Trails Committee
at 17:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
208 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:04 Everyone ready? Angie, good to go? All right. We will commence the October 9th meeting of the Mammoth Trails Committee. Let me do a roll call, please. Committee Member Souser. Wait, wait. She told me I'd get in trouble. Present. Committee Member Haller. Here. Committee Member Howell. Here. Committee Member Ostergaard. Here. Vice Chair Connolly. Here. And Chair Britton. Here.
1:43 Thank you. I see no comments at this time. Comments online? No comments at this time. Okay, um, would someone like to make a motion to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of August 10th, 2023? Move to approve as presented. Second. And roll call, please. Committee Member Souser? Yes. Committee Member Haller? Yes. Committee Member Howell? Yes. Committee Member Ostergaard? Yes. Vice Chair Connolly? Yes. And Chair Britton? Yes. Thank you.
2:28 Okay, moving on to reports. First report is the trails program manager update. Good evening, everybody. Let me get my presentation up here. So we're going to share just kind of an update on what we've been up to the latter half of the non-snow season here. So you'll recognize a lot of the topics just kind of giving you an update from the last time we talked. So go over some trail maintenance that we've been up to, give you an update on Black Bear Run construction.
3:29 Talk about hazard trees a little bit again, go through some new signs we've been installing along the multi-use path, talk about some ideas for trail improvements we have for Mountain View Trail, brief update on our Horseshoe Lake Trail Day, along with our standing sharp update and an up-to-date budget for you. So trail maintenance, kind of been keeping up with logouts just last week.
4:01 A few things blew down on Panorama Dome and Mountain View Trail, got those out of there, replaced some bridge railings out on the Horseshoe Lake Loop, thanks to MLR for organizing the donated funds to help that project happen. We've been doing some minor tread work here and there with big rain events and such, but overall the trails have been holding up really well, so we've been able to spend most of our time on Blackburn Run. So maintenance,
4:32 Hasn't been taking too much time from the crew this summer. Aside from repairing some signs, our wooden 9A signs have taken a hit. So we've got kind of a list of broken 9As that we're going to order over the winter. Here's a few photos of those logouts that we did last week. We're going up on the top of Mountain View there on the left. Additionally, we were able to install
5:08 Bike Tool Station up at the Community Center across from the Village, and this is the same product that we'd like to use out at the Sherwins Trailhead when the time comes. Well, we'll test it out, but it's a candidate for the same product that we'd like to use out there, but it's got basic bike tools, and as you can see, you can put your bike up on a stand. Lawson's ordered some picnic tables for that site, and we've got a bear box over there.
5:37 So it's coming together. We haven't seeded the bear box yet, and we'll install the picnic tables likely in the spring so that they don't get crushed over the winter. Black Bear Run construction has been kind of taking up the majority of our crew time. Got some amazing photo on the right here. Long-time bike trail enthusiast and awesome volunteer.
6:11 Mark Davis out there working on our turn down near the waterfall, and up came the namesake, Black Bear, and he didn't even flinch, walked right past Mark, like five feet away from him, as you can see there. But we were able to rally a bunch of volunteers throughout the season with a Wednesday evening work shift, I think we did, and Distant was kind enough to donate some beer for afterwards and fawns and
6:45 Mammoth Pizza Co. Worked from 5 to 7 and then socialized and ate some food. We were able to get a lot done. Typically 8 to 12 volunteers would show up and with that kind of like small group, we were able to really get in there and you can see on the right here, building a wall, excavating some tread, blossom, getting this rage out there on that stump. Those were really fun. We were able to get a lot done, like I said.
7:25 I think it was a cool way to engage the community. But in general, Black Bear Run, I'd say we're really close. We kind of worked our way up from the bottom. So we covered, the cabin owners were concerned about their water pipes. We covered those with some rock armoring, widened out a lot of the turns as you work your way up. Had to basically build retaining walls on the low side of each of those turns to be able to expand the real estate a little bit.
7:58 And then as you get to the very top, that section, it's a sharp turn climbing back up to the road. Angie knows that she was there, digging away at it. And the only solution really to make that turn work is to build a probably six foot on the low side to be able to hold there. To make the turn work, so this past week we got the skid steer up there and harvested a bunch of nice rock, wall building rock.
8:31 Brought it to the site, and then set up a grip hoist and a highline, and we're able to belay the rocks down into place. It's going really well, but unfortunately, this is the last week that I have a trail crew, so we're going to hammer it for a few more days, but that's going to be a once again next year completion on Black Bear Run, unfortunately. Just a lot of work up there, but it's going great.
9:01 Keeping up with hazard tree removal up there, we've been basically working from Horseshoe down to Poconoby. I'd say we've gotten through about half of the load of hazard trees up there. We're still trying to get some communication from Frontier concerning the majority of those hazard trees that are down below the pack station that are close to their line. So Forest Service is trying to get an answer out of them in terms of if they're aware of their responsibility there and what their plan is.
9:32 Forest Service has opened the Lakes Basin to firewood collection, so a lot of that material that we've been dropping and bucking has been disappearing with firewood. So we kind of, you know, I kind of had most of my crew working on Black Bear Run pretty much the entire summer, but then Scott and myself kind of peeled off a few days here and there to try and keep up with these new signs that we want to get installed on the multi-use path.
10:04 So we installed three 6As near Eagle Lodge. We poured concrete footers for an additional three 6As along Main Street that I mentioned to you guys last time. We also poured footers for a few more 4-6 signs over in the Eagle Lodge area. Here's photos of those two new 6As. There's another one that I just don't have pictured here. But that was a good process. I'd never...
10:33 I don't think we'd ever installed those signs in-house before. It's usually a contractor kind of handles it. So it was neat getting to kind of work through all those processes. And I think they came out great. Here's a picture of the Force 6 that we're going to install out there. As I was kind of going through the process of installing these things, came up with a few kind of ideas for improvement basically on these signs.
11:02 There's a map panel that goes in that blank space, and it's got eight fasteners, two of which mount into the steel pole, which requires drilling and tapping, and I think moving forward, we'll try and get rid of those two holes in the maps and just streamline things a little bit, but anyways, those will go in in the spring once we get the maps. We took a team outing to Mountain View Trail to look at
11:33 Potential reroute as well as stream crossing up near the top of the trail. Mike Braun, who's a SEMBA president and also adopted trail advocate for that trail. It kind of brought it to our attention that a bridge could be useful up there, especially in high runoff seasons like this year. There used to be a bridge there. It washed out, I think, in 2011, 12.
12:02 And so looking at that site, it's a pretty wide floodplain. And so to have any type of engineered structure in there would have to be 50 feet plus, which I don't think is realistic or really fitting for that type of trail. But there's a standing dead lodge pole right kind of in the perfect spot. I think if we just drop that across the stream and mill it up as a walking bridge option, that should.
12:30 Should serve the needs of the trail users crossing that stream in the spring mostly. Yeah, we also looked at a reroute basically as you top out that first climb coming out of earthquake and then drop back in and climb back out. There's a really steep climb, overgrade kind of pitch. And so instead of doing that drop and climb, we're thinking of
13:02 Proposing a just rolling contour segment for that section to replace that overgrade area. And we're planning to submit that to the Forest Service on January 1st. We've been kind of coordinating with Chris Bure, the rec officer, that that would be a good time to deliver anything kind of in a bundle for him so he knows when it's coming and can get us an answer in a reasonable time before spring. We had a really great Horseshoe Lake Trail Day.
13:38 Great to see our river cleanup. We've painted picnic tables, picked up trash all over the Lakes Basin. Well attended, as you can see in the great photo there. And Lawson, you want to share anything on Sharp? Hi, Lawson Reif, Outdoor Recreation Manager. I will provide a brief update on Sharp. I spoke to our archaeology contractor this morning, and things are going very well, and they believe they have
14:17 Recorded all sites out there currently. So then what they need to do is cross their T's and dot their I's as it relates to their paperwork. They will then submit that to the Inyo National Forest and the process will move forward from there. So they've been very efficient. I did mention to you all, I believe, last time that we were going to be doing block surveys of the entire area of potential effect.
14:43 But Stantec, after further conversations with the Inyo, did not need to end up doing as many block surveys as they had thought. So we will now see what the Inyo National Forest says as it relates to these sites. Stantec, our contractor, felt that things looked pretty good out there from an archaeology perspective, i.e.
15:11 Are we going to have to move a lot of our lines? Their assessment was no initially, but that is up to the Inyo National Forest. Once they submit data, the Inyo National Forest will help inform that decision-making moving forward. But we will see how this progresses. Right now, like I said, they're going to cross their T's and dot their I's for their data. Just make absolutely sure that they have everything that they need to record before they submit it to the Inyo. And then they will submit.
15:40 And we will hear what they have to say related to that. If some of our lines need to move, things of that nature, every other specialist is effectively waiting for archaeology because archaeology would cause the largest movement in our trail alignments, right? So we're waiting on arc, then botany, hydro, wildlife will do their thing out there. And I'm assuming most of what they will be finding out there, we can mitigate either through sustainable.
16:09 Design, Bridges, things of that nature, but we will see. So that is the most recent update on track. Thanks, Austin. This one's for you also. Yes. Let's talk budget here briefly. I want to update you all where we're at roughly here in the first quarter. I think we're right on track in terms of overall spending. Of course, we designed this new simplified budget document.
16:42 For you all, and now I think what I'm running into is because specifically our contract with Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access is a little bit different, that this may not be the most accurate reflection, I think, of the budget and that we can streamline it even further. And I know
17:08 That I said last time, that this is what the budget was going to look like moving forward, but as you know, with MLTPA, we now have a $100,000 contract for a base 1,100 hours of services. So a lot of these program categories that we had developed prior aren't necessarily as relevant, but we're going to stick with this for a little bit and see how it works, and I'll keep you guys up to date. But a few things to keep in mind, these four categories up top,
17:36 are the primary categories for our contractor. These are the primary categories that they work in, website operations, communications, implementation, the GIS and data, graphics and design, as well as planning. So what you will see reflected in that is the first quarter roughly of $25,000 for our contractor and how that money was effectively divvied out, right?
18:04 You'll see in here that we are spending a decent amount right now on operations and administration, specifically communications and things of that nature. As you know, there's been a lot going on this summer from the donut to Reds Road.
18:20 To Shady Rest timber work, now Lakes Basin timber work, getting the word out a lot as well related to our trails that were covered in snow for a while. So I think we're spending a little more than we might in a normal year as it relates to communication to support a lot of those efforts. I do not anticipate those numbers being even close to this high as we go into the winter months, but obviously a lot of the information and information campaigns that we have been doing have been pretty substantial.
18:49 And the signage needed to support that. I forgot to mention as well, Lakes Basin and the Lake Basin opening and the shuttle and all of those different things that we were trying to communicate out. You'll also see in here a lot of graphics and design work to help support that various signage, to help support these different media type campaigns that we were doing to get the word out.
19:16 Lots of signage related to the inner valley bus that we had in the lake space and all of these different things. We've had, I feel like, dozens of signs made already to support those operations, including trail closures from the timber work that maybe trail crew was doing and things like that. Website operations, you know, pretty standard there. We have done some more information on MammothTrails.org in terms of getting the word out, a lot of updates in the trail system update for all of these various campaigns.
19:45 Payne's that I've talked about. As you'll see up top, not much in the realm of planning right now. We're doing a lot of that stuff in-house as it relates to planning, whether it's for Sharp, utilizing our grant, working with our contractors, stuff like that. So not much in the realm of the contractor for that line item. Then you will see a very substantial amount in trail and trailhead maintenance. A lot of those dollars are staff dollars for this summer.
20:14 But also a lot of tools, a lot of equipment, signage purchases that Andrew spoke about. A lot of that stuff is contained in here in the trail and trailhead maintenance. But all in all, if you look at these numbers from a percentage standpoint, and I messed the one up on top.
20:34 It should say percent available, not percent spent for the total budget up at the top. That's my fault. But that we're pretty much right on track for roughly being at the quarter mark. Now, you will also see if you scroll down what we've spent out of the 510, 595.68 for Sharp Environmental. I actually literally just got a bill yesterday and didn't update this that contains a good amount of their field work.
21:03 And that is roughly about $50,000. So there would be a substantial increase to that. I literally just got it yesterday and didn't have time to update it. But as you can see prior to that, a lot of the prep work, working with the Inyo National Forest, doing records reviews, Stantec being our main liaison with the Inyo, developing the plans for survey, that is what is reflected in this document. But literally yesterday, just to let you all know,
21:30 About $50,000 for a lot of the fieldwork, Airbnbs for the staff to be up here and stay up here, things like that. And again, the majority of their initial fieldwork has been. So in conclusion, I think we're right on track as it relates to our budget in terms of the percentages that we've been spending. A lot of these numbers will be going up.
21:57 Obviously, a lot of sign orders are going to be happening real, real soon here, as Andrew's team has gone out and done a lot of sign assessments. He mentioned the soft surface trail signage. A lot of his crews have also gone out and done signage assessments on the MUPS for a lot of those signs that are damaged. So, obviously, these numbers will be rising as we go through our inventories or order new things and spend money on that stuff. Any questions related to the budget?
22:34 Thank you very much. Excellent. Thank you, Lawson. That wraps up the Trails Manager update. Unless anyone has any questions for me, pause before I mic over to Lawson. I just have one quick question actually for Lawson. What do you think the timeline is for the sharps, you know, once you get that? I know. Do you have any estimate?
23:04 I don't at this time. It really all depends on how quickly the Inyo will go through all of the initial survey work that I mentioned because that will then determine when the other specialists get out into the field. I would really, really like to think that let's assume that nothing else gets done in terms of field work this spring. Spring? Where am I? This fall. That
23:34 The majority of that would be sussed out over the winter. A plan would be developed and it would be done relatively quickly into the spring where we would then have a proposed action for our NEPA document of what this would look like and then move into public comment from there. I would like to think that's what it would look like. Unfortunately, I don't have a good feel.
23:59 For how long this next step is going to take, i.e. the Inyo looking at the myriad of information that was collected out from the survey area, and then determining how that may affect our alignments, and then working with the other specialists. But I would like to think, again, if no field work occurred anymore the rest of this fall, that everything could be worked out over the winter months. We work all those things out that we could do in the office, and as soon as it is melted out there, get out there onto the
24:29 onto the trails and finish that survey board. So we're going to have a spring next year. I cannot promise you that. I also don't know that either. I might have messed this up, but I think I got it. Thank you. Gretchen Hasfar, Outdoor Recreation Coordinator. Just a quick update on a few things. Trail Days has wrapped up for our summer of stewardship.
25:07 I'll give you guys a quick update on the Outdoor Recreation Host Program, Trashy Thursdays, and Adopt-A-Trail. So Trail Day Summer of Stewardship started with National Trail Days. We had weekly volunteer opportunities for trail crew hosting and water hosting. We had the new Trail Crew Wednesday work nights, and then we wrapped it up with the annual Lakes Basin. So you already know a little bit about this one. This happened back in June, National Trail Days. We did collect over 150.
25:36 Pounds of trash out of the Sherwins area, we've had about 70 volunteers, totaling 280 volunteer hours, which is valued at $10,449 for our program, so pretty successful first kickoff for the summer. Then the weekly opportunities, we had 44 and a half hours of trail crew volunteers for the weekly opportunities and 33 water host volunteer hours.
26:06 Just hosting volunteer hours, sorry. Water hosting, we had 33 hours, which was pretty impactful. We had one main volunteer, Dallas, who came out quite a bit, and we did get a lot of, lot of fishing lines. She had some kayaks. We were out on boats getting fishing line. Other days, we had volunteers on the shore getting fishing lines. I'm really excited about how the water hosting and Tango Free Waters programs are really kicking off this summer.
26:32 The total value for the weekly opportunities was $3,564 for the program. Andrew touched a little bit on this, but the trail crew Wednesday work nights were a pretty big success. We had 92 volunteer hours for a total of $3,433 for that Wednesday night effort, which is pretty good for work on Black Bear Run. I think everybody had a lot of fun.
27:00 And enjoyed those nights. It was pretty social as well. There you can see Scott, our injured trail crew, manning the grill there for everybody. Again, the sponsors were Distant Brewery, Vons, and Mammoth Pizza Slice. So probably looking to do something like that again next year, building that community up a little bit more. And then our last event, the annual Lakes Basin Cleanup. We had about 70 volunteers for 210 volunteer hours cleaning up the Lakes Basin.
27:30 Valued at $7,800 for our program. We found a lot of stuff up there, some mattress springs, a big culvert. We had 115 pounds of trash, over 150 feet of fishing line collected by the crew. We also were able to sand and paint eight picnic tables around Horseshoe Lake, and it was pretty fun as we were wrapping up the event. We saw a family roll up with
27:59 They're cooler and use the new picnic tables. So we were excited about that. So that was a great day up at the Lakes Basin. And we had Old New York Deli as our sponsor. And then Edison was also a big sponsor. And you can see on the right-hand side, every volunteer got this very nice bucket. I have some right here. They're used, but for the Mammoth Trails Committee on your way out.
28:30 You guys are part of the volunteer crew as well. The host program this summer, we had 14 staff members working on this program. They were stationed out at Lake Mary Road Closure for a while at the beginning of the year. That was fun. Horseshoe Lake Trailhead, when it finally opened up, Lake George and Twin Lakes. Then we also do work at Mammoth Creek Park around the multi-use pathways, Shady Rest Park, and then we support the buses and Main Street.
29:00 The crew of hosts also supports the stewardship programs, Trashy Thursdays. We helped that facelift last weekend with Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And then they also help just do one-off things like distribute flyers about Red's Meadow or the timber work. So it's pretty nice to have this crew of staff working for us to really help us out throughout the year. We also, Elise, check that out. We did some host volunteer on a horse.
29:30 Which was pretty cool. One of our staff members actually owns two horses, and so we got to go up and down Mammoth Rock, and I'd like to report all positive interactions along Mammoth Rock. Everyone stopped. It was very nice. We interacted with bikers, people with dogs, everything. So it was really cool to see that for a day, and hopefully if she's still with us next year, or if you want to come out with us, we can get some more days on horses.
29:59 Trashy Thursdays this summer, that's our weekly cleanup around town. We had our third summer of it. We work with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, and Mammoth Lakes Recreation and Waste Connections on this program, so a lot of partners in this to make it happen. This summer, we collected 630 pounds of trash, 68 pounds of recycling.
30:24 20 pounds of dog waste. We had 199 volunteer hours, which is a total of $7,400 for our program. So a really strong year for stewardship for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. The last and most important one probably is the Adopt-A-Trail Program. These are volunteers that pick up a facility in our area to support and clean up throughout the year.
30:51 We had 13 new volunteer adopters this summer, so I think we have over 25 volunteer adopters, which is pretty cool seeing as it's only the fourth year for this program. And we partner with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Mono County, and the Forest Service to...
31:07 Implement this. The volunteers so far have reported, I'm hoping I get more reports from them, but we have 280 pounds of trash removed, over 800 feet of fishing line, and then they've reported 80 interactions with other users on the trail system, which I think is a pretty positive impact for people to just see people caring for the land while they're out there. So it's been a great year of stewardship. I think I've collected over 160 waivers.
31:35 Just for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Volunteer Program. So it's been a busy and fun summer. People were really excited. Should continue next year. Any questions for me about stewardship or the host program? Of course. Do you want a microphone? Excuse me, can I have you come up to the, may I have you come up to the mic? Just a quickie. Does the mountain contribute to the outdoor host thing or not?
32:14 No, we're separate programs. They have their own host program that focuses on the mountain and their activities. They do have hosts in the village during the summer, which is a really nice support for the town. But yeah, we're separate. I do work a lot with Anna Allen. If you know her, she's given me a ton of information to support my program. So I do work with her as a partner, just sharing ideas and information, but no crossover with staff or anything. All right, thank you. Thank you, Gretchen.
32:58 Are you giving an update or no? You're technically next on the agenda, I believe. I don't mind, I'm quick. We can get set up. Hi, everyone. Kim Anna Clario, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Sorry about my lack of a voice today and a lot of talking over the weekend. Just a couple quick updates.
33:43 The last two weeks, there was the organization Clean Up the Lake came to Mammoth again this summer, and they worked at Lake George for two weeks straight. A couple of stats, there was over 1,000 pounds of litter was pulled out from beneath the surface of the lake. The total count of the total number of lines and lures set was 3,277.
34:12 And these are just initial counts. Colin West, the founder and director of the organization, has taken all of the loot back to Tahoe, and they are going to sort and evaluate it and then report back to us. So you can always check their website, cleanupthelake.org, for updates. But then I know they're working with Mammoth Lakes Tourism and going to come and be making some formal presentations to the town.
34:42 About their efforts this summer. And a quick update on our Tangle Free Waters program, another successful season. It's not over yet, but certainly winding down. I want to let you know that we'll be collecting all the line from all the tubes, you know, once more when fishing season closes. And then I hope to see you all at a sorting party that we're going to have, adult beverages and food included.
35:11 Where we can sort all the line, package it up, and send it off to be recycled. So we've been collecting it all season, so there's quite a pile. We're going to need some help. November 17th, location time, TBD, but mark the date. And I think Lawson's going to be, have we talked about the Sherwins already, the grant? Okay, just another update, it's going to be going out to bid also on November 17th.
35:41 We're going to, I started. The trailhead bid will be going out to bid November 17th, and town is hoping to award that contract towards the end of November, and in the beginning of spring, as soon as we can, since we're going to have one, construction will begin. And also, just to add on the planning part of it, the tribes have been involved in the evaluation, they've been out in the field.
36:14 With the contractors and are very eager to stay part of the process throughout the rest of it. I think that's it. I just want to again thank Edison International for the $5,000 grant they gave to MLR, partly for an adopted trail sponsorship and partly to help support the trail days. We are now going to get the report on the over snow. Hello, Lawson Reef, Outdoor Recreation Manager. Before I start this, I just want to jump in real quick on the stewardship stuff.
37:00 When we did the lake space and cleanup, everybody almost to a T said they actually had a hard time finding trash out there. I say that to say what we are doing is working. What Gretchen's doing, what Andrew's doing, what Kim is doing with MLR is working out there. We are seeing results to these efforts, and I just want to say that's amazing to see.
37:27 So super grateful for everyone's efforts in that regard. I was shocked as well. I went out and I was out there with my parents for two hours and maybe got a half a bucket of trash. And in previous years, I've gone out there and you get full buckets really quick. So kudos to you all. Thank you very much. All right. OSV subpart C, everybody's favorite topic. I presented a similar version of this presentation to town council.
37:55 Recently as well. Mr. Sauser, bear with me. You will be hearing this again for the second time. But I want to go through this extremely important process with all of you to, number one, discuss your feelings on the matter. I would love for each of you, if you have comments on the matter, to bring those comments forward. And then...
38:21 I would like you all to decide if you would like to comment on this process as a body. We'll talk about the public comment process, what all of that looks like with the Inyo National Forest. And this process, and I said this at Town Council recently, does not happen very often. So it's one of these things, speak now or forever hold your peace, regardless of how you feel about this issue. I just can't stress enough the importance of...
38:51 Exercising your civics, in a sense, as it relates to subpart C. We are going to talk about the rules and requirements, what is the proposed action, how to submit comments and timelines, and then some Mammoth-specific info, and then I will give you a little bit of a brief update of what town council said and how they felt about some of these issues. Some of these things I'm going to move through pretty quickly. It was in your packet.
39:17 Especially as it relates to the process, procedure, kind of what this is. If you have any questions, feel free to interrupt me. It's not a problem at all. All right, rules and requirements. So again, the purpose of this project is to manage over-the-snow vehicles. Good way to think of over-the-snow vehicles, snowmobiles, timber sleds, something with a motor that's going over the landscape. But the goal of this project is to provide access and recreational opportunities, obviously.
39:46 Ensure that OSV use is designated only where there's snow. Safety, of course, minimizing cultural and natural resources as well as conflicts among users. Again, what are the requirements? Travel management requires that the Forest Service designate these areas for over-the-snow vehicle use, and that is what the Inyo is doing right. What else does the rule say?
40:14 It basically says it is designated by the responsible official, in this case the forest supervisor, to once again determine where OSV use is appropriate based on snow. What is different and why are we kind of going through this process and what might be different about the current condition?
40:34 And really, the translation part is what's important. I'm not going to read the whole CFR, which stands for Code of Federal Regulations. All areas not specifically designated for OSV use are closed to OSV use. We have effectively the opposite right now. So we are moving towards basically a map that says you can go here and then everywhere else will be off limits as part of this process. What is the proposed action?
41:05 I included in your packet the proposed action document as well as links to a lot of the other stuff that maybe doesn't have a direct nexus to the Mammoth area. I encourage you to look over those other maps, those other things to kind of create that holistic knowledge of sort of what's happening here with this process. Obviously, we'll zoom in here as it relates to Mammoth here soon and talk about those.
41:32 But what is included in the proposed action? Well, first of all, this only applies to public recreational users, not permittees like a recreation residence holder, for instance, in the Lakes Basin, who can get permission to ride a snowmobile in the basin even when snowmobiles are not allowed because that is their structure and they need to maintain their structures, right? Administrative emergency use, all of that makes sense.
41:59 The forest, as it says here, considered the class of vehicle and season as part of the use. And again, this is a decision about OSV management. This is not winter recreation management. I'm sure that will come down the pipeline as well with the overwhelming popularity of things like backcountry skiing, things of that nature. But that is not the focus of this. The focus of this is OSV, over the snow vehicle use. We talked about this before, current condition.
42:30 Is going to be the opposite once this process is completed. Right now, the entire forest is open to OSV use, except where it is specifically prohibited. Again, we are moving towards the opposite of that, designating areas only where you can go with the end product. Again, thinking of this process being a map. That's a good way to think about how this will end. Adequate snowfall. We've talked about this a little bit. Part of this process is going to be determining an adequate snowfall level.
42:58 for OSV use. And the forest basically used remote sensing lab data to determine areas that receive at least 12 inches of snow on average for at least five days per year. If it does not meet that criteria, it is automatically excluded from one of those areas that would be considered open for OSV use. So again, 12 inches of snow on average for at least five days per year.
43:25 We will talk about the snow depth requirement here a little bit, but again, something to think about. Does that make sense? Should areas be included that do not meet that threshold, but maybe once every 20 years have snow? These are things that I encourage you all to think about, or is this exactly what we want? So again, think critically about these things as we move forward. How has the proposed action developed?
43:54 First of all, there are certain areas where OSV use would never occur based on law or regulation, something like that. One is, of course, congressionally designated wilderness, right? No mechanized transport in congressionally designated wilderness. Another is RNAs, research natural areas. So areas that had another designation that automatically prohibited OSV use were, of course, excluded from this process.
44:21 Again, which areas had adequate snowfall, which areas might have had adverse impacts to natural or cultural resources or other recreation uses, i.e. recreation conflict. Determine if any of these could be minimized and if so, prescribe management requirements to minimize those impacts. Which, I went over this briefly, which areas were not considered at all? Again, wilderness, research natural areas, of course, Mammoth Mountain and June Mountain. That would obviously be...
44:54 A mess, if OSV use were allowed in those areas, and ancient Britsilcone Pine Forest. This map is in your packet. Again, it's small, difficult to see here, but basically everything in the blue are these areas that would receive 12 inches of snow on average over five days per year. So these would be the locations where snowmobile use would be considered. And then it was the job of the forest to nail down what it should look like after that point.
45:23 So these would be the areas that were not automatically excluded. Here we are in the Mammoth area, and again, a little tough to see, right, on the PowerPoint. Take a look at your maps or look online. I mentioned this to counsel as well. I'm happy to speak with any of you about this as well. If you have any questions or want to sit down on maps or say, what does X, Y, or Z mean in a certain scenario, you can see my mouse right here. You'll see some stuff like this.
45:52 Right? Like, oh, why is there this open patch in the middle of the blue? Well, that's private land. That's our Calarius Ranch. All around Crowley, right? That's BLM and DWP. The forest obviously does not have the authority to designate OSV use on private land or BLM land. So you'll see some little holes and things like that within there. The majority of those are another landowner, but not all. So again, if you have any questions about any of these, let us know, please.
46:20 Again, another map just showing the Mammoth area, what this all looks like, and what areas are going to be in the proposed action listed as open for snowmobiling. And that would be in the blue. And please remember, and we'll go over this, this is phase one of the process. This is the initial proposed action. This will go through numerous comment periods.
46:48 And I can tell you with a relative amount of certainty that the alternatives to the proposed action that they develop, I am sure one will be one with less snowmobile access. It's possible there's one with more or some gray area in between. So again, this will go on for a while. We will talk about timelines. It is not, and I just, again, want to make this clear, it's not like after this first public comment period, which closes
47:15 The 20th of this month, that this is just going to be over, right? That, oh, you put in your comments, Inyo will come out and say, help, we're done. There's going to be alternatives proposed. You will have opportunities to comment on those alternatives. So I just want to be very clear on that. Here we are again, Lakes Basin area, Tamarack in the purple right there. Obviously a special designation for Tamarack that we know opens on April 17th for OSV use.
47:40 The yellow there is the slow 15 mile per hour zone that you will see in here as well, which extends up to the vista there. And again, of course, Town of Mammoth Lakes shown in this as well, as well as the area out at the Sherwins. Okay, so after all of this, where are we? How do we distill this proposed action in the 60 pages of documents into a coherent
48:11 Examination of the situation. And the best way to probably describe it is more or less status quo, not completely. So the Inyo chose, for one reason or another, to start with roughly the status quo. Let people comment on that and develop alternatives to the proposed action from there. There are some exceptions to this, which we will go through. But more or less status quo
48:42 Besides the fact the area needs to receive 12 inches of snow, right? So besides that fact, more or less status quo and a few other things as well, which we will discuss. What happened to current OSV closures? I don't want to spend too much time on this, but there are numerous areas, as you all I'm sure know, that are closed, whether it's operated by a permit tee, whether it's because we groom trail.
49:09 In some of those areas up at Obsidian, Shady Rest, Nordic Trails, things of that nature. So won't spend a ton of time there. How to submit and comment and timelines. So we'll go through this briefly before hopefully we have a quick conversation. How to view the documents. You have these web links. All of these documents are located on the website where you can check them out. And also on that website is the
49:37 Place to comment under get connected there in the right, comment and object on this project and or object on this project. So again, please, I encourage anyone listening as well to please comment on a process like this. These are very, very important processes. How to comment. What would the forest like to know and what encompasses a constructive comment? We'll just go over this here for a little bit just in case any of your friends as well ask you or any people interested in this.
50:10 I don't like this or I don't like that is not really a constructive comment. Hey, I see we have X issue here and I think we could resolve X issue through maybe some delineation of uses. Or maybe we could, I notice a problem here, maybe we could solve this problem through some increased signage or greater staffing. Don't just place value judgments on an activity. Think about how to solve problems or maybe where you see areas of concern.
50:40 Ring those things up. You don't necessarily have to have solutions for everything. But try to point things out that the Inyo can use constructively to make choices and decisions, right? And obviously, I like this or I like that doesn't fall in line with that. So again, suggestions for alternative specific issues or resources you would like to see analyzed or other specifics related to OSD use.
51:10 Again, kind of piggybacking this slide here. Be as specific as possible. Specific comments about specific aspects of the proposal. Support statements with detail. Again, biological resources is helpful to focus on a particular species. If you know something exists out there on the landscape that you're concerned with that OSV use could have an impact on, be specific in that regard. Timelines.
51:41 This is not a short process. This is not a short process, and nor should it be. These are important decisions that will have impacts for decades as it relates to use, accessibility, and what things may look like. As a result, the forest lists here that it could be an environmental assessment. I would not be surprised if it's an EIS, which is a larger level of detail, an environmental impact statement, and all of these things take time.
52:08 Through the NEPA processes, there is opportunities to comment, opportunities to object once a draft decision occurs. And the Inyo National Forest is looking at later in 2025 for this process to be completed. And again, I want you all to know that in the sense of this is round one. This is round one. You will not be hearing. This won't be the last you hear from me.
52:34 on this process. This will be going on for some time. And again, the initial comments are due October 20th. October 20th is the key date for this first round. Mammoth specific information. So let's talk specifically here about some specifics related to the Mammoth area, OSV subpart C.
52:57 And what this looks like. And I brought this up at town council as well. First of all, are there any policy documents or planning documents at the town level that speak about this, right? That could inform some of our decision making. And I was able to find that basically through the Sherwins Area Recreation Plan and through the Sherwins Working Group, which was then adopted by town council.
53:24 As part of the Trail System Master Plan, the one thing that I could find that said, if Town of Mammoth Lakes groomed out in the Sherwins Meadow and had a grooming program out in the Sherwins Meadow, the recommendation would be for that meadow, and you can think roughly Telebowl's West in the meadow there, that that would be non-motorized. That is the recommendation of the Trail System Master Plan. You will see that the Inyo does not have that in their initial proposed action. So again,
53:53 Is that something that you would like to see? And if so, that would be a great example of a public comment related to that. Also, let's talk about some of these red areas on the, maybe not, there we go. Let's talk about some of these red areas on the winter rec map shown here. Many of these red areas are now listed as open on the new proposed action because the Inyo National Forest was not able to find any appropriate documentation of
54:22 Those areas being closed under an approved process. As a result, in this first version, these are listed as open. This would include some of the areas up by Minaret Vista, some areas near Earthquake Dome, although Earthquake Dome itself is listed as non-motorized. The cherry stem up there between Mammoth and June, just south of the Obsidian Nordic Trails, with, of course, those trails remaining non-motorized in that surrounding area.
54:49 Non-motorized, as well as up at Tioga Lake and Saddlebag Lake. Again, I think another quality thing to comment on. Do you want to see this? Are there any changes that you would like to see? Do you have concerns about any of these areas moving forward? Also, part of this proposal will be part of...
55:11 Town of Mammoth Lakes Expanded Grooming Proposal that will go through this NEPA process. The town has proposed grooming some more trail for the enjoyment of users out there. And again, you will see that one blue line out there in the Sherwins. We are under basically a multi-year pilot program with the forest right now.
55:32 That's that blue line that you see out there at the Sherwins. So that's what we're putting on the ground now. This may change a little bit. We did recently go out on the ground and truth some of these things. We want to go out on the ground again and take a look at the Sherwins and see what makes sense out there. But just so you all know that this expanded grooming proposal is going through the subpart C process. Inyo did not feel it was appropriate to examine this sort of thing outside of this process.
56:04 Another, yeah, that would be the proposal right now. Of course, we, I think the number one thing we need to see right now is if the Inyo has any concerns with these alignments. That, I think, will be the number one thing coming up. We did feel a lot of these would be multi-use, especially the ones that are northeast of the existing trail system out of Shady, because technically those are outside of the no-OSV use corridor.
56:36 At the same time, though, I think there's an education piece and an education element that could come with some of these things in terms of appropriate use for OSV users, like they always teach in golf, you know, go into the fairway at 90 degrees if you are going to go into the fairway, things of that nature. But a lot of this in terms of designation, things of that nature, isn't 100% worked out simply because it's still just going through the environmental problem.
57:06 Right now. Once we know what it looks like. Yeah, so last on that, you're saying like yellow, which would be our groom trail at all? Yeah, no, no. So blue is existing, yellow is new. Yeah, but the new groom, but then also could end up being multi-use with OSV use and cross-country use and dog walking and fill in the blank. Yes. And I don't know if the OSV applies to the motorized like fat bikes that they're considered OSV. Right.
57:32 No, because fat bikes are, oh, if it's electric, yeah, that would be different. Fat bikes are currently allowed on our groomed trail system. Yeah, they're electric. Right. I'd have to look into that one. Even if electric at this point, Forest Service views them as wheeled vehicles, which are not over snow vehicles. Yeah. They do ride them out there. No, they do all the time. Yeah, the fat bikes are legal on the trail system, so, yeah. But it took a change of forest rules to make that happen. Right.
57:59 Yeah, and I think, again, a lot of this will be sussed out in the NEPA process. Like, do these alignments even work? Are there concerns related to these alignments that the Inyo has? And that's why they wanted these things to go through the subpart C process. Because when it all boils down to it, the subpart C process is a NEPA process. A big change, well, maybe for some, a big change that you may see in the initial proposed action is the proposal for a new staging area at the dump station of Shady Rest.
58:29 New Shady Rest campground, right? Bill, as Bill knows, this has been kind of out in the air for a while now. And the Inyo, I think, is taking this seriously as a serious option to maybe try to eliminate or get rid of some of the user conflict that occurs in a massively busy area that is Shady Rest Park. And again, here's another great example of something to comment on. And I'll talk about this in a little bit more detail. But do we like this idea?
58:58 Are there other ideas for maybe delineation of uses to eliminate conflict? But to translate this map for you, basically the proposal is to groom the multi-use pathway that basically follows that red line all the way till it crosses the road at the entrance to Shady Rest Park right there, have it go on existing roads around the park and connect with the A-Trail north of Shady, which would eliminate any snowmobiles using
59:28 Shady Rest Park, which could help with some parking congestion, maybe some user conflict, things of that nature. Then what we would do to maintain our existing mileage, and the Inyo supports this, the yellow line, we would just bump over our alignment a little bit more to the east in the woods, so we wouldn't lose any mileage. Because right now, you can see the blue underneath the red, that's where our current
59:58 Groom Trail is. So we would bump that over to the east to maintain our existing trail mileage and the Inyo supports that. I think another great thing to relay is right there at the OSV staging proposal at New Shady Rest, there are already winterized restrooms there. There is parking there. There is a turnaround area. The area is basically a circle, right, which could be great for trailers. Obviously some logistics need to be worked out in terms of
1:00:25 Who plows it? What that might look like? We'd love to create access corridors then to our groom trail system. So grooming this little piece right here, you know, what does that look like? But all in all, another great thing to think about, do you support this? Do you think something like this could work? Are there other options for things like this in other places in the Mammoth area, which we'll talk about shortly? If I may, from a historical context, this was the trailhead and the only trailhead for all users.
1:00:54 Until ORMAT needed to start plowing roads out into the forest, which caused us to not have a legal corridor for motorized. Then the whole thing was moved to where it is today. Believe me, this trailhead works far better. My opinion, it works far better for motorized and non-motorized. And there's a lot of tree lifts area out there that this could expand over the course of years. From my standpoint, for both user groups, without having to...
1:01:27 Tear a lot of forest and a lot of untrammeled land down. Thank you. And again, from a process standpoint, just always good things to think about when you're looking through these and thinking about public comment. Should it be the opposite? Should OSV users be in Shady Rest Park and encourage the Nordic users to be down in the other area? Again, just always good to think about different options so that we can be successful.
1:01:57 In our management, not only of OSV use, but all of these other uses that we have here in Mammoth with, you know, for all intents and purposes, massive amounts of use, limited numbers of trailheads. So again, just encourage you all to think very critically about these as we move forward. A few other items here before I've already talked too long. Is there a high elevation staging area that needs to be proposed? Climate change.
1:02:24 Sometimes less snow at those lower elevations and shady rest. Does something up higher need to be proposed to accommodate OSV use? Should there be some staging areas on the scenic loop? Is that a good location to have? Maybe some staging or maybe something like up at Obsidian where there's those nice paved parking areas that Caltrans made. Do we need something like that off the scenic loop? Are there other locations for delineation of uses?
1:02:51 Could we do some delineation up at Minaret Vista? Could we do some delineation like we spoke about out at the Sherwins? Are there other spots that we feel this is needed? The Sherwins Working Group recommendations, again, about non-motorized in the meadow there. Do you support those recommendations? Would you want to see something different? And again, of course, other ideas and recommendations. And real quick, I'll just run through a list.
1:03:19 Presented this to town council, like I said, very, very recently. Just to relay their feelings, and feel free to correct me if I misinterpret any of these, folks like the Shady Rest delineation on town council. They thought that was a good idea to potentially eliminate some conflict. Like the idea of proposing a higher elevation trailhead as well at a place like the Cinder Shed, if possible. Formalize that.
1:03:44 Like the idea of some staging on the scenic loop, just not near that area where everybody sleds, where the lanes become two lanes right there. Just not near that area. And there was some, oh, they were okay with the snow depth. Council was okay with that snow depth requirement. And they also liked the idea, if possible, of delineating uses at the Vista.
1:04:12 If it made sense and there was a corridor to do that. And then there was some talk amongst folks about the Sherwin Meadow and there was a suggestion that maybe that meadow be opened if it were closed to motorized. There was a proposal that that would potentially be opened on April 17th to allow users to access the lakes basin from there with references to parking congestion, things of that nature at Lake Marietta. All right, I have spoken enough.
1:04:43 If you have comments on the process, we would love to hear those. And keep in mind, again, the public comment time is the 20th, so we have 11 days before the public comment is due. We can start with Mr. Souser, if you have any comments? You know, I think you covered what we said at Council very well. If anyone would like to get personal opinions from me, I've been dealing with snowmobile use on the Indian National Forest.
1:05:16 I started snowmobiling up here back in the 60s, but I would enjoy having that conversation, give me a call. Unfortunately, between now and the 20th, my time is not all my own, but I would look forward to talking to you or anyone out there in the public that would like to. I see their initial proposal as being a very valid proposal. If it works, everyone, I think we should each, maybe no pressure, but to comment each as a committee member and then maybe discuss if we do want.
1:05:56 And then I think we'll have public comment after that too because you see people in the room. From my own perspective, yeah, we've discussed this at the council pretty indefinitely. I think the recommendations that came out of that add to a little bit of what was the proposed action so there are some additional components. The meadow area that would be closed during the season opened up the corridor access. I think some of the elements we had to support that from a committee perspective is what issues were raised. This is focused mainly on
1:06:41 Mammoth Lakes, so there are other areas where there were. The idea of the expanded staging area there at Shady Rest, we toured that one day, additional details. I thought some of the elements there made a good allowing for near-term and longer-term expansion. It's important from a trails committee aspect that we lose any of the cross-country. So Sherwin Meadows, it's important that we keep that a non-motorized area because we've expanded there. To me, of when
1:07:55 Good question. Roughly. I'm trying to think, Gretchen, in the last days we were out there. We groomed for six months this past winter. Yeah. But I know Sherwins ended before Shady Rest, so, I mean, probably April. I need to look at that photo where we got stuck out at the meadow because that was one of the last times. That was one of the last times. I'll look through my phone here in a second. Just to clarify for you, too, that is currently open to motorized use, that trail right now.
1:08:23 That trail is multi-use motorized. So we encourage OSV users to use the open area so that, you know, Nordic skiers and walkers can use what we groom, but it is open. Okay. Yes, and in the proposal would be no net loss of trail mileage that we groom. If I remember my land management plan from the forest, if it is turned into a blue diamond trail on the forest,
1:08:56 And if it is groomed, that trail is closed. I believe that's an automatic loss, and you would be able to answer that better, but I believe that is my understanding of how. I don't think we were allowed to when we put this in as a pilot program out at the Sherwins. To mark it as Blue Diamond. It wasn't marked as Blue Diamond. It's a blue line on our map, but yeah. But it is an option. It could be an option, yeah. And the other thing I wanted to comment on is if we...
1:09:27 If the new trailhead moves forward, which I think is a great plan, I think we need to make sure to limit the amount of intersections that the cross-country trail has with the motorized trail. There were a couple of blue lines that just deaded in area and limiting the places that we have to sign extensively to prevent motorized vehicles coming through trails beneficial. Yeah, so the goal
1:10:01 I agree with that, and I think the goal would be to just sign heavily the one intersection right here, and I think you bring up a good point, sign that intersection heavy, because that's the main intersecting point. This actually right here would potentially be eliminated because you would push people onto this one, right? But no, that's a good point right at the junction there.
1:10:32 I would definitely be a proponent of a higher elevation staging area. I think that certainly the propane tank area is very, what does that look like in 20 years? We don't know. So I think that we need to.
1:11:24 Big consideration. Definitely a proponent of scenic loop staging area. Tamarack access or the, I don't know how we actually refer to that juncture point at the end of the road there. To me, that's a, I would love to see some sort of improvements in that area. I know it's very difficult with the space and I don't have a good understanding of what could be done there necessarily, but
1:11:55 You know, we have a lot of people now using areas as snow play that is, you know, possibly at certain times of the year is more than, you know, than all of the other user groups on certain weekends. And we're driving a lot of those people to that destination. So if we can look to have a different destination for them.
1:12:16 I think that could help eliminate some of the parking. And also just with the public transportation, just I'm not sure if we can make that any better. I know it drops off over at Tamarack or at the lodge, but if there could be a second stop somehow, integrate to kind of that other area. And then last thing is just as this develops to come up with either, obviously we had color coding and stuff like that, but just figure out a good way to really make it simple for people for the suggested
1:12:46 Best place to do something. So not that you can't do certain things in other areas, but I think trying to drive people to the suggested area will make a better user experience for all users. And I also would support the map at this trailhead proposal as well. I think that's great. Thank you. I want to start out just piggybacking on what you were saying about being conscious of creating a map. Now we're inviting people.
1:13:21 to use snowmobiles in a specific area as before it was the map indicated where snowmobiles were not allowed and it was assumed anywhere else was free for snowmobile use. Now we're basically creating a map saying this is a great place to go snowmobiling in theory. So I think having kind of these optimal places or best use areas, best parking areas.
1:13:48 I think is a really good idea, and I think it's something that we have to be conscious of as we're creating a new map. I, too, agree with high-altitude staging, multiple staging areas, scenic loop. One thing I really like that no one else mentioned, one of the maps, the new map is proposing a slow zone, kind of on the north side of town. I'll get there, eventually. Okay.
1:14:21 I would love to see a slow zone for, and it looked, you know, I was looking at the distance, it's difficult to gauge what that distance is exactly, but if we just had a mile, within a mile of town, within a mile of a staging area, within a mile of a home, however you access your snowmobiling experience, to have that be a slow zone.
1:14:51 I think we've done a really good job with Camp Like a Pro, and that's kind of part of the culture in Mammoth. I think the mountain has know the zone. You give everyone 15 feet. If we create this culture of, like, this is snow play area. This is most likely snow play area. So as you were saying, too, I work up at Tamarack. I'm trying to tell people where to go, where to go with their kids, where it's safe.
1:15:19 If we could kind of create this slow zone and have it be part of our marketing, have it be part of the culture of OSV use in our area, I think that could eliminate a lot of potential conflict. And then whether or not, I mean, I would love to see the Meadow area be non-motorized, in part, largely because we have this pilot program.
1:15:49 And if you look at every other place where there's grooming, it's non-motorized. You know, like we've talked about, Sidian and Tamarack and Shady and, you know, so the precedent has been set and I think we need to plan for the future and I would love to see more free, Nordic, multi-use, but possibly non-motorized, you know, safe for kids and dogs and
1:16:17 But then if you extended that mile around town, even if there were motorized in the meadow, you would have this zone. It would be within a mile of town and in theory have just a slow area. And I think that also when we're creating a map, if a snowmobile user looks and sees this yellow surrounding the whole town, they're going to maybe think twice about...
1:16:44 Where do they want to go? Does the meadow really take them anywhere? Is that not really appealing? I don't know. And I did do a little bit of research. It's hard for me to believe, but it said that the average snowmobile user goes about 50 miles when they go out. It's kind of an average ride is 50 miles. So I think a mile is a reasonable kind of...
1:17:11 You know, period of time to just go slow and then they can spend their next 49 miles or 48 miles going at whatever speed they feel comfortable. So, I think that's about it for me. If I may, for your comments, you're actually referring to a few things that the snowmobile group has come up with in the past. We didn't call it a slow zone, we called it a no-wake zone because everybody knows what that is. Right.
1:17:38 And there was no snowmobiler that was opposed to that. It's the closures. It's the slowly choking off of the sport. The other thing you refer to was a Blue Ribbon Coalition effort years ago that went nowhere because certain groups didn't want it to go anywhere that we called EPA. Encourage, prohibit, and allow on the premise that if you encourage people to go to a certain area, that's where they will go. Where they absolutely shouldn't be, you prohibit. The rest you leave is allow.
1:18:08 And if those who are really want to go out and explore have a chance to do that, but the majority of your people are going to go where you encourage them to go, which is the basis of the maps. That's why we put on play areas and the rest of that when they were developed originally. So yet you're speaking things that we have spoke before, and I appreciate it. Thank you. All right, my turn. I like all the proposals. I think that, you know, as a group,
1:18:41 We may have enough to, you know, be able to comment as an entity. But, you know, I like this whole process. It kind of makes me regret, you know, 10 or 12 years ago, when we were doing this for the non-winter season, travel management, it was way different. You know, it kind of seemed like it was even a little secretive. But this is out in the open.
1:19:10 Everyone can say their piece. That's my favorite part. Thanks. And then I think, oh, more comments, but if you guys would like me to follow up and draft a letter or what something might look like for a public comment. Let's get public comment first. Okay. I'll take public comment, please. Hello, Craig Albright, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Yeah, I just want to echo, you know, I'm really...
1:19:48 Excited that the process is going. It's not going to go real fast, which can be frustrating on the one hand, but probably good for us in the long run. At Mammoth Lakes Recreation, we're kind of the nonpartisan recreation group. What we really look at is how, first of all, as a group, we need to understand what are the needs of the various
1:20:17 Recreation Groups. And, you know, it's easy in this particular one to focus on the Nordic skiers and the snowmobilers and their partisan history. But I would bring up that the snow play that Caroline brought up is probably for our community and our visitors is the one we need to maybe pay, but also might be an opportunity for us to
1:20:47 Where appropriate, and I don't really have a strong opinion, but we'll use Sherwins as an example, is might be a place where if there are natural separations where non-motorized goes this way and motorized goes the other way, that snow plague is that place that starts that division a little bit of naturally non-motorized and motorized. I don't know if
1:21:17 Sherwins is the place for that or not, or Obsidian, I'm less knowledgeable about the particular areas, but eager to go into those areas this winter with those eyes of how do the different user groups interact with probably safety being number one, mitigating any conflict, avoiding and mitigating conflict being number two.
1:21:47 But number three is Mammoth Lakes Recreation looks for how we can, what are the shared needs of those groups, trailheads, bathrooms, accessibility. That's where the role we see where we can play in this process. And I'm eager to see us get started. And I think we're off on the right foot. But snow play is, they don't have the advocacy group, I don't believe.
1:22:17 And, you know, the, and maybe they should. Anyway, we're going to try to be that for all the groups and find ways to make the most of the great resource we have here. So thank you. I'm Arthur Silverman. I just have two points. One regards Minaret Vista and the adjoining areas. So I just think that
1:22:58 Those should be reserved to non-motorized use. And in particular, from Interet Vista out toward the San Joaquin Mountain, that ridge. There's a lot of snowmobile use out there, and there's a lot of conflict with Nordic skiers.
1:23:27 Again, as Craig was suggesting, it may be possible to designate routes that allow some snowmobile use that is separate from Nordic. I'd prefer to see it gone altogether, but okay. That's one point. The other is enforcement. And as you may know,
1:23:56 There are a lot of snowmobiles now going up into the Lakes Basin, and they're even high marking, and, you know, they know they're not supposed to be there, but that doesn't stop them. So I think as part of this plan, I guess it's a question to Lawson, is there a potential enforcement element of this, or is that out of bounds?
1:24:30 So yes, I think there is an enforcement element. A lot of that would fall to the Inyo National Forest and their capacity. So to a certain extent, I think those questions need to go to the Inyo along with any partnerships that they may have in the law enforcement realm, whether that's Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mono County.
1:24:54 Other OSV staff or OHV staff who are working in the winter. And I think that would be a very poignant question to the Inyo. But it would be outside this comment. No, I think it would be part of this process. Yeah, to say, hey, if X, Y, or Z did occur, what is your enforcement capacity? If you are looking at enforcement as a mitigation measure, can you actually?
1:25:21 Perform that enforcement to mitigate X, Y, or Z. Is it known that that's occurring? I don't know. I don't know. I worked for the forest for 12 years. We definitely had some conversations about that. But in the lakes basin, I haven't heard a ton, simply because that area only opens April 17th and later. And I want to say, don't quote me on this,
1:25:52 Six, five of the last ten years, there really wasn't even any snow at that point in April for those types of uses to be occurring in decent numbers. But I think that enforcement issue is a great thing to comment on in your public comment, especially as it relates to it being used as a mitigation measure. And do they have the capacity to do that? The mountain could also do more enforcement-wise.
1:26:24 There have been cases where upper management contacted about violators in the upper and declined to take action. And I found that pretty upsetting. Anyway, I'm done. Thank you. David Page, Wildlands Alliance, former Trails Committee member, former MLR director, Craig. Appreciate what Craig said about
1:27:08 Trying to find ways to create some places for people who just want to walk on snow, want to walk their dogs, want to place, I think multi-use air trailheads can work with the right culture, but I think having just, when you look at the map the way it's proposed right now, there aren't any places that are not, as we know is really crowded. So to find a place where people can walk from town, walk on snow without having to compete with snowmobiles, I think is really something to focus on.
1:27:41 I really like the Shady Rest proposal a lot. I think we can do something really similar at the propane tanks. Then the only other thing that I wanted to say to you guys, just as Lawson said, the forest is going to be coming up with some alternatives over the next probably four to five to six months. Their goal is to come out with their environmental assessment in a year.
1:28:06 So as they're pulling together those alternatives, that's the time. I mean, obviously October 20th would be the best time to give them maps and say, here's what our alternative would be. I think there is time to work with them collaboratively as you're doing on the Shady Rest to kind of come up with a holistic winter recreation master plan for free. We love to spend millions of dollars on master plans, but this is one where we can kind of look at
1:28:35 How do we want to manage winter recreation for the next 30 years? And to that point, I think also if you look at the maps, you know, things like snowmobile use designated right up to Mill City, you know, where I think it's so far has just been a GIS exercise for the forest and they haven't, and I've talked to Aaron and to the forest supervisor, and they haven't had the resources, they haven't been out, they don't really know what's going on. So that's where a body like yours, where a team like...
1:29:03 You guys, where you have hosts, you know, to try to figure out this winter, what's actually going on? So it's not just he said, she said, you know, get some people out there able to document what's actually happening and thinking of solutions on the ground rather than on a map, on a computer. That's it. Thanks for having the conversation. Any other public comments? No public comments. Oh, sorry.
1:29:58 If you don't mind if I just share it quick. I was just trying to think of a way to illustrate what you were talking about with the mile buffer around town. So this is just a mile buffer of where we are right now, the old Mammoth and Meridian intersection, which I don't think quite gets us to what you were describing. But then I brought in the urban growth boundary, which pretty much kind of illustrates where
1:30:47 Where town has been developed, and then if you put a mile buffer on that, I think that gets you maybe something more in maps like this to help you out with your comments. Yeah, as we were talking there, the one thing that also came to mind, I know the town did a great job this winter plowing the muffs best they could. I think like it's one thing that we kind of forget about in the winter is the user group of the walker, not on snow, the people looking for a paved experience. So I think that's something we can...
1:31:34 Continue to, well that's more of a town responsibility to integrate that into having good parking for those locations and things like that and potentially directing people better to walking areas. I'm curious with you guys, do you have, are there any other areas in town that you've thought about that you would like to develop or is there anything that's like, is of mind to you guys? I think eventually, I think you brought up a good point.
1:32:05 I think this is a really good time to potentially tell the forest they need to address Lake Mary Road through this process with winter. I think that's a big one, and the fact that OSV use is currently allowed in there might provide that opportunity to say that it can be addressed through this process. If there wasn't any OSV use in the basin, you wouldn't be able to do it through this process because, again, this is OSV stuff. But also, we've definitely talked about
1:32:34 You know, maybe more robust infrastructure at Old Mammoth Road to take some pressure off of Lake Mary Road in the winter. That being a possibility, you know, we've obviously going to have development of the Sherwins Trailhead here soon and how that may help to provide a spot for people to launch and go and do snow play, depending on what things would look like in the meadow. You know, I think David brought up a good point, too.
1:33:04 What is actually going on? Do we want to encourage the Inyo, like, hey, you need to survey X, Y, and Z, or you need to go out to Shady Rest and just interview people? You know, what does that sort of thing look like? And can we encourage the forest or through its partners to do something like that? But I think really a lot of the areas that we've discussed and brought up are kind of some of the big ones, you know, Lake Mary, Old Mammoth, Sherwins, Vista.
1:33:32 Scenic Loop as it relates to staging, Cinder Shed. I think those were a lot of the big ones. And kind of stuff that really stuck out in my mind is opportunities to address some of these things. I think a few more also are really thinking ahead in terms of our use. Just something that I've thought about personally. Oh, we're talking about...
1:33:55 Scenic Loop Trailhead. Well, should there maybe be one at Inyo Craters? But then, when we have really, really heavy years, that road doesn't get plowed, right? Which means there's probably snow all the way down to 395. Should there maybe be another staging area right by the gate at 395 where the scenic loop comes out? And that would provide, I think, even more opportunity as well just for general use and access staging. You know, these trailheads are used all year round, not just in the winter. So...
1:34:23 Is maybe that more prudent than maybe just having something in your craters that on big years could be socked in and potentially unusable. But of course, very viable on those years where the scenic loop is plowed all the time. So that's just, for me personally, the things that I'm thinking about as it relates to this process. Okay, so I think we're at a point where it's in favor or not in favor of submitting something. You know, I have all the faith in Lawson that there is. If it appeared that we were...
1:35:03 Opposed on things, I'm sure he could leave those out, but where we, I would love to see him write a letter and send it in for this group outside of the town. That way we have standing in this movement. Be in agreement with that. Yeah, I would agree too. Good to have it come out in. Okay, marching orders now. Got it, thank you. There's nobody opposed it. We can just do that as consensus. Chair, the sign of the sign. We are now moving on to agenda item five. And looking at the, that letter was not included.
1:35:54 We have a potential new committee member, I believe that is Michael Draper. Can I ask a question before we go down this line? Having not read our bylaws recently, haven't even had a set of bylaws, what is the size of this committee supposed to be? It is supposed to be seven. Okay, thank you. One down. Yeah. Hello, Commissioner. My name is Michael Draper. Just wanted to introduce myself and put a face with the name and put together a little...
1:36:32 Resume, letter for you all to read a little bit about myself, and I'm happy to answer any questions you all have. In the letter, I just kind of noted my interest in joining this committee. I've been in town for about 10 years now, and looking to just kind of use my knowledge and education to better the town. Michael, when it comes to all the trail stuff around here, I have always been, and I've been involved in trails. To me, multi-use gets us the biggest bang.
1:37:20 And what I would always have loved for the town to do, and what we've tried to do with this group, is commit, okay, I can't even talk today, is to make a committee that is well-rounded. Not a non-motorized committee, not a motorized committee, not an equestrian committee, but a committee who is open and encouraging of all different types of pursuits. We all have different things we are capable of and not capable of. So tell me how you fall in that category.
1:37:50 Sure. So, you know, most of my hobbies have been around non-motorized sports and trail uses. Not to say that I haven't, you know, dirt biked or used snowmobiles before. I just don't own any, so I can't really comment exactly on those. But I understand their needs and their use. You know, I've got a lot of friends that like to do those things. I just personally don't. I have enough hobbies that I do between all the other outdoor activities.
1:38:19 Totally understanding of it, totally respectful of everybody's desires to recreate in the environment. So I'm always open to hearing everything. On decisions that would maybe go over, such as this OHV things, I would look to hear public comment and to hear the rest of the commission's ideas before I made a final determination on anything that I wasn't firsthand knowledgeable. Thank you for your interest, though. The only question is what it's going to say.
1:39:06 What is our process? I believe you can make a motion to appoint him to the committee, take a vote, and then he can start next meeting. Kim, I think we'd have to just look and see what... Yes, and so if this goes through, I will update our matrix and include it in the next packet. And so it's a two-year term, so we'll find out...
1:39:46 If he's, you know, and they start in January. Everything's based on January, so we'll just, I don't know offhand, but it'll be either expiring next year or the next. Yeah, I think closure-wise, I worked with Michael a little bit when he was working out and stuff, and obviously in his current involved in a number of different areas. I think your experience, always that healthy. I'd agree with Dan, too. I've known Michael a long time and always seemed, you know, well-rounded and capable.
1:40:56 Used to work at the county, I'd always come by, questions and problems, so. Does anyone like to make a motion? I'll make a motion to appoint Michael Draper to the Trails Committee. Okay, I'll second. Roll call, please. Committee Member Souser? Yes. Committee Member Holler? Yes. Committee Member Howell? Committee Member Ostergaard? Yes. Vice Chair Connolly? Yes. And Chair Britton. Great, thank you very much, I appreciate it.
1:41:40 I look forward to the next meeting with you.
1:42:19 Fall. Yeah, I don't think I'd update on, and I believe it's tomorrow, Lawson, we have a group from the state coming down to do a tour with us. We have a grant application in for work on our mups, which would allow for the fixing of several of them with the cracks and stuff, but also in some areas, widening them out. And the goal is that to have it to a tour. Hopefully that will go through. Look forward to that and ongoing with some of the other trail work. A lot of e-bike discussion. Looking there also just better.
1:43:04 Signage out on the mumps, as well as that more traditional and more fun stenciling. Again, back and forth on some good work going in. And not from a recreational use, maybe not so much from a trail side of it, but new surface on the tennis side, the old ice rink next to the library. It is now a six-court pickleball complex there, and that'll be open. That's exciting. And then, along with the trail system as it goes past the college there, we're also a new parking area and just past Edison Theater down to the end.
1:44:10 I've been traveling a lot in recent, why I missed the last committee meeting, but I exploit some trails in Switzerland. More recently, I've been on Mountain View, which is holding up spectacularly for the end of the year. The dirt's still great out there.
1:44:55 And then hiked up to TJ Lake as well. I enjoyed the Mammoth September month of endurance. I did all the bike races. That was super fun. And then I'm not a runner, but I was blown away by the Trail Fest. I think that event will bring tremendous exposure internationally to Mammoth and showcase our trails. And I think it was really cool. I think the trails did.
1:45:32 The cleanup day was also going on at the same time, but it was just a really, really great event for our town and good use of the trails, and I think it was just nice to see that many people enjoying them. That was me. I enjoyed being a part of some kind of workshops. I went to the Towns to Trails Planning. John was there as well.
1:46:04 Also enjoyed the fact that the Inyo gave a similar presentation to what you gave, Lawson, both online and in person, so it was really nice to be able to get in the same room as a bunch of Inyo Forest Service employees and ask questions and look at the maps up close. Really appreciate how, like John was saying, how involved we can all be if we want to be in this process.
1:46:33 Participated in the facelift cleanup, I think two weekends ago, a few weekends ago, that was great, won $100 gifts card, which was a bonus. And also went to the Crowley Lake Run, that was an awesome community event, and just attended the Eastern Sierra Mountain Film Festival this last weekend, which...
1:47:02 Didn't get a ton of press, but was a phenomenal event. And then, you know, it was a couple of the films were down in Bishop, a couple of them were up here, great, like, mountain culture, environmental films. So I would like to maybe find ways to get more people at those events because, you know, there were a couple films where there were only...
1:47:30 10 people. And it's just such a great thing that's brought to our community. So I'm going to maybe work on getting a little more traction on marketing for that. So that's all I have. Help pulled off the Crowley Trail Run. It was during Trail Fest, but we're still, you know, had lots of participation. Raised a bunch of money for our community. One of the things we're working on is like a 30-mile trail system.
1:48:02 Connecting Lower Rock Creek up to Mammoth, hitting all the towns along the way. I got together with Mono County, Marcella Rose, and a ranger from White Mountain. We went out and we looked at alignments, you know, starting for we're Lower Rock Creek, the upper trail hit, you know, going from there to Tom's Place and beyond. So it just takes a lot of time, but, you know, someone's out there pushing it forward.
1:48:31 Also went to trails to towns or vice versa, I forget what it is, but I liked looking at their maps and they told me they put them all in and the computer generated all these routes. So I was looking at them and they didn't make sense. I wanted to know if the computer was AI and they said no it wasn't. I thought okay, that's probably why. But there's just a lot of things where they say where if the computer shows no trail,
1:49:01 From one area to another, it just draws a straight line, but it's a little deceiving when you look at it. I've been doing trails and towns all my life on a dirt bike, so I've been trying to tell them and help them out, look, this is how you do it, you know, this is the only way you can get through. So, you know, there's a lot of, you know, work to be done on it, but it's a long process. And I think other than that, oh yeah, just...
1:49:28 Mountain biking and pedaling Lower Rock Creek almost every day, and it is sustainable to go every day, so I just wanted to throw that out there. We didn't mention real quick, but we had the OCR championships in town. It sounds like it went off. It sounded like it was a good event, I think. Okay, then last is, do we have any requests for future agenda items? You mentioned that she was going to look at...
1:50:22 Like what, like, where we are, yes, where we are with our time commitment on the committees, and so if we could just get that for everyone, that would be great. Okay, thanks. You know, it might also be good at this point, since we're well before the season, to get a report on the grooming that we are doing, and the equipment we're using, and what our contingency plans are, and those sorts of things, so if there,
1:50:52 Could be an emergency process. We can start looking at that while there is still time to look at it and not midpoint. I'm interested to in a follow-up on that. As I mentioned, or as that comes in the right flow on the e-bikes, because I know that was a top-up conversation in our last meeting, so it does us. We will adjourn at 6.50 p.m. Next meeting will be held on December 14th, right here.