TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2023

Town Council Special meeting

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

206 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

7:49 Good evening. Good evening, all. Welcome to this special meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, April 26, 2023. Meeting is called to order. Jamie, if you could call the roll, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Here. Councilmember Ray? Here. Councilmember Rice? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Souser? Present. Mayor Wentworth? Present. Here. Thank you. Please lead us in the pledge. Thank you. Thank you very much.

8:44 Okay, so our first item this evening has been agendized for some interviews for the building advisory committee, but apparently one of the applicants is removed with their names. We only have one applicant. So we'll skip this process and we'll just deal with this as an item further down the agenda to actually approve that person. So that's what we'll do. That being said, let's move on now to some public comments. And just to remind everybody, these are for items that are not otherwise on this evening's agenda.

9:15 And just to be clear, some of you here for the TBID discussion that is on the agenda, you have an opportunity to speak your mind on that topic. Other items such as Measure A are not on this evening's agenda. So please come forward. I believe we have a timer this evening, Jamie, is that right? So we're going to start with three minutes, if that's okay for everybody. Thank you. Hey. Hi, good evening. Good evening. I'm Kendra Knight. Hi. Happy Earth Month. That's my comment. Yay, it's April. Happy Earth Month.

9:43 Just wanted you guys to know, thank you so much for everything you do. I have done about 10 assemblies and demos in our Mammoth Schools recently, including worm composting. The kids love digging into worms. And it has been a blast. I want you guys to know how much we're doing in the town with grant funding from the town of Mammoth Lakes. Thank you so much, you all. Thank you. Happy Earth Month. Happy Earth Month to you, too. Thank you very much, Kendra. Mr. Casabian. Sure.

10:17 Three minutes? Just watch Jamie's little lights right there. It's kind of like Christmas. Yeah. All right. Dan Casabian, Acting Chief, Mammoth Lakes Police Department. We've got some exciting times with the police department now. We've got a couple recruits that we've hired getting ready to go to the academy who are sitting over here to my right. I'll have them come up and briefly introduce themselves in just a second.

10:39 In order to hire somebody to the academy or hire them within an organization, there's an extensive background which takes about three to four months on a good day, sometimes six to eight months. So they've been through quite a bit to get to where they're at now. They were hired a couple weeks ago and Officer West has been working with them. Actually, the entire organization has been working with them, but Officer West has been working with them nonstop for the last two weeks.

11:06 Getting them prepared and getting them ready for the academy, which is a stress academy that lasts about six months. When I say stress, a lot of running, a lot of push-ups, sit-ups, pull-ups, that kind of stuff. And then they yell at you and try to get you mentally prepared for things that you're going to see when you get out on the street. So the first person I'd like to introduce is Jason. Jason Garcia comes from Bishop. He got married out of high school.

11:34 He lives with his high school sweetheart. He comes up here for work when he used to work up here. He used to work in construction. Came up here quite a bit and likes to snowboard, ski and mountain bike and fish and do the outdoors. He's excited to work for the town. He's excited to work for the community. He loves the community and wants to give back.

11:56 Maggie grew up in Fresno, moved to Mammoth in 2011. Kind of a cool story with Maggie, not that Jason's story's not cool. Kind of a cool story with Maggie. She graduated from Mammoth High School. Jason graduated from Bishop, so both local to the area. Maggie spent five years of her high school career as an explorer. So it shows that the explorer program for the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, Mono County Sheriff's Department, works.

12:23 And it's kind of like full circle. So she did five years. She absolutely fell in love with it. And here she is. So I'll let Jason come up, say a few words real quick. Go ahead, Jason. Hey, I'm Jason. And I just want to say thank you for this opportunity that you guys give us. And I'm willing to give my all for this community. I love this community.

12:54 This career just motivates me because I also have a family member here, Madera. He's also in the law enforcement and also just have other family members there for the law enforcement. Yeah, I just thank you guys for this opportunity. Maggie, thank you for this opportunity. It's nice to see you guys once again. It's going to be a very exciting journey.

13:30 Go through the six-month academy, something I've been waiting for when I was a former explorer, so it's going to be something very exciting to move on and work with the people that helped me grow as a person through the explorer program and be able to work beside them and beside everyone else in the town and be able to connect with the community. Thank you so much for the opportunity. Thank you. They start the academy on the second.

13:56 So we wanted to sneak them in here real quick so they can say hi and give their thanks and they're off to the academy come Saturday. Can we shake their hands and say hello because they're not going to be the same when they come back, right? Thank you for your service. Thank you. While you're down there, let us know how you're doing. Thank you both. And best of luck to you both. Any additional public comments out there? Hello, good afternoon.

14:50 My name is Lucero, and the reason that I'm here today is because I've been given a 60-day notice to vacay my apartment due to remodel. I'm seeking your help on a petition to place a moratorium, no fault eviction, on the declared emergency that started on January 2, 2023. The logic is as follows. There's already housing crisis. I'm sorry. Okay, take your time. And it has been impacted more by red tags and yellow tags.

15:21 My unit has not been red tagged. The reason that it is so strong is because my parents have been displaced from their home since September 2022. I've lived in Mammoth since I was five months, and I was a student at Mammoth USD K-12. I now have a 14-year-old and a 3-year-old daughter who attend Mammoth schools. I have three sisters and a mother that still reside in Mammoth.

15:56 I've been in contact with Patricia Robertson, and that's also been put on the list for the Purcell. We have been so unsuccessful with any help. I'm just asking for your help to put a moratorium help on nonstop for the eviction. This is not a time for an eviction unless it's absolutely necessary. I don't use drugs. I paid my rent on time. I'm simply asking for your help on this matter.

16:29 Thank you very much for coming forward. I know that the town manager is going to give an update on the snow emerging related items. And if you can hang around a little bit, maybe check in with him or check in with Sandra's back over there. Go say hi to Sandra. Make sure she's got your information. We're going to see what we can do, of course. Thank you very much. If I may. Sure. Probably in public comment, I don't know where the right space. Everybody may notice that I'm not sitting in my normal spot. I'm battling the end of a cold and trying to keep.

17:00 All of those around me from getting sick, I have sort of tried to, as best I can, isolate. Except for Dan. Well, you know. Let's see going here. Okay, okay, good. Thank you, we appreciate that, Bill. Thank you very much. Any other public comments? Anybody in the virtual world? No? Okay. All right, then we'll move on. We'll move on now to policy matters. This is item 5.1, to appoint an applicant to serve as a member of the Building Advisory Committee Board.

17:31 I think it's just, there's no manner in which we have to do this, so I would just move to a point

18:04 Dan Pollis to the Building Advisory Committee for the term that expires on April 1st, 2024. I'll second. Great. We have a motion to second. Any additional discussion? Not seeing any. Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Congratulations, Mr. Pollis. You've signed up for another tour. We appreciate your time and we appreciate your service.

18:31 Okay, moving on now to item 5.2. Council update and direction on management and response to extreme weather declared emergency. Mr. Holler and Mr. Haislip Hayes. Thank you. I'll kick it off and Hayes will have some items as well. Kind of walked through some of the items there as it relates to the staff report, but these are always prepared kind of a week in advance, so we have changes happening, et cetera, even now. So a lot of the work we have ongoing is winding down some of the...

18:59 Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation work, et cetera. We'll get a report out of them probably this next week, the total amount of homes that they were able to help with. We'll continue to work with MLH on some of the housing for folks who have lost their housing and others are slowly getting back in, those types of things. So we're working through that. Hazel will give you an update on the tagging process, the red tag, yellow tag, green tag, no tag.

19:29 Well, maybe not no tag, no. But anyway, that'll go through that. Also, the work with FEMA and what we're doing with them and trying to get in the right emergency declarations to add additional services and support in the community, which will be big for that element. The other one is we have got our kind of a draft of a program to help small businesses in terms with snow removal, snow costs and things of that nature.

19:58 We'll be asking for, brought up before, for $500,000 to commit to that program. We'll have a kind of two-tier grant, depending on the cost that people incurred for, whether it was just snow removal and or snow hauling. Make a little bit of distinction there, add additional cost. We're working through the guidelines. We'll have those out shortly. We've just got the first draft done. Be able to put that out, and that'll provide a lot of help to small businesses.

20:26 We can take a look. I'd need to follow up with Andy whether or not we can do the no-fault eviction process. We'd have to take a look at that. It's probably a short-term if we do do it from that type of nature. It's something we can definitely take a look at. And then the next real bunch of staff work that will happen is these ongoing projects, but then also complete an after-action report that will be required, I know, by Cal OES.

20:51 As well as just our own internal process and what we've looked at and things that we've done well and things where we can do better and be able to walk through that. And once that is done, we'll bring that back to council and then if we have any other groups we present that to or information put out on that. But we do want to spend some time working through that. There's different formats for it, but really it's really helpful as we look at it and not lose sight of things and these types of emergencies of how we respond and what we do.

21:20 You can always learn from them and do better, so plus some things that went well. So I'll highlight that. So I'm going to let Hayes dive into some of the other details and then I'll be glad to take any questions from the council. Thanks, Dan. A couple things. Tag updates. We started out with around 60 red tags. We've now reduced that to 35, working with the property owners, building department. We've found ways to get people back into the year units.

21:45 That has increased the number of yellow tags to 78, so these individuals still have a lot of work to do to reconcile the damage and so forth, but we're working to get these people back in their homes. Dan mentioned we've been working with FEMA, coordinating with Mono County. The week before last, we met with Cal OES and FEMA and did a tour of MCWD fire department and town infrastructure, really focusing on the public assistance side of things.

22:13 We're looking to get a declaration to potentially recoup some of our losses from the storm damage. In order to facilitate some of that data management, we've created an application. All of the parks workers, engineers, road workers have an application on their phone to collect data in real time on the damage they find and any of the repairs they make. So we can roll that up and give that to finance to hopefully recoup some of our losses if we do receive a declaration that allows us to do so.

22:43 Last week we met with FEMA, Cal OES, and the Small Business Administration on individual assistance. We'll hear back in about two weeks if we cleared those thresholds. That would make available funding for businesses and individuals from FEMA through a disaster recovery center. So we hope that we clear those thresholds and bring that assistance to the public.

23:10 I know someone's going to ask me about potholes, so I'm just going to get in front of it. The patch truck is out. We are targeting local streets with our own crews. We did secure a contract with a local asphalt company. We hired a grinder from out of area to start work on Monday. However, the weather is taking a turn for the worse. We do need warmer temperatures to pave with hot mixed asphalt.

23:39 We have not canceled it. We are still hopeful that we'll be able to get some of the most egregious work done, Sierra Nevada, Commerce, and so forth, before the weather turns on us. So we'll stretch it as far as we can and try to get as much done before, you know, we're kind of shut down by weather, and then we'll pick back up as soon as we can. We know there's a lot of work that needs to be done out there. We're well aware of the situation. Finally, I have heard a lot of comments about flooding, nuisance water, standing water.

24:09 There's a lot of snow banks still out there, and that turns into a lot of water. We know there's water in some of our low areas. It's kind of predictable in certain spots. We've also had reports of unusual locations, and then water kind of finds its way to the low spot and is definitely flowing in our larger drainages. I do want to caution the public. In a lot of these areas, you cannot see how much water is flowing because it is still covered in snow. There are snow bridges out there.

24:39 Huge amount of caution when, you know, for just traversing the snow, out snowshoeing, skiing, that you could fall through, and definitely use caution when you're around running water. Sandbags are still available at the town yard, $2.99 Commerce. They're pre-made. And definitely call us at Public Works if you see something that is unusual. We know there is a lot of water running. We have been tracking it. We've been out twice a day, kind of looking at our usual locations.

25:09 But if something gets plugged, culvert, or some drainage, it'll jump our historic drainage course and go somewhere else, and until someone notifies us, we generally don't know, so we do rely on the public to keep us abreast of any changes in water drainage. That's the end of my update. Happy to answer any questions. Thank you. Questions? No, not over here. First of all, I just want to say thank you so much. I know that...

25:44 Everybody I'm looking at in this side of the room has been working almost continuously since the emergency started, and I just hope you know how much people in town appreciate it. So I've been starting to get some inquiries from people who are talking to small business owners, for example.

26:02 And so nothing's getting stopped as quickly as a hurricane or a wildfire.

26:30 Knowing that, how can we advise people when we, you know, who should we point them to just to say, hey, maybe you could get an emergency bridge loan from this credit union or, you know, Dan mentioned that to me today. But I would just love to know as people are starting to really feel the effects, where should we point them just to, you know, sort of, and I see Sandra looks like she might, I don't know, or maybe you're just making eye contact. But if there's any advice you have, you know, it can come in, yeah.

26:59 You know, the chamber might be able to help. You mentioned the SBA. But I would love to have, like, a simple answer to tell people, and right now I just don't know what to say. That's a great question, and the answer is quite complex. Specific to the SBA, Cal OES, FEMA, I would say hang tight. Until we get that declaration, there's really not much we can do. I was told, because I asked this question if there was something we could do in advance, and they said if we gave them that information,

27:28 Everything would be denied because it hadn't been declared. And that would be some bad information for the public, so we decided not to go down that path. So hang tight. We were told two weeks, and that was last week, so I'm anticipating a week and a half. Mono County should get word if this is going to be available. The other opportunities, you know, we've got our small business program.

27:53 That Dan's putting together. You know, you can reach out to credit unions. There are other outlets that are kind of you went through. That's the extent of, you know, kind of what we have available at this moment. And maybe, Dan, you can elaborate on the program that you put together. Yeah, so two things to that. Yeah, we just had an email came in on Alta One, the credit union doing some stuff that way. Again, if the disaster is not...

28:20 I don't know if they would still provide the small amount of a bridge loan that they were looking at if that would work. SBA and stuff may have some things, but it wouldn't be under the disaster as yet. And one of those elements, if you do some stuff in the front end, you may not be eligible for that either. So there's some process and just timing on that. I think the other one, really what we were looking at, we talked about it early on, just given the unusual amount of snow and the cost of snow removal.

28:48 As we go back to work through that and be able to do some type of reimbursement back, if you will, or offset back. Again, we do that and we focus generally usually on smaller businesses. So we'll set an employee size and a total income for the year size. And our goal on that is, one, we want to keep those in business to the extent possible that this will help. The other side was with the small businesses, that's a key element of our employment and often kind of tight for folks.

29:18 Degrades the town, obviously. Very similar to what we did in COVID, some of the same public benefit processes. What we want to be cautious as we do that, we do make that public benefit finding. There is, I think, a good rationale to do that. If it's a one-off and we're just providing bridge loans and stuff, that may get us a little bit of trouble in terms of how we do that as a government.

29:40 Andy's listening in, so you can correct me if I'm wrong there, but I'd be cautious on that being sent as a gift, because what happens if it's not repaid, they still go out of business, you run into those types of issues. So to the extent that we can treat those businesses the same, or say we're reimbursing for some of the snow impacts, how they ultimately utilize those funds, if they've already paid or they have a CAM charge that's coming up to pay, we have to get information. But that actually may be able to help tide somebody over.

30:05 We're going back and forth a little bit on the maximum dollar amount, trying to get a feel of the number of businesses that may ask. As I mentioned, we're looking about a half a million dollar starting with that level of input financially. And so that will provide a pretty good chunk of change for a lot of, let's say, smaller businesses. And we'll look at is that cap two or three million a year in revenues or something like that for a small business. We'll take a look at some of our business license information and see what we can have to help narrow that down and see what it looks like.

30:36 And then a lot of them, they won't know their full cost yet, but I know, for example, the town's been put on notice already that our cam charges are going to go up quite a bit for the $600,000 plus spent on snow removal in the parking lot here at the Merritt Mall. So we know there's a lot of impacts out there on small businesses. I've talked to several. They expect to see anywhere from five to ten times what they normally pay. So being able to get something back out there to offset that, we know cost just for the...

31:05 Drugging and everything else that happened. So that'll help, and we can move that pretty quickly, get an application thing done, and then within a month at the longest, but it should even be potentially before that as we get that pulled together. So that would be a lot of these elements, and you hate to say that because the timing, some of them I know are holding on on the edge. And then other things we would encourage events to do is talk to their landlords if they have that issue.

31:35 Especially those who had structural damage or something. Are they still having to pay rent? Can they have that held off? Can they not pay? How badly? Do they want to keep them in the building? And those types of issues. And then we talked about it before. Some of it gets real complicated. And we expect there to be ongoing disputes between a tenant, an owner, property manager, probably a few other things in there as well in terms of

32:05 Andy, if you followed that. Andy, if you followed that.

32:32 As Dan was saying, I mean, anytime the town spends money on anything, you have to be able to make findings. There's a purpose, kind of a public benefit. And so it's best to have some kind of program with objective material that's open to more than just business. But if the council were to start making sort of individual decisions and picking and choosing, it would be just like. Okay, good. Bill, are you good? Okay.

33:05 A couple items again just on behalf of all of us. Thank you. You guys are working really hard and we appreciate that. We know this is the beginning of a very long road. Speaking of roads, the roads in Tahoe were much worse than they were here. I can tell you from firsthand experience that I'll be back up there tomorrow. I've got photographic evidence of that. Good to hear that the red tags are down. Good to hear in the FEMA that that work is proceeding. Who does that notice come from? Does it come from the county? Does it come from and what department in the county is responsible for this?

33:37 Yeah, so it'll go through the Office of Emergency Services, which is Chris McCrassick. And FEMA generally works, you know, federal to the state, to the county, and then the counties deal with the other levels of government. So it'll come through that process. Okay. Do we have anything from 16, 17 about where things flooded that might be helpful to just say, you know, to folks, look, this is, we know this is probably going to happen.

34:06 Is that anything we have easily available? We did track a number of locations, and we had a database where we kind of tracked some of the unusual activity. It's difficult to predict where these things are going to occur. Generally, water is flowing where we would expect it, but we've had a couple instances and a couple reports of some surprises. It subsided very quickly once water kind of found its way. We don't know if it was a blocked culvert that broke free or what was going on.

34:36 We do know of some general locations that we track regularly. Like I said, twice today we've gone out and looked at those locations. We know if there's a problem there, what will transpire, and so we're kind of watching those. But then, you know, there's so much water flowing under snow we can't see. We're kind of relying on the public to crowdsource any kind of surprises, if you will. Okay, and then finally, this is a little bit to one of your other side hustles, is...

35:08 The LTC, this Local Transportation Climate Adaptation Program. I know you've been busy doing other things. I shared with the chair, Rhonda Dugan, and with Elmato County staff, there was a session today where they're trying to set their guidelines, but this is a $400 million to $600 million pot of money. If you haven't heard it already, I hope we're tracking this thing. I know we've got an LTC meeting coming up on the 8th. I'm going to be interested, and I'm sure we're all going to be...

35:40 Wanting to know what might be there for all of us. It's directed at LTCs, it's climate resilience, it's climate mitigation, all that kind of stuff. So I just wanted to make sure that's on your radar. Yeah. Okay. So we're good? I'm sorry, is there public comment? Okay, I'm sorry, please. Pam Mitchell, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Is it unmuted? Yes. Yes. Oh, good. Thank you. Thanks very much. And I'm sorry, this comment should have come in.

36:17 Probably earlier, but I wanted to ask about the road repair work being done and the asphalt work being done, that type of thing. Who those companies are and who is the one being brought from the outside and if this will be prevailing wage work? That's an excellent question for our public works director. Please go ahead. Black gold asphalt is the contractor and yes, it's prevailing wage.

36:52 Thank you. Does that help, Pam? She's gone. No, I understand. I understand. Okay. Anything else out there? Okay, good. Thank you all very much. Keep up the great work, and we look forward to making our way through this most interesting set of situations. Okay, so we'll move on. And, ma'am, did you get a chance to talk to Sandra, right? Or she's coming around? She's coming around. Good. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Sandra.

37:23 Okay, so moving on now to item 5.3, resolution of intention to renew the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Improvement District. Dan. Yes, I'll kick it off with the staff report, a little bit of background and some process stuff we'll need to follow through. So, as we've had different discussions regarding the Tourism Business Improvement District, you'll hear us refer to that as the TBID, or to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Business Improvement District.

37:53 We've had a lot of comments regarding it being a tax and it is not. It's an assessment on

38:21 Particular businesses as defined as being benefiting from a tourism activity. I think that's a key issue because ultimately we do see that the vast majority of businesses pass that assessment on to their customers. They're not required to. There's a couple in town that do not. They just pay it through their own calculations versus a pass-through.

38:43 And so, but it isn't an assessment that goes to those businesses. It's not a tax that comes back to the town, for example. It's not a general tax that can be utilized for any public purpose. It's very much restricted on how it can be utilized to do that. But we'll spend a little more time on that. But as the process I mentioned, it starts with this evening, where you will be considering a resolution of attention, which means we're setting forth the attention that we want to renew the T bid.

39:12 The first step to be able to do that, though, is you have to have a written petition signed by tourism businesses, those owners that who will pay more than 50 percent of the assessments proposed to be levied. So it's a key issue there. It's just this follows the state law requirements on these types of districts. And so before we dive into a lot of discussion, we need to confirm that. The petitions have been submitted to the clerk accordingly.

39:40 Jamie can report out on what we have received. We have 62.64% received petitions. In favor. Yes. We're supporting the TBIN. That's what they're for, yes. So given that we have over that 50% threshold, that allows us to proceed with the resolution of intention as presented. The information in the packet that's presented to you is

40:11 Thank you.

40:40 As we go through this, the council has a couple of different points on this. I'll kind of walk through the quick process. The first one is tonight on the attention to renew. All of these are permissive to the council, so for some reason tonight the majority of the council, we do not want to proceed. It would be over this evening. It is permissive in state law for you to make that type of an action. Going forward, if it goes forward tonight, we have to send out a notice.

41:09 to the business to let them know that's happening. It sets up two additional steps in the process. One is a general public meeting, which allows for a public dialogue and discussion on the TBID. There's no action related to the TBID necessary at that public meeting. The current structure, however, though, we are proposing that you actually introduce an ordinance at that meeting.

41:32 The ordinance introduction deals with the fee structure being put in place ultimately by an ordinance. Andy can probably speak to this in more clarity than I can, but it's a taxpayer initiative that is qualified for the November ballot. If it is passed, it's retroactive, so if you have fees of this nature that have not been adopted by an ordinance, if I'm saying it right, Andy, it nullifies that, so you'd have to go back and do the process. Yeah.

42:01 Dan's right. The ballot measure, if it's adopted, would retroactively require finance measures, both taxes and assessments like this one, to have been adopted by ordinance. So that hasn't taken effect. We don't know if the voters will approve it. But the idea is that although the current law says this could be adopted by resolution, the thought is that we might as well have it adopted by ordinance if it's going to be adopted at all, just to protect it against being retroactively wiped out if that measure passes.

42:33 Thank you, Andy. So the introduction of that would be on May 17th as part of a regular public meeting, the management district plan, that nature. Just real quick, so that May 17th meeting, that'll be a public, regular town council meeting or a special town council meeting? I think it's on a regular date. It's a regular meeting date. Regular town council meeting. Okay, thank you. The council will convene as the council holds a public meeting. Okay, thank you. That would be followed up, assuming that goes forward, which there's no action at that meeting. We would follow up then on June 14th.

43:06 with a formal public hearing and the second reading of the ordinance. At that public hearing, you go through the public hearing process, and that's where the council that has an opportunity again to, it's permissive. We decided we don't want to go forward. Yes, we do. We're good with the way it's been presented. Done deal. Or you can modify.

43:30 The district management plan. You can modify what was presented. There's some limits on that. You can't increase rates, but you could lower rate, for example, or you can do a modification to the plan. So that's just kind of laying that process out. And then there's a couple of timelines for the ordinances, which take 30 days. And then there's an open period of time to the T-BID itself, where somebody can challenge the creation of the T-BID, which also falls in that. And then the goal would be if it's all passed and goes through,

43:59 That it would then be effective as of September 1st with the existing TBID expiring August 31. So there's no break in that process for the collection of the TBID revenues, if you will, those assessments coming in. So that's the general process. It's kind of laid out in the resolution that's in the staff report that's presented. So I just want you to, there's several steps in this we'll need to follow through and make sure that we're walking through that.

44:29 The TBID is currently proposed for 10 years. There is two changes in terms of the business types that are being assessed in the rates. They've incorporated, along with ski resorts, golf courses. So the two courses in town would be paying 2.5% of their revenues, basically, as being assessed. The other element on that is that went from a...

44:58 I did want to touch on a couple of

45:24 So the resolution that's presented in the packet has that information in it. So if you do go forward and you're adopting the resolution as recommended, this isn't the time to modify and change and do that, because that comes after the public hearing process. So a little more, a little different than some of our processes here. And I'm going to walk through some of this stuff, and then I do want to note we have several members of the MLT board and MLT executive director, Mr. Erte, here, who can speak to this as well.

45:52 I think maybe more detail or clarity than I will provide. But we've been well, we've been engrossing this pretty hard for a few weeks, and they've been involved with it for over a year. So I think some of the key elements that I want to highlight that's in the plan, some of it was prepped going into this and some discussions since this has been brought forward. I'm looking at the actual management district plan. I'm on page seven. This deals with an initial estimated annual budget.

46:20 It's $6,668,250,000. And that is based on the assessment percentages that are presented here as well by the different types of businesses. So that is the initial base budget. And the way the plan is set, it then breaks it down by how those funds would be utilized. And then that carries forward through the life of the team. There's some modifications that can be done annually if we move some money around.

46:50 And so the current plan, if you look at the packet, it actually allows, there's 45% that goes to air service, there's about 47.6% going to marketing, there was 5.4% going to contingency reserve, and then the town has a 2% administrative fee for the collection processes and stuff, and that comes back to the town. So that was the proposal coming forward. The two elements that were modified in some of the discussion in here, one was

47:19 We've added a little stronger language regarding the development of tourism-related infrastructure. We'll talk more about that shortly. And then the air service marketing subsidy. There's actually, it's on page 37 of the packet or page 9 of the report toward the top. We actually talk about the air subsidy portion being capped at 85% of the budget that can actually go to the subsidy side.

47:46 There's additional dollars that can go into the marketing side for air. So there was a cap placed on the total amount that could go to air subsidy. The marketing side is what it is for everything else. And all of these expenditures, as they come in, need to be designed to benefit those businesses who are being assessed. In the law, you'll read it, it'll talk about a special benefit being conferred on those businesses that are paying the assessment.

48:14 I.e., you can have some spill over. There's obviously some general public benefit, but if that's too broad or that's what we're trying to achieve, then that's not a legal use of the T-bid assessment funding. It has to go back to benefit the businesses who pay it. There's a couple places in the law where it talks about proportionality, so not 100%, but if you're paying 1% and you're getting 80% of the benefit, that could be something that could get challenged in the T-bid structure.

48:42 So those pieces are out there as you walk through the legal framework to do that. And in here it talks about that specific benefit. It walks through it. There's several statements. The elements being done is to drive business and to drive tourism business to those folks who are paying that T-Bid. And then the different rates and the amount you pay then is also related to that benefit. At a good level there, it's difficult to say how many people show up and walk into each business.

49:14 Patronize a particular business, but it is there. The contingency reserve was there. It was modified, and we did it in the existing one here recently as well, the current TBID, to address a California tax issue regarding the payment of sales tax on top of the tax on retail businesses. So that has been addressed in the plan as well. Excuse me.

49:40 The rest of the plan goes through it and we can answer any particular questions. I'll defer probably to the MLT staff on some of the other elements in the plan. The one piece I do want to speak to is based on the conversations that we had jointly with the MLT board, council and staff, was really trying to hear and listen to some of the concerns being raised, I'll say publicly, but really by town council.

50:09 And the thing this evening is just about the T-bid, so I'm not going to speak to other funding sources for MLT being out of other town resources and the Measure A funding. Measure A refers to old tax measures that were all passed, and they had the letter A on it, so they're called Measure A. It's not something that's new or a new tax or anything of that nature. But the things we heard from town council really focused a little bit on just total marketing dollars for one. How much are we spending?

50:39 We have a lot of people coming in. Cleminary March numbers actually came in stronger in TOT than we expected, even with the weather. So that was good to see from a revenue standpoint. When we had the discussion with town council, I think there was a general consensus that the marketing is effective. It is beneficial to the community. I always have fun discussions on marketing, how much of it is really effective and isn't.

51:05 It's definitely there, and it has provided that benefit to the community. I think there's general concurrence that there is a benefit out of that marketing dollars. A lot of other things drive rates in people, so it's not solely marketing. The other piece has been a long discussion the last several years regarding air service and providing a regional level of air service in this area with the most recent shift in the United going out of Bishop.

51:34 We have charter service working out of Mammoth Yosemite Airport. And that has also seemed to be a valid benefit of bringing those destination-type visitors into our region and those elements. You can debate down the road on how much air service and from where and those issues. But I think those two primary services that the TBID supports, it seemed to be consensus that those were still valid things to do. The third piece that really came up with discussion...

52:03 Was back to how do we invest or make sure that we invest in infrastructure and amenities? A little bit of discussion of what that means, talking to people and asking when you say infrastructure, what do you mean? And it goes from everything to patching the potholes to beautification to parking structures to bike racks to better sales service. It kind of just runs the whole gamut. So every dog park's been thrown in there as well.

52:32 You guys had a much longer list from MLT. So you look at all that type of stuff. So one of the things we tried to do is take a look at it and say, given the feedback we got, there was also concern about the term of the management plan, whether that would be 10 years, is that the right term, or should it be shorter at a five-year term? We've had some comments asking for a two-year term. We've had other elements. And so we really did try to take the comments we heard and work through.

53:01 Some potential modifications. And I want to present these just so people are aware of them, understanding that you cannot do that tonight. After the public hearing, the council will have that opportunity to adopt a plan with modifications if you so desire. But I do want to put this out there. We started this at staff level. We met with a small subset, if you will, of the MLT board.

53:24 To let them know that we were going to talk to this and so they're familiar with it and going in there. So I'm going to pop up a chart on the screen and speak to that and I'll get through that and then I'll open up for any questions and comments from council and then also to the public and elements there as well. I've lost a document. It'll take me a second to find it. I did practice this earlier, so there we go.

54:18 And the main thing we took a look at was, again, going off of the comments that we received, was looking at carving out a portion of the TBID that would be directed at that infrastructure very clearly. We'll still have to go through the process and define what infrastructure and making sure it still has the benefit back to businesses. The other side of this is more than likely the types of infrastructure we're looking at will have some broader benefit as well as direct benefit.

54:48 I'm just wondering what percent we ended at. Okay, thanks. Yeah, so I'll walk through this. So what we did,

55:19 We actually reduced the contingency in reserve down to 2%.

55:49 The thought there is there is a reserve already within the TBID funding that's held by MLT, so there is additional contingency there or reserves if there is a need or an issue that comes up or an extra program that needs additional funding. The town admin fee is held the same. What we ended up doing in the math was reducing that contingency side and then reducing the amount of sales and marketing going.

56:19 Out of TV, that went down to 45%. We left the air service at the existing 45%. So that would stay the same. And so reductioning on the marketing side, again, trying to listen to the comments we got was how much is enough marketing. And that's, again, very difficult. But this does reduce that down by a percent and a half or so, a couple percentage points at the most, to be able to do that.

56:46 In discussing this with the MLT board, the two other pieces that came into play was looking at the term and also looking at the additional half percent that would be collected from the Mammoth Mountain related activities in the golf courses. The discussion with all of that, the request was made to look at the first request is why can't we still move to a 10-year term?

57:16 We didn't hear a lot of support for that. So the proposal would be at a seven-year term. There was at least some discussion about that, just given the cost of when you have to renew these. But also then to leave that additional half percent into the collection process, even though initially it was done based on a 10-year term. So a little give and take on both sides of the table, if you will, or maybe it was a four-sided table. I don't remember. Three-sided at least.

57:46 Working through that. And so if this isn't written in stone yet, we'll actually come back with edits to the document that you'll need to approve if this goes forward. But did want to daylight that out there so the proposal comes in to say we want to have a piece of the pie that is called out specifically for, you know, infrastructure amenities for tourism. We wanted to reduce the marketing side a little bit.

58:11 In terms of that, that seemed to be the other concern. There seemed to be less concern on the air subsidy side if we capped it, which we do. The plan already, and it continues, of that budget to air service, only 85% of it, about $2.5 million that can go to air subsidy. So it does cap that, so it's not an open book process. The other amendment we looked at is there's a shift up to 20% of the budget in any given year.

58:38 The current plan allows that shift to happen, but then it stays there. The recommendation is to have it reset each year back to the base budget, and there's some back and forth on that pro and con issue there as well. But the idea there was really trying to listen to what the business community said in terms of the support, listening to individual council comments, because I don't know if there's a full consensus on some of these items, so we're really trying to...

59:07 Address a number of comments in this type of approach. So let me pause there. Those are the key elements that we want to look going forward. So there's two elements here. One is what is in front of you is what you'd be voting on this evening. The proposal here is not probably 100% baked, but it's the concept, if that makes sense, then we can take that forward. And that would come back ultimately for discussions probably at the public meeting, but really for action.

59:38 At the public hearing stage for any amendments to the plan. Okay, so I think what I think we'd like to do is maybe hear from a representative from MOT just based on what Dan said, and then we'll turn to council questions after that. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, council. Thank you for having us. As was mentioned, we received 62.64%. That is not the highest petition level that we've ever had. Back in 2013, we were upwards of 68%.

1:00:11 It was also back when we were judging off of total revenues because we had no TBIT in place to say this is where people committed. But this year we did receive 104 petitions. That's about 25% more than we did even in that first year. So that is by far the largest number. You know, looking at where we've been with this process, as the town manager had mentioned, we've been working on this now for more than 13 months. You know, this is not something we take lightly and we don't think anybody else should as well.

1:00:41 When we've talked about the successes of the TBID in the past, you know, the 10 years prior to the implementation of the TBID, we were seeing an average of about $10.8 million. With the pace that we're on for this year, the 10 years of the TBID, this town will basically be looking at almost double that, nearing about $20 million average in TOT each year. MLT is well aware that we are not responsible for 100% of that.

1:01:05 We've got a rather large business up the hill that spends quite a bit of money and now has quite a few hundred thousand pass holders that help us as well. When we have talked about this, and I know that some of the council members have recognized this and commented on it, we're not just a marketing agency. In the past five, six years, we have very much turned towards a management agency. We've been able to be very flexible with what we do.

1:01:30 We've been able to utilize our funds. As the town manager had mentioned, the TBID funds are somewhat restricted, but we've been able to use those funds to be able to turn on a dime when we need to. Even prior to COVID, we had been shifted to stewardship. Mayor Wentworth and I have had comments or conversations for seven years about kind of what we need to do, and we have been working on that piece. At the onset of COVID, we halted all the marketing. We asked people not to come.

1:01:57 And we stood up a $300,000 food bank so that we could hopefully keep our employees in town for the few weeks that we expected to be closed. Little did we know. But I think that was very successful by the time we opened on June 19th. We were able to at least keep a good portion of our folks still here. When we reopened, there was just a major focus on education versus visitation during that peak COVID time. We knew people were coming. They were escaping the cities.

1:02:23 So the flexibility that we've had out there has turned into our ongoing stewardship messaging. The Real on Real campaign is all about stewardship. It's really not about, hey, come here. It's when you come here, do this, don't do that. During times of smoke and fire, we really focus on what people are still available to do and really keep people up on conditions. And even during this massive winter, we've been really focused on be patient, be considerate, be kind.

1:02:49 Things are going to be challenging. If you're coming, please expect to have delays and challenges. And really, our major focus as an organization has been on the need times. You know, we know that the holidays and the weekends and the wintertime are strong. We need people here on Tuesdays, midweek winter. We need people here in the fall. The fall numbers, if you look at the TOT growth, September has more than doubled with the idea that we're getting people here for fall colors. And then really...

1:03:18 You know, talking about spring now, obviously we have skiing until who knows when. We are challenged with things like Tioga Pass. When will that open? I think with the melt that we're seeing, hopefully we're not too far off of where we were in 2017, which was kind of end of June, so maybe it's early July, but probably not going to hurt us as bad in some of those situations as we thought it might. You know, we are your marketing agency. We are your partner. You know, we were hired back in 2010 to operate for the town as an NGO.

1:03:46 And to bring people here and to, at the time, stave off potential municipal bankruptcy and really to grow those periods that we talked about. As we move forward, you know, we've heard from the business community and our community itself that they support the TBID, but they really feel that we need to work on mitigation efforts, and that includes infrastructure.

1:04:08 I think that a lot of our board members have been out talking to different businesses throughout the community, and it's been very clear that they feel that that's great, we're bringing all these people here, but the experience is suffering because we're not doing X, Y, and Z. We're very well aware of that. We have been more than happy to participate on the infrastructure side, and so that's where I think the management district plan reflects the comments that have been made at our various meetings so far. It's been a positive force.

1:04:37 For the community as well as our town revenues. Again, as of today, this is our second best DOT year ever, and we have three months left. We're $11 million ahead of budget. That's fantastic. That gives you a lot of leeway to work with the parcel. That gives you a lot of leeway to work with finishing the CRC or trails or bike paths or parking or whatever we have to do. Since 2013, the town has been fortunate enough to bring in nearly $55 million more than budget, and we have been proud to be part of that.

1:05:07 Process to help drive the future prosperity for our community. And really just in general, we want to thank you for your support. Thank you. So at this point, council members, you got any questions for Dan or for the MOT folks? Then we'll go to public comment after that. Who's got a question? Please, thank you. This one's for you, John Urdi. What would you say you gave us the average TOT?

1:05:36 Prior to TBID and what the average has been since TBID's been in effect. What would you say your average budget has been annually that you've spent? So starting back prior to 2013, our budget was about $2 million, maybe $2.5 million. Since then, our average budget's probably been around $5.5.5. Over 10 years, it's $5.5? Yeah, $5.5, $6 million. I don't have it off the top of my head. And then what's been your biggest? This year.

1:06:06 Yeah, we had, last year we budgeted conservatively, so we carried over about a million and a half dollars. We also put about $600,000 from our Measure A reserve, our dollars that we have as far as Measure A, into the program this year. Okay, and would you, do you have the number for that biggest budget year? 10.5 million. 10.5, okay, thank you. I just have a question for Andy. Dan, you outlined it a little bit, but I just am not crystal clear on, in the legislation,

1:06:40 Andy, would you be able to help articulate what are the kinds of things that infrastructure projects that we could use TBID dollars for that would meet all the criteria? Good question. So the TBID law has a definition section. And one of the things in the definition section is activities because the TBID is allowed to fund activities.

1:07:07 So the things that are included in activities, and this is in section 36606 of the Streets and Highways Code, if anybody wants to go look it up, but the activities definition includes things like promotion of tourism within the district, marketing and economic development, and then about infrastructure, it says providing security, sanitation, graffiti removal, street and sidewalk cleaning, and other municipal services supplemental to those normally provided.

1:07:36 So the idea is that it still has to be stuff that benefits all the payors, but these are examples of things that are considered to be okay if you can find that they benefit all the payors. And with respect to infrastructure or other municipal services, the funding has to be used to provide things that are above and beyond what the local government would otherwise be able to do.

1:08:06 You know, every potential expenditure is kind of fact-specific, and you'd have to be able to tie that expenditure to a benefit to the businesses. But the fact that the legislation provides these examples of the kinds of things that may be okay helps. So, you know, I can't say definitively that every infrastructure improvement would fit within this, but certainly there could be some things that do.

1:08:38 I do appreciate that comment, Bill, because...

1:09:31 I do think our community needs a little bit of a civics lesson. I'm getting a lot of emails like vote no on measure A. So I think we could do a little bit of a better job of informing the community actually what this process is. I know it's not easy to understand, even for some of those of us who are really in the know. So I would, again.

1:09:58 Our community needs a little bit of a lesson on how this works because, yeah, someone telling me to vote no on a measure that's been passed by the voters is not. And I inform those people what is happening, but it would be great to have some talking points and maybe some social media pushed out as to what this process actually is. I also want to comment on, and Bill, again, I appreciate what you said. I think we don't need to get in the back and forth of this.

1:10:26 In regards to, John, you saying that the business owners are saying they would like to see a little more infrastructure spending as part of the TBID, the business owners that have emailed me have said they do not want to see and they do not think it's appropriate for MLT to be investing in infrastructure. So if you have...

1:10:46 Members that you know of the business community that do think that that's a good idea, please tell them to contact us. Yeah. Because right now it seems like that's not. Yeah, and that's also the mix on my board as well. Got it. Okay, great. And I'm not sure where I land on that. But that's not a conversation for tonight. So thank you. Thank you. Sure, go ahead. Yeah, Bill, I appreciate you saying that.

1:11:12 But I do think there's some things that this is our only chance to clarify. The one thing that I just wanted to reiterate, Dan did a great job, but just in case people weren't totally paying attention, May 17th is the public meeting, and June 14th is the hearing. So if members of the public have something to say, those are your two opportunities, and I strongly encourage people, because, you know, we are, we're getting a flood of emails, but I'd rather have people

1:11:38 Give us informed input. And I think in order to do that, you have to participate in the process a little bit because it, you know, so I'll leave it at that. Anything else? I just want to make sure that, John, for you and your board, whatever Dan said, does that, any qualifying things in what he said? And Dan, same thing for you, back and forth, just so we can, we're all on the same page as we head off on this process. Yeah, and I would like to, between Dan and Rob,

1:12:09 We have had a number of meetings earlier this week. We had a meeting with a number of our board members as well just to talk about where we're going and what the process looks like. And so I do appreciate the time. And so everything that Dan has brought up today has been something that we have spoken about. And I think that we are comfortable with moving forward. OK, I think the only sort of outstanding question we will get into tonight is kind of the arbitrary and capriciousness that came down with the tax thing from the state.

1:12:38 And I want to make sure that we explore what's happened with the infrastructure side of that. Andy, it's a question for a later day, but to make sure that we don't have an exposure to something, some arbitrary thing like that. I guess we always do, but it'd be interesting to explore that down the road. Yeah, I guess I'm confused. I'm not sure what you're... Well, the fact that there was the sales tax piece where businesses were told all of a sudden, actually, that's a burden that you have to address. And so if we start getting into the infrastructure pieces, some other pieces like that,

1:13:06 Whatever the board was in the state that made that ruling that said this is actually a tax burden all of a sudden, I would like to understand better if there are other components of the TBID that we may want to bring forth that we will bring forward, do we still have that kind of exposure to that body somewhere in Sacramento that could arbitrarily make a determination about something? Yeah, and that was specifically on sales tax, so I think unless we have anything moving forward that's going to affect...

1:13:31 So as far as that issue is going with restaurants and retail, which are the sales tax focused.

1:13:57 Lodging doesn't have sales tax. Ski area doesn't have sales tax. So those are the two affected groups. I don't know that it will expand. But then again, we didn't know this was going to come up after nine and a half years. Okay, we'll put that entire headache off to a later time. At that point, it's time for any public comment. Folks like to speak on this item. Hi, John Morris, Director of Operations for Snow Creek Resort, Chairman of the Lodging Association.

1:14:28 Proud sole surviving original member of the MLT board after 13 years. Good evening, Mayor Wentworth and esteemed members of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council. Tonight you will vote on a resolution of intent to renew the TBIT. I ask that you do so based on facts and not on emotions. Emotions are running high in our town after this winter. We all know that. We're all exhausted after enduring one of, if not the biggest winters on record.

1:14:56 Were there challenges? Yes. Did the winter expose some of our town's weaknesses and needs? Absolutely. And can we use the lessons learned from this historic winter to create a better place for locals to live and guests to visit? We must. Tonight you will hear that support for the TBID by the business community is still very high. In fact, more businesses have returned their petitions supporting the TBID renewal.

1:15:22 In fact, all of the business who are supporting the renewal at this time are also supporting a 10-year T-Bid. In fact, the T-Bid is being renewed with no increase to the rates for lodging establishments, restaurants, or retail because Mammoth Lakes Tourism heard loud and clear from the business community that while they do support renewing the T-Bid,

1:15:52 They did not want to see an increase in these rates. We know that the TBID and MLT in general have their detractors. There are some in this community that will say that we don't need to market at all. The people will just come. I ask, based on what information, what studies, what evidence? Here's a fact. When Colorado slashed its marketing budget, it took 10 years to recover. Some say,

1:16:21 Well, we don't need to market for the next year because everybody heard about our record winner and they'll still come. I asked, based on what evidence? Fact, when Sedona cut its marketing budget, it lost 15% of its market share in six short months. Like it or not, we live in a world with a fairly short-term memory. To quote Janet Jackson, what have you done for me lately? Sorry.

1:16:49 We have to remind our loyal guests that we're still here and at the same time look to attract new visitors to Mammoth Lakes. It's very important. Both of these groups are constantly and all of us are being bombarded with messages about and invitations to beautiful places to live or to visit, excuse me, recreate and enjoy other than Mammoth Lakes. And I'm willing to bet.

1:17:14 That none of these other destinations are cutting their marketing budgets anytime soon. If someone were to be able to show me that slashing our marketing budget would lead to prosperity, I would love to see that evidence. In closing, I know we have work to do. There are many, many projects that need to be put in motion to make Mammoth Lakes a more enjoyable place to live and work for myself, my neighbors, my employees, my community, while also

1:17:45 Thank you for your time tonight.

1:18:15 Thank you for all your service to the community, and I look forward to your yes vote on renewing the TBID. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Morris. Okay, anybody else? Okay, I guess there's nobody else. Oh, wait, there's some movement in the crowd. Thank you. Yeah, I'll probably repeat this come on the 14th or whatever, but I'll go ahead and say tonight, as I've been listening to the debates going on about TBID for the last two months.

1:18:54 Even though I've watched John work on it for the last almost two years. Good evening. My name is Ken Bringle. I'm Executive Director of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. And I'm proud to say that Monday was my six-year anniversary in Mammoth Lakes. I'm here first to inform the Town Council that the Mammoth Lakes Chamber Board of Directors has unanimously endorsed the TBID renewal with the 10-year term.

1:19:23 Every MLCC board member who is a T-bid remitter has signed and returned their petitions. Second, as a word of caution, don't let our marketing efforts suffer a death by a thousand cuts. If you continually siphon off funds for non-marketing efforts, you will lose your position in the marketplace. Kind of what John was just talking about.

1:19:53 The purpose of your marketing is to increase economic activity, which in turn increases your local tax revenue. In fact, it's projected to be $12 million more than budgeted this year. Third, this is about employment. We are a tourist-based economy. Every job in this community is reliant on strong visitation. Our chamber members want to be able to offer their employees consistent year-round employment.

1:20:25 The TBID has been the primary factor in driving the midweek and shoulder season visitation that is giving our businesses that opportunity. On July 1st of this year, I will celebrate my 47th anniversary of the start of my Chamber Resort Association career. In that time, I've been the chief executive at three separate DMOs, Destination Marketing Organizations.

1:20:54 I've been CEO of the Durango, Colorado Area Chamber Resort Association. I've been CEO of the Big Bear Lake Resort Association here in California. And I've been president and CEO of the Montrose Association of Commerce and Tourism in Montrose, Colorado. Each of those organizations were responsible for the tourism marketing of their respective community. Something that has always stayed with me was a Ben Franklin quote.

1:21:24 The Drango Herald used to have on its masthead. The quote was, there are three things everyone thinks they can do better than anyone else. Make love, poke a fire, and write a newspaper. After my experiences, I want to add a fourth, and that's market a community. Concerning the TBID, there is only one question this council needs to consider. Do you trust Jeremy Goico, Deb Radcliffe, John Mendel?

1:21:56 Pat Foster, Darlene Manger, John Morris, Eric Clark, and your colleague, Bill Sauser. They are the ones guiding MLT. They are the ones directing the policies that guide the direction of the organization. There is a management philosophy that is universally accepted in the nonprofit management field called policy governance. The ends versus the means. The ends of the organization.

1:22:25 Policy, direction, what the organization will look like in one year, five year, ten years, is the responsibility of the board of directors. The means, the day-to-day management of the organization, the budgeting, the management, financial management, the implementation of board policy and direction is carried out by the staff. The T-Bid Management Plan is the MLT board of directors vision and direction for MLT.

1:22:54 Truly the ends of the organization. Please provide, please approve the 10-year T-bid management plan as presented by the MLT Board of Directors so the MLT staff, those empowered with completing the means of the organization can get to work to securing in concert with the town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce and the other economic drivers.

1:23:22 The economic future of Mammoth Lakes. Thank you. Thank you very much. Can I make a comment? Sure. Please keep our comments to the three-minute limit. As Shakespearean as that was, I feel it's disrespectful to the council if we deliberately go over the three-minute limit, and that's why we have a limit. Thank you. I'm sorry. I thought I had five minutes. I'm sorry. It was down to three minutes. Can you change it to five minutes for this evening? Yep. Thank you.

1:23:57 I won't be three minutes. Question, aren't you considering renewing the T-bid and at a later time you will discuss five years, ten years, 20 years, et cetera, et cetera? Mr. Town Manager. Yes, the item before you tonight is as presented, the tenure, and as you get to the public hearing, that action then can modify what's been presented. I think...

1:24:23 They have a 10-year limit, I forget, on the law, but that's where you could modify it to a 5 or a 7 or a 2 or not approve it. So council isn't locked in, much like the ballots that were sent out, which were supposed to be just kind of advisory, not official business votes. I believe I quote you, right? They're official business votes. I talked to one of you, and it was just to get an idea of support to the business community. You did not say it was an official business vote.

1:24:55 Absolutely told me something different. This is what is required to present to Council as the vote to move forward, as is this meeting tonight. So does the business community vote again? No. I was misled. I apologize. I don't think anyone in the business community wants to stop marketing. I just think in the business community there are a lot of things to address. A 10-year T-bid renewal makes the T-bid...

1:25:24 So, I'm not against the marketing. I think the marketing is great.

1:25:54 But I think we have a lot of needs in the community. I think 10 years is too long. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. You guys figure it out. Yeah. Terry Stelick, Seasons 4 Condominium Rentals. I actually was on the original board of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I actually helped start this, and I was the president for a couple years in that. And I haven't been involved for about the last three years. But to my knowledge, if this is something that's renewed for 10 years,

1:26:34 The town has the opportunity to bring a contract that's negotiated within that time frame so that if there's something that needs to change, that needs to happen within Mammoth Lakes Tourism within the town, that that can be negotiated within a contract that says these are your deliverables for the next two years, three years, whatever. And maybe I'm incorrect in this. I don't think that you would be setting something right now that's for 10 years.

1:27:02 Doesn't change or isn't overseen or anything else for that time frame. So, I don't know. Yeah, that's a very good question. We've talked about that before. Dan or Andy, do you want to weigh on that, please? Yeah, I can jump in on it. The two elements to that is with MLT, we have two different pieces of that. One is the MLT agreement that deals with non-TBID funds. A lot more oversight, deliverables, everything else. The TBID, once the management plan is adopted,

1:27:32 That budget allocation, we have no authority at the council level to change that. So it stays for air service or marketing or capital infrastructure. So there's a lot less agreement even in that contract. The contract we have with MLT-related TBIT is to implement it. The ability to direct that implementation on a given year is extremely limited. From the TBIT law and language, it really falls to that agency we're required to contract with.

1:28:01 So there's more flexibility on one side than on the other, if I may, between TBID and other revenues. So the TBID is very limited. Yes, thank you. And I will add that the council's discretion is mostly here on the front end in deciding whether and how to renew the TBID. Once it's renewed, there's a lot less flexibility and discretion. Okay, Mr. Truax. What do you mean? Brent Truax, Managing Director of the Sierra Nevada Resort Spa. I recognize what tonight is, so we're not going to go ahead.

1:28:37 Detailed numbers because I think we all understand that process. I'm just here to say I am in support of moving this to the next level. I believe that MLT provides a very valuable functions for this community. We can define that as we keep going on. It's going to always be redefined from council to council from time to time. But there's needs that are coming up, not only for air service, but also I look right now and say, what's going to happen this coming June? Are we going to have mountain biking? Maybe. Maybe not. We're going to have golf. Sometime.

1:29:06 When is some of this stuff going to happen? Devil's Postpilot going to open when? Route 120 going over to Tiago Pass to Yosemite is going to happen when? So I think we're going to have some challenges going forward. I also want to echo some of the other comments going forward. We as a community also have to keep our focus on where our needs are. And for instance, we all have our individual needs right now. For instance, I'm trying to find staff that have housing in this community that can afford a particular housing unit.

1:29:36 It's a mid-level staff. I can't find that. So I just want to make sure we all stay focused on the needs that we have at hand that have the biggest impact on our future and hope we can move this forward tonight and then have further discussion on it. Thank you for your time tonight. Thank you very much. Good evening, Council. Kirk Schaubmeyer from the Alpinoff Lodge. Nice to see you all. Just want to keep it brief. Bill said it best, I think. We're talking about just the direction of the TBID and not getting...

1:30:15 I'm caught up in the minutia, but there's a big discussion to be had here and unenviable positions held by all the town, MLT. But ultimately, I think that this is representative of the community and I think that I would just have to throw a story in there that's maybe anecdotal in nature, but we celebrated our 50-year anniversary.

1:30:47 of coming to this town and being in business. And, you know, short of Bill Sauser, that's a pretty long tenure. So we've actually seen quite a few things. And I'm not here to say that the TBIT is the reason for the season, because it does take a group effort, but it certainly doesn't hurt. And when I can report to you from a lodging perspective that we have seen...

1:31:15 Months of occupancy and occupancy rates in the high 90s. I can tell you for certain that's never happened before. So call that what you want. Have your opinion as to how you feel that plays out. But I think that that's a positive direction to go. And I think that the TBID is certainly something that helps us in that endeavor. That's about it. Thank you.

1:31:45 Thank you. Thanks for coming down. Mr. Mendel. John Mendel, partner and owner in Devil's Creek Distillery and also MLT. So first, success has a million fathers and failure but one. If we were sitting here and TBID or TOT hadn't hit its target and we didn't have the money to fix roads or recover whatever we did, I guess I would ask the council who you are you're marketing on.

1:32:29 As a business owner, I don't view tourism as a bad word. And sometimes I get the impression that some in town feel it is. And I get that. They've been here a long time. They want it the way it was. The world isn't as it was. As a business that depends on tourism and people showing up to town, we strongly support this for all the reasons that have been laid out. Forget the minutiae.

1:33:02 Fix the big things and the small things will take care of themselves. So I would encourage you very, very strongly to vote positively. Thank you very much. And thanks for coming down. Okay, anybody else in the room? Not seeing anybody out in the world there. Pam Mitchell, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Did I unmute? Yes. Thank you. So a couple statements and a question.

1:33:43 Trying to be informed so I can attend the coming up stuff. First, I think you could market a community when the employees have and can afford housing. Employees are our biggest asset. Employees are the biggest asset anywhere. And when you're in a place where you can't afford or you don't

1:34:13 Have access to housing. You not only lose employees, but then the business owners have a hell of a time because they can't keep that going. And part of the reason that employees are the biggest asset is because that enhances, they enhance the visitor experience. We know all about the theory and all those different things. But when people get here,

1:34:41 How their employees are, how their services, how they're treated is major. And if you want to, well, I think the businesses will be supported when the employees who I'm stressing are our biggest asset, when our employees are supported. So the way that leads to a question in listening to this one.

1:35:11 Sorry, I'm not real informed, but I'm trying. Is that this T-bid stuff and this infrastructure stuff is tied in to benefit as a benefit to businesses. And so through that, there seems like there should be able to be some way to tie in to support our biggest asset, which is employees. I also think that business owners...

1:35:38 We'll be more likely to even want to come here and invest if there is the housing for our employees. So is there a way to tie this in with the T-bid infrastructure? Infrastructure, can that be employee housing instead of more three or four or five-story hotels? Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much, Pam. Okay. Anybody else? No answer. Nobody in the virtual world? No, but I received three letters. Okay.

1:36:16 I think the, I think if you want to read them, we can do that, but I think council members have all received these letters. No, that's what I'm saying. We've received a lot of letters and they're all online. I've received three that you guys didn't receive. Okay. Yeah, let's, if you could just read those real quick. Thank you. My comments are specific to the T-bid renewal.

1:36:45 I own and operate three brick-and-mortar businesses and promote and manage two music festivals here in town. I want to emphasize how important it is to the business community for us to not only renew the T-Bid, but to renew it for a 10-year period. Renewal is critical to the sustainment and longevity of the entire business ecosystem here in Mammoth. 10 years just makes sense due to the costs associated with the renewal process.

1:37:09 As a former partner and director of sales and marketing of a larger entity in Southern California, I can tell you from experience that the biggest reason for contraction or failure is forgetting where you came from. Most entities cycle in the shape of a bell curve because entities start believing things will never change and stop doing precisely what they did to become successful. Marketing is at the top of that list.

1:37:33 My former hometown of Simi Valley, a bedroom community suburb of Los Angeles, has a TBD now. In talking to leaders in the community, their thought process is that they can capture that family trying to figure out what to do over the weekend who might normally be thinking of wine country, Lake Arrowhead, or Mammoth Lakes. Why not come to Simi Valley and visit the Reagan Library? Point is, competition for people's visitors' dollars has never been more competitive.

1:37:59 It's no longer simply other mountain towns. It is a plethora of destinations which are looking to capture visitor dollars and all of the related economic benefit from that revenue. That said, Americans have never been more spontaneous with travel plans, and this is not the time to be out of sight and out of mind. The conversations we should be having are not how to reduce our income, but how to spend it wisely.

1:38:22 We should demonstrate fiscal responsibility and renew the T-bid for 10 years and continue to work together as a community to improve the obvious areas of need, such as available employee housing, basic infrastructure, and responsible visitation. Thank you for your time, Michael Ledesma. Thank you. Okay. Dear Town Council, thank you for your time here tonight. Your commitment to our town, to the well-being of our residents, and your interest in work to maintain our local economy are greatly appreciated.

1:38:57 I have owned and operated a business in Mammoth Lakes for 14 years. I am fortunate enough to have called this place home for over 40 years. When the TBID was first established, I was not in favor of the assessment. I have since become aware of the benefits that the TBID provides for our town, and I work towards positive, educated conversations about how we can use the increased visitation dollars to elevate the town in Mammoth Lakes. Yes, I realize the impact of this increase and how it affects our environment. The increase in traffic on the road and the traffic

1:39:26 And the trails is a concern for many locals, myself included. This is understandable. Population is on the rise on this planet, and outdoor recreation is more accessible than any other time on earth. It is incredibly important to recognize the role of using marketing dollars as a means of educating our visitors. MLT has made great strides towards increasing awareness and education amongst our tourists and our locals.

1:39:49 After the established T-Bid assessment, it didn't take long for me to realize how incredibly valuable it is for our business community to have a marketing source reaching out to bring people to town during the off season. Two years after the T-Bid was established, when I was generally laying people off for the season, I found myself keeping employees through what used to be the slow spring season. I was suddenly looking to hire more people than previous years. I watched as business rapidly grew more than it had in their first four years.

1:40:16 I am highly in favor of the 10-year T-Bid. The process of renewing the T-Bid is long and it is

1:40:45 As a local business owner, I would like to know that our main marketing source is supported and sustainable for many years to come.

1:41:13 It concerns me that there is not a consistent messaging from town council with regards to the benefit of TBID has on the town as a whole. TOT is a huge source of funding for the town, and TOT comes exclusively from visitation dollars. Not all people see how tourism has a benefit for them personally, but overall as a whole, it truly is how this town has managed to survive for decades. The only time this area was viable solely on its residents was when it was inhabited by the indigenous people who cared for the area.

1:41:42 Then there were the miners. They didn't need tourists either. Next, this area became a summer fishing spot and embarked upon its long journey as a tourist destination, relying on visitors to come and enjoy the area as a means of economic growth. Now as a year-round resort, visitation from tourism is what drives the economy and provides a healthy income for the town of Mammoth Lakes.

1:42:02 It concerns me that many people in town believe that it is MLT's job to fund public works projects. MLT staff and its board are not contractors. They cannot build infrastructure or conduct these projects. However, the money that is brought in via the TOT can be used for these projects. TOT is driven by visitation. With this funding, it is then up to the council and the town staff to decide the best way to use the money to elevate the experience of our residents and our visitors. As a business owner on Main Street, I would like to suggest the use of these funds to conduct a central...

1:42:31 Thank you so much.

1:43:00 I hope that there is a stronger relationship between Council and MLT and that you look toward MLT as a partner in the economic livelihood of Mammoth Lakes. I hope to see Town Council strengthen the bond with MLT to work towards the potential this town has to be a leader in sustainable tourism. Thank you for all you do. Andrea Walker. Thank you. Dear members of the Town Council, I write today as a business owner and submitter of TBID to voice support for renewal of the Tourism Business Improvement District Assessment.

1:43:37 As what I believe to be a direct product of Tibet and Mammoth Lakes tourism's efforts, we have seen overall visitation, but particularly shoulder season and weekday visitation, grow by leaps and bounds over the past decade. We used to lay off multiple employees during the shoulder. We now retain a full staff. The fall of 2022 was one like we have never seen before. I can't count how many times we heard the words, we've never been here this time of year before. We had no idea what we were missing.

1:44:03 The MLT staff has done a fantastic job of increasing visitorship, and this is good on two accounts. Businesses thrive, putting money directly in the pockets of our residents, and creating a thriving economy for our non-tourist-facing businesses. And the town of Mammoth Lakes receives more revenue in transient occupancy tax. A bigger town budget benefits all residents.

1:44:24 However, with growth comes growing pains and the residents of this town are feeling those growing pains as the town's infrastructure has not progressed quickly enough to provide for increased visitorship. This town is in dire need of parking, restrooms, more sidewalks, beautification and recreation facilities. We can increase visitorship all we want, but if the amenities don't meet a visitor's needs, they likely won't return. The town of Mammoth Lakes needs to attentively move towards infrastructure improvements.

1:44:49 There have been much talk about a portion of TBID funds going towards these improvements, but in my opinion, this funding should come from the town's TOT budget. The annual $6 million in TBID funds is nowhere near enough to fund the projects this town needs in addition to funding our marketing. With more than $26 million raised by TOT in the 21-22 alone, and annual totals that continue to trend up, plus millions of dollars in TOT budget surplus, this is where our community should be looking for these funds.

1:45:18 It is my great hope that the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Lakes Tourism form a healthier relationship and work together to better this amazing place we all call home. Communication, education, and understanding are vital for building a better community in which our residents and visitors alike will thrive. Thank you for your time, Alyssa Moeller Harper. Thank you. I think you've got a couple hands up. Ron C., please unmute yourself and give your comments. Ron C.? Ron C. Okay.

1:46:15 That's it? Okay. Okay. Well, thank you all. Thanks for all the public comments. Thanks to all you for being here this evening. At this point, is there any final comments or thoughts from Council? Otherwise, we'd entertain a motion to move this forward. John, I would make one comment. Okay. Those people out there that are talking about housing and everything else, I would encourage them to call me. My wife will be mad I said that. I would encourage them to give me a call. We have a sheet here of how the T-bed...

1:46:45 Everybody keeps talking about excess TBID dollars and where they went, not TBID, but TOT. And we have a sheet here detailing the last few years. This isn't the time or place to have that conversation, but I'd be more than happy to help educate and have that conversation. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Anybody else? I think that, as Dan has laid out, I mean, we're embarking this evening on a process, should we decide to do that. There will be a public meeting.

1:47:13 That will truly be what that implies, a public meeting. We look forward to hearing comment, ideas, feedback from folks at that point. And then the ultimate point of determination of making decisions will be in June. So with that, I don't have anything to add. I'm very much looking forward to this process of moving this thing forward. So I'd entertain a motion from a council member. I'll make a motion. You make a motion? Okay.

1:47:35 So I move that we adopt the resolution of the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lake, State of California, declaring its intention to renew the Mammoth Lake's Tourism Business Improvement District, MLT bid, and fixing the time and place of a public meeting and a public hearing thereon, and giving notice thereof. Thank you. Does that work? Everybody's happy? Okay, is there a second? I will second. Thank you, Bill. Any additional comment or discussion? Not hearing any, Jamie, please.

1:48:04 Councilmember Bubser. Yes. Councilmember Ray. Yes. Councilmember Rice. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Sauser. Yes. Mayor Wentworth. Yes. Thank you all. Here we go. Looking forward to having a good community conversation over the coming weeks. And we'll see you in May and we'll see you in June. So thank you all very much. Thanks for all your efforts on this. With that, the council is going to turn into closed session. We'll give us a chance for everybody to pack up their bags. And if you want to note the item and then we can. Yeah.

1:48:33 So the item will be, this is item 6.1, pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.6.A, Conference with Labor Negotiators, the Council will meet with its representatives, Town Manager Dan Holler, Administrative Services Finance Director Rob Patterson, Community Economic Development Director Sandra Moberly, and HR Manager Amanda Pelham with respect to the following employee organizations. You guys might want to listen to this.

1:49:04 The Mammoth Lakes General Employee Association, the Mammoth Lakes Management Employees Association, the Mammoth Lakes Public Works Employee Association. Thank you all. We'll take a quick break while the herd heads out, and we will re-adjourn here at 5.50. Thank you all. See you shortly.