TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2021

Mammoth Lakes Recreation

at 17:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

264 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:10 Hey, Kim, were we expecting Bill and Eric tonight? We are, let me turn my video on, we are expecting Eric. Bill is out birthday-ing. Yeah, I was just with Eric, he'll be right on. Perfect. Perfect. Awesome. We'll give it a couple more minutes and get going. Sounds good. Angie, are we all queued up there at Sweet Z?

1:51 Yep, I'm ready to go in here. Okay, thank you. Oh, there's Eric. Okay, I think we have everybody. Awesome, good evening, everyone. I'd like to call this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Board of Directors, Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board of Directors meeting to order. It's Tuesday, November 2nd. I've got a 503...

2:22 PM. And Angie, why don't we start with roll call. Let's get started. Chair Albright. Here. Chair Schaubmeyer. Present. Secretary Bankson. Here. Board Member Sauser. Board Member Ferney. Here. And Board Member Wasserman. Here. Thank you. Awesome. And I think first item on our agenda is a bit of housekeeping.

2:57 via Sacramento. And I don't know if, you know, I saw Dan was on the line there a second ago. Dan, do you, are you going to lead us through this little part with Assembly Bill 361 and what we need to do to continue our online meetings? Yes. Thank you, Craig. Dan Holler. The item before you really just continues.

3:26 the process to meet via teleconference and virtually, so the Zoom platform or others at agency using across the state. AB 361 allowed legislative bodies to make findings that say that there's still an emergency in place, which in this case the state and the county emergency are still in place for the COVID-19 pandemic, and there is still a health

3:57 a directive from Mono County Public Health about the issue of distancing and potential spread of COVID-19 and indoor settings and et cetera. Given that the law allows you to make the initial finding that this is still there, great, we want to continue to meet virtually and then

4:23 Every 30 days thereafter, once you make the finding, you need to continue to make that finding again. The idea, hey, conditions are the same. We're going to continue to meet virtually. And then there's some noticing provisions and stuff that's required, which we assist with meeting all those things. So the action here is to allow you to continue to do that, to be able to meet.

4:51 virtually to be able to continue this type of activity. Again, at the countercuff, it's the first time you've met on this, but as we do those things and then take that action, then either you have to schedule a special meeting to do it every 30 days or at a future meeting if the condition is still warranted, you would have to take the same resolution, do an initial action again at the beginning of your meeting to be able to have a virtual meeting.

5:22 So I know like for a lot of the agencies, they meet monthly or twice a month in our case. So we have to continuing findings as we need to. Awesome. Thanks, Dan. Any questions for Dan from the board regarding that? Pray you looked through that in your packet and seems pretty straightforward. Any questions for Dan?

5:50 Not seeing any, entertain them. Sounds like, Dan, we need to take action via a motion and voting on that. Yeah, if there's any public comment, otherwise you're free to take action accordingly. Cool. Angie, do we have any public comment lined up on Zoom or there in Z? No public comments. She said no, so. Okay. Sorry, so yeah.

6:21 You're free to take action. It does need to be by a formal vote and approved accordingly. Okay. Would someone like to make a motion to move to accept this item on AB 361? Yeah. Basically, you're adopting a resolution making findings to allow the board to continue.

6:48 and the legislative bodies of the board to meet virtually during the COVID-19 pandemic emergency. I'll make a motion to approve that. I will second. So moved by Schaubmeyer and second by Bankson. Any further comment? Angie, can we do a roll call, please? President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Yes. Secretary Bankson? Yes. Board Member Ferney?

7:25 Yes. And Board Member Wasserman. I can see your mouth moving. It looks like a yes. Yes. Sorry about that. Thank you. Thumbs up or thumbs down, Eric. We'll take it. Awesome. Passes 5-0. And thank you for that, Dan. And we will, you know, make sure that, you know, in the subsequent months, as long as we're in the pandemic, keep that on our agenda. So great. Thank you for that.

7:56 keeping us on the right side of the Brown Act. Next up on our agenda is public comment. This is a time for the public to address the board regarding items not on the agenda this evening. Angie, do we have any public comments submitted? No comments at this time. Except for down hauler, it looks like. Yeah, I'd like to just...

8:24 Let the board know that tomorrow at 3 o'clock we're doing a community celebration groundbreaking at the Carson. We'll have some of the development team in town as well as others on site give an overview of the project and excited to see us move forward to be ready to have 80 affordable apartment units coming online come mid-2023. Seems like a long time away but should be here before we know it.

8:53 And so invite you all, if you have the time and ability, pop out there on the 3rd of November, tomorrow, Wednesday, 3 o'clock. Join us for a celebration out there. And one of your esteemed board members here, Mr. Fernie, was involved very intimately in the acquisition of that property and involved in that. So a long time coming through since I think we closed the purchase back in 2018.

9:21 And to see some activity movement forward there on affordable community housing here in town is just quite exciting. Leveraging relatively small amount of town money, about 10 to 1 for grants and other funding sources going into this project. So it's exciting. But you're all invited to come on out and celebrate. Awesome. Thank you for that, Dan. I mean, that is certainly our community's most pressing issue these days.

9:51 to have the opportunity to move forward. I know a lot of communities like ours and other mountain towns would love to have 25 acres devoted to develop workforce housing. So we're quite fortunate and very grateful for the work that has been done and excited to see it come to life. So excellent. Thank you for

10:18 bringing that before us. Angie, any other public comment out there? Not at this time, thank you. Excellent, thanks. Next up on our agenda is our friends from the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, an update on the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center, and I'm assuming maybe Betsy, you might be up to bat on that one?

10:47 Yes, thank you, Craig. We're really excited to be here this evening and really appreciate you having us. I am here and in my role as Executive Director of the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, and I know you're all very anxious for an update on the project, and we can't wait to share our work with you this evening. I'd like to introduce with me is Luan Mendel, who is our very capable board chair.

11:13 We also have Gary Myers, our former board chair and very active executive committee member. And then we also have, we don't have two Kyle Petersons. We have from HMC, our architect, we have Kyle Peterson. I'll have Kyle just wave. And then Brandon Gilotti, who had some technical difficulties, but is, oh, now he's here as Brandon, so perfect.

11:38 And they are going to share an exciting presentation with you showing our design work on the project, which we are really anxious to get out in front of you and members of the public. But before we dive into that, I just want to provide a brief bit of background on the Mammoth Lakes Foundation just for the benefit of the public who might be listening this evening.

12:01 I think most people know that the Mammoth Lakes Foundation was started in 1989 by Dave and Roma McCoy and many of their friends to support higher education and cultural enrichment here in the Eastern Sierra. And since that time, the foundation has played a role as a catalyst for several community projects. In 1998, the foundation received a 265-acre land donation from SCE.

12:29 And following that, in 1999, the foundation completed an 86-acre land exchange with the U.S. Forest Service. From that, 27 acres of land was donated to the Kern Community College District to build our local campus of Cerro Coso Community College. 14 acres was donated to the Mammoth Unified School District to build school facilities, and six acres was gifted to build the Mono County Office of Education.

12:58 In 2003, the Dave and Roma McCoy Learning Center, which we know as the college today, opened to students, followed by the South Gateway Apartments opening in 2008. So today the foundation awards full tuition and book scholarships. We also have a very robust mentoring program for Mono County students pursuing full-time study at the college at our Mammoth campus. And then we also provide partial housing scholarships and we launched a new transfer scholarship this year.

13:27 As a small nonprofit, which I'm sure all of you can empathize with, we see this model of the foundation as a catalyst and a supporter of facilities, is really aligned with our history and with our future. Shifting gears a little bit, the largest sources of public funds in the MAC project come from Measure C, which was the special school bond passed by the voters of the Kern Community College District in November of 2000, and Measure U, which you're all intimately familiar with.

13:57 passed by the voters of the town of Mammoth Lakes in June of 2010. And the foundation was very active in advocating for both of these measures. So now I'll just ask Luan to share a little bit of the recent history of the project, and then we'll let HMC kind of show us what it looks like.

14:15 Thanks, Betsy, and thanks, everyone, for having us this evening. As Betsy said, we're excited to share with you where we are. It's been a long journey. As Gary Myers will attest, this project goes back more than 20 years. So it has been in various stages of development along the way. But it is a key piece of Dave and Roma's legacy, this community amenity.

14:42 And so it is very obviously important to us. But equally important for us is the fact that this is a public-private partnership. And in that regard, we feel like this project is a model for future undertakings. So we're very excited about the nature of the project as well as the project itself.

15:03 The recent history of this project is that by January 2020, we had an initial design and we were far enough along with that design to get some cost estimates. Unfortunately, those cost estimates were a full order of magnitude more than we knew was affordable.

15:26 So at that point, the Mammoth Lakes Foundation Board recognized that some significant changes would have to be made to the project. This is not unusual in these kinds of projects, so it was not necessarily unanticipated, but I will tell you the cost estimates were certainly unwelcome, to say the least. In February 2020, we hired HMC to take another look at this project.

15:56 Unfortunately, about three weeks later, as pandemic-induced uncertainty slammed into all of us and all of our projects and plans, the executive committee of the board decided that it was time to pause the project and try to let things settle down a bit. The pause was a golden opportunity for us in many ways.

16:25 It gave us an idea or a time frame to rethink the project, which was important. We didn't have severe time pressure, so we had time to really consider all the ins and outs. There were two major takeaways from this pause. The first is that

16:45 The design needed to change in order to bring down the cost. That seemed to be a given. And HMC has been helpful in that regard. But the second, also very important takeaway, is that the Mammoth Lakes Foundation has neither the staff nor the experience to run a facility of this type. So those were, you know,

17:12 good things for us to realize before we had gotten too far down the road. With regard to the first takeaway,

17:20 We're very grateful to Brandon and to HMC for the pro bono work that they did to help us develop a new concept. And I think all of us on the board are very proud to say that that new concept involves repurposing Edison Hall, which is currently underutilized, and then creating an addition onto the existing structure.

17:44 That is an amazing development and has really moved the project forward. With regard to the second takeaway about being our ability to own and operate this facility, again, I'm very pleased to say that we're negotiating with the town for TOML to become the owner-operator of the facility. It's really the thing that makes

18:10 the most sense. We're also working closely with the town on programming and sustainability because both of those things are critical. That will include a scope of work from Bill Blake with AMS Research to update prior work on programming, which will include outreach to user groups and the community.

18:33 These changes also necessitate an update to our agreement with the Kern Community College District. They are aware of the changes and they've been very gracious about extending our timeline. There are obviously a lot of moving parts to this project. There are many different entities involved. And this is why we've been somewhat reticent to share where we are with this up until this point. I think

19:02 We feel comfortable now and are glad that you've given us an invitation to see what you think about where we are with the project. And finally, we owe a huge thank you to the Town of Mammoth Lakes for approving funding to bring HMC on board so that we can get to that next level of design, which is a critical step in this process.

19:26 We have a lot to be grateful for, and despite the pandemic, we feel good about where we are. I'm going to let Betsy tell you a little bit about the current status of funding for this project.

19:39 Thanks, Luan. And, you know, I think one of the reasons that the foundation really wanted to find a path forward for this project is that, one, we do think it's an incredibly important project for the community. And that's what the foundation has always really been about. The other reason is that we do have significant funding for the project. And most of our lead donors are still committed to the project. They understand the challenges that we face in construction in this environment and are supportive.

20:09 So just a quick funding breakdown. There's $10 million of public funding in this project, the $7.5 million from the Measure C bond from the Kern Community College District, and then the $2.5 million in funding capital from Measure U. We also have about $3.25 million of private

20:28 major gifts in the project, and we also see potential for additional fundraising as all of these agreements are finalized. We also have some smaller donors, you know, whose gifts we, you know, are holding, and, you know, we will, you know, do some outreach with them as this project continues to move forward.

20:47 Our agreement with HMC, and thanks again to the town for the funding to bring us to this point, it's based on a schedule that has us breaking ground in early 2023, but as we all know, it could be sooner, it could be later, just depending on the progression of these various elements and different tracks, but we're optimistic that we'll get moving as fast as we can. So with that, I'm going to turn it over to Brandon to show you what it looks like.

21:18 Here on my screen here. Kyle, do you want to go ahead and give us an introduction? Yeah, actually, Luan and Betsy gave a really good overview of what's happened to date. I think the only other thing that I want to add is that we had a highly collaborative and interactive design workshop in July to really look at

21:39 parts and pieces of the design in detail and come together as a team to determine the best path forward. We're really excited and, you know, think this project, this building has a ton of potential for the town and the community of Mammoth Lakes. So go for it, Brandon. So as Luan and Betsy and Kyle alluded to, there was a moment definitely during this process.

22:03 from January 2020 that we really decided it was time to relook at the design and that certainly the workshop was kind of the culmination of that where we got together and said, okay, let's look at all the priorities again and the goals and the vision and really what this community needs and make sure that we're on the right path. So that's what that workshop was about. It was really a productive workshop where we learned a lot and we were able to put together essentially what you'll be seeing here.

22:31 So this is, again, a high-level conceptual design, and it's looking at rethinking, you know, the prior approach to the project. And I think ultimately really where we all came from was after we heard all the goals and visions that there was an opportunity with the existing Edison Theater that wasn't being utilized before. And really that opportunity is there was space that was underutilized. And so how can we leverage that space to now support a new theater? And so ultimately that's where the largest.

23:00 So, again, looking at the project, we validated that we wanted to look at a 250-person capacity and really validated some of the main goals that, you know, we heard during this process, prior to this process, and even Betsy and Luan, when you were working on this a long time ago with Bill Blake and programming and community outreach. So, again, validating all the goals, and then we moved into really looking at what this project is for the town.

23:30 And so one of the things that we really wanted to make sure that we were conscious of is that it sits on Meridian. And it's one of the, if you take Meridian off the 203 instead into Maine, it's really one of the things that you're going to see heading into town, but also one of the last things you're seeing. So it's either on the way in or on the way out. And I think when you look at the site, that's a really unique opportunity to really have this cultural center reach out to the community. And so again, looking at

23:59 This is, you know, existing, which you see here in number one, the existing kind of more traditional building. And then what is this new theater? And really what we're looking at and we'll see in some inspiration imagery later is this theater, a theater really needs to be a solid volume. It needs to be massive so that it can really work with acoustics. There's not windows. And, you know, a lot of the imagery that we'll be looking at later, it's really about this gesture, especially.

24:28 In Mammoth, as far as some of the landforms that we're looking at. And so that's what the solid volume becomes. And that volume is the theater. And then connecting together would be what we're calling this jewel box connector. But really, it's that connector that brings and ties together the traditional architecture with this new kind of mountain modern architecture. And it really become adds a lightness to it. And so looking at the diagrams here, number three is showing how these connect together.

24:58 And from a floor plan standpoint, we looked at various options. I think we actually probably had five or six during that workshop that we worked through trying to really understand, you know, what's going to work for flow and efficiency. And we had our theater consultant on board and we were looking at all the different layouts and the recommended spaces for this type of theater. And ultimately what we're looking at is for our auditorium, the angle that we chose had to do with accessing the backstage and accessing it in a way that we could utilize.

25:27 Again, some of this existing floor plan. And so you can see here, this is the, if you can see my cursor, this is the existing building. And then this would be the new auditorium. And then here's our connector here. And so it was about how do we utilize that space and then how we connect that.

25:44 You know, existing space to the new auditorium in a way that, you know, you can have everybody from the backstage, but also how do you utilize the new front door and utilize the existing lobby so you're not building double lobbies and double square footages. And so a lot of what we were looking at was really how do we be efficient and provide the right sizes and the right spaces for what the community needs. And so I will go back to the plan and dive into a little bit more detail, but I know 3D is always pretty interesting. So I will fly through.

26:14 So we just so we can kind of see the volume and how this starts to express itself in three dimensions. So again, this is entering the town on Meridian and how that landform and how that expression really comes out of the ground. And this is one of our images here that we're using to explain that. And this is on Meridian as you pass by and you can see a glimpse of this jewel box connector and some of this traditional architecture. And then again, this would be leaving town.

26:42 And this is in the rendering. So these are really, it's conceptual, it's high level. So we're really looking at what's called solid void. And so you're seeing solid, which would be walls and then the void, which is this transparent material. So this would be glass, but at night or when there's a function, this is really going to light up and be like a lantern that's very welcoming and warm. So that's not quite expressed in this imagery, but it will be soon.

27:05 And this would be entering the front entry, the parking. We looked at some other items as far as redoing some sort of entry portal and then also some sort of new front entry here. And again, this is kind of just a aerial view and another aerial view. And then from a site standpoint, you know, we're really looking at

27:30 you know, potentially how the site can be used, because again, we want to make sure that how we're siting our building and how we're siting the program really works for future development. So we're looking at, you know, potentially some sort of back house workshop area out here, again, some sort of site work that can be done in the future to really accentuate that landform building.

27:49 potential future courtyards, monument signs, this new entry walkway to bring everyone from the parking and the adjacent parking lot into the front entry, an entry portal, and potentially redoing the parking lot in the future as well. And so to jump back to that floor plan, now that we saw some imagery and hopefully can see how this building is articulating itself.

28:15 I will zoom in a little bit here. We're showing this would be the front entry actually. Is that better? Hopefully. So this would be a new front entry, new lobby that really lends itself well to a space that can be used during intermission connecting to the, I'm sorry, this would be a remodeled existing lobby connecting to a new lobby. And then this lobby would then lead you into the auditorium with

28:39 Terrace seating that would be built in. So this would be something, this was another thing that we heard during the workshop is really the goal would be a well-functioning auditorium space for its uses and not necessarily highly flexible because as we looked at that and we were exploring it, it was something that in some ways impacted the performance of it as an auditorium.

28:58 I think, Brandon, going back to the lobby real quick, it's sized appropriately to fit all of the spectators during intermission so that, you know, obviously in the winter months, you're not going outside to a courtyard where you're having, you know, outdoor function. So we wanted to make sure it was sized appropriately for everyone at that time.

29:23 Then looking at the existing, you know, really what we heard is these spaces are working quite well, support spaces, and so the one area that, you know, potentially could be a future modification is a concession area here, and then the back of house could be something that's done as well to really support the space, but right now there are some open spaces in these rooms that could be utilized as storage and shop space.

29:46 New restrooms, these will need to be done to meet code. So we're looking at adding stalls to the existing and also doing a single occupancy all gender stall and then doing new support spaces here for the auditorium. So I think that's, you know, again, keeping it, trying to keep it somewhat brief and high level, but wanted to really allow a lot of time for questions and, you know, any discussion here as we want to dive into more detail.

30:20 Thanks, Brandon. And again, just want to reiterate that we are working through, you know, an agreement with the town. And then we are also getting ready to execute a new contract with Bill Blake from AMS to make sure that the facility will work, you know, for the intended use and doing a little bit of that, you know, kind of building on some of the outreach that he did previously.

30:44 So we're happy to take any questions about the process, about the design. We'd love to hear your reaction. In terms of cost, you know, we're working through some preliminary cost estimates now and really just trying to meet the goals of the project, but at a price tag that we can achieve like every project in Mammoth right now. So thank you.

31:07 Let's see. Also, I just want to point out that slide on the lower left. That is very close to the interior as we actually envision it in the project. The seating configuration is pretty similar, stage area and all of those things. And some of the finishes we're anticipating will also look similar to that slide. Yeah, thanks, Luan. We really worked through some great design inspiration with HMC in this workshop.

31:38 I think that it is a high-level concept, but I think it's on the right path. So thank you, Craig. Thanks, Betsy and team. Board members, questions, comments, thoughts to share with our colleagues. Betsy, I have a question for you. I actually have two questions. The first being...

32:04 The existing theater space that's small, am I correct in that that gets remodeled into something, into those back of the house spaces? That is correct. Okay. And then the second question is, you mentioned an outdoor amphitheater area. Is that included in this design or is that a separate project?

32:25 So we did remove the original concept of the amphitheater from this iteration of the project. With that being said, in our negotiations with the town, it's possible that that's a project that the town might bring back separately later. And again, that's just kind of part of the negotiation we're having with the town. But unlike in the prior designs of the MAC, this iteration doesn't have the space to kind of connect it to the auditorium piece. Okay.

32:55 So this time there's one theater piece. That is correct. One performance area basically. Okay. Exactly. Just for curiosity's sake. Thank you. Betsy, how is the relationship going to work financially with the town and let's say people who want to use the space for programming? That's really what Bill Blake will work through with the town and potential users that is still very much to be determined but would build on that prior work.

33:30 Kyle and Brandon, good to see you guys again, and thank you very much for taking the time and the work on this. You know, obviously what we're being shown today is just kind of high-level conceptual massing and stuff. I guess this is a question for any of you guys. You know, when do you feel like we'll be at a stage where we could get drilled down into a little bit more design renderings for the facility?

33:55 So I think we're working right now on developing a contract for kind of the next stage of that. And that's really at that time is when we're going to start to be able to look at materials and colors and that next level detail stuff that we're looking at. So if I had to guess, I think we're probably four to six months out. Betsy, would you agree with that?

34:18 Yeah, I think that's probably realistic. And Colin, just so you know, I mean, one of the things we need to work through is our agreement with KCCD, bringing the town in as a party to that contract, and also just looking at some project delivery methods that might be available to the foundation. And remind me, what's the existing capacity of Edison Theater?

34:41 So even though we sort of generally reference it as a 100-seat black box theater, some of the seats, actually most of those seats were replaced a couple of years ago. So realistically, there's about 76.

34:54 permanent seats in there, and you can add some more. But right now, the Edison Theater, we actually have closed because we know that the air exchange is not really sufficient given our current concerns about indoor air quality. So yeah, this would be substantially larger than the existing facility. Yeah, so about three times the capacity, roughly. Okay, thanks. Betsy, a question I have is, you know,

35:26 I really like the concept of tying it in much more closely with Edison that I would agree has maybe been underutilized and hasn't reached its potential. It seems to me at least what maybe I envisioned for the map was going to be a larger footprint on the landscape and this really, you know, with it

35:56 Fitting between the Edison Building and Meridian really is the footprint on the land is quite a bit smaller than what maybe I had envisioned what you guys were thinking, particularly like Tamara said, with an outdoor component. Am I on the right track there that, you know, it gives you guys a little bit more land to use in another fashion here, but with this concept?

36:24 That's correct. And it is a smaller footprint. But one of the things we like about it is we do like the visibility from Meridian. We think that's something that the facility has always struggled with. It's a little bit tucked in. And so we like the idea of having that on-street visibility.

36:42 Also, what's interesting is in the original design, you know, there was a lot of kind of event space built in. And what's interesting about this repurposing of the existing lobby and then having the connecting space to also be lobby space is it actually comes out square footage-wise, even though it's a different shape. It actually comes out very similarly to what was originally in the prior Mac design. And you can also see from this slide, thanks, Brandon, that

37:09 where you see the heritage room that was part of the original design and that's actually a repurposing of the existing foundation library. We're kind of excited to update that space. We have some great memorabilia from Dave and Roma McCoy that I know HMC is excited about thinking of some really creative and fun ways to display it both in the heritage room and in the lobby. So we did, I think, retain that intention. Excellent. No, I like the

37:39 concept where it's heading there. Good work. Thank you. Other comments or questions from the board? Well, I'd like to say I'm happy to not see another sprung structure because I think we have enough of those in town. So congratulations on that. I'm just curious, with the limited parking upgrades, is there ample parking for the capacity of the theater?

38:09 Yeah, that's a great question. Thanks, Eric. So in the prior iteration of the MAC, there's actually a parking agreement between Kern Community College District and the foundation, which would allow us to use the additional parking that the college has. And KCCD is aware that we'll need to update that agreement, you know, with the town as the operator of the facility, but they're very, very receptive to that, and I don't think it will be an issue.

38:39 Great. Just a couple other follow-ups. One is, what's going to happen to the existing ski museum? So the existing ski museum is pretty small these days. It's interesting. But a lot of it, you know, is just kind of panels with information. And so we'll still, I think, keep that aesthetic and really just be able to add some of this great McCoy memorabilia that the foundation recently inherited. Okay. And then I'm just wondering, and I don't know if this is planned out yet, but...

39:09 From an operational standpoint, once it's built, the operating expenses, if it's owned by the town, does that mean that it's mandated that town employees are the ones that are being hired and thus causing a much higher employee payroll because of benefits? Yeah, that's something that we haven't, you know, really, really gotten through yet, but that agreement's still in negotiation. So I know the town is, you know, is kind of considering their options and I know Dan is here and I don't know if you'd like to address that at all.

39:39 I think most likely we'd be looking at a combination, whether it's part of a contract operations, some level of town staffing, and also potential to part-time volunteer staffing for a lot of the operations and programs that go on. Again, I think it's going to be critical in that operational side. How does it meet the various needs we anticipate that'll be met through the facility and obviously demands coming in from people to utilize the facility and to work it through to where there's

40:06 not just paid for by the town, if you will, Major U and general fund dollars in terms of operational subsidies, but that the facility moves toward some level of a balance of generating its own revenue income. Knowing that given the types of programming elements we have in the community, that there will likely always be a level of subsidy just given our community-based programming that we believe will help.

40:32 Definitely step in and want to utilize a facility and different cost structure, not able to probably pay the full cost of the running such a facility. Gotcha. Okay. So I just, yeah, I was just wondering, I know we're at the top of the first inning here and I'm asking questions that are kind of the eighth inning. So, but I was just, you know, while decisions are being made, it would make sense to think about that. Like, could you sell beer and wine and alcohol if you're using public funds as a revenue source to offset operational expenses?

40:59 So anyway, thank you guys for answering the questions. I appreciate it. Another question I have, Betsy or Luann, is regarding your funding that you highlighted. I got the impression, I want to make sure I understand correctly what you're aiming at. Is your aim to do this with not needing to incur any debt?

41:29 Obviously minimal debt that you have most of your funding streams lined up and would not need to take a note to finance this over time. Yeah, that's correct, Craig. The foundation is a nonprofit. We're really not looking to borrow any money. That being said, just sometimes the way that major gifts are structured, we might, and because of the way that the foundation would be kind of the...

41:55 You know, possibly the builder of the, of the facility in the construction phase is that we might, we may look at some type of a, of a bridge loan, which is pretty common with kind of the, you know, kind of pledges as collateral. But really our, our primary intent is just to do as much as we can with the funds that we already have in hand, which are, which are substantial. And that was, that was really the direction we gave to HMC, like, hey, like we have this money, what can you do with it?

42:19 You know, as we move through this process, then we'll be ready to go back out to some of those donors we'd started to cultivate prior to March of 2020. And I would imagine that as we do come out of the pandemic and, you know, I think overall we have a greater sense of the need for community spaces and the desire to come together. And so in some ways, yeah.

42:49 Your timing might be, you know, kind of a godsend that the brakes got pumped a little bit and that, you know, who knows, it seems like you might have a good fundraising window here as these plans get out there further and, you know, there are so many new people in town working.

43:15 hear from remotely with maybe other funding mechanisms that, you know, weren't there pre-pandemic. So, you know, we hope you guys will be able to make the most of that. Thank you. Betsy, I'm assuming the answer to this is yes, but, you know, the updated design, when you guys are ready, that'll go back through planning commission design committee, correct? Yes, it'll go through the whole design review process and all that. Okay.

43:44 I just want to add, I know the outdoor amphitheater has been removed from this plan, but, you know, while we have all the players involved on this call, I want to just reiterate, there is a, that should be one of the priorities in town, as someone that puts on an event, goes to a lot of events, we really do need an outside amphitheater, so if there's any considerations to bring that back, I'd be all ears.

44:10 And Eric, I can speak to that briefly. The idea was, you know, fighting off at this point what we thought was the highest priority and what we can get done. The land that's there and the design for an amphitheater still exists, so that's not off the table at all. Future project, future phase into that. And then it's looking at how do we manage parking in the size of the amphitheater. Is it a 300, is it 500, is it 750?

44:36 What kind of, how do you lay that out in the kind of bowl area in there to be able to add that type of value to the performing arts side with that outdoor venue? Utilize for a number of things, not just performing arts side. You can do a lot of other things within the space once it's laid out appropriately. But if we can get this one up and running and going first, and then we can transition to look at what's the demand for that outdoor level of activity.

45:03 No, that's great. I just hope that the plan would have scalability to it so that it's a lot easier to add and you're not just redesigning something because it doesn't work. Correct, yeah. So you want to make sure you do it right the first time. I agree. So you just go to that, look at the slide that's up off to that right side in there where it was kind of identified before. So probably a separate facility, but not physically connected to lay out that and lay out a stage area in the amplifier so it would fit kind of a, there's a nice kind of almost bold setting in there that you can lay it into.

45:33 Thank you. The scope of it. It added value there, absolutely. A quick question. I asked this back when we were talking about the CRC. I asked the question, and it's the same question here, is the point of this to make money on this venue, or is it a community aspect of funding it continuously and having it be flush and affordable to the community? I'm just going to see what the angle is on this now with the town being involved versus it just being the college.

46:03 It'll be balanced. Even with the college, we had, you know, the commitment, all are involved in this too with, we added that commitment of about $300,000 per year out of Measure U for a subsidy level. My guess is potentially on that, that there'll have to be some additional talent subsidies. So we don't see it making money from a sense of breaking even or paying for all this cost, but definitely also not being 100% subsidized.

46:32 We'll be working through that in terms of what we think the annual budget would need to be to run a facility. The previous one that was done, I think it was looking a little over a million dollars a year with, again, that subsidy for Major U, if you will, still coming in at about 300 grand a year ongoing. I don't necessarily see that going away on that, but I also don't see the overall budget being as high as the other facility was just given the structure.

46:58 type of facility we're looking at. So being able to narrow that down and try to limit that level of subsidy, but knowing that given the community values and I think we're going to get requests to utilize it at lower rates is given the ability to raise money from the types of events and venues that there will be an ongoing subsidy to some of them. Awesome. Well, Betsy and Luan, Gary,

47:30 Kyle and Brandon, thank you so much for sharing. You are right, Betsy, it's exciting. We've been all kind of, during this pause, kind of wondering, I know they're up to something over there. It's good to finally see it, and I'm really excited to see that we've, you know, got some funding in place, got good ideas in place, and wish you the best in

47:58 as you get that further out into the community with moving this project forward. Thanks so much, Craig. We really appreciate the opportunity. It's great to be here with you all. So thanks. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. All right, team. Thanks. I think there may be some comments and questions. Oh. Angie, do we have some public comments? Yes.

48:26 Going to ask for that before our guest signed off. We have Tony Taylor. You can go ahead and unmute yourself. Tony Taylor, you can unmute. Okay, can you hear me now? Yes. There you go. Yes, we can hear you. Hello, can you hear me? We can hear you. Yeah, go ahead, Tony. I'm sorry, I could not understand much of what Dan said, and you may have covered this, but is it, is...

49:11 My understanding is that apparently the foundation with funding they have and perhaps will additionally procure that the foundation is going to build this but the town will be the owner operator of it and it'll be the town that assumes risk for

49:41 for operations going forward. Is that correct or not? Yes, Tony, that's, yeah, the idea would be is it would be a bid let by the foundation. The town may help in terms of managing the construction project itself versus having to hire people to do that. So we'd be engaged in that. And ultimately, we'd have an agreement with the foundation for the operation and maintenance of the facility.

50:10 Going back and forth on do we actually end up owning it or is it structured under the agreement? But for the bottom line, which you're looking at, the answer would be yes. That structure would be in place. And Tony, hi, Tony. Just to add to that, you know, just as the foundation built the college and then, you know, but we don't teach the classes or our own or operate, you know, that facility, I think that's the model that we're really looking at with this project.

50:42 Thank you. Angie, do we have other public comment out there? We do. Allison Page, you can go ahead and unmute yourself. Oh, hi. Can you guys hear me? Yes. So, a lot of you guys know me, and my name is Allison Page. I'm the Artistic Director of Sierra Classic Theater, which is one of the two theater companies in Mammoth. I'm a little, actually kind of, it's a little bit upsetting that

51:16 We were not invited to be part of the project of looking at what needs to be built and everything. And I guess I just, I see that you guys had to cut back with the MAC. We were at years and years of meetings about that. And now you're going to give it to the town to run a theater. So I have been directing and producing theater since 2010 in this town. And I just...

51:44 You're going to build it and then hope they come without actually having a theater until 2024. I just, I don't really quite, I don't really understand why we were not kind of invited to the table and whether, like, what is it you guys are expecting to do with this theater? The town is, I mean, Dan Holler is not going to direct unless...

52:14 He's planning on direct, Dan. Let me know. You're absolutely correct. I just don't understand why you guys are actually building a theater if you don't have anybody on board to be actually running a theater and you haven't really talked to those people to see what is best and how it would best work.

52:35 I don't think this is a Field of Dreams situation where you build it and they will come. I think that if you don't have theater for four years, I don't think they will come. So I'm just a little like you're selling this to the town, but you're not actually inviting the people who've been working really hard to create theater in this town.

52:58 to be a part of it and I don't and it makes me feel like it's just some sort of vanity project and not something you actually want to see succeed and that's and I don't know if you're going to be charging us a ton to use it or we're all in this together to try to produce theater or you're just trying to make a big fancy building so I don't I don't really know that's I guess my question and my concern at this point because right now we could be starting to

53:26 do theater, and we're trying to do whatever we can by doing Shakespeare, and now we can't, we don't have a theater in this town, and the Edison's going to be closed to be building a theater in four years. So I don't know how you guys think this is going to, and I just don't understand how it's set up for success.

53:53 Would you like to talk a little bit about Bill Blake and the research and outreach that he'll be doing? Sure, exactly, Allison, and you're absolutely correct. There was years and years of process and input and a lot of outreach with Bill Blake from AMS Research previously to groups like Sierra Classic Theater. And so when we were working through this workshop back in July, we took...

54:21 We took that into account, but also knowing that we needed to really, you know, we needed to develop a project financially, a concept that was going to work. Now, we are in the process, we're getting ready to execute a contract with Bill Blake to go back out to users and to build that pro forma.

54:42 to provide, you know, that guidance and that direction. So we're very excited to be working with him again and would absolutely include, you know, Sierra Classic Theater and all of the other potential users, you know, in that work. So it is the next step. I hear you. I guess what I'm saying is I think potential users and a theater is sort of almost misaligned.

55:07 I think that if you're really going to sell this, it's not selling this place. It's selling, if you're going to, you know, if you're going to build a basketball court, you've got to have a basketball team that's saying, hey, let's have fans. So I think that you're kind of, I think it almost needs.

55:24 I think why the MAC didn't work is because you didn't have that. I think you want theater goers. You want to be selling an idea of a place and everything and people who are working really hard to make it instead of being like, okay, we're going to then after the fact sell it to the users. I really personally feel that you need to have some sort of like

55:51 A vision and somebody, people and something that is, you know, that is attached to that vision from the get-go if you're really going to sell this thing. Because, you know, people came here for sports. They came here for the outdoors. And you need to cultivate audience members.

56:14 We were much lower than usual. I mean, even though we had two this summer and that's probably COVID, but you need to cultivate audience members. I don't think you just build it and then you get rental companies to come and fill your seats. I think that just is something that you should really consider at this right now because $16 million is a lot.

56:42 to just throw out if you're never going to see any return and nobody's ever going to fill those seats. And I don't think anybody here that I'm looking at can do that, can actually fill the seats. So I think you need to really go out to the people who are going to work their ass off to get those seats filled and to build what's inside the theater. Awesome. Well, thank you, Allison.

57:14 for your comments and for all the work you've done cultivating theater in Mammoth Lake. Angela, other public comments? We do have a couple more. Joe Bacon, you can go ahead and unmute yourself. Thank you.

57:33 And boy, it's nice to see some of these faces I haven't seen in a while. For those of you that don't know me, I've been active on this project since the first working groups in 2010. And I will just quickly restate what Allison said, is that I don't see the user groups in the community being involved at this point. And that really concerns me. I mean, we worked long and hard on several iterations of how to fill those seats. And yet, I haven't heard anything along that line yet.

58:03 And while some point down the road, the road community will be involved. I do like the town, the idea of the town being involved in some ways, but I didn't hear you saying that there's going to be someone who's going to bring, it's got to be a combination of local and external things. And we have that had that in the past, but I'm not really seeing that. And I'm knowing that.

58:28 You know, there's a whole bunch of questions I have about how this would work, having been on the stage in the tiny Edison Theater, having done concessions and tickets, and there's a lot more input that the community and the users should have to this. So I ask that that be something sooner rather than later, because that's also where you're going to buy the commitment for that last mile of dollars that you're going to need to build it. You're not going to build it if you don't have the community involved.

58:58 I was lucky to be part of building our beautiful library, which took seven different levels of funding sources to get built. And if you don't have that collaboration, we won't get this off the ground. I am a little concerned about construction costs and getting a look at this from the performer's perspective to make sure that we're not

59:22 It's still something we can live with. It's not something that we're making do with what we've got available, where if we waited a couple years, we'd have better funding sources, you know. So I'd like to see some discussion of that is getting the groups in to see can we live with this. I'd like to hear more about getting other grants and things like that. It cannot lie on the back of just a few big donors.

59:51 Or it won't happen, or at least the library wouldn't have happened if we hadn't had everything from $100,000 to $1 bids, or I guess even from a million in this case. I do look forward to getting, you know, hopefully there'll be another group involved in this. And I did want to reiterate Tony's points about the long-term management and Eric's about, well, how does that really work?

1:00:20 I would hope that there would be some kind of a community session because unless we were lucky enough that Kim knew to include someone who knew us in this original email, most people didn't even know about this meeting. So I would ask that there be some kind of a review sooner rather than later for everybody to get involved. And I did have one question that I think came through later is that

1:00:50 When the architects were saying that there was a design workshop in July, that was just for staff? Yeah, so the design workshop back in July was very small. It was foundation staff, foundation executive committee members, and some town staff. And always with the understanding that

1:01:14 You know, we just wanted to see if we could get, you know, a conceptual design, you know, on board. And then, I don't know if, Brandon, if you want to talk a little bit about, HMC does have a theater consultant that was part of the workshop. But the intent, I think, was always to, you know, to develop this concept, but then, you know, to go back out. And this is really our first public unveiling of the concept that we, you know, that we were able to work through with HMC.

1:01:40 I guess I'm just suggesting that this is almost like your beta run, that you need to do a bigger one that more of the community can be involved in, in seeing what you have so far to kind of, you know, what do they say, kick the tires?

1:01:55 Yeah, Allison and Joe, completely understand and appreciate your comments. And, you know, I just want to clarify, as Betsy had mentioned, we were really trying to take a step back and it's more of a feasibility conceptual approach of, okay, you know, what would it look like if we were to reuse some of the existing and try and find ways to make it more efficient and reduce the cost of it, especially, you know, as Allison, I believe, mentioned with this escalating market, how we can do that. But we're still very early on in the process.

1:02:25 And there's, you know, we haven't even begun really what we call the schematic design processes where we then go back into, you know, the program and validate everything and meet with users. So, you know, very early on, and as Betsy had mentioned, we're really trying to test a theory, as you might say, and look at it and see, okay, okay, something like this could work, this does seem feasible, and then move it to the next steps.

1:02:50 Okay, and I guess what I'm saying is, and I think what Allison was also saying, and Sher would say if she was not out of town, is that don't get too far down the line before you get that input, because it's so important to have that from the people who will actually use the facility. Yes, absolutely. Joe, thank you so much for your comment, and it sounds like duly noted. Thank you. Angie, we have more public comment.

1:03:23 We do. Leslie Ann Hoxie, you can unmute yourself. Hi, can you hear me? Yes, Leslie. So I just want to clarify the fact that so the Edison will absolutely not be used at all going forward from this moment forward. There's not like any kind of window where there could potentially be use of a theater space and tall construction.

1:03:50 Yeah, let me jump in and clarify one more thing, Betsy, if you don't mind. What we were indicating, so as far as this approach that we presented today, there is a lot of flexibility when it comes to phasing, and there's certainly no reason, construction-wise, that would need to be decommissioned prior to, you know, a few months before completion, essentially.

1:04:12 Some of the existing theater would need to be utilized for restrooms, and that would only need to be built after the new edition is built. And so there's some ways to phase this so that there could be a really short period where there is no available theater. And again, that's up to a lot of other factors as far as COVID and the town's mandates. But ultimately, from a construction standpoint, we can shorten that window as much as possible.

1:04:40 Okay, yeah, because I do think, you know, what has been brought up in the last couple comments is the fact that, like, when you don't have anything, you lose, you know, you lose performers, you lose the momentum, you lose the interest from the community. And, you know, obviously with COVID, we've definitely had some struggle with maintaining that.

1:05:04 in general. And so I do, I want to just, yeah, completely underline, you know, exclamation point a couple times. The point that, you know, Allison and Joe both brought up that if we don't have this animation of performance art, then it's going to be very difficult to bring it back.

1:05:28 And in a capacity where we would need that much space. And so I don't know if that's necessary, completely directed towards the foundation or just MLR in general to kind of be aware of that fact, that we do need to make sure that there's a way to keep theater alive and performance alive in our town. You know, before we...

1:05:55 Bring, you know, really have this grand opening with this new space. And I think I had another thought, but I can just email someone. Thank you, Leslie Ann, for your comment and your passion for performing arts in our community. Thanks. Yeah, I think it's a great point, Leslie. Thank you. Angie, any other public comments? Not at this time. Okay.

1:06:30 Well, excellent. Betsy and team, it looks like we got some good feedback for you. And as I was starting to say, all the best as you start going through the next steps and as you engage with the community. It's exciting to see the passion out there. And as I mentioned earlier, during COVID, the absence of some of our performing arts, we did have

1:06:58 You know, some momentum going, and it's exciting to see that we have a number of people in our community who really want to keep that going and to see how these two fit together in the future will be exciting. Thanks very much. Yeah, lots more to come. Yeah, thanks. I just want to say thank you, Betsy team, for making your presentation with us tonight and sharing the first viewing with our little family here. Appreciate you guys' efforts. Thank you.

1:07:29 Thanks for the time. All right. Thank you. Okay, let me get my agenda back open here and moving on to 5.1, approval of minutes from the regular meeting September 9, 2021. I will make a motion to approve. We got a motion from Tamara Bankson. Do I have a second? Do I have a second?

1:08:09 I'll second that. Thanks, Greg. Oh, thank you, Heather. Second, Schadmeyer. Any discussion? Angela, could you do our roll call, please? And per the agenda, we're looking for a motion to approve the consent agenda? Yes. And I just want to clarify that that was Ms. Minksen's intent was to approve the consent agenda. Correct. It is my motion to approve the consent agenda. Thank you.

1:08:41 on September 9th, 2021. President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Yes. Secretary Bankson? Yes. Board Member Ferney? Yes. Board Member Wasserman? Yes. Thank you. Passes 5-0. Thank you very much. Moving on to policy matters. 6.1. Approval of

1:09:11 401k employer match to be based on total compensation for program director. Kim sent out a little report with that. Kim, why don't you take it away? Thank you. So going back to our last meeting where we approved the new employment contract for myself, one of the

1:09:40 stipulations was the 401k match be based on salary only and not any other compensation and that is actually not allowed and so I wanted to make sure we brought it back to the board and everyone was in agreement to continue to move forward with I guess the original employment agreement without the change for the 401k plan.

1:10:09 And if there needs to be any other changes. So basically the match needs to be made on total compensation paid to an employee. It can't just be salary. So that is going to include salary, the health stipend and remote office stipend as well. If I can just reiterate that we have some emailing back and forth and I apologize, Kim, I can't remember her name. Sarah.

1:10:40 Sarah, sorry, they confirmed that that was correct. So I was a part of that conversation that it does need to be the total compensation. As well as talking about the percentage that we match that Kim puts in. Other questions from other board members on this item? I'll just say this. I'm the advisor on the plan, so I'm going to recuse myself from the voting as I need to, but that's spot on with what they said.

1:11:16 You know, that is a Department of Labor, IRS type of thing that that has to happen. That's what was negotiated with the employees originally. So I will say this, this is a safe harbor 401k plan. It is mandatory that 4% gets matched anyway. So what we're looking at is an extra 2% that was negotiated in the past. I'm going to assume I need to recuse myself for the same reason.

1:11:52 Well, that doesn't leave very many of us to vote, does it? Thank you for doing the homework on it. Yeah, I will make a motion to approve the 401k employer paid match to be based on total compensation to our program director. Tamara, I'll second that because it's kind of our thing right now. Thanks. It is kind of your thing. So we got a motion from...

1:12:19 Board Member Bankson and second from Schaubmeyer. Any further discussion on this? My only question is obviously we have to do what's legal. My question is, is it a huge number? Is there a huge number of difference that we're concerned about for the budget? Okay. No. Thank you. What? 6% of what's our 1,000? 6% of 12,000 and another... 900, yeah.

1:12:51 Yeah. Okay. So $900,000, something like that. And typically it's 2% because the other 4% had to happen anyway. Yes, it's, I think it's $775 a year. Got it. Got it. Thank you. Yeah. Cool. All right. No further discussion. Angela, could you, can we do a roll call on this? President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Sorry, yes. Secretary Bankson? Yes.

1:13:25 And board member Fernie, did I hear you were recused? Correct, yep. And board member Wasserman? I recused as well. Thank you. So motion passes 3, 0, and 2 abstain or recused. So it passes 3, 0. All right, moving on to our next item, 6.2, which actually is

1:13:58 may help us avoid these little missteps is appointment of a human resources review ad hoc committee. And so Kim, I'll let you take it away again. Yeah, so exactly. The 401k match brought up some other issues in the contract and it just got brought to our attention. We should really

1:14:26 Take a few minutes and review our employee handbook and guidelines just to make sure it's current with all of the regulations and policies that are in place. And so what I would like to do is have two board members sit on a ad hoc committee with myself, take a look at the handbook, make sure certain things like sick leave.

1:14:55 are awarded correctly, paid time off. I don't anticipate it'll be much, have a couple meetings. Town of Mammoth Lakes has offered to have an internal review after we've done a review with their HR department to make sure we're on the right track. And then from there, if we choose to have like an outside human resources attorney reviewed as well, then we can do that. But I certainly think that we

1:15:25 It's not my expertise. It's not any of our expertise. So it should be something that we attend to since it is such a binding document that we abide by for contractual agreements and whatnot. So with that said, any questions about that before I ask for some volunteers? Like I said, I think it should be about two meetings. You know, well, it's not a long handbook, but just reviewing it, kind of bouncing some ideas off of each other.

1:15:57 Making some edits and then sending it off for professional review. Do we have access to anyone to help us for free that is an expert in this? I know me personally, I hire an outside firm for this because I don't know the first thing about it. And I'm just wondering if we have access to the town in our relationship. We do. So yeah, so town manager has indicated that the HR department for the town of Mammoth Lakes will review it for us.

1:16:27 I'm thinking that it's in a state we need to give it an internal review first and then have them review it. And our accountant also gave us a human resource attorney that she works with often if we feel we need to take another step and pay for some services. Does it need to be an ad hoc, Kim, or can it just be something that we all review? It can be that. I was just trying to be mindful of...

1:16:57 People's time and just getting a couple folks to hop on that felt maybe that was interesting to them. Or, you know, if you guys want me to send you out and everybody can make edits and track changes and then we can have the Human Resources Department review that. I'm okay. I don't know about you and me, Kim, but I don't think anybody thinks reading HR documentation is available for anybody. I'm sorry. But I think all of our eyes should touch it.

1:17:25 And there might be some points that are brought up by having different POVs with different business owners on here. That's my two cents. Okay. Yeah, I'll agree with Heather on that. I think we all have different eyes and expertise and we might all see something, some components that we're aware of and Colin might have different, you know, different things that he's aware of. So there's not that many of us left. There's six of us. I think we can all take a stab at just a quick, like you said.

1:17:54 A first eyes. And then we have, if we have an outside body, the town, they can correct us if we're wrong. Is there any way we can just all read it and get back to you by next Monday or something or by next Friday? Like, is there any way that you give us a reasonable timeline? Everybody just spend an hour reading over the exciting handbook and then get back to you. That's even better. That's fabulous. Is that agreeable to?

1:18:21 I think that's a great idea. Fabulous board members. Yeah, that's fine by me. It's one last meeting, right? Everybody gets to go home and read it. We all give our input by a certain day and it's less meetings for everybody. Tablet on the couch is much better than being in a meeting. Perfect. Okay. Awesome. I will send it out for review. When would you need a response by Kim? Do you need to get any feedback from us on that? Like I'm assuming it's something timely.

1:18:51 here by like the end of the week or something next week? I wouldn't go that far. I'm going to give us a couple weeks probably because we want to probably I would say adopt something at our next meeting. So we have about two months to review finalize. So I'd say within a couple weeks if you could have it back to me I'd be happy. So Kim you'll just send it out and give us a deadline. I operate best on deadlines.

1:19:19 I was going to say, Kim, unless you don't give us a deadline, it'll be like the weekend. It will never get read. Tomorrow. Give us two weeks or something. He's going to read it on the morning of the 15th. I'll read it on the evening of the 14th. And don't give us two months. That's two months. We'll all read it. You get a week. And the holiday. It don't count. So throw out three weeks in there because of holidays. Feedback. It will be one week. One week. I like it.

1:19:49 Crack the whip, Kim. Kim, I'm going to ask for two. Give us two. I'm going to second Eric on two. I'm out of town next week. Well, certainly before the start of the Thanksgiving holiday. So, Kim, when you send that out, give us a deadline on there. Yeah. Certainly before Thanksgiving. Yeah. So, I think we can all agree by the 15th or something like that. So, it's done. Let's do Friday the 12th. I like it. Boom.

1:20:20 I like it. Okay, so we don't need to, since that's going to be a board action, I don't think we need to do anything. That'll be on our next agenda. And so then moving on to 6.3, financial report, Kim, for September. September. Do you all have this in front of you? Do you want me to share my screen? I don't know.

1:20:48 Show your screen if you wouldn't mind. Sure. Please. Find it. Okay. Pulling it up. Make it a little bit bigger. Does that look all right? Anybody? Okay. It's just kind of small, Kim. Sorry, my eyes aren't great. Can you make it bigger? Yeah. Thanks. Let's see. Let me just minimize the bookmarks, Kim. Okay.

1:21:32 Tamara, they have these things called reading glasses, I'm just saying. I'm avoiding those, that's way better, thank you. All right, I think that's about, you'll get the gist. Okay, so these are monthly financials through September 30th, 2021. Just run through them. Let's see, first to note, if you'll look at the total for direct public support.

1:22:03 We're at 705% of budget. A couple reasons for this. One, we budgeted very conservatively for income and contributions. This will definitely even out over the year. We had a great start to the year with contributions, business contributions for different programs and initiatives we've been involved in. And now things are going to start slowing down for that.

1:22:33 Kim, was there a particularly large donor for one thing that made the number so much larger? No, no. I mean, I wouldn't say particularly large. You know, there was some $5,000 donations towards like the Dispersed Camping Initiative, some Adopt-a-Trail sponsorships. I think $5,000 has been our biggest single donation thus far. Great.

1:23:04 So yeah, so we're quite ahead for the year, but we're at $24,000 through September, and for the year we budgeted $37,000. So we're certainly on track to still meet our goal. Let's see, moving down to government grants here. We're a little bit ahead of budget only because the only thing that was budgeted was the town contract.

1:23:35 And other items like income from our grants from like Sierra Nevada Conservancy are added here. So that is just sort of income that is accounted for. Let's see. And so the expenses for these government grant restricted from like the grants, the Sierra Nevada one that Matt Perula wrote are going to show up in the program service expenses later on in the budget.

1:24:13 So, you know, business expenses, we're doing good. Contract services, about spot on. Office supplies, you know, for the most part, we're doing good. We are over budget here on the last item, the bank service charges, which I think I spoke about last meeting. Those are directly related to our contributions.

1:24:45 So the more contributions we get, the more we're going to pay to process those. So it's a good thing, I guess, to be over budget on that. It's not like late fees or things like that. Those are our sponsorship pay, whatever you call them, percentage that we pay to take a donation comes out of. Let's see, insurance, we're doing fine. Payroll. I do need to add the remote office stipend.

1:25:20 to our budget. I entirely didn't account for that as part of our payroll expenses. So I'll come back in January with some reallocations, an updated budget for you to look at. So Kim, I have a question. When you look at the total expenses, it's $39,000 over budget. And I see that line item is $60,090 program service expense. What is that? You're already at the bottom. We're getting there. Oh, sorry.

1:25:50 No, it's tough all day. Let's see. So let's see. Travel, I mean, everything else is good. And let's get down to 6,900, which is our program service expenses. And that is where all of our expenses for the adopted trail program and all of the expenses we pay for a grant. You know, we paid $22,000 for a...

1:26:19 Vault toilet that is being installed at Buckeye Hot Springs. So our income is showing up higher, and then all of our program service expenses are down here, which just is another thing that it's not budgeted for at all, and I need to figure out how to do that. Now that we've had these programs running for a couple years, I could have a better idea of what expenses are going to come out.

1:26:46 So is it fair to say it's like a pass-through, we're getting money in for these things, and then we're just laying it out, so these aren't our expenses, it's to run things. Exactly. So if you back that 47, that 40 out, we're essentially right on budget, a little bit ahead. Gotcha. That's what I was trying to drill down to. Yep. So yeah, it's just an interesting way to try to show that on an accounting sheet. Let's see if there's anything else I wanted to say about that.

1:27:19 Kim, I would say this might be an offline conversation, but I'm wondering from an accounting standpoint, is it better to have an account number for each pass-through project so that we can see how they're running all lumped together where you can't really figure out what's what? That would be good. Then I wouldn't have to track it separately. So yeah, maybe we can talk offline and figure that one out. Kim, isn't in your...

1:27:49 In the next item, your program budget report, doesn't it have some of that detail in it? Maybe I was mistaken when I was reading through my packet, but... It does, exactly. And that's separate than this accounting. And I think Eric's idea of combining it all is wonderful. It'll just, you know... I would agree. A few more numbers and lines, but that's okay. It's a great idea.

1:28:19 Eric, I think if I'm correct, if this is QuickBooks, you can classify them? Yeah, totally. And then when you run the report, if you don't want to include those program services, you just remove that class. And then it's going to show us everything that's relevant to MLR's budget, but doesn't include those classifications. Is that correct? That's exactly where I was going to go offline. Yeah, you're exactly right, Tamara.

1:28:47 We'll go. It's not very hard, Kim. We'll help you do it. Perfect. Yeah. I mean, I think it's working with our accountant because this is the system that was come up with and it certainly can be improved. So it'd be great. Okay. So expenses, we're essentially right on if we back this 40 out, that is our income that we brought in specifically for to be spent on those expenses. Let's see.

1:29:19 Scrolling, this is all over the place being so big. Other income, good news to share, the second Paycheck Protection Program loan was forgiven. And so definitely grateful for the help that program provided that completes any obligation MLR had through that. And our bottom line here, net income, $19,000.

1:29:51 We can be excited about that, but also then step back and remember that there's still several thousand dollars probably, you know, in the next slide we'll get to this that MLR has taken in and is still accounted for by other programs. Any questions on the budget overall? I like the idea of getting together with you guys offline and discussing some of the details.

1:30:18 That's great, Kim. Like Tamara was saying, the benefit of doing that is it strips out what's ours from what's not. Because I know personally, I'm looking at the finances trying to figure out if we're on track because we're at a pretty tight budget. So this makes it simple. Excellent. Great work, Kim. Thank you. Thank you. Let's see if I can just scroll right up. So if we have no other questions, I'll move to the next item.

1:30:50 Which, you know, speaking with the board, I've been hearing some interest in learning exactly how each of our programs are doing. And so this graphic here, this spreadsheet is sort of a trial run. Want to get some feedback on how it's presented and, you know, maybe we won't even need to do this now if we can get it into our other budget. But basically I've chosen three.

1:31:20 of our more active programs here, about out of 15 or so that have to be tracked separately for income and expenditures that are dedicated to programs. So starting with Adopt-A-Trail, jump into that one's probably the hardest first, sort of gave you a program lifetime view, and fiscal year 1920 MLR put out

1:31:53 You know, almost $8,000 to develop the webpage to host the Adopt-a-Trell program and accept donations and have people adopt it with the intent that that was just what MLR laid out. And we'd recoup it slowly over time through administration fees, which makes sense, except then you're not really accounting for your admin time, you know, which I definitely do spend time on that.

1:32:24 But looking at the program as a whole, this has been very successful. It's taken in over $31,000. You can see the expenses and what admin fees are generated that do go towards MLR in my time to administer the program. The two bottom boxes here, the Eastern Sierra Dot Patrol Program has facilities that are both in Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mono County.

1:32:53 So the monies have to be separated and that's the sponsorships coming in and as well as the expenditures. So you can see the balances for each. Mammoth Lakes has a larger number of facilities, a larger number have been adopted and so their figures are larger. Mono County also has a significant number of facilities and is also using the funds to get some projects done on the ground as well.

1:33:24 So that's how I'm tracking those ones as part of our program service expenses. These all come out of here. Any questions on this so far? I'm just trying to figure out if I'm reading this right. So basically we've brought in $31,500, spent roughly, call that close to $8,000. So does that mean that if you subtract that $31,000 from $8,000, that's how much money we've kept?

1:33:55 No. The design of the program, when it was initialized, was that MLR was just going to pay for that initial expense. And, you know, it might have been because we were 100% funded by the town, and this was a program we were going to provide for the town, and that was part of our contract.

1:34:19 And so that's just, I'm just showing this as, you know, we have put a lot of skin into this program and we're administering it for very little return. But the point is, is there is, we are able to bring a lot of money in to put back to projects on the ground. So I guess I'm confused because from the way this looks, it looks like there's a lot more income than there is expense. Yep. And that's because it's up to,

1:34:50 The trail system, you know, Joel managing the trail system and Matt Perulo managing the Mono County Recreation Department. As projects come through that they need funding for, they invoice MLR. And so this is sort of a bank account that they have ready as a project comes to fruition. Yeah, Eric, so maybe the way to think about it is, you know, we've had that $31,500 in income, and like you said,

1:35:19 between expenses and admin fees, you know, so far, $8,300. The balances below that towards the Mammoth Lakes Trail System and Mono County are the remainder of that that are going to be spent on those projects of keeping the trails, you know, signage, whatever may be needed. Am I getting that right, Tim?

1:35:46 That's exactly right. So it's like the checking account balance, basically. Yes. Yep. Okay. Exactly. Thank you, Craig. Sorry, I wasn't explaining that clearly. That's okay. Yeah. And so, you know, Tangle Free Waters, you know, the accounting's a lot easier than that because it doesn't have to be split between anybody. We just have income and expenses.

1:36:15 You know, again, MLR put out a lot of money to build a website or a webpage to host the ability to sponsor and volunteer for these facilities. And then over time, you know, this program has generated some income. It's certainly one that, you know, I think is a really important program on the ground, but we do need to figure out how to make it more viable and increase our capacity to manage it.

1:36:46 And so that one, you know, down here, the program balance, the end of each fiscal year, and then the current balance is just over $3,000. And the dispersed camping, that was just started last year and still have some invoicing to do, but I imagine that there'll be close to $8,000 or so for

1:37:17 You know, the county to decide how to use this program moving forward next year if they want to do it the same way or, you know, use that donations and sponsorships as a grant match. But that was a good one to be involved with. Can I ask maybe a silly question? Does this beg the question that our admin fee should be larger than what they are, than the 10% we're taking?

1:37:52 I think that's a yes and a no answer. Yes, if we need to cover our costs more. No, if we want to have our costs covered or have our bottom line be positive and still put as much money as we can back in the community.

1:38:21 Good answer. The more I thought it through, it's like, well, you know, because it is the benefit we provide, you know, whether it's the town or whatnot, is that this whole idea that we're leveraging funds that, you know, that we have donations coming in and we want, by and large, for them to go towards the projects we don't want to be

1:38:49 I don't think we want to be saddled with a ton of administrative expense diluting the work that people are donating towards. I know all of us as we donate to charities that, yeah, how much goes to fundraising and how much goes to administration and how much goes to feeding kids or saving animals or whatever the cause may be is, you know, and

1:39:19 Certainly 10% is a very reasonable admin fee and it was more of a rhetorical question. Yeah, I mean, yeah, as long as we can cover our expenses, I feel that the best function of Mammoth Lakes Recreation is to put the money back into the community. I would also say it's relatively on par with where the expectation should be in this space. So I think it's not...

1:39:47 You know, wildly out of line with what you see across the board in, you know, too high, too low. Yeah. Now that feels like a good sweet spot and we're doing good work and that's the most important part. So then the second page here is the line item 6,900 from our monthly financials.

1:40:21 That 40,000 you see, this is how it's all broken down and coded between each project. And so all that is extracted to receive the balances that we're just looking at in the charts above. And so, yeah, I just kind of wanted to show you guys what it looks like on that end. Awesome. Good job, Kim. Any other questions? No. So let's move on.

1:41:02 Fiscal year annual report 6.5. Okay. That's me again. Okay. So I did a annual report. You may remember we sort of did some test runs maybe six months ago or so, but

1:41:37 I think this one, we finished our finances for fiscal year 2021, so I felt comfortable making just a short, simple annual report that we can share. It's never been done for the organization, so it would be nice to start building upon these. Just started with some information about who we are, our mission, you know, to deliver cutting edge.

1:42:04 Sustainable Recreation, Mobility and Arts and Culture Opportunities and Infrastructure for the Benefit of the Community and Natural Environment of Mammoth Lakes. Guiding Principles, Quality of Life, Public Benefit, Stewardship and Sustainability. And then dove into the Contribution Reporting, which is the Direct Public Support.

1:42:39 Grant funding and sponsorships that we received for community programs and initiatives. So it was $164,500. I did note that it was a 290% increase over last year, which I also want to note, I don't expect that number to be as wildly high ever again. I would hope so, but we had a start of a lot of programs that we were involved in.

1:43:09 And grant efforts that, you know, Matt Perulo worked very hard on getting when he's with MLR and working with the county. So, you know, it's a significant increase just to show how much work we are doing and putting back into the community. But again, it's quite a high number and I hope for increases, but I don't expect that much. Then I highlighted our community programs, the Adopt-A-Trail.

1:43:40 Tangle Free Waters, supporting Mammoth Lakes Trail System. And so these were all contributions tagged specifically for these programs. And same thing with a couple initiatives that we're involved in, you know, accepting donations to help Sierra Trash Eliminators procure the safety supplies, trash grabbers, anything they need to do the good work. Part of the Dispersed Camping Collaborative, administering the

1:44:12 Temporary infrastructure at all the key locations. And here's the three grant projects that we have been administrating. The Buckeye, this is a big one, some incredible improvements to the parking area, created safe access to the actual hot springs. Interpretive panels will be developed and installed in the coming spring.

1:44:40 The toilet is up and running and picnic table is on site. It got delivered last week, a couple weeks ago. The education and safety grant, we're able to work with Mammoth Lakes Trails Public Access Foundation, working with the OSV hosts at staging areas.

1:45:04 and developed a very awesome winter recreation map and brochure that will be live soon. And the National Wilderness Stewardship Alliance Grant, that provided for a lot of town trail crew and Mono County's trail crew steward time, completing a bunch of great projects. A couple sponsorships, we got a $5,900 sponsorship from Los Angeles Department of Power and Water.

1:45:37 They built and maintained six tangle-free water stations, were the presenting sponsor of our Fly Fishing Film Festival, and they hosted the first annual Mammoth Lakes Photo Fishing Derby. Mono County Fish and Wildlife Commission, when they were around, also donated $5,000 to support local waterway cleanup efforts. Here's some pictures of those programs in action.

1:46:07 Here's the Earth Day Festival we participated in from the Mono County money, the wildlife. Here is the toilet and dumpster out at Owens River Road. Mono County Trail Stewards, flying a log over the trail. One of our tangle-free water stations being used, always nice to see. Doctor Trail sign being installed up at Horseshoe Lake.

1:46:37 Trail host out at Shady Rest on winter fat bikes. Another Tangle Free Water Station up at Gall Lake Park and just some great trail work that got done. In the annual report, I also highlighted, you know, the important role that MLR plays in making recommendations for Measure R and U to Town and Mammoth Lakes. Link to our webpage showing which organizations were supported.

1:47:08 And gave just a quick overview of the grant process just to let viewers know how much time and oversight is involved in this. And then I moved on to advisory committees, talked about the Mammoth Trails Committee and the role that they play. Community outreach we've done, Mammoth Trails community meetings, hosting those twice a year. And then in addition, some

1:47:40 Topic-specific meetings, like on the 18th of this month, we'll be hosting a shady rest in your craters trail planning project meeting, so that will be good. Completed a couple trail etiquette videos, did one on e-biking, another on controlling speed, and we had one lined up for equestrian encounters that got snowed out, so that was a welcome canceled. It was nice to have snow.

1:48:11 Highlighted the Childhood Newsletter that goes out every other week. And finally, just introduced or gave a link to introduce the viewer to our board and staff. And I thank you with a link to further support us. And that is our annual report. Great job, Kim. I know a lot of work went into that. That looks great. Yeah, that's awesome. Thank you for taking the time to put that together. Yes, awesome. Thank you.

1:48:45 Tight. Very good. Should be easy to build on from here, so that's great. Fantastic. Can I ask what program you used? It's called PictoChart. PictoChart. I like it. It turned out great. Thank you. And then, Kim, we had talked previously about doing, whether it was quarterly, sticks in my mind, but maybe

1:49:15 You know, at least once or twice a year, you know, being on the Town of Mammoth Lakes Town Council agenda, and that's a nice, tight, you know, 10-minute presentation of what MLR is doing, and is the intention that you would use that annual report to get before the Town Council? Definitely one of the intentions, yeah.

1:49:45 I think it suits itself for that very nicely. Great idea. Thanks. No other questions for Kim on that? Then we'll move on to 6.6, Discussion and Possible Action on Open Board Seat. I know we had some stuff in the, I believe, the sheet. I don't know about the Mammoth Times.

1:50:13 But, you know, of opening on our board. And so what do you get to report to us on that front? Well, I don't have much to report. The vacancy was noticed in the sheet 1023 and 1030 issue. We had one interested person respond, but that person has since withdrawn their letter of interest. And so we, you know,

1:50:44 The issue is still out, so we could be getting some more interest, but I will be working on like a one-page overview of Mammoth Lakes Recreation that can accompany perhaps the annual report that we can use as a resource for outreach and recruitment. You know, so hitting the streets, and then we can also notice it again come December if we haven't had any interested people. Okay.

1:51:17 You know, I know we had talked about, you know, each of us as board members, you know, kind of who might want to join us within our circles and do we have any updates there from people who have, you know, reached out and made any contacts and maybe what the feedback might have been? Nor I.

1:51:51 And, you know, we've all had our heads down and running, but, you know, just a reminder for all of us to, you know, be as we're, you know, coming out of COVID and, you know, getting out and socializing a bit, you know, look for that person who might complement our team here. And so, awesome. It's that lack of a day, Mike. What a great team it is.

1:52:22 I feel like we might need somebody in the arts to kind of add to our collection of folks right now. I think we're missing out on something, someone in the arts area personally. That's a great point, Heather. And with the, you know, with the MAC starting to get some momentum again, that's even that much more important that we're kind of engaged in the arts community and helping them be a voice. So, you know.

1:52:51 Maybe one of the folks who talked this evening just volunteered. Send me an email. Cool. No other questions on that? Then moving on to board member reports. We'll start off with you, Eric. Well, I'd like to thank both Mother Nature and Mammoth Mountain for having a wonderful opening. I was on the Hill Friday and Saturday.

1:53:22 Great job, Craig. The mountain for October skiing, it was pretty darn awesome. Quite frankly, for November, December, it'd be pretty awesome. So my report is I am thrilled that ski season has started and that we're operating and let's pray for some more snow. We're off to a good start. Yeehaw. Thanks, Eric. Yep. How about you, Heather? Sorry. We, not much report here. I've just had a lot of family stuff going on. So at this point, it's just been a lot of

1:53:55 Trying to stay healthy. I did get to experience having COVID. Double vax was one of those breakthrough cases and shared it with my whole family. Don't do it is my recommendation. It was not enjoyable and everybody had a different experience. So that was kind of interesting. And then just trying to get back into work. As you know, the snow is flying and they are coming. My phone's blowing up with the amount of people that are planning to come up here for Thanksgiving and for the holidays.

1:54:22 Bring on the weather, and that's all I've got to report right now. Cool. Thanks, Heather. How about you, Tamara? Also, not that much to report here. It's a slower time for MMCF. We kind of close out our books and start looking at next year. I'm super happy that the mountain is open, which is really great, but just getting into the season and looking forward to the holidays, so not a whole lot to report. Cool. Thanks, Tamara. Colin?

1:54:56 Yeah, I think the only thing I was going to report, potentially there were some perplexed faces on the board when I recused myself from the 401k item, so I thought I might clarify. Not sure whether I've made you guys aware, but I have joined Eric at Mammoth Wealth as a financial advisor, so it's been...

1:55:19 A long run up with a lot of licenses, you know, SIE, Series 7, Series 66, California insurance license, all taken care of at this point. And actually my first official day, I suppose, was yesterday. So I guess I'm a glutton for punishment with a new baby. And I announced to you guys that I started a summer business, ramping up for black tie.

1:55:48 joining WAAS at the practice, so needless to say, I'm stretched a little thin these days, but just figuring it all out, managing everything, excited for winter, and excited for all those new adventures, so yeah, I'm here, I'm around for the foreseeable future, so just excited to be settling back in here and getting rolling with the winter. Sweet.

1:56:16 Thanks, Colin. And hopefully none of that gets in the way of your ski time. Yeah, I mean, that's the same argument I make to my wife all the time, so. Yeah. We'll have mandatory meetings on a chair left, Colin. Fair enough. Mandatory. Yep. Mandatory. Yes, we're equally as excited to be open and get things rolling up at the ski area. And so all good on that front.

1:56:47 You know, Mary and I got away to Prescott, Arizona in, when did we leave? A couple, you know, kind of early, mid-October. And boy, what potential exists for multi-use trail systems. All around Prescott, hundreds of miles of multi-use trails, hiking, biking.

1:57:16 Horses on all of them. There's enough of them where, and Prescott's a good-sized town and a lot of visitation from Phoenix and from all over, and it spreads everybody out. Awesome, awesome bike riding. And so it just gave me a glimpse of what the potential is here. And so our work with Mammoth Lakes Trail System and Joel is,

1:57:46 aiming towards something like that would be just such a huge asset to our community. So anyway, I went out and did a little test riding and I highly approve of particularly rider-built multi-use trails, two thumbs ups. And aside from that, looking forward to a busy winter. And like Heather said, all of Thanksgiving week looks

1:58:16 crazy. It's not going to be a three-day holiday. It's going to be all week long. Lots of families out of school all week. So it's going to be great. And then any requests for future agenda items? Seeing none. You know, before we...

1:58:41 adjourn, you know, Tamara, you want to give us an update? I'm not sure we're going to need to go into closed session here, and maybe Tamara, you can give us an update on how we're doing with Kim's evaluation process. Sure, thank you. To Colin's point of meeting a deadline, I definitely needed a deadline on this to keep me on track, so this meeting was it, and I managed to send out an evaluation form. Thank you for

1:59:11 to comfort your eyes and review. I wasn't able to do the online version that I think David did it last time, last cycle. So I was cut pasting a lot, but I was able to send it out to all of you. So at least we've got the ball rolling. I also sent it to Matt Perolo and Joel and Dan and John Wentworth. So I'll hopefully be able to get it all back in the next week. I have asked for a deadline, so.

1:59:39 Please get it back to me with some comments and feedback by next Monday. And I will compile it. And then what I'll probably do is send a consolidated version out to our executive team, myself, Craig, and Heather. We'll obviously don't need to send it to myself, but get some review on that. And then we'll have a consensus for what we're able to present to you in our next board meeting.

2:00:06 If that timeline is too long, we can talk about that. If we want to make that a short, you know, just a closed session meeting once Heather and Craig and I have a chance to review the compilation, that's up for discussion. What's everybody think on that? Maybe my question would be, Kim, you know, is, I'm laughing because this is a great question at Mammoth Mountain with,

2:00:39 Either Mark Brownlee or now Ron Cohen. It's like, when am I going to get an evaluation? And so, you know, we can, you know, I really kind of defer to Kim a little bit, you know, because, you know, it's for the employee more than anything. And so if we can pull this together and get it.

2:01:07 Is it best not to wait till January and maybe have a quick closed session early December, maybe just before or just after Thanksgiving if we're ready to roll? Would that work for you, Kim? I think that was a permit. Yes, that's fine with me. Is it possible to do like a quick review with?

2:01:39 Executive committee and then a full board review at our next meeting. Oh, there you go. I'm not sure if that's following the procedure, but that would be easy. We could, you know, get something in front of me and then do a formal on the agenda at our next meeting. At our next meeting. Is that compliant with Brown Act if the executive team just delivers a review to Kim? That I don't know.

2:02:10 Angela, any feedback on that? Angela or Dan, if you're still there? If Dan is still on the line, I would defer to Mr. Hall. Oh, there he is. Yeah, so it depends. The executive committee can take a look at that and start the review process. What they can't do is make any decisions related to compensation in that type of meeting. That has to be done in an open session. But as far as, you know, the review process going, yeah, you've done a great job, excellent, good, improve here.

2:02:41 Those types of things in the evaluation side. They just can't make any decision related to compensation, which has to be an open board discussion. So they could review comments and do a like consolidated evaluation, for example, if they wanted to do that for the whole board. And do we have to put that out to public knowledge that we're having a closed session or can we just have an executive team meeting with Kim?

2:03:08 If, I don't know how your executive board, if it's set up as a standing committee that, you know, is a designated standing committee, then it becomes a agenda meeting. You can do it, you can do a special meeting, it's a 24-hour notice, you can do it via Zoom and stuff like that, but you would have to open. And just go into closed session and then, okay. And you can go into closed session for, you know, evaluation of a public employee, so to speak. But you would have to open it publicly, then go in and do that.

2:03:38 Okay. Yeah, because I think it is a standing committee, so it has to be treated like a bracket. I think you're right. Yeah, it's not an ad hoc, you're correct. Yeah. Okay. All right. Well, I like that process of just compiling it, and then when we're ready, and the three of us have had our opportunities to consult on it, then we can go over it with Kim in an agendized fashion.

2:04:03 in a closed session, and then we can present it to the board. And consider that. And at the board, if you want to at the board meeting, you can still have a closed session on the eval. Again, not compensation with camera in the room or out of the room and have that discussion. Then you come back at an open session, talk about it and how it would justify any, you know, any other types of adjustments and compensations, any other actions that you could.

2:04:31 speak to it in open session than at that point, but there should be no decisions in the closed session. Yeah, exactly. I'll just say from my experience doing it a few times with a number of different organizations, you know, my personal opinion and the way that I feel like it runs best is to start the evaluation in closed session with the employee, so with Kim, have a discussion with her, get some feedback from her on a self-evaluation.

2:04:57 And then kind of have some discussion amongst Kim and the board, any feedback we want to do with her directly. And then it's nice to kind of excuse her for a period of time so the board can just deliberate on our own without the employee. And then again, keeping in mind what Dan had already said, that the compensation piece always has to be in the public sphere.

2:05:20 So we can kind of do two different sets to the closed session piece and then come at a closed session for anything compensation related. Okay. Sounds good. Sounds good. Awesome. And so with that, we'll nothing else. Let's adjourn. I have 7.06 p.m. and we will

2:05:51 Come back on January 4th is our next full board meeting date. We'll have a big Christmas holiday largely behind us at that point. All right. Thank you, everyone. Thank you. Thanks for everything. Thanks for that clarification, Dan. Yes. Thanks, guys.