Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2024
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 09:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
219 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:25 Good morning, everyone. I have 9 a.m. on Wednesday, August 14th. I would like to call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for today, August 14th. If everyone would please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance, and Hayes, would you please lead us? Please join me in the pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God.
0:56 Indivisible, with liberty and justice. Thank you, Hayes. Appreciate it. Heads up to my new commissioners that you will be called upon to lead that pledge at some point going forward. So with that, Jamie, how about roll call? Commissioner Eckert is absent. Commissioner Fleming? Here. Commissioner Grand? Here. Commissioner Verruck is absent. Chair Vanderhurst? Present. Thank you, Jamie. All right. Let's go to public comment.
1:24 I will say, though, if anybody has public comment that pertains to a matter on today's agenda, please hold on to your public comment until that agenda item has been opened. So with that, is there any other public comment that is not outlined on today's agenda? Any staff updates that we might have here at public comment? Jamie, any public comment via Zoom? Thank you. Then I will close public comment. We'll go to business matters.
1:55 We will open up with Business Matter 4.1, which is review and provide comments on the proposed amendment to the 2010 Snow Creek Development Agreement. I believe our staff contact today is going to be Nolan. Just for the public who may not be familiar with the process, kind of the way this will, the process will kind of unveil itself up here a bit, today is not an action item.
2:23 We will not be making any decisions on the revised proposed Snow Creek Development Agreement. It's a workshop and we're here to get public comment, public feedback, as well as commissioners' thoughts, opinions, questions they might have for the staff or the applicant. So we're going to start off with the staff presentation and then I will give the applicant, Mr. Landy, a chance to approach the commission.
2:51 And then we will go to the commissioners themselves for any questions they may have of the applicant and or staff. And then I will open it up for public comment. And public comment is five minutes. I will have everyone in the audience know whether you're attending virtually or you're attending in person. If you have submitted public comment, like for example, Greg submitted a written public comment a month ago when this meeting was...
3:19 was moved a month later. We have read your public comment. So it is in the public record. It is in the packet. So rest assured, if you have taken the time to already submit it, it has been, it has been read. So with that, I'll pass it off to Nolan. Great. Thank you. So as Chair Van Hurst indicated, this is a workshop item only. This is primarily focused on the proposed amendments to the Snow Creek Development Agreement.
3:49 And while it's related, the tentative tract map that was on the agenda on the July 24th meeting, it is a separate item. That item is not yet on the agenda due to we did not have the revised map materials in time to make it to compile the noticing requirements for a revised public hearing. So that item will be at a future meeting with the phase one tentative map.
4:17 I froze for a second there. Just a quick overview of the outline. As Chair Van Hurst indicated, this is a chance to present the overview of the proposed amendments. It's an opportunity to ask questions to the applicant, as well as for the applicant to address the commission, receive commission and public input, and then next steps on the project. Just a quick overview of development agreements.
4:42 What is a development agreement? They are governed by the California Government Code as well as the Towns Municipal Code. They're a negotiated contract between a project proponent and a public agency. They're a voluntary agreement of both parties so there's no requirement or obligation for either side to enter into a development agreement. They're required to be accompanied by a development plan.
5:07 In this case, that plan was the 2007 Snow Creek Master Plan update. That was specifically for the Snow Creek 8 project. They're intended to provide mutual benefits to both parties, provide a degree of certainty in the land use regulatory process, and provide greater benefits to the community than the development, than what we could require under just the zoning code or other regulatory documents, meaning it's
5:35 Negotiated for greater benefits than what you can normally ask for. With an amendment to an existing DA, the process is the same as for a new DA. It requires public hearings before the Planning Commission as well as the Town Council and an ordinance to be adopted to implement that amendment.
5:54 A brief history of the Snow Creek project. The original master plan was adopted in 1974. Here on the screen it shows all the phases of Snow Creek. The Snow Creek 8 area was largely within that original master plan area with the exception of the 94 acres on the east side of the project area all along.
6:20 The east side here that borders Sherman Creek Road, that was part of a land exchange with the U.S. Forest Service that brought that into private ownership. The original master plan was amended in 1981. Shortly thereafter, the developer at that time entered into a development agreement with Mono County and later was added or adopted by the town. So that was the 1982 Snow Creek Development Agreement. It was in effect for 20 years.
6:48 The Snow Creek 7 project, which is kind of to the northwest of the Snow Creek 8 project on the other side of Old Mammoth Road was approved in 2006. Construction started shortly thereafter and then it was ongoing for the next long period of time all the way until 2024 when it was completed. So that's just, and that was 118 units to just give a scale of the kind of time for these developments to occur and to be completed.
7:17 In 2009, the 2007 Snow Creek Master Plan update was approved by the Town Council. That update included the certification of an EIR for the project and that analyzed the entire Snow Creek 8 area and that also serves as the environmental documentation for all the future projects within the Snow Creek area provided the proposed projects are consistent with what's in the master plan update.
7:42 And then in 2010, the current development agreement was approved. That development agreement has a term of 2010 to 2030. However, there is some language in there where the development agreement would expire sooner if construction of the expanded golf course and hotel had not commenced. Since those items have not commenced, the development agreement, if those
8:08 Items don't commence construction by July 2025, then the current development agreement would expire in July of 2025. Development agreements vest the projects that are included within the development agreement. So for the 2010 development agreement, that included the Snow Creek 7 and Snow Creek 8 projects. The Snow Creek 7 project was 118 units, also included a bike path, easement, and public access along Mammoth Creek.
8:37 And that project has been completed, so it's really not subject to the, it has been completed and all the units have been sold, so it's not subject to the terms of the development agreement any longer. Snow Creek 8 is the future phase of the Snow Creek projects. Again, it was approved under the 2007 master plan update. It allows for up to 990 units, of which 790 are residential units.
9:06 And 400 are hotel rooms or private residence club units. The master plan update does identify the hotel rooms and residence club units, counts them as half units due to the size of the proposed units. It also includes a resort hotel, an expansion of the current golf course, and includes open space, access to recreation, and a great lawn, which is a kind of a large community gathering space near the hotel.
9:36 As indicated, there has been a request to amend the 2010 Snow Creek Development Agreement. The proposed amendments are highlighted here on the screen. The developer, in this case Chadmar, is requesting an extension of the term or to extend the term for an additional 20 years. That term would be based on from the expiration date in 2025, so it would then extend it to 2045.
10:01 Also includes removal of the language where they lose a day for each day construction of the golf course and hotel have not started. So if the 20-year extension was approved, then there wouldn't be a language in there that shortens the DA for not starting those pieces. The town, in exchange, is proposing the following amendments. Continued operation of the existing nine-hole golf course for the life of the development agreement.
10:28 Within the current DA, there's no obligation to operate the existing nine-hole golf course or build and operate the expanded 18-hole golf course. The only penalty in the current DA for not building the expanded 18-hole golf course is they lose time on the life of the DA. There's nothing in there that says you shall build this prior to any such unit or build this at any point. It just says if you don't build it, your DA will expire sooner.
10:57 This language, at least this, would commit the developer to operate the existing course for that term. Within the amendments, we will need to define the exact parameters for the continued operation, include such things as the typical season for operation, the budget, how the course will be maintained, what constitutes an event of default, terms such as that. We're also proposing
11:24 Or asking for the permanent protection of the roughly 61 acres that the existing golf course occupies. This would be similar to the permanent open space protection that's on the expanded area. So this would ensure that that area can only be used for recreation or open space uses and cannot be developed with condominiums, hotels, or other types of development.
11:48 Within that amendment, we will need to define the time period for the completion of that agreement or that covenant when it shall be recorded against the property. And then the last one here is an option for additional summer and winter recreational amenities on the golf course expansion area. As indicated earlier, there is really no leverage or ability.
12:13 At least that we see it to require that that golf course area, the expanded area be developed. However, we know the developer has interest in developing it should it align with the rest of the development area and wants to keep that option available. So the option to add summer winter recreational amenities would allow for interim uses out in those areas such as bike trails, cross-country ski trails within that area.
12:40 The amendment would need to clarify that any uses that weren't analyzed in the original EIR may require additional subsequent CEQA review depending on the scale of what's being proposed. With these amendments, the town contracted with an independent financial analyst to analyze the proposed community benefits together with the existing community benefit package to determine if
13:08 The value to the developer as well as the value to the town. That analysis was included in the Planning Commission packet. That financial analysis concluded that the community benefits package is sufficient to justify approving the proposed amendments, meaning it is mutually beneficial to both parties. As we discussed before, the main kind of
13:39 A feature of a development agreement is that the town and the community receive additional community benefits that they wouldn't receive otherwise. Within the development agreement, it highlights numerous community benefits, which I'm going to walk through here. I have color-coded them on the following slides, between blue and black. The ones colored in blue are really the community benefits that the community would not get without the DA.
14:09 More of the community benefits that will occur regardless if there's a DA in place or if the project is, because the project can be developed without a development agreement. So those benefits we would receive whether we have the development agreement or not. So the first one here is a $10 million additional financial contribution. So this is money paid with every building permit that's in addition to any standard building permit fees or development impact fees.
14:38 It is prorated based on each unit, so it would be payable with the building permit for each residential unit or hotel unit. It's intended to be used for public facilities within the area of geographic nexus. That nexus kind of area includes all of the phases of Snow Creek plus an additional buffer beyond that area as well as the entire Sherwin Area Recreation Plan area that's
15:06 And located between the Sherwin's and the development. So this money could be used for future recreational uses, future really any, it's defined pretty broadly. So it could be used for housing within that geographic nexus. It could be used for recreation purposes. There's really no limit as long as it's a public facility.
15:32 Within the development agreement, it does highlight a few areas where that contribution would go down. The main one is if not all the residential units or hotel units are built over the life of the project. So if they don't build 990 units, we wouldn't get the full 10 million because it's paid on a prorated basis with each permit issued. Some of the other ones are tied more to the
15:56 Any change in the housing mitigation framework or if we required units to be sold at a lower AMI or if we change the how those on-site affordable units payments are calculated, it could then reduce that additional financial contribution on a proportional basis. It also includes in the DA an option for that.
16:20 That financial contribution value to increase, and that's tied more to the sales price of the market rate units. So if the average square foot price of the units for that previous year hit $800 to $1,000 per square foot, then that financial contribution would increase based on the national CPI increase for that year.
16:44 And then if that square footage exceeds a thousand square foot, then it would increase at a hundred percent of that CPI for that year. So there's some factors in the DA for it to go down as well as to go up depending on what occurs. Some of the other benefits within the DA, again, these are the ones in black are the ones that we theoretically get regardless of the DA, such as the fiscal benefits to the town, meaning if they build the projects, we're going to get an increase in TOT.
17:12 It's not tied to having a development agreement in place or not. It also commits 8.9 acres of park land in excess of what's required by the town documents. In total, they're proposing about 15 acres of park land that's spread out between the public park area, the open space area that's to the northwest of Old Mammoth Road, as well as the open space corridor that kind of goes down the middle of the project.
17:42 They're required to preserve the Mammoth Creek Open Space Corridor, that's the parcel to the north of Old Mammoth Road, that has been donated to the town and has a conservation easement recorded against it, so that has been completed. The 18-hole golf course and golf practice facility are included as a community benefit. Again, the DA doesn't require them or obligate them to necessarily build that at any period of time.
18:07 And it could be built with or without the DA because it isn't allowed use in the master plan update. Provides secondary access for Snow Creek 5 and Snow Creek 8 and emergency vehicle access to Sherwin Creek Road. It allows for allowed egress for backcountry winter recreation users. That easement has already been recorded against the property and it is already allowed use for wintertime recreation users to cut through the site.
18:37 The programming of public spaces, that's really intended for that, the great lawn that's near the hotel, it would allow for various community events to occur there. So that's one where, you know, without the DA, they could restrict that space to only be used for the hotel. I don't know why they would, should be built, because it would obviously encourage more of the public to come there, but that is something that we can't necessarily require how they use it if we don't have the DA.
19:07 And then access through the project to public lands. In the Snow Creek 8 project, there's a series of multi-use paths that are adjacent to all the streets that then provide access to the public lands adjacent to the project. And the last one was they offered up land for the propane tank storage and easement.
19:28 That was really in the event if we couldn't come to another agreement with the Forest Service, we have since come to an agreement with the Forest Service, so we have the tanks out on Sherman Creek Road. However, that language is still in the DA that should that deal go away or something else happens, we do have an easement on the Snow Creek Aid area property for propane tanks. So the other benefits in the development agreement is the housing mitigation.
19:57 Here on the screen we highlight the differences between what's required by the Affordable Housing Mitigation Framework and the DA versus what would be required under the current Town of Mammoth Lakes Housing Ordinance. The DA requires them to provide 47 units of on-site housing. Those would be ownership units sold to area median incomes of 150 to 200 percent, so really hitting that missing middle that we struggle to.
20:26 Struggle to provide housing for otherwise. It allows them to use their 16 and a half housing mitigation credits that the developer owns. Those credits were resulting from credits provided for the Aspen Village Apartments back in the early 2000s, the donation of that land to build that future project. The developer at that time received credits for that donation. Those credits have since been used on
20:54 The Snow Creek 7 project, some of them were sold to or transferred with the land at the old Novato site, so 6060 Minaret Road, those credits that were used for that Rock Spring project originated from that land sale. Then the remaining credits would be applied throughout the Snow Creek 8 project. It also requires them to payment of in-lieu fees. It's a total of about $2.6 million, assuming full build-out.
21:23 So those three, the on-site housing, the credits, and the fees, that's a combined package. It's not they're going to do, you know, any A, B, or C. It's they have to do all of those as part of their housing mitigation for the whole project. The estimated value of that framework, assuming full build-out, is about $9.8 million to $12.2 million. That was calculated based on the $2.6 million in fees.
21:52 The value of the credits, and then a subsidy of $150,000 to $200,000 for those 47 units, meaning if we were to try to go acquire 47 units of market rate housing that we would then deed restrict and sell, that's about the average that the town has been paying to deed restrict units to 150 to 200 percent AMI. Under the current, if the DA went away or they weren't, if they expired, meaning we didn't approve an amendment.
22:21 The future project then would just be subject to the current Mammoth Lakes Housing Ordinance. That current housing ordinance allows for a variety of options to mitigate housing impacts, such as payment of in lieu fees, provision of on-site housing or off-site housing. However, the key factor in that menu of options is that all options are considered equal and are based on what the fee would be.
22:48 At full build-out, based on the current housing fees, they would be obligated to provide $9 million in housing mitigation. They could just come in and pay the fee for each unit. They could build $9 million at that fee of value on the land. They could buy land. But it doesn't require them to actually build the units, which I think in this case is a tremendous value to the community since we struggle at those higher AMIs.
23:20 The last one here is within the DEA, it vests their building permit fees based on the building fee schedule in effect in 2010. That fee schedule or the value of the or the amount of the fees does increase on an annual basis based on the California Construction Cost Index. Since 2010, that index has increased at 4.1% annually.
23:51 Here on the screen, it just shows a graph going from 2014 to the current year. On the bottom, the black line is the fees that they would be paying based on that 2010 fee. And the green line is the current fees for each fiscal year. As you see, the increases track pretty closely year after year.
24:17 Does result in average savings of about $3,300 per permit, and that's based on a permit for a triplex. So if it's an eightplex, the fees would be higher, but the gap between the current fee and the 2010 fee would be the same because they're really tracking at that same increase.
24:44 The other ones that are proposed remain the same in the DA. The DA highlighted three milestones within the development agreement. The first one was to allow egress of backcountry winter recreation users. That has been completed. The next one is the permanent protection of the Mammoth Creek open space corridor. That has been completed. Then the phasing of developments based on what the market will absorb. The DA and the master plan are very clear.
25:12 Very clearly did not identify any specific dates for development or timeline. It was very clear that it's really up to the developer as to what the market will absorb and what they see as the kind of appropriate number of units to build each year and when those units would be built. It also is very clear that it didn't require
25:34 The hotel or golf course prior to residential or the residential first, it really left it all up to the developer on how that phasing would be done. What happens if the Snow Creek development expires? The town loses the additional community benefits, primarily those ones highlighted in blue area that we wouldn't receive otherwise. That's the additional financial contribution. That's the higher housing mitigation. The developer would be...
26:04 Subject to the current building diffs and housing fees. So we wouldn't be, you know, couldn't require any of the on-site housing units. They would be paying that slightly higher building permit fee for each building permit. However, the developer could still build the entire project outline in the Snow Creek Master Plan update. Mammoth Plans did not require the operation or development of projects. They really only provide the regulatory framework and the use is permitted. So they
26:32 They serve as the zoning document for that area. Future entitlements would then be subject to the timelines in the zoning code, meaning that any approvals wouldn't be vested under the DA, such as the phase one tentative map. If there was not a DA, it would have a life of two years before it needs to have a final map with the option for up to a six-year extension.
26:57 Where if there is a DA in place, those entitlements are then vested for the life of the DA. And then the last one here is that the master plan update does not require the operation of the current golf course, meaning the existing nine-hole course. Whereas if that amendment and the developer agrees to the terms, that is something the town is pushing for and feels very strongly that should be included in any amendment is that at least the current golf course will operate for the life of the DA.
27:28 So next steps. Following this workshop, there would be a subsequent update at Town Council. A similar presentation was presented to Town Council in February of this year with the proposed amendments. So taking any feedback from this meeting, then any feedback from the Town Council update, we would finalize the proposed amendments to the development agreement.
27:51 And then at future commission and town council meetings, there would be a public hearing to consider the proposed amendments. Next up is for the Snow Creek 8 project. So as indicated earlier, they can build the Snow Creek 8 project with or without a DA. And also the current DA is valid for approximately another year until July of 2025. So they're looking to get started on the phase one of the residential development.
28:20 So there is a phase one tentative tract map that was included as a public hearing at the July meeting. However, due to a change from the developer on the unit count, that will be at a subsequent meeting. So it's currently proposed to have 172 condominium units within that first phase, broken out over three phases of development. That also then will require a subsequent use permit and design review to allow the actual construction of those units.
28:47 And then future phases are to be determined really at the discretion of the developer as far as timing goes. You know, I don't want to say it's going to follow the same timeline as Snow Creek 7, but we really have no control on the market forces as to what happens and as far as how long that might take to see future phases come forward. That concludes the presentation.
29:15 So I can answer any questions from the commission now, or we can open it up to the developer, Chuck Landy, to provide any comments. Yeah, I'd like to hold on to our questions at this time, if you wouldn't mind. And I'd like to give Mr. Landy a chance to address the commission. And after that, we'll have some questions from the commission. I know I have a few. And then we'll open it up to public comment. So you will definitely have a chance to address the room, everyone.
29:45 Hi, good morning. Chuck Landy with Snow Creek. Nice to be here. I think Nolan did a great job recapping what was in the development agreement and what is contemplated going forward. I will tell you on our side there are some people that think we're giving too much away and shouldn't extend it, but I gave my word and as always I intend to keep it. So I look forward to working with you on this extension. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Landy. Would you mind just staying at the podium in case anybody has any questions from the commission, I mean? Sure.
30:14 And with that, I'll throw it open to the commission. Any questions for staff or the applicant? Yes. I'm curious, how many deed-restricted units will be built in the first phase? No one, do you remember? The first phase proposes 5% of the unit count, which is, can't do math here, nine units. Okay, thank you. The total, just so you know, we don't like to, and this is really for, what's the right word, social reasons.
30:46 Some people go put all the deed restricted units in one spot in a corner. We spread them out throughout the development. So they're mixed in with all the market rate units as they should be proportionately. Any other questions at this time? You'll definitely have a chance again during this meeting. Commissioner Grand, any questions for either the staff or applicant? No, I think Nolan did a great job filling in all the gaps. Okay. I've got a couple of questions here.
31:16 The 61 acres that you mentioned that I think were protected as open space or recreational use, is that the current nine or is that the eventual 18 holes? So the 61 acres is roughly the existing nine holes. That one currently has no protection. It's currently no...
31:40 Permanent protection is open space. It's identified as recreation uses within the master plan. There is a slight variation in that 61 acres with the way the phasing of the development occurs where the clubhouse, the parking lot, and a portion of hole one do get converted to housing in that first phase, which is always part of the master plan. So it will be slightly less than 61 acres that's permanently protected there.
32:08 That exact number will be finalized when we get the revised map area showing what that area looks like. And then the 94 acres, that's the expanded golf course area, so along that eastern edge of the development area. That area is already permanently protected with a covenant that's between the town and the developer. And then Eastern Sierra Land Trust is the, I forget the word, but they basically oversee and
32:39 Ensure that that covenant remains in place and that all the terms of it are being adhered to. Got it. So it would be a similar covenant recorded against the existing use over that area. And the deed restricted units, the eventual 47, but it sounds like nine will be built in the first phase. When you say deed restricted, who holds the restricted deed? The town.
33:08 Okay, so can you kind of outline the terms of what the restrictions are, please? Sure, so these would be ownership units, meaning they're sold to income-eligible households earning the target income. So in this case, they'd be 150 to up to 200% AMI households. Depending on the household size, that dictates the maximum incomes. So they'd be sold to those households. The deed restriction then...
33:35 Restricts the future sale of those units to the same target income, so meaning it can only be sold to 150% AMI household in the future. That deed restriction is in place for 55 years. It doesn't restrict them in the same way a rental one would, meaning that it only looks at their income when they purchase the unit. So if their income goes up, it doesn't mean they have to sell it. They can still live in it for as long as they
34:04 Continue it as their primary residence and continue to work in the region. However, it does then cap that future price to that AMI level to ensure it remains affordable. Got it. Who determined the 150 to 200 percent range? So that was negotiated in the development agreement. It was discussion between the developer of the town and then Mammoth Lakes Housing to come up with the appropriate AMI target.
34:33 I think the goal was really to target the missing middle, which has historically been a challenge because there's no state or federal monies in that area to provide units. So it's kind of an area that isn't being addressed through other projects. Got it. Not to go down this rabbit hole of information, but just for the general public or maybe some new commissioners who aren't aware of how the state determines AMI and what AMI means.
35:03 Sure. So it's the AMI for us, it's based on the county. It's set by the state. And just for clarity, sorry, sorry, Nolan, AMI means what? Area median income. Thank you. So the area median income is set by the state for the county. So for us, it's Mono County as a whole. It's the average household income for a household size of four across the county. So it doesn't, you know, if.
35:32 We hear often people earn more in Mammoth than outside the county. That doesn't come into play for the area median income. So for example, the ranges we're talking about, the median income for Mono County for 2024 for a household size of four is $105,900. And so then the income for a household size of four at 150% or 200% AMI, which would be these targets.
36:00 Would allow for a household income of about $160,000 up to $212,000 for a household size of four to qualify to purchase those units there. Got it. And how often does the state of California recalibrate AMI per county? It's updated every June. And so for a period of time from about 2010 to really I think it was two years ago.
36:27 The AMI was flat for Mono County, meaning it didn't increase. I think part of that was tied to the economic downturn. The area median income dropped substantially in 2008 to 2010. However, once that AMI set, the income limits don't decrease regardless if the actual income goes down. So it took up to about two years ago for that incomes to...
36:52 Catch back up and exceed the 2008 levels. And we have seen about 10% increases over the last two years, kind of each year on that area median income for Mono County. So they have been climbing. And the state recalibrates that for every individual county? Yep, correct. Every June they release new numbers. Perfect, thank you. What is the, you mentioned that there was a current valid
37:21 Use agreement with the Forest Service for the land under the propane farm slash tanks out on Sherwin Creek Road. What is the length of that agreement? Sorry, guys. I put you on the spot. I believe there's about 20 years left on that use permit. But I could get back to you with the exact figure. And the town feels pretty comfortable that that 20 years is foreseeable usage for the 20 years. There won't be
37:54 Let's say the District Ranger changes out and they don't like the agreement. Are there exit clauses that they can take, off-ramps that they can take or off-ramps the town can take? I am not aware of any ability for the Forest Service to change things other than something catastrophic or listed in the permit itself. I don't expect there to be any changes for the duration of that permit, but I can't speak to the future beyond the life of that permit.
38:23 And the only reason I bring this up, guys, is the snow pit example is probably one I think is probably the most relevant that I don't think we have the ability to use the snow pit going forward. I just want to make sure that the usage with the Forest Service, the usage language kind of maintains that usage for that land going forward. Yeah, and there's a difference in we didn't have a permit for the duration.
38:52 That we have for the tank farm for the snow pit. So we're currently in negotiations on a new permit for the snow pit. There's no need to renegotiate for the tank farm because it still has longevity. Got it. And it's not subject to the whims of Forest Service staff changeover? No. Got it. Thank you. Mr. Landy, quick question. I know right now currently the Snow Creek Golf Course has a operational agreement with Sierra Star? It does. What is the length of that operational agreement?
39:21 Oh, I think initially it's three years. It's a concept that we came up with probably 10 years ago just for efficiencies. They were losing a ton of money. We were losing a ton of money. Maybe if we combined forces, it would be better for us both. So it's working well this first year, and we look forward to it going on into the future. Great. I did have another question for you, but I think we might have nailed on it.
39:51 At this time, any other questions for either the applicant or staff from the commission? We will circle back to you guys if you do have some questions that come up. No. Okay. At this time, I'd love to open it up to the public, public comment. I will remind everyone that you have five minutes. I am normally not a huge fan of public comment becoming a Q&A session with either the applicant or staff, but because this is a workshop, we will do it. Just keep in mind that
40:20 If you do want to engage in Q&A with either staff or the applicant, you still will be subject to your five minute time limitation. So with that, please approach the podium. I'll be short because I already submitted comments and I'll submit more before the time is up. But I just wanted to quickly say that this is the largest project in the history of Mammoth Lakes by far. It's a thousand units over 30 years.
40:52 It makes a big difference. You would not see Truckee, you would not see Tahoe, you would not see Sun Valley, you would not see any resort community doing this without a high-powered development agreement consultant over a period of a couple years really working on this. I sort of feel bad for Nolan putting this position to do something that really should be done by high-powered professionals. I think that's irresponsible of our town government.
41:17 I mean, we have a history of hubris, Mammoth Lakes. We took the airport development agreement. We can do that ourselves. Well, we know what we're doing. $50 million settlement later up at the village. That's supposed to be a three- or four-story parking garage. The town goes, we can do this. We'll just call the town blighted and do a real development agreement and pay for it. Well, they got sued and they lost that. Hubris and irresponsible. This is hubris and irresponsible, in my opinion.
41:42 And I think a lot of Nolan and I think a lot of Seth. I don't think so much about government above that. I think that they put him in a bad position and he's a great guy. But just a couple really quick notes and there will be more later is the only thing you get out of this is a nine-hole golf course. That's it. And for that matter, you don't get a nine-hole golf course that can be kept up in any condition whatsoever to be determined later. In the beginning of this, you had those four different items to be determined. That should be determined now.
42:11 Before we were standing here, so things yet to be done. Don't leave anything on the table that the developer himself can decide what happens. The open space you referred to, the 61 acres, that was the Forest Service granted that, so it's a deed restricted. The last development agreement amendment, staff had said pre-Nolan, well because the Forest Service says that it's open space, you can do open space. No, that doesn't work that way. It means he can't develop it as units because that's on the deed. You in turn can require anything you want.
42:41 You're not stuck by any of the agreements. However, because it's a mutual agreement between the developer, that should be worked on over a period of time. So the only things I recommend, because it's too late to really do it right.
42:54 is make sure you have in writing that that nine holes in perpetuity for the extension of the 20 years is kept in a championship condition as determined by the 10 amount. Don't let this guy determine it because it'll, you know, the ponds will close and look like crap and, well, you can still play on it. You want to be the driving force and in the open space for recreationalists, it's if he wants to do it.
43:18 I mean, you have to approve it like you would anything else, but he's really the one making the call, not you, so there's no financial benefit. All the things that are already accomplished, they're done. So there's no benefit to that. That was the first 20 years. I question the legality of giving him roughly 25 more years on the development agreement. I would not renege on... It normally would expire next year, but you're saying, let's...
43:45 Let's just forgive him for all the things that we said you had to do so we can go until 2030. Then we'll give him 20 years on top of that. I'm not sure that's legal to do a 30-year agreement because it's no longer a 20-year agreement. Now it's longer than that. It's just my own legal opinion. I'm not an attorney. So anyway, I'm not going to talk too much about that, just the need for the golf course.
44:06 I feel that we're not getting a whole lot out of it, if anything. And the financial analysis, like, why would they do a financial analysis? I'm sure he paid for it because law allows, you know, the town to make sure the developer pays for all of that stuff. So why they did that and didn't bring a DA consultant and attorney to look at it, it's...
44:25 Absolutely dumbfounding. No other community would do that. It's just our usual hubris. So anyway, I think the world, if anybody's willing to commit their free time for the benefit of the town, thank you for that. I think it's fantastic. Staff, I think a lot of staff, as you know, are good guys. I just think we're doing it all wrong and I think it's unfortunate. I'll be gone by the time this is done.
44:45 And it's such a huge, huge project. No one in this town can conceive how big it is. It's just another phase of snow creek. It's not. It's a thousand units. It's absurd to just say, let's just rubber stamp it and go with what we were going to get the last 20 years. Anyway, thank you very much. Thank you, Greg. Appreciate it. Nolan, can you confirm that Greg's written public comment that was submitted at our July meeting has been entered into public record? It has, yes. Okay. Appreciate that.
45:15 Public comment, please approach the podium. Good morning, Garrett Heigert, I'm the District Engineer with Mammoth Community Water District. Thank you, great presentation. I just had a couple of things I wanted to add for the commission and the public just related to the water usage on the site. So the existing Snow Creek Master Plan and EIR.
45:47 One of the key things in it related to water is that it requires that recycled water be used to the maximum extent feasible. And so this applies to the golf courses and it also applies to the landscaping for the common area in the Snow Creek development, Snow Creek 8 development. So with that being said, we're working with the developer.
46:15 on a update to our recycled water agreement. There are actually some provisions in our old recycled water agreement with Snow Creek. I believe it was entered into around maybe 2015 time frame and then it was amended a couple times. There are some provisions in there that have expired for the additional nine holes and the practice hole that is somewhat
46:45 Definitely tied into this whole development agreement discussion. And so we're working with the developer on a new agreement for that. The other interesting thing that's happened as water usage and wastewater usage has developed in town, some of the early projections on how much recycled water were going to be available have not played out exactly as planned.
47:13 As you can imagine, you know, based on estimates. So part of what we're doing is an analysis of that and the realities of that demand or that supply that's available could have some impacts on how the golf courses are, the new golf course is designed. It could even have some impact on the existing nine-hole golf course and how much water usage.
47:42 the existing course requires in order to keep it in the condition that the town would like it to be in for play. So I just, that's really the only thing that I had to add to the discussion about the development agreement. Would you mind if I asked you a couple of quick questions? Like I said, I'm not a huge fan of Q&A from the dais, but you are representing one of our public utilities.
48:12 The negotiations you are having with Snow Creek about the water usage, is that public record eventually when that agreement is finalized? Yes, absolutely. Okay. You hinted that possible water usage for the existing nine and potential 18 future, the additional nine, there may be a reduction in the water usage, it may remain the same, or there may be an increase.
48:44 You're a little bit vague on that. Is that something you're willing to expand upon now? Well, I think Chuck, I don't think he knows exactly how much water the new nine holes would use. And we're also trying to pin down a little bit more how much water would be available. At this point, as you're aware of with this whole discussion,
49:14 The developer still has the ability to build the additional golf course, but is not necessarily required under this new proposal. And there's no deadline that it should be built in a certain number of years. So depending on how the water and wastewater usage in town happens in the next 5, 10, 15, 20 years, it's somewhat of a moving target.
49:41 But what we're trying to do our best at right now is to have a true up of that so that everyone is on the same page. The EIR for the specific or for the master plan and the master plan, it really has good policy in there. It really is good policy that we should be using recycled water for the golf course and for the landscape irrigation, especially with the
50:09 You know, just what's happening with our water resources here in Mammoth and then on the state. So it's good policy. It's just a matter of working on what the details are and then how that works out. You know, one thing we've been really pretty pleased with with the arrangement with Sierra Star operating it is that there's a lot of thought going into
50:35 Just exactly how much water it takes to be efficient with operating and maintaining a golf course. I think they put a lot of thought into it and want to apply the right amount of water, but not too much. And so I think that that's a pretty good development. But yeah, a lot of kind of unknowns and some variables.
51:03 And another thing that hasn't really been discussed yet, but phase one of the Snow Creek Gate, actually there is a portion of the area that the golf, existing golf course is on that would have condos on it. So there will be, need to be some reworking of the existing nine hole golf course if the phase one of the Snow Creek Gate track map is approved, which
51:32 Hasn't, you know, come to the Planning Commission yet. Garrett, would you say that the negotiations between you and Snow Creek are kind of running parallel with the negotiation timeline between Snow Creek and the town on the possibility of updating and revising the development agreement? Like, are you progressing at that speed? Yes, yes, and that's been our intention too, is to make sure that it's aligned as much as possible.
52:02 And that's my reason for attending today and giving a brief update because the water is key to that component of this development agreement. Got it. Thank you very much. I actually have a question based on the fact that was brought up just a few minutes ago. The 900 units would create a tremendous amount of sewage. Does the town with the current infrastructure of piping and everything supporting it?
52:32 Have a capacity to handle an extra 900 units of sewage? Yes. Yeah, good question. We've evaluated that both on the water and the wastewater side. And yes, there is capacity. We, at one point, we're looking at whether or not any off-site improvements may be required in order to transport and to, you know, get that sewage down to our wastewater treatment plant.
52:58 But that's not the case. So we do have the infrastructure and then the developer will be constructing a significant amount of water and wastewater infrastructure to support the development. So yes, we do have capacity for water and wastewater. And you're right, there will be an amount of wastewater that is contributed from the development.
53:24 That then we would then be able to turn that into usable recycled water. The thing is that what's happening right now in the state, the fixtures are really very efficient though. And so when you have new development, it doesn't, you know, by design, it produces a relatively modest amount of wastewater that then could be recycled.
53:53 to come back to that project. Thank you. If that makes sense. Yeah. Thank you, Garrett. Appreciate it. Thanks for attending today. Any other public comment from Sweet Z? Good morning. My name is Phillip Bettencourt. I'm a return seasonal visitor, honored to be here, and very much a fan of both golf courses, both of which my wife and I have played this week, and we're delighted at the new management.
54:34 Synergism that we think is going to be good for both courses. We're on a first-name basis with folks there. I am a supporter of the community benefits package recommended by the staff. I think it's more complete, it's more substantial, it is more reflective of the value of a development agreement in the first place, if you will.
55:05 I do want to say, I want to make the recommendation I made last year, I feel you would be better served to have a membership in the National Golf Foundation so that you had independent counsel on the standards for operation. The difficulty of this document about either of the courses is that they don't have significant specifications.
55:33 for the course operation, time, condition, amount of money to be invested, and standards, and I think you would be well served to tighten that up, and the National Golf Foundation, they have no skin in the game, they don't operate golf courses, but they are experts. I have worked with them, and I think you find their counsel very helpful. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
55:59 And congratulations to Jamie for her continued service to the city. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Appreciate that. Do we know if Sierra Star is a member of the affiliation the gentleman just mentioned? I don't know the organization's name. National Golf Course something or another? I'm not aware, but that's something we're going to look into. Okay. Please do. Thank you very much, guys. Any other public comment from Suite Z?
56:30 Please, sir, come to the podium. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Commissioners. My name is Rich Noland, and I'm a resident or owner over at Snow Creek 5, have been for well over a decade now, and been anxiously watching Snow Creek 8 come and get ready to go. In my opinion, I think it's a fantastic property, not only for the neighbors, but also for the town as a whole.
57:01 It's going to provide a lot, a lot of public benefits to the community that you otherwise wouldn't get. This thing's been baking for well over a decade, and it seems the extension is only beneficial to the town at this point. And as, you know, I would also do some development as well. That development agreement is very important when you're out there trying to finance something that's probably a billion-dollar development in the future. To get the kind of equity and financing to do this, a development agreement is essential.
57:30 for such a large, complex project that's going to be built out over maybe 30 years, maybe beyond 30 years. I mean, if you look at the time out here, they'll eventually get built, right? If the market's good, if we still have water, all these things, they will eventually, these homes will be built, just like everywhere else in California. I think this project and a development agreement extension is a really good thing for the town. Thank you. Thank you, Richard. Appreciate it. Any other public comment from Sweet Z?
58:04 I don't see a bum rush to the podium. So, Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? Yes. If someone would please just let us know their name and let them know that they have five minutes, please. Sure. Trano, would you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Yes, good morning. Hi, can you guys hear me? We got you. Great. Thanks for the opportunity. My name is Matt Trano.
58:34 I'm a homeowner at 1198 Pyrapid Peak, that's in Snow Creek 6, and our home fronts the golf course. I just wanted to raise a couple of points that have been touched on, but touched on lightly. One is with respect to the continued operation of the nine-hole golf course, and I did submit public comment to Nolan, and he's been great in responding, so thanks, Nolan. And this may be more a question for the commissioner, for the developer, but we've talked about
59:04 One of the main benefits go forward if this is amended is the developer is going to continue to maintain the golf course and operate it. Standards certainly need to be created. As we've seen over the last five or six seasons, there's been a significant underinvestment in that golf course. But the bigger issue to me is we keep talking about nine holes, but the first phase that the developers brought forward to the town eliminates hole one. And I've not seen anybody address
59:34 That discrepancy between this continued benefit for the community of a nine-hole championship golf course and the elimination of the first hole with the first phase of this development, which has, I think, nine phases? I question why the first phase needs to eliminate the first hole of the golf course. Does anyone have any clarification on what happens with that first hole? Nolan, you want to take that one? Sure.
1:00:02 So the first phase, as proposed, there's three phases, phases 1A, 1B, and 1C, so three sub-phases to that phase. Within phase 1C, it does require the relocation of the clubhouse and the parking lot and a reorientation of hole 1. So it's likely we've also not seen a revised hole layout, but potentially that hole would be shortened.
1:00:30 or amended to move the tee boxes to a alternate location. So that would be obviously all included in that one, the DA as to the timing that that all has to occur prior to the commencement of any construction. That also is included in the proposed conditions for the phase one tentative map. It's our understanding that the phases one B and one C would likely be
1:01:00 You know, at a distant point in the future, primarily since they just rebuilt Fairway Drive in the last year to a substantially higher quality than was what they were originally looking to since they were looking at it as a more temporary road. They completely rebuilt that road.
1:01:18 So, you know, I don't want to speak for the developer or commit to the developer's timeline, but it's likely that as we see that the development would proceed more on the east side along the new Snow Creek Drive and loop around rather than rebuilding that phase 1B and 1C immediately. So we can't commit to a timeline when that would be eliminated, but it is likely to be a ways in the future. But we will require with the DA to be
1:01:46 Exactly clear what that proposed realignment looks like with, because that does tie into that continued operation of the course. And that would, so you're saying hole one would not be eliminated, it might just be relined or shortened or altered in some way, shape or form, but will still be, it'll still be a nine hole golf course. That's correct. Sir, did you have any other questions or points that you'd like to make? Yeah, just a couple more comments. Thanks, Nolan. I think it's important that that
1:02:16 Revised layout be agreed upon before the DA gets finalized. I'm sure that's what you guys are thinking. And then in terms of ongoing maintenance, I think that there is a benefit to the town to defining what type of capital investment should be allocated to the course go forward so we don't see the continued deterioration of that course. It's been a little bit better this season, but there's probably 5,000 golfer holes out there.
1:02:45 The car paths have been completely destroyed. It is, you know, it's nowhere near what that golf course used to be, and I think the town and myself would love to see it come back to life. The second point I'll make is, in my opinion, the two big benefits of the town in the 2010 DA was the development of a five-star resort property and an 18-hole championship golf course.
1:03:11 So we're not getting an 18-hole championship golf course. We're getting the continuation of a nine-hole course, which was already there before the 2010 DA. Something to just point out. And then I haven't heard anything about the continued efforts to develop the five-star resort. I know that the DA gets audited annually or certified annually. I'm not sure what the correct term is. I've never seen in that document.
1:03:38 Anything that requires the developer to disclose or to indicate what they've done to try to further the efforts of that five-star resort development, whether it's their discussions with operators or flags, whether it's financing, whether it's a capital markets update, whether it's further development of design. I think there should be some kind of component in this annual review go forward where
1:04:05 The town gets an indication of what is the developer actually doing to further the development of a five-star resort property. And I'll conclude with that. Thank you so much. Thank you for your time. Appreciate it. Jamie, any other? Tom, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, guys. Tom Daniels here. I just want to maybe echo, reinforce some of the comments that have already been made.
1:04:37 In regards to the condition of the course, I mean, I have to support what was said earlier. It really needs money to be spent soon to get that course back in the operation that it once was. And I worry about, I mean, I think it's great that Sierra Star is doing it and the agreement that they have with Chadmar, but what happens when Sierra Star decides
1:05:05 That it no longer fits what they want to do. Snow Creek doesn't have equipment. They don't have a maintenance shed. You know, I worry about, you know, what the agreement's going to look like to ensure that the condition of the course is what we all expect. And we really need to nail that before this DA gets approved.
1:05:34 And I think it really needs to be on the line of a budget. How much money do we expect to be put into the course every year? And that needs to adjust over time. The second thing I want to talk about is the realignment of hole number one. You know, the original plan and the master plan
1:06:04 was to build condos on one when the rest of the championship course was built. So I hear that we're going to keep a nine-hole course and we're going to shorten number one, but without really knowing what that looks like, the character of the course could potentially radically change if we really hack into that first hole. That's the best par five in the Eastern Sierra.
1:06:31 I would say and I would urge you guys to think about there's plenty of other land on the other side of the street. Why do we need to infringe on the golf course at all? I don't understand why we need to do that. And again, I'll just repeat myself. That was contemplated with the expansion to an 18-hole court. So I've put all those comments in the public record. I'll probably provide some more, but that's...
1:07:05 That's what I have to say today, Michael. Thank you. Thank you, Tom. Appreciate the time. J.G., please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hey, good morning. My name is Jenna Glasser. I'm a resident of Mammoth Creek, which is right across the street, right across Old Mammoth Road from the proposed development zone. And I just want to raise the concern.
1:07:35 about the degree of development that the town is taking on simultaneously. I'm greatly relieved to hear from the Water District that there aren't concerns necessarily about our ability to handle water and sewage, but I think there is a lot of work to be done to look at the degradation of air quality, increased noise, the amount of traffic that...
1:08:01 goes on just from using that snow pit or from the period of time when they were rebuilding the sorry I'm forgetting the name of the street they rebuilt over in Snow Creek 5 over the last year there's been a significant impact to the community over here and I think that needs to be considered in looking at the phasing of this growth as well as what the town is actually getting out of it I think
1:08:31 We are at risk of really ruining our community and ruining the tourism that comes here given the overall degree of development that is happening in the town as a whole. And I think developing significantly in that Snow Creek area is a significant portion of that because right now we're talking about
1:08:51 Empty land, right? We're not talking about taking down a building that's an eyesore and building something else in its place. And I think there needs to be a significant amount of consideration and work done to ensure that the community is kept whole during the development. Thank you. Thank you for your time. No further comments. No further comment. I'll throw it back to Sweet Z. Any other further comment you'd like to put forth today?
1:09:22 Please, sir. Good morning. I'm Paul Bostwick. I owned 839 in Snow Creek 5, and I applaud you. I'm a past planning commissioner in the city of Anaheim for over 10 years, so I applaud your service. Two things. One is traffic. The amount of traffic is not dealt with anywhere that I see.
1:10:02 In the staff report, any additions to Old Mammoth Road, widening, traffic lights, anything there is not dealt with. I think you need to consider that. Secondly, the golf course is very important to everyone, but one of the things it says in the staff report is that access to
1:10:34 The public lands and the sure winds was completed. I've never seen anything completed with access to the sure winds other than the road out by the propane tanks that is not really a road. I mean, it's just, they threw some asphalt, leftover asphalt down.
1:11:04 And we still have a problem in Snow Creek 5 with people parking in driveways to access the Sherwood. There's another item. It's what happens when you get old. Oh, how do I get a copy of your presentation today? I will provide the presentation to Jamie. She'll post it on the agenda packet, but I can also get your email and send it directly to you. Thank you.
1:11:42 Thank you, sir. Appreciate it. Any other public comment from Suite Z? And I'm going to go ahead and close public comment. I'm assuming we had no additional via Zoom. Okay. Close public comment. I'll bring it back to the commission for any questions. I do want to just piggyback on one of that gentleman's, two of his points. Are we required to do any sort of a traffic study of that area and the potential future impact?
1:12:11 Yes, so within the EIR, there's a mitigation measure that when the, looking for the exact trigger, but it measures the level of service at the intersection of Old Mammoth Road and Minaret, and when that level of traffic hits what's called a level of service D, I can let Hais speak to exactly what level of services are.
1:12:42 They're required to provide a roundabout at that intersection. We went a step further on the phase one tentative map and clarified that it's the earlier of when that intersection hits a level of service D or upon or prior to the issuance of the building permit for the 300th unit that they're required to provide that roundabout at that intersection.
1:13:04 Additionally, as part of the final map for the 2009 tentative map, which created all the parcels for future development, they were required to acquire all the land or authorization to use the land to construct that roundabout, so they did secure easements on the northeast corner there, that vacant private parcel, they did secure the necessary easements there, so they have the available land to construct that roundabout when it's
1:13:34 necessary based on the traffic at that area. Okay. And the gentleman's second point, would you mind just summarizing when you say the recreational backcountry access has been completed, what that means? Sure. So they were required to provide an easement allowing for that use. That's when I said it's been completed. The town does have an easement.
1:13:58 That allows backcountry users to traverse that area. Obviously, the infrastructure has not been completed. That comes with the development in the form of trails and the multi-use paths that allow the public to use that. And then we'll have access points through the development out into the winter areas. And it's over snow. So it's, you know, certain points to the...
1:14:24 Visualizing geographic to the west of the hotel area, there's a primary access point that would be constructed allowing for that egress through the site out to that, the Sherman's area. And that future access point would include parking, public parking? Yeah, I do not believe there's public parking as part of that. However, it allows for the public to traverse site to get out to there. Okay. I have a comment on that with, I mean, we're ready, especially during the winter month.
1:14:57 experience such a heavy traffic on minarets, going up to the lodges, both on the main traffic light by the brewery and the traffic past the brewery, with 900 units being added, that significant amount of traffic that will be added, especially during the winter month, how, what are the plans to mitigate the traffic or is there going to be plans to
1:15:23 Put shuttles that would take people from that new development up the road because adding extra, you know, if you take, not all 900 will be occupied at any given time, let's say get at 50%, so, you know, 400 units, 450 extra people and some of them will have, you know, will be with friends and whatever, but even putting extra 450 cars on the road, like in the winter months,
1:15:53 How are we, like, what are the plans to mitigate that traffic, especially on the minarets, on the minaret road? Sure, so the EIR that was prepared that analyzed the entire project for the 990 units in the traffic chapter, analyzed all those potential impacts and proposed the required mitigations to ensure the level of impacts would be less than significant. So those mitigations include the roundabout at that intersection.
1:16:22 It envisioned it based on just the level of service. Like I said, we went a step further to require it tied to a certain unit count or the level of service, whichever occurred first. It also includes four transit stops along the loop road through the development. So when you look at the proposed road network for the development, the new Snow Creek Drive loops over and connects to the new fairway drive alignment.
1:16:50 There would be four transit stops throughout the development that would be serviced by the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority on a route going through that development. Also, the HOA for the entire development is required to provide shuttle service that residents there would have access to for getting to and from. It's similar to what they have at other large developments in the town, such as Juniper or Obsidian, where they have a
1:17:17 Kind of dedicated shuttle just for theirs. So with those mitigations, it was all determined that the traffic impacts would be less than significant. Okay, so the development will have dedicated shuttle going. It's not going to be the existing shuttles extended to that because the extended shuttles already when you get to the village, I mean, people cannot get on the shuttles because they're already so full. So this development will have its own dedicated.
1:17:46 shuttles going from there. That's yet to be determined. So we plan on servicing this area with town transit, the town-funded transit system. And anytime we add service, we have to evaluate the impact of the entire network. Just like when we added service to the parcel, we had to add an additional route to service other parts of town because that line was too long. It's too early in the process to say exactly how it's going to work.
1:18:16 Whether that's an additional route, changing headways or what that looks like. All we can say at this point is that we do plan to service the neighborhood with town transit, but it will not be a specific like concierge type shuttle service. It'll be free public transit. Yeah, but there is a condition with an HOA and there is a budget should there will be need to add extra shuttles.
1:18:44 There is a dedicated budget within this development for it. That's correct. So there's the public transit piece that follows a standard route with the hits the four stops throughout the development. And there was also condition that at a certain point that HOA provides that transit just for their development as well. Okay. Thank you. Just for the member participating members of the HOA. Correct.
1:19:09 And just for clarity for the public, the four transit stops you're mentioning, fellas, those are bus stops, publicly accessible bus stops. Four bus stops, two of which would have the full shelters, and the other two are just signed stops. Got it. Thank you. Any other questions for staff or the applicant at this time? No. Quick question. In your presentation, one of the slides kind of mentioned
1:19:39 Timeline, future steps. Would you just expand on that a little bit, how it pertains to the PEDC and Town Council? Sure. So for the development agreement, like I said, we intend to provide an update at a future council meeting. Then following kind of update of these comments, update from the Town Council would finalize the kind of negotiation points between the developer and the town so that everyone is at that point in agreement as to what's being asked for of either party.
1:20:08 At that point, it would then come forward to Planning Commission at a public hearing, so that it is a noticed public hearing. We'd be looking to the Planning Commission to provide a recommendation to Town Council, either in support or in denial, depending which way the public hearing goes. Then that recommendation is taken to Town Council at a future public hearing, and then at a second reading would be for the adoption of the ordinance to implement the development or to adopt the...
1:20:36 amended development agreement if it goes that way. Nolan, if I ask you to look in your magic eight ball, when do you foresee the time frame for this workshop and presentation to come before town council? Depends how the conversations go with the developer and where we're at on kind of all the negotiation points as well as the ongoing conversations with council members on any questions or concerns they have out there. So I'd say in the next one to two meetings we hope to have that workshop.
1:21:06 Okay. If the public does have subsequent questions that were not addressed today, who would be the best staff, town staff member for them to contact? They should contact myself. Okay. And public comment can still be submitted all the way through that workshop with town council, all the way until the final decision is made by
1:21:35 a future town council. So the PEDC will make a recommendation one way or another, and if that recommendation is of approval, then it'll go to town council for final decision, and public comment is still accepted all the way until that point in the process. That's correct, and the PEDC recommendation goes forward to town council either which way, if it's in support or denial, it goes forward to the town council to
1:22:04 and take that into consideration and make their decision. Okay, thank you. Last chance. Any other questions? No? Then I'm going to go ahead and close this. Greg, please. Just one real quick question. And it's only because I like your wife so much. Once all of a sudden done, I assume it's referendable? That's correct. That's all. Thanks. Thank you, Greg. Good point.
1:22:33 All right, with that, I'm going to close Business Matter 4.1. Thank you, everyone who joined us via Zoom or here in public. Your input is greatly appreciated and it helps form the future of this community. So thank you so much. We will now go to Business Matter 4.2, which is the selection of Planning and Economic Development Commission officers and committee appointments. It's something we have to do on an annual basis. But we do have three new commissioners on this.
1:23:04 on this body now, so I think it's important that we really clarify roles. So as the sitting chair, unless somebody else wants the flogging, I will be more than happy to put my hand up again for another term as chair. Is this obviously an action item, Nolan? It is. So we would be looking for a recommendation and then a second and then a vote. All right.
1:23:31 Would anybody like to take assume the chair position? No, thank you. Then I will entertain a motion for the chair as Michael Vanderhurst continuing as the chair of the PEDC. So we just look for either Commissioner Fleming or Commissioner Grant to make a recommendation recommending that Michael Vanderhurst be appointed as chair. I recommend Michael Vanderhurst to be appointed as chair. It's a motion.
1:24:02 Sorry, a motion. I make a motion. So, Lana, if you're in favor, it's either a yay. You second it or you don't? It's a yay for me. Okay. Jamie, a vote, please. Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Commissioner Grant? Yes. Yes, thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. Vice Chair, I do travel quite a bit for work. I will throw that out there. So whoever does assume the responsibilities of Vice Chair will be chairing these meetings at some point going forward.
1:24:31 Having said that, we do have a commissioner who is not present today, Dawn Veruck, who has sat on this commission in the past and does know kind of the procedure and the ins and outs. I don't mean this as a slight towards anybody else who volunteered to sit on this commission, but it might behoove us as a body to have
1:24:55 A seasoned hand guide the commission in my absence. So I would like to make a motion unless anybody else wants to discuss it. I would love to make a motion that Dawn Verruck is nominated as vice chair. I second. And I would add that I did discuss with Commissioner Verruck ahead of this meeting and she was willing to accept that appointment as vice chair if proposed. Normally if you don't personally attend.
1:25:23 You get nominated. So, with that, Jamie, may we please have a vote? Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. So, congratulations, Commissioner Baruch. You are the on-deck circle. So, we have to do, what else? We have to do the committee, the mobility and design?
1:25:44 So we have two standing committees and then an appointment to the local transportation commission. Those two committees are the design committee and the mobility committee. The design committee or both committees meet as needed, not on a set schedule. The design committee typically meets approximately four to six times per year and the mobility committee has not met since 2020. With that I would
1:26:13 You know, my recommendation is that we do appoint two commissioners to the design committee. However, I would ask that we delay any appointments to the mobility committee and the LTC. Commissioner Chang, Paul Chang, previously served on the local transportation commission. That recommendation is partly based on looking into whether we still need the mobility committee. Like I said, it's not met in over four years.
1:26:43 So I need to kind of review exactly what their original purpose was and if we still need that committee or if we can disband it. And then the LTC, really need kind of Hayes serves, that's his world is the LTC and I'd like to discuss with him more detail exactly what that role entails to then educate the commission on what they're stepping into on that LTC appointment. Okay.
1:27:10 So I would be looking to appoint two members to the design committee. Again, with Commissioner Verruck being absent, she did offer that she would like to be on that committee. She is a design professional as her employment, so I think she obviously would be a good fit on that committee. I would like to be on it as well, if possible. Can I get some insights on the roles of design committee?
1:27:39 Sure, so the design committee is primarily an advisory board that reviews primarily residential projects that are approved at the administrative level. They provide input on comments on kind of the design, the aesthetic, and how it complies with our design guidelines for various master plans as well as under our zoning code. They also then serve on what we call the advisory design panel, the ADP, which is a
1:28:09 A larger board have appointed the two members of the design committee as well as five additional members of the community who work in the design world such as architects, builders, professional designers, and that board reviews much larger scale projects that are coming forward for the design aesthetics such as
1:28:30 Large-scale hotels or major development projects. So both the advisory design panel and the design committee, like I said, they meet as needed. Sometimes it's as often as one to two times a year. Sometimes it's every month. It's really just that kind of depending on how many projects are coming forward at any given time. And it would be meeting time above and beyond this commission. Correct. This scheduled commission meeting time.
1:28:58 You know, the commission meetings are obviously scheduled every month on a monthly basis. The design committee is as needed. There have been times where we've met two to three times a month. There have been times where we haven't met for six months. But it is above and beyond just the regular commission meetings. Any conversation? Any discussion? Only two seats available and Commissioner Farouk putting herself forward and since she's involved in construction of the town already.
1:29:27 And Commissioner Fleming is, has been a strong member of the real estate within this town. I will not be contesting either of those seats. So I will let the ladies march forward with that. Would you like to make a motion? And we can also, I forgot to add, be looking to appoint an alternate too that would be available should either the two main appointees not be available. So that is an opportunity as well if you'd like to.
1:29:54 If anyone would like to make a motion or a recommendation for Commissioner Grand to be on as an alternate is that opportunity as well. I will take that. You'll be your truth. Then I'd like to make a motion that Commissioner Fleming and Commissioner Baruch are nominated as the two primary representatives from this commission for design review and that Commissioner Grand is nominated as the alternate in case of absence from one of the other two. Do we have a second?
1:30:24 And they second themselves. I second. Jamie, vote please. Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Thank you, ladies. I appreciate you stepping up. And I will like to say I 100% agree that we reevaluate the necessity of the Mobility Commission. It was the sweetest gig from this dais. Haven't met in four years, so that was amazing. And let us know about the representation for public transit as well, whether...
1:30:52 Haze, whether you think it's still something this community needs from this commission or if you think that time has expired and we evolve. Everything you need, guys? Yeah? Nolan, everything? Yes, thank you. Awesome. All right, let's move to the consent agenda, 5.1. Do we have enough votes to pass the consent agenda considering my two commissioners were... Okay. Then I would like to make a motion that we approve the consent agenda which consists...
1:31:25 The meeting minutes of our July 24, 2024 meeting. Do I have a second? Either one of you can second. Oh, we can? Yeah, I second it. Vote, please, Jamie. Commissioner Fleming? Yes. Commissioner Grand? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes, thank you. Commissioner Reports, this is just where it's your chance to kind of update the community. Keep in mind, we have one gentleman here in Suite Z, but we could have 500 people watching this on...
1:31:57 On our local access channel. So if there's something you'd like to bring up, maybe something in the community that's coming forward, an event, something you attended, I know you guys are new to the commission, but something that caught your fancy or something you want the community to be aware of, this is kind of your chance. It's a little bit more informal, but if either one of you, I'll start to my right. Commissioner Grand, do you have anything you'd like to report out? Nothing to report as of yet. Thank you.
1:32:24 And this would be, going forward, if you do attend a design review meeting, this would be where you would report it out. Okay. Anything you'd like to report out? No. I'm going to pass as well. Things are, yeah, I'll just say it's busy out there. I know occupancy seems a little soft. If you talk to most of the lodging partners out there, lodging association in general, everyone seems to be reporting somewhere between 10, 15, 20 percent down year over year. However,
1:32:53 If you're in town, it's busy. TBID is consistent with previous year. TOT is generally consistent with previous years. So tough to say why. Could be second homes, could be short-term rentals, could be full campgrounds. But the town is booming. So that's really all I have to report. I don't have any statistical analysis for the reasons for that other than waiting 15 people deep at Vons every time you go.
1:33:22 So with that, let's go to the director's report, and that would be Nolan. Sure, I just have two items to update on. Last Wednesday, August 7th, we had the ribbon cutting event and the groundbreaking for at the parcel. So ribbon cutting for the Sawyer of phase one and groundbreaking for the Kingfisher. I think it was a success, it was very well attended.
1:33:46 Variety of community members showed up to the event, so that was great. It was exciting to watch the enthusiasm and kids playing at the park. The PD ran out of food and they had to go buy more, so that I think means it was a successful event based on our expectations. They are looking, even though it was the ribbon cutting to kind of officially open the building, the developer and the property manager.
1:34:14 Property Management Company, Buckingham are just going through their punch list for the units before they're handed over the keys and move everyone into building A. So they're hoping the update I received at that was kind of by next week or by the end of the month, the latest, to be moving people into building A. So that's the 66 units where building B is already fully occupied. That's the smaller 15 unit building.
1:34:43 And then with phase two, they're well on their way with the grading that's necessary for that whole phase. We've also been told that the actual units, the modular units, are completely done sitting on their kind of holding area in Idaho waiting to be trucked out here. So it's exciting that
1:35:06 The kind of main core and all the actual structures are already done and they've just started grading at the site which just kind of shows that why modular is a benefit and works here. The other one is the town's 40th celebration is scheduled for August 24th. It's a Saturday, scheduled from 12 to 4 at Mammoth Creek Park at the Community Recreation Center. So everyone in the community is invited.
1:35:34 The full commission is invited to attend. There's going to be celebratory speeches from past town managers as well as the current town manager. There's going to be food and beverages available. There's also going to be an interactive kind of booth set up inside the CRC highlighting the theme of the event, which is celebrate the past, plan for the future. So it's kind of looking at
1:36:03 Kind of tracking along with the general plan elements, but also just with kind of everything the town does, celebrating all the past accomplishments, and then looking for feedback from the community on as we embark on the next 40 years. Got it. At this time, I'll ask my fellow commissioners if there's anything you'd like to have Nolan or Hayes or any of the town staff member, but primarily Nolan, to report out at our September meeting.
1:36:34 I personally would love to have a report out on the progress of Mammoth Creek Inn, and if it hasn't progressed to a satisfactory level, what our course of action is. I would also love to have an update on the grading of the Civic Center, the new town Civic Center, how that's going, if you're satisfied with the progress. It seems to be very busy over there. And I'm assuming the ship has sailed for our new commissioners if they wanted to have
1:37:10 Quick tour of one of the unoccupied units at the parcel just to see what that looks like. Yeah, I believe we can still get them in in the next, you know, week or so until it's occupied. And then obviously once it's open, if there's any vacant units, we can still coordinate with the property manager there to access it on the site. Okay. I would highly, either one of you want to see what the inside of one of those units looks like. It's pretty amazing when he says, when Nolan says they're
1:37:41 Pre-built modular units that are trucked in that makes it sound so utilitarian and bland. The units are amazing and they easily have some of the best view sheds anywhere in town. So if you do want to have a quick VIP tour, just reach out to Nolan and I'm sure he can arrange it. It's well worth it. It really is. I think Dawn's back today so maybe we could...
1:38:07 All go together. Yeah, we'd have to just bring two commissioners out at a time due to Brown Act, but we can schedule back-to-back tours, work around everyone's schedules to culminate that. And since you brought it up, Nolan, if all five of us attend the town's 40th celebration at Mammoth Creek Park and CRC, is that technically considered a Brown Act violation? It is not because it's a... Just do not discuss planning commission business.
1:38:36 Yeah. It's a celebration. You guys can all participate, but you just cannot get together and start talking shop. Is that pretty clear? Very clear. Thank you all. Appreciate it. And even though it's not the Public Works Director update, Hayes, a volunteer to give a quick update on Civic Center timeline. Oh, amazing. Thank you, Hayes. You're welcome. Anything for you, Michael.
1:38:59 Yeah, the contractor is doing a great job. We went from pre-construction meeting to breaking ground the following Monday. They mobilized quickly. They've been incredibly professional, got all their security up, got their trailer in, and have just going to town on the earthwork grading, building the pad. They've given us a three-week look ahead and a schedule for the season. They're going to work through their off-sites and their on-sites.
1:39:29 And then they're just going to walk away.
1:39:59 And the utilities in, and then they're going to go take care of their shops and for steel, get that fabricated. So in the springtime, they'll go vertical as soon as the snow melts. So they've got a very realistic plan and they're not going to be pushing up against weather in any way, say, any shape or form. So we're pretty impressed so far and glad to see this thing moving along quickly. Amazing. And pretty obvious that you're very satisfied with the
1:40:27 Progress, the pace of progress over there. So far, it's been great. And Commissioner Grand, you are familiar where this is happening? Okay. Great. The only other thing I'll ask for, maybe, Nolan, for our next meeting is, would it be possible to get some sort of an update on the renovation of the high school? I think that's the last campus of the three that is still a work zone. And I know classes start on the 22nd of August.
1:40:55 So they're up against it a bit. I know they don't want to have heavy equipment out there with kids coming in and out of those buildings. But I would love to have some sort of an update on what's going on there. It'd be great if the update is, we're done, we're out, Seacrest out, see ya. That would be amazing. But I don't know where they are, how far out, all that kind of stuff. Definitely, I can reach out and either provide the update or have a representative from the school give an update during that.
1:41:27 Probably presentation. Got it. Last thing, and I don't want to belabor this too much, guys. How is the progress on the dog park? Are you guys satisfied? Come on, work with me. They had some challenges last week with paving and their equipment. They'll be back tomorrow to finish up the paving, fog seal, the asphalt, and stripe.
1:41:57 We had expected the fencing contractor to be out Monday. I don't have an update on when they're going to be here to finish up their work, but we are very, very close to a ribbon cutting on that project. I would say it's within two to three weeks. Fantastic. And that will be something that the general public will be made aware of. Absolutely. As you know, we have a very keen population of dog owners in this community that have been advocating for a long time for that dog park.
1:42:26 Whether you agree with it or whether you don't agree with it, whether you think we're surrounded by two and a half million acres of national forest, but we do have a dog park on the horizon. Yep, and they've already been testing it out, even during construction. Thank you, guys. Appreciate it. With that, I'm going to adjourn today's meeting until our next regularly scheduled meeting, which is to be September 11th at 9 a.m. here in Suite Z. So with that, thank you, staff. Appreciate it. Thank you, Jamie.
1:42:54 Thank you, sir, for sticking in there to the bitter end. Honored to be here again.