Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2023
Planning & Economic Development Commission
at 09:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
146 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:24 Nine o'clock. There we go. So if everyone's ready, I would like to call the order the Wednesday, August 9th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. Jamie, may we please have a roll call? Commissioner Chang is absent. Commissioner Eckert? Commissioner Kennedy? Here. Vice Chair Burroughs? Present. Chair Vanderhurst? Present. Thank you, Jamie. Would everyone please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance? Dan, would you care to lead us? Thank you, Dan. Appreciate it. I know.
2:14 We all had coffee this morning, I'm assuming. I'd like to open public comment right now, and I will ask if anybody has public comment that pertains to a matter on this morning's agenda that you hold on to your public comment until that agenda item is before us. So, this morning, Dan, would you care to lead us off with public comment? Thank you. I wanted to just, I didn't see it on the agenda formally, so I did want to come in and just recognize Sandra Moberly.
2:41 for her work in leading this commission, for the involvement she's had in it, for the technical expertise that she has brought to the professionalism she's brought to it, and also the development of her staff in that process as well. So the effectiveness of the commission is reflective of the amount of quality of the staff that we have. Very proud of the work that they've gotten done. And as we see her move on to down the street, so she'll be supporting us in another role.
3:10 Or vice versa. So, but, you know, I can go through quite a list of accomplishments. I think you are familiar with the vast majority of those. But I did want to make sure that we recognize her this morning for her work and her effort in the development of the Planning Commission. It's one of the key roles of that position. And the ability to manage that on top of everything else I think is really critical. And I think she's done a great job in stepping up into that area.
3:37 And it shows in the work product that comes out of the commission and out of her professional staff. So I wanted to say thank you again to Sandra and make sure that that recognition is here as we both kind of mixed emotions but celebrate her accomplishments and also wish her much success down the street here and or over the hill depending on which city she's working in. But it's been great. It's been a really great relationship in terms of
4:04 The professional work that's going on in the community, so I just want to make sure we say thank you to you, and it shows in the strength of the commission. Thank you. Very well said, and I could not agree more. It's definitely a bittersweet moment, no question about it. Any other public comment? Jenna, please. Speaking of bittersweet. Yes, another one. Thank you. Jenna Carter with the Town of Mammoth Lakes Code Compliance, and I have given my notice, so actually today is my last physical day in the office.
4:37 And I am done, but it has been a pleasure serving for the community and in front of you and presenting in front of you guys, so thank you. I have a couple of stats I wanted to go over or a couple of items I wanted to touch on. 5700 Minaret, we've been making some progress there. We did issue a notice of intent to abate and they did reply and so they have hired a project manager. The project manager is promising. He knows how to work with municipalities. He's already applied for some...
5:06 You know, he's working along the process. We don't have a permit application in yet, but that's the next step. So with the next couple of days, we're expecting that permit application. For 955 Forest Trail, that's the one behind Burner that's collapsed. It is considered a nuisance right now, and it is blight for the community. That is the resident's in site, so they are planning on developing that site. I do know that the developers don't want to apply for a building permit or for the demo permit until they have the whole project permitted.
5:34 That's their stance right now. They have not been put on notice, though, so fair enough, they have not been put on notice about the nuisance or the blight issue. If we put them on notice about them being a blight or a nuisance to the community, they very well may start demo sooner than later. That just has not been initiated yet. I wouldn't expect that to be demoed this season, though, just because of the time that it takes to hire a designer for the demo, apply for the demo permit, and then actually start the demo work itself.
6:04 Just setting expectations there. I would expect hopefully the new code compliance officer can take on that case and start it for this spring of next year to have that demo start. Mammoth Creek Inn. There's been some progress made there. If you guys have seen from the creek side, I just checked it out yesterday, there's some roof eaves and some chimney chases. A little bit of the footings were installed for the elevators and stairs. I'm just a little optimistic there because now the silhouette looks a little bit better.
6:32 It looks a little bit more like a building, a residential building, instead of just a block, a purple block. They have not had an official inspection, though, since April, so they are overdue for inspections. They are working on the interior, from what I understand, which would be mechanical, stuff that doesn't require inspections right now, so like drywall, some of the electrical stuff on the inside, finishing. So not too surprising that we're not doing inspections, but we would like to do more inspections on the footings and exterior.
7:01 See the elevators going. Lastly, I did receive word that there was possibly some dispersed camping along Mammoth Creek Inn and I did go check it out during the day. I did not see any signs myself but I did alert the Mammoth Police Department and so they're going to go by at night and they're going to check to make sure and disrupt any camping out there because the area that I was notified to should just be day use only. It's a nice little picnic area to take dogs out or have a nice picnic by the creek.
7:31 Not to camp. And no dispersed camping is allowed in town still. So we are on that one. It is an open case right now. That would be my final update, unless anyone has any questions for me. Any questions for Jenna? First, I just want to say thank you for all the work that you've done. You've done an amazing job, and I wish you the best with your future. My question revolves around the Mammoth Creek Inn. You see they're working on a lot of interior.
7:59 Yeah, we're probably going to run out of time here on the outdoor stuff, so is there a push for them to finish their outdoor stuff before it starts snowing again when they're going to have to stop everything? Definitely, and I did, I personally recommended to them that they at least start roofing and the elevators right now before the winter, but it is up to them to do, and we did tell them that at the end of this summer, we're looking at receiverships.
8:26 So that threat still is active with them, and they do understand that. They're insisting that they're going to be done, you know, and that it's looking great, and it'll all button up right before the end. So, but the threat is still out there, and it's still open. Okay, thank you. I don't have a question, but I just wanted to echo that I'm super grateful, and I was part of the hiring committee that brought you on, and you have, I knew that you'd be a good fit then, and you have.
8:51 Blown me away. Every time we get an update from you, I'm just so impressed. Thank you. Thank you for everything you've done for the town. It's huge. And wish you the best. Thank you. Thanks for all you do, too. Thanks. Commissioner Eckert, any questions? Thank you for the time you've been here. And where are you off to? I'm doing Frosty Four-Wheeler full-time now. My husband and I own that up-road towing business. So we're going to commit to that business full-time now. Good. See how that goes. I'll just echo what's been said already. An amazing job. You definitely
9:21 Handled one of the toughest positions in town staff with grace and dignity. You always kind of balance that line between being strict and being compassionate. So thank you for your time and thank you for your professionalism. Thank you. Just for the public record, the part of Mammoth Creek that Jenna is referring to is the bike path side of that creek.
9:49 We also have requested that the Mammoth Creek Inn be agendized later this fall, maybe September, October. I would like to take public comment officially on that project, so that will be coming our way down the road. Thank you, Jenna. Appreciate it. A couple of follow-ups on Jenna. Also, congratulations, Jenna, on moving on, and I'm really excited for you, and you have been a fantastic member of the team. I think...
10:17 Echoing what the commission said, it is a tough job. It's one of the toughest jobs in town, personally, I think, and you've done it, as you said, with grace and dignity. Just for the commission's awareness, we, just because Jen is leaving doesn't mean we won't have code enforcement support. We are working closely with the police department. They have two code, or, sorry, community service officers, community compliance officers, who will be helping us during this transition time. So we are recruiting already for Jen's position.
10:47 We just did a recruitment for the police department for a similar position. They had a great candidate pool, so we're kind of pushing it out to that candidate pool, and so we expect to fill this position relatively quickly. And Jenna, I think, has been working on training the police department staff, so I think we'll have a really smooth transition from Jenna to the next code compliance officer. And then just a note on the Mammoth Creek Inn project, the process, so we will bring it to you just to have a discussion on it.
11:15 And take some public comments and just that'll allow you all to talk about it. The process for receivership, we would work with our attorneys to determine whether we think the judge will actually grant us a receivership. So that's why we didn't pursue it. We had given them kind of a deadline of March and when we actually sat down and met with our attorneys, they said, we just don't think the judge is going to grant you the receivership at this point. So we gave them this summer and so we'll go through that process again, meeting with our attorneys to see whether or not we think a judge would grant us the receivership.
11:44 Then the process would be it would go to town council in closed session where they would talk about it. The town council has to authorize us to then take the next step to go into receivership. So then we have to go to court and the judge has to appoint a receiver. So that's that process. So it's certainly not a quick process and it does require a number of things to line up. But just so the commission understands that it would be a process. But I think having that public discussion here.
12:11 Talking about it and, you know, maybe making kind of an informal recommendation to council or informal, you know, item to council to consider doing this, I think would be helpful in this process, just so you all know. That's all I have. Would you consider the discussion we had this morning kind of in that, towards that? Well, you can't technically make any, in public comment, you can't make any recommendations or come to any consensus. Got it. So, no, I think that it leads us to getting this item on the agenda. For the fall.
12:42 For the fall, but technically there's no real action that you all can take. It would just be kind of just comments from the commission. It's not really a formal recommendation of the discussion. Thank you, Sandra. Nothing but the best, Jenna. Nothing but the best. Any other public comment this morning from Sweet Z? Jamie, any public comment via Zoom? No. Okay, then I will close public comment and we will go to business matters. 6.1, we have a presentation of, sorry.
13:12 We have a presentation 4.1, update on the Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Resilience Project, aka the Mammoth Donut. We've got Janet Hatfield on Zoom to provide the presentation. We also have Lawson Reef here to provide comments as well. Good morning, Janet. It's yours. Take it away. Good morning. Do you guys want me to share my screen or do you prefer to do that internally? I'm happy to do either. It'd be easier for you to share your screen, I think, Janet. Thank you. Okay.
13:43 Super. Okay, someone out there, give me the green light that you can see this slide. Yep, we can see it. Super. Well, thank you, Sandra, for the invite, and I appreciate the Zoom option. These days, I'm splitting my time between our Mammoth office and Bishop, and so...
14:11 It's a real luxury to be able to fit something like this in while I'm sort of between two places. So thanks for that convenience. It's been quite some time since I gave an update on this project. It's moving along, has some challenges, some real wins as well. So just a general update for the commission today to bring you up to speed on the recent happenings.
14:35 So, just a refresher, because I know you guys balance a lot, we've continued to assimilate a robust group of partners that are all contributing in different ways to helping us get this work done. That list will continue to grow over time, but these are some of the key players that have stepped in with some type of capacity, either technical, managerial, financial, or just supporting roles, which is a big...
15:03 reason for the success this project has had. One thing of note I will recommend that everyone keeps in mind is this has really been a project that was conceptualized by the Inyo National Forest and without their cooperation and leadership in this, it wouldn't be happening. So we as a nonprofit partner help drive the process along.
15:28 Because we're a lot more nimble to do that. So it's a very similar analog to what the town might be familiar with, as of the likes of MLTPA pushing along recreation things. So with that, one key element to make sure that folks keep in mind, particularly folks that visit the Mammoth community, is this is not a logging project.
15:53 A, we don't really have a lot of real merchantable trees. There are some, but the intent of this project is really to promote old growth and to take the forest condition that you often see kind of on the left-hand side and try to get some active treatment in there so that eventually it starts looking like the picture on the right. So there's not a lot of economic incentive to do this work. In fact, it's quite costly. And so I think
16:22 We need to be really careful in how we talk about this to the public so that the intent of the project is clear. Where the project is happening, this might be a familiar map, this was an early map we made of the initial boundary around the town and it has changed a bit and so I have that new map on the second slide here but briefly the colored units within the project boundary
16:54 If it's hatched or somewhat translucent, that means it has some of the federal environmental compliance work completed, so the NEPA is ready to do treatments in those areas, and the dark solid colors are what is funded that we're currently working on with the Forest Service in the town. So it's...
17:18 Kind of a contrived boundary in some respects unless you know the landscape. So it's really dominated and dictated by wilderness to the west and south. And then as you'll see in this slide, it's morphed a bit as a result of the public scoping process.
17:37 This map shows how it stands at current date, and I'll just speak to a couple of the new colors here, as well as that extension into the north towards June Lake. So some of the public comments were from the June Lake community of like, hey, we want work done here too, which I think is the sign of the times. So again, we were bound by wilderness to the west, but the extension of this project ties into some other existing
18:06 Planning documents from the Forest Service around the June Lake Loop. So that would provide continuity. Also of note, you see in blue, that's the work that has been funded already. And then you'll see some sort of cutouts or vacancies from the former map. That is also an older Forest Service decision that is currently in continued litigation. It has been appealed.
18:36 And so as a sort of a conservative measure from the Forest Service, they elected to sort of keep those acres under the current environmental document that's in question. And there is not a cease work order on those units. So there is some work continuing, but the decision from the land management agency was it was a more conservative approach to sort of leave those acres under the current environmental document instead of
19:05 having this NEPA exercise sort of supersede those. Also of note, the color, the dark kind of brownish-red colors around the town, that points to what we have identified as 10,000 priority acres that would be critical to implement in order to provide emergency services personnel better options to protect the town when the next fire arrives. Right now,
19:34 It's a pretty tough date for anyone under sort of challenging conditions to be effective in that emergency response. So again, that's one of the key goals and the key messages that we're promoting is that this project will not make people safe or the town safe. There's an incredible amount of due diligence that needs to occur at the parcel level from homeowners, et cetera.
20:02 And that this work helps ensure the resilience of the forest and make sure that those emergency services firefighting personnel can be safe and effective in their jobs. So this is just a very high level overview of what's happened over the last, we're going on three years now since the initial award from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy who kicked off this project with some seed funding.
20:31 That award was in spring of 2020, but we elected to start really the stakeholder meetings in the fall. Turns out that was the same year of the Creek Fire, so it was pretty easy to get folks' attention about this work. And then shortly thereafter, CAL FIRE, CDFW, and the Sierra Nevada Conservancy were all stakeholders in that early planning process.
20:56 We were able to attract several large grant awards to ensure that some of the early implementation ready acres we could begin working on, recognizing time is of the essence, and CAL FIRE stepped in to fund those, approximately 2,000 acres of NEPA ready land. And then really shortly thereafter, we work with the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments to secure a fairly large
21:24 planning award from CDFW under their managing headwaters for multiple benefits priority to conduct the environmental analysis for this large landscape. That includes a real heavy look at those 10,000 priority acres so that they are actually shovel ready as we like to call it upon this decision from the Forest Service. So what we didn't want to have happen is a NEPA document
21:54 That was just a NEPA document, and there was a substantial amount of work to get those acres ready. So we included sort of a critical number of tasks to make sure that those acres were ready to implement at the first opportunity. Since that time,
22:13 We were able to get about 1,000 acres of work collectively done last summer between the Inyo National Forest, the White Bark Institute, and the National Forest Foundation. That's about a three-fold increase of what we've seen happening on the forest in years past. So just to put that into perspective, our aim is to double that again by 2025.
22:38 It's a bit of a training wheels exercise. There's a lot of moving parts. The work is logistically quite complex. And it's also very public. So it's going to be an interesting and challenging exercise as we scale up. Of note, particular to the town and the recreation economy of the area, the Sierra Nevada Conservancy did come in with another large implementation grant award.
23:06 that will allow us to complete treatments in the Reds Meadow Valley. So right now it is a public safety concern as well as an incredible risk of ecosystem services in Reds Meadow due to the conditions. So we're really, really pleased that SNC heard that plea and really put their money where their mouth was. And we're hoping that we can get
23:33 A thousand acres of treatment done next year in the Reds Meadow Valley. And again, a lot of logistics there with the roads, etc. But recognizing that as a really special place, not only ecologically, but economically and in every other way, really, spiritually, it's a really incredible spot on the Inyo National Forest and quite unique. So that work, we're planning for it now, but in earnest, we'll move forward next summer.
24:03 if all goes well. And then this summer, a big focus outside of planning for next year is all of the survey work for the NEPA and CEQA analyses with a focus on the 10,000 priority acres as well as a number of units.
24:24 that are not, that are owned, not by the federal government, but actually two that are owned by the town, the Mammoth Creek Parcel and the Bell-shaped parcel, as well as Camp High Sierra. Those units, the CEQA document was just recommended for approval this week, so we're hoping those units all move forward later this month in order to get that work done.
24:47 this year instead of extending it out. It was a bit hit or miss with the winter we had. We weren't sure if we should be more worried about flood or fire implementing these units. So I'm hopeful that all of those move forward smoothly and we'll have a good set of acres to report at the end of this season.
25:12 Oh, whoops, I skipped a slide there. I don't know that I have to belabor why this work is critical. I think if we've been paying attention to the news for the last five years in particular, I think a lot of this momentum from the state was catalyzed by the campfire, which took out the town of Paradise near Chico. But the photos at the top are a more recent and more local event of the Tamarack Fire in Alpine County, as well as
25:43 What the sort of remnant effects look like when we have what we call uncharacteristic or high severity fire. Of note, in our area, a recent report from the Sierra Business Council does county level assessments at what we can expect. And so I thought this was an appropriate slide to include here for Mono County in particular, but this is what we expect. So it's about a threefold increase in acres burned coming up in the next few decades here.
26:14 as well as some extreme heat, warmer nights, et cetera. So I think this is just a real nod to some of the challenges that lie ahead as we prepare for some of the climate-related impacts to all of our work, and in particular, in my line of work, how that may impact communities and important landscapes.
26:36 And then, of course, on the ecosystem side, there's a ton of benefits of keeping forests healthy or helping them return to a healthier state. These are just a snapshot of some of the biggies and we're looking into some of these benefits as potential payment mechanisms to help fund this work. Again, there's not a strong economic incentive because there's really no timber value to be
27:03 found in these landscapes for the most part. So really we're looking at what do the water benefits look like not only locally but to our downstream beneficiaries of the City of Los Angeles who have substantial amount at stake with the forest and the condition that they're in. So this is kind of a
27:23 A newer area, we're making some progress. It's a little slower than I might like, but there are a lot of things evolving at really a global scale in response to all of the different climate related work as ways to try to quantify benefits to things like.
27:39 Biodiversity, et cetera. Water benefits have been around for a while. The carbon piece has been around for a while. So we're working through those. And I think of particular interest is what is the recreation benefit locally to ensure that these forests stay intact?
27:58 It's a big project. It's a bit overwhelming if you think about it as a whole. So we try to take bite-sized pieces. This is a little bit of a snapshot of the portfolio of grants than partners that have stepped in to help get us where we are today. So as you can see, pretty significant investments in this project alone. And we're really using it to build capacity for
28:24 A lot of the smaller projects at the county and regional scale that also are of critical importance to the folks in those communities. But beyond monetary needs, this is really how we've broken the project up and how I focus my work. So again, at the bottom, we have three really key elements that are essential or this is just a, you know, sort of a far-flung idea. A big piece of that is
28:53 How do we secure funding to ensure that the work can move forward? Another one that you guys have heard a bit about probably from the town's work and Dan's leadership in particular is what do we do with all this material? Working at this scale is going to generate a tremendous amount and then
29:12 Finally, is who do we have to do the work? Right now, all of the contractors that we're using come from out of town and there is a large desire and an economic incentive to figure out how do we support local businesses who would be interested in joining us on this journey to build resilience. There's incredible opportunities to that end. And those three elements collectively are going to be what makes this project go.
29:42 Above there, these are some of the other areas that I work. We've got, you know, large data sets to help us with project prioritization as well as a lot of stakeholder input. A pretty significant outreach program that is in its early years, but we're building that, recognizing the need for it, both in the town and more regionally. The research is a bit light because
30:06 There's really consensus from the scientific community that like we need to do this if we want to be around and we want forests to persist. So that's been a pretty light lift. And I will say we're really just touching the tip on the operational end. And that's really where over time our efforts will focus once we know everything's moving forward and we've got sort of those foundational components addressed.
30:34 Of interest on the biomass end, we have two different irons in the fire. One is a pilot this summer with the folks at Kodama Systems. They are a sort of entrepreneurial new startup business with, you know, some talent from MIT, et cetera. They've gained a lot of traction, but they have a very simple and novel approach to burying wood. They call it the wood vault technology.
31:02 As a way to store carbon long-term. So they're working with Mono County to pilot that using some of the acres up in the north that MFF is overseeing. And they will likely have results in about a year. And if their data lines up with what they think, they're hoping to have a carbon credits program that would help be another economic piece of this puzzle. So that'll be interesting to see how that works out.
31:31 And we're happy to help support their progress as a new company. More broadly, Mono County has been awarded a grant from the USDA Wood Utilization Grants Program. And it is for the pre-development of potential technology that could meet the needs and the scale of this project. These are a couple images of what some of those different technologies look like.
32:01 And this is a quick just graphic of how it works. So it is a direct combustion technology. I am a lay person in this field, but essentially the wood is chipped. It's incinerated. It goes through a heat exchanger and a turbine generator to create energy and power, which is one of the economic drivers of what makes this work.
32:27 And then is cooled and returned in this loop system that you see here. One of the key elements was to figure out where this could be cited, given that's a concern here. And ORMAP has joined this effort as a critical partner. This is a look at their current facility. And this is the cooling mechanisms that were shown in the last graph. This is their organic ranking cycle technology.
32:58 One of the conditions of them working with us collectively as partners is being able to site it, not on federal land, because the Forest Service doesn't really have a mechanism to do these type of facilities on federal property. And so, you know, given the land status in the Eastern Sierra, it was pretty critical to figure out where could we locate it that might work. And ORMAT stepped in and said, hey, here's a few acres, let's figure this out.
33:28 And of note, because of the other needs in the community and the county more broadly, we requested that the developer investigate the ability for this technology to utilize both organics as well as municipal solid waste that can be added right along the wood chips or in a sort of complementary anaerobic digester unit. They have
33:57 Pretty extensive expertise and background in that technology, their chief engineer does. So that's exciting moving forward. And again, Mono County will shepherd that grant through the next few years of the planning process. And we look forward to what that might potentially mean as far as a solution for the material that this project will generate. And with that, I'm happy to take questions of anything I might have left out for all of you.
34:27 Thanks for having me. Thank you, Janet. Great presentation. I'll throw it back here on the commission. Any questions for Janet on presentation this morning? Any questions for Lawson or anything you'd like to add, Lawson, to the presentation? Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. Yeah, if you don't mind, I'll talk maybe a bit more specifically briefly about the town parcels and what we're doing related to those parcels. Let me share my screen. Very fun. How exciting, you guys.
35:19 Okay, so as Janet mentioned, as part of the ESCCRP or the Mammoth Donut, there are several town parcels. In particular, two out of the three are on town-owned land. That would be the bell-shaped parcel as well as the Mammoth Creek parcel. This will have impacts to folks as this timber gets pulled out of these parcels, the more complex one.
35:53 being Mammoth Creek Parcel. We are going to do our absolute best on our end to get the word out related to this. Whitebark has done excellent work in their outreach. They have already sent mailers to people's front steps, effectively, where folks could learn about the project and attend various public meetings as well.
36:14 I was at those public meetings to provide any information from the town side, and then town council most recently relayed that they would like another outreach to Shefferd on our end once we knew the actual dates as well as how the project was going to affect in particular recreation in that area. And the main impact in that area will be to the multi-use pathways, the MUPS, right? So you'll see on the document, this is a one-pager.
36:42 that Whitebark came up with. That's the first page in this little packet here. We didn't need to reinvent the wheel here, just giving a little information, so we piggybacked on Whitebark's info and just put the dates on there, which effectively is going to be August 24th through September 29th. This is going to be basically a multi-pronged approach as this project moves from west to east in the Mammoth Creek parcel.
37:06 Primarily, as you can see on the maps on the second page, it will occur, the work will occur between roughly Sherwin Street and Waterford. It will go a little bit east of that location, but again, the project will move from west to east. So phase one, which we believe will occur August 24th through September 7th, will effectively
37:29 Close the town loop in certain locations, but we have created detours down Majestic Pines across Waterford and then connecting back with the multi-use pathway on Old Mammoth Road with the following segment, Phase 2, September 8th through September 29th, which will again close that more central part of the town loop there through the project area so folks will be routed around Sherwin Street.
37:54 And to the Old Mammoth Mupp via Old Mammoth Road. We are having professional signage developed with this information for folks that will be at all closure sites. We will put it at the visitor center. We'll probably put one outside of Vons as well, a sandwich board for folks so they're aware. We'll laminate some copies of this map, maybe a bit more informal and just get it to all the bike shops, things like that so folks are aware.
38:20 of what's happening out there, and we'll get some kind of slow signage on Old Mammoth Road, you know, for folks coming down from that direction. So really just trying to focus on getting that word out, ensuring folks are safe out there and know where to go as part of these impacts. Then, after this one, we'll be bell-shaped, which is far less complex. I don't have any neat pictures for you. Unbell-shaped. That one will be far less complex.
38:48 We'll have some traffic control on Meridian as they are moving logs out, but that one is of far less concern on our end in terms of recreation impacts and overall impacts to the community in terms of noise, pulling logs out, things like that. And bell-shaped parcel would be four days, five days, whereas Mammoth Creek parcel, as you can see, August 24th through September 29th.
39:13 So a bit of a longer effort. And then that little packet that I just gave you, we will be dropping off at people's doors maybe a week before the start of the project, just to remind them of what's occurring out there. Any questions for me? Excellent, excellent presentation. Any questions for Lawson from the Commission? Very, very proactive, Lawson, very proactive. Thank you for that, and thank you for thinking three steps ahead with the signage.
39:41 with the notifications. I really like the idea of you handing out this information to the bike shops because that is the absolute point of contact for people who are going to be accessing these bike paths with, you know, whether it's e-bike or regular bike. So, well done. Thank you. Janet, are you still there? I do have a couple of quick questions for you. Yes, I am. Hey, and I apologize if you covered this, Janet. I must have just missed it, but would you briefly summarize
40:14 Any activity that's going on in the Valentine Reserve? Yeah, there is no activity that I'm aware of in Valentine Reserve beyond some nature walks that we're involved with leading folks through the work that happened several years ago. That work, I believe, occurred two summers ago, 2021. They did a portion of the Valentine Reserve. There's more work to do there, but it is not funded as part of this project at this time.
40:45 The Mammoth Creek work is a continuation of what happened on Valentine for some continuity along the creek, which has long been recognized as a real additional risk because of the vegetation being quite dense in that corridor. But to my knowledge, there's not a lot of work happening. The Mammoth Lakes Fire did burn some piles late spring when the snow melted to dispose of
41:14 The leftover biomass at the reserve. I know Greg Cook, GC Forest Products, took some of that wood also as firewood. So they were able to get those piles cleaned up, which is, that's a big win and needed to happen. So that's my knowledge of what happened on Valentine. Got it. So there is future treatment of the Valentine Reserve somewhere in our future. We just don't know, A, funding or schedule? Correct. Because, and that was really,
41:45 Because Alice Tamire, Chief Tamire brought that to our attention is like, look, and this happens a lot. Valentine did what they could do of some of the easier logistical acres, but typically the more complex acres get punted, right? Because people don't want to deal with it. So there is a need for additional work there and an opportunity to, when we are working on the federal property.
42:11 to work across jurisdictions and complete that work. And we have, you know, a year or two to sort of figure that piece out. It makes sense to do it as a cohesive block instead of stopping at an arbitrary line that is a jurisdiction. And that's really what Cal Fire and the state wants to see, right? That fire doesn't know a boundary. They don't care if you own it or somebody else does. So we need to be thinking about these treatments.
42:38 Not to ignore those lines, but to make sure that those lines aren't dictating our work. So there's a huge opportunity there and one that Chief Temeier brought to our attention that we have a keen interest in addressing. Got it. Thank you. And one last question from me, Janet. Did I hear correctly that you treated 1,000 acres of forest lands this summer or hoping to complete that by the time the snow falls?
43:06 That was last year, and that is, you know, acres that we did, NFF did, and the Inyo did collectively. So we managed X number of hundred acres, the Inyo did as well, and then NFF just did some pile burning with their contractors. So that was a collective, like all the partners together. This year, the acres...
43:33 Might be almost equivalent because NFF is still operating up off the Deadman Creek Road and they have a 500 acre unit up there. I don't know how many acres they will treat, but our acres...
43:47 are down a bit because they're really complex as Lawson alluded to. So you just can't move really quickly in a tight, confined space with a lot of values at risk there. It's more of a precision surgical approach. We call them boutique treatments in this work. So this is all happening and what we're also doing is picking up
44:10 60 acres in the lakes basin of work that the Mammoth Lakes Fire Safe Council initiated several years ago and kind of lost steam because it was a purely volunteer effort and I don't think anyone really recognized the amount of work involved. So we have partnered with them and said, hey, if we provided the technical expertise to move this through, we can complete those. So that work will also be happening after Labor Day.
44:37 in the Lakes Basin to pick those acres up. So collectively, I think whitebarks, the managed acres that we're doing is only around 300-ish, but they're really complex and it's a pretty tight season. So if we get all that done, I'll be happy. Got it. And that kind of leads to one last question and I'll open it up to both Janet and Lawson. With the...
45:04 I'm assuming you're talking about the burn piles up in the lakes basin. Is that kind of what you're referring to, Janet, or you actually will be thinning forests up there? Yeah, so there...
45:14 In the lakes basin work, there were two units that never got completed for a number of reasons. One was a big question whether or not prevailing wage applied, and so we waited, we, I can't say we, I wasn't there. The Mammoth Lakes Fire State Council waited for a year for a decision from Department of Industrial Relations. So that postponed things, I think it...
45:40 Also contributed to losing some steam on that project. And so once that decision was confirmed, basically there was a decision of whether they just could say we're done, here's the money back SNC. And we stepped in and said, hey, this work is important. What if we helped and collectively we work together and utilize the rest of your funding, contributed some of our new funding and got the work done? So it will generate additional piles.
46:09 There. It will also generate a lot of public firewood that will be decked in the lakes basin and opened up for fuel wood. There may be some fuel wood that goes to Great Cook through a timber sale, etc. But there is additional couple hundred acres of piles still, and that is work that the National Forest Foundation oversees on behalf of the INYO, and they bring in contractors to do that.
46:35 We didn't get much of that done this year because of the conditions. So it's on the radar for this fall if we get the window or next spring if winter is a little more forgiving. Lawson, quick question for you and I'm asking you to look in your Magic 8 ball a bit here. Do you foresee this activity up in the lake space in this fall affecting access to recreation, mainly the mups, hiking trails?
47:03 I don't really have a good feel for that right now. I'm not sure where the forest stands and if that work and what the timing of that work is going to be. Once I do know that, we will take appropriate steps. We've certainly had impacts for some of the work that we've been doing. We are responsible, you know, kind of a two-fold different thing in there.
47:25 Larger landscape scale timber work that blends in with a lot of the stuff that Janet's been saying and then just general hazard tree removal along the mops, which we've been doing a lot of up there and we still have some more of that work to do. So unfortunately, I don't have a good feel for what that's going to look like being that it is in the lakes basin. Yes, it will probably have some sort of impacts and we will attack those, you know, full force and get as much word out as we possibly can once we know what that work is going to look like.
47:54 Got it. And this would be a fantastic template to use for that. So no further questions from me. Anyone else in the commission? Last chance? Jamie, do we have any public comment on this presentation? No. All right. Janet, I appreciate your time. Lawson, appreciate your time. Keep up the great work. Thank you. I cannot overemphasize how important that is to the overall health, long-term health of this community. I will close that presentation now, and we will go to Business Matters 6.1. We have the Mammoth Main...
48:24 A main base renovation project update. And who is Sandra? We'll be providing the update this morning. So we just wanted to bring an update to the commission on the main lodge redevelopment project. Things are kind of ramping up a little bit. We've been doing environmental analysis over the past year, really doing those background studies, cultural studies, biological studies, doing some traffic counts, those types of things. But we expect that our environmental analysis and the project analysis will be...
48:52 So we intend to provide the council and the commission with routine updates. Kim Cook will be the planner assigned from the town. She'll be taking my role. Jen Murillo, who used to be here at the town, Jen Daugherty, is the contract planner for this project. So she's really managing it. And Kim's the town staff liaison and working closely with Dan on the project.
49:16 We'll be bringing these updates to you routinely, but really wanted to get it out there and let the commission, the council and the public know where we are with the project. I think there's been some concerns that the town's been working on this project, but no one's heard anything, but really it's just been kind of some background analysis at this point. So we provided a brief summary in your packet of the kind of the main points that have happened over the past time period.
49:42 We've done environmental, we're starting environmental work. We are the lead agency for CEQA and the Forest Service is the lead agency for NEPA. We can come back with a more broad, maybe to refresh your memories of the private versus federal land to show you a map. So there's two properties that are private land that CEQA applies to and then kind of all the surrounding development that NEPA applies to. So we've been working on technical studies, like I mentioned, biological cultural traffic.
50:10 And then we're hoping to complete all of the field work this fall. So it really depends on the weather. We have to, we cannot do any cultural field work until the site is completely free of snow. And there's areas of sight which about two weeks ago still had 40 feet of snow piled on them. So, but it's melting fast, right? So it's been melting fast. And so the cultural staff cannot come out here until all the area they're going to survey is free of snow. So we're really hoping for this project.
50:39 to have all the snow melt and not to have an early snowfall so that we can actually get out there. And that's what happened last year. The cultural team actually came out, started a day of surveying, and it snowed, and they couldn't finish their cultural work last year. So in the event that it does snow, we've been working with the Forest Service about maybe having some conditions of approval or some requirements that allow for that to occur after the project kind of gets further along in the process.
51:04 Another main point for us is outreach. We're working on an outreach strategy. We've drafted a strategy. We've sent it to the applicant, the applicant team. They've hired their own, you know, public relations team as well for this project, but just really trying to make sure that we're getting out to the public. We're keeping the commission, the council informed, and that when the project comes before you all and the council, nobody feels like this is the first time they've heard of this project. So we want, you know, to have a very inclusive
51:33 process similar to what we did with the parcel, although not as much, you know, conceptual planning as we did with the parcel, but really having people come in, understand what's going on, having some workshops, joint workshops with the council and the commission to talk about various issues. The applicant has indicated to us, they are working on a specific plan, so this area won't be the current zoning, it'll be its own specific plan like Clearwater, like the North Village.
51:58 And all of those standards have to be drafted. So we don't have any standards for development up there right now. So this would be really, we intend to have some, you know, council commission meetings, public meetings to talk about the key points in the specific plans. The applicant has indicated they don't want to come in and just drop a specific plan on our laps, all written and everything. They want to come to you, come to the council, come to the public to talk about really the key issues there. So, you know, aesthetics, height.
52:27 Setbacks, those types of things. Housing, how are we going to deal with housing there because that is a component of the specific plan. Traffic, parking, those types of things. Their intent is to have these workshops this fall and early next year that would help inform the drafting of the specific plan. Once that's submitted, then we can actually start doing our analysis and really understand how this is going to affect the development there. Ultimately, the project will come forward to the Planning Commission for consideration.
52:55 You will make a recommendation to Town Council, and then the Town Council will take the final action on the project. So that is a ways out there. We said mid-2025. We expect that process to occur. It's a very big project. It has a lot of complexity. We are moving a state highway, which basically takes an act of Congress to move a state highway.
53:20 So there are a lot of components of this project that just take a long time. When we're dealing with all the different agencies as well, it's just a project for us. So with that, I'm happy to answer any questions that you have. As I said, you'll be seeing more of us. Kim will be coming before you. And I'm not sure if she'll come every month or every other month. We don't want to kind of overwhelm you and just kind of keep coming and telling you nothing's happened, nothing's happened, nothing's happened. So I think the idea is that as things occur, we would be coming.
53:52 But I'm happy to answer any questions you have on it. Any questions for Sandra on the update for Main Lodge redevelopment? Not so much the update, but was there any consensus, I'm sure there hasn't been an agreement yet, with the Mountain and the Water District where they're going to be providing their own water and sewer or if that was bought into the Water District or was there any progress made on that? That's still under discussion. We're setting up meetings. We've had a couple meetings with the Water District with the applicant to talk about the pros and cons. I think
54:21 I think there are pros and cons with both. I think there are benefits to having the water district serve the property. I think the applicant sees the benefits to having the water service on their own. Sewer is another question. They have looked at having a treatment plan up there for sewer. But I think that's all still under discussion. They are going to be, obviously, tearing up that road as a part of this project to put in different infrastructure. So there is an opportunity to add that infrastructure.
54:50 I'd say it's still kind of in the beginning discussion stages at this point. Any other questions for Sandra? No. Thanks for the update. I think it's actually a very wise strategy to kind of keep this in front of the public as well as the different commissions and town council just so everyone feels fully vested in this project as it kind of comes to fruition. So good call by you guys, good call by the applicant. Thank you. Jamie, any public comment on this matter? No. All right.
55:23 Thank you, Sandra. Appreciate the update. Thank you. We will move to the consent agenda, and unless somebody has any edits they'd like to put forth, I would love to hear a motion to approve the consent agenda. To approve the consent agenda. We have a second. Second. Jamie, vote please. Commissioner Eckert. Yes. Commissioner Kennedy. Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs. Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Matter passes 4-0. Any Commissioner reports? I'll start left or right. Commissioner Kennedy, welcome back from North Carolina, by the way. Thank you.
55:57 Commissioner Burroughs. Commissioner Eckert. Not so much a report, but maybe a request. There's been a lot of comment and poop a lot over the Snow Creek Golf Course. I get questions. I don't know the answers as to just what exactly the town can or cannot do, whether the developer is even required to keep the course open on one extreme, whether he's going to lose his future rights on the other extreme. I'm sure the truth is somewhere in between.
56:35 But I imagine you guys have gotten questions on this also, and I don't know what to tell them. So if we could have some sort of a, I think Dan might have done something like this. I read it in the paper, but I haven't seen it. But some sort of a fact sheet of this is, this is what has been asked, this is what is required, this is what was intended. You know, something that's just a little less than gossip.
57:00 And with that, did you have a chance to, I know Sandra and her team put together a little PDF of kind of the, I think, the town's position. We did. We sent it to the commission, but I'm happy to print it up for you if you'd like. If you want to just come with us after the meeting, I can print a copy for you. We did try to respond to all those questions that we're hearing. We provided it to, you know, the council, the commission, and members, any members of the public had questions about it, and I'm sure it made its way to the paper.
57:31 They put some information in the paper about it as well. So we're happy to add questions too. It's a working document and happy to add items. But in summary, the town cannot compel Snow Creek to operate that golf course. That is not in our development agreement. It's not a requirement that he operates that golf course. He does have to keep it maintained, just like anybody has to maintain their property. You can't let it get overgrown or where it becomes a nuisance. He's a long way from it becoming a nuisance.
58:00 There is that there, but so at this point, we don't have any way to compel him to make him operate the golf course. There is a development agreement that requires the development of a future phase of the golf course, and if he doesn't develop that piece of the golf course, he loses time off of his development agreement. So it's a 20-year development agreement. If he doesn't build a golf course, he loses basically five years off the development. I think it would end in 2025 if he doesn't build a golf course. So there's a couple.
58:30 There's a couple layers of regulation there. So he has a development agreement that gives him certain benefits, and the town receives certain benefits. We received, I think, 16 acres of land donated from Chuck, from Snow Creek. Also, there's affordable housing requirements that he has to provide as a part of that that are above and beyond what we currently require. So there's the development agreement. Then there's the Snow Creek Master Plan, which is basically the zoning for the site. So if the development agreement went away, let's just say that he...
58:59 We rescinded it or it went away. He would still, he still has the ability to request entitlements and build out there. All of those, the hotel, all of the condo, everything is essentially allowed by the Snow Creek Master Plan. He does need to come forward for like a map and design review just like anybody else would, but he wouldn't be subject to the development agreement if that went away. So I think that right now we have an application for the first phase of Snow Creek 8.
59:27 which we anticipate will come to commission in September, October. So sometime in the next couple of months, it will be before you for consideration. This will be just phase one of Snow Creek 8. No request for the development agreement. As far as I know, no formal request for the development agreement has come in yet, although Chuck has asked us different questions. We've had people who had discussions about it, but nothing formal has come in.
59:52 That would require consideration by the Planning Commission as well. So you would all have to review. If he requested a change to the development agreement or a new development agreement, that would come to the commission for your consideration and it would go to the council for approval. So right now, there's a lot of rumors out there, a lot of things that I've heard. What I've heard, people saying he's just going to build on the golf course. That I think is very unlikely. That would require a change to the actual Snow Creek Master Plan.
1:00:21 Which is a zoning amendment, which would require CEQA, which would require likely a build-out amendment to our general plan. I mean, that is, I would say, if anyone's saying that is the far, complete, not very likely to happen situation. So, in my opinion, that is very, it just would take a lot of process to go through that. And it would be a public process. Everyone could comment on. So, I think that there are people who are out there concerned. I think it's most of the concerns I've heard is just about
1:00:49 Not operating the golf course and then not building that second phase of the golf. So, but I mean, that's out there still. Like I said, we haven't received anything formal on the development agreement at this point, but it is, you know, something that he could request. So just for your information, if you'd like to have more information, I'm guessing when the Snow Creek 8 tentative tract map comes forward, you guys will have a lengthy discussion about.
1:01:15 All of these topics, we'll try to be ready to talk about things and maybe have Andy here to help you all make sure that you understand what you can and can't do with that. I know that there's some people who would like to use, you know, maybe possibly use that to help compel other things, but we'll try to make sure that you're all well supported as you're considering that item. So I'm happy to answer any other questions. I just want to make sure we don't get off too far off of agenda. Just the one clarification, I guess.
1:01:44 When you say he has to build 18 holes by 2025 to stay in compliance, build has a lot of variables. Is this breaking ground or is this teeing off? I don't know exactly what the development agreement states on there. It's really... Yeah, the development agreement states they have to commence construction on the hotel and golf course in order to not lose that time on the development agreement. And that's really the only penalty in the development agreement if they...
1:02:14 If they don't be in construction, development agreement theoretically ends in 2025. There's no other penalties in that agreement that says if you don't do it, you can't do anything else. You can't build or anything like that. It doesn't have that language. Thank you. Just for the clarity of the public, and you can be very, very brief on this answer if you like, Sandra. The current land the golf course sits on, whether it's the first nine or the projected second nine,
1:02:45 Can not be built out housing at this point. It's zoned recreation. It cannot be built out housing in the current DA, correct? The current Stow Creek Master Plan, yes. Master Plan, okay. I think it's zoned open space, right? Or is it zoned recreation? So it's zoned open space, and then additionally the future nine, we'll call it, so the kind of expansion area also has a conservation easement over that section of land that further prevents any
1:03:16 Any change over any portion of that to anything other than open space. Thank you guys, appreciate it. Any other questions or no? I don't, I do not have a commissioner's report other than I'll remind the public that we do have the OCR slash Spartan Games coming in October. I believe the dates are the 5th to the 9th. Right now we're expecting somewhere between 4,000 to 5,000 people. So it's, you know, it's traditionally.
1:03:43 A soft time for us, October in Mammoth Lakes, so this should be good for our local economy, our businesses, as well as it's a worldwide event, so it's going to be great publicity around the planet, so I'm hoping everyone's excited about that. The great news about these competitors is the worse the weather, the more they love it. So if we get early snow, they eat it up. So with that, I'll move to Director's Report. Sandra, did you have anything else you'd like to throw in there?
1:04:13 Again, I think we talked a little bit about this last month, but I take an opportunity to thank you all for all of the work we've done over the time that I've been here at the town. I've been the town liaison to the Planning Commission for over 10 years, and it's been a really great 10 years, and you all have been, you know, the commissioners, I think, for a majority of that time. And it's been great working with you all, a fantastic commission. As Dan mentioned, I think great work comes out of this commission, and it is, you know,
1:04:43 It's you all, and I think it's also the really great staff support you're getting from all of my staff. I made a list of all of the things that we have worked on together over my 10 years. We've worked on the comprehensive zoning code update, which is the first comprehensive update that we've done since we incorporated. That was in 2014. We've worked on general plan housing safety elements, floor area ratio changes, the 2021 parking code update.
1:05:13 We have managed a development program and entitlements for over 680 hotel condo units, 190 residential units, 580 workforce housing units, 27,000 square feet of commercial, and all of that has an estimated construction value of over $500 million. All of that has come through our department and through you all as commissioners.
1:05:37 In addition, a lot of different entitlements, projects, environmental analysis like the Inn of the Village, Gray Bear, Limelight, Yotel Pad, the Parcel, Mammoth Hotel, Sierra Center Mall, Sierra Nevada Lodge, Residence Inn, the CRC. You all have also been part of our policy work like the Main Street Plan, Downtown Revitalization Action Plan, Walk, Bike, Ride. We did a comprehensive update to the Development Impact Fee Ordinance.
1:06:06 And then the Destination Resort Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy Update. So a lot of work has come through you all, and I think I really appreciate all of the attention that you provide. You all come prepared, and it's been really, really great to work with you all as commissioners, and I am sad to leave this commission, but I am happy to be moving on to the county, and I hope that we all see each other outside of Sweet C in the future.
1:06:34 Thank you all for your support. I really appreciate it. And really a big kudos to my staff who have done fantastic work for you and I know will continue to do fantastic work for you. And just a note on transition, you'll be seeing Nolan here. He'll be staffing the Planning Commission during the interim. They are going to start recruiting for my position. So next month. So, but yeah, and I am available. I will be just like Dan mentioned, just down the street or possibly over Bridgeport, but available for phone calls or texts.
1:07:04 Appreciate your work, appreciate the collaboration and the friendship. Thank you. Thank you, Sandra. I don't know what type of availability you'll have, Sandra, because you've got a big job coming your way. That's true. That's true. But just I'll quickly say I haven't spoken to either of these ladies, but I'm sure Mickey and Elizabeth would want to say congratulations and thank you for the partnership and leadership you've shown this commission over the last 10 years. And how long did it take you to pull that list?
1:07:34 It took me a little bit of time. That's amazing. Our staff does an amazing annual planning report. So I was able to go through our annual planning report over the past 10 years to just kind of see all the different, and there's so much more that I didn't include, smaller projects on there you probably missed. And so it is nice, it's so nice to have that as a resource for all of us, you know, as we're kind of looking at what we've actually done. And it was really amazing to think about, gosh, all of that.
1:08:02 A lot of work has occurred, and really, I don't think you think about it because it's occurred over 10 years, but you all have really managed a lot of complex, controversial projects and a lot of changes here for our communities. I think it's been great. Big shoes, Nolan. Big shoes. Nolan's going to do great. Thank you, Sandra.
1:08:23 With that, I'll go ahead and adjourn today's meeting into our next regularly planned planning and economic development commission meeting, which is September 13th at 9 a.m. So thank you guys. I appreciate the time. And thank you staff for everything you do.