TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2025

Planning & Economic Development Commission

at 09:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

236 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:34 So I'm just wanted to just let it go. I figure there's a lot of people with stronger opinions about the whole process of opening houses in town. Some of the hurdles they face from staff, some of the hurdles they face from.

1:54 Well, yeah. And frankly, it's like, is there any way that we can start funding a new business? Like if there's a new restaurant that comes to town, can we give them, you know, give them the whole money?

2:23 Yeah, and I don't, to be honest, I don't, I'm not taking it in a position in any position in my arm. I don't know if the town's role is to be a venture capitalist.

2:52 I think the town's role is to facilitate the administrative process. That's just me from the outside looking at.

3:22 Hey, Jamie, I've got nine. I've got a quorum. Brianna, we've got a quorum. It's nine o'clock. Are you good to go? Okay. Well, good morning, everyone. If you wouldn't mind taking a seat, I'd like to...

3:50 Get this meeting going. I want to respect everyone's time. So I would like to call to order today's Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting, which is Wednesday, April 9th at 9 a.m. I believe. Before we get to the workshop, we do have a little bit of administrative stuff. Jamie, would you please call roll? Commissioner Fleming? Here. Commissioner Grant is absent. Vice Chair Verruck? Here. Chair Vanderhurst? Here. Thank you, Jamie.

4:20 With that, would everyone please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance, and would Mr. Urdi lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance of the United States of America, and to the republic in which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, John. With that, I'd like to open up public comment. I will ask if anybody has public comment on an item that pertains to today's agenda, that they wait until that agenda item has been opened.

4:54 If not, if there's public comment otherwise that somebody would like to give, either from a staff level or please approach the podium. Good morning. Haislip Hayes, Director of Public Works. I'd like to talk to you about the 2024 Multi-Jurisdictional Hazard Mitigation Plan. This plan is being updated to include the most current information on the risks and vulnerabilities of multiple hazards affecting the town and county.

5:23 As well as new specific mitigation strategies and actions that will reduce or eliminate those risks or vulnerabilities. This project comes to us through a grant from FEMA and the California Office of Emergency Services. And this update will cover both the town and the entirety of the county, ensuring eligibility for hazard mitigation funds made available through FEMA.

5:49 Increasing public awareness and understanding of vulnerabilities as well as support for specific actions to reduce losses from future disasters, ensuring community policies, programs, and goals are compatible with reducing vulnerabilities to all hazards, and building partnerships and diverse stakeholders in increasing opportunities to leverage data and resources. The consultants would like to hear from the community. They've got these flyers all over town. It's been on a bunch of websites.

6:15 We'll have some flyers in the back, but we encourage everybody to take this survey, answer the questions, let us know your comments, your concerns, issues you have, and kind of your feelings about how we're handling hazard mitigation throughout the town and county. That's all I have. Thank you, Hayes. Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? No. We do not. Let's see. We have a door opening here. Might be last-minute public comment.

6:43 It is not. Then I will close public comment and we will go to the workshop. Item 4.1 is a workshop with the Planning and Economic Development Commission and the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce Board of Directors. First of all, I'd like to thank everyone for taking the time this morning to attend this workshop. Staff as well, thank you for taking the time, guys. I'm going to pass it off mainly to Nolan to tee this one up. I kind of got together with Brianna.

7:13 to brainstorm on putting this workshop in place to give everyone in the business community a chance to have an open and positive dialogue with town staff about maybe some of the challenges they've faced in the past in opening businesses or maybe some of the wins they've had in the past with the town and opening a business or any creative suggestions you may have that you'd like to maybe float amongst.

7:41 The Economic Development Commission as well as town staff. So I am definitely going to take a back seat on this conversation, but I look forward to a lively discussion. So with that, Nolan, I'll pass it off to you, my friend. Great, thank you. So this workshop really came together with some comments made at the strategic planning for Mammoth Lakes Tourism and a desire to have a workshop between the Planning and Economic Development Commission really looking...

8:08 As they wear their economic development hats and the Chamber of Commerce Board. So we put together kind of a, you know, rough agenda with some just discussion topics. Really, we're looking at this to be a discussion with the board and the commissioners and kind of a dialogue with any, you know, urging or nudging from Brianna or I just to keep the conversation going.

8:33 So with that, we would like to just do a quick round of introductions so that everyone knows who's here. So I'll start. Nolan Vavaroff, Community and Economic Development Director. Donna Verute, I sit on the Planning and Economic Development Commission. Cynthia Fleming, I sit on the Planning and Economic Development Commission. Michael Vanderhurst, I also sit on the Planning and Economic Development Commission. Gina Van Hesse, the Communications Manager, Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. Tom Parker, Board, Chamber of Commerce.

9:06 David Eichmann, Appleby, Interim Director, taking over for Brianna. Thank you. And real quick, if the people that are business affiliated can also, I mean, I think we all know Tom, but if you could also say what business you are with, that would be great. And if you could turn on your mics when you talk. Oh yeah, that too. Sorry. John Urdi, President, CEO of Mammoth Lakes Tourism, also Chamber Board Member. Wyatt Simmons, Chamber Board Member, owner of Mammoth Lakes Longermat. Brianna Aguaco, Chamber of Commerce.

9:36 Elise Mocha Harper, Chairperson for the Board for the Chamber and also Warming Hut Restaurant. Sonia Bush, Board Member and Owner of Destination Real Estate. Luan Mendel, Chamber Board Member and Devil's Creek Distillery Owner and Operator. Good morning. Todd Roberts, Board Member, General Manager, Holly Haas, Edelweiss Lodge and Modern Hospital. Noam, I think we have two participants online as well. Would those online like just...

10:09 Go ahead, sir. We can hear you. I'll start. Carrie Peterson, Chamber Board Treasurer and owner of Systems Process People. And I'm Robert Brunfield. I've been the general counsel to the chamber since, I think, 2018. You can always measure it when Jerry Moen got appointed to be a judge. So that's about when I became general counsel. And I have a part-time office in Mammoth and the rest of my times in Southern California for my law office. Thank you. All right, Nolan. Great.

10:40 First topic on here as we listen on the agenda is what assistance or resources can the Planning and Economic Development Commission provide to the business community? Just kind of a brief summary of the role of the PEDC. Their duties include updating and implementing the general plan. Includes any revisions or future updates to that. They also...

11:07 We provide an annual review of the capital improvement program to determine if it's consistent with the general plan. The kind of larger role they take is considering in any entitlement applications, so that's any development applications that come forward for whether it be new hospitality projects or new retail or new residential. Those come before the PEDC and then for

11:32 larger kind of legislative actions, that would be zoning code amendments or others, they provide, then are tasked with providing a recommendation to the town council on how to move that forward. So that's just kind of a, like I said, real high level overview of what they do. So really like to open it up to the group here as to kind of what assistance or resources can they provide, what has been helpful, what was missing or that you would be looking to the

11:59 PEDC for on any assistance. So just a quick thought from me as the chair. Our responsibilities seem to be rather heavy on the Planning Commission side of our mandate and light on economic development side of our mandate. And I would like to counterbalance that a little bit and see how this commission and with the help of staff can...

12:26 Find avenues and pathways to help facilitate the business community, whether they're opening more businesses, new businesses, expanding, or any of the above. So, I'll start. Unfortunately, it's really hard to talk about growing business right now when people are struggling so hard to employ, to get employees. It all goes back to housing, right? It's like a broken record.

12:53 Almost every business owner I know in this town is struggling to get employees because there's no place for them to live. So I really feel like it all boils back to housing, like that's our main issue right now. So it would be cool if this is appropriate to get an update on the parcel and placemates and just kind of the housing now in general. Sure. So the parcel, so phase one was completed last September and they began leasing up then. They did fill all 81 units.

13:24 By December, so about a three-month lease-up to fill the initial 80 affordable units and the manager's unit there. So those are staying completely full. And going forward, we're getting towards spring. They should be mobilizing back on the site to continue the grading and construction work for phase two. We'll call it 2A or Kingfisher 2.1. That initial phase will be 76 units.

13:52 And we do anticipate that those will be vertical by the end of summer. So they'll have the foundations done. It's a modular construction again. So that's kind of what they've committed to. It is roughly from last summer anticipated to be about a 24-month build or about a two-year construction period. So we would be looking at a round of probably, I'd say fall of 2026 completion for those.

14:19 As far as placemates, the program is ongoing. They initially had a kind of a one-year pilot project window with enough funding, which we estimate to provide about a subsidy for roughly 40 households. There are up to six completed leases. And then they have kind of what they say is in the pipeline of those that are

14:46 Kind of interested. They think some of the difficulties was they launched, right, roughly kind of beginning the ski season. So a lot of people have already had commitments for kind of the ski season, either short-term rental leasings on the books or other commitments. So they didn't want to necessarily enter into a lease at that point. But they do have about, I think, 15 to 20 that were interested in starting leases between May and August. So we're hopeful to kind of see a pickup and

15:16 The interest there, we also just had a recent kind of marketing push with them to get more information out to the community via social media and other channels in the last few weeks to get additional information out there on that. The program can provide up to $18,000 subsidy if you lease your unit for a year, I think, with four individuals, and then that subsidy kind of, it's scaled based on how many qualified tenants and the length of the lease it is. So that program is ongoing.

15:46 We will kind of see as we get closer into May and June as to kind of the interest and whether it's starting to pick up momentum or not. And then kind of on the other side, just the general housing now, our 60 Joaquin project is nearing completion. We're in the, that's the town development of four units. There'll be ownership units. We're in the kind of cleanup or pickup stage with the developer of walking through as the owner.

16:14 identifying any things we want them to fix before we go out for marketing with those units. We anticipate that happening potentially even this week, if not next week, going hopefully live with the interest list on those. And then kind of looking to the future, we're really looking at, you know, where we move and put our kind of interest in, whether it's focusing on phase three of the parcel, which is anticipated to be an ownership phase, kind of moving that forward.

16:43 Or on some of our other small sites in the community, whether to focus on those. So we're kind of in the planning stage for what we put our efforts into next on that side. Well, I just want to interject. The social media advertising works. I've had several clients call and ask about it. And I know there's three or four that are exactly what you're saying. They're waiting for their winter revenue. Great. That's good. Great to hear. Yeah, we had kind of a...

17:09 Coordinated effort between the town, social media, and then placemates, reached out to Joseph Bogorod and did a kind of a video highlight piece from his and then some print media around town as well. So the hope is just to, yeah, that kind of the word out that this program exists and hope is, yeah, that it does become successful.

17:34 Nolan, what's the projected AMI on the next 76 units? So with the parcel and the funding that exists because it's tax credit funding, it's very restricted to 80% AMI and below with a kind of mix of units at 30, 50, 60, and 80%. What was the AMI projected for the Joaquin project, Nolan? So that we're looking to target between 150 to 200% AMI. Got it.

18:06 And how about if you guys do decide to put your resources towards phase three of the parcel that has the potential to be private ownership, is there an AMI component to that? There will. So the parcel master plan allows up to 200% AMI on the ownership for 15% of the total number of units allowed in the master plan, so it allows 85% of the units have to be below

18:35 Got it. Thank you.

19:07 Do you have a forecasted metric on how many units we really need in town based off of our growth and where we are? So we had a housing needs assessment completed in 2017 that said we needed 595 units and then it further broke that down as how many affordable kind of below 80 percent, how many above 80 percent, how many rental and how many ownership and then

19:35 We, you know, haven't had any recent updates to that study as we started providing units. So we just kicked off last year an update to the housing needs assessment. We are doing it as a regional housing needs assessment with Mono County, Inyo County, and City of Bishop. So the four entities looking at kind of the region as a whole, but then with focused information and data on all four of the regions. We had

20:01 Initial workshop about two months ago is kind of the kickoff for that. They are getting ready to launch here in the, I'd say in the next two weeks, two different surveys, one that's going to be focused on kind of at the individual household level, so reaching out, trying to get information on household level, on what their needs are, what their issues are, what their kind of incomes, various information to inform, and then

20:27 A separate survey that's targeted towards employers specifically. So reaching out to the employers region-wide to get feedback on housing, their challenges and areas of that. So that we anticipate going live here in the next two weeks. It'll definitely be a big kind of blast out of information to get participation in that survey. We anticipate that kind of

20:53 Whole assessment wrapping up here in the fall of 2025 with the draft report going out. And really we're looking to that to say what is our needs across the level, like, you know, across the span of affordability and what types of housing we need, where we should be focusing our efforts on. Because the kind of other level of report, which is the state has a regional housing needs allocation arena.

21:21 It's tied in with the housing element cycle, so it's kind of, right now it's on an eight year cycle from 2019 to 2027. But that number, that's what the state has said we need to kind of develop based on our population trends, but we also know that number is woefully low. It said we need like 160 units to basically satisfy our whole needs for the community.

21:50 We've exceeded that in every category except the 120% AMI level as far as with just the parcel and some of the partnership projects with Mammoth Lakes or Eastern Sierra Community Housing, but we also see that the need still exists in the community for more kind of housing across the spectrum of affordability is what we hear from employers. So we know that that number isn't necessarily accurate, so we're really looking towards that update to the housing needs assessment to provide really good detailed data.

22:19 Basically from the state, not from local data? That's what the state uses. That number, like I said, we track it as far as, you know, what we're kind of hitting to show the state that we're building units and what they've said we needed to do, but we also know that number is not really indicative of the actual need here. So right now we're still looking to that 2017 numbers, kind of using that as the baseline with the hope that this new study will really provide much more, at least

22:50 Newer information or more recent data as we then project and kind of plan for the future on what projects we're focusing on. And the needs assessment, is that being led by Elaine Kavala with SCOG? So SCOG is kind of providing technical assistance on it. It's not being done directly under SCOG. We have a MOU between

23:16 with Inyo County and the four entities. It's BAE is the consultant working on the study. They assisted the town in Mono County on the STR study that was done during the moratoriums. They're kind of an economist consultant, so they look at it like really from a kind of they bring in the planning perspective as well as the numbers perspective into the studies to provide that kind of

23:45 Statistical analysis of what we need. So sticking with that theme of assessment, but kind of returning to Michael's point, is there any kind of assessment done by the Commission about what kinds of businesses might be needed or desirable in our community? Because

24:05 I think that we can say there are some fairly large gaps. Certainly one of them I think is restaurants and another is retail. So I'm just curious if you guys have some kind of assessment on that. Not to my knowledge. Nothing formalized. I mean, I, you know, the planning department, I mean, I don't know how many people were here back in 2005, 2006, but, and I don't recall the why.

24:34 But it was just a planning, it was a planning department planning commission, and then in 2005, 6, 7, something like that, the name was changed to encompass the economic development. Now, like I said, I don't know the history, I don't know, I don't recall why that was, I don't recall what the intent for this, for that change was, I don't even know what the, if there was ever

25:04 Some sort of specific purview that was given to both the town department as well as the planning commission. So it's kind of an interesting thing because I don't know and I don't know that there's anybody here that was here then that can even answer those questions. But at the time I found it odd because while I think it's important planning department and the economic development department can, there is some overlap.

25:34 I don't see that that's necessarily the purview. I'm not saying that we shouldn't be trying to engage with people to open businesses, but having had a retail business in this town for 12 years, 13 years, brick and mortar is very, very challenging.

25:55 And I'm happy to not be in that business anymore, quite honestly. I mean, it was very fun, it was very social, I really enjoyed it, but it's a completely different animal than it was. And I'm not saying that we shouldn't encourage people to try and establish a retail business, but it's very challenging. And I don't know that, I mean, I am a business owner in town and I know my business, but I don't know restaurants.

26:23 I don't know, I don't know what other, you know, businesses do and how they can succeed and prosper per se. You know, to Lisa's point, yeah, I mean, employees, I mean, being in construction, which I am, it's challenging finding, I mean, I mean, we just need a body at this point. I mean, that's it. I mean, we just need somebody that can breathe and show up and is there and it's challenging to find those people and everybody in this,

26:53 And this room is dealing with that challenge, I'm sure. That's helpful, because in my mind, I thought, when I saw economic, you know, I thought the idea was exactly what you said, identify gaps and then help build along with the chamber. So I think that's what we were looking to learn more about, right? I think this could be the first step in that process, but I think it's pretty important that we identify roles.

27:20 Is the town going to be in the business of venture capital funding? Probably not. But the town could help administrative in terms of the administrative process and permitting and all that kind of stuff. Is our job to identify, you know, hey, we need a French restaurant? I don't know if that's our lane, to be honest with you. I mean, I'm a free market person. Like, I definitely believe in capitalism and free market economy.

27:49 If there's a need, it'll be met if there's a way. Now, we have some hurdles that we're up against that we all can agree on, right? Like housing, employees, lack of employees. I think we can also acknowledge that the town is making motions to alleviate some of those problems. I mean, it may not be as fast as we would all like, but the town is moving. And we just have to keep in mind that there's always a rate of speed difference between the private and the public sector.

28:19 And the public sector has got some constraints that they have to work within. And they are moving as quick as they can in the housing. They hear you guys loud and clear. But, you know, I would love to hear if there's some other issues besides housing. We all agree housing's the number one. But, like, are there some other things you guys would like to talk about for this next hour while you have, you know, the executive team here from the town? Let me ask one question. So just when we're talking about new businesses,

28:49 And I'll use Slocum's as an example. Why is Slocum still empty? Did it go through Rescaro? Are the owners not willing to put the money into it? Are the construction costs too high? Can't they find staff? That's a building that's right on Main Street. It's a massive facility. Why is that building still empty? I mean, I showed it to a restaurant owner a year ago. He owns four restaurants in Reno, and he would be a great person to have here. And once we walked the property with a contractor, I mean...

29:18 The amount of money it was going to take to rehab it was, it just didn't pencil, between buying the property, you know, and the TIs, and it was practically, you know, between the electrical and the plumbing and, you know, everything else, it just didn't pencil.

29:29 But, you know, my question, I mean, listen, I own a property management company here of, you know, 100 Airbnb's I manage, I sell a fair amount of real estate, so I have a lot of, you know, clients that I communicate with constantly, and they love Mammoth, and their biggest complaint is that, well, gee, I could buy a property in Mammoth, or I could buy a property in Park City, and I can get to Park City in the same amount of time it takes me to drive here, and Park City just offers so much more. You know, they have...

29:55 You know, so many great restaurants and bars and shopping. And so, you know, my question to MLT is, gosh, you guys spend millions of dollars in marketing. You do such a great job bringing people here. But at what point, who is responsible for the guest experience? Because the guest experience here just stinks. And, I mean, there's nowhere to eat. You know, the grocery store runs out of food constantly. So is there an option financially, and I don't even know the legalities behind it, to where, like, you know, the town or MLT can contribute, like,

30:24 Some rents to open up a restaurant, like TIs to help the guy that buys slocums to remodel it. Like, you know, what can we do to tap into some resources to get the ball rolling to, you know, open up some businesses here? So, but I just, I don't know the legality is behind that, but I mean, is that an option? Probably not. Yeah. Well, I think the answer is nobody owns this issue. What's that? I mean, nobody really owns this. We're all like wanting that. Everybody, I think we're all in agreement. We want this, but no one owns it. So who should own it and how does that look?

30:54 But it's my understanding that Slocum's is actually in escrow, and I don't, Matthew Lehman, I think, has it in escrow, and I haven't talked to him a couple weeks, but it looked like it was moving forward, and prior to that, I think it was just, he did bring a couple offers, and there was just issues or concerns with the current owner, and that's, you know, but again, you know, to your point, I mean, buildings, I mean, we do have a code.

31:18 And I don't know, I don't recall what the date, what the timing is, but when a building is vacant, it's supposed to be abated, correct? In a certain time period? Well, think of La Sierra. La Sierra is a perfect example. Correct, La Sierra, and then the corners with the hotel. Yeah, so we have, it's not so much a vacant building, it's more based on the condition of the building. So if it's in a, becomes a nuisance or is a hazard to the community, so if it caves in or is in a

31:47 Condition that's a risk, and then we can step into forest abatement through different channels or different tools. So that's what we did with encourage the owners of Los Angeles to demo that building, same with when the structure collapsed on Minaret and the structure collapsed on Forest Trail. Stepped in to force them to remove those. If it's in a semi-habitable condition, then it's a lot harder to

32:19 Force them to tear it down or do anything with it. So I think of Slocums, I also think of the Sierra Center Mall and how long that has been in development, sitting empty, businesses being asked to leave because it was going to be developed, then it not get developed. So is there any way to encourage these owners to move forward more quickly or discourage them for leaving it vacant for so long? Their permit's open.

32:45 Yeah, so across the street at Sierra Center Mall, they do have an approved entitlement to convert that to a hotel, and they also have an issued building permit to begin the work on that site. Once the permit's issued, they have roughly 180 days to basically kind of make progress to keep their building permit active, so that deadline is coming up here in, I believe, I want to say the end of June, as far as they need to kind of...

33:15 begin those motions to do something with that site, or they risk their building permit expiring and then it doesn't still force them to do something with it, but if they do want to then move forward with that, they'd have to reapply and update all their plans to current code cycles. So there's definitely an incentive. They are serious about moving that project forward to begin here soon. The worst case scenario in that example is

33:44 There is a pathway to slow walk that development to keep your permits valid. And that is probably what I would personally view as the worst case scenario. Yeah. I mean, I feel like that's what we're seeing, isn't it? I don't think I've done anything. Yeah. No, I think, yeah. And to Michael's point, you know, I think Mammoth Creek Inn is kind of an example of someone that slow walked the development process very much so throughout that build.

34:13 So I guess what I'm asking is, is there a way for you guys to, you know, come up with some sort of penalty for slow walking or incentive to move forward more quickly? I think that would help with the blight in our town. Well, yeah, we were incentivizing homeowners to rent their properties to locals. You know, we're putting millions of dollars into housing, so isn't there another channel that we can start helping business owners launch here? There has to be.

34:42 I mean, the only penalty is, I mean, you know, in the case of Sierra Center Mall, the only penalty is they have to start over if they don't do anything by the time that they're, you know, by July 1st or whatever, the end of June, whatever that date is, then they're starting over. And starting over, it's expensive. It's the same, they're going through the exact same process.

35:05 Even if they're resubmitting, correct? Even if they're resubmitting the exact same things, it's still the exact same process. And they have to abide by whatever the codes are today, which could have changed from the time that they got their permits before. But, you know, I don't know, like, you know, I don't know what the incentive is. And I don't, again, you know, kind of tagging along with what Michael said, I don't know that the town's in the position. I don't know that any municipality's in the position.

35:34 to incentivize financially a company, you know, business, aside from just nurturing somebody and explaining the situation or explaining how to open a business and making, streamlining the process. And it really, I mean, I, my experience, it's not that, it hasn't been that challenging. I mean, maybe other people have had challenging experiences with the town and town staff, but I personally haven't. I feel like I've been listened to and

36:02 Town's been very responsive to my issues, concerns and stuff over the last five years. I don't know what the answer is and I don't know that that's our purview. I'm not saying that. I don't know what the answer is and I don't know how to accomplish it and I don't know that and I really don't, again, going back to the fact that I don't even know why

36:28 The planning became, why the Economic Development Part came into the Planning Commission to begin with. That's the real question. I think that is the question. So does anybody know why that happened to anybody? Or is it a valid? I'm feeling really bold because I feel like I'm the only one. So I'm the outsider here and all I can tell you is I've served on the board of the West Hollywood Chamber of Commerce for 30 years. So I'm very connected with the city. So to go to your question, who owns it?

36:55 To me, the city has, the town has to own it. West Hollywood has an economic development department in the town hall, you know, in the town structure, and they're the ones that do all this. The town has the incentive to get new businesses here. In West Hollywood, new businesses get free taxes for one year. Last month, the chamber suggested to the town, because things now, people are...

37:23 Afraid because of what's happening. How do we try to get more people to come shop? So with the chamber, the Economic Development Department of West Hollywood came up with a program. For April, we have free parking. So the city has to sign off on that, of course, because that's a loss of revenue.

37:41 from the parking meters in the city, but the chamber really worked with the Economic Development Department to do that. They had to go to the city council to get it approved, but that's just one small program that, you know, a chamber working with a town can do. So I think that's where, and I...

38:02 Right, I mean, when I started getting involved here, I said planning and economic development commission, why are they together? Exactly. Because in West Hollywood, it's the planning commission, which does what, I think, a planning commission in every city does, which basically is give out approvals, you know, and interprets the ordinances. So, to me, economic development should rest within the town structure. It's almost a separate entity, then.

38:26 Well, not a separate entity. I mean, it's within. Well, I mean, within the town, but it shouldn't be necessarily like, you know, because again, I questioned this, you know, 20 years ago. I don't understand what, you know, as, you know, I'm sitting up here, I'm looking at design review and I'm looking at building height and I'm looking at the aesthetics and making sure that it follows the guidelines, the general plan and the building codes. So, but as far as a business coming, you know.

38:54 If somebody's talking to me about a restaurant, I'm going to be like, oh, that sounds good to me, as long as it's not pizza or Mexican food, I think it's great. Right. I mean, a normal business in West Hollywood just gets an over-the-counter permit. You know, it only is if they're like extended hours or they have liquor. There are reasons that you have to go through a commission structure. But to me, it should be the town really working with the chamber to come up with ways to...

39:21 Attract new businesses, and then the other part is retaining existing businesses. I'm sure it's that way in Hollywood, it was that way in Bakersfield. You want to start a business, you start at the economic development. They give you all the tools, the resources, and I think that's the gap. In your name, I just applied that's what you're supposed to do, but I guess not. Yeah. So I don't know how we fill the gap. Well, and the other thing, too, is like, you know, my family just signed a lease with a gentleman who has a business here in town, and he's...

39:50 Opening a VR arcade kind of thing. But again, it's not my purview to say, I can't do those video games. They make me want to throw up. So it's not something I'm going to participate. But then again, there could be a million people out there that really want to do that. So I'm not the person that's going to say, oh, you can't open that business because it's silly and it's not going to be successful because I don't know. And I don't know. I mean, there may be somebody, town staff,

40:20 That if there was a specific more economic development division within the town staff, then maybe that, you know, then there could be some sort of history and understanding of, yeah, that is a really viable business that's really successful over in this municipality or in this city.

40:38 And we receive that a lot when new businesses, the one that you're talking about, reached out to us and is asking, is this viable? Does this make sense? And again, I don't have any data to go off of. It's my opinion, my, you know, from working at the chamber, from working with businesses, but it would be great if we had something more concrete to go off of. And I think businesses are looking for something like that to be, to inquire, does this make sense? Will this be profitable in Mammoth?

41:05 And how are you going to help me if it does? You know, so, I mean, it almost sounds like you guys are saying, we don't really, we don't do that and we don't really want to do that. And we don't know who does. And we don't know who does. It's not so much that we don't want to, we just don't have the tools. Okay, so, but that's, if that changes going forward, you know.

41:26 More than willing to have that conversation. And what you said, Michael, is exactly true. We live in a free capitalist society. We have a free market economy. So it's very difficult when you go to a town and ask for incentives for one specific type of business because everyone wants the incentive. So for example, in West Hollywood, we have lots of vacant storefronts right now. So one person on the council said, well, why don't we see if we can

41:55 Reach out to the arts community and do pop-ups during this time. But of course, they need the money to transform the space into a pop-up art gallery. And then other people are like, well, why are we spending the money on arts? Why don't we spend the money on attracting new businesses? So whenever there's money involved, it becomes then a political issue. Can I interject, guys?

42:24 A couple of questions, like, has any research been done on what is best practice for in other towns regarding this? Like, just echoing what David said, if there's empty storefronts, it could be pop-up bar, it could be a pop-up clothing store, it could be pop-up anything, you know, like restaurants now, the trucks can be really anywhere, and so there's lots of different options for that regarding slocums.

42:51 Isn't that a health issue right now with Hantavirus? Like, can't we go in and condemn it? Or, you know, isn't there something the town can do to incent the owners to do something with it? I'm surprised there's nothing at our disposal. And regarding the development permits, there's, you can have a disincentive for not using the development permit. Some of the people that own these properties have owned them, you know, for a long, long time.

43:20 And so whatever the fees are, are not really a problem to them. I've seen in San Diego where a developer would just keep redoing the fees to keep the property open because it didn't make sense for them. But there's got to be a way to get them to incent them maybe by saying, you know, once you lose that development permit, you don't get it again, you know, unless you've got a good reason for it sitting there. But I'm shocked that there's not examples in other towns and cities that we can emulate here to bring business in.

43:56 I never really shut up a room, but... Well, I just think the whole thing goes back to what we've all been saying. No one really owns it. So what says you, Rob? Yeah. Well, let's first get public comments. Sorry, Rob. I'd love to give you the floor.

44:10 Oh, if I, I'll do a full public comment in just a second. Just jump in. Jump in for the first part. Going back to Don's portion, the name was changed, in my recollection, actually, after the lawsuit with the airport from Planning Commission to PDEC and Economic Development. At that point in time, we were facing some very uncertainty time frames in the community, and that's when that whole shift started. Do you remember the logic behind it, though? The logic was the town didn't have any money, and we were worried about town couldn't.

44:36 Sustain itself going forward and we need to increase economic development. We had a whole steering committee that was created by Matthew Lehman. We were working on actually that committee apart from the town's services itself going out and creating economic development. We went down and visited with some people in Southern California to try to entice them to come into open businesses within the community. Are you sure that was the right? Are you sure this wasn't before that? Because this is 2000. In my head, that's where the name changed. I disagree.

45:06 Yeah, I think that was earlier, but regardless. If I could just say, so, using my quick five minutes. Just one of the things, just Brent Truex, just want to reiterate, I'm here as Brent Truex, citizen who does business in the community. The council, when they speak, will be as a voice to the mayor, but my issues are what I see in the community. And just a couple quick items. One, the forward-facing issues that happen in this town, the simple things that you can gain on.

45:36 For instance, I was in the town offices when somebody who owned Harmony came in and they were trying to get their business started and all of a sudden they're like, oh, did you get fire department approval? And they're like, well, I didn't even know I had to get fire department approval. I don't know where to go. So that guidance is really critical. I know the chamber is working on it. I hope the Planning Commission and everybody else and town staff, I don't see no one here, but are getting them the information to get that document out. I think that's a valuable resource for the community to be out there in front.

46:04 Two, we've developed a lot of plans in the community. I was looking at the downtown revitalization plan that exists that was approved in 2017. I encourage you to re-look at those and re-strategize, is that the right format and right direction that we need to go into? I'm just using that as one example. And three, from the standpoint of, I believe there's a discussion in moving ahead with the destination management plan, but isn't that what part of creating a destination management plan is what we're talking about here today is having certain items focused on who's responsible for what area and how to move the town forward.

46:33 So that's my comment. Thank you. Appreciate it. Rob, love to have your input. Sure. Rob Patterson, Town Manager. Yeah, so thanks for the discussion today. I think it's an interesting question. I can look forward to reading on Friday about why PEDC was created, but we'll have to wait for that. With regard to the town, I think we all need to be involved in the success of our community.

47:07 Right. And when we look at everybody around this table, we've got PEDC and we've got Chamber of Commerce and we're talking about business development. I don't want to have the finger pointed to the town to say, you know, it's your guys' responsibility to figure this problem out because as someone said earlier, you know, we don't have quite the data on that aspect of it. But I will say that the town's role in anything to do with this community is services.

47:34 Right? So if there's something that we can do in that space, I think someone was mentioning, how do we, you know, understand what is going on in other municipalities and how they're leaning into that space? I'm open for that, wide open for that, right? Part of Nolan's role is economic development. But I think either through our own problems of staffing and challenges, we've been focused quite a bit, quite heavily on housing, which is also in his purview.

48:03 and all other planning aspects of things. So we're willing to lean in in any space that is necessary for success, but I also need everybody else doing the same. Very, very space. So good dialogue. I know this is not much of an answer and folks wanted to see where things are. I just think that we're partners and we're here and ready to engage in that space, but we can't do it alone.

48:31 Well, and to your point, too, you know, not to put Nolan on the spot, but, you know, I don't know, I mean, I think Nolan's doing a great job, especially with housing, but, and I've never asked Nolan this, but as far as, like, economic development, you know, is that, like, what, you know, is that just part of your title, but not necessarily, you know, your expertise, and is there somebody that, and I'm not saying, you know, I mean, my gosh, I mean,

48:58 Who knows what's going to happen in the next 6-12 months with the economy, so it might be a moot point that all of us are discussing, nothing might be happening, but I'm just wondering, does it make sense to have somebody that has a specific education or history or understanding? Resources. Resources, yeah. So good? Because it's a lot, I mean, that's a huge, I mean, I know you have staff, you have people helping.

49:27 It's not just you, but it's a lot on just one person's, on one person's plate. Yeah, so right now we've got, we've got, well, Nolan has done an excellent job actually in every part of his job, but we have housing position we've been trying to fill for more than a year now, and I think we're close, we're very close, so what that will do is take a little bit of time off of Nolan's plate.

49:52 The Snow Creek Development Agreement, which you all know just passed recently and you guys were part of that success, was a great deal of his time. So I think as we look to the future, we probably will have some freed up resources to focus in on this space that will help that out a little bit. So I would go back to probably 2009 when the town had a tourism and recreation department and the way I described that to people with now Mammoth Lakes Tourism is that the department was in charge of getting people here.

50:21 and making sure the soccer field's got mowed. Not really focused. The split was, okay, recreation goes to the town, tourism becomes its own entity. It sounds like we're in the same boat here where, you know, planning is one thing. Economic development is a totally different thing. You know, if you ask me to do recreation, that's not my job. I don't know what to do with that. But splitting MLT off 15 years ago could be where we're at with economic development.

50:49 You know, Mono County, with their economic development, a few years ago, they put out their push to get businesses into Mono County. They had brochures, they had videos, they had testimonials, they had a lot of really good things going on out there. I don't know if that's the solution, but, you know, if you don't have, and I'm not expecting Nolan and his crew to be experts in economic development when really planning is the focus. And with all of the things that we have going on with housing, that's...

51:16 More than a full-time job right there and expecting economic development to come out of the same office is kind of ridiculous. In terms of the research, you know, we've been meeting with the UC Cooperative Extension, Aaron Wilshire works out of this area and we just met with him yesterday, the day before yesterday at the chamber to talk about specifically

51:37 He comes from the UC system, so he's very research and education focused, and he's working on starting to do some of what we're talking about in our area. Nolan, I'm not sure how many conversations you or the town have had with him, but that's one thing that I know he's looking at.

51:53 Thinking, speaking with other chambers of commerce in other areas, you know, there are chambers that they take on the economic, they're both, they're economic development, they're the DMO, and they're the chamber. So, you know, I'm not saying we're ready right now today to take that on, but, you know, I think exploring what, where economic development lives and who really oversees that is something we need to be working on moving forward.

52:22 These are all good long-term things, deciding who owns these things. Short-term, I'm not going to give you an example, I'm really embarrassed. I think there's something we can do now. When a new business starts, what do they do? So I started my business four years ago out of my house. I didn't know what to do. I filed the fictitious business name. I looked on the website, tried to figure things out. I did all that. Then I went and got a physical location.

52:47 And I said, oh, now I need a business permit. I didn't have a business permit that whole time. Now, I did do it, and I filed my back fees, but I didn't know, and I'm kind of smart, I think. So I didn't know how to do it. So maybe in the town there's a checklist or something. I feel like I have to go to help somebody else that was starting. There's like five different places everyone has to go. So a one-stop shop, and if you tell me it's there, I'll be really embarrassed. Does that make sense? So we have a few different iterations of what you're describing that have been out.

53:16 In the public realm, there's links to them in the agenda. One was, I'd say, a very bureaucratic feeling document of how to start a business in Mammoth Lakes and not exciting to read through. And the other one was a joint effort with Mono County in the town. But it's much more on the marketing side, kind of touching with what John spoke to. And so, I don't know, Brianna, six months ago, we kind of kicked off an effort with

53:47 Working with Mono County Economic Development, myself and the chamber to basically merge those two documents together and come up with a comprehensive how to start a new business here in Mammoth and will include checklist of, you know, the goal is kind of if you're starting a restaurant, here's all the people you should be talking to and when you should be talking to them.

54:10 Or if you're starting a retail or even down to a TOT rental, like here's all the people you should be talking to. And it also includes much kind of broader information for all businesses of how to get a fictitious business statement, how to come up and formulate your business plan. So our goal is for it to be a very comprehensive document, but also not so kind of bureaucratic that it just gets tossed aside because

54:40 It's too boring to read through. That exists now? It's in the works. This is what I've been talking to the board about since we've been meeting since August. So yeah, the town's document is sorry, let me pull it up here. It's like an eight page, again, very bureaucratic, not easy to read document. Then the county joint one is

55:02 A 12-page, much more marketing document, so we're working on creating something that's kind of a combination of the two. It will be more like a 50, 60-page document, overly thorough probably, with the goal of then creating something a little bit more digestible that's like a one or two page. So we actually just got the design back from the graphic designer.

55:24 That the town uses. So we're working through it and the goal is within the next few months hopefully that is ready to go. So exactly what you're saying, Sonia. And that's what we hear from businesses. They're like, I don't even know where to start. Yeah, what do I do? Yeah, what do I do? What are all the steps? What order do I need to do them in? So that is what this document is explaining. Who owns that document once it's completed? And who will be responsible for updating that document? So we started leading the process in doing this and we've been

55:54 Coordinating all of the meetings, so I'm happy for the chamber to oversee this and work in partnership with the town and the county, but I hear constantly from the businesses, so I think at this point it's living in our world, but it is a joint documentary partnership. And that has been part of our focus too on as we're kind of drafting it is, I wouldn't say it, you know, once it's done it never has to be updated, but creating it in a format where it's, you know,

56:24 Doesn't say like, oh, if you want to start a new business, go talk to Nolan. Yeah. Because I could be gone tomorrow. It's, you know, so. Or evergreen. Yeah, really like having it where it's, has great information for every type of businesses with kind of, you know, you need to be talking to these, but not getting into such, you know, level of detail that it becomes obsolete second something changes. It's really like.

56:50 Trying to create that information so you could go to that, have a checklist of I need to, I want to start a restaurant, okay, I need to be talking to the fire district, the health department, the planning department, the building department, the finance department, kind of creating on there who you should be engaging with because we, you know, I can touch a little bit on kind of our role in, you know, the community economic development department as far as, you know, the economic side which is really focused on how to assist.

57:20 You know, businesses get started, get through the regulatory process on our end. So whether that's, you know, oh, you want to, you need to do this, you need to get a tenant improvement and submit plans, trying to really help them get through that process, not so much on out there, you know, going to conferences or in SoCal trying to, you know, recruit new businesses in. It's more if you have an idea how to then get you open.

57:49 And, you know, hopefully, you know, provide those resources for them to be successful. And a lot of that is, you know, looking, okay, like, you know, you should be working with the chamber because they can help get your name out, working with marketing to, you know, market and advertise, not so much. We're not doing the work for them, but trying to help them through our process at the town.

58:12 And also the West Hollywood Chamber uses this to recruit members because we tell people, join the chamber and we will help you. And it's not so much we're going to do the work, we're going to introduce you to the people you need to talk to based on your business. As you mentioned, restaurants have safety, food safety issues that retail store doesn't have to worry about. So that's a different, and West Hollywood, so that's county, right? So that's even outside of the city.

58:39 But you need the business owner, you give them a list and say you need to talk to this person, this person, and this person. And that I think is helpful, especially for like a solopreneur. I mean, big businesses have expediters and people that help them. But for a small business, which I think every community likes to keep and retain small businesses. So that's where the chamber can be very helpful. Sonia would have liked to have that, right? Yeah.

59:07 So I would ask, you know, we're nearing an hour here, but on topic three, which is what resources and content should a business guide provide? And I think, you know, amongst the Chamber Board, we have definitely a wide range of

59:35 Business sectors represented here. So I would look to kind of this group as to if you're starting up a new business, whether it's real estate or property management or hospitality or restaurants or laundromat or even a hospital, like what you'd be looking at in that business guide as to how it could help you be successful. And that's something you want directed to you, Nolan, and Brianna as well.

1:00:03 Maybe this guide that you guys are working on, we could be your test cases, because for me it was more about I know how to do my business, but I didn't even know, so when do you need a business permit? What kind of insurance does the town need to have? I mean, I didn't know what I didn't know. I've had a chance to proof the document, and I think it's very thorough. And I think equally important to me is that the tone of it is positive and welcoming, I would say. And in some cases,

1:00:32 That may be the part of the most important change. Number two, right under, here's exactly the checklist. It's like, we want you here. Here's the pros about bringing your business to Mammoth. Those things are in there. So I do think it's a good, solid document.

1:00:50 I hear you and I agree with you, Luan. I also do think it's important, like we face unique challenges in this town, cyclical in nature. Somebody that's going to come from out of town and open a business needs to know that it gets slow in May and June and October, November, even between Thanksgiving and Christmas. It's slow. You need to plan for that.

1:01:08 So that is something that was recommended. Maybe you, it was funny, we sent it to three different business owners and a lot of the comments were very similar. The golden rod, the golden sheet was mentioned, what you just talked about, the nature of our economy here. I remember meeting with a business, they've been open probably within the last two years and I was describing shoulder season and talking about, you know, April, May and...

1:01:33 They had no idea what I was talking about. We live so close to what we forget that people don't know, right? Yeah, I figure people know. But anyway, that's something that we've been talking about incorporating into the guide. Also things like signage, how to get your, do you need to get your sign approved? How do you do that? For restaurants, it would be working with the health department, the fire department, all the codes that you need to pass to get your certificate to open.

1:01:59 Michael, you posed a really good question. You know, we developed this really cool document and it has all the resources we need. But once they go into this, are they now fingering out and emailing 20 different people? Is there a way that we can put a resource together to have an administrative champion, somebody that is focused on new business development that answers all these questions? It's guiding this individual down the right path.

1:02:25 You know, pushing them off to the Planning Department, pushing them off to the Fire Department. You know, assuming that somebody is going to try to take this document and do all the things that they need themselves, it's a tough ask. That's a really good point, and that came up, that was a comment that somebody made, is, are, you know, is there one person that is helping this business and knows, you know, is there like a tracker of where they're at in the process? And then do all the other departments know?

1:02:54 Where they're at working with other departments? And I think the answer to that right now is no. Fire doesn't know where they're at with environmental health at the county. I assume they don't know those kinds of things. So that was something that one of the reviewers mentioned was having some sort of like tracking system. So both the individual is very aware of where they're at in the process. And then also the different departments are at least aware, you know, not necessarily talking, but at least aware of.

1:03:23 Where that business or that individual is at. In our world, that's called a navigator. Navigator. That's better. I was thinking shepherd. Well, and just to that point, though, you know, as a general contractor, I'm pulling permits all the time. I am required. I have to go to the town. I go to the fire department. I go to the water district. I know that's what I have to do. And granted, you know, I've been doing it long enough where it's...

1:03:46 I don't, it's not bothersome to me, but I think it's really important. I mean, I think it's important to streamline the process for anybody that wants to open a business, but at the same time, I think it's also important for that business owner to get in front of those departments as well. I think it's really, I really think it's important because then you're, there's a, and if you're talking the fire department, you know, there's a, there might be a specific code requirement and to have that one-on-one with the fire department.

1:04:13 And understand why that code is in place or why they're required to do whatever it is that they're asking. I think it's still valid and I think that's still important. But again, to have it streamlined so it's like, okay, so I have this checklist, I'm doing all these things and now I'm going to these different departments and having conversations. Because if you're doing, you know, depending on what the business is, you're going to the water district as well. You know, if you're opening a restaurant that wasn't an existing restaurant, you're going to, you know, the water district is involved.

1:04:42 And that kind of thing. But I think that streamlining it and making it simple and having, like, elite, you know, having, like, if I have a question, I can go to you and say, okay, like, okay, now what's my next step? Oh, now you have to go to over here. But I think it's important to make sure that there isn't a middleman doing all that in the sense that having some face time with each department, I think, is really important as well. And does that navigator live in the chamber world or does that navigator live in town staff?

1:05:11 Lives in your computer. It's an AI chair. Well, I hate to do this, guys. I can have... Please, Tom. I'm sorry. I want to go back to what David was mentioning about what worked. So we talk about comparing ourselves with other municipalities, what worked and was Hollywood. One of those ideas being tax incentives.

1:05:32 And I just want to make sure that we don't lose that concept. I think it needs to be talked about. I think it needs to be fleshed out clearly a little bit more. Alicia's talking about our seasonality made me think, well, the first year in West Hollywood maybe works. Maybe here the tax break is not just the first year, but it's the first couple shoulder seasons. But I think tax incentives ought to be something that we...

1:06:00 Don't just brush off because we know it works elsewhere. Well, and then just on your point too, I mean, depending on who the business and the landlord, I mean, the landlord typically is offering a lot of incentives to business owners, whether it's TI credits or red credit. So landlords, it kind of starts there, unless the person owns the property. You have a different landlord than I do. But another, for example, another very concrete example two months ago,

1:06:29 To retain businesses, the West Hollywood City Council enacted a program that if you sign a new year five-year lease, you get a tax break. So that's a way to people that are thinking of moving outside of the city would then maybe say, oh, maybe it's worth staying another five years. So more the carrot than the stick. I mean, I just think in the world, the carrot always works better than the stick.

1:06:56 And that takes the liability off of the landlord, too. But then the landlord still has, you know, they're not sitting in an empty space. And unfortunately, we're all dealing, West Hollywood and Mammoth Lakes are both located in the state of California. So, to your point about something coming from Reno, I mean, Nevada is generally a much business-friendlier state than California because of our laws, basically.

1:07:22 Being more employee-friendly than employer-friendly. So those are other, I mean, that's kind of outside of what the city would deal with, but that's also a factor when we're talking about economic development, because most people would move to Texas rather than California. This conversation poses a question to me about revenue for the town. So, you know, are we worried about tax revenue in economic development? Are we worried about permitting revenue?

1:07:51 Is there something that we can do as a municipality to create more revenue? So we're not worried about that. So we can drive the new interest to new business, but not have to worry about making all the money. Because I think the benefits, the tax benefits, are phenomenal. People would really jump on that, both landlords and business owners. All right, that's a great point. You should be part of the analysis on tax breaks.

1:08:19 Michael, thank you. Sorry to derail for a minute there. No problem, Tom. Appreciate it. Unfortunately, I am going to have to put a bow on this, guys. I really appreciate your time. I want to respect all of your time, but we do have another whole segment of today's commission meeting. I don't want to have this be a one and done, though. So, like, I would like to maybe quickly go with some takeaways and next steps.

1:08:44 I know we're about to lose you for... I'll be back in July. I'll be back in July. But I mean, is this something we can get together quarterly and have a conversation and keep the ball moving? I just would hate to have this conversation die. Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, I think that'd be great. I think the immediate action is the business guide, which will hopefully this summer be done.

1:09:06 Like I said, we started working on it last August. I think a year is a good goal to have it completed and compiled. So the immediate goal, I think, is that. And then Nolan and our team can definitely continue discussing. And I think quarterly would be great to explore what comes of economic development. Rob, would you be comfortable if we tried to do this quarterly from a town leadership standpoint? Yes. Okay. Nolan, since you're kind of department head here.

1:09:33 Yeah, I think that'd be great just to keep the conversation, keep the momentum. In the meantime, I might ask everyone, if you do have a little bit of free time, which none of us really do, maybe do some research and see what other municipalities and communities do in terms of economic development. Who owns that? Is it a town facility? Is it a chamber facility? Is it its own entity altogether? And when we get back together in a couple of months, let's talk about that.

1:10:01 What our findings were. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. We have somebody who wants to give a comment online. And I'll come back to you, please. Liz, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, Michael and everyone. This is Liz Grand, the Economic Development Director for Monaco County. I appreciate being able to listen in on this discussion. I hope I can join you in the future for one. As Brianna and maybe Michael know, we're going through a similar process right now where we are.

1:10:29 Re-evaluating our department's role in the greater economic development world. I have experience with what other jurisdictions and counties have done and what we have tried and combining that all to see where we should be going. Part of that is stakeholder outreach.

1:10:49 We've hired SMG Consulting to help us kind of develop this work plan. They're going to be doing a workshop and interview, Michael, at our upcoming Tourism Commission on April 29th. And then we're doing individual ones with some county staff, the supervisors, our other chambers of commerce. And then we will hopefully with Brianna and the Mammoth Lakes Chamber or maybe with this group, it would be appropriate. I'll send him this recording at least so he can get an idea of what you guys were discussing.

1:11:17 I think it would be great to have him touch base with you and explore kind of where, you know, collaboration could continue between my department, the town and the chamber. So I'm really excited to see where this goes and hope we can kind of integrate more into the discussion. Thank you, Liz. Wyatt, take us home. Pose a question and a challenge to everybody. So being that the town, our main revenue is from tourism, top tax. Let's figure out a way.

1:11:45 That we can thrive outside of that. That would be amazing. Say if we had 10 to 15 to 20 extra million dollars outside of tourism, that we could develop these programs, develop out our community, put more money towards housing. You know, sky's the limit when you look at a 20 million dollar resource. So I pose that question to you guys. Let's try to figure out what we can do to get out from underneath tourism.

1:12:17 Thank you all. Appreciate your time. Thank you, guys. And we will try and get this on a pretty regular schedule, maybe quarterly. Everyone here is for items on the rest of the agenda. Maybe give us two minutes to kind of relocate, and if anybody has to use the facilities. My thing is, like, just don't sign up for something that you're not going to really put 100% in, or at least 90%, right? Make the effort. That's all I ask. We all...

1:17:07 I appreciate that. Thank you. Jamie, you ready? Yeah. Dawn, you ready? Do you need a moment to get settled? No, I'm fine. You got the dwarf chair? I got the dwarf chair again. All right. Thank you for that. All right. I would like to reconvene today's Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. I would like to say thank you to everyone who participated in that workshop that just concluded. I thought it was very, very interesting.

1:17:42 will lead to some, I think, very positive conversations. And I also want to thank everyone who was arriving for other agenda items for your patience. So thank you for that. So with that, we'll move on to our business matters. We will go to 5.1, which is consideration of a major design review 25-001 requesting approval of a 10,460 foot

1:18:09 461 foot square foot multi-purpose building for housing airport safety operations equipment including the aircraft rescue and firefighting equipment and snow removal equipment and I believe Sierra and Kim are our staff contacts.

1:18:27 Thank you. So I've shared my screen. I'm Kim Cook, and I'm going to be giving the presentation. We do have Sierra Wah here, the applicant for the town. Sierra is our deputy airport manager. So the item before you is a major design review application for the construction of a new multi-purpose building. The intent for this building is to house the airport aircraft rescue and firefighting equipment as well as snow removal equipment.

1:18:59 The project site is the Mammoth Airport site. The proposed multi-purpose building is a component of the Mammoth Yosemite Airport Terminal Area Development Project site. This site comprises 22 acres of the 196 acre airport parcel.

1:19:23 The proposed building is situated on the southeast end of the existing airport terminal and is situated nearest to the easternmost row of airport hangars. So the proposed building and the associated infrastructure improvements are listed as the number one priority in the airport capital improvement program and this program is consistent with implementing the airport layout plan.

1:19:54 Planning and Economic Development Commission previously approved a major design review in 2022. The approved design was for a taller and a larger scale structure than is currently proposed. The reason the design of the building has changed is due to an unsuccessful bidding process for the structure combined with FAA.

1:20:18 FAA's determination that many of the rooms in the original building would no longer be eligible for funding due to changes in the town's commercial air service. At that time, the town determined that it did not want to take on the full financial burden of the ineligible components along with anticipated construction, so the town did decide to redesign the project. And since the FAA determination

1:20:47 was provided so late in the process, that agency did agree to provide grant funding to the town for that redesign work. The redesign has eliminated spaces that were no longer eligible for FAA funding and these areas included a wash and dryer room, a first aid medical room, day room, two dorm rooms, two locker rooms and additional storage.

1:21:16 The current design review application was submitted March 6, 2025 and the proposed use of the structure is determined to be consistent with the zoning code description for required aviation safety structures. The project includes construction of

1:21:44 A new 10,461 square foot seven bay multipurpose building. The building is going to house again like I said previously the airport rescue firefighting vehicle as well as the snow removal equipment and maintenance operations. The building does include a small lobby that is intended for customer service and access badging operations.

1:22:12 Airport staff office space, a training room, a break room and restrooms. Other site improvements that are associated with the new building include pavement areas for a 11 space parking lot, air side access road and a septic system with leach field. So the project is a permitted use subject to the airport zoning district and is

1:22:44 A design review is required and no other land use permit requirements are needed. So a major design review requires consistency with the general plan, the zoning code development standards, the town design guidelines, as well as CEQA. The general plan land use designation for the site is airport and this allows aviation, fueling and fixed space operator services at the Mammoth Yosemite airport.

1:23:11 The proposed multi-purpose building is a required aviation safety structure and is consistent with the aviation uses on the airport property. The town's airport special purpose zoning district is described in the zoning code as being intended to implement the airport layout plan and the goals and policies in the general plan related to airport facilities. The applicable development standards are fairly limited in this zoning district.

1:23:43 For instance, the design requirement is intended to enhance the airport facility. The yards and separation required under the zoning designation is determined through the design review process rather than applying a specific setback or distance between structures requirement.

1:24:08 The maximum building height required in the zoning district is 45 feet for required aviation structures. The proposed structure is 27 feet in height at the highest roof fridge line. And then the parking requirement is also determined through the design review process. So no minimum standard is specified in the zoning code. And the proposed parking lot associated with the new building provides 11 striped parking spaces.

1:24:40 So the building's consistency with the town design guidelines include that the building form is appropriate in scale and proportion within the airport setting. The project does take advantage of solar exposure and solar panels. The proposed roof color is dark and muted rather than bright and it features a matte finish. The building facade colors are taken from the natural setting of Mammoth Lakes.

1:25:08 They have low reflectivity and are subtle earth tone colors. The large planar surfaces are slightly darker than the surrounding natural colors. The mechanical equipment and other utilities are cited to minimize visibility. And the parking areas are located

1:25:31 in an area that is least visible from the public right-of-way, and I am thinking of the public right-of-ways 203, Highway 295, sorry. And then finally, the current design is within the scope of development that was analyzed through a 2022 addendum to the Terminal Area Development Plan EIR. The addendum describes minor technical changes to the certified EIR.

1:26:00 Due to the modified building design and site design and that addendum concluded that the environmental data and analysis presented in the certified EIR would remain valid with respect to the modified ARF and snow removal equipment building design and determined that the proposed design modifications would not involve new or more severe environmental impacts compared to those that were identified in the certified.

1:26:29 in the certified EIR. The addendum found that the mitigation measures that were adopted with the certified EIR remain valid for this project. They are included as conditions of approval and they're listed on this slide. So since the project was found to be consistent with the general plan zoning code development standards, the town design guidelines and CEQA, staff recommends that the

1:27:02 Planning and Economic Development Commission, adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving design review 25-001 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. That concludes my presentation. Sierra was available if you have any specific questions about the airport operations. I'll turn it over to you.

1:27:30 Thank you. Appreciate that, Kim. Sierra, do you have a statement you'd like to make or you just would prefer Q&A? I think we could just go right into Q&A. I think Kim provided that and we're just happy to have the opportunity to come back in front of you guys with the project that is hopefully still carrying forward regardless of some of the previous changes. Okay.

1:27:56 So before I open up public comment, do we have any questions from either of my commissioners for Kim or Sierra on the facility being contemplated down at the airport? No. None? No. Any thoughts on the design review? I believe you are a representative. Well, I mean, the fact that it's downsized, you know, quite a bit, I don't really see that there's any need to have a conversation about it. It's, you know, I'm sorry that it, that those things, those areas did get eliminated. That's too bad.

1:28:26 But I don't see that there's any need to have a discussion. Okay. With that, I'll open up to public comment. Jamie, do we have any public comment in the room? Sweet Z, please approach the podium. Do we have any public comment online? Going, going, gone. All right, I'll close public comment, and I'll bring it back up to the commission. Any other thoughts, opinions, or would someone like to put a motion for it? I make a motion to adopt the attached planning and economic, that's what I'm reading, yeah.

1:29:04 Planning Commission resolution making required CEQA and municipal code findings and approve their design review for DR25-001 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. Is that right? No, without, sorry. Without. Without any modifications. Sorry. Do I have a second? I second. Any further conversation? None. Jamie, may I have a vote, please? Commissioner Fleming? Yes, approved. Vice Chair Verruck?

1:29:36 Yes, Chair Vanderhurst. Yes, passes 3-0. May not be the dream facility you were hoping for, but at least you get one. Yeah, yeah. I mean, it's going to suit what we need and it'll be great. It's just a different operation that we have out there without commercial service. So some of those spaces were just no longer required. And knowing you and your team, you'll make the best of what you're getting. So congratulations. Yeah, thank you very much.

1:30:06 All right, we will move on to business matter 5.2, which is consideration of major design review 24-008 and administrative permit 25-001 for the Mammoth Hospital North Wing replacement project located in the public slash quasi, the public slash quasi public zoning district. The project consists of construction of a 60,788 foot.

1:30:35 Square Foot Facility. And with that, I believe, Kim, you are our staff contact again. Yes, thank you. Me again. Let me just get this into slideshow mode. Okay, thank you. So the project before you today is the major design review application and an administrative permit application for the Mammoth Hospital North Wing Replacement Project.

1:31:22 This is located in the town's public quasi-public zoning district and is located at the southeast corner of Sierra Park Road and Tavern Road. The property is approximately two acres in size and functions as part of the larger nine-acre Mammoth Hospital campus. The western half of the property is currently developed with a 96 space parking lot which serves Mammoth Hospital and the

1:31:57 Western half, sorry, the eastern half of the property is the proposed location for the new hospital building. A lot line adjustment application was submitted at the same time as the design review application and this was a request to merge the project parcel with the larger hospital campus parcel and this lot merger is currently in process and is being processed separately because it is a ministerial application.

1:32:30 The proposed project consists of the construction of a two-story, 60,788-square-foot acute care hospital building with associated site improvements that include reconfiguration of the existing parking lot. The building is designed as a steel brace and concrete structure, which is reviewed and permitted by the State Department of Health Care Access and Information, also called HKI.

1:32:59 And this agency permits the structure rather than the town's building division. The project is necessary to comply with the seismic retrofit requirements under Senate Bill 1953, also known as the hospital seismic retrofit program. This bill requires acute care hospitals like Mammoth Hospital to redesign and construct their facilities.

1:33:24 to ensure they remain operational and can withstand a major earthquake or other seismic event. The structure is two stories with 29,967 square feet of floor area on the first level. The second level features 28,496 square feet. The acute care patient rooms are located on the second floor of the building.

1:33:51 which, because of the topography of the site, is at the same level, the second floor is at the same level as the existing hospital, and that allows for two pedestrian bridge connections between the existing hospital structure and this new hospital building. And the two bridges provide separate circulation for the general public and hospital staff with patients.

1:34:19 The application narrative states that the proposed project intends to modernize the hospital campus to comply with current clinical and seismic safety requirements and does not intend to add any significant patient capacity. The change in capacity for acute care patients is proposed to increase from 15 beds to 18 beds and the narrative also states that a marginal increase in hospital staff is expected to change from 60 to 64.

1:34:51 The existing parking lot will be reconfigured to create through access to Tavern Road and a new patient drop-off loop is designed to provide ease of access to the hospital entrance. The existing vehicular access from Sierra Park Road will be maintained. The number of parking spaces within the existing parking lot will be reduced from 96 spaces to 42 spaces as part of this project.

1:35:21 And to allow for this reduction in the required off street parking, the applicant team has applied through the administrative permit process for a reduction in off street parking that does not exceed 25% of the required number of spaces. The alternative parking provisions of the zoning code does require that the review authority make one additional finding for approval.

1:35:46 that demonstrates how the implementation of transportation demand management measures will continue to reduce the need for onsite parking on an ongoing basis. One site improvement that will significantly help implement new transportation demand management measures is the dedication of land at the front of the property for a new bus shelter and a cost share agreement between the town and the applicant.

1:36:14 A 50% cost share for the construction of that new transit shelter. The perimeter setback areas of the site are proposed to be permanently landscaped with trees and plants that include native drought tolerant species appropriate to the Mammoth Lakes region. These landscape areas will also be used to store snow. However, the applicant is required to provide a snow management plan to the town.

1:36:42 which will commit Mammoth Hospital to permanently haul snow offsite in accordance with town standards. The public quasi-public zoning district is a special purpose zoning district. The applicable development standards for the zone do not include a maximum building height or maximum lot coverage standard. The parking

1:37:12 Minimum parking standard is also a little bit different from other zones in that it requires that any approved uses comply with parking standards that are applicable to other similar uses within the town. The project complies with the applicable development standards including setbacks. The building height proposed is primarily 35 feet in height to the

1:37:39 to the top of the parapet wall on the flat portion of the roof, and then there are two tower features, one on the front, one on the back, that reach up to 48 feet in height. The number of parking spaces that are provided for the project are campus-wide spaces, and the total will be 325 spaces proposed. When we apply the

1:38:09 parking standard for service uses in this parking zone, a total of 390 spaces would be required. So the applicant is requesting a 17% reduction in the required on-site parking. So the zoning code classifies hospital and medical service uses within the service land use category.

1:38:45 Land use designation requires that the hospital use be approved through the administrative permit process. The service land use designation also determines the applicable parking ratio for the proposed use. In this case, what I've got here on the slide shows the town's parking areas. We have three different parking zones, zone one, two, and three.

1:39:13 In the table on the left-hand side, you have the different land use categories. So the hospital property is located in land use parking zone three, and the applicable parking ratio is four spaces for every 1,000 gross square feet of leasable area. This parking ratio is larger than other similar service uses in the town.

1:39:41 Because of the parking zone location, it kind of splits the, it splits both sides of Sierra Park Road into two different parking zones. If we were to apply the parking zone one, which is located on the east, on the west side of Sierra Park Road, the required parking ratio would be three spaces for every 1,000 gross square feet of leasable area.

1:40:09 Really the distinction that is made between these parking areas are due to the mixture of land uses and availability of multimodal transportation options. In this case, the east side of Sierra Park Road is really the side of the road with the transportation infrastructure with regard to public sidewalk connections being consistent throughout that.

1:40:38 side of the street and the bus stops along that side of the road. So staff was able to determine that the available multimodal transportation infrastructure for the hospital does justify the request for the 17% reduction in parking spaces compared to other uses that are located across the street that don't necessarily have the same

1:41:08 So this application was reviewed by the advisory design panel. The projects that are deemed to be significant by the community and economic development director are required to be reviewed by the advisory design panel before being considered by PEDC.

1:41:38 The role of the ADP is to provide impartial and professional advice to town staff and PEDC regarding site planning and building design and this is intended to improve project conformance with the town design guidelines. The advisory design panel reviewed the project on March 5th, 2025 and the consensus recommendations that were provided included

1:42:05 That the design of the sloped covered entry roof should be designed so that it does not shed snow into a pedestrian walkway. Another recommendation was that the proposed cultured stone base material would be replaced with the natural stone material primarily because ADP believes that cultured stone tends to crumble in our climate and doesn't withstand the freeze-thaw cycle.

1:42:36 And finally, the preservation of two additional Jeffrey Pine trees located in the rear setback area were recommended to be incorporated into the site design. The project design was revised in response to ADP comments and successfully improved the site design and functionality of the building. The changes made in response to ADP recommendations include the replacement of the cultured stone-based material with the natural stone material.

1:43:09 The applicant relocated handicapped parking spaces and the path of travel associated with those spaces in order to avoid passing under a snowshed condition at the covered entry roof and to avoid passing through a vehicle drive aisle. The applicant team also agreed to preserve the two additional Jeffrey Pine trees located in the rear setback of the property if that ends up being feasible.

1:43:38 Based on the site grading requirements. If that does not end up being feasible, staff has included a condition of approval that requires these two trees be replaced on a two-to-one basis with the same species and in the same general location. So the required findings for approval for the application types, does the proposed project meet the design review criteria?

1:44:07 and required findings pursuant to the municipal code chapter for design review. Staff was able to make affirmative findings that the project meets the design review criteria. Overall, it was found that the proposed building and site improvements combine together in an attractive visually cohesive manner that integrates well with other buildings located on the hospital campus as well as the Mono County government building located north of the property.

1:44:37 The building design complements the desired aesthetic character of a mountain resort community and provides pedestrian connectivity to town sidewalks and a planned bus shelter location at the front of the property. Additionally, findings are required to determine if the proposed project meets the administrative permit review criteria. Staff has made affirmative findings for approval of the administrative permit.

1:45:06 These findings include that the proposed hospital building will provide improved public health and safety infrastructure for the community by modernizing the hospital campus to comply with current clinical and seismic safety requirements and that the requested 17% reduction in the required number of off-street parking spaces is justified in this case because multimodal accessibility infrastructure currently connects the hospital campus.

1:45:33 to other parts of the town and additional improvements are planned to provide new multimodal amenities such as a new bus shelter location at the front of the property and convenient bicycle parking and bicycle lockers. And the final finding for approval required is determining whether the project is consistent with CEQA. Staff did find that the project is consistent with CEQA because it qualifies for a categorical exemption.

1:46:04 from further environmental review. This is pursuant to CEQA guidelines section 15302. This is for replacement or reconstruction projects and this exemption specifically includes projects for the replacement of existing hospitals to provide earthquake resistant structures which do not increase capacity more than 50%.

1:46:32 So because we were able to make the findings for approval for the proposed project, staff recommends that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving design review 24-008 and administrative permit 25-001 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. That concludes my presentation.

1:47:03 We have the applicant team. We have Mark Lind, the hospital COO, and we have Richard Casabian, who's been working on the project design for the hospital. Thank you, Kim. Appreciate that. With that, I will invite any or all of you gentlemen, if you'd like to come to the podium and make a statement. I express my appreciation for Kim Cook and her team. They did a really robust job and were closely with us in the design phase. I think we have a good product that meets the town's needs.

1:47:44 We're looking at it as a 50-year investment in the hospital, and it'll be a big upgrade for our care for our patients, really get us to the current standard of care. What we have now is a 1978 building. It's really quite dated. This is a big jump forward for us. It's mostly driven by the state code, the seismic code, but also by just needing to move forward and have proper technology.

1:48:13 and a care setting for our patients. Thank you. So any questions? Yeah, if you wouldn't mind just hanging tight at the podium. I'm going to throw it back on the commission. Any questions for staff or for the applicant on the presentation and the matter before us? I was just, my only question is, what happens to the existing building? Great question. We plan to use it primarily just for storage and office space. Though being a real no...

1:48:42 Clinical care provided in that space. It really doesn't meet clinical care criteria at this point. At some point, we'll be coming back to the town because I think long-term we'd like to take that old building down and probably put a clinic in that space, but that's probably 10 or 15 years out. Would a parking structure be something that you're discussing in the future as well, maybe? Yeah, we'd definitely have to consider parking as any part of that kind of planning.

1:49:13 You know, we're really, we built parking, we, I'm not sure if you're aware, but we vastly expanded our south parking lot. It's much larger than it was, and that's been a project that's been going on for about two years. Pretty much wrapping up, we've got a few details to do and some landscaping, but we've put parking everywhere we can on the existing campus, short of a multi-level parking structure, which is a big investment. Thank you. Sure.

1:49:43 Any questions, Commissioner Fleming? No. I just have a quick question for staff, and it could be for the applicant as well. The bus shelter that is being constructed on, what is it, Sierra Park? Sierra Park Road? Sierra Park, yeah. Is that, that's a partnership of 50-50 funding on private-public? Is that what I understood? Yes, that is my understanding, and there is a condition of approval, I believe it is number 46.

1:50:13 included in the resolution, which describes the 50% cost share for the construction of that transit shelter. Got it. And the bus shelter, will it be aesthetically similar to the other shelters throughout the community? It will be exactly the same design. Exactly the same design. Okay. That was really the only question I had. I appreciate your time. Thank you. Jamie, do we have any public comment, either in Suite Z or online?

1:50:43 Anybody in the audience? Public comment? No? Okay, with that, I'll close public comment. I'll bring it back to the commission. Any other questions for staff or the applicant you'd like to throw out now or would anybody like to make a motion? Okay, I make a motion to adopt the attached.

1:51:04 Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, the resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving design review 24-008 and administrative permit 25-001 with conditions recommended by staff. Perfect. Do we have a second? I second. Okay, we have a first and we have a second. Any further conversation, opinions, thoughts? None? Jamie, will we have a vote, please? Commissioner Fleming? Yes.

1:51:35 Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 3-0. Congratulations, gentlemen. Look forward to the new facility. All right. With that, we will close business matters and go to the consent agenda. I believe we only have the minutes of our March 18th meeting. Do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda? I make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Do I have a second? Second. Jamie, we have a vote, please. Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Vice Chair Verruck? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes.

1:52:08 We'll move on to Commissioner Reports. Does anyone have a report they'd like to put forth? I'll start on my right, Commissioner Fleming? No. Commissioner Verruck? No. I think I'm good. Yeah, it's still pretty busy out there. There must be spring break school districts down south that are still enjoying the snow. I know Mammoth Unified doesn't go on break until the third week in April, which I believe is the 21st to the 25th, something like that.

1:52:38 Looking at the other parent in the room. Don't look at me. So I think the numbers are good. Snow has been great. Yeah, get out there and enjoy it if you can. With that, we'll go to the Director's Report. Nolan, take it away, sir. Great. Just a few items to update the commission on.

1:52:57 We have interviews scheduled for April 16th, where the town council has interviews scheduled to interview two applicants for Commissioner Eckerd's vacant seat on the commission. So following that meeting, we will look to them to appoint somebody at that meeting and that new commissioner will be seated at the May meeting here.

1:53:23 The Snow Creek DA, which the commission considered at their last meeting, the town council considered it on April 2nd and they did vote unanimously 5-0 to approve that. So that will be coming up for a second reading here on April 16th at town council. Also the second reading for the Clearwater Specific Plan amendment will also be on that agenda.

1:53:49 Which the Commission previously reviewed and provided a recommendation on. And then just a brief update on construction. Updates throughout the community. Most of the projects will be coming, we anticipate them coming out of their winter kind of hiatus here in the next month or two. So we will have a much more informed update in May or June as to what looks like it's moving forward this summer. We have received these, you know.

1:54:16 Ongoing discussions with 6060 on some of their design changes. We do anticipate that coming forward at either the May or June commission meeting. And then following that meeting, we anticipate they will be underway on construction on that site this summer. We've also had discussions with residents in about them pulling their building permit to at least begin kind of preliminary construction on that site up off burner. But we don't have any concrete dates as to

1:54:44 When they'll fully be underway, same with Mammoth Creek Inn, we do, we know coming into last winter they had limited site work left to complete that project or at least call for final inspection, so we're hopeful that 2025 will be the year they finish. Optimist, I love it. Thank you, Nolan, appreciate it. And the dog park is officially open, is that correct? That is what we have heard, the dog park is officially open for summer.

1:55:15 Perfect. Thank you so much. With that, I'm going to adjourn today's meeting to our next regularly scheduled meeting, which is in this room, May 14th at 9 a.m. Thank you, everyone, for your time.