Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2024
Eastern Sierra Council of Governments
at 08:30
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 finding- The Safe Sierra Streets budget lists $272,800 for ESCOG project management and grant administration Regional (ESCOG, Mono County)
Transcript
263 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:05 Chair Gardner is absent today. Vice Chair Mohove? Here. Board Member Griffiths? Board Member Oral? Here. Board Member Salcedo? Here. Board Member Wentworth? Here. Board Member Bubzer is absent. Board Member Schwartz? Here. Thank you. Would you mind leading us to the pledge?
1:28 Public comment. This time is set aside for public comment on matters not calendared on the agenda. Do we have any public comment today? I see no comments at this time.
1:54 Okay, moving on to consent. We have five items under consent to approve minutes from the August 28th and September 25th meeting, the Mono Broadband Consortium Activities Report, the findings and recommendations from the Caltrans audit, and a letter to the 18th District Agricultural Association, California Department of Food and Agriculture and Division Affairs and Expositions. Do we have any...
2:22 comments or board member discussion on the consent agenda? I just want to congratulate Elaine and her staff for such a clean audit. So that was great. Thank you. Okay. If there, do we have any public comment on this matter? I want to entertain a motion for approval. So moved. Second. Okay. We have a motion to second. Do we do a roll call for this?
3:10 Motion was Mr. Wentworth seconded. Yeah, Wentworth and Salcedo, and I'm sorry, my computer is doing something funny here. Vice Chair Mohove? Yes. Board Member Griffiths? Yes. Board Member Oral? Yes. Board Member Salcedo? Yes. Board Member Wentworth? Yes. And Board Member Schwartz? Yes. Thank you.
3:33 Okay, on to policy matters. Item 5.1 is to approve Amendment No. 1 to Prop 1, Watershed Restoration Grant Program, Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator. Let's go on to you. Yes. Good morning, Board members. It's always nice to see you.
3:49 The first item today concerns our first contract amendment to the agreement between the ESCOG and the California Department of Fish and Wildlife for the Proposition 1 grant that is funding the Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator Project.
4:07 We have requested this amendment because there is unspent funds associated with the project. So this is the project that has sort of a broad scope. Primarily the grant is to fund the completion of the NEPA analysis for the Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Project, also known as the Donut Project.
4:31 And then there's additional scope around that to build capacity for workforce development to be able to do that work, to build communications around wildfire resiliency, and then funding for the ESCOG to be able to administer the project. Our contractor, Whiteberg, delivered the NEPA decision under budget for what was budgeted in environmental planning.
4:55 And we've had discussion about this amendment before we request it from CDFW that there is an opportunity to use this funding to expand some of the environmental analysis into a bigger footprint, so basically expanding the footprint of the study area into the Mono Basin. So we've requested an amendment that would allow for Whitebark to be able to do some of the preliminary environmental review and stakeholder convening for that expanded scope.
5:25 as well as being able to do some preliminary SQL work. WhiteBark has procured funding through a separate grant that would be able to round out their environmental analysis for that expanded footprint beyond this funding.
5:41 And then we have also requested to move funding out of the environmental planning line item to the Inyo National Forest line item to be able to continue our contract with them to serve as consultants and advisors on the NEPA work in the Mono Basin as well. The contract amendment also extends the term of the agreement to
6:06 December 31st, 2026, which will allow additional time to be able to spend that funding, achieving that scope, and also will be able to allow for the ESCOG to be able to continue to draw down funds to be administering the grant and participating.
6:21 in building wildfire resiliency capacity throughout the region. And then I'll just add separate but tangential to this. Part of this discussion that we've had with the board in the past was how building capacity for wildfire resiliency through this fund could be expanded into Owens Valley. And at the time, we reached out to have this conversation with Inyo County. It was prior to the adoption of their community wildfire protection plan.
6:51 But Whitebark has received funding from lots of sources, including CAL FIRE, and is looking for opportunities now to start some of the pre-development work around the Bishop area, just convening stakeholders to see, you know, what the appetite is to start to do a project, maybe similar to this in the Owens Valley as well.
7:12 So that is my overview of the contract amendment in front of you today. And I would request that the board approve contract amendment number one to the CDFW grant funding the Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator. Thank you. Great. Any comments, discussion? I mean, I think it's great that we've been expanding the scope of that project and obviously seeing it grow there. Yeah, thank you, Elaine, for taking time yesterday to walk.
7:48 Walk me through some of this, so yeah, I'm very supportive of this. It's a good idea. Any input from the public? No comments at this time. Want to entertain a motion? So moved. Second. Okay, we have a motion to second. Call for the vote. Vice Chair Mohove? Yes. Board Member Griffiths? Yes. Board Member Oral? Yes. Board Member Salcedo? Yes. Board Member Wentworth? Yes. And Board Member Schwartz? Yes. Thank you.
8:26 Okay, next up, let's adopt a 2024 board calendar and approve moving a December meeting. Probably the most contentious item that will be on here today. Good morning. So I think maybe the easiest part of the presentation, truthfully, is talking about moving the December 18th meeting.
8:48 In the calendar, we'd adopted a calendar this year for meetings to occur on the third Wednesday. There's a request that December 18th is close to the holidays and could we move it up earlier? And then I believe there's also a request that December 10th would not work. So I would ask that the board consider moving our regularly scheduled meeting for December to December 4th. Separate from that, we'd like to get an early start on setting the calendar for next year.
9:17 In the past, ESCOG meetings have aligned with ESTA meetings because there's a lot of overlap between board members and that was something that was considered to be very efficient. I reached out to ESTA and didn't hear that there was
9:40 A lot of commitment or enthusiasm one way or the other about aligning those again. So I presented a similar calendar to this year's calendar for 2025, which is to hold the meetings on the, did I say third? Maybe I mean fourth Wednesday of each, every other month in 2025. So I hope that that continues to work for all of the board's calendars and the many things that you're juggling.
10:09 If so, I'd ask that you adopt the calendar as presented. Thank you. Would the 4th be in Bishop or in here? Oh, it's in Bishop. I think your microphone's off too, Linda. Yeah, I'll have to check with Bob to see if he's available for December 4th. There's a chance the Inyo County LTC is also on December 4th. Also consider December 10th.
10:50 I mean, I do think that for next year's schedule, I think that's fine. Good with me? April 23rd doesn't work for me. And probably the other county supervisors. That's the legislative conference in Sacramento. December 4th or 11th worked for me.
11:26 One sort of observation is that, you know, we meet, our meetings are spread out, which is nice, but with, I'm just concerned a little bit sometimes that we may be missing some opportunities. We're not acting on things when it may be needed to act on things. Sort of a general observation, I would defer to staff if, you know, if you think that the nature of how our meeting's scheduled, we're missing stuff, things aren't happening, I would just look to staff's direction as to whether that's happening or not.
11:57 You have to do it now. I'm just saying as we start going into the future, it might be something to be thinking about. Do we want to do something about the 23rd meeting now? I think we can propose that for the 16th. The 16th should work. Are we talking April of next year? Correct. That is the LTC. LTC is third Wednesdays of the month. Could you do the 30th?
12:43 Or the 9th. I think April. So do we have any objections to April 30th? I can't do it. That's the five-week, you know, month. True. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. We could do the 9th. Okay. So I think what we're looking at is the proposed meeting schedule on here, except we're changing April 23rd to April 9th. Okay. And for...
13:18 What do we want to do about December 4th? Did we decide December 11th, doesn't it? December 11th is good, just for the town. Wednesday mornings are generally pretty good. December 11th would work, for me at least. December 11th of this, of next year. Although, hold on, December 11th has who's up for re-election, who might not be here. Will we have... So he will be until January.
14:02 So he'll be here on December 11th, not until January will the next person be seated. December 11th is fine. Okay. Wait, did I just say I couldn't do that one? You mentioned something. You can also move it off a Wednesday. I have it down for December. That's a Sunday. Yeah, the 11th works for me, yes. That's this December, right? This December, the 11th works for me.
14:40 Let's do that. Sorry, what did we decide? December 11th. Looks like it's good. And that will be here, Bishop? Bishop. Okay. Sorry, Trina. It doesn't work for Trina? No. Is there, it also, one of the things that makes this complicated is we also have to schedule quirks around all of the other meetings as well, and I don't know that December 11th will work for Angie.
15:12 I can do the 13th. Friday? Friday the 13th. I'll be there. Dangerous. Yeah, I could do that. The 12th is ESTA. Is the 12th bad for people? Bad for me. December 13th. Okay. I mean, not to go back in circles, but was I the only one who had a problem with December 4th? I did. I did.
16:01 You're not here. No, Linda also couldn't make it. Okay. All right. So we'll shoot for December 13th then? Okay. Okay. Then I guess so we're looking to approve moving the December 18th meeting to December 13th and for next year's schedule having as presented except for the April meeting being on April 9th. Is that correct? So there's no meeting on December 18th.
16:39 There would be no meeting on December 18th. Any input from the public? No comments at this time. Can I get a motion? So moved. Second. Okay. We have a motion and a second. Call for the vote. Vice Chair Mohove? Yes. Board Member Griffiths? Yes. Board Member Oral? Yes. Board Member Salcedo? Yes. Board Member Wentworth? Yes. And Board Member Schwartz? Yes. Thank you.
17:20 All right. What did we make April? Our next item is to receive an update on the California Jobs First Catalyst concept. Real quick, just a quick point of order. April, the April ESCOG meeting, what date was settled after that? The 9th. The 9th. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Pleasure. Okay. Update on the California Jobs First Catalyst concept. Ms. Calla?
17:50 Good morning once more. So we've had lots of conversations about California Jobs First. And the important progress that has been made in that is that we have moved into what's known as the catalyst phase of California Jobs First, which is the funding phase associated with moving forward the strategies that were put into the strategic plan. The application for
18:17 Submitting proposals for funding open on October 15th and will close on December 15th. I provided the RFP in your agenda packet for your review, so I won't go over that in detail, but I will just point out a few criteria guidelines that are relevant to developing projects and what projects might be submitted.
18:47 First, they need to advance the strategies that were developed in the strategic plan, which includes the foundational elements that had been discussed around infrastructure, housing, community development, child care, sort of basic social service and physical infrastructure that supports economic development. Or they need to advance the sector
19:14 Industries that were identified in sustainable recreation, tourism, healthcare, natural working lands and forestry, agriculture, and healthcare. The projects need to meet state criteria for equity, which includes Justice 40. They need to meet the state's climate goals, so fossil fuel-based projects can't be included.
19:44 And then there needs to be a partnership and a direct nexus to providing benefits back into disinvested communities as defined by the strategic plan. Projects that include more than one county will be weighted higher than projects that focus on a single community or within a single county. The Sierra Business Council
20:11 We'll be administering the Catalyst Fund, but the funding decision will be made by the Governing Council, which is comprised of, I think, 22 or 23 appointed positions from across the region, not just elected officials. Over the last couple of months, I have been meeting with partners.
20:37 on a regional basis, on an industry sector basis, partners who have been engaged with California Jobs First to try and gain an understanding of the landscape of projects that are being considered, opportunities for synergies, opportunities to create partnerships. So I provided an inventory of
21:05 What I've been hearing as part of your agenda packet as well. I apologize, I was remiss when I was formatting this and I actually left out two areas that I've been talking with people and talking about their projects. So I've provided a revised handout to you now that includes those and the two areas that I did not include within this inventory were tribal government and sustainable recreation and tourism.
21:35 And I don't necessarily want to go through this full inventory. It's available to you. I will call out perhaps a few of these that have some interest, particularly those that are trying to reach a seven-county collaboration. So that includes the counterpart to the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments.
22:05 Supporting this project. Thank you. Sorry. It's good to know that Charlie's doing his homework. We can have an offline conversation on that. Apologies.
22:20 So the counterpart to the ESCOG on their site is Motherlow Job Training Center, and they have a couple of projects that they're looking at implementing on a seven-county basis and submitting to Catalyst. The first is a project that they're calling Sierra Sourced, which would include a feasibility study and then capacity building funding to build a comprehensive regional brand e-commerce site.
22:48 And an economic collaboration for local makers and producers. So branding things that are coming from the eastern, from the Sierra region as Sierra sourced. And they've been working in partnership with the Chambers of Commerce throughout the seven county area to develop that application. They have a pretty extensive business plan that they've put together to support that. They're also considering a program that would provide stipends for
23:17 individuals to become certified as in-home daycare providers, and they're looking at a couple of micro-enterprise grant programs, one targeting youth entrepreneurs and the other one targeting businesses generally. There's some interest on both sides of the crest in doing feasibility studies for agriculture, focusing on meat processing, particularly on grass-fed beef.
23:45 There's some interest in doing municipal service reviews of water and wastewater, looking at other opportunities to leverage this for infrastructure pre-development costs. And then focusing on the east side, there's several applications that are being developed and considered to support sustainable recreation and tourism, including, I had a conversation with the Tribal Council yesterday, and it seems like they have
24:15 alignment around putting together a program to build capacity for cultural tourism that would be tribally led. So I'm happy to answer questions, provide more details on some of the things that I've included in this inventory, but what I wanted to have a discussion with the board about
24:32 today is where it is appropriate for the ESCOG to be convening some of these conversations and in particular where it would be appropriate for the ESCOG to be submitting an application or to be administering applications on behalf of other partners. As I said, applications that serve more than one county
24:55 or more than one partner will be more heavily weighted. Also projects that are serving disinvested partners will be given higher consideration. And on the basis of the grant program being on a reimbursement basis rather than a cash advance, I think that it is especially for Eastern Sierra community is going to be important for some of those applicants to have a partner that can help.
25:23 basically help cash flow some of those projects on a reimbursement basis. In particular, some of the conversations that this whole process, as you know, is a novel, it's a pilot program in the state, and from a local level all the way to the state level, it feels a little bit like we're all feeling our way through this together. And so this conversation
25:49 is evolving very quickly, particularly now that application period is open. So even beyond the things that I've included here, I've had conversations in just this last week around places where there might be interest in the ESCOG serving as a lead applicant for these grants. In particular, one of the conversations that I've had with several different partners at this point is
26:15 developing an application to build capacity within the ESCOG, to serve as an incubator, to build out programming that reinforces the Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem Management Program. So really building capacity in understanding what the Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem looks like, both in terms of
26:40 How different governments work together, but also what nonprofits are working within the landscape, working in partnership with land managers to do implementation work, for instance, that support recreation projects. Similarly with forestry, we have...
26:57 Gained a lot of ground since especially initiating the Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator around momentum for community scale wildfire resiliency projects, landscape scale wildfire resiliency projects, but there's still lots of components within that.
27:14 to be able to activate that planning work, which include things like workforce development, job placement, who is going to be doing actual implementation work on the ground, how are we prioritizing projects beyond Mammoth in the future and bringing in funding for implementation. And you'll have to forgive me because the details of it continue to be a little bit nebulous.
27:38 I hear Councilman Wentworth talking about the value of more frequent meetings potentially, so it would be nice to have conversations with the board before submitting an application in December.
27:48 to really help solidify the concept. But the idea would be to leverage the ESCOG as established as an umbrella to be able to advance the work that we're already doing in strengthening the partnerships across the region, across jurisdictions to build out a sustainable recreation tourism economy and to be able to build out a wildfire resiliency economy. There was also some discussion about whether or not it would be appropriate to
28:18 Include some funding for convening other industry sector areas as well, such as agriculture. I think that's something that we could consider as this is being further developed. And then finally there is
28:37 I think an opportunity within the Catalyst funding to advance towns to trails into the next phase in particular. And so some of the projects that are listed here you're familiar with, in the handout I provided this morning, you're familiar with as coming out of the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative. And so I'd like to get some guidance.
28:58 from the board, if it would be appropriate for ESCOG to serve as the lead applicant on those projects specifically. So I understand that that's an extremely broad discussion point, and I wish that I could provide you with a little bit more concrete information, but it is the nature of California's California job first to be nebulous and in development. Okay. I mean, first,
29:28 Question just to do due diligence. We do meet the eligibility requirements to be a lead applicant, as in, yeah, so we've attended at least one sub-regional table meeting, blah, blah, blah, blah, all of that good stuff. Okay. And so, yeah, open it up for discussion. What are people's thoughts here? I've got a couple sort of quick thoughts.
29:55 So our next meeting, ESCOG meeting is on the 13th, correct? Correct. And the response to the RFP is on the 15th, is that correct? So could we anticipate seeing whatever staff and partners come up with to be in front of the ESCOG for approval at that point? Yes. Okay. The second thing. Approval how? Like if we're submitting. Yes, that's correct. An obligation. Yes. Yeah, so the ESCOG is going to submit. Another thing to point out is that.
30:23 This is a response to an RFP. So this is not a grant application. And SBC has been pretty, they're very loose with their language and their descriptors of these things. So it's very easy for people to get confused. Is it a grant? Is it a contract? That kind of thing. So that's something to just be aware of. Another thing perhaps you could speak to a little bit is on the reimbursable capacity that the ESCOG has that you mentioned.
30:51 What do we have lined up to be able to do that? In other words, if the ESCOG works with partners and submits a response to RFP for $2 million worth of stuff, how do we have that capacity? Do we have a line of credit with our county partners and things like that to be able to perform on that kind of way? Or is there a limit? There is a limit. So we, as you know,
31:18 I used the Mono County Treasury to fund ESCOG projects largely on a reimbursement basis. My conversations with Ms. Dutcher, who serves as the treasurer for Mono County, have been that she has a relative level of comfort if grants are awarded because there is assurance that they will be reimbursed. I hate putting numbers out there, but the number that she's...
31:43 provided to me, she's comfortable with ESCOG running a deficit of about $500,000, but not more than that. And we previously had a line of credit through the rural county representatives of California organization. We are in the queue to request that again because Ms. Dutcher really prefers that she has some assurance in being able to manage. And so I think that does put
32:12 some boundaries on the amount of money that we would want to fully request and how much money we could be spending at any time, particularly given that we also have the Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator that we're currently administering right now as well. And there's also a staff capacity concern, which is I think one of the areas like if something was awarded through this, we'd
32:39 want to commit to being able to have a full-time administrative assistant within the ESCOG to be able to manage and administer the different grant projects that we're operating. Okay, so what I'm hearing is that there's a, I mean, is the $500,000 cap for all ESCOG projects or is that, and where are we at in terms of like the CDFW grant? Where, what are we running? I'm just trying to get a sense of what, what are we typically running? Yeah, what, what can we actually represent to partners in terms of this is how much?
33:09 We could do. Yeah, we, on a quarterly basis, the CDFW grant is reimbursed on a quarterly basis, so we're usually running a deficit of approximately like $200,000 to $300,000 currently, and then it's reimbursed on a quarterly basis. So we're thinking for these jobs first projects, we're looking at about $250,000. But that is on a quarterly basis. Right. So that would be the amount that we could balance. We could float.
33:37 So it could be like a multi-million dollar grant, whatever the numbers are, as long as it's about $250,000 a quarter to be able to deal with that. One other thing I said on the board of a non-profit that is theoretically playing a role in all this, which there's no contract yet, which brings up a little bit of the sense of the exposure that the ESCOG, not just the ESCOG, but all the partners in the region have to this process.
34:04 And one of the things we received from SBC is they are still trying to clarify whether these contracts coming out of this RFP would be as a subcontractor to Sierra Business Council or as a subrecipient. The distinction there is really, really critical.
34:23 Because if the ESCOG is just a subcontractor, well, ESCOG prepares an invoice, gets reimbursed, and we move forward. A subrecipient means that we are, in essence, an extension of SBC's contract with the state, which is a whole other level of administrative burden. To your point, Elaine, about staffing, that SBC would need to be able to do this kind of stuff.
34:45 These things need to be clarified. In addition to this, we have budgeted based on a contract with SBC, which Elaine, I understand we still don't have that contract in place. Is that correct? That's correct. So, Mr. Chair, I don't want to put you into this burden position, but I think somehow on behalf of the ESCOG, we need to have a conversation with the Sierra Business Council to figure out exactly what's going on here because this is a great...
35:10 I have nothing to add to that, Councilman Wentworth.
35:35 Except to say I've had the same conversation with Sierra Business Council. We have not yet received a contract for them to be a subrecipient or a contractor for California Jobs First, which is something that we have included in our budget. My understanding from them similarly is that they've received guidance from the state of California that they needed to change how they were administering those contracts, and we are expected to see something this week. Okay. Okay. The question I have.
36:05 It's what we're going through to try to do this with the contracts, the work you're already doing, Elaine, already been doing. Is it worth it to our region to engage at this level? I mean, are we determined that if Elaine and ESCOG does not do this, there creates a void that would be very detrimental to this whole region in moving forward? Because if so, then it's worth it to continue to pursue, try to figure it out, work with SBC, get them to come to the table and actually make this happen.
36:36 I mean, this calendar is condensed. I mean, it's quick. And the fact that we're still fluttering around out here is not inspiring. So what is our guiding principle here? Yes, we absolutely want to get in touch with them, get a contract for ESCOG, you know, be part of this solution, or, you know, what's the option? No, I think I would propose that we give
37:02 Direction to staff with whatever members of the board that you need to have a specific and direct conversation with Sierra Business Council about our current contract. I think it's important to note that the state of California has looked very favorably on the regional summary that was produced on behalf of us. This is being discussed and reviewed at the highest levels of the state so that they think, oh, the Eastern Sierra seems to have some game. They seem to know what they're doing. We have these administrative
37:29 Things going on with the Sierra Business Council that really need to be clarified. I think it would not, it's not in our region's interest not to pursue this. I would agree with that. But pursuing it means there's some things we got to get in there on the administrative side and the risk side for us with the Sierra Business Council specifically to clarify what is going on, you know, what is happening here. So what are the hurdles at this point of having that?
37:54 Clarified with this year. Well, there's two questions. One is the subcontract versus subrecipient question. And which one do we want to advocate for there? Subcontract. Okay. That's what we want to do. We want to get that clarified from them. And the other one is the status of our current contract, which we have still not received, that was built into our budget for this current year. We still haven't gotten that contract yet.
38:16 It's like, look, you're asking us, asking not just this, the ESCOG, which has a budget, it has some capacity, but you're asking community organizations, nonprofits, the capacity we have in this region to get engaged in a process, Linda, to your point. I mean, we're seeing that there's some risk out there. And I think on behalf of all of us in the region, the ESCOG could play kind of a leadership role with this to say, look, we need to get these very simple questions clarified. And I think with that, with that conversation and
38:46 You're the chair, and she usually leaves seven. I'm not the chair. Who's the chair? You're not here. Huh? Bob is. Bob is. Bob is. Okay, well then, okay, well then we'll draw straws. This is the next. We'll draw straws. You can, somebody can do it. But however we want to do it, but to make, have a very specific, specific and direct conversation with SBC, say, what is going on here? Okay. I'm also aware that Barbara Hayes is no longer going to be overseeing the council. Really? From RCRC.
39:15 Correct. Yes. So they're shopping for somebody else to do that because they don't even have that. They don't really let it out. Which means, again, back to this calendar, you know, it's condensing closer and closer and you don't even have the people in place that are going to facilitate that. Is there any other organization in the region who has shown an interest or participated in the past?
39:37 With the position we're talking about, ESCOG, Stepping into, assuming, continuing. Can I get some clarification on what exactly we're talking about here? I'm just confused. Maybe I'm behind the curve here. Are we asking about Elaine running the High Road Transition Council? No, no, no, no. What are we asking? What are we talking about? We're asking the Sierra Business Council.
40:05 For clarification on the status of ESCOG's current contract, which is budgeted for $100,000 that we still have not received a contract from, and I don't know if we've even paid any money from. So that's the first question.
40:19 For what activities? For previous activities? Previous activities. Previous activities. Previous activities. That we already completed. The work's already been done. So, Elaine, if you could respond to Supervisor Griffith's question about the ESCOG contract for which we do not have a contract. That was for work that was done a while ago, I'm thinking, right? Yes. So,
40:42 SBC provided contracts to ESCOG and Mother Low Job Training Center and subsequently others to serve as sort of geographical partners for the east side and the west side to convene stakeholders and develop community means to inform the strategic plan in phase one of California Jobs. And was that the thing that was thrown together when there was an uproar because the
41:12 Eastside was not getting support? It was prior to that. It was prior to that. It was prior to even that. And so that was for phase one of California Jobs First, and that contract expired on August 31st. And then the Sierra Business Council had, in the application that they put in for the second phase of California Jobs First to the state, they included ESCOG as a contractor to serve, again, in the similar capacity of...
41:38 Being boots on the ground to convene partners and stakeholders in eastern Sierra counties to coordinate things around the catalyst phase. So ESCOG's contract with Sierra Business Council that's reimbursing that work expired on August 31st. For phase one. And phase one is over.
41:59 And so we're expecting to get reimbursed for that? And so we're expecting that we'd be reimbursed for phase one. Okay, so what you're talking about is the contract for phase two, which is the catalyst phase. No, we still haven't been reimbursed for phase one. We are still waiting. Because I think this is actually important and relevant to the reimbursement component, which is in that contract, the Sierra Business Council will reimburse contractors after they're reimbursed from the state. And so that puts a pretty significant delay in our reimbursement.
42:29 We're going to provide a second contract for this catalyst phase for ESCOG to build capacity, be able to convene partners, etc. Today is October 31st and I have not seen a contract yet. I have continued to do outreach to partners and try and understand the landscape of potential projects so that we can ensure that we're meeting some of those criteria as a region around
42:56 submitting applications that can be funded, that it's meeting the goals of the strategic plan, that it covers multiple geographies, that's impactful and sustainable, because we have a December 15th timeline to submit those applications. If it's not, if all the catalyst funding isn't awarded within this first round, they expect to do a subsequent round, but there's obvious benefits to
43:17 having coordination beforehand. So I have been doing that work since October 31st out of general fund revenues because there is no reimbursement for Sierra Business Council to be convening those partners. But it's in their plan to have a contract with you? Yes. For $100,000? I think it's $150,000. Okay. And so this is in addition to
43:37 What you're asking for in the recommendation is to identify any projects that we as the ESCOG may want to do. And you're telling us this for situational awareness of maybe we want to be wary about doing that? And with these applications that we apply here, if we are successful, is that also through the Sierra Business Council?
44:07 It is. It's not awarded by the Sierra Business Council. But it's administered through them? It's administered, and they are responsible for reimbursing those projects. But they're also, again, only going to reimburse once they get a reimbursement from the state. My understanding, and I will clarify this, is that they will have those monies in a treasury because they have been appropriated by the state.
44:33 Right, because for this catalyst phase, Sierra Business Council has been awarded $14 million, of which $9 million is available for projects, which means they're receiving $5 million for administration. There's no way they're going to spend that money. What if they don't give out contracts? They didn't spend all the money last time. I assume they didn't spend all the money last time. This is this ongoing thing, because this is a directive from the state of California to empower.
45:02 Regions across the state to get money into community-based organizations, small JPAs like us, to build capacity and to get things done that's theoretically in our interest, but we keep running into this administrative crux with the Sierra Business Council. And that's, to Linda's point about risk, that's kind of what we're messing around with right now. And that they continue to push up to the state as the people that aren't doing what they're supposed to do.
45:31 So if the state would do what they're doing, then see a reasonable council could do what they're supposed to do, and so it's just this big pass back and forth. Back to just that question I had. So there's no other entity besides ESCOG in the whole region? I didn't have a chance to answer that question, but I appreciate it. The Motherlow Job Training Center on the west side serves as the counterpart to ESCOG on the east side.
45:59 I believe they also don't have contracts and have been serving in a similar capacity because I think it's also relevant to note that the Sierra Business Council has not, in this period of time between submitting the strategic plan to the state and the catalyst opening, they've not been doing work to convene partners or organize projects. As you can see, given some of the criteria,
46:21 For having multiple partners, having multiple geographies, it really does require someone to have a landscape view and be able to convene people to have those conversations. So Motherlow Job Training Center has been doing similar work to the ESCOG on the other side, as well as a contractor. Without contract, without payment, without anything. And so we're supposed to front that for you to gather the east side together and begin to consolidate projects and talk about what we would put forward.
46:50 to request Catalyst funding to the group that would meet again at the start, I think, well, whenever they would call their meetings, but yeah. Okay, so that is... Well, and the other piece of this is I serve on the board of the Mammoth Lakes Rules and Public Access Foundation, MLTPA, which convenes the ESSRP.
47:09 We responded to an RFP to be the industry sector coordinator for the recreation and tourism sector. We did that. SBC identified us and a group on the west side to be the industry sector coordinator for recreation and tourism. But we're seeing the same thing that Elaine is seeing. No contract and a really compressed timeline and a really uncertain environment around questions like, is it a contract or is it this, are we an extension of your state?
47:37 You know, auditing and administrative reporting. It's important to move forward with this, but it's also important to be highlighting that there needs to be a conversation with the Sierra Business Council leadership or their administrative people. What's going on here? Because our ESCOG staff is working, you know, we're extending ourselves to a very limited general fund. We want to see this thing moving forward. We're gathering partners. We're putting all this stuff together. What? Two simple questions.
48:05 And who are the people at the SBC that we need to be rattling? Kristen York, Mr. Steve Frisch, and Erica Harvey. Those three people are the people that need to be talked to. So I was told by Erica recently that the Sierra Business Council is going to be the co-facilitator of the agriculture group because they had no response from the east side.
48:33 So they're going to even step into that role because no one else is stepping up to it. Oh, but they're not stepping up into it. Well, this is a whole different thing. This would be the group that's trying to put together projects, right? So they're, yeah, that's even a weird. So what you're looking for from us is direction on the projects from this list that we would like to. Or different projects. Or different projects. No, I appreciate the question for clarification.
49:01 I am not looking for direction on any of these specific projects. Some of them are being spearheaded, like the ones that are included under Inyo County, Inyo County is within that working to build partnerships and submit those applications. I think what I'm looking for is kind of some broad authority from the board, which is to, one, continue to try and convene partners across the region and develop those partnerships.
49:30 Two, where it is logical for the ESCOG to serve as the applicant on these projects and it falls within some of the authorities that we've already identified for sustainable recreation, tourism, forestry, that I could work specifically towards those applications to develop them. And then third, I'm looking for direction to be able to develop a
49:57 an application that would be independent of the contract that SBC has provided to develop an application for the ESCOG to build capacity under Catalyst to continue to convene the regional partners and develop an understanding of the gaps and the needs.
50:21 for building an ecosystem under sustainable recreation on a regional basis, under forestry on a regional basis, and potentially incubating some of other tangential items within that as well. Appreciate the clarification. That was all very well laid out. So one in three, I say yes, go forth on. The first one, even like I think since they wrote it into their
50:49 Plant budget or plan or whatever it is with the state and they're going to have to spend the five million dollars even though they're delayed in all of this and that's concerning. I think we have a reasonable amount of confidence that that's going to come through so I think you should continue doing that. The third one, if we can find a way to get capacity for ESCOG through this in a way that is additive.
51:17 Can I ask a question about the third one? Would that be, we just bypass the Sierra Business Council and kind of use the word convene and we're kind of like the convener now? Not for this whole big project, but for like ESCOG type projects, we can just go straight to California Jobs first as our, no. No, it would be, potentially in the next round, I love how complicated this is, potentially in the next round for the implementation round, we could
51:45 Thank you. Thank you.
52:15 the Sustainable Recreation Ecosystem Management Program that was adopted. Okay. Okay. Yeah, so not for advancing Sierra jobs for California jobs first, but for advancing the goals. Already established. Already established. Yeah. And with the goal of being able to leverage this funding to make
52:40 to develop capacity that is then impactful and sustainable beyond the Catalyst Fund. Right. And so then on number two, my concerns, I'm not saying no, we shouldn't do that, but my concerns are that... Remind us, number two. Number two was should we submit, should we be the lead applicant for submitting a project, like one of these on the list or something else? And my concern with that is if
53:10 If an idea doesn't have a champion outside of us, then I think it has a lower chance of being successful. Like I think people have great ideas about stuff, but if there's no champion for it out there, then we become the champion at the end of the day. And so I have concerns about our capacity and the overall
53:37 Chances of success for the project. Let me add a nuance to that, which it goes back to this accounting piece, which is that A, the ESCOG may be able to assemble a package with advocates and proponents where it's clear that there is value in the ESCOG playing the role as the lead because the ESCOG has access to be able to finance through the reimbursable part that's not going to be that other organizations are not going to be able to provide. That's the first thing.
54:05 And the second thing is that, you know, with that in mind, there's an opportunity for the ESCOG to play a role with that second financing piece is whether is it a contract or a subrecipient. I think we as a region need to be able to exploit all nimble, all possible roads of nimbleness to be able to apply for these funds, in which case the ESCOG may be
54:34 By far and away the best lead applicant with a package of projects that are going to be supporting other things that are around it. I guess that makes some sense, but those are some strong caveats in that there has to be the champion out there. They're going to be doing the bulk of whatever. We are just a vessel to make that happen. That makes some sense. I don't want to be...
54:59 Yeah, I don't want to be taking up a bunch of your time that even if this comes with money, that doesn't create another 20% of an Elaine. Right. Have any such champions come to you and asked the ESCOG to apply on behalf? Any of them who don't have a conflict? Is that you? Well, I was in a conversation yesterday. I was in a conversation with Elaine down at Bishop with Inyo County, Sierra Costa Community College, and the National Forest Service.
55:28 Where we are talking on exactly these questions, and we're dealing with these vagaries from SBC. Is it, what are we going to do about the reimbursable? Is it a contract? Is it, is there going to be this huge administrative burden, which is not clear yet? There's not an answer to that yet. But I think what you're saying is consistent with what the ESCOG has said on other projects. We've said the same thing with the burpee, right?
55:50 Did the grant, we're done with it, it's on the website, but the implementation of that is going to have to rely on other partners. And have we been clear to those people who approached the ESCOG in this capacity of what the ESCOG is willing to do and what they're not willing to do? As in, we're not spearheading this, you have to be the boots on the ground. Yes. And to answer the question, even beyond the conversation that we had in Bishop yesterday, there are other partners that...
56:19 On occasion, for instance, I convened a group of forestry partners to talk about workforce development opportunities and is there something within Catalyst that we could fund that would help solidify that ecosystem or be able to propel it forward? And in that room, everyone looked and they're like, well, isn't this a thing the ESCOG is supposed to be convening and corralling and administering? And so, to your point, Councilman Mahoby, like, we don't...
56:47 It is, I think, frustrating to everyone in the Seven County region and even beyond that to be in the middle of an application period and for things to still be so undefined. So there's a lot of unanswered questions. For things like forestry, I think...
57:04 As a really good example, the specific thing that came up was we have some workforce development activities that are happening in Cerro Coso around workforce development training. And we have, you know, potential investments in tribal workforce development or in, you know, other elements of this. We have the work that is being done through the Pace and Scale Accelerator to identify these projects. So there is a lot of momentum. There's a lot of funding. We couldn't identify sort of that key gap.
57:30 That we would fund through a catalyst project to advance it. At the end of the day, the conversation with these several partners from different organizations resulted in, it's like, well, what we really need is we need someone who has capacity to do job placement. So as people are coming out of all these programs we're establishing and we have all this skill and, you know, all these needs and landscape, how are we helping to, like, translate and place people into those positions? And is that something that ESCOG?
57:56 Would do. Isn't that what the job spot is supposed to be doing? Well, and, which was, which is what, you know, my response is, is there's also, in the seven county area, there's capacity with, in other organizations that are partnered at California Jobs First, that that is their skill set. That is what they do. They have those relationships. So, no, that's not a thing that the ESCOG should do, necessarily. Good answer.
58:17 But then there's other conversations that I've had with, for instance, the tribes, and they're interested in, we want to do cultural tourism, we want to have a relationship with some of the recreation projects that are coming out. Could ESCOG be a partner to help facilitate that type of project where there would be multiple entities across different jurisdictions and it would need a single applicant to be able to administer that program?
58:45 So I think, I mean, Jeff, I hear what you're saying about ESCOG not going in there as a one-off. But I think given the uncertainty of a lot of the environment that everybody's trying to work in, if an assembled group determines
58:58 Look, the best way for this thing to succeed is for a role like this for the ESCOG with the champions that you've identified that's part of this package. I mean, this is an opportunity to bring the tribes into things, to bring, to assemble a package that way. I think we need to say to Elaine, see what's out there.
59:16 with the understanding that this is going to come back to us on the 13th, right? And so there can be a representation of the rationale for whatever role the ESCOG is playing based on the direction you just, I guess, with the- Yeah, but then the applications do on the 15th? Yeah. So that's a little- Right. So I guess the caveat I would say with that, or the warning, is because, say,
59:39 You know, it's really hard for us to give you specific direction today on work on this project, work on this project, work on this project, because we don't know what those projects are. And we don't know which parties are the leaders, the people who are going to be doing the work on those projects. All of that. And then, so if we say, go forth and plan all of this stuff, and you put in a ton of work in the next six weeks, two months or whatever, and then come back to us with two days, there's...
1:00:07 We're in a tough position there because if we say no, the project's dead. You know, there's not enough time to pivot to something else. So, like, I don't quite know how to give the direction other than, say, be super cautious and, like, maybe the first answer is no unless it's, like, obvious all of the stars align. But how long do you think it would take to, like, whittle down a list to something that's, like, that you're even thinking about?
1:00:36 I would say several weeks, in part because there are so many different partners to this that convening them and even getting people to set their own project priorities seems very challenging. I don't know if you were driving towards this, but one of the thoughts that I have had is does it make sense to have a special meeting between now?
1:01:01 And December 13th, depending on how this is developing, so that- Either a special meeting or something where you can solicit input from the board members on an individual basis. Certainly. Here are the ones that are floating around. Realistically, we can only do one or two. Tell me which would be your top two. Yeah, and I think that kind of communication-
1:01:30 We wouldn't have to have like a special board meeting to say, you know, you're hearing what the board is saying here. This is how, and I think the focus, Elaine, is the role that the ESCOG would play in a, perhaps a package of projects or in individual projects. Hearing what you've heard up here today, that this is, ESCOG's potentially playing a role with this constellation of projects, perhaps.
1:01:56 ESCOG has met with a bunch of people in this constellation of projects, but this other capacity is going to be the lead. So that it's clear that we're putting the ESCOG in the right place with our core competencies, which we've talked about as part of the strategic planning effort. This is the kind of role that's expected of the ESCOG, and this is the role that the ESCOG is probably going to play. The only other thing that I would add to that is I think when we're going through this, we should definitely think in the long game.
1:02:25 And so now we've had phase one that kind of was a little bit of a debacle. Now we're going into phase two and you say that there's phase three. I would like whatever we do here to set us up so that when phase three comes around, we're like, okay, we are actually ready to take the lead on these things and our applications look a lot more solid with the state.
1:02:55 Bypassing some of the issues that we've been addressing with. From a really high level, you know, look down, it's like, okay, so we have ESCOG who's going to have a contract or should have one now, currently, to do the things you're doing, pay for the stuff you've done in the past, and to set up to be paid for what you're doing currently under the scope. But within that scope of what you're doing, we're also talking about a further advancement of ESCOG and trying to
1:03:23 Touch some of the money that is going to be available for the sector work to continue funding ESCOG going forward. So when you look at that from a really high level and how money moves around in these grants, I think that's a really odd setup. We're paying you to convene everyone and we're sort of paying you to advance payment for yourself also.
1:03:49 You know, in the world of, you know, money moving around from the state level down, that's a very weird setup. Just saying. Well, but also, I mean, keep in mind things like, and I think what you're hitting on, Stephen, is we're doing a lot of project development work. We're doing a lot of sort of capacity building work with our partners. Linda, the point about the implementation funding for phase three of this, there is no money from the state to do it. Sure. The governor's cut that. No, yeah, right. There's no money there. But Prop 4 is polling very well.
1:04:18 And that, and the Sierra Nevada Conservancy is online to get tens of millions of dollars out of Prop 4. And SNC is very good at putting together reliable, understandable grant application process. SNC. What's that? SNC. SNC. SNC. Sierra Nevada Conservancy. SNC. Sierra Nevada Conservancy. So that, if, but a lot of this work could be looked at as development work for future funding opportunities that are above and beyond Sierra Jobs First.
1:04:48 Okay, yeah, well noted, it's just that I also, you know, am always concerned about the capacity of our staff to run in so many different directions simultaneously. Yeah, I appreciate that, and I think that that would be one of the real intents of the concept around the capacity building is to have, you know, if there's $150,000 in the contract with the Sierra Business Council.
1:05:15 That's over two years, $75,000 a year. A portion of that already would be allocated to pay for just my salary, which means that there is a lesser component to be able to hire administrative staff, and I think to be able to sort of accomplish this bigger body of work in developing partnerships.
1:05:43 And understand the ecosystem of sort of how some of those partnerships can move between, you know, federal partners, local partners, non-profit partners to be able to implement this work on the east side. That is going to require more than 1.5 people to do that. One thing I really appreciate the board entertaining a very complicated discussion.
1:06:09 I regret that I couldn't come with very specific proposals at this time, but I do think this is really helpful for setting direction as we navigate this application process. And another boundary I think that I would provide
1:06:22 To add to Supervisor Griffith's caution is that we could really focus in on those potential partnerships under the authorities that we have in this area and be very specific to sustainable recreation and ecosystem management, which I think, you know, we wouldn't be looking at infrastructure. There's not funding for broadband anyway. You know, we don't have a role necessarily in agriculture, so I think we can
1:06:46 keep it really defined by the authorities that ESCOG has, which will help limit things considerably. Would you say at this point you have direction?
1:06:59 You have three choices. The answer is sure. I don't know exactly what to do. Yeah, I would say given the type of definity we have within, definition we have within California Jobs First, generally yes, this has been a very helpful discussion. Thank you. I'm so glad we could help. And I will look forward to keeping you all informed as those conversations progress over the next month.
1:07:27 Awesome. If I could make a comment on just on the list here with one of these that I've been involved with is the creation of a community found Eastern Sierra Community Foundation. I've been working a lot with former Supervisor Corliss and future Supervisor McFarland with their
1:07:50 Representation of various foundations in the area to work on that. And there's been a lot of momentum and movement on that, sort of even outside of the Sierra Jobs First Catalyst program. And we will be having a community meeting at some point here in the next month or so. And encourage everyone to attend and if anybody wants to.
1:08:16 Chat about it, happy to chat about it. Well, I'll just say when looking at this list, that that was the one that I was like, that will have the most impact across the board, like access to capital regionally. I was like, that's the one that I liked the most. Yay. Yeah. When's that me, what are you setting that up? So, where we are right now is, so me representing the CCR Foundation, Stacey with the Mammoth Community Foundation, and Paul with the DeCembeau Foundation, we have agreed amongst our boards to
1:08:46 put some initial money out to get a facilitator and there's fingers crossed there's a woman who was heavily involved in starting and now runs the Nevada County Community Foundation which started about five years ago and knows how to do this type of thing and so we're getting a contract with her to come and help facilitate this whole thing and
1:09:10 We're going to be putting together a list of stakeholders, so non-profit representatives from around the area, as well as, you know, electeds and executive officers and stuff like that. And so hoping to get all of that done by the first week of December. So you don't need to worry about that one as in your application. That would check. No, great.
1:09:39 Any input from the public? Okay. Moving on to Executive Director update. Okay. So I have provided a written update in your agenda packet, but I will just pull out a few things for the Board's attention. First, the decision notice for the Eastern Sierra Climate Communities Resiliency Project Environmental Assessment was signed on September 19th.
1:10:08 And this is a huge accomplishment to be able to have gotten that work done. I included the decision notice within the agenda packet as well if you want to look through that. But it is especially worth noting that for the decision, implementation can begin following the signing of this decision. So the objection period has passed. And this will allow work to move forward on the Donut project for wildfire mitigation.
1:10:38 I wanted to share with the board, give me just a moment here, I haven't shared something in Zoom in so long, I don't know if I remember how. I wanted to share with you
1:10:58 As part of the Towns to Trails Project, Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access, which serves as one of our subcontractors, provided capacity for someone to ride the entire proposed alignment in its current iteration from Tahoe to Elantia, which I think is really exciting, and I'm really sorry that that wasn't part of my job.
1:11:22 They should be paying us. Is that Chris McNamara? Isn't that Chris? We're hiring, you know. Was it Chris McNamara that did that or was he going to do it? It was a colleague of his. Yeah. So I just, as the individual who wrote this went through,
1:11:39 They went through each segment. They did photography of the segment. They did a review of what worked and what needed to be improved. They wrote, there's, in this alternative, there's segments, or in the iteration right now, there's alternatives where, you know, maybe this works, but maybe this would work better. And so this individual wrote a lot of those alternatives and then provided feedback.
1:12:08 on that as well. So this is really important for us to move into this next and sort of final phase of developing proposed alignment because now we've had someone go on the ground, say what works, what doesn't work, where there's definitively gaps, and the feedback and the review overall was really positive. In fact, I forget where in the presentation.
1:12:38 He provided that, you know, this could be a world-class experience. Really not recommended. Yeah. I guess this is it. So overall Townsend Trails is a world-class experience. The room was fun and scenic and relatively easy single track. And it was, he also includes in here that it's a really
1:13:01 A wonderful medium to be able to not just experience the landscape of the Eastern Sierra, but to experience the culture and the history in each of the communities. So I'm very grateful to Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access Foundation for providing this capacity. It's really exciting to have had someone be able to go out and test that route. And then all of that information is going to be really important for
1:13:31 Providing and refining a final alignment and developing a story map with feedback and with pictures. So I just really appreciate that. I wanted to share that with you today. Also wanted to let your board know. Can we get a copy of that? Yes. There's a little piece of caution just for everybody to understand. This route takes place on existing infrastructure.
1:13:58 And I think, I don't want to speak for what the ultimate outcome is, but I think it's anticipated that there's not going to be an ask to do anything that's going to trigger any NEPA or trigger any CEQA. There are folks in the environmental community that have come to these meetings and have, they're perhaps not quite understanding what this is.
1:14:18 So I just wanted to add those notes of this is not a motorized project. This is not about recreating Jawbone Canyon here in the Eastern Sierra. It is a very, very different type of a project. I would say the caveat of those people who have commented do not, I don't believe that they represent a majority. I'm just saying, I'm just offering that the larger public context. And I would add to that two things. One, this is also still not a final.
1:14:47 So it's a review document. But also, one of the things that's accomplished by having someone write this is that it identifies some gaps that we knew were probably there where it's not going to be possible to do.
1:15:04 The entire stretch on soft surface infrastructure, there are places where it has to default to Highway 395, and there's also going to be segments there that are not permitted for or usable by OHVs, so it can't be done as a throughout OHV trail. And I think the analysis that's going to come out of the report is going to look at all the various types of recreation uses.
1:15:28 And look at equestrian. Well, you could ride this on a horse, but you know, you can't take a horse on 395, so maybe it's not going to work for you. And to Elaine's point, there's segments of it that are already legal for OHV, but you can't take an OHV on like a county road or the state highway, so it's not going to maybe work for that. And it's pointing towards some kind of a bicycle, bikepacking kind of experience. It's sort of heading to something like that, but we'll see. So do we know where, when would trigger
1:15:57 It depends a little bit. We just made a map with existing uses. That already happens. There are a lot of the motorcycle groups that you see that come through on dirt roads. There are international groups where they look at the existing infrastructure and they draw routes. But if we were to say. Within this. Yeah. Yes. So it's one of the things that has been really challenging in the data analysis.
1:16:26 is we use GIS data from the counties and the agencies, and within each of those agencies, there's different definitions of motorized versus non-motorized and what's permitted. So sorting through the data has been a little bit challenging. We will have a high-level analysis of segments that are permitted for motorized versus non-motorized. And there's also a little bit of...
1:16:50 Just different discretion that requires some analysis from the different agencies about what would trigger a NEPA analysis. So for instance, the Forest Service has been very supportive of this project and says, you know, you're using existing infrastructure under an existing use, and so no NEPA would be required for that. That's an ongoing conversation with Bureau of Land Management. But wouldn't, I mean, there's always exposure, right? Even if the Forest says we don't need a NEPA, the Sierra Club might say, yes, you do, and we're going to sue you.
1:17:18 Also true, but it's the question of what triggers that, because we're, I mean, these are things that people can already do on that. Sure, sure. So is it the, if it's on a formal designation, then there's no action, there's no discretionary approval that's provided. Yeah, yeah, okay. Right, so if Mammoth Lakes Tourism took this analysis and printed a map and handed it out and called it the East whatever, that, is that?
1:17:48 According to the service, that would be fine. But that already happens. I mean, I can share with you some of these. This already goes on. Please do. Yeah. Sure. So, yeah, I can just jump in a little bit on the CEQA environmental review perspective. You know, I think the most important thing to highlight is that in order to perform
1:18:13 sequel review and I'm not saying that I think we do need to do any sequel but the very first thing you need is a project and the project must be concrete and defined.
1:18:23 We are not there yet because we don't even have an alignment defined yet. So, you know, I think the absolute first thing that would need to happen before we could even begin to think, and I'm using the royal we of, you know, sort of all agencies involved in this project, we would need a concrete alignment of, you know, this is the path that the, quote, official route, you know, will follow. And then at that point, as Elaine very correctly indicated, the question then becomes discretionary action.
1:18:52 Is there any discretionary action being taken in support of the project? So we're still very much in the phase of bandying ideas about to define the project. And once that's done, then I think we can take a much closer look at any sort of potential environmental review. Okay. Cool. Thank you. Anything else? Yeah, I do have a couple things to add. Thank you for that. So just to let your board know,
1:19:23 Part of the expanded scope to develop a story map as well as being able to include the findings of the ground truthing exercise, I've requested from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy an extension on the expected completion date for the project.
1:19:43 The expected completion date is currently December 31st, 2024, and I've requested an extension to April 30th for work to be completed and June 30th for any administrative wrap-up of that. And that has been granted, and I will be bringing that contract amendment to your board at the December meeting.
1:20:07 Let's see. Also, you may remember we have been working with each of the four member agencies' jurisdictions to put together a scope for a regional housing needs assessment. Mono County is taking the lead in administering that, and they developed a request for proposals, which is currently being circulated, and we will have responses back on October 30th.
1:20:32 for considering contractors to do that work. And then finally I wanted to let the board know that I attended the Cal Forward Conference in Sacramento a couple weeks ago. I attended it primarily because there was a real focus on how do we work as a region following California jobs first and how
1:20:48 Do we advance that and start to activate those strategies? I thought it was a very inspirational conference. There was a lot of presentations on very, very innovative regional economic work that's happening across the state, so I really appreciated that. There were wonderful networking opportunities, including I met with the CEO of CalCOG, and I will be sitting down with his office tomorrow morning to talk more about how councils of governments function across California and what best practices
1:21:17 That concludes my executive report, but happy to take questions. Thank you. I have a question, Elaine. Okay, you get to the very last page of the document here, and we have Safe Sierra Streets, Reclaiming Highway 395 Main Streets. How does that fit into the larger ALTA project? Is that like an overriding name that we're putting on everything? I just didn't remember seeing that.
1:21:48 It's not related to the ALTA project. I'm not sure what you're referring to. Okay, page 81 of 110. Yes, that is the application that we submitted under the Federal Reconnecting Communities Grant Program, and I'm just including it for your reference. Got it. Okay, thank you. Yeah, that was the counterpart to the state one that we went toward. Okay, thank you. I actually do have a question on
1:22:19 on your update. So obviously we lost staff. Yes. So how's the search for a replacement going? I've reached out to a couple of people who are providing consulting work in the area who are familiar with the work that we're doing at the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments to see if they want to be able to fill that role.
1:22:48 So I have conversations set up with Celeste Berg, who had worked with us before, and then another potential consultant for the next week and then the first week of November. Okay. And then looking similarly, I think if I could have...
1:23:09 One of those individuals agreed to sign on in a greater capacity than we had before, that would be much more efficient and effective. So that's what I'm aiming for. In particular, because as noted in my director's report, we have a grant with the Inyo National Forest that is actually parallel to some of the things we were talking about earlier with building capacity and understanding the ecosystem about recreation that I had not initiated because there was not capacity to do it.
1:23:37 Now we've initiated it, and there's not capacity to it. So yeah, so it feels, I definitely feel some pressure to try and get someone to fill that role as quickly as possible. And if you know of anyone who might be interested and have good qualifications to be able to provide some of that consulting services, please send them my direction. I'd be happy to talk with them. Thank you. Any other questions for Elaine? Any questions from the public?
1:24:07 All right. Thanks, Elaine. Moving on to board member slash agency reports. I wanted to talk a little bit about the field trip that we took last week to go out and visit the proposed biomass sites at ORMAT. That was after our board of supervising meetings we convened to the
1:24:35 Ormat side out there and walked around and looked at different sites in comparison, which was best, which wasn't, you know, which was on whose land and who could approve whatever Fred was with us. And there was an article in the paper, in the sheet this week that quoted him the same things I didn't hear him say, but it was also a larger group.
1:25:00 Surprise, surprise. Which was basically a, well, I don't know about this approval from the Forest Service to do this. We don't know if that would work or not. And I didn't hear that. So it seemed that the site that's preferred by most people and would have the most buildability and, you know, places to store, stock and stuff would be that site. So to be continued, next steps, I think we're kind of in it.
1:25:29 Thank you so much. Thank you.
1:25:56 And would this be like an industrial composting site as part of that, or is it just for fuel mitigation? No, no, that was not part of it. It's mostly fuel, mostly, you know. How do you deal with there being five feet of snow on top of all of the rocks that you're in? Yes, that was all discussed. It seemed to entail lots of plows.
1:26:16 Plows? Snow plows. Snow plows. Snow plows. To keep the road open. It's funny because they say, well, it's really such a small amount of trucks per day. It would be, you know, maybe, maybe six trucks a day in. I'm like, six trucks a lot. That's a lot of trucks that need to come down this road that could be covered with snow. Yeah, just think about if there's a...
1:26:33 Yard where it's all laid out that would be unusable. Yeah, it's all part of the consideration. It has a ways to go. It's not right here, but they've gotten some nice grant money and stuff to kind of... Apparently, our bill that we tried to get through the state legislature for not paying sales tax on emergency equipment, like fire trucks and stuff, got...
1:27:00 Bastardized into being that you don't pay state taxes on snow plows. What about fire trucks? I used to pay taxes. Oh, okay. But snow plows, for some reason. Okay. Well, good. Yay. Only municipal snow plows. Yes. It's not like the private person. True. Municipal snow plows. So I don't even know if it even...
1:27:29 Made its way through. Got it. Well, not that there's a sight in Inyo County that jumps out in mind, but, you know, when, I mean, there were discussions, I remember, like a decade ago about this, and there was the thought of if trucks are rolling down the hill full and back up the hill empty, that wouldn't be as huge of an impact, and it's snow-free. So, I don't know.
1:27:56 I think it's all, you know, studied out on this area because it's so close to the work that you've done. And you begin to, I mean, you know, these are the finance guys. They're all running these scenarios. Is there still talk of burying stuff? I haven't heard that. I mean, I've read that over time. I have not heard any discussion of that recently. That always seems like kind of a silly idea to me.
1:28:21 Well, I mean, there's so much, you know, different going on, you know, the stuff that's going on over the hill through RCRC, that stuff over there, that's all pellet, generating pellets on those two sides. This would be generating char and electricity. Up north, there's some work being done on this wood, taking it and...
1:28:40 Manufacturing and compressing it and doing things to make what they call strong wood, which is, you know, proposed to be as strong as metal and building, I mean, there's a difference. Yeah, and I think in Plumas County, they have a laminated timber operation. Yes, right, yeah. I don't know, does anyone know what they're doing with Carson City Hill, what they're doing with that wood, all this huge amount of wood that's up there? I've been poking around a little bit, that was on tribal land, so they were able to stand it up really, really quickly.
1:29:09 It's all coming out of Tahoe Basin, and I don't know what they're doing with the woods. Someone said they're milling it, but I don't know what that means. If it doesn't turn into, you can mill it, but then what do you do with it? So I don't know any more about that, but that's another huge facility up there that stood up pretty quick. You know, chop it down, and then it will grow back, as opposed to the old days of, oh, we can't chop anything down. So now we're back to the, you know, oh, where were those lumber companies we used before? Yeah, where did they all go? Okay.
1:29:39 Anything else? Karen. Well, we have a new building that's getting erected quickly in Bishop. Yeah, that's cool. I don't know if you guys have noticed, right next to Spellbinder. How many stories is it? I don't know, is it three? Yeah, three. He's doing like business on the bottom and he took advantage of our downtown improvement plan, which is great. So that's exciting, you know, some private investment.
1:30:07 Moving quickly into town with a brand new cool looking building. So it's, yeah, it's next to what's really, it's really narrow. Like the plot is, you know, he's, it's like, it's almost like what you would see in, you know, like New York City, like how do they build something in between those, you know, but it, so it's cool. And, which is exciting. So that's, that's, and then we have, you know, our Christmas stuff coming up. The parade is going to be the first weekend in December.
1:30:35 We had the Haunted Swamp last weekend, just, you know, normal Bishop fun, yeah. Is this a modular building? No, no. It's a stick and he's just going up quick. He's going up, yeah, he's, you know, well-funded and he's took advantage of, you know,
1:30:52 The new zoning that we... The opportunity zone. Yeah. No, well, that and... That too. And our downtown specific plan. And the downtown specific plan. Yeah. Did the old building come completely down? Yes. Yeah. Yeah. It's a brand new construction. They had to trench it out. He has a huge piece of plywood in front of it that spray-painted Bishop. It looks kind of cool. So if you are driving by and you wouldn't see it, yeah, it's obvious. It's pretty cool. How about a good specific plan?
1:31:18 And that guy follows building codes. Oh, absolutely.
1:31:24 When you follow the building codes, it just goes right up. It's fast. Yeah. And well funded. And when you follow building codes, anyone from the public who enters that building or who lives there has some level of assurance that it is actually safe. How many units? How many units is he going to have upstairs? Four. Four. Yeah. Two in the front, two in the back. Okay. Yeah. Cool. What's going on with the other one? The bigger the...
1:31:54 I mean, she's just got a big task ahead of her. She's got, she just held a chamber mixer, which was fun. It's always fun to go in her space. But, you know, she's looking for, she's still looking for funding. Yeah. So she's got a big, a big, big project. Yeah. Jeff?
1:32:17 Yeah, so a couple things. One, the Small Business Development Center in Bishop is nearing completion. Oh, and I heard you guys hired an executive director. And I wrote it down right here. We hired, finally, well, not we, Sierra Business Council, we have a contract with them, and they were really, they had not hired an executive director, even though it really needed to happen, but they just recently hired Merrill. Do you just pay them every quarter?
1:32:46 So they hired Meryl Picard. Oh, wow. And so we're very excited about that. And we're waiting on like some children's furniture, I think. But otherwise, it's almost all completely done and built out. And we're looking for a
1:33:15 Grand opening sometime in the middle of, I mean, beginning of December, I believe. Sometime after Thanksgiving. You should have a float in the parade. Okay. I think you should. Okay. You're full of great ideas. Yes, one of them. And this is a regional small business development center, so we should continue these conversations and figure out how to make it.
1:33:43 The whole region can benefit from that. EMS, so we are nearing the process of releasing the or submitting the RFP for the exclusive operating area for the Bishop area to ISIMA.
1:34:06 And hoping for an expedited process to get that done as quickly as possible. Our current contract with Reach Medical for providing the service that includes a subsidy from the City of Bishop, Inyo County, and the Tribe.
1:34:28 So that contract expires December 31st. It seems unlikely that we will have a new EOA in place, but there's some automatic extenders of that contract. But the good news is I believe it's about ready to go in for a review on that. There apparently has been some discussions on the staff level, but maybe like
1:34:56 You know, just throwing it out there so it's on everybody's radar. But that service provides a certain amount of service to Mono County in the Tri-Valley area and then the Paradise area. And I don't fully understand y'all's system for that, but there has been some discussion of should we...
1:35:23 Does that level of service reach a level that we want it to be legitimized in some way? Or do we just want to continue to call it mutual aid and let it ride out as it is?
1:35:37 But I know that Nate has talked with Sandra. Yeah, I know that was happening. Yeah, there's a little bit of a documentary to get down into there quickly because it's just so far. Pardon me? It's really far. Yeah, it's really far for, you know, EMS, Mono County EMS Provider. It's really far for everybody. And the issue for Bishop, like, particularly when it goes into an exclusive operating area, there are time requirements.
1:36:05 You know, if you have a unit that is going out to Hamill, that means it's out of circulation for an hour or something like that. And then is there like how many units are on standby and can they meet their other requirements if they're going all the way out there, which I think obviously they're going to go if there's no other option. That's just the way our first responders work. They're going to go there.
1:36:34 So I think at some point it would be good for a regional discussion on, you know, what does that mean. That's all I wrote down. I'll let Trina handle the bulk of the report. She already passed. So considerate. She already passed. She already passed. Oh, our DA is retiring and our treasurer tax collector is retiring. Oh, really? Those will happen at the end of the year. We will be holding interviews.
1:37:05 So maybe we could steal somebody from Mono County. Yeah. No? Okay. John? So the town council of Mammoth Lakes has been relatively quiet. Our town manager is on a, I don't want to say a vacation, but a break. This is Ann Holler, who used to take this opportunity to go to Uganda and do public service kinds of things. So we're a little bit quiet.
1:37:31 And as you'll notice, our colleagues from down south, when you drive around town, you don't see a whole lot of signs out there on the ground. That's because our council election is at this point a foregone conclusion. Brent Truax will be on the council as long as Bill Souser was not contested. There's no contested election. We're really in the ballot initiative.
1:37:49 Game. We've got four initiatives on the ballot. One from the county for a TOT increase, one from the town for a TOT increase that we're really focused on housing. Also something from the schools and something from the fire district for public safety. There's been some bizarre things in the press. There's been some anonymous editorial opinions that I don't...
1:38:11 I don't even know who's behind all that stuff, but you may see a letter from me in the local paper, the regional paper this week about that. And I do want to, you know, as you know, I provide services for the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, the SSRP, and I've really encouraged, we haven't had a presence from Bishop for the last couple of meetings.
1:38:33 But there's a confluence coming together around wildfire and recreation economies that's happening on the state level. I was at the Wildfire Task Force meeting last week. I want to talk with you a bit on your role with CSAC and others.
1:38:47 Where, you know, Jobs First is not just a region by region thing. There's a statewide council that's being chaired by the head of the labor agency and GO-Biz where these regional strategies are rolling up and this intersection of wildfire and the threat that it represents to communities and the climate and all the rest of it.
1:39:05 Combined with the value that recreation provides as economic drivers for all of rural California, it's getting some attention. We'll talk a little bit at the SSRP meeting next time about how that's coming together, but I think for county folks who deal with RCRC and CSAC and things like this, there's something to talk about at the state level with the stuff that may be helpful in terms of getting resources and capacity to help to come back down through the jobs first thing.
1:39:32 In our region to benefit all of us. So anybody wants more information, we're happy to go on and on about that. But that was, that's pretty interesting. One, two other quick last things. In our discussion with Jobs First, Elaine, I want to make sure that you know that the board is prepared to support you around those vagaries that's coming out of the Sierra Business Council process. Is that...
1:39:55 Can we assume that if you get to a point of saying, look, I cannot get a definitive answer out of this. I need support from the board or electeds to have a conversation. Is that clear? I appreciate that. Thank you. And just to add that Supervisor Gardner has been included on my correspondence. Supervisor Gardner, I believe, is overseas. He has been included in my correspondence. Okay.
1:40:25 And please just reach out to the vice chair, whoever's appropriate to get that clarified. The final thing is obviously there's a very significant federal election coming up in a couple of weeks. There is.
1:40:46 I think I would request perhaps that we have an agenda item on the 13th, whatever happens, because the implications, we're 90% managed by the federal government. And if things happen one way or the other, I think that we need to think in terms of our own resilience, our own regional capacity to be able to navigate whatever's going to be coming our way.
1:41:08 And I don't, I have some ideas, but I think it would be an important tactical and strategic thing for the ESCOG to at least, I'd like to hear from my- We're not at request for future agenda items yet. Okay, I'm sorry. Can you hold on? I will. I'll shut it up. Is anybody from Inyo coming to the recreation partnership meetings? Trina's been coming, yeah. Oh, yay. Yeah, yeah. Trina's been making it. Because I've got a standing meeting that conflicts from here on out.
1:41:37 No, Trina's been representing. Okay, good. Okay. Thank you. So, are you okay with your report? Yeah, yeah, yeah. All right. One last thing to add that's going on with the City of, or with the City of Bishop. A few weeks ago, maybe last week, we, the topic of downtown circulation has been coming up, in particular, downtown circulation in Bishop, where our
1:42:07 Daily average vehicle counts are at over 15,000 down Main Street. We have big rigs coming by an average of one every minute. We've already exceeded the Caltrans projection for their upper end projection of how many trucks should be going through Main Street for 2040. So we've already exceeded that.
1:42:37 And so there's obviously we hear from the members of the community that we want downtown to be walkable and inviting because we know that that is also good for business, especially small businesses as opposed to big box stores. And so inevitably during those discussions the topic of a truck bypass comes up and in particular
1:43:05 The old studies that Caltrans had done regarding that didn't take into account a lot of the very important considerations that the members of the community care about. Caltrans obviously just cares about traffic and not necessarily about the impact that that would have on our local economy.
1:43:27 As we embark on this next circulation study for downtown, at this point we're soliciting input from members of the community about what are the things that we should be taking into account in such a study that go beyond just strictly the number of vehicles. But hasn't Caltrans like changed sort of their directive? Like that was what they used to be all about, but now they're more holistic in their approach of like...
1:43:56 Biking and walking and that is part of their mission. That's part of it, yeah. And so you'll, and so a lot of the discussions have been around that. So actually like approaching it from that standpoint as opposed to like, oh let's route trucks through people's backyard or let's, yeah. And so one of the ideas that has been gaining some ground is a Highway 6
1:44:24 Bypass. Because the majority of truck traffic goes on Highway 6. And so you'd be able to, one of the ideas has been also with the development of the airports, there's been a concern about how do you actually get traffic in and out of the airport. And so looking at kind of a holistic approach there. But at this point, only in ideation phase, getting input on what are the kind of things that we would want this sort of a study to answer.
1:44:54 Other thing... Just real quick on that. I mean, I think we'd love to support and be kept aware of what's going on with that. For sure. Certainly, Carson City is a much more interesting place these days. Their downtown is great. Yeah. And it's... Dried up and blew away? No, it's thriving. You can park on it, people milling around, you walk around. Even like Minden, I was trying to determine like why is Minden...
1:45:24 Different than Bishop. And I realized they don't have parking, but they do have greenery. Like that was like, they have like lawns and trees that are in front of the buildings. I was trying to figure out, remember when we were discussing that, I was like, what is it that makes this more inviting than downtown Bishop? And I was like, oh, they have more like landscaping. But downtown Carson City is next level. Absolutely. Yeah. With a bypass. Yes.
1:45:51 The other thing, the, so, I'm the treasurer of the Eastside Student Center, and this year we've actually expanded and have two sites, one that is doing after school programs for fifth and sixth graders, and then we actually were able to create a dedicated space for that, and now we have another site that's for seventh through ninth.
1:46:21 And we are having our Halloween fundraiser this weekend. Where is it at? It's in this large property on Lagoon Street, at the end of Lagoon Street. It should be a fun time, but it is a great...
1:46:47 It's a great project that definitely addresses one of the big needs that we've had. Regularly, the fifth and sixth grade center has over 70 kids coming every day. 40% tribal members, 40% Hispanic Latino, and we're really targeting disadvantaged communities and doing a great job there.
1:47:14 And a new band is debuting at the Eastside Student Center fundraiser called Squid Eye. My husband happens to be in the new band. Two bands. I know, but this is a debut performance. And for all of you up here, I can guarantee you it's going to be much more fun than the ESLT fundraiser that's happening at the same time. ESLT. ESLT.
1:47:35 Yeah, I think we haven't come to ours. I think it's going to be Griffith's family band. Yeah, the split eye was, yeah, they weren't psyched up. Well, may I add a couple more? Sure. That I forgot about. So, big news on the dump front. We are purchasing our landfills from the city of Los Angeles. What is their livable life?
1:48:04 I think it's actually longer now, because it's minimum of 40, but as we keep reducing the amount that we put in, as we divert more, then extends the life, so there's quite a bit of life in the Bishop one. So minimum of 40. There is a regional aspect of that in that legally, well, according to...
1:48:29 The agreement with the City of Los Angeles, we were prohibited from accepting waste from Mono County, even though people from Paradise drive down and use the dump. So after we own it, who knows what can happen with that. So after you own it, is there an opportunity? I think so. Is this going to limit our lifetime of it?
1:48:54 Pardon me? Keep that in mind. If you add more, then you limit the waste. No, I get it. But for things like, for instance, as we are implementing organic waste diversion requirements from the state of California, if you have one commercial composting facility, that may make some sense. From a climate perspective, we're sending all our stuff to hundreds of miles away. It's just ridiculous. I appreciate what you're saying.
1:49:23 We have agreed to form an Assessment Appeals Board as opposed to the Board of Supervisors sitting as the Board of Equalization, which I think is a good thing. There was some discussion about forming a regional one.
1:49:44 I still think that that makes sense, just given that there's a limited amount of people with the expertise necessary for such a thing. There didn't appear to be an appetite for it for this very moment, but that doesn't mean we can't look at that in the future.
1:50:01 We, there is an applicant who's looking to put in a large-scale solar facility down in the far southeast corner of, and I'm sorry, my back's. That's fine, I can hear. A large-scale solar facility in the Charleston View area. A couple of points of why in my mind that makes some sense. One is that that is all zoned residential and if
1:50:28 Somebody would be like, oh, we want to put in another pahrump. Then there's actually space for 50,000 people, which would make it four supervisors in Charleston view and one supervisor for the rest would dramatically change things. So solar is preferable to that in my mind from a water perspective and a human perspective. But also the prohibition against property tax.
1:50:53 The exemption for property tax on large-scale industrial solar facilities sunsets 2027. So everything would have to be built by January 1st, 2027. Is that state or federal? That's state. That's state. Which that's a game changer for everybody in the realm of industrial-scale solar because there's...
1:51:18 Really no incentive for us to do it now, but if you're getting 1% of a billion dollar project, that kind of changes the whole equation of everything. And we have been having public meetings on MECO, which is the micro home enterprise home kitchen operation, which is allowing people to have small little restaurants. We'll see how that goes. There's people that are for it and people are against it, but I don't know if Mono County, Mammoth Lakes. Pardon me? We have that.
1:51:46 Are you sure? No. I think you have the cottage food. We do have cottage food. Yeah, I think, so you have to opt in to the MECO. Seems like people should have the freedom to do what they want with their house. And I mean, yes, that and I think it'd be fun to go eat somebody's dumplings or whatever. Do you already have cottage? Yeah, we have cottage. We have cottage. I think cottage is statewide.
1:52:11 Did that come about because some in particular advocated for it? They wanted to do something and brought it forward? No. No, it just came through environmental health and like them. So a county's, so cottage foods, I believe it's either all counties already have it or you have to opt out if you don't want to do it. The kitchens are opt-in.
1:52:37 From counties or cities or towns. Well, we'd be covered by the county. You'd be covered by the county because we don't have our health inspection type of stuff. I think, never mind, maybe it's just charter cities that can do it. There's a few cities who have done it outside of their counties. Our public works directories.
1:52:58 Terrified of it because of grease traps. Well, there is a significant difference between Cottage and MECOS. Pardon me? There is a significant difference between Cottage License and MECOS. Cool. Anything else? No. Any future agenda items? Yes, I'd like to have a little discussion, sort of an across-the-board election update, local, state, county, federal.
1:53:25 Impressions, no specific action, but just impressions of that. I'd also like to maybe have a discussion, if staff thinks it's appropriate on this solar stuff, because BLM, this came up at the SSRP, BLM has published a nationwide map of where they are saying it's okay to start, they're accepting applications for large-scale industrial solar, and there are tracks within the Eastern Sierra, our view corridor.
1:53:53 The landscape that makes us unique and makes us who we are, that's on that. And I would like to, I think, maybe start having a little bit of a conversation. There's some Inyo areas that are very problematic. And look, if LEDWP already owns the landscape and our financial bet going forward is there's no other place like this in the world, recreation opportunities, the scenic opportunities, this is what we are, and we start putting that kind of stuff all over the place.
1:54:22 That's going to be a problem. There's limited ability for the locals to enforce zoning. Is this cell tower? This is the cell tower universe. Well, if you're a municipality and you own, you don't have to get a building permit or follow zoning if you own something in another municipality. So those are the two. Okay. Any other future agenda items?
1:54:50 I would love for us to extend an invitation for one of those three members of the SBC that you mentioned to show up at our meeting. That would be great. That would be terrific. I mean, hopefully, laying these conversations with Chair Gardner, these things can get kind of worked out. I think it would be an interesting conversation to have with the small business center going in and SBC's presence in our region and things we're working on. It might be a nice thing to have a chat with them. Cool. Anything else?
1:55:20 If not, I will adjourn this meeting until our next regularly scheduled meeting to be held on December 13, 2024. At 1029. Where? Down in Bishop, 830. We figured that out. Yes. Okay, good. Okay. Thank you. Pleasure. Let us know about that bypass. I'd love to... Huh? Yeah, I get it right there.