TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2024

Town Council

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

297 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

4:28 Okay, guys. Okay, kids, are we ready? Ladies and gentlemen, if you will, thank you. I would like to call this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council to order for Wednesday, March 6th at 4.02 p.m.

5:06 Roll call, please. Councilmember Rae? Here. Councilmember Rice? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Here. Mayor Souser? Present. Pledge of Allegiance. We are going to ask Dan Holler to lead us tonight in the pledge. Please join me in the pledge to our flag. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation.

5:38 Public comments. This is the time any member of the public wishes to speak on an item that is not otherwise on the agenda to speak. Hi, my name is Dan Holler, resident citizen. Actually, last meeting, I didn't bring this in, so Stu and I wanted to make sure we present the council with a

6:14 Photos taken at the recent christening of the LA Kings ice at Mammoth Lakes. This was the buck drop with Luke Robitaille and our Mammoth Stars and a number of other characters here as well. So it was a great night. Several of you were there and it was a lot of fun and it really did catch the moment, I think, of what's going on at the ice rink in that facility and the benefit it has to the community. It's great that the Park and Rec Commission is here this evening. So we thank

6:44 Current Council, past councils, current rec commission, and previous ones that were all part of bringing this to fruition. So it was great to have it, great to have a good turnout, and it's something you all should be proud about for years to come. Stu? No, I didn't really need to follow Dan, but thank you for joining us. This photo actually captured everybody. There was one photo that we didn't...

7:11 Quite see the mayor in the photo. So we've selected one. We didn't have to Photoshop anyone. Everybody is clearly seen. Great to have our kids there. Wonderful amenity. Thank you again for your support. And we're going to frame, sorry, we're going to hang this somewhere in the back or in the chamber somewhere that is visible for our community. Pretty amazing somehow that the fat guy didn't show up in a picture. You were behind the other kind of larger person skates, i.e. woolly.

7:41 Thank you. And I have seen it. It's a beautiful photo. And if I may also, one more, just thank you again for this council and supporting myself. I thank the staff for the work of the last number of years. And may you all continue to do really good things for the town of Mammoth Lakes. Thank you very much. Thank you, Dan.

8:09 Hello, good afternoon. Brianna Gweiko. I'm the current Assistant Director at the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. I just wanted to come up today and just give a few updates. I'm sure most of Council and the community has heard, but just wanted to clarify some changes coming up at the Chamber.

8:24 So Ken Brangle, our current Executive Director, will be retiring on June 30th of this year. He's been with the Chamber for seven years and wish him well on his retirement. And I will be stepping into the role of President and CEO starting on June 1st of this year. So we'll overlap by a few weeks, get some training, and then Ken will be on his way to Vegas.

8:48 Live out the rest of his retirement there. So I just wanted to formally announce that and then just make comment on, I know later in today's meeting we're going to be talking about short-term rental moratorium. You know, we really just wanted to speak to the long-term rental subsidy piece. So just for some context, back in 2019 the chamber began our workforce housing program and since then...

9:13 We've seen some limited success. We've reported to council a few times. And, you know, for us, we basically modeled our program after what was then known as Landing Locals, today known as Placemate. And, you know, recently we've reviewed the program with our board. And, you know, without the subsidy piece, the program, it really can't produce the way that it should. So we recently brought in Placemate to a power lunch to kind of explain their model.

9:42 We highly encourage Town Council and staff to take a serious look at it. It's shovel-ready. You know, they already have the structure and systems in place. So, you know, those are kind of the thoughts and opinions of the Chamber and of our Board. And, you know, hopefully, you know, we don't need to put this in place, long-term subsidies for a long time. You know, I know that the parcel and other housing efforts in town will hopefully curb

10:08 The housing issues that we've had in town. But this is a short-term solution that could create housing now. So we just really encourage you to take a look at that. And I look forward to working with all of you in my new capacity and working with both you and the business community so we can create useful and meaningful programs and help our businesses. So thank you for your time. Thank you. Thank you. Any other members of the public wishing to speak? Seeing none.

10:39 We will move on to additions to the agenda, and I won't be asking Dan about this. I'll be asking Rob. There are no additions to the agenda, Mr. Mayor. Thank you. Next up, 5.1, introduce and swear at, no, swear in, new Mammoth Lakes Police Department Sergeant Wes Hoskins. Good afternoon, Councilman Dan Casabian, Police Chief. We're here this afternoon to introduce Wes Hoskins, or Hoskin, I should say.

11:12 He's no stranger to the Eastern Sierra. He started his career with Mono County in 2009 as a public safety officer working in the jails and dispatch and that kind of stuff. Eventually got promoted in Mono County in 2012 to deputy sheriff. Went to the Riverside County Sheriff's Department. Graduated number one in his class.

11:32 And then he also received Deputy of the Year in 2015 from Mono County. So he was up here for quite a while, loved the area, was up in the Bridgeport area, now we've kind of pulled him down a little bit. But when he left Mono County, the Sheriff's Department, he went to the DA's office and assisted the Chief DA Investigator, Chris Callanan, with investigations through the DA's office and stuff like that. So he comes with that experience as well, which is great.

11:57 That was grant-funded. When the state stopped that grant funding, he lateraled over to Placer County in 2017. While he was there, he worked canine, so he's familiar with canines and stuff like that. He can help Matt West with his dog and Jax and that kind of stuff, and then he was ultimately promoted to sergeant.

12:16 So he received the MAD Award, Mothers Against Drunk Driving, twice. So he's out there within the community, keeping the community safe. It's an honor to have him. It's an honor to get him back on this side of the mountain, not only in Mono County, but in Mammoth Lakes. So with that, I'll let him say a few words, and we're happy to have him. I'd just like to thank the town council, town manager, for giving me this opportunity.

12:40 I actually applied at Mammoth Lakes PD back in 2009, 2010, however you guys weren't hiring. So it took me about 14 years to get back over here, but I'm happy to be back here working for the community, and it's an honor and a privilege to be able to represent the police department, and I look forward to building a relationship with the community and also being able to make Mammoth a safe place to live and recreate. Thank you for this opportunity. Thank you. Thank you. Let's go right up there. Let him swear in first. That's where we're at.

13:13 I must be also, do swallow and swear, do swallow and swear, to support and defend, to support and defend, the Constitution of the United States, the Constitution of the United States, and the Constitution of the State of California, and the Constitution of the State of California, that I take this obligation freely, that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation, without any mental reservation, or purpose of evasion, or purpose of evasion, and that I will well and faithfully, and that I will well and faithfully, discharge your duties, discharge your duties, upon which I am about to enter, upon which I am about to enter.

13:43 Congratulations. Thank you. Welcome aboard, sir. Thank you. Welcome. She took a breath there for a second. I know. It was wonderful. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I'm very excited. Thank you. I applied when I first moved here.

14:30 I was trying to get some other stuff going. Okay, next up in tonight's lineup is a workshop.

15:01 With the Park and Recreation Commission for that, we will wheel our chairs down to those tables and reconvene from there. Good to see that much support. Did he have family with him? We should have introduced them too. I'm too late now. A nice lady pinned his thing onto him. So I'm assuming, yeah. His person. Yeah.

15:32 This is the easy part of the night.

16:31 Come on, Bill. You can do better than me. Okay. We will now start this joint meeting, if you will. And I will turn it over to either Dan the Chair or to Stu the Director, whichever one of you wants to lead this fracas off. Okay. I guess I'll begin.

17:03 Maybe some introductions. We have new commissioners here. I'm Dan O'Connell. I'm the chair of the recreation commission. I haven't been in one of these meetings with you. And incidentally, it's called a workshop, but it's not like we're going to roll our sleeves up and, you know, solve the recreation problems of the world. I think it's a little bit of a misnomer. Maybe we should call it an annual meeting or whatever. So that's just kind of a general comment.

17:32 We're happy to be here. And we have two new commissioners here. My name is Scott Reef, and I've about two years now we're in, almost. Yep. Somewhere in there. And Greg Nubry. I'm fairly new on the commission. I'm one of the cheerleaders we're staying on. He was an amazing guy. Did you want to make some opening remarks before we... Just a couple, and then we're just missing... Do you just want to walk through your other commissioners that aren't here?

17:58 Yeah, we're missing Ben Wisner. I don't know. Was he planning to be here? And then Silver Chesick, one of the owners over at Footloose. He's also relatively new on the commission. I don't know. Scott, you haven't been to one of these meetings, have you? I have not. Okay. And neither has Greg. So, you know, I think if we're not going to really solve the problems of the recreation world, and we call it a workshop, you know, what do we,

18:29 How do we make this valuable? And I think for one thing, it's a great meet and greet and have a chance to share some big picture thoughts, some concerns, some directions that we're going. It's a public forum, so I could meet with any one of you and share the same thoughts, but I think it's important to address some of these things publicly and as a group.

18:56 So looking at this workshop agenda, it kind of speaks for itself. You know, present item two, present and discuss Parks and Recreation Department 2024 strategic priorities for the year and key objective statements. So that's a big statement in itself. But then we drop down and, you know, this A, maintain and enhance town recreation infrastructure.

19:26 That basically comes from our master plan for parks and recreation. And Stu and his staff have been great about taking those mission statements and these principles out of the master plan and putting it into every agenda that we have as a recreation commission to see where we are accomplishing our goals and where we have to go still.

19:55 And, you know, looking down here, we've got a bunch of projects and bullet points. The community dog park, a park at the parcel. There's progress being made on all this. The MAC, Edison Theater and Outdoor Amphitheater. That's a huge project. And Betsy back here, you know, is in charge of all that.

20:18 A community bike park and pump track. That's a pretty simple thing. I mean, if we had just some open space, there's not enough room over at the CRC for this. It would have been nice to fit it in somewhere over there. There's enough room for a bouldering park, which is, I think we mentioned that somewhere here. You know, Mammoth Creek Park East, I guess it is. Is that the other side of it? Yeah. Out in front of the bowling center. You know, that's a perfect spot for that. You know, there's nothing.

20:48 The hardscape that's built, it's just conforming some earth, but the Forest Service obviously has been somewhat of an issue there, I guess. Stu could speak more to that, but that's not the purpose of today. Reading between the lines on this, though, and this is something that a large concern I've had for quite some time. Reading between the lines, you know, these are CIP projects that we've listed here.

21:17 And something that, you know, certain constituents have been speaking to me about quite a bit are the tennis courts. And, you know, it's a tennis facility. It's six courts. When I first moved here in 2014, I was just kind of exploring around town, and I was moseying along up that street, and I was like, whoa, check this out. It was full of people playing. And they invited me to come play. It's great.

21:47 But they've fallen into serious disrepair. And, you know, there's cracks that are this deep and that wide. We tried a new approach. We experimented with a plastic grid surface that went down. And it's acceptable. It's okay. But it's, how much was it? 175. How much? 175. Yeah, 175. So that's a lot of money.

22:13 You know, I play tennis. I stopped playing up here because the courts suck. And, you know, I played down in L.A. when I visit L.A. and the game is just exploding. It's so popular. Beverly Hills, West L.A., 10 o'clock in the morning. The courts are full. And I'm talking not just seniors or people retired. I mean, there's, you know, all ages are out there. And so, you know, and...

22:41 Part of this equation, you know, where are we going to spend money, what's important? You know, pickleball is the fastest growing sport, you know, but we've taken care of that. We have like a world-class pickleball center now on the old ice rink. It's beautiful. So, you know, one question about the tennis courts is money. You know, where's it going to come from? Because it's going to be about a million bucks or some large amount. Where's it going to come from? And, you know, what...

23:12 Are the demands current, you know, for projects, you know, dog parks, pump tracks, bouldering, all these things, you know, what's a priority? Now, I've explained to my fellow commissioners and to Stu that last summer I was down south and I was at a centennial party for a beach club that I belong to and I'm talking with an old friend and it turns out, you know, I told him what I'm doing up here, Recreation Commission.

23:41 And we've got all these great projects going on. The CRC, I mean, everybody's just thrilled with that. And I said, you know, we've got these tennis courts. I knew he'd played for Stanford. And he said, well, you know, I'm like number three at the USTA. And we've got like hundreds of millions of dollars to give us grants to communities to build the game and to restore courts and that kind of thing. Here's the problem. And this is...

24:11 The real issue that I see that's evident now in our town is where are we going to put $750,000 or a million dollars into tennis courts because I raised this issue and I don't want to go chasing after money, especially with somebody I know at the USTA when we don't have a place to put the courts because the pushback that I've gotten is we don't know what we're going to do with that property.

24:38 Do you really want to spend a million dollars there if it's going to be turned into a parking lot or something else? I don't know. That was the first time I heard about this. So, you know, we've got the bell parcel. We have needs, but we don't really know where we're going to put some of these facilities if we're going to raise money, new tennis courts. Should they go to the community center? A lot of people would say yes. Others would say no.

25:07 You know, because we may have other needs for like a parking lot. So we're really kind of in limbo right now. You know, those courts, every community that I've ever been to anywhere has public tennis courts. I don't want to pay to go to Snow Creek. A lot of people don't. And, you know, I was in Switzerland in St. Moritz, you know, and they've got tennis courts there.

25:34 Just down the street where we were staying in Sils Maria, and I used to go there regularly, they've got tennis courts, indoor in the wintertime, outdoors in the summertime. So, and there's a final comment I'll make on that, and then you can, we can just toss around, you know, whatever impressions you have, is that, you know, the CIP plan, and I keep getting, you know, blowback from the tennis community.

26:02 Is that the CIP plan doesn't have tennis courts in it. And I just printed this out. This is 2023, 2024. It says the five-year CIP for the town of Mammoth Lakes is the community's plan for short and mid-range development. And if we don't have the money for tennis courts, maybe it doesn't fit in here. Mid-range development, maintenance, improvements, and acquisition of

26:31 And so, you know, it just sticks in my craw that tennis is nowhere on the radar. New tennis courts. And then, you know, I printed out here the 2012 Parks and Rec Master Plan, page six out of it. And I'll just read real briefly.

26:59 Parks and Recreation Facilities in Mammoth Lakes should advance the following six goals. Goal one, maintain parks and open space within and adjacent to town for outdoor recreation and contemplation. Goal two, provide additional parks within the town. So really, you know, goal number one, according to our current master plan, is to maintain what we have. And we have a lot of new shiny stuff.

27:29 I'm, you know, the CRC was a high priority that you've been working on, Bill, for decades now. But to look at new infrastructure coming along while we have a dilapidated, falling apart part of our recreation infrastructure, that's kind of contrary to what the goals are stated in the master plan.

27:56 And the CIP, really, they're going to take both of those items together. So, you know, we need to start thinking, you know, and I share these same concerns with MLR when we had our workshop and Craig Albright, he's like, you know, we need to, and Stu is aware of this and this is part of our discussion today, start thinking about a new master plan, you know, and...

28:21 Taking a strategic look at what we have and what we need and where it's going to go. Because if we don't, you know, I'm not going to go to the USTA and raise a bunch of money and say, Chris, they don't want to spend it at the community center, at our tennis facility with six courts, because we don't know what we're going to do with that property. So, and I don't want to wait 10 years, you know, for something like that.

28:48 And as Stu knows, and everybody on this, I've been trying to get some wayfinding for the town loop going up the frontage road. We've got one side. I don't know. Has Lawson got the other ones? I don't know. Anyway, these are my big picture concerns that I wanted to share with you.

29:05 Yeah, I'm going to jump in if I can. I didn't know you felt that way, so this is all new. No, I'm teasing. I actually agree with him in total that we really should have tennis courts on the plate somewhere to be done within a real period of time. I also would suspect and would understand completely if the tennis courts up by the community center

29:30 Might want to wait on doing something there in case that ends up being something necessary for that whole area because once you put the money into that, well, in case. But if you leave it in limbo so you don't know you want to do that, okay, fine, let's do it someplace else. Let's get it done. Let's budget and get it done. I mean, you've got Snow Creek 8 coming up. He doesn't want to do it after nine holes. They can put a parking lot in and they can put in eight tennis courts for public tennis and have them pay for it.

29:59 You know, there's lots of ways that it might be done, but I totally agree that it should be budgeted, it should be funded, it should be in our plan. You know, under B on this here, we're supposed to amend and revise the park plan this year. That's part of what we're on. So it's something we can do. And I understand Dan wanting to sort of hammer on the council because you guys all work together and talk.

30:23 You know, and we sort of chatted about this as well, and when it didn't go into plan here, you know, Stu said, well, you know, it's not on the plate. This is something that is fun to do, and it's not fun, it's what doesn't go into plan. Well, we need to figure something out there. I don't think we should just sit and wait because we don't want to put 1.5 million into fixing the courts up on Forest Trail. So, and to be a destination resort, I mean, we have tennis courts in Bridgeport, in Walker, in Lee Vining, in Benton.

30:51 In Hamill Valley, I mean, they're all over, all public, all public courts, some of them in good shape. So anyway, I happen to agree that's something we need to work on, and I think it's appropriate for us to bring it up to the council about where we, how we feel on this. And we have our fearless leader, Stu, who can help us put all this together in some sort of master plans. Let me ask her real question.

31:19 So we've been pushed here for tennis courts. I've been pushed because an Olympics heated indoor swimming pool is the most important thing Mammoth can have. The number of assets that there are groups pushing in town are far beyond our capacity. So how is a rec commission, do you plan on sorting that out and telling this outside of your own prejudices, of course, what is the top facility then? So I'm hearing this.

31:49 I'm going to go off here for a minute, gentlemen. Our infrastructure is falling apart. We aren't maintaining it. This was true up until a few years ago when we started putting multiple millions of dollars into a fund specifically to maintain. We're talking about the tennis courts weren't working. How many times we have torn out the...

32:13 So we went with a sport court, which we haven't even given a full good trial yet, to see if that could be a solution for us, because our weather problems, even if we go to post-tension concrete, which would be a whole lot more than $1.6 million to replace those six courts, more like a million bucks a piece. So we are doing our damnedest to bring this to the forefront and to correct these issues.

32:37 Already, so I take a bit of an affront on we are just letting them go. I do not believe that this council has done that at all. We have, in fact, allocated large sums of money to bring our facilities back up to snuff. Then there is the answer, not the answer, but the question, is tennis courts the most pressing need to spend millions of dollars on?

32:59 Is it the MUP system around town that needs to be widened and needs to be replaced and needs to be resurfaced? So I'm counting on you guys after this impassioned plea for tennis that somehow you're going to find a way, and not the traditional way, because as far as I'm concerned, planning your parks didn't work. All it did was bring out a few different very special interest groups to try and tell us that their project was the most important. So I'm looking for that answer in this community.

33:27 As fractured as it can be sometimes, what is that most important? On the tennis facility, for me, it's not necessarily we're going to use that for something else. Where is the best place to rebuild them where they will have the longest season and the longest longevity without them getting tore apart? That's a very snowy piece of town. So there's a lot of questions that need to be answered. Will the sport court work? If it will work, it's a great solution.

33:56 You know, let's give it a shot. Mr. Mayor, if I could, just to add on to that, I think I'm a little surprised here. Thank you. You know, we look at these agendas, and there's nothing on here about tennis. So I'm just, again, your time is valuable, our time is valuable. I think it would be really helpful to hear what you're saying.

34:19 We spent a lot of time on tennis over the years, but I'd really like to maybe focus on some of the things that are actually on the agenda, if that would be okay for you, Mr. Ray. That's fine. I think the point he's bringing up is an important point. I would love to hear from the other commission members how they feel about how to bring this all forward, and I would love to hear from those of us up here as to how they feel about determining what the best and highest value and...

34:46 Where we need to move forward is. Mr. Mayor, if I may, I believe Stu has some prepared open remarks and a process to walk through this that will get to, you know, a needs assessment and possibly some other aspects of that. Stu, if you're ready to dive in. Yeah, no, no problem. Thank you. Incidentally, before you get started with that, I'm not criticizing anybody. I'm just raising issues and looking at what the master plan says as goals, which is to maintain things.

35:17 I'm not even aware until now that you are aware of the issues. So that's why I'm bringing it up. Thank you. So the little introduction was just to kind of run through this little document. So this document is very much aligned with the town council document that the council adopted in December 2023, not that long ago. So Dan, I know, spent a lot of time with council kind of putting this together.

35:46 Our task each and every year for staff and our department is to kind of summarise, highlight, align, and to kind of unify our strategic objectives, priorities, and put them in this one-page sheet that we can all kind of unify around and then work together to achieve. So hopefully that makes sense. The previous version of this was multiple pages, so I think we've come a long way.

36:09 The left-hand side just really talks about, if you haven't spent a lot of time looking at it, kind of the fundamental purpose, our vision, mission, our tagline. These strategic initiatives, these are kind of year over year what we aspire to each and every year as a department, which is excellence, teamwork, sustainability, health, safety and social equity. So these are the kind of initiatives or the pillars that we want to kind of immerse and integrate through our programs. On the blue section here, very easy. Dan kind of mentioned them before.

36:38 Strategic priority one, maintain, enhance the town's recreation infrastructure. Strategic priority two, which really talks about programming. And what I want to kind of highlight in that section area is to kind of really narrow down the focus of the department and the commission is the second bullet point, is the core program areas. So if someone asks the commission and the department, what are you really focused on, right?

37:02 I'm going to give you these five responses. One, really kind of just focusing our youth team camps and programs. Really want to kind of focus on completing the CRC, LA Kings Ice, Mammoth Rec Zone, adult activities, facility operations, maintenance and community events. So that's kind of really in a nutshell our fundamental purpose. And then we in turn take those strategic priorities, key objectives and narrow those down into a budget document.

37:27 Right, you've seen those. And then the other two here is our organisational systems, how are we running our department, which I think is really important here. So that kind of gives some kind of meat in the sandwich about kind of what that looks like, how we communicate with the public, and then building capacity, teamwork, and so forth.

37:44 So we do this every year. We bring it to the commission. We review kind of how we did, a little checklist. What are the areas that we want to focus on for the coming year? What are the town council priorities? And again, as Dan mentioned before, how does that align with the Parks and Recreation Master Plan? That's kind of our blueprint for success, right? So when we kind of put together this number one, there's three bullets in the infrastructure. One is obviously to get the CRC over the...

38:14 Finish line. I know it's never going to be really finished, but we're going to do our darndest this year to finish off those interior improvements and turn it into an even more aspiring facility the community really enjoy.

38:27 And then we kind of narrowed down these CIP projects. So these projects here, and Dan mentioned this before, these all have funding. So these have been awarded by council, right? So these are actionable items we're working on, except the bike park pump track. That's something that we've committed to for the last two, three years. But we've got the dog park underway. We received an award from CPRS and a grant a couple of years ago for the park of the parcel.

38:55 Which is underway, Edison Theatre, Outdoor Amphitheatre, and Mammoth Creek Park West, which we hope to have completed by Labor Day weekend for the town's 40th anniversary. It should be very exciting. So that's kind of how we put that together. So that's really, when you look at what we are doing and what the commission has focused on this year, that is our strategic priority document, key objective statement.

39:19 I will jump in at a later time to kind of talk about where this kind of master plan...

39:45 How do we prioritize our very limited funding?

40:15 Department and Commission, we're bringing forward this kind of first bullet point here on strategic priority number two, that the Parks and Recreation Master Plan kind of times out in 2025. So it was put together in 2007 when the needs assessment, it was adopted by council in 2012. And when you look at that...

40:38 Was it Parks was 212? Yeah, Parks was 212. It was adopted from CEQA. But the plan and the needs assessment was 2007. So it's been a while in the making. So a lot of those needs have probably changed. Pickleball wasn't really a thing. Now it's a thing, as many are activities. So we see the Parks Master Plan. We see the Trials System Master Plan. How do we kind of advance that and kind of build it for the future? So that's kind of the way that we thought would be a great way to kind of move.

41:06 These kind of, you know, questions forward and to kind of provide a kind of a roadmap for the next 10 years for our Parks and Recreation Commission and Department. And that's kind of what we were bringing forward with you today. So does that start with a needs assessment? Typically. Yeah. So I've just kind of summarized, I went through and kind of summarized the plan and what was interesting about the Parks and Recreation Master Plan.

41:31 That in 2025, it actually forecast a population of Mammoth Lakes of 12,500. That's probably what it is. And I think we're actually where we were in... 93,546. Is that the number, Greg? Okay. I think it's more like 8,000. So, you know, that Parks and Rec Master Plan was built on a level of service of 12,500 people, but we're still really at 8,000. So I think there's a lot of questions that we need to ask.

42:00 To Rob's point, it's really evaluating what's in the plan, what really makes the most sense, what we've accomplished, and what still needs to be done, and then perhaps what we can do is kind of update that plan and turn it into something more actionable and meaningful for the community. I'll stop my introduction, if that makes sense. Thank you for that time. Questions to this point?

42:23 If I could, I don't want to. Yes, no, I was looking at you, that's fine. Thank you. I think, I appreciate that your top priority here is these interior improvements of the CRC. I would hope we're all concerned that when we take on big ambitious projects that we finish them and we get them completed. So I'm really interested in that as being a top priority.

42:48 The other thing I'll just point out is, Stu, is that you, we were some of us around back in the day with this happening. Yeah. The Park and Recreation Master Plan was a discrete effort. Correct. The Trails System Master Plan was a discrete effort. They were two entirely different efforts. And I think it would make sense to be clear that the Parks and Recreation Commission, the department, is focused on that parks, the parks plan. That's, that's.

43:15 Consistent with your work and what you guys do, and that should stay over there. Trail system, that's a whole separate discussion. Lawson's coming up a little bit later to talk about the office about the recreation. The trails program is living in that office, so I think it's a good idea to keep those two things separate. So those are some initial thoughts. I concur with that. I mean, this is blended in with a slash. Yeah, there are two. It says master plan slash trail system, but our emphasis is going to be

43:42 A revision of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. Yeah, so I would just take the whole trail system, just take that out of it. That's not our bailiwick. Exactly. We had a joint meeting with MLR, and it just came up at that meeting that both plans have been in effect about the same period of time, and both plans probably need to be revisited. So that's the only reason that...

44:08 The two are being talked about at the same time. They're sort of on the same time schedule. Yeah, I would just, that's a separate discussion, but I would, I'd be interested in understanding from the Parks and Recreation Department, your needs assessment, what has been implemented, what's still outstanding, what has changed, you talked about the population, really focus on that specific effort. I think the trails program is a whole different.

44:31 You know, fish, and that requires a separate discussion. They should be kept really separate and discreet. And there is a section in the marks, in the past, Parks and Recreation Master Plan on trails, but it's only kind of a couple pages and it has a little reference, but yeah. Yeah, yeah. If I may, your comment about finishing the CRC and getting that finished, that is the highest priority. Okay. I mean, I've built, I've done construction, and what's not mentioned is the outside with the porch.

45:00 And that was something I asked for when I had some input and we looked at plans. I wanted the exterior to be softened a little bit and to be improved aesthetically. And that was something that was important to me, was to see the entry and it kind of wraps around and it softens the whole shape of the building. And for me, that's a high priority, just so you know. Well, I think we all have expectations that that will be... Inside first, though.

45:29 That's the priority. It would be good at some point to get, I don't know, to get an update of where that project is at. I know there's a lot of public works, Hayes, you've been doing a lot of stuff with that, so I think it's all of our expectation that the visual renderings that were presented that the council worked on to improve the project, you know, over a decade, that that's where we're going to be ending up, so I think we're all looking forward to seeing that get completed. Hey, John, Chris? Amanda?

46:00 Yeah, I like your strategic priorities, and I would also like to see an emphasis on entertaining our youth and having safe spaces for our youth so they don't just go around trolling and, you know, getting into trouble. I know in this building especially, we have a lot of, you know, problems with kids that have nothing to do. And so, you know, so far with everything we've been speaking about,

46:27 I'd like to give the tennis courts, you know, we just put $175,000 into that and to see, you know, how that goes, you know, but those are. Would you like my feedback on it? I would love your feedback. I've played on it quite a bit. And other people I know played on it. It looks great, the color and everything, but it's not a great surface. I've been playing on court, too, I guess it is, the last functioning.

46:58 How does it, how does it, I mean, I feel like here we have the extra.

47:23 Element of we have super harsh winters. So, you know, maybe it's not the best court, but if it holds up to our harsh winters, maybe it's great for a public court in Mammoth. That is one reason we waited. I mean, we were, we looked at $175,000 to use another court in there, two more courts. And the commission said, no, you know, it really doesn't play that well, doesn't work that well. Let's wait. Let's take that same $175,000 and put it into the bathrooms at Shady Rest and redo those because those, as you know, really need to be done.

47:52 So we're watching and paying attention, and we're actually moving money away from that in order to do things that need to be done so we can further assess the plastic, which isn't coming out great from a functionality perspective that works.

48:05 One star stuff. Well, it was a bandaid on something that needs a full repair and we didn't square the cord up and flatten the surface before we put the plastic in. I think you'll see what SportCord actually does when we open the CRC with that surface in there. I think we'll understand it a little bit better. But obviously...

48:25 You know, we're thinking small picture when we're talking about the courts and redoing that. We need to think of something as big as the CRC that services this community and I'm hearing nothing but...

48:38 We do indoor recreation during the winter for our kids, so they're not riding the bus, they're not lighting fires over at Shogun, and they're not doing stuff like that. That's what I see all the time, and as someone who deals with kids all the time, I feel like we don't service the children enough in this community, and we're just letting them go down pathways.

48:58 That we don't want to see them go down. And I think we as a group and a town and recreation committee have an opportunity to start making an impact in these young kids' lives as this community keeps growing and growing and kids are growing from what I'm seeing even with the ski and snowboard teams. We have more kids on our team, more local kids than we've had in the past.

49:20 I think whatever we're doing with master planning, things like that, we need to think about the children in this area, not the elderly or the older people in our community. Okay. I'm glad that Greg brought, well, thank you for your comments because it's very well taken. I just want to concur with what Greg was saying. I was going to bring it up. We actually played on it, taken feedback on it. We had another 175,000.

49:48 Budgeted for it. Based on all that feedback and my recommendation, I said we should use that for something better, which we moved that to the restrooms. Amanda, anything else? Not at this time. Sarah? A couple of things. I just heard that we didn't level the old courts before we put the sport court on it. I was told actually originally that we did completely level those and there was a problem, so we pulled some of it up to fix the level. And then they're coming back to re-fix it again.

50:17 Okay. Yes. But it was leveled. It was not just laying over the old. And we still noticed some high and low spots. It was pretty bad, as you know, five and six were. Yeah, I know. Don't want any misconceptions there, though. No, they definitely worked on it. It's just when you got such a big space, it's hard to get it perfectly flat. And that's what that sport court requires is there to be no air between the plastic and the ground.

50:41 And that's why I'm very excited to see what happens at the CRC when we... If roots under it, it's going to constantly crack. You're not going to fix it. I mean, like you said, Bill, it's going to do it right. It would cost a lot. That may not be the spot that makes sense. And one last point about that support court where it is outdoors. It collects conelets and pine needles. It looks like they're growing out of the surface. You can't sweep it. You cannot sweep it. They get stuck in the little...

51:08 Square. I said that right off the bat. We've got to buy some kind of commercial vacuum in order to deal with that. That's where we're going to go. But there's so many things. We do require specialized equipment already, so that doesn't faze me. The other, a couple of things. The playground at Mammoth Creek West, Stu, I just have the question, that all-inclusive, beautiful playground, hopefully we're going to be able to open that before September? Yes.

51:34 Okay, well I heard that we hope to finish this by September and I was, I don't need any more angry people calling me saying, how come this isn't open? We were on schedule until we obviously got a little bit more snow, but yeah, so it just requires some safety surfacing. Right. And then once that's in we can fix that and then we should talk about that briefly about timing and...

51:56 Yeah. So we plan to close the CRC with the California Curling Championships on the 21st of April, which will be very exciting. And then we're going to pull that ice out. Haven't done that before, so it'll be...

52:09 First time for everything. And then the team from Sport Court come down the first two weeks of May, they'll install the Sport Court, and then we try and get going the third week of May before Memorial. So that's that program. We're trying to sync that up with Mammoth Creek Park and the playground as well. So really the goal is to try and get the safety surfacing in, get the framework done, get the little kind of rockers and the swingers back and all the pieces that broke the last couple of years by mid-May.

52:36 So Memorial Weekend, we're good to go. And then the plan is to have the 40th anniversary there with the new rehabilitated park playground pavilion on Labor Day weekend. Perfect. We had some questions, or at least had some questions about the actual bouldering part. Maybe you can talk about how the safety aspect of that is going to be tied into the height of the rocks and those types of things. Yeah, so it's going to get treated like a playground. So the playground has certain height parameters and distance and thickness of the safety surfacing.

53:04 So if you're familiar with that, it's a 12-inch minimum. You can use a pouring place, engineered wood fiber. So that's going to be surrounding that whole playground area as well, including the bouldering park. So that will be treated like a playground. That's really the intent. So safe, great space to play and hang out. And from a programming point of view, I think that's what we're really excited about, not just the CIC. The CIC is really just that hub for summer, all that camp.

53:30 Programs, all of that, but really having that park, the playground, and that whole kind of recreation destination.

53:35 So, Stu, could we get from you or from Hayes an update on kind of the sequencing of all this? Sure. Because we're still not done with this site. I mean, the Sierra, we got in there a bit, questions about the playground and getting it open, when is this construction going to happen for the face in the front? We're still in construction on this thing, so it'd be really helpful to get a sequence. Yeah, and that's a great point, John. That was kind of the

54:00 Why I wanted to talk a little bit about some of the components, because when Stu was saying that, you know, by memorial we would have, I think all those functions, right, all those other infrastructure elements that are yet to be built, that would be the time frame in which they would be complete. So the full sort of build out, if you will, would be that sort of time frame. But at the same time, I had a lot of questions about when that park is going to be ready to go. So the park will be ready to go in end of May.

54:27 The full build-out, where it all ties in very nicely, is looking more towards the end of summer. And that's really, I think, a function of the ability to get in there in time and just contract to work, because it is construction. Just to be clear, that's all still within Hayes' world? Yes. That's all the grass, the pavilion. Yeah, that's a CIP project because of the award from Council, so yes. One more comment, which is a little different than John's. We can get together and box about this later. Too many times.

54:56 I have seen especially the town go into these planning efforts and, well, the trails aren't ours, they're over here, this is over here, and we end up in silos. Silos never, ever work. You get competing efforts, competing for dollars, instead of working together on an overall plan. I would rather see close consideration and communication between our Office of Outdoor Equeration, MLR, Park and Rec.

55:24 On how to move an all-inclusive recreation package forward so that poor Stu isn't over there fighting with somebody else for dollars and instead of working together collaboratively, we're butting heads. I saw that too much going all the way back to 84 when we incorporated different departments. This is mine, not yours. This is mine. We silo. And from my standpoint, it flat out doesn't work. Collaboration, communication.

55:52 Those are what I'm going to be looking for moving this thing forward. Not, this isn't my job, this is your job, and I'm going to fight for money from me, which may take money from you. Don't need to see that. I have some thoughts on that, but we can save it for another time. Yeah, thank you. In our last meeting with the MLR group and Craig, that was a productive meeting because we talked about some big picture needs, which is to start strategically thinking about...

56:19 Where we can put some new facilities and where's it, you know, together as a group figure out what's best for a location for whatever that is. I'll just point out one point. The points you're making about youth and, Stu, we went through all this stuff with the birth of MLR. We went through a lot of stuff about the value and the purpose and the focus of community recreation. Correct.

56:44 And the things you're bringing up are so important. I hear that from constituents all the time. My kids have no place to go. They have no place to play. All these kinds of things. And I think it really makes sense to be factoring that into the focus of what the community recreation program should look like. The recreation programs that involve the federal landscape and all the rest of that, that's obviously a very important part of this. I think if you go back to the councils,

57:12 Priorities, when we talk about enhancing sustainable recreation economy with partnerships and investments, we need to figure, that's got to be part of the balance in there. We've got to figure out how all that, how, you know, what's, what's really the focus of this, and what's really the focus of that, and what are the audience for these two different things? And it's, it's a conversation we have for many years, and I think they're conversations that continue.

57:35 Obviously, everybody's got to collaborate. Everybody's got to work together. I think we need to make sure at the end of the day we're touching all the bases. Those are my thoughts. Thank you. With that, I will turn it back over to our... Yeah. I think something that illustrates that that's interesting is our effort to produce a community park pump track. You know, there is funding out there. There's corporate sponsorship for that.

58:05 There's been quite a few people from the community coming to our meetings requesting that. It's a place for kids to play. But it's extremely difficult to find land for that. We really probably need to work with Officer Outdoor Rec, Lawson, or a private entity somewhere in the hospital land, something like that, to make this happen. And that's why...

58:28 You know, we have been meeting with a joint meeting with MLR. Lawson was also at that meeting and provided a lot of insight. So I think we are trying to coordinate the different agencies and trying to figure this out. But, you know, without like the master plan, it's going to be difficult to come to the proper agency or the person in charge of that, you know, part of our town infrastructure.

58:57 And work with them. So that's why we're, you know, so focused on coming up with a new master plan so we can make some of these things happen for the kids. And I agree with you that the silo problem can be a problem. But I also, even though I'm a short-timer here, watching Stu and how well he works with other agencies and people, so I haven't really seen that problem. When we had the MLR, I mean, I think it's a great idea to have these separate agencies.

59:26 But I think Stu does an amazing job of bringing it all together in a cohesive sort of way because he understands that. So just on your point there, one thing is you may have heard, and this may be something, Stu, you could help sort of relay to the commission. We've had a private property, a significant real estate development project that's in front of the town right now. There's a request for a development agreement. There may be some opportunities with that. So it's something you can maybe keep your eyes on. If it's the same spot we're talking about, I think it's great.

59:55 Great opportunity. Yeah, just so I'm sure you're communicating that with the commission, but that's something to be keeping our eyes on. Bill? Who knows? Someday maybe we'll get another district ranger that will work with us. We've had that in the past. Some day. Keep going short, it did not. Okay. Chris? Oh, I just wanted to make sure you were done. Yeah, I'm done. So the one thing that I would say is I'm listening to all of this, and, you know, we've been talking about tennis a lot for the last couple years, and, you know, it's just one example.

1:00:23 You know, Rob, one thing we do incredibly well as a town that I give you a lot of credit for is our snow removal equipment and all of our main heavy machinery is budgeted and planned for so that we know what it is going to cost to keep everything we need functional.

1:00:47 It seems to me like we have more infrastructure for recreation than we could possibly maintain optimally given our climate and the challenges we face. So I just, while we were talking, looked up Telluride.

1:01:03 Telluride's a smaller town than us, but arguably, you know, a destination that people think about. They have two tennis courts. Maybe we have to start to think about what we can actually afford to maintain optimally and right-size things so that we aren't always borrowing from one place to another. And Rob, I'd love to, you know, say I'm sure you are eminently qualified to help us figure this out. Yeah, thank you, Chris. We are, you know, we do have a model.

1:01:30 to follow with our vehicle replacement program and that type of thing. And we are talking about enhancing our sort of facilities maintenance, something that we haven't done. We've always let those to be at a department level.

1:01:44 And we are looking this year to augment that so that we have someone who's responsible for monitoring that. Now our first focus is going to be on the actual buildings and facilities that we operate and making sure they're tip-top and, you know, maintenance schedules and things like that are maintained as well as, you know, large repair replacement type things are sort of budgeted for very similar to vehicle replacement. And I think that could be a model that expands out into some of the recreation and infrastructure elements as well.

1:02:14 But I want to get that one stood up to ground. It's going to be a 24-25 budget discussion. Just so you're aware, you know, it's not the number of courts. It really isn't. I'd be happy, you know, I think the commission would be happy with two real tennis courts or four, not six. We have six. But the number isn't so much, you know, we're not fixated on a particular number. But it's a good point that you make.

1:02:40 The number wasn't my point. The point was we have more things than we can properly maintain. And by the way, sorry, community, we're never going to have a pool. And that's like sad for me, but we can't afford everything. The part that's quietest is usually the most efficient, and that's public works. And I think they're remarkable. The job this town does on snow removal, on...

1:03:05 Cleaning the sidewalks and the trails. And I've been to many sea resorts. I just have nothing but admiration for these guys. And they're very good at telling us what they can and can't do and what's realistic. So you're right. I think we have a great department to do that. But any town that's a snow town that provides recreation during the wintertime, it's all indoors.

1:03:28 Need to stop just looking at what our pool is of money and start thinking of who can we bring in to create these buildings and infrastructure for us in collaboration, who owns it, whatever, that's a whole other story.

1:03:45 Any place I've ever been in any snow town, you go to Breckenridge, you can go indoors, and there's a whole facility there that's a multi-purpose, and they're bringing summer inside. And then in summertime, people are still inside using that same building, and the revenue's coming in to maintain that building, whether it's a partnership or whatever, it doesn't have to just...

1:04:06 Be the town. It doesn't have to come from one coffer. There can be many ways to collaborate, and there's a lot of people in this community, especially drawing from LA, even different, what was the tennis thing that you were looking at with LTA, sorry, USTA, like there's all these other opportunities, but again, the bandwidth of what we have in the town parks and rec commission is not big enough, so it needs to be a collaborative effort.

1:04:35 Throughout everyone. Or we need to draw people who are the squeaky wheel and say, hey, you're the squeaky wheel. What can you do for us? Bring us an idea. And we need to work with these people and not be closed off and not answer emails or phone calls and just say we're doing our thing. And I know there's a group of people in my constituent that are very, very excited to try to help the town bring these things for their children and for themselves as well. But we need to...

1:05:04 Find those people in the community and make them work for us. We don't have to do it all on our own. And I feel like that's kind of the, since joining this, that's what we do. We go, hey Stu, do more. Hey crew, do more. But we're not going to give you more. We're not going to give you more people to help that happen. We're just going to pick at you and pick at you until.

1:05:27 You do something for us, and the CRC is a prime example of a huge project that maybe we need to bring more people in to pull these types of things off, but master planning, we need to all have one vision of what, where are we going with it? I remember the Red Garth conversations way back in the day when I first jumped in, I was like, we're talking about boat ramps when we have nothing for our children. We need to figure out.

1:05:54 What the balance is there and listen to our people for it. And I don't know how to do that because I'm new to it. But I feel like we're just really stressing the small pool of people that we have to do more when they're doing the best they can. Sorry. There's people out there. I know them. Let's get them in. Tell me how because I would love to bring more people in. Believe me, as someone who's run volunteer organizations in this town.

1:06:24 There's a lot of people who say they will, but a very short supply of people who step up to the plate and get it done. John, I'll introduce it to them all. I have a small working group that keeps bugging me every day, so I'll introduce them to you. It's the same people. We're running short on time. Our hour is basically up. I'd like to understand if there's sort of a consensus here for Stu to move forward.

1:06:54 Start working towards creating a new recreation master plan. I think that's something important to take out of this meeting. I will start this out just from my perspective. We talked about this earlier today. There's a lot of our master plans that need updating. I'm not interested in starting with the general plan and doing them all at once. We as a council, and I'm sure staff will bring forward to us the plans that need to be updated, then we're going to have to create a schedule. We only have so much staff time.

1:07:24 And so much money to pay consultants. So I can't tell you right now that the parks is the most important. Maybe these guys will give you their opinion on that. Well, Mr. Mayor, in terms of helping council prioritize, I think we would like to hear from the current plan what has been implemented, what is being used, what did not get implemented, why did it not get implemented.

1:07:47 And what things did the current plan not cover at all that you see as being new needs going forward that you want to plan for? So if you could just one sheet kind of an assessment of where we're at with that, that would be really helpful. I've got, and I will let my other council members go too. I've said too much already today. There's a couple things I'd like to say. When I was chair of the rec commission, and that was for no short time, I kept telling my recreation commissioners that they have the ear of the council. All they have to do is

1:08:16 Thank you.

1:08:46 Group meetings we've had in a long time. We actually agreed, we disagreed, and we actually had a conversation about something, so I will give you kudos for that. Any from commission or council, any further dialogue on this? Or have I bored you all already? I'll be taking your phone number at the end of the meeting.

1:09:09 You got it. I'll give you a card before you go. I just want to say I agree with everything you just said. This was the first time I was in, we were like, what are we doing here? What are we talking about? We have this massive agenda. We can't get anything done. So this was the most productive dialogue about a lot of issues. And that's what I kind of threw a rock into the pond just to start a conversation about some things.

1:09:33 And thank you for being patient. It wasn't on the agenda, but I opened up by saying this is pretty self-explanatory. This is what we're working on, but what's not here, it's on my mind. And so thank you for being patient with that aspect of what I had in mind. And also to get across that it's really important that we start reevaluating our needs and goals.

1:09:58 Just to summarize, however, John mentions to you then,

1:10:32 He needs to see a summary of... Sure. What got accomplished? And is that the next step then to moving into the new master plan then? To working from that? Or to... The step is, I think the comment I heard from Rob was to turn the microphone on, but to also, I think, collaborate town-wide. So I think there's an opportunity that there'll be a discussion with council, Rob, town manager, about how we're kind of tackling the general plan.

1:11:00 What updates move forward, you know, what doesn't, you know, we can kind of look at an update that way. So what I'm going to work on is if Rob kind of directs me to work on the summary of our Parks and Rec Master Plan, I'll kind of put that together. And if that's something I think is important enough that we want to bring forward a commission, we'll agendize that and then have the commission weigh in. We'll bring that back to town manager and go from there. Just to be clear, you said general plan. You're talking about the Parks and Recreation Master Plan.

1:11:28 Yeah, there's, I mean, I heard the general plan obviously is a large document. That's all different. What elements in there that kind of need to be updated too. So I think there's that larger picture. I kind of convey the highlight to the town manager who would then convey that to council and hopefully get some direction moving forward there. I'm excited to see, I'm really looking forward to seeing it somewhere. I mean, for those of us who were around back in the day when this, when these plans got put forward.

1:11:55 It's great to see what worked, what didn't work, what do you do for it. That'd be really helpful. I look forward to it. I do. I can't speak for the rest of the videos. It's impressive what the current plan has produced, the time frame it has, and previous to that, you know, not so much got done. So these plans are really actionable, right? Yeah, they're really great to have. Mammoth Trail System, all that stuff has produced such a

1:12:27 A lot, really a lot of positive things in a pretty relatively short period of time. Okay. With that being said, I will adjourn, not adjourn, we will take a short break from 10 minutes while we clear the room. Thank you very much, Mr. Mayor. Thanks. Thanks, everybody. Everybody.

1:12:58 Good to see you. Good. Excellent.

1:13:02 This might be the hardest groove that they've had. Because it's still punchy. Yeah, I skated the last two days. I skated yesterday in the Classic today, and it was, I was talking to Matt at one of the groomers, and they said, this is the hardest thing I've done since I've been groomed here, which is maybe four years. But I think, I think, I think they all agree.

1:13:32 Thank you.

1:14:01 Because that was my experience.

1:14:07 Those two?

1:14:37 Thank you.

1:15:03 Thank you.

1:15:26 I don't know if it was the most productive morning. I don't know if it was the most productive morning.

1:15:55 Nodding her head. Yeah, that's definitely a lot of that.

1:16:11 Still here, buddy. No more, no less. My life right now is an emotional rover.

1:16:41 I got family feuding. Feuding? Feuding. Yeah. I had to deal with that before. Yeah. We've done it. Yeah. If I, you know, if there's anything. Yeah. Right now, it's just a game of trying to manage insurance of what is best.

1:17:09 The medical community says, okay, we are now crowdless. Wow, okay. And back in session. Let me figure out where I am. Reports from commissions and or departments as needed. We have a did you know, I'm assuming we're not having a presentation on that.

1:21:51 No, Mr. Mayor, each one of these is intended to provide you a written document, especially when we talk about the complexity of the CIP update and the now monthly Office of Outdoor Recreation update. Since their work plans are fairly complicated and having someone stand at the podium and present that wouldn't be as effective as putting in writing, that's the approach that we're taking.

1:22:18 But staff is here tonight and available to answer questions that may have come from a review of that. So that being said, let me go around the dais and ask if there are any questions on 7.1. Is that styrofoam? Styrofoam. I just have a quick question. Is Pam here? Yeah. Pam, if you could just give us a quick update on how it's going on the rollout.

1:22:44 You know, the outreach. And the reason I ask is more about for future consideration when we think about the single-use plastic bottles, which will be more challenging. So I was just curious if you could give us a quick update. Sure. Thank you. Pam Kobylarz, Assistant to the Town Manager.

1:23:02 As we mentioned last year, we did that big push with all of those flyers that we made, and I know that Kendra went around to each restaurant and made sure that they were informed of this. So we did kind of a big push in the last few months of the year, but honestly, not a lot of additional outreach has happened so far.

1:23:22 In 2024, Kendra's been out on medical leave for a while, and she really is our primary person who does the education and outreach. With all of the mandates, including the state mandates, we've really kind of taken an approach of...

1:23:36 Waiting for complaints to come in and addressing them in that way rather than actively enforcing. So we'll have to determine if we want to take that same approach to our local ordinances or if we want to approach those a little bit differently. Regardless, I do think it will be important for us to do another round of in-person outreach and education to the businesses. Anecdotally, I know there's quite a few businesses still using Styrofoam. As far as I know, we haven't had any...

1:24:03 Complaints to me or Kendra, but we do want people to be in compliance, so we'll have to determine the best way to get compliance. We did write in that exception where businesses can request an exemption from this for the first year, but they do need to do that in writing, and it has to be approved by the town manager. We have not received any written request at this point in time. It might just be a matter of businesses not being aware that that's a process that they need to go through.

1:24:32 I think I did mention in one of my previous reports that I felt that six months wasn't really enough time to roll this out and get the outreach that I would have wanted to do prior to this going in place, and so I still feel like we're a little bit behind the curve on that. So that's kind of a general summary of where we're at. That's all I was hoping for. Thank you so much. Okay. Any other questions? Thank you. Okay. Any public on 7.1? Any public?

1:25:03 7.2, any questions on the CIP update? John, you good? No, no questions on the CIP. Thank you. How about the Office of Outdoor Recreation update? I would love to hear the Office of Outdoor Recreation. I think it's the first time we've had a written agenda. Yeah, we have a written report in the packet, of course. Right. Yeah. Thank you, Wilson. Thank you, Wilson.

1:25:31 Hello, Lawson Reef, Outdoor Recreation Manager. As Rob said, I just wanted to provide a similar update to you all that Hayes has been providing regarding the CIP. As Councilmember Wentworth said, this is the first one. Obviously, if anybody has any questions, feel free to ask. I can go through maybe a few of the big ones. And if there is...

1:25:55 Any questions on some of the other ones that are written, feel free, but I think one of the big ones for next summer is we got some good competitive bids on the Sharp Trailhead. Right there at the propane tanks, where we will do some paving work, we will eventually have a bus stop there, bare boxes, trash cans, a real trailhead. Trail system signage.

1:26:17 Things of that nature. So that's going to be really, really exciting. Obviously, again, working in conjunction with our Sharp Trails proposal, which our contractor, Stantec, is working through as it relates to the archaeological analysis. And then we are going to be starting the back and forth. Hey, there's resources here. What do we do? Can we go around them? Can we mitigate these things in other ways? And I will have much more comprehensive updates for all of you as we move into the summer months. I also want to be clear with...

1:26:46 Both of these, the Sharp Trails and the Trailhead, they are funded with SNC grants. Despite the cost of everything going way, way up, I believe we are only slightly over the $953,000 that we have for implementation for the Sharp Trailhead.

1:27:08 So we'll work through that process, what money we may need to add to that, but it's not much, and that is a good thing. Obviously, I thought it could have been more. We've spoken about this as well, and we're in the process of developing a plan right now with Town Manager as well as Public Works Director related to the snow pit. I think we all know that's a big one, important one for the community.

1:27:31 Basically, we have found through some soil testing that there are some contaminants there. There seems to be a little argument of where those contaminants came from, and we are working with our forest partners to try to figure out a plan moving forward. We have met internally on this, and again, we'll keep council posted as we move forward. An exciting one for me.

1:27:55 Along with Outdoor Recreation Coordinator, Gretchen Hasselbauer, we have a lot of our 2024 stewardship days all planned. These are near and dear to my heart. Go out, pick up trash, work on trails, things of that nature. So we'll be getting that full schedule out very, very soon. And we are working on a new summer recreation map as well, which will be very helpful for our visitors.

1:28:16 Wayfinding, we'll have all the updates. We've been waiting until the e-bike ordinance went through, all the updates related to those new rules and regulations that will cover those very, very popular modes of transportation. And then the last, well, the last two I wanted to mention, winter grooming efforts going forward in earnest. We are grooming as much as humanly possible.

1:28:39 A big shout-out to our friends at Mammoth Mountain who allowed us to lease one of their snowmobiles since the Nordoni, the much-loved Nordoni, has gone down, and that has been very, very effective, again, for all of you. We did request expanded grooming to groom more terrain, which is going through the forest subpart C process. So we'll have more updates for you on that as things move forward. And last but not least,

1:29:06 Tons of damaged stuff along the trail system, including our signage. We just received a big package of sign graphics, and we will be moving to replace around 58, 60 broken signs along the trail system. So you'll see a lot of fresh signage out there. Any questions for me? You know, I had one question I wasn't going to ask at an open session, but I will since you're here. In your piece, you talked about the Forest Service requesting us to go groom the...

1:29:37 Was there a reason behind that that is normally groomed as they do the OSV trails with the OSV groomer? That was an arrangement that was made decades ago. So did something happen to change that relationship or? No. Good question. This was a one-time thing. The forest...

1:30:01 So basically the forest had nobody trained on their groomer early season. The Sequoia National Forest is currently up here on the Inyo training their drivers. So prior to that, the system was ready. There was enough snow, but they did not have anyone to drive their cats. So they reached out to us.

1:30:21 And we used some more unrestricted funding to go up there and have Trails Manager Andrew as well as Outdoor Recreation Coordinator Gretchen go up there and groom that. So just a one-time thing. They are grooming those trails into the future, and the Sequoia is up here now training a cadre of Inyo National Forest drivers. Thank you. No problem. Mr. Mayor, just a question or two.

1:30:47 Rob, just for the edification of the council, I believe that the forest supervisor a while ago had advised the district ranger here to have a regular monthly meeting, I think, with the district ranger. Could you just give us all an update on how you are engaging with the district on some of these topics? Yeah, certainly. So part of my work plan as town manager, which I'm day six now, is relationship development.

1:31:13 And one of the key elements, obviously, with our partnership with the Forest Service is one of the critical elements. So what I had planned in my sort of write-up for the first, you know, efforts that I was going to do as Town Manager was establishing these monthly meetings. I think the intent of them, you know, is certainly to discuss some of the things that we've got going on, to try to bring

1:31:36 The Forest Service awareness into the projects that we have, maybe how we could partner, the mutual benefit comes from that. And so that was my plan. I understand, yeah, that the Forest Supervisor had had that desire maybe a couple of years ago. And so my goal will be to reach out first and foremost through her to get that confirmation. And I would also like to have some quarterly meetings, if you will, higher level with her.

1:32:03 on those efforts, but try to establish that for sure with Fred here locally. And that was the plan. Okay. I think it's just important for all of us to know that all these different Forest Service interface and even Park Service interface issues that you guys are maintaining, these relate, that would be really helpful. One other just last sort of observation, Bill, I know it's near and dear to your heart, is the OSV groomed network. And we just keep going through this thing year after year when

1:32:30 Finally, there's snow, and for whatever reasons, the Forest Service staff, they just can't get it together to make it happen. And I know you all got plenty of things to do, but I think it would be interesting to maybe look into whatever kind of opportunity with the capacity we have to maybe start finding a way to maybe take on that program in a way that could be reliable, because it's just not working. Interesting to me, John, that you said that, because I had a long conversation with the gentleman that used to run the grooming program here to tell me just how ineffective

1:32:59 In your national forest has been in doing this and asking if the town couldn't take over that concession. Oh, interesting. It is a state groomer. I have talked to people at the state. I have talked to others to get that off the ground. At the time, I was told we don't need to worry about it because the Sequoia was going to be here way early on training employees and we were not going to have this problem anymore. So it might be a good time for some of us to have that meeting again to determine.

1:33:29 What the best cause is going forward. The Forest Service does not own that groomer. It is owned by the State of California Office of Outdoor Recreation, the OHVMR. They don't have an Office of Outdoor Recreation. Well, it's, yeah. Off-highway vehicle motorized recreation division. But I have worked with them for a long, long time. And it is a good time.

1:33:52 Over this next off season for us to start those conversations with the forest to see whether or not that isn't a better way to travel. Okay. I just wanted to bring that up because I know that's. Yeah, no, and I appreciate that. It is something that, you know, in my off hours I have been. And I'll add, you know, a little bit to that as Lawson presented on the grooming efforts that we have this year. We're doing a little bit of a proof of concept, right? We recognize, he mentioned the fact that our desire is to expand it.

1:34:21 I'd like to see how successful I am with these monthly meetings.

1:34:51 Come at the Forest Service with our expectations, but more just talk collaboratively about mutual success and then see where we get, right? So we've got eyes on this and I think very much a desire to have, you know, world-class groomed trails. I also have asked Lawson to make sure that we have really good uniform.

1:35:15 They're easily identified when they're in the field doing that because they are on snow machines and sometimes in an area that is for not snow machine recreation, but they're there to do the maintenance types of things. I want to make sure that we are professional looking and that we're well identified as why we're out there and what we're supposed to be. So we've got eyes on this process and really seeking to make improvements. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, and thank you, Lawson, and thank you, Rob.

1:35:42 Yeah. I just wanted to also make a point. When you talk about recreation in our community, it's incredibly complex, right? There are multiple components of that, multiple aspects. We have an Office of Outdoor Recreation. We have a Parks and Rec Department. We have Mammoth Lakes Recreation. We have the Rec Commission. They're all working very collaboratively. As you can see, Kim Montclerio, Executive Director of MLR, has been here tonight.

1:36:07 To make sure she's able to address any questions that may have come up through either the joint meeting or this presentation that Lawson just gave. So the collaboration is strong in there. It's a complicated beast, but I think it's working very well. And took the comments received earlier about fear of that siloed effect. That is my job to make sure that does not occur. So I recognize that, and it's working very, very well right now, and we'll continue to enhance that.

1:36:36 Thank you, Rob. Any public comments on 7.3? Seeing none. Do we have any verbal reports from commissions or departments as needed? No one is jumping up. Moving on to consent agenda items. 8.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of February 21. 8.2, authorize the town manager to execute an agreement with Ms. Lunatello, contractor, for the operation of a food truck at the Community Recreation Center.

1:37:05 Subject to final legal review and approval by the contractor, 8.3 award contract for the Sharp Trailhead Facilities Project to Spice Construction Company, 8.4 except check register 222-24 and 228-24. Anybody want to pull anything from consent? Just a point of clarification, Mr. Mayor. This Sharp, this is the Trailhead thing that Lawson you were just talking about? Yes. It is? Okay, great. Just clarifying. Thank you.

1:37:35 Anybody in the public want to speak to anything on consent? Seeing none, I would entertain a motion. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve the four consent agenda items as presented. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberations? Seeing none. Jamie? Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes.

1:38:05 Passes 5-0. Thank you all. As soon as I can separate my pages here, we will move on. Policy matters 9.1, waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance amending Municipal Code Chapter 3.12, Transient Occupancy Tax, and 5.40, Transient Rental of Residential Units. Rob. Yes, thank you, Mayor Sauser. So this is

1:38:33 We've been talking about this for the last several months as we've been working through the STR Advisory Committee and different functions on how we can improve the administration of our short-term rental. I think the work that was done and the fruits of the labor and so forth in these two edits are sort of indicative of how the town is investing in short-term rental.

1:39:02 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:39:31 tax certificate focus with a certified property aspect that brings the owner of the property into the conversation. With these changes, what we've tried to do is augment some gaps in our management of it. We've had to augment some of our enforcement capabilities and just really formalize that process.

1:39:58 There's nothing really new in the presentation, so I'm not going to go in detail on that unless there are questions. I will say that we spent at least a month and a half rewriting 312 and 5.40, which are the management aspects of short-term rentals. I expended quite a bit of personal capital with the town attorney.

1:40:21 In reviewing that and going through that, it took a couple of weeks through that process, but incredibly grateful for his efforts in providing this in the coherent way of reading it, if you will, from mine. But what you have before you is a comprehensive list of municipal code edits reflected in what we were trying to achieve with certified properties.

1:40:45 The process that this will take is, provided that you approve this tonight for the first reading, it then goes to a second reading on the 20th. So if there are any small adjustments that can be made between this first reading and second reading, as long as they're not substantive.

1:41:03 Then the second reading will occur on the 20th and then the full and that's when it's adopted and then implementation occurs 30 days later. So in this case 30 days after the 20th lands on a Saturday so we targeted the timing of this to be April 22nd. So that's when the new rules and regulations will take place and as I said or I haven't said but

1:41:28 This is really tied to the next agenda item, which is on the moratorium. And that's really based upon the fact we wanted to get these rules set. We wanted to get these edits done so that when someone, you know, should there be new businesses that start to open or want to progress, that can happen under the new regulations. And that was a critical part of that, right? So that's the step that we are at.

1:41:54 Today is getting this process finalized from the legal aspect of things. This will, kind of to address some of the questions I had earlier today, once both of these sort of roll forward, this would lift the moratorium and allow, I'm sorry, I'm not going to go there at this point. I'm going to stay on the certified properties element. But I want to know if there are any questions instead of me rambling on about that. Questions, John?

1:42:24 Rob, thanks for that. And so just to be clear, this represents updates to the municipal code, correct? That's correct, yes. Mr. Morris, are you on the line? I'm wondering if Andy... Oh, Andy, not... Oh, no, not John, sorry. Are you a lawyer? I need to speak with a lawyer Morris, that one. Andy, Rob shared that this was a pretty significant effort and you were deeply involved in this. Maybe you could share with the council what your experience in all this. Well, I mean, as Rob said, the idea is to try to have...

1:42:51 A clearer set of enforcement tools and a clearer understanding about who holds the STR certification for a particular property, which I think has not always been clear in the past. So it's intended to give property owners more flexibility, intended to give the town better enforcement tools, and overall intended to make the process work better. So that's what we're trying to do. And as Rob said,

1:43:15 The, well, actually, I shouldn't say, as Rob didn't say, the moratorium could go for another year if the council were so inclined to do that, but I think that staff feel that it's appropriate to have the moratorium go away now because we've now gotten to the point of having maybe more effective STR regulatory tools. Thank you. Those are my questions. Chris? There we go. Rob, my only concern here, and I should have talked to you about this earlier, but, you know, things are what they are.

1:43:50 Could this potentially cause a bottleneck for staff as several properties that currently have STR certificates are going to have to change them to the owner rather than the operator? And are we prepared to deal with that? So we are. We've been developing a program by which we can register this. And so we're going to sort of onboard all of our existing and known properties.

1:44:18 And we also believe that some aspects of the collection of data and so forth on the returns will be implemented probably by July 1. So while the rules and regulations are in place and that will govern anyone who's signing up for a new business or anyone who's currently in business, some of the aspects of actually submitting the data

1:44:42 And that process will occur a few months later. So we are prepared with our sort of electronic processes. And I think they're going to be much improved to what we have now for having tax returns submitted. But the whole process of onboarding the properties is going to be very, very

1:45:04 User-Friendly, if you will, not intrusive at all to our existing workers or existing operators, if you will. Thank you. No more questions? Go ahead. One of the challenges that we had when we were starting the process was that we didn't have the data to really understand how, you know, sort of where the revenue is coming from, where were the most, you know,

1:45:36 Profitable parts of town, if you will. Will this also address that, that we'll be able to have much more granular detail? Yes. So a tax return today, for example, I'm going to pick on a management company that may have hundreds of properties. Today what we ask for is really high-level macro data. We want to know gross receipts of all the units combined.

1:46:02 We want to know some statistical data, but we rarely get that information. What we've set up is an electronic submission process, and the requirement will be that each of the units, they provide the gross receipts for each unit, the nights that are available for rent, the nights that were rented. So we're going to have a whole lot of statistical information about how these properties are being managed and really what occupancy is.

1:46:31 Really what ADRs are, and really the impact of personal usage versus available for rent night. So we're going to have a lot of statistical data on each and every unit. And what we've been spending time on, and I appreciate the efforts of both Stephanie Trujillo and Sean Troy in my department, have been developing this software that will facilitate that, right? We can't...

1:46:57 Put together something that's going to be so arduous that people cannot submit a return. But what we have is this. It's very simple. The items will be existing on the sheet. They can go down and key the data for each one of them. It accumulates the gross receipts and says, here's your tax return. You want to submit it here, submit it and pay. So it's going to be very good. We just have some final aspect to finalize. Thank you. Yes. Any public comment on this item? Any online public comment on this item?

1:47:31 Dan, please unmute yourself and give your comments. I just have a really quick question. There's a, in the proposed, by the way, I think the short-term, the certified product-free program, I think it's going to be terrific and really, I think that's, whenever we get to doing that, I think it's needed. I have a quick question on, there is a definition of a local 24-hour emergency contact, and I was wondering,

1:48:03 In the case of condominium association, like our condominium association has on-site property manager, which is, you know, emergency in my mind is fire, blood, you know, plumbing, electrical, structural problem, you know, that type of stuff. And the on-site property manager really should be the first person

1:48:30 I just want to make sure that I don't know that that definition encompasses

1:49:00 The actual homeowners, I mean, that's my question, I guess, too, maybe somebody can answer that question. Would that local 24-hour emergency contact person be the, can it be, the condominium association, if they have, we have somebody who actually lives in a unit on site.

1:49:21 And is available and should be available because that's the purpose, that's the reason they live on site is because they need to handle any type of emergency. So that could affect a unit and they should really be the first person contact, quite frankly. So just had a question about that. I mean, would that condominium association, you know, the condo association typically are non-profit corporations. I just was wondering, will it meet that legal definition that's defined in that

1:49:51 Yeah, Dan, I can address that. So the 24-hour contact is definitely one of the aspects that's been written in our code for a number of years, but it's also one that we have the most trouble with. So what we were trying to do is narrow that down to really

1:50:18 Three people that that could be. So it can certainly be the owner if the owner lives within an hour and can respond. It can be a property management company as long as they have someone dedicated for that activity. Or it can be a licensed business within the town. So if you have someone designated in your condo complex, what I would ask is that they register to perform those services within the town and we can help facilitate that.

1:50:48 What we're really looking for is a specific contact and someone that we can reach out to from the town's aspect if we need to for any reason, but also the opportunity to talk to them about the roles and responsibilities of doing that function, right? What you described is often enough, you know, emergency response, but I think in general the questions that come up and what I'm hearing from lodging operators, it's not always an emergency. Sometimes it's a

1:51:18 Just a general nuisance issue at any hour. So I want to make sure that folks are willing to be responsive to that because you're right, an impact of one particular area is really problematic for other surrounding. And part of this was wrapped into a little bit of a quality of life expectation we were trying to achieve with this process. So yeah, reach out to the town. We'll have a process by which they can register.

1:51:41 With us, and again, it'll be more, it's more sophisticated than it has been in the past, and that is by design. And that would be, Rob, up to the condo association whether they wanted to register their managers as that or not. That's correct. Because there is a growing number of condos in town whose managers aren't allowed to deal with the STR issues. They are there only for support of the owners. Correct. Hopefully that helps. Any other comments on this issue? Seeing none.

1:52:14 I would entertain a motion. Or I can make it. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance amending Municipal Code Chapter 3.12, Transient Occupancy Tax and 5.40 Transient Rental Residential Units with a sincere note of gratitude not only to staff but to the Advisory Committee, to all the members of the public who

1:52:46 Participated in this difficult and challenging process. But real gratitude, I think, on behalf of the council and the town myself. Thank you, John. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Seeing none. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Passes 5-0. Moving on then to 9.2.

1:53:12 Waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance to terminate the moratorium on the issuance of short-term rental certificates. Conversation. If I may? Yes. So as I stated before, the regulation, the rules, the municipal code edits that we just finalized were really critical aspect and the moratorium kind of gave us that cover to achieve those.

1:53:46 With regard to having that finalized and having that on a course by which they'll be adopted, on a course by which they'll become effective, staff felt it appropriate to bring to you the opportunity to cancel the moratorium in the same time frame that we would adopt and implement the new rules and regulations.

1:54:12 These two are sort of combined as meaning they'll run at the same time and take effect at the same time. But I think, you know, it's important to note the council has been very diligent in this process. Originally, you know, as we said, it could be up to a two-year process. We went out and I think, you know, thank Dan Holler for his efforts in making sure this was a...

1:54:39 A focus is like, let's get a six-month time period on this. Let's do that extension of the moratorium so that it expires on May 31st, right? So that we as staff have pressure on us to get this done and get it achieved. So I'm grateful for that effort and for your leadership, all of you. But this would then terminate more than a month early if it is so approved tonight.

1:55:08 I personally as staff think it's appropriate based upon where we are with the municipal code edits and having that finalized to bring this forward. So that's what we did tonight. Thank you, Rob. Questions or comments? John? No questions. Thoughts for deliberation, but no questions. Okay. Questions? I don't have any questions. Questions? Same as John. Sarah? Nope. I have no questions on this.

1:55:39 Do we have any questions from the public? So what I'm going to do first is take the deliberation of council and then go to public. Anyone online? But it's a question, yeah. So at this point, I would take the, start the deliberation if someone would like to start us off. I'll go. Well, I guess I would like to say, you know, I feel like

1:56:08 We put the moratorium in place so that we could have a conversation about what tools we're willing to use as a town to address how STRs are affecting our local housing supply. This was to stop a rush to the counter for people getting permits while we talked about this. I do feel that it's been a missed.

1:56:37 I would have liked to have discussed.

1:57:04 You know, other management tools. You know, I feel that, you know, Bill, you've said multiple times like, oh, TOT, it's taxation without representation. And I have to disagree with you completely on that because STR operators and hotel operators, they do not pay TOT. They collect TOT from visitors and they remit it to the town.

1:57:35 This in no way to me is taxation without representation at all. And I don't think that we're going to be able to build our way out of this problem. I think that we need to look at other management tools. And it's been disappointing where we are now. I just really feel that it's a missed opportunity. So, you know, I feel that

1:58:05 It's great we're doing the certified properties. Currently our solution is we've gone from a $25 fee to a $250 fee and an inspection every four years. I don't think that's going to do anything to stop long-term rentals being converted to STRs. I don't think it's going to do anything to promote people changing from STRs to long-term rentals. So those are my thoughts.

1:58:35 Thank you. Amanda? Sarah? Okay. I appreciate your comments. And I appreciate what the council members, we as an organization staff, all of the tumult that we went through with this process. There's a couple things that really registered with me. And one is that

1:59:10 The relationship of nightly rentals to the infrastructure that we have in this community. The second thing is the realization, looking around at other mountain communities, other destination communities, and understanding this is an across-the-board ubiquitous challenge to all of these places, and that each one of these places is picking and choosing their own way of what makes sense to address this and how we move forward.

1:59:37 I think that what has come out of the advisory committee, what we're doing tonight is consistent with what this community is and how it functions. I think also when we had the workshop and we reviewed the documentation from the consultant and the question was asked, okay, well, how do you get from a cap to a bed? And the response was, well, that's a really good question. And at this point,

2:00:05 That doesn't seem to be sufficient to start imposing those kinds of things on a whole wide variety of people and getting all those complicated issues if we can't make a really clear nexus between taking those kinds of actions and getting the kind of outcomes we're looking to produce.

2:00:25 Given that, I think that the recommendations from the advisory committee, and also, Bill, you were online, I think, when you were leading the meeting at the workshop, the suite of tools that we're going to deploy to see if they work, to see what they do, I think that that's a reasonable and a good first step. But I also appreciate, and I don't want to characterize it as an admonition,

2:00:52 From the Mayor Pro Tem. But the idea that, look, if we're not willing, if we as a community, the voters, are not going to be willing to support the funding that we need to move these things forward, if we're not going to be willing to invest in all the various programs that came out of the advisory committee, if that doesn't happen, the council can come back and take another look at this and see what we do.

2:01:16 I'm happy where we're at for the moment. I think we should support taking this moratorium down. And again, I didn't hear the other more punitive tools. I could not understand the nexus between putting those things in place and getting to the solutions that we want to see. The nexus, for me, wasn't sufficient. So I think we're good where we're at, but we have a lot of work to do to bring in.

2:01:45 The other tools we need, the money and the revenue and the resources to invest in our Housing Now program, which we put in place, and to see what we can get out of all that. So those are my thoughts. Thank you, John. Chris? Thank you. I heard what you said, and John, I heard what you said. I do want to thank the members of the short-term rental committee who volunteered.

2:02:17 I think that the first thing is that passing the Certified Properties Program is step one because one of the frustrations that we had as a council was we didn't have, you know, statistical data to tell us what was going on in our town. And that made it, I think, extra challenging for us to really even understand what kinds of levers we could push. So that, the Certified Properties Program step, to me, is a first step.

2:02:49 I wish we had done it a long time ago. We're doing it now, and we'll move forward with that. The second thing that I think is really important is that we need to move forward quickly with the placemate program. We all agreed that that was one of the most practical tools we have seen in practice that is moving short-term rentals back to long-term rentals. So I really want to make sure that we're clear that that needs to come forward quickly. The third thing is that

2:03:18 We do need to pass the 2% increase in TOT to fund our Housing Now program in a broader way because I have just seen or heard that we are starting to see some quotes and pathways forward for phase four of the parcel, which is a home ownership program. It is expensive and we, what's that? Phase three. Phase three.

2:03:49 We are going to need a lot of money. So that's why it is essential that we as a town pass the 2% increase on TOT. And while we're at it, I've said it before and I'll say it again, we need to pass the fire bond because if our town experiences a catastrophic wildfire, none of this matters. So I'm really making it clear to our community that all of these things have to happen. And so with all of that,

2:04:19 I just want to reiterate to staff so it's super clear that we need to be prepared that if those measures don't pass on the November ballot that we'll be back here and we may be having a very different conversation from the one this evening. So I just don't want any, I want it to be crystal clear that that I think is essential for the future of our town. And those are my thoughts. Thank you. For myself,

2:04:49 I have yet to hear an argument how restricting short-term rentals was going to put more long-term rentals in the market. I've been waiting. I've been listening. I understand what you're saying. You're disappointed we didn't get there. I would like to see better solutions as well. But in my business, I have dealt with both long-term and short-term rentals and the owners of the units and why they buy and why they don't buy, and I see no clear path.

2:05:19 Between the short-term rentals and how many of our condominiums, which is, face it, that's what we're talking about, not houses, we're talking about condominiums, and how we could reduce the price of those enough to make them attractive for the local buyers. I just don't see it. So for those reasons, I am in favor of ending the moratorium tonight. Any public comments on this?

2:05:54 Good evening, Mayor Sauser. Great to see you in person. John Morris, Chair of the Short-Term Rental Advisory Committee. I agree with all you guys in that if we can't get this done in November, then if this community cannot see the importance of housing in this fashion, that this is a potential solution.

2:06:19 It's not going to be the only solution, that's for sure, and there's always going to be a challenge. But if we can't convince the voters of Mammoth that these proposals make sense, and that's going to take a good campaign from, I would hope, from the town.

2:06:36 From all the associations, from the businesses, and I'm not talking about this as a business person, I'm talking about as a resident of Mammoth. If we can't convince the residents of Mammoth that this is going to improve their quality of life and be able to make their job experience more positive by having more staff and less stress and all that, if that's not going to work, then you're right.

2:06:57 We need to come back next year and put some sticks and stuff out there and some caps and some restrictions because that's the only other solution. If we can't move forward with creating more housing that way, then I don't really know what other solutions are. I've beat my head about against this for 15, 20 years now. And what we came up with out of the committee was the best thing that I think that we could in a positive manner.

2:07:24 Again, I appreciate all of your guys' work on this and your comments and so forth. It's difficult. It's a very difficult situation. But I think we've got some programs that we've presented to you guys that could work. I hope they do. They've been proven to work in some other areas, so we've got our fingers crossed that we can make this go. But again, our job now, if you so, move forward to this.

2:07:49 Is to convince the public of Mammoth Lakes and all those people that need housing that this is something they need to vote for to get us to that point. So that's our next challenge. So appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you, John. Any other public comments? Online public comments, Jamie? None. That being said, I will make the motion.

2:08:17 To adopt an ordinance lifting the current moratorium on the issuance of new short-term rental registration certificates pursuant to the Town of Mammoth Lake Municipal Code Title V. Okay. I will second that bill. Thank you. Motion and a second. Any further deliberations? Seeing none. Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Thank you all.

2:08:52 And just to reiterate the timing of that, so this is still a first reading, so the moratorium lifts on April 22nd. Yes. Thank you. Provided we go through the second reading and so forth. Thank you, Rob. Yep. 9.3, appointment of Town Council representatives to the Mona County Local Transportation Commission. Rob, are you going to start us off on this? Yeah, I'm going to open that up. So as town manager, I did attend the LTC meeting.

2:09:21 For the month of March. And for various reasons, I think we've had some change in our assignments right now. So we have Mayor Sauser is assigned to the LTC. And you've been out of town quite a bit. And Amanda.

2:09:40 You are also assigned and have had take on additional work duties, making that meeting not something that's possible. So it's important. There are three representatives from the Town of Mammoth Lakes, one being Paul Chang from the Planning Commission, as well as two of our electeds. So the recommendation or the request from the LTC was to bring forward to the Town Council a discussion on changing the

2:10:08 Or having someone else appointed that will be able to attend the meetings. And so that's what we put forth for you tonight. And, you know, we've got some ideas. I'd love to hear them. Well, I would like to suggest Chris Bubser to replace me on there, if she's willing. I am willing. Thank you. I would like to say I would like to stay on it. I think I've only missed one meeting.

2:10:36 Yes, I have some family obligations that are keeping me out of town, but this is a meeting that I can attend online. And, you know, hopefully my time will be increasing here in town, so I would really like to stay on this. However, I think since we have three representatives on the board, the idea of having two alternates might be a good idea instead of just the one. Yeah, so...

2:11:04 Right now, so my role as Town Manager, I am an alternate to that. Haislip Hayes is co-director of the organization, so he's town staff on that. So I will convene with Hais and talk about what could be appropriate to provide that second degree, since both of us are engaged already in that process, but we'll think about that recommendation. Thank you. So right now,

2:11:33 Can I make a motion? Yes, absolutely. I make a motion to appoint Chris Bubser to the LTC. Thank you. I'll second that. And I, Bill, I mean, with, I mean, I did a lot of time on the LTC. So if you need, from any one of us, if you need any introduction to the acronym SOUP, it's not really a SOUP. It's like a, it's like a bouillabaisse, you know, it's never ending. But if that, any one of us can be of assistance, I think we'd all be willing. So I'll second that.

2:12:05 Thank you. Yeah. Is there a second? No, you're seconded. I seconded. Yeah. I have a motion. I have a second. Any further deliberation? All right. Let's go to any public comment. Seeing none. Jamie. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. So if I understand what we just did, that leaves myself and Chris on the LTC. Is that correct? That's correct. Or do we need a further motion?

2:12:39 That's it. We just had the one we were replacing, and so we're good. Okay, moving on to that. Councilmember reports. Who'd like to start us off here? I'll go first. I have nothing to report. Perfect. Nothing. John? Yeah, I've got a couple things here. So we'll start with I attended the MOT board meeting this afternoon, and

2:13:06 Heard a lot of interesting updates about the kinds of things that MLT does. We talked about the Clean Up the Lake program. We had a good presentation from those folks. MLT is helping to fund that. If I got that right, they're down here cleaning up lakes. And there's all kinds of interesting stuff in the lakes that shouldn't be there. The board is going to be looking at from the strategic plan perspective.

2:13:31 Not doing a review of the strategies, but rather focusing on the tactics, because the strategies don't seem to change that much, but the tactics are the things that really need some focus to move that kind of move and focus the organization on what it's doing. Winter Air Service, the numbers are a little bit below what they were last year. Last year was a big year. It's something to keep our eyes on. I know, Rob, we talked about the report out we get from your staff, what's happening at the Mammoth Airport. It's good to get these kinds of numbers to kind of see what's happening.

2:14:01 There's appointments made to some ad hoc committees. Heard some interesting updates from the various departments. And really trying to, from my perspective, trying to really focus on what it is that MLT is doing that the town needs to be doing in concert. An example was the Lake Mary Spur, which the MLT just made a video about how to park up there and do those different kinds of things. There's no trash cans up there. Okay, was that something that's on us? Are these the kinds of things we need to have discussions about?

2:14:30 But I think we talked earlier with the joint meeting with the Rec Commission about working together and not having these silos. There's a lot of stuff happening on the MLT side that we need to bring into these conversations to complement all that stuff. We talked about a lot with the TBIT stuff and the renewal of the contract for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We've got to really be working together.

2:14:49 The Community of Recreation Center is a great example of that. A public facility, a lot of support from MOT to bring in the LA Kings and all the rest of it. And that's the kind of three-legged still we want to be operating on, so I'm continuing to advocate with that board. On a slightly different thing, it's not a formal council appointment, but there's an ESSRP, Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, meeting happened on Monday.

2:15:12 Very interesting presentation on a number, two great big grants, each of them worth about $30 million. The ink isn't dry yet. Between the Economic Development Administration and the Department of Energy, about $60 million that could be going into helping to build a biomass facility here in Mammoth Lakes. That's a pretty exciting development. You look at the Donut Project, where is all that stuff going to go, all those logs out there by the propane tanks?

2:15:40 That's a pretty interesting development, Rob. I'm sure we'll get more updates on that as we move forward. I attended on March 1st the California Jobs First HRTC meeting. Councilmember Bubser was at that as well. That process is starting to really create some real concern for me. I think this is something we need to be thinking about. I won't go into much detail about it now.

2:16:06 Our region, compared to the other regions in the state, seems to be significantly behind. And I'm not convinced that people facilitating this are hearing us. We're being properly represented. And I'm really concerned about a train wreck that could happen when they publish a strategic economic development strategy for our region, which includes four counties on the west side.

2:16:29 They don't even have a date of when they will publish it for our review so we can comment on it in a way that our comments can be incorporated before they have to turn it into the state in August. It's making me nervous. I mean, Chris, you may have your own ideas about it, but it's concerning. I attended Dan Holler's farewell celebration, which was wonderful and very nice to celebrate his last council meeting, which was last week.

2:16:58 I attended the ESCOG meeting. And Chris, I'll just read from my notes. I'm sure you've got some better things to share on that one as well. But there was some interesting stuff that happened there. One is the Dan came forward and said goodbye. He's made the rounds. We met a guy named Tyrone Grandstrand, who's the Monroe County Housing Opportunities Manager, which was interesting to meet him. Received an interesting update from Rob Patterson on the Mammoth Lakes, sorry, on the Eastern Sierra Air Alliance.

2:17:28 Which is theoretically the group where the funding is going to come from for the subsidies, which is important for us to be thinking about in terms of what MLT is doing, what Altera is up to. That was interesting. But we had a very interesting discussion around the CEDS, the Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy, which is this grant that Dan had put together, this $30 million grant before he left, where the federal folks said, well, where are these projects listed in your CEDS?

2:17:52 And he said, they're not listed in the SEDS. I said, well, you have to put them in the SEDS or we can't fund it. So the ESCOG kind of stepped up and danced around a little bit. We got those things listed. But that's a good lesson, sort of a caution for all of us going forward. We need to get those projects listed in the SEDS. There's now a process to the ESCOG to do that. So that was a good thing. And we received an update on this California jobs first process from Stacey Corliss. Stacey, just to be clear, who lives in our region,

2:18:20 Was pulled off of that project by leadership at the Sierra Business Council. So now we don't have anybody who actually lives in our counties who's directly involved in some kind of way with this project, other than the ESCOG. The ESCOG has a contract, but I think they're frustrated also. So this is something we've got to keep our eye on. The Buttermilk Infrastructure and Recreation Initiative document was accepted by.

2:18:43 By the ESCOG, there's a lot of work going down in there around the Buttermilk, not too dissimilar for the Sherman's Area Recreation Plan. From all that work, they've got their own kind of project going on down there, which is interesting. Then there's a really good update, I'm sure, from Scott Armstrong and the Eastern Sierra Broadband, which I had to leave the meeting before that happened. And then, and that's it. Thank you. Thank you for your patience. Thank you, John. Chris? John covered most things that I attended.

2:19:12 I would say the one thing that concerns me about the California Jobs First, which used to be called the surf, is the fact that there's one pool of money, $150 million or something, for the entire state. And once again, I think that our main disadvantage as a region is that there's a rubric that's going to be used to be evaluated. It hasn't been created into a formal rubric.

2:19:40 But it's clearly a rubric. And we are at a disadvantage based on that rubric. And we don't have any recourse to change that as a region unless we go to Sacramento and make some noise. And I'm totally willing to do that because I'm tired of our rural areas being ignored by Sacramento. And I think this is a perfect example. They're going to pass out all this money, and it's not going to come here.

2:20:13 Thank you. I really have nothing to share tonight. With that, we will move into a closed session. Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957, the Council will hold a conference to consider evaluation of a public employee town manager. Mr. Town Manager, are we staying where we are for this, or are we moving to the right here? That's perfect. Thank you.

2:20:42 So we will take a five-minute break and then come back later and tell you all what we did or didn't do. Have you thought about getting involved with the Legal of California's Rural City Conference? I should do that. Yes. So we need to get together at some point and look at that.