TransparentMammoth

Short-Term Rental Committee · 2024

Short-Term Rental Committee Special meeting

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

241 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:13 We have a quorum, so we may. Jamie, could you do a roll call, please? Committee Member Avery. Present. Committee Member Bubzer. Here. Committee Member Gardner is absent. Committee Member Harper. Here. Committee Member Kellogg. Here. Committee Member Ocampo is absent. Committee Member Rice. Here. Vice Chair Fleming. Here. Chair Morris. Here. Okay. Second on the agenda. We'll go with the consent agenda to approve the minutes of our last meeting on the 23rd.

2:47 I move that we approve the minutes of the special meeting of January 23rd. Amanda? I'll second. Lisa, any comments? Any discussion? Okay. Roll call on that, Jamie? Committee Member Avery? Yes. Committee Member Bubzer? Yes. Committee Member Harper? Yes. Committee Member Kellogg? Yes. Committee Member Rice? Yes. Vice Chair Fleming? Yes. Chair Morris? Yes. Before we get started, I'd just like to have a very brief comment.

3:20 Just regarding the last meeting, apologies to anybody, any members of the public if they felt that their comments weren't properly heard. I know a couple of us did have to leave early and I apologize for that. But just a comment, this committee was tasked to look at a very, very narrow scope of information regarding the short-term rental program. We were not asked to look at things like DIFF, Mammoth Mountain, the limelight, or any of those other items.

3:47 What I would ask is, in the interest of time, is that when we comment on things on the agenda tonight, let's really try to keep it specific to the topic, if there are comments from the public, and any public comment at the end, again, keep in mind that this committee has not taken up any of these other issues, so it probably would be better served that some of these comments be reserved for town council.

4:16 Outside the scope of what we've been working on, because again, our focus has been very narrow. What we will do is we will have public comment after each policy matter. Again, please keep those comments germane, very, very specific to the topic that we're discussing. And the last thing is that we, the agenda may look pretty robust, but we've already approved a lot of the stuff on here, so we don't need to go back over a lot of these things unless there's some new information.

4:45 We do want to give the public a chance to give comment on it, if appropriate, and then we'll go from there. Rob or Dan, do you have any opening comments you wanted to make? Okay, so going into policy matters, the first item on here is funding alternatives for housing programs. Basically, there are two items on here. The first, the 1.5% short-term rental tax.

5:15 We have already discussed and approved that. So unless there's something that needs to be discussed there within the group, I guess. Yeah, I guess I feel that I don't know that, you know, do we want to send both of those things forward? Or I kind of feel like that's a big ask, you know, tacking on a, you know, potentially $1,500 and then also bumping T-BID, I'm sorry, not T-BID, T-O-T up one or two percent.

5:45 So I think we should discuss. Is that $1,500 or was it talking about 1.5%? 1.5%. Yeah. Yeah, I agree with you, Amanda. I think that it's, we definitely, I think as a group, well, we haven't, we didn't really get through the TOT increase. I think we kind of did at the last meeting, so we need to go through that too. But I agree with you. I don't, I personally don't believe that both things should be on a.

6:14 On a ballot next year, one or the other. But I would like to give the council options. So in that, maybe our preferred option could be one or the other, but in case the council decides to go one direction or another, it's always good to have different options. I'm personally not super in favor of the short-term rental tax, but that's just my opinion. So we've gone through the guts of that. If it's okay, let's just briefly touch on the...

6:42 The proposed TOT increase. One of the things that was brought up for the town is do we know where that puts us in the state in terms of other municipalities with what their TOT levels are or tax levels? So just to recap, people may not have heard that.

7:28 So we did do some analysis. I reached out to Mammoth Lakes Tourism asking for some analysis that they perform on a regular basis. And Civitas is their legal advisors that have the ability to get the information through Visit California. So they're acquiring that information for all municipalities in California.

7:53 But we did our own quick analysis. We saw just a handful that were higher than where we are today. There were not that many. I'd say probably about six or seven, Danny, that were up above us on that, and the highest being 17%. With our proposed both TBID and TOT, it was comparable to those numbers. So we would be at the upper end of that process.

8:22 So just to clarify, the current rate is 13%? 13% TOT, 1% TBID, so that's where we get a total of 14. Got it. So when we looked at the two charts, it's like, do they have a TOT tax, do they have a TBID component as well? It's not, it's indiscernible from a payer's standpoint, right? I mean, it means different things to us, but not necessarily to them, so we kind of consider them combined, even though they're not, they're totally separate things. Okay, so a 2% increase would take us to?

8:51 16? Yeah, 16 total. 15. If I may on that, too, I mean, the recommendation, we talked about a 2%, and the recommendation could be a 1%. So take what I think walk through this, and sorry to jump in on that part of it. Other places do different types of taxes for support tourism. Some do a bed tax per person, dollar amount, things of that nature. So it's apples mostly, but there is some other uniquenesses. I think for the discussion this evening, I think what we're looking for is

9:20 Taking one or more recommendations forward, so you could recommend a couple different ones for council to consider. We said up to one and a half, if you want to look at that one percent, that on the short-term rental tax, you could say, well, we said up to, but maybe we want to look at capping it at a one. The other side of that would be on the TOT tax. We talked about a two percent, but again, it's up to you if you want to recommend something different. I just want to make you have that option as we're sitting here walking through these.

9:49 If you're looking at maybe a little lower rate or on either one of them or like I mentioned, here's two but the preference would be 4X. Please feel free to have that discussion. When was last time we increased TOT? With the T bid. And then prior to that it was like 06 or something with the voter initiatives. I think transit was the last one. It might have been later than 06. 2013. That was the T bid. That was the T bid, 1%.

10:20 And so it's been 13%. Well, not just the T-Bid 1%. It would have been a T-Bid increase at the same time. No, but the T-Bid went in and that increased the T-Bid. There was a T-Bid increase of 1%. It was primarily focused on transit. And I just don't recall. I don't care. I want to say 06 or somewhere in that ballpark. I just don't remember off the top of my head. Have we attempted to increase T-Bid? No, we have not put anything in the ballot system. I mean, I guess the, you know, the

10:50 The bottom line on this is really how aggressive we want to be as far as the recommendation and really what we're looking for as far as funds because obviously we can recommend up to 1.5% on the STR tax. We can recommend up to 2% on TOT. It's just a question of what amount of funding do we think that we need to generate in order to run these programs we're proposing?

11:19 The difficult – I mean, I'm – to be honest, I'm not a fan of raising taxes at all for anything, but I don't see any other – I don't see any other funding mechanism that's available. And again, this group was strictly looking at how STRs can help that, not any other funding mechanisms that might exist out in the world that the town could be involved with or anything else. Strictly how STRs can help with this. So – John, can I share my screen real quick? Yeah, sure.

11:49 This is the work that we did internally to pull up some analysis. So you can see here we're talking about TOT numbers, so the percentages, and whether or not there was a TBID component associated with that. And these are current rates. So as far as a rate is considered right here, 13% for Incline Village, but they don't have a TBID. And then you can see the ones that were below us.

12:18 It caps out at 17%, but there's some other weird calculations as far as the TBID based upon average daily rates per night. But yeah, you can see the other areas just to give you a sense of who have those higher rates. Ours would slot in right at the 15% with Anaheim, and then there would be another 1% above that. So we would really slot in right at the top for the analysis that we did.

12:48 A couple things to consider. Obviously, with the short-term rental potential tax of 1.5%, so that's, again, that is strictly a tax that's going to hit homeowners who rent their place short-term. That's approximately 80% of TOT. Yeah, right. We figured that these short-term rentals produce about 79% of...

13:15 The TOT that's collected, the other 21% is attributed to hotels and condos, which we call Schedule E in the town. So that's the one proposal. The other, the 2%, that is broader. That would encompass everyone who engages in lodging in the community, hotels, B&Bs, everybody. And the payment of that would fall on a different group. That would fall on our visitors rather than our homeowners.

13:43 So those are the major differences between those two. At the rates that we're looking at, the 2% increase in TOT on average would yield quite a bit more money on an annual basis. So, I mean, really, those are the two things. And again, they can be manipulated up or down depending on what the council chooses to take either one of these things up. It still has to pass as a ballot measure next year, either one of them.

14:13 But I would agree with, I think, what most of us said last time is we do not want, we're not going to suggest that both of these things be on the ballot because it's just, that's kind of crazy. So any other discussion? Is there hesitancy to push either one of these things through at the rates we've discussed? Yes, it puts us at a higher rate for TOT and so forth.

14:40 We're talking about a 2% increase. I know it's not nothing, but it's a 2% increase in what our guests pay when they come up. So on a $1,000 weekend, they're paying $20 more. That's not nothing, but it's relatively small, in my opinion. And I'm not a fan of having this just lie on short-term rental homeowners.

15:06 Because, again, I think what that message is is saying that our short-term rentals are our problem in town, and I personally don't agree with that. I think it's a blend of issues. So, anyway. Can we add to the recommendation that this might sunset at some point? You know, they've still got to vote on it, but maybe five years, let the parcel get built out and see what the other programs have done, and then it can be re-evaluated and possibly put back on the ballot at that point if we think we need it.

15:34 Yeah, you can make a recommendation that would do a couple of different things. One would be, you can look at the rate, obviously. Yeah, and you could make a recommendation that, based on other factors out there, yeah, you look at a, it could be a five-year, ten-year, pick a number, frankly. Make it worth your while, but the five years would probably be a minimum you'd want to look at, I would think. But, yeah, if you could look at it as a sunset, and you could do that with either of these. It could have a sunset clause on there. And I hate to blindside you guys with this.

16:04 Do we think in five years we'll be halfway through the parcel build-out, or do we think we're only going to be like phase two? Do we have any sort of estimate? I know it's not really year. This isn't what we're discussing, but just to try to come up with a time frame, five, seven years? We really don't. I mean, it's all depending on ultimately funding. That is mainly federal and state grant funding. Yeah, you've got to source it for each phase, right? Right. So right now at phase one, 80, 70.

16:33 Six that are, I think, funded at this point, and then the second half of that's up in the air right now. We're looking at that. Maybe let's recommend seven years on this as, like, a sunset, if that would make anyone... I think, yeah, you could make a year recommendation. You could also have the recommendation to the council that this have a sunset date, not to extend beyond, say, 10 or 7. That way they can play with that, and you can make... You can all come and comment at the council meeting, by the way, so... Yeah.

17:01 But yeah, so you could look at some, you could put a cap that you're looking at not to exceed. Is anyone opposed to that idea? Because then if we find that we don't need the funding anymore, it would drop us back down and make us a little more competitive versus other tourism areas. Just one thing I'd like to add, you know, at least from our perspective, the town, you know, we've contributed a lot of money to housing in the last few years, right? And this is, you know, unallocated TOT revenue.

17:32 Things that we were collecting over and above what we needed for operational expenses. As the cost of doing business increases and the revenue stream, which is not guaranteed, may decrease, the ability to contribute funding to that may dry up in the future. This is one of those elements that is a dedicated funding source, and it's outside of that.

18:00 It's not a part of the town funds associated with operations. It's dedicated directly to that. So it would be providing a permanent funding source. To consider us being out of housing challenges in the next seven years is probably not going to happen. But that's just something to bear in mind, right? When folks are saying, you know, this is all in the STRs to fund housing, not even close, right? This is a matter of the town has been funding it 100%, and we need something that's more consistent and dependable into the future.

18:31 Rob and Dan, if the recommendation is made without a sunset, the council can still vote to put a sunset or they can at some point? Yes, they could. The other question for either of these would be whether it's a general or a special tax. As outlined in the staff report, what that means.

19:01 In the interest of time, I would like to propose a motion that we... Do you want to take some public comment? Oh, yeah, before we make a motion, yes. So any comment from the public specifically on this topic? This is the topic of short-term rental, of taxing short-term rental owners and or raising TOT and just only those two items. You can go up to the podium so we can hear you. Thank you. My name is Rose Perez-Jessen.

19:35 These comments on your tax program is baked into the other comments I was going to make regarding your other proposals. But basically, I don't think STR should be specifically targeted for taxing this program. It should be looked at as a community-wide problem to solve and taxed on a community-wide basis as an increase in property taxes or the like. It's not STRs to solve or to be taxed. Thank you very much. Mr. Lehman.

20:09 Thank you. Thank you. Back again. I thought it's the TBID tax thing, I think it's a sensitive topic for me after last week. And I just don't know, and thanks for the comment, because I think that, you know, we talked about it before, we're one of the most heavily reliant communities on TBID type taxes and TOT and whatnot, where other communities, you know, I remember

20:39 When I sat on the council, I was talking to a mayor of Big Bear, and they were much more stable because they actually had a diversified tax program. And I'm just wondering if we shouldn't be looking at other forms of just, I hate to raise any taxes. One, I don't think we should be doing it. I think we need to start looking internally and maybe saving some money. As costs and things like that do go up, we need to remind ourselves, so are revenues, so are,

21:09 So are the rents everywhere. So if we're going out and asking for new taxes, because we have a shortfall or shortcoming someplace, so I think we need to really be looking at that. It's just really trying to cut elsewhere and to come up with some of our funding. Also, I think we all know once a tax goes into place, it almost never goes away. I don't think I've ever seen it. And if Truckee, as has been pointed out in these documents, is being so tremendously successful with

21:39 Putting more housing on the market. And if we think that we're going to solve our problem by doing this, then I think we need to also acknowledge the fact that we won't need these funds in the future for the housing. So I think having a sunset if a tax is put in place is imperative. And I don't think any type of tax should be ever passed without a sunset in place, particularly if it's tied to the fact maybe we need some criteria of housing. So that's all I had to say on this one. Thank you. Thanks, Matthew.

22:09 Anyone else in the audience? Thank you for your comment on property taxes because I agree that to whatever degree we can raise taxes, I think across the board we should. I totally disagree with picking on the middle class, i.e. the blue area only for any TOT. And if we're going to do anything that impacts property values in order to create housing, it should be in the resort zones, not the middle class zones because that's where housing is really needed. So don't pick on the middle class.

22:42 And I own an Airbnb with somebody else at Sierra Manners. And I support a 2% increase across the board for TOT and Mammoth Lakes with an additional 1% to 2% for all transient rentals that are not hotels or campgrounds, meaning we Airbnb types. So that would be a total of 3% to 4% depending. And I agree. If you take a look at the amount of housing we're going to need for the mountain and for

23:12 Snow Creek 10, and for the village, we're going backwards, we're not going forward. The amount of housing we're going to need over the next 10 years far exceeds the amount of affordable housing we have on the books and that you're going to create. Therefore, we really should have a long-term plan that analyzes and assesses, which I assume you've already done and have before you, the amount of affordable housing we're going to need at build-out over the next 10 years versus the amount of money we could bring in.

23:38 From any source of basis. And we should be aiming at creating the housing necessary. I mean, I have one line here that I think sort of really says the whole thing. And I say, heavily taxed mega mansions visited a few times a year where invisible people clean their toilets and disappear into a one-bedroom condo with four other families, all working three jobs. That's just not okay. And I'm fine. I should pay more to...

24:06 Help resolve that issue. I think we all should pay more to help resolve that issue. But we shouldn't pick a particular segment and assess them. And as far as the sunset, I'm okay with that. I don't like the idea, but I'm okay with the sunset. But I think we should analyze the housing we're going to need in the long-term, increase whatever taxes are necessary for what will inevitably be a high resort area as Mammoth Lakes is just going to get more expensive. This will be an upper school resort.

24:33 Let's plan out accordingly and make sure we treat the workers as a decent human being. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anyone else in the audience? Jamie? Jan, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, can you hear me? Yes. Yes, we can. Okay, thank you. My name is Jan Henry. I am a homeowner and short-term rental provider that lives off of Tyrell Lane. I just wanted to say that

25:09 I would really recommend only suggesting 1% increase in the TOT tax rather than 2% because we do not want to be at the top of the list at the very highest occupancy taxes on that list. I think it's going to drive people away from the community and we're going to end up with less money in Mammoth Lakes and less money for your budget for housing. That's all. Thanks. Thank you.

25:42 Scott, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you. This is Scott Miller. Can you hear me? Yes. Thank you. Thank you for your work and for continuing to address these issues. I know they're difficult issues. I spoke at the meeting last week, and I'm not in town today, so I'm speaking by Zoom. I think there was one comment saying that STR is not the pain for all of these issues.

26:10 And I guess my understanding is that the town revenue is 80% from STR from TOT monies. And as a result, it seems to me that all the money that Mammoth has spent to date on this, to the extent it is Mammoth money, has come from the TOT. Perhaps I'm wrong on that, but that's just my understanding from the facts as I get it. And now you're adding about putting another 2% on that. I think it'd be much wiser, in accordance with what the last person said, that you have to be careful not to be at the very top.

26:39 of the TOT list in the state of California. Anaheim has a lot more things going on for it than Mammoth does in many ways. And you're certainly going to drive people away from Mammoth during the summer and other periods, if not also during the prime ski season. I think it'd be much better, instead of doing that, to do a 1% increase in the TOT and a 0.5% increase in the sales tax. That way, the entire town is supporting the issue of additional housing and make that 0.5%.

27:08 sales tax or whatever that quarter percent or whatever it is to make up that difference between the one percent TOT would be shared by everybody, the residents and the visitors who are buying things within the town. I think that would be much fairer way to go about funding these issues and put everybody with a stake in the process. Thank you. Thank you very much. Ann, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

27:34 Yes, good afternoon, everybody, and thank you again for hosting this meeting. I spoke last week, and here I am again. I totally agree with the last two comments. STR is not an issue. We all know this. However, it is asked from us, the owner, and by the way, we are all blue-collar hard worker and investing our money in the town that we love. However, just expecting to squeeze...

28:03 us to get an answer and a solution to a problem that has been there for many years and that will not go away with a little amount of money you're trying to squeeze out of us. This is a town issue. This is an all-business issue.

28:22 Frankly, it's an all-visitors issue. So if you do want to raise the TOT, by all means, but absolutely should not be a 1.5% on NSTR gross sales because that will never stop. When you need more money, you'll just bring that up and we will not issue bring the...

28:44 Resolution to the issue. So, sales tax, where everybody is going to participate, yes, that does make sense. I urge you to consider that, because we are not the issue, and frankly, to think that we're going to solve it, TOT is 70% of the budget of the town. Where has that money gone? So you're going to add another 2%, and then you want to add 1.5% on the STR.

29:15 In the same time, restricting a year when we sell a home so that it cannot be STR'd, you are actually going to remove funds from the budget. So thank you very much for understanding once again that we're not the issue and we cannot solve it. But together, we can. Thank you.

29:38 Thank you. And if I may just make a very brief comment. Again, let's narrow the scope. This particular committee is not being tasked to look at sales tax, property taxes, or anything else. It is strictly items associated with short-term rental. So just please keep that in mind. Thank you. Jennifer, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you. Good evening. I just want to...

30:06 say that I feel like a sunset of seven years would be really premature, five years premature. As it's been pointed out, we've had an affordable local housing shortage for decades, and it's only gotten much worse. I think we could look to our peer resorts and see that some of them, such as Aspen, have had affordable housing programs.

30:35 You know, since the 70s, and they have, you know, chronic issues with housing their locals still today. It's not something that I don't think we're going to solve in five years or at the parcel alone.

30:53 I wish we could say with confidence we could do that, but I don't think we've seen historically that that's proven to play out in resort communities. No matter how many millions and eventually billions we throw at this, I think it's just going to be an uphill battle in perpetuity given our land challenges, private land development challenges and lack thereof. So I just, I would.

31:21 Suggest that we do not have a sunset on it because I don't think that's how it's going to work. Thanks. Thanks, Jennifer. That is all. That's it? Okay. So to bring it back to the group, I would like to make a motion and that would be to bring forward to the council two different options, the 1.5% short-term rental tax.

31:52 And being obviously a ballot measure and also and or, actually or, one or the other, not both, or a 2% increase in TOT with at this point, since the council has the discretion, no sunset. That would be my motion that we put into our packet for the council. Do we want to consider a 1% to 2% TOT increase?

32:24 Give them the option, or do we want to simply recommend a 2% increase? I think we could say up to 2%. I could amend that up to 2%. Would that be reasonable? And also, so up to 1.5% on short-term rentals, homeowners tax, and up to 2% on TOT. Reasonable? That's an or, right? One or the other? Yeah. I'll second it. Any more discussion on that?

32:56 More comments? Okay, Jamie, can we have a roll call, please? Committee Member Avery? Yes. Committee Member Bubzer? Yes. Committee Member Harper? Yes. Committee Member Kellogg? Yes. Committee Member Rice? Yes. Vice Chair Fleming? Yes. Chair Morris? Yes. Thank you. Okay, next item is subsidy options. Now, we have gone through, I believe, we went through the first one, the carrots and sticks.

33:27 Long-term rental subsidy option, and I believe we voted and approved that last meeting, unless I'm incorrect. So I just don't want to go back over things that we've already discussed and approved. I think we discussed on it with support, I think the main motion last time, I have to go back and look, but it was more focused on the down payment assistance program with the statement that we liked the rental program, but I don't know if it was in the same motion.

33:55 There's three of them, different ones here that we can look at. Right, right. Yeah, again, in the interest of time, I mean, I think all of these are worthy. They're similar. They're worthy programs. I think, again, it's good to give options to the council of different things that they can look at. They all more or less accomplish the same thing, which is trying to get more long-term rental available. I'm not sure.

34:24 Again, I think the first one, is there any question on that first item that we went over? That was more related to down payment assistance as well. I think we all said we liked that program in theory, in principle. Any discussion on that? Okay.

34:44 The second item. Excuse me, Chair Morris, just so I'm clear. I thought we were on 3-2. You said down payment, and you mean rental. Yeah, well, Dan had mentioned down payment. Was that one tied to? Yeah, last time we had those together into discussion. Right now, the only thing before you on the subsidies for rentals, one would be doing a longer-term subsidy, looking to try to get a 5-year, a 10-year, get longer-term commitments for folks to do rentals, which is kind of...

35:11 It's a broader look in terms of longer-term rentals. I think the second one, we didn't have a lot of discussion last time. It was in your packet. The information was there. That's where it's just, hey, what type of a subsidy can you provide to somebody? There's some examples in there, like 20 grand a year, but you have to max your cap your rent at a dollar amount here is 2,500. That could all be set based on size of units or number of people in the house and those types of elements for that.

35:39 That was in the packet last time. We didn't spend a lot of time on it. We ran out. The third one that's listed is really the one that came up at the chamber after our last meeting with the placemates program, which is very similar to the second one, if you will, where here's a subsidy for people to do rental, and there's a private company that takes on the marketing, working of that nature. The PowerPoint they went through was provided in your packet, so looking at that.

36:09 So they're similar in nature. One just looks, trying to focus on a longer-term component. The other two are more short-term. They can go longer-term depending on what people want to do. But I would say number two and number three are pretty much quasi-identical in terms of how do we subsidize somebody to step in and rent out their units either on a, I think it's up to six months or up to 11 months or multiple years if you want. So it's up to the folks for a year. And then that would...

36:37 All of these will need some more programming work and processing going through what does it look like, what are the limits. The placemate one has, again, the information based off the trucking program. They've done it in a few other places, I think with similar type restrictions. So all that is out there in terms of those three. You would have more work in terms of the details that go into that. And again, all this kind of ties back to the front-end one in terms of how much funding do you have will determine how successful some of these might be.

37:06 John, if I could add a few things. Yeah, sure, go ahead. So one of the main items with any of these government subsidy programs is a nexus to public benefit. So when Dan talked about programmatically these things are going to have some more work to be done on them, is those connections have to be clearly illustrated, right? They have to have legs to stand on and very strong.

37:29 There are minor differences in some of these things. I think in the second one, which is the one I sort of worked with you guys on a little bit and co-authored, if you will, it had that conversion from short-term to long-term. That was one aspect that's slightly different in calling that out. And while we've heard of a lot of people saying, well, it's ludicrous that that would happen, there is some subset of STR operators that would actually...

37:59 Take advantage of this. And I think what we're looking for in this particular one we called out is recognizing that this is a small component of our overall Housing Now initiatives. And so it would be very limited, right? 50 units is a target for the year. And in that process, that's the full scope of what we would be trying to do. Achieving 50 units would be seen as great success in that particular type of program.

38:27 But income limits would definitely come into play. That's what the public benefit elements are going to have to be worked through. They are slightly different. But again, we're looking at multifaceted tools. We're looking at a toolbox full of options for things that may work for an individual operator to make this type of a choice. So I think that's just some additional comments I wanted to frame on. Is there, I guess I'll ask the group, is there any

38:57 Are there, is there, are there any of these three that are absolutely a no-go for anybody? Again, I like the idea of giving the council options of things to look at. These are, again, yeah, there's lots of work to be done afterwards. This is not baked by any means. But, you know, there's some really good things in here. And, again, one of the things that we don't know is we don't know exactly how many

39:26 How many folks that are not renting their place at all or are not, that are renting short-term and might be enticed to rent long-term? We don't know how many of them are out there and we don't know what the amount is that would entice them to move over or to open their homes. So there are some unknowns there and so there's a lot that needs to be played with as far as how these programs would work. But do we have a basic consensus on these three different versions of programs are good to

39:54 to go ahead and send over to the council. I feel like we've heard from people, the general public, STR owners, that are saying we need some sort of help for renters and not just ownership programs. So I think, you know, presenting the council with some ideas to address that is a good idea. So it looks like we have, I don't think we necessarily need to vote, looks like we have nodding head consensus. Oh, I'm so sorry. Yes.

40:26 Going through this. All right, so any public comment, again, specifically on the subsidy programs that we have discussed? Any public comment from the audience? Hi, my name is Brian Hughes. I'm curious, are you looking into part-time owners? Do you have a number? So I'm the HOA president for Chateau de Montaigne, and I know many of the homeowners there are part-time, so they're not going to do a long-term rental.

40:59 So it seems like there's no discussion on what's going to happen for people who buy property. This is a resort town, live here a few months out of the year. I live here six months out of the year. But I'm not going to do a long-term rental. And nobody is going to come in and rent my home for three or four months or six months that I'm not here. So I'm curious, how is this recommendation taking into account?

41:26 The fact that there's a good portion and what is the number of homeowners in the short-term rental program that are not LLCs? So that's typically who people buy these properties just to rent them out short-term. They're LLCs. And is there any consideration for banning LLCs instead of individual homeowners? Thank you. Thank you. I can address two of the questions.

41:57 We've done some analysis on ownership but not that level of detail across that. I know in other places and even some of the discussions we've looked at, there is options to do a shorter term lease. People currently do that today. They'll do a five-month or six-month or three-month winter for people coming in to work before the season. We have that request at times in the summer, a little bit less there, but where people are looking for that.

42:24 Peak season of work where they might only be in town for four or five months or less. And that is an option. I know the Placemate Program actually makes a differential on how they would assist people with a shorter-term lease versus a longer-term lease. So that's definitely an option that can be presented, and those who wish to take advantage of that could. We've had a few people, different reasons for this, who actually...

42:48 Have rented a place or owned a place, and they'll rent it out long-term, but they want you to be gone on your own vacation for a couple weeks out of the year when they come in and play in Mammoth. So that's just a coordination between the person leasing the unit and the owner. They work that out on their own. That's actually a couple different places we're aware of have done that. So there's some options to look at that. We haven't looked at restricting it based on ownership, whether it's an individual or an LLC at that point.

43:14 But there is a variety of programs that are out there already in terms of some of the stuff we've seen that are both short-term, long-term, medium-term, if you will. Probably there's been less or been more pushback on long-term over 12 months just because of renter laws in California. That's been a little bit of an issue, but we haven't seen substantial issues with that here in town, but it does come up. Just so I may add as well,

43:41 So the 50 units that we're talking about, that's 1.4% of the active STRs. So while that particular individual didn't have necessarily the ability to rent because they didn't utilize the property, there is some small portion that don't, and that would be an option. Any of these are options available to people. It's not a saying, hey, you're going to not be able to rent your property short-term. You'll have to do something like this. It is you have the option to engage with a program like this.

44:09 If it fits your particular situation. Any more comments from the audience? Jamie? No, there's none on that. Okay, great. All right, so with that, any more discussion? It seems like we have consensus from our committee on this. Do you guys feel like we need a vote or we're good on this? See nodding heads, yes? Okay, great. All right.

44:37 Then we will move forward. The next item on here was the Home Down Payment Assistance Program. We went over this in detail at the last meeting. Unless there are any changes or discussion from the group. Robert, Dan, was there anything that changed on this since our last meeting? No, the presentation, we didn't repeat everything we had put in the packet last time. It's generally the same element that's there.

45:06 We had a couple of questions. This might have been more email questions in terms of do we actually think there's a demand for this? And one of the elements we see in the Towns Bridge Program, we do see that where we're actually buying units. And then we, instead of doing a down payment and leaving the price up, we actually reduce the price and sell it with the deed restriction on it so it stays affordable over time. I think we have nine units in the program. Currently, five of those, if I got this right, Nolan, five have been sold, four in process or different.

45:35 One's being repaired, and I think the other three are actively being marketed, if you will, or being looked at as an element back to somebody in that 150% or under AMI levels, area median income levels. So trying to target that missing middle and making it a permanent program. This one looks a little different in terms of dollars assisting somebody to buy, and then there's a shared appreciation and a return of the dollars back to those dollars in.

46:00 Come back into the program. Same thing with the bridge program. When we sell a unit, we take a loss, but those dollars go back into the program. So this is a way to recycle some of the money that we do have out there that we would generate for this. Again, in the short term, not a lot here just because of the cost potentials, but again, if you have a steady funding source, this program could out there. And again, this would be ultimately, it's a willing seller, a willing buyer market. So it's...

46:29 If it's out there, great, you have that. If it can work out and they can make the payment, whatever's left, great, that works. If they don't have a buyer that qualifies for that, there's some other restrictions you'd put on it, and we'd have to do some public benefit-level stuff to make that work. And we talk about the public benefit for folks who asked. Rob brought that up. As we look at using government funds, we have to show a public benefit, a public good. And it can't just be a gift of money to a private individual or a company. It's a pure gift that becomes illegal.

46:57 So we work through those types of issues as we define the programs. All right. Any other comments from the committee regarding this? And do we have any public comment? I have a question. Oh, I'm sure. That's okay. So I see here it says shared appreciation and value. Have we looked at what happens if the housing market crashes? You know what I imagine? Yeah, there's a...

47:26 Good question in terms of what happens when there's no appreciation goes negative. Agencies have done it two ways. One is, depending what the banks end up doing, if someone's losing that half of it, because there's a lot of equity day one because of the assistance. So there's less concern over probably the bank calling a note, although that could happen. A couple agencies have done it two ways. One has been outside of the bank gets paid first.

47:52 The down payment assistant gets paid next, and then if there's anything left, the homeowner gets that. Others have shared equally in the loss as well as in the gain. So it would be a question of how we want to structure the program in terms of what that would look like. But again, the more aggressive ones, or at least a few I've looked at, is bank gets paid first. Sorry, that's good. Everything else will be under that. The down payment money comes back next.

48:20 And if there's additional dollars available, then the owner would end up with a remainder. Because I just worry if we do this, you know, 2008 crash, I know we lost a lot of deed-restricted units. Right. And the recommendation on this didn't have a hard deed-restriction on it. A minimum would need to have, like, a workforce-related one. But if the value's down, I think what happened to the other ones, too, the value's going down there was if you have up to, like, a 49% cash-in.

48:49 It's hard for that to drop below those values again unless we really, really tank. Probably have bigger issues at that point. Thank you. Any other comments from the committee? Do we have any public comment on this particular item? Before we vote, so you'll take public comment and then, but I just want to ask for clarification from the committee.

49:18 We're putting a lot of proposals. We can't possibly afford them all. Could we get some input on prioritization so that council has some, you know, input? Sure. Yeah, I think it's a good point, Chris, if we want to just kind of work through all these and we have that. If you want to come back after each one, we're done with the list of four or five or six, whatever it is. You could come back and say, by our choice, we would look at one, two, three, four, five from a priority standpoint.

49:48 And as we noted, they're all going to be subject to available funding at this point that we're talking about. So does that help? That's great. Thank you. That sounds like a great idea. Yeah, go ahead, Ted. Sure. So in the last round of housing programs and the participation, the people who were in those programs were responsible for all their, they took the losses. I had some friends who lost a significant amount of money. Thanks, Ted. Any other comment from the?

50:23 From the room, Jamie. Sarah, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Can you guys hear me? Yes. Yes. All right, sorry. Hi, this is Sarah. Apologies, can't be there tonight. I'm also out of breath because I'm trying at the same time to get my son ready for hockey practice. So apologies in advance. That's so rude. But just, I'm sorry, I missed the public comment on the last agenda item. I wasn't quick enough on my phone. I just had a couple of kind of questions, comments, things to maybe consider for the...

51:00 Long-term rental assistance program. My comment is the criteria for the rental tenant, do they have to have lived in Mammoth for a certain period of time? Is it maybe a, I don't know, a grace period so people can't show up to town and instantly get a place to live while people have been here years waiting? Is there a...

51:27 A criteria that they have to live in Mammoth full-time, or is this open to seasonal workers? Again, is there going to be some sort of a prioritization to house local full-time residents versus seasonal workers? A secured local job at states work in the region, again, could be a little bit vague. I assume that construction workers, transient visitors could apply for these units, so we just want to make sure there's some sort of reward program in place without identifying a tenant.

51:57 If I sign up a property for a summer lease but rent it in the winter, my question would be, do I still pay the license fee? Do I still pay the potential tax on gross receipts? Or do you sort of get a pass on that fee? The $2,500 rent cap, I totally understand the methodology of getting there. I'm just curious, though, that if there are some larger homes.

52:23 That would be above that. Kind of what was that based on? Is it square footage? If there are some four-bedroom large homes that are open to this program, but the $2,500 is a little bit low. If you do have four bedrooms, then maybe that would be taken into consideration. And then just a question about enforcing sort of occupancy limits, property safety requirements, so that the same quality of life ordinance is available to these long-term rental tenants, just like it is the short-term visitors.

52:52 Thanks so much. That's my comments. I apologize for jumping in at the wrong section. Thanks, Sarah. Jamie, anyone else? That's it. Okay. I believe we had consensus on this. Do we feel that we need a vote? Are we good on this program? The down payment program? Heads nodding. We're good? Okay. Great. Very well.

53:18 Okay, the next one is certified properties. Again, we have approved this in principle. Robin, are there any new items on here that need to be discussed? The only thing I'd like to talk a little bit about is the process by which this is implemented. And there are some things to work out, you know, final bits. But certified properties was, this subsection was really designed to inform changes that need to be made to the municipal code.

53:46 In certain areas, I focused on safety area, which included inspections, penalties, and then fees. So there are no changes to how this has been presented. This was presented back in the 11th of January, and that was agreed to. We get questions often about whether or not the lifting of the moratorium. It's sort of tied to the update of the municipal code associated with certified properties.

54:14 With this program, you know, council says yes, proceed with this. We are already preparing municipal code updates to bring forward on the 21st of February, and that would be considered the first reading of those code changes. And any municipal code, which is the laws that govern our activities, take a specific process. So you have the first reading, you have a second reading 15 days later, which is another presentation as council.

54:42 It's a public hearing. No? Okay. So it's not a public hearing, but it's a presentation to council where public comment can be accepted. And then after that final second reading, council adoption, there's a 30-day waiting period before it becomes effective. Best case scenario, what we're looking at, a first reading of the 21st of February. That would, based on timing, you have to have 15 days between meetings and so forth.

55:11 The second reading would occur the second meeting of March, and then 30 days after that, so roughly April 22nd. If council proceeds with this, it would be our recommendation to concurrently run with a reversal of moratorium, which is the same three-step process. And so we would look for the moratorium lifting to have an option of occurring along that same time frame. Okay, so that's just some...

55:40 Some logistical components, if you will, of what that certified properties program means. Once implementation occurs, then sort of everyone, both current STR operators and future prospective STR operators, operate under these same set of laws and procedures. So that does not change. We are working on our programs by which to collect the data. As you know, certified properties is going to be very data-driven. It collects.

56:08 Information on each unit, which we don't collect today with our tax returns, it's by operator, and there can be a multitude of units per operator. So we're going to collect some more data on that. So there's some timing with the fees, probably the year one, proration of that, probably the first full tax period after adoption would be the time when we start.

56:33 Requesting that information in, there's a whole lot of onboarding that we have to do with the owners. So there's a bit of thing that has to happen with a lot of this, as any of these things are some components. So likely, you know, first, if we hit that April deadline, likely first data collection would be for May's transactions, which would be due on June 30th. So a lot of work to be done, but I just wanted to kind of clarify the process by which we do that and what really it means to do this.

57:03 Could you just repeat the date of when, if everything flows through, as you mentioned, what's the date that it would be lifted? Yeah, so the second reading would occur the second meeting of March. Oh, that's March 13th. Which, let me just get the exact. Second reading. Oh, no, it's the 20th. 21st, yeah. And so, it's actually the 20th.

57:28 of March would be the second reading, and so 30 days after that would mean it could take effect on the 20th of April. Thanks for the, I just missed that 20th of April, thanks. 30th is a Wednesday, and for March, or for April, I'm sorry, that's a Saturday, Monday the 22nd. Okay. That's what was in the staff report was the 22nd, so that Monday.

58:02 And I'll say the process of that read, we'd run the two ordinances together. Ideally, this would go to council again on the 7th as a recommendation. So yes, proceed. Comes on the 21st as an ordinance, first reading, second reading, and then the 30 days. And so that would be that April 22nd when that would be the recommendation for the ending of the board. So you can launch the moratorium immediately, but then it takes a very long process to lift it. Yeah, because you put it in as a, you put it in as a,

58:32 Ordinance, is it an urgency ordinance? But to remove it, the regular process for the ordinance has to be followed. We went through that a week ago as a town attorney working through this with him on the process. Plus, what you don't want to do is put something, if you have this ordinance going into effect and you just lifted the moratorium in front of it, you would have a whole group of people coming in under one set of rules. That would change literally 45 days later.

59:02 And say, great, now come back in and go through it again. So you'd want everybody with the same rules, not that weird gap in the middle, if you will. So for new applicants. Any more discussion from the group on this? I know we've approved it in principle, and Rob gave us the update sort of on the timing and stuff. Great. Any public comment on the certified properties program? Anyone in the audience? Jamie?

59:32 Sure. Go ahead, Terry. Thank you. Terry Stellick. A couple questions kind of clarifying some things. So if you've already had a unit inspected, is that inspection still good if it was within the last one year, two years, three years? And then I realize that we're going to have to have a lot of inspections. Is there going to be a grace period for when this goes into place?

1:00:05 That everything has to be inspected and in place by such and such time, because you only have a limited amount of inspectors, and you're going to have a whole town that's going to have to go through this whole process that you're looking at. Yeah, if I can address that, there's roughly 990 properties that would need to be inspected on an annual basis. We currently, properties should be inspected every three years. We're extending it out a year.

1:00:32 We would focus on two things. We do have a subset of properties that were grandfathered in originally and never inspected, so they would be the very first that we would start with, as well as through the normal course of onboarding new properties, those would be inspected. So we would kind of work through that process in such a way that the ones that were most recently inspected would probably be in the four-year time frame, so we extend that out just to make the most sense and get the shortest amount of time.

1:01:02 between inspections that's most appropriate. Any other comments? Jamie, anyone? Yeah. Jan, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, Jan Henry again.

1:01:16 I just had one question regarding the paragraph with the emergency contact. It says, the emergency contact would either need to be a business in town providing 24-hour contract services, licensed as such within the town of Mammoth Lakes, a property management company that provides those services, or an owner who lives within 60 minutes of town. Currently, my cleaner...

1:01:40 Who is a resident of Mammoth Lakes and is a license through the town is my 24-hour contact. It looks like that wouldn't be allowed. Is that correct? So we have not had good success as a town with those types of relationships for 24-hour contact. So that's why we added those elements about being a business or being the owner of the property.

1:02:11 That would specifically do that. If your property, if your cleaner wanted to register with a town as a 24-hour business, then they would certainly be able to do that. But under the capacity of a cleaner to be designated also as 24-hour contact would not work under this new program. Wow. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Jamie? Catherine, please unmute yourself and give your comments. My name is your task force for taking this on. I know it's a thankful...

1:02:50 So I appreciate all of these things that you have to go through. On this Certified Properties Program, I'm wondering if you need to spend the number of years between inspections because if it's 990 units per year, that is going to be three inspections a day and that's if everything is going right.

1:03:21 And I just think that you're setting yourself up for some chaos here and might be prudent to expand the inspection period to five years or even longer. That's all I have to say on this issue. Thank you. Thank you. That's it. That's it. All right. So we have already voted on the certified properties. We're good there. And second to last on our...

1:03:52 Our agenda here is the zoning, and just to be clear on the zoning, the recommendation that we had was to direct the Planning and Economic Development Commission to do a thorough assessment of the existing zoning to determine whether a change is appropriate, and at the bottom, the report, it also says at this time, this is a low-priority work program item that will be further analyzed and considered at a later date.

1:04:22 So this is, I believe we've kind of discussed this and said this is definitely low on our list of things that need to be addressed at this point. And we have voted on this in theory. So any more discussion from the group on zoning? No? Okay. Do we have public comment regarding the zoning? Yes, go ahead. Hi, Rose Perez-Jessen again.

1:04:54 I am president of Villa de los Pinos in your previously targeted subregion of the RMF2 zone. I'm just curious, when you say you're making it a low priority, are you still going to make it as a recommendation to the town to consider it, sending it over to this other committee or commission to review it, or what are you doing? Because

1:05:19 And I'm asking basically that you remove it altogether like you did your sticks and carrots because while it continues to be a pending item, it affects our property values and, you know, basically clouds our titles. So I would ask that you remove it completely. Thank you. Thank you. Any other comments from the gallery? Terry again.

1:05:48 I did make this comment before, and it's just one of those things. As long as rezoning is out there and it's on the table in any manner, whether it's low-hanging fruit, whether it's being passed off to another person, it's still out there. I will tell you there's been comments out in the universe here in Mammoth that 50% of the short-term rental certificates are going to be taken away. It's just one of those things that...

1:06:17 It needs to be clear, it needs to be precise, and it should not be something that lingers forever. And another comment that I would like to make, and it kind of goes with zoning, kind of goes with your financing and everything else, is I don't know that there's any property in this town that should be taken off the table for any type of subsidy or any type of down payment assistance or anything else. We need housing.

1:06:43 So there's a lot of homes that are out here that have been owned by people for many, many years. They might be interested in putting somebody in there. There shouldn't be any property anywhere in town, we're four and a half square miles, that's taken off the table if it fits within your qualifications of any type of assistance. Thank you, Jerry. That's Brian again. I also wanted to bring up the unintended consequences of a lot of this stuff.

1:07:17 I'm sure maybe many of you have heard about Palm Springs, and they've moved forward with very similar ordinances, rezoning, and the property values have crashed. And so we're a resort town again, and whether or not you can take off the zoning, remove it from the agenda item since it's such a low priority, or we just don't talk about it, I think it's important to understand if the property values go down here,

1:07:47 The town is going to be doomed. So, thank you. And it is what I think the lady Sherry said. We should be building housing, not ice rinks, right? Like, we should be building housing. So, thank you. Thank you. Anyone else in the audience? Jamie, anyone online? Jan, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, Jan Henry again. I just wanted, and I made this request before, I am right on the wrong side of Lake Mary Road.

1:08:19 People in summer and fall have commented multiple times how great our location is because we're right on the bike path. We're a half-mile walk to the village. We're actually closer to Eagle Lodge than many of those properties are that are on the other side of Lake Mary are to Canyon. And I just think that that area on Tarryville Lane should be reconsidered if the zoning changes were going to go forward. Thank you. Thank you.

1:08:49 That's it. All right. Any more discussion from the group regarding zoning as far as we've discussed it and as far as our recommendations? No? All right. Go ahead. I was going to say, John, before we do have the final BAE report, the analysis economic report done, we weren't planning to spend a whole lot of time walking through that. But prior to doing that, as mentioned earlier, if you want to walk back through...

1:09:21 The various recommendations and do any sort of prioritization. That would be helpful as we prepare information to go to council. I guess what I would ask, too, is kind of the two things together because obviously there's some interesting summary stuff in the report. We can speak to that now if you want. Yeah, I guess because whether it shifts any recommendations, it really doesn't in my mind, but I don't know, but I don't want to speak for the rest of the group.

1:09:46 Whether their summary analysis changes anybody's mind about prioritization of anything. Real quick, I'll just mention the author is on the Zoom call, Aaron Hussain, so he can speak to items if you have questions. I wasn't planning to walk through a bunch of the recommendations, assuming you've had a chance to look at it. It didn't change dramatically from the last one, but there was some. Feel free to ask questions or comments, I think would be good.

1:10:16 What I would say personally after reading through it is I was glad to see that a lot of the recommendations aligned with what we had talked about. There weren't a lot of things that were outside the scope of – there were some things that were, but there weren't a lot of things relating to STRs that I felt were really very different from what we had come up with as far as some of the things we talked about. So is there anything in the summary report that anyone feels should –

1:10:47 Be brought forward as a change or a priority or anything. Really, it's, I mean, I was looking specifically at pages 51 through 56, which is the recommendations portion. And I, you know, I agree with most of what's in there. I didn't see anything that really jumped out at me that was very, very different from what we had considered and talked about. So I'd open that up for comments from anybody if they have it. Sorry, yeah, go ahead. I'm sorry, I'm just trying to.

1:11:20 Find the page so I could quote it exactly. Well, the thing that was interesting to me was the 90-day rental recommendations. I thought that was rather interesting and something that we should look at as a town. I guess I haven't been able to look through this in depth since yesterday. But the thing that really struck me was similar communities. I feel like we...

1:11:51 Some people in this town have been unwilling to discuss caps. I feel that it's hard to have an honest conversation about it. And then the city of Santa Cruz and the town of Truckee have relatively straightforward caps, totaling 250 STRs in Santa Cruz, approximately 1% of the city's housing stock, and 1,255 STRs in Truckee, approximately 7% of the town's housing stock.

1:12:21 That really jumped out to me because on page 24, Mammoth, we're at 35.9% of our housing stock and we are not willing as a community to discuss, hey, should we do caps? What can we do? This is a crisis. What can we do? So that, it really, really just jumped out at me and it kind of hurt actually. So that was my feeling. Would you consider

1:12:50 Taking baby steps into this, so raising the taxes, you know, see, maybe, you know, implement these programs right here and see how that goes before throwing out the term caps. I mean, I guess, I mean, ultimately, it's not up to me, right, the council, I'm on the council, I'm one of five voices on there, but I just really felt that having a moratorium, this was an opportunity. So that's what I'm really struggling with, and we do have a cap, and it's called Measure Z.

1:14:45 So I just feel like we need to take baby steps, get some income in, hire a placemate, bring it in-house, whatever we're going to do, but put some roofs over some locals' heads and come back in a year, year and a half, and then see if that works and if we should explore CAPS. Would you put another moratorium in place to discuss CAPS in a year and a half? If I'm on council, no. But I'd have to recuse myself, I suppose. Other comments? Sure. Well, actually...

1:15:19 Yeah, let's go from the group first and then we'll do public comment. Anybody else have? Yeah, I do just want to say that I really wish that this report had come out when this committee started because we're out of time, right? I mean, this is our last meeting, but I would be remiss not to point out at the very beginning there's been a lot of talk about the fact that short-term rentals do not affect the housing market, but this study did find that according to the literature, STRs impact the cost for...

1:15:48 of for sale housing by providing a revenue stream that potential investors and second home buyers can rely on to cover at least a portion of their carrying costs. This not only increases what many potential buyers are willing to pay to purchase a housing unit to use as an STR, but also increases the pool of potential buyers by increasing purchasing power.

1:16:08 In this way, STRs facilitate the consumption of housing resources by the second home market and the tourism industry in what is sometimes called the hotelization of the housing stock. STRs then influence the rental housing market via a cumulative reduction in the available supply of rental housing. We're not trying to punish short-term rental owners here. It's just, I mean, this says right here that short-term rentals affect

1:16:37 The local housing market, and it's affecting our local community, and we have to look out for our local community. So, I don't think there's a whole lot more that this committee can do than what we have right in front of us, but I hear you, and I think it's important to point this out. I would agree with those comments, and I would say that, you know, personally, the way I feel about it is that I think we've gone far too long without really implementing other housing programs.

1:17:08 Which we're asking to put forward now. And I agree that I think that if we start moving into a direction where we're really seeing a lot more, a higher percentage of our properties that are now becoming in the short-term rental market, then that could potentially, you know, that could signal some things and we may need to pause. But looking at the study and looking at the increase over the last five years at a relatively small, relatively,

1:17:37 Small percentage of about 3% per year growth. To me, that doesn't signal that we have a monstrous problem. Could we have a run? Sure, we could. We might. We'll have to see what happens there. But at any rate, any other comments from anyone else on the committee? No? Okay. Jason? So earlier we discussed what, I guess, defined what success was out of the rentals, right?

1:18:06 And also the home ownership. So if we're not successful in, say, three years, maybe that is something we should recommend as pulling that trigger, but having that on a recommendation. So I do agree with having the discussion, but I think that we do have other options right now that we're recommending. And I like those options, but I think that we should have that discussion.

1:18:32 I agree, and I think that the section that we had that were sort of the sticks, that we just said these are good recommendations, but prioritization as far as let's get some of these pros, get a funding mechanism, let's try some of these programs, and if they're not successful, then the sticks are going to be necessary. I mean, that is true, but I feel like we should try the other route first and see if it works. Any other comments from the group? Chris, go ahead.

1:19:02 You know, I just would say to the entire community, and I really want to thank all of you for your participation because this isn't easy, and so I'm grateful to the members of the committee. I want to say to the community that we have worked really hard, we've listened, we've come to recommendations. There will be likely some kind of revenue measure in order to support our housing going forward, and if the community can't come together and back that,

1:19:32 Then we're going to be back. So I really hope each of you who participated in this will full-heartedly support or wholeheartedly support whatever council decides to go forward with. And you'll talk to your friends and family because that's the only way we move forward as a community. And thanks again. All right. Public comment. Thanks for waiting.

1:20:04 Again, Rose Perez-Jessen, and I am a lawyer, so I spent time reading the BAE report on short-term rentals, and I found areas that basically said that it was mainly focused on impacts within major urban tourist markets, and thus it doesn't really specifically apply to Mammoth. According to that report, 59% of the town's housing market is for seasonal and occasional use second homes. Per that report,

1:20:33 And I've submitted written comments, and I've cited the pages that these quotes are on. Quote, there's no specific mention of the impact of STRs in markets dominated by large numbers of second homes, though this topic is addressed in the report's findings. Those findings are based on six studies on housing markets in Placer, Mariposa, Truckee, San Luis Obispo, and San Bernardino County.

1:20:57 Those studies essentially conclude that the conversion of long-term housing to STR use does not represent a significant market driver. In fact, it was found that STRs can be used to facilitate the purchase of residential properties for second home use.

1:21:13 Leading to increased home prices and an expanded pool of potential second-home buyers. And that STRs are not the primary driver of housing availability and pricing issues in those communities. And that the STR industry is not taking units out of full-time occupancy. The studies also clearly acknowledge the importance of tourism spending to the economic and fiscal health of many communities.

1:21:39 STRs can offer a different consumer experience compared to traditional hotels, and we're notably more resilient to the impacts of COVID-19 pandemic compared to traditional hotels. So please take a look at the report as a whole and my comments for those specific quotes. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anyone else in the audience? Absolutely.

1:22:10 Since that, I guess I just disagree with you in that Measure Z is a cap. I don't think of Measure Z as a cap, and I don't think that residential single-family homes have become more affordable because of Measure Z. So I don't think that, I mean, say we have 300 locals in the downtown area, you know, I just, to me, Measure Z, if it is a cap, I don't think it's been successful as a cap since we're still scrambling for housing.

1:22:40 So I just wanted to clarify that. Yeah, I think the reason why I bring it up a lot is because everyone likes to compare us to other peer resort communities that were overrun with Airbnbs in every single property across town, and we just have not had that issue. So I just, but I agree. I think that.

1:22:56 Listen, if we do this and we move forward for three years and we bring in some extra money and we still have the same problem in three years, and Chris is right, then we need to circle back around and revisit caps. But I think it's a very drastic measure to do without even implementing any of this. Jamie, any comments? I just wanted to wrap up my comments with saying, so I think that, you know, this is a little outside the committee's purpose, which was STR zoning, but I think the town itself,

1:23:34 Needs to rethink its approach to public housing and workforce housing. So a good example is, I just brought up the ice rink, $14 million. So it costs about $325 per square foot to build here, according to Mammoth Lakes Realty, Resort Realty. You think it's up to $400? Oh, okay. Still, that would have easily have built on the order of about 25 housing units.

1:24:03 So, you know, it's important for us to think about our spending as a town. So we're, you know, our revenues is TOT, right? I mean, we don't have a diversified economy, which is unfortunate, right? So with that, we should be rethinking of our spending, our town budget, and focusing those funds into building workforce housing. I've heard other comments here in previous meetings.

1:24:32 About, you know, the development, you know, getting the hotels, this new hotel that's being built to help work towards public housing, right? And when I say public housing, I mean workforce housing, right? Something that people can afford, you know, a 900 square foot two bedroom, you know, complex, right? Where people can still have a nice life, have a nice place to live, and it's, you know, we can be building towards that instead of...

1:24:58 expanding our tourism and expanding stuff like an ice rink that we don't really need. So thank you very much for your time. Thank you. Excuse me real quick, John. If I could respond to that just briefly because we've heard this before in terms of the dollars there. A lot of the funding that went into the ice rink would be illegal to spend on housing. So a lot of those dollars would not be utilized for housing. A lot of it was restricted money.

1:25:24 By tax measures and other elements that restrict how we can spend those dollars. So that, I just want to note that, because I think we hear that in reports, putting 15, 16 million into an ice rink, great. Well over half of that would be restricted for those types of purposes and would be illegal to spend on housing. So when we look at the budget, when we look at elements that way, we do make those distinctions. And as noted before, it's higher than us. Now the last five years, from 17, 18 through 22, 23,

1:25:54 The town did put about $30 million into housing. A lot of different programs, different elements, different funding, short-term, long-term support, especially through the pandemic and through the snowstorm we went through before. So those priorities on housing and funding has been dramatic and substantial, and that's one reason you see the current projects coming out of the ground that are coming out today is because the town has put dollars in there that are out of general fund dollars, if you will, or unrestricted dollars.

1:26:23 As well as other grants that have been put into housing as well. Thank you. Thanks, Dan. Jamie, real quick, just again, we're looking at comments that are specific to the BAE report right now, not general, so if we could limit it to that right now, we appreciate it. Mammoth Lakes Housing, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Oh, people have lowered their hands since you've said that. Veronica, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, Mike.

1:26:56 Hello? Can you hear me? Hi. I hold my master's degree from the UCLA Graduate School of Public Affairs, which includes a comprehensive program and study in urban planning. And I have a single point to make in that on the topic of caps on short-term rentals, so some have raised an issue of decreased property value.

1:27:23 with caps, which is actually true. However, caps on short-term rentals lead to decreased housing prices, which equal more affordability for locals who are trying to live in the community, which appears to be the point, which is an argument that I haven't heard in the three meetings that I've attended, so I do want to make that point.

1:27:53 That caps could potentially be a productive way with a grandfathered approach, not revoking any current short-term licenses, but potentially capping new short-term licenses to allow housing prices to decline slightly to give a more affordable edge for locals to purchase. That is all. Thank you. Thank you. Ann, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

1:28:23 Yes, thank you. Thanks again. And regarding the BANU report, and it goes straight with what the comment from the last person before the last one, understanding STR and approaching from existing housing. However, what would be the plan? And Cynthia, thank you for bringing it up. You know, let's try what we're trying, and then in three years, let's see what we got.

1:28:49 However, what will we do between now and three years from now to actually create more housing? Taking from one to house the other, however novel, probably not going to work. And will we be in the same position three years from now? So what is really the plan based on that BAE report? I didn't see anything that says at the end of the day, what are we doing to provide more housing?

1:29:19 Meaning by that, build it. If we cannot take the ice rink money, what tax measure are we passing that actually is going to provide dollars toward new housing? Thank you. Thank you. That's it. That's it. So, before we go to public comment on items not on the agenda, before we go there, briefly, can, Rob or Dan, can you give us a...

1:29:55 Two or three minutes, sorry. A synopsis of what this, actually, I'm sorry. We should go back to our prioritizations. We did not talk about that. So really, do we have, we really should have this in a priority to the council of what is, what's burning? You know, how do we want to approach this? I would submit that the number one issue,

1:30:24 At least on my hit parade would be a funding mechanism for short-term. We need short-term, excuse me, we need long-term housing. We need long-term rentals. We do need a blend of rentals and a buyer assistance program. I agree with that. But we don't know exactly what that ratio is right now. So my, personally, I feel like we should, we should be pushing the long-term rental aspect, the rental subsidy aspect.

1:30:47 For that. And then looking at where the response is and how many folks do we need to house? How many people are interested in moving here? How many people can we house? And then looking at, you know, obviously we'll have to look at how many of those people who are looking to purchase and can qualify and all those other things. But I think the ratio is kind of here. So I would say that number one priority would be to have a ballot measure.

1:31:12 For one of these options to raise some funds so that we can start a long-term subsidy program for housing. Does that seem reasonable as number one on the hit parade? And if anybody disagrees, chime in. I mean, I'm just one person. Yeah, if I can on this, I think from a practical standpoint where we're at with the moratorium and stuff, the certified program would probably be the number one item. Absolutely, yes.

1:31:41 Ordinance going to get that implemented so we can move that forward. For some reason I thought that was a given. Well, I just focus on these other things is, you know, we've got to get this other piece done. So I just want to clarify that from my own notes. I did pull that one up and just as a separate item almost and then started the one, two, three, four outside of that. But I just want to make it clear that that will take a little, that'll take some work and some time to get that ready to go. And the recommendations to council, all these would go at the same on the 7th.

1:32:09 We'll walk through whatever the priority is here. But that one really needs to get moving forward so we can work it in tandem with lifting the mortgage. Anybody have an issue with that? I agree 100%. Sorry, I thought I figured that was just fixed. I just want to make, yeah. All right, so number one being certified properties, number two being a funding mechanism for mostly long-term rentals and looking at how that interfaces with long-term and housing. Okay.

1:32:40 You're calling those out separate. One is rental, one is ownership. So there are two separate items there. So I want to call them equal because we're calling them out separate. Okay. If that's what I'm hearing correctly, I just want to make sure I'm hearing you correctly. Yeah, I guess what I would say is so one certified property, two, a funding mechanism, period, for all these programs. Number three would be one, looking at the options for long-term rental assistance. And then four would be the...

1:33:10 Yeah, I would just say if we're, the main thing I agree that we should get the funding going first and then if we could actually do the rental and down payment assistance kind of as a combo, like not have one ahead of the other because I do, I mean, I've talked to multiple locals in town who are really excited about the down payment assistance and like want to know when can this potentially happen and so hopefully we can do both.

1:33:37 Kind of as a merged program, because the funds that we're going to be receiving is going to be for both programs. It seems reasonable. I'd kind of go, you know, 3 and then 3.5 for the, because, again, I think, I wish I had solid numbers, but I believe that the number, the rental situation is going to be more of a, there's going to be more demand for that than the housing, at least to start. And that's a little bit of a guess, but, so.

1:34:09 And then, of course, zoning is down the road, probably number five. Does that seem reasonable to the group? Any comments or changes or reprioritization of any of that? Go ahead, Dan. Yeah. We can make recommendations if you want, but a couple things just to kind of put it in perspective, I think, working through this. One is on the, I'll start to kind of the bottom, the VAE report, we'll provide that to council also as background information, so they'll get that.

1:34:43 Thank you, Aaron, for that. Sorry. Yeah, Aaron, you're still on the call there. I'm still here. You're all very, very welcome. It's been a pleasure working with you and town staff. Thanks for having me. Thank you. Funding is definitely one of the critical things. There's some other policy questions in that. We talked about a sunset. We'll need to talk about it as a general special, those types of issues to work through that. That has a timeline. Basically, we'd have to be ready to go end of July.

1:35:11 To get on the November ballot because there's 88 days pre-election is the last date that we can get it on a ballot. So there's a timeline on that. So I just wanted to highlight that element. Does that work? And that's going to be a substantial amount of work to draft that, put it out, and get the community behind it, those elements. On the rental subsidy options, we had looked at a couple of those of looking at kind of a pilot program.

1:35:38 We do have some housing dollars currently, for example, with the placemates, probably the simplest one, because that's more of a turnkey, we can actually probably put that out as a recommendation to go. In their presentation they did for the chamber, they have $400,000 as a one-year program. Great. We can probably move the dollars around in our housing program, here's $400,000, go do that, and then see, that'll answer the question, what do we have?

1:36:04 Rental units that are interested or individual housing that's interested in putting a room, putting a unit in a short-term, long-term rental position. And that will give us some good data and say, how is that going to work? The down payment is a little more difficult on an interim just because of the dollar amounts. You're only looking at doing a couple given the available funding. And we've been focusing that more on the bridge program. So that would be a...

1:36:32 A little bit of a trade-off there, but if you get a funding source in, I would agree we need to blend them together to do that, to have those work. Then, obviously, we already mentioned the Certified Property Program, so I would kind of suggest if we want to move one of them forward and get data out of it, the one that's a private sector driven, if you will, a little more expensive probably on the admin side, but it's a way to move something forward if people want to look and see what is out there, and I would leave that up.

1:37:02 To the group here, I wanted to be a little more surgically, if you guess, on a recommendation versus here's three programs, we'll work on all of them. We'll probably do three poorly, so let's look on doing one well, I'm just being honest, just in terms of the workload that they'll put on staff. So I'm asking for feedback related to that. Sure.

1:37:24 I agree, and I think, given the presentation, not that our town can't do a great job at a lot of this, and I think there's going to be a lot of blend that's going to be needed, even with placemates, but placemates would be a program that we could get, hopefully, going prior to a vote, and it would be in place, and then dollars, hopefully, would start coming in if that vote passes.

1:37:46 That would be a, I think that would be, that would be my recommendation of these programs, at least to start, would be to get Placemates involved because they're plug and play, basically. Yeah, I agree. And, you know, the initial investment into Placemate might not be able to come from this funding mechanism. It would have to come from the general fund, I think. But I think at $400,000 to get this program up and running by the next winter season is when they said it would be doable, is super valuable.

1:38:17 I'm just surprised, I guess, at the 25% administration cost. I feel like that's excessive, and I wonder if we would be able to do this in-house or with MLH's help or, you know, and get more locals into housing doing it that way, you know, spending that, I don't know, I know there's some administration costs, but that just seems excessive to me. We do have limited funds and, yeah, bringing them into non-productive elements as well.

1:38:44 They have a program, right? They're doing that. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to attend that presentation, but that was my first question, too, as far as administrative elements. We have the lovely Nolan there, and we have Patricia with MLH. We could beg and plead them more to their place. And look at that. I think the amount of time we'd put into it would be three, four months or five months getting a program in place. That plug and play would tell us, especially for this one, because the chamber...

1:39:14 Basically did this without the subsidy, reaching out. We did a mailer to everybody in the community we could think of in terms of who had places that could be rented potentially. I think they ended up placing about 50 people. But the chamber didn't have a subsidy in place. They didn't have the subsidy in place, correct. And this year would begin doing that. I mean, we could ask them if they could take it on again also if they had the dollars to work with it versus spending. Again, their staffing capacity may not be there either.

1:39:43 I think you're right. It seemed high on that, but it would be an easy click and play, if you will. That's the only benefit to it that I could see off the top. And if you don't like it, it's a one-year program. If it's not working great, done. One of the main different, one of the things about Placemates is that they're, at least initially, their program is basically a matchmaker program. So they do the marketing and so forth, and they do the administration to go find.

1:40:11 And match people up. And after a year, normally, they basically walk away from it. Now, I would not envision that we're going to be able to put a program into place where, after one year, an owner's going to say, OK, great, I got $20,000 or $15,000 subsidy for that first year to house this rental person. Now I don't need anything.

1:40:30 I do not envision that that's going to work. So there's going to be some blend of what Placemates does and perhaps how the town is involved if this is adopted. And I don't think, Amanda, that's a good point, but I think when you look at the totality of the program, I think it brings that admin cost down a lot. I think it's that initial investment that's a higher level, but when you're looking at what subsidies might be for three to five years on a rental, that admin cost comes down substantially.

1:40:59 And of course, the town would have to hire staff to do this. I guess the problem is that if we don't initiate it, in my opinion, it would be probably close to a year before we would actually have a program going, whereas we do stand a chance of getting something going maybe next fall if we go with placemates. That's a possibility. I think it'd be worth talking to the Chamber of Commerce and seeing if they'd be willing to assist.

1:41:28 You know, it would, I'd rather put that $100,000 into our local economy by hiring local people to do it than outsourcing. So I saw $200,000 over three years for their admin costs. Yeah, that's what I recall. Yeah. Yeah, just in their presentation, they showed one year startup at $300,000. That included, that includes the incentive for the, so it's, right.

1:42:00 I think it would be worth us having the presentation because many of us here were at the chamber meeting and we were all pretty impressed. Yeah, I mean, I agree with Councilwoman Mammoth Bowser. The presentation was great, I think, and that's something, one of the comments that I had at the chamber luncheon was that, I mean, staff at Eastern Sierra Community Housing currently is so overwhelmed with work that they can do. It's like...

1:42:27 But they're open to having that conversation to have a staff person in office doing the program, just dedicated solely to doing that program. But, I mean, adding that to staff that's already in office would be a very, it's a burden. So having, I mean, hiring another person to just do that program specifically, I think is a great idea, and then doing it in-house rather than having a different company who is, you know, regardless of how great the program looks, they're not in Mammoth, they're not living the lifestyle of Mammoth.

1:42:56 So it's having a staff person do that in Mammoth would be best than just hiring another company outside. And maybe it's a hybrid. Maybe we start with placemate and then the chamber who very well may be interested in taking over the program as it moves forward. It's also a question of finding out what the demand is.

1:43:16 You know, that's, I mean, honestly, that's, there's been no real number thrown out there of exactly how many matches we can make. So, you know, that's, that's another thing. But I agree, I think, I think it is going to be a hybrid program. I don't, I think Placemates is great, but I don't see them being the standalone solution to this, to this entire program. So, but to get them going would be.

1:43:37 The quickest way that we can get this program off the ground and get some people in housing and see how it works. So there likely is some eloquence to their approach, right? Things that they figured out through the process they've done in a few places. What's not indicative or indicated in this list here is, you know, is this sort of a sunk cost? It's showing at 25% of the program that they recommended, right? It's $103,000 administrative costs against a $400,000 bill. If you doubled that,

1:44:07 Amount of funding? I mean, are they targeting maybe an achievable funding of $400,000 in a year? If you were to say $800,000 in a year, would the administrative costs remain the same? You know, so the economies of scale, if you will. Adding a town staff cost and benefits is more than that.

1:44:28 Adding, you know, chamber and stuff like that, we've contributed funding before to support that. That also then is supported by membership of the community, right, the business membership, and not just on the town, so there's some elements to that as well. One of the, you know, one of the interesting parts of their presentation, and I would encourage the council to see that.

1:44:51 That presentation as a whole. But one of the things that's nice about the presentation is very, very flexible. They have a lot of things that can be moved around, so that's a very good point. Perhaps if you say, hey, we're looking to do this, they may say, okay, great, we'll cut our cost to 15%, or whatever it might be, depending on the amount. So anyway, to bring it back, is this a reasonable thing to, as we're discussing this item with the council, that we recommend that they look at, you know,

1:45:20 Looking at getting this program off the ground as quickly as possible with whatever funds are available from the town and perhaps looking at placemates because they've got the marketing and they've already got the cake baked basically how to do this and then seeing how it goes down the road. Does that seem like a reasonable thing to ask? Good? Yes? Oh, sure. I'm sorry. Comment? Do we have a public comment? Oh, I mean for this particular item. Mammoth Lakes Housing, will you unmute yourself?

1:45:52 I just, I'm waiting for general public comments, so, but I guess along, I guess, I don't know, I can wait, I guess. Okay, I think we're just about, we're just about done, so, are we good with that? On the prioritization? On the prioritization? We're good? Okay. All right, John, if I may, I want to address some of the comments we heard earlier on some of the, you know, town focused on housing and some of those other elements. So, you know, as we all know, we're working on the parcel project.

1:46:24 That's something the town acquired that land, $6.5 million donated to the project as a part of that. As each phase has come along, because it's an affordable housing component, which has caps on the rent, caps on there's for sale units, caps on the potential that it can pay for itself. There is both grant programs for the state that folks are going after, but then there's also town funding.

1:46:53 Phase 1, I think it was a little over $4.5 million the town put into that. Phase 2, we have $7.8 million set aside. These are funding. We talk about that $30 million right out of the general fund contributions. Town council directing that. All built out, which will be several years down the road, 450 plus units being produced by that program on 26 acres in town. We have the Housing Now initiative.

1:47:22 Which is multifaceted. The bridge program is where you can buy. We buy properties at market. We turn around and sell them at a subsidized rate for ownership. So we've got that going through. We've done a number of properties through that. We acquired land, land in the town of Mammoth Lakes. And I'm trying to provide user facts about what we're facing when you're talking about building housing. Town of Mammoth Lakes, four square miles. We cannot expand beyond that.

1:47:52 The town itself, we look for property, open land that goes up for sale, and we try to buy it. If it's out there, we are first ones trying to get that. Purchased a quarter of an acre on 60 Joaquin, put four units on that. Each unit costs $675,000. So all in, we were just under $3 million for those four units. That was funded out of the town's programs. We purchased a unit...

1:48:19 Plot of land on Manzanita, half of an acre, could go up to 12 units. It's half total, the two. Yeah, we bought one on Manzanita and one on Chaparrali, but up against each other. There could be up to 12 units possibly on that. The building of those units, and I'm talking building of those units through very cost-effective methods, 675 a unit.

1:48:44 Those are, you know, pre-prefab, out-of-state, brought in, those types of things. Well-constructed, but still the lowest possible cost construction. Six, seven, that's $8.1 million. So these are the types of things building housing is also expensive. And it's not something that we haven't considered. It's not something that we're ignoring. We're actually leaning in quite heavily on that because we will have to come up with a way to fund that $8.1 million. We'll have to fund the building of those homes.

1:49:15 Definitely something we're doing. Thanks, Rob. All right. With that, we will take a public comment for items that are not, again, not on the agenda. Patricia, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi. Thank you. This is Patricia Robertson. I have been a full-time member of the Mammoth Lakes community since 2011. And I just had some general comments I wanted to make, so they weren't specific to any of the items necessarily.

1:49:50 I wanted to thank the committee and to the town leadership for undertaking this issue. I know that we all wear many hats in the community, and I just really appreciate you all putting this one on. My husband and I both work full-time in the community. We own a condo at Big Wood, where we live in a one-bedroom loft with our two boys that attend the elementary school. I volunteer with the women's club, and I serve on the Mono County Planning Commission and First Five Commissions.

1:50:21 We support the arts and utilize the recreation programs, including the parks and the ice rink. I wanted to just talk about how hard it is to live here. Our condo HOA has gone up. It's basically doubled, mostly because of the cost of fire insurance. And so currently we pay $833 a month for our condo and then our mortgage on top of that.

1:50:53 You know, we pay our HOA dues and our special assessments and, you know, just to have our HOA give us citations for having bicycles in our garage. Meanwhile, our driveway is rarely plowed in time for us to get to work. I wanted to make everyone aware that I have heard and seen in writing some HOAs suggesting that STR owners change their primary residence to Mammoth Lakes to influence local politics.

1:51:24 I just think everyone should be aware of that. And I wanted to say that living here gets, well, yeah, you know, people always ask this, why don't you just move to Crowley? I don't move to Crowley because I care about this community and I vote in this community and that's where I live and where my village lives and where my family's being raised. But that's just my situation and compared to most people, we have it pretty easy.

1:51:55 There are approximately 50 households currently homeless in Mono County, and I know that because we just recently completed the annual point-in-time count, which is the one night a year that the nationwide homeless folks are counted. I know people that have had to move nine times in one year due to displacement from owner-selling units or switching to STR or other reasons.

1:52:22 And I do believe that it's unfortunate that in the United States we have commodified housing and made it impossible for everyone to have safe, stable housing. Housing is the number one determinant of health, physical health, mental health, school outcomes. Oh, that's my time. Anyways, so I'm proud locally that we're taking this on and that everyone's taking time and been really thoughtful about this. I think...

1:52:53 You know, if you don't know someone struggling with housing, I think you can ask your barista, your grocery store clerk, your salesperson at any of our retail locations. It's not, it's not, you'll find it, you'll find it. And then I just wanted to say that the chamber's program was pretty successful. We spent a lot of time developing the guidelines and the website. And so I think the chamber has the capacity.

1:53:22 to undertake a similar program. Okay. Thank you, Patricia. Appreciate your comments. That's it. Oh, Bita, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Bita, if you want to unmute yourself and speak. Ms. Klein. Yeah, I'm unmuted. Can you hear me? Yes. Okay. So I just had a general question about this.

1:54:08 Program that we have to hire somebody to be our 24-7 on-call person? Is that supposed to be a property manager? What is this? I mean, I have a good, I really don't understand it, and I'm hearing different things from different people, and I just need a clarification. I don't want to give 30% to a property manager. I have good people that work for me and take care of my place.

1:54:38 And I have, you know, I don't want to, you know, fire them for somebody that's going to take over and then I'm out of control. So what is this? So it's not intended to require people to have a property management company. What it is intended to do is have either yourself be the 24-hour contact if you live close enough to respond within 60 minutes, which is the requirement.

1:55:09 Or hire a company to perform that for you. There are companies within town that do provide just a 24-hour service and they don't require 30% of your gross in order to perform that. We think we do look for a higher degree of professional approach in this area. This is one of our biggest problems as a town. People just put anybody's name down there or they put their buddy's name down there. Sure, they'll call. These are 24-7.

1:55:37 requirements. So we are upping the expectation that it's going to be either contracting with a company that performs those services professionally, which will certainly be known to the town as licensed, and we would trust their ability to respond, or yourselves, or a property management company which has the same level of service. So that's how we laid it out, but it's really addressing a problem we have today with our current short-term rental program.

1:56:04 All right, but is, is the person has to come on site in middle of the night or they just have to respond to a call from the town? It depends on what the issue is, but the expectation is they would be able to respond to the site in any hour. Thanks, Bita. And do you have a list of those people right now, non-property managers that I can contact? Yeah, we, you can contact me directly at the town offices and we can work through that offline.

1:56:38 Okay. That's Rob Patterson for you. Right. Thank you. Thank you. Any other comments, either online or? Go ahead. Just press this button. It should be green. It's green. Yes. I just want to make it really brief. I know you guys want to get out of here, but thank you so much for all of your endeavors. We truly, my family and I are truly appreciative of the time and the research that you've taken to find viable and sustainable.

1:57:09 recommendations to the town council. And I think we're moving in the right direction. As a long-time renter here and a teacher in town, this is great progress. So I just want to say something positive. So thank you. Thank you very much. We appreciate that. Any other comments? Nope? Great. All right. Close public comment. So, hey, great. Five minutes to spare. We have, yeah, go ahead.

1:57:36 I want to note that we do actually have one item on the agenda there, a committee member closing comments. I do want to say thank you for the committee, the work, the effort, the discussion, the ideas that came up. This will close out the committee's work program outside of the recommendation of the council. All of you are more invited to come and speak to council if you so wish. But I do really, a lot of the comments and thoughtfulness has been greatly appreciated. We challenge our own thinking when this happens.

1:58:03 I greatly do appreciate that. But we did want to have an offer for anybody in the committee who wanted to make any closing comments process-wise, work done, et cetera, concerns, whatever you want to say. But I think it's your opportunity to just kind of an open element here on purpose for closing comments from the committee members as we wrap up the work of the committee. Sure. The only comment I'd like to make is thank everybody. I mean, this is all volunteer work, and I really appreciate everybody's time, not, you know, town staff, everybody. Also, there,

1:58:33 If there is a need, I'm just speaking for myself, not for the committee, but if there is a need in the future for future work like this, as the council wants to work through some of these things and get more input, I'm happy to help with that. We're not one and done. I know there's a lot of work that needs to go into this stuff. But I appreciate everybody's time and effort in this and putting up with things that we normally don't put up with and so forth. So I appreciate everyone.

1:59:01 Yeah, agreed. And thank you, John, with everything you said I agree with completely. And also just wanted to put out there, if there is any, if you guys need help with any of the down payment assistant program details or anything like that, I'm happy to continue to be on board to do what I need to do. Otherwise, we are adjourned. Thank you, everybody. Appreciate it. Yeah. Thanks for your leadership.