Town Council
at 16:00 · recording 3 hr 51 min
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
3 findings- A February 4, 2026 action sheet recommended Council approval of a Police Officers' Association agreement for July 1, 2025 through June 30, 2028 Public Safety and Police
- The MLPOA agreement sets 5% and 2.5% pay differentials for bilingual ability and special assignments Public Safety and Police
- A February 2026 staff report notes a paid-parking weekend at Canyon Lodge and lists paid parking on Town roads as an option Transit and Mobility
Transcript
481 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:36 That's good. That is good. Well, it's all good because the truth is you sent a whole bunch already and I've been... It seems like there's a reasonable amount of consensus. Or it's just the same letter. I read that letter. Maybe.
1:06 I feel like the one, I don't know if someone's using the same letter. Do you need a few minutes, John? Is that a no? Is that a no then? Okay.
4:38 I'd like to call this meeting to order and do a roll call, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Here. Councilmember Souser? Present. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Truax? Here. Mayor Rice? Here. Ms. Bubzer, would you like to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance this evening? Thank you. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God.
5:07 Indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Are there any additions to the agenda this evening? No. No, okay. Oh, yeah, I'm sorry. I skipped ahead there. So we are now on public comment. If there is anything on the agenda, I'm sorry, if there's anything that's not on the agenda that anyone in the room would like to address, please come on up to the podium now. We'd love to hear from you.
5:37 Come on up to the podium so we can all hear you, please. Ooh, is this thing working? I was just going to compliment the local library. It's been in a lot of libraries in my time, from San Diego to San Francisco, et cetera, et cetera. So I'm here to say nice things. Yeah, about that. And I just talked to Cynthia, and she says that this is library stuff is other people's business.
6:14 Since you said if there's someone here who's going to talk off topic, I just want to say nice things about the library. And as a way, hopefully it's not going corporate because it definitely had a pretty good hippie element to it with the people that I've been going since I moved here in 08. Excellent service. I'm not saying hippie like we're all smoking pot and back, but just excellent service.
6:43 Pretty close to all I have to say, other than the hiring process at this point in time, which I know is not this form, but hopefully it doesn't go corporate. Hopefully it keeps that cool, mammoth, you know, Dave McCoy thing. And so, in the spirit of Dave McCoy, hopefully the library doesn't go corporate, and hopefully you hear me saying good things about the library. And that's about it.
7:10 Wonderful. Thank you so much. I love our county library. Thank you. Are there any other public comments for items that are not on the agenda? Is there anyone? You want to come on up? Sure. I didn't take the notes. That's okay. But I don't know if it, I don't, I was told, I was told this was going to focus on parking on. Oh, that's on our agenda. That's item 7.2. Yes, but this is not, I have issues about that, but you said that are not on the agenda. That are not on the agenda, yes. Correct. So being.
7:42 A person that uses a walker or uses arm crutches, I find it very disheartening that part of our sidewalks are plowed and then they run into dead ends. And I don't understand. I was told maybe the equipment's not wide enough to go around corners, like at the new parcel as you're coming from Mammoth Liquor. There's a bus stop right there.
8:11 And there's a sidewalk and the whole sidewalk is plowed except we can't access it. So I just walk in the middle of the street because I'm staying on that side. So to ask me with the walker going back and forth when it's plowed, things like crosswalks and curb cuts are very difficult to get over when there's a snowbank.
8:42 I think sidewalks and things, it would be nice if they got, you know, plowed all the way around. Another thing we wanted to bring up was the fact that we have that nice new bathroom right there that's now closed. And as it, using the bus and transferring and walking around, telling me to go all the way up the road to use a public bathroom, I can't use it at the Shell Mart.
9:12 But the only public bathroom, they're just, it's right there, it's a new bathroom. Is it because the playground's closed? There's a bus stop right next to it. Good point. So there's that. Another thing I wanted to bring up, I don't know if this is the right time or place, is our nice, beautiful new ice rink. We had exhibition games there from the Reno Ice and the LA Kings.
9:42 And it rained for three days. So we had no lights in the parking lot. And you've got people in their wheelchairs and with their walkers and trying to get their equipment in and out. I was just with my arm crutches going to a parking spot. Obviously all the disabled were taken. But walking through that parking lot at night in the dark is a little scary. Even if it is a public rink.
10:13 And it would be nice if our town got a set sled so that, you know, they let us try the sleds the day after their exhibition game, but there is no equipment for people that want to sit down and skate. And just to clarify, a sled is a piece of equipment you use to ice skate? Correct. That's what they call them, is sleds. I did reach out to the LA Kings to some foundation that I found.
10:43 To see if I could get one donated to me and my Pretenda company that I have to help voice the concerns of the people that don't have a voice. And lots of people come to me. I was just talking to Caltrans and the woman down there. When we get to parking issues, we can talk about that. But had told me some very interesting things.
11:13 Yeah, it's just interesting how our town and our county and the Caltransit, nobody like really works together to do stuff for us. I find that I've been stuck in the middle of a blame game for a lot of things. So I forgot, I'm sorry, I like got a little distracted because my notes are in here for parking issues and just a few other things that I had wanted to.
11:44 Bring up if that was allowed to do so. But there's that. She gave me lots of insight from Caltrans. Well, thank you. Thank you so much for your comments. I'm sorry, it's time for public comment. We're listening to her. Please don't yell things out. My name's Ilana. Ilana. Ilana. I've lived here since 1989. Mm-hmm.
12:11 And I just decided to take the mountain up on my lifetime season pass. Thank God they gave us one. I mean, for real. And I'm sure I'm going to end up stirring stuff up because I'm getting a mobility trike. And I know that by law, or by ADA laws, that there are certain places we'll be able to park. And not yet that there are laws specifically for mobility vehicles.
12:41 That maybe we as a town, as a mountain, as a community, they're like, oh, well, you live in the snow, you're going to get a mobility trike? Well, yeah, because I'm tired of being stuck in my house. I used to be able-bodied until five years ago. And I try not to abuse the dialeride and let the people that are more disabled than me use it. Maybe that's my pride. Maybe I like, you know, those guys raid.
13:09 Raise tough people up at the mountain and we learned to slip it up and do what we got to do. But I have shoveled. Can you wrap up your comments? Your five minutes. Oh, okay. Okay, thank you. But I have shoveled the crosswalk at Highway 203 and done things like that. Thank you so much for your comments. Are there any other public comments for things that are not on the agenda? Anyone online? No?
13:39 So now I'd like to move on to are there any additions to the agenda? No. Mayor Rice, there are no adjustments to the agenda this evening. Okay, great. So we are on to item number five, reports from commissions and or departments. No. Oh. Welcome, Sabayan. How are you doing? Good afternoon, Mayor and Mayor Pro Tem, Council, staff, public, Sabayan Spring, Mammoth Yosemite Airport.
14:09 I have two items that have happened in the last since Council has last met that I would love to share with you. One of them is kind of a big deal. It's a new instrument approach procedure for Mammoth Yosemite Airport. So the background on this is historically periods of low cloud cover or reduced visibility, limited aircraft operations. We're all pretty familiar with that, specifically landings.
14:39 At Mammoth Yosemite, flights were often canceled, returned to their point of origin, or diverted to nearby airports. These disruptions created an inconvenience for travelers, both visitors and commuters, and even for airport operations workers. That challenge has now been addressed. The town of Mammoth Lakes, working in partnership with
15:01 Our Airport Management Consultants, Aviation Insights, QED, and Flight Path Economics, along with the FAA, have implemented a new instrument approach procedure that significantly enhances the airport's operational reliability during marginal weather conditions. So the new procedure allows aircraft to arrive safely when cloud ceilings are as low as 500 feet and
15:28 When forward visibility is reduced to one mile. In addition, the approach aligns the aircraft directly with the runway center line rather than the previous offset alignment, further improving safety for flight crews and passengers. Importantly, this enhancement required no capital investment. We have been receiving loads of positive feedback from private and commercial pilots since the approach becoming available on the 22nd of January.
15:59 Very enthusiastic, lots of exclamation points. People saying, finally, a real approach. It's been great reception. So that happened. That took about two years. Can I just use that approach also valid for both ways on the runway? Because that's usually from one way, but is it valid for both ways? Definitely not. It is just runway 27. So approaching from the east. The other...
16:27 A major occurrence for us at the airport is that Sierra Wa departed. On time. On time, as planned. And safely. So last week, our deputy airport manager of four years, Sierra Wa, left MMH and the town of Mammoth Lakes, where she had worked for about 13 years. I like to think of Sierra having graduated from
16:57 Mammoth Yosemite Airport, that it was part of a natural progression that she would leave after four years. However, Sierra and her partner are examples of bright, talented young people who love their jobs and contributed to the community, but ultimately relocated toward affordable housing, fewer regulations, and notably DMV offices that are staffed five days a week.
17:27 That was one of the features. But instead of thinking of Sierra's absence as a loss, we are really focusing on the tremendous contribution that she made to Mammoth Yosemite Airport. She came in winter, late 2021, when the airport was reeling from the loss of commercial service and from COVID. And from the start, Sierra endeavored to clean up.
17:55 And streamline and rebuild the weaker links of the airport chain. Her list of accomplishments is long, and while none of them are the work of one person alone, she is the thread of continuity through most of our improvements in the last four years. And those include grant awards of over $5 million for capital improvement projects, including AWOS relocation, a new landside parking lot.
18:21 The multi-purpose building design and a vehicle access road to the East hangars coming this spring. Also rebuilding relationships with our airport district office in the Western Pacific region of the FAA. Advocating for Mammoth Yosemite Airport as a regional resource for more than just passenger service. Selecting and managing our exceptional aviation and engineering contractors.
18:46 Our admin office rehab, the terminal reservation and general airport beautification and this new instrument approach procedure. But the contribution that her teammates will remember most is her unwavering support. So Sierra was always talking about future progress at the airport as a when and not an if.
19:11 She advocated for tools and training to enable the most effective airport staff possible, and she was always sharing a curiosity and an exceedingly positive spin on the things that happened at the airport. So as a crew, we wanted to say that we know that Sierra is going to uplift any situation she chooses to be a part of. We're grateful for her imprint on Mammoth Yosemite Airport, and we wish her every success and happiness.
19:41 Thank you. Thank you so much. Are there any other reports from commissions or departments? No? Okay. Moving on to the consent agenda. We have item 6.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of January 21, 2026. 6.2, approve the request for a public convenience or necessity letter in support of grocery outlet's application for a type...
20:04 21 General Liquor License, allowing off-site sales of packaged beer, wine, and distilled spirits at 37 Old Mammoth Road.
20:12 Item 6.3. Approval to continue emergency installation of above-ground waste oil tank at 299 Commerce Drive. 6.4. Approval and adopt resolution number 26XX establishing the fiscal years 2025 to 2026, 2026 to 2027, and 2027 to 2028 compensation schedules for the Mammoth Lakes Police Officers Association, MLPOA.
20:36 Item 6.5, approve the memorandum of understanding between the Town of Mammoth Lakes Town and the Mammoth Lakes Police Officers Association, MLPOA, which shall be in effect from July 1st, 2025 through June 30th, 2028. Item 6.6, accept check registrar 1-22-26 in the amount of $916,083.04.
20:59 Accept check register January 29th, 26th in the amount of $1,333,411.26. Is there anyone who wants to pull anything from the consent agenda? I'd like to pull item 6.2. Okay, so we'll pull item 6.2. And can we approve the consent agenda besides that, or shall we discuss about that? Okay, so I am open.
21:24 For a motion? I will move to approve the consent agenda as presented without 6.2. Okay. Second. Roll call please, Jamie. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Souser? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truax? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay. Motion passes. So item 6.2, what would you like to chat about, John? Oh, well, thanks.
21:56 I just wanted to check in with my fellow council members. I heard that there was kind of an unusually exuberant experience in the village over the weekend. And I know, Councilmember Bubser, you and I have talked a lot about concerns about alcohol, partying, general kind of rowdiness. And I think with the concerns about kind of where we're at with the staffing of the police force,
22:26 And I think also some of the complaints, some of the concerns we've heard from folks who live up by Canyon Lodge is that like an event venue. And I just wanted to, you know, take the pulse of the council a little bit on approving hard liquor sales down there at the grocery outlet and see if that's anybody had any concerns on that. I have no concerns on it. I think it's completely different than what we're seeing at the bars.
22:53 I think that a lot of what's happening at the bars has a lot to do with people showing up with several different types of substances in their bodies creating different issues. How do I put this politely? But I think they're two completely different things. I think this is business. It's business-driven. I don't think what we do with our businesses will have any effect on the total alcohol consumption in town. Prohibition didn't work.
23:23 So other than, you know, trying to educate people not to do the wrong things and educate our businesses to have a better handle on when to cut people off, which is really the crux of it, this I have no issue with this moving forward at all. And I have no issue with moving forward, but my only concern was originally there's a value to a license.
23:46 And if you have too many licenses, other people who have a license will have a reduced value of their license. This type of license, which is just sales, is not nearly as expensive or as prevalent as a Type 47, which is the real valuable ones. So I didn't have any issue. Rite Aid's out of business. Whoever knows what's going to happen there, I don't think the total amount of sales in town is going to alleviate. We have other issues that I think are going to have to be addressed with some late-night activity. Chris, what are your feelings? I agree with...
24:17 Brent, although you do raise the question of if there's a cap on the number of licenses, then what happens when a new business comes into Rite Aid? Will they have to, I mean, that... They'd have to do this. I think they'd have to do the same thing and get approval. Unless Rite Aid still has their Type 20 license and they transfer it to a business. So, look, there's no other licenses because sometimes licenses are available. I can't find another license that is available right now.
24:47 Because that would be the ideal scenario versus adding. But right now we're down a significant retail store and we're not really adding an old store. We're just adding an item that they sell in that store. I don't think, to me, the total number of retail sales is not going to change that much. Okay. Thank you for that. And then, yes, I have, you know, many concerns, particularly after my ride-along last winter with the police department and there was a similar situation at the village the night that I was out on my ride-along.
25:17 It's no joke. We have to figure out a way to make sure that these late night things aren't putting our police force at risk because we all know there's just limited capacity and it's a dangerous situation. So I'm glad you brought it up, Councilmember Wentworth. In this situation, I think I feel okay about it, but I do, the broader question you're asking needs to be addressed. And I guess my feelings are that
25:43 You know, since it's a retail store that's open until 9 p.m., that I don't know that that would, denying this application, I don't know that that would, you know, prevent another occurrence from happening at the village. So I would be in support of this, but I also think that, you know, we have some other serious conversations to discuss, you know, what our...
26:08 How our nightlife scene is in town and, you know, keeping our employees safe. Yeah. Okay. Well, good. Well, thank you for that. I just wanted to bring that up. So with that, hang on a second. Hang on a second. I'm not in charge here. Madam Mayor, I'm prepared to make a motion unless you want to take any public comment. Shall we take public comment on this? Sure. Any public comment? Come on up to the podium, please. And can I ask you what your name is so I can put it in my name? Say that again?
26:37 I go by Billy, but it's William Edward Fix. All right. Thank you, Billy. Yeah. So the grocery outlets, we're at the third owner now since they came in town. And rumor has it it's up for sale. Anyone? Anyone hear that? I can't confirm that. I'm pretty sure they're in the process of selling. Okay. Just like the first one, just like the second one, just like the third one. So when you're talking about liquor license and how to protect,
27:09 Man in blue. You're trying to prevent things. It almost, I think you should put things on hold a little bit because the new owner's coming in. Call it a rumor if you want. But just like the first one, sold it, what, in less than a year? Second one, sold it less than a year. Third one, rumor has it. So there's going to be a fourth owner. Once again, rumor has it.
27:41 So however you're talking about liquor license right now, you're actually not talking about the current owner, you're talking about the future owner. Am I talking about the right subject, about grocery outlet? Yeah. Yeah, so we're not even talking about the current owner, we're talking about the next owner. And that's pretty much all I have to say, but when we're saying embrace what's going on right now, what's going on right now is in transit. Yeah, there's going to be a new owner.
28:10 And so whatever you're voting on for the current owner is hunky-dory. Yeah, go for it. But it's going to apply to the next owner. Thank you for your comments. Okay. We, as guests, we will find a way to get liquor. I mean, you know, we bring it from home, you bring it in your pocket. So whether you're selling it or not, I don't think you know whether more people are. But if you're asking about what could we do.
28:41 I mean, Robert has a great crew in the summertime, and I don't know if these shenanigans occur in the summer as much as the winter, but maybe it's worth calling the village and seeing if the village wants to provide some security on Friday and Saturday nights for when everybody comes down from Canyon Lodge, and that's, I have to say about that. Maybe they can, they,
29:12 Thank you. Are there any other public comments? Looks like we have one online, Jamie? Oh, yes. Is that the applicant? Okay. Hi. Hello. Good afternoon. I'm Steve. Can you guys hear me okay? Yes, we can hear you.
29:37 Terrific. Thank you. Hey, again, my name is Steve Rawlings. I am the representative for Grocery Outlet, and I wanted to just provide a little bit more information to you folks. First of all, I'd like to say we've appreciated our business there in Mammoth Lakes.
29:57 The opportunity to add a product line that includes distilled spirits is something that we try to do with most of our stores. In this particular situation, we're looking to add
30:12 Basically, just a couple of shelving units. Right now, we dedicate about 600 square feet toward the display of alcohol. If you've been in the store, when you walk in, it's immediately to the left. But you have to pass by all of the check stands. That is by design so that we can keep a careful eye on the product over there.
30:34 We're not expanding our area. We will just literally be removing some product from some existing shelves and placing it and then placing the distilled spirits there. I do like to point out to everybody, we don't carry like the airline size spirits. We carry only the 750 milliliter bottles. And as I mentioned, the inventory is not more than about two shelving units there.
31:03 Also, it is my understanding that this license is actually being transferred from the Rite Aid to our location.
31:12 So we're not actually adding any more licenses to the area there. And also I'd like to mention the one gentleman made a comment about the store being sold. The owner of this store is Grocery Outlet Corporation. They've owned it from the start. They operate though with a model that is called independent operators.
31:36 It's a little bit different than, say, like a franchisee model. It's people that are the operators of the store, and they do participate in the success of the store, much like an owner would, but they are actually an operator. And there are times from time to time that operators do change from stores. Sometimes it's because there's an opportunity at another grocery outlet in a different community.
32:03 And maybe they have family in that community and they decided they wanted to move to that particular community. You know, and other times there's other reasons why operators do change. But I can't comment on the current situation, but I do want to assure you that the ownership of that alcohol license belongs to grocery outlet stores. They usually are not adding distilled spirits on stores that they have plans to close anytime in the near future.
32:32 You know, with that, we certainly would appreciate the support on this, and I think we've proven as a responsible retailer of alcohol, and I don't see that this would be an issue from a public safety standpoint going forward. And I'm available for any additional questions that anybody may have. And thank you. Thank you. Are there any other public comments? Nope. Any deliberations here? Are we ready for... Oh.
33:02 Madam Mayor, if I can just address a couple things. I do appreciate, Dan Casabian, Chief of Police, I do appreciate Council speaking to some of the issues that we've had over the weekend at some of our local establishments, late night drinking and stuff like that.
33:20 This license isn't going to affect any of that as a grocery store shutting down at 9 o'clock. I have no concerns with that. But I do want to just thank you for your recognition of the issues that we have been having. Just one of the things that I think we can start with, a little bit off topic, but just bringing it to your attention and bringing it back to you at a later date.
33:43 Is creating a town ordinance for alcohol use outside of buildings and stuff like that. So we don't have individuals walking up the street with open containers and that type of thing. So we'll bring that back later. But I think that is probably something that we can move forward with or discuss that would solve a lot of the issues that we're having.
34:06 As people go from one establishment to another establishment and walking around with open containers. So we do not currently have a town ordinance for an open container law. Thank you. Is there anything else that you'd like to say? That'll be it. Okay, thank you. Are there any other comments? No? I would entertain a motion. So, Madam Mayor, I would move that the council approve the request for public convenience or necessity letter.
34:33 In support of Grocery Outlet's application for type 2-1 off-sale license, allowing the sale of packaged beer, wine, and distilled spirits at 37 Old Mammoth Road, and authorize the Community and Economic Development Director to sign the letter documenting this termination. I'll second. Roll call, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Salzer? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truax? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay, motion passes, and we are on to item 7, policy matters.
35:01 7.1. Receive a presentation on van life overnight parking efforts. Is this Nolan? Yes, it'll definitely be a group effort here amongst us all. And so tonight's item is really intended to be a discussion item to kind of daylight some of the efforts we've been making, some of the challenges with moving a program forward, and some of the possible pathways that we've identified that
35:33 Can both get us to kind of a temporary solution as well as what we're calling a near-term and then a long-term solution. So there's really three pathways that we've identified. Each have their own challenges with it and to implement. So a little on the background, the town's municipal code currently prohibits sleeping or camping in any vehicle or recreational vehicle on any public street, parking lot, town, right-of-way, public park, or rather public place.
36:04 This is outlined in Municipal Code Chapter 12.40. The zoning code does have a small carve-out for property owners who are currently, say, building new residence to use a RV as a temporary residence, provided there's an active building permit and there's some other limitations on that, but it's very specific to that use, so it's not, doesn't allow for the continued...
36:30 Use of an RV or other such use currently within the town. As we all know, due to housing challenges here related to cost, availability, a whole assortment of other issues, there's an increased number of residents that have transitioned to living in their vehicles. While at the same time, you know, I think we saw the really large influx during COVID and it hasn't seemed to slow down since the recreational van lifers.
36:58 Their numbers have increased dramatically as well. So these are those who are coming up to just go skiing or climbing or otherwise enjoy the area who don't want to pay for the RV park or camping, who have also then ended up in the same spots where those who have been displaced from housing are also currently trying to park overnight. So with those two uses,
37:22 The one who's living here full-time, trying to survive and work in the community versus those who are up here solely for a good time and to, you know, those uses potentially have conflicts between them. So, you know, noise, timing, and just how they interact in those spaces, which kind of creates issues for them cohabitating. So, really,
37:48 What we've identified is a need to identify areas where it's legal for overnight parking and be able to then identify who those are that are permitted to be in those spaces while also creating a program that allows potentially for addresses those who are here for recreational purposes, you know, is it create
38:10 You know, work with a ski area where they might build a park at some of their parking lots or at hotels or other sites where it becomes more of a TOT generator, but we also have identified where we can direct those uses to go. So over the last few years, I had to look back my notes, it appears since about mid-2023, we have been working with Mono County and other partners on the Sheriff's substation site as a potential for kind of a permanent van life overnight parking use.
38:39 Those conversations still are ongoing with the county. They've identified the process that needs to happen kind of on their side to move it forward. And then at a certain point, we'll step in and kind of work together with them to then take it to actually implement is where we're at currently with them. And again, since this is really a dialogue, feel free to...
39:04 Cut me off, ask questions, interject as we go along. Yeah, I just want to, so I appreciate that you're making this distinction between what you're referring to as recreational van lifers. Have you established another term for the folks who are living, working in town, so it's easy to make when you start proposing policy ideas and things like that, that there's, you don't have to do it now, but that will be helpful down the road to do that. Yeah, you know, we've, variety of terms, you know, when you look at.
39:30 Other cities who have done these, there's, you know, the unhoused, the vehicle dwellers, the working homeless. There's a lot of different terms that, you know, we lay back to it. Generally, when you're talking on these, a lot of times you hear a safe parking program, kind of the term that's used most often, but we'll definitely differentiate the terms. It would just be helpful for us as we go forward. And I agree with you, John. I've been trying to focus on this in terms of how that language is, because I think sometimes the current vernacular...
39:58 Jerry's a certain image. This is workforce housing we're talking about, and this is just a subset of workforce housing. Yeah. So we need to redefine it so it's not incorporated. Well, and also the issue when the county, when they're, they're, um, um, I'm sorry. Um, we get into issues of homelessness, state mandates around homelessness. We're, this is, this is not, there is a home, perhaps a homeless component to this, but we're talking about a unique set of challenges to this.
40:27 Destination or a place that I think having these terms established is going to be helpful to navigate all that. Well, and it's important to come up with a term because we keep calling it van life. And as someone who in my past professional life has dealt with people locked out of their van life vehicles and such or lost keys, I would say almost the majority are not van lifers as you think of them.
40:53 They're living out of Subaru Outbacks. They're living out of Broncos. They're living out of 40-year-old pickup trucks. This is the poor end of our working class who, for whatever reason, can't or won't spend money on rent. So van life and the images that I think that conjures up isn't what's going on. So we have to be careful about how we... Well, and I think staff can come up with a term that we're all comfortable with.
41:23 Yeah. We're going to take public comment at the end of the item. If you'd like to make comments, you just have to wait until the end. Yeah. Yeah. At the end. Yeah. Perfect. And I would just suggest that we consult with the local folks and ask them, you know, for input too. Great. So as I said, we've kind of identified three different pathways that we're working on. You know, I wouldn't say one has, you know,
41:50 No single solution is the perfect solution, and really all three of them can work in conjunction with each other, so meaning that all three could be implemented, and they each kind of address different sectors. So the first one, what we really call the long term, and this mainly because it's outside of the town's control. It requires working with the county on it to kind of secure their site.
42:21 Is the sheriff's substation sites. This is the one we have been working on in a number of years, have had a number of meetings with them. I think it really is an appropriate site for it. It's close to town. There won't be conflicts directly with neighbors who dislike the use or oppose the use or oppose seeing it. So I think it has a number of positives to the use. However, there are some challenges. It does have to go through CCOR review.
42:49 Seeker review and develop an entitlement. Likely that entitlement would be a master plan that really looks at the entire site. That site is two acres. So it could be more than just an overnight parking site. There could be, you know, overnight parking component. There could be a kind of rehabilitation of the existing substation there into, you know, is it transitional or supportive housing or a warming center, a variety of uses.
43:18 As well as, you know, the county may still want to use it for equipment storage and other uses. So it, right, say I put this in the long-term buckets really because they need to kind of determine what it is that they want to do with that site and how to move that forward and then complete the SQL review and the entitlements on that. At the bottom, I do have on each slide kind of some areas where we can anticipate cost. So for this site,
43:47 Obviously, the totality of the cost would be unknown, but it's likely that they would be shared amongst the operators, either, you know, in direct costs or doing the actions. So, for example, snow removal, trash, restrooms, improvements to the existing well there and structures. Obviously, costs are unknown since we don't have access to the site, but some of them, you know, would be easier than others. For example, snow removal, the county's already plowing the road next to it.
44:14 Fairly easy to just go through there to remove the snow. Nolan, quick question. So I don't have to pass them a little out of data, but it was Assembly Bill 130, Senate Bill 131 was describing an expedited CEQA process. Would that apply? Could this be called housing? I don't know the definitions within some of these, but that basically says some of the CEQA process can be either expedited or put to the side to help people with housing.
44:41 I'll really look to Andy on this one. So the Senate bill is the one that, you know, exempts uses. You do have to basically be on a site that's not
44:53 It has no potential environmental impacts what this site may have, some being close to a creek, being in a riparian zone, potentially in a very high fire zone. So there are some other factors that kind of remove that automatic sequit exemption. That kind of applies here town-wide to a majority of the sites here in the community, not just when looking at an overnight parking site. Yeah, and I only bring it up because sometimes sequit takes a very long time to get through, and we have a current need.
45:23 Depends on where we go with lots of different things. How do we get something to happen this year is where I was kind of appreciate, if as it being an option. Yeah, there are certain types of projects that are exempt under that bill. I'm not sure that this one is one of them, but as Nolan's about to explain, Pathway 1, the long-term solution, is only the first of three. We're also looking at some medium-term and short-term solutions that we think we can get done this year as requested. Okay. If I could just one.
45:51 Just a clarifying question. I mean, this has been going on for a long time. It seems to be a little extra long. And when we're talking long-term, are we talking like a decade to get this thing done by the county? Or we just don't know. It's so long-term that we're not even going to put a time frame on it. Yeah, we really don't know because it's completely subject to their process and how they move it forward. So it's probably something we're looking at short-term solutions that would just...
46:19 Let the county do whatever they're doing and just see what happens. Yeah, we've been engaged with them. I see Supervisor Kreitz in the audience. I don't know if she's here to speak to that or wants to weigh in on that, but really it's a subject to the county process, so we can't really dictate how long that might take. Okay, good. Thank you. I will say I'll just add just a little bit to that. So we have been working for a while. We did sort of separate some of the job duties with regard to getting this accomplished, and so one of the key areas are what
46:48 Nolan has identified up there the sequel review and the master planning efforts. And once that's done, then, you know, we sort of as a town committed to taking over from there and getting it to fruition, right? So we need them to go through the legal processes by which they're concerned about some of those elements and things that absolutely have to be addressed. And once they get through that, we will take it and run with it. I think that it's probably the heavier lift.
47:12 for the work that they're doing on the front end than it will be for us to get this to completion. So I think we have a good sort of separation on that. It was a town-county liaison meeting tomorrow afternoon. This was a topic of discussion for that, and we continue to discuss it. So county is definitely a partner in this. We just need to, it just takes time. Thank you. So pathway two that we've identified is really what we're calling the near term, only because we can control the outcome as far as
47:46 As moving forward and ensuring that the work continues on this. So this would be a pretty significant policy change within our zoning code looking at the potential to amend the municipal code to allow safe parking as a permitted use subject to a use permit. We would likely limit that to the commercial zone and then any residential site that's developed with a church provided it's an accessory use.
48:14 So this would allow for enhanced enforcement within the town on those who aren't within a permitted site. It would be scalable, meaning it's not set to say only a large parking lot could come forward to get a use permit. A business owner...
48:35 Who has some, you know, areas in the back that his, their staff might like to park in could come forward and get a use permit to allow two vehicles or three vehicles to park behind their, their building overnight or a larger site could come forward such as a church that has a large parking lot and so really it's scalable and that would all be looked at and reviewed through the use permit process. The nice thing with the use permit is it is, it requires, it becomes a public review process. It is a discretionary permit.
49:04 So conditions are imposed on the use to address issues with noise, hours, what the check-in process or how you access the site, kind of all the issues. It also creates then a process if there are issues to revisit that use permit or potentially even revoke that use permit should the issues become so large that they become a nuisance.
49:28 Similar to the county process, it will require the zoning code changes as well as the future use permits. We'll all require some level of sequel review. We're different from the county in that we're kind of a more urban use here. Most of these would be on existing uses that are already there, so the impacts would potentially be a lot less from an environmental perspective. We're not dealing with a riparian corridor directly adjacent to the site.
49:57 We're not dealing with a scenic being directly next to a scenic byway. So there is, from a secret standpoint, I think it's a little more straightforward on this. We'll require municipal code change. So that does require PEDC and Town Council approval of an ordinance. So the timing on that, you know, if we were to begin working on it immediately, and so that's part of, you know, tonight's goal is from Town Council to kind of
50:25 Receive direction on where, you know, we think we could go with this. Minimum would be six months to complete to implement those code changes and then it would require those property owners to come forward with to get a use permit to then allow the use on there. Again, at the bottom we have kind of cost outlined that, you know, could be incurred.
50:50 And really, I think the cost that we would be incurring on sites within the town would be more to incentivize a property owner to do this use so that, you know, is the town willing to step in and share in snow removal costs or cover the cost of trash or restrooms on a privately controlled site is really the question because that, you know, I don't have too many property owners who will just step up and say, hey, I want to give my site to everyone in the community who's unhoused to park here unless the town's willing.
51:18 Kind of share in those expenses and really incentivize it. Oh, yeah. Go ahead. So just so I'm clear, a couple different things. That six-month, well, any code change is going to require a full public hearing with diagnosis, all the normal. So six-month is probably a pretty confined time frame of actually getting that done for the use permit. So are you saying that any business, hypothetically, any business that's operating would have to?
51:47 Do a use permit for the two spots separately? Potentially, yes. It could also be done through an administrative permit, which is, you know, could be called a minor use permit. Really, the distinction there is those were approved administratively. We still can put conditions on there. However, it doesn't require going to the PEDC if that was the direction to say approve these through and make them subject to an administrative permit.
52:12 I don't think we want to make them just permitted outright because then that alleviates the ability to impose conditions on the uses. Yeah, and I was just trying to see where you were thinking because if someone already had an existing conditional use permit, it would amend it or it's a kind of... Yeah, I didn't amend it because it's a different, it would be a use specific for that safe parking use on the site. Are there businesses that currently allow people to park overnight on their property? Without pointing anyone, we know it's happening.
52:41 Okay. And that is against the Municipal Code or since it's on private property? It's currently against the Municipal Code. I can't speak to if it's being, you know, strictly enforced or not, but we do know it's happening, various businesses throughout the community. Okay. Thank you. So, Nolan, this is on commercial properties. Have we thought about doing the same for private properties, for private property owners that have the available parking, wanted to allow someone on there?
53:11 So I think, you know, just a don't tell don't. Yeah, I think it's one where, you know, it is a fairly significant policy change. And so I don't know that we want to just say, you know, any property within any zone can come forward with a use permit. I think it's something that you definitely want to kind of tiptoe into. And, you know, that's why I think it makes sense. There's a lot of examples of cities who have done this. They, you know, a lot in their commercial zones.
53:39 Then often churches sometimes do end up in a residential zone, so they have extended it to church sites, provided it's an accessory use to that, that more permanent use. I don't know that we want to just say open it up throughout all residential zones, because then it's, you know, is every driveway going to become, you know, where someone's parking and sleeping, and what does that do? I think it, some of you know where if we roll it out and there's no issues and the council wants to expand it.
54:08 We can look at that, but I think it's one that you want to kind of implement fairly slowly and controlled. And just to clarify, so right now, you know, someone can't park in someone else's driveway and live in their car? That's correct. Okay. They could park there, but they can't sleep in the car? Is that? That's correct. Okay. Thank you. Just another quick question. So the CEQA, is this a programmatic CEQA? Is it per site?
54:33 Is it townwide? Do you anticipate like a neg deck coming out of this? The use permit would look at it on a site by site. I said with majority of the sites there would be already existing uses. And so it could be looked at as a categorical exemption under the existing use exemption for the use permit to allow such a use to continue.
54:59 Okay, so that we're not dealing with new disturbed areas. I think we're talking about using existing infrastructure. So the secret process would hopefully be pretty straightforward, I would think. Correct. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. And just to come back to that a little bit. So you'd really be looking at like individual zoning zones where it would be allowed at this point in time and feather it out if it worked.
55:20 Correct. So the kind of comprehensive zone change would be looking at, you know, allowing this as a use subject to either an administrative permit or a use permit in the specific zone. So within the commercial use table, there would be a line item for safe parking. Next to it would say use permit. Then there'd be a relevant code section addressing kind of all the requirements for that use permit or administrative permit that then would be a separate entitlement for that.
55:54 All right, so then the pathway three, which we've kind of identified as the immediate solution, meaning it's the one we feel we can stand up the quickest, but it's also very limited in timing under the code, would be to allow overnight parking as a temporary use as an emergency facility to address a public safety issue. So this temporary use is under chapter 17.56 of the zoning code.
56:21 It does limit those uses to 90 calendar days within any single year. So if we were to stand this up, you know, as soon as, say, the next town council meeting or the first meeting in March, it could then operate for a period of 90 days, which would really carry us through majority of the winter, which is generally, you know, where we see the most impacts. Also talking with
56:50 Some of the folks who are in this community, you know, they've expressed that the winter is the biggest need because once the forest service roads and other sites do open up, they do become more dispersed. Long-term, obviously, we'd like to address for the permanent solution, but we feel that most kind of urgent need is during the winter months when the impacts most, those spots do become unaccessible with snow and others. So again, this would limit the use to 90 days.
57:18 It would allow, under the temporary use chapter, allow staff to regulate hours, nuisances, screening, waste. So through the kind of operations plan with a private property owner, we could put appropriate restrictions and requirements. What we've discussed would be that the vehicle dwellers would be issued a placard to identify that their vehicle is a registered vehicle.
57:43 Again, this would allow then the PD to enforce those who are not registered to either issue a fine or otherwise remove them from the site. It does require a property owner to offer up their site. We have been talking with various private property owners in the community.
58:02 About, you know, if there's interest in there, there has been some interest expressed, so we are continuing to work through that to see if we can't secure, secure an agreement. More to come on that. Timing, this can be executed relatively, relatively quickly. Again, on the cost side, we feel there is likely going to be a need to incentivize such a use, so whether the towns...
58:29 Partnering or sharing the expenses of snow removal, trash, restrooms. There's potential or discussion of, you know, security cameras and other costs. So the bottom line is none of these solutions are free. None of them are easy. They all have various issues with them. But we think they're all, at least there is a path forward to, you know, implement an immediate solution as well as
58:57 Can potentially create at least long-term opportunities to address the issue. Several questions. Starting with, so for emergency order, we have to have findings. If we were to try to have something ready by the next meeting, would that take an act of the council to actually officially do it? Or is the town manager authorized to do that if we were trying to move along quicker?
59:19 So it's a little, you know, the zoning code for temporary use does not necessarily require town council action. However, tying it back to the emergency use and I think really just the visibility of the issue, we would bring it back as a policy item to adopt a resolution, making those findings and then implementing that temporary use. Would that, is there any...
59:43 Delay timeframes. Let's just say that it comes back to council. We do a resolution. Could that be enacted at that time? Or is there any wait time or any other timeframes that we'd have to be aware of? There's not a timeline associated with implementing the resolution or that temporary use that any delay would really be that is the private property owner ready to commence operations and is there a plan in place? So that goes to my second question. Why does it have to be on private property? Because we can change ordinances. I mean, if we...
1:00:13 For emergency action, we have the authority to do quite broad activities, and it could be a different location other than private property, even though private property might be a more preferential location if that becomes available, but what if it doesn't become available to our point? Because I read through all of our codes and ordinances that we have in the town, and we have flexibility in certain things under emergency ordinances, but also trying to find the right solution that makes it work for everybody. I think that our thought has been that
1:00:43 A facility like this to be run well needs some degree of oversight, some degree of supervision. At the moment, I don't know whether the town has the capability of doing that on a publicly owned site. And I don't know that we've asked any of our partners in the fire district, the water district, whether they're interested. So we had thought, I think, that a site like a church, which might be willing to offer some kind of oversight, some supervision.
1:01:10 Maybe access to restrooms, that that might be a good starting point. I agree with that, but just we as a council could choose that we want to do it on town property and we recognize our risk and other things that involve. Ideally, having a private operator has advantages. And that goes to my third set of questions, which is if somebody, let's just say we have somebody's private property and we have certain restrictions that we're recommending, do they have to follow those? Can they have their own restrictions? So...
1:01:39 You know, let's just say somebody has a large lot, they're willing to provide location that helps us greatly fulfill a need, but then they say, well, you can't park here on Tuesdays, you can't, you know, just, would they have ability to add to restrictions above and beyond anything that we would offer? Yes, so a town-issued permit would set kind of the baseline operating parameters. If the private property owner wanted to impose further restrictions, they could.
1:02:07 They couldn't relax the restrictions that would be in this permit issued by the town. But if they wanted to do more than that, I mean, ultimately, it's their property. And we cannot obligate anyone to operate any kind of facility like this. So whatever restrictions they're comfortable with that might be above and beyond what the town requires, they could do. Because where I approach this from is I look at this as workforce housing. And let's just say somebody comes up from another location that is not workforce housing and they were to pull into this.
1:02:36 I'll just add just one thing to that since that
1:03:09 It was a little bit in the weeds, and we are working through the parameters of the program, right? So when Andy talked about the limitations that the town would use for the permit that we provide for the right to do that, we could spell out some key aspects in there that make it workforce, make it local, you know, sort of control a little bit of that freedom to make it whatever you want it to be.
1:03:34 And I think, you know, if there's any needs to get any tighter based on a particular unit or, I'm sorry, location in which someone's offering this, then they could add those pieces to it. But we would really want to provide an entire outline for the intended program that is probably a tie to the part of the permit issued by the town. I think it also comes down to, you know, when you talk a public site versus a private site.
1:04:00 The ability to kind of impose trespassing on people versus not, where you've created a system where you've issued on a private site, issued a permit, you've determined who can be overnight on that site, and as private property, you can also define who cannot be on that site. So if it is someone, you know, a recreational van lifer who tries to access it, they, you know, the property owner could contact the PD to say, hey, this person is not permitted to be here, we're on a public site.
1:04:27 It becomes a little bit more of a challenge. Like if we were to, say, clear the dog park parking lot of snow during winter, currently it's not cleared, and say, okay, everyone who has a permit, great, you can park here overnight. But then it becomes really challenging when the dog walker shows up at 6 a.m. to, you know, even though the dog park's not technically open.
1:04:47 They're still going to show up to try to access the park, and then you start creating conflicts on that. But it hasn't been open all winter, so no one should have that expectation. We're repurposing it for a winter use. I mean. I'll let Hayes speak to kind of what they've seen. I mean, I know the lock's been cut before. People have jumped the fence. It doesn't stop people from trying to use the park. Yeah. Nolan's spot on. If we open up that parking lot, people will use that site, regardless if there's a lock on it.
1:05:13 Or it says it's not open to the public. We dealt with this in the very first season we had it open. If that law is clear, people will use the site. That's frustrating because that means that people's bad behavior is stopping us from helping community members who need it. And that really, really bothers me. I mean, there's nothing we can do. Well, I mean, you're saying using the dog park. So what?
1:05:40 What they're saying is we could use the dog park lot and we could clear it because it's our lot and we're the town and we have the plows and we could, but that then people go in the dog park illegally in the winter when it's closed. I mean, we also have the CRC parking lot, which is much bigger than the dog park parking lot. Well, but that's being actively used.
1:05:59 Great location, the dog park, because right now it's just covered in snow. So, but the point is that the public is breaking into the dog park when it's closed in the winter. That's really bothersome to me. Can't we enforce? It's our, like, right to say the dog park's closed in the winter. You can't go in there. Can, you know, I mean. So, Mayor Boebser, I mean, I'm sorry. Former Mayor Boebser, I can say.
1:06:24 Nolan's point was more along the lines of publicly owned land has sort of different abilities to remove individuals that aren't supposed to be there versus a private. So the trespassing component is much more difficult for us to achieve, if at all. That was kind of the point of that, right? That is a public space in regards to that. I think if we wanted to get very, very heavy-handed about
1:06:49 You know, closed utilization of the dog park. That could certainly be an enforcement aspect that we would do. I just don't think it's been something that we've decided was necessary at this point. I just, I guess what you're hearing is me feeling like, you know, now we're going on, we've heard about this problem for a month and I just
1:07:10 Feel that there's a sense of urgency that we need because we're going to lose community members, valued community members who are going to leave the area. And so I understand and I'm grateful that you've brought back these options to us quickly. But like one of the things, for example, is I don't understand why if we're using an emergency ordinance, and I think Councilmember Truax was alluding to this too, why we have to have a council vote.
1:07:35 It's like we have the authority to make these decisions and move forward, and I just hope that we are going to do it as quickly as possible, because right now it's not snowing, but the next time it snows, we're going to have the same problems. So that's all. Sorry, jumping in. Please. On the same portion. We're February. We're halfway through winter, and we haven't done anything. I'm frustrated. I'm frustrated because this is part of our workforce for the town, and we have failed to.
1:08:05 Adequately provide a safe location for individuals who are residing and trying to work within this community. And I think it's our obligation to do something for them as well as quicker. But it's not as easy as just opening up the dog park parking lot. I wish it was. Again, I have worked, you know, in the midst. I've seen the trash along the sides of several dirt roads. The human...
1:08:32 Feces and everything else that is left out there as well. So if you open a parking lot, now you're talking about having to gear up with more employees. And believe me, I've been looking for a solution for this for years. When Dan was still here and we first bought the parcel, I said, can't we just take whatever section is going to be used last and open it up as a... But the complexity, I mean, it seems so easy, but the complexity that's there, hiring somebody, and you'd have to have somebody to go and inspect it on a daily basis.
1:09:00 to have enforcement of some type so that we only have the van, and I've got to stop calling them van lifers, the car livers, if you will, that truly should qualify to be there and not the weekend warriors who are coming up and want a cheap place to stay. I will also say that in their responses, and I probably shouldn't, all the places they're talking about being poached by those coming up from out of town that don't work here are all illegal campsites.
1:09:29 In the first place. So it is something that we really have to deal with in the long run. It is just every time I try to get my head around everything that's required, it's really a much more complex issue than it seems. So I just want to address one thing you said, Bill, because you're making an assumption that the littering and, you know, things that are left behind
1:09:53 Are the local people who are trying to live and work here? And I think that's unfair because I would imagine that it's much more the visitor population. That's just, that's me making an assumption, but let's try it and see. Because I tend to believe that the people who want to live and work here would take great pride in making sure that they're keeping it clean. Well, hold on. Do you have more slides after this? No. Okay.
1:10:23 I mean, because I think that this is an important topic for all of us, and I think that we all, you know, want to act on this, but I do think that we need to make sure that we're asking the right questions to hopefully potentially avoid issues that are avoidable, you know, so I guess listening to you all chat, you know, one
1:10:48 The space that pops to my mind is like the parking lot behind the pickleball courts because there is the winterized bathroom at the pickleball courts. You know, that's already a bathroom that is winterized and, you know, if we could make that available to people, you know, I guess I would be more inclined to, you know, if people
1:11:11 If there were signs that said, you know, permit parking only, I don't understand why we couldn't just, you know, have the police go and ticket people who are parking overnight without a permit. Can I offer a little twist on this? Yeah. You brought up the possibility of a privately owned parcel. What I'm hearing is we have a need. It would be great to have it on a privately owned parcel first, but the question mark, if that doesn't happen, what next? I would be kind of pushed along the lines of,
1:11:42 All right, can we get the private parcel available and can we make this happen in a very reasonable time? If not, I would like to see what's the other options for other locations. I can think of three different options that we have as current town property that would be available. The political law courts may have, that's maybe a sub-issue because that's kind of education. I don't know, someone may have to do a legal analysis on some of these, but I would love to see if the first private properties don't work.
1:12:10 Other options, how we can make that happen. I would come back to where Councilmember Bubser has said in terms of do we actually need a resolution? I'm trying to move this in a thoughtful manner, but we've been talking about this a long time. And it's time for us to do something, not just keep pushing. And I got it, we may make mistakes. I'm okay making a mistake if it's for the betterment of the people here. Well, and I think that...
1:12:34 Like, this is our time for questions, and then we should take public comment, and then we should... But my question is, if we go down that road, is that a reasonable portion? Because I'm a little concerned when we go down and talk about the substation. We've also been talking about that for a period of time. That could be very long. I think we've got to look at all options. But we've got to address the immediate needs, which is wintertime and the next snowstorm and activities coming. And the question would be is...
1:13:02 Also, do we look at option two as I start that process or not? I'm kind of judging in my head. Are we looking for those types of options? Because as a recommendation, are we saying that one, two, and three should all be pursued? I think the staff thought has not been to pick one of these to the exclusion of the others. It's we'll do any of them or all of them, whatever you'd like us to do. Picking one or two of them does not exclude the others. We can do whatever you want us to do.
1:13:28 Yeah, and I was waiting for you guys to finish before I dove into a lot of these comments, honestly. So I'd like to go ahead. There's some hands raised up there, and we'll finish that up. Chris, let's hear from Chris. Could we go back to option two just for a moment? I was trying to remember what that is. So would that be able to be completed? You said it was six months. So I'm most focused on option three because I'm most focused on the immediate need. But I'm also curious.
1:13:57 Will option two get us a solution by next winter so we aren't doing this again? Yeah, I think six months would likely be really the fastest it could be done, but I do feel confident that a plan, the code changes would be fully completed before next winter. Thank you. Are there more questions? Yeah. So one of the things we have not talked about is liability issues to go along with all of this, and I'm sure there are plenty.
1:14:23 And I'm sure we have some sister cities and such who have tried such things. I would love to hear is what they have found on the ground versus speculatively, the types of lawsuits filed, the types of injuries, the types of liability issues that we have to deal with on this. Because that's just another part of this. As I said, to me, this is just not simple. I wish it was. I move, you know, four people onto my lot tomorrow.
1:14:51 You cannot do that. The liability to me as a homeowner is... So I'm glad you brought that up, Bill. Honestly, I will tell you that to say that nothing has happened is not accurate. We've been working hundreds of hours on this particular problem. This is not as simple as people would like to think it is with regard to making a decision to just have people park wherever and do this. As a municipality...
1:15:16 We are required to follow a certain set of rules that are not necessarily the same set of rules for a private entity. That is why the staff has brought forward that recommendation. Second to that, there's a lot of liability associated with this. When you call something a safe parking area, living in your vehicle at 8,000 feet in a snowstorm, especially if it's not a large vehicle, is not a safe thing to do. The potential for someone to die in a safe parking zone provided by the town is great.
1:15:46 The liability on that is extra for us if we've provided that as a component of it. Andy has provided a few, done some analysis on what other entities have done, other municipalities have done, and is really ready, I think, to talk a little bit about that tonight as well. I will say that every one of these options is what we have moving forward. I told you earlier in the conversation that option one, which is a long-term solution with the county, I will be driving that point home again tomorrow.
1:16:15 In our liaison meetings with the county. I think we need to move forward on this. There are some specific timings required for municipal code changes that require first, second readings and 30 days for implementation that allow for those additional times to take that take place with that. I'm assuming there's also alternate meetings that have to happen with our CED folks. But then the final solution, the third solution that we're working on, you know, we've been talking to people. We think we are very close on that.
1:16:44 I hear you loud and clear with regard to alternate sites. We can certainly pursue something that goes on perhaps even out at the airport, right? I have the personal authority as town manager to make a decision on utilization of the parking lot at the airport, right? That could be something along those lines. So we hear you loud and clear. We have to pay attention to the details. That is what lives at this desk. And so these are the things that we're kind of moving forward with on that. The resolution
1:17:12 That we made the recommendation for is because council's action in policy making and decisions that change this is what we're looking for as staff to have that in writing. And that's what the resolution provides us for. It outlines the details by which this process is going to work and it has the stamp of approval from the town council. So that's where the resolution had sort of a meaningful impact for the town.
1:17:38 So, you know, aside from that, I think there's maybe opportunities for us to move forward, you know, very quickly with regard to that, and I'll look for Andy on some of those legal details, but I will say we're hopefully very close on a private partnership that will work in this space. Another question, Chris? So, in the past, we've had special meetings when there were extraordinary circumstances. Is it possible that if that were to come forward rather than have to wait two more weeks? Thank you. We could do that. We could do an emergency meeting quickly.
1:18:07 Well, we could make some findings, perhaps. Do we have more questions about the presentation, or can I take public comment? I think Andy has some things to add. I can discuss some liability issues, if you like. So we've looked at at least four programs from other jurisdictions. Union City, Fremont, City of San Luis Obispo, County of San Luis Obispo, and also Alameda County. And it turns out that safe parking does sometimes spawn litigation.
1:18:34 So there was a federal case in Monterey County where a woman who had exceeded the amount of time that the county was willing to let people stay. She sued, claiming that she had a right to stay there indefinitely, that she had tenant rights. The county won that one, but, you know, they still got sued. The San Luis Obispo, county of San Luis Obispo, I think, program, they had a facility that was
1:18:59 It was kind of thrown together, maybe not really thinking through all the issues. It had two deaths within the first eight months, one overdose and one RV fire. Then there was a big grand jury report about that one. There was subsequently some litigation. When they tried to close that site because it just wasn't working, they got sued from people who said that they had a right, that the county or the city was obligated to continue operating it. The county of San Diego got sued.
1:19:29 There were some people claiming that they had an obligation to continue providing safe parking and to expand their program. They ultimately had to settle and agree to provide more parking. So, I mean, I will say that everything that the town does or any government does, does have the potential for liability. And it's not a reason for us not to do things, but it is a reason that we try to do things carefully in a thoughtful way. And this issue, when I was thinking through it, I mean, I just jotted down a list of what turned into about...
1:19:58 15 issues that I shared with the staff about, oh, we need to think some things through. And that wasn't an exhaustive list. That was just what came to me in looking at this for a little bit. So we're not saying don't do it. We're not saying that it's impossible. We're not saying that we're going to get sued.
1:20:14 I'm just saying that there are some complexities to this. It is not as simple as people might like it to be, as Rob said. So we're trying to be intentional. We're trying to be thoughtful. And we think that there are some things we can do quickly. And that's fine. And the things that are going to take a little bit longer are going to take longer because we need to think some things through and because there are some procedural requirements. Another question? So there is one scenario that because some of those safe parking situations
1:20:43 I don't think they require the people to leave in the morning. Maybe they do, maybe they don't. But what we're contemplating is a certain time in the evening until a certain time in the morning, and then everyone has to leave that parking lot. What if someone refuses to leave? Well, depending on whether it was public property or private property, if it was public property, we could issue them a citation and ultimately, I suppose, we could trespass them.
1:21:08 And a private property owner could do the same thing. You're not allowed to be here, and they could summon the police and say, can you please have this person removed because they're trespassing. Obviously, we don't want to get to that, but there are some options available if it comes to it. Thank you. Are there any other questions? Let's take public comment. Anyone in the room like to comment on this? Come on up to the podium. Ilana, let's hear from you.
1:21:37 Well, I have a question. Like, with your path three, with a placard, are you suggesting, like, if I was one of these campers, that we go to a certain place and get a placard so we can park in a particular lot? Was I correct in hearing that? Go ahead. So, yeah, likely, you know, that all the details are to be determined. If it's a town partnership, it'd be something you'd come to the town, likely sign a liability waiver, sign, you understand the rules.
1:22:06 I just wanted to, because I was a little concerned with your use of words of a registered vehicle. I mean, if our vehicle's not registered, then obviously we're subject to a ticket. So you mean registered with your program. That's correct. And I know a lot of my homies that work on the mountain that make it possible for me to ski every day, whether it's their van or their little car or whatever they have to live in.
1:22:34 Because they can't afford to live in employee housing where there isn't any yada yada. We all know that. Have we as a town or whatever gone to the mountain and said, hey, you know, you've got all these employees. Maybe we could use one of your lots. You know, the employees could have a platform to use their lots so they can get to work safe. I mean, I've got...
1:23:02 The privilege of living at the Main Lodge in 1989 at the Ober. And my how convenient was that to go right to work every morning and not drive anywhere and no matter how buried our cars cost. Now I understand about snow and all that, but I feel like our mountain could do more to help its own people.
1:23:26 I mean, if they, I, like, I was thinking about it as you guys were talking. Yes, they have nice dirt locked behind the hotels and all that and the noise. Well, maybe if we were off in the dark dirt, we wouldn't make as much noise and there's a bathroom you could walk down to and maybe shower off. I don't know if there's still a shower down there like there was when I worked at the inn way back when, but at least have a bathroom at home.
1:23:54 Some of that stuff. And then if there's living room, the Mammoth can be like, what are you guys doing? Where do you need a place to stay? And the Mammoth could police that a little more. I mean, I'd suggest that I think they should offer employee dinners. They don't want a two-hour line for traffic. We can't have night skiing to break up traffic lines and stuff like that. It would just be doing, I know Dave.
1:24:22 Would never wanted his employees to not be affordably split and have to fill what they go through. So that was just another question. Has the town gone and asked if the mountains willing to help their employees like that in any way? I was curious, is the community center, is that lot not open anymore? I mean, I've seen people park there.
1:24:52 What? There are frequently people parked in the community center lot. I don't mean overnight, but just in general, because the last couple of times during the day, we haven't been able to park there. I don't know specifically, but I know. Well, it's been closed off to parking. Okay. And the issue I have is there's two disabled parking spots at the village. Thanks to, I mean, Sergeant Better.
1:25:21 We just got a second one. During the holiday, during the big snowstorm, there was some sort of vehicle park there for a couple days, and they didn't get towed, and as a result, we had no safe crosswalk. There's only one crosswalk on Highway 203 where you push the button. On the other side, the uphill side, there's a one-foot snowbank to get off the curb at the proper curb cut.
1:25:51 So, like, when the other parking, when that's, when the one spot was taken, us disabled people tried to go over to the community center. So, that's one of my, you know, another parking concern. And thanks to Sergeant Vedder calling whoever he called with the town, thank you guys, whoever it was, that had that one spot melted out because up until Monday, there was
1:26:21 An ice bank on it that if you weren't disabled parking in there you could have been after trying to get out of the car. And I think that's all I have to say. Oh, so at the substation too, would that just be for locals or is that some place that you were thinking for everybody? Do you mind finishing up, is that your last comment? Yeah, that was my last question. Yeah, that's with the county, that's for...
1:26:51 Our car living individuals. Our car, not, it's, it would be geared towards our workforce who's car living. Yeah. Cool. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Are there any other public comments? Come on up, Billy. Bernie. I can give some contrast. Chris, you made a great point. I've, on and off of the near 20 years I've been here, I've lived in the woods.
1:27:21 Let's say collectively close to three years. And I've never let a single piece of trash behind. I show up late, leave early, and I'm a local. I consider myself a local. And so your point, what you said, was people who live here, they're not riffraff. They don't just, you know, I live here and I don't care where I, part of my language, you know.
1:27:47 But there's a gentleman officer here, who I believe runs a crew who has excellent instincts. And so for all this litigation and making everything right, like we got code, code, code everything, that takes away from the officer. This officer knows who comes to town. He knows who's, you know, if they have a shaggy van, just because they have a shaggy van doesn't mean they're polluters.
1:28:14 It doesn't mean they're going to make, you know, make Mammoth a blight on society. That's in the hands of the gentleman in blue. And they see us coming. Not us, but because I'm a non-polluter. And Bill, you made an excellent point. I wish I could remember. But, um... So do I. But, um, but yeah, there's, it's, um...
1:28:43 All this litigation, we're taken away from the instincts of the men in blue. All these words that we're using, we're saying, this man, he's, you know, he's got his hands tied. You know, the people he trains are not very well trained. You know, he knows what's going on. Casparian, that's a compliment, by the way. Yeah, yeah, and so it's like, hey, let's litigate our way through this.
1:29:10 Let's put code on top of code. When this gentleman, there's only one way in and one way out other than the earthquake. And so you can't really come into Mammoth and be, you know, stealth. You know, the cops don't see me. And so let's give the man in blue a little bit of credit. They see everyone coming in on 203 and everyone coming out. And so all this litigation, these gentlemen doing this, all this, what do you call these?
1:29:40 Thank you, thank you. It's like, did any of these guys ever say, I think the men in blue, actually, hopefully you're well funded and whatnot, but I'll promote your extra funding, how about that, to make sure when they train someone, there's only two, this isn't like a big city, there's only two, one way in, you really can't consider the earthquake zone.
1:30:08 And as a matter of fact, free living, no one mentioned the earthquake zone. No one mentioned, is that a highway or anything? I just call it the earthquake zone. People live out there all the time anyway. And so, and there's all kinds of offshoots. And so what are you going to do without that? How are you going to litigate that? And there's this gentleman right here. Boo! He has no problem saying, hey, oh, you're local, you're cool. Oh, you're not leaving trash behind? You're cool.
1:30:39 And then there's the other dirty bags, dirt bags, who clearly behave terribly. And so why not put that in the hand of the men in blue instead of litigating everything? That's all I have to say. Put it in the hands of the cops, man. Thank you for your comments. Hello, Tom. Mayor Rice, Council, Tom Cage. I'm a business owner on Main Street and a property owner on Main Street.
1:31:09 I apologize. I'm going to bring up two things that weren't on the parking overview, and that is the Main Street two-hour parking. This is the van life. Do you want to wait for the parking conversation? Well, that's my question to you. Do you want to hear it now, or do you want to? Because it wasn't clear if it was going to be discussed the overview of all parking, or it looked like it was just van life.
1:31:37 Well, there's two. So we have 7.1 is receive a presentation on van life overnight parking efforts, and then 7.2, consider changes to town parking policies. Ah, okay. So wait until 7.2? If you wouldn't mind. I wouldn't mind. Okay. Thank you. Do you have any comments on this item? Tom, can I have a question on van life parking? No, it's a tough job. No, but can I ask you a question on that? Oh, of course. As a business owner? Yes. If you had the availability of two parking spots for people to live.
1:32:06 And reside in your parking lot. Would you take advantage of that? I have two employees that are van lifers. I allow them to park there when either the roads are really bad or if they have imbibed a little bit too much and it's worked out. They're employees. They respect it. They are gone in the morning before snow plows get there. So I kind of have that going on now, not daily.
1:32:35 But it does occur. My problem would be with it not being somebody that's respectful of it and recourse and what, you know. So I reserve that for my two staff members that live in their vans. So I don't know whether that helps or hurts. You happen to be a prominent businessman here, so I thought it would be a good point. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And based on what I'm hearing, it seems like that might even be illegal.
1:33:01 for me to have them park there overnight. It is. But, you know, Andy and I could go into a long conversation about private property use and, you know, and we don't want to do that. But they park there when there's an absolute need. Thank you. Are there any other public comments from the room? Come on down. Hi, my name is Luis Medina. I'm with the Mammoth Times and the Indian Register. And I don't have a comment. I just have a couple of questions for staff. In the research that you've done with these other
1:33:32 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:34:01 I can't speak for the family-related research on that, but I can talk a little bit about paraphernalia or pamphlets and things that are provided to help that. So obviously Health and Human Services is a Mono County function, and I understand that there's a lot of materials at the library where a lot of people do spend time, and there seems to be an entire section that can help get
1:34:29 Someone who's currently experiencing homelessness back to a place where they can have a home in town. And so I think there's a lot of materials at the library that support that. We talked a little bit about the community itself. I will tell you that we had the wonderful people that came in to the public comment at the last meeting, and the town staff did meet with one of those members, spent some time talking about the details and getting from a...
1:34:58 Thank you. Thank you.
1:35:27 That is left behind is usually left behind by the recreational side of the envelope versus the people who are there living. What I come to understand is a lot of the people who are, I'll say, a workforce living in their vans are actually cleaning up after people that are here because they do not want to draw attention to the fact that those things occurred from someone living in their car. And so they're actually cleaning up after others just to make sure they don't get on the wrong side of that opinion.
1:35:57 So I just wanted to kind of draw that. That came up a number of times tonight, and I think they're really doing the very best they can to make sure they don't rock the boat, honestly, with regard to that. So I really appreciate that level of effort, and I just want to call that out, that I recognize that they're probably not the sources of that, and they're actually part of the solution for that. Could I just address one part of Mr. Rodina's question?
1:36:21 In the past two weeks, I've been doing a lot of research, talking to Supervisor Salcido, talking to folks from the county, really trying, folks from Eastern Sierra Community Housing, trying to understand, like, the situation for us with our unhoused population. And I think that Rob makes a really good point, that that is a county function. All of the funding and all of the work, when the town and county separated, the funding stream went there.
1:36:51 And I've also talked to Amanda Greenberg. So I think it's important for us all to learn and understand. And the point in time count for unhoused people was just last week. So that report will come out soon. And I think that's when we'll get more insights into families specifically. Because my understanding is that that's not very prevalent in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I think it is in the area. But that's a way for us to.
1:37:19 Get more information on that because I know we've all been asking the question as well. So thank you. Are there any public comments online? Okay. Oh, we have one more in the room. Tom, come on down. Good evening, Madam Mayor and Councilmembers. Tom Hodges, VP of Planning and Development at Mammoth Mountain. Just a few comments on the subject. You know, I just want you guys to know we're actively engaged in this particular issue. We have been participating as an active participant with the
1:37:49 Town staff and county on the sheriff's substation site. And in fact, we were, you know, willing partners and potential could be potential managers of that site as a part of our staff accommodations operation. So just know that we do recognize the need and are willing to participate in it. You know, and I would say that, you know, as an employer and having, you know, we have active
1:38:19 Vehicle residents in our workforce, and we do actively engage with them and try to address their needs when needed. And on occasion during, you know, big storm events and so forth, we will make accommodations for them on our facility so that we know they have a safe place to stay. But we don't accommodate it on a regular basis just because of a lot of operational conflicts, right? We're out there with snow removal equipment and overnight and trying to maintain.
1:38:48 Clearing the parking lots and so forth. There's, you know, obviously safety concerns if we have people parked and so forth randomly across our properties. So there is problems with that. I know in many years ago, before my tenure, and I've been at the mountain almost 30 years now, there was the, they did allow people to park, like, for example, I think in the Chair 2 parking lot at one point in time, guest overnight.
1:39:13 To Andy's point, you know, about the liabilities and so forth that, you know, when there are storm events and so forth, it is very dangerous because vehicles can literally get buried to a point where then they're running their, you know, car to heat their car overnight and literally can die from carbon monoxide poisoning because it gets trapped around the vehicle. So those are real, I think there's actually been incidents of that in the past in the community and I know that's why.
1:39:43 There is Mammoth RV Park that is available for our visiting guests as a place to camp and spend, you know, overnight for visiting guests, right? So that's out there. I would say as an employer, you know, we do provide subsidized housing for our employees that's affordable to our employees at all income ranges. So we have vacancies currently, so you know. I mean, at this point, there's available beds. And so we certainly encourage our employees to stay in our employee housing.
1:40:13 It's a much safer alternative. And then finally, I just would mention that, you know, the ongoing effort of the development of the parcel in town that you guys are leading. You know, there's a new phase under development that will be being delivered soon. That is a, you know, serving income ranges all the way down to extremely low income ranges in our community. And, you know, I certainly would encourage people to consider those alternatives, you know, if they're in fact,
1:40:43 You know, their income will qualify them for different levels of availability. And those are brand new, fantastic apartments and have actually covered parking in many cases. I know some will be also surface parking, but that'll be an opportunity for, I know, even in the first phase of development, there was some trouble filling some of those lower income level units. So, you know, that product's out there. It will be available in this next phase of work as well. And, but, you know, I know people, some people choose to live in there.
1:41:13 Vehicles as a matter of choice and wanting to save money and so forth. And, you know, I think we can find reasonable, maybe there's reasonable ways. I think these suggestions that staff provided today are actually a lot of great alternatives and certainly think the syrup substation could be a good long-term solution. Thank you for your comments. Good evening. Jennifer Kreitz, Mono County Board of Supervisors, District 1. I just want to touch on the Mono County Behavioral Health.
1:41:45 The health and human services aspect of helping people with wraparound services. And so Mono County does provide about $150,000 to Eastern Sierra Community Housing. They have a housing navigator on staff that helps folks in Mono County find services that help them, whether that's with housing, it could be with food, it could be with
1:42:12 I feel like, you know, we're trying to partner throughout that.
1:42:40 And you made, you're accurate, obviously, with the funding that goes to behavioral health and health and human services through the county. But we're present in the town. Thank you for your comments. And Supervisor Kreitz, can I just confirm, you said it's $150,000 that the county provides? All parking, but I think it's about that. Okay. Yeah. Okay, thank you. Any other comments in the room?
1:43:09 I'm not seeing any. Jamie, are there any comments online? Yes. Emily, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Can you hear me? Yes. Okay. I just wanted to say thank you to everybody that asked questions and participated. It was very hopeful to have a long discussion on this because it means that people care. Everybody here is invested in helping
1:43:38 Me and other members of the community and I think it was Rob that had mentioned I was going to say something about the fact that we are cleaning up and we are picking up trash in the woods in the summers so thank you for bringing that up and mentioning that but I'm looking forward to hearing what's coming and I just want to say thank you to everybody who asked questions and has been working hard on this. Thank you very much.
1:44:06 Is there anyone else online? No. So now we can have our discussion? Okay. Who'd like to spill the beans? Chris, would you like to go first? Well, I think, so first of all, I really do want to thank the staff and everybody for how quickly you have addressed this, coming forward with three options. I think the thing that I would just like to, I mean, I've already said it, so maybe I deliberated early, but
1:44:38 When, if a private entity is to come forward, which it sounds like that could be close, I would just encourage staff to find a way to make sure that happens as quickly as possible, because I think, as Brent mentioned, you know, the winter's half over. And the other solutions look reasonable, and I'm glad that we'll start to, you know, implement those as well, because I think we need multiple solutions to this challenge.
1:45:08 So I would, the only thing I would ask for is when that place becomes identified, then let's just move as quickly as possible so that everyone in the community understands, you know, we are taking this very seriously. It comes with many challenges. I am not suggesting that the challenges aren't the challenges. And so thank you. John, you've been quiet over there. Can we hear from you? Yeah, I just, I'm actually, I was
1:45:36 I'm kind of profoundly impressed with the options that have come in front of us. In my conversation with staff this afternoon, I think obviously option three is the most, maybe the quickest one, and I would assume that there may be a private, I would hope that there's a private party in the community to come forward. I think also it's the advantages of doing this on private property versus getting into public property stuff, that's something that I think we all understand how
1:46:05 Tricky that could get. So I'm looking forward to see whenever can come forward for number three. Number two is a relatively quick one thing also given environmental analysis and review and code compliance issues and things like that. So I think we're in relatively good shape. I think there's a lot of focus on what was going on at the substation piece for a long time, but that seems to have gotten mired up.
1:46:31 In things that who knows what. But I think from the town's perspective, I think we can do this. I do want to emphasize again the importance of the semantics and the terms that are used. This is not, from my perspective, this is not about a homelessness solution or an unhoused solution. The people who came in front of us, you know.
1:46:53 Proud, good members of the community. They're working. They're trying to be part of this place. They're looking for housing options. Let's see what we can do with this. But again, you get in the terminology how it might trigger things with state law, state regulations, all the rest of that kind of stuff. I think we want to be very careful. The audience we're trying to address and the recreational audience that comes up here that are becoming weekend warriors and those kinds of things. Got a beautiful RV park over there. So good on you. Looking forward to seeing what you guys come up with. So thank you. Okay.
1:47:23 Bill, what are your thoughts? Anxious to see stuff come back again. It's not as cut and dry. I mean, it sounds so easy, and it really isn't. The more I delve into it, the more confused I get. And, you know, I want to clarify something, because we've talked about people picking up trash, and I've suggested that trash is out there. I believe the same percentage of visitors that come to Mammoth pollute as the percentage of locals. I have a thing I call the 3% solution. 3% of every group are total idiots.
1:47:53 So it happens regardless what your group is. There is not one group that's better than the other or one group I'm pushing over the other. It's just it is a fact that when I drive the forest and I do it a lot, this is what I'm seeing out there. And that's it. I'm anxious to see what comes forward. I'd like to see us deal with this, but in a way that isn't going to come back to bite us like other things the town has done in the past. Okay, thank you, Bill. Brent? So a couple different things. One is...
1:48:23 Workforce housing has been identified as one of our priority needs for this community. I look at this as workforce housing. We've talked about this a very long time, and in my world, in my head, if this building was on fire, we'd do something to put the fire out. We have a fire. And because it doesn't affect us and we don't see it as much, we think, oh, we could just let it burn for a while and we'll come back to it and hopefully maybe it'll burn itself out or we'll do something else.
1:48:50 I think there's been some very good solutions that have come to the table to address on this, but I'm going to stay on the first part in terms of timing. My hope is that we can address something by the latest, our next council meeting, with alternatives, and I think the alternatives are kind of outlined where you've gone forward. Ideally, private property is the first one. There are benefits to do that, and we don't need to go back to those, but I think that is a very...
1:49:19 Good solution, but if that doesn't work, I would be looking for an alternative solution, location, implementation, what do we need to do to make this happen so that we are prepared. At the same time, I think that we need to keep moving ahead with option two. I'd love to think that we could have a substation by this fall, but I don't think realistically that's going to happen. That's pathway one, substation. No, but I just, but pathway one would be
1:49:49 It has potential. I think that also has some very strong benefits, some challenges that go with it. But I think we need to look at solutions because I really don't want to come back here next year and say, oh, we need an emergency order to fill something out. We need to take care of it because in this community, workforce wellness is a primary benefit in the community. We have a social obligation, I believe, to take care of our workforce, even just not only workforce, but take care of the people in the community. I sit up here representing the public.
1:50:18 I would not be doing my job if I'm not really adamant that we need to take care of those people. And I can't stress that enough, but that's where I'm coming from is we need to move forward. I understand we got it. We got our challenges with requirements, making sure we follow procedures, et cetera. But I also know that if we end up playing with a solution that is not a private property, I think that's the council's decision to say, is that liability? There are other challenges that we have.
1:50:47 Going to be worth the risk, and we take that judgment, but we just know and make an informed decision based on the information we have. Thank you. Okay. Well, so my feelings on this is I would love to see us move forward with all three pathways kind of simultaneously. You know, I'd love to see something done as quickly as possible for our car living residents.
1:51:11 You know, other things that kind of come to mind, I know you started your presentation with, you know, identifying areas where you can park and identifying who can park there. You know, something that comes to mind for me is there's been a lot of acknowledgement tonight that it's not safe to sleep in your car during a winter storm. You know, I think that, you know, we have a space, the community center, that I think is underutilized and, you know, I would love to see that space opened up during large...
1:51:39 Winter snowstorms so that people who, you know, are car-living residents could go there and be safe and be warm. So, and then I also think, you know, we need to think about, you know, is this program only for employed individuals or, you know, if there are people that are on disability or retired that are community members, if they'll be included in this or not.
1:52:08 But I thank you for bringing this forward. And I hear a lot of, you know, support up here. And I hear a lot of, you know, that we want to get this done quickly. So I look forward to seeing what you're going to bring back. And I hope that it's going to be quick. Are there any other comments? I'd just like to address one of the speed in which we can do this. So talking to Andy on this and Chris.
1:52:36 Councilmember Bubser, you mentioned this earlier about a special meeting. So we can call a special meeting with 24-hour notice. So what we're looking for in that space and these resolutions and other things are authority to commit something. So authority to contract with perhaps this private entity or to execute some of the details of the cost and so forth that was discussed this evening in the presentation.
1:53:02 But we can pull that together fairly quickly, and I will commit to doing that. So if an opportunity comes up where we can execute quickly, I will call a special meeting, and we'll get it done. Thank you very much. Okay. Looks like we're going to move right along to item 7.2, consider changes to town parking policies. And I'll need just a minute to get all my slides and everything set up. Okay. Just give me one sec. What?
1:53:31 We'll take a five-minute break. What's that? Candy? Oh, my God. And such good choices. Milk Duds. Milk Duds. I know it's sugar, but... I love Milk Duds. Rolo and Payday. There's no Snickers in here? Let's see. What's a Reese's Take Five? Pretzels, caramel, peanut butter. Oh, my God.
1:59:50 Okay, and we're back. On to policy matter 7.2, consider changes to town parking policies. Thank you. So we will continue our conversation about parking, but different. So this evening, I want to kind of go through the purpose of this meeting, some of the issues and concerns that we're seeing, an idea about resort zone parking, a signage plan, circulation plan, developing a parking map.
2:00:20 Inbound services and paid parking. The goals, like I stated, looking for is that this is a discussion, right? We want to have an open discussion about ideas and concepts. We presented a number in the staff report and we'll present a number of other ideas in this presentation. We want to get your feedback. We want direction and we want to really focus on the resort areas and really an emphasis on winter.
2:00:49 I think there's an immediate need to do some work in this space. And we're not going to talk about the systemic issues around town. I know there's some folks here that want to talk about Main Street. There's issues on Sierra Manor, the park and ride lot, Laurel Mountain, the frontage roads, use and misuse. There's a large area of public right-of-way that is cleared by an HOA, and there's probably 50 illegal cars parked there right now. It's systemic.
2:01:20 But the reason we want to talk about the resort area, specifically around Canyon, is because there's things we look for in public works and in public safety. Illegal parking for us is a problem when it blocks transit, obstructs snow removal services, impedes emergency services, blocks fire hydrants, impacts pedestrian safety.
2:01:45 Decreases site distance, so that's when you're driving around a corner you can't see because there's a car legally parked, or reduces vehicular circulation. Now, while parking problems are systemic, these are the areas we want to focus on because these are where we're going to have emergencies. These other locations, you know, frankly, they're nuisances. We can manage them. Yeah, it's frustrating and difficult to deal with, but we have areas where we have real issues that could, you know, be a life safety issue, and we want to focus on those.
2:02:16 So one of our thoughts is developing a resort parking zone so we can have a different level of parking citation for these areas. And our thought was that would apply to the Canyon area, the Eagle area, and the North Village. And we would have to go through a process to map it and identify the roads, but in general, those areas. The Lakes Basin is an area where we know there's a lot of conflict, but it's unique.
2:02:46 In that it's forest service and the municipal code doesn't apply to that area. So what we would be doing to change parking regulation would not apply there. The citations that are issued in the Lakes Basin are based on California vehicle code and are not something that non-sworn officers can cite for. So we need to tackle that independently.
2:03:11 We've also had a lot of success in the Lakes Basin with the host program. I think that's something that shows that an active management program can help to deal with this type of situation, but we're carving that out intentionally, even though it has similar type problems. Can I just ask a quick question on the create new parking zone? Is that just administrative creating, or would we have to change ordinance? Because I understand, I look at the vehicle code and...
2:03:38 It looks like we have authority, or actually it looks like you mean we have some authority. Yeah, so that's a great question. Should have led with that. Pretty much everything we do here is going to require some level of resolution, ordinance, fee structure. There's a lot of work that needs to be done. It's not one thing fixes everything. So we'll solicit your feedback, your ideas, and then we're going to need to work with Andy to figure out what is the best instrument to affect those changes.
2:04:07 Because in our vehicle code, it's currently saying is that you have the authority to create certain modifications. This would still have to require above and beyond that? Yeah, so when you say vehicle code, that's California vehicle code. We're talking municipal code. Yeah, I'm talking in our municipal code, vehicle code that lists under section 10 that gives you authority to change during winter time hours. There's a winter subset that allows the town to be flexible. Yeah, through the ordinance.
2:04:37 There's some technicalities in there we need to resolve, but just for the sake of this discussion and conversation, pretty much everything we talk about is going to require some new instrument to affect that change. So when we say parking zone, we're going to have to create that administratively. What instrument that is, not quite sure yet. So within that zone, we are recommending increasing the ticket cost to...
2:05:04 Somewhere around the neighborhood of $300. That is up for discussion. We recently bumped them from $40 to $110, and that was not enough. Earlier this season, myself, the chief, fire chief, reps from the ski area, we all got together, looked at some of these, this one high profile area that's really constrained that we have a lot of issues in. We all agreed on some changes, put up a picket fence of no parking signs, painted the curbs red, and
2:05:34 It did nothing to stop the violations. The bad behavior is very, very difficult to manage. So can I speak on that? Yeah, please do. So it's a good part for me to intervene. I just kind of wanted to give Council another update. So the last couple of Council meetings have given you updates on citations and stuff like that. I'm going to go back to 2324. In 2324, so this is going to show that the issue, the parking issue is getting worse over time.
2:06:02 23-24, we had a total of 789 parking citations. 24-25, 944. And this year, and that goes from November to April. So no parking on the street. So November 1st to April 30th. 789, 944. And this year already, with three months left, all of February, March, and April, we're at 636, which we're on track for close to 1,200 tickets this year.
2:06:32 I know there's another item in here as far as ADA violations. We bumped that from, I believe, 350 to 550. Just in the last month, not in the last month, but since November, 46 ADA citations were giving and three fraudulent citations, which are misdemeanors. So we're writing misdemeanor citations for fraudulent tags.
2:06:58 So it's happening. We have a real big issue, not only with parking in resort areas, but we also have a big issue as far as handicap parking goes too. I know Hayes is going to talk a little bit about upping and increasing the cost to $300. Honestly, I don't know if that's going to work. I spoke with Finley earlier. I know Finley's going to talk on it a little bit.
2:07:21 He's had conversations with patrons and guests at the mountain saying, hey, you can't park there. It's a $110 ticket. They said, well, there's three, four people in the car, 30, 30, 30, 30, they're going to pay for it that way and go for it, right? So we need something that is impactful and something that will help with this issue. It's pretty bad. Oh, just a quick question.
2:07:48 If someone parks illegally and it creates a safety hazard, is there something more that you can do? So there is. If it creates a safety hazard, we can get it towed. Problem is, we can't get it towed. And get it impounded and taken to a lot. Lots are usually full, unable to respond. The tow companies are busy out on the highways with accidents and stuff like that, having a real issue.
2:08:15 with getting a tow company to respond and tow that vehicle even if it's creating a safety issue. Okay, so then, sorry, now a question for Andy. As a municipality, can we create our own law that says it's a misdemeanor or something more that it's not just a fine but it's some kind of crime to park in front of a fire hydrant? Well, I think that's already in the vehicle code. So the vehicle code is pretty prescriptive. It's one of the areas of state law where
2:08:44 We have some ability to choose our own rules, but largely the vehicle code is what it is. So I'd have to look and see what's already in the code about that, but I don't know that we can kind of innovate because the vehicle code preempts it. Okay. So later in this presentation there will be conversation about towing and some things that we're looking at doing to help that situation. Just want to give you an example. Monday we had a rollover crash on Beaver Trail.
2:09:12 Somebody lost control of the car, looked down, looked up, turned the car, went up on the snowbank and rolled over, no injuries or anything like that. We could not get a tow company out there for probably three hours. We ended up having to cone off the vehicle, leave it there, so our officers can respond to other calls and stuff like that. So even getting somebody to come out and tow a vehicle on a rollover, on a crash where all officers are at, is a challenge. Thank you.
2:09:40 So my question is on the amount, because as a preamble to my question is, I was concerned because we're hospitality oriented, we want people welcoming, it kind of feels a little bit of a hammer, but I also did research on what other areas are charging, and I've learned why 300, because Big Bear is charging 400 to 500 for parking. Mount Shasta is $300, depends on...
2:10:06 So I didn't know if you had other backup for Y300.
2:10:37 Appreciate those comments. A couple things. One, the price of the ticket is, while it's punitive, it's supposed to be a deterrent, right? I think we all, we're trying to figure out what that number is. $300, you'll see, it's an estimate. We tripled it before, we were thinking we'd triple it again. If you want to make it $1,000, this is your choice. We're going to go along with this. I've seen parking ticket prices all over the place. I can find them higher, and I can definitely find them lower.
2:11:06 I found beach and resort communities with tickets only in the $60 range. And then we found them, I think the highest I found was a ticket in San Francisco for impeding the flow of traffic at $1,000, which is something we're going to talk about here in a moment. So what number you feel is appropriate is what we would move forward with. However, we will be looking for that direction and consensus because, like I said, we have to come back with whatever instrument to implement that.
2:11:36 So we need that information from you guys. We'll be circling back on this because we'll need that or direction on how you want us to come up with it. And that's the same issue with the ADA violations. Most of the placards or the ADA spaces actually say the violation on there. And if $550 is not getting your attention, what number is it going to take? 46 tickets in three months for, you know, willful violations of ADA spaces.
2:12:06 It's pretty egregious. Something else we want to address is, again, separating vehicle code from municipal code. We are moving forward with the development of a municipal code code enforcement officer non-sworn that will help to manage tickets, dogs off-leash. They cannot cite for California vehicle code, only municipal code violations. Our code section, we do talk about impeding the flow of traffic.
2:12:34 But there isn't like a dollar amount or fine or anything associated with it. We would like to create that. And this would be for just those purposes of people who are parking unsafely. I can't put a picket fence on this entire town with parking here, parking there. There are just some egregious misuse of parking that just deserve this type of ticket. I'll cite an example. It was a few weeks ago. People were parked down the voodoo chute.
2:13:02 No place to park on the voodoo chute. You are literally parking in the travel lane. You shouldn't have to put a no parking sign there. It should be obvious. We have people who park on our multi-use paths. You shouldn't have to sign for something as obvious as that. And there's a lot of other examples, people who park in bus turnouts and bus stops. This is the ticket that would be specifically for them. And I didn't put a number on it. I did cite San Francisco as as high as $1,000. My personal opinion, it should be higher than a parking ticket.
2:13:31 This is your decision and where you'd like to place that type of ticket. It's to really manage those really egregious violations that should be obvious. It's just a willful disregard for public safety and the flow of traffic. And again, going back to the original comments, why are we doing this? Maintain traffic, snow removal, emergency services, it's all related to that. Someone's violating.
2:13:59 You know, impeding the flow of traffic. They are potentially a life safety risk. Yeah, and I've driven that road multiple times in preparation for this, and I'm not sure we actually have more parking, because I've seen voodoo shoe parking throughout the years, but when you go up through there, even the bus can't come down through there. I mean, it's not a safe situation. I don't know how you'd even get an ambulance up there. Yeah, and I'll show some photos and some images that kind of demonstrate some of these ideas. But I appreciate you bringing up the other, sorry. Oh, I just want to ask you a quick question.
2:14:28 So we had 47 ADA violations. Do these violate, like, do we collect on all of these tickets? Or what, if someone is willing to just park wherever they want, are we able to collect from them? Or do they just not pay? Or, you know what I mean? It's like, you write them a ticket, it goes, it's on their car, it goes to them in the mail. Like, do they pay it? So, yes. They have an option of challenging this citation.
2:14:57 So when our officers go out there and write the citation, they take pictures. They take pictures of either fraudulent or expired or no ADA tag. They have the option, the individual who gets the citation has the option to challenge the citation. They'll come into the police department and we want to challenge the citation. The way that they do it is mentioned on the back of the citation. They usually challenge it through Ryan Tanaka, who's our police services technician.
2:15:27 He goes through them, and if there's something legit there, they'll change it. But usually, as far as your question goes, do we collect on it? We do. We use data ticket. Data ticket is the collector of the money, and then data ticket sends us revenue after subtracting the cost of the equipment and the cost that they charge. We do get the money for it. So, I mean, we're seeing upwards of $30,000 a month.
2:15:54 For citations, which is after revenue, after they take their portion out of it. Excuse me. Thank you. Yes. If, you know, hypothetically, you know, that's where it's going and you probably don't have that data, but I would love to know if we issue $50,000 a month, do we get $30,000 back in terms of how many people appeal and don't get off that appeal process? Are we, tend to be somewhat lenient?
2:16:21 Like 99.99999% have to pay. It's discretion. So it's discretion, you know, if they come in and, I mean, they're appealing that they're appealing the citations that the officers wrote, right? And they have to appeal it through the police department. I mean, they take it as far as Superior Court as well, right? But we don't ever have it go that far.
2:16:46 Usually I have to sign off on a citation that is appealed and is successfully appealed. And I haven't signed off on a citation that has been successfully appealed in a long time. So I don't believe it's happening very often. And when it does happen, there's a legit reason for it. Okay. So I'm going to pause here. Any questions or any additional discussion before we move on to the next topic? I will circle back because I do need direction on this. We're going to hold public comments until the end of the presentation.
2:17:20 So our next topic for discussion is a revised signage plan. And I won't be looking for a lot of specific direction on this, more of a general consensus to do something different, because it's going to take a little bit more work. If there's a specific thing that resonates, please let me know. But we want our signage to be more explicit.
2:17:53 For the longest time, the direction has been to expand parking, create parking, identify places where you can have it where you can't. And I will agree that creates some level of confusion and conflict. And while it may be signed appropriately, it may not be obvious. It also creates an opportunity for bad behavior because, you know, they can use those discrepancies to their advantage. So we want the signage to be more explicit and more clear.
2:18:22 That will entail slightly larger signage. We know our signs get buried, and that just happens during snowstorms, and that creates problems. So talk to the team about how we could do that differently, and we have some thoughts on it. We want to be more clear on where you can park on one side of the street or other. I'm going to get into a little bit more detail on this, but the idea is when you come into a street, parking on this side permitted or no parking this side permitted. Very clear.
2:18:51 Or just no parking on this street within these zones. Larger signs when you enter that area so it's very clear you're not looking for small no parking signs for one or two spaces. We also like the idea of adding the ticket price again to discourage bad behavior. Hopefully we come up with a number that does that. And also we'll talk more about tow and impound but certain zones where we intend to tow.
2:19:17 And put that on the signage package so it's very clear. We also want to eliminate parking in certain areas that are pinch points. One is the uphill north side of Lakeview. And we've reworked a striping plan because we're doing that now for all of town because we're going to contract out all of our street striping.
2:19:47 And the idea is we would move the travel lanes to the far north and leave all the open space on the south for parking and pedestrians. And this concept, and I'm going to apply this to a lot of other streets, allows the snow removal crew to have one side of the street to plow to. Right now, when it's going back and forth between parking on one side or the other, it's really difficult to get equipment through these areas. By creating one side only,
2:20:16 On any given street, it allows our crews to move through during a storm cycle while there's active parking for the ski area or other uses. And so we're going to apply that throughout these zones. With the exception of one-way rainbow where we are going to strongly recommend eliminating all parking on that street. That small section of downhill...
2:20:41 Road is incredibly challenging to manage. Not only do we have a number of parking conflicts with how it's used, but it's almost impossible to remove snow in this area. And so we're recommending eliminating all the parking on downhill one-way rainbow. Two mammoth slopes. Two mammoth slopes. It's just that one section that's really, really constrained. They'll still be parking.
2:21:08 Before you kind of enter the corridor, and I'll show you a couple little maps on what that looks like, but that downhill section is just incredibly challenging, and we have nothing but issues there. It only takes one car to park in the wrong way, and you cannot get emergency services, you cannot get a blade through it, you can't get a cop car through it. It takes almost nothing to bottleneck that section.
2:21:30 And with that, we're going to reevaluate parking based on road width throughout this entire corridor. So this is a holistic. We're going to go through Mammoth Slopes, Forest Trail, and look at all these roads and evaluate what we can and can't do one side or the other if we can allow parking. So I'll pause there and see if there's any questions. Did you have something first? Quick, and you're not going to have the answer tonight. So in looking at the things you have just said, do we have any concept of how many parking spots we're losing?
2:22:01 Because all of those cars still have to be somewhere. So what I've written in my notes here is all we're doing to create these issues, and I agree with everything you're saying, is, and sort of tongue-in-cheek, is pushing the parking issue down the road. If they can't park here, they're going to find a place to park. So ultimately, how do we deal with that issue? Why has the issue come to the forefront?
2:22:29 Today, and I'm going to give some comments here that I probably should have held until the end, but in talking to somebody who's been in management at the top of Lakeview for a long, long time, they really don't feel in the long term that it's gotten that much worse. It's always been this chaotic up there. For whatever reason, we are now calling it out and trying to do something with it. But the problem is a parking problem, not in where they're parking, but in our inability and in the businesses. I can point at the mountain here some as well.
2:22:59 To provide parking for the guests that are necessary. So who's the creation? Who creates the issue in the first place? How do we solve it? Who has to pay for it? Again, it's not an easy task moving forward, but I would be interested in how many spots we're losing and how we plan on replacing them if we do. So the short answer to that question is a significant number of spaces. Yes. And the short answer is we're not planning to replace them.
2:23:30 Unless something changes and we get different direction, Public Works, we're not in the parking business. We're in the public safety, snow removal, emergency service, you know, business. And so unless you want to give us a different direction to create parking townwide, it's not our intention to replace those spaces. It's our intention to resolve the parking issues in such a way that we can continue to provide circulation, snow removal.
2:23:57 And access for emergency service. I'm going to keep going back to that slide. That's the intent of our policy change. Right. But as a town who invites guests, part of our job overall, perhaps not in your department, Hais, but is parking. And it's not incumbent on just the town of Mammoth Lakes. We need to find a solution with the partners. How do we finance it? How do we produce it? How do we create the land for it? How do we give our customers a place to park?
2:24:26 We require that restaurants have a certain number of parking spots in order to be open. So do we make a municipal code change that if you have X number of guests you have to provide X number of parking spots? I don't know the answer. I'm just saying it's awful simple to put up signs. And I know, listen, I travel our streets all the time. I've questioned people parked between two no parking signs who said, well, but those parking signs are for those parking spaces, not this one.
2:24:54 So I'm not even sure you fix it by putting up, you know, as you said, we can't sign every 10 feet. Yeah, appreciate that. See, and I'll add to where you're going because I was actually, it sounds like a court of law I was going to say, in your opinion, the spaces that we are losing, do we need to look long-term to find other parking spaces? Not say that we are today, I'm just saying in your opinion, do you think we need to find more parking spaces? In my opinion, the answer is yes, but that's not a short-term solution. Yeah, I understand.
2:25:24 Bill's already covered where part of my question was. Second part, I drove down the street today even and some of the parking signs are still buried in snow. Even changing signs, is there any way of having a different way of sign visualization because it does get kind of buried? Yeah, that's what I was alluding to is a different type and different style of sign that signs the street and not individual spaces.
2:25:49 Because it's really difficult to bucket out snow for each one of those little small signs. And so talking with Warren and Pat, we kind of were thinking about how we could do it differently so that we could avoid the larger signs. And so when you enter a street, it's clear that this street is this for the duration. So it's not a onesie-twosie. It's this side is permitted or not permitted. And then the third part is just going in terms of the realignment of the roads.
2:26:18 So in the past, they used to put cones going up like Lakeview. You park a side, someone would go down and put cones. I think actually the mountain would just come down and put cones up there. Would that give enough space? For instance, if we're sliding to one side, I'm still a little concerned with bikes, but we're trying to find a solution here. Is there enough space to have parking and a pedestrian way? Because the other thing I've run into going up and down that road several times during the busy time frames is not just the cars. People are walking up and down the middle of the road and they suck up.
2:26:46 A great deal of space. It's very difficult to, they don't seem to appreciate you're driving a 7,000-pound vehicle sliding down the hill. It doesn't even be cognitive. Yeah, I appreciate that. So this is part of the short-term solution, looking at the availability of right-of-way and what we can do with striping this summer when we re-stripe it and obliterate the old lines. We can create that space which will be wider and create more of a pedestrian corridor. That's a short-term solution.
2:27:15 Long-term, and this is not even in the CIP, it's so long-term, we have enough real estate to do a sidewalk up Lakeview with parking. So that is something we've discussed internally as a, you know, it's probably a five-year-plus solution with transit stops and so forth, but that's not solving the issue today. And the direction we received from Council at the last meeting was to come up with some solutions that we can implement now. Any other questions at this point?
2:27:48 Just kind of a quick question. North side, are you thinking melt, like south side melting out, north side's going to stay icy kind of thing? So, yeah, we kind of went back and forth on that, and it's challenging because when folks are parked on the south side, they're blocking the sun from melting, and then we get ice buildup, and then we have to try to chip that out at night. There's no...
2:28:13 There's no panacea here when it comes to managing snow removal, snow banks and parking. The goal is just to have a lane for your crews. That was the thought. This is a better solution. If we have a clear path, we can drop a blade and we can clear it more regularly as opposed to, and I was going to bring this up next, an image like this, this is Rainbow at Majestic Pines looking east. Pat has to turn the flights off when we're blowing this.
2:28:44 He cannot run the blower because there's people so close to the bucket or the box that it's unsafe. We can't even clear snow on this in a snowstorm when it's parked like this. So when we talk about creating parking on one side, well, there's enough real estate to allow parking on, it doesn't matter, pick a side. We'd be able to run equipment on the opposite side creating those lanes. So same concept. So what we're talking about in Lakeview with that kind of...
2:29:13 You know, picture of parking one side lanes on the other, apply that to any street, but for the entire lane. Can I just ask you, where is Majestic Pines on Rainbow? At the intersection of Rainbow and Majestic Pines looking east. Is that Mammoth Slopes or Majestic Pines? Oh, yeah, thank you. It's been a long day. That's okay. That is not even close to Majestic Pines. Yeah.
2:29:38 I'm glad you're awake. I have my Google Maps up. I was like, I walk there with my dog and I have not walked on that street. We are fallible in public works. Yes, that is Mammoth Slopes. Thank you. Okay. Okay. So I just tried to read the signs. Did I say no parking? Yeah. So you can see the no parking signs, you know, in the background and in the side here. But this is to demonstrate that, you know, this type of parking is unsustainable. We can't manage it.
2:30:06 And if we had an emergency on the cul-de-sac that's just down the street, we would struggle to get a fire truck through this. So is this the one-way portion of Rainbow? No. This is where it's supposed to be two- This is the good part. The one-way does look like this at times where they're parking on both sides and you can't even get a vehicle through there. Yeah, we can jump into that. Let's circle back to that. So moving on, this is something we've talked about a few times.
2:30:39 Is the idea of a parking map. And we worked with Betsy to kind of modify the tear-offs and made some pretty great improvements to that tear-off map. And that image to the right there, you can see in the yellow, it basically says parking allowed here, but obey signs. There's, you know, a lot of restrictions. But we need to do a little bit more in the space. So internally, we've been working on a GIS effort for asset management.
2:31:09 Before we even had this conversation, like the week before, Pat ordered 150 parking signs. We don't destroy 150 parking signs a year. They get stolen, they get destroyed, and they just disappear. And so there's a lot that goes into managing parking signs. And we're not omnipresent. We put up a sign on Tuesday on the scenic loop, about 50 of them. And then Wednesday, they were all gone.
2:31:37 Stick air tags on them and catch the people. Yeah. It's a lot of money, but it's also very difficult for us to manage because we are not actively driving around until someone brings it to our attention that, hey, all those signs went walkabout. We can't manage it. So we're looking at developing a program where we can do parking sign audits and putting that into GIS so it's very clear for the staff out in the field.
2:32:03 Where things were, where they should be, and that was an internal effort for asset management. And then we thought, how could we develop that product for print, social media, web-based, various applications, and so we're working through that now. I'll add, the ski area has their own parking map, and I appreciate the fact that they represent just the parking on their areas and they don't represent the town parking.
2:32:29 But they do have information out there for their guests. And I wanted to be clear that it's not just the town that's trying to make improvements here. The ski area has parking information on their website for their guests as well. So, Hayes, just because you brought this up, it's a question that I don't know where to fit in, but I'll throw here. Do you think that there's an impact with parking because the mountain has, over time, evolved a larger pay-to-play parking in their lot? And people might be trying to find a cheaper place first and then...
2:32:58 That pushes people away before they fill up that lot? And maybe you can't answer that, but just, you know, I'm going in terms of, does their paid area have an impact on pushing people away? We haven't studied that. We haven't asked the guests any questions. We haven't done any surveys on this, but my gut is no, because that lot's full. Yeah. Yeah, but it usually fills up secondarily. The paid area is slower.
2:33:25 Yeah, but... It eventually fills up. Everything fills up. It's still full by like 9 or 10. Yeah, by 10 o'clock. It's full. If it was sitting empty, I would say maybe. But at least the times I've driven up there to look and take photos and kind of look at things, it's been full. So I don't think it has... I think the demand is just that high. Yeah. This might be a silly question, but is there something we could do to prevent...
2:33:51 Signs being stolen, like using a different kind of screw that doesn't have the same, you know, like not a flathead. Electrify them. I don't know, like is there a different, is there a more secure screw that we could use that's harder to take off? We've used tamper-proof bolts, but there's nothing that's going to stop an angle grinder. Yep. Those battery angle grinders just cut them right off. Well, it doesn't even have to be an angle grinder. All these security screws.
2:34:17 The bits to use them are available at the hardware store. Don't share that, Bill. Bill, stop taking our parking signs. It's really challenging. We've welded nuts on. We've done a lot of different things, but there's a lot of signs to manage, and it's really, really frustrating. But if we had one bigger sign at the beginning of the street, we could maybe take some more precautions so that it would be harder for someone to steal it? Yes. Okay. Yeah, that's kind of the thought.
2:34:47 It'd be a little bit more obvious if that disappeared as well. We'd see it. And whose garage it's hanging in. Yeah, so this is a frustrating component of sign management. And this is town-wide. This is not just in the resort areas. We see this throughout pretty much every neighborhood. So you have this vision now that someone's stealing no parking sign, they're cutting it, using it on a hanger on an ADA spot, and then just throwing it in there just for the fun of it.
2:35:19 So I'll pause here. Again, I think we'd be just looking for consensus. Yeah, I'd continue working on this. Don't need a lot of direction. It's something we'd bring back. I don't think this is something that's going to take a lot of resolutions or codes or something. This is something we were already kind of working on from an asset management. It would just be taking the time to turn that into a product that we can share through different media sources. And you could have this available this winter? I don't know. It's a lot of work.
2:35:47 So you talk about print, social media, web apps, but we have those wonderful flashing signs when you're coming in that the PD uses special event or whatever, like follow parking, you know, just tell people like
2:36:18 The fines are for real and we're coming for you. I mean, I know it sounds hostile and we're a destination that welcomes our visitors, but this is ridiculous because it's a safety issue. It's not just you're inconveniencing somebody else. You are literally endangering our community. Yeah, thank you for that. And there's been a couple times where we've had to call in the cavalry to move vehicle because it was blocking an ambulance. That's not, it's scary.
2:36:45 I did put something at the next steps about CMS boards or something coming to town if we do make some significant changes to try to really do a robust messaging program. But on a daily basis, it's really difficult to keep those signs up. One, if we're putting them on the highway, we have to get approval from the state, and we're kind of limited on what type of messaging we can do. We could do things in our own right-of-way.
2:37:12 But we're more challenged with, you know, weather and, you know, they are kind of large and make up space. Well, and just to add to that because we don't have a lot of them. When you look at it, Cambridge becomes the desired location by many people to access the mountain facilities. And if there's a way to divert people to other areas, it seems like there's one potential solution down the road to minimize the people that are headed up to that location because you have easy access to a canyon, you get better facilities, it's an...
2:37:41 You know, it looks good, the food's better, you got an after party, all those things went up there and you're going to go, oh, I'm going to go to Canyon versus go to Main Lodge because it's another three miles up the road. Yeah, I appreciate that. I hate Canyon. You know, it's also really important to message that we have free transit. Yes! And I was out taking photos and people were like, well, what do I do? I'm like, take transit. We have a great free transit system. Please use it. So, talking to owners up there and there are people, what they're pointing out though is that transit is very busy.
2:38:11 In that morning, and that's also facilitating that a lot of traffic might be actually coming from just down the road on Mountside and Discovery because they go up there and park up there early. They take the bus, but when people try to get through that location, particularly in that area, buses are full, and so people start driving. Yep. I don't know. That's antidote. I don't have any facts. I'd say I believe it. There's no easy solution, and there's challenges with every idea and concept.
2:38:42 Well, I think if we're encouraging people to take the bus, we need to make sure that we have enough buses to move out people. Right. You know, when they want to be moved. And they do bring in buses, and I don't want to segue into a transit conversation. I think Phil will be here at the next meeting with the state of Vesta, but they do flex in buses if we start getting reports that they're full. And we do have an intelligent transportation system that is currently being tested in Riley's office that we're hoping to deploy.
2:39:10 Shortly, if we can just overcome a couple little bugs. So moving on, one, thank you for authorizing the purchase of a town hangar. That purchase is going to facilitate the movement of a lot of town treasure to an inside storage facility, and it will allow us to clear that site as an opportunity to be leased for a municipal tow yard.
2:39:37 This is something Chief and I have been working on for quite some time to try to identify a piece of property that would be appropriate for this use. And we believe, with your approval, that this site at the Sierra Business Park is the great location for this. Our vision is to have a contract on call for town-first services. While they may be permitted to conduct business all over the eastern Sierra, when we make that phone call,
2:40:07 We are the priority. And that's because we are providing the land. And we think that is something we can do. This will require an RFP for services. It's going to require some contracts. It's going to require some updates to codes, ordinances, zones. We have a lot of work to do in this space. I think right now we are looking for consensus to continue to move forward with this.
2:40:36 Kind of a consensus to use the slot as the catalyst. And then we will go forth. And it's going to take a bit of work. This is not something that happens overnight. But we had a great conversation with the local provider today. And it was incredibly encouraging. And I think we can be successful in the space in a relatively short amount of time. It'll still take a few months to overcome the challenges. And there's some timing on the hangar.
2:41:05 I honestly think this will have the biggest impact on the adherence to the rules. It's one thing to pay a fine. It's another thing to have to go find your vehicle quite far away and also pay much more.
2:41:29 The costs associated with that, the inconvenience of having to go get your vehicle erases the convenience of you parking in a bad spot. So I think this will have the biggest impact on compliance. And I would agree. I like the idea of towing people that are not where they should be. However, besides just the impound yard, this will put it across the street from where it used to be and, in my opinion, still should be with that pony ran a long time ago. What about the
2:41:59 Towing Services. It is my understanding that we are woefully underserved in that capacity. So how do we then, I mean, how do we encourage? It used to be that almost every mechanic in town had their own towing service plus AAA plus, and we have lost them all for whatever reason. I'm assuming liability costs are through the roof, so we have trouble with that. How do we then encourage the return of some towing services?
2:42:28 So that once we get this impound yard and once we put up our you're going to be towed stupid signs, that we have the capacity to actually get them towed. Well, Bill, that's a great question. And needless to say, there's a significant amount of business to be had in the town of Mammoth Lakes for a tow company. The challenge is the land to tow the vehicles too.
2:42:53 That is the constraint that we have heard time and time again is that the land is just not available to take the vehicles to. So by overcoming that, by facilitating and leasing the land, we will create the opportunity for tow companies to tow to a municipal lot. And I think in the conversation we had today, there's a willingness to expand services to provide.
2:43:22 Not only for the town, but for local businesses and, you know, HOAs and so forth. And this will be a tremendous benefit not only to the town, local businesses, residents, but also CHP in Mono County. I think this has got the ability to be a massive benefit to all of our partners as well. And it's the land, Bill. It's as simple as that. Overcoming that challenge for the business.
2:43:50 It's going to solve that problem, we believe. As well as contracting. So right now we do not have a contract with the tow company. If we're contracted with the tow company, we're priority, which would be outlined in the contract. So if there is a tow company that is interested, that wants to come in and help out and use that lot, they would be contracted with the town of Mammoth Lakes as a priority response.
2:44:15 Right now, without a contract with any tow company, their priority is where the money's at, to be honest with you. So it's hard to get them off the highway, you know, rescuing vehicles on a snow day that are rolled over or whatever to get them to Mammoth to tow a car because it's blocking a fire hydrant. If we had a contract with a tow company and we had the ability to move those vehicles to an impound lot, then we would be very successful.
2:44:44 Right now it's a little bit rough because we do not have a contract and we don't have a place to take the vehicles. Just a quick question. Two-part. One is how many cars can we take in that lot? I just don't have a sense. Are we talking that whole space there? Are you going to make me do math on the spot? No, no. Just how many square miles fall apart? Maybe I'll take up 200 cars.
2:45:15 What is it? Probably 75 to 100. To start. I live on Davidson. There's always cars that need a place to go to from Davidson. But just general comment is more than just fines. This probably would have more impact on somebody not parking up there again. When you show up back up and your car is gone, that message will spread very quickly. A couple of strategic Facebook posts will probably go a very long way.
2:45:44 So I'm getting the feeling I've got consensus on this item and I'm not going to have to circle back to continue working on it. Is that fair? No. Paid parking. Staff is not recommending this in the resort area, but we would be remiss if we didn't bring up the topic and the opportunity for council to discuss it. While staff would probably say that paid parking would be more successful in other parts of town.
2:46:11 It would be incredibly difficult to manage in this resort area. However, it's something for you to consider, and I put it on here as a topic for you to discuss. I think that by issuing costly tickets, we have instituted paid parking. I agree with that. Yeah. Yeah, I'm not a fan. I mean, I feel like I don't understand how we would put in meters or anything, or that just seems...
2:46:44 Super complicated and who would shovel them and I would pass on this. And just to be clear, you're talking specifically about the area around Canyon Lodge on the town roads, right? Correct. This presentation is really geared towards that. So nothing at the village, we're talking like up. No, no, we're, well, we could talk about at the village, it's up to you. I mean, I think everything's on the table. And it's kind of in that resort zone that we're creating.
2:47:10 Around the canyon area, we don't think it would be successful. Could there be paid parking in some parts of the village? That could probably be successful. I think there's other parts of town that we're not discussing right now where it could be successful. This would take a lot of research. There's a lot of feedback, too, from the public about specifically that because people saw it in the proposal and were like, eh, so. Yeah, people are not a big fan of this. But like I said, I think it's something that needs to be discussed. Sure, sure. It is an opportunity.
2:47:39 And there are companies that manage this. They do it a number of different ways, through applications, through active management with people, through cameras, through kiosks. I've seen pucks in the asphalt that can sense vehicles. There's a number of ways that this can be accomplished, and it would take a lot of staff time to go and start researching what would work in our climate and snow area, all the things that are mammoth, what would work.
2:48:08 If the consensus is to not move this forward, I'm good with that, and that's all I need to hear. It seems overly complicated for solving the problem, which is to get people to stop behaving badly, and we still have to keep those spaces clear, which is one of the challenges. So for me, it just feels like it's creating a massive headache for staff with not really solving what we set out to solve. Is anybody? Okay. Okay, that's an easy no. Okay, so...
2:48:38 Next steps. So I want to circle back to a couple of the topics where I didn't get kind of the final answer. Collect that and then we as staff are going to have to go back, kind of work through this and then come back to council with some resolutions and ordinances and so forth. And that's going to take not a ton of time, but a little bit of time, you know, and we'll keep you informed as we work through that. And then obviously we'll have to order materials and deploy the material. So, you know, it could take
2:49:08 You know, 60 to 90 days if we work really quick to deploy some of these concepts. And then obviously we'll want to talk about a public outreach, you know, letting people know that these things have changed and we'll talk about, you know, how that's deployed on social media through our website. I put CMS boards on here because I think that's an active way to do that. So with that, I'll pause there. Should we take public comment first? Yeah, I'm going to pause there and hand it back to you. I think that's the end of my presentation. Other than
2:49:37 Circling back to those questions. Can I ask questions? So thank you for this. It is solving the most crucial problem. But we have heard a lot of that it's starting to spread into the rest of town, some of these parking problems. And so, you know, I think in the
2:49:56 Future, it would be also beneficial to hear about other solutions. Like I'm still begging for my tell people to park at the airport and we will drive them around for free and safely all weekend. You know, so I would like us to try to encourage those conversations as well because it just seems to be getting harder and harder for people to solve that and we have free buses. Like it makes no sense to me why anybody would even want to drive once they get to this town. So thank you.
2:50:25 Okay, so let's take public comment first. If you have public comment, come on up, and then we're going to do it slightly different than the last public comment. Staff, if you'd like to write down any questions, and then we can address questions after we take all the public comments. That's what we'll be doing. Come on down. Hi, I'm Richard Board, local business owner and volunteer fireman. The safety issue is paramount, getting access.
2:50:54 And I like the public outreach. I'm suggesting that we go to our lodging association and make this a, as you check in to your hotel, let me tell you one of the secrets, how to navigate around Mammoth. You know, make your restaurant reservations early and do not park where you're not supposed to park. You will regret it. Thank you. Thank you.
2:51:22 Any other public comments from the room? Come on down. This is just a quick agreement with the paid parking. I'm from San Diego. Oh, my name is Lillian Grassi, and I live up here part-time and San Diego County part-time. And we have, I think the latest was 80, 85% of the business owners around and in about Balboa Park.
2:51:49 Are all up in arms. We have lost so much business and traffic in that park and the museums just in the last couple weeks since they implemented paid parking. Thank you for your comments. Any other comments from the room? Come on down. Oh, Alana. Who's first? Ladies first. Why, thank you. So, am I clear? We couldn't tow the car that was parked at the disabled and cross-locked because we have no towing?
2:52:21 They're going to answer questions. If you want to just ask all your questions, then they'll address it at the end. How come we couldn't have gotten it shuttled out a little better for people in our wheelchairs? And sometimes I use the walker on public transportation, that kind of stuff. It's easier for me to use my walker and put my skis into everything with the walker, but it's not always possible in our town. Thank you. Bill, you want to come on down? Sure, go.
2:52:52 Thanks for having me. That was a great presentation, Mr. Hayes. That was a great presentation. But I wasn't joking around about the, if it's a safety issue, and I said pick, move them, it seems like it falls in the same category. You know, when someone is, someone's going to die over here, and this person's competing, I think you should have the right to, not just say pick, move, but don't.
2:53:21 Just shove them out of the way, you know, and with your big burly, you know, fenders that you have up front, but that's one of those issues, and I say this a little bit tongue-in-cheek, but just at the front, you know, when you make a, you know, a left, I'm dyslexic, so I'm assuming you're coming northbound from Southern California, just have a, whoever said the flashing sign, so something like that, just say no parking.
2:53:51 Just have one big, huge sign that says, no parking. And that's it. And of course, then you can litigate that because, of course, everyone has a hotel to go to and they have parking. But as long as right when you come in the town, it says, no parking. And then when you can avoid a lot of liability, right when you made a left turn, it said, no parking. Big flashing sign.
2:54:21 No parking. And of course, someone who's at the West End and at the, you know, the Ritz-Carlton, how many Ritz-Carlton's we have? Zero, of course, that's what I'm saying. But really, you're going to save yourself some signs right when you come right when you make a left. Save no parking. We're open. Come on down. My name is Richard Lawson. As a tow operator, we have a long-haul service. We tow vehicles that break down here.
2:54:56 That need to get back to dealerships in Reno, Los Angeles, San Diego, Orange County, etc. The biggest problem we run into is space. We receive phone calls from HOAs. This last weekend it was Summit. We get parking lot calls from here, Fred Johnson, to clear out vehicles. You may have noticed the old Dodge that was in the parking lot is out of here. So for us as tow operators, having space is
2:55:26 A huge asset that would allow for business to grow. So as an operator for the town. I didn't understand that. What would you like to see from us? What would you need from us in order to position ourselves well to be possibly received as a vendor in a situation like this? All right. Thanks. Thank you. Any other comments from anyone in the room? Hi, Tom Hodges again, VP of Development at Mammoth Mountain.
2:55:58 I think Bill's got AI. He can tell you he's had the phone a long time because he can't understand. My body seems to be talking to my phone without my permission. So, yeah, I really appreciate the staff's effort on this, and we had some offline discussions with them as well. And, you know, a few points I think we'll make, you know, obviously we want to be cooperative partners with town and welcome any further opportunities. We have historically always.
2:56:26 Partnered with the town in these discussions. We've been involved past with sort of the current scientists in place on Lakeview, for example. You know, certainly support your guys' discussions with respect to raising fines and enforcement and, you know, finding people who are violating our regulations or our rules and our parking. Certainly think that's going to go a long ways towards mitigating issues as you're contemplating here. But, you know,
2:56:55 To other comments that were made by Council and Bill as well is just, you know, if we do eliminate parking and there's no replacement for it, it may exasperate issues. I, you know, I don't know whether you want to take a measured approach and first implement the, you know, the stricter enforcement and higher fines as a first step and then see what transpires as a result of that before you start taking away parking. And then just on the bigger view, you know, it is, it is a
2:57:24 What are our main issues in this community? Workforce housing, parking, they're probably the first ones, transit. They're, you know, always top of the list. You know, we've had past discussions and participated in discussions about district parking. I think it's still something that we need to consider as a resort, as a community, because this is, you know, it's a resort-wide issue. It's not just the mountain. It's, you know, there's issues in town as well. And I know we've had, I'm pretty certain we have a,
2:57:54 Consultant study on the shelves that had recommendations about where we could site parking reservoirs for the community that support our commercial district and the resort areas as well. I would encourage Town Council to kind of maybe bring that back to the front burner as part of this discussion. And let's start talking about that. I mean, I think responsible communities have district parking.
2:58:23 Fund and support the construction of, you know, parking structures and pool parking and in a way that we can then look towards coupling with transit and having shared parking, you know, to your point, Chris, that, you know, hey, we got transit, we have transit, we can support people parking remotely and bringing them up to these locations, you know, at the critical times and, you know, there's...
2:58:47 Bacon parking, for example, on a Saturday probably at the high school and the college and other locations, you know, could it be a community-wide effort to kind of pool all of our resources and work collaboratively to figure out a solution where we can and then communicate with the public and say, hey, by the way, you can park for free down at the high school and there's a shuttle bus arriving every 15 minutes to shuttle you up to the mountain. So just some thoughts on that, you know, we obviously welcome the opportunity to continue to participate in these discussions as things move forward.
2:59:16 And let me see if I forgot anything else I wanted to bring up. I think that's it. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else in the room? We're doing public comment. Yeah, this is public comment. So I guess a procedural question. I have Tom Cage was unable to stay. He has some items. Should I be giving this to Rob to go? Because I'm up here in diocese. I just want to make sure how to get his comment in. Because I said I'd make sure his comments were incorporated.
2:59:48 The town clerk would be the best location for that to go. We can interpret there, but he'd like those comments included. No more comments in the room? Are there comments online? Okay, let's wait for the people who are at the meeting first, and then we'll do Tom's comments. Does that make sense? There's some people online. Oh, yeah, no, no, no, I just want to make sure.
3:00:10 You've already been up, Billy. I'd like to back this gentleman as a suggestion. He's working outside the box. He's at high school and stuff like that. I watch town 12 now, and there's a CG woodcutting thing. He's like, you know, for sure, he's got a huge area. And there's a gentleman that's towing. And that's all he needs, a huge area. All right, thank you. I'm sure you'll get a tow truck here and get him to the tow away. All right, we have some comments online.
3:00:38 Patrick, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Can you hear me, counsel? Yes. Thank you very much for your time. So I'd like to first start off thank the MLPD and Public Works for the time that they put into this. Officer Tanaka has been out on the beat a lot. I've seen Sergeant Federer, Officer Hansen, Chief Casabian, and we really appreciate the enforcement effort and what we're trying to do.
3:01:12 Most importantly, as a neighbor, I don't want to villainize our guests. We realize and I think a lot of our residential community that is adjacent to Canyon Lodge, although there has been an uptick in traffic and uptick in events, we have, I think for the most part, been okay with that. There's certainly spillover stuff that happens and people have fun, but when you do have a residential property next to the wonderful mountain,
3:01:42 You know, you do have to expect some stuff. The mountain certainly has been helpful when I've personally called in for cinder trucks or things like that when I've noticed safety issues and, you know, they certainly manage their parking lots, the flat areas very, very well. But I will speak to a couple little things. So we live in a very complex weather environment and bottom line, you know, these signs and things like that, you know,
3:02:11 Mr. Hayes spoke to it. You can't be omnipresent. I look at some of these signs daily for 10 years, and once they're buried, I don't even know exactly where they are. So I certainly go out there and try to help the town. I dig out my fire hydrant. A lot of people do that in town. Some don't. But the main thing is where we live is it's a residential neighborhood. In a residential neighborhood, there's a certain expectation of curb availability and access. And a lot of that is not really just parking up front. I think my owners understand.
3:02:40 They're not really going to have availability parking out front. But what that is, is safety access and getting in and out of your property okay. And then not being okay with seeing four, five, six, seven car pileups or cars getting swiped. And a lot of that is due to the slope. So I'm going to continue with a couple little things really quick. But the recent expectations of guests and desires in the proximity to the mountain, as the chief had alluded to.
3:03:09 Regardless of parking fines and costs, has certainly changed. Parking costs in a lot of other areas have gone up. And, you know, that has become a detriment to the residents. I think also to police service, who I've witnessed dozens of times. I've been told a hundred times, what's the ticket price? No problem, I'm going to go. And I have empathy for those guests. But we do encourage...
3:03:34 And want to remind the community that it is a residential neighborhood next door. And so I wanted to point something out. Bill asked the question. And I presented this last time. On the north side of Lakeview, there's about 130 parking spots on the street. On the south side, they're proposing, I believe they eliminated about 15 spots up to the choke point. They'll call it the choke point. There's about 25 or so cars remaining on the south side that would be in front of Lakeview. The loss of spots on Rainbow.
3:04:02 That we're specifically asking for. We believe, you know, a lot of the mountain employees park, they do as best as they can. They're certainly respectful. There's a lot of guests respectful. But just below our property,
3:04:16 You know, we don't really expect to be able to park in front of our property. Our property is actually really good to park in front of because of the flat spot, but just below 414 Rainbow Lane, there's about 25 spots on the right-hand side of Rainbow that have caused more accidents in bigger years than they can provide parking. And so certain days, I've had pictures, I'd be happy to send 20 or 30 photos I have over the years. I have plenty more. But the loss of parking spots that we're specifically asking for,
3:04:44 Timorarily, or at least to start the conversation, is about 50. Tom, Mr. Hodges is here, so he can certainly speak for the mountain better than I can, but the sheet just provided on a busy day, 17,500 skiers. So, you know, a total amount of parking spots that overflow into Canyon is about 250 spots. That represents probably two to three, four percent of daily skier visits. But the facts are clear, and the chief has pointed out,
3:05:12 The increase of parking tickets and the numbers are there that it's in proportion or proportionate to what Canyon Lodge has. There's probably 40 or 50 parking violations that I deal with in front of my property compared to one in town. And I wouldn't doubt Rainbow Lane has probably had 150 parking violations this year or at least 100 on that small stretch. So there's a few things that we would like to encourage. We would like to encourage the walk, right, and bike plan.
3:05:39 We encourage park carpooling. The South Lake Tahoe stepped up for the community and the residents next to Heavenly. It's very clear on the South Lake Tahoe's website.
3:05:50 They did implement a residential parking area, so that was certainly discussed, even giving the van lifers residential parking. So that's a little bit long off, but what they did do is they offered discounts in the parking lots for people that carpooled. So that was very interesting, and that's a thought that maybe the mountain can do. We certainly encourage removal of the additional parking spots that I just discussed, the 50. That represents...
3:06:14 Of 17,500 skiers. Patrick, you're at your five minutes. Plus than one percent. Can you wrap it up, please? And then we certainly would like to increase ticket prices, and that is basically it. If you have any questions, feel free to fire away. Thank you so much. Thank you. Are there any other comments online, Jamie? No. No. Okay. Would you like to read the comment that was handed in?
3:06:40 Well, unfortunately, this is Tom Cage's notes on what he was going to speak on, so it's not, it's just his notes. So, two-hour parking garage on Main Street, developer parking. Is it the town's job to support? I mean, it's not his. So, just read the first one. I did. Two-hour parking on Main Street. So, people are parking on Main Street, taking the bus up, and he doesn't feel they're being enforced on Main Street. What's the second one? Developer parking.
3:07:05 They're selecting parking spots and just wondering do they have to have as many parking spots as they're taking up through the different developments in town. Is it the town's job to support business and their parking needs? No, but it is the town's job to not negatively input, he must mean impact surrounding business. I think that's a comment by itself. Example, Village, Limelight, and NBC Banner. So I think where he's going is there.
3:07:33 The question is, is the development agreement still in force for the North Village area? Because certain developments have instituted new development and they don't have enough parking for employees and other people are being burdened by their employee parking. Main street parking and taking the shuttle to Main Lodge? That goes back to the comment board. DEA North Village expired? There's a question mark. Town finally provided lot for parking? Recommended Town finally build a parking garage to handle parking.
3:08:03 Okay. Okay. That was related, so. Okay. So there's no more public comments. Staff, can we answer the questions that were brought up during public comment, please? There's a couple things we can address. So providing information through lodging partners and, you know, TOT, I think that's something we can look at as part of our outreach program. The PIC move with our Burley fenders.
3:08:35 I can tell you there have been two occasions that we have directed staff to relocate a vehicle to allow an ambulance to go through by pushing it out of the way with a loader. Fortunately, in both those instances, the vehicle moved on its own before the loader got there, but that does happen. District parking, that is something we are working on, and you can expect a presentation here shortly on something in the North Village, and there is something we have.
3:09:03 An idea for in the commercial district on Main Street that has a lot of moving pieces, but we have a concept that could, if a couple things fall into place, work. So this is something we are looking at as part of a number of walk, bike, ride and mobility hub studies and stuff that's been, you know, direction. It's just finding the opportunities with land. And then I want to address Patrick's comment about residential availability of curb parking.
3:09:32 I decided early and I wasn't going to say this, but I'm going to. The town has an ordinance that prohibits parking on town roads from November to April throughout this town. We intentionally permit parking in certain areas. So there is no residential availability for anyone in this town. We invite this conflict on ourselves by creating these opportunities for people to park in these discrete locations.
3:10:01 It creates a challenge for us to tell one group yes and another group no. So to answer his question, there is no expectation in that area of residential parking because that is actually prohibited by our town code. But I do echo his concerns about access and how the parking constrains access into that area and that's why we are recommending no parking on one-way rainbow because of all the other conflicts.
3:10:30 A little bit more aggressive than what he was representing, but similar situation and similar comments. And I think that was it. There was the crosswalk, and I'm not familiar with that situation. So I think the question was, is the reason we didn't tow that vehicle because we couldn't get a tow? I can't answer that question. I'm not exactly sure. I'm not sure where she went to ask her, but I'm not exactly sure where she's talking about. I think she was talking about at the village. There was a car parked in a...
3:11:00 Handicapped parking spot for an extended vehicle for an extended period of time. And Sergeant Vetter helped get the car moved. But I think her question was, why didn't we tow it? And I guess my initial gut response is probably because there was nowhere to tow it to. We don't have a tow yard. I would assume that that is correct. Yes.
3:11:32 So at the village along that quarter, that is State Highway and the jurisdiction of Caltrans, not the town. Okay, well, Caltrans has told me otherwise they have gone back and forth with moving at Caltrans. It has told me it is the responsibility of the town, and then the town says it's the responsibility of the village. If it's on the village side, and if it's on the other side, it's the responsibility of the town. I mean, of the town going up that way and the village going.
3:12:02 Okay. So there's some, maybe some, maybe you could chat with her out in the hallway when this is done. Yeah, I can just help you out with some of the jurisdictional responsibilities. So that I'm clear, you're talking about the snow from the sidewalk to the street to access the crosswalk. The cross, because I have pictures too. The cross, there was a car park, I don't know if it was at the disabled spot or
3:12:33 In the crosswalk, but you cannot use the crosswalk without going up a snowbank, turning left, and turning right, and then you could go to the proper crosswalk where there's a push button so it lights up in the crosswalk. Okay. He'll chat with you after. Okay. Do you have comments? I have a question about what Hayes just said. You know, it's funny you say that because
3:13:00 Everybody who lives in the rest of town knows that there's no parking on town roads from November to April. And it's just like, I was today years old when I was like, wait, what? So, you know, I assume that that's partly for snow removal to make it more manageable as town. And also, that's why we don't have rural postal delivery, or excuse me, home postal delivery, right? Because I looked into it recently when I saw some comments online. And it's all about...
3:13:30 Making it possible for us to do our jobs. So it's a reasonable question to say I understand why we allow it, but we should ask ourselves the question of how much are we turning ourselves inside out to make it convenient in some places and everybody else it's like oh sorry you live in a snowy town you can't park on the street.
3:13:52 There's a lot of people's houses I can't go to in the winter because they don't have any parking. So we all just hang out in the summer. And then for six months, everyone's kind of just stuck with it. It's worth asking the question of why we work so hard in certain parts of town that makes our jobs as a town that much harder. Do we have more comments or discussion?
3:14:22 You had another question? Oh, yes. He had his question about, like, what his business should do to have a favorable application. I can't give those secrets. Maybe in the hallway. However, the process, the request for proposals, the request for qualification process will outline
3:14:46 What a qualified tow company should respond to. It could include, you know, their availability, number of staff members, the types of equipment, the kind of rates they're interested in. It will spell out what we're looking for a response to. That's kind of a typical process for us to outline the questions and then it's on them to...
3:15:07 Dazzle us with their response. Hey, Hayes, can you go just a little bit deeper about the competitive bidding process that you're describing sort of in detail there? Is that posted in the newspaper? Yeah, so our request for proposals, this will not be like a public contract code competitive bid. There will be different metrics on which we weigh an application or a proposal. We'll have to define that. We'll define that in that document what we're going to grade.
3:15:36 The proposal on. But it gives us a chance to weigh all what we hope at least a couple of possible tow companies based on a number of different, you know, criteria. Yeah, by the way, we can't just decide who we want to do business with. We have to go through a particular process by which we get them out. Will that be noticed in the newspaper or how would someone learn of that? Thank you for that. We have a robust bid platform online that
3:16:05 Distributes this to a number of different locations. We also will publicize it in the local paper. And then typically when it's something that's close to home, we'll actually call local businesses and make sure that they know that it's available. To apply. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Are those all the questions from public comment covered? Okay. I think so. Great. Do you want to ask us specific questions for the answers that you need? Okay. So I think I got good consensus on everything.
3:16:34 Except for ticket prices. And there are three of them. Okay, just, Madam Mayor, I do have some general... Let's hear it. You want to do that now? Sure. Okay, so before we get to that, comment on the ticket prices, I'll save that for when we get to that question. I think, echoing Chris, what you said about the rationale for all this is public safety. Oh, your microphone's not on, John. I'm sorry. So the rationale for all this is public safety.
3:17:08 So that's an important thing with some other things here. I think also that the messaging campaign, the outreach campaign, this must be something that's coordinated with the mountain, with the ski area. It must be coordinated and the outreach done through Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And I say that because the understanding of skiing in California, certainly in Tahoe, is parking. Parking is like that's...
3:17:36 That's the thing you got to think about. So we're piggybacking on something that's already out there, people know about it, but it needs to be in all channels so that if the town was just doing the outreach, someone shows up, they don't know anything about it, and then we're toning cars, that's going to really exacerbate the problem. So I think we should be working with the Mountain and working with MOT to get that out there. Hi, welcome to 21st Century, parking's an issue in Mammoth. A couple of people mentioned walk, bike, ride.
3:18:05 And I know Walk, Bike, Ride has not had any kind of a CEQA programmatic analysis done on it. But if nothing else, if we could track against what's in that, so at least we can be on track to getting to some holistic vision of the various components and how they're going to work together. So we're not doing one-offs. We're not going to one-off over here and one-off over there. It's rolling up and it's adding up to things. I know Patrick mentioned that. I think Tom Hodges, you kind of alluded to that. And that's it. So I'll save. Those are my sort of...
3:18:35 Comments outside that maybe the general conversation. Okay. I'm sorry. I do have one question. Sure. Question. Go ahead. We have a boundary going right now, a destination management plan. As we go down, is that plan going to tackle any of these areas we're discussing? I recognize we're keeping it very confined here, but some of the overlap with town parking and where that plan was going and parking was brought up. Yeah. Is that going to address that down the road? Yeah. So the destination management plan,
3:19:03 Is coming together. There was a very lengthy discussion on options and how we can handle parking and sort of good variety of options really that addressed similar to going into a parking garage where you know how many available sites are on an individual floor, almost a directory around town that tells you where green, yellow, red for parking issues are to alert people coming into town that where they should probably go to have the best success.
3:19:33 So there's a couple of areas where we're obviously looking at this. I'll say for larger scale parking issues and parking facilities, that's another topic that we as staff have decided to sort of separate this slightly from the discussion of the resort parking area because that's really the on-street stuff. I will say there's another whole work plan sort of being analyzed for that, which references what John was just speaking about a minute ago.
3:20:01 That we'll be bringing for council shortly, and that's closer to the village, but probably something that could support, you know, really large-scale parking options that would help the visitors. So to answer your question long-windedly, yes, we have a few areas that we're looking at that in, and, you know, started really trying to keep these issues slightly separate, because they're not, it can't be rolled into one topic of parking. They almost have to be broken down into smaller components so we can have success.
3:20:30 And why I brought that up is because something may come up as we go down the road that's another alternative to help to alleviate some of the challenges, not just the other areas. All right. Any other questions or comments? No? Hayes, what would you like to ask? Yeah, so bringing it all the way back. So starting at the beginning, we received, you know, concerns from the public a couple meetings ago.
3:21:02 Staff was directed to agendize some ideas, solutions, and so forth. At this point, I have consensus, I believe, on working on a signage package that we'll need to go through a process and we'll need to bring that back. Developing a parking map that's internal, but we will find a way to make that a product for others. That's going to take some time to continue working on the towing. But we didn't finish up the conversation on ticket prices.
3:21:30 What about the issue of creating new codes so that we can enforce it through a non-police officer person to... That's one of the three points I have on the pricing. Okay. And again, all these things require coming back resolutions codes. So that's going to take a little bit of work. So first one was the ticket price in the resort zone. I guess I should ask, do you guys want to tease out the resort areas and have that as a separate ticket price?
3:22:00 Compared to the rest of town. Yes. I think that makes sense to me. Okay, so I'm getting consensus on that. Mostly. And just to add into that, I actually thought about doing reverse ways and causing a safety zone because then we could use it in other areas, but I'm not against creating a resort zone, but I was trying to use it down the road and maybe it might be applicable in other locations. And we can work on the name. I don't think we're hung up on the naming convention at this point. I think it's just the idea that we're going to have a separate fee for these areas.
3:22:29 If I may. Go for it. I'm going to just strike right out with some prices here, Hayes. Surprise everybody gets the point. Oh, boy. I believe $300 is not out of line for the resort zone for tickets. I believe that 50% added on to that, which would be $450 for any cars impeding traffic or parked in the other zones you were talking about, and I would make that throughout town.
3:22:59 Town here, if someone is parked and our ticket's $110 or whatever, it's somewhere in that neighborhood now, 50% more would be added on if you're impeding traffic or in a fire hydrant or in a handicapped zone or whatever it is. So I would say I like the part about the 50% step up. However, in the zone, this kind of resort zone we're talking about, I think we should price those tickets at the same rates.
3:23:27 Can I answer a question also? I would love to hear from Chief Casabian and Hayes because you've
3:23:56 Had those interactions with people, like what would it take to get people's attention? I think it would be above $300. Above, you said? Above. So our initial conversation was, you know, $300, because if you look at the impact of $110, you're tripling it to $300, around $300 or so. We haven't seen a decrease at all. We need something that is impactful that will get the attention of illegal parking.
3:24:25 And I wouldn't go below $500 on parking violations in a safety zone or whatever we want to call it. ADA places, I want to bump that up to about $750 versus the $550 of where we're at. So as long as there's no legal ramifications, and that would be an ante question, I think, as far as does the vehicle code allow us to set a price?
3:24:52 Because I do recall when we were talking, when we did this in the past, there was an issue, there was something came up regarding ADA parking and maybe a cap as far as what California puts on it. So I'm not sure if you have anything on that. I don't have that answer right now, but I'll find it for you. Okay, thank you. Thank you. But if it's allowable, I would go up to 750 on ADA violations.
3:25:16 And I would just say that we did this two years ago and thought we were really making a dent and we didn't make a dent. It's continued to get worse. So I think we're not doing this to deter people from causing an inconvenience. As I said, it's a safety issue and you've got to get their attention and be done with this. Like we have to be done with it. It's not fair to the folks who live up by Canyon Lodge. Like that's their home. And if you're not safe in your home, like
3:25:44 That's really us not doing our job. As you said earlier about something else, Councilmember Truax, like it's our job to keep people safe. You know, and Chris, I also want to kind of touch on, I've heard a lot tonight about Lakeview parking and parking on both sides of the roads and what Hayes was saying as far as eliminating one side.
3:26:04 You know, if there was no snow on the roadway and they're parking on both sides of the road where they're allowed to park, it's not a problem. But as the snow drops and as the road narrows and we're still parking on both sides of the road, that's where the issue comes in. And if we eliminate one side of the road and we use the south side as Hayes is talking about, we can even talk about extending down Lakeview.
3:26:26 into where it's currently no parking areas and turning those into parking areas to recoup some of the parking issues that we would have by eliminating the north side. But it's when the snow bags start to close in and people are still parking on both sides of the road. That's where your ingress, egress, public safety issues come into play. Well, and during the big snow, when the road was effectively cleared, still Forest Trail was one lane. I mean, it happens. And so we just have to, like,
3:26:55 Live in the real world. We acknowledge in the whole rest of our town from November to April you can't park. So it does beg the question. So thank you. I just think we have to make everyone understand that we're serious. I guess my comments are I live in the Slopes neighborhood and the last three times that I've been on Rainbow Lane either driving my car or walking my dog
3:27:20 I have had to tell a vehicle you're going the wrong way down a one-way road. So I want to make sure if we're increasing tickets for public safety and everything that we do have really good signage because I know you're saying the signs get stolen. I've walked around my neighborhood with my dog and it's kind of...
3:27:41 Funny to look at all the parking signs because there's signs that say no parking, no parking November to April, parking okay 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., you know, no parking on this side, and it's just very unclear.
3:27:55 And I don't have a problem with giving big tickets to people who are clearly have no regard for our rules and are just, you know, parking in an unsafe spot. But I really don't want to slam like families who are visiting just trying to find a place to put their car when, you know, the lots are all full and it, you know, it looked like it was okay to park here. So I do just want to make sure that we're being very
3:28:22 You know, crystal clear about where people can park and where they cannot park. You know, and I think that, you know, in the meantime, because I think this is going to take some time to put into play, you know, is I don't know if we'd be able to have someone from the mountain, you know, saying you're not allowed to park here in those first spaces or, you know, where the part where you said like up at Lakeview, right at Canyon, that there, you know, you put out.
3:28:48 Cones or signs and people are still parking there. I don't know what is the immediate solution to that. If we need an officer there Saturday morning saying you're not allowed to park here or if a Mountain employee would be threatening enough. Last year we worked with the Mountain. I believe we're doing it this year. I don't know if it's as much, but the Mountain did have their parking staff out there assisting us.
3:29:13 With telling people where they can and cannot park and it seemed to work pretty well. This is going to take some time and I do appreciate the comments as far as the confusion and that's one of our top priorities to eliminate any confusion.
3:29:24 Whatsoever by the sign is. Because I have seen the confusion as well, and I understand what you're saying. Our officers have discretion on writing citations too. They're not just going to go out there and start writing everybody. If it's confusing, it's also confusing to us. And we would write a warning or something like that. So that's how we get around the confusion. If it's confusing to the officer, but it still looks like a violation, they'll write a warning.
3:29:49 But that is the priority, and I'm sure Hayes would say the same thing, is eliminate any type of confusion, especially when you're looking at a $500 parking citation. And I'm okay with the $500. I feel like that, you know, we tripled it the last time. I just think, you know, you're saying that people are like, oh, we'll just all chip in $30, you know. No, I think also $500, I think, and I'm going back to this communications piece, I don't think the signs matter.
3:30:16 The signs on the side of the road, yeah. But if the message goes out through the social media channels, through the Altera channels, through the Mammoth Lakes tourism channels, where you have a huge audience is engaged, hey, $500 parking ticket, Mammoth Lakes. I think it better when we tow the first car. Well, whatever. But I think getting, I mean, this is how the audience is engaging with the destination. And I think getting that message out there will be helpful. But I think people just see other cars doing it and they think this is okay. Like, I mean, the,
3:30:47 Not this winter, but I think last year, you know, people were parked down Canyon Boulevard and there was snow on the road, so you couldn't see the yellow line. I'm walking my dog, walking by people saying, hey, just so you know, like you're parked in the lane, like, you know, and there's just a line of cars doing it all the way down. It's like if you can stop the first couple of fenders, then everybody else is, you know, they're not, it's not like sheep saying like, oh, it's okay to park here. Look, everybody else is parked here. Well, I was on Davidson two weekends ago.
3:31:17 And I'd never seen it before. There were cars all the way down Davidson. But I called a town manager, got to you guys. I came back two hours later, every car had a ticket on it. Sunday morning the next day, there were no cars on Davidson. So it's, I mean, it's a combination of these things. It's effective. I do also think that your comment as far as it...
3:31:38 Putting signs up does not deter people, but I do think if you put signs up that say $500. Let's try. Let's see what happens. They're going to, I think that will resonate. Those are the things also we can point to. Look, see, it says $500 right there. Is everyone okay with $500? $500, but I have my second, going back to the handicapped spots. If we go to $500, I think handicapped should be $1,000. I agree with that. I don't think it should be just $750.
3:32:04 As long as we can do it and there's no legality in the California vehicle code, I'm on board with $1,000 for that. Okay, so a couple things. Remember, this is a suite of policy changes. The signage package, the changing of how we do parking in this area, that is a major policy shift. You know, it's going to result in the loss of parking spaces, but a much clearer picture.
3:32:31 And hopefully we won't have the no parking on town road, but it's okay between this time, you know, trying to manufacture as many spaces as possible. So that policy shift, and then I'm hearing $500 for the regular ticket, $750, a 50% increase to the middle ticket for those egregious non-signed people parking where they shouldn't be, and then $1,000 if it's legal for ADA space violations. Yeah, I mean, I guess I feel like
3:33:01 Impeding the flow of traffic, I could see that as $1,000 too. I mean, that's a public safety. If you're parked in the road, you know, going to cause an accident, I could do that $750 or $1,000. What are the other feelings? I prefer $1,000 only because it's a certain scale difference, but I can go either way in that portion. I mean, what we come back to so many times is it's the enforcement of it. We can set any price, but we've got to make sure we've got tickets out, whether it's on Main Street.
3:33:30 Ticket people, wherever it is, we are enforcing the rules that we put out there because I think part of what we aren't talking about is really having somebody up there on a Saturday that's, if we say it's $500, everybody gets plastered with a $500 ticket. I still like the idea of 50% over whatever the standard ticket is for the... I'm with Bill now. I'd go either way. Yeah, because that can be town-wide regardless of what the price of the ticket is in that section. I just personally get very frustrated when even here people parking.
3:33:59 ADA spots in there on ADA, and I'm on a board for a group that has a lot of people with disabilities, and I see that, and it's very discouraging that people are that intolerant and just don't give a darn. Okay, so I don't have consensus yet. $750 or $1,000 for the middle, for the egregious. For the ADA. Is that what you're talking about? ADA is $1,000. Okay, ADA is $1,000, so Munich's a ticket for impeding the flow of traffic. Yes.
3:34:29 750. 750? 750? 750? Okay. Deal. Which is 50%, so you can do that on the town tickets. Okay. So we would have to do a 50% increase because it's going to be different for people, let's just say, on Manzanita. No, that's town-wide. 750 town-wide. It's town-wide. It was 750, it was one and a half times whatever the base rate is for towns, I think, which we're saying. Yeah, so the 500, just so we're all clear.
3:34:57 Is for the resort zone parking, $750, the greatest violations of impeding the flow of traffic is town-wide. The $1,000 for ADA violations is also town-wide. And that was, the impeding the flow of traffic would include like a UPS driver leaving his, parking his car in the middle of the road to go make a quick delivery or who, what kind of moves? I mean, I just, I feel like in your thing it said like businesses,
3:35:26 Or, you know, people that are parked in the middle. I just want some clarification as to who this would be targeting. So we actually talked about that, and it would target the egregious vehicles that are parked, like, left in the middle of the roadway, and that is what happens. So if you've got Cisco and you've got UPS trying to make their deliveries to our community, we're not, you know, hey, we would approach and tell them, you know, you need to move as soon as you can or you need to move now.
3:35:54 And they would do it. We would get compliance. I would leave that in the discretion of the officer. Their officers aren't going to cite a UPS driver who's trying to make deliveries to our community if it's not agreed. Now, if the UPS driver parks his car and leaves and parks it in the middle of the road?
3:36:09 That's a different story. And those are the people that we're targeting, the ones that just leave their vehicles in the middle of the road because they don't know what to do and they go to their hotel and now we have a car in the middle of the road. Those are the types of vehicles and actions that we would be looking at. And then one follow-up question. Would you be able to cite someone, like if someone's parked in my driveway that I don't know that they've just...
3:36:33 Left their car there. Would you be able to site on private property or would this only be public? No, it would have to be public property. Private property, you would have the ability to get that vehicle towed if we have a tow company that has a place to take vehicles. Okay. Other questions? No, just a statement. It's important that the officers have discretion. A lot of times in the winter, regardless when it is, a service person has to leave their car where normally you wouldn't want to park.
3:37:02 Because I can't service your building if I have to park three blocks away. I can't change your water heater if I've got to park three blocks away. So discretion has to be in it. So that's a good point, Bill. And if that does happen and they do get a citation, they will come in to challenge it. Hey, I was working on this house. I didn't have any place to park. I ran in real quick.
3:37:26 And that would be a challenge citation, as we talked about before, most likely signed off on and disregarded. Depending. Do you need more clarification? No, I think I've got all I need. Thank you for doing the hard work. I know this was a lot.
3:37:47 It was a lot in a short amount of time to try to get something together for you guys to have a good discussion on. So I appreciate you playing along and providing the direction. And we'll be back. It's probably going to be a series of conversations and decisions, final decisions, in order to implement these changes. Okay. You want to say something? Yeah. Yeah.
3:38:08 I just want to say thank you so much because, again, I know that the gentleman from Kenyon Lodge, I think it was 1849, came just a month ago and I realize, like, for the people who are frustrated, a month seems like a long time, but this was a lot of work for you all to figure out in a short amount of time and I just want to say thank you. I think the community, I'd like the community to know how much work this was and how hard it was and we do appreciate it. Thank you. Okay.
3:38:39 Moving right along? All right. So we're moving to item 7.3, Consider Amendments to Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code Chapter 9.32, Tobacco and Related Products. So it was brought to my attention by Lauren Kemeter from Mono County Public Health.
3:39:02 That the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code, Chapter 9.32, Tobacco and Related Products, needed to be updated to reflect the current law, which moved the age to buy tobacco products from 18 to 21. A review of the entire chapter was conducted in addition to making the change to the age, and edits were made by myself, Assistant to the Town Manager, Pam Kobylarz, and Town Attorney, Andy Morris, to enhance clarity of the chapter, including placing all of the definitions in one section.
3:39:31 Adding the word vape to the smoking products and smoking paraphernalia definitions and updating sections regarding flavored tobacco. So tonight, staff recommends that the council waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance amending Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code Chapter 9.32, Tobacco and Related Products. May I ask you a question? I didn't hear about the age changing from 18 to 21. When did that go into effect? Do you know when it went into effect? Yeah. Okay.
3:40:00 And so, like, all the sellers of tobacco products in town are all aware of that now? Yeah, I mean, this was just, like, buried in our code, right? And if you weren't reading it, you didn't know to change it, but it was great that they brought it to our attention so we could do that. All right. Anybody have any questions? December 20th, 2019. 2019? No. Yeah, no, it's, yeah. Okay. Are there any public comments on this item? Let's do this. No.
3:40:30 No public comments? No, no, no. Okay. Are you guys ready for a motion? I'm ready for a motion. Madam Mayor, I'd like to waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance amending Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code 9.32, Tobacco and Related Products. I'll second. Roll call, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Salzer? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truex? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay. 2019. We'll blame COVID for that. It happened during COVID.
3:41:01 Okay. We're going to continue on with our meeting. If any conversations want to go out into the hallway. So we are on item number eight, council member reports. Who would like to go first? I can do that. Oh, there you go, John. Bill. Okay. One thing. On the 27th, speaking of thanking our employees for all they do, I attended the employee appreciation luncheon.
3:41:26 At the eatery, I think that the team that puts this together, this is a great team building. I love to see our employees all come together and interrelate. I think this is huge for morale and a lot of other things, so that was an important thing, and that's what I did. Great. All right. We'll go over to Don. Okay, so as you know, I'm the town's representative on the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District Board.
3:41:54 Currently serving as the chair of the board. That will be over, I think, in the next meeting in March. The Great Basin Air District has been very busy. But if you look at the last agenda, the first seven items of the agenda are closed session. So there's not a lot I can share with you. But perhaps in time, it will be clear what's been going on. But it's been very busy. February 2nd, I joined Councilmember Bubzer for a small,
3:42:25 But, you know, good, pleasant call with Congressman Kiley. The substance of it was basically around the fact of the support that he's provided for public lands and the change, I think, that we all saw, the dawning realization in our representative of, oh, this is really important to these crazy people. So it was a nice call. And Chris, if you could add whatever you need to add to that. We had an ESSRP meeting on Monday. This is such a nice, pleasant, wonderful meeting we had this evening.
3:42:56 Focused on local things that matter to the community, to our visitor audience and all the rest of it. But there is a world out there that is quite problematic. And it's coming from, you know, federal leadership. And one of the things that, you know, I put these meetings together is just the torrent of headlines and news that's coming out of public lands. And I finally had sort of an epiphany about this, that this is an intentional thing.
3:43:26 Someone is doing this. And it goes back to, there's an article in the New York Times by a guy named Ezra Klein, just quoting Steve Bannon and the tactic behind this. If they flood the zone and just keep us completely distracted, they'll be able to do whatever the hell it is that they want to do and we won't have time to respond to it. And that's certainly happening in the federal public lands arena. It's happening all around us and I think we're aware of it.
3:43:54 It's a real challenge. So that was sort of an interesting way to approach all that stuff. And then yesterday I was in Sacramento. The Natural Resources Agency had the first Outdoors for All convening, which is about as close as the state of California gets to outdoor recreation, truly outdoor recreation, very state parks heavy. They had a panel on federal public lands in California. There's not a single federal person on the panel.
3:44:21 We know more about that than they will know in a lifetime. It's just the nature of things. The surprise speaker was the keynote speaker was the first partner, Gavin Newsom's wife, Jennifer Newsom. And she spoke about her relationship to nature and she had a sister that died and she found a lot of sustenance and reassurance in natural settings in nature. Wasn't clear exactly where that was.
3:44:51 But it came around to a very specific articulation of California's view of federal public lands, which is state parks. What they have control over is state parks and all the rest of it. They don't know what to do with it. They don't know how to deal with it. And she sort of quickly pivoted that into political stuff. I'm sure they're getting ready to run for some kind of an office in 2028.
3:45:20 But it's interesting to get that perspective and just understand clearly they just don't really know how to deal with this. Which goes back to big bond measures that come into the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. We can apply for grants and that's about as good as it's going to get for us at least in the short and medium term. So that was it. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'll go because mine will be short.
3:45:43 So I also attended the Employee Appreciation Luncheon, and I just want to again compliment the staff who puts it together. It's delightful and really important. We need to thank our staff early and often, so thanks again. And then the other thing is the conversation that
3:46:02 Councilmember Wentworth was talking about is the Mountain Pact. So, you know, we've been working with the Mountain Pact and our resolution that we did last November, just talking about how important public lands are to the town of Mammoth Lakes, was suggested in concert with a bunch of other communities and municipalities. So the other people on there were, excuse me, Supervisor Hardy Bullock and Supervisor Cindy Gustafson, a staff member was there, the former mayor of town of Truckee,
3:46:32 Dave, who I didn't know before. So anyway, it just gives us a chance to remind the congressman because he did step up and really make an important plea on the House floor about why some of those public lands proposals last year were so catastrophic. And it's nice because he has been here enough that we're able to remind him of the places that we're talking about, like the Lakes Basin and the Sherwin Trailhead. And so he does seem to continue to be committed.
3:47:02 to stopping some of this public land scrap. And I think we should just, you know, make our voices heard on this subject whenever we possibly can because it's not going away. Thank you. All right, Brent. All right, several different things. Particularly from the list of CPT meeting last week, don't ask me to regurgitate with the acronym of that, but we have 30 plus people from the town, county, forest service.
3:47:29 Collaborative planning team. Collaborative planning team. Thank you. Just a couple highlights and some are evident to everybody, but I thought it was interesting that the Indian National Forest is actually for this area allowed to, allowed, that's the term they used, to hire 39 temp employees, 15 for Mammoth this summer. There is a couple of associations, the California Deer Association and White Bark are also happy to backfill a couple positions to help with the need.
3:47:59 For certain items within the forest. The horses that are gathered have been moved to the MODOK National Forest and are doing well down there. What I thought had gone away is with the prices of gold is the new proposal to have 12 drilling sites for gold back in the Hawk Creek area is back on the table and Fred has to make a decision about NEPA by April 1st on that.
3:48:25 Tree permits, there are 800 issued for Christmas tree permits for the area. They don't know, they're going to survey afterwards to see if people cut them off high, low, but they did a more regional versus having to go all the way up to Bridgeport to get Christmas tree. California Department of Fish and Wildlife has got a million dollar reduction in their budget, but they did a lot of reductions in their...
3:48:48 Helicopter work, particularly with bighorn sheep, unfortunately, that's about $350,000 savings with not doing some accounting that they've done in the past, so they're trying not to impact their personnel, but they're trying to save money in different ways. They did warn, though, that if the tariffs keep up, that what we're spending on money for fish is going to go up significantly because we get a lot of our product from Canada, and we may see a significant increase in price from that.
3:49:16 BLM currently has a hiring freeze. They have five vacancies and they are allowed to hire some seasonal for eight to nine months this summer. Forest Service is only staffing two engines at this moment. They do not have a, I'm not sure what the right crew captain or whatever they call it, but they cannot man the third one. So they will still be short a fire engine for the entire summer at this moment. And then I went to a community state skate night last night. Oh, great.
3:49:47 Could you say again what that meeting was with all the different agencies? It's our planning team. And what's that? It's the county. Oh. Yeah. Which is interesting because our last meeting we didn't hold because no one could attend and we had more than 30 people on the call with this meeting. Thank you. Well, mine's going to be really easy. So Eastern Sierra Community Housing has.
3:50:17 Postponed their February meeting until February 17th. So I have nothing to report except that my third grade class, they have read over 2 million words this year. So we're celebrating next week. That's a lot of words. 2 million. 21 kids. They've read over 2 million words. So I'm super proud. What are you having to read your packet? Yes. They read it for me. They summarize it. That's what we do every week. That's nice. All right.
3:50:46 So we are done with Councilmember reports, so we will be moving into closed session. So thank you all so much for coming this evening, and we'll let you know if we have anything to report after closed session. Oh, closed session item. 9.1, Conference with Legal Counsel, Existing Litigation, Paragraph 1 of Subdivision D of Section 54956.9, Name of Case, Assessors to Jesus Uribe, Corona, and Mammoth Lakes Police Department, Case Number 25, UCM62.