TransparentMammoth

Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board · 2023

Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board

at 18:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

297 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

5:12 Details. Call to order the regular meeting of the Public Benefit Corporation, Eastern Sierra Community Housing, Inc., whose mission is to support affordable housing for a variety of variable economy, viable economy, and sustainable community. Board member Brian D. Andrea will attend this meeting remotely from the following address, 1000 Corporate Point.

5:41 Suite 200, Culver City, California. Roll call. And actually, I believe Board Member Nuttall has an announcement to make as well. Yes, thank you, Angie. This is Board Member Nuttall. I will be participating under the Just Cause provision of AB2449 due to illness. So I'll be participating virtually via Zoom.

6:10 And I believe under that provision that you are to keep your camera on. We'll turn it on. All right, thank you. All right, we'll move to... Okay, I'm gonna go ahead and take roll call now that we've got all of the housekeeping done. President Stapp? Here. Vice President Hodges? Here. Treasurer Barksdale? Here. Board Member Kreitz? Here. Board Member Perkins? Here. Board Member Steenstra? Here. Board Member DeAndrea? Here.

6:46 Board Member Nuttall? Here. And Board Member Rice? Here. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item two, public comments. Are there any public comments? We do have a caller online with their hand raised. Mr. McFarland, you can go ahead and unmute and give your comment. Hello. Thanks very much. You folks can hear me, I'm assuming? Yes, we can hear you. Wonderful. Thanks. Sorry I'm not there with you in person today.

7:24 I have a house full of sick kids that stayed home from school, and so seems like it's been going around, and hence I'm on Zoom. My name is Paul McFarlane. I'm currently the program officer for the DeChambeau Creek Foundation. DeChambeau Creek Foundation is a small local community foundation based up here in the Mono Basin that seeks to inspire meaningful connections between place and one another through community investments.

7:52 One of the recent programs that we have been working on is to foster more intense and solution-based dialogue surrounding housing, which we all know we need, and you all have been very effective at advancing solutions for that. So thank you.

8:13 I'm here tonight because I would like to formally request for a future agenda of Eastern Sierra Community Housing, a discussion with myself and some other people I work with up here on a small little volunteer group called the Mono Basin Housing Working Group, potential pathways for partnerships for the establishment of a housing trust organization solely focused on the unincorporated portions.

8:42 of Mono County to lower the barriers to entry for many in our local community for home ownership, as well as to protect the housing stock we have through the tools that a housing trust would offer. I've had many conversations about this with Patricia, your Executive Director. They've been very fruitful.

9:06 Worked very successfully also with Olya, Eric, and Isara on some recent community conversations we held over housing, which 80 people attended, including some of your board members. And would just look forward to sitting in front of and with you all in an agendized meeting to see if there's an opportunity for a housing trust establishment through some kind of partnership going forward. So with that, thanks very much and thanks for all you do.

9:40 Any other public comments? Please go ahead and step up to the podium. Hello, everyone. My name is Matt Johnson. I just wanted to come by and introduce myself. I moved to Mammoth earlier this year, and I'm just kind of looking to get involved. I've heard about this organization. It seems like you guys are doing a lot of great work in a place that definitely needs some help. I met a couple of you. I met with Patricia last week.

10:17 Hopefully be doing some volunteering, helping out where I can. I'm just going to be hanging out, kind of learning a little bit more about the program tonight. I just want to come by and say hi. Thanks, I'll see you around. Thank you. Any other public comments? No comments at this time. We'll move to board reports. Any board reports? Yeah, this is Tom. I just would report that I did attend the last two town council meetings and spoken support.

10:53 of our project, Access Apartments, which we'll be talking about, but I thought it was kind of a good process with Town Council that we went through, a lot of good collaboration and working with staff and council members and resulted, I think, in a good end result for us that we'll talk about further, but yeah, it was some good positive action by Town Council. Any other board reports?

11:24 I wanted to start an effort to amend the contract with the town of Mammoth Lakes to not have the Brown Act or minimize the Brown Act requirements in some way that makes it more feasible for a regional organization. I'm coming up from...

11:50 Bishop and it's difficult enough from there but our organization is serving a much larger area than just Mammoth Lakes and Bishop so if we want to have more active participation from the board it would be easier if we didn't have to provide our home addresses to attend online and attend here in person during weekdays for

12:20 Training and stuff that is intended for Town of Mammoth Lakes employees. The next one is in January and we're supposed to be here in person. It's not offered online and I can't take four hours off of work to drive up here and do a two-hour training and drive back in the middle of the week. And if we want to be a regional organization and get more representation from...

12:48 And if I may interject, there is an online option. I sent you an email this afternoon. Maybe you haven't seen it yet. The course with the FPPC.

13:15 It does expire at the end of this calendar year. They've lost their funding, so they'll no longer offer it. We're looking for other alternatives. It will still be free as an online option at this point. We haven't found any, but we think there's one possibly coming online. So I just wanted to clarify that for everybody if you're having issues with that training. Thank you. If it's okay, I'll go ahead with a quick report. I just want to highlight that since our last meeting,

13:52 Which looks to be November 6th. I couldn't figure out if we had a special meeting somewhere in there, but I don't think we did. Yeah, I think it was right before that. Yeah, anyway, the California State Association of Counties held their annual conference in Oakland, and our Housing, Land, Use, and Transportation Committee finally was able to secure the HCD director, Gustavo Velasquez, and that was really great.

14:21 I just want to highlight a few things that he shared with us that I thought were of interest that may be of interest to the public and my colleagues on the board. The state needs 2.5 million new housing units by 2030, and 1.2 million of those are for low and moderate income. As you may know, we have roughly 171

14:54 1,000 homeless people in our state, 30% of the homeless population in the country, three-fourths of those people are unsheltered. One of the things that it sounds like the HCD and the governor are very interested in is keeping Home Key around.

15:18 shared some figures with us that home key units take roughly $200,000 per unit versus new construction, which averages a little over $600,000 for one and two bedrooms. Again, these are just some things that I took note on that I found interesting, and I hope you don't mind me sharing them. To afford the median housing unit in California, you need to earn $41 an hour.

15:50 Some of the governor's priorities going into the coming year are homelessness, interconnection between the environment and the housing, so reducing VMTs, people driving far for work, and then equity around housing.

16:17 I found the presentation to be interesting. I think there's a lot of people frustrated with government's oversight in some of the more rural communities, but Gustavo was engaged, and they are going to be taking over the HHAP program in the fifth round, which I'll just note our organization has received some of that funding for the Innsbruck Lodge, so we want to keep an eye on that.

16:45 That's all I have, I think, at this moment. Thanks. Any other board member reports? I have a comment to make. It's just anecdotal. Again, I live in a Snow Creek complex, and it's getting harder and harder to get employees. I mean, they carpool up from Bishop. I repeat this over and over again, but, I mean, it comes down to concrete impacts.

17:19 on our community. I also went to a restaurant where there was only, it was a large restaurant, there was only one waitress trying to manage all the different tables and everything. So, I mean, housing is really coming up and it's need and importance throughout the community. Any other board member reports?

17:48 If not, we'll move to the consent agenda. Okay, I'm sorry. That's okay. I was debating on whether to say it or not. Tomorrow, we have, the Town Council has the STR Advisory Committee. We'll be meeting at 4 p.m. here in Suite Z, and we will be given the economic analysis from the Economist on STRs and their impact. So if anyone's interested in attending.

18:17 I'll see you tomorrow at 4. Is that report already on the website? Is it because you follow the Brown Act, is that available on your agenda? Is it in the packet? Yeah, it is. Okay, thank you. And is that meeting able to be viewed online? It is. It will be available online, yes. And then I don't know. I think it was made a decision, but is Esauro now sitting here? Esauro is on our board. Uh-huh. So congratulations.

18:50 Thank you. Yes, she's on our, the STR Advisory Committee. Thank you. You are a busy woman. Yeah. She's also on the AMACA board. Yeah. And I think the COC? Yes. Maybe. I don't know. As part of, yeah. Part of our own. And a mom. And a mom. But it's okay. We're good. Great. Thank you. Any board, any other board member reports?

19:24 If not, we'll move to the consent agenda, approval of the minutes from the November 6, 2023, regular board meeting. Any corrections or relations? If I can have a motion. I move to approve the minutes from the November 6 board meeting. I second the motion. Discussion? Roll call? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. I'm going to abstain. I can't hear.

20:06 The names, but I vote to approve the minutes as well. Oh my gosh. I'm sorry. My turn to not mute myself. I'm just going to repeat everybody so anybody listening can hear it. President Stapp. Yes. Vice President Hodges. Yes. Treasurer Barksdale. Yes. Board Member Kreitz. Yes. Board Member Perkins. Abstain. Board Member Steenstra. Yes. Board Member DeAndrea. Yes. And thank you for pointing that out that you couldn't hear me.

20:35 Board Member Nuttall? Yes. And Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. We'll move to policy matters. The first policy matter is the board will receive an update from Buckingham Property Management on the status of the 22-23 winter repairs, ongoing maintenance, manager, transition, et cetera, at our limited partnership properties.

21:00 Great, thank you. This item is a result of the board's request to have an update regarding any capital improvements or repairs that are being made to Aspen Village Apartments, Manzanita and Jeffrey's projects after last year's winter, as well as to receive a brief update on some staffing transitions and our ongoing relationship with Buckingham Property Management Company.

21:28 And so today, this evening, Jenny Reed is here with us. I appreciate that so much. And she's a regional director for Buckingham Property Management, and she's here to give us an update. Hi, good evening, everybody. So we have been diligently working on items for Aspen Village and what we call Mammoth 2, which comprises the Jeffries, Mammoth, and Manzanita properties.

21:56 Most of the minor items have been taken care of. At Aspen Village, Pacific West Builders organized temporary repairs to the building expirators that were designed to get us through winter. I believe those were contracted through Ken Carpenter. And they have plans to do all of the remaining work and to potentially reside the entire property.

22:19 in the spring, which just seemed like it was what needed to happen as far as timing with weather. And Darren Lynch, who's a supervisor with Pacific West Builders, he's overseeing the repairs at the property that have already been completed and will be organizing logistics through PacWest for the items that are going to be completed in the spring.

22:43 At Mammoth 2, there was an insurance claim that was filed for the property. Farmers just visited the property a week and a half ago, so ownership is waiting for information from them. Some of the minor repairs have been completed, but they were trying to get feedback from the insurance company on how the insurance company was going to expect us to proceed.

23:05 I do know there was some concerns from a recent issue with a tree on property that was approved separately and Ken Carpenter is taking care of those repairs as well. So any questions? Do I ask if you have questions about the repairs? Hi, Jenny. Thank you. Hi. I appreciate you coming and joining us tonight.

23:34 I want to, I have a few questions and a concern that a tenant at the Aspen Village property put up on Facebook that they had gone five or more days without any hot water and they were told that that was not, that that was not a health and human safety issue. Just seeing that on Facebook,

24:02 That they were, they couldn't get a response. They couldn't get the people, I think, from either Idaho or the Central Valley to do the repair work. And I don't know what it was, but just airing those kinds of grievances on Facebook doesn't look good. It doesn't sound right to me in the winter. This was recently. So I would just want you to know that and to see if there's a way to...

24:29 Yes, I totally agree.

24:47 For us, you know, echoing a little bit of what was said earlier, we have had a maintenance position posted that is supposed to provide maintenance service for Aspen and Mammoth 2 for almost nine months. It's posted at $27 an hour, which is the max that the properties can afford to pay with the constraints of their budget.

25:07 We have had a couple of applicants that haven't been able to pass the background in order to access people's units. And so we unfortunately have to then rely on vendors, which are limited in your area and are also, you know, under the demands from other people. So we are working to try to get other staffing in place right now. There is a community manager. Her name is Princess Anne. I think it's pronounced Inak.

25:35 And she is the manager for Aspen and Mammoth 2. And then Marvin Oreck is a manager maintenance combo for Bristol Cone and Willow Plaza. We would love to fill the maintenance position. So if anybody has any leads or anyone they could send our direction, I think that would be very life-changing as far as responsiveness and able to get things done. We are using temp agency employees right now to try to do that.

26:05 But I hear what you're saying, and we have sent multiple crews of people from the Valley because we know that it's not acceptable to just not have people to make sure that, you know, we are getting work accomplished and things taken care of. It's just those one-off situations where it's an urgent issue on Thanksgiving Day and there's no vendors available that are willing to go and do those type of things and just not having someone with a skill set in that area.

26:38 Yeah, it's just, again, I understand that scenario, but I think part of that is also the hearing and acknowledging and listening and not telling that person that's not a health and human safety requirement, that that's not a big deal, that you haven't, you and your family haven't had hot water. That's what I feel like is part of that puzzle that I think just some training on sensitivity, maybe.

27:06 Because I know if I didn't have hot water from my landlord for five days and I was told it's not a big deal, it's not, we don't have to do that, I would be upset. The other two questions I have, and I think one of them you hit on, it sounds like you have addressed all the structural issues from last winter on your buildings. Yes.

27:29 Okay, great. With temporary fixes. So they, it was my understanding that they had met with the town, Pacific West Builders had met with the town as far as what they were going to be doing. They went to the building department, but they didn't think there was enough time left before snowfall to really like open up the sides of the buildings more than they already had. And so temporary fixes were put in place just to get us through until spring. I got it. That makes sense.

27:57 I've heard of other people having to do that. And then the last thing, I haven't been out to Aspen Village in a long time. What's going on with the playground? Has that been replaced or what's going on there? It was repaired. It did have playground bark. We did suffer some damages again this year from snow plowing. Unfortunately, with, you know, it being buried in the snow bank, the plowing company can't.

28:24 Yeah, totally. Yeah, it's hard, difficult.

28:48 Probably over at the Jefferies as well. I don't know for sure. It's a little more protected, actually, I think. Yeah, that one's a little bit tucked away. So that one seems to be in good shape. I noticed the playground bark was still there in the photos that I saw. So that survived. But I'm looking right now at emails. And the issues with it from the winter were totally resolved. So the playground was online until.

29:14 You know, okay. Now it's too cold. That's great. That's great. Okay. I think that's it. Thanks for getting into the weeds a little with me, Jenny. Okay. Jenny, just to touch upon a little bit of on the back of Jennifer's questions. She mentioned about couldn't get a vendor coming from wherever it was. Do you guys use local vendors? We do when they're available.

29:41 I'm not sure if it's the same unit. We did have issues with the unit and it literally went down on the night before Thanksgiving and then getting someone available in the area. So we do try to rely heavily on vendors. So Princess has been actually getting new vendors signed up that are willing to do work at the property. So there are some requirements to become a vendor as far as having...

30:03 The appropriate liability insurance, workers, comp insurance, things like that. But we try, yeah, we try to use local vendors as much as possible.

30:12 Okay, good to know. I also do property management, and I know if the units that I manage, that would not go down well after 12 hours, never mind five days. So, you know, happy to share resources, be interested to see who you have on that vendor list, and obviously, of course, be licensed and insured and have the appropriate workers' comp.

30:36 Excuse me, the second question just about the maintenance workers. I'm just curious to understand kind of where you're advertising for that. I haven't really seen any ads for that. Do you, are you advertising on national sites locally, all of the above? I would have to check with our recruiting department. So typically they advertise on Indeed, Glassdoor, places like that. I know we've done flyers too.

31:03 Local hardware stores and I believe a lumber mill, lumber type facility in the area. So it's been kind of a, we'll get someone that will be in the background for a little while and ends up not having the ability to meet the background. Someone more recently, you know, was, yeah, so many issues, but.

31:28 I would love if anyone has any recommendations in the area of securing leads on employment because it would be year-round guaranteed 40-hour employment. Yeah, I think we do a lot of advertising as well and I do use Indeed and those other national websites for certain positions, but I think for us when it comes to maintenance, we kind of keep our advertising local. I definitely would recommend getting a...

31:57 Ad placed in the local newspapers, in the Times and in the Sheet. I've actually had a lot of maintenance workers come in looking for work recently and I've had to turn them away because we don't, I don't need them until it snows. So unfortunately I don't have more work than my crew right now, but so I was a little surprised to hear that that seems like a very reasonable, you know, wage and package that you're offering.

32:26 If I'm getting people coming in, applying through our local efforts, that's why I asked, you know, what channels are you kind of going through? Maybe we can help get the word out. And then, yes, I'd be happy to pass along some names and recommendations. I don't know what your sort of background checks are or requirements that you're obviously, you know, need to have them pass, but it's worth sharing resources. That's wonderful. Thank you so much. I appreciate it.

32:57 Further comments from the board? Questions? Hi, Jenny. I just have one quick question. How old is Aspen Village? When was that built? Ooh, I'd have to look at 2006. 2006. It came online in December, leased up, and right before Christmas. All right. Thanks. Just curious, if I heard correctly in the beginning, you were anticipating doing a full re-side on it this spring?

33:26 Potentially, yes. I believe that was Mr. Lynch's assessment of the property. The type of siding that they used is just not holding up well to the extreme weather and then the pressure from snow being pushed against the side of the building. So I think a lot of people's complaints about the cracking and then when you go through and you actually repair it and then you paint that we're just sort of putting a Band-Aid on a bigger issue.

33:55 Yeah, I'm also in property management, and I just went through a full re-side on my project, but it hadn't been done since the 70s, and it lasted since the 70s. With the architecture, just to put it out there, coming up four feet, five feet from the ground with a rock, I believe what you guys have is hardy board, and moisture doesn't do well with hardy board. Just putting that out there.

34:24 Yes. I found that interesting. Any other questions or discussion? If not, we'll move to agenda item 4.2. The board will receive an update on the 20th anniversary rebranding effort. Thank you. I think I'm going to pass it over to Olya to present. Yes. So we prepared another rebranding rollout and marketing plan update.

34:59 And I guess I wanted to share some highlights. So on your tables, I passed out the trifolds that we recently received. And in the board packet, there's the advertisement that we were able to post in the sheet. I think three in-progress items that we have going on as well to highlight are the stickers to sort of help with publicity locally, I think. We are in the process of ordering the business sign. We just haven't received it yet.

35:28 And lastly, we are still working with legal counsel to officially change our name. If there's any questions, feel free, but that's pretty much it. Question from the board? Well, I think I just have to go through it with more details the first time I opened it up, but it looks good. One typo jumps out at me, but with the ADUs, if we're helping with construction loans for ADUs,

36:09 Are we giving some kind of requirement that those are going to be for personal use and not for short-term rentals? It just depends on the funding source and what the requirements are of either the state or the jurisdiction and how those overlap. Because I'd personally rather not have this organization provide loans for short-term rentals.

36:30 So there's state law. It's a state law that ADUs can't be short-term rented if there are certain sizes, and it's almost all of them. And I know Mono County doesn't allow any of their ADUs to be short-term rented, and I'm not sure about the town. And I think there's a new bill that was just passed, and maybe you've seen it, Patricia, I don't know. We're getting an update on some new legislation that just passed that further restricts ADUs to be short-term rented.

36:58 So it's almost like it's very difficult for anyone to short-term run an ADU. Yeah. Thankfully. I agree. Any other comments from the board? Yeah, I was going through and I hit on the board members and I'm not on there. I was like, hang on a second. I go to the meetings. I do the work.

37:33 I'm so sorry. I know it can be fixed, but I was like, hmm. I remember seeing that. The website's a work in progress. Are the flyers out somewhere in town, or is there a plan for where they will be? So this printing, we sort of did a small print just in case there was critical feedback. So far, you're the first to receive in bulk.

38:05 I think we only printed maybe a hundred, and so I think we'll leave them here, and then happy to leave them, the rest of them, if you have suggestions. The library maybe? Notice there at the post office, there's a little thing near the pin board, the cork board. Okay, great, we'll add some there. And then any feedback we'll gladly take and incorporate into the next print.

38:31 Also, if I could add one more update, we did send out all the holiday cards. So thank you to board members for stopping by and signing cards. Yes, I received mine. Thank you. It was beautiful. And if we're just being, pointing out some things on the, also on that board page, my email is listed as Brian's. I'm happy for you to receive my emails, Brian. That would be great. Thank you for volunteering for that.

39:02 If you want to update that too, you can. Thank you. Any other comments, questions, corrections? If not, we'll move to agenda item 4.3. The board will receive a draft of the 2024 strategic plan. Okay, I will introduce the item and Patricia will wrap it up. So Patricia and I have been working on the...

39:54 What we are now calling the 2024-2027 Strategic Plan. And part of these efforts are identifying our core values as an organization. We have our mission, we have our vision, but we're missing some core values to help guide our decision making. So I provided some context in the staff report on what are core values and how do they differ to point out a little bit of the significance of

40:23 Why we might want core values. But I think that's about it. Oh, yes. Yeah, so I did provide a handout that I think I gave enough of. If not, I can run up and give some more. Those papers have an activity that was from one of my trainings at NeighborWorks, asset-based community development. So it's a head, hand, heart activity.

40:55 And on the other side, there's some questions. It's more of an assessment-based questionnaire, but just to see why you all joined as Board of Directors members, what distinguishes Eastern Sierra Community Housing as an organization, and so forth. So feel free to jot down. I mean, you don't have to answer.

41:18 The questions at all, you can just jot down your notes, and we'll take those back at the end of the session. It's supposed to be more of a brain dump, and then maybe we'll finalize with one of the committees later. But I also attached the RCAC, which, let me see what the acronym stands for, I always forget, Rural Community Assistance Corporation, their strategic framework, and so they have their mission, vision, and core values as well.

41:46 And their core values are more framed as action items as well. So it's just some considerations as we move forward with, I guess, finalizing the strategic plan. Yeah, that's great. I think the intent is to sort of flesh out, as Lilia mentioned, the mission, the vision, and how we operate as an organization and the values and the faith that we want to put forward to the community as we finalize this.

42:19 Strategic plan moving forward for the next couple of years. And so if you could complete your worksheets with any initial feedback that you have, we can incorporate that into the next draft that the board will review in January. I would like to go through, the strategic plan update isn't too lengthy, and I'd like to go through at least quickly each section and receive any initial feedback you might have so that we can make sure that the next draft

42:49 reflects the intention of the Board of Directors. And I have a draft with some red lines and some notes that I had added that I'll share my screen. But I wanted to let everybody know that dinner did arrive. It was a little bit late. And so if you want to grab some food while we go through this, maybe that would be a good time. Or we can take a quick pause before the next item if you want to wait.

43:23 If you want to, yeah. If that works for you, yeah. I didn't think that would take very long. I'm good. With all that darkness, oh. Oh, yeah. I was going to say, you blanked it all out. Thank you. Thank you. Great.

48:08 It looks like they've got a lot of snow. I went up that direction and back a couple times. It looks like all those groomers at the top have plenty of snow.

48:52 Yeah, I was going to say, I think it's El Troll.

49:43 You heard me. Yeah. What's up?

51:20 Okay, great. Everyone can just jump in as you see something that you'd like to comment on. This is the first draft that staff has looked at since our consultant, Shawna Doherty, provided us with her feedback from our strategic planning session that we held in order to update our current strategic plan, which goes through 2023.

52:31 And so all of your feedback is much appreciated. Here we're going to add the new logo and maybe some more or different images. If there's feedback, just let us know. Patricia, before you scroll too far, and it was not at the strategic planning session, I apologize, but the elevating housing horizons in the Eastern Sierra, is that something that came up in the session or that?

53:02 You've come up with, or where did that come from? That was in the draft that Shauna gave us. What I noticed is that one's there. The flyer has everyone deserves a safe, stable, and affordable place to live. And then we also have our mission and our vision. And so I was just feeling like maybe trying to come more together with a similar statement. Might be nice, but I don't know how other people feel. That's a good catch.

53:38 And actually, I think this draft that has my track changes in it isn't the most recent draft, which you have, which has the land acknowledgement. And so I might, unless there's specific comments on, you know, the first page where we talk about the board and the staff. I do have actually one comment about the land acknowledgement. And it's just right at the end, the wording of it.

54:11 lists the various tribes, and then it says who are ongoing stewards of the land, of the land that we gather, and I thought maybe it could be, it just didn't sound, sound right, but on the lands on which we do something, or I don't know, just that one didn't, on which we, yeah, yeah, something like that, who are the ongoing stewards of the land. Yeah, I don't know, some about it didn't seem correct. Okay.

54:50 Thank you. I want to get to the meat. I don't know if there's comments about any of the other pros sections. I'm just excited to get to the meat part. I have one more small edit in the who we serve section. In the middle, second sentence, utilizing many public sources of funding.

55:30 So just what I thought was interesting is the first sentence says, we work to advance community housing at all income levels. And then the very second sentence, the next one says, our emphasis is on low to moderate income. So I didn't know if we could, like, utilizing public sources helps us maximize our support for low and moderate income level houses, maybe instead of putting an emphasis on it, because we are.

56:00 Trying to do a lot. And then in the last section, oh, it says we have four bilingual staff, three of which speak English. I think it might be three of whom speak English. Speak Spanish. Excuse me, speak Spanish. Three of whom instead of three of which. I should work on my English. For me on that section, if you go back up to about, I think we're making edits. Yeah, there, about.

56:45 I felt like this was a little formal and maybe a little, it could be a little bit more about, I don't know, it just felt a little kind of like bullet pointy, like, I don't know, it just didn't feel like it had a lot of appeal to it. It was kind of dry and I'm sorry for saying that. I don't mean to insult anyone, but it felt like it could talk more about like the board and

57:25 Maybe even like the background of some of the board or what we've been focusing on. I don't know. It just didn't seem very personal or personable. So I was trying to come up with something more specific and I don't have anything. So I'm sorry. I'm more of a problem finder than a problem solver. I think your comment makes sense. We'll add some flair.

58:08 I think under foundational elements is where we'll add some feedback from the worksheets that you have in front of you. I think we took this part out in the one that you have, so this will all be amended. Okay, so these sections are taken directly from our previous strategic plan. I believe there's five focus areas, and I think they need to be, I need to make sure that they're all labeled.

58:52 Correctly. And so the first one we have here is build and facilitate community housing. And I just wanted to get some feedback on these came directly from the consultant. And so this is what she distilled from our meeting. And I just want to make sure that that is what you remember having as part of our conversation and so that we can memorialize it in the next draft.

59:22 The red line is my comments, and so if those don't accurately reflect the desire of the board, I would like to know that so I can make sure it does. Patricia, do you mind reading it? I can't read what it says. Oh yeah, sure. And so build and facilitate community housing is the first bucket. No, because mine has the red line. Yours doesn't have the red line. And then so the consultant broke it out into,

1:00:06 Year one and two priorities and then future priorities. Objective A was identify three priority projects for the next three years and my question to the board was is this in addition to the pipeline that we already have established or does this include the projects that we're already working on? And so that's why you sort of see here I've redlined that and say work to complete the current projects we already have.

1:00:36 Maybe it's different than that. Maybe there's something in between that the board would like to see. But this is in the next one to two years. Patricia? Yes. I'm sorry to ask this again, because I feel like you did already tell us, but I'm not sure what copy I'm supposed to be looking at here, and I don't know if there was a separate handout in person, but in the one in the agenda packet.

1:01:10 Is that the most recent or this one that you're sharing your screen is the most recent? The one in the packet should have this exact language without the red line. It's like a little bit different in a bunch of different places. So that's why I was getting confused. It's not just the red line that's different. Just this section, just the most up-to-date version of everything up until this section is in the packet. This section with all the priorities, just the...

1:01:42 Focus areas and the priorities is the most up-to-date version in your packet. These are just my comments in the red line. Okay, I think her point is, like, we don't have the black, like, the create materials that outlines ESCH reference. No, I don't have that. Yeah, and I have identified one project for the next three years, not three. We do have the outline, it just wasn't bullet pointed. It's just part of the first bullet point. And, like, your red line, conduct outreach to public and private entities. I mean, that's not on my copy at all.

1:02:23 Which maybe is fine. I guess my question was, should I just look at your screen? Yeah, if we could just go through the one in your packet, it looks like all these changes were accepted already, but I didn't want to accept them without getting feedback from the board. Well, there's still some differences, like objective A on this one says identify one priority project. Right, I think that that was a change that had been accepted in a previous version.

1:03:01 And so this is the version from the consultant with my comments. And if we need to have a copy in the packet, we can look at it at the next meeting. I'm okay to continue and have you read what's on there, but I don't know how others. A lot of what your red line is is what I had talked about as well. Just like adding the bullet point that says create materials, that was just part of the first bullet point. It's now down.

1:03:37 The board could also send feedback individually and we could incorporate it into the next draft if that's more efficient. Patricia, maybe you could circulate this version with your red lines, your suggested edits for our review and consideration. That way we're all looking at the same document with your recommendations in it. Ryan, do you mean at another meeting? Right now, I think.

1:04:06 Yeah, well, not right now. I think I don't know the extent of the red lines on the screen. I think we're just looking at one page here, but just in the interest of time, it might make sense to have the benefit of being able to read through Patricia's recommendations and come back at a later point or individually share our feedback with her and our fellow board members rather than trying to kind of react real time to what we're seeing on the screen.

1:04:38 I agree. Maybe Patricia can just go over some of the priorities she thought that she wanted to see differences from the last strategic plan. Yeah, I think that would be great. I don't think there's a lot here, so Olia and I will go back and make sure we have all of the sections in the right form and send it out to the board to digest and send feedback so we can bring an updated draft to the next meeting.

1:05:14 I don't think there's a lot. There was just a few things I thought were maybe too vague or maybe would take away from other priorities of the board. Certainly that's for you to decide. But there's just a few question marks, some clarifications, adding homeownership counseling through the HUD certification process.

1:05:44 And so I don't think there's a lot to digest, but I think it would be great if everyone had the right copy in front of them and could provide their feedback individually. So I'll make a note to send this out first thing tomorrow. Yeah, and if you could give us a deadline to submit comments, obviously before the next meeting, but you probably need a little more time than that. Okay, great. Okay, we'll do that.

1:06:25 Thank you for all of your comments so far, and I look forward to bringing this back. Great, thank you. This item is related to the committees that the board established in 2019, directly following the adoption of the 2019.

1:07:33 the 2023 strategic plan, which was to create some committees to help add capacity in the areas of marketing, was one of the ad hoc committees. We also established a governance committee as well as a diversity equity inclusion committee and a fundraising committee. And so through a lot of the trainings and the work that we've been doing as a team, it has come to our attention that in order to continue to compete

1:08:04 In the realm of nonprofit affordable housing for grants and to raise our professionalism that it would be in our best interest to reignite the diversity, equity, and inclusion committee. A lot of new funding sources now require policies in the strategic plan to how is your organization addressing

1:08:32 These issues of diversity, equity and inclusion and we don't want it to be difficult for staff to be able to respond to those types of questions and so this committee would help formulate you know start practicing some of those items and formulate the best practices for us to implement as an organization in that specific area. I think that

1:08:58 In terms of staff capacity, Olya, our housing navigator for Alpine County, has taken on this responsibility and is eager to dive into this part of our work and would like that two or more directors volunteer to serve on this committee and it must be less than a quorum, so no more than four.

1:09:25 And she suggested some work program items, including review of some state legislation supporting our tribal partners, continued discussion of our core values as an organization, and analyzing things like our communications campaign to make sure that it's inclusive of all of our community members. Oh yeah, I don't know if you would like to say more.

1:09:58 But our recommendation is that the board accepts internal nominations for this committee and that they should also be aware that members of the public are able to serve on this committee as well but would need to be appointed by the board of directors in order to serve on the committee. Just a caution, if we appoint people, it becomes a Brown Act body. And this board, this committee is a Brown Act body because it's a standing committee. Oh, okay.

1:10:31 Got it. It's not an ad hoc. That's right. If you're looking for committee members, I would be happy to be on that. I guess I can add, if you don't want to join the committee, but you know someone in the community that might want to join the committee, you can always refer them, I guess, to me or Patricia, and then we can see, I'm not sure what the process is, but, you know, getting them to join the committee. Because it would be Brown X, so...

1:11:14 We would have to meet likely here. Make a suggestion that if we are interested in bringing people from the community into this committee that we maybe do some outreach. Rather, I mean, I don't know, it would be more equitable if it wasn't just word of mouth from us.

1:11:43 Yeah, I had proposed that to Patricia. I think we wanted to see if there were any board members and then we could kind of, if there were two, then we could move forward with figuring out a communications campaign, but I agree that.

1:12:11 Doing some outreach locally, whether to students or to other organizations would be really great. And we could even, well, I guess with some limitation, you know, go across the Eastern Sierra to have, you know, more input. Right, because you can use the Zoom feature, so you could attract, but with community members, they don't start to create a quorum, so you could still have the four board members plus as many.

1:12:46 So do we have any volunteers from the board? Heidi volunteered. I'd like to nominate Heidi Steenstra. Second. Since we've got board members via Zoom, we're going to do a board. So the motion was to nominate Heidi to the DEI committee, and that was made by Amanda and Jennifer, did you, Ms. Greitz, did you?

1:13:42 President Step. Vice President Hodges. Yes. Treasurer Barksdale. Yes. Board Member Kreitz. Yes, and thank you, Heidi. Board Member Perkins. Yes. Board Member Steenstra. Yes, you're welcome. Board Member DeAndrea. Yes. Board Member Nettle. Yes. And Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. We only have one. We need two for the committee to be formed.

1:14:24 I thought so. No, you may appoint two. We could start with one. Okay, yeah, it says the recommendation is two or more, but yeah. Party of one. We'll grow. We'll grow. We'll move on to agenda item 4.5. The board will consider approval of the contract for services with the Inyo County for their rehab and ADU program funded through the...

1:15:17 Thank you. This item is a result of our partnership with Inyo County around creating a housing rehabilitation incentive program and an ADU loan program.

1:15:49 This program was spurred by an analysis that revealed that a large portion of Inyo County's housing stock is owned by absentee landowners who are maybe letting their homes deteriorate and they are not being occupied either full-time or for temporary vacation use. And so the county

1:16:17 The county contracted with Mammoth Lakes Housing a year or two ago to develop some draft guidelines around that desire to have a program that could incentivize these homeowners to improve their properties and then rent them to the local community members. The development of this program happened before there was a funding source identified.

1:16:48 In 2017, Governor Brown signed the Housing and Jobs Act bill, which created SB, which included SB2, which was the $75 recording fee for every real estate transaction. I think it's 70% of that funding goes back to fund local housing programs. And so Inyo County,

1:17:13 And also the City of Bishop in a separate contract that's not on the agenda tonight. Both would like to use their funding from that source to seed this housing incentive rehabilitation incentive program and ADU creation program. The contract in the agenda this evening is a draft contract. Our attorney has reviewed it and provided comments.

1:17:46 I've also spoken to Megan McCammon, the Assistant County Administrator for Inyo County, regarding some of the technicalities around this contract and the scope of services, specifically around the term, which I've proposed as a three-year pilot program term for the implementation of the program. The administration fees, which would cover

1:18:17 General administration, including the updating of the guidelines to conform to the funding source requirements, marketing, general fielding calls, and general administration services, but would not include legal services. We're going to take that out of that part of this contract. It appears that

1:18:44 Legal may cost more than what the general administration allows for, and so we're asking the jurisdictions to take on that cost, which I think is reasonable for both parties. And then there's also a question around what the activity delivery fees are, which are separate from the general admin. Those are the costs directly associated with staff time.

1:19:09 And coordination with the county on actually delivering a loan and rehabilitating a home. So whether that includes an appraisal, staff time and travel, coordinating with the general contractor, site inspections, or anything along those lines. It's not outlined in this draft contract before you, but that's an outstanding question that we need to address.

1:19:39 And so this evening I'm really asking the board to approve, you know, this draft contract, this relationship that we're attempting to formalize with Inyo County, specifically in regards to this program. An additional benefit of this contract specifically is that the City of Bishop is attempting to do the exact same thing. And so they have a similar pot of funding.

1:20:08 That can be used to administer a very similar or exact program. And so that adds additional administration fees to help cover all the costs that many times these programs don't cover the entire cost. And so by joining forces, we're consolidating resources so that we can implement a program cost effectively. And I would hope that I could have that draft contract at our next meeting.

1:20:40 I think that's my overview. I'm happy to answer any questions. And if the board would like a more finalized version of the contract, we can have that at the next meeting. I guess I would ask the board, if interested, to approve the draft contract pending the legal amendments specifically related to those items I mentioned. I would like to express my concern again about accessory dwelling units being used.

1:21:14 I'm not sure what rules are in place for this, but I know that some of the local entities aren't enforcing the rules anyway, and as a landscape architect, I know rules for outdoor construction are not enforced to get permits unless the owner is on the bad side of the...

1:21:41 People who want them to. And so if we were going to pursue something like this, I would want rules against short-term rentals being put in the guidelines and being enforced. And I would want that to be agreed upon before any going forward with any parties, the county or the city of Bishop. Like I said, not only have it be a guideline, but be enforced.

1:22:18 I did have a quick comment on Section 3 under consideration, subparagraph B, travel and per diem. It does make note that the contractor will not be paid or reimbursed for travel expenses or per diem, which the contractor incurs in providing services and work requested by the county under this agreement, which specifically if you guys are going to be having to travel to Bishop or Inyo County to

1:22:48 Yes, and I think that's really one of the main reasons why I think the general administration and the activity fees need to be broken out so that there's an understanding of what each pot can be used for and specifically staff time and travel costs throughout Inyo County, potentially.

1:23:18 Because, you know, it's considerable expense to, especially driving down there, over 100 miles per hour trip, right? So. Other discussion? I have one. Sorry. One question on the timing in here, the terms. One date, you mentioned it was a three-year term. One date says 2023, September 1, 2023 to June 2030.

1:23:58 Yeah, those are all going to be updated at the time, you know, once the final contract is executed, we'll have the start date and I'm proposing a three-year term, which it sounds like the county is amenable to. I guess I should also mention that the Inyo County Board of Supervisors is very supportive of this program and is looking forward to working with us and that they have some, I think that they are going to approve some final

1:24:27 ADU plans shortly in the near future. I know that they've already seen a draft. And so they're excited to get this, you know, wrapped up and underway. And once we execute the contract, we will dive right into cleaning up the guidelines and making sure the program's reviewed by legal counsel and has all the deed restrictions and other required loan documents associated.

1:24:54 And then start advertising and working with the county to rehabilitate some homes. And to Tony's point and concern about short-term rentals in ADUs and then from his, the board report and Jennifer's comment that there are some state rules prohibiting short-term rentals. Do you have an answer? Is that something that would go in this contract? Is it dictated by the funding source?

1:25:24 Is there anything that, because I would say, I would share Tony's concern that I don't know that I want to be promoting short-term rentals and some things that are funded and helped by us. So typically I would defer to the zoning code and whether or not short-term rentals were allowed in a zone where we were creating an accessory dwelling unit and then also the funding source.

1:25:55 I'm trying to think about our Cal Home Program. I don't, you know, it's funded by the state. The state's not trying to promote short-term rentals in utilizing state housing funds. And so I would say that most currently those would be where I would fall back on. But also there's some new legislation and I think maybe we could prepare a staff report for our next meeting to go over what all those requirements are. And the new

1:26:26 Laws that are coming out and what the local requirements are, all the requirements at every level. And then I guess I should also mention that there is interest, at least on the county's part, to have our organization monitor their loan portfolio in the long term. I've parsed that out of this draft contract. I don't think that should be included in this pilot three-year term.

1:26:54 Contract and that if they are interested in those services that we should address that under a separate contract in the future and so I think that ultimately we're the program operator and we are going to provide the services to rehabilitate this housing and distribute the loan funds but ultimately the responsibilities on the jurisdiction to ensure compliance with the requirements because they are

1:27:26 The recipient of the funds from the state. If they would like to contract with us for those types of services, that would be outside of the scope of this contract. So I just wanted to reiterate, if I were going to support it, I would want the fact that we're not doing this for short-term rentals regardless of the zoning or the funding source or local ordinances that would allow it.

1:27:59 It's a full board, but me personally, if I'm going to vote yes for it, I want to see it in the contract agreed by the local entities that we're doing it with that it's for long-term rentals and for private use for homeowners and not for short-term rentals. I can certainly take that recommendation to the county and see what their thoughts are about it and report back.

1:28:35 I had a comment, Patricia, and actually something Tony just said, I was just thinking about that too. You know, if the ADU is for the personal use of the homeowner, not really sure, not really clear on why we would support that. So I agree with his comments, but I feel like, again, a little bit more, at least for my purpose.

1:29:02 Little bit more determining factors of what the ADU's purpose is, what it's being, what the loan is supporting, what these funds are supporting, are there specific guidelines and criteria of the use purpose? And then the other comment was in the scope of work number seven, it talks about that Eastern Sierra Community Housing will participate in monitoring.

1:29:32 Monitoring whatever, monitoring findings under the control of the subrecipient, monitoring by this, the participate by the state or other agencies. Can you clarify exactly what that is stating? What exactly are you monitoring there? So I think this goes back to my comment about the county's desire to have us.

1:30:02 provide ongoing annual monitoring of the loan portfolio in the future after the loans have been dispersed. And so that's a service that we provide for the town of Mammoth Lakes, for example. But I would take that service out of this contract since that's an ongoing service unrelated, I think, to the delivery of this program specifically. And so if they are interested in adding that on, that that would be a separate contract. Okay.

1:30:34 And I don't know, to me, that statement as it is, is not very clear exactly what you're monitoring. To me, initially, I thought, are you then in charge of enforcement, which I don't think you want to be. But if it's just the loan documents and files, which it says the necessary documents and files, but I don't know, it's a little vague there, I would say. But if you're going to take that out and have that be a separate scope of work contract, that makes sense.

1:31:05 I didn't have any other comments. Thanks. Did you have a direction? Yes, I think what I'll do is go back to the county. They have a lot of our comments already, see if we could get a new draft of this contract, clear up some of the fees, the dates, and all those, take the monitoring out. And then we have draft guidelines, so I can provide what we have. I don't think we want to spend staff time

1:31:51 Working to update guidelines if we're not under a contract to do so. We can bring back an analysis of what the draft guidelines say about ADUs and their restrictive uses and then compare that to what the funding source requires and any other state laws that are relevant and pertain to accessory dwelling units. That would be a more comprehensive

1:32:19 Look at what the scope of this contract entails. That's what I'm hearing. Thank you. Any further discussion? Then we'll move on to agenda item 4.6. The board will receive an update on the Innsbruck Lodge project home key conversion. Thank you. This item is...

1:32:59 As a result of a request from the board to receive monthly or regular updates on the construction project at the Innsbruck Lodge. And so Eric's going to give a presentation about a little bit about the background, where we are to date, percent complete construction and milestones met, and then some upcoming items that we're working on.

1:33:28 And then if there are questions, maybe we'll take them at the end. I don't think it'll be very long. Okay, just, yes, I will share. Okay, so this is the, I guess, the update on Innsbruck Lodge. We recently went up there last Wednesday. So these are all recent photos of the cover one. So here you go. All right, so a little bit of background. So in front of you guys, I just hand it out.

1:34:45 More detailed background if you want to read through it, but this is just, you know, bare bones what it has. So we acquired, or Mammoth sent a letter of interest in January 2022 to acquire a 17-unit lodge that was located at 913 Forest Trail, and then we closed escrow on August of 2022. So that's the acquisition portion of it. Funding, we were awarded round two in May of 2022.

1:35:12 Demo, we finished that in March of 2023, and then the building permits, we received that in June, and then we are estimating the completion by, or construction completion by October of 2024. Okay, and then this is just an overview of our capital stacks. As you can see, it's a percentage of what, I guess, funding we have. You can see that Homekey was our base contributor, and then that match is our second base.

1:35:44 This is our development budget. I think we had a $6.9 million development budget. A lot of it went from between acquisition and construction. That's just what we estimated. And then based on this estimate, we've used 10% of spent to date. So that's the percentage we've used of what we budgeted. And then this is our construction budget and the percent completed. So based on the invoice that we've gotten from Christian.

1:36:22 This, we're around 37% complete of the construction portion of it. That's what's been drawn down to date. The following are just some photos that we took, like I said, last Wednesday. So, we're trying to clear out that tree, the one in the front. Upper, middle levels, the place has been gutted. So, and then I think plumbing is done.

1:36:52 And electricians, they're currently working on it, so they should be done within the next week or a couple weeks. As you can see, we see some electricians here working. The lower left is the manager's unit. They haven't really done much to it. There's not going to be much rehab on that unit. HVAC system's completed, and then the bottom right is just units that have been rehabbed, or they're in the process of being rehabbed.

1:37:23 And then project updates. So we're applying for a temporary certificate of occupancy or a TCO. That will deliver six units, including the manager's unit by March of 2024. And then occupancy. So due to electrical equipment, like supply chain shortages, we have been delayed on that aspect. So we expect to have

1:37:51 That's it. I guess you guys have any questions.

1:38:25 I guess I have a question. How long will the completion take after we get that key component that is backordered? Like do we, is that, you know, it says that it's going to arrive between July and October. Is there a lot that has to happen after that gets installed or is that like? So they're going to be doing most of the work right now. They're going to be installing the process.

1:38:54 Basically, they're going to be doing every work, so then it's just plug and play. They'll move over the electrical power to the new switch gear and then remove the old one. Okay. And our costs are still looking the same? I mean, it's just the part that is slowed down, so he will finish work there and then just go back and finish up that part when it comes? Yes. Okay. How did we commission the contractors? Did it go to bid or did the...

1:39:27 Did the architect recommend contractors? We did a negotiated bid. We reached out to a handful of local contractors that we thought would be interested and have experience. And we went with the one that we thought was most qualified, was willing to do the project because of the certified payroll requirements. And that's how we selected the general contractor. And the general contractor has everybody else as a sub? Why not?

1:39:58 Contracted with different contractors for the electrical and et cetera. And one more question about the tree removal that was a recommendation from the arborist. The tree had been flagged by Southern California Edison to be removed. Oh, that one. They only removed the top. That's not even a tree.

1:40:23 Yeah, and then they only removed the top because there were some other utilities connected to the base of the tree or to the middle section right from where they cut it. It was a phone line. And so we had to work with the phone company to have the phone line removed and then go back to SCE and ask them nicely to please remove the rest of the tree. Thank you for working on that. I know it was maybe something I had chirped about at one of our meetings about getting it.

1:41:01 There's no reason. But I can see why they do that. They've done that in the Sierra Valley sites. There's a tree on Dorrance that is acting as a pole for the utility, for the foam, not for SE. And I guess the town hasn't been successful in getting that removed. Yeah. So that, in the picture, that bit that's there, that's what's coming out. Yeah, I think we're going to keep the base and make it into a planter.

1:41:32 I was going to ask about that, what that would entail. Yeah, I'd taken out a tree that size before. Or you could ask a local chainsaw artist to get artistic. And then the delay in occupancy, does that affect any of the grants?

1:42:02 So we've been working really closely with submitting letters. We submitted a joint letter with our request for an extension. I don't think we've heard back yet, but they're aware they have the letter detailing the timeline, and so we're waiting to hear back from them. A couple questions. With the six units, including the manager's unit, being ready.

1:42:55 Will we move people in and then it will still be a construction site?

1:42:59 Yes, so we're also working really closely with the town building department to make sure that we meet all the health and safety requirements for the temporary certificate of occupancy. So the five units that will be occupied as soon as they're available will be on the main floor, and then the basement level units will be blocked off, and the mezzanine level units will be blocked off, and then we'll also be able to occupy the manager's unit. Good workaround.

1:43:30 And other question on the handout about impact fees that we attempted to pay the school fee, but the payment was not accepted. Is that because they don't want it and we'll get to keep that money? Yet to be determined. We did go to pay all of our impact fees in order to pull the building permit. And when we went to pay the school fee, there was some question about whether or not we had paid the right amount.

1:43:57 So they returned the check and we wrote another check, which they also weren't sure if it was the right amount. And then at which point I became concerned and did some research and it was questionable about whether or not the rehabilitation of this project is considered eligible for school impact fees. And so our attorneys are having a conversation.

1:44:26 The town let us pull the building permit despite our fees still being pending and we will resolve that in order to get the final certificate of occupancy, whatever that outcome is. Thank you. Any questions from the board? If not, we'll move to agenda item 4.7. The board will receive an update on the Innsbruck Lodge. We just did that. 4.7.

1:44:57 Board will receive an update on the funding stack for access apartments and provide staff direction. Thank you. This item is just an update for the Board of Directors regarding the budget for this project and our newest funding sources. I've been attending a number of public meetings, including the Mono County Board of Supervisors and two town council meetings.

1:45:27 At the direction of the board to request the final funding gap for access apartments so that we could proceed and attempt to break ground this spring. In early November, the Mono County Board of Supervisors allocated $600,000 to this project. And then recently at the December 6th town council meeting, the town council allocated an additional $700,000 towards this project.

1:45:58 I wanted to make sure that the board was aware of the change in the budget at the request of the town in order to make a good faith effort to fill the funding gap, which was approximately $1.4 million. And so you'll see on page three of the staff report the change from the budget in November.

1:46:29 And then Nolan,

1:47:03 And I worked hard to find some additional funding sources. He suggested that we amend the CDBG budget and move the administration fees for staff time and administering the CDBG portion of this project, move those into the construction budget or into the development budget. And then I was able to update some of our fundraising numbers. And I think we added about

1:47:33 Was it about almost $300,000 in additional sources? And so when we went to town council on December 6th, we presented this budget that shows a gap of $819,000. And the board, the town council awarded an additional $700,000. And so today, with the budget that we have here amended, we have a current gap of $115,000. And so I just...

1:48:06 Wanted to make sure that we all had the same information, and I'm happy to take any additional staff direction or feedback that the board would like. Questions from the board? I do have a comment in respect to what was funded and what you're showing as a small remaining gap. The council did make statements during their deliberations that they were willing to...

1:48:43 Consider additional requests down the road for legitimate, like if we were to overrun our contingency, for example, due to unforeseen circumstances that are, you know, very specific to the development costs and so forth, they were certainly willing, they said they were willing to hear that again, so I just would point that out, that in the budget there's $740,000 in the budget for contingency, so if we were to exceed that for, again, unforeseen circumstances, obviously it's a

1:49:13 Rehab of an old building and there'll be all kinds of things that'll pop up, but it does seem like we have a pretty good, you know, estimate going in. And again, the town did express a willingness to consider if that number was exceeded in the future, you know, as long as we can back it up with details and so forth, the way that might be, they would consider providing additional funds if needed to close the gap or finish the project. I have a question about the deferred developer fee, the $80,000.

1:49:43 Is that, would we be able to increase that? I mean, I feel like, could we put this $115,000 gap and include that into the deferred developer fee and have that be about $200,000 that we'd collect over like 55 years or however long? And then that, you know, so that we could sign these papers tomorrow and get this project going? Yeah, I don't think there's a magic number on how much of our developer fee we would like to defer.

1:50:13 That's the number that's been approved in the budget by the board, but that's certainly something that the board could contemplate. The total number for the developer fee, the 351 for developer costs. I think that's what's budgeted at this moment. That's what's budgeted of that 351. 80 is deferred. 80 is deferred. 80 is deferred. Was there discussion? I had a comment.

1:50:52 I also attended the meeting, as Tom mentioned earlier, and whilst to echo his sentiment, it was great, I would say that the council approved the 700k funding. I personally found the meeting extremely confusing, and the funding request versus the statements that town staff made.

1:51:18 Dan Holler specifically said that 700,000 would fully fund the project. And I felt like I knew that was not correct. Whether you're referencing, Tom, like the contingencies or other, you know, I don't know, other potential commitments. But I just found it kind of a lot of different information.

1:51:48 And, you know, what the Town Council voted on that I felt was that they thought this would fully fund the project. I know Amanda suggested the, for additional funding to request the full amount, the 819,000. I just kind of wanted a little bit more background on why the Town Staff Report was stating that the 700,000 would fully fund it and your budget is showing.

1:52:18 A different number. Maybe it was me that was confused. Yes, so I've been thinking about this a lot, and Nolan and I have talked about this a lot. My direction from the Board of Directors was to go to the public jurisdictions and ask to fully fund the gap, which at the time we had learned was approximately 1.4 million. And so that is the goal that I had pursued when I presented the budget numbers to Nolan.

1:52:48 and the town council. I think that there was some desire for us to come to a magic number independently of our board of directors and town council, which I felt like is out of my control. I can't independently make decisions about the funding of the organization. That's the role of the board of directors.

1:53:19 And we are a Brown Act body, and this is how we conduct business. And so the town felt like $700,000 was sufficient. And while I thought that I had made a really good faith effort to reduce the budget as much as I possibly could at a staff level, it didn't seem like the town had suggested any additional funding to help fill the gap.

1:53:49 That I was able to reduce it to. And I think that's why there were two separate recommendations or two separate asks at the town council meeting. I don't think it would have been in my place to say 700,000 is sufficient. That wasn't the direction that I was given by the board. Can I ask a question? Who sets our developer costs?

1:54:18 That fee is predetermined by the state of California, and it's customarily part of the cost of development, and I believe it's, I think the section of the code that I provided, it's in the multifamily housing program guidelines at the state of California. Okay, so, but, I mean, I guess I just feel like we are so close.

1:54:48 How do we make this happen? You know, I mean, what are, I guess I feel personally I'd be willing to take less of a developer cost, but I don't know if that pencil is out for us or what other people are willing to do, but I just, I mean, I feel like we need to move this project and get it going. So how do we, you know, I feel like you're saying it's because of us that we can't change some of these numbers or that these things are set, but I feel that

1:55:17 I don't know, you know, I don't know what our books look like. I don't know what these developer costs are supposed to pay for. I don't know if the project pencils, if we, you know, just say, hey, we're going to move that $115,000 to a deferred developer, excuse me, fee. You know, I just, I want to make this project, how do we get there? How do we push it and get it going? So I guess I could say I don't have this number in front of me, but I,

1:55:49 I've looked at it before. Mammoth Lakes Housing has invested approximately a million dollars in cash into this project that is a sunk cost for the organization. And that's part of the risk of taking on this project. And I have provided the developer fee that's allowable under the guidelines and followed the directive to defer $80,000 of that.

1:56:20 If the board would like to invest more of our fee, we would be reimbursed less for the cost that we've already incurred, and that would be a decision for the board to make. We could defer more. I think it's paid back over 15 or 20 years, and that comes out of the gross revenue of the project.

1:56:50 And then, just to be clear, so it has on here, the land is $1.2 million, and we owe about $400,000 on that. So that, like that $800,000 is part of the million dollars of our sunk costs, right? Yes. So we would be getting back that $800,000, and then right now we have about $115,000 of our developer costs funded.

1:57:13 Right, because we, I mean, I just basically subtracted the $115,000 and the $80,000 from $351,000. So we should be getting $155,000 if we start signing contracts and everything. So that puts us like $44,000 short of breaking even completely on the fees that we've been paying over the last seven years and the land there that there would be, you know, no

1:57:43 Nothing borrowed on the land. The land would be completely paid for. We'd be reimbursed $960,000 and we say we've paid out a million. Is that right? I don't really understand reimbursed. So we bought the land for $1.2 and our total including interest is $1,255,374 and

1:58:23 That is included in the budget for the project, and so we would be reimbursed that full amount, but we do have about a $400,000 outstanding loan on the building. So that $1.2 million, $400,000 would pay off the loan for the building, and we would get the $800,000 back that we have already invested into the project.

1:58:45 I just want to clarify that none of the carrying costs of the project are included in the development budget. So the interest that we've been paying on the loan, snow removal, repairs to the roof, insurance that we've already paid over the past six years, none of those costs are included in the million. Those are costs that we've decided to invest in the risk of taking on this project. But the cost of the land is

1:59:14 One, two, five, five thousand or something. Those are the costs associated with the acquisition, so like escrow fees. Okay. Okay. So, I'd rather see it come out of the contingency, personally, and try to make up for that in value engineering. I saw something about the architect wanting more fees to do further value engineering. Is that, that's reflected in the...

1:59:45 Yes, the new fees for the architects to go back and incorporate the value engineering into the building permit set of plans is included in the current budget. Okay, and so it's not going to be additional value engineering from what? Correct. So they've got that down. It also, as I understand, there was two additional units added to the project from 11 to 13, so it includes

2:00:25 The redrafting of that part of the building to add those two units in it as well as incorporating the VE changes that were evaluated with the contractor, which I think we're going to discuss in the next agenda item coming up. Yeah, I mean, you know, I would point out again the contingency is a hypothetical value. I mean, it's a guesstimate. There's no telling whether we're going to be under or over. But again, I think on the risk side, on the high side, the towns expressed a commitment during the town council meeting that they would consider.

2:01:01 If we were to exceed the budget, they would consider us coming back with, you know, legitimate backup and reasons why. So, you know, I don't think we have a risk on that side of it, or, you know, we have a willing partner that's willing to work with us on that. As you pointed out, Amanda, we're going to get a substantial amount of the land value back. So, you know, I feel like we're pretty darn close, but I do see there's a couple members of town staff here, so I would assume they're going to make some comments, and I think, you know.

2:01:31 Brian, I thought maybe I heard you possibly going to provide some input as well? Yes, a couple of reflections. I think it's customary and typical for all of our pre-development costs, including land acquisition costs, and affordable housing to have that reimbursed. That's a good thing to have that capital repatriated to the organization. You know, Patricia project with the additional infusion of resources, the gap, the remaining gap based on the budget is, it's great to hear that the

2:02:11 John is willing to consider potentially an additional infusion as we get into the project. But with that type of a remaining gap, I think there's several ways that you could think about how to finance. One is we could think about continuing the capital campaign, the fundraising efforts that already spearheaded, and I think we've raised $80,000 plus could continue. The developer fee effectively becomes a source of last resort. If we can't raise that extra $120,000, we effectively leave that developer fee.

2:02:44 In the deal, and that would get ideally pulled out over time through operations, although I think it will take a while because the amount of cash flow from this type of a development I think is fairly modest. And then lastly is just managing the project to the budget and contingency, and if we can generate cost savings through the course of the project, we can reduce our uses and in essence reduce our sources, meaning we don't have to defer that piece of the fee. So just, you know.

2:03:13 Just wanted to share that. I think the town is closer. I think we're going to, gosh, when the vids came in, it was deflating, to say the least. Evaluation, so, and I just want to thank staff and Patricia for working collaboratively. It's confusing. I think Sarah appropriately stated earlier, put your heads together, and, you know, I think we can move forward, and, you know, I think we've got a great, like Menentia's great, and them to.

2:04:33 The numbers that we're getting from them, right? So if you're looking for staff direction, I would say, let's go. Let's go. Yeah. Mr. Chair, Dan Hall, our town manager for Mammoth Lakes. I did want to touch base on some of the comments and discussion we had at the council meeting, and that followed a couple other meetings in terms of trying to nail the budget down and some of the numbers and projections there. And we did come in and recommend the $700,000 on top of the...

2:05:24 $1.5 million we'd committed earlier already to the project. And I agree, the statement made earlier, the Brian, that often the pre-development costs, land costs are something that folks look to recover those costs. I'll be honest, I know a lot of the work the town's doing in affordable housing, we do not. We actually eat a lot of that cost on the front end on purpose because we're trying to make things affordable and to get projects moving and to add additional costs has that challenge on it.

2:05:53 When we said that the project is funded with the allocation, you know, you could easily, there's 800,000 coming back to the Eastern Sierra Community Housing from the land purchase. A large chunk, I believe, of the A&E soft costs were coming back in cash to those pre-development costs. You could drop either one of those by 115,000. Your budget is balanced. You're investing, yes, some more of your capital into a project, which I'm assuming that's what

2:06:23 Eastern Sierra Community Housing is about is how do we make this work. I understand the desire to bring those dollars back and reinvest them in a future project, but you need those dollars right now for this project. It doesn't mean you spend them, because as was mentioned, depending on what happens in your contingency and what happens in your developer cost to feed out of that. So when we say the project is fully funded, that's because there's up to one and a half million or more.

2:06:51 Coming back into Eastern Sierra Community Housing. Does not spend $115,000, $120,000 of that back in the project versus asking the town or the county or others to pay for that. Seems a little short-sighted in terms of getting the project done. I believe you have the adequate funding if you sign the contract tomorrow to do the construction. You're fully covered for that construction contract. The other two things that the council...

2:07:20 Agreed to and we recommended it was helping with cash flow. That was getting rid of the construction loan. So we would be putting our $2.2 million up day one, if you will, once we're moving forward so you have that cash in the bank. Request accounting could do the same thing with $600,000. That would give you 40% of your construction budget sitting in the bank in order for cash flow and stuff. Because I know getting money back from grants sometimes goes quickly, two, three months, sometimes it's six or eight months.

2:07:50 So understanding those challenges and our commitment on that is if that was the problem, let us know because we could put some additional cash in waiting for that to come back from the grant so you're not worrying about cash flow through the process on that. And at the end of that too, the reimbursement's back, which I'm assuming be at the back end of the project after everything is said and done, you kind of pay yourself back last. We end up doing that very regularly.

2:08:16 To be able to walk through those types of elements in there and say there's more dollars in there, you know, everything from everything that's been allocated from a revenue source to fully fund the capital project, that $7 million. And I would agree, I think you have additional soft costs probably above the number or it's not all reimbursed, there's still some coming. And then obviously contingency, rehab, that's a guess 10% in there.

2:08:45 Would not be surprised if you spend the majority, if not all of that. And then also the developer fee gives that last cushion as well. That is set by a guideline, but it's not absolute. You have to charge that. I think the guideline says how much they'll pay. I could be wrong on that, Patricia. But the guidelines say here's your maximum developer fee, not that thou shalt charge one. But you have the option to do it, obviously. And it's in there for that. And so based on those types of elements, the reserves there, I wasn't sure if that was for part of the project.

2:09:15 So when we were looking at the project, one, we did a lot of work and appreciate Patricia's work and Nolan's work from our team, getting rid of the debt, the $150,000 that way as well, making sure cash flow is covered, making sure that the actual project cost, if you look at the construction, A&E, and the contingency side, that's all fully funded with the dollars that are sitting there.

2:09:42 So it's not like the project can't go forward. The question is, if you have to have 100% return back to Eastern Sierra Community Housing, then you can wait and go out and try to raise another $120,000 to pay yourselves back. Meanwhile, the project languishes. So I would suggest that you do have plenty of resources to move forward. And as Tom mentioned, if there's some blow-up in the project cost, all of a sudden you've got to go to an $800,000, $100,000 contingency.

2:10:13 Project is just, who knows when you dig up a, when you go into rehab. Something, you know, pops up like that, yeah, come talk to us. We want to see the project done. Glad to see it went to 13 units and a potential, I don't remember, one or two that could be at 120%. Three of them at 120% AMI. So it diversifies the type of project, which is a good deal for the project and the community. I think that provides some additional potential ongoing revenue back as well.

2:10:42 So, again, Townsbury supported the project. The council was there, but there's also, it seems like there's a whole lot of cash sitting there that's just going to flow back into Eastern Sierra Community Housing. Ideally, yes, invested in another project, but this one needs the cash first. And so we suggest that that's a primary funding source that could go into play there and not worry about the last $115,000. It's pretty much covered. Other money comes in great. If it blows up, let us know.

2:11:12 Otherwise, I think the project, you could, technically, I'd say you could sign construction documents from a funding standpoint tomorrow. So, let's get the project going. Thanks. Glad to address any of those comments again or questions if there's a particular one on the town side. Questions? Thank you, Dan. Thank you. Comments? Any other public comments? No comments. Mr. Bobroff, would you like to make a comment?

2:11:58 Yeah, I was just going to echo Dan's comments. He pretty much repeated or said everything I was going to say, but it has been a good process for between the town and Eastern Sierra Community Housing, working with Patricia to narrow down the budget, refine the budget to hopefully get this project to the finish line. So like I said, Dan already said everything I was going to say. So this is just an informational item. We have a couple of additional items related to this project on the next.

2:12:39 Agenda items. And so if the board would like to move forward with the current budget as shown in the staff report, you don't need to do anything. We can just continue with the meeting and address that later, or you could give staff direction. I have one more question. So would you say that this project was severely affected by COVID? I guess my feeling is that

2:13:04 This project would not have sat on our books for so long. This project has probably costed us, cost more money because of COVID and due to other factors and everything. And I guess like my feeling at this point is like we just need to get it done. Like just push it over. If we have to take a small hit to get this done and to deliver these units, to me, it's worth it.

2:13:29 There were a lot of impacts due to COVID, one being the increase in construction costs and materials, and the other being the extreme delay in the grant awards, which was two years for each grant award to be awarded from application to award, which was COVID-related. Questions? Well, I think it would be good to have a consensus, even though we're not officially voting on this, but I certainly support moving forward with what...

2:14:02 As shown in the staff report that we proceed with the project. Is that, is that, I guess I'm confused because is it moving forward like signing the contracts that we want to, we want to, commit funds to, yeah, to start. So we're willing, architect moving on his contract with revisions. So we want to get the project rolling and not direct staff to fill final funding gap. Like are we, I guess that's my question because on our, on this paperwork it kind of says like,

2:14:32 The Board of Directors directed staff to fill the final funding gap and ask our public partners for support. So is the next step, Tom, that you want to take is to get the project, like start signing contracts and get it going? Or do you still? Yeah. Yeah. I agree with you. Yeah. I mean, you know, as much as we can continue ongoing other private fundraising and so forth, sure. That's obviously to our benefit regardless. And yeah, a little to echo Amanda, do we need to amend this?

2:15:04 Budget that we see here, the comparison between November 15th and December 6th, and move some money around or take some things out of contingency and developer costs so that we're at zero gap, or are we moving forward as is to just see what happens at the end? I mean, I personally think it's, you know, I'm fine with the way it is. I mean, just recognizing that, you know.

2:15:35 As the best that we know the numbers, we feel there might be a small gap, but I think it's within the bandwidth of the funding, as all the issues we've discussed, or other areas of funds, or money that's coming back to us, that, you know, we're not going to be out-of-pocket money at the end of the day, one way or the other, so, you know, we should have, you know, we should get $800,000 back on land, if, worst case, you know, whenever we get squeezed on the land reimbursement and the developer fee.

2:16:06 If these numbers bear out. But as Dan reinforced in his comments, if there was some big unknown that hit us in the contingency side of the project, there's some commitment from the town to help back us on that if need be. So again, I feel plenty comfortable myself moving forward with it as proposed. I don't think we need to revise the numbers because all kinds of things are going to happen in the next two years before we get to the finish line. Who knows?

2:16:36 It just becomes an exercise of sort of nonsense, in my opinion, to try to say we're fully balanced. It's sort of naive to think that the numbers are all going to balance what these are on these proposed budgets. So it's close enough, in my view. Patricia, is there anything in grant funding that says we have to have a balanced budget?

2:17:07 Or that funds have been awarded. There's nothing on sort of that official government end. We will be working with the home program through their closing checklist, which I believe is at least four pages long. And so as we move through that, the home program will take the project back for final underwriting and approval for the additional. They've proposed to add an additional $800,000 into the budget as an infusion for the additional two units.

2:17:37 And if there's any concerns, they'll let us know, but I don't foresee any. And yes, I would echo Tom and Amanda that let's, and Jennifer, let's do it. Let's roll forward with the information we have here. Yes, I agree. I agree as well. And just for the minutes, can you clarify what the consensus specifically was? Move forward with development with the budget as is.

2:18:13 Well, I guess that's my question. Like, I see it as a funding gap. Like, I guess I see it as I want to initiate the next step, you know, signing contracts and everything. And if there is a gap in the budget that that would, you know, we would get paid off last. Like, our developer feel like maybe we can continue. Yeah, I think that's what I'm hearing is that.

2:18:39 We're moving forward. We're still going to pursue additional sources as a team, whether that's fundraising or additional grant funds, in the meantime, as capacity allows, but that if we don't achieve that, that that would be absorbed as part of the risk of this project is what I'm hearing. We don't have to determine exactly where it's going to come out of at this moment because when it all pans out, it could come from anywhere.

2:19:13 Yeah, that's exciting. Oh, shine up the shovel. Let's do it. We'll move to agenda item 4.8. The board will consider approval of an amendment to the contract for services with Kevin Daly Architects for design and engineering service related to the values engineering process for access apartments in the amount of $228,370. Thank you. This...

2:19:51 Amendment to our contract with Kevin Daly Architects reflects the change order, so to speak, and the additional services required for them to update the existing plans to incorporate all of the value engineering and the additional two units. And once we authorize this contract, they'll be able to start work on that scope. And this contract...

2:20:22 was reviewed by our legal counsel, who was confident that it met all of his requirements as it's an amendment to our existing, what is it called, A-108 contract that we already have with Kevin Daly Architects. The only, there were some small amendments to the federal provisions so that we will be able to use Section 4 funds that we received through Enterprise.

2:20:53 If so needed to help pay for this portion of the project. And that's all I have unless there are questions. But this one has been reviewed by our attorneys in full so you could approve as is. And our consultant, Kevin Sharada, also reviewed this as well? Yes, that's right, yes. I believe he's on the line. I am on the line. Hi, everyone. Hi, Kevin. Hi, Kevin. So, Kevin's Tom here.

2:21:33 So you did, I believe you went through the KDA's amended services proposal in detail, right? That's correct. Yeah, it all looks good? It all looks good, correct. Great. I would just add that I think it's, now that this has been negotiated, that we get this service possible so we can get into the building department with our revised plan to get this project started in the spring. I don't think, as we've kind of discussed them,

2:22:13 So I'm taking that as a recommendation from the development committee that we approve it and don't question it so we can just get the ball rolling. Yeah, I mean, there is a real schedule risk because it's December and ideally you want to start this project as early as you can in the spring. So, you know, say,

2:22:49 No later than the 1st of May. So that's a very, very tight time frame to revise plans, resubmit, go through plan check, review, and get a permit issued. And there may be some options to do possibly a phased permit if need be to try to get started sooner like a foundation-only type permit if need be. But that's kind of the kind of steps we may have to take even where we are right now. So it really would present some severe challenges if we delay.

2:23:21 I'm happy to make a motion to approve the contract as presented and reviewed by our council. I'll second. I move and second it. Further discussion? Roll call. President Stepp? Yes. Vice President Hodges? Yes. Treasurer Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? I agree at the recommendation of the Development Committee. Yes. Board Member Steenstra?

2:23:58 Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. Board Member Nuttall? Yes. Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. 9. Board will receive an update regarding accounting and financial services. 4.9. 4.9, that's what I ask. And the board will consider approval of a contract for services with Mena Nisha? Mena Nisha. Mena Nisha.

2:24:39 A development group for pre-construction services for the access apartment project in the amount of $25,000. Thank you. The Mnemsha development group is the general contracting firm that we had conditionally selected for the access apartments pending securing the full funding for the project.

2:25:09 Part of that process was that we contracted with them to help with the value engineering, during which we were able to save approximately a million dollars in the construction budget. They are providing a proposal for pre-construction services to help with the ongoing coordination with the architects through the plan design process.

2:25:32 If there are additional cost savings to be found that they would help find those and then helping get the permits through the building department and being able to report on any of our achievements through that process as well. I wanted to make sure you had the correct version of the contract and so there is a version in front of you that's also been provided online for the public but the total proposed

2:26:01 Contract amount is $25,360. Make sure I said that right, $360. And so if this amount is included in the development budget that you saw in the previous item, and I'm happy to get them on board and get them started and fully onto the team so we can start coordinating and pushing this towards construction in the spring.

2:26:34 Is that in the A&E cost, the soft cost in the budget? Yes, it is. The only other thing on this contract is that legal has it. We discussed it this morning, but I am waiting for their comments. And so if the board would like to approve it pending minor legal revisions, that would be sufficient for us to continue to move forward. I would make a motion to accept it pending legal. I'll second.

2:27:07 I have a question. Is this the company that we would then be working with for construction? Yes. Have they worked in Mammoth before? Yes, I believe so. They did provide some background information at our Board of Supervisors meeting. They do have experience with public school districts.

2:27:40 Which I think is a key component as this is sort of a public-private project. And so we've had a really good relationship working with them. And they did competitively bid on it originally. That's right. Their employees would have housing to come and work here. They figure that out. That's included in their estimate. Okay, perfect. Had a reasonable. Great. Okay, thank you. No further questions. Any other comments from the board?

2:28:18 President Staff? Yes. Vice President Hodges? Yes. Treasurer Bergstel? Yes. Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. Board Member Nuttall? Yes. And Board Member Rice? Yes. Thank you. Thank you.

2:28:50 You know, since the packet was published, I'm still doing research on this item, but I'll just give a brief overview, and if there is any ideas or staff direction, that would be helpful. I'll let you know that both of our bookkeeper and our longtime accountant are phasing out for various reasons, and so I've been...

2:29:16 Trying to think strategically about what the best way to fill those responsibilities is. And so I have come up with a couple of different ideas. I have spent a lot of time looking for local resources, which I have found one, but I have another one that I would like to continue to pursue. And so maybe that's where we need a little more time for this item.

2:29:46 But I have explored automating some of the processes, utilizing some systems like bill.com that helps with accounts payables, so we're not writing checks in the office, but automating that system and cutting down on staff time. And you'll see that cost estimate for something like that. We also do need to move to QuickBooks Online, which I think will be a really big improvement.

2:30:13 Especially considering that we can open a new company file for all of our new projects. We'll have a separate bookkeeping system. They won't all be under MLH. And with the online system, you can open as many as you need. Whereas with the current desktop version, I think we can only open three, and all three have been opened with MLH, Sierra Housing Advocates, and the Innsbruck Lodge.

2:30:39 So I could really use some assistance with the technical components of moving that, you know, doing the data migration and just having some support in making sure nothing gets lost in the transfer process since technology, as we know, isn't my area of expertise. So I've just been doing a lot of research and I wanted to make the board aware that this is a gap in the moment in our capacity.

2:31:08 And I have also pursued two separate third-party accounting firms that are national, one is national, one is international, that specialize in bookkeeping and financial reporting for nonprofits specifically. And so there's an estimate of the cost of what one of those might look like if we were to utilize one of those services.

2:31:39 I think that there's some potential that once I do a little bit more research with this other local firm that is taking new clients, which is great, that maybe I could come with a better baked proposal the next time we meet. But if there is any feedback or guidance on what the board would like me to focus on or the direction that they would like me to go in the meantime, that would be great. Patricia, I will go.

2:32:18 I think it's absolutely crucial that you get that migration done and get on to more digital online version of QuickBooks. And I do think that that's going to be a pretty big endeavor. So I agree that.

2:32:37 And I think it's really important to get that set up the way you want from the beginning so that it's all ready to go and kind of all buttoned up from the get-go. It'll save a lot of time later. So I would highly recommend and support engaging a professional firm to help you do that. I think that I do think that the

2:33:06 Consultancy, or the company, the, what were they called, the, your part-time controller, I think that their costs were a little bit on the higher side, so I also see some pros and cons to, maybe more cons to having,

2:33:27 Sort of more national kind of generic company. So personally, I would encourage to go the more local route. With that in mind, though, I do think that a professional accounting firm or professional services would be more beneficial rather than just.

2:33:49 Not just, but rather than a bookkeeper to help you do, you know, some of the items that you have on your list. If you could have one firm that could do it all at a reasonable rate, at a reasonable cost, I think that that's the right direction to go. We've talked about expanding these kind of infrastructure services.

2:34:09 I think you need more resources and support to take a lot of this sort of back-end work and organization of these financial statements off of your plate, being able to produce reports in a timely manner that you know are kind of foolproof and accurate. I think you'll benefit from the additional support and expertise of a company.

2:34:37 Hopefully one of those local companies that you're talking to is able to, it's the right fit and is able to help, but I personally would support that option. I would just make note of the, that you did in the staff report note where budget lies and what you've spent to date and what remains. So, you know, it does appear that, you know, at some point we'd have to reconcile those costs with our budget.

2:35:22 Potentially go up slightly, but to your point, I mean, it's something we have to do, and I, you know, certainly not my area of expertise. You seem pretty up to speed on it, and it's certainly nice, I think, if you have a local resource, but if they don't have the specific expertise you need for the things we deal with as a non-profit housing organization, you know, it may or may not be the best choice, but I'll leave that up to you guys to determine.

2:35:56 The other thing I was going to ask or make comment on is that, you know, as we now are going to accelerate access apartments, I think we'll have to organize that development pretty quick here, right? Yeah, hopefully during the financial close, ownership will be transferred into the LLC. Right now it is owned under Mammoth Lakes Housing, and so it has a separate bank account that we've been using for pre-development.

2:36:22 for access apartments, but it's currently owned and operated under the MLH books, and so once we move through closing all the financial sources, we'll move the ownership into the LLC, and we'll need to open a new QuickBooks account. Yeah. Yeah. Fairly imminent. I wish Santa could just deliver it. Is there a discussion from the board? Do you have a preference? I don't. Initially, it was really difficult to get anybody local who would

2:37:00 Say that they had any availability or willingness to take on new clients. However, it seems like as the meeting got closer, I did find one bookkeeper who has some availability, which could be helpful, and possibly one accounting firm locally that is possibly interested, and then one other accounting firm that was maybe interested, but not really.

2:37:24 So I want to explore those options just a little bit more and see where they could fill in and maybe hopefully I could bring something more comprehensive soon. Yeah, I guess the only comment I would make is that you did point out that based on our current budget, current fiscal year budget, we have about $28,000 remaining and we're about halfway through our fiscal year. So looking at the fee proposal from that.

2:37:57 Yeah, what I really liked about that firm as opposed to the other one which I didn't provide the proposal for was that there is

2:38:30 There's no contract terms, so you can use them or not use them, and they only bill for the time they spend on it, so we wouldn't be committed to a certain amount or a certain time period. So even if I said let's just do startup, I think that they might be amenable to that. They just seemed really flexible in those terms, and so I think maybe for startup that'd be great, and then maybe get someone local to help with ongoing. For the discussion from the board.

2:39:11 Patricia, do you have a staff direction? Yes, thank you. I really appreciate it. Move on to the next agenda item, which is Mammoth Lake Housing Program update. I'll take this one. Thanks, Eric. So, yeah, we'll just fly through this. That'd be good. Just stop me whenever you guys have questions. So, rental unit turnover, we don't have any turnover. The waiting list, we have kept out 187 households.

2:39:45 We sent out some letters to see if they're still interested, so we'll be hearing back from them. And then the housing aggregators, they're participating in COC policies and procedures, subcommittees. They're reporting with Anthem on the 25K donation for access, and then they will be participating in the listening booth. I don't know if they want to share a little bit about that. Sure. I just wanted to say we did submit a proposal to Anthem Blue Cross for their...

2:40:14 Basically a proposal for use of funds under their HHIP program, HHIP, not HHAP, but different, but very similar acronyms. So that's been submitted and we'll hear back, I think, early spring, which is exciting. I can share more information later. And I also wanted to say that I was able to present with Patricia at the Albine County Board of Supervisors this past week. Yeah, so I just want to add, we did a listening booth, we partnered with Distant Brewing, and we got a lot of our community members to speak.

2:40:49 On the housing crisis in Mammoth. And we had a really good turnout. I believe we had eight written testimonies and I believe we had four videos. So I believe in total it was 12 people sharing their housing stories. Yeah, we had a good time. We had Joseph. I forgot his last name.

2:41:07 He's a realtor here in town, and we partnered with him, and he did a great job helping us navigate through editing for a video that we presented to Mono County, or we tried presenting to Mono County Board of Supervisors, and a video that we presented to the town of Mammoth Lakes. And hopefully if, you know, we can do it again, we are probably going to do it again. It was a good turnout, and I think we can probably get a bigger crowd next time. So transitional housing.

2:41:42 That's our Birch Creek project. There has been no changes since the last report, so that's good. Ownership programs. So our Marine Corps E-301 is currently in escrow at 150% AMI. The repairs were completed. Yeah, were completed. So that's good. AMRing, we're up to 81%. That's good. Ownership wait list. There has been no changes reported. So the town.

2:42:21 For that, Marine Corps Unit, we're going to be using for that. Moving on to projects. So, Innsbruck Lodge, like you guys saw in the presentation, demolition was completed, and then we requested a TCO, or it was submitted to the town. Aspen Apartments, town gave us $700,000, and then $600,000, and so we sent our money, and then up to date, we continued on that. Valley Apartments, we're waiting for the next PRP notebook to come out. We've been coordinating with Kevin, trying to get a meeting.

2:43:13 Environment Phase 1, and then we're working at Stan's Lost Housing Authority. Silver Peaks, we're pursuing affordable housing and the work items that we completed. And you attended the customer service? Oh, that's it, yeah. Okay, great. I just wanted to touch on, in terms of staff, I have two staff evaluations that I would like to complete. Eric has a six-month.

2:44:06 Which would complete his year, and then Olya has a six-month evaluation upcoming, and we've implemented weekly check-in meetings individually with each staff on Fridays, so that's a great chance for us to catch up on how progress has gone during the week, and then we have our weekly staff meeting on Mondays. Olya mentioned we attended the Alpine Board of Supervisors meeting in person in Markleyville.

2:44:34 Last week, which was really successful and a great opportunity to meet face-to-face with some of our partners that maybe sometimes you don't recognize on Zoom, so that was great. I wanted the board to know that we were awarded a CCRH internship this year, and so we'll start recruitment in January, and we have reached out to a couple of folks who were interested in the past or that have

2:45:01 Shown interest already, and so hopefully we'll be able to get an intern on board to help with some of our projects that we have. And I am presenting at the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce Board of Directors meeting on Wednesday. They are interested in the funding stack of access apartments, and so I'll be happy to share with them all the different funding sources that we've secured for that project.

2:45:32 And then upcoming agenda meeting items, just I wanted to make you all aware that in January when we do meet, we will be appointing new board officers. So if anyone's interested in shifting their responsibilities around, we'll need a president, a vice president, and a treasurer. I have a few new fundraising irons in the fire, so I'll keep you posted on how that goes.

2:46:03 And I think we should consider rescheduling the January board meeting. Do we want to do that now? Or I can send an email. What's the date that it's supposed to be? I think it's the 1st. Oh, let's reschedule. It's Monday, January the 1st. Yeah, we could just put it on the 8th. Makes more sense. I'm fine with turning it, just doing it the following Monday. Okay, perfect. Let's just do that. Monday, January 8th.

2:46:47 That's all I, yeah, that's all I had, I think that was interesting. Can you put the address of the hotel I'm staying at as a public meeting location? We can, yes, we can chat about that, yes. I'll be out of town, sorry. I had a question, Patricia, does the, just you mentioned about the chamber, and I kept meaning to ask you this, do they still have their housing coordinator position in place?

2:47:30 I believe so, that Marcy Castro is currently filling that position at the chamber. Oh, okay, okay, I, I, yeah, okay, I knew that it wasn't the same person, so I didn't know if it had been filled, but okay, that's great. And, and in that same sort of thought process, maybe more of a question for, for Jennifer, has the county housing manager position, has he started and is in place? Yes, Tyrone.

2:48:10 He has started, he is doing a lot of investigative work, just really trying to understand the landscape and digging in our housing ad hoc committee regularly. Awesome, that's great. Patricia, do you see, and maybe you guys have already talked about this in the committee, but do you see potential, you know, collaboration, partnership with, you said Tyrone, is that his name? Yeah, Tyrone.

2:48:47 Yes, yeah, I do. I've met with Tyrone. We had coffee for about an hour and a half, and we talked about housing almost the entire time, and we both have a lot of ideas. And he's reached out a couple of times via phone, and I know he's researching a lot of the state programs, and so I think he's going to be a great collaborative partner. Awesome. Yes, he's very inquisitive. Both of you. Yeah, good, yeah.

2:49:41 We're adjourned.