Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board · 2025
Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board
at 18:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
270 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:43 Okay. Good evening. I'd like to call to order the monthly meeting of the Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board. This is a regular meeting of Public Benefit Corporation's 501C3, Eastern Sierra Community Housing, Inc., whose mission is to support affordable housing for a viable economy and sustainable community. Roll call, please, Angie. President Hodges. Present. Vice President Barksdale. Here. Treasurer Nuttall is absent. Board Member Stapp. Present. Board Member Kreitz.
3:21 Here. Board Member Steenstra is absent. Board Member DeAndrea. President. And Board Member Rice. Here. Thank you. Okay, we have a quorum. We'll continue. Moving on to agenda item two, public comments. This is an established time for any member of the public wishing to address the Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board of Directors on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda. Members of the public desiring to speak on a matter appearing on the agenda should ask the president for the opportunity to be heard.
3:53 When the item comes up for consideration. Public comments may also be submitted to the Executive Director at Patricia at ESCH or ESCH housing dot org or clerk at townofmammothlakes.ca.gov before or during the meeting. It may also be made it here in person in Suite Z by or by raising your hand online on Zoom. Do we have any public comment? If you wouldn't mind, please introduce yourself or state your name.
4:23 Sure. Good evening, Mr. President, Madam, Vice President, Board Members. My name is David Eichmann. I'm the Interim Director of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. First of all, I want to thank you for your service on this board. As you're well aware, the number one reason why businesses can't open or expand in Mammoth Lakes is housing.
4:48 We look forward to continuing to work with you to address that, which of course is a multi-year problem, as you know. I also just wanted to make you aware of some upcoming chamber events. Tomorrow night, we have our non-profit coalition mixer, five to seven, right down here at MAC at the Community Arts Center. And that gives a chance for all the non-profits to get to network with each other.
5:16 And also for members of the community to learn about the nonprofits. They'll each be given a chance to do a little pitch. So that'll be fun. So again, five to seven down here. It's free for chamber members, $15 for anyone else. There will be appetizers and refreshments. The next event that we're organizing is on Tuesday, June 24th. Again, from five to seven.
5:44 That's the next business after hours. It's hosted by MLT with Visit California. It will be over at the Welcome Center. And again, that's open to everyone and it's free. So that's on the 24th, 5 to 7 at the Welcome Center. And then the chamber has been spending almost all of our time on the July 4th parade, which we've gone through all the sponsors. We actually must
6:12 Gloat a little. We have a record number of sponsors this year, which is good, considering it's not the best economy at the moment for some businesses. HCL is going to be the lead sponsor. And, of course, our grand marshals are Chris Benchetler and Kimmy Fazzani. And so this actually is some art from Chris, which Gina Van Hess, the communications manager for the chamber, designed into the minarets.
6:40 And then we have the butterflies, which are a shout out to Kimmy and her movie, Butterflies in a Blizzard. So we're excited. It's a Friday. So we're expecting even more people in town for that. And what we've just opened up is float registration. So I'm going to float the idea to you. Maybe the board wants to do a float. For nonprofits, it's only $35. Chamber members, 40.
7:09 Non-members, 60. So also as people in the community, you may know businesses or individuals or organizations that would want to have a float. So this is the time to do it. We're trying to register them as early as possible. The greatest number apparently was 54. So we're hoping to get 55 this year and beat the record. So any help you can give us with that. And again, thank you so much for your service.
7:38 Pleasure to meet you. Thank you so much. Love the flyer. All right. Are there any other public comments, Angie? No comments at this time. Okay. With that, then we will move on to agenda item three, consent agenda item 3.1, approval of the minutes from the May 5th, 2025 regular board meeting. I'll entertain any motions to approve or amend. I'll motion to approve. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion?
8:13 Seeing that, we'll take roll call, please, Angie. President Hodges. Yes. Vice President Barksdale. Yes. Board Member Stapp. Yes. Board Member Kreitz. Yes. Board Member DeAndrea. Yes. And Board Member Rice. Yes. Thank you. Okay. With that, then we will move on to agenda item four, policy matters, item 4.1. The board will review and consider adoption of the budget for fiscal year 2025-26. And Patricia. Great. Thank you.
8:44 Our Director of Finance, Chris Fisher, is here with us this evening, so I'm going to let him kick off this item and then we'll dive into the details. Thank you, Patricia. It's good to see everyone on the board again. I just wanted to give sort of a quick little update on sort of the relationship with charter impact and where we're at right now and sort of high level how we came together with the budget that we're proposing for this next for the next fiscal year.
9:13 We've been working for about two months now with Patricia, and the current financials are all being processed now inside of Charter Impact Sage account. We are obviously doing all of the day-to-day financial activities that are needed to support the organization. The reason why I don't have financial statements for you tonight but will in the future is
9:38 We are still in the process of reconciling some of the year-to-date information. So we've had access to QuickBooks, we've been poking around QuickBooks, looking at QuickBooks reports for a while. They're mostly reconciled, but not everything is 100% reconciled with the audited financial statements that we've reviewed.
9:58 The prior accounting firm, I've reached out to them. They have told me that they have no additional working papers than what is inside of QuickBooks.
10:09 So they have not been particularly helpful in helping us sort out some of the small discrepancies we found. So I've reached out to Tom, the auditor for Eastern Sierra, to see if he's able to, if he has any collateral that might be able to get us a little bit closer. If not, we're going to have to go to the point where we're going to have to look at old emails and stuff like that. But we just want to make sure that we have the cleanest data possible going into our system so that...
10:36 We're starting with clean data coming out. So in the interim, Patricia and I have spent the last two months working on the budget. It's been a combination of, like I said, looking back. I have access to QuickBooks, the historical information. So it's been a combination of looking back at historical data, historical trend lines, looking at the budget that was approved by the board for the current fiscal year that we're in.
11:05 And then Patricia and I have had maybe a half a dozen sessions together for me to ask questions to better understand the sort of relationship between the LLCs, some of the activities that have been going on, what she knows might be coming in the next fiscal year. And so we have been working on this budget for the past two months.
11:33 I'm going to, at this point in time, cede the time back to Patricia to sort of walk through some of the details with more of the historical lens of where we came up with the numbers last year and sort of how they influence what we're planning on doing next year. But thank you for your time and looking forward to continuing next month to...
11:58 You know, have a more detailed financial package once we've had the sort of legacy information reconciled to the extent that we're comfortable with obviously representing Eastern Sierra in the next coming audit cycle. Great. Thank you, Chris. As another note, I think just looking at this package that we provided you is that the financials haven't really changed.
12:31 too much in terms of complexity, I guess. However, the number of financial statements has doubled. So we don't only have Eastern Sierra Community Housing and Sierra Housing Advocates, but we also have Innsbruck Lodge, LLC, and Access Apartments, LLC. So there was additional work that we had to put in to sort of create those fresh for the organization and the board to review.
13:01 We can start, we'll just start with revenue on Eastern Sierra Community Housing. I'll just hit on some highlight items and then we can talk about any comments or concerns the board has. Patricia, for clarity, are you reviewing what was sent out in the packet? Are you reviewing what you just handed out? I'm reviewing what was handed out is the same numbers, but what was handed out has
13:32 This fiscal year for comparison. Okay. But the green numbers are all the same. Right, right. I just want to make sure, because if there's any discrepancies, yeah. Thank you. Yeah, I'm sort of looking back and forth. So under revenue, I projected that we would have the same contract income from the town of Mammoth Lakes. This is the same amount that we've had in our contract.
14:02 With the town of Mammoth Lakes, at least for the last five years. And so that revenue line item is unchanged. You'll see that the Alpine County Housing Navigator contract is budgeted for the full amount in the coming fiscal year. That is pending a contract renewal with Alpine County, which I'm still working on.
14:24 You will see an increase in the property management fees, and that's due to a projection that will continue to manage the Innsbruck Lodge and collect fees from that property, but also bring on access apartments in the coming fiscal year and collect fees from that property as well. This also includes property management fees from the Star Apartments, which is owned under Eastern Sierra Community Housing. Contract income other is our small contracts.
14:54 It includes the City of Bishop, a contribution from Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, as well as any broker's fees that we collect throughout the year for real estate transactions. We added a revenue line item for the Chip-In Business Program. That program is generating monthly revenue right now. We made a projection.
15:24 of what we think we maybe could collect in the next fiscal year if no other businesses sign up. So if other businesses sign up, which would be great, then it would be higher than that. And that is our business partnership program for businesses to switch over to a credit card processor who donates parts of their commission fees to us as a nonprofit.
15:51 We also have interest income, which we haven't had in the past, and that is being generated from a money market account where we deposited proceeds from the financial closing of the Access Apartments building, and that's the annual estimated amount of revenue. You know, in this budget, I predicted grant administration here as zero. You know, I think
16:23 The previous fiscal year was around $10,000. This fiscal year I'm projecting around $6,000, maybe a little bit more. We could probably, you know, estimate maybe $10,000 to $15,000 there. It just depends on how much, when our first-time homebuyer grants expire, how many homebuyer mortgage assistance loans we're able to complete. And, for example,
16:53 Right now, we're working in partnership with the town of Mammoth Lakes, administering their PLHA, Home Buyer Assistance Program, in conjunction with the bridge program, and that's being paid for through contract income under the town contract. So there's some things we could do to collect grant administration fees, and that number is not included here.
17:24 Same with fundraising. I've historically forecasted fundraising really low, but we have made a concerted effort in the past to increase our fundraising sources and sources of revenue. And then the other revenue line item is for last fiscal year, it was an investment of net proceeds by the board towards
17:54 administration of the organization from prior year revenue and then a few other miscellaneous items that are all lumped in there whereas previously other revenue was really application fees and so that's why there's a big difference in those numbers there and I didn't project any other revenue source in the coming fiscal year. You could stop there. I was going to ask you, Patricia, on
18:25 You know, Mammoth Mountain's been pretty consistent in making the donation annually, so I think we can go ahead and reflect that in the budget. Yes, that is included under contract income other. Okay. Okay, and then for the individual projects and the developer fees, where do we recognize those? Chris and I had a conversation about this, and I believe we put it under other income.
19:00 At the bottom of the balance sheet. And I'm not sure if we completely landed on what the best way to show that is, but I had mentioned maybe booking it as a liability and then having the project pay it off over time. And then that way it's a liability that's owed to us instead of operating.
19:31 Revenue, but we have in the past had it at under operating revenue. Okay. Is that like the, like from the access apartments, wasn't there like a $400,000 developer fee? Yes. Which we deferred a huge chunk of it, right? Yes, 100% of it. Yeah. At this time. Okay, all of it. 100% of the $400,000? Yeah. Yes, it's $416,000, which was 100% deferred, and that was a requirement of the additional investment that the town of Mammoth Lakes made.
20:00 I thought we still got a portion we can get, but there's a contingency? Correct. Okay. Yes. And so we're at the point now where we need to start balancing the contingency against any other outstanding line items, including the developer fee and carrying costs over the lifetime of the project. So actually, Leslie, our intern, will be helping me.
20:28 Compile all of our pre-development invoices in the next few weeks and making sure we can put a number to those pre-development investments but also the carrying costs and then we have the number of the developer fee as well. Brian has his hand raised. Yeah, go ahead, Brian. Hi, everyone. Patricia, we are operating on an accrual basis as opposed to a cash basis, correct? Correct. Okay.
21:00 Because the developer fee that we are deferring on access, I believe, should be accrued or should be being accrued over the life of the project. So we should be booking a developer fee revenue even if we're not collecting cash and then it automatically is reflected as a liability of that LLC back to Eastern Sierra. And so if you do that, I don't think you're going to end up with
21:30 Additional accrued developer fee revenues for that project in the fiscal year ahead because the project theoretically will be complete, well by the end of this fiscal year perhaps it will slip slightly into the following fiscal year. So just a point on kind of treatment, those traditionally are from an accounting perspective if you're on an accrual basis are
21:56 Booked on a straight line basis over the construction period from the point of closing to when the project is completed. And then separately, I guess, a question about Valley, are you assuming, it doesn't appear to me that we're assuming any fees associated with the Valley closing in the fiscal year ahead, is that correct? That's correct. There is none included in this proposal. We can add that and
22:27 And book it as an accrual. Similarly, it's also a deferred developer fee. Okay, so I think you would look at it from the point at which you expect to close on Valley, which might be six months or eight months into the future, and whatever time remains in that fiscal year, you know, perhaps there's an accrual. But I don't think we should be going into that project assuming that 100% of that developer fee is deferred. I think there should be a fee that is earned.
23:01 You're only really deferring it if there are not enough sources to cover your uses. That becomes your contingency of last resort. To that point, Brian, if we are, the last report I heard we were doing pretty well, knock on wood, with our contingency fund on access and will likely not expend.
23:32 A significant portion of the contingencies, from what I understand. In which case, would we then be able to claim the developer fee for coming in, you know, ahead of budget, so to speak? Yeah, I would think our, we would be bringing the project in under, essentially under budget and would not need to defer the fee as we originally anticipated at closing. And so that fee could be paid out, you know, in one of the final
24:02 You know, disbursement requests to the lender or lenders that remain with undrawn proceeds. Okay. So that could be a significant amount of money. And then, remind me on the other pre-development costs that we, potentially from access, that we would get paid back for, would that go back to the parent entity, the ESCH?
24:33 For all those sunk pre-development fees? Yes, yeah, yes. So that's like a reimbursement that you should get that, right? Yeah, I've run a few reports for Leslie and we're going to meet again on it tomorrow. Just hoping that some of these reports from QuickBooks will help her, you know, make sure she finds all the right invoices and we can check them off and come up with a billing package to get reimbursed through CDBG. Can I ask you a question? How come there's no developer fee for the Valley Apartments?
25:02 That's the one that I said, there's no developer. Yeah, it wasn't included. We can include an estimate for it. And I think going back, I need to review that development budget again before we close on that grant. But the board will have a chance to look at that before we move forward. Because I guess from the town's perspective, like I feel like the town has supported MLH for a really long time and then
25:29 You know, us putting on a big developer fee on the Access Department. I know we waived that fee, but, you know, like, I just feel like if we're going to do that to the town, we need to be doing that on the developments that are not in the town as well. I think that's what she said she was proposing, is deferring it just like we did on Access. No, but that's not what I'm saying. You misheard. So I'm saying, like, the town, I mean,
25:55 The City of Bishop has not been supporting our organization since its inception, and so to me it doesn't sit right to, you know, try to charge the...
26:06 The town money for a developer fee and then do another project in another town that has not been supporting you and to not charge them a developer fee. That doesn't sit right. But it's not charged to the town. Yeah, we don't. It comes through the grant. It's included though, right? Like we were trying to close the budget and the town put in the extra money to close the budget. That's why the town was arguing, you know, your budget is not short because you have this big developer fee on there. So, I mean, that's bringing up old arguments. Yeah, I think
26:36 I think this is also part of a conversation I like to have with the town's contract committee because all of our work on access apartments is not part of the town contract necessarily and we're still doing 100% of our work or more under the town contract in addition to access apartments and funded all of the pre-development.
27:06 Acquisition independently as an independent business. And so I think that's being combined and I'm not sure that it's like supplanting or supplanting one use of funds for another but they're for different purposes. Yeah. I have a few questions too when you're ready. I'm sorry. Before we leave the subject of developer fees, is there anything to be
27:38 With Innsbruck? Oh, and I guess my other point would be certainly if there's a budget deficit in the Valley Apartments Project, we will go to the jurisdictions to ask for money. That's just part of the financing process, of course. And I understand it's a little early to know for certain where those things lie. But in terms of Innsbruck, though, is there, remind me, is there a developer fee deal on that as well?
28:09 Yes, we collected the developer fee, and a portion of it went towards operations, not in the last fiscal year, but in the previous, I think, two fiscal years, and so that revenue has been received. Okay. Nothing due current or moving forward into the either current year or next fiscal year? Correct. I don't believe so, but Chris and I can work on making sure all the developer fees are reconciled.
28:37 Okay, so I guess, again, the big question would be if and how much would we potentially realize through savings and contingency on access and whether we recognize that as a revenue in particular, I guess. It could be a significant amount of money, I guess. And then to what extent amount on these other fronted pre-development fee costs for
29:07 Access as well, the architectural fees that we paid and the acquisition costs and carrying costs and so forth. Yes. Yep. Right. Okay. All right. I'm sorry. Jennifer, you had some comments. Yeah. Thank you. I just wanted to see. Okay. Well, it seems like... Okay. I'll ask my question. Did we approve a contract with Mono County that had an increase?
29:43 And funding? Or was it not? Yes. Yes, it's for one year and that is the moving forward. Is that reflected? No. Okay. It's reflected in actually this fiscal year because we did receive additional funds this fiscal year. Okay. But I didn't project it forward for the next extension. But it is part of next year as well? It should be added in, yeah. Okay.
30:13 And then how, you said that the Alpine was pending. How confident are you in that pending? Is it like we're just waiting on the contract or we're not even, we're like 50% sure, 25% sure? How conservative are you being with that pending?
30:34 I've added the revenue in here just based on recent conversations and a desire for Alpine County to have staff in their office more regularly. Your desire or their desire? Their desire. Okay. And so if they would like staff in their office more regularly, then they need to pay for the position. Okay. So you're pretty confident it's going to... Yeah, 75%, I guess. Okay.
31:04 Worth noting where you feel you're projecting revenues conservatively versus not. And I think you're articulating that around the town contract, which is stagnant still, but under discussion, given inflation, that probably is going to change, I would imagine, and cost of services.
31:33 Right, similarly to Mono County's contract has increased. Yeah, right, exactly. So that's, that I would assume you're doing a conservative budgeting there. The Mono County one, I mean, obviously you know what that is. And then the Alpine County, you're 75% sure. So, you know, I just, thinking about it that way, I think is helpful.
32:06 For me, as one board member, to think about next year, given all the uncertainties we have right now, and the grant administration that you referenced that, you know, could or could not. Because, as I understand it, what are the grants that we have funding for that have
32:33 Have program activity delivery fees associated on that could be used next year. Do we have active grants? So, for example, along similar lines with access is a CDBG grant that we were awarded that we haven't taken any administration funds from because it's all going towards the construction and the development costs. So that wouldn't have any grant admin funds associated with it.
33:02 We do have an active CDBG award through the town for homebuyers' assistance, mortgage assistance, and so there's some activity delivery that we can build. Potential. Yeah. And then we have our CalHome grant for another six months or so, and so if we do another CalHome award, there's a little bit there, but it's not very much. It's negligible. Yeah. Okay. I think that's it on my questions. I think that...
33:32 It seems like, if I could just make a comment and not a question, that the developer fees and then the reimbursement of our investment into access are still being fleshed out. We don't have that locked. And, you know, and I see on our agenda, we have an, you know, it's agendas that we should approve.
34:04 Consider adoption of the budget today. You know, I think you've got a number in here for developer deferred fee. It sounds like there's some work to be done between you and Chris and the positive feedback that we got from Brian or direction kind of advice from Brian seems helpful, but maybe we could adopt a budget, perhaps this budget, you know, with these.
34:32 Because we have to adopt it today or can we adopt it in July? I don't know if we've ever adopted it in July, but I believe last year we adopted it and then we made changes and adopted it again in July. Yeah.
34:49 I mean, that kind of scenario is kind of what I was leading to because, you know, we've just found that there's a little bit more revenue in Mono County and we don't know exactly, you know, I'd be comfortable adopting it knowing that we were going to have to make some more large changes in the near future. Typically, we do those budget adjustments when we need to when they become realized.
35:11 And we don't have enough information today to add them, it seems. Yes, yeah, and historically, my preference is to bring a draft in May. I don't think I did that last year and certainly not this year, so that we have that time to add in that iterative process. And so if we need to, yeah, make some changes, we can do that and bring it back at the next meeting. Right, right, and re-adopt it. Yeah. I mean, I think it's understandable that we're in this place, given...
35:40 The prior firm's capacity and ability and then now trying to transition in such a short time period to a new firm and everything we're going through. So this seems acceptable to me, I guess, I'm just going to leave it at that. I guess my question is just that I'm reading it right, is that our annual forecast is negative $21,068, right?
36:09 The net operating revenue is negative $64,188. Okay. So, and then down below, then it says the net income. Like, is the, like, I just want to make sure that I'm reading it right. So, the net operating income is negative $64,000, and then what's the net income $21,000 for? The below the line after operations is typically where we include the operational budget for the Star Apartments project itself.
36:37 And so you'll see rental income from Star Apartments, and then you'll see the expenses for that property, and then the net revenue from that property specifically. Okay, so then, so would we add those two negative numbers up to find what? The negative and the positive of the access to get to the total number. Which comes to the $21,000. So that's what I was asking, the $21,000 is the, like, that's what will be in the red for this?
37:06 Typically we look at the net operating income for the organization and we don't include operating budgets from properties specifically. Okay, so our net operating income will be negative $64,188 this year? Yes. Okay. And so ideally Star Apartments would have its own budget similar to Innsbruck and Access, but it's owned under Eastern Sierra Community Housing as a
37:39 As a business, and so that's why it's still on this balance sheet. Okay. But once we move it into its own LLC, it will have its own balance sheet. So I feel like I don't remember doing this last year. And so I just, to me, that's scary that it's negative $64,000 and then another negative $21,000. So is that how we operate? Well, it's actually, the Star Apartments is actually a positive of $43,000.
38:14 Okay, so I'm reading it wrong. So the net other income is plus $43,000, and then this $21,000 is the $64,000 minus $43,000. Exactly. Okay, so overall? Overall. Between everything, we'll have negative $21,000. Right. And I think it's worth pointing out, too, board member Rice, that there's...
38:38 We don't know the town contract amount. It's conservative. And then there was some amount not included from the Mono County contract. Oh, yeah. And I haven't gone through all the expenses, so I do have a few other comments about why. So I'm not sure. Yeah, maybe we're getting ahead of it by getting straight to the 64. Maybe we should wait. You want me to run through the expenses? Yeah, I was going to see this. Why don't we run through the expenses then? Okay, so I'm just going to highlight, I think,
39:10 Some points where I see. So you'll notice on fiscal year 24-25 and the proposed fiscal year maybe some fluctuations. And that's a little bit because Chris and I have tried to condense some of the line items. And so they don't all exactly match up between this budget and last year's budget. So I've tried to focus my eyes mostly on
39:38 You know, the bottom line of each subsection. And so you'll see under marketing now includes all of our graphic designer, web developer, you know, printing the annual report and things like that. So that's why that number is higher this year than you would have seen last year, for example.
40:08 And then I wanted to point out that accounting and audit is down $25,000. And we did execute a three-year contract with Charter Impact. I believe it's $80,000 a year. And that's being allocated to each of the LLCs to pay their fair share of the cost to operate the business and their financials.
40:37 And so we're saving money by spreading our costs out over the portfolio. So that's down. And then you'll see under pre-development expenses, which we have historically called strategic investment, you know, a line item for the board to insert an expense for a specific project or goal.
41:05 This year we're calling it pre-development expenses, and I've added $50,000 of expense for consulting and project management for Valley Apartments specifically, but could also be used for other potential projects. If we're doing an environmental analysis on a piece of land and we need to spend some upfront money, that's where this expense line item would show in the budget. And then can I ask the consulting?
41:34 It's gone up like $33,000 from last year, what that bump is from. Oh yes, okay, right, yes, and consulting other is, I've added a few things in there as well. One is a transaction coordinator who is helping us with all of our bridge real estate transactions to help homeowners get into homes. That's an hourly rate for that person. It's not that many hours, but it is a cost that we have, so it's included in there.
42:04 And then I've also added the one thing that I didn't write my notes here, but the one thing I know I added here was consulting for human resources consulting and some of those other, oh, I remember, Sierra Employment Services. If we did want to hire a temp, we've had those conversations at the board level before, and I wanted to make sure we memorialize those conversations so that we can hire capacity if we need to, and it's in the budget.
42:37 For those professional services around HR, for example, but also for any temp employees through the temp agency or other professional services that we might seek out as we grow. Those are probably all of the most interesting items. Another thing... Patricia? Yeah. Go ahead. I was just going to comment on the notion of pre-development costs.
43:14 If those are on deals that we expect to move forward, those costs would typically be capitalized. They wouldn't be expensed under the income statement. They'd be carried as a pre-development cost, as construction in progress or development in progress on the balance sheet. And they'd be carried there until such time as the deal moved forward and the costs were reimbursed. Or if the deal didn't move forward, at that point, you would take those costs and you would expense them directly from the balance sheet and write them off.
43:43 But I don't think it's typical to consider those in expense unless it is, you know, kind of a pursuit cost with a low level of likelihood or low probability of, you know, those deals moving forward and you were just characterizing it as kind of an acquisition or a pursuit type effort. But if it's on deals that, like for instance, Valley, that, you know, you got to, you know,
44:11 Procure a phase one environmental report. Maybe you have to do an update to the P&A. I mean, those should be costs that we're putting directly onto the balance sheet. That's a great comment, Brian. I think to your point, I think we have said that there are potentially things that we've spent time on that didn't manifest into a transaction or a project. And I can remember a couple of properties we chased and nothing worked out.
44:44 So, I mean, it'd probably be reasonable to carry some expense on that line item. I don't know if you characterize it as pre-development expense or business development. I don't know, something like that, possibly. Yeah, and I wonder if there's a policy that maybe we don't have about when those get capitalized, because we still need to have the revenue in order to spend the money up front. So, like, is it like...
45:09 Capitalize these things quarterly and then hope to get reimbursed at some point. Well, like Brian says, you would take it to that whatever entity that's stood up or whatever that you would start, you know, capturing as capitalized cost. And as long as the project proceeds, then that rolls into that entity. And then, but if it, if for whatever reason, it
45:38 Doesn't come to fruition, then you have to expense it at that point. There could be different sources for it. The Eastern Sierra Treasury could be a source because we have cash on hand. And this is, for instance, one of the reasons we want to be generating positive developer fees because we need to be capitalizing ourselves to be able to pursue future projects. Another source would be going out to a LISC or a LIFT to get pre-development.
46:05 Capital that is tied to a particular project, and they might require a trustee and a loan agreement, but there are various ways to pay for these things. I think that's separate and apart from where they should be carried, though, and I agree with Tom. Maybe there's, you know, a portion of this that you carry here as, like, a pursuit cost, things that, you know, may not pan out, but the stuff that's on a live transaction where we have site control, we're moving ahead, we might have commitments to financing at hand.
46:34 I think those should be carried on, you know, on the Eastern Sierra balance sheet. How often does it, like a project fall through that you've spent money? I mean, I guess I feel like going in, how I would do a transaction or something, like do we have plans drawn up and then the project falls through and we've wasted money on those plans? I know that access apartments took a long time to complete, but yeah. But I'm thinking like if we pursued a real estate transaction, maybe we...
47:05 Fronted an inspection cost and an appraisal and then found out that it didn't make sense, then we stopped. Yep. But you might have spent several thousand dollars. So in that regard, I probably wouldn't put this line at anything more than 10,000 maybe as a placeholder for the moment. Well, and I guess, yeah, yes, I see both.
47:29 ways, and so we can certainly make an amendment based on the recommendation. I guess my perspective just was in the past, you know, we've had project budgets that maybe didn't include the project manager, and then we've hired the project manager separately under Eastern Sierra Community Housing's operating budget. And so I guess my question is
47:57 Something like that, for example, which may be an ongoing cost, but isn't staff necessarily. Where do we want to fund? Brian, you've got a little more experience with that, but it's kind of a cash flow issue where we're affronting money, but ultimately it will get paid through the entity ultimately. Right, but we still have to have the cash map available. Yeah. And most developers, if they're advancing cash review deals, they're charging, this is a whole other level, but you're charging a pre-development interest rate on all those.
48:28 Advances, there's an opportunity cost to us, you know, advancing those costs, but that, we don't have to go there necessarily, but for any of like, for instance, the Zen Development, you know, construction management costs, those are costs that are tied specifically to projects, those should be on the project balance sheet, and shouldn't be touching the AFH, or the, excuse me, the Eastern Sierra income statement. I think ideally, I'm just not sure, I think there's some gray area.
48:58 Well, I'm glad Chris is here to hear this conversation and, you know, that you and Chris can work through these changes together. And, Chris, feel free to speak up if you have comments. I mean, as one board member, I'd like to hear from you as well. Yeah, thank you. It's been interesting to listen in so far. With respect to developer fees, you know, I did take some time. There's just nothing in the audit.
49:22 The last audit that I looked at, there's no, there's revenue, there's no comments about it being deferred or where it's sitting on the balance sheet or anything like that, so that's certainly going to be a focus that I'm taking away from this is that we definitely need to do some more digging. I need to do some more digging on my end, familiarize myself with sort of exactly what's happening with the current state of developer fees because the audit that I've been using for most of my background just...
49:49 Doesn't sufficiently speak to that at all. To Brian's point about what gets capitalized versus what doesn't get capitalized, I take that point. Certainly, there are, as you described, certainly things that, yes, I would 100% agree that's a balance sheet item that sits in CIP until the project's completed.
50:13 I will take that as a note to go back. Patricia and I will spend some more time sitting down and talking about what maybe necessarily made up that $50,000 assumption. Some of that I'm sure probably moves onto a balance sheet item and some of it maybe, to your point, stays at a little bit of a level in there. I think part of the maybe
50:43 Question, or I guess just sort of statement of feedback is yes, there's two ways to look at it. You're right, Brian, we do run the books on an accrual basis. We did not yet put together like a CapEx budget for next year. So currently what you're looking at is more of, in a sense, yes, there's some cash implications of, hey,
51:12 Have you prepared, um,
51:43 Like a statement of cash flows on a budget basis where we could see from an investing cash flows basis the type of cash that we might need to fund our CapEx or our CIP in a given fiscal year? Because I'm not 100% reconciled on the balance sheet because I don't have great beginning balances yet. No, we haven't done a cash flow and we haven't done a balance sheet budget yet. So that's...
52:12 It's coming. It'll be available next month. That's something that we should work on. But I don't have one to present to you today, no. Okay. All right. And I'm happy to make myself available if, either, Patricia, you know, you want to tap me for any additional, you know, thoughts or perspective on any of this. Yeah, the context and advice would be appreciated. That'd be great. Patricia, if I may, I had a quick question for you in regards to the
52:42 Personnel expenses and the assumptions of what's included in the 436 in terms of positions and bodies. So I'm assuming it's yourself and the two navigators. Is that the count? It includes myself and the two navigators and the intern. And the intern. OK. So that's covered in those costs. And so then in addition to that, we have, as you mentioned, in the other consulting,
53:14 Some allowance for potentially some temp employment expense. That's where I put it. Somebody there, right. And maybe a real estate coordinator for helping with some of the bridge program, so forth. So give you a little extra, if you can find the right person, the talent. Right. Being the key, but you have some allowance there that you didn't otherwise have. So, I mean, I think that's a good thing as much as we've talked about, you know, the need for more help and, you know, I think it's good. We've got some coverage there.
53:43 Does that also include like Eric's position or no? No. But it looks like it hasn't really changed from last year, right? Yeah, let me pull up my... I think it's because... And it looks like the actual is $338 from last year and the budget from last year was $427. That's because we had vacancies throughout the year. And Eric's salary was not included in that? Let me just double check.
54:15 I don't believe so. And also last year our navigator position sort of terminated before full expenditure, right? Yeah. Yeah, we had a lot of vacancies last year. So I'm not surprised by the $338. It's lower, right? It should be lower. It's about $100,000 lower. What? What are you asking is lower? The budgeted. The budgeted is actually an increase of about $10. Oh, okay. It is.
55:09 A full-time executive director, two full-time housing navigators, the intern and the property manager. Oh, okay. Okay. Oh, that's an addition. But some of his gets paid from the properties, no? Yes, through the property management fees is how we're paying it. Oh, I see. At the moment. Which are recognized as revenue up top. As revenue. Got it. I have two questions at the moment. With the
55:50 Intern, where is the revenue for that intern position? Contract, income, other. Perfect, thank you. And then I just wanted to follow up on Tom's question about the, is it Mammoth Resorts or Altera donation? Is it from Mammoth? Yeah. Do we have a contract with that? And is that why it's in contract, income, other?
56:11 And if no contract, then I feel like it's fundraising. I know. I've thought about that before. Historically, we always put it there initially. We can always move it. Yeah, I mean, it's a donation, so it probably should go on fundraising. Okay, we can move it. That's my thought. So, you know, I guess in sort of view of our discussions here, in summary, from my perspective is that we're talking about reducing the pre-development expense, sort of a miscategorization, but...
56:53 However we decide to define that, but it's sort of the business development that doesn't manifest into a capital project that, you know, should be nominal cost there. So maybe if that gets reduced to a $10,000 expense line item, you know, that would already take 40 out and close the gap there on the bottom line. And just looking at some of the other
57:23 Categories of expense in terms of the prior budgets and the actuals, albeit the actuals don't have the remaining budget for the remaining months of the fiscal year, but there's probably a few bucks there that we're going to save. And then, like I said, I think the reimbursement of the
57:51 Some of those sunk or pre-development costs on access as well as the potential savings on the contingency funds on that project in particular and how much revenue that can generate. I mean, it seems like we're going to get a lot more revenue coming in than what we've recognized here. You know, I think we're pretty close. But I kind of do...
58:18 I agree with Jennifer that given some of our feedback, if, you know, we can give you guys another till next board meeting to maybe go through and make some of these corrections, adjustments, updates, and then bring back a kind of a final budget for us to adopt in the July board meeting would make sense to me. I don't know that we, do we have any like obligation or risk to have this approved prior to the start of the fiscal year? I believe the budget policy says that the budget will be approved by June 30th.
58:46 Last year, we approved it and brought it back with modifications. With modifications? In July. Okay. Got it. That's my recollection on the policy. Yeah. Yeah. But, yeah, maybe I can confer with the President before bringing it back, but, yeah, I'm interested to have more of a conversation around the pre-development expenses line item.
59:16 I almost think it's a maybe it's a policy discussion just because I think we have in the past taken some of that capacity and spent operating revenue from that. The line item expense number represents approximately the other revenue that we generate not related to service contracts with our government partners.
59:46 And I think we could capitalize it maybe semi-annually or quarterly. But I think that there's cases in which maybe our projects might not be able to pay that amount back. And then it's a sunk cost or money out that we don't realize. Well, I understand. Yeah, it's really to say, to me, it's kind of an accounting question and then a risk question. Yeah, exactly. So, yeah, I don't know quite. I mean, there's obviously many different scenarios where that could play out.
1:00:16 Well, and I think the one we've seen it play out most recently and we're trying and our lovely intern is going to help us get on track with is access. That's one that we did it all out of our operating budget. Yeah. Although we had a line item, we actually did set aside a bucket, but it all flowed through MLH. Yeah. And I think it's sort of like we're in between.
1:00:46 Small and big, and just how we want to manage that, I think is, I think it's kind of an important question. Well, I mean, I would be comfortable with, I'm sorry, go ahead. Which is why the amount sort of matches our other revenue sources to reflect that we're doing other work so that we can fund other endeavors. Right, right. And, you know, obviously the things such as, you know, the
1:01:21 Mono County Housing, Alpine County Housing, Navigator Service, you know, revenues and so forth. We obviously aren't going to hire the position until we know the funds are committed, right? Correct. And so forth. So, you know, we can kind of sort of regulate in that respect. We still have that recruiting effort to go through, right? Yes. To find those positions. Being that it's already almost the start of our fiscal year, I mean, you know, that may drag out for several months before we find people to fill those positions or possibly even longer.
1:01:51 I didn't see on here, and historically we've had funds for deed restriction retention. We moved that, I believe, to the Sierra Housing Advocates LLC. Okay. It's another interesting question. I'm not exactly sure how we want to handle it, but we moved it from operations to a program expense.
1:02:19 If we are going to fund that on an annual basis, we should probably show it in operations, but we didn't. So let me know what you think about that. Well, it is a capital investment into the property, by and large. I guess some, like, administrative costs, like if you had to pay a real estate agent, that would be included in deed restriction retention. If a buyer came, I don't even know if that happens anymore.
1:03:04 Yeah, I believe so, because all of the costs of sales would fall under that line item. Right, and I have had this conversation with Chris briefly about how Sierra Housing Advocates operates as our holding entity, mostly for home ownership, deed restricted buybacks, but it doesn't actually have any regular revenue. Right.
1:03:33 Except for Birch Creek, rent now comes into there, but that also comes with expenses. We did move it over there because maybe if we're going to look at it as a capital expense, then maybe it's okay to put it back under ESCH, but I was looking at it as a specific programmatic expense, and so I moved it over. But it is a town program. It is a town program, and so I guess you could say currently it's unfunded.
1:04:02 In this proposal. Because otherwise we would show it as an expense. Is it part of our contract with the town? Yes. So I'm not sure what the solution is. Well then it seems to me like it should be probably either on this budget or a portion of the town's contract revenue needs to go over to Shaw to pay for the program. I don't know. That's just my...
1:04:47 Off the top of the head. Yeah, so I'll add that to the things to make sure we add in when I meet with Chris again. Are there any other questions from the board in regards to the draft budget? We're still going through it, right? Do you have more highlights, Patricia? On this, no, unless you want to talk about any of the LLCs. I guess my question with the LLCs, like all of those books, pencil or I mean, how do we?
1:05:24 Are some of those in the red? I feel like this is not the complete picture of everything, right? Because there are separate LLCs in here? Yeah, right? I saw LLCs in there. Yeah, Sierra housing advocates. Yeah, I saw all the properties in there. I have a question on the... But they have negative income as well.
1:05:52 So one thing we didn't provide is that we do have a consolidated picture of the portfolio all wrapped into one, and we could bring that back. We didn't bring it this time because we haven't seen that before, and we wanted to make sure that at least the operational budget got approved. For me, I think it would be helpful to, like, you know, the operational budget is something separate, but then to get an idea of, like, the health.
1:06:23 The budget overall organization. Yeah, I mean, because when I look at this and it's like, you know, this one is negative 55,710. Which one? Can you say which one? I'm sorry, Sierra Housing Advocates. And then the Innsbruck Lodge affordable housing is negative 73,530. Yeah, and I think that, you know, part of the Sierra Housing Advocates is that it got the deed restriction retention for one added there.
1:06:53 That's $20,000, and that should probably have $20,000 moved into it from the contract from the town, which helps offset the deficit there. And I don't see any rent revenue on Sierra Housing Advocates, and you did mention that Birch Creek has revenue. It's under other income. Oh, I see it down there. Thanks. I was looking up at the top. I agree it would be helpful to see these.
1:07:38 Stacked up as, you know, individual entities with kind of the consolidated view maybe at the right-hand side of a spreadsheet. You've got the Innsbruck, the Access, Sierra, and then you've got Eastern Sierra consolidated. And some of these, for instance, like Innsbruck, like the rental revenue, that's the primary revenue.
1:08:08 I mean, that is a housing entity, so that revenue should be up top. I don't know what the grant revenue is, but I think some of these can maybe be reoriented a little bit. This is just purely presentation, not substance. But I think it'd just be a little easier to read and interpret in this way. I think another question along those lines is, would you book rental revenue from
1:08:37 Like a grant source like ESG under rental revenue or under a separate revenue line item? I guess if it's paying rent, it would be under rental revenue. That's what we would do. I think something like that. If it's an independent subsidy source, I think you would ordinarily treat that as separate from a tenant paid rental revenue. Okay. Then that's something we can add.
1:09:08 Ryan, quick question for you in terms of just like how you would prefer to see it organized wise. I take your point about like, hey, Innsbruck and Access, their operation is rental income, so that's why it should be up top. The kind of question that we went through is, okay, then you have Mammoth and Sierra where rental income is on the bottom and then you have...
1:09:33 I guess I would probably put all
1:10:02 Recurring revenue above the NOI line. I'm not sure what the benefit is of treating it below that line so you have all your core operating revenues and maybe you've got different roads, rental income, subsidy income, maybe there's grant income, etc. And that way, not every entity is going to have every revenue type.
1:10:22 But that way, unless it's truly extraordinary, if it's extraordinary one time, I can see maybe that's why you might move something below the NOI line. But if it's recurring, and it's a core part of that business, I would put it above that NOI. Agreed. I agree with that as well. Yeah. That's how I'm used to seeing it. Mm-hmm.
1:10:44 Yeah, okay, I guess the question that we were going back and forth on is something like Birch Creek Core to Sierra Housing Advocates, but I take your point. Well, and I think more specifically, or a better example, is the Star Apartments, which is located in Eastern Sierra Community Housing, and is a separate asset that we manage with a separate operating budget.
1:11:07 For repairs and insurance and things like that. Yeah, and I think that's where it's, like Brian was saying, it's a special situation. Okay, so we'll keep that one under. That's a special situation versus these other ones, this is all they do. Okay, that's what I got. That's how I interpret that. Okay. I mean, that makes sense to me. I just wanted to confirm that. So do we want to look at the individual entity pages here? Yeah, we can.
1:11:50 Do we want to, well, I could talk about Sierra Housing Advocates owns the Birch Creek Transitional Housing Unit in June Lake. It doesn't generate regular revenue, although if we move $20,000 there for deed restriction stewardship, that would be annual amount allocated for revenue, and then it pays a portion of accounting and audit. And it has rent.
1:12:22 Yes, and it has rental income from Birch Creek Condo when it's occupied. We guesstimated a 5% vacancy rate, which is higher than, I would say, our other permanent affordable housing projects, but because it's transitional, we don't know how many households will be moving in and out over the year. There could be periods of time where it needs cleaning or, you know, it's vacant for a month or so.
1:12:51 We added it at 5%, and then you'll see the expenses and the net income at the bottom, which I think under expenses we should see, is there a repair line item? There is. Miscellaneous. Yes, so, well yeah, so this isn't on here either, but we are planning to have the windows replaced.
1:13:24 And maybe that's it. But that funding has already been received by the entity. So Mono County subsidized the repairs for that property when we acquired it. There was $30,000 invested into Sierra Housing Advocates as a one-time allocation for
1:13:57 Repairs and Capital Improvements at Birch Creek Condo. So those expenses are listed here on this operating budget, but have already been paid for, and we report to Mono County on what those improvements have been. So it's basically similar to a reserve fund as you would for a HOA or something, right? Yes. I don't know how you show that. It didn't really reflect in the annual budget. Yeah, I guess that would be. It's more on a balance sheet. Yeah, exactly.
1:14:26 Money in a reserve fund. Yeah. Then... Okay. Should there be a positive side to that then? Well, it was recognized in a prior fiscal year, so I'm not sure. Okay. Which is, it happens. That happens all the time. And I'll leave that to you and Chris to figure out. But the property tax seems high to me. Do we not take a BOE exemption? Or am I confused? Oh, yeah, that does look...
1:14:54 I saw that across the line on our properties, and I didn't know if we were doing BOE exemptions. Yes, we are. Because they all have, even Innsbruck has a 5,200, and it just seemed like that was high if you had a BOE exemption. Yeah, that needs to be changed. Okay. What's a BOE? Board of Equalization, if you're serving people that are low income, you're exempt from property tax.
1:15:21 You have to file with the state and work with the assessor's office to get it approved. Oh yeah, I see it. I will note that both of those were actuals from what we did in QuickBooks last year, so I don't know if we missed last year doing that or not, but those were, that's what we paid, those actuals that we paid last year.
1:15:46 Yeah, I think we're still responsible for any voter indebtedness or direct assessments, you know, whether they're school district assessments or sewer district assessments or what have you. It's just the ad valorem property tax that we're exempt from. So I guess you'd have to kind of go back and look at those property tax bills and just tease out, you know, all the direct assessments and confirm what those are.
1:16:09 Yeah, I can't imagine that there's much in Mono County. The town tends to have more school and hospital bonds and such, but in Mono County, I don't think we have anything other than basic, so I'm not sure. I'll go back and check. That's where Innsbruck is. It's in June. Or, Birch Creek. Birch Creek, yeah. Well, do we want to go through each one? I feel like we've gotten some really good feedback.
1:16:49 Yeah. Well, again, with Sierra Housing Advocates, it, you know, maybe the allocation of the accounting expense is disproportionately high for what it is. Mm-hmm. I was thinking that, too. Would you want to do some kind of pro rata based on your budget? I don't know how you guys came up with the 25 per LLC if you just did a, I'm not sure. Yeah. We just split it up. A quarter each. Yeah. Is that typical?
1:17:19 I mean, theoretically, if we wanted to, we could go ahead and say, well, Sierra's books are simpler, and we're probably using 20 or 15% of accounting time. If you really wanted to, base it off of time spent on each individual LLC and sort of move it around a little bit here and there. Just looking at Innsbruck, it also has a $25,000 charge, and typically we're managing it, and so
1:17:59 What would be typical in a housing partnership like this is that the partnership bears the cost of its own audit. I don't know if Innsbruck requires an independent audit. And to the extent we're looking to charge any bookkeeping fees or accounting fees, that would have to be part of the property management agreement between Eastern Sierra and the LLC. So that might be something to go back and look at to confirm that.
1:18:25 The agreement provides for this type of a charge on top of whatever the direct audit expense is for that particular entity. We'll take a look at that. And then on Innsbruck, a couple questions on other expenses. Construction in progress. Again, that's a capital cost and it's not an operating expense. Yes, correct. So I don't know.
1:19:10 If that would, why that would be in there. And are the utilities based on actuals or is that a guesstimate? It seems really high. It's a guesstimate. It seems really high. I know I've seen some of the bills for the, we got electricity and I would just say we should bounce that off what we've seen in the last couple months of utility bills between Amerigas and SCE in particular. And just make sure, get a reality check on that.
1:19:40 Seems high to me. I think Water District as well, right? We got Water District, Amerigas, and SCE. And internet. And internet, yeah. So I mean, right there, that could close the gap on the negative on the... Well, I think just taking out the construction process does progress does that, actually. Almost gets you there. Yeah. And I think the facilities could probably narrow quite a bit. But I don't mind being a little conservative on that, honestly, given we've never operated it.
1:20:12 This would be our first time being full through the winter. I don't know, it makes me a little nervous to skimp on that one. Yeah, we don't really know what snow removal will be like. Yeah, totally. Trucking. That's where you got snow removal as part of utilities. Yeah, so I'm kind of okay with that number, honestly. But take a look. I mean, if you feel like it's too padded. Okay. Yeah, you might be right. Stop.
1:20:41 Yeah, we'll do a sanity check, but that is one of the areas where I went into QuickBooks, looked at the historical trend line. You're right, it is a couple of different lines kind of collapsed into one utility's area and then took the seasonality based on when we historically have high bills and stuff like that, but we'll do a sanity check on that. That's not a problem. Okay. I guess, yeah, we can take another look at the accounting fees as well, but...
1:21:14 I think the management fees are on the lower side, maybe. And really, we're using that revenue from ESCH to pay for the property manager. If there's a different way we want to structure that, right now, that just seemed the easiest. So professional fees, like the accounting fees, have just been allocated equally across the LLCs. But we'll look at it again.
1:21:45 So in terms of our property management party individual, Jose, right? Yes. Yeah, at Innsbruck. We're planning to recruit him to also help with property management access once it's occupied, correct? Yes. So how are we handling that split, so to speak?
1:22:12 So the way I have it set up is just that we're collecting property management fees from Innsbruck and Access as revenue at ESCH, and then his time is just booked under salaries, and so it just comes out of the operating budget. Okay. We initially had it set out as a percentage of his time, and it was being billed back and forth to each entity, but I think if we're collecting the management fee that it should help pay for his time. Right.
1:22:42 That makes sense. So that made sense to me and it seemed easier. Right, okay. Okay, so you've got to account for it in that respect. And accounting for him at approximately 15 hours a week. And he's helping us with Birch Creek, Star Apartments, Innsbruck Lodge, and also any repairs for deed restriction retention as well. So I've averaged him out at 15 hours a week, but sometimes it's more.
1:23:16 And then on the other income for garage rent on access, garage rent at $10,000. We have five garages? Yes. So I was $2,000 a year per garage. $166 a month per garage. Does that sound like the right rate? I think it's supposed to be $200. So that might be $12,000 in total. Okay, we'll look at it. $200 a month for $10?
1:23:58 Per garage, five garages. Thousand, thousand a month. Per garage, there's five garages. Okay, I thought I heard 10 somewhere. Yeah, 201. But I could see how you know you're not going to get the first two months. Oh, maybe that's what it is. Yeah, I mean, to me, you've just calculated in a vacancy there. There you go, that makes some sense. Look at attention to detail. And then also highlighting the utilities line item being quite low.
1:24:35 In relative terms to Innsbruck on access? But they pay their own. They will pay all their own utilities. Okay, that's... There will be two public meters that we will pay for common area. Okay, great. Thank you for clarifying that. So is that snow removal fees also in utilities? Good question.
1:24:52 Yeah, snow removal might be in addition to... It's probably in there because those house utilities are probably very low because they're all Title 24, highly energy efficient. It's really low. So it's probably mostly snow removal, I'm guessing. We might, if you guys could add, if it's utility slash snow removal just to indicate, because snow removal could be significant depending on the year. It'd be nice to, I almost think we'd ought to be a separate line item as an expense. Once you did a separate line?
1:25:21 If you add snow removal for Innsbruck and Access as a separate line item for expense. That might account for the big number at Innsbruck, the big utility number. Yes. That's what we said, yeah. Yeah. I think it would be good to track it separate, honestly, because it can fluctuate so much, and it'd be great to know year to year what the utilities are without having to go back and decipher what snow removal costs were. Good.
1:25:52 Or does the property manager do the snow removal at Innsbruck? He does some. Some, but there's still a loader. The parking lot's still done with a loader. Okay, so we got in a lot better shape on Innsbruck with taking the construction and progress out. Yep. We're about a little bit ahead on access, so. I think this is, I feel like we've been very productive. Yes, thank you. So, are there any...
1:26:35 Further questions from the board on any of the budgets, Amanda? You're good. I guess I just, like, my ultimate question is what's paying for all of this stuff in the red? Like, what, how do we balance our bucks? Like, what, I don't know. That's just what makes me nervous is seeing that they're all... Well, I think we just found a bunch of stuff that's gonna... Okay, so you think it'll all be balanced next month when we come back? I do. Okay. By and large. I look forward to it. Yeah. Right.
1:27:06 I do. So, in terms of action here, you were saying that we were going to... What about just approving it with the modifications discussed with the July 7th board meeting revision and adoption agendized?
1:27:40 Yeah. Would that be not approving? I mean, wouldn't that be like waiting until next month to approve it? No, we're approving it. The motion is to approve it and bring it back. With the incorporation of the changes discussed. And bring back the changes to the July 7th board meeting. Yeah, yeah, July 7th. So we have a motion. Do I hear a second? I'll second. Any further discussion?
1:28:20 You know, again, budgets are budgets, right? And I think we'll strive to maybe update our budget or expenditures on a quarterly basis, Patricia. I think now that we've got charter ones, we get up to speed and we can get updates so that we can monitor progress on these as we move forward. And as we always like to say, adjust to reality as necessary.
1:28:45 You know, I do believe there's a lot of levers to pull here within these different cost categories and some of the other revenue areas where hopefully we can pick up some ground. So, you know, I think we're going to get pretty close here when it's all said and done for sure. With that, we'll take roll call, please, Angie. Any public comment? Oh, I'm sorry. Any public comment? No comments at this time. Okay. Roll call, please, Angie. President Hodges? Yes. Vice President Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Stapp? Yes.
1:29:17 Board Member Kreitz? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. And Board Member Rice? No. Thank you. Okay. With that, we will move on to Agenda Item 4.2. The Board will receive an introduction to Leslie Carrillo. Great. Thank you. From the California Coalition of Rural Housing as our intern. Intern. Yes.
1:29:49 We applied for and were accepted, again, to host a CCRH development intern. We had two applications. It was very competitive. And I'd like to introduce you to Leslie Carrillo. Today's her first day. Oh, wow. Welcome. She is going to be a senior at the University of Nevada in Reno this year.
1:30:18 Majoring in Finance. Awesome. She's a local Mammoth Lakes resident. And what else can I say? We're excited to get started. We have a lot of projects. We will be working together on the Valley Apartments project, as well as some pre-development invoice collecting for access apartments.
1:30:48 I don't know, I sent her a big list today, so we will just keep plugging along. And she'll be full-time over the summer if you want to stop by and say hello. And then during the school year, we'll work out a modified schedule. Terrific. Well, welcome. Yeah, welcome. Great to have you here. What an asset you're going to be for us. Thank you. I hope you get a lot out of it. You definitely will get exposed to a lot, that's for sure. Well, good for you. Congratulations. Thank you.
1:31:21 All right, terrific. Actually, I do have one question, Leslie. Just for our future recruiting of interns, and maybe you already know this, Patricia, but how did you hear about this program? I saw it at the Mammoth County Flyer, the ad that they posted, and that's how I applied. Okay, great, thank you. Are you bilingual? Yes. Awesome. And a Mammoth High School graduate? Yes. Terrific. All right, great to see. Okay, any other comments, questions for the board? Good.
1:31:56 Okay, we'll move on to agenda item 4.3. The board will receive an update on current housing development projects. Patricia. Oh, just give me one second to share my screen. You bet. Okay, this is our monthly update on our housing projects development pipeline. These are projects that we currently have in the queue. For Innsbruck Lodge, we received our final certificate of occupancy in April.
1:33:21 As you'll hear from Jarrett, that project is fully occupied except for one unit, so we're working to fill that final unit. That's because there's been some turnover and some successful client stories, so there's a unit available for the next person. Access Apartments, you'll see we're on track to complete construction in July.
1:33:50 Valley Apartments will be our next project that we will be working on with our intern, Leslie. We have the Silver Peace Project and then we have a number of new opportunities for our next project and I'm hoping to share those with the board at some point soon. Okay, here's Innsbruck Lodge. It's one of our shorter
1:34:27 Projects. We acquired the property in 2022, so that's only three years ago, and it's 70% funded through state funds, state home key grant funding. Those of you who were able to attend our grand opening were able to see the new apartments. It's 15 apartments. They all have a kitchenette, and the majority have direct access to the outside.
1:35:04 Patio. There's a couple of things still happening on site. The trash enclosure is being constructed. I'm still working to get the fireplace upgraded. And then there will be some additional repairs to the flat roof where the old electrical switch gear was located. So the team still needs to take down that old electrical switch gear and then repair some of that roof. We'd like to put a small pitch on it at least to maybe help with
1:35:43 The snow load. Was that the $66,000 we saw in the operating budget? Yes. Okay. For access apartments, we have, this is our longer project. We will be delivering 13 apartments. There will be studios and one-bedroom apartments. And households will, are required to earn below 80% of the AMI and 120% of the AMI.
1:36:24 I wanted to add in this slide about affordability and the proposed rents. These are the rents that were used in the proposed budget to calculate the anticipated revenue. Here you can see the income level requirement for each AMI. And so an 80% AMI household of one person will need to
1:36:55 Earn less than $57,200 gross for their one-person household, and then 30% of that on a monthly basis is $1,430. And so I did some market research to see what market rate rents were and determined that the market rate rents for a studio are around $1,500 and for a one bedroom is $2,100.
1:37:31 Those are for the units that you can find that are available. There's not that many. Do you think that's the time of year that you're looking to that just seemed high to me for the market? I just kind of had a question of how you came up with the market rate rent, but it just seemed high to me. I use the listings on Blizzard just, you know, while we were working on this budget, so just last month.
1:38:02 Okay. Thanks. And then I compared those to what I could find on Zillow. I think the ones on Zillow aren't as reliable. But I did try to make sure I used a broad range. Okay. And we looked, are there like any Facebook groups that people put, I mean, I just feel like the problem is we have like 1% vacancy rates. Yeah, zero. Yeah. So like basically somebody puts something on and the next day they find a tenant and it comes off.
1:38:32 You know, it's like, I don't know, the properties that sit on Blizzard are maybe higher than what people are paying, or like, would it be beneficial to talk to people and see what they're paying, or are we all comfortable with those prices? Well, I guess, as your question, is the market rate too high for people to afford? Possibly, but I think as long as we're below what market rate is charging, then we're within the range.
1:39:01 As long as it's still affordable to the income level. I think that would be the... I mean, I think those rents look for market seem appropriate because it's not renting a one bedroom in a house. It's renting a one bedroom unit. And I don't know if that's what you're basing it off of or if you're thinking about what it would cost to rent a room in a home.
1:39:34 I'm not thinking of what it would cost to rent a room in a home. I'm thinking of, I have a two-bedroom unit and I know what I charge. Yeah, and I do too, and I know what I charge. This was on par. Okay, well it seemed, I don't know, I just was wondering how we came up with the market rate prices. But the garage is an addition, right? Yes. This doesn't include the garage because there's only five. Yeah. And so... Yeah, I don't know, it seems...
1:40:06 Spot on to me for new development, especially. Is there like a price per square foot that Blizzard gives, or are we just going up with one bedrooms? No, I just estimated it based on this one bedroom that happened to say how big it was. And knowing that, you know, it's like a 1960s condo, one bedroom, 420 square feet. I know not all the boards walked the units, and so I'll...
1:40:37 Hope to schedule that soon. But the unit, the 700 square foot, one bedroom with high ceilings and lots of natural light for $2,000 seemed within range. Especially if at the income levels provided by the state, that number is still considered affordable. Yeah, so in that little blurb above the $120 AMI affordable rent, those numbers are dictated by the state.
1:41:10 That's correct. Yeah, okay. And access, does it have any market rate units or it's only the 80% and the 120? Only 80 and 120. That's just for comparison, okay. Yeah, that's just to make sure, you know, that we're in range and being reasonable. And this isn't written in stone. I can, you know, I can go back and do some more analysis just to make sure.
1:41:40 So if you have suggestions, please let me know, and I can definitely write that. I know for my unit, I was getting 2,800 for 800 square feet, so. I've got to raise my rent. Yeah. Yeah. Perhaps. Maybe so. Perhaps. You know, that's how it is. But mine is newer construction and modified. Mine's pretty damn nice. I guess my only, just, I mean, I don't want to make you do more work, but I guess.
1:42:11 My concern is what happens if we don't find anyone in the 120% AMI that will pay that and it's all 80% AMI. How would that affect our annual budget for that, for the access apartments? Is it the LLC? I don't know. But that's my main concern. And so, I mean, I guess the market will dictate if people will pay that or not. But how would that affect if all of the units were at 80%, how would that affect us?
1:42:39 I didn't run that analysis, but I certainly could. I think that would be quicker than doing more market research. Well, it's up to 120%, am I right? So, I mean, we could potentially have some people at 100 or whatever, right? I mean, depending, like you said, depending on market demand. Right. But given the vacancy rate in town is effectively... Zero. Zero, right? Negative five. Yeah, and we don't have any rental units above 80.
1:43:08 The parcel's all 80 and below, and there's not that many 80s. Right, right. And I bet those were the first to get released. Yeah. So, I'm... I feel pretty good about the numbers myself and what I know about the marketplace, but it'll be interesting to test the market. Yeah. I mean, I have walked the units, so... But further along now than what I like, I've walked them six weeks ago or so. They're very nice, one-bedroom units than the $1 billion.
1:43:39 Like I said, extra high ceiling, some of them have amazing views. They're pretty cool. So I feel like they would go pretty readily, honestly. But I think we tackle that when we get to it. But I think from a target perspective, if you're at these numbers for the 120 to 60 units at 2000, and if you're running those numbers and those are matching up with our pro forma budgets that we had.
1:44:09 Based art, everything on it. I feel pretty comfortable about it. Are the... Go ahead, Brian. Go ahead, Brian. Go ahead, you can go first. Okay, are the studio units big enough for two people, or is it anticipated it would be one person in them? It's ideal for one person, I would say. Originally, it was proposed to be all one bedroom, so if you think about it, it's two units, yeah, squeezed into one original, would have been one apartment. Okay, thank you.
1:44:43 Yeah, they're small. I was just going to ask, Patricia, as part of any of the AT applications, I'm not suggesting you go out and do this, but did you have a market study prepared? Yes. It's probably from 2019, but I could certainly go back and see if we had one done for the, see if we had an updated one before the CDBG award. Yeah, it might just be a useful data point, even though it's a little stale.
1:45:20 That's a great point. Okay. So I should continue. Let's see. Those are delicious, by the way. Great job. Yeah. I'm trying not to have another one, but I really want to. So on the budget, we have spent approximately 65 of the total development cost, and that seems on the lower side because we haven't.
1:45:47 been reimbursed for the pre-development expenses. So once Leslie and I get our head wrapped around what that number is, we can submit that for reimbursement. And this number will go up, ideally, before the end of the month. We have spent some contingency. And the number is approximately $130,000 of $700. So there is some leeway in the budget there. And then we have processed
1:46:14 The most recent payment to the general contractor, which is number 10. And that puts us at about 85% of the construction budget spent. So we're really close. And we've had some issues getting the electrical set up through Southern California Edison. So we have the equipment. There was a piece that was damaged that we reordered, but it's not delayed.
1:46:42 But just setting up the account and all the meters and dealing with the bureaucracy and who's doing what is challenging. So we're projected to be complete mid-July at this point. Patricia, if I may, you said the number 10 payment, it brings us to 85%? Of the construction budget only. Okay. And what's the 65% then is of the total development? Okay. Thank you.
1:47:12 And then I recall that their contract with Menincia goes through June. Like, they're contracted to finish and everything. We're not going over on time or anything for that, right? Yeah, I think we were up to, like, September, October, if I remember right. September, October. I guess I just remember, like, one of the last ones, it was going to be done by June, and the contract was up in June. No.
1:47:39 I think because we were I think we contemplated potentially being shut down for winter conditions, and they actually were able to work through winter. I just remember asking about that specific question, and it was yes, we're not contracted past June with them. I don't remember that. Yeah, and I'm not sure actually, so let me double check that. Because I thought we weren't going to be done with construction until September or October.
1:48:03 Can you check on that? I just remember recently asking that question, and the answer was that the contract is up in June. In our last weekly meeting, when the team said we're out to July, Mnemsha didn't bring anything up about the contract being expiring. So let me double check. Here's some photos of all the concrete dug up.
1:48:44 For the electric and the gas. Is it this week? They'll be connecting the water meters, and so they'll be directing some traffic down Sierra Manor Road so that they can connect to the main line under the street. I believe that's happening this week. Here's just some interior photos, and I wanted to share these photos even though they're not that interesting. The one on the right is really big.
1:49:25 Closet. The one in the middle is laundry hookups. So all of the units in the big building will have in-unit laundry. That's great. And then the picture on the left is just of the bathroom, which is a large bathroom. Let's see. So we recently, you know, just recent past, we had all the windows installed and the sliding glass doors. You saw the drywall and the cabinets have all been installed.
1:50:01 We're anticipating Certificate of Occupancy in July now. Well, what's not on here, oh yeah, the appliances should be coming and then also the water connection, I guess that's under utilities. And then I am thinking about planning the grand opening. That's another project we'll be working on so that we can make sure to give all of our partners adequate time so that they can put that into their schedules. Probably be in August.
1:50:35 Before you leave that, if you wouldn't mind on the leasing. And so we intend to advertise the availability of the units via newsprint and radio or something like that? Yes, I was going to put an ad in the newspaper and on our social media, but we could also do the radio. Okay. And then
1:51:03 Assuming we get more applicants than space available, would we say that we would accept applications up to a certain point and then hold a lottery if we have more applicants than space available? Historically, or how we traditionally have done it, is that those who submit a complete application first and qualify would get the first unit.
1:51:32 And we would process them in the order that they are received. But if a lottery seems like something we should explore, we could do that. We haven't before. I certainly open this to discussion with my fellow board members in terms of, I would prefer maybe that we, just in the sense of fairness, that we say, hey, we'll accept applications through, I mean, here it is, June 2nd, right?
1:52:04 You know, July 30th, maybe, 31st, and then if there's more applicants than space available, then we would hold a lottery for those that are adequately qualified, you know, income qualified and acceptable, as opposed to just saying, hey, first person running who can run the fastest gets the, I don't know, to me that doesn't seem fair. Is that from a pre-existing list or just starting a new list?
1:52:36 Because I feel like if it's a pre-existing list that we're going off of, and that's what we've done historically. Well, I don't think, well, maybe in the 80, I don't know, well, we don't, I don't know, do we have a list? Is there a rental wait list? Yes, we have our rental waiting list, and we have included folks who are 80% and sometimes above on that list, with the understanding that their income could change at any time.
1:53:02 But we could just let them all know they need to update their information if they want to be considered for one of the units, I suppose. I mean, I guess since it's a new product in the 80 to 120 percent range that we probably don't have an extensive list of interested people. So maybe a lottery would be the most fair way to do it rather than just whoever's in the office first gets it. I agree with you, Tom.
1:53:26 Yeah, but it would be nice with the waitlist people who've been there for a while. To be contacted without signing up for this. Yeah, and to update, you know, hopefully people are increasing. I would suggest consulting with our attorneys at Goldfarb. I think there are potential, you know, I think I would agree with Tom and others that I think a lottery seems fairest. We could also look at what was done over at the parcel.
1:53:54 And I imagine other of our transaction partners may have a similar expectation as to how these very few units get fairly allocated. I think the last thing we want is claims that someone had an unfair advantage or better information than someone else. So I think it would be worth our while to consult with Goldfarb on how to set this up.
1:54:24 You know, in a fair and transparent way. And your question about the parcel, I know that there was an interest list that was started like when construction started for the parcel. And so they started with number one on that list. And I think the list was over 400 or 500 people. And they just started with number one and then, you know, sent the first batch of correspondence out and then income qualified people. And then when people had moved on or didn't qualify, then they sent.
1:54:54 You know, they kept going down the list. But I think that I don't, I don't know that that was, that that's what will be repeated in the future. Looks like Nolan has his hand raised. Yes, hello everyone, can you hear me? Yeah. Yeah. Yes, on the parcel phase one, we did an interest list and it was first come, first serve as far as reaching out. Because they started the list so early, many of those that were in that initial batch had,
1:55:34 Either found other living accommodations or their rent or income had increased, et cetera. So it wasn't the smoothest process. And I know for phase two of the parcel, the tentative plan is to go with a lottery where we'll have an initial application period with a set date. And then at the end of that, those names would then be entered into a lottery. Okay, that's great. Nolan, thank you for the input on that.
1:56:09 So I think Brian's pretty sage advice as well, as always, that we should consult with Raphael and the team there and just do a check with them and maybe we can solidify the lease-up plan at our next board meeting with specifics that I think would be a good objective because I think we'll be likely into
1:56:40 Well into July before we get to final CFO and be ready to lease. So we'd assume it'll be, if things go well, maybe by August 1st, we'd be in a position to start placing tenants. But if we could kind of pin that down by an export meeting, it'd be great. That sounds great. Our next project is about the Valley Apartments. And I don't have much to update the board on this project now that Leslie's on the team.
1:57:19 We will start conversations with the architecture firm to get that contract to the board for approval to start architecture and engineering. And then also Leslie and I will be working on reaching out to the state more regularly regarding the standard agreement to make sure that their team is on our team and so that we can get those important
1:57:53 pieces moving regarding the grant funding. And so those are the two big next steps for us. I guess in terms of the timeline, our purchase option does expire this December. So as you can see, I'm hoping we can get the architecture team on board and the contract approved by this board as well as the standard agreement with the state finished before then.
1:58:28 So we could start construction at some point in the spring or the summer. And that's all I have on projects to date. In regards to Valley, I think in terms of the time schedule there or the steps, I think it would be worthwhile once we get the standard agreement. We know we got the award letter, but we have more certainty on time frames and so forth.
1:59:01 I think it would be worthwhile to make a presentation to the Bishop City Council, just as a little bit of self-promotion, I think, in some respects, public relations, just to show them that we're doing stuff, right? Significant, that we got a significant grant award to improve product in their community. We're not asking, we haven't asked for their help, but we certainly would welcome it. You know, just because they seem like they're so much further behind compared to the Mammoth Lakes.
1:59:31 Town Council in terms of addressing affordable housing in general and or denying or whatever. I don't know. They just don't have funding sources for it and so forth. But I think it's important to inform them of what we're doing in their community, how much money is being awarded and how much money is going to go into upgrading this property for long-term sustainability.
2:00:00 And just, again, I think, you know, in the lines of building relationships and so forth, it would be an important thing to do and certainly would be happy to join you in that endeavor. But, yeah, maybe in the next several months when at the appropriate time we could think about doing that, I think it would be a good idea. And with respect to the architecture contract on that, you know, again, that's maybe one of those things where we're talking about fronting some cash flow on that if we're going to, you know, try and get started before we actually get.
2:00:29 Initial grant funding, but I think to a certain point we can expend some money to get to the schematic design maybe and then having the certainty of the timing of the funding from the state so again that we can capitalize those costs and it'll come out of that LLC budget for that entity and not jeopardize our overall cash flow position on Eastern Sierra Community Housing.
2:01:00 Just be mindful of that, but I think we can flex with the cash flow a little bit and make it work. Yeah, that's a great point. To that extent, architecture fees were not included in our operational budget, but if we wanted to allocate reserves to that, then we should just make sure we track that liability investment so that the reserve gets paid back eventually. Yeah, yeah, exactly. Not too far down the road. Yeah.
2:01:33 Okay. Any further questions or comments regarding the development project updates? Okay. With that, then we'll be moving on to item 4.4, policy matters. The board will receive the 2024 annual report, which I think is on our dais here in front of us. I don't have a lot of things to say about this other than I'm glad it's done.
2:02:06 It is a nice little recap of some of the work that we did last year. We have never mailed these to our supporters in the past, but the plan, these were actually supposed to come folded and ready to mail, so we got a credit for that. But we'll be folding them and putting them in the mail to all of our partners so that we don't just have to rely on personal connection, but that we can get them out to everybody.
2:02:39 How many are you mailing, folding and mailing, do you think? I can't remember if we ordered 200 or 250, so probably somewhere around 200. Is it just a fold tape label, sticker label? Yes. I can help you with that. Okay. Thank you. There's some great stuff in here. Very nice. Yeah, it's really well put together. Thank you, as usual. I guess one question.
2:03:16 I have is that I normally produce it based on the calendar year, but we operate on a fiscal year. I don't know if the board has a preference. Yeah, I know. I mean, I think most people in the public think about calendar years as opposed to fiscal years. Okay, good. That brings it up, too, from the annual kind of budgeting and audit process. It stages it at a different time of the year for you, ideally, right? Yeah, that's a great point.
2:03:54 All right. Terrific. Any further discussion? Yep. Okay. We'll move on to policy item 4.5. The board will receive an update on other programs. Patricia? Yes. I have a few notes, and then I think Jared's still on the line. I'll give him a second to hop on. We did not have a chance to prepare a staff report.
2:04:22 For this item, it's been really busy with the lease up and just managing our tenants at various properties. But, well, I guess that's one of my updates. We're very busy with property and asset management, it says. So that's exciting. And this month, I will be working on the Willow Plaza annual home monitoring.
2:04:52 And the first time home buyer deed restriction stewardship process. I have some invoicing to do before the closeout of the fiscal year. We still have the Meridian Court unit revolving loan fund unit. And I'm not planning on opening escrow until the new fiscal year. We have a town contract committee.
2:05:28 The week, I think it's on June 19th, with the town of Mammoth Lakes. I suspect that will be really productive. And we're still sort of peripherally having a lot of conversations with the health plans around this CalAIM initiative, housing supports, and the funding that the health plans are required to invest in supports for housing to reduce
2:06:02 Health expenses. It's really complicated, but there are funds for housing navigation and rental assistance and housing deposits and things like that. It's convoluted to access, but we're trying to navigate our way through that. I've been invited to serve as a voting member on one of the advisory committees. It's just out there. I haven't responded, but
2:06:34 It doesn't seem like those conversations are going to go away, so I'm trying to participate as feasible. That's all I have, I think, but I'll turn it over to Jarrett. How you guys doing? I have a few program updates for y'all. So the first one is on Innsbruck Lodge. All but one unit at Innsbruck Lodge is currently occupied. We have 14 tenants in the residence, 12 are receiving rental subsidies, and two are paying grantful independently.
2:07:03 We continue to work closely with the county and the COC partners to secure rental assistance for our participants in the HHAP, CalWORKs, HDAP, HomeSafe, and Alpine probation programs. We have a new partnership that we're working kind of with Mono County Jail. We've recently started working with Mono County Jail to support individuals in need of housing upon their release. We've already had success at carrying rental assistance for one client at risk of losing housing while in custody. We hope to collaborate with Mono County Jail more frequently to help clients connect to those housing resources and assistance.
2:07:33 On the Food and Securities Grant, on May 28th, we submitted an application for the Food and Security Grant, 2025 through Anthem. This initiative aims to provide food, personal hygiene items, and cleaning supplies to individuals and families facing food insecurities in the Tri-County area. Our goal is to assist between 49 to 61 households. We expect to hear back on the award by June 30th if we got approved for it. That's all for my programs. Thank you. Any questions? I have a question.
2:08:04 Is there any update on the Joaquin units for the town? Yes. I'm working really closely with Nolan Bobroff at the town of Mammoth Lakes on the Joaquin project. The goal is to partner with them as the listing brokerage and connect clients to those units through a lottery.
2:08:31 We are, I think the APNs just recently were assigned, so we haven't moved forward with the listing agreements yet. But I believe that we will be compensated at the percentage that's listed in the current contract, which is 1.5% of the sales price. And we don't have any capacity to really launch that at this moment, I would say.
2:09:04 But I know that there's some construction still taking place on site. And so once those are finished, Nolan and I are working on setting up a web page so interested parties can submit some basic information so that we can vet them and get them into the lottery. So that's all happening. I know the town is still trying to figure out the sales price. We don't have that yet.
2:09:32 I think all the pieces are coming together. It's just taking some time. Okay. And do we have like an estimated for sale date or no? I don't because last I heard it wasn't clear when this construction component was going to be completed. Okay. Thank you. But fairly soon. Yes, I think it's a minor component that's left. So if people are asking, I would direct them to?
2:10:04 Eastern Sierra Community Housing Office for getting initial waitlisted and providing initial information? Yeah, I think we're waiting for this web page to be launched so that it will have a database attached to it so that everyone's information will just be in the database. But folks can come get a home ownership application for any of the programs at our office anytime that we're open, which is Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. And they're doing a lottery on those? Yes.
2:10:36 And that's why the database on the website is so critical. Yes, yeah, yeah. I know Nolan's with us. I don't know. Did he raise his hand? He maybe doesn't have anything to share. I mean, I can just chime in. So, yeah, we are finishing some minor construction updates on those, which has delayed the launch since we really want them to be move-in ready when we launch that marketing effort. And we do intend to go with the lottery on these, kind of as a...
2:11:10 A trial run to see how it's working. I've done a lot of research looking at how they all is conducting their lotteries, so we're modeling it off of what they've done with all of their deed restricted housing portfolios. A way we might try to transition in the future as we do more projects. And all that will be managed by the town? I'd like to do the town and working closely with Patricia at MLH, obviously, or ESCH, sorry.
2:11:42 Under contract as the sales brokerage on these. But does that include operating the lottery? The sales is different from operating the lottery. Yes, the town will be doing the lottery on them. Yeah, that's what I was asking more about. I understand the sales part of it. That's more straightforward, but yeah, but the town's managing the lottery. Correct. Great. So possibly there could be a website link both on?
2:12:11 The ESCH homepage and the town or something like that. Yeah, I know Nolan's working on a page and I have had a conversation with our web developer to add another page specifically for this project, but... Or a link to their page. Yeah, we'll link to whatever the database page is that we need to have active. Terrific. And remind me of the income levels again for homeownership? 150 to 200% for the walking.
2:12:44 Yeah. And do you have sales prices yet, Nolan? No. No, that's what we're trying to finalize. We're trying to figure out the exact final construction with all the different contingencies and variables into it so we can come up with that sales price. And do you know the HOAs? The last number I saw, I believe, was around $700 a month. So that'll then factor into the sales price to keep it affordable. Okay.
2:13:15 And that would include snow removal and trash? Snow removal, trash, water, and insurance. Which the insurance is hard to get. Yeah. I get that number. I don't have the budget in front of me at the moment. Oh, that's okay. We were just commenting that it's expensive. Like everything in Mammoth, right? But it includes all that stuff, so. Yeah. That's good. It's 700 a month. Okay. Thanks. Okay. Any further questions, comments on other programs? Okay.
2:13:47 We'll move on to agenda item five, committee reports. Any active committees having reports that I'm on the town contract ad hoc committee and as Patricia said, we got a meeting scheduled in a couple weeks with town and hopefully we'll get closer to a draft, final draft of our contract update with the town. No other current committee reports for me. Anybody else? I'll just add that the
2:14:20 Development Committee, we're continuing to meet and support Patricia and the team on the active construction projects. A particular emphasis right now is obviously access and increasingly trying to get Valley moving here in the months ahead. And that's all I would share on that. Great. Okay.
2:14:52 All right. We'll move on then to agenda item six, board member reports. And I can lead in on this one, I suppose. So this past month here, I did attend a public meeting on the Silver Peaks project with Visionary Builders presentation down at the CoLab.
2:15:15 Space down in Bishop on Main Street, which was a really cool space I'd never been to before that I thought was great. The Business Resource Center. Business Resource Center, okay. On Main Street, if you ever get a chance to poke your head in there, I encourage you to do so, but it's kind of a cool space. It's kind of close to the Bishop Theater, Twin Theater. Anyway, it was a well-attended meeting. I was there. Patricia was there. And, yeah, it was probably...
2:15:43 20-plus people from the public attended and had a lot of good questions and got a lot of good information shared, so it was a pretty productive meeting. There was a couple other possible leads on some other opportunities that were afforded themselves there while we were there with Patricia and I, and so we'll see where that leads here in the future, some other opportunities down the valley maybe. And then recently,
2:16:09 Over the Memorial Day weekend, I attended a meeting with our assemblyman, David Tangipa, if I pronounced that correctly, was in town meeting with a number of different folks in the community. I think he also met with some of the people in Inyo, but I had an opportunity to spend a couple hours with him up at the ski area. We hosted a lunch and took a ride up a gondola, and we...
2:16:37 Had a lot of discussions with him, some in regards to affordable housing, workforce, affordable housing, some of the issues we're having locally, you know, were mentioned, and also spent a lot of time talking about wildfire risk and wildfire mitigation. One of the daunting kind of discussions that came up was insurance and fire insurance, and he, the assemblyman,
2:17:08 I think he had mentioned that he had been on the Insurance Commission or had participated in that. And he said, yeah, that he said to say that there's an insurance crisis in California is an understatement. And he says it's more of an insurance catastrophe right now and that the fair plan is effectively bankrupt at this point with all the claims that are going to be coming in in the Southern California fires.
2:17:34 Basically require the insurance companies. I don't quite understand how it all functions, but from what I understand that it's a collective of all the insurance companies that contribute to it based on the percentage of policies they have in the state in terms of the overall policies written in the state. And they'll have to make up the, they'll get the funds back to hold for these claims. But the end result is it's going to increase everybody's insurance across the state.
2:18:04 Including all of us who have policies. So that was pretty depressing. And I asked him, well, what's the solution? And he said, there is no easy solution. The only way we're going to get past this is to improve fire safety or obviously reduce wildfires, but hardening existing development against fires when they do occur.
2:18:27 To prevent losses. And yeah, we just, as a state, are going to have to get on top of this issue. He said it's absolute number one priority in terms of what he's trying to do in his position in the assembly. And so it was a real eye-opener for me. I mean, I know I obviously think we all intuitively understand or know that that's going to be a huge problem for the state with the big losses down in Southern California this last winter.
2:18:56 And I know my local neighborhood is working on towards to get certified as a fire safe community as well and taking some measures to do improvements around homes and so forth that are recommended by like a state level fire safe council. But it's a big deal, right? It obviously has a huge impact on housing affordability and there's going to be some heavy lifting that has to be done by a lot of people and a lot of us individually to really get on top of this and ensure that we can even get insurance, right?
2:19:25 So anyway, great to meet him. He was actually, I thought, a really knowledgeable fellow, and I was pretty impressed. He's the youngest guy in the Assembly, or youngest person in the Assembly, but he seems very, very motivated. And he lives over in the Fresno District, and the reason he has so much interest in the fire issue, fire mitigation, wildfires, he did actually, he was working for Fresno County during the Creek Fire.
2:19:55 So he had a lot of involvement in that, and as well as he had some family members directly affected by wildfires and losses and so forth, so it's real personal for him. So it was great to meet him, great guy. And yeah, so that's kind of my update. Anyone else? Okay, well with that, we have a closed session here, gen item 7, pursuant to government code section 5.
2:20:30 4957, the board will hold a closed session to consider the evaluation of performance of an employee, the Executive Director. And I don't know if we have a, had put out a link for Brian to connect, but I think with that we can go to a closed session. Yeah, if you could send a link, please.