Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
285 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:26 Just as a programming note, Councilmember Rae is ill and not able to join in person tonight, but she will be appearing remotely, which the Brown Act allows. This is the just cause authority to participate under government code section 54953E2A, somewhere F2A. So she will be joining us. No, Mayor, keep it on.
2:04 That's cute. Councilmember Rae? Here. Thank you. Councilmember Rice? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Here. Mayor Souser? Present. Thank you. And I've asked John to lead us in the pledge tonight. Okay, ready? Begin. Public comments. Now is the time any member of the public wishing to speak on anything that is not otherwise on the agenda. Hello, Council.
3:02 This is on. I'm Paul McFarlane, resident of Lee Vining, and I'm actually here to introduce myself to many of you who I've known for many years and worked with for many years and saw a meeting for the first time. I am a candidate for District 3 Supervisor for this year, for the March 5th election. And as many of you may know, District 3 runs from the top of Conway Summit down through the Mono Basin, Mono City, Lee Vining.
3:30 Through June Lake, down through the Owens River Headwaters, and here into Mammoth, and basically from the village all the way up to the mountain is within Mono's District 3. I'm excited to come back to Town Council. I've sat in here quite a bit, spoken quite a bit, worked with you on quite a bit of different issues. There's 2,500 folks in District 3. The majority of those live within the town boundary of Mammoth.
3:56 One of the things that I'm learning is going to be more and more important as I walk around the district and meet with people, and I've known for a long time, is that we're all one Mono family. The issues that are facing the town, as well as the county, are so entrenched and complicated, and they're also exceedingly expensive to move out of. The things that are facing us from housing, emergency preparedness, and economic vitality,
4:26 Aren't going to be solved if we stick within our jurisdictional boxes. We need to figure out how to work together effectively and efficiently. And I hope if I'm elected supervisor, I can help do that and see the county and the town work together more collaboratively to collectively solve these issues. We're at all hands on deck moment. We need to drop the boundaries and figure out how to work together as best we can.
4:53 I've given over two decades of service to this place on a number of levels, from a coach to a firefighter to an elected leader of our local public utility district. I've worked at the local, federal and state level on regulation and legislation. Through all of that work, the best thing that I've learned and the number one lesson I walk away with is the power of collaboration. And collaboration truly means
5:21 Losing your predetermined ideas, being truly willing to listen and recognize that you get so much more done with the public good when you work with others than you ever can alone. So with that said, thanks for all that you do. It's not easy sitting up there, but it's much appreciated by so many of us and look forward hopefully to working with you more as the next district supervisor for Mono County District 3. So thanks very much. Thank you, Paul.
5:50 Any other public comments? My name's Emily. I'm sure many of you have seen me up here talking about Nohawk Creek Mine, but I just wanted to thank the town council for taking some action on housing. I've been here six years. I've been through four apartments. I've lived in my car. My housing has never been secure, and it's been like a lot of people my age, and I speak on behalf of people in their 20s and 30s who contribute a lot to this town.
6:26 I'm thanking you guys for taking some action, and we really appreciate you trying to help us retain some housing security in this town. Thank you. Thank you. Any further public comments? Seeing none, we will move on to additions to the agenda for urgency items. Dan, do we have any? No additions this evening. Thank you. Thank you. We will now move on to reports from commissions and or departments as needed.
7:05 Rob Patterson, Admin Services Finance Director for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. I just wanted to give you a brief update on work going on with the SDR Advisory Committee. As you know, back early part of December, we sort of broke up into subcommittees focusing on three specific areas. Certified Properties, which is the division I'm leading, Review of Zoning, which Nolan has in Housing, and then the Carrots and Sticks Committee, which Dan is driving that one.
7:34 The committees have been working meeting primarily weekly to get through a lot of the topics. I know my crew has finished up as of today on the work that we want to do. The goal is all of these subcommittees will come together on the 11th of January in our next meeting and start to work through any final preparation for presentation to council. I will say that my group, we are putting together
8:02 Sort of individual packages to talk about specific sections. And I think I'm going to encourage everybody to do that same thing so we have just different elements to review and different elements to vote on. But the committees themselves, the larger subset, the full STR committee will be coming together on the 11th and we will have three meetings before the town council meeting on the 7th of February. So the goal will be to have a lot of that stuff wrapped up.
8:29 Every committee has been instructed to be ready to be finalized as a subcommittee by the 11th. So that's going very well. Any questions on that while I'm up here? Just one quick question. I'm assuming with the deadline we're working under that on the 11th, the committees are preparing things in writing. And so I think that would be in the agenda packet for the meeting on the 11th that will be publicly available? Yes. So I can speak for my subcommittee.
8:59 I will have all of the write-ups for the certified properties presented both to the larger committee as well as in writing for the agenda. The goal will be, I think the chairman is going to go through and say, you know, do we have any questions on that aspect and let's move forward so we can get to the discussion items that are going to be more spirited, if you will. But yes, that will be in writing. Just because I think for the larger public that's watching, if it's in the packets, then it's publicly available and everybody kind of knows what's happening. So that would be great. Thank you.
9:30 On a slightly less thrilling note, the audit is completed this year on time and early. If you remember last year, we had a new auditor, and they were delayed in getting stuff to us until the end of May. But they're actually prepared to send us the first draft here next week, and so we'll be well in advance of our deadlines to have that finalized. So excited about that process. Thank you. Thank you, Rob.
10:01 Hello, Nolan Bobrov, Acting Community and Economic Development Director. I just want to give you a quick update on the Innsbruck Lodge Affordable Housing Project. It's the project that Eastern Sierra Community Housing is doing in partnership with the town with the Home Key Grant. The original target occupancy date for that project was March of 2024 due to some delays.
10:25 They were anticipating that getting pushed out, and we did reach out to the state. We did receive notice this past week that we did receive an extension from the state. So their current schedule for that project is to deliver six of the 15 units, so that's five affordable units and one manager's unit by March of 2024, so within the original target deadline. Then the remaining nine units they're targeting for by the end of 2024.
10:53 And that delay is primarily related to the switchgear for the electrical panel. So all the work will be done. It will be wired. It's just waiting on that equipment, which is necessary to power all of the units. So the state was understanding of that delay due to the equipment, and they did give us that extension. A quick question. Who is the developer of that project? Is that the town project or is it Eastern Sierra Community Housing? Eastern Sierra Community Housing. They are the developer. Yes.
11:25 Thank you. Thank you, Nolan. Anyone else? Okay, looking at the other items on that, most of those are just for information. The monthly main base redevelopment update. Did you know air service? Affordable housing construction update. I believe you're going to give us an update on that, Amy. That's correct. But before we do that, I think Jen Murillo is on the line. Oh, okay. Only if needed. Thank you.
12:00 Hi there. Hi, Mayor and Councilmembers. I can be very brief. Thank you, Jen Rillo, Contract Planner for the Town. As you know, for the Maine Base Redevelopment Project, we're providing regular monthly updates to the Council and to the Planning and Economic Development Commission just due to the significance and size of this project. So since the last month update, we had a workshop. We had a workshop on November 29th.
12:27 And based on the feedback from that workshop, we will be working on scheduling some topic-focused conversations so we can really get into some particular areas of interest and kind of chip away at some of the key topics on the project. So we are planning on that. We will be working on scheduling those meetings next year, and we'll keep you up to date.
12:50 We are also preparing a summary from that workshop, and we will post that on the project's webpage. Additionally, we are scheduling a workshop with the Planning and Economic Development Commission on January 10th. That workshop should be focusing...
13:10 Material, presentation, information that you all heard last month. That's just going to give the commissioners who were unable to attend last month an opportunity to hear the presentation and provide their input.
13:25 Also, based on the Council's approval, the Town has submitted the request to Caltrans for the Relinquishment Assessment Report for State Route 203. So Town Public Works staff is in communication with Caltrans on that, getting more information about the process and the report itself. So again, on these monthly updates, we'll give you more information as we get it.
13:51 Otherwise, we'll keep you posted as meetings get scheduled next year, but the overall timeline is the same with the draft environmental analysis, the EIR, EIS being available toward the end of next year. So thank you very much. Questions? Yeah. Hi, Jen. So at a council workshop, I think you heard a fair amount of interest from the council about the establishment of a framework for the discussion of these topic items.
14:19 I'm wondering where that framework might be and when we can expect to see that. Oh, absolutely. So what we have right now is an agenda kind of schedule of topics that we're going through with our working group currently.
14:33 That information we can provide to the council at any time. It is fluid. You know, we continue to look at new topics as they arise. So we've kind of got an ongoing list of current topics we're discussing, and we'd be happy to provide that to you. We also talked about at the workshop the potential for having topics focused around the CEQA or environmental analysis categories as well. So that's another opportunity.
15:00 For future conversations. But I think what would be helpful now is to maybe provide you the information with our topics that we're discussing with the working group, because I think that can provide a framework for when we can move forward with meetings ahead of the environmental analysis being available. Okay. And is it appropriate for council members to attend any of these workshop meetings?
15:23 The working group meetings? Yes, we have talked about that. And I think that is absolutely an opportunity. We want to be cautious, of course, with Brown Act requirements. And at this stage, we feel like we're early, early on in the project right now that we are kind of having internal discussions with the applicant and town staff. But we do feel that there is an opportunity, yes, to involve council members. I'm just really concerned. This is the largest real estate development project in the history of the Eastern Sierra.
15:52 That's not hyperbole. This is, Bill, I mean, maybe you can, right? And I just, I think, I don't know, I hope I speak to my fellow council members. I think, you know, we're looking at a huge project coming forward with very little to date engagement by the council in any way. And I just want to express on behalf of all of us, we'd love to know what you guys are up to. We'd love to see that framework document. We've asked for it. We just really want to avoid a situation where
16:21 Things may be getting baked or things are getting out of sequence. Just as one council member, I'd very much like to see those documents. I'd like to see the agendas. And if this is appropriate to be brought into a meeting, I think many of us would love to attend just to listen and see what the tenor of the conversation is and what things are being discussed. One other question. Has Mono County been involved in this at all? Have you been giving any updates to the Board of Supervisors as to the progress on the project and what's happening with this project to the Mono County Board of Supervisors?
16:51 No, I don't believe this has been agendized on the Board of Supervisors' agenda as of yet. I know I think it came up with a joint meeting between the town and county on other discussions, maybe related to EIFD, but no, it has not. Yeah, I would think we didn't have a terribly productive conversation that last joint meeting between the council and the Board of Supervisors, and I think it's given the magnitude of this endeavor, I think, Dan, or I think...
17:19 Some outreach should be made to the county to at least make sure that they're aware of what's going on. They have, they're potentially a very significant beneficiary of this, and it's going to have real regional impact, and I think it would be a real oversight if we don't start bringing them into this in some way and in a timely fashion. So it might make sense. Thank you. Thank you. To tag on to what John said, my hope would be that the supervisors would take a large enough interest.
17:47 to come to us for those. We have not seen that yet, but that's my admonition for them for today. Thank you. Any other questions? All right. Thank you. So moving on. I didn't know we were going to have an in-person presentation there. So the air service, did you know? You've all looked that over. Do you have any questions? Monthly parcel affordable housing project construction update.
18:22 Thank you, Mayor Sauser, Councilmembers. I'm Amy Callanan, Engineering Manager. I will share my screen here. I've got some photos. A bit of a slideshow to go over with you. The parcel, just a quick recap. The parcel is our affordable housing project. Phase one of the parcel has been dubbed the Sawyer and contains 81 units in two buildings, and these will all be rental units at a...
19:14 Less than 80% AMI level. This phase of the project also contains a half-acre public park and then community space and a daycare facility within building A, which is the larger of the two buildings you see in the photo. These were, just to recap, the renderings that were approved of the project a couple years ago. And up top left corner is a progress photo from last month. And down on the bottom right was where the...
19:45 So this is where the buildings look today. So this is building A taken from the perspective of the extension of Tavern Road. We're looking at the child care facility and updates or progress since the update that you saw last month include the sun shades and paint on the building.
20:06 Multi-use path and pedestrian ramps have been constructed around the building. The rock has been installed on the exterior. That's a rock wainscote you see at the bottom. And our daycare playground has been installed. Here's a better look at our playground. And this is the playground for the two- to five-year-old daycare facility. The fence around the playground has not quite been finished yet.
20:33 Under those black and orange blankets is a concrete perimeter, and that will also receive a soft, like, pouring place, soft surface for the kids as well. Moving around the corner, again, you can see where we were last month, also on Building A from the perspective of the intersection of Tavern Road and the new Inyo Street. And so this at the ground floor is the community space with units above.
21:04 And you can see, again, that the siding has been completed and sunshades installed. The paint is complete. The sidewalks, again, have been constructed around the building and the exterior rock installed. A few other views here. This is building B. Again, this building B contains 15 units. It's a little bit more complete than building A at the moment. So all of the same.
21:35 So this is looking south from approximately from Center Street. And you can see we've got some construction vehicles parked in what is going to be a few public parking spaces. Just gives you an idea of what the neighborhood feels like. On the inside, I did mention that Building B is a little bit further along. They're working primarily on cleanup items.
22:17 All of the common areas, the hallways, corridors have been drywall painted and cleaned up. They do have some data cabling that still needs to be run in the ceilings after which you'll see that they'll hang the ceiling tiles. And after a bit more cleanup, they will install the vinyl flooring in the hallways. Building A, not quite as complete, but it's quite a bit larger.
22:45 They're working on drywall and texture, but you can see that some of the stick-framed areas, like the stairwell, are a lot more complete than they were about a month ago. Upcoming work, a big highlight will be when they get permanent power to the site.
23:09 A poll on the corner of the new Inyo Street and Center Street and then run the cabling. After they get permanent power, then they'll be able to commission the buildings, in particular, do the elevator and fire alarm testing and inspection. Building A, the community and the daycare spaces will receive a metal roof. The childcare and community space still have quite a bit of work to be done on the interior.
23:37 There is some site work, some joint trenching that needs to occur downtown Tavern Road in order to make the communications and fiber connection. So we will see that occurring probably after the holidays. And we'll work closely with the contractor and with our public works maintenance and snow removal crews to make sure that that trenching is safe even in case of a snow condition.
24:06 In the spring, we'll see the completion of more of the site work, including multi-use paths, the sidewalk connection to Center Street, landscaping, the rest of the park development, and street lights and bus shelters. Moving on, just real briefly to phase two, the Kingfisher will be 148 units in five buildings. This is situated at the northeast corner of the overall site.
24:37 It contains a central green space, and we have our completed tree removal in that area in anticipation of starting construction next year. And so here we are in Building B looking east towards this phase. You can see the trees for the site work and the buildings have been removed. We're happy to say that Phase 2.2 funding has been approved, that Phase 2.2 consists of the four
25:06 Three-story tuck-under buildings that front Inyo Street and Tavern Road. And we're still pending funding approval for Phase 2.1, which is the larger four-story podium building. But regardless, we are anticipating the contractor breaking ground in the spring and moving through grading, utilities, and potentially foundations next year. Any questions? Questions? John? You mentioned something about a project being funded.
25:39 Yes, I can. It kind of got our attention there. When does the fireworks show begin? We've been waiting for this forever. We got the award letters were sent to us today by Pacific for that. So that's for phase 2.2. We also got a reservation. They're doing some.
26:04 Creative refinancing to get funding for 2.2. So we also got an award letter of tax credit reservations for the Sawyer, which is one that's nearing completion. Because if they can get tax credit funding for that, it could free up some of the housing accelerator funds that originally funded that project, which they're working with HCD to try to move that to fund 2.1.
26:29 That'll likely be kind of ongoing in the first quarter of 2024, but we're hoping to get notification of that, and then they'll also pursue some additional tax credit financing for the gap on 2.1. That'll be there that exists between what they can get from Housing Accelerator and other sources to fund 2.1. So they're hopeful that the entire Phase 2 will be funded in the first quarter of 2024, but we do have confirmation of 2.2 being funded.
26:59 Just saying. Congratulations. Congratulations. Thank you. Yeah, fireworks were mentioned. I think it's a really big deal. How many units are we talking about if the whole phase two goes forward? 148 units total. Additional? For phase two. Okay. I have nothing more to say. And how many of those are in 2.2? I missed it when Amy said. I believe it's...
27:27 76 units in 2.2. Okay, great. Progress, progress. One quick question. I'm always reading these income tables because when I try to talk to real people about real housing things, I want to make sure I'm representing things correctly. So is it correct that for one person in Mono County, 80% of AMI is 47,600? These tables are tricky because, you know, they're ranges.
27:59 Doesn't it? But I looked in the two places, the state and the federal. You don't have to answer right this second, but I really want to get super clear on that because I'm now talking to anyone who will listen that has a housing struggle about our parcel, but I also don't want somebody to get excited and then find out they don't qualify. So wherever possible, I would just really appreciate having just a quick one-pager even because I sat with three
28:28 Friends the other night, all of whom are housing challenged, and they all have such different situations that I realized, like, we gotta start to talk about this with real people and real case studies, so I would appreciate that. And Amy, did the, when I saw the playground, I realized that that's the tree where the bear lives. Is he, is Fred gone, or is he still? As far as I know, Jeff the bear is still very much around. I thought his name was Fred. Jeff's there. Okay. Jeff the bear. I haven't seen him myself in a while, but.
29:01 Okay. Thank you. Okay. Are we still on schedule in phase one for a March occupancy? It's end of March, as far as I know, has been the target. I have not heard anything different. Thank you. The critical path over the course of the last several months has been connecting to the permanent power. And while that did get pushed a little bit from original estimates, it's...
29:38 It is happening at the beginning of January, and as far as I still know, if there's... Okay. You know, it might be, on what Chris says, it might be helpful at some point in an update to look at exactly what the qualifications are going to be. That is, besides income, is there a live in the area, a work in the area, and I know we've had all of that before, but a refresher might be a good thing. Along with...
30:07 We're all thinking 80% of AMI, but in actuality, they have to achieve a, what is it, a 60% average? So a lot of them have to be rented to people making significantly under. So to know what that means in terms of number of units without me having to try to do the math, after all, I am a Levining High graduate. Thank you. Sure. I was going to say a few additional pieces to talk on to Amy's. We did get an update on the wait list for not even phase one.
30:37 Who's on the wait list currently as of today is 760 people on that wait list. They're not necessarily income qualifying all those when they're getting on the wait list, but that's the current number. They anticipate beginning to reach out to those at the end of January, early February. Again, it ties back to that projecting to the end of March and going backwards 60 to 90 days because they don't want to qualify people too early because then if their situation changes before occupancy, it could...
31:06 So they anticipate probably going in blocks of people, blocks for about 50 people as they start to qualify people working down that list they'll begin reaching out to. And they also said that the Facebook page for the Sawyer is expected to be updated today or tomorrow with updated construction photos and details. Chris? No, John first. John.
31:39 I think, Bill, to your point, I think it's going to be very helpful as people start applying and they go through that process. And this question of the AMI levels, we do have a microinflation thing going on with wage inflation here in the town, with the ski area, you know, bumping up their lower wage tiers. I think it's going to be very important to start getting that information back to us so we can start making decisions about where to start investing.
32:06 If the missing middle is all of a sudden going to come way down here, we need to start thinking about where to make our investments going forward. And I think it's also important to be talking to Pacific. My understanding, and I know it's a complicated document, Pacific has some kind of a first right of refusal or something like that, that if we have to make an adjustment to say, look, we don't need 500 units of 60 or below AMI housing, we're going to need to really start
32:33 Spreading out our portfolio. So I think getting that kind of feedback is going to be really helpful for all of us to start making decisions about where to start making our investments. It's a down-the-road kind of a question, but I think we need to start tracking that pretty closely. Thanks for that idea, Bill. Chris? Nolan, you also said that the list is 760 people. For the longest time, it had 400-ish people. So what changed? I'm not sure what caused the massive jump from when they were here, I think that was two months ago, to now.
33:02 It's just more outreach, more interest, but yes, it was when they were here, I believe that in September, it was about 450, and as of today, they said 760. Great, and then one last thing, I know Mammoth Lakes, oh, Eastern Sierra Community Housing has their own list. Is there any way we could see if they could compare the list? Because I would just be so curious to understand, you know, is this...
33:31 Tracking, are they the same people? They're just, it feels like there's information out there that would be beneficial for us all to know, and it just would take a couple steps, but I think it would be really valuable. I don't think that Eastern Sierra Community Housing, their list is anywhere near the 760 on the parcel. I think that we have a list of maybe fewer than 20. Oh, is that? Okay.
34:00 I thought it used to be in the hundreds. I could be wrong. I could be wrong, but I think that, like, they're current. Nobody knows. So let's figure it out, and we don't have to do it tonight. They have a group that they've qualified, unqualified. Then they do have just an interest list that was similar, again, unqualified also. And my guess is there probably is a fair amount of overlap as people are looking for housing and getting on lists accordingly, wherever they can, to begin looking at housing. And I also know that several people in existing units are putting their names in for the parcel,
34:30 Sure. You know, wherever we can rationalize things and just better understand who these folks are, I think will help us a lot. And then I guess I had a question about are we trying to get any data about, you know, people on the list? We talked with Buckingham about that, you know, what their living situation is now, you know, if the unit that they would be moving out of.
34:57 If it's their vehicle, you know, that's not going to open up for anybody else, but what sort of, you know, unit they're in. And then I think, Chris, you had mentioned, you know, letting people know kind of where they are on the wait list. Are we planning on asking or, you know, requiring them to do those things or? My understanding is Buckingham has said they would request, you know, what we're moving out of and provide that kind of best they can. And then as far as providing where people are at on the wait list and follow up, I know before they,
35:30 We don't generally do that. The wait list management, we can ask if that's something they could do, at least give a ballpark range, are you in the deep second, whatever we can ask if that's something. They were willing to do it. They said that they could do it by like large. My remembrance is that what they said was they won't start the process until three months out at the most before they start looking at this. The frustrating part of that is while there are 760 on that list,
36:04 Part of that original 400 have been there for a couple of years. We don't even know how many of them are still living in town, let alone if they qualify. So we really have no idea what the number is, which is frustrating, and I believe we have all expressed that before, that there should be some way for them to vet at least some of the list beforehand so we know what we're dealing with. I think part of that is what they've said. They typically don't open up the wait list as there is.
36:34 Did for this project on most projects here just because of the sheer interest in new housing. They started the way it was much earlier than they normally do, which generated the interest in people getting on it for multiple years versus other projects where they might only open it up six months, nine months out. Any other questions here? No, I mean, I don't think so. I think 300 people in a couple months. Since this is such an important issue, do we have public comment?
37:05 Not that every issue isn't important. Do we have any public comment from the audience on this? Do we have any online public comment? Okay, very good. Thanks, guys. Moving on then to 5.4, receive the notification that application for an amendment to the Snow Creek Development Agreement has been submitted. At this point, as I understand it, this is just a formality and it's not the actual application. I have expressed that I would love to see, Nolan, what they have...
37:36 Presented to you. I would love for you to send that to all of Council so that we can have a look at in advance. Other than that, unless some of you have questions. I think it's with the point you made about clarifying that this is just a formality. We're not taking any action on anything, but thank you for asking to share that with everybody. We appreciate it. Okay. Very good. Moving on then to item 6.1.
38:05 Inyo Mono Broadband Consortium Update on Regional Broadband Activities. Scott Armstrong is going to be our presenter here, right up on the screen. Good evening, Mr. Mayor and Councilmembers. My name is Scott Armstrong. I'm the Regional Broadband Coordinator working for the SCOG. I'm an employee of Inyo County in case you see my email address and it surprises anybody. So I'm going to give a presentation today that is essentially...
38:36 Similar to the updates I try to give, and I want to highlight one section of my presentation, which is my public outreach and engagement effort. So I'll talk to grants, the state's minimum broadband initiative, work plan updates, outreach engagement, briefly touch on the Mono County broadband strategic plan, other activities, and then got acronyms for reference. So going through the regular list of updates,
39:05 The grant that covers the IMBC, which is me, grant year one ends the end of January, so I'm working on the second semi-annual reporting and audit work at the moment. The federal funding account grant, which awarded the town of Mammoth Lakes, one of the grants, also the county of Mono, those are in process, are in progress right now. The challenge process timeline is...
39:35 I believe, and now there's a rebuttal timeline for that. The grants applied for, the grants that were awarded to both the county and the town were challenged, and Golden State Connect Authority, which is the joint powers authority that RCRC set up, is going to be responding to those, and based on what I've seen, we shouldn't have an issue getting those projects funded.
40:05 Let's see, the big news is the awards are going to be expected. We're expecting awards for notifications in January. So that means that CPUC is currently busy evaluating the grant applications. And we're expecting a second application window in 2024. And I don't recall exactly how much funding was requested for the region, the Mona County region.
40:31 Which covers both the town and the county's applications. But we'll have enough to probably pick off another small area. So the local agency technical assistance grants, which is funding design work for the locations that were submitted for FFA applications, is still underway. They're doing the low-level design work. And I don't recall whether it was going to be this week or next week, but...
40:57 Tilson Technologies, working for GSCA, is going to be flying drones to do some measuring using LIDAR. And the INEO grants, LADA grants are in progress as well. We're going through, we're going to have four phases of those. So B, the NTIA's Broadband Equity Access and Deployment Grant that they award to states is going, it's a multi-path
41:28 Set of activities that are going on and NTI, or excuse me, the state submitted its five-year plan to NTIA in August. They submitted its first plan to NTIA. It was before the end of November, I believe. Initial comments are done and now they're working on the final draft.
41:54 And they also recently submitted, the state also recently submitted their broadband equity, what is it, let me check my notes, broadband digital equity plan. So, and that comments are due at the end of January. So, and they'll take public comments on that. So I can provide a link. There are links to those at the website that I'll point out as well. So the.
42:28 Annual CASF Infrastructure Grant. The next window is not yet open. We're expecting that to open in the next few weeks and is expected to close April 1st. This is the one that was delayed last year until I think June. I want to highlight this one because local governments can apply for this and it also allows for fixed wireless connectivity for last mile service delivery, which the FFA grants don't. So some areas that we have that just don't have enough people.
42:57 To provide the incentive for a company to connect, may want to look at something like this. Also, not necessarily related to the town, but the county of Mono got a USDA Rural Development Grant to do design work in Hamill, and Inyo County got one to do design work in Furnace Creek. This is similar to the local agency technical assistance grant as well. And also, I've been asked not to make a lot of noise about this yet, so no... No...
43:29 Fresh releases on this. We signed our letters of cooperative agreements and things on December 5th to those moving forward. Middle Mile Broadband Initiative, not a whole lot new. I think this has been the same information for a couple of months now. The state is planning on building all the initial 10,000 plus miles within, I guess now it's about the next 15 months. And the Middle Mile Broadband Initiative is in the...
43:57 The initiative will include the purchase of Digital 395 Network, the asset purchase agreements been signed. In order for that APA to close, it requires an NTIA waiver because it was NTIA funded, membership approval, which will count in January, and Class A membership approval, which is the county board, so Kern and Illinois counties. And I'll be talking with them probably toward the end of January about that.
44:26 Work plan updates. I won't go into each of these in order to save some time, but we have service issue escalation tools incoming. I got a couple of the providers a little bit touchy on this one. There's been one of these on the Mona County website for about a year and a half now, maybe two years. I think it was 2021 when they put one together because of issues with Suddenlink. So we'll have escalation tools for Frontier, Suddenlink, excuse me, Optimum now.
44:56 Race Communications, and SHOT. I think SHOT has service up in Mono County. I also updated some of the unserved data, the project areas with unserved data from the CPUC sites. So if you're interested, you can get an idea of how many locations we have, what the population of those areas are, and some other details in an effort to make it easier for us to identify the next priorities for the areas to get done.
45:28 Hold on just a second. Sorry about that. I got a cough here. Sorry. I'm not there in person for a reason. All right. Back to the presentation. Okay. So unserved data. I added a resources page. One of the requirements for the bead challenge process is speed test reporting through approved speed test sites. And I've got those updated on the website, on the Connected Eastern Sierra website as well.
46:33 So this is the one I wanted to spend a minute or two on, and I'll take you to this page in a minute. Additionally, the main point of this is to get more public input, reach out to the public and to the boards and councils, and give them a way to reach out to connect with me a much easier way. And this link will take us to a page that will allow you to tell us.
47:03 What you're getting for service or what you're paying for service, where you live, if it's enough, what providers you have. And this is information that will be helpful for me and for the councils and the boards to identify which regions really need some work, you know, which ones aren't getting services that need. I'll just have some quick links to other pages with input options, things that they need to do and things they need to look at.
47:33 I'm also asking for information, just what they feel. And so I'm asking where they think the next projects need to be. I'm asking them where they live because that's going to be priority one, but I want to make sure that they understand that we get it. Where you live is important, but what else do you think is important? So I'll be looking at priorities two through five that they submit and I'll bring that to boards and councils and we'll talk about that. Additionally, I've got a place for you to sign up.
48:03 For a broadband newsletter, which I'm going to start in a couple of weeks. And I'll let you all know by email, but I will probably sign up all of the board members and council members myself to give me an opportunity to get information to you more frequently than every couple of months. So I've got some interactive graphs that I want to highlight. This is in the speed test page.
48:41 Click the link to submit your speed test. It'll take you to this page. A lot of information is here, and I can see that it's going to get really, really ugly for a while. You can hover over the provider and get an idea of what speeds they're offering. You can also click on one to delete it. So Frontier in Bishop has some pretty good service because it's all brand new and it's fiber in the home. So when you take that away, these are some other options for those who don't have Frontier fiber.
49:09 So I just wanted to point that out as well. It's useful information and just give people an idea where they may want to connect to. So for Mono and Town of Mammoth Lakes, I'm working on a broadband strategic plan. I'm working with public works departments from each as well as the IT department. We're working on a roadmap for Mono County to improve internet access. And this will be something that we can use as a
49:40 A plan that's on the shelf and actually usable. And our goal is to have this end up being about, you know, less than 20 pages. We don't need anything that's going to sit on the shelf and look like dust. There are a lot of things that are assumed and understood. We don't need to rehash. But essentially, it'll recommend strategies to overcome the challenges that we know. It's based on the Pew Charitable Trust. I think I might have mentioned that before. It has participation both in the county and the town.
50:08 We've already put together a problem statement and we're currently in the process of gathering data. The data that we're collecting includes both service provider data and speed test data that we can get from one of the major speed tests. Other activities, I participated in a CPUCB workshop in October and I was involved in talking through the challenge process, provided some input.
50:38 Based on our unique conditions in the Eastern Sierra, a lot of area, a lot of mountains, a lot of trees, and not a whole lot of people. And then acronyms as well. So with that, I would like to stop the share and answer any questions that you might have. I guess, you know, this is just to help us get better internet and maybe expand the service providers with this.
51:15 Because it's my understanding that, you know, most of Mammoth can't use digital 395. Is that right? They can if a provider brings it out into the neighborhoods. So digital 395 is what, I mean, race communications goes back to the digital 395 network. I don't know if Optimum uses or where Optimum connects, but they also use a lot of the digital 395 bandwidth or the route.
51:47 I think Frontier has their own fiber backbone, but most of the carriers, including the cellular carriers, do take advantage of Digital 395. But it's not a direct connection. So Digital 395 doesn't necessarily connect homes. It allows an internet service provider to connect and then provide services to others. Okay, thanks. I mean, I guess I thought that really only Frontier and Optimum.
52:15 Are the internet providers for houses or condos in the town of Mammoth Lakes? Is that correct? Currently, yes. And the FFA application that went in will connect back to the middle mile, to the digital 395 middle mile. So assuming we get some areas in Mammoth Lakes and up in the lakes area, those will be going through the digital 395 network. Thanks. You're welcome.
52:50 Thanks, Scott. You know, I've never asked you this at ESCOG, but my understanding is that the Middle Mile projects that were approved in the last state budget were mostly in the Central Valley, and then we didn't get awarded any money here, correct? For new construction, that's correct. And the reasoning behind that is that they're going to purchase the Digital 395 Network and make it part of theirs.
53:20 If you have a moment, I can give you an idea of where they're going to build. Just take a second here. In our area? Maps. So I think they're going to extend out from Digital 395 into some of the areas. So let's zoom in. So this green is Digital 395, and they're planning to build out beyond Mammoth? Yeah, we can't see your screen. You need to share your screen again, Scott. Oh, I forgot to share again.
53:58 I was looking really good to me. I was imagining it. Yeah. Okay. So the green lines are the digital 395 that the state's going to purchase. The orangish line is what they're planning to construct. So they're planning to construct from June where they end in June Lake out to the resort area and those areas.
54:25 There's not a lot of construction since they've got all of this. So nothing in town or Mammoth Lakes? Yeah, not directly through town. But the FFA grant does show the path from Digital 395 into the areas in town they want to cover. Down in New York County, they're planning on doing a loop that goes out through Death Valley. But that's the only construction in the area. So all the green is the existing Digital 395 network. Thank you.
54:56 You're welcome. So if we want to complete to town of Mammoth Lakes, we have to apply next year. Well, I think there's a map on the states. So there's a broadbandportal.cpuc.ca.gov. Let me reshare again. I think somebody's hoping to leave early tonight, so I hope I don't slow them down. But let me show you this portal.
55:36 The broadband portal gives you a look at the public applications that are there. Type in the county name and you can go to that and it's kind of finicky. And you know what, Scott, I'll follow up with you separately, but I would like to make sure that we're like staying on the radar because I'm getting increasingly jealous of my rural friends in other parts of the state who are getting their middle mile. So let's just, we can get in touch with this through ESCOG, but thank you. Okay.
56:10 And that site's not working at the moment, so I don't know what the issue is. But there are maps of the areas in town of Mammoth Lakes that are in that application. No, I'm good. Thank you, Scott. I owe you a couple emails, but thank you very much. Oh, that's all right. It's my pleasure. Thank you very much for your time. Don't go away, Scott. Let's make sure we have no public comment on this. Seeing none, you're good. Thanks. Okay, great. Have a nice evening and see you next year. Yep.
56:45 Thank you. Okay, moving on now to consent. 7.1, approve the minutes of the special meeting of November 29. 7.2, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of December 6. 7.3, receive and file the Snow Creek Development Agreement Annual Review Report, finding the developer in good faith substantial compliance with the terms and conditions of the DA. 7.4, accept the project closeout report for the 2023 Emergency Facility Repair Project.
57:16 7.5, accept the project closeout report for HSIP 203 crosswalks project. 7.6, approve the resolution authorizing the purchase of property located at 1629 Majestic Pines Drive. 7.7, approve the resolution authorizing the purchase of the property located at 449 Sierra Manor Road. 7.8, approve the resolution authorizing the purchase of the vacant real property located...
57:43 At 362 Chaparral Road, 7.9, approve the resolution authorizing the sale of the property at 550 Mono Street, 7.10, approve the request for public convenience or necessity letter from Mammoth Lakes Town Council in support of the 70 action application for a type 40 on sale beer license from the ABC.
58:10 7.11, adopt a resolution approving the physical year 22-23 development impact fee report making finding that there remains a reasonable relationship for the fee program 7.12, accept check register 12-6-23. Does anybody wish to pull anything from consent? No, no. Seeing not, I would take a motion, not an e-motion, but a motion.
58:38 I move to approve the consent agenda as read. I second. I have a motion and a second. Jamie, please. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser. Yes, got it. Thank you. Moving on then to item 8.1, waive the reading and introduce by title only.
59:10 The attached ordinance to adopt a single-use plastic water prohibition. Pam. Thank you, Mayor Sauser. Good evening, members of the council. I'm Pam Kobylarz, assistant to the town manager. The town council previously requested that staff bring forward a prohibition on single-use plastic water bottles. In May of this year, the council discussed a number of policy questions regarding a potential prohibition and provided a wide variety of feedback.
59:38 To staff with direction to bring back an ordinance. So here we are. To determine the recommended scope and implementation time frame for the proposed single-use plastic water bottle ban, staff took into account the feedback from council, existing prohibitions throughout California, input from our counterparts in South Lake Tahoe and the town of Truckee, current and future town resources, existing and future state mandates,
1:00:07 And other considerations to ensure the best chance of success. Excuse me. I've been battling the mammoth crud for a few weeks here now, so pardon me if I have to clear my throat throughout the presentation. A little bit of background on other plastic water bottle prohibitions throughout California, and this is by no means meant to be exhaustive, but based on the research that staff did, there's a handful of cities within the state that prohibit single-use plastic water bottles.
1:00:39 From being distributed at city events and from being purchased with city funds. The cities that we found, most of the cities that we found that have that don't currently have commercial prohibitions on plastic water bottles. Both LAX Airport and San Francisco Airport have prohibitions on the sale of all plastic water bottles. And then in South Lake Tahoe and Truckee, they've both established a number of prohibitions. I'm going to go into some more details.
1:01:07 On what those two cities have done, since they're kind of our counterparts. So a little bit of background, starting with South Lake Tahoe. Staff met with the sustainability coordinator for the city of South Lake Tahoe, and that position is relatively new. It was created in response to the city's climate action plan. South Lake Tahoe's strategic plan addressed a plastic water bottle ban, and that's what enabled staff to be able to prioritize it as part of their work program.
1:01:37 South Lake Tahoe adopted and implemented its single-use plastics ban over a number of phases. It started in 2018 when the council adopted their styrofoam ban. Similar to Mammoth, they prohibited styrofoam food containers, but theirs went a little bit further, and they also prohibit the sale of things such as coolers, packing peanuts, and other styrofoam products.
1:02:04 In October of 2022, their council adopted the commercial ban on plastic water bottles and the municipal ban. That was phased as it went into effect. The municipal ban went into effect in April of this year. And when I say municipal ban, I mean being prohibited from city events and prohibited from using town funds to purchase those items. The commercial ban is currently slated to be effective in April of 2024.
1:02:32 So that is not currently in effect. South Lake Tahoe has been working to develop a substantial water refill station program prior to the implementation of its commercial ban. And the Drink Tahoe Tap initiative was also already in existence prior to their adopting their ban. The Drink Tahoe Tap initiative is an initiative throughout the Tahoe Basin that encourages visitors and residents to drink tap water rather than to purchase water in bottles.
1:03:02 South Lake Tahoe has one staff position dedicated to sustainability initiatives, as well as their partnership with Keep Tahoe Blue, which is an advocacy group, and it has resources available to help with outreach and education, as well as data collection and other things that can help support their initiative. In total, from the initial adoption of the styrofoam ban by the council in South Lake Tahoe to when their commercial
1:03:32 Prohibition on plastic water bottles will be effective. It will have been approximately six years for that process to be fully implemented. Moving on to the town of Truckee, and Andy, please correct me if I misstate any facts here. Town staff met with a sustainability program manager for the town of Truckee, which is also a relatively new position that was created earlier this year. And Truckee also has two sustainability
1:04:01 Analyst, or two analyst positions in their sustainability division. They adopted their single-use foodware reduction ordinance in 2021, which, similar to us, prohibited the styrofoam takeout containers. They included a few other things that we didn't do, such as charging a fee for disposable takeout containers. And the way that Truckee has addressed
1:04:27 Their municipal ban was through an internal policy that prohibits the town from purchasing and using single-use plastic water bottles. It's not part of their municipal code, so therefore it's not enforceable by citation like the municipal code would be. So far, the Truckee Town Attorney is meant to be looking at a draft of an ordinance. They'll go to council next month. I'm getting to that, yes. So they are working on a commercial ban as well.
1:04:55 It is expected, at least as of the last time I spoke to my Truckee contact, to be presented at their January 9th town council, right? They've taken the approach of conducting outreach prior to the adoption of any ordinance. So they put together a stakeholder committee, put together some community surveys, and they want to make sure that they understand the potential impacts of a prohibition prior to adoption so that those potential impacts can be incorporated into that.
1:05:26 Municipal Code Language when it's adopted. They also recently launched a water refill station grant program to support these efforts. And they want to ensure that they have community buy-in and that issues are addressed, like I stated. Their lessons learned through their research that they conducted through their process has been included finding that a long-term implementation time frame is important and working with businesses from the beginning will be critical to the success of a future ordinance.
1:05:56 Did I miss anything on that, Andy? Thank you. As you know, there are a number of state mandates that we're currently required to be in compliance with regarding recycling and diversion from our landfills of various different types of waste. Not going to go into detail on those. I know that I've presented these to you several times previously. But just to state that
1:06:22 A lot of staff resources are dedicated to ensuring that we're in compliance with these. I did want to briefly touch on the styrofoam prohibition that we adopted earlier this year. So while it's not a state mandate, it is now a town mandate because it is part of our municipal code. That was adopted by the council in July, and it will go into effect on January 1st of 2024.
1:06:47 The prohibition, just to remind you, will be on takeout food containers from any restaurant or food provider. We've had approximately five months from the adoption of that ordinance to the effective date, and we've recently begun the outreach for this. I don't think I brought them up, but we have some postcards in the back of the room. We've also created flyers, both in Spanish and English, for this outreach.
1:07:14 Kendra, the Sustainability Coordinator for Mammoth Disposal, has been going to the Restaurant Association and going around to the businesses to make sure that businesses are aware of this prior to its implementation. A few other considerations that we took into effect through this process. One is the California Redemption Value, or the CRV program. I'm sure you're all familiar with that. You take your bottles and your cans into the buyback center at Mammoth Disposal, and they give you money for it.
1:07:45 No definitive conclusions, but just anecdotally speaking to residents, a lot of our citizens do rely on the CRV redemption program to help supplement their income, as well as high school students use it to help support their athletic teams. And the majority of the items that are redeemed for CRV, again, anecdotally, are plastic number ones, which are what the single-use plastic water bottles are made out of.
1:08:14 Mammoth Disposal Buyback Center for the month of 2023 provided us with some data that was included in your report. They averaged approximately 2,083 pounds of number one plastic. The majority, just based on visual inspections, was comprised of the small water bottles. Mammoth Disposal doesn't collect specific data on what percentage of the number one plastics are water bottles. But again, visual inspections at certain point...
1:08:44 And time indicated that perhaps approximately 70% of the number one plastics were plastic water bottles of the smaller size. Additionally, in regards to CRB, there's going to be some major changes to the program going into effect on January 1st. I think Kendra attends a webinar on this daily pretty much to learn about how this program is, what we're going to need to do locally in order to be in compliance with that. But part of the program means that
1:09:13 People will be eligible to collect CRV on new things that weren't previously eligible, such as wine bottles, liquor bottles, the boxed wine with the bladders inside. So really all of that to say that prohibiting the sales of plastic water bottles will impact residents and it will impact the CRV program, but we just don't really know exactly what those impacts will be, particularly with all of the new regulations coming online in the CRV program.
1:09:43 So it's just something that we're going to need to put more analysis into and be cognizant of as we go through our process. And one other input was reaching out to CalFresh staff. CalFresh is a statewide program for low-income residents to help them include healthy and nutritious food in their households. CalFresh didn't have significant concerns with the idea of a plastic water bottle prohibition.
1:10:14 But they did state that a number of underserved school kids bring those water bottles to school as their water bottles, and they want to make sure that if there was a prohibition, those students would still have easy ways to be able to bring water to school. It's something that we're just going to need to work closely with CalFresh on and be thoughtful in our approach as we move forward with implementation of a potential prohibition.
1:10:40 We want to make sure that underserved and disadvantaged community members aren't negatively impacted by any decision that we make. Following a similar path forward to South Lake Tahoe and Truckee, town staff believes that having a robust water refill station throughout town will be critical to the success of any program that we choose to implement. We've already started working on this initiative. We received a $5,000 grant from CalRecycle, and we recently purchased five water refill stations that will be installed at...
1:11:10 Businesses and town facilities throughout town. And we're getting ready to apply for an additional $5,000 in funding for the next calendar year. Additionally, we had applied for some EPA grant funding for a much more robust water refill station program, but we weren't awarded that grant. Staff recommends that council support development and implementation of a town-wide water refill station program prior to implementation of a plastic water bottle prohibition.
1:11:40 So moving on to our recommended prohibition. Staff took into account the lessons learned. And just looking at some of the state mandates, for example, we've seen where the systems and the resources weren't in place to ensure the success of those mandates. And now cities and jurisdictions are having a difficult time implementing and complying with them. And we don't want to make those same mistakes. We've also taken into account the
1:12:09 The existing and future mandates, staff resources that will be necessary to ensure compliance with those, as well as staff enforcement capacity. We want to make sure that anything that we choose to adopt will be successful. So based on that, my recommendation is a three-phased approach to the single-use plastics prohibition. The first phase has already been adopted by the town council, and that was the adoption of the styrofoam food containers.
1:12:39 Which, as I mentioned, will go into effect very shortly here on January 1st. The second proposed phase would be the prohibition use and sales of distribution of single-use plastic water bottles less than 500 milliliters at town-affiliated events, including events that require a special use permit from the town. So that would be pretty much all of the larger events that take place in town require a special event permit.
1:13:05 As written, the prohibition is proposed to go into effect on January 1st, which would allow staff approximately one year to put into place all the regulations that would be needed in order to make sure that's effective and successful. The third phase of the prohibition would be the commercial ban. That's proposed to go into effect on January 1st, 2027. Again, for the 500 milliliter or less sized water bottles.
1:13:33 And that would allow sufficient time to conduct the necessary outreach as well as for businesses to make their operational changes that they would need to implement the change and to ensure that we can set up an adequate water refill station program throughout town. With that, I would like to make my recommendation. I have three steps to my recommendation. So I would recommend that staff...
1:13:58 That Town Council direct staff to develop a town-wide water refill station program prior to the implementation of the plastic water bottle prohibition, direct staff to develop an outreach and education program for the plastic water bottle prohibition, and waive the reading and introduce the attached ordinance by title only to adopt a single-use plastic water bottle prohibition. I'm happy to answer any questions that you might have. Thank you. Any questions for Pam? Sarah, let's start with you.
1:14:31 I think you're muted. Thanks, sorry. I have no questions. I would wait to comment. Thank you. Thank you. Chris? We do questions, then public comment, then we deliberate. So we haven't received any public comment from this other than the representative of the Girls' Association, correct? I didn't get any letters or anything. Okay. Just making sure.
1:15:12 So I am curious why, you know, we landed on three years for this ordinance to go into effect. To me, that seems unnecessary. I realize that, you know, Truckee and Southlake took longer, but they were way out ahead of the curve. And so I just, could you like sort of talk a little bit more about the rationale for why it's three years? That just feels long to me.
1:15:40 Sure, no problem. It really comes down to our staff resources, which the amount of resources that we have dedicated to be able to implement this effort is pretty limited. It's a percentage of my position, and it's a percentage of Kendra, who's not actually a town employee, but we work very closely. We also want to make sure that whatever we put into place, we have the resources to be able to enforce, so taking those resources into effect as well.
1:16:09 As I mentioned, the first phase, the municipal ban, there would be a number of things. I know it sounds easy, but we would have to update our special event permit language. We want to make sure that we get information out to all of our special event operators and so that they have the time necessary to be able to comply with that when it goes into effect as well. So we would want to make sure that we have that first year to really focus our efforts on making that first phase successful.
1:16:37 Before we really have the resources to be able to focus on the education and outreach needed for the commercial portion of proposed ban. Just as Truckee did all of their research and outreach ahead of time prior to adopting anything, that's not really taken into account in their time frame. And what I mean is that when they adopt a prohibition, it's not going to be effective immediately. There will still be an additional information.
1:17:07 Thanks.
1:17:39 So those are really all the factors that we took into account. I want to be realistic with what we're able to successfully implement, and I want whatever we adopt to be successful. So that is why I'm making the recommendation. OK, thank you.
1:18:01 Quick question for staff. You know, we've been talking about this for a long time. I'm pretty sure Councilmember Rae started talking about this when she was first elected, and she's at the end of her term. So I guess my frustration is, like, this isn't new. So it's something we could have been doing in parallel. And I just really want to make that point because, you know, we talk to our visitors about stewardship and all the things we care about.
1:18:27 I think that it's really important as a town that we live our values and push harder on some of these issues. So that is my appeal to staff and my colleagues. I was pretty shocked to see that it was three years for implementation. That just seems excessive to me. So with that, I will see if anyone else has any other questions. I guess sort of a question about the I'm going to get them.
1:18:58 I think the word's wrong, but is it CalFresh? They're concerned with school-aged children bringing these water bottles to school. I guess I know that elementary school has water bottle refilling stations. You know, I feel like we could do some outreach or, you know, like water bottles of Mammoth's Finest and give them to all the school kids in town or...
1:19:24 You know, I could see like at events, Blueza Palooza and things like that, having water refilling stations and having these town water bottles that are pushing Mammoth's Finest. So I guess my question is kind of how do we encourage our guests? Because I think most of us all drink Mammoth's Finest because it's great. But how do we encourage our guests to drink the tap water? Sure. And I think that was kind of two questions. One was about the school kids and really.
1:19:54 The CalFresh input is, that's just what they're seeing. So whether there are alternatives or not, what they're seeing now is that a lot of the more underprivileged children are bringing the plastic water bottle. Certainly that's something that we would want to address as part of our outreach. But you have kids, you know they lose things. Just a matter of handing water bottles out to kids isn't going to guarantee that they're going to be able to water bottles to school every day. And definitely part of our outreach would want to be encouraging people to drink Mammoth Tap.
1:20:26 Tahoe has their Drink Tahoe Tap initiative already. That's been in place for a number of years. So that was another resource that both Truckee and South Lake had access to prior to adoption of their prohibitions. And we just don't have that in place right now. So that would be an initiative that we would need to develop. And it will take time and resources to do that. No questions. I have a couple of questions. Water refill stations. It sounds great for those who carry their own water bottles around.
1:21:03 A lot of the people that I see walking around our town have no place for those water bottles. That's fine. We live in freezing temperatures. How much do the outside cost? What does it cost us to hook them up? And then what does it cost us to heat them to the point that they don't freeze and break and have to be replaced on an annual basis? These are all things I fear for the cost of this program taking away from other programs that I view as more important at this point. And staff time.
1:21:33 What kind of allocations are we looking at? Where are we going to have to pull money from in order to pull this off? You're absolutely right. All of those are factors that will need to take into place, especially maintenance of those facilities once we install them. And that's just research that we haven't had time to finish yet. So as part of my recommendations, I did recommend that the council direct staff to develop this program of the water refill stations.
1:22:02 Through development of that program, that's when we would have this data and information and bring it back to you. Of course, before I would want to push that forward, I would want some security that the cost isn't going to be so overbearing that it costs us a lot of other things. And just to also add that, of course, any significant cost would be something that council would need to approve in the future. So really, right now, what we're just asking for is development of the program, gathering that additional information. So that would be like...
1:22:30 What are the recommended placement of these? How many outdoor water refill stations versus indoor water refill stations do we think we should place throughout town? And then what would the cost of those be, both initial purchase and ongoing maintenance costs? So that is just something that we need to do further work on. Any other questions? Seeing none, I will move forward with the deliberations then. Let's go with public comment first. Seeing none in the room.
1:23:12 Tim, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Yes, thank you, Councilmembers. Tim James, California Grocers Association. So sustainability has been a significant priority for grocers, and we have proven that with both our support for state and local regulation. However, I think we're in the situation tonight where we must ask the Council to not move forward at this time for both process and policy issues. It's Christmas week. This is absolutely the busiest time.
1:23:45 For the food industry and grocers at this time. And quite frankly, many of the stores in Mammoth Lakes were quite frankly unaware.
1:23:55 That this was even coming forward at this time. This issue goes very, very deep into a lot of operational challenges, sourcing, whatnot, and grocers haven't had time to either not only reflect on the language, but also provide their individual thoughts going forward. So we think the timing for this is, let's call it challenged, just to be kind on that one.
1:24:22 In addition to that, we also feel it's a bit backwards to pass a policy and then look to fully engage regulated retailers and businesses. But let me speak to the policy aspect of this. So you're bringing this decision forward at a very unprecedented time in food packaging regulation for California. SB 54 is an absolute landmark piece of legislation that's being implemented now.
1:24:49 That provides both the holistic and comprehensive mandates on food packaging to meet strict resource use and recycling standards. What we're asking Mammoth Lakes to do is to join so many other jurisdictions across California and support the most sustainable packaging for each use.
1:25:11 SB 54 applies tremendous standards for each of those packaging type and kind of sets up each packaging type to earn its keep, if you will. So when you look at item specific bands like this one, you're actually potentially limiting your sustainability options, especially in cases where situations are.
1:25:36 That the product that you may not appreciate actually becomes the product that is probably best suited with that role. In addition, SB54, you've got SB1013, which is basically a complete redesign of the CRV recycling options for consumers, different than just adding on new products, but actually changing how consumers get access to that going forward.
1:26:01 Banning plastic water bottles will move customers to other packaging items. We're now going to be looking at aluminum, glass, mixed material packaging. Each of those options also have its own negative impacts. I haven't heard much discussion about what those are so they can be judged in combination with each other. Those options are heavier. They take up more space. They're more costly. They're less available. This means greater effort and operational burdens for us.
1:26:30 Increased truck miles, increased costs for consumers, and more. Additionally, many of those alternatives and replacement options are not going to be available and enough to support consumers for a couple of years. One of the other concerns that we haven't heard addressed is that when you move away...
1:26:52 When you're only allowing less available and more expensive water options, you're likely just to move consumers to other products, whether those are caffeinated drinks, juices, energy drinks, sugar-sweetened beverages, maybe even for some of it might be alcohol, but we're going to see and have seen the changes.
1:27:13 For others where consumers are just replacing those items. And then to that point, when you start talking about both intentional and unintentional litter, you're not really making any movement forward on that as well. So, you know, I fully understand. I think we all understand the reaction is to kind of reject or remove items we may disagree with or may not appreciate. But I think we need to be very, very careful with that. Our reactions need to be tempered.
1:27:43 To make sure we are not limiting or removing some of our best options when we look at complex issues like this. So again, we're asking you to take time with grocers to understand not just the impacts to consumers, but also the value in ensuring the most sustainable options.
1:28:02 Will still be available to Mammoth Lake. So respectfully, we ask you not move forward at this time, engage the regulated businesses, and work with not only us, but a lot of your peers to support both aggressive and broad food packaging sustainability. Thank you for the time tonight. Appreciate it. Thank you, Tim. Any other public comments on this? Seeing none, bring it back to council for your pleasure. Amanda is probably 500 plus.
1:28:45 20 fluid ounces. So that is 591 milliliters. Yeah. I have my microphone. Want to say it all over? Okay, I can say that again if you want. Could you hear me, Sarah? I actually could. Okay. I know, you're the microphone person, so the irony. Guys, three years to implement this. I just...
1:30:20 Chris, I appreciate you saying that. Like, I have said this was my number one priority for probably two years now. Pam, I really appreciate the work you've been doing. I understand that this is going to take a minute, but like, we live in a country where you can fill a receptacle from a sink, any sink, and that water is safe to drink. I have been to a lot of places where that is not the case.
1:30:49 I don't think that getting a town water refill station program dialed in is a necessary step that we have to take in order to do this. Like we are supposed to be, we pride ourselves to be at the leading edge of sustainability in this community. And the idea that we would need to take three years, like I will.
1:31:18 I could be dead by then. I just, I understand that we want to do this correctly. But again, we live in a country where we can stick a cup under a tap and have clean drinking water, really great drinking water. And I'm really thankful that this has finally been brought before council. And I will vote for this if this is the only option that we have.
1:31:51 I think we can do a little better. I think we can be a little more expeditious about this. Yeah, absolutely. I, first of all, you know, I would have even, and I thought that our direction had been to be a little bit bigger. I just feel like, you know, I don't know how many of you go to town cleanup trail days, but like,
1:32:29 We pick up a lot of empty plastic water bottles. We also pick up a lot of broken glass, which is another story. But, you know, this is the kind of thing that we need to take some leadership. You know, we just had the COP, whatever number it was, go through, and they're finally talking about fossil fuels. Folks, we're destroying our planet. And so...
1:33:01 Seems to me like if we just pushed ourselves a little harder and were a little more, you know, forthcoming that we could do a lot of good and show some leadership. And so I would be in favor of changing the ordinance to still be the anything that you're buying by the case. You know, so I don't I didn't remember. I don't I didn't memorize the milliliters, but that's.
1:33:29 Step one for me. But step two at a minimum is I just don't feel good about something that I think we say is going to take three years to happen. I don't think that it should take that long. So that's where I am. And I'd like to make a motion to amend the ordinance, but I won't do it until everyone's spoken. So I do agree. I think that's what I heard was the challenge with staff resources.
1:34:01 My understanding is we have a budget process coming up this spring. Would it be possible for Town and Kendra to get together and say, okay, if we were to do this in two years, to be able to make a recommendation what the resources would be needed to do that? Is that a possibility? I mean, we can walk through that. It'll just be balancing that off against other requests and things of that nature. It's a priority from the staff time of that. Basically, you're talking about contracting or hiring another position.
1:34:31 Would be an ongoing position probably versus just a short-term type level of position would be my guess on that. Oh, but we've got, I mean, you've got a, we've got a public-private partnership going on. Yeah, I mean, or if they hire a position and then that comes back to us to fund different ways. But yeah, I mean, it's, none of us are out, if you will, going, yeah, we've got extra resources to hire bodies and this and then the competition, they'd have the same issues, I believe they could speak to that at Mammoth's disposal. I think, let me.
1:35:01 Say two things, and I know the mayor still has to weigh in on this, but on the time frame and stuff, I think if you took that January 1, 27, back that up six months, it's probably, I'm going to say probably doable. Also, if we get out in front of this and we get the work going, nothing says that you can't modify that and implement sooner, but this would be the effective date currently. That gives us time to work, as the gentleman mentioned, grocery stuff.
1:35:27 We haven't done a lot of outreach to the grocery stores yet and stuff, but what does that take? What does that look like? And they may say for a small number of businesses we have, that's great, that's fine, yeah, we can accommodate X, Y, or Z. So if you want to move that back somewhat, we could do that. I'd be hesitant to start prioritizing at this point additional resources and bodies in a budget process because it'll be next meeting. We'll have another one and say, well, I'd like those elements so you want to take that in context of
1:35:57 The full scope of services that would come forward. Okay, so it would be helpful to understand what the opportunities would be if we, let's say we put this in place as is with specific direction that says how can we accelerate this? What are the opportunities for acceleration? With the understanding that if it really takes three years to do this, this is not going to sit well with council. It's not what we want to do.
1:36:25 Can we bring that back with some sense of how we could start the program? Yeah, I think we can do the regular updates to it and things of that nature. I think from a practical standpoint, you could back it up six months realistically, that we could, I'll speak for staff at this point, to be able to implement that. And again, if it's ready to go and we can actually bring that up, and I know Kendra's still here, can speak to some of that as well as Pam's work on this, going, yeah, okay, yes, we're ready. You know, you can do a simple amendment.
1:36:52 Get the town attorney to write it. Simple amendment to the ordinance that would say, yeah, okay, this could be implemented January or whatever month prior to that if we're ready. But it sounds like tonight if there's pressure or desire to move that backward, but I would suggest backing it up by six months. And then if we're ready to go and we can get outreach is done and we get people confident and they're going, yes, let's do this, we can take it, we can, again, amend that and have it even sooner than that.
1:37:19 Okay, so another question, this question about state mandates. The gentleman brought up the issue about SB54. You know, we've run into this, we run into this all the time. And maybe you could speak to what position it puts us in if we put something like this in place vis-à-vis the state and SB54. Okay, so a couple things. SB54 says that by 2032, nine years from now,
1:37:45 There have to be some kind of strict controls on packaging. You have to move towards the most efficient types of packaging, but it's a long way out. We can't do anything that overrides state law, so the town can restrict certain types of packaging. That's fine, but that has to fit within state law. I'm not aware of anything in the draft ordinance that would conflict with state law. Certainly, if Mr. James or anybody else thinks that there is something
1:38:13 We'd be happy to look at it. We could fix the ordinance later. But that's a long-term project, that new law. And what we're talking about is something shorter. So you could certainly wait for the law to take effect. If we were to vote to approve this and put this into effect, just making sure going forward we're not out of the box, sideways with anything going on with the state. I'm not aware of any way that we would be, no. All right. So what I'm hearing is the best that you guys could do is maybe move it up by six months.
1:38:45 Yeah, looking at that and the staff and the work we want to do on the outreach to make it effective would be there. The whole other question down the road will be this is somewhat probably light-handed enforcement process, but figuring that out too. What does that look like? Okay. A little bit of a compromise there, but it's to make it effective to make that work. Sorry, one other thing. I do share your concerns about the outdoor water bottle program. I think that seems kind of crazy.
1:39:19 We need to think about that. That's not, I mean, that could be a lot of very expensive infrastructure that I don't know if it's designed for this environment. I don't know what's going to happen to it, but I think there's some more analysis for that, but Bill, go ahead. I think there's a lot more analysis. First, I'm going to say that my first priority has never been a ban on plastic bottles in Mammoth. My first priority is in housing, in economic sustainability, and a lot of other things before it comes down to this.
1:39:50 We don't know what the cost of this is going to be. Are we willing to segue some of the money going into housing, to staffing, to enforcement, to making water bottles that the town purchases available? There are so many things that, to me, are more important. There is also, at this point in time, and Tim from the grocers sort of pointed it out, there are no viable alternatives at this point. They are all going to cost a whole lot more.
1:40:19 Yes, we can send our kids to school with an aluminum can that's going to cost three or four times what the plastic does. And then instead of picking up plastic on our cleanup days, we're going to pick up more aluminum or steel or glass or whatever that is. But currently, there are no viable alternatives on the market. We have heard our friend from Tahoe who worked on this program come and tell us that these things could happen.
1:40:45 But they have not yet happened, so there is no viable alternative here. Until the state or the federal government gets in the business to change some of this, for our customers, we are a resort. For our customers, there's no viable alternative for me to take something else of water and throw it in the back of my snowmobile or something and go down the road. So for those, I probably will not vote for this. I'm not going to go on and on.
1:41:15 Thank you. Thank you.
1:41:42 I want to correct what I said earlier that this is my number one priority. Obviously, housing is my number one priority, but this has been a pretty high priority for me. I'm just sitting here hearing this discussion. Bill, you're like, put something on the back of my snowmobile to put water in? What could that possibly be?
1:42:23 I have 15 reusable water bottles on the top shelf above my step. You get them as swag. I'm just a little bit flabbergasted to hear people be like, but what are we going to put water in? We're going to put water in the reusable water bottles that we get. We all have a million of them. And yes, maybe there are members of this community that we need to think about.
1:42:55 That don't have a million of them. But this is not an intractable problem. And I don't think that this takes a full employee to solve and to do outreach for. And maybe I'm incorrect here. And maybe I don't understand the depth of the issue. But this does not seem like it's going to take a team of NASA scientists to solve.
1:43:27 We know how to do this. This is 2023. We know how to do this, guys. It's not, it doesn't need to take three years to do. I'm not being very eloquent right now. I'm sorry, I don't feel very well. This is obviously a really important issue to me, so it was important that I join this, but I just, I think we can do this, guys. I really do. I think we can do this in less than three years.
1:43:58 And I believe in you, you know, I believe in our town staff. I believe that we have the capability to do this. I even believe that our guests know that we have, that they can bring reusable water bottles here. I just, I don't see this as being such an issue that takes three years to solve. Again, I'm sorry, I'm not feeling well, so I'm not being as eloquent as I.
1:44:30 I think we can do this, guys. I really do. I think we can do this in less than three years. But if three years is what I have to vote for, that's what I'll do. But we've been doing this for a long time. I, as a kid of the 80s, I don't remember ever drinking water as a school child, right? So, like, our kids know how to do this. My kid has two water bottles at school, one for the playground, one for inside. Like, it's...
1:45:00 One is provided by school, one I provide. Like, we can do this. Okay, sorry. I'm rambling. I'd like to say something. We can do this. I guess my feelings about it is the town-wide water refill station, I don't feel that that needs to be.
1:45:21 In place before we knock out the 500 ml's. I mean, I feel like if we were going up to a gallon, then yes, we need to have refill stations available and open, but 500 ml, like Bill's bottle would not be included. So, I mean, I feel like, Bill, you can bring a larger plastic water bottle if you are insistent on getting a plastic water bottle. Like, there are alternatives available. There are larger sizes.
1:45:48 I mean, I just, I think that, um,
1:46:14 My thought with, you know, waiting for the commercial ban until January of 27 is that since it is only the smallest size, that I don't think that the water refill stations need to be in place. And, you know, I guess I kind of feel like they're two separate issues. Like, I would love to see water refill stations around town. I think that would be a benefit to the community. And then separately, I think it's easy to
1:46:43 So, Mr. Mayor, I'd like to make a motion kind of along those lines. Again, a question for staff. I mean, I'm thinking the same thing, Amanda. I think we should do a discrete analysis of the water station program with costs and all the rest of it as a separate parallel effort. Is that...
1:47:04 Does that going to do anything near to the ban of the 500 mil or less water bottles? Yeah, if I could just make a clarification, Amanda, to your point, the water refill station program and the outreach program, the effective dates that I've proposed aren't contingent on those two things. I just recommend that those two things be in place in order to ensure the best success of a future program. And I think it would be best to develop those ahead of time. However, they are not.
1:47:33 They're not interdependent. They're not necessarily linked together. Could I make one other comment just briefly on the 500 mLs? That size is the size that are sold in the pallets, and so that's why we established that size. Thank you. That helps. Okay, so I would, I'm going to just do this. Yeah, Dan, go ahead. If you look at the modification we talked about, I'm just going to reference.
1:48:00 That would be to the 8.15050 section of the ordinance, item D, changing the January 1, 2027, July 1, 26th date, if you wanted to back it up that six-month window. It would be that particular section and that date, if you moved it, that would make it six months sooner, if you will. But again, there's another question with this, which is the way that it's laid out in the recommended motions, it's sequenced. It says, do the...
1:48:27 Town-wide water refill station program first and then go into the ban. If we set these up as being parallel efforts or not interdependent efforts, would there be any possibility of advancing the ban of the plastic water bottles themselves to do that even six months earlier than that? Yeah, I would still recommend the July 1, 2016. I think it makes it more effective for us, I think, from a processing and education and timing and working with our business community, et cetera. All right.
1:48:54 Additionally, the three items in the recommendation aren't sequenced. They're meant to be concurrent in terms of obviously the effective dates aren't concurrent with each other, but the efforts for the first two items, the water refill station and the education and outreach would start now and be ongoing in the appropriate phases established for those two items throughout the next several years. I'm just reading where it says
1:49:23 Water fill refill station program prior to implementation of plastic. So I'm assuming we can disconnect those. Sure. We can unlink those. Yeah, because it's not called out that in the ordinance that way. So if you just, if you, the motion is to adopt an ordinance tonight and amending the one date, that's what I'm hearing. Right. The workload, as you're mentioning, we can accommodate through that process. And then if it's ready to go earlier, again, the council can always say, hey, if this is ready, we can bring it back at any point for amendment.
1:49:51 What would that look like? What is that? So let's say we've done a bunch of outreach, we're working with the grocery stores, everybody going in, hey, we're ready, you can do this, you know, three months, six months from now, and that's sooner than state. Then we can come in and say, do you want to move forward quicker? But this gives us time to do that outreach work and other work that would go in this for information and things. But we have to come back and amend the ordinance? Yeah, it'd just be a one, it's a, you know, two-step process, but yes.
1:50:18 Okay, but there's no 30-day wait. Yeah, you do that. You do the introduction second. It'd be the same process for an amendment. Because we'd have to be way ahead of a schedule to be able to pull this off. Yeah. To a degree, yes. All right, well, I'm going to make a motion, and then we'll see what we do with it. So I would move that we direct the staff to develop an outreach and education program for the plastic water bottle prohibition, that we waive the reading and introduce by title only the attached ordinance to adopt a single-use plastic water bottle prohibition.
1:50:50 With the date amended to being, was it July? July 1, 2026. July 1, 2026. And to concurrently direct staff to develop a town-wide water refill station program for further review and potential adoption by the council at a date in the future. I'm just putting that out there, so we'll see if we do that. I'm just wondering why this feels like a negotiation.
1:51:20 We said we wanted this and we want it sooner. So now we've just moved it six months. Like, why can't we do what we always intended to do, which is to do this as soon as possible? I mean, it's just absurd. Like, plastic water bottles were not a thing until the late 80s. I have an article from Fast Company I will happily share with anyone. When did this become a human necessity? Like, it's bizarre to me and I'm so frustrated tonight.
1:51:46 Well, the motion, what I'm hearing is just consistent with, again, we have a set of priorities, housing, things like that that are really important. I think this is important to advance this. I'm not hearing from staff that there's, you know, the option, I'm taking this literally, is if we want to advance this, it's going to require hiring additional staff. I mean, we could punt this and bring it back and say, look, we want it. Really, is there really going to be another full-time staff position to do this? I mean, that's an option, but I just put this out there to see.
1:52:18 So, currently I have a motion. If I'm not hearing the second, it dies for lack of second. I have a question for Pam. Can I ask a question first? The styrofoam ban, how long did that take us to implement? Well, it hasn't been implemented yet because it doesn't go into a first. I will say that I feel that we're behind on our outreach efforts for the styrofoam ban. They've started recently.
1:52:49 We have spoken to most, if not all, of the restaurants. However, I do anticipate a number of restaurants coming forward and asking for an exemption within that first year, which was written into the code that they could do that based on having stock available that they want to use up being the primary reason we would allow them to do that. We won't really know until the date comes and we start seeing things coming in, but I don't feel that we've done a sufficient job of outreach for that as we could have.
1:53:19 I feel like this is more substantial. I feel like it's a lot more substantial, yeah. Just based on the...
1:53:54 Purchasing changes that businesses will need to make, making sure that the community is aware of this, and I just think that there's a lot more robust outreach that will need to be for this versus then what was done. Kendra's here as well. She's been doing a lot of that outreach, so I don't know. Kendra, can I ask you a question? Do you know what size plastic water bottles go in vending machines? Isn't it like 20 ounces? It's all the metric. Kendra, can I get you to come up to the podium? Yeah, come to the podium, Kendra.
1:54:41 Thank you. Actually, vending machines, I know they're above that 500 milliliter size, so yes, that wouldn't affect any vending machines per se. I'm not aware of that many in our area. Thanks. I'm happy to ask or answer any questions regarding SB54 as well and SB1013 that the grocer was mentioning. I follow about a dozen mandates right now, so yes, I'm happy to answer anything.
1:55:16 Do we have any idea how many businesses are selling plastic water bottles that are 500 mil or under? I'm curious to think about it because I'm just, I'm trying to think of a business that I've gone into in the last, you know, five years where I could find that small plastic water bottle for sale. Does anyone have any idea about that, Pam? Data, no. Those are grocery stores, not restaurants.
1:55:51 Not the restaurants or every other store? Every gas station with the little store attached, every grocery store, correct. Okay, so how many gas stations in town? Four and then two big grocery stores. There are a few restaurants currently that will not be selling those soon in the future. Correct, but the ones I've spoken with are telling me they will not be selling that size, those restaurants that I've been doing outreach with for about...
1:56:25 Five to six months regarding styrofoam. So maybe 10 businesses? I can't give an exact number, Sarah, but yes, I would say, sorry, Councilmember Rae, but I would say about a dozen currently. Okay, thank you. That's helpful. Lack of seconds. Do I hear any other motion? I mean, I would just like to get that date. I feel like I'm free to make a motion. I don't know what, I guess I feel like, is there a way to...
1:57:24 Push it up. I mean, I guess I feel I would be happier pushing it up, you know, and having it be in one year. It's enforced. And, you know, if it doesn't go smoothly with those 12 businesses, that to me is better than waiting another year and a half after that. Like, I would rather, you know, come into... So, could you make a suggestion? Yeah. Maybe just take my motion and amend the date. Okay. Just say that...
1:57:52 Date I have was six months earlier, whatever date you want to put in, you can ask. That might be the easiest. Okay. Dan, what date can you give me? So when we discussed this back in May, Council asked for staff to bring forward our recommendation based on all of the information we collected in our resources. This, what is being proposed today, is what we feel is a recipe for success and a realistic proposal based on available staff resources. As Dan mentioned,
1:58:26 If you want to change the date, we can do that, but we need to also make sure that the resources are in place to be able to make this successful. We're not talking about a full-time position just to implement a plastic water bottle ban, but the town manager's office and my position specifically has a lot of other functions, and dealing with solid waste and sustainability is one small part of that, as well as Kendra's position has all of the mandates to be in compliance.
1:58:56 We want to make sure that the resources are available and that we can be successful.
1:59:26 Dan, if you want to add to that, please feel free. The success of the program is a key element here. The other day, I mean, you wanted to make everything January 1. I do think we'll end up with a lot more impact than several of the other, I think it's probably a larger number of businesses that actually do this. Of course, the other prohibition on this is that there's non-profits like in a parade handing out walls. For small ones. Giving anything, giving it out more about those types of issues and same nature. So there's a lot of activity that involves having to reach out to. And then, of course,
2:00:21 Like I mentioned earlier, it would probably be relatively light on the front end. Here's your citation. Again, exactly any types of elements of how that'll work for the code. If you backed up to January 1, 2025, that date, soft citation, especially on the enforcement side, I think you will get pushback from people show up in town with it. They don't buy it. We've kicked around a lot of different elements like that that we don't have a lot of control over to address as it comes up. Thank you. I guess, yeah, we're banding about the...
2:01:19 The question of what does success look like? We want to have a successful program. So like, what does success look like? And what does failure look like? And is there somewhere we can meet in the middle if we implement this January 1, 2025, and there are some offenders and we have to do some...
2:01:43 Potential citations or maybe we get some people who are, you know, applying for an exemption or something like that. I just, if we're talking about 12 businesses, like what is, it is a failure of the implementation that a couple of those businesses continue to sell those water bottles or, yeah, or people are handing out larger than 500 mil water bottles. I just,
2:02:12 I don't do the enforcement, so I get that it might be more complicated than I'm thinking, but if we have a few outliers that are refusing to comply or are unable to comply, can we not address those on an individual basis and still move forward with, I mean, we're talking millions of these water bottles a year. A year is a lot.
2:02:43 A lot of water bottles. If I could have a picture of how many water bottles it is that January 1, 2025 versus January 1, 2026, how much of a landfill is that? How much are we shipping out in that one year? I just, I think we can do this again. I think we can do this. And if we have to address some outliers, I think we can do it.
2:03:15 Could I ask a quick clarifying question? Because we started at 1-1-27. How did we get to 1-1-25? Because we were in July 26th. I have the same question. Oh, I'm sorry, 26th, I'm sorry. Yeah, I think we're talking. 26th, I'm sorry. Okay, so we're asking for January 1st, 26th, just so everyone's clear. Yeah, sorry, I was looking at the one above it and going down. So, Mr. Mayor, if I could, I mean, I don't want to jump, but I'll...
2:03:46 Maybe if we could amend them, I would amend them my motion to be effective January 1st, 26th. January 1st? Yes. 2026. That would be the correct date. I have a new motion with a new date of January 26th. Only? Yeah. I hear a second. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Bubzer?
2:04:22 Yes, Mayor Sauser. Thank you all. That almost hurt. Okay, moving on to 8.2. Waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance amending municipal code chapter 10.24 regarding vehicles on trails, mops, and sidewalks. And Dan, you're going to kick this off for us? It started real quick. The ordinance you had before you was based off of our discussion meeting or so ago where we talked about limits on
2:04:53 E-Bikes and other bikes, et cetera, human-powered items and other things on our MUFs and our sidewalks, our MUFs primarily focused on that. Other vehicles, too, allows us to have a little more teeth and authority as we manage the use of that infrastructure. I think the ordinance that's proposed addresses those areas of concern that were raised by the council, touches on a number of a couple of areas there that we discussed at that point. So what I'd like to do is...
2:05:23 As we had a pretty robust discussion at the last meeting, if you have questions on any of the particular items here, Lawson can speak to those. I think we covered the items that were addressed in a couple of questions raised by council, so we weren't planning to spend a lot of time walking back through the things we rehashed at the previous meeting. But if you have any particular questions, be glad to address those. And as noted, staff would recommend waive the reading, introduce the ordinance by title only as presented and or if there's an amendment.
2:05:53 Thank you, Dan. Questions or comments? We will get into this quickly. Let's start with you, Chris. No questions. Thank you. John? I don't have any questions. I appreciate the work the staff has done. I think we all know that this is a very fluid space being driven by technology, being driven by a lot of very impressive investments by the private sector, and all of this is moving around.
2:06:22 I'm good with this as presented. I think we need to move forward this and see what the hell happens. Thank you. Sarah? Amanda? I don't have any questions at this time. Thank you. I will echo some of what John said. I'm very happy to see that this pertains to human-powered as well. My bad experiences in the last couple of years at my corner have been more with the human-powered than with the powered bicycles, so I am fine with this moving forward.
2:06:58 Public comment. Yeah, any public comment on this issue? Seeing none. So, Mr. Mayor, I would move that the council waive the reading and introduce by title only the ordinance adding municipal code chapter 10.24 regarding vehicles on trails, mops, and sidewalks. I'll second. You're so fast. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie? Councilmember Ray? Councilmember Rice? Yes.
2:07:32 Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp-Bubser? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Thank you. 8.3, Approval of Council Strategic Priorities and Key Objectives for 2024. Dan? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Again, we actually had a pretty good discussion on this at a previous meeting, and the rewrite of that was taking comments from Council, trying to work those into the key objectives and the strategic priority statements.
2:08:02 And then one thing it did add to the staff report that was in there was laying out a number of tasks below each area to give you a feel for the types of things that, as we look out over the next year, the types of things that we'd be implementing, working on. I think it kind of puts a path forward as we look out for the next 12 months or so. It also gives you a feel of the workload that this incorporates. And we did incorporate information looking back at the last year and the things that we've accomplished going forward.
2:08:31 Again, it's similar in discussion as the last meeting, so I wasn't going to spend a lot of time walking back through that. My real question is in terms of the priorities and the particular statements and stuff, did we capture the comments and various elements raised by council, if they're adequately covered in that, or if you have any amendments to either the priority itself or those key objectives, still with the goal to try to keep this down to one page.
2:09:01 We're smithing it through to do some of that things in terms of the statements as well. But glad to answer any questions related to that or if there's any minor modifications, that's any one typo, but otherwise I think we're in pretty good shape. So I'm hoping we captured the conversation from the last meeting. Thank you. John. I think, Dan, that whoever compiled all this did a really good job. I'm mindful of your successor.
2:09:31 I think I had one minor...
2:09:56 So I would like to make a comment real quick. On page 121 of 130, or page 3, up from the bottom, the top bullet point on strategic priorities, sustainability, and diversity, it should probably read resident experiences with improved recreation.
2:10:23 And trail access points with parking signals. The word trails needs to be added. Yeah. That's just a little housekeeping. I have other comments. While John is looking, Amanda? I think you guys did a good job. And I think it was nice that you put the tasks underneath. It's helpful on the staff report. Sarah, questions or comments? No, thanks. Chris? No, I just thank you. I think you captured.
2:11:04 Our input from the last conversation, so I'm good with it as is. Have you found it yet, John? I found one. Bill, why don't you go ahead and get some comments? I will. One of the comments I want to make again on the tasks on page three, coordinate with ESTA on new bus purchases. I've had several conversations with Phil, our director at ESTA, over the last few days at the critical need at this point of getting some new buses. Our large buses are
2:11:35 Failing at a fairly high rate. They've come to the end of their useful life shorter than we would have liked. But I'm glad to see that in there. That is a critical piece for me. Other than that, good job, Dan. I think you did an admirable job of moving this thing forward for us. So I think I found, these are minor things, but on page 122-130, the first bulleted task at the top, Sherwin I think is misspelled.
2:12:10 Should be ER, not IR. And in the strategic priority in the middle, third, Chevron down, engage with, I think you should say recreation planning, recreational planning, yeah, that's something, probably something different. Yeah, that's in Cody, we get it. Other than that, I think we're, and one other, just as a, there's something, I thought I saw something in here that mentioned.
2:12:39 Responsible Recreation. And if we could change that to sustainable, just because that's a term of art with the Forest Service that aligns with federal policy, I think it basically sort of mean the same thing, but if we can be aligning with the federal policy document, that might. Or maybe responsible and sustainable, because I think responsible sort of means something outside of.
2:12:59 We need a motion on this one, Dan.
2:13:41 I still have public comment. Yes, we will be asking you to approve it this evening as amended, as then we will publish it out as an adopted document then versus. Any public comment? Our public has dwindled. Any public comment on this issue? Feel free to speak up. Anything in cyberspace? Okay, I would accept a motion. Mr. Mayor, I move that the Town Council adopt the proposed 2024 Town Council strategic priorities and key objectives for 2024 as amended.
2:14:13 I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. 5-0. Thank you all. Moving on now to item number nine, Councilmember Reports. Who'd like to start us off this evening? I'll start, Mr. Mayor.
2:14:40 On December 7th, I attended with you and with others some Visit California High Sierra Region focus groups on tourism and the visitor experience. I don't know who else participated in that, but this is a very widely, heavily funded statewide initiative to redefine tourism strategies for the entire state. It's pretty interesting. The nightly rental advisory committee meeting, I sat humbly and in awe of the deliberation work being conducted.
2:15:10 Good work to that committee and encourage them to keep doing what they're doing. The ESCOG meeting, I've got some notes. Chris, I can go. You can go. That's fine. So I'll go through some things happening at the ESCOG, which is a very interesting meeting. Let's see what we did. We were introduced to a gentleman named Aaron Wilcher, who's with UC Extension for Economic and Community Development with the Department with their Agriculture and Natural Resources Division.
2:15:40 I think he's going to be a really important asset to us in the region. He's very involved in surf issues now, California Jobs First introduced to him, and that's going to be a very interesting thing going forward. He's done some very interesting work in Recreationville, published some very interesting papers and things like that, so I think he's going to be a real asset to what we're doing in this region. We got an update on the Buttermilk Initiative, the Burpee Initiative.
2:16:08 Final plan is being finalized right now. That should be done shortly. We received an update on the SURF, California Jobs First effort. They're in the middle of submitting a big application back to the state, so it was a little bit of a truncated thing. We had a very interesting conversation about our calendar, not bumping into ESTA. ESTA bumps into ESCOG. ESCOG bumps into ESTA. I think we got that figured out.
2:16:34 And then we had some discussion about the core competencies and strategic priorities for the ESCOG. And I think that Aaron and the UC Extension, who he's with, I think there's going to be some capacity to help really start to scale up and grow that thing based on how we put it together so far. It was an interesting discussion. And then we had a presentation from Scott Armstrong, very similar to what we're here tonight. It's great to have him in that seat because he really knows his stuff and there's a lot of interesting stuff going on. After the board meeting, we went and we
2:17:04 Cut the paper, you know, cut the toilet paper on a new toilet for the Burpee area. The Burpee area is, I think, an area really worthy of our set of engagement. It's not that dissimilar with the work we did out in the Sherwins. And the biggest recommendation coming out of that project is that there needs to be a coherent management authority needs to get figured out. You've got LADWP, Inyo County, Forest Service, BLM.
2:17:32 All on top of each other. Everybody's just pointing fingers at everybody else. So it's a great project for New County, a great project for Bishop, and we'll see where that goes. That's kind of exciting. Then, what else happened? Other things happened, as they always do. Just pull this up. And then I attended the California Jobs First, their High Road Transition Council meeting, which was virtual on the west side. Sorry, it was in-person on the west side, virtual on the east side.
2:18:03 It was a little better than I think I anticipated it was going to be. Still pretty murky going forward, but there's some sense of coherence coming out of all that. And I think we could see some very accelerated things happening in the first couple quarters of next year. So I'm sure, Chris, you were there at that meeting as well, so we'll keep you guys posted on it. End of report. Thank you, John. Chris? The only thing, because John covered very well,
2:18:32 Those issues, but I attended one of the after-action report meetings, so there's been a series of focus groups on specific topics, and it's incredibly thoughtful, very well done. I was pleased to be able to, you know, sort of hear the staff talk about the, you know, sort of what happened, what went well, what didn't. I really wanted to go to the utilities in propane.
2:18:59 But I wasn't able to make it. I'm sure there were great discussions there. This is an amazing opportunity for our community to learn from a difficult situation and do better in the future. So I'm not sure who all has been shared the survey from the consultant, but I highly recommend that anybody who receives it should weigh in. I'm super pleased that the Town of Mammoth Lakes is spending money to do this.
2:19:28 As comprehensively as possible. I know the county's trying to take this on on their own, but I think that the most important thing you can do after a difficult situation is learn from it and be better for the next time. I also just want to take this opportunity to say one more time to all of our first responders, thank you for keeping us safe last winter. I really don't think we've thanked you properly enough. I don't know how. I guess you're...
2:19:55 You know, you're just people who do your job happily and so we're grateful to you because, you know, no one died in Mono County last winter. That is a miracle. We don't talk about it enough. We don't celebrate you all enough and I'm glad that we will have a really solid representation of what happened and how we can be ready for the future because we know that the climate emergency is not a one and done. It's going to continue to evolve and so thank you.
2:20:28 Sarah, anything? No, thanks, and I apologize for not being able to be there in person. Nothing to report. Well, I was at the STR committee with Chris, and John was in the audience. Thanks for being there, John. I went to the Eastern Sierra Community Housing meeting after our last meeting, and the board voted to...
2:20:52 Approve the Access Apartments and get that ball rolling. So I'm super excited about that. And then I had the pleasure of ice skating with my family twice this last week. So the CRC, it was a lot of fun. It was a huge rink. I think Monday must have been a record-breaking day, I'm guessing. We went Monday afternoon and I think everybody was there. No one was on the hill. But we really enjoyed ourselves. So that was fun. And that's it.
2:21:22 So on the 11th, I attended with Dan, the LTC. I just had my notes going. Nothing super important, although after that I did get, and you probably all got, a notification that Yosemite is going to be using a reservation system again next year. But for those of you in the audience that aren't here but are out there in TV land, something for you to research so you know how that's going to work.
2:21:52 Primarily, it's going to be holidays and weekends. And then there are times after which that our guests will still be able to go without a reservation. But that's critical moving forward. I hope that that system works well. Mr. Mayor, just one thing to add. It's a great opportunity to try the YARTS bus because you can always get in on the YARTS bus. Very good. That's true. And that's my whole report. I missed the Trails Committee meeting.
2:22:23 The other day, they took a group out to show the thinning that had been done along the creek corridor. Dan? Yeah, if I may just add to Amanda's skating exploits that tomorrow evening at 5.30 at the CRC, if you want to skate with Santa, you're more than welcome to come by and watch and or skate as we kind of kick off the Christmas season there at the CRC tomorrow evening. No, not this Santa, my brother.
2:22:54 Mr. Mayor, I got just one quick question. I tried to sign up for the after action report, but all the meetings were booked. It was full. If there's another one, I don't know if there is or not, but yeah, we can make, they had a limited number originally on that, but we can always, if you're, sorry, we could squeeze that in and say, hey, allow it. That's fine. I really appreciate it. I think it's a really important thing. Is the county involved in this at all?
2:23:16 Or is this geography just like the town of Mammoth? We've had county folks involved at some of the meetings where there's been interaction. They've been a part of that. But it really is focused on the town. The county chose not to participate in this level of detail of an after-action report. They are putting together one to meet the requirements for FEMA, which will be in that as well because it's countywide.
2:23:42 So is the extent like our municipal boundary or something? It's not actually the boundary, but it was the response component, which was the town. So as we talk in a lot of the different things, we had the county involved, for example, when we did sheltering in Red Cross. We talked about coordination in some other areas with them. The fire district's been involved, for example, and Alice is still here. He was the regional coordinator for Well Beyond Us, those types of things. So it is focused on the response elements of the town of Mammoth Lakes.
2:24:12 But it does bounce across the boundary. It's not that narrowly tight, if you will, if we talk about coordination of trucking. That came out of the work in Bishop with the IMT teams and then elements up. So there is some overlap, but it is an after-action report focused on the town and our response. Thank you. I'm assuming, Dan, in that it will include the town activities that occurred outside of town, as you're saying. We ferried some people up here.
2:24:42 Yeah, we talked about- We sent plows out on the Benton Crossing Road. We did a lot of things that we paid for and don't know if we're going to get reimbursed for yet or not outside of the municipal boundary. Yeah, our overall response, yes, did go beyond. Thank you. Anything else from Council there? So, at this point, we will adjourn into a closed session.
2:25:11 Pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.8, Town Council will hold conference with its representatives in regard to property negotiations pertaining to property 100 College Parkway. And we're taking a brief five minutes. Those lemon cookies are excellent, by the way. I'm telling you. Yeah.