Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2024
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 09:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
76 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:42 Good morning, everyone. Sorry for the late start. We were waiting for a quorum. I want to call to order the Planning and Economic Commission meeting for, what is today, May 8th at 9 a.m.? I guess it's 9.05. Let's start with the Pledge of Allegiance. Commissioner Kennedy, I'm going to put you on the spot. If you don't mind, I'm going to go ahead and take a roll call real quick. Oh, sorry. Yep, I missed the roll call. Chair Vanderhurst is absent today. Vice Chair Burroughs? Present.
2:11 Commissioner Chang. Here. Commissioner Kennedy. Here. And Vice Chair, excuse me, and Commissioner Eckert is absent today. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Commissioner Kennedy. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you.
2:38 At this time, I'd like to open it up for public comments. This includes anything that is not on the agenda. Any public comments for items that are on the agenda will be taken at the time that we address that topic. Are there any public comments on Zoom? No comments at this time. Any public comments in this room? No. Okay, moving on. We will...
3:06 Open up public hearings and our first public hearing is on the consideration of variance 24-001 to permit a 62% reduction of the 10 foot east side yard setback requirement and I believe Nolan is our staff contact for this today. Great, thank you. Let me go ahead and share my screen. Alright, so this is the public hearing for variance application number 2024-001.
3:49 The application requests the reduction of the required 10-foot east side yard setback for construction of an enclosed access stairway to replace an existing unenclosed access stairway at the same location. The property is a steep upsloping lot located at 682 Canyon Place. The variance request is for a 62% reduction of the 10-foot east side yard setback. The resulting setback will be then 3 feet 10 inches.
4:18 Whereas the normal required setback on that side is 10 feet. A reduction of the east side yard setback would allow for the construction of the fully enclosed access stairway. The area of encroachment is a total of 58 square feet. And on the screen here is a rendering the existing house, the existing garage, and there on the kind of bottom right corner shows the proposed enclosed stairway. The existing single-family home was built in 1979.
4:50 The application narrative describes the need for an enclosed entry stairway to improve accessibility to the home, provide safety for the homeowners and reduced maintenance. The narrative explains that the accessibility to the residents
5:18 is limited during winter because the stairway becomes impassable due to snow accumulation, which creates a serious life safety issue for the occupants. The property owners express concern that the existing conditions would negatively impact response time of first responders if emergency access to the houses necessary during the winter. The existing garage was constructed with a reduced front setback of five feet due to the steep slope of the property and it
5:48 The garage additionally encroaches an additional two feet into the front and east side yard setbacks, which are existing non-conforming conditions on the property. The location of the property at the end of a cul-de-sac results in a front property line that curves into the property, which is likely the reason why the front of the garage encroaches into the front setback. This site plan illustrates the location and length of the existing exterior access stairway.
6:17 The proposed enclosed access stairway and mudroom design replaces the existing exterior access stairway and landings and improves the livability of the property. With approval of the variance, the proposed addition will provide the existing home with a functional enclosed entry that significantly improves the functionality and appearance of the existing home. This slide illustrates the interior layout of the enclosed access stairway.
6:47 which is a relatively modest addition to the existing home that results in a significant improvement to the practical use and maintenance of the property by creating safer year-round access to and from the home. In addition to the steep topography of the site, the shape of the lot is irregular and features a substandard width of 40 feet at the front of the property, with the widest portion of the lot being located at the rear of the site. This condition with
7:15 Combined with the placement of the detached garage at the front of the property and the area available to create a covered entryway while maintaining the required setback areas and minimum number of garage parking spaces. Staff has made affirmative findings for the seven required findings for approval of the variance. The required findings are then shown on the screen here.
7:44 Additionally, no public comments have been received on the application. It was published in the newspaper for two weeks prior to today's public hearing and notices were sent out to all property owners within 300 feet of the property. With that, staff's recommendation is to make all the required findings and approve the variance with conditions as recommended by staff. With that, that concludes my presentation.
8:15 AVAILABLE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMISSION. WE ALSO HAVE MIKE BRITTAN. HE'S THE APPLICANT REPRESENTING THE PROPERTY OWNERS HERE PRESENT TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. MIKE, DID YOU HAVE ANY PRESENTATION YOU WANTED TO GIVE OR ANYTHING? MIKE. MIKE BRITTAN. RELATIVELY THE SAME FOOTPRINT AS THE EXISTING STAIR. SO IT'S A MORE ACCESSIBLE HOME YEAR ROUND. AND ONE OF THE IMPORTANT FACTORS WAS THE FACT THAT
8:58 You know, last winter, if a first responder ever needed to get there, they would not have been able to without some touring gear or snowshoes or some way to get up there. It was quite a challenge. So thanks for your time. Okay. Thank you. Commissioner Kennedy, do you have any questions? My only question was just to confirm with Nolan that you guys didn't hear anything from that, I guess it was the east property owner that this butts up against.
9:28 We did not. Okay. Thank you. That's all. Commissioner Chang? Nothing important. Nothing that important. I mean, I'm just curious, you know, you see a lot of properties like this in Mammoth, right? I'm assuming that they probably had this property for a long time and they just suddenly, they just decided to do something like this. Okay.
10:08 No, I mean, I have no issue with it. Okay. Thank you. Yeah, my only question was whether or not there was any concerns from the neighbors, but it sounds like there isn't any, so I don't really have any issues with that. The neighbor to the west contacted me. Personally, I know them. They own the vacant lot, and then they own the house on the corner.
10:39 Just a general conversation about what was going on. He just wanted to make sure nothing was happening on his property line. All right. Thank you. At this time, we'll open it up to public comment. Is there any public comment on Zoom? No comments at this time. Okay. Any public comment in Suite Z? Seeing none, I'll close the public comment. Any other last-minute discussion items? Does anyone want to make a motion?
11:13 I will make a motion to adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approving variance 24-001. We don't have conditions, right? Or do I say that correct? There are conditions in the resolution. Okay, with conditions as recommended by staff. I'll second. Okay. Can we call for a vote? Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Chang? Yes.
11:49 And Commissioner Kennedy. Yes. Thank you. Okay. Approve 3-0 here. And that we will close item 5-1 and move on to business matter 6.1, general plan consistency determination for town acceptance of donated property located at 156 Lost Lane within the town's rural residential zoning district. And I believe our staff contact is Tess. Thank you. Just a minute. The item before you.
12:38 Is the proposed land donation of property located at 156 Lost Lane to the town. The current property owners submitted a letter on February 7th, 2024 indicating their desire to donate the property to the town. The property's general plan land use designation is low density residential one and the property's zoning is rural residential. The two key issues
13:08 Is the donation of the property to the town consistent with the general plan in terms of location, purpose, and extent of the proposed land donation? And is acceptance of the proposed land donation consistent with CEQA? The property that is being offered to the town is approximately one-half acre in size, vacant, and features steep terrain and dense forest. The parcel is just north of the bluff snow.
13:39 Deposition Design Zone and is within a documented avalanche runoff zone. This slide depicts the locations of the existing avalanche areas and known path starting zones. Is the donation of the property to the town consistent with the general plan in terms of location, purpose, and extent of the proposed land donation? In terms of location and purpose, the proposed land donation is consistent with the general plan.
14:16 because the town would preserve and maintain the property as open space, which will ensure that the existing native vegetation is not removed and can continue to stabilize the slope and slow any landslide snow slides. In addition, the site could contribute to snow storage capacity in the event that properties on Lost Lane are ever developed and the street is improved to be a private road.
14:41 The extent of the donation is consistent with the general plan because the property would be donated to the town through grant deed. This table summarizes specific general plan policies and an adoption and an action, excuse me, that will be satisfied by accepting the proposed land donation. The proposed land donation has been determined to be categorically exempt from the provisions of CEQA pursuant to CEQA Guideline Section 15.
15:19 32.5. Transfers of ownership of interest in land to preserve existing natural conditions and historical resources, since the project consists of the transfer of ownership in land in order to preserve open space. Based on staff's analysis, the donation of land would be consistent with the general plan. Staff recommends the Town's Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached resolution, making the required findings and determine that the Town's
15:52 The town's acceptance of property located at 156 Lost Lane is consistent with the general plan. Great. Thank you. We'll open it up to questions from the commissioners. Commissioner Ching, would you like, do you have any questions? It's kind of a stupid question, but I see Lost Lane on Google Mail. I think you just said this is not a developed road?
16:31 It isn't. So is that something that the town does not maintain at this current moment? That's correct. So it's what's called a paper road. It exists on maps. But you do see it. So you do see it. It's not maintained. It's not cleared. It would be a private road, as many of the roads out in Old Mammoth are. But there are a number of private developed lots, especially on the north side.
17:02 Northwest, northeast side of Lost Lane. That could be developed at some point in the future if those owners chose to do so. At that point, the road would need to be upgraded and then maintained to a certain standard even though it would remain a private road. I see. So it's similar to kind of Woodman actually is another good example. So if you went, Woodman kind of ends there at the Pinecrest Bed and Breakfast, but it does extend a ways further and there are some lots.
17:35 Beyond that, again, private road that if they were to develop, they would have to improve that road. I see their units, buildings, to the, according to that picture, is to the south of it, but I don't know if that's south. So those ones, yeah, that show up, shut your screen. So above Lost Lane is the bluff, so if you looked at just two-dimensional, it looks like they're right there, but they are then up above and then kind of just the way Old Mammoth.
18:07 Worse, there are some below it, kind of that are accessed off of the end of Tamarack Street. I see, okay. I'm just curious, because I never really noticed this road. Yeah, Old Mammoth is kind of a unique configuration of lots and development. It's because it's lost. Yeah, yeah. It's truly lost to me. That's all I have, thank you. Commissioner Kennedy.
18:38 Yeah, I guess I was just going to clarify similar to Paul that the properties around this lot are all privately owned. Is that correct? Yes. So this will just be a town owned parcel in the midst of other privately owned parcels. Okay. Yeah, that's all I had. I guess the only question I have is does the town plan to do anything with it or just let it be natural?
19:04 Town's plan is to let it be natural. The only real use that we would ever use it for would be snow storage at the bottom portion should Lost Lane be developed out and built out. Okay. Being a cul-de-sac, cul-de-sacs kind of create unique challenges for snow removal. Absolutely. I live on one. Any public comment on this? No comments at this time. Any public comment in Suite Z?
19:35 No, okay. Any other discussion or comments, questions? I actually have one other question. I am guessing this is the town owns other vacant parcels that are not intended. My first thought with this was, oh, this is housing since the town's working on housing, but obviously not. But this is a kind of routine procedure for the town to go through. We do. You know, we don't.
20:02 Get a ton of people coming to the town wanting to donate property, but on occasion we do. The last kind of two donations that we've worked on were properties that were desirable from an open space wildlife preservation area. So there's the large portion that is donated by Snow Creek with the conservation easement, the 15 acres at Minaret and Old Mammoth Road. And then
20:29 The years prior to that, we had a donation of about a half-acre parcel on Shadow Lane that, again, was a desirable open space parcel that we have no intention to develop on. It was just desirable from a preservation standpoint. Awesome. Perfect. That's it from me. Anything else, Commissioner Jane? All right. Would someone like to make a motion?
20:54 I can. I have it up. I'll make a motion to adopt the PEDC resolution, making the required government code findings and CEQA findings and determine that the town's acceptance of donated vacant property located at 156 Lost Lane is consistent with the general plan. I'll second. Okay. Andy, can we get a vote? Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Chang? Yes. And Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Thank you.
21:25 Okay, vote passes 3-0. That brings us to item number 7 on the agenda, which is the consent agenda. Would anyone care to make a motion to approve this, or are there any discussions or anything that we need to pull out of there? I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. I'll second. Okay. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Thank you. Item passes 3-0.
21:59 That moves us on. We're just speeding right through here. I knew we were going to. No one always gives me the light agenda. It's awesome. Item number eight, commissioner reports. Commissioner Chang, I'll start with you. Nothing for me. I did not participate in design. Okay. Commissioner Kennedy? We did have a design committee meeting. Maybe I'll let you report on that. It was pretty brief as well. But otherwise, nothing for me.
22:28 Okay, so the design committee met on the 540 Old Mammoth Road project and went over the storefront, the retail part of that property and reviewed the ADA guidelines and so that should be coming to the commission here next month is my understanding and so that project will finally be completed and that's great news.
22:56 I also attended the Sierra Jobs First Council, which is not part of this, but it kind of pertains, and Nolan will talk more about this, but it pertains to us with our planning and economic portion of this because the state is really looking to invest money into infrastructure and creating jobs, sustainable jobs within our region, and so we've partnered with
23:26 Other regions, Inyo, Alpine County, and then on the western side as well. And to bring, to figure out how we can support infrastructure to build jobs. And so their priority sectors are community health care, sustainable recreation and tourism, natural and working lands, clean energy and energy resilience, and sustainable agriculture.
23:52 In food systems. And there are a lot of smart people that attended that conference that was at the end of last month. And so there will be more coming our way. Yesterday there was kind of an open house sort of thing at the chamber talking about this and trying to get ideas out there or trying to get ideas from the community on things that we can do. And so anybody who has a plan.
24:19 has an interest in obtaining funding. They can apply for this, but it really, they're looking at how it's going to impact the region as a whole, and not just our community, but how we can build our entire region. So it was really interesting, like I said, Nolan will give more information on that as soon as we get to the director report, which is now because I have nothing further to add. So that moves us on to item number nine, director's report. Great.
24:49 So I can just continue talking about the California's jobs first to build off of what Vice Chair Burroughs mentioned. So we did attend that. We also had the chamber power luncheon yesterday at Gomez's. Sierra Business Council, they're a consultant that works out of Truckee. They are the kind of main facilitator of this project for our region. So the state's
25:17 State's effort on this California's job first is to create a pathway for investment by the state for regionally developed economic plans that will lead to an increase in high quality jobs, prosperous communities and be climate resilient. They broke the state into 13 regions. Our region is a seven county region of Inyomono, Alpine, Amador, Calaveras, Tuolumne and Mariposa counties.
25:42 So it is unique in that there's east and west side counties within our region, which also kind of, I think, creates some challenges when we're looking at trying to come up with proposals and projects that truly benefit the whole region. The kind of what's called the collaborative, which is the governing council as well as those on the subcommittees within this efforts, have developed the core issues in priority industry sectors.
26:11 that all the kind of projects will need to fit in within those boxes and that's what Jennifer was talking about related to the sustainable recreation, the healthcare, those kind of core issues. Then the projects that will ultimately be funded through the effort will need to benefit the entire region and result in an increase in the number of
26:38 Quality jobs with equitable access, attract investment into disinvested communities, and be climate forward, resulting in climate resilient communities. So, you know, a lot of projects that kind of fit within that, some ideas include, you know, regional kind of trail networks that could increase sustainable recreation efforts to
27:05 Add additional curriculum and programs through community colleges, such as like healthcare, or even going into looking at like trade stuff, so there's a lot of ideas floating around. I don't know about Jen, I was exhausted after the two-day workshop in Tahoe, like I, there's eight hours of kind of non-stop interaction, and I went and just stared at a wall for a little bit afterwards. Stared at the highway.
27:33 It's exciting right now. They're finishing up the kind of the initial stage of the program, which is the planning phase. They're looking to have the strategic priorities out, I believe it's August 1st. So they're currently in the drafting stage of that. Once that's out, we move to what's called the catalyst program, which is $14 million available for this region as a whole to do.
28:01 Pre-implementation funding of that $9 million is dedicated to projects, so it's looking at kind of work that can be done region-wide to set us up for future projects. And then the actual implementation funding kind of seems to keep evolving as to how much will be available through the state. The current budget has kind of changed some of that. There will be money. It's just unclear exactly how much there will be.
28:29 Then that will be a competitive pot statewide, so that will be unique in whether we're competitive or not. It's unclear if there'll be kind of rule set-asides or how that'll work, but that's to come. The other update I have is on the parcel. We were looking to have occupancy of Building B May 1st at the last hour, literally like 15 minutes before we were at council.
28:59 We got word from Pacific that there is an additional delay in occupancy related to the funding side as they're looking to bring additional tax credit funding into phase one, which will one, fund some of their cost overruns on the project, but more importantly, it'll free up some of the prior grant funding through the housing accelerator to move that over to phase 2.2 of the project.
29:28 The state basically said they have to complete that refinancing before they can get occupancy. And so they're looking, they're hoping by May 15th with kind of a latest deadline would be June 1st to kind of complete that refinancing to then get occupancy. It's really disheartening because it's completely like done. Building P is like construction clean, ready to be occupied in the state.
29:56 Who says we need housing so bad is in the way of getting housing. Well, how much overrun are we talking about? Cost overrun? Fairly significant on just the overruns, but that is all on Pacific to fund and figure out which they've done. They have the new funding. It's just doing the closing on it. Yeah, but I'm just curious. How much are we talking about? And is it because of?
30:24 I don't have an exact number, I can definitely get you the exact number. Is it because they're construction cost related? Yeah, it was snow related, delays from the large winter, some other delays just with building the region, I think it's just part of the kind of learning curve, even though Pacific has built projects here in the past, it was, I think just, yeah, a result of it.
30:52 So the winter storm had a significant impact to their progress? It did, yes. Not this winter. Yeah, this past, this other one, the big one. Okay. Which makes sense. But yeah, they're working through that with, like I said, this kind of influx of tax credits. One funds that, but like I said, majority...
31:19 of that tax credit now frees up what was the Housing Accelerator, which was the original program to fund it, which they're working with HCD to move that to the second phase. They had broken phase two into two phases, and so the first phase of 76 units received tax credit funding, that's the one that they're hoping to, they're looking to break ground on next month. Then the second phase of phase two, which is 72 units, that's the one they're hoping to move this
31:48 These funds over two, then that will be funded as well, so they'll be able to move forward with all of phase two at once. So realistically, how much longer do you think the occupancy certificate could be issued? They said they were anticipating having that resolved within two weeks from May 1st, so we get about 50 emails a day on just
32:14 All the different, because there's two different financial closings going on for phase one and phase two right now, so it's constant agreements and documents that we need to review, weigh in on, sign off on, and it's, so I believe they're getting close, it seems, you know, that they have a pretty, I say, firm answer that June 1st would be the latest that it would be occupied.
32:39 No, Nolan, what's going on with the occupants? Do people know that they're moving in there? Have they selected people? Are they still looking? So my understanding is for the building B, that's the smaller building, that's the 15 units. They have filled that unit. They've confirmed with the tenants, verified their income, but they've also let them know that, you know, until they give them a firm move-in date, there's not a firm move-in date. Gotcha, okay.
33:10 And so they're, my understanding is kind of in contact constantly with those occupants. And then for building A, which is 66 units, they, my understanding will start, will kind of reach out to those who they've met with and kind of gathered the income documents for when they were here two months ago. But they didn't want to go through the full income verification until they had a kind of closer move-in date because that's...
33:34 Those documents have to be current within 90 days of the occupancy. They're targeting, I believe, July 1st for building A, but until they have kind of that firm date, they don't want to get ahead of themselves. Gotcha, okay, but that second building will be, they're hoping for July 1st occupancy for that, okay, cool. I was hoping those people weren't homeless for these two weeks while they're dealing with financing. Yeah, I hope they're not, you know, we haven't, I usually gauge by how many emails I'm getting from, not, say from the public, and I haven't.
34:04 Knock on wood, I haven't been getting a lot of angry emails lately, so hopefully the communication is working between Buckingham and the tenants. Gotcha. And then I am still looking to schedule. I'll be reaching out to the commissioners today to hopefully set up tours of the parcel prior to opening. We'll likely bring the commissions out two at a time, set up dates so that it's not considered a meeting, but look for that email to come. Awesome.
34:33 Can I ask one more personal question while we're on the topic? What happens if and when someone whose income is verified gets a raise or a better job? Do they then have to move out? So my understanding is, you know, the units based on the funding, there's 30, 50, 60, and 80% AMI units, kind of a mixture of those units, and they float around somewhat, so it's not like, you know.
35:03 Unit 1 is a 30%, if they can change up, and then once, you know, they have to be income qualified to move in, and then once they've occupied, should they get a raise, I believe they can usually go to 20% above that and stay in, so kind of up to 100% AMI, and then if they exceed that, I believe then they're
35:31 It's not an immediate, like you need to vacate, but it's usually at the end of the lease that they're no longer eligible for this project. Some of the other projects that, it all kind of depends on the funding, allow for those occupants to stay in it if their income significantly increases, but usually if they say exceed like 20% above, then the rent will change to a calculation that's
35:58 30% of their monthly income. Gotcha, gotcha, okay. Being kind of like the, I guess, deterrent where if you kind of significantly, you know, increase that 30% of say if you make all of a sudden 180, 200,000 will be higher than kind of market rate. So it's kind of incentive to not stay there. But like you're saying there's some shuffling where if someone kind of...
36:21 They move into the 80% category, then they would try to fill a different unit with a 50 or whatever. Okay, gotcha. Okay, cool, good to know. Just kind of part of why the need for, you know, a third-party management company of the affordable projects that specialize in just all the requirements from the state as to what they require. Awesome. So they have to submit for income verification from time to time? Annually, they, um, yeah, the...
36:49 The property management company recertifies their income on an annual basis. I see. That's great, but it makes it a little bit more challenging. It's kind of tricky. It's a little more work, which is great, because you don't want people taking advantage of the system. Of course, exactly. I just worry about the missing middle we've talked about a lot of. Anyway, it's not agendas. Can I ask a quick question about what Chair was talking about, the first item? Sure.
37:18 Something about the resilience. California jobs first. And you mentioned the word aquaculture. What do we have here in the region? We obviously don't have any agriculture here in Mammoth, but because this is where they're looking at our whole region, so the whole seven-county region of the east and west-side counties. Obviously, Inyo County has quite a bit, Mono County has quite a bit.
37:48 I'm not as familiar with the counties on the west side, whether... But what does Mono County have? Cattle. Other than cattle? They have cattle, they have, you know, some, it's alfalfa or hay, especially as you go out towards, kind of on, you know, Mono County extends all the way out, like Benton, everything out there, kind of white mountain shelf fonts all in Mono County, and then to the north you have Walker and those areas, like there's...
38:19 Quite a bit of ranching and not so much true crops growing, but agriculture in the county. And do you give feedbacks from people, groups that want to pursue in that industry, in the county? I'm not sure. I'm just curious. So yeah, one area they're looking at, within that as far as kind of a core area was the sustainable agriculture.
38:48 One of the areas that they're looking at is part, you know, potential as creating jobs that, you know, are needed and part of it is to, especially, you know, obviously Mammoth is very tourism driven, but a lot of the communities on the west side are too, to try to diversify from, you know, kind of a single sector job, single kind of job sector to expand that out and have additional job sectors in the area. It's always nice to diversify.
39:18 Given that we're such a tourism focus. Scared me. So, anyways, that's all I have. Thank you. All right. Nothing else? That leads us to item number 10, adjournment. And so, this is a quick meeting. 940, we are going to go ahead and adjourn the meeting. And our next regularly scheduled meeting is June 12, 2024.