TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2024

Parks & Recreation Commission Special meeting

at 14:30

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

167 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:48 Okay, let's call this meeting to order, please. Commissioner Newbury? Commissioner Reeve? Commissioner Wisner? Vice Chair Cheswick is absent. Chair O'Connell? Here. Okay, thank you very much. That brings us to public comments. I see that we have someone here to speak to the commission. Good afternoon. Happy Election Day. Good afternoon.

1:21 Betsy Truax, Vice President of Community Engagement for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I just wanted to mention a couple things, but particularly that the special events funding program, which is administered by Mammoth Lakes Tourism, will open on November 15th at 8 a.m. and will accept applications through 5 o'clock on Friday, December 13th.

1:42 And more information about that program, we have up to $350,000 we can allocate for events in 2025. And there's more information on our industry website, which is visitmammoth.com slash industry.

1:56 And while you are there, we are in the process of, we actually just sent today our annual report to the printer, so that will be arriving in Mammoth Lakes P.O. Boxes. And in the annual report, we will do another resident sentiment survey this year. There's a QR code. So I also appreciate Stu and I have talked about some ways that the town can collaborate to get.

2:19 residents to take that survey. We did it last year as well and the results are on the industry website if you want to check them out but we've really tried to emphasize in the annual report this year just the connection between visitation dollars and great community projects ranging everything from the CRC and the dog park to new sidewalks just

2:41 All the things you're all very familiar with. So I'm really excited to share that piece with the community and also just very excited to be collaborating with your team on community skate nights. Awesome. Well, thank you, Betsy. Did I miss something? For whom are you speaking? Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Oh, okay. Yeah. Congratulations on that new role. Yeah, thank you. I started July 1, so, yeah. May they be worthy of you.

3:08 Well, I'm very pleased to be there, so very exciting to continue to work with you all. Thank you. Excellent. Thank you very much. Okay. Thank you. Stu, that brings us to item 3.1, the CRC closeout report. Yeah, I'll be brief and then I'll hand it over to Hayes, who has a presentation. He'll walk you through a little bit revised and abbreviated from the information in your packet. So Hayes will walk you through that. But we presented this to Council on October 2nd.

3:43 So that included the closeout report, and then council also approved phase two of the project, which Hayes will walk through as well, and it can also give you a quick update on the contractor and his work to date, and then when that work might be complete. Thanks, Stu. Thanks for coming. Yeah, as Stu said, we gave this presentation about a month ago. I'm going to give a truncated version, give you guys an opportunity to ask any questions.

4:09 I suspect you all watched that Town Council meeting and took notes on the presentation and this is just all remedial at this point. So by way of background and a little trip down memory lane, we started working on this project in October of 2015. That's when the Town Council authorized the preliminary designs and environmental review for this project nine years ago. And then we contracted the following year, the following January, with HMC Architects.

4:37 We certified the EIR in May of 2017. We did the first round of bidding in March of 2018. And then we rejected those bids in May of 2018 because it was substantially more expensive. We bid that steel structure right when the steel tariff spiked and just blew the budget. If I could just interject quickly, what was the bidded price again? I forget.

5:04 I want to say it was 21 million, right around there. I could get you that exact number. I don't need it. I was just curious. Yes. And I think at that time we had a planned budget of like 12. Yeah. It was allocated, so significantly over. The indoor-outdoor one, remember? Yeah. Which we'll talk about here in a second. So we went back to the drawing board with a phased approach.

5:30 And decided to move forward with a sprung structure in June of 2019. In March of 2020, we did the second bid. That was with the mezzanine. I'll kind of talk through some of the things that were eliminated here in a minute. We rejected those bids in June of 2020, went out to bid for the third time in August of 2020, and awarded a contract finally in February of 2021.

5:55 We had a long road to just get to the design, and we went through so many different iterations, and I've just got a couple images here. I mean, we spent a lot of time initially just figuring out where to place the building. Months spent just how to locate it, orientation, impacts to the neighborhood. We did massing studies, kind of looking at the height of the building, how it was going to look, you know, next to the neighbors and so forth. Like I mentioned, this was an open-air

6:24 building, the first go-around, which in hindsight would have been a terrible idea. So we were somewhat fortunate the price was really high because we would have probably ended up enclosing this later. But we had looked at just a rink and a roof, I think was the moniker at the time. Here are a couple images from that. I have to admit it was a good looking building. And big, big open entrance on the front which would have just filled with snow. So that would have been fun.

6:58 But then we transitioned to a sprung structure, and now looking back, that was the right building for the site, the right performing building. And we had a couple of grandiose ideas for the sprung structure. Start with a mezzanine and community rooms. Ultimately, we had to eliminate a few of those. Our first phase ultimately ended up being just over 40,000 square feet, the Olympic rank.

7:26 The mechanical enclosure, the locker rooms, the public restrooms, storage areas, the exterior patio, and then we added on the parking lot, transit shelter, EV charging as a mobility hub. That was tacked on but was made part of that first space, but an additional contribution from town council. What we eliminated was the mezzanine viewing, the concession space, the office spaces, elevated bleachers, the exterior sign, the community room.

7:55 The Mobility Hub, like I said, we did put that back in. And there was a number of other smaller value engineering decisions that were made to get the cost down to the budget Town Council gave us to perform to. Now, we'll talk later about Phase 2 because there's obviously a desire to add a lot of these components back in. And we have some of them underway and some of them are, you know, in the future. On the construction side, we broke ground in April of 2021.

8:26 And by that fall they had completed the slab. The following spring they began installation of sprung structure and they were working on the interior by that fall. There was an original completion date for the contractor of January 2023, January 9th to be exact. However, he was incomplete and work continued through that following summer.

8:50 By that fall, we had a big push. The contractor got the building into a state where we could open, not complete, but we could get it open. And on November 24th of 2023, we had Ice Friday and we opened to the public. The contractor continued working on the building through that month, the next month. We filed a notice of completion in January 2024, earlier this year.

9:18 Accepting a pretty substantial punch list from that. And the contractor continued to work on that punch list up until recently, which I'll talk about here in a minute. Funding. And I put everything in my funding conversations. This is all him. I didn't want there to be any confusion about where the money came from, how it was spent. Anybody can draw their own conclusions or make their own interpretations, but this is nine years worth of spending.

9:47 So every dollar was accounted for, all the revenue sources and how we spent it. But you can see here the large majority was Measure R, 57%, followed by Measure U at 18% and the general fund at 20%. Where we spent the money, the big ticket items were the construction contract and the sprung structure, but we accounted for everything from, you know, the scoreboard.

10:18 The boards, the train that we, the train chiller, we bought that and supplied that. How much money we spent on architecture, engineering, legal fees, you name it, every dollar was accounted for and is included in the overall cost. At the time, and I left this slide the same and I'll walk through, this was approved by town council ultimately.

10:42 But at the time we gave this presentation, the funding was at $16,959,862. And that's all the costs. We were still holding and are still holding contract retention. We're still in the process of settling out with the contractor. But a settlement of $800,000 contract deduction was approved by town council. That takes our closeout budget to

11:11 17,115,240,000. Town Council approved that budget gap and those funding sources of $155,378 to close the gap, to close the project. And we still had some remaining work. So like I mentioned, the contractor was still working on the punch list, but as part of the closeout, we basically cut him loose and are working with our phase two contractor to complete some of these.

11:37 elements that we believe need to be done to make the building perform. We felt it was appropriate to keep that in the phase one bucket so there was a clean break between all the work done before we started phase two. So the council also approved that additional $150,000 under phase one, bringing the total gap to $305,000 and a final dollar amount all in for nine years worth of work including that incomplete work.

12:04 $17,265,240. So if someone wants to write an article and say how much the first phase of the CRC costs, that's the dollar amount. That's all in. With the mobility off. With the mobility off. That's everything we've spent to date. And we have all those finances broken down to any elements. So if anybody wants to know how much each discrete piece costs, we can give that to them. And like I said, so the town council authorized the town manager to complete the settlement agreement.

12:34 That is still ongoing. That hasn't been executed. They also authorized the town manager to use capital reserves to close out this phase. So it's fully funded and we are now kind of basically moving past phase one. So I'll stop there before we go on to phase two and see if you guys have any questions. Any questions, commissioners? No. No, not at this point. So what Stu was saying is when we

13:11 Move forward with the phase one construction contract. Because the budget was so tight, we did not have a contingency. No contingency authorized, which is, we always put in 10% and allocate 10%. You'll see that in our award. But at that time, working with Dan, the money just wasn't there. So we didn't have any additional funding to work from. When you look at a $17 million project and we needed $155,000 to close out, you can run the numbers and that percentage is a fraction.

13:41 We typically have 10% available to staff to deal with change orders and the unknown and so forth. Had we had that, we wouldn't have had any of these conversations about needing additional funding. We would have been with the budget, no matter how you play the numbers. So while, yeah, that's a big number and it was a huge commitment from the town to this project, we feel pretty good about how those monies were spent and how we manage them.

14:11 And only 20% came from the general fund. Yeah. Which is important, I think, to note. Yeah, Measure U was the mobility hub. It's kind of that transit mobility area, so that was a good fit. Yeah, so a really good use of, like, a variety of funds from all the town sources. So, yeah, but very nominal use of that discretionary money, I think, was the point. And Measure R, which rightly so, you know, was the primary funding source. Right.

14:38 I think the community got a lot of great value and certainly got their money's worth out of the engineering department as well for all their work. When you kind of talk about the contingency and how tight they were to that budget, I mean, they did an extraordinary job and I know Hayes lost a lot of sleepless. Hair. Night's hair. I think I'll say hair. And really the entire team to pull that together because that really was it.

14:59 A heavy lint, as we all know. Yeah, I mean, Stu and I worked on that. I mean, we started in 2015, but you and I were working on this well before that. I mean, it's well over, and Betsy, I mean, well over 10 years. 10 plus years, yeah, and the commission, yeah. So it's very much a celebratory event. I mean, that's why we brought it back to you today, because we just wanted to kind of get that closure of the project. Right. And we spent an inordinate amount of time as a commission. Yeah. And it's been a long meeting. A lot of hearings. Yeah. And there's been a lot of questions.

15:29 I'll say a little bit of misinformation with the public out there and so we thought it was appropriate to bring this forward and just lay it all out. Here are the facts. So moving on, turning that page to phase two. So this contract was awarded and we are working on it right now and some of these elements have been completed. The town council approved the plans, they approved the budget, they approved

15:57 Basically, the ability to award the contract and execute the contract and so forth. So that all happened at the same meeting on October 2nd. We went from the same thing, talking about phase one, turn the page, working on phase two. What's included? So the construction contract has roofing for the mechanical structure. We had value engineered out that roofing. That's already done. So we're ecstatic to not have to deal with icing issues inside of that structure.

16:26 Decking and access improvements for the elevated viewing and bleachers. So that work is underway. It's in shop drawings right now with an intent to hopefully pour that slab in between Thanksgiving and Christmas. The exterior facade that was value engineered out, I'm calling it a sign now. I think it's more appropriate. That's in shops right now. We've seen the steel drawings. And then there's a significant amount of electrical HVAC and sprinkler connections that need to occur to tie in the

16:55 Office spaces. Now, these elements, like the flooring, have already been completed and paid for. Those were previously approved by Town Council. The office furniture and the office spaces were previously approved by Town Council, and that's already moving forward with an anticipated delivery date of January 5th. And that was kind of part of the, it was a measure R allocation of, I think, just 700 and something thousand, and then council matched that with 300. So we had a working budget of a million.

17:25 Which is where the flooring office space was already kind of occurring. And then the action that council took, which is what Hayes is walking through, was the balance of that work. And then exterior lighting. So we'd previously purchased the lights under the Mobility Hub contract. We had our new contractors installing the foundations, and I believe that work's happening right now.

17:47 So we'll have lighting up here shortly. That's in the parking lot. In the parking lot lighting, exterior lighting. Can you walk or can you drive around the parking lot? No, it's pretty dark. Hopefully dark. I just noticed it last night. Daylight savings, we're getting the lighting out there. He's driving past, there's a lot of cars over there, but it's pitch black. Hopefully within a week or two we'll have our lighting up. And it's all solar lighting, so there's no wiring, we just need to get the foundations in. We already have the lights, they're down at the shop.

18:13 Same lights that we use, solar lights that are on our multi-use paths, like the same kind. And then they approved the purchase of the bleachers, the netting. We are going to provide the lift that will be owner furnished. Like I mentioned, the exterior lighting and some sound deadening for the chiller unit. It's a little, we are now under our threshold for noise, but it's still pretty obnoxious. And so we're, we've spent,

18:41 About $30,000 on sound deadening to bring that high-pitched wind down a bit. So what's that involve? Wrapping some of the components in the sound deadening product. Train actually has a product available. It's quite a flame. Yeah. Yeah. The screw compressor is pretty high-pitched noise. You know, we're under the threshold for code, but that's not being a good neighbor. So we believe it's the right thing to do. You just wrap it, basically kind of sound insulation blankets on the screw compressors and everything.

19:11 In the unit itself. And then they completed also, if you've been out there, they've actually put the gates on the end of that structure as well. So we actually have gates with a solid wall around that mechanical enclosure. So that actually added a lot to that sound effect. It was fully open last year. And we'll see how this plays out. We've got other plans too. If it's not enough, then we've got some alternatives, but we want to be good neighbors.

19:36 So what did that look like financially? So the construction contract was just under a million dollars for those elements. $184,000 for flooring. The dirt offices were $327,000, and we'll go through what the scope of that here in a minute. Furniture was another $44,000. We spent about $5,000 on some new concession counters. I mentioned the parking lot lighting, which was $30K, actually came in at $27,500. Contingency, really important, $117,000.

20:06 And then the purchase of these elements, the bleachers, the netting and so forth, we've got a budget for all this. And all these financials were approved by Town Council. That's good. So just a couple of renderings. When you take the offices out, you know, the other material costs here, you know, with the exception of the contingency, I mean, it's not that dramatic, but the construction contract cost seems high relative to those much less material.

20:36 You know, costs. Yeah, yeah, it's definitely skewed, and I think it's really related to that elevated viewing platform. That is not a cheap build with the structural elements and the staircases and the concrete work and so forth. So that's above the locker rooms, right? Yeah. Okay. And they've got to move a lot of the HVAC that's up there already, a lot of that venting in the lines, because they're not going to get pushed back for the bleachers. So when the original contractor was in there, just put it pretty much anywhere.

21:06 So we've had a few challenges in that regard. So there's a little bit of that work to do. And then, you know, looking at the bleachers and netting, that's all we're getting kind of reconfirmed right now. We're kind of back into kind of looking more for an elevated bleacher. The ones we spec'd out originally, which are these ones, were a little bit more of a low rise. So the third and fourth row didn't give you some great viewing area. So now we've gone back to three, but increased the pitch.

21:31 And then made a bit more of a custom with railing, just for safety on the back there as well, with kids and everything. So they're going to cost us a little bit more, but you'll actually get, from a net seating point of view, you'll get every seat to count. So the seating capacity goes from 220 to 150, but everybody can kind of sit and see in the eyes, which is a big difference. And some other little tweaks as well that we'll get into.

21:55 So just a couple renderings. So remember the sign, like I mentioned, this steel structure is in shops, and we hope to have that approved here shortly from the structural engineer. The elevated staircase, and I broke this up with, you know, this is Hayes' Arts and Crafts, just to kind of demonstrate to town council the different spaces, but you guys are a lot more familiar with what the plan is to have the elevated viewing platform and AEA lift. And it's got a little back of house area that's in red where we can

22:24 Keep our mechanical and so forth and make changes if we need to in years to come. Okay, so that kind of explains it. I thought we were just putting the bleachers on top of the structure that was there. Oh, no, we value engineered all the structural elements to try to bring that original contract cost down and so now we're adding it back which is, it turns out, more expensive than had we just done it in the first place but, you know, that's what the budget allowed for at that time. Right.

22:52 This is an image you guys have all been inside, you've seen all the great flooring, it's wonderful, it's an incredible improvement to the facility. That really should have been phase one, but you know, how do you operate an ice rink without rubber flooring, I don't know, but anyway, we made it work. We did. We made it work, the scene did great. And these are just a couple images of the new offices, so we've got kind of a public counter built in, we've got Kat's office, and another storage.

23:22 building slash locker room, so that'll be for co-ed sports, just an additional space, Stu's birthday room, this'll go down towards the west side of the building at the end of the locker rooms. An interesting thing here that like the original plan on phase two, we actually had a building there that was kind of originally tagged as like a referee room slash extra locker room.

23:46 Again, it got phased out from value engineering, and now we're obviously trying to put it back again, but Hayes will go back one more. So this image on the bottom left there, so this will be kind of the hub for Parks and Rec. I think we've talked about that all the time. So when you walk into that entrance, on your right, once we get the spaces here, when you walk in, you can kind of see the entrance on the top right. You'll go in that first door, and on your right, that's where all the skate.

24:12 Rental Area Office will be, and on the left we'll have that different kind of layout. And then on the left here, on that blue space, you can kind of see we have a lower ADA counter, a regular counter and a TV. That's where you'll have kind of parks and rec. So that'll be where you'll go for non-ice or summer related kind of questions, right? So if you come and sign up and want to rent the community center, which we do a lot of, you know, a lot of Hispanic speakers, you know, just don't do it online.

24:40 They can now kind of walk in and get it done quite easily, which is great. Renting facilities, summer camp, registration, or whatever it might be, that's really that purpose. And then secondarily, now we actually have a staff on site, you know, managing and supervising and running that building at the moment. As you know, we're all over here and, you know, our largest facility with all our guests are over there. You know, it just doesn't work. So, and then this is a modular design. So, again...

25:04 It can come in and come out and get moved around to some extent, which we think has a value in that building from a multi-use perspective. And then this is also the same company that Hayes and his team were working on for the new Civic Center. So we're kind of doing a little beta test here. Where are the concessions going? Like where you have the current desk?

25:26 Yeah. Where is that on? I don't see that on here. No concession. So, you know, we made that decision in this phase to eliminate that just because of a space saving, you know, once we started to, you know, when you've been in there, run the sizes and the space, the original design in phase two would have basically pushed all the public spaces, you know, away from the rink and made it, I think, a little bit prohibitive for the public when we're running 200 plus, you know, people with skate sessions.

25:53 Right. So we would call it just kind of the skate rental area, you know, where the skate racks will be, and that's just kind of on the first two bays on the top there of that diagram in the right-hand corner. So pretty much opposite where they are now. So we're just going to shift all the skate racks over, all the benches over, we've got new benches coming. And then the lobby restroom wall where the racks are currently, we get the two big TVs and kind of those lounge areas, so a little different kind of seating there.

26:22 And then the concessions from the food point of view is Luna's, you know, Capybara food truck. Right, right, right. Outside. And then Kat's working on kind of some, you know, food options indoors and outdoors, those type of things. And we've got some, a new vending machine provider that will bring in what, two or three vending machines, Kat, hopefully? Two to start. Two to start, yeah.

26:47 The problem with the vending machines is that they need to be plugged directly into an outlet, so that's something that goes along with this. Phase two is finding some more outlets that we can install for extra vending machines, so right now you'll see two new ones are going to go in soon, shortly, and that might expand later as we find more outlets.

27:08 Maybe you just get some vintage ones where you like crank on something and it opens the door. Yeah. No electricity. They will require coins though. Not that many people carry coins anymore unfortunately. So that's the last of my images for kind of the phase two improvements. Happy to answer your questions but work is well on its way. It's going to take a few months because we're coordinating and we don't want to impact operations too much.

27:38 There's work going on today with exterior lighting, there's some work going on tomorrow with the drains, trying to get the concrete in, stuff some shop drying. So, I mean, overall, we're probably looking at an early spring completion, but it's a local contractor, a local guy, and it's been great to work with so far. And it's, you know, we're excited to see what future phases Stu comes up with for us to construct. But anyway.

28:04 Slash cat. Slash cat. So anyway, like I said, happy to answer your questions, Mammoth. So that slab above the locker room is November to December, somewhere in there? I mean, that's the hope? Yeah, currently projected. A couple pieces are in shop drawings with the steel fabricator. There's some components that need to be made off-site. And so we're targeting a time frame in between Thanksgiving and Christmas to pour that slab. But the seating and I think everything else.

28:32 Commission will be probably end of January, February. By the time the seats are up there and we have the ADA lift and all the access. The staircases have to be procured, go through the whole process, installed. There's puddings that are associated with those. There's a very robust railing system that needs to be installed. We need to take delivery of our lift. There's a whole bunch of electrical components and structural elements that need to be associated with that. So it's pretty complex. So it's going to take some time.

29:00 And then, like I said, we don't want to impact, you know, the public's use of the building, so there's a little bit of coordination that goes on there. But we're on good pace and things are getting done. We expect sometime in spring we'll be done. Not to beat a dead horse, but they just threw the top of the locker room to just threw the HVAC or whatever it was. Let's leave it alone. Yeah. Could have been better. Never mind. We have a plan forward. We have a path forward. I'll just leave it at that.

29:30 We're moving on. Yeah, very exciting. I think Kat's team and everybody and I think the community really sees the value in these Phase 2 improvements, which are really kind of where we designed the original building, you know, with all those spaces. So I think it greatly enhanced the operations, certainly. You know, I think that's what we're trying to get to first, you know, the function, the operation, and then the enhancement for the public. So we're getting there. It's pretty exciting. Any questions, Commissioner Weisner? No.

30:00 Do you need any actions from us? No, just wanted to, you know, take a moment to walk you through our presentation, give you an opportunity to ask any questions and kind of let you know where we're at with closing out phase one in that settlement and moving forward with phase two and the future improvements. What to expect over the season. So when will you be doing the work while operations are ongoing? It kind of depends. It's like they're working in the parking lot now, I believe. That's not an impact.

30:31 Tomorrow they're going to be working on some bathroom drains, I believe. And then we just coordinate, you know, on a regular basis as to what the needs of the building, the users and so forth with construction. So right now, because we are hosting a lot of Southern California Amateur Hockey Association games, along with the LA Kings High School League hockey games,

30:54 We really need those locker rooms over weekends. But typically we don't need them as much during the week. So we can have some flexibility with closing off locker rooms and letting them work in locker rooms. Same thing as we transition out of hosting a lot of these games, which are sort of finish up mid-December. You know, outside of busy public skate sessions, we can close off the...

31:18 Public restrooms in the main lobby, and we can direct people towards the locker rooms to use those restrooms. So there's ways that we can be flexible and accommodate, and the contract has been very accommodating with our schedule at the moment. So hopefully we'll just keep moving forward, working hand in hand. So you can be working while there's people in the building. Yeah. And what's the estimated time of completion? I mean, I know you never want to really say such a thing. We're targeting kind of, you know,

31:47 Mid-Spring, sometime in spring. We'll have to see when materials are delivered and what kind of the timing with all the other activities going on. So I don't want to set a hard date because we really, we're being very flexible with the contractor. We've been very transparent about our schedules and needs and, you know, accommodating him and being respectful to the schedule on both sides. Right. And so exterior work is limited to the sign.

32:13 And also work around the chiller or the mechanical. Yeah, and that work is complete. So the new roof is on, it's done. They're working on the foundations for the lighting like we talked about. And then it's really the sign, which could go in middle of winter as long as it's not a storm cycle. Right, right. Rolling wind? Sorry? Anytime, really.

32:35 Should be nice. Yeah. Yeah, we're excited to get it done. It's kind of like a picture frame. It's going to give it a facelift. Yeah. It would just be a real pleasant. I skated last week. The ice is nice. Excellent. Well, we've got the level ice system running. Yeah, Andrew was telling me about that. It's three winters. That's pretty cool. You know, before moving on to the next item on the agenda here,

33:00 Can you, Kat, just kind of bring us up to speed on what's going on? I mean, you mentioned briefly the youth activities that are going on in there. Could you just give us a little report on that? Maybe before that. I have a hard stop in like two minutes. I just want to... Well, you can be excused. I just want to make sure I've answered all your questions. Yeah, I think you have. Thank you very much. Thank you. Sorry to run. Yeah, great work. Hey, Hayes. Nice work, Hayes. Ten years of your life. Yeah. Yes.

33:27 It's a wonderful accomplishment. It is a good legacy, right? It's a great, great product for the community. And with no contingency. That's impressive. That's scary. That would be sleepless nights.

33:54 So what I was referring to before was the official youth hockey games that we're now hosting. So when we had the outdoor rink, we couldn't really host any games because of the inconsistency of the weather. We couldn't commit to having teams travel to Mammoth and spending a fortune on accommodation and travel and then not be able to play their games. If you remember last year, we started hosting some of the LA Kings High School Hockey League games. So that's the Bishop Broncos play in that.

34:22 Competition. And then this year, our Mammoth Lakes Youth Hockey for the first time joined SCAHA, so Southern California Association, or Amateur Hockey Association, as a travel team. So we have one team in, one team, one squirt team, which is the 10 and under, one peewee team, which is 12 and under, and one bantam team, which is 14 and under. So because they play in SCAHA, the idea is that you have eight.

34:48 You host eight home games and you play eight travel games. SCAHA have been great working scheduling-wise with them, so we requested that we host all of our home games in October, November and early December. That way those teams traveling up from Southern California aren't going to be impeded by snow or anything like that.

35:08 It's also a great time to have them in town. Sometimes I see some of the lodging at the moment and I'm pretty confident that most of those numbers are from the three or four hockey teams that we have in town each weekend right now playing at the rink. So it's affordable pricing for them to come up here.

35:24 Having said that, it means that Mammoth Lakes hockey players come December will spend the next two months traveling down to L.A. most weekends to play games. So right now we have a really jam-packed schedule of hosting high school and then the Skaha youth games every weekend and that will end mid-December and then we'll see our teams travel down south and play for the rest of the season at Southern Rinks. What are the hours of those games?

35:51 When does it begin, like on a Saturday? So you can jump on our website. There is a big banner there advertising all of the games that we have on. So for example, this weekend, we start games at 2 p.m. on Saturday and they basically run through until Saturday night. And then Sunday morning as well, we start at 8 a.m. and they run through until lunchtime. These game times are posted on the website. And it's open to the public. Open to the public, yeah. We've had great attendance right now. You know, obviously the families of...

36:21 Youth hockey players are there, but we're starting to see a lot of other people that are not necessarily affiliated with youth hockey coming to watch the games, you know, particularly the Bantam and the high school games are pretty good hockey to watch. So I certainly suggest all of you coming in and take a look. It's a great atmosphere in there. I bet. And do we have public skating in the morning on Saturdays and the afternoon on Sundays? So typically that public skating goes around that schedule for...

36:48 The youth hockey games. So we try to get some in in the morning and some in in the evening, just depending on how many games we're hosting that weekend. Some weekends we just have, you know, two games a day. Other weekends we have four games a day. It just depends on the schedule that we got from SCAHA. Okay. Very good. Is there any public comment on this agenda item? No. Okay. All right. So let's move on to the next item on the agenda. This is an important one to discuss the...

37:18 Fee Schedule Recommendations for this upcoming year, 2025-2026. Thank you, Chair, and thank you for being also accommodating this extra meeting. I know we try to commit to every meeting every two months, but here we are, and I think this is that kind of perfect example why this kind of works.

37:41 You know, and you can kind of try to get most of your work done every two months that, you know, here's a situation that just gives you a bit more time. You can just solely focus on, you know, one item. And then we took the opportunity to kind of put in the CRC closeout phase two because otherwise we'd be waiting till December. And again, you know, it's a little bit late. So I think for this reason it works really well. So, yeah, thank you for sharing your day with us on election day. So the staff report that we have for you is kind of an evolution from the previous version. Right.

38:12 We went through, I think, a pretty good presentation. I know Ben was in Switzerland in the middle of the night, but I think we had an opportunity to present, you know, the issues, you know, that we kind of addressed over the last several months. So this staff report is kind of really packaged into, you know, option A, B or C. I think we kind of realised last time, you know, the direction, the concerns, a lot of the impacts that not only we've kind of addressed, but all the staff have kind of...

38:41 Continue to kind of dig into, which we've got some little more information here on it as well. So in the essence of kind of expediency, we're going to present option A, option B, option C. You can see here we'll do that in recommendation one. We'll by motion, you know, recommend either one of those motions or a combination of, or you can package them up, you know, whatever, you know, you really prefer. It's your recommendation that goes to council.

39:06 And then we can spend that little bit of time finalising those recommendations, any narrative that you'd like to add, or you can kind of present that verbally to Town Council on the 20th of November during that workshop. Because the workshop is primarily this item, if that makes sense, right? So really the essence today is to make sure from the last meeting we're very familiar with the issues, Council direction to actually institute a resident and non-resident fee schedule.

39:35 And then as we've got now an opportunity through Council's action to allow us to kind of sell that discounted pass, you know, is one of these options more favorable over the other? And then to provide that recommendation to Council. So any questions so far? No, not from me. Other commissioners? Not so far. Okay, good. Maybe out of town. On the 20th? Okay. We just want to make sure we'll capture any comments that you have. So,

40:07 So the staff, I'm just going to kind of read through just the highlights of this analysis discussion because this is kind of a pertinent item that we kind of discovered here. So you can kind of see here we went through the main ideas in October 1 and we kind of prefaced that with a conversation that we've been having with the Forest Service about what they kind of call preferential pricing. And you can kind of see here we included a little bit on that in this staff report and basically in Kat's correspondence to Chris and you can jump in any time.

40:37 They don't really have, well, they clearly don't have any preferred pricing or preferential pricing, i.e. being resident, non-resident, for kind of outfitting and guiding services. So when we kind of originally presented this to them, they were kind of scratching their heads saying, well, that's not really consistent with the use permit and not really consistent with the policies that they have currently.

41:04 So if it's something we wanted to pursue with the Forest Service, it would require action and discretion by the Mammoth Ranger District, Mammoth Ranger of the Mono County District. So Mammoth Lakes Ranger District. There goes another 10 years. So it's not like it can't be done, but I think what... Pause actually on that. Pause.

41:27 I literally received this email at 2.47pm this afternoon and they did some more digging. They have now discovered that there is a non-discrimination clause in the permit that mentions activities are open to the general public on an equal basis without regard to any non-merit.

41:47 So it was their understanding that differential pricing, being a resident versus being a visitor would not be a merit-based factor. So therefore they would not allow differential pricing of that nature under our permit with the Forest Service. So that would affect any of our summer camps because all of our summer camps take place on Forest Service land. They're all permitted. And then a number of our other activities.

42:15 Shady Rest Park, remembering, is on a permit from the Forest Service, so anything that would take place there could not have that preferential pricing. No summer camps, some of our after-school programs. Yeah, so that's the latest that we have from the Forest Service. That's no surprise. I mean, I can't imagine they'd have a different point of view. So that's good. That works into the analysis here. Yeah, so it does kind of lead us in a specific direction.

42:49 You know, then you could say, well, if we still wanted to institute a resident, non-resident fee that would have to occur on non, you know, public lands, you know, with a use permit. And I... Make them go off-site, then sign them up, then they can go off-site. Well, yeah, it wouldn't... Yeah, so for a summer camp program...

43:08 Wouldn't be applicable, but you know, we could. We would be limited to doing all of our summer camps on town-owned property, i.e. the Community Recreation Center, which might impact our mountain biking camps, our climbing camps, our skateboarding camps, our nature camps, essentially all of our camps. Is the skate park on federal land? No, town-owned land. Okay. But we do use the Shady Rare Skate Park for a lot of our introductory skateboard programs. I didn't know that. Yep. So.

43:38 Can't say it can't be done. We just have to relocate. Right. Well, we can get to that as we get into option B here. Yeah. So thanks for that. That was good. It saved me a couple of minutes of narrative underway. So with Commissioner's direction here, I'll kind of walk you through option A, which I think really hasn't changed from the presentation last month on October 1st. What it has changed, though, is just some updated numbers here.

44:08 You know, the way we approached this was kind of through a filter of kind of supply and demand. So, you know, if you can kind of see here where we have capacity, where we have demand. So we were kind of looking at it from that perspective. No, no, Doug's not here right now, but Commissioner Wisner brought up a point. You know, we'd use summer camps, for instance. There's an opportunity here. We're currently limited to one camp, minimum one, well, let's not limit it, but we try to make sure at least one child gets one camp per summer.

44:37 You know, there's an inclusion here to say we can actually max it, max it out at three camps per child for summer. You know, we had a couple of kids that had seven camps, you know, six camps, four camps. So if we're able to kind of limit to one maximum of three, that would open up, you know, I think Doug said additional 70-something spaces for kids to get in the camp. Again, just spreading that diversity, right? So really option A, when you look at the option summary, you know, speaks to access and availability.

45:06 You know, I think that's the platform that we're coming from with Parks and Recreation, right? We just want to make sure we're accessible and provide that availability for all. The affordability, which is really council's concern, which is our understanding, comes through some, I think, really targeted pricing options, and that's kind of been the limited winter skate membership, and we also introduced a winter play pass. There were some older numbers in here that I just kind of put in.

45:34 At 488 passes. As of today, we're at 555 passes. So that's over 405 public passes, roughly, plus or minus. And 150 plus or minus through our youth hockey program. So I think that was where it received. Right. So I think it really proves the point without kind of getting into a...

45:59 Kind of say, not, wouldn't call it discriminatory, but really a kind of preferential kind of pricing model, you know, basically saying in person for that entire month, anybody can come up and purchase that membership and get these benefits for that discounted price, and I think it worked really well. So you can see here the numbers last year, 145, 120 of those with youth, you know, youth hockey team. So we only sold 25 to kind of the general public, and this year we sold 405.

46:27 So, you know, it's a big difference. Yeah. So, yeah, it's 300 plus percent, right? It's staggering. Yeah. So we're really excited, I think, with that program. So that kind of runs you through, I think, that option. I think we're all familiar with that. Looking ahead, where would this go for next year as we get into the fee schedule again? We would look at kind of that summer play membership, which would be what it's called. We rolled it out last year, so that would be the pool and the rec zone pass.

46:57 Membership. See where that goes. And then the winter play pass that we had, which really kind of packaged in kind of drop-in hockey, stick time hockey, curling, you know, those type of things with different pricing, we can kind of look at rolling something like that together too, if that makes sense. But for right now, summer would look like a, you know, 50% discounted summer play membership, you know, with that appropriate pricing. Again, available to all in person. So I think that works well.

47:26 So that's kind of option A. I don't know if we need to spend any more time on that. I think it's pretty clear. I don't think so. Okay. No questions. Respectful of time. Option B is, as we've spelled out, the resident, non-resident fee schedule. And as we heard from the Forest Service, we're clear, we are a little clearer now on the preferential slash non-discrimination clause and the difficulty of implementing something like that across the breadth of our programming. Right.

47:57 We can't, we're not going to say it can't be done, but it would be very limited and only for a few products and services, right? So that's just something we'll just have to convey to council next week when I do accreditation. We can still institute something, but it will be limited to, you know, any service product or program provided and operated on town-owned land.

48:16 Yeah, and I think that's just being kind of penny-wise and pound-foolish. You know, you have enough to do. You're very busy doing a successful job. And the last thing you need to do is create a new system for a few products, in my view. And, yeah. No, I appreciate it. I just want to be respectful of town council's direction. And by the way, Commissioner Cheswick isn't here, but he talked about, you know, their deals that they do over at his business.

48:45 For locals versus non-locals, and I mean, it just led to a lot of issues. How do you even define that? How do you prove it? How do you even bother the person with questions you have when you have some doubt? It just wasn't very functional from a business point of view. Yeah, and he's eliminated it, right? I think he's discontinued that program because of those problems. So option B, as you can see, is exactly that instituting resident, non-resident fee, and we kind of

49:16 Applied the same filter to our kind of products and services based on, you know, capacity to demand, which is that table. And just in the option summary there, it certainly meets the goal of resident, non-resident, but it does not lower resident fees, right? It just essentially just introduces non-resident fees, right? So residents would essentially pay the same, and the non-residents, you know, would essentially subsidize, you know, that reduced fee. That's kind of how it would work. We kind of, you know, walk through some of the pros and cons of this in that second paragraph.

49:46 You know, I think that's pretty clear. We kind of covered that at the last meeting. Another thing is, I mean, how many people, I mean, the definition of a resident is a second homeowner here, which is great, property taxpayers, but how many campers are not connected to some second home up here through a grandparent or just aunts, uncles, I mean.

50:17 There can't be that many campers that are coming and wanting to be in a camp that are just visiting Mammoth for a week or two. We got a few that stay, some were staying at Camp High Sierra, I mean, I remember, that stayed just for the week, they just came up camp for the week and got our kids in the camp, but that was probably just a handful, right? Yeah, I mean, just to... And it was available at that time. Yeah. Even if you wanted to do it, it just seems unrealistic. Yeah.

50:42 But I wanted to provide this definition because I think we included it in the packet last time. So if we did want to go with option B, we would have to consider what a proposed definition was. Right. To your point. But again, you're talking about so few people. Right. There's not going to be any financial gain for all the hassle for a handful of campers that aren't connected to a second home. Right. Yeah. That's just my view. Got it.

51:12 Discovered Option B is probably the weakest option of all, right? It is hard to institute across the breadth of all our programs and services, I think is what we're saying. Very well said. Yeah. So we could probably move to Option C. Yeah. So, yeah, so if you wanted, as the Commission, to further...

51:35 How would you say consider option B? These are the questions here that were put before you in regards to kind of these policies, you know, so what would be a definition of a resident? Should resident, non-resident fee apply to all camps, lesson programs, fees, or just memberships and passes? And then how should it be amended? Increased non-resident fees or decreased resident fees? So I've included those as a consideration for the commission if you wish to weigh in.

52:01 We can. If not, we can just make that determination based on this new information. It's really your consideration. It's not me. I'm really looking at you. It's really your consideration in regards to do you want to further evaluate or provide some definition to these policy questions. I think it's well written. I just think we're all in agreement that option B is not a good option. I think you do a great job, but it's not something that we'd want to pursue with all the risk and the extra work involved. I think we should be looking at option.

52:31 A or C for discussion in table B. Thank you for all your work putting option B together. It's a tough one. We went through it. We know it. Now you've made some questions in my mind. For the future, I think there's a typo here. There's A, A, and B. Maybe it should be the three points or A, B, and C. You're exactly right. I mean, if it's going to go into the town council packet.

52:56 You know, I don't have any issue with, like, item C here, the amount to charge non-residents. It's just that conceptually, it's too complicated, and I think we have a consensus that it's not an option that we would recommend. Taking us to option C, which that's kind of a no harm, no foul thing. Yeah, exactly right. So if you, as we kind of went through this and we presented it in October,

53:29 You know, fee schedule and cost recovery is a pretty elaborate, comprehensive, you know, study. And, you know, we've been running our fees. We've just been increasing it, you know, CPI each year. We have that approved subsidy by town council, right? We subsidize our youth programs by 80 percent, adults by 20 percent. That's just been kind of the status quo here. This is what speaks to.

53:54 If, for instance, Commission or Council would like to consider and learn a little bit more about how our fees are established based on our environment, as I said here, our financial goals and objectives and what our cost recovery is, then the option is to institute and recommend a more comprehensive cost.

54:18 A fee schedule, cost recovery analysis. It might be something that is worthy in the future if you deem it helpful. From a staff point of view, again, we just don't see a lot of issues and concerns that the public's bringing forward to warrant a pretty heavy financial commitment and time to undertake some of these.

54:47 You know, studies. We've talked about this every month. Moving forward, we will, certainly. You know, where I think we really want to focus our attention as we move from this forward is really that kind of master plan, right? What does that look like for the community over the next five to ten years? I think in a way, we'll see a lot of, you know, qualitative information, comments come from that needs assessment and the survey with our public.

55:16 That would probably inform kind of our fee schedule kind of cost recovery as it moves forward, you know what I mean? So I think that becomes that kind of foundational document to move us forward with something like this in the future if it's warranted. I feel like from the people I've talked to that the fees aren't really the issue and then we have our...

55:36 Scholarship programs to help subsidize those who really need it. I feel like this option C would be a bit of a waste of time when we're trying to think of what's next. You know, as you said, you'll capture all that in there. Are we having debate on this right now or between the four of us and then we're having a vote?

55:57 Yeah. Yeah. Because I'd like to put in my two cents, I feel like when I do speak to everyone in the community and even having children myself, option A, having the ability, if I really, really want to get into those camps, whether I live out of town or whether I'm in town full time, if I really want to plan my summer out, I'll come up here and one month is plenty of time.

56:24 To be able to come in person and sign up for those camps, I don't think it's a hardship to go to do that, but I think it'll give what I hear from the locals that, hey, I missed it, I didn't get time to sign up and I missed out on these camps. It's going to happen still anyway, because the camps are so popular, they fill up so quickly, but I like the idea of, you know, if you're a family of five, you know, just that wording there for me was a little...

56:53 Three camps, three camps per child, you know, three camps slash child, three camps per child, right? Per child. I think that's an amazing add-on to anyone who wants to come up and sign up for it, whether you live in town or not. So that would be my vote. I don't think we need to waste time on B. We're just asking for a trouble there. And I think if we look at our option C, money spent better.

57:22 Doing more things for the future than studying something that we'll find through those future studies. If that's my two cents. Thank you, thank you. Adding a third cent. I agree with that 100%. And the recent communication from the Forest Service, I think, shut the door. The door is shut. So that obviously is...

57:51 Pretty definitive. Good news in that respect because I think that's where we're headed anyway, quite frankly. Commissioner Newberry? Yeah, I mean, might come from a slightly different perspective. Even if either option A or B ended up being a savings to the program, we're going to get more money, I'd be opposed to them regardless. Even though you might say what we're doing here is we're simply saving money for the people who live here to do something.

58:23 Realistically means we're treating our guests, the people who actually come here and make this town possible differently. I'm adamantly opposed to treating anybody differently in any regards. We're all equals. They should be treated equal. If we're going to do anything, we should be using the tax dollars we can to provide all the services we can to everybody and anybody, not just those that live or just those that come and visit. So I'm all for C altogether. But I would like to, you know,

58:51 Reiterate, we don't make widgets. We're not in a cost recovery program. We're in a services industry where we help. We do wonderful, beautiful things and your department is excellent at it. To analyze like we have to do cost savings and bring anybody in to pay for it is to be absurd. So I'm all for anything we can do to treat everybody equally without treating anybody any differently regardless.

59:20 I concur with everything that all the commissioners have said. And I would say I would only add that I support option A, but I don't see option C as being like mutually exclusive. You can do both, really. I mean, we can implement option A and then do a financial analysis about whether to raise fees or not and whether that's worth the effort or not at the same time.

59:48 You know, and it's, we know that it's not, you know, it isn't cost prohibitive, and there's lots of options, including the scholarships. And, but do we really need to raise more money? And that's kind of what Commissioner Newbury is saying. We're not in the business, this is not a business for profit business. Maybe you want to address

1:00:17 How much other municipalities subsidize and what the cost recovery is there? I think we discussed that once and maybe that might be important for Town Council members to understand. Yeah, we could bring some more information to, you know, thanks for bringing that up to Town Council. You know, I think my comments before regarding Option C kind of warranted in regards to

1:00:42 If we wanted to institute something now in a study, it wouldn't be ready to go by next year. It would be a subsequent year and it doesn't make sense if we're running through a master plan needs assessment survey where we're going to get all that information and have that plan, I think, either justify or validate where our fees are. If we see a lot of concern from our residents being, hey, it's affordability and fee concerns, okay, maybe that warrants further analysis in the study.

1:01:12 But if those comments come back from what's really not affordability, it's really access and availability, then that gives us that kind of direction to move down that way, which is kind of where we're going. So that would be my recommendation. I don't think it's necessary right now. I think it's probably helpful. But I think option A in further building that program, I think will kind of give us and meet perhaps some of Council's concerns regarding affordability. So that would be... And I think Council's concerns... That would be my recommendation. Could be...

1:01:41 The recommendation could be for them to look at their permits and see what options they have with Forest Service to be able to offer those discounts later on in the time. But if we want to make an impact right now, I think that's going to help those who are trying to register their kids for it. And I feel like that's what I'm hearing the most of, is that everything fills up too quickly and it's not fair.

1:02:12 So it's access and availability, I think, is what we're speaking to. Is this council concerns or a council person's concerns? It was the consensus of council and it was direction from council. Yep. You have to take some responsibility to be on task to take care of your sign-ups for your kids. Well, even if you are, they fill up in minutes. Well, they do. We just don't have enough camps.

1:02:43 Or all the demand. Right. So some of the direction, you know, I think we're hearing is, you know, we talk about that internally. If that's a growth strategy, how do we build our team to meet that demand?

1:02:57 Right into all of that, with your master planning, right off the sea into the soil. Auto master planning is expanding the resources to be able to hold these camps, offering more opportunities, which trickles into where do we house these people, where do we find them, all that sort of stuff, and that can be the part of the master plan, because if we are going to have recreation, we need somewhere, if we expand recreation, we need to expand our workforce, and if we will, it's all big.

1:03:26 It's the sum of all parts, right? Yeah, we can't really consider one without the other, you know, it's can't build a chairlift without more parking, right? Yep. And one area that we have had some success with, and I know this is a very specific camp.

1:03:46 But our contracted UK soccer camps and the Challenger Sports soccer camps. So this year we were able to include, work with them. We included our Tony Colosado scholarship to be applicable to those camps. So straight away we worked with them on their registration system. They provided us with codes. We were able to give them to our scholarship recipients so that they could use those camps as well. Excellent. So working I think with those external vendors, that eliminates a lot of the

1:04:14 internal or within Mammoth Lakes workforce and expanding that if we can just you know work with them to create more opportunities not just soccer camps I accept that not everybody wants to do a soccer camp but those were available to use they tend to not have as

1:04:30 Strict caps on them because they can just funnel more coaches into the area for two weeks if those registration numbers climb. So we're looking at them. The difficulty of that is obviously having people come to Mammoth. There's costs associated with that. They have to bring coaches into town or instructors if it was for another kind of camp. So it has to be worth their while financially. But we're certainly excited and happy to work with those external vendors and then to

1:04:58 Make that Tony Colisado Scholarship applicable to those camps as well, so that they're an affordable option. So even when our camps sell out, we still have this other pool of camps. And there's grand opportunities through Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation for those outside contractors as well. We need to make them aware of that too. So did we take a vote now? Yeah, before we take a vote, do we have any public comment on this subject? That's what I thought I'd ask.

1:05:29 Thanks. So Betsy Truax just speaking as a member of the public. I was actually at the town council meeting where this was discussed and I just want to mention to the commission that it was very much my impression. I certainly don't want to speak for the council but I think

1:05:44 You know, whereas you as commissioners and certainly when I was on the commission and I know staff here is all the time more concern about the camp registration, I think the council was actually a little bit more focused on like facility use fees for locals. Not that they didn't care about the camps, but I think that that was kind of just the area more of their focus. And so I personally thought that, you know, the October opportunity to buy a half price skate pass was a really elegant solution to this to this challenge.

1:06:13 Thanks for your work on it. I know it's an issue that comes up all the time. We talked about it in the 10 years I was on the commission, so thanks for tackling it. Yeah, yeah, thank you. That's important to know, facility use fees, you know, as a focus. Okay, then I propose that we move to approve option A. Is that the motion, Sue? To approve a recommendation to council for option A? Yep.

1:06:47 That's it. I move. Do I second it? Yeah. Yeah. A second. We have a second. I think I made the motion. Yes, you did. You did. Jamie got it. Pretty simple. Option A. Good. Okay. Commissioner Newbury. No. Commissioner Reif. Yes. Commissioner Wisner. Yes. Chair O'Connell. Yes. Motion. The motion passes.

1:07:15 Thank you. I did want to say, Kat, we'll just give you a quick update on, we also closed, it was a busy month in October, we also closed the Old Wooden Street Sign Auction as a fundraiser for the scholarship fund. So maybe Kat, you didn't know that. Here we went. Yeah, so it was very successful. We have bids totaling just over $16,000 for those wooden street signs. So that money will go towards the Tony Colosado Scholarship Fund.

1:07:39 So that's really exciting. I'm just working through all of those bids now. It's a little bit of a process. So for anyone that's listening that did bid on a sign, we will get the pickup information out to you by the end of this week. We'll start to finalize payments and those folks can come to the CRC, which is where we will have the pickup location. We're just in the process of moving all of those signs over there and accounting.

1:08:02 For all of the bids that we have in right now, but really successful auction, a big thank you to everyone that participated, and we're excited to keep finding ways to raise funds for that Tony Colosato Scholarship Fund, because it's obviously making a big difference, and we're excited about that. What's the balance in the fund right now, approximately? I don't know off the top of my head, but it is probably around 80, I think right now, 83,000, something like that. That's a lot of camps.

1:08:31 So it's a lot of camps, it's a lot of programs. So, and we've, as you've seen in our, you know, biannual reports, the amount of scholarship recipients is quadrupling each year, the amount of money that we're subsidizing those scholarships with, which is great. We're starting to see a lot more reach in the community with those scholarships. I think Sherry Lynn, the learning...

1:08:56 Learning Officer, I'm not sure of her title exactly, at Mammoth Elementary School has been amazing in helping a lot of the Hispanic families translate and apply for those scholarships, and she's also become very adept at our registration software, so she not only gets the scholarship in, she then helps those families sign up for the program, so that's great, we're seeing a lot more traction there, which is really cool. Excellent, that's good news. We also, I think I've passed this on before, we've also got a $2,000.

1:09:24 Donation from the Rebel Rally when they were here in September. That was the women's only off-road navigation challenge. It's not really a race, but they drove essentially over eight days, I think, from Mammoth away down the Mexico border and finished, but they were here in town in October. Off-roading? Off-roading, yeah, with no... Jeeps? Like off-road vehicles? Everything. You bought everything, but you could not use any navigation device. It was all maps and compasses. Very cool. Great event.

1:09:54 You know, third time in Mammoth and really successful. So they were very generous with their gift to our scholarship fund as well. And they also donated to the animal shelter. They donated $5,000 and a Chewy order to the animal shelter as well. Anyway, thank you for your time today. Yeah. One final question with respect to the upcoming meeting. Yes. How are you, how do you wish to see that progress? November 20th? Yes.

1:10:24 As far as we have, a motion has been made, seconded and passed, with respect to option A, so are you going to deal with it then? So I will present this, I think the background information on this staff report is what I'll kind of start with, with council, because they, remember they first took action on March 20th, and then June 19th, that's when they enacted that change.

1:10:51 And then September 4th, they had that other resolution. And then here we are on October 1st, we presented that item. And then, you know, November 5th, we've come forward with a motion. So I'll kind of summarise that. And then based on the consensus and by motion, action taken by the Parks and Rec Commission, their recommendation is option A. And then I'll pause. And then I'll just hand it over to the chair. And then the chair with the mayor.

1:11:19 Can kind of handle that kind of that dialogue of how it goes. So I think at that point, what I think they'd be looking for is why, you know, you selected option A, and then you would be in that position to based on these reasons, you know, we just looked at option B, which had this kind of non-discrimination clause, you know, from the Forest Service, and then also these other, you know, challenges that have been addressed by the department. Right, I mean, you can...

1:11:44 You know, summarize your kind of conversation over the last kind of couple of meetings. I'm sure that considering it wasn't unanimous, you feel comfortable explaining my hesitation to being opposed to option A or B, right? Yeah, I'll write all that down here. Just equitable recreation for all. As elegantly as we choose to not treat people equally so good. Yeah. And so I think that's the dialogue at that point. So I think as commissioners, you know, you would just be relaying why you selected option A. Mm-hmm.

1:12:13 As a consensus of the Commission, as the advisory body to Council, and then Council can certainly take that under consideration, but it's still going to be their decision, you know, to move forward with an action at the time. So there's no action presented for them at the workshop because it's purely just a workshop. So if they wanted to, you know, take action, they would have to then agendise it and then bring it back for adoption. I think what we're looking for is to say, you know, is this the direction like the Parks and Recreation Department to move?

1:12:43 Forward with and then present that as part of that fee schedule for the next year when we present that to you in February and then council would get to approve that in March again, right? So that would be what I would recommend and probably where we are with our kind of timeline. If that's helpful. Typically you've got 45 minutes, right? Because you usually start late and then they'll try to wrap up just before their next item because this will start at four o'clock. We have the dog park ribbon cutting ceremony.

1:13:11 Costume Contest over there, it's going to be very busy, lots of dogs, lots of people. So we'll be coming from there straight into essentially the workshop that will be here on the tables and then they'll get wrapped up and then they'll resume and convene back to the dais and start their regular meeting. And if there's any other items at the end that you'd like to bring up, I think the item that you're working on with the master plan right now, I think that's a good topic for

1:13:38 Discussion at the end with Council, you know, that's up to the Chair to kind of present to the Mayor and say, hey, we've been working on this as part of our strategic plan. We'd like to see, you know, this move forward. And then staff have met and then we're kind of trying to package our presentation to Council that will happen hopefully in December as part of the strategic plan for Council moving forward. So it's all kind of in play. So I think that would be worthy of some discussion at the end of that workshop.

1:14:06 Sounds good. I'm considering the direction. It's going to be interesting. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Thank you for your time. Let's move on to Commissioner Reports. Anybody have any report they have to report on? The dog park is booming. Yeah. Both dog park as well as the wonderful Halloween thing that you guys did. Oh, yeah. It was really good. Thank you. Wow, that was incredible. Greg was there for three hours. Yeah. Anyway, thank you for letting me do that. Everybody. It was really good. Thank you.

1:14:33 Just quickly, I was driving up to the lakes basin and the gate was closed. Is that going to open up again or is that closed for good? It should have reopened. Oh yeah? Yeah. Okay. We closed it Friday at 6 o'clock. The Forest Service closed it at 6. Okay. Yeah, it drove up on Saturday. It reopened yesterday. I was just wondering about that. Yep. Okay, well that's good to know. Yeah. Reds Meadow is still closed at this time. I don't know if there's any update on that road at all, if they'll reopen that at all.

1:15:00 All right, agenda items, I guess we don't really have anything, we don't have another special meeting coming up. Yep, so we've got November special meeting and December 3rd, because we won't have a chance after the workshop to go through that, but that's kind of where Hayes will be here presenting the CIP, kind of that program of work again. Cat will be presenting the youth sports funding process and timeline, kind of get that going again, we start that in January.

1:15:24 We have an opportunity just to kind of review and evaluate our strategic priorities, key objective statement, and remember that kind of follows councils. So we'll kind of start that conversation and then we won't get back to it until February, kind of when council kind of has theirs ratified and then we'll kind of ratify ours. And then just a monthly department update essentially on the rink and our progress at the CRC and all the other activities with our winter programming that is almost about to begin. So that's it.

1:15:53 Hopefully we can keep that to a pretty concise meeting as well. All right. Very good. Thank you, everybody. Good work. As always, thank you, Betsy, for coming and being here and sharing. Commissioners, see you at the workshop. Coming up with that. The meeting's adjourned. Got to be to the dog park first. Oh, yeah. I did find out there were some questions about...