TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2025

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board

at 13:30

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

237 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:08 Welcome, welcome, everybody. We're going to get started. We had a couple technical difficulties, but Angie's got us going. Thank you, Angie. Okay, so we're going to call the meeting to order. Angie, can I get a roll call, please? Sorry, little delay over here. Things going on. Chair Foster? Yes, here. Vice Chair Clark? Here. Treasurer Morris? Here. Secretary Mendel? Here. Board Member Wentworth? Here.

3:48 Board Member Parker? Here. Board Member Wallace? Here. Board Member Quezada-Costa? Here. Board Member Erickson? Here. Thank you. Okay, so I think we're just going to jump right into this, Angie. So, pursuant to Government Code Section 54954.2b2.

4:13 The board hereby determines that there is a need to take immediate action and that the need for action came to the attention of the board subsequent to the agenda being posted as specified in subdivision A, said item being the resignation of president and CEO and appointment of a CEO search and ad hoc committee. And we'd like to add this item after action item number one. We'll do that now. So to proceed with this, I'm going to need a motion and a second and a vote.

4:42 If somebody wants to make a motion. I'll move. A motion and a second. Chair Foster? Yes. Vice Chair Clark? Yes. Treasurer Morris? Yes. Secretary Mendel? Yes. Board Member Wentworth? Yes. Board Member Parker? Yes. Board Member Wallace? Yes. Board Member Quezada-Costa? Yes. And Board Member Erickson? Yes. Thank you. Okay, so John, should I turn this over to you? Yeah, absolutely. Thank you.

5:18 For the benefit of our large gallery out here, our board and my team and the town council are aware of it, but I am pursuing a new opportunity as the president and CEO of Visit Huntington Beach. And so I'll be leaving here, my last day will be December 19th, and I'll be starting down there on January 5th. It's been a heck of a run here. I've been here for 15 and a half years. We've done a lot. We've seen a lot.

5:43 had a lot happen to us and we've made a lot happen for us. So I really appreciate the support of everyone on the board. My team has been amazing leaving you with the best team that we've had in the 15 and a half years that I've been here. So I'm very, very confident that things will continue to be off the charts. And so the board, Pat, will be very involved with the team, making sure that they have what they need for resources and support. And if there are any big...

6:11 decisions or check signings that we need to do with airlines or others. So I really feel mixed because I love this place. We love you, John. It's been a long time. But I know that we've made huge impact here and I really look forward to seeing things like the Destination Stewardship Plan come to life and really the things that we've put in motion. So just appreciate all of you. Thank you. And I just want to...

6:44 Preface this with, look, I'm a huge John Urdi fan. I know a lot of you are as well. We've talked to some of the board members. We've talked to town council, Rob, town manager. We need to put together a party for John where we all have the opportunity to give our thanks and to say goodbye and show our appreciation.

7:10 Maybe it's in the form of a roast. We don't want his head to get too big. But we will certainly be working on that. We want the community to have the opportunity to say goodbye to John. So it's well-deserved and very important. So we will have the opportunity to do that. We'll be working on that soon. In the meantime, we need to put together an ad hoc committee for CEO search.

7:39 So any discussion on that? Yeah, Chair Foster, I'd like to move. I know that there's been some discussion amongst the group of who might be interested, but I'd like to move that the committee, the ad hoc committee, to search for a new executive director slash president would be Chair Foster, Eric Clark, Mary Beth, and John Mandel. I think that would be a good group. I was considering it, but...

8:06 I have other things, and I know Mary Beth's interested in it, and I'm happy to step out so that she can step in. So that's my motion, I guess. Well, John, I appreciate that. Any other discussion? Andrew, do I need a motion then on this? You need a second. I need a second? Okay. I'll second that. Thank you, Tom. Yes, Tom Parker. Yes, right. Chair Foster? Yes. Vice Chair Clerk? Yes. Treasurer Morris? Yes. Secretary Mendel?

8:46 Yes. Board member Wentworth. Yes. Board member Parker. Yes. Board member Wallace. Yes. Board member Casalacosta. Yes. And board member Erickson. Yes. Thank you. And Angie, that's noted as an ad hoc committee? Yeah, that can be an ad hoc committee. It's a one-time. Perfect. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, we'll move on to item number two, board member reports. Do any board members have anything that they want to share?

9:16 Absolutely. Absolutely, I do. First of all, on the business side, reservations are looking good for the winter. Interest seems to be there, and we're ahead of last year. I think a lot of people are ahead of where they were at this time last year, so that's good. And I just want to say to my lovely Mammoth Husky ladies, what a great year they had. They just, we made it to our

9:45 Section final, and we made it to the state semifinals, and that's a hell of an achievement for a little tiny school in the mountain that doesn't recruit and has to drive everywhere and raise all their funds and all that. And I will just say that if that group represents what the future of this country looks like, we're in good shape. They're a bunch of great human beings, so good on you girls. Congratulations. Thank you. Thank you for what you do. We're reopening today after a two-week break.

10:14 So we'll see how that goes. But yeah, today's our first day. Good for you for taking a break. Good for you for taking a break. That's unusual. Yeah. I was so busy doing stuff, so it doesn't count. Any other board member reports? Okay. Public comments. I know we've got some public comments in the room. Come on up. My name's Billy State. I'm a homeowner.

10:51 Part-time, full-time resident since 2007. You might have seen my email from last night. I brought the landlord from the village, Mark Vincent, to introduce a brand new concept for activating the dormant peninsula space at, oops, there I am. By the way, thanks, John, for your service. It's been great to know you, and off to the beach. Absolutely.

11:22 So, like in the email, I had said, you know, I've had, you know, decades of retail experience as well as event experience activating the California lifestyle brands from San Diego to Santa Barbara. I used to work with Rusty Gregory and Mark Claussen and one of the things, you know, I found it kind of easy actually to activate the lifestyle brands to, you know, to be like a...

11:50 The welcoming committee. Like, there would be a time to come. And it's been, like, 20 years since there's been, like, ski, snow, like, large-scale, you know, industry parties. So we'd like to have the opportunity to activate the peninsula space. I think that there's an opportunity to kind of counter the youth at the Canyon Lodge with an adult operate. There's an opportunity to activate it in a manner that's professional, executive.

12:19 I mean, there's, I mean, the slate's wide open on what we can do. I just want to explore the opportunity, you know, really engage the community to see how the business, how a business ecosystem can launch from that spot and create a winter town square. So, we do have Mark, we're gonna, and Mark,

12:40 Mark, if you want to say anything, Greg is the landlord, and we're going to be at the next meeting, too, just to address the city council, trying to activate the entire community to get behind this initiative. So thank you very much.

12:56 Just remember, you're a Boston sports fan moving down into L.A. I was asked when I was down there, Angels or Dodgers, and I just said Red Sox. Don't worry about me, Mark. I think a lot of you know me. If you don't know me, my name is Mark Vincent. I run Eastern Sierra Entertainment. I have a Mammoth, a ton of Mammoth business license.

13:18 Came up here and went to work for Brent over at the old Sierra Nevada. Many of you have probably danced to the bands over there and saw some DJ stuff that I've done. I have a background in technical installation of sound lighting and video systems certified through JBL. I have had my own JBL concert level system. I've done some stuff for Mr. Clark, putting speakers on trees. So if I can put a speaker in a tree, I can build out an event space.

13:43 I'm going to be working with Billy and hopefully you'll approve the concept of an APRE ski location. We will set this up also for small conferences, presentations. I think that's necessary in this town to have a space where you could put a couple of hundred people in. Training, if you want to look at the safety aspect, you could do safety training in there. We could support activities that are happening in the village of outdoor nature by having an indoor space available as well.

14:11 And I like the concept of the apres ski ending up somewhere around 7 o'clock at night so we're not disturbing the neighbors up above. I have a complete sound lighting and video system that I used at the fair. Many of you may have come down to the fair and saw the movies we did in the back 40. I have a complete system right now that's being unused. So we could turnkey this situation very quickly if you wanted to decide to open that up. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Any other public comment in the room?

14:43 Angie, do we have anybody online? No comments at this time. Okay, thank you. Okay, we'll move on to item number four, the consent agenda. I want to approve the minutes of the regular meeting on October 15, 2025. Any discussion? I'll make a motion to approve the minutes. Second. Thank you, John. Chair Foster? Yes. Vice Chair Clerk? Yes. Treasurer Morris? Yes. Secretary Mendel? Yes. Excuse me. Board Member Wentworth?

15:20 Yes. Board Member Parker. Yes. Board Member Wallace. Yes. Board Member Quezada Costa. Yes. And Board Member Erickson. Yes. Thank you. Excellent. We'll move on to item number five, policy matters, 5.1, winter ad effectiveness research. We're going to do a review of research showing results of the winter 2024-2025 marketing campaigns. We have a slight change of things because Sarah has laryngitis.

16:04 Okay, great. Looks good. Everyone can see it. Good afternoon. I'm Olivia. And on behalf of Sarah and the marketing team.

17:04 And everyone's hard work last year. I'm going to give everyone a high-level overview of how our 2024-2025 winter advertising performed and how these insights will be applied in the future. It'd also be good if I could scroll to the next slide. Here is the run-through. All detailed information will be found in your packet, while some of the slides do get more involved.

17:33 I'll be speaking to this at a very high level so everyone can come away with a sort of broader understanding of the main insights. The Real and Real campaign was launched in the winter of 2022-2023. This particular study looks at 2024-2025, winter advertising, diving into are people seeing the ads? Do they respond positively when they do? Do the ads influence how they think about Mammoth Lakes?

18:02 And do the ads help drive visitation? Travelers were surveyed in our three key markets using the same approach each year so we can have comparable results over time. The sample size for the study is roughly 3,000. We ran a slightly leaner campaign this period with 19% less budget across video, social, audio, and digital channels.

18:34 However, even with the smaller spend, the campaign still had wide reach. And you can look at some of the sample panels that we tested in this slide at the bottom right. Add awareness stayed strong at 36%, even with less spending, and our cost to reach people improved, making it a more efficient campaign than industry standards.

19:05 Video continues to be our strongest performing format, which is also standard for the travel industry. We like our visuals. So the TLDR, too long didn't read here, is for every $1 we spent, the campaign returned $130 in visitor spending, and the California, Nevada, and Northeast remain our strongest markets. The top three strategic callouts in this slide

19:41 are essentially, per historical trends, Denver, Colorado continues to be a hard market for us. We'll go into that a little bit in the following slides. Sustainability continues to matter more to our visitors than average travelers. And lastly, stress relief actually emerged as a top motivation for visiting Mammoth Lakes. So diving into ad awareness specifically,

20:12 The winter ad awareness held steady at 36%, even with less spending, which, again, is a strong efficiency signal, and you can see that a bit in the graphic here. The real and real advertising awareness, you can see the total at 35% 2023-2024, 36% 2024-2025.

20:38 We reached people more cost-effectively than previous years and beat the national benchmark. As you can see, the average cost per AWARE household is at 32 cents, and we actually were able to beat that at 26 cents on the dollar. Video and audio platforms like Pandora were the most remembered, especially for our snow-specific travelers.

21:12 This is interesting because nearly half of our campaign in multiple places, nearly half saw our campaign in multiple places and that cross-channel visibility actually helped drive a lot of the results. And this overlap is important because increased awareness does translate to increased visitation. There is a direct correlation there. And we'll essentially just go into a little bit of how the creative itself was evaluated.

21:41 Of all of the channels, I know this is a lot, but of all of the channels and all traveler types, videos performed the best overall with the how unreal video exceeding our positive response goal. Audio formats like Pandora and Pluto were less effective, unsurprisingly, and that sort of lesser performance with audio is standard as, again, travel is a highly visual product. This is

22:10 The same as the last slide, but we're just looking at, instead of all outdoor travelers, we're just looking at only snow-specific travelers. And again, video, especially strong audio continues to lag behind. With snow travelers, not just one, but most of our ads exceeded our positive response goals. So yeah, this slide has a lot going on, but the takeaway is that while we had some decline in ratings from the previous year,

22:44 Overall, people continue to think our ad creative does an excellent job showing Mammoth Lakes beauty and outdoor experience. And excellent is the best you can get. And, similar slide to the last one, unsurprisingly, this is snow travelers specifically, unsurprisingly, because that's our core target audience, our ad creative resonates even more with snow travelers. And you can see here, each

23:13 Threshold far exceeded the excellent top 10%. Across all traveler types by market, California, Nevada, and the Northeast respond very well to our creative. Denver remains more difficult to influence, which is fully in line with their sentiment across the industry. Coloradans tend to be quite biased towards their mountains. And specifically looking at snow travelers,

23:46 We saw the same trend among the snow-specific travelers and a strong response in the California, Nevada, and Northeast markets. While again, Denver continues to rate lower, though the snow travelers there are a bit more positive. And moving on to ad impact. Essentially, this is looking at how did our ads impact the image people have of our destination. People who saw the ads think more highly of Mammoth Lakes on every brand attribute from beauty,

24:19 to friendliness, to stewardship, and this is very strong. All ratings are above industry average benchmarks. So digging into the impact of ad perceptions and choice, people who are ad aware tend to be more familiar with Mammoth Lakes as a destination. They rate it higher and are almost twice as likely to choose it as their preferred destination. This means our ads are creating the positive perceptions needed to generate more visitation.

24:54 I know this graphic isn't simple, but this is how SMARI calculates what trips are influenced by advertising. Basically, incremental trips are the trips that happen because people saw our ads, which means not all trips count. Only the ones advertising most likely influenced, which is an equation that is depicted in this graphic and is the conservative industry standard approach to this calculation. So this is how it played out for Mammoth.

25:26 Again, incremental trips are simply the extra trips that happen because people saw the ads, not the trips that would have happened anyway. And so using that standard approach I just saw you to calculate the incremental trips, this is what is estimated. We influenced about 1.7% additional trips last year with our ads, which is slightly lower due to the reduced spend, but still meaningful. So when you take that 1.7% increment and apply it to the total AdWare households,

26:02 Last winter's returns equals roughly 64,000 trips and 130 million visitor spending, all generated by advertising influence. Even with the 19% less in spending, ROI only dropped 15%, which means the campaign held its performance pretty well. And looking specifically at those incremental trips again, California, Nevada is our strongest market, again.

26:34 And the Northeast actually overperformed relative to its size. Ads often have stronger impacts in more distant locations. And this was the case for us here. And Denver contributed very little incremental visitation, unsurprisingly. So in a nutshell, looking at multimedia overlap, the more places someone sees our ads, the more likely they are to visit and rate Mammoth Lakes highly.

27:08 is essentially what this graphic is showing you. Specifically looking at how ads impact people's trips, people who saw the ads do more activities, spend more, and rate their trip better. And that's broken out in each of these boxes. And onto this last section, tactical issues. Sustainability is especially important to Mammoth Lakes visitors. Most

27:43 Say, it influenced their decision to visit, and once they were here, they focused on respectful, community-minded actions. And some of the top motivations for our visitors were stress relief, connecting with nature, unique experiences, and feeling carefree. And as far as activities in Mammoth Lakes are concerned, some of the top ones were sightseeing, scenic views, skiing, snowboarding, and geological features.

28:20 Some of the stronger activity motivators for visiting Mammoth. And here we're looking at air service. Air service is essential for long-distance markets. The northeast visitors mostly flew, unsurprisingly, and the ads in that region increased awareness of this access, which shows just how important advertising or air service is in that location to attract visitors.

28:56 And the remaining slides are including the full questionnaire, which is included in your packet for your own reference. I'm not going to go over those. We can take questions, and I'll have Sarah jump in for helping with the answers, because I'm still new to all of this, and I will jump in if I can. I just have a question, and I'm getting the numbers right, regarding the ROI.

29:26 I realized we spent less money, but our ROI was down 15%. So is there a, for lack of a better way of saying it, is there a sweet spot somewhere in there where we spend more, get more ROI? Because obviously, you know, ROI is the important thing, is how much we're bringing in. So I'm just curious how that works. It seems like, you know, even though you spend...

29:54 If you spend less, if you're being efficient, you should still be able to pull in approximately the same ROI even with the less spend, unless I'm just getting something wrong about that. Sorry, Sarah. If there's a quick way to say it, otherwise I can talk to you later about it. No, it's fine. No, you're not reading that wrong. Okay.

30:16 varies depending on what we're doing. So one, there's a little bit of ad fatigue going on. We've had the same real and real videos for the last couple of years, which we're working on.

30:25 Similar with different creative. You'll see some of the Northeast numbers did really well. That's all new creative as of last year. And then some media units, like our rich media ads, those cost a lot. So you're getting like, you know, for every $13 you spend, you get a, or for every dollar you spend, you get $13 in ROI, where with Meta, it's a lot higher. So I think it just fluctuates, but it's good to note the percentage there of like being able to play with some funds. But I don't recommend lowering the budget.

30:53 Thank you. Appreciate it. Sorry, I have one question, too. Will you go back to the last slide, the air service slide? I was trying to see how the 85% of Denver kind of correlated with the fact that we had a really hard time in Denver. That's a good question. Just because of the people surveyed?

31:28 Yeah, I might have to look into that. That might be an error, if I'm being entirely honest. It's showing that it has 85% and 92% for Northeast, but 85% I would think would be a success, but I didn't quite understand the slide, so I asked to come back. My gut is that's wrong. Gotcha. Just based on the numbers and where we landed with actual trips, influenced trips out of Denver, but I would have to triple check with you on that. Thanks for catching that.

31:58 Could you go to... It's also possible, and this is... Please note, this is a hypothesis, because I have not seen the numbers. However, because the sample size in Denver is likely very, very small, that could mean that there were two people, and of the two aware people, or four aware people, 85% of them are represented in this graph. Yeah. I do not know. I do not know the sample size for that particular bar. Okay. So...

32:28 We can double check on that, but it's likely also due to a smaller ad-aware sample size, given Denver was less ad-aware. Completely agree. Could be that. Hypothetically. I like that better than my opinion. Just a question. With the hyper-awareness that the skiing and winter sports audience has of snowfall and all the tools that they have to be able to track where the snow is, are we correlating any of this against

32:57 You know, the perception or the actual amount of snow that's on the ground, that's on the mountain. And I think that's something we really need to start doing because you're not, you're not, you've got an audience that's probably going to their open snow apps first or their NOAA apps first. But I don't know, maybe that's a more sophisticated audience, I don't know. So there's a couple things there. One, this is just testing our ad creative. So people that are just snow travelers are looking at our...

33:23 specific snow messaging, so they're seeing samples from our endemics, so like on the snow, we did a large buy with last year. In terms of actual like comp set data, we, this is the first year that we're actually able to do media buying that actually changes as we get snow, so taking from the mountains read on snow levels.

33:46 Mid-Mountain, and so I think after this winter we might have a better idea of how to gauge that, but for last winter it's really looking at their awareness based on the creative we're serving, not what other people are serving. No, I get it, and that makes sense, but I think with all due respect to the mountains, you know.

34:04 Absolutely 12-star snow reports come out of the mountain. The audience perhaps may be looking at a number of different resources. I'm sure this is something that you guys are aware of, that it might make sense as we go forward to start aggregating the resources that skiers and people are looking at, because that might be more effective in figuring out where to spend, how to spend, and where to target things.

34:25 Yeah, I think that tends to go a bit more into the media planning process with our agency, and they do look at that. So we typically do a handful of custom media buys with just winter-specific publications, whether that's on the snow or snow grains and other things like that. But yes, but they don't necessarily offer up a ton of their...

34:49 Information in terms of data, they more offer kind of like just their benchmark and then where we're at within that benchmark. Okay. Yeah, it makes sense. Thank you. So, Sarah, would you consider this year then a baseline because of the, you know, that it'll be the first time that we've got sort of everything aligned? Yes and no because it's just a small portion of our buy, but I think it's a really fun way of dipping or toeing the pond to be able to like...

35:16 in a more time-effective manner, clue people into what's happening in terms of snow. I think one of the other things we're doing this year for the first time that we're not doing is a retargeting message. So we're going out with the brand awareness message and then the mountains following us with a snow-specific message. So I think there's going to be a couple different new baselines that we're going to have to start kind of measuring new KPIs and ROI on. Both of those would be considered in that bucket. Great, thank you.

35:40 Given that John's from the Northeast, are you going to spend less there when he's gone? I'm also from the Northeast. Oh, okay. You lose. Northeast is actually my favorite creative. I want to show it to you guys, but it basically says when you come here, you don't have to skate. Skate to see. It's actually a fun way. You can't hear if you're skating. Exactly. It's actually a really fun way to have a bit more of a goofy and witty creative than just the brand awareness piece. I love our literature creative in the Northeast.

36:11 Could you go back to slide 34 for just a moment and educate me about what, I think I understand the first column and maybe the second column, but I'm clueless about what the third column is measuring. Yeah, it's a question within the questionnaire about what motivates them, so it's kind of sharing the percentage that people would participate in this, what's motivating them to book the trip, and then if it's not motivating them at all to book the trip.

36:41 I'm reading, mine says net. Sorry, if it's an average of the two. Oh, it's an average of the two. It should be. Prior columns. No. That doesn't make sense either. It looks like it's just... Half of the participate. No, it's not even half. Sorry, I can't move my screen. Net motivate. So, yeah, thank you. Yeah, I'll have to look into that. Thank you. Which is alarming, since John and I have had about 50 conversations. Sorry about this one presentation. Okay, appreciate that. Thanks.

37:16 Any other questions? Thank you, Sarah. Thank you, Olivia, for filling in. Thank you. Yes, thank you to Olivia for helping me out. Okay, we'll move on to item 5.2, Community Engagement Plan. We're going to get an overview of the MLT Community Engagement Plan with Betsy Truax. Betsy, thank you. Thank you. Share my screen. All right. Well, good afternoon, everyone.

37:59 I just really want to begin by congratulating John on his new role, and I also just want to take a moment to say personally thank you for giving me this opportunity to build out this really critical role in the organization. I am very appreciative.

38:13 I will miss you, but I know that I will see you often, so look forward to that. And then I also just want to say how much I appreciate the board's recognition of the critical role of community engagement and the role that it plays in our strategic plan. So I look forward to continuing working with all of you on this. So the full community engagement plan is in your packet.

38:34 I do think of it as a living document, so please take time to digest it, reach out with questions and feedback. I'm happy to sit down and talk through any of it with any of you. It's just based on kind of building the plane as I was flying it over the past year and not quite a half, so these are just a few slides today to share kind of a high-level overview of the plan, and I'm happy to answer any questions at the end or along the way. Okay, so the overarching goal, as we all know, is

39:07 The need to strengthen trust and understanding between MLT and our community. I really want people to understand the great work that this team does at MLT and how we do it and then what the end result looks like in terms of community investment. And that's important, I think, not just for our residents but also for our visitors to see that the money that they come and spend here really goes back into the community and it benefits them as well as the people who live here full-time.

39:35 And then just a few additional objectives. These are pretty straightforward, but a big goal, really need to turn our businesses into MLT champions ahead of the TBID renewal, which will be here before we know it. So give a lot of thought to that. Again, just really want to make sure that we're transparent and educating around MLT's funding and work. I think a lot of people in the community don't really understand how this organization works or is funded or how the funding...

40:01 that, you know, we received from TBID and a little bit of TOT, you know, the investment that that makes and then what that generates and then what that produces for our community. So, also really want to make sure that our residents are aware of all the initiatives that MLT does. You know, it's interesting to hear Olivia present about how interested our visitors are in sustainability. I know that's important to our residents as well.

40:27 And so I really want people to be aware, you know, just of the visitor education that we do around stewardship as well as local stewardship events that we sponsor and participate in and then of course our special events funding because, you know, people really love our special events. I'm not sure people know our relationship to them.

40:46 And then here are just a few key resident sentiment indicators. We are about to launch our third resident sentiment survey. So here's some data from 23 and 24. I really look forward to seeing how these numbers might move in the 2025 survey. It's pretty clear that everyone here understands that we are a visitor-driven economy. It's not so clear that they understand the role that visitation and visitor dollars.

41:14 Play and making this a great place to live, work, and play. So these are some of my KPIs moving forward. Also just, you know, we're increasing the number of residents who've seen the Real and Real campaign. We're increasing the number of residents who feel that they're listened to and heard, but there's still a lot of room to move these numbers forward.

41:36 And this is pretty self-explanatory. These are just some of our own communication channels that I can use as tools for local communication. I appreciate the work that Olivia is doing so that I can easily communicate to all of our TBID remitters using our CRM database. And then Sam is also doing an incredible job on a refresh of our community slash industry website. So really looking forward to sharing that with all of you in the coming months. But I really want to use all of these tools at our...

42:06 disposal to really target the local community and also just to meet people where they are. We're also very fortunate to have some great partner communication channels. I really appreciate the willingness of both the town and the chamber to help us push out local facing information through their channels. I don't think, you know, I...

42:25 I talk to Stu Brown a lot about how, you know, he kind of has my audience already, so really happy to be able to work together with them. The chamber has the business community audience, so we can really leverage those opportunities. And then obviously just our partners in terms of, you know, print advertising, you know, radio. Laura's on KMMT every week with the 5 and 5, along with our other paid ads. And then Destination Think, I think, is a great platform. Our collaborative membership with, you know, our peer destinations all around.

42:54 world to share out what we're doing and the power of community engagement and what visitation dollars do for all of our destinations. All right, and then outreach.

43:07 You know, I often realize how little the community knows about MLT's local sponsorships, so I want to take full advantage of those opportunities like Trashy Thursdays and other stewardship events like we did Host Hounds together with the town last summer so that we can just meet the community out in person doing that work. Really having a great time doing the community skate nights and anytime I have the opportunity or our staff, you know, can...

43:31 It can be at a tabling event, whether it's Town Cleanup Day or Indigenous Peoples Day or Earth Day. We're happy to be there and participate to the extent that we can and just talk to people. I think that's in a community of around 7,000 people. It's a really effective tool. And then here are just some KPIs and deliverables for community engagement. We talk a lot.

43:58 I've had a lot of conversations with my counterparts as well as in the Destination Think Collective about the challenge of measuring the impact of community engagement and how do you really measure something that's kind of emotional and sentimental. It's a little bit more challenging than things like ad awareness surveys, but we try. We're definitely at the forefront of measuring resident sentiment. Most other destinations have maybe completed one resident sentiment survey and are working on a second, whereas we have done

44:28 One, two, and are going into our third. I don't actually know of another destination that is actually about to do a third resident sentiment survey. I think that data is invaluable, and it's also just critical to keep doing that every year so that we don't miss a year and then have to backtrack.

44:45 We also, I also have a lot of informal communications with our business community leaders, with elected officials, and then other partners, but we also really need more formal outreach, so this is a key deliverable for me going forward, and I really look forward to Pat and other board members joining me for some of these meetings, especially in the business community, ahead of the team in renewal.

45:10 All right, and then finally, just a couple of the programs in process. There's a lot of kind of program information in the full community engagement plan document, but I know that community destination stewardship plan is near and dear to John's heart, so definitely look forward to delivering that. Hunden Partners is the agency that's helping us with that. They have made two of their three destination visits, and

45:34 So they have gathered a lot of great information already, done some terrific community outreach. And so that plan is actually scheduled for completion and adoption by the end of this fiscal year. So really excited to keep moving that one forward.

45:47 And then on community engagement marketing, the Abby Agency who concepted our It's a Mammoth Thing video series, I am working with them along with Sarah, making great progress on our community engagement marketing plans. So look forward to unveiling that tagline and creative to you as well as the rest of the team. We've really kind of taken our time and given them a lot of direction and feedback. I feel like we have one chance to get this right and I really just want to nail it.

46:16 Super, super excited for the opportunities there. And then the MLT Infrastructure Fund. So these are some of the programs that are in process from using those TBID funds that are earmarked for infrastructure. The town is, I believe you heard about it at your last workshop with council, but real-time digital transit information in the bus shelters. They actually have signs testing in the engineering offices right now.

46:41 Seems to be working pretty well. So when a visitor or resident is at one of the bus shelters or transit stops along Old Mammoth Road or Main Street this winter, they will see kind of the time of the next bus arriving.

46:55 And then there's also an app component to that as well. So excited for that. The branded bike rack program had a little hiccups, but those racks are ordered, so they will be here ready to deploy for next spring and summer. Really excited about that and about them having the branding on them. And then finally, the digital kiosks. This is something that Hayes from the town actually found, and these will have some opportunities for local businesses to have advertising on these around town, so looking forward to rolling that one.

47:24 And where would those be? To be determined, but probably kind of in, you know, main kind of visitor-facing corridors. Anyway, happy to answer any questions and again, happy to just sit down with any of you. I'd love any input or feedback that you have into the plan. Betsy, thank you very much for this and the very important work that you're doing and I'm really excited about it and ready to help any way we can. A comment, I was in a meeting yesterday with Amanda Rice.

47:55 And she suggested, and we've done a series of educational videos, and she thought it'd be very helpful for us to put something together, explaining the difference between the TBID and the TOT, and who pays it, how it's collected, and where those monies go. She still has a lot of confusion.

48:12 I think as clear as we can make that would be helpful for us moving forward. So I'd like to talk about that with you. Absolutely. I think that's a great idea. And, you know, I worked with the town on their Did You Know TBID piece that they pushed out, but I think we can absolutely expand on that and also with TOT to also really educate on how MLT is funded and how that operates. So, yeah, I think that's a great idea. Absolutely. John? Hey, Betsy. Oh, go ahead. Go ahead. So a couple questions. One is, you know,

48:42 Measuring Progress and Success, I know you have the Resident Sentiment Survey. Do we, do we do, have we thought about like a business sentiment survey? Because one of the things that, I mean, I know they're residents, but for me as a business, I'd want to know what's in it for me. And I know when we talk about TBID renewal and those kinds of things, it's, it was really eye-opening when you went business to business, meet with people and literally they go,

49:11 Yeah, but I don't really know what I'm getting for this.

49:14 Yeah, absolutely. I think that's really critical to do. And, you know, when John and I attended the Destinations International Advocacy Conference, I actually got some great ideas from peer destinations about how they've doing that, how they've done that and accomplished that. So, yeah, I think that's absolutely critical. In fact, we have a subscription now to SurveyMonkey, so I can push out, you know, I can push out email surveys, but also I think just, you know, sitting down and talking to people and, you know,

49:43 Collating that data, I think, is... I mean, just getting a baseline on what do businesses think, right? Absolutely. And then we can address those because it's, frankly, it was different, but it was the same for everybody we talked to. You know, it was like, well, okay, but I don't want to be the only one not supporting it, but I'm not sure what I'm really getting for it. So if we can tease that out. The second thing is you're getting ready to do the resident sentiment survey.

50:13 Have we revised that survey at all? I know I got a lot of feedback individually from people last year. Why did we start asking by asking everyone's age?

50:23 Is the first question. Right. Okay, that's a- I mean, that's always the addendum stuff and you get a chance. I don't want to, you know, but like the very first thing, where do you fall in your age group? No, that's a fair question. I think this year we'll ask people their zip code first. But, no, fair point. We have actually changed our vendor for the survey this year. We have switched from future partners to Longwoods International.

50:49 Longwoods does the national and regional resident sentiment for the U.S. and Canada, and also I think people will be pleased to learn that we have eliminated most of the open-ended questions that took people a long time to get through last year. It was great to see that and have that, especially as I was putting together this plan, but we also recognize that people's time is valuable and there's not a lot of it in this community, so I think that people will be able to get through that a lot faster this year.

51:18 Those demographic questions, we need those for benchmarking and other things. And part of it is it kicks you out if you're under 18. Yep. Which is fine, but you're going to ask that. Most of them ask at the end, you know, what ethnicity are you, male, female, you know. I just don't think we want to have people waste their time and then get to the bottom and say I'm not 18 and make this tossed out.

51:39 Well, don't tell them. We just tell them. Thanks for your time. Get your response rate up. I'm sure that a lot of our local teenagers would love to be eligible to win a $500 gift card. But yeah, John is right. I mean, that's a big qualifier in that. But I totally get the sentiment. Petty, am I wrong in thinking, though, that you parsed out data from the resident sentiment survey?

52:07 by business owners and non-business owners. That's correct. So we did collect a lot of data. Yeah, there are questions that only go out that, you know, we ask people if they own a business in Mammoth Lakes and then they get a series of questions that other people don't. And is that something that the new firm could, you know, beef up a bit to get more business?

52:28 Yeah, we can definitely look at that moving forward, but I think it's also important in the business community to have not just the owners, but also just the operators, because we have a lot of businesses that are managed by locals who don't necessarily own them. And that's definitely something we can look at for questions in the survey for next year. But yeah, John, I'd love to talk to you and Pat and everyone who kind of did that outreach with the business community ahead of the last TBID renewal, so maybe we can ask similar core things and see if we're making progress.

52:57 Along those lines, you may also want to connect with the chamber around the surveys the chamber is doing. I don't know if you want to combine them, but just cross-fertilization is possible there. Yeah, absolutely. And I really appreciate being able to kind of cross-promote surveys. You know, we've pushed out, you know, stuff for them. And then also the chamber is great about including my items in their newsletters.

53:23 Yeah, thanks. A couple maybe softball type questions. Is there, when you talk about TBID renewal, is there representation of the date? Is there any internal talk about when the campaign might get started? Yeah, I mean, it's, you know, the renewal is 2028, so, I mean, we're talking internally about it right now. Okay, but I mean, is, but like a campaign, I mean, the outreach to the business owners, when does that start in earnest? It will start end of fiscal, or end of calendar 27.

53:52 With the fact that the renewal will be September of 28th. Okay, so like nine months before? Nine months. Okay, good. And the second question is, you mentioned, you listed these things, here's the MLT infrastructure fund projects, those three projects. So if I go to the town manager and the public works director and say, what are the three projects that we're working on together at the TBID, they're going to tell me those three.

54:15 Projects, correct? Well, you know, funny, they're also in this evening's presentation, so yes, I would expect it. Well, but if I, before we get to your presentation this evening, if I go to them and say, what are the three projects we're working on with TBID, they're going to say those three projects, right? Yeah, ideally. I mean, you know, the town is certainly aware of the bike rack program and, you know, certainly the kiosks and, yeah. And John, this is a very moving project. I had a call with Hayes this morning about something that just potentially came up that could be really good for us.

54:43 So, yes, we're in constant contact. Okay, I've just, again, it's been, we talked about TBID renewal, that was a big thing, looking at TBID funds and how MLTPA with the TBID dollars are going to specific infrastructure things. We also have something on the agenda this evening about bathrooms and the towns. We had a conversation about bathrooms a while ago that kind of disappeared, didn't go anywhere. And I just, I hear these things, I hear these are needs that are tangible things that we could be doing, and somehow they don't, I don't know, I can't figure it out, but it doesn't seem to be sticking.

55:13 Hey, John, if you recall, though, just as a reminder, you know, we had that whole list of stuff over here, right? Right. And there was discussion in the middle of that, and I could be wrong, but I thought Hayes was part of this, is to where we stop and where the town, you know, do we want to be funding hard infrastructure in the town versus bike racks or things that...

55:36 And, you know, how far into that we go. I don't know where we came out, other than the fact that there had to be sort of a bright line in terms of public works didn't want us doing public works, and public works didn't want to be doing bike racks, you know, and so somewhere in that. But as we go back into a TBID renewal, and hopefully we're looking at a 20-year term, and hopefully we're really going big with this thing, we cannot let any stone be unturned.

56:05 Now you're getting into messaging, though. And I think that's super important. We need something to message. I mean, this is a hot button with me, only because I remember sitting in early meetings where members of the council said, I don't even know what MLT does. Well, I have some idea what MLT does. But I'm just saying, you know, we work at the behest of the town. Okay. Is that true? I mean, yeah. I don't think we're working independently.

56:34 We're reporting to the town, we're funded by it. And so I just think that from a messaging standpoint, you're absolutely right, but that's a messaging part on our part and on the town's part, is that when people ask us, we ought not be in a position where any member of the town says, yeah, I don't know what you're doing. And so I think that messaging is super important, that consistency is super important.

57:04 Short of everybody having a 3x5 card with here are the 8 projects that you got last year from TBID, you know, somehow we've got to drive that through the organization. Agreed.

57:16 Yeah, and if I could just mention too, just specifically with regard to restrooms, Hayes and I have actually, we've actually talked a lot and John has been part of most of these meetings about managing expectations in the community. That's certainly something I learned a lot about in my 10 years on the Park and Rec Commission because

57:35 There are some limitations, plumbing, electricity, that kind of thing with a project like restrooms. So Hayes and I kind of work together on some of the phrasing for that type of a project and an investment because we certainly understand the desire and the need, but we don't want to get tripped up in the execution. So I think the partnership between MLT and the town is really strong right now in that area. John Wentworth.

58:00 Isn't the destination plan meant to help us seed what we want to spend that infrastructure money on so that when you do go to town and they know exactly what it is, when we are talking about it, we know exactly what it is? Right now, we're in the midst of developing that plan. There's ideas that are coming out of it, but we don't really know what the plan is except for those working on it. But isn't that the document that really helps us drive that home?

58:29 That's the idea. But I think it's going to kind of jump. We've talked about this a lot. It comes down to political will. It comes down to navigating the legal intricacies. It comes down to managing the expectations. So I'm just, I'm leaning into that so that when we come out of that thing, I want to make sure we're all on the same page. I mean, I look at what's happening up in Tahoe, the north, you know, that district up there, where they produce.

58:57 You know, reports, these are the tangible things that we're doing with the TBID. And they're not, bike racks are nice, these things are nice, but they're doing some pretty heavy infrastructure things that we could all point to to say we're doing this stuff. And I just, I just, I've got my spurs the mule here. We got, we got to get in that lane for the destination management plan to be a success. We gotta, we gotta be able to say that we're doing it. Exactly. And actually execute it. Absolutely, yeah. Thank you, Eric. I feel like the, what the,

59:28 The most important thing that I find that resonates with people is the subsidies for the air to come to Mammoth. That seems to be, if somebody's a little iffy about TBID, when you get into that conversation, it's like, okay, that makes sense. Yeah. Yeah, and I think the annual report, our new one is about to go to print. I think that also just does a nice job of kind of showing some of those items for the benefit of the community.

1:00:01 Great. And any other questions for Betsy? Okay, Betsy, thank you very much. Thanks, everybody. Okay, we'll move on to item 5.3. We're going to get an air service update. Brief update on winter 2025-2026 bookings, service to MMH and VIH. Yep. Get this up there. Take it away. You don't need to see me. Okay. So looking at where we are year to date, the numbers are actually really strong.

1:00:41 In Denver, we have added 46% seat capacity, and right now we're booking just about 46% ahead of last year, so one-to-one's not bad. San Francisco, we added about 26% capacity, and we're up about 102% to where we were last year at this time. Again, the numbers right now at this time of year are small, but it's definitely a good momentum boost. I think that looking at the...

1:01:06 The snowfall, obviously, I'm sure you're seeing earphones ring with the snowfall. The bookings are going to see the same thing at this point. The mountain has been getting picked up all over the country, all over the world, and I think that that's really boding well for us. The other side, when we were talking about the northeast and we were talking about the efforts, the mountain is putting a good...

1:01:28 pretty much matching the same amount of funds that we're putting into the East Coast with a very strong effort back there as well. And so I think that those compounded things as well as the additional 50 flights in Denver and 29 flights in San Francisco over the course of the winter are going to bode very, very well. Those loads are looking very good on those additional flights and so very, very promising. So the United side is super strong.

1:01:51 Carlsbad is up about 35% year over year, and Hawthorne is actually the exact same number year over year where they were last year. So Hawthorne's been kind of the one that has been struggling the most, which is, I guess, surprising to us, but we'll continue to focus on getting those numbers up.

1:02:10 We do have advanced air starting next Wednesday, so the day before Thanksgiving, so we won't fly on Thanksgiving, we'll fly the day before, and then after that it really goes to the Thursday, Friday, Sunday, Monday schedule with both Hawthorne and Carlsbad. San Francisco will start in Denver on December 11th and it'll run through April 5th, and then the Denver flight will open up on December 18th and run through April 27th.

1:02:35 One thing that's not on here, because it's still not anywhere near finalized, but we are working with United right now on next summer's schedule for San Francisco, and there's potential what they propose to us is starting a four-day-a-week service from May 21 through basically 4th of July, then going seven days a week until Labor Day, and then four days a week until I think October 23rd. So we are very...

1:03:00 We're looking at, you know, spreading this out quite a bit. If we end service on April 27th and start service on May 21st, we're talking about a month that we're out of service. And so that's really, I think that's promising. And then the same thing on the flip side, if we go till October 23rd and we start back up mid-December, we're really looking at limiting that gap. And the fact that they're actually interested in looking at the four-day-a-week service is good. When we came out of COVID, they would not even think about that.

1:03:29 They were just, if you're not going to fly it seven days a week, we don't even want to talk. So the opportunity with them, the fall service that we did this year, basically that September 4th to October 6th, was the best load factors of the entire summer. And so that was a four day a week service. That was a great addition to the program. So really bullish on the two a days from Denver and the two a days from San Francisco. I think that's going to really

1:03:55 Make connectivity a lot easier getting to the East Coast. There are quite a few of us that fly to the East Coast. It's a lot easier if you have two options to get out of here. And same thing for those folks to get here. So right now, very promising. The airline is very pleased with the numbers. They're happy with what we see coming down the pike. Request. Yes. John, you know, there's no snow at the beach. You know that, right? I'm aware of that. That's a big selling point right now.

1:04:26 Two torn labrums in the shoulder. I don't need the shovel this winter. Okay, just checking. The ESCOG, Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, has a meeting coming up December 11th, I believe. How can we get, who can go from MLT at this point and get you in touch with Elaine? Pat, can you do that? Pat and I'll be there. Oh, you'll both be there. Have you talked to Elaine about that? Nope. Okay, well, I'll talk with her. Yeah, we'd love to come down. This is very important information that needs to be in front of...

1:04:55 All the governments understand it's stable, it's growing, we need to start investing in this, and we need to really pile on with this success. Yeah, and we are, you know, I think you mentioned earlier tonight on the agenda, we do have the MOU for the Eastern Sierra Airlines on the agenda to get the town signature. We have Inyo County, we've got the Mountain, we've got MLT. It's really a joint partnership on the air service, and that's been...

1:05:21 That's excellent. But I understand there are other partners in the region that potentially may want to participate. If they respond. Not the usual suspects. Yeah. And that there is a way to participate. It's not a high barrier to entry. It's a dollar and cents kind of thing. But this is the model we've seen in other regions. And I don't know. I know you've got to go home, get to bed early because the surface, I don't know what the tides are tomorrow. But maybe someone from MLT could be there to help flesh that out a little bit. I think it would be really helpful.

1:05:48 Yeah, it's important. And I think that the partnership between the county, the town, the mountain, and MLT is once we get that solidified, it really sets the pace moving forward. And so I think that's what we need right now is to lock that in. Because right now, even coming out of last winter, we're scrambling with a few things. And the potential new partners are great.

1:06:12 We can present to them as much as we can. It's just right now we haven't been able to get a response. It's the nature of the business. Do you serve? I do. I do. You do. There you go. All spirits, snow, and sea. That's right. And the contrast between the performance of the air and what they were talking about with the advertising, probably because a lot of people from...

1:06:39 L.A., etc., drive, so that's more tourists that are connecting, right? Yeah, and that's where the Denver flight is about, it's only about 20% of the people on the Denver flight are coming from Colorado. The rest are connecting from all over the world, mainly the East Coast. 60-some-odd percent are Icon pass holders, so I mean, it's obviously having the mountain piggybacking with us in the East Coast and hammering that message is only going to help us in the long run.

1:07:09 Yeah, this is a big deal, and this has been a lot of effort for a lot of years. We've heard from the communities that, hey, listen, we really want to get towards year-round air service, and as John was pointing out, now we're looking at a month in the spring, and then if you consider going in Bishop until October 23rd, and then generally starting in Mammoth right before Thanksgiving, we're looking at a month in the fall. A lot of work to close those gaps.

1:07:34 You know, keep supporting air service and we'll keep plugging away at it. It's been great. As John Wentworth mentioned, we could have the potential for some other partners, which might create more opportunity for us. So always working on that. Yeah, and John, to your point, Pat and I were down there last, I don't even know when, Monday, Tuesday, to meet with the county in Enio and really get this MOU buttoned up on the Eastern Sierra Airlines so that we have clear direction moving forward as to who's

1:08:03 Who's coming in at what levels and we don't have to keep going back and doing an annual revisit unless we change the service. If we add service, then we go back and say, hey, we're adding services to the expectation and we're going to increase this to whatever. And as far as cancellations due to weather, like flying to Mammoth versus to Bishop, I know we have new family that wants to come out and they're thinking of flying to Bishop, they're coming from Miami.

1:08:31 And I would say, no, fly to Mammoth. And they're like, well, what if there's a storm and then we get stuck and we can't get here? So I know that's always a concern, but there hasn't been much as far as cancellations, right? Most of the time we can divert advanced air to Bishop. It's very, very rare that an advanced air cancels because of weather. So we have the opportunity to divert to Bishop. And then last winter, Bishop's flights, I believe we had no cancellations at all. Right, right.

1:09:00 Yeah, the reliability is really strong. That's good to know that it diverts. Yeah, the reliability is huge. I mean, we had one cancellation at the end of the summer. We didn't have any last winter, and we had one cancellation at the end of the summer, which is phenomenal. And to Pat's point, the great thing about Advanced is that they're 99% guaranteed you're going to get here. It just may not be at Mammoth Airport if it's going to divert you down the hill.

1:09:22 And we did just sign one of our diversion agreements for transportation to meet those folks that get diverted and bring them up the hill on our dime. So we did sign one of those this morning with Mammoth Taxi. Encourage them to book. They're all planning it right now. Any other air service questions or comments? Okay, we'll move on to 5.4. John, you're still up. Financial reports. All right. Okay.

1:10:01 You're surprised me as which one. Just ask them now. Yeah, right. TOT collections for September actually came in a little bit lower than I had hoped they would, but we were still 31% ahead of the town's budget. We were about $100,000 behind last year, so about 7.7%. I actually anticipated that those numbers would come in stronger, but unfortunately did not. So year-to-date is ahead of budget, obviously. We still have the conservative budget, and I think that really being only $21,000 behind last year,

1:10:31 through September. So the first three months of the year, that's negligible. That's not even a rounding error. So I think we're, I'm happy that we're that close to where we were last year. The 2% for Measure A is continuing to raise money for housing initiatives. It was about $176,000 for the month, about $800,000 so far for the year. As you'll recall, that's really slated to be about a $4 million plus opportunity for the town, which is fantastic.

1:10:59 On the TBID side, September came in at 281, which was about 12% behind budget. And then for the September year-to-date, it was about 6.7% behind last year. So a little disappointing there. Year-to-date, we're about 3.3% behind budget and about less than a point ahead of last year.

1:11:20 The fact that we're ahead of last year is good. You can see a lot of red numbers under there as far as it goes for the difference to LY. They're fairly small red numbers, which is good for the difference to last year. They aren't meeting the budget numbers that I had proposed. So that's of concern. Where's your question? The question would be, so the TOT came in at 7.7% behind last year. But if you look at the lodging line, that $1,000 difference to last year is 1%.

1:11:50 And that's on the TBID? Yeah, so, I mean, you're saying that September TBID was 99,000, 100,000, basically. Yeah. No, I'm sorry, TOT, which was minus almost 8% from last year on that month. But on the lodging line down below, when you're looking at the two numbers there, it was only $1,000 behind last year, which is a 1% difference to last year, unless I'm reading something wrong. So I don't know.

1:12:20 In other words, if we came in and the lodging came in at 8% behind last year, TBID for lodging should be 8% behind last year, or a number, right? Yeah, I'd have to go back and check out the town on that one. Just kind of jumped out. Yep, yep. No, and it's been something that we've had some challenges, some of the numbers, so it could be. And I think the other side with the TBID is that there are certain

1:12:46 There are certain things that get remitted that don't necessarily show up in the TOT, like penalties and interest in previous months and things like that. So that could be some of the difference there. It was close. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Still disappointing thinking that we had better numbers. I do think October should come in good, but again, we'll see. You can see the checking account and savings account numbers there. Don't really need to go through those. The CDs that we have out there.

1:13:15 You know, we still have the unrestricted Measure A CDs to the tune of $473,000. The special events money that we have in there, that's still really set aside for either event venue opportunities or potentially to use for event funding down the road. And then to the point where we were just talking about the infrastructure fund is about $734,000 and continues to make some good interest on that as well. So that keeps growing.

1:13:42 And then the commitment for this year will probably be in the $350,000 to $400,000 range. And as a reminder, this is the half a percent that was added to the ski areas, 2% last time we renewed. So that's two years worth right there, the $734,000. And then at the end of the year this year, we'll figure out what the number is and roll it into that account. Thank you for adding that. Appreciate it. And then the money market, which really is the TBID reserve, is at about a million dollars.

1:14:12 You know, that's one that we move money in and out of fairly frequently. We will, once we have the United Airlines contract signed, our first deposit with them is due in January. That's a million bucks. And so we have that in the bank account right now to be able to wire that. We did have, this year, because we did a year-long contract with Advanced Air,

1:14:34 So we included summer of 25 and winter 25, 26 in one contract. It actually brought our rate down for the summer flights. I think our rate for the winter flights may have gone up a little bit or they're pretty consistent. But we did, we have a cap for the entire last summer, this winter program at one point.

1:14:56 $4.7 million, I think, and we put $750 up front in the fall, and we wrote another check for $4.25 recently, so we won't have a big chunk with them as we move forward, and again, hopefully we can buy that number down and get more people on the flights. The tourism reserve, the joint reserve is at $320,000. Any questions? Great, thank you, John. Okay, we're going to move on to department updates.

1:15:28 Betsy, you're up first. Community engagement. Thank you, Chair. I'll be quick since you've heard plenty from me today. Community coffee is tomorrow morning at 8.30 a.m.

1:15:41 And thanks to the government reopening, we will be able to have Dawn Johnson from National Weather Service out of Reno with a winter outlook. So had to reschedule her from last month. She's really looking forward to presenting tomorrow. And then the featured coffee shop is the new All-American Dave's Food Truck, which is located at the Kittredge Sports parking lot. And I understand has excellent coffee. Dave recently catered the chamber board retreat to some pretty rave reviews. Unfortunately, I was at a conference in Sacramento, but I...

1:16:11 I heard it was great. So he's really looking forward to being part of the program. I mentioned the annual report for last fiscal year. It's complete, headed to print. And then we talked about resident sentiment survey a lot.

1:16:24 We will push the annual report out through the same channels as last year and then also expanding our distribution to, we'll also be mailing that to non-resident second homeowners this year so that they can learn about our organization and what we're doing and then I'll also be emailing the PDF version to all of you along with all of our TBID remitters and other partners. The special events funding applications are currently open so I'm getting just a lot of questions about that. I have a couple.

1:16:52 Potential new events may be applying this year. So looking forward to reviewing those with the committee. But that funding is open and closes on December 15th at 5 p.m. So any questions, please send them my way. And then our next community skate night is Tuesday, December 2nd from 7.45 to 9.15 p.m. And I also think that will be a really great opportunity to get people starting to take the resident sentiment survey, which hopefully that link will be live next week. So thanks very much.

1:17:21 Betsy, thank you very much. Okay, marketing content. Sarah, are you up for this? Yes. I'm going to give a quick update on fall. You'll receive a full fall update in one of the upcoming board meetings. So October was our last full month. We ran a little bit into November. We saw engagement rate across the video increased month over month. So into October, 89%. We had an 89% completion rate with over 35,000 new

1:17:50 ad engagements. So one of our highest fall ad engagements with some of our fall creative with fall activities as the top performer for our fall creative this year. I want to give a shout out to our team. They did an incredible job this year with our organic all whether that was social newsletters, PR and beyond. So we're going to have even more assets for next year. Winter launched.

1:18:13 In the Northeast in September, we're seeing about an 89% video completion rate. The Northeast Video delivering 88% video completion rates. And we've launched our Travel Zoo kind of immediate need to booking with 2.5% click-through rate. So we're seeing really good numbers so far in some of our further markets for early winter. In terms of content, you guys all got an opportunity to see the restaurant campaign. We're going to continue to rule that out.

1:18:42 fun winter pairings coming up. We are also launching a Keep It Local December 1st, which is a shop local the first two weeks of December, trying to rally our retail businesses. We have 13 businesses that will include landing page, owned assets for photography and video that our businesses can actually utilize, as well as social, and then a passport that our visitors can use. So thank you to the 13 businesses that reached out and are doing that.

1:19:10 And then the largest project that I'm looking on is our certified Unreal, the next step to our Unreal, which will highlight all of the geological features and wonders in our area. So I'm super happy to see that pop up on our advertising inspiration.

1:19:24 And we got really good accolades from the Yosemite Park Geologists who reviewed all of our information, 55 pages of information, to really say that we did a great job and he feels really good about the information that we're sharing and where we're driving people. So we've definitely been looping in the right partners there. And then last, I really want to congratulate John. As someone that's been in the industry for 15 years, John really is.

1:19:48 like the staple people associate was at Mammoth with John and so he's leaving a really positive legacy. I've had personally a wonderful two and a half years working for John. We have an amazing team and I'm wishing you all the best. You deserve it, honestly. So, thank you guys. Tara, thank you very much. Okay, we'll move on to 6.3, digital and social media marketing.

1:20:12 Samantha, welcome. Hi, thank you. For today's report, I'm going to give some updates on our content, website, and social media. So to begin with our content, we have worked with local partners to significantly update our town map, and we now have those available within our town offices if you need them for your business. The 2026 visitor guide is underway and will be sent to print very, very soon.

1:20:38 And then we also had a very successful year with our Fall Colors newsletter, which grew by 1,500 subscribers, and we continue to just grow this program overall, which is very exciting. For the website, we had a 24% increase in our website sessions, and our total page views increased 22% year over year.

1:21:01 And we're continuing to see a lot of growth to our local businesses and events and had 26,000 outbound clicks to those businesses in October. Some of the top content for visitors in market was our Fall Callers blog, restaurants, events, and even our Halloween page.

1:21:22 With GuideGeek, we continue to see our users increase on this platform, and we're seeing about 25% increase of return users, and our messages from September to October have increased 53%. For social media, we've had a lot of good stuff going on there since October was busy with fall. Our overall impressions for Facebook and Instagram were at 7.2 million, with our engagements at 84,000.

1:21:51 Some of our top performing stuff for Facebook included our stories and reels, which were up 200% month over month in views and interactions. And for Instagram, we had some of our top posts being that we finally got snow in Mammoth Lakes and that fall was still holding on towards like the later end there.

1:22:22 highlighted a road trip from Yosemite to Mammoth Lakes, and they produced three pieces of content for us, and within those three pieces of content, they had 285 total views and 7,000 interactions, and our total combined stats for our fall color post totaled at 1.5 million views with 675,000 in reach and 60,000 interactions.

1:22:48 And for the continuation of our Opry adventure Reels for October, we had nearly 115,000 views, 76,000 in reach, and 2,600 interactions with that. So fall was like a really, really good month, and for our upcoming meeting, we'll have a more in-depth recap of that, so we're excited to share. Any questions? Taking such wonderful photos.

1:23:20 Yeah. Thank you, Kim, as well for her help there because it's been a joint effort. I can't take a look at it. Yeah. Great. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, communications and PR. Allie Watson, Allie, any press releases lately? Yeah, so had a little crunch time press release to get out, so hopefully you guys all got that and you can feel free to share that with anyone. If you have any questions, let me know if you need an additional copy of the PDF. Do we have a link? Is there a link to the?

1:23:51 It will be going on our website too, so I can send you the link once that's up. That'd be great. Yeah. Let me write that down before I forget. Send to John. Okay, so we've kind of officially wrapped up our fall colors. We're transitioning into winter. Our fall colors efforts this year were incredible.

1:24:13 Extra thanks to Kim and Sam with all the content produced. That's really where things start to get picked up in that department with the seasonal destination storytelling for PR. It's those eye-catching photos that make people want to tell that story. Shout out to Sam who got the lead photo in the New York Times, which is a big monumental moment for her.

1:24:35 Yeah, and we had some really great media work and storytelling done over October, which is what I'll be recording on. And kind of building on last year's Fall Colors success, we've really turned a page from...

1:24:50 being the hidden gem fall colors destination to a true standalone fall colors destination. So we've spoken with our PR agency on shifting our messaging for next year and coming in with a new angle that also weaves in a lot of responsible recreation tips and things like that.

1:25:08 That's really exciting. We had 270 broadcast clips alone, so that's all TV segments, likely due to our exciting early winter storm that made some nice contrasting colors with the fall colors, but also...

1:25:24 345 total earned media placements in October only, including coverage in Photos, New York Times, Vogue, and then that broadcast number is really impressive, so that boosted our numbers as well, and this show a 65% increase over last October, and with the Fall Colors program,

1:25:47 in its own department, we had 186 of those 345 placements were just fall colors focused, and that shows an 82% increase in last year's fall colors program. So we've also submitted our fall colors program to the Visit California Poppy Awards for a public relations nomination. We'll see how that goes, and we can report back in the winter when we attend the Outlook Forum there.

1:26:14 Yeah, and again, Sam mentioned our influencers that we saw. That was a Gold Pass partnership with Visit California. So really great to continue that resource where Visit California helps fund those multi-destination visits. And we had a journalist come through that program last month as well as the influencers. So making good use of their support.

1:26:37 And we're moving towards planning and integrating more visits for winter. We had our annual in-person strategy meeting with our domestic PR agency, so really great to sit down with them, focus on what's next and then how we can grow our programs and looking for any gaps that we can fill with our team's efforts. One major takeaway from that that I would like to share, and it's also been surfacing in a lot of other networks in the PR world, is

1:27:04 The impact that earned media holds in generative search optimization, so those little AI windows that pop up in your searches, it'll give you kind of an abstract or an overview of what you're looking for, and that is pulling from the search engine's AI optimization of what is out on the internet.

1:27:25 But with a recent report from Muckrack, which is the leading PR platform, it reports that 89% of those results are sourced from the earned media landscape.

1:27:35 So all of our work that we're doing to get these placements is going to directly impact people's search results. And if you play around, I definitely encourage you to do some searches that you might not usually do and just see what the results come from. And it's also not pulling from long-standing past results. AI is getting smarter by the day, so it's using current results.

1:27:57 The stories that we're facilitating now are going to be the AI results of tomorrow. So that is really exciting and it's a really great motivator for our team and future work. And it also just demonstrates that the relationships that we're building are not only powering human sentiment, but also now AI. So we're kind of doubling down on our earned media landscape there and that's really exciting. Yeah, I think this is important to note because I think that even though we have the authoritative...

1:28:24 website with all of the information. When you go to Google and you get that AI summary at the top, it's not pulling from our website. So everything that Ali and the team are doing to get these articles out there that are talking about skiing or hiking or stewardship or whatever, that's what's feeding that and a lot of people are skipping everything else. They're just reading the AI overview, taking it for gospel and moving on. So our click rates across the world.

1:28:53 Click rates are going down because people are like, oh, I got my answer. And so, you know, the zero click era is here and we need to make sure that we're still getting the information out there. So, thank you. Yeah, and it's also really relevant when Sam talks about our website activity as well. She's working really hard to consolidate a lot of our pages where there's less pages and kind of one source of information and that feeds directly into that AI optimization as well.

1:29:19 It's really exciting and all those relationships that we're working hard to build and amplify our messaging is really clearly being shown in those AI-generated results. So it's nice to put an extra little ROI on our work and see how impressive those results are.

1:29:39 And then, yeah, we have a lot of winter visits in the pipeline, one specifically coming in December for a Condé Nast destination overview, so really exciting there, and I will be busy hosting journalists, and you'll see those results in the AI-generated overview of your Google searches. But, yeah, thanks, everyone, and thanks, John, for almost one year of mentorship and guidance, and we hope to visit you down on the beach. Thank you.

1:30:07 Any questions? Feel free to email me if you have any questions about that AI stuff too. Happy to share. Great. Allie, thank you. Thank you very much. And Samantha, congratulations again. It's very, very, very cool. Okay, we'll move on to other standing updates. We'll go to 7.1, Mammoth Resorts Update with Eric Clark. Yeah, Sam, congrats. You know, we thought it was pretty cool that Peter got on the cover of Powder.

1:30:34 That's a little less distribution than the New York Times, so congratulations. We have our first camper, even before I came down here, so they're lining up and getting ready. But of course, with our new lift, Chair One, there's a lot of work to build a snow ramp up to it because it is such a big building and so forth.

1:31:03 So you should see what's going on up there right now. And we've moved the campers inside to our ticket lobby. So they'll be in there. Of course, we'll move them out once we complete the work, but that won't be until early tomorrow morning. But really happy to report that it's going to be a great skiing day tomorrow. So if you have the ability to get out there, get up there.

1:31:31 The lifts that we are going to open are chair one, chair two, chair three, gondola one, gondola two, chair 23, 11. Come on. I am serious. And now there is weather coming in. The ski shop's going to be open to sell new skis. There's some good snow out there. I know you probably have been up there. I'm going to take this right back.

1:32:01 No, it's looking really good up top. Everything is ski-able. And if, you know, there is weather coming in, so depending on weather. But we might even open up 13 tomorrow if it's good weather. But we're definitely looking to do that for the weekend, 12 and 13 as well.

1:32:29 Really fun opening, given the fact that, you know, it was a week ago that we had zero snow out there, just what was left over essentially from the October 12th snowstorm referred to earlier, but so great progress, snowmaking has been outstanding.

1:32:51 where we've really finally got some temperatures. And unfortunately, our other, you know, brothers and sisters out there in the resort world have not gotten those snowmaking temps. So we will see probably a lot of people coming down from Lake Tahoe area. Eric, are there, for Thanksgiving, are there any plans for Canyon?

1:33:19 Yeah, that's a great question, John, and I was going to give that update where we have plans, and I want to go back to the word hypothesis that we were using earlier. We've had several plans of how we were going to open, and they've changed. But we are doing everything we can to get there. We've really invested in a lot of snowmaking to get us down there.

1:33:46 So over the next week, though, the temperatures do warm up. And it's going to be a little bit of a stretch. But we will, you know, the ultimate goal that we're trying to shoot for is to have returnable skiing there. The alternative goal, if we have to, would be to be able to park there, take a lift.

1:34:12 And most likely that would be 16. Could be 17.4, but most likely it's 16. And you would be bussed back. So we will look at that. You know, we're looking at our demand for that week and it looks great. And looking further into the season, you know, we really like all our early booking trends that we track.

1:34:41 Our quad pack is doing better than last year. Our season tickets, or not the season tickets, but the daily tickets are doing better than last year. Our lodging packages, you know, our early winter booking packages are doing better as well. So there's a lot of good things that are tracking in the right direction. We just need some Mother Nature to help us out. So that's good.

1:35:08 I also want to share with you, we have a really kind of a special event tonight. It's just a team event, but I think worth sharing in the sense that tonight we have a Leaders and Legends celebration where we celebrate our team. And not only all of our leaders and department heads, but also the people that have had 30 years of service, 40 years of service.

1:35:37 50 years of service. And so there's a lot of those people. So we have nine, six, and one in those categories. So really fun event coming up. Opening day events, hopefully you got that information out there, but of course we'll start spinning the lift at 8.30, break the banner, and then we'll do a toast at 11.

1:36:06 Yes, 11, I think it is, but again, changing. Eric, I know you've been really, very exciting news. You've been really busy this summer with infrastructure work. Yes. Do you mind just giving a quick recap of some of those investments? No, not at all. You know, a lot of the infrastructure work that we were engaged in this summer was all around snowmaking.

1:36:34 And different capacities. We now, for instance, we were running 39 different fan guns last night. And that, we couldn't have done that just a couple of years ago.

1:36:51 And so the infrastructure to get the electricity there, the infrastructure to update our pipes in the ground too that have been failing and the air pressure and doing that. We've also invested in a new system of managing to making it more automated so that as soon as we see a temperature at a gun, we can turn it on from the pump house.

1:37:17 versus having to go out and set it up. That's impressive. So that's a lot of the infrastructure. Also really pleased about the fact that we built some new buildings on the mountain. And we built a new bump shack, a bump shack being defined as where the ski patrol poised themselves prior to getting a call, which everything's gravity fed, so you have to have certain areas on the mountain, you know,

1:37:48 with our patrol kind of ready to go. And so we have a new bump shack at the top of chair two and at the top of chair 22, which will give them much better facilities. We also completed a new bump shack over at the top of 12. So that's been some of the infrastructure out there. Then, of course, the Woolies. It was

1:38:17 in construction. We still have more to do, but we've stopped that now, so we'll add the additional activity next spring. We will, speaking of woolies, woolies will start making snow here tomorrow, hopefully, and it will open on Saturday, and we'll open the coaster and possibly the zip line as well.

1:38:44 But probably not the two being quite yet. So, but we'll get that open for Thanksgiving. Awesome. Very excited. Yeah. Thank you. All great news. Great news. Yeah. And Tom, thank you for the prompt. Excellent. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Tom, with that, we'll move on to you with a Mammoth Lakes Chamber update. Quite a few events coming up for the Chamber. The first are a couple of grand openings or ribbon cuttings.

1:39:13 First is for Limelight for its grand opening. That's Monday, December 1st, 3 to 5 p.m., and that will be in the main lobby. The bar and lounge opens at 3. There's going to be live music, holiday carolers, property tours from 3 to 5 p.m., and that's free and open to the whole community.

1:39:39 The other ribbon cutting is for the Eastern Sierra Mountain Club. That's relocating from the village to Main Street Promenade next to Black Velvet. And that is Thursday, December 4th from 4 to 5. And we have a number of programs for workshops and training coming up. The first is peak performance.

1:40:04 program, and this is a training for on customer service for all of our frontline staff. That is December 2nd and 3rd, and that's really about helping everybody get ready for our peak season. The next are a couple of workshops. One is for managers and business owners and the others for frontline staff. The manager and business owner power lunch workshop is going to be December 2nd.

1:40:34 That is, of course, this lunch, noon to 1.30. That's being held at the eatery, and that's a focus on psychological safety, basically creating a work environment where everyone feels respected. And that's $25 for chamber members, $35 for community members. The other workshop is a frontline customer service workshop on December 2nd, 4 to 6, also at the eatery, and that's also a way to

1:41:03 No, I just, I don't think your mic is working. I don't see it. It looks like it's dead. So maybe just move one more down. Thank you. And that's, as I mentioned, also at the eatery. And just, again, another event to get our people ready for the coming season. Lastly, we have, not coming up right away, this is January 14th. This is the chamber's annual career compass day at the high school. And the reason I'm

1:41:32 Mentioning it now is that I'm pitching, really, because we need participants to come and be a part of the...

1:41:42 Transfer of knowledge to our high school students. We're seeking community members from all fields, business owners, trades, healthcare, creative, government, nonprofits, hospitality, entrepreneurs, retirees, and more. We're asking people to do a simple presentation, no more than 20 minutes on how they got to where they are today and how students can further explore opportunities in those industries.

1:42:12 What about alcohol? Brewing? Absolutely. Science. You know what? Brewing is a science. That's right. So we'd welcome that part of it. Yep. What day of the week is that? That is coming up. That's Wednesday, January 14th. At what time? I don't have the time. There's two slots.

1:42:40 I just, in fact, I just got the email. Oh, did you? Okay. Like 9 to 10, 10. Thank you, John. It's whatever those two sessions are. Yeah. Thanks, man. Great. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay. And last but not least, town council update with John Wentworth. Sure. Thank you very much. I think there is one other chamber event happening on December 1st, which I believe is the ribbon cutting up at the limelight. That's what he said. Oh, I'm sorry. I missed that. I won't be able to make it there unfortunately.

1:43:10 Okay, so now time for the buzzkill report. So Town Council this evening, taking care of the community's business. We're going to be talking about, well, we're going to have a workshop with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, very much looking forward to that. And then we're going to be another presentation from the Heist Energy Energy Foundation, which is celebrating their 20th anniversary, doing a lot of good work around the region.

1:43:33 And then we're going to move, there's a CIP report coming up from the Public Works Department. That's some of those things we talked about. Okay, where does the infrastructure meet? Come on, everybody, let's get all these things lined up. And then we're going to have a public hearing for an appeal for a housing project that's run into some difficulties. This is an appeal from the Planning Commission. That would be an interesting item. A policy manner to extend the placemates program for housing.

1:44:02 which is, I think, a lot of folks are involved in that. That's something, interesting discussion on that. The air service memorandum that you mentioned, again, I just hope to get a little color on that is what the, kind of what the program looks like. So there are private sector folks who may be the, you know, the house of the drunks who want to, like, get involved in the airline subsidy business. Just, sorry, not casting any expressions here. And then some financial results, and that's about it. There's a lot of...

1:44:29 What's going on in the region is a lot of work. Again, this job's first stuff, which I've mentioned before, which is flying just below the radar of the elected bodies. And I think probably a lot of y'all don't know what's going on with all that. But there's an enormous amount of community communication, collaboration, working on regional efforts as defined by the state of California. There'll be some outputs coming up from that probably in June, July this year.

1:44:55 The funding for that runs out in September, and there's going to be a gap between administrations and the state. It's not clear where the state's going with this, what they want to do with these programs, but the idea of California establishing a regional program like New York, Pennsylvania, other major states have these things. It's interesting to see what happens with that. There is a recreation and tourism working group that's going to be meeting through June that's going to be publishing a series of recommendations for collaboration and future actions that

1:45:24 Some of the board may be interested in participating in that. But that's about it. Great. Thank you. Great. John, thank you. Thank you very much. And we're looking forward to seeing you shortly. Does anybody have anything else they'd like to add? Yeah. One other thing. So on Saturday, December 6th, from 3 to 7, we will be hosting the Sierra Canine.

1:45:46 Group, our four-legged first responders, the Avalanche is a fundraiser. They will have all four dogs there from three to seven in shifts. We have bottled 120 bottles, $30 per dog with their pictures on them and we're donating $25 per bottle to the Eastern Sierra Canine and they will have other things to sell there. In terms of tchotchkes and stuff, you can come buy a bottle.

1:46:16 Make a donation, whatever you like to do, but it's a fundraiser for them, a much-needed resource here that gets underplayed. I think we all just assume it gets funded somewhere else, but it depends on a lot of donations from a lot of different places. So if you have time, stop in during that period of time and meet the dogs. Thank you. December 6th, 3 to 7. And are you going to be pouring samples? Are you going to be tasting? Yeah.

1:46:45 Yeah, we're open. Yeah, I mean, we'll be there. You've been there. Yeah, we'll have the business open, but the dogs will be there, and it's, I will tell you, when you see the poster, or if you look online, the dogs are just amazing. They brought them over for, we did some photographs in the distillery, and one of the handlers said, well, would you like them on a bar stool? I was like, well, when they get up, he goes, up.

1:47:08 Sat right on the bar stool, so we got one picture with him by his bottle on the bar stool at the bar. I mean, just like, well, whatever. Whatever you want. What day of the week is that? Pardon me? What day of the week? Saturday. Saturday. Saturday afternoon.

1:47:23 Great. Is Scott's new red Labrador on one of those places? We haven't seen, we haven't committed whether, they haven't committed whether they're going to bring the puppy or not. That is a beautiful. That's a long period of time. That will make you a lot of money. You bring that dog out. That dog is so cute. I listen to the four of them between Gritter and Luna and, you know, Cody and all of them. They're really incredible. Mary Beth, go ahead. Yeah, so the Christmas tree lot opens, holiday tree lot, our holiday tree lot opens the day after Thanksgiving. So that'll be at Outbound again. And it is,

1:47:53 A really important fundraiser for Booster Club to make sports activities accessible to all kids in Mammoth. So if you have time, run by and pick up a tree or a tree. Actually, the team included it in their local shopping this year, which is really, it'll be nice exposure for us. So thanks, ladies, for putting that. Great. Thank you guys for doing that. Anybody else?

1:48:20 Okay. Well, we will adjourn this meeting until our next scheduled meeting, December 17th, 2025. This one will be back to 1 o'clock, and hopefully we'll see you all here shortly. Yeah. It had 3.30 on the thing when we started, that we were starting at 3.30, but it's 4 today? Okay. Yeah. We're 1.30 to 3.30 on this meeting. We adjourned this meeting at 3.30, start to town council at 4 o'clock. Okay.

1:48:50 Okay, everybody, thank you very much. Congratulations, John Urdi. Yeah. So you're still here for the next meeting, right? Because you leave the 19th. I'm probably going to run short since the clock.