Town Council
at 15:15
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
417 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
4:42 Ready to say here. Good evening and welcome to this regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, November 15th. Jamie, if you could call us to order, please. Councilmember Bubser? Here. Councilmember Rae? Here. Councilmember Rice? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Present. Mayor Wentworth? Present.
5:13 It's my great honor to ask Dr. Tom Boo, if you would please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance this evening. Thank you. United States of America, the republic which ends, one nation under God. Thank you, doctor. Yeah. Okay, so we'll get started this evening with public comments. If anybody's got anything they'd like to speak to that's not on this evening's agenda. Sir, please come forward. Good afternoon. Good afternoon. My name is Michael.
6:10 And I'm one of your newer residents, just moved here in August. Welcome. Thank you. I'd like to speak to you about a modest proposal for a safe parking place. I notice we don't have one up and running, and I've spoken to a few folks who have informed me that it's been in the process for a while, and they're working on it, try to make it a reality. So I thought, as a person who would participate in such a program,
6:41 I'd come and encourage a speedier approach and just present one person's perspective on it. And to do so, I prepared this little handout. I didn't make enough copies. Maybe you guys can pass it along. Thank you. Well, I am here. This is my new home for an unusual reason. Mammoth Hospital is compassionate enough to accept Medi-Cal coverage.
7:41 Whereas most major medical centers throughout the state does not. So I'll be up here getting a long series of multiple surgeries. And as a person of limited resources living in his van, a safe parking place would mean a lot to me. I'd also present it to the city as a very convenient program that would allow the appropriate authorities to patrol and keep protected the participants, as opposed to dispersed camping or scattered parking throughout the area.
8:11 I've been talking to some folks and I've been hearing an array of ideas. Everything from using a particular title to charging a certain amount of money for participation. And I would try to emphasize that my motive for encouraging such a program is to help out the employees I've been meeting in your town. I'm quite stunned by the number of people that are working here in town.
8:41 But due to the limited housing inventory and their resources, they're living out of their car. And as a person who's doing that, albeit for different reasons, medical disability reasons, I can attest to how difficult it can be, how wearing could be on one's spirit and outlook. So I'm hoping that we could implement such a program swiftly and that we could, if anything, charge nothing. But if we have to charge something, make it a nominal rate.
9:11 So the participants may know that it's not charity but something that they've earned. Again, just to build to the character of the town and to help out the individuals in need. Because I think anyone who's ever been in a position where they were in need would know how important it is and how wonderful it feels to see your community respond accordingly. So that's my little pitch. I put a few things in here. It's just kind of an emotional motivation to get people to understand.
9:41 Where I'm coming from is that these needs exist, and they've existed for a long time, and out of sight, out of mind doesn't work. If anything, it only allows a problem to become a dire situation. And right now, from what I've heard, there's been rare occasions where people have been harmed by living in their car at night, and we'd like to keep that to a minimum, if not prevent it 100%. So safety, affordability,
10:11 And supporting the workforce so that we can keep up a quality of standard of care and a quality of life here would be the main motives for implementing such a program. And as far as reality, like the actual nuts and bolts, I've looked around at a few facilities, a few locations, but I learned from the city that they already have an idea in mind, they're just not in a position to disclose that, so I would defer to them. But I think there's ample opportunity in town, and that's what I'm pitching.
10:41 Thank you very much. Thank you for coming forward. And, sir, do you know Mr. Nolan Bob-Roff over here? Have you guys met? Good. I just want to make sure that he's in charge of that department that might be helping out with that program. Thank you very much. Okay, any other public comment? Yes, Mr. Boo. Dr. Boo, I'm sorry. Excuse me, Dr. Boo.
11:14 Good evening, Mayor, members of the council. I'm Tom Boo, and I was just reappointed by the county as the county health officer last Tuesday, so I just wanted to come by tonight, reintroduce myself, pay my regards, say hello to some old friends, and certainly encourage any of you, if there are any public health issues that you might want to discuss or whatever to reach out, but glad to be back.
11:42 Thank you. Does Dr. Tombu need any introduction? Any reintroduction? Welcome. Wonderful to have you back. Thanks, Tom. Yeah. Okay. Any other public comment? Jamie, anything out there in outer space? I did receive one email. Okay. It's from C.J. Sterling. He says, reflecting back on your recent meeting from four weeks ago, I just want to say that discrimination should never, ever have a place on this town council.
12:15 I am referring specifically to a council member that felt the need to angrily call out and lecture an entire sector of our local working community simply because of what they do for a living. And to take it even further, snidely asking which of those people held assets such as rental properties is unacceptable and frankly none of your business. It's clear now that decision making is being influenced and based on a dislike of a specific working sector of this community.
12:42 Not only is an apology way overdue, this should not be tolerated by the rest of the council. I respectfully ask that this position be resigned immediately. The public trust has been violated and I now have very little faith that this governing body can act professionally and vote on real life issues in a non-biased manner. Thank you. I guess if you wanted to. I did want to apologize for the tone of my comments on the October 18th board meeting.
13:16 Council meeting. I did actually email Stacey Castellano at the Board of Realtors to ask her if she would forward an apology on my behalf, and she declined to do that, which I totally understand, but I do regret not choosing my words more carefully and offending a really big section of our workforce that really loves this community, and I did want to apologize, so thank you for the opportunity to do that. Of course, thank you very much, Sarah. And thank you, Mr. Sterling, for writing in.
13:45 Okay, anybody else in the room or out there? Anything else, Jamie? Okay. All right, well, let's move on then to any additions to the agenda. Mr. Holler, anything you want to add? Okay, thank you. We'll move on then to reports from commissions and or departments. Yes, Dan. I'll kick one off real quick. You may have seen some of the social media and stuff, but we did close the Lakes Basin at 5 o'clock today, or we'll be closed at 5 today.
14:12 For the storm that's coming in, just a precautionary measure, how much snow we get or don't get there, we will look at the reopening of it as neat as we can, so it still may be open for additional use throughout this fall, depending until we get enough snow or the cross-country skiing activity would take off, but at this point it is closed, just a concern of people being up in there if the snow came in fairly heavy.
14:37 And we will monitor along with the Forest Service to look at reopening as we can if the weather holds as it's projected for another couple weeks potentially to have good weather and people to enjoy the basin. Excellent. Thank you, Dan. Who's Mr. Morris? I have some good news. Oh, good. We got the court's rulings in our twin Main Street Taxpayers Association cases, and the town's demurs in both cases have been sustained, which means both cases have been dismissed, and we win.
15:08 The plaintiff can, of course, appeal if he wants to go for round four. We've now won three times. But anyway, very good news for us. It's unfortunate we've had to spend taxpayer dollars to defend suits that were maybe not very strong in the first place, but good news for now. Thank you for that update and report. We're all very happy to hear that, and I'm sure the communities as well, so thank you. Oh, go ahead.
15:37 Thank you for your leadership on that. These are really challenging things that most people don't even know are happening, but they affect us very much, and the way that you guide us is much appreciated. Thank you. Happy to help. Counsel Morris. Thank you. Amy Callanan, Public Works. Thank you. I will go ahead and share my screen. I've got a construction update on the parcel project.
16:17 Hot off the presses. Mostly it's a slideshow with just a little bit of background information. I know you're all familiar with the parcel project, so just in brief, we've got under construction 81 units of affordable housing in two buildings. This first phase of the parcel is called the Sawyer. And in addition...
16:42 This phase includes a half-acre public park and a daycare facility, as well as the roads and sidewalks and public infrastructure. So this is an aerial photo that was taken this morning. All of these photos actually are from today. I thought I would show you one of the original approval renderings here in the upper left corner and the equivalent photo from this morning. It's pretty nice to see everything coming together the way we all thought it would.
17:11 Progress so far on Building B. Exterior siding and the painting is complete. Building B is the smaller of the two buildings. The roofing is complete. Interior painting is complete. And utilities and the ceiling in the corridors continues to be in progress. And Building A, which is the bigger building.
17:35 Most of those items are still in progress. The siding and the painting is going in. Again, you can see a rendering from the approval plans in the upper left corner and a photo from this morning down there in the bottom right. An aerial drone shot. You can see that some of the paint is actually starting to go on the larger building A. So that's one of the newer accomplishments. On site, on the larger site, the roads are complete. Our concrete curb and gutter.
18:10 is in place. The asphalt is in place. Sidewalks should be installed this fall, weather permitting. But after the winter and the spring, we'll see construction of the multi-use paths and the landscaping and the remainder of the park. We'll just kind of page around some photos. This is the back corner of building A. So we're looking at bicycle storage, garage entrance.
18:43 That's the garage entrance again at the bottom and the daycare facility on that bottom right of the photo. You can see there are about 15 of these snorkel lifts on site right now installing siding. It's a busy site. So what you're seeing there is installation on the exterior with backer boards for the siding and then the siding being installed. These are all views that are taken from south from the park area, all of building A.
19:22 This is looking at about the main entrance at the center of Building A. And here we are. I'm standing at the corner of New Inyo Street and the tavern extension. On the first floor here is the community space. And you can see Building B, which is fully painted in the background. Moving around the corner, we're heading north up New Inyo Street to see the building A is getting some paint on the facade. And some siding is still being installed.
19:52 This is looking back the private parking lot, surface parking lot for both buildings. You see a garage entrance for building A there at the bottom, and this is the second bicycle storage room here in the front. I think quite recently building B has had some of these exterior architectural features constructed.
20:22 And this is looking at the back of Building B and Building B's bicycle storage building here from the private parking lot. Again, this is standing in their private parking lot looking back towards the street entrance to the two buildings. I got up on the roof and got some photos looking towards Mammoth Mountain, Building A getting some paint. This is from the roof of Building A looking back at Building B, so looking about to the northeast direction.
20:59 And the weather was starting to come in, so I moved inside to take some interior photos. So here we are in building B, which is a little bit further ahead in construction than building A. As I mentioned, the interior utilities are in progress and fairly substantially complete, and they're getting some of the hung ceiling and the interior light fixtures installed. And most of the units, I think, in fact, all of the units have been...
21:29 Fully drywalled and painted out and are just getting the finishing touches on the interiors. And then these are just a couple of photos from the interior of Building A. I think we mentioned before that the elevators were being installed, so we've got an elevator actually in place. And then this is one of the longer corridors of Building A. It still has some utility work to be done. I just want to move on quickly. We're looking forward to phase two called the King Fitcher.
22:01 Some renderings from the approval plans here. This is a much larger phase, which may be broken into two smaller phases, so for 148 units altogether in five buildings. And just this past week or week and a half, the contractors started to remove trees in preparation to hopefully receive funding and start construction in the spring. So there are some of the trees being removed from this second phase in the northeast corner of the overall site.
22:34 There we go. Nolan and I are here to answer any questions. Thank you. Questions? Hang on one second. Hang on one second. Any questions up here? You guys good? You have a question? Oh, I'm sorry. It's looking great. You must be excited. December 8th is the day we find out about the next grant, correct?
22:58 Correct. So we have a kind of series of applications into the state, into the tax credit applications. We will find out December 8th whether we were successful on all or a portion or none of them. Also on December 8th, it's anticipated that Pacific is going to submit the building permits for Phase 2 as well to the town. So those, regardless of the funding, will be coming in for the plan check. And we're hopeful that we're successful.
23:28 Thank you. Anybody else? No? Okay. If it were to be split into two phases, is that a funding-related question? Yeah, so right now it's proposed as phase 2A and 2B. That's what it's meant, a series of applications. There's one that kind of covers all of phase 2. There's one that covers just phase 2A. And they have another option of applications in as well. Okay, so it's all in the funding.
24:01 Okay. Any public comments or questions? You had a question, I think. Yep. Oh, you're okay? Okay, great. Thank you. Anybody else? Anybody out there? Jamie? Nope. Okay. Thank you. Next, look at those laptops flying around. Good afternoon. Good afternoon. I would like to provide council with a brief update on the Community Recreation Center, and then, as we talked about last meeting, kind of give you a really quick snapshot of the last year in Parks and Rec.
24:45 Let me go here and do the usual, share your screen. I don't quite have as dramatic aerial shots as our last presentation, but let's see how I do. Start with Parks and Rec first, if I may. So we presented this to the Parks and Recreation Commission last Tuesday. Had some great input, good feedback. I think everybody was very appreciative of all the hard work our team.
25:33 Kind of puts over a year. So this gives you a snapshot between last, essentially, October and September. So it's a little kind of different. So it picks up kind of in the fall, does winter, and then it kind of, you know, covers the majority of spring and summer. So I'll kind of double over a few items, but again, just why Parks and Recreation is essential to our community. This is our clear vision that we've had for quite some time. Gives us kind of sense of purpose. Here's our mission.
26:02 I think everybody's kind of understanding that it's indoor-outdoor, residents and our visitors and so forth. So this covers kind of our programming, our scholarships, parks and facilities, community events and the Whitmore Pool. I kind of took out the Mammoth Ice Rink because I think we've covered that before. So hopefully this will just be a quick update for you. Real quick snapshot just kind of by the numbers. You can see we...
26:27 Catered to 171 more youth in our programs this summer as compared to last year and over 149 more adults in programming as well. So, you know, we're on a good climb there. So jump in any time. These are our age groups. You can kind of see we cater from toddlers all the way up to kind of our active adults and seniors. And that's been with the addition of Mark Bell, our new adult programming supervisor. So he's really kind of narrowing down on kind of that 16 to the 65 plus age group.
26:57 We have Doug focused on our youth programming. And then, as you know, Andrew, our recent community recreation center supervisor, caters just for our new building. This is kind of the array of our youth programs last summer and certainly over a period of time as well. You can see we have summer camps. We have our new camp listing. We also have after school programs that we've put in there as well. So that's kind of our bike squad, skate squad, Doug's famous cooking class. Everyone loves that.
27:25 And we introduced this new Little Wreckers program that was really successful. So that just kind of gives you an overview of kind of what we provide. And then in our contracted camps, you can see we do UK soccer and challenger. Again, this is just kind of a look back over the last decade. You can see obviously COVID interrupted a lot of our programming, but you see we're kind of bouncing back. You can see here just kind of a...
27:50 An overview again of and a breakup of our programming. This is kind of what we offer. So the big three there is you can see our soccer, biking and our skateboard camps. They're kind of our larger three. After school program. Again, this is something we've really picked up in the last couple of years post-COVID. You can see gymnastics is really, you know, spending the majority of time. And a lot of these programs are really reliant upon our contract instructors or staff in our community that can really provide them.
28:16 Thankfully, we have some wonderful gymnastics instructors that are employed by the town, utilised in the community centre. Swim lessons is great, skate lessons, you can see the cooking hot shots and the skate squad in there, and then Doug's famous bike squad camp as well, where we actually pick the kids up after school, get them on our bikes, and then two of them around town in the fall, so everybody really enjoys that. This is our Tony Colasotto Scholarship Fund.
28:43 So what we do now is essentially add them to, in our DaySmart application, just add their discount. So anytime they go through in that period of time, they buy a product that just zeroes out at the end for those families and those kids in our community. So again, just a really easy way, we think, to make sure we can get all our kids in our community participating in our camps and programs. So you can see that was 104 scholarships, just over $11,000, and we hope to continue to increase those numbers.
29:14 Adult programs, that's kind of our menu. You can see it covers summer and winter. So you can kind of see curling in there. You've got a hockey league, indoor soccer, indoor volleyball is kind of what we offer, and then volleyball this winter as well. So those programs and leagues are currently open for registration. Again, that same little graph, you can kind of see a decade ago, we're at kind of 544, jumped to 824. So you can see we're kind of going back in the right direction, and I really kind of see this jumping.
29:43 Particularly with the CRC opening. And then we're also kind of looking at a pickleball kind of league kicking up in the spring and obviously that will be super popular. It's probably even sold out and we haven't even put it online yet. But anyway, this is cool. So this is kind of a little bit of a snapshot. So this takes all our kind of survey information from our participants. We had just over 100 surveys completed by our parents representing their kids, hopefully.
30:09 The bigger letters, obviously the more responses, so everyone really loved the councillors, they liked the friends, the mountain biking, the fun, the learning, those type of things. We obviously exceeded this camper's expectations for their day, so really appreciate those comments. Switching over to rentals, you can see the bump here, I think just down was just the extended season. You know, shady rest in a lot of our parks weren't open, so really couldn't get...
30:37 Our community into our facilities, so that's really the only change there. We do a number of community events. We had a really fun bike rodeo, if you're out at Shady Risk Park, about a month or so ago. We think that went really well, and that was on a minimum day, so I think we really kind of timed that well. We did a haunted roller rink the year before, and then we did a haunted pickleball rink this year. Again, had to cancel a few events due to snow, and then the Parks and Recreation Department hosts our July, annual July 4th fireworks at the lakes.
31:07 Very proud to put those events together. Just really quickly on the Whitmore Pool, I just got a few slides here. A really busy summer last year. You can see it's kind of our biggest one since 2016. And certainly this is kind of more accurate data because it's kind of when we started with our new online reservation system and tracking people. So this gives you a number of people each day at the pool. This one gives you a number. You can see that we operated for a total of 101 days and we get on average about 71 people.
31:35 A day. And that includes our lap swimmers, visitors, and our swim team as well. Big year for the pool. I mean, 33,000 was kind of our largest that we've seen for quite some time. So again, we really try and make sure that our visitors, our residents can enjoy our pool at a very affordable price. So, you know, it's $5 for youth, $6 for seniors, $7 for adults. So hopefully that's a good value for our community.
32:03 And that is that presentation. I know I kind of went through it pretty quick, but if you do have any questions, happy to answer them. That's fine. Thank you very much. It's great to see all those numbers going in the right direction. Real participation. Questions? Yes, everybody okay? Questions? Any public comments or questions? Well, Vamp as Stuart reloads his next presentation. Yeah. Here we go. Do you know how the ball grew so much when this was such a short season? It was really hot.
32:36 It wasn't. Like, it thunderstorms every day. Like, how did you do this? Yeah, so, I think what made a really good difference for us, it's not reflected in the numbers, I could probably get them to you, but I think probably two to three hundred of those numbers from our free swim Sundays in July. So, it's something you really want to promote as, you know, Park and Recreation Month. Yeah. So, just make our pool available to, you know, our entire community and, you know, get them down there. Welcome.
33:04 So I know we were before you, I think, last meeting, but again, we're getting really close, and compared to probably a few months ago, construction really is kind of at warp speed over there at the Community Recreation Center, getting ready for our opening. So I'm just going to give you just a few photos here to share with the community. So this was last week. So they poured, Hayes thinks it's about 3,000 something square feet. That's our big deck. So that kind of links and connects.
33:33 The CRC to the deck to the playground. It's really exciting. We think there's so much programming opportunity here, certainly in some nice winter months and certainly some summer days. So we're really excited about that. So that got poured last week. They also cleaned up the asphalt between the deck and the playground so you can get kind of around that playground area now. We're pretty excited to, again, reopen that playground next summer. But, again, this was why it was closed. I mean, we were right up to...
34:02 November, you know, still finishing construction in and around the CIC. So again, just want to thank everybody's patience with us. So there's the stairs down to the playground itself. So you can see it's very accessible. Excited about that. We also have an ADA ramp on the other side. This was Monday. Actually, yeah, Monday afternoon. So as part of the LA Kings partnership, we contract with American Sports Entertainment Company.
34:31 And they operate the majority of LA Kings ice arenas. They actually brought up a team to help us make ice indoors, which was great. One person there you can't quite see, he's got a hood on, that is Kyle Lampke. Kyle is the Director of Ice Operations for the LA Kings. So he handles all the ice at Crypto and all the ice at the training facility at the Toyota Sports Performance Center. So he knows his stuff. So again, we were so grateful that they were able to come up and help us.
35:00 This is actually called sealing the ice. So this was the first layer of water. This is the first layer of white paint. So once you've sealed the ice, you start throwing paint, and that gives that the reflectability on the ice. And we do three layers of this super white bright paint on the ice. And then once you've watered that in, then you can actually start putting in some lines and some logos. So this is kind of the center ice, which is really cool. We've actually, as you know, never had lines.
35:29 Brave New World. I think everyone's going to be really excited to actually see lions in the ice. This is kind of how they put down logos. So the King's logo's in kind of four sections. It's like a big squeegee. You kind of lay down a section, throw some water on it, and then push a little roll around and freeze it in the ice. So there you go. That's the way to do that. That's looking back towards the east of the facility.
35:57 Amazingly, it goes quite fast when you have the right people working with you. This would probably take us two days to do this. So, again, very thankful. But this is looking back to the lobby area. You can see the scoreboard up, ready to go. We've tested that. That's great. We also hung the sound system, which is right above Center Ice, and we'll hope to get that hooked up next week. Again, that's the crew with us and with the LA Kings Ice Crew putting that together. So, again, really thankful.
36:24 That's essentially kind of what it looks like and that's essentially what it is right now. So for the next couple of days, our crew is just out there putting on probably another three quarters of an inch of water. So essentially you're just pushing a wand that sprays water on the ice and that's it for two days. So you just kind of build it and build it and build it till we get to about an inch and a quarter of ice. That's about the depth. And then we keep that ice temperature at about 22 to 24 degrees. So there you go. Very exciting.
36:53 Staffing update, I think you're familiar with this, so our manager overseeing that facility is Kat Kelly, and your supervisor is Andrew, site coordinators is Mike and Dylan. We're getting a lot of interest right now actually, we went to the school fair yesterday, we got a really good interest from the school, so we're excited about that, so we'd really like to see some more facility staff join us at the holiday times and our weekends. Staff have been here, there and everywhere, so they're getting trained on kind of operations.
37:22 If you haven't been to our new websites, lakingsicemammothlakes.com and our new social media page, Mammoth Lakes Ice. So you can kind of follow us along there. I'm not too sure if I showed you this before, but this is the new Zamboni that we purchased about a year and a half ago from the Clean Air Grant. Still trying to find a little Clean Air Grant sticker, but that's kind of compliments of our Southern California Toyota dealers. So that we hope will be on the ice on Friday.
37:48 CAT's been overseeing our sponsorship program. This is kind of our dashboard program. We opened up 28 dashboard banner locations. They're 12 feet long, 30 inches high, and I think within a week we sold 25 of them. So just a great, great response from our community. Really excited to see the community supporting the CIC and demonstrating their commitment by purchasing a dashboard banner. So really excited about that.
38:18 And then, just again, just a quick snapshot of events. So this weekend, we're actually going to open up just for these high school hockey games. So you've got Ventura coming up to play a local Bishop High School League. This is part of the LA Kings High School League. 24th is our opening. We're starting to push that now. So we're excited. We're almost there. And you can see these are the other events that we have coming up to skate with Santa on the 21st.
38:45 Just a myriad of programming will be on offer at the facility, anywhere from public skating, hockey, adult hockey, youth hockey, curling. Our curling league is open right now, so everybody's excited about that. We've got some new intro to ice sports for our after-school programs, so we'll have to see some kids participating in that. Seeing some interest in our skating lessons, and Thursday night will be community ice night. And then I'll just finish here. This is kind of what we're starting to push out right now, so on Ice Friday, not Black Friday, but Ice Friday.
39:14 Is our official opening. So 3 o'clock is our ribbon cutting. The entire community is invited. So we hope to see everybody out there. And then 4 o'clock through 9.30. So you can kind of come and go. You can skate. You can go up to the tree lighting. You can come back and join us for complimentary ice skates through 9.30 that evening. You can see we've got some session times there as well. So that is my presentation. Just very excited to be here to share that information with the council and the community this evening.
39:44 Thank you, Mr. Excellent. Thank you very much. Any questions from Council? Just a reassurance that the restroom facilities have been installed because that was a huge issue, I know. So I was told earlier they were. I just want to make sure everybody understands that. So we are good to go for the weekend. I flushed the toilet today.
40:08 Good boy. Okay, we're not going to go down that much detail for you. Yeah, sure. It worked and everybody's happy, right? Thank you. Yes, thank you very much. Any public comment on this? I just want to add, I will be out of town, unfortunately, for the ribbon cutting, but I think that I can't emphasize, I don't think any of us can emphasize how important it is to make sure that the community understands when they show up that it was the community and the taxpayers and the voters of Mammoth Lakes that have made this possible.
40:38 And I think it's really important that we start really instilling a sense of community pride in this. A lot of big high-profile sponsors. That's wonderful. It's great to bring that in. But this community made this possible. And let's never forget that. And let's be emphasizing this over and over and over again, whether they like it or not. But let's assume they're going to like it. But let's make sure we do that.
40:58 Okay, one other question. People interested in getting boards in the rink. Is it Cat they reach out to or do you? Cat Kelly, and we have a waiting list. Okay, good. Do reach out. I got a couple calls. I got some calls this morning. Wonderful, thank you. Thank you very much, Stuart. And thank, again, to you and the team, the unimaginable, unimaginable persistence of all the departments of the town that made this thing possible. So, feel gratitude for you guys. Thank you.
41:27 Okay. Are we moving on now to the Mammoth Main Base Redevelopment Project Update? No, we're introducing it. Oh, yeah, you're right. So, and before we get to that, Dan, I do have one. You and I talked about something. We received a letter from some residents on Old Mammoth. Dr. John, I can never pronounce his name properly. I will try to pronounce it. Watelli? John, excuse me, I apologize.
41:53 But we were going to provide a response. There were reasonable questions. They were very straightforwardly presented. I just want to get an update. That'll be completed this week to be able to do that. I know you had mentioned even others if you want to get something out to them or even go out and do a meeting with the community again and explain why we're landed, where we did with the Woodman turnaround. And we'll have those answers prepared here shortly.
42:15 Okay, and I'll be out of town next week, but I think we get back. We want to be able to, if there's neighbors out there want to get these questions answered, there's a lot of right technical stuff that went with that, but we're going to need that document. Okay, thank you. So now I guess we move on to the Mammoth Main Base Redevelopment Project update. And Jen is going to, okay. Hi, Jen. Hi, thank you, Mayor, Councilmembers. Jen Murillo, Contract Planner for the Main Base Redevelopment Project.
42:43 Due to the size of this project, we're providing regular updates to Council and the Planning and Economic Development Commission. We just have a few updates or items to note since we came before you last month. The first is that the environmental fieldwork for the project site has been completed, and so that includes cultural, biological, and wetland.
43:06 So that information will be documented in technical reports that feed into the environmental analysis that's required for the project. On outreach, we have, I'm pretty sure we're now confirmed in having a special council meeting on November 29th, so two weeks from today. The intent of that meeting is for the council to be able to discuss some key project considerations ahead of the specific
43:35 And that specific plan is also needed to be considered in the environmental analysis that is required for this project. And then lastly, regarding the potential relinquishment of State Route 203.
44:01 We are in communication with Caltrans on this, and the initial step in this process is for Caltrans to prepare a relinquishment assessment report. And to do so, the town must make the request to Caltrans to prepare that report. That report is informational. It documents key pieces of information relevant to considering a relinquishment.
44:27 The report in no way requires Caltrans to relinquish any or all of the road. It doesn't commit the town to accepting any or all of the road. So we do expect to come back to council next month. So a meeting in December with a request for the council to consider making that request to Caltrans to prepare that relinquishment assessment report.
44:53 And this is a long-term project. We are now looking at our overall schedule, and we're looking at, although the update does note that we expect maybe mid-next year to have a draft environmental analysis out to the public, it's probably going to be closer to a year from now.
45:12 Due to the length of time and the coordination between the town and forest service. So, yeah, expecting something toward the end of next year. And with that, I'd be happy to answer any questions. Okay, any questions from council? Can we just repeat when the special meeting is? I was trying to write it down. November 29th, I believe. Is that right, Jen? November 29th. Okay, any questions from you? Okay, Jen, I've got a couple questions.
45:45 I think we're all, as a community, and certainly as the council in the town, we're very eager and looking forward to a collaborative working effort with, I don't know what the name of the entity is that's actually producing this really ambitious project. And again, so far we're still kind of in the dark, and I guess on the 29th you'll start laying out for us what this looks like. I just have some concerns that the environmental process seems to be moving.
46:11 Doing field studies, doing all kinds of things. You're saying you're going to see something in a year. We still haven't even seen conceptual, the community hasn't even seen conceptual red rings of what this looks like. I have every confidence in Ron Cohen and the leadership team up there. From the first iteration to the second one, they made some very good and I thought very smart adjustments to that, but I think we're very eager to get into this process and to work with Altera and Ron and everybody to really...
46:38 Come up with something that's really going to make the most sense for the community, for the destination. The second question I have for you is I'm wondering if you could just offer some advice or information to the council about the nature of the approval that we're going to be making on this project. My understanding is something called a discretionary approval, if that's correct, given the fact that this is basically tabula rasa land. There's never been anything on it. I think the only requirement is we'd have to put some zoning on it.
47:06 Could you just share with the Council the nature of the kind of approval process we're going to be going through with the idea that it is discretionary? Thank you, Mayor. Yeah, this project includes a specific plan. That means it's approved by the Council and establishes the zoning and development standards for the project site.
47:27 The project was annexed in to private land from public, and that's why it doesn't have any zoning today. So a specific plan is considered legislative. It's approved by council. The council has the discretion to be able to determine whether that specific plan is consistent with the general plan and goals and objectives of the community.
47:51 Towns Municipal Code does have findings that the council must consider when approving a specific plan, but you do have more authority in terms of the nature of your review because there is no existing development standards or parameters that you would be reviewing the project against for consistency. Okay, does that all kind of make, this is a different, this is not the usual thing. Okay.
48:18 So thank you for that. I think, again, things like having a good collaborative working relationship with the applicant, addressing issues like housing and all different things we're going to be talking about, I think to really start to establish a productive framework to have those discussions is something I think we're all very eager to get into. Thank you for that. Any public comments or thoughts on this? Sorry, ma'am. Could you please come forward? Thank you.
48:46 We're all, everybody's watching at home. We want everyone to hear and see what people are saying. I apologize for not knowing, but what is this project? Oh, this is the Mammoth Resorts. It is doing a major redevelopment of the base, the main base lodge up at Main Lodge. This has been the work for many years. They've been working, I think, for about 20 years doing a land exchange to acquire the property. And now they're getting ready to move forward to very ambitious redevelopment of Main Lodge. Yes, you're welcome.
49:20 Okay, anybody else? Nope. Dan, yes. Just one more item. Sure. We did get notice from the Inyo National Forest that environmental analysis is moving forward for the proposed Eastern Sierra Climate and Community Resilience Project. Basically, a major fuels work going on in Mono County impacts the town of Mammoth Lakes.
49:44 That's out there. That project will implement a variety of thinning processes over about 58,000 acres. The assessment, there's information. I will put that out as well, but the Forest Service put out information. If people want to go in and comment on the analysis that was done for that, there will be a 30-day period of time once they do it in the formal noticing in your registers or paper of record. And so if people want to go in and comment accordingly on the analysis that was done for that project, that will...
50:14 Be open for those public comments. We've talked about this a lot, but now this, you know, what, two years later or longer, it's, the project's actually out, the NEPA's been completed and is ready for comment. You will know that we jump-started this project on private-owned property here in the town of Mammoth Lakes and a couple other places, or where other NEPA's been done.
50:38 I would think that the town, and I don't know who would...
51:05 Take the lead on that, but I think it's a vital interest to the town as an agency provide comments on that. We've been engaged in this all along. Sure, of course. I know there's an advisory. The financial advisory team is meeting later this week, and Dan, I think you'll be there as part of that. Okay. Thanks for that update. Very important. Again, Mono County fuels getting into that space. Okay, moving on now to, I believe, correct me if I'm wrong.
51:32 Introductions. Introduce new code compliance officer, Sandra Gamaldo, Chief. Good afternoon. Good evening, Council. I'm Dan Casabian, Interim Chief of Police, Mammoth Lakes Police Department. This is our newest member of the Mammoth Lakes Police Department in the town of Mammoth Lakes, Sandra Gamaldo. She is our new code compliance officer. A little about her. She grew up here in Mammoth. She's local. She graduated Mammoth High School and she went off to Santa Barbara City College.
52:03 Where she got her AA in criminal justice. Then she attended Colorado State University Pueblo with a full ride. Got her BS in criminology, which is pretty awesome. While she was there, she volunteered at Baca Elementary School as a fourth grade teacher's assistant. That's in Colorado. Pretty awesome. She was an intern for the PD. 17 and 18 helped us move from the old station to the new station.
52:32 She graduated from the Reserve Academy at Cerro Coso and Bishop, Level 2, Level 3, back in 2018, and she obtained Best Academic Award, so congratulations for that. Biggest hobbies include soccer, working out at the gym, and spending time with loved ones. We are very happy to have her, and I think she wants to say a few words. Yes, please. I want to thank everyone for their time today. My name is Andrea Grimaldo.
53:04 I have been part of this community for over 20 years. In a few words, I want to thank everybody for this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. I have been wanting to work for the town of Mammoth Lakes for a long time. Thank you to the Mammoth Lakes Police Department for letting me be part of their team. I really hope to give back to the community as much as possible. Thank you. Excellent. Thank you. Thank you. Welcome, Sandra. Do you guys need to take pictures or are you good? Huh? Okay, let's go. Let's take a picture.
54:53 Okay. Welcome, Sandra. Thank you. All right. The consent agenda. I'll read the items here. Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of November 1, 2023. Accept check register from the 1st of November in the amount of $882,508.79.
55:26 Can I, anybody want to pull anything? Nope. Is there a motion then to approve? I'll move to approve the consent agenda as presented. Thank you. I'll second. Oh, great. Thank you. We have a motion, a second. We're good. Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you very much. Okay, moving on now to policy matters.
55:54 Item 9.1, short-term rental study report regarding temporary moratorium on the issuance of new short-term rental certificates. Mr. Holler. Thank you. I will try to hit the highlights of the report, not spend a lot of time, a lot of the details. Hope you've had time to review and look at the report. Quick overview of where we're at, the short-term status of the moratorium on short-term rentals. It's in designated zones, mainly in our multifamily residential zone area.
56:23 A few others as well. This was adopted on October 18th, 2023, and it has a temporary initial ordinance. It's good for 45 days. It would expire on December 2nd. You will have the option to extend the moratorium. You could go up to an additional 10 months and 15 days. Prior to an extension, 10 days prior to taking action on that, you have to hold a public
56:52 Meeting related to issuing a report pursuant to state law, which is before you this evening, to be able to look at where we're at and the work that's been done to date. It's not a long time implemented, but it's there. A couple actions that has happened is the appointment of an advisory committee to look at the impact of short-term rentals and the management of those. They've had one meeting so far. They can speak to that later, Amanda.
57:21 Chris are both members of that. We are making a recommendation that if you consider extending the moratorium, that would be at the special meeting on November 29th, that it would only be extended for an additional six months to start with. You can always do it again after that for up to another 12 months beyond. The shorter time frame is done on purpose to keep kind of the urgency of this matter before the council and the community and also to get work done in a timely fashion. So we're looking at a
57:51 Shorter, relatively short time frame. If everything is ready prior to that, you can always terminate it sooner as well for that. However, to do that extension, as I mentioned, you do have to approve a steady report, which is before you to do that. The other thing, and just clarification on some of these items, the moratorium impacts the issuance of just new short-term rental certificates.
58:18 We've had questions from people who have existing and they're going about the regular business and they're thinking they can't anymore. There is no impact on current operations, if you will, which will include the renewal process, which will happen in December as well in January for active certificates. People will be able to continue to renew those.
58:38 Certificates and continue to operate their short-term rentals. We can't issue new ones, like if a sale of a property happens and somebody wants to have a new one, that would be prohibited in the areas impacted. When we adopted the moratorium, one of the key issues that is just the housing crisis that's facing the community. We know that we're challenged with housing for a workforce. A number of different studies have gone through that.
59:05 Fair amount of documentation through the staff report. I won't walk through all that, but starting back with the housing needs study and then into our housing elements and other information that we've seen out there in terms of the availability of housing, and that's one reason you see the parcel under construction we just got an update on. Focus primarily in those larger projects is on low-income housing. Low-income meaning you're making 80%.
59:32 Or less of the area median income. And then it's based on housing size. There's some information in the staff report that kind of touches on that. And we're also seeing that growth just in the cost of housing. And when you start to look at what has happened across the state and, frankly, across the country, there are cities and communities taking a variety of different approaches to managing short-term rentals.
1:00:00 Everything from basically doing nothing, just making it available to complete banning of that activity in their communities. We really look at it as still a need. I'll touch on that in just a minute. But as we look at how do you manage short-term rentals, there's a number of activities that we want to address or look at that. And a lot of that's under our certified property type program. How do we make...
1:00:24 You know, stiff penalties for people violate our town's rules and regulations, everything from illegal building to illegal renting or violating the conditions of their short-term rental permits. And so the management of short-term rentals in a lot of places has become one of the tools in the toolbox that has dealt with both a housing issue but also the quality of life issues.
1:00:50 We went through a few years back a lot of issues related to noise and trash and parking and those types of things, and we put certain things in our code, and it's a good time to review that and look at is it being effective? We still have problems out there. We still get complaints, and how do we respond to that? How do we manage that side of the short-term rental market as well as looking at the relationship potentially into the housing market? And in the report, we noticed a couple, I think, things we want to affirm as issues in there.
1:01:19 I think we recognize the need for tourist accommodations. Mammoth Lakes is funded primarily on transit occupancy tax. That is our primary revenue source in the general fund sense. It's funding a lot of our core programs as well as additional programs that we have in place based on economic research.
1:01:41 Data out there, short-term rentals do influence second home buyers and how they buy and decisions to hold property accordingly, which potentially pulls it out of what would be community housing opportunities as well. There's a relationship, it's really hard to nail that down to a fine percentage point. We also know that the availability of workforce housing impacts the economic sustainability of our community.
1:02:07 You'll hear the phrase kind of a hollowing out of the community. We have people moving out of our community. They can't afford to live here. Even we're seeing that, I think, a little bit more even in that middle income level. We'll refer to something. You'll hear us talk about the missing middle, basically making above the 80 percent, very median income levels, all the way up to 200 percent. So you're looking at families in the 80,000, 90,000 a year up to 170,000 a year that
1:02:36 We also know that the regulation of short-term rentals is a way to help look at and manage our tourist accommodations balancing with housing. There's no magic bullet for this. There's no one-size-fits-all. Again, if you look across the state, just in California, you'll see
1:03:05 A myriad of different things that communities have done in this space, as I mentioned, from very little to complete banning of itself. Those elements are out there. As we take a look at this, our first focus has been on truly the management of short-term rentals. What does that look like? Part of that quality of life issue becomes real critical for us. How do we help connect operators better with the town? And that's part of our certified property program.
1:03:33 And then as you look at the housing linkage, this was not going to solve all of our housing issues in the community we hear about, but depending on how you structure management around there, the focus would be on that missing middle group that making above 80%, maybe below 200% of area median incomes as a focal area where we believe short-term rental housing management may have an influence. How that looks?
1:03:59 We're not predetermined at that point, but if you're going to look at an area, it's probably more than that than it is the very lower income areas that we are addressing in a number of different ways within our community. So as we begin to look at that funneling down, one of the committee challenges, I think, with the STR Advisory Committee is to, yeah, get that focus on what does this STR management look like, what is it intended to do, et cetera, as we work through that.
1:04:27 Brief overview. I assume you had time to look at the report and a lot of detail in there. Rob Patterson, our Finance Director, Admin Services, has been engaged in this process and definitely is overseeing the revenue team, working with a lot of the management side of STRs as we do today in the Certified Property Program, et cetera. It's also available for questions or answers on that. Again, a lot of data provided. I didn't want to walk through it all this evening. I trust you've had a chance to look at that.
1:04:55 If there's questions under the information, we'd be glad to answer that as well. But that would include the current presentation. Andy also wants to jump in as need be. Yeah, I just want to clarify for members of the public that the council is not taking any action tonight to extend or not extend the moratorium. That's not the decision before you. You're simply required to issue a report, and that's all that you're doing tonight. And you can talk about anything else that...
1:05:20 It kind of fits under the heading of the report because the report is about the efforts the town has made and is making to look at this issue. So you can talk about stuff like that, but again, no decision tonight about whether to extend the moratorium. Okay, thank you. Any questions from council? Questions? No, don't hear any questions. Okay, any public comment? I do, but I'm not sure. You have a question? The sequencing. Well, you know. Is it a technical question for staff? It has to do with
1:05:51 What happened at the meeting? Go ahead and ask. We'll come back to that discussion and talk about, under discussion of the council, I think would be more appropriate. Thank you. Okay, good. Okay, who's got a public comment? John Morris. Good evening, Mayor Wentworth, council members. John Morris, I am the chair of the newly formed short-term rental advisory committee. And we're looking, we had our first meeting Monday, I think as Dan mentioned, and we're really looking forward to diving in and trying to
1:06:23 Bring back some great recommendations to the council as quickly as we can. We have a real short window to do this. Our meetings conclude at the end of January. Current schedule, we're actually, I've talked to a few of the other members and we're going to try to, if we can, jam some more meetings in to get some more time and really get through this. I'll be here if you guys have any questions for me. The one thing that I would ask that was, and I think,
1:06:48 Councilmember Bubser was probably just about to ask the question. There was a little bit of, not so much confusion, but we weren't quite clear whether this direction from the council is strictly to have conversations regarding short-term rentals.
1:07:03 Thank you so much.
1:07:32 I think, Dan, perhaps to your question here, John, is about the nexus between the housing crisis, which exists, and the fact that all sectors of the community have to play a role in this. And this is specifically about the role that short-term rental management plays to address the housing crisis. There's a legal nexus in there somewhere.
1:08:02 And perhaps, hopefully I have stated that properly, but that's, have I stated that properly? Sure, although you're not bound by nexus concerns in the same way that you might be with some other things that the town does. I mean, you can do essentially anything you like if you think that it'll help in some way. Okay, but, so John, housing is the crisis. This particular sector, how can it help or alleviate or affect the crisis?
1:08:31 If that makes sense. Okay. So you had a question? Nope. Yes, nope. That was my question. That's it? Okay, good. Chairman Morris. Okay, so who, I have some, I did attend the meeting. I've got a couple thoughts, but I want to open it to deliberation if you want to start, though. I have public comment on Zoom as well. Are we done with public comment? Oh, okay. Zoom, please. Okay. Chris, please unmute yourself and give your comments. All right. Can everyone hear me? Yes, we can hear you just fine. Thank you.
1:09:05 All right. Evening, Mayor and Councilmembers. My name is Chris Stramatin. I wanted to touch on the connection and how I see that between short-term rental, the moratorium, if it continues in long-term housing. The moratorium, as I think has been discussed, creates downward pressure without an incentive, but it doesn't have an incentive for homeowners to move.
1:09:34 And I don't think it can be assumed that owners will simply move to long-term housing leasing options for their homes to make up for lost income if nothing is in place to push them in that direction. And, you know, if they cannot find other means to pay their mortgages, likely they would sell. You know, additionally, the certificate is non-transferable.
1:10:03 Which would mean less values for prospective buyers and could potentially drive home values down, which maybe sounds appealing in the affordability aspect of things. But I don't think for the long-term health of Mammoth Lakes, that would necessarily be a good thing. Additionally, I think as we all know that, you know, tourism industry is one of the main drivers of the Mammoth Lakes economy.
1:10:29 And, you know, from my perspective, I don't believe that there's enough hotel rooms and hotel networks in Mammoth to accommodate the current level of tourism. And additionally, the hotels that do exist are old, some of them in a deteriorated state. And I don't think those meet the needs for the typical tourist demographic, which spends its dollars at local businesses.
1:10:56 And the typical tourist and visitor, for the reasons I just mentioned and due to current trends, necessarily don't prefer hotels over home rentals, especially for something like a ski vacation. And obviously, less tourism is not good for the town for spending money at local businesses, the TOT tax, which was mentioned before.
1:11:22 And could create, you know, if this continues, job loss for many of the employees and people that call Mammoth home. So I just wanted to draw my opinion on that connection between the two and how some of the how the impact of the moratorium could could actually lead to unintended consequences. Chris, thank you very much for your comments. Appreciate it. Anybody else out there, Jamie? Okay, I'm sorry. Did you want to start?
1:11:55 Yeah, that's fine. Just a couple of things. I'm not going to talk about the short-term rental moratorium and everything else that's been decided already. But a few things in the report here. There is some confusion on members of the committee whether we're talking about short-term rentals or whether we're talking about housing. And if they're going to talk about housing, we need to, I believe, open that conversation up for that group to more than just our condominium base. Then we need to talk about the affordability of building in Mammoth.
1:12:26 And a lot of other things that could lead to more home ownership for our middle and upper management folks. So that's just a point to be made there. We need to clear up that confusion. A lot of the reports and a lot of the other places that are putting short-term rental bans in place are putting them in place on private homes, not on condominiums that were built originally to be short-term rentals. So we have to be careful about using those to make our decisions. It's a whole different thing.
1:12:55 In essence, we put our moratorium into effect that they're doing now years ago with the passage of Measure Z, which prevented the nightly rental of those homes that have become so problematic in ripping the core out of other towns. We dealt with that. We're way ahead of the curve there. So those are just some things I want everybody to consider. I would love to see this committee come up with some housing.
1:13:25 We know 48% of our rentals in that particular zone already do not rent. So knowing how many of those are being used for permanent local housing could help influence whether or not
1:13:53 Closing some of those rentals out in the future could substantially put more long-term beds in. But if out of those 48%, there's only a handful that are actually locals, then we can gauge from that whether or not we would be successful by limiting those short-term rentals. Those are just some thoughts on this. We need to pass this to keep going down this road, and I want us to go down this road as quickly as possible, so let's get her done.
1:14:23 Yeah. Okay. Anybody over here? Thoughts? Well, Bill, just, you know, what you just said about we have that Measure Z in place and that protects our single-family homes. I would just like to point out, you know, I think most towns don't have the same split as Mammoth. Mammoth has, I think, I believe it's like 80% condominiums and 20% single-family homes.
1:14:57 You know, I don't really want to get into any discussions here tonight, but I just think it's worth noting, you know, yes, the single-family homes here are protected from businesses competing with individuals for housing, but I think, I'm really glad that we are at the table discussing this and seeing if it's something that we need to address as a town or not, so I'm just, you know.
1:15:26 Glad that we are, you know, it's hard work, and I'm sure we've all been getting some emails that are not so kind-hearted. And, you know, to those people, I would say I appreciate your opinion, and I'm willing to have a respectful discussion with you. But I think that it's hard on our community right now, but I'm hoping that in the long run that it will be beneficial to all of us.
1:16:00 Feel like I did want to address Mickey Brown's public comment. She had asked several questions, and I don't know if that's something that we want to address as a council or. Yeah, I received the same comments. I think what would be helpful, I thought about this, I think it would be helpful to address these things individually. So we're not going to try to get any consensus here tonight. Yeah, gotcha. But if you want to go ahead and respond to those, I'll respond to those as well.
1:16:24 Yeah, I mean, I think my answer to all three of those questions would be no, and I have to say I don't know what my quantitative measure for success is. Okay, good. I just wanted to make sure that I addressed that. Sure, great, thank you. Thank you, Mickey. Anything from you, Chris? Yeah, a couple of things. I think that, and I think, you know, our Chair Morris addressed this, but I think it's important.
1:16:53 That we just state very clearly as a council that this is about short-term rentals specifically, yes, in the context of our housing crisis, but I'm a little concerned about scope creep, and it started to happen in the meeting on, was that Monday, on Monday night. So I think it's imperative that the council
1:17:22 Again, reiterates very clearly what this is and isn't, and it's about specific ordinances that we will be looking to change. And so I know that in the discussion, we talked a little bit about the very specific work stream that was about short-term rentals, but then there was another work stream about housing, and frankly, I got lost. So that's why I'm concerned for
1:17:49 You know, the other members of the community who aren't in these kinds of settings as much? I don't have the answer, but I think we better address it, or we, because, you know, there's certain things that are really important that staff has done. We're not taking, if, when we vote at the end of November, on an extension, we're not taking the full amount of time. That's to keep the sense of urgency and to get this, you know, sort of process done, but I don't,
1:18:19 I don't think, unless we're very, very clear, that this isn't going into housing. And I heard you, Bill. I think what you're saying is important. I just am trying to be realistic about what this committee could get done successfully. And I feel like there's a little bit of chance for scope creep. And I want to make sure we do everything we can to prevent that.
1:18:53 Yeah, so I just want to follow up on that. I agree I was at the meeting, and I addressed this, and I think, as I said originally, the crisis, the reason why there's a moratorium is because of the housing crisis. So the task to the committee, as I understand it, is to look at the regulation of short-term rentals in the context of the housing crisis. Again, I'm just speaking as one council member because we're not going to get into consensus this evening. I don't have any – I do not –
1:19:21 Want and desire the committee to start trying to solve the housing problem for Mammoth Lakes. This is an all-hands-on-deck approach. This is one sector we've got to deal with. And John, in your very able hands, I know that you'll be able to keep that focus and move these kinds of things forward. I think that's going to be really critically important because we want to get this done quickly. We want to get through this particular sector, this particular focus, and move this thing quickly.
1:19:46 A couple things in terms to follow up a little bit, Sarah, on your responses to Mickey's question. I'll just deal with these first, and then I've got, John, a couple of ideas or requests that I have of questions I'd like to see answered as one council member in your process. So the first thing is, to build your point, nightly rentals are in the DNA of our infrastructure, of our community, of our culture. This is how so many second homeowners, so many people in our audience have enjoyed and come to love Mammoth Lakes over many years. So that's...
1:20:14 So we're not...
1:20:43 I don't think we, well, I'll speak for myself. I have no interest in messing with the TOT, you know, the way that we bring in those resources. I have no, certainly no interest in messing with our recreation economy and being a forward-looking 21st century gateway to the unbelievable recreation opportunities that have defined this place from the very beginning. This goes way back before ski areas. This goes back to the, you know, except for the miners, but it goes back to why this place exists in the first place. So I think.
1:21:12 I hope we're all on the same page with that. I won't speak for the council. Excuse me. So to Mickey's question, is the primary objective of these regulations to limit the number of short-term rentals with the assumption that these properties will transition to long-term rentals? And Sarah, I agree with you. No. I'm certainly not making that assumption. I'm not looking at this to find some way to get everybody to long-term rentals with our regulation of our program. That's not.
1:21:40 A fundamental motivator for me for doing this. The regulation is designed to restrict nightly rentals to drive down the market value of specific properties so they become affordable for the workforce. Again, no, that's not an intention of mine to do that kind of stuff. I think the degree to which we have a vibrant and viable short-term rental program in this community is going to benefit all of us in terms of driving TOT but also providing opportunities for long-term residents this year.
1:22:08 Limiting tourists. Does the council intend to limit the number of tourists who visit Mammoth Lakes? Absolutely not. We need to look at tourists and visitors coming to here from the lenses of sustainable recreation, sustainable tourism. This council and this committee have been talking about this for decades. This is the frame and the lens through which we're looking at all these things. And again, people have implied that it's pre-baked, it's pre-determined, we already know what we're going to do. Please...
1:22:37 Get familiar with the Brown Act, how we conduct our business and how we do things. We're not sneaking off to the bar and coming up with some secret agenda or secret cabal to do things. This is as transparent to us as it is to everybody else. I hope that's helpful. John, a couple things here in terms of the committee. And again, thank you very much for stepping forward, John, if you're able leadership with this group. I'm very encouraged with what I've seen so far. So licenses to rent.
1:23:07 Would it be possible to explore the idea that the town owns the permits, the town owns the licenses, and that we can avoid commodifying permits, DOT permits, and those kinds of things? So we don't create a market for those things. Is that something that could be explored? And I think it would be of interest to explore looking at the true cost.
1:23:33 of the permitting process, of what we do to have TOT permits and business licenses, especially if we start getting into an enforcement or an inspection program that would be happening year over year. What is actually the true cost of doing this, of running this program, Rob? I appreciate Stu does these things for the recreation programs, but that's a little bit different. Through the quality of life ordinance, if you're staying in a nightly rental property licensed by the town,
1:24:01 Can we ensure that there are uniform standards for all of the units that are being rendered through licenses coming out of the town? Can we ensure that it's uniform for safety? Can we ensure that it's uniform that in terms of like a presence on site, this whole thing about who's representing the owner, who's representing the management company, that there's a presence on site, much like a hotel. If you run a hotel in California, you'd have a 24-hour presence on site to do those kinds of things.
1:24:28 Can we really get to a program, John, that is going to guarantee, not guarantee, but ensure that whatever you're renting in this community, you're going to have a good experience. You're not going to show up and be horribly disappointed by your nightly rental experience. So these are the kinds of things that we can do through this program. And I think from a zoning perspective, which is a little, that's sort of tangential, it's kind of related.
1:24:56 Is it possible to look at the relationship between what is resort and what is residential? Do we have the zoning set up so the residential is in the zoning where it's supposed to be and the resort is the place where it's supposed to be? We heard at one of our last meetings about what's going on at Canyon Lodge or the portals around Eagle Lodge, places like that. Is our zoning really right? Do we have our expectations right? And this goes to another thing it would be good to look at, which is
1:25:26 The built environment. Bill, back to your point. What was the intention of what things were originally built? Is our zoning in the era of big tech and Airbnb and VRBOs? Do we have the right zoning that lines up with the intentions of what these things were built for in the first place? And if not, maybe we can make some adjustments and move some of these things around. I think that would be helpful. For the real estate development community, I want to make sure that, you know,
1:25:54 Oh, it's a moratorium. They hate us. We welcome you. We want to work with that community. As Dan, as you pointed out, communities all over the planet are wrestling with this. This is not something that's unique to Mammoth Lakes. We have to do, I think, as a council, the due diligence to look at this sector, figure out how it contributes or does not contribute to housing, and do right by it.
1:26:15 And I think we want to, I just want to say on behalf of myself that I don't have any intention of looking into the resort zoning and putting residential housing into what's being zoned for resort. I think we need to put, get everything in the right place and the relationship, and John Morris, I know you're keenly aware of this, of the relationship of the nightly rental program and condominiums and other places where it's zoned to the hotel, the truly resort experience. What is the balance going to be that it's impossible to predict it, but between
1:26:44 Good quality nightly rental experience or a hotel, as the gentleman just said on the phone. This is something that we all have to look at and to get right. I'm hoping you guys can be looking into that stuff, figuring out what we do with that. Finally, I think there's a really important point around grandfathering values. There are a lot of members of our community who have purchased homes, purchased condominiums with a zoning in place that says, look, there's a value because I know I could
1:27:10 Theoretically rent my unit if I wanted to, even though many don't. But to look at if there is a recommendation to adjust zoning or to make any adjustments into the program, please consider how to grandfather in those folks who've bought in. They have an expectation of value so that they're not going to lose that value. It may be over two or three sales. That changes over two or three sales, and maybe we can adjust it that way.
1:27:37 So those are just some ideas, John. I hope that that's helpful. And I think, Rob, there was the question with the committee, hey, Rob, you say you're having problems. What are the problems? Where's that list? And I'm really hoping, I think that'd be very helpful for John and the team to see exactly the types of challenges that you're having, because that's good, concrete, specific focus information that could be helpful. So enough of me gassing up here. If anything I said is way off the mark,
1:28:06 Yeah, Chris, go ahead. I would just like to answer Mickey's questions as well. Okay. So for limiting short-term rentals is the primary objective of these regulations to limit the number of short-term rentals with the assumption that these properties will transition to long-term rentals. No, that is not the intention. I think that what has come to light for us is that it's been a long time since we've looked at our short-term rental program, our zoning.
1:28:36 What is the, you know, sort of right sizing and best way for our community to move forward? As Mayor Wentworth said, every other community, every other resort community in the country is facing this. And I think it's really important. You know, the one thing I will say, and I don't have my chart, but the Colorado Association of Ski Towns put out a report, and there's two charts in it. One shows the proportion of
1:29:05 The community that lives in the housing and the other shows the amount of housing that's unoccupied or available for short-term rentals. And we are at the, in my opinion, at the top of the chart that shows that the community isn't really having the opportunity to have the housing they need at the bottom of the other chart. And I'm sorry, I'm not explaining that well, but, you know, email me and I will show it to you. And it's very
1:29:34 So I think that we are taking this opportunity to hit pause, look what we're doing, and make it better. The second thing is, I want to answer your third question next, Mickey. Does the council intend to limit the number of tourists who visit Mammoth Lakes? No.
1:29:55 First of all, you know, as you know, for those who were really paying attention when we dealt with our T-bid and Measure A dollars and the TOT, for anyone who would listen, Mayor Wentworth and I made a big presentation to show that
1:30:11 TOT is the lifeblood of our community. We don't have revenue to spend on the programs we need as a town unless we protect our TOT. In my opinion, this is a TOT protection program because we're really going to make sure that we are evening things out so that when people come to our town, they have a positive experience. And then are the regulations designed to restrict nightly rentals to drive down market value of specific properties?
1:30:41 I personally feel hurt by that question because why would we as a council ever do something like that? We care about our community and we want to make things best for everyone and that just feels like an accusation and it's a little hurtful. We couldn't even
1:31:14 Manage that if we tried. So I wish that the community would have the faith that we are trying to do what is best for our community for the long run because, I mean, we wouldn't sit on council if we didn't love this town. This is a hard job and can be quite often very thankless. So I just hope that nobody would ever think we would even attempt something like that. And then finally, our quantitative measure for success.
1:31:43 I do want to say that for me, what I was trying in the first committee meeting to get at is that we know that our biggest challenge because of the way that the state and federal government doesn't give
1:31:59 We can do things for people in those salary ranges.
1:32:29 If we're developing that kind of housing and it costs between $500,000 and a million per unit, our TOT that we're all so proud of doesn't go very far. It's like one or two units a year. So we're talking decades until we solve this problem. So I would like us to try to think about quantifying how many people we're talking about in the missing middle and really think about what the kinds of solutions we're
1:32:59 So, Mickey, to your question about what is the quantitative measure for success.
1:33:28 I think that's to be determined because this is not, it's not like we can just write a plan and say we're going to do A, B, C, D, E. I think that this wonderful dedicated committee that we've formed is going to approach each piece of the puzzle and one is how do we make sure that we've optimized our short-term rental program and keep our TOT healthy. And with that, I think I've said no.
1:33:59 Can I add something, too? Of course. I mean, I would answer Mickey Brown's questions the same as you all have, as no for all three questions. And, you know, I think that our STR Advisory Committee, a huge word that we're going to be embracing is compromise. You know, it's, it's, we're going to compromise and we're going to find something that works for our town. And I think that just about everybody in town, they know or they should know that.
1:34:25 You know, we could not survive without T.O.T., and I don't think it's anyone's intention. Just like Chris said, you know, nobody wants to kill the golden goose. So I think we're going to have to compromise and see what we're willing to do to help the missing middle. Yeah, Bill. So as a citizen, not a council member, because government works in mysterious ways, even to me after all of these years.
1:34:53 The problem I'm having is if the answer to all of Mickey's questions are no. And our reason for going down this road as an emergency ordinance was to deal with the housing issues. What, if anything, did we hope to accomplish if we weren't trying to force long-term rentals, if we weren't trying to bring pricing down so that locals could afford it? Just as a person, hopefully, a lot of great things are coming out of this. If our answer to all of those is no, I'm not sure.
1:35:23 What we ever thought that the emergency ordinance had out easily. Okay, well, that's a good place to leave it. I think, yeah, one second. John, just a final thought. For a measure of success, timeliness, efficiency, if you need any support to get you there, that will be really helpful. So, public comment, yeah, Sandy. Sandy Hogan. And, you know, it's interesting because I only saw two comments that were favored.
1:36:00 of the program, and both of us based our comments really on the part that Rob presented, which said to me that the whole goal of this program was to better our program, make better management, direct contact with, you know, the owner and the town. Right now it's a three-party thing, you know, and that's never efficient.
1:36:29 And then I saw in that staff report some great comments, I'm sure coming from your staff, about how to improve this program. Now, I was involved with Measure Z, as a lot of people probably know. But before that, and many people that were involved in that, the 12 of us basically, had been tracking the enforcement. They were, I think, probably with John.
1:36:59 On a committee. And, you know, way back when, and we've always had a great enforcement program, and the whole idea was to make it better. And if you have better management, better tracking, I see fine toning of the zoning as one of the topics, little stuff like that, you'll get a better program, you will actually get more TOT, because, you know, people, there are people around, and we all know.
1:37:28 That fudge. And they know how to get around it. So I see that as a primary goal. Better management leads to better, quote, enforcement or collections of TOT, if you like to say that. And really, a better, you know, towns, we see this all over. You know, it's a national program. But let's lead, as we've been doing, I think, forever. You know, when I saw...
1:37:57 Started doing this, tracking this back in 2010 or 11 or whatever. So that is to me. Now maybe I'm wrong, but you know, I see that it's hard. As Amanda said, she acknowledged it's hard on parts of the community. But the end product will help us all, I think. Thank you, Sandy. Yes, Terry. Council and staff.
1:38:35 Terry Stellick, and I was sitting at home and then listening to you guys speak, and I had to come down here, because I'm going to reiterate that everything that you guys are talking about up there that you feel that we need to do and we need to improve can be done without a moratorium. We did have a lodging committee that was working with staff. It was very effective. It was pretty much disband.
1:39:01 And, but all of these things can happen. If you're not looking at changing or trying to force a price on a condo to go down so it's not, so it's affordable, I'm not sure why a moratorium is necessary for anything that you guys are looking at doing. All of the stuff that's been suggested for the lodging part of this and TOT and short-term rentals has already been discussed with the Lodging Association and there was no pushback.
1:39:29 And we are all willing to work with that. We're willing to work and improve that. So I guess I'm listening to you guys, and I don't feel that you're all on the same boat that you know exactly what it is that we're trying to accomplish. I know there's been a lot of rumors, and I haven't sat down and spoke to your staff, but there's a lot of things that have been said that are pretty disturbing. And so I'm just, once again, don't know why you need to go down the road of a moratorium to do the things that you guys all up here tonight said.
1:39:59 All of those things can be done without a moratorium. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anybody else in the room? Anybody online, Jamie? Okay, good. Council Member, can I offer a suggestion? I'm not quite hearing a clear direction from the dais about what the committee should or should not be doing. I'm hearing some look at housing in a broad way, look at housing in a narrow way.
1:40:27 It might help if we could get a consensus of the council, or at least a reading on the council, of are there certain things that the committee should or should not be doing? So, for example, there's some potentially housing-related topics that you might or might not want them to look at. So, should they be talking about different ways to spend the town's TOT dollars? Should they be talking about incentive programs for shifting short-term rentals to long-term rentals, or constructing ADUs, or any of the other...
1:40:57 Myriad ways you can encourage housing. Is that what you want them to do? Or do you want them to be doing STR stuff? Or both? I think, again, they just had their first meeting Monday night. We're here this evening. I think we're going to be coming back on December 6th, I believe. And I think if staff, if that's something, and John, I think if you could be working with staff to say if that's something that you think you really need, I think we can agendize it that way. We can have that kind of a discussion. But I think that, you know, we're
1:41:26 You know, I am speaking as one council member. I'm looking to see what the recommendation that comes, the types of recommendations come out of the committee. I don't want to predetermine it. I don't want to prejudge it. I want to keep this, for lack of a lighter term, a nexus between the emergency, which is why the moratorium is placed, and the specific recommendations of an SDR management program to come out of this committee. John, if you feel like, hey, we're floundering, we're going all over the place, we want some more specific direction.
1:41:56 You can maybe work with staff on that, and then we'll agendize our, we'll figure out a way to agendize that and provide that kind of direction if it's really needed. I think tonight it's a little premature this evening, I think, at this point. Does that answer your question? It's entirely up to the council as to what direction you want to provide. Okay, thank you. If I may, I think, so part of this process, and as you know, there's a lot of staff on the committee, not on the committee itself, but more just sort of governing the process.
1:42:29 I'm very clear on what your expectations and intent are. I will say that I probably am part of the problem when it comes to how so much conversation around housing did occur at our first meeting, because it's difficult to uncouple some of those comments. And I think part of the things I had provided were, you know, Dan and I have been trying to noodle through quite a bit off hours, if you will, to solve some of these issues. So I'm clear. I think that working with John, we can guide,
1:42:59 This committee to the right area. We recognize we have to get done in a very short amount of time. There is no way, shape, or form we intended to take on the entire housing process. It's just the peripheral elements of that. And I may not have been that clear, but I will be absolutely crystal clear going forward how we want to get that acknowledged. So I'm good. Good. So any of your observations? I appreciate that. I think we all appreciate that. I think, John, if you just work with Rob and staff, and if that comes up and you
1:43:28 It comes to that point, hey, we don't know what we're doing. We need something from questions you want us to weigh in, things that come up. To your point, Amanda, about compromise and some direction is needed along the way, I think we need more to jump. Sure. Just real quick, while I may not necessarily agree with it, I think that I saw consensus on council to keep this focused to the short-term rental program. So I think that is clearly there. That being said, I don't think we could have made the nexus to pass an emergency ordinance.
1:43:59 But we did. So I have no problem with it going forward. Yeah, there's one other piece of this, you know, we've hired its BAE economics. And I think that, you know, the whole purpose of that consultant who has helped many municipalities, including
1:44:19 is to take in all the data of what is our problem and then make some recommendations for us about what kinds of changes we should be making and right now for us because we haven't seen any reports yet it's a black box and I do think a lot of this will become more clear but I think the public needs to know that as well that we're not just as a committee.
1:44:45 You know, going forward, we are waiting for some very important recommendations that will guide our work, and unfortunately, we just need a couple weeks until that assistance arrives. Can I say one other thing, too? I mean, I guess I feel that the committee is discussing STR management tools. Okay, good. Okay, so with that, is there any other public comment or from anywhere? Okay, so with that, I would entertain a motion, then, on this report.
1:45:19 Who would like to go ahead and make that? I will move to approve the draft short-term rental study report and direct the staff to issue the report on behalf of the town. I'll second. Thank you. Any additional discussion? Hearing none. Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you all. John, team, everybody, thank you all very much. Okay, so we're going to move on now to item 9.2.
1:45:51 Receive an update on the fiscal year 23-24 Eastern Sierra Community Housing ESCH work program. Nolan. Good evening. I also have Patricia here. There she is. She's hiding in the back. So the ESCH, we're going to butcher their name repeatedly as they go through this name change process between MLH and ESCH. Their current contract went into effect in July of 2022 for the...
1:46:22 For the previous fiscal year, within that agreement, there's the option to extend that agreement automatically for two additional one-year terms, provided everyone agreed upon those at the time of renewal. So for the current fiscal year, that contract was extended for another year. The current funding for the contract is set at $336,000 per year. That has remained
1:46:49 The same from the previous year. And within that contract, it outlines that ESCH is to provide a minimum of two work program updates to town council. So this is the first update for the current fiscal year. With that, I will hand it off to, I'm not sure if it's Patricia or Olya presenting. All right. Hi, good evening. Hi, thank you. Just give us one second to get, yeah, what do you call this?
1:47:23 Aligned. Whoa. Are we there? Yep, there you go. Thank you for having us here this evening. I'm excited to be on the agenda on this very housing-specific town council meeting tonight. I'm Patricia Robertson, the Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing, and I'm joined this evening with, joined by our team.
1:48:24 I'm staff here who are going to help me present our work program. As Nolan mentioned, we have been going through a rebranding process as part of our 20th anniversary, and so I'll talk about that a little bit later towards the end of the presentation. I like to always give a little bit of background about our organization. We are a 501c3 nonprofit community housing development organization serving the tri-county area of Inyamono and Alpine counties.
1:48:59 We recognize our board is very keen to the fact that housing is a regional issue in our area, and so we're committed to helping our communities meet their housing goals. Our mission is to support community housing for a viable economy in a sustainable community. And a little bit more about the specific aspects of our organization. We're really unique in a few different ways.
1:49:33 We're a 501c3, so we're able to receive donations in exchange for tax benefits in accordance with the IRS. That includes financial contributions, asset contributions, property contributions. We're also a community housing development organization, which is a certification that we receive from the state. That allows us to compete for grant funding that might not otherwise be available if we didn't pursue it individually.
1:50:04 And then we're also a real estate brokerage, and so we have licensed real estate agents on staff, and that allows us the capacity to assist our first-time homebuyer clients. It's also part of our work plan with the town to provide those services, and so that's another unique way that we can contribute to housing solutions. It's always good to remind folks what a nonprofit does. We provide a public benefit.
1:50:35 And so the income that we receive goes directly to fund our overhead costs and services that we provide to the community. And then any revenue over expenses that our business generates is invested back into the mission of the organization, which is to support community housing for a viable economy and a sustainable community. And those decisions are made by our nine-member board of directors. Our board has...
1:51:05 One third of our board is representative of the low-income community. Not more than one third of our board is able to be an elected official or a public employee. And then the rest of our seats are open seats for the public or anybody who wants to join our board and make decisions about community housing. We've recently expanded our staff. We have four full-time staff now. We used to have only two.
1:51:41 And I just wanted to say that our staff are extremely knowledgeable and educated and provide great customer service in our office for our clients. We hold professional degrees in community and regional planning, rural community development, environmental science and natural resource recreation, political science and public service, and Chicano studies. And so I'm really proud of our team.
1:52:10 That we've been able to get really hard. It took two years, I think, to get everybody on board, and so I hope they never leave. But so I wanted they're all here this evening to share a little bit with you about our work program. These are the six elements that Nolan outlined in the staff report that are part of our work plan, which was revised extensively, I believe, from the prior contract that we had.
1:52:41 To concentrate it down into these six components, I think there was a desire to see a little bit more flexibility in some of these items, and so I'll try to go through each one directly, except for that some of them overlap, and my mind doesn't always see them in these boxes, but we'll do the best we can.
1:53:10 I wanted to talk about our budget, especially because our budget has changed substantially in the last year or so. Historically, the town has funded a vast majority of our operational budget, and that contract amount was $300,000 for about 10 years. Over that time period, the value of that contract appreciated about 30%.
1:53:36 And so we had a need to diversify our income stream so that we could sustain the ability to continue to provide services. And so in recent history, we have cooperated with Mono County and Alpine County to achieve contracts for services, specifically under a housing navigation program. And that is how we're able to hire two full-time staff for those positions.
1:54:06 That represents, I think it's about a third of our budget now, those additional contracts. And we've also tried to diversify our funding through fundraising efforts, which is not our area of expertise, but that we've been dabbling a lot in lately. And then with the addition of some of our development projects, we're able to generate a small revenue source that helps.
1:54:33 Pay for staff time to provide services to the clients that live in those housing developments. Okay, great. So we'll just jump into some of those work program items, and I'm going to pass it over to Olya, Olya Igorov, who's our housing navigator for Mono County. I mean, Alpine County. Oh, home ownership. Oh, home ownership. Sorry. Okay, so home ownership's in a lot of different boxes. So anyways, we do home ownership.
1:55:16 We are seeking our HUD certification for homeownership counseling, which we've never had before and is a need in the area. We would be the only HUD certified homeownership counseling agency in the Tri-County region. And so we're working towards that. This year, as you probably know, we've worked with the town to acquire and sell five bridge homeownership units to households earning
1:55:45 Below 150% of the area median income. And then we operate a mortgage assistance program that's funded through a variety of sources. We have our own grant that we can use for mortgage assistance. We're partnering with the town on their CDBG mortgage assistance grant. We are partnering with Mono County on their home mortgage assistance grant. The town has another source of funds that goes up to 120% AMI that we...
1:56:14 So, Esaura and I are the
1:56:47 We have new full-time staff who support housing navigation in the region. As Patricia mentioned, our roles are directly funded by Mono and Alpine counties. Our day-to-day duties include homelessness prevention and case management, where we mostly are linking community members to housing and also mainstream services like social services, food pantries.
1:57:13 And many more throughout the service area of Inyamono and Alpine counties. In this role, we also participate in the Eastern Sierra Continuum of Care, where we perform administrative duties like the review of written policies and procedures, as well as entering households into the regional homelessness database to place families in permanent housing projects.
1:57:41 Additionally, Isawad and I help build partnerships across the service area with traditional and non-traditional housing providers, as well as other service providers, including Wild Iris Family Counseling and Crisis Center, Mono County Behavioral Health, IMACA, and California Indian Legal Services, just to name a few. I really view our rules as bridging the gap between housing and other...
1:58:08 Underlying housing-related issues like public health, mental health, affordability, and physical well-being. So we have a legal aid station in our office. Eastern Sierra Community Housing is a proud partner of California Indian Legal Services where we facilitate weekly office hours for households seeking legal aid and also serve as an access point to fax, email, and print.
1:58:39 Crucial legal documents. It's been a really key resource for us to connect our community members to free or low-cost legal resources when applicable. So in addition, since the pandemic and as staff capacity has permitted, Eastern Sierra Community Housing has launched crisis and prevention programs in partnership with public and private entities. During COVID-19, we raised nearly a million or
1:59:10 A little over a million, I believe, for emergency rent relief, which helped more than 400 households and 150 landlords. During the recent state of emergency, we facilitated an emergency response and relief program to support households that experienced a storm-related crisis. And this was in partnership with the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Altera Mountain Company Community Foundation.
1:59:36 And most recently, over the summer, we gathered camp gear for our local and house population in partnership with Wild Iris, and we were able to help seven families across the service area. Thank you. Okay, so one of the other boxes is creation and preservation of deed-restricted units. That includes both ownership and rental units. We have a couple of different projects in our pipeline.
2:00:14 As you know, we'll talk about access apartments, commercial conversion projects in the Town of Mammoth Lakes. We have the Innsbruck Lodge Project, which is a partner project through Project Home Key with the Town of Mammoth Lakes as well. We're also working to help alleviate IMACA from some of their housing duties that they no longer wish to have responsibility of.
2:00:39 And so in the city of Bishop, attempting to preserve 19 low-income apartments where the regulatory agreement has expired. And so those are at risk of conversion to market rate. We're also the nonprofit local partner on a tax credit project in the city of Bishop with Visionary Home Builders. And we have transferred ownership from IMACA to Mammoth to Eastern Sierra Community Housing.
2:01:08 of the only transitional housing unit in Mono County for homelessness transition into permanent housing, and that's located in June Lake. Part of the preservation of deed restricted units includes the stewardship of our existing homeownership below market value homes that we have in the portfolio already. Our organization manages about 50 of those. I know the town has some.
2:01:42 As well, and so we're working together to get all of those into one database where we can monitor them all more efficiently. But we do coordinate with those homeowners annually to make sure that they're in compliance with their requirements of the program, including occupying the home for nine months out of the year, making sure that there's no renting of the unit happening since the program is intended for homeownership.
2:02:13 We do that annually. And then we maintain an ongoing relationship with our homeowners through when they need to refinance, we're part of that conversation. When they would like to make capital improvements to their unit, we're part of that conversation. And then when they would like to sell their unit, we're the main contact as part of that conversation as well.
2:02:45 12 months, I believe, we've transferred one home from a unit that had been owned for 10 or more years to a new household that works locally and has lived here for a long time. And so that was a good successful transfer. And then we have one unit in escrow, and we have two cases that we're monitoring right now for compliance. I'll talk a little bit about some of our grant programs.
2:03:19 I did mention that we have an award, a grant that we have procured through the Cal Home Program. This grant can be used for mortgage assistance and ADU construction loans throughout Mono County and the town of Mammoth Lakes. That serves 80% AMI and below. We're also working with the town on their mortgage assistance CDBG program, and we have obtained, I think it's $7 million.
2:03:53 For access apartments, which included a negotiation for an additional $1 million due to the COVID delay of the awards and an additional $800,000 for the two units that we've added to the scope of that project. You know that we submitted a successful Project Home Key Award when we were offered a purchase option on a hotel in the North Village and acquired that hotel, which is currently in rehabilitation.
2:04:32 We're working with the town on another mortgage assistance program, up to 120% AMI. Most of our clients need both below market value and mortgage assistance to fill the gap to afford homeownership. And then we provide grant reporting support. And so we collaborate with the housing coordinator on all of the reports that are due periodically with all of these grants that we receive. Some have quarterly reports.
2:05:02 Semi-Annual Reports, Annual Reports, and Milestone Reports. So we work with Nolan on all of those. Here's another component of stewardship, and this is more related to apartments, I would say. We do provide monitoring services for existing de-restricted units throughout the service area. We do the annual monitoring of a tax credit project in the City of Bishop on behalf of the city.
2:05:38 And then we also ensure that the Kits Buell Workforce Housing Apartments on Berner Street are in compliance with their deed restriction in the town of Mammoth Lakes as well. And then we also provide the annual vacancy report, which is a report of data that we collect during the month of December and January on how many rental listings are available to the public. And then we analyze that against how many long-term rental units exist in the community.
2:06:10 And come up with a number called the vacancy rate. And I think as long as I can remember, the vacancy rate is below 0%. So none of our apartments or long-term rentals are vacant in January for anyone to rent. And then we try to get out there in the community and let people know what we're up to. For the past couple of years, I've been partnering with the Board of Realtors to co-accept.
2:06:46 Present the Fair Housing Proclamation in the month of April. We also did some outreach that we hadn't done before during Affordable Housing Month in May. Our housing navigators went out to businesses and handed out flowers and business cards and let them know that if they had employees that needed assistance that we were available. We presented at the Chamber Luncheon on Workforce Housing this year. Our staff also attended the high school job fair.
2:07:18 In partnership with the Chamber. We hosted a listening booth for members of the community to come and tell us their housing stories. We've done that in the past. It's always an interesting event. And then we've also held some tenants' rights workshops in partnership with the Mono County Library. We held one in Bridgeport and one also in Mammoth. As I mentioned, we've been dabbling in fundraising, and I think we've...
2:07:54 I think we've really secured unprecedented private fundraising for housing. I've never seen anybody else raise private money for housing before in our community, but we'll talk about it a little bit more, but we almost raised $200,000 for access apartments, and we have received some private grants during the COVID rent relief program.
2:08:20 The winter state of emergency, but we also received our own capacity building grant from enterprise community partners to help staff consultants to help us with the value engineering process on access apartments. This is some of our impact from our last annual report, and so I usually try to get the report out before the end of March, and so our next annual report will be out hopefully in March 2024.
2:08:53 And I'll have that available at our next update. So I wanted to talk a little bit about our rebranding. You know, it's been 20 years as Mammoth Lakes Housing, and as part of efforts to diversify our income stream and better make those regional linkages to housing, we were finding it difficult to build those partnership relationships with our name as Mammoth Lakes Housing.
2:09:27 I think we all know there's different personalities out there in different parts of the service area. And so many times we were associated with Mammoth Mountain and why should we help solve their problem or it's not our problem. And so our board really felt that in order to successfully harness our collective capacity and these partnerships, that a more inclusive name would help us in that effort.
2:09:54 We did do a stakeholder survey, and all of our stakeholders, staff from all the jurisdictions in the communities really supported the change, and so I think it's going to be great. It's going to be great moving forward. And so we are Eastern Sierra Community Housing now. You can call us Esh, I guess, or whatever you feel good about, and we'll just roll with whatever sticks.
2:10:27 That was the name the stakeholder group felt best reflected the role of our organization and our board was comfortable with that and so that's what we have today. I guess, you know, this is just some of the stuff we've been up to. Over 20 years we have leveraged more than $62 million for housing, created 130 units to date and we have
2:10:59 We have more than 100 units in all of those projects that I listed currently in the works, and we are just very busy. That's all I have for this presentation, but if you have any specific questions about our work that we do, I'm happy to answer those. Excellent. Thank you very much. Okay, who's got questions? Questions? No? Okay, go ahead. Thank you so much. So the one slide that you showed
2:11:38 In 2018 and 19, the proportion of your budget that came from the town, and now it's changed in 23-24, but I might have missed it. What was the difference in the total budget? You mentioned it, but it went by fast for me. I may not have mentioned it. Well, I think it's grown. I did this calculation the other night. I think between those time periods, it's grown 30%, which
2:12:07 Which is inclusive of the two new contracts with the counties, which each one is $100,000 each. Okay. And then, sorry. Oh, another one was that if you had to say what proportion of your organization's time and energy is spent on helping folks in the 80% of AMI and below, and then what...
2:12:41 I would say that the majority is under 80%, and that's likely because they know that we have those resources available. We do have homeownership programs that go above that, and so I would say 75-25.
2:13:09 Those programs aren't always available. You may need to get on a waiting list. And so those folks drop off sometimes because the majority of our programs don't serve those income groups in the higher levels. Sure. And then I guess for now I will leave it there. Okay. Anybody else? Well, first thing is big congratulations on rebranding and your regional scope. I was way back in the day a member of the board.
2:13:49 So I've got a couple of questions. Does the foundation consider itself a developer, a builder of projects?
2:14:14 Yes, our organization is a community housing development organization which allows us to develop housing. Okay, I'm getting a little more specific because you've got an amazing and beautiful suite of services. Are you a project manager of construction of building projects? Is that in your portfolio? I didn't see anybody...
2:14:34 Specifically tagged with doing that kind of stuff, so I just wanted to ask that question. We have in the past had construction managers on staff when we had a larger budget. Right now we are using some of our grants that we've secured for capacity building to hire a consultant to help with project management. Right now you don't have anybody on staff. If I were to call you guys up and say, hey, do you build things?
2:14:58 And if so, who is your lead for project management, for building projects, and that kind of stuff? It sounds like at this point there is anybody on staff specifically who does that. There's not a project manager, but I would direct them to me, I suppose. Okay. Okay, good. Does the organization have any interest going forward in the management of housing units, housing developments, housing projects?
2:15:21 I think we've had that conversation many times at our board and especially during our strategic planning sessions. We've done some preliminary research on what that would take to make it a viable program because the capacity to manage the unit versus the fee that you can collect doesn't pay for a person. And so I think that...
2:15:47 We would be interested in continuing that conversation, but at this time we're not, we're managing our own units, but we're not taking on additional units. Okay, I'm just looking at a new organization, so I'm just asking these sort of naive questions. It's great portfolio work and great things that you're doing. This same presentation, your other clients, which I'm referring, you referred to yourself as a business, I'm referring to your other clients. Have you shown this same presentation, I guess, to Alpine County and to Pinot County as well?
2:16:15 I have a meeting with Alpine County on December 5th. Okay. I have presented to, we're well represented on the Continuum of Care, which is the regional homelessness entity. And so a lot of stakeholders from the entities are all there, social services from all the counties. And so they know the work that we do. I haven't given a specific, I've presented at the SCOG, but not specifically to the City of Bishop yet, for example.
2:16:45 Yeah, just because I, as electeds, we serve a variety of different boards, SCOG being one of them, talking to county folks, other folks in Monroe County. I just want to make sure that we're all seeing the same information. So we're talking about different services, who's doing what, we're thinking about tackling what kinds of things we want to do. Oh, yeah, this group does this, they don't do that, that kind of stuff. So I guess, and finally, who is in charge of client services? I mean, who does the outreach? Who's the liaison when you're talking to talk to clients?
2:17:13 It depends on who the client is. So if a client comes in and needs home ownership services, we direct them to Eric. If a client needs to get housing and also linked up with Mono County Social Services, we connect them with Isara. If they are an Alpine County client, we connect them with Olia.
2:17:33 And Olya also helps a lot with our Mono County clients because she's based in Mammoth Lakes, but she does visit Alpine County regularly and holds office hours for the clients there as well. So it just depends. Okay. But say with public agencies, like who's the leadership between your board, your board chair and yourself? Who's talking to Mono County? Who's managing those conversations? Does that involve your board as well or just you?
2:18:03 It would depend on whether it was a contractual agreement or not. Okay, good. Okay, those are my questions. Anything else? No? Okay, so are we taking any action here? Are we just informational? What's that? Our packet just says we're receiving the presentation. Right, so I'm assuming that's what it is. Is there any public comment or public observations on this? Yeah, Kirk, please. Thank everybody on the board, I have several.
2:18:34 I wear several different hats on a homeowner's board. And getting hourly employees for landscaping or painting or roofing or anything else is becoming so critical because the fact is that even down in Bishop, they have beginning to have housing shortages down there. So when you look at Crowley, when you go all the way down Valley and you're seeing...
2:19:04 Thank you. Thank you. Yes, thank you.
2:19:34 Good evening, Council. Tom Hodges. I'm Vice President of ESCH. Okay. I'm used to that. You have to slip there, Patricia, when you said MLH, but yes, ESCH, formerly MLH. John, just to your question about project management and so forth, I mean, obviously, we do have a development committee that I participate on and, you know, provide, you know, input to Patricia as she manages these projects, as well as a couple of other members of our board, Jennifer and Brian DeAndrea, who's...
2:20:02 Also runs a non-profit housing development company down in Century Housing down in the Los Angeles area. In any event, you know, providing a lot of expertise and feedback to Patricia as she navigates these projects that are very complicated. And we do have a contract, construction management, a gentleman that helps us out. His name is Kevin Sherada and Zen Development Group, I believe is the name of the company.
2:20:30 And he's a very highly qualified project manager. So, you know, it's just through the, you know, the funding of those, Innsbruck in particular, and Access as well, of the funds that we do have available on those projects that we use to fund his services. And, you know, he's actually very, very competent and qualified for assisting us with that. So it's a way that, you know, we recognize that we're shorthanded in that aspect on staff.
2:20:59 You know, it's actually worked out to be, you know, I think a great approach for the short term and the near term, because, you know, in the case of Innsbruck, there were, you know, developer fees built into the funding requests with the state and so forth, and those funds are available for that use. So I think it's worked out well. I mean, it's a great way to supplement, you know, our staff as we ramp up and down, being a, you know, a small organization overall. You know, and as time goes on, I mean, our goal is to try to launch a development project.
2:21:28 Every year if we can, right? And so we're working on that. We're looking at where some of these other opportunities are coming up down in Bishop and so forth that we're pursuing as well. And so I think depending on as things start to scale up over time, there might be the opportunity to bring somebody with that expertise. I just think just looking at the presentation and knowing the history of the organization, a lot of great work getting funding, getting grant funding going into projects. But just in the presentation, there's no specific representation.
2:21:57 Oh, we have a development construction division or arm or someone who does it. There's been certainly growth in that direction, I feel like, in the last couple years. I guess the question is, is that something that the organization is going to want to get? Is that a... I think so, and I think, you know, once we can, you know, put some projects together with adequate funding that could then provide funding to support that, we would do that, right? You don't want to bring somebody on and we only have funding really to...
2:22:24 Keep them in place for a short period of time or one project, you know, as an employee. So I think, you know, in the early years of Mammoth Lakes Housing when they had larger projects, obviously, you know, there was that opportunity and they did do that. And so, you know, we'll see as time goes on and whether we can, you know, start to create that growth and sustain it over time that certainly would be a logical position to bring on to staff for sure. It'd be good to know we look forward to meeting that person whenever that happens. Help her out with what we know and we got, you know, some really...
2:22:54 Some well-qualified and knowledgeable people on our board. Good. Excellent. Thanks. Thank you, Tom. Anybody else? Nope. Yes, sir. Yeah. Michael again. Thank you for hearing me. I just wanted to talk about the other end of the services, which is the interpersonal relationships and the warmth and support that I experienced almost immediately from the agency. It's really hard to relocate for medical reasons.
2:23:30 Especially when you have very limited funds. And Mammoth Lakes Housing now, Eastern Sierra, just opened their door to me and sat me down and spent an inordinate amount of time reviewing the options and availabilities. And a person couldn't ask for better reception from a town. So it's not just the big projects they're engaged with and the difficulties of managing and funding such projects, but it's the one-on-one stuff.
2:24:01 It gives individuals hope. And it's a very critical link. There's an intersectionality between their services and the goals of this city and individuals like myself. So I just wanted to give a compliment and express gratitude for that fact. Excellent. Thank you very much. It's no surprise to hear that that organization is providing that level of service. We all appreciate it. OK. So thank you. We're done with this one? All right.
2:24:33 Excuse me? I have somebody on Zoom. Oh, okay, great. Thank you. Jennifer, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, good evening. This is Jennifer Kreitz, Supervisor with Mono County and also a board member of the Eastern Sierra Community Housing. I wish I could be there tonight. I'm actually in Oakland at the California State Association of Counties Annual Conference. And, you know, I listened to the presentation and...
2:25:03 I want to just thank the town and the organization for working together to make the Home Key Project happen. I know it's delayed, as many things are under construction these days, but it is going to be a great success. I'm confident today at our...
2:25:27 We had a committee meeting for housing, land use and transportation. We had the director of housing, the state housing community development department, Gustavo Velasquez, and he really highlighted the home key projects as a success in the state and that we should look to more funding coming into that program. There's 400 million available right now over the counter for that program.
2:25:57 continue working together, perhaps in this capacity under this program. I think we could really serve our communities well in Mammoth and up and down regionally as we think about our region. So thank you and that's all I have. Excellent. Thank you, Supervisor Kreitz. Anybody else? Okay, I think we're good.
2:26:28 Thank you all very much. So we'll move on now to the next item. And this is to consider a request for additional funding for the Eastern Sierra Community Housing, formerly Mammoth Lakes Housing Access Apartments Project. Nolan. Great. So I'll just give a brief overview of the history of this project at the town level. And then I believe Patricia also has a presentation on this. And we'll open it up for discussion.
2:26:56 This project has been ongoing for a number of years. We actually met in May of 2017 initially with Jennifer when she was still the Executive Director to discuss this project at the town level at our DRC meeting. Following that, they worked to secure the property, worked on a concept, worked on outreach. In November of 2019, they approached the town about
2:27:23 Thank you so much for joining us.
2:27:52 Over-subscription and just the applications. So it was approximately two years after that that we at least were notified of a conditional award for the CDBG portion for $3 million. Around the same point, they also were notified that they were successful in their home application for around $3 million as well. Once we got the conditional award, it took about another seven months to get our standard agreement from the state for when we actually could then start.
2:28:22 Using those funds, so that was in December of 2022, we got the standard agreement. Also during that period in 2021, missed in my notes, the Town Council did allocate an additional $1.2 million to the project. So at that point, the Town had committed $1.5 million for this project. The Town and Mammoth Lake's housing worked to put out a bid for the construction in March of 2023.
2:28:48 Those bids, two bids were received. They were both significantly over budget. And then since that time, Mammoth Lakes Housing has worked on value engineering that project to reduce the construction cost. They've also pursued looking for additional funding from other organizations and other donors, which they'll talk more about in their presentation. With that, I know they were successful, as we talked about in our report.
2:29:16 Getting $600,000 from Mono County last week. So with that, their current ask for us, it ranges. It also appears the project has increased from 11 units to 13 units. That is a new revelation in the project that there is room for two additional units. Also, they talked about the additional home funding and the presentation of a potential for additional $800,000 from home for that. So those are all kind of
2:29:46 The current budget, as we know, is approximately $11 million for the project. So with that ask of the town, the subsidy range, depending if it's...
2:30:08 11 units or 13 units, and if it's $1.4 million or $2 million, ranges from about $223,000 to $264,000 per unit. Can you repeat those numbers real quick? Ranges from $223,000 to $264,000, and that's if it's $1.4 million or $2 million, and then also depends if it's 11 units or 13 units on that range.
2:30:37 When we compare this to other projects, just for comparison, the average subsidy of other housing-funded projects we've funded, it ranges from $11,000 per unit to $200,000 per unit. So that's with other recent housing projects that we've funded. With that, there's no exact formula as to what's appropriate, what's the maximum amount to invest in the project. Every project's unique and different.
2:31:03 However, with that, as we kind of looked at other projects, the recommendation in the staff report would be for up to a $200,000 per unit subsidy. So that would be $700,000 additional beyond the $1.5 million previously committed. And again, if it is a 13-unit project, that is a discussion item whether that would be additional funding on top of that or how that would work out. Okay, so I'm going to turn to my fellow council members if there's any questions.
2:31:32 And then Patricia, do you have, is there a presentation that you have or, um, do you want to do that first or? Okay, let's go ahead and let's, so we have all the information, if you want to give that presentation first.
2:32:46 I'm just going to move over. Yeah. I pushed out a mask. Big freeze is over there. My DSES Heli Hanson Parker right about now. Yeah. Okay, ready? Yes. Okay. Thank you, Mayor Wentworth and Councilmembers. I'm Patricia Robertson, the Executive Director of Eastern Sierra Community Housing, formerly Mammoth Lakes Housing.
2:33:24 And I'm here to present to you today our project, Access Apartments. This is some of our team members. We have Mammoth Lakes Housing staff, myself and Eric, obviously our development committee that Vice President Hodges mentioned. And some of these folks are online, so if we have specific questions, they're available. We have Kevin Sherata, who's our project manager.
2:33:52 We selected Kevin Daly Architects as the architecture firm, and I know Jared is online. And we have conditionally contracted with Menemsha Development Group as the GC for this project and who has worked with us through the value engineering process. We're also a partner with Visionary Home Builders on this project who brings additional capacity and expertise. They are a nonprofit.
2:34:21 Affordable Housing Developer with 40 years of experience. With that, I'm going to pass it over to Eric so he can give you some background information, and then I'll come back. Evening, Councilmembers. Yeah, like Patricia said, you guys have seen an iteration of this before, so I'll go brief on the overview of it. So in 2017, I believe the town created, yeah, the Community Action Housing Plan, and that housing plan, it was said that...
2:34:58 We need 595 units for the region. So this project meets those objectives in the housing plan, those and the ones that are listed below. And a brief overview of Acts Apartments. So Acts Apartments is a commercial zone two or two zone. And this allows short-term rentals. So thankfully, we got this partial land donation from the seller during the acquisition. So at the completion of this project, we will have 11 units.
2:35:30 11 or 13 studio and one bedroom apartments with five covered garage spaces. And then something I want to point out is that this perfect case study for SB35 and the recent bill that was just passed, which is AB 1490, where the Tenor Center for Housing Innovation at UC Berkeley. So they really study looking at the streamlining possibilities of affordable housing and the benefits and the creation of affordable housing.
2:36:00 So that's a perfect case study for them to look at. And then the AB 1490, which is the state's desire to prioritize adaptive reuse projects. And again, this is a good case for that. Okay, so location amenities. This is a really big one. But due to location of this project, we had really good competitive advantages in the grants that we applied for.
2:36:30 The location is primary pedestrian centered. So most of the residents are going to be living there. We'll have access to the following list. So they're going to have access to free transit, school, library, medical facilities, community service, shoppings, and more, all within a mile radius. So that's really good. It centerizes the location of it. And then an important thing to note on this project is that with the completion project, it diversifies.
2:36:58 I guess the area where affordable housing is, it's not concentrated in one area, and it prevents income segregation in our community. So instead of it all just being based in Passport Village, you know, it's operated around town. So yeah. And then this project also meets town council strategic priorities, and that is to deliver diverse housing solutions working with the private sector and other agencies locally and regionally.
2:37:29 This project is meeting a lot of surgery projects that we have, as well as our work program deliverables, which is, we have two here. One of them is the creation and preservation of deed restricted units. That's both in ownership and rental. And then the procurement of grants and management of those grants. And then a little background. So we purchased the unit or the building in 2017. And as you can see, we've done.
2:38:02 We've been working on it throughout the years. I know this board is one of our hardest priorities on this. So that is good. I mean, in 2013, like Nolan mentioned, we did a public bidding process. We did some value engineering. And now we're in the final funding stretch of the project. And then something that's not mentioned here is that to date we have a million dollars sunk into the project. And that's not including any curing costs or
2:38:32 Staff time that have been put into it. And then, okay, so, capital stack. So, to date, we have 87% of the toll funds completed that we have for the project. As you can see, the majority of it is state and federal grants. And then, oh, okay, so, in the staff report, it says that our funding gap is 2.8 million. Fortunately, we were able to secure 600,000 from county supervisors, and then we got an issue.
2:39:05 An additional $800,000 from the state to include two more units into the project. So that brings down the cost a lot less to $1.4 million, which is going to be our ask for today. And then there's just a different way of seeing. What do you want? Which one? I apologize, everyone. So you said that the gap was $2.2 million, but you got $600,000 from the county and $800,000 from $2.8.
2:39:40 2.8, that's what I heard wrong. Thank you. That's all I needed. Thanks a lot. But just to clarify that, even though this additional money came in, it's for two additional units, right? So it went from 11 units to 13 units? Is that in the staff report? No. Okay, so this is all new information that's not in our staff report. Frantically writing. Sorry. No, I appreciate that. Thank you. Okay, sorry. Go ahead. Yeah, no problem. And it's just a different way of looking at the funding stack.
2:40:17 I guess just something I want to point out. We have $6.9 million in grants and state funding. And then we do have fee waivers from Mono County Library, which is $200,000. Then we did raise, like you were saying, we did fundraising and that. We got some private donations and that equals $120,000 around that point. And then obviously our local jurisdiction contributions, which is $1.5 from the town and then $600,000 from Mono County Supervisors.
2:40:52 And I apologize. We have been working with our funders to find out if adding units would be acceptable. And the reason why we had come up with that idea was to try to reduce the cost per unit because we knew it was a concern for the community. And when we went through the value engineering process, that budget includes the two additional units. There was cost savings there, even though there was some cost increases in some areas, there was savings in other areas.
2:41:24 And so there still was an overall cost savings even by adding the two units. And so the budget that Nolan said of $11 million is still the same budget. Question. Number of bedrooms on the 11th plan versus the 13 now. Did we add more bedrooms? Because originally I think we were looking at primarily one-bedroom units and now we're talking about one-bedroom and studios. Yes.
2:41:52 So it will be two studio, the two additional will be studios, and they'll be, the rest are one bedrooms, the same. Okay. No, it's hard for us because none of this is in the staff report. There's a lot of new information coming in. It's great. It's good progress, but, you know, it's...
2:42:14 So we weren't sure if the funders would allow for it, and we sort of just, CDBG said it was okay, but home wasn't sure, and we had asked them in May, and they never got back to us, and so they just got back to us and said, if you add the units, we'll give you more money. So I said, okay, well, that should be what we do, I think. Okay. So, yeah. I was thinking about this project and just reflecting on the time it's been taking and some of the success that we've had and setbacks.
2:42:40 And it occurred to me that over the past six years, given the funding that we've been able to achieve, it really represents more than $1 million each year, two units per each year, culminating in this project, which is $6.9 million in state and federal funding and 13 units. And so I was thinking back on that, and I thought that was a good way to think of it. This is the budget.
2:43:11 And so the $11 million is at the bottom. We have the land cost is in here, the rehab cost, which includes the scope that we just discussed. Soft costs, we will take out a construction loan, which has costs associated with it. We also have to pay insurance. And then we're required to provide reserves for the project by the grants.
2:43:44 And so those reserves have been funded by the Eastern Sierra Continuum of Care. So we have – that's – their portion of contribution will go towards the reserves. We have a contingency built into the budget. It's not large. And then we have – Sorry, real quick. The contingency is – what percentage is it and percentage of what? I think it's a percentage of the rehab. And it's –
2:44:14 It's less, is it less than 10%? Less than 10%, so the, okay. And then we have our developer fee, which is a number calculated by the state, and that's our contingency of last resort. Those funds can be used to help hire our project manager and help offset the risk that our organization has taken on by pursuing this project. Nolan really gave a great overview of the history of this project, so I will try not to go into it.
2:44:54 We did have public design workshops in 2019. The architects came to Mammoth. We had bilingual architects available. The meeting was in English and in Spanish. It was family friendly. And we took the community's input and we put it into the project. That included the need for one bedroom apartments, the need for covered parking, storage, storage, storage, and affordable rents.
2:45:28 I wanted to touch on some of the sustainability considerations. Eric mentioned the state's goal to promote more adaptive reuse projects in our mission to provide housing. And so there are some benefits to doing adaptive reuse, including less waste from not having to scrape the site entirely.
2:45:53 Potential reduced carbon footprint from having less heavy machinery and also not utilizing all new materials. And then this project will meet the Cal Green Code, which is energy efficiency by California standards. And it will, one of my priorities was that it would have enhanced durability and reduced maintenance in the long term. I know we've seen with some of our projects the exteriors really suffer in the weather here.
2:46:23 And so that was a priority for me and our board. Considering that this is a small project and won't generate a lot of revenue, it's important that it's sustainable and maintains itself so that we're not putting tons of money into it year after year. And then one really unique thing about this project is that it preserves some of Mammoth Lake's history. This property was partially donated by Sharon Alper in loving memory of her husband, Gordon.
2:46:56 You know, he built the Country Glass Building in the 80s when he had a broken window and there was no window company to fix it. And so he wasn't a glass expert, but he became one. And he was a former council member, an active community member, and the champion of the urban growth boundary. So I've heard.
2:47:22 But so this is a really unique opportunity for us to reuse an existing structure that has meaning for the community. The funding requires that it be affordable for 55 years. These are the units and the income levels. We will serve up to 80% AMI, and you can see the rents here as of 2023. I know this slide is crazy, but I...
2:47:54 I wanted to just throw this data at you. We have about 200 households on our internal waiting list for affordable housing. I know I've heard that there's 400 on the parcel waiting list. But based on household size and income, approximately 65% of the households on our list would qualify to live here. So this is just some images of our community members, single individuals, single parents.
2:48:30 Couples, Workforce, obviously. And then we do have a video that we'd like to share of a few testimonials. I know we don't have a lot of community members in the audience, but we do have community members that shared their story with us and asked us to share it with you. You may have to make sure you're muted over there, like mute your microphone and mute the computer.
2:50:04 Or if you turn up your computer's volume so we can just hear it off the computer and play it loud and then I would turn that microphone off so there's no feedback. I think it was worth it. Okay, this is where we are now. And so we have done some value engineering. We have saved a little more than a million in the original bids, the lowest bid. And we are here to secure the final funding, which is a total gap.
2:53:59 This project is really unique and special in so many ways, but one of them is the really diverse
2:54:34 Funding stack. It's a combination of public contributions, private donations, $25 donations from our community members, and even in-kind contributions from our local businesses. This coffee cup sleeve that you see here was actually a collaboration between Eastern Sierra Community Housing.
2:55:01 Andrea Walker from Stellar Brew and Mammoth Lakes Tourism. They helped fund this coffee sleeve that has a QR code on it so that if you feel like housing is important to you, whether you're a visitor or a local, you can scan that QR code and make a donation. This is a timeline of the grants that Nolan already laid out for you.
2:55:30 But part of our fundraising launch, it really was spurred by the delay in the grants. So we weren't sitting around just waiting. We were actively pursuing additional funding and options for this project. One really interesting thing about this project as well, though, is that it has both home funds and CDBG funds. Home funds are traditionally used for new construction.
2:55:57 And CDBG funds are usually used for rehabilitation. But because of the unique nature of our project, we're able to secure both of those sources. I think that our fundraising efforts are unprecedented. We came up with some fundraising tiers to make it more interesting. You could be a sustaining wall or a window of opportunity. But here are some of our partners to date.
2:56:33 Foundation, U.S. Bank, Anthem Blue Cross has donated, Century Housing Vacasa has made a contribution, a couple of different contributions, Eastern Sierra Continuum of Care, and then many others. I don't have to name them all, but this is some of them. I think this is the slide we want to see.
2:57:04 This is the cost per unit based on the funding source. And the gap is here. And so the gap per unit is $107,000. You can see that the grants are 63% of the total cost. The private donations and miscellaneous other grants are 5%. And I just rounded up on this bottom number. The town has already contributed $1.5 million.
2:57:35 I just said, well, if they contributed another $1.5 million, that's an even number. It would be 27% of the total development cost, and it would cost $230,000 per unit up front. However, these units are affordable for 55 years, and so while it's an investment up front, the town's really putting into a savings account.
2:58:04 A cost that it would cost to house these households for 55 years. So the cost per unit for each year is $4,000 for that hypothetical town contribution that I had in the last slide. A little more about the cost I think it's important to talk about before we go to questions. We obviously know that there was...
2:58:36 An increase in cost during COVID across the construction industry. We know there's labor shortages. We know that there's supply chain shortages. It's hard to get electrical equipment, for example, right now, and it costs twice as much. But another interesting thing about affordable housing is that an independent study showed that for each additional state or grant that you get for affordable housing, it adds an additional $15,000 in cost per unit to the project.
2:59:14 I did some research on cost of affordable housing in resort areas, and I found this project in South Lake Tahoe. That is another Pacific Company's project. It's 60 apartments for their phase two. It's a tax credit project. The total cost is $55 million.
2:59:39 They did receive an infrastructure grant, so if you even subtract that out, their cost per unit is $873 per unit for this phase. Cost per unit is one concept, but this large tax credit project can also take out permanent debt because they're collecting rents on 60 units. And so they can afford to pay monthly debt service on a loan of $2 million. We have explored loans for access apartments.
3:00:12 But with 13 units, you don't generate enough revenue to afford to pay a private mortgage company monthly debt. Another interesting point about the cost is that in many projects, similar to, I believe, the parcel, land isn't even included in the total development cost because it's donated in many cases, or it's a dollar. In our case, the land is included in the cost because it was an upfront cost of our organization to purchase the land.
3:00:43 And we currently carry a loan on it right now today, which we will need to pay off at closing. There's another project called the Lumber Yard in Aspen, Colorado, that's going through the permitting process. And that project's estimated to cost just over $1 million per unit. And that's just another example of a resort area affordable housing project.
3:01:16 Larger projects are often more competitive for different types of sources like tax credits or even affordable housing sustainable communities grants because the programs are designed that way. We all want more units and higher density, but that's only one piece of the solution. It doesn't surprise me that our project needs more subsidy per unit than some of our other projects that we've been working on.
3:01:50 I was recently at a conference and I did talk to the home program section chief who let me know that she didn't, you know, the state doesn't have a problem with the cost per unit. They have underwritten the pro forma. They have looked at this budget. They have scrutinized it. It has gone through final loan committee on their end and their loan committee has approved it and that they don't see a problem with the cost per unit.
3:02:18 They are pulling for this project and that's why we were able to get an additional $800,000. I think what, you know, the unique aspects of this project really illustrates is our ability to think outside of the box and deliver non-traditional funding stacks for a smaller scale project that still meets our primary goal of community housing. I wanted to make a note about the housing mitigation ordinance passed in 2015.
3:02:59 Removed the 10% inclusionary requirement and it recommended a fee that new development pay only 30% of their actual impact. And the reasoning for that was because the town and other agencies would make up the difference. Well, we know that we needed 595 units through 2022 and we're working on delivering 100 of them.
3:03:27 But I just wonder if we're really making up that 70% and what we could do to make sure that we are. There's also a lot of housing mitigation credits still out there, and so new developments may not have to pay even 30%. If they have a credit, they might need to pay nothing. And so I would hope that this project could help deliver the housing that we need for various reasons. Well, here's the iceberg.
3:04:02 You know, we have unfilled job vacancies. Everybody's hiring. The business community's struggling. We're going to have growing job demand with new development like the Limelight Hotel. And so we believe that this is how we can help contribute to the solution. We have explored a lot of alternatives for this project. To bring you what we believe is the best product today, we've explored phasing the project.
3:04:34 It's going to cost more overall in the long term to phase the project. And there's no guarantee that we could get the grants that we need to finish phase two. We could start from scratch. We could give up our $7 million in grants and all the costs that we've incurred to date. But really, on this item, what I can't figure out is what is the cost of waiting more time to deliver the project, the housing.
3:05:06 I don't know what the cost of that is, but it strikes me as an important factor. I have played around with the idea of foregoing one of the grants, keeping the other, and raising the income limits to 120% of the area median income, where we know there's a need. Possibly we could take on some permanent debt because the rents would be higher. But my estimates gauge that the gap would increase to $4.5 million.
3:05:37 I think if that's something we want to explore, we should talk about it, but it's certainly more money up front. I think we could use, you know, money to invest in homeownership bridge units through the bridge program. I think Nolan estimated $125,000 per unit. I don't know, maybe we could get seven units, but I looked on the MLS and the five cheapest...
3:06:12 One bedroom, condos are all more than 50 years old. They're all more than 50 years old. We have no control over what the HOA is going to do. We're seeing HOAs increase 100% for, you know, and I'm concerned about the clients that we already have in condos where HOAs are going up. We have clients who struggled with their special assessments last year. So while I think the bridge program is...
3:06:42 I don't think it's the only solution. You know, we've played around with the idea of moving our offices over there. We own the property. We're expanding our staff. We could use some more space. Maybe we could rent some of the other space to Wild Iris or another partner agency and make a little community hub. We'd still lose the $7 million in grants that we've worked so hard for. We still have to rehab it. It's not in the best shape.
3:07:15 But we could maintain the asset for a future opportunity. Or our board has discussed possibly selling the property. We lose everything that we've put into the project to date. The land is zoned, available for short-term rentals. But we could use the proceeds from that to pursue another project. So we all know what the community benefits are. But I do believe that there's another benefit that's not on here, which is supporting
3:07:54 A non-profit agency in the community by supporting this project. It helps diversify our portfolio and our income stream so that we can continue to reinvest those funds back into our mission. Thinking back on this project, I've been working on this project for a long time. Oh yeah, there he is. I completed the home application when I was on maternity leave with my second son. And I didn't know that he was going to be
3:08:26 I believe that if we can deliver this product to you today with a $1.4 million gap with only two full-time staff and a volunteer board of directors, I think it's not only worth funding, but it's worth celebrating.
3:09:02 Well, I want to say, you know, as Rusty Gregory would say, don't let perfection get in the way of the good. Is this project perfect? No. If we could do it differently, would we? Probably. Are we in that position today? No. And while it may not be perfect, I think it's pretty good. And I'm really proud of this deliverable before you. And before I go,
3:09:32 I just want to thank all of our staff and our board for their time and thoughtful decision-making. The town, for their initial commitment of $1.5 million, because if we didn't have that, we wouldn't have been competitive for the grants that we got. Our team at Kevin Daly Architects and Manemcha Development Group for dealing with me, Visionary for all their capacity and extra experience.
3:10:01 And all of our private donors. It's amazing. Without this collective effort, this project would not be possible. Our team is online, so if it's for them, I might just call them out. You go first. No, you go. I'm on the board, so you go ahead.
3:10:50 You know, Patricia, I'm glad you mentioned the land value because I was thinking about that. So, Nolan, I know when we think about the cost, the town contribution per unit, we're talking about the hard dollars that we're paying for the construction part for the most part. So, for example, the parcel, the town purchased that land and then contributed it to the project. So, it is a little bit of apples to apples at the way we're looking at the
3:11:21 Summary. Yeah, in the breakdown of the summary, the, you know, the town purchased the parcel for, I believe it was six and a half million. Each phase is sold to the developers, so the actual land for each phase, based on the appraised value at the time of closing. That is a deferred loan, so the, in that spread, in the, the staff report when it says the $10,000 contribution, that is the deferred loan value of the land and the diff fees, because that is our contribution into phase one.
3:11:51 That is just the cost of phase one. So it's not, you know, it doesn't include the six and a half million pulled in because that's broken out across phases. But the way you did it, it would eventually all catch up. So, okay. The next question. The way I see it is staff recommended an additional $750K before all the new information came in tonight. So that's, so that that would contemplate that the town.
3:12:20 Would put in 2.25 million, but the need is 2.9. So now we're talking about a $700,000 difference. Did I do that right? So it's just, I just want to lay that out there because it's getting closer. And I think we should acknowledge that. I don't know. I'm not, I haven't had a chance to totally digest that yet. And this is a little hard because every, you all know this, but
3:12:50 We usually do our homework and have it all figured out. We try before we get up here because it's really hard. And I understand why I'm not. But I'm just saying, like, if we seem a little bit like you're in headlights, I think it's because we are. So with that, I will turn it over to my colleagues. I am having some of the same issues here. What I would really like to see is a new action agenda sheet to come on that.
3:13:31 Patricia and Nolan would both work on with all of the relevant figures that are not going to change in front of me. That being said, that would be at the December 6 meeting, I'm assuming. Would that endanger in any way the project? I can't see how it would, seeing how it's been six years. So that's my question. I would like to see a clean presentation of all the numbers and facts and
3:14:01 1.4 million is still a large chunk of change. Are we having to rob from something else to get that money? What does it mean budgetarily? Where would that 1.4 come from? And when does it have to come out of the budget for the project to succeed? I think those are the important questions we need to have answers to that we are not going to have tonight. Okay? Sarah, Amanda? I guess just to jump on what Bill said, you know,
3:14:32 Yeah, like, what's our, I really want to see this happen. I really don't want to keep walking and riding my bike past this building with plywood up on the windows. If we're all about housing, I want to support this project, but I, what is our safety net if we don't break ground, or, you know, what is our safety net if we don't break ground in the spring? What, what is our, what is our guarantee? What is, you know, I,
3:15:06 I'm really, this is really hard. I really want to see this building come to life. And I am willing to throw a lot of money of the town's money, it's not my money, taxpayer money to see it come to life. But I want to make sure that we're making a safe investment. Thank you. Amanda? Well, I didn't have time to write down the full costs from that sheet.
3:15:39 But I did get a few on there. And I'm on the board of Mammoth Lakes Housing. I hate to suggest this, but I do feel like, you know, the developer's cost is $814,000. I feel like that's the gap right there. If we do $700,000 today, which staff is recommending, you know, negotiating the developer's cost. And, you know, it seems that when Mammoth Lakes Housing is short of funds for
3:16:07 Prior projects, you know, you come to the town and ask for funding. We helped additionally on the Innsbruck to get that fully funded. I mean, I just feel like we're there, we're so close. I hate to see $700,000 derail a project. And so I feel, you know, I don't know if you would be open to that, Patricia, but I did notice the developer's cost is $814,000, and that's kind of what the gap is.
3:16:37 So I don't know if there's wiggle room on that. Okay, so I think what I'm hearing here is a real desire from the council to make this project. Oh, I'm sorry. Thank you, man. You got a new job up here. Thank you. I think that there's a real desire from the council to support this project and to make it happen. But we've got some problems, some questions. We're getting to that point. These are maybe these questions about developer earlier.
3:17:07 Tom, here we are. We need to understand, is this organization the developer of this project? Which is important, because I think it's important in terms of public funds. I think the town and the council and the taxpayers need to know that we can have a productive, professional, arm's-length relationship with any developer. I think we have the same relationship with Pacific. We have expectations that you're going to hit deadlines, you're going to hit budget.
3:17:37 It's kind of a maturing process, which you've demonstrated amply this evening, regional, brand, you're doing all this kind of stuff. We're kind of at that point, we've got to have these real kind of grown-up kinds of discussions to make sure we're clear in what we're doing. So I think if it's okay...
3:17:55 And we're making the assumption, Patricia, that if we were to continue this to December 6th, that's not going to put at risk any of your funding. Is that fair to say? I think it puts at risk any of our funding. However, we can't proceed with the redesign of the plans until we have all the funding committed. Right. We don't want to continue to invest money in the project if it's not going to go forward. And so it could possibly delay the building permit. That's fine. We're talking a couple of weeks. And I think it will be helpful.
3:18:23 For staff, for Nolan, and again, I go back to that, the client, the leadership team of the organization. I don't know who it is, if it's your board president, your vice president, working with the town to address some of these types of questions, roles developer, what actually is the gap, this 11, 13 units, just all these types of questions to come back with. I don't think you need to pitch it to us anymore about the value of doing this. I think we just need to see, you know, good, cold.
3:18:52 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:19:18 Make an informed decision. Like if I can't explain what just happened. Exactly. Which I can't really. Exactly. We want to be. 29. That's. I wouldn't know. We can't put it under that. No, that, okay. I think, and I think, let's, let's, there's a holiday in between now and then. Let's. Okay. Let's give staff and leadership of the organization a chance to really get. Could we, could we approve, like, do the staff recommendation and approve $700,000 tonight? And then. My problem with that, Amanda, is.
3:19:50 This project has been ongoing for so long. When we approve an amount of money, I want to make sure that that's it. We're done. It's not going to come back for more. We have funded it if that's what we choose to do. And even the 700, I would still have questions today. Our staff is very creative. But what do we damage and when does it have to come forward? Those are still questions I would like prior to committing. And I think also, I think that's just...
3:20:20 This is responsible, but I think also going forward with the project for the council, the community to understand who are we, who's accountable, who's giving project updates, you know, how, because this is a development project and that's what you guys are doing and I think it'd be really a good positive step forward to be defining that relationship and knowing who's accountable, who's doing what, because it's a great thing you guys are doing and I think we need to get into that type of relationship. That would be really helpful.
3:20:48 We all want to see this happen. If this entity is the entity that can say, here is the amount and we're done, it's happening, I want to be, I desperately want that. Desperation from the dais. Okay, is there anything else or any other thoughts? Oh, do you have some? Oh, great, thank you. Jennifer, please unmute yourself and give your comments.
3:21:18 Oh, thank you. I've sat here, so I just want to make a few comments. First, I'm going to go back to Director Velasquez from the state. He informed us today that the average cost per door for affordable housing development is $609,000 per door. So that's an average.
3:21:47 And he acknowledged there's in high cost areas like Mono County and other places, you know, Marin, et cetera, coastal areas, you know, there are a million and some are lower. That's how we get to an average of 609. So this project isn't outside of what is happening across California, I think.
3:22:10 You know, we already have a relationship. I'm speaking now as a board member for Eastern Sierra Community Housing with the town in development. We have the home key projects. This isn't a new relationship. Eastern Sierra Community Housing has been managing the conversion of Innsbruck Lodge. And so I don't think we're getting outside of any territory. We're not already.
3:22:40 I want to, I want to, I guess those are, those are, that's mostly what I want to say at this moment, but I do think it's important to not delay. So thank you for considering putting it back on early in December. I appreciate that. Okay, thank you, Jennifer. Thanks for listening in and paying attention. Mr. Hodges. Yeah, thanks. Thanks for letting me.
3:23:13 Get back up to make a comment real quick. Just a couple other thoughts. You know, recognize that the project is, you know, meeting current code, right? So we're taking a, what, mid-80s? So we're 35, 40-year-old building. And to meet new code is extraordinarily expensive. And so that's certainly driving, you know, some of the construction costs that you're seeing reflected in the cost of construction. I mean, the building's basically brought up the current code for structural, energy, efficiency, green building standards, and so forth.
3:23:45 And those coats are, you know, those costs have added up over the past couple decades. And it's added true incremental cost to building, period, in California. And then you add the mammoth factor onto that of our remoteness and the challenges of getting construction crews here that are competent enough to build this. One of the other things, too, you know, that comes with the grant funding was a requirement that it was publicly bid.
3:24:13 So we went through a public bid process. So we went out and asked, we advertised it actually in some of the prominent public bidding publications across California. We got two bids. So, and one local bid that was a couple million higher than the lower bidder that we've been working with, Menentia, who's from Southern California. So it's a very challenging marketplace right now in construction.
3:24:43 Just finding resources to do the work period is a super big change from that firsthand from, you know, what we're encountering on the mountain doing our projects. And, you know, the cost of construction inflation are probably double sort of the consumer price index inflation. So, you know, 8% consumer price index inflation year over year. It's probably 15 to even higher than in construction industry right now. Maybe backing off slightly a little bit now, starting to ease up a little bit.
3:25:13 It's been crazy the last two years. The construction inflation is huge. So those things are impacting the cost of the project. And, you know, yeah, so it's just, you know, again, I think Jennifer mentioned too, I think you guys recognize it. The longer it drags out, if we were to go another year, costs are only going to keep going up. So we're going to be in this continual loop of trying to, you know, match, catch up the funding to the construction costs, and you'll just never get there.
3:25:51 You know, I do appreciate your guys' perspective, and I think you're absolutely justified in asking for that. We should definitely come back to you guys with full clarity of pro forma, you know, cost of construction and funding and just the pro forma analysis for the overall development. Absolutely, that makes total sense to me. But I think, you know, the ask would be for to fill the gap. And because we just we need to get there and get this thing going. It's otherwise, you know, relatively shovel ready. There'll be some amendment for this additional two units.
3:26:22 And then just finally, speaking to the developer fee, you also saw the contingency combined is about 1.6 million, in excess of 10% of the project cost. But again, to your point of, hey, don't come back. So we're trying to be realistic. I can't tell you anything I've been doing recently. We've been going way deep into the contingencies and beyond. Nothing's been challenging. So it's, again, not a perfect world. We can't, we do everything we can.
3:26:53 Follow the processes we have to with public bidding and so forth. And then the developer fee, as Patricia did point out, is going to pay for project management, third-party project management, which is a real cost. You know, that will be a significant portion of that. And then there is a real risk to development, you know. And it's, you know, we're a non-profit organization. If there is some leftover developer fee, that only just goes into helping us pursue other projects.
3:27:22 There's been a couple other opportunities we pursued that fell flat. We spent tens of thousands of dollars pursuing those, and that's money out the door. So there's a cost of doing business to be a developer, just like any private business is, you know, and that's reasonable. There's a developer fee on this project. So I just wanted to bring that to light. It's not like it's just hidden money or we're just keeping that. It's money that's going to get probably largely spent. It is a contingency of last resort, because if we blow through the budgeted contingency,
3:27:53 We will dip and we will spend that developer fee to whatever extent we have to to get it to the finish line. So recognize that, you know, that's risk. You know, you're talking about, you know, a project that's going to start, you know, next spring and get built through summer. It's a building that we're, you know, repurposing. There's going to be some surprises inevitably. We know we're going to hit things that aren't on the plan as far as. So anyway, those are my comments and we'll look forward to coming back.
3:28:22 Thank you. Thank you very much, Tom. I think one thing just to keep in mind is this council and previous councils has been through a very difficult development construction project here in Mammoth Lakes with the Community Recreation Center. So we are keenly aware of what's involved in doing these kinds of projects. And I think for us as being stewards of public money, these are appropriate and responsible questions to be asking. And we look forward to your organization working with our staff in light of we know what it takes to build here. One other thing I just want to add to the discussion is that
3:28:53 The question of who's going to manage this? Who's going to manage these units when it's done? I think that's a reasonable question to get answered. And you don't have to answer it now. You don't have to answer it now. We've got plenty of you guys. We've got plenty to work on. But as part of coming back with this refinement to this back to council, let's make sure we get that figured out so we know where we're going going forward. Any other thoughts? I think we're good. Thank you all very much. Wonderful. Oh, Sandy, would you like to say something, too? OK, thank you. Long-term supporter.
3:29:31 And I have to tell you, I'm frustrated because you've got the figures, 1.4.
3:30:04 Nobody asked the question that I would have asked, is it ready to go, the contract signed tomorrow, and you can do this? That's the question I asked Patricia. If that is committed, then contract can be signed, contract, it doesn't have to go out for bid. Nolan gave you the steps, the two plus years between an application and receiving and the rising costs, we all know that.
3:30:45 And I just, it's such a good project. And I, you know, you saw that probably the headline on the Mammoth, not the Mammoth Times, the LA Times, that each unit costs now as well in excess of a million dollars. The council, what, 20 Mammoth Lakes Housing, you're asking questions, oh boy, because you're, for the first time, looking at managing a parcel.
3:31:23 You know, in those days, there wasn't micromanagement. There was trust. Five and six staff, money, and they said, council said, go do it. And you know what? Most of those 130 units were built in that period of trust. And then we got to the period where there's the budget. We have one person for a while. I worried about her health. She didn't even have, and for 10, now, after 10 years, we went up from 300,000 to 360.
3:32:00 336, I'm sorry. You know, I mean, this is an organization created by council. It's an NGO. And you need to give them some trust and some money. Let's just close this out. They have, you know, the state is in excess of $6 million. The state alone, that says that we have a name. Mammoth Lakes Housing over the years.
3:32:36 Town of Mammoth Lakes. We've got a good reputation. We wouldn't get all that money. And I mean, the town's contribution is so, you know, I mean, that's 1.4. It's nothing compared to, you know. Anyway, I'm just, I'm sorry. Thank you for all you've given. And I just, too, we did something else. And the staff report doesn't measure. I mean, I, but anyway, I'm just sorry. There is a contract to be signed.
3:33:25 We waited so long. I'm sorry. I'm sorry for being so emotional, but I've been following it. I was at the planning meetings. They were wonderful. You know, I mean, they were really the pilot for parcel. They were the model. We're still another couple of weeks. You think that's not much. You know what? Micromanagement is something I, as the line officer for the Forest Service, always try to avoid.
3:34:10 It's good to have oversight and detailed questions, yes, but this is a property that we'll own for 55 years at affordable housing costs. So anyway, I thought that was really a great presentation and I'm amazed at the new, I mean, the workload for Eastern Sierra Community Housing is massive. I just, I had one comment, wow, I hadn't seen it.
3:34:44 Anyway, thank you. Thank you very much. Any additional comments here in the room? Anything out? Okay, well, thank you all very much. We've got work to do between now and December 6th, and we'll see you then, so thank you all very much. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, so we'll move on now to, I believe, Council Member Reports. And who wants to start? I can start if you like, check things off.
3:35:23 Thank you all. Thanks for coming. We appreciate your time. Thanks for your efforts. So I'll just, I attended the Rural Voices for Conservation Coalition Conference in Tahoe. Super interesting. A lot of amazing information. A lot of great things happening in Oregon, rural parts of the West. I also attended, but did not participate in these, likely rental advisory committee. Anybody else? Sure, John. I attended the
3:36:04 Desert Mountain Division, a League of California Cities meeting in absolutely lovely Victorville. Not a whole lot to report back there other than the Chimboli Award, which I received last year, went to the mayor of Big Bear this year, who was incredibly deserving, incredibly hard, and I can't bring his name up immediately, Dan, which is terrible on my part. I should have written it down. I've known him for a long time. You know he's a mentor.
3:36:36 He's great at what he does, and he's gone through some of the stresses in Council there that we have here as well in the past, so I'd love to see him get that award. Also attended the LTC meeting with Dan on Monday. The one thing out of that that I would love to report is that the Topaz repair and or rebuild, they say will be done easily by the end of this month, which will eliminate that traffic light and the 20-minute delays.
3:37:05 The one other item I think of note there was the allocation of additional funding coming in in the regional transportation plan. We have
3:37:36 Three million that will be programmed out in the third year. But looking at that for funding the MUF between up the corner of Minaret 203, Lake Mary, down to Old Bammoth, which was a really good deal with the staffs working together to allocate some additional funding and each connection. Field System Master Plan. There you go. One more thing. Sure. My memory was just sent to me. Oh. Randall Potts.
3:38:09 Is the gentleman's name that we have worked with for so long and it has been a pleasure to serve. Chris, anything? Just briefly, I just want to thank all the members of the public who volunteered for and then those who have been selected and seated on the short-term rental committee. It was a good first meeting where you saw that people are ready to get to work. So I just, I personally commit that we are going to stay on that timeline. I was at the STR committee meeting as well.
3:38:44 And I love all the passion that our community has for housing and these issues. And then I also attended Mammoth Lakes, or Esh, Esh meeting this month. Yes, yes. So you got the gist of what we've been chatting about. I attended the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board meeting last night. We started off with a joint meeting with Parks and Rec. It was really great to, you know, hear.
3:39:18 Hear what everybody's excited about. We talked a lot of biking stuff. And yeah, talk about a one-person show. Kim Anna Clario's, like, so many projects going on, and it's just her. So kudos to her. She's really a dynamo. So I get it. It's hard to only have one person, but it is amazing to see sometimes what one person can do. So that was a real treat to attend that. Excellent.
3:39:48 Okay, so I think anything else, Dan? I think we're good? Okay, so we're going to adjourn to our next regular meeting or is it a special meeting? We do the special meeting of the November 29th. And time and place? 3 p.m. here. Sweet Z, 3 p.m. with some members of the Planning Commission but not a joint meeting. All good? One more thing, John. Of course. You guys have a great Thanksgiving. I was just going to say, happy holidays, everybody. I'll be traveling, but I'll be back in the 26th. And please,
3:40:29 If you're going to the ribbon cutting on the 24th, thank you all very much. We are adjourned. Thank you.