TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2025

Mammoth Lakes Recreation

at 15:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

220 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:53 Angela is, and here we go. I'd like to call to order this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board of Directors. Today's Tuesday, September 9th, 2025, and it is 3 o'clock. And let's start off with, oh, I should probably make the announcement that Brent Truax will be attending this meeting remotely from the following address, 158.

1:23 And so, but Angie, could we do a roll call, please? Yes. President Albright? Here. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Here. Secretary Torrance? Here. Board Member Wasserman is absent. Board Member Truax? Here. Board Member Pasqua? Here. Board Member Kuznitz?

1:54 Here. Thank you. Awesome. And we'll start off with any public comment we may have. There's a time during our meeting when people can address the board with any issues of note. Mr. Brown. Not issues, but excitement. Ah, exciting issues. Thank you for the introduction, Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation Director.

2:21 I just wanted to share with you that the LA Kings Ice Rink CRC, your Measure U Funded Facility, was the featured ice rink of the Ice Rink Magazine, which is the national publication for rink magazines in the country. So this was the July-August edition. I have copies. If you do want to peruse, we have a great little feature. It's a nice little kind of photos from all our team.

2:44 And again, this goes around the country, so certainly great recognition for our wonderful facility. So yeah, just wanted to share that with you. I'll come up and give you some copies. Cool. Congratulations on that. Congratulations. Yeah, thank you. Thank you. Excited. And Angie, do we have any other public comments via email or calling in? No comments at this time. Okay, great.

3:20 We will move on to our consent agenda, which only has one item, the approval of the minutes from the June 5th special board meeting. Do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda? I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Move by Schaubmeyer. Do I have a second? Second. And Truax second.

3:50 Any further discussion? Seeing none, Angie, can we do roll call, please? President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Yes. Secretary Torrance? Yes. Board Member Tuax? Yes. Board Member Pasquale? Yes. And Board Member Cousness? Yes. Thank you. And motion approved. What have we got? 6-0 today? 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. Yep. And so moving on to

4:19 Item four, policy matters, and 4.1, Mammoth Lakes Recreation appointments to the Parks and Rec Master Plan Advisory Committee. Who's going to take us from here? I will volunteer to go at this time. You got a good one over there? It's pretty loose. Yeah, pretty loose, so thank you. Hopefully you've had a chance to kind of read the brief staff report.

4:48 Just a little bit of background, right, we adopted a park and rec master plan in 2012. The public outreach and community assessment was undertaken in 2008, so it's 17 years old. Certainly passed its useful life, and if you had a chance to obviously get around the community, see all the wonderful amenities the town has been kind of investing in and building, such as our wonderful community recreation centre, you can see that the plan has passed its useful life.

5:16 It is also an element of the general plan, right? So the process is kind of twofold, threefold, if you follow me along. So most municipalities undertake a master planning process, and that's typically a plan that would kind of outline a roadmap for recreation amenities, programs, capital improvements, you know, so forth, over a 10, 15, 20 year period. We're certainly going to undertake that. So that's certainly how the community would like to invest in its future.

5:46 Perfect. The second half of what this effort is, is kind of updating that general plan element. We are open space, recreation and parks. And again, that general plan was updated in 2007. So this process will sequentially update that element to the general plan, right? So we kind of write that in together. Part of that is updating the general plan to say, we would like to update elements.

6:12 of parks and recreation a little bit more frequently than every 20 years. So what we'd like to do is produce kind of a strategic action plan, right, that would kind of summarize the phases of the short, medium, long-term goals and objectives of the master plan into more bite-size, relevant, manageable outcomes, if that makes sense, right. So this general plan is going to come forward with a strategic action plan and then recommend

6:38 a subsequent one every kind of five years after that, right? So we don't want to get into a point of spending, this is a $300,000 commitment to produce a wonderful document and have it kind of sit on the shelf, right? That's not what we're about, right? We are an action-orientated, right? Community. And also with this document, we're looking at some conceptual sites or opportunity sites, which is kind of what we're calling them, right? So

7:02 We have the wonderful bell-shaped parcel right in the middle of town. Everybody always wonders what we're going to do with that. That's a large open space area. We have our community center park up there in the village, which is kind of more of our neighborhood park. And then we have a really intriguing opportunity down at Whitmore. We're in kind of negotiations right now, or probably not negotiations, but just through a lengthy process with LADWP to a kind of extend.

7:29 The acreage from 32 to 110 acres down at Whitmore. So a significant site opportunity, not only for the town, but for the community in our region to expand kind of recreation. As you know, town has a finite amount of land, but this would give us an amazing opportunity in the future. So this master plan is going to kind of look at that as well. But to kind of narrow it down, what we're really making sure that one,

7:54 We've selected a consultant. We went through a really rigorous, demanding kind of selection process. We had eight submittals. We got it down to six. We got it down to two. And we had council agree to the terms last week with a firm in San Diego called KTUA. And we went with that firm for a number of reasons. But the selection committee across the board said they were probably the best fit, the most aligned.

8:20 had the most, I think, distinct and diverse community engagement plan, the most robust, right? I mean, building a foundation for our future really requires leaning in and understanding what our community wants and desires. So we're really excited. I have this little thing here I can kind of share with you, but this is kind of what they provided in the shape of the snowboard, really cool. But what really won us over was just their level of personal attention to Mammoth Lakes, their personal...

8:47 association with Mammoth Lakes. Their proposal had photos of each and every one of the project team in and around Mammoth Lake. So they spent a lot of time here, they're vested here, they love it here, and it really showed with their kind of presentation. So really fun, we're really excited to get into it, and to help the town through this process, which will be probably 12 to 18 months, I mean the plan is not going to be done until next year, at the end of November, December-ish, we've formed this advisory committee.

9:16 So it's a Town Council appointed Brown Act Advisory Committee. That would meet, we believe, once a quarter. So over the duration of this process, probably at least six times. You can kind of see how we kind of put the composition of the Advisory Committee together. You can see it kind of all rolls up to Town Council. There's two Town Council representatives already. We have two Parks and Recreation Commissioner representatives. We're looking for, and when I say,

9:45 Two representatives. We have a primary and we have an alternate. So we're looking for a primary today and as a backup, we are looking for that alternate. Again, about four to six meetings. Planning Economic Development Commission, we have those representatives. School district, this is really important, right, to make sure that we're really reaching the community. We want to make sure the school district is part of that. MLT, and then we have applications out right now for our community at large.

10:14 And you can kind of see the organizational chart there that were put together illustrated in the staff report. So really it's a way to provide both up and down direction to not only the consultants but to the town's community, town's technical team which is myself, Nolan and Hayes. So as an MLR representative you would represent not only your organization

10:38 But organisations that you share and sponsor and fund and represent, if that makes sense, right? So all your Measure U recipients, you know, any Measure R recipients, those type of things. So you're kind of making sure that you're speaking in your one voice and pushing it up through this kind of advisory committee format. It's a very diverse committee, you can see. Again, we're pretty excited about how the...

11:05 The process is going to roll along. And then the way we're kind of framing this, the town has many plans, right? Lots on shelves. But really the goal here is to try and build a template and a framework to update these future plans in the future. So this is the first one off the kind of the list. So we're really looking to kind of build a framework that we can kind of use in subsequent plans. So depending on how this goes, we'll kind of zig and zag, you know, improve, change, adapt.

11:34 Pivot, which is that word from COVID, don't want to use that really much anymore, but really just make sure we're very agile and adaptable as this process moves along, with the outcome being a wonderful park and recreation master plan and a future template to update our kind of general plan goals in our lines. So, Chair, that is the introduction. I'm happy to answer any questions. Is there, what is the community outreach process?

12:05 for what the community is looking for for the next 10 to 15, 20 years. Yeah, so thank you. Great question. And again, we have a draft engagement plan that I can share with you. They're actually going to start at the Winter Expo. They're going to kind of launch the master plan there. And really their approach has been we go where the people are, right? So there'll certainly be the traditional surveys. You'll certainly get, you know, a sample size.

12:31 The RRC company from Colorado, Market Research, kind of putting that together. They'll do a lot of ski resort stuff. So they're doing that kind of statistical survey, statistically relevant survey, which is really important. They're also doing a lot of pop-up events, right? So, for instance, you know, where the expo is or summer events or, you know, whatever winter events. And because Mammoth Lakes, it's a probably innocuous question, Heather, but I'm going to give you kind of the long answer, if that's okay.

12:58 So Mammoth's demographics are pretty distinct and diverse, right? So we have residents, non-resident stakeholders, transient workforce, second homeowners, right? We mentioned visitors and our stakeholders. So, you know, six to seven different demographics we want to reach. So that plan is built to reach each and every one of those demographics. So it's going to be pretty... That was going to be my next question is who are we building these for? Yeah, pretty reverse. We're building it for the community, clearly. But we need to make sure that we're hearing, you know...

13:25 all of the voices and all of the kind of the needs and desires of our community and also those demographics. But at the end of the day, this is Town of Mammoth Lakes Parks Recreation Master Plan that built and accommodates and puts together, basically at the end of that plan, level of service recommendations for each one of those kind of demographics over time. So park acreage, amenities, things like that. So hopefully that answered that question. Yeah.

13:54 And then that process again will take, you know, we'll start in October and then that engagement process is probably not going to wrap up until May because as we know we're a very seasonal based community. So we want to make sure we're reaching folks here in the fall, winter and spring and then kind of leads into summer, right? Because we have different clientele that are here. But again, it's really driven to make sure that every one of our community

14:19 Members has an opportunity, and this firm are all, the majority are Spanish speakers, so they'll be here, you know, everything will be bilingual, they'll be here in person, everything will be translated, you know, the website's already, you know, getting billed flies, everything like that, so again, it's a pretty heavy lift, but we're really excited, yeah. Thanks for the question. Yeah, absolutely. Anybody else? Any other questions? Just curious about, I would assume the alternate is just there,

14:51 If the primary is, can no longer serve, they're already, that we don't waste any time trying to find, or are they involved in the process along the way? Yeah, it's a great question. Essentially that would be, you know, if your representative couldn't attend the next meeting, they would jump in their place. Jump in there. But again, the alternate would be that primary contact for your organization for Mammoth Lakes Recreation.

15:19 It's not like a one and done type of thing, right? If you have to miss, you have to miss. That's fine. And then, for instance, you know, we want to try and keep the number down as much as we can, but we're certainly, at any opportunity, happy to meet with the alternate to provide any updates, you know, to that process if they feel like they, you know, would like to really be involved.

15:41 More than what's available with this kind of format. It's also something we can add to our agenda to just kind of give the board an update just so we kind of know what's going on. Which would be great. To get the communication going in case two people get hit by a bus. I'll certainly come to provide public comments first to the board. You can see all these organizations. Again, we just want to make sure you can see the agencies, the organizations that we're representative. Really, everybody has a stake.

16:11 in that community, and our recreation amenities really wants to be involved. With everybody being involved, funding, what bucket are we looking at for funding for these recreational locations that we're not quite sure what they're going to be? Yeah, that'll be through that master plan, so the consultant kind of puts together funding strategies and sources, so what's appropriate, what's not appropriate. They have good access to what grants.

16:38 Might work. You know, they understand our special use taxes, how a general fund works. They've obviously, they've been into the CIP. They're aware of that. Okay. So, yeah, it's part of that process. I think that would also depend on what the public outreach comes back with. Where do we want to go? Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And just, and Mr. Chairman, just as a precursor to this, I'm ineligible to be either a primary or secondary in this regard because council's already involved in other conflicts I have.

17:10 Yep. I've already had some conversations with some people, and I've been asked if there's something I'd be interested in, and based on what I'm hearing on the time commitment, I volunteer myself to be a primary, unless somebody else really wanted to do it. Are there interests out there of people who really... Yeah, I'm also volunteering. I can be an alternate, too. Okay. Sounds good. Thank you.

17:37 Is that what you wanted? Does that work for y'all? It would need a motion because it's a the Bran Act advisory body. Okay, absolutely. Thank you. All right, well then let's do that housekeeping, I guess you would say. Yep. And so I would entertain a motion. We had Heather as the primary or

18:07 As the, uh, what is the title of this? Um, um, I'm finding it here. The appointee, that's the word I was looking for. And then Darlene as the alternate. So moved. Okay. So, Truax has made the motion. And do I have a second? I'll second.

18:43 Torrance second. And any further discussion? And let's have a roll call, please. President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Yes. Secretary Torrance? Yes. Board Member Truax? Yes. Board Member Pasqua? Yes. And Board Member Cousnitz? Yes. Thank you.

19:09 Awesome. And then, so the only thing I would ask is I've got a pretty jammed up October, November, so if you have any dates on the book right now, if you can soon, let me know as soon as possible so I can figure out what I need to move around or shift and what I can do. Appreciate that. Our first kickoff meeting with the consultant is September 16th, so we'll be scheduling the meetings and they'll be either the second or the fourth week of a month of...

19:33 Not in conflict with Council's meeting, like Council's the first and the third, so we would meet the second or the fourth of whatever that month would be that we're looking at, so. Just let me know as soon as we know I date on the 16th. Sounds great. Because those two months are pretty gnarly. Yeah.

19:50 Appreciate it. It won't be in December. I thought those were the shoulder season. No, those would be volleyball. Oh, that's volleyball season. There is no shoulder season for youth athletics. And then getting ready for the winter season for menus. This is what I do. Indeed. Thank you, Stu. Excellent. Thanks, Stu. That will be exciting to see the work that comes out of that. It's actually going to be really cool.

20:14 All right, moving on to Policy Matters 4.2, Fiscal Year 24-25 Financial Closeout Report. Kim, take it away. Love your one-pager. Excellent. Okay, so we have finished up Fiscal Year 2024-25 and presenting you with a high-level closeout.

20:57 of our income expenses and fund balances for our programs. I'll just walk through line by line since there's not too many and please just stop if there's any questions along the way. No problem. Looking at one of our largest buckets of sustainable recreation, we have a fairly decent fund balance in there. We had some grants come in

21:27 for a bridge repair out on the trail system that the Mammoth Lakes Trail System trail crew, Andrew and crew, are working on currently fixing a bridge that a private donor was very interested in making sure got repaired, so she made a donation. The trail system can then bill us back and the money will come out of there. This is also where the annual donation from Mammoth Brewing Company comes in for the trails beer that we do.

21:57 So that was about $1,200 or so coming in. So not a lot of expenses, but we do have money there to be spent. Same thing moving down into Adopt-A-Trail and Tangle-Free Waters. All of those programs are thriving. The two Adopt-A-Trail programs are primarily private donor or business donation based.

22:25 Not a ton of expenditures. Mono County did repair the boardwalk at Rock Creek with these funds. They used about $5,000 from their bucket. Tangle Free Waters has had some significant donations from the Mono County Fish Find Fund. We applied for a $5,000 grant, and that has really helped.

22:54 Ramp up new stations. We've spent this whole past summer repairing and getting the system right and tight, so we are very good at that. Disperse camping. We had a large donation from Los Angeles Department of Water Power, Friends of the Inyo, Convict Lake Resort, and Refuel Your Fun. I don't know if you all have seen those reusable

23:21 Propane canisters, like the little one-gallon size, so they made a donation into this program for our dispersed camping. Then our, you know, the Sierra Trash Eliminators and Winter Recreation, those are stagnant, still in the books. Those will be moving off soon. We'll use those funds. Last year, Community Recreation Center, those funds,

23:52 That is the Measure R special projects, so money from Measure U for the volleyball courts, the batting cage, and I think there's some mountain, or some bike jumps that got put, and then the King's donation, so that just comes in and out through MLR. Our Sierra Nevada grants, the planning one, I, you know, everything is still tracking on budget-wise planning. We just received an extension because the project got split up.

24:24 Again, we're going to extend planning efforts so we can still utilize that. But the implementation grant is about to close out. It'll be closed by the end of this fiscal year. And so the expenses are what has been spent of each grant. The Sierra Nevada Conservancy does hold 10% of any reimbursement.

24:52 So we have about $125,000 that we have spent out already that will get reimbursed when we finally close the grants. So the implementation one, which is the larger, that was the $900 and some odd grant, which will be closed by the end of this calendar year, we will realize that 10% and that will get added to our fund balance, which ultimately falls into

25:20 Unrestricted assets in our administration, organizational costs. And then the planning grant, that'll come, you know, when we do finally close that grant out. I anticipate probably another year from now. And let's see, community building, our education and outreach programs. Southern California Edison has made grants to us for these. This helps out with

25:50 Cleanup events, the Tingle Free Waters, we had to clear the line even at the beginning of the year. We'll have a sort the line event at the end of the year again. Administration costs, this is, you know, program administration fees that come in, grant administration, our services agreement with the town and any additional work. And then our expenses, definitely a negative.

26:20 Loss here, that does get made up with, you know, those SNC grants money that will come in and also down lower into our fundraising and other categories to balance those negative numbers out on the purely MLR side, not on a programmatic pass-through. So, fundraising just general, which is our merchandise and donations made specifically to Mammoth Lakes Recreation versus

26:50 the Adopt-A-Trail Program or Tango-Free Waters Program. That's the income expenses for that and our events, the 2024 Arts and the Fourth Festival netted about $26,000. So very happy with that as a successful first year. And looking ahead, the numbers aren't quite fully in for this past year's festival, but looking closer to about $30,000, $32,000.

27:21 We will be able to use for events and priorities that are for MLR. And can you speak to the lessons learned and kind of contrasting year one with year two from particularly the burden on you? We learned a lot. Yeah, so this year was...

27:50 Much more enjoyable to put on this festival because one, just knowing what to expect, having a relationship with the vendors that come, with the, you know, vendors that come as artists and then the vendors that we hire to help produce the festival. This year I was able to hire staff, I had an operations manager.

28:14 We hired a photographer, we hired security for the evening, so a lot, and a bar manager, so a lot was off of my plate, that all of that was what I was doing last year, and it allowed me to be more involved in the festival with the vendors that came, and develop better relationships with them, and get feedback, and it just made for a much smoother, more enjoyable experience, I think, for everybody.

28:42 I think we are all glad to hear that because I know it was, that first year was a bit of a burden and we were maybe pondering whether the juice was worth the squeeze, as they say, but it feels like that was, you know, I mean, obviously a steep learning curve for us, but something that we feel now, you know, we've got a little momentum, we know what

29:12 And that we intend to carry on with. Yeah, so definitely plan on 2026 at least. Awesome. Great, great, great work on that. Yeah. I just want to ask a question too, just because we've talked about it before. So looking ahead, is it still something that you want to see if you can find someone to manage the whole endeavor or are you, yeah? I think so. Not, you know, I think that's maybe,

29:43 Two, three, four years out. It's a hard weekend to work and I don't mind it right now and I think it's good while we're really getting systems ironed out and in place and then when, you know, I feel confident that we can tell someone else what to do instead of being like, let's try this, then I think it would be a good time to pass it off. But still retain it, not pass it off as in give up the festival. I think it's a really great fit for Mammoth Lakes Recreation.

30:12 But to hire more on-site management and more people to help with the production and overall organization of the event. That would be great. You know, and I certainly think, and I know maybe I'm getting ahead of myself a little bit as we talk about our, you know, kind of strategic planning, but, you know, it does seem like there might be other event opportunities that benefit the community, benefit our organization, and then,

30:42 an events manager who's potentially heading up a couple of these either throughout the summer or maybe eventually throughout the year could really be a great add to our organization and particularly staff to help you in areas that again free you up to kind of be more the face of the organization rather than the

31:12 Person doing all the lifting. Awesome. Now, good job for somebody who hasn't had Labor Day off for 11 years. I totally understand what it's like working at a holiday event, but the audience is here, and it's a great opportunity, and thank you for also letting us have a space for Mammoth Club Volleyball. We sold a bunch of snow cones and raised a bunch of money for those kids, so thank you very much for that. That was awesome. Forgot about that. Yeah, it was pretty awesome, so thank you. That was good. You guys had a great line.

31:44 Great line, and like I said, all the funds went straight to the kids so they can go for a big competition in the spring, so thank you. Awesome. Yeah, there's great community support for this event. I did notice, you know, there are other events, activations that have popped up over that weekend now besides the actual fourth, and that definitely took away from the festival, like in the late afternoons, evenings, like the, what is it, the Giddy Up Festival in the village? Yep.

32:16 Yeah, because it depends on where Fourth of July falls. Exactly, exactly. And so just, you know, we're already brainstorming ideas to bring people down, you know, something extra to do in the evenings, like a happy hour type of thing. Oh, nice. You know, some more live music, but very specific times all day, every day. Is there something going on over the brewery too, right? I mean, when you have Fourth of July on a weekend, it's just going to be busy everywhere. It's just different. And, you know, some people instead of...

32:45 Coming back multiple times, they, you know, hit the art festival once and then do something else, which is great. We just gotta make it enticing for all sorts of people to come at a different time. Yeah, and then it's gonna get weird because if I'm correct right now, I think 4th of July's gonna be on Saturday. I think we have two more good years. Two more years and then it starts to fall into the middle of the week and then that's when it gets odd. Yeah. We get 4th of July that's on like a Monday or Tuesday. It's just, they're just softer. It just is what it is. Yeah. So trying to figure out how to make that balance out.

33:16 Exactly. Okay. Got two years. Mm-hmm. Any other questions on last year's financials or how it all has ended up? What's that whopping $10 expense on that? That was some, like, filing fee. I just thought it was funny. Yeah. I know. There it is.

33:43 And what did you say? What was the negative on admin? Why was it so negative? I don't remember. It's just, you know, our, our, the income, you know, is admin fees from the programs, admin fees from grants, the town contract, any extra work, and a lot of that. So that's where we, that's the 114 minus.

34:12 Any Sierra Nevada Conservancy grants have not been taken out of the grant line item right now. Okay. So nothing from the grant. So any admin fees or that 10% on things that we have paid out. And so it will balance out to, you know, so currently as of June 30, 2025, there's $13,000.

34:42 Grant admin fees that are just sitting in another line item on our budget. Okay. Will that get corrected into next year? It will get corrected when the grant closes. So. Okay. Okay. I don't have so much question, but if it would be okay with the chair, if I could get sent afterwards, your expectation, when I talk about that at the town council, I just want to make sure.

35:10 Correct in terms of what is the reimbursements and where things are projected to land. Yeah, I'm sorry, I didn't quite understand what you asked. I'm just looking for, as you verbalize, with these funds that, where we have reimbursements and or expenses that will get changed. Oh, okay. I just would love a quick summary so that when I talk about it with council, I just have a very short explanation to add to that. Yes, absolutely. Perfect. Awesome. No further questions about

35:42 Financial close. We will move on to 4.3. Board will evaluate the performance of an employee executive director and consider approval of merit-based bonus and or salary increase for fiscal year 25-26. I wanted to start this off in that, you know, just

36:10 kind of lay the groundwork and Kim correct me where I'm wrong but this time last year we approved a two-year contract with yourself kind of to line up with our contract with the town and that our hope is at this time next year we'll be looking at doing ideally a three-year

36:38 Contract with the town and aligning your contract with that. So in a sense, I lay that out in that this is kind of a, yeah, half-time update. And, you know, I'll throw this out to kind of start the conversation going is that, you know, we haven't had the opportunity to get

37:06 The performance review materials out to you all. But since we've started the new fiscal year, you know, I think I love the board's feelings on, you know, Kim has done a great job for us. Do we need to make any adjustments? You know, I'm thinking along the lines of COLA cost of living increases, kind of did a little research on that.

37:33 at this point with the new fiscal year having started. But then also, you know, thinking of merit right now as some sort of bonus until we have a more formalized, you know, and this is looking ahead to potentially hiring more staff, is really having a more formal merit and wage and salary

37:59 policy for the organization. You know, we kind of ad hoc it every year and, you know, it makes it, I think, a little uncomfortable for all of us and we're learning how do we do this in this public forum and whatnot and to have a policy in place where Kim knows what to expect, we know what to expect as we go through this process and because obviously we want to provide good performance.

38:29 Feedback, and that's one part of the equation, and it really ties in with our next item as we really set a strategic plan for the organization, and Kim is the primary deliverer on those items and those measurables, but also that we're recognizing and rewarding our employee.

38:54 for that performance. And Craig, the same thing in terms of, I was curious because other organizations do it a little differently in terms of do the review in closed session, but no discussion on any financial or other remuneration, but they do the review in closed session. So I didn't know going forward what's the best and how we wanted to set it up because I couldn't find a policy on how we have done that in the past. We have done closed session in the past.

39:24 This year we're just choosing to do it all right now. I like it, but we have done it in the past in closed session and like I started with, you know, had a much more, you know, detailed and, you know, my perception was getting the feedback to come back was difficult and then tabulating it was even more difficult.

39:53 And it seemed like a lot of work for what I think it should be a pretty straightforward process that maybe we can take care of. I don't know anyone in this group of being particularly shy with their opinions. And so maybe I'll leave that as kind of a context to start.

40:23 Do we have particular items of feedback? And maybe I'll start with one, which is, you know, and we just finished talking about it. You know, what Kim took on with Arts in the Fourth, you know, was maybe overstating it, Herculean, she's small but mighty. And, you know, that this was an event that the community was going to lose.

40:50 And it was an opportunity was seen and grasped and struggled through and now has gotten to, you know, a much better place. So I would start that off as just, you know, indicative of Kim's always looking for opportunities for us to impact the people we serve. I think it's a great opportunity, as you said, tying it into next year.

41:20 I'm working out as we're working through this new statement about having deliverables and then being paid on those deliverables. And then for her to be able to plan, knowing what she, if she hits the deliverables, then she's going to know she's going to get X so she can actually plan a future herself. So I think that would be a wise incorporation of putting everything together. Other comments? So looking ahead, the next year when we start your three-year contract, then we would mirror what the town does. That's correct, right?

41:50 At that point, that's when we would do the 6% raise the first year and then 4% and 4%? That's how the town does it, correct? That is the current contract that the town has with their employees. That'll change next year. As an NGO, that's not a...

42:12 Comparable. I'd be careful about using that as a direct comparable standpoint. Remember, the contract that's existing, I believe, is up next year for all-time employees, police forces now, but all-time employees next year. And that's correct. So they'll renegotiate. Their union will renegotiate that. Correct. For a new three-year contract starting July 2026. But we'll be moving towards something more structured. Exactly. Very similar. And we can choose to follow suit. We can be similar.

42:40 Yeah, and I would clarify that. That was an example of what the town's doing. We should find what's the right fit for our organization and particularly our employee. And I've been thinking about this a lot because we're going through this on the mountain, this yearly exercise of performance reviews and merit increases. And there are

43:09 An unlimited number of philosophies on how to do this, and I don't think anyone has figured it out yet. How to do it perfectly, because there's not a perfect fit for everything. But I do, as Mammoth Mountain has went through many different evolutions of performance review and merit increases, separating the performance review so it's not clouded by

43:38 What number am I going to get? I think has certain merit and value in it that the review can be focused on deliverables, measurements, you know, what tools you need and support you need from us. That conversation can be kind of separated from and but tied to.

44:04 Performing on those measures and then here's what those will, you know, potentially, how that will benefit our employee. There's also this notion of, you know, kind of just a cost of living increase and should you just call it that? We're going through that at the ski area, you know, not having a fabulous year. It's...

44:29 Our merit increase feels like a COLA increase. And maybe we should just call it that, I guess is my point. And we can, whether it's the county or the state, figure out what their, you know, what that measurement is. Those are the opportunities we have to kind of create a policy that we all understand what we're, you know, the financial commitment we have to.

44:57 Kim and the fiduciary responsibility we have as a board and balance those things out in a way that's less ambiguous. And my question with that all is, I tried to find your existing agreement, Kim, but did we send any parameters in there in terms of any COLA or anything else? I was just trying to, as we talked here tonight, I was just trying to see if there's something I've missed in that.

45:27 No, there's never been any sort of COLA or any financial obligations beyond like the first year contract of salary, straight salary. Is there language in there that allows us to adjust remuneration during the contract or the contract states this is the pay level? There's room for adjustment. So correct me if I'm wrong because I may not remember this correctly, but last year I believe we gave you a 6% raise.

46:01 And then we also gave you, was it a $6,000 bonus? I believe it was a percentage, which worked out to approximately $6,000. And Matt, was that when we were catching up or that was catching up to the years before or was that because we were doing it because of the event? I'm trying to remember, I think it was because of the event. The catching up was our agreement with the town. I think that that was separate. We did the first year was a larger percentage of the three year. That was two years ago, right? Okay.

46:31 My brain's like, I know we did that at some point. Was it two years ago or last year? Last year is when we did for the event, two years is when we did the catching up with the town. Oh, okay, gotcha. So right now your position, your high salary, if you talked out, would be at $130,000, right? Correct. And currently, like when I'm jotting down numbers right now, I'm using $85,000 as a basis. Is that approximately correct with your salary? $85,685.65. Okay, I'm close.

46:57 All right, so, you know, I'm a math girl. So, when I look at your position right now, and my number that I keep turning back to personally is 6%. When I do that, that would be a $5,100 adjustment to your salary. I always like to see what that would look like for someone after we take taxes out just to see what you have to live off of. That would leave you with that $3,825.

47:20 Basically left for that, and then if I divide that by, I just divide it by months, I'm not sure how often you're paid, so I just did it by the month, it's $318.75. So I just want to bring that forward because I know 6% sounds like a lot, but when you break it down like that, you go, hey, it's $318 a month after taxes. I would like to do that and then follow up with a one-time bonus as well.

47:43 The reason I like to do that, and everybody could say, no, Danielle, that's not what we're going to do, but is because it helps to move you up on the salary schedule when your position's budgeted at $130,000. And how many years have you been doing this? In this position, I mean, I've been with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, January will be six years. Okay. As an ED, it's been four? One and a half. Yeah, I mean, I think...

48:11 Yeah. I mean, Matt left and it wasn't an official ED position. However, there was nobody else doing any other ED. I was going to say, there was the title and then there was the... The official ED job description began one year ago. Okay.

48:38 So what were you proposing? Sorry, my brain's right now thinking. That's okay. Usually a 6% plus what? I was looking at 6% and then I would like to do a bonus as well. Okay. What is the stipend for health insurance right now? $1,000 a month. And is that taxed? Yes. Got it. Got it. So that's essentially $600 change, $650? Okay.

49:10 And you said at the end of the day it's 120 and we're right now doing it at 130. 6% would be for this year. Then is that one of the things you're thinking about for the future, doing 6% this year, 6% set every year? Or are you thinking about making that as one time and then kind of see where we're at from there from the adjustment? Personally, I'd like to do 6% right now with a bonus and then come back to the table with a little bit more of a structured system that we can do if we do a three-year contract. Yeah. And I would agree with that. Whatever we decide to do now.

49:38 you know that we have a more structured and system in the future and you know the that idea that we would seems like from a timing perspective doing well I can I can argue both sides of this case whether performance review is best done you know kind of as we're

50:05 Seems like this time of year is a good time to do performance review in that we've completed our big cycle. The final numbers are in. A lot of our projects are done. A lot of our summer programming has been complete. That seems like a good time to do the review. Kim's anniversary date is in January, if I'm not mistaken.

50:34 To me seems like a great time to do whatever merit looks like and whether it's salary, bonus, whatever. And maybe there's, you know, as we develop the system in the future, maybe not for today, is that then we can plug COLA in during something like this time period. Because we know that's...

51:00 Coming every year when we go through our budget in the springtime, we know that now 2 to 4 percent is probably going to be cost of living on most years. Budget that in, have it go, start paying it June 1, or excuse me, July 1, and then do another, whatever that merit looks like, bonus.

51:27 You know, trip to Tahiti, whatever. I'm willing to know also as I'm looking at like the events line that we put that she has on here for the events for the 54th. So that is including the 4th of July and what else? Nothing. That's just 4th of July for income. So if you had an event producer do something, normally they would charge you anywhere from 10 to 20%.

51:50 So that's something that you can consider when you're looking at the income. I mean, that's part of what we did on our bonus set last year. Very much how I am kind of thinking about it. That's a great point. So I encourage everybody, as you're looking at this, for NGOs, nonprofits, the valuations for ED can't be based on financial performance. It's about their job done. So be careful in terms of how you phrase your portions.

52:19 Because the bottom line is, cannot be evaluated as part of the criteria. Okay. Yeah, good, good. It's not saying revenue, it's not saying revenue can't be talked about, but just saying, be careful about, as far as a P&L, it's supposed to be about the ED's overall performance based on what they did, whether it was events or other things. And how that aligns with what they've done for the year. Mission, strategic, you know, outlook of the organization, so good.

52:46 Good feedback front. Thank you. Absolutely. And I'd like for us to consider also when we're getting into this next stage is what does staff look like and how would that broaden what MLR can accomplish? Yes. And the one thing I'm going to contradict myself right now with giving a bonus, I would also like if possible to see as much of that money onto the salary schedule as possible.

53:08 Just so that moves to the future, you know, a bonus is just a bonus, but even if we gave a little bit less and it stayed on the salary schedule, I think that would be more to your benefit. I mean, there's, yeah, from a philosophical standpoint, there's, you know, those are the two ways to look at it. More on the salary side, it has the cumulative effect. Now, from when we're more in a...

53:35 More tenuous financial position. The flip side of that should be something we also consider is that, you know, maybe a one-time great event. And I think this is a little bit of the thinking last year, a bigger bonus because there was a whole new, you know, category that needed to be made. But we're a little hesitant to make that part of until we knew.

54:03 You know, is this thing going to be a success? You know, and so. So where do you lie on it doing a salary versus a bonus? I mean, right now, let's say that we did the 6% and the bonus, and we looked at what that is, like $318 a month. I'd rather see her get maybe 8% and bring down the bonus. It's still, for each percent, you're talking about $950. It's not very significant. Great.

54:36 See, my problem is I'm the other way in terms of given that we have a two-year agreement, I have a little bit of challenge going over COLA for the base pay, and I think from my standpoint that the recognition would be more into the bonus a little bit until we reach that next year when we renew that and change what that pay structure is, but that's just my personal feel on that. I'm not trying to... Imprint, I'll just... Real measure on it.

55:04 Just to add for everyone, because I do, I have the contract pulled up, the language says, your salary will be reviewed annually, however, the company reserves the right to change your compensation on reasonable notice. So that's up or down the way I read it. That's nice and warm. It's warm and fuzzy is what that is. You know, there is room for an annual review. Darlene? And where I'm struck, and where I'm struck, sorry.

55:36 Go ahead, Brent. And where I struggle a little bit is I think the agreement needs to be strengthened, as you said, for the future. If we had more clarity here, it would be very easy to say, okay, this is what we're doing, this is what the parameters are, and it's very vague, and that's what is a little challenging. Yes. And let it go backwards because we kind of jumped into the other side of it. I think Kim does a great job. I think many employers would love to have somebody like Kim who shows up, does the work.

56:05 Doesn't complain about anything and it's just a great asset to the organization. Amen. Okay, that's what I was looking at. Go ahead. You were going to ask. Yeah, Darlene, thoughts, feedback? Yeah, I'm a little bit curious how we want to kind of address this because it sounds like we're kind of trying to align to a structure today. Is that the goal? Good question. I would say we're...

56:37 Brainstorming structure for future. Yes. But have a more immediate, you know, do we want to do something for this fiscal year and particularly between now and, you know, the new year? So we're looking to evaluate the performance of this previous fiscal year and I have to ask, what is the fiscal year here?

57:07 Is it June? July to June. July to June, okay. And then we would want that award to hit either in the next month or on her anniversary? It would be effective July 1st. Oh, so it would be prorated back to retro. Perfect, okay. I feel like we should budget for the COLA because that doesn't feel like it's reward-based, right? Yes. That's more of a market review compensation analysis. Yeah.

57:36 towards sort of what the Executive Director's role is and what their impact is in the community that is being done. I do think we can split up awards in multiple ways. I do, you know, bonuses are great, but also more money is taken out up front. So if we want to feel like that money is...

57:54 Compounding over time to make the Executive Director feel that reward. It's almost more of a salary bump in my mind of X percent. Now the X percent, I'm sort of wondering how we're aligning to that. Because that's the question I have in my head. What structure are we kind of aligning that percentage to? And I think that's my question. So I think...

58:22 So I'm in full plus on the 6% or whatever the COLA is, but I think there's and to that. And I think that's what we're discussing now. Correct. And how is it being proposed? Is it being proposed as a percentage or is it being proposed as a bonus? And so that's what that, that's what we're passing numbers back and forth and looking at that. Yeah. And I guess that's where I'm like trying to understand, like, are we like, what is that number? Like, like, is it a, are we looking for like a monthly to hit or are we looking for? It'd be a one-time bonus. One-time bonus, yeah.

58:54 So as I was looking here, like if you do the $6,000 bonus, right, then it'd be $500 minus taxes. You're thinking about like a $300 net. But if you, and then you're going to do the 6%, you're at $5,100, right? If you're going to do the 8%, it's $6,800, so that's going to be a difference of $1,700, right? And that doesn't flesh out the same as the $6,000 bonus. So all in all, it's $6,000 bonus. Except it's ongoing. So it's ongoing. So it becomes accumulative.

59:18 Okay, got it. And it goes on our salary schedule. So next year's COLA is on a bigger number rather than a smaller number. And so that compounding nature is compelling. And, you know, Danielle brought up a good point is that the salary range for this position, Kim is very much on the bottom half of that. And that was appropriate when we got started.

59:48 You know, we don't want Kim to be in her early 90s when she reaches the top of the pay range, too. And so, you know, good. Heidi, just feedback. Go ahead, Heidi. I don't have a ton of input, so learning, and this is so much not in my field, so learning about all the things is helpful.

1:00:15 And so I don't have a lot of opinion necessarily except to say that like for the time that I've known Kim just super passionate and loves what she does and we all know how much she loves the town and how seeing and growing up here how hard it is to find people and good help who really like want to be doing what they're doing and to show up and like really be passionate about it and Kim does that so well. Awesome, thank you.

1:00:43 Thank you. Perfect. Well, with that conversation, I'm personally proposing 8% on the salary period. That's my proposal. If anybody else has any other... I would support that effort. Yeah? Yeah. I think that's good. Brent, it sounded like you had feedback there a second ago. Did I cut you off? No, I'm sorry. I just jumped to the next thing. I'm good. Okay. What I was going to say was one of the things that...

1:01:14 What tends to happen in this community is we say, oh, we're going to give somebody an X percent, X percent, X percent, and it just keeps growing each year versus a structure saying, okay, what's the position worth? What's the right pay for the position versus just people growing at six or eight or 12 or whatever percentages? It really should match what is the right pay for the position.

1:01:33 When we were doing a little bit of research, I was helping another nonprofit here a few months ago, and when you're looking at a nonprofit or NGO position, you're looking at anywhere from $85 to $165 for a smaller organization, right, based on what our income is and based on what our salaries are, not our salary, our budget is, because I was looking at something similar. And I think that when you look at California and specifically even Mammoth Unified Resort Town, that our cost of living is so much higher, I think that we're right now on the low end of what we should be paying, period. That's my two cents.

1:02:02 Yeah, and it's tough too because for NGOs in this committee are even a broader range than you put out there and there's even lower and there's even higher. Yeah. So it's all over the board. Yeah, it is. And so I just, I think, I think what we were proposing is if we do the 8% now, it gives us something to say, okay, this is what your base is for next year with the contract for the next three years and there won't be another 8% but this is going to give you a stronger platform to build off for next year is kind of what I was feeling.

1:02:31 Can I ask a question? Would it be possible, Brent, you might know about this, to create like a step-in column for this position where she would move through the step-in column each year and then she would also get a COLA raise on top of that because otherwise what's going to happen the way we're looking at it right now is she's eventually going to reach that $130,000 but at that time when she finally does reach it that position might actually be valued at $160,000 because the cost of that position wasn't adjusted.

1:03:02 I don't, I do not know in this situation I'd have to get somebody else to involve in that. In terms of where, I agree with where you're going in general from that standpoint, but I think we have to have a conversation as a board in terms of what is the scale position, what's the max position, what's the max price in this position based on qualifications, etc. Is that $130 based on what position is scale level tier one or reverse price tier three? And is that the max out?

1:03:31 I'm not sure because we can't really follow what the town does on some days. We have to be set our own criteria because we don't have to follow the same criteria. And I think it's something that as an organization and a board, we could bring back the position description, any employee's position description, and review it for qualifications, duties, and salary range, and just approve it as needed.

1:04:00 So the question is, is that for today? That's exactly what I was going to say. For today, what are we going to agree with? Because these are bigger conversations for the future. We need a policy that, though I appreciate the brainstorming here. Yeah, we can't talk about it right now. It would be unwise of us to try to nut that all out here. That's a whole other conversation. Yeah, and I would like a couple of us.

1:04:28 to have a proposal of a full policy. Come, let's see, we're... I feel like it's happening right here. I do feel it happening. And, but that, you know, a couple of us can come back with a proposal for, you know, a couple different ideas for the board to really consider, get it to us ahead of time so that we can study it and then really debate this with it.

1:04:57 Something tangible in front of us. So with that, aiming for potentially on our November, is that too early to kind of pull something together? I know you said you had, you know,

1:05:12 Busy. Personally, I can't add one more obligation. No more obligations. I'm already saying yes too much. We're scheduled for a meeting in November. Scheduled in November and then again in January. I'm just questioning whether, you know, the time frame until November to have something to present to the board or should we give it two meetings? So maybe two meetings because we're not in a rush for that, but we will make a decision for today. That's what I recommend is two meetings. I just think that's...

1:05:41 Time to review that. It takes a little bit. Yep. Okay, so we'll have that on our January agenda and get some stuff out in December for the board to look at as far as a couple. I'd be happy to work with you, Danielle, on that and anyone else, you know, a couple. I just want to also add, that's also in addition to how we do the performance review too, right? Yes. Yes, indeed. Yep.

1:06:09 All right. So I'm going to go back to saying I proposed 8%. Does anybody else want to counter or add? So was that in the form of emotion? Well, no. I would first like to see if anybody else had any feedback, if that was a yes, if people were into that, or if you wanted to say something else besides me. My observation is we're trying to reward for sort of extraordinary performance, right, particularly around the fourth event. And I kind of want to know how we arrived at 8% because we did the math. You did the math.

1:06:39 So COLA being 6%, and then from there having a conversation if you're going to do a bonus on top of that, which is what we've done in the past, and then rising to the decision that if we did a percentage raise, it would help the bottom line versus doing a one-time bonus. That's kind of where that number came from. And where I would add feedback, or at least a point of clarification, is when I looked today, Mono County was doing 2% or 3%.

1:07:08 COLA increases depending on the position. So I don't know if I didn't search far and wide. Maybe I saw the state was at 4%. So my sense is we did our own 6%.

1:07:27 A couple people's... Calculations and trying to catch up a little bit to what we've done in the past. Based on performance annually. It should have a concrete basis. And maybe that's ahead for the future. And so, yeah, I'll leave that at that. I think when you look at COLA, too, it's always dependent upon the salary. It's like looking at COLA at an hourly.

1:07:56 If we had an hourly employee sitting here that made $22 an hour, well, Cola's going to be insufficient for that person, and we're going to have to look at a stress raise for that person. So when I look at the amount that Kim's making, and we know that we need to reward performance, and we need to continue to improve her salary, knowing that $130,000 is the top, you continue to bring money into the organization, you continue to grow the organization, and I think we at least need to do 8%.

1:08:23 But that's where I'm at. And that's solely because I'm looking at it that I want that on your salary schedule. And maybe you don't want that. Maybe you'd rather have, and we should ask you that, would you rather have some of it as a one-time award and some of it on the salary schedule? I think the cumulative effect is wise. So just to give this a quick calculation context.

1:08:51 You know, Kim, as stated earlier, is currently her salary is at $85,685 and change. Eight percent would bring her to $92,539. You know, that is the eight percent that was proposed here. And, you know, frankly, editorializing when you do look, eight percent gives me pause. That number doesn't.

1:09:22 Which maybe speaks a little bit to, you know, what we're struggling with here is there is some catch-up for the position, where we're at as an organization. And it's not sustainable every year. Well, yeah. That's the future conversation. And that's, that is the future conversation, that 8% is not, you know, the path we're on until we get to 130, you know, or whatever number.

1:09:52 So, okay. Great. Do we have a motion? Or any other further discussion? Anything else you want to add to that? Yes, Mayor? Do you have anything else you want to add? For me, I'll go aboard, but I may abstain for eight. It's a little tough for me to swallow on that without justification, but I don't want to be the naysayer in the courtroom.

1:10:23 You can be that. That's okay. But I think what I was looking at was I was looking at doing a bonus and what that broke down to versus doing on the percentage. And I was looking at the long-term effect of what was more beneficial to base our future conversations off of. So if you feel that there's a bonus that would work out better versus a percentage, then please have a conversation about it. Yeah, I just, as I go off the cuff here, I don't have a quick number to go there. I more favor a slightly higher bonus and a little bit.

1:10:54 lower start and then contract next year to reflect where we go with the salary. But if the board goes 8%, it's a board vote on this. I'm just one of the board voters. Okay. There you go. Thank you. All right. All right. Well, then I will make a motion to increase Kim's salary by 8% for this year, this fiscal year of 25-26.

1:11:22 25, 26, and retroactive back to July 1? Yes, because that's our fiscal. Okay. I have a motion, Schaubmeyer? Okay. Can you say the motion? Yeah. Can you rewrite the motion? That's the motion? That's the dollar. Okay, I'll make a motion. Do I need to quote the original amount and then see what the percentage is? Or can I just say what the bottom line percentage will be with the new salary amount? Do bottom line? Okay.

1:12:01 So I make a motion to increase Kim's pay 8% to $92,539 fiscal year of 25-26, retroacted back to July. Okay, we have a motion, Schaubmeyer, do I have a second? I'll second. Second, Torrance. I'm supposed to see your mouth on there. I trust you 100%. I trust you 100%, but I'm going to double check. But I'm going to double check. I want you to double check. Let's see if we're going to vote on it.

1:12:50 It's perfect. Excellent. Okay. I'm a numbers guy. You did good. You did good. All right. So we have a motion Schaubmeyer, second Torrance. Any further discussion? Seeing none, Angie, could you lead us through a roll call, please? President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Yes. Secretary Torrance? Yes. Excuse me. Board Member Truax?

1:13:19 Angela, am I allowed to abstain or do I have to vote? I'm sorry, I do not know that answer. I'm going to abstain. If you look at the rules of abstain, you'll understand it's not a no vote. Does that make sense? Board Member Pesquois? Yes. And Board Member Cousnitz? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Passes 5-0-1. One abstention. All right. Awesome.

1:13:57 I think California, the rule is that the vote is that by those who voted yes and voted no, it's a non-vote. Okay, non-vote. Thank you, Robert. I look forward to our criteria as we go forward and to setting the right portion. I think it's better for us, too, and I think it's better for Kim, so she understands versus us sitting here, kind of like, hey, I just think it would be.

1:14:29 I think we gave a great demo why we need a policy. Exactly. And then, Kim, as we're going on to the next moment, I just want to be mindful of time. I know Kim's got some stuff she's going to be at here. So I'm just going to know that we've got to cut off here in about 30 minutes or so as we're going over the next information. Perfect. Thank you. And so moving on to...

1:14:51 The next item, I lost my agenda. 5.1, review Mammoth Lakes Recreation mission, vision, and strategic priorities. Yes, so we, the current Mammoth Lakes Recreation strategic plan is the original one, 2016 to 2021. And this board, we've talked about it for a while. We need to review, see if there's

1:15:23 Room for improvement, places to update. So Darlene and I have worked together to sort of get to a draft starting point and look forward to a good discussion. And I do want to just throw it out there, like, feel, this is like discussion item, workshop-y, like, throw your ideas out there, speak over each other, do whatever you need to do. Very informal.

1:15:52 This will be our starting point. I'm going to be taking notes on your thoughts and feedback, and then make any changes that we do need to incorporate. So, I don't know how to make this look good. I feel like this is kind of a workshop-y kind of thing. It definitely is, and that's what this meeting was intended. There was concern that because board member...

1:16:22 Truex was zooming in that we needed to allow everybody to zoom in. Okay. So we are here. So just remember that this is kind of workshop-y and it's a good starting point. And to help kind of structure the discussion, we're just going to focus on mission and vision because I think that drives the rest of the strategic plan in the time frame that we have allowed, right? Yes. So what we did is we reviewed all sort of the

1:16:51 The strategic plan, mission, and vision, and sort of we saw an opportunity to sort of refresh. And one of the reasons we wanted to sort of refresh is because I think the mission and vision sort of lacked sort of what was the impact on focusing on mobility and access? Like what is it that we want the community to feel? What is it that we want to tell the world about Mammoth Lakes, right?

1:17:12 And so we also had some community input on previous surveys where it highlighted, you know, we wanted to provide, and I use this term people first infrastructure because I didn't want to focus on building houses or building more roadways, right? Like we have a very specific concern of building access that encourages community, right? And enriches daily life here. We also wanted to focus obviously on stewardship and sustainability and kind of foremost put the community up front.

1:17:40 of Mammoth Lakes as part of our goal of serving the larger community. One of the things we did is obviously we looked at a lot of the previous documentation and probably the surveys and we kind of made this exercise where I tried one lens where it was very grassroots focused and then we tried another lens where it was very aspirational and I think somewhere in between is where we're going to land in this exercise, right? We wanted to focus on

1:18:09 Daily life, walkable, community access. And we wanted to kind of drive the aspirational model for Alpine hometowns everywhere, right? And we wanted to make sure the framework included feedback from the larger community. And I'm using the word community, but as we know, we have like multiple demographics in that lens.

1:18:32 So the first option, and I started with the vision because Kim asked me, do we have to have a mission and vision? And I said, separate, right? And I said, no, but I was like, this is how I think about mission and vision. Vision's about how you want to feel about what the org is doing. It's the why of what we're doing, right? And that the mission is the what of what we're going to do. So I'm going to start with the vision. I kind of publicized sort of what is the current one.

1:19:00 And I'll just read it out loud. It's to transform Mammoth Lakes into a world-class high-altitude training center, a premier mountain arts and culture destination, and the best alpine recreation community in the country. And so I drilled this down sort of like what makes Mammoth Lakes world-class? What makes a premier mountain arts and culture and what makes the best alpine recreation community? Because I think we all feel that, but sort of what does that mean?

1:19:28 Tangibly, like how does that make you feel? So we went through many iterations and were willing to go through multiple ones, but this is the one that sort of resonated with what Kim was telling me about sort of the original plan of Mammoth Lakes and what the town was trying to achieve as a goal. It's a little bit long, but I think it lands how we feel about our community.

1:19:51 So Mammoth Lakes will be both a beloved hometown and an internationally admired alpine destination, a place where paved paths and trails weave through town and into the wild, creating effortless access. Here, people connect more through pathways than roadways, recreation and culture within easy reach, and the town itself becomes a model of how people-first infrastructure can strengthen community, inspire well-being, and protect the land for generations to come. Thoughts?

1:20:19 Am I missing? Should I move it into a different direction? Let that sit. This is just the vision, right? There's no, like, measurable outcomes of this yet. No. But I love, you know, that you... I have one... Go ahead, Brent. No, no, please go ahead. Oh, I was just going to say, I love the starting off with how does it make you feel? You know, that's certainly in the...

1:20:47 Mission, vision, strategy I've done countless times at Mammoth Mountain. You know, I always, you know, the why, and it is about feeling, and I like the feeling of this so much more than previous. You know, the other felt chest beating to me, and vroom, vroom, and this is more community-centric.

1:21:19 And the blend of community and I love the use of the word wild in there. Yes, that was something, yeah. It like takes it to a different place and that juxtaposition of a hometown in the wilderness is directionally really good. Yeah, I think that's what makes Mammoth Lakes unique, right? Especially with bear country, you know. Indeed.

1:21:49 Brent? A couple different things. So the past one was the original from 2014, right? Yes. So it's weird because I was on MLR board when we did that one in 2014. And at the time, MLR was charged for a lot of different things, but one of those was really to go out and raise a ton of money to do stuff and leverage funds. The organization has evolved a long way since then. Yes.

1:22:19 I like where this is going, but I do have a slight suggestion on the wording here, change. The one word that stuck out to me, a place where paved paths. I do not like the word paved. It may be true, it may be part of what we have, but my suggestion is changing paved path, sorry, I've got to change the screen, where it says right now, a place where paved paths and trails weed. I had a place where

1:22:50 Trails and natural connections flow through town and into the wild. I'm just, I'm trying not to get too editorial, but I don't like the word paved. It's somehow antithetical to, as much as I think our MUP is maybe one of our greatest resources, you know, and biggest successes, paved does have a city feel too. It does, and that's totally fair.

1:23:20 What I was trying to highlight, sort of the ease of walkability, right? And maybe finding ways of sort of, I forgot what you said in red, but it's not, I'm not considering, but I think, if I heard correctly, a place where maybe, you know, walkable paths? Or maybe, or, yeah. How accessible. I said where trails and natural connections flow through town and into the wild.

1:23:52 It wasn't perfect. I was trying to reword Hayes. I know we have them up, and I got it. I feel you. It sounds like cement, right? Yeah. A different mental image. I like what he's saying, but I do want to point out that my dad used the wheelchair most of my life, and I like the term, if you don't want to use paved, at least accessible. I agree, too, because that was my push for paved is until you're pushing a stroller.

1:24:21 Or you're in a wheelchair, or you're using the paved paths to commute to work. It's a really great resource. The only thing, though, is I've suggested accessible into our mission statement, so I was just trying to be careful there and segregate out words. As a former chair and board member for disabled support, I'm also very cognizant of needs for everybody. I'll channel my inner Bill Salser.

1:24:51 And go, all right, when I moved to town, there wasn't a single sidewalk in this entire town. And every morning, I walk. Or a streetlight. And I thought about it. Honestly. I walk on the sidewalks on my street, out to the Mupp. You know, though, I just said a minute ago, paved has an earth.

1:25:19 We are an urban center in a wild environment, you know, and, you know, and I live downtown here in Mammoth Lakes, you know, and that walkability is, you know, you just have to walk out in the road if you wanted to walk and not get your feet muddy. Exactly. So, interesting point. I'll definitely...

1:25:48 Oh, I was just going to say, you know, let me go back to the drawing board and kind of find some other phrases that might resonate a little bit closer to where we're trying to get to. And I'm going to say I'm a direct person. And so this, I feel like I'm reading a book and I'm taking a little adventure somewhere. But for someone who's a little bit more direct, I'm like, okay, a little bit less description, a little bit more to the point.

1:26:10 Does that make sense? It's very artsy. It's very, like, I feel like, again, I feel like I'm reading a book and I'm going on an adventure, but I think that we need to have a little bit more directness to it. Yeah. And so that I'm not, because interpretation is something that can be, wordage, verbiage can be used in different ways, right? So I think sometimes being too wordy, like people first infrastructure, I think it's just wordy.

1:26:32 And so I think finding a little bit more direct words or something to consider and think about accessibility, public access. I feel like communities and hometowns use a lot. It's warm and fuzzy. I like it, but I'm a little bit more direct. That's my two sides. Yeah, I'm not sure what you mean by more direct, to be honest. I feel like I'm trying to, I feel like I'm having to understand, like when I'm reading it, I'm having to process in my mind what that means.

1:26:56 I'm having to, like, when I'm sitting there reading it, I'm like a place where paved paths and trails weave through the town into the wild. So now I'm like, I'm like, ooh, I'm going on a book here. And then in my head, I am like, hey, where am I going? I'm creating effortless access, which I do like. I'm here, here people connect through more pathways than roadways. Again, it's very poetic, it's very, it's beautiful, but I'm like, okay, like, what's my point to it? You know what I mean? And that's totally fair. And so I guess what I would want to know from you is like, what is it that you want?

1:27:23 To walk away from reading the vision as you think of MLR as a board member. I guess that's something I'm going to have to do some reading on and I'll give you positive feedback 100%. Like I will spend some time because I have not done that and read this and kind of give you my two cents when I'm in a car for eight hours tomorrow. No, that's totally fair. I think it's more about like I think I totally get the like I'm a person who likes to use.

1:27:45 Someone told me I put the min in minimal. It's totally fair. But I think the goal is, what is it that you want the reader to take away when they read the vision? So I recognize it's a little wordy and it's not getting, it's not landing, there isn't a lot. So like, is there a feeling you want to come away with? Or is there sort of like, what's the one thing that MLR?

1:28:06 does that you want to have taken away. And I will definitely, I'll do something out, because I do believe about, you know, accessibility and community and arts and culture and bringing, it's a hard one, right? So you're putting a lot of things into one box. Exactly, yes. And I totally respect that and I understand that, right? Trust me, it's...

1:28:25 Somebody who's been on the board for nine years, I still sit there and go, okay, all right, where are we going with this, you know? So yes, but I feel like we've gotten more defined in the last couple years than we ever have been. So I think I just need to take a little bit more of my own energy and kind of give you constructive criticism that it's understandable on my side. So yes.

1:28:44 One thing that I felt strongly that one of the versions came up was the Inspire Well-Being, which was something I feel like actually kind of closed the loop for me of what we're trying to do, right? We're not here to just try to have fun, you know? You know, we're trying to enrich, is the best way I can think about it, life here. So that was something I really liked from this statement. And yes, I love this whole town in the wild. That was something Kim and I were like, wow, that one really...

1:29:15 Got it. Is unique to Mammoth. But I appreciate, like, this is why we're doing this right now, right? Yeah. I so appreciate. Because now you're like, yeah. It's the blank sheet of paper that's the hard part. Our part, right, yes. If we don't mind, we can switch in the mission. Yeah. And this is where we can be as very specific as we want, right? Because that usually helps us drive our priorities as an org.

1:29:44 The old mission was deliver cutting-edge sustainable recreation, mobility, arts and culture opportunities and infrastructure for the benefit of the community and natural environment of Mammoth Lakes. For me, this was very broad, and also I sort of was kind of challenging Kim on sort of what is sustainable recreation, what is mobility, what is arts and culture, like what does that do for the community?

1:30:15 We proposed a mission that kind of sort of aligned with the vision as well. So you should look at them as kind of they go hand in hand. And to read out loud, it's to create sustainable recreation, arts, culture, and community access experience that enrich daily life in Mammoth Lakes. I think I've made a mistake and that was supposed to be experience. My bad. By prioritizing walkable connections.

1:30:41 Trail access and people-first infrastructure. We make it easy for everyone to enjoy nature, culture, and community while showcasing Mammoth as a model for thriving mountain towns everywhere. So we kind of added that community blend but also with the aspirational aspect. And I think we should be conscious of the walkable aspect. I think it should be about accessible connections, something where you're being mindful of everybody and not everybody's walking to get somewhere. You're right, exactly. So we're still kind of trying to figure out how to make... I have a suggestion on that.

1:31:12 Because the wording that I came up with, again, we're all being wordsmiths here. Yes, we're just wordsmithing. Is that change that sense that it is by prioritizing walkable connections, trail access, and people first infrastructure to make it easy for everyone to enjoy nature, culture, and community. I changed that to by prioritizing accessible connections.

1:31:36 Inclusive infrastructure and opportunities to engage with nature and culture. We make it easy for everyone to enjoy what our town has to offer. I like that. I think that town has to offer is a little vague for me as well, though. Yeah, I know. Yeah, yeah. I like the beginning part and I kind of want to write that down if you don't mind, Brent, in repeating it for me. You said by prioritizing. Let's come back to it. By prioritizing.

1:32:15 Accessible connections. Okay. Inclusive infrastructure. Ooh, fancy. And opportunities to engage with nature and culture. I'll stop there because the last one I agree, unless you want the rest of it, you know, because I continue that, we make it easy for everyone to enjoy what our town has to offer. Right.

1:32:54 Yeah, I think that adding that last bit is redundant because enjoying nature, culture, and community is what the town has to offer. And then, though, I can see where Brent's going, and I do kind of like this last little add-on of showcasing Mammoth as a model.

1:33:25 Too much. Maybe the, I was channeling my inner Heather, make it short. Get to the point. Stop being around the point. The dry one over here. The saltine cracker. It is, you know, kind of an aspirational aspect to that.

1:33:48 Yeah, I include it because there was a lot of language in your earlier documentation about this. I mean, everything was aspirational before, right? Like, everybody was just like, we're going to be the ultimate, you know, Alpine, you know, training community. And then we're like, no, but no one can afford to live here. So it's hard.

1:34:04 Sorry. There's that dry part again. But I understand vision and mission. A vision needs to be a little bit more of a vision, a little bit bigger aspirational aspect. It's just how you feel, right? Yeah. It's meant to sort of take away what MLR really does. And I think as we get into the strategic plan, I think we have a lot of opportunities to highlight the...

1:34:27 Impact that MLR has, right? And I think we're doing a lot about trails and outdoors, but it's not just what we do. Correct, right. We're forgetting to involve arts and culture, which is also music, which is a big part that we are part of also. So I think we have to figure out a way to incorporate that. Right. So, you know, I think we avoided sort of using the typical outdoor recreation terms because I think the organization is more than that. Correct. Yes. And so I wanted to go ahead.

1:34:57 Oh, right. All you. No, no. I was just going to do we need the word everywhere at the end of that? Because I was really struggling with the model where you were, Craig, and then I was like, okay. I think everywhere is necessary. But I was also saying maybe it's while showcasing Mammoth as a model for thriving mountain towns, period. Correct. I hear you. That also, I think, lands well, too. Yeah. I wonder in both the mission and the vision you talk about, which I really like both of them, but

1:35:33 Talking about how it makes it easy for everyone to enjoy nature and how, you know, it's like effortless access to get into nature. And while I know we do want to make it easier and more accessible for people to get there, like being in the wild, I think, and a lot of what people are coming up here to do is it's hard and it's not like super effortless or easy. And I'm also wondering if there's a way that we could like skew that in more of a way of like we want to

1:36:02 help you or like equip people whether because people come up here training and you know there's disabled sports and there's there's all the ski team or the teachers and the fishing guides and there's so much recreational help that people who live here can give to like help people come up and like and obviously someone who's coming up for the first time for a weekend isn't gonna be able to train to hike to Mount Whitney in a weekend but

1:36:29 If there's some way that maybe we could rephrase that so that it's not quite like we don't want to make it super easy for everyone but we want it we still want to help you do or like we want to make it easy.

1:36:40 For you to come here so we, I don't know, so we could teach, I don't know, something like. Set you up for success. Set you up for success. Yeah. Yeah, we were, that's very, it's an interesting take because I think I hadn't considered that when I was thinking about access, I was thinking about how to move within Mammoth Lakes as a town, right? Yeah. Because it is cool. Yeah. Because that's what I was, I go, oh, she got rid of, I've always thought mobility has been so clunky for us. Yes. And, but, you know.

1:37:10 Access, now that's... That's broad and big. Broad and big includes mobility, but doesn't make you think buses. Yes. Only. Yeah. And so. So let me see. Add a need of like, you know, you're a starting point. Because I think there was an initial plan to build these transit systems to make people get from one part of town to the other relatively easily.

1:37:41 And push for a lot more community-oriented experience in that way versus just people just driving to the trailhead and parking and not enjoying the town of Mammoth Lakes. That would be amazing. Cars that, oh man. Cars are our single biggest. 4.45? Yeah, we're going to have to. 4.45, right? So we've got five minutes. That was a good start. Yeah, absolutely. So it sounds like everyone's liking the direction. Directionally.

1:38:11 Makes me feel good. I haven't heard anything that's like, you know, we're heading there, you know, we all want to put our, you know, flair on it, you know, and, but, um, I think it's so heading the right direction and would it be helpful for us to continue to wordsmith and play with our different versions and, you know, keep

1:38:41 Throwing it at the wall and let you kind of continue to... Kind of blend it on. Blend it together. Throw the email chain out there. Yeah. Put what you have out there and let people kind of give little suggestions if you want or not. Or we can do them individually. Make a new baby out of all of it, yes. For sure. I know it's a lot, so thank you. That's awesome. Great, great start. And I would just add, I thought narrowing it down, you know, just having the...

1:39:09 The three strategic priorities, you know, those topics are great. And I think, like you said, the details and the measurables, those fall into place and will be refreshed with each iteration of this, you know, as we move from, oh, we have this need and now we've met these needs, now we can move on. But the categories.

1:39:39 are kind of timeless, I think, for us. You know, they're not going to go away. And I think that's super important where...

1:39:50 All right. Thank you. Great work. Thank you. Yeah. I really appreciate it. Thank you very much. The blank piece of paper is always so hard. Or looking at the old one and going, I just want to rip it up and start all over. I did include, we did look at also like what the town had written for their goals and priorities and well included that. So it would complement and not necessarily contradict, if you will. Yeah. Excellent. Excellent point.

1:40:19 Where did my sheet go? All right. Great job. Thank you. You know, don't know if we'll do a quick, anybody have, starting with Heather, anything to report on? No, nothing to report on right now. No, we're good to go. Thank you. Great job with the 4th of July. That was a lot. Yeehaw. Brent, anything to report out to the board on?

1:40:49 Now, just a quick question for you there. What's the AQI right now? Is it terrible? It's not as bad as yesterday. You can actually see some blue in the sky, and it's white smoke instead of red and gray smoke. So, I don't know if it's 200 and change now. 220. There we go. It's pretty bad when you can guess within 10%. I can tell you what 446 feels like, and it's not nice.

1:41:16 Half is bad, but at least we didn't have what Mono Lake and June Lake had, so we're very fortunate. Theirs was gnarly. So nothing for Brent. Heidi? Nope. Nope. Nope. Love it. Darlene? Nope, I'm good. All right, awesome. Just a big shout-out to the Mono Lake committee for the Tioga Pass Run. They did a great job.

1:41:41 Oh. And they kept it going with the smoke. That's awesome. Oh, wow. Yeah, I would say the same thing with the Mammoth Grand Fondo got super lucky to squeeze it in. If you didn't finish fast enough, you were punished double, you know, because the smoke definitely came in for those later riders. I would just add one thing that's kind of what we're seeing on the mountain is

1:42:11 Bookings for this winter are looking stronger than we expected. We keep, you know, lodging and every month of the winter is beating last year, same point in time, which is kind of, you know, a little odd good news. Maybe we're, if we just have, obviously snow is the key ingredient, but it's kind of looking.

1:42:40 Promising after a kind of an off summer, winter looks, at least early, is looking good. So with that, we will at 4.42, three minutes to spare, bring our meeting to close. Oh, future agenda items. I got the January one. Got the January one. Okay.

1:43:09 440. I'm sorry, the only thing would be talk about allocations board in our next meeting, talk about who's going to be on that and how that's going to look for the future. Excellent. Peace. Okay, allocations and wage and salary policy. Awesome. Thank you. And we will adjourn. Thanks, Brent. Enjoy that clean air. It was very nice. 72 degrees and pure sunshine today. Nice. That's a little odd for Vermont. I know.

1:43:39 About 49 degrees tonight. Appreciate it. Thank you.