Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2025
Eastern Sierra Council of Governments
at 08:30
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
313 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:30 Supervisor McFarlane, please report to the dais. Supervisor McFarlane, please report to the dais. I make announcements like I'm the New York City subway. I can be silly because this is Sweet Z, which is very informal. Hello. Yes. Good morning. Welcome to the June 25th regular meeting of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments.
2:10 Angie, can you please call the roll? Chair Mohove is absent today. Vice Chair Bubzer? Here. Supervisor Griffiths? Supervisor Oral? Here. Supervisor Salcido? Here. Council Member Wentworth is absent today. Council Member Schwartz? Here. And Supervisor McFarland? Here. Thank you. Excellent. Kim Anaclario, will you please lead us in the pledge?
2:41 Sorry, I usually warn someone. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right. So we can start with public comments for items not otherwise on the agenda. Is there anyone online, Angie? Oh, here comes.
3:21 Mr. Eichmann. Hi. We just need to borrow for one second. Good. Morning, Madam Chair, members. David Eichmann, Interim Director of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. So as most of you know, the Chamber's been working feverishly on the 4th of July parade, which is next week. So the two things I'm here today.
3:51 is number one, floats. We have 40 floats registered. We'd like to get up to 50. And when I say float, that can be a marching contingent. So if you know of any, especially nonprofit groups, this is a great opportunity for a nonprofit group to get their name out there. So if you know any, we're still accepting applications through the end of the week. So encourage people to do that. And secondly,
4:18 Judges for our float competition. So actually Supervisor Salcido, I've cornered her in last night to do it, so thank you. But if you know other people, the only thing is they can't be affiliated with any of the floats in the parade, and they have to be there the entire parade. So either float judges or float registrants, please reach out to me. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone online, Angie?
4:48 No comments at this time. Okay, terrific. Thank you. So we will move on to the consent agenda. Three items. Item 4.1, approve the minutes of the special meeting of April 30th, 2025. 4.2, receive the ESCOG Wildfire Coordinator Report. Is that the, that's not the one we're not, okay. And then 4.3, receive the Inyo Mono Broadband Coalition Coordinator Report. So I will entertain a motion. Second. Second. All right, Angie, could you please call the roll?
5:21 Vice Chair Bubzer? Yes. Board Member Oral? Yes. Board Member Salcido? Yes. Board Member Schwartz? Yes. Board Member McFarland? Yes. And Board Member Griffiths? Yes. Thank you. All right, and moving on, item 5.1 is to receive a presentation from Christina Darlington, California Law Empowering Renewable Energy, regarding opportunities for funding to support biomass utilization through the JPA-led initiatives. Welcome.
5:57 Oh, thank you. I can go ahead and share through my presentation if that's going to be easier for you. Give me a moment and I can set that up.
6:10 Before Ms. Darlington provides her presentation, though, I just want to say good morning to the board and provide a little bit of context around the presentation. You may remember at our last meeting I mentioned briefly that there is an opportunity for Ms. Darlington and her organization to come to the Eastern Sierra.
6:32 And provide facilitation services among the parties interested in biomass utilization. I think that this is a really wonderful opportunity that's probably much needed at this time given a lot of the fuel management work and vegetation management work that's happening in the Eastern Sierra. So really appreciate her making the trip to the Eastern Sierra to provide this presentation to your board and for the benefit of the community. Thank you. Okay.
7:28 No? Uh-oh. Christiana, if it's easier for you, I have your presentation loaded. I'm sorry about that. All good. I'm associated with a project that is being funded through the state with the OPR, the Office of Planning Research, which is now going by the name called CI. But in the past, it's done with OPR. This project has been in place for about three years.
8:19 And what we've been doing is looking at ways to fund local agencies to explore how we can best utilize forest violence. So what we have been doing, we need to go to the first slide. So the first slide here we're talking, this program is part of the California program that started back in 2016 based on the to look at how we can as well deal with. That's been a lesser focus of theirs, but recently it's become about a big amount.
9:13 From fuel reduction. So recently, in that was funding for the work. In 2025, they came out with some key deliverables that they want to see occur by the end of the year. And one of those includes the activities that we're talking about in northern college. So some examples of things that some of the other pilots have done so far include drafting feedstock supply assessments, looking at how local governments can work together to solve problems in terms of
9:48 Thank you.
10:15 And then Marin County is also involved, and then there's one on the North Coast. So just for reference. Okay, next slide. So in the other regions, we have a lot of public workshops. We have met with individual entities in some regions. It turns out that cities and counties are a great type of partnership to work with. In other places, RCDs are actually really active in the space, and they tend to be the ones that are doing a lot of work.
10:44 This really is a focus on local agency or government agencies. The reason that we're focusing on that is because the non-profit, Carolina, has been already very active in the past couple of decades in this space with non-profits doing work and doing the work in collaboratives, if you're familiar with that kind of a term. Those are great and they take up a certain space, but what we're really looking at is how can entities that have authority, they have legal status, either a legal entity, not just a
11:13 So now that we have our three years of work under our belt, which some of this discussed here,
11:41 We found that there were four main things that these groups wanted to focus on. So the first one is developing local partnerships and expanding those to regional partnerships, right? And that includes relationships with the Forest Service, which is very important to this type of work, as well as with BLM and with other even non-industrial private landowners and industrial private landowners. So all of those relationships.
12:09 are things that we see could be enhanced with these types of partnerships like ESCOG, like these JPAs. Additionally, we also talked a lot about how do you provide services to the business community. For example, doing mapping services or providing information around business planning, things like that. Some of these entities are really focused on that. Another focus is on workforce development. That's particularly on the West Side partners here.
12:38 They are very focused on workforce development. And CSED, which is the economic development district over on the west side that you might be familiar with, they have just recently voted to support and move forward with focusing on forest biomass utilization as an aspect of what they're going to be looking at over the next few years in terms of workforce development growth. So that has been a great partnership that we've been developing on that side. Next slide.
13:08 So this is a model that I'm not going to get into. It's kind of complicated, but it's in the slide deck if you want to look at it later. This is essentially the type of JPA model that we've been looking at. It's different than ESCOG. This one is. This one is particularly focused on how to establish a long-term fee stock supply contract template that businesses could use to get loans.
13:34 And so a lot of these new businesses that want to use good products have trouble getting loans or investors. And the new idea here is that if we could just get a long-term feedstock contract, we could solve a lot of those challenges. So we are looking at that quite with a hard look. And we have several partners still analyzing what type of insurance products or guarantees could be set in the relationships between these folks.
14:03 And so that they could get financing in these loans. Next slide. Another focus, again, so this is this long-term heat stock contract and risk mitigation that I just talked about, that model supporting. And there's some key components to this. This has to do with...
14:22 It's more around setting up the relationships
14:51 So that they can come to an understanding and then have this guarantee behind their relationship that will come from the JPA in terms of the state funds guarantees or insurance. So next slide. So the other type of work that the JPA could do is actually help with contract management. This could be in terms of grants. It could be in terms of other types of contracts that folks need help with.
15:21 They could, you could also potentially help folks understand their subs. I mean, there's a lot of work in and around contracting that's complicated that people could get assistance from. So that's another idea that we have had. There's also the financial administration, as you probably look at that. That's something that JPA can help with. Okay, next slide.
15:46 So we also really want to have these JPAs work with the tracking and funding from, for example, companies that are trying to do green programs or get involved in impact investing. We can also look at groups like the Moore Foundation and other foundations that might be interested in supporting this work. We already have several of those types of entities interested in work happening in some of the other regions, so that's really exciting.
16:14 There's more and more interest in supporting bioreduction and biomass utilization in the space. So that's another aspect of this work. Next slide. And then, so essentially, what we're doing with ESCOG here is we're coming to the end of this program for all of these other JPAs, and we've basically brought in three other JPAs that were already existing, thinking about widening what they do to include some of these.
16:44 And so we are coming to the point where the state conservancies have gotten interest and they are essentially going to envelop the work that we're doing.
17:15 So the conservancies are really interested in seeing these programs succeed. And as we were transitioning, we realized, you know, ESCOG was the model to start. Maybe ESCOG would like to get involved with this program. So we, you know, cut out a little extra, you know, and decided we had it left over. They said, we're going to go up there, we're going to spend some time trying to share the information with you all.
17:44 And answer questions about it, and see if you would like to participate in the upcoming funding that we expect to support different JPAs in Northern California to take on, of course, about social social issues. The funding amounts that we're looking at right now are between $1 to $5 million, depending on your particular interests and programs that you're interested in supporting. And the types of things that you could use for this funding include your own costs.
18:13 So that's absolutely expected to be covered, is that any new administrative costs that are borne by these JPAs will be covered by this funding. And then additional funding can be made available for businesses, to run a new program, to support workforce development, to support seeking new types of funding mechanisms, to, you know, whatever it is that you particularly, each community has really come up with one or two of its top plans that we'd like to fund.
18:42 So that's basically it. The next slide, I think, is
19:13 Yeah, the state funding commitment I just went through, so we're really excited. I mean, even if the conservancies have any issue or challenge around the funding, there are other state agencies that really support our work, including the Department of Conservation, and they have several different funding mechanisms that are also available that we can also tap into. And honestly, if OPR thought, or LCI,
19:37 Thought that there was any chance that we wouldn't get funding, they will go after funding like they did for this initial program through legislature in the next session. So, you know, they will find a way. They're very determined, which is a great partner. So I'm really up for any questions. I know I didn't cover everything. I was trying to just give you a broad overview and happy to answer any questions. Questions? I know, I know. Yeah.
20:11 It is a lot, and thank you for that presentation. You know, this region definitely does need to address the biomass fuels that are laying on our forest floors, even as they're being cleared out. They're not necessarily going anywhere. My question, though, you referenced supporting businesses in this space. What types of businesses are we going to be looking at?
20:41 Entrepreneurs that are not established businesses or are we looking at established businesses that want to expand? Yeah, good question. Yeah, so this is definitely aimed at both. Okay. And in the other locations we have, for example, one JPA that's completely focused on trying to bring back to life an old business.
21:04 That used to, you know, or still has some jobs, but they're just going to collapse without this. That's one example. And then in another, I think in two other JPA examples, they are really focused on micro businesses. They really want to focus on small entrepreneurs that want to work, that are producing high value products, you know, but at a very small scale. They think that that is what could work best for their community.
21:28 So in terms of that workforce branch, there's a lot of other things it's doing, but that workforce and community economic development branch, there really are many options that the JPA itself, each of the JPAs are choosing to focus on. I have a question. Can you just give me specific examples of these JPAs? Like who are the organizations in the JPAs and where are they?
21:56 Sure. Sorry. I know I ran through that really bad. That's fine. I apologize. That's okay. Sure. So the other JPAs. So from working from north to south. So the furthest north, they are actually creating a new JPA. I think they're going to call it SCUBA, but don't hold me to it. They're working on the name. It's a JPA that includes five RCDs in that example from Shasta.
22:20 Shasta Valley and Western Shasta RCD, and then the Pitt River and Fall River RCDs, and then the Modoc County RCD. There is the Lava Bed Buttes RCD that's also considering joining, but they're quite small right now and they haven't quite gotten there. So that's number one. And then what are the, what is that JPA? Are they, do they have like specific projects that they're, like the biomass fuel project, is there, or they're working with entrepreneurs? Can you give me exactly what they're doing?
22:49 Well, I mean, they're starting, right? So what they have going now is each of these RCDs is really active in the fuel reduction space. So they are producing a lot of waste, biomass residues. So they have a lot of that on hand. And they're trying to figure out how to avoid just wasting it.
23:05 Burning it and things like that. Of course, in the prescribed fire context, that's great. You know, some of it will be burned, but there's a lot more of it than can be burned through prescribed fire. And so they have this residuals that they're trying to figure out. So they're not going, the JPA itself is not doing fuel reduction work. The fuel reduction work is being done by the members of the JPA. And then the JPA is focused on how can we support
23:31 Business or utilization activities of the biomass. In that particular JPA example, they have three main focuses. One is bringing back, saving burning forest power, which I mentioned, it's an older business that is having a lot of challenges and they want to focus on trying to revitalize that business. Number two is... Sorry, is that a biomass plan? Yes, it is. Okay. And number two is to bring a new advanced technology...
23:59 CHP system to a mill, a very small CHP system to an existing mill that would like to see that there and their community would like to see that in Wairica. And then the third main focus for that JPA is the Western Shasta RCD is working closely with the Shasta Trinity Ranger District to respond to the volumes of biomass that we are expecting to see from the master stewardship agreement that has been entered into with Sierra Pacific Industries.
24:26 That was done sort of at a federal deal, and now the forests, the forest rangers and the districts are having to deal with what do we do with the volume of that that we're expecting, and they really want to focus on how to get it out and how to market it and what to do about it because it's going to be a lot.
24:44 So those are the three focuses. I probably shouldn't go through that deep amount of detail with everyone, but that's an example. And then how are you involved with those JPAs? So, right. So I'm a consultant and I was hired by the grant recipients in each of the five areas. In that, just to use that one as an example, Fall River RCD was the grant recipient in that example.
25:09 So I work for Fall River RCD and I've helped them for several years getting their paperwork to, like, we had three public meetings where we had, we invited people from all the different, you know, to talk about should we even do a JPA? So there, you know, you had already done this, okay? So we, we had to do all of that groundwork with the RCD people, the people who work for the RCD, the people who sit on the board with RCD.
25:35 The community members who utilize their services. Sure. Okay. So we got through that, and now we are, I'm also a lawyer, and so I, now I'm helping them develop their JPA documentation. By the way, just for a fun piece of information, I got my first job at Mono County Council, so Marshall Rudolph was my first boss, and was my first job out of law school, so I'm familiar with this building. I didn't know about this space, though. Oh, Christina, just a comment. Yeah. This is not,
26:04 Native language to all of us. So when you use your, you know, CHPs, it's like. Oh, combined heat and power, sorry. I try to really avoid acronyms. CHPs again, what? Huh? Combined heat and power. Combined heat and power. Okay, gotcha. Thank you. Trina, yes, go ahead. Okay. So when we're talking about the funding and what it can cover, are there any limitations within the scope of the biomass?
26:33 I'm thinking specifically of our challenges of transportation because we're not close to any biomass processing facilities and so the transportation is one of the biggest hurdles that we've run into so would this funding be able to
26:56 Support a business, a transportation business in that field as well, or is there limitations on just simply removal and production? So there hasn't been any limitations set on the funding because we haven't developed how the funding is going to work with the conservancies. What I do know, though, about the conservancies is they're really hoping on focusing on
27:21 business development that is as close to the source of the biomass as possible in order to lower the cost and basically lower the distance. Of course, there will still be the need for some support around that and transportation businesses like hauling businesses are certainly part of the ecosystem that has to be supported. So I definitely would expect there to be, you know, no limitation on that. I just, I would expect there would also be hope that
27:51 People would be developing businesses closer to the sources, you know, and reducing transportation as much as possible. I mean, we have a history in California of spending money on transportation subsidies, but that's really a band-aid. It doesn't actually solve the problem long-term. It's just sort of a quick fix. But to your point about, like, a business that wants to invest in a hauling truck and things like that, or pay for driver's insurance, I mean, those are the kinds of things that definitely are within the scope of the work, yeah.
28:20 Do you have a question? In some way, you know, this effort wouldn't be an island. It wouldn't work on its own. So one of the things I'm interested in hearing and understanding is how this would work with the other efforts that we have, because this is a process-rich environment for biomass, but we need the outcome. But one of the things that I'm worried about is investing in yet another potentially duplicative process.
28:50 rather than focusing directly on getting outcomes and solutions on the ground now. I'm so glad you asked that question because it really opens up the conversation around what role could ESCOG really play to help this situation.
29:06 And the idea is that these JPAs generally, and specifically this one, will be able to help coordinate and keep the communications lines open. So that is one of the things that really happens that's unfortunate in all of these regions is that people end up being in silos or having other challenges in communication. Also, you know, with the federal agencies the way they are right now, they're challenged.
29:31 They're challenged with not having enough staff. They're challenged with having different types of mandates. And so the communication lines with our federal partners is something that's going to take some focus. And so, yeah, it's such a great question because that really comes down to the crux of the matter, which is...
29:50 looking at ESCOG and the other JPAs to really serve as a hub of information, really, providing also that fiscal support, administrative support that you'd get funding for, not asking anyone to pony up that, and hoping to see that that will really
30:06 Help avoid duplicative efforts and also conflicting efforts. I mean, for the RCDs, I'm just using that one example. There are four others if you want to ever go into those, but they're totally different. But with RCDs, it was tough because they're all out doing fuel reduction. So they want to talk like, well, who's going after which grant? And which area in MODOK needs help from Fall River to do work in their jurisdiction, which is a big point of JPAs, right?
30:33 Because of just the way the road network is and things like that. And they're like, can we, can you do that? And so that's why, you know, again, it's really about communication. So I have a question. I'm aware of Tuamne County. There's a project called Heartwood Biomass. Is that correct? So that's like, would that be an example of one of the micro businesses that was created because of this? Is that something that, and that's,
31:04 A small company of like 14 jobs that is dealing with the biomass like so specifically aren't they making like little bundles of wood and wood chips and just doing something with it so that it turns into a business as opposed to just because I'm sitting here and I'm trying to think like how would this work and I'm looking at Janet Hatfield who is with our Whitebark Institute and Janet's job and focus is to get the biomass out but then the next question is
31:33 Who do we give it to so that they can do something useful with it? That's what you're talking about here, correct? Yes, yes, absolutely, and Hartwood is a great example. Okay, and then, so my next question is, in my opinion, when I hear biomass, I'm always thinking that that's a power plant to make electricity, but you're talking about any use of the biomass, correct? Lots of uses. Lots of uses. So can you give us other examples, because I feel like I've heard of this, but maybe I just made it up, that there's a, like,
32:02 You can do sort of like engineered wood with the biomass. It's not going to, you know, our wood, our timber in this area isn't so useful for like traditional uses is my understanding, but it can be used in other capacities. So is that something that any of these JPAs have started to work on is some kind of like manufacturing capability right in the area?
32:29 So they're all exploring. I mean, they're all starting. I mean, that's why we kind of cut, like, you know, there's been all this work and you guys were way, you were ahead, right? And all these people are coming and now we're like hitting the same place. So we're just like right in the groove here. So nobody has actually, you know, picked a business and started. I mean, we're just about to do that. So I don't have, Heartwood started before this.
32:50 In that region, CSED, the Economic Development District, their board voted last month or two months ago to get into this and start making this happen. So that's sort of the timing.
33:01 In terms of examples of other types of wood products, yeah, there are many. I would recommend a presentation by Martin Tourer from the Watershed Research and Training Center. He could come and give a presentation or even a workshop on the plethora of types of things you can use. I mean, there are, I mean, I think that there's an example in this region of someone considering doing kitty litter, which I would just support wholeheartedly as a cat owner.
33:30 But there are there are initial investments in that type of equipment that need to be made. And this is the exact kind of program that would say, look, we can get a lot more out of buying a million dollar piece of equipment for you that you're going to now, you know, have a business for 20 years than giving a bunch of people transportation subsidies for three years, right? Like we're going to get a lot more bang for our buck if we invest in that type of equipment. So there.
33:54 There are many things. Hi. I was going to help you out a little bit. We actually have a business proponent. It's very relevant. She works with me on this project. Subcontractor to clear. Working first on the Southern Sierra Westside project and now helping with this. But I just wanted to let the board know that whenever the time might be appropriate to take public comment, you do have a proponent of a project. I thought so.
34:24 Just the sort of thing you're describing in the audience. So I think it would be... It was a kitty litter example. I think he's here. I haven't met him yet. Oh, no, it's the pellet. Our pellet. Okay. So we will do that. Can I ask one more question? Absolutely. So we have one more question and then we would love to take public comment. A couple more questions. Sorry, I only saw Trina. I got you. Well, I am the most important. Okay. Great. So as I'm listening to you and we're...
34:52 Going back to contract management and financial administration, so as part of the vision of what you're describing, we as a JPA would then utilize our administrative capabilities, whether we need to grow them or not would be a question for a different day, to start to seek out those opportunities and contract with maybe
35:21 entrepreneurs or established companies to take on our biomass out of our forest and utilize them into these because there is a plethora. I've actually done it all the way into electronics, believe it or not. There is a plethora out there. I mean, you're talking about billions of dollars and this is the base for those industries. Is that kind of the process that you're looking for?
35:50 If that is what the JPA wants to do, 100%. You can even back, you know, you can go a little slower in that you could coordinate relationships and you don't necessarily directly have to contract yet, you could, but you can also arrange for contracts and provide contract templates and do things to support and then eventually, you know, grow into that, what you described. So, you know, you can take it step by step.
36:20 And I think if I may answer that question as well, the opportunity here is to leverage Ms. Darlington's expertise and experience in
36:32 Biomass Utilization in different parts of California, the complexity of working with federal agencies and, you know, startup entrepreneurs and people who are doing fuel management, leveraging the JPA to do an exploratory conversation over the next few months, leveraging funding she has to talk to the different partners. So I don't think there's anything...
36:56 that is going to be deterministic in this conversation about the role that ESCOG may play in the future. This is an opportunity for us to really explore if there's an opportunity to leverage the JPA we have to deal with some of these complicated conversations that were already
37:11 These are conversations I already have with the Forest Service or that Sierra Business Council is having with forest entrepreneurs to make sure that there's alignment, to make sure that there's opportunities with some of the biomass utilization, particularly as we do have this focus on fuel management and fuel reduction in the next few years. So this is really just an exploratory facilitated conversation over the next few months.
37:39 I think these are all really important and valid questions that we need to be asked, but I just want to make it clear to the board and also clear to the attendees in the room that we're not intending to make decisions about ESCOG's role in facilitating this today. Thank you. Thank you, Elaine, and thank you, Trina. I think, yeah, that's where I am to clarify and to boil it down to the most basic level. ESCOG, the board has not yet made a commitment to.
38:05 Pursuing anything around this. Correct. So that is where we are. We're getting information about what if and if you did and maybe could be. And so even to talk about all the different modalities of, you know, dispensing out of biomass is...
38:18 Something of interest at this point that the decision for ESCOG's role and for us to take this on to basically say to our director, you know, we want to do this. What does that mean? What does the funding look like? What is the capacity? What would be added capacity? Those are steps that we need to take out before we even begin to, you know, further evaluate.
38:41 actions into the future. Absolutely. And I think you, you know, could play a critical part in that in helping us understand. So even jumping into this conversation is kind of we're all sitting here going, well, we haven't even decided to do this yet. Well, I like the enthusiasm. Yeah, I think that's what we are. Right. But I also think just understanding, because I think some of us really just wanted to wrap our heads around what it even is, was really, I think, the challenge. But just to clarify, there's no motion in the packet. There's no action required. Yeah.
39:10 But Supervisor Griffiths, you had a question. Hi, Christiana. Hi. Good to see you again. Good to see you. Okay, so what is FSI insurance, FSI policy? So that's feedstock supply insurance, and it's a product I can talk with you about offline, but essentially it's being developed by a Canadian corporation that is interested in supporting long-term feedstock supply contracts with an insurance-type product. It's one pathway. I'm actually more focused on creating a contract guarantee fund.
39:41 From the state of California, I think that'll be more effective. But it's still a good product. It could be. I don't want to really dispose of it. Anyway, it's really a side conversation I'm happy to have. And I did really want to end. My plan was to end with introducing Stacey Corliss and asking her to fill in anything I missed.
39:58 in my presentation. But we dove into those questions so fast, I didn't really have a chance to do that. But Stacy Corliss has been working with my shop for the past year and a half on the West Side pilot. And then, you know, we got to talking and we're like, why aren't we talking to ESCOG and trying to get them in? So it's really from her impetus that we're here today to bring this to you.
40:20 And I'm happy to invite her up to fill in anything that I may have missed or that she'd like to add now that she's got the benefit of all of your questions as well. Thanks. Good morning, ESCOG Board. So I think all I would add is just a little local context that not only I think was there was there interest from
40:41 some folks on the dais and your staff in the project that we were working in the statewide LCI pilot project. I think Supervisor Salcido, Elaine, and others attended a workshop that Christiana and I did in Sonora a couple months ago. And then
41:02 Simultaneously, as many of you know, I'm also a consultant with Whitebark Institute working on the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance, and in all of these conversations, biomass utilization questions have emerged about the east side, and it really led to could this exploration of governance structures, which of course is a teeny, teeny, tiny little piece of the biomass puzzle that is one of those big jigsaw puzzles that would probably take you years to
41:31 You know, solve and you have to leave on your coffee table forever. But it is one thing that we could bring. We have this great JPA in ESCOG, a Joint Powers Authority, that could potentially take this on or at least serve as a convener to have some much needed discussions about feedstock supply and the status of projects and potential roles and just looking very pretty narrowly at what a governance structure could solve.
42:00 And then potentially be a convener and a location for some of these bigger, more intractable issues that biomass projects all over the state, all over the West are facing. So look forward to continue the discussions. Thank you. Any questions for me? Questions? Let me make sure I look down. Don't miss anyone. What is, what was it, C? If it's an acronym, I'm the wrong person, Jen. C-S-E-D-D.
42:30 Oh, I can answer that one. That is the Central Sierra Economic Development District. And that was a title. Yeah. Oh. I think you're looking at the second to last slide. Yeah, next steps. And then the CSED and then ESCOG, and I tried to get that title. But much like ESCOG, it's focused solely on economic development, but it is a JPA composed of the five counties from Mariposa up to Alpine and the city of Sonora.
43:03 Quite similar governance structure. Oh, Angel, I always forget it. Go ahead. So is the idea that the JPA, ESCOG in this case, would have the contract to supply the fuel for the project and it would be the stability of that?
43:29 I'm trying to understand you're very complicated. It could or it could not be. It's up to the JPA to determine that. It depends on the needs in the community. Whether or not, so for example, in the one that we've been talking quite a bit about, the RCD-led JPA, they don't need that because they already have relationships. They just need contract templates that they can enter into that have these great provisions and these guarantees that I've been talking about. So they aren't looking at the JPA to serve as a broker.
43:57 It could be in other examples that they do want a JPA to be a broker. I mean, right now, there isn't any that have, like, put that on the front of their problem list. But, you know, like, for example, just really quick, the other one is three counties, Placer, El Dorado, Nevada. What they're looking at is setting up either through an agreement or through an actual agency. They haven't decided which path yet, paperwork-wise. But they're specifically looking at how to attract.
44:25 Okay. Okay, yeah.
44:49 Question? Yeah, just on timing, I mean, if we choose to move forward with these initial phases today, what's the next step look like and how long? So what Stacey and I would like to do is spend the next couple of months working more closely with all the actors in the space around here and figuring all those things out and having more in-depth conversations around that and then hopefully coming back to your board in September, if that works out, to...
45:17 take action on formally participating in the program. And all that requires is an action to formally participate. I mean, you could do a resolution. I mean, you don't have to. We just need that indication for the funding that we will take the request. Just as an aside, the funding through the Sierra Nevada Conservancy will be directed funding. So at this point, they are not indicating that there will be a grant program or grant.
45:47 document required. But it is very important to the Sierra Nevada Conservancy that your JPA, if you want to get involved and, you know, pursue this, work closely with the ready landscape concept that they have been developing in this region. So those need to be in cohesion and leveraging each other. That's very important to the director. How near are we to being able to leverage that? Now that's a Stacy Corliss question.
46:19 Coming all the way up here to stay here. I don't know. But as many of you know, and I think Kristen is going to brief you on later in your agenda, the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance is active through funding from Whitebark, the state of California, is working on becoming an active wildfire planning and implementation collaborative. So that is, that's where the ready landscape concept lives, is that
46:46 You know, the vision is Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance would take on that role, prioritize this landscape level project planning and that the region would apply for block grant funding and that there would be a biomass solution, you know, in place or at least a plan for it being in place to make all that work. Thanks very much. Yeah, I don't see how we... And Whitebark Institute, we're hoping.
47:16 Janet's here. I won't put her on the spot. You know, it will obviously be included in these conversations this summer, along with other key wildfire resilience partners, like the Inyo National Forest, who we have made the name. Thanks. Yeah. Okay. Any other questions?
47:34 Elaine, looks like you have something. I do. I have one more comment. Thank you. Relevant to Supervisor Griffith's questions about the Central Sierra Economic Development District and Supervisor McFarland's question around tying this into other efforts.
47:49 The Central Sierra Economic Development District, which also serves as Mother Low Job Training Center, has been ESCOG's counterpart in Sierra Jobs First for the counties on the west side. And so under Sierra Jobs First, there's a whole emphasis on forestry and job creation, entrepreneurship that's based out of the economic opportunity. Obviously on the west side, they're much further ahead of us. They have a timber industry with a lot more trees.
48:15 But that is still one of those economic opportunities that we have invested in through Sierra Jobs First and also through some of our comprehensive economic development strategy efforts on the east side. And so there is a bit of a through line in between these different efforts in economic development and workforce development. And over the past few years, we've had conversations about the importance of the Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Resilience Project in catalyzing workforce development regionally.
48:45 And the opportunities that also presents to Bishop in Inyo County, through some of the workforce development program that Sarah Coso is doing. So these things really are tied together. At the other end of this, all of these...
48:57 And I think, you know, Mr. Patterson, Town of Mammoth Lakes can speak to some of the challenges that they have faced in just some of the preliminary treatments happening around the Town of Mammoth Lakes.
49:16 And biomass storage. And so these are questions that keep coming up again and again and again. So I just want to emphasize that, again, I don't think that we're necessarily even suggesting that the JPA, the ESCOG JPA needs to serve in that capacity in the future. But in this moment where we have an opportunity.
49:34 For someone to facilitate that conversation among many partners, I think the ESCOG is well positioned to serve as a convener. And I also would want to emphasize that in that it's very important to have representation of each of the four jurisdictions of the Eastern Sierra that they have a seat at the table and that we are all part of this biomass conversation which is going to have a regional impact not just in wildfire resiliency and fluid management but also in economic development and workforce development. Thank you.
50:04 Supervisor McFarlane. Yeah, what I was going to say is just I don't see how we can say no to this. We have to close this loop and we're being offered some amazing resources to do it because right now the circle is broken and we've got to close it and this is the best way to do it. So thanks. Go ahead. So the discussion, the comment that we might bring this back as early as September to discuss about again.
50:33 is there's a lot of work to be done in the nitty-gritty of this to make sure that the funding is appropriate, that I don't want it to come to ESCOG, yeah, we're going to do that, and suddenly Elaine's left trying to figure out how to do this. I want to be sure that the funding is in place, that we have the ability to hire staff, that the scope of this work is clear, and that it's not just suddenly, well, ESCOG's going to do it all.
50:56 ESCOG is going to go out and find, you know, biomass facilities that will come live here and work, and she's going to find the people to do it, and we're going to create jobs, and she's going to work with the forester. I mean, let's have a very clear scope of what we're going to do and what will be the mechanism to do that between now and potentially September. I'd like to, you know, we aren't prepared to talk about that today, but I'd like to make sure that that's, you know, clarified. Thank you. I appreciate that.
51:24 Can you come to the podium, sir? The only thing we need by September is just your initial interest, just a confirmation that you need, because I need to be able to tell the Sierra Nevada Conservancy and have evidence that your board took action to support the initial concept. No commitment to anything specific. Thank you. But just a point of procedure, then. The evidence that we support this, would that be
51:50 So is there any public comment either online or?
52:20 No comments at this time. Well, look who's coming to the dais. Oh, wow, it's automatic these days. Thanks, ESCOG Board, Janet Hapville, Whitebark Institute. I just wanted to provide a tiny bit of history for I know some of the ESCOG Board members have been very involved in some of the work happening in this vicinity of the region and others have not. So I want to try to close a little bit of the gap in the understanding and support of...
52:52 This concept and the role that ESCOG could play. So most of you might know, I'm sometimes affiliated with the Eastern Sierra Climate and Community Resilience Project, or the Mammoth Donut. And about five years ago, when that project came to me,
53:12 I knew I was going to inherit a lot of additional work above and beyond funding the actual work on the ground. And biomass utilization is one of those components. We performed an early needs assessment, which identify biomass workforce development and sustainable funding as really foundational elements to solving the wildfire crisis. And with that came a responsibility to
53:37 Not put our head in the sand to like we're generating a massive amount of material as a result of this work. And so we have a planning effort that has been ongoing for the last four years. There is a bioenergy facility in permitting. It's wrought with challenges. Christiana's group is well familiar with those, trying to address some of those head on. It's not in the bag, but I will just tell you
54:06 It's hard to articulate the scope of the challenge and how much time every day that we spend trying to figure out what to do with this material. Right now, take a drive around the scenic loop, you're going to see hundreds if not thousands of piles that are going to be burned in winter months whenever the windows present themselves. Might be a high tourism season, might not. That expose, that increase our exposure.
54:32 For additional two years than what would otherwise be, you know, the treatment is done, our exposure is reduced. So leaving those piles on the landscape is not the best solution environmentally or economically for anyone. I think we all know that. It's our only solution at the moment at the scale that we're working for all of this excess material. So I would just offer that this
54:56 Conversation is likely happening because I was getting a lot of emails like, hey, can you coordinate this? And there's a point at which, you know, we're working our tails off, but we can't do this alone. And this is a request that we made early and often that this problem is far too large and we all have to come to the table to figure out a solution. So thanks. Thank you. Oh, hello, Nathan.
55:28 Good morning, Board. I'm Nathan Sill. I am the Natural Resources Program Manager for the Inyo National Forest. My comments won't be anything new to you, but this issue is probably the greatest issue we are facing with achieving our forest restoration goals and creating fire-resilient landscapes, as many of you have already heard.
55:50 I just wanted to express my gratitude for the conversation and support for ESCOG moving forward with this conversation and trying to figure out exactly how you all can serve in finding a solution to this huge problem for us. So thank you. Thank you for being here. Oh, Linda has a question for you, Nate. Can you come back? Sorry. Thanks for being here. I appreciate it as always. Best case scenario.
56:22 What would be the timeline on something like ORMAT's project out there? I mean, best case scenario would have been a couple years ago. But I think from a permitting standpoint, from our agency's perspective, best case scenario is probably two years. Okay. And that is best case.
56:42 I think so. Given that we still have yet to even receive an application from West Biofuels for siting the location on National Forest System lands, we would still have to go through the environmental permitting process. And then construction, I think best case is probably two years. So two years includes construction, not just the permit? I think so. That's a pretty fast timeline.
57:09 We do have some relatively new NEPA authorities that allow us to streamline some things like this, so we would certainly look to utilize those if at all possible. Two years is probably a pretty aggressive timeline. Is there precedent on other forests for a facility such as this? Not that I'm aware of. Nationwide, this would be the first, as far as I know. Okay, well, hope springs eternal, right? Yeah.
57:38 Thank you. Thank you. Any comment online, Angie? No comments at this time. Come on. Greg Cook, GC Forest Products, Mammoth Firewood. I've babbled on in front of a few of you more than once. We're currently proposing a pellet plant to go along with our firewood timber harvest. We do a little bit of lumber and other things. I just wanted to kind of...
58:10 I'm understanding there's people from Inyo here too. So we serve Inyo Mono County, basically in firewood, a few different products, including recreation with bundled firewood to the campground management facilities. There were several things that were touched on that we're experiencing now with our pellet plant, feedstock agreements, things like that, that are really becoming stumbling blocks for us getting this project going forward.
58:37 So I just wanted to throw that out there. And there's been talk about transportation and subsidies and things like that. So I think at this point, I just wanted to let you all know that from a business owner who's been almost 50 years in this forest, I think I've got stuff to add. And maybe in smaller groups, if you guys decide to go forward, that I can help with. We are looking to
59:03 be completely engaged with we are working on whitebarks programs now through through their harvest harvest contractors and such and seeing kind of what's going on in the forest so there are projects that are trying to go forward but there are several obstacles that probably need help through these public entities to actually get this
59:31 Sooner than later, get the traction and get it going forward. So I just want to throw that out there. So I'll try and participate as much as I can. Go ahead, Linda. Thank you, Greg, for being here. Appreciate it. So you're not currently able to make pellets yet? We are in the permitting process at this point. We've run into some on the financial study. We've run into some issues with financing. One of them, the two largest ones are feedstock agreements.
1:00:01 to be able to get commitments from entities, financing. I think the most important thing to understand is this is not cheap. We're looking at a pellet plant that's $10 million investment. Seriously, the market that we're looking at is very local in Yamano County, 3,000 tons a year.
1:00:25 So between the feedstock agreements that seem to be three to five years, financing is 20 plus, right? So that doesn't line up at all to try and find that financing at this point. The other aspect of it is like for a pellet plant, typically they're taking residues off of large sawmills. So that feedstock is
1:00:51 Virtually free, let's say, you know, some transportation costs and things. For us to do the breakdown from logs that are coming off of, it's been called biomass, it's logs, right? It's trees. Yeah. Okay. That breakdown equipment is very expensive. For us to break down the logs, you're looking at $2 million. You know, investment in the forest, which is another challenge, is where do you locate this equipment?
1:01:20 Right? If you want it on private land, we all know where land values are at. It's really difficult to justify that investment separate from the equipment to do the breakdown, to get the material to, you know, where you can actually, you know, bring it to market, do the manufacturing to bring it to market.
1:01:41 Something like West Biofuels is awesome. My understanding is they're not necessarily vertically integrated, so they're not coming in to do their material breakdown. They're looking for someone to actually provide that. We'd love to do that. The equipment that we're looking at, the pricing of that equipment, and the production that that equipment can do, we'd only be looking at taking 10 or 20 percent of the output of the equipment. Would that address everything that's going on in our forest?
1:02:13 Maybe, yeah, you know, if you're grading out lumber or you're grading out, I heard engineered lumber, viable option, log home materials, firewood, the stuff that we do, it's all there. The problem is, you know, we got all this going on, right? There's a lot of movement. So it's really going to take some commitment and soon. My personal opinion is, is if we don't have answers soon, the money's going to go away. The interest is going to disappear.
1:02:43 I don't think our, personally, I don't think our answers lie in faraway locations to take whatever's going on here. It really needs to be addressed on, there's so many positive attributes to doing this locally, you know, job creation, et cetera, skilled up jobs, the whole thing, so. Where, where are you proposing to put the actual plant? So we,
1:03:12 We meaning my family owns property at Sierra Business Park. We've got some developed, partially developed. We've done the improvements for my firewood business. We have an additional acre for the pellets. It's tight, but it could work. But we really would be relying on hopefully finding secondary staging. We have some temporary solutions, I think, at this point, based on
1:03:40 The harvest contractor that we're currently working with through Whitebark, but it's all temporary. And we're talking volumes. I mean, at this point, you've seen my, possibly seen the decks at the Mammoth Yard, and now at the Sierra Business Park, we're decking logs. I've got five years worth of firewood inventory, right? I'm done. You know, like taking more inventory in is really difficult right now. But the pace of the work going on in the forest is creating a glut, so.
1:04:10 I just want you guys to kind of understand that, you know, some, not an urgency, but, you know, things, it can't sit idle for much longer if there's going to be a local solution to this. That's all I've really got to say. Thank you so much. Wait, I see microphones turning on. Yeah. You dropped wood off at my house yesterday afternoon, so thank you. Appreciate the business. Do you, I mean, have you looked at down the hill? Yeah. And does that make any sense? No, absolutely.
1:04:39 We are actually got a couple of things we're working on. We'll see. I mean, yeah, I mean, Inyo was huge for us, right? I mean, we got into, about 12 years ago, we made a pretty strong commitment to sales in Inyo County, and it's working, and we're actually in preliminary conversations with some partnerships down there, so we'll see where it goes.
1:05:04 I think that some of the value in the conversation that we can help facilitate over this summer is also looking at broadening the opportunities for storage beyond Mono County and what the costs and benefits of those might be. Yeah, more just a comment. Thanks. I mean, the work that you and your family are doing, you're closing the loop. Yeah. And I think if this process can be worth anything, it's to help.
1:05:31 Folks like yourself get over these hurdles to make this actually work here. Just to add to that, I mean, we're just one small aspect, right? I mean, the forestry community is always looking for opportunity. And, you know, even the folks that we're working with, the harvesters we're currently working with, the Red's Meadow Treatment and all of that stuff. I mean, these people want to be here. Yeah. But you've got to figure out how to, you know, I mean, it's...
1:06:00 It's a full circle, right? And the circle's only half closed right now, so. Yeah. Appreciate that. Thank you. Thank you. And thank you for being here today. I think it helped us turn this into like a practical solution because sometimes the theoretical can be challenging, at least for me. So any other questions or comments? Elaine, I think you have what you need because there's no formal resolution required.
1:06:24 That's correct. I appreciate the robust discussion this morning. Thank you, and thank you to the members of the public who came and supported this initiative as well. Yes, thanks. And thank you, Christiana and Stacey, for being here, bringing this to our attention. So next, item 5.2, we are not doing today because Nick Buckmaster wasn't able to be here. So we'll move on to 5.3, and that's the fiscal year 25-26 ESCOG budget.
1:06:51 Good morning again, Board. Thank you so very much for the robust discussion in the last item. I think that's going to be really valuable, and I look forward to continuing to keep you updated on that. With regards to the fiscal year 25-26 budget, staff is presenting a balanced budget to you this year with revenues in the amount of $1,988,000.
1:07:15 I just want to highlight a couple of the grants that we're anticipating and the breakdown of how I've allocated the cost to implement those projects over the next year.
1:07:34 As you know, we have received three grants through Sierra Jobs First for project work in addition to the capacity funding that we received from the Sierra Business Council to support staff in the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. That totals approximately a million dollars. We also continue to have about $930,000 from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife Grant to continue to support work in environmental permitting and planning, expanding the Eastern Sierra climate community.
1:08:03 Thank you. Thank you.
1:08:07 I have included three contracts, funding for three contractors under expenditures that would be funded by Sierra Jobs first. The first is approximately $1,000 for a Inyo Mono agricultural study to expand product diversification and look at opportunities to activate different agricultural opportunities in the Eastern Sierra. The second is the Recreation Incubator.
1:08:34 Hiring a strategic consultant to support...
1:08:38 and facilitate meetings around recreation, bringing stakeholders to the table under that effort and documenting that in a deliverable that we can use beyond Sarah Jobs first to guide alignment between recreation stakeholders in the region. That's in the amount of $130,000 and then $170,000 approximately for a consultant to do the existing conditions analysis for Chipmunk Canyon.
1:09:04 I've also included a blend of revenue to support the contract we have for the Inyo County Wildfire Coordinator to support wildfire resiliency efforts through the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, as well as approximately $117,000 for a recreation coordinator supported by the Inyo National Forest Service liaison funding as well as Sierra Jobs First funding.
1:09:29 There's approximately $50,000 for the Inyo County Project Management Office, which we've agreed to as well. And then there is a small amount of revenue beyond that to
1:09:42 Consider a part-time contract assistant depending on how some of these other contracts shape up and what the requirement is. But I did want to include that funding in there to provide some flexibility if there is an opportunity to bring on some additional support capacity for grant management and such. I've also included $15,000 for the development of an economic development district application.
1:10:08 I've looked at several of those applications, and they seem very straightforward. I've reached out to some of the other economic development districts to get a sense of cost. Unfortunately, they haven't gotten back to me, but I've included that in a placeholder, although the...
1:10:25 UC Cooperative Extension Community Economic Development staff we have and Mr. Aaron Welcher has agreed to provide technical assistance which is within his scope to help the region develop that application so we may not need to use that $15,000 this year. I just wanted to highlight each of those contracts because that is
1:10:48 That's relative to an upcoming item regarding contracting under each of those efforts. I'm happy to take any questions you have. We've also been joined by Ms. Bunn from the Mono County Finance Office. She can answer any additional questions you have on the details of the budget. But this time, I would request that your board approve the fiscal year 25-26 budget as presented. Thank you. Go ahead.
1:11:14 Thank you very much, Elaine. I have a question on the wildfire coordinator expenditure of $70,000. Where is that offset? Is that offset by revenue? It's offset by revenue under the Inyo National Forest liaison funding as well as the California Department of Fish and Wildlife funding that we have. And so the newly renewed funding
1:11:44 For wildfire coordinators, where did that go then? That will also fund a portion of Ms. Feiler's time. So she's an Inyo County employee that serves part-time to work on regional efforts under the ESCOG. And then the...
1:12:02 Cal Fire funding could be allocated in part to staff and then in part to other activities. And I forget all of the activities that they included in their Inyo County application, but I think it included things like working with additional consultants, funding to develop GIS maps for regional coordination about wildfire resiliency efforts, some other technical assistance costs. And Kim, maybe you know part of this. How is that in parity with Mono County? I do not know the answer to that question. I apologize.
1:12:32 Yeah, I'm not sure what Mono County is contributing at this time. Okay, so I do know the answer to that. If both counties receive the same for a wildfire coordinator position, then the contribution here that's going directly to Inyo, why, how is that in, it doesn't make sense to me. Maybe Nathan knows more about this.
1:13:08 I can try to address the question. So I think, as the board may recall, this action predated the funding that existed through the Cal Fire County Coordinator Program, which was renewed. It was $150 for the? Yeah, $155 maybe, if I remember right. So we each got that, each county. Correct. But that was recent. That was within the last couple of months. And so when your board took action to approve this and my board in your county,
1:13:37 And that when the council approved the transfer, if you will, of Ms. Viler to the ESCOG for at least a portion, if not the entirety of her work, that there was there was no certainty. There was no knowledge, actually, of the CAL FIRE grant existing at that point in time. What we had speculated at a staff level in the background was that money may become available. And if it did, if it would.
1:14:01 What we would like to try to see and do would be to blend the work that's being done by Mono's coordinator and Inyo's coordinator and recognize that in the work that would be logical to be done on a regional basis, there would be some sharing of that responsibility. And each county is going to have county-specific work that needs to be done that could not be funded through the ESCOG dollars.
1:14:30 Inyo was notably potentially giving up some resource by transferring Kristen over to the ESCOG prior to the Cal Fire funding coming up, and that was something that my board had a little bit of consternation and concern around, but now that the funding is there for both the counties for this work, I think we actually have a good problem to solve for, which is we probably need to look at some additional capacity.
1:14:59 And what that looks like is something that Kristen and Elaine and I had kind of knocked around a bit, but we had not really gotten to any answers for. And so I think it's all to say that what we are sort of thinking in the short term, and I don't want to speak for Kristen, I'll let her sort of get the specifics in here, is that actually we would not be funding the entirety of Kristen's position through this ESCOG money. Instead, we'd be...
1:15:23 using a portion of her time for the regional work that is sort of identified through that work program and then using the CAL FIRE money for the Inyo County work that's specific. I don't see any reason that Mono couldn't have a similar situation in a relationship with Wendy, but I do think that the issue that we are going to run into is
1:15:47 How we spend down the entirety of that CAL FIRE money and or the money that's coming through the ESCOG without some additional capacity. So what I'm hearing you say, I think, is that the $70,000 towards the Wildfire Coordinator, which is Kristen, would equally benefit Mono County as it would Inyo County? The intent was always to have the ESCOG dollars be focused toward regional work, not...
1:16:16 Yeah, so yes, I think the short answer to the question is yes. Okay, it still doesn't sit right with me. Okay. You got 150, we got 150. Inyo County, you got an extra 70,000. Okay, so that on the budget doesn't settle well with me, and I would ask our other Mono County people to speak up. Please.
1:16:38 Yeah, I think we're missing a critical piece of information, which is what Mono County's Wildfire Coordinator Grant committed to, how it overlapped with Inyo's, and what the plan going forward is. I think we're going to hear some of that later in today's agenda, but I think it's something that we need to be very watchful for as this regional approach evolves, is parity of outcome and effort. And so I'm glad you're here to speak to this. Thanks.
1:17:07 And I think hopefully we'll have some more answers to that later because many of, in your presentation that's in the packet, many of the projects that you're looking at cross both counties. And we also just heard, at least from the biomass side, that solving these is going to be a regional issue. I mean, that's how this used to work. Logs used to go downhill to be processed. They weren't processed up here. You know, folks used to really understand weather and adapt to it rather than try to fight it.
1:17:37 So that's where I think I'm at with the budget side is taking more of a look at what's on our list. There are things like CWPP completion, other things that are on both Inyo and Mono's list and seeing how the outcomes of this partnership basically realize the funding division.
1:18:09 This board a couple of months ago, which was, you know, I think Inyo offered to step up to help fill a gap that was there when the issue was presented by ESCOG. I don't see this, I didn't see it then, and I don't see it now as opportunistic. I think we have more work than we, you know, have capacity for. So I'm not trying to find a way to offset our costs. I want to be very clear about that. I recognize the concern that exists.
1:18:39 for Mono County. And frankly, I think that there would be great value in Mono County coming forward with resources and capacity from within the organization to help balance some of that out. But all of this predated the existence of the $300,000 that has now become apparent. And so I think the challenge that we are actually faced with is maybe not the
1:19:02 The way that the dollars are flowing, but how we are actually utilizing all of those dollars, because the horizon for that $150,000 is actually quite short, and I think we're prudent to spend down that money first and foremost on county-specific activities, and then look at how we are addressing the regional ones as well, and knowing that we can't double bill, you know, we don't want to leave money on the table, and I think how we do that is going to be a collaborative effort.
1:19:29 And the horizon for the $150,000 each, not only is that short, but also there's an exceedingly short horizon for this $930,000. That's the Fish and Wildlife Prop 1 money that we're going to consider in a minute here, expanding into the West Mono Basin, a project that has yet to even formally kick off. So we're running up against some timelines where we have a lot of resources, but yet...
1:19:54 Our capacity on the ground to actually produce stuff has not kept up. And I think to Supervisor Salcido's concern and comment, I think that's something we really are going to need to look at in the next few months is how we create equitable capacity to create that leads to real outcomes in both counties because the need is real in both places. And that's our job is, I think, to ensure that that actually happens.
1:20:25 Yeah, I agree with that wholeheartedly, and I think I would look to Kristen or Wendy to, you know, think about and provide maybe some solutions that they've considered around some of that capacity development. I think there probably are resources that are available. The last thing that I'll just say is that, you know, I think one of, you know, the awkward and sort of incremental or iterative elements of the ESCOG and its development in this new phase is how and where
1:20:55 The staff live within the organizational structure of our five organizations, essentially, that are now here. And it has been that, you know, Inyo has been the actual employer for Elaine, for Council, you know, certainly Angela's coming here from the town. And I think that that was just part of that, like, who can move quickly in this in terms of bringing
1:21:22 The employment need that is there, recognizing that in some cases, such as some of these projects that are coming forward, it is logical for the ESCOG to contract directly with an entity or an individual to carry out a discrete element of work. In other cases, such as with Kristen, there was an existing employment agreement with an individual, and so we were basically just loaning that person through what was already a preset sort of structure.
1:21:50 I think that it is very logical for, you know, at least Mono County, if not also the city, if it becomes applicable in some cases, to consider whether other resources can be brought forward. Because I don't want it to look like Inyo is the one that's benefiting entirely from this. And I think there's a flip side of that coin, which is that
1:22:10 You know, we do carry a certain amount of burden and responsibility for that as well. And so how we share that collectively across the entities and appropriately, I think it's important for all of us. Thank you, Nate. I appreciate your explanation. I'm not still completely satisfied with that. There's money going into the, I mean, I know we agree on all this, the Project Management Office, this and that, but when you add that money up,
1:22:36 I think we need a clarifying document to accompany the budget, and I see what's here, but it's not really clarifying. It says, you know, this is money going here and here, but as we go forward, in order, I think, to keep a healthy partnership in organizations such as ESCOG, there needs to be total clarity.
1:22:56 around where this money's going, so that in a few years someone can't look back and say, why'd they do that? How come Inyo County got an extra almost $200,000 and Inyo County, Mono County didn't get that and they both got the same wildfire coordinator funding, so what happened? So I'm not comfortable with this at the moment. This budget goes in effect 7-1, July 1st? That's correct. Okay. All right, I think we need a little bit of extra. I'm not saying that we move the money.
1:23:23 I think we need a clarifying document to say why the money went where it was, where it did. And I think one thing we can probably do to get at least part of the way there is we can look at or look to the agreements that have been executed by your board and by Inyo, at least with respect to those specific areas of work, and we can basically pull the purposes out of those and just define it.
1:23:47 The signature of both CAOs understanding that this is what we're doing. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, I'm sorry if no one from, you know, Kim, you're here, which I appreciate, but, you know, someone from the administrative, the CAOs, there's something to kind of weigh in on that. And I will say that when the conversation was first happening with respect to Kristen and potentially bringing her over to the ESCOG, there was a conversation with
1:24:13 With the Mono side, with Sandra. And so we did talk about that. We did think about the potential impact, you know, even consider whether there were resources on the Mono side. And I had suggested to Sandra at that time that, I mean, this contract could be a template for Mono to execute a very similar agreement with the ESCOG for other services. So I, you know, I think that opportunity is there if, you know, if Mono's interested in stepping into that.
1:24:40 Absolutely. I do think that the bottom line is what Supervisor McFarlane said, though, which is, like, how are we going to execute in this narrow band of time that we have, recognizing the limits on resources that we have, and that's the one that I'm most critically concerned about at this point in time, you know, recognizing the needs that Inyo has, that Mono has, and that regionally we have in this space. They overlap and intersect, but I think part of why that is concerning to me is if we are awarded the Community Wildfire Defense Grant,
1:25:09 We're going to have that problem in spades. We're going to have millions of dollars, and we need to be able to draw down not only these three pots of money that we're talking about today, but another whole chunk of money, which is going to be a good problem to have, but we're going to have to solve it. I mean, I think that the mindset, as you said, to share between the counties, to regionalize whenever we can, to do the work jointly, I mean, I think that is the ideal and the purpose of a joint power like this.
1:25:36 I think that when we do have a budget item that kind of sticks out like this, that we do asterisk it up, put a clarifying document with it every time. So that in the future, we will understand and be able to go back and look, not that, oh, I thought we did that, you know, but actually clarify it, pinpoint it, make sure that it's clear on all of these budget, you know, things that look a little off, you know, to the eye that isn't going, that none of us are going to be around to talk about. So I think that we need to do that on a routine basis going both ways.
1:26:05 So if we could do that, I would be more comfortable with this budget document. Like a more robust budget narrative that actually explains some of these things like, you know, and I spoke with Elaine yesterday, like the recreation coordinator position, like how does that fit in? What is it? It's a line item in the budget, but what does it really look like? Where is it tied to? And you answered that question yesterday, but if it was within there, then we have, you know, a narrative document to point to. We all have the same understanding. Thank you. I appreciate that feedback. So with that,
1:26:37 Are there any other questions on the budget? So are you saying you don't want us to approve this now? No, I think you guys can go ahead and vote on it. You don't need a complete, you know, unanimous decision to pass the budget. Okay. Okay. And then, so, but, okay, so just no other questions on the budget specifically then. And so we'll take public comment.
1:27:03 Next, I believe, would be important. So, is there any public comment online or in the room? No comments at this time. And so, I guess we could entertain a motion and then is the question that this, would you like a motion where the budget is passed with the caveat that we will come back in August with further clarification that's codified or... I mean, you can pass it now. Well, right, but we have...
1:27:35 I mean, just to be clear, if you approve the budget today, you approve the budget today. You're giving direction to staff to come back with additional
1:28:03 information for the future if people need to review the budget and see what happened and why. I will trust that that will happen. Yeah. Okay. Okay. So I, so we could. Thank you. Any more discussion? May I make a suggestion? Certainly. I understand that Supervisor Salcedo is not comfortable with this. May I suggest, though, that we pass the budget as it is and we ask that
1:28:31 Whether it be August or whatever, that we start to have a discussion about our purpose, reiterate that we are a region, that we function as a region, and what kind of clarifications we would like around the finances and how that plays out as a whole.
1:28:54 Okay.
1:29:25 That's more of a suggestion to staff, not the motion itself. Okay. Is anyone ready to make a motion? I'll make a motion to approve the budget. With the caveat that we will get further explanation on some of these. Sure. Okay. I'll second. Great. Angie, so the motion is to approve the budget as written with
1:29:51 the understanding that at a future meeting we will get further clarification on some of the specific line items. Is that fair? Yes or no. Okay. And the second was from Council Member Schwartz. Can you please call the roll? Vice Chair Bubzer? Yes. Board Member Griffiths? Yes. Board Member Oral? Yes. Board Member Salcido? Yes. With a caveat in place. With a...
1:30:23 A date that that will be at the next regular meeting we will discuss or have that document ready to be included. Are we changing the motion slightly or you just? No. Okay. Board Member Schwartz? Yes. And Board Member McFarland? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. We are moving on to item 5.4. This is to approve the modification collection agreement 22 CO.
1:30:49 A lot of numbers for the Eastern Sierra Climate Communities Resilient Project. So Elaine, is this you? Yes, thank you. I'll take this item. This item is in regards to an existing collection agreement that we have with the Inyo National Forest.
1:31:07 So they can provide their staff and technical expertise on the development of environmental documents supporting environmental permitting for the Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Resilience Project. Our original agreement with them included $228,692,000.
1:31:30 to support the original work for the 58, 56,000 acres immediately around the town of Mammoth Lakes. Last year that project was completed.
1:31:41 on time and under budget and we received an extension from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife to extend the term of the grant through December of 2026 and then also to extend the scope of the project to include additional acres in the West Mono Basin. So this
1:32:02 Allocates some of the balance of that funding, $210,000 to the Forest Service for their staff to provide interdisciplinary team staff to support the development of the project description for the West Mono Basin. Thank you. Thank you. Happy to take questions. Questions? I think I more have a question actually. It might be for Nate.
1:32:33 You know, part of the agreement talks about identifying a pathway for NEPA authorization. I assume a lot of that is actually going to be looking at documents that are already in place and projects that can just go now. Because there are things within the June Lake Loop, fuel re-entry, some other things that could be done now and achieve these goals. Yeah, good question. I think our intent would be to look at...
1:33:01 existing NEPA documents and see where there are some inconsistencies with our new land management plan. Thanks. And then look at, you know, a new NEPA analysis that might bring them more consistent with our existing plan direction. That doesn't, that's not to say that we would have to redo NEPA. I think we would just be looking at those existing documents and seeing where there's a need to change.
1:33:25 We also would be looking at expanding the opportunity to do fuels reduction fire resilience work where we don't currently have NEPA analysis for that. And we would probably be looking at our emergency situation determination NEPA authorities to do that, which allows us to streamline NEPA processes. Does that answer your question? Yeah, it does. I just wanted to be sure that, you know, we authorize this today
1:33:54 That there isn't too long of a pause to, so work that could have proceeded already can continue to proceed. I just am constantly concerned about creating artificial hurdles for projects that are already moving. And we have some of those in June. There's fuel re-entry, you know, these are old NEPA. I mean, old NEPA is still good NEPA. Yeah, there is no expiration date on those NEPA decisions. So we will still continue to operate underneath them.
1:34:24 Up until the point we have a new NEPA decision, if that is the decision to sort of create a new NEPA decision that's more consistent with existing plan direction. Cool. Yeah, great. Thank you. You can have your work cut out for you. I mean, this is a short time horizon. Yeah. So, thanks. Yeah, you're welcome.
1:34:42 Yeah, and I'll just offer that, you know, we're continuing to do work under those existing NEPA decisions now. In fact, June, there's more work planned on June Mountain that we're working with with National Forest Foundation that will probably happen next year. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Other questions? Is there any public comment on this item? No comments at this time. All right. Any discussion? Anyone want to make a motion?
1:35:14 I'll make a motion. Second. That we approve the modification to collection agreement 22. So it's yes. Angie, as written in the packet, that's the motion. A second? Did someone second already? Linda already seconded. They're very fast. So if you could please call the roll. Vice Chair Bubzer? Yes. Board Member Griffiths? Yes. Board Member Oral? Yes. Board Member Salcido? Yes. Board Member Schwartz? Yes. Board Member McFarland?
1:35:43 Yes, thanks. Thank you. Next, item 5.5, I think this is again Ms. Gabala to talk about ad hoc committees for consultants and contracts for a number of projects. Thank you, Chair Bubzer. So as I discussed in the budget, we received a number of grants through Sierra Jobs First that we'll be executing over the course of the next 14 months. So that included
1:36:13 Funding to establish a recreation collaborative that would bring together stakeholders, non-profit stakeholders, chambers of commerce, to have alignment around project prioritization for recreation projects in the Eastern Sierra. So I have two contracts that will be issued to support that project. The first is for a
1:36:36 a coordinator who would help with the project management and oversight of developing that collaborative, and then the second would be for strategic planning consultant who could provide facilitation services, be able to document the input that we've received, make recommendations in a formalized deliverable that could be used to guide that effort beyond Sierra Jobs First.
1:37:04 The second contract we received for Sierra Jobs First was to support an existing conditions analysis for the trail system that has been developed by users in the Chipmunk Canyon area. So we would be developing a request for proposals for a consultant to provide to conduct that existing conditions analysis.
1:37:27 The project coordinator for the recreation component would also have project management oversight of that project as well. So both that project management...
1:37:37 Coordination would serve as capacity in supporting that effort for the ESCOG. And then finally, we had included funding under our collaborative application for the Inyo Mono Activation Plan to advance agricultural products and economic diversification that's in collaboration with the Inyo Mono Agricultural Commission Office. So we would be contracting for a consultant to do that body of work as well. One of the challenges
1:38:06 One of the advantages of Sierra Jobs first is that the funding has to be expended by the end of September of 2026. So that's a very tight timeline to be able to do this project work. And as you know, ESCOG meets on a bi-monthly schedule, which makes it very challenging to develop RFPs, to issue them, to come to the board. Mr. Vallejo has helped me in identifying a process to help streamline that a little bit. Our recommendation to your board.
1:38:35 is the development of a committee that could help with
1:38:41 Contract selection as we have interested applicants respond to the request for proposals or the request for qualifications and then make a recommendation on which of those contractors we would enter into contract with. Staff would recommend that as part of that committee we would also include two of the regional managers as additional staff.
1:39:05 to support that work. And once we have a regional coordinator for the recreation component on, I would ask that that individual also be included on the subcommittee for selecting consultants for both the strategic consultant for the recreation collaborative as well as the existing conditions analysis.
1:39:30 Staff is also requesting that your board provide authority to the executive director to negotiate and execute agreements with not to exceed amounts that were identified in the budget earlier for those contracts. And I can provide those specific amounts if it would be valuable for me to do so.
1:39:52 Thank you. Thanks, Elaine.
1:40:21 The question really becomes, are we going to create a Brown Act Committee, or are we going to create a committee that doesn't have to post its meeting agendas, et cetera? And so if your board would like to facilitate, I think, what staff believes would be a more efficient selection process, the two options are creating three separate ad hoc committees or having your executive director just create the committee herself.
1:40:46 With some maybe general guidance, but not specific decisions about who's going to be appointed to those committees by your counsel. I think that issue is pretty clear, but if you have any questions, I'm happy to explain. Questions? Seeing none. Is there any public comment? I'll do a comment. That's it? I'll do a comment. Okay, go ahead. I'm comfortable with Elaine, you know, taking those out.
1:41:17 And, you know, being able to sign those contracts. And as far as the question of whether or not to create a Brown Act, you know, kind of thing, avoid, if possible, so. I agree, given the immediacy of the need, let's get this moving along. So, with that. Do you have an amount? An up to? Yes, there is an up to amount. It's included in the motion, in the recommended motion. Oh, okay. I'll look at that again. Thanks. Okay, great.
1:41:50 Did you have a comment or anything? No, I was just, I mean, I'm new to this body. I was just wondering about how many people you're looking for. I think I would be looking for two board members, two regional managers and staff. Okay. All right, terrific. So can we, I'll entertain a motion to approve as written. So moved. All right. So Angie, could you please call the roll?
1:42:22 Yes, and was that Board Member Oral with this? Okay, thank you. Vice Chair Bubzer? Yes. Chair Griffiths? Excuse me, Board Member Griffiths? Yes. Board Member Oral? Yes. Board Member Salcido? Yes. Board Member Schwartz? Yes. And Board Member McFarland? Yes. Thank you. Ms. Plastid, I just wanted to bring it to the Board's attention. We do have a hand raised on Zoom. Oh, I apologize. Hi, Josie, go ahead and unmute yourself and give your comment. Hi, I'm Josie Perulo. I'm a...
1:43:04 A bishop local here. And I'm really sorry, this is my first time ever doing this, so I'm sorry if I'm interrupting at the wrong time, but I just had a comment to make on the chipmunk project, if I could. Can we accept that, given that it's not? Well, I mean, the chipmunk project is included in this, so it does count. Okay, then please go ahead. Okay, so I just want to thank you for the opportunity to provide comment. I'm sorry I can't be there. I have a couple young kids.
1:43:35 And I would just like, please forgive me if I'm already jumping the gun, but I just recently learned about this project a couple days ago. I support COG's plan to better connect communities through a regional system, but I strongly feel in this case that the best thing for government is to just do nothing. I grew up in West Bishop. I have been recreating here my entire life, and I'm raising a young family on South Barlow.
1:44:03 There is relatively little impact to the landscape in terms of human waste litter and certainly much less than developed trails elsewhere such as buttermilks, Mammoth Lakes Basin, and Alabama Hills. It is apparent what happens when you develop areas like these. While there has been an increase in recent years due to word of mouth, this area is enjoyed by many different recreation users such as families, walkers, runners, bikers, with no user conflict to my knowledge.
1:44:32 In developing this recreation area, I feel like the government may be creating a problem that does not exist. Some of these problems will be increased traffic down South Barlow, which is a relatively low volume area safe for families. Also increased recreation costs due to infrastructure that needs to be maintained. And then
1:44:58 Also, I don't know if there's been any community outreach in this department. As I know, there has been little. I was watching the meeting, I think it was last week, and John Wentworth had actually brought this up. And this, as I said, I may be jumping the gun in this area, but I do think that the community deserves some outreach. A much better use of readily available grant funding and tax dollars is to repair the multi-use bike path, which runs down Lion Street to Barlow.
1:45:28 This has been deteriorating for several years. That is proof the government is often good at building something, but not necessarily good at maintaining it. Repairing this existing bike path would also tie in nicely with the Caltrans bike lane, Main Street revitalization improvements, the Bishop Paiute Tribe community open space, and better fulfill the mission of the towns to trails models, but actually connecting communities to the better system already developed.
1:45:57 As I said, I realize this is very early days in this project, but I believe if you are working in the best interest of the community, there would be more outreach to inform your constituents and collect public opinion before moving ahead. Thank you for the time. I'm sorry for my nerves. I just felt it was necessary to make a public comment on this. Thank you. Thank you so much for joining us. Yeah, thank you. Bye.
1:46:26 Thanks. All right. So we can move on now to the next item, which is the update, item 5.6, update on regional wildfire coordinator activities. Thank you. Well, Ms. Weiler is setting up, I just, again, want to provide a little bit of context for this. There are a number of...
1:46:49 Excellent opportunities and regional collaborative efforts supporting wildfire resiliency that are happening. And I've attended some of the board and council meetings virtually over the last couple of months and I know that this is a...
1:47:05 issue that all our communities are deeply concerned about. So I've invited Ms. Feiler today to provide your board with some information about some of the work that is happening through the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance and some of the opportunities to work together across the region at scale to start to do work on the ground. Thank you. Thanks, Elaine. Kristen Feiler, the ESCOG Wildfire Coordinator in Inyo County.
1:47:35 Combo Wildfire Coordinator. And yeah, today I just want to share a little bit about, just quickly about a lot of the stuff that's happening to organize and then really kind of to your point, Supervisor McParlin, like what, how are we turning this into action? And there's a lot of really exciting discussion that's happened today that I think, yeah, really feeds into this. So just a quick agenda, just talk about some of the takeaways from the California Wildfire Task Force.
1:48:04 what the Wildfire Alliance here locally is looking at, a new riparian working group that we're getting going, some of the grant funding that's coming up and that we've received and some of the projects, and then any other kind of topics that you want to talk about, I put some on here that might be of interest. So the California Wildfire Task Force, if you're not familiar, they meet quarterly and it's the state's
1:48:33 Yeah, task force to tackle wildfire and forestry resilience. And this past meeting was June 6th, and kind of one of some of the takeaways for me was it was all about regional coordination and the groups across the regions and how imperative that really is to start forming those. Primarily to start taking some of the money that's coming out through the state and applying it to the ground in a way that matters most to those regions.
1:49:02 There were a bunch of different models that were shared, pretty high level, but basically the point is there's a lot happening, there's a lot we can learn from, we don't need to reinvent the wheel. They shared this slide at the very beginning, which is just the outlook for fire potential this year, and it's significant. Starting in June, our area is already pretty inundated, and it just doesn't let up. So, just wanted to...
1:49:32 share that. This is the agenda from that Wildfire Task Force meeting. The morning was all about hearing from those different regions, and then the second part of it was how those regions are planning to implement the Prop 4 money, basically. And so there's a lot of information on these slides. I just kind of pulled from their presentations, but there's
1:49:59 Every region has their own unique way of forming, and there were really consistent, I guess, advice and almost like best practices from each of those that we can take as we're forming our wildfire alliance. So this is the Southern California one. They have a bunch of different regional forest and fire capacity recipient groups, and so they all formed together to implement.
1:50:27 that funding in a consistent way. They have a bunch of different national forests that also combine together, and it's all based on kind of the needs around what they're experiencing, and so they kind of have these different working groups that address those specific needs, and so on the right, this is kind of how they're breaking up those kind of four pillars of their working groups across the forest.
1:50:55 The Northern California, they've been doing this, I feel like they're kind of some of the North Star of how to do this. They've been doing this for a really long time and are very, had many iterations, I think, of different regional collaboratives and we could probably learn a lot from them. Notably is the North Coast Resource Partnership, which I thought was interesting that it's led by tribes and the counties, which is
1:51:25 Pretty cool. And then I included this other group that is in the north too, the Intercoast Collaborative, that is pretty much made up of RCDs, which is also, I think, pretty interesting. But here's some of their best practices, and I'll just let you, you can peruse those on your own. I wanted to just highlight the project pipeline from the North Coast Partnership really quick.
1:51:53 Because it's something kind of a vision in a sense of what we can create here. And I think maps are really useful and give a lot of context. So for example, they have all types of projects listed there, different multi-objective projects, all the way from concept to maintenance and monitoring. And then on the right, the projects that are proposed by the different
1:52:22 Entities. And there's, in that area, there's a lot that's proposed by fire safe councils and non-profits and not so much necessarily federal agencies. And so how to piece all this together, you can see I included their little, their budget, which is, yeah, $3 billion, which is, you know.
1:52:43 Eventually, maybe we could get to something like that, but I think looking at these multi-objective projects and start to really lay those out in a pipeline so that we can, yeah, someday kind of be prepared to do this work. Central Coast, this was from the Santa Cruz Mountain Stewardship Network. I really enjoyed their
1:53:09 like tips for organizing on a landscape scale, so engage the high functioning stakeholder group, which we're doing, develop the prioritization framework, which we had done prior to me actually getting into this job, but I think we're going through iterations of redefining that, gather project ideas, convene a bunch of technical advisors to give input on that, and then identify where those gaps and overlaps exist, and
1:53:39 And then for our area, Sierra Nevada Conservancy kind of laid out there how they're going to be allocating some of this climate money. And I thought it was really great that the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance is listed on their Ready Landscapes map. And so I have it circled here in the red. But they
1:54:10 Really proposed, you know, they're delineating between pace and scale, and so pace is like, what can we do right now, and scale is like, how are we organizing and being able to do these landscape projects on a more consistent, sustainable, bigger thing. And so, yeah, we're right on track, I think, to be...
1:54:36 Yeah, getting that. And this is what they clarified, like, this is what ready means for them. So we have the people and we have the planning and we bring that all together and so that's what we're working on with Stacey Corliss leading us in the Wildfire Alliance and Whitebark Institute. So, yeah, and so just to give a little bit of an update, a few of you attended our last Wildfire Alliance meeting and this is a picture from that.
1:55:07 Stacy facilitated this really great ecosystem mapping exercise so we could all really get an understanding of who all the players are, what they do, and what we want to focus on. And so we'll be coming out with the analysis of that here pretty soon.
1:55:29 I'd just like to add that even if you participated in that meeting remotely, the tool that you used was really excellent, and I felt like even for those of us who couldn't be in the room, that was a really great example of a hybrid meeting, and I just want to thank you. I know it took a lot of extra work to organize that. Oh, awesome. I'll pass that on. Heidi from the Whitebark Institute made that platform, and the Whitebark's crew did a really great job facilitating, so thank you for that.
1:55:59 And this is a tentative timeline. We're still kind of waiting back on these specific dates for the future, but this is kind of what it's looked like. We started really organizing in November, and a few of you joined that meeting here in Mammoth, where we really dove into what are our challenges, what are our needs. February and May, we listened to what are the projects, what are some updates, what are we kind of working on for the summer.
1:56:30 And then in June, we did this mapping exercise, and we really asked people to sign up for subcommittees, and we divided those subcommittees into governance, projects and funding, and then communications. And so with those three kind of subcommittees, hopefully we can start to really figure out how we want to form and what we want to work on, and then how to actually make it happen.
1:56:59 I guess my plug is that if you want to be on those subcommittees, we would really appreciate your input and insight, and I think ESCOG plays a really pivotal role going forward. So kind of what's next is we'll hear from the subcommittees. We'll meet this summer. We'll hear from them in September.
1:57:21 And get kind of a draft idea, discuss some different structures and roles for how the alliance will form. And then the rest of the fall will kind of be on really fine-tuning that and drafting up some sort of charter or whatever the group really decides how we want to form best for our region. And again, those dates are subject to change. One piece of this that I wanted to bring up
1:57:51 and share a little bit of insight on is our Eastside Riparian Resilience Working Group. And this is a group that started basically in response to the governor's proclamation to suspend CEQA and permitting for certain fuel treatments. And so the intention here is to prepare a shovel-ready multi-site riparian fuels reduction project.
1:58:20 near and adjacent to our high-risk communities across both counties that leverage that proclamation. Here's the state map of what's already been accepted and here's a QR code you can go and check out that website. But essentially it seems like a pretty slick process, hopefully.
1:58:49 The eligibility requirements are pretty minimal. There is an environmental protection plan that was created that outlines best practices and what we can do and what we can't do. And so we've been meeting to really develop this project in alignment with those so we can just check the boxes and submit our application and get approval. Who is on this team currently? It's Los Angeles Department of Water and Power.
1:59:21 Fish and Wildlife, Lahontan Water Board, White Bark Institute, Cal Fire, Wendy and myself, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, and then we, because we have multiple sites all up and down both counties, we're reaching out to those specific, like, our tribes and specific fire safe councils and things like that. And I think this is a pretty cool group, I think, because
1:59:49 It feeds right into the Wildfire Alliance. Like, I can see it becoming a standing fuel reduction working group. So while this specific project is focused on how to actually leverage the state, you know, work basically not on federal land to really take advantage of the CEQA exemptions, I think in perpetuity, like it will continue, hopefully so.
2:00:18 And then just in case for context why we're choosing riparians for this is they're our primary carrier of fire basically leading, you know, as wicks right into our communities and they haven't historically been treated. Most of the treatments have happened either alongside of them or, you know, not even anywhere close because the permitting process is so onerous. And so here's the actual write-up of what our goal is on our
2:00:48 on our project proposal. It's very similar to what I read to you at the beginning, but just wanted to include that. Here is some of the places that we have identified so far. We know that there are more places, and so we're just, we're in the process of planning this. So this is not a complete list, but starting from the north, so far we've got Mammoth Creek.
2:01:19 The area around Snarl, Crowley Lake, Tom's Place and Sunny Slopes, certain areas around 40 acres, Rovana and Pine Creek, and then a bunch of areas around West Bishop. And then continuing down into the Owens Valley, Big Pine, Birch Creek and the Three Creeks property, Oak Creek and Fort Independence, and then a bunch of sites around Lone Pine. And so this, right now we're reaching out to more partners and trying to figure out
2:01:52 Yeah, what the full scope of the project will be. July 1st, we're going to be doing a bunch of site visits, starting from the south and going north to, I guess, identify the, like, really map it out and apply the treatment, like, the different types of treatments that we might need for the different locations. This summer, we're going to write up the proposal and submit it, and at the same time, really look at how funding to implement it.
2:02:25 That's all I got in that part. Go ahead. At what point will be the outreach to expand the scope north of Mammoth? Like now? Now. Yeah. I mean, I would recommend Mill Creek that goes right through Mono City as well as Levining Creek. And if you're looking at areas that are not federally owned, both of those have sections that are not federally owned because it looked like all the creeks you mentioned have.
2:02:55 Or on either private or utility land. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Excellent. Thanks. And is the, like, the fire district or the fire safe council or who should be, who should we reach out to for that specific? Probably the fire safe council, the fire wise community, the fire district, and I can put you in touch with them. Great. As well as the public utility districts. And also I would add Rush Creek to that because we have a lot of water.
2:03:26 Infrastructure along it in the riparian corridor. And in addition to just the fuels improvements, once you get north of Mammoth, this work is critical right now because our riparian corridors are at a tipping point where we're completely losing all of the broadleaf component as they're shaded out by white fur and lodgepole. And so getting in there now will really bring back some semblance of ecosystem health. Awesome. Yeah, thank you.
2:03:56 Okay. Yeah, that's really helpful to hear. Thank you. Yeah, so that feeds right into the funding opportunities that are coming up, and this is what was presented at the California Wildfire Task Force. So Cal Fire is combining their proposition for money with their Cal Fire Prevention Grant, and that tentatively will open up this fall.
2:04:23 They're saying about $50 million, and really their emphasis is on acres treated, so not so much on the education component or planning necessarily, but on actual on-the-ground implementation. And then Sierra Nevada Conservancy also gave their a little bit of insight into what's open now. As I said, the pace part of their, I guess, plan is
2:04:55 implementation money for work on the ground to protect communities. And so we think that this riparian project is actually a really good, well-suited for something like that. I know we have a lot of other projects that are either planned or in the works that also fit with this. So we'll be at our next Wildfire Alliance meeting. I think Matt Driscoll was the SNC, our regional area.
2:05:24 Liaison, he's going to give us a little bit more information about this, and as an alliance we're kind of going to coordinate and put in some project proposals, so. And then I did just want to remind you all about the Eastern Sierra Communities Wildfire Defense Grant that we applied through ESCOG, and I've heard that we'll
2:05:52 Decisions on those will be coming out this fall, but this is just a reminder of what that program was for your information, and it's really embedding county public works into getting the hazardous fuels out of communities, along with a few other things, but that's the primary purpose.
2:06:14 And then kind of to speak to some of the discussion earlier, we were, Inyo Mono Counties were awarded the CAL FIRE County Coordinator Funding. Again, both counties received $150,000. And Wendy and I, I guess through our time doing this work and getting the needs assessment and getting into communities and agencies and
2:06:44 The emphasis really has been clear that we need a regional approach to this, and so we intentionally built our scopes of work and our applications to work across both counties. Instead of doing the same project in two counties, we're doing different tasks across both counties and diversifying, I guess, to make better capacity. And as Nate had said earlier, capacity really is our...
2:07:12 issue here with this. And so there's a lot of other things beyond just this scope of work that are contributing to all of the work that we're doing. Notably, like, leveraging the project management office is being used across both counties to do this work and develop projects and grant applications and things like that. And so, like, my pot of money for this is partially going to fund my salary, but funding
2:07:41 I think Wendy's is going solely to her salary, but she's going to be working on the community side across Inyo County, too, to help with that. So I don't know what else I wanted to say about that, but I also just wanted to share a little bit about the
2:08:08 The mini-grant program, the community-directed grants program that Southern California Edison funds and White Bark Institute administers, these were the recipients this year, and there was $60,000 that was awarded across 17 different groups across both counties, and they're doing this, I think I just wanted to really highlight this because this type of program is worth investing in and allowing us to make really tangible efforts in not just
2:08:38 I don't know, like community work, but like capacity even. And it's, yeah, it's just doing a lot of really great things and is really important. And even though this is only for the Southern California Edison service area, it would be, I think, wise for us to think about how we can implement something like this across both counties beyond that. Yeah, not only, this is by far the biggest impact on individual communities because it,
2:09:07 Proves to people that their organizing efforts lead to actual outcomes on the ground. It gives them the dollars, even though they may seem like small amounts, to little communities, they're huge. And anything we can do to grow and sustain this program, so much of this rolled up into the Community Wildfire Defense Grant, which was so wonderful to see. But I mean, you've got everything from Mustang Mesa to Bridgeport Fire. I mean, you hit every single...
2:09:37 Community, this is a really solid program, so thank you. Yeah, and it's really, like in our community wildfire protection plan, we gave like recommendations for each community, you know, and they're literally checking off the boxes, like Mustang Mesa did addressing last year, this year they're doing the juniper issue, like, so it's really allowing us.
2:10:01 to solve concrete problems. And yeah, like you said, it doesn't take much money to make a big impact. And I think that this, yeah, this program is working really well for us. And here is a letter I asked Chief Wave, the Bridgeport Fire Chief, if we could share this. And I think it just really speaks to like, yeah, the importance of a little bit of money into some of their organizing efforts. And they know how to use this money.
2:10:31 best for their communities, and he was able to save a life through this mini-grant program, which I think is just awesome. So, and then I did want to just highlight, this map is incorrect, but the National Forest Foundation, our region, was awarded the CAL FIRE Forest Health Grant for the Lava Mountain Forest Health Project, which is part of the, in the Eastern Sierra Climate Community's resilience footprint.
2:11:01 I think it's up here kind of by the scenic loop. So just wanted to share that. And if you want more information, I included that QR code there. And then, yeah, just any other topics for discussion. I know we're kind of running short on time, but the local hazard severity zone maps were passed and adopted by both Town of Mammoth and City of Bishop.
2:11:32 And does have some impacts on us. But yeah, here's a little bit about the timeline of those updates. In speaking with CAL FIRE, they're intended to be updated as they update their state responsibility area every five years.
2:11:54 They go through a process of reallocating lands like that. They obviously haven't done that in a very long time. So the last update was in 2007 and 11. And the difference that we're seeing here is that the LRA, the local responsibility area, at that time only included the very high hazard zones. They didn't map out any of the other zones. And so this, as you can see, Bishop,
2:12:24 There's a cool slider map, and I should have probably pulled the website up, but you can see, like, the past map and this current update, and it looks significantly different, and that is one of the reasons why, in addition to climate and, yeah, the topography and all of that that we're seeing, so. I think it's really important to note for those maps that got lost on a lot of people, I think.
2:12:51 Is the reason that they changed so much is because the previous maps were modeled at 20 mile an hour winds. Yeah. And the new ones are for real winds, which are actually a lot less than winds we get. Right. And so if any, like the quote you have in here is good. Like if anything, it still underestimates it because we get 80 mile an hour winds here. Yeah.
2:13:20 Yeah, exactly. And we saw Los Angeles. Exactly. Yeah, and the technology is so much better. They're actually including ember cast now into this modeling. So, yes, and the categories and the stratification of those in the Bishop area, like, isn't really going to matter when we have a wind-driven fire, honestly. So, one thing I did want to just note with this is that we have
2:13:49 Like I'm in pretty good communication with our building inspectors and safety inspectors and our planning department because this is what those these maps are really used for is land use planning and and building requirements and things and one of the things that is
2:14:11 I guess on the docket this year is that the fire risk reduction communities list is open for applications, which is CAL FIRE's high priority list. It opens up in July and closes, I think, October, and it's only open on odd years. And it's a chance for local agencies to show that they're taking efforts in alignment with, like, recommendations from CAL FIRE.
2:14:41 Organizing in a way to reduce their risk. One of the stipulations for like a local agency to apply for that is we have to have a stricter ordinance than what the state requires. And so this differentiation of hazard zones kind of opens up at least a question of like do we want to implement something around defensible space or something like that that is you know
2:15:10 Greater than what the moderate says from CAL FIRE to implement. So just a food for thought there. I'm really quick. I apologize for interrupting, but I do want to let the board know that ESTA will be meeting in here in 15 minutes. Yes. I'll wrap it up. And this is like what is required in each of those categories for your reference. And these maps don't impact insurance. Just wanted to include that in there.
2:15:43 Zone Zero is going to be coming out at the end of the year. So that's a really big deal, I guess, for us on how we're going to actually go about retrofitting all of our homes. And then I did include, as Christiana Darlington referenced, the 25 key deliverables from the Wildfire Task Force is up and is worth looking at. So that's all I got. Thank you. Questions?
2:16:15 Questions? Okay, is there anything? Go ahead. Good morning, this is Carol Snow with CAL FIRE. I just wanted to provide a super quick update on the wildfire prevention grants. I had announced at the last Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance meeting that we were told they were going to be postponed, which is where Kristen got that fall 2025, but they were actually publicly announced.
2:16:43 43 minutes ago. So those will be, that's $135 million of wildfire prevention and Prop 4 money for wildfire prevention grants and those applications will be due on August 6th. So I will be getting with Kristen and Wendy and other relevant entities to get those projects lined out. Thank you. You're going to be busy. Thank you so much for updating us. Thanks, Carol.
2:17:11 Is there anyone else online, Angie, with their hands raised, or does anyone in the room want to give a comment on this? I didn't see any questions. I did look down the line. Good work. We're short on time, but excellent. Yeah. But any public comments? No comments online. Yes, thank you so much. That's quite a lot. And also, we're just really grateful that we are ready to apply for these grants. So thanks for everything you're doing. Any other final comments from the team?
2:17:42 Okay. Thank you for being here. Thank you. Thanks for your participation, too. So really make it happen. We are, it's just great, we're grateful to see Stacey here and you and everybody who's participating in this, this single biggest existential threat to our region. So it's nice to see us all really pulling together. With that, we will go on to the Executive Director update.
2:18:05 Thank you. I will keep my comments very brief. First, I just want to thank the board for their time today and for everyone who has participated in the meeting. Thank you for your time. In particular, I want to thank the regional managers for coming in for their participation and to let your board know that I did have a meeting with all four regional managers who took time to come together and Bishop and have a conversation about how to help.
2:18:31 ASCOG become organized and efficient and better support all of the member agencies in the individual jurisdictions. And so I wanted to, of course, let you know and really thank them for their investment of time and attention and expertise. And I'm looking forward to being able to provide more information regarding that to your board at our next meeting. I also wanted to let you know that we do have the regional housing study out. There's a housing study for
2:18:56 And there's a housing study survey available for employers. So please continue to push. That will be on the streets through July. So we're trying to get as much feedback from across the region as we can on that. And then finally, I wanted to let your board know that I attended the Sierra Jobs First Strategic Meeting in Sonora a couple weeks ago. And that is
2:19:23 That has been intended to develop some sustainability strategy for how the seven-county region will work, continue to work to advance economic development and advocate for the Sierra at a state level after Sierra Jobs First is completed. So thank you again for your time. I'm happy to take any questions, but do realize that we're short on time. Thank you. Questions? All right, then I think we move on to board member reports. Who would like to go first?
2:20:01 Okay. Thank you. Okay. Anybody else? No. I'll just say real quickly, Carrie of the Last Resort update appears like AT&T has purchased the State Assembly and Senate, and so that is going through. There appears to be still some protections for our most remote communities, but
2:20:31 The bill is moving forward. Thanks for your work on that. Yes, thank you. And I'll just very briefly say that the town of Mammoth Lakes did write a letter to Congressman Kiley and our senators, CC'd all of your jurisdictions about it. And I, you know, one of the best pieces of information that we were able to provide really came from the SEDS and then the California jobs first. So
2:20:58 You know, I really want to thank everybody for participating in this JPA because we wouldn't have really been able to execute this eds and these are the things we can point to to help people understand the importance of sustainable recreation to all of our economies and so thank you. It's, you know, it's great to just have that.
2:21:19 Reference to, sorry, my phone's not here, so I had to do it with my watch. So thank you. I thought that was just incredibly helpful to have it at our fingertips. So great work on that and we're using it. And with that, are there any future agenda items that we haven't discussed that you want to make sure we cover at a future meeting? And if not,
2:21:42 We will adjourn to our next regular meeting on August 27th, which will already be a packed agenda. Thanks, everybody, for your time today. Thank you very much. All right. Let me go get just a little bit of food. Do you want anything?