Trails Committee
at 15:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
317 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:18 Committee Member Souser? Present twice. Committee Member Patterson? Here. Committee Member Howell? Here. Committee Member Ostergaard? Here. Committee Member Britton? Here. Vice Chair Draper is absent. Chair Connolly? Here. Okay, that brings us to public comments. All right. Step right up. Yes, please. Thank you.
2:55 Hello, MTC. I'm Christy Williams, Project Management Specialist for Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access Foundation. And I came today because I am the lucky one who gets to be the project manager for the MLTS project working with the Office of Outdoor Recreation. So I think I know almost all of you, most of you, but I'm super excited to work with this great team. And I think you all know we're in year two of a contract.
3:22 MLTPA is in year two of a contract with the OOR to provide trails-related services, and primarily it's in website management. It could be in graphic design, it could be in GIS, supporting this team how they need it. So I'm available if anybody has any questions, but just wanted to say hello again and let you know that I, I mean, I've watched this committee and I've watched the MLTS for a long time, but I've never been the project manager, so I'm very excited, and it's good to see you all. Thanks.
3:52 See you too. Thank you. Okay. I think there's no more public comment? Okay. Let's do a consent agenda. Move to approve and presented. Okay. All right. Do we need to do a roll call? Yep. All right. Committee Member Souser? Yes. Committee Member Patterson? Yes. Committee Member Howell? Yes. Committee Member Ostergaard? Yes. Committee Member Britton? Yes. Chair Connell? Yes. All right.
4:30 Moving along to presentations. Yes, thank you. Give me one second as I share my screen. Is it? Show all windows. There we go. That was my issue. Okay, Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. We wanted to provide you all with just another brief update on...
5:24 What we are doing in collaboration with Mammoth Lakes Police Department, and I believe Sergeant Jason Heilman is on the line as well in case you guys have any questions at the end. But we just wanted to do a review due to most recent letters to the editor in the sheet and just a lot of comments in general related to bikes and bike safety.
5:43 on the multi-use pathways. Town Council has been getting a lot of questions as well, and I wanted to provide you with this letter that we developed along with Mammoth Lakes Police Department to alert any concerned citizens or governing bodies of the steps that have been taken to date.
6:00 to attempt to address these issues. You guys have this in your packet. Hopefully you've been able to take a look at it. I don't think I need to go through and dwell on each bullet point, but what I do want to do is provide a few updates. The speed monitoring signage that we have recently purchased, which has a data collection component as well, those are sitting in Reno. So those should be here very soon, and we can deploy those on the trail system. There are six of them.
6:27 Obviously, I think we all know where a lot of the big problem areas are between Twin Lakes and town. But of course, if you had any recommendations for placement of those six signs, happy to hear any of that. But we are obviously continuing to take these steps to try to address e-bikes on the multi-use pathway. Another item I'm attempting to pursue right now with the Inyo National Forest is to attempt to address the lack of opportunity for e-bikers by just...
6:56 Marking some routes on the dirt roads to provide maybe some other areas for those e-bikers to go. But other than that, you have the majority of the information in your packet, the steps that we've taken. If you have any questions, I am available, as well as Sergeant Jason, if any of you have any questions. I don't have any questions, but anyone else have any thoughts? No questions. I'm glad to see we're doing it and producing encouragement for certain routes.
7:28 It's always productive. I don't care what form of outdoor recreation you're talking about. So I encourage us to produce that and get it out there for them. This, I think, also will continue to be an ongoing process as more potential issues come up or new MUPS are developed. We have plans for new multi-use pathways, so we will continue to keep our eyes on the issue. This is related to the MUPS, but kind of tangentially.
7:58 The area by Obsidian that's blocked off for construction, do you know how long until they're rebuilding that or opening that up? I would need to speak to Public Works about that. I can certainly get you that information, but I will need to speak with Hayes regarding that, get that information. All right. All right. Thank you very much. And Jason, I know I'm sure you have a lot of other responsibilities as well, so you are free to go as well. Hey, thank you.
8:37 Mr. Lawson, thanks again for all the collaboration we've been doing. It's been great between the police department and the town attacking this issue because we can't do it alone, so appreciate all your work on this. Thank you. Jason, you're talking about police department and town as if they're two different entities. They aren't. All right. Well, that wraps up the e-bike presentation. Now on to reports. Is that you again, Lawson? Actually, Mr. Mulford.
9:11 I believe we'll be starting with the trails program report and I will be following him. Okay. All right. Let me share my screen. Good afternoon. Andrew Malford, trails program manager, here to share my manager report for the summer season thus far. So we'll talk a little bit about Sharp, Sherwins area trail planning, some work we've been doing up in the Lakes Basin on timber.
10:04 near the Mammoth Lakes Pack Station. We'll talk about the Black Bear Run construction effort and a little bit about our sign installation to date. So for Sharp, you all are familiar with our kind of concepts so far. Here's a map showing in orange the proposed action currently. We had a great interdisciplinary team field visit slash meeting on June 20th.
10:35 That was the first time in about a year that we've convened that interdisciplinary team. So sometimes, you know, there's new players in the room, old players in the room, good to get everybody back together and get the project kind of fired back up in a big way. So at that meeting, there's a NEPA planner who helped to organize it, who was...
11:01 Since then been detailed out to a different position, but she was really instrumental in getting all the players together and kind of getting us organized from the forest side. So she was able to wrangle this list of attendees, which included two members from the archaeological team from the forest, the tribal relations officer, our local rec officer, a wildlife biologist, Casey Shannon, the hydrologist.
11:31 Kim was there representing Mammoth Lakes Recreation, the SNC grantee who's supporting the planning work, and then myself and Lawson representing the town. So we met at the Forest Service compound and then headed out to the project area. The rest of the Forest Service folks had met that morning and kind of identified internally some of their...
11:57 Concerns or just things that they wanted to discuss out in the field. So we went to a few kind of targeted areas to have some discussions in the field. We went to the Sherwin Meadow at the end of Tamarack Street, talked about some hydrological concerns around, you know, just consistently wet areas. Also, we had a proposed line behind Hidden Lake that Casey pointed out would
12:27 experience a lot of seeping basically because it's going through an aspen grove that is at the base of the Sherwins at the base of the avalanche path so he had some concerns around that but then we discussed you know that route is basically what we thought was a better alternative to the existing user created routes that are down in the meadow which we would need to build a boardwalk to mitigate the seasonal moisture
12:56 That's out there. So we didn't necessarily land on a complete conclusion for that site, but got the conversation started and kind of identified, okay, here's the process moving forward for, you know, working through these individual issues with the right players in the room. So in that case, it would be myself and Casey scheduling a follow-up trip to go out there and look at that.
13:23 Other concerns that were brought up were pretty limited. Overall, project-wide, there's a lot of archaeological interaction, so we paid for quite a bit of survey work to be able to have comprehensive survey coverage of the entire project area, so that will inform any...
13:46 Moving of proposed lines that we need to do going forward. So we all knew archaeological was kind of the big one. But in terms of all those other members of the interdisciplinary team, hydrological concerns limited, mostly concentrated right there around the meadow. There's some pine marten suitable habitat. That was the only issue that was brought up by the wildlife biologist. And that is a
14:15 Small area, basically in between Hidden Lake towards Sherwins Trailhead on the kind of west side of the creek there. It's riparian vegetation and dense aspen and nice habitat. So I think based on...
14:41 The hydrological concerns and the habitat concerns, we dropped a line in that area and just decided to use the current user trail alignment, which will require some boardwalk building. But those are kind of examples of some of the talks and negotiations we had out there in the field. Whitebark pine was another issue that was brought up. That's primarily found up near Panorama Dome.
15:07 The White Park Pine has been recently listed by U.S. Fish and Wildlife as an endangered species and requires a fair amount of back and forth with that agency to move forward with a project that will have a negative impact on those species. So we heard a few different things. I think the forest is kind of figuring out how to work through that process on another project, and that's helping to inform how we move forward with those trails.
15:37 You know, as long as your project was outside of the trip line of existing trees, then you could write it off as not having a negative impact, but then we heard that fish and wildlife might be a little stricter and say anything within 40 feet of a tree, a whitebark pine species, would have a negative impact. So if that's the case, having a negative impact isn't a showstopper. We can still keep our trails through those alignments.
16:07 Has an effect on the timeline. And so basically, to get through that negative impact would require about four months of back and forth with Fish and Wildlife. But like I said, not a showstopper, just, you know, significant time impact, but based on some other parts of the project that are going to require some consulting with the State Historic Preservation Office over archaeological resources.
16:36 Our strategy, I think, will be to keep those lines in and go through that lengthy process and just have those trail segments be on a separate timeline than some of the simpler alignments. So not piecemealing the project but just being realistic about, okay, these segments all are relatively straightforward and don't have a lot of resource concerns so let's put them on a track.
17:05 Put these other segments on a separate track that will have a slightly different timeline. So at the end of that meeting, we identified that Forest Service was going to deliver a resource avoidance data set to us. We were going to rework our routes, bring them back to them with the goal of avoiding resources where possible. And then we would work together as a team to come up with a proposed action, finalized proposed action, which would then go out to scoping.
17:36 And get the ball rolling. And so that NEPA planner who I mentioned generated this really nice table that has, you know, the amount of days required for each part of the process factored in. And so, you know, basically anytime there's a delay to the start date, you can plug it into this table and it'll give you relatively realistic prediction of
18:01 When we can expect to implement the project. So, this has been really helpful. Coming out of that June 20th meeting, we were all pretty optimistic. She was saying April 21st, we could likely be implementing the project. We reconvened on July 25th, and it became clear that the report that we've all been waiting for for Stantec, which was due quite a while ago in February, they still haven't.
18:31 Completed, which is frustrating, but, you know, that's kind of holding up all the progress that we discussed at that previous meeting, basically, you know, in order to work out these new routes that avoid resources, we really need that report to be complete so we can have, you know, information that's concrete to inform these further reroutes.
18:56 So we kind of pushed pause on developing alternative routes and really leaned hard on our contractor to get this report complete. They promised to have that report complete ahead of our upcoming interdisciplinary team meeting on August 22nd. So we're optimistic that that report will be delivered. We had a kind of check-in meeting with Stantec and the Forest Service archaeological team just to make sure
19:25 That everyone's on the same page in terms of what they need to get done, what they need from either party, and just that they're communicating well, which they are, and it sounds like the Forest Service will bless the report once it's complete, and they anticipate that it'll satisfy our needs. It's just taken a long time to generate. So initially, Stantec was saying that they needed
19:55 A long time to still complete the report, and I, you know, it's pretty firm that if we had to, we've got an interdisciplinary team scheduled, meeting scheduled for August 22nd, those meetings are really hard to schedule given the amount of people in their various schedules, so, you know, my argument was if we have to postpone this meeting, it could be 68 weeks before we can get another one on the books, that is going to have a really
20:23 Huge lag on our implementation time because, you know, if we're able to have this meeting in August, we can still have some subsequent field time with all the specialists to dial in our finalized proposed action going into the winter, and then we'll be able to put the project out for scoping and still implement next year. So they heard us and said that they would rally and get the report done ahead of our August 22nd meeting, which is good news.
20:53 So in that July 25th meeting, I guess I mentioned this already, but Courtney, the NEPA planner, informed us that she was moving on to a different detail, but Chris Bewer, who's the rec officer for the Mammoth Ranger District, has now taken on the role of project lead on the forest side, which is, you know, great. Courtney, the NEPA planner, had a lot of experience in that world, but Chris is, you know,
21:24 Our partner, and we work with him day in, day out, and I think it's good for him to step up into that role of leadership on their end. So in the meantime, they've gone out and had a look at some of the lines. Fred and Chris were out on Monday, and Fred had voiced some concerns around trail density, especially in the area behind Sierra Meadows Ranch, when you look at a map.
21:50 You know, they were calling it, referring to it as a spaghetti bowl and whatnot, and I encouraged them that there's certainly instances of denser trail networks all over the place, and if you got out there in the field and looked at it, the landscape's pretty big and the trails aren't actually as close together as they might look on a map, and they found that to be true on their field trip.
22:12 So we're just excited that we've got an engaged forest partner, that they're out there reviewing the project, and we just anticipate that, you know, upon completion of this archaeological report, we'll all be able to work together to finalize a proposed action and get that out to scoping. Hopefully mid-October, I think, is where we're looking at finalizing the proposed action. So we'd be planning to host a public meeting sometime
22:42 Any questions on Sharp before I move on? I have a quick question regarding the area behind Sierra Meadows Ranch. That area historically has been pretty much equestrian only just because of the nature of the trails. They were made by and designed for, if you can say designed, for equestrian use.
23:10 And I know we've discussed this many times, and, you know, the intent is that this is multi-use. These will be multi-use paths or trails in this area. But is there any consideration, I think we discussed it a while back, about having equestrian-only loops, like in that spaghetti bowl-type area, just to give the opportunity for someone who has a horse.
23:35 That is skittish around bikes for, you know, or for young children riding or something like that to have a safe area where they're not going to have to have that interaction. Yeah, those decisions are still very much on the table and the forest is eager to build that into the project. So, you know, if you don't mind, I'd probably reach out to you as kind of a local equestrian source of knowledge if we...
24:03 Have those conversations moving forward. But, you know, certainly that center line coming out of the back of Sierra Mammoth's Ranch, I think we would recommend as an equestrian route. And then in terms of the other routes, I think we'd like to keep a lot of it open to multi-use, you know, and I think the distinction that I often see out there is if they're guided, you know, pack station tours on a route, then...
24:33 Then it's best if that route is equestrian only. And if it's open to, you know, the recreational user, typically conflicts are easy to manage and there's not a lot of problems out there. But there's certainly, I think, a need to think about those things on the front end and make it so everybody feels safe out there. And I ask specifically because many of the trails that have been
25:03 created some of the connector trails that are multi-use, truly, in my opinion, are not multi-use. There are blind corners, there are very narrow areas. You know, some of the areas coming down from rock trail into the meadow are very hard to navigate on horseback and bicycle, and I ride both. You know, so I just think as we move forward, I would like to...
25:32 Be involved in that and make sure that our committee considers that. I think one other thing to consider is the fact that that is the only area in town where people can have private forces. They may not have a PAC station in that area right now. They have historically, and it fluctuates. So I think we need to consider that as well, that even though there aren't PAC station-led
26:00 Rides out of their area doesn't mean that that's not going to happen in the future. Well, that's what I meant. I think that it's in their permit to operate like that out of the back of the CRM's range, so we need to, yeah, that's why I mentioned that. Do you have a one connector? Yes. I've chosen. That's a little scary, right? It is scary, and I've chosen not to. I've ridden it maybe twice.
26:27 And I've chosen not to, you know, the areas that are on the hills where there's a line of sight, it's much easier and it's much easier to anticipate a potential conflict, but that connector, you know, that goes up kind of through the woods. A big drop-offs. Yeah, and a big rock on one side and tree on the other. I mean, I can tell you exactly where those spots are because, but the technical components aren't really that technical for a horse, you know, it's easily.
26:53 I can ride it better on a horse than I can on my bike. But I will say that when we are making multi-use paths, I think we need to be cognizant of that. And I think the path truly does need to be multi-use. If that's what we're naming it, that's what we have to build. And then the second part is, are the existing equestrian trails that are out there,
27:22 They're not being like taken over. Are they staying as equestrian trails? So currently none of those trails behind Sierra Meadows Ranch are system trails. So the goal of this project is to analyze that area and figure out which ones would be good candidates to bring into the system and which routes aren't really serving.
27:51 Our environment or a recreation community and would need to be closed. And so we're making recommendations to the forest, but ultimately it's all forest source land and we're kind of looking to them to help us make final decisions on those things. So you're saying that forest trails aren't legal? Correct. Well, it's interesting the way they characterize it.
28:18 It seems like there's not a problem with people using those trails currently. The only problem lies in I'm not able to go out there and maintain it. We can't put it on a map and share it out with people that are visiting or might not know about them. So they function in a way for the people that know about them and in the state that they're in. And that is okay with the forest. But we think that there's a better way to manage it.
28:48 It is a change in the way the Forest Service has operated. So if we go back a number of years, I know everybody gets tired of hearing me spew history, but if we go back a good number of years, the Forest Service used to produce maps showing all of those trails. They just never formally put them in their inventory because it wasn't necessary. Then with the changing attitudes, now you can't maintain, you can't improve, you can't do anything with those trails.
29:17 And that's just a political change. Maybe someday we will see it swing back again in the other direction, but it makes our life tough. Andrew, my question for you here is, I don't even know how many years ago we were involved in creating a cost share agreement for the Sherwins area when the Sherwins Working Group was done, and we're told by the Forest Service, and we were very positive in it, that this would all be done a decade ago, that they were on board, that we were going to have this. Now, here we are 10 years later.
29:46 Or whatever it is, I don't know what the exact dates are, still being stonewalled and told, yes, we think this can happen. Is there a cutoff point at some time where we shift our focus and try to get some of the, what the Forest Service now refers to as user-created trails, some of them were by the equestrian of old, some of them were by the Native Americans that lived here, you know, for centuries before that.
30:13 And get them put into the system so that they can be maintained and work properly. When do we shift some of our energy from SHARP, which seems, unless truly something happens in the next year, which seems to be getting drug out as far as possible by the organization, to something where maybe we can actually create a positive partnership with them and move some of this forward. I'm just, you know, I was involved with the Hayden Cabin Museum for years.
30:42 We weren't allowed to clear any debris off of the trails because technically the trails don't exist. So I share your frustrations and I understand them completely, but I think I'm really optimistic about our current cast of players, I guess, and I would say that I wouldn't characterize our current situation as getting stonewalled. I think
31:10 Fred, District Ranger, has made it clear to his team that it's a priority to get this project across the finish line as soon as possible. So that's pretty clear based on the staff allocating time for it. It's on their program of work. They're committed to getting this thing done. They don't want to see it languish any longer either. I think the most frustrating timeline concern recently was
31:40 Based on the contractor that we hired, just not producing the work in the time that they promised that they would produce it. So, unfortunately, that is kind of our most recent headache in terms of timelines. I, you know, also have been working on this project for a really long time. Seems excessive. Seems like we've spent an excessive amount of money on it, so I hear you. That, you know, instead of continuing to just throw money, hopefully, at this thing, there's got to be at some point where we...
32:10 We make a decision to pivot, but I'm optimistic that before we hit that point, we're going to get some real implementation, and I think that this timeline that's been provided feels very realistic, and I don't feel like we're being pandered to. I feel like we're being treated as partners, and they understand the amount of effort that we've put into this, and they don't want us to
32:41 You know, give up. They want to see it get across the finish line. So I'm going to remain optimistic and keep pushing on all fronts and really hopeful that we'll be implementing next season. Yeah, and real quick, I think we've made a very good amount of progress on this in the last year and a half that gives me very similar hope to what Andrew has.
33:12 You know, I think this project in the past, whether it's 15 years we've been doing this, has been stalled out numerous times, but I do actually believe we have some momentum right now. And Andrew's working great with the Forest Service, and the fact that we have timelines like this is, I think, a really positive thing. And then real quick to your comment,
33:31 I'm sure MTC or you as an individual may want to comment on this process when we do come to a proposed action. And one of the reasons I think kind of how Andrew designed things out there is smart.
33:42 When you have more trail opportunity or authorization to make trail out there, we have more flexibility to adjust if we did need to do an equestrian-only trail out there. So if it was one of those scenarios where we're starting to see a lot of conflict, we're starting to see all these different things, oh, all these trails that Andrew may be proposing were authorized.
34:02 And we might be able to do some delineation on those. So maybe from a public comment standpoint, that might be something to think about. Andrew mentioned that the forest was going out saying maybe there were too many options there, but maybe there's a positive to too many options as it relates to all the different uses. And I don't think any of those are going to get any less in the future as well. I had a question regarding this, and you may have already addressed this, but the Stantec report delays which are impacting you guys.
34:30 Moving forward on this project. What are causing those and how are they being mitigated? I can jump in and take this one. I think part of it was the forest didn't seem like they were moving very quickly. So I think Stantec thought they had more time. And part of that was on me. They would tell me, hey, you know, we're a little bit delayed from this delivery date. And I would effectively say, just keep working on it. You know, the forest service isn't ready for this.
35:00 And then all of a sudden the Forest Service was ready and they weren't. So I think some of this is on me in terms of making sure I'm managing them appropriately and holding them to their timelines. I think we did have a good little moment recently where Andrew and I did not mince words with them in terms of our demands and they said they would meet that. But I think a good chunk of that, and again, I don't want to make excuses, definitely some of that is on me.
35:27 Was, you know, initially the forest wasn't ready and they were saying they were delayed, Stantec, and I said, oh, it's okay, you know, the forest is moving, just make sure to keep us posted and get it updated and then the forest was ready to go and we had a bunch of momentum and they weren't finished. So that's kind of the scenario that occurred with Stantec and much of that is on me. Yeah, I mean, they did drop the ball in a big way. They promised the report by February and they just didn't dedicate the appropriate staffing to get it done in the timeline that they promised us.
35:57 And there's a little bit of back and forth, like they may have been waiting on comments from the forest that, you know, may not have been super timely, but I think from what I saw, the main onus was on the contractor there. Yep, but I think we're in a good place now in terms of them getting that work done by the time both Andrew and the forest needs it done. Anything else on Sharp? All right, let's move on.
36:33 So I just wanted to give you a, you know, kind of recap of what our crew's been up to this year. We've got six folks on our trail crew this year, four, three of them returning, three new, four returning. So it's been a really nice work season with, we've got Nate, who's a ex-hot shot, excellent with a saw. We've got Scott, who's a
37:01 I'm an avid trail user and been on our crew for several years who I can just trust to do really good maintenance work or just to kind of lead a crew and have solid vision for a project and see it through. Got some motivated younger folks. So all in all, good crew and having that six-person crew allows me to...
37:26 Tackle big projects and knock them out. Also to divvy up the crew and continue to make progress on, say, Black Bear Run while making sure we're paying attention to the Mammoth Rock Trail. This morning we're working on Black Bear Run with three or four folks working on a rock wall. Meanwhile, three of us are up on Mammoth Rock Trail brushing and doing some tread work. So that is a relief for me. Whereas with a smaller crew, I feel like
37:55 You know, you can only do one thing at a time. So this has been really nice. That being said, this spring, a lot of our capacity was dumped into this timber work up in the basin, which, you know, needed to get done. It was a good project. You can see in the pictures here, there's, I think in the hundreds of trees, I haven't gotten out there and counted them individually, but standing dead lodgepole that had been up there for a while. And, you know, last year it came to my attention that
38:25 All hazard trees proximate to the multi-use path were our responsibility. I don't think that had been communicated from the forest previously, so there was a backlog of trees to catch up on.
38:36 We did a pretty good job of that last season, and we left this whole area by the pack station because of some complications around frontier communication lines and whose responsibility and where are we going to be able to, you know, get those trees on the ground with the lines up. It became clear that frontier wasn't going to do anything about this and that the hazard was too great to open the path. So we kept the path closed as the basin opened, which wasn't ideal. We had, you know.
39:05 Bicyclists and Pedestrians on the roadway. So we really just, you know, decided to dive in here and get the work done regardless of Frontier not being able to get in there and drop their lines. So we just used directional falling techniques to keep the trees away from the lines. And then where we got really close to the lines, we just used a grip hoist and pulley system to get the trees to fall.
39:30 Where we needed them to fall. So that was my crew, as well as Mammoth Lakes Fire Department has a wildland fire crew. And they helped out a lot. They've got some nice equipment. They let us use their chipper. And we're up there running saws alongside of us. So that was several weeks of work up there, just getting these trees on the ground. So we basically mitigated the hazard to the mup.
40:00 So we could get it open as quickly as possible ahead of Fourth of July weekend because I felt like having that pedestrian conflict on the road was just something that we didn't want to deal with through the Fourth of July busy weekend and I didn't want to see somebody get hurt up there. So we got the trees down, got the path open, and we have a ton of timber up there. So it's kind of a cool project. It's like a multi-benefit fuels and recreation project.
40:28 Step one's done. The hazard's been mitigated from the pathway, but not the fuels and fire hazard. So we've kind of promised the fire department that we get back in there with them this fall and help clean it up from a fuels perspective. So they're able to chip 12 to 14 to 16 inch diameter logs, and then everything else is getting bucked up into rounds. That'll be...
40:55 Moved towards the road and some sort of plan will be developed for getting all that firewood out of there. But it's a lot of work. There's going to be a huge amount of chipping. But after seeing the chipping, I'm kind of sold on that in terms of an alternative to piles and pile burning. Because previously...
41:18 You know, there's piles sitting up in the lakes basin for a long time, and those require NEPA. They require the right conditions to burn. They just sit there on the landscape forever and ever, and then eventually they get burned, and then people don't like the smoke. But the chipping, really, you can take a ton of material and turn it into, you know, a barely noticeable pile of chips, which I think is great from a fuel's perspective.
41:41 Just kind of removes the eyesore of all the material. So I think we'll chip a lot of it and we'll leverage the CAL FIRE inmate crews, which we can hire as a municipality. And then, like I said, we'll get back up there with the fire department crew and tidy this area up this fall. Fun project, got to drop a lot of trees and it was fun working with the fire department. Black Bear Run, we are...
42:11 Nearing completion. I can confidently say it will be done by the end of the month, which feels good to say. But this is some pictures of the top section, which we've been working on for quite some time now. So once we finished up that timber work, we pivoted up there, set up our, you can see on the right there is their grip hoist up in a tree, creating a high line so we're able to hoist rocks up in the air and then belay them down.
42:40 Steep slope into place on a large rock wall that we built to create a larger radius on the top turn there, which is a steep and tight turn, but less steep and less tight now. So that we finished last week and we just moved all this rigging equipment down to the bottom turn, which similarly needed some widening and a retaining wall built to make it a little more usable. Here's some pictures of that wall.
43:09 Ended up being, I think, three tiers higher than that. And, you know, essentially you're doing dry stack masonry, so you're finding suitable large rocks and then taking medium-sized rocks and pounding them with a single jack and making crush and then using that to really solidify everything that you're building so that it'll last. And then final step, bringing dirt in, and we actually brought in some...
43:37 Water backpacks and watered everything when we were done to try and get it to lock in. Here's some more of that. Crush making, here's that top turn and I didn't get a chance to nab an after photo but we'll have to get up there and look at it together. I'm pretty excited. Moving on to sign installation. So on the left you can see our metal
44:03 Type 4-6 signs, that's a new one that we put in over by the library recently. On the right are our new HTPE plastic composite soft surface signs. So soft surface signs, we've gotten those all installed, basically replacing things that were broken or damaged during the big winter 22-23. And then the metal signs, I've started.
44:32 Got all the signs here, they look great. Thanks to FEMA for reimbursing us for a large chunk of that major expense. And in terms of installation, we're getting there. It is, it's fraught with some fun obstacles. These signs, the 4-6 is actually going pretty well. There's only three mounting bolts into the steel beam. The 6-A's,
45:01 The longer, skinnier ones, sort of reassurance markers along the bike path, they, so to install both sides requires drilling 16 holes through quarter inch steel, so that is not an easy process in the field. Where those posts are installed on a stanchion with anchor bolts, I can just take that whole post off, bring it to my welding contractor in the
45:30 Industrial Park and have him drill the holes and, you know, that's easy. But in most cases, these designs were installed before that specification was created, so they're just concreted into the ground. So in most cases, we're having to drill those holes in the field. So that's just laborious and time-consuming. But I plan on putting the crew on that as soon as they finish up with Black Bear Runs. We'll get it done.
46:00 Yeah, other than that, we've been having some great stewardship events. Last night we had a Wednesday work night up at Coldwater. Really fun event. I think I like those events because you get a lot done and a smaller group and with that hour of socializing after the event, I think people really enjoy making connections and friendships. So I really enjoyed participating in those.
46:32 Yeah, we're out there kind of just keeping an eye on maintenance issues as they arise. We got some nice rain this winter, or this summer so far, and that's helped to kind of highlight some erosion issues, especially up in the Lakes Basin, so I've been kind of jumping on those as we can get to them. That's all I've got for you this afternoon. Thanks for your time. Any questions? With the tree removal, was there NEPA needed or any sort of environmental stuff, or was that just all part of it?
47:02 Having the MUPs in that location, how did that go with the Forest Service? Yeah, so that's all part of our current agreement in terms of trail maintenance and MUP management. So anything that is within falling distance of the MUP and is dead and considered a hazard, then there's no further NEPA needed to remove that hazard. Beautiful. Is the new boardwalk on Mountain View your work as well or no? Mm-hmm.
47:35 Yeah, that's great. When was that completed? Late June, I think. Okay. Good work. Thanks. Is there any opportunity for firewood with all those rounds up there? So I think the current plan is to make it available to tribal members from the area first, and then last year I know Fred signed a special...
48:10 Firewood Collection Order for the Lakes Basin, and I would assume the same thing would happen this fall. Yeah. And with Black Bear, there's going to be like a grand opening eventually? Yeah, that's tentatively planned for last of the month, last of this month or, you know, 1st of September. Keep it posted. Okay. Sounds good. Good job. Thanks. All right. No more questions. We'll keep moving. Let's see.
48:47 5-2, manager report. All right. Give me one second here as well. I'm going to share my screen. And while I'm doing this, I, yeah, just want to give Andrew and crew the credit. I mean, the timber project he was talking about there in the lakes basin was enormous in both scale and scope. If you have a chance to get up there, I highly encourage you to go look at it. This was no small feat.
49:14 Huge thank you as well to Alish, Bob, Jeff, with Mammoth Lakes Fire Department, just an awesome partner project. But if you go up there, and yes, these trees were threatening them up, but this looks more like a landscape level ESCCRP Mammoth Donut sort of project up there. So if you get up there, definitely encourage you to check it out.
49:40 You know, not that Andrew didn't do it justice, but I want you all to see the scale and scope of that. That was a huge thing. Huge thing. Lawson, sorry to interrupt. So is the ESCCRP knowledgeable about this project? And because, you know, they did a big survey of scale for what they needed to remediate. And so I'm wondering if they take this into consideration. This was more our responsibility as a result of the multi-use pathway. So I've stayed in close communication throughout.
50:09 All of these different types of work that we do, anything related to trees with Janet and the crew over there, related to the town-owned parcels or providing recreation input as it relates to maybe mitigating any of the negative effects of that to recreation. But no, that one fell into our purview along with frontiers of which we really took the lead on that. We'll put it that way. But that one was strictly in our purview. Yep.
50:39 All right. Let me maximize my screen here. All right, everyone. I will try to be brief as we go through the Office of Outdoor Recreation Manager report. Again, Lawson Reef. We'll talk about last year's budget, how we finished up. I would love your input. I'm starting to work with the town manager on our program of work request with the Inyo. Would love your input on that. The over snow vehicle.
51:11 I want to talk to you all about that as well. Bikes and e-bikes we did speak about. I have one slide on here where I want to show you what our new devices look like to track speed. Then there are a couple other items where I will bring in Trails Program Manager Andrew to talk about with you all. Getting some initial input on potential foundation site, recreational development, a potential request as sharp
51:37 Goes down the pipeline and we might be building a large amount of trail related to a trail dozer and then we will talk a bit about our trail system interpretive signage. But first things first here, since we did not have the last meeting, I wanted to give you all a review of the budget from 22-20, I'm sorry, 23-24. In this particular document, you will see two of them. I'll bump ahead to the other one real quick. Again, I've been trying to expose you guys to
52:05 The normal way we have reported to you in the past and then show you kind of straight from our Cassell system what these budgets look like. So you can see based on the various budgets and allocations which we reviewed with you all prior to this, we basically ended up about $12,000 under our budget. But you will see in one of those budget line items we did go over. Spent a little bit more in winter grooming than we initially anticipated.
52:34 Mammoth Trails.
53:05 Report we received from Stantec regarding CEQA, potential CEQA work in the Mammoth Creek parcel for some of the recreation development that we have discussed prior. One thing that I think we're pretty proud of is we continually seek to make the most of these dollars. And one of the ways that we have tried to do that
53:31 Is through grants, of course, but we've really embedded ourselves in the local transportation commission funding and possible options to utilize some of that funding to help with our various recreational programming. So we were able to do some of that. For instance, data collection devices are contained under this and those signs that I'm getting for the multi-use pathway are data collection devices.
54:00 So I can use an alternative funding source to fund those. So I would like to think we are getting as much if not more in the past while spending a little less of these dollars. Now what that does confuse for me a little bit is the initial beginning of the year budgeting situation. As I learn about these new funding sources, oftentimes I did not anticipate.
54:21 at the beginning of the season. If I would have known I would have been able to spend some of these dollars, I would have been able to relay that to you guys when we did our budget planning, and maybe some things would have looked a little bit different. But I think it's really, really great, and we will continue to try to leverage these alternative funding sources and apply for grants as we are able to. So any questions about last year's budget?
54:51 Obviously, as well, Andrew mentioned this briefly, we will get $39,000 to measure our reimburse from FEMA. But we didn't know if that was actually going to happen, right? So we had to buy those signs. We submitted the request for all the things that were destroyed during the winter months, and we did end up getting that money. But any questions related to last year's budget, how we spent, questions there? At what point did we realize that we were over budget in winter?
55:24 I really didn't until I took a greater investigation into our staffing and what we covered. I think it was just a long winter and we just ended up spending a little bit more than we ordinarily would. I really didn't notice that we went over in that particular program category until I really started adding things up in preparation for this meeting. I focus a lot on the overall.
55:53 Oh, complete side note.
56:23 New snowmobile arrived for winter grooming for next year, so we're very excited about that. It is in storage right now since the Nordoni died. But that happened recently, so it wasn't in my update. Nordoni died recently? No, that was last winter. It's been, you know, it's been the living dead for a while, I think. Yeah, yeah. All right. So I just looked at the last budget for May 31? Yep.
56:54 So was there just more that was allocated after that point? I think it was a longer winter. It didn't snow much in the beginning of the season, but we did have staff who were able to help with some projects that we needed to get done, so we did spend some, even though it wasn't snowing. And then later in the year, it was a longer season. The snow lasted longer. We had quite a bit of snow. So just ended up allocating...
57:23 More to that line item. Yeah. Lawson, I have a question. So, you know, this SNC grant was fairly significant. Do you see potential for future grants like this? And if so, should more money be allocated maybe for professional services in seeking out those grants? Or is this something staff can do and has time to? Yeah, so we actually have a, and Rob can't correct me if I'm a grant contractor.
57:53 That we contract with called California Consulting that actually seeks out and will write grants for us on our behalf. And there's actually a meeting going on with them right now. And we are constantly liaisoning with them to find appropriate grants, things of that nature. But a grant, and again, thank you to Kim and MLR for Sharp Grants, a grant of that size and that quantity is going to need to be project-based, right? So as we move to complete
58:23 Sharp and do that where a lot of this grant money is being allocated. I am hoping that we will be able to then get another project in the bank with the Forest Service that they would pursue environmental analysis with us on and move through the NEPA process and then I think that would be appropriate time once that project is identified to start applying for some of these larger scale grants. Go ahead. Just one thing to add. I think with the SNC grant cycle you can typically
58:53 Anticipate an implementation grant to follow a planning grant, but given the budget difficulties at the state level, we're not counting on SNC to have the money to follow up with that. So I think to your point, it would be good to look for creative solutions to fill that gap. And then Lawson, I have a quick question. Yes. I saw nearly $10,000 in unemployment assessment. So,
59:27 Again, in showing you what we get from Cassell, this is all the first lines above office supplies are related to our staffing. It's all staff things and staff items. And I'll be honest, a lot of that stuff is budgeted at the beginning of the year and what that allocation looks like for each individual. And we simply tell our budget folks, hey, we're anticipating this amount of staff.
59:57 And then those numbers are calculated. I don't really create those numbers. I think it's just based off of these leave, health insurance, all these different things that can come with these positions. And it's just an algorithm. And we work with HR and budget and say, hey, we want X amount of staff. And that's basically populated. That, oh, if you're going to hire this amount of staff, this is going to be your actual cost to government to have these staff.
1:00:28 in that arena. I mean, does that make sense or even answer the question? No, that's fine. I just noticed that it wasn't on the budget for next year and I was just wondering there's nothing in that line item for next year so I didn't know if you're anticipating that you will not have an assessment or... Let me take a look because what happened was for our budgets allocations for next year...
1:00:50 It is corrected now, but when I made this slide, the numbers weren't in the correct category, so I had to work with budget. So the spreadsheet that I gave you guys, I made because the one in Cassell, dollars were put in the wrong spot, and we have since remedied that with our budget folks. So that's why that one looks slightly different. I can provide you all, if it's appropriate as well, what...
1:01:14 This exact document I have up on the screen looks like now. I can provide that, but in prep for this, I did not have that. Yep, because some money was in the wrong spot, and we worked through that and moved it around. That $10,000 that was allocated, is that part of our $12,000 that we have under budget that was left? So we allocated, sorry, I didn't look at this as close as I could have, we allocated $10,000 for unemployment. Is that what you said? We spent.
1:01:44 We spent. Yes. We didn't allocate. And so I noticed on next year's budget, there was nothing allocated. Yeah, and I can certainly get some more information from you guys on what this looks like. But like I said, we're primarily just identifying the amount of staff that we have. And then these numbers are populated through the system. Rob, maybe? Yeah, sometimes there are expenses that are not understood to begin with.
1:02:13 Or not identified in the front of the year, meaning they're just not something we budget for. And when they do show up, like this particular one, it is distributed based on number of bodies. And so that's how it ended up here. And so we can work through with the accounting department just exactly how those distributions occur and get some more information to provide to you all on that.
1:02:42 Yeah, and I wasn't necessarily asking how. I mean, I understand that there is a cost. I'm just wondering why it was, but now I understand why it wasn't accounted for for next year, anticipated for next year, but it sounds like it has been. That's been corrected. All right. You mentioned that we purchased a snowmobile. Where in the budget did that come from? Is that Measure R? Is that separate? I believe that came out of the
1:03:13 Vehicle Fund, did it not, Rob? It was out of general fund. We do quarterly reviews, and that was requested from Lawson to augment the program, and so that came out of general fund dollars. All right. Inyo National Forest Program of Work, I believe I've engaged you all on this in the past, but
1:03:43 This is for things that we would want to do that would require a higher level of NEPA analysis or require us to contract NEPA that we would want to request of the Inyo National Forest. The end of the forest fiscal year is September 30th, so usually we would like to submit this to the Inyo National Forest maybe roughly 10 days before that.
1:04:09 And then what happens is in early September, I will want to bring your suggestions as well as our suggestions to Town Council to then get their final of what they would like to see on the Inyo National Forest program of work. In past years, of course, we've had SHARP on there, we've had land acquisition items, trying to maybe acquire some land near the airport to help with those operations.
1:04:35 In the past, we have also done collaborative efforts on fuels management due to the importance of the ESCCRP for this particular area. I have some things written down on here. Of course, Sharp is always on there as well. We'll want the continuation of Sharp. But just want to engage you all. Any other that maybe some of your constituents have said to you that they would like to see and keeping in mind again that this is stuff that's going to require high
1:05:04 Higher-level NEPA, you know, not Andrew going out and fixing maybe a bridge in kind that broke, you know, a small bridge. This would be for sharp type-scale NEPA projects or land acquisition, which is a big thing. So I just wanted to engage you all. Do you have any suggestions in this regard for the Inyo National Forest Program of Work?
1:05:28 Are there things here that you like that you would maybe like to see, things that I haven't listed? Can you remind us about Shady Rest? That was diverted because the forest didn't want to focus on two projects at once, is that right? Andrew might be able to provide some information on that as well, but I believe it was a high-quality planning endeavor that then was presented to the forest for
1:05:58 Actionable implementation, and it was then stated that there was not capacity to accomplish that? Andrew, am I? Yeah. So, Shady Rest. Inyo Craters is what you're talking about. That was a planning project that was funded through the California Green Sticker OHV Fund. And a lot of work went into that. And when we did bring it to the forest. So, in order to kick off that
1:06:25 Planning, we got approval from the forest to do that planning, but then sometime down the line there was some change in leadership at the forest and leadership at the time urged us that they didn't have the staff to move that planning project anywhere and so that they kind of encouraged us to basically cease and desist and give the money back to the state. So the state would be keen to
1:06:54 to open up that project with us again. And since that time, there has been another change in leadership at the forest. But what I've been hearing from the current forest leadership is very similar. Staffing capacity, not a lot of will to reboot that project. So we will keep our
1:07:20 Ear to the ground and try and find the right time to bring that thing back up, but I don't think right now, I think, as you said, get sharp done and then think about what our next priority project is going to be. Yeah, and piggybacking on those comments, think about this as well, and every single year we have submitted this, we get a reply from the Inyo that basically says we can do one thing. We generally submit five things, but what this does...
1:07:42 I agree with Andrew. We want to finish sharp right now. But having something like Shrick or one of these other projects if you would prefer on that document kind of sets the tone for the next project in the pipeline. So thank you for that, Andrew.
1:08:09 But any questions, comments, things that you would like to see, things that you wouldn't want to see? So is it more, is it related to the size of Shrick or just the idea of another project? As I understand it, the idea of another project. I think right now, I mean, Shrick is a big project as well. I personally believe with a lot of the e-bike issues that we're seeing on the landscape, Shrick could address some of those, which is why I potentially like it as a next.
1:08:37 Proposal, you know, for the Inyo once we complete Sharp. But I was under the impression it was a bit more of a capacity issue and that they really only have the capacity to pursue Sharp with us right now. Well, so the original idea that started the project in the first place, the Forest Service had an idea to study everything from the Forest Service here, Shady Rest, to June Lake. It was not going to be kicked off until
1:09:05 Someone proposed commercial building in the area. At the time, Mammoth Mountain was still looking at potentially joining Mammoth in June. That's how the project got started in the first place. I was very surprised when it took on a life of its own and became this project with green sticker funding. I'm not sure I would have even supported it at the time because I'm not sure what the need was at the time for that.
1:09:31 You know, the amount of money it takes and the NEPA process and everything else on a landscape that's got some pretty well-defined trail systems and everything else that we've worked our tail off to get already. So the history is a bit weird on this one, and I'm a bit cloudy on its importance, actually, at this point in time. There's single-track motorized and non-motorized in it. There's so much that's already happening. What are we looking for with Shrek?
1:10:02 What is it trying to lead us to? Can I respond to that one? So I think the, you know, at the kickoff of that project, we went to a lot of local user groups and what we were hearing loud and clear was obviously we have a lot of a dearth of double track, right? Dirt roads. But motorized, you know, dirt bike riders basically are fearing for their life out there on the double track. What would the...
1:10:32 Rise in side-by-side traffic, which those things go really fast and folks weren't feeling safe. So they're either not riding or riding their own trails that they just put in to avoid using those roads. And if you look at the current motorized single track system out there, there's 11 miles on the Mammoth Ranger District. So, you know, compare that to hundreds of miles of roads and those 11 miles don't even connect to each other. They may using
1:11:01 Bootleg Trails, but on a map, they don't connect. So you've got these little disjointed half-mile segments. So the idea of the project was, let's make a route that makes sense that people can actually ride that's going to be fun and usable and safe. Again, the Forest Service itself had plans for a lot more single track than those 11 miles that were partially funded years ago through the Green Sticker Group. I worked with Forest Service personnel on helping lay out some of those. They never came to fruition.
1:11:30 But I promise you, somewhere the Forest Service has a map showing a fairly substantial single-track system out there. I was under the impression that a lot of the work had already gone into the environmental on that, but you never can tell. Yeah, that'd be great to try and dig up if you still have contacts over at the forest that might know where that information lies. All my contacts at the forest are pretty much retired or dead. Sorry, I shouldn't put it that way.
1:11:59 Andrew, thank you so much for that. And just one more comment to add to that. E-bikes are motorized. E-bikes are motorized. So I think that's where Schrick, I think, really makes sense as a potential next project. We're running into talking about all these issues with e-bikes, all of these different things. And right now, e-bikes are motorized. And that would create more opportunity for e-bike users.
1:12:24 Staging, you know, out of Shady Rest and being able to connect to the June Lake area, connect these other trails like Andrew described. So that's where I really felt the benefits were of Shrick potentially being the next larger scale project that we move to, along with addressing where we really lack opportunity. What we're trying with Sharp, to jump on Andrew's point, what we're trying with Sharp is to address the lack of single track non-motorized around here. And, of course, to address the fact that...
1:12:52 The bunch of illegal trails were put in on the landscape as a result. And what, 11 miles of motorized, you know, multi-use single track with the advent of e-bikes. I feel this really addresses a condition on the ground that's needed. And it probably does. I have a fear that most of you don't have because of how long I've been in this process. Every time I've seen a project like that come to fruition in the Forest Service, it has created closures, not openings.
1:13:18 So I have that, I'm sorry, I just have that natural fear for what a project like this creates. You know, I worked on the travel management plan, which was a fiasco, and we ended up losing 1,000 miles of essentially double-track trails on the forest because of it. I just have this... Fair enough. Yeah. So if Schrick is this big project that the forest may or may not move forward with,
1:13:49 I feel like we have so much momentum with SHARP, especially if we can get NEPA done in April. I think there might be some, maybe a smaller project we can propose to keep moving forward with this addition of trails. My first thought would be like somewhere around Mountain View or Earthquake Dome or somewhere along that general area.
1:14:18 to propose a smaller project that would still provide more trails in directly adjacent to town. And this just seems like the only direction from town that we're not. I totally see your point there. I think it's a good point. One thing I do want to mention is if we put, first of all, these are usually listed in some sort of order.
1:14:47 Like, what is our number one priority for you? Number two, Sharp's going to be number one. We want to continue that. Unless something comes up or, you know, if town council has some sort of other direction, that will be number one. And putting Shrick on there would not preclude us from finishing. Again, usually what the forest does anyway is they just say one project. But I do like that idea in a sense that it could
1:15:14 Create maybe an opportunity for them to say, oh, well, maybe this one's a little smaller. Maybe we can do this one instead of something larger like Shrick. So duly noted there. And I can work with Andrew and maybe we can come up with some stuff there. It seems like we as a town, as the trails, have to take those first steps of either getting archaeological or something like that before the forest will even really
1:15:43 Start to get going on stuff. Well, and that's what we liked about Shrek, too, is a lot of those, like, it would still need to go through a NEPA process, right? But a lot of the planning had been done. And that groundwork that you're talking about, that important groundwork, including community buy-in, all of those things, those were done for those projects. So that's part of the reason I had it on there as well, is a good kind of natural next one. But I see what you're saying. I totally see what you're saying, and I think it's a good idea. Yeah.
1:16:12 Lawson, quick question. During SHRIC, I remember there was also a movement towards getting an OHV staging and an OSV staging, and has that just disappeared? No, I don't think it's disappeared. Anything related to snow, the Inyo's lumpen into subpart C right now. And that kind of brings me to the comment that I have here related to expanded grooming and wanted your input on.
1:16:37 Being that subpart C might be on an indefinite hold, and being that our expanded grooming was in part of subpart C, maybe do we want to ask the forest to pull that out of there and work with us on that? But as it relates to those, any trailheads related to subpart C or related to winter are probably going to stay in subpart C. We can certainly ask the forest if those types of things can be pulled out of there. In terms of OHV trailheads, we haven't really worked much.
1:17:07 At least since I've been here with the forest in that regard. They are usually the holders of kind of the OHV grants and usually do those different things. But seeing the writing on the wall right now, being that BLM did not receive an OHV grant this year, and I do not believe the Inyo did either, that we may need to be taking on a larger role with some of that in the future. But no, I don't really have much in the way of...
1:17:32 You know, kind of updates on the Inyo's pursuit of those endeavors. We had one planned for out at Shady Rest, and it was going to double OHV in the summer and OSV in the winter. Yeah, and we had obviously discussed the Shady Rest parking area and the OSV process, Rob, you were a part of that as well. We can talk to the forest about that. The town manager generally meets with Fred relatively consistently, and maybe that's a Fred.
1:18:01 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:18:29 We were told by the Inyo National Forest that, oh, you know, we're doing subpart C, let's put it in with subpart C and analyze it. But maybe a question for the program of work is, hey, can we pull this out? Because we don't know what subpart C is going to be moving forward again. Our expanded grooming is primarily a non-motorized section, right? Yes. Which to me doesn't belong in subpart C regardless. Some of it would be, I think, in the...
1:18:54 Some of it extends into the forest further that would be more multi-use grooming. So it's not all non-motorized grooming. But yes, I see your point there as well. But with complete unknowns related to subpart C, do we want to pull it out and say, hey, Fred, will you guys maybe consider looking at this separately so that we can move it along? I don't know, but just a thought. Have we had updates?
1:19:20 From the Forest Service on the subpart C process? I have not. I have not had what I would consider a formal update besides being told that it is on hold. It is on hold. On hold here on the Inyo? Correct. Yes. Correct. Yep. And I think a lot of that stems from the departure of Aaron Nesser, who we know and worked with during that project. I don't know that, but that is, the timing was similar. They pretty much lost the whole crew that was working on the project. Yep. So, yeah.
1:19:53 I think it was then dropped on Courtney's plate, the new NEPA planner, who then has since been detailed out to a new position. Oh, was it? Okay. Yeah. Yep. Thank you, Andrew. Still does not have a captain. Looking at your, if these are in perspective order, the snow storage, and I know that's not something for this group, but that is of such huge importance to me and to this town that I would probably place it at a higher level of importance. Yep.
1:20:23 If we don't get something and we were to have another large winter, even as big as the end of last winter was, we're in potential trouble. And again, I can engage, I'm going to engage council similarly, pardon me, council similarly, work with the town manager as well on this. And I don't know, we could also, if council has some very specific direction on this before we submit things to the Inyo, you know, we...
1:20:53 We could get your guys' eyes on that as well if you wanted to take a look at it. You know, you don't necessarily have to tell me I want one, two, three, and four, but not five and six, but just kind of wanted to get this in front of you, just general ideas as we move forward. I have a couple quick questions. Can you just clarify, is the grooming the, just the shady rest area or the pilot program out at Sherwood? So the expanded... Part C.
1:21:22 Or affected by subpart C? So in subpart C is any areas that we requested to groom that we currently do not groom now. All the stuff that we groom now is in the system. In the pilot program? It seemingly continues every single year. Yeah, it's part of the trial system. When did that change? Was it just this last year? Or was it official?
1:21:50 Yeah, I would have to go back and look at my records, but what governs this is we have basically a non-funded challenge cost share with the forest that governs all of this stuff, and in that, that line out at the base of the Sherwins is part of our normal grooming operations, and when we submit to them, they sign off on it. Yep. So anything that we're looking at here is outside of that stuff. Yep. New proposed grooming, which I believe we presented to this.
1:22:19 I believe we presented to this to you guys last year, I believe? Yeah. So I know that any other place where we groom, it is considered non-motorized. Or when you look at the maps that we looked at for subpart C, so Inyo Craters and Shady Rest Area, and it wasn't official out.
1:22:47 at our pilot program. Is that going to be non-motorized since it is now part of our grooming? So we don't make those designations. The forest does. We are simply a grooming entity on public land. We go and do that work. So subpart C would be the process that works that out, right? The area where we groom between Shady, I'm sorry.
1:23:15 Yes, I'm sorry, between Shady Campground and Shady Park, that area already had that designation of non-motorized. And then we groomed it. Yep, go ahead. Yeah, sorry to jump in. I think that is part of the rationale for punting the analysis of our expanded grooming request to move along with subpart C because we don't want our expanding grooming to inform
1:23:39 The decisions about what types of uses are allowed where. We want those decisions to be made and then groom where is appropriate after the fact. Yes, we are the grooming entity and the forest makes those decisions for their land. So outside of this, but since we're talking about grooming, I'm going to add this in there. Since it looks like we will take over the grooming program from the forest, which should have happened, we've had that conversation. The bulk of that,
1:24:11 is on existing roads, and when the NEPA was done originally, neg decks were done on all of that because it wasn't necessary. Subpart C is saying it's necessary, but even subpart C doesn't say it's necessary on existing roadways. Could we ask the Forest Service if we take that over? If we could groom, there's several crossovers if you follow the steam line from Shady to 203.
1:24:40 So to me, I think...
1:25:09 I think those things are possible, but with the scope and scale of this project, we'll talk about this in a second. As it relates to that grooming, I would want to ensure that we have the knowledge, the capacity, and the skill to take care of what is already out there on the landscape first. And then I think we could cross those bridges and have those conversations once we...
1:25:38 We know we can do it. We become confident. We're providing the highest level of service possible. I think we could, at that point, maybe definitely have those conversations. But I wouldn't want to bite off more right off the bat. That's my gut instinct. It's just an idea that popped into this little brain. If I don't spit it out there, I lose it. So from my understanding, that groomer that the Forest Service has that's OSV funds, the green sticker funds, cannot be used for non-motorized.
1:26:06 Technically, that is true. However, it's used for non-motorized on a daily basis on the international forest. All of the trails in the glass mountain area and the glass flow area, whatever you want to call that, are groomed with that groomer. We, as a snowmobile association, went years ago to the green sticker folks and said, look, this makes no sense. We can double what we are providing by allowing...
1:26:34 Non-motorized to be groomed, and we got permission to do that. I thought at the time that that was written into the contract. I found out only years later that it actually wasn't. So what you're saying is technically true, but there's been this under-the-table agreement that that groomer can be used for other purposes as well. Otherwise, there would be no grooming north of Mammoth. That would not happen. And the motorized community has always been in favor.
1:27:04 We don't want it to be taken and used primarily for that. But anything, and John's a big part of the motorized community as well, anything we can do to create opportunity for recreation is beneficial to us all here. That's my take on it anyway. But I'll back you guys up here real quick. We're definitely going to talk about OSV and that larger program. Any other suggestions potentially for program work? Otherwise, maybe
1:27:36 I can continue to work with the town manager and write something up and possibly be able to submit it to you guys or email it to you guys for your comments, if you had any comments, if that maybe is a solid approach, but I just want to make sure we're, before we jump to the next one, that there weren't any other pressing things related to the program work, and I can certainly draft it up and shoot a letter out. I just, I guess I want some clarification regarding how
1:28:04 Some of these things on this list I see are totally related to trails and some of them not so much. Yes. When you say that the forest allows one program of work, is that from the town in general? So we as a trails committee, we're not just suggesting trail related.
1:28:29 Program of work. We're looking at the scope of what's needed and we're trying to put that in, you know, an order that we think is reasonable or because we are a trails committee, you know, I'm thinking I want to focus on getting more trails. Yeah, I would, that's where I would want your focus to lie, I think, is more the trails end of things. I do have these other items on here to inform that, yes, this is a request overall from the town of Mammoth Lakes, not just.
1:28:57 Me or not just Andrew or not just the Office of Outdoor Recreation or the trail system. So there will be some other larger scale items in here like land acquisition, you know, for the airport. But I think for you guys and council will give their two cents from that all-encompassing level as well related to this. But I think for your purposes, focusing on more of the trails type things is the type of input.
1:29:23 I would love for you guys. I mean, you can tell me, you know, other things that you're feeling, no problem, but I think that's where your focus should lie. Right. And then, you know, kind of piggybacking on what was said earlier regarding just how long we've been focusing on SHARP. I mean, I remember going to a meeting maybe in 2005. I don't know when it was the first meeting I went to regarding this.
1:29:49 And Andrew said, you know, like, is there a point at which we pivot? I don't know. But do we want to discuss that as a committee? You know, like, how much longer are we going to hold out for this when we have the shrick on the back burner? Like, can we move forward on that? There's so much, there's no water out there. You're less likely to have the archaeological. We all know that. But I don't know if that's for another meeting.
1:30:17 But I think it's something we as a committee need to think about. Like, we can only put one thing forward. And we've been doing this for, I've been on the committee for six years, eight years. I don't know how long I've been on the committee. And we're in this kind of, I mean, we've made progress. Totally. We have made so much more progress in the last year and a half, and I recognize that. But, like, when do we pull the plug? And I just kind of want to put that out to all of you.
1:30:45 It seems like there's been a lot of progress in the past year in Sharp. So it's hard for me to think about stopping when there's actually been momentum moving forward and there's a discussion at least of a start date when projects can be moved forward. So rather than this ambiguous big project that seems like there's some sort of movement, it's hard for me to think about.
1:31:16 I think booting another project before, you know, I mean, there is the world that Sharp never gets completed and that's insane, but optimistically,
1:31:45 You know, we complete SHARP and then we kind of have a playbook of, okay, this is what worked, this is what didn't work. Now we have kind of a track record of, oh, okay, the Forest Service has agreed that they can share avoidance data sets with me, which is a big step, right? Before we were just kind of planning based on...
1:32:05 General topography and not actually knowing where the areas that we had to avoid were. So I think we made a lot of wins in terms of process so that our next process should go a lot smoother optimistically, but I think it's really important to get this one completed so that we have all those lessons learned in the barn. I have no problem getting that completed if we can get there. Part of my suggestion would be that for the next project, before we identify it, so
1:32:36 Sharp was, we took that to the Forest Service. That was started here, created by locals, moved to the Forest Service. It wasn't something they went looking for. Perhaps the next large thing, we need to sit down with them before we say, here's what we want, and say, let's talk about what we can produce together and come up with a program that they're willing to entertain right off the bat so we aren't twisting their arm the whole way.
1:33:07 Collaborative effort that we need better than we've seen to move everything else we want forward. I mean, that's just politics A1, sorry. It's the way we've got to create a relationship better than what we've had for the last 10 years with the Forest Service. Yeah, couldn't agree more there. I think that's a good way to approach things. We don't want to feel like these are Town of Mammoth Lakes projects. We want to feel like they are
1:33:35 Inyo National Forest Projects with the Town of Mammoth Lakes partner support, and I just think that's a great way to get to that point, is to sit down and do that. I think Andrew, myself, Gretchen, we've all worked really, really hard to maintain positive working relationships with the Forest Service. The Town Manager, I think, has really amped up his interaction as well with the District Ranger, which I think is important, because that is ultimately the decision maker, and build that trust.
1:34:04 I think that's one of the main things. We're not here to destroy the ecosystem. We're not here to just build recreation for recreation's sake. We want to address conditions on the ground and do it sustainably. I can talk a little bit about that since this seems a little odd. Fred and I have monthly one-to-one meetings. The intent of those meetings are to sort of improve the partnership and to
1:34:31 Create a better understanding of the situations that both of us are facing, right? So we talked, just the two of us, about challenges that we're having and how we can partner and help each other in those areas. That's been very productive, in my opinion, because we've been able to establish a general level of understanding that wasn't there before. As Lawson was alluding to, how we are
1:34:54 We are trying to be stewards of the land and protect that just as much as anybody else is in the development of the things that we're doing to support visitors, right? So we're also doing a tremendous amount in their space to help them accomplish things and achieve things that they just simply cannot get done. We have resources, we have capabilities, and we have the willingness to lean in on that stuff.
1:35:23 recognized by Fred, how we are partnering and what he can come to depend on with us. So I think we're going to continue to build that. We have another one on Monday afternoon. So it's been very, very helpful. I'll just give two cents on the program of work here. I like the first two items in their places. I think that the Shady Resigno Craters Project.
1:35:52 I think could be lowered on this list a little bit because I think the snow storage issue and the fuels management are two pretty high priority issues. Unfortunately, I think, you know, as our duties, or not our duties, but as our role in looking at trails and getting people out into the forest and using these things, I think we got to look at these fuels managements and the urgency that some of that takes prior to rebooting.
1:36:20 A program that would potentially get more people out into more of the forest areas. I think we really got to nip this fuels management stuff in the butt, unfortunately, coming onto our desks as the town and not the forest. Thank you. Well, either way, I will draft a letter up, and again, we will continue to have these conversations with town council as well and see what we can get moved forward. Anything else related to program work? Copy that.
1:36:55 Okay. The Inyo National Forest OSV program. We are pursuing this. We spoke with you all and received some of your initial support for this as well as some of the town council. Currently the state is working to move the agreement over to us so that we can take on this grooming program. We think we can provide a very high level of service.
1:37:24 And really help create a good experience while, I won't mince words, being more reliable in our grooming schedule out there. But this will necessitate more support. And I wanted to start the conversation with you all. We're not there yet in terms of making this decision. Obviously, council will want to weigh in on this decision as well. How do we do this? With the understanding that roughly $33,000...
1:37:53 from the agreement with the state can be devoted to an individual effectively. We have discussed at length with Rob and within our own shop the positives and benefits of either a seasonal taking on this role or a permanent position may be needed within our shop. Obviously, any position can be supported with state funding.
1:38:20 And again, the way the agreement is currently written, and we are taking the agreement as is from the forest, obviously, if we have more needs later down the road, we can adjust fire, but that roughly $30,000 or $33,000 can go towards salary for grooming or support of the grooming program, signage, things of that nature. In our discussions, we really saw the benefits of a permanent position, just in terms of reliability.
1:38:50 Information Retention. This is a complex program. You need to get to know 90 miles of trail out there, the ins and outs of those trails, how to drive a complex piece of equipment, a piston bully, and maintain some of that institutional knowledge over the years. And we really just felt that a permanent position is the best way to do that. Obviously, funding will dictate some of this. Council direction will dictate some of this.
1:39:18 But just wanted to have an initial conversation with you all. And of course, if a formal proposal comes forward here and what we want to do, we will want to engage you on that. But anything that you see in this realm, I think ideally, if we got the most ideal seasonal humanly possible, who came in here, was willing to learn about the program, came back each year, I think
1:39:42 That would be a really great and possibly even an ideal situation. But any of us who have hired seasonals in the past, that can be difficult. It can be difficult to bring those folks on, seasonal type of employment, cost of living in Mammoth, which is why we really felt for continuity's sake, permanent position would maybe be the better option. But wanted to get some initial thoughts from you all. Go ahead. Are you thinking...
1:40:09 Full-time, part-time, how does that balance? I should have elaborated a little more. It would be a full-time position, and we really felt that there was a need to have somebody at that permanent level with that kind of institutional knowledge helping in the trails program in the summer months as well. If we're going to be building 20 miles of sharp trail, doing all this different stuff, we still have signage install, Mr. Mulford will be spread thin, and we really saw the benefit of potentially having somebody.
1:40:37 With that kind of continuity of a permanent position to be able to help in the summer months as well. But yes, full-time position. We anticipate somebody being in that groomer six days a week. If we're going to provide the level of service over a 90-mile trail system that often could require two to three days to groom the whole trail system, let alone buff outs, things of that nature, that it would be a full-time endeavor.
1:41:02 Let me add a little bit of context as well. So the town of Mammoth Lakes and other areas where we have part-time staff have been shifting to what we call a hybrid position where they have a function both in the summertime and in the wintertime because we were typically having part-time staff in the summer and then part-time staff in the winter. So you find one body who can perform both of those functions across that time. You're not fighting for a very tight labor market.
1:41:29 Seasonal employees, which is what occurs here in the Town of Mammoth Lakes. We also have some restrictions that occur with a part-time employee. They have to work roughly 960 hours a maximum with us, so they do have some limitations on what they can do. But I'll also say that a permanent position is significantly more costly from our benefit package cost perspective than seasonals, and it's roughly four to one. So I could have four seasonals for one full-time position.
1:41:58 And cost equivalency. So no decisions have been made on this whatsoever, but we are weighing different opportunities in how we bring that thing forward. But we have current part-time staff in the summer working on the trails. And so that would be seeking possibly to have one of those positions perform the full year. So for all the benefits that Lawson indicated, full-time is definitely the benefit, but there's a cost to it.
1:42:27 Also within the town, you know, full-time employment is a sort of coveted need for many departments, and we as a group weigh, the leadership team weighs the need in this particular space versus other needs within the organization when we do a full-time position. So the seasonal is pretty easy to do because it's on and off.
1:42:54 But it's more dynamic to create this permanent level position. So that's just a little bit more background. Yes, thank you, Rob. Yeah, so I can throw in two cents. It's, you know, I grew up with a town. We did seasonal for everything. And then finally, if you find the right person, it makes sense to transfer. I mean, you know, turn it into a full-time as long as the work was there.
1:43:25 I started seasonally. I wouldn't hire an ice rink person to, you know, learn how to run the Zamboni or the Olympia and say, you're now full-time, you know, unless there was a summertime position that they could overlap on. So, it just, you know, it depends. I think that part of the Forest Service issue was that they were running a part-time groomer.
1:43:55 To drive that piece of equipment is a very specialized skill. Not everybody can get into a piece of heavy equipment and drive it. So I would lean towards, as Rob was saying, the hybrid type position, although that hybrid may both live within the trails, so it just becomes a full-time. But if you look at the money involved, and Rob would have to tell us what the average employee costs to town an hour, but...
1:44:24 If you do the 33 at 20, 80 hours, it adds 16 bucks an hour to the cost of that year-around employee that the grooming adds into it, which I'm assuming is about half of the cost of a full-time employee, a little less than half the cost. So it certainly helps to improve the funding for a full-time employee that can do a lot of things for us. Since the program changed,
1:44:54 And the maintenance is no longer covered in the grant because the state does all the maintenance on the machine and pays for all the fuel on the machine, as I understand the last iteration of it. All we're really talking about is the person to drive it and maintain the trail system. And there are going to be a lot of days in the winter where he's probably not on that, but perhaps on a private snowmobile out checking orange diamonds and blue diamonds and all of those other things that exist out there.
1:45:24 That are part of the trail system. Just to add a little bit of context as well, like Rob said, nothing's set in stone, but one of the scenarios that we've kind of been talking about is probably for myself to be the main cat operator with someone that we could train up to be the backup slash doing it three days a week likely and helping out with those duties. And we've got a candidate.
1:45:55 Rick Laborde, who's potentially offered to help out with training and be a part-time employee. So I think that could be one scenario that I could see having a high chance of success is him training me and the two of us handling it for the first season. No one knows the program better than Rick. Exactly. If I want to take that program over, that's kind of a stipulation that I added in. I would like to learn from the person who created the program and who has the most...
1:46:24 Kind of skin in the game, so to speak. Well, and it works well for me, because we only give you 10 bucks an hour, don't we? Exactly. No, thank you for that, Andrew, as well. Yeah, this would all fall under the purview of the trails program manager and Andrew, obviously, with my support. So thank you for that addition. I'm very pro this full-time position, permanent, but I do think about lower snow years and not being able to have that
1:46:55 OSB grant money come in. Is that something that has been thought about or discussed at all? Yeah, we have discussed that. And obviously, I lived on the other side of this for a while working over at the Inyo. And generally speaking, even on low snow years, you're still able to get out there and groom a good amount. And again, with the level of service that we would want to provide out there, I don't...
1:47:20 To me, and this is me personally and I could learn from experience or Andrew and myself could learn from experience down the road that I'm definitely not correct that grooming days and ensuring we have enough days to get in the groomer is not going to be an issue. That's my personal belief based on our analysis thus far entirely possible.
1:47:41 Could have a crazy year or something like that. But even in some of the low years here, even the Inyo at the level of service that they were providing were getting in the cat a good amount and not giving much of this money back. So I do believe that even on the low snow years, as it relates to potential permanent versus a seasonal, that there is work. And even on the low snow years when the whole program can't be groomed, although that very seldom happens, as I said earlier, there's a lot of work for this person to be doing.
1:48:11 And maintaining the trails and going out and doing work on the trails that can be put into the OSV program that the state will pay for. Because maintaining the signage on the trails and doing all of that is covered under that position that you can use that money for all of that. Yeah, and I would like to think we could have a conversation with the state in that scenario. Like, hey, you know, hasn't been snowing much. Let's route some of this money that's meant to supposed to be grooming and we're actually going to go out and...
1:48:38 Fix a bunch of signs or do X, Y, or Z. And the state and myself and Andrew's conversations with the state, they seem to be quite flexible and were extremely happy that we were willing to take over this program from the forest. They made that extremely clear that they were very happy that we were willing to take this on. My recommendation would be to make it a permanent position. It's a lot harder for somebody to
1:49:08 to leave when they're not posed with that decision twice a year, whether or not to leave or not. Also recommend requesting more dollars. Our winter can be six months out of the year. It'd be good to have a decent salary for that person. And then throw them into maybe some maintenance, trail maintenance program in the summer. It sounds like we're going to get some new equipment for trail building, get them on board with that, and maybe can take Andrew off of some of the just small people management during the summertime.
1:49:37 Yeah, needless to say, you know, this $33,000, we would obviously, if we're going to hire a position, you know, permanent position, we need to supplement that, you know, through our coffers. But right now, this is basically the max that could be devoted to a staff person. But great comments. Any other related to this one? All right.
1:50:04 I'm going to move it along. I'll stop on this one real quick. I probably should have brought this up when we were talking about the biking. But one of the main things that I wanted to show you here is just what those speed and data collection devices are going to look like. So you'll see those. What's really nice, if you're speeding, you can pop a little message below it, like, slow down, or whatever you want on those. So looking forward to getting those. They'll be coming in here soon. Bear ahead. Yeah, bear ahead, exactly.
1:50:31 All right. Here's another one that we are just kind of in the preliminary stages of discussing and, of course, wanted to bring to your attention. Right off the bat, we will obviously address this again, I think, when we have a more formal proposal. Also, you know, the land sale up there needs to be completed as well, but I'm actually going to hand the ball over here to Mr. Mulford to kind of briefly describe what we were thinking in terms of development up at the quote-unquote foundation site.
1:51:01 Where we currently have the dog park going in, as well as some daycare infrastructure. But, Andrew, you mind jumping in? Sure. So, yeah, to the north of that map would be, you know, the school and the trails, and then you've got the college there. And in between the new dog park and the daycare is roughly an acre in that forested section there, and then going up onto the hillside a little more room.
1:51:28 There's been strong community support for a bike park, especially since losing some of the informal facilities that we had over where the new affordable housing has been built. And just a strong need. We've got world-class everything, pretty much. And this is something where we're really lacking. So Ben Comfort has been kind of spearheading.
1:51:56 A local petition, he's got over 300 signatures of folks that are in support of this project. Silver on the Parks and Rec Commission has been sort of engaged in this process. Several of us went out there and did a site visit and just looked at the feasibility of a bike park there. We think that it ticks a lot of the boxes. You know, existing parking, existing restroom facilities.
1:52:22 Right next to the bike path so folks wouldn't have to drive there. The right landscape and so we're excited about the potential of that location for a bike park. You know, preliminary talks. We'd want to bring in, you know, a world-class outfit that does these things to design it and help us build it. And then it'd be a parks and rec facility that the Office of Outdoor Rec trail crew would assist with as appropriate.
1:52:55 Thank you, Andrew. Just wanted to bring this to your attention. It was actually brought down as well from the diocese council, potential interest in us looking into this site, so wanted to bring it to your attention. Any questions, comments? I like the bike park. If there's a space, I don't know if it's been discussed for a small outdoor amphitheater, it would be awesome. It has been discussed, and it exists on some of the original earlier drawings.
1:53:23 Yeah, that's correct. The forested section right there has been sort of reviewed as that for an opportunity. But what I'm unsure about is the extension of the playground for the child care facility into that space and if there's enough room for that to exist. But that was originally looked at. There's other sites as well for the outdoor amphitheaters. I'm in full support of this. I like the idea. I think it'd be awesome to develop that site.
1:53:54 Connected, I mean, the college is right there, the schools are right there. Connect those things as much as possible. Seems like a great spot for some of these activities. There's the site in Bishop now. Have you guys been in communication with Bishop Recreation on any of their perspectives on that, how much it's been utilized? Go ahead, Andrew. Big enough area. Thanks.
1:54:26 So Keith Roberts is a good friend and fellow trail builder that used to work at Mammoth Mountain. He and I built the Meadow Trail Connector together. He's kind of spearheading construction down there. All I know is that it's very popular with young adults and they're working on some dirt jumps to kind of satisfy some of the...
1:54:49 Variety of users that would want to use it. So I think currently they've had a hard time keeping up with demand, basically. They've got some facilities, but they need more. That, yeah, we can talk more offline, but that's all I got. Thanks. And then size this versus that, this area, what we would be able to use? Does anyone have any idea on that? Meaning just is there enough room for what we want? Yeah, yeah, I think there is. And again, we're at the beginning.
1:55:19 Kind of the beginning stages of this, but just want to plant the seed with you all and maybe just garner some initial support to keep looking into it. Dogs and bikes. That's a good combo. I know the dogs will be fenced in, so I'm just kidding. You know, with the bike parks, we've been to the one in Truckee several times, and it looks like a ton of maintenance. So it's like some things like skate parks also require a ton of maintenance, but they're...
1:55:48 You know, made out of concrete, so they're pretty durable. It's just who's going to take it over and, you know, shape it and run it and water it, all that stuff. Yeah, no, duly noted, and those are things we will need to work through and come up with a plan with and really try to figure out how much maintenance it will take and, you know, see about community volunteer groups who may want to be vested in something like this. So these are all things we're exploring.
1:56:16 I guess one more note, you know, just looking at the Bishop one briefly, I remember they have this exercise center with some interesting equipment. Might be a potential idea in addition to that. Anything else on this site? Moving it along, and actually I'm going to hand this one over to Mr. Mulford here as well to discuss. We again are...
1:56:45 We have not made a final decision. I think a lot of this will depend on, you know, sharp progresses, which we are very optimistic of, but looking at the option here in the future of bringing a proposal to you all for the purchase of this small trail dozer, which Andrew will describe. We have not worked out necessarily yet how we would pay for this, but we were thinking possibly a combination of a drop to trail and measure R, but I will hand it to Andrew to describe why we feel this would be a really beneficial piece of equipment.
1:57:13 Thanks, Austin. So we were introduced to this instrument in 2017. We hosted a sustainable trail design and construction workshop and brought in some contractors, some forest service.
1:57:29 Trails Manager for Region 5 and this gentleman, Kevin Joel, who has a trail contracting company up in Reno. And he was kind enough to bring this machine down and help us build a little bit of the Meadow Trail Connector with it. And, you know, piqued my interest and I've been keeping my eyes on different tools and this one is unique in that it is 24 inches wide. And so, you know, any other machine you get is going to be 48.
1:57:58 Plus a wider blade. And that means you're cutting a really wide trail. You're having to do a lot of work to rehab that scar on the landscape to bring it back down to the 24-inch tread that you really want with a type 2 or type 3 forest service trail. So this is kind of the only tool for the job, in my opinion, for creating, you know, actual single track. The need for it, I think,
1:58:25 It's really well suited to the landscape that we would be building trails in out in Sharp. So it doesn't do great on, you know, vastly steep hill slides, but it does do really well in kind of open terrain. And, you know, given sort of the staffing, seasonal staffing woes that we go through every year, you know, our crew is excellent.
1:58:56 But in terms of bringing in talented people with years and years of trail building experience, I haven't been able to crack that nut yet. So I think in lieu of that, having this machine just gives me a lot of confidence in terms of being able to crank through the mileage once we do get it approved of Sharp. So it really hinges on getting Sharp approved. But I would hate to spend 15 years.
1:59:23 Getting to this approval and then spend another 15 years building the trails. I'd like to be able to build them pretty quick. So this tool would help us to do that. I was able to go up to their factory in Mammothouse, Nevada, which is near Sparks. But I was on my way up to California Trails and Greenways Conference and got to meet the...
1:59:50 Proprietors and the folks that make these things, they're real characters, but these things are used across the world. They've got a map of the world with little pins of where they're all at, and they're in Australia, they're in New Zealand, they're everywhere. It's kind of an industry standard in terms of a narrow-width trail dozer. It's the only one out there. It's got a really heavy belly pan on it, nice low center of gravity, so you're not worried about tipping over.
2:00:20 It's got all the bells and whistles in terms of attachments and modern California carb-compliant motor. It's kind of the bee's knees. So I got to drive it around to have a dirt playground, if you will. And I got to drive it around and test it out. And I think it's the tool for the job. A side note, it's really good at
2:00:51 Trail construction is also really good at trail maintenance in certain situations. So looking at some of our motorized trails like the geothermal line out there, you end up like, I'm sure you know, Bill, the snowmobile trails get whooped out. Same with the dirt bike trails. And we did a little bit of maintenance on that last year just to see how it would go by hand. And it doesn't really work by hand.
2:01:15 But a machine like this would make short work of, you know, smoothing out those whoops, which I think would really improve the user experience on a lot of our motorized trails in the area. So I think, you know, there's a lot of benefits to having something like this in our toolbox. And it's a bit of a steep cost, but, you know, something that you could maintain and get a lot of life out of and build a lot of, really.
2:01:45 Excellent trailhead. So I'm very supportive of adding this to our toolkit. That's all I got. Thanks, Austin. Yeah, appreciate that, Andrew. And again, we're not at a, you know, vote on something decision point yet. I just wanted to bring this to your attention and, you know, assuming the good vibes we're getting from Sharp and that all continues.
2:02:08 We will probably bring this forward to you all to maybe get an official vote on it, obviously, if we're going to be using some Measure R funding for it. Any thoughts right off the bat? I like the direction that you're going. Thank you. I also like it a lot and think that it's what we would need. How far out would we have to put in that order? Four to six months. Also, this would be a request of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board.
2:02:39 to appropriate the funds for this, both from Adopt-A-Trails and Measure R? Kim? Hello, Kim Anaclario, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. The Measure R, I believe, would come from your approved budget, your approved trails budget, correct? And if it was an additional Measure R request, yes, you would go before Mammoth Lake Trail. And that is TBD. Okay. So that would be the difference, whether it came from your...
2:03:20 Anticipated $300,000 budget or it's an additional request and adopted trail funds are not tied to any constraints. Geographic or equipment wise is just for specific use to maintain the trail system. But those monies live in Mammoth Electric Creation, the adopted trail, that's a fundraising program within that. Correct. Thank you, Kim. Would there be any funds potentially from the general fund?
2:03:50 Kind of similar to the snowmobile that was purchased out of the general fund? Would that be a possibility? We often look for things that can, something specialized like this that may be funded from, like Adopt-A-Trails, a great opportunity for that, right? It's a fairly large, I'm going to say, for lack of a better word, impactful purchase, right? So people can say, yeah, what did we do with the funding?
2:04:20 We purchased this trail dozer that builds trails, right? So that's kind of the thought process behind that. Certainly, general fund can contribute to anything council would like to provide for. So we go quarterly to review funds available, and typically what we have is a list of needs from the town organization, and suggestions like this come forward.
2:04:47 You know, partnership, I don't see any problem with that, but it would be, you know, part of a larger request probably from the other entities as well. I am going to obviously pursue grants, you know, pursue every road possible to seek alternative funding, yeah. There are some unintended consequences to Measure R when it was passed originally far different from what those of us that worked on thought.
2:05:16 The only thing that's tied to it is it has to be a town of Mammoth Lakes owned or operated facility. So when it comes to equipment, I don't know how that plays out. I don't know that you might have to do a general fund and then offset with Measure RU somewhere else. Those are games we've had to play in the past, but there would be an awful lot that would go into making that decision from my perspective anyway. Is there a possibility of working with the county?
2:05:45 As a shared piece of equipment with their trails program? Yeah, 100%. And these are things Andrew and I have discussed. What is the best approach? What is the best approach to take? Is it our machine that we could potentially contract out to an entity like Mono County, CSA1, if you guys built some trails down there? Or is it better to share the cost with another entity right off the bat? These are things I think...
2:06:10 I think we're still working through. I would obviously want the recommendations of the individual who will be using it the most to construct our trails out there and really take his recommendation seriously as it relates to that. So then if it's purchased with Measure R, would that be impeded, that sharing or that contracting out?
2:06:30 These are things I think I would still need to work out and look into. These are all great questions and all things I think that we would need to look into as part of a purchase and it would all depend on I think the monies that we use, right? If I was able to get a grant to fund the whole thing, we wouldn't have this conversation more than likely, but if not and we decide to go down those avenues with Measure R, those are things I'm going to have to 100% look into. So yeah, thank you for those comments. So maybe not because Measure R has
2:07:00 A big equipment list that's available for anybody to rent all over the county. So this might fall on the same thing. But still a few things, obviously, as you can see, you know, to work out as it relates to the funding piece and what this looks like and continuation of Sharp, but wanted to bring this to your attention. I think it's definitely something to pursue and like to vote on it in December. Copy that. Yeah, I'll just offer my support of it.
2:07:31 I like that the company is somewhat close to us, just being over near Sparks, Nevada. It seems like a reputable company. You know, the thing with machinery, you know, you always might need parts and things fixed. So I would just like to make sure that they do have parts and things like that and maybe kind of looking at what we can anticipate needing replaced in the future perhaps and hoping that it's still there. But yeah.
2:08:01 Okay. Anything else on this topic? All right. Moving right along. I wanted to bring this to your attention related to our interpretive signage simply because we are going to put roughly 10 of them, new ones, on the landscape here very, very shortly and specifically as it relates to the QR codes, which I have circled in red right there, and the fact that they don't get a lot of use. You can see on this chart on the left here, we're talking, and this is over the course of two years.
2:08:32 We're talking very minimal use on a lot of these, eight clicks, six clicks, three clicks, four clicks in two years. With 10 new interpretive signs coming in on the landscape, we wanted to engage you all on the level of effort you want us to put into this. So, give you some background here a little bit. Prior, when you click on these QRs, and this even happened when I was at the forest, one of them, you click on it,
2:08:58 It'll have a video production of somebody talking about something. One of them has me on it where it was recorded talking about various things. All of that costs money. As we put these new interpretive signs on the landscape, do you want us to continue that based on the level of use?
2:09:19 That we are seeing on this chart right here, which is extremely minimal. This first one is one of the first ones you run into on the lake space in Lake Mary Road. So people are clicking that first one and then it's kind of dying off from there. The other ones aren't getting clicked very much. My proposal for this would be to...
2:09:36 We still do the QR code thing. We still build a backend webpage for it, right? So it actually goes somewhere on Mammoth Trails. We can maybe provide some information or links for folks to more information, but based on what I'm seeing here, us spending a good amount of money to hire somebody, to bring in a camera person, to take a video of somebody, and then to do some post-production on that video to make sure it looks good, I don't know.
2:10:06 If that is the best use of our time and money based on what I am seeing here. But I wanted to engage you all and see what you thought about this. But again, my recommendation would be we do QRs, we build the back end page, right? We maybe get some links on there or some information that maybe people can just click on. But high value productions like we did in the past, do you still want to see that? So just a level of effort conversation.
2:10:34 On these QR codes. What do we think? When you say there was high level of production in the past, was that through the Trails Committee or was that Inyo National Forest? I believe that was through this office. All of this was done when I was still on the Inyo, so I can't speak with 100% certainty on that. But to my knowledge, it was the town of Mammoth Lakes in conjunction with our contractor.
2:11:04 Doing this. And it was? Yes. Are the videos related to like accessibility with or is it more just a addition to? Yeah, it's kind of an addition. Like the one I'm on where I got interviewed for it I think was an education component. And then you have me talking about education and the importance of education and connecting people to resources. So a lot of time it's a supplemental one. Like just to give you an example, one of the ones that we're putting in
2:11:34 In Mammoth Creek about, let's say, like, bark beetles. You know, we could, using this model, we'd maybe call Janet Hatfield over at Whitebark and interview her about, you know, bark beetles and maybe provide some more information than the sign provided. That's kind of how it went, but it was a little bit of, I guess, a larger scale production.
2:11:55 And had more costs associated with it. If you need some of those costs, I can look into that. I unfortunately don't have those right now. But again, looking at these numbers that you're seeing on this chart over two years, I mean, some of these signs have been clicked on once in two years. Was that your speech? Yeah, totally. Totally. That's a good one. It seems to me that the QR codes, because they're used almost universally now, the QR codes themselves are a great idea.
2:12:22 But if it's a trail sign, an informative sign that already has information on it, QR probably shouldn't do much more than to lead you to the page on the Mammoth Trails website that talks about that path and gives you the information on the path, just written knowledge to produce something that most people, I would estimate that an awful lot of these clicks
2:12:45 Wanted just a little information. And when they got to the point where your face is on the screen, they just turned it off. Yes. That's probably accurate. Whether that would be your face, my face, Rob's face makes no difference. It's just that I, so probably the usage is much less than even this. So QR code that connects you back to the trails website for that trail to give you that information, that's great. But to create product.
2:13:14 Specifically for that QR code at this point seems nonsensical. Okay, and to piggyback on that, I think the good thing about what you're saying is you can always go in and do that stuff later if there's the need. You know, you have the page. You can even make its own separate page, you know, that that QR goes to. We can hold that page, and if it is decided by this entity or others in the future that we do want to do a large-scale production, we'd still have that option or a larger-scale production. It was a good idea. You tried it out, but it's really not worth it.
2:13:43 Right. Yeah, I recommend less effort in this. I like less cell phone usage in these general areas. And service can be spotty, so I wonder if that attributes to some of this not usage of it. Leave the cell phones at home, get on the trail. Great. Any other comments? All right. That is all I had for you today. Thank you very much. All right. Thanks for that.
2:14:18 Report. We enjoyed it. Okay, where are we? Item seven, committee member reports. I know we're over, so we can keep them brief. Is that if I start on your end, Bill? Oh, sorry. Look at me. I was ready to go there. All right. Sorry, Kim. Policy matters number six. Yes, this is me again, where since we missed the last meeting, I wanted to present to you all.
2:14:51 are proposed for your approval budget for fiscal year 24-25. Let me share my screen again here. I don't think you will see much too different here. With a lot of this stuff, you will see that the overall dollar amount is the same that we are requesting. $300,000, you will see that added a little more into that winter grooming line since we went over last time.
2:15:32 And you will see that under the planning segment, I changed that to a more general line item for planning before it was more specific to sharp and things of that nature. And being that a lot of the planning was done, I just built that in just in case, but built in more general trails planning. But yeah, I think much of what you will see on here is similar to previous years. Obviously,
2:15:59 We have gone into year two with our contractor, which is $100,000. You can see, obviously, as well, all of the sharp trailhead, which we are hoping to build here in early September, which we're all looking forward to, along with what is left for sharp environmental analysis from the SNC grant, updates to Eastern Sierra drop-the-trail funding. Any questions? Oops, sorry.
2:16:28 Any questions related to this? Any comments? Any concerns? There's almost $80,000 in the adopted trail. Yes. Yes, there is. So this budget looks more or less the same as the previous year's same total budget? Yes. I guess my one concern is regular salaries listed here. I hope that we're keeping up with other agencies similar to us.
2:17:05 Able to retain our employees and meet cost of living increases such as that. Yeah, there's the general fund component that isn't on here, that is not on here that you're not seeing. So, yep. Great. And then uniforms and personal equipment, does that go towards trail workers getting boots, for instance? Exactly what that goes towards. Awesome. And, you know, shirts, so they're all looking professional and super visible out there. Yep. Great.
2:17:36 So the Measure R is $300,000 as it was last year and was that the same for the year prior to? I believe so, yes. Is there a reason not to try and ask for more money as it goes or is it? I think the approach that I want to take with this, I feel a great amount of responsibility as it relates to Measure R dollars and
2:18:08 I think we may come to that point when we get a larger scale project like Sharp implemented and we all decide as a group that we don't want to take that implementation to take 10 years, which may require staff up, purchases of equipment, things of that nature. So I can definitely see that happening as we move forward to implement a lot of the projects that we've been planning for. I feel like we've...
2:18:36 We've done a lot of planning and now is the time for implementation. And I want concrete implementable things to come to you all with budget requests for. I want those concrete type projects that we can work on if we need more money for staff. Obviously, it's entirely possible, depending on how this trail dozer goes, that I may come.
2:19:04 Back to you guys, for Andrew, myself, for a budget allocation for that piece of equipment. So generally, I'm just working off the status quo to kind of start here in the beginning of the year, cover our seasonal employees, cover what we know our costs are going to be, continue to get a good feel for our budget, how much maybe support might we get from LTC dollars, other grant funding. So that's why I left it here.
2:19:28 I'm just going to add a little bit to that too. So Measure R, Measure U, they were part of our general budgeting process with the town. And working with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, they provide sort of input on how we should balance those budgets. And when you look at Measure R, you know, it has two components. Obviously the amount of money it's going to collect from the taxes portion, it's revenue.
2:19:55 And then just other commitments that it has. And so we try to balance that out to where we're not making wholesale adjustments year over year. We have sort of a consistent budgeting process. So that's where the $300,000 comes from. It's a transfer from one fund to the trails fund. The difference is where the opportunities lie in the fact that Measure R can produce or accumulate.
2:20:20 Fund balance over time. And then a decision can be made to say, okay, we want to allocate $500,000 of this fund balance to, you know, Trails fund balance, right? And then it can become, for the larger projects, funding mechanism to get those things accomplished. So that's pretty much how it's set up to function, is it's fairly consistent. And then you'll see, you know, the $300,000, we basically allocate all the funding that
2:20:46 is generated from Measure R to the trail system and expand that out. And I'll say when I first started, I've been doing the budgets here for eight years. When I first started doing the budgets, the bulk of the work was done by contractors, right? So we had just very little funding for support for the uniforms and other things that you see in there. And then the bulk of it was for contract labor for these productions.
2:21:13 You know, we've got crews. We have our own crews we hire every year. So this shift has been more into the labor side of things. So most of the work is done, I'm going to say, quote-unquote, in-house from Andrew and crew. And so that's a little bit of a shift in that process. So hopefully it's more efficient. Hopefully it gets things done a little bit more concisely. But that is definitely something to note in that process. So a few things to think about. There was a major change from the contractor to this several years ago.
2:21:43 The then advising body was the recreation commission for a lot of reasons. And the amount, and I wouldn't be willing to change it right now, but the amount was tied to the trails getting a third of Measure R. So the $300,000 initially set was a third of what the income was expected to be for Measure R. However, the way it's set up does not preclude
2:22:12 I just said I'm not interested in changing here right now. That amount does not preclude this body or MLR or anyone else from going to Measure R with a specific project that may be over this. That may be that $80,000 piece of equipment. That may be, it can't be salaries, but we've, the $300,000 has been augmented by general funds so that we can use someone like Lawson outside of
2:22:41 The confines of Measure R as well. It's a complicated thing. But certainly if there was a project we were working on, the Sharp being one, the Shrek being one, if we ever got there, this body could decide to go to MLR and ask for that allocation and then on to Town Council after that. So there's no limit on just being that $300,000. That budget has also allowed the trails.
2:23:08 To, I don't know where our balance is now, I don't pay that close of attention as I used to, but it has allowed some buildup of funds in the account to be spent for larger items. Yeah, just another thought, you know, is we are going to do a White Park type infrastructure, you know, at that foundation site, and we want to build something world class, we're probably going to have to bring in some people who are world class, and, you know, that may be a request from...
2:23:37 Measure R as well. So again, that's kind of what I was thinking. I'm sorry, I did not have that on. Any other questions related to the budget request for 2425? All right. Do we need to vote on this? I would think consensus would be fine. I would think so. We need a motion to approve. Yeah, I think you need a motion. Yeah. I will make a motion to approve as presented. I'll second.
2:24:23 Okay, roll call. Committee Member Souser. Yes. Committee Member Patterson. Yes. Committee Member Howell. Yes. Committee Member Ostergaard. Yes. Vice Chair Draper. Yes. Chair Connolly. Yes. Does that conclude? That is what I had. Okay. Then, Bill, Board Member report since we've seen each other in the past few months. Gee, the weather's been nice. That's it. Okay. It's acceptable.
2:25:00 Elise, anything new? Just, I've enjoyed trail, the trails and the improvements that you've made on the trails, and I just like how smartly our trails are being made and how little maintenance is required, so thank you for that. I did want to let everyone on the committee know that I have a new job and I'm teaching STEAM at the elementary school.
2:25:27 So I'm teaching third, fourth, and fifth graders, science, technology, engineering, art, and math. And I've been really trying to focus on making their learning relevant and local. And because I don't have a curriculum, I'm creating my own curriculum. So I've been reaching out to community partners.
2:25:47 And really trying to tie where we live, like we live in such an amazing place and we have so many amazing resources and so many amazing people in our community. So I might be reaching out to some of you.
2:25:58 But I've reached out to the police. I've reached out to different artists in our community. I'm working with waste management. So really trying to tie in the town has been supporting our garden towers. And it's really so wonderful to see how much our community is supporting our school system. And just want to let you know, if you have something to offer, feel free to reach out to me. And thank you. All right. That sounds great. Working with kids is the best, I should know.
2:26:30 All right. My wife and I had our first child, June 23rd, so that's been a lot of my summer. Thank you, thank you. But we've been using the mups a bit, using the stroller, and yep, so it's all been good. I just wanted to put out there, still working on trails in South County, but every frustration that we go through here,
2:27:03 I repeat it, you know, and so it's super interesting, super long process. We identified the BLM. Where we have a problem is we have Forest Service, BLM, DWP, and it's a patchwork of all land managers. So the idea is you get one to agree, the rest will follow. We reached out to BLM because they're the lands of multi-use.
2:27:32 BLM does mining claims, off-road racing, you name it, you know, horse races, they'll do everything, you know, rock hounding, but when it comes to trails, they're not too sure about it, so, you know, it was a good meeting, it wasn't great, but we just keep working forward, so, it's fun meeting people face-to-face, you know, in the field, you can kind of...
2:28:02 You know, talk a lot about a lot of things. BLM wasn't interested in seeing a lot of people come to the area. What are you going to do next, you know? So, you know, that's just the way it goes. How about you, Michael? Anything? I've been getting out a little bit more. My knee's healing up from a surgery I had back in February, so I've been able to recreate quite a bit more. Enjoying the trails.
2:28:30 You know, I went up Crystal Lake the other day and that trail is just not, you know, it's always a heavily used one and I really wish the forest could get some manpower on that per usual. It's kind of getting a lot of switch cutbacks and cut throughs on it. But so it goes. The other thing I had seen a few weeks ago on social media was a post about a motorized user on the Mammoth or the Mountain View Trail and it seemed to kind of raise quite the hub of
2:28:59 comments. You know, I know it's not Lawson's role to respond to anything of those, but I do know that this group does have a good presence on making really great videos and posts on social media. Not that you guys need to respond to that or anything like that. It just kind of caught my attention as some misinformation that a lot of people had. So kind of unfortunate there.
2:29:23 Other than that, I loved the monsoon season that we had kind of briefly. That was really nice for the evening rides, but enjoying the summer. Sounds good. You can't skip over me. I usually am just completely invisible. But I would like to just make reference to a couple of items. First and foremost, how much that town staff and our construction season is going.
2:29:49 I mean, I think you all see all the things that are going on out there. A lot of it has to do with MUPS and MUPS updates that are going on. But the construction projects around the CRC and the playground areas and those things coming in, as well as down Main Street, all the road improvements, all those types of things, the team is working very, very hard. I couldn't be more proud of these folks for the work that they're doing. We just had a ribbon cutting and a groundbreaking.
2:30:18 Simultaneously at the parcel for phase one on completion. And if you haven't got a chance to get out there, take a look at that. It's really quite beautiful. And then there's a lot of work going on with what's going on on phase two. So yeah, just the town's humming and our 40th anniversary is coming up on the 24th. So please mark your calendars. That's Saturday, 12 to 4. We have a big celebration at the CRC, which I'll have to note is
2:30:46 Becoming one of these major hubs for our community. We had one, you know, Trails End Park is one where it generates a lot of activity. The CRC is really a central hub. The activities we talked about at the foundation site is going to be similar to that, right? We're trying to develop these little enclaves of really important aspects for the community, but they're also connected with our MUP system. So really trying to look like, you know, we know what we're doing with all this process, but really proud of our town staff for all the work that they do. Thank you.
2:31:15 Was it a big party at the parcel? Yeah, there was estimated to be just under 200 people that showed up for that. We barbecued a bunch of things for people to eat. There were some speeches given and tours of the open facilities. That was a cool part. There were five different residences that were open for people to review and walk through and take a look at, and that was one that generated the most interest and impressed. So really good out.
2:31:45 Outpouring from the community. Thank you. Item 8, do we have any requests for future agenda items? I'd like to keep an update for how we're doing on the OSV grooming thing on it so that we can see how that's moving along. If there's none else, I'll make a motion to adjourn. It's 530. I'll second it. Third it. Whatever is necessary. Thanks, everyone.
2:32:24 Thank you, John. It's been a long time since I've been in a meeting, so I'm a little rusty.