Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 findingTranscript
519 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:17 Exactly. We don't know you. Hello. Hello. Hi. Hi, Leanne. Sorry about that, folks. My town account tried to lock me out again of all the silly things. So do we have everybody here? One, two, three. I'm assuming that Kirk is in Sweet Z. Yes, he is. Yes. Thank you.
4:30 I will call this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council to order. Roll call, please. Councilmember Rae has an excused absence. Councilmember Stapp? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Present. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Here. Mayor Salzer? Present. Thank you. Sandra, you're on with us. Would you lead us in the pledge today? I will. Thank you.
5:00 Please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Sandra. Thank you. Of the comments, this is the time any member of the public wishing to comment on anything that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. I would like to go first, Mr. Mayor. I would like to give a...
5:29 Big shout out of congratulations to our fellow board member, council member Sarah Ray, who has a new healthy baby boy born on Monday. So welcome to the world and we need all the help we can get. So I thought that was good news. Thank you. It is good news. And hopefully they are both doing just fine. Public comments, Jamie. Mark Dutko, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments?
6:04 Hi, thank you for your time today. I would like to comment on some of the safety and secret comments related to the Woodman bus turnaround. A group of residents has made a public records request and we have some concerns related to the findings as well as information that was not provided per our request. Related to safety,
6:30 No traffic survey and study was provided to us other than measuring of the line of sight of Old Mammoth Road. This is a significant concern, and even Gary Poskin of Triad Homes Engineering, who was hired by the town, described this area as, quote, a bit of a nasty intersection with snow in sight distances to Mill and Old Mammoth Road. These issues are in the present state.
6:56 Without the additional entry points from the project are creating compounded traffic concerns. I have a question, why is there no formal traffic study and survey? And also, are all the federal and state bus requirements being met for the site? Related to CEQA, planning department has not provided any formal CEQA notice of exemption for development, although they claim exemption.
7:23 Communications in the Planning Department by Amy Callahan and Sandra Moberly of the Water District reveal that when the Water District asked how the Town has concluded the project is exempt from CEQA, the response seems to be multifaceted. One idea the Town had was that Woodman Project was a condition of approval of another project, presumably Snow Creek. So CEQA issues were already covered. This seems to be outside of CEQA requirements.
7:51 Also, another was that the town had never given a use permit for a bus stop ever. The Woodman project doesn't require one by this precedent, given that the only permit needed for the bus shelter was a simple routine permit. So the town concludes the project is, quote, ministerial. This also seems to be outside the exclusion of CEQA requirements. Please note that this project is not a public works project, but rather a public slash private venture.
8:19 As negotiations have been conducted and funding is also coming from a private entity. My question is, this is not just a bus stop. Is it true the town has never given a use permit for any bus stop? Also, how is it possible that a permit of a property on one APN can apply or include unrelated work to another non-budding location on a separate APN?
8:44 Additionally, how can a residentially zoned property be used for commercial purposes like this? These are just a few of the concerns raised by the communications we have received. However, we are missing key information we requested and many communications linked to these others and emails were not given and provided to us. Is there a reason the city is not able or willing to supply the full documentation we requested?
9:11 And also, it seems peculiar the city would sign a lease with the Water District after a public meeting with strong vocal opposition to the project. Does this represent the transparency objectives of the town toward its residents? My last comment is that when we made our public records request, which is a 10-day period, the city requested 14 days. So we gave them an additional 14 days, but we're still missing.
9:39 substantial records and portions of the information. Thank you for your time on that. Thank you, Mark. Any further public comments? Mr. Mayor, this is Dan, if I may. I'm not sure how many of you made it out to the Shakespeare in the Park, Shakespeare in the Woods event. We do have one of the actors in the audience with us that was in The Tempest, Ted Carlton, our reporter.
10:11 Anyway, I just wanted to note that we got out to those. They were very enjoyable. It was good to see people out actually enjoying that evening in the woods with the Shakespeare play. And Mr. Carlton did just fine in his position, whatever his name was. So anyway, it was a lot of fun. And just seeing some things like that, kind of coming back to normal, even in the midst of everything else going on has been nice to see.
10:45 Agreed, Dan, thank you. Any further public comments? Hearing none? Sorry, there is one. It disappeared and then it came back. John, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone. This is John Guatelli from the Woodman neighborhood again. Thanks for your patience in hearing from me again on the Woodman bus turnaround. I hope everyone's doing well. I just wanted to follow up on Mark Dudko's comments.
11:20 First of all, our neighborhood, I said this a couple weeks ago, we thank you very, very much for taking the time to reconsider this project. I know that's a big inconvenience and a problem, and we think that we really appreciate that you're giving this matter more thought. In that regard, one thing that came up in the public information that I was a little bit surprised to see was that the town actually had apparently received...
11:46 The plan for the site that's been mentioned before that's east of the fire station on Old Mammoth. And, you know, I know that the town staff obviously preferred Woodman for various reasons, but now that there's been a lot of negativity about that for many people in the neighborhood, maybe that site just needs a fresh look.
12:08 You know, I think obviously it has some advantages, cost, right? Snow Creek would pay for it and it's near the current turnaround. I'm sure there are some issues that I don't know about that you guys know about that, you know, might make it not so good, but I just want to doubly re-emphasize something I said two weeks ago that we really hope there's a way to work together to make this, you know, a thing that, a solution to the red line turnaround problem that we all can get behind. So thanks again for taking the time to try to do that.
12:40 Thank you, John. Any further public comments? No, there is not. Thank you. Moving on to additions to the agenda, Dan. Yes, Mr. Mayor, we would like to add an item to the agenda to have the council discuss and provide any staff direction related to the Tahoe-related fires, the Calder fire, the need for support in evacuations.
13:12 And also the impact locally with the forest closures related to the fire threat throughout the national forest, I'll say forest plural, in California and specifically in the Inyo. This matter has really come up in the last couple of days after the agenda was posted. We are requesting that the council consider adding that item to the agenda. It will require
13:41 All four of you to agree to add it to the agenda? And if so, then we would recommend that it is discussed as kind of after the staff presentation, or sorry, after the introduction of our code compliance officer, kind of a 6.2 item on the agenda. That would be a discussion and direction related to the Calder fire and the impact of the forest closure on the town and the overall fire threat we're seeing within our state.
14:12 And the concerns raised thereby. And Andy, if you need to add anything. So that would be the request. There'd be a formal motion to add the item and then we could look at placing it on the agenda and moving forward. I would make a motion to add the item to today's agenda. Andy, do I need to call out any specific rules here in the motion? As always, the rule is that you can add something to the agenda if there's a need to take immediate action.
14:45 And if the need to take action came to the town's attention after the agenda was posted. So it's pretty clear that this is an ongoing crisis and you could definitely say there's a need to take action before the next council meeting. And I think obviously the situation's deteriorated a lot since the agenda was posted. So I think the council could make both of those findings if it wanted to add this to the agenda. Thank you, Andy. I will add those comments to my motion. And I will second that motion. I have a motion and a second.
15:16 Any further deliberations? Remember, this has to be 4-0 in order to add it on. Seeing none, Jamie. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. That is 4-0, so we will add that on. Dan, do you want to add that in introductions, which is 6.0, or you want to save it and add it as 9.05?
15:47 No, no, I need to address it up front. We have other people on the call that can help speak to it, so we'd like to expect their time. Very good. So it'll be 6.2. Thank you. Thank you. Moving on now to item number five, reports from commissions and or departments. Okay, Stu's picture came up, so he must want to speak. Stu. Thank you, Mayor. Just a few items for the benefit of the council and the community that's going to pop up.
16:21 My little word, Doc, I won't share it with the public. Wouldn't put them through a lot of my notes and chicken scratch. But just regarding that last item, you know, we do want to reach out and thank Leanne Murphy from the U.S. Forest Service, allowing us to continue operating the Shady Rest Park, our wonderful municipal.
16:47 Park, which incorporates the Disc Golf Park, and it's an extremely busy park right now with AYSO soccer and so forth. So we did receive an official exemption to operate that through the temporary forest closure. So I wanted to make council and the public aware of that. We also received exemptions for the town-wide MUPS system and then also to perform trials maintenance along the trial system within the boundary.
17:14 And then finally, Hayes submitted an exemption request for several, if not many, U.S. Forest Service permits relating to critical public safety infrastructure. We're just waiting for the determination there as well. We have posted a lot of that information. We're sharing as much as we can, as frequently as we can. It's on the town homepage. It's obviously on our website, Facebook page.
17:41 You know, Deb and the Forest Service are doing a wonderful job sharing that with the public. There's also some great sites on visitmammoth.com regarding the closures of the public wanting to know what's happening in and around the town of Mammoth Lakes, visitmammoth.com has all that information, as does Mona County. And we've tried to create that one-stop shop and put all that information on our town website right on the homepage.
18:09 In the news flash section. So if anybody wants to read the FAQs, know what's open, what's closed in the town or Mono County, I would direct them to Town of Mammoth Lake's website. On the Parks and Rec front, just run through a couple of items here, again, for the benefit of the public and council. The pool closed for recreation swimming on Sunday, another great season at Whitmore. Pool stays open through September 10th for lap swim.
18:39 So if you do want to get some last-minute swims in, we welcome you down there. The Adopt-A-Hole Program has two holes remaining for sponsorship, and we're going to be installing those tee pads and tee signs September 20th. They had 72 registered participants in the first-ever PDGA-sanctioned singles tournament at the Disc Golf Park on August 14th, 15th. So a wonderful new inaugural event.
19:06 Summer Camps wrapped up on August 17th. We accommodated just under 500 kids in our summer camps. Unfortunately, we still ended up with about 85 kids on a wait list. So again, with the CRC opening up next summer, we hope to address a lot of the need in our community with that. Adult Softball League wrapped up August 19th. I want to congratulate our men's.
19:35 Seven men's teams, six co-ed teams. 2021 softball champions were XRC in the men's league and free agents in the co-ed league. We also hosted the Eastern Sierra Agility Challenge. I don't know if people know, if our community knows that we host a sanctioned High Sierra Agility Challenge for our many four-legged friends at Whitmore Recreation Area. They had over 80 registered participants, which was great.
20:01 And we also have a free Friday night skate coming up at the rec zone September 17th. Just to wrap up, we received the Prop 68 per capita contract. So that's $177,952 that we've allocated for the CRC to purchase the sport court. So we've executed that agreement. So we're looking to purchase that sport court when we can install that.
20:29 In the CRC, hopefully next spring, summer. And then our Recreation Commission meets on Tuesday, September 1st at 1.30. And we are welcoming Janet Hatfield. I'm sure you're all aware as the Eastern Sierra Project Manager. She's going to present our little mammoth donut project, not little by any means, but that's the Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Resilience Project. And then we'll also provide an update to the commission on the CRC.
20:57 They were pouring concrete this week, so a lot happening at that site, including the Whitmore Recreation Area Planning effort. And sadly, we just did want to make again the community aware that due to the Forest Service closure, you know, the restrictions and the challenges for our firefighting resources, Grand Fondo made the decision to cancel their upcoming 2021 event scheduled for September 11.
21:27 With that, Mayor, I will end my presentation. Happy to answer any questions, but thank you for the opportunity. Thank you, Stu. Any questions for Stu? Yeah, I just had a comment. Stu, we went out and watched and walked around during the disc golf tournament. What a fun thing to do. Yeah, thank you. Those people are so happy to talk about what they do and having been to big golf tournaments and walking around, this was way more fun than that. So, yeah, it was a great, great, great event for sure. Congratulations.
21:57 Yeah, just, I'm just glad we can provide that wonderful opportunity for our community. It's a free activity. If you haven't been out there, please do. And we're looking at hosting another one, hopefully later in October. So we'll keep you updated on that. But yeah, thanks again. Thank you, Stu. Shireen. Hey, hi, everybody. Can you hear me okay? Yep. Awesome. So I am here.
22:22 To provide an update on the upcoming election recall, or recall election, sorry, and just hoping to get the word out, and I want to thank Dan to invite me. Anyway, sorry. So, you know, really just kind of going over the basics of it. This is, it's not a special election, it's a recall election. So if you have it, if you've been living under a rock here in California.
22:50 The governor Newsom, he is going, he's being recalled. So the ballot has two questions. It's two parts. The first question is whether or not you want the governor to be recalled. The second part is who you want to replace him if he is recalled. You can answer both questions. You can answer one question. You can answer zero questions. I don't know why you would turn it about if you answer zero, but that is your choice. But feel free. It's both one.
23:20 And so if you are registered in Mono County, you have received your voter information guide. If you opted out because you like to go green, it is available on our website at monocounty.ca.gov forward slash elections. And that's where we put all of our information, especially on election night. A lot of people want to know what the results are as they're coming in. And so that information is there as well.
23:51 So just to kind of go over everything you need to know about this election, everybody received a ballot in the mail. That does not mean you have to vote by mail. It just gives you the option, especially with COVID and people who travel or second homeowners, it's a good way to be able to vote. But we will still be having our traditional polling places on election day. There in Mammoth, it's going to be at the high school, in the library this year. The other places...
24:20 Are mentioned in the voter information guide, but we have Chalfont, Crowley Lake, June Lake, Bridgeport, and Walker. I say that because as a Mona County voter, if you were to show up to any of those polling locations, you'd still be able to vote. You may not be able to feed your ballot into the machine, but we would still have a ballot for you to vote in the correct precinct. So if for some reason, let's say you go to...
24:47 Gardnerville to get some groceries and, oh, I forgot it's election day, it's 7.30 and I'm only here in Walker, feel free to stop. So you just want to make sure if you do choose to vote your mail ballot, just make sure it gets postmarked and mailed by election day, 8 p.m. And we do recommend that if you're going to take it to the post office on election day, take it inside and make sure that they postmark it with that date.
25:15 So that it shows September 14th, that's the postmark date. You can drop it off in one of the six drop boxes that we have here in the county. In Mammoth, it's in front of the Mono County Civic Center at 1290 Tavern Road. Otherwise, you can at the Crowley Lake Community Center, Shelfont Community Center, Bridgeport at Memorial Hall, June Lake, it's in front of the Community Center there. It's also at the Antelope Valley Community Center there.
25:44 Let's say you're visiting out of town, you leave Mono County, you can still drop it off in a drop box in any county in California or any poll location on election day, and it will get forwarded to us. So it is really easy to vote is my point. So if you, I think that's basically what we want to make sure. Also, if you have not received your ballot, give us a call.
26:10 A lot of people are getting their mail forwarded from their PO box and ballots will not be forwarded. They get returned to us. So give us a call if you haven't received a ballot and you're expecting one. Ballot tracks, that information is also in the guide. It's a great way to know whether or not we receive your ballot. So if you haven't signed up for it, I highly recommend, even after the fact that we've already checked it in, it'll let you know that. But you can always give us a call or email.
26:41 I want to say that is the jest. Just remember, the polls close at 8 p.m. on Election Day. So try to plan accordingly. They open at 7 a.m. so you have plenty of time. And I just want to thank all of our volunteers to come work for polls. You know, we still have, we're going to follow the same safety guidelines we did last year. Everybody came out of that safe. So we're hoping for the same thing. We do the best that we can to keep everybody safe. We keep the poll locations clean.
27:09 So no one should worry about that. But I still want to thank our poll workers who are stepping up during this time. Are there any questions? Any questions for Shireen? Shireen, thanks very much for coming down. Appreciate the update. It's a very important election. I hope everybody's doing their civic duty. Democracy is never anything to be taken for granted. So thank you very much for the update. I'm sure if folks have any questions, they'll get in touch with you. But good to see you. And thanks for coming down. Thanks.
27:41 And I did have one thing. I don't know. Hopefully, as a panelist, I can share my screen really quick because I just want to be able to show our website. So here it is, motorcounty.ca.gov elections. And right there, click on that, and it'll take here's our guide. We're required to list our poll workers and just a lot of other information that's important. So and our contact information can be found over here as well.
28:12 It's a good resource for anybody who has any questions about the elections. Any other questions before I go? Thank you, Shireen. Good to see you. Good to see everybody as well. I'll be back to turning in and checking in ballots now, so I'll see everybody later. Good luck. Thank you, Shireen. Grady. No, I'm not hearing you. Okay. While we're waiting for Grady to get his sound figured out, we'll go on to Sandra.
28:52 Thank you very much. I just wanted to provide a brief update that the Planning and Economic Development Commission will be meeting next Wednesday, September 8th at 2 p.m. They will be receiving an update on broadband from Nate Greenberg. They will also be making a decision on a remainder lot for the Obsidian project, which is four units at the very kind of north end of the Obsidian kind of former Talus project.
29:18 They will be receiving an update on the CIP from Hayes. Just some more time to kind of walk through that, answer their questions. And then finally, they'll receive an update on code enforcement activities from Jenna Carter and Rick Bellis. And that's all I wanted to make the council aware of. Thank you. Thank you very much. Has Grady managed to come back on? I'm not seeing him. Mr. Mayor, I had a quick question for Sandra. Yes.
29:47 Sandra, I'm assuming that you, the town, are aware of the litigation involving Altera and some development work up there. You guys are taking a good hard look at that, right? Yeah, the city attorney and I just discussed that before this meeting. Yes. Good. Thank you very much. Thank you. Grady, you're moving all over the place on me. Well, hopefully you can hear me now. I can hear you now. Yeah, for some reason, if I'm on for a few minutes, it disappears, but no worries.
30:16 Yeah, I have a couple things on the parcel. First, I'd actually like to start out with a comment and a question for Hayes. I know he's on there as well. We did receive our timber harvest permit from CAL FIRE, hooray, on the 31st, as expected and as promised. So that was great news. Everybody was one elated and he's a sigh of relief. This afternoon at 1.30, I know the subcontractor GC Forest Products was being on site.
30:42 with Hayes and Engineering to talk about the right of entry permit. And if Hayes, if you can, I wasn't able to attend that meeting. Just give a quick 10-second update on when you think Pacific might be able to start taking down trees. They hope to do so this week. But again, I was not at that site meeting. Thanks, Grady. Yeah, we met with a number of the subcontractors and had subsequent conversations with the general contractor and Pacific companies regarding fulfilling their obligations with the permit that they've executed to start work.
31:14 We also coordinated with the archaeology team and we're coordinating with the nesting bird folks and so forth. I'm not going to commit to a date, but it looks like we're on track to start work next week if they fulfill all of their obligations, like I said. Thank you. Thanks for that update. As I said, I wouldn't be able to get out on the site, so appreciate that. I know Shellen from Pacific is on top of that as well.
31:41 A couple of things. We still expect or will try to start grading this season as well. It really depends on the weather, how fast the trees come out, all those things. So that's something that's going to be watched very closely all the way through November probably, maybe even early December to see what they can get done before the weather hits. One more.
32:01 Quite momentous thing that occurred is we did receive the IAG agreement. We actually got it from HCD. I know the town attorney has it in his hand. I don't know if he's finished his review yet, but he was going to take a look at that and be able to recommend to the town manager for execution on that. But we did get it in hand. Most of it is the pretty standard boilerplate. There are a few things specific to the project that I've already gone through and provided comments. So that's really good as well. One final thing I want to just comment on is that
32:31 This is, everybody needs to take a pause, please. This has been 25 years in the making to be able to start work on this project on site, at least 25 years. We're finishing the final hurdles, and once Pacific takes care of whatever engineering needs, we'll be out there on site. And as a measure of how, frankly, important it is and how much it's on everybody's mind, there are actually three items on today's action agenda, policy items that...
32:59 Have parcel related items. The CHAP update, the parcel with a significant part of the Community Housing Action Plan first steps, big steps. So that's gone far ahead. Second is the CIP. I know the CIP also includes some major parcel items. And third, the grand jury report, which frankly says you're not doing enough for affordable housing. Well, you've now spent $7 million, you have an agreement close to signing, and we're going to start work on site. So I just wanted to point that out that it's in.
33:25 Every day we deal with this in town as a council, as a staff, and as people in the public. So with that, I'm good. And if you have any questions, I'll be glad to answer. Thanks. Questions for Grady. John. I just want to point out, I think, Dan, you mentioned that we do have a regional representative in GoBiz, a guy named Derek Kirk, who I think was pretty helpful in this effort. I think it's pretty rare that we can actually point to a member of the state of California staff that's actually...
33:52 Really stepping in there and doing something for the benefit of Mammoth Lakes and rural places like us. So if I got that right, I just want to make sure I've got that right and give them the acknowledgement as appropriate. Thank you very much. Thank you, John. Any other questions? Seeing none, do we have any other reports? Seeing none, I will go on to introductions, introduce new code compliance officer.
34:26 Ryan Tanaka, Al. Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers, it's my privilege to introduce Ryan Tanaka as our new code compliance officer. It's a new position that council approved, so we have better code compliance work going on out there. So Ryan comes to us from Anaheim. Originally, he grew up in Torrance, California. He's got a bachelor's degree in psychology, a bachelor's degree in criminology, and then he also has a master's in criminology.
34:55 All from UC Irvine. He's worked for numerous law enforcement agencies, including Irvine PD, Manhattan Beach PD, Laguna Beach PD, Orange County Sheriff's, and most recently, Orange County District Attorney's Office. He loves being up here. He's visited here for years. He loves skiing, hiking, sitting at the lake and cuddling up with his 70-pound shepherd named Rocco. And he just wants everyone to know his favorite dessert is cheesecake. Just somehow that comes up and you want to buy him a cheesecake. So I think he's looking for handouts.
35:25 So with that, Ryan, I will let you say a couple words. I don't even see you on the screen. There you are. Hi, everyone. Sorry. The sun kind of got away from me in the past half hour. I just want to briefly say I'm excited to be here. Finally made it up here. I hope to meet everyone soon. And I'm really looking forward to, you know, help keep Mammoth Lakes a great place to live, work, and for people to visit. Thank you, Ryan. I'm virtually shaking your hand.
36:01 Anybody have any questions or comments other than welcome on board? Glad to see you're here. Welcome on board. Welcome. Okay. Thank you. Moving on from that, we are going to go to our newly added agenda item 6.2, update on the Tahoe evacuation and our local forest closures. Dan. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor.
36:32 We wanted to get this item in front of you just because of the impacts we're seeing. Obviously, we've all experienced smoke impacts, other areas a lot more so than here, coming out of the current fires. The other key elements, and I'll speak to these in more detail, but just with that impact of not just the Tahoe fires, but all of them have had on resources and drawdown, and Leanne Murphy is on the call with us. She's the acting district.
37:00 Mammoth Ranger, so she'll be able to speak into some of these issues as well. And it's like, welcome to Mammoth. She thought she'd be out hiking and boating and just enjoying a great recreational experience. That's still coming. But in the meantime, with the fire impact, we wanted to talk about that. And one of the elements that came up on that was really we're seeing evacuees coming into Mammoth. There are friends and family and also just getting far enough south to get out of the smoke versus...
37:30 The Carson Valley or Reno area. Others are going the other direction into Sacramento, et cetera, and other places. But as we saw that happen, one of the elements we began to work through is whether they actually park a vehicle. Some of them have multiple cars full of stuff they pulled out of their homes for the threat of having it burn up. And then we've also had others just getting out with an RV or a camper and those types of elements where they can actually get out of that area.
37:59 With the evacuation orders and then just the unhealthy air quality. To do that, we'll just ask council for kind of concurrence on this in terms of needing direction. We have put together or working in the process of getting together a map where people can actually park legally versus just scattering around the town. With the forest closures, obviously they can't just go disperse camp. And so we have been working with the...
38:25 Park and Ride lot that the town owns as a site that people could park in there. We're looking at if people do park overnight, that they need to be in a self-contained unit. We're not providing facilities, you know, restrooms and that. We don't want people setting up tents and camps and those types of elements. But we're also then working with Saracosa College to use a portion of their parking. They're working with us on that.
38:49 We have reached out to Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, the Eagle parking lot. We're looking for all the areas that are off Forest Service property to make that simpler with our private partners. Sierra Nevada Resort has indicated their larger parking lot area there would be available. We're working through those to try to get some contact names so if people do show up, they can call or they can get coordinated into those areas versus others showing up who should not be in those potential parking lots.
39:18 The Forest Service has allowed the Mammoth RV Park to stay open. It's already had several evacuees come into the park there. They've also had some people come in who are actually working in different areas, so kind of essential workers here in the community. So I will say that as Stu was talking earlier, a lot of the activities around the forest, which is closed, but yet the impact of the community operationally was really key.
39:48 And Leanne and her team, Reef Lawson, or Lawson Reef, and then on up has been really quick in turning around some exemptions that we filed for and be able to keep those things open. And we often don't think about how much of our public facility issues are on the Forest Service. You think about, you know, the recreational activities, but the town's drainage system ultimately goes down through town and out to Murphy Gulch. We need to be able to maintain that.
40:17 The airport actually sits a large portion of it is on Forest Service land. The materials pit that's being operated out by the airport. Just to note a couple of things, but there's a number of different areas of that nature that we actually work with the Forest Service. And so I was hoping initially this evening to have Leanne join us really just to be able to have her introduce herself as the new acting Mammoth District Ranger. But she is...
40:45 Dove right into the midst of all of this chaos, if you will. And I want to give her a chance to introduce herself in just a moment. But we've shared out, we put it with the agenda packet, the closure order on the INYO and the rest of the forest. The HT has followed up with some closures in the Bridgeport District. And then also, I think it was out today, the Forest Service, the FAQ on a lot of different issues helping.
41:14 We are really trying to coordinate a common message out there and get as much information as we can out in front of people. So one of the concurrences from council will be just our effort to go forward and provide overflow parking with a focus on our evacuees that are coming into town. We won't be enforcing the no camping element and those types of components through this process. We're really got our fingers crossed that by the 17th of September, the closure can be lifted.
41:46 People are, I think, taking bets on either side to that to what will actually happen, but unknown with the fires and just the threat that's out there. So we'll be asking for direction there, but we do want to give the council an opportunity to ask questions. But before we do that, Leanne, I wanted to give you an opportunity to actually introduce yourself formally and say thank you for joining us on short notice and welcome to Mammoth. Thank you. Can everybody hear me okay?
42:11 Yep, you're good. Okay, great. Thank you so much. And thanks for the invite. It's great to be here in Mammoth. Just to give you a little bit of background, my current position is on the Carson National Forest in New Mexico. I'm a collaboration staff officer there. I've been there three years, but previous to that, I was on the Inyo National Forest as a resource and planning staff officer. So I worked with a few of you. Forest Planner Vision was one of the big things that I led in that position.
42:40 Good to be back in the area. And yes, I had great plans for going hiking this weekend, but like everybody else, maybe I'm going to Bridgeport. So thank you for all the support. I know this is a very trying time. I know there was closures last summer, COVID and fire as well. This was something that, you know, a hard, hard decision to make.
43:06 But extremely important. I think the events that are happening on the Calder fire are really showing us that the threats that are out there and it's that resource drawdown. So thanks for the support. I know this is not easy for everybody, for businesses, all the folks that are planning to come this weekend. So like Dan said, we are offering exemptions for our special use permittees. Those have been coming in. So we're looking at those individually. You know, the activities.
43:35 For those still need to be consistent with our order. These are not to give special permission for recreation to happen or something like that. So reading those individually, really trying to help out where we can. And Hayes, I've got yours on the list. I'm hoping to look at that tonight. I do believe some of those maintenance requests would already be covered as an exemption under the order. I just want to double check so I'm giving you the right info.
44:05 Also, feel free, if you have maintenance needs that come up, feel free to take care of that. Don't think that you don't, you're not allowed to do that at the moment. So, also, just trying to, the forest itself is looking, going to be talking tomorrow, I think, about evacuees also, and coming up with a plan. Many folks, I'm not sure if you've met her yet, Stephanie Heller is our new district ranger for the Mono Lake District in the Vining.
44:34 And her house is actually in Southlake. And so she was an evacuee as well. Luckily so far, it looks like her house is okay. So we're going to talk tomorrow as a forest leadership team to also see if the forest can come up with some plan, you know, whether that's keeping a campground open for evacuees or also helping with any parking that needs to be done. So if you guys are seeing more need for parking space.
45:01 I think we do have some space at the Visitor Center. I also went and took a look at the kind of open area where the propane tanks are and think there could be something there we can provide if needed. So just keep me in the loop on that and the Forest Service can try and help if needed on the parking thing as well. It's probably a quick introduction. And yeah, sorry the circumstances are a little different than we intended, but I'm sure we'll get through this.
45:30 I think like everybody else, we're hopeful that this order will end on the 17th. I think similar, Dan, we're back and forth on that. But we will continue to work with you if it's extended and what that means moving forward. But thanks for the invite. Yeah, and Leanne, if you would touch on a couple of the items that really drove the decision. I know it was a tough one from the region on down.
45:54 Touching especially on the drawdown issues, and that'll impact our next discussion on local fire departments and the impacts that we have as partners with the fire component. I know there's a couple other factors that you looked at as well, just so we're full understanding the magnitude of that decision and the effort that goes into those things. It's not done lightly and the impacts that it has are significant. And the drawdown area is a concern for us should something happen in our backyard.
46:25 Yeah, excellent question, Dan. So I did get some numbers from our chief for fire operations. And it was good for me to understand what drawdown meant, because that's a word we use, but I've never really understood those implications. So drawdown, the Inyo National Forest is at that. And what that means is we currently have four engines on the forest. That's it. And then we've got one patrol on every district. So about four patrols total.
46:55 So that does not leave a lot of resources. We've requested, if our engines go off forest on an assignment, we'll request some coverage for others, but that's kind of the minimum amount, and that's what we call drawdown. So that is what we are seeing across the forest in California, mostly because of our large, you know, Caldor and Dixie are the largest, of course, that are drawing a lot of those resources. And then we still have several other fires across the state.
47:24 This is also occurring nationally. It just sort of depends where you are, but California is being hit hard because of these large fires, but there's also resource drawdown in other parts of the country also. And so that was one of the main drivers is the risk. If a fire were to occur in the Mammoth area, how quickly are we going to get resources? Calder was a good example where it took a couple days to get enough resources to really start.
47:54 Finding that fire, they really just had to let it go because they did not get that quick response because of all the other fires that people were fighting. So that's kind of that extreme end when it comes to what drawdown means and that we don't have the resources in play. It doesn't mean we won't be reactive if something were to occur. It just means that that quick reaction, that containment relatively quickly just won't happen. It will take a long time to get resources here.
48:24 So that was occurring across the region. So that was one of the discussions a regional office leadership team was having. That conversation occurred with the four supervisors. And so with resource drawdown and then the risk if a fire starts, then you talk public safety. Then, you know, can we be responsive if especially if something occurs in our canyons where one way in, one way out, you know, how safe is that for our public? And so can we really be offering
48:54 A lot of these experiences and drawing people to our forests if we're not sure we can fully protect them if something were to happen. Those were the main concerns. And unfortunately, you know, COVID is still here. And so also with our fire crews, that's something they're still having to work with and through. And we've had an increase of COVID cases at fire camps too. So we're trying to get those things out.
49:22 So that was another piece is public safety and then also firefighter safety, just bringing more and more from outside areas and then potentially COVID outbreaks because that is something that we still have to think about. So hopefully that answers your question, Dan, on some of those drivers. Thank you. I think that's good information for people to understand because those are tough decisions and they're not seeing flames and smoke in town.
49:51 The threat is real and the concerns were real and I know the decision was not made later. Thank you. At this point, Leanne, would you take questions from council? Yes, absolutely. Thank you. I think I'm going to go ahead and start then if I may because my mind is weak enough I'll forget them if I don't. No worries. We were talking about evacuees and of course for this weekend it's not going to be just evacuees. We're going to have a whole bunch of people come up.
50:22 Yeah, excellent question. Unfortunately, that would not be the case. So we do understand getting messaging out.
50:52 And as try as we might, we're still going to have some people come up. What the communication would be to those folks when they arrive is letting them know where they can go. So BLM, any county campgrounds would be open. Developed camping on certain areas in the Bridgeport District is still open. So it's mostly going to be communication and redirecting. We do know that's still going to cause some havoc and confusion and not have some happy...
51:21 But unfortunately, when it would come to kind of our normal visitors, we would not be able to have a campground available for that. Thank you. And I know in the past, there has been problems with our fire department, and Frank could answer this as well, and maybe that has changed. I don't know if we have an MOU or not, but there's been a problem with the forest allowing our fire department.
51:48 To attack any fire that occurred on National Forest. And we have the scenic loop and we have the sawmill cutoff roads, one and two that get very heavy use. And I know that your resources are down to almost nothing. But if it was on a level two or three road, would and have we considered a memorandum of understanding with our local fire department? And Frank can answer this from his side as to whether or not there would be.
52:17 Allowed to go out and be that quick first responder on something that close because I fear no matter how hard we try to enforce it, we're going to have a bunch of people that don't know how to camp trying to pull off the road and camp because we're closed. Yeah, that's a really good question and maybe, yeah, Frank, if you have some background, I would have to dig into that a little bit more with our prior staff on the rationale there, but unless, yeah, we know that there's an MOU, you know, if there's...
52:45 Anybody with further info on that? Otherwise, I can look into that. I'll pick that one up, Leanne, and welcome back. Thank you. Yes, we actually had just updated or renewed yesterday our local agreement with the Inyo National Forest. It had been in suspension for a while due to some spirited negotiations really out of Region 5 on some items, but we did get to some good resolution.
53:16 We do have language in there to allow each agency to take independent action if they feel that it's a threat to their area. And so, you know, we've got everybody's frequencies. We're very well tuned in. And to underscore the resource situation that Leanne addressed, you've heard me all say this before, we're going to get about 90 minutes of drawdown from friends and neighbors. And then it's going to be six hours on a good day before anything appreciable shows up. It'll be longer now.
53:47 But yes, we do have a local agreement in play. Great. Thanks, Frank. Those were my two main topics. Hoping that we could keep Shady open. That would be huge. But if we can't, we can't. Questions from other council members? John. Hi, Leanne. Welcome back. Good to see you. Thank you. Yep.
54:14 A couple of things just to help you kind of get integrated into things. You may know that there's every Tuesday morning, Joel Ratchie, our town, the trails manager hosts a regular meeting with Forest Service staff. Your predecessor was attending every week, losses every week. I think it'd be great. Hopefully you can make it on Tuesday, get yourself introduced. A couple of little pieces of capacity we have that may be helpful. The town worked with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, funds a...
54:40 A community host and a trail host program. We've got people out on the ground. I've been getting reports and photos of them today. I know theoretically the forest is closed, but there's about...
54:50 I don't know, 15 cars in the Horseshoe Lake parking lot. There's people all over the place. And I would really encourage you to start getting with Joel and tap into those resources that may be very helpful for you and your team to understand what you're dealing with. And I think the impression of the community is that hard closure goes up on Friday. Is that fair to say? Is that when the lake space and gate will close? Or is that already closed? Yeah, so it's already closed. I drove up there today as well with our assistant recreation staff officer. And yeah, I counted.
55:19 About 10 cars at Horseshoe. So one of the things that might be a little different than last year's closure, we're going to allow people time because we get trying to get the word out. So we just drove around today. We didn't even start pestering people. We figured a lot of those folks were probably just camping and visiting. And so Friday is going to be more of the stronger message, engaging with folks, really letting them know they need to leave.
55:48 And I am planning to shut the gates for Lakes Basin on Friday. And we'll follow the typical notifications that we do for the end of season. And so we're hoping that that will at least eliminate the car presence. I know you're still going to get people going in there. But one thing to go back to what you were talking about for the trail host, that is something that I did also offer an exemption for.
56:13 To offer for that help, that'd be great. I think Lace Basin would be a fabulous spot for those folks to be at. And then also to update you for Reds Meadow, I'm actually going to leave that gate open through the weekend. East NCR Transit is giving us a great favor on pickup for anybody coming out of the wilderness down there. And so that gate will probably be shut on Tuesday. And we'll again follow those same processes for notification for that. So just to give you a heads up on those closures.
56:43 And then, yes, coordinating with the trail host will be very, very helpful. Our folks are going to be patrolling heavier in those areas of risk. So where that dispersed camping issue really is, Scenic Loop and other places, that's where a lot of our folks are going to be out and patrolling, including law enforcement, since we know those are going to be the places people are going to go and probably don't know how to camp properly. I don't want to labor into any of this, Mr. Mayor. I'll kind of let it go with that.
57:12 If you can make that meeting on Tuesday, 8 o'clock in the morning, you can start meeting all the people running these programs and really avail yourself of a lot of capacity that this community has put together to work with our partners in the Forest Service. I think it'd be a very beneficial stop for you on your virtual tour starting Tuesday morning. Yes, thanks for that, John. I think it is on the calendar. So I was planning to go this week, but it got a little crazy. So yeah, I will try to be there on Tuesday for sure.
57:42 Excellent. Welcome back. Thank you. Yep. That's it for me, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, John. Linda or Kirk, anything you would like to? Yes, Leanne, welcome, and very nice to meet you, even though we're here. And I just wanted to, I just wanted to say that I really appreciate your attitude. You know, you're, you know, kind of reaching out, working together, not just slamming doors, but trying to find ways to keep everything going, and that's really appreciated. So thank you. Glad you're here. Look forward to meeting me in person. Thanks.
58:11 Thank you. Yes, you're welcome. We are going to do our best. Any other questions? All right. Seeing none, Leanne, thank you very much. Awesome. Thank you so much for your time. And if you guys have any questions or anything, feel free to work through Dan or others and contact me anytime. Thank you. Yeah, Mr. Mayor, if I can bring it back, too, we are looking, as we really get out and focus on the parking and where we put people as they come in with private partners and with the town lots.
58:45 Just that concurrence that there's not any concerns from council in terms of being able to go out because basically we'll be doing stuff and just not doing enforcement on overnight parking, overnight camping in a lot of different areas. I don't think we have time to do an ordinance or a code change by the time we get it done. Hopefully the crisis will be over. But just a practical component to that as we work with people and we will end up coordinating.
59:13 Have like some of the PD go by some of the areas and make sure people are behaving well and those types of issues. We've had that request from the private side that we do some checks. I know Mammoth Mountain will have some of their parking and their security team in play as well. So really looking to say how do we help this as people come in from an evacuation standpoint and some of the areas, I think we are going to have people show up and not know that they need to stop down at the BLM areas prior to getting to Mammoth to find a
59:43 So just unless there's concerns over that, we will proceed. We're working on a map and information that we'll be getting out here in the near term. Very similar to what we've done in a couple of the big snowstorms. The only differential there is we actually did have a local emergency declared that we took those actions under. So this is a little bit different in doing it. We do believe we have a
1:00:08 You know, potential, you know, conflict and crisis and other issues in our hands as this moves forward. So we do want to go provide safety and we do have concerns of just equality in the community if we don't address it head on. Yeah, so with that, I would take it back to council. Basically what Dan is saying, do you have any problems with us not enforcing that 24-hour parking? And Dan, I'm assuming that's on private property as well as the public spaces you have mentioned? Yes, it is. Okay.
1:00:48 Linda, how do you feel? No, I think that makes a total amount of sense. I was just, I just received a text from a woman saying that there was a lady staying at Motel 6 with a dog and she's telling people she doesn't have any money to stay there longer. So the person who called me will be reaching out to her and putting her in touch with social services. Any other kind of immediate needs that come up like that to us? Dan, who would you say would take point on that for those topics?
1:01:21 Depending on when they're coming up, if it's off the weekend, you can reach out to myself during the week in regular business hours. A lot of that can be run through our planning department. I'll look at Sandra and Jenna. In the code enforcement side, we've actually worked with her, and she's aware of what we're looking at doing so she can provide some direction accordingly through code enforcement, either helping out with...
1:01:44 Getting them referred to social services and or letting people know that we are not enforcing those types of rules because I'm assuming we'll get some complaints from the community as well. Right. No. No, I think whatever we can do to help these people would be obviously appropriate. So thanks. No, nothing else. Thank you, Linda. John? I'm good. I think, Dan, I think it's I'm glad that we have put this on the agenda just at least get the discussion started. I think a situational awareness thing, Dan, will be helpful.
1:02:14 If we start seeing trends or things that are of note, it'd be great to share with the council. Otherwise, I'm good with relax. I'm always good with relaxing parking restrictions. So, yeah, good. Thank you very much, Jen. Thank you, John. Kirk? We have nothing to add. Thank you for the presentation. I think the more information we get out there, the better the community will be able to function.
1:02:47 As for me, I have absolutely no problem allowing people to park for 24 or more if it becomes necessary. I don't know how to determine whether or not it's necessary in each case, but I'm sure we will figure that out. I know we added this as an emergency item, but is there anybody there in Suite Z or online other than council that would like to ask a question or weigh in? No, there is not. Thank you. Dan, is that good? You have our...
1:03:19 Consensus? Yes, thank you. Thank you. So with that, moving on to staff presentations, 7.1, presentation on the status and work program of Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. Frank? Mr. Mayor, members of the council, thank you. I would say this was something we're actually planned on doing pre-COVID, which is further back than we can imagine.
1:03:51 It seemed appropriate to wait until we got to at least a lull in activities. I would also mention Commissioner Beeler. I don't know if he joined as an attendee, but I'm sure he's available as a viewer if the council has any questions I'd like to follow up with there. So I'm going to try to push through this material concisely, and then obviously I'll take questions in the middle, but it may be best if I can kind of...
1:04:20 Pick those up at the end. So let me attempt, Jamie, I think I can do a share screen. Just someone let me know if that comes up properly. It's up. Okay. Because I've got two screens and I'm never sure where my camera's going. A little latitude here so it doesn't look like I'm staring off in the space. Thank you. All right. State of the district address for Town Council, Mammoth Lakes.
1:05:01 Quick reminder on our mission, if you've not been on the site, it is to respond promptly with sufficient personnel, equipment and competency to make things better when they're at their worst. Got a graphic up in the right-hand corner I'll refer to as we go through, but essentially for us to change outcomes for the better intentionally, we've got to have the four things that are in the mission statement. We've got a quick response time.
1:05:28 Enough people, right equipment and the right training. And if we don't have all four of those, we really don't change outcomes intentionally. So I'll come back to those. First thing is fire district versus a fire department. We learned as we went through the supplemental tax measure attempts, two of them, that there was a lot of misunderstanding about this area. And I'd be the first one to say it's confusing, especially when the doors on the vehicles say Mammoth Lakes Fire Department instead of a district.
1:05:59 That's actually not uncommon. LA County Fire Department is actually the Consolidated Fire Protection District of Los Angeles. So we do have districts that go by the name department. But just to underscore for everybody, we are an independent fire district. Typically, they're smaller than fire departments. That has to do with just the components of being a district.
1:06:24 We have the four divisions that you see here, which you don't see is HR or finance or some of the other components you might see in a department that was within an incorporated town or county. A brief history there, just how long the district has been around originally as part of the fire district. We have, as an independent board, we have our own board of fire commissioners and Commissioner Mueller is with us this evening.
1:06:54 And generally, for people who don't know, we're generally coterminous with the town. There are a few exceptions, airport, and maybe a few other minor areas, but generally we're coterminous with the town. So we'll take a look at that first piece and our kind of response components here of response time, people, equipment, and training. Did a little over 800 calls for service last year. They are a direct reflection of economic activity in the town.
1:07:26 If there's a lot of economic activity, a lot of tourism, pretty much any indicator you would measure there, you're going to see our call volume track with it very closely, including time of year, time of week, time of day. Our response time is just a little over eight minutes. That's skewed upwards because we do have some long response times to frequent places that will extend that out. So our Red Meadows responses are obviously very extended. That's actually outside of our district.
1:07:55 That's another discussion. You know, we have a lot of winter driving and many calls up the main launch. So it does extend our response time average for those reasons. I want to underscore a couple of things here, and you'll see it in the slides. Direct relationship to economic activity. So every time we as a community want to drive activity, which we understand that's part of the economy.
1:08:25 It does affect your fire district directly with calls for service. And the thing is that all of our people live in town. I'm sure a number of you are aware that you have members in your own departments that have the luxury not to live in town for all kinds of reasons. That can be favorable. For us, we lose our first opportunity to change outcomes as a response time. For our people who are largely, I'll go through our workforce here in a minute.
1:08:55 If not responding from in town, we lose the ability to change outcomes by virtue of response times. And then you can see distribution by day of week with peach really on Friday and Saturday. And you'll see that we've looked at our staffing over the weekend of the week. Response scope, just a quick breakdown. Generally, we're dealing with fire, rescue, EMS and hazardous materials along with emergency management.
1:09:23 Those mean the full scope in those items. And so as you can see on there, there's, you know, talking about fires, there's multiple types of fires, talking about rescue, multiple types of rescues. The pie chart just represents how we would, you know, enter those from our records management system. You can see the bulk of our stuff is rescue and emergency medical. But this response scope has direct relationship to types of training and equipment that we need to bring to bear.
1:09:52 So we're going to move on to our staffing model, which is unique. I've been around the block and I've never seen one set up quite like this. It's a tremendously high value for what it costs us. It also has some fragileness to it, which we'll discuss. We've got 8.6. It's odd that you have a .6 full-time person, but I can explain that at a later time. So it's a small full-time staff, really myself, some division chiefs.
1:10:22 Some office help and the office help doesn't cover it. Caroline's our cotter pin here, our office manager. And then we have some full-time staff. Really what that full-time staff does is do all of the caretaking that allows us to surge a bunch of our volunteers.
1:10:44 In an unscheduled way so that they have the right equipment and training, show up, they can get behind pieces of equipment that they've trained on, have maps, radios, et cetera. If you looked on our roster, it'd show a little over 50 people. If you looked at our stats, as far as our regular, you know, active members, it's down to about 15. If any of you are managing volunteer groups, you probably have the same kind of a demographic display there.
1:11:13 A lot of pressure on our volunteer services, and most of them are members of multiple things, and in our case, they have multiple jobs because they don't have a full-time job here. I want to underscore this one, our baseline staffing, whether it's on weekdays or weekends, it's one engine company, just one. You drive past the station, people see, you know, a large station. That's really to house the other equipment that we hope to surge if we need to do it.
1:11:40 When we request more people than what we have on duty. During the weekdays, it's two people during the day and three people at night. And on the weekends, we bump that up to three people and it's for the reasons that I showed you in the previous slide as far as response frequency and where it's at. So our emergency staffing then when we really need help for larger calls, that's when we'll page other people in.
1:12:11 We try to get about 20 responders on those calls, but that is trending down. It has been for several years. So we're wobbling there, and it's not for lack of commitment of our members. And so this represents that second part, again, in the upper right-hand corners. We talked about response time. This is really the people part of our capacity. Quick overview of our resources. Two stations.
1:12:43 The one here on Main Street, the one on Old Mammoth, that one is not staffed. I will very rarely put a crew on, if we have a severe winter storm, we can lose Old Mammoth, as you all know, once we get that berm up, the work to access the snow fence, and we can lose that. So very rarely during a winter storm, we'll put some people out there, but it's typically not staffed. You can see the array of equipment in our apparatus. I would add that a lot of people don't realize it.
1:13:12 Two of our pieces of equipment, our utility piece of equipment, are loaders. We do our own snow removal. We've got to clear the parking so that the people are coming in off-duty, have a place to go. They don't have to jump a berm. And so, you know, when it's busy, that's, we're either running calls or running a loader. We don't have any extra staff for that. Anything that goes on in the fire district happens with the staffing that you're seeing here, facility maintenance, et cetera. And when I talked about the scope,
1:13:43 of responses that we do. The specialized equipment is hand in hand with that. So you saw the different types of fires or rescues that we go to. All of those have their own specialized equipment. And understandably, as we'll discover, they all require their own specialized training. So it is a full-service fire department with a very small amount of full-time staff.
1:14:09 Heavy, heavy reliance on our volunteers. They do the heavy lifting when we really put out the call for help. And we also have some communications equipment. We are integrated with the county system, but we also try to get off that system as fast as we can. They have their hands full. We also serve as a backup dispatch center. We've activated that, I believe, four times since I've arrived in 2012. And we're certainly working through some communications issues within the county and the town as we speak.
1:14:39 So a quick overview there of our resources by way of equipment. And this last piece, the last of those four things we need to intentionally change outcomes is our training. And I want to spend a little bit of time here because it really tells a story about the state of the district. Obviously, we have to cover those areas, as I addressed. Our rookies require roughly 500 hours of training.
1:15:08 Emergency Response and Emergency Medical before we can really turn them loose as responders. That's a significant amount of time. It takes us a year to get them through a part-time academy, and that's while they're doing whatever jobs they have to cobble together to live here. They do have to live here for a year before we admit them to the academy so they can demonstrate the ability to survive so we don't train them and lose them right away. That said, the attrition of our rookie classes is about a third per year.
1:15:39 Imagine if you're trying to put on $500 of training a year for a group and have that kind of attrition, it's one of our primary loads of our full-time staff is to keep trying to feed this recruitment and retention machine with a high level of attrition. And that's for our firefighters.
1:16:04 You know, it's steep, windy and snowy here. We drive pieces of equipment that are very heavy. They don't stop on a dime. Our ideal is to have at least four years of experience with our people before we put them into the engineering training. It's not something you want to just throw somebody behind. There's a lot of life risk in response. We've actually had to truncate that down to two just to make sure that we have enough people to drive.
1:16:33 So we're shooting for four years of experience before they go through that training. But in recent years, we've had to trim that down to two. On top of that, we need at least two additional years before we turn them loose as fire captains. And the captains would be the people that run that engine company, make those first on-scene decisions, guide the initial response, whether it's rescue, EMS, hazmat, et cetera. So a lot of discretion there.
1:17:03 Hoping that they make good decisions. And that's not something you hand over to someone who's brand new to the district. And if you look at that, you can see that we are really struggling with an attrition game right now. I say it takes six engineers and six captains for the system to work. It's actually eight if I put in our full-time people. And so for the system to work that I'm describing to you, we have to hold on to people enough.
1:17:34 And recruit and retain them enough to get them through those four and six year marks to essentially be those first line supervisors and run the system. And we are struggling mightily right now. In addition to the topics that are directly related to service delivery, we also have the general compliance topics that all of you do in your departments. We get access to our people roughly
1:18:00 Our training nights by the time you remove bad weather, which we'll train in just about anything. And some holidays, we typically get about 45 opportunities in terms of weekly training on Thursdays from six to nine. Sometimes it goes a little longer to 10. And so that's our contact time. And then obviously we make the most of whenever we do get people on for the weekend shifts. Quick financial overview. If I pull out my capital expenses.
1:18:32 Operational budget is going to be about $3.43 million this year. You can do your own comparisons with where we're spending that kind of money on other items in the region, but this is what your fire district is operating on. We are monolithic for all intents and purposes on our revenues. It's property tax. That's it. We don't have any TOT. People thought that we had TOT. We did tax measure. People thought the town would just consume.
1:19:02 To support their fire department financially. That's obviously not the case. Our biggest liability, like a lot of public employers, is CalPERS. We're about 73% funded right now. And we're working on trying to get that percent funding a little bit higher. We, like you, probably don't like having any loans out at 7%. So we're looking to restructure for that. Have been for the last six months.
1:19:33 I'm going to come back to that. Last bullet there. We own all of our facilities, apparatus and equipment. We do have a large capital expense drawdown that we're entering into now, and that's secondary to an expansion with the district back in around 2009, 2010, where we put on full-time people, picked up a lot of equipment, and for various reasons at that time, there was not a sufficient capital repair replacement.
1:20:00 program put in place. And so we've initiated that in the last five years. Now, after all that great planning on how to pay down our UAL, I've had to call an audible based on the explosive cost of living increases. And I'm presently reworking the budget to try to close that gap. We did a raise for our folks not that long ago, and it's been completely eclipsed. They're really upside down from where we were from that point. So we're working on that.
1:20:31 As a district, if I don't do that, we'll have the best set of books available for a district that has no people to deliver the services. So I've got to make that pivot. Kind of a SWAT summary of what I've covered. Our strengths, I can't state this enough. The strengths are our people, the culture, which was healthy before I got here. I'm trying to be a good steward of it. We have good facilities and we have good equipment.
1:20:58 And we've got to keep up on those replacement. But those are really good, strong suits for us. Our weaknesses are recruitment and retention. It has nothing to do with the dedication of the people involved. They are answering the call. But at some point, you've got to pay the rent. You've got to have gas in the vehicle so you can get to your other three jobs because this one isn't going to pay for that, especially if you're in a volunteer status or a part-time status.
1:21:29 Another week has been our inability to secure a supplemental tax. We've had one in the history of the district. It came on the heels of a 10% redirection of our revenues towards crisis with our school system. The district voluntarily rescinded that supplemental tax four years after it was instituted. It's almost unheard of out there. But if we can't find a way to do that, the forces that are cavitating our system right now are going to keep on.
1:22:00 And we're really struggling with captain and engineer succession. Our folks are getting, we're having to bring the same people on more and more frequently to cover those engine hours, and we're running into the same caps that you have on part-time. In fact, I'm probably going to have to exceed all of them and go into PERS by default. We have some opportunities. Our WUI fuel mitigations, we've been leveraging those through the FireSafe Council.
1:22:28 And our partners, Mammoth Donut is a great example, but there are a lot of other ones concurrent with that, which is an awful lot of activity. And that space in California, we've probably got more money than we have the capacity to intelligently use it and apply for it. We also have, we're looking at some possible ERAF relief through a couple of different venues, and that would be about $270,000 a year if we were successful, but those are, in each case, those are multi-year.
1:22:59 At least four years out before I could realize those. Our threats, can't stress this enough, it is wildfire. Yeah, we could have an earthquake, yep, could have a snowstorm and an avalanche, volcanic activity, but the most predictable, seasonal, repeatable, existential threat to our fire district in Town of Mammoth Lakes, which are one and the same as wildfire.
1:23:27 I did not set the timing for this presentation with knowledge of the calder fire. I think the chances of those happening regularly, if we've seen it, they're going up. Someone recently asked me, Chief, could you describe for us your thoughts on our status here and what kind of risk are we in and what's our status? And I just said, this is really easy. Calder fire, comma, cut, comma, paste, Mammoth Lakes.
1:23:57 When I came here, the Angora Fire struck me as a setting for that in South Lake Tahoe. A lot of similarities for here, and I've been watching some pretty uncomfortableness on the South Lake situation, and I was very thankful that wind conditions and tactics on the ground were able to steer that around South Lake Tahoe. They've still got to get through today, but hopefully that's going to pan out as a lot better than it could have been.
1:24:30 Our loss of response capacity and capability to staffing shortage is an absolute threat to this system. I tried to summarize it in nutrition numbers that we're struggling with. That is a direct threat to our ability to continue to provide services. COVID-19, that's affecting everybody. I've got to be hypersensitive to what I allowed to happen in that station here.
1:24:59 Normally, we have this fire station open to a lot of public use, and I've just really had to truncate that because with the small amount of people that we have, we could run through that in a heartbeat, and we've dodged that so far. And the last thing I would say is a radio system. We have got to get that resolved. We've had many different types of failures. The system has been, it's a real testament to what it was really built, originally built.
1:25:30 It's lasted this long, but actually Dan and I are working closely on some solutions for that now, but it is a real threat. You know, you try to handle something like a colder fire or an evacuation or any number of other emergencies we have, and if we don't have a solid communication system, it's really going to compound things. A couple of closing comments. In the simplest terms, let's say we're a four-cylinder fire district.
1:25:58 I'm proud of that. It's very well-run, sufficient for most of the conditions we've had in the past. And I inherited a lot of that. I'm not going to claim that. We had a good start when I got here, and I'm trying to be a very good caretaker of that. But the conditions that the district is facing as an independent district within our community, and there's a lot of good directions that we're doing, but it's putting a six-hiller demand on the system. And you've all done enough mountain driving to know what happens when you're...
1:26:28 Try and pull six-cylinder country with four-cylinder capacity. We're going to break something or we're not going to make the hill. I'd remind people that our emergency responders are your service industry people. The people that are working for us, which is the bulk of our workforce and the bulk of the people we rely on when we really hit that button for an all call, those are our restaurant workers. Those are our hotel workers. Those are our hotel workers.
1:27:00 You know, some of our construction folks. And if you've heard your business community talk about its challenges in staffing, add to that 500 hours before you can turn the moose. And that's what we're dealing with. So we're sharing that work pool, but our cost for turnover and attrition is much, much steeper. And our ability to provide succession planning in those engineering captain positions, they're really being challenged.
1:27:31 We're presently going through an ISO review. That's an insurance services organization review. Those come up about every five years. The place we took our biggest hit last time was our staffing. And I actually have fewer FTE staff now than I did then to balance books and take up our capital asset requirements. And I'm not going to try to overstate that. Not all the insurance.
1:27:59 Underwriters have to follow ISO. It's a voluntary service they have, but it recommends to insurance providers how they should underwrite their risk. It's generally better if you have a lower ISO rating, and it'll take us a few months to find out if we have any changes. As I mentioned, our revenues are monolithic, and we lag behind initial service demand. We'll see the property taxes at the end of the process that gets them on the tax roll.
1:28:28 And lastly, again, I'll just underscore it, wildfire is the most predictable threat, existential threat to the town of Mammoth Lakes. I was looking at our numbers, I asked prevention to pull them together, and I've tried to match the resources that we have to that threat. Since 2015, we kind of got two broad categories of inspections, defensible space and generally commercial. My commercial inspections during that time frame have gone from about 120 to a little over 150.
1:28:58 My defensible space inspection's gone from 42 to, well, well into 800, 800 to 43. And it's happening at the expense of some of the other service areas we have to get those done. Certainly not getting to the commercial inspections, but I'm matching the resources we have against the threat. And it's about as far as we're going to get on it.
1:29:24 So thank you for your attention there, and I will do my best to answer any questions you may have, and I can certainly go back through the slides if you want to follow up on something. Thank you, Frank. Moving on to questions from Council, John. Frank, good afternoon. Good afternoon. Frank, I've been lulled by your calm, uber-professional demeanor through a pandemic, and I would like to say that this presentation I'm feeling just
1:30:01 Just fine. And unfortunately, I'm just not. We have some real challenges here that we really need to address. And it's not on you, it's on us as a community. This is not, from my perspective, this is just not acceptable status quo. And I'm not going to belabor that. But a couple of questions for you.
1:30:27 No real particular order, but when you talk about the cost of living increases that you're experiencing, how are you calculating those? Is this just anecdotal what you're hearing from your people, rent and that kind of stuff, or do you have any kind of specific metric you're using, or is it just mostly anecdotal? The direct relationship is turnover, and when we discuss exit interview-wise why people are leaving, they can't afford it.
1:30:53 Okay. And that's the direct relationship, the metrics, while it might be helpful, you know, when you run, you know, cost of living, you know, for various areas, you know, you can get any comparisons, but the most direct relationship is, our situation is that people can't stay here. It's not because they don't want to. And I guess I'm probably, I suppose I'm probably telling you things that you've already heard from some of your own organizations and people when they, you know, when we do lose people.
1:31:20 It's usually because they, it's not because they don't want to live in Mammoth Lakes. No, I understand, but it's just, if that's, it's good to hear, it's just that simple, it's that straightforward, it's very good to know. Can you speak a little bit as to why, maybe Dan, you could, if you needed to chime in, why is it that the town, or what are the challenges to the town as an organization supporting the district? Is it just because there are two legally discreet entities, you can't, you can't cross over those lines?
1:31:49 Correct. I don't want to step on down. I would appreciate his input here, too. But yes, we are distinct entities. We have our own taxing authorities. And it's a trap that you're stuck with as well as we do. If the state imposes something, they can call it a new mandate, but they don't have to provide any funding to it because we have the authority to raise our own taxes.
1:32:16 You know, whether it's training requirements or code requirements, just like you do, I have to try to meet those. And then there's not anything directly the town can do to my knowledge. Okay. Are you planning on putting another item on the ballot for 2022? I am encouraging that we would do that again with our board. We have talked about that. You know, I don't see the downside to taking another run at it.
1:32:49 I would have thought that the conditions under which we were making those requests, and the request was clearly about our ability to do more fire prevention in the WUI space, and to not have the past conditions that we asked and wanted to be sufficient, I really don't know if the current conditions would be sufficient, and it's startling. Well, I think...
1:33:13 We can figure out a way to have that conversation. But I, as one councilman, would strongly encourage you to do that. I would look to our attorney to make sure that, you know, we're not mixing up the lines here anywhere, but this is a critical need. And I think at some point, if the town is trying to move forward with a fire district in the situation that you're in, this is just not acceptable by any way of looking at it. It's an extraordinary set of circumstances.
1:33:42 I think I'd like to follow up with Andy and Dan on that and see, look, we need to get on top of this. This is a non-acceptable situation. A couple other things. On the Caldor fire, when the debrief happens from that, would the fire district be participating in that? I mean, how should you guys be doing that? Should the town be doing that? Who owns that debrief and the lessons learned and what we as a community should be doing better?
1:34:09 So the, I mean, there's obviously an informal network I stay in touch with there. I mean, I worked 24 years with the City of Sparks and we were in the Lake Tahoe Basin regularly, for incidents. I am profoundly interested to hear how they handled the last few days as it was, you know, spotting into South Lake Tahoe, because that is our exercise out of Lakes Basin into Old Man, they're nearly identical. Yeah.
1:34:38 You know, now is not the time for me to be, you know, pressing on those, but there will be an opportunity and I'll absolutely be, you know, trying to get, there's the debrief, right? And then there's the ability to talk to people with relationships you've had and say, okay, how did this part go? What would you do different? And, you know, here's my situation. What are lessons learned? And we also watched very closely how their evacuation process was going because our situation is very similar.
1:35:07 So we're doing that real time as well as an opportunity comes up in the after action. Okay. So a couple of final questions just leading to the ultimate kind of question, which is who owns fire safety in Mammoth Lakes? I appreciated some combination forest service, you guys, the town, but leading up to that. Holly Alpert, who I think you know, has done a lot of great work in the region, a lot of different fronts.
1:35:29 And she's advising there's some opportunities through FEMA's Hazard Mitigation Grant Program to do some structure hardening stuff. Is that a program that, Dan, is that something that should go into the town? Is that somebody, Frank, is that something that would go through you? How do we start working with Sierra Nevada Conservancy and those opportunities to move this kind of stuff forward? So probably not a big leap on my part, but I was pretty sure we get this question. This.
1:35:54 is a reflection of, thank goodness there was an interim present. I did pull together some of these groups for a meeting because there is a misperception that somehow Mammoth Fire quarterbacks all of the, you know, these related mitigations and my sphere of influence is coterminous with the town, but most of that, other than about 4.6 square miles, is, you know, federal or otherwise owned property. So,
1:36:22 This is the most simplistic, you know, drawing we could come up with that discuss these relationships. You know, Mammoth Fire's role in here is that Chief Heller put in for the CEPAW grant, you know, the planning documents. I think that was one of the best things we ever did. We were the first entity in California to receive the CEPAW and heads up or hats off to the planning department for helping us integrate those things in. And so that's still a document that has legs on it that we use.
1:36:53 Our Community Wildfire Protection Plan is the link for prioritizing grant work for fuels mitigations project within the district. So from the district standpoint, those are our kind of two direct pieces. We obviously also support our Fire State Council. And, you know, they did a huge lift in Lakes Basin with Sierra Nevada Conservancy to get...
1:37:20 That strategic approach, much of it mitigated. We still need to get rid of the piles, but tremendous work there. Also, I mean, so people, if they don't know it, this is, I mean, I come up very well, but this is sort of a graphical representation of the Mammoth Donut. I would point out these pink areas. Those, as you would see in the legend here, that's non-federal land that, between our collaboration, we've gotten federal dollars to
1:37:49 Manage. And I would say that that's, you know, I was on the phone with some of our cooperators today. And the link is, my focus is at the structure itself for hardening, at the parcel level for defensible space, and at the community level for these pockets like this. And then where we handshake and integrate with our federal and state partners are those layers outside of that, ideally to get a fire on the ground and give us a chance.
1:38:15 So I'll just, I'll leave it with this. I know my other fellow council members, I've got some really insightful questions, I'm sure. The question of who owns fire safety in Mammoth Lakes. I'm just leaving that as somewhat rhetorically at this moment. But I, this is something we've really got to focus on. And I'll just point out to this map, I believe that's the bell-shaped parcel, which I think is the towns. And then the one to the left is, is that the LA, that's the Alterra's Mammoth Resorts.
1:38:40 That's a campground area. And I can't tell you how many times I've had meetings with Mammoth Resorts leadership about getting that area cleaned up, and I don't quite understand why they're not doing anything about that. I think the next time we have a conversation with Altera, I think they need to get on that, and we need to start moving forward on this stuff. This is just no joke anymore. I'll leave it there. Frank, thank you, as always, for your calm, your professionalism, and your work. Very much appreciated. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, John. Linda.
1:39:10 Okay, thank you, Frank, for that really excellent presentation. A couple of things I want to just go back to on just for clarification for, you know, is your, the property tax that you receive. So let that be no question that the only way that goes up is if the tax rolls go up at MoMA County, correct? Yes, and the caveat I give to my board is
1:39:36 Do not make long-term budget conditions on changes in property value. We want to do them on changes in square footage. So anytime we have property value peaks, those of you who've been here a long time, when those go up, we want to take those excesses and try to pay down debt. And then it gives us room when we fall into what will always happen. We'll have these economic downturns. But taxable square footage changes are the ones that I try to match for long-term commitment.
1:40:02 Right, exactly. And the fact that, you know, Mammoth Lakes and their fire district is a volunteer fire department. I mean, at the end of the day, we are a fire department that has full-time staff, part-time staff, paid staff, but are ran, you know, day-to-day by volunteers who are, you know, reimbursed at some level, but certainly it is a commitment that people make. And your attrition rates, I think, speak to that.
1:40:28 This is a hard thing to incorporate into an area that makes you work really, really hard just to stay here and the capacity that people have at the end of the day to jump back in and participate. Also, I think what sets us apart is our level of fire expertise. You lead the way in that. You've been doing fire and the world of fire for a long time. Some of your full-time staff the same. We have excellent, unbelievably talented staff.
1:40:57 And just for those who have forgotten already is that during the time of COVID, Frank stepped in as the commander of the EOC. And so, you know, the kind of overseeing, I mean, the oversight, the person who was running the whole thing. So that expertise also has been well utilized throughout the whole COVID experience in the county.
1:41:20 So stepping up to add that to your plate, I think you don't, you weren't going to take credit for that or mention that, but that was another thing that you were doing rather than, you know, staying home and running the fire department and your staff was able to fill in the gaps behind you. So an asset like this in our community, and then go to your last slide again, just for kind of a, is the fact that on top of everything else that they do,
1:41:46 The Fire Protection District, Fire District here in Mammoth. One more slide. Oh. Yeah, the next one. I think we didn't do that one. Okay. Yeah. Now, these are all the other things that you're also involved in, that our fire district is involved in. This is a huge lift for our fire capacity because not only are we responding to fires, we also respond to every EMS call, county EMS call.
1:42:14 You know, EMS in Mammoth is housed at the fire department. The medics sleep there. They have their truck there. They run with Mammoth Fire. So you are not only doing calls that just come in for quote-quote fire, you're running on every emergency call also. So, you know, these are huge undertakings that I don't think the community necessarily understands and appreciates the depth of that. So, yes, do I think we should...
1:42:41 You know, it would be a good idea for the district to go back out again and asking for this little bit of support. It's shocking that it wasn't recognized for the quality of what we have and that people did not support that, but I would keep going at it until, you know, people sort of understand about that.
1:43:02 When you say 96% of your revenue comes from the property taxes, can you talk to the audience a little bit about what the other ways that the district is supported, not only from grants, but some of your response work, some of the things you do around that too? So the other forms of revenue that we have, one is we instituted a new fee structure on the prevention side just to help us with plan review.
1:43:32 That we've outsourced, right? Because to get to these defensible space inspections, which I can't outsource, you've got to be boots on the ground to do that. You know, we set up a fee structure to try to outsource expertise in these other areas to focus on the things that only we can do. So fee structure is part of that. I think we get $1,000 a month from Mono County for the paramedic stall in the facility and housing here.
1:44:00 I do have a line item that says assistance for hire, which is as part of the state mutual aid system, if our resources are requested to go out, I've got to make payroll to them per our agreements on payroll basis, but it can take six months longer sometimes to get reimbursements. But I also show that as an expense and a revenue, and I try to match those out. But it does come out as a percentage of revenue that can come in.
1:44:30 We get a very small number of donations every year. It's a rounding error and the rest of it. Yeah, and also not to forget that when there is an emergency in Alpine County, there's an emergency in El Dorado County, we show up. You send off people sometimes to help with that too. Yeah, let me underscore that. I rejected about a half a dozen requests over the last month.
1:44:58 Simply because we were too thin here for me to feel good about doing it. I was on a Cal with Cal OES. I told them another five engines from Mono County to the Dixie Fire aren't going to be as good as them here on the initial attack. I was prepared to send one to Lake Tahoe the last two days. It looks like that's going to steer around there. And I declined the request today based on what it was seeing on the ground. So I hate to do that. I've not had to do that for a long time.
1:45:27 You know, Mission One is here, and yet we're going to hope someone sends people here. We have a fire, and I feel like I'm cheating a little bit, because I can't send anybody, but we are so short, captains, engineers, I can't do it right now. And how many fire districts are there in the county? 11? Nine, we sometimes count the, not more for a training center. We are as small as we are.
1:45:58 We are the massive fish, and these other districts are doing Herculean efforts, and we're in a much better position than them, but we also have a tremendous, you know, we have a lot more proportional responsibility. And I guess what I'm trying to get at is that I think our average citizen in the county and certainly the town of Mammoth Lakes.
1:46:19 Have not had the opportunity, maybe it's time for our local media to dig in again and talk about all the things that our fire district does, because this town would not be safe for our 40,000, 60,000 visitors on any given day on high season without the presence and work of our fire district. So I think that there has to be a way to get this funding.
1:46:48 back up there so that you are not rubbing every penny together and it takes a little bit more money to help people be able to volunteer for this. I think that needs to be found so.
1:46:59 I think whatever, you know, we can do as a council, as a town to assist in that, I think we need to take really serious looks at that. So I'm not going to beat this to death. I think we've had some good questions already. I'm just going to thank you for all you do and hope that people are paying attention and understand the really wealth of knowledge and the scope of everything that this department does and leave it at that. So thank you, Frank. Thank you. And if I could add just one additional item on this is that
1:47:29 Let's say, you know, we just, we do our best, but we just somehow we can't, you know, we don't end up bridging this gap. At some point, and it's happening right now, I'm going to give you an anonymous example, but it's, the numbers are real. We have a property in town that is going to go from an annual fire insurance situation south of $100,000 to north of $500,000. I work on this stuff through Cal Chiefs at the legislative level.
1:47:59 We're pulling together the state insurance commissioner, the state fire marshal, you know, organizations from across the country in two weeks will be doing that in San Diego. We have got to get this fixed and it doesn't eventually fire insurance problem and cost will exceed the ability to do the other economic development. And that happens without my permission.
1:48:30 Thank you for bringing that up because I think that people are starting to confront that now as their policies are needing renewal and they're going, what? It's gone up how much? And understanding that if without the presence of this department that insurers would be more able to say, no, we're not insuring you at all or the cost would be even greater because one of the factors that they use to set these rates is the availability of fight response in our community. So I think that's an important, important.
1:49:00 Awesome. Awesome. Awesome. Awesome.
1:49:31 Front and center on that topic. Well, that's really good. I was unaware of that, as I'm sure a lot of people are. So that's important for us to know the full scope of everything that's being done, because that is just the people need to understand that without that, this would be a very different place. So thank you. Thank you again, Frank. Thank you, Linda. Kirk. Thank you for the presentation.
1:49:59 And it seems that it all comes down to looking some sort of funding mechanism. And it seems that a, you know, that the town council and the community and the fire district need to look at some sort of taxing. I know people get upset because I bring this a lot, but, you know, a funding source needs to be.
1:50:27 Created maybe temporary, maybe ongoing to keep the community safe. So I'm not too sure if I need to approach the town manager or we need to have the fire district board as well as the council sit down and say, okay, this is the funding issue. This is how we can do it. This is capital and this is ongoing.
1:50:57 So I think that there needs to be a coming together to look at this to be able to address it. So that's my response. And I'm not too sure how to walk forward. I could put this on a council agenda, but I'd like to see staff to look at the opportunities.
1:51:25 And began to shape an agenda that comes before the fire district as well as the town council. I think the whole community supports it. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. Frank, thank you for the presentation. It is always nice to be educated. I think the other council members have asked most of my questions. I too would look forward to see you bringing back another.
1:51:57 Thank you very much.
1:52:28 Other than that, just thanks. Great presentation. I will now ask the public if there are any public comments on this, Jamie. No, there are not. Thank you. With that, unless the staff has questions they would like to ask Frank, and I can't see you, you'll have to speak up. Yeah, Frank, if you'd stop sharing your screen that we can get the full... I apologize. I'll just make the comment that...
1:53:06 We do work closely together with the fire department in a number of different areas. And even, you know, since Frank's been here, even before that, we've been in the last several years, too. They are a separate legal district, and so there's that separation issue. But we actually work together as the Mammoth Lakes Fire Department as far as discussions, as far as input, recommendations. It's a pretty tight
1:53:31 Group that way Frank is actually invited to and joins our department head meetings accordingly and is part of that discussion. So the relationship there between the district and the town operationally is really solid. We do a lot of work with his key chief officers as well. So I think we've had a good relationship that way. We've come together now in a couple different snowstorm type emergencies, COVID emergency.
1:53:57 Last year, the planning, pre-planning for the Creek Fire. A lot of different elements that have really come together that way that the town and the district work really close together in those areas. We are two separate entities, but we're linked at the hip as far as looking at public safety and the protection of the community. And I just, real quick, I'd like to underscore that, but Dan and really the entire staff, as I look around the screen, I mean, we've worked on all kinds of things.
1:54:24 You know, I could pick up the phone and ask Hayes the other day, hey, I've got an intersection that looks like it's impeded, and boy, by sundown, you know, it's corrected. So, yeah, when I look at the staff, I mean, it feels like we're a department in here in terms of the healthy relationships and the integration, but I just, we just needed to get before you to understand, help you to understand, we are not keeping up with you. Tongue's hanging out, we are falling behind you, and to not say anything, it wouldn't.
1:54:53 Good to cover during COVID, obviously, but you understand our situation. Thank you for your patience and your time on the agenda this evening. Thank you, Frank. With that, I will move us on to the consent agenda. 8-1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of August 18. 8-2, appoint the mayor and the town manager as the voting delegate and the alternate to the League of California Cities Conference. 8-3, adopt the resolution designating Canyon Boulevard.
1:55:24 Between Hillside Drive and Lake Mary Road, closed for the Mammoth Tough Bike event on Saturday, September 18, between 8 a.m. and 11 p.m. 8-4 approved the revised resolution authorizing the Community Development Block Grant application for the $248,809 in CDBG-CV2 and CB3 funds allocated to the town and the execution of a grant agreement.
1:55:51 8-5, accept payment approval report 22-09 and 22-10. Does anybody wish to pull anything off of consent? Seeing none, I would entertain a motion. So, Mr. Mayor, I would make a motion that we approve the consent agenda items, items 8.1 through 8.5. I'll second the motion. A motion from Linda, a second from Kirk. Any further deliberations? Jamie.
1:56:28 Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Councilmember Wentworth? Uh-oh, John Froese. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Okay, Andy, is that a 3-0 vote with one, oh, there he is. He's coming back. Did you catch the motion, Mr. Mayor? Yeah, I got the motion, and we're voting on it, John, yes or no?
1:57:06 Oh, yes, please. Yes, thank you. Thank you. Passes 4-0. Well done. Love our internet. Moving on to Policy Matter 9.1, Community Housing Action Plan Progress Report, Sandra. Thank you very much, Mayor Salzer and Councilmembers. The item before you tonight is an update on the Community Housing Action Plan. This is a document that was accepted by the Town Council in 2017.
1:57:37 And, you know, we're here tonight to talk about the CHAP, as it's affectionately called. But I did also want to just briefly describe the difference between our general plan housing element and the community housing action plan, our CHAP. So the CHAP's an informational document on community housing. And obviously it was accepted by the town council, not adopted by the town council. And our general plan housing element really provides that legal framework for our town's housing work.
1:58:05 Our Housing Work Program. And together, these two documents work to define actions that can be pursued by the town. As noted in the staff report, the CHAP had a number of objectives, including to provide 200 to 300 housing units over the next five years, including both rental and ownership units.
1:58:28 And within a range of affordability, including ownership for households up to 200% area median income. So we did provide a comprehensive list of all of the actions included in the chat with a summary of where we are with all of those. I think the biggest action item that we're extremely proud of is the progress that we've made on the parcel. Grady mentioned it during his presentation and it's a really exciting project and really exciting to see it move forward.
1:58:57 With that, I will turn it over to Nolan, who's going to walk through a little bit more detail and summarize the actions. Thanks, Nolan. All right. Thank you all. Thank you, Sandra. So, yeah, this is just a basic summary of what Sandra just discussed and the background on the chat. I won't go into too much detail on that. The key part of that, though, is really focusing on...
1:59:26 The second objective, which is targeting the full range of community housing needs. So that's really looking at the range of all the kind of unmet income levels. So this slide here, it's one that I think, you know, has been on a number of presentations lately from the town as well as Pacific and a few others. It's known as the housing bridge. So really where we're focusing is this.
1:59:50 On the left side, the low-income side, which is all kind of grant-funded, as well as the middle here, often referred to as the missing middle. So that's really where income level is up to 120%. However, the missing middle is a challenge because it's not supported by federal and state grants. That's really where local funding can step in to achieve that need.
2:00:15 So just touching on the CHAP, the foundational structure of the CHAP. These are all items that were really set to kind of be completed to then really facilitate all the future implementation of all the strategies. So the CHAP broke it into planned governance, capacity, program management, financing, public outreach, education. So within planned governance, that's really, you know, getting all the different...
2:00:42 Stakeholders to accept the CHAP, which was done back in 2018. Looking at capacity, that was town hired the housing coordinator. MLH added one full-time staff as well as got additional funding to bring on interns. And then the Chamber of Commerce was able to add a housing position as well. Program management, that's really looking at the management of the deed restrictions.
2:01:10 So that's really looking at, again, the locations of,
2:01:40 A variety of kind of housing staffs, but TOT certificates, apartment locations, existing deed restrictions. So we were able to compile all that into a map and then going forward, information will be added to that database as it becomes available or as sources get identified. Some near-term work programs on the foundational structure, as I said, looking at putting additional data.
2:02:10 I'm going to skip forward to the next slide just to highlight. This is kind of just a snapshot of the GIS database. So really it's showing all the location of all the TOT certificates issued. It's not indicative of kind of active TOT necessarily. So it's not showing who's renting currently or who rents the most. It's really just who has been issued a TOT certificate. Also, the D-restricted units are shown on here.
2:02:39 Apartment units are listed on this as well because apartments are considered typically as kind of an affordable housing source in town because they're generally used as long-term rentals. Then those are apartments are monitored on an annual basis to do an apartment count so any new ones are added into the database annually.
2:03:04 Going forward with the database, we do plan, or at least I plan to work with IT on hosting this on the ArcMap online platform. Then it's easy to access, easy to share, provide access to others who need to see the data or the database in map form. Then also with GIS, we can, as we add in more background data on, say, deed restricted units, then we can map or depict those in a variety of ways. We can map it.
2:03:34 Based on, you know, AMI levels, we can map it based on one of those deed restrictions. And so you can kind of really start refining the data or using the data to kind of inform some policy decisions or direction for future work items. So skimming back, we're also working on the status of all the town deed restricted units. I know this has been a
2:03:59 A hot topic for a number of years to identify all those. Going forward, we will consider partnering with MLH and looking into how their Homekeeper database software might help streamline some of this work. So that's a software they're working on currently, putting all their deed-restricted units into that software. So we're going to look into how that can assist us. Also looking at establishing a schedule to provide updates on the CHAP to Town Council.
2:04:29 And the last one is one that Sandra and I have talked about. It's still fairly not fully.
2:04:55 The details known yet, but looking at how can we do an annual community survey really to inform where we're at as far as the community housing needs. This would be no way as extensive as the needs assessment that was done as part of the chat, but really more a snapshot in time as to where we're at currently. So we've kind of looked at a number of other entities who have done similar surveys, so we're going to...
2:05:22 Try to come up with some questions and ways that we can then track that on an annual basis. And Nolan, just to add a little bit on that, I think that would be a really valuable source for us to, like you mentioned, to track the data, to have that data. And if we get kind of into gathering this data on an annual basis, it'll really help to inform our future, you know, CHAP updates, future housing element update, and we'll kind of provide that stop gap between our rare, expensive and
2:05:52 Heavy lift of a needs assessment that we do in advance of the housing element updates. So I think that's an exciting piece of the work program. So going forward, the CHAP's broken into near-term strategy, mid-term and long-term. So we're kind of working right within the near-term and transitioning into the mid-term. So of the strategies, 10 of the 12 strategies have been completed or ongoing or underway.
2:06:22 Ongoingly, a lot of those are ones that don't really have a completion date, but they provide a lot of the framework then for future work program items such as the zoning for affordability. So that's really looking at, you know, what zoning code updates are necessary to then kind of facilitate future affordable housing projects. So for example, on that one, we recently updated the ADU ordinance. We also updated the
2:06:49 The Town Density Bonus Program, which then allows for future affordable housing projects to take advantage of those code changes. Then one additional work program item just listed as ongoing. That's the discussions with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area on their Lodestar parcel.
2:07:10 We've had discussions with them, but there's really no concrete details as to when they'd be submitting for a project or what the project exactly will look like. Then the two that are not started yet, really we need to, at staff level, look at additional research on the effectiveness of those strategies and whether they make sense to try to implement here. So we'll likely be coming back with additional information on those.
2:07:38 Then as far as kind of near-term work program items, really the focus is now increasing the number of affordable units in the community. We've kind of done a lot of the foundational structure. We've done a lot of the code updates. Now we're really, how do we add units? So in the near term, this is hopefully completed or construction underway by mid-2022. We have a goal of 102 units.
2:08:06 So obviously there's the 81 units from the parcel. We're looking at acquiring six existing units. Either keep ownership retained at the town or deed restrict them and then resell them as deed restricted units. We're looking at increasing the housing stock by 12 additional deed restricted units. One looking at the 60 Joaquin parcel that the town recently purchased.
2:08:34 Then have a goal of establishing six additional deed-restricted units through a public-private partnership. We'll be looking at working with a private developer, providing some sort of subsidy to get six additional units. Then also looking at providing down payment assistance for a minimum of three additional home buyers in the community that would be relying on just the BEGIN grants that we have.
2:09:03 Thank you so much. Thank you.
2:09:29 The last one is the focus with accessory dwelling units or ADUs, really formalizing the incentive policy on how can we increase not only the number of ADUs, but increase the number of ADUs that are actually lived in or used as long-term rentals. Internally, we've set a goal of 10 permits that will be used for long-term rentals. So again, that's really just, I think that long-term rental use is the key part there that it's not just
2:09:58 So just touching on the midterm strategies, within the kind of strategies in the CHAP, three of the 13 are ongoing or underway. The remaining 10 are not yet started. The three that are ongoing are looking at ADU pre-approved plans, working with the U.S. Forest Service on
2:10:28 The transfer of land. And then the last one that is an ongoing one is the land acquisition. So the shady or the parcel entitlement and finance. Again, that's obviously in place and ongoing. Then again, with the focus being on how to increase units on the ground for midterm, we have a goal of 77 to 177 units.
2:10:59 Range there is really related to the parcel with what direction Pacific takes on the next few phases on the number of units there. Aside from the parcel, we have 238 Sierra Manor Road, which is Mammoth Lakes housing's project. I apologize, there's a typo that says 218 Sierra Manor, but there's 238 Sierra Manor, so that's 11 deed restricted units.
2:11:24 I know their goal is to start construction as soon as possible, but a lot of that is dependent on the grant funding and when those come through. And then aside from that, looking at doing six additional units for another public-private partnership. So again, just really working with developers out there on identifying projects that would work for affordable housing or workforce housing in the community. Nolan, if you would pop your...
2:11:54 PowerPoint backup to be a full screen. Oh, yes. Somehow. There we go. Then just to close, I wanted to touch just briefly on the regional housing needs allocation, where we're at on that. So this slide was included in the progress report we gave a few weeks ago, showing they anticipated for 2021. I haven't updated this slide, but...
2:12:28 Based on the kind of near-term work program, we anticipate 18 to 24 units in this moderate range within the next three to five years. So that really will take a large chunk out of the moderate RHNA. And then the second and third phases of the parcel will cover the remaining units within the extremely low and very low. So as far as the RHNA goes in the state looks at it, we're in
2:12:57 We're in good shape for hitting those numbers. Again, the state really, you know, you're not penalized if you don't hit the RHNA and you really only have to provide to the state that you have adequate land zoned to satisfy the RHNA, but with the current planning cycle, the 2019 to 2027, I feel that we will satisfy all those numbers by the end of, definitely by the end of 2027, so.
2:13:24 With that, that kind of concludes the update, and I'll open it up to council or the public for questions. Thank you, Nolan. I'm going to council, starting with John. Mayor Sauser, thank you very much. Nolan, thank you very much. Great to see this chap and Sandra, the whole team. Great to see this thing moving forward. A couple of questions. Some of them are pretty obvious and pretty stupid, but what the hell.
2:13:53 Nolan, you are the town's housing coordinator, is that correct? That is correct. Okay, so you, when it's not housing coordinator, it's Nolan. Nolan and housing coordinator, one and the same. Okay, good. On the question of management and housekeeping, and forgive me, I'm going a little bit off order because my notes are for the agenda item that I've got, that the council got. Is, are you, is the town, are we talking with MLH about the management of units that the town may own, build, construct?
2:14:23 That kind of stuff? We haven't started discussing that with them. We know that for the parcel, the Mammoth Lakes Housing won't be doing property manage for that. That will be managed separately. However, that is, we're having some internal discussions about potential new units or acquiring units, but we haven't approached Mammoth Lakes Housing with that formally yet. Okay, I would encourage you, let's all, because...
2:14:49 We're investing money and we're going to start building and buying and acquiring things. And obviously, it's going to be important to know who's going to be managing all that stuff. On the GIS work, very much appreciate that effort. Great to come to fruition. Nolan, could you go back to the slide of the map that shows the GIS stuff? And can you tell me, when I'm looking at this thing, the lower left, there's a little red triangle, a right triangle with a green dot in it.
2:15:17 Last I checked, there's not anything on that property. Is that little piece of land I think Rusty Gregory owned at one point? And does that actually have some sort of a thing on it? Or is it a TOT certificate on that property? Yeah, so I'm pulling up the map. I think that parcel actually has like an APN that's tied to another portion of property.
2:15:48 And so I think it's tied to a ski area, the APN. So it shows up because the whole database is based on APNs. But yeah, I can definitely confirm when that certificate was issued and if it's actually valid or not. Like I did indicate in the presentation, the tricky part of the TOT certificates is the TOT certificates are issued to a point, but when they report,
2:16:20 They're reporting based on their business tax licensing. So they don't, entities don't have to break down what, which TOT cert they're necessarily reporting on for that period. Let's say it's a management company that manages 100 units. They indicate that the number of nights rented total of those 100 nights units and how much TOT they're remitting.
2:16:44 So we have had kind of internally those discussions if it's even feasible because that would provide a lot of useful data to at least the housing size to what units are being actively rented, but at this point it's not on their work program to change how that data is collected or trapped, but we can definitely look into that triangle parcel as to why it shows up in the DOT database.
2:17:08 That's fine. I think I certainly appreciate data development is a thing and you got to work it, you got to work it, you got to clean it. I'm just hoping, Sandra, that as you guys develop this thing, you're anticipating, hopefully, council policy discussions. We start talking about single nightly rentals, short-term rentals and all that kind of stuff that we're building data that can help support.
2:17:29 The case is TAP's going to make the council look, you got to think about this. And here's the data that shows. So that's very much appreciate coming forward on the on the CHAP on the tax measure. And we don't have to belabor this at this point, but it's my understanding that the work that we did at the last council meeting, we looked at the commitments of TOT that we're making on an annual basis equates roughly to almost.
2:17:54 Just shy of a half a point increase into the sales tax. And I'm just throwing out these numbers so that we can all understand, the community can understand, that we're able to make a commitment of funding to housing that's somewhat analogous to about a half point.
2:18:12 Dan, you correct me if I'm wrong, if I'm way off base, but I think that's an important metric and point of reference so that we can, not that we're never going to put any kind of a revenue measure on the ballot, but maybe we bought ourselves a little bit of time. If we've committed to that, the council's committed to that, we do that going forward. I think that's an important thing to get out to the public. And Dan, I'm close, right? Just shy of a half a point of a sales tax increase. Is that about right? Yeah, that is correct.
2:18:41 Okay, good. So just, I think it's good for all of us to know, but we can do things as a council. We don't have to go out and try to raise taxes on people. That's good. The housing fees, again, we had that discussion at the last council, correct? We raised them a little bit by inflation. And that will be coming forward at your next meeting for consideration. Okay, good. So we gave you direction, but you're coming back to us. Okay, good. Forest Service, very interested in that.
2:19:11 I had a meeting with the congressman in D.C. I was back visiting my aging father, met with his staff a little bit. I've shared all that, which they were not aware of, that administrative site stuff. They say they're very willing and eager to support us in these endeavors. So, Dan, we can talk about that further, but there's a guy on his staff whose name I can get to you. I shared that with. I'll give it to you in a second. But they're in the loop, and they're federal, and hopefully they can help us.
2:19:40 And I think that that's it. Final observation is I mentioned that gentleman from GoBiz who helped. I don't know exactly what he did, but Dan, he was helping you and Grady with Cal Fire and this collision of state priorities and things like that. We're going to need as many friends as we can get on the state level to help us advance these things that we're doing. We're uniquely configured. We're a unique situation.
2:20:09 It's great to have him working for us, but let's make sure if there's anything that the council members can do to work on those relationships, to encourage those things, to help out to advance our housing program, just let us know. That's one of the things we're here to do. Mr. Mayor, I thank you. Thank you, John. Linda. Thank you. Nolan, thank you for the presentation. What was really valuable to me was not only your presentation, but in reading through the staff report.
2:20:38 where you laid out in great detail also kind of where we were, what next steps were, which I think was really helpful to me as a council person. So I appreciate the presentation here. I don't have any particular other questions. I know you said you're still working on the GIS housing database. It's pretty hard, especially in this document on the screen here to see, but even the printed out copy to kind of...
2:21:06 Separate what was the deed restricted unit from the apartment unit. Purple and red somehow didn't, you know, I couldn't really tell what was what there, but I think this is a great start to begin to see.
2:21:17 You know, where we have, what we have, and I think that was useful. So for whatever it's taken to do this map, it's useful, and I hope it's going to continue on that. Other than that, I don't think I have any questions right now. I look forward to your coming back with the next sort of, and what did we talk about as far as the frequency of coming back to sort of update this with the staff? You're thinking once a year, twice a year? Yeah, I mean, I think definitely on an annual basis. Like I said, I think most helpful would be kind of
2:21:46 Towards the end of the fiscal year, once we have some idea where we're at on TOT numbers, but prior to budget adoption, so we can really try to program in funding from at that point as far as what kind of commitments we're looking at for the next year. Okay. And then if you could go to the, I think the slide, the last slide, what was the little chart that you'd showed us previously? That one. Can you explain again kind of what we're looking at here and how you anticipated that this would meet?
2:22:15 The RENA progress goals? Sure. So the state sets the RENA and they base or you can count units in the annual report once a building permit has been issued. So that's kind of the indicator they use. So 2021, the anticipated units, the 8, 8 and 75.
2:22:41 That includes the 11 units of 238 Sir Manor. They did submit their building permit in 2020, and we do anticipate that they're going to at least pull their permit in 2021. Then it also includes the 81 units for phase one of the parcel. Again, that permit is close to being issued as well. And then...
2:23:03 Over here on moderate and above moderate. Above moderate is basically anything market rates. That's just listed as a TBD since we really don't know how many will be issued at this point, but we already have met all of our above moderate. So based on just the anticipated for 2021, we'll have achieved our required number of low units and we'll have almost satisfied our extremely low and very low. And then.
2:23:30 But we aren't anticipating, at least for 2021, any permits issued in the moderate income category. So then if you were to add a line for 2022, that's where we anticipate the 18 to 24 units of ones, including looking at the 60 Joaquin Road parcel or the public-private partnership or the acquisition of units where we would hopefully count those if they're deep restricted at that 120% level.
2:23:56 And then phase two of the parcel, if that permit's ready to be issued in 2022, would likely satisfy the remaining extremely low, very low, and then just add to the low as far as how much we're exceeding the required numbers. Okay, so, yeah, so do we get penalized or what kind of an issue is there, for example, very low or still, you know, we still need eight more?
2:24:25 At the end of that. So what happens then? Yeah, so there's no penalty of the state. In our housing element update, the state requires jurisdictions identify land, identify an adequate amount of land to satisfy all the RHNA for all the categories. So the only time that you kind of are penalized or not really, or kind of out of compliance with the RHNA is if a site that's identified as being needed to meet the RHNA is developed at,
2:24:55 Income level is different than what you had specified in your housing element or at a lower density than what you had specified in your housing element. At that point, you have to come in and identify additional sites to make up that kind of lost numbers. But if you, assuming you have enough land identified to meet all of your arena and let's say you build no units during your planning period, there's no penalty at the end of that. The state just requires that you maintain that adequate
2:25:24 vacant land inventory. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Yeah, I was a little confused by that, so that helps. So, yeah, other than that, I look forward to, you know, continuing to visit this regularly so we get even better at kind of parsing it out. So, thank you very much. Thank you, Linda Kirk. Thank you, Bill. My question is, when will we actually have turnkey units where people can walk through the front door?
2:25:56 And actually occupy a unit. When is that going to happen? I mean, I read all of these, you know, reports and everything else, the need assessment over the years and the 600 housing units and, you know, all of this. When will we actually?
2:26:16 You know, is it 2023 that we're going to have 81 units on the parcel? Is that what's going to happen? And what else is going to happen? When are the units available? So I'll respond to that, Councilmember Stapp. Yes, the parcel units, the 81 units, 80 affordable units, one manager's unit at the parcel is anticipated for occupancy in spring of 2023. And I understand that the 238 Sierra Manor Road project, which is 11 additional units,
2:26:46 Will be scheduled for occupancy later in 2023, most likely in the fall. With that being said, there's other units here and there that will be coming online between now and then, and we'll be tracking those and can report those to council. But kind of the biggest chunk of units is going to be delivered in 2023. Thank you. That was my only question. I think that's the question that more people...
2:27:13 From the community asked me, when are the units going to actually be ready? Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. And I'm just going to pontificate for a moment here. I want to point out that from the time we purchased the parcel, I won't talk about the actual housing there. I'll be careful. But to the time that we are being told units are going to be available is basically a five-year time frame. And for government, that's working at the speed of light.
2:27:46 So I want to give all of our staff and everybody else working on it huge kudos for that. People keep saying we aren't doing anything and haven't done anything, but when given the opportunity, we moved and we moved quickly. My question here, Nolan, on the GIS database map, hopefully you'll have that online pretty soon so that I can expand it, see it in more detail. Does this include all the deed restricted units?
2:28:15 Are the Town of Mammoth Own deed-restricted units or the ones that Mammoth Lakes Housing operates or the ones where developers added a couple of extra units at a deed-restricted level to increase their density? Are they all included on this map? They are. Thank you. Other than that, I think that the rest of council has pretty much covered it. I just wanted to get in that, you know, job well done thing. Do we have any public comments on this, Jamie?
2:28:47 No, we do not. Okay, with that, thank you all very much. Thank you. Moving on to item 9.2, adopt the Town of Mammoth Lakes Five-Year Capital Improvement Plan. Hayes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. All right. I'm going to do the obligatory, can you see my screen? You know, Hayes, hold on just a second. This sort of looks like it is going to be probably a long presentation.
2:29:28 Not particularly, but go ahead. But we've been meeting for, what, two and a half hours? Did somebody want to take a break or do you want to continue on? I will defer to the will of the council. I'm taking three of you. Linda? I am taking a short break. Okay, so let's take a five-minute break and come back in whatever five minutes are.
2:29:59 Uh, 627, so. 632. It would be good. That's, uh, greetings in Zoom speak. Yes. Yeah. I thought that was in, uh, what was the old science fiction movie from the 60s? That was the greetings thing? Don't, um, I didn't start my sci-fi thing until a little later. Ah. I know, I missed out on some classics. You know, they've remade Dune. Yeah, did they?
2:35:33 Yeah, we'll try it again. There you go. I like that. Try again. Yeah. Great book, terrible movie. Yeah, we'll try again. It's always interesting to read the book, either before or after a movie, to see what Hollywood's interpretation of something was. Indeed. Well, look, Andy got rid of his N95 because he was having trouble with it.
2:36:08 Yeah, I took that thing off, man. I couldn't breathe. Yeah, he's much more artful now. Okay, just waiting for Linda's face to show up and we can continue. I want you all to know my disappointment. I actually, for the first time in a long time, was going to take the rig out this weekend and they've closed my forest. Well, Nevada's right over the hill. Yeah, well, that's a fact. But normally, John, I don't travel that far. I happen to love our area.
2:36:53 Oh, yeah, I get it. Yeah. There we have Linda with us. So, Hayes, I'm turning it back to you again, buddy. All right. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Let's share my screen again. You see a field of orange? Yep. Beautiful. All right. So, this evening, we're seeking approval of the five-year capital improvement plan.
2:37:26 You're going to recognize these slides. I've given this presentation a few times now, and you'll probably see it a few times more, and we'll talk a little bit about that in a bit. So we'll go over our recommendation, some of the background, review the process and schedule, go over the 21, 22, 22, 23 programs, talk a little bit about 22, 20, excuse me, 2023 and beyond, and then a little discussion and direction to staff.
2:37:53 Again, recommendation, we're just seeking approval of the document as it was presented to you in the packet. So background, just to, so we're all on the same page. The five-year CIP includes development, maintenance, improvement projects. CIP projects are non-recurring projects, have a long life. Expenditures are considered beyond the scope of normal annual operating and maintenance expenses.
2:38:18 This does not appropriate funds. It's just a budget tool. And we don't include vehicles, technology, software, emergency, stopgap type work. The document, as it was in the packet, had an introduction, kind of talked about the process, some of our highlights from previous years, and that'll continue to grow as we improve the document. Current year project summaries, the five-year CIP is represented in tables, and that's so that we can...
2:38:47 And then I added a number of project narratives, as I said it would back in June. So every project now has a small kind of synopsis about what it is to kind of provide a little bit more information about what we're doing. So CIP projects are reviewed to meet a number of different needs and I'm not going to go through this, but what's important and I want the takeaway here is that this is a dynamic document and that this will come before council
2:39:18 A number of times. And with consensus from council, we can make adjustments to the document based on what our needs are at that time. It is a living document. So where are we at today? So June 2nd, when we introduced the document and the process and the project to council for the first time, we got kind of a thumbs up. We took it to PEDC. They adopted a resolution confirming that the document is consistent with the general plan. I put together a matrix.
2:39:46 Each project was related to a separate item in the general plan, and they approved that by resolution. And today we're here to approve the document. And like I alluded to, you'll see this again. We'll be reviewing this in the future for funding, looking at what we're doing on an annual basis, making budget adjustments as needed. And I believe, Dan, you wanted to talk a little bit more about that future process.
2:40:12 Yeah, I think it's really key to a lot of council to know this is going to be a dynamic process, a dynamic document, or we'll refer to it as a living document because of the capital projects that come forward that we have really no way of knowing some of them based on grant funding, other unknowns that may hit the community in terms of need or failures of different sidewalks or a roadway or something. So be able to do that quick response element. But at a minimum,
2:40:42 The council will see this at least three times. Once as we're actually putting the budget together, that'll have a CIP discussion in it. We identify those key projects at that point that are often continuing projects in the prior year or some that may be funded from past revenue and or grants and other funding sources that are going to roll into the budget.
2:41:06 And then when we come forward, we look at our third quarter adjustments. When we start to look at how are we doing this year? What type of savings do we have? What type of additional revenue do we have? Or if we don't, like in the COVID year, we ended up reducing our capital program, those types of things. But as we look at that third quarter activity, that's often when we know we're going to have additional revenues. We start to allocate those out. There's different needs of the town.
2:41:34 We begin to look at the capital improvement program and we walk through some of the details. You'll see areas where we would program money into, including the housing discussion we had earlier, as well as other streets or sidewalks or transportation elements that we would fund. And then again, when we come back with our fund balance, usually in the October timeframe, often again, that's another adjustment opportunity. We take a look and say, are we fully funding all of our reserve requirements? Are we meeting?
2:42:03 Any other operational needs that we have? And then again, what are those dollars that are available for reinvestment in other areas? Do we have any impacts operationally we need to cover ongoing? We've used those dollars in the past to support like our vehicle replacement program, which is a real key element for us. We handle it separately versus the CIP, but it's definitely a key element of our, you know, the amount of equipment that we run and operate is huge.
2:42:31 And so given the opportunities there at budget and then at a couple of key, you know, revenue expenditure adjustments, at least three times a year the council would they have the opportunity to look at the CIP more holistically. Then throughout the year if there's a project or there's something that comes forward, again, unknown grants, et cetera, then you would be adjusting that program, you know, at each step of the way that ultimately those projects would get built into it.
2:43:01 And as Hayes noted too, we start to look at the past projects and stuff. And the goal would be to have a minimum of like three years of history, kind of showing the projects that are being done as we go forward. Here's where we're succeeding at. Here's what's getting on the ground. Here's what's being built. Here's the current year projects that are well-funded. And then looking out one year of budget and four years forward. So that's a key element as we structure the CIP and making sure there's adequate
2:43:30 Information review and input. Thanks, Dan. Appreciate that. And to Dan's point, I wanted to kind of demonstrate just that. In just the time between June 2nd when we kind of started this process to now, we've actually had to make some changes to the document. As Nolan discussed in his presentation, we've got some housing projects and those have made their way onto the CIP. Council has put funding into the dog park and the town hall improvements just at the last council meeting.
2:44:01 Those were previously unfunded. We did some combinations, talking to staff, kind of reviewing the document. We had programmed road rehabilitation, SB1, which are road rehabilitation dollars, and the parks and maintenance and improvements into annual allotments. And for simplicity, we've combined them. And the reason is these three programs are reviewed on an annual basis. For road rehabilitation, we work through our Street Saver program. We identify the projects that are the highest need.
2:44:29 We work with our staff to figure out what needs to happen on an annual basis, and then we program that. SB1, we come forward with the resolution to council every year, seeking approval on the projects. And Stu has a process with Parks and Maintenance and Improvements where he works through his list of needs and improvements with the rec commission. So for instance, a project like the tennis courts, that would work through his group. And then if they decided to move that project forward,
2:44:56 That would come to Town Council as a recommendation on how to spend those funds, and if it was so approved, it would become a discrete project in its own element. So we combined this for a little bit more clarity, and also removed some clutter in the plan. We also do the same thing with the CRC Mobility Hub and CRC Building. They're really becoming one of the same project. I think people are recognizing this is now like one project. The 2021 Streets and Mupp project, the budget was reduced. We had...
2:45:25 We had incredible bids on this project. We had budgeted $3.1 million for the scope of work. It came in at just under $2.4 million. Great number. We're going to take that scope, expand it to spend the full $2.7 million in stip funding, but it allowed us to pull $400,000 out of road rehabilitation and put it into a future year project. So that's great news.
2:45:48 I made a mistake. I put two sidewalk projects in the plan that were actually in the complete streets list, not in the strategic priorities from the pedestrian plan. So I removed those just because it wasn't clear. And then my staff report, I noted that when we do this mobility master planning effort, we'll identify new strategic priorities for pedestrian investment, and those will work their way into the CIP. And then finally, I deprogrammed the Whitman improvements.
2:46:17 Pending a future council discussion on Old Mammoth Transit Service. So what that looks like, 24 projects, about $39 million worth of work. There are no funding gaps in our active projects. I don't expect you to be able to read this, but I provided this in the packet. And I do have hard copies available for town council. If you'd like a full CIP hard copy, please let me know. It's about 80 pages. So I didn't do that.
2:46:46 Off the bat, but if someone requests it, I'm more than happy to provide it. And this is a breakdown of all of our funding sources. Same thing with 22-23. Not a lot has changed going out years. A couple little minor changes, but nothing really of note. But that over this winter is going to probably change pretty dynamically as projects start to advance. As we start to get hard numbers from bids, this chart will change when we start to learn what the projects actually look like and the scope starts to evolve. And like Dan alluded to,
2:47:15 No doubt new projects are going to hop out of nowhere. We're going to find grant opportunities. You know, money will flow from different sources and new projects will avail themselves. And through the road rehabilitation SB1 and STU's process, discrete projects will come out of those as well. Again, don't expect you to be able to read this, but this is a breakdown of the various budget sources, excuse me, funding sources for the various projects. You can see there's still a $2.2 million gap.
2:47:45 And what we'd like to accomplish going into 2022-23. And again, longer years, projects are less developed. You'll see that in the project summaries. A lot of opportunity to work through prioritizing these projects, opportunity to leverage various sources and really prioritize how these projects move forward. And again, we'll be looking for consensus from town council to make those adjustments. So with that,
2:48:14 You know, really looking for town council approval on the project, any discussion, any consensus on any changes. And like Dan said, we'll be back to talk about this probably in just a couple of months. Thank you, Hayes. I wanted to touch on a couple of items also as we build the capital improvement program. One of the key issues that we've really instituted in the last five years or so, maybe seven years, is how we manage the budget and end up funding our capital program.
2:48:47 Instead of having the capital program every year fully funded and having it compete with operational dollars, your operating budget, one of the easiest ways to balance it is to cut your capital budget, not a unique process across local governments. So as council is more than aware, we have really tried to tighten down our operating budget to what we really kind of need, not to go too big in terms of that area.
2:49:16 We're very conservative in our approach with our TOT estimates and some other revenue streams. And what that has really allowed us to do is a couple of things. One is we, the first one is being able to have our reserves funded to be able to respond to unknowns as we did through COVID and some other projects we've had to do historically. But really then it allows us to come back in and say here is $6 million for housing.
2:49:46 Here is a million dollars for road work. Here is dollars to do a lot of the projects that are in here. And one of the concerns we have is not to begin to prejudge that revenue flow or savings. So we're not impacting a budget at a level all of a sudden we're doing actually probably more reductions and trimming back versus adding in too. And I think that's a critical process not to lose sight of.
2:50:15 As we come in with the budget, the majority of the discussion is on the operating budget. And yes, it's tight and it's tight on purpose. And then we take a look at what are the known dollars for capital if we have a grant program or like the SB1 money that comes every year from the state. We walk through those types of elements for some projects. But then the majority of the heavy lifting for the capital program comes in in that third quarter review and the fund balance review.
2:50:44 So we can actually say, yeah, we think we have $3 million for capital work, or we have X dollars over here for this. And that goes to both our general fund dollars as well as some of the restricted dollars that we work with at that point in time. So we're able to roll that in at that point, and then we have projects that are fully funded versus kind of a wish list of a lot of projects. I think that it serves the town very well, not just on the capital side, but it's our vehicle.
2:51:14 Equipment is one. We had to respond back with a bunch of our generator work. It's been two years ago now to get that up and running and going. And different elements that we have that way that we've really been able to step into and fund well. And then one of the examples, I'm going to use the housing component of this. And this is kind of nontraditional as a capital improvement program. Generally, you wouldn't see affordable housing as part of your capital program. Most agencies I'm familiar with.
2:51:42 But by putting it in there, we know we're going to commit to projects and whether the town's actually doing the work and doing the process or we're working with the private sector or partnering up on the parcel, for example. If you take a look at that section, if you look at the very last page of your pack at the top, you'll see where we've allocated those revenues that council approved. And then we've looked at each year putting 1.1 million.
2:52:10 In there, again, that $1.1 million is not yet funded. But that starts to set the stage going, hey, we have dollars left over in terms of excess revenue, in terms of savings. Here's our capital projects that are not funded. Is that housing project still the council priority? Is the road rehab project the priority? And we can work through that and fund them accordingly.
2:52:37 I think we want to identify those. We did it on purpose in the CIP to say we believe this reflects the priorities that Town Council has set. We have a number of priority areas and we believe we are targeting those. We have money for deferred maintenance. We have money for roads. We have money for housing to be able to do those things. If you look at that housing investment, just some quick math, if you actually take the dollars that we programmed this year, excluding the
2:53:05 State money for the infill infrastructure grant, the IIG money. We will set aside about $2.1 million annually. Now that's front-loaded this current year with the dollars there. But if you took all of that over a five-year period, you'd be committing about just over $2 million a year starting in the current year. Going on, we used kind of a low-end $1.1 million. As I mentioned earlier, that's just under
2:53:35 A half percent sales tax or a transaction use tax level, similar to what we do for measure R. Or it's about one point of the 13 percentage points we do for TOT. If you took one percent of that as a one point of that 13. On a $15 million TOT budget, it would be right in that 1.1 million range as well.
2:54:03 So we think it's a good baseline to target as we go forward. Again, based on the priorities and other funding sources, I'll say highly likely, probably very, very likely, especially in the next year or so, you'll end up putting additional dollars into housing over and above what we have allocated there, provided our economy holds and it moves forward. The elements that we're seeing right now that were unforeseen, fire,
2:54:34 Forest closure, cancellation of one of our larger events, the Gran Fondo. What does that impact have on our economy and our revenue? It'll have an impact. How much? We don't know yet. We don't know how long this will last. But we know financially we're set up to we can weather those types of storms and still be able to move a lot of projects forward. So I really wanted to highlight that. What I don't want to do or we're not recommending is that we...
2:55:02 Change our budgeting process. And so we start front-loading a lot of elements and then have to start scrambling of how do we actually implement them or turn to a frustration side in terms of what do we have to cut out or reduce back. So that's an ongoing process. Again, the council is very engaged in that through the budget and then through the updates that we do in that quarterly review of our budget prognosis.
2:55:28 So I really do want to highlight that because I think it served us very well and we have actually been able to accomplish a lot. And as we begin to show more of the history as we get into this document going forward, I think a lot of that will start to flow out and say, yeah, we have accomplished a substantial amount of investment in this community. If you look at the last several years, it's been millions of dollars that we've been able to put back into the community in a variety of ways. And again, one of the elements I'll mention, I know,
2:55:58 The deferred maintenance issue, and we'll look at the parks for a moment, but it goes beyond the park side. That has been an ongoing request which had to compete with the operating budget. So it was always reduced or appeared to that it was just not a priority because we didn't want to reduce other operations. Building that into our capital program the way we have.
2:56:19 The last few years, and Stu could give me the number, but it's probably well over a half a million dollars or more that we've been able to put back into our deferred maintenance of parks, which has always been spoken as a priority. Now it's reflected as one by the actual investment we're making out on the ground. And it's always fun this last week talking to some of the park guys and the work that they're doing. And we need to do a little more training. I think one of them was testing the electrical problem they were having by touching it.
2:56:49 So if it bit them, okay, that wasn't working, and if nothing happened, they were fine. So they were part-time employees. But to hear the excitement, frankly, that our employees have that they're able to go and do that and be able to actually repair and fix and make sure things are working well, they take a lot of pride in that. And having those resources, which is a result of this process here, goes a long ways. And so we're very, very pleased about that.
2:57:21 And for me, it's very rewarding when you talk to your employees and go, yeah, our fleet is looking like it's finally caught up. Or, yeah, we can actually be proactive in our maintenance on our parks. Or we can step in and fix the sidewalk. We can get out there and get the street done, whatever. And it's not an ongoing battle for revenue and for allocation. So hats off to the employees who take these dollars and make it real.
2:57:46 But I think the policy direction that this council has set for us to achieve those things has been dramatic. And the other big element on this one, you're all aware of it, but had we not walked through this process, we wouldn't own the parcel right now. I don't believe we'd be talking about building 450 units over the next several years. We wouldn't be talking about 80 units coming online in 23 at that site. Between the purchase of that and the
2:58:16 Investment in the community planning and stuff. Again, our financial process as well as just the success of our community has really allowed us to do that. And so this is reflective of that work and it's an ongoing element that really begins to drive that. So can't kind of express that enough that these are commitments, they're priorities. But each year we walk through and say, are we on track? Do we have the funding?
2:58:44 Let's move these forward. And then we get as creative as we can in finding money. And staff is good at that. We're meeting with EDA on some discussions. Look at the state budget, federal budget, as this stuff rolls out, are we ready to consume what we believe will be a whole lot of money coming into local government. And hopefully we're ready for that and we can take advantage of those things to achieve the goals and the priorities that we have.
2:59:14 This council and those before you and after you will have set to the benefit of our community. So thank you. Thank you for that. Important to reiterate that from myself well before I was on council, previous councils that I think John was a part of at the time, we have wholly changed the way that the town works its budget. And it has been incredibly successful and has allowed us to do these things.
2:59:46 I want to piggyback on what you're saying, Dan. We need to move forward right along the same lanes because if we do, we will be able to afford these things that we need and want. That being said, I will go to questions or comments from council. I'm going to start with Linda. You just muted yourself, Linda. There you go. Is that better? All right. Thank you for this.
3:00:17 I really appreciate the detail of this capital improvement plan. I also appreciate that we have, when I first joined council, that the big push was deferred maintenance. Let's get that deferred maintenance done, you know, and I know what great strides we've made in all that too. So my favorite document this was the project list, which was the 21, 22 through 25, 26, all laid out in itty bitty teeny writing.
3:00:46 That is, to me, is really sort of the biblical source for this whole discussion, where we have tried to think of every idea and everything we could think of, not that this is a done document, this is going to, you know, weave and ebb and flow over the next few years, but it's here. And I would defy people to find much on here that they couldn't, hadn't already been included, but I did manage to do that.
3:01:15 Because I have a couple of comments about that. One of them was sort of the build out of the CRC with the room and the bleachers and maybe someday in our dreams, you know, the upper level. So I thought that was a pretty good achievement given the thoughtfulness of this list.
3:01:36 I appreciate how we're, you know, did so well in 2021 in spite of everything. 22, 23, we just have to line up a few things, but we're, we have a great start on it and it's only September, September 1st. So I have no other comments, Hayes, on this and for the rest of the staff that participated in this, I think this gives us a great, a great map going forward of what we'd like to see accomplished and what we'd like to be able to do if all things were.
3:02:03 We're equal, and it gives us five years to think about it here, so, or four more years to think about it, so thank you for that, and I'll keep thinking of other things to add to the list, if I can. Yeah, Lynda, to your point, what we'd be looking at is in that 22-23 year, if we allocate funding for the build-out of the interior of the CRC, then that would plug right into that column there. We don't have a hard number right now for that, but that would be something that, as you're mentioning, that even...
3:02:28 As we come back in October, that could be a time frame for us to take a look at adding something like that. Again, the additions on that will take a consensus of the whole council so that we're all on the same page. It's not a one-off, one-at-a-time priorities. But that type of input is good for us to hear and ultimately consensus from the group as we move these things forward.
3:02:53 And then that leads me to another comment too, and that is the capacity of staff to have their ears down all the time listening for these grant opportunities. I mean, they are flying. They're flying through my mailbox and I can only imagine what it is at the staff level. You're just getting inundated with these every day like this grant, that grant, this grant, that grant. And to really keep an eye on if we have the capacity to do that. Because if we don't, I think that's a serious discussion because not...
3:03:22 Thank you, Linda. Kirk. Thank you.
3:03:53 It really spells out not only the long-term, you know, the capital improvement project, but also our budget and where the dollars are going on an annual basis and over a five-year projection. So I think it's an important document. It lets the community know, you know, what our priorities are and what our expenditures and a timeline. So I thank the town manager and the town staff.
3:04:23 I think it's very important that this be provided. Thank you, Town Manager. That's my comments. Thank you, Kirk. John. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Okay, so I've been on the council for, I don't know, six, seven years. And man, I've been waiting for a CIP. And this actually looks like a CIP. And it sounds like it's going to walk and talk and...
3:04:56 Do the duck thing like a CIP. So my first question is, Dan and Hayes, are we going to be seeing this on the schedule that you've been talking about? Is this going to be a regular instance before I get too giddy? Absolutely. Yes. Okay. So I'm very, very excited about that. And I'm very excited that...
3:05:16 This CIP is going to function the way that I think we always intended it to function, which is this nice firewall between our regular sort of general fund budgeting, setting up a long-time priority vision of capital, something we can do that's iterative, that's going to move around. So this is everything that I dreamed about. And don't ask me what I dreamed about, because that's maybe a little bit strange. But this is very exciting and really, really happy to see this. A little bit strange? Excuse me? A little bit strange?
3:05:46 We can talk later, but this is exciting stuff. This is great. So to follow up on a couple things, things that Linda said on funding. I don't have to tell you all that we're living potentially.
3:06:03 There's a generational amount of money in the California state budget. They're going through a very weird process to nail it down right now. But by September 10th, we're going to know. And Linda, I want to follow up on your suggestion. And Hais, I'll look to you and Dan. If we need to get some people or somebody on this.
3:06:23 Derek Kirk is a good place maybe to start, but some other people say, where is the money that's going to be, we can align with the CIP as money we want to get our hands on. And I think also I want to talk about how this is going to align with policy interests that we have. We'll talk about that in the next agenda item. The second thing is in the federal government, I am, I don't know if optimistic is the right word, but I'm seeing a line whereby
3:06:47 The $3 trillion probably reduced a little bit reconciliation package in the federal government with the infrastructure package. I can see where that gets through. I think we can all see that. There is a certain political party in the United States that has a visceral interest in seeing that thing pass. And that's October, September, October. But I think, Linda, to your point, we got to start getting lined up for that. We've established our priorities. We know the things that we want to do. We've now go after we got to get that money.
3:07:17 So it's something for us to be thinking about. And it's due in large part to having a CIP like this where we've got strategic priorities from the council. We've now got an inventory of things we're trying to pursue. We got to get on that.
3:07:31 On the couple of nitpicky questions. On the CRC, on the Mobility Hub, I've been torturing Dan and Hayes, I think to some degree about whatever you're working on with Tesla. I've still got my eyes on that thing. And universal chargers is something we've got to really be smart about. I won't belabor that now. It's a technical thing, but we've got to be talking about that. Another tangential question. With the Forest Service closures, are the MUP improvements going to be able to happen this fall?
3:08:00 That's good. Okay, great. Thank you for that. And here's an interesting question. ARPA funds. You know, Mono County got, how many million did they get? They got two and a half, three million unrestricted funds. Or maybe, I think Mono got three million, Inyo got two million. Dan, how much did the town get? Where is that money? Is that nailed down somewhere? Are we really nice to know from the council level where those dollars are? Because that's...
3:08:28 Nice unrestricted federal money we can put to good use somewhere. And the first, real quick, John, the first round of that will be part of the discussion in October with our fund balance. Okay. The first payment came in July, late July. Okay. I think it's going to tell about $1.8, $1.9 million. For us? For us. It's over two fiscal years. Okay. Next year. But we'll be pulling that in that fund balance discussion. Excellent. So, I mean, Linda, the...
3:08:56 These are the kind of things that are going to be happening. Money will be somewhat falling out of the sky. Doesn't happen very often. It's happening now. We got to be ready for it. And there could be a lot more of this to come. And it could be happening over many years. Another thing to keep in mind. Quick question for you, Hayes, on minaret sidewalks. I've had some...
3:09:17 An inquiry from folks about making sure that that connects to the Lodestar Trail. It's maybe kind of a technical thing that we can maybe talk about it later, but I can tell you exactly what someone asked of me to that end. Are you speaking to the Minaret Mupp? Yes. Okay. It's the, yeah, connection to the Minaret Sidewalks. They may not be using the right term, but it's the planning thing we did to the LTC to make sure that connects to Lodestar.
3:09:49 That's one thing I saw as being added. And right now, I'm not going to jinx myself with anything else in there other than that mobility plan. As one council member, I've maybe gone out on a limb with this bird scooter thing. The nexus in my mind is to house it.
3:10:07 It all comes back to the conversation we've had about the parcel. Are we going to be building infrastructure for cars? Are we building infrastructure for human beings? The more that we can move people around using multimodal transportation things, micromobility, which, Hayes, I know you know a lot about, we need that mobility plan. And I think as these dollars start coming from the federal government or from the state, that's how we're going to line these things up and really realize real opportunities for the community. I'm very excited, looking forward to that. I know you're working hard on it.
3:10:36 Very much looking forward to seeing it. Mr. Mayor, I'm done. Thank you very much. Thank you very much, John. As for me, job well done, Hayes. It looks good. As John said, it looks like a duck and walks like a duck and talks like a duck. So I'm happy with the whole process to this point. Mike, do we have any public comment on this, Jamie? And Mr. Mayor, if I may, I'd like...
3:11:05 Just because this is a little bit different process, I'd like to respond to a couple things and propose a few things. And I can do that after public comments. It's fine. Carolyn Sanderson, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Hi, everyone. I have a comment that I received from Mono County Supervisor Stacey Corliss. Can everyone hear me? Yes. Yes. Okay, thank you.
3:11:35 She asked that I read into the record and then I also have my own comment to give so I can do those in either order at the pleasure of council. How are you pleased to go forward? All right, then I will read Stacey Corliss's comment first, which I believe you received. Dear Mayor Souser and council members, first, I'd like to make a general comment as the board of supervisors representative for district five that I hope council and the board can meet soon, both at a joint meeting and through the county town liaison committee.
3:12:06 As tonight's council agenda demonstrates, there is a need for local government to work together to better address issues such as the housing crisis. Thank you for the unprecedented investments and effort you've made already. I'm ready today, though, to comment about item 9.2, approval of the five-year CIP. Overall, the plan itself is well presented and clearly aligns with the council's identified priorities. My concern, no surprise, is only with one project, the bus turnaround in Old Manor.
3:12:36 The project description notes that implementation is pending a council decision on transit. I urge you to direct town staff to reframe this project entirely and to not approve the Woodman turnaround specifically as a part of the CIP. Instead, please consider categorizing this project as an old mammoth bus turnaround replacement. This is a difficult situation as there is no perfect short-term solution.
3:13:01 But if it's the town's intent to look at options for the replacement turnaround beyond Woodman, then that should be reflected in the project description. If it is not the town's intent to seek alternative turnaround replacement options, then town council must be transparent and engage all impacted by a potential decision to either cancel much needed public transit to a residential and resort area of town or to ignore legitimate safety and quality of life concerns from residents of Woodman Street.
3:13:31 And adjacent areas. As a fellow public servant, I sincerely hope that council will opt for the first scenario, looking at alternative turnaround options and avoid pitting its residents against each other. Thank you for your time and your service. It's not easy, but we've needed local, but we've never needed local leadership and attention to detail more than now. Yours in service, Stacey Corliss. Thank you, Caroline, and your own comment quickly. My own comment,
3:14:07 Parts, I made some notes and parts of my own comment were addressed by Hayes and I do appreciate that. Thank you very much. My name is Caroline Sanderson and I've lived on Woodman Street for 23 years. Hayes stated tonight that the Woodman improvements have been deprogrammed pending future town council discussion about public transit in Old Mammoth. And to be honest, my main concern in reading the capital improvement plan
3:14:33 Was that Woodman Street was designated as the actual location of the old mammoth bus turnaround. Because our understanding from all the other meetings and presentations is, you know, that we're surrounding this proposal was that there were other sites being considered and that the location and the associated project would go to town council for a separate vote. It wasn't our understanding that it may be buried under the umbrella of a five-year CIP. Now, what I've heard tonight,
3:15:01 Is positive for me. I've heard that the CIP is a dynamic document, that it's a living document, that it's things that we can change. But it does make me nervous that the location has been designated specifically in that document. And I also realize that council is not required to respond to public comment, but I respectfully request that you clarify the process for a lot of us, since our understanding is that the location of the turnaround has not been decided.
3:15:30 And I also urge council that if the capital improvement plan is, if it is dynamic and you do adopt it, that you replace that language or amend that language where it says Woodman bus turnaround with something to the effect of proposed old Mammoth bus turnaround to alleviate any bias against other viable sites. And again, I'd like to thank Hayes for the clarification that he provided tonight about.
3:15:58 The nature of this document being a living document. It's new to me, and I'm sure it's new to my neighbors, but we just want to make sure that the discussion remains open and that eventually this will go to town council for a vote on the specific project and not as a part, not under the umbrella of the CIP. Thank you. Thank you, Caroline. Any further public comments? No, there are not. Mayor, I can respond to that or Hayes can, but
3:16:34 The project for that turnaround is not listed actually in the five-year CIP, you know, actual project list and funded list. So even with the approval of the document, that project would not be approved without further council action. Thank you. Sorry, Mr. Mayor. Caroline, are you still on and listening to this? Council Member Wentworth, I muted her after her comments. Would you like me to unmute her again? She's still on, though. Yeah. No, I just want to make sure that someone's listening and hearing this obviously at the end of a council meeting and this has been a contentious
3:17:09 I just want to make sure that someone is hearing the action that we take so we can get the communication out to the public. That's all I did. I'm sorry. I didn't mean to interrupt. Hey, if you want to add to that, you can. Yeah, it's the pleasure of the council. So like I said, Mr. Mayor, I was going to respond to a couple of things. Procedurally, I think we want to kind of understand how these things can move through the process. And I'm happy to answer questions as we're kind of learning how to use this document.
3:17:38 Councilmember Salcido mentioned wanting to see the build out of the CRC 2223. If we had, I don't have a process for like nominating a project, it's not a formal thing, but if we had effectively three out of four thumbs up, staff would take that, put it, program it in a line item. There might not be funding, but we'll program it out there so that, hey, we know staff go start looking for a way to get this, make this happen. Start looking for opportunities, bring it back to us, figure it out.
3:18:07 Obviously we'll have to work out the scope, we'll have to work out the budget, but it sends a message to us to go work on these things. And I think that can play out with any type of project that is something the council wants to advance. A lot of times these things like the housing happen in other discussions and we take that information and incorporate it, but there's always that opportunity to just raise your hand and say, hey, do we want to move this forward? Do we want to put this on the list? And we can maybe work out a formal process if that was the desire of the council.
3:18:36 I wanted to mention, John, spot on, generational money. If you look at the planning work that's going on in this document, multitude of sidewalk projects, you know, Fuel Island, HSAP, there's so much stuff that we are going to be, I think I counted six or seven planning projects we are teeing up for this winter to try to be ready for that, what we hope to be an influx of money. We have a gut feeling on how that money may come to the state based on how it worked with COVID.
3:19:05 And we want to be ready for it. 100% agree. And I think this document reflects some of that work. And we can talk offline about this conversation about the Minaret Mupp. We're kicking off that work. That funding is available in October. And we're moving forward with that. And universal chargers are happening with the Tesla stuff. So we can talk offline about that as well. I'm happy to field any consensus changes to the document that you're interested in.
3:19:33 Moving forward or removing. So, Mr. Mayor, if I could real quick, Hayes, just to follow up because this ties into LTC work and I'm thinking, Bill, that we need, you know, we have our preview of the LTC meeting. I think we should make sure we carry this into that, into those efforts. Good idea, John. Any further questions for Hayes? Dan, are we looking for a motion here or just a, it's not clear in the packet, but I'm assuming you want a motion.
3:20:10 And I will make it to approve the four-year CIP. So that's a motion. Bill, I'm wondering if you would be open to making a minor tweak to your motion, which is in the interest of public clarity, that references to the Woodman turnaround as described. I appreciate, Dan, the way you said it. It's not on the list. But Hayes, the exhibit that you've got and the thing that was in the packet, did we just remove that?
3:20:41 So we can make clear to the public, I know Caroline's still listening in, that it's not in the five-year CIP, and we will remove it from the exhibit just for clarity's sake. Whether or not that means amendment to your motion or not, Bill, I don't know. John, I would be willing to change it from the Woodman turnaround to just an old Mammoth bus turnaround and not specify location. Yeah, okay, that's fine. Then I would like to second your motion then, Mr. Mayor.
3:21:14 I have it. We got a motion to second. My other question before you call the question was, to Linda's point, do you want us to take a look at adding a project in for the interior work of the CRC? I would support that. Yeah. So if we include that in your motion as amended, we'll do that? Yes. I will amend my motion to include that. I will amend my second.
3:21:45 I still have now an amended motion and second. Any further deliberation? Seeing none, I will call for the item. Jamie? Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Passes 4-0. Thank you all very much. Moving on to agenda item 9.3, Prop 68, Regional Park.
3:22:16 Program Grant, Stu. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of council. We provided a hopefully detailed, sorry, detailed staff report for your review. I'm going to try and keep this brief. And every time I say brief, tends to go a little bit longer. And all my colleagues ribbed me a little bit. But I'm going to try and keep it as brief as I can. I'm happy to take any questions at the end.
3:22:44 Not by accident that this item is following the CIP discussion. This is actually part of Project PR8 in the CIP. And then as I think Councilmember Wentworth and many of the Council members, you know, this is what we call kind of getting on it and finding some money. So this is the Prop 68 Regional Park Program Grant.
3:23:10 So I'm just going to run you through a few of the details, a little bit of background and kind of where at and then the action before you. But the town in partnership with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Mammoth Hospital, Mammoth Track Club and Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access, MLTPA, are submitting a $3 million competitive grant for the Proposition 68 Regional Park Program. It's called the RPP grant.
3:23:38 You know, compressed everything as an acronym. So the RPP is for us, I would believe a very or an extremely competitive grant opportunity. It's a reimbursable grant and there's upwards of $23.125 million available across the state. The funds have to create, expand or improve regional parks and regional park facilities.
3:24:06 The projects need to create at least one new recreation feature that attracts visitors from at least a 20-mile radius or county-wide population to a regional park. There is no match required. They're not using any medium household income, which is why we're kind of pursuing this grant, and the grant by itself may fund the entire project. So if you can get hold of this money, as Councilmember Wentworth said, very generational.
3:24:32 We can build a phenomenal, we can build out a phenomenal regional park down at Whitmore. So the grant application that we're proposing to submit in the RPP is a new recreation center. It's approximately 3,000 square feet and a new multi-use trail, approximately 2,000 linear feet. Or if you're from the Mammoth Track Club and Andrew, it's up 600 meters. We're also proposing to place several fitness stations along that trail.
3:25:03 And so really the goal is to include these features that will enhance the operation of the existing Whitmore Track and Sports Field, but also attract visitors from not only around the county, which we know we already see high visitation from, but clearly throughout the state and potentially from across the country. You know, there's tremendous upside here at this Whitmore Recreation Area. As we know, you know, looking forward 5, 10, 15, 20 years, this could very well be our premier.
3:25:31 A year-round recreation destination. So we really believe there's a lot of opportunity for this area. So what we're proposing in the Grand Submittal, you see a table there. We're estimating about a $2.5 million cost to build a recreation center. Pretty much a multi-purpose room space, concession, small kind of area, lockers, changing room, storage room, those type of things.
3:25:59 And a multi-use trial, Joel tells us, is probably around about $400,000 to construct with fitness stations. And then it does include some eligible grant costs and a project contingency, which kind of rounds out the $3 million. To complete the application, and I know it's, and I acknowledge the recognition that council made tonight regarding the time it takes to submit these grants. It is a lot.
3:26:29 This is a large grant. We've formed what we believe is a dynamic A-team working group, and that's from MLR with Kim, Joel. We've got Recreation Commission involved. We've got our staff, Hayes, and we're meeting on an ad hoc basis via Zoom. So we're really trying to do the best we can to kind of get this completed by November 5th, which is the deadline.
3:26:55 In the packet, there's also a letter of support from the LADWP. They've been involved with us in discussion of this project for the last year and probably two, which is kind of part of this larger discussion with the LADWP on extending our existing lease. When we installed the track in 2011, when we opened in 2012, we extended that lease to 30 years. We're now eight years into that lease.
3:27:24 So one of the requirements is for this is to have a longer term tenure as a lease. So we are pursuing a 50 year lease with LADWP with also the opportunity to acquire additional lease area. So LADWP is very supportive of that. We've provided a map. So we think we can probably acquire and roll into this new lease quite an additional amount of land down there at Whitmore.
3:27:54 Development, not only if we're successful with this grant, but just for the long-term planning of that area. So as we said, we recognize that the grant is extremely competitive, will take considerable time, but we know that this stunning track that we have, the full-size synthetic field, and the new recreation features will only further position our region as that premier high-altitude training destination for a multitude of endurance sports and recreation.
3:28:24 So that's really the staff report. There's a lot more in the staff report that I provided council. But really what we're looking for tonight is the adoption of the resolution. And that's approving the application for staff to submit the regional park program grant from the California drought, water parks, climate, coastal protection and outdoor access for all acts of 2018 or commonly called Proposition 68.
3:28:53 Mayor, I can end my presentation there. I know it's kind of a longer evening and take any questions from council. Thank you, Stu. John? Stuart, is the group looking to use the track that was locally funded and locally produced as part of the match for this effort? So there's no match required. I understand. But to say, look, we're asking you to invest in something that taxpayers voted to fund and to build and all that. I mean, I think you know what I'm getting at.
3:29:22 Yeah, I mean, that's terrific leverage, isn't it? We can already prove that this destination already attracts and meets a lot of the grant requirements. So what we're really saying is this is going to further elevate this application because we already have these features. And as you know, you know, we opened up in 2012, the funding sources were very vast, right?
3:29:49 Private funds, a lot of money was raised, $2.3 million to get this track off the ground and get it built. And this application is actually phase two slash phase three. Okay. So, you know, again, here we are 10 years later, here's an opportunity to come and complete this project for that Whitmore Recreation Area. So we're very excited. Thank you. Yeah, thanks. I'm all for it. Thank you. Thank you, John. Linda.
3:30:17 Yeah, that was a good comment there that, you know, showing that we're doing this, but we had plans to do more and this is that key to that additional plan. I think it's great. I think you could also talk about people wanting to come out and use those fitness stations who normally maybe don't already use that and that, you know, exercising at some time of the year is difficult here and that being a more conducive area to that, I think those are all great.
3:30:45 Great topics to bring up in a grant. So yeah, when is this grant due to? November 5th. Okay, she still had a little bit of time. Yeah, and one of the elements of that is community outreach. So right now we're working to get this online survey out. Hopefully Kim got it up on Mammoth Lake's recreation website, which looks fantastic. So we're hoping to get this out tomorrow because part of it again is community engagement.
3:31:12 The grant really wants to see and ensure that the public has design input. You know, I was thinking about something else briefly, but that was letters of support. I think that a letter of support from, for example, Mono County Public Health would speak to the wellness areas of it. Mono County Behavioral Health.
3:31:35 They already have sort of a wellness center and they try to do their classes and stuff. This would also be an augmentation to that. And if you could tie it up with the supportive housing component of the parcel and talk about the mobility, how that's going to be able to move people maybe from the parcel down to Whitmore for exercise and wellness. And I mean, I think you could tie in a lot of community aspects to this that may, you know, get some attention too, but that's just a thought on grant kind of philosophy, if you will.
3:32:06 Oh, they're great ideas. Thank you. I'm going to scribble those down. Okay. Good. Thanks. Yeah, but no, great. This is great. I'm glad that we're on top of it. And it feels like you pulled a great group together, so that's the way to do it. Thank you. Thank you, Linda Kirk. I support everything Linda just said. It's, yes, we need to move forward. Yes. I don't have anything. Thank you. I, too, am...
3:32:39 Happy to see this move forward. Happy to see we're finally doing some of the things we had planned down at Whitmore. And having the fitness stations down there is huge. They will be available for several months longer than they would be in Mammoth every year. Gives, you know, people in Mammoth a chance to get somewhat out of the major snow and do some exercise. So let's go. Any public comments on this, Jamie? No, there are not.
3:33:11 Thank you very much. With that, I would entertain a motion. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council adopt the resolution as presented. Is that what I'm moving? Yep. Yeah. Approve the resolution as presented. Thank you. I'll second that. I have a motion from John, a second from Linda. Any further deliberations? Seeing none, Jamie. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth?
3:33:45 Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Yes. Mayor Salzer. Yes. Passes 4-0. Thank you all very much. Moving on to item 9.4, Town Council discussion regarding development of a workshop schedule. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'll dive into this, but first of all, I want to thank our clerk for spending a lot of time putting the attachment together. Jamie did a good job in kind of outlining.
3:34:14 The various elements that are happening already through each month as we look out for the next year. And there's a potentially a substantial amount of heavy lifting in terms of working with a number of different partners as we meet and discuss and look at elements and try to move this forward. The agenda item was really prepared based on comments from council members and from our NGO partners and others.
3:34:42 That have all mentioned the desire to, hey, we need to sit down and meet with the town council. Some of the NGO discussion with MLT, for example, hey, we want to do quarterly meetings. I think MLH has made similar comments as well as MLR. Then we have other groups. Do we want to meet with the chamber? Do we want to meet with Mono County Board of Supervisors, as referenced actually in the supervisor Corliss's comments earlier. There's just a number of different
3:35:12 Groups of that nature that we have partnership with that we need to sit down and have a good open, you know, dialogue with and a good discussion and direction. And then we have a lot of topical items that have the potential to, you know, take two or three hours or four hours even working through that. And whether that's our kind of review and update or a detailed dive into the council priorities or budget.
3:35:39 To the questions that some of the items within the agenda item as we look at Major A allocations in our whole TOT function. We look at our contracts and deliverables with our partners. Do you want to look at those in context of the council direction? Each year we go through a whole issue with our airport, the operations, which is going through a significant change at this point in time.
3:36:05 Having the time to really walk through and understand those types of elements I think are very critical and important. But as we begin to look at these, it also means that you're adding an extra meeting or two every month, either separate meetings and or, you know, if they're shorter in nature, potentially building them onto your regular council meetings, which tonight be an example. We've been, you know, three and a half hours already and we've got more items to get through.
3:36:33 But thinking through that, and then also really for the council to think through what we've kind of suggested is the last Wednesday of each month is generally open without other conflicts on the agendas or the use of the room and those types of elements. If that works, does that become kind of almost a standard workshop as needed date? And then what are we missing in terms of potential projects or workshop topics?
3:37:02 What's the priority for the council so we can begin to work through this? If you have particular areas, will you really want to sit down and work through an area? And again, we probably don't have every potential area listed on here that could be a topical workshop. And then some of the topical ones would be joint. We're looking like the mobility hub study as it comes forward. That's part of a planning commission element as well. But do we do that as a joint planning commission council?
3:37:30 Taking advantage of their schedule and your schedule. For some of the other groups, it's not as bad. It's a couple times a year meetings, but for the council, you are definitely looking, if we do all of this, you'd be looking at one to two additional meetings almost every month and or an extended council meeting as part of that process. So we really wanted to lay this out as people request the idea of meeting with other groups and doing these things.
3:37:59 And also then the time that goes into it, there's just the basic agenda preparation, all of that work. But also we really do want to be able to do a good job of prepping and getting information together, laying that out. And then having enough time for the council to really have a good, hard discussion. In some cases we want to make sure, are we all on the same page or the majority of us from the council perspective moving in the same direction? And so...
3:38:26 We really was kind of struggling through how to do this. And so, you know, hats off to Jamie. I started to just do a list of groups to meet with. And she said, well, let's provide a calendar so you can see what the lifts might be. And it notes. And this is on top of your other committee assignments as you're all working with different agencies and other elements. So it's a good amount of work to be considered. But we do want to kind of open it up for discussion. We can provide a little more input here and there.
3:38:55 One of the elements is looking at a regular schedule, but also kind of the priority of topics and or groups to meet with. I think that becomes kind of critical as we look at ways to enhance our working relationships and benefits we get out of the partners we have out there. Let me pause there. I'm glad to address some detailed questions, but also really was the council's desired and
3:39:22 Adding these types of meetings, this type of workload to your own calendars as well as staff management. John. So thanks for bringing this forward. These are my priorities. I think I just throw out to the council for discussion. The first thing is our priorities to make sure we are revisiting them in a really timely way. And the second sub for that are
3:39:53 I think that's a critically important
3:40:23 Council discussion topic for us to have that's in front of us. I think also the council priorities, Dan, I think we're supposed to be revisiting those later this year, is that right? Yes. And I would be very much interested in having that discussion, especially around issues of climate change, fire, the future of Mammoth Lakes as a destination, given the environmental effects that we're all seeing. I think we need...
3:40:47 I don't know if we have to change our priorities a whole lot, but I think we need to revisit them and really establish the lens that we're looking at these things through as we then start to engage with other parties. My second tier of priorities is with those NGOs that we contract with, MLT, MLH, MLR. I don't know, maybe I'm missing something. I hope I'm not. And then after that, the priorities after that would be
3:41:15 JPAs, other authorities that we deal with. I frankly think that we could do a better job as council members reporting on what we're doing, representing the town on those bodies. I don't know if it's necessary to have joint meetings with those folks. And certainly in with the NGOs we contract with, obviously, are the commissions, the BEDC and the Rec Commission and those kinds of folks that were directly involved with policy. I hope that makes sense. I hope that was succinct. Those are my thoughts on this.
3:41:46 Thank you, John. Linda? No, I agree with John almost completely on that. I think that those are very good priorities. Just in a more global manner of having extra meetings and things. I think that our council meetings run fairly well. I mean, I think they're tight. I think the agendas are tight. I think we prepare beforehand. So some of them are just going to be longer than others. But as much as possible.
3:42:14 I wouldn't mind starting that hour extra or starting at three instead of four and trying to do as much within a council setting as possible. The priority for me, as John mentioned, are also especially working around the NGO question. You know, if we're going to make changes to MLT.
3:42:40 You know, funding formula for going to make changes to MLH, MLR. I think that that special time just doing that is going to be really beneficial. I think those are big, you know, policy and questions. And, you know, I would like to think that this council was able to help formulate a way to go forward with these NGOs.
3:43:01 You know, there's going to be changes, that they'd be sustainable, that they'd be, you know, measurable, that they'd be a way to do it into the future, not just for the next few. So that'll take a bit of work.
3:43:13 I don't know. Did you ask us to talk about personally, like, could I make these meetings? Yeah, I mean, I think it's important that we commit to this. I think I would like, like I said, I'd like to keep them as much as possible within the context of a meeting. If it's an extra meeting, then I'm fine with trying to do that, too. My only request, as always, and I think we do a good job of that, is that we have a tight agenda, that we stick to an agenda, that we don't go wandering off into flower fields left and right, because then you leave a meeting and you...
3:43:42 Don't know exactly what was accomplished, and I'd like to try to avoid that when possible. So, yeah, I think that's all I have on that. Thank you. I just left one group I don't want to leave out of this is the county. They're in there somewhere. Absolutely. Yes. Join meetings with them. Right. That's it. Sorry. Thank you. I absolutely agree that we do need to develop some workshops.
3:44:11 And in those workshops, I mean, if we're going to change some things, especially historical things that have been voted on and everything else, that we might want to shape those in order to put something on a ballot measure to shift some funding and that sort of thing. So I think it's an important conversation and an important workshop that we have. And again, look at the history and look at where we are today. Big changes.
3:44:41 Thank you. I certainly look at our town council to help guide us and tell us what really would be necessary to do some of those things. So, Andy, this may require a little bit more of your attention also. Always happy to help. I like the idea of workshops. I think that outside of just having meetings with the NGOs,
3:45:12 Because I think that most of those hook onto our council meetings fairly well. There are some who take more time, but Linda, as you said, an hour for some of those, you know, milquetoast meetings almost is adequate. However, when it comes down to measure A allocations or when it comes down to some of the other things that we deal with with our NGOs, if we're going to change how we work with them, I'd like to see a workshop format where it is council.
3:45:42 And we're not sitting, while they can always be at our meetings, we aren't actually sitting as joint meetings. We are, as a council, are hashing out what we want to see and what we want to do with each one of these NGOs. Otherwise, it just, it's not, we don't come out with a proper outcome. And from my standpoint, I would like them to be workshops where we don't actually make a decision at the workshop.
3:46:09 The question would then be at the next council meeting, which would have more people at it for us to vote on. But we can hash some of these things out as to how we're going to bring them forward to council. Mr. Mayor, let me ask you a question on that one. Would it be possible to do these things and agendize them in such a way that we could take action if we wanted to?
3:46:32 Just for efficiency sakes. We can, you know, if we have a good meeting, we have a good discussion, and we've come to consensus around something, we can take a vote and move it rather than having to just talk about it and then come back and then vote on it. And if we don't want to vote on it, we don't have to vote on it, but we just agendize it in a way that we could take action we wanted to. Yeah, absolutely, we can do that. We can do that legally as long as it's a noticed council meeting. That's my understanding anyway. Andy can speak up if it's not right. I just, yeah.
3:47:03 Yeah, that works fine. Yeah. Thank you. As far as the dates on here, yes, if we need to meet on all those dates, I will make myself available as much as possible, of course. Hopefully, as we get some of these things hashed out, the number of meetings we need to do like this will shrink, not increase to take up the whole schedule. But as far as the schedule, I have no...
3:47:31 No real issue with it, especially as long as we're all meeting in this format, which I think ends at the end of September unless something happens with the governor's orders. Yeah, I was just going to ask that. Does anybody have any insight into any of that? No, when we get to the COVID update, I'll touch on that. But the bottom line is there's just a lot of unknown. Yeah, and I don't think there will be any gnomes until after the 14th.
3:48:06 Got that right. Yeah. So, to be non-political, but I think that's just a fact. Nothing is going to be done until then. Do we have any public comment on this? No, we do not. All right. Thank you. Mayor, sorry, I didn't brief before this, but Jamie, if you want to weigh in on some of the other just logistical issues at all or anything on your end, feel free. I just...
3:48:36 I work closely with Jamie on putting agendas together and the processes and maybe it's just it's a matter of just the logistics of additional meetings and processing it and notifying, etc. But I just want to give you an opportunity. I think she's good. Okay. Linda. Mr. Mayor, yeah, I just, you know, this is also a burden on staff also.
3:49:09 I mean, you know, it's a burden on who has to be there, who has to prepare the meetings, who has to do all that. And, you know, I guess I would not want to unduly, you know, burden staff with our stuff. So, you know, whatever, whatever can be done to make it as problem free for staff as possible, I would like to do. And Linda, I agree with that. But also, I just got a little thing on my little device coming through saying that some politicians in Washington are vowing to retaliate.
3:49:40 If tech companies apply with legal subpoenas and things like this, I'm really feeling like, look, this is a small democracy in action. And I think that with all due acknowledgement to staff, everybody else, this is work that's really got to get done. Let's find the right balance. Let's not be inefficient and waste people's time. But we've got important work to do here, I would hope. And if it gets to be, you know, staff and council somehow not.
3:50:09 Making it easier than making it harder than I would expect someone to tell us. Yeah, exactly. You know, let's all work together and let's get this work done. Yeah, as we start down this program, I would expect to know what staff productivity we're losing so that we can then change our behavior to see to it that the important things get done because I do not want to overburden them. Yeah, well put. Agreed.
3:50:38 I think that, Dan, we have consensus. Do you want a motion on this? Are you good with what you've heard? I think we have direction on it. And we will look at, for longer meetings, utilizing that extra for last Wednesday of the month. And then also for shorter items or something that maybe they're more manageable, looking to where we can incorporate that with some of the regular meetings. Perfect. Thank you, Dan. Moving on then to.
3:51:09 Item 9.5, update in response to COVID-19. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. We had a couple of slides, but I think I'll just speak to this real quick. I have another item to get through. As you all know, we've been trying to give you updates. Jennifer Burroughs in the public health has been really good about putting information out to us. For example, just this evening, we got the update. We had eight cases reported in today.
3:51:40 Five were from schools and then one from the Marine Base, one from the same household of a recent positive and another Mammoth local. So we are seeing kind of a consistent caseload come in. It's down a little bit. We're hoping we're sliding maybe off the top of the curve, but it's not unusual to have those popping up at this point. We're assuming most of that is the Delta variant.
3:52:10 So we're working through that, ongoing that way and trying to manage that. We're also seeing probably about one case a week, sometimes a couple in the hospital, generally either transferred out to other treatment and or treated through the hospital and released. And so we're probably seeing more at that at this point there than we've seen historically through this pandemic.
3:52:34 And it's a mix there of visitors and locals. We'll have visitors that are reporting to the hospital testing positive and having the hospital take care of them accordingly. And so the numbers that we get reported to us are our local numbers, people who are residents of Mono County. We actually end up with more positives from a testing standpoint, a lot of those being visitors, though, or being out of the area. So that's an area we're watching as well.
3:53:04 Having the impact on the schools was something I think we looked at and expected. We know it's creating some challenges with students and parents and quarantining kids out and those types of elements. I believe just the middle school here, or sorry, the elementary school has 66 kids quarantined today because of the positives at the school. We've had kids and teachers show up positive.
3:53:32 Especially at the elementary school where those kids are not eligible for vaccination. And so we're still pushing on that. I think we're pushing 70% fully vaccinated in the county and about 73% or 74% or better with at least one dose. We're getting that vaccine out there. We've been doing a lot of testing outside of Mammoth. Optum Service is still here. We had a hiccup with them working in Bishop here this last week. Hopefully that gets squared away.
3:54:02 Public Health, for example, did a number of testing Colville today, 108 of them with PCRs. Basically, they tested the whole school to go through that and some of the families there. So really trying to identify those clusters where we see it. We are seeing a lot of it come out of families. If a parent test, you go back in, you hit the family.
3:54:25 We do that. We're also doing rapid tests on a lot of those, and a lot of those that test positive are not going back and getting a formal PCR test. So that'll skew the numbers a little bit as well, but we're looking at those. And so we're seeing that continually bump up over time. If you go on the website, you'll see that where it's going up. We're continuing to do the walk-in vaccines, walk-in testing, and really pushing that out still.
3:54:51 It'll be interesting to see if we see a decline a little bit with the closure of the forest and we'll expect to be a little smaller visitor base coming to the community if we see kind of a drop off in transmission in that area. The EOC is still meeting weekly. We'll do it on Monday, so we'll miss next week unless we need to get together. Looking at different avenues staying on top of what's going on. The 211 line has been reestablished for people to call.
3:55:21 And then pushing again, really still trying to push on the vaccination and the testing side. If you're not feeling well, get checked so we know. The worst thing you can do is not think you're ill in the variant and just in terms of the contagiousness of it. And you end up spreading a lot and somebody will be really sick and then it's a tracking back process. The other thing we're seeing is on that.
3:55:46 Definitely the contagious side, we do have some breakthrough cases. Again, we've had another couple the last week or so, one in different places. So people who are fully vaccinated getting that. But again, as we've said, and here in the regular media out there, the cases that people are getting if they've been vaccinated are non-symptomatic or very mild symptoms.
3:56:15 There's probably been some, but very few who actually end up sick enough to be hospitalized, and obviously we're not seeing near-the-death component related to people who are vaccinated. This really has been a shift in the pandemic to the unvaccinated, so we've been driving that message out there. The other element that we're watching here in California and a broader issue, we are seeing some spikes in other rural communities that are also having hospitals impacted.
3:56:42 Some of our neighboring hospitals that we transferred people to have also been impacted that has limited some of the transfer capability. We had one person that took, I think it was two or three days to find a place for them to actually be transferred to. It was a visitor that our hospital was treating. So we're watching that regional and localized impact on the medical system. We're seeing that happen. And given all that, the other real unknown is
3:57:11 We don't have any statewide mandates coming out that we're aware of, such as the stay-at-home orders and those elements. There is definitely an ongoing debate over the requirement of vaccination for schools from elementary or age-appropriate on up through the colleges. Different workplaces have stepped in and wanting to do mandated vaccinations or in lieu of that, mandated testing.
3:57:41 We haven't made that shift that way here with the town yet. We have a large number of our employees have been vaccinated. We've been continuing to push that. Some areas not as strong as others in terms of departments. But pushing through that, we'll be taking a look at that. We've been encouraging people to continue to be tested, and we do have that happening. So we want to continue to drive that from the town side that we're working through. It's going to be...
3:58:10 And we'll see what happens the next few months as flu season kicks in. You'll see the advertisements already, get your flu shot. So start thinking through that as well. And as winter comes, more indoor activity, do we see this kind of level off or do we see a bump up again? So those are all unknowns. And as far as the governor's executive orders, as we asked the question earlier, trying to watch that, check the CDPH site, et cetera, we haven't seen any indication.
3:58:39 The extension of those executive orders which allow for the Zoom type meetings and other things of that nature. So that right now is just a big unknown and probably will be for another couple of weeks. Glad to answer any questions there. I think I hit on the major items there. The other, I guess the other couple elements, my notes was we are seeing all ages. We had a report out, I think it was in Bishop, of a nine-month-old on up to somebody who's in their 60s, 70s on up.
3:59:08 Who are getting sick. So this is not a age respecter or a health respecter almost type disease is the types of folks we're seeing impacted and happening there. So, and again, as I mentioned, that mix between locals and visitors who are being tested here in Mammoth and turning a positive. With that, let me pause there if there's a particular questions or Linda, you've been on some of our EOC meetings and department meetings. If you want to add to that as well.
3:59:37 No, I think you recapped it really well, Dan. One thing I will add, though, there's a, you know, pretty vigorous conversation going on at the state level around how to roll out the third vaccine as well as the flu vaccine. So far, we know this. They can be given at the same time. We were talking about whether that would be best to do with a drive-thru clinic or stationary clinics. Again, I think we kind of came around to
4:00:05 More of a stationary clinic, given the weather, you know, that will start coming at us, we hope, soon here. And so, you know, what is the capacity of a health department like public health in Mono County to ramp up again to the level that they were at at the beginning of the vaccine last, which, I don't know, when it was again, whenever that was, you know, about eight months ago is when it was.
4:00:32 So, you know, the people that were vaccinated in December and January would be just about up for a third vaccine, especially if they were in the immunocompromised category. So there's a lot of discussion about that and what would be the real capacity, you know, how much more would we depend and push it on to pharmacies and on to, you know, maybe the hospital for their own.
4:00:59 They have patients that are in there anyway for an appointment perhaps. So we're still waiting for a little bit more guidance from the state to give information and sort of understanding what their capacity would be like. The state has now, they're stopping the OptumServe program, the testing program, end of September officially, but then they're going to push a little bit further.
4:01:25 That was the ability of a county in a surge to say, okay, we can't handle all this. You go ahead and do this. Well, the state just canceled out of that contract. So they basically said, well, you know, your county's free to contract on it. So I was like, whoa, wait, wait a second. So we were hoping that the state doesn't back out on a lot of their other helpful things that they decided. So there's just that going on. So stand by for that of when those clinics will be. In the meantime, there's a clinic Friday for a regular vaccine at Mammoth High School.
4:01:55 So, yeah, I'll keep you posted as we know, but that's sort of what that is. A lot of cases, you know, we've had, you know, fatal fatalities that were not our county residents, but who came through, you know, Mammoth and were transferred. So, you know, there's people that are really sick. And yeah, in fact, it feels like more hospitalization than we had before. So this Delta virus is not kind, not a nice virus. You do not want it. That's it. Thank you, Linda.
4:02:27 Questions or comments? Just go ahead and... Dan, quickly, we did a very well-coordinated program with Mammoth Resorts last year. It's probably too early, but we don't have any insight into those kinds of protocols or what their programs will look like. None of that yet, right? We do not at this point. And a lot of that was through the mandates and stuff. What they do voluntarily will depend on, I think, the level of...
4:02:58 Okay. All right. Thanks. Any other questions or comments from Council? I've seen none. Thank you, Linda and Dan both. Moving on to 9.6. Approved Town of Mammoth Lake's response to the 2020-21 Grand Jury Workforce Housing Crisis Final Report.
4:03:32 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'm going to set the stage for this with just a little bit of a review of what the grand jury is all about. Then I imagine that Sandra and Nolan will get into the details of the report. So as everyone will remember, the grand juries exist in every county and they're authorized to report on the functions and workings of local governments, both cities and counties and special districts. And so they get to decide whatever they think is interesting enough to look into. They can't make anyone do anything. That's something that
4:04:01 Even sometimes grand juries themselves get a little confused about, but they don't have any authority to do to require anything. They just get to look at whatever they want. They can interview people. So when you get a grand jury report, a city has 90 days from the date of the report to respond to it. And the response has to come from the city council or town council. Grand jury reports usually have findings and recommendations. For each finding, we're required to say whether we agree with the finding.
4:04:28 Completely disagree with the finding and why, or partly agree with the finding and partly disagree and then explain what we disagree with. For the recommendations, we're required to either say that they've already been implemented, they won't be implemented ever because they're not reasonable or not warranted and we have to explain why, or that they will be implemented at some point in the future and we have to explain when, or that we're still kind of studying the recommendation and so we'll get back to them no more than six months later.
4:04:57 So that's what it is. So the draft response to the grand jury has been set up, and Nolan and Sandra can explain this in more detail, has been set up to kind of explain for each finding whether we agree with it or not and why, and for each recommendation whether we will implement it or not and why. And as we go through, I think that it's staff's view that the grand jury may not have entirely understood some of the facts and some of the issues they were reporting on.
4:05:26 Thank you, Andy. One of the key elements of the grand jury in this round, what they've been doing is they actually released
4:05:57 Three separate reports on topics. So the first one here is housing. We'll have a second one on broadband and a third one related to the drainage in the trails. The housing one, there's a number of findings in there. We do make a response to each of those and walk through those, as Andy mentioned. I want to get a couple examples and maybe open it for questions versus rereading the letter to each of you, but we want to make sure you're comfortable with the recommendations.
4:06:26 But like in the very first one, an F1-T, finding number one for the town, talks about our housing elements. And on this one, you'll see that we wholly disagree with the finding. We think they really missed the element of what the housing element is and the requirements of it. And a lot of that goes to the discussion we had recently this evening in the chat of what arena is and what it means in terms of available land versus actual housing construction, those types of elements.
4:06:53 Others in these we will note that whether we partially agree and walk through why we partially agree and why we partially don't agree. So before I turn it to Sandra and or with Nolan who's spent a lot of time pulling these together, I'd like to ask just to counsel if there's a couple of these areas where you have specific questions, glad to address those in detail versus
4:07:20 We don't necessarily probably need to re-read to you all of the information that we put in there. We did attach a copy of the actual grand jury report, so you have that, and then it's page 214 of the packet, begins the actual letter that we would want an action on, authorizing the mayor to sign that letter and to submit it to the grand jury.
4:07:43 The 90-day timeline is very tight, so if there's some edits, we can make those this evening, but we don't have a lot of time to bring it back to you at your next meeting, for example, for the 90-day timeframe. So if that's fine with the council, Mr. Mayor, if there are particular responses that have questions or there's elements that you want more understanding on, if we could do that first, it may save some time. If you're very comfortable with the response, that's fine too.
4:08:12 I'm assuming you've all had a chance to read it and previously and again for the meeting of being able to review the grand jury report itself. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. So let's go to counsel for comments or questions then, John. I don't have any comments or questions. I think staff is basically getting all this right, so I'm good with the work that staff has done at this point. Thank you, John. Linda?
4:08:41 Yeah, I'm sorry, I lost a little bit there. I had to reboot my computer, so I didn't hear everything, but I assume that Andy explained what our role was in this and why we had to do it. So, yeah, I read it pretty carefully. I don't have any additional comments, I don't think. Thank you, Linda Kirk. I have no comments. Thank you. Thank you. As for me, reading through both the report and the response, you did a good job at the response.
4:09:12 I've been much more critical than staff was in coming back to this because it was clear to me that the grand jury didn't understand several different facets, including the difference between 1.1% because one point is actually 7% or plus, you know, give or take. There were several areas in our response where you were very kind and said we partially agree or I probably would not have, but at this point I wouldn't ask for any changes made. I think that the...
4:09:42 The response is adequate. And I'll hold public comment until if Nolan and Sandra wish to. I just wanted to thank Nolan for putting all this together. This took a lot of time and effort, and I think it shows in here. So thanks, Nolan, for putting all this together for us. Okay. Seeing no other questions, I go to public. Any public comment or questions on this? No, there are not. Thank you. That being said,
4:10:19 I would take a motion. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve the Town of Mammoth Lake's response to the 2020-21 Grand Jury Workforce Housing Crisis Final Report. Thank you, John. I'll second that. I have a motion from John, a second from Linda. Any further deliberations? Seeing none, I'll call for the question. Jamie? Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes.
4:11:01 Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Passes 4-0. Thank you all very much. Again, Nolan, job well done. Before we get on to the next agenda item, I'm going to stick one in here. I want to say to Sandra, happy 15th anniversary. She has been with us for 15 years. I don't have the certificate in my hand.
4:11:33 Thank you. Thank you. Yes, that's a huge milestone. Thank you. It's been a pleasure to serve for these years and had a lot of really great times, great projects, and a lot of great people to work with. So I'm happy to be here and happy to make that milestone. So thank you. Well, hopefully we'll enjoy you for another great 15 years. Hopefully. Yeah.
4:12:06 Okay, with that, I will go on to Councilmember Reports, starting with John. Mr. Mayor, on Tuesday, August 24th, I was back east visiting my aging father. I had an opportunity to meet with Congressman Obernolte and some folks from his staff.
4:12:25 Following up on a meeting that I have with Supervisor Kreitz, Patricia Robertson, we talked about housing, we talked about administrative sites and the opportunities to do some work with that that's been identified in the chat. They seem very enthusiastic to write letters of support and help us out. We shall see. But I know that he was in town today and scheduled a coffee at five o'clock this evening. I'm not quite sure how that works.
4:12:55 They're there, and they say they want help, so let's see what we can do to hold them to it and make sure they do, in fact, help us. And that's all I have to report. Thank you. Thank you, John. And Linda? It was quiet. I don't think I have anything to report on town council, so nothing. Thank you. Kirk? I have nothing to report on Mammoth Lake Housing or ESTA other than, you know, the ridership is down a little bit, so that's all.
4:13:26 The only thing I have to report is not going to an ESTA meeting, but ESTA has canceled its September, what was it, September 10th report meeting. So, yes, Dan. Yeah, I would like to note, it's kind of for the record, but with ESTA, they're another partner we're working with in this whole forest closure. They are doing some work with us up to the, I think we mentioned it early on, but just to note that as these things happen, we get a hold of Phil.
4:13:57 The director there. So we'll be running a trolley somewhere up to the basin so we can pull people down if they're up there hiking out. Some may go up and drop. And then also in the Reds Meadow, not taking people in, but definitely we have PCT or John Muir folks coming across and coming in through hikers, helping them get out of those areas. And so it's been a really good partnership making that work. As Kirk noted, some of the ridership had been down. It started to come back up.
4:14:26 Expecting to have to extend out the lake space and trolley through this weekend and even through next weekend. Obviously, that's not happening at this point. So we'll be saving a little dollars, I guess, that way. But I just note that for ESTA, I know they canceled their meeting, but when you get back there, you can pass that on to the full board that their cooperation in a lot of these moving target crisis elements have really been appreciated and very helpful.
4:14:57 Thank you, Dan. Yeah, John? And one last thing. My fellow council members, you may be getting things in your email box from Microsoft that says something to the effect of my analytics. I don't know if you've seen those things.
4:15:13 I clicked on mine the other day. This is related, I believe, to our Town of Mammoth Lake's email accounts. And the report I got was pretty disturbing. There were a lot of contacts and emails and networks that they described for me that's not town business. It has to do with my work accounts, even some of my personal accounts. And I've asked Dan to look into this. It's not one of those happy technology stories.
4:15:42 So I would encourage you, if you get it, if you see it, click on it, look in there, look at what it's tracking. It tells you how much time it thinks you're spending with people. I'm frankly really kind of concerned about this from a privacy perspective. Andy, this is maybe something I would like you to just maybe look into a little bit. This is not public record stuff. This is some big tech thing that's going on that's got nothing to do with public records requests or anything else. And frankly, it's kind of disturbing. I hope we can look into this and see what's going on with this thing.
4:16:10 So again, it's Microsoft, My Analytics, just saying. Thank you. Thank you, John. And I want to thank you all. Tonight's meeting went just about perfect. A way to stick to task and stay on board. I'm always happy with that. So unless somebody else from staff or council has something they want to get across, I will bid you all adieu and adjourn this meeting. Bye, y'all. Take care. Bye, everybody. Thank you.