Trails Committee
at 15:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
154 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:04 Yeah, we've had some regulars signing up this season, which is really nice to see. And Leah and Harry joined us yesterday again and got to see some of their work finished. And it's just nice to have folks along for the whole season. That's such a fun idea. I love that you guys are doing that this year. Way more flexible for people in their schedules. I think you want to get started with that.
0:47 The quorum, is that correct? Yeah, I was going to say, I think we still need one more person. Okay, I just heard back from Finley, there was an incident, he's not going to be able to join us today anymore. So if Dan can make it, we can have the meeting. And if he is tied up as well, we can look at rescheduling or push this to our next meeting. There he is. Hi, Dan. Howdy.
3:10 The show goes on. Thank you. Okay, let's get started here. Okay, Angie, we are all set to go? We are good on my end. Okay, great. Let's kick off this, the Mammoth Trails Committee for the meeting of Thursday, August 12th. We are starting the meeting at 3.07 p.m. We'll do a call to order. Angie, do we need a roll call as to who is attending?
3:53 We do. The agendas look a little different now, but yeah, roll call is kind of built into call to order. Bill Souser, I believe, is absent. John Connolly? Here. Finley Torrance, Kim just said, will not be attending. Dan Holler? Here. Elise Howell? Here. Caroline Britton? Here. Here. All right, thank you. Okay, great. And do we have any public comments right now?
4:25 No comments at this time. Okay, great. Okay, so we'll move on to item agenda number three, the consent agenda. Item 3.1 is the approval of the regular meeting minutes of, sorry, I think I'm looking at, of June 10th. 2021. Yeah, sorry, I'm looking at 2018 going, I'm looking at the right. Sorry about that.
4:54 That's okay. So we're looking to approve the minutes of the regular meeting that was on June 10th, 2021, and those are included in your packets. Would anyone like to make a motion to approve those? Caroline, if you want to reference lead point two, it is a consent calendar. Perfect. Okay. So with the consent agenda, we'll also include the fiscal year meeting schedule, the adoption of that. Would someone like to make a motion? I'll make a motion to approve both items.
5:26 Yeah, I would second that. Oh, she's approved the consent agenda on 3.2. Excellent. Okay, and I will do a roll call vote. The computer's acting kind of wonky, but we're going to, John Conley? Yes. Dan Holler? Yes. Elise Howell? Elise Howell? Yes. Caroline Britton? Yes. Thank you. Okay, moving on to item number four, the trails manager report.
6:05 And I'll let Joel take it from here. Thank you very much. Can everybody see the slide presented? Yep. Thank you for your time today. Just wanted to take a few minutes to go over several areas of the Measure Our Trails program this season, some of our activities. This season, with the host program, we're working with Mammoth Mountain and Visit Mammoth on Trashy Thursdays. So every Thursday,
6:53 We go to a different location that's heavily impacted by visitation and litter and clean it up. It's been pretty enlightening, especially in places like Comic Lake, but we've had a presence in the village and town and also at Trailheads. Here's a very basic graph showing some of the interaction activity. As you might expect, July 4th weekend was busy. Our highlight or our highest point was July 3rd.
7:23 With over 500 interactions. So we were pretty well staffed up this season for July 4th weekend. That was really nice to have that coverage this season. And we've had a lot of reporting going on as a result. A lot of the queries that people have are based around wayfinding and directions.
7:49 Where can I find a certain trailhead or a trail or how do I navigate between different trails? And then transportation, shopping options and other outdoor recreation options. Here's some of the reporting that comes in. We've seen a general trend of more dog owners having their dogs on leash.
8:16 Don't know what the cause and effect is there, but it's positive to see over time that at least in this snapshot, 87% of the observed dog walkers had their animals on leash. So that's good. But it only takes a few. We definitely see mostly hikers and walkers and cyclists, but you have to keep this in context. You know, we don't have a presence in some areas.
8:47 In the region, we have a strong presence in the Lakes Basin where only certain activities are permitted. Here's a couple of photos. We get a lot of photos from staff and volunteers. Clearly, we see a dramatic uptick in bicycle use in and around Mammoth Lakes. And we have identified a strong need for things like bike racks and working with the forest.
9:17 To try to hopefully address some of those needs. The Town of Mammoth Lakes Walk, Bike, Ride Action Plan does prescribe some of these solutions. So we can certainly leverage some of that planning work as we move forward. And then keeping the Welcome Center clean and the right photograph for whatever reason, we see a lot of trash. It's unfortunate, but we are doing a lot of work to clean it up along with other groups.
9:44 A lot of layers of stewardship taking shape in the Eastern Sierra. You know, we've been talking about the hosts picking up. We also see other groups and folks helping out. Our Adopt-A-Trail program is one of those layers. And this is a program where people can, on their own time, participate in this program. They can donate only or volunteer or both.
10:16 And this has been very successful, thanks to our good friend, Kim Anaclario. Terrific job. We've been able to install, I think, now all of our signage for acknowledgement of all the participants in the program. Okay. And we've had almost $15,000 donated so far. I consider that a great success. Thank you, Kim. Also, 250 volunteer hours.
10:45 Which is equivalent to almost $7,000 worth of labor. And so that's really been a highlight this season, I think, are about the trail program. Trail Days. Sorry, Joel. Kim, I had a quick question on the signs. So there's the business that is listed. And then who is the name? What's the reference of the person below the name? In this picture?
11:16 For example, our Mammoth Hospital one, there's a guy's name below us, so we're just curious who that guy is. Sure, so each trail has the opportunity to be sponsored financially or sponsored with volunteer hours. So we have a sponsor and then a volunteer for each trail. And so Mammoth Hospital is a sponsor and then there's also a volunteer that comes out for, you know,
11:46 The requirement is 20 hours a season and just does work whenever he has time. Perfect. Thank you. Yeah. That way people have the option to give money or sweat equity. Or both, I might add. Or both. Or both like the hospital. Thank you very much, Caroline. Yeah. Let's see. Summer of Trail Days. This program's been adapted from what you might recall.
12:22 In past seasons, 11 of them were three to four events, like singular, fairly large events throughout the season. This season, we've had trail days every week. Each Wednesday, you can work on a trail project with trail crew. Weekends and holidays, you can volunteer with a host and help us at trailheads and other areas. So far, we've had
12:51 Some pretty strong participation with a core group of people. It's been very good. Getting some regulars. Now they're pretty well trained up. And I don't really have to provide too much advice. As an example, yesterday I had a really great work day working with Leah and Harry in the Lakes Basin. And we had a really good day working our bodies on a hot day on a great trail project.
13:19 So far, equivalent labor values over $10,000. We did also have two large youth groups participate this season, which was also very gratifying, and they helped us to do a rough cut of the trail that we're really sculpting with our volunteers more recently. Does anybody have any questions about the Trail Days program before I move on? Okay, sign up with us before it's over. Great, great work on that. Yeah.
13:51 Traffic Study. So if you didn't have a chance to look at this, there aren't real big surprises. If you live or spend any time in Mammoth Lakes this season, you see pretty strong activity on the trail system, on the pathway system. A lot of people are choosing bicycles and other things.
14:18 Interesting trend. I know we've been asking people to get out of their cars for a long time. It seems like that's occurring. We are seeing an uptick in activity in places like the Duck Pass Trail, Mamie Bridge, and a few other key areas. Otherwise, it's pretty on par with last season, which when I say that, everyone...
14:43 You know, kind of looks at me like, well, last season was really busy. So yeah, still busy, I guess, is the message generally coming out of this. And the trend seems to be headed in a, you know, steady to upward trajectory nationwide with outdoor recreation in general, with a lot of the trends around, you know, bicycle and other gadgets expecting to double.
15:12 By the end of 2022 is what I read most recently. So pretty interesting to see the activity on the trail system. July 4th weekend, tremendously busy. One number really jumps out at me. You know, it's the Duck Pass Trail, 2020, 2021. Pretty substantial numbers there on a trail that accesses
15:42 Wilderness. Anybody have any questions or observations they'd like to point out? Anything meaningful that you were able to glean looking at these? One last thing to point out is we did add a counter in the Welcome Center Plaza, tracking activity there as one example that could help inform us to recommend better and more restroom capacity there.
16:14 Based on the number of people going in and out of there, things like that. This graphic shows overall the raw usage, so we can see the Lake Mamie Bridge, big winner in this data set that's from June 1st through July 5th. Questions, comments, observations out on the trail system? Joel, can you, it might be a better spot to speak to this later, but.
17:00 Just anecdotally been hearing some things about e-bikes and kind of how they're interacting up there. Can you speak to that either now or later? Yeah, yeah. Sure. May as well. It's come up. We have, let's see, there's different areas we can talk about related. You want to talk about e-bikes? You want to talk about bikes in general? What do you want to talk about? Yeah, maybe keep it broad too.
17:31 To kind of just how bikes are interacting up there in general and just if there's any concerns or safety things that need to be brought up or just your observations. Sure, I get emails, texts, calls on a regular basis from people, different trail users, some people, you know, letting me know that bikes are going too fast.
18:00 Some people letting me know that other trail users are ruining trails. It's just a pretty wide spectrum coming from each trail user group on any given day. On the bike area, I could say that speed is an issue. It is a continuous message coming in. That's acknowledged by the Sierra Eastside Mountain Bike Association leadership. They hope to engage.
18:27 In an educational program as a result. You know, so generally speed is the biggest complaint I get about bicycles, the Mammoth Pack Station has had issues with the Lakes Basin Path. I know Public Works got some signage up as a result. Things like that are happening. Overall, it's the speed, whether it's an e-bike or normal bike, we're running into etiquette issues and it's
18:58 Really across the board. You know, another person said they almost got run over by a pack of 20 runners that just wouldn't stop. And they're with their baby trying to take a peaceful hike. You know, and just different things like that come in. Everything seems to be associated with speed. Like every day is race day is what comes to mind. The things, applications like Strava.
19:28 have enabled people to have races as individuals every day. It's a trend that's not working for a public multi-use trail system, for sure. I'm getting the feedback from other trail users, hikers, mountain bikers, equestrians, alike. Nobody seems to want to share the trails. That's been made clear. However, I'd say that
19:59 80 to 90% of trail users who are happily using trails and practicing good etiquette, they don't bother to call me, right? I'm not getting a plethora of calls from people saying, boy, I just had the best hike out there and nobody bothered me. And so I'm trying to keep it in perspective that I'm only receiving the negativity mostly and that a lot of the positive trail experiences are quietly being had out on the forest.
20:29 Sorry for going on a little too long. Oh, thanks. That's good. Good insight for sure. Let's see. That completed that part of the agenda, the trail manager report. I do have a couple of other items I know I think that are called out distinctly on the agenda. Can I just ask a quick question, Joel? Of course.
21:08 So you say, you know, this trend is not really working for multi-use trails. What's your idea moving forward? Or, you know, I know you've talked to Simba and they plan to have some sort of educational program to reach out to the bikers and just probably all user groups. But what are you thinking, what is our role in that, the trails committee, as we move forward making more trails in our area? This is,
21:38 This is tricky. Years ago, I was in a training around, you know, trails planning, design and construction and management. And the person who had years and years of experience was explaining that, you know, designing and building and maintaining trails is really great and you can really get quite good at it.
22:07 You know, pretty easy for him to do. He loved it. He loved the work. But that the social part of, Jamie, can you turn that off, please? Yeah, sorry about that. The social part of trail system management, he had no answer for at that point in his career. What he was trying to tell us as a group, you know, was that that social human part of this is a heavier lift.
22:36 Then just go fix it or just put up a sign, you know, just go build it. I can take a set of plans and make sure that I install a bridge properly. Trail etiquette and human interaction is pretty elusive, I'm finding, and we do have a lot of signage out. We do have hosts out on the system. We do have what I think are
23:06 Thoughtful people in our community, skilled people that work for Inyo National Forest and other agencies, and we're still not able to regulate, you know, people's trail etiquette or even road etiquette. I was driving up to the work site yesterday, I was right near the Mammoth Pack Station on Lake Mary Road and somebody proceeded to drive what seemed like 60 miles an hour right
23:37 And I don't know how you tell people that they should be nice to each other. And that's, it's going to take a heavier lift than just the bike club and just the town and just the district or just the MTC, but to try to instill
24:07 Trail etiquette and kindness so that we can all use the trails together I think is the goal. I was part of a group called Trails 2000 in Durango in the 90s and that was why they were formed was to instill trail etiquette. One thing we might consider doing, I brought this up with a committee in the past and it's a lot to do.
24:32 But it was a really interesting event that that group put on, and it was a Share the Trails Triathlon, and it was around multi-use trails, and it was a triathlon, they called it, but it wasn't a race. Each team was made up of an equestrian, a mountain biker, and a runner or hiker, and the goal was to precisely hit or most closely get to the predicted time, not the fastest time, but whatever group.
25:02 Came closest to their predicted time, would win the race. It took the day to act out proper trail etiquette in the celebrations before and after. Kind of act out how you're supposed to interact with each other. You know, there was a raffle, barbecue, things like that. But really trying to bring people together to have an event to show that a runner and an equestrian and a mountain biker can be on the same team.
25:32 That ethos came out of Southwest Colorado. I've been carrying it with me ever since, trying to describe that multi-use can work. And I'm being flooded with feedback from the public that tells me otherwise, and I'm struggling with it. But I still want to carry that ethos forward to think that in the Eastern Sierra, we can practice multi-use on
26:03 Public lands that are intended to be used by everybody. It's a big ask, especially right now, culturally, it feels like things are different. So I need some help. I wanted to throw in a couple observations. And, Joel, you shouldn't struggle too much because, you know, I went up to the lakes basin on a busy weekend in July just to kind of see what was going on.
26:37 And there's just too many people packed into a spot with limited trails. And the main trail, you know, it's paved and it heads downhill. People gain a lot of speed. And I've always noticed it was dangerous when I bring children up there. But I think one of the solutions is just completing more trails and giving the crowds more options.
27:06 to spread out because I've seen multi-use work but there's just less people on multi-use overall when it works. If you bring so many people up there, it's tough right now. You know, my biggest thing is I hiked up the Twin Falls because I wanted to see your work up at the top and the falls were just crowded with people.
27:34 They're in the falls, on top of the falls, underneath the falls, in the creek, you know, there's use trails going up on both sides, and it was, it didn't seem right, you know, to have, like, everyone in the falls, because, you know, it's kind of sensitive, there's a lot of plants, and, you know, I just know, you know, when you're around the creeks and rivers, you know, you just want to,
28:03 Be sensitive, but people were camped out and having picnics, you know, and there's just, there was a lot of people up there. So, you know, I'm sure you get complaints, but it's understandable. That's all I want to say. Anyone else? Observations? Mid-season observations around the usage pattern? I'm trying to tie this to the context of our traffic study.
28:38 that we were just talking about to kind of talk about, yes, there's your numbers and then we've got these etiquette issues around it. And just to clarify, so we would play as a committee, we would play a role in that along with the town and other user groups, but like what do you see our responsibility as we move forward in making trails? Do you see that as, you know,
29:08 We need to consider all of these aspects and the social aspects to minimize potential conflicts. And I know it's impossible to predict, and I know people are difficult to deal with at times, and playing together is a challenge, playing well together is a challenge. But just to kind of, if you could just reiterate what our role as a committee is in moving forward and considering all of this, and maybe even...
29:37 You know, assessing what's going on on the rock trail right now. You know, what can we do as a committee and what do you see our responsibility as? So from my perspective, as we develop solutions, recommendations, this committee, we're bringing forward to you, like, as an example, any signage that we deploy, we always bring it to this committee for
30:07 Review. We get feedback. We often get really good feedback about making improvements to the products and things like that. So you're a part of the product development. And I think signage is a good example of that, where we've consistently brought forward each piece of signage. Today I'm bringing to you an adapted type 2 sign. As an example, before we deploy it, before we install it.
30:37 So you can take a look at it and say, hey, is everything on there that you need? And so one example there, as we go toward trail planning, we're going to talk about the Sherwins and the Shady Rest in Your Craters. Both projects are in different phases of development, and that's where the committee can make recommendations.
31:07 Let's just give an example. In the Sherwins, we're going to be proposing multi-use. And there's a lot of lines that are proposed. And we work through that on the ground a lot. And we've made a formal proposed action for the forest. And along the way, the committee can advise me on how to change the proposed action.
31:35 to accommodate some of your thoughts. And that's how it's intended, to really be a co-developer, right, with us on all areas of this program. You've worked with us on webpage content. We've presented you with that sort of thing. I think of the committee as helping to vet projects and ideas so that we're not just doing things in isolation.
32:04 Very, very helpful. And then, most importantly, budget oversight, right? As we come forward each year with a proposed budget, your main role is to make a recommendation to the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board, and then they, in turn, make their recommendation to Town Council. If we need to reallocate quarterly to kind of tightly track our program,
32:34 That's another ask of committee members. So very much a strong budget oversight role as well. So I don't spend a million dollars on a bunch of rocks or something. Thank you. Let's see. The next item on the agenda, if you want to, I should ask if everybody would. Shall we be ready to move on to agenda item five? Yeah, would you mind saying the item out loud?
33:19 Sure. Moving on to item agenda five, it's the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation. Oh, hold on. And excuse me. We're still on the trails manager report. I believe we're on number three in your written report, Joel. So if you're looking on the bookmarks, it's four, number four. Okay. And then we're on three. Lakes Basin Trail names, Sharp Trail proposal, Shrek proposal.
33:50 And go down to number three, which the Town of Mammoth Lakes MLTS priorities for Inyo National Forest. Is that the next one? Town priorities? Correct. Which, if I'm not mistaken, to tag on to the last conversation was... I just don't have the agenda in front of me. That's all. It's in your trail manager's report. In the written report.
34:21 I mean the agenda itself, just so I go in order. I see. Now I'm looking at the agenda. Thank you. I need two computer screens. All right. I'm going to go ahead and share my screen again. Thanks for your patience. I'm going to briefly touch on our project, our construction project in Lakes Basin, where we've been working with some cabin owners and other stakeholders in the forest.
35:03 Will be presenting to the forest a recommended naming convention for our new trails. We also have a reconfiguration that we want to share with you, potential reconfiguration around the Horseshoe Lake Loop. So what you're looking at here is a current situation. You can see the Horseshoe Lake Loop here in yellow. And you can see our new proposed trails, like here's the one that goes up the waterfall.
35:32 In a 5% grade, you can see the switchbacks. You can see our systemizing trail along Lake Mamie and the blue line connecting back to Horseshoe. Here we have modified loop. So with our new trail configuration, we thought it made sense that the Horseshoe Lake loop actually be a real trail loop. Right now it uses a road connection.
36:04 With our new trail, we're actually to create a loop trail experience that goes back closer to the trailhead. Makes a lot of sense to us. We'll see what the forest thinks. And the names that have been suggested would correspond like this. With the current configuration, these are the suggested names and working with the cabin owners.
36:32 We're pretty open to name ideas still with the exception of the word waterfall. Nobody can call this the waterfall trail or anything waterfall. That was interesting to hear from the cabin owners. We got a lot of feedback. Interesting to hear what different people think about names. This is the recommended configuration from our team. This last slide where we have the trail loop and we have
37:02 These names listed as suggestions. We're going to work with the Mammoth District to see how they like them. And before anything gets formalized, we'll of course bring them back to you before we order signage. Anyway, if anybody has any initial concerns or really good thoughts, you know, you can throw them on the table here, but please send me an email. It would be really helpful to capture.
37:34 Any detailed thoughts you might have around or concerns around names or concern about changing the configuration of the Horseshoe Lake Loop? No, I think that looks great and no good names come to mind right now, but if I wake up with one, I'll let you know. It's tricky to put you on the spot. Next up, I wanted to talk to you about the Town of Mammoth Lakes priorities.
38:10 This was brought before Town Council after some time where Town Manager, Dan Holler, who I believe is on this meeting, saw him earlier. Yeah, there he is. The town has a list of priorities for engagement with Inyo National Forest staff as they have limited resources, human resources, and Sherwins Area Trails.
38:40 Are one of those priorities. And going through this, I know some of you have been around with the committee for a while and you're familiar with this project. But what this is, is the distillation of many years of planning where the Sherwins Area Recreation Plan, which is a part of the trail system master plan for the town, included these concepts from about 2009.
39:10 And now we're trying to implement many of those concepts. We have done a couple of phases so far in the Sherwins of projects out of that plan. This would be a third phase. And it's definitely the most ambitious. I think of this as the remainders from the Sherwins Area Recreation Plan. So it's all the rest of the concepts in this last phase. What's interesting about this is
39:40 The 11 miles of reconstructed user-created trails. There's a lot of use trails in that area. And then 11 miles of proposed decommission of user-created trails as we create some new ones. So a lot of this work is actually going to be, you know, a bit of a net loss in linear feet, interestingly. And I'll show you in the maps.
40:10 How this is going to look. And this is a little complicated to look at, but the data breakdown is in the legend. So those numbers I just read off are reflected in this legend here where we have new trail construction, reconstructed use trail, a new wider trail, 16 inch tread, and then also decommission of 11 miles.
40:38 This second map shows in blue the existing user-created trails in the Sherwins that were GPS many years ago. I know there's some more miles that have been created since and just not GPS'd. And then you also see the note of our trailhead where NEPA has been complete in a previous phase. This project, as it's been prioritized,
41:09 I've also met with international forest archaeologists. I was working in the field with them in the lakes basin recently and was able to talk to them about this project and others. And they seem pretty anxious to get going with this and getting it into their program of work. So that was very good to hear from the archaeology team. Does anyone have questions about the Sherwin's proposal that town council
41:39 has asked to be prioritized. I'll just make a quick comment, Joel. It's wonderful to see this moving forward because I think, if I'm not mistaken, this committee recommended this as a priority for you to pursue, to move it up through town, and it has, and now it's going to the Forest Service. So thank you. It's great. Elise, Andrew.
42:10 Yeah, I just want to speak on behalf of a lot of equestrians in the area. Historically, these trails are user-made trails and primarily by equestrians. And I've been riding horses and mountain biking and hiking for the last 20 years in Mammoth. And 90 to 95% of the users on most of these small trails have been equestrian over the years.
42:40 That's been my experience. I think we need to be very careful, and I know that I've expressed this in past meetings, and I've had a conversation with Dan Holler about it after a meeting regarding moving, inviting bikes into an equestrian dense area, if I can say that. And I think there are just a few things that I want to point out that are really important to me. Like this is the only area in Mammoth.
43:10 where we can have horses. There are no other areas on the Forest Service where short-term or long-term boarding can take place. There's one other place, and I think it's actually Madera County down in Agnew Meadows where there's horse camping. But, you know, aside from the pack stations, which are completely separate, this is the only place where we can have short-term or long-term horses. So horses are concentrated in this area.
43:41 And I think we just need to tread really lightly. It's, you know, what we've seen with the rock trail, and I know that you've had multiple letters coming in from equestrians regarding the new part of the rock trail and decommissioning the old rock trail and how that has affected the equestrian community. And I think we just need to be really sensitive as we move forward and careful. And like you said, you know, you can't control drivers, you can't control the social experience.
44:10 experience. But what's inconvenient in a car or on a bike can be deadly on a horse. And I think we really need to understand that when we're moving forward here. So I don't know if anyone else has any comments about these trails, what your experience has been on these trails, how often you've been on them, what you've seen. But as a 20-year user, like on a daily basis every summer.
44:37 This has been 90 to 95 percent equestrian. And I think it's going to be a challenging move forward. So I think we need to take that into consideration. I'd love to hear other people's feedback on that. Well, I'll jump in. I also use the trails, you know, daily as I was, you know, working at the town offices. You know, not so much in the summer, but spring and fall.
45:12 Every lunch break was, you know, pretty much a bicycle ride, but I only ride on the new segments that, you know, were recently built, and sometimes, you know, I'll go up the rock trail, you know, from the bottom, but I mostly see bikers out there, and once in a while, you know, maybe once a week I'd come across some equestrian, but yeah.
45:42 We use the rock trail for mountain bike camps. And one time we were coming down and horses were coming up. But, you know, we're going real slow because we have, you know, young children. So we're able to just get off the trail and take a break and, you know, watch the horses come by. But I notice people do race on the rock trail and try to generate speed going downhill.
46:13 So, you know, hopefully they keep a good line of sight. But I would think, you know, areas that are flatter, closer to the creek, you know, maybe there's more horses on those trails. But I see them all over and, you know, they're kind of trails are trailblazed all over and I never see another mountain biker just because they don't know it exists.
46:43 And I've been seeing even new trails further down by, you know, the Laurel Mountain Road. So, you know, as I said before, if there's a lot of space for people to spread out, you know, that's what I kind of like. You know, if we only had the Mammoth Rock Trail, you know, that's, it puts a lot of different users on one downhill trail, which isn't ideal. And so the more trails.
47:12 I think the better my two cents. Thanks, John. Interesting things for us to consider as a thoughtful group. So, Elise, I think you're referring, when you say 95% equestrian use, you're likely referring to a lot of the user trails in the eastern area that we're looking at on the map, right next to Sierra Meadows, and then it goes out to the east and winds up toward the
47:45 Sherwin-Valentine area, right? Yes. Yeah. So I agree. Those, right? And to the Forest Service, they don't exist today because they were never, nobody ever proposed them in a formal way. Nobody ever said, let's take these in, let's put signs up or let's put them on a map. And there's other trails like this in the International Forest too. I was at a meeting in Shady Rest for the Shady Rest Inyo Craters planning effort. And
48:14 And a wide array of users. And there's a lot of bootleg or, you know, not legally formalized trails out there as well, where, you know, the dirt bikers like to go and they feel the same kind of threat where I got feedback, strong feedback from a dirt biker who simply will not share trails with anybody. And they own those same, they own that single track and they,
48:44 Just simply can't fathom the idea of allowing even somebody walking or a horseback rider or a mountain biker on that same trail, even though it was illegally created in the first place. A lot of this doesn't make sense to me because I go by the book. And the book says a lot of things that aren't in reality, right? The book says that those user-created trails aren't part of the system and can't maintain them, can't manage them.
49:13 Can't send people out there. And we think they're equestrian trails, but are they really? Can anybody actually go out there and use it? Probably. And then the same would apply for the trails out in the OHV zone, that the other person had that perspective of, you know, how dare anyone else come and get on that trail between Shady Rest and Inyo Craters. And then from the Mammoth District perspective,
49:43 They don't take responsibility for it other than to say it shouldn't exist. And wow, we didn't know it was there. Maybe we should shut it down. Maybe we should close those trails since they shouldn't exist. It's an interesting juggling act. But the reality is that they exist on the ground. Carrie Wood, rec officer, worked with Sierra Meadows several years ago.
50:12 To come up with the design on the east side here. His perspective, like mine, is multi-use. He made it clear to Sierra Meadows that they should participate in this trail design and planning. He did not recommend at the time exclusive use for just horses. He didn't see that as a part of what the Forest Service does. That was his perspective. Sierra Meadows may want to consider
50:43 Some kind of use permit. I don't know. If they want exclusivity or the equestrian community prefers exclusivity in trail use, a mechanism like a use permit would work, something like that. You know, I'm a little up in the air and very open to suggestions at this point in my career. I have seen...
51:09 Trails succeed. I've seen trails fail. I'm seeing a lot of our trails in Mammoth Lakes fail right now as far as people getting along. So when I look at this map right today, you know, my instinct is to separate people out and get more miles of trails and have a bunch of big signs up that say you can't go here and this guy has to go there and you have to go over there.
51:37 You know, that's where my head is today with all the different voices whispering in my ear over time is that the equestrians want their own trails and they don't want to see a bicycle. A lot of the motor cross rider, the dirt bike riders don't want to see like slow mountain bikers on the trails or what have you or hikers and the pack station.
52:03 Would like to eliminate all bikes from the lakes basin is what he told me straight to my face. And looking at this amount of mileage, we might be able to work out a system of exclusive use just because of the configuration and the mileage. We might be able to figure something out to where we can separate out user groups. Well, I do want to be clear.
52:29 I have interacted with bikers, hikers, and equestrians. I'm one of each of those groups. I don't know that the equestrians, as a full group, I can't speak for everyone, wants to keep this exclusively equestrian. I have spoken to a fair number of people. I explained to them that, you know, these trails can't be maintained the way they are, you know, until they get approved by the Forest Service. I understand all of that. But what is difficult for me...
52:59 And I think for a lot of people in the equestrian community is as we invite more people on bikes into a space where there are blind quarters, where there are hills where you can get excessive speed, it becomes incredibly dangerous. It's not just, it's not an equestrian saying, I don't want to see bikes here. It's, I would love to see bikes and bikers when they see me.
53:29 to step off the trail with their bike or know what to do. And that's what I'm, that's kind of why I was leading into this prior to, you know, seeing this map. What is our responsibility? You know, can we, if, I don't think that we're going to stop this. I don't think the equestrians are going to stop it. I don't know that Sierra Meadows wants to stop it. And I don't see the need. The need I see is
53:54 Maybe we have massive signs that say caution entering equestrian intensive zone or something like that because you know I was looking at the sign we have that to approve later and there are bullet points at the bottom or you know sentences about who yields to who and whom and there's a little triangle and we have those all over and I appreciate that you've heard me and that you've put that information out on the trails because I think it's important but
54:21 This is an area where it can be very dangerous. And I know that as a user for the past 20 years. And seeing what has happened to the rock trail since it's been changed. And, you know, there are trails that I love on my mountain bike, the connector up to the rock trail from the meadow.
54:41 I don't write, I've ridden it on my horse once. It's horribly dangerous on a horse if I have a bike coming downhill. It's narrow in areas, rocks, trees, all sorts of things, drop-offs. So their build has multi-use, but they're not truly safe multi-use. And I don't want to see this area that's been historically equestrian turn into an unsafe place for horses.
55:06 Is that clear? It's not that I don't want to see, I'm saying, I don't want bikes there, I don't want hikers there. I don't want to see our little nugget of forest that is accessible without a horse trailer adjacent to the only place where we can have horses long or short-term in our community turn into an unsafe space. Moving forward, how can we make that happen?
55:33 Yeah, we're going to have to think critically about this with Inyo National Forest. You know, I've greatly appreciated everything you're saying. I've come to terms with the idea that, you know, we're just going to have to separate it out. You mentioned a big sign. Somebody else told me today, we're going to have a lot of big signs. Somebody else told me today that we have to put a giant sign at all of our trail access points that says no e-bikes.
55:59 So we're going to have a giant sign, poster size, that says no E-bikes. We have a giant sign that says, don't be mean to people. Another giant sign that says this and that, and it just gets out of hand. At some point, there's going to be like three billboards out there that says, please be nice to people. So I'm at a loss at this point as to what to do for signage.
56:30 If we go bigger and bigger, it's going to be pretty amazing the amount of messaging. Or maybe we communicate stop for horses. You know, maybe we, I don't know, but I'm telling you, you know, it's scary. Yeah, I agree. The other side of that, Joel, to be thinking about it would be in the design of the trail, if they're too narrow and you have like blind corners, so to speak, as we look to reroute.
56:59 Modify or work through and clean up the trails. Can they become safer for that two-way traffic? Yeah, horse coming up or down and bikes going the opposite. So if it creates unsafe conditions because of the type of use, if you have the sign that says, you know, give way to horses, but you don't see them until you come around something and the trail is narrow, we're just, I guess, the question of what it sounds like.
57:27 At least I could be wrong on this. It's fine to have them both on the trail, but you do have areas of the trails where the situation, the way the current design is, they are truly, I'll call it single track, whether you're on a horse, a bike, or walking, and therefore the visibility issues make it an unsafe condition. Am I hearing you correctly? Yeah, that's absolutely correct. And there are great trails. I appreciate where you have, Joel, where you've designed trails where there are a lot of...
57:55 Turn. So mountain bikers can't build up a ton of speed in certain areas where it's more difficult to see or steeper. And I think maybe, you know, taking all of that into consideration as we look in this area is, you know, super important. One thing from the mountain biking community's perspective, the feedback I get from them is that we only have 17 miles of multi-use public access trails in all of this area.
58:24 And that there are hundreds and hundreds of miles of trails for public access on a horse, where there are no bikes allowed in wilderness. So they hit me pretty hard on that, where they say, well, you know, in the 80s and 90s and 2000s, there was no expansion of trails as mountain biking came on strong, except for pay to play on Mammoth Mountain. So you either have to buy a lift ticket.
58:51 Or you're very constricted in a very limited trail system of 17 miles where a mountain biker could choose to go to Breckenridge and ride 812 miles or Crested Butte in an even smaller community with over 700 miles of public access multi-use trails where you can ride a bike. So that's the feedback I get from the biking community is, hold on a second, you know, everything can't be hoarse.
59:18 Is what they say. You know, they say everything's locked up in wilderness, hundreds of miles of trails, and that we should really try to provide more public access facilities that are truly multi-use in the front country near town. And that's to generally and to put it like sum it up. You've heard me say that kind of stuff before about the limited mileage. That's where I think John Connolly was making that point earlier about spreading people out.
59:48 That's definitely part of the solution. And I agree, Elise, I want a safe sanctuary for the equestrian community to have a delightful trail experience in Mammoth Lakes. Love to make that happen where aggressive mountain bikers don't make people scared on their horses. Jill, I'm not sure if this exists, but I have seen, I think, in some communities that have multi-use where it's...
1:00:21 creates more work, certainly for you and your team, but to have suggested, a lot of times the bike route is, you know, each user group kind of falls into their favorite areas, and a lot of times there's not a ton of crossover between those two. Sometimes there is, sometimes there's not, but maybe potentially outlining some suggested mountain bike routes versus a running route or things like that.
1:00:52 That's kind of been alluded to in the past, like as an example, the Mountain View Trail. People think of it as almost like a codified mountain bike only trail, but I'm here to tell you it's multi-use. Legally, I can go out there and ride a horse on it, or I can run on it, and that to me is multi-use. I can walk on it if I want to, but people call it a bike trail. Same with the Panorama Dome area. There's like a hiking only trail and a biking trail, but you can legally run on that.
1:01:21 Trail that says Panorama MTV Trail, you can run on it if you'd like to. And so you can see in the past, people were headed that direction. The issue was, you know, people misunderstand it. So on the Panorama Mountain Bike Trail, I was walking one day, taking photos, I was working, and I almost got run over by a mountain biker who was, you know, somebody I knew.
1:01:50 And they didn't know it was me and said, hey, get off the trail. It's a mountain bike trail. And so that's a problem. I was certainly allowed on the trail, but because it's kind of labeled that way, people think I'm not allowed on it. Our regulatory signage now reflects the legal intent of those trails. I think that in the past they were trying something, but it was like halfway, right? They went halfway with it.
1:02:20 And didn't go through the process. So it's kind of a putting Humpty Dumpty back together again. We have to figure out what the future looks like for multi-use in Mammoth Lakes. And I don't know that looking back is the way. Right now, I'm trying to describe to this committee, I'm completely wide open. I don't expect any solutions to come in this hour. But I'm asking this collective group to start putting our brains together.
1:02:50 To think about what multi-use looks like in the Eastern Sierra for the next 10 to 20 years as new technology takes shape, the electrification of motorcycles and ATVs and things. You know, what does multi-use look like from an equestrian perspective in Mammoth Lakes when by the end of 2022 we're expecting another doubling in bicycles?
1:03:16 What does that look like? It's not going to go away according to the data. We're going to see more and more bicycles on our facilities. I think that's fair to say. I can't even buy a bike for my wife's birthday right now. You can't get one. So sharing thoughts. Thank you for the brainstorming. Similarly, in the town priorities is the shady rest in your craters.
1:03:52 Planning effort, which is years behind the Sherman's Area Proposal. This one is funded with state OHV funding. And so far, we have done a lot of public outreach in pre-scoping before formal scoping. As an example, I recently met with a group from June Lake.
1:04:20 Getting this in the queue with the Inyo National Forest Program of Work has been a priority. I think that that formal action by council will work. I know that this committee's been tracking this fairly closely. Right now, we are collecting anyone's creative ideas about concepts between Mammoth and June. Right now, the strongest concept has come forward.
1:04:50 involves this line from Mammoth to June on the east side, and it connects all the way up on the east side of 395, and we're working on the ground today to make a key linkage right up in here by Hartley Springs on the west side of the highway, and then we're really starting to think critically about adding some trails to the mountain view zone. What could that look like?
1:05:17 What could that look like? And some more non-motorized trail facilities, things like that. I have also been arranging for one-on-one meetings. If any of you want to meet one-on-one or with a small group of our team, happy to accommodate that time. Like I said, we're very much in the project development phase. We'll be presenting a, here's the steps.
1:05:48 We'll be presenting a proposed action to the forest and basically creating a trails plan that the land manager, county and town can approve and or adopt as a trails plan. So far, let's see, feedback has been mostly positive. I met with friends of Inyo privately and publicly twice.
1:06:17 They love the idea of connecting the two communities with the big loop. We'll get into the weeds with some other areas of discussion, but generally speaking, they're on board with the concept so far, so that was good feedback. A couple of people on the June Lake Committee are pretty resistant to us, Mammoth, going anywhere near them. Pretty strange.
1:06:45 Most of the folks were very receptive, but a couple of tricky personalities that don't want any encroachment from Mammoth Lakes, but anyway, we can help with trails planning. That's where we can help with this, and that is another priority on the town priority list. Lastly, I wanted to share this draft, and this is just pretty basic, but for your awareness,
1:07:14 We have a winter sign at the Sherman's Trailhead today where there's an avalanche beacon checker, that technology and a sign and a map for orientation purposes. And we thought that it would be wise to put one out for the summer. I know that with the trailhead, we're going to put a nice type two out there, but this would be a temporary solution. We see a lot of people that are curious looking at the winter map, wondering where the summer trails are. And so this is what we would propose.
1:07:42 The backside would be the same as the summer map, a more broader view of the system. But this is pretty much for your awareness. Thank you very much for that time. I covered a lot of material. Happy to open it up to any questions you may have. No further questions on my end, Joel. Thanks for the hard work and appreciate the very thorough presentation here. My pleasure. Thanks, Joel. No questions. Just...
1:08:22 Looking forward to the next SHRIC get-together with the public. Yeah, November 4th, you know, and in between now and then, hope to see you out in the woods. Thanks for your assistance, helping Andrew out there, very valuable. John, thank you very much. You're welcome. Okay, we're going to move on to item number five, that is the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator Report. Excuse me, Chair Britton?
1:08:56 Before I move on, I do have someone from the public who's been waiting to make a comment. Oh, absolutely. Great. Julie DiOrio, you may go ahead and unmute. Thank you for your patience. Hi, can you hear me? We can hear you. Okay, thanks. I just wanted to give feedback. I have had my horse out full-time for five years out at Sierra Meadows, and I have 99% of the time found people great.
1:09:27 On the multi-use, and I use it a lot. I do the Rock Creek. Really, my only, and I know, I know, Joel, you're concerned about signs. My thing is that I don't think people understand when they're on a bike or they're walking when they come up to a horse. They don't understand that running at a horse or a bike coming up fast at a horse, they're a prey animal and that can scare them.
1:09:51 I see no problem doing it a multi-use out there. I don't think it's a big deal to put a sign out that would simply say, please stop if you see a horse. I've seen that on other multi-use trails. I think it's just a communication and an education for people. I really don't see that. It's a huge area. I don't see there are going to be so many mobs of people.
1:10:16 You know, that it's going to be a big conflict. You know, the downhill part on the Rock Creek, of course, is really is very dangerous for anybody if bikes are coming fast. So I personally just try to choose time on that trail when I know there's not going to be a lot of people. But I just think it's a general education if you're going to do multi-use around horses, because people just don't understand, especially like runners that come up and they don't understand.
1:10:40 That if you run up behind a horse, you know, that can scare them. It's not that they're bad people. So I'm sorry you feel like you've gotten so much negative feedback because I don't, I have not, I mean, I had, my worst encounter was with a runner, quite honestly, and a dog. So I don't, I haven't, I haven't found that. I haven't found people not trying to get along out there in the multi-use part at all. And I wanted to say that. And I, I think that area can be shared.
1:11:09 I just think it's a matter of educating people around horses. Because when you're on a bike or you're walking, you're self-contained. But when you're riding, you have a horse that's unpredictable. And that's all I think Elise was trying to say is that people just need to understand that. And if they don't, they don't think about it. And that's all I would say is just that it needs to be education around that when you're going to do multiple.
1:11:34 multi-use with horses, but I've ridden other areas with multi-use with horses, and it seemed to work, too, so I don't think it's, you know, something that shouldn't be considered. Thanks. Thanks for jumping on. We appreciate it. If there's no other comments, item five, Matt Perula is not able to join us today, so we will skip over that one.
1:12:06 Okay, skipping over item five and moving on to item six under policy items, item 6.1 to discuss options and provide direction for outreach to fill the vacant seat. Lead this to the, open this one up. Anybody, someone have any suggestions? I can just remind the committee of what's been done in the past. There's been, you know, sort of internal
1:12:35 Outreach slash nominations. Public has expressed interest. We've also done outreach through ads in the newspaper, like a public notice. And so I think really a combination of all three seems to reach the widest audience, the most diverse audience. So I think just deciding how you would like to go about
1:13:05 This next round of outreach would be great. Yeah, Kim, I think I don't have anybody up top of mind, so I think trying to get information out, as you described, amongst all those channels would be wonderful, and I think certainly as committee members, we can do our best to also try and engage with people that we think that might be potential candidates, but I think the more that we can do to get it out, the better. Excellent. Okay, so I will go ahead and
1:13:43 post that public notice that there's a vacancy, and if there is any interested parties, the committee comes across, you can direct them to me, and I can provide them information on next steps. Sounds great. Does anybody else on the committee have any comments, or? Yeah, we'll continue with that direction. I thought the process went pretty smoothly last time around when we added John, so I think I like reaching out to the community through the newspaper, online.
1:14:22 Great opportunity. Okay, great. And we will move on to item number seven, committee member reports. Start off with Dan. Thanks. No, I was just going to mention on the council priorities we took forward was also in response to requests by the Forest Service so they can begin to incorporate some of our priorities into their program of work versus being hit up by stuff kind of on the side or to the whatever. So this here actually gives a focus.
1:14:58 We included in that discussion a lot of other things that are going on. Did I get a package for Schneider's? Julie, is that you? The FedEx post delivered. Yeah, I was just going to note that because a lot of other things going on there, other work we're looking at, everything from our snow pit to purchase of the property around the airport. So a lot of different activities going on with the Forest Service, who currently, I think, do not have any full-time district rangers on the Inyo. They're all detailers or interim, whatever you want to call it.
1:15:33 Make the life kind of interesting. Excellent. How about, I'll go to John next. All right. Well, this is where I usually get a, you know, cut out when I talk too much, but I'll make it quick. Mostly just recreating in the summertime. Really grateful for having smoke-free for most of July, which is awesome. And I don't know if anyone knows, but there's a lot of websites out there.
1:16:08 I use Purple Air. You can check the air quality. We have sensors down in Crowley. They're also in June in Mammoth. You can kind of find the best air quality on those real bad days. Also, tonight's the last night of VC races in about an hour. So it looks like we can all be there. And lastly, I just wanted to put out there that
1:16:35 Mammoth County is doing a plan your park survey for the Mountain Gate Park, which is on the 395 right outside of Walker. And if any of you have ever used that park, you know, it's got a lot of potential. It's got a lot of river frontage. And it's an interesting spot. And the county is kind of planning right now. I think Matt Perullo is actually the one in charge of it.
1:17:04 There's a real good survey and you can find it online. So, you know, if you ever use that park or drive by there, I just suggest checking it out. That's it for me. Thanks, John. And Elise? Not too much. Just been busy out riding horses and mountain bikes and hiking around. I'm definitely enjoying the lakes on the paddle boards. And I don't know.
1:17:39 I can agree with John, having clear skies is definitely appreciated. So, and, you know, I appreciate, you know, having the opportunity to represent the equestrian community. I know it's a small community, and I just thank you all for listening and considering the concerns about safety. Thanks, Elise.
1:18:10 Let's see, my big summer biking event did get ruined by a fire, literally, but that was okay, less about me, and glad that everything in Markleyville kind of, certainly some bad things are there, but sounds like the town kind of came out on the right side, and I feel for the event producers, but looking forward to a bunch of good biking events coming up here in September. We've got the
1:18:39 We'll be doing the 50K on August 28th, which is going to be a great showcase and really showcases all the great work that Joel has done and a good tour of Mammoth and then the Gran Fondo and the Mammoth Tough. So definitely looking forward to some good biking. So that's kind of my plan for the next couple of weeks. With that said, does anybody have any requests for future agenda items? I don't.
1:19:14 I don't either. I'm just looking forward to having another person fill our seat here. So hopefully we can maybe make that happen by the October deadline or our next meeting. And with that said, our next meeting will be held on October 14th. And we will look forward to seeing everyone then, or if not before. And Angie, I will say that our meeting is adjourning at 4.23 p.m. Thank you, everyone. Thank you.
1:19:47 Thanks, Caroline. Thanks, everyone. Thank you.