TransparentMammoth

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2021

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments

at 08:30

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

306 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 One or two more minutes. That's true for Linda also. She's on the road. All right. Well, we have a quorum. Let's get started. Are we good? Yes? Yeah. Technically, we're good to go on my end. Thank you. All right. I would like to call this meeting to order of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments on August 13th, 2021 at 8.31 a.m. We can do the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:53 Please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. Find a flag nearby. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, indivisible, under God, for liberty and justice for all. Sometimes forget that. I get a little stage fright there. Okay. Public comments.

1:21 Notice to the public, this time is set aside to receive public comment on matters not calendared on the agenda. When recognized by the chair, please state your name and address for the record and please limit your comments to three minutes. Under California law, the Eastern Sierra Council of Government Board is prohibited from generally discussing or taking action items not included on the agenda. However, the ESCOG may briefly respond to comments or questions from members of the public.

1:49 Therefore, the ESCOG Board will listen to all public comment, but will not generally discuss the matter or take action on it. Are there any public comments? There is, but would you like me to take roll first? Oh, yes, let's take roll. Thank you. Chair Schwartz? Here. Council Member Wentworth? Here. Supervisor Corliss? Here. Supervisor Gardner? Here. Council Member Griffiths?

2:26 I'm here. Oh, you are here. Good. Whatever capacity you want me to be, I'll be here. Council Member. Oh, my God. Supervisor, I apologize for that. No words. Oh, my goodness. Supervisor Totoro. I see him. I think he's muted. Council Member Ellis. Yeah, I was muted. I'm here. Sorry. All right. Thank you. Council Member Ellis. I'm here. And Council Member Salcido. Thank you. Great. Thank you, Angie, for reminding me of that.

3:04 All right, we'll move on to the consent agenda. Do I have a motion to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of June 11, 2021? So moved. I think you have to go back. Is there public comment, Angie? There was a hand raised. It's down now. And there it is up again. We've got Laura Drescher would like to make a comment. Laura, you can go ahead and unmute yourself. Morning, folks. Can you hear me?

3:37 Okay, I see heads nodding. So I just wanted to update this team. You might remember I'm with a company called Quantified Ventures. We are based in D.C., but we have been working with the Inyo National Forest looking at how can we bring more funding and financing to campgrounds on the Inyo. And I just wanted to update this team that we are, or this group rather, that we are finishing our business plan, finishing that up.

4:06 Next month. And also, funny timing, we also put in for a future phase of this work that would be building, actually building on and implementing that business plan. The Innovative Finance for National Forest Program run through a collaboration with the National Forest Foundation and the Forest Service and the U.S. Endowment for Forestry and Communities. They've issued a second round of funding and so we worked.

4:34 to put in an application there. We anticipate hearing back on that also in the month of September. So a lot of things coming to conclusion here, but especially if we are awarded that second phase of funding to go ahead and implement the business plan, we're really looking forward to engaging more closely with you all on the business plan and are already thinking about, you know, how do we...

5:02 Break out of our Zoom silo and travel out and spend some time and meet with you all. So just a heads up on some of the things you've heard about the business plan and the IFNF program and what's been happening in that arena. Thank you for the update, Laura. That's great news. All right, let's move on to the consent agenda to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of June 11th, 2021. Is there any public comment on the consent agenda?

5:39 No public comments. Thank you. Okay. Can I have a motion? So moved. Second. All right. Call for the vote. Can we have a call for the vote? I'm sorry. Chair Schwartz? Yes. Vice Chair Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes, ma'am. Supervisor Tothero? Abstain.

6:27 Council Member Ellis? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. All right, let's move on to policy matters. We have a large agenda today, so I'm going to try and give time to items that we want to have a lot of discussion for. So 5.1, receive a presentation from Mr. John Urdi, Executive Director, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and Ms. Ashley Helms, Deputy Director, Airports Inyo County, regarding the Bishop Regional Airport.

7:00 I will take it over to you guys. I think it might actually be more worthwhile to start with Ashley just to get the update on the physical plan. Okay, let's start with Ashley then. Thank you. Morning. Ashley Helms, Inyo County Public Works. I'm going to share my screen. So I'll be giving a brief update on the physical work that's been done at the airport as well as a few other items that the Bishop Airport.

7:42 has been carrying out to prepare for the proposed commercial service. I looked at the last time we presented to ESCOG, I believe, was later in 2019. So I've tried to do an update on everything we've done since then. So in 2020, we completed two major airport improvement projects, which were funded by the FAA.

8:22 with some funding also coming from the California Division of Aeronautics. The first project done in the summer of 2020 was the taxiway rehabilitation project. We rehabilitated all of the taxiways at the airport to varying degrees. Several taxiways were pulverized and repaved, some received crack repair and slurry seal.

8:53 The project was very successful and was completed on time and within the budget. The second project was a rehabilitation of runway 1230, which is the primary runway at the airport and will be the runway used by the air carrier. The center 100 feet of, well, the 100 foot runway received a three inch overlay.

9:27 of asphalt, and the shoulders, or 25-foot paved shoulders, because the runway used to be 150 feet wide, were pulverized and repaved. They were in very bad condition. I think it was like original asphalt from World War II. So that was also a very successful project that wrapped up in December, I believe. So we have

9:58 Almost all of our asphalt at the airport now is in excellent condition. Oh, and that second grant was 100% federal funding. That was a special grant that was received by the airport. I think two of those grants went to the state of California or went to airports within the state of California and we were lucky enough to get one of those. Okay. One of the other construction projects that is soon to begin

10:32 is the construction of a sprung structure similar to other structures within the Eastern Sierra. I think there's several in Mono County and we have at least one in Inyo County down in Independence. So we went out to bid for a vendor for this type of building and did receive only one bid from Sprung Structures Incorporated.

11:03 And then just two days ago, we opened bids for a general contractor to do the site work, connect utilities, and erect the structure. So we'll be awarding that within the coming few weeks. We do anticipate long-term use of this facility for general aviation activities, but this will temporarily house the TSA screening area.

11:35 Passenger screening area, pardon me, and the passenger waiting area. And we do have a separate commercial service terminal. Once this is underway and we know what our passenger load is likely to look like into the future, we will be doing a terminal area study and

12:11 the other planning documents required to move forward with a separate commercial service terminal. We do have it in our capital improvement program with the FAA for fiscal year 2026. And that will be in a separate location. It'll allow us to completely separate general aviation activities from commercial service activities. The proposed structure will connect to the existing terminal

12:42 The photo on the top here is just an example of what the building would look like. It will have a flat face like this, so it looks a little different than some of the other ones that we have in the region. There will be a 22-foot corridor that connects from our existing terminal, and it will connect into where the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority offices currently are, and the structure will be located on that south side of the existing terminal.

13:13 And ESTA is in the process of moving out into their own administrative offices out in their in the parking lot at the airport. So they'll still be at the airport, but they'll have a lot more space and be out of the airport terminal within the next month or two. And there are some renovations that will occur within the existing ESTA offices, which

13:44 will make room for a, we'll be repurposing that area to use it as the lobby, the united check-in area, and TSA baggage screening. So construction on the structure is anticipated to begin in early September and wrap up in mid-November, just in time for service to start in mid-December.

14:21 One of the other FAA grants that we received in 2020, yeah, fiscal year 2020, I think we received it in August of 2019, was for the purchase of an aircraft rescue and firefighting vehicle. We do have an older art vehicle at the airport. It was Mammoth's old truck. It's from 1986 and is not up to the current standards required. So the FAA issued

14:49 issued us a grant to cover 100% of the costs of the new truck, as well as other equipment necessary for staffing the vehicle. The vehicle shipped this morning from the Midwest, where it was constructed, and will be here sometime late next week.

15:15 The vendor sends a technician out with the vehicle or shortly after to provide a five-day training for all of the staff on maintenance requirements and operation of all the different components of the vehicle. It is an index B vehicle, our vehicle, which is slightly above the RF.

15:47 capabilities that are the minimum requirement for us right now, but it'll allow service to grow over the next 10 to 15 years. It will be able to handle any projected growth in service. We have sent staff members down to the FAA-approved ARF.

16:12 Training course. Myself and one of our other airport technicians have completed the course and we have two more going next month. And then we also have some trainings specific to our airport and our vehicle that will be completed in the next two months. So another big component of the proposed air service was the environmental review of both the FAA.

16:44 Issuing the operating certificate, the Part 139 operating certificate for the airport, and the amendment to SkyWest Airlines operating specifications. So that's been ongoing for the last year and a half. And the document was put out for the two documents, the NEPA and the CEQA document. No, I'm giving their presentation.

17:19 Sorry about that. That was our operations supervisor. Okay. So the National Environmental Policy Act Environmental Assessment and the California Environmental Quality Act initial study were put out for public review on March 4th. And the public review period ended April 12th. We received five comments. Three from

17:49 members of the public, one from Caltrans and one from the town of Mammoth Lakes. All comments were addressed in the final documents and the final CEQA negative declaration was reviewed and approved by the Inyo County Planning Commission on July 28th and recorded that the negative declaration was recorded with the Inyo County

18:21 Clerk Recorder after it was approved. And the NEPA document, the FAA actually sent me yesterday the signed copy of the finding of no significant impact and record of decision. So they have completed their review of the final document and have approved the Fonzie Rod. Now that we have received the document, we will

18:56 Put a notice in both area newspapers and make the final document available for public review. So just some other coordination that's been underway. The FAA has been very involved in this process and very supportive of the activities at both airports in the Eastern Sierra Region. We've been holding monthly coordination meetings with a lot of

19:32 of different players and two FAA area district offices, the regional office. It's been wonderful to have their full support and engagement. We do have our FAA Part 139 inspector here right now. We completed our final airfield inspection, daytime and nighttime inspections yesterday, and she will be here again today after this meeting.

20:03 to review the final paperwork, but we are feeling very good about how the inspection went. And then TSA approved our request for federal screening equipment on June 1st and has been very engaged since then on the federalization of the Fisher Board. I believe there were

20:35 seven TSA staff people that came last week to see the airport and to meet us and to talk about layout and security plans and how everything would work out. And they've been very helpful, very engaged as well. It's been a great process. We hold bi-weekly meetings and then other breakout meetings as necessary and they feel good about

21:07 Getting everything in place well in time for December 16th. United did begin selling tickets on June 19th. I think John's going to talk a little bit more about the air service component, but they did have a disclaimer in there that it was subject to federal approval, which the main approval needed was received yesterday. And maybe

21:42 I can answer questions now about the airport or we can wait until after John's presentation. Thank you, Ashley. That is a lot of hard work that you guys have put into this project and I know that our constituents are overwhelmingly excited about it. Is there any questions that anyone has? Hi, Karen. It's Stacy. Sorry, I'm on my phone.

22:18 Can't see everyone very well, so sorry if I act like I've never been on Zoom before. No questions. Thank you, Ashley, for the presentation. I just feel compelled to, I'm thinking of him right now to say none of this would have been possible were it not for the incredible work of Clint Goulter, and we all miss him and remember him. And I'd like to ask that we adjourn our meeting today in his memory. But, you know, thinking of, I remember Clint.

22:46 Probably five years ago, coming before this board, the ESCOG board, really encouraging us to think regionally and broadly and strategically about air service and his leadership has gotten us here today. So thank you, Clint, and all of Inyo County staff and board members. Well said, Stacey.

23:15 Ashley, I'm just curious, what were the nature of the five comments in the environmental document? The Caltrans comment was correcting something about bus service to Mammoth, I think. Our consultant said that there was Amtrak bus service. The town of Mammoth Lakes was requesting a modification to

23:49 The description of challenges to the air service at the Mammoth Airport. And the three comments from the public, the concerns were focused on air quality impacts from the air service to our valley. I believe one mentioned noise impacts as well, but air service was the primary concern.

24:21 And what was the answer to the air quality concerns? Well, the analysis looked at the increase, the analysis that was in the documents looked at the increase of each pollutant that would arise from both the

24:58 Aircraft coming into the airport and the increase in traffic and trips from the airport all the way up to Mammoth. It took all of those emissions into account and then compared those to the threshold for a significant impact that have been adopted by Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District.

25:31 They haven't set their own criteria for a significant impact, but they have adopted the criteria, or the thresholds rather, from the Mojave, I can't remember the full acronym, but another regional air quality board. And it falls well, well below the thresholds.

26:04 Thanks. I just, you know, constituents have brought that up and it just seems, you know, it seems kind of obvious to me that it's not going to be a significant impact, but it's something that keeps coming up. So it's looking for ways to answer when constituents come with that question. I think it's good that it's been measured and studied now. So it's not like it's an assumption that we don't think it's going to impact air quality. We actually know now that.

26:37 It isn't going to. So that's good. Yeah. And it did look at the 10-year, well, I believe our second study year was in 2028, which is where the flight forecast or the passenger forecast levels out at six daily flights. So I looked at the growth, the effects from the growth or proposed growth as well.

27:12 Any other discussion or comments? Well, again, Ashley, thank you so much for your time. That just from back when we were standing in a circle at the Mammoth Airport, I don't know, six years ago to now is really lightning speed, I think. So thank you so much for your hard work. And John, do you want to take it over? John Urdi? Yeah, absolutely. Thank you. Let me share my screen here.

27:49 And just to note, too, we've got Grady Dutton and Dan Holler on the line if there are specific questions regarding Mammoth-Hosemite Airport as far as the physical plan. So really what I'm going to focus on is the transportation side of things. So the routes, the carriers, the transportation that's being looked at for the airport itself. So thank you for your time this morning. And this isn't, okay.

28:17 So for Mammoth Yosemite Airport, we are looking at scheduled charters, which we've been flying into Mammoth Yosemite for the last six years. We last year were scheduled to with a company called Advanced Airlines. They are very dedicated to the region. They have a hangar here. They've been flying service through their charter service for decades. In fact, their tail numbers on their main planes are 395 MTS. So Mammoth to the sea.

28:44 And obviously, homage to Route 395. In fact, Donnie Sandusky, who's one of the owners of the company, is up here right now with his family on his annual summer vacation. So they're very dialed into the area. They've worked with Huck Creek Aviation for years. And so even though we didn't get to work with them last winter because of the pandemic, we are excited to really get off the ground with them this year. So one of the best things with them is they fly two different aircrafts for their scheduled charter service. So they have flexibility.

29:14 They fly a 30-passenger Dornier 318, which is the main passenger jet. And then they fly nine-passenger King Air. So if we have lower flight loads coming out of one of the markets, they don't have to fly the big plane. It can actually reduce the cost and take a smaller plane up to us. Right now, we're looking at flying Burbank, which we've flown for years with another carrier and been very successful with.

29:39 We're flying Carlsbad for the first time. It's probably the number one airport that we've had demand from or at least requests from and interest for. And then Hawthorne, which is another regional airport down in Los Angeles. So they're based out of Hawthorne. They provide a tremendous service and we're excited to be working with them out of those three markets for now. They actually did go out and they are in the process of purchasing a new 30-passenger Dornier four-hour service with the opportunity for us to even brand that.

30:09 Potentially. Service is going to really range four to six days a week. We won't fly on Saturdays with them. Saturdays are just typically a slow day. And we're going to start service just before Thanksgiving, the Wednesday before Thanksgiving, and run it for Thanksgiving weekend. Then we'll just run it for a couple of days for the weekends in early December, and then kick into the holiday schedule, which actually flies seven days a week. And then we'll go back to four days a week for

30:37 And then from February through the end of March, it'll fly six days a week. So we'll have great connectivity with them. Again, with the scheduled charter service and any passenger planes, 30 passengers or less, there is no TSA. So you can arrive at the airport about 20 minutes before your flight and no bag fees, et cetera. And as we've always had with the scheduled charter service, because they aren't scheduled in Bishop, they could divert if needed down to Bishop. So if we have winds or weather up here that challenge them,

31:07 It really has only happened maybe five or six times a year in the past few years, and it's very rare that we actually see their service completely canceled. We've worked with them. We do have a locals discount code that'll be available for Mono and Inyo County residents. That'll be released next week with a press release that's going out Monday from our office here, but basically it's Mammoth Local. And when I say off-direction travel, so typically on Thursday and Friday, the planes come in full, and then on Sunday and Monday, they leave full.

31:37 And what this would do is if we have locals that want to fly out on Thursday, Friday and fly back in on Sunday, Monday, typically the lower used segments, that'll save people 20% off. Those flights are already 20% lower than the peak time. So it turns out to be about a 40% discount in general. This is really just a rough idea of the schedule. Basically, we're looking at flying one plane. So you can see that it starts in Hawthorne, comes to Mammoth, goes from Mammoth to Burbank, Burbank back to Mammoth.

32:07 So it basically ping-pongs up and down the state of California. And this is the schedule that we felt works best. When we do get into the four-day-a-week schedule or when we're not flying Hawthorne, the schedule does change. I didn't put that on here just because it would just get a little bit confusing. But the main flights are really the Burbank flight and the Carlsbad flight. And Hawthorne is just another great option. And there's a good chance that the Hawthorne flight may fly the King Air if needed.

32:39 So we just move down the hill to Bishop. United is our carrier right now for the commercial service. You know, the big opportunities down in Bishop are to expand the markets and potentially the aircraft type in coming years. We know that's not an immediate thing. United Airlines would really love to be flying their Embraer 175, which is not much bigger than the CRJ-700. It's a 75-passenger jet. It's just not one of the approved aircraft at this point. So we will be continuing to work on that.

33:08 It's a very efficient, very comfortable plane that can fly, you know, we could fly further markets like a Dallas or a Salt Lake City as well. Looking for the destination folks, we're really looking at Bishop as a great opportunity for us to increase the reliability of the service and be able to open up the markets on the Northeast, you know, Boston, New York, even if we start to talk Midwest where we've got Chicago or if you start to get down into

33:35 Texas with huge skier populations. Believe it or not, Texas is probably one of the largest ski clubs in the country and great opportunities for us there. So for this year, we'll be flying the same routes that we have in the past. We'll be flying seven days a week from Denver, San Francisco, and Los Angeles. Service will start on December 16th and as Ashley mentioned, it'll run through March 26th at this point.

33:58 It's, you know, the idea of flying to Los Angeles, we talked with United, we were not sure that it would be as successful as it has been in the past, because of the fact that you still have, you know, still have an hour to head up the hill from Bishop. And so we worked with United to make that as affordable and lower the risk for us as much as possible. And they worked really, really well with us on that. So we're going to try it for this year. We didn't think the connectivity, or at least in the past, the connectivity there had not been great. This year, it's actually

34:28 pretty strong. So to go into that on here, the San Francisco flight starts, it's our first flight in the morning. We tried to spread things out so that they were a little bit separated so we could make the transportation work as well. And so the San Francisco flight is a morning flight. The connectivity inbound is not as strong as the other as Denver because of the time of day. So there aren't a lot of flights that you can take from the East Coast, whether it's JFK or Logan Airport in Boston and connect through San Francisco.

34:59 So the connectivity inbound from San Francisco from the East Coast is not huge, but there still are 36 flights that come in at what we call a perfect connection, which is really anything, you know, kind of two hours or so where you won't have to wait in the airport for too, too long. Obviously, there are many more flights that come in that may have longer connectivity. You know, you may have a four-hour layover, but really these are all based on perfect layovers.

35:26 And then outbound from Bishop, we have 60 connecting flights. So once you get to San Francisco, you can connect all over the world to those. Denver is right in the middle of the day. We felt that that works very well from the East Coast. As you can see, the connectivity in Denver is phenomenal. And United is in the process of adding 20, I think it's 23 or 26 new gates at Denver International Airport. And so the connectivity will only grow from there. So when we look at 133 flights connecting inbound to Bishop,

35:56 You know, they're doubled up. You've got multiple flights from Newark. You've got multiple flights from Boston, multiple flights from Chicago, Houston, Washington, D.C., all of those different major markets for United. And then Los Angeles, as I mentioned in the past, you look at the inbound connectivity, the 28 inbound connections doesn't sound like a lot, but when we looked at the actual markets that are connecting for us, it's all of those major hubs. So it's Denver, it's Chicago, it's Houston, it's Newark.

36:24 And so we really feel that the Los Angeles flight, which typically in the past has been majority folks coming from Los Angeles, that we feel we have a great opportunity to connect people from around the country. And again, those folks that are coming from around the country are staying longer and spending more money here. So they're really the people that will fill the midweeks for us at this point, the midweek winter. On the transportation side, we've been working with Enterprise and National.

36:53 Enterprise has been established here in the Eastern Sierra for decades. They've worked with Hutt Creek Aviation at Mammoth Yosemite Airport, and they do have their office down in Bishop. As I mentioned, they've been a great partner, a long-time partner. When Hertz pulled out of Mammoth Yosemite Airport, they stepped up with additional fleet, and they did a great job of servicing for us.

37:16 Their focus, obviously, is going to be on four-wheel drive and all-wheel drive vehicles, and they're looking at an in-town location here in Mammoth Lakes with the idea that they could potentially do one-way rentals so people could fly in, rent a car, drive it up the hill, check into their hotel or their condo, return the car, use our free public transportation all week, and then rent the car and go back down the hill. We met last month. Ashley and I walked them around the Bishop Airport.

37:42 We looked at all of the opportunities down there for them. I think they're looking at potentially having six to eight cars on site, but then have shuttle services take people off site to get car rentals at their in-town location in Bishop. On the shuttle side, we're still working on this one. We have a few different people that have raised their hand and said that they're interested. We've got a local operator here in Mammoth Lakes that currently runs van service.

38:10 And they're looking to expand. We've got a company out of Colorado that services multiple mountain town airports in Colorado, and they are also looking to either partner with our local operator or potentially start a different business. Looking at 14 passenger vans, so we're really not looking at the motor coach or anything bigger than that. The idea is, you know, if you fly into a place like Montrose in Colorado and you're going to Telluride, it's an hour and 15 minute drive.

38:37 And whether you're staying in the town of Telluride or you're staying in Mountain Village, they put you in certain vans because they do door-to-door service. And so, you know, they will take you to, they'll say, okay, all the people that are going to Mountain Village are in van number five, and then they will drop you off right at the front door of your hotel or your lodging establishment. We really, really, really need to get the message out there about pre-booking the transportation. We want to make sure the last thing we want to do is have people show up in Bishop and not have a way to get up the hill.

39:07 Either they didn't make a reservation for a car or for a shuttle bus, and we all know that there's not a lot of other options out there. We don't want them thinking they're landing in a major metropolitan airport that has multiple options and last-minute booking opportunities. So the pre-booking is going to be a massive message that we need to get out with all of our lodging properties. In town, in Bishop, we've worked with us to work on the dial-a-ride program to continue that.

39:36 There are other reserved private car services that will be operating. I know that a couple of the tax companies up here have different private services that they offer. And I would also assume that we'll probably see some Uber and other potential taxis or shuttles that pop up companies in the future. So I want to get into minimum revenue guarantees because I think that there's a lot of misunderstanding as to what those are. So I'm actually...

40:06 I don't really like to do PowerPoint karaoke here, but I'm going to read this verbatim just so you guys understand what minimum revenue guarantees are. With MRG, the airline is guaranteed it will generate a specific amount of revenue from ticket sales associated with the service. If the airline does not meet the targeted revenue, the local entity providing the guarantee makes a payment to the airline for the shortfall. Basically what that says is that they have to be guaranteed that amount of money or they wouldn't fly here.

40:33 They have, you know, as we know, a lot of the air service right now is strained. They have limited aircraft, they have limited staff, limited pilots, and they're going to fly where they make the money. And so without the MRGs, we wouldn't have service in either Mammoth or in Bishop. And the goal is to minimize the MRG by the success of the air service so that we can reinvest those funds into new markets. I think there's always been a question of when do we stop paying MRG, and I think the goal is not to stop paying MRG, it's to get...

41:01 certain routes profitable so that we can move into other potentially new routes for us. On the minimum revenue guarantees, so the scheduled charter service at Mammoth Yosemite, Mammoth Lakes Tourism has committed the first $275,000 of our Measure A dollars towards that subsidy, and the town at this point has come up with the potential gap of $175,000. The maximum that we would pay for service into MMH this year would be $450,000.

41:32 So if the subsidy comes in at $175,000, then MLT is $100,000 under budget. If it comes in at $375,000, then the town would come in with the next $100,000. But there's no risk of it going over the $450,000 mark. And we're also looking at that rolling into summer as well, looking at summer service in both markets. Commercial service to Bishop, we actually have the lowest

42:00 Cap number from United that we've ever had. Again, I mentioned that Los Angeles was going to be, we felt it was going to be too much risk. They wanted to continue to fly it, so they gave us a very, very low number on the cap there. San Francisco this year is about half of what it's been in the past. Denver's fairly expensive just because it's a much longer flight. You're looking at a two-hour, 15-minute flight, and so the total cap there is probably going to be right around $2 million. So the risk above and beyond what MLT has included.

42:29 is pretty minimal, and obviously, you know, I know Inyo County has expressed interest in the past at some level between winter and summer, and then Mammoth Mountain also, we still need to figure those pieces out. From my standpoint with the Tourism Business Improvement District, the funds need to go to benefit the people that pay into it, and so I need to make sure that we're paying for the folks that are coming specifically to Mammoth Lakes and spending money in those four categories of the T-Bid, lodging, restaurant, retail, and the ski area.

42:58 So that I can provide that specific benefit. The other thing that we've had in the past is that at least at Mammoth Yosemite, we've seen anywhere from 18 to 22% local traffic, meaning that it's you and I flying. And so we will be doing intercept surveys at the Bishop Airport to really get a feel for where people are coming from, how long they're staying, what sort of transportation they're using, and then we'll be able to at least know exactly who's coming into the airport and where their final destination is.

43:28 Are there any questions? I've got a question. What are the fares? So the scheduled charter is probably anywhere from 200 to 400 each way. But again, you're basically getting commercial service or private service at a commercial rate. And then United, we actually were challenged with some of the rates that were put out there initially. We had a number of ski clubs from the East Coast that were trying to book and they were coming up with

44:06 Rates that were way too high. And so we've really worked with them to get those rates down. You know, depending on where you're coming from, you know, they could be anywhere from $300 round trip to $600 to $900 to $1,000. The other side of it, too, is you do fly in from, if you connect through another market, if you originate at a place that you don't have direct service. So if you come from JFK in New York and you fly through Denver,

44:33 And you end up in Bishop. We only get credited the portion of the fare that is Denver to Bishop. So even if it's a $1,200 flight from New York, we may only get $400 for the segment towards our subsidy coming from Denver to Mammoth. So the direct flights are more advantageous for us as far as the subsidy, but obviously someone coming from New York will come and spend much more than a weekend and much more than a drive market visitor.

45:02 The LA flights you think will be around, what do you think the LA flights will be? You know, I would say that they're probably, you know, if you were to fly on a Tuesday, they could be 300 bucks round trips. You're going to come on a Friday non-holiday, it might be six to 100, 800. You know, it's all, it's all dependent on demand. Thank you. Yep. Mr. Mammoth? Yes. Madam Chair, I'll just pop in here, I think, just to...

45:35 echo a little bit on the Supervisor Corliss' statement. I mean, if we go back on the ESCOG and think back over the last four or five, six years, reliable regional air service, and here we are, this is a huge, huge development and a huge opportunity for all of us going forward. We've all got our fingers crossed that Ashley, you get all that infrastructure work done and all the...

45:56 All the, everything gets signed and the lights work and, you know, the sprung structure goes up. Super exciting. And John, that all the work you've been doing with the airlines for the air service, that all these things are going to come together, it's going to work. There are going to be some growing pains and we're all going to be patient, figure out how we get through all that. I think one of the things, once we kind of get through this first season,

46:17 is to start looking at how we're going to optimize all this. A couple of things to look at down the road, the TBID is up for renewal, Mammoth in a couple of years, I think, John, is that right? Yeah, 2023, September. Yeah, so we need to be thinking about, do we really have this whole thing financed properly? How do we make sure that's really going to benefit Inyo County, City of Bishop, Mono County, Mammoth is sort of an obvious target for all that, but how do we really distribute?

46:46 All the opportunities coming out of this going forward. So we don't have to get into all that right now, but fingers crossed. Great work, everybody. Let's all do our best to optimize this thing and make sure this is going to work. And then really start to optimize these opportunities for more economic activity here in the Eastern Sierra for our residents and to make sure we're doing all this with this sustainable mindset in mind. Our resources are going to be sustained and we're going to be playing all this for the long haul.

47:14 Great work, everybody, and let's see how this goes. Yeah, John, and to that point, I'd love to throw out there that the Bishop Airport has really popped up on a lot of people's radar. You know, American Airlines, we reached out to them and they said, yeah, we've been watching you and we're interested. So we have started discussions with them potentially to fly Dallas and Phoenix in the near future. I've got to say between Ashley and Mike and obviously Clint in the past as well,

47:43 The process has gone incredibly well, but we can't say enough about the FAA. The FAA has been phenomenal to work with, and I say that very rarely about government agencies. Mark McLarty and his team have bent over backwards to make sure that we can get this done. Mark was set to retire, I think, two years ago. I'm not sure it was just for this project, but he is very proud of this project, and we really appreciate all of that support from them. So, you know, I can't imagine that

48:13 Working with the FAA is always this easy, but this has been really just, they've been incredibly helpful and incredibly collaborative. Yeah, well, that's all great to hear. We couldn't have done without them. And this thing starts to work. We're going to have to, I know the ESCOG, we still have our MIWOG, GRACE, right, which is a special kind of a standing committee as needed. But how we start looking institutionally, how we're going to start, what's going to live with the ESCOG, what's going to live in some regional economic development stuff. I know there's things going down on in Bishop.

48:45 Inyo County around those things that will have a regional spread at some point, but we're going to have a lot of work to do to make sure this thing's going to really be successful. Yeah, and John, lastly, there is one of the things that the FAA wanted to put together and we started working on a year ago, regional system plan. So not just talking about, you know, what's happening in Bishop, but also what's going to happen in Mammoth, what's going to happen within both counties, because we do have other airports in

49:11 in Mono County, et cetera, but really talking about that regional plan, talking about what the future looks like, talking about who does what, and really what the strong suits are, because I think that even with Mammoth Yosemite Airport, we have the opportunity with the scheduled charter service, we've been working with multiple other, or have conversations at least with multiple other scheduled charter airlines that want to fly in here, and so we have a great opportunity to expand that service as well. And what's the status of that regional plan? I remember

49:39 Hearing a lot about that. I haven't heard much about it recently. What's the status of that? I'll let Grady talk to that because he's mainly the contact for us on this side. Yes. We've actually prepared a draft request for qualifications for a consultant to do that study for us. I just received comments about a week ago from Ashley and Michael on that, and I'll pass them on to Caltrans. He'll be our partner in that. But again, it doesn't have a lot of detail in that draft scope because it's for qualifications.

50:05 based stuff. So it is moving forward. I know that FAA has staff assigned. Caltrans does as well, even though one of their key staff members actually moved over to the FAA side, which will be a great partnership as well. So that is moving forward. We anticipate a grant for that sometime in spring. So when we would see a draft report in the spring, Grady, or after that?

50:26 I think we wouldn't get the grant even until spring. My guess is that later this year, we'll actually start work on it. Some of the agencies may have to front some of the money. Hopefully, Caltrans will step up and be able to do that as we move forward. And then next year, you'll see a lot more activity. Okay, great. Thank you. I have a couple questions. Great presentation, everybody. And that is good to reflect how far we've come since just a few years ago. As far as the scheduled charters go,

50:58 Is there much impact on the Bishop Airport and staff costs and stuff like that? And are there any discussions about how that works if there is a big impact? I can speak to the idea that in the past it's really been four, five, six times a year, so it's really not a huge impact to begin with, but I can't speak to the impact on the staff down there. I think that my...

51:28 Things that keep me up at night when we do need to divert, we obviously don't have those folks scheduled for shuttle service up the hill, so how are we going to make sure that folks that are coming in and going out on schedule charter down there get up the hill as well, so, but I can, I'll defer to Ashley on the impacts to the airport. Oftentimes those flights have come in during our normal scheduled hours at the airport. There have been times where staff has had to stay

52:02 A couple hours after their normal land time of 5 p.m. But we do, when commercial, so the scheduled charter flies in under part 135, when those aircraft land at our airport, we do collect a ramp fee from them. Our ramp fees are not very high, but that does offset the cost of having staff stay after.

52:36 Okay, and then do they refuel as well? I don't know if they do every time, but certainly sometimes. Okay. And Jeff, Pat Foster and his team from Hutt Creek Aviation typically go down. If they know the flight is getting direct, they will leave Mammoth to the airport and go down and meet the plane as well, so it limits the impacts on the staff down there. Yeah, I believe they've used the Mammoth Mountains shuttle bus to come down. Yes, in the past.

53:12 Okay. And then my other question, you know, I think the $6 million slide you had there was the question marks under the subsidy, but we're not calling it subsidy. What are we calling it? M, minimum, M, G, M, what's that? You can call it subsidy. It's minimum revenue guarantee. Subsidy is just the... I like minimum revenue guarantee sounds more eloquent. There you go. MRG, it is then. MRG.

53:40 So, you know, there were the question marks below for Mammoth Mountain and Inyo County. Who's having those discussions? Are those discussions happening? You know, what forum are they happening? When do they need to be decided? How's that all working? Yeah, absolutely. And so the MRG is in the past, so the, you know, you scared me when you said $6 million. The cap this year is sitting just over $2 million. So we're in for the 1.51.

54:09 In the past, we've had a cost-sharing agreement with Mammoth Mountain to fund anything above and beyond the $1.51 million that we are committed to for winter subsidy. I think that those discussions are going on. Ashley and I talked about that maybe a month ago, and we do still need to get one final meeting together just to make sure that we have all of our cost-sharing. We've talked about multiple cost-sharing agreements to make sure that that is covered.

54:37 Again, working with United, I'm glad to see that the gap is much smaller than I think I originally anticipated that it could be. I think the bigger questions come down to places like summer service. You know, I think for year one, I'm willing to contribute a fair amount to run service, but it's probably a Father's Day to mid-September timeframe versus taking risks during the spring and fall when we typically see the reductions in demand.

55:05 So I think we're trying to walk before we run here. I think United recognizes that with us with the winter subsidy. The fact that it's the gap is really less than, well, it's about $500,000 that we need to answer that question to. But yes, we are having those continued conversations to make sure we typically do our cost sharing agreement with the Mountain in September. And so we should have all that lined up well before we get to the service starting December 16th. And a little bit more on that from the Inyo County side.

55:35 So there were several discussions over the last several years with John, Mike, myself, Clint, and Eric Clark from Mammoth Mountain Ski Area talking about how it would work. And then more recently, Eric Clark provided copies of past agreements with Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

56:06 And we discussed the likelihood of two separate, as John said, two separate cost-sharing agreements, one between Mammoth Mountain Ski Area and Inyo County, and one between Mammoth Lakes Tourism and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. And let me also clarify, too, the mountain actually, for the winter service, Mammoth Lakes Tourism contracts directly with the scheduled charter service. Mammoth Mountains continues to be the main contractor with United Airlines.

56:38 There are a lot of pieces that come behind the United Airlines contract that Mammoth Lakes Tourism doesn't have the funding to manage. So Mammoth Mountain has handled that from the lines of credit that they have, from the insurance, et cetera. So that's why we actually contract the service through Mammoth Mountain, and then we reimburse Mammoth once we get all the invoicing at the end of the year. And we did, so after receiving those...

57:09 examples of those agreements. Grace actually reviewed a bunch of stuff that I sent over, and we've, Mike and Leslie and I have started talking about it. Eric Clark is out of the area right now, but he'll be back in a week or two, and we'll be having some final discussions and then bringing something. Great, thank you. Any other questions? All right, any comments from the public? No public comments at this time.

57:53 All right. Well, Ashley and John, thank you so much for the hard work and for the presentation today. I know everyone in the area, like I said previously, is overwhelmingly excited. So thank you, thank you. Thank you for your time this morning. Thanks. We look forward to seeing you guys on December 16th for the inaugural flights. Yeah, are we going to, is there something being planned for that, one hopes? Oh, yeah. Cheese plate. There's going to be a cheese plate. Okay, and some fruit maybe, or?

58:23 What? Maybe some fruit. Depends on the cracker. Maybe. Can we smash a bottle of champagne on the plane? Someone from the FAA requested tequila. Yes. Great. Okay. Thank you very much. Great. Thank you. All right. Let's move on to 5.2. Receive an update on the CAL FIRE Wildlife Coordinator Grants.

58:58 Good morning, honorable supervisors and council members. It's a pleasure to be with you this morning. It was really good to get an update on the regional airport. Unfortunately, that leaves us with a lot of items to get through in a short period of time, so I'll keep my update items as brief as possible. Of course, always happy to take follow-up questions you may have.

59:21 So we've brought this item before you a number of times before we've been anticipating that CAL FIRE would be releasing a grant for counties to have a two-year position for wildfire coordinators. That grant has been released earlier this month on August 2nd. At previous ESCOG meetings, we had representation from Inyo and Mono County, and it was decided that both counties would apply independently for this grant opportunity.

59:51 Since it is competitive and there is not funding for each county in California. I've spoken with Inyo and Mono County and they are proceeding to submit applications independently. Those applications are due on September 15th.

1:00:07 And the award will be announced in October. At our previous ESCOG meeting, your board prepared a letter of support that could be provided to both Inyo and Mono County, and I will intend to provide that following this meeting unless there's direction to do otherwise. With that, I'm happy to take questions. I believe that Ms. Kelly Williams is here from Inyo County, and Mr. Rick Cattleman is here representing Mono County if you have questions about their specific applications. Thank you.

1:00:40 It looks all straightforward to me. Thank you. I don't have any questions. Anyone else? Kelly, did you want to give us an update from the Inyo County side? Good morning, board and council members. I really appreciate you guys providing the support letter. That will be a great attachment to go along with it. I've been working closely with the fire safe councils that we do have established.

1:01:14 Getting some input on, you know, what they're looking for, on how we can best use this funding if we are awarded the grant. So we're in a really early stage. The grant is actually for 18 months, not for two years, unfortunately. So when this does get, goes for review in September, it has to be submitted September.

1:01:42 They're going to award it in October at some time. They didn't give an actual date. So when that comes about, we're going to have to hit the ground running because we only have a certain amount of time and a lot of things need to be accomplished in that short period of time. I think we have things aligned pretty well in Inyo County. And so I'm hopeful that we're awarded because we certainly need this position. And I know you guys up there.

1:02:12 in Mono do as well. So I'm sure we can connect both of these people together once we both get the grant. We'll think positively. Anyway, thank you for support and I look forward to receiving the letters as soon as it's ready. Thank you. Thank you, Kelly. Any public comment? No public comments at this time. Any other questions or discussion? Okay.

1:02:45 So go ahead, John. The cities and towns are watching all this very carefully, but we don't have much in this, but good luck to the counties in all this, and hopefully we can continue to collaborate and maximize our collective resources. That would just add, you know, I think a big part of the grant, though, is working across administrative boundaries. Our Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District Chief.

1:03:13 Free Vault is following this very closely and, you know, very supportive of it. So by note, you know, and a part of our application, this is actually coming to the Mono Board to, you know, to authorize our CAO to apply for the grant on behalf of the county. And a big part of it will be working with the town, working with all our fire districts in Mono County. Does Mono County have a disaster services coordinator?

1:03:46 No, we still don't. Working on it. I recommend it. Everyone should have a Kelly. I know. Kelly, how do you feel about being cloned? But that's why, so I know Rick is standing by, really have to, for Mono County, you know, we are really limited on staff capacity.

1:04:10 Our CAO managed to hire a brilliant staff member for his office who immediately had to go into the position of acting clerk recorder registrar voters and administer the special election, which is, of course, the day before this grant is due. So Holly and Rick, in their capacity as the regional forest and fire capacity program contacts, agreed to help Mono County.

1:04:38 get this application in, so it takes a village, but hopefully we are part of our strategic planning effort for 21-22 is to create some kind of an emergency services department. Okay, let's move on to item 5.2. Receive an update on the, wait, we just did that one, 5.3.

1:05:05 Considering of a resolution of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments designating authority to negotiate and execute an agreement with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife to receive grant funds in the amount of $3,384,239 for the Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator.

1:05:29 Good morning again, Board. In February this year, the ESCOG Board provided a resolution that authorized staff to submit an application to California Department of Fish and Wildlife.

1:05:42 Proposition Restoration Grant for the Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator. The grant application was prepared by Janet Hatfield, and you may remember that the project is intended to develop local capacity and skill for preparing NEPA and CEQA documents for projects that will be located on federal lands in partnership with the U.S. Forest Service so that that

1:06:09 Team can work independently of the capacity of the Forest Service to meet their NEPA requirements. And the pilot project associated with developing this interdisciplinary team or the ID team would be the large fuels reduction project located around Mammoth Lakes. Very fortunately, we received notification that that grant was awarded in June for the amount of $3,384,269.

1:06:39 There was a component of the original grant application that was removed for biomass planning. Ms. Hatfield was able to secure funding from a CAL FIRE grant that would take care of that. And so that component of the grant no longer falls under the scope of this project, but will still occur and may be considered a match against this project as well, which is beneficial.

1:07:03 We received a draft agreement, which we have been working on in partnership with CDFW to make sure that it

1:07:11 reflects the scope of the project proposal and the budget and the personnel all line up the way that the narrative was originally written. I have included the most recent draft of that agreement for your review. It is still being finalized. I've received a most recent version just this morning. At this point, the only changes that are being made are, again,

1:07:35 Just ensuring that the scope of work reflects the draft proposal and that the personnel lines up, but there's not significant changes anticipated to terms or conditions. With that said, in order to execute the grant, I need an authorization from your board.

1:07:53 for the Executive Director to negotiate and execute the grant for us to receive funding. As mentioned, the grant is for approximately $3.4 million. Of that, there's $123,700.

1:08:08 $123,729 in anticipated reimbursement for administration to the ESCOG directly, as well as $5,000 in indirect cost recovery for every subcontract that we are going to administer for a total of $15,000 in revenue directly to the ESCOG. I think that really concludes my overview of the resolution.

1:08:37 This morning, as I said, the most recent draft of the agreement is available for your review. It does focus mostly on just ensuring that the deliverables and the scope of work are in alignment with the grant proposal. I believe Ms. Hatfield is...

1:08:53 also available to answering questions you may have. But at this time, I would request that the board adopt the resolution of the ESCOG designating authority to negotiate an exoncute an agreement with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife to receive grant funds in the amount of $3,384,239 for the Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator. Happy to take questions. Ms. Hupla and Ms. Hatfield are also available. Thank you.

1:09:24 Jeff? I'm wondering if you could, if this is technically possible, if you could share your screen and put the line item budget detail up and just kind of go through it line by line and explain what each one is and where, who that money goes to and just to make it clear in my mind.

1:09:47 The line in a budget? I can do that, but it will take me a moment. So perhaps while I'm getting organized for that, we could take additional questions from the board. Thank you. So, Madam Chair, I'm obviously, I think we're all fully in supportive of this. I think that kind of detail Jeff's asking for is appropriate. One thing for all of us to keep in mind is doing something like this with this grant.

1:10:14 is dependent upon leadership in the international forest continuing to be supportive of doing third-party NEPA. And that's something that we should not lose sight of. That's the only way that these kinds of things work. So let's just all make sure we keep that in mind. I don't see anybody from the Forest Service on the call. I'm sure they're out for a number of reasons. But this is great. I mean, when do we adopt our shrimp? When do we become a...

1:10:40 Joint Powers Authority, and here we are putting resolutions for three and a half million dollar grants, so it's good work. Not that easy. Those are my thoughts, but I'm prepared to make a motion when we're ready. Please give me a minute. I am continuing to find the place in the agenda where we have that. It's either page 14 or 50, depending upon which. Thank you. That's helpful. I think I'm nearly there. There we go. Okay. Thank you for your patience.

1:11:35 Hi, can you see my screen? Am I on mute? You're all good. Very good, thank you. So as you can see, the first bunch of budget under A is personnel services in the amount of $124,000 approximately. All of that is ESCOG budget. So the...

1:12:06 Executive Director for the time being would be me. There is budget in here to continue or to consider ramping up for staff, though obviously that would be grant-funded staff and subject to future discussion of the board, as well as funding for our legal counsel. There's nothing under operating budget, obviously.

1:12:30 And then going down to see operating expenses. This is really the bulk of the budget and that corresponds to the scope of work. And so the scope of work consists of developing an interdisciplinary team and all of the project management.

1:12:53 Work that would go associated with that, such as getting appropriate permits, running RFPs, managing budgets, so on and so forth. Under environmental planning, that is a lot of the work that would be associated with the NEPA, so conducting biological studies and archaeological studies, studies of trees. There's budget in there for recreation planning, which is not...

1:13:17 Typically included in NEPA, but has been accounted for in this, given the nature of the project and its location. There is also funding for the Forest Service to collaborate in developing that interdisciplinary team to ensure that their product and their skill set is what will be necessary for getting that environmental permitting in the future. Then there is

1:13:43 money included in there for implementation planning, which is what is necessary for preparing for the fuels reduction and actually taking the project that the NEPA will be permitting and getting ready to have that done. That includes within it outreach and education to the public as well as some workforce development activities for identifying

1:14:09 Ideally local contractors who can do that fuels reduction. And then as I mentioned, the biomass planning task has been removed from that scope of work and we are working with CDFW to ensure that this agreement and the budget will, you know, reflect how these monies will actually be spent. Were there additional, oh, I should also add, this is very relevant at this time, this grant is being submitted.

1:14:37 And administered by the ESCOG. And as a government agency for all of those tasks under item C, so for the bulk of that scope of work, we will be developing requests for proposals or requests for qualifications for qualified teams to bid to do that work. And I think that there will be

1:15:03 I will be working with Ms. Hookla to make sure that the way that those RFQs are structured is both efficient for project implementation, but also designed in such a way that we're getting the best outcome for the intent of the grant, which is to ensure that we have that capacity locally for future environmental permitting through the federal government.

1:15:38 Perfect. That explains it all clearly to me. Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions? Any public comments? No comments at this time. So, Madam Chair, I would move that the Eastern Sierra Council governments approve and affirm the resolution as presented. Second. Call for a vote. Oops, I was muted. Chair Swartz? Yes. Vice Chair Wentworth? Yes.

1:16:18 Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Totoro? Aye. Supervisor, I'm sorry, Council Member Bisch, Ellis, I apologize. Yes, it's okay. Having a hard morning, apparently. Thank you all. Okay, thank you, Angie. Let's move on. And thank you very much, Elaine and Janet, for all the hard work that...

1:16:49 went into this grant. I think it's going to be a great pilot project for other forests, and I think it'll be really beneficial to the Eastern Sierra. Next, 5.4, consideration to submit correspondence to the 2020 California Redistricting Commission regarding redistricting for Inyo County and Mono County. Good morning again.

1:17:18 I had the pleasure of visiting all four member agencies in the last couple of weeks to present the draft correspondence on the ESCOGs board's recommendations for redistricting, and it was very pleasurable to sit in on those meetings and hear what's happening throughout the region. So with that, I know that also you're all familiar with the correspondence presented for you today.

1:17:44 which was requested by your board in response to the request from the California Redistricting Commission to define the Eastern Sierra as a community of interest. As was presented to each of the member agencies, the two priorities identified by the ESCOG subcommittees were first, that Inyo County and Mono County should share state representation, and then secondly,

1:18:14 that if possible, we would be grouped with a Sierra Nevada sub-region for regional representation. Each of the four member agencies provided authorization to submit the correspondence with the following requests for slight modifications and additions, which I apologize, I have not been able.

1:18:39 to incorporate this week, however they are noted and will be made. One is that there's a typo on the bottom of page two, where it should say parts of the various counties that are listed. Also, there was a request from Inyo County to place greater emphasis on a relationship with LADWP and the unique shared agricultural economy between Inyo and Mono counties. There was also some minor wordsmithing that was done

1:19:08 in sentences related to our relationship to federal land ownership and LADWP land ownership. I believe the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mono County both agreed that they would also be submitting their independent correspondence that would mirror the recommendations of the ESCOG Board.

1:19:31 The only other item I would add at this time is that there is going to be a redistricting meeting held for public input on August 20th for our region from 2 to 6 p.m. and that information is available I know at least through the City of Bishop's website and probably other locations as well. We can certainly make that available. With that I would request that your board provide

1:20:00 authorization for staff to submit the correspondence to the California Redistributing Commission unless there are further comments or questions. Thank you. Was it unanimous everywhere? Yes, it was. And I would add that the Mammoth Lakes parallel letter is only to emphasize and to really just double down on the comments in the ESCOG letter. We feel strongly about it. We want to make sure that we

1:20:31 Anybody who's listening knows that we, as one jurisdiction, really support the ESCOG's letter and the efforts they're in. And the meeting that Elaine is referring to on the 20th is for all Californians to comment on. So you can get the word out to your constituents and they can register or just log on and offer their public comment. And Karen, I'd like to say the letter was well done, I think well drafted.

1:21:03 The points it made aligns us better, I think, strategically for what we need as counties. It takes us out of areas that we probably shouldn't be in where we're underrepresented and our needs and what our constituents need don't align with what happens in Fresno and different areas. So, and along those lines too, I want to say

1:21:29 You know, being on ESCOG for quite a long time and watching this, to see ESCOG regionally becoming a team and looking towards, you know, what we need as a region, it's impressive to see, and on behalf of City of Bishop, I want to thank every one of you and your entities for ESCOG is becoming an entity of its own and doing amazing things, so it's a pleasure to be part of.

1:22:00 And I'll just add to that, I did listen in on the last, I can't remember which zone we're in, is it zone G, it's Inyo, Mono, and basically the central Sierra Nevada counties that we, most of the central Sierra Nevada counties we list in our letter, that's how the Citizens Redistricting Commission has already grouped us for their communities of interest.

1:22:28 Public meetings, like the one coming up on the 20th, but there was one in July, and I listened in on that, and there was a lot of support. There were other people who commented from west side counties, including, if I recall correctly, Calaveras and Mariposa, who commented that they wanted representation for their mountain communities. And when the commission, a number of people from the Eastern Sierra spoke at the meeting,

1:22:55 You know, advocating for a for a district like we're describing in our letter. And I thought it was interesting that a number of people in these west side counties also were advocating for that and, you know, seemingly without communication between us. So I, you know, it's something I it makes me feel hopeful that maybe our comments could make a difference in this. Hey, any public comment?

1:23:26 I do have an email from Jane Anderson with the California Redistricting Commission. She was actually answering another email to us. It says, do tell the group that these numbers must now be formatted into the usable numbers and then have the prison population reallocated to their previous addresses for representation. The official California census database will be ready in the third week of September.

1:23:56 In the meantime, get your communities of interest into us at WeDrawTheLinesCA.org or in the Friday, August 20th COI public input meeting that is the last one dedicated to the counties in your area. I am attaching information that would be helpful in this regard. Please share with the group. I will forward that to all of the board members with her attachments and I'll update that onto the ESCOG website with the agenda. Thank you.

1:24:28 Thanks, Andy. Has anybody had a chance to find the numbers that were released yesterday as they pertain to us? I mean, I poked around a little bit, but it's like share files. There's a San Francisco Chronicle article that crunched some of the numbers, and according to there, I can send a link, Mono County lost 6% of its population.

1:24:57 And it's something like 13,100 people, whereas Inyo County gained population 2.5% to have a population of 19,016 people. Pretty interesting. I know, Mona, we really struggled with census response. I mean, we struggled too, and theoretically they adjusted for that, but... And on that note, Supervisor Griffiths, I was...

1:25:29 Just about to sit down with our GIS people to see if he could help me make any sense of the data, because my understanding is that what was released yesterday is...

1:25:42 effectively unusable for an average person. And that's why we have to wait about four weeks for California to crunch the numbers, not only so that California can do things like allocate the prison population to where they used to live, but also so that it can be put in something like an Excel format where any person can open it up and take a look at it.

1:26:04 So I was going to try to work with our GIS people to see if there's any sense that they could make of it. But if not, in four weeks, we should have very readily accessible data for anyone who wants to see it. I will move to approve the letter. Second. Great. Call for a vote. Chair Schwartz? Yes. Vice Chair Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes.

1:26:45 Supervisor Griffiths? I believe that was a yes. Supervisor Tothero? Aye. And Councilmember Ellis? Yes. Thank you. Great. Item 5.8. No, 5.5. Discussion and direction on the Fall 2021 Regional Housing Strategy Roundtable. Good morning again.

1:27:21 At our ESCOG meeting held in June, staff was given direction by your board to work with a subcommittee of the ESCOG board to begin discussing a regional housing summit or roundtable or a forum that the ESCOG could organize and host to bring together the staff and the representatives of each member agency to discuss regional housing issues and then ideally solutions.

1:27:50 Since June, I met with Supervisor Griffiths and Councilman Wentworth, as well as Supervisor Kreitz of Mono County, who took a particular interest in this item to discuss what the intent of such a workshop should be, what a draft agenda might look like, and who the stakeholders would be that are invited. So this is largely an update item, though I am hoping to get specific feedback from your board about

1:28:20 What the desired outcomes of such a meeting would be. The goals as they were established in the subcommittee would primarily be to educate local housing partners on the baseline.

1:28:34 The baseline conditions of housing policies and incentives across the Eastern Sierra, as well as the opportunities and constraints. Then to develop a collective policy agenda that would identify specific actions, responsible parties, and potential funding sources for regional housing stakeholders. And then finally to create a dynamic working group where all the housing stakeholders and advocates could work to discuss regional issues.

1:29:01 The agenda as presented in the staff report would be first a presentation from the staff of each member's agency on baseline housing conditions and policies and programs, followed by a very high level discussion about housing constraints, capacities and solutions that have been implemented in Inyo and Mono County towards meaningful results, followed by breakout groups of the staff and the

1:29:29 Other partners that would be invited to work on developing specific strategies, assigning responsible parties to those strategies and identifying possible funding sources. And then as media workshops would go, everyone would come together, compare notes. The outcome of this would be a...

1:29:51 A high-level action plan or strategy document. It would not be an adopted policy, so it would not be binding, but it would at least create a regional dialogue and a shared understanding of regional housing opportunities and constraints. The stakeholders identified would include Mammoth Lakes Housing, Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mono County, Inyo County, the City of Bishop, Inyo Mono Advocates for Community Action, Alterra,

1:30:21 The US Forest Service, the Bureau of Land Management, and of course, Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. As discussed, the timeline for hosting such a workshop would be in the fall, probably looking out towards October to do that. As I said, at a staff level, in order to organize such an event,

1:30:47 It would be important for me to have very specific direction from your board about what the outcomes would be, particularly since there is very limited capacity in each of our member agencies, and I value your staff's time a great deal, and I would want that to be meaningful for all participants. With that said,

1:31:07 I would invite feedback and discussion from your board. I would also add we had a very positive meeting with Mr. Derek Kirk of the governor's office yesterday in which he discussed that there will be specific funding dollars allocated regionally over the next three years to develop regional housing plans and

1:31:33 align those with potentially implementation dollars. So certainly I think the timing for organizing such an event is virtuous. So that concludes my update of the conversation we had and the work that the subcommittee has done since June. I'm happy to take your questions. Thank you. Well, I know that the City of Bishop, we just worked on updating our housing element. And one of the things that is,

1:32:11 You know, very front of mind is just purchase agreements with LADWP and holding them to their word that they will actually release some of this land for us to develop into housing. And I don't know, I know what like Mono County and probably not Town of Mammoth Lakes, you guys don't have LADWP land in your town, but you know, is there a way maybe we could collaborate working with LADWP on a regional level to, I don't know, hire someone?

1:32:41 I have no idea, but where we could maybe get the collaborative forces of our four entities together to have a point person that's just constantly hammering them on releasing these purchase agreements or, you know, getting these purchase agreements to the table? You know, I think that that's something that that's exactly the type of question that I think should be discussed at the right table. Okay.

1:33:13 I think the round table is the first step of getting everybody together to look at what everybody's capacity is, what our individual needs are, where they align, where we can work together. And, you know, I think, yeah. And I'll just add that. Go ahead, Jeff, sorry. The main outcome for me, you know, I think that it may take a couple of

1:33:42 A couple of steps to get where we're going. But the first step, I think, is getting everybody in the room and just making sure that we all know what everyone else's capacity and challenges. I agree with that, Jeff. I think this is a great idea. I do think it's got to be outcome-oriented. We don't need to have a bunch of people, you know, frankly, vent about what kind of a housing problem we have in the region. We need to get on with it.

1:34:13 And I think this is a good first step. I like the idea that it seems to be focused on specific outcomes. And I would hope, I think I saw the reference to sort of focus groups. Karen, your example is a great one. There needs to be a focus group that focuses on land. And one of the big pieces of that is LADWP that we all share. It needs to be a focus group on ADUs.

1:34:34 It needs to be a focus group on tiny homes. It needs to be a focus group on, you know, getting developer incentives and things like that. Basically have a lot of groups that just go after this stuff. Another concern I have, though, is this just can't be us. This has to be the business community. It has to be nonprofits. Federal agencies, as you say, everybody has to be involved in this so that we all own solution to the problem. And that's a tall order.

1:35:01 And then I'm also concerned, Elaine, about your ability to support it from a staff standpoint. I think down the road, as you point out, we may have some good opportunities for some grants, but just to get to October is a tall order. It's an incredibly different example, but our dispersed camping thing, which is nothing compared to what we're talking here, did require a devoted person who was subsidized by a foundation to do the legwork, to just get that little thing going.

1:35:31 We have a huge challenge here. And Elaine, with all the other things that you're doing and your time available, I'm concerned about the ability of us to be able to do this well in October. And it's not to take anything away from your skills and abilities, Elaine. It's more the hours of the day and your sanity in terms of everything that has to be done. And so I think maybe we need to be honest to ourselves about the staff ability to get this done well.

1:36:00 in terms of Elaine's, the limits to her time and her day, and perhaps augmenting that in some way if we can. And I think, Bob, we've talked about that, Jeff and I and Supervisor Kreitz, and I think the way to do this is to, you know, one little bite at a time, and I think to do something sooner that's...

1:36:21 It may not be as large as we'd all like it, but it's going to be starting to line out what are the specific needs that we've got things to focus on and then get a sense of what's going to be needed, as you're saying, down the road to sort of build it out. And I feel pretty confident that we'll be able to do something in the fall that's going to be, it's not going to be the whole thing, but it's going to be.

1:36:42 It's going to be the framework to get things started, to start moving things forward. This is enormously complex. I think from a land management perspective, you've got LEDWP, but also the U.S. Forest Service. And Bob, you and I have talked about a number of opportunities with administrative sites and those kinds of things. Land is probably maybe an initial real opportunity to focus for this first go-around to figure out, okay, what is the land-based? What have we got to work with? What do we not have to work with? What are the things we can start advocating for to bring more land into it?

1:37:11 And then I would anticipate follow-ups to start building on this thing to see where we go. Jim? I would... Just a quick one. I think Bob brings up some great points, but the funding source, because I believe, yeah, you can only stretch our staff so thin. But a funding source, as I'm sitting here listening to this, who is the most in need of housing? I think we need to bring them to the table, too, such as

1:37:43 Mammoth, both our hospitals, Inyo and Mono, we cannot keep staff here because they cannot find housing, U.S. Forest Service, so I think we need to bring them in and also look at them as a funding source. Can they help with the funding to hire a staff member to help all of us get to the end goal of finding more housing? And I think they...

1:38:07 They have a lot of interest in what we're trying to talk about here and maybe can help expedite this because they have businesses to run and organizations to run and cannot find staff and cannot find housing for their people. It hurts them. So I think it might be a good incentive for them to help expedite this through. Lane? I want to thank Supervisor Gardner for his concerns about staff capacity. And it is...

1:38:39 Something that both came up as part of our subcommittee meetings and something I've been thinking about. First, that such a meeting would require a qualified facilitator and that I do not think that that should be any of the ESCOG staff or board members. And then secondly, that I agree in order to just coordinate.

1:39:03 Staff and the member agencies to develop that baseline information and be prepared will require a great deal of coordination as well. I appreciate Councilman Ellis's point that we could potentially do fundraising for not potentially like bringing on long-term staff, but maybe just

1:39:24 developing a proposal to prepare us for this workshop and hiring a facilitator and someone who can organize those member agencies and getting the baseline data. Also, there is some contingency budget in the ESCOG budget for this year. I think we were going to wait a little further down the road to see if that was necessary, and I think it was specifically earmarked for grant writing services as necessary.

1:39:52 Potentially, there's that opportunity to procure services in a very limited scope to facilitate this workshop. Stacey? Yeah, thanks. I agree with all the comments made so far. It's a tough position. You want to get this going now, but you also want to do it right, and you don't want people working.

1:40:20 incredible overtime hours. One thing I want to point out, there's a great, and I know many of you are already aware of this, but I encourage us to actually reach out to them. The Mountain Housing Council of Tahoe Truckee is such a perfect model for what we're trying to do here. It's a project of the Tahoe Truckee Community Foundation. Unfortunately, in Eastern Sierra, we don't really have a true community foundation that covers the region, but

1:40:47 I'll send this link out to Angie and she can send it out, but let's not reinvent the wheel. They've done this and might even be able to help us maybe with facilitation, but there are 28 partners. And as Jim pointed out, including hospitals and special districts, they include the Board of Realtors, the Visitors Bureaus. I think those are, again, it's a good model for us on who should be at the table.

1:41:15 And, you know, yeah, with fundraising, I don't, you know, I don't know if there is a regional nonprofit who could really help us just, again, we don't, we don't really have that community foundation role filled, but I encourage reaching out to the Mountain Housing Council and at least using, at the very least, using that as a model so we're not feeling like we're starting from scratch. Ann? One of the aha moments for me in that wonderful discussion yesterday, thank you, Elaine,

1:41:49 was how the two land-based agencies in our area also have housing problems, and we ought to be able to use that. Certainly with LA releasing some land, Forest Service has some difficulty doing that, but are there some opportunities through permit that the Forest Service could have something on their land more in Mono County than Inyo County to help both their

1:42:18 housing issue and the bigger picture of housing issues. I think we ought to be using that as best we can. Do you think we should contact Mammoth Lakes Housing and see if they could facilitate such a workshop and be the ones to take charge and we could give them some of our money from our budget to compensate them for their time? I mean, is that... I'm just going to come back a little bit to the work that Jeff and... We've had a couple of meetings on this. Okay. And I think... And I've run...

1:42:47 We've been involved in housing summits of Mammoth. They can very quickly turn into very big productions. And that's fine. But I think we want to, I would really encourage us to take a first step in the fall so we can bring, we're not going to cover all the bases, but really answer and deal with a lot of these types of questions. And then if we want to do a larger effort, we get some real funding and real capacity to do, we can do that down the line. But I would, I don't, I want to make sure we don't.

1:43:17 We don't say, well, yeah, we got to go big and do everything, because that's, that'll put us months out, for sure, and that's, that's going to be a huge undertaking. And what are you envisioning? Like, what's, what's the small? The small thing? All right, Jeff, go ahead. I guess, so, as it's written in the staff report, you know, we got the four entities, Mammoth Lakes Housing, Amaka, Altera, Forest Service, BLM, and LADWP. So, I think that the first step,

1:43:47 I think what we're all talking about here is what will come out of this meeting, doing just an initial discussion with all of those sort of higher level invested communities of what is the next step, because there's some things that aren't regional in nature.

1:44:15 You know, I don't know that we need a regional discussion about what Mammoth is doing with the parcel. You know, they got that on lockdown. And so it may, you know, I think we'll know a lot more after this initial meeting. And there'll definitely be some planning involved with this meeting. But if we keep it small and focused,

1:44:39 And then we can have a better idea of what the next step is, and then we can decide who's going to pay for it, who's going to facilitate it. I mean, I'm all for it. I guess I'm just a little bit confused with what, you know, Elaine is the staff member who would coordinate it and what John and Jeff are proposing. Like, I feel like there's a bit of a disconnect there because I'm not seeing how can it be small with this many stakeholders at the table.

1:45:17 There's still a significant amount, even small, you know, I just don't, I don't envision, I mean, maybe it just stays as a subgroup until we can dedicate funds. I don't know. I'm not sure I'm seeing the connection between what Elaine suggested and what you guys are suggesting. I'm confused on how we're going to get to that meeting.

1:45:40 I'm assuming that what Jeffrey and I are saying is in line with Elaine, what you've presented in the staff report. So the staff report with that group of stakeholders, Karen, I think what Elaine's representing in the staff report is consistent with that kind of a gathering. Elaine, I don't want to speak with you, but is that about right? I think that there's validity to both sides. I think with that many stakeholders and that agenda, it could be

1:46:11 you know, a full half-day workshop to coordinate that. I also agree that rather than anticipating that it is going to result in a full, fully documented, you know, action plan, it is just that initial conversation and perhaps the conversation isn't so much how we're going to solve for housing, it's getting all the people in the room.

1:46:38 and working on those next steps, and perhaps that is almost even, in fact, the fundraising opportunity is to see what the engagement is from those agencies towards working together. And I think the analogy that Supervisor Gardner used for dispersed housing or dispersed camping workshop, I mean, the first one was very much

1:47:04 Yeah, and I think we can manage that. I mean,

1:47:36 I mean, between Jeff and I and Supervisor Christ and some others, I think we can get the capacity to do a half-day session to do, let's set the table, identify the issues, figure out where we're going to go, what the next steps are going to look like, and then bring that back to the ESCOG and say, this is what was determined, this is what this is looking like, and then what's it going to cost to do a larger effort? You know, where do we go from there? Yeah, I'm all for it. I just, you know, didn't want to...

1:48:10 Put effort into something and then have no key person to follow up and follow through. You know, you want to make sure if you're going to put the starting effort in, there's capacity to continue the conversation and follow through.

1:48:26 I feel pretty confident, at least from follow through, we can get whatever comes out of that half day thing, comes back to the ESCOG with some kind of a very simple black and white report app that says, okay, this is what we heard, this is what we found, this is what next steps potentially going to look like. And then we can start looking at, okay, what are the real capacity needs going to be to do something like this? And how much money do we have to raise to do it? Identify, I mean, I think Mammoth Lakes Housing could be perfect if they're willing to do it, you know, nonprofit sponsor for something like this.

1:48:53 In their strategic plan, they intend to try to get to be more of a regional entity. I know they're working on rebranding, so it's not just a Mammoth Lake specific thing. But I think we need to do that, do those first steps to figure out what's going to be needed going forward. I think we can pull that off in a half day thing with some Elaine's support from Jeff and myself and some others. I think we can pull this thing off. And would we hire a third party facilitator or would it just be like Elaine or John or Jeff to facilitate it?

1:49:26 We could hire, we could do a modest local third-party facilitator, but I think between, I don't know, I feel pretty confident we could facilitate this ourselves. I would not recommend that. I think you need somebody, that's the lesson we learned, you know, Paul McFarland, who is certainly local, but Paul was able to run it separate and then, frankly, track down everybody and still is. How are you doing? What's going on? What's happened? You said you'd do this. Who's going to do that?

1:49:56 Well, I think, again, I think the first step is to figure out exactly what it is we need to be chasing down. And I think that becomes something that we could find. We could talk to Mammoth Lakes Housing. Maybe they got someone who could facilitate a half-day session like this. Keep it relatively modest, but get it. Do something that comes back that then, Bob, articulates what these next steps are going to look like. Because we don't have a Paul McFarland for this thing yet.

1:50:26 No, that's my point. I'm all for it if there's, you know, a way to do it without it causing, taking away time from the bigger, the other projects we have going on with ESCOG right now. You know, I just don't, you want to give meaningful time to things like this. So I don't know if fall makes sense.

1:51:06 Even if it is kind of just throwing it together, if that's what we want, that's fine. I just, I guess I would defer to Elaine of whether or not it's in her capacity to even manage something like this. But yes, I'm all for it. I think it's within my capacity between now and we'll say October or November to organize a meeting of relevant stakeholders as identified in the staff report for a half-day conversation.

1:51:41 Yes. And I think that an advantage of doing that is, again, if there is this funding that is going to be coming out of the state to develop regional housing plans, then we do potentially have in the future a source of funding that could fund having a professional consultant come on board to develop a housing plan and rope all these people together. Well, at the same time,

1:52:06 Establishing a baseline of communication with each of these agencies in preparation for applying for that funding. So I could see there being value in that. I agree. I think your point, Councilman Schwarz, it is something that we need to invest focus and value time in.

1:52:34 And so I think the outcome will be proportionate to the amount of time we have. So if it is going to be in a more informal conversation.

1:52:41 which I do still think has some value, then we're just not going to anticipate that there's going to be big, robust action items that are coming out of that. We probably will not get to the place where we can develop focus groups on ADUs or DWP and task people to follow up with them. However, if it is an informal conversation for us to just all get together and talk about some housing issues and develop some loose strategies about how as a region we might begin approaching and addressing those, I think that is an accomplishable thing to do.

1:53:10 between now and fall. I think the other thing to do is that funding source that Derek was identifying yesterday, Elaine, which I don't know exactly what that is, but to use that as a framework so we can be setting ourselves up to saying, okay, there's money potentially coming out of the state, and then we can organize those funding sources for the next steps, and that might be a good way to frame that conversation. Yeah, I mean, that makes sense to me, that we start off with just the conversation.

1:53:46 And because it's, you know, we can talk about it, but, you know, we need the people who are day-to-day thinking about the housing issues to all be in the same room. And that's going to inform how robust and what kind of next steps we do. And I think that's the point where we look for funding, all of that. All right. Elaine, do you have direction?

1:54:20 Yes, it is my understanding that I will organize a meeting of the stakeholders as identified in the staff report for an initial discussion about regional housing issues and potentially developing some next steps and strategies to come out of that meeting where we would look for funding and develop a more formalized process. Great. Any public comment? No comments at this time. All right, let's move on. 5.7.

1:54:57 Receive an update on the Sustainable Recreation Tourism Initiative. Thank you very much for the discussion and the feedback on the last item. I think you skipped one, Karen. I did? I think you skipped one, yeah. Oh, God, I was trying to be so organized. Consideration of the Eastern Sierra, I'm at 5.6, right? Yes. Yeah. Consideration, oh, I did skip one. Consideration of the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership Memorandum of Understanding.

1:55:33 Good morning again. So we have at all previous ESCOG meetings, since I have come on board, had some conversation around the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, which is an initiative funded through the Sierra Nevada Conservancy through Prop 68 funding. One of the components of that program has been the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, which

1:56:03 Largely is an organization that holds monthly meetings to discuss regional issues as it relates to recreation in the Eastern Sierra and has consisted of our federal partners, our local jurisdictions, BLM, DWP, basically anyone with a land management

1:56:28 Role in the Eastern Sierra has participated in this organization to share information and discuss what's happening. As the funding for the Sierra Sustainable Recreation Purism Initiative is set to expire, the SRTI is proposing a memorandum of understanding for each of these agencies to continue to collaborate into the future. So the memorandum of understanding

1:56:58 Memorandum Understanding, or MOU, is attached to your staff report for your review. The responsibilities of the parties in the MOU would largely be to continue to participate in the ESSRP meetings, to share their experience and their expertise, and to maintain project inventories of work that's relevant to the initiative. As drafted, the MOU would be non-binding for each of the parties.

1:57:28 This morning, I'm not requesting that your board approve ESCOG's participation in the MOU, but I am asking that you focus and provide feedback on a particular section.

1:57:45 2.12 particular responsibilities for the ESCOG. At this time, the ESCOG is the only agency within the ESSRP that has been called out with particular responsibilities. And so I will read that language to you.

1:58:03 And so those particular responsibilities would include the ESCOG will endeavor upon approval and or direction by its board and the boards of its four member agencies to leverage its position as a regional and the to pursue funding opportunities that may not be accessible to other parties whose jurisdiction is limited to one specific national park, national forest.

1:58:25 County, City, Town, etc. ESCOG will also attempt to pursue funding opportunities that are related to the SREMP or any future programs that may be authorized by the ESCOG board and all member agencies. So for context, you'll remember that the ESSRP is in part intended to develop a list of sustainable recreation projects, which the SRTI is going to identify grant applications.

1:58:54 the fund. And those grant applications need to find an agency that will house them and administer them in order to be submitted and awarded. The intent of the SRTI is for those projects to be regional and cross-jurisdictional. So one of the limitations of the projects and the grant applications is that the Forest Service or the Town of Mammoth Lakes

1:59:21 Or Inyo County may not be the appropriate organization for housing and administering the grant because it is going to cross over their jurisdictional boundaries. And so the intent of this section is that the ESCOG would become the primary organization for administering those grant applications that are coming out of the SRTI. The SRTI

1:59:50 has the funding to provide the staff support for identifying and drafting those grant applications, but the long-term implementation and management would rest with the ESCOG. Many of those projects, as proposed, would probably fall under the jurisdiction of the SREMP program, which would the board and your member agencies have authorized that funding opportunities

2:00:17 Underneath that umbrella can move forward without the approval of the four member agencies and only through the approval of the ESCOG board. And so we would be taking ownership potentially of the projects that are coming out of the SRTI pursuant to this section of the MOU. So that is my overview of this item before you today. I would appreciate your feedback and your comments as it relates particularly to the section.

2:00:46 2.12. But the request from staff today is that your board would approve the language related to the particular responsibilities of the ESCOG under the MOU. Thank you. So if I could, I think that the language reads well. I would like to propose adding a couple of words in there that relates to conditions this type of effort to the available staff capacity of the ESCOG.

2:01:15 I can propose some specific words for that. But I think also this is not intended, I don't think this is intended to be specific just to the SRTI stuff. This is intended to go way beyond the SRTI so that as the ESSRP continues to meet over time, if members of the ESSRP, if there are funding opportunities.

2:01:36 that are going to be happening way beyond this SRTI work that the ESCOG is making a representation that is willing to entertain being a fiscal sponsor for efforts that are going to be happening in the coming years. So does that make sense, Elaine, that this would go well beyond just the SRTI stuff? Okay. And Madam Chair, I've got the language I would propose to add would be this would come after the

2:02:04 It would read as follows, ESCOG will endeavor upon approval and or direction by its board and the boards of its four member agencies and then add this text and with consideration to its available capacity, comma, to leverage its position, et cetera, et cetera. So it's a little one, two, three, four, five, six, seven word addition to that language that makes sure we're not going to be overwhelming the ESCOG.

2:02:28 Even if the ESCOG comes up with a great idea, ESCOG can say, this is a great idea, but we don't have any bandwidth to do something like that. That's the only thing I would want to think would be a good idea to add. One thing I wasn't clear on what Elaine said is if the ESCOG does take a project, it's the board that approves it, not the four entities. Is that correct? If it fits within the...

2:03:00 Sustainable Recreation and Ecosystem Management Program. Each of the four member agencies earlier this year provided authorization for the ESCOG to pursue activities that fall under that umbrella without returning to them for approval. Okay. Okay. Thanks. I guess on that, I think just philosophically that

2:03:30 I think as an organization, we should be careful just to make sure that what we're doing fits into the sphere of that. So like if it's questionable at all, you know, I think we should, as a good practice, make sure with all of the agencies that we are within the boundaries. Are there any other comments? This is great. Let's go forward. Any public comment?

2:04:11 There are no public comments. Madam Chair, I would move that we modify the language as presented by staff to include the text, quote, and with consideration to its available capacity in the first sentence of Section 2.12 as proposed. Second. All for a vote. Chair Schwartz? Yes. Vice Chair Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Corliss?

2:04:49 Yes. Supervisor Gardner. Yes. Supervisor Griffiths. Yes. Supervisor Tothero. Aye. And Council Member Ellis. Yes. Thank you. Okay. Thanks, Elaine. Thank you, everyone. Moving on to receive an update on the Sustainable Recreation Tourism Initiative. Good morning. Following on the heels of the previous item, the Sustainable...

2:05:25 Recreation Tourism Initiative, or the SRTI, is a grant-funded program intended to work with regional partners to identify sustainable recreation project opportunities throughout the Eastern Sierra. One of the tracks of deliverables underneath that funding opportunity is for the SRTI to identify

2:05:51 available grant resources for the implementation of projects identified through that program. In late July, the ESCOG staff identified a grant opportunity through the National Fish and Wildlife Federation, also known as NIFWF, which is a very

2:06:11 Interesting and Eastern Sierra Regional-focused grant opportunity. The funding is being provided by the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, and the grant guidelines included, I believe, six very specific projects that they were providing grant funding for. Each of those projects was for fuels reduction within the Owens River watershed from June Lake.

2:06:40 to Bishop Creek. The exception was that there was one recreation project that was identified in the Buttermilk area. And the project, the grant guidelines included some specific infrastructure improvements that they wanted to see. But the description in request for proposals was

2:07:09 was broad enough that there was opportunities to expand the scope of the work. So the infrastructure improvements that they were looking to see included replacement of toilet facilities and buttermilk, potentially parking and signage improvements and formalization of certain trails. So ESCOG staff coordinated and collaborated with the SRTI staff to submit a grant proposal which would

2:07:37 both address those infrastructure needs as well as expanding that scope of work to develop a conceptual recreation plan for the Buttermilk bouldering area and the geographically adjacent areas with similar uses on recreation impacts. As that was explained, the project area was expanded to include the Buttermilk environs, the Tungsten Hills.

2:08:04 Pine Creek Climbing Areas and the Trailheads for the Happy Boulders and the Sad Boulders. The project scope would go include conceptual planning, stakeholder outreach, analysis of baseline conditions, and then developing a conceptual plan for that infrastructure implementation, as well as identifying opportunities to take those lessons learned for things like dispersed camping and parking improvements and replicate those

2:08:34 areas that have similar impacts and similar user groups. The grant application received support from the Inyo National Forest, Bureau of Land Management, OHV groups, the Climbers Coalition, the Access Fund, and Inyo County. ESCOG submitted that grant application on August 5th in the amount of

2:08:55 $181,500 with an approximately 10% amount for administration costs. So there are no budget impacts associated with the item at this time. This is...

2:09:09 Only an update to let you know that that grant application was submitted in support of the Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem Management Program, as well as the projects that were identified in the SRTA process. I should add that in collaboration with the SRTI team, the proposed project

2:09:35 Both in terms of infrastructure improvements and conceptual planning was identified in 14 of the projects that were submitted by ESSRP partners. So it does also support those efforts as well. That concludes my overview this morning. I'm happy to answer questions you have. Thank you. Good job. Well done. This is a exciting, fast-moving grant opportunity. So thank you. And I like how it also could be a replication for

2:10:11 That whole area, like you could use it to increase potential signage and recreation opportunities in like the SADS, Happies, Pine Creek. I like that. So, nice work. I was just going to comment as well on the footprint of the project area. I mean, it's huge. I was talking about the Tumstons, Pine Creek, the Chalk Bluff area, you know, it's really comprehensive. Yeah, so when they get off the airplane,

2:10:47 Where are they going to go first? Just saying. To the bathroom. Shots. Thank you. I would be so remiss if I didn't acknowledge the SRTI and the MLTPA team for their very hard work and fast turnaround in supporting this grant effort. Any additional comments? Any public comment?

2:11:32 No public comments. All right. Well, nice work, Elaine. Good work, everyone. Thank you for the update. And we'll move on to the last one. I thought COVID was over on June 15th. Came back. So I guess we'll have an update on COVID-19. Who was going to give us that update? I guess we can just... I guess we'll all be doing it individually here. Okay. Anyone want to start?

2:12:07 I'll just say, Inyo County, you know, we just got our weekly update a few minutes ago, and we've had 11 new cases over the past seven days. The week before that, it was four. The week before that, it was 22, I think. So it's definitely been increasing.

2:12:32 We do have one more death. It's not a recent death. It was a clarification of the death certificate from when it happened a while ago. Concerningly, we are seeing an increase within the pediatric community. It's 17 and under. It is...

2:12:58 Primarily cases are amongst the unvaccinated. Inyo County's vaccination rate is right around the state average. We are seeing a slight increase in the number of people getting vaccinated, but it's still way lower than it was in the past. Hoping that with the predicted soon,

2:13:26 full approval of the Pfizer vaccine, but maybe that will encourage some other folks to get. We gave 100 doses of the vaccine in the last week, 150 doses of the vaccine in the last week, and that's up from about 100 the week before, so I think with the Delta variant, you know, people are starting to get a little more scared and get vaccinated, and so we stand at

2:13:52 Let's see, 59% of the eligible population fully vaccinated and 67.7% with at least one dose. So we're right near the state average. And, you know, hoping that we are peeping or at least it's not going to get any worse considering that the fair is coming up and it's going to be very busy and no pond after that.

2:14:19 Hoping that things are under control. We stand at not having a mandatory indoor masking for all residents. The county health officer thought that would be a challenge to enforce. And I tend to agree that that's probably true, that it would be a challenge to enforce. But it is highly recommended. And within our county offices, we are requiring masks.

2:14:50 for those vaccination status. And we are also having some challenges with some of the state regulations that if you are in an institutional setting, be it in jail or hospitals or whatever, that people either have to be vaccinated or tested, we are getting some pushback from some of our employee groups.

2:15:19 Even on the testing. So we're trying to deal with that challenge. I think that's all on the county side. Dan, did I cover it? About everything I can think of. Thank you. I guess I can jump in from Mono County. And Stacey, maybe you can correct me or add to it if I get some of it wrong. Our cases are increasing. I think we're at, as of Tuesday, we're at 18 cases per 100,000. That was based on last week.

2:15:54 I think the week before we were at 15, and of course a month or so ago we were at four, roughly. We are on a required mandated masking indoors. I would agree that it's a challenge to enforce, but it's also a concern for public health. And our vaccination rate is fully vaccinated in the high 60s, and one vaccination, I think 75 or 76%.

2:16:22 We had a couple of hospitalizations recently, both visitors unvaccinated. We do still have, separate from our numbers, we have a lot of cases of positive cases from visitors. So the positivity rate or the case rates are among residents, of course, which doesn't reflect the amount of COVID that may be in the area, given the large number of visitors that are here.

2:16:48 And that just means we need to, again, be careful, maintain distance, wear masks inside, and be very much aware. We are very much pushing vaccines as much as we can, very sensitive about issues of children under 12, and certainly making testing available. We had a hiccup last week that was very unfortunate, had an incredible spike of cases on Wednesday, like 30 or 40.

2:17:17 It turned out there was a lab tech that made a mistake at the state lab in Valencia, and those were all invalid and needed to be retested. But for about 11 or 15 hours throughout the county, we had an incredible anxiety about a positive test that in fact turned out to not all be positive. Some were, but most of them were not. And it was completely a fault of the state lab in Valencia.

2:17:43 When a certain amount of tests are positive, there's a protocol they go through, and this lab technician did not do that protocol. So it was an incredible roller coaster that affected many, many people, sadly. I think that's about it, Stacey. Is there anything I left out or got wrong?

2:18:07 No, I think that covers it. I would just note that, you know, case, because this came up a couple weeks ago in our meeting, our Board of Supervisors meeting, that cases are on the rise across Mono County. Obviously, Mammoth is where the most people are, but it's impacting the entire county. Yeah, I think the, Dan Holler's been sharing numbers out to the town council. I'm assuming that those are probably county-wide numbers. I don't know if those are town specifically. I'll defer to Dan and certainly Stacey Bob on this.

2:18:57 Hopefully they can get that vaccine, FDA approved, and once it's approved, I think there'll be a lot more comfort in people wanting to get vaccinated, hopefully. That'll change. We'll see. I don't really have anything for Bishop. It basically mimics Inyo County. So, Jim, is there anything? Okay, so then let's move on. One last thing is we are back to virtual meetings. We held in-person meetings for three,

2:19:39 Okay, so we are fully moved into the consolidated office building and it seems to be good.

2:20:30 Everybody seems to be happy. There's no artwork, as you can see from what's behind Grace right now. We're going to make it prettier as time goes on. You got the full update on the airport. Obviously, the county is mourning the loss of Clint. It was a big blow, unexpected, and we're looking for ways to honor him.

2:21:00 in the future and honor his memory. Leslie Chapman, who we all know and love, has been named our CAAL, which is a good thing. I didn't write down the list and I don't have anything else off the top of my head. Dan, do you have anything to add? Other than the wonderful housing or economic development meeting that Elaine organized with the state yesterday, that was a very productive meeting.

2:21:34 And the Mexican Council coming to visit, both of our counties. All right, how about Mono County? Again, maybe I'll jump in and let Stacey add, we've been trying to have more of a public reopening of our new building. We are moved in, but keep putting that off, given some constraints related to COVID. And I must say, I saw Leslie Chapman yesterday at the meeting. Well, HLA really was great. I agree with Dan.

2:22:07 And I did say to Leslie, you know, you may be one of the only people in the country who's actually built two buildings or been involved in building two buildings. And that is a beautiful facility you guys have down there. We're in our building, certainly in Mammoth, but we are hoping to have it be more available to the public and more open as soon as we can and finishing some pieces of it. Beyond that, I don't think there's too much more I would add. Stacey, I'm sure I'm forgetting something.

2:22:37 I'd just add that recently Mono County, the Mono County Board and staff held a facilitated strategic planning workshop. So excited to continue working on that and be focused on what we want to get done in the county. And yeah, I think otherwise we're just trying to struggle along like everybody else.

2:23:05 deal with COVID, and I would add, we hear, we get weekly updates regarding the continued Mountain View fire recovery efforts. You know, there's still fire survivors struggling to get their lives back together and start to rebuild, so continue to work on that. Jim, do you want to give the update for Bishop? I'm sure I won't miss some components, but before I do that, I do want to thank Elaine.

2:23:43 yesterday for the meeting with Derek Kirk. I think it was great to be with Bob and Town of Mammoth Lakes, Linda, no wait, what was her name? Sorry. Linda. Yeah. It was just, it was a great meeting. It was a great discussion. I love where we all went. It was, we were bouncing stuff off each other. So I was there representing ESCOG and I think we got some great feedback and I like that Derek

2:24:13 I think he truly cares about our region. Oh, Dan was there too. I like that he truly listened to what we were saying, had insight, and I think we're going to go great places with his assistance. So speaking on behalf of ESCOG for that meeting, I think it was a very, very productive meeting and it's going to help us. As far as Bishop, we touched on it earlier, the housing element that we just approved.

2:24:42 Our push to the next step is truly amazing piece of work. I think it's, again, another step in the right direction with tangible, measurable goals. And I think it's a government at its finest. So thank you, Elaine and group that did that. And then we're getting closer on our Caltrans crosswalks. There's some hiccups in Caltrans, which is pretty normal, but we're getting closer on crosswalks at East Elm.

2:25:11 And by the post office. I know it doesn't really affect us regionally, but visitors won't get killed there, so they'll be able to go elsewhere. There you go. Or touch it regionally. And then the Line Street Bridge that we all know of right there by the canal that is going to be part of the airport component of our world is moving forward, getting rebuilt. It's basically going to double in size almost width, so it'll help out.

2:25:40 Traffic there, people fishing on bikes heading out that way. We're moving slowly forward at working on mobility in that area. So that should help out when it comes to airport time. Won't be done before the airport, but it's moving forward finally. So I think I touched on it, Karen. That sounds good. Great. Thank you. And then Town of Mammoth Lakes. Thanks. I'll jump in. Dan may have something to add.

2:26:10 Housing is the top priority of the Town Council, and the last couple weeks we've looked at the funding we generate through TOT and Recreation and Tourism, and we've, looks like we can put about six million dollars into housing. A lot of interesting things happen with the parcel, these are the types of things to share when we get together in October, November, some very weird colliding policy objectives coming out of the state of California that affect housing, but

2:26:40 We can share a lot of stuff down the road. We're going to take a step into the micromobility pool. We've approved a very limited agreement for a company called Bird Scooters to try out a scooter program. We'll see how that works out. May not work out as well. You may not see me at the next meeting because I will have been successfully recalled from office, but you never know. But we're trying to do everything we can.

2:27:04 to free up what real estate that's available for housing and not for parking automobiles. So this is part of a number of experiments we're going to take on to really maximize what we've got available for housing. Pretty, you know, the recreation numbers here that we've been tracking are pretty similar to last year. Last year was the big COVID year. And as COVID sort of transitions into being a chronic friend to all of us going forward, I'm thinking that this is just going to be something we're going to be living with. But so far, so good.

2:27:33 Things have worked out pretty well this summer. And I think that's about it, Dan. I don't know if anything to add to any of that, but I'm sure there's other things to add that I've missed. And one thing, another piece there, we've been looking at Caltrans, similar as the others, with some safety improvement grants for improving the crosswalk signalization on Highway 203 to get, we call it more obnoxious lighting there, without flashing lights and stuff, if people cross the street there.

2:28:04 Improving two of the current ones and adding a new one in, which should go forward here in the near future, and also updating some bus stops and pretty significant rebuild of mucks and some streets here in town as well this fall. And as John mentioned, if we can get a tree harvest permit out of state, we'll charge ahead with taking trees out and some rough grading and parcel hopefully still this fall. That's been a real challenge in terms of

2:28:33 Cal Fire perspective on an infill project versus the other priority in housing times, a little frustrating. Thanks. And I just, the only thing I would add to that is we, we met with Derek up here as well. And I think that I'm hoping we're all aware of the unprecedented amount of money that's sitting in the state budget and potentially the unprecedented amount of money that's sitting on the federal side.

2:28:57 And how important it's going to be for all of us to coordinate and be talking with each other so we don't trip over each other, we don't go bump in the night, and we really align, certainly from the ESCOG's perspective, the regional opportunities we've been working so hard to pull together to bring real resources into this region and to do it in a coordinated, very well coordinated and well thought through way. It's going to be challenging, but man, there's a lot of money out there. And so looking forward to work with everybody on this. We can really...

2:29:27 Work for the region's best interest. And certainly with this air service component, if we were a region dammit before, we were a region dammit doggone it at this point. So here we go. Well, with that, I would like to adjourn this meeting in a clink quilter's memory to our regularly scheduled next meeting on October 8th, 2021. Have a good day. Thank you. Have a good day. Bye, everybody. 11 o'clock, right on the nose. Thank you.