation source.

2:26:11 And then this is the second location. It was down in the southern part of the town of Mammoth Lakes there, you remember from the big picture, in some right-of-way area. And this is the slide that shows the full construction of the hut. So they dig the pad, pour the concrete, again, very simply put, drop the hut on, and hook up all the mechanicals. How's that for an engineering? Yeah.

2:26:48 I brought the hut locations to your attention because one of the items that Hayes mentioned that you are acting on this evening is approval of the hut easements once the meets and bounds are finalized. So I wanted you to be aware of where those locations were, having worked with staff on those. One of the other items that we're asking for your action on tonight is the public hearing that you gaveled open is notification of the fact that we will be issuing bonds for this project.

2:27:18 Golden State Connect Authority is a JPA. Governmental entity has the ability to issue tax-exempt bonds. You can see there in the second bullet, 89% of the project costs for this project area, Town of Mammoth Lakes, will come from those bond proceeds. 11% is that a little over $4 million that we got in terms of grant funds. The reason it's usually reversed when we're working on county projects, it's flip-flopped.

2:27:47 A higher element comes out of grant funds and less comes out of the bond funds. You all are flipped because of the dense nature of the addresses down here. So it's more sustainable to issue bonds and pay for bonds given the customer base that we'll have down here. The bonds, this is probably the most important bullet on this slide, the bonds are not backed by county taxes or obligations. They are...

2:28:14 That's totally the responsibility of Golden State Connect Authority. The reason for the public hearing is just the notification that we are issuing bonds for our project in the town. And I think this is the last slide. It just reiterates and answers any questions you might have. The repayment source will be revenues from system revenues.

2:28:37 When we sign folks up, a portion of their payment will go to pay down the bonded indebtedness. A portion will go to operation and maintenance. So the bonds will come directly out of the payments that we receive from the customers. Again, the county role is just formal acknowledgement of the issuance of bonds.

2:28:58 Barbara, would it be fair to say that when you have county roll in there that you can insert town in the space of county? Oh, my gosh. I'm so sorry. So this would, yeah, wherever it says county roll, it would be town roll. It's not Halloween yet. I'm sorry. The fact that I thoughtfully called you council members and not supervisors, that was a, that required some thought. Yes. So I apologize for that. Yes. Town. And that is, oh, next step in community benefits.

2:29:27 I think we've talked about this, but, you know, we're bringing fiber for the community. There's no financial burden on the town whatsoever. We will handle all costs and operational matters. In the MOU that you are reviewing, there are three items that we do ask of the town, and it's been provided throughout this whole process, so it's really business as usual, nothing new, none of which is monetary per se.

2:29:55 It's identifying a single point of contact with whom we can work and actually, I think it's Hayes by default. Hayes and team. Hayes, Rob, and Amy are our go-tos. Yeah, in that regard. The second is to help us identify locations for the Hutt locations on publicly owned real estate. We will come back to you when we...

2:30:17 And we're just starting the design of phase two, which is everything above that initial 40 miles. That design is occurring right now. It's starting. So we'll go through that process again, identify alternative hot locations for that project area. And then the third thing is just to be our eyes and ears on the ground, and relative to my PowerPoints, apparently, to keep us informed as to community sentiment.

2:30:44 As we're designing, don't go down that road. There's a creek. Go around it. Go here. That kind of thing. And like I said, that's been our partnership throughout this process from the beginning of the local agency technical assistance grant. So business as usual. I have some questions. Certainly. Yeah, go ahead. Can't believe this might be happening. You got a grace period. Nothing happened this year. OK, fine. It's going to happen next year. Fine.

2:31:15 So a couple of questions on kind of the infrastructure side of things. The hut location, for hut location four, there is some planning documents that the town has that could engage that site. So the technical question is, a lot of times when you do runs, you know, it's like to an exact distance.

2:31:46 Would there be any challenge to move that hut location? I'll field that one. Yeah, go, go, go. Yeah, thank you, John. Good aye. So we are well aware of the planning efforts involved, actually with both sites. Right. And we're working with the team to try to place these runs in setbacks in areas that would not be subject to future development so that we are not encumbering the site.

2:32:11 With lines in the wrong place so that we can't move forward with our vision for these locations. So that's part of the process and that's why this is written in such a way and the recommendation and we don't have the final documents is to authorize Rob to execute it once we've come to the final alignments. Staff is well aware of those future visions and we're working to place them in such a way too. Good, because there are some

2:32:36 Cards on the table for, I think, for both sites. And I know for the second site, there's a snowstorm. I don't know exactly where that is, but it's... Yeah, the second site is just off the right-of-way. It's also near an existing easement with the water districts. We're kind of consolidating that infrastructure there and also putting it in such a way that it won't encumber, you know, our future plans for that site, whatever they may be. We're going through that process now.

2:33:02 You answered that question well from a standpoint of the planning process, but I think it's clear to say that, and you correct me if I'm wrong, that these sites cannot be moved once they're in. No, we're married to these sites. Once they're in, the runs are made and you can't move them. Yeah, this is probably the town's contribution to the project is providing the land to support the infrastructure to allow these projects to move forward. So you all heard that, right? Okay.

2:33:32 Then the next question has to do with there are firms, companies, providers, people in town who help people navigate internet services and set things up in houses and things like that. What, because it's freezing cold up here? It is so cold. It's cold up here, right? It's really cold. Yeah.

2:34:00 Some of us are better insulated than others. Some of us are. That the outreach to the providers, there's probably a handful of them who are getting questions already about what is this going to be? Is there an outreach program or to start getting to the people who are dealing with, like you've asked for, like the local kind of knowledge about things, oh yeah, this is what this is going to look like if you need to make decisions about your cable service or what to do.

2:34:29 This is when things might be available. This is what it would look like. This is what the pricing might look like. Yeah, we're happy. And let me give you an answer, a quick answer, and then I'll talk to you about timeline. Yes, we're happy to connect with whomever you all. Again, this is part of the eyes and ears on the ground thing. Happy to have conversations with whomever you all deem appropriate or ask us to. Absolutely. So you could put on like a little like a workshop for?

2:34:57 Sure. Cable TV, Internet, home theater providers, hey, come and get a preview of what this is going to look like. Sure. I mean, we're happy to have community meetings. Okay. Yeah, definitely. In terms of timeline, what we're looking at now is bringing the bid packages forward to our board for their approval for posting and for bid, putting into OpenGov for bidding.

2:35:24 That being said, um,

2:35:50 We expect to have our board approve the cohort of three winter weather impacted Town of Mammoth Lakes among them at the December 10th board meeting of the Golden State Connect Authority board. As early as the very next morning we'll load it into OpenGov and hit go. What that will do though is we won't accept bids for these projects.

2:36:15 Until next March. Right. Because we want fresh numbers. But we want it in the system so that contractors know it's there and that they can come and walk it and look at it. Ideally, this was to happen six weeks ago. And having driven in in the storm the other night, I think we maybe missed that window a little bit. But nonetheless, we'll give the contractors an opportunity to get over here, walk the community.

2:36:42 Before the bids are due. We want fresh numbers in March. So you mentioned Alpine, Mono, and Town of Mammoth Lakes. Inyo County? Inyo's in our round two application round. We have not yet received an award for Inyo. CPUC has not made those awards yet. Okay. Yeah. But Inyo would, in all likelihood, they, well, let me take that back. Inyo will run on a set guard list because of the timing. Yeah. Thank you. Sure. Questions?

2:37:10 Any questions? I have two, but it's really technical from the standpoint of, so what happens to all this like RJ, what's the old stuff, 59 and RJ-8 that's all around town? Coax. The old coax crap. Right. Is that with this project or it just lays there and... I don't have anything to do with it. It belongs to somebody else, so I can't answer it. Gotcha, okay. That's the answer. Yeah. And then those, so for fiber biotech, those two power sources, they'll power the town, but...

2:37:38 Fiber still requires a net end to have connected to be operational? Yes. So by connecting into the middle mile, the state middle mile, that the dead end center that the state connects into. Okay. It's kind of an interesting question about the COAC. So is that in Frontiers? Yeah, it's owned by whatever provider, you know, put it in, maintains it, owns it. So if it's Frontier or Verizon or...

2:38:07 The old cable vision, whatever, there's a lot of infrastructure. It still belongs to them, whether or not it's being utilized or not. To have a conversation about if that ends up going is, becomes a problem. Probably have to have a different conversation. Yeah, that's something to think about, because there could be hazardous waste issues. But there's nothing to stop that provider from continuing to provide services.

2:38:30 Dial-up and all that. Yeah. Okay. AL stopped dial-up two weeks ago, so. I know, but some of us still, you know. I remember the tone well. Have any of our last mile providers showed an interest in what you're doing yet to subscribe to your system? Thank you. Great question. I have not heard from any of them. As of yet, however, we are going to release a request for proposal because we're a governmental entity. Everything is publicly bid.

2:38:59 To select internet service providers to be on the system, it'll be, we'll select for the three regions that we were awarded in. So Glenn and Tehama will have different providers than what we're calling the Sierra region, which is where you all fall, which includes not only Mono and Alpine County, along with the town of Mammoth Lakes, but also Amador County. So the nice thing is there's a good number of potential customers.

2:39:29 Amongst that cohort of project areas. So we're probably looking for five to six providers initially to serve that this area, the Sierra project area. We are, we haven't written the RFP yet, but we have committed to our board that we will give preference points to local providers who participate and meet all nations.

2:39:55 The reason for that, I mean, I'm an economic development person my whole career, is to building and helping those businesses kind of grow their footprint. They can get on our network and they'll pay a per-customer basis. They don't pay, but it expands, it'll expand their footprint in their project area. So someone like Optimum that's currently here, no accident. They absolutely could.

2:40:22 They would not be considered a local provider. A local provider would be maybe a small fixed provider, small business person here. Optimum is part of a big, huge company, but Optimum, AT&T, Bright, I mean, they could all respond to RFP and jump on the network. History is a fact. Sure makes good to expand their high levels of via fiber, but it kind of

2:40:51 If they can assess model is one that in the direction opera owns stuff, stuff, the technical stuff that they can have back. Will that be part of this whole project will be, it's just done in two, but it's done at once. The bond issuance and the effort in core project plan to phase one, phase two, because the 40 miles of network is out of the local agency technical grant that with the town record award.

2:41:21 To get the first files of design largely done. There's small tweaks here and there, like the hut, you know, perfection, but there's small tweaks here and there, but that files in the phase two just for us already, all of the numbers that you saw. So public, also, I can close the hearing. Adopt the resolution for the issuance of the revenue findings will have a significant.

2:41:51 Okay, any discussion or comments? All right, then we can continue to read all.

2:42:09 So, it would be to make any issue that we would approve by resolution the issuance of the revenue bonds that we would, can we do all at once, by the way? Is that okay? Okay. That we would the town acute E27 network structure, authorize the town manager and main network. Then the scene. Councilmember? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem. Has Digital 395 been there? Anyone? Okay, well, we're joining Mara. Thank you, Barbara. Thank you very much.

2:42:39 All right, you're on to council members. Who would like to kick us? So I attended the municipal service for CSA, and then it's your community housing. We have ribbon cutting, which it was so nice to have all of us there. And, you know, I'm really project that it's all I have to report. All right. Yes, I have a meeting for my fellow council members. That alliance is important to kind of keep on our radar. It is a recognized state collaborative.

2:43:08 And as you may have heard, three have been released, our alliance, the landscape scale project on September, the Mammoth Lakes and Sturge meeting with them, that was interesting. The federal government shut down, I guess, making visits to it, but that certainly had to come. The SSRP meeting, that's the eastern state, we're just trying to get some reporting of what's going on with the federal government, with the lands, again, any access apartments, and now the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board, when that we approved the

2:43:38 It was great to see Sharon, I'll see her there. And then I attended the award meeting, and interesting with that, that I'd be for the council to be aware of. Let me just buy notes. The first thing, we didn't get to the whole end of the meeting. Oh, it's okay for us. Never mind. A cross project from, he's on schedule. I'm going to have on the hospital down in Fish. Doot revenue in the occupancy in town.

2:44:08 Not into, but the larger of that, occupancy through the older cities has been up significantly. Well, I think August was another record TOT. Then get into discussions about air service, and I think stable, the numbers are going up through Golden State Broadband Connect, sort of economic opportunities for the region because then remote work as that air is able to maybe even get remote work things starts to get some attention into that as well. Percent 21 for Capac was down a little bit.

2:44:37 Hawthorne was down a little, San Francisco United, all that stuff is going up, stabilizes, now it's a better relationship, the subsidy amount is going down, so that's all good news. The international market, and with Visit California, and California, we are aligned with that, but there are definitely some challenges out there. Thank you. Just a word on the other side, I just want to...

2:45:01 You know, for perception-wise, people are providing service to people visiting the area because that I can tell. And I know that Polk Works and Athletics Tourism and everybody else has been in different ways, but I just, it should not go out of notice because I know other areas are really, really struggling. And I think that people are experiencing. And just the other thing, while the IRS was not only well done, when you're doing a lot of work with somebody, you hope you don't have those issues, but they have a lot of variety in this community.

2:45:30 They've really just, they're a critical resource. The 29th senator and her assistant down, he felt a very good meeting of who we are and what we do and what our... On the 6th, I attend very... ...had to pass a resolution to... So, did Phil say his announcement was public? No. Anything about that? On the king, a reception for the kings on their own night with Rob...

2:45:59 Uh, it was very well done, uh, and appreciated, and then we went and watched the Kings play a terrible experience. Uh, attended the, uh, League of California. Uh, and, of course, the, uh, uh, and today, the ribbon cutting at, uh, Mammoth Crow. There we have it. Your report. State Senator Senator Otto, thanks to, uh, future, uh, uh, for resolution regarding plans, um, um, uh, something that, um,

2:46:28 The entire council I work with called the Mountain Pack. It's a better I'd like to. All right. Wildfire Alliance meeting, and there's another one tomorrow. There's been a lot of great progress. And also AMS and the communications subgroups, because there's just a lot of discussion and coming together for all of these different agencies. So trying to make sure that, you know, just trying to help out.

2:46:56 Focus a lot on talking to her about our housing programs and how challenging it is for us to help break between 80 and 200 percent of AMI. So if there is any, so we'll see, our special meeting and what Councilmember Sauser said, the reason to approve the budget changes, we have, and escalating. We had, as you all know, ESTA is very well run and fiscally responsible, but we have to keep an eye on that. And then on October 8th, I wanted to mention,