TransparentMammoth

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2022

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments

at 08:30

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

194 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Yeah, I'm sorry. We had a member of the public who just came in. I was speaking with him. Oh, okay. I wasn't sure you were calling roll or something. Thanks. We're good. And Mr. Ellis was having issues getting in. I've re-sent a link out to him, so he should be hopping on momentarily. Good morning. I want to make sure you know we can't hear anything. Asked about this. How is that? Does that sound better? Yes, now we can hear you. Thanks.

7:39 All right, awesome. Thank you so much. Okay. Okay, I'm sorry. And just so you know, we can't, oh, there's Stacey and there's Bob. Okay, good morning. We were just waiting for signs of life. We've called to order this regular meeting of the council. So if we could please call the roll. Thank you. Chair Wentworth? Present. Vice Chair Totheroe? Here. Council Member Schwartz?

8:15 Here. Supervisor Corliss? Supervisor Corliss? Here. Supervisor Gardner? Here. Supervisor Griffiths? Here. Council Member Ellis, I believe, is having technical difficulties, so we'll come back to him. And Council Member Salcedo? Here. Thank you. Thank you all. So, Destin, I'm wondering if you would mind leading us in the pledge this morning? I'd be honored to hear your voice. Through the flag.

9:01 of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. So, first order of business, is there any public comment? I don't, is anybody here who wants to make a public comment? Anybody, Angie, on the virtual universe?

9:28 Yes, we do have a member of the public here in Suite C who would like to make a comment. If you want to go ahead and state your name and make your comment, please. My wife and I are August residents here in Mammoth Lakes. We're from the city of La Quinta where it's 105 today. I'm a former chair of the planning commission there and now a member of the Coachella Valley Energy Commission, so I'm anxious to see.

9:56 Government virtually and personally and to learn more about this great area of our state. Thank you very much, Madam Chair and members. Thank you very much. Welcome to the Eastern Sierra and thanks for showing up and saying good morning. Any additional public comment or? No comments at this time. Great. Thank you very much. So we'll move on now to our consent agenda. Item 4.1 to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of June 10th.

10:28 4.2, approve the minutes of the special meeting of July 8th. 4.3, approve the minutes of the special meeting of August 5th. 4.4, consideration of a resolution of the board of directors of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments regarding the need for continued virtual meetings to protect public health. Would anybody like to pull an item? Seeing any, I think we're all good. I would then entertain a motion to approve the consent agenda as presented. Move for approval, Mr. Chair. I'll second.

10:57 Thank you. Motion to second. Any additional discussion? This one's not getting a lot of takers, so we'll go ahead and call for the vote on this question, please. And I apologize. I believe I may have skipped over Supervisor Griffiths in the roll call. I'm still here. Still here? Okay. Maybe I just didn't check it in my system. I apologize. Okay. And we had the motion was made by Supervisor Griffiths. Supervisor Griffiths?

11:31 Second by Council Member Schwartz. Thank you very much. Chair Wentworth? Yes. Vice Chair Tothero? Aye. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. And Council Member Salcedo? Yes. Thank you. Good, thank you. So the consent agenda appears it was approved unanimously.

12:04 We'll move on now to item 5.1, ESCOG staff and funding capacity. Elaine, tell us what we need to know. Good morning, ESCOG board. It is a pleasure to see you all and a pleasure to see those who have joined virtually. I'm going to go ahead and share some documents. These are all included in your agenda packet, but I wanted to go over them to provide the staff report today and the background information that you need.

12:37 So this, sorry. Okay. So this item is in response to a request from the board at previous meetings to discuss the ongoing capacity of the ESCOG. We've been successful in receiving several grants implementing the program of work under the Sustainable Recreation and Ecosystem Management Program.

13:09 And I've heard concerns from the board about the capacity to staff and ensure the successful implementation of those projects, as well as concerns and interest in where the ESCOG will be going in the future and what that pipeline of projects looks like. So I've worked with regional management over the last couple of months to prepare a model for your consideration about

13:40 Increasing the ESCOG staff from its current part-time single employee to a full-time executive director with the potential to add a part-time administrative assistant and then potentially increasing staffing as appropriate and additional projects come into the pipeline in the future. This has been shared with each of the regional managers for feedback and Mr. Councilman Ellis.

14:08 And Councilman Wentworth also joined us in one of those meetings and are familiar with this as well. So I'm going to go over some of the assumptions that inform this model, and then I will move to the financial model that explains how I anticipate that that funding would be budgeted for over time. Kind of hard to center it around the Zoom stuff. So these are the...

14:40 First overview is just a very high-level overview of an organizational chart with some key assumptions that are made. So here, looking out towards the end of this year, it's proposed to bring on a full-time executive director and then maybe looking towards the beginning of 2023, a part-time administrative assistant. The assumptions that are made are that they're

15:05 would be limited increases and new projects. And the key assumption that underlines all of the staffing modeling and the financial modeling is that the ESCOG would be able to participate in the Community Economic Resilience Fund or the SURF project. And this model also, excuse me, includes the Inyo Mono Broadband Coordinator.

15:28 We submitted a grant in July to the California Advanced Services Fund that would fund that position. So the other assumption in each of these models is that that position, if the grant is awarded, would be budget neutral because it would be entirely funded by that grant. So at a high level, looking forward into 2024 through 2026, potentially expanding.

15:58 that part-time administrative assistant as appropriate to also take on additional grant responsibilities and that would be a full-time position so then there would be two full-time employees to the ESCOG plus the Inyo Mono Broadband Coordinator position and that Inyo Mono Broadband Coordinator position will be employed within Inyo County but report to the ESCOG who would be administering that grant funding.

16:26 One of the things that the model that I'm proposing today provides a number of key decision points for the board and for the member agencies to be looking at the success and the sustainability at each of these points before committing to additional funding requirements or staffing requirements.

16:47 Assuming that the ESCOG continues to be successful in obtaining grants and financially sustainable, potentially looking at 2026 to adding another part-time administrative position, if that's appropriate. I want to go over a little bit some of the assumptions that were used to inform the financial model, and these were provided very graciously in collaboration with Mr. Haller of the Town of Mammoth Lakes.

17:17 We've just gone over the different positions and some of the funding sources in those organizational charts. All of these models assume that the other support costs would remain static to what they are, so continuing to receive clerking services from Mammoth, fiscal support from Mono County, legal services from Inyo County at the same contracted rate that we have now.

17:41 And then these are the salary ranges that were provided by the town of Mammoth Lakes. And so if there's direction from the board today to continue to move forward in the direction of having a full-time executive director, there would certainly be room for doing more salary comparisons against member agencies and seeing, you know, what would be appropriate in making the organization sustainable. But this is the salary range that was used to build the financial model. With that, I'm going to...

18:11 Go over to a slightly more granular budget. As I said, this is included in your agenda packet. I'm going to run it off Excel because I think it's a little bit more legible than it is in your agenda packet. Just a moment. Okay. So I'm going to the financial model that I prepared here includes two different things.

18:52 So the first one is the base case scenario, which looks at the lower end of those salary ranges and includes the benefit package and then the high cost and includes just the singular part-time assistant for the entire forecast horizon. The high cost scenario looks at a slightly higher salary range for both of those positions, increasing the part-time administrative assistant to full-time. And both of these include

19:19 5% increase over time for cost of living increases in merit. I'll start by looking at the proposed revenues. So the assumption that is made in both of these models is that there would be no additional member agency contributions. Each member agency would continue to contribute $25,000 over this planning horizon. What would be able to support the increase in staff?

19:47 is the grant revenues you've seen. So we are under contract and obligation to deliver on three different grants at this time. That includes the California Department of Fish and Wildlife Grant, the Sierra Nevada Conservancy Towns to Trails Grant, the National Fish and Wildlife Grant, and then potentially that California Advanced Services Fund Grant that would fund the Inyo Mono Broadband Coordinator position. And for the simplicity of discussion, I'm probably just not going to talk about that. It's neutral across the model.

20:17 As I said before, the important consideration, yes, Mr. Griffin. I was just curious. You just read my mind. Yes. Is there, so with the broadband grant, is there no admin funding that comes along with that? You know, I don't know that there's administrative funding that was included. I apologize. Okay. That would be beneficial to the model if there were. Right.

20:46 For the, again, for the sake of discussion, we'll just leave it as a neutral position. Got it. Thank you. Thank you for the question. And I will follow up with that information. What this model does rely on is the assumption that the ESCOG would be able to participate in the surf planning phase. And the Sierra Business Council has contacted staff. They had a $5 million budget that they needed to build up to apply for that funding.

21:15 They set aside $500,000 for on-the-ground outreach on both the east side and the west side. On the east side, they proposed putting that $500,000 into two buckets. One would be to place staff in Inyo County's Small Business Development Center, and the other $250,000 they've proposed to allocate to the ESCOG.

21:40 to coordinate regional public input and outreach to support that planning effort. And so this model does assume that approximately $100,000 over that planning period would be available for administration through the ESCOG for the implementation of that project. So I've described some of the salary ranges. Again, right now, the... Can I ask a question about these best case and high cost scenarios?

22:08 Yes. So the difference in these two funding is basically out of the Advanced Services Fund. That's true. And the difference in the revenue is that assumption that the grant will pay for that fund, will pay for that position. So it's considered to be, the potential is that it would be higher salaries in the high cost scenario. But again, I'm assuming that it will be budget neutral because the CASF.

22:36 Grant is supposed to cover the entirety of that. So we've discussed a little bit about the salary ranges that are proposed here, both for the executive director and for the administrative assistant. As I said, the services that are provided by the member agencies would continue to remain static to what they are today in this model. And then looking at office and management costs.

23:08 Proposed increase of about $10,000 starting in 2023 to cover incidental things such as attend conferences, travel, training, and other items that might come up that we might not have anticipated, such as in the past, setting up an email account and putting the appropriate IT securities in for that. So if you look at that model, we start positive.

23:38 And we go through 2024 in the black without additional member agency contributions filling out to a full-time executive director and a part-time assistant. And there's a couple of important assumptions that also need to be included in this model, which are, I apologize, you can't quite see this, but you can see in this graph. So we continue to remain solvent.

24:06 until 2024, and then there's a deep dive. And so one of the assumptions that you have to take into consideration of this is that there's no other new projects in the pipeline that are included or assumed in the funding. It does give the ESCOG, again, multiple decision points to decide if things are sustainable and to continue proceeding, but we would also have those opportunities to continue to look for funding and grant opportunities.

24:41 Through the Sustainable Recreation and Ecosystem Management Program to bring in additional grants and administrative funding, and that would change the curve of that graph. Additionally, once the SURF and the SEDS are in place, the ESCOG with the board's direction could go and request the authorities to be working on implementing some of those projects, which increases other opportunities to bring in grant funding to support those administrative costs as well.

25:17 So that concludes my overview of the staffing models that I've discussed with regional leadership and with members of the board. At this time, I'm requesting that the board would discuss the staff capacity forecast and provide direction to staff and regional leadership for support for full-time executive director, potentially administrative assistant, and provide direction to work with regional leadership.

25:46 on the, what would be required logistically to make sure that that would work in terms of, for instance, placing staff into a member agency for human resource efficiencies and finding an appropriate location for staff to be seated within one of the member agencies as well. I'm happy to take any questions you have at this time. Thank you. Okay, good. Thank you. Who's got questions for Elaine?

26:16 Yes, Mr. Griffith. So back to this broadband grant. So we're getting $150,000. The grant is for $150,000 a year? No, I apologize. The broadband grant was developed by somebody else and sort of gone through the ESCOG as a conduit. And so I'm not as familiar with the particulars of the budget. But yes, the funding that I included in the staffing position in this model was pulled from that budget for the position.

26:50 I think Nate knows about that. Nate knows about that. Yeah. Right. So is that, I guess what I'm thinking is some money in that for the Executive Director, Todd. And as I said, I believe there's probably two that there is funding in there for administration. I would need to go back and look at the budget. Okay. And then I can come back with answers on that. If it is flowing through ESCOG, then ESCOG should be getting some money support. Certainly.

27:23 That's it. Anybody else? I have a question for the projected cash flows and the dip in 2024. If we pursue more grant-funded opportunities, but we're still maintaining the current grants that we're working on, will then that increase the admin staff?

27:51 Like the need for, is the plan, the organization will just grow bigger because we'll still be administering the current grants that we're working on and then we'll be soliciting more projects. So does that? So the dip in 2024 reflects the end of those projects. So towns to trail. Yeah, so towns to trails goes through 2026. The NIFWF grant goes through the end of 2024.

28:20 The SURF grant, we don't know exactly the timeline, but it's approximately 18 months to two years. So those would all be sunsetting. Okay. Okay. That answers my question. So one of the changes in this then would be making the Executive Director position be a permanent full-time position that will still be sitting in one of the member agencies, correct?

28:48 Yes. So I would certainly invite any of the regional management to step in and either collaborate with or corroborate my story or correct it. But the conversations that we've had are that the state of California makes it difficult for it to continue to be a contract position and to be contracting that out. And so it would make sense also for the sustainability of the ESCOG and its projects.

29:17 to house that within one of the member agencies, and particularly staffing that up to full-time, gaining efficiencies and things like PERS. The other consideration is having that staff sitting within one of the facilities of the member agencies, and I certainly, speaking of staff, see a lot of value in that and just being able to continue to, you know, hear what's happening and coordinate and meet with the public. And just for point of clarification,

29:47 Given the structure of the ESCOG, we are not able to employ a person such as an executive director. Is that, I mean, we could, but it wouldn't come with any of the certainties and the securities of working for one of the member agencies, and that's why we're not considering bringing that position into the actual ESCOG, correct? I think that's probably a good summary. Among other things, we simply just not have human resources infrastructure, which is obviously very complicated.

30:16 Really, you know, maybe one of the people on Zoom here could give a little bit more clarification of that. Dan, you perhaps? Yes, Dan Holler from Town of Mammoth Lakes. And we were looking at the structure for that position and ESCOG, rather than having to stand up the ESCOG as a full legal entity, which would require

30:45 The HR function, it requires agreements with the state for CalPERS, its own insurance program, et cetera. There's a lot of additional costs with that and time and effort that would need to go into it. Potentially looking at some additional insurance side of that as well. So, and then of course, then it's a housing, where do they live? Where do you put them? Do we rent space? Do we end up in another building, et cetera? So it seemed to make a lot of sense to have a...

31:12 Employees, a member, just an employee, employee of one of the member agencies, that way the HR function, you know, for the additional position or have one and a half position is pretty minimal. You already have a benefit structure that they can step into versus having to create one. And then also, you know, the payroll function, all of those elements of that nature then can be handled by that entity versus having to recreate that for a

31:40 One, two, three person type of organization. So I think there's a lot of operational efficiencies and savings in that process. Okay. And then the stated, for example, the stated salary for executive director for the next year, depending on which scenario you're looking at here, then is that reflects fully loaded salary plus benefits, correct? Correct.

32:08 Yeah, that would still be new to get negotiated with whatever you do from the ED. There'd be some negotiation, I'm sure, in that process. It gives you... I'm sorry, what, Dan? If you're going to hire an ED, we'd have a salary structure there. There may be some negotiations with whoever gets brought on for where they land in a salary structure, but it gives you a feel for the potential cash flows for that. And then the sponsoring agency, one of the members, then agrees to, you know, bring...

32:36 That employee into their full-time employee, but fully committed to ESCOG alone, correct? Correct. Thank you. Okay. Anybody else? Dan? So thank you, Elaine. Thanks for taking the time to put this together. I think for the board, I think, as you know, we wrote a letter of commitment to Sierra Business Council supporting their application. That application is going to be awarded, I think,

33:08 It's mostly awarded this week. If it's not awarded already, this is for them to be the planning thing for the serve process. So I think we, I think, I don't want to speak for the board. Well, before I go on, I'm sorry. Bob or Stacey, do you have any questions for Lane before I start rambling on here? I don't. We're at the question part, not the what do we want to do part. That's my...

33:32 Yeah, do you guys have any questions? I've got a couple questions, and then we'll do our deliberating and give directions. Go ahead. Okay. So I think that on behalf of all of us, we have an expectation that we will have a full-time person in place by the beginning of Q4 of this year, because the SURF thing is going to start happening, and we've got, if we're taking this money from them, so is it fair to say that we will have something?

34:01 to vote on, when's our next meeting, October? October. October, is it fair to say that we will have, that the board can assume one way or the other, we will be able to take action on the capacity that you've described this morning? First, staff would request a distinct direction from the board that that is the direction that you would want to move in, is to have a full-time capacity. I don't think that that has been clearly stated at this time. Second,

34:37 With that direction, we could work with the, we would move forward in working with regional management to sort through the logistics of what that would look like. And I think that will take a little bit of time to sort out. Currently, I'm speaking as Executive Director, I'm on contract. And my contract would come up for renewal in October. So I think that that timeline makes sense. You know, speaking frankly.

35:05 I also have served as the part-time planner for the city of Bishop, and they recruited. I can't speak for them publicly as to exactly where they are in that process, but they have been recruiting for a planner, and so when that person comes on as a full-time planner, they would be able to take over much of my responsibilities, bringing up a great deal of my capacity to devote back to the ESCOG. That being said,

35:32 So with the direction of the board to move to full-time and assuming that we were able to work through the logistics of the different member agencies for what that would look like, we could bring something back in October. Yeah, so we'll get to that in our deliberation, so that's good to know. I think we're making commitments, we need to know where we're going to be at with that. I would suggest also if there's any issues along the way that if we had to have a special meeting or some kind of discussion to figure out where we're going, that I think the board would be happy with something like that. Go ahead. Mr. Griffiths.

36:02 So do you have a staff recommendation? That's my first question. I think that the financial model indicates that there's funding that's sufficient to support full-time. I've certainly heard that there's the need, and if there's direction later in the agenda to adopt a resolution to participate in the SURF and we're able to get that authority from the member agencies, I think that will be an enormous lift. I also think it will be a really wonderful opportunity for the ESCOG to demonstrate value across the region and will require a full-time position.

36:33 Okay, great. So, good answer. And I'm also thinking that, you know, the key assumption that you have in there, the second one, under the key assumptions was, you know, no future, no new projects initiated through the forecast period. I think it's a safe assumption that that is a safe assumption that that key assumption is a conservative assumption. Yes. And that that is not the goal of the agency.

37:02 That's correct. And, you know, I think maybe going back to the preload of this entire conversation, I think the ESCOG is in a bit of a fulcrum at this time. It was established as a JPA with the intent to do projects on a regional basis. And it has been, you know, staffed with a skeleton crew sort of as a pilot concept. I think we've demonstrated and proven a certain amount of success and that there is consensus that the ESCOG should continue in that direction.

37:31 of bringing in funding to implement projects of a regional benefit. So yes, it would continue to require additional staff to make that happen. Okay. And I guess maybe this is under commentary instead of questions, but I would say that, you know, ideally we're looking at these types of things without knowledge of who is in the position and just doing it position-based as opposed to personality-based, but the reality is it's very small and there's people in these positions right now.

38:03 How's that? And so I would assume that we would be able to work with regional management and the needs of the City of Bishop, for instance, to figure out the right mix. So it could be 100%, 75%. I wouldn't want us to give any authority in such a way that has the flexibility to make it work for the agencies and the personnel involved. I appreciate that.

38:28 There certainly are. Yes, there are positions. And at a certain point, I feel like it would be appropriate for me to remove myself from this discussion, allow for the regional management to discuss what makes sense in terms of salary and so on and so forth. It becomes odd, obviously, to be in the middle of that discussion as the only staff. One of the things that I haven't stated explicitly but is implied is that I do have a commitment to the city of Bishop.

38:54 to help them with their transition to a new planner in making sure that there's continuity and success in the projects that are in the pipeline within the city of Bishop. So that's certainly reflected in the forecast of at least through October. And if there were flexibility or if it was a necessity in working through the logistics, you know, I would appreciate flexibility to ensure that success if it's, you know, determined that the board would want to continue to include me as the executive director.

39:23 Okay, so a couple other questions before we get to our full-on deliberation. There's some other tasks at ESCOG that we've laid out from the beginning, grant writing, along with the website, our communications portal. I think one of the things that the SURF process is asking to do is to be facilitating communication and doing a regional-based outreach effort. Do these budget numbers assume that we'll be able to get those tasks done as well? Yes, they do. Okay. And I think in terms of the HR issues about

39:53 Moving forward along the lines you're talking about, Elaine's talking about, I know that, Destin, when we met, you, me, and Jim, and Dan, and others met, I'm assuming that between you and Dan, you guys will help with Elaine to figure out the logistics of moving to this position and get all this set up, because I'm assuming that we'll have our deliberation here, but we have an expectation that come August, someone's going to be there, because we've made a bunch of commitments to SBC and the SURF and all kinds of other people who need to make

40:23 So those are my questions. So any, there's no other questions we can deliberate, but let's, I think, focus in around the direction that Elaine is asking for the staff to our expectations and needs for staffing and for somebody to come back at our October meeting. I can try to frame it up, but if someone else is more articulate than I am, wants to get started. So I think I'll just start with the...

40:51 The direction to staff would be to, at our October meeting, or in advance of that as necessary, to return to the board with a proposal for full-time staffing, along with administrative assistance as represented this morning, and to, if there's any complication with that, that would perhaps put the ESCOG in a position of not having full-time staff and support coming October, that staff makes the board aware, and if we have to have a special meeting to discuss it, that we do it.

41:21 And that we are relying on the wisdom and technical facilities of town managers, city managers, county managers as needed to help facilitate all this. And we look forward to a thorough and forward-looking proposition in October. So just a question on that. So we will be asking the four parties to look at this together to bring us back. So it's those four parties.

41:49 Will there be any representation from the board or will that be those managers? It's going to be the managers. A process is already in place. Managers, they don't work on that. So they will bring back to us an agenda item to move this forward. Is it good? Everybody happy? Are we happy in the universe? Okay, good. That means Zoom, yes. Yeah, I refer to that affectionately as the universe. Okay, so Elaine, thank you very much for this. And Destin and Dan, sorry. Is that all you need?

42:21 Yes, yes, that is sufficient direction. So thank you, Destin. Thank you, Dan, for helping us with this. And I know we've got some CAO things moving around, and that could be part of those conversations as well. Thank you. Okay, so we're going to move on now to item 5.2, the approval of bid for implementation of the Buttermilk Infrastructure and Recreation Planning Initiative Phase 1, Toilet Facilities Replacement. Good morning once more. Happy to provide the update that we're starting to...

42:54 move through the contracting phase of some of the grants we've received into a tangible work on the ground. At the board meeting in June, your board approved bid documents and specifications for phase one of the buttermilk infrastructure and recreation planning initiative, which is funded through the National Fish and Wildlife Grant. Phase one is demolition of the existing

43:18 We received one bid from LB Foster CXT Products for a prefabricated toilet that meets the specifications from the U.S. Forest Service and the ESCOG. The bid was for the amount of $77,330.

43:47 which is within budget of the grant. The grant includes $83,300 for installation of the vault toilet. The bid only includes delivery and installation of the toilet. And I think that this project has been a wonderful learning experience about the ESCOG's ability to work with the Forest Service for certain types of implementation on ground. I'd like to talk a little bit about the lessons we learned in procurement.

44:16 Valuable in looking at projects in the future that we would be able to partner with the Forest Service on. So we've been working, ESCOG has been working with the Forest Service for the past 18 months on various efforts to support sustainable recreation and California speak to each other very well at all. Very different languages. To say the least. Excuse me.

44:51 And this instance was no different. And so under our state of California, if the ESCOG were to contract someone to go out and turn a spade of dirt, it becomes a public works project, which does all kinds of different things to bidding procedures and things like prevailing wage. And for the placement of a prefabricated vault toilet into the forest, on the forest side, that's all.

45:19 part of one complete package. It's not considered a public works project in the same way. And so the Forest Service has worked with us very graciously to agree to do the demolition of the existing infrastructure and to excavate wood.

45:43 and put it in place. And the last component is finishing the grade from the vault toilet to the area, which is G, at a separate standalone bid just for pouring the concrete pad, or they've even suggested, the project manager on that side has suggested that it would be an appropriate project for a volunteer with the coalition at ESCOG.

46:19 The only thing I'd add is that we were hoping to have this project contract and installed by November, but due to supplying delays and also very high demand for this type of vault toilet infrastructure due to the Great American Outdoors, LB Foster CXT products would not be able to deliver and install the vault toilet until spring. And so with that said,

46:47 Certainly, I think, Angie just said you're cutting in and out. Oh, my apologies. Thank you very much, Grace. I appreciate it. So, if the board gives us direction today to secure the contract with LB Foster, I would also like to receive direction that with that contract in place, we would be able to move forward with preparing an RFP for the second phase of the project.

47:15 Which is the recreation planning phase and developing an RFP in advance of delivery and installation of the toilet. Concludes my overview of this item and I'm happy to take your questions. Thank you. Thank you very much. Any questions for Elaine? Is the maintenance of the toilet still going to be the same as with the current toilets? Like does the Forest Service currently maintain the toilet and are they going to continue? Yes, it would be the Forest Service.

47:47 That'd be a climbers coalition, right? And the gentleman that I'm working with on the forest side, Mr. Durgo, he seems to have very close contact with the climbers coalition and volunteer projects for the forest. So I can get further clarification from him on that. Okay.

48:12 One thing, this is an action item, so we'll vote on this in a second, but Dan, I know we've had some particular sort of idiosyncratic challenges up in Mammoth Lakes with the installations and toilets. Do you have anything you'd want to add to this that may help inform the board on what to expect here in the buttermilk? The elements we run into is, again, contract, lead time, those types of elements as mentioned. The most recent project, Forest Service, was done. We had to go back and assist with some just...

48:42 Basic landscape cleaning up to keep them safe. The other side, Elaine mentioned that, is you really don't want this to turn into a public works project for the ESCOG. That has a whole other requirements and you have to get a DIR certified contractor, et cetera. Having the Foreign Service take the lead on that side of it is very beneficial versus having ESCOG actually be the contractor, if you will, for that. So I think that's one of those.

49:11 You know, administrative things we want to be real cautious about. We start to get into that process. It just adds, again, a whole other layer of complication and whole bidding process for that. We run into that utilizing nonprofit and other groups, depending how we structure it. Sometimes they run into the same problem of being the public work if we're actually paying for it. That's just a good kind of a learning, and Destin, I'm sure you know about this. It's a good learning thing for the ESCOG that staying out of that.

49:41 Public work implementation thing is a very important thing for all of us to be aware of as we go forward. The other thing I would just caution is when we're dealing with a contractor installing the toilet, that the finished work may or may not be something that volunteers can do. What I've just seen in Mammoth and the Lakes Basin up at the Coldwater Trailhead with these toilets, I don't know if the stuff that's been left undone or the finished work is really something that volunteers can do. So I would just encourage staff as we get into this to say, now look, what...

50:10 How are you really going to leave this thing? And is this really something that volunteers can be able to do the finished stuff? Or is there anything that gets into that public work arena that we don't want to get into? And I think I would encourage you to be very mindful of that. What's the vision of the extent of the finished work? My recollection of it from 25 years ago is a backhoe backfill.

50:34 The space between the hole and the new vault that's put in. Come on up to Coldwater, Dan. Come up to Horser and take a look at what we're looking at. It's kind of scary. Yeah, we ran into where they set the toilets, just the concrete, the gap between that and the rocks and the dirt created tripping hazards, and we were very concerned with somebody stepping out of the restrooms and having a trip and fall accident, and then whether that's after the contractor, the Forest Service, etc.

51:02 As far as the legal stuff, but the other side of that is just, we don't want one of our residents or guests to be injured in that type of a system. So it's, they weren't able to complete that. Some of that's putting some landscaping back, but just clearing the dirt and the rocks to make it actually accessible without having to trip over the two to four inch, six inch concrete slab was problematic. Just, it's just a, you know, caution. Heads up, yeah. So.

51:32 So any other questions, Bob, Stacy, you guys good? Can we put a big plaque on it? Says ESCOG. All of our names on it. Big photo, 3D hologram, yeah. Mine at the top for the design. All right. So I think we're ready for a motion here, unless there's any additional questions or discussion. And certainly entertain a motion if someone wants to make one. I'll move for approval.

52:02 Okay, and that would be staff request the ESCO board award the bid for the butternut infrastructure and recreation planning initiative phase one toilet infrastructure LB Foster CXT products for an amount not to exceed $77,330. Okay, we have a motion, a second, any additional discussion? Not seeing any. Angie, if you could please call the roll.

52:25 I forget that you're in space, but please call the roll. Thank you. Certainly. We're having a few technical difficulties. I could not catch who seconded. I believe Supervisor Griffith. That was Linda Salcedo. Linda Salcedo. All right. Thank you. Chair Wentworth? Yes. Vice Chair Totharo? Aye. Okay. It looks like you froze. I'm sorry. That was an aye. Thank you so much. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Corliss?

52:58 Yes. Supervisor Gardner. Yes. Supervisor Griffiths. Yes. And Councilmember Salcedo. Yes. Thank you. Excellent. Thank you very much. And Elaine, thanks for all your work navigating all that with forest staff, forest engineers, who are now going to be maybe right down the hall. And thank you also to Ms. Hugla for her assistance in preparing the bid documents and helping guide us through the forest service procedures as well.

53:29 Okay, good. Thank you, Grace. Okay, so this next item, I'm going to recuse myself. I serve on the board of something called MLTPA that may be participating as a subcontractor for someone responding to the RFP. Not clear yet, but in the interest of full disclosure and transparency, I'm going to hand this over to Mr. Tothrow, and I'll be out in the hall. Okay. Okay. We'll call you when we're done. Yeah, that's where I'll be. And this is item number 5.3, approval of request.

53:57 Request for Proposals for Towns to Trails Plan. Elaine again, surprise. Good morning once more. Again, tangible progress on implementation of one of the grants that we've received and moved through contracting.

54:16 at the June meeting, your board approved an RFP document for the towns to, or I'm sorry, you approved the contract for the town to trails plan. Staff at this time is bringing back a request for proposals for planning, recreation planning, trails planning services for the implementation of the project.

54:36 The trails plan will identify existing trails and other soft surface infrastructure as a baseline of desired trail alignments and identify connectivity gaps that may require new infrastructure with the ambition of developing a map and plan network from Alpine County, Southern Alpine County to Lone Pine, connecting the communities of the Eastern Sierra.

55:01 and identifying opportunities to connect those communities to their recreation destinations. The RFP includes standard planning procedures for community outreach, developing a library and a database of existing infrastructure and infrastructure gaps.

55:26 And then the deliverables would be a GIS map of proposed alignments, identifying opportunities for infrastructure improvements to create new connections. And those could include things like signage, wayfinding signage, informational signage, new trail development if needed, bridges, for instance, and then publication of that to the public. The grant award.

55:54 It was for $370,000, and that budget included approximately $40,000 for administration of the grant, and staff is requesting today that the ESCOG Board approve the RFP for the Towns to Trails Planning Services, and direct staff to notice the request for proposals accordingly. Thank you. Any questions or comments from the Board? I think it's time to move ahead. Good one. Any...

56:24 Anybody on Zoom that's wanting to comment? No public comments at this time. Okay, then we'll request a motion. So moved. Second. We have a motion to second. Andrew, can you call the roll, please? Vice Chair Totharo? Aye. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes.

57:07 Council Member Salcedo. Yes. Thank you. Passes unanimously with one more crucial. Thank you. Excuse myself a moment. Thank you. After resolution of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments to establish a program of work to be known as the ESCOG Economic Resiliency Pilot. Elaine, what's this all about? And good evening once more.

57:52 I'm going to go ahead and take a moment in the end letter presentation for this item. Thank you. Everybody you see out there in the universe? Very good. Thank you. Thank you for confirming that we've had issues with that in the past. So again, good morning. This is an item that we have discussed before your board, I believe at least at the June meeting previously.

58:30 I think that there has been an opportunity in the past, in your past agenda packets for you to approve, or I'm sorry, for you to review this resolution and draft form. I'm going to go over a little bit about the intent and the opportunity that this resolution supports and some of the changes that have been made to the resolution since your last meeting. So as we've discussed,

58:57 At several previous meetings, there's two significant economic development planning opportunities coming to the Eastern Sierra that are going to be implemented concurrently, I believe starting really in about October. The first is the state-funded community economic resilience fund, and the second is the federally funded comprehensive economic development strategy. These opportunities will come for funding.

59:27 for the ESCOG, as I described previously and can elaborate on, the SURF funding does have a $250,000 set aside for the ESCOG to do on the ground public outreach and coordination. So participation in or approval of the SURF resolution and the authorities that it would empower the ESCOG with by your board and the member agencies does not

59:57 request any additional funding from the member agencies. It does have a timeline and a sunset of two to three years. And the resolution would require all four member agencies to approve it for the ESCOG to have those authorities as described by the Joint Powers Agreement. So I'll provide a quick overview of the SURF fund first. We have

1:00:23 I had several presentations throughout the region on this, so please forgive me if it's redundant. As you're aware, it is a one-time $600 million opportunity through the state of California that has two phases for funding. The first is the planning phase, which begins in October, and that provides $5 million to different subregions across the state of California.

1:00:47 to develop a regional economic development plan. And the second phase is the implementation phase. It says planning phase, forgive me. But it is the implementation phase, and that has $500 million set aside in rolling competitive implementation grants for implementation of either projects and opportunities identified in the surf or in a SEDS document. Inyo and Mono counties are included within the eastern Sierra subregion, which also includes five counties on the west side.

1:01:18 So an overview of timing, the applications for the conveners for that $5 million planning phase were due July 25th, and the Sierra Business Council did submit that application to be a convener. The state anticipates that they would finalize contracts with those conveners in October, which would be a project kickoff, is when we'd anticipate a project kickoff, and then in fall.

1:01:45 The state is proposing that they would release the implementation phase draft guidelines. Obviously, if the state were to slip on that a little bit, it might be beneficial to everyone. As mentioned, Sierra Business Council applied to be the SURF convener. And as part of their proposal to build up that $5 million budget amount, they set aside $500,000

1:02:16 for the Eastern Sierra, not the Eastern Sierra subregion, but the Eastern Sierra as we think of it, so Inyo, Mono and Alpine Counties for relationship building and on the ground outreach. And they set aside $250,000 specifically to the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments to be coordinating that outreach. They also set aside $250,000 as I described for placement of staff in the Bishop Business Resource Center. I have a question.

1:02:45 Is the locally based coordinator ESCOG? Yes. Okay. Their proposal to the state described it as a contractual relationship with ESCOG to be the locally based coordinator. I'll also provide a quick overview of the federal SEDS opportunity.

1:03:07 So a SEDS is required by the Economic Development Administration to pull in any kind of funding, federal funding from that agency for economic development activities. Eastern Sierra does not have a SEDS either within Inyo or Mono County, and we are a little bit unique as a region in not having one of those in place. It identifies opportunities for lots of different projects, but those can include things like broadband, water and sewer systems, infrastructure projects.

1:03:36 This, over the period of COVID, and I don't remember exactly when, because COVID's all such a blur, there was a tourism opportunity that the Eastern Sierra couldn't participate in because we didn't have a SEDS, and there's obviously different needs and opportunities that we were interested in applying for at the time that we couldn't access. The Rural County Representatives of California, or RC, has a

1:04:05 received a grant from the Economic Development Administration and was working with Inyo County as the lead agency to develop a SEDS for the region. And so this resolution would also request not that necessarily that the ESCOG would receive funding through that, but that there would be authorities for the ESCOG to participate in the development of the SEDS, which is being spearheaded by Inyo County.

1:04:31 So that's an overview of the opportunity that is available to the Eastern Sierra, in particular through the ESCOG's approval of this resolution and the support from the member agencies for us to receive funding for participation and coordination of the SURF opportunity. What this resolution allows the ESCOG to do is to receive funding to participate in the SURF planning process.

1:04:58 to participate in the SEDS process, to serve as a local coordinator for the implementation of the planning phase of the SEDS process, and then it also, those authorities would expire at the conclusion of the planning phase. One of the concerns we heard from regional management was that they wanted to ensure that the scope was very defined.

1:05:24 So once that plan is completed and there's clear deliverables and actionable recommendations that come under those planning efforts, the ESCOG at that time would return to the member agencies with clearly defined scope and authorities to do implementation work. With that, that concludes my overview of the resolution.

1:05:53 And staff would recommend that the board adopt a resolution of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments to establish a program of work to be known as the ESCOG Economic Resiliency Fund and to seek approval from the member agencies from this work. Thank you. Thank you. Really nice presentation. I think this is useful for all the member agencies to be working off this thing. I know it is a little fix to do with that planning versus the implementation wording, but other than that, it's really nice. Who's got questions?

1:06:23 I just have one question. Well, I have two. Elaine, could you forward us this slide deck? It's really good. Thank you. Many times as you read it, it's always good to read it one more time. There's a lot of stuff in there. And this resolution then covers everything we need to do today. It does. And since bringing you a draft in the past, we've made it much more concise.

1:06:53 And that was through, you know, collaboration and feedback from all of the regional managers. And so it is very specific in that it allows the ESCOG to receive funding for implementation and serve, has authorities to implement the planning phase and serve as coordinator, to participate in the SEDS planning effort as well, and that there is a horizon on that program. All right. Good we got all that crafted up.

1:07:23 That's an accomplishment. Thank you. Can you just say what you just said one more time? So the SURF is going to help with the SEDS planning or the SEDS is going to help with the SURF planning? They're concurrent and distinct efforts that have similar acronyms. They work in parallel. And they work in parallel. So the SURF funding.

1:07:52 is an initiative from the state of California that was initially funded through American Rescue Plan X funding. And so they have a vision of establishing these regional economic development plans for these 13 separations. And there's this very tight horizon to that. And there's a $5 million planning grant over a two-year horizon is...

1:08:20 Huge amount of money, in my opinion. And so the state has, I think, pretty high ambitions of what that plan will include. They want to establish demographic baselines, economic baselines. They're trying to create a whole library of all of the economic development plans and different planning efforts within the region. So we've already been sending over, for instance, the Bishop Economic Development Plan or the Sustainable Recreation Tourism Initiative. They want to roll all that up to sort of define

1:08:49 What the economic clusters are within a region and the relationships they want to address, climate action and pivoting to climate resiliency and equity as well. So that's the state effort. Completely distinct to that, but related and necessary and on a concurrent timeline is the SEDS effort. And that was identified as a gap for a region in being able to access federal funding.

1:09:17 And irrespective of whether or not the surf had existed, it just happens to exist at the same time, that is something that Inyo and Mono County should be collaborating on to establish and put in place. So why do we have them as one resolution? Because they are concurrent activities that are going to overlap and I think it's just there's a lot of efficiency in the ESCOG being able to participate.

1:09:46 Paid in both of those activities concurrently. They're both economic development. Sure, sure. Supervisor Griffith. So did you make the logo? I did not make the logo. I will have to thank Mr. Wentworth for putting that together. Nice Photoshop skills. Nice logo. Put in Lone Point and Bridgeport. Sure, of course. Just trying to keep it clean, you know, aesthetically. But this was developed for the

1:10:21 for a whole other projects. Okay, so I have one last question. Sure. So we know that the Sierra Business Council is the convener. Where does the SBDC fit in? Because they're out of Kern County, but there are, do they fit in at all into this as our? There's a lot of.

1:10:48 There's so many overlapping economic development opportunities in the Eastern Sierra right now. So the small business development center that is based out of Bakersfield and has jurisdiction over our region will probably be included in the surf and sets planning process because they coordinate small business development for our area. They have jurisdiction over us. But they're just, they stop at Inyo County, right? No, they have jurisdiction over Mono. Oh, they do. Okay. Yeah.

1:11:18 But they did not elect to put in an application as the convener. So the Sierra Business Council did. The Sierra Business Council has lots of initiatives that sort of live within that organization, their wheelhouse. And so they felt like they had appropriate relationships to be coordinating that, the surf effort for the Eastern Sierra region.

1:11:41 Particularly since they have established relationships on the west side as well with those western Sierra communities that are part of the eastern Sierra sub-region. The Bakersfield SBDC would be obviously included and consulted as part of the preparation of all these plants and part of the outreach because we still have that relationship with them and serving our community. And the Bakersfield SBDC also has that relationship

1:12:11 to the Small Business Development Center that's being set up in Bishop, that Inyo County is spearheading, and that Baker, Kelly Bearden at the Bakersfield SBDC and the SBC have, they have communicated and they're in agreement about how they will be cooperating to serve the region. Great. Good? Yeah. Good. There's always extracurricular conversations if needed, so. Got it. Supervisor Griffith.

1:12:43 I would just say that I appreciate this approach of keeping it very specific and putting the timeline on it. I think just doing a resolution that just forever and ever puts economic development into our portfolio would cause some heartburn amongst some of our colleagues. So I'm fully supportive of this approach and I think it's the right way to go. And thank you for doing all of the work to herd all of the cats in the one place. Very much my pleasure. Thank you.

1:13:13 Dan, you're good? Mono County, any thoughts from up north? Let's get on with it. This is where we need to go sooner rather than later. Thank you. Thank you, Uncle Bob. Stacey, anything from you? Fully support this, agree with the approach. Just a note, back to Karen's question, I don't think Elaine mentioned it, but...

1:13:39 Sierra Business Council runs the Small Business Development Center for the Tahoe Region. I get so confused by the state's various regional blocks that I don't, I couldn't tell you exactly what that includes, but Sierra Business Council's Economic Empowerment arm runs, already runs a Small Business Development Center, so they're quite tuned into that. And if there's a need to make a, I don't know if there's further discussion, I'd be happy to.

1:14:08 Make a motion to approve this resolution. Okay, Stacey, we'll take that motion. I've got a couple quick things for staff and then we'll take that motion. So it sounds like there's consensus of the board to approve this. So going forward, our next step is obviously to take it out to the member agencies. I think there's consensus that everybody would like to have access to the presentation. So Elaine, if any final tweaks you need to make, but let's share that with everybody. I think, Grace, also when we've done this in the past that you've provided a...

1:14:37 The resolution and staff support to the four agencies are all on the same page. We're not, nobody's doing anything different with any of the resolutions. It's consistent. And along with the staff report, Elaine, if you want to provide that, maybe based on this one to go out as well. My only final thought is that on the title of the resolution, what's in the packet right now is the

1:14:58 ESCOG Community Economic Resilience Fund Phase 1 Program. And I think to Supervisor Griffith's point, that might cause a little bit of heartburn. I think Elaine, you did a great job with identifying this as a pilot program. Perhaps we could rename just the title of this to be the Community Economic Resilience Fund Pilot Program, consistent with the presentation. So it's clear to everybody, this is a pilot. And that...

1:15:22 And to your point, the focus is good. It's appropriate. I think we'll get support from all the agencies. But there should be the understanding that if good projects come out of the surf, if good projects come out of the sets thing, the ESCOG will be coming back with realistic and appropriate recommendations for things that are going to benefit the region and that we're being responsible in this pilot part of it. But everybody should know that if we find any gold out there in our hills, we're coming back and saying, let's go get it.

1:15:51 I'll leave it at that. So, Stacey, does your, I'm assuming your motion stand at this point with the caveat to rename the resolution? I support that as the motion maker. Okay. Is there a second? Second. Second from Mr. Tothero. Any additional discussion? Hearing none, Angie, if you could please call the roll on this question. Thank you. Chair Wentworth? Yes. Vice Chair Tothero? Aye. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Corliss?

1:16:22 Yes. Supervisor Gardner. Yes. Supervisor Griffiths. Yes. And Councilmember Salcedo. Yes. Thank you. Thank you. The resolution is approved unanimously. Big thanks to staff, to Lane and Grace and all the CAOs, Destin, Dan, everybody else who worked so hard to bring this thing into focus and to get something to where we need it to be. I think there's also sort of an anecdotal expectation that our member agencies will act on this quickly.

1:16:53 So we can bring it back at our next meeting in October, and hopefully we'll have all the various boards will have voted by then. I know there's been some interest in having this done before the election. It's coming up in November, so it will be good to have that done if that's possible. So I know that we'll all work hard to make that happen. Understood. Good. So thank you all very much. Very exciting days for the ESCOG. So let's move in on then to the Executive Director Update Report on the Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem Management Program.

1:17:24 Thank you. So I wanted to provide a few updates on the CDFW NEPA project that ESCOG has overseen and administering. So the White Bark ID team has completed all of their contracting work and all of their hires were local and have housing in the area, which was deemed an important consideration.

1:17:54 They have established a regular meeting with their sub-consultants and have kicked off the NEPA project. All of their early tasks are focused on completion of the proposed action due to staffing changes on the U.S. Forest Service side, and so Whitebark has absorbed some of those responsibilities within their organization. They've also begun tribal consultation.

1:18:19 Which there's a new approach under the Section 106 compliance for large NEPA projects. And so they are doing, they've developed a heritage implementation plan with extensive tribal consultation. I've sat on on one of those meetings and it was very impressive, the amount of participation and the depth that they were getting in coordinating with different tribes for feedback. And they're anticipating that scoping will be conducted in September or early October.

1:18:49 I'm sorry to interrupt. Angie, could you possibly stop sharing the screen of the presentation so we can see our friends in Mono County? I apologize. I actually stopped the screen sharing about 10 minutes ago or at least five minutes ago, so I'm not sure why it's still showing. It's not showing here on our end. I must have done something wrong. I'm sorry. You're forgiven because we can see Bob and Stacey, so we're good. Thank you.

1:19:18 Thank you very much for letting me know. So staff attended the whitebark field trip to the donut project in July. It was really nice to see some of the board members there that day to take a field visit out of the office and go see the work that's being conducted on the ground for fuels treatments in the Mammoth area. The same day, we also had a conversation with an organization known as called Blue Forest.

1:19:46 which has a very interesting venture capital model that they're proposing for implementation of things like watershed restoration, where basically they look at the downstream beneficiaries of projects such as fuel reduction and are able to identify investors on the front end to fund that work and then get a return on that investment to pay the investors back.

1:20:14 Based on the end users and the beneficiaries of some of that work, they have an interest in fuels reduction work in the Eastern Sierra. And so they're having conversations with WhiteBark and really more spearheaded by our partners at the Forest Service as a potential alternative financing model for projects on forest lands.

1:20:35 I also had an opportunity to meet with another more traditional venture capital group that is interested in bringing investments into the Eastern Sierra, known as Sunstone Investment, and they're looking at, I know they're coordinating with different jurisdictions and municipalities, Inyo, Mono, Town of Mammoth Lakes, City of Bishop, for project opportunities to

1:20:56 bring different vegetable capital models potentially into the Eastern Sierra as well. So that's an exciting opportunity that I just wanted to have on your radar. At our last meeting, I suppose it was a special meeting in July, staff had presented that there was a Strategic Growth Council grant for regional climate collaboratives that we were considering bringing back to the board for consideration in the future based on the

1:21:24 all the conversations of participating in the SURF and staffing and the extent of work it would require to implement that project and determine there is not capacity to pursue that project at this time, but that was round one funding. We're optimistic that there will be round two in the future and hope to work with your board to consider that grant opportunity in the future as well. And to that end, I took under consideration

1:21:53 Councilman Salcedo's recommendation to establish an ad hoc committee such that when those types of grant opportunities arise, I could go to a subcommittee of the ESCOG and we would be able to vet those and bring back a recommendation to the board. And based on the conversations that I've had with council and other regional managers, it wouldn't help with circumventing any of the Brown Act requirements necessarily. So unfortunately, I don't think there's efficiencies.

1:22:20 Gained in that model, but it would be my hope that with additional staff capacity, I would be able to enjoy coordinating with you directly and individually on a more regular basis. That concludes my department head report for today or my executive director report. I'm happy to take any questions on those items. Thank you. The only, I'm sorry, anybody thoughts, questions? No, anybody mono? The only thing in my conversation with,

1:22:50 Council Member Ellis, sort of a concern about, well, what is something happening in some other part of the region? How does that benefit a locality? Or how does that, what's in it for us? I think that the question we always all have to always be asking ourselves, what is it that we're doing? How is it going to benefit the region? We have to come back to that. Sometimes it may take a sec to kind of extrapolate and figure out what that means. But certainly the work that's happening up there with Mammoth, with fire and all that kind of stuff.

1:23:19 We're getting a lot of bugs out of the system. And I would really encourage Inyo County, City of Bishop, just, you know, pay attention. If you want to come on a field trip, you want to know what the hell's going on up there. And perhaps start looking at what are the fire projects, certainly the wildfire projects that involve federal agencies. What do you guys got going? Let's start bringing those things forward. Let's start bringing those up. Because I know that that project at least is getting a certain amount of visibility with the California Wildfire Resilience Task Force.

1:23:44 Because they're looking at it as a multi-sector. It's got recreation in it. It's got workforce development. It's got fire in it. And if there are projects that you guys know about, Bishop and Inyo County, whatever, start bringing those things forward so we can really build on the work that's going on up there. And it has lack of smoke for all of us. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. So just a thought. Thank you very much, Elaine, for that. And so we'll move on now, I guess, to our board member reports. Is that where we're at?

1:24:14 Yes, that's where we're at, John. Answer your own question, you fool. Let's start virtually with our friends in the universe. So Mono County, Bob, Andrew, Stacey, what's happening up in Mono County? Yeah, all right. Mono Chair Gardner is motioning for me to start. So one thing I thought would be of interest to the ESCOG is very recently our board approved

1:24:44 A new Office of Emergency Management with Director Chris McCrassick, who prior to this served as our Chief of Emergency Medical Services. So we're really excited about this. The office will cover the full spectrum of emergency prevention, response, and recovery. The new director seems to, in his discussions with our board,

1:25:12 Really want to focus on great communication. And then yesterday, I'll let the town report on this, they actually did a training exercise. So excited that we're moving forward with that. It's especially exciting to not, you know, actually be evacuating or dealing with wildfire smoke. So it's a great time to be able to look at this. And just also wanted to, not necessarily a Mono County thing, but the state wildfire and forest resilience task force.

1:25:40 is doing another in-person meeting in, well, they say this year in Nevada, it's Grass Valley. I would really consider that the foothills, but can't quibble. But that meeting takes place September 27th and 28th. Our own ESCOG chair will be presenting on a recreation-related plan for the task force and a lot of other great stuff happening.

1:26:09 Check that out. WildfireTaskforce.org is the website you can attend in person or remotely. I will be there. And I bet my dear colleague, John Wentworth, will be there too. Thanks. Bob, what do you have for us? I just mentioned quickly, I mentioned at the last meeting that we had our Children's Summit on July 13th. It was a good event and several priorities were identified and we'll be talking more about that.

1:26:36 in terms of task forces and perhaps initiatives that we can pursue on that. And the other thing is Monday night is the monthly session of the Citizens Wildfire Academy, supported by ESCOG and others. Thank you, Jeff, for a great recommendation for a speaker. The topic on Monday night is home hardening and defensible space. And I think we have really a couple of great speakers that will make a presentation and provide.

1:27:02 residents and guests basically the opportunity to learn a lot more about protecting their home and how to be in best shape concerning wildfire prevention. And that's again Monday night the 15th at 6 o'clock. I think that's all we have. I have. Thank you very much. We're going to stick with the county theme here. So I'm going to turn to Mr.

1:27:27 Supervisor Totho, then Supervisor Griffith, what's happening in Indiana County? A couple things. We're in the process of filling a soon-to-be-vacated CAO position. Leslie Chapman is retiring. And as I'm sure all of you know, the south half of our county got hit pretty hard with a number of rains and lots of flooding and lots of work to keep roads open.

1:27:58 It would be nice if we could have gentle range rather than all at once, but that's the way life is. Jeff, do you have anything? Yeah, so the flooding stranded over a thousand people in Death Valley and also stranded hundreds of campers in the Sierra because it cut off the road access to get them out. So the county spent a lot of time getting those folks out and sheltering them and everything went relatively smoothly.

1:28:27 But that leads into another topic, which is we are extending our TOT tax to include campgrounds and RV parks, just because there are quite a few services that are required for those folks, and I believe Mono County already does extend it to campgrounds and RV parks, so that will be going before the voters in the next election. And the only other thing I have to add is we have a new company that is offering skydiving trips in Lone Pine.

1:28:57 Let's skydive Mount Whitney. Thank you for that. I'll start with the town of Mammoth Lakes. I know the mayor's got some things to add to this. So just a question for you. The TOT thing for the campgrounds is going to be on the ballot, correct? Yes, that's right. Okay, good.

1:29:16 That's very exciting. I know the town, Mammoth Lakes, and Mono County, we all collect TOT from the campgrounds. I know there's an effort happening regionally for the group called Quantified Ventures that may reach out to you guys. You've probably met them before. I think they're coming back out here in September. There's a certain amount of momentum now starting to build around that project with some pilot projects. And what that will say is that we will, if approved, collect TOT on all short-term rentals. Okay.

1:29:45 Including campgrounds. All of them. Okay, good. That's, yeah. If I could ask, could I ask a question? Of course. On that, I want to make sure, when we say campgrounds, these are, are these all campgrounds, including National Forest campgrounds, or just private campgrounds? It's all campgrounds. It becomes a little bit tricky if it is a Forest Service run campground versus a concessionaire campground on Forest Service land.

1:30:14 My understanding is that you cannot collect a tax from another government agency. So, for instance, concurrent, so we have county campgrounds that we can't tax ourselves, but we are instituting a user fee that is equivalent to what the tax would be. Okay, yeah, I asked that question in Mono County, and I'm not sure where we stand on that, so thank you for that clarification. We need to follow up.

1:30:46 Yeah, and I think on that quantified ventures program, I think they're looking at a pilot that would include some campgrounds in Mono County, maybe a couple campgrounds in Mammoth, some campgrounds in Inyo County, so they're going to be out here. I want to make sure they get in touch with you guys to talk about that. Yeah, and that issue of taxing is, I don't think that that is related to all government agencies. I think that's a federal supremacy issue, and so any of the federal agencies are what we

1:31:16 Don't have the authority to collect. We may tax them, and if they wish to pay, they can, but that's voluntary. Federal supremacy, Bob. I guess I will add that we also considered raising the TOT tax from 12% to 14% and declined, or to put it on the ballot tax. In all my career, you never, ever used the phrase federal supremacy. Right. I heard it here first.

1:31:48 After 30 years of federal supremacy, I use it often. After 30 years of federal survival, we never use it. Yeah. Well, to pick up on the election theme, there are elections happening obviously in November. I'm running for re-election for the Mammoth Lakes Town Council. We had a very interesting tour that the staff put together of the...

1:32:16 of the parcel site of the housing there. It's very exciting and hopefully to have some more public tours coming up maybe later in September, October. I know staff is working on that. We've had a smoke-free so far, knock wood, pretty smoke-free summer. The numbers, I don't know if they're regressing to the meme, but sort of back in a world that looks at least for the moment somewhat kind of normal, but the TOT is still strong.

1:32:40 It's busy and it's fun and that's about all I have to say. So Karen, City of Bishop update and then between Linda and Dan, I'm sure we can close up any mammoth loose strings. So the City of Bishop repurposed a Sterling Heights studio, Sterling Heights assisted living into studio apartments. So that passed with our planning commission a few weeks ago. So we will add

1:33:10 Correct me if I'm wrong, 68 units, is that right? 69 units to our housing stock, which is huge. And it's right downtown, which is great. We also, Elaine, is pursuing businesses to now comply with our new signage ordinance. So we will have a more cohesive downtown look soon. That's going to be fun. Yeah. I was going to say. No comment.

1:33:40 The cohesive look will probably take a while, but it will happen. And those are, that's the only updates that I have. Thank you. Good report, John, as always. The only thing I have to add is that last night was a little party for Chief Frank Frivald, who is retiring from his position as Mammoth Lakes Fire Chief, and his successor has been named as Alish Tomer, and he has been a long time.

1:34:08 Employee of Mammoth Lakes Fire District and will be a great replacement for Frank, but we will miss him. And I think COVID wore him out, that whole incident command system. He ran for the year and a half. I think he's ready to take it easy a little bit. So that was a great event out at the Hayden cabin. Other than that, I think you got it all, John. Good. Okay. So I think finally, as we wrap up, one thing that Elaine and I did talk a little bit about is

1:34:35 to provide with members of the ESCOG, just a little simple report out, because we're doing, you know, we're taking actions and we're doing things that may be helpful when you report back to your board's action items, maybe a simple sentence or two, these are the things that happened, this is very helpful. Yeah, so that we can really start, we've, we, I think we've recognized we've got a lot of communication, communicating that we have to do.

1:34:57 And I think, you know, we are a joint powers authority. We're taking action. We're getting into the staff business. Money's flying around. I think it's going to be very helpful to make sure those lines of communication are clear and open. And Dan, I'm sorry, did you have anything you wanted to add from the town of Mammoth Lakes? Yes, please. If I may, I want to just note two regional exercises that we recently did, touched on briefly. We did an evacuation drill of the trail subdivision here in Mammoth.

1:35:24 Testing out some of our Office of Emergency Services stuff, the whole co-read, iPods, how do we notify people, but that involved about 10 to 12 different departments across multiple agencies, board service to town, the county, social services, etc. So we had a lot of people engaged in that, a half-day exercise. Overall, it went very well. A couple of things we need to work on, but it was a good live exercise. By our side, I actually did some of their own exercising with

1:35:54 Hose roll out and putting water on the bushes, etc. So that went really well. Prior to that, we also had an active shooter exercise, a full-day exercise at the Mammoth Elementary School. Again, about 10 different agencies involved in that from Inyo Mono Counties to Town, Forest Service, Highway Patrol, Hospital, EMS, Fire, whole nine yards there.

1:36:18 Really great exercise in terms of a couple different scenarios. The mayor and I were able to pop in to see one of those. But that regional effort going on at those levels here as we're doing a lot of this training work and exercising, I think, is really valuable. And ultimately, for our remoteness, we will be relying on each other heavily in any of these types of incidents. So the cooperation across the agencies was great to see. Excellent. Thank you.

1:36:48 And Destin, I don't want to put you on the spot, but would you close us out today with a report from the City of Bishop? Oh, of course, yeah. So last Friday, we put together, Elaine and I, a little housing forum between the city, the county, the tribe, Forest Service, BLM. We're all talking about this issue individually and collectively. I think we have a better chance of...

1:37:18 Coming up with something, you know, nobody really thinks about the tribe as being an opportunity for employee housing or something. And they were very interested. They actually appear to have maybe a worse situation than even we do. Yeah, they need, you know, they have the health clinic and they have nowhere to put any doctors, nurses. And then they have a huge amount of problem with just their own housing for the tribe itself, their members. So, and we learned the Forest Service says they have.

1:37:47 Approximately 75 positions open. They can't fill because of housing. Yeah. And then the only player we didn't really involve was DWP because I didn't want to make it about DWP. We all know that there's some solutions there, but we just sit in there and beat them up. So we stayed away from that. And the other thing I'd like to add is next week, we're going to have our first ad hoc committee to start discussing a joint powers for fire.

1:38:15 And it'll be fire EMS and start looking at what that looks like in the bigger picture because we're having the ever-increasing problem of the private ambulance services having a hard time hiring people. I don't want to say it's our business to worry if it's profitable or not, but there's definitely some issues that we're seeing down here and I think you up there have addressed this.

1:38:40 Any advice you have to give us would be great. Yeah, call Mono County. They got it all figured out. Other than that, that's all I have to add. And I will say, though, thank you for the kind of staff meetings that we've been having, you know, six months in this seat that I'm in now. There was a lot to digest with ESCOG and catching up to it. And I appreciate those meetings. So thank you.

1:39:03 Yeah, thank you very much. And do you want to say, you've got a, I've heard you've got a new Public Works Director, is that? Oh yeah, you should say that. So we made an offer and it's accepted by Nora Gamino from the Forest Service. So Nora will be stepping in as our Public Works Director first day of September 26th. Now I've had to hold that in for a month, but we finally, she said it could be public now. So very exciting times. Very exciting. We've been working, we've all been working with Nora and Sonia.

1:39:33 Configuration, that's a great hire, so congratulations. It is, we're excited to have her. Yep. Thank you, guys. Yep, thank you very much. Okay, if there's anything else, if there's not anything else, I think we can adjourn. Anybody, we're happy? Good. Okay, so thank you all very much. Again, thanks to staff, to Elaine and Grace for pulling all these things together. And so we will now adjourn in our next meeting. Do we have a special meeting or a regular meeting? I would propose a AB 361 special meeting on September 9th.

1:40:02 Okay. Everyone's available. Come around. Good. So we'll plan again together September 9th. If there's anything else we need to add to that, we'll let you know, but September 9th it is. And then the regular meeting is October 14th. Okay, great. All right. So let's sit and stand to adjournment. Thank you all very much. Sure.