Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2021
Eastern Sierra Council of Governments
at 08:30
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
264 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Hey, great. Is everyone ready? Let's call this meeting to order Friday, December 10th, 2021, 8.30 a.m. Can we do roll call, please? Yes, I'm sorry. Chair Schwartz? Here. Council Member Wentworth? Here. Supervisor Corliss? Here. Supervisor Gardner? Here. Supervisor Griffiths? Supervisor Griffiths? I will come back to him. I believe he's here.
0:52 Uh, Supervisor Tothero? Here. Council Member Ellis? Here. Council Member, okay. Mayor Salcedo? I believe she's muted, but I see her, so we'll mark her here, and, uh, Councilor- Yes, yes, yes, I'm here. All right, thank you. And Supervisor Griffith? Here. Thank you so much. Great. Uh, let's do the Pledge of Allegiance. Uh, there's gotta be a, I see a flag on John Wentworth's screen, so we can all look at his flag, and please join me, um, on the Pledge of Allegiance.
1:29 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay, public comments. Notice to the public, this time is set aside to receive public comment on matters not calendared on the agenda. Is there any public comment? I have no public comments at this time. Excuse me.
1:59 Chair, I'd like to just say that I need to leave at nine o'clock for a brief time. There's a family conference I need to attend. And so I'll go off and then come back as soon as possible, if that's okay. And that would still leave us with a quorum, I hope. Okay. Thanks, Linda. Thanks. The consent agenda is approved the minutes of the regular meeting on October 8th, November 5th, and December 3rd. And a resolution of the board of directors
2:31 of the ESCOG regarding the need for continued virtual meetings to protect public health. Would anyone like to make a motion? I move to approve the consent agenda. Second. Great. Call for a vote. Chair Schwartz? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Aye. Supervisor Corliss? Aye. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Supervisor Griffiths?
3:11 Yes. Thank you. Supervisor Totharo? Aye. Councilmember Ellis? Yes. And Mayor Salcedo? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Moving on to policy matters. 5.1. Receive a presentation from the Inyo County Administrator's Office regarding preparation of a regional comprehensive economic development strategy, SEDS. Good morning, supervisors and council members. It's a pleasure to see you.
3:44 I'll start with a brief introduction of this item. Inyo County recently spearheaded a conversation with each of our regional member agencies, including Alpine County, to discuss an effort to put together a regional comprehensive economic development strategy for the Eastern Sierra.
4:07 And a comprehensive economic development strategy, also known as a SEDS, is an important document for accessing certain federal funding, specifically through the Economic Development Administration, but also potentially through the U.S. Department of Agriculture as well. Currently, Inyo County and Mono County do not have a SEDS. Alpine County is working to join the Central Sierra SEDS.
4:34 So there was a conversation with the CAOs and the city managers from each of those jurisdictions. Today I would like to invite and introduce Megan McCammon.
4:45 from the Inyo County, County Administrator's Office. She's the newly appointed Assistant County Administrator. So pleased to have her there. And she'll provide an update of that conversation. What we're looking for today is general direction and feedback from your board on a regional effort. Thank you. Good morning, everyone. Thank you, Elaine, for the introduction. Elaine really covered basically the work that's been done right now on
5:16 conversations around having a SEDS, but we're really just here today to gauge interest from leaders in the COG in pursuing funding for a regional comprehensive economic development strategy.
5:31 Inyo County has identified some EDA funding that is available in the near future and is interested in pursuing it. I know, speaking to Elaine, she's interested in speaking to the principals from Mammoth, Mono, Inyo and Bishop. All of us have expressed some interest in moving forward with a regional effort. As Elaine mentioned, Alpine County, already a part of the Central Sierra Seds on the other side with Tuolumne, Mariposa and a few other.
6:00 But I think that they are looking at whether they can participate on an east side SEDS as well. So curious your thoughts and any direction that you have in pursuing this opportunity. Okay, go ahead. Are you going to try to dance? We were part of the discussion with the four agencies. We could sort of go talk about the SEDS document.
6:34 And I think it is something recently that we should proceed with. I think the questions that came up is there's probably a $50,000 match requirement. I think it was a $250,000 estimated project. So if we shared the cost for the matching funds on that. The question also came up regarding just the leadership wanting to be able to move it.
7:02 And that discussion, it kind of leaned toward Inyo County continuing to take the lead out just because of the staffing requirements. And it's probably a contract out to somebody to manage that. And I believe it's a reimbursable grant again. So we're having to carry the funding. Look to that. Fully support. I think from a regional perspective here, if people are supported.
7:27 Really, it's going back to the agency saying, are we all going to kick in some money for the match funding and then to have people engaged in the process from the various economic development planning departments or wherever that would lie in the various agencies to work with whoever they brought on board to do the work. Also, from the town element, we're in the process of having it next week.
7:55 to the Council and to our Planning Commission last week, a localized or semi-regional, if you will, SEDS for our area. But we had to do that in order in talking with EDA. We've had a similar document before. The comment was they would accept that as a SEDS document that could be utilized for a certain grant fund. So we're pursuing that regardless at this point to move that forward so we could actually have some potential applications in January.
8:21 But it was a good discussion. I think all the administrative side of all the agencies seem to be very supportive of looking at a regional element of it for the SEDS document. But the timing and the cost and elements may be better handled through one of the agencies versus directly through ESCOG. I want to apologize. I had it right here in my notes to make a point of mentioning that the match, the grant that we are looking at does have a 25% match requirement.
8:51 I have gotten a variety of feedback around the cost of a full SEDS. From what I've heard, the range could range from anything from like $50,000 for a regional SEDS for Inyo and Mono up to $250,000. I'm thinking just based on the variety of answers that I've gotten that it would be closer to about $100,000.
9:17 And then with a 25% match with the grant funding that we've identified at this point. And I'd also just like to add that SEDS is distinct from the Community Economic Resiliency Fund, which is coming out of the Office of GO-Biz. I know that each of the member agencies, the ESCOG, independently submitted a request.
9:44 to identify the Eastern Sierra as a distinct region within that greater region that the state is looking at. And I think the SEDS effort would really help to support and define our region within that state effort as well. Sorry, what is the timeline on this? Did you ask for the timeline, Mayor? What's the timeline on this project?
10:14 I think ideally we'd like to move it forward as quickly as possible. The EDA funding I think has a rolling deadline is open right now. So the hope is just to keep it moving as quickly as possible or start it moving as quickly as possible. This is Leslie. I think that generally these things take about a year. So we just want to get the ball rolling. Also, I wanted to mention that
10:43 You know, besides not having any firm numbers about what exactly it's going to cost, I know that our county partners know that RCRC has been working on a project, and I believe, and Bob Burris is here, so I'm not going to speak for him, but I know that they're also working on some funding for our regional SEDS for certain areas that don't have one yet, and so...
11:10 There's a lot of details to work out, but today the main thing is that we want to know from this group, is this something that you support and are you willing to go back to your full board if we move forward and able to secure the funding? Are you willing to go back to the full board to get approval on pitching in on some match funds? That's all.
11:39 Okay, so I am, as one board member, I'm willing to do that. I just had a logistics question. Maybe this is a grace question. Is this something that is already approved through the JPA, or is this something we would have to go back to each entity and get formal approval before we submit a grant? So, good question, Supervisor Griffiths. Right now, my understanding is that
12:07 The ESCOG is not being asked to take any concrete action today. It's more just an informational kind of item that's being presented to you. So today, we're welcome to have any sort of discussion that the board would like. However, depending on what the...
12:27 what or if the concrete action is that may stem out of those discussions, then yes, it would need to be something where, for instance, if ESCOG is seeking a grant to do something that does not fall within the scope of any of ESCOG's authorized projects, which I think at this point is only the SREMP, yes, we would need to go back to each of the member entities boards and get approval to do that. Okay, so I,
12:57 Go ahead. Thank you. That was part of our regional discussion as well is that although there could be certain benefits in housing it with the ESCOG as a regional entity, given that it's not within the current JPA, it's a program of work and the ESCOG, it would be cumbersome to, you know, get that approval, seek that approval from all the member agencies.
13:21 And Inyo County is already volunteering to spearhead and lead this effort. It would make sense to continue housing that effort there. Okay. That seems to make sense from a time standpoint. I mean, that was my concern is how cumbersome and timely we could get that done. But it might not be a bad idea, even if Inyo County is taking the lead on this on behalf of the region, to go ahead and start that process so that we can just get it.
13:52 full buy-in from everybody. And I think we have informal buy-in from everybody sort of at this point, but I think it would be good to formalize it. Stacy? Thank you. And as one supervisor, and I sense consensus from my colleague, Mr. Gardner, but we'll wait to hear from him. I would certainly be happy to bring this to the Mono Board. And regarding
14:23 We do have Bob here. Bob is the Deputy Chief Economic Development Officer for RCRC. And as he mentioned in our meeting yesterday, our board meeting at RCRC yesterday, it's really his job to help member counties with projects just like this. So I don't think I'm totally putting him on the spot, but I wanted to take this opportunity to let Bob
14:47 speak a little bit about his work, and I would just urge us, or Inyo County, however this is going to work, to take advantage of the program that Bob and RCRC can offer. So if it's okay, Madam Chair, I would like to let Bob say a few words. Great. Thank you, Supervisor Corliss. You're right, I wasn't expecting to provide a lot of information, but no problem at all. And there's a couple areas that I could...
15:16 I could provide that information. So I think it's fantastic that you're thinking in terms of a larger regional SEDS, and I think that that's probably the most effective and efficient and realistic. And really, I think that EDA really likes to see multi-jurisdictional SEDS. And the fact that your economies are very similar, I think that it makes the process even easier.
15:44 And we want to support everything that you're trying to do. I want to make sure that everybody knows that RCRC has launched in an effort to provide resources to be able to create a SEDS. About five months ago, we did apply for, or I guess it was about four months ago, an EDA grant.
16:09 And really, that was on the pathway for rural broadband. So the intent of that EDA grant is to support our member counties develop a broadband strategy plan. So part of that was making sure that all of the counties that were a part of that also had a SEDS. And at that point, we identified Inyo as not having a SEDS. And actually, Inyo,
16:39 County agreed to be a part of that effort to create one and agreed to, once the grant is awarded, to put in, I believe it was $26,000 matching funds to access the funds to create that SEDS for the county itself. At that point, we didn't know that Mono County did not have a SEDS. So we had several discussions with EDA.
17:08 Should we go ahead and amend our application to include Mono as well? They advise not to. You don't want to disrupt that process. It already takes long enough to get approval and analysis. So we just kind of opened up the conversation if both counties, Mono and Inyo, would be interested in merging efforts as the process.
17:36 So there is an opportunity here.
18:07 to amend the EDA application we already have in process. And we're hoping that this will only take another couple months. You never know with these EDA applications. Everybody knows that's ever applied for an EDA grant, knows that it's really hard to tell how long that's going to take. But we're totally open to amending that application and adding counties to that.
18:36 to add to the requested amount of funding. And we're open to having that conversation with all parties to do that, including Alpine. And I think that that makes sense as well. Added to that, because this is a grant that requires reimbursement, and it's something I think we're going to talk about on the next agenda item, we do have the capability with our revolving loan funds.
19:05 to provide funds to start a project that could be reimbursed at a later date. So that provides that funding to make sure that cash flow is secure as you go through the process of these grants and creating the SEDs. In addition, we have access to quite a few consultants too that perform the research to complete these SEDs.
19:33 Our best estimates are anywhere between $50,000 or $60,000 and $100,000. I believe in our application we included a $100,000 estimate for the SEDS completion in Inyo. I don't think it would be much more to combine because it is one SEDS and it is a similar economic area. So I think that your range is appropriate within that area.
19:59 And we can also assist with that RFP process if necessary. So I hope that that helps in your process. I think our main goal is to make sure this happens as quickly as possible. We want to make sure that there's not a lot of redundancy. And we want to, I think, also make sure that if you do decide to go after an EDA grant independently, that there aren't any red flags that pop up on either of our applications.
20:27 So we should probably clarify that as well. So I hope that's helpful. Can I ask a question? This is Leslie. So I heard you mention the broadband strategy and the said strategy. Are we talking about two different things? So the broadband strategy is something that we're going to be working for several, I think 26 counties that are a member of that effort.
20:55 As we launched that effort, we found that three of those counties didn't have the SEDS, and we felt that those were going to be necessary to move forward on the broadband strategy as well. So they are independent things, but the SEDS is really kind of a building block to that broadband strategy. Yeah, it's a building block to a lot of things. So I wasn't, I...
21:20 I wasn't aware that the county had made a commitment to participate or to put in $26,000, and I'm guessing that's because of the, you know, I didn't have the opportunity to have a smooth handoff with my previous CAO. So it sounds like I have some things that I need some information on. So would it be okay if I just contact you outside of this meeting and get some information? Yes, absolutely. Okay, thank you.
21:48 And I'll grab Barbara Hayes on that meeting as well as she's leading our broadband initiative. Okay, that sounds great. Thank you. Thank you. John? A couple of things. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. I am enormously supportive of this.
22:15 I want to clarify maybe something when Dan mentioned something about a SEDS in Mammoth, that's a semantic distinction. There was a very localized planning document that had to do with a previous planning director put something together that the acronym adds up to being a SEDS.
22:33 It is not a SEDS. But the point of it is that in dealing with our regional representative from EDA, we've all been having to try to cobble together things that would satisfy their requirements, which is not the desired way we want to be doing business, which is why we very definitely want to move forward with the SEDS, with whatever comes out of the discussions with staff.
22:59 The other thing to add, following up on Jeff's comments about and Grace's advice on how the ESCOG does business, we do not have a program of work for this yet. And I think it's going to be incredibly and vitally important that a well-thought-out, well-reasoned resolution is drafted. It could be happening in parallel with requests taking the temperature of our agencies. That is
23:28 going to be worthy of the ESCOG and worthy of this region, especially in light of the fact of the hundreds of millions and frankly billions and billions of dollars that are going to be available through the state of California and the federal government for regions such as ours. And I think it's incredibly important that we draft a resolution. So Jeff, if we are writing a grant to start moving forward with the SEDS, it's going to have a larger scope than just the SEDS.
23:56 It's truly going to be about an economic initiative on behalf of the region that the SEDs can fold within. But something that all of us, when we go back to our boards, we're not just asking, hey, would you mind putting 25 grand into something? No, we're asking you to invest in a larger economic vision for this region.
24:16 And I think that's critically important to do this as we go forward, so that as we build programs into the ESCOG, they make sense, they speak to each other intelligently, it's clear what they are, so it's clear to the public, and it's clear how we will be able to maximize the kinds of opportunities that are in front of us right now that we're going to be dealing with in the coming years. So we're normalcy supportive, let's do it right, let's not mess around.
24:41 Looking forward to any way that I can help or other members, Elaine of the ESCOG can help you with this. But I think it's critically important to really build the right foundation to do the kind of work we want to do going forward. So thank you. I have a question about like, for instance, if an entity like the City of Bishop wanted to apply for something that required a SEDS, we would just use this regional SEDS in our application or is the application
25:10 Always going to be something that's region-wide. I can address that for the City of Bishop. We are looking at possibly applying for an EDA grant locally, and the regional EDA representative has just recently approved our economic development element of our general plan as our SEDS for one year.
25:45 So that we can apply within this next year, but we need the regional SEDS in order to be able to do that in the future. But each entity can apply for funds for local projects, or we can apply for regional projects as well. And are we looking to divide the cost of this equally four ways, like we did with the ESCOG? Is that what we're proposing when we go back to our entities? How are we looking to...
26:23 Divvy up the cost. And I'm sure if I could, I think I've heard that staff's got some work to do between the representations from Mr. Burris and what Inyo County's been working on. I would think it would be a prorated or a divvied up share, but I think we don't quite have the numbers yet. Megan, is that fair to say between you and Leslie and Bob? I think that that's fair to say. Okay. And I think also this is an anecdotal.
26:50 requests at this point, as Leslie, as I think has presented it, I think as Grace has said, in order to actually do this and submit a grant, we're going to have to have a program in place. So we're going to have to do a bunch of things kind of simultaneously. Forgive me if I'm not getting that right, Elaine, but I think that's my, I think that's, is that the right understanding? Okay, thank you. This is obviously a longer journey, but it needs to start with a single step, and I'm willing to support taking the single step right now to move ahead.
27:22 Question. Is this ultimately, though, a reimbursable cost? So we're basically fronting the money and then we'll be repaid as the work is done. Is that correct, Elaine? I think it depends on what the grant opportunity is that we ultimately pursue. I would anticipate that the match would not be reimbursable. A match is not. Okay, thank you. But yes, I'm also very supportive of this. I think it's...
27:51 A good example of a way that we can sort of collaborate together, moving this forward. It'd be great if Alpine could join us, but certainly Inyo and Mono. Thanks. Alpine staff is definitely interested. They're in kind of a unique position because they straddle having more in common with the people that they're already involved with on one half of the county and then the other half of the county, they identify more with us. And so ideally, if they can participate in both.
28:24 I think they're interested in doing that. Just one thought, Madam Chair, I see Janet Halffield's with us. When we originally came forward around the recreation stuff and the ecosystem management piece was added to it, it made for a much more robust, broader-looking, solid resolution of what the ESCOG would intend to do. So I would really encourage us to start working on that simultaneously as staff is getting the rest of the stuff figured out.
28:54 Okay, so does staff have enough direction on this? I think so. Great. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Very excited. Thank you. Okay, then let's move on to agenda item 5.2, consideration of an agreement with the rural county representatives of California revolving loan fund in the amount of $500,000. Morning again, Madam Chair, your board. So,
29:29 This item is a wonderful opportunity for the ESCOG in collaboration with the rural county representatives of California. You'll remember that over the last year we have been working to pursue funding through the ZDFW for the Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator and we were successful in getting that award in the amount of approximately $3.3 million.
29:55 And we're now looking to enter into contracts with consultants with Forest Service to begin that project work. In conversations that I've been having with CDFW and looking at the anticipated cash flow for that project over the next year, as we start to bring those consultants on, particularly specialists who will be doing work in the field for NEPA analysis, we will start to incur some sizable invoices.
30:24 which are reimbursable through the CDFW, but on a quarterly basis, no guarantee when the state might actually send that funding. So one of the concerns that came about in the last couple of months was cash flow and how we would be able to advance funding to pay those specialists. The CDFW grant does not provide for an advance and the budget for the ESCOG is not large enough to accommodate those invoices.
30:52 Fortunately, Supervisor Corliss, in her work with the RCRC, put us in touch with Mr. Burrus, who you've heard from earlier. And the RCRC had established a few years ago a
31:07 Finance Authority, Known as the Golden State Finance Authority, which was established specifically for the purposes of advancing funding to special districts for them to provide advances on grants, particularly grants that promote public safety and environmental protection. So this couldn't be a more perfect fit for our project and for our need at this time. The RCRC is offering the ESCOG a $500,000 advance.
31:37 That would be repaid over two years, and that would be at 0% interest. You'll see in your agenda packet, in addition to the MOU provided with RCRC, staff has done some cash flow analysis, and I believe that that $500,000 is both the appropriate amount for us to cover our cash flow needs over two years.
32:03 But moreover is the essential amount for us to be able to cover our cash flow needs over the next two years. I've also had conversations with ESCOG Finance Director, Ms. Dutcher of Mono County. She has reviewed this with me and has lended her support. She's available today as well to answer any questions you may have. At this time,
32:27 I am happy to take questions. Mr. Burris is available to speak to this program, as is Ms. Judger, but staff would recommend that your board approve the MOU with the Golden State Finance Authority and the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments regarding advancement of funding for public purposes so that we can stand up and start work on the Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator Project. Thank you. Discussion? Questions? John?
33:09 You're muted, John. Sorry. Stacey, why don't you go ahead and I'll go after you. Yeah, I just wanted to give a little as a, still, I'm still chair of RCRC for a few more weeks and board member, just wanted to provide a little, you know, a little more background.
33:36 You know, both Inyo and Mono counties are members and I think the programs of RCRC and its affiliate organization, Golden State Finance Authority, which I'll put their website in the chat and RCRCs. I encourage you all at another time to just take a look at the, it's complex, but incredibly powerful kind of network of affiliate organizations with RCRC that
34:02 that work on behalf of rural counties like Inyo and Mono. So Golden State Finance Authority also has incredible housing programs. But as an affiliate to RCRC, as described in the staff report, Golden State Finance Authority started this revolving loan fund program just a couple years ago, and only one special district so far has taken advantage of it. So it's really exciting to have ESCOG moving forward with this. Just yesterday,
34:31 The Golden State Finance Authority Board, which is the same virtual, pretty much the same as the RCRC Board, all the member counties, approved a higher loan limit for the revolving loan fund. So not only is this helping us get an incredible fuels reduction forest restoration project done,
34:54 This is helping RCRC develop the revolving loan fund and better understand member county needs. So it's truly a win-win and really an exciting time. And Bob, I don't know if you, Bob Burris, I should say, if you would like to say anything else. Thank you, Supervisor Corliss. Yeah, no, hey, we're as excited as you are to be able to use this program. I mean, we...
35:20 We've had this program. It's about a $3 million fund. We've had it in place for, I think, four years. And yeah, we've only had one other loan. And the reason for that is just we haven't marketed it very well. And also the usefulness of it, we've had to kind of tweak as we get feedback. And yesterday was a great example, having the ability now to increase the amount that we can loan out and extend that term.
35:50 from what was originally six months to two years, which really fits your effort and this project. And we're just really happy to be able to use this program to sort of unlock some of those grant funds that you and other jurisdictions will use. And this is available for public institutions, so commissions, JPAs, counties, and cities to utilize.
36:19 So, again, really excited to have worked with Elaine and John and Supervisor Corliss on this and to make this happen and excited to see the results. Thank you. So, Madam Chair, I'll just add in, I want to thank Elaine for including me in those discussions. Bob, real pleasure to meet you and to work with you. And I think for my fellow members of the COG, just understand that
36:43 The parameters and the opportunity here, Bob just keeps making it a little better every time we talk to him. So I would really encourage us, this is one of those opportunities, we as a nascent COG with our Joint Powers Authority.
36:57 Nice. Well done. Timely. Excellent opportunity. I would anticipate Bob will be coming back to this well perhaps a couple times. So thank you very much for your time and thank you, Stacey, for the introduction and for connecting the dots on this one. Great opportunity. Thank you. I'll just, so Janet, thank you for doing the cash flow analysis.
37:27 And I'm trying to understand a lot of numbers there. So do we think that the $500,000 is fully sufficient? I mean, it kind of looks, by reading it, that the most we'll be needing at any one point is $120,000? So first off, the cash flow analysis was prepared by Elaine, so I can't take credit for it. Thank you, Elaine. But she and I did consult on it.
37:57 And I've reviewed it a couple of times. The way it's constructed right now, you know, we brought down the half a million dollars immediately upon initiating this program. It then provides what I would call working capital through the three years and one month of the program, of the grant, you know, after 36 months, you know, the anticipation is your full three-point.
38:26 And I would ask Mr. Burris to
38:53 I can't confirm or deny anything that I say wrong here, but if you pay back some of it because you don't need that working capital on hand at that point in time through the program, then that amount is available to you later.
39:07 to draw down, and the caveat is that any principle that you draw down, from the time that you draw it down, it's owed back to RCRC's revolving account within two years. And then, like you said, it's a revolving account, which means it acts kind of like a savings account. There are three, four, well, there are several months, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven months in the current analysis where
39:37 Aside from other resources from member contributions that might be available, that our checking account goes negative. And it's negative anywhere from $15,000 to $265,000. There may be ways that being creative and innovative that we can draw down on any principle that hasn't been.
40:03 That's available to us that we're not capped out at half a million dollars to cover some of that cash flow. But aside from that, there are three options that I see to this organization at this point in time. And I'll list them in order of my personal or my professional preference. And any combination of the three is available to this organization.
40:26 First, understand that the ESCOG's money is held in an investment pool that is managed by myself as a treasurer for the county of Mono County. It's a very robust investment pool. We have at times more than $100 million in that fund, in that pool that holds the cash and investment resources for the county, for the town of Mammoth Lakes, for our school districts, and
40:55 A whole plethora of special districts and other organizations. So here are your options. One, increase the member contributions to create a layer of working capital to cover the cash deficits. Two, consider an investment pool loan from Mono County's investment pool. That would require paying interest on that loan. And then interest is in our program typically been what our pooled investment.
41:22 Interest earnings are, which is fairly low right now because the market's not real good, but then we add anywhere from 25 to 50 basis points to cover administrative costs on them. The other is for myself as a treasurer, and I would need to, you know, consult and get advice from my assistant treasurer, is to allow ESCOG's account to go deficit in the pool. One reason for doing this is that, you know, the deficit
41:49 is not insurmountable. It's not large. You know you have secured a grant and that the reason for the deficit is only merely because you're waiting for reimbursement. When you look at that cash flow schedule, you'll see that the deficit occurs, I think in every single case, occurs in the third month of a quarter. And all that means is that we're one month to 45 days away from
42:17 receiving that reimbursement from the Department of Fish and Wildlife. And so it's really a temporary deficit, you know, within 30 to 45 days, it turns around and you're back in a positive cash position. Of course, this is all done without any consideration of any member contributions that we normally acquire from each of the members that pays the administrative cost.
42:43 So what would happen in that situation is that the fund itself would receive a negative apportionment of interest. This is just like interest expense and with interest rates really low, you know, that cost is not insurmountable to this agency. And so with that, I'll, you know, answer any questions you have and, you know, if Bob has anything to correct on what I said or my understanding of the MOU.
43:12 Well said. I agree with everything you said. I think that one thing we're going to do, if this helps clarify the way this works, is it's probably less of a revolving loan fund and more of a line of credit. And I think that that's probably what we're going to term this fund from this point on. Lane, you're muted.
43:46 Thank you. I wanted to thank Janet for providing that additional analysis much better than I possibly could begin to. But I wanted to add to that to Mr. Griffith's question that bear in mind that this cash flow analysis is a model. It was a model to begin to understand how we would be allocating those funds.
44:09 And to make sure that at the end of the day, the ESCOG is positive and capable to reimburse or repay the line of credit that we would be looking at taking from RCRC. And so...
44:23 Those numbers obviously could begin to fluctuate. And I've also isolated in this model just the CDFW grant and not potential other grant awards that we might receive in the future. I have additional models that I've looked at that incorporate some of those funds that will potentially be awarded by other grants that we've submitted in the last year. And that additional cash flow really helps the ESCOG in this model rather than
44:53 compounding any deficit that we might incur. John Lentworth, your hands raised. Do you have a comment? Yes. Quickly, Janet, thank you very much for that very eloquent summary of a very complex financial scenarios. Going forward, Grace and Elaine, is Janet Dutcher going to be the staff-ish or person who will be advising ESCOG on financial
45:30 things like this, irregardless of the program. I just want to make sure we're hearing a consistent technical analysis of items that will be coming forward in front of the ESCOG. Should that be our expectation? I would anticipate that should be our expectation. Good. Okay. So thank you, Jen. So we get into SEDS, we get into grants, we get things like that. It's great to know you'll be advising us as we consider these things. Thank you very much. Okay. Is there any more discussion? All right. Are we looking for a motion to enter into this?
46:10 Agreement? Yes, please. Yes. Yes, I move that we approve the Memorandum of Understanding between GSFA and ESCOG for public purposes. Second. For a vote? Chair Schwartz? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Supervisor Totoro? Yes.
46:46 Council Member Ellis?
46:49 Council Member Ellis, Yes.
46:49 Council Member Ellis, And I see Linda's name. I'm not sure if she's here.
46:53 Council Member Ellis, We had to step out for a moment at 9.
46:57 Council Member Ellis, All right. I wanted to make sure, since I saw her name up there, so we will mark her as absent on this vote. Thank you.
47:02 Council Member Ellis, Great. Wonderful. Thank you.
47:07 Council Member Ellis, And I would just also, I would be remiss, and if I didn't thank Mr. Boros, he has been absolutely wonderful to perfect, and I'm very grateful.
47:16 Thank you.
47:17 A pleasure.
47:17 Stars were aligned on this one. Moving on to 5.3, consideration of a collection agreement between the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and the United States Department of Agriculture, U.S. Forest Service, Inyo National Forest. Good morning again. So several items this morning with regards to our CDFW.
47:43 Grant in the Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator and everything that will need to be done to stand up and begin the scope of work on that project. So this item also relates to the CDFW grant. One of the components of the scope of work in that grant and one of the line items in the budget was establishing a collaboration with the Inyo National Forest so that the environmental planning team
48:09 can work directly with the Forest Service to ensure that the NEPA analysis that they're conducting meets the standards of the Forest Service and moreover so that interdisciplinary team, which is one of the goals of this project for the ESCOG, has a relationship with the Forest Service and their expectation for NEPA projects in the future so that we can start to facilitate a third-party NEPA team in the Eastern Sierra.
48:38 So the collection agreement before your board for consideration today formalizes the arrangement between the ESCOG and the Inyo National Forest so that we can collaborate on that scope of work. It includes a budget of $228,692, which is consistent with the budget allocated in the CDFW grant specifically for the U.S. Forest Service staff to be working with the environmental planning team.
49:08 The agreement is fairly straightforward in establishing the roles and responsibilities of the two parties. The obligations of the ESCOG will be to administer the CDFW grant, to work with the contractors that are hired, to ensure that the NEPA products will meet the standards of the Forest Service, to meet with the U.S. Forest Service staff on a regular basis, to ensure that we are meeting
49:35 all of the progress that we need to be doing and providing all necessary reports and documentation, including the administrative record. The obligations of the U.S. Forest Service are to make staff available consistent with the scope of work in the CDFW grant, specifically several technical specialists that will be necessary for completing the NEPA work, working with the ESCOG to ensure that there is public outreach on this project.
50:02 and that we are meeting quarterly to look at the progress that is being done against the grant. The U.S. Forest Service will also initiate consultation with regulatory agencies where it is not possible for the ESCOG or consultants to initiate that work and will also help us to ensure that we are selecting the appropriate contractors to complete the scope of work.
50:28 The agreement template included in your agenda packet, you'll see that it appears there's crack changes. That agreement template is locked by the U.S. Forest Service, but don't anticipate that there will be changes made to that document.
50:42 Mr. Sill from the Inyo National Forest, who is our point of contact for this, is available on the call this morning as well to answer any questions you have. This concludes my overview, though, and I'm happy to take any questions you have. I request that your board will approve this collection agreement with the Inyo National Forest. Thank you. Thank you, Elaine. Does anyone have any questions for Nathan or comments? Nathan, where are you? There you are.
51:13 Nathan, thank you very much for this. Just to remind all of us in ESCOG, this is all part of the plan. This is how, you know, we as ESCOG work with our federal partners to advance projects. The degree to which we're successful with these types of efforts, again, I'm going to be your favorite broken record for all of us as we go forward. Hundreds of millions, billions of dollars that can be coming to our region.
51:37 as part of our Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem Management Program. This is specifically focused on the fuels and firework we got to do. Sustainable recreation is right in there with all the rest of it. So Nathan, thanks for all your work on this. Of all the members of the team that brought this forward, I enthusiastically support this. And this is not a one-off thing. We're going to be doing a lot of this kind of work going forward. So very exciting to see this as kind of the first part of that. So thank you, Nathan. Thank you all. Welcome. Thank you. Stacy?
52:09 Yeah, I just want to add my appreciation, and I don't think it could be overstated how complex this plan is, and it's just wonderful to see it being implemented. So thanks to all of you on this meeting. I see Janet, Holly, Rick, Elaine, Nathan.
52:30 John, thank you all so, so, so much for this, and I'd be happy to make a motion to approve the collection agreement. I would second that. Great. Call for a vote. Chair Schwartz? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Aye. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Excuse me. Supervisor Totoro? Aye. Council Member Ellis?
53:05 Yes. And I believe Mayor Salcedo is still off the call. Thank you. Wonderful. Thank you, Nathan. Thank you, everyone. Moving on to 5.4. Consideration and direction regarding proposals received in response to the Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator Project Management Request for Proposal. Elaine? Good morning once more. I appreciate...
53:34 Supervisor Corliss's words, obviously, it is a very complex project with moving pieces to get the CDFW grant and the Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator up and running. One of those first things was issuing a request for proposals to bring on a project management consultant to complete
53:59 one part of the scope of work in the CDFW, which is project management, assisting the ESCOG with identifying the appropriate consultants for environmental planning, and working on components of the project implementation, such as public outreach and workforce development. Your board reviewed and approved that request for proposals at our October meeting. It was published on October 20th.
54:26 and noticed for 30 days. The ESCOG received one proposal on response to that from the Whitebark Institute of Interdisciplinary Environmental Sciences, also known as the Whitebark Institute. To try and address some of the timing issues we have with bimonthly meetings, I had requested that your board establish a subcommittee to review and approve
54:56 and make a recommendation on the proposals we received. Unfortunately, it has worked out such that I can also bring the proposal before your board for consideration and direction today. I did provide the proposal we received to the subcommittee, and I have received input from them that
55:15 They've reviewed it, and the Whitebark Institute has presented a thorough understanding of the scope of work, in particular, a thorough understanding of the intent of establishing the interdisciplinary team for third-party NEPA in the future, and is exceptionally qualified to implement the scope of work as defined in their request for proposals. In addition, their proposal came
55:42 in budget for what has been allocated through the CDFW grant. At our meeting in October, your board authorized me to negotiate and execute an agreement with the team that was recommended for the team that is selected coming out of the RFP. At this time, I would like to ask your board
56:09 to provide direction to staff to begin negotiations and entering into agreement with the Whitebark Institute. Following that, the next steps will be to work with the Whitebark Institute to finalize the request for proposals for the environmental planning team. And then we are off and running with the project work and getting started on the Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator.
56:36 I'm happy to take questions you have on this. I also see that Janet Hatfield of the Whitebark Institute has joined us on the call today, and I believe I also saw Ms. Holly Alpert is available to answer questions as well. Thank you. Elaine, does anyone have any questions or comments? I support this, but I particularly support it because of what's in the direction from the ESCOG and the intent of the grant was around local hiring.
57:12 and building local capacity. And it's great to know that after the RFP process was completed with all its appropriate due diligence, it looks like we're going to have some local people working on this thing. I think perhaps Supervisor Corliss could speak a little bit from the Forest Resilience Task Force of that.
57:30 this keen interest of building local capacity, building good-paying local regional jobs, and this could be a pretty significant opportunity for this. So again, many thanks out to all the members of the team that pulled this together. First target is the donut, but a third-party NEPA ID team is going to have enormous benefits for sustainable recreation as well, which is consistent with the entire work plan of the shrimp, our dearly beloved shrimp. Don't eat them for Christmas.
57:58 ESCOG is fashioned and put together. So this is a very exciting moment and a very exciting day. So I'm fully supportive of this. Thank you. Thanks, John. Stacey? I already said the comments that, of course, apply to this item even more so than the last. But as John said, I mean, this is exactly the type of work, type of project. Every little piece of this puzzle that has been put together adds up or really
58:32 Puts together a beautiful picture of the type of forest restoration work that both the state and federal government are hoping to get done. And we're making it, thanks to all your work, we're making it happen here in the Eastern Sierra. So thank you. I can't even comprehend how much work it was to even put this proposal together. And I'm so excited to, you know.
59:01 Keep moving forward and get this work done on the ground. The entire state. Hi, Jim. When Stacy got done, I moved. So I had to go chase myself. Hey, I just, to look back and when we started this JPA not very long ago to see where we are today, it's pretty incredible the fact that we've come this far and that the pieces are falling in place. Elaine, thank you. And I agree with Mr. Wentworth that
59:36 To see 455, or the number just disappeared, coming back to local economy is great. I think that's kind of what we're all here for is to try to get our economy moving and get, but to see that kind of money, but I think, Elaine, the component I like the best is that you have people who are here who know the area. We all know from living here that they're, you know, what happens here.
1:00:00 On paper and what happens here in reality, there's little fine tunings that have to be done and subcultures and different things. So it's great to see people who actually know the area and can navigate what's rather difficult at times. But I just want to probably say kudos to everyone for involved in this, to see us, you know, the funding sources fall in place, the grants fall in place, the bridge loans. We're moving forward, guys.
1:00:29 A good way to end a not the best of years, but here we go. Attack. I agree with you, Jim. It's just a great example of, you know, local constituents seeing an issue, going after, finding an opportunity, partnering with a local agency, and actually partnering with the Forest Service to really benefit the entire community. It blows my mind that everything laid out. And really, thank you.
1:01:00 You know, to John for seeing the vision. I would not have been able to see this as an outcome when we had our first initial little meeting at a coffee shop eight years ago, and it's wonderful. So thank you everyone for seeing it and putting forth the effort and going back to your constituents and getting the support for something like this. I look forward to more in the future. Anyone else? Any comments? Very quickly, I agree with all the comments. We'll be coming.
1:01:34 More of a region, damn it, and that's good. Great. Would anyone like to? I'll be happy to make a motion to approve this agenda item as presented, and I'll just echo what everyone said. Very impressive proposal, and I think just lays out amazing work, and it's going to have benefits for a really long time.
1:02:04 Karen, that's also a good trip down memory lane to remember that coffee shop meeting and to, you know, see how far we've come since then. Yes. Yes, and to honor the Great Basin Bakery where all good things happen, I'd like to second the motion from Supervisor Griffiths. Great, call for a vote. Chair Schwartz? Yes. Council Member Whitworth? Aye. Supervisor Corliss?
1:02:33 Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Supervisor Totharo? Aye. Council Member Jim Ellis? Supermative. Thank you, and I believe Mayor Salcedo is still off the line. Thank you. Great. Moving on to 5.5, we also had an addendum that Angela sent to us yesterday.
1:03:07 Everyone received that in their emails. And we'll move on to 5.5, Discussion and Direction to Submit a Notice of Interest for the California Hazard Mitigation Program Funding Opportunity. Is this you, Elaine? Yes, good morning. I don't know if Mr. Cattleman has joined us, so I'll certainly invite him to speak and elaborate on my introductory comments.
1:03:37 But this is a follow-up item from the special meeting held last week on December 3rd. Mr. Cattleman provided a public comment that there is a grant opportunity through the California Office of Emergency Services for Cal OES channeling some FEMA funding for hazard mitigation grant program. It's a rather sizable fund that's available and in order for
1:04:05 Agencies to participate, you have to provide a notice of interest by December 31st, 2021. The fund will provide financing for local hazard mitigation plans and then moreover for fuels reduction and hardening for communities and safety projects associated with wildfire risk. After submitting a notice of interest,
1:04:36 within the month of December, Cal OES will review those, and then you'll be invited to submit a full application in March. Mr. Kalman has graciously prepared a notice of interest for the ESCOG to submit, if that is your board's direction. That is the addendum that was sent out yesterday for your review. That notice of interest was a request for $1.6 million.
1:05:02 for funding for fuels reduction and hardening for critical infrastructure across the Eastern Sierra. That would be $1.2 million in federal funding with a $400,000 local non-funding match that can be provided through either work in kind or as a cash contribution. Staff today is requesting that your board consider
1:05:31 the Notice of Interest, and if appropriate, direct staff to submit that to at least keep the SCOG in consideration for applying for this funding in the future. With that, I'll invite Mr. Kettleman to provide any comments in addition to my staff report. Thank you. Thanks, Elaine. You captured all that very well. Since the background context of this thing,
1:06:00 is that since getting involved with the regional forest and fire capacity program a couple of years ago, one of the most obvious needs in our whole region has been a need to protect our public buildings and the public spaces that immediately surround them.
1:06:23 Now, obviously, the two most recently constructed county buildings are pretty darn safe. They're concrete and not much landscaping. So the newest buildings are in fabulous shape from a fire safety perspective. But sadly, virtually everything else, if you even take a casual glance, is not. And that...
1:06:48 is our fire stations, our sheriff's stations, our schools in particular, even our two historic courthouses could use some work from a fire safety point of view. So if protecting the public buildings from both a
1:07:13 You know, continuity of government point of view and just minimizing future replacement costs, you know, is important to everybody. There is an opportunity through CALI OES using some FEMA funds and apparently, from what we learned, there is a heck of a lot of them as
1:07:35 Council Member Wentworth referred to earlier, just the hundreds of millions of dollars in circulation is daunting. But because of this arcane formula that FEMA disperses their monies, California literally has hundreds of millions of dollars in their fire mitigation pot for the next couple of years or several years.
1:08:01 Early this year, Sierra Nevada Conservancy asked the RFFCP for a kind of a demonstration project idea. The public buildings thing rose to the top of the heap. They liked it, but they thought that FEMA was a much better funding source for this. So that's how we got directed in that direction. It seemed like an obvious fit for ESCOG.
1:08:28 Attack this on a regional basis where there's some economies of scale. Project would probably require hiring two or three people to provide kind of the expertise in building hardening and re-landscaping in a more fire-safe manner. And then virtually all the rest of the work could be done by public works staff, I think, if there's capacity available in all the different jurisdictions.
1:08:58 As Elaine mentioned, there's a 25% match, which can be in kind. And I think should you like the idea, we submit the notice of interest and start building a proposal next year that the real budget and those numbers, I mean, just really came out of thin air. I mean, just...
1:09:24 based on $100,000 per the four jurisdictions as the match. I had no basis whatsoever for coming up with those numbers, but they need something to start with. And all of this is super flexible. And the notice of interest, should you decide to go ahead with this, commits ESCOG to absolutely nothing. We can drop this idea at any point if it becomes
1:09:51 Untenable for any number of reasons. But if we don't get a foot in the door, nothing will happen. As Supervisor Gardner said earlier on the first agenda item, it's potentially a long journey, but you got to make that first step. And the first step would be a notice of interest. With respect to how big to make this, I would want to defer to public works departments.
1:10:21 to just what could they reasonably accomplish with their staff and budgets over a three-year period. These grants are for 36 months. And realistically speaking, from other counties in California that have dealt with FEMA grants, this is a long process, even though they in their
1:10:46 Their little two-pager about this program said that decisions would be made this year. That's very unlikely. It's probably 23, if not 24, that anything would start. FEMA is just slow from everything I've heard from other folks that have dealt with them.
1:11:11 And that's kind of, you know, that's the basics as we see it. I'd be happy to entertain any questions. Thanks. I'll just say I'm super excited about this. You know, I definitely at the last CSAC conference and I've been hearing a lot lately that, you know, home hardening and building hardening is going to become equally as important as forest management. And, you know, given the amount of time that it's going to take to do forest management, that
1:11:46 Home, home hardening is really important. And then, you know, if we have these big destructive neighborhood type fires, the fire department and the, you know, social services buildings are gone and we're really in deep trouble. So I'm excited about this and hopefully it has legs. Yeah, I'm excited as well. Jeff, it kind of sounded like a motion, but I didn't hear it, so I'm not going to second anything.
1:12:15 Really supportive, Rick. Again, thanks for keeping those good sharp eyes out on the horizon for these types of weird buried opportunities that will have big long-term implications for us. And again, all of the money that's out there, it's going to need to attach to something. And if we're attached to this,
1:12:33 The money can get attached to us. One other thing I would mention is the SRTI is that climate resilience assessment we did. There's a lot of information in there that can be used as rationale for proposals and for grants for things like that. We're way ahead of the rest of the state in having that type of analysis. And there's $15 billion in the climate change fund. So there's money out there. There's a lot of ways to do good things with it. So if anybody wants to make a motion, I'll be more than happy to second. Stacey has a question.
1:13:01 Well, I'll make the motion unless Jeff wants to go back and make it. You can do that. Okay. And just under further discussion, thank you, Rick and Holly and the RFFC program for, yeah, ferreting, finding the money that's out there. There's a lot of, what I see as a continued conundrum for the state is there's a lot of money out there.
1:13:29 But it's, you know, distributed among so many different agencies that it's hard to find. Jeff, Bob, actually, I think both Bob Gardner and Bob Lawton, we were all at this California State Association of Counties conference with a really good wildfire presentation. Assemblymember Jim Wood, who's in North Bay Area, you know, he was very proud of the fact, and he should be, that they've gotten all this money out. He said things like, well,
1:13:58 We've provided you the tools, now go out and do it. It's like, well, yeah, thanks. I mean, I hate to be a pest, but it's really hard to get the money. So thank goodness we do, through Sierra Nevada Conservancy, have the capacity building program. But I would just urge both Rick and Holly and all of us, if we have specific comments on how this process could be made better, how the state could better and more efficiently and more easily get the money,
1:14:27 into local government and local agency hands. Please jot those down and send them to me so that I can pass that on. That's one thing I think I could actually do that would be productive as part of this state wildfire and forest resilience task force is help them and RCRC help them figure out how can we make this all a little easier. So, but all that said, I'll go back to moving to approve this application or whatever the recommended action is.
1:14:57 So, Madam Chair, if I could, under a little bit of further discussion, Supervisor Corliss hit on something that's very, very important, which is the state, with all this money, does not have the tools to get the money from Sacramento and the state coffers out and onto the ground. And the Fire Resilience Task Force is looking at existing collaboratives that exist across the state as informal as they may be to move this funding.
1:15:26 And there's going to be a lot of discussion in the coming weeks, months, years probably, of the formalization of these types of partnerships and collaboratives. We have the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership. These are the types of things where you aggregate the recreation interests and you aggregate the fire and fuel interests, then the state has got things on the ground they can move the money to to get work done on the ground.
1:15:52 We'll talk more about that as we go down the road, but that's, I think the Sierra Nevada Conservancy is tracking, I think, 20 different collaborators at the moment. Again, grassroots things like we've got in the Eastern Sierra that they're looking to potentially formalize, figure out how can we get the money from Sacramento to those folks get those things done on the ground. But I digress. I second the motion. Thank you. Offer a vote. Chair Schwartz? Yes. Council Member Wentworth?
1:16:23 Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Supervisor Totoro? Aye. Council Member Ellis? Yes. And again, I believe Mayor Salcedo is not on the call at this time. Thank you. Thank you so much, Rick, for bringing us. All right, moving on to 5.6, discussion and approval of the...
1:16:58 2022 ESCOG JPA meeting schedule. Looks good to me. Stacey? Yeah, you know, sorry I didn't notice this early. You know, I get like you look at it and then suddenly realize there's a conflict. Friday, February 11th, I think many of us county folk may be either in D.C. or en route for the National Association of Counties Legislative Conference. So wondering if we could move that a week back or a week up.
1:17:36 I would request consideration of a week back, if that's possible, a little earlier. Meaning the 4th? Yeah. I could do the 4th, I could not do the 18th. Let's go for the 4th. The 4th works for me. Anyone else? Any comments? The 4th is not good for me. That's the Consetica Tribal Council. Is that all day, Bob, or is that morning or afternoon? No, it's just the morning. It's just the morning. How about, could we do like maybe after lunch thing? So on the 11th,
1:18:08 So just because ESTA's meeting as well, I won't be traveling until Tanako until the start of the conference. And I'll be doing my line afterwards. So I don't know if Bob, and I don't think Dan's going. So I don't know. Bob, are you going early as well? Well, the public land starts like 9 a.m. on Saturday this time. So we've got to travel Friday to be there.
1:18:38 You know, I'm totally messed up my dates. I will be gone. Sorry. Yeah, all the committees need Saturdays. We do the 28th? Does that work? January? That doesn't work for me. Would the idea of the 4th in the afternoon, or did that not work for folks? Yeah. 4th in the afternoon's good. Okay, with me, let's do that. So what time? 1. 1?
1:19:28 Okay. I may not be able to do the fourth, now that I look at it, but if it's in the afternoon, I may be able to use it. All right, well, let's just stick with the fourth at one. Does that work for you, Elaine? Yes, thank you. Do we, so we have to approve this schedule, or can we give the, give changing that date, because we should talk with ESTA too,
1:20:04 They may have the same issues. We could probably approve it at one of our meetings that we have to meet at because of the public health issue. Maybe we could send out an email and approve it at one of those meetings, right? Would that work? Yes, that's fine.
1:20:37 Just to follow up on that, I want to just for all this to be clear, these public health meetings, Elaine, I've tried just ever so subtly and nicely to say, hey, Elaine, if we got to meet on these alternate Fridays, maybe we could do a little bit of business. Elaine has said, look, don't push that. We're not going to be meeting outside of the regular meetings. Elaine, do you want to just articulate that publicly to the group while we got them here?
1:21:08 Thank you, Councilman. We can agendize things as necessary. I think certainly approving this schedule on January 7th would be appropriate. I just also want to be sensitive that those opportunities for us to get together don't creep into larger meetings, given that everyone probably has other things on their schedule and everyone is very busy. So I'm certainly just trying to be sensitive to the board's schedule and time with that.
1:21:36 But if there's like some minor administrative thing or something we had to take, we could maybe take care of something like that. Absolutely. No. Yeah. Okay. Just checking. Thanks. And I don't want to complicate things. We could just set it for the fourth if I'm the only one who can't make it on the fourth in the afternoon. You just do the fourth in the afternoon and call it good and approve it right now. Make it easy. Yes.
1:22:05 I move we change the meeting on in February to February 4th at 1 p.m. and stay with the other items as stated in the schedule in the agenda. Second. Call for a vote. Chair Schwartz? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Supervisor Totheroe? Aye. Excuse me. Council Member Ellis?
1:22:37 Yep. And I believe Mayor Salcedo is still not with us. Thank you. Excuse me, Chair Schwartz, I've got to jump off right now myself. I would defer to my colleague, Supervisor Corliss, for a report from Mono County, and I apologize to Councilman Wentworth, although I have heard his SRTI summary twice. So I will bid you all farewell, and I think you still have a quorum, so you're okay. Bob. All right. Damn it.
1:23:12 Okay, bye, Bob. Moving on to receive an update on the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative. Thank you, Madam Chair. And again, many of you have probably seen this once, a couple of times. This is probably more for the public record, but also there are two items in here that I think I would like to request for agendizing at future ESCOG meetings.
1:23:40 And Elaine, I can do that. I want to get to the end once we've gone through this. So excuse me if I go. I don't want to go quickly, but I'll try to move through this deliberately so that we can get through this. And if anybody's got any questions, just wave your hand. Or Madam Chair, if you'd rather wait just for questions to do at the end, we can do that. So this is extracted from the presentation that was given to the public Wednesday evening. It's a virtual wrap-up meeting for the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative.
1:24:09 This presentation today is primarily focused, this is for the benefit of the ESCOG, for our audience, for the public record, and for members of the ESCOG to give an update on what's been happening with these various projects. A key takeaway from where we are at at this point is this transition from the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, which will continue and endure, the Sustainable Recreation Tourism Initiative, which is
1:24:38 Going out of business, for all intents and purposes, the next month or so, and transitioning to this partnership between the ESSRP and the ESCOG. This relationship has been codified in the draft MOU between that the ESCOG, the ESSRP will be circulating, that will bind the ESSRP members together.
1:25:00 And Grace and Elaine were kind enough to take some time to really refine the language of the future relationship between the ESSRP and the ESCOG. So this is...
1:25:10 This whole thing is going to go on and endure as the SRTI wraps up and completes its project deliverables. And it's just the timeliness of the work we've been doing. No one could have predicted, but this was just yesterday afternoon when the Secretary of the Interior, Deb Haaland and Wade Crowfoot, and the state announced
1:25:31 A billion dollars, a billion plus to expand outdoor access, $548 million to create and vitalize parks across California. There's no need to be hyperbolic about this, but the amount of money that is flowing, it's just unprecedented. And for us to be in a position, having put these institutions together, this is really a moment. This is our moment. We as civic leaders really need to step up and make sure we take full advantage of it.
1:26:00 This is generational. It's not going to come around as long as we're all alive. So here we are. And it's really time for us to be acting. So all the projects that were ultimately recommended for funding were informed by a prospectus for investment that the ESSRP put together with about a 10-year horizon to make sure that investments that go into sustainable recreation programs and infrastructures guided by some kind of
1:26:27 a strategy for investment, what's desired, and then they were assembled ultimately into a portfolio of the final eight projects. And we'll walk quickly through what these are. The first is the buttermilk.
1:26:40 The Buttermilk Infrastructure and Recreation Planning Initiative, the Burpee, which will fund recreation infrastructure improvements for toilets and trails and provide focused recreation planning in the Buttermilk bouldering area and conceptual long-term recreation planning in the Buttermilk project area. A funding source was identified through NIFWF, the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation, highlighted in red there.
1:27:03 And as you can see, you're all very familiar with the geography and the terrain of what this project is about. And Elaine and the ESCOG received notice that the NIFWF has approved $247,300 for this project. And this is anticipated to be funded at that amount.
1:27:20 The Visitor Connection Program would coordinate in-person opportunities, create content and a website for digital outreach, develop employee training, coordinate kiosks and signage, develop a strategic plan, and research our visitor audience to maximize messaging efficacy. This is a classic situation. If we don't tell our story and define ourselves, someone else is going to do it for us. And that's already happening. It's happening out of the TRPA. It's happening in the Sierra Nevada Alliance. It's happening out of the Geotourism Initiative.
1:27:49 This is something that we really need to consider investing in for ourselves. We identified a funding opportunity through the EDA. The regional representative advised us to go build more gas stations, which seemed to be kind of a disconnect, but I'll leave that to others to make a determination about that. This effort was locally generated by local thought leaders and the DMO, the marketing, NGOs, visitor, the frontline folks who engage with our visitor audience.
1:28:18 And this is one of the items, Elaine, that I would like to bring back as an agenda item at the February meeting to consider, for the ESCOG to consider investing in this program. And I think the SOTI team would love to work with you to develop a staff report and recommendations for this. It's unfortunate that we have a reasonable representative in the EDA that is so...
1:28:39 invested in fossil fuels, but that's a whole other conversation. The regional recreation capacity, which we started talking about today, this is for the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments as a joint powers authority.
1:28:51 And we will be applying for future funding on behalf of the Sustainable Recreation and Ecosystem Management Program. That is our charge. That's what we're going to do. But for its long-term resilience, the ESCOG will require organizational capacity and institutional support to administer, identify, and participate funding opportunities for our SHRIMP program. Again, we went to the EDA. They have about a, you know,
1:29:14 $500 million program around recreation and tourism. Again, we were advised to build more gas stations. This is what we've got with this ESCOG. You know, we have created an institution that can identify and bring federal, state, and private sector investment into our region. And it's working. It's functioning. It's working. And
1:29:38 As I mentioned before, this institution is tied into the ESSRP through the draft MOU, which will be circulated next year. And the ESCOG is making possible things like this $3.4 million grant from CDFW. Here's a visualization of what Janet Padfield dreams about at night, and she was kind enough to turn it into a slide for a PowerPoint presentation. But it gets this complicated.
1:30:02 But it brings in big money. So this is another item, Elaine, that I would like to consider for the agenda in February. This effort, many of you may have heard, was nominated by the Regional Forester as one of several projects nominated from Eastern Sierra. I guess the award should have been announced yesterday. I don't know who won anything, but the ESCOG was nominated. All of us and Elaine was nominated along with Janet.
1:30:27 Plumas Corporation, White Park Institute. So we're having some impact statewide. And here it is. Let's bring it back to the ESCOG. Let's start talking about how we are going to vest in the ESCOG for this program, but for SEDS, for regional economic development. There are times in life we all know when you got to spend some money to make some money. And we're in that place. And so looking forward to moving forward with that.
1:30:54 Eastern Sierra Campground Improvements. The ESCOG will need to close a capacity gap for opportunities to fund Inyo National Forest Campground Improvements that spill over very quickly into campgrounds in Inyo County. ESCOG is pursuing funding to perform necessary technical and financial analysis, stakeholder public outreach, and fund or engagement to finance construction for a national opportunity funded by the U.S. Forest Service's Innovative Finance for National Forest Program.
1:31:23 This was identified as a good opportunity to go to the Sierra Nevada Conservancy with Prop 68 funding. Again, you've seen this many times. These are the campgrounds in the Inyo National Forest. All the campgrounds in Inyo County could benefit and should benefit from a financing program like this. The business plan is in place. This is recently completed. And the ESCOG needs to have the capacity and the tools to engage with this opportunity.
1:31:50 which is ultimately a $30 million ask. It's a $30 million project we're talking about trying to do here. Again, another nominee for the Regional Foresters Award. Hope somebody won something. The concept proposal was submitted to the SNC, who said this was not a good match for Prop 68. It did not line up properly.
1:32:09 However, the Quantified Ventures submitted a grant application to the Innovative Finance for National Forest Program, and they have been awarded. So this program will continue. And I think you all had a chance to meet with members of the QV team who are out here. I know Elaine did. But this program is going to be going on for another couple of years. We're going to need to find a way to get Elaine, the tools, and the ESCOG team to engage with this project. The Town to Trails Plan.
1:32:36 The ESCOG sought funding to develop a region-wide trail system in collaboration with ESSRP partners. Eastern Sierra communities will be provided with opportunities to envision, create, maintain a trail system connecting towns and cities to public lands and to each other. That was the project proposal and the very good opportunity again to the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. The application was submitted.
1:33:02 And again, that gives you an idea of what we're trying to do here to connect all of our communities to each other and to the public landscape that defines us. And Elaine has been advised that the ESCOG will be, that this project is being recommended for the SNC Board for approval in March to the tune of $370,443. So that's a
1:33:24 Very good success. The Desirsk Camp and Camp Like a Pro program, Mono County will be the lead applicant for this project. And Mono County will be seeking funding to enhance outreach, expand waste management, reducing instances of human-caused wildfires through information sharing and enforcement. And this program could have significant
1:33:47 Benefits to Inyo County and the southern part of our region in the fall, winter, spring seasons when the climbing, the climbers show up. We get the snow and the skiers up here in the north part of the region and down south. We've got enormous challenges with dispersed camping. Elaine knows about this personally because, well, there are neighbors and Dan's neighbors for nine months out of the year. A grant.
1:34:14 A concept proposal is in to the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. This was yet another project nominated for Regional Foresters Award. And again, I hope somebody got some prizes out of all this.
1:34:26 And so we will see what happens with the concept proposal submitted to the S&C. There's another funding opportunity through Clean California, which is a California grant program, a billion-dollar program that the governor is personally invested in to really clean up the state and do what we can to make the state as appealing and compelling in its byways, highways, and built infrastructure as it is in its natural infrastructure. So more to come on that one.
1:34:55 On the vulnerability in California's Eastern Sierra Asset Inventory and Gap Analysis, a funding opportunity was identified through the California Resilience Challenge to implement the recommended actions, some of the recommended actions coming out of our vulnerability assessment that would specifically do updates to all the GIS data in all of our regional databases, some of the Forest Service GIS database.
1:35:23 information. Dan Tothrock did the original scanning and compiling of those things.
1:35:29 A couple years ago. They have not been touched since. So as we move into having to adapt to climate change, moving roads, moving campgrounds, we're going to need a solid foundation of where everything is in order to access a lot of funding that will be coming out. That application has been submitted and we should be hearing, Elaine should be hearing in mid-December when that will be available. I don't think we're mid-December yet. Are we in double digits yet in December? What's the date today? Eh, we're not really mid. Eh, we're close.
1:35:59 So we'll hear more about this soon. The final project is the Eastern Sierra Scenic Byway. And the original intention for this was to look at refurbishing the byway. But it's becoming painfully clear that nobody actually owns this project. It's not owned by anybody. It's not administered by anybody. No one has the authority to improve it. So this is going to be an interesting question, interesting challenge.
1:36:29 I know we've heard from Caltrans and the Forest Service that, you know what, if infrastructure gets beyond its useful life, it should be returned perhaps to what the natural setting in this situation was before it got there in the first place. But this will be something for the ESSRP partners to discuss probably in the first part of next year. So that's an update on the SRTI program. We are going to have, the team is having its last sort of formal work.
1:36:58 Towards the end of next week, Christy Williams will be working for a couple months to wrap things up and we're coordinating with Elaine, tying up loose ends, making sure we get public communications out to everybody. But Madam Chair and Elaine, those two items, the visitor connection package and the capacity for the ESCOG are two items I'm hoping we can bring back for further discussion. More than happy to entertain any questions. Hope you like the show. We had a great time on, what was that?
1:37:26 Was it last night? No, Wednesday night. Wonderful project. A lot of fun. And thank you all for your indulgence of my time here. I'm more than happy to answer any questions. John, is there a hard copy or a possibility of getting a hard copy of the final report? Yeah, there will be a, well, what are you looking for? Are you looking for like a summary thing or? Yeah, yeah.
1:38:00 Yeah, let's talk about that. We're still, Christy Williams is doing all the final reporting, you know, the financial, all that kind of stuff. There are, I could put some links in the chat of, like, if you wanted to look at the presentation or get the recording from the other night, you probably don't want to do that. But we can talk offline. We'll figure out which, interested to know what you need and how we can provide some new work for you. Okay. Yeah. Thanks, John. I also attended on Wednesday. It was great community outreach. I think you had.
1:38:32 quite a few people online, and thanks for coming to present to the City of Bishop in January. Any other comments? Okay, great. Well, then let's move on to board member agency reports. Let's hear from Inyo County. Hey, let's see. I will, or Dan, do you want to go first or do you want me to go first?
1:39:04 Okay, so I'll start with redistricting. That's the exciting thing on our plate. Grace knows all about it. We are looking to make some pretty dramatic changes due to some population trends that have been happening for a while, but I've gotten to a place where we cannot ignore them anymore. It's proven to be a bit challenging to come up with
1:39:31 A new redistricting plan. So as far as District 2, my district, that's the most stable one. It looks like it is going to shrink to be just the city limits of the city of Bishop. The other four are quite up in the air. There has been population growth in the northern part of the county and population decline in the southern part of the county. So it looks like the 5th district will be moving north, taking on more
1:40:01 Terrain and population in order to balance things out and how that all shakes out is to be determined. We have a deadline of next Tuesday in order to make our final determinations. There is also an intriguing proposal to make a majority Native American district. And so we are actively seeking public comment and hopefully we will have that all.
1:40:29 Figure it out and we'll figure out what happens on Tuesday. We got a report recently about cannabis activity, legal cannabis activity in the county and things were pretty quiet for the last 18 months but they have picked up and so it looks like there are some additional proposals.
1:40:54 for grow operations and a distributor in southern Inyo County. We do continue to have a fairly serious problem with illegal grows, both on public lands and also on private land in the far southeast corner of our county. And so we're looking at strategies to deal with that.
1:41:19 Marshall Rudolph retired as our County Council and well-deserved retirement. Mr. John Vallejo has been appointed as the County Council and we thank the County for donating both of those individuals to us and it's not intentional poaching your people but sometimes people like the warmer climes. Let's see, we next Tuesday we will have our
1:41:48 First presentations on the American Rescue Plan dollars that will be coming into Inyo County and deciding what to do with that. Looks like a substantial investment and so I look forward to seeing what sort of new and innovative programs we can design with that. On the 19th in the Bishop Airport we will have our first commercial flight.
1:42:12 So it's another opportunity for the ESCOG to pat itself on the back of successfully navigating that process through a regional effort. Our sheriff, Sheriff Halliwell, has announced that he is retiring in the middle of this month. So we will be going through the process of appointing a new sheriff to serve out the remainder of his term.
1:42:39 And that will be interesting to see who applies for that, given that the election is coming up next year. And we formally named our new consolidated office building, the Clint Quilter Consolidated Office Building, in honor of our late county administrator. And I just have one thing to add. Yesterday, the Owens Valley groundwater...
1:43:09 Association met and we now have an approved groundwater sustainability plan that will be sent to the state. Great. And one other thing I just did want to bring up that I found really intriguing from the CSAC conference is it was mentioned earlier there was a great presentation on wildfire mitigation efforts and as part of that
1:43:38 I first learned about something called the Venado Declaration that former Governor Jerry Brown has taken a great interest in accelerating and being more effective in our forest management and home and building hardening efforts. And so he convened a whole bunch of people and they came up with something called the Venado Declaration, which is
1:44:07 I think it's spot on. It has some controversial things, including sort of a re-interpretation of CEQA and NEPA to have the no-action alternative taking into account that it's also going to burn down if there's no action, and a lot of other stewardship-type initiatives.
1:44:33 And so I think that's something we may want to formally support as a Regent at some point, but certainly something to keep an eye on. And also, I was elected to the Executive Board for CSAC to represent the rural counties. Great. Thank you, Inyo County. How about Town of Mammoth Lakes? I will and I must defer to the Mayor.
1:45:08 And I, in turn, will defer back to the Mayor Pro Tem to take a first glance at this, and I'll see if we miss anything. Thanks. Okay. Good to know you're watching, Linda. Mammoth, it snowed a little bit, but as cold, and it's going to snow a lot more. So that's good for water, fire, fuels, all the rest of it.
1:45:36 Council will be meeting this coming week, I believe. We're watching all this redistricting activity and making sure that all of our various interests get represented. Housing is moving forward. That's all I have. So, Madam Mayor, the balance will be yours. Okay. The Housing and the Community Recreation Center, aka the ice rink.
1:46:03 are pretty much locked up for the winter as far as working on it, but they did get some extra time in there with a nice weather, so we made some good progress on that. I think that it is going to snow more, there's a holiday, there's some big events coming up, which lead me to remind everyone that if you haven't already gotten your booster, your COVID booster, please try to do so. We're finding that the people who have not received boosters are much more likely to
1:46:33 Incur a case of COVID, so please continue to be careful. We're not out of this yet, unfortunately. And other than that, I think that's the main stuff for everybody. Thank you. Mono County. Sure, I'll start. And then if our CAO wants to weigh in, he can. I'll start with redistricting since Inyo covered that as Gesundheit. We...
1:47:05 We're set to, we have published six alternative maps. Really, there are probably four that are most likely to be under consideration. There were two variations that go slightly above the allowed 10% population variance. So I think it's likely that with a slight change in the Long Valley area that doesn't really affect any community. So I'm imagining we're going to
1:47:33 Probably not seriously consider the two variants, the two maps that go above 10%. So our board, last month, a majority of our board voted to basically keep the districts the same. The supervisor Kreitz and I voted against making the decision that early because what it means is basically four districts.
1:48:01 Supervisorial Districts remain within the town of Mammoth Lakes. So the fourth district, which is the primarily North County District, John Peter's seat, will continue to have a wraparound, come down the East Shore of Mono Lake and dip into the northern part of Mammoth. But exactly what that looks like is what our maps address. So there are basically four different
1:48:30 variations of supervisorial districts within the town of Mammoth. You know, Mono County's population shrank, and we did have to make some major adjustments to the supervisorial districts within Mammoth. They were underpopulated according to the census status. So really, at this point, trying to get in touch with people who live within the town, have them take a look at these maps and tell us which ones they prefer.
1:49:00 Two districts would be, as they are now, almost 100% within the incorporated town. And one district, that's District 3, Bob Gardner's District, which covers the Mono Basin and the northwestern part of Mammoth, is somewhere 58-59% within population out of Mammoth Lakes. So still a majority Mammoth Lakes population district.
1:49:30 We'll see what happens and we're poised to make that decision at our board meeting on Tuesday. Also, otherwise in the county, we're going through a robust strategic planning effort involving staff and the board that's underway, looking to complete that by early next year, I think.
1:50:01 Going back to the wildfire forest resilience discussion, one thing Supervisor Gardner and I are discussing is putting together some kind of wildfire summit in the spring. I would certainly open up that if there's interest in doing that through the ESCOG, we could. Really what both...
1:50:25 Council Member Wentworth and I attended a tour of the Caldor Fire Footprint. It was just incredible information. And that was through the State Wildfire and Forest Resilience Task Force that I sit on the Executive Committee, you know, representing California's rural counties. So, so much information. And as Jeff mentioned, basically the...
1:50:46 The document produced by former Governor Brown's group, everything's in alignment. Nobody really right now in leadership of either the Forest Service or Cal Fire or other state agencies is saying anything else. It's just how do we really get everything aligned to get done what needs to be done? So I think having presentations, so what Bob Gardner and I were thinking is just having presentations both on the state and federal efforts.
1:51:15 our local situation, you know, and what can people do, how can people get involved, you know, get funding for things like home hardening and find out what we as their local government representatives are doing to address the wildfire situation. So I'll stay tuned on that, but if we want to bring that back as a potential agenda item maybe in February to discuss, I'm happy to do so and I'm happy to do a little more work.
1:51:43 what a potential wildfire summit agenda might look like. Other than that, I think I'll leave it at that and turn it over to Bob Lawton. I don't know if he's still there. One thing I will say, you know, Linda could elaborate, but you're welcome, Inyo County. Mono County now has the worst COVID numbers in the state. Fortunately, our health outcomes still appear to be
1:52:12 All right. Is that a fair assessment, Linda? But our numbers. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's really very true. And, you know, we do some really robust testing at the schools. And so I think that, you know, a lot of those cases are driving out of the schools and then into the families of children. And so that's been a lot of it. But it is just still a lot. There was a couple of things that happened that seemed to be some events that happened that were driven out of those events. So, yeah, it's not time to.
1:52:39 to let down our sensibility around that, because it's winter, we all know what happens in winter when it's just a regular flu season. Good news is there's not a lot of flu out there, but there's certainly abundance of cases of COVID. So, very disappointing at this point, and it's just, you know, we've got to keep going. So, thanks, Stacey. All right, I'm not hearing from Mr. Lawton, so I'll say that's it. Thank you, Stacey. Jim, do you want to brief everyone on the City of Bishop?
1:53:17 Really briefly, I'd like to say to John Wentworth, it's good to see the SRTI come together in a real manageable, real specific targets that benefit the whole region, including the cities and counties and all the entities. So well done. It's good to see that. Similar in our little 2.2 square miles, my report's going to be kind of 2.2 square miles worth, can be short. We have before us this Monday, the kind of
1:53:47 End of our, let me see here, downtown specific plan, which is a Caltrans and state funded opportunity for us to review Bishop and kind of put it all together as far as our game plan of where we're going. And that's including the parking, the design standards, signage, walkability, mixed use zoning.
1:54:13 Rezoning. So it's a chance for Bishop to kind of, we had an outside agency come in and do a really great presentation, or not presentation, but analysis of Bishop, a lot of public input from it. And I think it's coming together and it'll set the tone for where Bishop's going in the future. We have an airport coming just outside our city, which is going to impact our city. So it'll be interesting to see where we go with all this. And that will be coming before us Monday.
1:54:41 And then we had a Christmas parade that was great, done by Chamber of Commerce, and all our city police department, public works, everyone came together and put together a great presentation. It's been summertime down here, so all this snow talk, John, it's crazy down here. I've been planting tomatoes and mowing lawns. We'll be right down. We'll be right down. We'll see. We'll get our shorts on. We'll see you this weekend. Yeah, come on down.
1:55:12 Yeah. And then my mind is kind of elsewhere at the moment. I have not seen my daughter in a little over a year. She's been living in Japan. I get a chance tomorrow at eight in the morning to meet my first granddaughter ever. And my mind is just going crazy. So it's, I've not seen my daughter in over a year since she moved there with her husband. And I, I don't know, it is just a crazy, I'm just getting old. The gray is really starting to get real now. Looking good, Jim, looking good.
1:55:42 Yeah, I was wondering when you got old. It happened. But this granddaughter thing is really getting worse. Jim, is your family in the Navy over there? Yeah. Yeah, my son's over there also. I think you and I talked about it. They're in... Yeah, that's great. Yeah, so it'll be interesting to just have this opportunity and squeeze this little girl. Really happy for you. That's great.
1:56:08 Thank you, guys. I will turn it back over to Karen to elaborate on my 2.2 square mile presentation. I don't have anything to add. That was a thorough report. So thank you, Jim. Anything? Okay, so I guess we're done with that. And any requests for future agenda items? I know John added a few in his report. Anyone else? Okay. Well, then we can adjourn this meeting to our next meeting, which I don't have the date written down. It's January when.
1:56:43 Seventh. Seventh. Seventh. Seventh. Okay. So we'll adjourn this meeting. Madam Chair, real quick. So, Lane, the issues around on the SEDS thing, working in parallel with the staff work and starting to work on a draft resolution, right? That's... Okay. Good. Thank you. Sorry. Sorry. One last question. Yeah. This request to make sort of an informal request of our bodies around, you know, participating in a SEDS development.
1:57:11 What is the expectation, do you think, for us to be doing that with our, do we need to agendize that? Do you want us to wait a little bit to get some more details? How would you like to do that? And what amount are we talking about?
1:57:24 I will confer with my colleagues in Inyo County who are spearheading this. I think once there's a better sense about which funding path they might want to pursue, I'll come back to your board and provide a little bit more specific request about what we're hoping that you can bring back to your agencies. Thank you. Yeah, we just don't want to be rolling, flaming bowling balls randomly around, if you get the metaphor. No one gets the metaphor. Okay, thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you.
1:57:59 All right. Well, then, let's adjourn this meeting to January 7th, and we'll see all of those who are on ESTA at 11 a.m. Okay. Thank you. Thanks, Elaine. Great to see everybody.